fA. CsepAnblK
lilT CsepAnblK


nplt1Hl.(lt1nbl nplt1BaTlt13al.(lt1lt1
)Klt1fibIX nOMeli.\eHlt1lt1
B POCClt1
CKO
 cDeAepal.(lt1lt1


Y4E6HOE nOC06i-1E


MOCKBA
IOp"cnpy,[J,eHII"

2012




Y.qK349.4
66K67.407
024


ABTOpbl:


r.A, CBepAllbIK, ,/J,OKTOp IqW\QI1
ec
x HayK, npc4ieccop - npe,Ql1CJlOBl1e,
BBelJ3K1B.rnaBbl1,3,4(ll8jJ<Irpa4J2),8bIBQJ:\bl,
M.r.CBePAIlbIK,KaI1lJ.lo1AaTlOpH,O,H
ecKI1XHaYK-npeAl1CJl06l1e,
rnaBbl2,3,4(naparpa4>1),BblBQlJ,bI


CBePAIlbIKr.A.,CBePAIlbIKM.r.
npI1H
nblnpl1eaT
I1)I(l1nblXnOMeUJ.BHI1i:jB
<PeAepalll1l1:
C24 Y"eISHoenoco!5l1e/r.A.COOpjJ,l1b1K,l-1rCaepjJ,l1b1K.-M. 1i\,!J,
,
2012.
ISBN978-5-9516-0259-6


y..,e6HoeIlOC06..eco,o,ep!l<l1T
lfT1lI1bHoe..cc.neJJ.OeaHl1enp06neMblnpl<H-

noBnpl1
)IOOlbIXIlOMI!U.jBHI1O\BPoccI1i1cKoo<1le,a,e
!1.BblnonHBHHoe
Io1CC1lep,oeaHI'Ief1y
Oloco6cTBoeaTb6o.r1eem\lf>oKOMYIlOH!1MaH\1IOcyUJ,H0CT1II1CO-

ar1bHoroHa3Ha
eHl'I!1caMorO)K1.1fl!1l1\Horonpa8a,
)I(I1J1blXnOMeUjeH!111
lo1ee
Pa3pa60TKa)'Ka3aHHOI1np06neMblHE!CBQIJ,L<TCHI1!1Wb
-reope-rmec.
KI1M
,nOCKonb"YBI1WH!1!1noKa3aHaIo1CTOp!1H4IOPMI1P08aHI'I!1I13a.OHO.
.u.aTeJ1bH01"o.poPMYn!1pOeaH!1HIlp!1H
noBllp!1earl13a
!1IK>1IlbV<IlOMeLllE1H!1i:j,Io1XCO-

ar1bHaH
HOCTb KaK perynHTOpa OOIl\BCTBBHHbIX OTHOweHIIOI no npl18aTI13aLJ,l1I1
)l(l1nbIXIlOMeLll8H!1""3Ha
!1MOCTbA'lHHOPMOTB0P"ecKoI\lo1

npal<T!1K!1.


YAK349.4
66K 67.407


ISBN 978.5.9516.0259.6


@r.A,CaePJlllbOl,l<1rCaePJlllblK,2OO1
@ot>opwleH..e.Ii\A.IQ:I!1cnPYI\E!H4L'I
.,2012




npEJ\I1CnOBI1E
ITplfBaTH3aLtI.fil Ipam,IlaHaMJil flawe!! C'lpaHbl:HGfJIbIX Haxo-
CR II rocY.l\apcrBeHHOM J1 aJIbHOM OM l}JoH.I\e, npe-
-reprreJla c 4 JUOmI1991 f. - C MOME'HTa Ha'IaJJ3. ,l\61crmLF! 3aKoHa Pocafiil:1ocJK
4'eJ\epaJ..tl'llf{(OmJ1JII1IqHOI'Oq)()HA<lB4>e)1epa-
Qlm.. nOHaeBpeMR-PMrlLnJXIB03I'.rra-
CJl!B, q')'() L\eJIbIO 3aR()Ha RBJlHeTCH C03;:\aHl1e)'C1l(Erli Ami OCYJ.l.\ecTBJIeHI1H
npaBaaHHacB06o)J;HbItiBbI60pcIIoco6ayn01pe6Hoc-
-reA II JKl.fJIJ1ll{e, a TinOKe y.nyqIIIeHIDI i'1CIIOJIb3OBaI Jj COxpaHHOCTII JiG'I-
oro4x>H,!\a, 3aKOHO,!\aTeJ1b, BIf,1\IfMO, np=eJI KIIbIBOm. 'ITOYKa3aIDJaH
LleJIb ,l\ocrnrnyra, If npl13HaJl CT. 13aKOHa PoccIrltcKOO: We.Qepaql1l1 «0 IIpI1-
B3.m3aLlJ1ll! JiG'lJII.flqHoro 4x>HAa B PocmiicKOO: 4>e)1epaqIDl, KOTOpaH o&bH-
BWIa npI>1BaTIl3a.qmo:oo1JIb!X KaK6ecILIIarnyronepe.!\8-'lY Bc06-
CTBeHHOCTb rH I'ocrni.ictrofI epawrn: Ha .l\ OCHOse
3atrnMaeMUX JfMJ1 :oofJIbIXlDM€11f2I{Jdj:S rocy,!\apCTBeHllOM J1 M)'HI1LtI-fi1aJIbHOM
MI}JoH.I\e.yrpaTIIElllciiclfJIYclHHBapH2007r1
B3aKOHOT 29.1\eKa6pH2004 f. N2189-ct>3sHeceHbIJf3Me-
Hemm, BCTyIDIBIlltte II clfJIY C 1 CelITmpH 2006 r., COfnaCHO KO'I'OpbIM yxa:3ClH-
HaH CT. 1 3aKOHa  epawrn <<0 IIpI1BaTl131U<lrn oro
4>oH,!\aBtI>e.r\epal.J;l1ll!({yrpa'il1Bae'l'cIfJIYJOOlJbcl Mapra2010r:».
PaCCM01]llw, KaKOBa :me IOptWNeCKaH npJ1po,!\a CpoKOB, KO'I'OpbIe 3aIW-
HO.l\aTeJIb CHa'ffiJla BBO.lUIT, a saTeM npoJ\JIeBaeT, Jj KaKy<O L\eJIb npec.rrWeT
3aKOHO)\aTeJlb, BBO)UI" npoAJIeBa;:I 3TH CpoKH, a TaIOKe KaK OH (3aKOHO)\a-
TeJlb) KBaJIJttlJm.p1pyeT npl1BaTI13aLlIo.
Cpmm, CHaCT)'IlJleHlfeMwrropbIX,!\OJDKHanpeKpaTWfbCHnp
rpam,1WHaMM)KIfJ[bIX HaXOCJlBJ\OMaxroCY,l\apCTBemlO-
rolf:1KKIDnwrnro4x>H,!\a,CJIWeTOTIIeCTI1KnpeceKaTeJIb-
HbIM. ITpeceKaTe1lbHbID: CPOK, ItaK npaBI1JIO,  
cy&beKTImHoronpaBa. O)\HaKO B03H11KaeT BOIIpOC, HBJIIJeTCRnH npl1BaTI13a-
I.{IfIf }K\fJIbIX  CyUbeKTl1BHblM npaBOM ynpaBOMO'IeHHOI?
 OTBeTHa 3TOT BOI1pOC OKameTCJI BecbMa CQMHlfTeJlblTh1M. B
KHlfre Mbl rIbITaeMCH ,!\OKa3aTb, 'ITO npI1BaTi'EaL[I1H rpam,1WHaMMJKI1JIbIX no-
 HaXQIIJIllVtXCf B ,!\oMax rocy,l\apcmeHHoro If M)'ID1J.\lfI1anbHoro
mw.mflL\Horo 4x>HA<I, npe)\CTaBJUleT co6oi.J: o-npaBOBOi.J: IfHCTrnyI',
KT1n_2<J>eAepanbHorOaaJ<OHaOT29Ae<atipH2004rN!!IB9-<t>3'OB_ I 
BAe>icTB..e>Kou1LWtOrOOAB.caFocaH:l<r:iipaL.lM'_ 

a He npocro npaBO, R3K Obi OHO He TOJIRCEaJJ()Q, B OIYbeImfi!HOM I>1JIiII cym,eK-
'TOMCMblCJle.
CJIe.n;yeT OTMeTIITb, 'IT{) oreqeCTBeHlIOH npaEOOOIf Ha)'Ke (yqJ1TbIBaH If
00BeTCItIfii nepJ10,lJ; ee IfCTOpJ1J1) HeH3BeCTHO 6b1J1o npeqeHJ1e H
npaBOBOro IfHCTIlTyra ,D;eJlo Be;u. He B nOJlMeffl.lJ11fJ1J1  'I'{'X
J1IDI J1Hb!X HopM If lfHCTI1TyroB, Ha 6a3e KOTOpb!X nOHBJlmoTCH COOTBeTC1'ay-
K'Ie npaBOBbie KQHC'Ip}'KlJ:l'li1, a, o'JeBt1,!J.HO, B CytI..\eCTBOBaHlfJ1 onpe,!\eJleH-
HOi1 ipymIbI  0'I'HWl€HJIii. KOTOpbIe ofu.eKTIffiHO 1pe6YKJT
J1IDI Ha R3KOM-'TO 3Tane )liKe He 'Tpe6yKrr JlX npaBoBoro peryJmpoBaHYIH. Ec-
'TTBeHHO, qTOB npaaoBOM peryJll1POBa.IDfJjHeHJjK,Z\aIOTCH'I'{'
Hble UI'H<IIleHI'iH, KOTOpble IfC'lep!ffi.JlJlj cefuJ.
TpyJJ;HO )'CT<IIIJBIfTb. 'IeM pyKO 3aKOHo,!\a'TeJlb, nOJIaraH,
'ITOIIJXJCCI1pJIB3TI13aQ>rnrpam,!\aH3.MIfPoccHi.firojjepa3affi1M3.-
eMb!XI1MJiI)f(J1J1b!Xrn.H3.B.AOMaxrocy,[l3.pCTBeHHorolf
)IOCIIlIJ1.tIIoro4x>HAa.UC'l€pI1aeTCeMTJ.O 1 MapTa 2010 r
3ToT CJXIK, cY.I\H no nOCJle.!{Hei1: p!$\K 3aKOHa PocarlkKoti epawll1
«0 llpHBaTl13aLlJ1lf )KJ1JiJ!lltHoro 4x>HAa B PoccniiCItoii epaW1l1», YCTa-
HOMeH lfMIJepaTIlBHo.
ECTh Bce OCHOBaHlfH nOJlara'Tb, 'ITO 3TOT cpOK MO:1KeT OKa3aTbCH He no-
CJle,!J;!U1M, 'faK RaK poccwrne Moryr He ycneTb TJ.O 1 Map1'a 2010 r 6eCIIJIa'THO
llpHBaTI13l1poBa'Tb CBOJ1:xrn.J1b1e nOMelIlelU1IJ,  B ,l\OMaX rocy-
)J;apCTBeHHoro If M)'HI1LIJDI3.JI :!KJ1JrniLIHoro 4x>H,!\3.. TaKoti IIpom03 6bIJI
C,!\eJIaH Ha KOJIJIel'lfliI fJIaBHOro yrIpaBJIeHlfH Q:leTJ.epaJlbHOi.J: perifC'Ip1l1tIt
HOi! c.nyitlfibl no r MocKBe, r,Ae IXI,I{BO.I{I'1J IITOfill pa6oTI,I CTOJIWlHb!X pe-
1'ItC1'pa'fOpCI3a nepBO€' nOJJyI'O;r:J;I1e 2006 r. 1
IIo 0l\eHKe ,l\enapraMelITa mI11IJJ11.1TdK111f »af.III11ltH0ro 4x>H,!\3.
r.MocKBbI,BCTOJiJ1I..IeJJ.OCJ1XIJOpHeI1J:nHOOKOJlO 1,2M11H:1KJ1JIbIX
Iii. IIo Ol\eHKe cneqIIaJII'JCTO, ecJrn 'TeMTThI llpHBaTI13<ll\H1'1 OCTa-
HYfCH Ha ypoBHenepBOti nOJlOBI1HbI 2006 r., 'TOnpoilecc npHBa'Tll3aIUll1 pac-
'THHeTCJ! €I.l..\e nO'ITI1 Ha 10 neT, eCJIJI,D;a B,!I;Boe yBeJlWlll!Th nporrycKHyJO
cnoc06HOCTb1c.nyitlfibinOllpHBaTl13ffiVfOHllbIM,AeJIaM
JfuBecrHo, 'ITO 3aKOH I'occmtaImI epawII1 <<0 llpHBa1'll3aq>IH)f(J1-
JllfilJ;!IQrO q.oH,!\3. B PocCJ1i.icKci.i tf:re.z¥;>paltIUi-o He YCTaHaMHBaJI B nplfHlI,I1rIe
cpOKJ1 OKOH'laHI1IJ llpHBaTl13al\l1l1.113TO ObIJIO npaBlfJlbHO. BCHKO€' llpOWle-
Hl1eCJXIKanpl1Ba-nl3aQJDlrpam,!\3.HaMl1)K1f.IIbLXnOM€I.l..\eHl1tiHe-
eT He TQJIbKO pa3)'MH0i1 CTafumurocTu 3aKOHa, HO If .If)C'TIf.'Il({ nOCTaB-
JleHHoi1J1MQeJlJ1.
R'Ilfc.nyH3MeHeIDmB'l.1 CT 43aKOHaF'occHftclocjitIJe-
.I\epall,l1l1«OllpHBa'T113aql1l1.oo.1J1111Q11oro4x>H,!\aBPocan"icItu1nV'
cJle.IJiYeT OTHeCTIl, B CIfJIY KCrrOpOro He nO,AJleiK3.T 6eclIJIa'THoti
-t;t 1"C""""'Jern2006.1B"lOnR

npliBam3aL{l1l1:HG1J1bleIJOMeHJ1H,rH3.MnO.l\Oro-
BOpaM OOQlfc1JIlllUO Halma nOCJIe 1 MapTa 2005 r.
IIoCKOJIbKY Q:leJ:!epa.1IbHbill 3aKOHO)\aTeJIb }lK1l38.HHhIM 3anpeTOM Ha 6ec-
lIJIaTHyKJnpliBam3aqlOO)f01JIbIXnoMeJ..QeHl1if,rpa*Jl3,-
HaM no 1\OroBOpaM CCI..\IfaJIbHCI HaiiMa nOCJIe 1 MapTa 2005 r. .promNeCIDI
nOCTaSI1JI WID!: rpa*JI3,H B HepaBHoe IIO.JIIDt(t'fIJIe C IpRJK,!\RHaMJII, no.nyql1B-
l1IHMt1)!oo[be1\o)'K1l3<lHHOii)\aTbl.CYAPoccJ6b«jitIJe-
nepa1!I1IInpI13HaJlYKa3alllloeHecOOTBeKoHCTI1TY-
QIDlPoccmlc:1roJltIJep;epawI!1, aCJle.IlOB3.TeJIbHO.He.l\6'
Jno3BOJU1eTC.IleJlaThBbJBO,!t, '1TOnpI>1BRTlf3allHRrpa*Jl3,Ha-
MIll :!KI1JIbIX nOMelI[emrn, H1lX01\HII[IIXCH B .l\OMRX rocy.n.apcTBeHHlJffi 11 MYIDI-
aJIbHoro :»GIJ!JIlltHoro os, 1\cifcTBYeT s HacTORI.l..\ee speMf! YJ, CMeeM
HaJleHThCfl, 6Y1\eT ,neIlcrsrnaTb 11P TeX nop, llOKa 3aKOH f'oocm1uroJl tIJe,!le-
pawrn«Onp:1KJ1JIYjlltHoro4x>H)J;aBHe
1\OCTIfl'HeT IIOC'l'aBJIemDi: tIN qeJill, T.e. 06ecne'llff C03)\alU1e yc.nomrn AJJJI
ocyII[ecTBJIeIDlHnpaBa IpRJK,!\RHHa BbI60pcIIoc06a Y.l\OBJIeTSD-
peHlU! narpe6HocTcii B :H01JU1llle, a T3.1OKe YJlyqweHYJH JjCRJJlb3CEl8ID1. Jj co-
xpaHHQCTIf:001JIlflI[HOro 4x>HA<I Pocon"k'Kod tIJe)wpa.
rJIaBHaJJ'IaaBTOpoB,J'!CCJE')IOBaEIIII1XnplfHL{lfIIblnpl>1BR'l'II3aWIi'I)KIf-
JIl,IX nOMeJ..QeHJ'!i1:, HaXOJJ,HUJ;IfXCH B rocy,llapcTselllloM 11 M)'IDfltIfIIaJlbHOM)KIf-
JUllI[HOM $:nme, - BOOpymIITb IpRJK,!\aH 3HalillRMlf KaK )'KR3aHHb!X npl1HIl;lf-
nOB, TalC Jj COCTaBJlHIOUJ;IfX co,!\epJt\3.HJ1e xapaKTepl1:3y{'Moro 3aKoHa
IpaJK,!\aHCKO-npaBOBbIX HOpM
'nOCTaHOOJ1eHeC;iIl'lP$OT1511IOHH2006W6.n
I 

BBE,l\EHI1E
>Kn.nnLllH3Ji npo6.rreM3. B Haweil CTpaHe, KaK CBlw;eTeJIbCTByeT OnbIT,1J.O
CIfX nap IlpQ,!1OJImae-r OCTaBaTbC$I mut6o.nee OCTpofl 1>13 Bcex 
'M
B Poecl'll'! c.i5ocrpHBwaHcH B ycJ1OBIIJ!x nepexo,D;a K Pb!HO'IHOn 8KOHO-
MHKe :m'.J1JUluvmH np06JIeMa onpe,neJmeT Heo6xoW'IMOCTb npOBelleHJ.1H
)KJ1J[l1lWIoii! pe4JopMb! KaK HeOT'beM.JIeMIJ 'l3.cnl c:-rafuwH3aW'l118KOHOMJI!-
KIf rOCYJI.apCTBa J1 OC}'l.1¥2CTBJIeHIf.II B Hen CTPYK'l'YPfJUX Jl!3MeH€Hllii 1 3To
O)\Ha CTOJXIHa Borrpoca JJ;pyraH:»re, He MeRee 3Ha'lHMan, COCTOI1T B TOM,
'ITO HaCTaJIa nopa np€O.IJPJI€Tb crepeonm, cJlCOtGfBWJliicH B C03HaHlfif
yme HeCIWJIbID[X IIOKOJIeHtfiI. COfnaCHO KOropOM)' Y'l'Bep,!\IfJIOCh OTHOllIe-
Ime K :!KI1JIbKl KaK K 6eCILllaTHO I1peJ:IOC"faBJM0M)' rocy.n;apCTBOM COW\-
aJIhHOMY 6.nary.
BamHefunHe OOl.\l1aJIb1ID-::UIDlJOMlf'lE.'ClUll:' RcrreKTb! pe co-
speMeHHoi1 )KJ pe4JopMb! COCTOHT B TOM, 'lT06bl BceMepHO CUO-
COOCTBOBaTb POCTY 110M mnJIIffitHOI'O q.OH,1\a B 'IaCTHort: c06cTseHHocTIf
rpa>K,lJ;RH JI topIW1'IeCKllX JD1Q nyTeM npY!BaTll3al.(lftl CYJ.l\eCTsymll.\ero
rOCY.AapCTBeHHoro JI Myoro  4x>HAa. BCH'IeCKoi1
nOMepmKe LleHTpaJIbHbIMR If MYHI1rrarrbHbIMIf opraHaMH BJiaCTIf If yrr-
paBJIeHJ1.f/ rpa)K,lJ;RH, npJ1Ba'I'II3HpOEaBllII1X :!KlllJlble nOMell.\eHJ1.f/, yCTaHoB-
JIeHlf10 meCTl\lfX  no OTHOllleHIUQ K OJImHOCTHb!M JllfqaM, npe-
IDITCTB nepe,!\a'le rpa)K,I\aHaM B co6cTBeHHOCTb 3aID1MaeMb!X JlMIi
)KIfJlbIX nOM€llIeHl1If B ,l\OMaX rocy,llapCTBeHHOro If bHOro)Klf-
JII1Orol}JolWl.
Cy:ti:\ecTBeHHaRpOJIbB peaJlJ13aIJ;l1Y! OTMe'leHHbIX CIJW
'lecKJIxnp06J1eMpec}x>pMbIJl3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbHOMY
pery.ID1pOBamIlO, erep:>KHeM KOTOporo Bb!CrynalOT nIJJ.IHIJ;I1IIbI npJlBaTl13a-
IJ;I1Y! )KIfJIbIX nOMell.\elrnlf. B Ha)'Ke jX.JCCIDIcKOro >Ka.IIJ1Il.\HOro npaBa nOKa He
npe,!\fIpIflUlTOHIfO)UlOro,l\I1CCepra1l1UllIJfO.MOHOrI1JII1J1Horo
CI\OJIbKO-Hlf6y,l\b 3Ha'illMOro ,  B Ka'leCTBe CaMD-
Ie.. lIene""nllpOrpa"Ma-.:Kl1nlIje'.OJ:\06pe""eose. 1
TaMHCTPOB-rlpa....enDCT""MJOT20"OOHn1g93(;N!!595"eO(jpaHHeao:ro.rlpe3l1-
Jl,eHTa..rlpaBl'll>!IlbCTBaMJ. 19Q3.NI'2B.Cr 2593. t--

CTCIHTE'JIbIICI'O npe,!\MeTa npl1HIJ;IillbI npl>1BaTH3aWU1 :!KI1.ITbIX nOMeIIleHMif'.
OcTalO'rCR He BHRIIJEI!HliMIt ill{ l'JereaH npl>1po,!\a, 
4Jop.llfpCJ&lIDlR, CIIeI.(I$= BbIpameHl1Jl (np:»rBJIflllIfJ, aaKpEfi1Iemm),
cyw;HOCTb, po,!\OBaR If BJ1.l\OBaR .DrJ<}xPepeHW\3.qJ1H, CVJCTeMa If OcooetiHCJC'I'JI
Mem.n.yTeMO'I'Me'«'lIHUenp06J1eMbIOTHocmCJIK'illC-
MYco,!\epmalI\ll!XMHoroac!IeKTHbIeIfMHOrOKa'leCTBeH-
HbIeCTOpOHbIIfOIDCpe.llC'!'BOHI1fI:»G1JnfI.l..tHoro
IIpaBa B006l1\e If npl>1BaTIl3a4l1l1 mVlJIhIX nOMelJ..lelll1if B 'l1lCTHOCfI1. M3yqe-
HHe JfX 6y,!\eT Tb 6o.nee I'.ny60KOM)'notG1M3.HY!1OCJl1'HCCTIIIf
coqIlaJIblIOfO Ha3Ha'l.eHIf.II caMero )KIfJIoro IIpaBa If npI>1BaTH3aJ.tV1H)lG!-
JIbIX nOMememm
H 11 Ha)"JHaH o60CHoBaHHOC'T'b pa3pa6oTKl1 }'Ka3aHHbIX
npo6JIeMHeMoryT6bITbCBe.rIeHbIJIHllIb Klf3seCTHbIMl'IeCKIIMlIo-
CTIDKeHi'lliM, nocKOJIbKY OHI1 l1MelOT He MeHee CJIIlecTBeHH)'lO QeHHOCTb K3.K
lIJ1J1oon.TaKlfnpaBCilplrMeHJ.ITeJlUlOfi:npaKTIfKI1.&eBbmle-
nepe'{J1CJIeHHoelfueo6xi:JJu1MJCTblfaKT.YaJIbHOCTbIfCCJIe-
lIOBaHI1.F! CJIIlecTB)'lOlQen npoMeMbI.
«> 1
II<1CKnIO'!eHeM"BI1eTCafWotJ\ilTCKaWA'1ccepTaLl"t"I<1_rCBePAl'''KnpI'",,'''
saLll1""'Il...IlOMEUIH'ii.(M..200110uiB11bH..ellOJl@;eH"3TOrOyCTa-
pell,TIII<Ka.paI5oTa0a3poBallaCl>H8.Cy\1I9CT8yIOw.e;;TClJJ,al4OpM8T\'leHO;;6a3e,uOTOP\'lO
c200IBHOCW1""bcytllOCrneHH..e__"29,qe,,,,15D2004fJ,y.
t.IOl\P<t>npI1_>Kw1I1!I<WI<QII,eKCP<t>"_"B,qe'I9C1MSpTa2005roJ>eAapan"""M
saKOHOMor29I\eo<a15p112004r N'189-1)B ..,qeCT"e)l(MnlJIHorO'QlIeKcaF'OC
Cl>a.<lepaL.lMM(CM.Co15paMMeF'occI1c.o;;.2005
111'1 'I. 1 CT14)

rnaBa I
0611111E np06nEMbi
>Kl1nl1l11Horo nPABA,
ErO npl1Hljl1nOB
11 npI1BATI13Aljl111
>Kl1nblX nOMEIIIEHI1i1
 1. IOP.l<4ECKA npPO.l<A >KlliHOro nPABA
 Em npa.1HL.II.1nOB
B QeJJJIX nOJIHoro " BCeC'TOjXJHHeI' J1CC,JI€J:\IJBaffi OCHOBHb!X npo6.JIeM
HGfID!!Wioro npaBa, npilllL\J!lIOB npJ1B3.TIi3aQIDI )KJ1Jlb!X nOM€llJ"IDIM, paBHo
KaK J1 pR,!1a J1HbIX CM3aHHbIX C J1CCJIeAj7el>D>IMJ1 npofuIeM, HaM npe,1\C1'aBJUI-
eTCH Me'I'O}:IOlIJI1 npaBIfJIbHbIM J1 He06xo,!J;I.1MbIM nepBOHa'ffiJIbHO BbI-
HBlITb IOplf)J;J1'leCK)'IO npYlpo,qy car-lOro HGfJmIQHoro npaBa. CJIe.!l)'e'I' nO):l-
'1epKIIYTh, 'lTO HaYI«' rom: CCEJeT'CKCI'O, TaR J1 COBpeMelllJOro }XJCO'II1cIocro
npaBa TepMJ.1HbI <IOpIWf'IeCRa.F! np"po,!\3., <npaBCEaH np"po,!\3.» J1ID! npo-
CTO -IIpIfJX!.l\a» 'I€ro-JIK60: npaBa, npaBOO'THIll€Hllii, IWHKpernDronpaBOBO-
ro J1HCTlITyra (lfMeeT OH OObNHbm J1ID! IOCI\IIIJIeIfiIIilli XapaKTep), no.n;OTpac-
JIY! npaBa HJIII! IOCiMIIJIE!OC'HCIii OTpac.iIY! npaBa J13BeCTHbI):lOBOJIbHO ,!\aBHO. Ro,
HecMO'Ipil Ha J1X llIIiIpoKOe JCDJIb3OBaIDI€', ):10 CJ1X nop OHIf OKa3aID!Cb 4x>P-
MaJIbHO Heill1}Je.I:It'JIeHHbIMIf. 31w.rn KaTeroplfHMI1 yqeHble-npaBOBeJ:{ll. KaK
npaBI1JIO, onepKpyKYI' nplf noru.rrKe paCKpbITb npaBOBble oco6eJJHocTJ1 '1ero-
JIJ16o: OTpaCJIeBb!X, po):lOBb!XJ1ID!BInCYlCTeMbIJ1ID!
C'JPYKTYPbI npaBa. J1x J1C1I0JIb3yKJr nplf 060cHOBaHIfYI -rex J1.IIJI J1HbIX 1Op1f-
J\If!.jeCKI1xrIfJC'I'POf2lUlii.niJ1T.n.
Or,AeJIbHble I1CC.IIe,rJJJBaTeJIY! B IXIIIl'KaX nO):lOOHb!X KOHC'IJJYKQlfH J1 nOCT-
poelIJl!H, He HaXO;I,J'l, a TaIOKe He paCKpbIBafI J1X Cyw,HOCTIf, oOo3Ha'ialOT 3T1f
HBJIeIDm TepMIDIOM «KJpJIJII1'IeCRB npHpo,!\3.». TaK, B.B. 363eeB, IIbITaJICb
pa306paTbCHBTOM, 'lT0c060l1npe.!lCTaBJIHeTIpHcKHi1060pcrr,06ocHo-
BbmaeT nOH,RTlfe ero, ee,!\eT pe'lb 06 o&beKTax  o60pOTa, J1X
npaBOBOM pe:>Kl1Me, a TaIOKe npCIBOW1T 0'ITpaHK'IeIIII rpa.m,1IBHIHJIU o6opo-
'fa OT o6opOTa ):IeJIOBoro. PaaHDpo,IJ;Hble J1 pa3HOC.l6pa3HNe nOHHTIffi BeCT- 1
eeHlIbIft J1 cyfri.eIcrHIDi cocrae Ha,!\eJImOTCH aB1'OpoM Ka «IOPIWf-
0\

'IeCIOCIf I1pfJXJ,[!W IpaJti,!\aHQ\Ol'O 060para, '1TO €)J;Ba Jrn M()jfQfO IIpl13HaTb
npaBJiJIhHb!M I .
Onep:ipyH Ha3Balllioiii RaTeropl1eiii, aBWp, Ha Haw B3I'JJ.IJJt HI1 Ha i1uryHe
npo)J;Bl1Hyncii BnepeA B paaq::t>rI1m Cyw;HOCTI1 K.p\!\WJearoD IIpI1POAbI
rpam.!\aHCKCI'006ojXITaJ106Hapy»mJITOro.'1T01\OJDKHOBKJIa-
,lUill!aTbCH B c01\€p)K1lHJl!e STom nOHffi'I1R
J1MeRBBUJ\YCJI()jfQfOCTbJ1Hepa3pa6oTaHlIOCTbY!\a-
3lU1H0i1 Ra-rerqJ1n1, B KOHTeKCTe 3TOi1 pa5oTb:I no)< «f IIpl1po-
1\0i!}) :!KIfJIoro npaB3. Mbl nOHI1M3.€M TaKi1e cp)'H,!laM€HTaJIbHble nOJlOiK€-
HWI, ROTopble Moryr CTaTb OCHOBOiii onpe,11eJleHIfJI TOro, 'lTO C060M
npeACTaBJIHeT oe npaeo, RaK [JHO IIpoHBJlHeITH B nplfHwmax npJII-
BaTH3aWlJ1.H\11J1bIX nOMeupOOj. KaKOea JIIX BHyrpeHHAA CTpyKTypa JII MecTO
B cI1cTeMepocem1rnoro npaBa
TIpo6.rIeMa cyw;HOC1'l1 J1 Me<:Ta caMOro npaBa 1KJ1.IlJIlW{oro B 06meI1 CJ.fCTe-
Me npaBa C UC1'OpW'Ie<.'K1 rI03JIltI1i1 Cl6cYi!(,!\aeTCH rop£1CTaMJ1 nOC'l"MHHO.
rrp£1STHXnp06n:eMJ1Mel1HOC)'Kaaal1Hb!XJ1cropl1'lecKl1Xno.n;-
XD,lJ;OB MOiKHO 06HaPY'f01Tb, 'lTOnp€ACTaBJITeJIJII HayKi1 COBeTeKOro Ipaa\A3.H-
CROro J1oronpaBa OCTamUIHXOjXIwee HaCJIee, BHCKa3bIB1lSI, 0)<-
HaKO, no paCCMa'lpl1BaeMoi1 npo6n:eMaTl1K€ }:\aJleKO He [J)J;H03Ha'lHble MHeHJ.1H.
TaR, no Ha3BaJlfI)fi: np06J1eMe, (),!\Ha Ipynna yqeHbJX-rop£1CToB C'mTaer,
'1TO >KIfJIHoe npaBOffilJlHeITH dHCTIrryIU\'lIpHCK!)ro npaBa 2 .
.lI:aHH3..fI TO'IKa 3peHJl!H BbICKa3aHa Ha3BaHHbIMlI! )"IeHbIlIrn 1\0 npl1H.f!TI1H
DeHOE .1KI1JII1lqHoro 3[lK!)HO,11aTeJ1bCTBa ColO3a CCP J1 COlQ3HbIX pecnyDJII1K.
BIDCJIeJICTBIfIf T.e. y*€ nOCJIe npl1HJIT11H )'Ka3aHHbIX DeHOE oro
aat(OJJ(),llaTeJlbCTSa, TaltOI1 :me II03IIWm nplf,lJ;ep}!{JISaJmCb }I Hl'I{()T()()lde
,Apyrl1e yqeHbIe. HaI1pKMep. B.I1I. HROBJleB C'llITaeT. '1TO .mI1Jll1lW10e npa-
Be «no peJKl1MY pery.lD1poBaHIfJI 0CH0BHbIX OXBaTbIB3.€Mb!X 11M DTHOWeIDfI1
(nO)lG!JlbeMJ1IIO.lIb3OBa1llnoIpai!(,!\aHaMl1)lG!Jlb!Ml1nOMel1\e-
HI1.HMI1) 1\OJDKHO 6bITb KBa.JIJ$14JipCGIHO B Ka'leCme I1HCTlITyra IpaiK,!\aH-
CKoronpaBa})3.::hoyrseP'f\,D;eHl1eHenpo,JJ;Bl1I'aeT.HaHaWB3rJlJUl, -
Hl1e BH.Y"1'P€HHei1 C'Ip)'KTYpbI O'lpaCJlJli npaBa BIIepe,11 J1 ee 1\I1a'-\l1l{
Ha IfHCTIrryTbI J1 n01\01pacJ1J1 Ec.rr11 C ll[)MO1O npeml'!eTa npaBoBOro pery-
Jlt1pOBaHIDI J1 TaKl1X '1epr MeTO.Qa Ipam,II,aHcl(O-npaBr)Boro perYJ1I1poeaHIfJl,
1 e.... 6.I5.rpa><,qaHcKo6opoT'flOO""""IOP........"ec"""flPI'IpoJI'I/frOC)'lI'IpcTIIO
"1lp890.I999W2.C32-3B
2C.... I5aGJ<HIO.r.Bonpoc"COI!e-rcKoro""'nLllHoron.Da.a.-AnMa-AT3 11"",-eoKa3rY.1963.
C. 21.15en"K0B8A.M.. KOMajJOa B.K. KopHeeeC.M >Ko<MLllHbIe npaaa rpa>K.D,aM eCCCP
Pef<3"l<aKHryBCJ>.'jM""pa Cooen:me>Kl<nMl1\HoonpallO"/ICo.e.-CKOOIUC)'A3pcT90
"n.D8BO,I965.W12C 136;nor""'08A.r)l(MnLllHoenpaeo.-Il-8o
roywe pcme1tI. W73 C.B
3f1KOBIl8iIB.CJ>,OcMoe"""""L1IHOroCotOOaCCP"COIOOM"Xpecrl\lOnK"
pe",...npa80Boroperyn"poaaM""'MnLllHblXOPCIIEHotii/lOcHO...cceera«>rc_nMUI-
 M"""'Y3.COOpH"KHay"HblXTpyl\Oe.-I13,!\.IIOYPrY,
QI

RaK ,IJ.rnBOJIK1'eJ " npa O)\HJII IfCCJre,IJ.OBaTeJIJI lIbITa-
JTh!Cb O'ITpaHWllfI'b rpam,llaHCKOe npaso OT yro.rrOBHOro I1JIIf a,!J;MI-
TIlBHOro l , TO.r:qJyI11e }l'!eHbIe 2 cnparewnlBO npe1 0 TOM, 'ITO
HeJlb3H nplf,!\aBaTb yKa3aHHbIM 'iepraM MeTO..u,a.IDfWb rpootQ:\3.tICKO-npaBO-
BOif xapaKTep, 1160 «I1le If MeeT MecTO nplf BCsrnOM npaBOBOM
pery.lIllpOBaHWl, B paMKaX lunroif fib! mpaCJIJl! 3TO perYJTh!pOBaHHe HH ocY-
TBJlIL1]Ocb.menpaBaMJICOI1pJlKdCaJIOCCHa)\eneIDieMcno-
c06HocTblOJ1MeTh06H3aIlllOCTIf,RaTerop"HcB060-
,JJ;bIHe BCBHJIf C RaTeropneH ,A0JIf3. yrpa'ilfB3.eTCBOif CMbICJI"
onpe1\E'JIeIlllOCTb.. 3 .
Cna60cTh m:B.I1I.HKOBJIeBaBTOMlfCOCTOI1T, 'ITo"-3erocyJK.l\e-
IDfifHef!CHO,RaROHnOHl1M3.eTpeJro1MnpaBoBOropery,1ICCJ1l;lJ;O-
BaID1e 'iepr Ipam.I\8.HCKO-npaBoBOro Me"f())18. Be)\eT C aocTpaKTHbIX 06lI\eoT-
pacneBbIX IIOOJIQIfi1: If He ,AeJIae-r nOlIblTKM 06Hap)'JKeID1H 11JIY! I1pOHBJIeID1H
'iepT MeTO)\a Ha ypoBHe TalG!X C'lpyltTypHbIX nOJlfla3,l1e1l€lUlii CIfCTeMbI
 npaBa, RaK no)\01pacIDI If npaBOBble I1HC'fI1'"lyfbI )'MB.JI.HH
po.m.lfCBoeo6pa3Ifeonocpe.II,yE'MbHOpMaMif
yroI3aHHbIXCTpYK"'YPHblXrpamJIallCIOCf"npaBa.I13BecTHo,
O)\HaKO, 'ITOperYJIi'lpoBaHJllecBOe06pa3HbIXOTHI:JIIHDfi.IHop-
MaMJI TaKKX, HarrplfMep, mrrJ1'I')"fCI3 KaR 06H3aTeJlbCTB3. "-3 nprtnrneHIUI
Bpe,1\a, a TaIOKe IJeOCIIEa'I'eID 06oraII{eIDI.I1 If HeROTOpblX .I\PYrIfX ocY-
I..I.\ff:TBJlHeTCH He CIIoco6oM ",I\OOBOJIIITE'JI, a ero aH'fJlIlO,JJ;OM, T.e. «33.-
npeni'I'E'JlblI' >, 06 m'OM Mbl)l)Ke IDICaJllf B IfHoif CBJI31f» 4.
Pery.lIl1pyeMble IM npaBOM  OTII)llHD1H1\D-
BO.i1bHO pa:nuo6pa3HbI "Heo,!\HOpo,!\Hb! no co,!\epmaHlOO OrnOWeID1J'1, 06pa-
3yrolI\l1e npe,!\MeT HeKOTOpblX WICTI1'fJTOB " nOJWTpaCJIeif 
npaB3., COCTaBJIJ'IIOT TOJlbKO cmpe,lleJIeHHyIO I1X 'ffiCTb, T.e. OHJII HBJIJilOTCH
IIJ,l1CI1CTeIIW CIfCTeMbI rpam,zr,aHCKo-npasOBbIX o6ru,ecmemIux O'IHOI11eHlm
B LleJIOM. Ec.rr11 RCCJIe,QOBaTb oe npaBO C n03l'1QHl1 ero co6cTBeHIIOii
CTpyKTypbI, TO HeJlb3J'I OCTaBl1Tb He3aMe>IeHHbIM>'I Te BI>K'I\a3aHtiI: B HayKe
MHeID1H, cornaCHO KOTOPblM :m:M.IDIlI\HOMY npaBY 1IpdCylI!I1 C06CTBeHHbie
npaBOBble 1HC'TII"'lyIH. J1CCJ!e,I\J"H CymHOCTb JKI1J!Y!lI\Horo npaBa C n03Y!-
IIIfI!: BOIIJIOlI\eHJ.lH B HeM 11pI1IIW1llOII. nOJlaraeT, '11'0 B )KJ.IJU1lI\HOM npase
CJIellYeT BbIJ\eJIHTb He TOJIbKO COOCTHemIO JKI1J!O-npaBOBHe 11HC'"I1I'I)'-
Tbl, KOTOpble npe.IIC"I<\BJl co6oif rpyIIlIbl HOPM, pery.lII1pytO!l.\I1X rropH,!\OK
ICM.f1KD!II1fIIIB.ct>.rp;l>i(lJ,aHCKD.npmIOSOMeTQJI,on'OL"e.
HH Y"elSHoenoco!'ie.-CeePA'lOBC., 1972.C. 70HCJlE\.!j.
2e_ ir'',1OJ\npallO"oroper)'"r>o""H"R"erOlIr1paoO""Ae
al(pacalMOO)lJOAnOH"TeCOBeTCK()I"Qlp<r*JlaHc.oronpaaaIJCoBeTCKOeIp<r*JlaHCKOe
npaso,-CBej),IIIlO.CK, 1976 Bbln.I.C 20 I
.CMr.A.npHlJ,LtnblCOBeTCKoroIp3)l(Jl,3HCKoronpa"":I\oIc...l\-pa,lOpLt,l\.Ha,,,,_
CaeM/lOBC., 19S5.C 120. ::::

IIpe,l\OCTaBJl€HHH :!KIfJIbIX nOMell{eHKi1, KHCTKTyr ,I:\OroBOpa Hai1Ma JKI1JIbIX
B,I:\OMaXroCY,I:\apCmeHHblXlf)KJfJ!IfJltHbIXo/JH-
,I:\OB ",I:Ip., HO" KHCnrryrbI, HOpMbI KOTOpbIX pery.lD1pywT roCY.l\3.pCmellliD-
a,D,MJIHW::'IpaTJllBHbIe Ifq:wmmBO-npaBOBbIe OTHOWeHl1H, npnMbIKaIOll{HeK
C06cmellliOIfTeCHOCBfl3aHHhIeCHI1MIf1.
Or,I:\eJIbHhIe yqeHhIe, COr.rraIIIaRCbC TeMIDJK:DReHJ1eM, COfJIaCHO KOTOJXlMY
)ID1Jll1oe npaBO BblC'fyna€'l' 'laCTbIO rpam,IlaHcrroro npaaa, TpaK'TJ'1O'T' ero
BMeCTe CTeMKaKnOIDIMaeMOeB'Ipa]UnmnD}l3KOMCMhICJIe. IIpl13TOMno-
J!CHHeTCH, 'ITO ero CO,!\ep»ca.TeJIbHYlO 'laCTb COCTaBJIHeT COBOK)'IIHOCTb HopM
Ipam,[laHCKQ-npaaoBOro xapaK'l'epa, peryJIJ1POTHOllleHl1$lnon0JIb3o-
BaHI1IO:JKI1JIhIMlf nOMeIl\eHl1lIMI1If I1JX]JKlfBaHl1lO B HI1X. 3TI1 0THUIIeHIDI C'!I1-
TaJ'lHAPOMJKlfJU1I.qHbIXOTHOWeIDn?CJ'K,!IeHI1.!!, bMa CXO;I,HbIecnpl1-
Be,I:\eHHbIMI1, BbICKa3bIB1IJllICb " paHee. Tal{, BJ1. JIIITCI!KI1H, npl13HaBaJ'l
JoKI1JIJ1IqHoe npaBO IICOC'IaBK:IK 'laCTbtOrpaJK,Z:taHcKoro IIpaaa»3, nOJiarae-r, 'ITO
era  COCTaBJUIIOT «cneJ.ti'!8JlliHhle HOpMbI rpajl\I\aHCKOfO IIpaaa,
pefJIaMeHTI1pyIOll{I1eBJIa)\emle IfIDJIb3OOaIDU' 'fj"KI1MJKlfJIbeM»4.
05OCTb nO,!\XO,!\OB B nOHl1MaHKI'I JKlfJl}!ll{HOfO IIpaaa rr.J1.Ce)J;yfl1HbIM
If B.H Jh1'TQBRIfiIblM B TOM If COCT'OHT, 'ITO 000 OID1 He TOJIbKO I'OJIOCJIOBHO 3a-
J!BJIIDOT,'ITO:HG1JII1oenpaBO-'ffiC1'bIIpaaa,HOIfHenbITa-
tOTCJ'I o6'wI:CHlfI'b, 'lTO 3TO 3a 'laCTb, a TO'1Hee roBOPJI, KaKOOO pmamE
3TOi1'laCTI1.AHa.ID13:mE' 3TOi1'laCTI1n03BOJU1eTc,!\eJIaTb
BblBO,!\ , 'ITO rr.J1. Ce.uyrHHY If B.H. JhI1'CEKJlHy He ,AOCTaeT caMOi1 M8.JIOCTl1 -
pelIDITeJIbH03a.llID1TbOTOM, 'ITOcyqeTOMKaKpaHeeKO,!\H(j:IJ1-
KaI.1ID1 JKI.f.IDIll{Horo 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBa, TaK" Ul'HOCI1TeJIbHO He,!\aBHO ocy-
I.l..\ec'I'BJJ€3aKOHO)J,aTeJIbCTBa rpaiK,l\aHCKOro,:HG1JII1oe
npaBOnpe,!\CTaBJIJ'leTc06oi1npaBOBOi1ID1CTJ1"1YI'.E.JIIDKeBCero
K TaKoMY BbIBO)Jy llO,!\OWe.rr llJ1.Ct>.AyrnH5, KO'I'Cp>rli XCTrH 11 He,[leJIaeT era
np.flMO, HOCOJllf,!1aPJ13IfJJYf2TCJ'IC B.q:. fuOBJIeBh!M,ymeno-
'c... Caep,wlIolKr.A npHLII1n"COile-rcKororpa;owaHcKOronpa.a.,AI1c ...-palOp......H3-
VI' - Coej)AllOIICK, 1985. C. 280 I< CJIeA 0 I<aJ1...." co6crneHH"" npa.o.". I<"CTIflyrO. B
C1P\'t<1)IJ)e",,,n"LllHoronpasaBa£l8TP&<b..n.C.H"KI<TIOK(C". H"".moJ(n.C,>K"n,,1WtOII
npa&O.-KwHee. 1985.C.40I<c.neJ:1.1
2C...Hn.J1.>Ki1n"UlHoeflJl3&l:Y<Ie6H"KW1"Bv.!0II.-M.I1"-'I3TeJ1IoCK8IIrpymaI1H-
ClJPA-M-HOPMA.1977.C 10.
3n"rOlJl(J<HB.H,>K"""l1jfIOOflJI3&I''''''''''UlHoe-coonIOL1I8H''eCIJIIDI'
HC'''''npaeo''IIHoB''Ipa)O:!laHC<"iiOOJ:1eKCPocc""I<cnpac.oeeOll-
M..1995C.64
.n"rOiiK"HB.HTa....e.
5C...  n.J1. >Kw1"UlHoe npa.o V><e6H"KW'" By.300. - M lo1"-'I3TeJlloCKaO rpyrma
I1H4>PA_M.HOPMA. 1977 C. 10 Asrop....enBB"J:1Yo<ap.!1>tHaJ",HoeHOBJIeH"e"KOJ:1>t<fi".
'a4"IO"'L<nLllHoro'orop"eOCYll\eCTBJllU1l1CbBJW""HOCT"'l"W\bInpo
WJlorocTOJJernHnOCJJeI1jJ"H""'HO:;Ho."'L<n"L1IHOrOComaCCPl1co.
I03H...pecnytin"K M..C'I"Taer.o..eoOxoJJ.L<......OOpa-rmH33TOBH"MaH"e.nOCKOJlbKYC
I1jJI<H""'eMH"'fIe>Ki1nHUlHoroKOJ\eKcapQ)npoeBA"OOeL1jB6oJJee""PJ\l'l
HaJ1bHoe"""'''UlHoroI<eroM..He.acaeMCH
ao.e<:bBQnp:x:aHBC'QJ1b.o.a'IeCT"eHOO310CJ\BII8HO
I

CJle Rap,lJ;l1HaJIbHOro 06HoBJIeHYIH tf KO,U;I :!KI1JItfIWIoro 3aKOHO-
TeJIbCTBa,'lT0enpaBO-tfHCTIfI'yrnpaBa1.
BnOJlXO",eKm :HULIIIfll\HoronpaBa BRa'lecTBe rpIDK.!!aH-
CKo-npaBOBoroHHCTIfI'yra IT.:!! Ce,uymH JI! B.H JIIfTOBI\I1H npOHBJlHK1I' HeKO-
TOPY1O OCTOpo:IKHOCTb JIilllIb nOCTOJlbKY, nOCKO.IIbRY 3Ta n03 He MQm€T
lIp€TeH,/\OBaTbHaqJfIl1fHa.JINIDCTb.,llJl OHa I1llJlJ1eKOHeHOBa.K
I1CTOpIU1Ha)'1\l'lI1:HUL1I1fIItHOronpaBa n03BOJU1eTHanOMIDfI'b:
B HfbE I'OJ<bI nporWlOro CTOJIeTI1fI PM yqeHbIX nOJlaraJI, 'lTO:mI1-
oenpaBO HBJI.F!E.'TCH JlHCTIlTyrOM npaBa  B TOT nepllO"',
Kor",aKOlD..\efiW'UlBbl1TaJIaCb, .OHaJl!MeJIanpaaOHa CJlI-\eCT-
BOBaHJ1e. nOCKOJIbKY HOpMbI rpaHi.!IilHOOCJ npaBa perynl1poBaJlJil OTHOllI€-
HJ1HnOHaj;iMY.mJ1JIb!XO)J;HaKOoenpaso,
eCR Ha OM ::!aKOHOTeJIbCTBe, pa3pOCJl0Cb]JJ) 06'beMa, COCTOffil.\ero
J13 c06CTB€HHbIX npaBOBbIX JlHCTKTyrOB. Or<:1QAa €)IB3. JIIi 6blJl0 6b1 npaBrnIb-
HbIM OCTaBaTbCH Ha ID3tfItI1If., corJIacHO IWI'Opoi1:)fG(Jn1lltHoe npaBO - 11l£l'II-
TyrnpaBa
B H3.Y'JKM JIliT€pa:I)'pe wecTleCf!Tb!X 1'O",OB npOIl/Jloro CTOJIeTl1fI BbI-
CKa3bmanOCb MHeHtfe 0 TOM, '1TO :m:JfJlllIIVDe npaBO npe.1J1:"I'3BJI co6oi1
KOMI1JIeKCHbrn npaBOBoi1 JlHCTlITyf. am MHeHJ.re  'reM no-
JIC»!\eHtfeM. cornaCHo KOTOpoMY a.zn>UiIHtfCTpaTtfBHO-npaBOBbIe tf rpIDK.!!aH-
CKo-npaBOBbIe HopMbI, BXo.wnu;I1e B 3TOT mfCTwryr, perynMpyKIT 
'Ip3.TJ1BHbIeJl!0I'tI01lIeHJ1.f/.amMHeHJI!eRaK6y"'T06b1HJI!I\eMHe
pa3",eJUlJIOCh B npaBOBOi1 Ha:yKe. O,mIaKO nOH JiiJlEpaY,I\e 6bIJIa no,l\-
BeJJrHYTa KptfTJl!Ke. Or,l\eJIbHble yqeHbIe IIOJIara.JIJl!, B 'ffiCTIlOCTJl!, 'ITO no-
CKOJIbK)' TaIDfe KOMI1J1eKCtIbIe JIlHC'I"I1T)'1'bI He JiMem e,l\lfHoro npe",MeTa JIl
COOTBeTCTB)'lOlI\eI"O 11M MeTO,l\a npaaoooro pery.mtpOBaIDl.l1, JI!X HeJIb3H pacno-
Ji())fGITb B o&belITJllBHO  CJl!CT€Me COBeTCKOro I@aa,noCTpO-
eHlroIinoyRa3aHHbIM1tBYMKJIaCCI.rrpeJJ;C'laEI-
JIJleTC1!, 'lT0 TaRaH KpJl!TJI!Ka He MO:IKeT 6bITb npJll3HaHa KOHC'Ip)'K'I'I1BHU1.
MHeHJ1e lOT. EacmIa JI! B.41 'bIrJllfla,'lTo  )KJI!JU/!IWIo-npaBO-
soi1 mfCTtf"ryr HeJIb3JI paCilOJIroKJIlTb B CIfCTeMe npaBa, €lI\e He Cm1,!\eT€JIb-
CTBye-r 0 ero urcyTCTBmL IIpaBOMepHO nOC'l"aBlf'l'b BOnpOC: eCJIIf KOtIllI1I€KC-
HbIe npaBOBI;IE' mICTIf'lyI'bI HeJIb3.11 paCIIOJI())KtfTb B CtfCTeMe npaBa, TO
l1Mem JIJI! OHtf npaBO Ha C)'II\€CTBIJRIHJI!€? CTaI!.JlfJeTCJI. 'ITO HaJIl1'Itfe
KOMIIJIeKCHbIX I1HCTJ1TyrOB npaBa Bo06!l.\e JI! KOMI1JIeKCHblX o-
1 CM fiIcoem1BB.4>.OcI<OSbl"""LWIOI"03S/;ObCTBaCot03S.CCPCOI03HblXpecnyO.nK
ItpeJl<l<...npaooooroperynPO"""It""""l1JHblXornOlJJeHIt/lOcI<oSbl""EleTCI<oro"""ltlJlHO
roMe>my3.c6."",",.lJ!YlI,OB.-C""p,anOllCK:IW:\-ooYp/'"Y.1981.C.45.
2S.'::21He"orop"'e Bonpo:;bOCI<CTe"''' ""aeTCl<Qronpa..../lY4eH_ 3811 BI'lIOH
Be.. 6ac...'IO.TBonpOC..00Be10:CI'0'".u1ltlJlHOronpa....__An...a.ATa.1963.C 19-22; 1 
"IW1<jJB.4>.CO""TGKOO'".u1l1JHoenpaao.-MltHCK, 1968 C.24. 

npaBOBbIX HHCTJ11'YI'OB B 'IaCTIIOCTII - ilJatIT OfueKTIlBHoi1 pea..rrbHOC'I1I
ITpe.II,CTaBI4'I'cfnteji TeOpJ.rn npaBa ymepiK,IlalO1', 'lTO KOMnJIeKCHbIe J1}J-
CTI11)'ThI HB.IUIlO'l'CJI O.n;HOi1 J'!3 $!pM B31U1MQAeiiX:'rmrn: Me)HJJy OTpaCJUIMH
IIpaaa. ,l\JlR1OCMrI.JI€!OC'H HHCTIIT)'Ta xapaK1'epHO, 'i1'O CBJf3b MeifQIy OT-
pacJlRMJ.I3a-rparnBaeT CaMOe CO,1\epmaHlfe  
npaBJIIcy6"beK1tJB71.
O!1brT'CBlf,!\eTeJJbCTtlYeT, '11'O,lJ,aJIbIlethll pa3BIfTIf€ npaBOBbIX J'!CCJIe,1\o-
BaHJ1i.i 0 CJlCTeMe J'! C'IpyK'IJ'pe IIpaaa n03BO.IDlJlO C OOIl.\fflpaBOBbIX n031fq1fi1
HamJ1 Mecm B CJ1CTeMe IIpaaa Ha3aaHHbIM npaBOBbIM IIHC'I1ITy'I8M. TaK,
e.e. A1rKcem yrBepm,I\aeT, 'IT{) «EOMIIJIeKCmIe I1HCTIIT)'Tbl flBJUIIOTC.II cne-
BropI1'lHbIMlfnpaBOBbIMlf
yJJ;BOeHJl!eHOpMaTl1BHoroMaT€pJ1aJIa . KaKJ'!yJJ;BOeHJl!eC'lpyK'T'y-
pbI IIpaaa Ha APyrnx ee ypomUIX, $:1pM>1JXH1lllE KOMIlJIeKCHbIX I1HCTII'lYfOB
CBJf3aHOCMHmKeCTBeHHOCTbIO'iepTKpCBoeo6pa3J1.Fle-
JleHWI npaBOBOi1C1ICTeMb1, a TalOl\e CJK."I"€IOOC6p
llp1X ilJaKTOpOB2.
Jhat\, Jf,!\eJf :HMIIJ1Oro IIpaaa BBU)\e KeiImJJeKCHC.ro
npaBOBOro ID1CTJ1"I')'1'a  caMa no ce6e, He 5bIJla B CBOeBpeMR
BOCl1plfHlITa J'! )\0JDKHb1M 00pa30M oQeHeHa W1Bf1JllfC'lW1earoM J'! I1H01t 1OpJ'!-
BCB.II3IfCnoJm.JI2IJU('MMHOrnxAPyrnxKOH-
Qerrwrli ::lTa eJf 6blJla OTO)J;BJ1Hyra Ha BTOpoi1, ecJlIf He Ha 6o.rree OT)\aJleH-
HbJif lIJIaH J'! 'rnXO npeAaH3. 3a6BefrnJO. DBa, Oq€BM.n;HO, 3aiIMeT CBOe M€CTO B
IICTOpHI1 J.tlIBIfJII1C'Iearoii MhlCJIJI, HO ymep1K)1€fltf€ 0 TOM, 'iTO »G1JIIilltHO€
npaBO IIpe)\CTaBJlJJeT c06oi1  l1paBOBOi1 I1HCTJ1-ryTJII cID3HWIii
COBpeMeHHOCTJI, MflrKO ro60pH, He COUTBeTCTBOBa.O 6b! ,1\eik'rBHTe1IbHUCTl1
3m roo6pa>IreIDt:e nO.l\TBepm,n:aeTCH BceM XO.llOM,1J,3JlblEi.iweO J'!CCJI€)\OBa-
HJ1.Fl J'! I13JI01t\EIIHJf MaT€pJ1aJIa.
.lWyraHrpyrmayqem,IXnOJIaraeT,'ITOO€npaB01IBJUI€TC.I'!nO)lOT-
pac.riblOIpIDK,!lB.HCKOm npaaa. CJIe.nyeT OTMeTI1Th, 'IT{) C IJ03OOj.j TeD-
pJ1lf IIpaaa H3J16oJIee OCHOaaT€JlbHO€ cyiKAeHJl!e 0 nO)I.O'IpaCJ1RX npaBa soo6
BblCKasaJI Cc. AJIeKceee. IIo em MHeHl1lO, B pa3B1ITbIXOTpacmIXIIpaaa I1HCTIf-
"I)"I'bIHepe)\KOnepepacraKT1' B)'KpyIIHeHHble1Jf - IJO.lIC1lpacJD1.
ITocJl€,1\Hl1e np€,1\CTaBJI.IIIOT co6oi1 TaKJ1e o6wrpHble OOIQHDcrIf ()'I"paCJleBblX
I1HCTI1'fYI'OB, B trorOpbIX 060co6JmeTCJI '\CBOJV' OOl/.ilJl 'IaCTh. Hepe.l\Ko tcpyrr-
Hble OTpocJII'I IIpaea, Hal1pJ1Mep I'pajti.!\aHCKOe npaao, BbICT)'I13JOT B COBp€M€H-
HbIX YCJIOBIUIX B BJ1J1e coe.rollJf2HllJl OOIl\€i1 'IaCTI1 JII rpynrIbl IJO.lIC1lpaCJIei1S.
I
'Arn1Io:eeeC.C.O'jL1lBflTeOjJIoIRCOIII1a<101CT11"ec.oronpasa.-C&epWloec.,lQ63.BbJn.1 C.231
2C.... AneKcooeC.C.CrpyKTyPaco"eTcKOmn,paaa.-M IOPItJl.nMT,I975.C 156.
3 C.... Anei<ceee C. C Ilpo6nBMbO TeopMM npaw Kypc naI«jM' B 2 T. - CeaPA"OBCOO CIOI<!,
1973.T.l.C.140.Ha63>l:Hocr.6I>UIf!neH"nOJl<)TpaCJJen,oa"aM.KC1JIYK.
1)'pHbJXerOpaHaaYl'a3..aanOCJ1o.t>4>e(CM.CrP\'<TYPHbJallQQ,Oa3,llBlIE!.
HHHCHCTeMblllpaBa(HaMaTepHaJIa)(rpa>K,!J,3HCKoron,paaal/Y«eHbleaallHC"HBHI'II<!C3.
1968 Bbln. 14. C. 50).

AEIfuroJIKJ1Hco5lI\eTeOpeTWleC=TOJKenO)J;'JepKHBaeT, 'ITO
m1JII.flltHoe IIpaBO I1bI,!\eJLReTCR II Ita'l.ecTBe nO.I\OT'pacJIH 60JIee KPYIlHOIf tf
CJIomHOW no COCTaay OTpaCJrn IIpaBa - aHclwro IIpaBa'. .n;eWCTBY!-
TeJIbHO, II HCKOMnpaBeMHOme QIIlBY!IDlCTbJBbI,!\emnOT'TaKJl!e erono-
J\OTpaCJrn, IWK npaBO co6cTBeHHo::rJl, 005l3a'I'€Jlht"I1'!eHlDe npaBO. IIpaBO
ro6cTBeIni:x:'rJl!.I\P.
HeKOTOpb[e }"JelibIe, allaJn13t1pY51 p.II,!\ KpyrmbIX np05JIeM lIayroi rpaiK-
.AaHCKOro npaBa, ItaK 6bl norryrno 3aMe'laIDI, 'lT0 II c1pYKTYPe IpIDK,IWHCKO-
I'D npaBa MomHO Bbl,!\eJDI!Tb TaK)'RJ IIO,I\O'IJ.6C1I Kat\ oe npaBO»:!.
CoJrn,1J;apl13Jl!PyroTC$! C 3T11M B3rJI5!,!10M, XOT.R J1 nOMepmlfBaJOT' ero C J1HblX
II:mIWrli. tfJlPYl11e }"JeHble. TaK, Jl!3}"JaR C1pYKTYPYJ1 OcHOB
mwnn.ijHOCOTeJIbCTBa COima CCPJI!COI03HbIX pecny6.rJtiK, a TaK-
:me erpeMJICb BblilBlfTh TO, '1TO COCTaBJUIeT npe,!\MeT npaBOBOro peryJIJ.!}XlBa-
HJI.fI Ha3BaHHblX OcHOB, o.A. RpaCaB'IIfKOB npI111IeJI K BbIBDJIY, COrJIacHO KO-
TOPOMY OCHOBHYIO MaCCY HOpM 3TQro npaBOBOro al\Ta OOpa3ytOT HOpMbl
 npaBa. Crre.I\OBaTeJIbHO, Jl!OCHOBblOro 3aKOHO)\a-
TeJIbCTBa COima CCP JI! COI03HblX pecny6JIJI!K IIpe,!\CTaBJIHIOT co6oi1 OCHOBb!
OCo6orOBlfJ\a-nO,!\OTpaCJIeBble 3 .
Ca BbIBO.I\ (XOT'R JI! aHaJIOrll'lHI:li C 3aKJIIO'IeHJl!eM
o.A. RpaCaB'lJl!KOBa) 0 TOM, 'lT0 )KJI!JIoe npaBO JUlJIJIeTC5I no.I\OT'pacJIblO
npaBa, 1paHeeJl!Mbl,JI!CCJl€JIYRnpofu1eMY
:!KJ1JIJI!IIIHoronpaBa.&IBO.I\TeM,'ITOeCJrnno-
J\OTpaCJIb npaBa IIpe,!\CTaBJLlleT co6oi1 OT1\eJIbHYIO BeTBb, pa3pocI.Il)'lOC5l no
CO.I\epiKalrnlOOTpaCJrnnpaBa, TOo<COBpeMeHHoe)f(lfJJY!lI\-
Hoe 3aKOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBO «nepepoc.nu. paMKJI! 3aK(ti(),1J,aTeJIbCTBa, COCTaM.lllO-
llIero CO.llepm8.ID1e J1HcTJl!'I'YTa :!KJ1JIJI!lI\IIoro HaiWa. ORo ::ma'll1TeJIblIO eM'Ie
no ofu,eMY, r.nyfuKe no COA€piKalrnlO JI! 3H3.'1I1Mee no cil>epe pery.lD1py€MWl:
OTHOIIIeHlfIf, n03TOM)' B KOMIlJIeKCe HblHelIlHee :!KJ1JIJI!lI\IIoe 3<U\OHO)1aTeJIbCT-
BO npe,!\CTaBJIJIeT c050w nO)J;OTpaCJIeBOe 3a.KOHO.!\ll1'eJIbCTBO. a :1Kl1JIJI!IIIHoe
npaso - no,!\arpaCJIb HCKOro IIpaBa»
)J;ejiC'l'BlITeJlbllO, npJ.! peryJIJ.!}XlBaHIDI :HG1.Tll1lI\Hb1X {)'I"H(IllelII1 paHblIIe,
p,a 11 ceWIac I1j:I1M8IHeTC.R 3Ha'lJIT€JIbKJ€ KOJIWIecmo HOpM IpIDK,IWHCKOro
npaea.rIpI>13'1'OMMHOmeI13H11Xl1MeIOT06ti.xapalM'ep.
HaI1pl1Mep: nOJIOiKeHJ.IJI  IIpaBa 06 OM3aTeJIbCTBaX, 0 c,!\e.rr-
1 M".:a1t""":\I<Ie6HH.A/lR""""",,"eC"""'By.JOBlnQJ100ll\'IJaA.A.C, nMroo-
2C.. X<ur4MHaPO,CoBe-rc"""HaY><3rpa;t:,/laHC.oronpasal!COBeTCKOerOCyI\ilfX;T.O.,
JJPaoo,1Q68 N!!7C.I84
Kpaca""""08D.A.OcHOB",>KIUIMlljHororJpeAIdeTperynHpo"",,MR"
OOP'I!IM"BCI(8npHpo.IIal!OcHOBblC08e-rc'orOJ!<WIMlljHoroMa:><BY3_c6
H!lY"_TPVJ1O"_-C"eA"JIOIICI< 1i\;!J\-IIQYPry, 1981 C_16 I
4Caep,all...r.A.rlpMH....n..COBe-rc.oronpaB8.,-I1:t11,-IIOKpaC..,...
HORPC.OroYHMIQ85C_I22 

Kax, 3aI1V'l'renpaBa  0TBe'l'CTBeHH0C3a HeIImO.IIH€HIIeJfIDI
HeHa,!tIIemau..tee HCDOJIH€lU1E' 005l3aTeJIbCTB, IfCI\OOOti: ,D,aBHocm If ;lip.; 6ea
IDIX HeJIb351 o50ifmcb npJ.l peryJIJ.l}XlBaIDrn  OTIJOllieIDIK B co-
BeTCKOM rpa.m.u.aHCKOM 3a TaIOKe 6bLID1 3aJlmKeHbI OCHOB--
HbIe nOJlomeHIffi no BJla,1\eHIOO, IDJIb."3IJ£!IDO If pacnopIDKeHJ.llOrpa:lK,1\aHa-
MYI.npfMi'1J.IMHanpaBe:!KI1.JIJ1IWlMJ.!,KOTOpbIe
HallJJlJ.l CBoe  pa3BKTJ.le }I B OcHOBax )IG!JuflItllOro 3aKOHO):\a-
TeJIbCTBa, }I B bIX KQ,!\eKCax COlO3HbIX pecny6= I'pam.u,aHCKO-
I1j':6B(.IaOii xapaKTep HOCRT}I Te HDpMbI )KJ.IJ!oro 3aKOHO):\aTeJibCTBa, 1\0-
TopbIeperyJIHpywrOTH()ll)2HlfJl,CM3aHHhleC,JI3Mf2HeHJ1€MIf
pacropJKeHJ.leM COBJX'MeHHbIX ,!\OroBDpOB  HaMMa }I nQ.ZJ;HaMMa
)!\J.IJIbIX nOMel.l..\eHI1M, MeHbI >KJ.IJ!J.I!l.\}I ;lip.
B COBpeMeHlIbIX YCJIOBJ1JIX 3Ha'ielIJlIe HOpM HbIHe,A rpaJK-
,AaHcKoro npaBa B peryJIJ.l}XlBaIDrn :!KI1JIJi!l.\Hb1X 0'I1KJIIHIHi.j 
nOBhIIlla€"TC5I B CBJ!3J.1 C B03MIDRHOCTbIO npl«J6peTemur KBapmp B ,AOMaX 1'0-
CY1\B.pCTBelllIoro If aJIbHOro:MaIID 4JoH,/\a B m6crBeHHOCTh
I'pa}K.!\aH. B COO1'BE'TCTBI1I C 3aKOHOM PocmitcKOit epal..{J.lJf O npJ.lBam-
3aI.\ID1 )KJ.IJlI1oro 4JoH,/\a B F'occnW:1roti <PeJ\epal\J.IJ1» rpa:lK,1\aHe, CTaBIill1e
co6CTBeHHJ.lKaMYI KBapTIlp, BnpaBe pacnopHJKaTbC5I1fMJ.! no CBOeM)' YCMar-
peHJ.OO. 3aBeutan., npo,II,aBaTb, C):\aBaTb B apeH;!Iy, cOBepwan. IfHble C.IleJIKII!,
Karopble p€fy.1IIipyKJrCH HOpMaMJ.!  npaBa 1 . C yqewM 113J10-
>KeHHoro He COBceM BepHOM HBJI.F!eTCIf n03J.1qID1 HJ1. Ce;IyrnHa 0 I1]:JICIPIIT€-
Teoro3aKOHO):\aTeJIbCTBanepe.IlCOBeTcroIM3aKOHo-
,AaTeJIbCTBOM, KOTOpoM)' aBTOp OTBeJl JlJ.lllIb  pDJIb B
pery.1Il1pOB<lHJ1l1)KJ.1J!l1bIX OTHOWeIiIot
lIo HallIeM)' MHelIJlIlO, B nEpCIIeK'Tl1Be p1I3BJ.lTl1e )KJ.IJ!oro npaBa 6y-
,Ae-rlfnonYflfBCe60J1bweroeroCHOpM3.MYlrp3.JK-
I CJ1wwerOTo.oeT>TTb,'ITOCOBpeMeHHoerp!aWlffC"oenpaBOpe;Y"PYeTBOCflO"O"OTfIO
lIJe" "o6crneHHOOT H3>1M11b1e mJMelljeHHH (m3"" 18 Il< P\tJ) 11 OTHOLIJeH"" no """Y)l(l1
"blx(ma""35rKP\tJ).eCTCPbIXe"CTjII1aer,",,.
"orcn(JMelljeHMl1nMO<""MLIO.Ta"Ol<ae"BOT"""MeOTCOUMaJ1bHoro
l<a...at<eKOTopbI"'''Y'fE!HbI..(c.....t<al1j)l1...ep,KpaWflHI1HHI1.
I<Osn.B.HaeM"'MOrClIrpa;.;.o,aHCKMI<QQeKCF(J).'iaCTbBTOj)8>l.TeKCTKo....
""'""'IHI ArnJ>alWlTHo-npeJl,MeTHbIYKa33Te.nb/l"\oJ\pe,II.A.K.MaKoIIC""ro,C.A.)(Q),"oEia
1I$HTppa3"T -M..I996.C350o<
cnE:.!\. &o_CTaTbflkc60pHM"Y')!(I"'LWIOO-M
11:\11,....c-Il3Pl<..I996.C,32)EcIIMHesa6b1.aTb,'ITOTep..."H.t<ae....,O<aK..
"rofjot;I1HoiiTep"'MH.HOCMTy\:IIOBHbIJlSpal(Tep.TOc_eroTaKO.bI"''''O'''fIO
2C.... 11"nU.npaBO"'>I:W1UlBeCCCP-M. IOP"A.,"'T. 1983.C.42.CnpeBeIl"".
=='r:;':H=;
e",nLllHbIX"'3TanenepexQ!lB,"p"HO'<HbI'"
OTHOLIJeHH"B>I<I1nMLllHoj:;"4>epe"B"B''''''CrtJl'Hlfll'!MHblHell<P\tJnpo.
One.....l<op...>I:W1..L1IfIOrC"rpa;.;.o,afIC"cronpaElaHeC""...aO)TcoCnOBeCT.
kM./1HR
\21

,w<HCKO-I1paBOBOro xapaKTepa 11 OrpaHWIeffi'Ul CQJePbl ,IJ;eHCTI!I1H HopM 3,A-
MHID1CTpaTI1BHOro npaBa, KOTOpbIe 6YJlYT peryJrnpOBaTb JII1Wb He3Ha t li'l-
TeJIbH)'ID Ipyrrrry IX OTHollIeID1i1:. Hanpl1Mep. CBJl3aHH)110 C of:iec-
ne'ietll1eM )!{J/!JIbeM no ,IJ;OrOBopy CQqI18JJbHOrO HaHMa OT,IJ;eJIbHbIX
KaTeropl1H Ipam,!\aH I .
B COOTBeTCTBI1JI! C nepBOHa'iaJibHOH pe,w<KI..\l1eH CT. 9 3aKOHa PoccIDic:IIOl1:
(fJe,l:\epaQm1 «0 m::ootmnJ..tHOCOQJoH,[\a BPocmilrnrn (fJe,IJ;epa-
l{I1I1 nOPJI,!WK I1pe,IJ;OCTaBJJeHJ1JI:mJ1JIbiI ill yc.rrOBl1HX ,IJ;oroBopa COQlfaJIbHOCO
HaHMaCOXpaHfleTCfI,lVIfI, BeTepaHOSeciiHbl, I1HBaJm)J;OBTpy,w< 11
,IJ;eTCTBa. ceMeti norvIDlill1X npJ.ll1CllOJlHeHi'1J.l rocy,w<pcmeHHbIX OOH3aIfHOC-
Tei1l1ceMetiC,IJ;CIXOJ:\aMJIHJ.I:ireYCTaHoBJIellllOronpmIDlTo'IHo-
ro Mi'lHlfM)'Ma. B HaC'l"MllIee BpeM.II OCHOBaID1.ll J1 nop$l,!\OK npe.IIOC'I3BJX'
>KI1JJoro I1UIfer.q=HJffi no ,IJ;OroBOPY CtI.(ltaJIbHOCO HaHMa, paBHO KaK 11 IIpaBo-
BOi1pe:iKJ.lMcrI.(lla.JlbllcHai1Ma>Kl1Jloropery.IDlpyIDl'CHrJL 7118
,IJ;€f1CTB}'KJllf3'OJKmn.rlltHoro KO.L\eKCa ptf:l (.L\a.rree - .}I\I\Ptf:l).
BoospallJilHCb K J1OC'ffiBJIeHRJMY paHee CaMOC'I"MTeJlbHOMy- BOnpocy. MbI
see JoKe .L\OJDKHbI cupe.nt'JIJI"Ib CBOe UfHOllleHYIe K HeMy-. B 3TOti: CBH3J.1 CJJeJIY-
eT OTMeTlITh, 'lTO TPYAHO cnopJ.lTb C TaKJ.IMI1 KJlaCcmtaMl1 '-t1fI!11JIJfCTUKJf,
KaK CCArie1«:eeB, O.A.RpaC8B'ImOCJB 11 P.D. Xa.rrqnma, O,IJ;HaKO XOTeJIOCb
6bI OCTOpOJoKHO 3aMeTIlTb, 'lTO I1X tyiK,L\eHWI, COrJIaCHO KOTOpblM )f(J.IJIJI!ll\Hoe
IIpaBO - no.L\OTpaCJIb I1paBa Ipam,!\aHCKOro, BbICKa3aHHbleB
11  ro)J;bl IIpOllIJIoro CT01IE'TI1H, BJ.I,!I,IDI!O, 6b1JIJ.1 cnpa&'Affi1BI>I.
BMecre C 'reM cJIe.QyeT OTMeTl1Tb, 'ITO HI1KOMy- ellle HJ.I C 06ll1eTeope'lWlec-
KJ.IX, HJII C Ipam,I\aHCKo-npaBOBbIX no3l1qJ.li1 He Y,IJ;aJIOCb ,l\OKa3aTh, KaKOH Me-
xaHJ.l3M nepepaCTaID1.ll IIpaBOBbIX (rpa>!\,IJ.aHCKo-npaBOBb1X) I1HCTl1TyroS B
nO.L\OTpaCJIJ.I I1paBa 11 KaKOS ,l\OJDI\eH 6b1Tb Bec TOn -Iq»tTWit'CJ{()j.j MaCCbl 330-
KOHo,w<TeJlbCTBa. 'IT06bl no.rraraTb 3aBepllIeHHbIM )'Ka3aHHoe nepepaCTa-
IDle. C }"IeTOM 3TOro, a rJIaBHoe 11 C n03l1wrn  peaJlJ.ltl: MbI He
MOiKeM corJIacl1TbCJ! C TeM, 'I'I'O cospeMeHIDe )f(J.IJIJI!ll\Hoe npaBO .ImJI$leTC$I
nO.L\OTpac.rrb1O I1paBa IpaJfGlBHClIDI'O. Ec.rrJ.l BeCbMa YCJJOBHO I1CXO.l{l1Tb 113 KD-
JU1'JeCTBa HOpMaTIfBHbIX )fGIJII1lltHo-npaBOBbIX aKTOB, TO eCTb Bee QCHOBa-
IDIfl noJIaraTb, 'iT{) B 3TOM CMbICJle mwnnJ1ll)E' IIpaBO «nepepocJlo .mOOY1O
')I(KP<!>CTa><oeeecbOAElY3"1'lOoI5naCTbk"'IIJIL!lHbI"'cm<O.
WeH"M"HoroB..acn<ocrn"HoerfJlME!HSIeI01
nw'k_nL!IH"'Ma)cpe...oHTo...nepeyC1J)OiiCTl!o""nepE!Ilna-
..ItJ)OBK01'i"'WlblX6J<J60pyJJ,OBaH...,BJI1peJJ,O
CJaIIII!IH!Mycnyr;r)l!HeceH"""'llnaThl"aycnyr"Tn.
kT8I<oMn03MI.I)I(KP<!>MO>KHOBblCl<a3aTbCJIBAYlOlI.jI<ec:006pa><e""BO.
nepB",x."I<3"eCTBeBblwe"'WIL!lHblXOTHOLUeH..40l)I\JI1pylOT"lIJbT3I<I1e,K I
kOTOP"'MMOryTo..m.flP\'I"'B"e"blnwbHOp.."'rpa;t;llaHc.oroaBO-8TO.
::'-:TO,'lTOnepe"e"b_nlljHblXOIIUlJI!H4I"" t::

rIO;wrpaCJlb aHclwro npaBa 11 BeCbMa Cepbe3HO MOiKeT KOHK)'pI1pD-
BaTb C caMJIM Ipam,llaHCKJIM IIpaBOM 1 .
'I'peTbi! rpyrma yqeHbIX TpaKTYeT :!KIfJIJflI1Hoe npaBO KaK C3l'«X:TOHI'eJIh-
HY;O OTpaCJlb CIfCTeMbI npaBa. HaI160JIee peunrreJIbHO 3T01' B3rJL<!,!\ OTCTaJ.1-
BaJI nCHMKlfTIOK. DH ellle B 1977 r. BbICKa3aJI IIpe.1l!IOJImKeHI1e 0 TOM, '1TO
>KJ1JIJflqHOe npaBO MOiKeT C1'aTb catolOC'I'OH"I'E'JIbHOii crrpaCJIbID IIpaBa .mIWb
Torna,KOrna6YJJ;YTopra1IK'llil>IeHQpMa'I'IfI!IIbalm>I
TmIa OcHOB >!G'!.IDIlWioro 3aKOHCWlTeJlbCTBa COtooa CCP H COKJ3HbIX pec-
ny6.rrIfK 11 pecny6m1:KaHcJa :!KIfJIb]e KOAeKcll. C np!1l1.l!'meM OcHOB
ro 38KOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBa COtooa CCP H COlO3HbIX pecnyfuurn:, a TaK-
JoKe >!G'!JII1llIHblX KD,!\eKCOB COI03HbIX pecny6.rn1K :!KIfJIJflI1Hoe npaBO, KaK yr-
Bepm,11aeTnc.HMKlfTIOKJC'l<lHOBIITCf!OTpaCJThlOnpaBa3.
Ha HaW B3r.Jl.l1Jt BbIBO)\ 0 TOM, 'lTO >!G'!JIJ1llIHoe npaBO HBJIHeTCJI caMOCTOR-
T€JIbH()ijcrrpaCJIhIOIIpaBa,c,J:I,e.JJaHllbn.C.TOJJbKOJDIllIbHaOC-
HOBe HaJllf'lIffi CII€f..IIIa1IbIIbI3aKOHOB - OcHOB JoKIfJIJ.fllIHoro 38KOHO)laTeJlb-
C1'Ba COtooa CCP 11 COIOOHbIX pecny6.rn1K 11 HGI.ID1ll1IIbIX RQAeKroB COI03HblX
pecny6rom, e,!\Ba.ml MDmeT 6blTb np:13HaH  Bo-nepw:x, caN
rIa ce6e 4mKT npl1llJITIffi OcHOB TOro J1JI1f HHOro 38KOHO,!\aTeJIbCTBa ellle He
.HBJJHeTCH KpJllTepIfeMAllHBb(.1\eJIeHJl!HTOnJl!JllfHHOnOTpaCJlJ1npa.Ba.C).1l.\e-
CTBOBaJllf BCOlO3eCCP OcHOBbI3aKOH0,!\8TeJIbCTBa COI03a CCP HCOlQ3HbIX
pecny6.rn1K «0 Ha'laJIbHOM 06pa30BaHJl!JIl. a B PoccniX:Ioc:U cI>e,!\epawm I1Me-
KJTCJ::r, HarrpI1Mep, OcHOBbI TeJIbCTBa pq:. «0 HOTapIfaTe", HOHHKTO
He IIbITaJICH 11 He rn.rraeTCJI o6oCHOBaTb nDm!.lIeHJl!e coorneTCTB}'IOl1\IfX OT-
paCJlen npa.Ba rID 4mKTY HaJiWIJI!.FI )'K83aHHblX OcHOB.  OcHOBbI
)KIf.I!}IllIHOro 38KOHo,!\aTeJIbCm8 COtooa CCP 11 COlQ3HhIX pecny6ro.m 11 >!G'!-
JIJ1llIHble KO.1leKCbl C0103HbIX pecrry6JIIfK He C03,1\aIOT ,!\JIJI :!KJ1.JIJ.1llIHoro npa.Ba
e,D;lfHoro npe.II.MeTa npa.BOBOro perymtpOB8HI1.II " He Jl3MeH.lUOT xapaKTep
JoKIfJIJ1llIHbI I1]:BBOO'l1IIJl1EHI1 Bo-BTOPbIX, MHeHJl!e 0 BroMCOKOOCTI1 BbIJ\e-
JJeHlf.f! c:aJOOC1OHTeJIbllOK OTpaCJlJl! npaBa npJ.! HaJIWIJ.II1 OcHOB COBeTCKOro
11JII1HeCOOTBeTCTBYeTnOJIOmeHI1.IIM06ll1eti:
ITOJ1bKOsanOCIl9.!1><ef"Ql1b<o:po..e3a,o><8.Poc:a<"icKooiiOJ>e.!lepaL.l>OM.o_.
nMUlHoroBPocwOI<<3>eJ:1epauM..3a.o"aOJ>e.!IepalJ,l<M.06OCfl()aax
4>e/lE!panbHO"'''''UlHO;;nOJ1''''''.Muene.o;;f1JXJIl)aMMbI-:>KMnL!If!'
npaOOBOMYperynMpoBaHMIO"'''''MUlHbjxC/1lO.l.lE!OHlM'''MnbRnOCll"UJeI<p"-,\
Y.""oBr1pe"""""H1aP<t>..nocTaHOIIIIeHMArlpaB"",nbCTBaP\1)l1c"",we504>e/J.epanbHbI)[
I1I1MblXnpa80BblXa>:roBlc..._Y.""npe3l1,l1BH1aP\1).ol<o80...aTanepea_
nsaW<Mrown.BOI<nporpa"'MbI.)!(MnMwe.IlC06paH"'-
eaP<t>I996,Nl4.Cr.143110::06aHpoo"a-roi'iC<J>epeno<anbHOMYHOPMO'
TeOj)'fBCTOy,KOTOpoBBBCbMaoO-.e""oeTat<.,TOJ1bKOnpa".....nbCTSorMoc......pa3nM"Hbie
p,enapraMeHlbl MynpaBllBl<M r M""'"blllp""nM "nocn!',J1l<M"I'Q!\bIp,e""n HMaTBI<bI)[
al(Toe,perynMP\'IOLIII'XC/T>G1J9ttSlnO""'"ML1IfIO;;C<PePbjlc..._.H8np11.
"'ep'JKI1nlljI<""pe<flop...BrMOCO<8"'C60pH.I<OpMarn""bI)[l1O"Y"'.H1'OB_Bbln_12 -
M.,1994-2O(1).
2CM. H..."H()J<n.C,)f(""MLlIfIO'H1pa80CC-KMwM"eB, 1977 C.19-22
3C.... H"J<"rjOJ<n.C,JKI1nMLljfKlBIlpa80.-Kw...", 19S5.C 37-40
I

TeOpI1Yl npaBa, COrJIaCHO KOTOpblM O)UDl!M Jl!3 rnaBHbIX KpJl!repJl!eB, Jl!CnOJIb-
ayeMbIX AM J\eJIeIDIR npaBa Ha OTpaCJIJI!, JUlJIReTCR npe,!\MeT npaooooro pe-
ry.ID1pOBaHIfJII,TOecTbO.lUlOpo,!1)lblXOTHOllle-
HJl!j;j, I«J'IOpbI€ nO,!\BepralOH npaBOBOMy perynll!pOBaHJ11O AHaJlI13
l1CCJX'J!Y€MoH n}Xl6J1eMbI C .nallllbIX ID3I1l!IIfi He ,lIaeT HaM BeCRJ1X OCHCEraHIrii
AJlH YTBepiK,!:\eHI1H 0 HaJlWlJl!JI! caM1JC'l'OJ'ITe OTpaCJIJ{ npaBa - )f(J1JIJI!lI\-
HOro npaBa. KaK rpaiK,!:\aHCKOMY, TaK JI! mwIlfOMY npaBY 
OJ{l-'!H JI! TOT:me npe,!{MeT npaBOooro pery.ID1pOBaHIfJI, a Jl!MeHlIO - Jl!MYIIleCT-
BellllbleOTHoweHMH,nonooo)J;yct5'beKTOB,KOTOpblMnplf-
C TOBapHO-J\eHemHbIe coci"1CTBa B paccMa'I'J:Imae Har.rn acneKTe -
:ITO :!KI1JIbIe ,AOMa, KBapTl1pbl B .nOMax rocYMpcTBeHHoro 1>1 
)!G1JIJ1!U<Horo4>oH,D;al>1l1Hble)IDjJlblen.
IIoMlfMO npe)J;MeTa npaBOooro perymtpOBaHI1.II B 06lI\eH TeOpJlllf npaBa
6b1J1onpJl!3H3.HoHe06xo)J;J1MbIMBbJ,!\e.IDITb.AJlH3TI1xLleJIei1
KplTt'pIfi1 - MeTO,!\ npaBOooro peryJIJl!poBaHmf, npe.ncraBJUIlWtlfi co6olf
COBOKynHOCTbIXCBoi1CTB.CIloco6oBJ1npJ1eMOBel1cTmrn:CO
CTOpOHbI roCYA'ipCTBa Ha peryJJJtpyeMble  OTHOWeHJI!H. I1c-
CJle,!\OBaHJ1eCTPYIITypblJl!co.nepmaHIMIHOpMJ1m1IIDUJ..tHCI'O
npaBa nOKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO MeTO,!\ npaBOBoro pery.ID1pOBaHIfJI JI!MJI onpe,!\eJIeH-
HbIXomollleHJ,1:IfHeJ1Me€'T'pa3JII1'lIf!iTaK,
nOpH,l\OK YCTlU!OBJIeHl1.II npaB Jl!o6H3aHlDCTeii: }l'!aCTIillKOB <JIHOIIHIdIl, pe-
ry.ID1pyeMbIX H3.3BaHHbIMJ1 HapM3.MJI!, BbrreKaeT 1>13 gaKOHOB 1>1 ,iiPrCII:!OpOB.
B )f(J1JIJI!OM npaBe :ITO .nOroOOpbI KYTIJIH-IIpO,!m)!G1 :»GIJIbIX ncMellf2Illlii,
KOMMepqeCKOIUHaiiiMa,IJOJJ;HBiiMa, 06MeH3.JKI1JIb1XJI!T.n
B W1B11.11J1C'I'W1€ JII1TepaTJPe eHCRa3LIBaJIaCb TO'IKa 3peID1H 0 TOM,
q']'() OT.neJlbHbIe )f(J1JIJI!lQIIb!e OTIIOIlleHMH B03HJI!KIHOT He TOJlbKO 113 .nOroBD-
pcB, HO J1 1>13 'lJIeHC'i'Ba B JIEHbIX KoonepaTJ1Bax". EcJIJl!
BeCbMa YCJIOBHO cor.naCIITbCII C TaKOIf I103IIl{IfeR, Hf2(){j"{0JJ:IfMJ Bce :me OTMe-
I e.. .Ai1eKceeBC.C.06L118>1T90P"CI1O.IIW1..c......ecKOrOnpaoa.-CIIep,wlOBC', 1963.E!bln. 1.
C.216-21B;OH>«e.llpo6ne"blTeopI<I<npaoa KypcJlel<l\l< B2T.TI - 1972
e.135-136;Teo]Jl1HOCyJJ,8pc-rsal1npaoaJOT1I.pe.o......H.Kopones 11.C !'lam -11. IiIa.£l-BO
Jl6HMHrpa,!lCl<oroVHeepc'<TeTa 1987 C. 4OO;Aila<'ceeeCC. OI5U11'e.-eopeT'enpo.
t;"""'blUlCTeMbI""""TGKOmnpaoa.-M. roc"'P""A"T,1961.C 14;DHxe.rlpeJ:u.te-rroseT.
CKOrOrP8>1<A8>fC.oronpaoa.-CeePJl,>10BC..1g5QC252"cna.<i.
2Becb""'3Ha""..O,'lTol1e1OcT";ooUll')KKP"'l<eTQJlbKooope""'...,'lTOnp""HaeTCSI>KI<m"..
JJ.QMo..l1o:eapn.tpCiil<oTaK>Kenepe<t..c.n"nB..;J,bI'"""bI."yeraH08W1.."I<a3H8-
eH"e"npe.D,enblI-lCl10n_H""(C"CT.I5-17)
3e.. Me/;jepaB.ct>.O.QeJlet<""COIIe-rcKoronpaoaHaarpaCll"IJCoeeTCKOen>cyJJ,8PCUol1
npaw.1957 N!' 3 C. 96-97; AJleK(;sss C.C. flpeJI,MecOBeTCKoro ro4"aJ1"CT"ecKQrO
IJ}IDKAaHCKOronpaoa -CaePJl,>1oocK,1959.C.252
.c..K8c8rIMH8TB.Tpacnel<T!lnpaoal<a>KW1"U(eIJOcHOBblCQ"eT.
cKOro'""'LllHomnpa"a:Me>KBy3.di.HaY"TPY/IO".-I1:\11.....oYprY,1Q81.
e.64.)KKP<:>CPe.<u1QCHooaH..;;IIOOtH:HOI!EHOJ""'n"LllHblXnpaa..ot;38H- 1
1<000e<:oJ\ep>Kl1Ty><a"aHel<a""eHC1BOrpIDKJJ,8H"JIOtn"LIIH""'"n">KI<n"l1IHO-CTpo"TeJ1b- 0\
I<""' -

TIITb, 'ITO B caMOH OCHOBe 'lJIeHCTBa rpIDK.!!aH B JKI1JIJII11HOM J1JIJI! JKI1JI11IWiO-
crpolITeJIbHOM KOonepaT£1Be, no cytIlecmy, Tome JIemm- ,l\OroBOp B BI1,!\e &1-
flBJIeHl1HIpIDK./laHlfHa () npl1eMe B JKK J1JIJI! >KCK AJI.I1 nOJIY'leH!1R KOHKpeT-
HOro :IKI1JIoro  (yKa3uBaeTcH pa3Mep, BIW;" ap;pec) tf
npl1l1RTVro no pernemoo 06Jl.\ero rof.pa1nm 0 3a'lI1CJIeID1J1 rpam.1I3IDnIa B
'lJIeHbl KOOIIepaTl1Ba JII BbJ,!I;e.rreHIDI eM)' COarBeTCTB)'!OJl.\eH :1KI1JIOH IL1IOIl.\8.,!\11
EcJrl1 pacCMa'T'pHBaTb MeTO,!\ npaBOBOro peryJIlfp(lBaIDUI Ipam,D,aHCKOro JII
oronpaBaCII03J1ql1ti:CT€IIeHI1aBTOHOMIIOCTl1cy&beKIDBnpI1B03H11K-
HOBeHIDI m: npaB 1106R3aHHocrei1, TO CJIe;J;yeTOTMeTI1Tb: BOM 3aKO-
HOMT€JIbCTBenpaBal106st3aHHOC'T'l1cy61.eKTOBI1HOrM6o.rreed(
()npe,!\e.rreHb! B npaBOBb!X HOpMax no CpaBReHmO C rp<lJK,!\aRCKI1M npaBOM, r.!le
cy6'beKTbll1MeIOT6om,we""HJIIWla:rllBb!B1EID1JI
CQlIepmaIDIR I1X npae 11 06H3llilliOCTeK CoorBeTCmyroll\l1e BQ3MIDKHOC'TI1 co-
.!IepJKaTCRJIIBoMnpaBe(npl106MeHec,!\a'IeI1XBH3.eM.mrt50
nO,l\HaeM 1>1 Tn), HO Rpyr J1X}'me, '1eM B rpam,IlaHCKOM npaae.
HaKOHeIl, JU:JIere MeTO.!la npaBOBOro pery.ID1pOBaHIm rpam,!\aH-
CKoroJll:lKl1JIJIll(HoronpaBaIIOCIIOCo6yJllCpe.!\CTBaM3anpaB 1106R3aH-
ROCTen cyfuelIT'OB IIORa3bIBaeT, 'ITO B Ipa:lK,1\aHCROM JIl :m:JIJIJI!l1VIOM IIpaBe
()CHOBHb!M cnocOOOM u6ecne'!eHwI: JIlCIIOJIHeHIIH IX 06R3aHHOC-
TeA .RBJlIIeTCH UCJ«J3(jt, CYAe6Hbr}i nOp.RAOK, a Cpe;:J;CTBOM - Ipam,llaHCRo-
npaBOBbIe MepbI RE)\eikTBlm.
BecKJ1x 0CHC.I!aH:>Ii1.AJlH yrBepiK,!:\eHI1H 0 HaJIWJ:JII1 B  npaBe
caMOl"T'CIH1'e cymecTB€HH() arJlM'laIOLIII1XCH ar aHcKoro npaBa
IIpe,!\MeTa JII MeID)\a npaBOBOro pery.ID1pOBaHIffi He JllMeeTCH. Cocrri!eTcTBeH-
HO )'iRe Ha 3TOM DCHOBaHIIJl! :»GtJ!JIlltHoe npaBO He NOmeT 6bITb Bbr,iJ;eJ/eHO B
 arpaCJlb IIpaBa. MomHO, OqeIDWIO, JIJ1llIb roBOpl1Th 06
OTtiOCII1'eJIbHu6ocufiJIeHa:.cJKl1ronpaBaR3.KCBo-
e06pa3m,!McoJ\epmaHUeMl1u&beJm,r,aTaIOKe
HeKOIDpbIeJIJ1lllbeM)'npl1cyIW1eIIp!.
"1£eTBepraH rpynna yqeHbIX IIOJIaraeT, 'ITO :HOIJII1lIIHoe npaBO npeAcras-
JUleT co6oi1 'laCTb  IIpaBa. IIepBbIM B npaBOOCi1 H3.YKe 3TOT
B3rnm:l BbICKa3aJI J1.Jl EpaY.!Ie. TaK, ee B llEC'I1V\€CRTbre 1'O)J;b! npOIlLllOro
crOJIE'T1UI J1.JI.EpaYAe IDIcan «...TO, 'lTO Y Hac H3.3bIBaJO'l' )I(JI.IllflltHbIM npa-
BOM, ecTh 'laCTh aHcKoro npaBa 1. Ee3 yqeTa 3TOro MHem'!H, TO ecTb
KaK 6bI BIIepBbIe 0 TOM, 'ITO )KJ1JIl1lIIHoe npaBO npe,!\CTaBJIReT co6oi1 '1aCl'b
IIpaBa, co06!1\aeTH3.yqHoM)'MI1PYJIlll.B. PaM3aeB 2 .EbIJII1J111
21
1 Aex...:»rnC.U. 6payp,eU.fl.,IlepraMeHTA.u' }f("""L1jfIOOIlpaIIO. _M. 1956.C. 14.Cn"JIY'
eTo....enfTb.TOIi3rJ1""""I1.Il.Epayl\eHalOp.......,...ecKYK>l1j)I1pC1Ay>Kl1nMlIjHoronpaBil...e"".
''''Cb.OH.KiI.OTMe"anocbpaHoo..II!IIIMMlI''poBan''''''''L1jfIOOnpaIlOKiI.
"HC1lfTYT.
2C.... PaM38e8IlB.OMSCTe""""LJ.IHOronpasaBCMCTer.oecoeerrc.oronpasaI/UMe"">!CTM'
..ec.Menp06ne.....npa"OBorOCTarycBJ1M"H"""'''06lJ.1!!CTBe.-Capa.
T08:ItI3.!I'BOCapaTOeco<oroI9a2C.49

y Ha3SaHHbIX yqeHbIX OCHOSaHW! .AJlH nO.n;ODHbIX yrsep»QJ;eHYIi1 JII 'ITO .l\atoT
Ha)'Ke TaKJIe? IIpem,Ile Bcero CJIe;zIyeT orMeTWl'b, '1TO 3'1'0 He
peayJIbTaTKaKI1X-.mt50 HaJ'IHbIX rl1, a JllMeHHO yrsepiK,!:\eHI1H HID!
3aHBJleHMH, troTOpble, SbipaJoKaHCb COBpeMeHHbIM .H3b1KOM, Hocm He HaY'l-
HbIi1, a, CKopee Bcero, norry.mrrcrofii: xapaKTep. 11M He npW:Yllf KaIDIe-JIII-
60 KOH[[ernyaJIbHble OCHOBb!, mill HWiero He ,l\a1OT C TO'fKJI! 3peHIDIYHCHemlH
 npJ.lpo;rJ;bl :»GIJIl1J1Uforo npasa JI! ero Cyt[[HOCTJ1. 11, HaKOHell,
'1acTbID rpam,llaHcKOro npaaa HBJIIll(JJ'CH RaK JIKfiaH nO.l101paCJIb, CKameM,
,II;CI'(.II(.{J JllJlJ.I 06H3aTeJIbCTB€HHttO npaaa, TaK 11 TOi1 JIIJII1 Jl!Hoi1 Jl!HCTJlTJ'T
ero JII ,l\aiKe QT.l\eJlbHO B3SITaH rpaiK,!\aHCKO-npaBoaaH HOpMa, BXOwnu,aH B
cocras TOro I1JIJf illIOro JiIHCTlf'TYIR y 0 TOM, 'ITO :HG1JII1lW1oe
npaBOHBJU!eTCH'IaCTbIDrpnpaBa,npaBJ1JIbHOel1,Aa.}1\e<J'leBI1tl-
HOe caMO no ce6e, He npo.n;BlfraeT 'lI1TaTeJUI BIJepe.l\ HI1 B BOrrpoce Q IOPIWf-
'1ecKOi1 npllpo,!\e 3TOro 4>eHoMeHa, HM 0 ero C)'Il\HOCTI1
11 HaKOHe[[, ll.RTaJI rpyrma yqeHbIXC'IIf'I"aeT, '1TOnpaBO - KOM-
llJIeKCHaH mpaCJlb npaaa. aro MHelD1e fu.LJlO BbICKa3aHO e B II.IIT11J\eCR'l'ble
ro.l\bl npOIlLllOroCTOJieTIfH. Tal<, BK Paiixep, r.ny60KO 060cHoaaBllll1>1 CTpaxo-
roe npaBO B Ra'lecree KCNJIJIERCHJii orpacJll1 npaea, RaK 6b! nonyrno yr-
eepiK,!:\aJI, 'ITOJI!JKIfJIJfll(HoenpaBO.HBJIJIeTC.fIorpaCJIbKlnpaaal.
RoMIIJIeKCHbIempaCJll.fnpaBa,KaKno.naraJlI1XBKPafi-
xep. 6yAY'lI1 pa:3HOpQlI;HUMJ no CBOeM)' HOpMaTIfBHOM)' COJleJ»KaIrnlO, I1Me-
lOT If,3B€C')H')f' npe.n;MeTHoe e,l\J'lHCTBQ cTaKaH OOJl3.CTb npasa, - yKa3b1BaeT
BK. Panxep, - C O.l\HOJ:'i CTOpoHbl, COC'I'l'MT I.f3 a:II€fIoIelITOO, orHOCfl It
pa3JlWlHb1M npe,!I;MeTaM npaBOBOro peryIDIpoBalD1fl, K pa3JlWlHb1M orpac-
JIflM npaaa (npasy, a,tI;I>n1ID'1CTpaTJ1B1loM)' npasy JI! T.,I\.), JI! B
3TOM CMbICJIe I1MeE'T  KOMI1JIeKCHblfi xapaKTep. Ho, C .v;pyroi1
C'I'OpOHbI, TaKaH OOJl3.CTb npaaa oOJl3.)J;aeT e,l\J'lHCTBOM)')Ke B J\PYI'OM aclleK-
Te B3$lTOro, no ,I1pyrOM)' npJ.l3HaK)' O'lep'lemrcro IIpe,!\MeTa npaBoooro pery-
JDIpCJBaHIDI M B 3TOM CMblCJle HBMeITH BHYTPeHHe e)\0i1, HecMO"IpH Ha
BCID CBOKI KOMI'IJleKCHOCTb CTpyKTYPbl, OTpaCJIblO npasa" .
JfJIeHUI KOMI'IJleKCHbIX<rrpac.1Iennpaaa C TeMH MIDI trnbl-
MHMO.l\IMHOmerO.l\blnOJll\ep>KJ.IBaJlaCbB1qJHa)'K€
pR.!\OMeeBH,!\Hb!X8.
IC....:PaJ1xepB.K.TI<nblClJl3X083HMR._M,1947.C,188
2Pal'i.<epBK YI(83.CO" C 190
3C..... HaflPI'IMep, MewepaB,4>. O_,,C<JBeJOI:Cf{)npaBaH8.cnpaCJ1flCOI*nCKOero-
cy.o,apcrsol1np3so.1957 C.96;MKOJIeH/{ofl.4>,OcCTeME!I1Id)'U18CTaeHH""'
Ilxnpa"oeoMperyn"po"a""IICo""H](oerocy.o,apcTeolnpaBo 1960.N03.C.86-89;
TOJICrOOlO,/(,OTeOpern"eC"'1XocHO"""I<OJI'ICI>I1""'-111"Ipa)I(JI,aHCKOro1I
rlpaBOBe,lle"II!! 1957N'1 C45,o._KQIIlo$I1<S(jW1Ipa)1(J1,aHCKOro3Sl<OH'WITenbCT8il
CCCP(1961-1965rr.):ABTope<l'-AMC. J1-palOP'l'l-l<a;o<,-Il.1970.C.lo-11;AneKreea
C.C. CrpyKJ)lpacoee-rcKoro npaea. - M IOP'III,filfT.. 1975. C. 184-206' 0.""8 O1paCJ1CO- .1
BeTC"oroflpaoa.npo!jJle"'bI,I1CXOJ1"bleIICo""TcKOeroCYI\BPCT"OI1np3SO
1979.NI3.C 21-23,fJrJJIeHJ<fiaC,B, Teopen,',,,,,,,,,enpo6neMblcoBBTckOro3alDlQll1Jll!Jb _
CT83.-M..1919C.32-33. 

Be3 KaKOI'f-.mt60 P;OITOJIHY!'feJIhHcM apryMeHl'aWlI1 Jj p;OKa3aTeJJbCTB no
cyIl.teCTBY BcfJocHooamm. HaJIJ'!'JJ.1.R KOMII..JJeKCHOi OT'paCJIH )KJIJIJ'!l.Wloro npa-
Ba C.M RopHeeB I'ICKOl\IIn Jj3 TOro, 'ITO 6bLJIO ObI «HIDfuJee npaBI1JIbHO C'II1-
TaTb, 'ITOoenpaBOHBJl/feTCH KOMI1JIeKCHOifO'lpacJ1blOnpasa, KCrI'O-
paH6a3upyeTcH HaOTpaCJIH3aKOHO;'\aTeJIbCrna -.mwIJ1lqHOM
300JH),I:\aTeJIbCTBe1. 3,1\eCb C.MRopHeeB co.mv<a C B.nrpJj-
6aHOBUM, KOTOpbI!t, aIIa.1m3Itp}'H CTPYKTYPY OcHOB )KJIJIJ1UUIOI'O 3aKOHO):\a-
TeJIbCTBa ColO3a CCP Jj COlO3HbIX pecrry6JillK, npJ'!llIeJI R BbffiOJIY: :m:J1JIJ1III-
Hoe 3aKOHO,1\aTeJIbCTBO - KOMllJleKcHoe 3aKOHO):\aTeJIbCTBO::1.
HeJTh3HOCTaBJ1'J'bHe3aMf2"il2HHlJjT{'pe3YJThTaTblHaJ'ffibIXt-
HHiii B Ul'HOllIeHl1lf KOMI1JIeKCHb!X mpac.rrei1 3aKOHQJJ:aTeJIbCTBa Jj npaBa, CO-
rnacHoKoropblM KOHl\HaJ!WD1H KOMJIJJeKCHbI:xmpac.rrei1 npaBaJj3aKO-
HO.1\3.TeJThCTBa He pa3,1\eJl.fIeTCH BOO6me TaK, o.A KpacaB'II1KOB elIle BHa'ffiJIe
cel&1.1\ecHTb!X I'O,1\OB npollIJloro CTOJ1eTKH rrnc:a.rr: «.. OTpaCJlJl
npaBaCYTbHeOtpaCJIIlnpaBa, a npoK3BOJlbHO. t1CXOt13T{'XI.fJlHJWymxCO-
of:pameHIDl, cyfu.ctmmHo cl}JopMHpOBaHHbIe l'pymIld HDpM npaBa, nplffia.1l-
Jle»\aLWIe OT,I\eJ1bHbIM <npaCJIHM CJl!CTeMbI npaBa B l\eJJOM .mroo KOHKpeTHblM
illICTJ11'YTaM,llaHHoH I«JHKpe'I'HOi1 OTpacJII1 npaBa B 'laCTOOCTUI'3. 3m MHeID1e
eJIHJJOCbJjC.C. A.rieKreeBHM. KOTOPb1i1, JjCIlOJIb3YH np!1Be,!\eHH)'IOWITa-
ry, Kaymepm,I\aJl: «llin<aI\MXKOMIIJIeKCHb!XmpaCJIei1BOO1.eK-
TIfBHOCJI!CTeMenpaBaHeTt16bITbHeMmKeTI'4.
EJ:\BaJrnCyiK.!leHt1HMOJKHonpI13HaTb,BO
BCHKOM CJIy'!ae, B OTHOllIemrn BCex KOMnJIeKCHbIX mpac.rrei1 npaBa. CKOpee
BCero, Ha3BaHHbIe aBropbI t1MeJlJl B BMJIY TaK)lKl «KOMllJleKCH)'IO mpaCJlb,
KaRxuamicTBemroenpaso, mctro.I1bI\)'npe.1J:C'I'3IIInpa-
Ba CeTOBaJlJl Ha TO, 'ITO OHO He I«W*1pOB1lID, a 3'l'OTOpM0311THe TOJIbKO
npaBOBoe pery.lIl1pOB3.ID1e XOOHitCTBE'tIHW: 0TH01lIeHHi1, HO Jj HayqHbI€ HC-
CJIe,1\OB3.ID1fl. B TO BpeMH Ha ypoBlre OcHOB )Kl1Jmll\Horo 3aKQHO.1\3.TeJThCTBa
'/(QpIIOOiIC,M.OcffOaHbjeTef¥WHIJ,01HpaaaH"'">KHI1Hll\HOronpaBaBpO",,""CTaHOBIIeHH"
ptoIffO'IHOO3KOHOMH.Hl/rpa>t<,D,a>lC<oenpaaoFoccHHnpHnepe"o.Cle.pbjHr;y:COoPHHKltay.,.
It....crarenpenO,llaearellei\<abjrpa>0:,!J,8HCI<OI"Onpeeeoop>\!J,loN9C.oro4>8"\1breTa
';5na""""rljJIXj>.B.n.rjJH6aItOBa/OTB.IJI!JI,E.A.C%aHOB.-M...AE-IOPE
2C.... rpu6aHllBB.n.OcI<OBbjCOBeroKoro"'I\IIHll\Horo -M. 3HaHHe
19B3.C13.MHeHHeOTO".'<TO"'HnHUlHoefl8JIAeTC"ebl.
CI<83bI8aIIOCb" paHee(C/d. HanPH"ep'6apyMU. nywKoIHA.A.. Cof6Hne8MH nOH"T"e..
!OPHJIH"6CKa>lIl.PHpo,o,anpaeat<a"",nHll!6/1Oc1<OIIblCOB6TCKOrO"'I\IIHUlHoroaaKO>tQlIa-
T61lbCToa.Me"'.y3,c!'i.HaY"-.pyj1OB.-IiI:>D.-BoYprY.19B1C.59).
3I(pacaB>mrosO.A,Co""TOKaRHaY"apa>t<,D,aIlCKOrOnpaBallY4eHble-.pyAb'
HIICT"'rYTa.TYlCeP"".rp&)O:,llaHc.oanpaeo.-CeePA"OBC.,I96IC.263
4A11eKceeBCC.06uIaRTf!OPHRnpaB3.-CB€PIIIlOeCK,1963B""1.
C.232 n03>l<e,u'3ToetorreKae-r"3paHeet<a3B3HH"",,,a"'Hpa!j(nC.C.AI1eKCeeea.oHOTO.
1IJ61lOT"TO"""HIJ,01H"pa:lJl,enl\Il"'HeHHeTexY'eH"""KOTopbjeOTCT""eaJ1"CYL1WCT"",,"
HHeBCHCT"",eCOIII!TCI<OI"OnpaBal<1JMlllD'Dti><<np3CJle!;'npaBa.
I

Cm03a CCP" COI03HbIX pecrryfurnK" JKII!JIJ1IWIbIX e&nI COI03HbIX pec-
rW>JllfKHe6bLJIOJI)!OC1llflltHOe3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbCTOO
XapaK1'epHO, 'ITO o.AKpaCaB'II1KOB, TBep,!\O  0.1\-
 BbICKa3aHHOro MH€HJ1H, JI Cnyc:TH 12 JIeT rIOJI3.raJl, 'ITO <COO6pmKe-
IDIHom «I«NIJJIeR'CHbImpac.neii:. npaBa(paBHORaKJl3aKo-
HO.l\1lTeJlbCTBa) OCHOBaHbI Ha He.l\Opa3yMeIDII1 JlJlI1 HeKoppeKTHOM
'I'EpMJIHOJIIDf:ftoBe.l\eTRnyraIDIltelDlUlTlfl.i,YCJIroKHe-
IDIIO JI rea wro CJIO:lKIIbIX npo5.rreM. B KOHe<rHOM:me c<reTe .l\3.HHaH K0lll.\en-
l{I1If npalITWleCRl1cH!1MaeT Hay<rHoe ItCCJJeJJ;OB3HJ CI1CTeMbI npaBa JI CI1CTe-
Mhl 3aKOHO)1aTeJThcma». .na.rree o.A KpaCaB'II1KOB C 6oJn,Im1M capKa3MOM
yreeP)K,/\aJI, 'ITO <OfEapyifG'lB, HanpI1Mep, B3aJIMQIleflCTBlfe HOpM rpmK.l\8H-
CKOro JI  npaBa, He CJIe)J;yeT .!\)'MaTh, 'CI'O COBepwt'HO 'O'IRpbI-
TIle» OOHKOBCKOro npaBa»' JI'1'-.I\. To.me caMoe CJI!'J!,YeT CKa3aTh" 0 X03ID1-
CTBeHHOM npaBe, paBHo KaK II! o.IIJ.IYrnX <IIOMIWet\CHbDD mpaCJIHX npaBa II!
3aKOHO,!\a'I'eJIbCTBa (mJ1JIJl!IItHOM, 'I'pCIlICII)p'I, Jl!306pe'I'aTeJIbCKOM II! 1q).).
3To He mpacIDI npaBa JI «He mpaCJIlf 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbCma, a BJIY'illIeM c.rry-
<rae c):I HopM3.TIfBHbIe MaCCI1BbI, or.l\eJThHbIM <racTRM KOTo-
pbIXnpl1CYJlti'I pa3JIM'lHbIe Me'I'O)J;b1 npaB(JB(Ji1 perJIaMelITaltl1l1»2.
JibJIroKeHHbrn: B3r.IDJJ\ o.A KpacaB'illKOBa npl1 BCeM ero CEOe06pa3Im He
HaweJlnO.D.Z\epiKKI1cpe.!lI1,6oJIeewro,oH
OCTaJICH KaK 6b! He3aMe<r€H. Hepa:meJlHeTCH:ITOT B3rJIH,/\ JI HaMYI.l1:J-
M3.eTCH, 'ITO OipJIIJP.tule  KOMIlJI€KCHbIX OTpaCJiei1 3aKOHQ.I!a-
TeJIbC'IBa"IIpaBa,KOTOpoeo.ACOBOKYTI-
HJCTbIOIEaJIbHhIX4Jpa3HeramBHOroCBOiicTBa TI1IIa. 1)coo6pa.meIDIH
eiiorpaCJIei1npaBaJl3aKOHO.l\aTeJlbCTBaOCHo-
BaHbI Ha He)\opa3YMeHI1I1 JIJIIII IEKqJpeKTHOM IfCIDJIb3(GlliHI repM>1HOlIO-
IWI; 2) :ITO B€;:\eT K nyJaHIIqE' nOHHTI1i1, yCJiOiKHetullO" re3 wro CJiroKHbIX
f1IXJ6JieM "'1'-.1\., He MomeT 6bITb npl13HaHO y\5eJ:r.I.rreJI ITpeJ\CTaBJIHeTCH
OQeBI1.I\IIbIM. 'ITO cnop If,/\eT He 0 'I'epMlffiOJlOIWI, KO"I'OpaH BCer,Ila HOCIIT YC-
.IIJBIIbIiJ: xapaRTep.
HapH.IIY c  HeraTI1BOM B KpJI'IWIf2CI{ID paUIX
o.A KpacaB'illKOBal1MeeTCHII!TIOOII'I1IBHbIiCMbICJi. C)'TberocOCTOIITBWM,
QTO nOHHTl1e «00MII.J1eKCHHl' mpaCJllf 3aKOHO.l\aTeJIhC'l'Ba JI npaea» npe,IIJIaI"a-
eTCH3aMeIDITb.l\PyrnMnOHJITllleM..HopMaTl1BHbI!'MaCCI1J3H.
'1(psca8'l<fl(080.A CCTef,lanpeBa CCTeMaS8l<OHQll,arebCrea(rpa>I',!I,aICI(
ace.,-)1I1975W2.C.65.
2I(pscaS<lIlK080.,o"TaM><e.
a Bo C"KOM CJJY'I'I", aBTop», B YIM 1111 I1HO ...epe kacalOll\I1ec>1 IOPH,l\l1"ecKO P<\l\bI
CTP'f>'T)Ip"oI"'III1UjHoronpaealll1J:Ia'«e"eynoM"aIOTB3rI\D.O_A_Kpa-
C<IB'IKOBa ""T npo6ne"'» (CM HE!I'1JW.oep- K0pHee8 C.M. OcflO"HbleTeHJ\6Hl\I< paaal1
T">KI1L1IHoronpaB3ByClIO.""ptoIfIO'IfIO_l/r»a>i<AaHCI<oenpa- 1
BOPoccnpnepexo.c.ep»HKY' COopH."aY"HblXCTaTeK8<PeI1P» 1"""\
npaBa<J>aYbTBTaMrY,nOCB"lljeHH»na"'Hmnpo<l>. -.i
Bnrposa/0r8_D9AE.A.Cy.<aHOB_-MJJ.E.1OPE.1995J 

{JT.l\eJlbHbIM 'iacTHM KOTOpbIX npJI! pa3JlWlHble MeTO)J;b1 npaBOBOi1 per-
JlaMemaltJllJl!. MomHO J]JI!, I TepMKHOJKI1fiO If cBoe06pa3lfe C'I'IfJLII
G.A RpacaB'iI1KOBa, yrnepm,/\aTh, 'ITO BBe.l\eID1eM B HayqHbIiii o60par nOHH-
TJI!H  HopMaTl1BHble N3.CCIfBbl coaepweHO «OTKpbrrne»
HOBOro npaBOBOro HBJIemm'llIoJiaraeM, '1TO HeT, TaK KaK He paCKpbma€'TCSI
J.1X cym;HOC'l'b, co..n;ep:?KaID1e JI! MeCTO B CIfCTeMe npaBa, 'ITO Be.l\e'!' He TOJIbKO K
nyraHJI!I.Ie nOllJITm1:, 80 If K HeRCIDCTJf HCC1IeJIY€'MbIX npo6.neM Tat!HOt! aB-
TOpcKOro 6b1TI1f1 OCTaJJaCb RaKail-TO He)\OCKa3aIDJOCTb J'I IEJaBePIIIfllliOCTb
«HopMaTl1BHbIXN3.CCJI!BOB.
J1cCJle,11yllCTPYKTYPY J'l3JJeMeHThI B npaBe C  [J()3IfQIdI:,
l1,.A RepIfMOB nOJIaraeT, 'iTO HeT OCHOBaHJl!t! .wrn paCllpOCTpaHeHHoro B
COBKon lOpH,lI;WJearoj.j J]JI!TepaTJPe yreep*AeHlff! 0 HaJllf'JJI!JI! B Halllet!
CIfCTeMe npaBa TaR Ha3bmaeMbiX KlJMlI.lleI«'HbIX mpacJlet! npaBa»'. R Ta-
KOMYBbIBO,11y aBTopnpJl!llleJi 6e3KaKI1X-.mroo .l\OKa3aTeJibCTB no cy:IT\ecr-
BY. COCJJaBIlI\IICb Ha MHeHlffl H.r A.JieKcaH.nposa2 J'I J.1 B. IIaBJlOBa a . CltJIa-
.Abmafl BITe<laTJlelD1e, 'iTO "l'aKOro JXI.1\3. yme J1MeeT QeJlb
BblCKa3aTb 3apaHee HaMe<leHHO€' paueHllE'. ABTOp He Y-WITblBa€T Hif pe-
aJlbHOl13MeHlfBllIlfXCHOT1lOIlIemnl,lD1C"1)JeMJ1eHWI3aKO-
HO.1la"l'eJiH yperyJlJl!pOBa"l'b 3TIf HOBbIe OTHOllJeHIfH, Hif IIOHBIIBllIJI!'«:JI KOH-
KpeTHbIX npaBOBblX aKTOB B qeJlllx lWMl1JIeKCHoro perYJlJI!pOBaHlf.ll
YKa3aHHblX OUJOrneHlflI. A Mem.z\Y TeM O'leBI1J\HO, '1TO tl3JlOHreHIDe MHe-
Hfle.l{,A. RepIfMOBBbICKa3aJ1 B 1972 r., OClIOBbIB3.HCbHa Bb!BO,!!aX, c;J;eJlaH-
HblX yqeHblM/.f B UJ58 r. 3a 3TOT 'ieTblpHa,IU..\aTJl!Jle'l'HJ'Ii nep£10A KaK pa3 If
IIJXIIf30IIlJlJl!Cy:IT\eCTBeIDJbleJ'l3MeHeHIffiIfBc4repeMHOfID!:
0'l'H0IlleIlIDt, ,l\a JI! B 3aKOHO,!!a'feJIbHOM peryJlJl!pOBaH111'1 fiX 3T1f 06cTo.ll-
"l'eJlbCTBa,llalOT .l\OCTaW'IHO OCHOBaIDm: WlR TOro, '1TOObl yroMHIfU>CH B Ka-
-relOfM'IHOCTU cY*.l\eHJl!n, BI:lCKa3aHHbIX B 1958 r. UI1IOCIf'reJIbH KOM-
llJIeKCHbIX mpacneti npaBa JI! B 1972 f. - OTHOCJl!TeJIbHO If X IK'IIUMalIHJ'! JI!
OCTJI!.
PaCCMaTPJI!BaJlJ'lKBaJIi'IH)fCIfJiIflQHOenpaBOJ'l3aKOHo,!!a"l'eJIbCTBo
c II03I'IQI'IIl cero.mUIllIHero.AIDI, cne)ly€TyqHTbIBB.Th KaK tIDfBlllI1I2CH06-
HHHeO'l'H:JllleHl1H,TaKJ'lpR,!\HOpMaTI1BHblXaK-
"l'OB, II01IBIlBllIJI! B 0603peBaeMOM , npoaHaJU13J1!JXlBaTb J'lX co-
crae, CO.1lep:?KaID1e J'I rno;1cma :Ec.rrJI! me pacCMO'IpeTb cocrae, COCTb If
CBOnCTBa XOTR 6bI TOt! 'iacTJI! )fOfJIlflQHoro 3aKOHO.l\aTeJibCTBa, KOTOpaR KO-
J'IBWHopMmmbIX
gjl
1 Kepw.<Oa,ll.A otII1MOOtt>c.e n.ooneM" npaaa - M.. MbICJ1b, 1972. C, 299
2CM, AneKca/flJJJDBH.rOMecrelJ>YJ\oaOmMt:III1Jfi!HOr()l1jJa"aBC"CTeMeaHm:l<lJrtJa:J
npaaaIfCo""TCKOI!mcYJl3pcTBoMnpaBO.1958W6.C.117-118.
3CM..nalll!{)l!J1.B.OClOCTeMeCOBeTC.orOCOlJ}l9Jl"C'fI<'IOC.oronpaaaI/CoeeT<;.oerocyllElP
CT8OMnpaBO.195BWI1 C.I1.

8K'l'8X, K8R O::HOBbI JoKI1JIJ1lWioro 3aROHOTeJ!bCTI!a CoI03a CCP" COIOOHblX
pecnyDJll1K', 3aKOHbI 4>e,!\epaL\l.flf: «0 npJ.lBaTI13aQIrn )KIfJII1II1-
HOfO 4xJH,/\a B I'occJ.Ii.Ictro 4>eJ:\epaqm:p.2, «06 OCHOBaX 4>e.1lep8JIbHOi.J::Ha1-
.ID1IIIHoi.J: 1iOJMI11KIp3 Jj .l\p., TO MOmHO )lBlf,1\eTb, 'ITO Ha3BaHHbI€ 8RTbl co.1lep-
)KaT HOpMhl npaBOBOro, a.,!\MJ.1HIfCTpaTIlBHo-npaBOBOro,
!f>l1HaHCOBO-npaBOBOro 11 IpaJK,!\aHCKO-npaBOBOro CO.1lepJ'KaHJI/H. TaR, IpyIllIa
HOpM J<OHC'l1fT)'1tI npaBa co,!\epmaJlacb B pR.l\e CTaTeti O::H08 .mIf-
.ID1IIIH0ro 38RoHO)\aTeJIbCma Cmma CCP 11 COlO3HbIX pecny6mm, 38RperIJII1-
!OlI:IIfX KCIIC1'J.1'IyWKfiHOe npaBO IpaJK,!\3.H Ha JKlfJIlfllle (CT. 1) 11 KOMlleTeH-
l\1f1O COlO3a CCP Jj COIOOHbI"< pemy6.nHK B 06JIacTJ.I peryJIHpoBaInm
)KIfJII1!.l.\Hb1X OTHOllleHJI/i.J: (CT 8-9).
PJUlHOpMOcHOS)KJjJIl1ll\Horo3aKOHOAaTeJIbCTBanpKmpaC-
JIJ1 a.,!\MJ.1HIfCTpaTl1BHoro npasa. 3,!\ecb .l\ClJDKHbI 6bITb Ha3BaHbI HOpMhl pa3-
AeJIaII «YnpaBJIeHJI!e:HGf.l!lfII:lHbIM.,a TaKJKeIJaCTbHOpMpa3AeJIa III
«IpaJK,!\3.H)KJjJIbIMJI! nOMe1.1.1eIDfJ!Mlf» (CT. 18-21, 24,25, :i:i,
44,46).
:MHo1'O pa3HoorpaCJIeSbIX HopM JlMeJIOCb B 3aRoHe Poc:cI1itCKCii llJe.l\epa-
QI1If «06 QCHQBaX Q:>e.1leJ.WIbOOlf )IDL1UnqROO nomrrnKIt.». TaR, B CT. 1 3T01'O
HOpM8TI1BHoroaKT8 6bLJIa 3aRpe!IJIeHa npaBOBaH HOpM80
npaeerpam.I\aHHa)l(Jl.JJtfiIje CTaTbH:iCO.1lepmwr
KOMI1JIeKC pa3HoarpaCJIeBbIX ofuJaaHHocrett opraHOB rocyMpcTB€IIlDtt BJIa-
C'rn 11 ynpaBJIeHlf.fl. opraHoB MeCTHOro caMoynpaBJIeHJI!.f! no 06e<:ne'leHJl!lO
npaaa IpaJK,!\3.H Ha mIf.Ill1IIIe. PM a..11MJ.IHJ.lCTpa'l'HBlD-OpaBOBH HOpM co-
.l\epJKl1TCH B CT. 5, 11, 13; 4mtaHCreO-npaBOBbIX HopM - B CT. 26, 27, 28;
rpa»<,!\aHCI\O-f1I:WIOBNX HOpM - B CT. 14-21, 't. 2 CT. 24 xapaKTepJ.f3}'€Mo1'O
3aROH8 Co,!\epmMT OH 11 HOpMY 3eMelIbHO-npaeoBo1'O xapaKTepa (CT. 22).
AHa.rioIWIHble HOpMbI pa3HbIX O'rpac.rrei.J: npaBa CO.l\epJKaTCH 11 B Aei.J:CTBY-
IOIJ..!eM>KK f'4I. K HaJ1fu.rree IIplW IIHpa)f(eHHHM CJIeJJ;YeT OTHeC'r11 HOpMbI'
1) IOCJIIC'I1II'Ty npaBa, YCTaP01!"tll!lIIJft' KOMlleTelfl\Jl!IO pa3JIWIHbIX
opraHoB 1'Ocy.l\3.pcTBeHHC.ii BJlacTJI! PoccMitCKOii llJe.l\epalUlI1: a) MeCTHo1'O
caMoynpaeJIeHJ1H; 6) 1'Ocy,[\apCTBeHHOif BJI8cru cy61,eRwB Pocan"icl«n1
llJe.l\epa!.\l1JIl; s) opraHoB MeCTIIoro caMoynp8BJ1eHlf.fl B 06JIacrn )KIfJlJI!IWIblX
13roTaKTOTMeHeH....e.!J.e>iCTayeTClIdB.PTa2005r HaCTpy>:Type"HopMal<Ha3aaHHbIOc.
"Osl5a.3Hposa.nOCb"'Ho><ecTaO.QO'y""e"'08CQaeTCI<oro"><blHeWfl8.
ronepHcmapocCl<CKOiiMKOHHcroj'MH.MbI",e,*,,,,o;«eMHellC:lJOla.3llBl
Y<a38HHbIE!OcHO....E!UieH nOTo"'Y. TO MHomev<eHbIE!onpe.o.&mU1H IOpH.IIH,eC"YtOnpHpo.D.y
H",ecro"'HI1Hl1\HoronpaaaBCHCTe""'COIE!JCI(I]r<JnpaaaBc""",,caHaJlH30MC)'W.HOCTH,
CTP'fI"TYPbI..caocraY<a38HHblXOC><08Htia3l1PY1O"""'CS1><aHIt)II1HblXOCH080r>oJ1aralOUi.HX
><W1I1U1HQ.npaeo.....e...a><
2c... E!8AQMOCTHE!ep.Oat1croCose-raPCotICp. 1983.N!26.CT 1J1J3. I
3c... E!8AQMOCTHCbe:¥\aHapQAHblXJI8nyraro8PoocioI'""<,,,,pal\HHHCo- t.n
III!raPC<%>CF!I991N1128.CrQ59. N

UI'HUIIaIIIii (CT 12-14); 1') 8JJ;WIIDIC1paTl1BHOro npaBa 00 ynpaBJIeHIDfMHD-
1'0KBap1'MpHbIMJ.:! ,l\OMaWf (CT. 161-165).
Ie :HOIJIJ1IqHO-npaBoBbIe SKTbI Hoem KOMIIJIeKCHbm
xapalITep. RoMITJleKCHOCTb AOfmnL\H1I'O 3aKOHO..!I,a:reJlbCTBa B TOM Jj COCTO-
t1T,'ffOOHOCOJ\ep:001Tofu,e,l\l1HeHHbIeeJ\I'!HCTBOMpa3HD-
O"rpaCJIeSbIe HOpMbI, Kal'OpbIe IIpl13BaHbl pery.ID1pOBaTh JKI1.IIJIIWfbIe OTHo-
WeHI1fI. B mrrepaType CIIpaBe.IIJIIfO OTM€"Ia.IIOC1>, 'lTO nO!UM'Jje «:»GfJTh!l1tHble
OTHOllleHl1fI HBJlReTCH c06l1paTeJIbHbIM 1 . OHO BKJIlOtffieT RaK Te IpaH-
CKO-npaBOBble  OTHOllleHI1fI: no llOJIb30BaffiOO JKJ1JIblMJ:!
,KOTOphIMnp£1CC'I'OIfMOCT1laS<jxJPMa, TaK£1OTHoweHliISI
no npx:f:peTetDno 3eMeJIbHbIX Y'JaCTKOB WUI >K£1.IDIl1tH0ro C'!JJa1TeJIN.'TBa,
npe.DPCT3.8JItc'IIWO :!roi!JlblX nOMel.l..\eHlia no ,l!OroSOpaM  JI! KOM-
Mep<lecKOro Hai1Ma I'pHaM, HymJlalOlL\I1MCSI B HI1X; Q::JrnaHcIfJXIBlliII'IIO
C'IpOJl!TeJIbCTBa JI! 3KCILJIY<ITa[(IiIiJKJ1JIbIX f; :1KI1JIJ1IqHD-KOMMY-
HaJ1bHOM:y o6cnymJmamoo Ipam,11<IH; uo rpaiK,!\aH B :!roi!-
JIJl!I[(HOac<lJepeIilT.JI
TaKJllM  yKa3aHHaH KONJ1JI€KCHOCTb HOpM oOJIa,!:laeT O'I'Hro1-
TeJIbHbIM eJll1HCTSOM npe.!\MeTa pery.mlpoBaIDtil. OrClO,1\a eCTb Bee OCHOBa-
HKf! nOJlaraTh, 'ITO JKI.tJD1I[(Hoe npaso - KOMIIJIeKCHaR urpaCJlh npaBa, OO3J1!-
pymUJ,aHCH Ha 00MII.JJeKCHW 3aKOHO,l!aTeJIbCTBe RoMI1JleKCHbIe mpaCJll1
npaBa, n0C'lJXleHHbIe KaKHeKOecoe,l\l1HeIDIe pa:mopo.!UlbIX npeAMeTOs JI! Me-
TO)\OB npaBoBoro pery, nOJIy'lJl!Jll1 H1f' BTOpWIHbIX
MHoroypoSHeBhIX OOpa30samrn C'I])YK'T'YJI>I (CJI!CTeMbI) npaBa Jj CJlI-\eCTByroT
HapH.D:Y C OCHOBHbIMJ.:! mpacJIHMI? «MMeHHO B cBoea MHOCOMepIDCTl1, - KaK
cnpaee)\.l1Jl!BO crrMeTJ1JI CCAtleKcees, - npasosaH Ci1CTeMa CJDC.1J6ttanpe.I!-
CTaTh RaK "I'IJeHHHif CTS6ItIIhHIDlliI B TO JKe BpeMR )\l1HaMM'-lHbrn: opra-
HI13M,3Ha'nrreJIbHblMJl!peryJJHTJl!BHbIMJI!IJjB
C£1JIY3Toror.nyfuKOJjMHorocTOpoHHem:Ha
UI'HI:IIIeHJ1H..4.
MoilOf() c.u.eJlaTb BbIBO,l! 0 TOM, 'ffO H8.JIWrne KOMI1JIeKCHbIX urpac.rrea3a-
JjnpaBaBoo6Il\€JjKBaJIJ14>I1Ra[(IDIJKl.tJD1I[(HoronpaBaBK3.-
'1eCTBempaCJlJl!-3TOHeI1Jl0)\4>aHTa3IDfyqeHbIXJjHepe3yJIb-
TaT I1pOIf3BOJlllIO «KOlIC'Ip, a o6'beJmmHo CYI.l..\f2CTS)'IOll1<lH
peSJIbHOCTb. J13,l!aBaeMble 38KOH0)\8TeJleM :!roi!.ID1l[(HO-l1paB(IJHe SKTbI, CO-
B ceoeHopMbIpa3JIWIHbIXurpaCJIeanpaaa, IJx:pM>:lpyKJTCHJj cy-
l.l..\ecTBYlOTofu,eKTJ'!BHOBCOOTBe'TC'IEIDIC1MIt.
t\J1
, eM. ToncrofllO.K.)I(wmLIIHoen.oa.o -M. 1966.e. 25.
2eM. rJo/!eHw<ae.B.Teope......8CI<ef1jXlOJ1e...blcCreMblcoeeTCcro-
M.. 1979. e.32-J.3.
3CM.TOIICIWIOXKcJ\M<Pw<aLl'K'rpa>l<J\afICl<QroBCCcP(I96I-I965n:)'
JlmopecJ>.p,I<C . A-paICP.......HajlK.-ll. 1970.e. 10-11
..lV1eceeee.C. TeoPR npasa.- M 1995.C 198-199

06mecTBa. 3attOHOJ\lITeJIh, npeCJIe,!\YH [(eJib KIJMIIJJetocHC ypery.m1poBaTb orr-
pe,!\eJIeHHYWrpyrmy 06me<:TBeHHbIXO'I1I'JIlBDrl.i, J.I3 }'Ra3aHHbIeaKTbl,
BKJJaJJ:bIBaH B HOpMbI 3TIIX aKTOB onpelleJleHHoe cOllep:lKaHJl!e. 3To of:i'bJICHIJ-
eTCHJIpOJlbtO>tG1J1}1ll{HoronpaBa, 3aKOHOMepHOCT.HMJ1eropa3-
m1TI1H no Mepe pa3BwrlfJl  OTHOIllelU1R B >tG1-
.m1ll{HOii cclJepe. KOfM lIeMOKpaTll3ilWm Bcex JiULJII1l[(HO-IIpW!OBHX
OTHowemfl!: Jj npeo6pa3oBamre ()T11(nJeHI1jt COOcTBefIHOCrn B )K1
c4>epe OOyCJIOBJrnBalOT HeOOx COOTBeTC'J'BY1C npe06pa30Ba-
mfl!:B:1KI1JII1l[(Ho-npaBOBoroperyIDipOBaHl1.Fl.Tal«.UBblI5op3a-
IWHOMTeJLflCJIeJ1Ye'T'YBamaTbJjJjMnpl1peryJIJ1POBa-
HlfI1JK11.1I11I[(HbIXUI'H<IIIeIIJdi.
J13JJomeHHoe n03SOJUIeT }'TsepiK,!!,aTb, 'IT{) COSp€'MeHHOe )!01JIl1ll<Hoe
npaso eM'le Hr.rry6me TOro, OKOTOpoM BeJIH pe'lb )"!eHhIe l<€CSlTI1JIeTIDI Ha-
3a)J;. CoBpeMeHHoe :1KI1JII1l[(Hoe npaso, KaK IIOMII.IIE'KOIa OTpaCJlb npaBa,
npe):1CTaBJIHeT COOOM [(eJIOCTHOe o6paaoBamte; eMY CIJ(iicTBeHHo Ha.JII.1'111e
06l[(11X nOJI01t\BlHii 111OC1H11pe'fHHX npaBOBbIX I1HC'I'11T.)'TOB, HOpMbI KOTOpbIX
peryID1pytOT csoeOOpa3Hb!e  OTHOIllefWJ& CoapeMEtiHoe >tG1-
JII1ll{Hoe npaso II}XIHIf3HBaeT 11 [(6IoIelmtpyeT nplfcyl[(l1e TQJIbKO eM)' IIpaBo-
BhIe 1IIbI1, OHO ofirraJ\aeT CBOeOOpa3HbIM  Jj peiKl1MOM
npasosoroperyIDipOBaHl1.Fl.
2. IOPI-1.D.H4ECKMI npJ.1PO)J,A J.1 CYLliHOCTb npJ.1BAH13ALJ.J.1J.1
>KJ.1JlbIX nOMELlIEHJ.1ft J.1 EE npJ.1HUJ.1nOB
Jf3BecTm, OJJ,HaKO, 'lTO BOI1pOCb! 0 KJI nplfpo):1e If C)'UUJOCTIf
npI1B1lTl13aI.{Vll1)K11!JIbIXIDIii, 8TatoKeOeeMeCTeBCI1CTeMenpaBaJ1P
CIfX nop He 06Cb B npasosoi1 H3.)'Ke. KaK 6y1J:l'O 6b! cej;iqac Y'K€
MOmBO C'iJlTaTb J\OKa3aHHbIM TO II()J1(!H(6IItE, comaCHO KOTOpoMy OT):1eJIb-
Hble MHCTIIT)'Tb! :HGIJIJ1ll1Horo npaBa BbIRBJIeHbI Jj 06ocHOBaHbI )"!eHbIM}! nplf
8HaJI113e CTPYKrypbI OcHOS )KJIJJJ1l[(Horo 3aKOHO):1aTeJ1bC'l'Ba COI03a CCP Jj
COI03HbIX pecny6.mm, 8 T8toKe}KIfJIl1ll{llblX KOlIeKCoB COI03HbIX pe<:rryfurnK B
COCTaBe CCCP. Bo3H11KaeT BOnpOC: .HBJIHIOTCH.m1 }'Ra3aHHble aKTbI TeMJII oc-
1jXIBaHHbIMI'IHq)Ma'I'I1BHHMHnpasoBh!MHaK-
TaMJII, KOTOpbIe cOllepmaT B ce6e HC'IepIIbIBaIOl[(I1e BlfJlbI (nepe'lHJl!) JlHCTI1-
'fYI'DB :1KI1JII1l[(Horo npaBa? KaK, Harrpl1Mep, 6bITb C npl1BaTl13aLPu:ii >tG1JIbIX
IIJMeIlf3Ufl1?
'rlpHL.lIma..npasoBOrOI<WlUIH"'OTHOwet<..nocs"UI8I<"Crte\jOW1bHbIE! I
"CCJI!\II,OBHHH. 3p,ec.. CJ1!',/I,}'eT nw.. nQ!1'1epKHyn" TO 0 npHl.lI'nox "'MnMUlHom npaaa t--
pe"..6yll'ITlV\rn8 N

HCHo, 'ITO HJiI B ClcHOBax JtG'!JmIWiOro 3aKOHOTeJJbCTBa CoI03a CCP "
COI03HbIXpeCnyfuItfK,HJilBIro,!\eKCaXCOI03HbIXpeCnyfuIlfK,paB-
HO talK iii B J»I,!Ie IilHbIX, BeCbMa 3Ha'lJ.1MbIX O-IIpaBOBbIX aKTax . 0
npJ1B3.m3aL\l1JI!)KJ\JJbIX no pe<Gf He WJlO,.I\a iii Jl,!l;TJ1 He Momo, TaK
KaK Ha MOMeHT IiIX npillUlTl1fl el1!e He C03p€Jm He06x01J;lfMHE' CCf..\ImJIbHO-
m«EIJMWJeCKI1eYCJIOBJ1H6ec!IJlaTHoj.fnep€.!]:a'mJtG'!.lIbIXrpa:1K-
,!\aHaM I.f npeo6paaooamul: 0'l'lI)1lHII.fi Coi5c'I'BeHHOCTI1 B )lGiJmlWioJ;i c¥pe 1
M3Becrno, 'ITO B 1991 r BepXOBHbIM COBeTOM PC«P 6bLJI npJ1HHT 3aKoH
 4Je.l\epaL\11JIl ,,0 IIpI1B1l.TJ13aL\Hlil >IW.TII1lWioro 4JoH,lla B POCCIDI-
cIrofi m:". Ha3B3.HJ1e oro 3aKOHa Bbl3hIBaeT re. ITo
MeHbIIIelf Mepe o Ha3BaHJile MIDKHO OTHecTK K 'illCJl)' He COBCeM YIJil'IHbIX.
Hef!CHO, 'ieM  3aKOHO,!\aTeJlb, ,JIaBaJI xapaKTepJ13yeMOM)'
3aKOHY TaRDe Ha3BaIDfe B KOHe<rnOM C'IeTe IIpI1B1l.TI13a'-\IDI rocY,lIapCmellliO-
ro 11 M)'HML{I1na.m,HOro 4JoH,lla 0603Ha'I3.JI3. 6b.! CMeHY npaBOBOro p€iKI1Ma 0.1\-
HI1X 4JoPM (C6CmemJOCTI.f Ha p€mHM tffiCTHOi.f C06cTBeIDJOCTI1 rpaiK,!\aH.
Ha3B3.HJileJIKJ60ro 3aKOHa ,(IOJDKHO IfCKOlIIITb 113 ero o-
MWlecKoro npe,!\Ha3Ha'ieHI1H, Co,n;HI1H 11 L\eJDI!. Bo-nepBblX, Jm C'ill-
WTbBepHb!MTO.cor.nacHOKOTOpoMy3aKOHOAaTemoueofixo.ro1M
3aKoH, pery.lIlfJJY1(l.Wllf OTHOllleHI1fl 0 CMeHe peiKl1MOB Jj cym,eKTOB c06CT-
BeHHOC'fl.f, TO TPY.J\HO o&wI:CIDfTb, nO'leM)' B ('()JJ;epmamm 3aKOHa pe'lb l1,!\eT
o IIpI1B1l.TJ13awrn 3aID1MaeMbIX  JtG'!.IIbIX nOMelQemrn, lffiXO)1.H-
I.l..\I1XCf! JIJ'!llIb B .l\OMaX roCYlJilpCTBeHHOro 11 M)'HIIL\IIII3.JII:lI )lGiJmIWiOro
4JoH,!1a(CT.23aKOHa4Je,!\epa«OnpI1BaTlf3al.\>m:mJ1JI1flQHO-
ro 4JoH,lla B I'ocaorl1CKOi.J: 4Je,!\m"). Bo-BTOpbIX, l.\eJIb 3TOro 3aKOHa 011-
pe,!\eJIeHa B ero ITpeaM6yJIe. 06palL\eIDle K Hei.f,J\aE'I' lICH06aHJ.fe IIOJIaraTb,
'ITO "LleJlblO 3aKOHa S!BJIHeTCH c03J1aID1e yc.oom:nl. JJ.JIJI ocyIQ€CTBJE'lDffi npa-
Ba rpaJK,!\aH H3. cBo6o,IJ;Hbrn BblI50P cnoco6a y,!\oBJIeTBOpeHWI nOTpe6HOCTeii B
.mwIbe, a TalOKe YJIy'IDleID1e IfC(1('JJIb3()BCHI1JI Jj coxpaHHOC'I'J.I )lGiJmlWioro
4JoH,lla». 113 I1I1TI1PYeMoro nOJImKeHJ1H 0 Qe.IDl3aKOHa BIf,!J;HO, 'ITO OH BO r.na-
BY yrJIa CTaBI'IT 'ieJIOBeKa, a He tOpl1,!l;l1'leCK)'IO CY.l\b6y :H01JD1lL\Horo 4JoH,!l8, a
To<rnee,  :HGLJIJ'!lQHbIX oorp€6HOC'I'eii rpam,11<1H n)"!'eM cao-
6o)J;HOro BbIDopa Cl1oco6oB y,!\oBJIeToopeHWI yKa.3aHHbIX ncnpe6Hx:reK
'Ilof<RTe""""'llJI<aot>epa'I1peJICT!IMAeTco6oI\.o61I!ICTbHa)XIJIHoro.BKnIO.
aIOUJYIOCl])OI'ITenbC1llOHpe"OHCTPI"'l1"IO'"""l1\<I,COOp;oo<eHH:meMeHTO"HH»<eHep
"oHCOLU1anb>fOyIlpa8Jle"eH.D.OM.eroCOJU!P..a"MeH
pe"'OHT'(CM_ a63_ ICT 13aK()HaPoc:otlt>d\4>e.c.epaLU1H.v6OC"0ea><4leAepan...o,"".
nHllJI<o..."."......IIBe)IO"'OGTHCl.e:laaH8JlOII't"'XllenyraTOepalll1H
BepxoB>fOroCOBeT!I4>e.c.epaLU1HI993_""'3Cr99_CHl\Onon
"eH""'. BHeoeHH"'''' <t!I>.J1epan"''''M """000'" Poc"""(,,,, 4>e.c.epaLU1H or 12 AH""IJ
1996rN"9.(f>3).3aKO!<PocC\'lCI\",,4>e.c.epaLU1H.v60C1t0BaX4leAepanbHO_nllJI<OO
non"",".npM3HaHyrpaTM9W"'CBC8<I3MCI'"f)H"IIT"'Mpan"'''''''3!I"OHOMOT29M.
o:a6pso 2004 r "'" lB9-$3-o BIIE\!IE!It BMT!!He >Kw1llJI<oroKO.llf!KCa PocccKOii ct>e.<Ie.
palll1'(CM.Co(jpa"..e3al<OHO.<IaTenbCJSaPocc>ict;o4:Ia.<IepaLU1 2005.""'1.'1 I Cr. 15).
M"',""HCnQnb3yeMero::mecbJ1WbnQro"'Y,ToeHe...enepB",e,QaHOneran...oeoopel\E!
J1a"..eno""TH"",",,"llJI<a"c4>epa.
gjl

lIpaKTI1Ka IIpIIlII€tIeHW! HDpM 11 npl1HU,illIOB, CO)\epJKalW1XCH B llHaJIJI!-
::D1p}'€M1M 3aKOHe, IIOKa3bIBaeT, '1TO npl1B3.TI13awrH - :'ITO He KOHe<rnaH
craTlf'leCKaf! KaTeropmI, a npOL\ecc. B paMKaX 3TOro IIpOl\ecca I1pI1B1lTJI!-
311pyeTcH He BeCb J'I cpa3Y>K>1JlffiWfb1j;j 4x>HA, a COBepwaKYrCH rpaiK,llaHa-
MJI c)\enKJ1 no npl1BaTtm KOHKpeTHblX 3aHlfMaeMbIX J'lMIf >K>1JIblX no-
MeHJdi.. Kama B o60apl1MoM6YpYIIleMrJIDfi,UiUffiMJI, 3aH1no
.I\OIOOOPY Hat!Ma WU1 apeH)\bI>K>1JIbIe nOMel.l..leHI1H, FI B rocy-
JWpc"I'BeHHJM t1J111 MYHl1l!,11IIaJlbHOM mlfJlltmHJM Q:!oH)\e, oY.l\YT Bce 3T1f
nOMellleHI1H npl1BaTI1311pOBaH1:l, Tor,n;a nOHBJjTCH Bce OCHOBaHY!H YT-
Bepm]:\aTb, 'iTO YKa3RHHbIe rOcy,l\apCTBeHHblt! t1 MYHI1l.\Ml1aJIbHbIt! )KIf-
.1ll1lW\Hf' clJOHAbl npI1BaTl13I1pOBaHbl, a npl1BaTM3IqXJBaHH OHY! (clJOHAbl)
MoryT 6bI'T'b Ha OCHOBaHY!11311KOHR PlJCCJjj.jcKoii4Je «OnpI1BaTJ'I-
3aqHI1 :m:IfJlI1ll(HOro Q:!oH]:\a B POCCJIiiicI«D 4oe,n;epal!,l1t1. B HacTOHIIIee :m:e
BpeMH Ha3BaHI1e aHaJll1311pyeMoro 311KOHa He COOTBeTcTByeT HY! ero L\e-
nlf, HI1 CYIl\HOCTIf, nonOMY eCJIIf ObI npe,l1CTRBlVIaa. B03MCOKHOCTb ero
nepel1MeHOBaTb, TO 60Jlee npaBI1JIbHbIM no cyrn;eCTBY, Ha Hall! B3I'JlHJ\, no-
,l\OlllJIO 6bI TaKae Ha3BaHlfe: 311KaH Poccl1iicKcit 4Je,n;epal\11JIl «0 npJI!BaTJl!-
aal\11JIl rpam,n,aHaMif aaID1M1leMbIX I1MIf :m:lfJlbIX IIOMelQ€lllm: B ,l\OMaX rocy-
,n;apCTBeHHoroJ'l :m:If.IDIll(HblX 4x>HAOB TaKOeHa3BaHl1e
,l\eRcTBy1cn{ero 311KOHa npe)\J'laraeTCH He caMO no ceoe, a ,l\OJDKHO OblTb
ocyIl\eCTBJleHOCTO'lKl13peHmIeroCOQ>l3JlbHO-31\I1111JM11'1e-
CKOMY J'I !Oplf)J;wleCKoMY CO)\epmaHIfIl1 Y:>tee caMO H83BaHIIe 311KoHa o6pa-
ll\ReT BID1M1IHl1e Ha TO: a) KTO SlBJUleTCH, eCJIIf MomHO TaK BbIpa3HThCR, OC-
HOBHbIM Q:JuyplH'IUM ,n;aHHoro 3aKOHa J'I cy&beK1'OM I1p11B1l 6) 'ITO
BblcrynaeT 00beKT0M npl1BaTU3aQlrn 11 Tn. C IIpaK'J'JNt'CKYIX JD3J11Udt Ta-
Kae Ha3BaID1e y<IH'IHBaJIOCb ObI ,n;JlH perneHmI pH,!\a npofureM. B 'laCTIfOCTI1,
MOryr JlI1 BblCTyrraTb Cy6'b€KTaMJI I1pI1B1lTl13aqHl1 :m:IfJlbIX nOMell.\eID1J;J He
IpaiK,!\aHe ft UI, CKR:>teeM,  11 nlfL\R 61"3
rpIDK)\aHCTBa",l Mbl C'II1TaeM, 'ITO He MorYT. 3To BblTeKaeT 113 caMOro Ha-
3BaHJl!H3aKOHa.
)1yMaeTCH, 'IT{) Ba 3a)\a'lefi, HaPHJIY C  l1pynrx,
I1p1f J'lay'leHlfJl! 3Ha'illMOCTM J'I pOJlJl 3TOro 311KOHa HBJLIjeTCH onpeJI€JI€HIfe
eroRIlpJ.f])OD.bII1MeCTaBU«.'TeM€JXICCI1i'iCKCI'npaBa,aTalOKe
Kp npJ.f])O):{b1 caMOi1 I1pI1B1lTl13aql1l1. Y:>tee I1p11 nepBOM I1pl1fuIlf-
:>teeHJl!M K a J'I CTpyKType Ha3B3.HHoro 311KoHa MOmMO 06HRpy-
:m:IfTb, 'lT0 OH B nepBOHa pe)\RKl\ID1 COCTOM If3 BBe)\eHIDII1 TpE'X
pa3.11eJlOB1, KOTOpbIe BOIIJIOIl\ilKYr CJ1CTeM)' npmU.{IDIOB 11 npaBOBbIX HOpM,
perymfPJ1OlIJ;IfX 0I'Ha1EHJtH no OecrrJlaTHoA nep€)\a'le B cOOCTBeH1IOCTb
Ipa3j\eJlIIIBaHel1pe"'OKTI1jJI<>'''IIl'''''no'''''l1jeHOi.yrpaTl\Ilc I
rryBCB03><CB_"B"'BlIB>icTBB)I(KP<1>(CM ..saO"OT292004r 0\
"'" 189.<!>3..oBBe,IJ,e"MBlIBCT8e)l(.uILII"oroQ!!,eo<caPoc<:l<eo<oI\IJ,I<M.) 

rpaJK,!\atl3aHl1MaeMb!XI1MJI!)f(JI!JIb!XIBroCYIJilPCTBeHHOM1 ill MY-
HIMq,oH,!\e.TepMillH«)KJfJ!iIIJltHbrti:
4JoH,!\» nOJffiJ1JlCR cpasnITelIbHJ He)\aBHO, HO ill ()H YJK!' JlMeeT CBOIO JIIC'I'OpillIO.
Tat\, ,1\etfcrBOBaBWIIi1 B CBOe BpeMH 3aIDH PCOCP «0 co6CTBeHHOC'I'JI B
popcp. IIpIf3HaJI mllID q,oH,!\ MecTHbIX CoBe'l'OB MJHI
006craeffiVCTblO. B COOI'BeTCTBI1I1 C 3TiIIM 114JoH,!\ CTaJi JlMeHOBaTbCR «M)'HI.f-
 ('1.1 CT. 23:yKa33.HHoro3aKoHa). CorJIaCHO CT. 24 3TOro:me3a-
KOHa :m:J1.IIJ1lqHbIi.J: 4JoH,!\nepe.Q1m B nOJIHDe xoom'icTBanIDe
Be,!!eHYIe llpeiJPPKH1'!1fi 11 ()rrepaTl1BHDe ynpaBJIeHYIe yqpeiK.!\eHJI!H, Ha 6aJIaH-
CeKOTOpbIX()HCOC'l"OMpaHee.BnolUlTIle .
 4JoH,!\ IIpO'fHOymepWIJIOCb B poccI1iibroM3aKOHom>TeJIbCTBe.
o HeM ynOMillHaeT CT. 2 3aKOHa PUCCl1ifcKOj.j  «0 IIpI1B1l.'I1I3aqIni
oro4JoH,!\8.BPoccm.icJwii4JeJ:\epa1!lnt1"(Bpe,D;.OT23,1\eKa6pH 1992r.)
I1CT. 7 3aKOHa4Je.n;epa!.\I1JI!«05()cHOB3.x4Je,!\epa.m,tIOtl:1K11Jillll1-
Hem !JQJII11'm(J1". 3ToT:me 3aKOH 'IeTKO fJ1)X'l\e1IIVIlf (te (COCTaB)
M)'HI1!.\I'Ina.m,HOro )f(JI!.ID!IlVi0ro 4JoH,!\a B Hero BXO)\HT: a) q,oH,!\:!KI1JIbIX,1\o-
MOB, B c06CTBeHHOC'I'JI panOMa, roPOJl8, BXO)\H B HI1X a"u,-
MMIDfCTpaTlmHO-Tepplrrq:U13JIlHbIX ()6pa3OB3.H1fl1. B TOM 'lJlICJIe B ropo,!\aX
MocKBe JII CaHKT-ITerep6ypre; 6) Be 4JoH,!\, H3XUJIHII111iiCH B
!IOJIHOM X03.RtiCTBeIDJOM Be,!!eHlfJ.! M)'HinvmaJIHIbIX np B KOHe'l-
HOMC'leTeem1HCKJfpa3I1eBnOHHTI1:eIfBlf,/\bIro4JoH,/\aBHec,1\elfc-r-
JKKP4>.BHeMCO,1\epiKl1TCH4JoH,/\a,no,1\
KaropbIM nOHl1MaeTCH CIJBOHYIDDCTh Bcex )KHJIbIX , HaxOJIH-
II1I1XCR Ha TepPm'OpIH1 PocmiicRu'i 4Je,1\epa!.1l1l1. B ,D;aJIbHefuneM ,I\JIJI.wrqr
ci:lepaiL!l13QJm )f(JI!JIlIII1Horo 4JoH,/\a 3aKOBO,!\8TeJ1b IfCn0Jib3YeT ,I\Ea KBaJII1-
ICornaCHo3aKoHypaL\HHo06OCH"""""W1ll\HOnOJ1""'.
.l5b111HBHeceH"_'COCT!lB"06l1i6CTeeHHoro"""nLI.jH"'"
IpoHAOB,Ta'.BC<XI1BeTC",,COCTIH83""HHoro3al<oHaBcOCTaB"'"
nMll\HorolpoH,D,B.BOIW1MI)Ba<J,OMcrseHH..ii"""nMll\H..iiIpoMA.COCTOOll\H;;;Brocy.o,apcrseH.
"oc:oOcrsetHocno PoCQ<Oict<o <1>e.c.epa...." Ha)<Q.!J$ILIIHCBnOmtO"'03OicTaeMMo"ee.
p,eHnpeJI,Ill""'n"nOOe"""'"HO"J1JCWI'IPGTOOHt
Y'<pe>l:,!leH, OTHOCRll\H'C<I4Ie,IJ.epanbHOc06cTBeH0CT0<.2,)IpoH,ll,
HaxoJIRl11"I"pec\'6J1'''cocTa"e<1>eJWpaLJ,l'l,Kpae",06
nacTeii.aIJTOl<OMMoiioOJ1ac:rn.OI<PYToeropo,£lO"Moc."",,,CaH<r
ra,aTalOKe4>oMA,HaxQ!1Rl11"IiiC<lBnonMo"eeJ:1e><HHroc:y.
lI,3pcTBeHH""'npeJlJ1p""'""OOepaT"HoMynpaEllleH
OTHOCRLIIH'C<I"'ll\YCoOcmeHHOCT
BCOCTa""""nlljHorolpoH,D,B.lIOwn:lJIpoMA,"co6cmeH
HOc:rn2)4>oMA,Cocroqll\HB.
3J4IoHJ:1.Ha><OJIRL1I"'C<lBoJ5ujel<..,,06l1ieiil!PneBOi\c06cTaeHHOCTpa3.
n"M""'KTIJI!aCT><oii.,MI'HLj\1"""bHoiico6cTBeHMOCTo<.aT1l""'e
MOCTo<o!'iL1l9CTtiSHM""'
BlI,3IIbHewe""""CTORll\epa6oTe"TaKOMC""'CJle"OOCT""er1OH'oMi!lOlCSlH)'rJ01peI'i
nRIOTCI1OHIIT>ffi""Mnll\Hblii
rpa>l(,!J,aHC"oe""YHHLj\1nanbH""W1lljHblHIpo"11
"a3b1BaeTeJ:\I1HblMTejJMHOM-4>oMJ\COlll1anbHoroal'lOroBOp.OrJOCPl'l1Y.
IOL1I"iirpa;t;<laHaM""""'"3yt<83aHMoro4>oMA8-,IIOroBO.
poMCOlll1anbHOro....HMa..""oronO""'LljeHICT.672rKP<t».
gl

IJJJ1KaL\ll!OHHblX Kpm'ep!1H: 1) B aaBll()fMOCTII OT <PoPMbl c06CTBeHH0CTI1 ill
2JB3aBH(m.£IC'I1t.OTIJ1Tal\,BOT4x>PMbl
c06CTBeHHOCTIf)KlfmH,!I;nO)IJJ1l3.l1eJlHeTCHHa: 1) 'ffiC'I'Hbrli::HGLID'!II1-
HbJi;iH,!I; -COBOK)'llHOCTb)KlfJlblXnOMni, HaXQ/J,RIlI;I1XBc06CTBeH-
HOCTI1 Ipa.m,11aH J1 co5C'rBemIocTIf KJpIf,IlI1'!ecKI1X mrn.. 2) rocy1:\aJX"TBEflHID1
HGIJIJ1ll!HbmH,!I; - COBOKyrrHOCTbHGlJlbIXIJOMeHIDI, neJKalI[l1x
Ha npaBe 006cTBeHHOCTIf POCCIfti:CKOti: q,eI!epa11 (mIfJII1II1HbIti: 4x>H;Q
PoccJliictroti epaQI1If). J1 )E'lfJIbIX nOMeIl{elUnl, IIptlHa,I\JlemalQl1x Ha
npaBe c06CTBeHHOCTI'l cy1TheKTaM F'oc:c:I1ii.tc: q, (HGIJIJ1ll!Hbm
H,!I;cy6u'K'JoBPoccmicIroiiIPem:);3)H,!I;-co-
BOK)'IIIVCTb:1Kl1JlbIX IXJMelI[eHllfI, IIptlHall1IemalI[l1X Ha npaBe co6crneHHoc-
TJI MyHI1I.J;11naJlbHbIM OOpa30BaHYIRM.
B aaBllCI1MOCTi'! OT l.\eJleti: 1«'IDJIb3OBaIDIH.mI1.III1lI[Hbrn H,!I; nO)IJJ1C.lIe-
JIHeTCHHa'I)HGIJIJ1ll!HbmH,!I;RCI1OJIb3OBalDlH-COBOKyrr-
HOCTb  rpam,!1aHaM no .lIOroBOpaM 00Qt1dJlbllOITJ Hati:Ma
:lKlfJIbIX HHtt rocYMPCTBeHHOro ill MJHI1I..I;I1I13.J1bHOro )KIfJIilllI[Horo
4x>H,!\a;2)HGIJIJ1ll!HbmH,!I;-coBC.IK}'IIK.ICTInpe.lI-
Ha3Ha'leHHbIX,ltJUI npo.ml1BaHl1H OT.lIeJlbHbIX KaTeropIDi Ipa.m,11aH ill npe;Qo-
CTaBJIHeMbIX B ,I:\OMaX rocY.l\apcTBeHHoro 11 M)'HI1QItrra.fIbHI:I'O JoKI1.ID1lI[Horo
4x>H,!\acJI}'iK€6Hb!X:IKI1JIbIXI1OM€fQ('IDrlt,:lKlfJIbIX
MaHeBpeHHoro 4x>H,!\a 11)IJJ. (CM n 4-7 CT 92 JKK P).
CK.rra)J;bIBaeTCH Bne<raTJleHJl!e, 'ITO COBOKyrrHOCTb HOpM, peryID1pytOlQI1X
OTHOllieIDfJI no yxa&lHHOti: nepe;Qa'le B col5cmeHHOCTb IpaJK,!\aH 3aHJl!Mae-
MbIX I1MI1 :!KI1JIbIX IIIJMe HBJIHeTCH He 'leM JlHbIM, KaK JlHCTIlTyroM
npaea. TaR JI}I <Yro? .lLnH TOro <rroow OTBeTiII'T'b Ha 3TO'1' BOnp1C, CJle)IyeT 06-
paTJITbCIlKnOJlIDKeHIDlMOOlnrnnyrenpaBa.
CorJlacHo  OOlI[eT€OpeTWleCKI1M llOJIOJKeHHHM J1HCTIf-
TYI" npaBa onpe;QeJUleTCH He KaR o6oco6JJeHHaJI Ipyrma e3aIfMOCBfl3aHHbIX
Kp HOpM, peryID1pylOll\I1X onpt'JI€.lIeHIillif B OOlI[eCTBeHHbIX
OTHOlll€'HJI!If ,a JlI1lIIb ltaK pa3JlWlHwe CTOpoHbI O.l\Horo TIffiWlHOro oOlI[ecT-
BeHHOTO. BcJ1e.I:1cTmle 3TOro aHaJIlf3 HOpM 3aKOHa Poccm1cl«n1
4'e.l\epa!.\11JI! «0 np!1BaTlf3al.\IDl )KIfJlJ1lQHoro H,!:\a B PomDicKUi 4'e.l\epa-
QI1iII» n03BOJUIe'T' BblHBI1Tb 060cofuIelffiJlO rpyrrny npe;QME'TIIO J1 o-
HaJIbHOB3alnpaBOBbIXHopM,peryID1pylOll\I1XOTHOllleID1lJno:
1) 6ecnJlaTHoti: nepe;Qa'le B co6CTeeHHocTb rpaJK,!\3.H Ha .A06poBOJIbHoti: OCHo-
Be 3aHl1MaeMbIX 11MI1:HafJIbIX m: B rocy,l1apc'I'IIf2HHIJM 11 MJHI1I-\I1-
naJIbHOM )f(IfJIJI!lI[HOM e; 2) YCJlOBIDlM npJ1B1l1'l13al.\lt: 3) o6c.rryiKIfBa-
IDIIO 11 peMoHT)' npifBaTK3J1pDB<UlHb :»GIJIbIX  ECJI}I HOpMbl,
Ie.. Ba[;lN!bf!BA.M.T!!op""uucYll,3pCTBa"npalla.-M.lOjJI1J\.""T.,1983.C 283. I
:!e..Teop""JUCjIpCTBa"npaaa/nQljpe.!j.A.H.Ko.ooneoa..l1.C.S1B,,"a.-,,.I1:w.-BlJl1e. _
MHpa,[f)(IIm,1987.C400. I"t'\

coTpe60BaHJ1H06yc.rroBJ.1HXperyJIJ1PYlO1'JtG'!-
JllfUtHO-ocY-
ll.\ecTBJIeIDU{) npJl!BaTI13a4J1l1, a HOpMbJ, OCJocpe1E' OTIlOUIeIDIR no 06-
Cny>KJfE3HJfIO JI! peMOHTY I1pJIBaTJI!3J1!pOBaHHbIX JtG'!JlbLX nOMeIl(etiJl!n,
pery.lIl1p:y1O'l' nOCJIenplfBa OTHOllieIDfH, TO 3TJI! rpynrn,r HOpM
MOJKHO YCJJOBHO Ha3BaTb BCnOMOraTeJlbHbIM}! JI! "reCHO I K
rpyrme HOpM, peryJTh!pYJOX COOcrneHHO OTHOUJeIDIR no nplfBaTJI!3aqHJI!
KaK TaKOBbIe. am HOpMbJ SffiJlJlIOTCH CTepJKHeBbIMl1, 06p1l3YJO MPO
HOpM xapaKTePf3Y€MOI'O 3aKOHa, J1x oI5ocoI'iJHme J1  Hanpaa-
J1eHHOCTJII onpeJ\eJlSllOTCH xapaKTepOM peryJTh!pyeMbIX ()'I'lI()IIIeIJ
J1:mrerno, 'lTonpaBOBOIiJ1HCTlfTYl'crpowrcHCy<leTOMoroi5eHHoCTeti:pe-
ry.lIl1pyeMbIX 0'I'I£JIll€HIft HopMbl rpaiKJ\aHcKOro npaBa pery.lIl1pJ1OT B oc-
HOBHotl:cBOetl:MaCceOTHOllIeHJ.fjI (CT. 2I1\pq.,). BMecTec
'feM OTJ\eJ[bHbI€ CTOpOHbI'feX mecaMbIX  <YJHOClleIII.If (OT-
HOllieIDIH no KOMMeplJeCK0M)' Hai1:My :»afJIbJ'!, OTIIOIl.I€llilfl no npHBa'I'll:3aWfi'l
:Haf.IIbIX nOMe) pery.lIl1p)'IDTcH HOpMaMK :HGIIDIoro npaBa. C1poro
roBOpiI,o&t.eKTOMBmm'kTmm3TMXHopMHeBblc-ryrraIOTOTIlOllieIDIRRaRo-
ro-TO oc06oro pOM, 'faK KaK OTHOllietIJI!IJ no UecIIJIaTIIOtl: nepe,!\a'le B C06CT-
BeHHOCTh IpaiKJ\8.H Ha ,!\oopoBOJlbHOn OCHOBe 3aHI1Ma€MbIX JI!MJ1 JtG'!JIb1X no-
MeIl.\€HIDI B rocyJJ;apCTBeHHOM J1 MYHJ1I1J1IrrarrbHOM :IKIf.1IIfIl.\IIOM <}JOH,!\e
IIpe,!\CTaBJIJIIOTCOOOtl: pa3IDI!I'J,l!II J1M.YI1-\ecTBeHHbIXO'IHJlll€IDlii 3TI1 0'1'-
HOllIeID!H 00pa3yIOT OTHOCJl!TeJ1bHO C8MOCTOHI'eJIbH 06.nacTb 061I\eCTBeH-
Hon JtG'!3ID!, OID! JIlMeKJr coi5CTBeHHoe:3ROH()NJ1'IeCKOe co.n;epiKaHJlIe JI! B"VIO-
B)'IO npOIDICKY. B CI1JI.Y:1TOfO J1 B03HJ1!KJIa treal':iXO)J;l(MOC'I'b BaHJm
rpyIIIIbI HDPM, npl13BaHHbIX OOeCIIe'lJI!Th CTaHEJIetu.Ie, HopMaJIbHOe pa3BJII-
TJI!e J1 peaJD13aWOO )'Ka3aHHbIX UIHJIIHn1i.J:
Ha.rrwrne 0TH0CJ1'l'e.III0 caMJC'I'OH'fe.I(I'() no cBDeM)' :H((E(JIIJJf'jecKOMy
06lI\eCTBeHHoroOTHollIeHJI!IJ}!JJJI!JIIxpa3HOBJ1,ll;HO('TnnpJI!HJ'lTO
Ha3biBaTb MaTepJl!aJ1bHbIM npJl!3HaKOM npaBOBoro JIlHCTI1TyTa, a CO£IOKyII-
HOCTb3aRpE'lIDftiHb! B 3aKOHe J1JIJI aKTeHOpM -lOpl1,!\WJec-
KJ1MnpJlI3HaKOM1.HaM 'lTOOmO'iKOBaB!ID'IeCHOTJ1M)'Jl.\e-
CTBeHHbIX 0'IRJUleHJIii OTHOCJl!T€JIbHO caMOCTOHTeJibHbre JIIX 
no UecIIJl'lTtlOn nepe,!\a'le B co6CTaeHHOCTb rp3.*,!13.H Ha ,!\OOp::JBOJIbHOn OCHOBe
3aID1Ma€MbIXI1MJ.1 :oo1IIbIXDOM6.1..\f2lliDi: B rocy.n;aIX'fBeHHOM If MJHIfl(JffiaJThHOM
)KIf.1llIIIIIIOM QxJH,!\e, BbIC-ryrraIOTMa.'I'ep.IaJIhIdi OCHOooii (nptl3HaKOM) npaBo-
BOI'OHHCTJI!'I'yTanpJ.1BaTIl3al(H1fmun.IXrli, aCOBOK;yIIHOCTh Co)\ep-
.m<III\I1XCH B xapaK'I'epJCY€MW 3aKoHe HOpM - lOpWf'Jearoti QxJpMofi (no
'Tep.mm.IU'IDI B.C.RKYllleBa, Ha Balli B3rJUJ,!\, He cOBceM y.n;alffiOtI:, IOp£1,!J;J1-
'lecKJIIM npJl!3HaKOM 3TOro HHC'ThITyra).
(\/ 1 -
tr'\ 'CM_ j:j<yweaB.C_OnOl<""""'pa.e090rO"Hcn<'I)T8I1 1970 ""'6_C_65

J1TaK, MO)f(HO npe,1UlOJlaraTb, 'ITO cO.n;ep:jfaUlHCH B 3aKoHe PoccRi1cRoM
4'e.n;epaQIHI«O nplfBa'l'I43a.QlfH )KIfJ'Il1JltHoro (jJoH,!\a B Poce>1ik':K£ji 4'e.n;epa-
QI1J'!» COBOK)'IIHOCTh HOpM,  pery.ID1pOBaTb arHOCIfTeJIbHO ca-
MOCTOJITe1IbJIO no CBoeM)'  CO)J;epiKaHIfIO OTHoweHlfe no
6ecnJIaoroojj: nepe)J;a'le B co6o::meHoocTh rpam,!\aH Ha .u,06poE1OJIbHJ11 OCHOBe
:'IalrnMaeMbIXHMY!:JKIfJIbIX nc:JMeIiiB rocy.QapcTBeHHOM 11 M)'HI1IJ;11I1aJIb-
HOMmIfJlI1JltHOM(jJoH,!!e,co6ofi:caMOC'fO.iIT'e1IbllbID:I1HC'I'If'I)'T
npaBa. B031UmaeTBOI1pOC: KaIWBa OTpaCJIeBaHI1HCTI1TY-
'fa :1KIfJIbIXJI()MEUHIfii'? .lLaH OTBeTa Ha 3TOTBOI1pOC HeoOXo-
JJ;lfMo06paTIlTbC.RKTeMltpH'I"epI'UIMKQTOpble
npmoBOiiHaJIUI. «Ram.nPrn npaBOBOMItHCTInyI', - IDlliIeTCC NIeKCeeB,-
nOCBRLQeH onpe,lleJIeHHoM)' )"I3.CTKy  O'I'HCWeJjIfif»'. TaIDfM
Y'ffiCTh:OM 3,!\eCb CJIY'KI'IT cneqI npeAMeT
npaBOBoro pery.!DlpOBaHHH. no CweH 3I«JHOW1'l€CRDH cym OTIlOllleHIfH no
npI1Ba.RBJI.RIOTCJI pTOBapHbIX
0THI:IlleIDrn. EcTb 60J1blllOM COruHillH KBaIDb :JTI1 OTIlOlllem1H
RaK, a paCCM3.T))I1BaeMbrMI1HCTI1"I'Yf -RaKrpaa\,lJ;aHCKO-npa-
BOBOH. O,llHaKO TaKOM no;:pro,ll K  npaBOBOM npmm,n.rreHlliOl
I1HCTI1TyTa npl1BaTlf3aL1ll!If:1Kl1JIbIX nOMerqemrn 6bLII ObI Ourn1Xr-JHbIM. CJIe-
1IYe'f OTMeTIfTb, 'ITO IIHCl1fTJ'I' nplfBaTl13alllflf.mIfJIbIX  Ha-
CTOJIbKO HacbIIIleH CIJe1M oOll\eCTBeHHO-lIIJ.IDITIl'lecIGlM, HpaBCT-
BeHHbIM 1Op1M CO)J;epiKaHlfeM, '1TO OH 00pa3ye'f oc06.YJO C<Pepy
npaBOBoro peryJIJlpoBaHIfJI.
Co,l\ep1KaHlle npaBOBOro I1HCTI1TyTa npl1BaTl1:'lal[11I1 >KIfJIbIX IIJMeIl[eHJ1i.i
opoID13aHO Co6cTBeHHblM11 o-npaBOBbOO:!  KOTopble
c!}JoPMYJII1poBaHbI 3aKOHO)\aTeJleM 1!1  IIpRMoBIIpeaMfiyJIe 11
TeKCTe 3aKOHa PocC1 <PeJl£P3.II;mf «0  oro
4JoH,1\a Bf'oocIDicKrjt <Pe1JW<lltlm».
HanplfMep, B IIpeaM6yJIe CKa3aHO, 'ITO OH <yt:'I'8KIBJIJIeT OCHOBHble
npl1H1..\I1IIbI oC)'llleCTBJI€HWI npI1BaTIl3aW1>'l». 06 OT,J:I,eJibHbIX lIpax
npI1BaTl13aII;mf :1KIfJlbIX IIIJMBl{eIDIi.i l1JIeT pe'lb B CT. 1 paaJJ:eJla I «06lJ..!Me no-
.1I»KeHWI.' xapaK 3aKOHa 11, HaKOHel[, 11M nOCBHIqeH paeJl II
«OcHoBHble nplfHi.\11IIb1 11 YCJlOBWI npI1BaI:»a1JIbIX.
CTaJlO 6bITb, xapaKTeptI3}'et4bli.J: 3aKoH npoHl13bIBaeT BXOJJ)IIII;Me B Hero:HG1-
O-nplBfEbl€ HopMbI Oc06blM>:! :1KI1JII1IQHO-npaBOBbIMI1 npl1Hl[I'IIIaMH.
3TI1 npIfIll.\I1IIbIH€K!B€CTHblrpaa\,lJ;aHCKOMYnpaBY,.Qa I1CaMOMY o-
MY npaay, 1160 TepMlfH «:lKlfJIHI.l[HO-nplBOEbl€» IIpIfC)'lll :1T11M I1pIIHl!ImatII
HaKc06I1paTeJlbHoe nOH.llT1fe <11pUHItJ1J1bImIf.JII11lUIOronpa-
Ba», KIYropbIe, HaK TaKOBble, nplfCJll\I'I npIDJIJ;I1I1aM ICUlffi.JEKClI)fi OTpaCJll1
HGfJIJll.l[Horo npaBa. TIPI1HI<l1lll>I>Ke nplfBaTI13aL1ll!If:1KlfJIbIX  33,-
'AneKCOOBC.C. ClpyKTypaC0geTCKOmnpaoa.- M .IOPIVI. nMT. 1975.C 140
I 

Kperr.mnDTCH B aHaJIiI31rpyeMOM 3aKOHe KaK I1pIHQIIIII:i JKI1.!illIWIo-npaSOBQ-
rOIfllCTlf'lJ"T'I.E.llaro,!\apHI1pI1l1ltIU1.aMnpJl!BaTlf3awrnmJ1JIhIX,
O-npaBOBOj;i I1HCTI1'JYl' npJl!BaTI13aqID1 :HGIJIbIX nOMenJ!HI'lii nOJIY-
'{:leT BHeWHee 060cr.61H:'HHOe 3aKpel1JleHJl!e B CI'ICTeMe J,'IOCCIIiicm'O)f(J{.]IJI!J.L(-
HOro 3aKOHQlW.TeJIbCTBa.
CoxpaHJIHHeKOTOpYJOCBH3bCOT)\eJlbHbIMl'lrCKO-npaBOBbIMI1W1-
CTJl!TyraMl1noJTh!HJII.f,xaJ1}JCTI1'IJ"I"o60-
c06JIReTCHBHJTPI1'iOTpac.nI1oronpaBanonpe,IJ;MeTHo-
MY npJl!3HaKy. ITOCKOJIbKy ctheKTOM npl'lBaTl'l3a1..lJl!11 HSJlf!IOTCH :IKJI!JIble
 TOOTHorneHlf$! no wxnplfBaTlf3a1..lJl!l1 MOmuORBaJII1poaaTh
KaK:HGI.IIJI!lWibIe.O)J;lffiKOKpyrOTHIJIlHIJrlI.UJCTImJIHKII(IIX
npe)\MeT' peryID1posamffi npasosoro Jl!HCTi1T)'Ta npJ1BaTJ13iil<I1I1:HmJIhIX no-
I\IelIJ'ffin"f, 3aHI'lMaeT oco6oe nOJlIDKeHJl!e B CI'lCTeMC IXarno!lleHidi.
3aRCHJ,IlaTeJlb, Jl!36pas B Ka'{eCTBe OObeKTa npl'lBaTl'l3aqJ1Jl! :HmJIhIC nOMe-
HJ.IJI,Brocy)\apcrseHHOMI1)IG!JD1IqHOMclJoH-
l1.e, 0603Ha'll1JI TeM caMbIM npJl!BaTI13a4l'l1O KaK CMeH)' pe»a1Ma rocyMPCT-
BeHHOi1 JI!  Co6CTsCHHOCTl'l Ha 3a.1rnM3.€MbIe tpa»C,Z\aHaMl1
:HmJIhle I1CMefl..!eIJll Ha pCmJIM 'iaCTIloif cofJcTBeHHocTIl rpa»C,Z\a1L
KaK BJ.1)\I1M, arnorneHWI no nplfBaT/13aqJ1Jl!:HmJIh1X rli HeJlb3H
OTHecT/1 HI1 K O)J;llOM)' BI1)Jy 113 paRee Ha3BaHHbIX:IKJI!JIJ.IUtHbIX 
no: npm6pE'TeH11lO 3eMeJIhHbIX )"IaCTKOB,(\JUI lIDlI1..\HOCO C'IJXlJ.ITeJIbCTBa;
I'lHaHCHJX.ti8HI1IO:1KI1JIJI!IqHoroCTpoJ.ITeJIbCTBaJl!3KClIJlYaTa>KI'IJlbIXnO-
npe)KJI!JIbIXIXJM€I.I..!eHIDno1\OroBOpaMCOl..IJI!aJIbHo-
ro 11 KOMMep'JecKOro HaHMa lpaJKl1.aHaM, HJiK,lI1lIOI.WIMCH B HI1X; ynpaBJIe-
Hmo :IKJI!JIl1l.WiblM ,>KI'IJII'II.WiO-KOMMJ1i8.JIbHOM)' 
r,Ipam,!\aHBfJIJC<Pepet1T.nAHamI3lil-
pyeMble arnoweHIDI HBJUfiOTCH Cweo6pa3HbIMl1, OTHOCJ.ITeJIhHO caMOCTOH-
TeJIhHblMl111  B CWJy 'JerOOObeK'l'lfBHO TPe6yror CBoe06pa3-
HOro npasosoro peryJTh!poBaHJl!H.
C yqeTOM  J'4()jKHQ)laTh KOppeKrHylO C npaBOBblX n
lJ.e4Innlqlnol1HCTJ1TYl'8-I1p'IBa'DlII.mJI!JIbIXKaKropflJ.ll'JeCKO-
roIIpaooBblMJmCTIrryroMIlpIIBaTJI3altIHGL.1IblXnO"lt'lQellldl
npu;3IIa('TCJI ()(.H(IB!lHHIUI Ha 3aI{OHC tlJ8OKyIIHOCTb lIJ>OHU3bIB,leMbIX IIplrn-
fUlll3MJ1 u HOpM, npI3BaHIILlX peryJll1posaTb 8 Ilpl',QeJrnX
npe,!!,MCTa KOmJleKCHoj;i OTpaCJIJI HGfJII1IWIoronpasa re OTHOCI-
TeJlbHOftThHOCTblOlicsoeofJpa3ueMUTHOIIUIWI
nonpIffiaTIIaau:m HGlJlbIX lIOI\Ia TaIDKeCBH3aJ1HbIC C ffilMU npoU3-
80)\Hblcnpe)\llpIB8l1nOCJIenpllB8OTHOIUCHl1JI.
113 nplffie)\eHHbIX coofpmremnl ID1)\HO, 'ITO I1HCTI1'JYl' npJl!BaTI13al..lJl!I'l
:HmJIh1X  C1I'JlWJa€1'CH err  OTpaCJrn )lG!JIJI!!l<Horo
1 arn.npl\I<n08p,aero"DCJ1W1j11OllWAmaBeI1OCJ1!\11,01111H'"

npasa If BblcrynaeT ee COCTaBHOH 'l3.CTbIa 31'0 OTJIWIH€ OOHapy>KmlaeT ce-
6.11KaI\OO'heMQM, TaKIfCBOe05pa3JieMnpeTa npaBOBOroperyJll.fpOB<lHlUl:
HOpMbJ iii nplflll.\11IIh1 Ha3BallllOro I1HCTI1TJ'Ta pery.mlpYKIT He BCID COBO!l:yrr-
HOCTb :IKI1JDI!b!X. a JII1WbOTHoweHMH no npIfBaTIf3aWlIi>K>1-
JIbIX IXJMeIl!E'HInL o-npaBOBOf1I1HCTl1TYT IIpJl!Ba"IK3a1..\Jfl1 :mJ1JIhIX
JI!MeeTCBOKlCTPYJITYPy.nOCBoe"CTpYKTYPeOHCOCT0I1TI13pe-
ryJI$lTi1BHbIX HOpM JI! 06JIa):\a£'T BCeMJ.! npIf3HaI\aMI'I CJfC'I'EtIoIHOro npaBOBOro
OOpa30BaIDtil, coo6pa:mo :IT0MY ,WI.H Hero xapaKTEpHa OTHOCIf'IeJIbIIaH ca-
MOCTOH1'eJIbH)C YCTOWIMBocTb JI 8BrCIICMtIOCTb  B
::rroti CM311 B03HlfKaeT BOITpOC 0 ICpt cyJJ;b6e II MeCTe npIDIl.\Ifi1OB
JI ROpM 3aKOHa Pocadictroif 4reJ:\epaI1IDI «0 npJl!BaTIIJ3al(111f >KJ1.IDjIWIoro
4>oH,(la B  <Pe;:\epaL\l1w> M<»KHO nOJJaraTb, qT{) Ha HacTO.IIllIee
BpeMJI OR BbIDOJIHI1JI CHOIQ t1cTOplf<lecK)'IO MI1CCJ1lO rJlaBHbIM 06p8.30M KaK
peryJl.F!TOp OTHDllIeHIDI no npeo6pa30BaHl1Kl QxlpM  B )KJi!-
oiic4lepe.HonOCKOJIbKYnJXll-\eccnpJl!BaTR3aJ..tlO'l.mmIbIX
npo,!\OJDK1I.eTCf!, TO OCHOBHbIe nplun.\11IIh1 JI HOpMbJ 3'T'OI'O 3aKOHa MOfJlJl! fib!
6blTb coxpaHeHbI B HDBOft pe,!\3.KU,I1I1 tTO 3aKOHa mroo BOI'IJIOJ.i.I.e-
HbI B:m.K f'<:I. Bo!I}Xlc 0 CilOCOOe 1.fI ytta3allllblX npl1HOB"
ROpM MO:?KeT peIilllTb 3aKOHO;:\aTeJIb. ITOCKOJIbK)' IIopR.1\OK 
:»G1JIhR ycraHaBJIJfBae'l'CH  3aKOHOM, TO ecJIH 3aKOHO,!!,aTeJ!b
CO'ITeT HeoOXO)U1MbIM 3aKpE'III1Tb B:m.K P!fll1HCTI1ryT npJl!BaTI13aIlID1:Ha1-
JIbIX,TOCOC1l'lleTCTB)'IOw;yKJCTaTbIOCJle.uyeTH3.3BaTb <lTpHBa-
m3aJ..!W13aHHMaeMblXJ1MJI!)KIfJIbIXBJJ;OMaxrocy-
JJ;apcTBeHHoro 11  )f(JI!JIJ1IWiOI'O 4>oHJJ;a, HaIJo.rnnlB ee
CJle;:J;ylOJ.J..J;JI!Mco,D;epmatlJl!eM o
«10 fpa:m,!\aHe JlMelOT npaBO nplffiaTI!3HJX1BaTb:m:J1.lIbIe nOMeIIleHIDl, 33.-
tlJl!MaeMbleI1MJl!IIO,llorooopYHaifMa BJJ;OM3.xroCY.l\3.pCTBeHHD-
rol1mJ1JIIIDtIIOID4>oHM.
IJpmn:pUThlI1 IIOpR.1\OK nptlBa'I1t3aQJDl Ha3BaHHb!X »a1JIb!X 
41eAepaJibHbIM33.KOHOM.
IIepe,D;a'ffi B c06cmeHHOCTb HaHI1M1ITeJUI 3aHJI!MaeMoro JIM :HG1JIOro nOMe-
l.I1eHJ1HTBJUreTCHH3.OCKJBaHJIUJJ;OroBOpa, 3aKJIlO'iaeMOrOHaHI1M1ITe-
JIeM c co6c'memooroM .mnm1l.IlH(I'O 4>oHJJ;a IfJIJI!  JIM Jll1I..!0M.
3ToT ,IIOI'OBOp IIO ycraHOBJIelllIbIM 33.KOHOM OCHOBaHIfJIM MIDKeT 6bITb npl1-
3HaHBcY,D;e6HoMIIopH,!UteH
2. fpa:m,!\aHe JlMelOT npaBO H3. IIOJI)"il'lDfe mJ1Jloro IXJMeIIrelD1H B c06cT-
BeHHOCTbBIIOpH,/\KenpJl!Bam3aIll1Jl:HUIJIbIX
IIpaBOHanpma'I'Jf3alUOO:HG1JIorocOXpaH$leTC$lTOr.D.a,Kor-
JJ;a B YCTaHOBJIeHHOM IIOpSI,!l;Ke npl13HaH He)\eiic'mI.rre.JII paHee 3aKJIIO-
'ieHHbJi.! ,IIorooop Ha npJl!06peTeHI1e JiU1JIOI'O IIOMeIl(eHJLfI B C06cTBeHHOCTb B
nopJl,!1Ke npl1BaTJl!3al.\l1l10
3ai1Myr .mI HOpMb!Ha3BaHHoro I1HCTI1TJ'Ta MeCTO B :m.Kp!fIJllJII1 OCTaHYT- 1
CJI B paMKaX OT,D;eJ1bHOro 3aI«tia - 3TO npaeo TeJlJt Mbi IIOJia£aeM, 

'ITO C TO'lKl13peHJl!H Q€JIecoo6pa3HOCTI'! fJ Y,1\OOcTBa IJI:AJIb.3OBaHIIH MecTO mo-
ra IDICTmyra B KQHe<lHOM C'IeTe B:m.K f'<:I. ECJIII! me 3alOOHQ):\aTeJIb CQ'ITE'T
HeoOXO)U1MbIMCoxpalD1Tb OT.r:\€JlbHO yrroM.lIllY'fbrl13a!l:OH, TO TOrN! CJI€)\OBa-
JlD 6w eMY yqecTb '" tl3.WJI! np€)J,IJOiKeHJl!H no 60JJee 'leTROM)' era H3.3BaHI1II1
ITplfmOOOM BapHame perneIDtil BOI1JXlca MHQI'He HOpMbII1 IIpHIllIIffibI <!Toro
3aKOH3 CJIe)lyeTCOBepIlleHCTBOBaTb.
J1'TaK, MbI I1bITaJrnCbJJ;OI\a3aTb, 'lTO npJl!BaTl13a.Ha1JJbIX OOM
flBJIJIeTCH npOMmIfJIOro npaBa BMeere C TeM B npaKTI1Ke rpam-
,D;aHe, ,I\3. JI cxpID..\J1aJIbHble yqpeiK,!\eHl1.F! Hepe;:uw ynOTpe6.muar TepllrnH
«npaBO», «npaBO rpam,11aH H3 I1pImaTIf3al.tI1JO .mI1JThIX IICMeI.l.\E;'fl» JI T.n
CJIe;:JyeT OTMeTIlTb, 'lTO JI 3aKOH I'occJ.iiiictro <Pe.I\€paL1l1I1 ,,0 IIpI1BaTl13a-
L\ID1 )KH.1!nlWioro 4>oH,(la B F'occJ.ri.jCJ«jj <PeAepaLl;l1Y1» ,If)E01JbIIJ WnpClKD Jf
MHoroacrreKTHQ ynarpefumeT TepMl1H . 3mT TepMl1H B ropIRIIpy-
,AeHIWIJI! IDIleeT ,IJ;Ba OCHOBHbIX CIIWCJDIiX 3Ha'ieHIDi. Pa3JIW13.eTCn: 1) npaBO
B rfi'beIcruE!H(N CMbICJle J1JII.1 ofu.€tmmHoe npaBO, T.e. BbIpa>KeHHOe B HOpMe
" oOeCIIe<leHlJOe IIpMHylJ;Ifl'elllHJii ctumti rocy.r:1<1J>CTB3. mme06Il3aTeJIbHoe
npaBmro IlOBe.u,eHl1H. Ror,A3. 3aKOHO)J,a:reiIb ,l\OIJyCKaeT BbIpameIDtil a) «Bcryn-
JleID1e B npaBa co6cmeHHOCTI1 Ha:001JIl1l1¥2 (IIpeaM6yJIa 31rnOlm); 6) B CJI.Y"!8.€
HapyureHII/H npaB rpH (CT 8 3aKoHa) OR liMe€'!' B BI1JIY npaBO B om,eK-
'TOM CMbICJle; 2} npaBO B  CMbICJle tfJllf, lfHa'le roBOpJ'l,
Cy&beKTI1BHoe npaBO, T.e. rapaHTIlpClBaHHbIe nptrny.r:v.rreJIbH)tl Cluri1: rocy-
)J;apcTBaB03M())j{HOCTIfnOBE')J;eID1.F!,npma,1:PJcy6"beKTy.
TaK, 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIh B CT. 11 aHaJII13JfPyeMJI'O &ROlla unpeJ\eJUleT, '1TO
Ipa:1K,/\aHl1HJ1MeeT npaBO Ha IIpJl!o6peTeHJI!e B Co6cTBeHH0CTb6ec-
nJIaTHo, B nop.ll,/\Ke npJl!BaTJl!3aqJl!J1, )f(JI!JJoro nOMeU,JeHJl!f! B roCY.llapc'I'ElftlHOM
t1M,YHJU1>IIIaIIhIIUvI>KI1JIJ1OM ljJoH,!\e» IIOCKD.IIbRJIpa:1K,/\aHl1H,
KaK)'RMbIBaeT 3 WIl€eT IIpaBO, TO B xapaKTepi13yeM1M 3aKD-
He }lKa3aID>I If upraHbI, ROTOpbIe ofuJ:3aHbI u6ecne'1HTb peaml3aJ..tlfiO <!Toro
npaBa. B Ka'leCTBe 06l3aHHbIX IDD..\ no nepe.!JWie rpaaHaM B c06CTBeH-
HOCTb :H01JIbIX nOM€l.I..IeHJl!i1 BbICTyf1am IOpJl!,lJ;Jl!'leCKMe JIJIlqa - TIfiYJlbHbiE'
mlfJIbRBJIJI!l[eHaiiMDJ:1aTe,TIeifmIfJIbIX
Cy6'beKTl1BHOe npaBO KIDK)\Oro IpaaHl1Ha Ha nptOOpeT€Hlle B c06-
CTBeHHOCTb 6ecnJIaTHO II nopRlI,Ke npJ.lBaTI13aW1J.1 :!KJ.IJIoro nOMell\eHJ.IR,
HaXO)J)lll.\erOCR B ,/\OMe rocy,/\apc1'IJel1IIDIU IfJIJ.I Mym:MGjJIJ.lll\-
HOro 1jJoH,(la. CTpOI'ITCR no MO;J;eJIJl! MeMetrra o6R3aTeJlbCTB€tIHoro npaao-
IJTHOIIIeInUI JI! MOmeT 6bITh OIIpeJJ:eJIeHO RaK YC'l3IIDB.IleHHaH 3aKOHOM Me-
pa  noae;J;eHJ.lR ynpaBOMO'leHHoro JIJ.Il[a. 3Ta Mepa MOJKeT
3aKJIIOI.JaTb' a) npaBOBYJO B03MIDKHOCTb COBE'pweHJ.lR .D.eiC'i'BI4i: CaMI1M yn-
paBOMO'i€flHbIMIDD..\OM. TaK, BCJ.lJIYCT.113aKOIJa Pocm:iictroi1: 4Jellepal[J.IJ.I
OnpJ.lBaTJ.I3aWIJ.IoroljJoH,(laBPOCCUIRait\;Z\O-
MY rpait\;Z\aHlrny  npaBO Ha n B oo6cTBemrocTh
l 6ecrrJIaTHO. B nopR,/\Ke npJ.lBaTI13aI11n1. :HGIJIoro I1IJMeIl[etnUI, HaXO)UHl[ero-
 cHBrocy,D,apcr&'llHUll'!JI!JIIf)!\tfJllfI.UHOM4>oHlIe,nOOTOMY

rp3JK.l\aHHH CaN pewaeT, Kor,n,a IIpH06pew.Tb B C06cTBeHHOC1'b 3aHl1Mae-
Moe JIM )!(.If.1l()e I1OM6l{('lIIfe JI KaK JICOOJIb3CIIIaTb 3'rY cofJcrBmHocrt,; 6) npa-
BOJJYIO B03MOmHOCTb 1pefXlBaTb yrrpaIJOMIJ"l€ .IDIl\0M OT 06l3aHHoro
Jrnq3. (.mrq) COBepweHHH HHbIX no 3aKJnU<lE'HJlK)JJ,oro-
BOpaonepella'le:m:J1JIoronoMelUeHlf.flJlnepena'le 3TOrono-
MeeHI1.f!.
J n03BO.il11eT c,!\eJIaTb BbIBU,!\ 0 TOM, '1T06bLJIO 6blHe COBceM
aepHbIM He BlfJleTb BIJYf}JeIIlEti CBJl3Jl! Me»w;y CMbICJIOBbIMl1 3Ha'iellJlRMJl! no-
HIm1i1: c:&beK'rnBHOe JI cym,eK'rnBHoe npaBO Ha npHBam3alC-OO >IG1JIbIX nOMe-
I..l.J2l1IDi JI He CMermmaTb n()H..llTIf.fl npaBOBOM JlHCTmyr «I1plfBam3aJ..tID1.mH-
JIbIXHIllI.' cnpaBOMHanpJl!BaTH3aWfIO:!KIfJIbIXnoMeHIili, BKaKOM
6bl3Ha'lem'IJI!OHO(3TOnpaBO) He0Cb6bl.

rna.a II I
nOHJlTI1E, KnACCI1C1>I1KAIII1J1
11 CI1CTEMA npl1HlIl1nOB
npI1BATI13AlII111
JKl1nblX nOMEIIIEHI1H
1. nOHTHE nPHHUHnoB nPHBATH3AUHH
)K1t1/lbIX nOMEli.jEHJ.1f1
IfcxuJ:\JI M3 TOro ampaBHOro nOJIomeHJ1H, cor.rraCHO RaropoM)' npJl!BaTI1-
3aW1R >K>1JIbIX nOMeIIleHllii, 3aHJ1MaeMbIX rpaiK,1\aHaMJl! If HaXO.!\Hll\l1XCH B
rocYAapcTBeHHOM If MrraJIbHOM :»Of.IIHOM clx>H,!\e, lIBJU1.eT'CJI mrrH-
'fYI'OM ROMILllffiClIlii aIpaCJD1 oro npaBa, JJ.JJJI 4xlPM)'nlfpOlIaIrnH
nOHHTillI JI BblHBJleHYIH CO.IlepiK3.HWI *fHIfl(Jlll cnpIDfWll1bl npl1B8TI133.-
J..tIDImHJIbIXIJVMel.\f2lllrli». no lUuneMYMHemno, JlC!10J1b3o-
BaTh 1I0CTIDKeHYIH EIJI'WI JI QI'1BJIIDIC'lWlecROIf HaYJG'! 0 CO.llePJKa-
IDII'I nomrr "npilllJJ;MfIbl npaaa» JI «npl1HIJ;YI!1bI rpamAaHCl«JfO npasa».
Mero}:pnonftIeCKaH poJIb TaKOfO nO,!I;XOlla onpelleJIlJeTCJI TeM 3Ha'leID1eM,
KOTOpOe B npaBOBbIXItCCJlE',ACEaHIIHX nplf,!\aeTCH pewemnoo6lW1X BOnpocOB
TeOPIDI!ta1(  6a3e  CYOCTIf 1IBJIell£1fl C IIay<lHO
u60cHOBaHHb!X IIOOJI[(I1I1. BJ1.JIelrnH nO.l{'lepKIfBaJI, 'lTO ".uK'I'O 6epeTCH 3a
'iaC"rHbIe BOllpOCbI 6e3 npe,D;BapIITeJIbIIIU pelll€IDtiI OOlW1X, TOT Ht'MJIHy€MO
6Yl1eT Ha KaM l.lffiIY 6ecC031IaTeJIbHO JJ.JJJI ce6:f1 "HaTblKaTbCIl» Ha m'J1 06-
ll1JI eso llpOCW» .
Je.me  fi: TeoplfJ.! npaaa, rpam,!\aRCKQ-
npmoBOii" :HG1IDIO-npaBOBOi.J: Ha)'Kn03BO.ID1T Ha OCHOBe BblHBJlemrn 06-
lW1XJlCPYH,!\3.MeHTaJ!bHb!Xnpt3H2IOCJB3TOi1l1cyqeroMCBCi1cT-
BeHHbIX illIC1'IITJTY npI1BaTl>13a'-\ill1 mMJIbIX  oro6eHoocTeH.l1aTh
xapaKTep!llCTI1KY I1pJil3HaKOB (OCHOBHbIX cBOiiicTB) npl1HOB IIpI1BaTI13a-
J.tI1I'I)KJ(JIbIX OTJIWI3JOl1tl1X J.1XOT.lIPyrnX, J1onpe,!\e-
JIJ1Tb pmamre nOHHTIffi IIptHWIIIbI IIpJl!BaTJo13BQ1D1 :m:J1JIbIX nOMeme-
HIlli.. B o6metl TeOpJl!JI! npaBa no,!\ nplfHWll1aMl1 npaBa» B O,!\HJI!X CJIY"!aRX
'1!e1<""B.f1.ncn.cp.CO't.T.15.C.36B
I 

00HJfMaJIJICb«rJlaBHb!e,p)'KOBOWill\I1eOIIpeJ\eJlHIOlIo5llt)'1O
Ii!Ha£1OoJIeeqepTb!COlllfaJIli!-
CTK'leCKoro npaBoBoro peryJillJXIBaHI1H  O'I1IIJllEHI1iiI, B
MJYrnX - «.OmpaBHbIe li!;!\eli, BblcTynatOlWleB KaqeCTBe I1C-
XO)\HbIXAJ!HnpaBaBQeJIOM2,B-TpE.'Tbt1X. -«OCHOBHble
Ha'iaJIa3, <arlIpaBllHE'li!;!\el1,KOTOpbleo6.n:a.n:aIOT,BbIC-
wej;jO!1epamBHOCTblO,«COCTaBJUl:IOTnpaBa,OTpa-
malOT 3aKOHOMepHOCm II YCTOH ,I:\aIDJOi1: 06nte<--rnemID-
4JoPMal..{!l!l1,  CB./!3aHbI C Cyw;HOCTbIO ,l\aHHoro TI1I1a npaBa".
BHKY,lIp$IBQeB B Ea'iecme I1pHHQ!BDB npH3HaeT  QeIDIOCTl1,
urpa>t<eHHNI'!B npaBe=r;. BBOBoi.J:IDl)'Ke ,I:\aHHOM)'BOnpocy
nocB./rrlUlJI! JI!CCJJe,I:J;() MHOrl1e )"I€HbIe. ITpaB,!{a, J1CCJIe,!!OBaIDU! 3TH BbI-
nOJllleHbI B 6o.m.rnetiMepE' IDl YJXIBHe  .mrreparypbL TaK, B.IT. fpH-
6aHOB,Hanpl1Mep, OTiiOCIfJI Knpl1HW111aMnpaBa «pyI«)BO.l\HU
COltI IIpaBa, ero OCHOBHbIe Ha'la.na, BIoIpamaKI.J.tU€ 06'beK-
Tl1BHble1, TeHJIeH4ID1li1nOTpeoHOCTII06lQeCTBa, onpeeJJR-
ecyw;HOCTb BCciirncT€MbI, OTpaC.ID'lWIJIJ1JJCTI1TyTa HBCJ1-
;rry JIX npaBoBoro 3a1qJ€IlJI€ffiffi 06lQ€06H3aTeJIbHoe 3Ha'ieIDre1' ri.
H 113 H3J!mKeHHbIX I1031IWm. npeoOJIeBaH TpYMOCTK IDl nyrn
onpeeJIeHHH  nOHHTI1J'! «npI1HlIl1!1bl npaBa WII1
rHCKO-npaBoBoronOHflTl1H <nptIllQ!UlbIIpIDK$lHcKOronpaBa, lilMeeT
CBOIi,l\OCTOJ1HCTBa 11 H€AQCTaTIG'l, HO IDlMJI He CTaBIITCH 3a,!!3.'la JIX,A€TaJIbHD-
ro paccMJ'I')J{'lO Jlj!H IDll1I€ro UCCJIe,l1OOaH!I npe.ACIaB.IUI(' Ha£1OoJIee
BaJKHbIM BbI,!I;eJDITb TO, 'lTO HBJIHeTCH 061W1M C T!)'l1U:! 3peHIDI 06lQ€i1: TeOpl111
npaBa Ii! rpam,!\aRCKo-npaooBOif, :»Gt.J1J1lQHO-npa:ooooit IDl)'K Ii! COOTBe'I'CT-
1  roo)'AaPcma.. npaaa I On! peJ\. H.r. AneKCaf\lV)OB. _ M IOp"'-'\. nT, 1974
:> BaCH/lbSeA.M. TeopHOCYAapcT""  f1P'I"". - M. IOpIo,o,. nT., 1983 C. 236
3rACBep.c.n",'cnpaBeA'l800To.oe<I!III.TOl<Or.l1!lB"ecKOl\nreparypeyrgef»K,D,a1()T
npl<HIJ,.In"'ABnRlOrCtlHa'lalla"'npa"""m.lpa>Kal()TeroCY\l1HOOTb,-rOnpl<:ITO"',"'1'I't...o,
HB)"Mr"'BaBTCA.'lTO:eTOCyw,HOOTbsroporOnopA.D,Ka,..oouKnpa80BblerJj)l'lHlJ,Hn"'Ta...
C8Monpaeo..t.IBfOT6oJ1ee06lJ.igee.!J.lolft09Ha"aJIO-...aTepMan.....B'''oAali...
(JnpeJlen"IOTCArnoco6o...""'Tepll8llbHbI.6nar,p"'"".
TII"BCelicoBOl<yllllocrn06u.recTaellll""'B.Q8.HHOMC_CJlenOAH""8/18Mllnpa-
B8..eronpH""'noacnnoHM8T"VTPO06llIetCTBa.ECJl
,""npH"",nbl M9HOeaTbH8'lan8MII. Toe.c.e8" l5y.D,BT npaBOnpB.D.BIlATb/:IBH'
I\I<lOoIlpllH""'n..rpa;«,lJ,aftCl<oronpasa.epe30<aTe/"0plllO""'""ano.."I5oTa.lleonpB.D.BlI9.
HIIAlc",..CBMm<Kr.A. npllll"",nblCCl!erO'£Jmrp8;l<,ll8HCl<Oronpa83.,AI1c.
.....-palOp"'-'\.H8YK.-CeBjJ.OJ10BC., 1985.C 71.)
4Teo"""rOCY.Q8.pcT""..npaaa/0m.peJ\.A.IiI.Kopone8"I1.C.SI"" -11 1'I'¥J-ooIleHIIH
rpa,a,corO\'H-Ta.m87 C.2I!S
5 KYAPAB""" B.H. rlpaBO  no"!U!elle -M.: ICpIl,ll. mfT., 1990. C. 99.
6rPHl5aHOaB.n rpaw..e,aHCKOerpaBO-mpaCJl"coaercKOrOnpa83"Co.
:OK()enpaeo/Or" pe,q.B.n.rJ)l<!iaHoB,C.M.KopHee" -M'!Opo<,q.nMT.
I

BeHHOMO:1KeT OTHOCJITbCHK OIIp2,AeJIeHmO ':npt1Hl!l1llb1 npJl!Ba-
TJ.I3a.qHH:»afJIbIX.
J1a BbllIlenpHBe,l:\eHHbIX TmteK 3peHIDI CJIe.n;yeT, 'ITO MHOrne Y"eHbIe-
IOpHCTbI'IepTOfinpl1HOBlIpaB3.C'lJ.'ITatOTm:pyKOBO,l:\JWJYIO
(onpe,l:\eJUIIOlIO'1O) pOJIb B pa3pa6OTKe, OOBep1I1eHCTI1C13 11 npt1MeHeHID1
npaBOBblX HopM. TaKOe I101KDtI8IHe npl1HOB IIpaB3.  Bo-
lIepBbIX, TeM, 'ITO caMO npaBO, a CJIe,!\OB3.TeJlbHO, 11 ero nplfHW1I1bI 06YCJlOB-
J1eHbI 6a311COM 06ll.\1'C'l'Ba, ero :JICUIOMII'Iecron.m YCTORMJ1. BamHble B :ITOM
lIJIaHe BblBO)J;b1 CO)J;epJK3.TCH B pa6crrax ill. 3HreJlbca, KOTopblti O'I'Me'-JaJI, 'ITO
BXO)1enpaBoBoropa3BIfIWIOCjIII\eCTBJUIeTCHnepeBOA«1X0T-
H:IIIeHJniBIqJtlenpl1lll.\lffiblI.B3aBJIC11MOCT110Tpa3JIWIJ1i1CIIOCo-
6aCTBaI1OTHOWeHl1fi
llpaBOBbIe 1lpl11ll.\lffiblHMelOT  pa3JIl1'D1e ill. SHreJIbC B 3TOi1
CBH3H OTM€'laJI, 'ITO '.Te:1Ke caMbie JIIO)J;H, KOTOpble YCT3HaBJIHBatOT 06Iq€-
CTBeHHble rtI'IIJIIEHIIJI coomeTcmeHHO pa3BI1TIfiO I1X MaTepuaJIhHOTO npo-
113BCJ,I:\C'"fB, coalOT TatoKe IIpIIlIQ1I11H, Jl)\et111 RaTeropl1Jll COOTBe1'CTBeHHO
CBOIfM  OTHoweID1.liM»2 TaKJIM 06pa30M, IIpIIHWIIIbllIpaB3.
HBJUIIOTCH WlK ofu.eKTHBHIJi,j WlTeropl>1eH, o6yc.noo.nemroti :Jl(()lJ()Ml'«'CKlf-
MIf 0'I'H0llleIIIDI TaK 11 cy&beK'lm3llOO: WlTeropl1efi,  OT BOJIJ1
JIIO,!\eJ::i, B I1X TeCHOJ::i. B no1IH(jj Mepe 3'I'JI! [J(JJI())I(eHII OTHO-
CRTCHKIlprraMmw:JfJIbIX,KOTOpbleOTpama-
!OT p;eficmyKJW;I1e OObeKTIfBHbI€ 33KOHOMepHOCTl1  pa3BI1-
T£1jJ nyreM 3aRpeIIJIeHWI J1X B npaOOBhlX HOpMaX, perYJll>1pyIOllVfX
npe06paaoB3.HJl/e {)THOlllemrn C06cTBeHHOCTl1 Ha >KI1JIble IIOMelI{eHKH, TO
eCTb OTpaJf\a1OT 3I«JHOMWJeCKIf 33KOHOMepHOCTif II€pl"OO.1J,a K pbIHO'lHbIM
OTHOllieHIDIM B:iKlLIII1II{lDti c4Jepe, xapaKTepHble P.JUI {)51I{eCTBa 3TOro lIept1-
0):13., H3.XO):(HT npeJIOMJIeHHe 11 KC:IIKpeTI13aQl1lO B IOpt1,!l;W!eCKofi rfxipMe 1lp11-
Ba'I'H3aQt1l'lmJ1JlbIX
.l\pyrofi xapaKTepHofi 'IepTofi IlpIDUl;vfi10B HBJIReTCH I1X HOpMaTl1BHO-Py-
 xapaK'rep, KOTOpblti npOHBJUjeTCJ'! B perYJll1pyJOlll.eM B03,!\E'ItC1'-
mfH Ha  (J!'H()lll('HIfH. Sro HOpMaTl1BHQ-pytWBO,!l,mI\ee lIMO-
HreHJl!e npoHl13bIBaeT 6o.nbllll1HCTBO HopM JIlHCTI1TJTa npI>1BaTl13a1.\11JII :1KI1J1bIX
 l13BecTHO, 'lTO HOpMaTI1BHbIti xapaK'rep IlpI1C)'ll1 npl1HaM
JD1llIb 1I0000000KY, IIOCKOJlbKY ()H!1 3aKp€llJIeHbI, OTpa:IKeHbI JI!Jill npoHBJIlll(}'f-
CJj B HopMaTIfBHo-npaBOBblX am3x, perYJll1pyKJlll;l1X :1KI1.ID1l1.\Hb1e OTHOwe-
mfH 1>1 IIpe.ltIIOJIaI' Bo-nepBbIX, 'ITO  B npt1HI.Iill1aX
I MijpKcK., SHrem,cr1J. CO" -2Iq/\.T.37C.4IB.
2M8po'cK_.3/!raJlbC""_Co"_2T.4_C_137_13B
3o6oe""'BHoro"eyfu.e""'.Horolln.DMHlII1naxcoaeTCKOrOrpa;t;/laHc.oronpa-
I13OCHOll3TenbllOlI"R.lI8Hal1l101<a3aHar.A.CllePAn".OMICM.Kr.An.oMHLII'n" l
COOeTCKOrOrpa>l(A<lHcKOrOrpaea:MOIDp3""'R._I(paCHORpcI<.I'i'¥\_BoKp3cH""",KOrO)IH_Ta, _
19B5. C. 17--36). -:!....

HOpMa'n1BRblefHHOCHT,IIIJ,II,JJe1KalI'ie3ycJIcmro-
MY npe.lI;I1ItC<UI,l\JUIrocy;IJ,apCTBeHHblXIf06I1teCTBemn.IXop-
raROB t1 qr.nnf3aQlrli npJiI pa3pa60TKe HopM JRJiIJIJiII1tH0ro npaBa, peryJII1po-
BaHJiIYI nOBe,!\eHJl!J! cymeKTOB npJiIBaTll3alUfi'I )f{JI!JIbIX nOMeIlleHJI!n If
npHMeHeHIDI npJllHOB npJiIBaTt13al\JI!J1 mlfJIbIX IICf>Iell\E'lDm B npaRTJ1<!ec-
Kon Bo-BTOpbIX, 'iTOBcenpaBOBble KOTOpble
BOI1JIOIlleHbI B 3aKOHe KaK npaBOBble HOpMbI, ,!\OJDKHbI CTpOro COOTBeTCTBO-
BaTb npaBOBbIM I1p1Hl\lmaM. Ht1 O.llJllH npt1Hl1,JiIll npJiIBaTJiI3I1:oo1JIbIX no-
MeIll€HJI!i1 He MOiKeT 6bITb BbIpa:?KeR BRe HOpMbI npaBa. 3TO C)'IlI€\.
npJiI3HaK npJllHOB.m060ro npaBa. IIpJIlHl\I'IffioI npJiIBaTJiI3aJ..t11t1)IG!JIbIX no-
Mm: HaxO.l\HJII1If HaXOmrr CB!Je KORKpeTH!Je  B OCROBOIIO-
JIaralOIllJ1XIq)MaTJlBHblXaKTax, TalG1:X,KaK: PocCHlicKOiitlJe-
./J:ep OcHOBbi :oo1JIJ1ll\H0ro 3aKOHo)\aTeJIbCTBa Coro3a CCP If COI03HbIX
pecny6JrnK,  KO.lleKC PCCPCP, 3aKOR Pocamc:IOOii cI>e.llepaIUlI1
«0 npJl!Ba'I'J.f3altlDf )f{I1JII1I1tHoro $)H,11a B Poccu!icJroii, 3aKOH
PoccIDictroi.i cI>e.llepal\JI!J1 Ofi OCHOBax 4Je.QepaJIbHOii on nOJIIm1-
Ki1>', HbIHe .lIencTB)'KJUJ;I1ij.H\K PtlJ, If B f»i,!Ie nOOpMaTI1BHbIX aKTOB'
BnpaBOBOj;j: HaYKeOTaBTOpbIn03TOMYnpJiI3HaKY
npaBOBon npt1Hl1,JiIll OTJIWIalOT OT Ha)"llfOl'O If  I1p1HIIIII1(E,
KOTOpble npe.llCTaBJUlIOT co50j;j: l1,!\elO, IfCIDJIb3}'€tdY B HaY'ffibIX IfC('JIe./J:o-
BaHl1HX I1JIJ1 npaBaJptlMeHlITe.YIbHlJ r. OTMe>ffiJ! npJiI3TOM, '1TO
rIOCKC.Jn:£y OHI1 He HaXOAflT CBoel'O 3aKpe!JJIeHJiIJ! B npaBOBbIXtropM8X, TO co-
omeTcmeHHO If He l1MelOT IJOpMa'I'HBKJI'xapaKTepa2.
c.ne.n;yKJIl\I1Mnpl13HilRUllnpJllHOBnpaBalfnpJllHOB
npifBaTJI!3al\JI!J1 )f{WJbIX nOMeilleHifn (noMIfMO H83BaHHb!X BbIIlle) fiBJIJlR
IfX C'ra6I1JIbHOCTb. KaTeroplliI CTa6I1JIbHOCTJiI eT 0 TOM, 'ITO
3TOlIpO'lHoe,)'C1'OWmBoe,nOCTOffHHO.llencmyKJW;eeOBO-
,I1flll.\€e noJICOKelII£ 3TOo6ocHOBaHHO, nocKOJIbKyo-npaBOBbI€ OTHO-
weHI1fl BqeJIOM, paBHORaK t1aJ'Howemm nonpJl!BaTI13al.\l1l1:Ji01JIbIX nOMeIIle-
HI1nlfCOOTBTBeHHO peryJIJlpy<Oll\I1e JiIX3aKOHbI, 06oope.uent'HHOti
CTeneHbIO Hel13MeHHOCTI11f CTamlJIUIlX'TIl, a CJI€)IoBaTeJIbHO, t1 npJllHl\I'IffioI,
3TJ1!OTRoweHJiIHIf3aKpeI1JleHHblel1JIJ1B3aKO-
Hax, COO'II!eTC'l'B€ IfMelOT aJ'HOC£1TeJIbHO npo'lHbIii: t1 ycmti<rn:BLIii xapaR-
Tep. CTa6IfJIbHOCTh»re npJllHOBnp£1BaTI13awrn:)f{IfJJbJXnOMeIlIeID1iiinpo-
.HBJIfleTC.H B TOM, 'iTO ORI1 npO,QOJIiKalOT .IIei1CTBOBaTb He3aBI1ClfMO OT
tl3MeHeHJiIJI, ,l\OIX!JIH€lIIf I1JII1 w:.KJIKNemm J13 :HOfJIJiIlltHoro 3a.KOHO,I18TeJlb-
I
'e... >t8np"Mep'llp..epflOenOO_MC"'.uILJ.IHorO"J1i.BPC<!>CPII
1'10KYMeHT..nOI1JJHII3T3allOlH>mn",,"PC$CPC6,!IiIHCrnJyT
3KO>fOMHKI'Iha<ieMXO"'CTBa.I1" KJI,na...pW1OBa.-M. 1991
2CM. KpacaB'''KooD.A.n'''''''''eOOBeTCKOroIJl'l'''A'!HCKoronpaB3'Y400HHKJJ,nHBy.JOII!
Or" 1JI!J\.D.A.I<paca""KOB -M:B..cw""IUKOa. 19B5, T. I.C 28.

C'J'13.3. ar,AeJIbHb!X npaBOBbIX HOpM'" O.n;HaKO He CJIe;r.yeT C'illTaTb, 'ITO IIpI1H-
wmhlnpIfIIaTJ.l3aqJ1J.1:»afJlblX -3TOI\aKJ.Ie-TOnQC'1'MHHhIe, pa3
IfHaBcer,AaycraHoBJleHHhIeBcBOeiii:IIJ.JKM\:eIDm.no.A06HO
3aCThIBlIDlM,AOrMaM..H\mmIe BK01'OpbIXKOpeHHTCHIIpI1H-
wmhl nplfBaTJ.l3aqJ1J.1 :HOIJlhIX I1OM.'nl, pa3BI1BaIOTCH " If3M€IlS!l(Y!'C C
paaBIITIfeM " lI3MffietDIIeM :JI({)H)M>1'IECKJIX OTHollIeH11iii: B OOlIleCTBe. COOT-
BeTCTBeHl!OlfMMOryr pa3B1fBii'I'bCR}I eH.lfl'bCH" IIpJ.lHWfl1hI IIpI1BaTJ.f3a-
Ql1J.I .mwJIh!X llOMelIlemri1: WlK B reopeTl1'l€'CKOM IIJIaHe (pa3paOOnlli callrnx
IIOHHT11iii:), TaK }I B IIp8IITWI€CKCI' IIJlaHe (3at\penJlemre B HopMax npaaa).
llpJ.l3TOM CJIe)1ye'l" nOJJ;'iepKJIYTh, '1TO B  IIJ13He}'MeHhllIemre
po.IDI O,AHJ.lX npl1Hu;vmOB 111 yraepJK,!\eHMe .n;pyrnx npl1Hu;vmOB B nepJllo,!\ nepe-
XOAaKpbIHO'IHhIMB>K11.Tll1lI\Hoi1cclJepeBC1pe'lae1'}lelIleHeJll3-
Ue)K!lO 6y,Ae'l" BCTpe'l3.Tb ronpc:YfII!!JIe BeJ\bB:;rror  nepJllo,!\
-rpe6ye'l"CH JlOMKa CJI))KIfBU]JIXC crepeonUlOB, IIOJiHhIi1 0TKa3 err a,JJ,MJnnJ:-
::::=:==::====::eo'!\o-
PaccMOTpeHHbIe craOJl!JIbHbIe HOpM3.TJIIBHO-pymBO.IJ.H1IIJI nCJJJroKemrH
IIpJ.lc C'8MI:I1!: :m:J1JIJ.I1IIHO-npaBOBOH J\eiicTmtTe.1IbHocf (00 He MhIlllJle-
HlfIO), 4xIPiii:CH nOJ\ I!03,I:t=tkTBHeM COq!1aJlbHO
4>aK'l'Opoa If O WI'It"CTBeIllIbI oco6emJocTI.f npaBoooro pery-
JDfJXJI38ffiffiClI"QlIIpyIIIIbI06II1eCTBeHHbIXOTIIOllIeHMi1:nonpl1Ba-
TJ113aqIDl)KJf./JbIX
YKa3aHlIbleBbICT.YTIaIOT()(H(JB(jjinpaRTI1'IeCKdiJ\esrreJlbHo-
ern npaBO'l'BOp'-J€'CKJIIX IJPG!IRJB. pery.IDITOpOM ID!eJIetnffi cy&beKTOB OTIIo-
llfiJHjfnonplfBaT}l3aQl1J.1)ID1Jib!XnOllIelIleHIfnpaBO-
nptlMeHlfTeJIbIIbIX opraHOB. C MecID1X iIJ3I'IqIfii nptlHI1lflIbl
npI1BaTJll3aI..(JI!H)ID1Jib!XCJIYJK3.THaJ\JleJK3.1IIJI!MII!OpJ.leHTIfJJar.rn:
I1pJ.l: 1) pa3pa60TKe" I1pIII.RTHH HOBbIX )KJ.I.1nflI\Ho-npaBOBbIX aKTOB; 2) pe-
ryJIIipOOaIIIIIfB3alfr\D)'I'HlIllelIlliicym,eK'l'OBnpHBaTlf3aI.[IfH)KJI!Jlb!XIIOM€-
tii,3)
llpmeJ:leHlIWi aHaJIJ.13 n03BOJIJIeT onpe.n:eJIJ1Tb IIptfilI\UIIhl npl1BaTI13a-
QID1:1KJ1JIbIX  WlK CTa6J.1JlbHbIe HOpllIaTJIIBHo-pYKoBOWIlI\l1e no-
JlroI\eH£1H, 3aIfJlJ.larJXOO€HlIbI€BOClDoopM3-
TKBHbIX aKTaX, a Ta10Ke B :m:J1JIJ.I1IIHO-npaBOBbIX HopMax. Chrn BbIp=
OObeKTl1BHble 3aKoHoMepHOCTJI! pa3B1fTIfH c.rrHillIeHJfii IIO npl1BaTl13aqlftf, B
1 CIIe.Q,YeTOTMe'MTb, 'lTOCQI!pe-,npfIIm<38.o"aPocc>1co<opaUl' .onpMB!IT\13!1"
IIMM """"LIIHOro cj:>oM,aa. Poccoc..o ct1E:o.epaw." HE!rO (e 23.12.1992 r. 00 15.06.2006 r.)
JJ,eeflTbpa3""0CW1Cbl13Me1<e"WI.Q.o,MS/;03THI<S...e_>tI1HeHOCW1MOCHOeooonaratOu.&erO
><apaKTepal1He...eHllllca.....np"""T>l3allL'>KIIIlbIXnO""'llI"HI1
2CM ElH.8W9S8BACoL!I"M"CT""9Cl<Oenpaaoaoarocyl18pc18OIIColiMa- 1
n"CT>NeC1<Oe npaBODOe rocyAaPCTDO_ -M."I'Ia<\-fIOI1HCT'"j'TarocYAaPCma"npaoaAHCCCp. rt"\
1989.C 5. -:5t...

COOTBeTC'l1ImI C KcrropblMJll CTpOIITCH HOpMa"rnBHaH 6a3a :HG1JIYjIWIO-npaBO-
BOro pery.mrpOBaHIf$I omowemrn no IIpI1BaTIf3aIV1t1 :»af.llbIX ,
perIIIJBt',[\eIIJUcy&beKWBnpl1BamaaqMJ1:IKIf.IIbIX
I1npaBOI1p11M€HeHJ1e
nonpeJ\eJIeHi'le,BbllIOJIHeHHoeBllli{)i:j:J1,KaKJIr060e
onpeJ:\eJJeHHe, B aOCTpaKTHoif if>opMe, BO-nepBbIX, OTpa:1KaeT 60raTCTBO t1
MHoroo6pa3l1e ero  njJH3H3ROB; BO-BTOpbIX, B 
Mepe nO.w.ITmKlfBaeT Halill13HaHJl!H 06 HCCJIe.rr.yeMOMHBJIeHHI1 11, HaKOHeq,
8-TpE'TbI1X. BblCTynaeT 0CII0BGIi: ,I\3JlbII€iiwer BblRBJIeHJl!H If pa3B1I1HH
)'Ka3aHHbIX3Haffim
05IIV1H nJXIrpecc HayqHOro 3HaHIDI If pa:mlITlfe SCecropOHHHX B033pe-
Hl1iiopeaJ!bll)iI,1J;.o;eJlaKITBCe6Mee"3y-
'leHMe IIpI1Hu;vmOBIIpI1BaTl13arvm mIfJIbIX IDMe1IJ"IDIif BO B3ffilMOCBJl3lf tfX C
 OTHOllIeHJ1RMH, a TatoKe C :IKJI.ffi1Il1HO-np8BOBbIMJil HopMa-
MIf, onocpelJ.Y1OMI>1If peryJIl.1pyro IIptMeHeHUt' B
cclJepe.HHbIenpl1Hl\IfIIbIHeHBJJJlIO'l'CRr.3aCTbIBlIDIMYIKa-
Teropl1RMY!, a npe,!\CTaBJlfflO1' co6m1 cra6JtJIbHy<O J1 pa6o<iyKJ rI.IUITIIiiHyJo
OCHOB}' AJUlreiicrmrn :m:J1JIJ.IlWiO-npaBQBbIX HOpM, 06pa3ySl IIpO'ffibllf Mexa-
HI13M npeo6pa30B8HID! OTHOllIeID1i1:  B >KILI!J:nW«:If cQJepe.
l13Y'1eHJl!enpl1HnoBnpIfIIaTJ.l3aW'lIf)!{I.fJIbIXBoB3alfMocM31f
CYJW.3aHHbIIIWHBJIeIDIHMJl!,CIIJ31IQ1dfB3al,aHeI13OJD1-
POBaHHO, BRe HX ,D,IDfaMl1KI1 rI03BOJ111T BblHBIfI'b BH)"IpeHHKIO ,IJ,JIlarreKTIlKY
t1XMcTmm"6MeeTO'lHO ycrmIJBIlTb, BbICT)'TIaIOTJII18HaJIJ13J1PY-
eMble IIpHHl\IfIIbI qeM-TO C8MOC'I'OJ!'I'eJIbHbIM B PH.DY )'Ka3aHHbIX KaTeroplfH
IfJIIf, Hanpon1B, npe;QCTaBJIJtKlTco6oii:cne}lxCOC'rOftHI.re.
npllHlVlIIbl npuB3'J'll3al\1U :IKWILlX nOMfllf'HIIii: If OTHOlllelllfH no npu-
BaTII2ImJlbIX
OmolllelUffino I1pl1Bam3aJ.tl1I1)KIfJIbJX I1CIIIellJ.'HIrliKaKTaKOBbIe,lfnpu-
MbeKHI1Mnpe,!l;IIpI1Ba'flfOllllbIeIfIIOCJIenpI1BaTIf3aI1IIOHHbIt!OTIIo-
llletIWI OOpa3ylO!' IIpeAMe1' npaBOBOro perymlpOBatIWI npaBOBOro
IfHcrlfTyraIlpI1Ba'rn3aJ.tl1l1m.11JIbIXJ1MeIrnore
OTHUIIetiHHC)'llIe<:TBeHHbIMOOpa30MBJIIfHIO'I'Ha 1IC'UJ)J;HbIX
npe.n;rDCLIJDK. KO'I'OpbIe JIemaT B OCHOBafUllf npl1HnOB I1pI1BaTJf3a.WfIf
)KIfJIbJX IDIit IIORBJIelille 3TIfX OTHOllIeHI1H om.eKTIlBHO 1pe60BaJIO
IfX ynopH,!\O'IeHJI!H If npaBoBOro pery1Il1p0BaHI1.f!. 3aKOHO):l3.'I'E'JIb, C03):(3.B3.H If
nplflillMaHnpem,fle Bcero3aKOHPoccmiCI«ni1 «OnplfBaTIf3a'-!lflf
JKI.fJIJ1lqHOI'O iJxJH,!\a B I'occMikKOO: cI>eJlI.' JI! HeKO'I'OpbIelijJyrne, CBJI-
3aHHbIe C IDiM 3aKOHbI, 3a1qX'IIIUI JI! OTpa3JI!JI B IDiX He TOJIbKO HOpMbI, HO }I
nplfHl\IfIIbIlm.I1JIbIXn1.J1xCyrn;HOCTbCOCTOIITB
1'OM, 'ITO 6.rJaroJlapH 11M ocy:rn;eC1'BJIHeTCH npec{pa3oBaHJIe rocy,!\3.pC'I'BeH-
HOHIf M)'ID1'-!IfnaJThHOfI iJxJpM co6cTBemJoconl B '1acrH:y1O 4IoPMY c06C'I'BeH-
I HOCTIfIpIDfl:,lJpHHa3aHlfMaeMbleI1M1f>Kl1JIbIeB
 yI<a3aHHbIX>KIfJIJfU<HbIXQJoH,!\3.X.

,[(eJlO,O)J;HaKO,HeTOJlbKOBTOM,'1TOreocHoBOi1
npl1BaTlf3aq1>11>1 )KIfJIW noMeI.l.leHlrn, I>1X, TaK Cl\a3a'T'b, nepBOOCHOBOIt BhI-
C'l)'IffiKIT peryIDIpyeMbIe npl1Hl\l1IJaMl1 npl1BaTI13a4lfl111 >KI1JIJ1IW1o-npaBO-
BbIMJI HOpM3.MI1  0THC.W€HI1H no npeo6pa3OBaHJOO OTHOWe-
IDIifcc6::.-rBeHHoc-IB:m:JI1IIfiltHOtiCq,epe.f.rraBHO€BTOM, '11'O1eCH
BHe npeJIeJKJl! )f(J1.ID1Il<HO-npaECtBOtt Marepl1l1 )'Ka3a.HHble OTHOllIeHl1H BbI-
C'l)'IffiKIT cpaK'l'OpoM, OnpeJJ;eAAlOll\IfM COCTb JI BOJIeBOe CO;!\epiKaHUe
mJ1.1I11I.l.IHO-npaBOBbIX npl1Hl\I1IJOB, a TaIOKe OfueK1'OM ifc'rurn no-
CJie;J;HJIX, 3TO n03BC1JIHM' yr'T'b, 'iTO OTHOWeHI1H, COCTaBJIRlOe
npe):1MM' :»GIJIlfI.l.IHo-npaBOBOro perym1pOBaHllJl JlHCTIfryTa np
JI BbIpa:maeMble 11M npmn.[lmbl cymecTB)'KJT B TeCHmi opraHK'JeOOCJii B3a1f-
MOCBH3i1, B3aJIMO,lletic-rBJ1II!. f.ny60KO npaB 6bIJ1 4I.3t!reJlbC, )1TBep:)K,!J;aJ!,
'ITO eJlC'l'Opll'K'CKOE HBJIeHlfe, ROJIb CKapo OHO BbI3BaHO K )f(J13H1f npwulHa-
MI1,1\pyroro nopH,lJ;K1i, B KOHe'IHOM 111'O!'e aoc:tIIJMK'J€CKIIMII, TYT:1Ke, B CBOIO
O'lt'pelJ,b, CTaROBIfTC.R atmmIIbIM cpaKTOpoM, MOme'!" OKa3hmaTb 06paTHoe
Bm,I:\eilc1mft' Ha OKpyiR1IIOIl\YIO cpe.n:y JI Ha nopo)J;I1BIill1e ero IIpf'IllHbI» 1.
TIpl1Be,!\etlHOe nOJl()jf\effif€' IfMeeTCTBeHHO€ 3Ha'leHlfe.AJIH BblHBJleHIfJ'I
 Mem,n,y npe.qMeTOM .mIfJIIlliVlO-npaBOBOro peryJDipOOIDIIIH 1>1
npl1Hl\l1IJaMl1 yl\a3aHHOro pery.!DlpOB1lffilH, KopeHJIIWl!MlfCfl B HOpM3.X ffij-
CTIITYTanpIfIIaTIf3aq1f1f)f(J1JIbIX VRa3aRHa.RMO-
:IKeT xapaKTeplf30BaThCfl COOTBeTC'I13HeM, BbI3BaHHbIM onpe,!\eJlelllIoro po-
1Jli CXO.IlCTBClM, 6J1J13OCTbtO JIX IlpIpQD.l>I.
l1MeHHonp1ThI np.ma'I1'GU.[I1)KIfJIbIX HIIIf COOTBe'l'CTBytOT
xapaKTepIf3)'eMbIM 06II1ecTBeHHbIM OTHOllieHImM, OHJII np.:J:ft:XI:JWIT OT yl\a-
3aHHbIX 0'l'HCIlHG1ti If 3aBI'ICJIT OT H!IX.. CTaJIO 6brrb, OHI'I HOCHT 3aIMCIIMIiii: If
 xapaKTep DT peryJllfPYeMbIX JlMIf 06II1ecmelllIblX OTHOIlle-
HI1i1, HO OHl'! K HJIM He CBO)J.lfMbI If He TOiK,!\eCTBeHHbI JIM,
IIpI1HL.[I>1IThlnpI1BaTl13a4lfl1)K1fJIbIX, KaKCYI.l.IHOCTlibleHOp-
MaTIfBHo-p)'KOBO,!J)lll.[l1e IIJ.JImKeHJ1II, - JIJ1llIb pe3)'JIbTaT llpOllIe,l{lllero 'Ie-
pe3 C03HaHl1e 3aKOHOI!1ITeJ1fI If nOJIy'ii1BIIIero onpep;eJleHHO€ UCMbiCJIJlB1IHJf€
If'\QlIjX'1\M€'llmaIDle>>OIIbrraOTlIOIlI'IDliinorrpe06pa30Ba-
HI1tOBC4>epe. YKa3aHHO€mpa*eHJlle
HeJlb3J'! Ha3BaTba6cOJIlOTHOJ1JIJI3epKaJIbHbIM, nOCKOJlbKY
C4JopM)'IDIpOB1IIIlIbI€If 3aKpellJIeIIlThIe 3aKoHO)\aTeJleMB coomeTcTIJYlOx
HOpMaTJ1BHbIX aKTax nplfHW:llThI np1fBaTJ13aLlIfJ:I}fGfJIbIX nOMeIIleHl1i1 - npo-
TJYl'!:frocY):1aJX.'Tl3€lIl1OOBOJIJIJ1pe3YJIbTaT1JIX.'TK
Ib::eeOC)'IIleCTBJIHeTCHlfnpeo6pa30BaHVleax."ffiBJDIKIIlXnpe,!\-
MeTO-npaBOOOJOlfHc-rlflYI'anpl1BaTIf3aLtlfI'l:»GlJlbIX B
TaKifenpillI.l.llfIIbI, tprnaHJft', QJoPMY.lll1pIIJlliIIf113aRpEfi1E1I11€BHOP-
MaTIfBHbIX aK'l'aX KO'I'OpW Ha3peJlO, IIOJIyUIJIO BbIpaJ'KeHHble B o&beKTIfB-
'M;jJJKcK.,8wem.cI1J.CO" -2-el<3Jl.T.39.C.84.
I w

HbIX ilJopMax, a caMJI IIpIDfW:IIIbI CTaJIM U!1D::IfTeJIbHO C8MOC:TOJITeJIb
.RIIJEHIUIMJ1.06.na.II,aJl3TOj;j:0'l'H0CWT"e.!InpJ.IH-
rIbInpI1BaTlf3awrn:naf.IIbIXrliCIIOCOfiJ:llaxTIlBHOTb
Ha I€ OTHOWeHJ1H, peryJDIpyeMble HOpMaMJI 3atwH3. Poccnii-
CKOi141eJJ:epaJ1 «0 npl1BaTI13alllfi1 :mI1.mfIWJoro 1lJoH,!W II Poca1lirnoii 4>e-
epal!Im 11 HeKOTOpb!Ml1 .QJJYI1'!MJI! HopMaTl1BHbIMJII aKTaMJ.f.
YKa3atIHoe  06HaPYmHBa.€'I' Ce6R J];BORKJIM cnuco6oM. Bu-
nepBbIX, np I1pI1BaTI13aW1Jll:HGlJIbIX nOM npeorrpe.r:\eJIIDOT
B03MOJKHOCTbJl!,lleHT€.JIbHJCTIIcyfu,eK-
'TOO np1If 3aIDIMa€MbIX tfMIiI)lG!JIh!X I1CM.'l.l.J;'flI1Ii nyTeM }"!aCTI1II B
npaBOBb!X C)\eJIKaX no ocyrr<eC'l'BJleHl1lO )'K1l3aHHOi1 I1pI1BaTl1-
3a. Bo-BTOpbIX, :HQ.fJUnpaEOBbIt' npIDfWI!IbInpl1BaTJI3a:HGIJ!bIX
ID CnOCOOCTB}'IO'I'{.'TIllD3JIeID1 J.fpl3BHTIOO HQBbIX pa3llOOlfJlHOC-
Tei1 06II1eCTBeHHbIX 0THCIIleHJrli, HanpJ1Mep, no peMOtrry}j OIDIIO
nplfBa'Ill3lipOB<lllHffO mKrlbflM T.n
npllllWlllbl DpuBaTII3aQ1III am.lIbIX  If )!GIJllIU(HO-npaBG-
Bble HOpMbI OJ:UKIIDIeIIHOro UHC"IUTJ"I1I.
AHaJllf3 m'11X R'a:reroplfif II acneKTe B3aJ1I'OOCBSI3I1 n03BOJUIeT BbUIBl1Tb
{)6e O)\HOpo.n;HbIe  If pa3JIWlllble xapaKTepHble 'lepTbl aHa.IDI3If-
pyeMbIX JmJIeHJ.M IIpIfHL>1In,l nplfBaTJ13alllfl1 )lG(JIbIX n J1 »G:!-
O-npaBOBble HopMbI IrncTlf'IYT8. npl1BaTlGlQlllf :m:J1.IIbIX IIOMeIIleIDli1:
cyw.eCTB)'KYI' II TecHOM e)\IIHC'I'Be, rrpep;CTaBJIH!OUI.eM co60i1: OPr8HlI'JeCKyJO
B3a11MJCBJI3b " meIDfe.QJJYI' B 1\Pyra. XapaKTepl13yeMoe
e)J;l1HCTB006Hapce6HB'iOnpe,Qi',.llffiHJCTtIYI\a3aHHbIX
Ka-reropldi, nOCKOJIbKY OHI13aKpelUleHbl B emOM OC1roOOf1U.ILar3IOllPI HOp-
ManlBHOM npaBOBOM 8KTe - 3aKOHe I'oc'CIu1c:E:Jii ep «0 npl1BaTI1-
3aql1J1 oro 4x:JH,!\a s PocamCKCii 4>e)\<paI1, a TalOKe HaXO)\f!T
np:mBJIeID1e If OTpaiKeHl1e B HeKOTOpbIX )lpyrlfX HOpMaTl>1BlfuIX 8KTaX
.AHa.1rnaI1pyeMOe e)\I1HCTBO 06HapyifGlBaeT Ce6R t1 B TOM, 'ITO npl1HIJ;t1IIbI
npt1BaTJl38Q!m :!t01JIbIX n3aKpeIIJ!JnOTCH, BbIpa»CalOTCfllf OTpa-
.'!KaIOTCH KaK caMl1 no ce6e, aBTOHOMHO, TaK If B :!t01JIJ1lltHo-npaBOBbIX HOp-
Max, npWleM He TOJIbKO e)J,IIHWJHNX, HO TIUQtre If S J1X COBOIt)'IIHOCTtL TaK,
eCJllf nplfHlJ."fI BOCTif nplfBa'IH3al:tlm 3aKpelUleH B C'T'. 11 3aKOHa
PoccJ.rl.iCKOiii4>e)\epaIJ;lfl1 «0 npI1BaTI13aIJ;lfl1oro 4x>H)18. B Pocrni1-
CKQi1 4Je)\epal..\l1i1>', KCTrOp3Jf  co60i1 o6bJ'IH)'IOHOPMY npasa,
Tonp6eCIlJla'I'HOCTI1IfOC'T'Ifnepe,l\a'll1BCo6c'I'BeHHOCTb
rpa:1K,1\aH 3aHl1MaeMbIX m.rn :!t01JIbIX nOMelI\etmi1, HaXO)I)IIIIIfXCH s rocy,1\ap-
CTBeHHOMt1:»GLIIJ1lltHOM4x>H.1\e,3a1qJ€JI1I6JI,(BCT.lpac-
CMa'IptlBaeMoro 3aKOHa, B KCTropOM Ha 6a3e yKa3aHlfuIX nptlHl1lfIJOB )laRO
JJeraJIbHoe HOpMaT!1BHOe te ca"lOn nplfBa"rn3aQm1 :»GLIIblX no-
M€ll\€ID"'-
I IIo)106Horo pO,1\a,AeHTe.JIbHOCTb npaBO'I'BOp'iecKoro opraHa MOJKeT 6bITb
'li 0'I'H€Ct;fi0l K TeXHI1KO-tM  xapaKTepl13yeMoro 3a-

KaHa. 3To CBlJ,D;e"feJIbCTBeT, 'ITO eJIeHHOe t?)J;J1HCTBO B BJ1):\e MOHOJIHT-
HOro CIIJIaBa m1IIHo-npaBOBbIX npmttIlTIOIIlf HOpM n03BOAAeT JIM COOT-
BeTCTBoBaTh06II1eMY3IWlII\finOJIIDKeIDIKl, BbIcryIIaThBH)lTpeHHe
COfJlacOBaHHbIM BbIpaJKeHJI!eM, t\OTOpOe He OIlpOBepraJJO 6bI caMOfO ce6.R B
CIfJIYBHyrpeHIDIX npoTI1BoJ')e'illi1:. ECJlI1 e;urncmo JI COfnaCOBaHHOCTh CJI!CTe-
Mbl :1KJI!JIYIoro npaBa C BIIeliIHetI CTOpoHbI npoJ!BJI.ReTC.R B BJ1):\e CI1CTeMa-
TJl3allJl!lf ero Ha ypoBHe HOpM, OObe;D;lfltlK'Ml;lX B npaBOBble MHC'TWIJ'Tbl, TO C
BHYTpeHHei1:- B TOM, 'iTIJ:xrn.JII1IIIlIO- HOpMbl1flI.'TIlT)"ff IlpI1BaTI1-
3al.\l1l1JKJ1!JlbIXKaK6bI <IJO,J:fD1H€HbI IlpI1BaTJI!3a-
J..tI1I1:»G1J1bIX ni..Cn:e1WBaTeJIbHO, BIlJI'I'P€HlE€e,!tJI!HCTBOJKJl!JIl1II1-
HO-npaBOBbIX HDpM, peryJlJllpy1OlI\I1X OTIIOllieHIDIno np1JII JKJI!JlbIX
nOMeIIleHl1ii, 06ecne'D1Ba€TCJ'! 6naro.u,apJ'! I1pI1lJl..c,maM.
KaK cIIpaBewnmo OTMe<iaJIOCb B Ha)"lHbIX pa60Tax no o6II1ei1: TI'lipID1
npaaa, BH)"I'peHHJUf COf.nacOBaHHOCTh npaBa, OCHOBaHHaR Ha ero :3ROHCiM»-
'1ecKOMJlCaJIbHO-{JOJllITlf'1eClOCl\leHCTBe, BbIpamaeTCJ'!Be)J,JI!HCTBeero
IlpJI!HIl;JI!IIOB .. IIpl1llI\l1lIbI 1Ip1Ba'I'll3aIUlJ( :!KI1JIbIX IDMell1€HJnI, KaK JI :Ha1-
O-npaBOBble HDpMbI, OTpamalOT Cyw;HOCTh If 3aKOHOMepHOCTh pa3BI'I-
TIIJIpery.ru1pyeMbIXtlHCTJl'lyT'Ci\'>KIf.III1lI\HOronpaBa06II1ecT-
BeHHblX 0'IHJllJeIIIIi1, HO OHl1 B OTJIJ1'IJ1e OT :!KIfJlllI1Ho-npaBOBbIX HOpM
BbIpaiKalOT60JIeerny601\OronoPJ'!;r:tKa,BClfJIYqeronocBo-
eM)' CO,!\epiKaHl1lO lllI1pe JI eM'le 3TJI!X HDPM, a nOCJle,!\ID1e lllI1pe no CTPYKTY-
pe JI paaHoOOpaaHee no CO,!\epiKaHl1JO,
IIpJI!Hl1ITaMIlpI1BaTt13a'-tJl!l1)K1fJlbIXIlpJl!cyw,a06Il.\ClJ'!ofu,e-
JJ;lfHffiOIl\W'I JIX OCHOBa. TBKOti: OCHOBOi1: HBJUreTCH HOpMaTJl!BHOCTh. IIpI1Hl\I1-
lIb! nplfBaTt13al\JI!If :»G1JIbIX nOMeIIleHMfi HBJU!JO'T'Cf! peryJlRTOpaMI'I I1IJI3l;l\e-
Hl1J'! cy6'beKTOB npJl!BaTJl!3B4JI!i'I JKJI!JIbIX nOMeIIleHl1M IDIllIb IJOC'IDUbK)',
nOCKOJlbKY B HID: 3aJJIDKeHbI  HDpMaTI'IBHO-
IDJIomemm, caMJl! OID! (IlpI1Hl\Jl!IIbI) 3aKperuuDO'I'CH, npoHBJUIlO'l'CH t1JlJI! OT-
paiKalOTCH B :!KIfJlllI1HO-npaBOBbIX HOpMaX JlHCT11T.)'TB IlpI1BaTJl!3al.\l1l1:Ha1-
JIbIX nOM€ll\t;tiIDi.. Y'IaCTl'le xa I1p11llI\l1110B B lIpaBOBOM pe-
ry.mIpOBBHlDl OTHOllleHl1t1 no I1pI1BaTI13Bl\1111 .1KI1JIblX IIfJMel..l\€Hml
06ecne'lJ1BaeTC.R 6.rraro.ABP.R HDpMaTJI!BHOCTJI!, KCTrOp3Jf 06.na.a;aeT 6o.nee BbI-
COKl1M 0606Il.\ClIOM  no cpaBHeHJl!lO c HOpMaTllIlHOCTblO KOH-
KpeTIIblX)KI'IIDIlI\HO"'flPBBOHOp..
1 eM Anel:ceeaC.C.06L11'1eTeapeTM"ecKI1e,-,poOOeMbJCI1CTeMbJCOIIeTCKOronpaoa.-M...Ib..
CIOPMo,o.aT,I961 C.3,CJoJJI(e.CrJJYI<IYPaCOlleTCKOrOnpaBa.-M IQP'll\.I1MT,I975.C.54.
2I-1aTOdicT!IIITI!I1bCmo,'iToI1jJMHl\Mn",npaBa"npa"oBbieHOPM",00J1HeO)lllOnOJJ!lAl«l"
Bo01HOP""""sflOCTblO.cnpaeE\!ll18000pal!l8JlOCb8Ht.I8HeKa"sICM.
H8I1jJI1..ep:An&OI!eBC.C.COll'WlbHilHllf!HHOCTbnpaBaSCOBercwM06L11!!CT8e.-M ..lOp'll\.
"'fT. IQ71..C.62-83) T3K"orpaCJleBo01l1lfTeparwelcM ..CMHpHo"O.B. eoon,oWeH>leHOPM I
,:".:=:c=:rt;=:';"'=..:r;;13;OHJ«e. 

HopM3.'rnBHOCTbIIplfHWlIX.l!npI1BaTM3aI<HI1JK11JIbIXBbICTY-
naeT B l\a'leCT13e Bero CBOOCTBa, OTpama.R cre 'lepn.i
cyIIIJIOCTIlI1X, a CJIeJlOBaTeJIbHO,J1 COCTHCaMoroillIC'I'I11YJ'a npJ1B1lTI.13a-
L(I1I1 JKI1JIbIX nOMeIl{eHI1it ITa CpaBHeHI1IO C tropM8TI1BHOCTb :IKI1JI11Il{HO-
npaBOBbIX HOpM OHa 06.na;weT l\a'leCTBOM oc06oro po;:w.. B npl1lll\lfi1ax npl1-
BaTI13<Uj JKIf.IIbIX  3aKOHo;:w.TeJIeM 3aJIOJKeHa "raKaT! CMCTeMa
npaBOBoro peryJIHPClBaHltfl, 6JIaro,!\apa KOTOpOfi: B03MOmHO, Bo-nepBbIX, ox-
BaTl1Tbl\aKc06CTBeHRoOTRoilleIIl1Hnom>Kl1JIbIXnl,
TaK J1 OTHOWeHJLlj",  K HI1M If Te<:HO CBH3aHHbIe C HJl!MJI!; 80-
BTOpbIX, OCy:w:e<:TBJUITb npotlRoe C'l"a6J.1J1bHoe npaBOBOe peryJIIqXEalIlfe
Yl\a3aHHbIX06w:ecTBeHHbIXOTHoweHI1i1KOTCTaBaHI1IOOT
oorpe6trocTeH J1 J1HTt'pe<:OB Cy6'beKTOB npi1Ba'I1CaQID'!, J13MeHeHJl!IO J1JI11 ,lIa-
me OTMeReOT,!\eJIblIbIXmIf.1IMIl{Ho-npaBOBbIX lIOpM CI1CTeMamenprroB
npl1BaTIf3a[(I1JI!JKI1JIbIXBqeJIOMHBJIHeTCHnOOTHOweHl1lOK:IKI1-
o-npaBOBbIM HOpMaM 6a3oBQtI: 0ClICIJ0i: )K1fJII1Il{HD-npaBOBOro peryJrn-
poBalIJ1H, n03TOM)' «YCTapeJIOCTh, a nopoi1 J1 "lI$KTHOCTh OTlIeJIbRbIX
HOpM He MOryr H3.HeCTJl! oco6oro y:w:ep6a nOJIHOTe If Ka'lecmy 3TOro peryJrn-
poBalIJ1H. 3"rnMM UlMJf pyKOBQlICTByeTCH J1 cYlle6Ha.S1 npaRTI1Ka.
Kama  opraH IIpIfMeHfIeT 8HaJIOIWO npaBa BBi1JJiY
OTCyrcrBI1J'! KOHKpeTHot! HOpMbl, OR I1CXO)J;I1T "1f3 06I1t11X Haqa.n J1 cMblcm
3aRlJH),I:\a'I'eJIbCTB, T.e. 113 npmwI1IJOB npaea. 3To nOJIIDKelII1e co,!\epma-
nOCb ew:e B HOpMaX COBeTCKOro 3aKOHO,!\aTeJibCTBa (CM, H3.!1pI1Mep, CT. 12
DeROO IpaiK,ZlaRCKCro CYllO!1poI13BO,!\CTBa ColO3a CCP J1 COlO3lIbIX pecny6-
JIJ1K). ORo MO:?KeT 6bITbBHBe)\eHO If 113 HOpMHbIHe >KKf'4:I
(CM., H3.l1pl1Mep,fJIaey 1).
ITpme.IIflIlIblll 8IIaJrn3 npI1HII;I1IIOB npl1BaTI13aL(l1l1:HG1J1bIX nOMel.J..leHl1i1lf
BblHBJIeHl1eOCHOBHbIXaCrreKTOBB3aHW.ICBH3IIC OTHoille-
HJ.fJIMJI! nonpl1Ba'IH3al.t>I£I.mI1JIbIX ,a TaIOKeC peryJUlPYIOJ1..II1MI1
3TH OTHOllIeHJ.fJI :lKll.lIIfl[(lID-npaBOBbIMI1 HOpMaMJl! II03BOJIJIIOT O'lepTIITb I1X
OTJIJI'UI1'e1IbHbJecBllicTBalfoc:of:anrocTw.
OrJII1'1I1TeJlblIbIe CBCI1CTBa xapaKTepl13yeMbIX npMlIl\I1IJOB COCTOJIT B
TOM,'ITOOIrn,Bo-nepBbIX,6Y,1{y'lI1reHepa..rrI13)l1OT,npo-
HIf3l,IB8I01' J1 lJ'MeHTlfPYIOI' Bee O-npaBOObI€ HOpMbI I1HC'I"I1T;yTa
npI1BaTl13a[(l1JI!)J{J1JIbJX  BO-BTOPbIX, no CBoeM)' CJIII;lIOCTIIOM)'
ecKOMy,I1OJIifTI1'I€CKMJJ1IOpJWf'J€CKOMyco,!\epma-
HI1IOHBJUIK1TCJIlfnepBll'llIlDfiI,TOecThco,!\ep:>KaTI1C-
xo.n;Hbrl1 HOpMaTIfBHbrH MaTepI1aJI 0 npeo6pa30BaHl1Jl! O"JH)llHIJ1i;j c06CTBeH-
HOCTi1 B :m:l1JIl1l.I.tHol1: cclJepe, B-'lp€TbI1x, CBH3aHb! reReTi1'1eCKI1MJ1! If
UIaJlbHblMJf3aBlfCl1MOC'l1IMJ.lB-'le'IE€pThIX.06JIa)laIOT

 I

2. KPIt1H1LjECKIiII1 0530P J.1 OT50P Bbll1B.nEHHbIX
I1I\ECTBYIOLljX npHunoB )I(nLljHoro nPABA
IIpIfHm,I:001J1l.i11tHOro npasa 6e3ornocJrrem,o 1\ TOr.ry, KBaJIl1$IWiPY-
ICYfCJI OHI1 Wl1\nO.llmpacJleSbIe l1JlJ1WlK Te, KOTOpbIe npl1:HOIJII
npaay KaK  OTpaCJrn npaB3., 3aKpeIJJlRlOTC.F!, npoHBJIHKrrCH 11
O'IpaiKa1OTCJlBnp$ThlOMJ1JII1IpOBaHOOMBlV1eBmrnrryrenpl1-
B3.TI13aI1IIJII)K!1JIb!XnOMeIlJ'.ffin'il1ll;I1OHI.fJJYlOTHaJ»l,!\YClll£TlfTYI1,IIOf!-
HbOOI  B 3'1'OfiCBH311 eameH He CTOJ!bKOnOI1CK 11 060cHosaIrne
KaID1X-TO HOBb!X npl1OS oro npasa, CKQJIblID HCIIOJlb3CIl!1l
 npaBosofi Ha)'KJI, 6.naro.llapH KOTopofi yiRe BblHBJIeH t106ocHo-
BaHpfl,1\t13H1fX.EepejKHOOTHOCHCb1\Ha!lll1MMbInpe-
CJIe;:JyeM qeJIb B npoQecre Rp 0530pa BbIRBJIITh t1CTJI!HHbIe npJIIH-
I.1:I1Ilbl :!KHJ!I111tHoro npasa, o6oCHOSbIB3.€MbI€, 3aRperuIHeMbI€ JI! OTpaJKaeMble
B HOpMaTI1BHbIX aKTax B 'qXJII'J nOpR.!\Ke, O'lepTJllTb t1X Rpyr, a
3aTeM cocpe.llaTO'lJITb aHaJ!l13 Ha cneID1cpmre 3aRp8IJ1€HWI, npoHBJIeHIIJH
JI!JllforpameHI1H np£1fnumosoronpaBaBJ[HCTJI!tyrenplfIla'I'J13aItJ1Jl!
)K!1JIb!XfI)MHI¥"mdi.
A '!:TO C06cTBeHHO Jl!3SeCTHO  Ha)'Ke 11 ee npe.i:ICT'8BH1'
° nplfHI.1:I1Ilax ro npasa? Ha 6a3e nOJlomeHIIJH ° TOM, 'iTO npl1lIT..\l1-
IIbI :!KHJIJ1ll1Horo npasa - ::1'1'0 B nepsyIO O'lepe.llb o&beIm.mHo OOyCJIOBJIeH-
HbIe cTa6wrbHbJe HOpMaTtfBHQ-p IIO.J!())Kt;ID1.R, Raropble Heno-
cpe.llCTBellllO 3a1qJ€JI.IHIbIl1JlJ1 HaIIIJll1 orpameHJ1e B OcHOBaX oro
3aKOHO,!!aTeJIbCTBa, >KK PC<OC:P, HbIHe .AetfCTsylolD;l1X >KK P<P 11 B3.)KH€fi-
llll1X :mJfJ!JI!11tHO-npaBOBbIX ID,l\3aKCflHbIX aK'!'ax l . B COQTII€TC'I'BI( c HJ.IMJI!
C'IpOIITCH CI1CTeMa mI1JIJIIlWIoro npaBa, BbIpIDKaIOlWlH 3a1OClllOMepHOCTl,
cyw;H0CTh 11 Ka'lecTBeHHble OC05eHHOCTI1 )KIfJ!JI!11tHoro npasa, JI! oC)'Jl.\ecTB-
JIJleTCH -npaBOBOe peryIDIpoBaHIIJe ornOllieHIIJi{ no ynpaBJIeHl1IO
:IK!1IDI1J.1HbIMI1 4JoH,T\aMJII, 06eCII€'leHI1IO t1X coxpaHHJCTlf, ::IKCrnryaTaQl1l1 11
peMOHTY, (JOmI1JIbIX  Ipam,IlaHaM 11 nOJIb30Ba-
IDIIO JlMI1. 3To ,AeJIeIDft' nOHHTIrn nptrnqmxm Hl1KeM He OClIapl1BaJIOCb
IDIBIDIBJIl1TepaTYpe,
K 'lI1CJIy TaKOBbIX co6C'rBeHHQ mJ1JIJ1ll1Ho-npaBOBbIX npJIIHIl;I1IIOB orno-
CHTCH: 1) r.rracHOCTb pacnpe.rl€JHlHH:1KIfJIbIX  2) 006.m0.I\eHJte
caHt1TapHbIX, T€XHJf'!€CJatX 11 6blTOBbIX Tpe6oBaHldJ, KoropblM ;QOJDKHbl co-
OTBeTCTBOBaTb mI1JIbIe ; 3) npo'lHOCTb npaBOBOro InJI»KelD1H
::;a;;;::K====::a=:=orno-
'0... Csep,anblKr.A. npHlJ,I1nblCOlleTCl<OrOrp;l>K/lliHCl;orollj)eBa:.A>oc. ..II-paQJWJ..ti3y<. _ I
CDej.wIoDcK,WS5C.282-283
20.. CaeAQfl"",rA Ta.."'e.. 283-301. Eroxe npH.....mbl C0geTCKOrOrpB><AaHCl<Ol"O 0\
npaaa:Iv\oHorpaIJ:ooA-l<pac_pc:l'ia.o.-60YH-Ta19B5.C123-130 -:!....

Cor.nawaEcbc TeM, 'ITOJKII!OM)'npaBYnpIfC yK3.3aHHble npilll-
QlfIIbI, If no.rraraR, '1TOOm:! l3LJ,!I,€.1IE;'o6ocHooaHHo, ne. HJ.OO1TIOK npe-
raeT ,AOI1o.mrnTh :ny CIfCTeM)' npl1Hu;vmOB ll\Horo npaBa nplfHIJ;lfl10M
cnpaBe;:vmBoro pacnpe,!\eJleHJl!H no,!\  KOH1pOJleM :H01JJoti
IlJIOIIW)];I>11.
PacCMOTpI1M Ha3BaHHbIe npe,II.ID)KeHI'DI ne. Hi1KIITlOKa 
na TOM 06cTO$M'eJlbCTBe, '1TO roCY,l\apCTBO npMBJI$IJIO 3a6<:rri' 0 Ipam,!\aHaX
B YJIY'illIeHlf1f IfX :HG1JI1fIIUIbIX YCJlOBIfi1, C'rpeMIDlOCb BCeMl1 B03M»KHllMI(
cpe,llCTBaMl1 pelIDITb:ny OC'l'pj'IO  Cyw:eCTBj'IOw;yKJ npol5J1eM)',
ne. HJ.OO1TIOK BH,!tBIfJ'aeT npilIHI.\MfI .6.naI'OlJPlfJl'rCTB» Ipa)l(,I\aHaM B
nplfo\5peTeHJm IfMl1 :1KI1JIbH, Karopbrn:, Ha HaW B3r.JlH,!\, npen:rnBJl.HeTCH
paCfiJlbIB'1aTblM If HeOI1p('.[!eJJeHHHM, He y<Gfl'blBaIOLWIM HeCROJIbl«) MOMeH-
TOB. Bo-nepBbIX, He COBceM HCHO, 'lT0 03Ha'1aeT B llOHI1Mam1lf ne. HwrnTIo-
KaTepMilIH«I5J1a».EcJlJl3TOcoJJ;eiicTBl1eBnOJIY"!eHII!IfJoKJ1JlbJj,
TO TaKOe [J('IJD)KE'IIIt O'leHb '1eTKO npOCMaTplfBaeTC$lIf 3aKpeIlJleHO B )KII!-
o-npaBOBbIX HopMax, B 'ffiCTiiOCTI1, B r)'MB.HJI!3Me, p€WIhHOCTi'1l1 ra-
 npaB If 06HaaHHOCTeH CyfueKTOB :H01JJoro npaBa,
O,!\HlfM t13 Ba:IKHeH!1ll1X YCJlOBIfi1 pea.m13aJ..!Hl1 ROTOpbIX SlBJUleTCH 06ecne'le-
HlferOCYMpCTBOMEI03lIIIDKHOCTUI1OJI)"IE'H11H rproK.!\1lHaMl1JK11!J1bHC COomo-
,AeIDIeMmpe.iI€.IK'HHbI3Ta B03MO:lKHOCTb -C)'UUlOCTh)Kll!-
oj.j IDJllfi11K1f, RO'I'OpaHB.K'I)'aJlbHa.110 HaC1'ORII\ero Bp€MeHl1. Ec.n:1f:me
TepMilIH«I5J1a» nc. HmmTIOKOTIIOCIfTK C1pOI1T€JIbCTBy:HGI-
JlbH, TO cor.naCHO '1. 2 CT.:3 >KK PCttCP OTlIOIlEIDIH,  co CTP(IIf-
TeJlbCTBOM JKII!JlbIX .lIOMOB, pery.JiJ1PYlOTC.f! COaI'BeTCTBj'IOIIJ;I1M, HO He JKIII-
JIIM,3aIDHBIf,!l;lfMOBCIfJl}'3TOro.llej.jCTB)'JO>KKP<P
OTHOllieHIfJI no C'"IJXXf'"I1'.JIbCTB}' }KIfJlbJI He OTHOCl1T K :mJfJIJ1ll\HbIM OTHOllie-
HIfHM (CT. 4)
Bo-BTOpbIX, ne 1h1K.If'MOK He )'Ka3hIBa€TlIa TO, OT KOro 3TO «6JIaronplf-
JJTCTBJ1e» I'ICXD.rorrt1KTO.lIOJIJKeHThpea.ID1:aau;mo,l\aHHOHB03-
MO:IKHOCTl/!.J1cxO)J,R1f3,€)J;BB.Jlt1MO:areT6b1Tbnpll!eMJIe-
I CM. f!W<>fTIOII n.c. >KW1"L1ItfOe npaso. _ K..W..IIEIB UiT"""LI!I. 1985. C. 41
2A><aJl>f3"""">flljHoro3aKOHlJ,(laTeJ1bC1B3roronep"""""nm"OJIIIeTGI\e11BThB..E!O)I{)TOM,'lTO
rocylJ,3pcJWf1POII.IISIIIOsa60T}'oI5y"y.ulleH>f>f""IIl>flljHblXyCOO.";;BCeXHBHOee;;.
rueM""'>KIIII"lIjHOMpel)'"4'\'IOLl\E!M,""",>flljH"eornoweH"'COBpeMeH
Horollep"OJI'Ipocc..()(Oj:;IoIGIqHI,"""'"H""TeIW'Hl1'IR-npo"BJleH""
sa6oTblrOCYlJ,!lp:;TeaJ1""",oI5cT.IIeI1"'blXCIIOA><lt8ceeH".I<OTOp"eCT_blKT9I"OP""
.COllM"""'OH!!3alijI1w,eH,""",.(>fH881I'IIIbI,ceM...IlCJr>t6w>f'Ilj)I1rCGy.o,apGTIiE!H.
HbI.COO3aHHCCTe;;.aT3O>KeCe......C.ll,O.C\<I8MHHI«eC$t1""""'...O)'Cl3HCSlJE!HO'.
TO'IHoro.....H.....,.......T.nj3nt....HeKOTop".."H"..'oner'.""'..rpaJllllBH,yxa3<lHH"'...B3a
 PuGc>f;;GKO C1>eJ\epatj..>f, I'iy/lyr" enpeI\bIlpel\OGTaBm'ThG ""bIe
nOMeUlB"...6eGMaTHonO.ll,OrcBOPYCOII"an...orO"aM!I.BorncweH""IJP\'T"'".kO.
Top""'BPocc....6oJ1bUJ>f.BecT>1PE!'JbCrJ)Olla.rJE!H>f>f:salicrrblrCGyMjX;T8ac.--pIDl:lJ,aHID<,
IIY'Ko'I2tOL!II\XGJIBYI"'WeH>f>f ,."">flljHblXyCIlO..,o;. MC»KHOn>fWbB TO ..ape. B K3KO rOCyJli!P.
CTBOcOOG06HOTbpbf<o">KIIIl"""o6eGn""""'yCIlo",,.np>fHaJl""""KoTOPbIX.--pIDI:IJ,a
He.\"'m>f6..B"GTyMThY'l"GTH.."".....aroropblH""K3KIlOJIOOI<JlOllHbleco6Gme"'>f"".
I

Mb!MIf1pyeMoeB Ka'lecTBeIIpI1HL\lfITaJKl1JIJlIWffironpaBa nOJlo-
:meID1e 0 «6JIaronpIUl'I'CTBW1» B IIpI«J6peTemm )IG1J!W1, RO'T'Opoe K TOM)' :me
He BbIJleJ»KaJIO J1CIIbITaID1e BpeMeHeM lIame B TOH Mepe, B KaKOH OHO 6bIJIO
npOB03rJJaweHO. TITO me KaCae-rCH npeAJIOmeHHOfO II.C. HI'IKIfTIOKDM
mcropacrrpe,l\euemUl:H01JJOHIIJIouw.]J,Mno,l\06rqecT-
BeHHbIM KOH'I'pOJIeM» I, TO B OTHOWeHIfI1 ;JToro npeAIIIDK8D1H HC. HMKi1TIoK
He }"111'Ib!Bae1' cBOe06pa<me KmQEfIltI'IJ1, o6ocHoBatnDi r.A
CofJlaCHO 3TOH IOCJHI1£'IIWnI B HCKOM npaBe <}JOHl1pymT oome-
npaBOBblenpll!I: ryM8H>13Ma.crrpaBe,!\JIJI!BOCTJl!,lIeMOKpa-
TJ.I3Mall!J\Pynle.&rlfnpJI!HWIllbIl1}XI.IlBJU!IO'I'CBOe,l\€ltcTmfeB
=,,:cc::-:=a;==lI!eBco=
HO:HGI.1II>1IqHo-npaBoBblXnInlHOB,IfJIII!npOJIBJUllOCH
"reM II!JIJiI JIlHbIM 06pa30M B HopM3.X JKI1.1!J1!1Wioro npaBa, noKa3aHa pDJIb npl1H-
ltJI!T1<Icnpa.Bl'J1JII'Inpll!pa)KJI!JlhIX
B-1pen.Hx. e.n;aa JIJI! 6bIJIO fibl npaBJl!JIbHbIM no cyIl\eCTB}T CBOlllITb C04Jl!-
aJlbHoe Ha3Ha'leHJl!e If pDJIb oolllenpaBOBOro npru'll.J;l'Ina CllpaBe,!\JlJilBOCTl'l
npaaa JIJl!llTh K era 3Ha'illM0CTII IIpIf paCllpeJleJleIDfIf :H01JJOH IIJIOI.l..\8..m1 nOJ!
KOH1JX)JIeM"'.
HaKoHelt B-'1eTBeprbIX, KOf,Jla ne HMKi1TIoK «lx>PM)'JIJI!pyeT «J1PII!HlUffi
cnppacnpew.nffilmJKl1J10HIIJIOIllB-AI'IIIOJJ;KOH-
1pOJleM», TO B 3TQH «lx>PM)', no H3.weM)'" MHeHJl!lO, CMewJl!BaKJrCH He-
CKOJIhKO IIpOB. 06l.l.\f2npaBOBblX - ,l\eMOKpaTJ.I3Ma II!  crrpa-
Be)J,JII1BOCTI1,aTalOKec06c:TBeHHO:1KllJIlHanpl1Mep,r.nacHOCTJ.I
p >KJI!JlhIX nOMellleHJl!H, KCYrOpbIM 0XBaTHBaI0TCf! JI cOOJlIO,!\e-
IDle mpaeeJI..III'llf, lfY'!acTJI!efBpacnpeJlj:'.JIEffilHmI1-
JlbIX ,lJ,yMaeTcH, 'ITO COTMe'leHHbIX rD3J.fQIIii:If3TOnpe,u.rrOme-
IDle ne HIfKJITlOKa He HaXO,l\IfT y6eJ:r.r.rreJIhHOfO no,l\TBepiK,!\eHJI!JI, a era
npeAIIIDKeIDIe 0 WfI)JIHetiI1J'1 CII!CTeMb! np:fHWIIIE mI1J1J1ll(Hora npaBa He
HOCJITKOHC1pyKTIfBHoroxapaKTepalfnOC)'l.L\eCTsy
IDK Tcm.croH HecKMbKO no J1HOMY no,!\XO,!\JI!T K CJ1CTeMe IIpI1HII;JI!IIOB:HGI-
JDfIW'Ioronpaaa, Bb\,lJ;eJIIDI BKa'lecTBe 1'3.KOBbIX: a)6ecqXJ'IHOCTb lIOJIb30BaH!1H
'fj"K"rlOKn.C,>t<""..LWtOE!npaao.-K..w.."e.Wm"HLI8.1965.C.41
2CM CB"P!VIb'Kr.A,rIpIoHLjMn»coooTCKorOIpa>l{,!\aHC<orollJ]alla,MoHOJJ>3d>""
pct< 1<1:t1J,-BOI(,paoap:J<cro,;><-Ta. 1OO5,C. 122-130
aTOCOljl<aJlblfYlOCnpilB!\W1".OCTbB""II1"LlIHO;;C.p"peB
nep"QJ;jlSbUloISboHBnpa""'bHOCIl=MB
HMHMilTep"aJ1bHblX6flar06u\>1MycJ1oo"eMcnpaaeJIII"BCH)T"B
nep"QJ;jp»HO"HbIKB"CT}'I1aeTCOOTBeTCTB"n
cKOronono_....c!/6beI<Ta"'''''..LlIH»'OTHoweH....eroponM..3I<a"eM.."B'''..ME\!IB"_
TenbHOCIl< 06weCTBa OIljJfW,en_"", epe3 Pi>OHO"HbI OllBHO'I"" MB><a"..3M. B ycJ10.""" I
pblHO'I""'OTHOweH....IJ)aJKIJ,8HBl1P\1peweH....cao".,..",..UIH".BOnpocoB.II,C>n;O:><blpaC.
"""""BaTbHeHaOOcIlIlaTHoenOll)"lBH"">KHflbll,a..aTO,I((}ropoeOH.....oryraaC"""cpeJ1_
cm,mp..oopecrn 

>KM.TIbeM;6)3aCeJJeHJleKBaprnp;B)rprotI.!\aH3M
)!OC1IbIX  orae'JaIOtJ.tI1X He TOJIbRO camrrapHbIM JI 
TpeOOBaID1IIM, lID JI TDMY YJXIBlllO 6.naroycrp:>HCTBa, Karopbrn  B
.l@.HHOMHaCeJleHHOMnyHKTe; r) cra6IfJ1bHOCTb' nOJlb3OBaHWI >KM.TIbeM; A1 He-
no06rqeMY npaBIfJIY ymeCTI'J'IelDfHnpaeOBoropemHMa:oo.1-
JloronoMeLQeHWI,npe,!\OCTaBJIeHHOrofHY,ayxyl1.-
llleHI1fI nOJlomeIDU! nOCJIe,!lHeW Yl\a3aH!Ible IO.K TOJICTbIM B KalleCTBe
npl1Hu;vmoBHaHalllB3rJUJJ\, B6o.m,llleH CTeIIeHl1nO CBoellfj' co-
l1.ep:1K3.HJ11O HBJIHIOTCfI npe,lJ;lIl1caHl1flMl1 KOHKpeTHbIX :1KI1JIJI!O-npaBOBbIX
HOpM, cy&beKTOB')IDfJUlrqHbIXO'I'lICIlEIDIff,a
He PYKOBOWIlWWM HOpMa'rnBHbIMl1 IIJJI:GKeHJUlMJf :!KI1IDIoro npaBa, KO-
'fOpbIeCOCTaBJUlKYl'C)'1lI;IfOCT1fOero.KaKJl!epyKoaoPJIllJ;Jl!enOJlO-
:HreHIDl, onpe,!\e.ID!IOlL\l1e06IJ.O'1OHarrpaBJIeHHOCTbJlHaJlfuJIee CCTBeHHbIe
Ileprbl npaBOBOro pery.lIl1pOBaHWI :1KI1.I!I1IWIbIX CTrHCIIHIJm cOl1.ep:1K3.TC.F!, Ha-
npHMep, BBII,!1e1I€HmMlO.K TOJICTbIMBKalleCT'Be«npl1HIIa» Tpe6clBaIDII!1
3aKOHa 0 IJOCeMefuDM 3aCeJleHIDI KBapTIlp? IIo HallleM)' MHeHl1IO, 3'I'O HBJI.H-
eTCfI KOHKpe1'HbIM yKa3aHl1eM 3aKOHa (C1' 28 >KK PCqJCP) opraHaN, pac-
npe,!\eJlfllOl1\I1M :m:J1Jlbre  0  JI npaBOMepHOC1'11
npHHHTI1fIJllIrnpellleHJl!HOI:HGIJIoroRaKnpa-
BJlJIO, B BJI,!Ie oT,!\eJlbHOJ::i KBaprl1pbI Ha ceMbIQ. Xar.ll .l@.HHoe IIO.JI(M['HHt' II(
6bIJ1o a1lKpeI1JleHO B yme He .r:\ei1CTBYJOll\!'M 3aKOHe, OHO He COl1.eifCTBOBaJIO,
a npOTl1BOpeIll1JJO :oo.1JIJ1IM I1HrepecaM  Ol1.l1HOKI1X rpaiK-
.l@.H,KorOpbIeeIIleHeC03,!1aJUfCeMbIO,aCJIeJ\OBaTeJlbHO,6bIJU106pe'leHbIHa
npmKI1B8HJ1!e B KOMHaTaX KOMM)'HaJIbHbIX KBapTIlp. ABTOp He OTBe'laeT 1m
BOIIpOC. Bl\aKOM:m:J1JlI1l1tH(}-npaB080MJfHC'I'I1'TJ'Te3aKpeIl.i1eHI1 I.J;I1OID1-
pyeT 3TOT «nptfiIIIIIII-. Ec.m.1 B3f1Tb .r:\pyroi1, onpeJlj:'.JIElIIlblIO.K TOJICTbIM
npHHlI;tIT! -npe.IlOC'I'8BJJ!rerpaJK,!\aHaM:!tGIJIbIXIIIJMeOTBe'ialO
HeTOJlbKOCaHJ.rrapHbIMJlTeXHJI'1eCKHM HQJI ypOBHlO6JIaro-
y<:TpID'kTBa :!KI1IDIIII B KOHKpeTHOM HaCeJIeHHOM nymcre, TO HeHCHO, nO'ieM)'
8TI1M -rpe6oBaHwIM .H\I1JIbre nOM!'I.l..\eHI1fI l1.0JVKHbI COOTBeTCTBOBaTb JD1ll1b
npH JIX npelJ;OCTaBJIeHl1J.l II( He 0TII0CSlTCiI K n0Jlb30BaJil1lO.H\I1JIblMl1 nOMeIIle-
'3roT""PMMl.II'n'BHeC.onb.0BMJ!,eyno"MHaeTCRp'lQO"Y"eM..x.TB..
QlJ,HMY"eM"ePB'I'OI1P\1HljMr>e..BCeI.IE!ptOii3aUl>fTB_nMl1IH"",npaB
I'J.I3'"ABH-lc" MapTI«)lJH.6.1lpa80HB>KI<nMlljel1eroY><e6Hoenoc06"8
nocnel\.K)'pcy.-M.1Q83.C.29),'lT011.5.MaprKO"M"
COB.IIMMeT 1I!IBCbl1B8 npHl\Mna II O.!J,MH_ K 'Oldy)lte cnB.Q,yeT CT"'8TT'. ....0 "I/I,e IIbI!1eneMM
I1060cHOIIBHMRnpI<H4na_bl",,"Ml1\fI"XnpaBrpa>OI18HnpfI!IJ\
nB>Kl1TIO.r5acMMy(cM..6aCMHIO.rnp..H'wmblC<JBe1Cla{))ltMnL!IItoronpaB8l1rlpa"oae.
I\BHMe 1961 N!'411JJJYrMe-c-CTa6w1bHOCT)ltIlJ1l1IH""'npaa-lcM KOM<IjXI8BA.>KI1
nl1IHoenpa80.-M.,lQ8{I.C.6JHB.oMel\.TpeTbHro"OjJllTocTa6,,"bH!JM,
npaBBl-t8-noJIb30aaHMe)ltIi]lMlljBMa.06Q1J,H!JM"3CnaraeM""'3I1eMeftTOB.q:aHB.!1O.
nycn<MOCTI1npo"3l1()J1bHoronMWBHMR>KI<nMlljB"lc..lU1_>KIi]IML1jHOBrpaeo.
Y"e6MM."""IIy30" -M..IiI. rpynMIiIHrtlPA-M-HOPMA. 1977 C.31)
2C... TOJlCTOi1IIo.K.rlpoOOe"'bI)ltMnl1IHoT03BKOH0JI,BTe.nbCT"aIlCooeTC",>erOCYl\BflGTao..
npaao.1Q87 N!'11.C.88.
I

HHRMIi. B ,II,aHHOM cJJY'Iae Bbl,/\eneHHbrl1 Hallrn npl1HlI;IDI c001llO,I\€HIDI caHH-
ropHhlX, J16hITOBhIX  npeA'h.lIBJUleMhIX K.mwIbIM
nOMeIIleHl1RM, B 6o.rrbwei1 erenelrn 06ocHOBaH, TaK KaK OH HanpaBJIeH Ha
OOecn€'leHYIe J1 paaBHTIf€ )fO/!oro npaBOO1'HOW€HlUl B lIeJl.'lx peaJJl133.-
l(I1J.f npaaa rpam,1\aH Ha:mJ1JIl1II1€ KaR npl1  :HGIJIblX noM€-
lI1€HJ1i.i, TaR J1 B IIpO!.\ecce n0Jlb30BaHIDI 11MI1. .llei1C'fB)'IOll(I1H :mK I'<tI "I.lIeT
eIIle ,lIaJIb11Ie B l1J11pOTe npo.llBJleHr.tII AaHlJOro  OH onpeAeJI.IIeT,
'ITO opraHhI rocYMPCTBeHHOi1: BJIaCTK J1 opraHhI Mecrnoro cm.KJYIIPaR1IE'lD1H
B npe,n;eJIax CBOeH KCl\iIIJeTeH!.\JIIl o6ecne>mBaKJr KOHTpDJIb 3a COOTBeTCTBI'I-
eM mlfJlhIX fDIeIII€EIrli! ycrnHOBJI€'HHliM CaHJ.rrapHhIM If TeXHJ.I'IeCKIfM npa-
BJ1JUlMJ1 HopMaM
PaccMaTpl1Ba€Ma.II lOR TOJlCThIM «cTa6I1JIbHOC'I'h Iffieccpo<uDcn.noJIb-
3QBaHIDI )fOi!JIbeM», paBHO KaK If 1MOC'I'b, no OOIIleM)' npaBlfJI)'
)'iKeCTO'leHKII npaBoBoro peiKI'IMa :HGIJIoro nOMelIleHI1R, npe,1\OCTaBJIeHHoro
rpam,ztammy, a cJIe,1\OBaTeJIbHO, If YXYJJ;UIeHWI I1('JJI("Df(I2H 1
e.l{Ba JII1 MOlYI' IIpeT€H,!WBaTh Ha pOJlb caIIIDC'I1)Jl'I npl1llWlnOB :1KI1-
oro npaBa. ITo caMOMy CBoeM)' CYl.!.\€CTBY 3TI'I 1I01I.J)f({;fiH.II BbIC'I)'IIalOT
He qeM J1HbIM, RaK WIeMeHTallrn c4>oPM)'JII1poBallllOro f.A. CBep}J,.JIbIKOM
npl'IHI.\l1IIa CTa6I1JIbHOCTI1 npaBoBoro nOJIIDKeHWI HaHlfMaTeneD >K>1JIhIX no-
Jj'lJleHOBJ1XceMeii
Eeccpo<nucTI.Io n0Jlb30BaHWI =-uIheM OOnRJ\alOT TOJIhKO ero co6crBeH-
HHKJI. .lloroBOpbI:me )fO/!oro Hai1:m, 3aKJIJOqaeMbie Ha 6a3e COBeTCKOro
)fOi!JlliJl.tHoro 3aKOHO,llaTeJIbCTBa, a TaIOKe 1\OroOOphI COQIfaJIhII(f'O J1 KOMMep-
qecKOro HaHm no HhIHe Jleik'fB)'lOlI\eM)' poaniicKuMy 3aKOHO):\aTeJIbCTBY
3aKJItO'JalOTcJlHaicpoK.To'ITOHaHlfMaTeJIh
lfMeeT IIpaOO no J1CTe'ieHID1 ycTaIIJBJIeIIHI B ,/:\OI'OBOpe CpoKa nepe3aKJIlO-
'lJITbJlOI'OBOpHai1Ma Ha HOBhIi1 CPOK, paHeepIf,1\OMHCCJJKBaJJl'I-
ItaKOJ\IffiJ13<1JIeMeHTOBnpIfHl.\IfIIaC'I'af.:i.un.HocTlfnpaBoBoro
nOJIIDKeIDIH HaHI1MaTeJIei1: J1 'lJIeHOB me ceMei1. 3T1f llOJImKeHl1.II aHa.1ImItpy-
IOTCH HaMl1 ItaK OTJ\eJibHbIe, HapHAY C APYfl'IMI'I, 3JIeMelITbl (rpaHI1) xapaK'r€-
pt3y€!lfOl"O npl1HII;I'Illa CTa6I>1JIhHQCTII npaBOBQro llOJIIDKeHKH HaHI1MaTeJIei1:
)KI.fJJb1Xm:, qJIeHOB If X ceMeii Co,l\l?p1KaHIfe 3T01'O I1p11HL(l1lla c,/:\e-
TaJIbHbIM aHaJIH3()M ;yKa3aHIn.IX WIeMeHT'OB paCKphITO B CI1eWIaJIhH("N IfC-
CJIe)\OBaID1l1, nOCBHIIleHHOM I1pI1H!.\I1fIaM )KItmllI\llUU npaBa. HaM I1pe,1\CTaB-
JlHeH. qTO ciPopM)'JIl1poBaHHble IOR TOJiCTbIM, M.B. MapTKoBWIeM,
B)J;.KoMapoBhIM, II.t1.Ce)1yI'mn.:rM  HeJIpaBOMf2pHO Ha3BaHbI
IIpIIHI1IDIiiMIf :!KI1.III1II\HOI'O IIpaBa, TaK KaK OHl'!, HapH,ZJ;y C YJKe OTMe'leHHhJM}!
He,1\OCTaTKallrn, nocBOei1 MaCce He,/:\OT.III'I1BalOT AOTeX HOp-
'C.._nOSTQMYBonpocy.£iaclmIOTr$)p....o6ecne"eH"CTa6w1b.
HDCTycno""Arpa>i<Jl<lH"OcHOBbjCODeTCKorO"""L1jHOro
B3 Meuy3.cl5 Hal" Tp.-C.Bp....,OBCK 10111<1-OOYprY, 1981 C. 48-49; Cee.PJ;im.rKr.A. I
rlpHLlMnbj()oIIE!TCK!TOrpa>KA3f£KIJIT}npaaa.MoHOIJI'I<I>" -KpacfOJllpCK:L>1:JJ\-ooKpac"""P- ""'"
CKQTQ\I\H3.1985 C.126-127 t!\

MBTKBHO-pyKOBOWfiWIX nOJlo:1KeHJlii.., KOTOpble Bblp3.:1tIaKYr C)'IL\HOCTb JtGf-
JllIlltHoro npaBa tf J1emaT B OCHOBe ero HOpM.
Oco60ro aHaJIJ.13a tf ,l\oJDKHOiii Ol.1:elOO1 3ac.rrymi1B1leT nplffie"eHHbIi1 B
yqe6IDfKe llJ1.Ce;:I.yrI1Ha «npJ1H1..\I'Il1  0IpIHWJ€HifH (J1Jm
JU1llIeIDfJI) npaaa 1101Ib3OBalIIUI .mJ1JIb1M JKMeI.l.If2IllDl 3a TaKlfe "ic'rBwI
HalrnMaTeJlH H.IIIf 'lJIeHOB ero ceMbJ1, KOTOpble He COnpmKeHh! co 3JIoyrro-
-rpe6nerofeMro.rn:CBOJ.IMIf)Klf.JrnutHbIMJ.:!npaBaMJItfJmc
B03Ha lillX)KIf.JrnIWIbIXo6H3aIrnocreiiil1Hennplf
3TOM He HapywaKYr npaBa 11 3aKOHHble I1HTepeCbI.DiPyrnx JIJ1Q;» .
ABTOp B  coo6l1\8.eT, 'ITa JW,HHbrn: np )!GIJ!IfIWIoro
npaBa $1KTW1ecKIf C4>oPMYJrnPOBaH B nOCTaHEJIEHItH 
Cy,lla Pef>OT 23 mOHJ'l1995 1". no ne.nyo nposepKe J«tiC"I1.1'!)'IOIIliOC'n'! 'i. 1 J1
n9'i.2CT.60>KKf'4I.
]npeJK,!\eBCeroBb13blBaeT ,l\Ba3aME"IaHlmBo-nepBblX,MmK-
Hoc<rnTaTh.l\OKa3amn.IMnonp06JIeMenpoB npaaa TO
COrJIaCHoKOTOPOMYIDIKaKOi1cy.l\,,l\IDKeecJIJIIOHKrnCTII1JlII;I'I:E-
HbIi1, He 4x>PMHpyeT, He 4x>PMYID!pyeT J1 He 3aKpellJLFleT B 0CKJBrn01l3.!1UO-
lJ..IMX HOpMaTl>1BHbIX aK'Tax nplnpaaa Bee 3TO 1I:eJIBeT 3aKOHOJlB1WIb,
!113TOelUI1TOJ1bKO eronpepornT!1BB 2 3a.z\a'l.a:1Ke cyJW,.mOOoj.i
HeTOOpmt>, anpJ.IMelUlTb, HapR,DyCHOpMaMI1npaaa, npL Bo-BTOPblX,
mHaI«JMJleHJf(' C TeKCTOM }lIW.3allliOro nOCTaHOBJIeIDl.l1 RGrnrryu;IUIlD'O
CY1l:a Pef> n03BO.IDieT yrBef»K,!1.aTb, 'iTO 3TOT cy,l\ He 4x>PMYJrnPOaaJl yKa3aH-
HbIi1np,.4x>PMYJIHpOBaHlfeeroBCelteJIOnpHHB,1\JIemwr
II.t1.Ce.nyrIfHY. ITa CBoeM)' CO,l\epJKaHIfIO  J.IM llOJIOJKeHIre J1
Ha3BaHHOe npJ1HWlnOM BKJI}()'laeT: 1) «IIpJl!Hl.\l1n» He.I\OlIyCTI1MOCTI1 orpa-
H!II'lemrn npaBa nOJlb30BaHl1Jl JtGfJIbIM nOMeIIleHl1ervf; 2) npl1I'Il1-HOPMY
o He,I\OllJCTHMOCTII 3J1oynarpe6.ne1rnH npaBOM, c4x>PM)'J!1.lpOaaHHyKJ J1
3aR)JenJIeHHyKJ B CT. 5 I'K F'C:tfJCP 1964 r t1 B «BKofi-TQ Mepe OTj)amem;yIO B
n 1 CT.IOfKpcfJ;3)InJI)jf(ffiJf('0HeJJJI1YCTllMO.::TIfHBpyrnemlJlQ!\Hl1MJIJ1Q;oM
npaB J1 wrrepecoB,DJJyrnX.I1J1l.I.
.'iTOCTOJlbeMKIfXITOJI'DKelDUiBoJ\-
HOM «»Hec:noco5cTByeTBbIRCHeHJ1}(}erocyrJ1, TaKKBKJ13HeI'OHa-
11:0 BbIBO)J.HTb Ha3BaHHbIE' Bbnue 3JIeMeHTbl, COCTaIlJ!.!nOe 
.lijJyrnxnpta TatoKeHeKoTOpbleCBM:lCTOJlTe.J!nOJlIDKeIDIH. Co-
 I
. ;9/IlI'l>l<.Mro<LIIHOEiI"f)a9O'Y<iOO"'.J:I'1IBY308--M. l'i:M,.rpynnaI'iH<!>PA.M.HQPMA,
2 0CJ10><HOM MeXaHL<aIde<J>opt.lJ)O!IaH"', <J>opMynJ)O!IaH"'"3a.pellll6H npHl\I<n08, pe
an""')lerooMI1jJI13TOMCM.:CB6JJ!V1b'KrArlpH....n"()o8eTC""ropaJI\l\aH
c""ronpaBa'MOHorpa<p"__l(pac_pc.:I'ia.a..BOYH.Ta 1985_C26_35
33ronollO>l<e"eTO><e"HaYl'e.HOttel<8.caMCX;TO"TeJlbH,,..a
I<8KQ/J,IOHI13aIlE!Me"To.np""LII1nanpallOaorolloM_-.ej;j..
neHO"""'CeMelcM.:CBeJ1ll1'bI.<rA.rlpHl\I<n"()o"eTCKOrOl1jJa",,:MuHO
lpao1l"-I(paGHOIIpcK:IiI"",,-eoYH.Ta.1985.C128)

BepllIeHHoe fiJ1. CeJr.yrnHbIM OTKpbITY!e" Kp :n}), BI1-
.JtI1MO, HaCTOJIbKO y6e,!\J.fJIO aBTOpa B CBoeA npaBO'l'e 14 ero,
'ITO OH 14 BO mupOM I43)\aID1l1 yqeEiID1Ka .r:\OCJIOBHO BOrnJXM3BOWIT ero l . En;s.a
Jrn CTOJIb ,l\JII1HHOe Ha3BaHJ:Ie yK3.3aHHOrO <I1p14HQl1ll3.}) Y;J;OOHO AJlH 14cnOJIb-
30BaHIDI B yqe6HOMnpOl\eccel4 YCBOeHiffi ero CT.YJI€HTBMIf
Ji1TaK, n03BOJIJIeTC;J;eJIaTbBbIBOA 'ITOnp06.n:eManp-
nOB.HOi.1IIllitI«RJ npaaa BbI3bIBaeT J1HTepec Y n .H01JItUltHo-
I1j:11BOBOii Ha)'K11 IITCH 14 3aK£IID,I\aTeJIeM I1pOl\eCC nOIfCKa, 1}Jop-
MJqXJBaHIfH If I}JopMY.m1pOBaHIf.fI paHee He 0003HaQeHHblX I4JlIf He
BhIJlBJIeHHbIX cTa6111IhHhIX HOpMaT£1BHo-p:yKOBOMI..l\HX IDJIO)I{€HI1ii, BbICTY-
IIaKJIIU1X B :1KI1JIYjIItHOM npaBe B Ka'leCTBe nptlHl!lflIJB R  He
npeo.l!OJIEtiO c-rpeMJIeHJl!e ar,lleJIbHhIX aBTOpoB '1eT'Je 0603HaQ/1'T'b CCPOPMY-
JDl4MHn1IThI, I4CJIel\)'eTCOrJIaClITbCHcyrnepm,n;eHIfRMHO
TOM, 'lTom060e=JIll1;O,'IT06bIBbICT)'IDITb
Cy6'beKTOM rp<UIQ:IaHCIlfCO npaaa 2 , ,!\OJDKHO He nplfBR)Clfi'b B Ipam,1\aHCKoe
npaBO .mrn})nplfHLl;l1IIbI,aOBJIaJleThnpl1cneqI1aJIbHOMnfnpo6.rre-
Mbl JfMelOlltI1MHCH B Ha:yKe 3HaHIfRMH.
CyqeTOMBceroMbInlXQlJ;IiMKBbIBO'!\YOTOM, 'ITOCOBpe-
MeHHOM)' )f(JI!JIJ1lltHOM)' npaay nplfcynI;I1 CJIe)JyKII.W1e npl1Hl.{JI!IIbI o-
ro npaaa: 1) rJIaCHOCTJ1 pacnpe,!\eneHI1H )IGfJIbIX fDoIell..I€flI.fI.i; 2) c06mo,!\eHJ:IH
caHl1TapHbIX, TeXHlf'lecKl1X If 6bITOBbIX Tpe6oBamd1, KOTOpbIM .r:\OJDKHbI co-
OTBeTCTBOB3.Tb >KI1IIble 110Me1.l\€HIfR; :n CTa6I1JIbHOCTI1 npaBOBOro nOJiOiKe-
HJl!H HaHIfMaTeJIeA.H01JIh!X OOM 11 'iJIeHOB JfX ceMeA; 4) 6epemHoro
OTIIOllIeHIDI cy&beKTOB )f(JI!JIIfIItHoro npaaa K >KI1IIbIM nOMeIIleHImM.
3aKpel1JIeH14e.crrpa:a<eHJl!e"KaiK,!\oroI43Ha3B3.HHblXnpl1H-
QI1IIOB B I1HCTmyre npl1B3.TJI3altIDl)IGfJIbIX IIJMHqeHIdi, a TaKme aHaJll13 J1X
cyw;H0CTIf OCyw:ecTBJlJOOTC.FI B cne;JylOIIIei1 I'JIaBe.
3. KJlACCH<DHKAH 11 CHCTEMA nPHHHnOB
[lPJ.1BAH13AljJ.1J.1 >KJ.1JlbIX nOMEli.jEHJ.1f1
.lJ.MnOJIHoroBblHBJleHIDlC()JJ;epmammI4Ha3Ha'leHl1Hnp110BnplfB3.-
Tlf3aL\l1l1 .H01JIh!X IJU\Hlj,effim, xapaKTep14CTI1KJiI B3IDlJIW,I\eirrEwI If Mexa-
HJl!3MaIfXK.IUIpOB<\HIIHBaJKHOllCliOJIb3OB8HleO;J;HOr0I1300IIlenpI13-
HaHHbIXnplfeMOBI43Y'1eHI1HOIIpeJJ12JIeHHbHBJIeHlfi7i-JfXKJIa
. c.. Ce,iIj"",n.J1. )l(1IJIlJIHoenp8llO:)'\<e6<KAI1"nyaoB. -2-e"M-.nepepa6."AO". _M.
11:to"I-IOPMA-I1H<tIPA-M 2000C,40 I
2 Mb< '\l\<!CI. " paaHO ...epe "'0>""'" YTllepJK,II,aTb - " q6beKTOM >IOOIl1IHoro npaM, TaK aK t.n
P""bI1'\!ITOro... fPIDK,!\aHCKOM npaae. e ClJ!YKTYPYKOTopomIlXO)\l\1l0" "'''''llIHOe npaBO t!\

RaK 113BeCTHO, KaJti,!\brn npl1H1..\I'Il1 BbIp<lmaeT CJreqII I«fiKp€'fHNX
()'ltJ(Illf2I!II1CX0,!\R 113 TOro, KaKYIO po.rn. 3T1f OTHOWeID1R I1IpaIOT B OOll.leCT-
Be. B 3TOM CBJl31f MOJKHO cornaCI1ThCII C TO'lKOM 3peHl1R, 'ITO Rpl1'repl1eM
npI1HLJ;II!IlOBnpaBaHBJl.F!erCRciPepaOXBa-
TbIBa€MbIX I1MI1  OTHIJllIEffiu1. TO €CTh c4x'pa Jlx.lJ2iicTmm
(IIII1p OTan IXUlBJI€mm).
BtiJlCl1rpnJ:6BOBOftJIl.1Tepa-
TypenpOBe,!\eHa.rofnpI1HLJ;II!IlOBnoapepe.nei.k-rmuI(nmpo-
Te nIXUIBJI€HJ1.f/) JI BWlBJIeHa cyw;HOC'Tb 06!l.\€npaBoBbIX' M€iK01p3.CJleBblX,
OTpacneBbIXl1pfl,!\aI1HbIXnpB.
BnpaBe.HapHJJYcUl'Me'IeHHbIMl1,IJOJJY'IIUIIIo6ocHOBaHl1e
l1T!l.\aTMbHOe e TaKiKenpl1H1..\l'Il1bl, ciPepa.ncifCTBI1.II W:rropbIX
paCIIjJClCTp3IDle'fCH Ha COOTBeTC'TB}'IOJ.IJYIO no,!\mpac.m. rpHCKOro npa-
sa J1BXO,!\ffiII;I1XBeeCKO-npaBOBble I1HC'TJITYTbI; 113y'1eHbI npl1HIJ;I1-
ru,ITaKl1Xno,!\mpacJIetinpaBa,KaKnpaBo,OOfl3aTeJThC'TBeH-
Hoe npaBO, TIJop'!ecKoe npaBOJ1:1K11oenpaBO
1KI1J1J1o-npaBOBblennpQRBJIHKYrCflBI1HCTIfTyraxBcetiRoM-
I1IIeKcHoti OTjJaCJII1 mllIDD.I.\HCf'O npaBa, a CJIe,l\OBaTeJThHO, JI B TaKOM :1KI1-
JII1IWIO-npaBOBOMI1HCTtnyre, KaK npI1BaTYI3aqJ1H:HG1JIbIX nOMeID1ti.
Co6c'mEro1oe 3Ha'leHJ.le 3TI1X nplfHI.{JI!I10B COCTOJ.lT B TOM, <rrO OHJ.I Bh!pa-
:)KaIOTOCo6eIlllOC'TI1OTpaCJll1)KJ.IJIlfIWloronpaBa.EY.l\Y'D'lOT-
HOCI1TeJThHO CaNOCTOJjTeJIbHbIMI1, OHJ.I BMeeTe C TeM 06HapYiKHBaIOT xapaK-
TepHble '!epThl B HHCTIf"I'}'TaX KCN£IJJeKCHJiiI OTpacJII1 oro npaBa.
CI1C'TeM)' C4JePbI J1X .nei1cTB11R COCTaBJImOT TIUGle ee CTPYKTYPHbIe 3JIeMeH-
TbI, KaK: O-lIpaBOBblenpJ.lHIJ;J.lIIbIKOMI1JIeKCHotiarpaCJII1O-
ro npaBa, Co6CTBeHHO tlHCTlTJYl\lUlHblE' npl1HIJ;I1IIbI npI1BaTYI3a4l1J.l :mK.IIbIX
noMeIlleHl1til1,!\p.TpaHc<lxJpMaqJ.IffJ1:1KI1JIJI!O-npaBOBbIX
npl1OB B JlHCTIfTyre npl1Ba'rn3aJ.ttI£l)KlfJlbIX, paBHO KaK JI
8HaJlJl3,!\eUCTBIDI Co6CTBeHHO mrftlTJ'lUlOllHbIX nptIIWIIlOB B ciPepe pery-
JII1}XJBatll1f1CTIHJll£ti11hnonpI1BaTI13a4l1J.l>Kl1JIbIXOTpail<alOT
,/J;U1Int'RTIrny B3IDIMOO'I'HI:UI OOll\ero J1 oc06eIlllOro, a IOCNIIJIeI\"CHWII1X
8HaJlJl3 n03BOJ1ffeT npe,!\C'TaBJ.lTh BCIO   Ha KOTo-
pbIX 6a311pYeTCff CIfCTeMa mJ1.1II1lltHo-npaBOBbIX HOpM, perynl1pyrolI..\J.lX OT-
HOllIeHl1HnOnpI1BaTYI3aqvrn::1KI1JIbIXnOMn1.
TIpe,!\CTaBI1TeJIJI IpaJti,!\aHCKo-npaBoBoti 11 )KJ.IJIlfIWlo-npaBOBoU HaY" He
Y,l\eJIRnJ.l ,l\OJDKHoro BHIfMaHJ.IfI npo6JIeMe c06cmeHHo 
npI1HLJ;II!IlOBnpI1BaTYI3aqvrn:JoKI1JIbIX1:,xoTHI13yq:eHl1eKIpe<:-
iR l
'LlaHH..enpHl»'n"l<aS"B,"oTCfI"""UII'''''..npSTo''Tep..''''.06.
U!fmpaBO"...enp""lJ,I1nbl.!5oneev.o.a"e".T3KK3.0H"B1'IBOTpa;t<aeT"BJle""Rpean.""'l!eiO.
crs....em"'ocrnI1Q11HOape..e"""'YI'a:!blBaBTK3.l<al1xo!'iUll'xapa.,-ep.T3.11H30!5LJ.1Y1O
np3BOBj1"'cyLl\HOCT.(C.... C""A'V'"""r.A,np"HlI"nblCOBeTCKororp""'l!<IHCK<;JronpaBa,MO
l1orpa'lm"-l<pacHoRpcK:IiI:J,!\-eoYH-Ta.I9B5.C.I79J

KQM .mrreparypbI nOKa3b!B3.€T, 'ITO B npaBOBOM HayKe C 06JW1>; ID3Jo1WUt BbI-
CKa3aHbIHeO,!J;H03Ha'lHbIeB3rnbIHaBh1,!\eneHMR-
HbIX IIpI'IHqI1IIOB BOO6II1e.
TaR, paccMa1pnBa.F! nOHRTl'!e JI! npl1H!.{JI!IIbI rpam.u.aHcKoro np:)J:\eccy3.JIb-
HOronpaBa,B,MCeMeHOBOTMe'ffiJI, '1TOIfHCTIfI'YJ'bI,xa11.JI5IoT-
wJIl:ll(ji mpac.mt npaBa, RaKI'IX-.m16o c.aMJCTOHTeJIbllla: IIpl'IHIU1ll0B He aa-
Rpe!1JUIIQT OcHOBHbIM aprYMeHTOM B.M CeMeHOB C'IU'I'a.eT ,D;OCTaTO'IHOC'!'b
TOm, 'lTOOHif (IDICTK1')'ThI) nJXIHl13aHbIOTpaCJIeBbIMK IIpI'IHIU1ll, 06ecrre-
'lJIBalOHepa3pbIBH)'IOCBH3b,A3.HHorolfHCTI1TYI'aCMJI! .
CaM IIO ceDe  apryMeHT He BhI3bIBaeT OC06bIX B03pameHifli
JJ;eJ1Hl'TIITYTbInpaBanpOHl13aHbImpac.rreBbIMKIIpl'IHIU1llaMl1,
If He TOJ1bRO Jl!MJI!, HO If, RaR OTMeqanOCb ,D;pyrIfMJl! yqeHbIMI'!, npl'! HaJiJI'iJDI B
OTpaCJIJl!npaaaIIOJl:OTpacIDI-COOTBen:TBelIIIO t1nOJ\mpac.ueBbIMKnpl'!-
JIaMJl!. C BbIBO)J;OM, KOTOpbm CJJ:eJiaJI B.MCeMeHOB, HeJib3HCOrJIaCl'ITbCH, no-
CKOJThKY norW.JeCKH ,D;OJDKeH rDCJI€,l1OBaTb t{ JJ;Pyrofi BbIBOJl: 0 TOM, '1TO OTpaC-
JIJIJ npaaa He IfMeHJI' CBOI1X OTpaCJIeBb!X IIpI'IHqI1IIOB: mill mro6bI npOHl13aHbI
JI! Mem:npaCJieBbIMII! IIpmUJ;l'!rraMI'I, TaIOKeOn1O-
J.I.tI'IMt1 Hepa3pbIBH)'IO CBH3b O,!J;HOi1 OTpaCJIJl! npaaa C ,D;pyroi1, XQTJI B IIpaBo-
80M Ha}lKe J\OKa3aHO If ofuJJ>np1laffiHO o6paTHoe.
BIrnMaHIfJlIf 60JIee rnyOOKoro paccMmpeHIfJI, no Ha-
rneM)' MHeHJI!IO, HBJUIeTCH n03VIIll'IH CropOHHKKOB JJ;PyroM TO'IKM 3pelU1IJ, KQ-
TOpble C'lJITalOT, 'ITO OT.u:eJIbHbIe npaBoBble JIHCTH'Iy1'hI (H3.PH.!\y C nJXIlfBJIe-
HKeM JI! 3aRpenneHKeM B ID1X OTpaCJieBblX t{ IIOJl:OTpaCJIeBbIX 11):IBIIIJfI1OO)
JlMelOT c06CTBeHHbIe nptHl!I'IIIbI. IIOCJIe..lJ;IUle npe.u:CTaBJIJIIOT co6otf cra-
fst.m.m,relIOpMaTJ.fBHO IIOJ10meHIfJI, onpe,!\eJUIIOl.i.tI'Ie paaBJ1-
melUlC'l11T)"IOBnpaaa JiIOKa3bIBaIOIIII'Ie'icrm1(' KaRHa npaBOBoe pe-
rynl'!poBaHKe nOBe.u:aUlH COOTBeTCTByKJlWlx cyfu,eK'TOB, TaR JiI Ha
npl1MeHeHlfe npaaOBbIX HOpM.
lenOJI())KeHI1HOHa.IDl'IIDfBnpaBOBb!XI1HCTJITYffiXCc6CT-
BeHHblXnpIflWWIOB(npJl!pa3JiI1'OO'!XBIIO)J;XOAaX
IfX CYIII;II()(.'TI11f 3aKjJ€'nnelIJl!.fl) CO)WpmRTCH B pafurax TaKJllX yqeHbJX-IOpIfC-
TOB, KaK: E.C. JI! RA fpaBe l , A.M.HeMKOB' JI! HC. IhnurnoK 4 ,
paccMa'IpllBaBllIlfX np06JIeMbJ H npaaa; 3Ha'ltlM If Bbmo,!\ 0
nQD;JIJI!HHb!XnpKHl\lffiaXIfHCTI1TYI'aHanpaBas.
I c....: CeMeHotJB,M. IIoH>m1e "C"CTeManp"HLIL'n08COBe'UOmIp3)<,!J,3HCl<Oro npoL\OCCY.
anbHoronpasaIlCti.Y"8H.1pyI1OB.B..n2/CePA"OBO'li1IOP9CI<"">lCTHryr.-
CII6fWIOBC..I964C.220
2C.....AHTmfOH08liC, rpaI>6KA.CoBfITC.oenpallO.-M..1955.C.30-31
3c....:HeMKooA,M.OcHoBH"'enpHLIL'n"COBI!11XI1}npaEIB"y"eH.""nH-
C.Hnap>AC.oroI965N!'129.C.10B-115
4C.....HH""J1OKnC.npBIIO"npol\6CC(rlpo6J1e"'''Teo.
PH"npa"-H.) -KiaIaKE. 1973 C.12 I
5C....:C""A'V'''''''rA.rlpHHLIL'n..CO"eTCI<OrOrpIDI<J1BHCl<IJronpaBa:M<HJrpBIJH!.-KpacHO- r---
APC.:Io1=\!\."oKpaCHOIIpc«,roy...-ra,1985.C 165-171 t!\

OmeJIbHble npaBOBeiJ;b1 B peIIHnlJlI OOcyiK,!laeMOi1 npoOJIeMbi nOllIIDl
eIIle.JI,aJlbWe. TaK,P.3.JlI,rBIlOO..\eMJlB.H.IMBWCKa3aHOMHeHJ.le,
COr.naCHO KO"rop0MY Tatroe npaBOBOe 00pa300.aIn1e, KaK IfHCTIlT)'T OJ<HOJ.IMeH-
HOi1 mpacJIJ.I, He HBJIHeTCH 3aMbIK3.IOIIIJ.IM 3BeHOM C TO'iIDf 3peHJ1H c4Jepw
,o:€'I1CTBJ1ji nplfHOB. P.3..llimlID1l\JlB.H. IhmilTIlHCKlmno.naralOT, HanpJ.1-
Mep, 'ITO B c4Jepe Tpy.l\OBOrO npaaaBCYICTeMe t HopM cy-
II1eemyIOT TaKJ.le oc06we JlX rpyrmbl, KOT'OpblM npucy1l.tH cne
npJ.llJIll1lIbL Ha3BaHHble aBTOpw yrnepm,/\aIOT, 'ITO .mc6ail OOIIIHOCTh HOpM, C
O.l\HOi1 CTOp.JHW, MO:?KeT OKa3aTbCiI cqxpoi1.l\ei1cTB11.F! IIpJ.IHOB, a C .I\PY-
nM - OHJ.lnpe.J1OC'I"€peI1CCJ1l'J1lmTereti, 'ITonpJ.l nptrn-
OB, arHOCHIIIJ.IXCiI Kar,I\eJIbHbIl'lI rpyIITIaM HOPM, He06xo.I\tIlOO co6.nID.l\aTh
pa3)'MHYIOOCM01'pl1"I'MbHC, TaK KaKHeTCMbICJIa OThICKI1BaTb
.l\.IDI .l\BYX-Tpex OT.l\eJIbHbIX HOpM. HapiIAY C <m1M OTMetffieTCil, 'ITO eCJIl!l B
I1Hcnrryre TpY.l\OBOro ,I:\OlUBOpa HI1pyKTI' COTIrn J.1  TbIcwrn
HOpM, rol13l1X 'lJ.ICJIa MOiKHO BbIBeeTJ.lTaIDfe IIpJ.lHbl, KOT'Opwe pacnpo-
CTpaHJllO'l'Cil TOJIbKO Ha OI1pPJIenEHHYID rpyrrrry HopM }'Ka3aHHoro KHCTIITY-
Ta, a He Ha Beeb l1HCTI1Tyr (HanpJ.IMep, npl1Hl.{IIlIIbI peryJmjX!BaHJ.I1i COBMee-
TJ.ITeJIbCTBa, nepeBQ.l\a Ha APyryIO pa60Ty JI T.,Iil.
]B3f.ruvJblno.l\BepraJIJI!CbcnpaBe.iIJIllBmIKpJI!TJI!Ke.OrMeqa-
JIOCb,BttaC'lfJ(JCTJl, '1TOTaKaHTpaKTOBKaBe.l\eTK-
MY YBeJIJf'leID1IO I1X'lJ.ICJIa, a caM clJeHoMeH npJ.lHl\lfi1a HI1BeID1pyeTd. Co-
fJIawailcb B OOIIlI1X 'ieprax C MHeffifeM OHCMJ.IpHOBa, MbI He pa3.l\eJlHeM
n03J.1qJ1!lO p.a.llim1ID1I¥l JI! B.H. IhmIfI't1HCKOro eIIJe 11 no CJIeJlYlO coo6-
pa:1KeHIfJIM. Bo-nepBbIX, e.l\Ba JIJ.I npaBOMepHo yrBepit\,l\eHJ.le, COrJIaCHO Ko-
TOpoMY JIlO6aH OOIIIHOCTh HOpM MO:?KeT OKa3aTbCH Cqxpoi1 ,o:€liCTBltf! IIptrn-
QIITIa. BHOpMa.xnpaaanpI1Hl\lfi1hlHe.l\ei1CTBJlOT.Om1bByKTrBpeaJIbHoif
 BooIIlecmeHHbIXOTHoweHl1HX, BJtGl3HJ1. BHopMaxnpa-
sa npmItUJThI3aKperrJUIlO'l'CH, IIpMBJUlIOTCH J1JIJ.I B rofi JIJIJ.I I.fHofi Mepe OT-
pa:1KaIOTCiI. 3Tonplf,l\aeTI1M COOTBeT xapaKTeJJ.
BO-BTOpbIX,  6ecIlJ10;J;Hb1M3atlflrneMCJIe.ayeT IIpJ.l3HaTb
nOIIbITIDf OTbICKI1BaTb npl1Hl\lfi1hl AJUI .l\BYX-Tpex OT}J;eJIbHhIX HOpM. Pe'lli
Be,IJb UJIeT He 0 npIDfL\illlax nOCTpoeHlfR HOpM (CJlCTeMbI) ofH<nt:»ii (KOM-
I1.JImCHOi:) OTpaCJIJ.lJIJIJ.IIfHCT£fTyra npaBa.] I1J::IfHItHIIOO Be-
.l\eTCH C n03J.1W1Y111X 3Ha'lJ.IMOCTJI Rail: pery.rurropoB nOBe.lIeHIfJI cyfu.eKTOB
onpe,II,eJI€HttJIjC4JePwOIH)weHIDl.
OrnoweID1Il, HaIIpJ.IMep, no npl1BaTJl3aJtIDI :HGIJIbIX llOM€flJ'lIIdi COCTaB-
JIH!OT TOJIbKOOIIp"JIeJIeHH)'ID 'faCTh OOIIleemeHHbIXJKI1JIJ1IIIHbIX 0TI«IIIE!tIJIi
npe.IJ;IIDC1lJ!I1XJ.I3Y'leHJI.IIHBJlHeTCH
!R I
. CM. RH8WI<IJ. P3.. HlmmmcKHI! B.I1. IlpHHLI"'nbl COBeTC"Oro -rpYfWBoro np1JB8./1 CoBeT.
cKOeroey.o.apcTlo'1Ilp.111O.1974.N!8.C 38-39
::1 CM. C"HjJHOIJ D.B. Coo-rnoweHMe HOpM" npHHLlMnO"BCOOeTC"OMnpaoeI/CODeTCKoero
CY!l"pGTBO..npaBo1977.NI:2 C.17

pattMO'l]JEHlle I1X B Hepa3pbIBHCii CBH31f C qeJINRJii CIIC:Tel\diiOl'HtEHllllino
nplff,COCTa.BJUII{)tJ.tIfX3JleMeHTbInpe,!l;MeTa
pery.!Il1Jx:>BaHIfR.JnpcfirreMbIC3TI1Xn03BeCbMa:ma'll1MO-
 It cyMM3.TIfBHOM)' KOJiI1'IeCTBy HDpM, B ItOTOpblX 3altpen-
JImOTCH 1f.II11113 KOTOpbIX B peJyJIbTa'I'e HaY'ffioro nOIfClta MOryr 6hITb BbIBe-
p;eHblxapaKTepI1JyeMble
HaBl,Ie acneKThl Blf,!J;eHIfH aHaJIIf3IrpyeMW npo6.neMbI IIpOfIBItJIIQ> B C8H-
:mCOC'I'pEf>LlI€ffill'M rocy.napcTBa peIillITb)Klfnpo6.neMYBfuullf B
yCJlOBIfSIX nepexo,@ It pbIHO'IHOi1 3KOHOMMKe JfKOMI1JleKCHOro OCTBJIe-
HIf.IIHOi1:)KIfJUlIItJlCli:ip$pMhI,BTOM'ilfCJIeJf3ac<leTJf3-
MeHeHlfH clJoPM m6crBeHIKJCTII Ha :HGI.IIhe.
.AJJa.rrn33aOnplfBa'I'J13aqJfJ1:HGIJ!bIX(I1OC(}-
6eHHo3aKoHa I'occ1liicmii4leJ\epa1\1fI1 «OnprnaTIl31llUtJforo I}xJH-
p,a B Pocorlic:Rcii 4leJ\epawm:.) In>8OJIHeT C yqeTOM paHee xapaKTepl13ye-
MbIX I1pII3l1<lKOO, npIfC nomlTInoHHC'lltryl(lUlHblX
nplHWlIIIJ npl1BaTI13a4lf1f >KIfJIbIX nOMeI.J.t€Hl1i1. Bbl,/\eJIl1Th CJI€JIYIDe
npIfHl..\IfI[bI)KIfJlbIXnOMel.l..leHl1ii 1)p;06poBOJIbHOCTbOCYJ.I..\e-
CTBJIeHIfH Ipam,11aHaMl1 npI1BaTJf3aqJfJ1 :m:J1JIbIX nOMel1\€mm (CT. 1 :3aKoHa
PoccmICRCif 41e.1lepal\lfI1 «0 nplfBaTI13a1\1fI1 JKIf.IIJfIWIDro clJoHM B Pocoliii-
aroii:4leJ\epawrn»);2)6ecn.na'l'lIOCTbnpl1BarpaiK-
NUJaMlf>KIfJIbIX  (CT. 1 Jf 11 Ha3BalilIOro :3aKOHa), 3) O.1\llOpa3(}-
BOCTbOCYJ.I..\€CTBJIeHIDIMI1IIp11BaTl13alJ;1f11:1K1f.1Ib!X(CT.11
}'Ka3aHHOro:3aKoHa).
Orp;eJIbHble 113 Ha3BaHHbIX npl1Hl\illlOB 3aKpeIIJIeHbI (npaB.1\1l, B HeCKOJIb-
KO JlHofi: pe,!\aKU,l1lf) B ITpl1Jll!epHOM nOJIOmeHlfI1 0 npI1Ba'l'J13al..\Wl.HillJ1lflltH(}-
roclJoHMBPC<PC::P'.
BMecTe C '/'eM TPY.l\HO COrJIacJ1TbCH C MHeHlfeM KOJIJIenrn rOCKOMJI1'eTa
mKXPCCPCP, 'lTOKOCHOBHh!MmaMnpl1BamroCY,!\apCTBeH-
Haro 11 M)'HIfWIII8JIbHro JKI1.IIJfIIUJoro clJoH,!\a OTHOCffi'CH TaKiKe HopMaTIfB-
HbIe'I'peOOsaHIfR, COrJIaCHOKO'I'OpbIM:a)lpe, CTaBWl1ec06cTBeHHJ1lta-
MI1:HGIJ!bIXI, B.JIaJJ:eIOT, IIOJIb3j1IOTCHl1paCilOpIDKaIOTCII3TKMIf
nOMeIIleHKHMJI! no CBoeM)' y<:MTIpeHIoo. OHif enpaee npD,1\aBaTb, 3aBeIl\ilTb,
aTl>BapeH.!!Y,COBepwa'I'bCID1MI1J1HbIeC}\eJIKJl,He
:3aKOHY; 6) npaBO o:i>crBemDcTIl Ha oi1 .l\OM, Bee KBapnfpbI, B KOTOpoM
IIpIfBa'l'J13JfpoeaHbI, nepexO,!l;lf'I'ItKBaprHp; 'iaCTIf'lli0 nplfBaTIf-
3t1pOB1lllHblJi .l\OM IJaX(),rorI'CSI B rocy'@(.X'TB€lIlIOO (tfJIIf M)'liI'Rt>maJIbHOti} "
 co6cTBeHHo::nl; BJIa)\eHlfe, nOJlb3OBaHl1e 11 pacnqJIDKeIDIe KaK
nOJIHOCTblO, 'I'aKJf 'IaCTIf'JHO I1)JIfBa'I'K3t1pOBaHHbIMJf1J,OMaMif oc)'Il\ecTBJIHeT-
CH no COrnallIeHlfIO Me:IIQ:\Y CoOCTBeHHI1K1lMlf.
- I
'C....C60pHKJlPKYMeKTOl1nOf1jJl<""n13aLjl<>KI\IIb""PC<t>CPI 0\
Io1H=nyr"KlJHO...""""'MMKOMM)'H""bHOroXO'"i4;maM.... KJ),. r1aM<I>w10B3.-M. 1991 t!\

etlHWiTeKCT, CO.n;epJKaIW1i1CffBlll1.4115 H3.3BaHHOrollpl1MepHO-
ro  CBt1,!\eTeJIbCTBye'T' 0 TOM, 'lTO pe'lb J1,!\eT He 0 
IIpI1BaTi'EaQlIJIIaOHECOBCEMKOppERTIlOMyrIO'IJJt'fine-
HJ1I1TepMJIHO!1tT1111. TaR,  o TOM, 'lTO «rpa»\,lJ;aHe,
CTaBIm1e co6cmeHIDIKaMJ.I mlfJlbJX nOMelIleIDfIi, BJIa.n;elOT, IIOJIb3j1IOTCH "
pacrropH)f(B.KJfCH 3TI1MI1  no CBoeMY ycMO'lpEHIDO. BIIpaBe
rrpo,!\aaa'T'b, 3aaelI\BTb, C.D;aaa'T'b B apeH.!!Y, coaepwaTb C ffiiMt1 tfHbIe c.n;eJJIGi,
He npoTI1BO 3aKOHY», paBHO KaK 11 yrBE'pmJlEffiE' OTOM, 'ITO «IIpa-
BOH3.)f(JI!JlOi1.D:OM, BCeKBapn[pbI, BKOTOpoMIIpI1BaTl1311pO-
BaHbI, n K BJIaJ\eJIbLjaM KBaprap», He Moryr 6bITb OTHecem,I K
IIpI1HIIW1aM npI1BaTI13aW1J1)f(J1!JIbJX lXIMeIQeHJ1it IIoCy:II\ecTBYI1 K npl1BaTl1-
3aLlJ1l1 )/{I1JIbIX nOMel.L\€H11i1 OH" He }[MelOT ffiiKaKOro OTHOWeID1H, nOCKOJ1bKY
B tf3.IIIDKeHHbJX Te311caX pe'lb tfJ\eT 0: 1) cOJ\ep*1l.HI1I1 IIpaaa c06CTBeHHOCTH
HaHHOemlfJlbe;2)npaBOMO'II1HXc06cTBeHHKKa,KOTOpbIeno
cooefi: IOpJIJI;If'J€CKOii npHpOJ\e SlBJLmOTCH IIX.'.1lenptma'I'J13altlf(
To o6croHrem.crno, 'ITO c06cmEHID1K:IKI1JIbH MIDKeT cOBepwaTb C IillM
cJ\eJiKl.f (OOcroJITeJIbCTBO, cnpaBe,!\JIl1BOeCaMO no ce6e), TI»Ke CBIJ,I:IeTe.JIb
BYeTOC06cTBelIIll1Ka,KOTOPbI€6a3I1pYIOTc.HHaIIpaB0C00CC6-
HOCTI1 IpaiK,!\aIDfHa, B 3aKOHHOM nOpR.1{KE CTaBWeM co6cTBetnnD«JM )f(JI!JIbH.
Bo3BO)J.l1Tb 3T11 I1().JI())I(BDf B paHI' npl1ffi.\IffiOB, TOIJ1J€e, ofu..HB.rrHTb I1X TaK(}-
BbIM}[Y C01]JYp;HJ1KOBr JKKXPC4CPHe6bIJl0" HETHI1KaKl1X
OCHCtiaHIIii. fuaerCH TOJIbKO cmt\aJ!€Tb, 'iTO ar,AeJIbHbIe )"IeHbIe, nepepa-
:3IfPOBaBHaMl1BbllllenOJIOiKeHlffirOCKOMJ.fl"eTaJKKXPC4CP,
no.rraralOT, 'lTO K I1ptlHl!\1lliiM npl1Bam3al.1l1l1:1K11J1bIX noMEHI1i1 OTHOCHT-
CJ'!: 1) ,l\06poooJ1bHOC'Ib npJ1JIRTi1H  peW€H11.II 0 npI1BaTI13aLlI1Jl!;
2) IIpaBoBJIaJ\eJIbl\eB npl1Ba KBaPmp":m:I1JIbIX lIOMOB BJIa-
lIETb, 1IOJIb30BaTbCH 11 pacrrOplDK3.TbCH I1M11 no CBoeMYycMOTpeHJUO; 3) O)J;HO-
KpaTHOCTbnp4)coxpaHeHl1€HanepenepI10AlIefiCTBytO-
Il.\EronopsJJ;Ka nOCTaHOBKl1Ha yq:erl1oOecne<lemE')f(JI!J]b!Ml1f;
5) u6cJlpKl1B3.Hl1e "peMOHT npl1BaTl13l1pOB8HHbl: )K}[JIbJX nOMelll€Hl11i, ocy-
lIIecTBJIHeMbIe nomeJlaHl1IQI1X BJIaJ\eJIbl\eB TeMl1 :m:IfmllI\HO-:;IlDI.rryaTaql1-
OHHb!Ml1l1qJrnHIf3aWIHMtI,KOTOpbIeo6cJl)'JKl1-
Ba.III1 3T11 lIOMa lIO npl1BaTJ13altIDt; 6) OIIJ!aTa pacxo.noB,  c
o6cJIyJromaHl1eMl1peMoHTOMnpI1BaTt:IKI1JIbIXnu.feno
TeM iKeCTaBKaM, KCrrOpbIe YCTaHOBJIeHbIlIJIH ooCJJyit01BaHl1H roCY.!\3.pCTBeH-
HOro"rraJIbHOroQ:IoH,!\OBI.
Hecor.rraIillUlcbCtl3JI»KeHHlJi.iC.n['pI1lllileBa,rr.I1.Ce.zr.yrnH
cnpaBe,!\Jll1BO nO)J;MeTI1Ji, 'iTO tf3.IIIDKeHHble nOJlt»f\eIDfJ'! He MOf)'T 6bITbOTHe-
C€HbI K 11J:I1HW1I1HM npl1BaTtl31llltltl:m:l1JIbIX nOMelJ..\€Hl1i1 JI npl13HaHbI TaKO-
.g 1P>\W86Iic.n'BaWenpasoHOCJ>1tta"'WJOii.llO""I<B8PTHPY.-M.I995'C'3.

BhIMJil, TaK KaK BCe OHJil HOCHT 06 XapaKTepJII160 pacC'MJ'aHbI Ha nepJ1-
0.1\ nOCJIe  IIpI1Ba'm3aWfl1» 1.1Ipm1nMaiI: B 06lW1X '1epTaX n03l1-
QI1IO llJ1.Cepynrna, XOTeJIOCb fib! prnyrb. 'lT0 II3JII:DKEIIlff TO'IKa
3peHl1H c.nfpJ1W3.esa He KMeeTHWIero 06Il1ero C nOHJilMaHJ1eM npmW,IIJIIOS
npaea BOOOIl.\€ JI I1J:IflIqHOOB npl1Ba7K3aJ.tlfl1 :m:JIJJIbIX JIOMell1,eIDIII B '1aCTHOC-
m, a n03TUMYnOAlIeJiG1T 6o.neeIqJ OCMb!CJII1Ba-
HJilIQ. Cpe;r:J;l1 ecex nepe'1J.fC'JIeHHbIX c.n['pJmJaeBbIM ID.IDmeHItii K nplfHltl1T)aM
IIpI1BaTIlJ:oofJIbIXnOMeIIleHlfi.i3aKoHRxnIl'kKm141eJ:1epawrn «OIIpI1IJa-
orocpoH,!!aBF'oc:ciH:Kcii4leJ:lepawrn»oTHocm" l)IIpJ1HWllI
JJp!)poBCIJIbIDCTI1 ocyrn,e<.'TBJI€EWI rpam,11aHaMIIJ npJ1BaTllJ3all1I11 )lG!J[bIX no-
HI1iI; 2) IIpJ1H1.\J1I1 O.I{HOpa30BOCTIIJ ocymecrenetnm Ipaw;,!\aHaMIIJ IIpJ1-
BaTIlJ3aL\J1JIJ )j{J1JIbIXnOMID1t1, 3) IIpI1HLCIJ116eenJIaTHOCm OCYJ.L\€CTBJI€lDlJH
rpam,11aHaMIIJ npl1Ba1'lGIlll'llf mIIJJIbIX nOMeI.l\eHI1iii.113 3TIIX TpeX, IIpHMO 33.-
RperwetIHNX B yKa3aHHoM 3aKoHe lIpfiILI>lIX.B Ha3BaHJile .I\BYX c.n fpl1Illil-
eBhlM JlJCKa:lKeHO, a Tp€'TIIl!: He ynOMIIJHaeTCJI Boo6Il\€
BMecTO IIpl1lIW1Iffi.  ocymecrBJHIIUI Ipaw;,!\aHaMIIJ IIpJ1-
BaTIlJ3aL\J1IIJ mIIJJIbIX OOMc.n fpJ1W3.eB Be,!\eT pe%O IIpIfHII;J1ne ,!\O-
6poBoJIbHocTu: nplfHSITIfjJ rpam,11aHaMIIJ perneHlliI 0 npmaTII3al.IIm_. TpY,l\HO
nOHSITb, C '1eM Mb! 3,!\eCb CTaJIKl1BaeMC.f!: BecbMa BOJIbHbIMTOKI:EaHIIeM 3aKO-
Ha ti:,!\epaWfl1 "OnpI1BaTI13aq11l1orocpoH,!\a B Poc-
C14Ie.r\epaI!lm IIJIDICHe6pe:>KHbIMJlC03lJaTeJIbHbIMJlCKameIDIeMero,
nOCKOJIbKY ...npJfHJITJ1HIpaw;,!\aHaMIIJpeWeHI1ifOIIpI1BaTJ1-
3al.\IfI1, JIJ <JJp!'ipoooJIbHo DCylIf2CTBJI€lIm Ipaw;,!\aHaMIIJ npmaTII3al.IIllf
:HI:I1JIbIX nOMemeHJilj.i» .AaJleKO He O.I{HO JI TO :me.
ITpemAe Bcero €Mblti: 3aKOH B aooaL\e nepSOM ITpeaM6yJibI
aIp€.lI€JIH€T, 'lTO OH «ycraII3BJIlfl!aeT OCHOSHbIe Dp:1IIQI1IlliI oCYlL\eCTBJIe-
HHH IIpHsaTH3al(llH rocy,!\apCTBeHHoro JI  :!KJ1JI11Il1Horo
iJxJliM Ha TeppIf1'Cl!JIDl PocCl1ti:rncli 4leJlepaI.II1I1». 0 «IIpIlJHJlTI1I1 rpam,Ila-
HaMIIJ peWeHl1i1 0 npl1BaTll31Il{l1lf"' pe'Ib B 3aKOHe He JIJ,Z1eT JIJ TaKl1e TepMIIJ-
Hbl He co,!\epiKaTCJ'!. EcJII1 ,II,aiKe He npJ1)J;aBaTb CTOJ1b C)'Jl.\eC1'SeHHoro 3Ha-
'1eHI1H TepMJfIIOJI(I'ID1, TaK KaK OHa BCer,II,a HOCI1T  xapaKTep, TO,
no cym, npJ1HHTIfe Ipa:Hl,!1aHIfHOM pellJeHI1.f! JIJ  ero - 3TO
,II,aJIeKO He O)J;HO JI TO me J'panw.am1H MroKeT npllJHJlTh peweHIIJe, HO 6e3 co-
OTBeTCTB)'IOll\e1'O BOlJeI13'bHBJIe 3T01'O perneIDm BOBHe HI1KOr,l\a He ocy-
lI1€CTBI1Tero.
UI,KaKI'J3EeCTffO,CJCyIlf2(.'TBJIHnyreM3axmo'!eHIfjJ,l\0-
1'OBOpa 0 nepe,!\a'le 33.HJ1MaeM01'O Ipaw;,!\aIDIHOM )j{J1JIoro nOMeIlJeHlliI J.13 ro-
CY,llapc'T'tl('HlDfi:JUII1  a:6cTaeHHoCTit:B'IaCTHJ1O. ITpI13a-
KJIlO'!eHJ1JIJ JIJ tDIJJIHeHJ111J ::!TOro ,l\orosopa IIpl1MeHmarCH Bee Tpe600amm It
n.u.)Kw)LJ.f<oelljJ!!ID:"K.IIJI"BjOOB.-M.I't\!1.'P\.""'IIJH<t>PA-M-HOPMA, 1 _
1997.C.:204 

HOJIe JI! BOJIei'13'hHBJJE'tI c.n;eJIKJI. Bur rIoqeMY B€CbMa 3Ha'illMbIM, cym;tIOCT-
HhIM 1l000roI\eID1eM B aH<\JIl13J1PyeMoM npt1He .l\OJDKH06bITb yt<a3aID1e 06
ocyIQeCTWJeHWIrpa)K,/\aHaMl1:naf.TIbIXIDlii, aRea!\:-
L\eHT Ha "npllHHTllll rpaJK,!\atiaMY! pewetmH 0 I1pI1BaTII3al.pUl».
BbJ,1\eJ1eHl4e CnrplillIaeBbIM «I1pI4Hl:pUIa OJ\HOKpaTHOCTJII npl1BaTl>13a-
1.11111" e;:J;Ba JIJ1 MO:?KeT 6bITb IIp'I3KlHIJ Y,/:\a'IHb!M. 3aKOHO)\aTeJIb )'Ka3blBaeT.
<{TO «Kam,!\bJi;i rpaiK,II,aHl1H }(MeeT npaao Ha nplf06peTeID1e B cOOcTaemncn,
6eeI1JJaTHO, B llOJJH.!'Ke npl1BaTIt3aIUm, :mJ1JIoro nOMeIIleHl1R B rocy,1\apC'I'BeH-
HOM JI! MYffi1L\J1I13.JIbHOM :mJ1JII1ll<HOM QJoH,!\€ COlW!3.JIbHOro JICIiOJIb3OE.aH
O.l\I4H pa3(pa3])MKaHaIIIa.-l1.C.)>>(CT 11aaKoHa4'eJ\epa-
1.11111 «Onpl1BaTI13a1.!I1I1oroQx)H,1\aBPocc1rl'K:Irii4leJ:\epaqJm».no-
CKOJlbl\Y 3aKOHO,!laTeJIb ynarpe6.rmeT repMmi IH pa3», a He OWlH «KpaT»,
1l000000.IIbKY no npaBllJJ3M pycrnci'i IpaMMaTI1ID1 t1 no CYJ1.\€CTBY 6o.rree '1eTKQ
Ha.z.O l'OBOp!1Tb 05 OJJ;t£IPa3CEIOCTi'J, a He DJ\HOKpaTHOCrn. YnOTpe6JlHeMaH
3J\eCh en fpHUJaeBbIM" - He '11'0 tnme, RaKHeJIO!11'IHoe
CO'leTaHl1€ CJIOB C HapynreHilleM OObNHbIX IIpaBI1JI CJIEOynurpe6.neIDuI. C
yqeTOM TOm, 'ITO Qm'l1pyeMaE Bbillie HOpM3. pacrIJJI.OKeHa B pa3,!\eJle II «Oc-
HOBlIbre npmilbIl1 YCJIOBMfl npl1BaTIf3aWUlmIfJIbIX lKIIIell..!E'IDm» :3aKoHa
PoccwicllOii 4>eJlepaL\J.l1f «0 npl1BaTtI3aQlli'1 >KM.1IMlWioro QJoHWl B PoccmI-
aroft 4>e,!!epawrn», MbI JI! q.opMYJIHPyeM HOpMaTJ1BH(}-pyKOI3OAJ'Illf2 noJIO-
meHI1e Rail: npl1Hl\1fi1 O)\HOplocy:Il\eCTBJleID1fl f npl1Ba-
TI13al..\ll!l1:HG1J1blXnOM€Il.\eHl1j.:i.
CJIep,y1CIl.tIfli npl1l11m npl1BaTJ.I3alllfli! mlfJIbfl en fpmnaeB o6ooHa'il1JI
KaK coXpaHeHl1e Ha nepexo.n;HbIIf nepl1o)\ )\ei.J:CTB)'!Orn;ero nopH,lJ;Ka nOCTa-
HOBKI1 Ha}"JeT fJ 06eC!1€'ielUle.H\W!UMII nOMel.l..\eHI1J'rMI1» 3To He npl1HL<I1!1
IIpI1BaTI13a4l1l1. a O'lepe.1lHaH lI('JI)rtl'lHOCTh c.n rpmnaeBa. dlopR.!\OK no-
CTaHOBKI1 Ha )"leT JI o5ecne>IeHHe JKJ1JIbIMJI nOMell(€HI1HMI1» npe,QcTaBJlffiOT
c060fl JJIJl'I4'leCIGII1 JOHaJIbHO II3aJ1MOCBSI3aH CIiCTeMY ap;MJmIlC-
TpamBHbIX HOPM, perYIDIpymIII;l1x 0"JH)Il]eIIIDI no nDCTaHOBKe Ha )"leT J\,/IH
YJIY'lWeHI1H:IKI1JDI!lx)'CJDBJIii:rpaif(,!),aHI1 06ec!1€'1eIDUI JIX>KI1JIbIMI1no-
MeIl{{'ID1IIMII. JJ:amlbIft nOpH,1\OK» no cBoei.J: IOpWI'II2CROii npl1po.1le npe.!\-
CTaBJIHeT c060fl a)J;MJ1HI1C'1paTI1BHo-npaBOBoi.J: IIHCTIIT)'T B CI1CTeMe KOM-
I1JIeKCHOO OTpaCJlJI :»G!Jll.fl.l..\Hora 3al\OlfO,l\c1'I'eJIbCTBa. CoxpaHemre 3Toro
JlHCTJI'lYfa Ha nepexo.n;mrn'i nepl1O.!\ CBlf,/\t'TeJIbCeT 0 TOM. '1TO 3aKOHO)\a-
1"eJlb IIpYJ)\aeTeMY CT I1jXJJXJHDIpYH era f}:IBaHIi!e
eIIle Ha on OTpe30K BpeMeIU1. Bo3BO.!\lffb ooxpaHeHHe 3TOra
nopH,lJ;Ka B npl1l11n npl1BaTJ.Iaal..\ll!l1:HG1J1b1X nOM€I.l..\eHI1H HeT HI1KaKl1X OC-
HOBaJIItii
Oqepe,QllbIM IIpI1lIIJ;illlOM c.nrpl1IIIaeB C'!I1Tae-r  11 pe-
Mom IIpI1BaTI1311p(.ti8HHb1:x :»G!JIbIX nOMel.l..\eHlfi.J:, KOTcpUii ocyw;eCTBJlHeTCH
no:me.namIlOJIXBJIa.!\eJIbl\eBTeMVITaI..\ll!OHlfu!MJIJlpe-
I opraHl1aaI.1J1HM}l,KOTOpbIeu6cJIYJoKI1BaJll.f3TI'l1l0Ma
 ll.ofl}JH8aTJl3aWlI1».3ToI1OJI())K('HJ.lnpe./ICTaBJlf!eTc06oflI«»mpeTHyKJHOp-

MJ:1KI1JIJI!IWIoronpaBa,peryIDIpyIOIIJ;ylOI1OC.1IeIIparHOllle-
IDI.RJ1nplfil6epemHoroOTHOweHlf$!Cy6'beKTOBnpJ.lBa-
TIl3a4l1lf K npI1BaTI13I1pOBaHHh!M >KIfJIbIM nOMemeIDIHM.
11, HaKOHeQ, KaK yKa3aHOB 3aKOHe PoccJ1jtCKOH4Je,[\epal..\JUf OnpI1BaTJ.I-
3a'-!J.ll1 :m:JIJIJ1lqHOro 4xUlJW B Poccimcooif 4JeJl:epaI.\ill1», «OIIJIa-ra paCXOJlOB,
CBH3aHHb!XCIDIeMl1peMOIITOMnpl1BaTY!3I1pOBaHHbIX:HG1JIbIXno-
 no TeM:me CTaBKaM, KOTOpwe ,!\JUI o6c:.JJymJ.IBa.HI1.II
rocyJl:apCTBellllOro 11 M)'HIfillmaJIbHI'O :1KI1JIJI!IWIoro qXUlJW». am nOJIOm.eHl1e
MO>KeT6bITbco,IJ;,IO"Crop:>HhI,ItaKKOHKpeTHa.FI:1Kl1JlJl!llI-
Ho-npaBOBaH HOpMa, peryJIHpyIOll\<lH OTHOweIDIH no OIIJIaTe paCX0)10B, CBH-
3aHHbIXCIDIeMl1paMOIITOMnpl1BaTY!3I1pOBaHHbIX:HGI.IIbIXnOMe-
Il.\l'IDDt. a C ,lIpyro - Ra!\ KpYlTepl1if QxJpMJ.IpoBaHl1H C'lUpOHdMJ.! ,lIoroSopa Ha
u6cnym1mamR' 11 peMOHT:HGIJIbIX  0WIoro 113 Taro1X cyru;eCTBeH-
HbIX K3KOILllaTa pacxO.n;OB.
IIoJ\Bo.11,Hl1TOfaHaIDl3YID.JIruKeHl.D\ v&bHMeHHbIXcn rprnnaesblM, BIta-
,<ecrse nplfilOB npl1BaTY!3aW1l1 :HGI.IIbIX nOMeIIlemrn: nOfl1'lI1O 6b!JIO 6w
npe,!J;rxrOOJKlfTb, '<TO 3'J'1I! rDJI())j(eJfJfJ .RKJr pa3Hwe npaBOBble KaTe-
ropYlYl, a no.n;OOHhle o6'be,(\J1HeHlf$! CTpa.!\aKJr, KaK ym.e 6b!JIO CKa3aHO, Heno-
rwrHblM CO'Ie'ffiHI1eM CJrOB.
 aHaJIYl3 3aw:ma f'occI.fiDwij 4Je.l\epa4l1lf Onp11BaTIl3a4l1lf
»MIII1ll{Horo QxJH,!\a B Poocm'irnm'i 4le.r\epaW1l1» n03BOJIReT C )"IeTOM paHee
Bbv:\eJleHHbIXnpYlcyID;l1XnmumIlOI1HCTJ.1'IylI;J.IOHHbIXIlpJ.lHlJ;ll!llOB
IIplfBa'T'lf3aJ.C.fl1:HG1J1b1XOTHeCTIlKTaKOBbIM: l)IIp,lI06po-
BOJIbHOCTIIrpmtl,!\aHaMl1f:lKlfJIbIXnOMe
HIDI (CT. 1 3aKoHa Poc:atitcmii ttJetlepau,J1J.l O IIpYIBaTIl3a4l1lf)J(J1JlJlll(HOl
QxJH,!\aB FbocJn1rncH4Ie.r\£P8.W1I1»); 2) nplfiIIlillI6eCf1JlaTHOCTIfnpJ1BaTIl3aWfl:l
rpam,u.1H3MY1:1K1fJIbIX(cr.11111H3.3BaHHoro3aKoHa);3)
O,[IIDpa3CEIOCTrpam;J,aHaMJ.IIIplfBa'Tlf3altIDI:lKlfJIbIXnOMe-
II1eIDI (cr. 113aw:ma ttJeJl:epaIJ;l1l1 OnpI1BaTlt3aL!lfll:1Kl1JlJl!II1-
HoroQx>H,!\3.B4Je.l\epaqHYI»}.Ha3'J'1l!HOpMaTIlBHo-pyKOBO,!J,Rll.I;J.Ie
n{)Jl().'lKeHIDl,npetlCTaBJUllOlQJ1eco6oi1IIpIfillmJ1J1bIXno-
Mell[eHJ1i.i, )'Ka3bIBaJIOCb p.R,!J;OM JIPYfi'Ix yqeHbIX I .
IIpa!\'T'J.IKa IIpl1MeHeHIDI KaK 3aw:ma F'oIxlfiicwji 4Je.z\epaltlfil O npl1Ba-
TIl3a4l1lf »G1JIlfll{HOfO Qx>H,!\3. s PocarlkKoii ttJeJl:epawrn» B qenoM, TaK 11 311-
KperIneHHbIX B HeM 11 H3.3BaHHbIX n IIplfBaTl13aqHYI:lKlfJIbIX noMe-
ll\eHlrn B ,<aCTHOCTI1 .l\enaeT B03MOmHblM 11 HeOOXO,!J,I1MhIM 
Ie... )/(p1xnBB. npa"aco6GT""HHocrnrp"""",,,HHa83jJTHPblIJPoccH-
CK8RIOCTHW'R.1993 N'15C.12-14.KopHeeeC.M..ODSnB.Il
...."HUlHoro4>oHM.bCTaoMnpaKTHI<il.-M..1996.C.30-32;"nJ1. I
Ilpaar3aW'""'"'I<iiKOCHOaaHHe_npa"acoOcToeHHocrnt<aaapmpy..
:T.-:te(jHH".Q/\RBY300.-2-B"'1A.,nepepa6 "l1on.-M 1.<1a,q. t:i

CJl/CTeM)' IJIulHu;vmoBIIpl1Bam3aLlI1Jl! JKl.fJIbIX 1 IIpI1HL\Jll10M-HOP-
MOi:'i.cpotm:)CTIf $pMJIeHl1ll pe3YJIbTaTOB IJpHBa'I'J.l3aqlt:l1». C yqeTOM 3TQ-
ro IIpe,((JIOmeHIDI CHCTeMa IJIulHu;vmoB WlcTIITYI'a IIpl1Bamaawrn »G1JIbIX
rIOMeu\eHlm:BK.IIIO'-Ia€TCJIe;:IyIOe l).I\06p:>BOJIbHOCTbIIpI1Ba-
7I1:3aqI1U rpa)R,!\aHaI\oll.1 JKl.fJIbIX IJOMelJ..\eHl1iii; 2) 6ecIIJIaTHOCTb npt1BaTH3aI.\1'1l'i
rHaI\oll.1JK1.fJIbIXrli; 3)O.1lHOpa30BOCTbIIpI1BaTl13awrnrpa:1K-
.l\cmal\oll.1»GIJIbIX;4)cp:>'lHocTbo4x>PMJIeIDI.llpe3YJ!bTaToBnpj,j-
BaTmaI(lU1.
TeopeTWiecKaH }I npattrwJeCKaH 3Ha'illMOCTb Ha3BaHHbIX BbDlle IIpIDI-
u;vmOB, Hap$l,1\y C OCOOeIDJOCTflMJI npoHBJIeHWl, 3cutpeIIJIeHlIJI J1.ID1 oTpame-
HIDI :HUlJUfiWio-npaBOBbIX IIpl1cyIIJ;11XIIpaBYKaK
lWMIIJleK<HJi1 0'TpaCJIJ1 B I1HCTmyre npj,jBaTJI3aQJ1I1 )f(MJIbIX nOM,
Tpe6yeT HX pa3BepayrOro aHaJIJ13a.

rnOKO III I
npl1HLll1nbl npI1BATI13ALlI111
>Kl1nblX nOMEII\EHI1J;J
I(AI( 3nEMEHTbi CI1CTEMbl
 1. npOBEHE, 3AKPEnEHE, CYLljHOCTb
III CnE41-1<P1t14ECKMI PO/lb nPIIIH41.mOB
>K1t1/lIllli.jHOro nPABA B HHCH1TYTE
npI'IBAH13ALlIIIIII >K1t1/lbIX nOMEli.IEHJ.1i11
IImtHlnrn fJJaCHOC"l'l( ITIMBaTl'1:3aIIl1tI rnB.:1KlIaHaM1I :1KI1Jll:lX rDMeIIIPHJlii
CaMa no ceGe rJIacHOCTb - Ka'l'eropl>1.R IfCTOpl1'leCKa$l, npl1cyIIW'l CJIaBJ!H-
CKI1M HapO,QaM, ee I1CTOKI1 JIeT B r.ny61fi11' BeKOB. HMKapaM311H mlcaJI,
'ITO« ..HapO.QXOTJj MKHR3bRM, HOCOXpaHI1JJHEKD-
TOpbIe BOJThHOCTH IfB,ltEJIax BamIfu!XJfJU1B onacHoCTflXrocy-
,AapcrBeHHbIX CXO)J;IVICJI Ha 06IW1i1 COBET. CJ.UI HapO,IJ;HbIE c05paHIDI 6blIDl
.a,peBHI1MBropo,!\axpoccJ1ftcKI1x, Y'1aCTl1e
rpH B npaBJIeHmlli! MOfJIJ1 JlaBaTb t1M CMeJIOCp" HEI13BeCTHYID B ,Qep-
:lK3.BaX C'I'pOrDro, HeorpaHWIEHHOro E;J;MHOBJIaC'lWf.'
CoJ\epmaIDIenOHSrrlf$l«rJIaCHOCTb..cooon-
P8.l\emIeTCH KaK «MaKmMa.JIbIIaH OTKpbITOCTb 11 npaB,!U1BOCTh B.l\eHTe1II>HO-
C'I'JlrocY.AapcrBeHHbIX 1100 ,[(etiCTBEHHaJ'i11 aK-
T£1BHaiI IJ:>opMa )"!B.CTI1H OOnrec-meHHOrO MHemm B J\eMoKpanNECKOM
paruEIWnI BaJKHeI'irrn1X npofureM CTpaHbI»2 TIepe3 rnaCHOC'I'b 06ecne'illBaET-
CJjCB06o.D;meCPYJfltW'!OHl1poBaHJ.leB06C'l'Be,
npem,llE Beero TOM ee '!:acm:, ItOTOJ>aH I1CIIOJIb3)'eTCfl (UIDI MO:IK€T I1C!I0JIb3D-
B3.TbCH).IVlH peryJD1}XJBaHWlIf caMop€fYIDfpoBaHJ1JfCOl..{lllaJlbHbIX IIpoLleccoB
Ita Bcex YPOBlUlX, Ha'lJ.lltaH C l1H]UfIllf,ZJyaJIbHOfO nOBE')WHIf.fI J1 RQHtffifl nQJ1l1-
TKKoil rocyJlapcTBa.
OIIbrr,'lTOrpaH[rnacHOCTl1Bpa3-
JIJ.NHble nepl10)\bl t1C'ropID1 POCCID1 ycmIffiBIDlBaJiJIICb HeD){H03Ha'lHO 11 aa-
Bt1Ce.ID'l OT I1HTepeCOB nOJlJITmecKOiI BJlaCTI1
1 K""I1.M. rlpe.o,aH"IIE!KOII.C<a3aHH",,,erelUlbl.paCCKa3b10!3MCTOPHHrocy.o.apcJ8a I
-M 1997C116. u-,
2Kpa"'nonHT"eGkH;;;CI1oBapb._M nonH....:J,I\1IT.1988 C.112 

XapaKTE'ptrnyeMbrn  HBJLF!eTCHROHopMaTI1B-
HO-  nOCKOJIbKY ;Qetl:CTB)'lOII¥I$I KoHcTIt"TJ'W'UI
I'occJ.rlicKoH4re.1l:epaIJ;l1l1 rpam,!\aHi1HY«B03MIDKHOCTb CBO-
60)J;Horo nOJ1CKa nOJIY'IeHJ1H (pa3pH,!\Ka H3.wa. - H.C.) 11 paCnpOCTpaHe-
HJ.fJIJII06OJIcnoMOI03RKOHHbIXCIIOco6oB..(n4cT.29).
BCOnpaBoBoi1H3.YKeo5IIV1enOJIO:1KeHJ1HOrJIaCHOCTIlH3.IIIIDI
OCBeIDIe B 5o.rIbIrEft Mepe B pa60Tax Tam1X roCYARPC'l'BOBe;QOB, KaK:
B.HKY;QpHBl\eB\ B.AKpIDKKOB 2 , B.o. JIJ'ilfH 3 .
KpOMe TOro, np rJIacHOCTIf npI1BaTJ13aqJIJ1 JKlfJIbIX rIOM€I.l.\eHJrli
6bIJl 3aKOHO,!W.TeJIbHO 3aKpeflJIeH B CT. 20 :1KK PC4>CP, B KOTOpotl: IIpfIMO
YKR3aHO, 'ITO «yqeT rpa:1K,/\aH, HJlm,!\a1OI.JJ;VIXCH B YJIJ'illIeHVIJII JKl{JIJ1IWIbIX
)'C1IOOI1ii, YC'I'aHOBJIeHl1e ()qepe,tlHOCTil Ha nOJ1)"leIDIe :IKJ1J1oi1 nJlo no
;QOroBOPY H3.i1Ma, a TaIOKe ee  B ;QOMaX rocYARpcTBellllOro,
M)'H11L{Iffi3.JlbHOro M 05CTBeHHOro :IKJ1JIJ1lqHOro clxJHAR, npl105peTeHI>1t?
.H\I1JIbIX nOMel1\eHMtI: rpa.H\.1I:aHaMJ1 B co6cTBeHHocTb B ;QOMax rocy-
.1I:apCTBeHHoro J1 MYHM1.1:MnaJIbHOrO :1KMJlMl1\Horo 4>oa 0CJII\eCTBJIR-
KTrCH no,D; 06l1\eCTBetIHbIM KOtlTpOJleM 11 C C06J1IO,D;eHJleM rJIaCHOCTJI
(pa3j)H.11:KR Hawa. - H.C.).. TaKJ1M 06pR3oM, corJIaCHO IDJotl: HopMe
JKK PC4>CP (B pe$KL(J1JI3aKOMa PC4>CP OT 6 JIIOJlIj 1991 r t' no)\ KOH'IpD-
JIeMJ.fCrJIaCHOCTJ.jOCYl1\eCTBJJReTCf!npl1Ba-
TJ13al(IDJ:1KMJlbIX =, l1Ha'ie roBOpH, npl100peTeIDIe:1Kl1JlJ1lllB
co6CTaellllOCTbJ'l3 rocy,!W.pC1'Belllloro MM)'H11L{Iffi3.JlbHOro )KJ1.1l11l1\Horo clxJH)\S..
XOT$I;QaJIbHetl:rneroC1«."I'eMIDI'pa3BJ1TJ1j!xapnn'eJ:lnp
B :!KI1JIJlli1HOMnpaBe Ha ypoBHe aRKOMa He nOJIY'll'l.ll, OH npl1CYl1\ aceMJ 3aKO-
HO)\aTeJlbCTBY 0 npJ1Bam3aQltJ1.HOC1IbD: nOMel1\eID1A. OH KaK 6bl IIpOcae'll1-
BaeT 3'1'0 aRKOHO)\aTeJlbCTBO J'l3HYTPJ1. TIpoHBJIeID1e 3'1'01'0 npJ1HqI1IIa COCTo-
J1T B TOM, '11'0 3aKOHO)\aTeJlbCTBO 0 npl1Ba'nf3aLlI1ll! .HOCIIbD: rIOM€I.l.\eHIIH
HOCI1T 0'I'lq)H'I'bIft xapal\Tep.
CaM 3aKOH pocmi1cKoi1 4reJ:\epaQI1>l «0 npI1BaTl13al(J1J1 :1KI1JIJIll(Horo
clxJH,!\aBiIepaIJ;l1l1" He co.n;ep)KJ1TKOHKpeTHOi1HOpMbI, IWI'O-
paH 3aKpeIIl1Jla 6bl3TOT np 1JeoI:ixow1MUM ycnomleM, oI5eme<nmmo-
l1\I1Mpea.mnpafJIaCHOCTJ1npI1BaTl13a1.1:l1l13aIDI-
MaeMblX J1MI>1 .mw:IblX [J()M B JIOMax roCY,D,apCTBeHHoro 11
M)'H11L{Iffi3.JlbHoroOI'04>oH,/\a, RBJIHeTCH.l\OOE,l\eHI1t';QO rpa:1K,/\aH 11
,° 1
'0
'CM. Ky;:r.oo9l.le!B.H.YcKOpeH,*lf!CNXOpa38"TRM8SJIB\,,<6MbIX.
IOPC10B/lCooeTC<ooroCYII"PCTBO..npa"o. 1986.N17
2CM_I(pR>i<I!08B.APa3BMTeM"CTM¥aHenOCpe.llC189""cMMt.IOI<P8TMMI
nepMOJJ./lCooeTC<oorOCYAaPCTBOMnpaBO_1988_N'9
"CM. nJ'MHB,Q, ,,*peH,[lyMMpa3SMTMecoW<aJlMCT>I"Iec.orocaMOyl1paetTeHMRtIBj)O,IIS/I
CoSe.-CKOOrocyA8pCT11OMnp8BO,1986Ni12
.CM.8eJIoMOCTMCbe:\lJ,8l<apOJJ.HblXlIenyraToBPC4>CP..E!ej'IXOB>OQroCoaeraPC4>CP.1991.
N'28_CT93

,I\OJLKHOC'l1IN.ID1II TeKCTOB 3aKOHa PocaiD:Roi1: epa-
 «0 IIpI1Ba'm3a1..l1fJ.! )IOC1UIUUJOfO QJoH,!\a B f'occuiiclIOji ttJetlepau,J1l1 I{
J!PYJ'i'IX, TI'CHO CBR3allllbIX C lD1M &tROHOB 11 IIO,I\8aIOCIIHb alITOB, pery.m1pY-
!OlW1XCTI'KJIl£'tU1H[jOI3aQJ1>f:HG1JJblXI1M€HHOB3TJ1!X
QI'JUIX  BepxomuoCOBeTa PC<+(;P «OBBI'.n:eID1H B,l\f2J1cJI-
BJ1e3aKOHaI'ocmifcKciiclle.l\epaIJ;l1l1 «OnpI1BaTIl3aQJoH,!\a
B PoccJdicIrojt aItJtM» npe;:I,I1MCbIBaeT MTHbIM COBeTaM Hapo,IJ;HblX
.nerryraToB, npe,r:uIpI1JITID1M, Y'<P€m.zIeHI1RM, TO eCTb TIITYJIbHbIM BJIa)IJ'JIb-
Q3.M:1KI1JIbIXnpoBec'fll!oprMepo-
IIplfJ!'l'£1JIno o6ecne'IeroooHaCenemmOnepa'I'l1:BlfOO I1J\OCTyrrnoifJl$pMa-
I1I1ei1onOpH,D;Kel1ycnom1HXnpl1BaTI13a'-1l1I1Ji01JIb!X1.J13Y'1eHl1e
OIIbITa OpraHl13aI1l1I1 IIpI1BaTI13aqIDj :oo1JJbIX  B J1CTOpWIeCKOM
IIJIaHe eT 0 TOM, 'ITO a;<MI1HI1CTpa'-\Hlf ropO,!\OB, nOCe.rmQB,
11yqpem,n;eHI1fiBYCTaHOBJleHHb!XJ1P;OCTynHbIXMeCTaXBbIBe-
lllIfBaJII1 'TI'KCTbl 3aKOHa PoccuncIroti tPe,1\epaI1l1If «0 npIfB<1TII3<Ilt .mH-
oro QJoH,!\a B Pocon1cRa:14'e.1l:epaQl1I1», MI'CTHbIX TIOJIIJJKeHIni 0 IIpI1-
B3.m3aLlI1Jl! >K>fJlJllWlbIX QJoH,!\OB,,D;eiicTBYJOlW1X B rex JIlIDI JlHbIX perl1OHax,
6JIaHKI{BCei1HeOOXQlI,HMOI1, KOTOpaH3anOJIlUIJIBCbJl!npe,1lo-
CTaBJlRJIBCb B KUMIIeTeH'l1INe OpraHbl,  npI1BaTJ13InOO
m1.IIbIX di:(6JIaRKJ.j  JJ;OroBOpOB 0 nepe,!\a'le KBaprl1p,
KBH'ffiH4IfiiOOyn.rraTeyc.nyrnOnpl1Bam3aql1l1:oo1JIb1XrnJlT.n).
 'iTOBI..\I'JlHXc:06mo.I:\eIrnHnpl1HL(lfi1arJlBCHOCTI1IIpI1-
BaTl>13al.\IfI1:1K11J1bIX m J1 00€cne<remm rapaHTHfI era peaJIM3ClqID1
CJIe)\OBaJl06bI,l\OIIOJlID1Tb3aKOHt «OnpI1BaTI13a-
ltI1I'I )KItJ]J GJoH;r:I,a B F'ocOOiCfroj,j ,lI.epa,-",Df" 1IO):M)ii-npI1HL\illlOM
TaKOfO CCl,AepmaHJ.1H: «npI1BaTJf3al(IDJ :m:J1JIb!XOCYlI\ecTBJIReT-
CH fJlacHO. r.naCHOCTb, B'IacTHOCTI'I, CH peaJIbHCif B03MOJKHOC-
TbIO  rpH C 3alroHO,IIaTeJIhcmOM 0 npl1Bam&lqmt.mH-
JIb!X nOMeIIleHl1fi, npe,!\OCTaB.JIeHlfeM MM 6JIaHKOB BCe" He06xo
",cpeweHlteMOpfaHOBOnpI1BaTJl!3a.mH-
JIb!XI1IJMEU.t€IDIii».
ITnmmm co6moJIP.H1U1 caHI11'aDHbIX TeXHlt'JeCIUlX It f:t:.rroBbIx -
Hlrii. KO'I'OObIM .1JJJIjKHb[COOTBeTC.'I'IIOOaTbmMble rn:fIoHIEffiUl HaxQ.!!l1'fBbIpa-
>KeHl1e npe)K,!\e Bcero B HOpMaX 11 npmnl.rrax, .AOrryCKaIOlJ..\VIX
G:\3.'lJB 3KCrr.rryaTa>KI1JIbIX 1J,OMOB, OTBe'lalOlJ..\VIX camrrapHbI/IIIl16bITOBbII'II
Tpe6oBaHJ1flM. B CBOlOO'lepe,!\b, CT. 22 OcHOB 3aRQHO,!\3.TeJIhCTBa COl03a CCP M
coI03HbIXpecrryfurnKoHe,l\OrrycK8.eTaace.rreHJl!e:1Kl1JIbIX
 He COOI'BeTCmYIOUJJfX caHJ.tTapH:b1M 'IpeOOBaHJ.1.RM. OmOCJl K
R:OMII COI03HbIX pecny6.rnm ycraHOBJIeID1e )KIIIDIIWD-ffiIDrrapHbIX
HOpM, OcHOBbI :!KI1JIJ1lWioro 3aKOHO,!\3.TeJ1bCTBa COl03a CCP }I COI03HbIX pec-
rry6JI1.1K )'Ka3lflIa1II1, '1TO OHM He MOryr 6WTb MeHee ,l\eBSITI1 KBaJlPaTHbIX
Me1pOBHaO,II.Horo'leJIOBeKa 1HOBeJIJl0i1,pa:3BI1B1lIOIIIixa- 1
paK'f€pI13YeMbMnp,1!BJlfIJIacbCT.113aKoHa1J.1 

«06OCHOBaX$?,!\epaJIbHoi1:1K1W1nwUfrDJIl'1'l'ifKJl...rn5-
mrn MexaID13M onpe,!\eJIeID1.ll COI:!Ita..JIbHOfi: HOpMbI IlJIOu.ta,!J;H )KJfJ!b$I1. Cor.nac-
H03TOM)' 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbHOM)' 1peOOBalD1IO «C04lffiJIblffiR HOpMa IlJIOu.ta,!J;HEIf-
JJbR 3KBI1B3.JIeHTHa MJ1HJIM3JJbHOM)' pa3Mepy npe,lJ;OCTaBJIetlJ1.If )KJ{JIbIX
I,KO'!'OpbMycraH1lBJll4BaeTCJ10pnlHaMI1rocy,l1apcrBeHlfOi1BJIaCTIf
pecrryfiJIJ1KBCOCTaBeI'occJ.rliDrojiepaIl}1l1,KpaeB,06JIaCTei1,
06JIacnl, aBTOHOMHbIX Ol\pyroo, ropolJ,OB MocKBbI JI CaHKT- ITerep6ypra B 3a-
Bl1C1111tJCTI1 OT .l\OC'J'ill'!1YTOro ypoBIDI :m'.I1.III1IWfoi1 oOecrre'leHHOCTII, COCTaaa
CeMbI'l,npJIMeH.F!eMbIXTJIIIOBJtOfJIbJXBp,oMaXOro4>oH-
,I1a COltlf(WlbHoro HCT1OJIb3CGlHI1 JI,lIpyrnx 4>aK'roPOS».
AHaml:MpyeMbIi1HeTOJIbKOHaCTa;:J;I1J'!npe-
.l\OCTaBJIeHW'I E1fJIbIX nOMeU.\eHl'lt! B I'IO.I1b3l:EIaI rpaHaM, Hy)I<.!:laIO-
CJ1 BYJIY'IllleHl1J1)KIfJIlfU.\llbIXYCJIOBI'IKJI!COCTOJIU.\IfXHayqeTe, HOJl!IIpIf
npeo6pa30BaHI'IJI/arK:IIIEfiJIif co6c:TBeturocm: Ha E1fJIble  B npo-
Qecce IIpl1BaTlf3aql'lif. BeCbMa 3Ha'illMO IIpIf 3TOM, 'lT0 xap
IIpI'lHql1IIBOrrJlOU.\eHJlBPOCCJ1l'lOnpJlBaTlt3aql'll1E1fJIbJ1.
TaK, 3aKOHl'oco1iIctroHttJe;J;epau,J1l'l «OnpYlBaTl'l3aQl'll'loro4>oH,l1a
B PocoIiicKOO np, tfCXOJ\H JI!3 aIIa.!Itf31rpyeMC1'O IIpl1HL(lfi1a, 3a-
KpelIIDlJl HopMbI, KO'!'Opble }lKa3bIBaJll'l, 'ITO He nO)l,JlemaT 1Ip11Ba1
)!\IfJIbIe I1OM€lQl'HJiJI, HaXQIIJIlItIreeJI B aaapJ.IfuIOM COCTO.IIID11f (CT. 4 }lKa3aH-
HOro3aKOHa). a IIpI1BaTI13awrn 3aHJlMaeMbIX1)KIfJIbIXnOMeU.\e-
Hl'lifB.l\OMaX, -rpe6ylOU.\I'IXKaIDITaJibHoropeMOlITa, XOT.IIJlO
B OXJTBeTCTBIDi C Tpe60aaHIUIMH 3alwHa :F'orxW1Ci\OO ttJe,l\epaQl'll'l «0 1Ip1'l-
BaTl'l3aqJ1Jll :!KIf.IDIlQHoro 4>oH,l1a B PoccuikROU 4re.l\epaII;I1l'l. HO:'la HafulIo;J;a-
'I'eJlJ!MI'I COXpaIDIe'I'CH cfu!3a:JmocTb npo1'l360,!tl'l'l'b KaIDITaJIbHbM peMoHT ;J;O-
Ma B COOTBeTC'I'BIIII C HOpMaMl1 oo 3KcnrryaTa4JII1'I JI! peMOlITa
ro4>oH,!\a (CT. 16 Ha3BaHHoro3aKoHa). Co4JllaJIbHbM cMbICJlnepe-
'lI'lCJleIDJbIX HOpM 3aKOHa COcrOI>1T B TOM, 'l'I'O aBapmiHble p,oMa JI.l\OMa, 1pe-
6y!oU.\l'le KaIDITa.JIbHoro peMOlITa JI! Ha.'«IJJ}IIII;I1eCH B TaKOM COCTOmrnI'I, Kar,l\a
OHJl! HeCOOTBeTCTByK1!'camrrapHbIM,  Jl6blTOBbIM'Ipe60BaHJl!-
JIM, He MOryr 6WTb IIpl1BaTI'I31'1pOBaHbL Cy&beKTaM IIpHBa1'K!ffi.\U1 )KIfJIbIX
IJOMeIleHJlii: (rproKJl<!HaM JI KOMIIeTeH'I'Hb1M OJfl'HJI3IiQYIHM) CT. 21-24 3aKo-
Ha:F'occuticKOO4re.l\epaII;I1l'l«0)!G!JII'IU.UfOro4>oH,!\aBPOC-
m:J1cKOO. 4Je,l\epaQl'll'l IIp8,l\IIl'1CblBaJ COfuno,!\aTb aIIaJII131lpyeMbIi1 IIpYIH-
!..(WI TlUOtre IIpI'l OOCJIy}Kl'lBaHI'II'II1 peMoHfe )KIfJIbIX
IJOMf2IQ£'HI'Ii 31'0 HOpMaTI>1BHO-pyKOBO)J.ffiQee IIJ.J1Im({IDIe ocyIQI2C'I'BJUI
'lepe3 HeHapyrneHl1e cy&beKTaMl1 IIpI1BaTJl3aqIDI HeihpamITe'Ta, a TaIOKe
nyreM   0 TOM, 'ITO 3a rocY,lIapcTBeHHbIMI'I E1f-
.llIIQHO-:JKcr1JIYiITaQl10HlIbIMJiIJI! p€lIMHI1IO-cq)(}trreJiblIllMUqJrmIi'23aQ11HMI1
0) 1 CO\iOla11bHaHQP...annOUill.D.l<"'''''abIjJ_roIIJIE!I<''KOTOjXJepaHeeo!\o3ota-
\.0 aoocbTejJ"'""o"'HOp"'a.

coxpaHHKYrCH OOff3aTeJIbCTBa no OOCJly}K>1B8HIOO " peMOHTY IIpI1Ba'rn311pD-
BaHHblX)ID1Jlb!XnO;QoroBOpyCHXeCJIJlCo6-
C'l'BeHHI1KI1 IIpI1BaTIl:3HpOB1l:JrolJIbIX  He 3aKJIIO'ffiT C lIPY-
rnMJ1cylh,eKTaMJl!.I\CI'OBC.PUrropeMoHTYI106CJIy}KIfBaHl1lO
MX:HOIJlbIX1ii
Co6mo)\€HYIe CaHlITapHbIX, TeXHW-Jec= 11 6bITOBbIX TpeOOBaHJl!H ClIO-
cOOcmYeTHa,l\JIemaLQeMYJ1a1OJIb3OBaffiUOJl COXpaHHOCTJ1»GiJIbIXIIOMel.Q;e-
IDIif, a CJle)\OBaTeJIbHO, I1m1fJIJ1!X <}xJH,/\OB l1}lKP€nrremno 3aIOCIIHOC'Ti'1 B
c4:lepe.3ro,BCBOIOOqepe;:I,b,eTHeTOJlbKOOOO.Il-
HOMtf3cnoco6oBaHamnpl1HL(lfi1a, HQ 11 o pea-
Jllt38l!lfJl3a)\a'ioro3aKOHO)\aTeJIbCTBa
IIDJrnwm cra6J1JJbHOCTit nDaBOBOf'O rIO.JI())KeJfJ1 fDaiKlJaH !1DJ1 DOOBa-
TJ1331T11H:Ha1JIblX I1t1Mt'TTIt'llUtI rrfic'mpHlllIKUJ .HG1J111JJJ U 'lJIeHOB UX ceMeH.
3roT IIpYlH!.\J1II 03Ha'laeT npo'IHOC'I'b, . I1OCTOHHC'IBO rpaiK-
]:\aB B :»a1JI1fll\HO-npaooern'l cillepe. Y.l10BJIeTBOp.fUl ecrecTBeHH}'IO narpe6-
HOCTb B »a1.IIbe, rpIDK,/\aHe, OqeBIfJ\HO, He MOIYT ;QOBOJIbC'I'BI:EaTbCH TOJlbKO
TeM, '11'0 B TOT JIl.IDf JfHoif MOMeH1' OHI'! fIOJIb3ytOTCR 3aHJ!MaeMbIM JIlMY!:IfOI!-
JIbIM llCl>lellWmreM.)J;ame eCJII1 rpam.n:aHe nOJlbJy1O'I'CH:HOIJlh[MJI! nOMeIIle-
HIDlMJI! no ,(IOroBopy COI..1l'Jll.Jll>H HanMa 11JIY! apeH)\bI, TO " TOr]:\a npoq-
HOCTb HX npaBOOOfO nOJIomeHIfJ'! B  ccpepe 06ecne'UiBaeTC.II
peaJIbHOii B03MIJ)KH()CThI IIpH06pernTh 11 OT'!pK.1IaTb >KI1JIbIe IIOMel1\eIDIH
J1 :HG'!Jlble ,D;OMa. 3Ta EI03M())!\H(JC' OOec:rrE"DlBaeTCH pa3BI'ITJIleM JI! oxpaHoi1
rocYJ\<lpcTBeIDJOroJlro<jx)HM,reMKOo-
nepaTl1BH0M.YJlPH,AIfBI:!KI1IDIIl1HoMYC'IpOI1TenbCTBy,crrpaBe.r:l-
J1J1BbrM pacnpe,t\eJIeHJleM no,t\ 06ll.\eC'l'BeHHbIM l\Olfl'pMeM )!{J.fJIoJ;i llJIOU{,3.,!tH,
npe.lIOC'TI!BJIMJH no Mepe eCTBJIeHID! 1Ip0rpaMMbI C1J!OJITe.JIbC'TBa
6JIaroyc'I'pOeHHbIX  a TalOKe  IIJIaTOH 38 l\B3.pTl1py 11
KOMMyHaJIbHbI€ YCJIyrl1.
HOBbIe CIIOC06bI 1II xapal\Tepl13)'eMoro IIpl1HL(lfi18 npoHB-
.IlfIKITCJ'IBC03,!\8lI1111)'CJIU1Hi1:,lVUIOCYJ.l..\eCTBJIeHI1f!npasa rpHH8cB060,t\-
HbIi1 BbIfup cnoco6a Y.l10BJIernopelIl1Il narpe6HOCTetf B.mI1JIbe. TIpI>1BaTIl38qIDI
)KI1JIbIX nOMeIl{eH!1J.:irpHaMl1- O)J;l1H Jl3 C!JOc060B )l.r:lDBJIeTBOpeIDIlfno-
1pt'6HOCTII rp8iK,!\aH B:»afJIbe. TIpJlH CTa6u.m.IDcTIf npaBOBoro nOJIOiKe-
HID! rpH IIpIf IIpI1BaTlf3al[ID1 :JroIJIbIX IIIJM€Il[elII1i npoHBJIIJeT cefuJ B
TOM, 'ITO 3aKOHO,lJ;aTeJIbCTBO 0 IIpl1BaTJl38qJ111 -rpe6yer ,I\3.'iJl cor.naCI1If H8
IIpI1BaTl13al.\illO)!{J.fJIorOKaRrpam,!\8H,npom.J1B8IOBmIfJIOM
nOMell.\eHIDf H8 MOMeHT perneHID! BOrrpoca 0 ero IIpI1BaTlf3aqJIl1, TaK JI Tex,
KTOGJaKTJI'iecKlf Henpoml1BaeTB)!{J.fJIOM HOHa MOMelfl'npJ.lBa-
TIl3al[l1lf He nOTepmI lIpaBO nOJlb30BaIDIH MM. B'iaCTHOCTII, CY.r:le6mU! Ko.rr-
JIemlf BepxoBHJro cy,!\3. Pili CBffiIM  OT 21 JlIOHIf 1993 r., co
CCH.IIIIOii Ha CT. 53 ,l1eficTBoBamIEro Ha TOT MOMeHT Il1Horo KO,IJ;eKCa,
ycTIlIIOBI'1ffi, 'ITO '".ecJIJt rpam,!\8He nepecTa..IDt6bITb 'lJIeHaMl1 CeMbI1HaHI1Ma- 1
TeM, HO npo,lJ;OJDKaIOT npo:oo'iBaTb B 3aHl1MaeMOM .1«I1JIOM nOMell.\eHI1I1, OHI'I 

:::;=Ba HHecyrTalGfe>Ke  Ra!\H1UillMaTeJlbJl
YKa3allllbIi1 IIpI1Hl(llI  MHOmMl1 ID.JII:DIreIDIHM}! poccl1i1-
CKOro3al«EO,D,aTeJ1bCTBa. BCOO1'BeTCTEIm: C'l. 2 CT. 7 3a!\oHa1
4'eJ\epal\lill OT4J.OOJU11991 r «OIIpI1BaTIf3a.I..!J1M.mIfJII.1lqHOroQJoH,!\a B Poc-
CltifcKuI'i fI'I B,l\oroBOpnepe,lla'1Y!JKlfJIoronoMeIIleIDIHBcooCTBeH-
HOCTb BI\JIK)I.JalOTCJ'! HecoBepwellllOJIeTHi<!e mu{a, J1MelOlI\Ife npaBO nOJIb30-
BaHIDJ ,l\allllbIM .HGLJIbIM nOMeIIleHt1eM t1 malOlI\I'Ie COBMeCTHO C
.JrnQ3.MJI!, KOTOpbIM 31'0 JtGfJloe nOMeIIl€HJI!e nepe.!\aeTCH B 06UO'1O C HecOBep-
lll€IIHOJIeTHII w6cTBeHlDCTh. RpoMe TOro, Cor.rraCHO '1. 2 CT. :3 Ha3BaHHoro
3aKoHa ,l\JIH cOBepweHl1lI C)\eJlOK B UIBJIIHllIi'I IIpI1BaTJ13Jl}XE1lllll JtGf-
Jlbrx nOMeIIl€Hlfii, B KOTOpbIX np0»C1fBaKJ1' t1MelOlI\>'le npaBO n0JIb30BaHJl!H
lWlllibIM:HGIJIb!MIJU\Hlt€IDE'MHeCOB-He31IBJIC1Il\£1OTTOro,
.HBJIfIICrrCHIDIoHlfc06CTBeHHlfKaMJl!,KJrn'LJIeHaMJl!ceMbIf
co6cTBemu1IwB, B TOM 'lt1CJIe fi,muoo,m" - 'Ipe6yeTCJ'! npe)1BapmeJIbHoe
paapeweHJI!e OpraHOB O!IelGf J1 nO!Ie'lVITeJIbCTBa Ha np:tBe,I\ElllibIt' BbIllIe
HOpMbI 3aKOHOTeJIbCT6a He pa3 CCblJl3.JIaCb CYAe6HaH RoJIJlerl1H BepXOB-
HOro CYAa pqi2, a  OT 6 MaSl 1997 r. OHa IIpfIMO ycraHOB1lJJa,
'ITO HeBblIIJJIHEHlIe )'Ka3aHHbrx Tpe60BaHHji 3aKOHa HBJlHeTCH C)'III€CTBeH-
HbIM HapyweHlfeM HOpM Ma'I'EpHCUIbHClnpaBa 3 .
B coorBeTC'J'BJ1Y co CT. 2 3aKOHa  4Je,llepaIJ;l1lf «OIIpI1BaTl13a-
l..\I1IfroQJoH,!\aBPoccm'He,3aHl1llWOlI\Ife
.mIfJIbIenOMeI.l\€HlfHBJ\OMaXrxQJoH,!\OBnO,l1oro-
BOpy HaHMa J1JIJ1 apeH,!l;b!, BnpaBe C corJIaCJ1H BceX COBMecTHO npOJtGIBIHOIIlY!X
COBepWeHHOJ1eT1D1X 'LJIeHOB CeMlM np:1 3TO nOM€IIleID'le B co6C'TBeH-
HOCTb,BTOM'lt1CJ1eCOBMecTll)'lO.ID15oll:OJIeJJYIO.J1cXO)!fIJ133TOro
3aKOHa, B03MOiKH3. nepe,lla'ia 3aJrnMaeMoroceMbeii }fGIJIoro nOMeIIleHlfH BCOO-
CTBeHHQCTbHe Beex IlJIeHOB ceMHI, a HeKaropbrx J13 HI1X J1JIJ1.na;Ke B co6C'TBeH-
HOCTbQ!J;tKIroJ13I1pOJK1fBalO!l\Y!XB>K!1JIOMnl,ecJIJ1Ha3TO
corJJaCJ1eBee.D.PyrnenOJlb3OBaTeJIYI)KlfJIbf[.
E.naI'()lJ:apHOO:yKa3alllloroIIpnpo'IHoenOJIO:lKe-
HVle 'LJIeHOB ceMbY! HaJrnMa1'eJIR 06ecrre'illBaeTCR C MOMeHTa BblpaJKeJillH ero
BOJlIfHanp:no.)Kl1J!oroKOrOHnOHe3aBlfCl1Ml,lMnplf-
'll1HaM 6bIJI JIIllileH B03M!»KHOCTK co6.nJOCTI1 see QJopMaJIbHbIe IIpaBl1Jla
<$opMJIeJillH ,l\OKyMeH1'OB Ha npi1Bam3aqlfJO. Ha 3TOiin03TBePAOC1'OIIT
t1 CY,l1e6HaH IIpaX"I'IfKa TaR, IIpe3Jl,!l;l1yM IIeH3E'HcKOro 06JIacTHoro CYAa B no-
CTaHEJIeHJ111noKDHKp€'THoM)' lI:eJrYOT 14HHBapH 1994r.:yKa3aJl: «Ec.m.1:IpIDK-
IillH,noB!llIfti3aJ'!BJIeHJl!eonpi<!BaTlf3aI..\l1lf)l{lf.T!bJ'!J1,l\JIH
3TOroI,YMepll:o<$opMJIeHl1lIt1pen1C'!pllUn1l1:0r0BOpaonepeM'le
g l
16oonneTeHbBep><OBHoroCyPC<t>CR1993_N'11 C.6
26ooMBTeHbBepceaoCy,llaPCI>. 1999. N'4.C. 7
36ooMeTeHbBep>«JBHomCyPCI>.1997 W9.C. 13.

)KI.fJI()ro I1OMeeHKH B COOCTBeHHOC'I'b, TO ero CMeprb He.HBJlHeTCH tX:HCEaHIlE'N
KOTI\a3YBYAOBJIeTOOpeIDlJ.1 npaBa Ita npI1B8.Tt13att1f1O)KI.fJIOro 1.
EIIIe OORee IIpO'lliO!' npaBOBOe InOOHreHJ1t' B :m:ItmlIIlHUii c4>epe 3aHIfMa-
!OT6blBlID'leH3.Hl1MaTeJDl! "'iJJeHbIJlXCeMei1, B.I\OM8X rocy-
J\8-pcTBeHHoroJloro:mwn.mtHoro4X:)H,1\8., TOeCThrpa:lK,1\aH!', KO-
TOpbIenpl1Ba:!KKJIble1HJlcraJlJl!JIXL
rpaiK,!\,me,CTaBtlrneCOOCTBeHID1KaMJ.:!npl1Ba»G!JIbIXnOMeIIle-
IDIi1, BJIa.!\eIOT, IIOJIb3YJOTCII JII paCnOpIDKaIOTCH t1MI1 no CBOeM)' YCMOTpeIDIIO.
OIDI BnpaBe  33.BelllaTb, c;\8..BaTb B apeH,!\Y 3TIf nOMeIl(eHI1H, a
TaIOKeCOBepnraTbCHt1MI1.rn06bIeHHbIeC)1e.mrn:,HeJ\eR-
C'I'ByroIIleM'j 3aKOHO,l\aTeJIbcmy (CT. 3.1 3BKOHB PoccIDJ:ari1 4'e.1l:epaIJ;l1l1
«OnpI1BaT>138WJII!.HmJIJI!I.I..\HOr04>oHtl8BPucatitcKoD:epaqJ1M"). Cor.nac-
HO MY:iKK p.p =b co6c'rneHHI1Ka npBBa IIJJIb30BaHIfH
I1J:IlMeM'jII!JIJIII!3'bHTberoMoiKHOJlll!IllbnOOCHo-
BaID1H1v1, 3aKOHOMJlTOJIbKonopellleID11O cy,l\a.
TIn1HI!Jm 6eDf!2KlII'() 0TIDIIeHIUI cvfi1.HcroB rrmmaTl13alrm1 K 1IIJIffiaTIt-
311!Dvt'IIWM>tOIJIl:iM [J(II£ll£'HiIHM. 3rornpl1llI(llI 6epe-rCBOe HB'l3.JIO 11306ll.\!'-
COI03HOro :m:ItmlIIlHOl'O 3BKOH().IJ:aTeJIbCTBa. B CBoe BpeMH OH 6bIJI 3aKpenJleH
B CT. 7 Jl47 OcHoa :HGl.IDllI(HOro 3aKOHO.l\aTeJIbCTBa JII B
JKK PCtt>CP. TaK, CT 10 JKK PCtt>CP OM3b1BaJIa rpH 6epeiKHooTHo-
CIITbCH K .l\0M'j, B KaropOM OID1 npmKMBaIOT, JIICnOJIb30BaTb :mJ1.IJoe nOMeme-
IDle a COOTBeTCI'EIm: C em Ha3HB'IeID1eM, COOJJ!QlJ;BTb npaBIfJIa nOJIb30BaID1H
)l(JIIJIbIMH CrBTbH43aKOHa PoccmbroJinI «CXioc-
HOBaXQ:>e.l\eparrbHoi1:m:11JDflI(Iri1:IIOIDmDDl"3aKpeJIJJRJIaxa
npL<HnB BJ.1,!\e o6R3amucTH II! CITBe'I'C'l'BEt rpail\)\aHJ1 
JJJ1lI6epeJKHo OTHOCJ1TbCHK:oo.1.IllfIIIHOM'j4>o. C He3HB'I]:ITeJJbIIbIM1ITeP-
MIDlOJiOI'WIeCKt1MI1 JI3MeHeHHHMJ'! Bee nepe-rn:CJI!'HHbIe HopMbI CO.1l:epiKBTCH
BmKp.p.IJooi.rrJmHInm(J13BCJJyiKlfBaIOcep,e3H(I'O
EffiIMaHIm) HB.II.H.Ill1Cb CJIf'1e nOJiO:lKeHMH 3aKOHO,l\aTeJIbCma 0 npl1Ba-
TI13BI..\IDI)KII!JJbJ'!,pB3BJ1!BBlOll(II!e"3TO'!'npn: 1)06cJCY-
:HGIBBHJ.le "peMOHTnpI1BaTIl3ItpCGIHHUXmIfJIbIXocyIl.\ecTBJUJ-
eTCH C 06H3aTeJ:JbHbIM co6.mo.I\eHJteII'I e)\I1HbIX npaBI1JI JI HOpM 3KClIJlYBTBW1J.I
J1peMOHTBoro4>oHtl8H3.ycJIOOIIJ!X,yc'I<lR)BJleHHbIX1J)I$IJ\OMOBro-
CY.1\8pCTBeHHOro J1 MJID1l\J.Iill\JIbHOro :mJ1.IJJ1IIIIIoro 4>0Htl8, 3a C'IeT cpe,!\CTB
}IX co6cTBeHfrnKOa (CT. 21 3BKOHB F\x:cm1c:roH epaIJ;l1l1 «0 npI1BaTJ.I3B-
W1J.I )KII!JU1IIIHoro 4>0Htl8 B PocoIlCroH 4reJJ;ePBQll!lI»), 2) 3a roCY.1\8PCTBeH-
HbIMJ.! >KIrnQlKIHHbIMJ( JI pBMJH'I'HO-C'lp!M'I opra-
IDI3BLtJ.lHMJ.:! CO"q)aHHIOTCfI  no OOCJJy}I\J.IBBIDIIO J1 peMOHTY
npl1BaTl13J.lpoBaHHbIX:mJ1.IJbIX 1..I.f2IIIDJ: no .l\orooopy C JIX COOCTBeHID1Ka-
MJ.I (CT. 22 3BKOHB PoccmtcRO epaIJ;l1l1 «0 npl1BaTJl38,-",nI oro
IBepxo.HOroCyP$1994.Nl5
I f:

4>oH,!:la B  epawm,'); 3) KOHTpOJlb 3a TeXHWIeCRJIM COCTOfI-
HJ.leM JI peMOHTOM npl>1Ba'Il13l1pOBIDIHfI'O )IG!JII.1IqHoro 4>oH,!:la ocyuI.ecTBJUIIOT
opraHbIMeCTHoi1CTpaQJ.IJ.lJlMeCTHoro(CT, 25 3a-
:==)HJ.lO::n;::
OTHOllieHIDI Cym,eKTOB IIpJ.lBaTIl3aqJ.IJ.I K IIpI1BaTIlaltp)'8olNM >KJ.IJIbIM nOMe-
I1IeHJ.lRMnpe.t\OO1IaJ'aeTt1XBHa,!tllemaI1leMCOCTO.llHJ.IJI!,aB3TJ.1X
QeJIJIX Hect5xo.rolM peMOlIT 11 KOHTpOJlb 3a ero IIpOBI',I:\eHJ.leM.
TIepl')CTp!JiK:TBO JI nepe!IJl3.HI1jXJBKa :1KI1JI01'O nOMHJ.I.F! 1'1'0 c06CTBeH-
HJ.IKQM MOryr npolf3BOJJ;I'ITb('jl TOJIbI\O B QeJUIX nOBbITIlI'HWI 6JIaroycTpoi:kT
KBapTl1pbI CnpaBIiI3aKOHHbIXI1HTepeCOBJIPYI1'IX co6crBeHHI1-
I\OB, apeH,!\aTOp1B, HaJlJ1JllaTeJ1ei1 JI ,l:\OnyCKaIOTCJ'! J1J1Wb C COfJIaCJ.IR KOM1le-
TeHTIlbIX opraHOB. B MocKSI', HaIlpJ.IMep, B Ka'ieCTB€' TaI\OBbIX HbIcrynaKIT:
rp, rocnC»KHa)J;3.JpJlq:ratD13aW1I1, 31\C-
rutyaTaQlflO, B .r:\PYrI{X cy&bel\'l"ax PoccJli.iurofi:  B
Ka'l€Cml' KOMIIeTeHTIlbIX opraHoB BbIcryna.rnt aHaJIOI'M'lHbII' qI1UD13ffiVII1.
Cb nplfHlI;J.II10M 6epeiKHoro OTHOllIeHJ.IR 
>KJ.IJIbRKIIpI1BaTl13J1}XlBIUllibIMJlMJ.!.mJ.IJIbIMIICJMf2IlWHI'1f 
I1CXO.!{ll!T I13wro, 'ITOnepe060PY.1\OBaHl1I' 11>KJ.IJIb1X IIOMI'-
I1Iemdi: He,l:\OJDKHbI npJ.1IlO,!l;l1Tb K: 1) HapyweIDllO npotrnOCTl1I1JI11! pa3pywe-
moo HI'C)lI1II1X KOHCTpyKL\J.Ii13J]pID1R; 2) YXY,1\llII'IDIIO COxpaHHOCTI1 J.I BHI'IllIII'-
1'0 BJ1,!!a >KIfJIbLX ,l:\OMOB, 3) COBepureHl1tO nepeyc1p01tCTB 11 nepennaHl1pOBOK,
3aTpY,1\HflIQlQHX B03MOiKHOCTb ,l:\OCTyna K JlHiKl'HepHbIM KOMMYHIfKa'-\J.l$lM JI
OTKJIKJ'la1OIW1M ycrpOHCTBaM 3Hepro-, ra3ocHaf))KeHJ.IH. JIMwi, ,l:\onyCTI1B-
llIJ.le caMOBOJlbHoe nepeycrpojtcTeo J1J1}1 nepe!IJl3.ID1poBKY )KJ.IJ1oro J1JIJ.I nOk
COBHOro lDUl, MOryr ObITb 05H3aHbI no CY!1:Y 3a CEOi1 C'l1'T IIpJ.IBeCTIf
3TJ.1 nOMeI1lemmB npeiKHee COCTORHJ.Ie.
.l*f1C'l'B)'IOlQlff:1KK po;tl CO)1epiKJ.IT rurT'b HOpM, Cf16tIICUIbHJ nOCMIQeH-
HbIX nepeyt:'lJXX1c'my 11 nep81JIi!ffilJXEKl' )KJ.IJIoro nOMI'I1Il'mrn, O)\HaKO B
HJ.IX HI'1' yKa3aHJ.IR Ha L\1'Jib ne B 3TOi1 CBH3J.1 CJIe;:r.yeT Of Me-
TI1Th, 'ITO B CT, 25:iKK Po;tI nepeyt"lJJCiicTBoJ1 rIlpEfiJ13ffitpemKa :m:J1JIoro no-
Ml'meHJ.IH MOryr IIpOH3BOJJ;m'bC TOJIbKO B qeJlRX II.IBHliJeHJfH ero 6J1aroycT-
I CT21.22253a'Ofl!lPoccl!IeAepalJ,l<....onpaarn3BIJ,I<"""""IJ.IHO!"O
4>oHJJ.3"PocCl101c'O;;lJ,I1".yJpaTWl"CIIJI}'''CBH3..c"_..eM"..,,ei;;CTB..e)l(KP<%I
(CM.'l!IeAepanbHblM3aKOHOT29AeKa!.ipo2004rN"le9-<!>3..o"BMeHH""l\el'lcTB"e>Klo
nll\HomKQl1""""l!IeAepalJ,l<".J
2c...noP!\!10KOifiop""eH"".QO"YTOBOneperu>atpoet:>t"""bI.",,e"""
n""'""""b"l\o...ax"r.MocKBell>Kw1"UIH""pe4>op""'''rMoCKBe:C60pHK
.QOKyMe>fTOll.-M.,LleHTPpe4>op...e,E!bln.31995
C.72-73.nOCKOn""YY""'!<IHH"'MnOP'\llO'4>oPMPOaanc<lIWI1j,WIKU""BCTYIlneH,,""0I
lI)I)KJ(P<%I,TO""""""CI!GT)IIlIIeH"eMY""'!<IHHoro>KKP<%I"rnny
CIIlrMOCl<8BnOP'lAO"""TOeonepe)ll::TpoI\cree."
nepennaH"poBKe,PB"fIO""'''opr8HbI.pa3{)el1laKX1lL'e''''''3anpelJ.1ilKX1J.'le
I1f!f)eyCJJ)OOcrElO"n......"orooo...eL1ll!H""lWlDKHbll'ibIJbI1j,WlBe.<iI!HbI"CO'
OTBeTCT""ecHOjJMa.....cT2S-29oHblHBJ\eI'IcT"Y"'L1I"MJKKP<!>
 I

poi1CTBa JI YJI)"IllleHJl!H yc.mmni npOiKl1BaHJl!H B )f(II!J!OM lIDII!efJI C CO-
 npaB JI 3aIWHIU>IX UlI'It'pe(U3 ,lIpymx w6crBeHHm0cm, apeH,lla-
TOpOBJIIHaID1MaTeJIeif.
ITpe,l:\\X7aBJIHHcc6cTBeHHJI!KaM>KI1JIbIX.IIC:IoIE'UPU1iiI1paBOMO'ImIrIOBJIa,!\e-
moo,n()JIb.3()B(UIJIJllpacnopIDKeHJl!lOCBOI1MIf(n 1 cr. 30JKKf'<:I),
:'IaKOHOaTeJ!b I1CXO)U1T 113  aooyrIYIpe6neHl1H npaBOM
(CT. 10 rKP<P). Rora  w6cTBemum.cm:»oolbJX nOMeJ..llE1Dtii: npo-
TIIBOpe'urr xapaRT£'pH3y6olOM)' npl1HL\11rry (HecM01pl1 Ha npe.qyrrpem.zleHl1e
JI npt1HHTJle K HJl!M KOMl1eTeHTIlbIMl1 opraH8.MI1 8,!I;MJ1:HlfCTpaTIIBHbIX Mep,
coI5cmemunmnpoJ\OJIiKaKYI', mmpl1Mep, JlCIDJlb.3VBaTbmHJIble
He no Ha3Ha'leHl1lO, HapyrnaKYI' :!KI1.IIl1ll1Hble npaBa Jll1HTepeCbl UJCe.Qeii JII1-
6o06pa!l,\alOTCflc)IDjJIbIMll!,,Il;orryCKa.llJIIX
pa3pyrneHl1e), 1'1) CYA MOme'!' nplflUlTb pellleHl1e 0 .IDmIeID1lf co6cTBemnmoB
)f(II!JIbR.llpaBOBb!MOCHOBaHlfeMJlJlHnp!1H.f!'lWfTaKOi1caJlOnp!1H.f!'lWf
ro JKK P<P IIBJU1.11aCb CT. 293 rKP<P no JlCKY OpraHa MeCTHoro
caMoyIIpaBJIeHl1Jl CYA MCDKeT npJ1HljTb perneHl1e. 0 npo,!\IDtte C ny6.rrwmb1X
roproB T3.KOro.HGlJ10ro rIOMeHmI CBbl!IJl3.roncc6crBeHHl1KyBblp)"leHHbIX or
CpeACTB, 3aBbNeTOMpacxoJ\OBHaI1OllJJ1lHllrecy,!\e6HoroperneHJl!fI.
TIpaBItTeIIbCTBO r MOCKBbI B JII1l{e Mapa IJX:TeMaTWIeclrn JlaeT )'Ka3aHJl!e
npeKTypaMoKpyroB,rocy,!\apcrnemroft:!!:
nJ r. MOCKBbI BbUIBJUITb ,Il;O!I)'IIIeHHble coI5cmeHHI1KaM11 mHJIblX
nOMel.l..\eHIDi HapyllIeHJI!.ij 11 npelJ:bflBJUITb B HapoAHbIe CYJlbI I1CKJ1 0 npeKpa-
ll\f2ID11f npaaa C06cmeHHOCTI1 Ha :HGIJIbIe IUIelIJ;'IfWI, TaKJ.1X w6cmemn1-
KOB-Hapynnrre.rreif 1
2. IIIHCU1TYL.J.I-10HHbIE npJ.1HL.J.l-1nbl nPIIIBATJ.13ALJ,1-1111
>KJ.1JlbIX nOMELllEHJ.1P1
TIDIIHIIim ndjIJ(H1J!},H[)C'JOCVII1P.<"l'B.llP.tlUl ITJa)f(naHaMlfnmB3'Tl13al!IDI
)I(J1l1hIX nOMPlII1'ID1K Xa paK'T'e nplfH flBJIfleTCfI O,iJ;Hoif J13 ra-
paIm1i1 B CQJepe :m:J1JI11l.l..\Hb1X npaB rpam,/\aH JI HaXO)\lIT CEoe 33RpeIIJIeIDI£',
orpa)f(eHJl!e JII IIpOJIBJI€HIIe B HopMaX JIIHCTIfT)'Ta npl1BaTl13aI111Ji1 mHJIblX
nOMel.l..\eID1i1,peryJIlf)JYlOlltHXOTHOrneHIfJI,B
CBJI3J1 C npl1BaTII3aWreJ1 )f(II!J!bJ! B ,Il;OMaX rocy,!\apcT1J€Hl«IO JI M)lHI1I1I1-
I13.JIbHOro >KI1JII.fl.l..\Horo CPOH,IIa. TaI<, B CT 1 3aKoHa PoccJJiiCl«.'4i tI>e.l\epal..\l1l'l
'0.. p""'3parMOO<8"OT10anpe1Kll996rN!'10B.PM.v6yc&<-
neH",,60p06b1COSJlocrH....."t<apyuJeH"".....""cOOJlb30aaH....>KH"bIXt<axQ.lI01- 1
IIIHXC"" cdlcTBeI<HOCTI1 rj}a>K.D,aH" IOj}HJJ.I1'IE!CK... "HLI//>K..""LW\B>I pe4>oP...a"  MocKee.
C60j}H"KHOP"""-"8HblXJP<;IMI'fIID'-MLLeffTJ>""""l1jHOpecI>oPMeB"n1.1"'f"'\
1Q 

«Onpj1Ba-I113<UIJ1Y!)!G'!.IDI!WiorolJxJHJ<3.BtI>e.l\epaL1l1H»orrpe,T\e-
JleHO, 'lT0 npJ.lBaTIf3aqm:1 )!\J.IJIb$! - 3TO 6ecnJIaTHa$l nepe,Tla'Ia B c06CTI1eH-
HOCTb rpam,!\aH Ha,l\lJ6pJBO.1Ib11rii OCHOBe 3aHJ1MaeMbIX 1fMJ.!:HGIJIbIX nOMe-
l.l..IeHIDI B rocY,D;apCTBeHHOM If M)'HIfWmaJIbJIOM )f(J\JJJ!!WiOM lJxJH,!\e
3Ta HOpMa-onpe,l1eJI€IDl, no HaIlleM)' MHeID1lO, BKJIlO'laeT no MeHbIIIei'i:
Mepe.ABa CJIeJIYIOIIIWt cyuteCTBt'HHbIX MOMeHTa. Bo-nepBbIX, 31'0 03Ha'iaeT,
<{TO peweHlfe 0 npJ.lBaT£13al.llfJ.! 3aHm.!aeMoro :»afJIoro IDME;'Il.\eHItH HaID1Ma-
TeJIb I1pJ1ID1MaeT no cBOei1 .no5poi1 BOJIe 11 IfCXO)\f1 113 CBOI1X mrrepeCOB. ,IJ;aH-
Hoe nOJiOiK€Hl1enQJ:IKPE'I1Jl€KHopMOi'i:, nopH,!\OKnpl1B<m1-
3a.qHJ.113aID1MaeMbIXtfMI>1)KJ.1JlbJXi.B'IaCTIlOCTJ.I,B
3aKoHe PoccHifctroif tI>e.l\epaw1J.l «0 np »rnJIJ1I.l..IHoro 1JxJHJ<3. B
Puccnitaroii)'CT3RJBJIaK),'lTOpeweHJ.leo)!G'!-
JlbIXB.noM1lxrocY,D;apCTBeHHoroIfMJHHoro)!G'!.Jll1I.l..IHo-
roclxJH,T\a,(lOJDKHOnpJ.IHJ.IMaTbCHopraH8MJ.1n03aHBJIe-
HJ.IJIM rpaiK,TlaH, TO ecTh yKa3aHHa$l ,I106pa$l BOJUI JlOJDKHa "CXOTh or
:JoKI1.IIbl.l0B, a He or KaKJ.IX-.mf60 opraHoB 11JIJ.I1IOJDKHOCTIlbIXJIJ.ll.\. ,n;aHHoe no-
JlOMretrne 3aKOHOllaTeJJhCTBa H8UL110 mp8)t(E'HIIE' B Onpe,T\eJleHl1J.1 Cy.Qef:tim1
KomIeI'l1l1 :&pXOOHOI'O Cy,TIa PtP or 10 ,I1eKa6pH 1999 r., r,D;e yKa3aHO, 'ITO
«3aJIBJIeHJI!e rpam,!\aH 0 nepe,n:a'le:1Kl1JIbIX nOMeIl1€HIDI B 
JlOJDKH06b!'T'bJlaHenOMeCT-
HOi1 a.n;wnurrpaQlllf» 1 Eo.rree TOro, 3aKOH He TOJIbKO npOB03rJlawaeT npaBO
rpa.Ji<.!l3H no CBOeM)' YCMO'IpeHmO CTaBnTh 11 pewaTh BOIlpOChl npl1B<m13a-
L1I1H 3aID1MaeMbIX tfMI>1 :1KI1JIbIX, HO If npe,rryCMaTpJ.lBaeT B03-
MOJKHOCTb 3a1.l..\l1Thl3TOro npaBa npJ.l era HapyweHJ1Y!, ycTaHIEIfB, 'lTO B CJIY-
<{ae 0TKa3a rpaiK,TlaHJ.1:HY B Y,l10BJIe'l'BOpeH meJJaIDIH npJ1Ba'l'J13J.1poBaTb
381UlMaeMoe :HGIJUfII(e, OH BIIpaBe oopaTIlThC>! B Hapomn.m CY.r:I3a 3a1.l..\l1TOi'i:
eroHapyweHHoro npaB8 (CM. CT. 8 yKa3aHHOro 3aKOHa).
Bo-BTOphIX, pp6p0001IbHOCTh lIpJ.lBaT£13aJ.tID1)KJ.1JIbIX OOMellJ'H!fif 03Ha-
'IaeT, 'lTOBcmtoe I1pHMoe I1JIJ.I KOCBeHHoeel1JIJ.lJJ,aBJIeIDIeHa Ha-
HI1M8.TeM )!G'!Jloro nOMel.l..l€'HI1f! JI! 'LIIeHOB eroceMhJ.l, H8f1}X\BJI€tili Ha npJ.l-
HSITJ.le JI! pearrif3aQ>OO peWeHJ.IJI 0 m 3aHl1M1leMoro )!\J.IJIoro
nOMJ.!MO I1X BO.IDI, HBIDleTCH H€3aWJHHb1M. EcJrn ClIeJIKa no lIpl1-
BaIH)KJfJIbJ! 6bIJ1aCOBepWeHa I1O,!\ BJ!J.I$IHJ.leM 06MaHa, Hact1Jllf$l, yrpo-
3bl, 3JIIJHiIMeP€HlDrocor.naweHl1f!n.I10)\Hoi1CTOpoHbIClIpyroif
CTOpoHOi1 JI!.IDI B pe3yJIhTa'I'E' CTeIleHJ.IJI Tffit\€JIhIX 06cTOSITeJIhCTB, TO HaCTY-
naIOT IDC.IIf2):IC'TB  CT. 179 fK PtP. B TaKl1X CJIy'lamr
CJ\eJIKa MOJKeT 6b!'T'b I1pJ.l3HaHa CY,,[lOM He no Jl!CKY norep-
neBWero.EcJlIfCJIeJII<anpM3H<lHaXOT.f!fu,InOO.ItHOM)'tf3
yKa3aHHhIX 0CIJ00aIDIit, TO narepIIeBWeM)' B03BpawaeTC>I lIPyroif CTOpoHOi1
Bee nOJIy'IeHHoe no ClIeJIKe. TIpJ.l3TOM He Jl!Me€T 3Ha'l€HJ.l.f!, or KOro dCXQJJ;IlJ)()
t!-. 1bBePXOeHoroCy,l19P<!>2000_N!'4_C_20

'ffiKOe HenpaBOMepHoe 1::'rBMP: ar ,l\OJDKHOCTHbIX  oc)'lL\eCTBJlHlO-
IJ.tI1XnpJ.lJlI46ocOCTOpom,I,lIpymxrpam,n,aH.3aKpel1JleH-
HbIifB3aKOHenpl1Hql1I1,(\05p:)BOJIbHOCTI'!eID1Hrpa»QJ,aHaMI1np=-
3aID1M3.eMbIX=)KjfJlb!XrroMeJ.qeHVrl1B,I\OMaxrocy,!\3.pCTBeHHoroJ.l
M)'HHOro mllIDllJ..tH(I'OqXJH]:\a, no HarneM)'MHeIDIIO, 1'aIDK€ OOHaqa-
€T, 'ITO Ha rpam,n,aH He ,l\OJDKHO OKa3bIBaTbCHHe TOJIbKO'Iepe3
 ,D,OJDKHOCTHblX}fJ!)f HHbIXJTh!lt HO I.f co CTOpoHbI 3aKOJJQII,aTeJI.R I.f
qJrnHJB. IX IIIJ,l\3aIOCIHHbIe aKTbI, nyreM yt:.'TaHIEJIeHJ1H B ID1X He-
6naronptHTHbIX cpaKTOpOB, YXY,IJ;W3IO!l.{I1X nOJIO:?KeHYJe HaHlfM3.TeJIej.! >KJ1-
JIbIX noMeIDIii JI BblHY"WlO KX np=TI13I1]JOBaTh  TaKOI1
nyTb YCKopeHl1R np!1BaTl13awrn )Kjf.IDD11: He3aK!EeH. PerneHln' ,lIaHHOi1 npo-
6J1eMb1 B03MOiKHO '1epe3 3aRper1JIeID'le ,D,pyfl1:x IIpIHWUDB, CTnMYJrnpylO-
lQHX rpam,!\aH K IIpI1BaTIl3awrn:HGl.lIJ1llt. tf (YfMeHY pa3JIJ1tlHbIX orpaIDNeHJnI
B 3TOM ,l\I'JII'. C'dicrBetnio. B MOM HanpaBJIeHHU llOKa JI eT pa3BJrI'JIe HOpM
)!GIJII.flltHoronpaBa,peryJIHPyro!l.{l1X0'III'Jlll€HIfJ.B03IDIKa1O-
mnenonOBOJJYnp=Tl13aJ_lfI1IiIOTMeHYpa3JIJ1tlHb!XapaHl1'!eHIdtB
3TOM ,l\I'JlI'. B 'laC'I'HOCTJI, TaKl1M ernMy.IDlpylOM 4aKTOpOM, B K3B€CTHOM
CMbICJIe, HBJUIeTC.II ycrnHOOJI€IIIfe nprra 6eCIIJIaTIIOCTII rlJ:nmaTIl3a'-\illl
:IKI1JIbIXnOMemeHldi:.
B TO me BpeMII CJle,!\j't'T OTMeTJI!Tb, '11'0, npJ.lHilIMa$l ,J:\OOpoBoJJbHoe pe-
rneHl1e 0 npl1BaTI13341111 aamlMaeMoro :m:lfJloro IlOMmrn. HaID1MaTeJIb
06H33H nOJI)"I1ITb H3 3TO COfJlaCYle 'IJleHOB CBOeii ceMbY! (cyrrpyra, COBep-
l.1.EIJHOJIe'I'JJ:e'fefi, poro1T{'.JIeii, .l1PyrlfX, He'Ipy,1\ocno-
C06HbIXB,a BI1CKJlKI'lI1TeJIbHbIXCJIyqaflXl1cOBMeCTIIOCHafrn-
MaTeJIeM npo:oo.'!BalOlWIX JI Be.z:lY1i.ll1X C HI1M 06ll1ee X03f1itcTBoJ, nOCKOJIbKy
OHl1 B COO'!1Je'I'C'TB1f C Tpe600aIuIeM JKK PtP JfMeIOT paBHble C lD1M npaBa
no n0JIb30BaHiflO :1KJfJIbIM nOMellleHl1eM. EcJrn )'K33aHHbIe rpaJK,!I.aHe nepe-
CTaJIlf 6b!'1'b 'iJIeHaMJI CeMbIf HaHMMaTeJUI (HanplfMep, paCTOprHYT 6paR cy-
npyroB, BHpoc1IIIfe ,1\eTK OOpa3JIOT CaMOC'IUR'I'eJIb11He ceMbJII ill T..r:\.), HO
npO,,1\OJIiKaIOT npOjKlfs.aTb B 3aHJllMaeMOM >KaJIOM nOMeI.!..leHlflf, He06xo;J;ll!-
MOl1l1XcorJIaCl1e Ha nptmaTI13aqHlOjKKJI, TaR RaK6blBIlII1e'lJIeHbICe-
MbVI HaHMMaTeJIH >KaJIoro nOMellleHJIIE, npO,1\OJIiKalOlWfe IIpOJKIIB8Tb c
ID1M, TaIOKe I1MelOT paBHble npaBa 11 o6HaaIrnocT1t: C HaHVIMaTeJIeM no
nOJIb30BaIDIIO >KaJIbIMnOMell\eHJlleM, a CJIenmaTeJIHjO, 11 paIJHoe npaBO Ha
ero
B ontOIllE'tGlVI HecoaepweHHOJIeTIrnX 'lJIeHOB CeMbVI CJIe.I\YeT CKa3aTb OT-
JJ;eJIbHO. B nepBOHa'laJIbHOfi pe,1\aKl\J1I1 3aKOHa PocUDia«Jji 4>e,1\epal.\ffif
«Onpl1s.aTU:3aQl1l1:HGf.1111ll(110roQxHI,lIaB4>e,1\epal.\ffif» onpas.ax
HecOBepIIEHWJJIeTHJfX 1\ereM He rctJqJWIDCb. 3Hb nOKill3aJIa, 'ITO MHOl'l1e
HeCOsepweHm.JJe'T'I J\eTI1. B npol\ecce npVJBaTJ.f3a :!KVIJIWlI1X po,1\VITe-
JlfIMVI OKa3aJ111!Cb H3. YJiVILle. B l..\eJUIX 3all(VlTbi 3aKOHHbJ:X np3B JI !lIH'I'epecOB
HeOOB 3aKOH POCQliK'KW 4reJ:\epaI1J IR «0 npJllBaTJ.f3al.\ffif I
:HGIJII.{ll(IIoro QxHI,lIa B PocclliicRoii 4>e,1\epa'-\ffi'l» 6bI.Tll:! BHeceHbI J13MeHeHJUL 

B pe,i:\aKIV1!1tI>e.l\ep3J1bHOI'O 3aKOH3 «0 npJ1B<mj3aL{l1l1oro<jxJH,ZIa B
4>e.n;epa1!l1H» OT 11 aBrycra 1994 r. ::JTOTBOnpoC pewaeTCHCJle-
.II.Y1Oll.IJ1:M OOpa30M: 1)  OT 1411.0 18 JIeTnplf06peTalOT
.m>1JIbIe nOMellleHr.tR B co6cTBemJocn, Ha 06lltJ1X 0CH0BaHIfRX, npe;r:J;yCMO'Ipt'H-
HbIX 3aKOHO.l\8.TeJIbCTBOMOnpillJaTIf3aQ1II; 2) :HG1JIbIenOMIDffi, BKOTOpbIX
llpC.IJtGIE&OT "CK.JllO'U11'eJIbHO HeCOBepWeHHOJIeTIDfe B BOOpaCTe.l\O 15 JIer, ne-
pe,i:\a1OTC.F! WI! B co6CTBeHHC:lcrb no 3aHBJIeHlOO PO,JJ;WreJIei1 ),
Ol1eKyHOB C npe1J,BapltTeJIbHOI'O pa3pellieIDUI OpraHOB OI1elGl " 11011e<rnreJTht:I'-
Ba; 3) )lG!JIbleI1OMeIqeID1R,B KO'I'OpbIXnpoilGlBalO1'lHeCOBep-
WeHHOJIeTHI1eB B03paCTeOT 14.1\0 18JItT, nepe,!\alOTCHWI!BCOOcrBeHHOCThno
I>1X 3aHBJIeHl1lO C CO!'JJaCJ1Jj po,rurre.rrei1l)'{HOOlJlrrenetiJ, IIiI1E'ilrrenEtt" opra-
HOB OI1€'KJ1!" nol1e<mTeJIbtTBa. EcJrn npJl! pellleHJl!ll! BOrI)JOC3. 0 npJl!BaTJl!
}KJI!JI()I'OIIM:tlJ;'IDUl6Y.1\e'fycTIlHlJBJ1elI!'ITOImJ-ID!60t£3:yKa31lHHbIXJOO.!,TO
eCTb JOO.! ,Will" HaHJI!MaTeJn, l1MeIOi.qI1X npaBa IIOJIb3OBaIDIjI:m'1fJIbIM I1OMeIlIe-
HJl!eM, B03pIDKaeT npcrrnB npillJaTJl!3a!.1Jl!ll! :!KJI!JIoro  (EieooTItxJJ-
TeJIbHO K MOTI1BaM -raKOI'O BO), TO 0cyIL\eCTB1fI'b ee HeB03MmKHO HJI!
npl1 KaKJ1X o6cToRTeJIbCTaax, TaK KaK 3TO n)XlTJl!OOpe'UfT np ,!\oopo-
BOJIbHOCTH ocy:Il\eCTBJIeHJl!fl rpam,I\aHaIlW npillJaTI13aIlKJl! :HGIJIbIX nOMellle-
HIDi. EcJrn npH OOJKmIlW cwryaI..m JIill\O OOpaTI1TCIlC
"CKOM B CYlJ" TO OH He BrrpaBe lJ,aBaTb oIleHKY 060cHOBaHHOCTJl! MOTJIlBOB OT-
Ka3a OT nOJI)"IeHl1.f!)KJI!JJbH B c06CTBeHHocTb, a "CK B TaKOM CJJyqaE' He nO)J;-
J1eiKJ.fI'YHJI! npl1KaKIIXOOcrosrre..nhcm
ITmHIum6em=TIlOCTII nl1dBm1fR3lI11J1 J'11a)K]ffiHaMi'lJRI'JJIHXIJIJME'IIIP-
.!:illi.i3roTnp1I3aKpellJIeHBHOpMe3aKOHa,CBIOTOM,
'iTO npI1BaTl13a.I1I1.f!.m>1JIbH - 3TO «6ecnJIaTHan (pa3pH,I\Ka llama. - M.C)
nepe,i:\a'ia B cOCicrBeHHocTI, lpaiK,!\aH PocCJJCKOJt 4>e.l\epaL1J1Yl Ha ,I:\OOpO-
BOJJbHOfi: OCHOBe 3aHJ.lMaeMbIX JlMJI :HGIJIbIX IIOME:f1{€HJIi1 B rocY,!\apcTaeH-
HOM JI M)'lII1IIJIII3J >KIfJIJill(HOM 4JoHlJ.€» (CT. 1 3aKoHa Pocclrlicfwif
tI>e.l\epaL(m1 «0 npl1Ba"I'IJ38WDI oro 4JoH,Zla B Poccnifaroit tI>e.l\e-
pa'-\ill1»). XapaKTep£13YeMbm l1pilIHIIJ.lI1 npe.1\CTaBJIHeT co6ofl6e:mooMe311.-
Hoe oopallleHilIe B co6crBeHHocTI, rpaiK,!\aH 3aHJ.lMaeMbIX JlMI1 >KJ.lJIbIX no-
Mell\eHJIJ.:!, txCH B ,!\OMax roCY,!\apCTaeHHoro JI MyHJ.lLrunaJibH()f()
)KJ.IJJJ.lIl.plOroclJoHlJ.a.
3aKOHo.n;aTeJIb, K3.K  He cPa3Y 3aKpeIDUl aHaJIt£3l1pyeMbm
I1pJ.l B 3aKOHe. TaK, B nepaOHa-'ffiJIbHOfi peJIa.Klt'DI 3aKOHa PoccmbroJ1
4>e,I:lepaQRIf O npl1BaTJl!3aL{l1l1 :m:I1JJJIIWioro <jxJH,ZIa B I'I:JccmtcKm: tI>e.l\epa-
L{I1I1» yc-raHaBJrnBaJIOCb, 'ITO npJ1B<mj3a Ip3)!(,!I,aHaMJf :!fOI!JIbIX nOMeIlIe-
HJ.lH, HaxO.l\mu;I1XcH B rocY.l\8.pCTBellllOM JI MJ'HIflUmaIIbH('IIoI »G1JIJIll(HOM
4JoH,l\e, OCy:Il\€CTBJIHJIaCb K3.K Ha B03Me3.n;HbIX Ha'laJIaX B nopH,!{Ke npolJ,IDKJf
.mwIbIXn TaR JI  - HaOCHOBe6ecnnaTHoitnepe-
l .Aa<m rpa»Q:\aHaM.m>1JIbIX nOMeIl{eHIDi. EeCI1JIaTHO:HG1JIbIe nOMell\eHlfJI ne-
\.0 pe.n;aBaJIJIICb B c06CTBeHHOCTb rpa»Q:\aHaM [10 HopMe IB KB.M 06Il{ei1 1IJI0Il{8.-
t'- ,!\J.I Ha O.l\Horo 'iMoaeRa JI ,I1(I1VJIHJ.I'I 9 KB. M Ha ceMbIO. EcJrn )KJ1JJaH

IIJIOIWl,!{b npeBbuna.rra )'R33aHHbrn pa3Mep, "I'O OHa nepe,!\aBaJIaCb aa yCTa-
HOBJIeHflYIOlIJlaTYCY'1eTOMKa'leCTBmJ1JlhJ'l1.
3Hbn0Ka3arra, 'lTOTalmi1CMHIIaHHb1ttIIJIaCIIOCoEi
IIpIfBaT1'I3al..\l'Il'I>KI'IJIbJXHeCl1OC06cTByeTyaeJIWJeHl'lIOKOJIWle-
CTBa w6cTaeHmdwB Ita pbIHKe >KI'I,JIbJI. B <lTI1X l..\eJIflX, a TaKme B l..\eJUIX CTI1-
M)'JIlfpOBaHIDI rproK.!I1lH, :!KeJIalOlW1X npl106peCTII 3aHl'lMaeMbIe I1MIf :HGIJIble
IDMEIQ2HJtH B co6CTeefrHocrt" B 3aKOH PoccJrlkt«rn tI>e.l\epa{If «0 DpIfBa-
TIl3amI>1ITI1IIWoroQxJH,Z\a BPoccw1llirn 4Je,r:r,epaI1Ulf» 23l\eKa6pi11992 r.
6bL1IJ1 BHeceHbI M3MeHeHl1H M .l\OIIOJIHeHl1H If 3aKpenJleH npmum 6eCIIJlaT-
HOCTlfnplfBaTlf3<U 3aHlfMaeMbIXMMJ1mJ1JlbIXIJOM.'I.l.\€ffif1'i
B,AOMaxroCY.l\apcTBeHHoro" MJ'HIfWIIE.J]NIOI'O>KMJIJ1IW10rO QxJH,Z\a He3aBI'I-
cl'IMooTeropa3MepoB2.Cy5'beKTbIPocCJfiIcKoHBCOOTSTBY-
IOX HOpMaTIfBHbIX aKTax He TOJIbKO  xapaKTepJ.f3YeMbill
npmum, HOMo6ecIIe'il1JIl'leroopraHIf30aaBB03apaTl\eHeiK-
HbIX CYMM - 1\OIIJlaT TeM rpam,1\aHaM, KOTOphie ocytIleC'l"BIfJII1 paHee nplfBa-
TIl3aIlIOO mvlJJbIX nOMeIIleHVrl1 Ha OCHOBe CMeweHHoro IIJIaTHO-6eCIIJIaTHoro
ClIOco6a 3 .
IIpaBITT'eJIbCTBO r. MOCRBhI, pa3pafuraBIIIee IIo.nomHrne 0 IIpI1BaT\f3a-
QI'IIf (6eCIIJJaTHOM nepeM'ie) >Kl'lJlMIWIOro QxJH,Z\a B r. MOCKBe, KOTOpae YT-
aep.l\IfJIIIct>e.l\epal..\ffif,nOWJIoel.l..\e,l\aJIbwe,pacnpo-
CTpaIDfB c4Jepy  3TOro IIpI1HIl;illla Ha IIpI1BaT\f3aIUOO Ipa:?K,!:laHaMif
H€TOJIbKOCYr1\eJIbHbIXKBaprnp, Bl\OMaxrocy,!\apCTBeHHoro 1'1
M)'HI'ILII'IrraJIbHOro mJ1JllfIqlloro QxJH,Z\a, HO M CYrl\eJIbHbIX KOMHaT, pacnOJIO-
:!KeHHbIX B TaK Ha3bJBaeMbIX KOMM)'HaJlbHbIX KBapTIlpax. BecIIJIaTHaJI nepe-
,l\a'la TaKI'IX KOMHaT B c06cTSeHHoCTb (X B H!'IX Ipam,1\aH ocy-
l.I..\ecTBJIHeTCfI IIpIf cor.rraclfl'l HaHI'IMaTeJlei.J: BCex KOMHaT Ha IIpIf06peTeHI1e
:HGIJIbJ'I B COOCTSeHH0CTb 4 . HaM  'lTO 3Ta HopMa BBe;J;eHa
'1iI3BecTHo,rocorIlaCHOpe.D,8IIMHSToro3ao><arpa>(,ll,3><3MnpeI1OCTae-
IlRllOCbIlp3BO"a"'H...ocyw,eCTOJJSOTb"""HTaIlbH,,pe"'OHT"'lII1b",HO
.T1IKO"'CIlY'<aeopraH",o15"3aHbl6",nHH"'CTOI1MOCTbH3paC-
Hape"OHT"pe,!1CT"("...OOJOPCYM6HOIlp3KTHKH.OHeKOTO-
p","BOnpoca.B03HHKw""npHpaCC"OTpeHHHCyQaMH.QeJl.CSR3aHHbI'C
rpa>l<A3><3MH"'Hn..'1t61oJ\neTeHbBep'OBHoroCy.c.aP<l>.I994.N"2
2c...:3a.OHctlep.epatJ,HH.oeHeceHHHOI3MeHeHH..e3aKOHPoc-
cHio:;ci;j)3IjHH.ollPHea-rn3aIlHH"'HHLllHcro4>oH,@.<tIeAepaU,H...JJ
BeJ\OIdOC1HCbe3J11lHapoJJ,H"",p,eyraroBC!Je.<\epalJ,HHHBep'oBHoroCoeeTa
PocC\'lCI<oo;ctlep.epaU,H'" 1993 N"2.CT.61
3C....06ecnnaTfIO"'III1"LllHoro4>oH,@erMOC'BeIlPB8H-
TBnbGTilaMoc..blN"l99H!lPHIlO>o:f!HHelKnocra>iOOJIBHHtOrlpa.,mmbGTilaMoc.BblN"63.-
IlOllO>l<eHHeOf1JJHearH3alJ,H"I6ecnnarflOnepe.D,8"el>lMl1"LllHoro4>oH,@erMOCK"e.YT"
YK3"OMr1peJHJ\eHTaPolx:i<iJic"""ctlep.epalJ,HHOT12HlIBJI"lgg2rWI611)t(HIl"L1jfIBSIpe-
4>op"'aBr Moc.ee CopttH'''opMaTHBHbIX.I1O''Y_TOB. _M. UeHTpCOAB!icT_"'III1"IIi-
HoI\pe4:tOpMe 1994. Bbln.I '4.1 C.96-99
4T3M"'e,c...n1nOO_HHO(oeCr1ll8lHOOIInej)B,<la'le)4tOt<JJ,a 1
er MocK"e. Yra. YK3Jo...IlpeJHABHTaPoccHLb<oC!Je.<\epalJ,HHOT12H""P" 1992I:NIII6. - t--
B.." 11994.'11 C.9B t--

TIpamrre.IIbCTBCI f. MOCKBbI JjCXO)\ff Jj3 3aIIV1TbI JKlWJIIWillX IfHTepeCOB
rpaHtfnpaBHa6eC!IJUlTHyronepe,!\aqyt1MB co6crneHHOCTbCJIYme6HbIx
KBapTIlP tf KOMHaT.
Jf.::Eecrtro, 'ITOcor.naCHO.AeiicTBoBaBweMy JKK PCqJCp npaBOBOi1 p€*I1M
cnyme6HOro :mJ1JIDro nOMeIIleHIDI Jt3IIoIelIfleTCH, €CJThI rpam,rwHIffi I1}XJmIf.II B
CJl)'JKe6HOM nOMe!l[eHl1K He MeHee 10 neT, OTpaOOraB Ha npe.IUIpHHl'I'Il, KOTO-
POMYKBapTIlpa t1JThI KOMHaTa, He MeHee lOneT. Ha TaKOeCJIY-
meoHoe :!Klf.lloe nOMelJ..\eIll1e, no cJ!l[eCTBY. pacnpocTpaHIJeTCJI pe:lKl1M mI{-
JIbH, HaXO)\nw;eroCff B rocy,!\apcrneHHoM J'lJIJI M.)'HHOM :H01JIJI!l[HOM
clx>H,!1e l . B JlJlTeparype O'I'ME."iClJJO, 'ITO 6bIJIO 6b1 npaBIfJlbHbIM Jj cnpase)\-
JIJIBbIM, ecJ1Ji16b1l\JJ;MJ1HJ1CTjJa'-1J1.H TIpe3Jf)\eHTa PtP IfJIJ1 TIpaBJ1TeJIbCTBO PtP
peKOMeH,!l;OBaJIl.'l cy6'beKTaM PocCI1itc!«jj tlJe)\epal..l;l1J'l3aKpeffiTl'b B llonOiKe-
HID! 0 6ecrmaTIlOi1 nepe,!\a'le (npI1BaTIWqmI) oro clx>H,!1a HOPMY
CJle.1JYlOll\!'1'O co.z.epiKaHl1H: «Pa3pewaTb 6eC!IJUlTH)'lO nepe,!\a'l)' B co6crseH-
HOCTb (npl1Ba'T'l13a'-\l1lO) CJJyiKeoHbIX KBaprl1p (KOMIlaT) np£1 ycoosmr, 'ITO
IpIDK,/\aHe IIpOJKI1JII1 B ,QaHllOti KBapTIlpe (KOMHaTe) He MeHee 10 JleT tfnpopa-
OOraJMHa npe)l(I])mmrn, B )"IpeiK,!!,eHI1I1,, KOTOpoM)' npl1Ha,!I,-
JleiKl1T ,QaHHaH KBaJYI'l1Pa (KOMHaTa), He MeHee 10 neT».
ITmlHIlIDI 0lJH()t:E.'IDBOCTI1 OCVlIF.CTBlJf'tlliJj I'DIDK1IaHaMK IIIJmBaT113a11ID1
mMbIX rnMeIIHItlii HOpMa'TI1BHO€' 3aKpellJleIDIe 3TOro nplfHltl.ma BblpaiKa-
eTCH B 'TOM, 'ITO .1 rpa:IK,!IaIIIffl1MeeTnpaBOHa npWJf:ipeTeHl1e B cc6cr-
seHH0CTb6ecrlJlaTHO,BIIOpffAl{eJKI1.TIOrOBrocy,u.ap-
cmeHHOMJ'IOMMcixJH,11ecoqHaJIbHOroI4Cl1OJ1b3OBaIDfH
O.J:\J'lH pa3 (pa3pH)\K1l Harna. - S1.C.) (CT. 113aKoHa  tlJe)\epam
«OIIpHBa'TJoroclx>H,!1aBPocCJlj.i(wiitlJe)\epaW1Jl!)
Co xapaRTep13y€M)rD np  'TeM, 'ITO Y
KaJoK,iJ;ororpaiK,Z\aHJ'!H3.JjMeeTCffB03MOJKHOCTbTb:!Kl1Jloeno-
,Ha B J\OMe rOCY.J:\apcmeHHoro IfJIJ1 M)'lilllIl.fi1aJIbHDro
:JiOI.III1lWIoro clx>H,!1a 'TOJIbKO O)\l1H pa3. ITpaKTI'!Ka eT no 'TOM)' nyTl1, 'ITO B
l\eJIf!X  KOlITpDJ1fI 3a QIJ;HOpa3OBUCTbIO npl1BaTl133.l\III1 C
fpaH, K!MeH1IBlill1X CEO€' nOCTomrnoe Mecro :HGITeJIbCTBa Jj :m:!'JlaIOmJ1X
npl1B3TI13J1!poBaTbJKl1JIble IlIJMt'lfI no HOBOM)'Mecry :lKJl!T!'JIbCTBa, 'Ipe-
6Y1O'f ,lJ;OR)'MeHT, TO, 'l'TO paRee3aID1MaeMOe :mJ1JIoeno-
Me!l[eHJl!e He 6bIJIO I1pI1BaTII3ItpO EcreCTBeHHO, 'ITO peaJIJ'!3aql1Jl :ITom
npJl!Hl\I1TIa3amDl'TOTnpmilJ;lma,l\OOCJll[€C1'BJIeHl1.F!IpaiK,1\a-
HaMJl!npI1BaTJl!3al\l1Jl!:m:J1JIh!X
R- I
1)I(KP4'xorn")'I<83b1aa8THaro,'lTO.IJ,OrOBOPHa;;..aCI1)l>Kf!Horo",,,,,orol1O.
ldeUWHH" 3aKIlrn3eTC" H3 nepHW\TPYAQllblXfJIHDIl.O'fri,npoX=eH,," cny>K6'" mt!5oH8
XO*J\OO"'H3,l\OJDKHocrnP4',,l\OJDKHocrn<¥i'beImlPc%l
WlHHaB",l5opflO.IXfIII:HOC'I".HDHecB<l3b1aa8TY"a:!aHHblxc
U......fiH60KOHt:peTHbI..CjJOI<OId n0K3HHXTO"31<D1dr1frrE!Hnt0jJrat108t<epa30.CHIIJI.
To4>aKTHCTe<IE!H""3Torocpot;anpeoOpa3yeTnpaBO.O;;pe>KH"CIIjIJKfOoro"",,,oronOME!.
IljeHH"Bpe>a<""'IIJIoronoMel1j""H",Hax<JJI"uwrOC>lBooyp,apcrneHHOIdWlH
HO..>KI1I1Hl1jHOM<!>oH,l\e

He npOHBHB ,(\05poi1 BOJIJI!, [J)am,1\aHI1H MmtreT HI1KOrJl3 He pea.mt:>IJBaTh
np  npJ.lBaTM3aQlm:!KJ.lJlOro nOMeHlfR J1 I1OJIb3O-
BaTbCH JIM Ha OCHOBaHJ1J.I paHee aaKJIlO'!eIDJ01'O Jlo1'OBOpa HaMMa. B OCHOBe
3TOro npmw,J1Il3. JIe*>'IT Jl06paJi BOM 1Ha, aaHl1M3.tOllIe1'O :lKJl!Jloe
te,H3.BJlOMaxrocyJlapcTBellliorOJ1JIJ.1MYHJIh-
HOro :HGIJIJ.IlI1Ho1'o QxJH,Z\a, a He 1"1'0 ofu!aaHHOCTb. CorJIaCHO ::lToi1 HopMe KOM-
neTeH'l'Hble rocy,llapCTBeHHbIe opraHbI, npe.l\!1PI1f!TI!Ji J1 }"Ipem,!!eID1.j'I Bnpa-
Be BbIKymITb Y rpam,!\aH C J1X cor.rraCI1f!:xrnJIbE', np 11M Ha
npaBec:OOcTaeHHocm,ClIeJIbI06cmeee1'O'.
Bo3H11KaeT, OJ\H<lKO, BOnpoC: KaK6b!Tb B roM CJIy'ffie, eCJIJI B nOPflJlKe CT. 17
YKf:I3aHH01'O 33KOHa Ha3BaHHbIe opr3HbI BbIKJTl3lOT npmaTII3JlpOBaHHIJe
:»G1JIDe nOMeIl.\eHJ.Ie Y rpa)J\,!laIDfHa. tJ3XO.l\flwerocJ'l B O'!epeIDI Ha YJIY'Dlle-
IDIe:lKJl!JIilll(HbIXycJIOOJIIl"
Bo-nepBbIX, TaKOeJ1CKJiIO'IeHJl!eIIpE'CaMl1M3aKoHoMnpJ.IMe-
HlfI'eJThHO It arJleJIbHbIll! cy6'beKTaM TaK, J\epaJIhHh!M 33KOHOM ar 11 aB-
ryCTa 1994r N'Q:!fi-4I3BCT.113aKoHatI>e.l\epawrn«Onp=TM-
3aqHIl! »GIJIJIIl(Horo QxJH,Z\a B PoccniiCKOil tlJe;J;epal..l;J1W' BHf'eeHO,I\CI1QJIH6IJIe,
corJIacHO KOTOPOM)' HecOBepIJeHHOJIeTInte, CTaBIIDle  33-
HJ1MaeMo1'O :!KI1JIoro nOMeIl.\eHJ1H B nOpH,1\Ke eronpJ.lBaTIlJ3aLll1Jl! «coxpaHmoT
npaeo 113 o,!J;HoKpa'l'1l)'lO 6eCIlJIaTH)'1O npJ.lBaTI13aLlIOO:!KI1JIoro HKH B
.l\OMax1'Ocy,!\3.pcTBeIlHoroJ1mI1Jll1Il(HoroQxJH,Z\anoCJIeJlo-
C'IWt\eHJ1H=IH».
TaKJ.IMOOpa30M,JICK.JIICI'leHJI.f3npOCCTB-
JIeHID! nplfBaTIl3a!.\IDl! :!KI1JIoro  C)\eJIaHO B IIOJIb3)' HeCOBepIIEH-
HOJIeTHJ1:X. Bo-6TopbI:x, JDt.III()<{('HJe 113 3TOro npl1H!.\J'!na MomeT 00Jm1.I'It>CH
B KOHKpeTBbIXCmyHXnpJ.l pearrif3aQllJ1 onpe;J;eJIeHHbIX YCJIOBJ.lH.
n '!TO ecJIJ.I KOMIIeTeHTHbIe rocYJlapcTBeHHHE' Opr3HbI,
npe.l\!1PI1f!TI!J'I JIJII1 y<Ipem,11eHJl!J'I OOycJICEIIfJIH npe.110C'I"aBJIeHJ.le O'!epe,ltl1lmy
KBaJITl1Pbl nOCJIe Bbncyrra  YHero KBapfl1pbI I1BbIKyn3ID1 paHee
3aHJ.lMaeMDe JIM :!KI1JIoe nOMel.I..leHJI!e B nopflJlKe,  CT. 17
3aKoHa  JlepaqHIl! «0 np.maTII3aI.tIni :m:J.IJIJ.Ill(IIoro QxJH,Z\a B
Poccnik:Rcii tI>e.l\epal(lllt.', ro npJ.lTaKOM O'i"'I)'iK,!:IeHIDI Y rpam,!\aHJl!Ha (113-
IDIMaTeMKB3pfl1pbI)BHOBbB03ID1KaeTnpaeoHaee6f'e-
IIJI3TH)'KJ  To eCTh npJ.l OIDiCaHHI:M cwrya!.\J'!J.I pe'!b MomeT
'IlQ!lOO"orOp0,c,3B""IIn"'nb"nonY""npa.cnpocTp8He"eBP"AeroJXl,!lOBF'oco<"_Bnre.
parypeymeP"'J1<leTC".'ITOBrBYKa3aHHOldnoP'I'\Ke6bmOBb"(ynnef<03H!1
"TBJ1bHoe KOJl",ec11l0 BBPrnp" f1)fIII:OCllESlBHOI1IQ11RM npo",,,aaoauu<ld. aB8POlf<Old
"""'CIM<J>oIlll","fI[)rOJl!!TH"'ldoeMbIIld,Y"acTHKaMBeI1""""'_H"'(CM:
rOHraooS.M.n.B."'''''b"K3al<OH}'POG.
ceo<oO\C!Je.<\epaLJ,L<.onpaarn3au""'n"UjHoro<J>oH,!laB<!>e.!1epaLJ,L<'" -
M_,1993 C.SO)
2c.. CoOpaH..esaKOHQJ1a.renbCT8a PocCl'lCI<OI1 a>eJ:1epau. 1994. N" 16.CT 1864. ynO. 1
Tpe6;leH"e3aKOOQ","T<"'eIdTepld"""l)JJ,HOKpaTHOCT"'BMeCTO"JI,Ba1l"
""""'T6b1Tbl1jJ"3I<aHoYII"H"'1d 3aMe"aH"B01HO",eHM 0\
3TOro11jJHLJ,L<naBblCKa3"'ean"Cb......."paHoo_ t'--

I1JITY!OOncK.l!lO<reHIDIJf3npl1HL{l1Il3.OJJ;RJpa3tEOCTI1npJ1Ba-
TJ.I3aqIU(rpam,!!aRaMJ.f)Kl1JIh!X.B;t\OMaXroCY-
.AapcTBeHHorol1M)'HHOro:HG1Oro4>oH,!JP.Crre.nyeTIfMeTbBBJ1-
p,y, 'ITO no,!\06HaR cJ1T)'aQl1,f! B o6IqHX 'Jeprax :>KeCTKO He aarrpellleHa caMMM
3aKoHoMI4>e)1epa'-\ffif«O np=TI13a'-\Hl1)KJ1Jloro<jxJH,Z\aB
f'oc:cIDJ::Iroi epaI1IDl. a TaIOKe MO:?KeT l1MeTh Neero JIJ1lllb npl1 peaJrn-
3RijIDI paRee It3JI())KeIJ:Hl npeAID1CaHr.rl!: TOro.me 3aKOHa (cr. 17).
CYlI\eCTBE'lllIoe :ma'leIDIe TaIOKe I1MeeT BOIIpOC 0 TOM, coxpaHJIeTCH Jrn:
xapa IIpI1H1..\I'IIl B cJIY'I3.e I1.3MeHE'HmI TIIT)'JlbHOro BJJa)J;eJIb
,ltOMa, I((Yrop HaXOJ1,H'l"C$l B rOCY.l1apcmeHHQM tfJIH 1IICl.!IUIDM)ID1-
JIJ1IWIOM <jxJH.!Ie. KaK 6bITb B TeX  KOf,Qa rocy,1\apc'I'BeHHoe I1JIJ1
 npe.ll;£1pHJITlfe, mlelO!l.\ee Ha csoeM 6a.riaHce :!KJI!.ID1lW1ble
$:>H,I\bI, nepexoJUITKlIPYfMM  m160 JIJlKBIIJUfPY€TC>I?
JI3BecTIio. 'ITOnepBOH3.'iaJIbHo3aKoHtI>e.l\epaIUlJ1 Onpl1-
Barnoro<jxJH,Z\aB4:re)1epHeperYJIHPOBaJI
no.n;OOHOro pOlla O'l'RJllJelDUL ITpaKTI'!Ka 1H nplfB3TI1aR4I11f
)j{j.fJIbIX nOMeIlIeHHi1 06HapY'fG1JIa Hacyw;Hy1O narpe6HOCTb Jj HeOOXQ,IJ;H-
MOCThB TaKOMyperymlJX'B3HWL TaK, CT. 83aKOHa PtPOT 23,l1eKa6pf! 1992 f.
«0 BHECeHJm I13MeHE!Hlllf Ji PJI]OJIH€HIIii B 3aKOH PoccItik:Irii tI>e.llepawrn
«OnpJ1BaTlf3aqHl{)KIfJIII!lItHoro 4x>H,Z\a B  lPe,1\epa'-\J1W' YCTaHO-
BI1JI, 'ITO «IIpH nepexo):\e roCyp,apcTBeHHbIXIiI npeJlIIpI1R-
TIili, Iii B KHyKJq.opM)'co5CTeeHHOCTlfm16o rIpH I1XJIII!KBlf,!!aqJIl1
<jxJH,!\,('JIBnOJIHOMBeJ\eHIDlnpeJ\-
npl1HTmi UJIJ1 orrepaTl1BHOM yrrpaBJIeHl1l1 yqpe:1K,/\emdi, J\OJDKeH 6bITb nepe-
.a.aH BnO.l1Iroe oeBe,!\eHl1eJIJI orrepaTJ1BHoeyn}XlBJ1€lIItenpa-
BOrrpeeMIDIKOB ::ITI1X  yqpem,!!eHIDi (eCJill OID1 onpeJIeneHbI),
ffilbIX  JlJl!LI B  opraHoB MeCTIforo caMJyIIpaB.JE'H B
ycraHOBJJeHHOMnOpH,1\Ke cooxpaH€lUDlBcexbIXnpaBrpam,!1aH, B
TOM 'lI1CJIe npaBa Ha npl1BaTI13aIDOO >KIfJIbH. CneJ\OBaTeJIbHO, tf npl1 OID1-
caHHoi1 I, TO eCTb npI1113MeHeHJ.UI OI'HCWeHJm COOcTBeHHOCTI1 B
mlLIII1lqIDiic4Jepe, np npl1BaTJII3al.\l1l1 Ipam,!\aHaMl1
JoKI1JIbIXICGxpaHHeTCBoe.r:\E'OCrBHe.
B npaKTIfite B03HIfitaJI sonpoc OTOM, crrq::raHReTCFIJIJI! np O)J;Hopa-
30BOCTJII npl1BaTJll3awrn JKVIJIbIX nOMerqemrlf aa TeMl1.1IV1IWMI1, KOTOpbIe JJ;a-
JW/ corJlaCl1e Ha nplfB<m'!3aLlJ1tO HU1JJOro nOMeIl.\eHKH JJiPyn1M11 'LIIeHaMl1 ce-
MH1, npom.l1BaKJIIV1Mi'! B KBapTIlpe, HaJro.lI.HllWMcR B 11.0Me rOCYlJ,apCTBeHHoro
UJIJ1 MJ'HI1W1IIaJIbHI'O :HG1JIYjIWIoro <¥JH,!Ia IIOCKOJIbKY JlJl!Qa, BbIpa311BIID1e
CGrJIaCl1eHanpI1BaTJII3aIO)lG!JIoroJlPYmMJIJIJI!WlMl1,n0JIb3Y-
IOll(I1MI1CH:IID1.IIbIM nOMeWeIDleM, He npl100pe.ID13TO nOMeIl.\eID1e B CBOIO CGB-
MecTH)'tO JlJII'I 11.OJIeB)'IO  TO Ha HI'IX paCnpocrpaHHeTCH J\ei1-
crBl'lenpO)J;Hopa30BOCTJll)lG!JIbIX
I npl1npI'lB3T113a4l'lI1J1M}!.r:IPyroro,BrrOCJU'.J\CTBID'InOJIY"!eHHoro
g >t\l'lJIoro nOMeWeID1R, TaK KaK xapaKTepll3yeMbm IIpI'lHl..\I1II He 6bIJI}lMl'! ocy-

LQeCTBJIeHnpl1.w>'1eCor.rracIDIHa:!KI1JIb.F!JJiPyrnMI1[J)am,1\a.-
HaMl1. 3To1f ID3IfltIdI npJ.l,D;epiKHBa€TCJ'! J1 CY,l\e6Ha.R npaKTIfKa I
IImllirnmcIXNHIX'TIf rxbol'JMJIf!lllU/ IJP.'IVJIbTaTIJB noJlBaTll3aJIm'L KHeo5-
XO)J;l1MOC'rn QJopM)'.ID1pOBaHIDI JI aaKpftIJ1'=HW1 ::ITOIf HOpMbI-I1pInUJ;ll!na B ;33.-
IWHe npl>1Beno HaC Jl3}"!eIDIe J1 0606meIDIe npaKTIlKH $pMJIeHIDI pe3YJIh-
TaroB nptBa'I'1I3&!I1 B r MocKBe.
.1*no B TOM, 'ITO t13Ha'laJIbHO CpoK $pMJJeHItf! JI pencrpaQlD1,1\oroBo-
pa 0 nepe.n;a'le npHBaTII3JIpOBaHHOI'O oro nOMeII:(eHIDI, HaXO)J,Hll:(el'OCR B
,AOM3.xrocy,J:lapcTBeHHoroJl:HG1Jrnoro4xJH,!\aBC06CT-
BeIffiOCTb rpam,!\aH aaKOHOM He ycTcUIaBJIJmaJI PeaJIbHO B r.MOCKBe Ha
COBepmeHll!e 3TIIX ,AefrrBIDl YXOWlT OKono Tpex MeCHL\eB. 3ToT q>cIK He Mo-
:>KeT Y,I\OBJ!eTBOp.IITb JlHTepecw MOCKBWJe. EcJrn Tb Bce
::rraIIbr pa6arbI C ,AOK)'MeHTaMl1 no $pMJIemllO pe3YJ!bTaTOB IIpJlBaTIf33-
QID1J1'fE'XHOJI(('WJ€cKIDi:lIfXJLlecc3TJ1X,IJ;OK)'MeHrOBCOpraHl1-
aaqnefi npeaplfl'('JIblDRl1X npcEIl1)KJf, TOMroRHo06HapymwrbJ1npeACTa-
mITbCJIeee«peaJ!bHOefeBeIIle»
l.CHa'l3.J!a cneI.P1aJD1!CTbJ ynpaBJ!eHnlf  :HOI!JIbJ'! TOro
IfJ!I1 WlOro B,AMlnurq:aTIlBHorooKpyra f. MOCKBWIIpIfHIfMaIOT naKeT J1PKY-
MeHTOB ar rHI1Ha Ha nplfB<ml3aLlJI!KJ, IIpOBepmur npaBJ.fJ!bHOCTb J1X
3anOJ!HeHII!J!J1'II1CTOTy.3aTeM,HOCKOllJIBIllif-
eCRl\OK}'M€HTbInepeB03HTCJI B rep I.1:eIITp perncTpaL\l1I1.
2. B CBOIO O'lepe,!\b, cnequa.J1ItCTbl OKp)'iKHOro l.\eIITpa pernC1'paI.1:Jl!l1 no-
BTOpHOnpcmepmareme pa3npaBJ.fJ!bHOCTbocpcpwremUI4>I1K-
CI1py1OT J1X B perncTpal.\lllOHHbIX KHm'aX J1 nepenpaBJIHIOT I1X B l'O.Y!reR!ii
l.\eH'Ip MocKOMpEmcTpaI.P111.
3.II()CJle cooeJIIIE'IDIHnjX)LleA,)'pbr J1PK)'MeHTbI OTIJpaBJ!.i!-
KTr 06paTHO - CHa'l3.J!a B OKPY*HO I.1:eH1'p, I;l\e ,IJ;eJ!aKTr COOTBe'rCTByIOIII;I
OTMeTRH, a namM B YIIpaBreHIte M)'HI1LIIfIIaJ!:!KI1JIb.F!, flJ,e YR<I3aHHbre
J1PK)'MeHTbI J1 nony<!aKTr IpaJK.!JPHe.
HaBCI03TyIIpOLle,!\ypyc OOopomM, "Jll\pyr0060poTOM,I\o-
K)'MeHTOBYXOAHTnO'l'fll! TpHl\lecsma.Orn.IT, 'ITQnOBTOp-
Ha.F! npOBepKa ,IJ;OK)'MetITOB OKp)'iKHbIM QeHTpOM peril!C'I'paIDm, HanpHMep
Ha npe,!\MeT TOro: peaJ!l.f3OBaJIJIH rpam,rwHIfHIIpO.AOOpa3OOOCTIt nplf-
BaTIl3aL\lfl1, lffiXO.AHTCJlJIHoelII\olelI{eIDlenOJlapeCTOMJlJ!lfHeT -Bnptrn-
QIfIle HWlero He ,AaeT. IIpalCTJ1Ka nO,ATBepm,!\aeT, 'ITO Ha  npoBe-
1 CM.llI1eIfYM".Bepxao-oCyA3P\t10T24a"rycra1993r.c"JMe""H"'''''
or2:JlI"Ka15p111994r.-ol<e.OTIJjJbIXBonpor.axlljJl1..eHel<"HCYA3....""roH!l.
lJ.!ITenOCTBaC!Je.<\epa"",-onpB8""""UII<oro.
l\I1".IIEioOJmereHbB€pxoB>tOroCyA3l\I1,,1993WII,arnK.
IK60fu0PCY.o.etSHo;;npa""".H-OtteKOTOP",XIlO'II03HK3OC1Ui.1<Xllj)\'IpaCCMOTpeH"" 1
CYAaMHJI6Il,C""aaHHb"CI1jJ"BBTTpB>KAaI<a""''''lIu.xIlIJMI!tlf!IH'I1I6I1W16TeHb_
Cy/IBf'4I.1994.NI2. CO

pHeMble ,l:\eJIa I1pnxO,l:\l1TCH OKOJlO JC( OIIDlfXJK'. XapaKTep I1X TaKOB, 'ITO 1I!3-
6emaTb Jl!X IDB'I'OpHfI'O cooepIIJ2I1W'! npaKTJI!lJeCKJI! He Y,QaeTCJ!, nOOTOMY no-
BTOpH1lJ1 m,:pY:IKlJaH np:lBepRa .lIIJKYMelITOO JlJl!llIeHa 3J\paBOro CMbICJla EcJrn
Jl!3 yKa3aHHOI'O Itpyroo\5opoTa ,l:\OK)'MeHTOB 1I!3'bHTb Oltp)'*Hoe 3BE'HO, TO OH
(Kpyrool5oJXYl')coKpallJilercn,l:\o{)JlHoroMeCfl1W-2.Kp{)Mem'llfcJJa
3BE'HbeB eCTb II! €II1e pe3epBb! Win HW! yKa3aHHOI'O CpORa, B 'ffiCT-
HOCTIfMe"icllilf3aq!4R  (uanplfMep, pa3pa60TKa KOW1b1O-
TepHb!XnporpaMMAJlI1emm,(loroBopaonepe,1\a'le:HG1JIoronoMeIIle-
HIf.F! B co6c-rBeInioc'! rpa)K,!laH). TIocKOJlbKY npJl! OOI1C8IIHOJI CII'I')'8WDt ero
(,I:\OroBOp)  3a!1OJ1lUlTh B TpeX <lK3eMl1.lUlpax JI! 6e3 eJJ;lfHofl no-
npaBKI1, TO 3aI1OJIHeHm' TeKCTa ,l:\OroBOpa C nOMOIl\b1O KOMIIblOTepa, a He "OT
P)'KJ1» 3H3.'iJl!TeJlbHO cOKpallJileT 8TOT IIpOI.\C.
Bce OTMeqeHHoe, a TaIOKe pR,!\JI!Hh!XMoMeHTOB n06ym,l\8.lOT Hac cI}xIPMY-
.m1pOBaTbIl!IIpe).\JJIDKJIlTb aaKpemITbnpeiK,lJ;eaceroB onpJ1Ba-
T113aJ..tI1I( (6ecn.narnotl: nepe,D,a'le) )KJ1.JII.1IIIHoro QxHl,l\a B r. MocKBe 3 , a TaIOKe
B 3aKOHe PocclliiCROii f ,,0 npJllBaTll3aI]:n( :!KI1IDIIIIHoro QxHl,l\a B
PoccJ.rncmiI tI>e,J.\epal.\lfl'l» HopMy-npI'lHl.\I'I!1 CJJe.J.\Y1OIIIero CO,J.\epif<aHI'lIf
«O!jxJpMJIeIDIe peayJIhTaT()B npJllBaTlf38J..!1'fi'1 :m:JI!JIh!X IIOMeIJ.t€IDIii ,(IOJimHO
BMWIHbrnqxE>
YB.l!eJlax'1wraTeJIRMOmeTB03miK-
HJTb BOIIpOC: TaK JIJI! ym HJmHa }lKa3aHHaJI HopMa-npl1llI\lfi1 B Ha3BaHHbIX
HOpM3.TJl!BHbIX aKTax, a ecJn1 11/1, TO '!TO OHa ,J.\aeT?
IIOI1hlTaeMCH IIMCID1Th :rro Ha CJIeJlY1Oll.\l'lX peaJIhlfu!X »GI3HeHHbIX CHTy-
awrnx. IIpeJ\C'ffiEIUI'I ce6e, '!TO HeKaH pJl!:mropcKaH ifMpM3., BbII10JIHIDI COOT-
BeTCTB)'KlwyKI IIpOrpaMM)' ropDP/1, pacceJIReT KOMMyHaJIbHyKJ KBapntpy
3Th QJI1pM3. HalWla !1OJP(0WIIl.\l'le 1.\Ji.iI npo:IKI1B1lHIDI ejj mlfJIbJe nOMeIIle-
HIf.F! JI Bb!CTpOl1JIa He06xO)J;JIMyRJqe!1CRKy: KTO, Kyl1/1 JI KOr,J.\3. nepe€).\€T.IIpaK-
THKa,'!TOBCOBepllIeHl1JfTalGlX(',!teJlOKHepeI.\KOY'lacmYeT
HKOJIbKO QJI1pM JI cy&beKTOB npJllBaTJl!3aW1Jl! (rpa)K,!laH), 'IX
CJleJOOIc:H01JIbiMl'lllOMHeK01'OpbleJl3HJIXHeMoryr(JIJ!JI!HeXO-
THT) no I1pOCh6e KOlITparelITOBTh ABa-TpH Me<'JII18. pe3YJIhTaTQB rocperlf-
CTpaL\JIJI! ,l:\oroBDpa () nepeP/1'le JKII!JIbIX IJUIoE'IIJ'HIrli B cdicrBeHHOCTh l'pa)K-
I1/1li Hepe,!J;Ko B TaK11X CJlyqaRX C TPYJlOM HaJl<lmeHHble OTHOIIIeIDUI Demo JI!
6b!CTJXI pa.an:a:lrolBa1OTCH. I'pHe - yqaCTHI1KI1 (IllK:3IIlIJ('() IIpOl.\ecca -
paccrpaJl!B8KJrC1f, OOpallJillOTCH B KOMIJeTelITHble roCYPI1pcTBeHHble opr3.Hb!
co mpaBe.lI.IIHBHM B03MJll.\€HIDIMI1 {) BOJiOK>ITe npo1.\eiIYPhI penrrpaI1WI.
m l
Ie.... MocKoockaRnpaB,II<I.2000.2QveHT.
2CM. MocKo8cI<a" np88,!Ia_2000. 29ce>IT.
3C..,n.ollllO>l<eH..elKYK33yrlpe31W.f!KT3P41-OOo6ecr1f!'<eHHHyC.opeHHoiinpH
co&:-rtieHHOCTH,,MocK.e.OT12"HB3PRI992r./JBa.<iO"OCTHHa-
POAH",xp,enyraToBHHCooelaCbe.<lep.
1\11".19921>/114.0153.

HaJlWll1e B )'IW.3aHHbIX HopMa'rnBHbIX aKTaX c<}xJpMY HOP-
MhI-npJ.lna 6Y11.eT He TO.IIbItO cnOCOOcTBOaaTb ycrpa.HE;'flt1lO cnpaae-
BbIX HapeKaID1i1 Ipam,/\aH', HO JI! eTI1MYJIJ1POBaTb BCex cyfu.eKTOB IIpI1BaTI1-
3aqJ.lll!COBepwaTb,[\eCTBl1HnOpe3YJIbTaTOBIIpJ.lB3.m3aB
YCTaHOBJIeHHbIe 3aKOHOM . KpOMe 3TOro, xapaRTepl13}'eMaJI HOPMa-
npl1HL\illl,HaHalIIB3rJIH;:\,HBIITCH4>aKTOpoMKTJ.IBHOro
IfHbIXnpJ.lOBnpJ.IB3.m3a:oo1JJb!X,KOTOpb[e(urn)
BIle BpeMellllOro, a TO'lHee HlII'O I1X OCy:Il\ECTBJIeIDlHIiI HaJI)Iema-
J.qero$pMJleHJ.IHTat\OroIlpeBpaw.aKTI'CHI13B03MC»KHbIX
«pa60'J(uollxMeXatlJl3MJB»BHe'iT03aCTbIBIlleelf
1""Oq,op.oP\'lOl1ri\4>oP"'Y.nPYIOUU'"sat<pen.nIOIW>iB
COOTBeTCTB)IIOO.1""I<OP"a"'""""'''KTa><Te''''''''H'''el1On><e''npe>l(,!\e
BCero.l\YMaTOnrQ.D,lO..6eraKJui.l<>;nOpa3H"M""cra"lII1M"CTO"LlI"""O'<ej)eJJ,lO'llej)eJJ,o;a-
tS""e"""""ePilJll1BbjX""OB"".OB"nonblTl<a><OCj'll1eCT""TbonpeJ\ene"Hble""-"'t>-
"",,,,,.>K"""b,,,,,,COJ<aJle""IO,oTO"''lTO''''or)\arp,,,,,,",,,''e-OOCBTTe
n",CTaT".Y'pe>I(,!\e"M;;nOpen.lCTpalll1"npaBH8.
He.I1B""'''Moe''''yu1eCTBo''e,o,enO.CH''Ml1O"OJIIITCRlJf)nOTep''COOHaH"''HepBH''''Cp'''.
BO.lcM.,3aii<l6B8E".Cnpa"K30nOTHHOM..peMeHIIPocc;;cK3Jlra3eTa.
20012<J>eBp.J
2CJ\enaHHOeHaM"eI1jeB2001np<;!J,IlH""()3aKJl"n.neH""0iIJP0&I()TOM.'lTO
.00000pMneH""PB3Y.nbTaTOBnpBaTIo\3i.UII<W1""'l'!OMEtIIEM'MlJ,OJ1",fIOOC\'\IjeCraMTbC"B
Mec"H";;CjX>K."""""MCI.6"",o3aMe"eflOOH3a.OHOMOT
20..a"2002N!55-Q)3"..ec"CTB3aroHaFoc:xHiD:;ci;epalll1".o>KH- 1
nll\Horo<!><>HlJ,aBepaL1I'I.'jac,-b2H""""HHOCTal""V""""'- ""'"'
""eyJKBHacpoK. CO

rnaKa IV I
np06nEMA C!>YHKLjl1ii
npl1HLjl1nOB npI1BATI13ALjl111
>Kl1nblX nOMEIIIEHl1ii
 1. nOHTHE H KMCCWI)HKAUH <l>YHKUHA
npJ.1H41.mOB npJ.1BAH13A4111111 >K1t1/lbIX nOMEUJ.EHlllfi
BnpeAb rnaBaX3Toro J.lCCJIel\OB<UU>1fl paCCMa'I])11Ba.1nlCbllOIDITl1S1
IIpPHl1JnIDB IIp;maTl13,U.\11JIl :HGIJIbIX r. m:: reHe3HC JI! cyIL\HOCTb,
KJIa }! CJ.:!CTeMa, TO eCTb, roBOpR WJalJe, J1X CTaTMKa. O)J;HaIW
IIpIfIll.\I1IIb! IIpvmaTIf3al.t"J.!:lKlf.lIbIX rlI H)"KHO paCCMOTpeTb ell\e B
O):{HOM acneKTe - BbillOJlHRe!lfbIX HMJiI. 3Ta CTOpOH3 I1pJ1HQI1IIOB B
OTJTIII<rne OT KX CTaTl1K!f xapaKTepl13YeT ,l\IfHaMl>1KY. TO €CTb 1\eticTmle npl1H-
QI1IlOB IIp>maTl13aqml »a1JIbIX 1: J.lBMepe OXBaTb!Ba-
eTCH nOIDITl'leM JlX peaJIJ13aW1>1-
B IIpaBOBOH JIlITepaTYpe nJIeMa if tf3Y'ffiJIaCb B acneKTe
rocY,I:\aPCTBaI iIInpaBa BLleJIOM,R3KCTaKJI!OT-
paCJIeB1>I:f JI! HHHX IlO3Irli. C3T1fX IlOOIrwm HaI160JIeeaKTIfB-
HO 113)"13lOTCH JI! nponanIH.Z{I1JJYIO'fCJI <tJ)lHK11 TaKOI'O lurrmyra, KaK
npaBOBaR 0'I1!€'I'CTBE'H ITpaK'IWleCIDf HeT 1m: OAMOro
yqe6mma nonpaBY. BKoroPOM3BTopblHeOCBelL\ClJThl6bITeX
JIIDII1HbIX acrreKTOB npo6.rreMbI m rpaJoK,!lPHCKD-npaEIJIU1 OTBeTCT-
'e.. 'JooHoK{JBJ1.I1,04>YHKLI"'XCoBeTCKOrorOCYAaIXT",,/fBonpOObI
<I>""!lCO<jJ 1957 W7 C.30--47,""",,6,B.KBOnpocy06ocHoBHblXI)JyHKlJI'I"xo<apoJ\-
H.:>rOCY/laPCT8!lBCOepeMeHHt>xvcnoeH""ffCoeeTCI<oerOCjl/lapc1eo"
npaeo.1959 N!'11 C_I4-24:KofjB.M.4>yH'L\MrocYJ1<l
uI/OLII8"rocYJ1<lpcJ8a.Y'IeO>tOeIlOC()(j..eILJ,li",,"eKLII1).
CDeJWIOOCK, 1970.C 107-141
2CM P<w>KOT./-I.ClcHOBH"'e<l>\'HKlIMCIJ4'I'IlIMCTWIeCKomnpaoa.-BoIlrorpa,ll, 1970,AneK.
cee8C_C4>yH'L\MMnpaoal/blTeOpI<Mnpaea'l(ypclle......'
B2T.-Ceep.l\llO"c',1972.T1 C.91--sa
3CM""!K9H.osA.f/.4>YH'LII1"COeeTCI<O/"Orpa;t;!laHc.oronpaea.-Capa-
Toe, 19a3.KCTaT>I,I\II,BaIl"'O>KHocomaClfTbC"cA.S< P"''''eHI<OB'''''.I1jJnC'''ealOlLII1''''''' I
4>\tHIUJ,I'IM"C€Myn.oaey.ro"pe..."..or.aa60nbUJHCTeOW<""'CTO"npa-
:,,a<I>YH'L\M"npI<C\'U1ilIlMWbTil'O"'Y"HCT'"Y'Y,""rpa>I(,!1aHCI«)-npa 

BeHHOCTI1 ' BMeCTe C -reM OT,AeJIbHble yqeHble He crpaHIf'IIfBaIO'fCH Jl!3JI0:?Ke-
HJ.leMB yqe6ooMJlJ.lTepaTYpe.mtlUbq:.YJIKWdinpaBOB01i:OTBe'T'-
C1'BeHHOCTIf,B.TafOKe eB.HaJIJ13 TaKOroHHCTJ.ITYfa,
KaKnpaBOBOJ.l,AoroBOp
ECJIJ.I OT,AeJIbHhle 4J)'HKJ.I rpam,1IaIICI«J npaea J.I CJ1CTeMa q:.if
HetOCITOpbIX ern HHCTI1TyroB 6hlJm IIpe,D;MeTOM IICC.Jle.A(IBaI pR,I:Ia KpyIIHhlX
y<leHhlX-1OpItCTOB, TOnp06JIeMe<tJ rIpJ.lHllrnJOBnpaaa HHC 06ll1enpa-
BOBhlX, HJII TeM 6o.rree C OTpaCJIeBhlX JI! 1HCTIrI'Jl!l1OHHhlX II0311q11if elI\e He
Y.I\M.IU10Ch .l\OJDKHOro BHJ.IM3.HJ.I.Fl. Eo BCHKOM CJIy'Jae npJ.l 
TlI\<lTeJIbHOro nO£1CKa HaM He YMJIOCh 06HapymJlTh B JlJ.lTepaTYpe no 06lI\eH
Teopl1l1 npaea pe3YJlhTB.TOB Jl!3yqeHIDI npoOJIeMhI 1111 IIpJ.lHlU1nOB
npasa 3 .
B J.lCCJle.IJ;osaHJ.1Ji1, nOCBRUjeHHOM II3y'K'IDOO npOOJIeMhI C!p11HQJffiOB co-
BeTcKoro rpaiK,!l;aHcKoro npaea,.I\a Jl 06U,JeOTpaCJIeBbIX JI! MeJtroTpaCJIeBhlX
npJl!HUl'll10BB JlX ClI-npaBOBOM npeJIOMJIeHJl!JI!.
'c...Coaem<oeCI;oen.oaso/nQjJ,oI'x1i.pe.o,.f1.DOq).O.A.I(pacaB""KO.a.-M.B",c.
IlJaSIWKOIIa,1968.T.1 C.482-483;rpa>l(AaHCKoenpaao/Ora pe.o,.CipnoB(:Ia.I.lnE.,Kop
HeeaCM.-M.:lOpHJ\.I1HT, 1969 T 1 C.516'CoaeTc"oepa;I\lIBHC"Oenpaoo/nQjJ,pe,q.
f1JJ04>.OAKpa.caa"H"osa.-2.e-M B"'::W!Iwl<Ona 1972 T 1 C.416,CoeeTC"oo
I'JXI'"A<IHC.oenpaBO:Y4e6H"KAI1"BYJO./not\pe.o,.aacny>KeHffOrOl\e<lTenHay"'PC<l>CP.
1\-palOp......t<ayp;.npo4>.O.A.-3-e":>o.....cnp.".IJ,On-M.B"'cW!I>IWKOJla.
1985. T. 1 C.504-505, rpa>l{,(\aHcKoenpaoo/l"\oJ\pe.1I. f1PCI4>. A.r KannHHa"f1PO<!>
A.1iI MacJ\eBa -M. IOpI<CTb, 1997.C.20--21,rpaJKJJ,aHCKoenpaoo:Y«e6HH"/Or. pe.1I.
f1JJ04>.E."'-CyxaHoo.-M 63K 1998.T1 C.43I--433
2C... t<aI1jJHMepKpacas,,,,,,,so.A.rp8>K,D,8,,CKO.npaooBCMl\orO.OP flOl<IITI<"'.CQlJ,€j»KaH,,"
"4>YI'KL.lHHllr/:IOroeop"ero4>Yl'.1jH,,:cOopH".Ha-
V<H""'lJIYI\08.-I1:>o.-80YprY,1980C.16-20:o..Jf<e.nOH""'e"4>YI'1<lJ,I<"
,ll[lr080pa/fCo8l!TCl«II!rpa>l(Aa"cKoenp8.cY<ie6H"KlIII""YJO"1
IloJ\pe.o,.Ae"TeJ1HaYK"PC<l>CP.t\paIOP......HaY..f1PO<!>.OAKpaca8""KO
,,".-3-eOWl.,l-ICIlp."'t\on.-M. BboCW!I>IWK0Jl8,1985.T.I C.435-436
)((rnIOAl<pecaeon<oBoI5oc""8aII"OCyL1lecT"",,CHCTeMbI.U,Ho;
J\Crooopa."'-anpOO"eMaocTanacb"".6",He3a""""'HHoi1IflOCJJe.
I\YIOllIMM,,IlpCI6Jlf!MblCyUl,Moc-ml\oro.opa,,npa...Ta..
MJ<1E;par"H"""A"BBrnyt;oKo"'o6cTOOTeI1bHOMaY""8w"ecOBpeo.oeHHbIe
npc6neM"J\CITIBOpa"'IlpaBalJI"J1I'IU,HOHH"X"CneKTax,HeTOnbKOHelGlCil
IOTCI1BOnpOCOBf10t<IITI<"'CHCTe"bl4>YI'.U,H/:IOr080pa.t<o"J:IBJIBIOTBHJ\, 'tT03T\<Xf1PO.
6I1eMaK6yt\T06"H"KOrp,aHeC)'llJ!CT"""""c"rnHH".e"HeT.e"'-"IlpO.
6neM",npe.a8l1":;3a6se"HIOICM.Epa"'lICKMiiM.U. B.B.J:\Cn:>8CptDef1)aBO.
06W)-.fH>0l1O>1<eH"" -M.eratyT,1977)
3Ta..B4>YI'AaMeHTa.l""o;MOHorpa4>"HA.Rl5ep"e".o..neH"HC.H8f1P""U,HnblCO<llolSl1Hcrn.
"ecl(Qronpaaa.f1J)06n8ManpMHLI"noBf1Paaa"sY"aeTCB"CTOpM..ec.OMpa"'VPC8"c06.
UjeCTpacneBblXflo""""A,t<OIl8TOMt<elIIDI<BnonbITK"fl<¥\-
xQ.o,a"Sl'"e"HI04>YI'.U,H
HeB",:JbIBaenX'MHeHHA, HaHaW B:Jmll,[\, IlOfIV>IIeHo1e(lTOM, T04>YHI<lJ,I<"np"HLlL,"08npa
""J\ClDKHbl6"Tb<ITHeceH""l<Cny""","eAwHxeroOJIHaKOeeecb""'eMKoo;,,
MO""rpa4>HH.roce"Ul9HHOnpe80BbIX"'ecTa
"'MHeH3WnocbtcM.,Hanp"MBp:Bac"""""A.M.r1pa"OB",et:aler1JpKLM
acne"-",paspa&>TK"CI<CTe"bInpaaa.-M.IOpo!,II.I1,,,.1Q76J.
as l

HeT rJlaBbIJlJII1napaqJaVa, BKOTOpoM Jl3yqaJICH 6bI BOnpOC
O1HXnpl'1HQill1OBCROmnpaBa"BMecTecTeMMOJKHOo6Ha-
P)'ifG'lTb, 'ITO <tJ)'HKI1 npl1HII;rn10B CU!eTCIOCJI'O rpwK.lIi1HCROIO npaBa IfC-
CJIe)I.yIOTCH B JlX cy:IIIeCTBe, cBoi1rrBaX If urHOllleIIJIHX BO E3a C
TIUGlMI1 lpIDK./IaHCKO-npaBOBbIWI KaTeropl1HMI1, KaK: npeAMeT JI! Me1'O.II
rpa»iJJilHCRO-npaBOlJ{JJ'(j perY.m1pOBaID1H  IJTHIXIIetIHiJ: H
npaBDBNt'HOpMbI'_06Il1enpaBOllUfJlQI1enO.ll-
XO)J;bl B 06'bRCHeIDfJi! q:.)'HKQIIii npHHQJI!IIOB rpaHCKOrO npaBa HCnOJib-
3yIOTCHBKa'leCTBeOCHoBbIfK.IDIM8HJ'IfiJl!o6'bRCHeHI1H
TaKOrO HBJIeHHH peaJibHOi1 )J;eiic'rBJITeJJbt, KaK q:.yHKQJI!H npwnumos
npI1saTl13aQll!I1>IG'!JIb!XnoMeweHm1 C yqeTOMcrrpa»reHmI CllewuptKK 31'0-
rDHBJIeHI1H,
HaM npe,lI('TaBJIHeTCJI. '11'0 H3yqeHl1e <J:IYJIKQI1H IIpl1HQ11110B npl1BaTI13a-
l-tJ1M)IG'!JIh!XnOMeIlleID1i1CJIe.IIYeT Ha'lI1lIaTb cm nOHHTIfHm'Om
HBJIeHl1..ll. 06paIQeHUe K paHee npHBe.IteHHbIM 1f(."J'(I'llII, B KOTOphIX B TOft
lfJII.fJI!Hoft Mepe pe'lb If,1\eTO 4>)'HKqI1HX rpaHCKO-npaBOBOj;iOTBeTCTseH-
HOCTb HJII1 rp3)f\.!\CUKKO-npaBOOCI'O .I\OroBOpa, n03BOJIHeT Y'I"sepTb, 'lTO
Ha3saHIThle HBJIeHJ.1J'! H3Y'JaIOTCH CaMM no ce6e, 6e3 C'I'peMJIeID1H ;IJ,aTb onpe-
.IIeJIeHl1..llno!1.lITl1i1,CKa:lKeM, npaBOBOj;iOTBeTCTBeH-
lIX"TID' I1IDI rpa*,!\aHCKO-npaBoBoro.llOroBOpa_
Ec.rri1, nOHflTI1e 4>» CBH3aHOC,AeHTe1IbHOCTbI BHellIHl1MnpoHB-
JIeHI1eM COOiiiCTB RaKOI'o-JII1fio o&beKTa,  Ha 'lTO-TO, TO ero
)'IDTJJe6.nem1e  K <J:IYJIKWIfIM IIplfHQl1ll0B npl1Ba"I'Jl3altIDl
}KIfJIb!XIXJMelQI'IDIiixapaKTepH3YeTCBOi1crBill!:1H
Ha BHeWHlOR) cpe.ll)'. B TaKOMnOHI1MaHlfl1 npl1HII;IfIIbI npl1BaTl13al1lfl1:1K11JIbIX
nOMeIQeHI1i1ID1!eKYrar'leTJIlfBocO.I\ePJK3.ID1e, KOropoeo6pa3y-
eT clfcreM)' ar.lleJIbHhIX, OTHOCJITeJIbHO caMJCTOHTeJIlllNX, HO B3aI1MOCBH-
3aHHbIX CIiOCOOOB tCTSJ.U:r Ha BHeunnOlO cpe.ll)' B Ka'iecme TaKOBOiii
BblcTyna1OTOTIloweHl1..llnonpI1BaTl13awrnJKIfJIbIXnOMeIQe-
HI1i111 Cy1TheKTbI 1IpMBaTI131llPDf.
4ryH npi1HwmOB npi1BaTI13aQll!i1}K1fJ1b!x nOMeU{eHIDi: npeAonpeAe-
JIH1OI'CH csoeo6pa3l1eM ill!: OObeKTa B03,I:Ieiii:cTm, Oc06etIHOCTHMi1 peryJUf-
posaHWI yRa3aHHb!X OOIl..\E'C'T'BeHH OTHOWeHI1i1 YI B03.11eiic'rBHeM Ha HIIX.
OrneceHYie K <J:IYJIKWIfIM npl1saTl13aL\1II1 :1KI1J1b!X mMElQ€HHii: TOro Jl!JIIf
JlHoroBl1;J;aJlXOCHOBblB3.eTCHHapR,!\eKpl1TeplleB.I1Mi1HBJIf!-
IOTCH: o&beKTImHaH HJIHHaHHanpaBJIeHHOC1'b
]JjlHHoroHaBHennnolOcpe.ll)',HeB03MOJKHOCTbocyrn,ecTBJlelD1H
6e3 Hee npl>lHQH!1OB, CJIOJKHOCTb OO,l\epmaHWI q:.)'HKLIHH, OTHOCJITeJlbHaH Jl!X

r.A,npMH""n"'croBl'lQo(irfiP""I'I"HCKorOnpa",,:-KpaCHO- I t'--
"PC K "!t1,¥\-BoKpacOOllpcKOrO)'H-Ta,1985.C.36-57 CO

]lrnomo3c.tiaHJle)'Ka3aHHb!XKpl1TepJ.feBno3BOJIReTOTHeCTIlKKl\J1HM
IIpJ.lOBnp£1BaTlI3<u.t"IJ.1)lGf.11bIXmMf2llf2IIIfI,iTaRl>1eBJUJ;bI1R,
K8K  IIpeoEipa3ClBaID1eOTIIIXIIffiJli1,
peryJJJITJ.lBHOCTb, ClCTeMoo6pa3)'€MOCTb. OrcIO,IJ;a, CY,IJ;Jf no CO,lJ;epiKaHJ1lO J.I
Ha3BaHHbIM HanpaBJJeID1.lIM BO:.V\€I1cTBwI, IIpJ.lmvmoBIIpl1BaTIf3a-
1.1I1J.IJiG'!JIbIX rn MOryI' 6bITboW!4xt>ePeHIl;l1pOBaHbI Ha CJle.1\YlOIIJ;IIIe
BJf,!I,bI:l);2)IIpeoEipa30BaHI1.II06T-
BE'HHbIX OTIIOIIIemrn, 3) peryJIflTl1BHaH ; 4) CJ.lCTeMoo6pa3yJo!.l.1pH
-
B paMKaX e)tHHoft]J,Jlfl IIpJ.lmvmoB npVlBaTJ.I3aJ.tHJ.I.mwIbIX IDM6IJ'mdi
HeI1OCpPJl(.'TI!eHHoti: [(eJIVI (06ecrre'IeHVle yrropH.ZJJJ'IeHHOC, COf.nacOBaHHOC-
TJj 3J1eMeHTOB CJIC'lUIoIbI) KaX<,lJ;aJI J.I3 Ha3BaHHbIX  KaK ::JJ[eMeH'fCJil-
CTeMbIJlMeeTco6cmelllloenpeAH8.3Ha'leID1e, cO,IJ;epmmml'J1MeTO.qblpeaJIl!l-
a8.[(IDI. TaK, I1H4x:JpMallHOIlll8.H K[(I1H ,t:taeT cyfu.eKTaM npVlBaTI138.[(JIVI
.mwIbIXri1J1HcpopMal\VIIOOIIp0IIlJ10M, HaCTOHIIleMJ1B03MJ)lQDCTJ1
IIpe.1lBl1,l\eHl1.II6YiJYII\ero IIpVlmvmOB npVlBaTJl:3altlfJl>Kl1J1bIX nOMel[(emdt
tl>yHK[(I1H npeo6pa3oBaHwf 06l[(eCTBeHHblX OTHOIIIeHI1M B03.11eticTByeT
Hac)xJpwrpoBaIDIe BCJ.lCTeMeOTIlOIIIeID1i11mJIbHJi.fJj rocy,llapCTBeH-
Hoi1OTHOIIIeHI1M'laCTHoti:co6cTBeHHOCTIl_IIOllZ\ePJK3.ID1eJIX
HaypoBHe,YKpelIJleHIDlJlpa
Pery.m1pOBaIDft' 06ecrre>rnsaeT orrepaTIlBHOCTh B03J\eiicTmm. 3WJc-
TJ.lBHOCTb .1IetfCTBII!Jf CII!CTeMbJ)'HKlII1I1 npnHltlmOB npVlBaTI133.[(I1I1!.mwIbIX
1IOM€t[(eHIDf B YCJIOBIfJIX nOCTOHHHbIX BHellIID1X J1 BIfj'TpeHHJ.IX B03J\eric'I'Ioof
HaHee.
HHoCTbHanpaBJJeHaHaC03)\8.HJI!eTaKOroJ.I
QeJIbHoroMeXaIDI3M1l, KOTOpbM npeBpal[(aE'TnpJ.lH1.1l1IlbI JI HOpMbIB e;J;IDIyIO II!
IIpO'IHyIOClCTeM)'pery.m1pQB8.H11H.
KaK S!BJJeHJl!H ufrbeImmHcro nopSW\8., Ha3BaHHhle I He MOf)'T
6bITb 1I!30paHbI. IIDOW..1IbK)'JIICXO)1.HTJII3cyrn:HOCTIIoroH8.3Ha-
'IeHVlfIIIpJIHWtnOBnpVlBaTJ.I3altVII1)K}!JJbIX,J13
 xapaKTepJ13YeMbIX )'HKlII1I1 Ha BHeunnolO cpe.1\)'_ KoHe'lHO,
HaKoHKpeTHoeCO)\epiKaHl1e)lKa3aHHbIX  BJIJIlHeTCIIe!.1l14JHKa o&b-
eKTa B03,I\eIic'mlur. O)\HaKO TaRoe BJllffiHl1e He J113MeHHeT COCTaB 11 COJ\l'pma-
IDIenpVlBaTI13aIlI1l1:HGI.IIbIXllJMeIIIelUrlt.KOTOpbIenpJ.lBcexyc.n:o-
BJIlJfXOCTaKYrCJfB[(eJJOMHI'II3MeHHbIMJI
TaRl>1M06p8.3oM, C y<leTOMOTMI'<reHHoro  npmIItIfIXJB npVlBaTl1-
aa[(IDI JiG'!JIbIX  npe.1lCTaBJIJIKJf co60i1 OObeKTI1BHO HeoOXO)\l1-
Mhle, HanpaBJIl'lIHble, t130I1paTeJ1bHbIl' Jj OTHOCI1T1'J1bHO calOOC'T'OR'T'e1l
JlXHaBHeunnolOcpe11Y(06II1I'CTBellHbleOTHOIIIeHI1.II,JJemaIIJ;llle
BOCHOBe IIpIBaTIf38ItIfJiG'!JIblXnOMeIIleHIDiJ1paHa
Cy6'bl'KTOB npVlBaTl13aJ..\1'111).
:B I

2. t1:JYHKL.J.1t11i1 npJ.1HI..J,l-1nOB npJ.1BATIt13AI..J,l-1J.1
>K1-1/lbIX nOMELLlEHJ.1ft KAK 3/lEMEHTbl CI-1CTEMbl
Bmnp06JIeMblq:.npJ.1HQlmoo.Hill-
JIbIXMb!J1CXOJU1MI13TOro, 'IT()BCHKaHKJIa1HnpoI13-
BO)J;I11'CH He pawl caMo» ce6J!, ORa npe.!\C'raBJlHeT co60i1 O)J;l1H 113 MemAQJIo-
l'I1'IeclG1X nplfeMoB CIfC'I'eMHOI'O cnoc06a  TeX WIIf IiIHhlX
HBJIeHlW: (B IIJIaHe Ha!llefO 11CCJ!t'JI{IB1lH - tit nplfmvmOB IIpI1BaTlf-
3aqIDj)KIfJIb!X).Ec.rm:cIfCTeMaCJ1Hre3I1pyeT,coe,!J;IfHJ'leT'COC'TaB-
HbIe arreMeHTbI 4)'HKIU1H IIplfmvmOB IIpI1BaTlf3aqlm)KIfJIb!X IB
LleJ!oe IiI n03BOJIHeT OXBaTIITh Bce IiIX MHoroo6pa3np, TO aH3.JI1f3 Ram,lI,oi1
q:.YIOO.\IfJ.I n03BOJIHeT BhIJ'Im1Th, BO-nej:lllilX, ee  J.I, BO-BTOPbIX,
coOcmeHH)'lO pDJIh TOi1 J1JII1 mlon KIJ;IfI1. B )'KB.38.HHhIX 1UJYX acneKTaX B
,AaJIh HeHweM atiaIDl3llJlY€TRam,lI,aRq:.)'IOOU1J!.
Jf1l.1popMoIDIaaciJYHKUI npuHl\ltlIOB nplfBa'Jll3aItlld2K1fJlL1X nOMC-
lL\cmm COCTOIIT B TOM, 'IT()  B 3aKOHC IIpI1HL\ffiIh! CO)\ep»caT
CBe)\emu:r06ycJIOBKllXnepeXD,!\a.mlfJIbIX,IIaXO,IUnL\IfXCB,I\O-
MaX rocYMpcTBelllJOfO 11 rraJIhHOro >KI1JII1lL\Horo 4>oH)\a B cOOCTBeH-
HOCThrpa)fi,!\3.H.Cpa3BlfTI'!eMOTHoweHl1ifno
npeOOpa3(EaIDno co6cmemJOcTi1 B )KIfJIJ1lL\Ilol'i c4:lepe, 3Ha'll1MOCTh 11 06'heM
ncpepa6aThIBaeMoi1 l1HpMaqIDj nOC'!'OJ'lHHo yeeJIWilIBaIOTC nOCKOJIhK)'
.I1tOOafII1H<¥JPMalJ,illl, BTOM'iI1CJIeliIHac,BCe6oJ1bwenpoHJl!-
RaeT B 2KI13Hb cOIUfj'Ma. IIo:ITOM)' 11€CI6xo.w ym.e cero)\HIJ fOTQBIITh Ka:IK-
p.ororpam,1\aHJl!JlaK2KI13HeByCJ!OBKllXBce6oJIee
yrBe06lIteCTBa.
J1l1(popMaQl1HIIpC)ICTIlBJ!HCc06oi1cnewIIpoJIYIIT, KOTOphIM
MO»CHO UIrpUpOBaTh B pa3HhlX c¥pax )KJ13H11, nopoiK,!\aJ'i pe3yJJbTaTbi B
MaI3()BaHlDIIIBlf,l\e. BCB.fI3lfC 3TlfMCyrbdHHlIOiiK-
L\I1IfIIpI1HL\illlOBnpllBa"I'II3IU!Jl!1f2Kl1J!bIXnKaKORa3aQJI1KCI1pOBa-
Hall 'J'eKCTOI!OO:4x>pMe I13aKOHeF'occIDicmjiDf «Onpl1BaTlf3aL\l1lf
>KI1JII1lL\Horo 4>oH,!\a B I'occJ.iiibooii 4Je)\CpaIi]nro If B pRP.e I1HhlX 3aKOHO)\a-
TeJlhHbIX alCTOB, IIpIf06peTaer oc06ylO 3Ha'illMOCTb. Ha3BaHHa.FI I1H<lJopM&-
L\I1H He Mo.m€"T CYIL\eCTBOBaTh If B HeMaTepna.ID13OBaIIlKIIf, CR'ameM, II BHpI'Y-
aJIbHOM Blf,l\e, HaIIpl1Mep Ha caiITax MHrepHCTa. .n;pyroe ,I:\eJ!o, 'IT() cnoc06bI
paCI1pOCTpaHeIDIJ'l xapaKTCpJ.i3yeMoif IiIHcpopMa!J;lf11 c)\Ba JIIf Moryr 6br1'b
OllCHCHbI B HaCTOmI(ee BpeMJI RaK 34xPeKTI1BHbIC.
Dre)QTeT'OTMeTIITb, 'iTOI1H<lJopMa!J,illl,COCTaBJ!lllO!l(3Jfcyw;HocTHoe 
xapaKTC <J:IYHK IIplfmvmOBIIpI1BaTI13aL\l1lf 2KI1J!bIX nOMelIte-
IDIi1, I1MCeT HeKOTOpblc arJIl1'IJ1TeJIbHbIC ocufJeHHoc'rn. CYJIlHOCTh 3TI1X OCO-
6mHocTeii COC'fOi1T B CJIe;IylOIl\eM:
Bo-nepBbIX, ::ITOce nacCMBHOCTh.M3BeCTHO, 'IT()1fHfl>cpnaro- l
KIf BHeJ\PHKrrCH B Te WIIf I1HhIe CJ!OI1 Hace.netIIDI 'iepe3 cpe,n;cma MaCCOBOi1 m

 KHOma, HaCTOWrnBO J1JIJI! ,I\3.)Ke aIpeCCKBKJ (
tfJIJI peKJIaMHa.lllrn4>opMaltlm). 3roro He HaCJ'! npH IH'.Z\peHlfd J1}J-
4>oPMa110npl1Hl\lffiaXIIpJlB3Tlt:33Ql1Jf:HGIJIbIXEcJrn:Hey<D1-
TbIBaTb H€KOTOp)'lO aKTIlBK.JCTb cpe,!\CTB MaccOBOi1I1H<lJOpM31..\J1J1 B nepBbl€
Mecsn nOCJIe npmmTl1fl Ha3BaHHoro 38ROHa  4Je.l\epa'-\Hl'i
OnpI1BaTl13a!.\I1I1JtG1.JillIW1oro$JH,!\aB Pocm:iiCluM 4Je)\tpal..\Jll1» MKaKytO-
'Tono.ItBliml\yopraHoBcy61.eKTOBROHKpe-
TIIXIf}'Kll!I1XYCJIOBIfHnpmHIerom)'K1l3allllOro3aRO-
Ha If pR,II3. HHbIX 3aKOHO,!\3.TeJIbHbIX atITOB HR CBOID: TeppwropJl!HX, B TOM Jf.IDI
KHOi7i Mepe  3aKpe!1Jl€HHOe B 4>e,1\epaJIbHOM 3aKOHe If
I>1HhIX 3aKOHO)\aT€JIbHb!X aKTaX IIp!1HW1IIbI, TO MOiKHO arMeTIlTb. BHe.u;peID1€
BC03HaHlleIpa>!\,!@.Ho"npI1BaTM3aI..\JlIf.H\MJ!bLXnO-
MeIlf*ID1 BOlllJIO B COCTQHHJ1e npO'IHOH If cTa6J1.1IbHoi1 naCCIffiHOCTI1. Cpe,!\1f
r C1paHbI B031illKJIJ1 MHeHID! 0 TOM, 'ITO IIp>ma'rn3aqJ1H :1KJIJIbIX no-
)'me 3aKOHI.J€Ha "RTO He ycneJI ocynr,ecrmtTh ee B IUITh-J\ecmb
JIeT noCJI€ IIpJ.fiurnm Ha3BaHHOro 4JeJlepaJIbHoro 3aKOHa, TOT He CMO:?ReT pe-
aJlJI!30BaTb npaBO Ha IIpI1BaTI'I3aLlI1K! MID'! 6y.l\eT B HeM orpaHJl!l.JeH' ,
BO-BropbIX, CQlJ'H KHQ::opM 0 nplfilax IIpl1BaT1f3a4l1J4
JiGfJIh!XmnoCBoei1K1pD.l1;1f'JeCKOitnpl1fXJ,[(e.HBJlHeTCJIHe'ieMI1HbIM,
KaK npe)J,.1lroKeID1€M .l\eJJaTb OifleprbI. ORa Bb!crynaer c.uit If rorre-
peCHoiii,l\JUl noope6J.ITeJIIL Om.rr CBJ1,/\eTI'JIbCTB)'eT, 'ITO,l\JUI CKHJBIDl MaCChI
rpaiK,l\aHTaKH4xJpM3.I..\JtH,KOTOpaHH3.CO,HBJJHeTCH»JI.IIJI
HeH.)?RHOM, a)'K1l3aHHMoco6eIffiOCTbxapaK'l'ePlf3yeMOMm$op6Y11f?r
cnoco6crBoBaTh BbIDopy ee If3 Bceofu,eM.lIIOlqero OO!.l.(ero nOTORa;
B-TpeTbJ.1X, aHaJII.I3HpyeMaJ'! HpMaLJ;J1H, f!IIJlH!'ICb '1aC'l'b1O,l\eMOltpam-
'1ecKOH1I:YJIbTYPbI oomeCTBa, n03BOJI.f!eT nmpe6l>1TeJIHM n0JIb30BaTbCH elO
KaK,IIe, TaK Kalt HeJIb3E HaCflJIbHO 3aCTaBJIHTb
KOro-JIJ1fu EOCII}:IDIIfMaT, OTCelfBa'T'b Hey,llOBJleTOOpI4TeJIb-
H)'IOI1HeHYmJYIO1RJ
T<UrnM06pa30M,peam.m.I..\JtHnpI1Hl.l;l1llOBnpl'l-
BaTl1:ooI.IIbIXrnIDlK'ffiCTI11I:jtlIbTYPbIc6rqe-
CTBa, npe,[lllOJIaraeTOC)'ll{€CTBJIeHl1e ,l\eMOltpa'IWIHOCTII I, CKOpD-
I HaJ>RJ\Y C OT"'e<leHbI'" pac><o""'''' ...»eH'Ie'" (;yL1\OCTBI"O't.. ($""aJ1bH"e npeJ!,llO)KeHM _
OrpaMM"MTbTa.Moc,oBC.aropo.o,c.a".ll.YMaBblCT)'mlllaC
"o;;saKl1lO'1atOLIIS;;CRBTO...,'fIOblBHec'm"s"'BHeHOIRBCT.4I1>a.!1epallbltoro
"".o"".onp"'n"33l\1<>I"IIll1jOOro<J>oI\llilB<tII',o,epal\l<...,BCOOT""'-CT"
COTopbl""'nMWMTbnpaea"""'''ffl>"l'e><rpa>l<.!J,8HOTOPb19
nOCJ1eCTYI1neHM"CW1ynpep,narae"'bIXB3a"OHl1>a.!1epal\l<.o
l1P\1earn3aLJ,l1">IIWWIIHITO<J>oH.@.LJ,I1""craHYTO'IIIpeIJ.Ht<3Id"a
nOflY'tB..ecOLJ,l1aJ1b1tOrol''''lI'''.nOflY'tBHoeTIII<I1Motipa:3OO<''''''b&noJJ,OroBopyC:OLJ,l1anb.
"oro.m;...al<e1\0Jl"'HOnQPJ,l1e,"",bB/¥IlIblte;;we"'11jJI10arn33l\1<"."epfl()'"
"3TO..npe.o,nO_""5I10JeTC<> CTJ><!WJeHenpaamem.CTB3r MOC....Crn<p3H""'..np"l'....
I<O"'''''''''''''L1jH''I\<J>oHJ\ropoAa,HOeAB<lI,..pewmb31Ynpo6I1e'''YMO
"'HOaaC"8Tyw,eMJTel<"npa8IJ)a><.11aH""8IiI'IO.....,""Bc""Y3TOrOYI'a3aHHb19
npeAnO_",noHaW8"'Y...HeHtO,HEtMoryrO"T.npH<I1b1
&1

CTIlnepe,Qa'rnJilnOJIHaJ'blnepe.n,aBaeMbIX.l\aHHblX, a TalOKeB03MQjfQf()CTI,ofura-
D,a.IDf$I ero TOJIbKO 3aKOHHbIMJ.! IIOJIb3OBaTeJIllMlf. C yqeT'OM CKa3aHHoro MCOKHO
npl1i1TI1 K BbIBQ!JY 0 TOM, 'ITO ceiNac yme Ha3pe.11a IJeOfiw.J:\>MXTb l\OIIOJIlI}fJ'b
pa3AeJlII .npJlyCJ1OBID1npHBaTl13alJ;ID1 :>IG1JIbIXnOMe
m1H»4>e,rJ;epaJIbHoro3aROHa«OroQJoH,!WBPoxm1-
CKOI1:.'CT.12CJ1e;JyKJro1I!:':pTIlMeHThI-
naJIbHoro )I{I1Jlb.II (J.fJ[J.f aHaJIOrn<rnble JIM opraHbI cy&beKTOB 
m)o6R3aHblrncTOJIHHOqxmaTbPOCCJilJlonp-
naxJlyCJIOBl1!IXnpHBaTl13alJ;ID1>KKJIbIX'
YK<\3aHHoe l\O[J()JIH€Ifi.E 6Y.l\eT. no lUuneMY MHemno, He TOJIbKO CIIOC06-
C'I'BOBaTb60JIeepea.m1aaIVmaHaJIJ13J1PyeMofiI1I1,HOJI
CJ6ecne<rnBaTbnpaBorpaiK,!laHHaI1:u6
YCJIOBIDIX npHBaTIl3aql1H :HGIJIbSI, RO'J'OpaH npl!l CTa6l1JIbHbIX npax
npHBa'rn3aIV1J1:, iJJeJ\epaJIbHblM3aKOHOM,HeperoroJl3MeHJj-
eTC.RcyfueK'l'aMl!lFOca1ftcRoji:4re.l\epa, aB03MOiKHOCTbm:
===apaHJNeHaCpoKOM,onpeJ1eJIeHHbIM4Je-
lIUI npe06pa30BaHII.R 0TII0IUI'HItii ro6cTBellllOCl'll B mIIJIUlltHOIi
,*"c
1Ipeo6pa3OBaHJtE' OTHOllieHIffi Co6cTBeHHOCTI1 B oi1: ciflepe KaK
OObeKTI1BHo'inpo,-\eCCMO:lKeTOCCTBJUITbCJInpI!lIIaJIJ1'lIDl
pH,!\aufu.eKTItBHblXrrp€.JJ;IIOCU.TKC1I'OpbleIJC.l3aOJlWDl6bI
3TOMY npo,-\eccy. K TaKOBblM OTHOCJITC$I: I) COHbIe YCJIOBI1II; 2) 3KOHQ-
MWleClG'!eYCJlOBIDI; 3) IOpi1W'f'{ecKl1e YCJIOBIffi.
ITo.l\ COlJlaJIbHblM" yc.ooBI1.RMI'i cJle.l\YeT IIOIJJIIMaTb TaK)'IO CJlTyall"JO B
aJQWIJIbHO-::lKounVII1'reCKOi1: ciflepe, RO'J'OpaH ofu.eRTI1BHO nQ3BO.IDlJIa 6b1wi1:
'iaCTJI HaCeJleHJ.1lj c1paHbI, HBJUnD!l.\el1:c.R HaHJ1M3:reJl.RMl1 :1KJ1JIbIX nOMell(e-
Hlfi1: B 1\OMax rOCY1\apcTBeHHoro IiI Mj'HI mJ1Jm1lV!oro QJoH,!W,
II"\cx:-raHOBneBepxoaHOrOCoBe-raPC4>CPOT4"KmR1991I:WI542.1-o"BaaeHM"
3a"OHa4>eJwpal\l<.O"""ll\HOro4>oH,l\aBPoe<:
cKO4>eJwpal\l<.06"3»"""oM8CTH»eCooe1blHapQAHbIX,qenyraTOB,..'f'
pe)O(,!1e"...d5eCr19'<HTb><ace.H."l\OCT'jII1HOOnopSUJ.Ke"
'::==;'a':=::==:
OJ1HaKO.a)COJJ,ep;gw.aC<lBSTOMnocTa><OBJle><..noPY"eH'IBC'aA><OPMalfOCH-
JJapa30B»xapaK1eD,6Jo"'COJ\eP>!<3/laCbHeDcaMOM3aKO"",aDO
BB"MoroD,QBi\cToB.ToeCTbDOTp»B90THBro,B)on»TCB>\Q9TBnbCTBjIeT.'<TO0H3
OC"opel5bU1a336»Ta"H""eMHe"Cr>JJ1HlIJI!ICb,Te...6oneeToopra... I<QToPO"'YOHa:appe.
COB3llaCb....KH33»B3eMblXMecJ><blXCooemo..<I3BHOHeCyuleCTB'{OT
Bcyon.oe'I8HH»' npM"H _.. nOMra..... '<TO. 11 npBA'W"aeo.oa. HOPMaJJ,OlI<Ha 15.....
33KpE!nI1BGID3a"OHef'oc<H;od:;ctIeJ:\epalJ,H-o>I<HlIjHoro4>oH,!\3B
4>e.c.epal\l<".2JC'fTbaTOiOHOPM»COCTO"'DTO"'.TO"o"nerOHTHbI9"><»>oe
CYLl\OCTB\'IOl1\HeOpraH»o6R3aH»nOCTo><><o.aHeOAflOPaaoBO"H4>oDM"poaaTbfP!l"',l\aH
PoccM onp"l\I<nax"yCno_. npB3rn3aLJ.l1">I<HblXnOMeL!lfjHM
:> c... "flalll,"»"aKOH OT 30 "OJH 2006 r. N'93-CII3-oBHeceH ""Me""H" 0 HeKOTO- 1
D""'bH»e"KTbIct>ep.epalJ,Hnooonpoc.aMo4>oD.."eHMReynpo._
I!I6HHOMnop!l,llKenp8Brpa>K,!J,8HHaOTAeJlbH»oo6beo<r»><IU1B"*"MOrO"IdjIL!lfjCTBB' 0\

yqaCTBOB<tTb II IIpO!.\ecce IIpvma'rn3aLlI1Jl!. IIoCKOJIbKY cym,eIITOB IIpIffiaTY!-
3aqHH MOmHO II 113BeCTHOM CMbICJIe paCCMa'TpJ.IBa'T'b KaK yqaCTHID\OB rpam-
,AaHCKOI'O I1jEBOOTHIJIIEH1H, TO 3TI1 yqaCTI1IDG1 ,AOJDRIIbI 6blI'b, Bo-nepBbIX,
npaBOcylTheKTHbIMY!, TOeCTbnpaBOCIDC06Hw.mJl!1, 11, BO-BTO-
polX, BbIcrynaTb  yme CYll\€CTB}'1Oll\ero mltmnJ..tHfJO npaaOOT-
HOllIeHl1H natiMa, B KOTOpoM OO1,eKTOM HBJIReTCH :1KIfJIoe. HaxO-
JI..IIll\eecJ'l II rocYI!apcTBellliOM I1JII.1 M}'Htn.llmaJlbHOM )IDfJUIUHOM c:lxm,l\e.
nOJI. ::mDlIIIfl1'n'CKl1MJf yc.num1IDU1 CJIeJlYeT nOID1MaTh TaKoe COCTORHJI!e
)!{HJno-tOCJMMyHaJIbHOC X03HitcTBa, BKJlK><ffiIOLl.\ee JI OOCTOHHUe:!tGUlbIX
I1OM II 1\OMax roCY.l1apcTBeHlwro " MYHmlHnaJIbHOro oro
4JOH,!\a.KOTOpoeII03BOJllfJl{J6bIOTHOCI1TeJIblKJMaCllITa6H)'1OB
npe.u;eJIax CTpaHbl: nepe,!:la'J)' rocYAapCTBeHHoi1 JI!  c06cr-
BeHHOCTI1 B :HGIIDIll\HOH cl}Jepe II co6cmellllOCTb 'ffiCTHyw. KaK 6YI!eT OTMe-
'1eHoB,I:l3..JIblleitM.HeBCffKOe)fGjJlOeI1OM€IIj,€lD1e.Brocy-
,llapcTBeHHQM IfJIIf maJIbHOM )KI.1JIl1li\HOM q.OlIJJ:e, MOiKeT 6bITb
IIpI1BaTIl3lfJJOBaHO.
IJoAlOpI1.!\JI!'IeCKJlMJI yc.rrOBJ1flMl'lCJ!e):lye'l'noHJtMaTbTaKOj.inpa-
BOooi1C11creMbI,ROTOpaRcnocc6HaperyJIl1]JOBaTbfi1I1JX1l.\ecc.
IJpem aHaJrn3 pm:ta npaBOBbIX aKTOB, CO.llep)K1l.IIJ;I1X HopMbl, pe-
rYID1pyweOrHoweIDI.RnonpJ.lBaTt13aJ.1)IGiJIbIX  n03BOJlR-
eT yrBepTb, 'ITO yttaaallliaH npaBOBaf! CI1CTeMa yme C03,AaHa.
B HaCTOHllIee BpeMR BCH COEOKyIDKiCTb llpaBOBbIX aKTOB no JIlX !Op"Wfie-
CKOfi CHJIe JIl JIlepapxH'll2CKCiii I1OCJIe,1\OBaTeJIbHOCTII MroKeT 6blTb YCJIOBHO
JJeHaHa CJle.1l)'lOlWferpymIbr
1 KrncnITyWtH POCCl1itc'Jroii ,1\eDf.
2.RO,1\eKCPOCcJ[HCKlJi.i4Je,1\epa'-\Hl1
3.JKJi1RO,1\eKCAepaL{Jl!I1
4.3aROHPoccuiicRrJjj:4Je,1\epaL{Jl!£1 «OIIp>maTl13aI..\IDloroclx>H,I1,a
B Poccm1cRu1 AepaL{Jl!YI.
5.J1Hble33.ROHbIF'oc:cnitc:KOO
6.YKa3bIIJproJf.!<€ffiB4Je,1\epa'-\Hl1
7.lJocraHoBnffiHHlJpamITeJrbcTBa  4Je,1\tpaQl1I1
8. ARm Cyfu.eKTOB PoccmkIroii: 4Je,1\epaL{Jl!Y!.
9.AKThI ,1\pyrl1X 4>e.1lepa.rrbHbIX If  opraHOB JIlCilOJIHJ1-
TeJlbHOHBJJaCm
I[eH'lpaJlbHbIM, 6a3oBbIM aRTOM cpeAM BCeH Ha3BaHHOfi MaCChI HOpMaTl1B-
HbIX aKTOB BbIC-ryrraeT 3aROH Pocm:iiu«M 4JeAepaQl1If «0 IIp>maTIt3aWIU
.HOC1Ioro clx>H,I1,a B PoccJmroij 4Je,1\epaL{Jl!£1 AHaJD.13JIPYfl 3TOT 3aKoH
KaK 61l3Y HOpM, IX crep:IKHeB)'IO OCHOB}'" CMCTI'MbI HDpMaTIm-
HblX aKTOB If IIpYlHWffiOB, perYJlYlpyIOllI,JIX crrHOweHlffl no IIp>manf3aL(I1JI!,
6bIJlO fihI HenpaBIfJIbHHM 3aMaJNlfBaTb TO 00cT0me1IbC'I'BO. 'ITO 33.ROHO,1\a-
N I TeJlbCTBOOICOAepiKl1TOll3aIIpeTbI,::aIIp>maTlf-
0\ 3aL(Y!lO >KI1J!blX rICiMtcU1€H1IJI. TwaT€'1IbHWt aHa.mf3 (){paIJWK'HIfI.1 Ha IIp>ma-

TIl3aqrno n03BOJIHeT yraepTb, 'ITO mrn npl1MeHHIOTCH RaRS 0THIJIIIeHI1I1
OO1.eKTOB, TaR I.f Cy6'beKTOB npvma'm3aJ.tl1K OrpaIDIl.JeID1.ll Ha IIpIIB<lTII3al.
 um.eKTOBYCTaHOBJIeHbl fKPrb, CO.!lep)t;aB II. 3 CT. 212
npI:lHl..\I1IDI3.JIbHOenpaBI:IJJO, cor.nacHoKOropOMYBl1,!\bI KOTopble
MoryrBrocy,IWJX."IBE'IIIU1IfJ114M)'H11q>maJIlHfJij:coI5cTBeIDJoc-
TII, {JIIpe,!\eJlJilOTCH aaKOHOM l\aK 6bI B pa3BI1TI'1e Ha3BaHHOfi HOPMbI, XOTfl I>1
HecKOJlbKO IIpOTI1BOpe<nmO, nl CT. 313 fRf'4I )'K3.3hIBaer, IlTQ B Co6c'l'BeH-
HOCTl:lfpaHI>1tqJIf.WI'II'CK>IX.lIIfL\MOmeTHa.'«JJUITbCH.m060eeCTBo,
3a JlCeHl:leMOT.!IeJibHbIXBI1,!I;OBCTBa, KOl'opoeBcOOTBeTCTBI:IJI! C
3aitOHOM He MomeT  rpaiK,I\,maM JI tqJl1,!\1N2CrofM JII:II¥IM
C yq:eroM 3TOro aaKOHO):\aTeJIbCTBO {J npvmaTl13al[ID'I JlCXO.l[l:lT Jl3 wro, 'lTO
npl:lsaTl13al[1:IJ'I >KMbJ'l rpa*.I\aHaMI:I MOmeT JlMeTb MeC'T'O JII:IWb tJa (JCHose
3aHI:lMaeMbIX I1MJI >KMbIX nl B rocy,!\apcTBellliOM J1 MYlnlIIJaJIb-
HOM JKl2JIJIIWiOM clJoH,/\e. OrcIO)13. JIOIWIecKJI MOJoKHO C.!IeJIaTb BbIBO.!\, 'ITO S
JIIOOOM II/HOM, RpOMe rocy,llapt"I'BE'llHtrO IiI  )lG!Jll.flltHOM
clJoH,/\e HaIDIMaTe.ID1:IKI:IJIbIX nOMeIl[emrn npasa Ha npl:lBaTI13B.l[VIIO 3aIDlMae-
MOro JlMII)lG!JIb.II He HMelOT 3roTaK Ha3bIBaeMble OIpaHl:I'IeIDIH nyreM YMOJT-
l.JaHIDI. O.I\H1illO 3aKOH Poccm"Docil <Pe,!\ep «0 npvma'm3 JKI1JIJ1Il[-
HOro clJoH,/\a B PocotitcI«Jl'i <Pe.!lepal[lmn co.n;epiKaJI B nepBOHa'i3.JIbHoti
pe,!\aKW<!111iI Hbrne co,!\epm.l1T IiI npJ'IMbIe 3aIIpeTbl Ec..7rn paCCMO'lpeTb 3TI13a-
IIpeTbI B xpoHJJI)1'H'II"CKIJM nopH,!I;Ke, W I1X TpaHc4>oPMal[lfJl BbITJUI;JJ'JIa
CJie)JylOID;I:IM: OOpa30M. TaK, B pe,!\aKl[Jll1 3aKOHa 1 <Pe.!lepal[l1l:l
or 23.l2.l{)92 r. N 4m9-1; 4>e,!\epa.rrbHbIX3aKOHOB OT O1.05U9{) f. N 8843;
or 20.05. 2002 r. N 55-4X3; OT 29.12.2004 f. N 189-4>3 cornacHo CT 4 xapaK-
Tepl13yer.JOro 3aKoHa «He nO.!\JIeiKaT.)KI1J!b1e WI,
HaXoeCH B aBapI1ihIOM COCTIJHID1I1, B 1HX, R:OMMJ'lffiJIbHbIX
KBaprnpax', B ,ADMaX 3aKpbITbIX BoeHHbIX ropo,lJ;KOB, a TaIOKe CJIyiK€6HbIe
:»G1JIblenoMeIl[eHl1fl,3aOCKllK1'l('lM2Moro4x>HAafXE'r03(J3J1JJ;Pyrl:lX
ce.m.cKIJXD3J1fx:TBeHHW!: IIpe.I\IIPJ.1H'I'Icl, It HIfM npipaBHEHHbIX, a WIOKe He
noATIeiKaTnpI:lBaTI13a,-"",I1:!t01JIbleJJ:JMell[elDUI,rpa:)K,l:\a-
HaM no .!IOroBOpaM COl[MaJlbHOro HaHMa nocne 1 Mapra 2005 f.
, B AaJ1bHewe'" 6w>o ycTaflOMeflO, 'ITO cn!(J<OOH"'e ...ulbOe nOMell\eH " OMld)lflallbHbIe
aapmpblMOryr(jbIT.nopeweH..coOc'-".uIL1IHoro4>oH,<18.
"n".."cpraHOa,aTalOKesaKOTCPbl..sao:penneH_-
J1L1IHbI<J>ooJ\l<anpa"enOJ1HoroBI!J\eH,"eonep"rn"ooe
ynpaMeHeOTOJ)bIXnDj)fW,aH....nL1IHbI;;<J>ooJ\(.2CT.43aKOHaepalll1
.o".uIL1jfIOro4>oH,<l8.Bepa1J,>I'Bpe,/\!lK3aKoHaPoc
c""","palll1OT23,l\eKafipH 1992r N'4199-11 BJI3IlbHel'iL1l8M I CT 4Ha383HHO
ro3aOHa(j..na,llOnonHeHa.corJl!lCflOOTOPOMYHenOAl1e:GT
>IMIlblenO""'ll\eH...,rp"""",,,"""'nO,lJ,OroBOpaMCOlll1aJ1.""'OHa;;""'no.
CJle1...a,crra2005(c"..CTI2epanbHoro33<OHaOT29,l\eK35p2004r.N!11!9-<%I3.o
""eJ\eHel\e<\cT""e>K.uIL1jfIOroKOJWKCapalll1'J
CyAF'<t>WCIiHBI'tH!M OT 15 KJII 2005  N\l6-n 11p\'I3f1a11  1 CT. 43aoHa PocC"""," I
O1>e.!1epalll1H.o>IMIl1llHCl"04>oH,<l8.e4>el\epalll1"'l<eCOOTaBT.rt"\
CTByIOW,BKOH""'TYlII1P<%l.a,HerJO)lllB><3ll\e;;np...e""H1O 0\

:BJwtMo. Cl\1HI"IetIJIe cymecrB)'lOI.W1X 3arrp€TOB MO)f(HO Ha3BaTb 'i. 2
cr.43aK()Ha4Je,!lepawnt «OrrplfBam3awrnoro40H,!\a
BPocorlluocii: 4JeJ:lepau;ml, corJlaCHOKOTOJXlii OO'! oro
H,!\a=I1MOpraHbI,aTalOt\eIIpe,JJ;JIpI1.F!'IWI,3aK01'OpbI-
MM 3aKpelLlleH  4oH,!\ Ha IIpaBe X03JIi.k.'TBeHH Be,!leID1Il, If yq:-
peJK,!\eHIDl, B onepaTIfBHoe yrIpaBJIeHYIe KOTOpbIX nepe.n:aH:1KIIJIJIIWIbrl H,!\,
C cornacl1fl cOOcTBeHH/.fKOB BnpaBe IIpIfID1MaTb peweHl1.ll 0 np/.1IlaTIl3a
c.nym.e6HbIXrlIIfHaXe!UCRBce.m,uroiiMeCTIfOCTKo-
roH,!\aCTalW!OH3.pHbIXyq:pem.u.eHl1i133.!lIHTbIH3.c:e.JIeHmpo
UIHa I1}:&maTIf3aI..tI'IImwIbIX ]J)ISIorrpe.11eJieH-
HbIX cy6'heKTOB MOIyr6bITb Bbme,!leHbI"-3 CT. 2 aBaJIJ1at!pyeMoro 3aKOHa, co-
fJiacHO mrrupoti npVlBaTJI311JXIBaTb)K}!J!bIe nOMell(eHJ1.F! MOryr JD1lLJb rpam-
,!IaHe, 3affi1MalCll!l1€ )KJ1J1bIe IIOMelJ..!€HJ1.F! B P;OMax rocYJlapcTBeHHoro If
M)'H11L{Iffia.m,HOroJKl1JIHlqHOroH,!\a,BKJlK)qaJjclx:>H,!\,H3XO)J,fl-
l1\IdicflBnOJlHOMBe,!leHJ.1J1t1JIKOnepaTIfBHoM
yrrpaBJIeHJ.1J1 yqJJem.u.eHl1i1 (Be 4oH,!\) no,AOrooopy HaiiMa IfJIJI
apetl,lJ;bl. BepXOBHhIi1 Cy,!\ pqJ B OO3ope cy.u,efuDi IIpatmrol «0 HeKOTOpbIX
BOnpocax, B03H1lliIDOll(MX npVlPaccMO'I'peHlfil cyp;aMl>1p;eJl, CBH3aHHbIX c np"'-
Bam3al1l1eiirpa.:m,rtaHaMJilJKl1JlbIXm )lKa3aJl, 'ITO«npaBOHa6e<:-
n.rraTH)'IO)l{I1.IIb$[aaKOHOMTO.IIbKOrpam,!\a-
HaM, aaH"'MalOll\VlM :m:t1JIble (paapH,!l;Ka Hailla. - H.C.) nOMeIIleHJ1.F! no
P;OroBopy HatiMa I1JIK apeH,QbI B p;OMax rocyp;apCTBeHHoro IfJIYI M)'HHlW!Il3.JIb-
HOro mJ1JII1oro 4oH,!\a». ClIe,!lOBaTeJIbHO, npaBO Ha npI1BaTl13aqillO)KJ1-
JIbIX  TeM 'lJIeHaM CeMbVl HaHl1MaTeJlH, KOTOpble He aaHYIMaJlVl 1
.H\J1JIoe  B }TKa3aHHbIX ,!lOMax, If TeM IpaJl<,!\aHaM, lWfopble aa-
HHMaJIH :m:J1JIble UI. HaxoWIllecH B .mo6bIX IllibIX )KJ1.1ll1ll\HbIX
410H,!\3.x 2 , KJXlMe rocyp;apCTIeHHoro = M)'HI!IWI!I1aJlbHOrO )KJ1J1V1ll(Horo
4oH,!\a IIOCKOJIbKY aaKOHO,!\aTeJib npep;OCTaBJ1JI npaBO Ha npl1BaTIf3aJ.tl1lO
;=If=,::O:If::=e:=
11t13.eCTHO'fTOflo.o.3aH"THeM",...,oro_"_HL1IHOMnpasellCtHo6eJC<iO.ceJ1e-
H..ee"erO"3a,oHoMnOpl\!1<e.ToeCTbcnpaSMopon..cH
I1IlHpefl1CTpalJ,HHrpa>l(A3HnoMeGT)'"",,",nbCTBa
2npeBOI<."'''''b''no...weH''B''WopoH4a><'''O><eTB03HH"HyrbnHWb
ccom.C>lRoo6CT11e1<H"KB)I(I1Jlbll
3Ec:Jl"aa.oHPOCCI1iic<oiiC1>eJ\epaLJ,HH.Qf1P\1eaTH3a"",""'HnHL1IHoroopoH,D,BBFocxH;o:ci;
<!>I',o,epalJ,H".He)'CT.HO."np>lM""'''.f1PBTOBlxolRC)\eJlenarOI1HblM
npHe""'M)npHII3TH3.""''''''...,'''''no'''"'1lBH''..n''......''6e3fP'1J1\l1BHCT..''.
TOB"P"f1P\1eal"3alJ,H""HbI.B'II\OB""'I'l1\8CTea'".e3anpeTbI)'CreHaMea-
n..cb.T"",3eKOHoMPooc>1cKOlii<J1e,o,ePB'-*'H.QnpHea.",JBiJ,I'IH)I(I1JlHll\HOro<J>olVleBPooc"ii-
C.Oii""'H.1998r.npeAyCMOTP6HO,'<TOOAHH.."3KPHTepHe.OCjlUjeCT.neHm1no.ll-
=:'=::a":;=:.-=
e"'3Bnpere"')"<.CTHeBerOf1P\1eal"3Bl1"HI1HOCTp.HH""'4'''JIoI'IeC''''''IOfJI'IAH"eCl<l<xnl\
In.3C1.4rnporp."''''blnpearH3BljI1'')'
I

LQeHl1H no ,l\OfOBDpy HatiMa J1JIJI! apeHIJ,bI B ,l\OMaX rocy,!\apcTBeHHoro I1JIJI MY-
HHQHTJaJIbI!OI'Oro<PoH;!\a
C yqeTOM If3JIroKeHHOro, mtemwlO, fibLJIO fib! npaBlWbIIbIM H JIOfM'leCRYI
BHecrHBcT.113aKOHaPocClfitcRci;i4Je,!\epaLUGfcOnpl'l-
BaTIl38.'-\illI »rnJIlfllVIOro <PoH,1\a B Poccw"D«n1 4Je.I:\m: ,lI(IJ()JIlI'HH€,
C4qJM)'IDIpoBaB 'i. 2 3TOiI CTaTbI'l CJleJ01IOlll;l'lM 06pa30M: "ITpaBO Ha npl106-
pe'I'eHlfeBBnOpR,l\Kenpl1,»rnJIoro
 B I'occJ.rlIcmi.i 4Je.l:\epaQllH J1HOCTpaHIWM iii IDIIWM fie3
Ipa.jK,lJ;aHC'I'BaHenpJ1Ha,u.JIeHGIT"
m<PoHJ\POCCID1,KaKBl'JIIf'Iai;ImeeeeHaJ..tl'lOHaJlbHoe,l\OC'l'ORHl1e,
npl1Ha,/\JIewrr  HapoiJY Becn.naTHaR nepe;!\a'ffi:!Kl1JIbH I«IMY fib!
TO ID16bl11o, KpOMe rpaiI\,!\aH PocCJ1l'l, I1pOTIfBOpeql'lJJo fib! HOHaJIbHbIM IDI-
1'epE'CaM. KpoMe BCel'O UfMe'!ellliOfO"BeI H36ee3TOl'OnpoTI1Bope'il1IlMbI
H npe,!lJlaraeM ,l\OnOJIHifib 8HaJIJ131rpyeMbIi13aKOHC4qJMJm1POBaHHbIM Bbune
 Iro'T'Opoe B CJIy'ffie nplflUlTI1fl ero 3aKOHO)\aTeJleM MorJIO fib!
CTaTh HeOfJxQrJ;IIIIdi HDpMOiI I1paBa
4t) npeOOpa3(iII3HJIH oTlKiUJ('JlJfji C06cTBeIIHOCT1 B 1KJ11I111Wf{1ii
_.
ITpeo6pa30BaHl1eUI'HOllJeHKiiBJKI'IJIJIlI1HOic<lJepe- 3TO
1Ip000ecc, KO'I'OpbIii BKJIIO'!aeT CJleJlYlOUJ;I'Ie 3BeHbR: a) 3aJ1BJ1elU1e HaHIfMaTe-
JIJI)KI1J1oro HaXrocHB,l\OMerocY;!\apcTBeHHoro tfJII1MY-
HJIQJmaJIbHOI'O AWmnL\K)l'O <PoHJ\a, 0 >KeJlaHJ1Yj npJllBaTd311poB3.Tb 3aHJl!M3.-
eMOeIilMrICI\IeIl.J'lll1E'.IiIreToro4JaKTa, 'iT03TUfHaHl1MaTeJIb
paHeeHeHI13TO.HI1RaKoe-IDI6o.I\PYfOe»rnJIoere
(co6Jno.l\eHJ.re IIpl1HWlfia O,1l;HOpa30BOCTII IIpl1BaTl13aql'lJ1 )KIfJJbJ1), 6) npl'lHR-
TIle ::!TOro ::!aRBJIeID1H I«JMIIereIffHljM opraHOM, pacCMOTpeHJI!e ero no cyIW'-
CTBy H y,l\OBJleTBopeID1e 3a.HBJleHHI)r() IpaJK,!\aHI1HOM >KeJlaHID1, B) 3aKJllO-
'ieHl1e rpa)l(,11aHIiHOM, npl1BaTI13l1pYlOl1\I.fM ml1J1be, iii 1\enapTaMeHTOM
(ynpaBJIeHl1eM)M)'H1)KI1JIbHJIJI!5oJ1HbIMopra-
HaM, TaK KaK B pa3JIWJHbIX cy6DeKTax q,e,l\epaI..\ll!l'l3TOTOpraH
MC»KeT Ha:3bIBaTbCR "no .I\PYl'OM)" , JJ:oroBopa 0 nepe;!\a'ie rpam,I\amrny)Kl1-
JIoro nOMeIIleHI1fl; r) ifJaKT nepe;!\a'I!ll »rnJIoro nOMeLQeHl1fl, nO.n;TBepJK,lJ;ae-
MbIti aKTOM IIpl1eMa-nepeAa'itt; JJ.)  M npaBa Ha
oe IIJMeIII.EIDI€nyreMBI1t'C€I1IffiRUmeTelITHblMJIJfl.\OM COOTBeTCTBYID-
IIII'IX 3a!lJl!ceil B EwtHbJJ1 rocy..QapcTBellHl:Dl peecrp npaB COrJIaCHO n 3 CT. 2
3aKoHa"OrocYJJ:apcTBl2llHCi1pernCTpaQl1l1npaBHaHeJ\Bl1-
JKI1Moe t1MJliI€CTBO H C.lIeJlOK C HI1M»..JlJ1rnb C MOMeHTa BHeceHIDI )'Ka3aH-
'O.pop""6I<e9Ceroo"'nneo<ca1))96yeM""'.QIIAnpearn3a-
1111" pa3HbIJ<eyrn.eo:rax F\xn.tib<Dii%J.epa1J,I<. npo.OJJW1OCbpa3HblM"Opra><aM, ro.
MJI>Kf! "Q/J.H""" Tex",eco:rax3TopraHbI "Hor.o.a ME!l<IUlC, Tal<. TOllbKO" r. MocKllE! I
oq:.op.."eH""T"""XJlOl<YM'!HTO.6b111onepe.1lOHoorB,/J,E3b1,"0T,/J,E30.-lt'\
"YnpaBJJeHe"'''''b"OI'PyroorojJO,!\1l, 0\

HbIX 3aIIJICeji rpaiK,!\aHJ1H C'IaHOBIITCH co5cTBeHHl1KOM IlpJllBam3J1lpOBaHHO-
ro )KJI!JIoro nOMeHI1.J!. rK pqJ TOiKe CM3bIBaer MOMeHT B03HJIlKHOBeIDi.ll
npaBa co5cTBeHHOCTJI! Ha He,IUJIDKJIlMOe JI!M)'IIIeCTBO C MOMeHTa ero rocy,!\ap-
CTBetiHOa pEmC'fJ)3QJ1JI! (CT. 131. IL 2 CT. 223). TI)'HKT 1 CT. 2 4>e,!\epaJIbHoro
3aKOHa «0 roCY'/:w'pcTBeHHOO lnpaBa Ha He1\BltmllMOeJ1MjIII\e-
CTBO JIl C,!\eJIOK C HI1M» CO,!\epiKJjT HDpM)'. cornaCHO KOTOpOi1 rocy,!\apCTBeH-
Ha.ll pemCTpal\11.II HBJl.IIeTCJ! e;t:UIHCTBeHHbIM ,!\OKa3aTeJIbCTBOM CjIII\ecTOO-
BaHI1.II 3aJXfl'IC'IPl1pCJOOHRJl'O npaBa 1 .
TaKI1M 06pa30M, n)"!'eM  peaml3aWD1 xapaKTepJll3ye-
MbIX 3BeHbeB ocyIl(eCTB 1IJIeTCfl npe06pB30BaHl'le 0'I'H0IlleIllm: cc6C'memI0-
corn B >KMJIJ1IWIOH cVepe, a pe3)'nbTBTOM )'Ka3aHHoro npeo6pa:30BaHI1II
BbJC'I'}'IlaeT IIpe co5cTBeHHocTif Ha KOHKpeTHoe )KIfJIoe 1I0Me-
ll.\emleyrocypCTBetiHorol1JIl1OpraHa tiI!()3l1l1l{llOB-
Htie npaBa IfBCTHofi co6cTBeHHoCTJl! Ha IlpJllBaTI13l1pyeMoe )KJI!JIoe 1I0Me-
ll.\eHtie y  JIMeHHO C OTMeIfeHHOro MOMeHTa rpam.11ClHIffi He
TOJIbKO I1Meer npaBO Ha oc)'ll.\eC'lBlIemre Tpl1aM>! npaBOMINJlii COOCTBeH-
Hm\a BJIB)J;etlKH, nOJIb30BaHJIlH J1 pacrrDpJDKeHJIlH, HO II! HeceT 6peMH C05CT-
BeHIDiKa. CBSI3aIIIIOE' C OcyI1f2CTE!JleIDleM paCX0,110B no CO,11ep:maHI1IO :iYfQro
I1MjIII\ecTBa II! ero oxpaHe
PeryJlflTVlBHaH c))YHKHI nplHmOB nplaa"IU38I(.IIU mlJIblX IJOMeIqe-
nidi CBJI!)\eTeJlbCmyer 0 TOM, 'lTO xapaKTepu:3y€MbIe IIpI1Hl\IffibI OOJlBJIBIOT
co5cTBeHHbIMJl!CBCiiCTBaM>lpery.1Il1poBaHI1.F!COOTBeTCTB)'IOW,J1X
H="""""",,,-
Cne.n;yeT cornacm'bCJ! c TeM l\OKa3aHHbIM B Ha)'Ke IXJJIIJ1ReffiIeM, corJIac-
HOKOTOPOM)'IIpJllHW1IIblKaKrpa>K.!!aHcKOro, TaKJIoroIlpBBa, a CJIe-
l\OOBTI'JIUIO. JI IIpI1Hl\IffibI Ilp :mJ1JIbIX nOMeIIlemrn OOJIBJlBIOT
peryJUITJ1BHbIMJl! CBOI1c:TaaMn. 3m- peryJIHTJ1BHble CBOdcrBa npmfi<JlIIOB
npl1BBTI13Bl\I1I1 )!01JIbIX 1IOM€f.lt€HI1iI3aJIDmeHbI HBMI>1 B onpel\eJIeHJ.IVII1X no-
HHTIDI. BMecre C TeM XOpOllIO tlalJecTIl). 'lTO J1HCTpyMeHTOM pery.mrpoBBHJlJH
 OTHOweHJIJH fiBJIfllOTCH npaBoBbIe, a IlplfMeHJ.fr€'JIbHO K Ha-
IlleMYo-npaBoBbIeHOpMbLHe'I"JIJI!3):jeCbl\y6JI11p0-
I nOC"Ob"YllpBaTaal\l'l" -,ITOH..AaKTnepe/lil")I(WI"""an>CY/lilpCT
BeHHO;;I1"'I"<I1L111nanbt<o;;coI5cTeeHHOCTHBIflXTbaCTHYtO.To4>a.TTa"O;;lle.
:Bn:.:;=:".:o:;;':
rOC)l/lilpCTBeHHbleopraHbI BHe"CTOpbl"cy6be"Ta><PoccAc'oA<1>eJlBpal\l'lH a"CB
AeTeJlbCTBy",.npaKTl'l.a,TawA.Be)\aOTI.at't\MDI'ep<..e06ll1"CT8aTa.."
r MOCKBe nO.D.061"O perCTPaLll1tOCHaHa.na 0Cy\1II!CTBJ1M0 AO MOC>KW1pen.tCTpa1.j1.t.
"aaTe..AOoc..TO"e3al<Oa_l1l1"a"e
CCblJl"H"B(;T><""HOBH"O.""OTCYTCT.Herpar.oOT"'"
.Ba",HOCTbltJl<lTeflbHOi;npoBBp""llepBH"H""AOKJ'ldeHTOBnpH"oaH"
"oBeHI1llpaBaco15CTBeHHoo...."ap,aHHY",>I<I1I1nncllIiIJ\b"T.n.lc.... Har1jJ..ep. Moo
OBC"anpaep,a.cT5..tOH2000r)"e"'oryrCJly)t;HTbopaep,aHHe"sToAHeaa<cHIOti
..nopO"HoAI1p8KT1'1"H
I

BaHJl!HI1JIJInpBBoBOroperyJIHpOBamrn?ITOJI3.raeM,'ITOHeT
J1BOTnO'JeM)'_
IIpem.Ile Bcem He CJIeJlYeT aa6bIBaTb, 'lTO pMJl!pyeT, 4>qJMyJD1pye'I',
mpaiKaeT " 3aKpeIl./lHeT B COQTIjeTcrB)'1OUJ;ID( HopMaTIIBHbIX aKTBX KaK
nplflll.\l1IThl, TaR J1 HOpMbI npaBa aaKOHO)1aTeJTh., o,mJaKO, OTMe-
'fIITb, 'ITO cyIWlOCTh J1 npe,lI;Ha3HB'leHJl!e npl1HlU1IIOB B npBae HecKOJThKO
HHwe, 'leM HOpM 05OCTbXBpaKTeplf3yeMbIX KaTel'Opldi:KaK pa3 t1npoHB-
JIJIeTCHB aHaJill3Ifpya.KIIllf, XOTHnplflll.\l1ITh1 J1O-npaBo-
Bble HOpMbI pery.n11pyKYf no-pasHOM)'"' . ITplfHlI;IfIIbI Hepe)J;KO 3BKpeII.TUOOTCH
B HOpMaTlfBHbIX aKTaX B BJ1,/\e 06Il.\J1X npaalfJI IIOBeJ\emrn, B Tome BpeMH Omf
MOryr ObITb BbIBe)J;eHbI 113 OT.r:\eJThHhIX HOpM t1l1HblX aaKtJHOll(jJ]())fIfH, TaK
KaK OHJl! OTpa B HIfX B BJ.UJ;e a6cTpaKTHbIX I:. ,l(€tiCTBYJ'I KaK
OOIl\lfe npaBlfJIB, nplflll.\l1IThl rom ow aaIIpelOT BbIXO,1\ 3a npe)J;eJlw HOpM,
" XO'fH CO,1\epiKaHlfe KBiti,!\Oti J13 HOPM, pery.nl1pylO!L\eti OT,1\eJIbHhIe rpaHJi!
npJIBB1 )IGIJThIX nOMeI1!emfli, CTpora rOBopJ!, HeCKOJIbl\OOTJlJI'JHO OT
CO,1\ep:IKBHIff! IIp'1HQI1IIDB, Ha 3TI1 HOpMbI KaK 6bI HemJHO (B CKpbITOM BJ.UJ;e)
HaJI3.raIOTC.F!OcocropoHbInpOB.IIpJllHW'!IIblnpllBaTJl!33.-
l{I1J1l :m.J1JIblX  B CTpyttTYP€ 3JleMelITOBnpaoonpHMeHeIDVI aa'l3-
C'I)'IOBblcrynaKJfBHeHBHOif,KBK6bIB c3a 4>qJMe.BcJIlJl)'
xaMHMIIpt1HltIfI18M,COJJ;HOifCTOpoHw,Bce06oc-
TK, a C ,Apyroif - OTHOCIt'I'eJIUIOO aOCTpBKTIlOCm OHJl! 3B)\3lOT JIJl!IIIb OOlI{YlO
nporpaMMY npaBOBOro pery.JlJllXE3HllH, He perJJllll8\"I11PYH :H\eCTKO KOH-
Kpe'fHble pMbI era npJllMeHeID1JL Mo.meT ObITb nooTOM)' Cy&beKT nplfMe-
HeHlff! HopM oro npaBa, pery.nl1pylOW,J1X 0THIJIlHDDI no npJllBaTIf-
aaW1l'l)KlfJThIX,t1HOr,D;aHeOC03H3eTpery3Ha'lJl!MOCTIf
IIDB, HaKOTOpbIX3IDIVIeTCHIIpaBOIIptlll81e1nE'J1IDUIM3HI1€3H3'lIf-
MOCmnOCJleJJ;Hero.
3,1\ecb MbIyme CTaJIKJIlBa€MCJI Hec peryJJSrI1fBHJii4>yl!Kl.\l1lf
nptlH4tnmB, a c npo6.neMoI1: npaBOC03HaIDIJI CyUbeKTOB IIpJIMeHeHIffi KaK
HopMnpaBa, TaK" npOB. BMeCTeCTeManpbI
BbICTynaIOT CBOero poJ\a 6a3on, Ha OCHOBe KOTOpoif npllHl1MBWICH I1JIJI OT-
aeprBI<JI'CH Te I1JIJIl1Hble HopMBTlfBHble IJOJIOmeHJI!Ij 6e3 Y!L\ep6B npaBOBOMY
peryJIllflOOBHlflOOOJ..l.1l'C'l'B€HO'I'I!Ol1JI2HIf
 4JyH npIIHl(IIIIOO JJpHBaTI13BqWI 3mJIldX
nOMeutemrn: rJ03BOJ!HM' npJllHU,Jl!IIaM 6bITb cBcero poJ\a 6a30if, Ha OCHOBe Ko-
TOpoif npumlMalO'l'CJl, BlillJQJIHJlIOT peryJUITl1BHyro poJTh, I1JIJI omepraIOTC.ll
Tel1JIJll1HbIeHOpMaTIfBHb!eAHBJ!lf3J1!PYeMhIenplflll.\l1IThlHBJLf!-
JOTCJ'I TeM KapK3COM, Ha OCHOBe KOTOpOro 06'be,D;lffUleTCJ!, KaK 6bI lIeMeHTIf-
pyeTCH, BCH COBOKynHOCTh HOPM, perym1pylClI!!1X OTHOllleHJl!JI no npJllBaTIf-
'npHL.u.mOB"'M""OOM6\1j6HMi'lMHOj)M I
nOJl MHblM yrOM 3J>eH" paDCMarp83JI"" «aldH B naparpacJ>e nepooM rIlaBbi BTopoi'l Ha t--
CTIJIIUJerDl'IIXTf\IJJIIaH 0\

3BqID1>K>1J1bIX  06pa3Y1O!L\aRBMecTe C nplfHWllmMJ.\ npJllBaTY!-
3BijJI!JI! >K>1JIbIX nOMeIDf!f npO'IHyro CJIlCTeM)' npBBOBOro peryJIJlpOBalUUL
taJIbH()-npaBOBOi1OCHoooii: HRapK.aCOM, a w'lHee CJllCTeMo06pa3)l1OI.l\MM
41BmopoM yK33aHJfOH CJIlCTeNbI BbICTynBtOT npmlL\IDIb!. B clIJI)' HX 6oJIbWei1
CTnocpaBHeHlfiOCIHOpMaMl10IDfMeHh-
we no.1lBep:?KeHhI TpaHC4xJpMaIl}1ll!:  ,l\OIlOJIHeHJl!lO WIJI! OTMeHe.
Kor,J\a 3aKOHO):\aTeJIb H3MelUleT KaK}'IO-JIH60 I«JHKpeTHY;O )KHJrnIIU10-npa-
BOByro HopM)' - 3TO He BJIe'leT C€pbE':llillXHe)\OCTaTKOB B npaBOBOM peryJD1-
poBaHJl!lf npeo6pa30BaIDfHOTHOIllE'tIIIii C06cTBeHHOCTJl! Bi1 c4Iepe,
'raR RaR ::IcjxpeImlBHOCTb  OTMeqeHHhIX OfHOIIIeHl1i!: H J1X
npaBOBOro peryIDlpOBaHl1fl BOCIIOJIHHe'I'CH [irrarO):\apH npmm;IlIIaM.
PMb 11 3Ha'leHlfe xapaKTepJll3yeMoi1If1yHKlI;JI!JI! npl1HIJ;JI!I10B npnaa'I'l13a-
QI1HmlfJIbIXlI:OJDKHbIy<rWI'bIBBThCRRaK3aKOHO):\a'I'eJIeM.ocYIlW-
CTBJIHJO!W1M npaBOTBCfJ'I€CT, 'raK H npaBOnptlMeIDrreJibHbIMJt OpraHBMIt.
TaR, 3aKOHO.1la'I'eJIh, l13MelUUI, OTMeH1UI WIJI! BBO.1\fI B CJ.lCTeM)' npaBOBoro
perym1JXGlliW1 OfHOIIIeHIDI, CBH3aHHbIX C npJllBaTI13aWted >K>1JIbIX nOMe-
Il\eHHi1, HOBbie HOpMhI, ,l\OJDKeH COOTHOCIITh CBoe npaBOTBopqecTBO C yqeroM
}:1€iij CI1CTeMhI I1pHlIQItIIIJB H npaBOBhIX HOpM. B CBOlO o'lepe):!h,
 opraHhIB npoL\ecce nptlMeHeHW! IIpBaa npl1 06Ha-
pymeHlU1 orc)'TCTBIif! ROHKpeTHhIX npaBOBhrX HOpM pyKOBO.IIC'I'By
npIHIL\I1I1aMl1
OrHoIIIeHWI no BJIB)J;eHJl!KJ, n0JIh30BaHJfiO H paCllopHJoKeHmOJKI1JIhIMJl no-
M€II.t2HlfJ!MJ1 BhICTynaror, C O)1HOii CTOPOHhI, <!w.KTOPOM, 
cyIL\HOCTb H CO.1lepJoKaHJ.le RaR HOPM, 'I'BK H npl1HIJ;JI!I10B npJllBa'rI13aL\l1l1 )KH-
JIhIX nOMeIl.\eHHi1, a C .IlPyroi1- 06'beKTOM CTBItf! [J()CJI('.lI;tI B3RThle
B e,l\l1Hcme HOpMhI J1 npl1lll.\IDIbI npJllBaTItmQHl1 )J{I1JIbIX nl HOCfIT
3BE!JI!CIIMhrli 11 I1pCIJ13BO.I\HhI xapaKTep OT peryJIl1pyeMhIX I1M11! 
HhrX 0'IH0IlleHIrn.. B 'I'O me BpeMJI OHI1, 6y,l\Y'U1 BhIpameHHhlMJl B o6oeKTI1B-
HhrX 4>qJMaX, aKTl1BHO  lIB nopoJU1BIIIl'E J1X 0'J'H(UJeIIJ1H, 011-
p€,!\eJIHH eaate I1npaBOBbIeOCHOBbinpeOOpB3OBaHJl!ft
0'I'lICIllEEJIi co6cTBEmrocTJ.I B :oo1.III1Il\Hoiii ct}Jepe, HX opraHJl!JyeMOCTh.

BblBOAbi
B KOHl.\e IIpO,!I;eJIaHHOi1 paOOrbI .HCRO H '1eTKO I1pOCJIeJoKMBaeTCH TO, 'ITO
xcrreJIOCb C',!I;eJIa'Tb B caMOM€e Ha'laJIe.lIroToM)' B BbIBO,!\ax nOHOMY I1C-
CJIe)\OBaID1lOHI"06xoJ:\HMo npee BeeI'D mp1l31ITbW, 'ITO 1I0CTJ1I1IYTOB pe-
3YJIbTaTenpoBe,!\eHHoroR.
Bo-nep6blX, B ILffilHe TeOpen1'ieCKOM MbI IIbITa.IDlCb 060cHOBaTb TO no-
JIom!'lD1e, corJIacHoKOTOJXIMYoenpaBOc06oj.jKoM-
IIJIeKCH)lIO mpaCJlb npaBa C m6cTBemtmICHCTeI\oKJtI npOB, a IlpJllBaTI1-
3a4l1H:m:J.IJIbIX  ilBJUleTCH 11HCTtnyIU\'! 1 OTpaCJII1
nOCKOJIbKynpJl!HW1JIbIco5crBeHHoronpaB3. B paMKaXCOOTBeTCT-
 KOMJIJ!€I«:IIO mpaCJJIf BWi1 J1JIJI! l1Hon MepeOTpaif(8KJTCH, npoJfB-
.IDlKYl'CH JI! Mor)'T 06HapYifO'ITb COO'I'BeTCTB)'IOlLJW4 06pa30M CBDe ,AetfCTBJIle B
Kam,!l.OM :>KI1JIJILlIHo-npaBOBOM I1HCTJrryre, TO Mbl 11 nOIIbrraJll1Cb 06Hapy-
}IG1Th 11 npoaH3JlJI311JXB3-Th :HGIIDILlIHO-npaBOBble nplflll.\11IIh1 B JlHCTIITyre
npJl!BaTJ13al.\ffil:HGlJIb!Xn1.
Oco6oe BIDIMaIDIe YJJ:eJUleTCSI nOHHTIlIO npl1HqmIOB IIpJllBa'rn3a'-\HI1.m1f-
JIbIXllCi\8lt€lllIii:.J1XKJIaro*1I1CIfCTeMe,a TalOK€xapaRTepl'IC'T1'I
Ha3BaHHbIX npJUilI;mJOB ICaK 3J1eMeHTOB CI'ICTeMbL
BrrepBwe B lOpIt,!I;K'Jectroii: .mrrepa-rype aBTOpbl Y.l\eJlHlO1' cyw;eCTBeHHDe
BHI1M3.lD1enpoI5JIeMe4npJUilI;mloB IIpJllBa'rn3aLlJ1ll!:1fGjJ!bIXnOMe1l(e-
HJli1.BJICCJF,ll(EaHJ1II!.I\aeTCHnOH.lITI1HJlKJI
4> IIpl1HqmIOBIIpJllBaTJ13a'-\IDImJ1JIbIXnOMeIIlemrnRaR3JleMeHTa CIf-
cre_
Bo-6'f'11O}JttlX, B ILlUme COBepllleHC1'BOBaHJ1H 3aKOHO.1l:aTeJIbCTBa B
KHI1reC)J;eJlaHpR,!\,KOTOpbleMoryrobITb-
HbICJle)JylOM 06pa3OM.
:EcJrn33.KOHO)J;a1'eJIbCO'ITe'rB03MOiKHbIMJ1HeCiJxQlJ,JIMbIM,l:\8JIblleJ1rnee
.A81C'rB11€ 3aKOH3. Ptx:cWicKni ilIe)J;epaIJ;l1l1 cO IlpJllB81'I13aIJ;l1l1 oro
I}xJH,1Ia B Poccm1rnm141eepaJIl. 1'0 eM)' CJIe.v,yeT, JIlCXo.l\H J13 ero co4M-
aJIhHO- npe,!J)la3H3.'1eIDIfl JIl CO.1l:epmaHIDl, JlaTh ThKOe 1U1JI!-
MeHOBaHJI!e. 3aROH Poccm1cIocl1 ilIe)J;epaI..\illl «0 nplfBaTIf3al..\MH rpam,llaHaMM
3aHJl!M(l{'MbIXJIlMJl!mJ1JIbIXBJ\OMaXroCY,llapC'I'BeHlU'JIlMYHI1-
l{I1rI3.JIbHOroOro<PoH,1la" BMeCTeC1'eMnpJllHW1JlblJllHopMblyKa3aH-
HOro 3aKOH3. MOryr ObITb BOI1JIOlIleHbI B roBepIlE'HC1'ByMOM B HaCTOHillee I 

BpeM$ImRpqJ1 BBeJKI1JIJ.1IWIo-npaBOBOroJllHcrI1TY-
1'a: «ITpJ.lBaTI13allKfl rpa:lK,1\aHaMl>1 3aIrnMaeMbIX JI!MJ.I :HG!JIbIX IDMalJ'mrn: B
110MaX roCYJlapcrBeHHOro JIl MYID1I!ImaJIhIICI'V JKI1JIJ.1IWIoro <PoH,1\a». B JlaH-
HOJ:! paOOre BhIClffi3bmae'I'Cfl HUe, corJIaCHOKOroPOMY BmRP40
)lOf.IIJ1llVIO-npaBOBOi1:JlHC'I'm:yT 110JDKeH6bI'n> pacnOJIOmeHBO'T'-
l1eJIbHoi1CTaTbeBpa3;J;eJle«rp3.J'K.!\3.H)fGjJIblMl1
MM. ITCIJIb3OBaID1P:lKWlbllIrn nOMemeHMHMVIA
2. 3,!\ecb CJ60CHQBhlBaeTCfl MHeHlfe, B COOTBeTCTBJ1J.I C KOTOpbIM B qeJUIX
co6.n:Kw>mm npJ.IHIJ;I1IIa rJIaCHOCTJ.I npJ.lBamaaqvrn:   JI
o6eCrIe<ieHJ.lH rapafITmf 1"1'0 peaJIJl3aLWlJl CJle.L\OBaJlO 6bl .L\OIlOJIHIITb 3aKoH
Poccm1cI«n1 I «0 npJllBa1'11311l{ID1 mIfJIJIll1\Ho1'O <PoH,1\a B PoccJI!i1-
CKOi1 qJe.L\eparunt" HOpMOi1 1'aKoro CO.L\epJ'KaHII/H: «IIpJl!Ba1'JIl3al!l1H JKI1JIblX
ncJMel1I('lIHJ:rJIaCHo.rJlaCHOCTb,BqacTHocTJIlJo6ecne'lJl!Ba-
eTCJI pea.mEa1: B03MIDKHOCTblO 03HaKOMJleIIJI!JI rp3.J'K.!\3.H C 3aKOHO,!\aTI'JIhCT-
BOM 0 npJl!BaTJ.l3aL(1IJI! :HG1JIb1X nrnetL(eHm1, IIpe.LIOC1'3BJJHJI!eM JIlM firraHKOB
BCeJ:!lIf206xoJ:\J1:MllfcperneHII/eMOpraHOBO
npJI!BaTIm::1KJI!JIbIX1:»
3. PeaJ1J13aL(J.Ifl JIlmpopMaWlOHHOJ:! cWH!W;I1J.1 npJ.IHI.J;J.IIIOB npJllBa1'Jl3aL<l1J.l
:1KJI!JIbIX nOMel.l..\eHJ.Ii11'pe6yeT .AQIIOJllieHKfl4I!'.AeparrbHOTO 3aKOHa «0 npJllBa-
1'JI!3aI.J;J.IJ.l1tG1.JlJl!l.l..oro I}xJH,1Ia B PoccHiIc:RoH qJe.L\epaI.J;J.IJ.l» CTaTbei1 cJle)IytO-
l.l..\e1'OcoJ\epmaHKfI: «.n;enapraMelIT'hI)KI.tJIb$ (l1.JntaHaJIo-
lWIHhIe JIM opraHblcy6'beKTOB PoccI1IbmqJe.L\epaI.J;J.IJ.l) OOHaaHhl nOCTOHHHO
I1H,¥:>PMJ1]XJBa1'b rp3.J'K.!\3.HPOCCI1J.lOnpxJIl )'CJK.I3JIfIXnpJllBa1'lf3aqnJ.l
:1KJI!JIbIXnOMeI.l..\f'Hl1i1:».
4. -qaCTb 2 CT. 113aKoHa PoccntK:troII qJe.L\epaI.J;J.IJ.l «0 npJllBamaaqvrn:)fGj-
JltfUtIIOrO<PoH,1\aBF'occu!icIIoA'He06xo,J:J;ItMo1\O!1OJIH11TbHOp-
Moi1CJIeJIYlOero co,I\eJ»K1llIl'1K «TIpaBolJa IIpJlloopereHJ.le Boo6crnemrocTI.,
B nopRAKe npJllBaTI13aL(J1J.l, JKI1JIoro nOMeI..l.\t'HKfI IIpOmlfBalOUI;J.IM B I\JccmI
Jl!HOC'Ipalll\8.MJIlJlJ11laM6e3rpa.m,rr.aHCTBaHenpt».
5 >ReJIa1'eJlbHO P;OIlOJIHl1'n> )'KaaaHHbD1 3aKOH HopMOi1-npJl!HII;MIIOM CJIe-
.I\Y1Oero: «DqxJpMJJefJJ1epe3YJlbTa1'OBnpJI!Ba'I'Jl3aL(J.IJllJKl1JIbIX
 110J1mHO ocyIl\eCTB.lUlTbCH B MeCJl'lHhli1 CpoK». AHarrofI1'ilI.YIO
HOpMY npe,!lJIaraeTCH 3aKpeIDITb 1'alOKe JIl B ITOJIomeHllJl! 0 npJllBa1'lf3aqnn
(6ecnJIaTIIOi1:nepe,11aqe))IDfJIJIl1IHOro <PoH,1la B r. MacKEl".
6. B [(eJIHX 3aRpt'IIJIeHIIH JIl pa:3BlITl1H IIpJ.IHIJ;I1IIa Uepe)KH()ro 0TIKIllleHI1H
cy6'beK'I'OB npJllBaTJl!3aLUUI K npJllBa1'Jl!3MpyeMbIM )KJ.IJIhIM nOMel.l..\eHI1HM
npe,!lJIaraeTCJI )'Ka3aTh B n I CT. 25 mR Poll, 'lTO nepeyc-rpoi'icToo JIl nepe-
nJlaHJl!paBKa JKII/Jloro nOMeeHIIH MOryr npaJ.l3BOWITbCH 1'OJIbKO B [(eJIHX no-
BI
'>KKP<1>l3!meTcofjosa.OHHaCTOJlbKOt<H3KOrOI<S."ecrea.'ITosana.
PHOA"ro,l\eC1B""cIMapTa2005r.not<acTO"l1JOOBJII'M"BHecefl[)"'fI[)rol<3M8t<eHHHI10
lIOIHeH'I1L.o.enyraThlrOCJ\y....paCCMOTpeJl"BIlepBOM"eH"HnaKeTIl,,"THI<3TP!'X,lIec>IT.
OB nonpaeo. B >KwIHUIH" OJJ.eI'C P<1>(CId PocCl'eo<a raaeTa_ 2006_ II..IOIKI)

Bb!llleHl1R ern 6JIaroycrpoi1cTBa 11 Y.ny'illleHl1R ycooBItH npoiKJ1B3.HI1R B >KI'!-
JIOMU1 CHU€MIIpaBJl3aKOHHbIXJIlrrepeCOB.zwyrl1Xco6-
C'l'BeHHI1KOB, apeH,/\aTOJXlB JlHaHl1Ma'Ienm
B-mpembUX, rpaifG:\aHe Poc:cwiicKcii ilIe.L\epal..\l1l1 cpaBHIfl'elINID He.L\aB-
HO noJIy'lJlJllf B03MomHOCTb IIpl1BaTIl311pOBaTb KBapTl1pbl JI 00lffiNJMHTbCH C
I1pJIH11HIIiiMIt. Ha 6a3eKoropblXmrnOnbITCB1J,D;eTeJIbCT-
Byer, '>T06oJn,wa..<IlJaCTbrpMaJlOO'TOM. 'lTOc}'ll..teCT-
BYKITnp1HQlffihIIIpll!BaTIl3al[lI!I1m1fJlblXIDfi.i,KOTOpble4JOIDt-
PyKTrJlBOl1JIOll[aKJrCRB)KJ13Hb.
Bc.ne.L\C'TBHe 3TOro BamH!M 3a;ta,>efi $lBJUIJIaCb He TOJThKO nOCTaHOSKa JI
EbIOOJIHeHIreHaY'{flOro1H, KoropoeB60JlbllIei1MepepacC'Ml'bl-
BaJlOCb Ha ItCI'I01Ib3OBaHHe ero pe3YJIbTa'TOB COOTBerC'TByKJw;HMYl cnel[WJlJl-
CTaMI1, HO JI CTpE'MJIeIDte nOKa3aTb: IIpHIll.\I1IIbI IIpll!BaTlf3al[l1Jl mlfJIblX no-
Mell[€lDJil peaJlbHO OCH JII1lllb Tor,Qa, Kor,Qa Mbl JIlMVI
IDJIb3}'eMC1I. 60peMCjI 3a JI!X peaJIJl3aJ..tl1IO JIl BOllJI()I.l.!eH B peaJIbHofi,l1€licT-
BJ1TeJIbHOCTI1. B/1i1llliOi1pa6areMb! CTpE'Ml1JMCbO'!epTIITb 110xapmcrepVl30BaTh
IIpll!tlQl1IIbl IIpll!BarI13aI..\I1I1 .H01JIb1X IIOMe!l[eHVli1 He CTOJlbKO KaK C'TaTJl'JeCKIje
HBJIeIDfJI. CKOJIbKO KaK A11Hal\oll1'!€crotH MeXmD£3M, C nOMOIO KOTOpOro
 KaK cyU'beKT IIpll!BaT1I!3aW1Vl, Mor 6bl n0'IYBCTBOBaTb ce6jI Ha-
CTO 1:1 ID.IIOOI1paBfIH X03JIMHOM BCSoeM ;QOMe (KBaprnpe).

ornABnEHI1E
BMecTO npeAMtnOBMH ......................................3
BBeAeHHe................................................ .7
rnaB2 L 06He npo6neMbi )f(HnHHOro npaBa,
ero npMHLjHnOB It npMBaTH3aLjMH
)KHl1blX nOMeuaeHMM
 1. IOpHAH4ecK npl'lpoAa >KH/lI1IJ.1.HOrO npaBa
l1erOnpHHLlHnoB ................ ....... ... ... .... ...9
2. IOpHAH"IeC npHpOAa Ii CYllIHOCTb npHBan13aL!I.111
>KHl1blX nOMeHHH Ii eenpl1HLII.mOB .....................27
rnaBa II. nOHJlTMe, Kl1aCcHlJlltKaLlHR II CMcreMa npHHLlltnOB
npMBaTH3aLlHH >KMl1blX nOMelQeHHH
 1. nOHHTHe npHHLlHnOB npHBaTH3aLll1M )f(Hl1blX nOMelJ.l.eHMH ......39
2. KpHTH'IeCKHH 0630P lot or6op BbUIBJ1eHHbIX
Ii lIeHCTB)'IOW)o1X npMHLlMnOB }f{HI1MI.l\Horo npaBa ............49
3. KnaccH4;lI1KaIlMJ'I lot CI-tCTeMa npMHLlHnOB
npl'lBan1Ja41'1H >KI'IJlbIX nOMeeHHH ..................... .55
rl1aBa III. npHHHnbl npI1BaTH3aMM )l(HI1b1X nOMelqeHMM
KaK 311eMeHTbi CMCTeMbi
1. npO.RBJleHHe. 3aKpenneHHe. CYHOCTb
H cneLlI'l4>I'I"IeCKa.R pO.Rb npl'lHLll'lnOS >KHJ1HIqHOrO npasa
B HHCTI'ITYTe npl'lBaTHJaLlI'IH >K1'IJ1bIX nOMelJ..leHHIA .. _.. ..... .65
2. I-1HCTI'IT}'LlI'IOHHble npl'lHLlHnbl npl'IBaTI'IJaLlI'IH
)f{l'IllblX nOMeeHI1H ..... _ __ .... .................... .73
rl1aBa IV. np06J1eMa 4JYHKMM npMHLlMnOB
npMBaTM3aMM )l(HJ1bIX nOMeaqeHMM
1. nOHSITHe H KJlacCI'I4>I'IKa41'1S1 4JyHK4I'1H
npl'lHLll'IllOB npl'lBaTI'I3a41'111 )f{1'IJ1bIX nOMew.eHHi:1 ............ .85
2. C1>yHKLlI'II'I npl'lHLlHnOB npHBarl'l3a41'1H )f{I'IJlbIX nOMeeHHH
KaK3J1eMeHTbICHCTeMbl ............................. .89
BbIBO,qbl .................................................99