V1HCn1TYT 3AKOHO,QATEnbCTBA
1-1 CPABHI-1TEIlbHOro nPABOBEJ:\EHI-1S1
llPV1nPABI1TEllbCTBEI'OCCM'ICJ(()I'



A.O. CI-1BAKOB


ITPABOBOEPEfYRMPOBAHME
BO,l];OnOJIb30BAHHH


HaY
Ho-npaKTH
eCKoe
noco6He




INSTITUTE OF lEGISLATION AND COMPARATIVE LAW
UNDER THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION GOVERNMENT
D.O. Sivakov
lEGAL FPAMEVVOR< OF USE
OF WA 1m FffiJUR::ES
SCIENTIFIC AND PRACTICAL GUIDE
MOSCOW
Jo"""""",
2010

YJJ.K349-6
66K 67 4lJ7
C34
ABTop:
CI1BaKOB lj..O_ - cr-apW HaY'1Hbl Corpyp,HK 0I",l:1E!/1a a.rpap-o-O, SK0I10rH-
..ec<orOl1nbCTBaIllHCTHryTa3a<OHap,ar-el1bCT-
Bal1cpaBHL>ITenbHoronpl'lllpaBL>ITeJ1bCTBePOCcl'IcKOi1l11e.o.epa-
LlHI'I,KaH.QlolAarl-IaYK
Pel$H3eHTbl:
E.A.BbICTOpo6eKaH,Ql1AaTl-IaYK
A.M.l.LMpIolH,KaH,Ql1AaTlOpl1,Qlol'lecKHXH<lyt(
CI1BaKoBlj..O.
C34 IlpaBOBOeperylll'lpOBaHl'leI'IRHaY'1HO-IlpaK1Vl..ecKOenoco-
6He IIJ..O CHBaKOB; IIIHcn1ryT 3a<oHQJJ,aI"eJ1bCTBa 101 cpaI3KIITertifO IlpaBOBe-
AE!HI'I -M !/\lHOpHcnpy,aeHLIL'IS;-,2010 -128c.
ISBN 978-5-9516-0508-5
BHaY'1HO-npaK1l1ecKoMnoco6HOnL>lC!lHblTef1ABH4HHl'lrEp(]lBKWIIbInpaBOBO-
foperynpOBaHRI1CI1Of"I>3CJI!BOJlHblXooraTCTBPocC!>l!>l.PaCCMa1pHBEIIOTCRno-
110JKeH!>IRBOJlHOrol1"'Horo
TaIOKE!YCTaHOBKBOJlHoi1CTpaTerPocCHKoi14JtaaepaUl'lHaOe-
pHO,!l.Ao2020rop,a.noKl1lC1'ieabIMBOnpOCaMBO,IJ,HblxaBTOpJlpBO-
.AIH3aj)y6e)I(Hbli1onbITnpaooBoi1MaTePHanlJ,8e-rcRHa4X>Hefeorpa-
1J>4BCKtMl1I1H4x>PMa4HH
AnWI1pOKoroKpyra"lIITaTel1ei1:pafioTHKOBBOJlHorofOCY,1lilpCTBBH-
HblX 11 MYH4HJlanbHblX CJ1y:1(aIlJ,HX, npeno, aCf1paHTOB 11 COHCKarene>i,
--
The manual «l.egaltramey,Qf"kol useotwater resources" reI1ectsmainstreamsand
prospectsollegalofwaterrBSOlJrcesolRussja Theaulhorpaysattentionto
lhecurrentwaterlegisiationand()l:herbranchesolnalureThebooktakes
into account main puints of Water strategy 01 the Russian FedBr<mon till 2020. The
aulhorllustndeskeypuiJllsolwaterrelationsbyforeignexperienceprO'lidingthemale-
rialswrthecologlcal,QeographicaiandtDcJlcJgcallnlormahoo
ThebooklsaddressedtoaWlOOClrcleofreaders:employeesolwaterloduslry,
stateandmunicipalpersonnel,lawpdessors,andstt.den&s,represen-
latlvesolconservancyorganizations.
YAK 349.6
66K67.407
ISBN 978-5-9516-0508-5
@IoIHCTI11)'THCPBBH!>ITel1bHOro
I1p!>lnpaB!>ITel1bCTBe
ct>e.l1€paLJ,H!>I.2010
@04>0ptM8HHe.I1A.2010

BBE.QEHHE
Ha,lJ;OJllO POCCID'! I1pJ1XOJJ;JITCH 2(1,'{- IDrpOBbIX 3aIlaCOB npecIl)Jf BO.D;bL
IIpt:! 3TOM B Harnei1 crpaHe HaC'UfThlBaeTCR OKOJIO 2,5 MJIH peR, 2,7 MJIH
o3ep, 2290 B()JJ;OJq)8HILmn.qofu,eMoM CBblllle IMJIH Nfoe, 30 TbIC. MB,-
JIbIX pamunfil\ " npY,1J;OB. 06ll.jaR I1JIOl1\a,l\b Mq)CKOi'i aKBaWpID'!,
i1noJ\IOpltCWfItW1IOPOccMi1cl\Oi141e.r\epa, COCTaBJIReT 7
MJIH KB. KM OrnpbITblE:' 11 IIJXI1I03HPyeMble aanaCbl npecHbIX nOA3eMHblX
BO,!\ ,lIlJCTl1raiOT 350 ftM31.
B TO >ICe BpeMR BOJ\oeMKOCTb BaJlOBOro mtyrpeHHero IIfX>fIYKTa POCCID1:-
cKOi14>eAepaQWlil COCTaBJLlleT OKQJIO 2,4 xy6. M/Tb!C. pyfirreH. 3Ha'Il1TeJIhHO
npeBbIlll8Jl  llOKa3s:reJllf CTpaH C pa3BKrOM::n«H::!MHIroJL rOo
pa3.ll;o BhIDIe «3a» nOKa3aTeJIei-1: C5poCHeoHHbIXCTO'IHbIXBOA,
urpawmKJIIJ;I1X BO.I\C1J'OKI.1 J'! Bo,!\oeMbI PoccJVL IIooTOMY He CJI)"lai1Ho Kam-
ro>rn. BTOpoi1: )f(11Te.Jlb POCCI1J1 BbJHY'K.!1eH IfcrD.JIb3()BaTb }J.JIII rum,eBhlX lIe-
JIei1 BOJIY. He COOTBeTCTBYJOWYlO no pH.IJ;y nOKa3a'feJIei1 YCTaHOBJIeHHblM
HOpMa'TIrnaM, no'ITl-1 Tpe'I'b HaC€JIeIDffi C1p8.Hb! n0.IIb3YeTCR J1CTO'llillKaMJI!
BO,1\OCHafuKeHt-lJl6e3 1 EIOJ1.Of1O.lIT'f. HaceJleffile PB.M
pemORGB C'I'p8..QaeT ar He,!J;OCTaTKa ID1'I'beBOM BO)J;b111 arcyrCTBI-tH CBR3aH-
Hb[XC3TUMHaJ\JIC8.ffi1TaYCJiOBl1i1npoitO-1BaH11R.
05ecne<n1Tb oxpaH)' J1 paQMOHaJIbHoe J1CIIJJIb3OBaID160raTefurn1x BO)1-
HbIX pecypcOBnpl13BaHOBDAHoel1CMemHble c HJ1M:crrpaCJIill
CTBa POCCI1J1. IIpe)K,1l;e Bcero, MMeeTCR B BI-f.DY Bo.n;HbIH IID)J;eKC Pocrni.icKoH
4>eAepaQWlil ar 3 JOOHR 2006r. N2 74-cI>3 (,!\8.Jlee - BE\ p<pr. CorJJaCHo CT. 4
BE\ P<PBO;:J;Hoe 3aKOHO,J:$:reJIbCTBO pery.mtpyeT BD;:J;Hble OTHOWeHJ1.ff, T.e. OT-
HOWeHlli'l B 06.naCTI:! J13yqeHlli'l" )"leTa, IK7IlYIb3OBaHKR" OXpaHbl, npe06-
pa3OB3ID1.fI " BOCCTaHOBJIeHlli'l BO;:J;Hb1X Om.eK"IOB. :Bo.rI;HbIe GmOUJeHJ1H pe-
ry.ID1pYKJI'CH TalOKe I1Hh!M}f ):\epa.rrbHhlMJ1 3aKOHaMlil, B TOM 'lMcne: OT
311-OOJU11998 r. N2 15543 «0 BHYfP€HID1X MOpcKMX BO,!:(aX, repPI1TOfuf-
aJJ:hHOMMOpe"130He FbccJrl'tcn:)}j,!(epal.Pflfloa, OT211-OOJU1
1997 r. N211743 (i06e30naCHOCTI-lI1VJPOT€XHH'lecKlfXcoopymeHJ-Ii;i»4, OT
1 MRH 1999 r. N2 9443 «06 oxpaHe roepa :Ea.1-lliarr»5
I CBO,[I,O-""bI.L<1I1:>!1i1HI>IeMnPPOCCH8cepoccI<KOHrpecCpa60T-
HKoBBoJIHoroX03SMcTBa.M,2()03.C.13-14
2 C3P<11.2006.N!!23.Cr 2381
3 C3P<11.1998 1In31.Cr.3833
4 C3P$ 1997 1In30. Cr. 3589
5 C3P<11.1999.1In18.Cr.2220
-,-

B BO,!\HOM TeJIbCTBe Pocnrl1a\oH 4Je,IJ;epaUHJ13a1q)€IIJlHeTCH
  co6c'meHHocTb Ha BO,!\Hble cfu,eK'l'bL
IIpJ4 STOM CTaHOBJ4'I'CJ'! 60JIee pbIHO'iHb1M MexaHJ43M npeJ\0CTaBJIeHKfI
npaaa BOJ\OnOJIb3()l38lnUI, ItOTOpbrn OCHOBblB8.eTCH Ha ayltoHaX J1 ,IJ;oro-
BOpax. )IOnyCKaH ':IacrnylO c06cTBeHHocTh Ha OrpaHl1'>eHHbrn Itpyr BO,!\-
HbIX 06'beKTOB, 3aI\OHO,l\8TeJlb .HBHO npe)J,IIO':leJi npJ4BJleKaTb 'iaCTHWe J1H-
BeCTHL(lm Ha OCHOBe npeJ1M)'L1J;eCTBeHHO ,!\OI'OBq)HOro nOJlb30BaID'iH
rocyp;apcTBeHHbIMlt:! no <PJpMe co6cTBeHHccrn BO,!\HbIMJ1 OfueltTaMJ4.
B xo,!\e 06HoBJlemm IIJ:&tpO.lIOpecypctiOI'O 3aKOHO,llaTeJlbCTaa 6oJIbwoe
Bm1M8Hlte npaBOBOH HayK.J4 6b1J1o y.l\eJ1eHO np06J1eMe yrnepeHIDI J1
pa3BJ41WI .l\OroBOpHbIX ornowewrn B 06JIaCThI HCI1OJIb3OBaID1H H OxpaHbI
pa3J1J1'llib1X npl1pO,!J;HblX 06'beKTOB, B TOM 'illCJle BO,!J;HbIX 06'beKTDB. B 3TOM
CMbICJIe paCCMaT(X-1BaJDfCb C H3M('H('ID1H nopH,ll;Ka BO,!\O-
nOJlb30BaHl1H (yrrpa3,!J;HeHJ1e JD1l{€H3ItpOBaHKH, 3aItJIIO<leHJ1e WIOBqXJB
BQl\OI1OJJ:b3CEIaHJr Ha OCHOBaID1J1 ayKLJ;l10HOB). Ha.z\o npJ.13HaTh, 'iTO K 2009 r.
nOpR,!\OK 13O,IJ.CIIOJ.Ib B l\eJlOM CJlO)lG1JlCJ'! H }"Ke 0CMbIC.1II-1:Ba
npaBOBOiii HaJKOiii 1 . B To:me BpeMH OCTaJlCJ'! HepenreHHbIM BOIIpOC 0 npa-
BOSOM ooecn€'1eHID1 ycnellnmro pa3BJ1TI1H BO,!J;HOro xooIDtcTBa, B xO)J;e KO-
TOpOro Kam,n;brn poccmilurn }J;OJIm€H nOJl)"UITb Ka':leCTBeHH)'lO BO,rry,
.l\0JDKHa llOIDf3JrThCJI  BaJlOooroBHYTPeHHer0 npo,!J;,)'KTa.
JI;m TOro 'IT06bl ,IJ.06nn.cH npopbIBa B o6.nacTI'! BO,!\OIIOJIb3OBaIDUI,
IIpa:mrreJlbCl'BOM P<P 6b1J1o npHHHTO pacnopIDKeHl1e OT 27 aBrycTa
2009 r. N21235-p «06 yrsepeHl1M Bo,!\HoiiicTpaTernH PoccJrnrnoH4Je-
,Aepa1JJfi1 Ha nepHO):\ .l\0 2020 r. H llJIaHa Meponpt1H'l'MH no ee peaJllil3a-
»2. Bo,!J;HaH C'rpaTernR onpe1\eJJHeTOCHOBHb!e HanpaBJleHI-fR.l\eHTeJIb-
HOCTH no pa3BI1TI1lO BO,!\OX03HiiicTBeHHOrO KOMIIJleKCa POCCHI1,
 ycroWrnBoe BCUPlruIb3OBalUle, OXpaHY BO,!J;HbIX 061,-
eKTOB, 3all\l1TY ar HeraTJ4BHoro CTBJUI BOA, a TalOKe no pr.rnpo-
BaHloOOH peaJllil3al\ffi1  npeJ1MYIl\eCTBPOcCJ1J1cKoH 4JeAE'-
pa.11 B «BOJlOpecypCHoiii c4>epe».
B npe):\CTaBJleHHOM HaJ'IH0- nocool1l1 paCKpbITbl npa-
BOBble MeXaHII3MbI 1 BO}J;{IIO.1Ib3OBaUl, KaK,l\€JICTB}'HIlP1e
BHaCToee apeMH, TaK11 TOJIbKO iPopfeCH.
1 MM tft6os""o.n.Hf1P. npaKTl<"ecKiiKBQJ:\HOMyop,eKCyPocc"ii-
c.oii/IlO)l,pe.q.OIlIJ.ytioB.M aKCMO,2007,KBQJ:\HOMyKop,eK-
r:jPocc"Rcw4>a.r:1epaUl1H(J/OTB.Pe.r:1.CA 6oromoooB.M Ben6H.I>1J.[1.-S0
rlpocneICT,2007
:2 C3PQ).N.36 20Q9. Cr. 4362

rnaBa 1
06111A XAPAKTEPHCTHKA
nPABOBOrO PE>KHMA
BOIIHOro cl>OHllA
1. BCi\HOE X03CTBO; nOnHTHKA H nPABO
06ll(a.H xapaKTep11M'HK3. 80)1.1101'0 X03.HiicrBa POCCHU. B lIeJlOM no
POCCID'! 06ecne'ieHHOCTh BObOO1 p€cypcaMJl! ,lJ;OCTJIII'a€T 30,2 TbIC.'; Ha
'ieJlOBeKa B I'O)1. OaKo Ha Halt6o.rree rycTOHaceneHHhle p€rJ.10HbI eBpo-
neU:CKOU POCCIDi, r,lJ;e npmKJiBaeT 7(f} H8CeJ1eHIffi H cocpewItNeII OCHOB-
HOH npotf3BO,l1CTBeHHb1iii: nOTeHW13-Jl crpaHbl, npKXO)J)fTCfI He 60Jlee IfJO
BO,!{Hb1X pecypcOB. Oco6eHHO HanpIDKeHHbrn  6arraHc
CJlIDIDtJICfl B KypcIri'1, Ee.rrropQIJ.aroJl, Ta.M6ot3t::J«: Kypra1JU«)i1 H 'G:eJlfl-
6wHCKOi1:o6J:raCTm-:,Kpae, Pecny6.mnce:K.a.rrM:bnam.B:.m-IX
cyfu,eIrnlX ,IJ;epal\ID1 BOn:x:fJecne<HIJle He npeBbllillleT 4 TbIC. ,; B I'O,!J; Ha
'ieJIOBeKa, "TO MeHbllle cpe.l1HepOCcHf1cKOro ypOBHR. IIpaB)W., npt:lBe-
.l1eHHble nOKa3aTeJlt:l 3Ha'llITeJIbllO Bblille Kpwi'WlecKoro MJlIHI1MYMa B
1,7 TbIC.'; Ha 'It'JIOBeKa, npt:IHRTOro OOR-.
B CT. 1 BK P<P 2006 r. pacKpblBaeTCH TaKoe nOIDITHe, KaK 6ofl1we
X03JtUcmoo. OHO onpe.n;eJUleTCH 3aKOHo.n;aTeJleM KaK .l1emt'JIhHOCTb B
c4>epe H3Y"eIDIH, HCnOJlb30BaID1H, oxpaHbl BO,!J;HblX ofu.eK-roB, a Ta10Ke
npe.n;O'rBpaeHt:I.R H .m HeraTilllHoro B03.n;ei1cTBt:I.fI BO.n;. 11:3-
BeCTeH TepMt:lH 8000X03S1:UC1TI.8f'HJWJl cucme.Ma, KOTOpbIi1: nOH>1MaeTCH
Kaft 1t0MIIJIeftC BO,!J;HblX 06'beltTOB H I14,Lij)OTeXHt:I'ieCKHX coopyiKeID1ii.
npe,nHa3Ha'leHHblX ,nJIH 06ecne..emfH paW'lOHanbHoro HCnOJlb30BaHt:lH
J'! oxpaHbl BO,!J;HbIX pE:'Cypa:m. IIpt:lMeHHeTcH TaIOKe IIOHHTIfe 800OXO-
MUC'17I6e1tUbU ywCTnO'lC Kaft 'i8CTb pe'iHOro 6acceihm, B npe,!\enax ftO-
TopOro Y1\06HO YCTaHaB.ID1BaTb JillMJilTbl3a6opa (lf3DHTIfH) BO,D;HbIX pe-
CypCOB 113 BO,D;Horo 06'beftTa t:I wyrne yCJiOIDUI nOJlb30BaffiIH BO,!J;HblM
omeKToM.
IIoCKOJIbKY BO,!J;bl HBJImOT('JJ He3aMeHI1MbIM pecypCOM, BO)J;Hoe X03HH-
CTBO npl13BaHO o6c.rryjfGffiaTb Bce mpaCJll1 npoMblllI.lI€HRJ TpaHC-
1 Bo.I1HaACTpa TerHS1Pocc1<1cm4>a.r:1epaUl1Hane'pO,IJ,lJ.02020r (VTB.f1JJBB-
Te.nbCTBaP<POT27aBI)'CTa2oo9r N.1235-p)
-5-

nopr, 3Hepre'I11KY, CeJIbCKOe, neCHOe 11 pbroHoe XOOJJ:iiicToo, a ':Iepe3 KOM-
M)'lIaJIbHoe X03ID1CTBO - CBH3aHHbIX C ID1M ,IJ;eCJITKl1 MIDDBRlliOB :HOITe-
nei-1. B HaCTOHI.qee BpeMH OCHOBHbIMl-1 OTpaCJIHMI-1 - BO,IJ;OII(JJIb3TeJIHMJII
11 BO HBJIHIOTCH 3HepreTl1Ka, ATIK, mKX, ,IJ;06bIBaIO-
ll\8H J'! o6pa6aTbIBaIOLq,aH npoMl:lIlIJI€lll
B 06JIaCTH p0ccr01cla:ro BO):\HOro X03.Hi-1CTBa HaH6o.nee OC'I'pbIMJ'! npe):\-
CTaBJIRIOTCHfenpcti.JIeMbI:
- Hep8BHOM€pHOCTb pacnpe.I1eJJeHM.R npeCHbIX BO)J.HbIX peCypCQB 11,
CJie1J;OBaTeJIbHO, HepaBHOMepHOCTb (HeXBaTKa 11JIt:I1136brroK) BOAbI B PJI-
1J.epemOt«)B;
- BbICOKJ1e BO.I\orrOTepYl H3 oo l1.n;pyrnx OfueKTOB BO,!J;HOro
-
- pOCT 3aIpmHeHHH, 3acopeHltH, uC'TCJIIt€HHH BO):\HOro $JH,!\8;
- HapaCTaHJ1e Bpe}J;HOro EI():3}J;eIICTBHH BOA rJIaBHbIM 06p83oM B pe-
ayJIbTaTe HaBOAHeHtrn.
Cpe.$:l 11HJIYCTPlf8JlbK) pa3BYlTb!X roCY.MpCTB POCCHII l1MeeT caMbIii
BO.I\OeMKll1 BBII Pacxo.I\ BO)J;bI COCTaBJIHeT OKOJIO 2,4 rl/1 TbIC. py6.
BBII BbICOK8JI BO,iU)€MJOC1CTb I1pOJJ;yK1.PUI npoCJIemHBaeTCfl IUlK B ceJIb.
CKOM xcrunicTBe, TIm: J1 B I1pOMbIliIJIeHHOCTI-f. I1pH 3TOM o6eCrre':leHHOCTb
BO)J;HblMl-1 pecypcar.rn AIIK Poccm'! B l\eJIOM, no HeK01UpldM .I\8HHbIM, co-
CTaBJIReT Jll1IlIb 51% HopMaTI1BHoi-1 nmpe6Hocrn l .
POCCHII OT.JIWIaH BbICOKJ1MliI nOTepHIIrn BOJ\bI IIpH ee TpaHCDOpTYI-
poBKe, nplromI3t1'reJIbHO 8 xr.i' B roJ\, 'l'I'O cc:JC'TaBJJH€T 10% om.eMaI13.bH-
THII, B TOM 'lliCJIe BO}JPJ1OT€pH B c4>epe mKX COCT8BJIH1OT 3 xr.i'. BeJiMID-I
BO):\onOTepH 11 B CeJIbCKOM X03HIIC'JEe. IIplf'lJfHbI KpoH'I'CH B 6oJIbIllOH 113-
lIOWeHHOCTIf ofueKTOB J'! coopy*eIDrl1 BO,IJ;OOTBe)J;eHJ1H,
CYlCTeM MeJillOpaJ.rn:, a TaIOKe B He,I:(OCTaTO'IHoi-1 KBaJllf<pYlKal\ID'l nepco-
HaJIa, B HJ13KOft KYJIbrype KOHe<JHbIX IIOTpe6HTeJIeiii.
B TO)J{€ BpeMH BO)J;HOe X03HI1cTBo l1MeeT onpeAt'neIrHWi pe3epB P83-
BYITHil. MHo:IKecTBo BOJ\oeMOBI1 BO):\OTOKOB B pai-10HaX C p H8CeJIe-
ID1eM 11 Hlf3Kt1M ypoBHeM OCBoeHHII 11.0 CI1X nop JII1IlIb 'lacrn'IHO BOc'I'pe60-
BaHbI B BO)J;HOM X03.fIiii:CTBe. MHorHe B011.OeMbI 11 BO;:J;OTOKM, xOTopbIe
aKTHBHO I1CI1OJlb3OBaJBICb paHee, H8 KOTOpbIX C'llX)I1JIUCb I'H,l1pJ'I'€XHtNe-
CKi1e COOpptreHJ1H (ITC), B HaCTOJILIJ;ee BpeMH no pa3HbIM npl1'n1HaM oc-
T8BJIeHbI 6e3 BHMMaHJ1H. Ot\OJIO 3 TbIC. pa3Be,!laHHbIX M€CTOemDI
nO,!J;3€MHbIX BO.I\ nOK8 He 3KCruIyanfpyKJTCfl.
I1pHMepoM .IIJIH POCCJ.1l-f B OfuJaCTI1 BO.I\On0JIb30Bamrn MOryI' 6bITb
CIllA, I',I:(e narpe6JJeIDIe BO)U>I He CTOJIb pac'fO'n1'reJIbJl). IIoTpe6.rremf12
lBoJ\HaCTpaTerHKOMnJlet<C8.PocCHl<anepoAA02Q2{)fop,a.MItI-\!\.
BHIt1HA,2009.C.11
-,-

paCTyW;WM HaCeJIemreM 3TOi1 C1paHbI BOAbI He )'B€JDl'ilmaeTCfl, a c01q)a-
llja.eTCJL 3a nepHO,!!; C 1980 no 1995 ro.n; nmpefinem1e BO)J;b! c01q)aTI1J!OCb
Ha W.... XOTJ'I Hacenemre B03pOCJIO Ha 16";n. 3To 03Ha<meT, 'lI"O nOTpe5JIe-
HYle BO;:J;bl B pacqeTe Ha .uywy HaCeJleHJ1fl c01q)aTl-UloCb Ha 20Vb. 3a npillJe-
.n;eHHbIi1 OTpe30K BpeMeHH npoMblIlIJlfllHO H ceJlbCKoe x03HiiiCTBO cra-
JIJ16o.rree 3KOHOMHO TpaTI1Tb BOA)'. B CIllA nepeCTaJIJ1 CTJXlWI'b 11 e
Ha'laJill .n;eM:Hl1'1p(JBaTb paHee nOCTpOeHHb!e lIJIOTillIbL IIpH 3TOM cpe,Q-
Hee KO.JIJof'1eCTBO 3aTpa"leHlIOi1 BOAbI B paC'IeTe Ha 1 3KP nOnI>1BHbIX 3e-
MeJlb c01q)aTl-1JIOCb Ha le'o, a B II}XIMbIlUJI€HHOCTI1 B LleJIOM nOTpe5JIeID:!e
yna.no Ha 35% lJ,O ypoBHJ'l1950 r. AMepm\aHCKJre CMJ1 c rop,!!;OCTblO 003-
BecTl-f.ID10paC'JUllJfI'e.JIbCTID:!J'I.Ho
3TIllJ,OCTI1iK€HHfl 00 MHOroM 6bIJllf L Oml BbI3ldBa.JIJ'1C
no.n;3eMHbIXBo.n;JI!.n;oporoBJmRMl1XlJ,06bl'il-f1.
BOAHaH 1IUJlUTI1Ka. I{eJlb1O eoOOwii nonnmu'ICU POCCHI1 ,lJ;OJDKeH CTaTb
nooTanHbrl-i: nepexo.n; Ha COBpeMeHHble pecypcoc6eperalOllC'Ie TeXHOJIo-
nrn, BHeJ]JJeHYIe B npcM3BO.llCTBO cxeM 3aMKHyroro LI"'KJIa. B aTOM BbIpa-
mae-rcJ'l nepexo,lJ; OT 3KCT€HC11B1iOIO It J1HT€HCi-1BHOM)' HaTIpaBJi€HHIO pa3-
BWI'Iffi BO.nc:»ro3JIiiCTBeHHOl'O KOMI1!IeKca. Ho 'lI"O TaKOe BO)J;lla.J'l nOJll1TI1Ka?
3ToM)' noHR'l'HIO .n;31OT pa3HbIe onpe,D;e.IIeIDuf.
Bo8nylO YWAumu1C1/ MomHO onpe.n;eJIWI'b Kalt CJ1CTeMY 3aROHo,!\a-
TeJIbHblX, OpraHIi!3aqHOHHo-npaBOBblx, KOH'l}JOJIbHO-Ha,l\30pHbIX Mep,
oCYl1\ecTBJUleMbIX B oonaCTIi! BO,!\HblX OTHoilleHHi1 rocy.n;apCTBeHHblMH
H M)'HJILll'maJIbHHMU OpraHaMH, 4JH3H'1€CKHMH J11O .IDI-
qaMM.
B KPYnHblX rocy.n;apcrBax BOWffifl nQJlJ1THKa I1MeeT pa3Hble Macrnra-
6bl (ool1\erocy.n;apcmeHlfbli't. M peI11OHa.IIbHbIt. Mecr-
Hbri1:).
B 4Je,Qepa.qmrx 3TH Macrnra6b1 Mor)'T 6bITb npe,QCTaBneHbI CJ1efIYKt-
Iq!1MJII ypOBHHMH:
- BCJ'l 4Je,!\epal.ll'lfl;
-HeCltOJIbltO pemOHOB (4)e;:lepaJIbIIbIiiOKpyr, rpyrmacyfueKTOB P<P);
- Kpai-i, oonaCTb 11 ,lIpyme cyD'b€KTbI rn: (aa py6e)ft()M -
wraT, npoBHHIJ;Hfl, RaHTOH),
-eoopa30BaHJ1fl;
-npe.IlnpJlH'I'J1.fI;
-,lJ;OM8.1llID:!e:xo::uillcrBa
lapaf0IX'l10e.>KypHaJ1onpol5eM<IXrOJX>IIiIPycC<oel1:J,!1i1HHe.«tIrbanAge..2009
C.17
2CldnaKaroB8B.AOCHOB"BOJJ,HbI)(Bf'ocx:Wic:1<oM<I>e-
J1€paWo1".A8Tope<j).11"CCUOHno1200.02..2009C.B

Bo,nHa.fl IlOJIJrnma. HaL\eJIeHa He TOJlbKO Ha :3KOHOMJOO BO)J;bI, HO 11 Ha
06eCrreQeIDfe 'iJIICTOTbl BOA npo,!\)'MaHHoe I'1CIIlJIb3Ol3aIDfe pe3epBOB BO,!\-
HOro X03HiiC'l'Ba. HYmHOIIpI13HaTb, 'l'I'O BPoccm1cIroi1: 4te,!\epaI100ll\e-
roCYMpc'lU'HKI.H BO,nHaH no.ID1TI1Ka nOKa He fJIa m,ICOIom ypo-
BeHb :3EOJIOI'WIE:'CI«Jii 6e30naCHOCTIf. B 'laCTHOCTJiI, mra He n()38()JU>€T
B03MecrnTbnpollIJlbrn: :3KO"OOI'JI<lecKtm: ep611 K'-Tb HaKOn-
.neHHble aarp.H3H€HJUL IIonbITKI1 COCJIaThC.fI Ira yc.nom1fl pblHKa, KOTOpbrli
caM Bce «T", B ,lIaHHOM CJIyqae rreJIbHbI. Be)J;b IIpJilpo,!\a
,lIaHa 'It'JIOBe'l€CTBy OTHfO,lIb He pbIHKOM.
B pa3HhIe I1CTDp1'l€CKJte nepI10,!\b! 11 CTClJJ,ltU1 pa3BIITHH BOJ!,HOro xo-
3JIi-1crna BO,!\Ha.fl nOJil1TJllKa 11 BO,nHOe 3aKOHo.u,aTeJlbCTBO 6Wll1 pa3JIl1'llibL
BHe COMHeHl1H, KJIlOQeBbie aCrreKTbIBO,nHoi-1 nOJIJilTl1Kl1 ,!\OJDKHh! 6brrb (JT-
pameHbl B 3aKOHO,!:\aTeJIbCTBe, IIpem,!\e BCero - B ero IIpJIHL\I-1Illf8JIb
-
PeTpocneKTHBHbIIf B3rJUf,lJ. Ha OTe'leCTBeHHOe I1sapy6e/lmoe BOJ],Hoe
33.KOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBo. B XIX B. BOJlHhle 0TH0IIIeHJ1R pery.1ll1pOBaJlJilCb B OC-
HOBHUM B paMJ\aX IO 3aKOHo.u,aTeJlbCTBa, npe,!\YCMaTpI1BEIIO-
lL\ero lID1poKl1e npaBa npffi'ipemHbIX 3eMJIeBJIa,!\eJlbL\eB Ha BO)J;bl. O,!\HaKO
113-3a oco6eHHocTeH pery.ID1pyeMbIX 0TH0ILIeIDm: J'! HeOOxo.I:\IlMXTIl IIpI1-
MeIDITb <U\MJilHI1CTpaTI1BHble MeTO)J;b1 B pH,!\e €Bponei-1CK11X rocYi¥lpCTB
}'me B XIX B. 6bL1ill IIpl1HRTbi OT,IJ;eJlbHble 3aKOHbL TaK, HaIIpl1Mep, C ce-
pe,!\11Hbl XIX B. B Be.mrn06pwraHJlll1, 4>paHl\l1l1I1 MCIlaHl1I1 TaIOKe CTaJIJII
IIpI1IDlMaTbCH CneIrnaJlbHb!e 3aKOHbl B oOJIaCTI1 J1CIIO.1Ib3CBaH1R 11 oxpa-
HbIBOJlI.
B XX B. 'reXRIf'lecKtm: nparpecc,  pa3BlITl1e BO):\HOro xo-
3JIAcrna IIpl1BeJIJII K C03):\aHl1fO caMOC'1'OR'I'eJi OTpaCJIl1 BO):\HOro 3aKO-
HOJJ,aTeJIbCTBa. MHorne roCYJJ,apCTBa (CIllA, q>paHW.'UI, MTaJll1Jl, CK<iH,1J,I1-
HB.BOCII€ c-rpaHbl) nOOIL\PHJIlI npI1BJI€'l:€HI1e 'l8CTHblX KaID'lTaJIOB Ha
OCHOBe KOHQ€CCJDI K Macurra6HbIM I1f,!\p03Hepr€Tl1'iecKl1M 11 MeJIJIIOpa-
TI1BHbIM pa6crraM.
Eo BTOpoi-i:nOJlOBl1H€ XX B. -Ha'laJIe XXI B. B rocy,!:\apcTBax EBpOIIbII1
CeB€pHrn1 AMepl1Kl1 IIpI1H11McUUro:I 11 ,[Iei-1CTB)'KY1' KOMIIJIeKCHbI€ 11 cneL\l1-
aJIbHble 3aKOHbI no OT,[IeJlbHbIM BI1.naM BOJ1;Hb1X pecypcOB 11 o&beKTOB, oc-
HOBHbIM BUJ\aM BO,[IOlnJIb3(EaIR (BO):\, TpaHcnopT), no 6opb-
6e C pa3JlI1'IHbJMll! BH,II,aMJ1 3arpfl3HeHl1if BOJ1;Hb1X ofrbeKTOB, no oxpaHe
6epeIOBbIX 30H. JIIrreocit:Bm 11 yClIelilllo pa3B11B8.K1I'Cf! 6accefuJoBbIe Mexa-
ID13MbI ynpaBJIeIDrn BOJ1;Hb1M  OrnOCI1TeJlbHO BOJ1;Hb1X nrraT€-
mei-i:,[Iei-1CTByeT oOll\eeBponeiicKJli-i IIpI1Hll;J1II «Eo,!:\a nrraTIIT sa BO.uy».
I 3P.ecbl1.u.anee:6orQII1O(ioBc.A..CuaaKQ8.li.O.6op,Hoe3aKQHop,arebCTBOBBQnpocaxI10TBe-
Tax.HBHo.noco!5l1e M.113I1cn:..t(()t-fTf'MT..2008 C 265-266
-,-

Ba:IKHaJl3a.M':Ia npaBOBoro peryJIJ-rpCJBaHI1JI- C01q)aIlIelille I11,Iq)OTex-
lIH'ieCKOrO CTpOJITeJIbC'J'Ba 11 orpaIDl':Iemre X03JIik'rneHHoro I1CllOJlb30Ba-
Irn.RpeKI103epBlIeJ1HXnpe,!\OTBpa111;eHl1Jl aTalOKE'noMep-
>KaHI1JI I1JII1 B03BpaI1leHI1fl eCTeCTBeHHoro COC'I'Q.fIHJfjl Bo,!\oeMOB 11
BO,!\OTOKOB.
B rocy.MPCTBax EapoCOI03a 11 CeBepHoi1 AMepI1M, I\8.K 11 B POCCI1J1,
nyfun1trnbIe q:.opMbI ro6cTBemrocTJf Ha BO)J;Hble om.eKTbl TalOK€' npe06JIa-
.MlOT 1laC11laJl c06CTBellliocTb B03MO:IKHa .ID1llIb Ha He6o.n:l.wJ1e no l1JIo-
fi.\O..!I;J1 JII Hepe,!\KO pyKOTBopHble BO,!\HbIe om.eKTbL IIo OTHoweHI1lO K
KpynHbIM peKaM J'! 03epaM, a TaIOKe K MOpCKI1M aKBaWpJ'IJIM 3aKOHo,!:\a-
TeJIb pR,!\a C'rpaH npl1MeH!3:e'1' HecKO.JIb1«) I1Hble TePMl1HbI, B ':IaCTHOCTH, He
«, a «061l1ee .JIO("l"VHIDfe". B TO me BpeMR IOpl1,D.WleCKaH
B03MOmHOCTb B oope.v;e.neHHOH Mepe onpe,!\eJIJITb cyy 3T11X BO)J;HblX
ofu.eKTOB 11 pyKOBO,!\J-'ITh I1X I1Cll0Jlb3OBalDfE'M 11 OXpaHOi1 OCTaeTCH y rocy-
,JIapc'l'l3eHHOiiiBJIacrH.
Ho 06paTI1MCH K OTeqeCTBeHHOMY OllbIT)' npaBOBOI'O peryJll1pOBa-
HI1H BO,!\HbIX OTHOIIIemrn:. B POCCtri1:CKOU I1Mllepllli OHO 6blJI0 pa306-
I1IeHHblM 11 HenOJIHblM. ComaCHO pa3DRCHem1RM IIpaBJ1'feJIhCTB)'lO-
I1Iero CeHaTa, eCTeCTBeHHble BO)J;Hble o6neKTH (peRJII 11 03epa) He
C'llI'rnJIUCb npe.qMemM npaBa Iffi.CTHOH C06CTBeHHOCTI1. ITo 061l1eM)'
npaBI1JIY, rOCY.MpCTBY H I\8.K cY,!\OXO,l:\HHe, TaR 11 Hecy-
,!\OXO)J.HbIe peKI-1. OJ{HaRO OHI1 CJle,!\OBaJiH 3a npaBOM Ha 3eMeJlbHYIO
C06CTBeHHOCTb. 3aKOHOtlaTeJlbCTBO 3aLqJIIlllaJlO HHTepecbl npH6pem-
HblX 3eMJIeBJJa,l\eJIblleB, OT KOropbIX 3aBllCenJil C03)IaHlle KaHaJIOB,
CTpOI1TeJlbCTBO nf,!lpO'IexHIf':leCRJIIX coopymemrn: 11 npOBe):1eIDIe MeJlll-
opaTMBHblX pa60T f _
COBeprneHHO }JJ!yrllMl1 6bIJII1 BOJ1HaB no.mmlKa 11 BO):\HOe 3aKOHOJlli-
TeJlbCTBO COBe1'aroro lleptfQJ:la: IIpe,!\YCMaTpl1Ba.naCb HCKIDCJ<n1'l't'JlbH:) 1'0-
cy,MpCTBeHHafl q:.opMa co6crneHHocTIf Ha BO,!\Hble om.eKTbl, n.naHl1JXlBa-
IDle BO,!:\Horo xromicrBa, npeJlI\oI}'UI;€'CTBeHHO 6eCIlJIaTHoe 1:1 6eccpo'lHoe
(JlR60.wnrreJlbHOeno CPOKaM) npaBO
B 1970 r. 6wII1 npllHflThl "OCHOBbI BO)J;HOro 3aKOHO,JlaTeJIbCTBa COl03a
CCP 11 COlO3HbIX pecny6JrnK,,2. B OT}J;eJlbHbIX COlO3HbIX pecny6.mtKax
,!\eflcTBoBaJul BO,!\HbIe KO,!\eKCbl, a B HeKOTOpbIX 113 HI1X B YCJIOBI1.fIX pa3-
Bll'1'oroopOweHl1Jl- 3aKOHbIOCeJlbHHOMBO):10nOJIb30BaHJIII1.
B pcq,cp 6bIJi npI-1H.ffT BOlUlbr:i1 KDl!eI\:C 1972 1'.3
1 JieM60n.I1 OCHO!IH",enpoOne"''''CCIIeT(:I:(JrQBOJ\Hor03aK(lHOJ\aTeflbCTBa.Jl.:IiI3.l\-lIOnrY,
1948 C.6-12
2 Be.a.oMocrnBepxoBHoroCoBeT3CCCP 1970.N!!50.Cr.566
3 C&U1:XU<OHOBPC<t>CP T4 Cr 163
-,-

Bo;:uIoe 3aROHo,!\aTenbCTBO He 6blJI0 Bce:q;eJIO nO,!\'imI€Ho 3'iaM
MeJUfOpaUHJ1 H J1ppHraWU1. DHO ,lJ;OJDKHO m.1JIO npHHI1MaTb BO BID1Ma-
HHe narpe6HOCTh B Bo,!\e Bcex oTpacneil Hapo;:uIoro X03HiiCTBa J1 Hace-
neHI1H. qTO RaCaeTCH IIpJIpO,!\OOxpallliblX Tpe601amli1, TO OHH He 6Will
WffiJIbHbIMJf H ,l(ame npH 3aKpeI1JleID1J1 B 3aKOHax ,lJ;aJleKO He BCer,l(a
""""","""cr,.
KoHC'I'I-I'I'YlI1Ul PocanlCKOii c))e,!\epaIJ;llU If BOWloe 3aKOHo,!\aTeJlbCT-
BO. B CT. 9 KoHC f'occuiiicmJH ,!\epaul (npl1HRTa BCeHapo,!\-
HbIM roJlOCOBaIDIeM 12 .r:\eKa6pJlI993r.) 3aRpenJIHe'fCJl, 'IT03eMJIJlH .r:\py-
me npHpO,!JJIbIe pecypCb! (B TOM 'iI1CJle H eOabt) HCIIOJIb3YIOTCH J1
oxpamnarcJI RaE OCHOBa :HG13HJ1 J1 ):\eHfeJIbHOCTH Hapo,!\OB, npO»a1BaIO-
I:q;I1X Ha COOTB€'TCTB}'IQllIei1: T€'ppwropJ111. IIo,!\'iepKJ1Bae-rcH, 'ITO 3eMJUI J1
,!\pyrne npl-1pO,IJ;HbIe pecypcbI HaXO,!\JITCH B 'iaCTHOM, rocYMPCTBellllOiI,
(&IJ1BJ1HblXq:.opM3xc06CTBelllioCThl.
ComaCHO CT. 36 rn P<P cOOCTBemUOO-1 npl1pO,!J;Hb1X pecyp-
COB (B TOM 'iJ1CJle H eoo,{bIX) BJIa;:J;elOT, n0J!b3ymrCH H pacrlopIDK.alO'l'CH:
J1MJ-1 CBo6o;:uIO, eCJIH 3TO He HaHOCJ1T yru;epoa 1 cpe,!\e J1 He
Hapyrnae-r npaB J1 3aICOHHbIX I-1HTE'pecOB J1HbIX  B OcHoBHOM 3aKOHe
CKa3aHO «npI1pO,IJ;Hhle peCypChI», HO 3TO BhipameHJ1e CJle.uye-r nOHI1M3Tb
TaK, 'iTO OIDf BOI1JIOlWUOTCH B npl1pO,!J;HbIX  (B TOM <rnCJIe B eoo-
1i'bIX 060e1mWX).
I1CXO,!\JI I-13 CT. 41, 42 mP<P, rnl-1MeeTnpaBOHa ox-
paHY 3,!\OpOBhR, Ha fuJaronpJ1RTH)'KI OICpymaKlrnylO cpe,!\)', .r:\OCTOB€'PHYIO
no 0 ee COC'I01IHI-1H I-1 Ha B03M€ll\eHJ1e yru;ep5a, npl'l'iUHeHHoro
erD3,!\OpoBhIOJ1JHf J1M)'llI;ecTB)' 3IOO.OOrJ'1'i€'CKJfM npaIlOHapyweHJ1eM. &a-
ronpJ1HTH8fl OKpym3IOll$R cpe,!la no onpe,li;eJIemt:KJ BKJIIOqae-r B ee5J1 'iJII-
CTbIe J1 6e30nacHble.wm 'ieJlOBeKa 6o<ht'ble peCYJXbt u eoo1-t'b1e o!k,er.-mbi.
3aI:q;l1TJ1Tb 3,lJ.qJ(EbE' Ipam,n;aH He y.uaCTCJI. eCJ!J1 J1CTO'iIDlKJ1 IIlITbeBOro
6YTJYT3aIpfI3HeHhL
B COOTBe'I'CTBIfU CO CT_ 57 KoH:nfT)7QID1 P<P K8m,iJ;hIi1 o6RsaH eoxpa-
IUITb npl1p0.!IY J1 OICpymaIOIQy1O cpe.!IY, 6epe)!{HO QTHOCwrhCfl K IIpl1po,!\-
HhIM60raTCTBaM. TaKJfMHe3aMeHl1MhIM «npl1pO,!J;Hh!M60raTCTB01M HBJIJI-
eTCH 06wup1-t'btU pecypc npeC1-t'btx 600 POCCJ1I-1.
B CT. 72 KoHCnnyIUm P<P YCTaHaBJlHBaeTCJI, 'iTO oxpaHa OKpyma-
lOIl\eJ::i: epe}];hl H o6ecne'leHJ1e SKOJIOI'lNecKOj;j: 6e30naeHOCTJ1, a TaKme
BonpoChl BJ!a,!\eHJ1.f1, nOJIh30BaHJ1H J1 paenOpmKeHJ1.f13eMJiei1, He)WaMM,
eOO1-tbtMU J1 ,!\pyrnMJ1 IIpI1pI)J;HblMJ1 pecypcB.Mll HaXO,wrrcfl B eOBMeCT-
HOM Be,n;eHUJ1 PocCilliCKOH ,!\epaQI1I1If ee Cy&t.eKTOB. KpoMe Toro, B
COBMeCTHOM Be,!\eHI1J-1 H8X0,WITCH 3eMeJIbHOE', BOa,We, neCHoe 3aI\.OHO-
TeJIbCTBO, 3aKOH0):1aTeJlbCTBO a Hep,pax If 06 oxpaHe OKpYIOIl\eH
cpe,lJ;bI.
-10-

1OHHb1E' nOJIOJKeHIDI COCTaBJ1HlOT OCHOay BD)J;HOro 3aKOHo-
]1aTeJIbCTBa, npe)K,!1€ seem BK PtfJ. HopMhI m: POCCMJ:I- 6aaa
BO)J;HOro 3aKOHo.!\aTeJIhCTBa.
CKO:"'::=:-:==c=e::=
paKTep otp:JpMJIeHllil npaBa IlOJII>3CEaIDf.fI BO)J;HhlM oIh,eKTOM. BHa'1aJIe
x03fli1C1'B}'lOllI;J-ri1 cy6'beKT ,IJ;OJDKeH fu.r.rr nOJIY'lI1Th JllWE'KlliIO. a 3aTeM
Tpe60BaJIOCb 3aKJUQ'-U1Th eIQe H JJ;OroBOp.
B HaqaJ[eXXI B., CJII,IJ,aJIbH2i.WnlMpa3Bl-fI'I-1eMBPOCCI1l1
pblliO'lliblX O1'Howem-ri1, 6bDlO pa3paOOraHo, IIpI1HflTO Jf Be'fYIDDIO B CJ.1JIY H0-
BoeBO)J;HoeClmmapR2007r.BCTyrrn.nBHo-
Bbrn Bo):(HbrnKOt\€KC Poxm1arii Dlar 3 IOOHR 2006 r.N274-cp3Z.
nplmqmIbl BO)l.HOrQ 3aKOHOMTeJIbCTB3. B CT_ 3 BK PIl> 2006 r.t B ar-
JIJf'lJlle ar BK PtfJ 1995 r.,  CHCTeMa nplllinOB BO)l;HOro
3aKOHo.!\aT€JIhCTBa. TaKMM 06paaoM, qepea 10 .neT nocne npl1HRTI-UI BK
PtfJ1995r.6bJJlaoco3HaHanpHMoBTeKC'rer.rraBHoroBo,Q-
HOro saKOHa 113JIO)KIo1Th 0CHUBHhIe Ha'l8.JTa npaBOBoro peryJD1poBaHM
BO,1l;HblX O'IHUIlleHIflf. B CJIY'ffiHX npOOeJIOB If npcmmOpe'll1H B BO.n;HOM 33-
KDHO,lJ;aTeJIbCTB€ OICTeMa IIpI1lll.\illIIOB J\oJDttHa C.rryiKIITh CBoe06pa3HhIM
CJPI'I€HTI1pOM IJ.MI CYJle6HbIX J1 HCfIOJJHJ.1T€JI opraHOB roCy,llapCTB€H-
HOM BJlaCTH. ,lLaHHbI€ IIpI1Hu;mIbl MOryT nOMO'Ib If IIpI1 penreIDm cnopoB
Me X03RHcTByIOLqI1MH CYO'bettTaMI-1.
COOOpa3HO InJI())I{eljJIRM CT. 9 flf PtPB BKPtPno.rr;qepKJ1-
BaeTCJI 3Ha'illMOCTb BO)J;HbIX o&t.e:KTOB 11 Bcero BO.wIOro <PJHM- B l\a'leCT-
Be OCHOBb! )KJI!3HJ111 ,l\eJITeJIbHOCTH qeJIOBeKa, COCTaBHoiii 'lacrn OKpyma-
IO" cpe, KOTOpaJi H€OOxo)J,J1Ma.wm x ,AemeJIbHOCTJ1.
IIp''' TOJIKOBaHJ1!il aTOro nepBOro no 3Ha'leHillO 11 no C'-IeTY np.un:ptna BO,Q-
HOro 3aKOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBa CJ1e,uyeT eTb B BM.U.Y lIpe:m,LJ;e Bcero npeCHble
BO, HO He CTOI1T I1CKJiIO'-Ian. Ii MopCKHe BO)J;b!, 60raTbie 6HOJIDrn'-IeCKJ1-
MIiII1.npymMlil IIpllpO,nHHMK pecypcaMlil. JicJro,QJ:I J13 Ha3BaHHoro IIpI1Im!iI-
na, BO.I\Hble OTIfOilieHID! I1MelOT ny6Jrn"1HO-'laCTH)'1O IIpHpo,!\y 11 He MOryr
HOCHTb nOJIHOCTbIO npaBOBoiii xapaKTep. li1MeHHo nO:mJMY
BO.I\Hble OTHOWeHID! peryJ11-ipy1OTCJI rpaiK.!laHCKJ-fM 3aKOHO.I\aTeJlbCTBOM
TQJIbKO B Toiii Mepe, B I\aKoiii OHH He o'IperyJ1Ii1poBaHbl CIJeQJIaJIbHbIM -
BObIM: H I1HblM aKO.1Di'J'1'-J:€ - 3aKOHO,!\ClTeJlbCTBOM.
113 Ha3BaHHOro 1Ip11Hqill1a BbrreKaeT 11 .npyroiii.: 06H3aTeJlbHOCTb ox-
paHbI BO.I\Hb1X om,eKTOB IIpH J1X J1C1l01lb30BaHIDL CJIe.I\OBaTeJIbHO, HC-
1 C3P$.1995.Nil47.Cr.4471
2pr2006Ni1121.8HIOHH

mTIb30BaHlle BO)UIbIX OfueKTOB, BHe 3aBJ1CHMXTI1: OT JfX BJ1):\OB Ii pa3-
HOOJ'J.!I;IJOCT€ii, ,/J;OJImHO 6bITb nO)J;'fi1HeHO 3KOJIorWiecluIM J:IlITepeCaM.
3aKoHO,/J;aTeJIh 4>oPMYJrnPYeT Tpe60BaID1J1 K IICnOJIh30BaHHIO BO,/J;HbIX
06'beKTOB B OT,neJIbIIOn rJIaBe BK fII:l>. 3TH 'Ipe60BaHIDI MOmHO pa3)J;e-
JII1Tb Ha OCHOBHble, pacnpOC'IpaHHIOIql-leCJI Ha Bce B>VU>I BO)J;QIIo.JIb3OBa-
HWI, II Cnel-tJ1aJIhHbIe - no OT.J1eJIhHbIM BJ1A3M BO)J;onOJIb30BaHWI (nHTb-
eBoe II X03HHCTBeHHO-6bITOBOe BO)J;OCHa6meHJtle, c6poc CTO':IHblX II
.n;peHamHbIX EO)];, 'IpaHcnopT, JleCOCmIaB, peKpeaIU1H, no:mapHaJI 6e30-
naCHOCTb).
IIpHopWI'e-I' oxpaHbI BO)J;HblX 06'beKTOB nepe.i:\ IIX JKn)JIb3OBallJreM MO-
meT 6bITb BbIpa:1KeH B OM orpaHJ1'-Ie:HMM X03JIiii:CTBeHHOIU IIC-
IJOJI:b:3OBaJilUi oco60 oxpaHReMbIX BO)J;HbIX 06'beXTOB, 3anpeTe OT,/J;eJIbHblX
ero BJ.1)J;OB. K IillM oco60 oxpaHReMbIX EO)J;HblX 06'beKTOB OTHOCmCJI BO,/J;-
Hble 06'beR1'br pa3JiJ1'rnblX BJ.1)J;OB. 3To MOryT 6bITb yqaCTKJ1 MOpCKJIX EO)];,
BO,/J;OTOKH II EO,/J;oeMbI, oc060 l\eHHbre BO,lIlV-f:oJnTHble yrO,i:\bJL KpoMe '!'O-
ro, oco60 oxpaHJleMbIMH BO)J;HbIMH 06'beKTaMJII MO:arnO C'illTaTb II MecTa
HepeCTa l\eHHblX BJ-UJ;OB pbro, 30Hbl oxpaHbI IICTOKOB J1JII1 YCTbeB pel{. Oco-
60 oxpaHJIeMble BO,[(HHe 06'bet\Tbl MOryT JlMeTb MepO,IJ;Hoe, <pe.i:\e-
p8.JIbHoe, pemOHaJibHOE' II MecTHOe 3Ha'leHJlle.
IJ;eJleBoe HCIIO.IIb3OBaHJ BO)J;HOro o6'beKTa OT,l\3JieHHO HanOMHHaeT
,/J;eJIeHJlle 3eMeJIhHoro 4xJH,i:\a Ha ceMb l\aTeropHH Cccl)Pa3HO J1X l\eJIeBOMY
Ha3Ha'leID:!IO('ITOnpe.IIYCMO'IJJeIIOB3eMeJIhHOM).BOT-
Jn1'll1e OT 3eMeJIbHOfO, BO.JlHbIiii 4xJH,I:I He .J1eJlJ1TCJI Ha IffiTeropMt1 no CBOHM
npaBOBblM peM, OTBe'-l3IOIqI-IM l\eJleBOMY Ha3Ha'leHJ1lO. O)J;11H II TOT
me BO)J;HbIiii 06'beKT (Harrpl1N!ep, pelffi) IIJD1,[(a:>Ke ero 'lacrb MOitteT 6bITb
JDIOJIb3OBaHa B pa3HbIX l\eJlHX: cyWXQD;CTBO, JI€COCIIJIaB, peKpeaIJ;l1H,
pH6o.ooBcToo, oXOTa II TJ(.
BMeCTe c TeM xapaKTep B(),[(OIIOJIbOOtH He JlBJIHeT(:JI,/J;eK-
napaTI1BHblM: OH JlMeeT 6oJrbllIOe IDplfAWleCJ<Oe 3Ha'leID1e. ComaCHO BK
PtfJ l\eJlh, B»JI H cfIoc06 fIOJIb3OBaHJtH BO.J\HblM 06'beKTOM .J10JDttHbl 6bITb
O'IpameHbI B )J;OI'OBOpax BQWIlOJlb3OBalillJl II B peWeHI1JIX 0 npe,!J;OCTaBJIe-
ID111 B I1OJIb3(E8ffile BO)J;HOro o6'beKTa.
IIpHn l\eJleooro 11CJX)JJb3(JI!8HH EO)J;HblX 06'beKTOB nOJIy<rnJI Bbl-
pameID:!e B pH.I\e r.naB BKPtfJ, B 'laCTHOCTIl, B rJL 5 ({Ie»
B cHJIY  BK PI!> npHopItTeTHOM l\eJlh1OJlBJIHeTCJI IICfIQJIb30-
BaHHe BO)J;HbIX 06'beftTOB IJ.MI ID1TbeBoro II xoam1cTBeHHo-6I.rroB<ro BO):\O-
CHa6:>KeHI1JI.
IIpHn paBHOro ,/J;oCTyIIa K IIOJIb&JBaHJ1IO BO)J;HbIMJ1 OfueKTaMJII co-
OTBeTcTB}'eT 8HI11KCp -qaM. 3TOT npmrn;mr CBfl3aH C
BBe,l\eIilleM aym:(t1OIDB c l\eJIbIO 33K.JIIO'leHIf.R .J10roBOpoB Ha J1CnOJIb30Ba-
ID1e BO):\HbIX 06'beKTOB, HO He npen;pernaeT ero.
-12-

C Ha3BaHHbIM np11HlUfiIOM CHmaHO ellle O)J;HO nOJIomeHJl!e: paBHbrM1J.o-
CTyn KI'1X JllIOPJWf'feCKHX JIJ1I.I KnpJ.106pereIDOO B'iaCTH)'1OCOO-
CTBeHHOCTb BO)J;HblX ofueKTOB (npY1J.OB JII 06Bo)J;HeHHbIX xapbepoB). Of].Ha-
KO 3'1'0 JI)Jl())KeID'!e CJIe;:I..YeT TOJIKOBaTb C yqeTOM «e)J;MHCTBa CY,/J;b6bl»
:.=rI'MX B01J.OeMOB C TeM 3eMeJIbHbIM yqaCTKOM, Ha KOTOpoM OHt:l Hax01J..!iTCR.
B CHJIY npmru;J1lla rnaCHOCTI1I301J,OIIOJ1b3(1H BJlaCTIlbie peweHWI a
IIpe,nocTaBJlEtlJll B01J,HbIX 06'beKTOB B IIOJIb:3OBaIDft', a TaIOKe IIDIUBOPH
BQI:J:fI0JIb:30BaHJ'UI 1J,OJPKHbI 6brI'b 1J.OCTyIIHbI .mo6oM}' .mnty, KpOMe IDf-
q,opMaQJ.1I1, COCTaBJIHIOIQf2 rOCYMpC'TBeHHYK> Taihry.
KOHTpoJIb 06lQeCTBeHHOC'fI1 sa BO,l\OIIOJIh3OB8ffi:!eM 06ecne-<n1BaeT
npMill\illI yqacTJ.m rpaJK1J,aH JII  qJraIDI3aQJIIi'i B peweHl1J1
B0IIJX!COB,  I1X npaB Ha BO)J;Hble OObeKTbl, a TaIOKe I1X 06.f1-
3aHHOCTeii no oxpaHe B01J.. B 'iaCTHOCm, rpaiK,lJ;aHe JII 06ll1ecTBeHHble op-
raHM3al:u1I1MelOT npaBO npl-001MaTb yqacme B n01J.l'OTOBKe pernemri'1,
MOryw;J.1XJIIMeTbIlOCJIe,J:J,(.'WWI.wmJllClIOJIb3OBaH1HJ10X-
paHbl B01J.. B CBOIO OlJepe opraHbl rocY1J.a1 BJlaCTJ1 J1 MeCTHOI'O
mMOynpaBJIeHJ1R, a TalOKe CyD'I>eKTbI X03$1iiCTBeHHOii J1 J1Hoiii: 1J.emeJlb-
HOCTI-! 06maHbl 06ecne'lJllTb B03MruKIIOCTb TIlKOI'O yqaCTI-!H.
BamHej;j:weA rrpe.lI;I1OO>I. o yqacrllil.flBJUleTC.fl CEO€-
BpeMeHHoeJ1nOJlHoeJIpOB8.IDIeOCOCTOJIID1I-fB01J.-
HbIX 06'heKTOB, 0 TIJIaHaX J1X MCIlOJIb3OBaHt1fl, npe06pa30BaHrut Eea nOJlHoA
H 1J.QCTOB€pHOA 11H4>oPMaqill1 e6lQ€CTBeHHoe yqacme:tf€B03M())KHO.
3aKoHo.naTeJIb SaKpeIIJIReT pery.mrpoBaHt:le BO)J;HblX amoweHlilii B
rpaHlilL(aX 6acceiiHoBHx OKpyI'OB.I\aK I13BeCTHO, BO)J;Hble ofueKTbI rpyn-
Ill1pYIOTC.fI no l'IeCKItM paflOIJaM, J1MelOLQWM pa3HbIe BO)J;Hble
peml1Mbl (H8IIpHMep, pe)KHMbI pelt BOJIrn If JI€HbI cOBepweHHo pa.3JIJ1IJ-
lib!). OrclO1J,a MBHO  K<Ut B POCCID'!, Talt JII sa py6emoM
6acceiiimBHii nOf].Xo)J; K pery.mtpoB3ffioo BO)J;HblX 0'I'H0llEH1ri1. BacceiiHo-
Bbrn no1J.xo,D; - OCHOBa co3)J;aID:!.fl JII clJ}'HKQJIOHI1pOO8HIm 6acceiiiHoBHx co-
BeTOB.
B IDfTepecax oxpallbl npHpo,D;bl perY.ID1pOBaHJl!e B01J.HbIX OTIlllleHKii
1J.OJDKHO )"MI'blBaTb npnpQlJ;Illde oco6P1IlIIJcrJ.{ pe)KHMa BO)J;HbIX OObeK-
TOB. TaK, HanpHMep, 'lpe3MepHbIH &lOOp BO)J;b1 J13 MeJIKOB01J,HbIX peK J1
03ep MomeT IIpJmecuI K If X 06Me.nemno. 01J.HaKO B cpe,!J;HeM, no OQeHKaM
J13peKJ1M:atHO «6e3Bpe)J;Ho» aa6paTb1J.O 1O-15%CTO,B
CJlyqae IIpeBblweHWI 3TOH QH<l:JPbl Ha'll-lHaeTC.fl  BOt\OTOKa .
B BK PtfJ npe;:I..YCMaTpHBaeTCR B3arn-.rnaR CBR3b BOt\HbIX ofueKTOB 11
I'Jf,!J,}XYI"eXJtI€CKItX COO 1t0000ble B COI!OItyIIHOCTI cBoeii 06pa-
I MHXOOeB HH Bop,a _ He TOBaj) II SKOJ1OmH 11"'3Hb. 2005 N 7(48). C 22-23
-13-

3ylOT  CY!CTeMY Il-1,n;poTeXlDt"IecmJe C'lpC&ITeJIbCTBO
npeBpaTI1JIO KpyrIHE'iWnre pocCMMCKJlle peKJII K KOHqy xx B. B:q;em. BO,!\O-
xpaHl1JIWI11 (HanpWMep, 6acceJ::iH BoJIrY!). B pe3YJIbTare CJIO:HafJIMCb npY!-
aH'I'pOIIOI'eHH KOMIlJIeKCbl, B KOTOpbIX BO):IHble 06'beKTb! cY"-Ie-
CTByroT no.n; CJfJIbllei-hIrnM eikTBneM rrc. Ee,!\a B TOM, '1TO 6e3
X03JlliHa ITC He}'MOJII1MO BeTllIaKIT, a B ceJIbCKOR MeCTHOCTY! B pe3YJIb-
TaTe pa3Bana KOJIX030B OHM OCTa.rrnCb 6ecxuam1HHM:Jf. PaCJIIX.CIPaHea}
MHeHJile, 'ITO Y BO):IHOro 06'belITa M ITC ,I\OJDKeH 6b!Tb O,D;Y!H X03ffi1H. IIo-
3TOMY npM paspa60TKe BK Pip 2006 f. HeIOCJTOpb!e cne:Q;l1aJiYlCTbl npe,!\JIa-
raJlJ'! npe.v;ya.rcrrpe B Ko,!\eKCe 1101ICOR'elDm, IIpl3lIaKJIl.O:te HanopHhle
rrc CXJCTaBHOi.i '1aCTbKJ BO):IHblX OObeKTOB.
B BK PtfJ 2006 r. aaKpeIU1eH) npaBO  BO):IHblX OObeK-
TOB KopeHHhOO1 MaJlO'lJ1C.1IeHllHM HapO.n;ar.rn CeBepa, CI16I1pY!, .n;aJlbHe-
ro BOCTOKa POCCY!Y! B paMKax J1X 'I'pa 06pa3a )KY!3HJ1. JI:.Jrn
3TJ-1X Hapo.n;OB, cormCHO CT. 11 BK Pip, He Tpe6yeTCB: 3aKJIKJ<leH!UI,I\Oro-
BOpa BQJ:IOJDJIb3OBaID1H Jf.Jll1 npY!HHTIlH BJIaC1'H(UU pellleID1H 0 npe,!:\OCTaB-
JIeffi1M BO)J;HOro OObeKTa B IIOJIb3OBaHHe. TeM caMbIM 1\OCTyrt K BO,!:\Hh!M
06'beKTaM B CJlyqae 1OHIO'O IIpJIpO,[IOIIOJIh3OJ3aHIm OKa3bIBaeTCfI
HaI1DOJIee IIpOCTblM
TaKJIIM 06pa30M, npY!HQMIThI BO)J;HOro npaBa He opY!eHTlilpoBaHhI Ha
BCe:q;eJlO KOMMepqecKJili xapaKTep BO)J;HblX 011l01llemrlii, J160 nOCJle,!\Hee
6b!JIO 6b! rnDeJlbHhIM]J,M! p(xc1(i«'I«I'O BO)J;HOro c:lx>H1\a.
2. nPABO C06CTBEHHOCTH HA BO)1HbIE 06bEKTbi
H nOP)10K nOb30BAHH HMH
CoAeJDK3lllle "paBa Co6crBellllOcrll ua BO)J}ILle o&beKTLL IIpaBO c06-
CTBeHHOCTIl-  nOH.'ITl1e K{JIWI'leCKOIt: HaYK"11 npax-
TI-OO-I. C Te'leHJ1eM BeKOB €Bponeiiio«ul npaBOBaJI MbICJlh nOHHMaeT npaBO
c06CTBellliocmKaKI13BecTHYJO'IpI1a.n;y: B.JIa):\elille (o6JIa.J¥l-
HYle), I1OJTh3CEIaHIfe ( 3KCrmyaTI1POBaTh, I13BJlexaTh none3-
Hhrn 3cpc:pe1tT M3BeLql1), pacnopfIm.etme (B03MQ)KHOCTbOnp€1\eJIJITb IOpM-
JJ}1'!ecK)'IO CY,ll;b6YBell{l1, npo,!:\aTb, C.n;aTb B apeH.n;y). Talwl1::me B3fJI.H,L\ Ha
c06CTBeHHoCTb pa3.n;eJlfleTCH poccm1cKoi1 npaBoBOi1 TeOpMei111 OTpa-
eTCJIB 3aKoHo.u,aTeJlbCTBe.
Co,!:\ep»\aHJile npaBa co6CTBeHH:OCTIf Ha BO):IHble 00DeI-m.I: rnpeMJIH-
eTCJI KaK 1'pa>fi,!\aHCKt1M, Tax 11 BO):IHbIM 3aKOHo.u,aTeJIbCTBOM. Hax CJleJ1Y-
eT Jf3 CT. 209-211 I'pam,IlaHCKoro Ko,!\eKca PtfJ, co6CTBeHID1K HMeeT npa-
BO BJJB.II:€HKH, nOJlb30BaHWlI1 pacnoJ1R'K€Hl1H CBOt1M l1MY"-IecTBOM, HeceT

Hace6e6peMflco,!\epmaHHfl JIIpHCKm6eJIl-f HM)'lIIeCTBa. Ho HBCaMOMrK
PtfJ (cr. 209, 129) ycTaHaBJIHBaIOT CBoero po,!\a «lOCJJIODl'reCKJle IIpH-
OPJITeTbI». CBo60,!\Hoe BJIa,!\eID-Ie, 1I0JIb30BaHJ1e, paCrrOpIDKeHHe 3eMJIei-i:
H JWYfMMi'I IIpWPO'!\HbIMJ.1 pecypcaMl1 orpaHIt<leHO 'Ipe60BaHHeM He HaHO-
CII/Tb Yll-Iep6a 1 cpe,lJ;e. KpOMe TOro, aeMJIfl J111IPyme rrpJ1-
po,!\Hble pecypCbl MOry'!' ()T<!TbC.fI JII rrepexomtTb or O,!\HOro .mll-la x
l-\PyroMY JIIHbIM cnoco6oM B TOi-i: Mepe, B KaKOi-i: JIIX o60poT ,lJ;onyCKaeTC.fI
3aIOCH8MH a aeMJIe J1 ,lij)yrnx IIp"J)O)J.HblX pecypcax (CT. 129). TaKID.II 06-
pa30M, IIpJtMeH€tfJfe II: IIpJllpo,!!,HbIM: pecypcaM (aeMJI.fl, He.D;pa, Jleca, Bo,!\a,
7ID1BOTHbDf MI1p) Jllicnnyra IIpaBa co6cmeJrnOCTIf J1MeeT CBOJII oco6eH-
HOCTH.
Ha OCHOBe IIO.JImf«'Illnl BO)J;HOro 3aKOHO):\aTeJlbCTBa MO:1KHO OTMeTWI'b,
Il'J'O XapaKTepHoi-i: <repTOH IIpaBa ro6crBeHHJC1'R Ha BO)J;Hble o61,eKTbI.HB-
JlfIeTC.fI HeIIOJIHoe IIpJIMeH€ffile IIOH.fITIDI «BJl3J\eID1e» II: BO)J;HblM o&beK-
TaM, JII60 oocpe.I1OTC:J<IeHHWI B HJIIX BO):\a HaXO)J)ITCSI B COC'IOmOOf Henpe-
pblBHoro AB11melUffl JII Bo,!\oo6MeHa. ELqe O,!\Ha oco6eHHocTb npaBa
co6cTBeHHOCTIf Ha BO,!\Hble 06'beKTbI 3aKJIIO<laeTCR B sanpeTe Ha 0T'IJ'fC-
J\eH11e BO)UIbIX ofueKTOB (xpoMe npy,lJ;OB JII o6Bo,I\HeHHwt KapbepoB)'.
B BK P4>BbIp<UKeHO 'I'eCpeTWlecIroe npe onoBepXHocT-
HblX BO)J;HblX 06DeKTax KaK a ffiI'IHCTEIe nOBepXH(x:THbIX BO,lJ; JII nOll:pbl-
TbIX JIIMt:I aeMeJlb B npe,lJ;enax 6eperoBOR Jlt:lHt:lt:I. CaMa 6eperoBall JlJII-
Ht:lfl, CJIe,lJ;OBaTeJIbHO, J1 rpaHt:ll-\3 BO)J;HOro 06'beKTa, ycT8H8BJTIfBaeTC.fI
aaKOHo,!\aTeJIeM. EeperoBbIe JI11HIDf peK, PYTheB, KaHaJIOB, 03ep, 06BOJ\-
HeHHblX KapbepOB eJI.fllOTCH no cpe,IUleMHoroJIerneMY ypoBHlO Bo-
.JIbI B 6e3JI€,JJ;HbIJ1 nepHo,!\, IIpy,lJ;OB JII Bo,!\oxpam1JlJIILq - no HOpMaJibHOMY
nO,!1IIOpHOMY ypOBHIO BO,!\bl. 3To cnoco6cTBye-r o6ocHoBaHHoMY pa3rpa-
Ht:llJeHt:110 npaB JII aaKOHHblX JIIHTepeCoB c06CTBeHHJ1KOB (n0Jlb30BaTe-
JIei-i:) BO,!1HblX o&beKTOB JII I1plfMHE8lOllCltX aeMeJIbHblX YlJaCTKoB. EOJIee
TOro, 3'1'0 6y,!\eT cn0c06cTBoBaTb HeyltJIoHHOMY JlcnoJIHeH11lO KOHKPeT-
HO onpe,!\eJIeHHbIM11 06JIa,!\aTeJI.HMJiI npaB Ha npll]XJ.D;Hble 06'beKTb! 0651-
3aHHOCTeH IIO oxpaHe BO,!\. OxpaHa BO,!\ BXO,!\JIIT B 06513aHHocTJII C06CT-
BeHffilIKa JII IIOJIb30BaTeJI.fI BO)J;HOro ofueKTa, a TaIOKe 06JIa,!IaTeJI.fI npaB
Ha 3eMJllO B npe,!\eJIax BO,!\ooxpaHOH30Hbl. ITpJII 3TOM B CJ-LJIY 3aKOHa, B
l-\eJl.flX J1136emaHJIIJI ,[Iy6.JrJIIpoBalllfH JII nYTaHHI-lbI, Bo,!\ooxpaHHb!e 06H-
3aHHOCT'" pa3J1JillJHbIX o6.rra,!\aTeJIeH npaB Ha 3eMJIJII If Ha BO,1\bI 'leTKO
onp€,n;eJIeHb! J'I paarpaH11lJeHbI «IIpocrpaHC'IBeHHO» co06pa3Ho J'lX npa-
BOBblM II03MCOKHOCTHM (B TOM IJHCJle «nepe,n;» 6eperoBoii: JD1ffilIei-i: H «no-
33J\W) Hee)
I KBw\Ho"YKOtl€KCyPocc;:;C"o;:;I!1e.<Iepal\H{bI;:;J/oTBpeJ1.C.A.60-
I"OJ1tdioB.M..Be1I6,flpocneKT.2007.C.40-46.
-15-

K COiK3.JIemoo, Ha npai\TJ1Ke ycraHOBJITb 6eperoByIO JOOIHIO Y MHornx
BO)J;HblX 06'bei\TOB.r:\OBOJIbHO TPY.r:\HO. 3ry 3a;:J;a'i)' npJ.-l,lJ;eTCJI pelliaTb, npe-
O,lJ;OJleBaR ynyI.IJ;eID1R B rw:IpDJIorwrecID-IX Hafimo.r:\eHJ1RX OTHOCJITeJlbHO
ypoBH.II BO)1;bI, HaEOILJIeHHble 3a IIpOlllJIble rO.n;bI. 3a ccrromnft'M MHOrnX
BO)J;HblX 06'bei\TOB B .ny<IIIIeM cnyqae OCYl1\€CTBJIHJlJtCb 311Jf3O)J;ItG€CKJ'E
Ha6.mo.z1eH1tH. Ha MHOIU'lJoICJIeH MaJlhIX BO.nOeMax iii BO.nOTOi\aX Cpe.n-
HeMHOrO.n€'nIHii ypOBeHb BO)]; B 6e3JIe,lJ;Hbli1 nepJ-fO,lJ; He OTCJie<ro1BaJlCR. Ha
crapblX npY.r:\ax, coopymeHHbIX KYCTapHO (6e3 npoeKTa), HeKOTopblX He-
60JlbllillX no OOneMaM HJ-1.IDW{aX, He J1MelO KTI1BHblX
n0JIb30BaTe1len, HOpMaJIblll:li- noJUlopHbIi1 ypOBeHb TalOKe He arc.rrearn-
BaJiCR. He MeHee npOOJleMaTw-mo onpe,l\eJlelll1e 6eperceOO JlillUII1 MopH
no JOOIHIt:! M8IOCI1M8JIbHCI'O OTJD1Ba. CJleJ\oBaTeJlbHO, B HaCTOHIQee BpeMH
OpraHaM, oC)'l1IecTBJlffiO  HafimoJ\eIme (POCl'J1,!J;po-
MeT iii Pocoo,n;pecypcb), npM,JJ;eTCH no  HaBepCTaTb yny-
ll\eHHoe. IIOCKOJlbKY rocy.r:\apCTBelllibIi1 MOHlITOpMHr (mfuno,lJ;eID:!e) 3a
BO)J;Hblllrn 06'beKTaMJII B Te'leID:!e MHOrl1X nOCJle)J;HJ.1X JleT OCTaBJIaJI :IKe-
JIaTbJIY'illlero, onpe,lJ;eJIRTb 6eperoByIOJOOIHIOB HaCToee BpeMH Mom-
HO JIHIllb C I1CI'pErnHOC'rnMIiI- OJ\HaKO rl1JlPO.1IOrnI1 If3B€C'I1IbI HeEtOTOpble
rrapaMeTpbl, n cJ\eJlaTb onpe,lJ;eJleHJ.-Ie 6eperoBoi1 .ID1ID:!J.-I
B€'CbMa 6J1J'!3KJ1M KIiICTIfHe. K Ill1M OTHocmCH II!3MepeID:!e TOJilWfHbI OCa;:J;-
KOB, npmll.\11II aHaJlOrnI1 (II03I3OJllllCU:rli npJ.-lMeID:!Tb yme J1MelOeCH
3HaID:!H 06 aHaJlOl'J1'llIOii CTPYKTYP€ BOJ\HOro 6accei-hIa).
YnOTpe6Jm.fl te «C06CTBeHHOCTb Ha BOJ\Hhle 06'b€KTbJ)),
MhII1CXO)J;J.1M113 TOro, q'J'OBClInpeJ\MeTOBnpaBaco6CTBeH-
HOCTMCOCTaB.IIHeT «BOJ\Hhlli.:!xuI,!\» Poccmf. BeJlb, I1CXO)J,.H113CT.l BKPtfJ,
BO)J;HbIi1 ct>oH,!\ €CTb C<JBCKyrnJXTb BO)J;HblX 06'beKTOB B npe,lJ;enax TeppJ.-l-
TopJ-fJ.-l Pocmi1rn.oii cpeJ\epaU;IHf.
MHoroo6pa3ue $:IpM Co6cTBeIDlOCTH. BoJ\Hoe 3aKOHO,lJ;aTeJIbCTBO yc-
TaHaBJll1BaeT rrpeuMyl1\€C'I'O .:J:Ie.nepaJlbH)'1O cofcrBeHaxTI, Ha BO.n-
Hhle 06'beItTbL CornaCHO BK P<P c06CTBeHHOCTb Cy6neItTOB cfIetIepau;mf,
MJIDIqI-1II8JibHHX 06pa3OBaHlm,  11 IOpK,IJ;If'I€C&1X Jlill.\ B03-
MO:iKHa.ID1Wb Ha IIpy.r:\bll1 06Bo,!UIeHHble IUlpbepbL
MomHo C yB€'p€HHOCTbIOyrBep:iK,Zl,aTb, 'iIO peKJII 11 03epa, KaHa.llbI II! BQI:\O-
xp, Jle;:J;IllOOIl1 CHe:iKHI1KI'I, 60JIara iii npMpO,!J;HbJe BblXO)J;bl nO,lJ;3eM-
HhIX BOA, MopH Ii1I1X 3aJTI1Bb!npl1Ha)J.JlemaT Ha npaBe co6cTBeHHOCTIiI PQCCMi1:-
CKOA4Ie.nepa1tI-1J1..lJ:a;Iee 6y.r\eTpaCKpbfro, KaK4Ie.nepa1..(lliI yrrpaBJlJleTCBOE'A
co6cTBeHHOC'TblO H OxpaHHeT €e.
B C11J1)' BK PtfJ B C06CTBeHHOCTJII pecrry6.ro1:KJ'I, KPaH, d'i.rracTII. ropo,lJ;a
ct>e,lJ;epa.llbHoro 3Ha"leWfH, aBTCflOMHOi.! 06.naCTI1, 8.B1OHOMHOrOOKpyra MO-
ryr 6b1Tb npy.r\bllil KapbepbL Ho C )"-IeTOM pernoHaJlbHoi1 Co6cTBeHHOCTIii
craBlfJIlfChlill1HbleEOl1JXlCbL
-16-

Hanpl1Mep, npl1 06cYiK,JJ;eHl1J1 npOeKTa BK P4> 2006 r. npe,lJ;MeTOM oc-
Tpoil ,IU1CK)'CCI1I1 6bDlO npaBO cy&beKToB PtfJ BJIa;:\eTb BO)J;HbIMl1 06'belITa-
MI1, BbIXOAflIQl1Ml1 sa. paMKl1 npY,I\OB iii 06BoAHeHHbIX KapbepoB. B 3TOi1:
BI yqaCTBOBaJlli opraHbI BnaCTI1 pa3Jlli'lHblX cy6'beKTOB PIl>. ITo
co,!\epmaID-1I0 npoeKTa BK P4> OT pen'lOHOB 3B)"1aJ111 CJle.JJ;.YlOLII;J1e 1iIHTe-
peCHble, HOarKJlOHeHHblenp:
1) COXpaHWI'b B 0: fic'meHHocTI.:! cy6'beKTOB P4>peKJ1, aKBaTOpl1l1 KOTO-
pbIX HaXO,!\HTCH I'1CJtJIRNJ1TeJ B rpaIDll.\B.X O,!\HOM pecny6JIJ1KJ1 (o6nac-
TI1, aB'IOHOMmU 06.rracm, KpaH, aBTOHOMHOI'O oKpyra, rop0.l1a c}:>e.l1epa.1Ib-
HorO 3Ha'leHl-Ui);
2) nepe,IlaTb B co6crneHHOCTb cyfu.eRToB PtfJ BO,!\OTOKI1, npel1M)'lll;ecr-
Bellm paClIOJl(})K('HIIbIe B O,!\HOM pemOHe;
3) nepe,!1aTb B C06CTBeHHOCTb CyD'beKTOB PIl> lfatyCC'l'BeHHbIe BO,!\Hble
o6'beKTbI, C03,l\8HHbIe B qeJl.flX ID1TbeBOro BO,!\OCH86m.eHillH,!1aHHOrocy6'h--
elIT8 PtfJ, BHe 3aBI1CI1MOCm ur IiIX reorp:wIeCKoro parno.Jl())Kflll1&
Eo BTOpoM cJIYGae pe'Ib llIJIa 0 peKaX, 6o.nee 1/2 TeqeHIiIR KOTOpblX
IIpI1XOJJ;JIT('JIHa AaHHbliipernoH. B-rpeTbeM c.rryqae -0 BQI:\OxpaHlmI1I.Wlx
:;e;:o=::Yr;=;::r:ea;:ao:: H8
O,!\HaKO B HaCTOffiL\ee BpeMR HeI<OTOpbIe cyD'beKTbI epaqI-rn He 06-
JIa.!\alOT Co6CTBeHHOCTbIO ,!\am.e Ha Te Bo,!\oeMbl, KafOpble, comaCHO ,!\eil-
CTBYIOIn;eMY BK PtfJ, MOryT 6bITb B peI11OHaJ1bHoil co6crBeIrmCTI1. TaK,
HanpJrM:ep. BOJIoroppcaSi 06.rraCTb He 38ttpemfJla cBOe npaBo COOcTBeHHQ-
CTI1 HaMHorne npy,!\bI I1KapbepbL 06.rraCTborpaHll'ffiJI8.cb3aKpeIIJIeHilleM
cBOero npaBa co6crBeIrmCTI1 Jll1llIb Ha HelIDTOpble OOWXO
npeAIIPI1RTI-fR (BO,!\OKaHaJIbI).
B BK P4> 2006 r. 38KOHO.I\8.TeJIb yKa38JI Te pa3OOBH,IJ;HOCTII IIOBepXHO-
CTHbIX BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTOB, KOTopble MOryT 6bITb B o::.6CTBemIocTH cytTheK-
Ta PtfJ,06p8.3oBaHl1H, J1IOp1Wf'IffKJfX
JIJ1lt (npY.r\bll1 06BO,n,HeHHhIe Kapbepbl). O.r\HaKO 'leTKJ1e IiIX Ollpe,l\eJIeHIiIH
B BK PtfJ arcy'fCTBYJOT. am MomeT nopO,!J;J1Tb KOJLIII13J1J1 Mem,uy pa3JIJ1'I-
HbIMl1 cylheKTaMJr, co6cTBemucTI, KafOpblX Ha 3m Bo,!\oeMbI,I\onyCKaeT-
CB BK P<P. Oc06eHHO OCTpo CTOWI' BOnpoC He C ii, a C 'l8CT-
Holi co6cTBE'HHOCTbIO Ha npY,D;bl11 Kapbepbr.
B HaCTOHIl\ee BpeMRB03MO}KHOHe npJtcBOeHJIIe B 'la-
CTH)'IO co6cTBeHHOCTb He60JIbnmx 03ep, PO.l1Hi11KOB J1.JIJ1 MaJIbIX BO)J;oxpa-
HI1 ITo AaHHblM POCBO,!I;pecypCOB, B MOCKtJBCKCii 06.rracm €CTb CJI)'-
1 CM nOJlP06Hee.&>ronN)tk>BC,A"CHsaKOB)1,.O.nOCTaTe;:;HbIKBw\HOMYKQJJ.eK-
::i:;,:,,<JIeJJ.epaL.ll<H("'YpHaf1bHbI;:;Baj)HaHT'"I1:i"oHOMH"a 2007

':laY! npHBaD13aL!JUI no)]; B11,ZJ;OM npy,I\OB Y! KapbepoB :>Ke )];epeBeHCKMX
BO,!\03a60pHbIX CXBa*J1H. IIo.z\of:In,Ie HeraTI1BHble .HBJleHl1H ,I\OJDKHbl6bITb
npeCe'ieHbI He TOJlbKO CY,!J;OM, HO JII Ha 3aKOHO,!laT€JlbHOM ypOBHe.
B rocTe 19179-73 «nf.lJPOJlOI'ID'lcynn-t TepMmlbl JIIonpe,I\eJleHl1.fl»-
HbIHe o'!eHb cOBepweHHble onpe,!\eJleIDffi npY,!J;OB JII IIpy,I\OB-I«I1aH2ii O,!\-
HaKO (0Eepll€HH0 He .HCHO, KaKJlO 1:13.l1€$ BbIpa60TaHHbIX B el1\e
cOBeTClG1e l3peMeHa B nepY!o,!J; roCIIO,!J;CTBa rocy,I\apcrBellliOH co6CTBellliOC-
'I'M Ha BOW>I, CJleAYeT npJIIMeHaTh,l\Jlfl mpeJI.eJI€HJf.f Hpyra BO.n;oeMOB, MOry-
I4HX 6bITb B 'laCTHOH cofrrnemIocrn. IIpY! 3'lUMTepMJ-IH «Kapbep» B rocTe
BOO6l1\e He onpe,!J;eJleH. TalG1M OOJED"!. nOJIruKeHl1.fl rocTOB - CID1llIKOM
rnaTKafl QCHOBa ,l\JlfI pOOJIl13a1tt1J1 BO,IJ;HOro 3aKOHO,l1aTeJIb
fuKJI3BI2CTHO,CY!CTeMarocToB 6y,I\eTaaMeHeHa per-
.naMeHTaMJ:!. BoJIee Ha,!\emHblMJ1 Moryr 6brI'b I'O'I'OB1IITCIteCfI ,I\onOJIHeHl1.llI:1
Jll3MeHeHIUI B BKPtfJ, JIeHHbIe Ha60Jlee':leTKOe onpe,!J;eJleIDlepa:mo-
Btf)J.HOCTefi BOJ\oeMOB 1:1 BOAQTOKOB.. TaKl1e nonpaBKi4 AOJIiKHbI npeAoT-
BpaTIITb MaccyIX, B03HI1Ka1OIW1XB xo,!\enpJIIMe-
HellWI HOpM BK p<p l .
fuK npe,lG'CMaTpHBaeTCH B CT. 42 BK PtfJ 2006 r., paOOrbl no 1:13MeHe-
HJ1IO 1:1 06yc::rpoiiicTBy IIpJIpOJIH(flJ BO,!J;O€Ma 1:1 BO,!J;(JIUKa npOBO,lUITCJ'I «npY!
YCJXJfllU1 coxpaHeHWI ero ecrecTBeHHcro HJ1JI». am Bbipa-
:HreIDIe KpaHHe HeY,I\a'lHO, n(JIUM)' ':ITO «ecTeCTBE:'HHoe npmHJ1e»
He 3aBHCYIT OT IIOCJIe,IJ;ylOIlV pa60T. 3aKOHO,!laT€'Jlb XOTeJI CKa3aTb, ':11'0
pa60Tbi no J113MeHeIDOO J1Jll1 06ycr BO)J;HOro ofueKTa He ,I\0JDKHb1
npl1BO,!J;IIITb K )'MaJIeHJ1lO ero I1pJtpO.D;HbIX IIOJIe3HOCT€i.1 JIIJIJ1 pa3pyweIDIlO
J1X eCTeCTBeHHbIX B npuae,neHHOH HopMe ynaBJIHBaeTCHlteHHaJ'l
MbICJIb 0 TOM, 'ITO JIKJ60e nepeycrpc&ICTBO BO,!J;oeMa I:IJTIIf BO,!J;01'OKa ,I\OJDI\-
HO y<n1TbIBaTb (J'! no EI03MCOKHOC'nf COXpaHHTb) Bce nOJIe3HbIe CBOHCTBa,
KOTOpblMJ1 OH 06.na.n;aJI,I\O nepeycrpoJrrsa.
IIpY!Be,!J;eHHoe 'I'pE'6cmHJre BK PtfJ mnpaBJIeHO lIpO'I'J1II npCIl3BOJIbID-
ro aanpYml1BaHllii MaJIbIX peR 1:1 py<IbeB, KOTopoe Ha6JIlQrla€TCJ'I B xo.n;e
 6)'Ma» JII 3aBeprnaeTCH npJl!CBoeHYIeM «CBemeY!cn€':leH-
RbIX» Bo,!\oeMoB ':IacTHbIMJI MJ:!. CrreAYeT I:IMeTb B BW, ':ITO 4>e.r:le-
paJlbHbrH3aKOH OT 19 JIIlOHJ'I 2007 r. N2 102-<p3 «0 BHeCeHJ-n1 Jt3M€HE'IDD1
B CTaThU 16 1:119 Bo,IJ;Horo KOAeKCa Poccm1cBxIii: cfIe,!J;epallID1 J'! B CTaTblO 27
3eMeJibHoro KO,!J;eKCa PoccJrl«:KoHcfle,!J;epawmb2 sanpeeT npHBaTIf3a-
J..tI.fiO 3€.M{>./UJlIbiX !fWC7J1K06 nor; npyr;CLMu U 0660&ueHlIbl.MU KapbefKMtU 8
zpa:1I111Ji1X rneppumopuii oI'iupo 'iWJ1.b306UHUJ1.
1 T 3a<oHAlmHOjIPoccHCt:a!lf83eT3..2oo7.27anpeJ1.
2 C3F'<J) 2007 N!!26. Cr. 3075
-18-

3Ta nOnpaBKa B BK P4I JIIMeeT CBoro JIICTOpJlllO. Yme B xo,!\e 06cym-
.r:\emrJl npaeKTa KO)J;eKCa BbICKa3bIBaJIOCb MHeHJlle :mnpeTJIITb npJIIBaTJII-
SaLUllO npY.r:\OB JII KapbepOB IDITbeBOI'O Ha3Ha'1eHIDI. Mem.u.y 'reM, .r:\aJIe-
KO He Bcer.na BO,noeMld, yxasaHHble B HasBaHHOM 3aKOHe, JIIMelOT
IIJIITbeBoe HaSHa'1eHJlle. KpoMe TOro, B CMJIY 6OJIblllOii aHI'pOIDIt'HHOi-i:
HarpY3KJII (peKpealtJllH JII T_.n.) npy,!\b! JII Kapbepbl MOryT 6blCTpo YTpa-
TJ1Tb HOpMaTIfBHOe Ka'1eCTBO BO,!\. IIpJII :aTOM JlC'I'O'iIIHI\aMJII IIJIITbeBOrO
BO,l\OCHB.6meHIDI MOryT c.nymJllTb JII Bo,!\oeMbi BHe npe,!\eJIOB Tepp:wropJlli-i:
o6LII;ero IIOJIb3OBalll1H. B CBJl3J11C 3TJIIMHeo6xo,IJ;JllM0 peWlITb BOIIpOC 0 sa-
npeTe npJIIBaTJII3aI\l1JII IIHTbeBldX no Ha3Ha'leHlDO Bo,noeMOB, He BKJIK}-
'1ellllblX B TeppJIITopJ,HO o6LII;ero nOJIb30BaHJII.II. TaKJIIM 06pa30M, KOppeK-
TItpoBKa BO,!\HOro 11, B03MCOKHO. 3€MeJIbHOI'O 3aKOHO)J;8TeJlbCTBa 6Y.r:\eT
npO,!\OJIiKaTbCJI.
nOpJI,II,OK BO)J;OllUIJb3OBaIDUI B POCCIDL Jlm.{a, teC.H B .r:\0-
CTyne K Bo,!\aM, HO He JlBJIffiOLII;JlleCJI C06CTBellllJllKaMJII BO,!\HbIX 06H'KTOB,
MOryr npJllOOpecTJII npaBo n0Jlb30BamfJI nOBepXHOCTHblM BO)l;HbIM OObeK-
TOMBnopH,!!;Ke, npeOMBKPtfJ, a nOA3eMHbIMBO,!\HbIMOObeK-
TOM - B nopMKe, IIpeJJyCMQI'p€HM S8KOHO,!la'reJIbCTBOM 0 Het\Pax
B CBom O'1epe,IJ;b npaBO co6crseJrnocnl Ha BO,!\Hble o&beKTbl3aKJIa.,!J,bl-
BaeT OCHOay ,l\JIJI nopJi,!\Ka BO,I{OIX)JIb3OBaH npe,!\onpe,neJUl€T ero xa-
paKTepHble '1epTbl JII OCo6ellllOCTJII.
IIopJi,!\OK ar - CJIICTeMa npaBJIIJI paD;JII01IaJIbHOro JIIC-
llQJIh30BaHJll.fi JII OXpaHbI BOAHbIX peCYPCOB. B YSKOM CMblCJIe B nOHJlTJlle
...nopfI.IJ.CIt BOJ\0IIOJIb30BaHJll.fi» BXQMT OCHOBaHi1JI 11 npoQeJl)'pa ocJ:loPMJIe-
IDf.ff 0CGm00I0BeHJll.fI, 113MeHemm 11 npeKpaIQeIDm IIpaB8 n0JIb30BaHWI
BO)J;HblMofu.eKTOM,aT8IOKepa3JiJll<lHbleYCJIOBIDIVI(BTOM
'1Y!CJIe IIJIaTemJII). YcnOBIDI BC\l(UIOJ!b3OBaVi ecrBeHHo ,D;JIIl}xPepeHQJII-
pylOTCJI B 38BJt('I1IIoI)CTi'1 OT l\eJIei-i: BQI:PIOJIbOOI!a (IIJIITbeBoe JII X03ID1CT-
BeHHO--fi,rroBQ BOJ\ocsa6meHJlle, 3JleK'I'pC3HtpreTJllK8, TpaHCTIOpTJII tIP.).
Ee3 nOJlPOOHoro rocy,!lapCTBeHHoro y<IeT8 pocan1:CJtHX BO)I;HblX pe-
CypcOB BpH,!\.ID1 MOmsO I'OBOpl1Tb 06 3cpcpeKTI1BHOM perymtpOO8llll1i1 OT-
HOWeHJIIi1: H rocY,!lapCWeHHOM ynp8BJIeHJ-rn B 06.rracTJII I1C1IOJIb3OBaH1V1 H
oxpaHbI BO)I;HOro  - C'OBOE)'IIHOCTJ BO)l;HblX ofu.eKTOB.
B TO.me BpeMJI c06.mo,!\eHJlle yc.rromm BOWIKJ,1Ib3OB8H JII BQA()OXJmI-
HbIX Tpe6oBaHI-rli npoBepJleTCJI B xOJ\e MCHMTOpUHfR JII KOHTpOJUI B 06.rrac-
TJIIHCI1OJIbJOBaHIfJI t10XpaHbIBO)I;HblX pecypcOB. BCJlY'ffie BblJlBJleHJll.llHa-
pyrneHt1M Bt1HOBHble  K yro.ocmnrii, 8)J;M11HHC'Ipa'I11BH(rii,
"iI1.wIClP1IIJIJrnapHoi-i:crrBeTCTBeHHOCTf. II03TOMJBll.U1poKOM
CMblCJIe nOHJlTJlle «nOpH,!\OK mo OXBaTblB8eT rocy,Il,apcr-
BeHHbrn y<IeT, MOHJllTOpl1HT, KOHTpOJIb JII OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb B 06.rraCTJII HC-
IIO.JIb3()BaHJ,IJI :t1 OXpaHbI BOA
-19-

Ba<KHoe HOBUJeCTBO, OTpameHHOe B BK PtfJ, 3aKJJlO'Iae-rCH B J13MeHe-
HJ1M nop fR. Ynpas,[\HHeTCR .mtlfH3tIpOBaHHe BO,I\O-
n0Jlb30BaHHfl, "ITO 03Ha':lae-r COKpall€lme rocyMpcTBeHllOrO a,I\MIDHICT-
pl1pOBaHI1.fI B c.pepe BO,l\OII0J1b30BaHI1.fI. IIoBblrna€TcH SHa':l€lH-Ie
,AOroBopOB BO,l((II(JJIb3O, KOTOpble J13 BTOpl1'lHOro no OTHOWeHl1IO
.JII.1qeH311J1 npaBOBoro HHCTIrryra npeBpaIllaJOO'CR B nepmPlHblii B pH,!Ie
c.nyqaeB OCHOBaHl1eM 3alOIKReHHH .l\OrOBOpa BO.l\OIIOJIb3OBaID1H craHo-
BHTCH pe3YJlbTaTbl aOHOB. IIop1I,1WK IIpOBe.l\eHJUI aYOHOB J1 38.-
KJIlO'IeID1H Ha J1X OCHOBamrn COOI'BeTCTB}'IOIlI;I-1X .l\OroBopOB OIIpe.Af'}I('HbI
nOCTaHOBneHl1eM IIpaBHTeJIbCTBa PIl> OT 14 anpeJUl2007 f. NQ 230 «0.l\0-
roBOpe BO,I\OnOJlb30BaHI1H, npaBO Ha saKJJlO'IeHl1e KOTOporo npi.106peTa-
eTCSI Ha aoHe, J1 0 I1JXIBe,I\emrn a)'K1\l1oHa»'.
B CT. 17 BK PtfJ 38.KpennHeTCR npaBOBoi1:nopH.I\OK J13Me-
H€HJ1H 11 paCTOpmeHl1.lI .l\OroBOpa BOJ\ClDJIb3IJB&II1f!. CorJJaCHOCT. 450-452
I'K PtfJ H3MeHeIDIe J1 paCTOpmeHl1e .JIOroBOpa B03MOmHbl no COrJlallleHl1IO
caMJ1X CTOpoH.ID1DO no pelIleHI1lO cYllP- B CBH3I1 C 'I'p€6ooam1eM O.l\HOi1: 113
CTOpoH. IIpuMeHeHJle Ha3BaHHbIX n()JJ())KffUm I'K PtfJ, Ha)\O nOJIaraTb,
n03BOJII1T II36emaTb IIpOJ13BOJIbHbIX .n;eiicrernl rocyllP-PCTBeHHbIX opra-
HOB BJIaCTI-I B 06.rraCTJ1 BO.l\HblX O'IHOllEHH¥i. OpraHbl rocyllP-pc'I'EI€IIHOH
BJlacTJ160JJbWe He CMOryr B O)J;HOCTopoHHeM nOpH.I\Ke, MK 3T0 .l\eJlaJiOCb
paHee, cCBOef,i BJlaCTbID» npeKpallViTb npaBa  J1lOpM,JU1'-lec-
KI1X JII1LI Ha JlIcnOJlb3Ol3aHHe BO,!\OTOKOB J'! BO,!\oeMOB.
CoKpaIIJ;eHlile a.JIMIflfltcrpa'I'HBlU"O pery.ID1poBaID1H He ,lJ;OJDKHO .nOMaTb
BCe 6e3 J1CKJllO'IeID1H pa3pelID1T€JIbHble MexaHl13Mb1 1JO,iUJIIO.1Jb31f!.
CorJJaCHOCT. 21-23BK PtfJB pH,!Ie c.nyqaeB, neBHa3BaHHbIX
craTbJlX, coxpaHHeTCH J1HCTI11yr peweHHiii ynOJIHOMO':IeHHbIX opraHOB a
 BO.l\HblX ofrbeKTOB B nOJlb30BaHlile. TaKOe np€.r\OCTaBJIe-
HI1e B03MO<KHO ,!\JIH pa3.ID1'lHbIX HJ'K,JJ;: OT 06ecrre<reHl1H o6opoHbI CTpaHbI
,lJ;O O QTAbIXa ,lJ;eTeK CorJJaCHO BK PIl>, peUJeHHe a npe.r\OCTaB-
.nelOO1 BO.l\HblX OObeKTOB B nOJJb30BaHl1e MOmeT npHWITb He 'I'OJIbKO IIpa-
BJ-ITeJIbCTBOPIl>, HO J1p,pym:erocYMpCTBeHHbleopraHbl 
BJIaCTI1 J1JII1 opraHbI MecTHOro CaMoynpaBJIeID1H.
llAaffl1-lOCfflb  CoxpaHaeTCJI KaKO,I\I1HJ13npl1HllmIOB
06HOBJI€HHOro BO,!\HOro SaKOHO,!\8TeJlbCTBa. IIpl1 3TVM J1MeIm'CR .JIBe CO-
BeprneHHO pa3HbIe $:JPMbl nnaTHOCTI1: BO,lJ.Hbli1: HaJJor (fJIaBa 25.2 «Eo):\-
Hbrn: HaJJOr" lIa.nCKuInu Ko,!\eKca PtfJ) J1 I1JJ8Ta no ycJDBJIHM .l\OroBopa BO-
]IOIlOJIb3OB8Hi1JI (CT. 20 BPi P<P). qTQ6b! J136emaTb «,lJ;BOi1HOro
o6.oomeHIUI" X03Hi1CTB}'IOIlI;I-1X Cym,eKTOB, B HK P<t> He npl13HalO'l'CH
1 C3P$ 2007.N!!17.Cr.2046
-20-

IIJIaTE'JlbI.W1K3.MJ1 BOOro HaJIOra IOpl-Wl'i€CKJle H 4IM3J1tIeCKJiIe ,
ocyrt1eCTB.runO'--W'le BOHMe Ha OCHOBe ,I\OroBOpoB BO,!10nOJIb3O-
BaHJl!JI J1JII-f peweIDfil 0 npe,I\OCTIlBJIeHMI-f BO,!1HbIX 06'beKTOB B nOJlb30Ba-
HJi!e, C(X)'I'Be'I"CT  M npMHJlTblX nOCJIe BBe,I\eIDfJl B,I\eil-
CTBMe BK P<P 2006 f.
IlrraTemJI pewaMeHTI1pyroTCJI cowaCHO noc-rnHOBJIeHHIO IIpaBltTeJJb-
CTBa P<POT 14 ,I\exa6pH 2006 f. N2 764 «06 nf IIpaBMJI pac'le-
Ta HB3MMaIDffillJlaTbI3a n BO,!1HblMJlIo6'beKTar.rn, HaXO)J.ffilJ;lll-
MMCH B 4Ie,!\epaJIbHOil C06C1'BeHHOcTM"I. B ,!IaHHOM IJOC'I'3HOE!JIeHMM
onpe.D.eJIeHbl IIJIaTE'mHbrn- nepHo,!\ J'! llJIaTeJKHafl 6a3a HeHaJIOrOBIdX llJIa-
Temetf, KOHKpeTHbIM pa3Mep KOTOpblX orOBapMBaeTCfl B J1IJ,!JJIBIf,!:JyaJIb-
HOM ,I\oroBope BO)JpIIOJIb3()B
Ellie B xo,!\e pa3pafxma.! BK P<P He pa3 CTaBJfJlCJI BOIIpOC 0 KOMTIeHCa-
ltI10HHOM xapaKTepe IIJIaTemeil 3a BQ,l1OIX)JIb3OBaHt1e. B ,116fC'IBYIOIl\eM
BOOM 3aKOH0,!1aTeJlbCTBe TarorxMeXaHJf3MOB HeT. OaKOHeHaJIoroBaJI
npaBOBaJI npl1pO,!\a IIJIaTE':meil3a 13O,l1OII01Ib301e n03BOJ1fleT rocy,!\ap-
CTBY BKJIa)J.b1BaTb ,!IaHHble Cpe,!\CTBa B BQrIOOX})8HHble MeJX!IIPHflTIiI Or-
MeTMM, 'ITO n0,!106HaJI npaKTI1Ka }':me J1MeJla MeCTO - KpaTKOe BpeMJI
fJ)OO8.HJI.fIlteJleBblX 61O,!1}KeTHblX H,!\OB BOCCTIlHOBJIeIDffl J'!
OXpaHbI BO)1JlbIX 06'beKTOB cor.naCHO IX)J!(O!{eIDfHM BK P<P 1995 r. B Ha-
CTOJlII.lee BpeMfl OqeHb BaJKHO, 'IT06blllJlaTa 3a OO,I\Ol1WIb3OBaIDle o6ecrre-
'DfBaJIa Mepno EIOC'C'J'aH:)BJJ'!oxpaHe BO,!1
B lIOCJIe,I\Hee BpeMfl pa3pa6aTblBalOTcJI nporpaMMbI, HaIIpaBJIeHHble
Ha MOJIeptul3aqMlO H peKoHcTpYKlt"1O CJ1CTeM B0,!1ocH86:meHI1JI H BO,!100T-
Be,I\eHIfH. 3To BJIe'leT If Ht:'06xoIM(]CTb iPMHaHcnpoBaID1H Mep no oxpa-
He H BOCC'ffiHOWIeHJ'!IO 1fC1U'lHJ1KOB B0,!10CHa6:memrn - car.rnx BOblX

IIpaBoBoii pemllM n(),l13eMHl>lX BO)J,. B npeaM6yne 3aKOHa P<P OT
21 4JeBpaM 1992 f. N2 2395-1 «0 HeJlPax,.2 3aKpeIlJI€HO. ..:TO B ,I\aHHOM
3aKoHe pery.IDfH 0'I'Ii)lli€ffi1fl, B03HJ1KaIO'--W'le B CBfl3M C reoJIorwre-
CKI1M H3y<1eHJf{'M, rx:nruIb3QBaIDIeM H oxpaHmf H€)q) TepPHTOpMI1 Poc-
CIi<PeAeparvrn:H KOHTI1HeHTaJIbHorollleJlbcJ:la. B TOM 'iJIIcne BCBfl311
C HCnOJlb30BaHMeM m€1tJ:$Jt'I€CKJ'IX Mill:IepaJlbHbIX pecypCOB, BKJIIO'laH
f1O,lJ;3€MHbIe BO,!\bI, paCCOJIbI If parry COJIJIHblX 03ep, 3aJIJ1BOB Mopeii Co-
fJIaCHO CT. 1.2 3aKOHa P<P «0 He]J;pax" He,Qpa B rpaHJl!Qax TeppJITOPMI1
Poccm1cKm1: <Pe.neJXil\l'D'l, BKJllOQaR n0,!13eMHoe npocrpaHCTBo H CO,!1ep-
m8.I.qI1€CR B He,Qpax £()Jre3HbI€ JfCKOnaeMbIe. 3Hepre-rw-l€CKille Jf JfHbIe pe-
1 C3FW 2006. N!!51. Cr. 5467
2 C3FW.1995.N!!10.Cr 823
-21-

CypCbl, HBJlflIOTCH roCY.MpcweHIJ:)j.j co6cTBeJrnocTbro IIpaBa nOJib30Ba-
HJUI He,!\paMJ1 MOr)'T 0T'1YTbCH HID! nepeXO,!J;>1Tb Uf O,!\HOm JIJU.la K
.n;pyrDMY B wil Mepe, B KaRoil J1X 06opm' ,QrnyCKaeTCH rPe,!J;epaJlbHblMJll
3aKOHaMH. Cne.n;yeT nOHCHI1Tb, "ITO yqacTKI1 He)q) BMemaKYr B Ce6H" no,!\-
3eMHble BO):\bL
I1TaK, nO,!\3eMHble BO):\b1 OTHeCeHbl K cneLlJl!ln:f'IeCIOfM MMHepaJlbHbIM
pecypcaM He)q)" HaXO,!\.HTCH B roCY.MpcmeHHOii coOCTBeHHOCTI-f.. O,!\HaKO
CJlellYeT 3aMeTl1Tb, "ITO B ,I\eiiic'rByKuteM 3a.KOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBe 0 He1J,pax
rrpl1MeHJIeTCH CJI()B(('.()'l€HI-1e «nO,!\3eMHb1e BO,!\bI», a He «IIO,!\3eMHble
BO,!\Hble oO'beKTbI». 3ro WbfICHHeTCH TeM, qTO B aaKOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBe 0 He-
.n;pax I1O,JJ,3€MHbIe BO):\b1 paCCMaTpHBalOTCH KaK 1:13BJleKaeMbriiJ pecype, a
He KaKrrpI1pO,lJ;lloe05pa3Oll8HJre,  B 3all\l1Te, qTO 3aMeTHO
orpaHl-1'1J11BaeT BCGMO:IKHOC111 OXpaHbl m,!\3eMHbIX BO,!\.
B BK P<P ycmHaBJIJ'1BaKT HeKOTOpble rrpJ13HaKJ1 rrpaBOBOm pe:arn-
Ma nO,!\3eMHbIX BO)J;Hb1X 06'beKTOB. B qaCTHOCTI1, rrpe.n;yCMaTpl1BalOTCH
pe3epBHp::eaHHe I:ICTQ'lHi1KOB ID1TheBOm BO,!\OCHa6iKeHH.II Ha 6ase 3a-
ll\eHHblXUf 3arpJI3Hemml13acopemrn nO,!\3eMHbIX BO.!\., MOHI:ITopI1lITno,!\-
3eMHbIX BO,!\. O,!\HaKO UfHOWeHJIJI no nOBo.I\Y nO,!J;3eMHblX BO)J;HbIX OObeK-
TOB peryJIl1pylOTCH rJIaBHbIM 06pasoM 3aKOHO,!laTeJlbCTBOM 0 He.D;pax,
KOTOpoe caMO HaXO,IJ,JI'IUI Ha CTa;:J;J1l1 06HOBJIeID:!Jl.
TpY,WIOCTI1 C nOID:!MaHl1eM 11 co6.mo,l\£'1IJ1eM rrpaBOBom pe:iKl1Ma no,!\-
3eMHblX BO)J;HbIX 06'beKTOB Ha"Il1HalOTCH "3-3a Heorrpl?,I\eJlf2HH()('Tj:l J1X
rpaID:!Q KaE npe,nMeTOB rrpaBa co6cTsemIocTII. KaK urMeqaJlOCb B IOpl1,l\l1-
'leCl\D]:f Jll1TepaType, 6bLJIO 11 OCTaeTCH HeHCHblM,11.0 KaKl1X npe)J;eJlOB rop-
:;o;::===:=::rC:;::::5
BK P<P rpaHl-1Qbl llO,!\3eMHbIX BO)J;HbIX WbeKTOB onpeAe.rr.moTCfI B COQT-
BeTC'IBlnl C 3a.KOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBOM 0 He,D;pax. O,wiaKo B 3aKOHO,!laTeJlbCTBe 0
He.n;pax nOKa HeT OTBeTa Ha STOT BOnpoC.
,lIaHHbrn: BOnpOC M<m\.€T nOKa3aTbCH nOKa HeCBoeBpeMeHHbIM, TaR: KaK
He,rrpa EICflteOO. BKJIfO'IaH nO,!\3eMHble aaITaCbI BO.!\., npl1Ha}VIemaT O,!\HOM)'
:)(()3j'Umy» - roCY.MPCTBY_ II03TOM)' nOA3eMHbIe BO,!\Hble ofueKThl KaK
6b1 Tep.ffiOTCfI B 06ll\eM MaCCMBe roCY.MPCTBeHHOil co6cmeHHOCTI1 Ha He-
.n;pa. OJ\HaKO C pa3BHTl1eM PblHQ'lHbIX OTIOIIeHU:K B 06JraCTIf rrpI1pO,!J;O-
nOJlb30BaH:l1H nO,!J;3eMHb!e BO,!\Hble Wbet\TbI Mor)'T C'raTb npe,!J;M€TOM ,!\O-
roBOpa A06bI'lJ1 nO,!J;3eMHblX BO.!\., rrpe.I\YCMOTpeHHoro npoeK'rJ1pyeMbIM
ropHbIM 3aKOHO,!laTeJlbCTBOM. B .mo6oM cJI}"Iae He06xo;:J;l1Mo 05ecrre'ffiTb
3ROHOMHoe «» BOAOIIOJIb3OBaIDIe.
I f.B1Iop,eKCeC3!e.tI.epalJ.HHII3aKOHQp,arebCTBQI1'O-
-22-

He OIIpe,l\€JleHHbIe IOpl'Ul,Jl'1€CKJl BHYTpeHHee c'IpOeIDIe J'! rpaHl1L\bI
nO):(3eMHblX BO):(HbIX o&beRTOB MaJlO noxo:»a:l Ha nOBepxllOCTIlble BO):(OTO-
KJ'!" BO):(oeMbI. KaRH:meCTHO J13 noreoJIOI11l-1 (Ha)'Ka 0 nO.D;3eMHblX Bo-
.flax), no.fl 3eM.IIE'Jf BO;:J;HaR Macca cOJ\epmwrcJ'l B caMOM lIJIaCTe nopo,l:\bl (B
TaR Ha3bIBaeMOM BCJWHOCHOM CJIoe), a He 06pa3}'eT BO,[lHylO TOJIlllY, KaR B
peKaX J1 03epax.
J1cKJIIO':IeHJ1e COCTaBJIHIOT .fIOBOJlbHO pacnpOCTpaHeHHble KapCTOBble
BO.L\Hble 06'heKTbl. Omr He TOJIbRO CBJ'/3aHbI, HO J1 CXO:»a:l C lKI3epxHOCTHbl-
MJII BOJ\(Jf()KaMJII J1 BOJ\oeMaMJ1, TaK KaR J1MelOT CBOIO BO,[lHylO TOJIlllY. KaK
Jf3B€CTOO, KapCT - pacTBopeHJ1e " BbeJIa'll1BaHHe ropHbIX nopo,l:\ Bo-
.fIOIO, BJIeKytW1e OOpa3OBaHJle «J1()]:\3eMHl£{» py<IbeB, peR J1 03ep. ITh1po-
KO pacnpoCTpaHeHHble B CTpaHaX CHI', OHH .HB.runOTCJ'I 06t1JIbHbIMH J1 He-
:B=R;.fIB
B qeJIHX qeTtWroOIIpe.JleJJ€ffi1JIWheltTa npaBOBC&1 OXpaHbI6yeTCH
yro'llieHHe B 41e,IJ;epaJIbHOM 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBe rpaHI1L\ If CTpyKTypbI
nO):(3eMHblX BO.L\HbIX c6l.eKroB. OreBl-UJ;lIO, 'ITO rpa J1 CTpylITypa
nO):(3eMHoro BO.L\HOro MeRTa 6yAYT CoornOCMTbCJI C IpaHJ1L\ei1 ropHOro
(".ID1reo.J1OCH'reCKO) arBO. KpoMe TOro, HnpeoAOneTh npo-
6eJ1bl B ropHOM If BO.L\HOM 3aKOHOJ\aTeJIbCTBaX arHOCJ1TeJIbHO nop.H,I:\Ka "C-
nOJIb30BallliH nO):(3eMHblX BO.L\HbIX 06'beRTOB, B TOM 'll1CJIe KapCTOBbIX..
3. .QOroBOPHbIE H PA3PEWHTEJlbHbIE
MEXAHH3Mbi PErYHPOBAHH BO.Qononb30BAHH
J\yxIvIoH:Y II ]l.OroBOpbl BO,IJ;OIIOJIb3(E'UIJIH. B BK Pet> ynpa3):1HReTCJ'I
CTaBlllee npHBbNHblM ,l1JI.H BO,!\HOro X03J'IiiicTBa npoBaHJle BO,!\O-
n0JIb30BallliH, Ha OCHOBe KOTOporo paHee 3aI(Jll(J'IBJItlCl> ,l\000B0pbI BO,!\O-
IIO.YIb3OBaHIIJI. IIpol1cxo)J;lllT COKpal1\eHl1e roCY.JI3pcTBeHHoro a;:r;t.rnHlilC1'-
pHpoBaHI1.fI B pacCMa'I'pl1BaeMoi1 cfi.rraCTIL B BK Pip }'Be.ID1'111BaeTCH
3Haqemle " pacllD1pHeTCH BO.'3MCOKIJ:)C' npJ1MeHeHI1.fI ,IJ;OrOBOpoB BO):(o-
nOJIb30BallliH, KOTopble"3 BTOpJI'ffiOI"O IIJ:6BOOOIO "HCnrryra npeBparua-
IOTCH B nepBl-I'ffibrlii.
B HaCToee BpeMH OCHOBaHJteM .JIJIH 3aKJllOQellliH .fIoroBopa BO):(o-
lIOJIbOOBaHJtH CTaHOBHTCJI pe3YJlbTaTbi OTRpbITblX aYKL\lIOHOB. IIOpH,l:\OK
npoBe):(eHHR a)'KL\J'l0HOB"  Ha J1X OCHOBaHlilH COOTBeTCTBYK>-
IqIIIX c):(eJIOR onpe.r:\eJIeHbI nOCTaHOBJIeHHeM IIpaBHTeJIbC'I'BB Pet> OT
1'-1H.A.KBpcTMMbIGJ1b,1981.C.7-17.
-23-

14 anpeJIH 2007 T. N2 230 «0 .n;ofoBOpe BO,D;OllCJ.JIb3OBaID1Jl, npaBO Ha 3a-
K.JIIO'lelUte KOTOporo npHoOpeTaeTcJ'I Ha aYKill"0He. J1 0 nPJBeneHIfll ayx-
ltwOHa»l.
OpraID:!3aWpaMJ1 a}'KQJ10Ha HBJIHlOTCH CJIe.Il}'1OI.lJ;JIIe opraHbl BJIaCTH:
1) <Pe.n;epaJIbHoe areHTCTBO BO.D;HbIX peCypCOB J1JIJ1 ero Teppl'1'I'C{M8Jlb-
lIble opraHbI - B UI'lIlliIeIDDi HaXOCH B ,l\£'pa.1IbHOii c06cTBeHHo-
CTJII B011P:xpaHMJII nepeqeHb KOTOpblX ymepm,lJ.8eTCH IIpaBl1'I'eJIbCT-
BOMPocci:mrnml€PeJJ;epaL\l1J1, a TaKme MopeiiiJ1JlM I1XUfJJ;eJIbHblX"ffiCTeiii;
2) opraH J1C00JIHI1TeJibHOI1 BJIaCTI:! cy6'b€KTa PoccMi'icKOiii 4:tet\epal\l1J'f,
yrH)JIHOMO'l€I! Ha 3aKJllOQelille .nOroBOpoB BOJPlO1lb3OB8ID1H, - B Uf-
HOllIeHffi1 BO)J;HbIX WheKTOB, 1XCJ'i B COOCTBeHHOCTI1 Cy6'b€'KTOB
 cpe)\epau;IDl, 11 BO)UIbIX 06DeKTOB J1JIJ1 HX 'lacTeiii, HaXOWI-
UV1XCJ! B <pe.nep8JIbHOii COOCTBeHHOCTJII H paHHblX Ha Teppl1TO-
pilli cy6beKTOB PoccJfi'lCI«JIl€Pe.n;EpaL\l1J1, 3a J1CKJI}()'1€}flreM BOblX o&b-
ettTOB, yrcasaHHblX paRee;
3) opraH MeCTHoro caMoynpaRJIeID1Jl - B 0'IHJllEHHJ'I BO.D;HbIX 06DeK-
TOB, H8XOCH B Co6cTBeHHOCTH MJHI1lUfi18JIbHOro OOpa30B8IDfJI.
IIpH npOBe.neHJrn a}'KQJ10Ha He .n;onyCKaeTCJ'I:
- C03,!\aIDIe npeJ1MYlL\eCTBeHlIblX yc.m:EJ1iii AJIH Uf,l:\eJIbHblX JIJ1LI J1JIJ1
rpynnJlJ1Ll,BWM'll1CJ1e,I:\OCTJTIaKJof,!\eHQtfaJIbHOiii
J1Hq:.opMaL\ffi1;
- ocyIl\ecTBJIeID-le OpraHl13aWpOM a)'KlUlOHa KOop,[lJ1 JJ;emeJib-
HOCTH yqaCTHUKOB aOHa. B pe3y,m,Tare KaropoJ::i: OIpaHWBfBaeTCJ'I
.mIDO MOme1' orpaHWnflJaTbCH IH Mem;ry yqaCTlillKaMY! ayx-
ltwOHa WIJII yr.w:M.1lmOTC.fl J1X HHTepOCld;
- Heo6ocHOBaHHoe 0IJXUDttreID1e ,l:\OCTyna K yqaCTI1lO B ayKQJxme.
IIpe,1\MeTOM aOHa HBJIHeTCJ! npaBO Ha 3aKJllO'IeHHe 11PI'OBOpa 00-
1H.IIO,[lfOTOBKanpoeKTa,l:\OroBOpaBO,[l{IIDJlb.'JOOaIDIHJ1<PoP-
MJ1pOBalille ero YCJlOBIDl OC}'llIeCTBJUIIOTClI C y«eTOM oco6eHHocreH npe-
JJ;0CTaBJIHeM)1U B lIWIb3OBaIDIf' BO):\HOro o6DeKTa J1 era pemHMa,
Inp 11 3aIlpeTOB, yCW]lIJWIeHHbIX B OTHOllleHI1I1 HCIJOJIb3OBaHIm
BO.rr;HOro o&beKTa, a TaJOKe C y«eTOM yrBepm,!\eHHblX cxeM KOMI1.IIE:'RCII
Iw:n0JIb30BaHKflI1 OXpaHbI BO)J;HbIX o&beKTOB 11 TepplrIOpl8JIbHOTO IIJ!aID-I-
poBaID-IH. BblHCHReTCH, JJ;OnyCTMMOJlJ1 J1CInJIb3(E8IIIle aKBaTOpllli BO):\HO-
ro MeRTa ,IJ,J1H TOif L\eJUf, KOTOpaH yrta3aHa npereH,!\eHTOM B efO 3aJiBJIe-
HJ1I1oaKBawpIlliBo):\Horo06'beKTaBlIOJIb3OB8IDIe.
OpraID13a'l'OpaYKLl"'OHaB TeQeHJ1€' 15 .v;Heiii C ,u,aTbIIlOC'IyIIJIeHJ1Jl3aJIBJIe-
lill.fI a npe,l1OCTaBJ1eID1i11 aKBaTOpID1 BO)J;HOro 06neKTa B IIOJTh30BaHI1e J13Be-
I C3P<112007.NI!17.Cr.2046
-24-

IQaE'T 3aJIIDITeJ1H 0 ,u,aTe npoB!,!\eIDm aJKU;l1OH8.. eHHbill: rrpoeKT
.r:\oroBOpaBO,[((JlDJIb3CEBKJIlO'IaeTCRB,!\oK)'MelITa06aoHe.
IIp" 3aI\.IIlO'1€HJU1 ,!\OroBOpa BQ[IOIDHb3OBallliH no pe3}'JlhTaTaM aYK-
ltI'IOHa He ,nOrryCKaE'TCH BHeCeHJ1e H3MeHemrn- B ycJDBJIH .r:\OroBOpa nyreM
oc06oro CorJIallIeIDm Me)K,!]y c-ropOHaMJII 3TOro ,norOBOpa J1Jll1 B O,!\HOCTO-
poHHeM nDpJl,!\Ke. Co,!\epmaHJ1e .r:\OroBOpa Bo,!\on0JIb30BaHJ1.H .r:\OJDKHO CQ-
OTBeTCTBOBaTb -rpe60B8mmM BO,!\Horo KO.r:\eKC8 P<P.
Heo6x 0CH0BaIIJmMJ'r.wm 3aKJIlO'IeIDIH ,!\OroBOpa BO.r:\onOJIb-
3OBaHI1H HBJ1HKYfCH:
- 1IpOT0KOJI 8)'KlJ;>10Ha, apopM.Jll2Hllbflf B COO'I'B€'I"crBMI C IIpaBI-1JI8MJ11
IIpOBe,!\emm 8)'KlJ;>10Ha no np"06peTeIDIIDnpaB8 H8 3aIUJIOIleIDie )J;OroBG-
pa BO,!\OIIOJIb'30B£iHHJI, yrBepm,!\eHlIbIMJiI IIOCTaHOBJIeHJleM IIpmmTeJIbCT-
B8P<POT 14anpeJ1H 2007 r. N2230;
- ,noK)'MeHT, nO;rrBepm,!\8lOIlI;ffif onJUrry no6e.I:\J1T€JI€M 8)'KLlHOH8
npe,IJ;N!eTa 8)'KlJ;>10Ha B Te'lemle 10 pa60'lllX ,/J;HeH, CJIe.ZJYlOLII;I1X 3a ,u,aTOH
3aBepweHJ1.H aYKII;J-IOH8, nyreM nepe'lJliCJIeHI1H ,neHemHbIX Cpe.nCTB B pas-
Mepe OKOH'ffiTeJIbHOH eHb!npe.nMeT8 a}'KQJMJHa Ha C'leT, YK8-S8HHbrn: op-
1'8HJt:!38TOpOM ayKI\lWHa, C yqeTOM BHeCeHHOrO 38}1aTKa
B CT. 13 BR P<P 2006 r. Ha3BaHhI c.YU.\ecTBeHHhIe YCJIOBI1H ,!\OroBOpa
BQ[((IlOJlb3OB8HJlIH. IIpem,!\e Bcero 3TO npe,!\MeT .r:\OroBOpa, T.e. caM BO,!\-
Hhrn: ctYbeRT J1IDI ero 'laCTb. B ,!\OroBOpe .r:\O.IDKHbI 6bITb )'Ka38HhI 6epero-
BM IDIHIDI, CJIymaIQaH IpiiBO,!\HOrO 06'beRTa, J1Jll1 me rpamlU,bI'Ia-
CT" BO,!\HOro 06'heKTa (3aBO,!\b, 38TOH, nJIec, p)'KaB). 3aKoHO,!\8TeJlb
npM3H8eT ueOOxOAJlIMblM YK8-3bm8Tb B ,o;OroBOpe lj;eJlli, Ern)J;bI J1 YCJIOBI1H
11CI100000000IDIH BO,!\HOro 06'heRTa, B TOM 'lJ1CJIe 06'heM .r:\OIIYCTJliM(II{J 3860-
paBO)J;bL
IIo.r:\ lj;eJlHMJ1 BQI:(OI1OJIb3OB JlMelOTCH B B>r,n;y IDITbeBOe J1 X03JrliCT-
BEtIHO--6blTOBOe Bo,!\ocua6meIDIe, c6poc CTO'IHbIX (.npeHamHbIX) BO,!\, npo-
3JJeK'IpK'-Iearoj;j:3HeprJnl, ,o;eHTeJIbHOCTbBO,!\HoroIilB03JIY111HG-
ro TpaHC!IOpT8, .neCOCf1JIaB, peKpe8l\l1JI, pt.I6oncecTBO iii OXOT8, pa3Be,!\Ka
J1 ,!\06bI'18 nOJIe3HhIX J1Cl\OnaeMbIX, o6ecne<letme nomapHoi16e30nacHoc-
TH, 38IW1Ta JICKOHHCJii cpe)J;b! 06J11TaHIDI J1 -rp<I,JJ;KW101llIOCO 06pa38 >KJ13HJ1.
IIo.r:\ Bu,IlaMJII BOWIlOJIb3(JlIaHW nOHHMalOTCH  J1Jll1 060c06-
JIeHHOe 13O,IJ,OI1OJIb3.
Yl\a3bIBaeTCH CpoK .J\OroBOpa BO.JIOI1(JJIb3OBaIH, KOTOpbill: corJI8CHO
CT_ 14 BR P<P, He MOmeT 6bITb 60nee 20 JIeT. IIo BR P<P 1995 r. ,lJ;OroBOpbl
,o;o.mucp:NHOro BOJ(orrOJIb30BaHI1B MOrJII1 3a1\JIIO'<8TbCfI M8KCI1M)'M H8
25 JIeT. TaKi1M 06pa3oM, S8KOH0,!\8T€JIb B ,[\8HHOM BOnpoce noweJI H8 co-
Kp8IL1emre npe.neJIbHoro CpoM.
B ,lJ;oroBope ,nO.IDKHbI Tb pa3Mep, YCJIOBIDIIiI CpoKJI BHe-
ceIDIH nJIaTbI 3a BOpprnJIb30BaHMe. CorJIaCHO CT. 20 BR P<P I1Jl8Teml1 B
-25-

paMKaX )J;OI'OBOpa oo,!\on0JIb30BaHJ1H ,!\0JDKHbI CTI1M)'JrnPOBaTb 3KOHOM-
HOe HCnOJIb30BaHl1e 11 OXpaHY BO,!\HbIX 00beIcrw; 3T1-f nJIaTe:lKl1 ,IJ;J11}xPe-
peHYKYrCH B 3aBJ'ICJ'IMOl"l'Jf OT pe'IHoro 6acceillia. R cyr.u;eCTBeHHbIM
YCJIOBHHM ,!\OroBOpa BO,lJ;OIlOJIb3OBaHJ1H arnOCHTCH TalOKe OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTb CTOpoH 3a HencIIOJIHeHKe J1JIJ1 HeHa.n;.rre:>Kall\ee J1CIIOJIHeHJE CBOHX
06H3aTeJThCTB (IIrJP<Utlbl, neIDI 11 T.]1.). B )J;oroBope onpe.ne.nHeTCH nopH,1J;OK
npeKpall\eWrH nOJlb30BaHJ1H BO)J;HbIM WbeKTOM.
B l\eJrOM npHBe,IJ,€HHbIe HHbIe YCJlOBHH ,!\OroBOpoB BO,!\O-
n0JIb30BaHJ1H nOBTopmar YCJIOBI1H .n;OroBopoB nWIb3OBaHl1H BO;:J;HbIMJ1
o6'beKTaMJ-I, npe.n;ycMO'lPEHHbIMJfCT. 49, 57 BRP<P 1995 r. (Tor.n;a OHI1COB-
IIaJ\aJIJ1TaIOKe C InJI())K{'IDIJIMR eH3JllJf).
O,!\HaICo B HOBOMBR Plp6blJIO ynYIl\eHoTaKOeyCJIOID1e .n;oroBCpoB BO-
,D;OIJ:)JIb3OBaH, KaK cnoc06blBO.n;OlI01Ib3OBaHHJL ComaCHO CT. 85 BK Pip
1995 r. J1CIIOJIb3OBaHJIe BO.D;HbIX 06DeKTOBnO,Ilpa3yMeBaJIOCb JII160 C 113'10-
HTl1eM (3a60p0M BO;:J;bI), JII160 6e3 113'bJ1THH (c6poc, J1CIlOJIb3OBaII B Ka-
'leCTBe BO,!\HbIX nyTei-1 l1.I\p.). CorJIaCHO CT. 38 BK P<P 2006 r. BO,!\01I0JIb30-
BaHl1e no.npa3YMeBaeT Tpl1 cnoc06a: BO,!\OIIOJIb3OBaHJf€ C 3a60poM
(Jf3'b.HTI1eM) BO,!\HbIX pecypcoB Jf3 BOAHOro 06DeKTa np}! YCJIom1]lj B03Bpa-
Ta BO, 3a60p (J13'bJ1T1-fe) BOAHOro pecypca Jf3 BOAHOro 06DeKTa 6e3 003-
BpaTa BO,!\bl, BO,l\OI1OJIb3OI3ale 6e33a60pa (J13'bHTID!) BO.D;HbIX pecypCOB
J13 BO,!\HbIX Om.eKTOB. 3a60p BO;:J;bl np}! ycnomm ee B03BpaTa Tpe6yeT OT
BO,[IOIlOJIb3(JBaTeJlei-1 6onwIoii: UIBe'I'CTBeHHOC Be,IJ;b Heo6xo.n;m.Ia 0'll1-
CTIm c6paCblBaeMoi-1 BO,i:\bL
IIol\olJ1MO npl1Be,i:\eHHblX ycnomrli, KOTOpble HerIpeMeHHO .I\OJIjtQIbl6blTb
yxB.3aHbl B .I\OrOBOpe OO,!\OTIOJI:b3OOaHI1H, CTopOHbl MOryr no CBoeM)' yCMO-
TpeHI1lO 3aKpelll1Tb B .I\OI'OBOpe H J1Hble yCJIOBHH. B STOM 6y.I\eT npOHB-
JUITbCH J1H11L\J1aTI1Ba CTOpoH, IJU3BaIIHaH KOIrKpe11lbll'4Jll X03J!iiK.-rneHHbl-
MJ1 06cT0Hre.JlbC'l'BaMlL
B l\eJIOM C011€J»K<lHHe .I\OroBOpoB BO,l\OIIOJIh3CEIJI .I\OJIjtQIO OTpa.maTb
npaBa JiI cfuI3aHHccn1 EIOJIOIl()JIb3OTeJIeii, npep;y<'MOTpeHHbl€ CT. 39 BR
P<P2006r.B'l8C'IE0CTII,o6H3aHbIHa6JllO,!IaTb3aBo,!\-
HbIMJ1 06DeKTaMJ-I 11 npJ Bo,!\ooxpaHHbIMJ1 30HaMJ1, CBoeape-
MeHHO ocyIi.\ec'I'BJUITb MepOTIpI1HTHH no npe.uynpem.n;eIDflo 11 JIJ1KB-
1.\1111 'ipe3Bl:l'XlHHblx Cl1ryal.\l1i-1 Ha OO,!\HbIX 06'beKTax, co,!\epmaTb B
I1CnpaBHOM COCTOmIl1I13KcnnyaTI1pyeMble I1MJ1  I1I'11,!ijX1I'eXHf-
'leCKMe coopYiKeID-m, BeCTI1 }"leT 06DeMa 3a60pa II c6poca BO,!\HbIX pe-
CypCOB. lIpl1 3TOM ,MHHble CBOHX peryJIJIPHbIX lffi6mD,!:\eHIDI.I1 yqem BO-
J];OIX)JIb3OBaTeJlb 06fl3aH cBoeapeMeHHo 11 6eCILJIaTHO rrpe.I\CTaBJUITb B
ynOJiHOMO'leHfIbli,i opraH.
CornaCHO CT_ 12 BK P<P 2006 r. )J;oroBopHbIe OTHOllIeHI1H npl1 nOJlb-
30BaHI1M BO)J.HblMI1 06'beKTaMJ1 nO)J.IJa)1alOT no,i:\ .I\ei1:cTBl1e rpa:Hi,!\aH-
-26-

CKora TeJIbCTBa (nOJIOiKeHl-1fl 06 apeIUJ;e). B 3TOM BK P<P no-
BTOpJleT nOJlomem-m CT. 54 BK P<P 1995 r. O.QHaIw .Qeik'rBHe rpam.r\aH-
CKo-npaBOBoro I1HCTJIITyra apeH,!\bl B03MO:arn0 JlJIIWb B TOM CTeneHJII, B
KarOpoM O He IIpOTJ1BOpe'lJIT BK P<P 11 cyCTBY .QoroBopa BO,1:\O-
nrulli3OBaHH&
B TO me BpeMJI 3aKJIa):\bIBaeTCJI Ba:!KHbI:W CTi1MYJI nOOII-IPeHJIIJI ,lJ;06po-
COBeCTHhIX H  BOWIIOJIb3(JBaTeJIeH. CorJlaCHO CT. 15 BK P<P
BOJ:nIOJIb30Bs:reJIJII, HSAJIe:maIIJ;JIIM 06pa3oM J1CIIOJiHHBlIIJ CBOJII 06J13aH-
HOCTJII, B c.rryqae ernUJ cpoKa .QeHCTBJIIJI .QoroBopa coxpaHHKYr lIp€-
JtM.YIlI€CT&'HHO£' rrepe,n; ,n;pyrl1M .rnrn;OM rrpaBo Ha mle ;QOroBOpa
BOJPIOJIb3OBaHJUJ Ha HOBbm: cpoK. IIpI1 3TOM YCJJOBJIIJI ;QOroBOpa BO)];o-
J1OJIb3OBaHIUI MOryr 6bITb 1i13MeHeHb! no corJIaweHJlIO CTOpoH. OwraKo
rrpe npaBa OOWIIOJIb3(JBaTeJIeH .QeMCTB}'IOT TOJIbKO B
TOM c.rryqae, ecJIl1 .QOroBOp He 3aKJilO':leH no pe3YJlbTaTaM aYKJ.\JIIOHa. Ta-
KI1M 06pa30M, .QaHHhm: CTi1MYJI .r:\lliI LI06pocooecrHOIU BOJIOII01!b3OOaHJUI
orpaHWIeH Ha3BaHHbIM YCJJOBHeM.
IIpaBO aaKJIIOQaTb ,n;orOBOp BO)];0110Jlb30Bam1H npm1CTeKaeT 113
nOJlHOMo'u:!i,j c06CTBeHHmUl. B nOJlHOMO'lHR opraHOB roCY.QapCTBeHHOH
BJiaCTlIJ: POCCI-fHCKOH €Pe.QepaWIJ'I BXO,!\JlT BJla.n;eIDIe, nOJlb30Bam'Ie II!
pacnOpmKeHJlle BO,!\HbIMJII 06'beKTaMJII, H8XO,!\JIlQJllMJIICJI B 41e.QepaJlbHOH
C06CTBeHHOCTJII. AHaJlOI1t<1Hb1e nOJIHOMO'lJIIJl yrBepm,JJ;aIOTCJI aa opra-
HaMJII roCY.QapCTBeHHoH BJiaCTI1 cy6'beKTOB POCCHHCKOH €Pe.Qepal\l1J11 H
OpraH8MJII MeCTHoro caMoyrrpaBJIeHJII.fi OTHOCJIITeJIbHO BO,!\HblX 06'beK-
TOB, HaxO,!\JIJlJ,JllxC.fi COOTBeTCTBeHHO B peI11OH8JlbH011 IIIJIJII MYHIIIqI1-
naJIbHOH co6cTBeHHocTI1 QwIaKo B OTHOllleHJIIJII BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTOB, Ha-
xO,!\JlLIJ;I1xcn B 41e.QepaJlbHOH co6CTBeHHOCTJII, .QoroBopbl H8 IiIX
HCllOJlb3OBaHHe .QaJleIW He Bcer.Qa 6y.r:\YT aaKJTIO'IaTb 41e.QepaJlbHbre
opraHbI. B BK P<P rrpe,DyCMO'lJX'H ME'xaID1:3M nepe.n;a'1I-i ocyr.u;eCTBJle-
HI1.fi OT,IJ;eJIbHbIX 41e,lJ;epaJlbHblx IIOJIHOMO'1I1fi: perl10HaJIbHbiM opraH8M c
norarneH11eM B03Hm(.aIOllUX npl1 :'.!TOM 3aTpaT (perIl!OHOB IiI.lUI MYHIIIqI1-
naJIlITeTOB) 3a C'leT cy6BeHQII!H 11!3 41e.QepaJlbHoro 6IO,!\meTa. B cJly..ae
rrepe,!\a'111 OTeJlbHbIX nOJIHOMO'lI-iH opraHbI roCY.QapCTBeHHOH BJIaCTI1
cy6'beKToB 4Je,!\epaQl1l1 6y.r:\YT npe,!\OCTaBJlJITb B ,IJ;OrOBOpHoe nOJ!b30-
BaH11e Bowrble o&beKTbI, HaXO,!\JILIJ;l1eCH Ha IiIX TeppJl!TOpmr, O,!\HOBpe-
MeHHO OHI16Y.r:\YT OTBe'-laTb aa rrpOBe,l\eHl1e BO)];OOXpaHHbIX Meponpl1J1-
TI1i1: 11 Mep no npe,l\OTBpalQeHl1lO Bpe)J.Horo B03,lJ;ei1:CTBI1.JI BO)];. TeM He
MeHee, corJlaCHO CT. 24, 26 BK pq,<pe,!\epaJlbHbIe opraHbI onp€J\eJLfIIOT
nOpJl,!\OK no,!\rOTOBKII! iii 3aKJIllNeHII!JI ,IJ;OroBopoB Bo,!\onOJlb30BaHl-1H, ec-
.ID1 OHII! McamCR 05'beKToB <pe,!\epaJlbHoii: co6cTBeHHOCTIr, OHJII :IRe
KOHTpOJlI1PYIOT rrpaBI1J1bHOCTb paCXO)];OBaHJII.H Bbl,!\eJleHHbIX cy6BeH-
",",.
-27-

B OJCTrneTCTBJBI CO CT. 16 BK P<P npIDllepHaH iPoPMa .n;oroBOpoB BO):lO-
n0Jlb30BaHIDI .n;0JDKHa 6bITb YrBepm,.I\eHa IIpamITeJlbCTBOM P<P. Pe<ib
l1,I:(eT J1MeHJIO 0 npMMepHo:w iPoPMe, TaR RaK nOHRTIle «TI-fllOBaH iPoPMa»
npe,!\YCMaTpI1BaeT ee HeyKJIOHHoe co6.moJ:\eHJIe 6e3 }'GeTa IWIpoJJOIWIe-
CKOM J1 BO,lOx03j{j;fcmeHlIOH OOI pEf'Jtma. IIpIDllepHaH iPoPMa
npe,!\YCMaTpI1BaeT 6o.rrblII)'lO nIDROCTb arHorneHIDi J1.n;ae-r 60J1brne npo-
CTOpa .n;M BbipafX)TI{J1 CTopoHaMY! .n;onOJIHJIITeJIbHbIX YCJIOBJ.rl1, OTBe<ialO-
llWIX cneqJl!(lmKe pEn1OHa.
BonpoCbI l13MeHemm If pac1'OtmreIfIUI .n;oroBOpa BOAOUOlJb3OBaHlfJl.
B cr. 451 fK P<P npe,!\YCMaTpI1BaeTCH B03M07KHOCTb J13MeHeIDIH J1 pac-
TOpmeHJUJ 33KJ1K)QeHHoro .n;oroBOpa B CBH311 C c:Yl1.m8e1-()-IbfJlt U3J1te1ie-
1tueM o6cmo.mneA-bCffl6. M3MeHeHJ1e c.fJc1ome.Jncrn npl13Hae'I'CH cJll-\e-
C'I'BeHHbINI, KOr.n;a OHI1 J13MeIDIJlJ1Cb HaCTOJIbKO, ':11'0, eCJlJ1 6b1 CTopOHbI
MOrJlJ13TO pa3yMHO npe,!J;Bl1,!\eTb, .n;oroBOp Boo6Il\e He fu.m6b1 J1MI1 3aKJlIO-
':IeH IfJlJ1 6bIJI 6b1 3aKJIlO'1eH H3 3Ha'lJ1T{'JIbIID OTJll1'lalOlI:p:f'{CH YCJIOBlliIX.
KaK )'K33aHO B cr. 10 BK P<P, npJnry.IJ;J1'I'€JI npelqmqmne npaB3
nOJlb3oBaHl1H BO)J;Hb1M O&beKTOM H3crynaeTB c.rryqaeero HeJfCInJIb30BaIDIH
I-f.ID1 He'--leneBOro HCrICIJIb3CEaH1m. JfJII1 I1HOro HapynIeHJm BO)J;HOro 3aKQH(}-
.n;aTeJIbC'I'Ba. BbUIBI1B rpy6bre, I£'QIJ;HOttpaTIIbIe J1 He yC'IpaIfHHbE Hapyrne-
HJ1H .n;OroBOpoB BQI:((UOJIb3OBaHWJ KaKO:W- JIJ160 J13 cmpOH, PocnpKpO.IJ;HaJJ;-
30p ,l\OJDKeH, KaK npe B cy.n;e6HOM nopJl,l\Ke HHJ1QJUIpmTb
paCmpmeHl1e roOOpoB BO,D,OII0JIb30B3HJ1H. IIpl1 3mM, comaCHO ':I. 5
CT. 10 BK P<P, I1pE1thfIBJIeHJOOTp€60BaHl1Jl 0 npeKpeHm1 IIpasa nOJlb-
3OBaHI1H BO)J;HbINI dh,etcroM ,l\OJIjtQIO npeJWlecTBOBaTb BbIHeceIDIe yrrOJl-
HOM()',jeHHbIM opraHoM, 3aI\JllO'lJ1BIill1M ,l\OroBOp, npe.n;ynpeifC,l\eHJ1H BO):lO-
nOJib30BaTeJlIQ-HapyrnJ1Temo.
B c.rryqae cnopa Mem.u.y cropoHaMY! 06 J13MeHeHI1I1 .n;ocooopa B CBH311 C
cyu::J;eCTBeHHbIM J13MeHeIDleM o6croJITeJlbCTB TaRoe J13M€HeHJIe ,n0r1YCKa-
eTCR no perneHmQ cY,l1a, HO TOJIbRO B J1CKJllO'ltITeJIbHHX cJl;y'laJ'lX, HaIIpI1-
Mep, Kor.n;a o,!\Ha J13 CTOpOH He MOJKeT J1 He 6y,!\eT ero IfCOOJIHllTb. iPaKTJ1-
':IeCKI1 ,l10roBOp OECameTCR paCToprHYTbIM. ECJH:[ TaRO" pe3YJIbT8T
npC),fI1BOpe'il1T  J1H-repecaM JIJ160 nOBJIe'ieT ,II.JIH cmpOH
yrn;ep6, 3Ha'iMTE'JlbHO np 3aTpaTbl, HeOOxo./:J;l1MHe ,nJIfl J1C-
llOJIHeHJHI,l\oroBopa, cy,l\ ,l\O.IDKeH nool1 Ha IIpl1eMJIeMble ,II.JIH cmpOH YC-
JIOBlliI, BITeKe J13MeHeHl1e ,l10r0BOpa.
B ':IaCTHOCTtf, 06Il\ecTBeHHhlM J1HTepecaM MOmeT IIpOTImope'II1Tb pac-
TO}»K€HJile .IJP'OBOPOO BOJ:\OflOJIb3CIHlUI C TeMJil Y"aCTRI1KaMJ1 BO,!\HbIX
oTHoweHJ.rl1, ,lI€:H'I'eJIbHO KOTOpbIX J1MeeT BaiKIlOe CQqr.18..JIbHOe 3Ha'le-
ID1e. MOiKIIo npe,lICT8BJITb TaRyro CJ-ITy3i.\11lO. RaK X03JI:Wcrnyroll.l;l-ri-1 cyfu.-
eRT (rYII J1 MYII) «BO)\mc8H8JI» OCCTBJ1JIeT,lIOI'OBOpHhrli 3a6op Bo..qhl
P.JlfI mITbeBOI'O J1 xOORiIcmeHHO-6brroBoro Bo,!\ocHa6,",eHl1Jll\eJIOro ropo-
-28-

.JI8.. ITo l\aKJ1M-TO €CT€CTBeHHblM wrn TeXHOreHHbIM IIpJ-f'illHClM, He 3aBI1-
 err «Bo,!\OKaHaJIa», :npon:CXOJ1lfT 3arpH3HeHl1e Bo,!\oeMa (BO,!\OTOKa)
l1.0TaKOti:CTeneHI1, '1TO» KfJHCepBJofpYeTycrpoti:CTBa no 33.60-
py BO.IJ;bL ITpl1 aTOM JJ:pyrl1M ,l\OroBopHblM BO,lJ,(UOJlb3OBTeJ1HM aTa Mepa
HI1'-1eM He yrpomaeT. ITOCKOJIbKY '1aCTb nOBepXHOCTHoro BOWiOro OOheK-
Ta, 6bwwero npe,!J;MeTOM ,l\oroBopa 0 IJO,[({IIDJIb3OQl, OKa3bWaeTCH
11.JlH «I301\OKaHaJIa» nOTepMHoJ;i, OH MmKeT nOCTaBm'b B(ITIPOC nepe,lJ;
yrnJIHOMCReHHbIM opraHOM 06 H:3ME'HeIDBI ,l\oroBopa BQJ:{OIIOJIb3OBHHH,
HaI1pJtMep. 0 nepeHoce Bo,!\03a60pa BBePX no T€'ieHillO, fl1.e Bo,!\a OCTa-
JIaCb'lllCTIM.
ITpam1TeJ1bC'IBaorI2Mapra2008f.N2165«Ono,l\-
IUI"OBKe Jl33.KJIl()'-IeHl1Jll,l\oroBOpa 1 yrsepm)J;eHa Ma
npMMepHOro,l\ClroBOpa BOJWIlOJIb3OBaHmr, npeOTpeHnoero 113M€-
HeID1Hl1Jll1npeKpall\eID1H.0HCBom-rrcHKCJI
- Bee J13MeHeHWI AorOBOpa OcpopMJUIiOTCR croPOHaM1f,/:PrIOJlllWl'e
Hb!Mlof CorJIarneID1RMl1 B IlllCbMeHHrn clxJPMe JI nO):\JIemaT B ycTaHCBJIEH--
HOM nopfl,$e perl1CTpalm B rocy.Jl8.peTBeHHOM BO)J;HOM peeCTpe;
- AOroBOpMo6bITb pacTOpmyr AO JlCTe'-leHHH cpoKa ero,l\€J1crBJ.m:
no corJIawemoo CTOpOlf,
- Tpe60BaHl1e 06 U3M£H€HJIllf JlID1 a pacropmemm: l1.0roBOpa MmKeT
6bITb 3aJIBJIeHO CTopoHOi1 B CYA TOJlbKO noc..ne nOJIy'-leHJ1H OTKa3a JJ:pyroi1
CTOpoHbI Ha npeAJIOJKeHl1e J13MeHJITb I1Jll1 pacTOprnyTb AOroBOP, JIJ160
HenOJJyqeIDfH OTBeTa B CPOR, YKa3aHHbIiii: B npe1J,1X»KelUrn, a npl1 era OT-
cyTCTBIDf - B 30-.l\HeBHbrn cpoK.
B <PopMe IIpHMepHOro ,l\CIroBopa B()]:1OI1OJIh3C He YKa3aHbI HaI1-
60JJee pacnp:x.-rpaHeHIIHe Ha lIpalITl1Ke cnyq:aJ1, l1OOBOJIHI01l:\re CTOpo-
HaMTpeOOBaTb H3MeHemml1Jll1npeKpa€HI1JIl1.0roBOpoB BO,!\onOJlh30Ba-
mm B 06eM BH,Lte TaKl1e c.rryqa11 33.<tJJlKCJt:pOBaHbI B rpam.lI<lIICKUV
3aKOHo,!\aTeJIhCTB€. O,lJ;HaKO IIp}! perneHI1I1 BonpOCOB 06I13M€HeHIDf AOro-
BOpoB BO.l\crIDJIb30BaHWI coorseTCTsyKJIIJ;I1e IX).)J(O!{eInm fR P<P He)J;O-
CTaTO'-IHbL Bo,l\HOe xoom1cTBo J1MeeT CBOlO cneqlofct:n1KY, KOTOpan Tpe6Y€T
,l\onOJIHeHJ1H 06Lq11X IJ().1K))f(Effim:, CO,l\epmaJIJ;l1XCR B fR P<P.
«BropJ<rnoe BO,D;onOJIb31l88JDlC» T))l'6yer AeTaJIhHoro peryJIHpOBa-
InUL CTaTbR 19 BRP<PnoCBRll\eHa o6c.rry*MBamno «BTOpwnD"O pblliKa»
npaB BCI,JJ,CIIOJIb3OBafJI. l1MeeTCH B B>r,n;ynepe.Jl8.'la npaB J1 06H3aHIIOCTei1
no AOroBOpy BO.l\OJX)J!b3()88JIJ ll.pyroM)' .ID-IQY. Ho Ha 3TO TpeOYeTCR co-
fJJaUle IJOJIHOMO'IHOro rocy.Jl8.pCTBeHHoro I1Jll1 M)'lIJfWIIJaJibHoro opraHa.
CpoK paccMarpeHHH 3aRBJIeHHH - 30 AHeM. OrKa3 .JI8.Tb corJIaCl1e Ha ne-
I C3P<11.2OO8 Nl!11 {'I. 1J.CT. 1038
-29-

pe,Ila':lY npaBa nOJIb30Bamm BO)J;HbIM WheKTOM MC»KeT 6bITb 06m8.JIOBaH
3amnrJ'eJIeM B cy1J,€
3aKOHO,IlaTeJIb ynOMJrnaeT 0 TOM, ':I'f() 1J,aHHaH nepe1J,a':la 6Y1J,eT oCy:D.\e-
CTBJIH'l'bCH B COOTBe'I'CTIJMJ C Ip 3aKOHO,naTeJIbCTBOM. 01J,HaKO
YCJlOBWI 3'l'oiii c,n;eJIKJ1 (IIJIaTa, 06'beM nepe)\aBaeMbIX npaB J:! ofumaHHOC-
Teiii, npaBa J:! ofumaHHocTIf TpeTIillX JIJ1Q) He paCKpblBaJOTCH. He pellleH
TaKlKe BOnpoC 0 B03MC.OKHOCTIf nepeyCTynKl1 OT O,!\Horo JIJ1l{a K ,!\pyroMY
TOJIbKO ':IaCTJII aKBaTopvu1. 3m .HBJIHeTCH KOppynOJ'eHHbIM npo6eJIOM B
3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBe, 'Ipe6yIO BOCnOJlliem-rn.
Heypery.1D1pOBaIIHOCTb Ha3BaHHblX OTHOllleHI1iii MomeT Bbl3BaTb
nOTepID fOcy.napCTBOM KOHTpOJI.H 3a JIICIlO.1Ib3OBaHJ1e J:! COC'fO.HHJ'I€M
TOro 11JII1 11HOro «nepeycTynJIeHHoro» BO,!\OeMa, BO,!\OTOKa 11J111 era ':Iac-
TJ:!. B03MO:iKHbl TaKlKe CneKYJlHl{1111 npaBoM Bo,!\onOJIb30Bamm. Oie-
BI1,!\HO, Tpe6yeTC.H nOCTaHOBJIeHJlle IIpaBJllTeJlbcTBa P<P, .I\eTaJIbHO pe-
ryJIJ1pYlOll\ee OTHOWeHJ1H CTOpOH B c.rry'lae nepe.I\a':lJ:! npaB J:!
06H3aHHocTeiii no .I\OrOBOpy BO,I:(0II0Jlb30BaHJIIJI. K 3TI1M OTHoweHWlM
.I\OnycTJIMO npI1MeHH'I'b HOpMbl a nepeHai1Me. TeopeTJl'iecllJol B03Mom-
HO np11MeHeHYle 11 HOpM a nO,!\H8MMe (cy6apeH,I:(e). O,wiaKo CT. 19 BK
P<P He npe.IG'CMaTpl1BaeT CJI)"iaH nO,!lHaMMa; B :noiii ':IaCTI1 aHa co,!\ep-
mI1T .HBHbliii npo6eJl.
PeweHJIH 0 npe,lJ;OCTaBJIeHHH BO)];HblX O&beKTOB B U01JL3OB3Hlle. Co-
 a;I;MJ1HI1C1p8.TIlBHOro pery.mtpooaHJ1H, npe.n;ycMOTpeHllOe B
BKP, He .I\OJDKHO JlOMaTh Bce paapeI1li'1'I'€J ('I1Q('.(Jfu.I JII MeXaHJll3MbI
peryJIJ1JX1BaHWI BO,I:(Of1OJI:b3OOaffiLfL IIpe,I:(OCT8BJ1€HMe BOAHblX 06neKTOB B
I1OJIb3OBaIDIe Ha DCHOBe 81J.MI1HIICTpaTI1BHOro aKTa .HBJlHeTCH lID1poKO
pacnpDC'IpaHeHHbIM cnoco6oM pery.1l:l1poBaIDtH KaK B CTpaHax CHI', TaK JII
B 3ana;:J;Hoiii Espone, pR.!\e racY.il3pcTB A3mf (HanpIDIep, B .flncnum
IIoJlliOCTblO OTKa3bWaTbCH OT pa3peIll1ITeJIbHbIX MeXaHJ13MlJ3 B BOllO-
IDJIbaOBa}UfH 6bLIIO 6b! npem,n;eBpeMeHHblM.
ComaCHO CT_ 11, 21-23 BK P<P 2006 f. coxpaHlieTCa IIp€JIyCMJ'Tp€H-
HaH €Il{e B BK Pip 1995 f. npoQe,I:(ypa pa3p€IlD1T€JihHOI'O (6e3wroooPHO-
ro) npe,l\OCTaBJIeHl1.H BO.D;HbIX 06'beKTOB B I1OJIb3OIJaIDf€- IIpJII 3TOM KPyr
CJIy'faeB B01J,OIIO.1Ib301H, npe,lQ'cMaTpi1BalOll\I1X npMMeHeHJlle 3'l'oro
J'IHC'Ip)'Ml2lffil, cy:D.\eCTBelllioBo3pOC: OT06opoHb!.I\OOT1J.bI-
xa,I:(eTefIJllJllHBaJltf,l\OB.
BoAHb!e WheKTbl,  B 4Je.!1epa.YIl>HOfi: co6C':rBeHHocTH
c06CTBeHHocThI Cy6'beKTOB Poc:cID1ct«:M  c06CTBeHHoCTJII MJ-
m o6pasoaamm, npe,l\OC'I8BJIffiO B 6e3wroooproe nOJIb-
3OBaHI1e 1J,JIH:
- o6ecn€"IOHJ1fI 06oJXIHb! cTpaHbl JII 6e30nacHocm racY.J1B.pcTBa,
- c6poca CTO'lHblX t1 (Will) p'peHa:iKHblX BOA;
-30-

-pa3MeLIJ;eHJ1RnpI1'f8.JIOB,cy,l\OnO,l\'beMHbIXliCOOpy-
m.eHIDi;
- pa3MeLIJ;eHJ1.f! craql1OHapHhIXI1 (J1JII1) IIJIaBJ'II1X IIJIa$pMI1I1CK)'C-
CTBeHHhlX 0C'I'p0B0B;
- pa3Mell\eHi1JI Ii CTpOl.-ITeJIbCTBa r1-1APOT1X COOPY'f'€HJ'Di (B
TOM qJl!CJIe MeJrnOpanmHbIX CHCTeM), MOcrOB, nO.n;BO,l\HbIX II[ no.n;3eMHbIX
nepexo.n;OB, a TaKiKe TpyfJcJnpoocJ.n; nO.n;BO,!J;HbIX JTI1HIDt CBJl311, ,lIpynrx
JnfHeiiHblXo6'beKTOB, no.n;BO)J.HbIX;
- pa3Berom 11 ,I\06bI'U1 I1()Jle3Hl£{ I1CKQnaeMbIX;
- npoBe.n;eHJ1.fl mwymy6JITeJIbHhIX, B3pbIBHbIX, 6ypoBbIX 11 ,lIpyrnx
pa6OT. CBJl3aHHbIX C 113MeHeHYIeM AHa J1 6eperoB BO)J.HbIX 06'beKTOB;
- nO.r\beMa 3aTOH)'BIill1X CY,l\OB;
- CIIJIaBa JIeca B IIJIOTax 11 C npl1MeHeIDIeMKOWeJl€ii;
- 3a6opa (YI3'bmJtH) BO)J;HbIX pecypCOB ,l\JIH opoweHJ1H 3eMeJIb ce.m.--
CKOXCI3RifcTBeHHOI'O Ha3Ha'leHJ1.f! (B TOM qJl!CJIe nyroB 11 naeroYJLIJ;);
- opraHl13CEl8HHOl' OT,IlbIXa ,I\€Teiii:, a TaIOKe OpraHH3OB8.HHOf' OT,lJ;bIXa
BeTepaHOB, rpam,tlaH n(l)KJ1JIOro B03paCTa, J1HBaJli1,1\OB.
CrreJJY€T J1M€Th B IDfJIY, 'IT(J paHee npaBO oco6oro nQJTh30BaHIDI BO)J;Hbl-
MI1 06'beEtTaMl1 B03HIDCaJIO J1Jllf npeRpal$J1OCb Ha OCHOBaHJ1l1 peuanrli
IIpamrreJIbCTBa P<P I1JIJII opraHOB IfCII)JIIDtTeJIbHOi1 BJIacrYi Cy6'beKTOB P<P.
3aTeM, cor.naCHO BH€CeHHbIM 1f3Me}Effif.HM B BK P<P 1995 r., opraHh! cyD'b-
eKTOB P<P6bLJl11..m-nueHbI TaRO" BOOMJ]KH)CTIt. B HacrOHll\ee BpeMfl, B CBfI-
311 C nepe,!\a'leA nOJIHOMO'llfiii no npmmrl-OO TaKQBhlX perneHIrn: I1HbIM HpO-
Me IIpaBl1T€JIbCTBa P<P rocy,IlapCTBeHHblM 11 JIbHbIM opraHaM
BJIaCTI1 npaBa nOCJle,!J;ill1X nepe:lt\l1BalOT «BTOpoe pmt\,!J;eIDIe».
B pewem1J-f 0 npe.I:J.OCT8BJIeIDDl BO)J;HOro 06'beKTa B nOJIb30BaHYie C
y<1eTOM Bcex 06cr0JrreJIbCTB 11 COCTORHHR BO)J;HOro 06'beKTa yxa3bIBaJOT-
CR: qeJIb, BJ1Ab1 M YCJIOBHR IrrnJIb3OBaHt1.fl BO)J;HOro 06'beKTa I1JIM era Iffi-
CTI1. Offi:! MOryr 6bITb caMbIMl1 pa3Hoo6paaHblMM M aaBI1C€Tb OT xapaKTe-
pa It:! Ha3Haq€HJUI It:!cnOJIb30BaHM BOMoro 06'beKTa, "TO onpe.n;eJleHO B
nepe'lHe I!Q3M{))KtillX BI1)J;OB 1I0l0JI:b3UBaHJ'UI BOMoro 06'beKTa.
Bo)J;HblH Ofu.eKT (1t:!JIJ1 ero qaCTb) 11pe)J;OC'I'aBJlH€T B m.JIb3OBaHJ1e
KOIIIqJeTlIOMy TeJIIO. IIo:ITOMY B peweHID1 0 npeAocraBJIe-
HID:! BOMOro 06'beKTa yxa3blBaJOTCR CBe)J;eHIfR 0 ,IlaHHOM BO):10n0JIb30Ba-
TeJIe; npH'ieM He TOJIbKQ ap,pec l1,l1pyrl1e peKBl13tfI'b1, HO 11 MaTepllaJIbH)-
TeXHI1QecKt1e xapaKTepHCTIU01, n03BOJl.llfCl1tJ CYAl1Tb a rapaHTllHX
BWlOJlH€HJ'UI BO):10TIQJTh30BaT€'JleM 06HsaHHocreH no paOH8JIbHOMY It:!C-
n01Ib3OBaHJOO It:! oxpaHe BO)J;HOro 06'beKTa.
BpeWaU1J-f.n;OJDKeH6bITbonpeAeJleHcpoKBnOJlo-
m.eHJ1.f!X BK P<P He y<ffi3blBa€TCR npe.!1eJThHbrn CpoK .r\eiicTBJIR perneHIDi
(B OTJII1'll1e ar cro cpoKa mroBOpOB EI()]p1OJlb3OBaHHR). O)J;HaKO
-31-

B CT. 23 BK ptfJ ncmcHHE'TCH, 'ITO :menaTE'JlbHbrl1 cpcm BOJ:I(JIIOJIb3OH
YK8-3bIBaeTCJI caMJ1M , lOpI-1,!I,J1'ieCKJ1M JIJ-lU;OM, 3al-fHTepeco-
BaHHhIMB nOJIY'lemrn BO.n;Horoo6DeKTa J1JThI ero<IacTI1BIIOJIb3OI3aIDIe.Ho
BKam,!\OM ar,neJlbHOM cJJY'Iae opraH,  peweHJ1e a rrpe,l:\O-
craBJIeHJ111 BO.n;HOro 06neKTa B InJIb3OBaID1e, BIIpaBe caM onpe.n:e.mfTb
>=qx>K
HanpHMep. lIpl1 npe,l:\OCTaBJIeID111 BOMoro ol'i'beKTa,IVIH oI'ieCne<:leWfH
o60poHbI CTpaHhI 11 6e3orracH:x;rn racy.napcrBa MtDKeT 6bITb ycraHOBJIe-
HO 6eccpoGHOe (nOCTOHHHoe) J1JII1, BO BCJIKOM cJJY'Iae, OGeHb AJillTE'JlbHoe
lIOJIb3OBaIDfe; JJ,J1H pa3Mell\eHJ1H KaEOro-mroo CTpOIITeJIbHOIU 06'beKTa
cpOK Momer 6bITb OlIpe,l:\eJIeH B a:xrrBeTC'l'BID1 C rrpoeKTOM CTpOJf'I"eJIbCT
BB.; ,IVlHnQ,L\beMa 3aTDH)'B1ID1X Cy,nOB - IIO corJlaCOBaHMIO C-
eiiJ, KOTOpaH lIpOBO,IJ;l1T 3T11 paOOTb1;,IVIH CIIJIaBa Jleca - Ha nepv!O,I:\ ce30H-
HbIX pafx:rr no cllJIaay .npeBeCMHbL
PeweHJ1e rna6:maeTCH IIpH.JImKeHIDIM 3ro - MaTepI1aJlb! B rpaclJWie-
CKOiiJ clJoPMe C YK8-3aHl1eM.npyrnx BO,I:\OIIOJIb30BaTeJleiiJ Ha BO.n;HOM OObeK-
Te, a TalOKe coce)J;HJ1X aeMJleJnJlb3lJBaTeJleiiJ, 30H C oc06blMJll YCJIOBI1HMJII
I BO.n;HOro 06neKTa; 1JIaI8IOTCH TaIOKe CXeMbl pa3Me-
ll\eHI1H  11 I1HbIX COOfJY'KE'IDriiI, paCl100())KellllNX Ha
BO.n;HOM OO'beKTe. K Ha3BaHHblM MaTepMa.n:aM lIpJ-fJIarae-rCH nOHCHlITeJlb-
HaH 3aIDICKa. ,AaHHhle MaTepI1aJlb! J-IMelOT BamHoe IIpaKTWieCKOe 3Ha':le-
HJ1e,[IJIH OpraHOB :3IIDJlcr1ttreCKOro KOHTpOJlH, Ha6JllO,I:\alOX 3a COCTOH-
HJ1eM BO.n;HOro 00l.eKTa. TaK leaK OHM n03BOJlffiO'!' 60J1ee OCHOBaT€JIbHO
npClBeplITb BbIDOJIHetme f:IO,IJ.CKiOJIb3OBaT€JIeM 06JI3aHHOCTeiii no paQ110-
HaJIbHOM)' I1CIIOJIb3CJ3aIDUO 11 oxpaHe BOMoro OO'beKTa.
O, 3al1HTE'peCOBaHHoe B nOJi)"leHJ1II! BO.n;HOro OO'beKTa J1JThI era ':Ia-
CThI B lIOJlb3OBa1Dwe, .u;OJDKHO OOpaTI1TbCH C 3aHBJIeIDfeM B COOTBeTCTBJIO-
I4I1iiJ HCIIOJIHItTeJIbHbIii rOCY,l:\apcrBeHHbrn opraH J1JII1 opraH MeCTHoro ca-
 B 'lbeM «BeJ\eHJ111» HaX0,lJ;l1TCJ1,naHHbrnB0,l:lHhIi10m.eKT.
CaMO pellleHY!e 0 nY! B II0JIb30BaHY!e BO.n;Horo OObeKTa
J1JThI ero 'lllCTY!, HaxO,l:\.HlQeroCH B 4>e,l:\epaJlbHUii COOcrBeHHOCTY!, COOCTBeH-
HOCH! cyl'i'beKTa Poccw1aocH ,I:\epaL\J1II!, co6crBeHHoc:nt M)'HI1L'lII3J1b-
HOro OOpa30BaHI1H, lIpI1Hl1MaeTCH 3aKOHHbIM l1peACT8BIrreneM COOCTBeH-
HI1Ka BO.n;HOro ameKTa. Cne,l:\OBaTeJIbHO, pe<ib l1,!\eT 06 IICIIOJ!IDITe.1I
opraHe rocy.n;apcTBeHHofr BJIaCTH Jf.Illi 06 opraHe MecTHoro caMO)'I1p3BJIe-
HJfJL Me TeM, aaK0HHblM IIpe.n;cramne.neM COOcTBeHHI-1Ka MOiKeT
6bITb 11 opraH 11C1IUJlffil'I'€JibH)ll MaCTY! cyl'i'beltTa PocCII:iicKoii ,I:\epa-
. KOTopoM)'. comacHo CT. 26 BK Pip, 6WiO nepe,l:\3HO 4>e,l:\epaJIbHoe
nOJiHOMO'il-fe no npe.n;tJCT8BJleJOOO BO.n;HOro oO'beltTa B 1IO.1Ib3OBaHI1e.
B3aI1MOO'IHOllleID1fl Mem,I\Y yrn.m«JMCRffff opraaoM 11 3aHBJITeJleM
perymipYJOTCR I1OC'raHffiJJeIfeM IIpaBI-fTeJlbCTBa P A OT 30 1J;eKaopH 2006 r.
-32-

:=':e=e;;;:
3aHlrI'€pE'COBa JIJ1Qa,  K nOJnlOMO'ffibIM opraHaM, C
npoc:HXn:t:BhJAaThCBe1fI0BOJVIOM05'heKTe;HaOCHOBa-
H:Jrn aTHX CBe,!J;eHJ-ri1 )'Ka3aHHOe JIJ1l.1;O COCTaBJ1ReT CBOe 3ammeHYIe.
B 3aRBJleHMM 0 npe):\OCTaBJIeHID1 BO):\HOro 06'beKTa B IJO.1lh3(E8HIiIe C(J-
.r:\epmaTC1I:
- CBe):\eHJ.1.fI a 3a.HBI-1T€JIe: nOJnloe J-I CORpaIQeHHOe H8J-IM€H:EIaHHE J-I
opraIlJ13alUMlliJD-npaBOBaH $>pMa, MeCTO HaXruK):(emrn, 6aHKOBCID'Ie
peKBM3JIITbI - .r:\.IIH IOpJ-l,lJ)f'I€ClOCII"O In-IQa;
- MJ1JIIDI, J1MH, O'I"IeCTBO, MecTO )IOIT€JlhC'TBa, peEBJ'1:3I1TCI .r:\OKY-
MeHTa, Y.r:\OC'TQBepmoll\E'I'O JII-1'IHOCTb, - .r:\.IIH rtJl13K4eororo In-IQa J-I-
BJ-UIYaJIhHOro npe.nrIJMInlMaTeJIH;
- HaMMeHOBaHl1e J-I MecTO paCIlOJi(J)fietDfH BO,[\Horo 05'helt1'a;
-o5ocHOBaHl1eBl1,L\a,:qeJIJIIJ-lcpoKaUL
K 3aHBJleHJ11Q npl1JI8I'a€TCH I.1;e.mrii naKeT .r:\OKYMetITOB:
-KOmrnY'IPe.nwreJlbHhIXBhlIIJ1CKaJ-l3oroI'OCY.MP-
CTBeHHoro peec'I'pa IDfJI-1,!I;I-ftecXMX In-IQ (.wm lOpl1,lJ;W'lecXMX .1II1lU;
- KOrIJ1.H  a IIOCTaHOBRe Ha)"leT B HaJIOI'OBOM opraHe;
- .r:\oK)'MeHT, nO):\TB 110JIHOMO'nlH JII1Q8. Ha oCy:Il\ecTBJIe-
HYle,QeHCTBImOTJ1MeHl13aHBJi1T€JIH, -npl1
- KOID-IflID.JICOKJ1TeJl:I'O 3a.KJiIQQeHYIfl rocY.MpcTIJ€HlIOH: 3KCneprl1-
3blJ-IaKTOeroyrBepeHJ1J1-BcJIY'laRX,3aKOHO)Ia-
TeJlbCTBOM P<xn1iic::Ju14Je.r:\epaLJ;m:!;
-l1HcpopMaQIDI 0 HaMe'!aeMhlX 3amU1TeJIeMEIO]J;Me-
ponpIDI11fHX J-I MeponpI1RTJ1HX no oxpaHe BO.r:\Horo 05'hERTa C )'Ka3aIDIeM
pasMepa 11 J-ICTO'IHMKOB cpe):\cTB, He06xo.Jll1MhIX.r:\.IIH J-IX t;
- .r:\OK)'MelIT a 1 B n0Jlh30Ba:mre 3eMeJIhHOIO yqaCTKa,
.r:\.IIHBO,I:\OI1
- CBe,!\eHJ1fl 0 Ha.Jll1<IJrn IfifIJX)JIh1D-I13MepnTeJIhHOii armapaTypbl
.r:\.IIH KOlIT}X>JIH Ka'lecTBa BO)J.bl B BO,!\HOM 05'heKTe;
- MaTepmuIhl B rp $>pMe C aro5pameIDfeM BO,!\HOrO o6'b--
eKTa, JIW-38.HIU"O B 3a.HBJIeHwt1, J-I pasMel1\eIDfH cpe):\cTB J-I 06'beKTOB Bo-
,II;OI1I)JIb3(I a TaIOKe 11OHCID1'I'eJIhKI.H 3aIIl1CKa.
K aaaBJlemuo a npe.D.OCTaBJIeHJ1J1 B IJO.YIh3OBaHtfe BO,[\HOro 06'beKTa.r:\.IIH
c5poca CTO'lHhlX J-I (11JU1) l{PeHamHhIX EOJJ:,noII)JIIDfTE'JIhH) npt1.JlaI'aRYI'CH:
- pac'!eT J-I ofocHOBamre 3aJIBJleHHOro 05'heMa c6poca CTO'lHhlX H
(J-IJIJII) .upeHamHhIX BOJJ: 11 nOKa3aTeJIJII J-IX KaqeCTBa;
1 pr.2007 N!!4(4267) 12J1HBi!J)I'
-33-

- CBe.n;eHM 0 H8.JIHtIJ1Y! KOHTpOJlbHO-J13MepJrreJIbHoi1 annapaTYPbl
WlfI yqeTa OO'beMOB J1 KOHTp0JlfI (Ha6mo.n;eIDIJ'l) Ka'teCTBa COpaCbIBaeMbIX
CTO'lHbIX J1 (J1JI!II) .upeHamHbIX BO.n;.
MecTo npe1J.l1(lJJ8I'8eM eopoca CTO'-lHbIX J1 (t1JIJ1) l{PeHamHbIX BO.n;
o50sHa'laeTCJ'I B rpaJ1qeettnX MaT€pI18JIaX, npMJIaraeMblX K 3aJIBJleHJ1l().
K 3aHBJlem1JO 0 npe,J\OCT8BJlemtJl B I1OJIb3I:.Wffile BO)J;Horo OOneltTa
P.JI.H pasBe,IJ;KY! J1 .l\OObffi'! 1IOJ1e3HbIX J1CKOnaeMbiX KpoMe }'Kll3aHHblX .1\0-
KYMeHTOB npMJIaraeTCJ'I JIJilQeH3M Ha JI)Jlb3()B3.}U1e HeJ\PaMJ1.
K 3aJIBJleHI-flO 0 m B IJO.YIb3()fI3HJe BO)J;Horo OOneKTB
WlfI saoopa (U3'hfITUH) BO)J;HbIX pecypCOB WlfI oporneHMJ'l 3eMeJlb ceJIb-
HOro H8.3H8.'leHMJ'l (BTOM 'lJ1CJle nyroB t1 nacWffil() KpoMe
npl1Be.l\eHHblX .l\OKyMeHTOB npW:I8.ralOTCJI:
- pacqeT Y! o50CHoBBHY!e 38JIBJIelllioro OO'beMa saoopa (J13'bmYIH) BO,!\-
HbIX pecypcOB J13 BO,!\HOro 06neKTa;
- CBe.n;eHM 0 HaJIJ1'1J1Ji! KOHTpOJIbHO-J13Mepme1IbHOJl annapaTYPbl
WlfI yqeTa 06'beMB BO)J;HbIX pecypCOB, 3a6l1paeMbIx (J1SblMBeMbIX) J13 BO.n;-
HOro 06neKTa;
- CBe,!\eHM a TexIDf'lecttnX nap8.MeTpax Bo,!\oaaoopHbIX eoopymetm:ii
J1 MepaX no npe.l\OTBpall\eHI-flO llOna,!J;am1H pbro J1.I\PYI'YIX BO;:uIbIX oY!OJiO-
IWiecttnX pecypCOB B 3m eoopymeHYIH J1J1J1 KOIDfJl .l\OKYMema 06 yr-
Bepm,n;eHJ1J1IIJXJe,lIOKyMeI,yxa.saH-
HbleCBe]:IeHHJI..
ITpe.n;oc-rnBJIeHle HeBnOJlHOMOUbeMe Af)KYMeHTOB HB.JUie'I'CHOCHOBa-
HJ1eM WlfI OTKasa B paCCMOTpeHffi:! Bonpoca, HO Tpe50BaTb npe.n;ocraBJIe-
HJ1JI He yC'raHOBJIeHHbIX .l\aHHbIM nOCTBHOBJIelDteM ,lIOK)'MeHTOB sanpe-
ll\eHO.
PerneHJ1e 0 npeppcraBJEHIDf B nOJIb3OBaHl1e BO.n;HOro 06neKTa 110J1jKHO
Ohl'I'b npY!HJ'lTO B Te'leIDIe 30 1\Hei1 CO]:1HJ'I nOJl)"-leHl-1J'l 3aJ'lBJleHJ1Jl 0 npe.n;o-
craBJIeHJ1J1 BO.n;HOro ofueKTa J1JIJII ero 'l8.CTI-I B nOJIb30BaHY!e. B Te'leHJ1e
3TOf'O cpoKa HCI10JIHJITeJibHblJI opraH roCYt\8.PCTBeHHOi1 BJIaC'rn t1JIJ1 opraH
MeCTHoro caMoynpaBJIelU1Jl 06.H3aH eoo6Lq11Tb 0 eBOeM perneHJ1J1 3aJIBwre-
JllO (05 y.l¥JBJIernopeIDDl npoCbObl mrt50 06 0TKa3e B npe.n;ocrBBJIeHY!Y! BO,!\-
HorooO'bEETa).
KaK npe,rtyCMOTpeHO B BK PtfJ, OTKaS B npe.n;OCTBBJleHJ1J1 BO.n;HOro
OO'beKTB I1JU:I era 'ffiCT}! 110J1meH 6hITb M:m1Bl1pOB8.H J1 He HOC}!'Tb xapaK-
Tep «(Y1'ITIw:KI1». IT03TOM)' B,lIIJEyMeHTe 110JljKHbI 6hITb yxa.saHbl KOHKpeT-
Hble CTaTbY! 3aKOHa,lOOTOpble ITOCJIJ'KI-1.ID'I OCHOBaHYIeM P.JI.H OTKaSa B npe-
.I\OC'I8BJI€Ill1I'I t\8.llliOfO BO)J;Horo OO'beKTa J1JIH era qaCT}!.
OrK8.3 He 3aKpbIBaeT 38JIBYJ:Temo B03MO:IKHOC'I'Y B036yIJ;JlJTb 1
cnop. ITpaBoHaIeOTKa3a 3ammTeJIbJ1MeeTHeTOJIhKOHaOC-
HOBaHJ1J1 I1()Jl(Df(f'IilrH Ko,n;eKca, HO J1 Ha OCHOBaHilll 3aKOHa PtfJ err 27 an-
-34-

peJ1H 1993 r. N24866-1 «06 06maJIoBamrn Bcy.l\ ,l\E'HcTmrnJII pernemrlii,
Hapyrna}(} npaBa JII CB06oN>I rpH" 1.
PerneHJlle 0 npe,!J;OCT8.BJIeHJrn: BO.l\HOro 06neKTa (JllJIJII era <mcw) B
no.JIb3()BaHl.le npl1ID1MaeTCHhIMOpraHOMno cneQI1aJlbHOH
TI1IIOBOJ14>oPMe, YTBeNhrnnpl1pO,!J;bI Poccmr. JIro6oe npllliHTOe
perneHI1e nO,!J;JIemHT I'OCy,MpCTB€HHOM peTIlCTpaLJ;J.m B I'OCy,MpCTB€HHOM
BO,!\HOMpeeC'rpe. TOJIbKOnOCJIeero,MHHoeBCTY-
naeTBcIDIy.O'IeBH.l\HO, "IT00TKa3Bpenperne-
HJ1.fI TalOKe MOmeT 6hITh OfuKaJIOBaH B CY,lI;e6HOM nopHAKe.
lIaJ:1o npl13HaTh, '1TO BOJ\Hoe aaKQHO):1aTeJIbCTBO He Y,lI;eJIHeT ,lI;OCTa-
TO'lHOrO BHWMaHJ1.H {lonpoCQM U3M€'H£1tUJ!. mpe6om:mti1., 
{I pew.eU1.l.RXonpeQocmae.n.eJQ1UD61>€":moo {I nMb30aaUilR, a TaK-
.me cnOC06aM npeo,!J;OJIeHJ1.fl KOHOB JllHTepecoB, B03MOmHhIX B 3Tl-fX
CJly<laJIx.
Ko1IOHJII,Ie corJJarnemlJI. HeKOTOphlenpOJIBJIeHJIIHBOJ1HhIX npa-
BOOfHorneHJ-ri1 MruKHO OQeID1BaTh KaK KOHQeCCJIIOHHhle. B 4:re,D;epaJIhHOM
3aKQHe 0'1' 21111QJ1H 2005 f. NQ 11543 «0 KOHQeC(J1OHHhlX cornarneHJIIRX,,2
npelJ:YCMaTpHBaeTCHJllHCTHTyrcor.rrarnemrlii,-
HOOTJUl'WC:IWdicfIKaKO'I'f TaKJIIO'I'c06CTBeHHo
ICOIIQeCCJRf npl1pO):1Hh1X pecypCOB (cOrJIallleHlliI a paaJ\eJIe npD,lI;)'K'-IWI1).
ITo lfiILIeccJlOHHOM)' comarneHJllIO O,!\Ha CTopoHa (I«JIILI€CCI«)p) 06H3}'-
eTCH sa CBOH C'-leT C03):1aTb 1-1 (JfJIM) peKfJlK."lpyHpTh, a TalOK€ 3KCn.rry-
3T11pOBaTh onpe.ne.nemue 3T11M COrJIallIEWH'M  JIIMJl-l];eCTBO
(06'helt'l' KQH'-IeCCIt:!OHHoro COrJlallleHH.II), a KOHljeJ\eHT ofut3YeTCJI npe,ll;o-
CTaBIt:!Tb JOC)HQeC(JIOHepy Ha cpoK,  3T11M cor.rrallleHJlleM,
npaBa BJla,l\eHWI JII nOJlh30BaHJ1.fl om.eKTOM KOHQI2CCJ«JHHO COmallleHJ1.fl
WIJI ocJ'll*CTBJIeHJ1.fl }'R8.38.HHOM }I.emeJIhHQCTM. ITpaBO co6cTBeHHQC'fJII Ha
riiJllJIl16ylJYlll;l'li106'heKTK'OHq2C(J'IDIll£rocorJIallleHJ1.floro-
BapHBaeTCJI sa R.'OHQ£' KOTOphIMMOIyr 6bITb Poccrn1cKaH 4:re,!\epa-
qwR, cy6'heKThI PoccmtcI«Jjj: 4leJ\epaQHIiI JfJIM M)'HJIIQ£rnaJlhHhIe 06pa30-
BaHJIIJI. ITpaBOBaH KOHC'IpymJ;JIIJI KOHQeccJlOHHbIX COrJIallleHJlli1 n03BOJlJleT
'-I8.CTH0M)' It:!HBecTOpy cY"-lecTB€HHO COKpall\8.Tb CBOIII sa'IpaTbI sa C'leT
TOro, '1TO rocy,MpcTBO nplllMeT Ha ce6H '1aCTh pacxO,!\OB Ha CTpOJrreJIhCT-
BO, peIfirIp JII.name JIICIIOJIb3OBaIfe 'fOro JIIJillJIIHoro o6'heKTa He-
,nBi>-OKHMOCTI1, KOTOpbIi1 n03BOJ1HeT 3Kcn.rryaTI1pOEaTb npl1po.$ihIe pecyp-
ChI. TaKI1M 06pa30M, 3aKJIa,l\bIBaeTCJI DCHOBa .J\JIH TOro, '1T06bl
rocy,MpC'fBO J1 '-I8.CTHhIi1 mf3Hec COBMecTHbIMJil }'CI1JIJUIMJI, KBK no,!\06aeT
1 Bep,oMOC1l1CI-\AHBCP4I.1993 N19 Cr 685
2 C3P<t1.2005.Ni30IY.2j.Cr.3126
-35-

IIapmepaM, H8.JlaiKJ1&WIH :3I\OHOMH'IE'CKyro J1HcppaCTp)'KTypy CTpaHbI
(npem.n;e BCerO 1paHCIIOpTHylO 113HepreTJf'fecKYIO). B IJ;eJlOM ,!\epaJlb-
HbIiii 3aKOH <iO IOCJHLtecat:CHHbIX cornarneHI1.RX» 6b1J1 npmurr WlfI perneHM.f!
npoo.rreMbI paasm1H J1Hcppac-rpYIITYPbL
ComaCHO CT. 4 Ha3BaHHOro 3aJCOHa, K 'UICJlY 06'heKTOB KOHl\eCCMOH-
HbIX corJIaIlIeHHii OTHOC.fITCfI CYM, noprbl, IIpl1CTaHI-f, I1pW1aJIbI, n.1,1\po-
coopymem1H (ITC), o6paayrolll}1eBO,!\oxpam-LJIl1ma. Ho,!\Jl.fl
poccJriiicKoro BO,!\HOro xQ3JIi1CTBa J1 BO,!\HOro TP8-Hcnopra OCo6eHHO BaiKHO,
'1TO I1OHHbIe COfJIawelll1.fl n03BOJI.fIlOT qaCTHoM}' J1HBecTOPY Ha
Bblra,!I;HbIX,nJIR ce6H YCJlOBI1.RX peKoHcTpyMpOBaTb cTapble J1 Hepe,!\KO J13-
HoweHHble ITC, npapblB KOTopblX MroKeT 06epHyrbcH .I\M C1paHbl
crpallIHblMJ1 CTJrxmtHlnnl 6e,!\CTBMfIMI1. O,!\HaKO 11M C'1'p(I'IT€-JIbCTBa J1
IITCHe06xo,!\WMonpe)J;OCTaBI1TbBnOJIbaOBaHUeKOHlteC-
cMoHepa J1 BO,!\Hbrn 06'beKT .mroo era 'laCTM (aaBO)J;b, 33TOH, pyKaB, 1'3-
BaHb),l16ooIill6Y1\YTBnp0'--1eCCe
c'I'pOHT€JIbCTBa. OtpopMJImbCJI 3TO .I\OJDKHO COrJlacHo BK PtfJ, ':Iepe3 pe-
weID1H a npe1 BO,!\HOro 06'heKTa B InJIb3OBaIll1e J1Jill ':Iepe3
1I0I'OBOpbl BO,r\OIJOJIb3OBUL YCJlOBI1fI TaKl1X perneli1-lfi J1110I'OBOpoB npJ1-
aeaHbl 06eclIerumaTb 3KOHOMHoe J1 3KOJIOrJ1qeCKM 0TBeTCTBeIIH)€ J1C-
00JUr:30BaIiJ1e BO,!\HblX WbeKTOB.
Heo6xo.I\l'1MOC'I'b YCTaHOBJIeHI1H BO,!\HblX npaBOOTHOweHI1i1 OTpa-
>KaeTCJI B nOCTaHOBJleHI1JIX IIpaBi1TeJlbCTBa Pel> aT 5 lIexa6pR 2006 I'.
N2747 «06 YTBep)K,!J;€IU111 TI1IIOBOI'O KOHl!eCCJ10HHoro cornawelillJl B
OTHOwelllfl1: I'YI.I\POTeXHJNecKJlX coopy:meHJ-ri1» I, aT 5 .I\€Ka6pJI 2006 I'.
N2745 «06 YTBep3K,I\eHHJl TYlIIOBOro KOHlteCCJ10HHOro cor.narneHi1.f! B
OTHOwelllfl1: MopCKI1X VI pe'iHblX noproB,I1'UIJX>T€XHJI':i€CKI1X coopy:me-
Hi1i1 nopToB, 06'heKTOB np0i13BO,!\cTBeHHoi1 J1 J1lDKeHepHoi1 J1H4JpacT-
PYKryp nopToB»2
BHaC'l"OHllIeeBpeMJIcorJIaWeHMRn03BOJImarMo,!\ep-
HM3Y1poBaTb CMCTeMbI Bo,!\ocHa6:meHMH 11 06ecne'll1Tb HaCeJleHMe B01\m
B CBRaM C 3TMM nOKa3aTeJleH IIpMMep POCTOBa. B 3'I"OM ropo,l:\e 140 JleT
Haaa.n TpM  Ha aCHOBe KOHJt€CCHI'1 C03.na.mt CMCTeM}' BO,!\OCHa6:me-
HI1JL Tenepb, 6.rraroMPJI '1aCTHb!M I Ha c}'MMY 40 MJIH 1J,OJl-
.naPOB, 61O,!\:meTHb!M .I\eHbraM 11 cpe,l:\CTBaM BO,!\OKaHaJia coo6ll\3 Y]:\aJIOCb
pellll1Tb npo6JreM)' BO,!\OCHa6:meHI1fI Ha .I\OJIrMe ro,!\b?
J C3P<t>.2006.N!!50.Cr.5351
2 C3P$.2006.N!!50.Cr 5549
3 MaTep8I1"'01'IBTaO4I1f1pe3IOA8HTaPoccHB.B.llyr-
Hanoeonpoca...peanH3al!l1Hal!l10H8l1bHblXnpoeKToellra3eTa
2006N!!124-n(13HIOH
-36-

O.I\HaIW ,IJ)1H TOro 'IT06bI MeXaIDf3M R'OHU,eccml sapa60TaJI B nOJIHylO
CKJIY, H;y)f{HbI  JIbI'OTbI,IJ)1H tIDH€poB, cmcpaIQeHlfe IIIX
IIJIaTbI 3a KOHl\eccmo C y<leTOM rocy.MIxTBeHHoro peryJlJllpoBamtH Tapl1-
QxJB Ha yc.rryru, OKa3blBaeMhle KOHLteccuoHepaMJ:f_ B pH,1J;e C.JIyqaeB lteJIe-
COOOpaSHbl IOCJMIIeHCalI.tfif y6bITKOB, mHeCeHHl:lX tIDH€poM Ha
nepBOM :nane C'I}XIIT€JIbCTB B OHID'! 1lpe.I\C1O 1lpJ1t5bLm1.
IIpfEleWHHbl€ saMbICJIbI 6bIJn1  B 4>e saROHe OT
30 HlOHfl 2008 r. N2 108-<1>3 ,,0 BHeCeIIJ1I11113MeHeHl-riii B 4>e.I\epaJIbHOM sa-
KOHe ,,0 R'OHU,eccJKHHbIX cornaweHJ1flXJ' III B OT,IJ;eJIbHbIe saKoHO.I\aTeJIb--
Hb!eaKTb14>e.n;epa»I_
CJJyqan JIClIOJIb3083HJm BO.n;HbIX O&beKTOB 6e3 .n;OroBOpoB II pa3pe-
lIIeHHii. He 'Ipe6YeTCH aaKJOOqeHl1e .n;OroBOpa BO,I\CIlO.JIb3OBaHII.R I-fJIM IIO-
JIY'leID1H pa3p€weID1H Ha IIOJIb3OOaHJre BO.I\HbIM O&beKTOM B c.rry<rne, eCJll1
BO.n;Hbill OObeKT IiICllOJIb3}'eTCH,IJ;Jlfl:
- cy (B TOM 'IIiIC.JIe MopCKoro cy.n;OXO,lJ;CTBa), IIJIaB8HKfI Ma-
JIOMepHbIX cy,D;DB;
-  pa30BOro B3JIeTa, paaoBoti: IIOca,!\KI1 B03;::rrIIlHbIX
cy,D;DB;
- sa60pa (IiI3'bRT11H) 1113 ID,[I:3eMH()IU BO.n;HOro 06'beKTa BO)UIbIX pecyp-
COB, B TOM 'lIiICJIe BO)J;HbIX pecypcoo. rx IIOJle3HbIe IIICKOnae-
Mble iii (11.1111) J!BJIRIOIqI1XCH IIpJ1pO.II;IIl: JIeqe6HbIMM pecypcaMY!, a TaK-
.me TepMaJIbHbIX BO)t
- aa60pa (IiI3'bHTMH) BO)J;HbIX pecypCOB B lIeJUIX o6ecne'leHJu:I IIOp-
Hoti:6e30naCHOCTI1, a T8IOKe npe.I\OTBPall\eHl1HCl1TJa
1II1iIX;
- aa60pa (1II3'1>HTtm) BO)J;HbIX pecypCOB,IJ;Jlfl CaHl-fTapHbIX, 3KO.YIOI'tf'l€-
CKI1X HYm,IJ;, a TaIOKe palU'l HJJK,D.: CY,[lOXO,[lCTBa (nonycKI1, OHI1 me ropoc
BO,i:\bl);
- sa60pa (III3'bHTKfI) BO.I1JlbIX pecypcOB cy,llaMY! B :qeJUIX 06em
paOOrbl cy,!:(OBbIX MexaHI13MOB, ycrpoti:CTB 11 TeXHWIE'CKJi1X Cpe,!:(CTB;
- IIpOBe,ll;eHWI roCY.MpCTBeHHoro MOHl1TOpl1Hra B01IHbIX 06'beKTOB 11
.[IpyrI1X npl1pOAHbIX pecypCOB;
- npOBe,!:(etrnJi re0J10rM'l€CKOro J.13yqeHM, a Ta1Ot\e reexpJ13tI'l€CK11X.
NeCKltx, KapTOIpaqnl'leCKHX, TOnorpa4ll1'1eCKI1X, rworpa4lM'le-
CKI1X, BO,l:(OJIa3HbIX pa6OT;
- OXOTbl, pH6o.rrOBCTBa, pH60, BOCIIp:>Jf3E1fJJ¥.'TB8 BO)J;HbIX 6110-
JIUI1f'1ecIGlX pecypccE;
1pr.2oo8N1!140(46971.2HIOJ1.
-37-

- OCyrn.ecTBJIeHnH 'Ip8.IU1IU-fOHOOIU IIplfJX).QOIIOJlb3OIIaIDm B MeCTaX
'Iporo npmKWBaHI-1RKOpeHHbIXMaJIOIlt1CJJeHHblXHaponOBCeBe-
pa, CH6t-1pt-l H .n;aJlbHero BocTOKa PoccJfikKoH <fIe.z1epawrn;
- CaHJiTapHoro, KapaHTI-1HHOroJ-l,lij)yrOro
- oxpaHbl OICP}"KalOlI.\el1 Cpe,QhI, B TOM 'lJ1CJIe BO)J;HbIXeKTOB;
- Ha)"IHhIX, y<le6HhIX qeJIeH;
- pa3Be.I\KJ1 J-I.I\06bNJ1! IIOJIe3HbIX J-ICKonaeMhIX, pa3Mell\eID1H H C'IpOt-l-
TeJlbCTBa,,Q0JX>rJ-l.ID1HillI1'l!iIHa6o.noTax,
3a IfCK.JIKReHlofeM 6o.nOT, 01'H€C€HHbIX K OXpaHHeMhIM EIO)J;HO-6o.rrOTHhlM
yro,QhHM, a TalOKe 60Jl0T, pa B noffMaX peK;
-IIOJIWBa CaJ\OBhIX, OropO,QHhlX, ]:Ia'iHblX 3eMeJlbHhlX yqaCTKQB, Be,Qe-
HJ1JI JIl1'ilIoro JX)J:\cofuuJ'O xromicTBa, a TalOKe BO.I\onOH CKOTa, npOBe.r\e-
HJ1JI pa60T IIO yxolrj sa CE'JJ:bCKOX03JIHHblMJ-I mI-fBOTHbIMJ1;
- K)'llaIDm HY.r\oBJIeTBOpeHJ1H J-IHbIXJII1'ilIhIX J-I6hrrOBbIX H)"K.1J; rpaIK,!\8.R
OcBo6o):\IIIB ]:IaHHbIe pa3HCEJf,.!\HOC'n1  ar oq:.opMJIe-
HJ1JI'lepe3JJ;oroBOpl.lJ-IK."I}:aTMBHblepa3pellle-
HJ1JI, 3aKOHO,Qa1'eJlb ynpOCTIfJI npoQe,Qyphl BfJAOIIOJIb3(JBI-1R. B pa,1\e
CJIy'ffi.eB 3TO C.r\e.rraHO B 11H"I'ep€CaX .Ill-14, 1I0000000IO pa3peweHWI B
«CMe:>KHhlX» BJ.1,!\ax .r\emeJlbHOCTJ1. HanpUMep, l-fCIIOJIb3OB8Ie BO)J;HhlX
OObeKTOB.IIJlfl pbl6o.TJOBCTBa If TaK cOnpCIBOm.Il8-eTCH 3aKJlIO'ieID1eM ,IJ;oro-
BOJX>B rnJIhSOBaHUR  yqaCTKaMlil, 'lTO npe}JycMar-
peHO 33IOCJHOAB-Te,m,CTBOM a BO):1HbIX 6i.mpecypcax. II03TOMY 3aI\JIKJ'l€HHe
JJ;oroBopa B011QI1OJ1h3OBa1f1U1 CTano Obi B ,lIaHHOI1 CHTyal-tJ-'lH J-l3Jlt:lIIIHJiM
}Jy6.rrn.JX>BaID1eM.
CepIUl-ryTbI11 11X 3Ha"lelDle ,IJ;JUI 8O,IJ;onOJlb3OBaHlUL B ,l\61CTByICJLqeM
BK Pel> HeT CTaTeI1 0 BO):1HbIX CepBJ.fryTax. 3TO MO)KHO 1I0HflTh KaK MOJI-
'la.ID1BYJO arMeHY BO,IJ;HblX cepBmyroB (KaK 'IaCTHbIX, TaKJ-I ny6J1WIHblX),
HeKor]:la npe1JYCMUIPeHHblX B BK ptfJ 1995 f. O)J;HaKO TaKOe 3aI\JIKJ'l€HHe
OblJlO Obi HeCKOJlbKO nOBepXHOCTHbIM: Be):1b aaKOHO,!W.TeJlb np:t:13HaeT npa-
BO CI'pBHIf'leHHoro nOJlh30BaHMJI 'iY'f'UM 3eMeJlbHhIM yqaCTIWM (3eMeJlb-
Hhle CepBI1TJThI). TaJ\OBhle MMelOT SHa'leHJ1e AJUI BO,IJ;OIiOJIh3OBaHHJL 3e-
MeJlbHhie CepBmyrbl (KaK ny6.rrwrnble, TalC If 'IaCTHhIe) npe,!JyCMOTpeHhI
CT. 23 3K ptfJ JII CT. 274-276 rK ptfJ
ComaCHO  rK P 'laCTHhIi13eMeJlbHIoIi,f cepBwryr MO-
meT YCTaHaBJIt-lBaTbCR .IIJlfl  npOKJIa):1Kt-I Tpy5onJX>BOAQB,
06ecne'lelillR BO,1\ocaa6meHt-IR H MeJlt-lOpa'--tJllt-l J-I J1HblX HYJK.D.: co6cTBeH-
HHKa H€}J;BI1)t(JlMJro "M)'W;eCTBa, KOTopble He MOryT 6bITb o6ecne'i€HhI
oe3 yCTaHOBJIeHI1H CepBI1TYTa. QaCTHbII1 cepBI1TYT YCTaHaBJIHBaeTCH
IIO cor.naweHHIO Mem,ny JlHL\OM, Tpe6yIOLII;I1M ycTaHOBJI€HJIIfl cepBwry-
Ta, J-I  COCe):1Hero yqaCTKa 11 nOJlJl€)Klfi pemCTpaQHH B
nopR,1\Ke, YCTaHOBJleHHOM .IIJlfl pentcrpaQHH npaB Ha He}J;BIDKl-1MOe
-38-

HM}'llJ;ecwo. B cnJ'iae He,lJ;OCU!:meIDfJl cornalliemur 06 yCTaHOBJI€HIIY!
CepaJ1Tyra WIt! 0 era YCJIOBJ1fIX cnop paapemaeTCR CYJ1..0M no I1CKY nll-
Wi, Tpe6YIOIl\e«J yc'I'8HOBJI€HI1 Cepal1Tyra. C06CTBeHHlIK :y'-IacTKa, 06-
peM€H€HHoro cepmlT}'TOM. BnpaBe, ec.IDI I1HOe He np€,l\YCMlrrpeHO 3a-
KOHOM, Tpe60BaTb aT nJ1Q, B mfTep€cax KOTOpbIX yCTaHOBJI€H
cepBJrryr, copa3MepHyKJ nJIaTY 3a nOJIb30BaHlle yqaCTKOM. CepBlIT)'T
He MOmeT 6bITb caMOC'I'OH1'eJIbHblMnpe,l\MeTOM KynJIlI-npO,l\a:IKJII, :mJID-
ra 11 He Mo:meT nepe]J..aBaTbCR KaKI1M-JlI160 CITOC060Mnl1QaM, He SfBJUno-
lL\HMCJI c06cm€HIII1Ja\MI! H€,IJ;BlI:mMMoro "MJIl\eCTBa, oWur o6ecne'leHJ1$1:
HWOJIb3OBam'IJI KOToporo CepBJ1T)'T YCTaHOBJI€H. lIo Tpe6oBaHJ11O co6-
CTB€HHJ1Ka 3eMeJIbHOlO Y'faCTKa, 06p€MeH€HHOrO CepBJnyI'OM, cepIDI-
Tyr MOJKeT 6blTb npeKpaIl\eH BBJ1)J;y yrpaTbi OCHoBaHIli1, no KOTOpbIM
OH 6bLJI YCTaHOBJIeH.
CornaCHO nQJIOJKeHJ1JIM 3KPlpnyfunf'ilfbl:M 3E'MeJIbHbrn CepBlITyr yc-
TaHaBJiJmaeTCH 3aKOHOM I1JIII J1HbIMJII npaBOBbIMY! aKTaMY! POCCI1i1CKOi1
tI>e)J;epaIJ;Y!J1, cyfu.eKTOB Pocmi1cKOi14:re.IJ;EpaI.\I1J1, opraHOB MeC11loro ca-
MoynpaBJIeHJ1fl. IIy6J1J1'IHbrn cepBJ-rryr YCTaHBBJIJllBaeTCJI p,rrJl 06ecneQe-
HJl!JI I1HTepeCOB roCY.l\BpCTBa, MecTHOra caMOynpaBJIE'ID1H J1JD1 MeCTHoro
HaceJIeHIIJI6e3 J13'bflTJ1J1 nOJlJlemaIl\l'lX 3eMeJIbHbIX yqacTKOB. IIp>! Heo&-
XO,lJ;Y!MOCTIl npoBowrrCJI cfuQecrneHHH€ c.nyuraHY!JL IIyfim.1trnl.ri13€MeJlb-
Hbrn cepBYIT)'T MruKeT 6bITb yt:'I8H)BJl€H, HanpJ1Mep, 'l'T06b1 06ecne'lMTb
,lJ;OCTYTIKBO)J;eOJ::num:XI. (,l\Jlfl3a60paee Bny6-
JIW-lHbIXu;eJIJIX). ECJn1 }'C.onuIffiJIEtIJ£ ny6.m.-r<rnoro cepBJ1T)'Ta IIpJ1BO,l\11T K
cyIQE:'C'TB€HHb 3aTpY.n;HeHIIJIM B HIDI 3E'MeJlbHoro Y'faCTKa,
era ro6cTBeHIDIK BIIpBBe 'Ipe60BaTb OT opraHa rocy,JIapcmeHHOii BJIaCTY!
I1IDI opraHa MeCTHoro CaMoynpaBJIeHJ1fl, YCTaHOIDlBIill1X ny6J1Y!'fHbIiii cep-
BI1TJT, copa3MepHylOIIJIaTY.
TaKJIIM 06pa30M, YMOJI'faHJ1e BK ptfJ 0 cepIMfyI<lX He «arMeHJI€'1'»
MHOl11e IIpaBoBbie B03M{))KH()CTII, CBJI3aHHble C BO.n;Oft

rnaBa 2
PA3nH'IHbIE BHtJbl
HCnOnb30BAHI1 BOtJ
1. KnACCHQ)HKA4H Hcnonb30BAHI1
BOi\HbIX 05bEKTOB.
HAH50nEE nPHOPHTETHAA
PA3HOBHi\HOCTb BOlIPnOnb30BAHH
KJIa('CI.flautlnfB3aKOHOBo,!\Hhle06'beKTbl
J-1IDf J1X ':iac-m MOryr  wrn YAOBJIeTBOpemm O)J;Hoiii J-1IDf
HecKOJIbKJ1X QeJIeii. O)J;H0M)' Jf.ID:! HeCKO.JlhKWM BO,!\on0JTh30BaTeJLIIM. B CT. 37
BK ptfJ ycTIlHOBJIeH nepeqeHb l\eneiii JfCIIO.JIb3(]3aIm BO,!\HbIX OfueKT(JB:
III1TbeBoe J:I brroBoe Bo,!\ocHafuKemre; copoc CTO':iHbIX J1
,D;peHa:iKHbIX B0.zt <mepreTJ1Ka, TpaHCTIOpT, neooaIJJaB, JIe<iE'6m,re H 03):10-
 l\eJlJ1,  pbIDHoe J:I OXO'I'ffi:I'fue XCl3HJ1cTBo, pa3-
Be,!\Ka JI! A06bI'1a nOJIe3HbIX J1CKOnaeMblX, 06ecne'ieffi:le nomapHoiii 6e30-
IJaCHOC'I'l!l Ha3BaHO TalOKe JfCD)Jlb3()BaRlf€ BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTOB B MeCTax
'lpnp:»romaHtfHJ1IXf)3J!jiJcweHIIDiiAemeJlb-
HOCTH KopeHHbIX M8JIOIll1CJIeHH Hapo,!\oB CeBepa, Cnfit:pt1, !{aJJ:bHel'O
BxTOKaPOCCHi1CtWi1f.
CTaTbeiii 38 BK pcp npe.IJyCMOIJJeH nO)Jpa3):1eneIDIe Ha BJ.-I,lJ;bI BO):lO-
I1OJIb3OBaJiJUL J1CXOM 113 yc;mmuii npe;:\OC'ffiBJI€HtfH BO)J;HblX OO'beItTOB,
Bbl,l\e.mnOT ffilJM2CTHl)e JI! o50rnGneHllOe B£W)IIt)JIb3OEaHHe.
06oc06J1eHHoe BOWIIOJIb3OBaHtf€ no CBoei1 npwpoAe HImpaBJIeHO Ha
lfJ€Cll€'l€HJf12 o50poHhI C'lpaHbI J1 6e30naCH0CTJ1 rOCY,!\apcTBa, a TalOKe
J1HbIX rocy,!\apcTIleHHbIXJ1 bIX  B CI1JI)' CT. 38 BKPIp
paCCMa'Ip1B<i€MbIJ1 BI1)\ BO,IJ;OIIO.JIb3(E  ill BO,!\HhIX
o6'beI\Tax (J1JlJ1 J1X ':iaCTHx) rocy MYHI-'lIIaJIbHo:i1 J1 ,!\ame
':iaCTHoi106oco6neHHoeEJ1CK.JIK)qaeTJ1C-
nOJlb30BaIDfe BO)J;HOro OO'beKTa.lUJYrnMl1 4Il13l1'iecKJ:IMJ'! HJlJ1 1Of'iec-
KlilMI1.m.maMJ1. Cne,JWBaTeJIbHO, ,l\aHHble BO,!\OTOKJII J1 EIO}JP€MDI,,!\ame npH
ny6.mr'iHbIx 4xJPMaX cc6cwemJxnt, He MOryT paCCMaTpJ.1BaTbCJI l\aK
BO)J;HbIe 06'beKTbl 06mero nOJlb30BaHllii
IIF"fMeHHeMbrli B BK P<IJ 2006 r. 'I'epMJ-IH «o50cooJleHHoe BQJ:IOIIOJIb3O-
BaHJ1€» BO MHOI'OM 6JTh130K K TepMJ:IHY BK ptfJ 1995 r. «oc06o€ nOJlb30Ba-
-<0-

lIYIe BO)UlbIMJ1 OObeKTaWf», OH TaR::me orpaHH'lJ1Bae-r Kpyr n0Jlb30ro:re-
Jleil c yqeTOM I.1;eJleil IIQlIIJII)JIb3OUI.
B COOTBeTCTBMI-1 co CT. 38 BK Pip no cnoc06YCTBIm Ha BO
OObEttT AI1cpeppyI{JT BOJ\on0Jlb30BaJU1e:
- C 3a60poM BO)J;HbIX pecypCOB 1IpY! ycnom.1JII11X B0313pa-ra B BO
oO'heKT;
- C 3a60poM BOJ\HhIX pecypcoB 6e3 B03BpaTa B BOj\HbIfi oO'heKT;
- 6e3 ttaKOro-JTh16o 3aoopa BOJ\HbIX peCypcoB 1-13 BOJ(HOro 06'heKTa.
TaKJ1M 06paaoM, Ha.TIt1l\O paaHble nOJIXOfIPl 3aKOHOj\aTeJIbCTBa K KJIaC-
cnqa:JKaWII'f n0Jlh30BallY!.Fl BO)J;HblMt1 ofu.eK'raMtt, HO Bee OHJ1l1MelOT nOJ\
0060iiOCHOBaHl1.R.
npaBOBbIe oco6emlOcnt perynuposaIDm BOJ\OIIOJIb3OB.}HWI B I.1;eJIflX
BOAOC J1CInJ1b3OBallYle BOJ\HbIX OO'heKTOB ,I\JIR IDITbeBOro 11
X03RioicTBeHHO--6bITOBOI'O BOJ\OCHaOID1R 1Ip113HaeTCH IlpJIDpwreTHhIM.
3rar lIpY!opl1TeT BllOJllie 060cHOBaHHO coxpaIDIeTCH B pol'CJrncKOM lIpase
BHe 38.IJJft.'I1MX'1 OT CMeHbI BOJIHbIX KO,lII2I«XJB. B 1990-e rOJlbI, 'l'I"06bI
06ecn€'n1Tb 3TOT 1Ip110pl1TeT 11 3aIW1TIITb I1CTO'lHY!KM 13O,l\OCHafuKem.rR.
6bUlO BI>I,!J;BI1liyIO aeCbMa.n;KCKyCCl10HH0e npe.ll..1I(DfreHe lIpY!lUITb J\e-
pa.rrbHbrlii 3aKOH "olIJ'1Tb€BOii BOJ\e 11 IDITbeBoMJ3OAQCIIat'im.eI» I. OJlHa-
KO 3aKOHOnpoeKT I!OCIIpOJ'I3BO. MHorne HopMbI ,D;pyrnx .pe,!\epaJIbHbIX
3aKOHOB, 11 j\aHHaH l1J\esr He 6bIJ1a peaJU13OO8Ha
CornaCHO CT. 43 BK PIp,l\JlJl I.1;eJIeH IllfTbE'BOro 11 :xo3Hi1crneHHO-6bITO-
Boro,!\OJDKHbIJICIIO.IIb3OBaTbCfl3aIWOT3arpH3-
HeHWI 11 3acopeHWI TIOBepXHOCTHbIe 11 I1O)J;3€MHbIe BOJ\Hble o6'neKTbI.
IIpill'Oj\HOCTb KOTOpbIX,I\JIR :yKa3aHHbIX lteJIeA onpeH Ha OCHOBa-
HJ1I1 caffi1TapHO-3IBfJ\€MI1OJJonN€CRJ1X 3aKJlIQ<leH.rn. JJ.JlII Ha3BaHHbIX
BOJ\HhIX OO'heKTOB YCTaHaBJillBaIOTCfl 30HbI, oKpyra caHl1'TapHoil OXpaHbl
B COOTBeTCTBI1II C 3aKOHOj\aTeJIbCTBOM 0 caHl1TapHO-OJIOIWIeC-
KOM furaronOJlY'll1!il HaceneHWI.
B 'fO me BpeMH ecTb MeCTHOCTIf, B K(Jf()pbIX CTBYffYI' nOBepXHG-
CTHbIe BOJ\Hble o&beKTbI, HO J1MeIOTCH ,nOCTa'fO'-IHble pecypcbl no,naeMHbIX
BO)];, npwO)];HhIX,I\JlRl\eJIeilIDITbeBOro l1bITOBOI'OBO)];O-
cHa6ID'!JL B HCKJIlO'-IJ1TeJlbHbIX cJIY'laID: B COOTBe1CTBJ1JII C 3aKOHOJ\a-
TeJlbCTBOM a He,!lpax H H('IVJIb3()BaIlte nOJ\3eMHbIX BO)];,[IJIH
QeJIeJI, He CBH3aHHbIX C IDITbeBblM 11 X03HiiX:rnemru..fucrom.rM BO)];OCHa6-
.m€'HJ1€M. ,lIaHHaH HOpMa, Sit npe, He OTMeHJIeT lIpY!opwreT
I1CllOJIb30BallY!H BO)J;HbIX OO'heKTOB,[IJIH IDITbeBOrO 116bITOBOro BOllOCHa6-
.m€'HWI, BCT. 3 BKPtfl2006 f.
InpoelITnporpaMMbI.Pa3BTHeKOMn.neKcaPOCCH"roc:y-
[lilpCTBeHHbICoBeTPOCci:\C<O..It>ep,epaL.ll'H.Io1KOMn.neKcl-lL>1A-
r1pHpop,a. M.,2003.C. 57.

HaCJIY'iaB03ID1KHOBeIDffiCwrya-
CR pe3€pBJIpOB8Hi' I1CTO'llillKOB rn-rrbeBoro BO.r\OCHa6iKeIDffi Ha OCHOBe 3a-
eHHblXnO)C3eMHbIXBO)J;HblXo6neK'I'OB. ITO.J\aHHOM)'BOIIpOCbIIIpI1HH'fO
llOcraHOBJIeID1e ITpaBJITeJIbCTBa Pip ar 20 HruIDpR 2006 r. N! 703 «06 yr-
Bepm,!\eHIDf ITpaBI1JI pe3epBI1pOBaHIDI I1C1U'iID1KOB rn-rrbeBoro BO.n;OCHa6-
meID1H"'. Pe3epID1pOBaID1e I1CTO'IHJ1KOB lIJITbeBoro  ocy-
Il\ecTBMeTCR rocY,l\apCTBeJfHbIMl1 opraHaMI1 cYO'beItTOB Poccmictroii
.n;ep8llW1,roropbIecMT{CPOCCI1I1I1F'oaIe.z:\paM1'
B HaCTOffil\ee BpeMfi  OOCy>K,!1aeTCR KOHqenquR
,l\epaJIl:lIOii l.\e.neBOii IIporpaMMbI ({CTaR BO)];8». yeMaH
nporpaMMa,!\oJDKHa l1MeTbTe'<HJl'IeCKJIe, ta.JIl>lIHe 113I«)
acneKTbL B ee paMKaX np€AJIaraeTCR yrneplJ;JlITb TeXHl1'feCKJ1e perJIa-
MeHThI 0 BO,IJ;OcHaOmeHID-I11 BO.n;OOTB€.lJ.('lOOL BamHocTb :noi1 npo6JIeMbI
TPYlIHO nepeOL\eID1Tb. Eo MHQjKE'CTBe ,lJ;epeBeHb 11 nOCeJIKOB BO)Jy 6epYT
J13 rnaXTHblX EtOJIOMeB, a .rraOOpaTOpI1l1, ClInCOOHHe ,lJ;eJI8Tb nOJIHOU;eH-
Hbrn aHaJIJ.-I3 mrrbeBoii BO):\bI, Mam'nfCJIeHHbL B pe3)'JIbTaTe ceMHe He
3Ha1OT, 'iTO OHI1 IIb1OT. B HaCTOHLIJ;ee apeMR He06XOIJ;JIIMO MaCIlITaOHoe ne-
peBoopymeIII1e Bcem BO,IJ;OCHaf)memrn 11 BO Hallleii c-rpaHbL
=:===:=::
BO,!\HOi1 I  camrrapHo-rt1Tl1eHlflleCKt1M HOpMaM. Ellie
60JIee He06xo,!\J1Mh! permrre.YIbHI>I MepbI no O'I!ilCTKe 11 3aLql1Te caMIDr I1C-
TO'llillKOB BO,IJ;OCHa6iKeHl1R -noBepXHOCTHbIX 11 nOJ\3eMHbIX BO.rr;HbIXofu-
eKTOB. BnOCJIe.n;IDIerOJlbIIIO,JJ;3€MHbI€ I cOCTaBJImcrr45l"(lOTBCerO 6a-
JIaHCa X03JriicTBeHHo-mrrbeBOm BOJ\ocHa6mem1R. ITpI1MeHIITeJIbHO K
ceJII>CK()fi: MeC'I1IOCTIf 110M llO):\3eMHbIX BO;J; COCTaBJlJl€T 80-85')'(c qeM
JIy'lliIe 3f«)JI{)I'J.IqecKOe COC'IOmfRe IIICT(JqH11Ka 3a6l1paeMoi1 BOJlbl, T€M HI1-
me 3aTpaTbI Ha BO):\onO)J;I"OTOBKY 11 BhIllle ee Ka'leCTB0 3 .
2. C5POC CT04HbiX H APEHA>KHbIX BOA:
OC05EHHoaH nPABoBoro PErYHPOBAHH
H nEPcnEKTHBbl COBEPWEHCTBOBAHH
PerJIaMeIlTal(Wl c6poca CTO'lHblX 11.npeHIDKHhIX BOA JIeraJIbHble 00-
pe,!\eJIeHmI)J;j)eHaJKHbIX 11 crO'1HbIXBO;J;,l\aHbI B nOJlII. 13111 HI cr. 1 BKPIp.
1 PL 2006. N!!269
2 r7aJ1eHOBaJ1. BQAaTpeBOrHawB/JPL 2008 (\J 116.311IOH. C. 7.
3 rOCYA3pcrnE!HHbIAOK1lM-oCOCTORHl1o5C1XJ)aHeOKpy>i<3lOwecpeJJ,blQ)eM-
PiI4I1HB 06lW\v' M.,2007C.471
-<2-

CnNHbIe BO mDlMaJOTCH KaK BO)J;bI, c6poc KOTOpbIX B BO)J;HbIe OObeK-
TbI ocyIl\eCTBJUIeTCR nOCJIe J1X JICIlOJIb3OBaHHH J1IDI CTOK KarOpbIX OcyI1(e-
CTBJmeTCH C 3aIpR3HeHHOiii Teppwropm!1. B C6010 Qqepe,IJ;b, .v;peHa)tCHbIe
BO -:no BO, OTBO,!\ KarOpbIX ocyIl\eCTBJIReTCR,IIJJeHamHbIMJII coopy-
MJ1]I,MI c6poca B BOJ(HbIe 06betcrbL K 1XOfCaJI€HJnO. TIpl1Be.neHHbIe
0IIpe,I],I?JI€ID1H He OTJIJf'1aIOTCR nOJlliOTOM J-f TO'ffiOCTbIO.
KaK OTMe<1aeT npo<:}:1eccop C.A EoroJu060B, no.n CTO'ffibIMJ1 BO.[(ar.rn B
Ha:y'-IHOi1: J-f ClIp8BQ<lHOl1.mrrepaType nOHMMalOTCfl Ta10Ke BO)J.be
- OTBO)J;l!1MbIe nOCJIe I1CfIOJIh3CI3afLfI B rrpou3BOJJ.CTBEHHOM TIpoQecce H
B 6mnKal1:rnee BpeMR He J-fCnOJIb3yeMbIe ]I,MI ,l\aHHoro TIpoQecca (MCa
6107/1-1986, n. 1.2.1);
- aTMociPepHbIe OCa.n;KH, OTBO)J;JIIMbIe JllIBlIelrif lOCJMM.Y!ICl.TIl CeTbIO
J1IDI c6pacbIBa€MbIe B BO)J;Hbri1 06'beKT, CBOJ1cTBa KOTOfJbIX 6bIJIH yxy,!\we-
lIbI B pe3YJIbTaTe ':IeJIOBe':lecKOiii,lJ.€HI'eJ!bHOCTJ1;
-CCY,!\OBBCOO'I'Be'I'CTBMtC Mepo,l1Hoj;j:KOHBeHql!1ej;j:nonpe,!\OT:spa-
IQeID1IO 3aIpH3HeHMR C cy.noB (MAPnOJI 73 / 78) (CTC3B 3543 - 82, n 16;'
- OTBO)J;JIIMbIe nOCJIe JtcInJIb3(E3HI!1 B 6bITOBOiii J-f nIx)J13BO
,!\eHTeJIbHOCTI-l':leJ!OBeKa (rOCT 17.1101- 77, n. 29)1.
.lWeHameM C'iHTaeTCH)'C'I"pOiicToo]I,MI c60pa H OTBo,!\a npoI-fJIbTpo-
BaHHbIX M nO,!\3eMHbIX BO,!\ (rocr 19 185 - 73, n 12). Moryr 6bITb]:lp€-
HaHbIe BO)J;bI TIp'" ocyrnemrn: 3eMeJIb, T.e. BO)J;bI, IIOCTYIDIElillIe B pe3YJIb-
TaTe ocymeHI-fR 3eMeJIbB ocyunrreJlbHyx>ceTb (rOCT 26 967 - 86, n. 72),
H ,lijJeHamHl:rii CTOK TIp'" ocywemrn 3eMeJIb, T.e. CTOK ,IJ;peHamHbIX BO,!\ no
OcyIIDITeJIbHoiii: ce-rn (rOCT 26 967 - 86, n. 70)'2.
C6poc C'I'O'iHbIX BO,!\H (J1IDI) ,IJ;peHamHbIX BO,!\ MO€T 6bITb oIpaJn{qeH,
TIp:WOCTaHOBJIeH J1JU1 sanpeIQeH no OCHOBaHJ1HM H B nopH,[\K.e, KOTOpbIe
ycraHOBJIellbI aJIbHblMJ,f 3aKOHaMH.
ComaCHO CT. 44 BK Pip 3aIIpern;aeTCH c6poc C'NYlHbIX BO,!\ J1 (J1IDI)
.v;peHaHbIX BO,!\ B BO)!,HbIe 06'beKTbI:
- cO)J;epmaLIJ;l-fe IIp'''po,!\HbIe J!e<:Ie6HbIe pecypCbI;
- 0THeCeHHbIe K oco6o QXpaHfleMblM BO)J;HbIM OO'beKTaM
3anpeIQaeTCR c6poc CTO'lHbIX BO,!\ '" (rum) )J;j)eHamHbIX BO,!\ B BO)J;HbIe
06'beKTbI, pa BrpaHHQax:
- 30H, OKpyrOB CaIDlTapHoiii: oxpallbI JICTO'lliJIKOB IllfTbeBOrO H xo3Hiii-
CTBeHHO--fucroo BO,!\oCHa6meHlm;
- nepBOM, BTOpoiii 30H OKpyrDB caHwrapHoiii: (ropHo-caHJITapHoii) ox-
paHbI JIetre6Ho---<.>.1WpomlT€.mlII:£II:: M€C'I1fXT€JI H KypDpTOB;
-pHf:o:JxpaH:m,lx30H,3anoBelIHbIX30H.
I 6or1)lJ1000BC.A., O<""KQBJJ..O.l"1octateW<bIBOJIHo"'YOJl6CY
4>anepallH(B3PaHT)lja<OHOM1032001.NIS.C.e2-83.
'2 CraH.o.a.p-rHbleTep"'HbI"BOJIHo...cnDa"(>IH. M MnpPo<x.1999
-<3-

BOCTaJIbHbIX cJIY'laID:c6poc CTO'lHbIX JIIAj)eHamHbIX BO;J;MmKeT npo-
H3B0)J;J1TbCH Ha OCHOBaHI-rn pernemrii a npe;J;OCTaBJIeHI-rn BO.ITHblX 06'beK-
TOB B IIOJIb3OBaHJte, KaK CJIe.n;yeT JII3 cr. 11 BK P<fJ.
B l!eJIOM no POCCIDl Hafuno.n;aeTCH IlOOH'I'JofBHaR TeH,r\eHlIMH K Cyt11eCT-
BeHHoMY COKpaLIJ;eHWIO C6POCOB 3alpH:llieHHllX C'1'O'iHblX BO;J;. 3a 5-7 JIeT
y,I(aJIOCb }'MeHblIDITb 06'beMbI copoca 3aIpH3HeHHbIX CTO<:lHbIX BO;J;Ha 
no cpaBlEHIDO C 06'beMaMt-l Ha<Ja.na 1990-x 1'1'. O;J;HaKO,lVlH3KOOOIWIeCI<O-
ro TpJIIYMc}Ja nOKa HeT OCHoBamri-f: 40% nOBepXHOCTHbIX JII 17% nO;J;3eM-
HblXliC'IO'lHI'fKOBBO;J;OCHa6HIDI He OTBe'ffiJOT CaHJllTapHblMnpamfJJ8M JII
HOpMaM. 3TJII 06croHreJlbcTBa Bbl3blBaIDr cIIpaae;J;JrnBoe 6eCIIJIroiicrBO
POCCIDiCKOro pyKOBO,!\CTBa, ':1'1'0 nO,!\'fepKl1BaJI B xo.n;e I1pe:m,!\eHTCI{JfX Bbl-
OOpoB 2008 I' ITpe3H,!\eHT P Jl..A Mee;J;eBI.
B2006 I'. TOJlbKO 12% oOll\ero d5DeMa C'1'O'lHblX BO.!\ m.IIDI HOpMaTillJHO
-.
IT"BhI no COBepmeHCTIIOIJaIlJUO perJIaMeHTall"H II 3apy6e3(-
Hbrn- olIblT.lv1Horne BJ.f,!\Hble n1,!\poJloru JII cnel!JffiJll'lCTbl B 06J1aCTI'! BO,!\HO-
ro  ceTYJOT Ha He;J;OCTt-DKHMOCTb MHorl-1X 3aBI>IllleHHbIX Tpe60-
BaHHi-f no O'IJIICTKe COpaCbIBaeMbIX Bolf. 3Ta n0311L\HH nplfBe.!\eHa B
OTKpbITOM IlHCbMe IIpamrreJIbC'I'BY PoccJ'Iibrofi: 4>e,lJ;epal!l1J:l. 4>e,lJ;epaJIb-
HOMY C06pamno PocCJ: 4>e,lJ;epaQt1Yl,  opraHaM nap-
TI-rn{{E.n;JrnaHPocom.,opraID13aIU1HM.
OrKpbITOeIDICbMOnO.!\flHCaAA 131f3B€C1HHX yqeHblX: AJ1. B.na)J;l1Mt-1-
POB, AD. rJIillW, B.J1. Jl,aID1JlOB-Jl,aHl1JIbffil, H.C. KaCHMOB, Mil KMpIIWI-
HWKOB, B.A Ko.necumroB, B.B. JI)'HI1H, B.I1. Ocl1flOB, B.c. lIeTpocmi.
lOA PaXMaHUH, BA PyM.m:iL\eB, M.r. Xy5JIapHH, AIQ.l!HBa.!\3e_
ITo I1X aBTVPJIT€THOMY MHeHHIO, HOpMaTillJ Ha c6poc npe,lJ;IDlCbIBaeT
c6pacbIBaTb 60JIee 'lHc'I)'lO BO.n;y. ,<eM BO)J;Hblfi pecypc, H3'bHrbifl npH 3<1-
oope. ITOCKOJlbK)' «clxJHOBbE» .!\JIR BO,!\HOro d5DeKTa KOHlJ;eHTpaQHH
BKJD(J«8IOTCJ'i B HOpMaTMBbI, TO OT :xQ3Sli:1cmyIOl.l.\ero CyD'bE'KTa Tpe6yIOT
OIIJIa'iHBaTb Te 3aI'pJI3HeHI1JI BO,!\HOM. Cpe)J.bI, KOTOpble OH caM He JJ;OII)'C-
RaJi. B wrore, RaK 3aKJlIO'ffiIOT IC'IU, HeruDRaR CHCTeMa 3KOJlOru-
':IeCKoro uop.mpoBaHHJI npHBO;J;11T K I1C':Ie3HooeHJ1iO CTI1M)'JIOB ,lVIHBHe.n;-
peHI1R l1epcneKTJIIBHbIX npupo,nooxpallllblX TeXHOJIomJL
Jl.JlII TOro ':I'1'06b1 p€Iill1TeJIbHO H3MetnITb HeraTl1BHOe nOJl<»KeHl1e C BO;J;-
Hbmrn pecypcaMJ1, aB'1'OpaMJII OTKpbrroro ID1CbMa np€,lVI<»KeHO onpe,!\e-
JIHTb Be.JJ:WllfHbIHeraTI1BHoro B03,IIeiOCTm1H Ha BO.!\Hbifl 06'beKT 3a Bbl'-IeTOM
I http://www.kandidBt2oo8D=422704
2 Kp/!€!jOB U. BOJI,HbIE! npo6JJeM'" Pocc II a.ancrv.n 11 "'3Hb. 2008. NIl 5 C. 24-27.
3TBblnI'CK/fPr.2008(\J145.1SI<lIOJ1

q,oHOBblX KOIrQeH'IP Bell\ecTB B HCTO'iIDfKe BO CtxrrneTcrnelnr
IIJIaTemJII ::!a TaKoe B03JJ;ei'rn!He TaIOKe JJ;OJImHbI 6bITb }'BH3aHbI C nepe-
CMO'I'peHHblMlf BeJll1<IJ1HaMl1  He06xo)U1Mo nepeffi11 K no-
3TaIlliOM)' .nOCTI1:IK€HMIO peaJIbHO BHIIOnHJ1MbIX HOpMaTl1BOB, n03BOJIRIO-
ll\I1X H8. npaKTIDCe npOBeCTI1 MacIlITa6H)'IQ MO,n€pHI13a.l{IUQ O'ffiCTHbIX
-
B CBR3I-f C 3TI1M n lIpHMep JfMeeTCH B rocy,!J;apcrnax
EBponeiiiGroro Cmma 11 CIlIA. TaM HopMWpOBaHJII€ B03,l\f'HcTBJ.uI Ha BO,[l-
HYJO cpeJ1Y, BK.JIKJlIaH cBpoc CTO'IHbIX BO)J;, YBH3blBaerC.R C peaJIbHbIMJ1
.RMI1 npe,nnpromnl-BO)J;onOJIb30BaTeJIell fI-f6Ka.fI CI1CTeMa
IIJIaTe:iKeiii ::!a C6POCbI He 06H::!blBaeT BO,nOIIOJIb3OBaTeJIeiii IIJIaTIITb ::!a q,o-
HOBbie xapaKTepJlC'I'J1K>I BO)J;HOro MelITa. CI1CTeMa HOPMHpOBaHIDI B EB-
pone 11 CIlIA IIpOp;yMaHa nO)J; IIOCTeIIeHHOe, HO peaJIbHO I1cno.JlHl,1Moe
)':iKeCTO'-IeHJlle HopMaTl1BOB.
IIpI1Be,!J;eIlHa.fI HaMl1 06ll\eCTBeIDia.fI J1HJ1lUIIaTIfBa BO MHOroM COBna.n;a-
eT C HaMepeHJ-reM poccHikKoro pyKOBO,!J;CTBa pe4JopMI1pOBaTb HOpMJllpo-
BaHJlle B 06JIaCTI1 J1CIlO.1Ib:3UBa1H BO,nHb1X pecypCOB. B'IaCTHOCTI1, B BO)J;-
Hoiii cTpaTerI-fM POCCI-fI-f .no 2020 r. 11 B lIJraHe no ee peaJII-f3allI-fI-f
npeAYcMOTpeH8. pa3pa50TKa HOpMaTI1BOB t\Ol1JCTI1MOI'O E\03Aa1c'rBJ.ui Ha
BO,D;Hble d5DeFtTbr, }"ffiTblBalOll\I1X pemOHaJIbHble oco6eIDiocTI111 -
Blf.1I.YaJIbHbE' xapaKTepl1CTI1KJ11 BO,D;HblX OObeKTOB.I\aK npe.nCTaBJI.fIeTCH,
4JoHoBbie I«El\f:'HIP3-lII-fI-f Tex Jtm1I1HbIX BeLqeCTB MOryr COCTaBJlRTb pe-
nYIO Jtm111H,1J) cnJlKY COO'IBeTCTBYIOIl\I1X BO-
JJ;oeMOBI1E1O,!WIOKOB, BO)J;OHOCHblX ropll3OH'I'OB. ,l(aHHaH pa60Ta BQ3JIO:me-
Ha Ha POCBO,!ij)ecypcbl, POCHe,!ij)a, Pocpbl6ononcroo (HHble 
opraHbI) 11 JJ;OJDKHa 6bITb BblllOJllieHa Ha Ha'<laJIbHOM 3Talle peaIDl3aQl1l1
Bo)J;HOiii CTpaTerllli POCCIlli B 2009-2014 IT.
3. nPABOBblE BOnpOCbl CTPOHTEJlbCTBA
H 3KcnYATAL1HH rHI\POTEXHHECKHX COOPY)KEHH
H BOI\OXPAHHHIl1
:r.l,II,pO'I'e'UIJl'JeCKoe CTpOJrreJlbC1IIO. ComaCHO CT. 42 BK Pip lIpl1 npo-
eKTI1pOBaIDBI,  CTJXllITe.JlbCTBe, 3KCILJJYaTa1lli11 peKOHC'I'-
 rl1J\POTeXHJil'leCKi1X cooi H CBOeBpeMeHHbre
Meponpl1JITl1.fI no oxpaHe BO,D;HblX OfueFtTOB 11 06ITro.1CJIl\!.IX B HI1X BO,D;HblX
:rKI1BOTHbIX 11 pacremoc
HapJl,!J;yC HOpMaMI1 BKPIp.nei-fC'TB}'€TI1)J;epa.m.HbIi13aKOH0T2111IO-
JI.R 1997 r_ NQ 117-413 «0 6e30nacHOCTI1 n coopy:me-
-<5-

HJ-rii:». B HeM paaq::HBaeTCH noHflTIIIe ITC (CT. 3 «O::HoBHbIe 1IOHHTIm»).
IIo,IJ; ITC nO,IJ;pa3}'MeBaKYI'CH: IIJIUIHHbI, 3,IlaID1fl I1f,!1JX)<JJ1e
BO,I:\IX'6pocHlde, BO,IJ,OCIIyCKHb If  mopym:emm, T)'HHe-
Jill, l\aHaJIbI, HaCOCHble craHQID'i, CYWXQJ:J;lIbE lllJII03bl, cy.nono,IJ;DeMH\'fKlI;
COOpymEHl1H, npe,1l)Ia3Ha'leHHble.l\lliI 3aLqWI'b1 OT  If pa3py-
IlIeHMM 6eperoB BOP;OXpaHJ1JIJ1lQ, 6eperoB J1.l\Ha pycen peK; coopymeHUJ'I
():1aM6bI), orp101W1e XpaH)f{UJUCmr 0'JX0,lJpB npDMbllllJIeHHbIX
Ifceorii, ycrpoi:1crBOT pa3MbIBa Ha Ka-
HaJIaX, a TaRme.l\PYI11e mopymeID1H, npe,1l)Ia3H3'1eHHhIe.wm IfClI0JIb30-
BaHIDI BO,IJ;HbIX pecypCOB J1 npel\CYI'BPaIQeHIDI Bpel\Horo B03):\eHcTBIDI BO):1
If )KW)\KJ1X arx0):10B.
113 3TOro HelIOnHoro nepe'lJK:.1IelIIDI BUJnIO, 'lTO ITC pa3.m1'-lHbl lIO
CTelIeHt1CTBU.H H3 BO):1H)'lO cpe)Jy If  3H3'leHmD.
KJJRCCfilfTCa8KOHO,IlaTeJIbHerrpOlf3Be,JL
ITo Mec'I)' pacTIQJIom€HMJ'I fTC paa):1ellillOT H8 Mopc:KJlle, pe'-lHble.
DaepHble, npy,o;oBbIe. fTC nOJ\Pa3J\eJUIlOTT8tOKe 1f,lij)YJ11M 06pa30M:
- B0):10TIo.n;rropHble (nJl(YI'I1HbI, .naM6bl);
- perYJlHQ!W1IHbr (H3npliIMep, CY):10BbIe XO,IJ;bl);
- BOJ1OIIPOBOJ1-Hre (aKBe1JYKI'I, TJ'HHeJI!iI);
- nycKHble (BoJ\oc6poCbl, 6bICTpOTOKJII);
- BO)J;oaa6opHbIe;
- CTIeqMaJlhHbIe (lllTIKJ3bI, cY):10IJ(),l:ilaOOf, I1pJ1'IdJIbI, lli1pCh1);
- rl-fJ\POy3JIbI IWMIIJIeltCHoro HaSHa'1eHIDI
B4Ie,IJ;epa.nbHoM aaltOHe OT B HOH6pH 2007 r. N2 261-4\3 «0 MOpCK!iIX
nopT3x B POC'CHiiclroiiepaI.\Hl'fJ10BHeCeHlfJIlf3MeHeHMMBOT.J1eJIbHble
a8KOHQ)1aTeJIbHble 8K'I'bl PexuDicI«jf 41eJ\epaL\!iIIiI,,2 TepM!iIH «rMJIPOTex-
HM'-IeCKJlle coopymeHIDI» p8cKpbrr nO)J;HeCKOJlbI\D J1PYT'I1M yrJIOM. ITopro-
Bble fTC - 3TO J1IDKeHele cooPY)K€H!iIJI (6epero3all:tttT-
Hble COOpptreJillH, BOJIHOJJOMbI, ,IlaM6bI, MOJIbI, ID1pCbl, npH'-laJIbl, 8 T8tOKe
ITQlJ;XO,lJ;HbI€ KaHaJIbI, nO,!J;BOAHble COOpptreJillH, C03,IJ;aHHhIe B peaYJIbTaTe
rrpoBe,IJ;eHJ1H ,IUlOyrny6wreJlbHbIX pa6OT), paCnOJIDm.€HHble Ha TeppliITO-
pID'! If (11.ID1) 8KBaTOpffi'I MOpc:KOro nopTa, B3aJ1MO.lI€i1cre c BO)J;HOi:1
cpeAOH If npe)J;Ha3H8'1eHHb!e.l\lliI o6ecne'1€Ht1.fI 6e30IIaCHOCTM MOpeI1JIa-
BaHIDl J1 crOmiKJII CYP;OB. ITopTOBble fTC HapJ'I)J;y C BHyrpeHHMM!iI pei:1M-
MJII BXO)J.m' B 06'beIt'l'bl J1Hcl>pacrpyRTypbI MOpc:KOro nopTa.
B4Ie):1epaJIbHbIX3aI\OH8X«O€CItI'IXCOOpy-
meHJ-rii:», «OMOpCK!iIXnopraXB4IeJ\epaIJ;l1HJ'!oBHeceHID1lfa-
I 5cmbllJaRpOO:;HcKaSl/npep,ceA(ITebp6,!\l<oe"'IO.C.OCnOB.T 7 M 113,1\-
BO«EoJ1bwa.,2001.C.106-107.
2 C3f'<!) 2007 N!!46. Cr. 5557
-<6-

MeHe:FlJ1¥i B OT,l\eJIbHbIe 3aKOHO,l\aTeJlbHble alITbl PocanicKcJji nV'
He onpe,lJ;eJleHb! MaTepffilJlbI, 1-13 KOTOpblX CTpOHTCH 1-1 peKOHCTpYJ1PYlOfCJI
rrc. B HayqHoti: .ID1TepaType I'OBOp:11TC.f1 0 pa3JIWIHb1X C'Ip(MTeJIbHbIX Ma-
Tepm..nax (rpYHT.ImMeHb, 6eTOH, rop83,l\O peme - ,l\epeBO). M3 3'TI1X MaTe-
pillUloBMOIyrCOOPY,l\J1TbOCTpOBa1.KaKJt:3BeC'lH),,l\aM6a,
lOIl\aH I'. CaHlIT-IIeTep6ypr OTHaBOp;HeIDm, B SHa'll-l'reJlbHoti: CBl}-
ei1: 'laCThl KaMeHHo-3eMJIJIHafl. COOpy.i\eHa OHa Ha npe.lVJapl-1T€JlbHo OOMe-
JIeIDIOM rpyHTe. Crre.n:OBaTeJlbHO, ITC(BJ1X'lIiICJle1-1 nOpTOBble)MOIyr pac-
CMaTpI1BaTbCH ImK CJlmKHble J1MYll-\eCTBeHHbIe IOCNIl.IEHCU, KY,lIa BXO.l\.HT 1-1
HCKyCCTBeHHO C03)J;aHHbIe 3eMeJIbHbIe }"IacTKJ1.
lIo.v;KpenneHHbIii C':OOI'B€'fCTByI npaBOBoti: 00301:1, qJe,l\epa.lIbHbrii:
saKOH «0 6eaonaCHOCTH n.1,1q)OTeXffil'leCKlfX coopymemrii» Ct1,l1eJ»KI1T
BecbMa .meCTK)'IO pefJIaMelITa npoeK'nq){JBaID-Ifl, cTp0J1TeJIbCTBa,
BBO,!\a B 3Kcn.nyaTaumo 1-1 Bbmo,!\a 1-13 3Kcn.nyaTaUID1, caMoi1 3Kcn.nyaTa-
UID1, peKCHCJPYKl-\l'llf, KfilIJ1TaJlhHOM)' peMOHT)'. BOCCTaHOBJIeHMIO 1-1 KQH-
cep3aI.{lnl rrc. J\.rrrotleooi1: J1HCTmyr mHHOro 3aKOHa - ,l\eltJIapao6e-
sonaCHOCTII. 31m ,l\OKYMeHT npe,lJ;OCTaBJIfleTCfl co6cTBeHHI1KOM J1JI11
3Kcn.nyaTl1p)'IOei1 opraHJl3aQJM3i B  opraH YTBe(»K.!lfllJte
,l\eltJIapawm HWopHbIM opraHOM n03BO.lli!eT 3aHeCTI-I rrc B CIIeLg:1aJIb-
Hbrn: perMCTp. TOJIbKO nacJle no,JJP6Hm1 «I" If QmHaHroEOro
CJ6ecnetIe1lJlH OTBeTCTBeHHocm co6cTBeHHJlKOB IfJUil 3KCn.JJYaTl1p)'IO'-W'IX
opraHl13aIJ;l'li1: sa IIOC.IJe,l\CTBJffi asapJ1i1: Bbl,!\aeTC.fl IDU\eJl3JUI Ha 3KCn.nya-
Tauorrc. Bc.rryqae HeCOrJIaCIDIX03flti:CTBJIOllU1Xcy6DeKTOBc np€,IJ;!IJII-
caffi:lHMt:l opraHoB Ha;J;30pa npOBO):\l1TCH ITJJaTHaJI rocympCTBeHHa.fl 3KC-
nepI'Maa,,l\aIQw;afI  rocY,l\apCTBeHHbIM HdJ!;3OpHbIM opraHaM
yrBep,lJ;Wfb HJU1 He yrBep,lJ;J1Tb ,l\eltJIapaI.\l-UO, npmu'lMaTb lllibIe 3KCn.nya-
TaI.{I10HHbIe perneffi:lH.
K C':CImaJIewno, B Hacrom.u.ee spewr no npWD1He IW.K BHyrpeHHero He-
COBeJM8lCTBa, TaK If npaBOBOro mtmmt3Ma npHMeHelilfe HaSBaHHoro 3a-
KOHa BeCbMa 3aTpY.l\HeHO. 3.n;eCb CKa3bmalOTCH OTCYTcTBlie HeOOXO)J;J1Mb1X
npa,l\OKYMelITOB,He,{€TKOCTbKpJ1'repHeBrrc,no,!(-
JIe:ma ,l\eKJIaPJIpOB<UllnD. fOCY,llapcTBeHHbrn: }"leT 06'belITOB BO,l\HOro
X03HflCTBa Ha,!\Jle:lKaM 06pasoMHe Be.n;eTCJL HeT  If non-
RbIX CBe,l\€tOOI 0 lIDIDl'lecTBe, TeXlIWIeCIDIX xapaKTepI1CTill\aX, MeCTe
pfl3Ml2I4eHJlfl IfBe,l\OMC'fBeHJIDi,i npMHa,QJ!emHOCTJII rrc. J1JmelITapJll3a
ITC npOBO):\l1TCH HeKa'leCTBeHHO, BeJIHKa,AOJUI HeytrreHHbIX rrc"'.
1Mopcmii3H4I1CJ1OBapb,B3T.T.l/nOJ\pe,!\.B.B..IJ,M..-rPHeIl8..Jl..CyJlOCTpoe-
HHe,1991 C.325-326
2 CM. l<a3BaHHbOe MaTep"anbO K -xpyrnOMY CT0"Y" Ha TeMY; -3aKoH POCC"CKO" ClJep,epa4l1"
.OfCODPYJKeH"""

3aKOH He.IJ;OCTaTQ'IHO 0603Ha'W.eT p83IDfLl)' B npaBOBOM cTaryce c06-
CTBemffiKOB, H60 TaKOBblMJl! MOryr 6bITb l\aK 4Je.IJ;epawm, TaK J1 ee cy6D-
eKTbl, M)'HJ 06pa:mBaHJ1J1, Kp1.IUI'1ecro J1 4>J.13W1€CKMe.ID1-
. RaK J1 B 3aKOHe «0 MeJlllOpaQIUl», He npe,l\YCMaTpI1BaJI npaBOBoiii
Me"'\aHJI3M pa3.IJ;e.n:eHl1.ll fTC no npJI3HaKY rn6cTBeIlliOCTIL 0 MYIUll-\l1-
rraJIbHoiiico6cmeHHorTIl Ha ITCJII1llIb ynOMl1HaeTCJI, poJIbMj'Hl1l-lHIl3JI11-
TeTOB nO.D;p06HO He paCCMOTpeHa. B K3':1eCTBe pe3yJlbTaTa He.IJ;OCTaTO':IHO-
ro BHJ1M8HHH 3aKOHO.IJ;aTeJIfl K 3TOiii np06J1eMe npOJll30WJIO yme
ynOMHHYTOe BbDlle Kpai-hIe HeY,lla'lHOe pacnpe,l\eneHJlle ITC Mem;:Jy c06-
CTBeInUIKaMJI, npJIIBe,l\lllee K 'Ipe3MepHOiii.IJ;eu;empaJIl13al-\l1J11H,l{a ITC.
HanpOTJllB, Hf:' 06'beKTbI He J1MelOT qx,,QepaJIbHOro 3HaQeHJIIJI, HO
If8XOWITCH B CcfcmeHHocTIl 4Je.IJ;ep3ql111.
B HaCTOmll.ee l3pE'MfI pa3paOOTbIBa€TCJI npoeKTHOBOiii pe,!-\3KIl;Jlll14Je.IJ;€-
paJlbHOro 3aKOHa «0 6e30naCHOCTJII rn,I!J)(rreXHWleCKJIIX COOPY'Kemrlii», B
KOTQpoiii lIJIaIDlpYeTCJI BOCTIOJIIDITb nMeI rrpo6eJIbl npaBOBoro pe-
ryIDlpOBaID1H 0'I'H0IlEHJ'1ii B OMaCTJII rn,IIJXYI"€XHWIecKOro CTpOJIIT€JIbCTBa.
B XXa pa3BJ1TI11e 3KOHOMJllKJllnmpe6oBaooMacrnra6Horo rn,IIJXYI"€XID1-
':IecKOro CTpoJllT€JIbCTBa. IIpeBpaI1-\€HJIIe KpyrrHeii:rrn1x peK B q€IIb BO.IJ;Oxpa-
lIJ1JII1I.Q;npl1BeJlO KHapyweHl-fiO l-\eJlOCTHOCTJll SfOCJCI£rEM 6acceillia, pa3MbI-
BY 6epel'OB J'I pyceJl, nepE$:JpMJtpCEalUoo pe<iHbLX J'I 03epHbLX ,l\0JiJIIH. Ho
HeraTJllBHble IJIBblcrynalOT J'lB.l-IPYJ11X 4opMaX: 33J11J1eID-Ie lIO':I-
BbI, BpeMeHHoe 3aTOlIJleID-le npemHJIIX CyxHX 3eMeJIb, no.zn,eM J'IJIJII na;:J;eIDfe
IpymoBbLX BO)-I, 113lIEHeHIWi' JIe,i:\OBOIii: oOC1'aHoBEJ'I. CMeHa $ITopb! J'I Q:>a)'HbL
HaITOJIHeHJ1e BOJIOXP8HH.ID1lI-\ J'I rrpoBe,Qetrne KaHaJlOB IIpaKTJ'IY:eCKM
BCerna Tpe6ye-r np€,D;BapIT€'JIbH:)i,j 3BaKyaJJ;I-1l1H3CeJleIDfJI, I1epeHoca CHO-
ca 3,JJ;aHI1iii J'I CTpoeIDIH. IIpJII :nOM B OCHOBHOM npo€RTbI CTpOJITeJIbC'TBa
npe,DyCM3TpHB3JIJII I1epeMeH)' 3eMeJibHbLX J1 BO,!J;HbLX IIpaB npJll'i3CTI1bLX
JII1I-IIIOXO)-\JI, HBO'lHb1M I10pH,IUroM, He 3aOOrHcb 0 Ha):Vlemall-\eM otl:qJMJle-
HJ'IJII. 3To 06'bf1CHHeTCH fJ'I'CYI'C'IBJ1 ,i:\OJDKHbLX 'I'p€6oBaHHit ,i:\eIii:CTBJ'lOU-\e-
ro sa TQ BpeM.fl33KOHO.IJ;aTeJIbCTBa no Y"-eTY 'W.CTHbIX I!lH'I'€peCOB.
C nf,lij)(JTeXHl'1'l€'Cltl1M C'IpOI1T€JIbCTB TaJOt\e CBJl3aHa npo6J1eMa
Bpe,IJ;HOrO B03,l\eiicTmm BOA l1Horna IIJIOTJllHbI  npJlMO Ha T€R-
TOID-l'leCIDfX pa3JIOMaX, a J1X nO,!-\I1op OXBaThIB3J1 celii:CMJII'!eCKJlle 30llbl,
':ITO yaeJlJll'il1J1o yrpo3Y B03HJllKHOBeHJIIJI ':IIX'3BbI'ia-f1HblX l11'I}'aLIIm. Kpo-
Me TOro, HaIlQJIHeHJlle BO,i:\OXpa MomeT YHJll'tTO:HCl1Tb J'IJIJII t130JI11-
poBaTh MecTO 06J11TaHJIIJl MHOI'JIIX l-\eHHbIX Bi-fJ-lOB 4>JlOpbI J1 Q:>a)'HbL JJ:orry-
ll-\eHHbIe paHee 0llIJll6KI1 npenO,!-\aJIJII HaM xopOlIDdi ypOK. PN\
I1pOH3BOJIbHblX pewemrn 0 CTpOJIITeJIbCTBe ITC J'I (\(JJ¥)XJJaIOOIJfil\ 6bLJIJII
OTMeHeHbI J'IJIJII XDTH 6bl npHOCTaHOBJIeHbl B Wifc'rBm.f.
HaCTOHl1tt1M- ,i:\OJII'OCTpOeM OKa3aJlOCb B03Be,neHJlle ):\aM6b1, 3al1\t1ll-\3-lO-
I1\€Iii: r. CaHKT-IIeTep6ypr OT MOpcKI1X H3BOIJ;Helrn:ii 3To IOCJMI1JIet\'.C no
-48-

CBOeM}' Ha3Ha':ieID1lO coopymeIDIe (B Hee BXO)J.m' aBTOTpacca If ,lIpyrne
KOMMJHI-fiW.u;mI)TaIOKenpI13BaHaCOe,!J;J1ID1Tbo.Kar.ID1H,r,[le
r. KpoHlllTa.n:r. C npOn1BOIIlJilliG1l1lMU 6eperaWf HeocKoi1ry6bJ. B 6ypHbie
1990-e H. OlIaCaJlaCb, 'ITV0'fC€<IeHIIaH.naMD0i1 HeBCKaH
ry6a OKOlJ<IaTeJlbHO narepHeT CBH3b C OC'l'aJlbHbIM HCKJilM 3aJIMBOM 11
IIpeBpaTI1TCR B CTOH'-Iee 3H'IpOnoreHHOe 60J10T0. OaKO nOCJIe nepepbl-
Ba C'I'plMI'eJlbCTBO ,lIaM6b1 EI0306HomfJlOCb, HO C yqeTOM onpe.r\f'.JIeHHbIX
Tpe60BaHIDi
ComaCHO CT. 42 BK Pq> npHnpOeKTIlpOOaHlDl If pa3Mer..qeHlrn, C'l'pUl1-
TeJibCTBe 11 peKOHC'I'pyKLll1J1. a TalOt\e 3KclIJlyaTalV-111 ITC 5yeTCfl
cBOeBpeMeHHo npe.uyCMa'I'pI1BaTb 11 npoBOlUfl'b M€pCUpJ1HTlVI no oxpaHe
BO)J;HblX O\h.eKTOB, If X cp.nOPb! If Q:>a)'HbL 3anpell\eHO J13MeHeHl1e rl1,!\po--
JIOlWlecKOro pemI1Ma BO)J;HbIX ofueKTOB, ciicTBoBaHHblX-
C'l'BeHHbIMl1 GfCTeMaMH, KOTOpoe MruKeT npl1BeC'l'I1 II: HapywelOOO I1paB
Tpe'1'bI1X JII1Q. Be;:J;b CJIeAC'IEreM CTpol1T€JlbC'l'Ba lIJIOTl1Hbl ffiJJlHeTCR no-
BbIIIIeHI1e ypoBHII BO)J;bl, Heperoro BbIIlIe IJJIaHJBbIX OTMeTOK. 3To MruKeT
nOBJIe<ib BblHy)l\,!\eHH)'lO cMeHY MeC'l'a mrreJIbCTBa, 6ecqepeMOHHoe 3a-
TOlIJleHl1e HeABJDKI1MOCTII If T.,IJ;
Ivhrorne Bpe,!J;Hble nOCJle,!\CTBYlH ,[IOJDKHbI )"!JfTbWaTbCH B IIpOeKTax
C'I}XJHTe.1IbCT rrc If BQl\ B pa3pa6aTbrnaeMble npoeKTbI
IJ;eJlecoo6pa3Ho BKJllO'IaTb J1MYll\ecTBeHHble 11  KOMIIffI1
3eM.llE:'IlO.1lb3 HO eCJIJ1 1f3-3a HI1X CTOI1MOCTb npoeKTa 6y.n;eT Bbl-
me, ':ieM BbIrO,[Ia OT era pe<iJlI133Q1.1U, 3 HeraTMBHble noc.ne,ncTBJfR 6y1JYT
CJlI1lllKOM BHJlillITeJThHbI. ':iT06bl J1X Ha3BaJIJ1 no60'IHblMJ1, TO npeiVIo-
lD1e a CTpol1TeJlbCTBe ITC If HanO.JIHeHI1R BO,!IOXpaHJ npH HeM 6y-
l1eTcnpaElt'.AJUfBOOTKJIOHeHo.
B 3aKOH0l1aTeJlbCTBe norca He onpe.n;eJleH npaBOBOn pe:Ha1M OCTpOBOB,
B03HJfiUlIUII!I'IX npl1 H8IIOJIHeHI1J1 BOJIOxpaHlfJIYIll\ 1f3 nOBbllIleHHblX yqaCT-
KOB noi1M If Teppae. am OCTpOBa 3a'iacryro He yqJITbIBaJII1Cb B lIpoeK"fHOi1
,D;OKyMEICTpOY!TeJlbCTBa BO,I],OXpaIDlJDtW,a. He npoXO,!J;Y!JIl1TOlIorpa-
Q:>o-1'IE'CKJlO C'beMKJ. He 6b1JI11 0603Ha'ieHbl B xo,!\e C1pOI3OIU
yqeTal.Me)I\,!\JTeM, OIDIo6JIa.r1aK>TIf
IJ;eHHOCTblO If Hepe.n;KO 3aCTpal1Ba1OTCfl ,lVi<IaMJ:!. KaK rrpeJ1C'T8BJ1J1eTCf1, ':Yfy
npo6.rreMY ell\e II})€ACTOI1T pelill1Tb rrpaBOml H8yKe.
YpoKHUnepcnelNl1Bbl MeJIlIB coB€TCKJ'1iinepI10AI\JllO'I€Bb!e
peWeHl1H B OMaCTI1 Me..1II1OpaIJ;H111IpJ1HJ'2lIW.JIJ1Cb B yc.oomVIX KOMalWlo-
HI1CTpaTI1BHOn CI1CTeMbI ynpaBJIeIDIH. :HecKom.Ko ,[IecHTKOB JleT
1OIDIpOI3aJiJ'1 caMOcrOJITeJlbHble (BlIJlarb 1J.0 ypOBHH OT,l\eJlbHOIU
I U!!afilJ8.l1.B.J1JJiJ.OnpaI!OBO"'cTaTYCeOCTpoBOBBOAOxpaH""HUIpaUjotHII
npaBo.2007N3.C33-37
-49-

MMHI1CTepcTBa Coma CCP) opraHbl, oC)'llIeCTBJlffiJllll1e MemfOpaw-no no
Bcei1 c-rpaHe. IIpI1 :nOM ynOJIHOMO':leHHble roCYAapCTBeHHble opraHbI (CO-
I03Hbie J1 pecny6.1ll1KaHCKl1e :MI1HJI!CTepcTBa MeJD-1Opa J1 BO.n;HOro xo-
3Ri1CTBa) He OTBe"laIDI 3a KOHe"IHbIe pe3YJlbTaTbL
Bcer,Qa Cy:Il\eCTBOBa.rra J1 ee O,QHa npo6.rreMa - HeXBaTKa KBaJD1-
4JMW1poBaHHbIX Menl10paTopOB. B pe3)'nbTaTe «ynY'-lllIeHl1e" 3eMJlI1
Hepe,lJ;KO He Jl.aBaJlO 3aIIJIaHJ1pOBaHHblX pe3YJlbTaTOB. Ha :no Heranrn-
Hoe oOCTORTeJlbCTBO Ha.JIO»\IIJIaCb HerOTOBHOCTb MHOI'J1X CeJlbCKOXO-
3Hi1cTBeHHbIX IIpeJJ;IIpJ1HTI1ii OCBOJ1Tb npeo6pa3yeMbie 3eMJlJ1. B J1Tore,
no COBpeMeHHHM paC'leTaM, B POCCJ1i1cKoi14'e,lJ;eBl60Jlee 2 MJlH ra
opornaeMbIX J1 1 MJlH ra ocynraeMblx 3eMenb HaXOJ\HTCH B HeY,IJ;OBJle-
TBDplITeJlbHOM COCTOHHID:!.
TOJibKO B KOHLle XX B., B yCJlOBI1RX pbIHO'iHOii: Pe<PoPMbl, 6blJl pa3pa-
60TaH J1 npl1HRT lPe,lJ;epa.1il>1IHH 3aKDH OT 10 slHBapH 1996 r. N2443
«0 MeJD1opa11 3eMeJlb", KOTDpbrn: B03JlO)KJ1Jl (KaK::ITO J1 ,lJ;OJlmHO 6bITb)
 ::Ia ce.JIbCKOX03Ri.icHllJIO MeJlJIqmu1ID Ha roCY,lIap-
CTBeHHb!e opraHbI, arBe<JalOlQl(€ 3a CeJlbCKOe xrosriiicToo.
B ::!TOM 3aKOHe onpe,L\eJlHlOTCJI 11 npMMeRHIOTCR TaKl1e nOH.H1'I1R, K8.K
MeJll1Dpau;J1R 3eMeJlb, MeJll10paTJ1BHble MepoI1pJ1JiTJ'1H. MeJll1Dpl1pyeMble
3eMJTI1, MeJll10pa-rnBHble CI1CTeMbi (CT. 2 ..QcooBHbIe nOHHTI1H"). MeID1o-
pau;J1R ::IeMeJlb (OT nanrncKOro «YJl)"illleHl1e") - KopeHHoe YJI)"illIeHl1e
3eMeJlb nyreM IIpJBe,L\eHWI I'J'J,,!JJXYI"eXIDl'lecKI1X, KY.I!b'fYPT€XIDl'lecKl1X,
XJ1MWJ:eCKI1X, npOTI1B08JXX3H0HHbIX, arpoMeJUw::>pa'I1lBHblX, aIpJI'€XHtNe-
CKI1XJ1,l1pyrl1X MeJll10paTMBHb!XMeponprunl1i1:. M3npl1BeJ\€HHOronepe"l-
RH cJleAY€T, 'ITO MeJll1opaH ttaK X03ffiICTBeHHafI ,IJ;€HTeJibHOCTb IDlliIb
oT'lacm COBna,!\ae-r C BOJIHbIM xo:miicrnOM POCCl1J1. CaMl1 MeJIl1opaTJ1B-
Rble CI1CTeMbi - KOMITJleKCbI B3aIfM)ClI.JI3a I1 11
,lIpyrnx coopymeHJ-rl1: J1 yt."l'pOiiCTB (KaHaJIbI, Kru1.J!eK'I"OPH, Tpy60npoBo-
I, EIO,l1OXp8HU.IDfiLIti, llJ1OTHHhl, ,lJ;aM6b1, HaCOCHble CTaHQl1M, BO,Qoaa60pbl,
,lIpyme COOpymeHMJI J1 }'C'I'POi'ic'rB Ha Me.mIOpHJXIB8HHbIX 3€MJmX), KO-
TOpble o6ecne'll1BaIOT C02,l\8}ille onTJ1MaJIbHoro BO,!:\HOro, B03.n;yuIHOro,
TennOBQro J1 rn-rraTeJIbHoro pe)J{IDIJOB nO'iB Ha MeJll10pI1poBaHHbIX 3eM-
JIIDi:. MeJD10pl1pOBaHHble 3€MJII1 - ::!TO 3eMJll1, r,iJ;e y.-Ke IIpJBe,!J;eRbI MeJD1-
opaTI1BHble MeponpJ1HTIl!Jf, MeJlJropnpyeMble ::IeMJII1 - ::ITO ::IeMJll1, He,!:\o-
CTaTO':IHOe IIJIoJ\opo.l1lf€ KOTOpblX ynY'llllaeTCR C nOMOLqbIO
oCYl1\eCTBJIeHl1R MeJlliOpaTl1BHbIX Meponp11flTJ1iii.
CornaCHO CT. 11-16 3aKOHa «0 MeJll10paLll111 3eMeJlb" MeJlI10paTI1B-
Hble CJ1CTeMbi 11 OT,IJ;eJlbHO pacnOJlOmeHHble rrc MOryr 6b1Tb BO BCex
clx>pMax co6crnemrocm: rocYJl.apCTBeHHoi1 (lPe,lJ;epa11 11 ee cyfu.ex-
TOB), MnaJlbHoi1, 'laCTHOi1 qaCTHaR co6cTBeHHocTb Q:lJ1:3W1€CIU1X
J1IOpJWfIlecKJlX nl1L\ B()3M())KHa Ha Menl10paTI1BHble CI1CTeMbI KaK 06-
-50-

ll\ero, TaK H HH):\mJJ1,[Iy8JIbHOro rrOJIb30Bamm. IIpe,l()'cMaTpHBaeTcfl
T8Kme BapI1aHT 05ll\e:i1: co5CTBeHHOCTI1 TJ:BYX IilJiI1 HeCKQJJbKMX JII1'-1 Ha
MeJi/ilOpaTIlBHbIe CMCTeMbl.1-1:3 CT. 2 3aKOHa MbI Y3HaeM, QTorOCY.r\apcT-
BeHHbIMI1 MeJII10pan1BHbIMI1 CI1CTeMaMI1 flBJIfllOTCfl Te H3 HI1X, KOTe-
fJbIe, HaXO.I\flCb B roCY.r\apcTBeHHoi1 C05CTBeHHOCTJII, o5eCne'lI1BalOT
oe JII (J1JII1) Me»oI:03ID1CTBeHHOe BO.I\Opacnpe,!\eJIeHJlIe H
npOTJlIBOnaBO,!\KOBYIO 3aUUfTY. K rocy,!\apCTBeHHbIM OTHOCflTCH TaKme
npOTJlIB03po3HOHHbIe JII naC1i5l JIeCHbIe Hacam,n;eHI1H ro-
cy.napcTBeHHoro 3HaQem1R.
!1CKJIlQ1JaeTCH llII1poKO 6bITOBaBrnaH B IIpoll1JIOM npaKTJlIKa HaBH3bI-
BaHJ1R :3eMJIeII.IJIb3TeJIHM pa3JIJIItIHbIX MeJIJlIopaTl1BHbIX MepollpI1H-
TItiI. 3eM.IIJIIMOIyrCaM>1npoBO,!\JlITbopoclITeJlbHbleHocyIlIJII-
TeJlbHbIe pa6oTbI, CTpOl1Tb npy.IU>I iii IilHbIe BO.D;OeMbL Ho I1X npaBa
orpaIDl'leHbI OIlpew.neHHbIMJII 'l}J€6oBamlHWL CTaTbH 32 3aKoHa «0 Me-
JllM)paQI'Bf» CO,[lep)KJIIT rJIaBHOe :3I«)JJ(I1f'reCKOe Tpe60BaID1e K IIpOBe,!\e-
HJIIK) Me.JIl10paTIlBHbIX MeponplilHTI1i1: - OHl1 He .r\OJDKHbI IIpJfBO.r\HTb K
yxyroueHmo COCTORHI1.fI oKpymalOIl\ei1 cpe,!\bI iii nO,[\'IJIIHHlOTCH Tpe50Ba-
HI1.fIM 3eMeJTbHoro, BO,IJ.HOro, JI€CHOro. YHI1CTl1qecKOro. ropHOro iii npl1-
aHHOOO 3aKOHO,!\aTeJlbCTB I .
PcrynllpoBaH11C BOAOIlOIIb308aHIUI lIa BOAOXIJIDIIIJII ComaCHO
CT_ 45 BIt P<P 2006 r_ TIpaBI1JIaMl1 HCJ1OJIb3OBaHHH BONfuIX pecypCOB BO-
,l1OXp3IUf.IlIfilt oopE',l1l".TIHeT pe)KJ1M I1X IfCIIOJIb3()BaHI1.fI, B TOM <nfCJie pe-
)KJ1M HaI1OJIHeHU.fI iii cpa50TKM :EI()):IOXpaHI
llpa6UM UC1WAbJ06a1tUJt eoch-tblX pecypcoo eoaoxpa1tUJ1.U YT-
BepI{JTCH,l\JIJI Kaiti,!\oro ynDJIHOIIpaBl1-
TeJlbCTBOM P4I ,!\epa.n:bHhIM opraHoM 1IT€JIb1J')Jl BJIacTJI!.
IIpaBJ.1JIa IICJDJIb3OB9.IDf BONfuIX pecypcoB BO.I\OxpaIDfJrnIIJ,a .nOJDK-
HbI cO.I\epataTb:
- xapaKTepl1c::rma1 ru,!\poy3JIa, BO.D;oxpaHI1.1IJ1I48 (HeCKOJIbKJIIX BO.D;o-
xpaHl1JIl1Il\ IIJ]J1 KacKa,!\a l3O.r\OXPaHI1JIJmU H I1X B03M(J)KHOCTeII. rr03BOJUI-
lOuurx peryJIl1poBaTb ypoBeHb BO)J;bl B BO.QOXpaIDWn$X;
- 0CH::I3I!HE' napaMeTpbI J1 xapaKTepHcTIrKI1 BO.r\OXP8IiHJIJIIlU8, B TOM
"iJIIcne mpM8.1lbHl:>ri1 BQ[IOI1O,[(II(pHbrii ypoBeHb, MJIXlx>Me1pJ1'IeCKJ1e, ru,!\-
pawnf'll2CKlle, rn.npo.rronf'leCKlle iii TepMJf'IeCKHe xapaKTepl1<::rHKJ1;
- COCTaB J1 KpaTKoeanmUDfe ITC OCHOBHorom.npoY3JIa (I1JIOTI1H, Bo-
.I10C6POCOB, BO,!\03a60pHbIX, BQAffibIII)'CKH J1.r\Pymx ITC), cy.n;onporry-
I CllsaKOS.o,npaBoeoeM8nHOpauI1HaeM8nbBP8TpocnsKTBe.
A<ryaJ1bHblBnpo6J18MbI npaBoBOroP8rvm.posaHarpapHblX,38M8J1bHblXOJt-!OIlJI!H'iOnppO_
LIOnOllbaOsaHI1OXpaHblCpe,ll,b'BteIlbC"OM MaTepOIiIflblMe>I<,!J,yHa-
po.I1HOHBY'iHO_KOIi<J:>epeHw</oT8.pe.Il.rE 6b1CTPoe B.<1> nOHbI<a.M..PY.I\H.
2010 C.570-573
-51-

CKHbIX coopymarniii. pbI600aIIJ;MTHbIX J1 pbl6ooponyCKHbIX coopymemrlii,
8 TaKJKe coopymemrlii, paCIIOJIOmeHHblX B 8KB8TOpJ111 BO,QOxp8HJ1 J1
H8 CneLl"aJIbHO O'I'&'.JIeIIHOIf Teppwropl.Hl  (BO.I\roaOOp-
HbIX, BO.nOBbIIIycKHbIX COopymemnl, H8COCHbIXCTaHQIill, Mt5, 6eper03a-
IqWTHbIX COOpymemrn, 06'beKTOB BO,QHOro TpaHCnOpTa J-I .npyrnx coopy-
*eHJ1ii, )'HKLtIf KOTOpblX OKa3bIBaeT B03,Qei1:cTBJ-Ie Ha
BO)J;HbJiipeiKl1MUIJ-JIUa);
- OCHOBHble XapaKTepMCTI1KJ-1 OO,QOTOKa (peJKIIJM noc'fYILIIeHJ1R OO,Q J1
peJKIIJM CTOKa BO,Q, CBe):leID1H 0 BO,Qoc60pHoii nJIoUja,!J;J1, rpaHJ1lJ;b1 BO,QO-
xpaHJ1.Jll-1lQa, pery.mrpYIDJl\ero BO)J;HbJii peiKl1M. KOOp,!J;J1HaTbI ITC J1 Be.ID1-
'lJ1Hh! narepb CTOKa oo.n);
-UI o6e30nacHOCTI1 BO,QOnO,D;IlOpHbIXCOop)?KeHffi1, OOpasy-
KJ1W1X BQIJ.OXPaHJ-1JIJ, a 6e3onacH:Jcn1 )KJfJ'eJIeii J1 6e30narnOCTI1 XO-
3HiiCTBeHHbIX OObeKTOB B npM6pemHoii 3(JHe  J1 Ha HI1-
:HreJIemall\eM Y'1aCTKe BO,QafOKa:
- 06'beM BO,Qonurpe6JIeHJ1R;
- nOpH):\OK peryJIMpOBaHJ1HpeiKl1Ma tpOBaID1HBOJJ:oxpaml-
JIJ1IQEi, B TOM 'iJIIcJle J\JIH npeJIYTIPeitC,!\eHWI aaapffi1" IfHblX-
HblXarryat!lnIBE;.!:J;tnroJf3Helcl1cTeMePOCCID1"npI1JI11KBJII-
,AaLJ;l1JlJJ1XIIO:'.JIe;::(CTmIiii;
- nOpH):\OK OnOBeI.IJ;eHJIJH opraHOB J-ICIIOJIHJfT€' BnaCTJII, BO,QonOJIb-
3OBaTeren. )KI1TeJleii 06 J13MeHeID1HX BO.I\HOro pe:001Ma LJIJn4<I,
B TOM 'iJIICJJe 0 pe:001Me 1OHUpOB8HJ1R BO,QoxpaHJIJJllillW. npJII B03-
HI1ItHOBeHl1MaBapJlJi1""HbIXcmyaQlill;
- nopH):\OK npOBe,I1;fHWI pa6OT" npe.I\OCI8BJleID1H JflJ$>PMaIJ;I-1J1 B 06-
JIaCTJ1 I'I1)J;})OMeTeopo.rronrn;
- CBe,QeIDlH 0 ,IJ;eHcTmIHX, 0C)'l*'C1EJlH€Ml:lX npJII BOOHJIKHOBeHJ1III aBa-
pHi1 J1 J1HbIX  CJ1'f)'8W1ii. J1 rrepeGeHb cOOTBeTCTB}'1OlUI1X
MeponpJlH'I'IDt
ITpaBJllJia JIICf1()Jlb3()I38H BO;::(HbIX peCypCOB BO}W.'q)aHllJil'1ll\ Mor)'T
BKJIIQ'-1aTb B ce6H Heo MaTepI18JibJ B rpacpWleCKoi1 $>pMe.
CorJIaCHO CT. 45 BK P4I npaBJIJJI8MJIJ reXHH'-1€CJOCJi,1 3Kcn.rryaT8L1"JII J1
6naroycTpOiicTB8 BO,QOXpaHJ1JlJ1Il\ ol1pe,QeJ1HeTCH nopH):\OK HCIIOJIb3CI3a-
HJ1R J1X ,IJ;Ha J1 6eperoB.
llpa8U1U1 mex-It'UtlOCliOii 31OC11AyamtUJUU u 6nazoycmpoUm-1ea 6000-
xpa1t1.IJIU ,QOJDKHbI CO,QepmaTb:
- KpaTKOeorrncaHJIJe 1JII1ll¥i "roc, J1XQCHOBHbIe rr8paMeTpM;
- CBe,LJ;eHJm 0 SOHaX 1cTmm OO,QOxpaIDfJlJ1lWl (SOHe noCTOJlHHOro
3aTOlIJIeHJIJfl, 30He rrepJIIO,!J;l1'ieCKOro J1JIIII BpeMeHHoro 3aTOlIJIeHJ1R, 30He no-
BbITlleHJIJH ypoBHH Ipym'OBblX BO.l1. 30He B03MillKHOro JI3MeHeffif.H 6eperoB
BQl\OxpaHlfJllfI1\3.,30HeKJIJ1Ma'I1f'1e{'1{(}f"()'icTBJm,30-
-52-

HeMHOrOJIe1HE.'I'Ce30HHoro,HE',I\E'JIbIJ:I cyro'IHoroperyIDf-
poBaHJ1H nOBepXHOCTIIoro CTOKa BO,I:( B BO,IJ;lIbriI OUbeKT lOOKe I11,IIJJOY3JIOB);
- nepeqeHb MeponpmITJlllf. ocyr.u;eCTBJIfleMbIX npll 3KCIIJI)'aTaUIDI Bo-
,IIOXp<UU1JIItma B 3J.1MHJ.1i1 nepllO,l\ IiI B nmo,l\ nporryCKa naBO,l\IWB;
- nepeqeHb Meponpmrrmf.  npll3KCIIJI)'aTaqIDI Bo-
,IIOXp3Iilf.1lWItaBCJIyqaeaBaplli1:IilJ1HbIX
 (mfBHl2Bldi,i IJaBO,l\OK, llITOpMOBOi1:BeTE'p, CJIOiKHaH ne,l\OBaH 06-
CTaHOBKa, nporryCK BO,l\ B KaTac::rpcq:WII:.'CKJ'I60JIbWOM KOJrn'IeCTBe, 3eM-
HJIeJ1,l\p.);
- <IpUlJ1'R'IIJIH 3KCIIJI)'aTaqIDI BOJ:IOXPilHI'1I J1 nepeqeHh Mepo-
np:vurrJ.1i1 no nO,ll,llepmamno HaJI}Iema CaIDITapHoro J1 'fe"{IDt'lecI«IIU
COCTomnur BQJ\OxpaHJIJunQa, nep€"leHb MepmpUl'I'J.lH, oCJ1l\ecTBJIReMbIX
B aKBaTOpllll BO,l\OXpaHl1JIJIIrQa, ero J3QIJ.OOXPaHHOi1: 30He II B 30He BO)J;HOro
06'beKTa HIDKe llJIOTI-lHbl B CBH3ll C J1CJIOJIb3OBallJteM BO,l\oxpaH
,l\JIH I.1;eJIei1: IIJ1TbeBOro IiI :xo:miicweHHo--f.ti-roBOro BO,l\OCHaOmemrn, pbIDo-
nOBCTBa J{ OXOTbl, peKP€ilLPfOHHbIX .1Ieii,,l\JIfl iiBO)J;HOro TpaHcnop-
Ta, CI1JIaBa ,l\peBeCl1Hb1 J{ ,l\pyrnx I.1;eJIei1:. a TalOKe nepeqeHb MepocIpwrri'Df
nO€ffi1I03aKJIeHHJI(BTOM'lJIICJIeO'illCTKaOTHaHOCOB, sapa-
CTaHJ1R, Mepb! no 6opb6e C I.\B€T€IDI€M BO,IJ;bI), no npe,l\OTapaLIJ;elOOO no-
CTyrmem-m 3aIpH3Hfll(IlV- BeLI:leCTB J1 MJ1KpoopramrwoB B BO,l\OXpaHI1-
Jll1lU;e, no o6ycTpOiicmy 6eperOB BO,l\oxpaHHJII, 30Hbi BO)J;HOrO
OO'beKTa HI1me llJIOTI1Hbl B  C Tpe60BaHI1HMJ-I J1X X03JIi'ICT-
BeHHoro I1cn0JIb30BaHI1H 11 Tpe60BaHlliIMl1 OXPaHbl 0Ep1 cpe)J;bl;
- nopJI,l\OK op1 peMOITHO-;,lIocn.n:yaTaqIIIOHHbIX pa6OT;
- nopR,!\OK ocyr.u;eCTBJIeHWI Ha6.mo,l\eHJ.1i1 sa C'OCTOmIIleM BO,l\OXpaHI1-
 (WMeHeHH€M CTOKa BO.rr. TeMnepaTypoi1: BO,l\bI, J1CnapeHl1eM,
leH, XI1MJ1'iecKJ1M J16HoJIoIw!:ecrrnM COCTaBaMJ1 BO,l\bI, TO-
HOi1:JIb,lla, ,l\B11m€mreMHaHOCOB.3allJIeHJIIE'M. It3MEtIE'HJIeM 6EperoB J1IIPY-
rnMI1RBJleHJ--1JlM:v!);
- y<teT J1cnOJIb3OBaHIIJI BOAHbIX peCypCOB BO,l\oxpalllfJll1lWl;
- nep€"ieHb CIIOC060B Ha6.mo,l\eHJ.1i1 3a T€XHlI'I€CICIM COC'fOHHJ'1eM Bo-
,l\OXpaHJ-fJ!11W,a J{ BXO,!lflIIJ;l1X B era COCTaB COOpym€Hl1M, nopfl,l\OK OCJ1l\e-
CTBJIeIDlH TaKI1X Ha6.rno.l:\eHl'ni
IIpaBl1J!a TeXHwrecKoi1: 3Kcn.nyaTaQI1Y! J1 6naroyeq:oi1cTBa BO,l\oxpa-
HJ1.JIJfi1t MOryr BKJnQ'ffiTb B ce6H Ma-rept-laJIbl B rp <PopMe.
IIpaBI-IJIa TeXHwrecKoi1: 3KCrmyaTaQI1Y! 11 6.naroycrpoikTBa BO,l\OXpa-
HI1JIJ-1LIJ;a yrBepalOTCJI l1.JIfl Kaoro BO,l\OXpaHl1JlI-1LIJ;3 ynOJIHOM(]qeH-
HbIM IIpamrreJIbCTBOM P4I l1.ep8.JIbHbIM opraHOM 11CInJIill1T€.JIbH(jjj:
B.naCI'a
B TO me BpeMH B SaKOHO,llaTeJIbCTBe }J:onYCKaeTCfl e 11H-
-reIpt-lpOBaHHhIX npaBJ1Jl IDJTh3OBaHI1fI EIO}JIJXp8JfifIDllItaMM,. Cor.naCHO CT. 45
-53-

BKP4I.JIOnyCKaeTCfl pa3pa6cYrnanpaBJ.-IJI JIICnOJlb30BaID'!flfJIJII-
ll\fl. B COC'TaB KOTopbIX BRJIlO':IaKYrCfl npaBJ.-IJIa JIICI1OJIb3OBaHJVI BO,!J;HblX
pecypCOB :EI(),lpXJ)8HIfJIJIIIli3- JII npaBJ.-IJIa TeXffiNeCKCJiij: 3KCruryaTaqMJII JII
6.naroycTpcjtC' BO)I;OXpaHJ.1JII-1illP.
KpOMe TOrn,  pa:3pa6cYrna npaBJ.-IJI JIICIlOJIh3OBaHIDi BO,!\-
HbIX peCypCOB BOJIOXPamtJ1JfIl\ JII npaBJ.-IJI 'fe.'<HW!eCKOii 3KCIIJI)'aTaL\11Y! JII
6naroycrpoiicTBa BO)I;OXpaHi-1Jll1ll\,l\JUI HecI\OJThlOtx BO.n;OXpaHI1JIJ111-\, ttaC-
tta):Ia BOJIOXPaIDlJIJIIllI I1Jll1 BO,!\Ox()3Jjj.jCTBeHJIOH CY!CTeMhI B cJIY'fB.e, eCJIJII
pe:an'lMbI romq:xmaHKR HeCKOJIbKt1X BO)l;OXpaHI1Jll1Il\ 11 .npyrnx
3JIeMeHTOB E!Ql1OX03Jn1:C'I'BeIIIKJii CY!CTeMbl CBR3aHbl Me:ai,llj' co6oH Tax, 'lTO
He MOryr Il>ymru;i'IOIrnpOBaTb pa3.I\E'.IIbHO.
4. Hcnonb30BAHHE BO/1HbIX 05bEKTOB
wm 4EJlE 3HEPrETKH, TPAHcnOPT A, nECOCnnABA
lJOJIb3OoaHlie .JIM l{eJleii npo 3Jlf'KTJXKIHepnm. Co-
maCHO CT.ll BKP4I, HCIIOJIb:3OBaHJIe BO.n;HbIX OfueKTQB,l\JIfl L\eJleH npo-
J.13BO.nCT1Xi. arreKTpJl'-lecKOH :mepTIBi OtlxJPM.JlfleTCfl.JIOroBOpOM BO)l;OnOJlb-
3OBaHJ1JJ:. I1cno.nb3oBaHJ-le BO,!J;HbIX ol5DeKToB ,l\JlfIl{eJlei1 npo113BO)l;CTBa
3JJeKTp: jHepr1n1 OC}'Il\€CTBJlHeTCR C yq€TOM MHTepecOB .npyrnx
BI1,lPIIOJIb3OBaTeJleH JII C co15.moJ:\eHJo!eM -rpe6oBamrii paIWOHaJIIoHOTO JIIC-
IUJIb30BaIilfR 11 OXpaHbl BO)J;HbIX OObeKTOB
OIIOJIb3OBaTeJIJII, 3KCTIJI)'aTJ-lpylOllJ;J1e rn.n;pO;'lHepreTlftI€CKJfe CO-
 06HaaHbI o6ecJreorMrb pe:arnM cpa6oTKJ'l JII HaIIOJIHeH!iIfl BO)l;O-
xpaHI1.m1I11 C yq€'I'QM npllopme1'8 L\eJIeH mITbeBOro JII X03fliiC"IBeHHO--6bl-
TOBOroBO
 IIpe/UIPIDm1fl HBJlfllOTCfl KpyIIHei-illrJ.-lMJ.-! n0Tpe6J-1Te-
JI.IIMt:I BOL IIpu 3TOM Ten.JIb1e, arpa60TaHHbre BOI,  ,l\JlfI
OXJIHJffl arperaTOB JII pewcropoB TeI1JIOBblX U 8TQMHbIX 3JIeK'Ip0CTaH-
QJrl-1, HaKaIIJll1BaJOTCfl B BO)I;OTOKaX U BO)I;oeMaX. 3To BbI3bJBaeT 
rn,n,po.oorIf'lECl-mX, 6mmrwrecKJtx JIII1HbIX yrnc:EI'Iii: llOBepXHOCTHbIX BO)\-
HbIX OO'bE'KTOB. TepMaJIbHbIe 3arpfl3HeID1H BbI3bIBaIOT}'MeHbWeH!iIe cO)\ep-
:H\aID1fIKJ'ICJIOpOI¥l B BO)I;e, yxy,JJ;WalOTyCJIOBJ1JJ:.?KJ13H!iIMHOrnx BOJJ;HbIXOp-
raHJ13MOB, 3Ha'll-ITeJlbHO yae.m-r<n1Ba1OT TOKCWlHOCTb 3arpR3 BO;::ty
npt-IMeceti:,Melll8JOTHepecrypbJfi t . TeMHeMeHee.6e3He
o6oifrncb HJ-1 B POCCIUI, HJ-1 B &na.n;Irii Espone.
I 6oromoOO8CA"JJiJ.K6op,H0M\IKQ!IeKC\ICJ!ep,epaWo1...M.TKBen-
l'iH,r1pocneKT.2007 C.I54-1S5
-54-

Ki\OHIty XX B. III:seapY!H HaytU'IJIaCb JIICnOJIb30BaTb OKOJrO 90'-[' pe-
CypcOB ,l\Jm BhIpa60TKJII rUJW03Hepnm Yme TOr.r\a IIIBelfQapcKI1e f3C
):IaBaJlJ'! 6(Y"t':meprl1Y!,WIH eJIe3HbIX .r\opor. YcnellIHoe pa3mrme rJ.UqJO-
03Ha'laJIOC03A3HY!eBO,l\OxpaHWllfill. 38.TOY!CTOpY!-
't:IeCKI-fe IIOCeJIeHJ-m, Y! Jll3MeHelille pe'lHoro pI1C)'HKa. lIpY! 3TOMHIDKe ruIO-
TI1Hb1 nom-topa peKa nepeCTaeT Tb: OT Hee OCTaIQTCR JUmIb
JIYmml;bI, BeCeHHJlle Y! JDIBHeBbE nOTOKM. lIo OL\eHKaM CIIelliIaJIJ'lCTOB,
npol1T «aMIIYTawm» peRI.
3apery.m1pOBaHHblMJII OKa3aJll1Cb KaR Kpymible peKY!, TaR JII MeJIKY!e
ropHble nOTOKI-f. B peayJIbTaTe C'IpOI1'I'€JIbCTBa ITC Ha p. POHe He Coxpa-
IillJIOCb Iill O)Uloro ecTeCTIJeHHOfO yqaCTKa 6epera. 113-33 nnCYrnH npeBpa-
l1\eHHble B BOppxpaHJf.1IKIL\3 peKY! pe3KO 3aMe,1\JlffiOT Te'lelille JII Tep.ffiOT
CEOY! cnoc06HoCTJil R no.:=no Tpy)UlO nOJlliOCTbID KOMIleHCY!-
poBaTh CI'iJIICTHblMM COOpyiKeHI1HMJ1. 06paaoBaHHbIe 3a nOCJieAHee .r\eCfI-
TYlJIeT/ile KpyrtHbIe BO.n;oxpaH fSC Hepe,lJ;lOO npe.n;cTaBJI.mOT co6oii
peaJIbH)'ID JII IIYI'elIL!>taJIbHYIO onaCHOCTb .r\J1H lIIDKeJIemanv;iX y<IaCTKoB
pe"iHblX .r\OJrMH npl1 peryJIJIpHOM, HeperyMpHoM It Ka
cnycKe 1t3IDIllJH('U MaCCbl BO)J;bI.
El1\e B 1975 f. III:sei143pcKJ;1:i1 COlO3 IIpOJ13BO):IIITeJIei13J1e:KTp03Hep-
mY! SaRBY!JI, 'lTO,J\aJIbH£'J1rnee C'IpOHT€JIbC1'BO f3C B CTpaHe HeB03MI:»K-
HO no X03HiicTBeHHtnlr: It  npI1'illHaM. ,lJ;aJlbHeiiuDtfi
XOJ\JfCTOpID1 onpoBepr3Tyn03MWOO. TOJIbKOC CepeJll-fHbI 1980-xrr. 6bl-
JIO noc-rpO€HO I1JIJ1 peROHCTpyI1poBaHO 26 fSC. lIo Bcei1 BlWfMOCTI'J. nOJi-
HOCTbID npe.n;arBpaTY!Tb CTpOt:ITeJIbCT8O f3C HeJTh3R. II03TOM)' TpeOoBa-
HY!H AeHCTByK>l1\ero saKOHo.n;aTeJIbCTBa HanpaBJIeHbI Ha «BiKI1BJIeHY!e»
BOJ\OXpaHRlIlfIl\ B JIaH,JUllacpT n)ITeM nOMep*3.HHR B HJ1X 6m.00rwrec-
ROro pa3Ho06pa3VIR JIIX EO;:J; JII 6epe1'OB 2 . KpoMe TOro, €CJIY! TaJIbIe EO)J;bI
aJIbIIIfi,icY,HX JIe.r\HJllKOB 6YlIeT pemeHo SaJIIMCTBOBaTb y npupo.ll.bI, TO
BamEO C03.r\aTb CJ1CTeM)' PYKOTBopHb!X BO;:J;oeMOB JII BO;:J;arOROB .l\EOi1HD-
ro Ha3Ha'leHY!R (KaK perymlpOBaHY!e CTQKa, TaR 11 saIlJ):fTa OT Bpe,!\Horo
B03JI;eikTBJ1H). lIpIfB€,lI€HHbItllI1Bei143PCKt1U OITbIT Q:lYHKW-IOHJ1poBaHJIIR
BO.l\HOro X03JIiiiCTBa MrnKHO npO,!1JKT/IIBHO JIICIIOJIb3OBaTb JII Ha pocCJ1iii-
cKOfI nO'-lBe.
B 6.JImKai1IIDle fO,!\b1 B POCCID1 OeTCR HOBbrn 3Tan rJ.f,!lpo3Hepre-
TWlecKCro C'IpOI1'I'€JIbCTBa: 11M 6yTIYT OXBa'leHbl ropHble 06naCTY! C!-16MpM
JII,lJ;aJIbHero BoCTOKa. CJIe.n;OBaTeJIbHO, 3HepreTI1'leCKVIe Ii npHJXJ.llOOXpaH-
Hble JllHTepecbl Tpe6yroT 'nqa'TeJIbHOrD JII n03TaITHOro cornaCOBaHi-ffl nna-
I n.CI1acTeAl1bn", M..nporpecc,1987C.IU1
2 P:tCBL>1HIt1TL>11992.N,11-12 C.102-103
-55-

HOB C 1lpJ1ME.'HelD1I2M B npe,DyCMOTpeHHbIX 3mWHOM CJJy'IaJIX M€X8ID13Ma
3B:O.JIOI1f'lf'CROii aKCIIepTJl3H 11 oEill1,eC'IEf'HHbIX c.nymaHllii:.
Oco6elDlOCT" npaBOBOI'O perymtpOBaHIUI BO)];OnOJlb3OBaHHII B QeJ:IHX
cy 11 crumsa ))p('B€CIUIbI. B HaCTORl1{ee BpeW! BO,i:\HhIH TpaHC-
UOpT OCTaeTCR O):\HID'lI13 HaJIDOJIee CYJ-1\ecTBeHHhIX Teneiii:"
B TO :/Ke8peMH - 3arpH3HJtreneMBOA HaIIpl1Mep, 3a MOpeiii:, cy-
.u;OXOWlhIX peK, fJIIffiIl1 03ep f1JXM£-'XO}J;JIT 3a C'-IeT yreqeK JTI160
aBaPmfHhlX pa3JIMBOB He1m'r 11 HecprenpoB, BeTpoBOro CHDCa TIhlJIe-
BIWIbIX Ip)'30B C 6ap)K-nnOOK, .u;06hI'-lV! J1 neperpy3KJf 
CTJXMTeJThHbIX MaTepm.JIOB, CJIMBa t:pCBaHHhIX BOA KpoMeTaro,
Ha cy HaKaI1JIJ1BaeTCR I1pJ "6bITOB0i1 M)'C0p, 06pa3y-
lOTCH 3Ha'MfeJThHbIe om.eMhI X03ID1cTBeHoo--6brro " qx.KaJIbHbIX BOA
O,[\H8KO Bpe;qnOCTb BO,!\HOro TpaHcnOpTa HeJIh3R yIpJilpoBaTh. 3a py-
6emoM IJH.YTPf'HIDuiBO,!\Hbrn TpaHcnDpT no npwullie cBoeiii: ,IJ;ewellit3Hhl JII
B CJ1ny UI'HOCJITeJIbHO 31\()JJ{I'J11qecKoi1 '-IJIICTOTbI BHOBh craHOBJ.1TCH O'-leHh
nonyJlRpHhIM. Bo.rree Taro, Ha Hero nepeKmO'laKYI' rpy3OI1OT01m C aBTo,!\o-
por, a 'ieMeCTh  nporpaMMbI«, «MapKO nono»1.
ITp" paapa50TKe npoeKTa ,l\eticTB:yJOl1\ero HhlHe BK PIl> BeJU-lCh O)Klffi-
.neHHhle cnophi B CBR311 C ociJopMJIeHl1eM TpaHcnopTHoro BO,!\onOJlb30Ba-
HJUL Hymno IIpI13HaTb, 'iTO B xo,!\e p83p860TIDI BK PIl>J1HTepeChIBO)UlO-
ro TpaHcnopTa 6b1J111 B 3Ha'lll'I'eJlbHOA Mepe yqTeHbL O,i:\HaKO OTCyrcTBl1e
,AOroBopOB JII a.n;MI1lDK'Tp8T11BHhlX peweIDIiii: He oCB06omJ:IaeT TpaHCllopr-
lIble opralD OT C06mo.J:\eHHH 3l\OJ1OD11{ecEI1X 06mamIOCTei'L KaK
YJffi38HO B CT. 47 BK PIl>, HCD:JJIh3()Ba}Uff' mBepXHOCTHhIX BONfuIX ofu-
eKTOB B Ra'ieCTBe nyreiii: coo6ll1eIDIJI ocyw;eCTBJlReTCH B COOTBeTCTBJIJII C
3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBOM 0 BO)UlOM -q:mnDpTe. B CBOIO o'iepe)J;b ,AemeJlb-
HOCTh BO,!\HOro 'Ip8HCIl(p'ffi perJJ8Mf'HTIlpyeTCH,l1B)'MR KJllQlJeBh1MJ1 npa-
BOBbIMJi! aKTaMJ1: Ko,!\eKcoM BH)'TpeHHero BO)J;Horo TpaHcnopTa Pocom-
CKOti 4Je,!\epaQl1l1 OT 7 MapTa 2001 r_ NQ 4>3 (,!Ianee - KBBT pll»2 JII
Ko,!\eKcoM TOproBOro MOpennaBaIDIH POCCIfHCHa1: 4Je,!\epaQl1l1 OT 30 an-
peJIH 1999 r. NQ 81-4>3 ()J;anee - KTM pll»3. K 'illcny aRTOB TpaHCllOpT-
HOro 3aKOHO)18TeJIbCTBa OTHQCHTCR 4Je,!lepaJIhHbliii: aaKOH OT 8 HOfI6p.fl
2007 T_ NQ 26143 «0 MOpCKI1X nopTax B PoCCJd:icloc:l1: 4Je,!lepal!IH1 JII 0
BHeceHID'l JC3MelHDm B OT,AeJIhHble 3aKOHO):\aTeJIhHble aKTbI Poccw:K1roiii
4>e,l\epawrn» 4_
13_oBaT.l-lapeKeurropMIfr/JPr.2006N11261XXII.21HO5p
2 C3P<11.2OO1 NIl 11.Cr. 1001
3 C3P$.1999.N!!18.Cr.2207
-4 C3 P<1I. 2007 N!!46.Cr 5557
-56-

CTaTbeil11 KBBT P4I npe.IIyCM:YrpeHO B03Melllem1e Bpe,!la, npH'lJ1-
HeHHoro HeHa):\JI€maI.W-1lWl ):\eUrrnHHMJ1 1}JJ-13W1eCKJ1X H KpJW1'reCKJfX
.ID1IJ; Ha BHYTpeHHJ1X BO,!{HblX nyr.HX. IIo.I\ TaKOBblM nO,Ilpa3}'MeBaeT(:H no-
Bpe)K,lJ;eHHe I1JIJ1 :yHH'ITOmeHHe cpe,!\CTB HaBJ1I'a1ttfOllH:ro o60Py'!\oBaHM,
CY.I\OXO,!\HbIX I'J1,II;part'..XHlN€CKItX coopymetmi1. cy,!\OBbIX XO.I\OB H JlPyrnx
o&beKTOB, nplIqJ1X oprammaL\HHM BHJTpeHHero BO,!{HOro
TpaHCIIOpTa. KfX>Me Taro, B CT. 121 KBBT P4I n OTBeTCT-
BeHHOCTb sa yw;ep6 B CJIy'lae 3arpmmemm C CYJlOB Hec}:rrt.ro J1JIJ1 IIPym-
MJ1BeIl.f2C'I'I\8MlL
IIoJIDmeHHH KTM pq:. TaIOKe RaCa10TCJl H 3KGJ10I'H'!eclG1X acneKTOB cy-
,!\OXO,!\CTBa. Pe'Ib J-t!1eT 0 TJI. IB «OrBeTCTBeHH<XTb 3a  C CY,l\OB
He1:rn>ro»J1rJL 19 ..3ayw;ep6BCM3UCMopcKOl1:nepeB03--
KQi-10llaCHbIXJ1 BpeJlHbIX.Mem.uyHaJXJJIHb!eacneKTbI3all.jJ1TblOT
IRBO.nCcy,1J;OBy<rreHbIBMem.nyHapoJlHO-lIaKTaxl.
HecMOTpJ'l Ira He3Ha'D1Te.!lbHbrii Y,l\€JII>HI>IIt: Bec B 06ll1eM rpy:3OOfxJpo-
Te, OTHOCJ1TeJIbHO ".I\eweebIM» BOJ\HbIIt: -rpaHcnop-r JllTpaeT BI1.I\HYJO pOJIb
B lrapO,1J;HOM x03m1cTBe Poccmi!, ocooeHHo B 3KOHOMlilKe OTJlaJIeHHblX pe-
mOHOB, T,!\e ceTbJlOpOrellle He pa3BlilTa. B CBoe BpeMJ'l BCCCP 6hLJla co-
3,!1aHa €,!\HH8JI r.ny6oKOBO,!{HaH ClfCTeMa (ErC), «11JXIHIf38Bll18» €BPo-
nei-1cKyro "IaCTb CCCP C BbIXO.I\OM Ha Ba.m1nkKoe, BeJIGe, qepHoe,
A30BcKoe H Kacmri-kKoe MOpJ'l. B Ha:maHHYW CHCTeM)' BXOJ],JIJIJf l!;Hoyr-
.ny6.neIrnue peKY! 11 03epa, a TaIOKe KaHaJIbl, BO.noxpaIDlJIlnI¥i. 3TY! cy-
JlOXO,!J.Hble nynl ObIJU1 paCC<l"l'raHbI JIJUI c}:IJIoTa ttpynHbIX ra6apllTOB,
JIM CYJlOB IIJI8BaHI-1JI "peKa-MOpe». B pe3yJIbTaTe CHlllmaJlaCb CTOY!-
MOCTb H YMeHbllJa.nOCb BpeMJ'I pa60TbI BO)J.HOro -rpaHcnOpTa. MocKBa
CTaJIa nopTOM II.HTM Mopei1.
B COBpeMeHHoi-1 POCCID1  BHYTpeHHJ1X BO,!{HblX nyrei-1
COCTaBJIHeT 100 TblC. KM., OHY! o6oPYJlOBaHbI 700 ITC, B ruM "lltCJ!e 110 cy-
JlOXO,lUIblMJ1lIIJl103aMH. OJUffiKO, K comanemoo, Ha3BaHHbIe nyrn Hepe,u;KO
OKa3bIBaIO'J'Cj'J H€f'O'IOBHMJI JIJUI I1HT€HCYlBHOro cyJIOXOJ(C'TBa. «IIpo6JIeM-
HbIe» -rpaHcIIOpTHble ttOPJ-t!1opbl (1UiH8.JI "Bomo-,lI,oH», IIJTb «Bo.rrro-
Bam», rn.rq:>oy3Jlb1 Ira Bo.rire) H)"K,!IaIOTCJ'I B KCIMII.JI€KCIri peKOHCTpYK-
L\I1Y!, B ,l:\HoyrnyfurreJIbHbIX pa6arax J1 T_A-
IIOCTaHOBJleHMeM ITpamrre.nbCTB13. P4I OT 15 anpeJLII 1996 r. NQ 464
6bLJIa ywepm,JJ;eHa cpe.I\epaJIbHaH L\eJleBaH nfX>rpaMMa "BH)'TpeHID'Ie
BO.I\Hble nyrn PoccY!Y!» Ha 1996-2000 rD.I\bf. Ee L\eJIHMY! HBJlHJIY!Cb co-
lEpMOfl"H8M.A.-npaBQBbJeCTa'll\ilPTbIAei<CTBHiinpH3al1jl1Te
M"PQ"QroOtoeaHaOT3arpH3HeH""CCYI\O".ABrQpeq,jJ,HCCmK.IO.H.nocnellH3flb-
HQC1I112.00.10 cn6.,2010
2 C3P$.1996 N!!17.Cr.1995
-57-

XpaHeHl1e H MO'!\epllH3Rl\I1H CeU1 BHYTpeHHJ1X BO,!\HbIX nyreM, nOBbIWe-
Hl1e OCTIf 3KCIIJIYaTIllV-'ll1 I'Jl,D;poTE'XIIJ1'iecKI1x coopymeHI1M J'! 6e-
30naCHOCTI1 cY,[lOX. B pe3}'JlbTaTe peaJll13aL\IDI KOMIIJleKCa Mep
Ere, .r\OCTaBwanca B HaCJle.r\CTBO OT eecp, 6hI.na B I13BeCTHOii Mepe
BOCCTaHOBJleHa. Ho Erc €TC.fI B HenpephIBHOM BHI1I\oIB.HHH J1 no,!\-
,IJ;epmamrn B onTHM8.JIbHOM COCTQRHJ1M, 'iTO He Bcer.r\a y.r\aeTCH o6ecne-
""'b.
B CBR3H C 3T11M OCHEHOO «XaMeHb npeTKHCEeHHH» - H1H3Hm-
poBaffi1e. Ha {'())J; BONfuIX nyreM C I1X ITC J1lllJl103aMJ'! J13 610,!1-
meTa BH,D;eJUIJIOCb He 6o.rree 60S'i cpe,!1cTB OT n0Tpe6HX'Te1t. Bar llO'-IeMY
ceWiac Tpe6yIOTCR He OT rocy,l:\apcTBa J1C'!"(J'-Iffi1K11 - 'laCTHble
llliBeCTl1lU'lI1 KOHL\eccJX>HepoB, B TOM 'II1cJle J1 J1HOC'IpaHHblX l .
POCCI1R npMHI1MaeT yqacTi-ie B EBponmCI«JM COrJIarneHl111 a Ba»{-
HhIX BHy1'peHHID!: BO,!\HhIX rryrHX Mem.I\YHapO,!\HOro 3Ha'-leHl1H 1996 r.
CTopOHb! COrJIaWeHI1H YCTaHOBJ1JU'i TeXHJI'-IeCKl1e xapaKTepl1CTI1K11
BHyrpeHHI1X BO,!\HblX nYTeiii 11 nopTOB, BXO,!\JIiIU'!X B CnelV-'laJlbHbrn: ne-
pe'-leHb. B 'laCTHOCTI1, B Hero BXOMT peKY! enp, ecTp, BOJira J1 Ka-
Ma, nOpTbl MOCKBa J1 CaHKT-ITeTep6ypr. B lteJlOM pOCOOCKafl ceTb
BHy'IpeHHHX BO,!1HbIX nYTeiii 1'OT0BI1'I'ca It OTKpbtrlliQ,l\JlfI J:lHocrpaHHblX
CY.IlOB It 2012 r. Ho lLIIH 3TOro He06xoIDIMo ee 06e30naCI1Tb J1 YCOBep-
rneHCTBOBaTb.
B HaCTOHlL\ee BpeMH MHome KaHaJlbI Tpe6yxrr peK£ECTpyKQJIU J:I yco-
BepWeHCTBOBaHWL B <ffiCTIlOCTl1, I1HTepeChI pa3BI1TI1R BO,!\HOro TpaHC-
nopTa Tpe6)'lOf I1pOIJ€AelD1H BTOpOif JII1ffi111 KaHaJla Bo.rrro-,lI,OH, MO,!\ep-
Hlf3a.1tWI Bomo-BaJITa. O.rr;HaKO,II,JIH npemopeHl1H B :m113Hb 3TI1X llllaHOB
MomeTnarpe6oBaTbCH C03,n8ffi1e Mepo,!\HoroKOHcopQl-'lYMa. C.IlaH-
HbIMH J1HJ1QHaTYlBar.rn BhICTyITJ1J!O pyxOBO,lJ;CTBO PoccHiicKoi1 Aepa-
. B TO >l\e Bp€MH "YABoeHJ1e» KJIJOqeBblX TpaHcnoprHblX ap-repHif He
oCBo6C»K,!J;aeT TCPOB"  npopb!BHbIX npoeKTOB OT
npo,!1)'MaHHoro 3KOJ1OTIN€CKOI'Q o6ccHoBaHHH.
YBeJIM'lMB81OTCHMHBeCTJn:tIfil B MOpCKI1e "pe'-lHblenOpTbL Br. CaHKT-
ITerep6ypre Ha r1-1JWOHaMh!BHhIX pat!OHaX CTpol1TC.ft nopT, I1pJ13B8HHbIfI
YCMJIJITb poJib ceBepHoif CTO.lll1L\b! KaK «Bopar B EBpony}}.
,lI..rrH YJIY'IllIeHl1H BO.D;HblX nyreM HYmHO y6>-rpaTb TaK Ha3b!BaeMoe
«3awHYBrnee "MJIl-IecTBo». B Pocci;m MHoro 3aTOH)'Brnero "MJIl-IecTBa,
BKJIIOQaH cy.na pa3HbIX BI1,!\OB" pa3MepoB, J1HhIe nrraBcpe,!\CTBa, rp}'3bl,
I 3b1KOB</Tl-lapeKeurropMHTI/Pr 2006 N!!261.)o(1I21HO5p
2 nOCl1aHo1>e.!1BP8l1bIf()MyCo5paHHlOllpe(n1.11elfraPocuAcld\o1>e.l1BpaLJ.HBB.
IlyTHajIPr.2007 N1190.25,anpem.C.3-5
-58-

JlpeBeCillIY. MHOI11e BOJlHbre 06'b€KTbl J116J!J113JIemalltHe SeMeJlbHble }"Ia-
CTKJ-f np€Bpall\eHbl B l\JIa.n;6J1!ll¥l 6ecx03HblX Kopafurei1, B CHaJIKY MeTaJI-
JlOJlOMa 1:1 3aTOHJBlllefi ,lIp€B€CJI!Hbl l . IIo;J;o6Hoe 3aCOpeHMe HOCMT MaCCo-
Bbrli: xapaKTep JI! J113-3a pm8BJI€HJm MeTaJlJla 1:1 rHll€HJI!JI zrp€B€CJIIHbI.
Hepe,D;KO BJI€':I€T SarpH3HeHMe, B pe3yJlbTaTe IIpOI1CXOJ];IIT y
yxyeIDfe lW.':IeCTBa BO IIo,!\'beM 3aTOH)'BIIIJIIX CYJlOB 1pe6yeT He
TOJlbKO BJ];MIfIDI(."lTI1BHblX pa:JpellleHlm, HO JII BCeIJ03M(OKHblX nOOIl\-
pemrl1.
CorJlaCHO CT. II BK P4Inpe,!:\OCTaBJIeIDfe BO,!\HbIX 06'beKToBB IIOJIb30-
BaHl1e Ha OCHOBamDi CneQMaJIbHblX pernemnl OcyruecTBJlH€TCR B ueJIRX
CrIJIaBa Jleca B nJlOTax 1:1 C I1pJIME'H€HJIeM KOIIIeJIeii
B CI1JI)' CT. 48 BK P4I JIeCOCIIJIaBHHe opraHM3a4l-fi1 06H3aHbI perYJlHp-
HO npoBO,!:\1ITb O'll1CTKY BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTOB OT 3aTOHYBlllei1 JlpeBeCI1HbL
HeraTI1BHOe Bl)3Jl('iic'rBHe Ha COCTOHHJI!e BOL\HbIX 06'beKTOB 01W.3bmaeT
JIeCOCn.naB, m.ny<II'IBIlIKi oco6o llillpoKoe pacnpoC'l]:laHeHJM:' Ha peKax.
fJle cYJlOxo,!:\cTBOra6apJ1TaMJ:IBOL\HbIXnyreii IIo,!\BJIlli'I-
HI1eM Jl€COCrIJIaBa, npe:lK,[\e Bcero MOJIeBOro, npoMcxo;rv.rr 3acopeHife BO-
,l\OTOKQB 1:1 BO,!\oeMOB 3aTCroIelUl:JR 11 ,DpeB€CIfHoit 06pa3J1OTCH
3aTOpbl, np€IlHTCTByrolWfe nepe,lJ;BMmeHl1IO pbro 1:1 CIIOCOfcrByKn:tre 3a-
l1JIeHI1lO pyceJlI1 H€peCTl1JIJ1ll\.
CrIJIaB Jleca no cYJlOXO,!:\HbIM nyrHM 6e3 cyWJ3Oi.1: TSlI11 JII MOJIeBCM
CllJlaB Jleca Ha BOL\HbIX ofueKTax 3anpern;eHhL POCCt1fI6bLJIa O)J)n:lM 1:13 He-
MHornx rOCYAapcrB, r,l\e MOJIeBblM CIlJIaBOM 3aHJ.IMaJIJ1Cb ,l\OBQJIbHO ,l\0JIf0.
3aTeMerocnpaBeAJThlB0l1 3anpeTl1JlJ1.
Ka:ai,r\oe TPaTOe 6peBHO JlOTCH Ha JlHO peKJIII1JlJ1 03epa. «Ton-
JlHK» I IJfJJPOKIfMK"!€CKIm: cocraB BO,!\bI, IlpItBHOCIIT TOIOCIIHbL
lIooToMY CJICTeMaTII':iE.'ClOClE' MHCI"OJ1€THE'e  JlecoCllJlaBa Ha
BO,!\Hble 06'b€KTbl HaHOCMT cyrn;rernellllbrll Bpe,!:\ pbIDHOM)' xoaIDiCTBJ.
5. Hcnonb30BAHHE BO.QHbIX 06bEKTOB
.Q HHblX I1EE
PCrJlaMCHTaU;MH IJ()J\OIJOJIb3OBaHIUI AJIH I.1;CJlCU pbwHoro II OXOTHII-
"{bero X03fII'icrna. PaHee, cor.naCHO BK P4I1995 r., saKOHo.n;aTeJlb YCTa-
HaBIDfBaJi npMopl1'TeT pb16oX03Jli.1crBeHHoro HCIIOJIb3OBaHH. Tex BO,!\-
HbIX 06'beKTOB, KOTOpble l1MeIOT BamHOe 3Ha':leHMe .wm coxpaHeID1H,
BOCIIpOI13BOJI('TI3a 1:1 Jl06bJ<1M pbroHbIX pecypcOB. IIo:IToMY Bce J1Hble BM-
I &w.aPOCCH 2001 N!!I C.4
-59-

)J;bl J1CIIOJib3(JB8.HJlIJI BONfuIX o15'beRToB J1.ID1 MX yqaCTKOB (3a "CKJIlOqeHJII-
eM IillTbeBoro"X03HJICTBeHlIO-15brroBoro)orpaHl-1'rnBa-
IOTCJI. OWlaKO, B BK PIl> 2006 r. .r\aHHbIJ::i: npHopHTeT «He 3aJIC»KeH», 'ITO
MOmeT Bbl3BaTb IqJJ1'l1'fleCKI1e 3aMe'laHHJI. B pe3ynbTaTe phl6ox03JliiiL"I'-
BeHHoe J1Cl1OJlh3()B8) BONfuIX o15'beKTOB He 6Y.r\eT B .r\OJDKHoJ::i: Mepe 3a-
llC-fiI.\eHO.
CorJIaCHO CT. 51 BK P4I2006 r. 1\JlJI Q€Jlei1 pbl6o.nOBCTBa JilcnOJIb3Y-
IOTCfI BOJ\Hble o15'beKTbl pbl50X03.fliiiCTBeHHoro 3Ha'leHIUI. B CBOIO O'le-
pe,lJ;b HopMb!BKP4I ,neTa}Bl31fJJYIO'!"G1 B<PeJ\epaJIbHOM saKOHe OT 20 .r\e-
Ka5pfI 2004 r. NQ 166-413 «0 pbroOJlOBCTBe M ccnq:lIDfeHMM BOJ\HbIX
6uo.norwIecKHx pecypcc:m» 1. B ):\aHHOM 3aKOHe He 06oii.r\eHo BHJlIMaHH-
eM COXpaH€HHe BOJnII;lX 611JOpecypCOB " Cpe,1\bl IIJX 05JITaHlfH, T.e. ca-
I'4JIIX BOJ\HblX o15'beKToB (rn. 6). IIonomeHHJI BK P4I2006 r. KOppecnOH-
ro-tPYIOT C 8HaJIOrWlHblM IlOJI())Kf'HIiI€M CT. 5038KOH8 ,,0 pbl6o.nOBCTBe
IIJ cOXpaHeffilIlIJ BOJ\HblX 15HoJlorWiecKHx pecypcoB». IIpH npOeKmpoBa-
HIIJIIJ, pa3Mellleffi1l1J, CTpOI'IT€JlbCTBe, peKoHcTpYKI-\J111J " BBO,1\e B aKC-
IIJIyaT8Lt11JK! xosmiCTBeHHblX 06'heKTOB (B TOM 'IMCJle f'I'C), a T8KiK€
npM BHe,!J;peHHI1 HOBbZX TeXHOJlOrWieCKHX IIpOI.\E'CCOB ,I:(OJl:IKHO Y'lHTbI-
BaTbCJI IIJX BJlHJlHHe Ha COCTOJlHHe BO,1\HbIX 6HopeCYPCOB IIJ IIJX cpe.l1Y
06HT8H11J1. J1Melllio nmTOMY Bce 3TH MepOnpHJITI1JI ,I:(OJImHbI cornaco-
BbiBaTbCJI C <J:Ie.r\epaJlbHblM opraHOM J1CIIOIIHlITeJIbHoJ::i: BnaCTJiI B o6na-
CTI1 phl60 llOBCTBa.
Ha3BaHHbrn 3aKOH no.npo6HO }"illTb1B8eT HKY pb16o:KO:3JrliCT-
BellliOro 11CnOJIb3OB8HI1JI BO,D;HblX ofueKTOB. B HeM npe.D;yCMOTpeHbI IWaC-
CJnPfKaQIDI BO,!(Hb1X 06'beKTOB pH6oxo3Hi'rmeHIKru 3Ha'leHl1Jl (CT. 17),
TpeOOOOHI1JI It BO,D;H0MY pemHMyM Ka'leCTBYBO (CT_ 47), ycnuw.nemte
pbI6ooxpaH:m,Ix 30H BOKpyr aKBaTOpID'! BO,D;HbIX OfueKTOB (CT. 48) IIJ Pbl-
\'5ox03Jn1cTBeHHblX sanoBe,!(HbIX 30H Ha BONfuIX 06'heKTax (CT. 49). IIpe.D;y-
CMaTpHBaeTCJI TaIOKE' pbl6oX03HiicTBeHlI8.II Mem'!Op BO,D;HbIX 06'beK-
TOB (CT. 44).
IIpe,IJ;N!eToM ,I:(ol'OBopa BO,I:(OIDI!b3<EaHHJI.HBJlJleTCJI caM BO,D;Hbliii om.-
eKT (JIffiJo ero'l8CTb). 01\H8KO B JIKJ60M cJlyqae aTO npllpO,I:(HO€ I1J1H py-
KOTBOpHOe o5pasoBaffile BKJllO'IaeT B cefuI mBepXHOCTHhl€ BO" no-
KpbITyro 11MJ1 seMJilO B npe,!(enax 6eperoBoi1 JII1HHH (CT. 5 BK P4I).
CorJIaCHO CT_ 18. oco 3aKOHa ,,0 pH6o..rroocrBe J1 co."q)aH€-
HI1I1 BO,!J;HbIX 6H0.n0IwIecKW{ pecypCOB» (c IIOC.JIe,II,YICf 113M. IIJ ,1\011)
BHH y<I8CTOK COC'I'OJIIT "3 8KBaTOpID1 BOJ\HOro 06'beKT8
pu6oxoomicTBeHHOro 3Ha'leHI1JI J1JII1 ee 'laCTI1. TaKi1M 05pasOM, 3eMJUI He
I C3P$ 2004.N!!52(Y.I).Cr.5270
-60-

paCCMaTpJ.-lBaeTC'JI KaK COCTaBHaH -mCTb pb1fxmpoMbICJ1OBOro yqaCTKa. Ho
yaroroBOnpOca eCTbCBOR1fI1.
yqaCTOKclxJpMJ.1pyeTC'JIBrpalU1-
qaX,l1JUI OCytQ€CTBJI€HJ1H npoMbIlllJIemlOro pbIDonOBCTBa, TIpOMbnnneHHO-
ro. pbl6onoocrna B l\eJIRX 06ecne':leID-1H Be.I\elD1J11pa,!J;illJ;lll-
oHHoroo6paaa :Ha:I3HJ.-Il1ocyrn;eCTBJJeID-1H HHOi1:
.I\emeJlbHOCThl KopeHHblX MaJllJ'IJICJIeHHbIX Hapo,!\OB CeBepa, CJ16HpJ.-l J1
):{a.m,Hero BoCTOKa POCCJ1J1, a TaKiKE' ,l1JUI opraHJ13aQm:! .1lIOOJITeJIbCKaI'O J1
cnopTJ.-IBHOI'O pbl60llOlrrna. fpaHJ1l\bJ puOOnpoMbI'JIOBOTO yqacma onpe-
l1eJlffi(}TC'Jl B nope, yc'I8HOBJJeHHCM yroJIHOMO'teHHbIM q,e)J;epaJIbHblM
opraHOM t1(I1(IJlRI1'I'eJJbHOi1: BJIaCTIiI.
IIepe'IeHb p yqaCTKOB, BKJIlO'-IalOll\I1XB ce6HaKBa-
TOp"'''' BHyrpeHHJ-1X BOA, B TOM q"'cne BHYTpeHffi:lX MOpCKt1X BO)];11 TeppJ.-l-
TO MOpH POCCJ1J.-1, yrnepJK,!\aeTC'JI opraHOM HCIIOJIHJITeJIbll)U
BnaCTJ.-I cy6'beK'I'a PocCJfticIroti: cpe)];epawrn no cor.naCOBaHIDO C ynOJIHo-
MOqeHHbIM q,e,!:\epaJIbHbIM opraHOM JICIJOJIIIJffeJ BJlacTIiI.
Cor.naCHO CT. 33.3 oro 3aEtOHa «0 pt>IfJonoBcrne J1 coxpaH€-
mrn BO.D;HbIX 6JKUlODflecKJIX pecypCOB» no 110I'OBopy a lIpE',l\OC'lBBJIemDl
puOOIIpOM:bICJIOBOro yqaCTKa O.I\Ha CTOpoHa - opraH rocY.I\apc'IH€HHOH
BnaCTJ.-I06H3}'eTC'JI 1IpE' .npyroi-icTopoHe -IopJ1,lJ;l.ID1-
JfJU1 J1H,!J;I1BI1,uyaJIbHOMJnpeL\IIPlIlil'1l\1B.TeJIlOnpaBO Ha,JJ;06bIqy (BbIJIOB)
BO.I\HblXfuropecypcOBHa BCMyqaCTKe.
B ,noraBope a npe.noc'I'aBJIf p yqacTKa YK3-3bl-
BaI{JTC'JI ero CTOPOHbl, npe,IJ;MeT 110I'OBopa, CpoK ero ,AeiiCTBHH. BI1,!\ pbroo-
.nOBCTBa 11 I1Hble yc.nomm. JJ:oraBOp 0 npE'JIOC'ffiBJIeIDm puOOnpoMbICIDBO-
ro yqacTKa 3aKJilOQaeTCJI no pe3y.nbTaTaM EtOHKypca Ha npaBo
3aK.JIIO'leID1fI TaKara 110roBOpa. B 3TOM OH OTJIWIaeTCH OT 110I'OBopa BO)];O-
nOJIb30BaHIDl, KOTOpbrli: 3aKJl101l8eTCH rJlaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha OCHOBe 8yK-
qJ10Ha.
I BnepBOHa"aJ1bHo(;jPBJ18KLj1-13a<oHB«Opl>l6ol1oecrEel1coxpBHeHHI-1BoJJ,HblxlSl-1011OO1'fBC-
Kl-1xpecypcoe. BnoHHu'epbl6onpo""'CIloeoroy<acnaeKflIO"aJ1H HeTOfibKOilK!laTOp1O
eOJJ,Horoo6!,e<Ta.HOl1npH6pe)KHy\onOI1OCYCywl-1 Bpe3y.nbTaTe.o.aHHoenoHnenpH6I1H-
..anocb KnOHHrnIOBOj\HOroom.eKTa OJ\HaKOcorllacHo3aKoHyOT29p,eKil5P\' 2{J06 f.
N,2601!>3'OeHeCeHI-1I-1113ldeHeHH;;;"ClJeJJ,epafibH"';;;3aKoH'Opbl6ofioeCTBel1
BOp,H",xlSol1or..ec<"xpecypcoB'113eMe.nbHbI;;KQJ:IB<cClJep,epal\""l1eraJ1b-
HOeOnpBJJ,el1eHeCTBeHH",xY"acTKo8orpaH""HfiOcba'BaTop..e;;;eoJIHoroo&,-
eKTa p"'60X03;;CTBeHHOr03HaeHR HI1 erO..aCT. np 3TOM 113bTaH 1130npep,e.neHR no-
HTI-1poBoroyacTKanp6pe)KHan0I10CaMO)KeTI-1Cn0J1b30BaTbCRHa
oCHoBaH"HnytinHHOfUcepB"TyTaBlIeJIXOXOTbll1pbl60l1oeCTBa,'lTOTa"",e}'Ka3aHOBn0-
npaBKaXB3e"el1bH"';;;KOp,e"cPCIJ3B"OHOJJ,arel1bHonpe.llyc..npHBeI1€HHeBCO-
orBeTCrIII1eTpe60BaHRldI10Bo(;jpeJ:1a"L.("H3aKOHa«0HcoxpaHeHI-1HBoJJ,H"'X
pecYPCoB"Y)KeaaKl1IOeHHblXJ¥]f"OBOJX)B
y<aCT<OId
-61-

IIOpflAOK nOAI'OTOBKIf J1: 38KJr!O<re1D1H AOrOBOpa 0 np€,!\OCTaBJIeHJIIJII
pl>lOOnpoMbiCJIOBOro yqaCTKa, clxJpMa npMMepHOrO ,!\orOBopa a npe,!\o-
CTaBJIeHlOf pl>l6onpoMI>ICnOBoro y<IaCTKa, nopR,!\OK opr8HH3allnf H
IIpOBe,IJ;eID'iR KOHKypca Ha npaBO 3aK./IKReHJ.1fl ,IJ;OrOBOpa 0 npe,!\OCTaB-
neHl111 pl>l6onJx!MI>ICJI(j3()I'O Y'ffiCTKa YCT8HaBJII1BalOTCa IIpaBlf'I'eJIK'T-
BOMPCP.
Ha QCHOBe npl1Be,!\eHHhIX HOpM 3aKOHO,!1aTeJIbCTBa 0 pHDonoBcTBe
MOmHO KOHCT8TJllpC)BaTb, 'iTO pI>IDonpoMblCJIOBbID y<IaCTOK HBIDIeTCR 60-
nee ycJIOBH::ll1 e$a1. 'leM BO,!\oeM. BO,!\OTOK - Boo6l1\e nOBepXHOCT-
Hhrn BO)I;HbIM 06'beKT. F'bI6onpoMHc.rrom:.rli: y<IaCTOK «1Iape3aeTCR» coor-
BeTCTBylQLqI1M opraHOM BJIaCTI1, B CJllJIY 'lero CaMOCTOSITeJIhHOro
3Ha'leHI1R C 'TO'IKJII3peHI1R IlfJUXIJIOrRJ1 MOmeT He JilMeTb (T.e. He 6bITb BO,!\-
HbIM OO'bE'KTOM). OJ\HaKO Meit\I\Y 3TIDrn JIeraJibHhIMH nOHjITJIIHM}'[ l1Me}()T-
Cfl H oOLql1e 'lepTbl: 3TO 8KBaTOpJllJ-'l, I:ICllOJlb3yeMble Ha OCHOBe ,IJ;oroBopa
HI1R.
B 06J18CTJIII1CIIOJIb3OBaID, BOCCTIlHIIJIelD1H 11 OXPaHbl BO)J;HblX 6J110-
pecypCOB eT Pocpb1fu.ooecTB l1MeHHoc HI1M CJI€A)"eT co-
maCOBaTb pa3M€I1\€HJII€ xD.1HiicrneHHbIx JI! HHhIX 06'b€KTOB, 8 TalOK€ BHe-
.npeHl1e HOBblX TeXHO.JIOrI1'Ie IIpOlIecCOB, BJII1R}()J.1tI1X Ha COCTORHJI!e
BO)J;HblX 6J110pecypCOB. B CIDI3J11 C <JTJI!M m.1JIO npJIIHRTO IIOCTalD3JIffDE
IIpaBtrreJIbC'I'BaPtfloT281OOJ1.'1 2008 r. NQ 569 (!06IIpa-
BJIIJI comaCOBaHJl!fl p X03JIi.ic'rneHHbIX JI! J1Hb1X ofueKTOB, a
TaIOKe BHe.npeHllil HOBblX 'l'eXHOJIOI'I1' npou;eccoB, BJII1R}()J.1tI1X Ha
COCTOJIHJlle BO)J;HbIX oJilOpecypcoB JI! cpe,I\)' HX 0611TaHI1R» 1 .
eCKOeJOO.10Jl!JIl1HbrnnpeiJ;IIp:I-1HI1MaTeJlb,n.naHJII-
pyIO[l\We pa3MeIQetME' :x(;I3JIffC'I'BeHHb[X 1:1 JI!HbIX ofu.eKTOB JI!JII1 BHe.n;peHJl!e
HOBbIX TefX npo:o;eCCOB, npe,!\CTaBJLllIOT B F'ocpI.IDoJKmcT
JI!JII:I B eroTepITOpI'28JIbHbIe OpraHbI 38JIBKy Ha cornaCOBaHJlle Pa:3MeIlJ'HJf.fI
Ha3BallllblX OOneKTOB I1Jll1 BHeJlPeIDtH 03Ha'lellllblX TeXHOJI)I1flL
Pocpbl6o.rrOBCTBO corJIaCOBbrnaeT ofu.eKT (TeXHOJI(JIm{) Ha Teppl1TO-
pl1Jll W!yx I160JIee cyfu,eKTOB PCP, Ha BIryrpeHHI1X MopCKJIIX BOJlaX, Tep-
prrDpl18JIbHOM Mope, JWHTI1HemaJlbHOM IlleJlbcpe, HCK.IIICJ<nIT€JIbHoH 3KO-
HOMJI'IeCI«)ji 30He PCP, a TaIOKe Ha KacrnUnroM H A30BCKOMMOpRX.
EcJlJl! OO'beKT (TeXOOJIOI1m) ,[IOJIiKHbJ 6bITb pa3Mell\€Hb! (BH€.n;p€HbI) Ha
Teppl1TOpJl!l1 o,!\Hora cy6'beKTa «P€,l\ep8l\!fi'1, TO 3TY 3aflBKY paccMaTpffila-
lOT TeppJl!TOplfaJlbHbI€ opraHbI PocpI.IDo.rrooc
Pocpbl6o.noocroo JI! ero TeppKlUpI-1<lJIbHbIe opraHhI Bnp8B€ OTK83aTh B
comaCOBaHl1l1,naHHblX JfHl1II;I1aTl1B B CJIY'I8RX JiIX HecooTBe1'C'I'BH Tpe60-
Ipr2OO8No165.6<1BrycTa
-62-

BaIDtHM 3aKOHo,!\aTeJJbCTBa. IIrrn: 0'I'Ka3e B CornaCOBaHID1 pa3Mell\emtH
03Ha':leHHbIX xromH.-rBelnrux o6oeKToB J1.IDf BHE'.IqJeHHfl TeXHlJIOl1rH 3a-
HBY!TeJlb BIlpaBe npe,!J;CTaBY!Tb ,!\OKYMeHTbI Ha nOBTopHoe paCCMOTpelille
IIp}! YCJIOBmt J1X 1J;opa6OTKI1 C Y"eTOM 3aMe':IaHJ(iii I1lIpeWJ(»KeHIm, I1Mo-
HHbIX B OTKa3e.
B Pocphl6o.ooBcTBe }'BepeHbI, ':ITO MOryI' ,!\06I1TbCR ar HeqrrRHl1KOB,
ra3IEHKOB J1.IDf  KU.meHcaQID:I Bpe,!J;a. J«:YIOfHii HaHOCwr I1X
,!\eRTeJlbHOCTb pbIDHblM 6oraTCTBaM.
B HOBOM BK pcp J1MeeTC'JI CCbLJIKa Ha 3aKOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBO 0 mfBOTHOM
""P'
eBceroJ1MeeTCJIBBJ1)1yepa.1lbHb1ti3tlKOHar24:mpeJlflI995I'.
NQ52 «Omt1BcmrOMMI1pe» 1.BHa3Ba1ffiOM3wcoHec(),[\epmrrC'JIpR,!\'Ipe6OBa-
I£I.1:i1 no oxpaHe Cpe,!:(bl 06l1TaHWI }J;WKI1X BO,!\OilJlaBaIOIQI1X iii OI\OJlOBQAHbIX
1lTI1L\. qeHHbIX nyIllHblX 3BepeH, umeceHHbIX K OObeIITaM OXOTbL
rIocJle.zl.1ll1TE'JIbH(jf IDWO'fOBKII6blJl IIpMHRT €Pe,!J;epaJlbHbIM 3aKOH OT
24 J1lOJ1H 2009 I'. NQ 209-4>3 «06 OXOTe J1 0 coxpaHeHID1 OXOTHi-f'ibI1X pe-
CypcOB J1 a mreceIDm J13MeHemrn: B QT,!J;eJlbHble 3aKOHo,!\aTeJlbHble alITbI
PoccnnCKOu CPe,l:\epaqi£ll»2. B CBR3J1 C OXurHlll'lliJlMIf npaBOOTHOWeHJUlMJl!
III3MeHeHHH 6bIJll1 BHeceHbI B YK J'ItI, KoAII J'ItI, HK J'ItI, 3K J'ItI, JIK
PIt>,BKPIt>.
O,I\HaKO no OXOTe npmnn&WIJK'b 11 penmH3JIbIIbE aKTbL B Ra'ieCTBe
npMMepa MO:IKHOnpJIBeCTHIQHaJIbHbIE:'3aKOHbI06 OXOTe. B ill{ 'll1CJle-
::Ox=:O::(;a
,!\eJlellJlle OXOTHJ1tIbI1X yro,!J;ID1 RaK Cpe,!:(bI 06JTrnHJ1H OX011ll1'1b11X .?KJ1BOT-
HbIX, B KOTOPY1O BXO,!J;RT 11 BOble 06'beKTbl (CT. 1 11 7). Kp(JMe TOro, B
3aKoHe C01J;epmaTC.fI IICJJX»K€Hi'1. no o6ecne<reHJOO, COXpaHeHillO J1 YJlyq-
WeHJIIlOKa'ieCTBa OXCtTHWlbI1X yro,!J;ID1 (CT. 13-15).
Ha MHOI11X poccImCIDIX 03epax B 1130611JillY! BOR npoMl:lCJIOBbIe
1OrqI1e IITI1Qb!, 06Y!TalOT Bbl,IUJa J1 HOpRa, IiIX MO:IKHO J1cnOJlb30-
BaTb.wm pa3Be,!\eHWI nyumoro 3BepR (OH,!J;aTpbI II[ HJTPillillt.
ropHoe ,/J;eJIO B paMRaX BOJ];OIIOJIL3OBaHJUL IIo 06ll\eMY lIpaBJ.1JIY, IiIC-
IIO.JIb.3OBaHJI BOblX 06'beKTOB.wm pa3Be,!J;ID1 11 J];06bNJ1 nOJIe3HblX I1C-
KonaeMbIX perJJaMeH'lJ1PYeTC.fI KaK BOWlbIM 3aKQHO,!J;aTeJIbCTBOM, TaK 11
3aKOHo,!\aTeJlbCTBOM a HeJ1Pax (CT. 52 BK J'ItI).
I C3P$.1995 N!!17Cr 1462
2pr.2oo9N!!13728HIOI1
31lQ/:J,Moc1<DB11<3Be<::TI1R.20003aBrycrn
411eCfl€HK()BKnp"PO/IHb'epecyPCb'(I:JepPC<t>CPl<HX M.06I11€CTBo.3Ha-
I<..e.PCax;P,1984.C 12-13
-63-

 KpaTKO OxapwcrefM30BaTb 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbCTBO 0 He.n;paX
::lg:=a:a::;;;e;;
IOTCH npaBOBbIe JII 3IroH0MIf'lffRHe OCHOBbll\'OMI1JIeKCHOl'O paH3J.IbRr
I'D HCIIOJIb3OBaID1R J-I OXpaHbI He,!U), 06eCne'll1BaH aaIqIIITa JfirrepecoB
rocyMpcTBa JII rpajK):\aH POCCIDl, a TalOKe npaB n0JIb30BaTeJIeH He.zIP.
HapHfI.Y C HUM,l\eHc-mylar cpe 3aH(flb]: (IT 17 ,lJ;eKa6pH 1998 I'.
NQ19143 «06HCM3IOCJHOMWI€CIOCii:30He POC{1I[I"icIroii4>e-
JI.epal\I1J1»2, OT 30 HC»l6p.fi 1995 I'. NQ 18743 «0 Kf)HTIfH€H'raJIbHOMmeJIb-
$> Pooo:niClarii cpe,lJ;epaQI.ur»3. OT 32 ,lJ;eKa5pH 1995 I'. NQ 22543 «0 CQ-
rJIarnemmxa pa3.n;eJIe npo» .
Bee npt 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbHble aKTbl perJIaMelITHpYJ<YI' arnorne-
HJ-IR He,DJXTIOJJb3ClB3fR, KOTOphIe MOryr 3aTpaI'MBaTb 11 Bql\OIlOJIb3OBa
Ho OTHX'JfI'e,JIhHO ,wJ6bNJ1 TOPct>a J1MeeTCR CneqI-faJIhHoe npaBHJlO.
cpe):\epaJIbHbIi1: 3aKOHo,!\aTeJTh .n;onYCKaeT nOTeplO 6oJIOTOM pe»rnMa EO,!1-
HOro ofu.elt1'a B pe3YJIbTaTe BbIpa6oTIa1 TOPct>a J13aMeHbl em MaTepMaJ1a-
l\oD1 ecTeCTBeHHOrO H T€XHOI"eHHOI'O 1IJXllHM.H. O.D;H81\O x03Ri1:CTBy-
lOlW1i1 cyfu.eKT 06113aH peKYJIbTMpOBaTb 6oJIOTa npeJ1M.Y1l\€CTBeHHO
nyreM I1X 06BO)J;HeIDlH (CT. 52 BK pcp). 3To Tpe60BaHMe BbITeKaeT }13
BeCbMa ne'laJlbHoro OnbITa OO,/J;MOCJ\OBHllX nC»KapoB JIeTa 2002 I'., Kor.r:\a
OI'OHb B03IDmaJI Ha  TOPiPHlllmax, Karopble 6poCHIDI 6e3
peKYJJbTHBaI.tlftL Top KaK qeHHbrn I1pJ pecypc ,l\OBOnbHO ,l\onro
ocraBaJlCfl B qeH1p€' BHHMaH!1fl rocYAapcma. K cmtaUi€ffiUO, 3Ta clIT)'a-
,TOJIbKOBe60J1eeKpylIHbIXMacurra6ax, nOBTopJ1JJacbJJeTOM201Or..,
J1 }"Ke He TOJibKO B IIoJJ;MocKoBbe, HO J1 BO MHOrl1X ,DJ)yrnx pernoHax.
IIpaBJ1Te.JlbC'l1J HOpMUl'B0p':lecroo no noBO.n;y ropl}»nrblX pecyp-
COB, OC06eHHO.l\0 Be.m1KOiiBOfun,j, 6blJl00QeHb 06lill1pHbIM
J13ac.llJ'Kl1B8.eT OT.l\eJlbHoro rxx.ne,lJE8.lD'm 3aTeM, }"Ke K KOHIl)' COBeTCKo-
roneplnp03ByqaJlJ1npe1H1iI3Be.n:opyccID1no
C03,l\aHJOO caMOC'J"Ofm'-JIbHOi.i: KaTeropIDI 3eMeJIb 'l'OpclmHoro $JH,I\a. J(aH-
HbJe npe,l\JlruKeHl1.R He 6blJTh1 nO,l1.!\ep:)Klll{bl, HO Bee me no IfCIIJ.JIb3OBaHJ(}Q
60nar CJIO»G1JIacb onp€,!\eJleHHafl HopManfimo-npaBOBaH fia3a5.
MecTO IIO.JIe3HHX IiIrnomeMbIX  ooep BeCbMa
6oraTbI, HO He Bcer 1i13Y"1eHbI iii OCBoeHbl. >Ke.rre3Hble PY.l\l>I.l\06HBa.m1Cb
J13 ooep Kape.IDflll ell\e c XVIII B., It3BeCTbIO 60raTbI 03epa HeQepH03e-
I BBCP<tI.1992 Nl!16.Cr 834
2 C3P<b.1998.NI!51.CT.6273
3 C3P<111995.NI!49.CT.4693
4 C3P<t1 1996.NI!1 CT 18
5 Bo.c.aPOCCH L>1HiI>oPMalJ,HQHHoeH3.I1iIHHeMHnpI<po.I1t>POCCH 1999.NI!3 C.4-,S
-64-

MhR, MMeKYrCH 3anaCb! ,D;HaTOMJIITOB B  Ko.m,CKOro IDJIyOCTpOBa.
MHmKeCTBO 03ep no pa3HbIM pen-lOHaM POCCJ-1I1 HaJroruLJUf rpaBHlf, neCOR,
r.IDfHY, ROTOpble IiIcn0Jlh3yro'I'CR RaK CTpOHMaTepl13.JIhl. B 3licyI11JIUBlolX
30Hax IOra POCCJ-1I1 HaXO,D;HTCJI nOHC COJIHHbIX 03ep. 113 HHX .n;06bIBaIOT no-
BapeHH)'lO iii Ka.mrlii:HYID COJIM, MaI'HJil, 6POM, 6op, nmc. OreHh 60raTbi co-
JIbIO 03epa BaCK}'H'faK (Acrpa"GlHCKaH 06nacTb), 3JIbTOH (BoJITorpa,!\-
CKaH OIirraCTb), 36eTI-1 (OMCKafl 06naCTb).
BoAoIIOJll>3()BallJ B .ne-re6HbIX. 03AfIP0IIIITCJI1iI peKpeaIJ;l-10H-
HbIX qCJlHX. B CT. 49 BR Pip cOJIep)tOfT('.fl J!Jflllb OTCbIJIO'fHasI HopMa Ha
3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBO 0 IIpI1pO.rr;HbIX ne"leOHbIX pecypcax, po-
Bl-1TeJlbHbIX MecTHOCT.fIX 11 KypOpTax.
OCHOBHbIM npaBOBbIM 8KTOM, onpe,l\e.mnoJ.W1M nOpR,l\OK J«n)JTh3OBa-
HI1JI BO,l\HhIX , cOJ\epmalql1X IIpI1}XJ,!\HbIe ne<i:e6Hble pecypcH,
RBJIHeTCR epa.nbHHiii: 3aKOH DT 23 BpaJiH 1995 r. NQ2643 «0 npl-1-
po.rr;HbIX ne<i:e6HbIX pecypcax, ne<i:e6HO-()3,J:J.OJ)OOlITeJItHbIX MeCTHOCT.fIX 11
KypopTax»l. Ha OCHOBe  lta3BaHllOro 3aKoHa pa3BJ.1BaH
npaBOBGe pery.ID1pOBaHl1e B ,AaHlIOM ccpepe Ita ,!\epa.n:bHOM 1-1 pemo-
H8JIbHOM ypOBHflX.
YHJ.1K8JIbHOCTb, OCo6aH qeHHOCTh IIpl1po,!\HhIX ne<i:e6HbIX peCypcOB
(JIeqeOHbIX MI1Hep8J1bHbIX BO,!\, JII1MaHOB M 03ep, yqacrKOB MOpcKl1X BO,!\)
06YCJIOBI1J!I-1 3a1«.H)J:1aTeJlbHOe IIpJ'131I8.HIte J1X oco6o oxp8.HH€l&DIJl. JIe-
"ieOHble CBOMCTBa IIpl1po,!\HbIXJ!e'ie6HHx peCypcOB IIpJI3HaIOTC.H Ha OCHo-
BaHl-1l-1 Hay<rHbIx  M MH()I'()1It'THeii! npaKTillGf iii YTBep*JIIi-
IOTCH 4Je,l\epaJlbHbIM opraHOM IiIC1IOJIHI-ITe.JIbHOi,i BJIaCTI1, Be,l\8IOIWfM
BCnpOCaMtI 3JJP8B00XPaHeHI-1.fI.
IIpl1po,!\Hb!e JIe"ieOHble pecypcbl HBJIHIOTCH rocy,l\apcrBEflHOii c06cr-
BeHHOCTbIO. (hm Moryr H8X<J.roITbCfl B <pe,i:\epaJlbHoA ro6c'rBeHR:>c11f JII160
IIpI-1Ha,l\JlemaTb H8 IIpaBe COOcrBeHHOCTJf cy6DeKTaM CPe.n;epaL!Jfil
B Ha3BaHHOM 3aKOHe YCTaH8.BJlJ1BaeTCfl CTporo qeJleBoe I1cnOJlh30Ba-
mreIIpl1po.rr;HbIXpecypcoB:WIHneqeHI1HI138-
O:JJI€BaHlm, a TaJOtre qeJlei1: OT,l\bIXa. MHHepaJlbHb1e BO,!\b1 Mor)'T I1CIIQJIb--
30B8TbCH ,WIH npOMblllIJleHHoro pa3Jll1B8. B Ka'leCTBe I1CKJllO'IeHl1H
B03MOjKHO ItCIX)JIb3()B3mre BO,l\HbIX ne'le6HbIX peCypcOB WIJI rnrIbeBOrO
BO,i:\ocHa6meHI1H I1.ID1Ii1HbIX qeneM. O,rr;HaKO T8Koe JICIIOJIb3(]B8Hfe caHK-
OHl1pyeTCH opraHaMIf IICIIOJIHI1'i'E' BnaCTI1 cy6DeKTOB F'occI1I"i-
CKOM CPe.r\epaQI1I-1 no COrJIaCOBaHi11O C PocBo.v;pecypcaMl1, Poca;rqJaMH,
rocy,!\apcTBeHHbIM (,!\epa.r:rbHbIM) Opr8HOM, oCy:IQecTBJImOLII;I1M ynpaB-
.neHJ1e RypOpT8MIf.
1 C3P<11.1995 1IR9 Cl713.
-65-

IIoJIb30BaTenflMI1 npl1pO,Ii;HbIX ne<:le6HbIX peCypCOB MOryr 6bITb
IOPJWI'iE'CIGI€ nJ1IJ;a Ii rpam,!\aH€. IIpe,!\OCTaBJIeIDI€ IIpHpO,/J,HldX ne-
'1€6HbIX pecypCOB B nOJlb30Baml€ otlJopMJIJleTCJI Cn€l\l1aJIbHblM rocy-
,AapCTBeHHbIM pa3pellI€Hlf€M-Jn1Ll€H3I1e:iii:. IIopJl,!\oK Bb'1lf nJill\eH-
3lfH onpe,neJIJI€TCH IIpaBJ1TenbcTBoM PCP. Ha KYpOpTaX J1 B
KypOPTHbIX pemmlax pa3pa6OTKa Dplfpo.nHHX JIe'le6HbIX peCypCOB
OCyrn;eCTBJIHeTCH Cn€l\t1aJIM3J1poBaHHbIMll reoJIOrl1'leCKMMJ1
IIpe.nrrpMHTJ1.fIMll J1 opraHt-I3a.qtr.m.rn, J1MelOMll JIlfLleH3lfM Ha 3TOT
Btf)1,ne.RTeJIbHOCTl1.
Cpe,!\11 o6roaHHOCTeJi nOJIb30BaTeJIeH CJIetIYeT 06paTI1Tb BlDIMatme Ha
BtdI1OJIH€IDle yCTaHOBJIeHHbIX 3aKOHOM TpeOOBaHI1:iii: 0 paqMOHa.JI:bH:IM IfC-
lIOJIb3OB8ID[Jl 11 COXpaHe1U111 nOJIe3HbIX coo:iii:CTB npl1JX>,Ii;HbIX ne'le6HblX
pecypCOB npl1 J1X pa3pa6oTKe:
- o6'beMbI ,n06bl'fl1 npl1pO,!I;HbIX ne'le6HbIX pecypCOB JII1MJ1TI1pytO'fCJI
yrnepm,Ii;eHHbIMJ-I no npoMb!llIJleHHbIM KaTeropl1JlM 3anaCaMl1 Ii cpoKaMl1
J1X3KCITJIya'raI.{lrn;
- IIpl1MeHfleMble TeXHwmm ,n06bNM, nQrJ;I'OTCI3ItIllf IfC:rIOJIb3OBaIDIH
npl1pO,!I;HbIX JI€'Ie6HblX pecypCOB ,nOJDKHbl rapaml1pOBaTh 3aLwrry OT
npem,!\eBpeMeHHoro IfCTOllleHl1H, 3arpfl3H€ID1H, 3aLwrry IIOJIe3HbIX IfCKO-
IIaeMbIX OT YTpaTbi J1X IIOJIe3HbIX CBOJ1c'rn;
-1lpJ1MeHHeMbIe npl13Kcn.rryaTaQl1I1 TeXHOJDIWIeCIG1€ MeTO,nbI ,[IOJDK-
IIbI OCHOBbmaTbCH Ha 'I'eXIIOJIOn1'l€CKl1X cxeMax pa3pa60TlIJ1.
)J..rIH: o6ecJIe'I€HKH 3aLIJ;l1TbI:J1 coxpaHeHI1JI nplfpo,[lHbIX ne'le6HbIX pe-
CypCOB J1 OBJITeJIbHbIX M€C'l'HCJC'I'ei OT 3arpH3HeHJ1.Fl J1
1fC'I'crQ€HHH lOTCHoKpyraCaffi:lTapHo:iii:
(ropHO---CaHHTapHO:iii:) OXpaHbI, npe.l1C'I'8BJI.fIK;IQ co6o:iii: oco6o roq:mme-
Ml.Ie TePPlITOpl1l1 l .
RaK yxa3aHO B CT. 50 BK PCP, IfcnOJIb30BaHYle BOJ\HbIX o{h,eKToB
,AJIH peKpeaLll10HHbIX LleJIei1 nOJ\pa3YMeBaeT OT.J\l.IX, TypJ-f3M, cnoPT.
PeKpeaLll-fOHHOe BOJ\onOJIb30BaHJ1e MomeT npe,IJ;IIoJIaraTh npoeKTYlpO-
HaHYle, pa3Mern;eHYle, CrpOllTeJIbCTBO, P€KOHCTPYKW'IlO, BBO.J\ B 3KC-
IIJIyaTBl\lliO J13KCIIJIyaTaLlI11O 3,1J;aHlf:iii:, cTpoeHIDI, coopymeHlf:iii: WIH pe-
KpeaW10HHbIx LleJIeii:. K J1X '1I1CJ1Y B nepayro o'lepe,lJ.h OTHOCIf'I'C1I
06YCTPOHCTBO nmI)Keii:, KOTopble Talt)Ke IfM€IOT CBOlO IfHcI:>pacTpYKry-
PY_ IIo3ToMY peKpeaQl10HHOe BO,JJ;OIIOJib3OB8.HI-Ie perJIaMelITJ1pyeTCH
He TOJIbKO J1 He CTOJIbKO BOJ\HbIM 3aKOHOJ\aTeJ1bCTBOM, HO 11 3eMeJIbHl.IM
3aKOHOJ\BTeJIbCTBOM, 3aKOHOJ\aT€JlbCTBOM 0 rpa,!\OCTpOJ1T€JIbHo:iii: .J\€H-

I Ci18ar08.l1.0.BQllHoenpaBO:noco6He.M..3AO.2007
C.70-74
-66-

K coma.neHJ1JO, B H8.CTOe Bper.rn nOC'lpOeHHbIe B COBeTCKOe IIpeMfl
Be,l:P4CTBeHllble ,AOMa OTa, naHCHOHaTb! 3aI1Ycre.JIJ1 H d5a1nqxJrn-
.IDlCb. J1x MeCTO MOIyr aaIDITb 'IaCTHbIe .l\OMa.
Pexpecuvf(flllOe OOWm.JIb3OBaIDte, COrJIaCHO CT. 11 BKPcp, B O):!Hl1X
CJlyqaRX M<»KeT 6bITb otlx>PMJIeHO .l\OroBOpaMJII BO,lI(JII01Ib3O, B .lU1Y-
rnx - perneHl1HM11 0 npeHllII BO)J;HbIX O&beKTOB B n0JIb30BaHl1e,
B-'I'peTbJlX - He 'I'pe6yeT HH pewemrl1. Jill,AOCOBOpOB. Heo6xo.n;J.1Mo pac-
CMOTpeTb Bee 'I'pH c.rryqaH.
Ha OCHOBaHIDI .l\OrOBOpOB BO,AOIIOJIb30BaHI1H rocy.v;apCTBeHHb!e H MJ-
m BO.l\Hble O&beKTb! IlpeJ:\OC'TaBJl A!IR U
3KBaTOJJI1H BO)J;HbIXOODeK'roB, B TOM 'll1CJle WIR  l{eJlei1.
Ho Jf3 3TOro o61l\ero npamma ecTh I1CKJiI{JqeHJUl.
Ha OCHOBaHID'! peweHJIlii rocY.l\apc-rBeHHble J1 M)'HK!.\I1II8JIbHble BO,!\-
Hble ofu.eKTbl npe.ll.OCTaBJIHIOTCH,l\J!R opmID13OB8.HHOfO OTa .l\erei1, a
TaIOKe BerepaHoB, rpam,llaH nO:iKl1JIoro B03pacra, Jnmam
IIp>! aTOM KJffilHl1e 11 y.I¥JB.!Ie113OpEWE I1HbIX JlWlHbIX J16bITOBblX HJ:iK,I:(
rpH He TpeoYeT orpopMJHIJ1Hnocpe.l\CTBOMJJ;oroBOpOBl1pE1lleIDul
I()HH(€ BOJIUIX)JIb3OBaHJ1€.l\OJI)ttHO COO1'BeTC'I1JCITb npaBl1-
JIaM nOJlb30BaHl1H BO)J;HbIX OODeftTDB WIR .IDIYIIblX 116bITOBbIX HJ)K,l\, YT-
BepJK,!laeMbIX opraHaMJ1 Mecrnoro caMoynpaBJ1€IDIH. ComaCHo CT. 6, 27
BK pcp opraHbI MecrHoro caMoynpaBJIeHl1R ycraHaBJlHBalOT IIpaBl-1JIa
IIOJlb30BaHWI I BO,!\HbIMJ.1 06'beKTaMJ1, paCIIOJIo:meHHbI-
MJ1 H8. Teppt1'IOpHlf M;yHI o6pa3<EffiU1iii, WIRJIJ1'-IHbIX 116bITO-
BbIXH}':iKJJ;.
npaBl-lJla BO,/WII0JIb30Bamm B l\eJlRX o6ecne-leHI1R npoTJlBonomap-
HOti 6e3oIIaCHOCTll. no pa3HbIM npl1'iHHaM (B TOM 'IHCJle OT caMOB03fO-
paHl1R) IUJ],IIO «rOpRT)) OKOJIO 15 cyfu.eKToB F'occJfiicJ«JJIcpe.v;ePaLlllJf.
B CT. 53 BK PCP npe,D;JCMaTpHBaeTCR 6eClIJlaTHbrn: 11 H20IJBIDI'IE'HHblJI
aa60p BOJI.bI WIR TyrneHWI nomapa 113 .mc6oro BO,IJ;HOro ofu.eK'I'a. IIpH
3TOM BOBCe He CJle,D;Je'f )fi,£\aTb <n>ero-JiJ160 pa3pemeHl1fl, I1fu JJ;opora
ttaifi,rlafl MJ1Hyra.
KpoMe TOro, l1Mee-rCR 4JOH,lJ; BO,!\oeMOB, npe,IJ;Ha3Ha'ieHHbIX A!IR 06ec-
lI€'iemrn nomapHoi16e30JIaCHOcTH. J1x ttaTerOJ:WiE'CKJlsanpell\3.eTCR I1C-
IIOJlb30BaTb AJlR.v;pyrnx u;eJleti, I1fu TaKOe JICJlOJIb3OBaHJte MruKeT He 1I03-
BOJlHTb sa,lJ;eikTBOBaTb ]13HHbIIii BO,lJ;OeM JJ;JlR TYllleHI-UI nomapa.
Hanpl1Mep, IIpYJ1, J1ClI IIO,IJ; c6poc CTO'IHbIX BO,lJ;, M<»KeT CO-
.l\epmaTb B ce6e  BeIl\eCTBa, 'iTO TOJlbKO ycJlOmHl1T
pa60Ty noma.pHJ1KOB.
C CM\aJleHl1eMH)"KHOKOHCTampoBaTb, 'ITO npOTIlIICIIIt:m\apHbIe npy-
JJ;b! SeJleHbIX 30H 11 neCHbIX MaCCHBOB HBJIRIOTCR 6p0c0m.IMtt. B pe3YJlbTa-
Te OHJ1 npHlll.Ill1 B HeroJI.HOCTh Jf3-33 OOMeneHI-UI I1saM;yCOplfBaHJlfL
-67-

Tpe6yeTCJI roTOBmD BO..n;OeMbI ,l\JIH I\CI3MOmHOI'O rrpcmlBOJl(»K8pHOro
o:::o6::'=O::laaKoHY OT 21.l1eKa6pH 1994 1'.
Ha:3BaHHHii 4>e.llepaJIbHhrn: 3aKOH onpe.lleJtHeT o6IqMe npaBOBble, 3100-
HOMM'leCRJ1e 11 CO OCHOBbl o6eCne':lelUm nOiKapHoii: 6e3onaaD-
CTI1 B POCCID1, perym1pye-r B 3TOii: 06JIaCTI1 oTIlowemm Me:m,I:()'OpraHaMJ1
rocyAa,pc"fBeHH£Ji.i: BJIaCTI1, OpraHaMJ1 MeCTHoro caMJYIIPaWIelD1H, yq-
pe)tQ:(eHl1JlMJ1, opra.HI13&II1JIf. <pepMepcKI1MJ1 X();3jliicrBaMJ1, I1HblMl1
KpJf,[\lf'ECKi'1I\oIJI JII1qaMH He3aBJtClfMO OT IIX OpmHlI3aqW)HHO-npaBOBbIX
c}x>pM 11 clxJPM Co6cTBeIIHOCTl1, a TaKiKe Me:m,I:()' d'iwec'rneHHHMn 06'belll1-
HemVIMU, ,IJ;OJDKHOCTHhIMJIIJ!J1qaMI-f, 1
ComaCHO CT. 19 3aKoHa «0 nOiKapHoii: 6e30narn0crJt" K nOJlliOMO'IM-
HM opraHOB MeCTIloro caMoynpaBJIeHl1Jl B OOnacTM nomapHoii: 6e3onacJD-
CTI1 OTHOC'JITCH:
- C0311aIDfe B LleJIHX nOiKapcrryuremur ycoomm,l\JIH aa60pa B JII060e
BpeMH rolla BO)J;bl:l13 I1CTO'ilIJfKOB HapymHoro BOllocHat»Kemm (T.€. BO,!\-
HbIX om.eKTOB), paCIIOJImN2HHbIX B CeJIbCKI1X HaCeJIeHHbIX nYHIITaX:I1 Ha
IlpJLJIeICUOIl\MX K ID1M TeppmopI1HX;
- 0CHalLIflIIf€ TeppJTIUpuii: 06IL1ero n0JIb30BaHl1H nepmf'lHbIMl1 cpe,[l-
CTBaMI-f TyweID1H nomapoB 11 nponrnorrOmapHbIM I1HBeHTapeM.
I C3P<J1.I994.N!!35.Cr 3649
-68-

rnaBa 3
nPABOBAR OXPAHA BOA
H OTBETCTBEHHOCTb
3A HAPYWEHHE EE TPE50BAHHH
1. 05l1jHE BonPOCbl nPABoBo OXPAHbl
BOi\HOro QJOHi\A
Cu:crcma npaBOIIOii OXpaHbI DO)); D Pottm.. COrJIaCHO CT. 1 BK Plpox-
paHa BO,lJ;HbIX o6neKToB - aTO CI1CTeMa Meponpm:ri1riii:, HanpaBJIeHHbIX Ha
coxpaHeID1e IiI EOCCTaHOBJIemI€ BO)I;HbIX c.6betcroB, B COBOI\yiIHOCTI'I cBOeii:
COC'TaB.IDIIOJ.W1XBo,!I;HbIiict>oH,rJ;PoCCI1J1.
OxpaHa BO)I;HbIX o6neKToB (a 3Ha'll1T, 11 BO)J;HOro $JHM) npe1J.YCMOT-
peHa H8. ypoBHe KaK MepO)J;Horo, TaK 11 OTe'ieCTB€HHOrO npaBa.
 Me>K,ZJyHapo)I;HhIX npaBoBhIX 3KTOB, a TaIDKe BO,I\HOro, IIpJ1-
po.lIOOXp8HlI)I'O 11 CaHi-fTapHoro 3aKOHO));aTeJlbCTBa nplt3BaHH npe,!\y-
npeTb, npeCeKaTb 11 YCTpaHRTb I1OCJIe}J;CTBtIR HeraTWBHoro B03,I\eii-
CTBHH Ha BO,!\Hblii ct>oH):\. rIpH aTOM BO,!\Hoe 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIhCTBO
OCHOBblBaeTCfI Ha npHopmeTe OXpaHhI BO)J.HhIX o6neKToB nepe,!\ I1X I1C-
nOJlb30BaIDteM (CT. 3 BK Pip).
CHCT€Ma npaBoBOJI OXPaHhI BO,!I;HbIX o6neKToB npe,IJyCMaTpHBaeT
tpOBaHHOe YC'TaHOBJIeHHe npl1pO.l1OOXpaHH TpeOOBaHI-1fl B
3aEHCI1MOCTI1 ar xapaK'l'epa BO,noIIOJIb3OBaHJ1H, BHM Bo.WlOro 05'beKTa,
ero COC'TOflHIUi 11.-urrpociOf'€HHi Harpy3fU1, npJ-IXO,!\HiI\eiiCH Ha Hero. IIo-
3'I"OM)' HI1:1Ke 5Y,IJyT CIJeQltaJIbHO paccMOTpeHhI oco5eHHoCTH, npo6.rreMbI 11
T})Y,WiOC'TH npaB(J3oii oxpaHbI nO,!\3eMHbIX BO)I;HbIX 06'heKTOB.
IIpaBOBaH oxpaHa BO,WiOro ct>oH,!\a POCCillIIl1MeeT CJIe.rr,yK>J1J,I1e OCHOB-
Hb!e HanpaBJ1€HH.H:
-pery.ID1pOBaIDIelw.HTeJIbHOCTl-1, 3a-
IpH3HeHJre I1l1flOe HeI'aTlfBHOe B<W1eHcTBHe;
- yc-raIIOlIJl€HI H c06.molleHHe peJKJfMoBIIO.JlOOXpaHlIN 30H b'l caHH-
TapHbIX OKpyrOB);
- ycraHOWIeHJ'le 11 e:ct5.mo.I:\eHHe p€mI-fMOB oco6o oxpamreMbIx BO,!UIhIX
05'beKTOB;
- IIOOIUJflllte BOCCTaHOBJIem-rn BO)J;HbIX o6neKTOB, HeiiTpaIDl3a4ID'l
HaKOnJIeHHOro 3KQJI)I'h'ieCKoro yruep5a.
-69-

.uofurrbCJI «nepeJIOMa» B ,IJ;eJIe OXpaHbIBO,!UIblX,,IJ;a J1 Boo6Il\e lIpwpo,!\-
HbIX peCypcOB MOO Jll1lllb nOCpe)1CTBOM BBe,I\eHKH 6e3O'I'X(),lJ;HUX Jf.ID1
MaJIOOTXO,!UIblX TeXHOJI()I1nl TaKQBO J1HT€rpaJIbH0e HanpaBJIeHMe CIiICTe-
Mbl npaBoBoi-i: OXpaHbl BO,!UIblX o6oeK'roB,
B cliIJIY CT. 55 BK plfI c05crBeHHIiIK BO)J.HOro 05'heKTa (3TO I'JIaBHblM 06-
pa30M I'Ocy,!\apCTBO B JIJ1II;e rocy,IJ;apcTBeHHbIX opraHoB) 05H3aH ocy:ll.\e-
CTBJlfiTb BO,IJ;OOxpaHHble MepOIIpI1fITI1fI. KpoMe TOro, 13WJ€CKIre iii KJPIiI-
,IJ;WleCKMe .ID1Qa - n0Jlb30BaTeJill BO,IJ;HbIX 06'beK'l'OB TaIOKe 06H3aHbI
npe,!\OTBpaIQaTb iii ycrpaH)ITb nOCJIe,!\CTBI1JI HeraTm3Horo EI03J(a'icT.BJul Ha
BO,!UIbrn $JH,!\.
IIpe'!\ycMoTpeHHaH 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIeM clilcreMa oxpaHbI BIJ,IJ;tUI11 4>uH.I\a
BKJIlOqaeT B ce5H MOHMTOplilHr 11 roCYpcTBE:'lIIIbrii}"leT BOJ\HbIX 06'heK-
TOB, a TaKiKe 1t0HTp0JIb 3a I1X 11CnOJIb3(ElUn1eM, np11BJI€'ieH11e It OTBeTCT-
BeHHOCTJI BJIHOBHbIX B HapymemlHX. IIo:noM}' B HaCTOHLqee BpeMH no-
CJIe,IJ;OBaTeJIbHaH oxpaHa BOJVfbIX pecypCOB HeB03MQjtQIa 6e3 yqaCTJ-1JI B
3TOM npoKypaTopbI 11 CY,!\OB. B l{e.IDIX roqmIbI poccJIikIroro BOJIHOro $JH-
J\a ycrB.HaBJIJ1BaIOTCH COOTBeTCTByrolll;VIe 3aHble pemHMbI 11 30HbI,
KOTOpble 6y.uyr paccMarpeHbl HaMJ1 JlaJIee.
B POCCID'J E'TCHOXpaHa BOJVfbIX 06'beK'l'OB OTpa3JIJ1q}JblX
BI.-J,l10B HeraTHBHoro B03AeiicTBKR Ha BO)J.Hh!e OObeKTbL ITpem,n;e Bcero,
3TO 3aI'pfl3HeHJ'1e BO,!UIblX o6oeKToB - nreryrureHJ1e B BO;:J;llbIi-i: o6oeKT Be-
LqeCTBa 11 (J1.1ThI) 3HepI'ID1, CEOI1crBa. MeC'TOIIOJI»f\te Jf.ID1 Kom-rqecrBO
KOTOpblX OKa3bIBaKYT HeraTI1BHOe Ie Ha 0xp)"fffilOrnyK> cpe,!\y.
TaK)'IO rP>PM}'.ID1poBKY MQjtQIO Tb, JR:IIO.llb3YH onpe,!\eJIeIDIe nOHJlTIIH
3arpH3HeHI1fIRcpe,!\bI,,!\aHHoeBCT.l CP3aKoHa
OT 10 cl>eBpaJUI 2002 I'. NQ 7-4>3 «06 oxpaHe rnp}"K8lOlllBl cpe,!\bl».
B BK Pip He onpe,!\eJIeHO noRm}!e 3aCOpeHI1JI BOJlHbIX OOheK'l'OB. Ho C
HayqHoi-i: TO'IKJII 3peHJ1Jl 3acopamf' - :no c6poc J1Jill noc'fYIIJIeHl-1e I1HbIM
cnocc60M B BOJ\Hble OOheKTbI npe,ro'YleTOB 11 B3BellleHHblX 'lB.CTI1q, yxy,lJ;IIIa-
1OLqI.1XI1XCOC"I"llilliJ1eJf.ID13aTpY,!\HHlOLqJ1XI1XHepa33aCo-
peHl-1e pOCCl'liiCKi'IX BO,!\OTOKOB 11 BO,!\oeMOB o6opa'lI1B8JIOCb 3aXJIaMJIeHl-1eM
6porneHHblMl1 TpaHcnOpTHbIMl1 cpe,!\crBaMJ1I13aTOH)'B1ill1M eCTBOM1.
IIol\olJ1MO 3arpH3HetrnJI 113acopeHI1fI poconict«:MyBOJIHOM)'qx,HJJ;y yr-
pomaeT JiCTOllJ'HJIE:' - nOCTOHHHoe COKpaIl\eID1e 3anacoB JII YXYJ\rneHl1e
l\8'lecTB8 nOBE'pXHOC11fblX JII nO,!\3eMHblX BO)}.. O,IJ;H8KO ,!\aHH0e nOHHTI1e He
OIIpeJ\eJIeHOBBKPcIJ
J1cro'iIDlKaloni 3arpH3HeHI1JI JII 3acopem1Jl HBJUllOTCJI:xro.ffi1c'rneH
ofu.eIcrH, Ie c6poc J1Jill nOCTyn.rreIDIe I1HbIM o5pa30M
I Bo.c.aPOCCH 2001.NII.C.4
-70-

13pe,!\HbIX Ber.u;eCTB B BO,!J;Hble 06DeKTbI. 3To - IIpOMbllllJleHHble npe,D;lIpl1-
Hl'11.R, c6pate HHble CTO'IHble BO, KOMM)'H8.JTh-
HO--6H'roBOeX03.HiiiC'I'BOCf CTOKaMl1; npe,!\-
npllmIDl CeJIhCKOro :xoam1cTBa, npl1MeHffiOIW1e lV\OXl1MUKaTbll1 .lWyrt1e
XJ1MJ1'IeCKilleBer.u;eCTBa, CTOKill1XIt()MTIJJ€IOC'OBJ1$?pM;
cy,!\8. 11 J1HbIe nepe,!\BmKHble cpe,!\CTBa 11 }'C'I1UI01!&1 Ha BO.I\e; CILJIaB neca;
1IpOBE',!\em1e C'I'pOI1'feJIbH, .AHoyr.nyf.:m-em.HHx, B3pbIBHbIX 11 ,lJf)yrl1X
pa6ar Ha BO,!\HbIX o&beKTax.
OxpaHa BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTOB OT aarpH3HeHIDlI13aCOpeHl1H OCY11-\eCTBJlfI-
eTCH nyreM perYJU1poBaHl1.R ,!\eme.JThHOCTtl HC'IO'lHtIKOB caMOro HeraTt:lB-
HOro B03,!\eHcrnAA  IOp".I\I1'leCKHe JU1qa J1 rpa:1K,!\aHe
.I\OJIjftHbI npHHI1MaTb}'CT8IiQBJI€HHbte 3aKOHQAaTeJIbCTBOM Mepbl no rrpe-
.I\OT8pall\eIDllO 3arJm3H€HI1JI J1 BOCCTaHOBJIeHHIO BO,!\HbIX 06DeftTOB, a
c6poc 11 3a6op BO.D;bl CTpOro HOPMl1py1OTCH.
1f'BQ!100xpaHHble,I1CaHl1TapHo-n-m-I-
eHW'IecKJ1e orpe6oBaHw:I K I1CI'O'lHWKaM3aIp&3HeHIDlYCTaHOBJIeHbIB BR pq"
B epaJIbHbIX 3aItOHaX «06 oxpaRe OKpymalOr.u;eH cpeAbl» 2002 1'. H
«OcaHIITapRJ-:;rn6JIaronOJi)"ll-fi1HaC€JI€ffi1Jl» 19991'.
,lLrrJi OXpaHhl BH}'TpeHHI1X MOpcKID!: BO.I\, Teppl1TOpJ.-IaJlbHbIX BO.!\, 01'-
KphITOro MOpH OT 3aIpJl3HeIDlH BeIl\eCTBaMU, 13pe,!\HbIMJlI wm 1KJ1BbIX pe-
CypcOB MOpJ'l, cYIl\ecrnyeT oco6b1ii nopJ'l,!\OK, YC'TaHOBJIeHHCnI Memp,yHa-
po,!\HhlMJlI ,!\OroBOpaMJ1. POCCI1.R npl-lHMMaeT yqacTUe B KoHBeHl\I-Il-I 0
3aJLtl:lTe qepHoroMopJ'lOT aaIpfI3H€HHJI OT 21 anpeM 1992 r., KoHB€Hl\I-Il-I
00 oxpaHe MOpcKOi1 cpeAbi Ea.nmiicKoro MOpH OT 9 anpeM 1992 1'., KoH-
BeHl\HI-I no oxpaHe 11 I1C1ICJJIb3CJ3aIDUO IIO,IJ,O'IOKOB 11 MeapO,!\HhlX
03ep, IB XeJlbCJrn:Kl117 M8p-ra 19921'.
RaK npaBonpeeMHI-IK CCCP POCCillI BHIIOJIHHeT nOJJmKeHI1.R KoHBeH-
qI1l-1 no npeAO'fBpaI1{eHIfiO ffI MOpJ'l c6pocaMl1 OTXO,npB M .lWy-
rnx M8TepIlBJlCE 1972 r. MopcKl-le cy,!\8., cY)J;opeMOH'I'HH€ 6a3b1, nop-rhi
06oPY,lJ;ylOTCJ'II, npe)J;ornpaIl\8IQ1l\I'IMI13arpH3HelmeMOpJI.
BhillOJIHeHl1e BO,!\OOxp8HHbIX TpE6cEaturii OOmaT€JlbHO co CTa,n;I>1J1 Bhl-
6cpa MecT8  J1C'TO'iH11Ka3arpH3HeHJ1i1 (T.e. X03ffi1crneHHOro
06Dacr8, npe.n;rrpI1JITI1JI), npY! ero npoelITJIpOBaHIDf 11 crpowr€.JlhCTBe. 3a-
npe1l\eHO BBOAWI'h B no MC'TO'OO1KI-I 3a1pJ'13HeHKR, He OOecne-
'IeHHhle COBpeMeHHblMt1 'reXHOooru.m.rn: 11 yc'ffiKJBK8MI-Ino CJ<nfCTll'e, 06ea--
Bpeml1B8HHIOM yn.un1 COpoCOBl1.0 ypoBHH npe)J;eJlbHo1J.OIIYC'I'i'iM
Bee 13arpH3HeHIDl.I\OJIjftHbI6bITh OCH8Il\eHhl Cpe)J;CTBaMM KQH-
TpoJIH 3a CTO'llIhIMJlI BO,!\8MH.
BTo:mespeMHH€COIimo.r\eIDIenTpe6oB8HJ1i.i:npY!npoeK-
TI-IpOBaHl-ll1, CTpowreJlbCTBe M p1I1 npe.wIptlJ'lTlfil, BBOl1.e I1X B
3KCILJIyaTaw-ooJI:BJffIK}'I'CfICaMhlMJlI'laCThIMt1C'TpaTI-IBHblMJlInpaBO-

HapyweHJ1HMl-f. BropbIM no pacnpoc1paHeHHOCTI1 HBJ1HeTCJ! HapyweID1e
CaID1TapHO--3IDJ,.T:\I"MJlOJIOI1f'H::1«I"()6.narono.rryqt1Rl.CneJ1.0Ba-
TeJlbHO, 6q:>b6a, KOTOpyIO Be.n;yr  11 npaBOOXpaID1TeJIb--
HhIe OpraHhI np<m1B HapynFHlfif BO):\HOro  11 BoOOl1\e
 3aKOHOTeJlbCTBa, eIl\eOqeHh,JlaJIeKa OT 3aBepWeHl1JL
IIo)J,!\epmaHl1e IIOBepxHOCTHbIX 11 nOJ1.3eMHbIX BOJ1. B COCTORmrn:, COOT-
BeTCTByrol1\eM Tpe60BaHllilM aaKOHO,JlaTeJIbCTBa, 05eCne'lMBaeTCH nyreM
YCTaHOBJIemml1c06JIlOJ1.eHl1flHOpMaTI1BOB,I\OII)'CTIIM)I,()Ha
BO):\Hble OfueKThl
HOpMaTl1Bhl ,u;onyCTJ.lMoro  Ha BO):\Hhle MeKThl pa3pa-
6aTbIBalOTCH Ha OCHOBaHI1I1 npe,IJ;eJIbHO ,IJ;OnyCTI1MOiii KOe1
(IUJ:K) XMMW-IeCKMXBel1\eCTB, lOOImt:BHhIXBel1\eCTB, MHII:JXX1PffiHII3-
MOB 11 .n;pyrnx nOKa3a'CeJIeti l\a"ieCTBa BOJ1.hl B BOJ1.HhIX IDbeKrnX. YT-
Bepmp;eID1e HOpMaTt:lBOB,l\OIlycTJM:I'O B03A61CTBMR Ha BO):\Hhle 05'beKThl
Ocyrn;ecTBJIHeTCH comacHO nOC'I'aHOBJIeHIOO IIpaBMTeJIhC1'Ba P OT 30 T1.e-
Ka6pH 2006r.NQ 881 (<OnoPHJ1.Keyrm,!\eHl1R HOpMaTIlBOB,IJ;OrryCTI1MO-
ro B03T1.eikTBtm Ha BO):\Hhle OfueK'ThI» .
l\oJll1'{eCTBO Bel1\ecTB 11 MI1KpOO(I'3HJf3M£E, co.n;epmaIIJ;l1XCH B c6pocax
CTO'lHhIX BOT1. 11 (t1JIt:I) .n;peHIDKHhIX BOT1. B BO):\Hhle OfueK'ThI, He J1.OJImHO
IIpeBhIIlIaTh ycraHOBJIeHHhIe HOpMaTMBhl ,l1OI1yC'n1MOr'O EI03,lJ;ei:i:CTB11J1 Ha
BO):\Hhle O&beKThL
l(eJIeBbie nOKa3aTeJIM Ka"ieCTBa BO)J;h1 B BOT1.HhIX ofueK'l'ax pa3pa5a-
ThlBalOTCH yrIOJIHOMO'IeHHhIMJII IIpaBHTe1IhC'l'BO pcp $',IJ;epa.1lbllblMJf op-
raHaMl1I1ClIO.llIDI'I'eJIbHOi BJIaCTI:!.wm l\am,Iloro pe'IHoro 6acceiiiHa J1JII1 em
QaCTI1 C }"I€TQM IIpI1pO)J;HhJX oco6eHHocTeR pe'IHoro 6acceAHa, a Ta1OKE' C
}"{eTOM ycJIOBJrii: l.\e.neB£IU HCIIOJIb30BaHlUI BO):\HhIX O&beKTOB, pacnoJIo-
m€HHbIX B rpaID:!l\ax pe'IHoro 6accei1:Ha.
OrJlWll1TeJIbHaR 'lepTa CJilCTeMhI oxpaHhI BOJ1. - BhlCOKaR ,IJ;I1HaMWI-
HOCTb ee 3aKOHOJ1.aTeJIhHoro o6ecneqeID1R.  ,lI;JfiIaMHKY
IIpl1BHec iPeT1.epaJIbHhIflaaKOH OT 14 I1IQJlH 2008 1'_ NQ 118-3 «0 BHece-
HJ1I1I13MeHeID1iii B Bo):\Hhrn: KOJ1.eKC POCCl1iiiClwiii<Pe.n;epaWlliI1 OT,IJ;eJlbHhle
aaKOHO,JlaTeJIbHhIe aKTbI PoccID1CKOi1: <PeJ1.epaWlli',s. B 3TOM 3aKOHe npe-
.n;yCMaTpJrnaIOTCR nonpaBKI1 He TOJIbKO B BO):\HOe, HO 11 B TpaHcnOpTHoe
3aKOHOJ1.aTeJIhCTBO POCCI1I1.
B 06JIaCTI1 BOJl.HOro 3aKOHO,!\aTeJlbCTBa pa3paOOrY:I1KI1 npI1B€,lI,€HHUI
<PeJ1.epaJIhHOm 3aKOHa Il€'ffiJllt3JtpOO8JIJ'1 I1paBOBoe perY.IDlpOBaHl1e B 06-
I 3OI1a",,H)I:3Hb.2oo1 (\J10 C.20-21
2 C3 P$. 2007 N!!4.Cr 514
3 C3P<11200S.N!!29(Y.I}.Cr.3418
-12-

JIaCThl npDBeJJ;€IDm BO,II,OOXpaHHbI MepOnpUHTID1: Ii  B
IJ;eJ1HX X03JIIICTBeHH0-6ldTOBOro HIDL B BK Pet> 6bUra BHeCe-
Ha HOBIUI CTaThH 7 ( «Bo,lJ;oX03HiicTBeHHhie MeponpIDITJ1H 11 Meponplf.H'I'JfR
no oxpaHe BO,!(HbIX ofueKTOB». Ha3BalllibIe Mep:mpl1HTI1H oCy:Il\ecTBJ1H-
KYI'Cfl q:.e,I\epaJIbHbIMt-l, pE'£'l1lJH8JIhHb 11 MYJUfi.tlrn8JIhHblMf opraHaMJ1
BJIaCTJII B npe,IJ;eJIaX J1X nOJIHOMo<IJ1H. KpoMe TOro, BO,!\OIIOJIb30BaTeJIJII MOo
ryr OCy:Il\eCTBJUiTb EI(),lT,O(D(p3.HHh1e 11 CTBeHHI>Ie Meponpl1HTIlJl.
Pa:3MelIJ;eHJlle 3aKa30B Ha BbillOJIHeHJlle BQJ:IOX03HJ1c'rBeHHbIx 11 BO,IJ;OQ-
xpaHHbIX M€JX1I1PIUI'T'Iri1 Ha BO)J;HbJX 06'hemax, H8.XONIllJ;I1XCJI B rocy,llap-
CTBeHHoi1J1J1J1M)'HJllqi1IIB.JJHfOii, nO)J.IIa,llaeTnO,!\,I\eiicrBJlle
clJe,lJ;epaJIbHOro 3aKOHa «0 pa3MelIJ;eHJIIJII 3aKa30B Ha nOCTaBKM TOBapOB,
BNlIOJIH€ID1e pa60T, o:r>asaHJlle yc.rryr .r:\J1H rDCy,DapCTBeHHbIX It MJID1ID1-
IIaJIbHbIX H}'}K,II;» 2005 r.
IIpJII J13y'I€IDm CUCTeMbI oxpaHbI BO,lJ; cJ!e,IIyeT )"IJITbIBaTb 3aKOHO)J;a-
TeJIbCTBO 0 TeXHM'1eCKOM peryJIJII}JOBaHID:!, Km"Opoe HaXO)J;!IJTC.fI B CTa,zu,rn:
c}xJpMHpOBaHIDI. BHaCTom..Q;ee BpeMH ,lJ;ei1CTsyeTclJe,lJ;epaJIbHbrn3aKOH OT
27 ,lJ;eKa6pfl 2002 r. NQ IB4-tP3 «O'I'€XHJII'lf'CK perymtpoBaliHJll1' 1. 3TMM
clJe,lJ;epaJIbHhIM 3aKOHOM 3aJIOmeHa OCHOBa rOCYMpcTBeHHOro peryJIJ1J)O-
BaID'IH B ,lJ;aHHoi1ce. ComaCHO CT. 6, 7 Ha3BaHHOrO 3aKOHa 06H3aTeJIb-
HbIe ]J)JR I1cnOJIHeHJll.fl TeXHJII'l€CKJIIe pernaMeHTbI IIpI1HJlMaIOTC.fI B IJ;eJ1HX
OXpaHbloKpymaIOIl\ei1cpe,IJ;bIl1noBOnpocaM1116Jf(Jn0I11-
'l€CKOii 6e3OlIaCHOC'I'Jf. Cne,lJ;OBaTeJIbHO, npoIJ;ecCbI I1poM3E1O}I.C'1Ba, 3KC-
IIJIYaTa, nepeB03IG1, npJII KOTopbIX J1ClI0JIb3yroTC.fI BO,!\HbIe 06'heKTbI
(roBopfl0606meHHo - BO4JoH)J;), TaKiKe AOJIiKHbInOJVIa,!W.TbnO,lJ;,I\eA-
CTB>1e TeXHJII'Iecrrnx perJIaMeHTOB. IIooTOM)' Tp€6y€'l'CH BHe.npWI'b TeXHJII-
"leCKMe perJIaMelITbI,1IIX'BHIl\€HHbI (J'lHC'TKe BO.n, ,lIeHTeJIbHOCTlii BO,!\HOro
TpaHcrrOPTa, .n;pyrI-1M BOrrpocaM BQrJ;OX03ffiICTBeHHOro KOMITJIeKca. B '<I8CT-
HOCTIiI,,lI.J!H npoeKTHpOBaHJfH, C'I'fX)J1T€JIbCTBa 113KCnnyaTa fTC CJIe-
.r:\OBaJIO 6b! yrsep,llHTb It BJJe,lJ;pJ1Tb COOTB€'I'CTB)'1OlW1e T€XffiNE'CKKe per-
JIaMeHTbl B]:\alllibIX perJIaMeHTaX ltenecoo6pa3Ho npe.IIYCMOTpeTb, B TOM
'<IJIICJIe, 1JQI:\OOXP8HHbIE' 'I'pE'6CElaHIm
IIpaBOBaH OXPaHa BO,lJ; 3a ro-6e-3roM. B B€)IyIl\JIIX 3apy6e:lKHhIX rocy-
,lIapCTBaX CJIICTeMa OXpaHbI BO,!\HbIX ofueKTOB I1MeeT pe3yJlbTaTJ1BHyro
HanpaBJIeHHOCTb Ha BHe.npeHJlle HOBbIX TexHOJI0I1£ii, OTBe"lalOlW1X 3a):\a-
qaMOXpaHb1np)J.bI.JJ:aHHaflCJIICTeMaxapaKTepI13YeTCflnporpaMMHbI-
MJ1 1IOJ];X0,lIaMI1, BOBJ!€'IeHJlleM B Hee Bcex «ypoBHei1 BJIaCTJf», aIITJIIBHbIM
IIp1lM€HeHIteM 3l\"OHOMWlecEOl'O CTI1M)'JlIIpoBaHJm (nocpe)J;CTBOM HaJIoro-
BbIX 11 Kpe)J;JIITHbIX JIbror).
I C3 P$. 2002 N!!52(4 11 Cr 5146
-73-

CMCTeMa oxpaHbI BO,!1 B CIlIA OCHOBaHa Ha ep8JIbHOM saKOlIE' a KOH-
'Ip)JI€ Ha.n; 3a1pH31J2HJ-1E'M BO,!1 {WIO€ Ha3BaIDI€ - 3aKoH 0 'iI1croi1 BO,!1€ J1JII1
3aKoH 0 'lIiICTOTeBO;:Q 1948 r. B,l1ei1CTBti pe,rr,aHHbrn 33.KOH ox-
BaTIUI nO'lT!-1 Be€ Bonpocbl np€',!\OTBpa111€IDtfI 1:1 ycrpaH€HI-1Jl BCeB03M<»KHbIX
fBO,!1. HaOCHOBe 3aKoHa a 'lIiIcroj.{ BOJ\€ pa3paOOraH 1:1, no MIle-
HI1H)11.OCTa'I"Ol{JIoycn€llIHOom-rpyeTnpaBOBOj.{Mexa-
1ill3M, HanpaBJIeHHbrn Ha }'MeHblllelill€ J'!np€,IJ;O'I'Bpa.II\€Iill€ 38.I'pJJ3HeH1m Bo-
/1,OTOKOBI:I BO,IJ;O€MOB, p€lll€Iill€ npo6.n€MbIHbIX CTO'iHblXlJ(.)A
3aKOHOM a 'iI1CTOTe B0,!16b1Jla npeJJ.yCMOTpeHa clx'-11.epa.IIbH'UI nporpaM-
Ma cy6cJwtpmmnm cTpOm'eJlhC'l'Ba HOBbIX 1:1 11.ei1cTByroIW1X I1HciJpacr-
pyKTyp M.YHJ-W;J1II8.JIbHb BO)J;OC'rOKOB. K ID1NI OTIfOCHTCH BO,!\OO'llilCTHble J'!
HaCOCHble L"ffiHl.\JDr.  Tpy6bl J'! KOJUleK'ropbI, CI-fCTeMa
CTOKa 11.<»K,!\eBblX BO,!1 (Jll1BHeBaH KaHaJlJ'!3aL\l-f.fl). JI:..rrH OCBO€HWI CP€11.CTB
BO BC€XIIITaTaX C03,!1aHbI opraHbI, I€ peryJH1pymlW1€ HKOH-
Tpo.ID1py1OlW1e WHKQill1 B o6.n:acTii O'llfCTl\ll BO,!1 ffi' 3aIJ»l3Hf2IDfH. B pe-
3)'JlbTaTe m /1,aHHOiii: nporpaMMb! ell\e B 70-x-fJO-x IT.
XX B. 6b1JIa YJ1}"IW€Ha I1HcppaCTpyKTypa MJID1Will8J1bHhIX 00/1,0C'I0I0CJB
Ha OCHOBe 3aKoHa 0 'iI1CTOTe BO,!1 BO Bcex urraTax C03)J;aHa 11.0BOJlhHO
nIDKa.fl CMC'I'eMa nOCTORHHO BOsOOHOBJI.fleMbIX q,oH,IJ;oB urra'I"OB. 3TI1 q,oH-
/1,h1 npe,11Ha3Ha'leHbl]J)IR clnmaHCOBoi1 nOMep:)KKl-f IfCIIOJIHeHJ1.fl BOj\HOro
saKOHo,!\aT€JlbCTBa Ha MeC'l'ax. IIpwleM BJIaCTJII urra'I"OB caMJ-1 BbIDJllPaKY!'
J'!3 6ora'I"O:W naIDITpbl cp€,IJ;cTBa B031J.€i.fC'l1Jllil. Kpe,!!;HTbI C PblllOqHbIM npo-
lI€HTOM, pa3Hh1M11 CpoKaMM norarneHWI I. 6ecnpoeHT-
Hhle CCY.t:\hl, npe,!\ocTaBJi€HMe rapaHTI1i1, nOKyITKa 06.m1I11ql1ii, OIIJIaTa 06-
pa:3(JBaBIIIJ1XCH /1,OJITOB. RaK CJI€)JyeT 1:13 CKa3aHHOro, B npuse.nemmfi
CI-fCTeMeHeMaJlOMeproB'I"OM'lJIICJIeJ'!CTII-
MJ.mtpOBaHJIIH.
B EBponei1cKoM coo6ll\€CTBeI:lMeeT ,!\aJ!eKOelIOCJI€ACTBIm.ll:JII-
peKTt1Ba 96/61 OK()MI1.l1e}(CHOmI:lKOHTpo.nesarpH3He-
Hill! OKPY:)!qiIOIl\€iii: cpe/1,h1 npoMbIIIIJJ€HHh npeJ\f1pt1.fITI1HM11 (IVU -
.lI:JllPeKTltBa. pyccKoeHlte-KKII3). B):\I1}JeImIBeYCTamlB.ID1Ba-
eTC.fI, '1TO IIpOMbllIIJleHHble np€,IJ;IIpJilRTt1.fI /1,OJDKHhI nOJly<IJ1Tb pa3p€rne-
Hill! Ha d5poCbI (BbIOpoChl) 1:1 J'!H)'lO 3KCf1JIyaTaL{l1lQ pa3JIJ1'iHbIX npt-lpo.r\-
HhIX cpe,lJ;. K 'iI1CJIy TaKOBhIX HapHAY C nO'ffioi1 J'! aTMocciJepHhIM B03A)'XOM
ffi'HOCHTCH 1:1 BOJlhL ,lI;Mana30H CJIICTeMbI KOMIJJIel\CHhIX pa3pememfif OXBa-
TblBaeT pa3JIJll'-lHbIe ceKTOpbl npoMbIIlI.IIeHHOCTII H paalU-I'IHble np0t13B0,11-
CTBeHHhre MOOCTII ,lIaHHbIX X03JIi.icrnyml.lJW( cyfh.eKTOB'.
IrapMOHI<3aL1HHKCTaH,<l(lpTOBII{r3Cllj01'IeT6noKII€HTenbHO-
7m,;::n pa3peUJeHH rlporpa....a CoTpyaHHecTBa EC-PoCCHH L>1lOJ1b

EaK H3BE.'C11IO, p,rrJl Poccm:I xapaKT€pHa CHCTeMa pa3pewewrn no 01'-
.r:\eJIbHb!M Bl-ij];aM npHpO)J;HhlX pecypCOB 11 cpe,!\aM (no He,!lpaM, BO.r:\e, aTM0-
cclJepHOMy- B03)JyXY I1AP.). Cy:tl\eCTB}'IOIQaJl B POCCm1 CHCTeMa paspellle-
IIJ1:i1 Ha IIpHpO.r:\0II0JIb30B8.IIJ1€ BbI3HBaeT Kpi1TI1Ky HaIID1X eBIXJI]eiicmlX
naprnepOB}(aK rpoM03,IJ;KaJlI1 61OpoKpaTI13I1p()B8HH8R B CBOIO O'fepe,!J;b,
nOIIbITKJII BHe,!\pHTb CHCTeMJ IWMIlJIeXCHbIX pa3pewemrlii ycnexa He
J1MeJll:l.
B EBpone B KOMIIJleKCHbIX pa3peweHl-fJIX ,!\0JDKHb1 3aKpeII.llJlTbCJI o6J1-
3aTeJlbCTBa B OTHOIIIeIUfiI Bb16pOCOB Bpe,!\HbIX BeIl\eCTB B OKpyma101QYIO
cpe,!I,Y, npl13TOM IroMIE'l'eH'I'Hf opraH .n;OJDKeH OpitelITltpOBaTbCJI Ha HaH-
.!1J'llllI1el13TeXHO.Jl(firli IToCYTHl1HpeKTI-IBa KKII3Ha-
npaBJIeHa Ha MillU1MI-13aIU11O 3aIpKlliewrn pa3Jll1'llibIX npoMbllllJleHHbIX
HCTO'IHJ1KOB B IIpe,!\eJIax EC.
CdX:rneHHo no oxpaHe BOIX pecypcoB EBpcrreJ1moe coo6ll\eCTBO
npe,!\np:illIl1Mae-r Mepbl yme Ha IIpoTIDKeHl1J130 JleT. IIpJ:nnlMaJIltcb cneQlil-
aJIbHbleJU1PeKTI1BbI ECno ID1TbeBOi1:BO)J;e,rpymuBbIMBO,!\aM, KOMMJ'Ha.'llr
HbIM CTO'lHb1M BO):1aM, no orpaHH'J:eHmO Bbropoca HI1TpaTOB]J)JR IIpe,!\OTBpa-
IQeHt1Jl 31, no IqI'leCTBY BO]J)JR aKBaXYJlbTYPbL JJ:eTaJlbHo
npopafx::rra.HHaa CHCTeMa npaBOBOro peryJrnPOBaHWI BO,!\Horo X03JThlCTBa Ha
ypoBHe EC Hepe,w<:o CTaBm'CJ! B npl1Mep Pocom It BOO6ll\e rocY.l\8pCTBaM
CHI'. I1Mee-r CMbICJJ OCTaHOBHThCJI Ha OCHOBHbIX ,IJ;I1]:>eKl'l1B8X EC.
B JJ:HpeKTI1Be a IIJf'I'beBOH BO)J;e, npl1HJITOi1: B 1980 r. I1I13MeHeHHoi1: B
1998 r. l , ycraHOBJIeHMaKCUM8.JlbHblitypoBeHb KOHl!eHTpaQJ.tI1Bru
BO)J;e TaKl1X Bpe,!\HbIX Bell\eCTB, KaK TJImeJlble MeTaJ1Jlb1, HI-ITpaTbl, neCTI1-
""''''''
B J];J.-IpeKTI1B€' 0 KOMM)'HaJibHbIX CTO'fHbIX BO,!\flX npe,J:l;ID1CNBalO 3a-
KJla,JJ;Ka KaHa.m13aUID'l It OOJl3aTeJibH8JI O'illCTKa C'J'O'fHb1X BO)J; ]J)JR Hace-
JleHHbIX II)'HKTOB C 'lJIICJJeHHOCTblO :HG1TeJlei1: 6o.rree 2 TblC. 'leJIoBeIf. ,lLrrJl
HOBbIX rocy,!\apcTB-'lJIeHJB EC npe,!I,YCMaTpl1BaeTCJI 6o.rree )J,llffeJIbHbrn
nepexo.u;HbrlfnePJ1 o .n.
B J»tpeImme 91/676 I1peJIyCMOTpeHO  Bbl6poca CeJIb-
HHbIMJ1 I1CTO'lHHKaMl1 HHTpaTOB B BO.r:\Hble 06'beKTbI, ]J)JR
npe,II;DTBpall\eHI1H 3BTpOclJl1Ka 3TH Mepbl npHIDtMaIOTCH B rex CJJY-
'laJIX, eCJlJil CO.QeJ»KalDte m-rrpaTOB B BO)J;e .r:\OCTHraeT 50 MT Ha.mrrp,.mroo
npl16.m1maKYI'CJI K 3TOMY' 3HaQeHillO.
J1CIIO.1Ib3OB8HKe OCa,n;KOB CTO'IHbIX BO,!\ B CeJlbCKOM X03HJ1c'rBe ypery-
.ID1poBaHo B CYrl1eJIbHoi1: JJ:HpeKTI1Be 86/27B. B HeM npe orpa-
1 RL98j83jIA BI.1998 L.330.S.32.
2 RL91/211/1ABI 1991.L.135
3 RL91/676/1ABI.1991.L.375.S 1
-75-

HJ1'ieIDfe CO.n;ep:maIDfH THmeJIbIX MeTaJLJIOB B OCa;J;KaX CTC)'{HblX B0,!111 B
nO<rneHHOM nOKpOBe, npHbI ycnomm 6e30IIacHoro X03ffiIcT-
BeHHOro I1CIIOJlb30BaHHfI 3T11X OCa,!\KOB. IIocKOJIbKY Ha3BaHHaH ,l1.MpeKTI1-
Ba He :WCKJIIO'Ia€T 60Jl€e meCTKMX Tp€6oBaHJfi:i, TO B l\€JUIX 3al1tl1TbI nO'lB
11 C€JIbXoonpo.DyKl\HI'f B03MOmHO 3aI1peIl\€HJre J1CIlOJlb3lIlaHHH OCa.n;KOB
CTO'llIbIXBO.n;'.
rocy,llapcrna EBpocOI03a IJOCTaBIfJIJ'I nepeA aToM aM6l1l\1aH)'lO 38.-
,lIaqy npeKpaTI1Tb BblfpOCbI B BO,!1Hb1e OfueKTbl TaK H8.3NBaeMbIX npJII-
OpJllTeTHblX Bp€)J;HblX Bell\eCTB K 2020 r. J1Hbre Bpe)J.HbIe Bell\eCTBa npoBe-
pHIOTCH Ha He06xo.r\JIIMoc I¥IM€H€HUH OI'paHU'llfI'eJIbHHX Mep nyreM
aHaJn13a pHCKa. Y.?Ke B 2001 r. 6bIJI ycraHOBJIeH IIepe'leHb npJIIDpHTeTHblX
Bpe,!\HbIX BellleCTB 11 Bpe,!\HbIX BelllecTB. B HeM6bIJIo Ha3BaHO 33 BellleCT-
Ba:W rpyrm Bell\eCTB 2 .
,lL.M POCCMJII BamHyIO p0JIb B ,!1eJie oxpaHbI npYlpo,!\b111 npe)f\,lJ;e Bcero
BO,L\HOro $JRM 6y.n;eT l1IpaTb BoJ\HaH CTpaTel11H AO 2020 r. ORa paCC'll1-
TaRa Ha MDlJ:PID13al:!!fK) poocnJlmoii 3KOHOMI1K!1 C l\eJlblO Cffl£lK£ffi1H BQl\o-
eMKOCTYi BEll Ha Wi," :aKQIO.mI13JIeK'IpXlHep!'l!lJtl Ha cyMMy60Jl€e 20wrp,!\
py6.neii: B ro,!\. KpoMe TOm, O,L\HOii: J13 SaJJ;a'i Bo,L\Hoii: CTpaTenrn HBJIHeTCH
BC€MepHOe CHJtmeHlI€ aHIJXI1OreHHOii ltarpY3K!i1 Ha BOJ1bl RlccJfif no-
cpeACTBoM BII€]Jf!eHKR HOBbIX 'I'€XHO.OOI'Hii
2. cnE4AbHbIE BOnpOCbl nPABOBO OXPAHbl BOA
Hhle 30Rb! 11 OKpyra CaHJlTapHOif OXpaHbL YC'rnHCI3JIf'HI'Ie
BO,lPOXp3HHbIX aOH He B.neqeT I13'bHTKH 3eMeJlbHbIX yqaCTKOB y c06CT-
BeHHI1KOB 3€MeJIb, B, 3€MJ1f:'I1OJIb3Tenei-i: I1.ID1 aanpe-
Ta Ita cOBepu:rem1e C.J1enOK C 3eMeJibHbIMJf yqaCTKaMH, 3a J1CJ\JIlO'i€ID1eM
CJIY'ffieB, npeJ1)'CMOTpeHHbIX 3aKOHOM. O,!\HaKO co6crseHIDIKK 3eMeJlb,
3€MJJ€B.ITa)J;eJlbLtblI1 3€MJI€JX)JIb3()BaTeJIIII, Ita aeMJU3X KOTOpbIX HaXOMT-
C.R B0,!100XpaHHble 30Hbll1 npffijpemHble 3aI1tt1'IHH€ IKIJIOCI:l, 06B3aHbI co-
6.mo,IlaTb ycraHOBJIeHHblJf pemJIIM I1CllOJlb30BaHJ1H 3TJ1X 30H 11 nonoc. JIH-
l\a, BJ1HOBHble B ltapyrneHIDI pemt-lMa I1CIIOJlb30BaIDIH TeppwropJlii
BO,I:PQ.-q:>aHHbIX 30H 11 npH6pemtib!X 3allll'ITHbIX nOJlOC, HecyT OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTb B COO'I1JeTCTBJDf C ,I\eiiCTBylOLll;J1M 3aKOHO,llaTeJlbCTBOM.
CorJlaCHO CT. 65 BK P<P Brx BO.n;OOxpaHHbIX 3DH 38.npell\3-eTCH:
- J1CII().JIb3(EaH CTO'IHblX BO,!1 ]J)JR y}J1J6pelmH no<rn;
I ABI1986 L161 S.6
2 PeUJeHHe66j540/lABI 1986. L. 297 S 6
-76-

- pa:3MeIlall1€ KJIa;J;6YU1,, MeCT saxop<JHemUrOT-
XO)J;OB TIpOM3BO)J;C'I'Ba III nmpe5neHIiIfI, pa)J;l1oaKTIilBHbIX, XLtM]:f'feCKt1X.
B3pblB'laTbIX, 'IORC1f'fHbIX, OTpaBJlHKJIqMX III H,!\OBWI'bIX BeI1leCTB;
- oCYJ-l\eCTBJIetille aBlila'--!l10HHbIX Mep no 6opb6e C Bpe)J;l1TeJllfMlil III 60-
Jle3HJ'IMJ1paCTeHIIIi1;
- ,D;Bi-PKeHJ1e III CTOHHKa -rpaHCIIOpTHbIX Cpe,lJ;CTB (KpOMe CIIeQMaJlbHbIX
Tpam:'nOprHbIX cp€,lJ;CTB), sa IIICKJIl()qeHJ1eM IIIX ,D;BmKeHJ1Jf no .l\oporaM H
CTORHKJ'! Ha .l\oporax III B cneQllanbHO o60pY)J;oBaHHbIX M€CTax, IIIMeKlJltl1X
TBep)J;oe I10IIpbITIte
Cp'pyroi1CTOpoHbI,,l:\onyCKaKYl'Cflnpo€KTI-fjX)BaHI-1e,, C1pO-
JITeJlbCTBO,pIJI,BBO)J;B3I\CIIJIyaT,3ttCIIJTyaTIU_tI-1J1
CTBeHHbIX III J1HbIX o6'b€FtIOB IIpI1 ycnOBIDf o6opy,lJ;oBaffi1H TaKl1X o6'b€FtIOB
COOpymelDfIDIIIf, 06eCII€'iI1BalO1ltJ1MI1 oxpaHy BO,!J;HbIX o6'b€FtIOB OT 3arpn3-
HeHJ1.H, sacopeIDm J1l11crOW,eHJ1.H BOA - B COJrBeTCTBJ1I1 C BO,!J;HbIM saKOHQI:Ia-
TeJlbCTBOM IIIsaKQHOA3TeJThC1'BOMB o5.rraCTl1oxpaHbIHCpe,!l;bl.
KpoMe TOro, B rpallJ1lW.x nepBOfi nonoCbl BO)J;OOX SOHbI - npl1-
5pE')tQi()Jf3a1I.{lITmfnOJIOCbl- salIperrlaJOTclI: pacnallll\a
3€MeJIb, pa3MeIl\eHl1e OTBaJIOB pa3MHBa.€MbIX I'pyHTDB, BbITIaC CeJIbCKO-
xoom'i:cTBeHHbv:: mlilBOTHbIX.
HeOOx1MO (III qacro J1MeeT MeCTO) saxpelIJl€HJre Ha M€C'THOC111 rpa-
HJ1lt BO)J;QOxpaHHbIX 30H III rpaH npl15pemHblX 38.LiV'ITHbIX nOJIOC cneltH-
8JIbHbIMM J1HtpJpMaWfOHHbIMU SHaKaMlil, OIIOBe1l\8-IOl1\I1MM a COOTBeTCT-
B)'101l\I1X 3alIpeTax IIICilOJIb30BaHI11I-
Illi1p1:lHa BO)J;ooxpaHHblX SOH BO)J;OTOKOB J1 BO,l:\OeMOB rnpe,l\eJme'I'C'Jl.
HCXO,D;.H 1113 ,l\JII1HbI BO,D;OTOI\a It IIJI01l\8-,!J;1:I altBaTopl1J1 Bo.n;oeMa, lID1plllia
np1:l5pe:IKHbIX Sall\l1THbIX nOJIOC -B SaBI1CJ1MOCTIf OT }'KJIOHa 6eperOB.
Illi1p1:lHa BO,IJ;ooxpamm 30Hbl peR Jf.ID1 PY'fbeB ycT8H3BJIItBaeTCR OT
IiIX IIICTOI\a ]J)JR peR J1JIJ'! PY'fbeB npoTIDKeHHOCTbKJ:
-.l\0 10 KI1JIOMeTpoB - B pa3Mepe 50 MeTpOB;
- aT 1O.l\0 50 Ki1JIOM€'IpJB - B pa3Mepe 100 MeTpOB;
- aT 50 KI1JIOMeTpOB iii 50JIee - B pa3Mepe 200 MeTpOB.
,lL.M peKJ'!, pY'fbH npOTaiKeHHOCThID MeHee 10 KJ.1JIOMeTpoB OT IIIcrOI\a
.l\0 ycrwr BQl:((J(JXpaHHa SOBa COBna,D;aeT C npli/6pe?KHoH saIWITHoM nOJIO-
coil pc EIO,lIOOXpaHHOii: SOHbl]J)JR IIICTOKQB peKJ'!, PYThH ycraHaBJIJ'!-
BaeTeR B pasMepe 50 MeTpOB.
Illi1p1:lHa BO)J;OOXPaHHOfi SOHbI o3epa, BO,o;OXPaHJ.1JII-1IWl, sa I
lilleMo3epa, paCno.mroBHJTP"6o.rrOTa, JfJIHo3€pa, 1J01IOXP3.1illJlIt-
Il\8. C 8f\BaTOpl1eM MeHee 0,5 KBa,!ij)aTHoro KJ.1JIOMe-rpa, ycraHaBJIJ1BaeTCR
B pa3Mepe 50 MeTpoB.
Illi1p1:lHa npll6p€HGrolf 3al1\l1THoi1 nOJlOCbI YCTaHaB.m-IBaeTCR B 38.BI1-
CJ1MOC'I'i1 OT )'KJIOHa. 6epera BO)J;HOro 06'beKTa III cocraBJlHeT 30 MeTpoB]J)JR

ofparnoro J1JTIII HYJIeBOro }'KJIOHa, 40 MeTpoB W1H }'KJIoHa.l\O TpeX rpa,!I;J-
COB Ii 50 MeTpoB ,l\JIJI }'KJIOHa TPy! Y! 60JIee rpa.n;yca.
AmI paCIIOJICOKeHHhlX B rpaHltQaX 6o.:rrOT IIpoTO'lHb1X H CTO'llIhIX o3ep
Y! COOTBeTCTBYIDIlI;J1X BO;J;CYrOKOB lillIpY!Ha npJf6pe>KHOJI3aoH nOJIO-
Cbl YCTaHaBJIHBaeTCJ'I B pa3Mepe 50 MeTPOB.
IIh1pmm npJt6pe>KHOJl aanv:ITlIOif nOJIOCbI oaepa, BO;J;OXpaHJI.IDfIUa,
J1MeIDLqJ1Xoc06o eHHoe (I>f6o3Ha"eID1e (MecTa HepeCT8,
Hary.na, 3MMOBKI1 phro J1 .l\pyrnx BO,lIHhlX OO()JI()l11'1€CKJtX peCYPCOB), yc-
TaHaB.ID1BaeTCJ'I B pa3Mepe 200 MeTpoB HroaBItcJ1MO ar }'KJIOHa npl1JIera-
X3eMeJIb.
B BK Pel> 2006 T., nocpaBHeIDOO C BKPel> 1995 r., CMRI"-leH pelKHM BO-
.l\OOXPaHHbIX30HIi npIDpe>KHbIX 3aLqMTHhlXnOJIOC, lfxMaKcY!-
MaJIhHbrl-t pa:3Mep, ;J;olI)'lll;eHo C'IpOJ1TeJIhC'r B npl>16pemHbIX 3aLqMTHhIX
nOJIocax. 3aKoHO,[laTeJIb norneJI HaBCTpeqy 'laCTHblM KHTE'pecaM If BO
MHOroM 3aKpeIllUI peaJIbHJ10 CJ1TyarJ;Y!1O Ha 6eperax BO,!\oeMOBIi BO,!\CYrO-
KOB. O,llHaKO B HOBOM BK PaanpeI1J;eHbI Hal1fX)Jlee 3K().]KYJ{'leCKIiI Bpe,[l-
Hhle ,l\eJlcTBJuI Ha 6eperax (HaIIpltMep, 3aXopOHeffi:le arXO,[lOB npOt-l3BO,!\-
CTBa If rnnpe6nemrn). OreBI1,!J;HO, 3aMbICeJI 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIR 3aKJIlO'laeTCfl B
YCTaHOBJIeHI-rn He O'leHb B3b1CKaT€JIbHhlX, HO 3aTO JICIIOJIH.fI€t.ruX X03JIfi:-
CTBYIDIlI;Y!MJ1 cy6'beKTaMJ1 rpe600aInrii
11MeHHO TaKOfi: «CMm"leHHbn1:» pelKHM BO,[IUQXpaHHblX 3UR 6epeTCJI3a
QCHOBY npI1 n.rraHJ1poBaffi1Y! IIpraHaMJl roCYMPCTBeHHOii BJIaCTI1 r. MQCK-
Bhl :EIOOCTaIIOBJIE If 6.rraroycrpoi'rrna CTOJIJ1'IHblX BO,!\oeMOB If BO,n;CYrO-
KOB, 8 TaIOKe noiiMeHHhIX 3eMeJIb. B CBR3Y1 C 3'rnM Y Bo.w.13allJIaHJ1poBa.ID1
If Ha'la.lUl B03BO)J;J1Tb KYJIbTYPHO-,n;ocyroBhle If cnopTl1BHo-pa3BJIeKaTeJIb-
Hhle KOM£IJI€ItCbI. He6oJIblID'le ToprOBbIe LlelITpbl, Ka<Pe J1 peCTOpaHhL O'!\-
HaKO ,l\emeJIbHOCTb nocne,!J;Hl1X ;J;OJDKHa 6bITb crporo HCpMltpOB8.Ha H no,n;-
KOH'I'pOJIbHa 3KOJl0I1f'lecIrnM opraHaM. Y"aCTKI1 Bo,n;ooxpaHHbIX 30H
npe.n;nonameTCH ocB060,!\J-'lTb ar pa3Mell\€HHbIX 3,!J;eCb rapaiKeH H 8B1'O-
CTOJ'lHOK, BMeCTQ KCYrOpbIX II€CI6xo.n;MMo IcrPOt-lTb cOBpeMeHHble MHoro-
HpycHhIe TapalKJ1 BHe BO,n;OOXpaHHhIX 30H
BTo:me BpeMR Ha3BaHHble JI3MeHeHJ'1H B pemYIMe BO 30H
J1 liX npY!6pemHblX 3aJ1tY1THhIX nOJlOC HeJlh3.fl C'It:ITaTb OKOH'laTeJIbHhIMIL
Be,!\b B Il.naHe Meponpl-1HTJm: no pea.TDI3aQJ1II BO;J;Ho:i1 CTpaTermt POCCJlH-
CKOH clJe):\epa'-tl1t-1 Ha nepl1o,!\,I\o 2020 r. B paMRax paa,n;ena I «CoBeprneH-
CTBOBaHIte HopMaTHlmoro npaBoBoro pery.rrnpoBaIDlID' npe,!\ycMaTpHBa-
eR perJlaMeHT8L1Y!R "{D3HUC'TB€HHOrO J1CnOJlh30B8HY!R TeppmupJlH
BO,I:POxpaHHblX30H (mtmlNaR I1X npY!6pe>KHhIe aabIe llOJIOCbI), YCY!-
1.-a3e-ra.2005.N!!S!I48j
-78-

JIeIDfe 0TBe'I'C'TB€HH0 3a HapyIlIeIDtH 1'pe60BalDfi.! B L(eJIHX npe,!\OTBpa-
l1\eHt-lJ'l eHKfI, 3aCOpeHt-lJ'l I-f I-fcTOIl\eHt-lJ'l BO,!\HhIX 06'beKTOB.
J1C11OJIb3OBa11He,OXpaHa,3aa, JIeCOB, pacnOJIo-
m.eHHhIX B HHhIX 3OHaX, O 13 COOT13eTCTBUH C
JIeCHbIM KO.n;eKCOM PcI>ar4,!\eKa6pJ'l2006 r. NQ20043 1 I-fl-fHblMJ-f HOpMa-
THBHblMJ1 npaBOBbIMJ1 aKTaMM. CormCHO CT. 104 JIK p!fJ B JIecax BO,!\oo-
XpallliblX 30H 3anpeIl{al(JfCJl IIpOBeJ:(E'mte CIlJIOlllllblX PyOOK JIecHbIX Ha-
rli, I-fcn0JIb30BaHt-ie TOKCWlHhIX X>1MH'l€CItMX npenapaTOB ]J)JR
OXpaHbI I-f 3allU1Tb! JIeCOB, B TOM 'll1CJle B HaY'lHhIX L(ellilX.
1vlH0rne npaBl-fJla nOJIb3lIlamm JIeCOB BOAOQXpaHHbIX 30H yrnepm,r(e-
HblnpHKa30MMIIPPOCCm1ar 22 J'lHBapJ'l 2008 r. NQ 13 «06 
oco6eHH:JCTeii: HCIIOJIb3OBaIIJUI, OXpaHbI, 3abl, BOC JIe-
COB, pacnOJIDmeHHblX 13 BO,!\OOXpaHHbIX 30HaX, JIeCOB, BHIIOJIHmCUt!.I
4JyHKLlHI1 3aLql1TbI npHpOLIHblX I-f MHblX 06'beKTOB, L(eHHbIX JIeCOB, a TaK-
m.e JIeCOB, paCIJJ:I.YI(I)K€H Ha oco6o 3aIl\!i1THbIX y<mCTKaX JIecOB» 2
JIeca, paCIIOJImN2HHblE' B BO.nooxpaIIlIbI"< 3OHax, nOJlJlemaT OCBOE'HlIID,
eCM3TO COBMecTI C L(eJleBbIM Ha3tnl'leHilleM 3Tm<: JIeCOB 11 BbIOOJIHJ'le-
MbIMJ-f J1MH IIO.IIe3HbIMJ'1 Wmu-lHRMJ:!. IIpl1 yxo,!\e 3a JIecaMM, pacnOJIO-
m.eHHbIMJll B BO.nooxpaHHbIX 30Hax, ocyrn;eCTBJlRlOI'CH py6KJ1 yxo,!\a O'leHh
CJ1a60M, cna60M 11 }'MepEtiHoi1 Wi'I'etiCI1BJiOf, 06ecn€'lHBaiOLqI1e q:.opl\olJll-
poBaHl1e CJlOmHblX, npel1M)'Il\ecrBeHHo pa3HOB03paCTHblX JIeCHblX Ha-
i BbIC()IWII nOJlHQTbI 113 Harn50JIee ,lJ;OJIrOB€'lHbIX ,n;peeecHbIX no-
po,!\, 13bmOJIHHK)LqJ1XBO.nooxpaHHbIE' H.
IIpa130Bb!e HOpMbI 0 I!(),lJ;OOXp8HH 30HaX 11 I1X npHi5pe 3aLWIT-
HbIX nOJlO('a" 'IaCTO HapyrnalOTCR. Hepe,$o (Hanpl1Mep, 13 MoCKOBCKOi1
06.rraCTI1) He lIpl1IDfM8.JrnCb I-1Jll1 He pea.ID13OBbIBa.rn1Cb peweID1H a BbJ,IJ;e-
JIeHID:lE!O.J1OOXpC.HHbIX30HJ1J1X3aIl\!1THblXnOJloc.KcmKa-
JIemuo, pentOHaJIbHble opraHbI BnaCT" «1IOJJ,!IaBaJIi1'": Hepe,$O YT-
BepiK,!\8.JIJ1 npoeKThl Bo,!\ooxpaHHblX 30H C c:mq:>aI.Q.eHHHMJl pa3MepaJ\olJ1,
He COOTBeTCTBYJOIl\!1MJ13aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBa. .D:OBOJIbHO'IaC-
TO «oxpaHHble pe:oo-fMbI» BO,!\oeMOB J1 BO,!\OTOKOB Hapywa.rrnCb. B 1990-12 IT.
Ha 6eperax npltropoJJ;HHX peK, mep I-f 1.JIJfI1I npOtICxO)J;tUIa KOT-
Te,IliKHaH 3aC!'poi1Ka, COMHI1'I'eJIb1J no CBOl1M KpI1,lJ;K'-lecID1M 0C1JJBaH»-
.HM. KpOMe TOro, Ha 6epernx 6bUll1 IID-IpoKO paCIIpOcrpaHeHbI npol13BOJTh-
Hble CBamm, MOi1Ka Malill1H I-f 1'.,1\. IIpHBE'A€HHbIe HeraTI1BHble HBJIeHI'IH
6bUll1 06ycJxBneHbI» 6)'MOM, pOCTOM peKpeaItJ«EHOi.i Ha-
rp)'3KJ1]J)JR IIpl1l'Opo,!J;HblX 30H.
1 C3P<t1.2006.Nil50.Cr.5278
2 pr 2008 N!!45.1 Map-ra
-79-

Henb3H CHJ1CXO,JJ;J1TeJIbHO OTHOCWfbCH II: CaMOBOJIbHOM)' 3aXBaTY
.mo6blX 3eMeJIb. 3a nocnee ro)l.bl cJIyqal1 np0l13BOJIbHOro 3aXBaT8
3eMeJIbHbIX yqacTKoB COCT8BJ1H1OT 65% OT BblHBJIeHHblX H8pywewrn
3eMeJIbHoro 3aKOHOAB-TeJIbCTBa, CMeJoKHoro C BOAHbIM 1 . IIooTOM)' nOCJIe-
,AOBaTeJlbH.YIO I1.7KeCTKYW 60pwy C IIpOJ-f3BOJIbHbIM 3aHHTIleM BO;:J;OOxpaH-
HbIX 30H 11 J1X npH6pemHbIX 3aLqMTHbIX nOJiOC HymHO npO;:J;OJDKaTb "11.0-
BO)J;MTb l1.0 KO.
IIopH;:J;oK Ha 6eperax POCCH"CKMX BO,!\oeMOBI1 BOl1.0T0WJB ;:J;OJDKHbl
HaBO,IJ,MTbPOCnpl1po)J.Ha,!\3op, PocpeecTp 110praHbl np01ypaTypbl. Tax,
HarrpHMep, J1MeHHO opraHbllIpoKypaTypbl,Ao6HJIIiICb np!il3HaHIiIH CYl1.0M
npOTHBOpe'-IaLqMM 3aKoHY nOCTaHOBJIeHHe A,zJ.Mmrn:CTp8.I:tIU-f IIpHMOp-
CKoro KpaH OT 18 anpeJIH 2005 r..N'2 aO-ITA «06 yrBepm.n;eID1l-1 pa3Me-
pOB 11 rpaHHLI BO;:J;ooxpaHHl.lX 30H 11 npH6peJoKHblX 3al'-\I'ITHbIX nOJIOC
BO)J;HblX 06'1>eKTOB ropo;:J;a ». IIpt1 cor.rraCOBaRlfif t1 YT-
Bepm.n;eID1l-1 ,AaHHoro perllOHaJIbHoro HopMaTIiIBHOro npaBOOOI'O aKTa
6b1J1t1 HapyrneHbl Tpe60BaHHH 11.ej1:cTBYlOl1\erO 3aKOHo.n;aTeJIbCTBa, B
TOM "H:lCJIe OTHOCHTenbHO pa3MepOB yxa3aHHbIX 30H 11 nOJlOC, He 6bLJIO
no.rromwre.m.HOI'O 3aKJllO'-IeHl-fJI roCYlJ.8.pCTBeHHoil 3KOJ10l'J1'-leCKOR 3XC-
neJYl'H3hf.
KpoMe TOro, COCTO.mrn:e n Teppl:ITOpIDI rn.x:\JIe>ttIIT He
TOJIhKO roCYlJ.8.PCTBeHHOM)', HO 11  KOH'l'pOJllO. B HeM MO-
meT yqacTBOBaTb 11 CIiICTeMa  rraJIaT, C03,!\aHHaH C Ha'la-
JlOM 11.ej1:CTBHH ;:J;epaJIbHOf'O 3aKOHa aT 4 anpeJIB 2005 T. .1'1'2 32-413
«06 frraJIaTe PoccttHcRuU epaIWR»3. BoIIpococ06J1IO-
11.eHill1 pem:IMa BO,IJ1:)OXp8HHb 30H TeCHO CBH3aH C BOIIpOCOM 06 06ecne-
'lem:ll1 pemHMa 6eperoBOti 1I0000Cbl CI6rr-Iero 1I0Jlb3OBaHJ1R.
,lL.M 3aLWITbI BO)J;HbIX ofueKToB, CO,!\epifCallJ;l1X IIpItpO.D;HbIe Jle'Ie6Hble
pecypCbI, YCTaHaBJIJ:lBa1OT oKpyra caHJ:lTapHoli J:I ropHo-CaH!t:!TapHoji ox-
paHbI. B npe,n;eJIbI Ha3BaHHbIX OKpyroB MorY" BXO)J;11Tb MeCTO
l\oIJ:IHepaJIbHbIX BOA, 8KBa'I'OpJ:IM J:I IIJIH)ttI:I peK, 03ep, Mopeil, a TatOtre pana
JIJ-fMaHOB J:I ooep. ComaCHO IIOCTaH:)B.1IeID:lK) IIpaBIrre.JIbCTBa Pel> ar 7 11.e-
Ka6pH 1996 r. .1'1'21425 «06 yrnep)fQJ;emrn IIoJIC»KeHI-fJI 06 oKpyrax caHIiI-
TapHOill1 ropHO--CaHHTapHoil OXpaHbl Jle'-le6Ho-03,l1OpOBltTe.IIbHI:lX MeCT-
HOCTe" 11 KypOpTOB epaJlliHoro 3Ha'lem:lH» lIoc.JIe,qHHe I1Me1OT
I AHM3cee.l18HH Orocy.lJ,3pGlBEHseMebHOMKOHTpoJ1eno PBUHHsa
2006rop,lIl>1cnOJ1b3oB3H"eHoXjJaHanpPDAHblXpecypcoBBPoCX:H.ltlt$OpMaUHOHHo-aHBl1"-
T'IE!c.600n.neTeHb.2007 N!!3(93J C.20
2.Kop,e"cyP$otSjOOAPBp,.
:3 r. llnaToBa" C.E. '1aHHOIIa M.. rpocc Me)J,L<a. Poc5yx, 2008 C. 160-161
3 C3P$.2005.N!!1S.Cr 1277
-80-

.QOBOJIbHO .meCTKO perHHbill: peOO1M X03JIiiicTBoBaIm. npo-
)f{J1BaHJ.1R,_
B IIpl1Be,!\eHHOM aKTE' co.QepmaTCJI BeCbMa no.IJ;p06HbIe npaBOBbIe HOP-
MbI 0TH0CIITeJThH> nepBOi1:, B'TOJXiII M 'IpeTDei1: 30H Ha3BaHHhlX OKpyroB.
TaK, HaIIpJ.1Mep, B nepBOi1: 30He 3anpeLIJPKITCJI IIpO)!G1Balille J1 Bee BJ-1,!J;hIXo-
,l\eH'J'€.JIhH()C'I K}XJMe CBR3aHHhIX C teM J1 J1C-
l1O.JIb3OBaIIJfeMIIpHpO,!\HhlXpecypCOBBJle'1e6HhIXJ1poIJIITE'JlhHhIXl\e-
JlIIX (c npt 3KOJlOl'WlecKU 6e30nacHhIX TeXHOJDntfl). Bo BTOpOi1:
30He pa3Mell.\ffiOTCR caHaTopHO-KypopTHhle 3,!\aHID1 J1 coopymeHJIH. HO 3a-
npeLIJ;eHO p dh.eKTOB, He CBH3aHHhIX Henocpe,!\C1'BeHHO C co-
3,!\WU:leM J1 pa3Btm:IeM Ccpephl KYPOpTHOro Jle'leHlliI M OT.r:\hIXa. B TpeThei1:
30He oqmnrqeHO p IIpOMbllllJleHHhIX J1 
HhIX dh.eKTOB.
B Ci1JIY 4>e,!\epaJIbHoro3aKOHa OT 14 MlOJIR 2008 r. .N2118-cI>3 «0 BHe-
ceHVU-I H3MeHetOOi B Bo.QHbIJ1 KO.QeKC POCCID1CKOIii: 4>e,!\epaLtJ-lJ1 I-{ OT,!\eJIh--
Hhle 3aKOHO.QaTeJlbHhle aKTbI PoccIDiCR'Oii 4>e,!\€paL\J-IJ-l» 6bIJI OTMeHeH 3a-
IJpeTHa 3aC'IpOi1Ky 'IpeTb€fO nORca CaHJ1TapliO- 30HbI. Tpe-rw"1:
nORC 6bIJI ycTaHCIBJIE:'H B paC'ieTE' Ha 10 CyroK «,!\06eraHlliI» BO.D;h1 no peKe
.QO MeCTa BO,!\03a6opa. PeaJlbHO me 3'!'a TeppHTOpIDI)'me BCH 3aCTpoeHa.
a 3aIIpeT OI(838J1CR M8J1oJ\ei1cmeHH.
KaKJ-I BO.nooxpaHHble 3OHh!, oKpyra CaIDITapHoi1: J1 mpliO-GUll'1T8pHOi1:
OXpaHbl J.1MelOT CBOIII IIpoeKTbL OHIII pa3pa6aTbmaIOTCH opraID13aLtJ-lH!\olill,
J.1MelOLIJ;iIIMJ-I Ha 3TO JIIrn, no 3a)IaIIJ1HM, COrJlaCOBaHHhIM C opraHaMJ-I
11CI1()JIHHT€JIbH(Ji BJ1aCTI1 Cyfu.€I\TOB PoccmICKOii <Pe,!\epaIJ;l1ill.
Oco6o OXPaHJ«'I\IhI£' BO,!\HbIe ofu.eKTI.L ComaCHO CT. 66 BK pcp BO,!\-
Hhre ofu.eKTbl (J1JIiII J1X 'lacm), J-IMelOlWfe oco6oe nplll}XJ,!\ooxpaHHoe, Ha-
yqHoe, KYJlbT.}'PHoe,, peKpeaLtJ-lOHHOe J1 O3,lIPpoBU'I"€JIl>IID
3Ha'leHYle, Mor)'T 6bITb npJ13H8Hb1 oc06o oXpamieMbIMYI BO,!\HbIMJ1 dh.eIC-
TaMJ-I.
B COOTBe'I'CTBJ'IfCOCT.:3 BK pcpKnpMHl\illflaMBO,!\Horo 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIb-
C'TBa OTHOCHTCR coxpaHelille oco6o oxpaHReMbIX BO,!\HbIX ofu.eKTOB, orpa-
HW-IeHllle J1JIiII 3anpeT IICI1OJIb3OB8HHH KOTOphlX yc'ffiH3.RID:lBaeTCJ'I ctJe)J;e-
paJIbHhIMYI 3aKOHaMJ-I
PeOO1M oco6oii oxpaHhI M rpaHmjbl T€PPJf!'OP'llf, B npe)J;eJlax KOTOpblX
pacno.rromeHhI Ha3BaHHhle BO,!\Hhle CJt1wcrH, YCTaHaBJllJBalO'l'CJ'l B COOT-
BeTCmillill C 3aKOHo,!\aTeJlhCmOM 06 oc06o oxpaHfleMbIX npl-:Ipo)J;Hh1X Tep-
pIllTOpMJ'IX. CJ:re,!\OBaTeJlhHO, BO,!\Hble 06'heKTbI MOryT BXO)J;m'h B rpaHiIIUbI
1 C3P$.1996 Nl!51.Cr.5798
2 pr 2008 Nl!153.1al1lOH C.3
-61-

samBe,/J;Hl'1lOCl3, 3aIW.31D1KOB, HaI.p1OllaJIb1lblX J1 IIpMpO,IJ;HbIX napKOB, na-
MRTHHKOB npMpO.IJ;bI, Jle':le6HO-03,!\opomrreJlbHldX ME'C'fHOCTeit. KYPopTOB,
OOramf'IeCKJlX Ca,!\OB J1 ,!\eH,IlpOJI(I1f'IeCKJlX napKOB.
I1Melllio pellli J1 03epa 3a"laCTyro cocraBJIHKJ1' cBoeo6pa3HOe HJJPO .wm
 roCY,l\apC'TBe:HHblX IIpHpo):\HbIX 3aIIEe,II;HKIOOB f'<IJ. 3To MO)K-
HO IIpoCJJe):\t1Tb Ha IIpHMepe CJJe.D.YJOllVfX 3afKOB 113 pa3HbIX KOH-
lIOB POCCHH: «BaiiKa.m.eKtu:1:», «BaiiKano-JIeHCKJri;i», «I30JDKCKO-I\aM-
CIllii:i»,«riI»,«C>IccKrrlb,»,((,
«YccypIDiicIool». PH,!\ Ha4H01IaJlbHbIX napKOB TaKiKe J1MeHYe'f(:H no Ha-
3Bam-IlOBO,!\HbIX OOceK'roB: «II.neIIffOO ooepo», .IhDKHHH KaMa», «CMO-
JIeHCKOe n003epbe».
KpOMe TOI'O, 1J,JIR 3aLqlITbl BO)J;HblX OObeK'l'OB B03MOJKHO  DT-
JIbHbIX oco6o oxpaHfleMbIX IIpI-1po):\HbIX 'reppJrroptnl K J1X <mc.rry OTHo-
CHTCH cnel\l1flJIbHble  3aJ(a3HHKH (pelJHble, ooepHble, 60-
JIOTHblE',MOpcKWe). HeMflJlopeK, ooep,60JIOT, po)J;Ht1KOB, npy,nOB
J13a6porneHHbIX SHaJIOB npi-1HaAITemELT K naMJITHJ1KaM npI-1po.IJ;bL
BamHoe 3Ha':leIDIe J1MelOT He TOJIbKO ,nepa.rrbHble, HO J1 pernOHaJIb-
Hble oco6o oxpaHHeMbie IIpItpo.nHbIe 'I"€Ppl1TOpH", B Ka"leCTBe npl1Mepa
MO*HO npMBeCTlii npl1po,IJ;HhIiii: napK «.D:OJIJ1Ha peRH CXO)J)rn B KypKl1HO»
Ha ceaepo- MOCKBbL OH 06pa30BaH B 2004 r. perneHJ1eM IIpaBH-
TeJlhCTBa MOCKBbI B noi:iMeHHoi1 ':IaCTlii pellliCxoJJ:HR J1ee IpI'J'O}(()B. Tep-
pwropMJI napKa. cpaBHtlTeJlbH:) He6oJlbwa.fl - 245 ra. IIpH 3TOM ,naHHhlii
npI1plJJJ:Hilli KOMIIJIeKC OTJ1J1'1a€TC.fI }!eM  pe):\-
KJ1MH paCTeHll.flMJ1 J1 OTHbIMJ1. 3a.HeceHHbIMJII B KpacHble KtillrH Poc-
CHH J1 MOCKBbl l .
IIOMHeHMlOMHon-1Xn3KOJDIW1ecJroii
TH. 3a,na'lJ1 oxpaHbl pocC1X BO,nHbIX pecypcoB Tpe5ylOT C03,naHJ1.f1
pa3BeTBneHHoi1 ceTlii OQm B )KJ13HeHHO BajKHbJX :y'IaCTKa.X pelffibJX J1
o3epHbIX CJ1CTeM. TaKi1e npe.nnomeHJ1l1 OTHOOITeJIbIiO K IIO,!\MOCKOBbll
Bbl)J;Bill'alOTC.fInpHpO.ll.ooxpaHHtlM $:IHJJ;OM «BepxoBbe» . 3Ta HeKOMMep-
':IecKa.flCTaBJ-1Tnepe):\co5ai13a,!\a':IYo6ecne'iJ1Tbc}:>opMJ1po-
BaHHe <':IJ1CTOI'O" C'roKa TaKJ1X peK, l\aK MOCKBa, :K.rni3bMa, Y':Ia, lIpoma.
O,IJ;HMM 113 cnoco50B oxpaHbl HBJUieTClI npl13HaHHe J1C'roKOB peR, CTO'lHblX
J1 npcrrOlJHb1X o3ep JlOKaJibHbIMJ1 oco6o oxpaHfleMbIMlil Teppl1TOpJ1llMM,
'ITOpeaJlbHOIIJXU.
IIo EaihtanbCltoH: npHpo):\HOi1TeppillTOpI1H ,!\ei1CTByeT l\eJIbrn: pfl,lJ;-
,!\epa.rrbHbIX npaBOBbIX aKTOB. YHI1KaJIbHOe no CBOI1M CBOi1cTBaM J1 pecyp-
I TcmcreHKQBQ. TaHal\011HblpeKCxOJ\HIIHaYKal1><3b. 2008 N.6. C 156-160
2 PycaHOBA,B., C.A" CoKOllOBU.B. YI<pEnnEH1ece-roco&loxpaHReMblxllppo.1\_
H..x"6acceHaBepxoB"""peKHMocKBbI.M 101:'11:\-808EX.2000
-62-

taM 03epo EaHKaJI 3aIW1ll\eHOcornarnoKoHBeHIU1J100H06oxpaHe BCe-
MMpHOro RYJlbiypHOrO J1 npl1pO,!J;Horo HaCJIe)J;J1H 1972 r. .lI:eHcrnyeT ,IJ;e-
paJIbHbIiii 3aKOH OT 1 MaH 1999 r..N2 94-cI>3 «06 oxpaHe 03epa EaHKaJI».
lIpJ1 aHaJIJ13e pemJ1Ma oom H£'06xo.u;JtMO yqJ1TbmaTb MeapO,l:\-
Hble COrJIallIeHJ1H. POCCJ1R - yqacTHJ-ma PaMCapCKOH KOHBeill\J1J1 ar 2 4>e-
BpaJI.FI 1971 T. 0 BO,D;HO--6o.ncmn, yrO,l:\bffiC, J1MeKJI1tJ1X Me)K,llJ'lffipo,l:\HOe
3HaqeHJ1e TJIaBHblM 06pa3oM B RaqeCTBe  BO,JJPnJJaBaIO-
Il-tJ1X mJ1It. B 1975 T. CCCP o6'hf1BW1 12 yro,1J)Ii1: (BEY),
J1MelOIl-tJ1X Mem,nyHapo,I:\HOe 3HaQeHl1e. lIpJ1 3'I'OM WJlbKO TpJ1 113 HJ1X Obl-
JIJ1 Ha Te(prrop:DI PCcI>CP. K 1999 r. B POCCJilJ1 HaC'lJ1Tbffia.n:OCb 35 yro-
JJ;Jrli, tx nO)];)];eOCrnIre KOIIB€HWDl Bcero me B MI1pe HaC'lJ1-
TblBaH OROJlO 900 "paMcapcKJ1X» BEY. B Ha'iaJIe 1990-x IT. B HallieH
CTpaHe npoBeJIJ1 J1HBeHTapJ13aL\J1KJ BO,IJ.HO-OOJIarHbIX yro,1J)Ii1:, Be)];eTCH
no)];roTOBKa Haltl'fOH3JlbHOCO Ka)1aCTpa, nJIaHJ1pYeTCH C4JopMJilpoBaTh
ceTb "paMcapcKJ1X» yro,!J)Iif, 'IltCJIeHHOC'T'HQ OKOJlO 400 1 . CorJlaCHO poc-
ClDuroMy 3aROHo.n.aTeJlb(.'rBy «paMcapCKJ1e BEY) MOryT J1MeTb Pa3.JlJ-l'{-
Hbrn: CTaTYC: 3aIlOOE'J]JllfKll, 3aKa3HJOO1, npl1pO,1J;Hble napKJ1.
BepemHoe OTHOIIIeIIJte R BQD;ID--6o.norn yro,I:\bHM BOOOme J16o.naraM
B 'iaCTHOCTII CBOHCTBeHHO AJlH ceBepHbIX coce.neH POCCJilJ1 - CKaH,JUfHaB-
CKJ1X roCY,llapCTB. B 1IIBe'-tJ1M, 41HHJlHH.luUf. a TaKme B .lI:aHMJ1 cof.:cTBemm:-
ICJ1 sa6o.oo'1eHJn,[x 3eMeJlbHbIX yqaCTKOB nOJIyqalO'l' sa orpaHIfIleHHH CBO-
efl X03JIRcTBeHHoii .n.eflTeJlbHOC'I'J1 KOMTIeHCaQI1OHHHe Bbln.naTbl,
 OT HaJIOrOB. L1x 3eM€JIbHbI€ yqaCTI\1f MOryI' ObITb Bbmyn-
JI€HbI roCY,llaPCTBQM J1JIJ1 M)'HJ1IUmaJlbHNMU 06pa30BaHl1HMJll. C 1989 T. B
):(aHJ1J1 3a rocY,lIapcTBeHHbIH C'IeT J1JIJ1 3a C'leT EC npoJ13BO,IVITCH pa6oTh1
no coxpaHeHIoo iii BOCC'ffiHOBJJf'HKlO 6o.nar 2 _
000r.eJm0c0rn: npoooBOfi oxpam.1  BO)l;HhlXpecypooB. B co-
OTBe'I'CTBIfIiI co CT. 59 BK P4I 4JJ13H'1€CKJ1e J1lOpl1,l\l'l'l€CICJ1€ JIJ1Qa, .n.€;I-
T€JlbHOCTb IOOTOpbIX Oxa3blBaeT I1JlYl MO'*'T Oxa3aTb H€raTI1BHOe B03,!\eH-
CTBJ1€ Ha COCTOJiHJ1e nQI:\3€MHblX BO;:J;llblX o&beltTOB, OOH3aHbl npJ1HJ1MaTb
Mepbl no npe.IJ:OT8paLIJ;eHYilO 3aI'pH3H€HnH, 3acopemuf nO,IJ;3eMHbIX BO,IJ;-
HbIX o&belITOB 11 J BO)];, 8 TaIOKe COOJIIO,!\aTb }'C'ffiHOBJleHH
HOpM8TWBbI ,rpI1)'C'IUMOI'O B03)];eiic'I'BIiI.H Ha I1O,l\3€MHNe BO)J;Hb1e oo"eKTbI.
Ha BQl1OC6oJ:mrrx llJIOJ1.W1.HX nO)J;3eMHblX BO)J;IIblX ofueIcroB. KOTOPbl€
JfCIJOJIb3yIO'I'CfI J1JIJ1 MOryT ObITb JICI1OJ'Ib3OBaH AJlH L\€J1eiii IDITbeBoro YI
x03Hii:CTBeHHO-fu.rroEOro BO,IJ;OCHaO,*,ID1H. YCTaHaBJIJllBEleTCR OipaID1'1J1-
TeJIbHbrn: peml1M.
I yrOAb!'Pocc''.BoJ\Ho-t5011OT..eYrQAbR...e''J\YHapo.PJ,Horo3a"eHR T.1/
nOJl.P8A.B.r.KpHBeHro.M WetlandslnlBmbonBl.1998 C.57-58
2 P:t<BL-1HIt1TL-11996.N,6.C.96.
-83-

He ,lJ;OnyCKaeTCfl p33MeLU,aTb MeCT3 3aXOpOl1emm OTXO)];OB np0J13-
BOJJ;crna J1 nOTpe6J1eIDifl,  CKOTOMOmJIbHJ1KJ1 J1 J1Hbre 06'beK-
Tbl, OKa3blBalOe HeraTHBHOe B03,[IeifCTlille Ha COCTOJUme m,[l3eMHbl"{
BOJ<
E.c.rrn: npJil HCInJIb3OBaHJfi1 He.np BCKpbITbI BOWHOCliI>IE:' mpH3OHTbl,
He06xo)];JD,u npJ1HJITb Mepbl no oxpaHe nO)];3eMHbIX BOWIblX 06neK'roB.
J1Ha'ie B03MOiKHO CJtIJlbHoe 3aI'pH3HeIDie nOeMHblX BO.I\HblX OO'beKTOB
ComaCHO ;:J;aHHbIMBo;:J;Hoi1CTpaTern:J1 POCCffi'I np06J1eMaMJil J1cn0JIb30-
BaHI1H nOeMHbIX BO.I\ JlBJlHIOTCJI:
- HJil3KaJl creneHb 0CB0eHJ1H 3allaCOB nOeMHbIX BO.I\ (B cpe,IUleM no
CTpaHe He IIpeBbrnrae-r 33%);
- l!eJ1CD).JIb3()B8JIe OKOJIO nOJlOBJilHbI 'iIIICJlJliIV'lXCJI Ha rocy.J1apCTBeH-
HOM y<Iere pa3Be)ViHHbIX iii OL\eHeHHbIX MeCTOpOnl npecHbIX no,!\-
3eMHbIX BO)t
- )];06b!'!a 3Ha<nITI'JIbIIOO JJ;OJD1 nOJJ;3eMHbIX BO.I\ Ha y<IaCTKax He.I\p. He
lilMelOiIV'IX }'TBepm,n;eHHbIX 3allaCOB nO.I\3eMHbIX BO)t
-  MeC'fOpru«.neIDm: IDW£'MHbIX BO.I\ BCJIe.I\C'I1JMe Hapyrne-
mrli: pe)lG1M8. I1X HrnOJlb3OBaIDlH, a TaIOKe 6ec:lro1rIponbHOJI ;Q06bl'ill Ha
Hepacnpe)];eJleHHOM q,oH,ZJ;e He,1Ip.
B lIeJIJIX llOBbIIlIeJillfl Ka'leCTBa BO;QbI B BOWIblX OObeKTax, BOCCTaHOB-
JIeIDfJlBO.I\HbIX aKOCJilCTeM J1peKpeaW1oHHoronOTeaJla Tpe6yeTCJI pe-
lIDITb, B ruM 'iIIICJle, 3a.Aa'l.}' OXpaHbI iii npe)];O'fBpal..L\eHIDI 3a!J)f13HeIDfJl
IIO;Q3eMHbIX BO.I\HbIX 06neK'roB.
B lIeJlOM nOJJ;3eMHbIe BO)J;Hble OObeKTbI nO)J;BepmeHbl ropa3)\O MeHb-
llIeM)' HeraTHBHOM)' Bm;Qei.ICTBroo., 'ieM nOBepXHOCTHbie peKJil iii 03epa.
O)J;HaKOBIIOCJJe,lJ,ffif€ 1JIeTIUI B POCCffi'I (KaKIiI BcrpaHaX CRr) npo-
CJleml1B3eTCJI IJOCT 3aIp.H:3HeHHJI, 33COpeHI1H J1Ii1CTOll\eIDIJI nO)];3eMHblX
BOA 3-ro KaCaeTCH He TOJIbKO TaIDIX npOMbIllIJleHHbIX u;empoB, KaE
MOCRBa, CaHKT-IIe-rep6ypr, KypCK iii .npyrnx. ,D;enpecCIDI ypoBHJI no,!\-
3eMHblX BO)]; KacaKYrCJI TaKlilX IIpID'Opo)J;(E CTOJiJ1L\h!, KaK Jbo6epL\b1 J1
Mbrr11ll\l11.
KaK coo6LU,aeT npecca, HeKOTOpble npe.nnpwrrHH 3aKa'lJilBalOT 3a-
IpH3HeHHhIe npo CTOlJRhle BO;QbI B rJly60Kt1e nOJJ;3eMHble
ropt13CIITbI, C03)J;aBafl TeM caMblM yrpo3Y ,l1ame AJl.fI BO)]; pelJHoro cruRa.
OpraHbl IIpOK)'paTypbl iii PocrexHaJ:J.sop 'iepe3 CY.I\ crpeMflTCJI ocraHo-
ID-ITb 3aKa'il1BaID1e 'UlN!Ji'leCKlf sarpH:3HeHHbIX crOKOB, CO.I\epmalIDfX (IT-
XO,!J;b1 nepBOro I-UIaCca OnaCHOCTl1 (B TOM'iJIICJIe pTy'I'b)2.
1 C118!iKDSA.O .nQ!13E!MHbleBQl1bl3aUIHTHTb.l1DroeopDMIIHS"DHOMKa.
20051\106 C.77--S0
2 nnaTB aa rpfl3b /l8"OnDn< H )I(3Hb. 2007 III! 10. C 20-21
-84-

B pJl,!J;e 3apy6emHbIx rocyoWlPCTB nO,!\3eMHble BO,!\bl TaIOKe He OCTa-
JlMCb 6e3 OXpaHbI 3aKOHa. B 3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbcrBe 4Ipr (3aKoH 1986 r.)
w€tUtaJIbHbIe 30Hbl OXpaHbI BO,!\ ,!\0JDKHb1 ooeperaTb IIO,!\3eMHbIe BO,!\bI
OT yme cyIl\eCTBYIDII.\WX IilJH1 IIO'It'HWWIbHbIX orraCliocreii. B QeJIJIX
}'BeJBI'IeJlHH IiI 3aLqIIITbi3arraCOB rpYHTOBblX BO,!\ ar CTO-
KOB 3aI1pflQE.eTCfI IiI orpaHWll1BaeTCJI onp€,l\eJIeHHaJl HHaH
.l\emeJlbHOCTb. IIo:ITOMY BJIa,!\eJlbLJ;b! IiI IIOJIb30BaTeJlH 3eMeJIbIIbIX yqa-
CTKOB BblliY<K,J:(eHbI IIpeTeplIeTb Jf3B€CTHbIe orp8.HWlelDm B Kopo.n:eB-
CTEe Bemmo6pwramm J1 CeBepmii J1pJIaHJUUI Ka'leCTBO IIOJ\3eMHbIX
BO,!\ .I\OCT8TO'-lHO BblCOKO BO MHOroM 6J1aro,!\apH ,n;eiiC'l'BeHllliM MepaM B
paMKaX rrpaBOBOro pe)KJ1MB. paffOHOB IIOBblllleHHoii 
II: IillTpaTaM B rpaRlfit8.Xnnoma,l1cil3aJleralillH II0JJ;3eMHbIX BO,!\. 3TH Me-
pbI pe3iW orpalill'-lJ1BaJIJI c6poc 3arpH3RfllOllV1X BeLq€CTB J1 6b1Jll1 OCHO-
BaHbI He TOJIhKO Ha Haip10HaJlbHOM 3aB:OHO,!\aTeJlbCTBe, HO J1 Ha ,l1.I-1:peK-
nmaxEC 1 .
,llaHHb!e 3apy6emHble no;:J;XO.I\bl J1 KOHCTpyKW1H He ocr8JurCb 6e3
BHI1MaHI1JI IIpH paspa60TKe Bo,!\HOii cTpaTerHH.I\O 2020 r. B ClIel\HaJlb-
HOM ILrraHe IIO pt'aJ!I:!3al\J1If Bo,!\HOii CTpaTeI'JIH.I\O 2020 r. rrpe,nyCMaTpH-
BalOTCH pa3paoarKa 1pe60samrli: K J1CIIOJIb3OBaHHlO 3eMeJlbHbIX yqaCT--
KOB B rpalDfLtaX lIJi)LQ.a.I\eJl 3aJleraHHH MeCTopom,nemm: IIOJ\3eMHbIX
BO,!\, KOTOpbIe MOryT obrrb HWOJlb3OBaHIoI AJIH L\E'H'IpiUIlf3OBaHHOro IIH-
TbeBoro J1 X03fIIICTBeHHO---fHToBOro Bo,!\ocHa6meHill'l, ycUJIeIDte arBeT-
CTBeHHOC'l1f 3a co6.mo.rIeime pemI1MOB 3KCIIJlyaTal\lli-l J1 oxpaHbI IIO):\-
3eMHbIX BO,!\.
3. IOPI1,QH4ECKA OTBETCTBEHHOCTb
3A HAPYWEHH BOI\HOro 3AKOHOl\A TEbCTBA
06LQHe BOIIpOCbI 0TBeTC'I'B€IDI0 IOpJ.1,iJ;WleCKaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb -
('.JI(J)KHH:ii I1p8BCI3t)M HHC'I'IITyT, KOTopbrn I fiecn€<iJ1BaeT B3aYlMH)'1O CBfl3b
rocY.Il8pCTaa J1 J1Hb1X cy6'beKTOB 06ll\€CTB€HHblX 0TH0lll€HJfi,i: B pa3JIJ1q-
HbIX cqx.pax }KYJ31U1 06J.I:[eCTaa. JJ;aHHbIi1 mIC111Tyr c.rrym-rr BaiKHOM ra-
paImleJf co6.111Q[1EtDfH 3aKOHHOCTYI J1 IIpaBOnopH,!J;Ka, peaJlJl3aIJ;YiJ'l rrpaB J1
OOH3aHHoc::reit:Bpa3HblXo6JIacTHXOTHoweIDrit
OrrpeLleJUlH IIOIDIrne IOPI:!,L!W{ecKOii arBeTCTBeHHOCTJoI, TeopeTHKYI
iIpaBa IIpl1,l\epmHBaHBO MHOrOMpa3HbIXB3I"JIJ'IJIOBJ1IIpe,n;CTaBJIeIDrit
B'laCTHOCTH, BbIpa6araHo IIOIDIrne II03JI'1'I,1BH(larBeTCT-
I cfuPH!<IKHBHI1I1C3.1988 (\JiI C 45,P)!(BI1HI1TVI.1990 (\Ji9 C 92
-85-

BeHHOCTI'! KaK oco:3Halnle JII1'ilIOCTbIO CO)J;epmaHI1H J13Ha'ieID-IH C06CTBeH-
HOro nOB€)1eHllil, cBOero )J;OJITa nepe)J;  J1 roCYMPCTBOM. .l(aH-
HOe nOHHTl1e coCy:Il\ecTByeT C nOHHTI'!eM HeraTI1BHoi1lOpl1,!\l1"IeCKoi1 OT-
Be'l'C'I'BeHH0CTK, CR B f)C()3HaHIDf npDlllJIoro rnEe,D;eHHR,
npDIllJIbIX npaBOHapyrnelUnl 1 . BHe COMHemUl, B CKOM 06l1\eCTBe
J1 npaBOBOM pCTBe ,l\OCTaTO'ffiO pa3BJfl1;d KaK II03JmlBlWJl, Tal{ J1
HeraTI1BHBJI IOpI1,l\l1'iecKafi crrBe'I'C'l'BeH
IIFUMeHJITeJIbHO II: I1pI'1pO.IJPI1X J1 IIpItpo.D.OpecypCHbIM (B TOM
'lI1CJIe J1 II: BO,IJ;HhIM) Q'I'H()llI€HKfI oe<:GH3Hi'fe JII1'ilIOCTbIO J1JI11 KOJlJIeKTI1-
BQM,l\OJITa nepe)J;  J1 roc)'AapcTBOM MC»KeT6hlTbel1\e He,lJ;OCTa-
TO'iHO pa3BJlITbIM. B POCCI1JI! no npwn-rne IIpaBOBOro HJl!I11Jill3Ma J1 HeBbICO-
KOf! 3R'OJJ()I1f'1ecIOOii KynbtypbI He pa3BJlITa II03M'I'KBHafI lOpU.IJ;I1'tecKaJ'l
UI'Be'l'CTBeIDI I1MeHHo n03'J"OMY nepeLlemmaTb OC03IW.HJte npMpO,!\O-
n0Jlb30BaTeJIHMJI! CBoem ,l\OJII'a BPH.!\ JII1 HMeeT CMbICJI. CJIe,IJPBaTeJlbHO,
roCYMpCTBeHHble opraHbI BJIaCTH, opraHbI MeCTHoro caMoynpaBneHJ1.R,
eoprnmHeAOJDKHbIOCJIa6JrnTbBlDtMaHJteKC06JIIO-
JJ;eHJ1JO 'I'p€6OBaJmR IIpItpo,rIOOXpaHHOfO M nplfpOro 38.KOHO-
JJ;aTeJlbCTBa.
KaK J13BeCTHO, 3alWHO,l\aTeJlbCTBO PocClm:CKoii ,l\epaL\l-fi1 npe)J;yc-
MaTpJlIBae-r HeCKOJIbKO BI-fJI.OB  0TB€'TC'I'BeHH0f, KOTOpbIe
,l\ei1CTB)'1OT J1 B ofuIaCTI1 BO,IJ;HblX npaBOHapyweHJl!H. :.flo- ,l\I1ClIJD1Hap-
Hafl, rrpaTI1BHWi, yronoBH8fl, npaBOBafl OTBeTCT-
BeHHOCTb
 'ieTKO pa3Jll1'laTb Ha3BaHHble BJ.-U{bl 0'I'BI2'K'TBe1lllOCTIl.
TaKKaK 113HMXHaCT,)'TIaeTnyTeMnpMMeHeHI1JIHOpMpa3Jlli'ffiblX
orpacneil 3alWHOt\aTeJlbCTBa:  a)J;MJIlII'lCTpaTJlIBHoro, yroJIOB-
HOro, rpam,II<lHCK()I (npl1 onpe,JJ,eJIeHHbIX 06cTOflTeJlbCTBaX - C yqeTOM
3aKOHOt\aTeJIhCTBa 060xpaHe cpe,!\b!, a TalOKeBO)J.Horo 3a-
KOHO)J;aTeJlbCTBa, 0 'ieM 6Y,l\eT CKa3aHO HJl!me).
HapyrneHJl!e ycJIOOJm: fIOAOJX)JIb3OB8.HMJI, KOTOpbIe 38.KpenneHbl B JJ;O-
roBOpax BOJI.CI1f)JIb3()BaIfIH, cne'--tl1B-JIhHblX pellleHWIX 1-1JIt:I HenOCpe,lJ;CT-
BeHHO B SaROHe, MruKeT TbCfl KaK npaBoHapyrneHJl!e B ofuIaCTI1
BO)J.HOro X03RiiicTBa. COrJIaCHO AeJ1c'rBy1ou.\eMy 3aKOHOt\aTeJ1bCTBY. 3TO
MOryr 6hlTb yroJIOBHble npecryn.nelUm, a.IJ;MJ1IDIcTpaTJ1BHble J1 JJ;J1CI.\JITI-
.mmapHblenpocTyTIKI1, rpte npaBOHapyweID-Ifl.
YI'OJIOBHaH J1 a)\MJ1HJ1CTpanIBHa» OTBeTCTBCHHOCTb, B 3aBMCMMQ-
CTM aT CTelIeID-I Bpe,na J1 06l1\eCTBeHHoil OIIaCHOCTJ1 HapyrneHHH B 06-
1 BuT1JjIK H.B. 06uiB TeOpl-K1lOpH,!J,HBCI«) 0T1IfITClBeIH)C M HoPMB. 2009 C 5-39
-66-

JIacn'I JlCIIOJIb3OBaffifH If OXpaHbI BO.I\ Mor)'T 6blTb RaK a;:J;MI1HI1C'l'p8-
TJIBHlDU'I npocTynKaMI1, TaR If yroJloBHblMI1 npecTyllIl€HI1HMI1. B YK
Ptf:I aT 13 IflOIDI1996 r..N2 6343 npe,IJ;yCMOTpeHbl cJle.I\YIDLII;I1e COCTa-
Bbl npeCTynJleHI1H, 3aTp8I'J1Ba101Q11X ofuIacTb HCII0JIb30I3<UIMH If oxpa-
Hbl BO,l1;: «3aHJI€ BO,l1;" (CT. 250), «3arpH3HeIDte MOpCKOi-i: cpe,l\w»
(CT. 252), clIe3aKoHHaH,I1;06bl'ra.BOWIblX :IKI1BOTHblX1f pa (CT. 256).
B 1f3B€CTHOi1: Mepe K HUM OTHOCwrCH If "Yffif'iTCOKeHHe Kpl1TI1':1eCKI1X
MeCToo6V!T8HJ-ri1: AJlH opraffif3MOB, 3aHeCeHHbIX B KpaCH)'lO Kmlry P<I>>>
(cT.2S9).
B RoATI Ptf:I npe.n;ycMOTpeHbl cJle.rr;yIOLII;I1e a.v;MJ1IDICTpaTIlBHble npo-
crynKI1, HaHOCHLII;I1e Bpe,l\ BQ,l\HblM pecypcaM:
- caMCI3OJIbHOE' 3aHJIThle BO.I\HOro OO'beRTa J1J1}'! nOJib30BaHl1e 11M C Ha-
pyureffilIeM ycraHOOJIeHHbiX ycoomrli: (CT. 7.6);
-mBfJ€'K,!\€HI1e,BO,JJ,OX03ffiiCTBeHln'OJ1JII1BO.I\o-
oxpaHHoro coopymemrn, yc-rpoi1:crBa J1J1J11 YCTaHOBKJI (CT. 7.7);
-CaMOBOJlbHOe 3aHJITl1€3eMeJlbHOroyqaCTKa np!16pearnoH3al1UITHOii
nOJlOCbl BO.I\HOro o&beK'l'a, BO.lPOXpaHlIOH 30Hbl BO)J;HOro 06'beK'l'a .m16o
30HhI caHl1TapHUii OXpaHhlIilCTO'-UlJtiCOB IDITbeBoro iii XQ3ffiICTBeHHO-fud-
TOBOro BO.I\OCHa6memm (CT. 7.8);
- caMOBOJIbH8JI nepeyCTyIIKa npaB8 IIOJIb3OBaHnH 3eMJlE'Ji, He.I\paMl1,
JIeCHbIM yqaCTKOM IiIJIJII BO)J;HbIM dTheKTOM (CT. 7.10);
- HapyrneHl1e TpefxEaHmi no oxpaHe He.n;plil rlUlJX]MHHepaJlbHbIX pe-
CypcOB (CT. 8.9);
- HapyrneHl1e I10pa,lJ;Ka €HI1JI rpam,l\aHaM, ropMi1'leCKi1M
JI\!Il1;aM 3eMeJIbHblX }"'aCTIOOB, JIeCOB B BO,II,OOXp<!HIiHX 30Hax, pe:atl1M8li1x
HCI1OJI:h.'3OOaHl-m(CT.8.12);
- Hapyuremle npaBI1JI OXpaHbI BO.I\Hh1X 06'beKTOB (CT. 8.13);
-HapyrnemlenpaBI1JIBaHJ1H(CT. 8.14);
-HapyrneHl1eIlpaBI1JI3KcrJJlyaTaLtJ1J1JfJlI1BO.I\o-
OXpaHHblX coopymeHI-m: iii ycrpoi1cTB (CT_ 8.15);
- HapyweHl1e perJI8MeHTItpyroLII;l1x ,AeHTeJIhHOCTh BO BHyrpeHHI1X
MOpCKI1X BO.I\aX, B TeppI1TOpM8JIhHOM Mope, Ha KOHTHHeHT8J1hHOM
WeJIb4Je iii (J'lJlJ'I) B J'lCRJIro'iI1TeJibHOi1: 3KOHOMH'ieCKoi1: 30He POCCHi1:-
CKOi-i: 4>e.I\epal\I1H npaBJfJI (CT8H;J;apTOB, HOpM) IiIJlH YCJlOBHH JIHL\eH-
31i11i1(CT.8.17);
- HapyrneHlile npaBI1JI npOBe,l\eHI1JI pecypcHbIX J1JII1 MOpCKIiIX Ha}"'-
HhIX HCCJi€,AOBaHI-1i1 BO BHyrpeHHI1X MOpCKi1X BO,!\ElX, B Teppi1TOpl1aJihHOM
Mope, Ha ROHThlHeHTaJIbHOM weJIbc}:>e 11 (IiIJIH) B IiICKJiro'-H-ITeJIbHoi13KOHo-
MI1'fecKoi130He POCCIiIMcKOH 4>e.I\epaL\ffi1 (CT. 8.18).
RaK OTMe'leHO B I10CTaHOBJIeHliIliI IlneH)'Ma BepxoBHoro CYM pq, OT
5 HOH6pH 1998 r. .N2 14 ,,0 I1paKTlilKe npJ1MeHeHI1JI CY.l1aMl13aKOHO):jaTe,JIb-
-87-

CTBa 06 CYrBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 sa  lIpaBOH8pyweHl-1H» 1, IIpI1
paccIlfUI'peHKIf yroJIOBHbIX.r:\eJI, B03HJ'DQllJfX B CBH311 C mpyrneHJ1eM moo-
JKI1f'reCK01'O 3aKOHQDP.TeJlbCTBa, He06xo.n;J1MO O'ITpaHJ1'Il1BaTb 3KOJI0rl1-
'1eCKI1e IIpec-rynJIeHI-IR ar 3KOJIOIWI€CKI1X 1Ip000ymwB, T.e. BHHOBHbIX
IIpO'I'HB(I1paB ;o:eHlulli, fX Bpe;o: OK IIpMpo;o:-
HOi-1 cpe,!\e J'! S,!\OpoBbIO '1eJIOBeKa, sa KOTopble yCTaHOBJIeHa 8,!\MJ1H11c-rpa-
TJ1BHaR arBeTCrneHHOCTb
BCJIY'Ule B03HI1KHOBeHl1HTpy,IJ;Hocrei-1ByrOJIOBHOHaKa-
3}'eMOrO ,IJ;eRHIDI J'! a.n;MI1HI1crpaTI1BHoro npaBOHapyweHl1H oco6oe BHI1MaHI1e
CJle;:Jye-r y,!\eJlHTb  acexo6cTrurrem,CTB, xapaKTep113}'lOll.\JfX co-
CTaB 3KOJIOIWIecKOro npaBOHapyrneHI-IR, IIOCJIe,!\CTBI1iii IIpOTI1BOrrpaBHoro
.r:\eRHl1H, pa3Mepa HaHeceHHOro spe,[la 11 I1pI'n1H€HHUfO YIQep6a.
B HayqHOi-1 JII1Teparype npo6JIeMaM IIpHBJIe'leIDIH It OTBeTCrneHHOCTI1
sa HapyweHl-1H  TeJlbCTBa y,!\eJIeHO 60JlbWCJe
BHHMaID1e 2 . JJ;OJDKeH 6e3CYrKa3HO pa6araTb MexaHJ13M BblHBJIeHJ1H If IIpe-
Ce'leHJ1R npeCT)'IIJIeHJ1i-1 JfJII1 a.v;MJ1IDIcTpaTJ1BHbIX npaBOHapyrnemrn, a
TaIOKe HaKa3aHJ1J1 3a HJ1x.
IIpM 3TOM B BO,IJ;HOM CTpaT€nn1 ;0:0 2020 r. 38.JIOmeHO 
caHl\111i-1 sa 8J];MJfHJ'!C'Ip8TW1Hb1e npaBOHapyllIemrn, Bbipa3MBlllJ11ecH B
HaHecewrn: ro Bpe,[la BO,!\HOMY<POH,!\Y. KaKnp€',l\CT8BJUle-r-
CH, HJ13KJ1e wrpa4>HbIe CaHKl\IDf 06ecu;eIDWalOT 3Ha'leHl1e ,IJ;eHTe1IbHOCTI'1
 opraHoB,  ElfHQBHbIX K OTBeTCT-
BeHHOCTK CJIeJ10BaT€JlbHO, M>00IMJ138.1\1-1.RHaKa3aHWI, He
IIJ;aJI 3Ha'IJIIT€JlbHOM)' 3IroJI()I11'1€CKOMY yIIJ;ep6y, eCTb HeCIlpaBe;Q.lIl1ElOe
npI1HJOftelD1e I1pJtpO,lIOOXp8.HHOi1 <PYHKU;Irn rDCy,IJ;8pCTBa.
Ha.r:lo npi13HaTb, '1TO TOJIbKO peaJIbHoe  3KtJ1J::!MJ1t1eCf
CJIlUI11Mb1X wrpacpHbIX C8IJ:Kl.g:ui, OCJIOmHHlOlI{ee cpl1HaHcoBoe 1IOJI(J)R'ffiJ1e
xo3ffii:CTB}'IOl1\ero cy6heKTa, n03BOmrI' ,lJ;oOm'hCJ1 ycnexOB B ;o:eJIe oxpaHbI
BO;f.l1MeHHo TaKOM IIQ,lJ;XO,!\ 3aJlOmeH B Bo,WIOM CTpaT€rn:Jf ,lJ;O 2020 r.
I'pMK,1I;8HCKO-np8BoBIDI O"TBt'TC'IBt'IUIOMb.lIocJIe;QCTffim HapyweHI-1i1
.r:\OroBopOBBO,IJ;Ol1OJIb3OBa.HJ1H npeAyCMOTpeHbI B CT. 18 BK «OrBeTCT-
BeHHOCTb CTOpoH ,!\OI'OBop8 BO,[IOIICI.:JIb3CIJ8H. Ha3BaHHaH CTaTbH He
JfMeJI8 8H8JIOl'OB B IIp€)KHeM BK pq:, 1995 r. IIOfIBJIeHJ1e T8KOM CTaTbI1 Bbl-
pam8€T TeH,!\eHWOO paSBm'IDI BO)J.HOro npaBa: npeBpallleHJ1e ,lJ;oroBopa
BD,lPII(JJIb3f) 1:13 BTOpoCTeIIeHHoro B K.JIKR€BOi:i: MexaHJ13M peryJll1-
poBaHJ1R. IIpI1 3TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb, IIpe,lJ;YCMOTpeHHaJ1 B BK , OT
I eTeHbBepXO!!HoroCyA1>P<b.I999 NI.
2)f(eSJ18KOfj3.H.oxpaHBnpHPOAHOCpe,!J,blBpauI1'I.M.:
3AO«EH3Hec.OUKOna., 1997.
3 pr 2009. N! 154. 2OilBrycTa: 2009. N. 156. 21 <lElf)'CTa
-68-

npMpo,!\bI rpam,IlaHCKO-npaBOBaJL B CBOlO O'iepe,!\b, BO)J;lH>-npaBOBOii OT-
BeTCTBeHHOCTM He cyIl\eCTByeT
B CT. 18 BKPCPYKa3aHbI CaHKqI1M (rreHM) sa HapyrneHMe ycJIoBIDiTJ{>-
roBOpa BO.n;OIIOJIb30BaHHH a I1JJaTHOCTI1. ITeHfl Ha'illCJUIe'TCH Ha'illHafl co
CJIeJlYlOero 3a onpe1J;€JI€HHbIM B 1J;OroBOP€ EIQl1OIIO.1Ib3( )J;II€M BH€-
C€IDIH IIJIaTbL 3aKoHo,!\a'reJlb oIIpe,!\eJUIe'T pa3Mep lIeHei-i:: 1/150 craBKI1
pe4ootaHCt1pOBaHJ1Jl DeHTpa.mH::ro 6aHKa pcp, ,leiiC'J'BYKll-l€j;i Ha 1J;eHh yrr-
JIaTbI IHJ('J1. O.n;HaKO 3Ta cyMMa He ;QOJImHa npeBbIlliaTb 2/10 rrpou;eHTa 3a
1ii,o;eHhrrpocpo'llU:l. BCBolOo<,repe,lJ;b, craBlta pect:U1HaHCJ1poBaHi-UI-
rrpou;eHTHaH CTaBKa, IIO,!:l IWTOpyIO EaJilC POCCI1JiI oC}'ll{ecTBMeT Kpe,IJ;l1-
TOBaID1e .npyrnx Kpe,lJ;J1THh!X OL )J;aHHoe KpE'Jl,JrroBaHMe 11Me-
lI)'eTcH pe1:II1H8HCHpoBaHJI€M 11 HBJIHe'TCH O,!:\ID1M 113 OCHOBHbIX M€TO,!:IOB
.J\eHemHO-Kpe,zc:rrnmIIIOmITMI-rn SaRKa POCCIDL IIplfEe]:\eHHbIe nOJlo
HllfH CO,!:l€J»l\8.TCH B CT. 4, 35, 40 41e,!:lepaJIbHoro 3aKOHa OT 10 l1iOJIfl 2002 f.
NQ86-00 «0 lXeHTpaJIhHoM 6aHKe PoccHffClrii epaIJ;l1M (BaRKe Poc-
clm)" 1. IIpM ::rrOM, lIopocanICKOMY3a:KOHOTeJlbCTBy. CTaBKa petl>MHaH-
C>1poBaHHH HBJIHe'TC.fI6a3oi-i: lfC'ntcJJelUUi MHaHCOBhlX caHKqJnl
B BK P 1B8.IOTCH >1 CaHKqI1>1 (mrpaciJhl) 3a IIpeBbIIlle-
Hllfe 3a1qJeIIJIeHHl:lX B .n;orOBope BO;:J;OIIOJIb30BaHHH o&beMOB >13'bflTHH (3a-
6opa) BO)J.h1. ITpoBHHlfBnnriiCR BOAQII0nh30BaTeJIh OM3aH yruraT>1Tb
wrpa B lIH111KpaTHOM pa3Mepe CTaBI-rn IIJIaTbI 3a 1I000030BaH>1e BO,!:\HblM
06'heKTOM.
B CT. 18 BK p. KaK yme CKa3aHO, YCTaHaBIDffialOTCRlIeID-I J1 nrrpa-
q>bI. IToCJIe,!\H>1e, cornaCHO CT. 330-333 rK pcp, BXOAlIT B rrOH.IITJ1e He-
YCTOfua1- 0,!:\H01'O Jf3 cIIoco6oB 1fl o6H3aTeJIbCTB.lIeycroimml
npJ.13HaeTCH onpe.ne.neHHaH 3aROHOM I1.ID1 ;QOroBopOM .n;eHemHa.fl C)'MMa,
KOTopyIO ;QOJDtCHI1K 06H3aH yrmaTI1Tb Kpe,!J;l1TOpy B CJIy'i8.e H€l1CroTIH€-
HI1flI1.ID1 ro HCIIO.JIHeHIfH 06H3aTeJIhCTBa, B 'lacrHOCT>1, B
CJIy'i8.e rrpocpO'lK11 I1CIIOJIHemuI. ITo 'I'p€6ooamuo 06 yrmaTe Heycrcii:lcl1
Kpe,!\t1TOp He 06H3aH ,!\OKa3hIBaTh npH'llrneHHE:' eMY y6bITKOB. Kpe.l1wrop
He BIIpaBe Tpe60BaTb ynJIaTbI HeycTOfua1, eCJII1 ,lJ;OJIiKHJ1K He HeCeT OT-
BeTC'IB€HHOCTII 3a H€UCIIOJIHeHHe I1.ID1 HeHa)1JIell\ee HCIIOJIH€ffif€ 06.f1-
3aTeJIhCTBa.
B rpa)K,!(aHCKI1X npaBOOTHoweHIDIX npaKTI1K)'lOTCH rne co-
fnallleHI1H a HeycrofIKe. O.n;HaKO ,D;onycxaeTC.fI J1 TaR Ha3hlBaeMaR 3aKOH-
HaH Heycroi-i:Ka. Kpe.l1wrop BIIpaBe Tpe60saTb ynJIaTbl HeyCTOfua1, orrpe-
,l\t'JJ€HfI:ii: 3aKOHOM, H€3aBIfCttMO OT 'fOro, IIpe,llyCMOTpeHa Jll1 06.113aHHOCTh
ee ynJIaTbl cornaIlIeID-leM CTOpOlI. ECJD1 3aKOH aTOro He 3anpee'T, pa3-
I C3 P<JI. 2002 N!!28.Cr 2790
-69-

Mep 3aKOHHOH HeyCTOfua1 MOiKE'T 6brrb }'BeJlK'leH COmaWeID1eMCTOpOH.
YIlIepo MOiKE'T npl1'n1HlITbCR CaMMM BOblM o&beK'I'OM. OR npJ:!OOpe-
TaeT 1lJ0pMY «Bpe,Ila" JiI perJIaMeHTKpyt'fCH Kim: BO,!(HbIM, TaK JiI npHpO,!\O-
OXpaHHbIM3aKOHO,IlaTeJIbC'l'EO'l: CT. 68, 69 BK pq:,J:! CT_ n, 78 4>e.r1epa.m,-
Hora3aKOHa «06oxpaHelcpe,!\bI".
I'pa*.!laHe JilKp€rnHe.JJJ1Wl, npll'il1ID1BllIJ1e yw;epo BO,!J;HblMo&b-
eKTaM, B03MelJ.-taKYI' era ,up5poBO.rrbHo .mrt5o B CY,l\eQHOM nopil,llKe B cocrr-
Be"fCTBJ'n1 C TaKcar.rn: J:! MeTO)J;J1KaMM JilC'IY!CJIellYlJl yw;ep5a, I1pJI'iI1lHIHDr
BOblM OO'beKTaM, a npJII J1X OTCyrcTBJIIM - no l$aKTJII'-IecKJIIM aaTpaTaM
Ha BOCCTaHOBJI£'HJft' BO,!J;HbIX 06'beK'I'OB C }"-IeTOM mHeCeHHbIX yObITKOB, B
TOM'llfCJIeBbIrO,!(bl.
I1CKt-1 0 IOCM1eHcaI.tJIIIII Bpe,!\a.o cpe,!\e, IIpIPlJIIHeHHJI'O Ha-
pyweRJlleM 3aKOHO,!J;aTeJIbCTBa B oOJIaCTJil OXpaHbI oKpymarow;eH cpe,!\bI, B
TOM 'llfCJle BO,!(Hora aaKOHO,IlaTeJIbCTBa, Mor)'T 6brrb IIpe,l\'bSlBJleHbl B Te-
'1eHJlle 20 JIeT. CY.lI Mome'!' B03JlOmwrb Ira OTBeT'-IJ1Ka oOJl3aHROCTH no BOC-
CTaHOBJJeHJ-OOlrapymeHHoroCOCTOflHHflCpe,l1bl3ac'-IeTero
Cpe,l\CTB B COOTBeTCTBm1 C npoeKTOM EIOCC'TaHCEllf'I'eJIbHbIX pa6crr.
J1cKH a B03Mell.\eIDll-1 yw;ep!5a, I1pI1'-IJnI£tIlD'(j BO.II,Hb1M OObeK'l'aM, npe,!\D-
SIBJI.mOTCRfrocY,!J;apcTB€HHbIMJ:IopraHar.rn:11CIDJIHI-1'I'eJ
HOHBJIaCTl-{(B'laCTH<:x:rn,)JfJillOpraHar.rn:caHJIITapHo-
NeCKOro Ha,£\3Opa. MeTOj\IOO1 1fI pa3Mepa Bpe,IJ,a,
I1}:WnrneHlKI'O BCJIe)\C'TBMe HapyrneHJIIJI BO)I,HOro  yr-
BeJ"K,lllliOTCRBnopJI,[\Ke,lIpaBJIITeJIbC'TBOMPq:,.
ITOCTaHOBJIeHJl!€M lIpaBMTeJIbCTBa PCPar 4 HOJIf)PJI 2006 f. NQ 639 «Ono-
pHJJ;Ke yrnepm,neHJIIJI MeTO.D;WIG1 ICJJelD1JI pa3Mepa Bpe,!\a., npWOOleH-
Hora BO.II.HbIM oO'beK'l'aM BCJI€,l\C'I'ffi1e HapyweHJIIfI BO)I,HOra 3aJOC)HO,IlaTeJIbCT-
Ba" ycTaHOBJIeHO. '-I'I'Q MeTOmma ttc'lJ1CJIeI!IDI pa3Mepa Bpe,!J;a,
npWOOleHHora BO.II.HbIM OO'beKTaM BCJI€,l\CTBJlle HapymeHJIIfI BO)I,HOra 3aKo-
.pa3pa5aTbIBaeTCRJ:!MmlIIpI'lpOthlPoCCID11.
)Lrmpea.m1:3alJ;J1H03lffi:QeHHblX IIpaBOBblX HOpM 6bL1lJ:!H npMKa3 MI1-
IillCTepc-rna npwJXJ,D;HbIX pecypcoB Jil3fOC\1JU[1n1 PCPor 13 anpeJIH 2009 f. NQ87
«06yrBep*.!leHJllMMeTo)J;J1KJ1tcJIem1Jlpa3Mepa Bpe,!\a., npWlJ1HeHHoro
BO.II.HbIM OO'beKTaM BCJIe,l\C'I'EII Hapywemrn BO)I,HOra aaKOHO.llareJIbCTBa,,2.
ITo,!( HapyweHl1€M BO)I,HOra aaKOHO,!(aTeJIbCTBa nOHMMlleTCH, B TOM 'lJIICJie,
Hapymemle npaBJIIJI3KCnJIYaTaLtJlll1 ICTBeHHblX CJilCTeM, coopy-
)t{eIDDf J:! YCTpoi1C'rB, a TaKiKe npl1 aBapwlX Hfl npe.n;rrpHJITlfHX, TpaHC-
nOpTe J:!,l\jJyrnX omeKTOB, CBH3aHHblX co C6POCOM Bpe,!\HbIX (3arpH3mno-
1 C3P<112006.NI!46.Cr.4791
2 pr 2009 N!!113(4937).24HIOH
-90-

) Bell\ecTB B BO,!\Hbrn 06'beKT, B pe3yJlbTaTe KOTOporO npoH30lllIIO sa-
IpH3HeRIfe, sacopeHHe, fe BO)I.HOro q,oH,r\a
UC'n1CJl€ID1e pa3Mepa Bpe,!J;a OCHOBbIBaeTCfl Ha KameHCarI,t:)lillOOI
npmn:pme O'--leHKl1I:1 B03Meli\eHI-fR pa3Mepa Bpe)J;a no BeJIWUme saTpaT,
,!J;JlH ycrnHOBJIeHIDI 4>aKTa npwnrneHI-fR Bpe,!J;a J1: ycrpaHe-
HJ1.fI ero npM'II:IH 1:1 nOCJIe B TOM 'll1CJIe saTpaT, CBfl3aHHbIX C pas-
pa6urnoi1 IIpO€KTHO-CMeTHOii BI, 1:1 saTpaT, CBH3aHHbIX C
JU1KBI-fAa'--\l'!e ,lJ;ony1l\eHHoro HapyrneHl-fR1:I BOCCTaHOBJIeHIteM COCTOHHI-fR
BO,!\HOro 06'beKTa ,!J;O nOKasaTeJI('ii, Ha6JllO,!\aeMbIX ,!J;o BbrnBJI('HHJIU Hapy-
IIIeHt:lfl, a Ta1OKe.&JIH yC'rpaHeHJ1.fl nOCJIe,lJ;cTBl-1fi: HapyrneHI-fR.
J1c<n£1i2ID112 pasMepa Bpe,!\a MOmeT ocyIl\ecTBJllITbCH HCXO,!\H 113 4>aK-
Ttf'IecKMX 3a'IpaT Ha BOCCTa.HJB.II€f HapyrneHHoro COC'T'I)ffiIJtfI BO,!\HOro
06'beKTa, a TaIOKe BcourBeTCTBffi1 C npoeKTaMHBOCC'l'aH(ErreJIbIIbIX pafur.
1IIJI"HapH1lH OTBCTCTBCIDIOCTb. 3Ta OTBeTCTBeHHOC1b npl1l'l'le-
HHeTCfl sa cOBeprneHHbIe ,l1;MCQIillJIJ1HapHble IIpOC'iJ'IIKI'I npH J1CIIO.1IIIeIDD
pa6OTHt:lKaMJ1, a paBHO .l\Pyrl1MJf .IDIl.\fiMJ'1. CBQMX TPY,!J;OBbIX 06H38.HHOC-
Te, B TOM 'll1cne B 06JIaCTI1 BO)I.HOro "ID3HJ1cTBa..
OrBeTCTBeHHOCTb IIpe,!J;YCMaTpHB8eTCH COOTlleTCTB}'lOllJ;I1MJII CTaTbfl-
MJ1 TpY,lJ;OBOro Ko,!\eKca pcIJl. MepaMJ1 )J;IfCQJrnmrnapHbIX B3bICKaHIm: MO-
ryr 6bITb: 3aM€'UlHt:le, BbIrOBOp, )'BOJIbHeHl1e C pa60TbI (CT. 192 TK PcIJ).
B3bICKaHJ1.flHaJIaraKYI'CHpyKOBOWrreJIeMIHaIJO,lJ;'lllHeHHbIX
eM)'TIocnyiK6e pa6onnIKOB.PaclID1pmbnepeqeHbB3bIc-
KaHt:lii sanpeIlJEO.
.lV-tcQI1IIJII1HapHbIM IIpOCTyIIKOM pa6crrnJ1Ka MOryr 6bITb n})K3H8Hbl
'IOJIhKO TaKl1e ero npo'TI1BOIIpaBHbIe ,lJ;€HcTBu.H I1JUiI 6e:meiicTBJre, KaropbIe
Henocpe.t\C1EeHlI CBfI3aHbI c J1CIlOJIHeHJIeM JiM TPY'!\OBbIX 06HsaJrn0cTeii.
He MroKeT, Hanpl1Mep, C'UITaTbCfl ,l1;MCQI1I1JIJ1}IapHbIM npocTynKOM {)1'Ka3
pa6crrnJ1Ka 01' BbllIOJllieHJ1.fl 06CTBeHHoro nopyt3:eHIDI I1JUiI mpyrneHt:le
HM npaBI:IJI nOBe,!\eHllil B ofaQecTBeHHbIx MeCTax 1:1 Tn HeltUJOJIH€HIfe J-IJIJ:!
HeHa,u,rre:maIQee I:ICIIOJllieHt:le Tpy,!\OBbIX 00r0alnr0creU: npl13HaeTCH BI1HOB-
HbIM,eCJll1pa6oTHI1K,D;eik.'T&EaJ:rYMbIlliJIeHHOl:IJIMnO
He Mo:IKeT C'llITaTbCR BI1HOBHbIMHeBHIDmI€tD1e J-IJIJ:! H
BHTIO.YIHeHIfe 06H38.HHOCTei1: no IIplfllHH8M, He 3aBl-1CRI1tI-1M OT pa60THlilKa
(HanpHMep, 113-3a OTcyTCTBJ.-IR Heo6xo,nm.n,Jx Ma:repJ1a.IIOO J1JIJII OPY)U1i1:
IIpOH3,113-3aHe,!\OCTaTO'-IHoi1lJlpa6OTHWKa, eroHe-
TPY,nocnocOOHOCTK, O'I"ryTCTBIUI Ha,u,rrelKaII.\ero I:IHCTp}'KTama 1:1 T.n.).
PasJllf'laIOT 06Il\)'IQ 11 CII€L{HaJIbH}'lO ,AI1CQI1IIJII1HapH)'IO 0TBeTC"I'B€H-
HOCTb. 05IQaRpHaRO'J'Be'I"CTBeII peryJll1pyeTCH Tpy,AG-
1 C3P<t1.2OO2 N!!1('i 11 Cr3
-91-

BblM KO.I\eKCOM PcIJ H pacnpOCTpaHHeTCfI Ha BCeX paOO'lIDlKOB opraHl-f3a-
,KpoMeTeX,,&JIHKOTOpbIXYCTaHOBJJeHap-
HaH OTBeTCTB€HHOCTb. CnewmJIbHafl ,Ai1CL,mJIJ1HapHaH OTBeTCTB€HHOCTb
n ycraaB.MJ111 I10JICQfteHlUIMJI 0 .I\IlIIJIIme}J,JIJI HeKOTO-
pbIX OTBeTCTB€HHblX KaTeropMi1 paOOTHI1I\OB. CnewtaJibHaH ,Ai1CUMITJIJII-
HapHaJi 0TBe'I'CTJ3eHH0 oI5yCJlOBJJeH8 cneI4J1KOJ1 TPY.I\OBblX 4IYHK-
. BbUJOJIHffeMblX <JTI1!v1M paOOrnMKa!v1M. H83BaHHaH OTBE'I'CTBeHHOCTb
npeJlyCMaTpWOOeT PM 6o.rIee CTpOfl1X, no CpaBH€HHIO C oI5Il-\eii: ,Ai1CL\I1I1-
JIHHapHoif OTB€TCTB€HH()(."f M€p B3bI0W.HHJI, a Ta1Ot\e B HeltOTophlX
c.nyqaax pacurnpfleT nOHJrm€ .I\lICW1I1JIJ1H8fJHOro npOCTynKa. H€KOTOphl€
OC06eHlIlx.'TII npHBJJ€':iemm: It ,Ai1JIJ-1HapHOi1 OTBeTCTB€HHOCTH YCTa-
HOBJJeHbI }J,JIJI roCY.I\apcTBeHHbIX CJIYm81l1;HX.
HeOOxo.n;J1MO ,Ai1CIJ;HIIJIillI8PHYW arneTCTB€HHOCTb ltaK $>pMY IOpH,IJ;Wle-
CKOi1 OTBeTCTB€HHOC'rn OTJIJ1'mTb err CTrB€TCTB€HHOCTIf, i
HOpMaMJ1 a)J;MHIDfCTpaTI1BHoro npasa. Omt pa3.lil1'ialOTCfl: no xapaKT€py
np8BOHapywelll1i1, 3a ItUlUpble HaC'rynaeT Ta I1JIJ1 J1Hafl 0'IEeTC'IEeHH0C
no cy6DeKT8M, l1MelOnpaBO HaJIaraTb B3bICKaID1fl; no KPyry.1ll1l.\, 100-
TOpble MOryr 6bITb npHBJJE"IeHbI K 0TBeTCTEIeHH0C' a T8IOKe no BlUI;aM
nKID1MMepB3bICKaHJ.mBar.rrwrnearrnapHoi1ar-
B€"I'C'IEeHlJr1, :KOTQp8.JI, ltaKym€OTM€'ffiJIOCb, H8CTJIlaeT 3a HapYW€HH€
TPY.I\OBOi1,Ai1I, a,w.oornCTpaTHBHaHurBeTC'TJ3€HlJO HaCT)'II8eT
3a COBepureID'le 8J1M1-'1ID'1C'IpaTIIBHOIU npoCTynKa, npe.uyCMOTpeHHOro
RoAII P<P. ,lLHCLJ;J1IIJIJ1HapHaJiarneTCTBeHHOCTb He yc:rpaIDI€T a..n;MJ1HI1CT-
paTJilBHYJO(I1JIJ1J1HY1O)
CWII1JIJrnapHble B3b1CKaHHR HaJiaraKYI'CH a,.nMHHHc'IpaqJ-1eii TOJIbKO
TOi1 cp1, C KOTOpOi1 pa60TI1J1K COCTOI1T B TJJYJlOBbIX np8BOOTHO-
W€ID1HX. q'f() KaCaeTCH npaaa npl1MeIDITb a,w.oornCTpaTIWHble M€pbl
B3b1CKaHHR, TO OHH OcyIL\€CTBJIHIOTCH Clli'Q>I3JIbHO yrIOJIHOMO'IeHHbIM op-
raHOM I1JUI JillQOM, C KOTOpblMH np8BOHapyiill1TeJIb He CBR3aHTpY.I\OBbl-
MJ1 0TH0IlIffiJ1RMJII (HaIIpJ1M€p, rocYJlapc'I'B€lIllUe I1HCIleR'l"Cp>I B o6.rrac-
TH oxpaHbl npHpoiU>I, opraHbl MBJJ: POCCIm 11 ,lip.). EcJUI OCHOBHb!M
BI-f.I\OM paTHBHorO B3ldCKaHJ1H HB.I1fleTCH nrrpa4l, 'f() urrpa41
KaK BlUI; B3bICKaHIfH 3aKOHO.I\aTeJIbCTBOM a Tpy.ne He .I\OnyCKaeTCH. IIo-
:mJM)' IlITpacp He MOm€T 6bITb npI1MeH€H 3a COBeprneHHe m1CWmmrnap-
HOro npOCTynKa.
ITpaBo BbIDOpa looHKpenroii Mepbl ,Ai1C'--\ffi1JU1H8pHOro B3bICKaHHR 113
'lHCJIa npe.IIyCMOTp€HHbIX aaKOHO)WT€JIbCTBOM nplrr 8JJ:MHHHC-
TpaL\l1H, Km'Opafl .nOJDKHa yqHTbmaTb CTeTIeHb THmeCTII COBepllIeHHoro
npoC'IJ'IIKa,JIbCTBa,npHKOTOpbIXOHCOBeprneH,
lL\€e IIOBe,l\€HJte pa6OTHMKa.
-92-

rnaBa 4
roCytlAPCTBEHHOE ynPABnEHHE
B OI;nACTH BOtlHOro X03itCTBA
(nPABOBbIE AtnEKTbl)
1. 06l1jA XAPAKTEPHCTHKA YnPABEHH
Hcnonb30BAHHEM H OXPAHoti BOI\
OpraHbI ynpaBJICHIIJL rocy,l:\apCTBeHH0e yrrpaBJI€HJ1€ B 06.rraCTl1 HC-
nOJlli3OBaID1H 11 OXpaHbI BOJ\ ocyrn;ecTBJIRlOT MmrnCTepCTBO npHpoJlHbIX
pecypcOB H :3IOCI.ImDI Pip (MIDrnpHpOI POCCI1J1).  areHTCT-
BO BOJlHbIX pecypCOB (POCBO.n;pecypcbl) 11 cI>eJ\epaJIbHaH crrymfia no HaJl30-
py B c4>epe npnpo,nom.JIb3(EalOO (Pocn). KaK JI3BeC'I'fV,
 PacCHH oeCTBJ1HeT HOpMaTI1BHo-npaBOBOe pel'yJD1po-
BaHJl!e BOJIHbIX aJ'HOllEHHi.i 3a PocBo.npecypcaMl1 3aKpE'I1JJflKJ oC)'llIe-
CTBJI€IDIe clJymcrJ;J-ri1 no OKa3aHJl!lO rocy,l:\apCTBeHHbIX ycnyr H ynpaBJIe-
Hmo clJe,!\epaJlhHblM "MYIl\eCTBOM. B <ffi.CTHOCTH, I1MeHHO 3TOMY
AreHTCTBY ,l:\OBepeHb! BJIaJ\eHHe, nOJIb30BaHHe 11 pacnopH:lKeIDIe clJe,!\e-
paJIhHhIMM BO,wn.IMH 06'beKTaMH, 3aKJllQ'-IeHJl!€ J\OroBOpoB BO)\OIlO1Th3O-
Bamm, roCy.zJ;apCTBeHHhrn yqe'T BOJ\ 11  COOpy:meHJ'IJf.
B CBOIO O'-lepe,!\b, Pocn})HpOJJ;lla./J,py ,IJ;OBepeHO ocyw;eCTBJIeIDIe KOHTpo-
AA 11 Ha,!\30pa 3a CacTMIDI€M, Hcr1Ol!b3OBaHIteM 11 oxpaHOii BO,IJ;HOro 4JoH-
J\a, 3a 6e30nacHOCTblO rrc. rocy,l:\apCTBeHH0e ynpaBJIeIDIe B o6JIaCTI1
BO,IJ;HblX 0'TH0nanrn: np€,lJ;!IOJ1arae'T ynpaBJIeHH€ Co6cTBeHHOCTbIO Ha BO)\-
Hhle 11 I\OJ\OX03HiiicTBemn: 06'beKTbL
Ba:IKHeHwaJl clJ)'HKLI11JI rocY,l:\apcrnelilmrQ ynpaBJIeHJ1JI - n.rraHHpoBa-
ID1eJICIIO.1Ib3OBaHBoJIHblX06'beKTOB-
CH nocp€,QCTBOM paspa60TKH CX€M KOMllJl€KCHOro HCrIOJIb3OB8.IDJlI1 ox-
paHbl BOJIHbIX pecypCOB.
YC'IBHaBIDIBaIO'I'CfI TalOKe JIJ1MI1TbI BO}JPJIJJIb30B3.HI1JI, npe):\C'I'aBJIfDO-
lLtHe co6oi1 npe,QeJIhHO ,IJ;onyCTHMble 06'beMbII13'bH1WI BOJlHbIX peCypcOB
J1IThI c6poca CTO'lHh1X BOA KpoMe TOm, JIM! Ka)K,[\oro cyD'beKTa POCCUH--
CKOM cI>e,IJ;epaWIl1 y<:raH8BJIJIBaKTrCH KBOTbI113'bHTI1JI (3a6opa) BO.
YnpaBJIeffife HCnOJlb3008HUeM 11 oxpaHm1: BO)I.HOro clJOH,!1a KaK npH--
HaJ\Jle:maIl\ero rocy,[lapcTB}' :/KJ13HeHHO Ba:IKHoro pecypca, Tpe6yeT no-
CTOHHHOI"O IJOJIY'-I€HIIR CBeWRIrii 06 JfX COCTQfIHJUf, Hafimo,IJ;€HtfH 3a HMMI1,
-93--

'ITO AOCTIJIaeTCH nocpe,!\CTBOM yqeTa H peecrpa BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTOB, MO-
lD1TOpHHra 3a J1X COCTOHHHeM H KOHTpoJlH (HalI30pa) B 06J1aCTI-f BOlIHblX
O1HOlll('HJm.
BamHoe npaK'IWll2CKOe 3HaqeHl-fe B OO.rraCTl1 BO,!I;Hb1X arooIIEHJrii J1Me-
lOT ap,MJlliJlrrpaTHBHbIe perJIaMeHTbI IilCnOJIHem1R rocy,!\apCTBeHHblX
4JYHKQIlli IiI OKa3aHl-fH rocyMpCTBeHHblX yc.nyr. B oo.rraCTII BO)I.HOro XO-
3Hitcrna MOryr ObITb npIilHmbI8,!\MJ1mIC-rpaTJ1BHble perJIaMeHTbI no npe-
,AOL'KlBJleIDOO BO,!UIblX o6'beRTOB B m.1Ib3OBaHJre (npl-fHmY!e COOTBeTCTBY-
IOIl\I1X pewemlit HJlI-f 3aKJIIO'IeHl1e .QorOBopoB BO.QonOJlb30BaHI1H),
Be,!\eHI1lOBOlIHoropeecrpa, npe.memBJIemOOCBe.QemmOCOC'IUHHJfilBO,!l-
HOro OO'beKTa. Bce 3TI1 perJIaMeHTbI .QOJDKIIbl BbIpamaTb IilC'lepIIbIBaIO-
I4I1i1 aJITOpWrM ,!\€HcTmu1:, IilC:KJi]{Jtl8IO I!C€EO:3MCOKHbIe yn}'ll-leHJ1Jl,
rrpoC'ieTbl H Heo,!\HoaH8'iHoC'm.
m.e B ytJIOBKHX PblHOQHOit 3KOH0MJ1Kl1 Y roCY.r\apcrna - co6cTBeIi-
HJ1Ka BO.IJ;HOro $JH.!\a coxpaHIfID1Cb HeMaJIble II03MO)KH()C'fJI.QJUI IIpHMoro
ynpaBJleHI1H BQlI(JX03Hi1CTBEtIIIbIM KOMIIJIeI«DM POCCJ1H. B TO me speMR
MHOI"OO6pa3Jft' iPoPM co6cwemroCTY! Ha IlC Iill1Hb1e BQJ:IOX03HfIel'BEtIHbE
COOP}')KeHl-f$i Tpe6yeT OT roCYMpCTBa 60JIee m6Ki1X flO)J;XO)J;OB, B 'iaCTHO-
CTI1, B lIJIaHe CTI1MJIDIpOBaHJ1Jl 'i8CTHbIX BO,I],OI1OJIb3CI3TeJleit no MO.IJ;ep-
lD13aY! Te'rnOJlODrn BQI:IOIIOJIb3OBHID!. IvlmIDle BonpoCbI B Oo.rraCTII IilC-
nOJlb30BaHI1H JII OXp8HbI BO,!\ MOryr JII ,ll;OJDKHbI pewaTbCH CaMl-fMY!
BO,lII)IIOJIb3()BTeJUlMl1, J1X opraHJ13al{J:1HMJoI JIJ160 TeJlHMI1
CQBM€CTHO C roCY.r\apCTBeHHbIMJII JII M}'RIfi.tI«18JIbHbIf opraHaMl-1 BJIaCTl1.
B Ka'ieCTBe cBoe06pa3Hoi1 «IIJIOI.qa)J;KJII» .r\JU'I napTHepCl{f)l'O, KOJIJIe:KTI1B-
HOro peryJlI1p0BaHI1.fI I!O,I:PX03m1:cTBetrnoii ,lJ;eHTE'JIbHQCTJII yme CJlC»t\J1-
JIJIICb JII ycnelIIHo npJIIMeHHJlJ-fCb 6acceibwebre .III£1nOCl-br ynpa6.i1£1-iWl eoo.
1i'b!M,
BacceiIHoBbJe MeTO)Uo1 ynpawreIDrn. Kmo'ieBOe 3HaQeHJlle WIH oxpa-
Hbl JIII1CI1O.1lb3OBaH BO,ll; JllMelOT 6acceU1i06'bLe CXeM'br  uc-
7/.O.II.b3CIOO' U oxpa1i'bt eOO1i'btX OOoeh'11J08. .QemeJIhHO(."I'l6aCCeiiHOBblX
COBeTOB, oxpaHa M8JIbIX BO)J;HblX ofueKTOB.
Baccefun31de CXeMbI JroMI1JIeKQfOTO J1QlOJJb3OB8IIH JII OXpaHbI BO,ll;-
HbIX ofueKTOB BKJllO'ia1OT B ceOH CI1CTeM8TI13H]XJB8Hl1He MaTep11aJIbI 0
COC'IOSIHJ'llI BOlIHblX 06'beKTOB JII 06 J1X JIICnOJlb30BaHJUL OHJII.HBJlHlOTCH oc-
HOBOit  KaK BQl\OXOOfriiCTBeHHblX MelX:I1pmmrli, TaK JII
Meponpl1.H'IW1: no oxpaHe BO,!\HbIX OO'beKTOB, pacnOJlOmeHHblX B rpaHI-f-
qax pe'iHblX 6acceiiHoB. II03TOMY Ha3BaHHble cxeMbi 06.HaaTeJIbHbI.r\JU'I
c}:Ie,!\ep8.JIbHbIX 1:1 pent:aIaJIbHbIX opraHOB rocy.r\apcTBeHH(Ji1 BJIaCTJII, opra-
HOB Mecrnoro caMoynp8BJ1eHl-fH.
CxeMbiIroMIIJleKCHOI' HCII)JIb3()88HJ1J1 JII oxpaHbI BO,!\HbIX 06DeKTOB
paapaoaTblBalOTCH B l!eJIHX onpe,!1eneHJ1Jl  aH'IpOllOI'€HHO
-94-

Harpy3Kl-f Ha BO)J;HbIe o\h.eKTbI 11 mTpe6HocTeif B BO pecypcax B
neJXYIe lITJ1Be
CXeMhI npe,!\YCMaTpI1BaIOT TalOKe:
- f.\eJIf2BldI2 nOKa3aTeJllf R<\'lecTBa BO.D;bI B BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTax Ha nepJII-
OJ]; ,!\efi:CTBM 3TJIIX CXeM;
- nepe'leHb CTBeHHbIX MepOIIpJIIHTJIIi.1 J1 Meponpl1Jl'I'Ri1 no
oxpaHe Boofu,eKTOB;
- BOJ\HHbIe 6a.rraHCbI, npe,!\Ha3Ha'leHHbIE' .&JUi oIteHKJII KO-
JIJll'-IeCTBa JiI CTenelD1 OCBOI2HJIR ,!\OCT)'IIHbIX AJUI JilCnOJIb30Baffi1H BO
pecypCOBBrpalD1I$.x pe'lHbIX6accei1HOB I1npE'.[\ cofu" pac-
'leTblnc:npe6Hocr€ii BO,n:OTI0JIb30BaTeJlei1: B BO pecypcax no cpalme-
HIDO c ,IJ;OCTyrrnblMJ'!,l\JIfl JilCIIOJIb3(JB8IDIf BQ)J;HbIMJil pecypcaMJil B rpoofJII-
I$.X pe'lHbIX 6acceillioB, no,n:6accei1HoB,  Y'-IaCTKOB
npw pa3JIl1'ffibIX yclIOBlfJIX BO)J;HOCTY! (c Y'ieTOM HepaBlICMeplioro pacnpe-
,.[\eJlellJlIJi nOBepxHOCTHoro 11 nO)];3eMHoro CTOKOB BO)]; B pa3JIl1'lHbIe nepJII-
O)J;bI, Teppl1TopHa.JlhHOro nepepacnpe.llE'J!eHWI CTOKOB rnBepXHOCTHbIX
BOA, IfiIOJIH€HIDI BO,!\HbIX pecypcOB nO.I\3eMHbIX BO)J;HbIX otTheIITOB);
B cxeMaX npe,!\YCMaTpI1BalOTCJI TaKme JlI1MMThl 3a60pa (J13'bJITJIIH)
BO)J;HbIX pecypCOB 113 BO;:J;HOrO o6DeKTa JiI JIJ1MY!TbI c6poca CTO'lHbIX BO,!\,
COCYrBeTCTByro HopMaTI1BaM R<\'IeCTBa, B rpaHl1I$.x pe'lHbIX 6accefi-
HOB, I1QlIfuccetmOB, BO,n:ox()3,fillcrBeHHbIX yqaCTKQB npl1 pa3JIl1'lHbIX YC-
JlOBI1HX BO)J;HOCTI1;
- KBCYrbl 3a60pa (113'hRTI-UI) BO,n:HbIX pecypcOB Jila BO)I.HOro 05'beKTa 11
c5poca CTO'lHbIX BOA, COOTBeTC'!'B}'IOII.\I1X HOpMaTI1BaM Ka'lecrBa, B rpa-
tm::ttax pe'lHhlX 6accei1HOB, no,!\5ac:ceHHoB, BOJ(OXOOJIiicTBeHHbIX yqacr-
KOB IIpJil pa3JIl1'ffibIXYCJlOBI1HXBO,!\HOCTI1 B OTIIcrIIeIDIJ1Orocy6DeK-
Ta PocmJlC}((lf tlJe,!\epawrn;
- OCHOBHbIe l\eJleBble nOfCaaaTeJll1 )'MeHbWeHYIJI HeraTJ1BHbIX noc.ne,!\-
CTBJIIi.1 HaEO,D;HeHJn'i I1,l1pYrux B"'.!10B HeraTJllBHoro BOaJIeioicTBHH BOA, nepe-
'leHb Meponpmrmn, HanpaBJI€HHbIX Ha ,IJ;OCTIDK€'HJile 3TJIIX nOKa3aT€Jleii;
-npeOObeM4IfH3HCOBbIXpecypcoB,IJ;JIJIpe-
8.JIJII3al\JIII CxeM KOMIIJIeKCHOro JICI1UJIb3WaID[ 11 OxpaHbI BO)J;HbIX rneKTOB.
llocraHoB.rreHJleM IIpaBl1TeJlbCTBa ptf! OT 30 ,!\eKa6pJl 2006 r. Nf. 883
5bl.lU1BBe,n:eHblITpaBI-fJIa paspa5()'I1G1, ymep)K,1J;eHllilI1 peaJlI133.l\I'Jf cxeM
KOMlIJleKCHoro J1CIlOJIb3OBaHJI JiI oxpaHbl BO)J;HbIX otTheKTOB, BHeCEtIJ1H
B3TI1CXeMhII.
BacceiiJ-i06'bl£ COi'.I!U'/1I.eHWl 0 BOCCTna'I-WBJ!RI-l.UU U oxpa:H.€ BOO1tbLX 060-
e1CmOB - Ba:mHbIiii: o-npaBCIEIOfi: MeXaHlI3M, IIpJil3BaHHbIfr:
1 C3 f'Q:J. 2007 No!5 CT6S1.
-95-

c6ecne<nITb 6oJIbwyIO rn6i\OCTb J1 .v;J1HaMJ1'lliOCTb rocy,I(aJ)CTBeHHoro yn-
paBneHI1.R B C4>epe BO)I.HOro:xo3.!BtcTBa. ITpaBOBaH OCHOBa :mJro MeXaHJ13-
Ma 6bLJIa 3anOmeHa B CT. 120 BKPcIJ 1995 r. B BKf'tt! 2006 r. He npe,!lyc-
MaTpJ1BaeTCJ'I, HO J1 He 3anpeI1laeTCJ'I caM MHCTI:ITYT 6acceiii:HOBhIX
cornalllemrlii, Cne,l\OBaTeJIbHO, JIIX MC»KHO JII, cy,WI no BCeMY,l\eJIecoo6pa3-
HO 6Y,lJ;eT 3aliJllOlffi.Tb BTIocne,lJ;CTBJilI1.
ITpeJilM)'llJ;ecTBO Ha3BaHHbIX CorJIallHllW: 3aKJll()'laeTcrl B 003MrnKHOCTJII
KOOp)J;MHJiIj)OBa'I'b JII  ycKJIJilJ'lTIO oxpaHe JllBOCCTaHOBJIeHJOO BOP;-
HbIX OO'beKTOB B paMK3X <JKOC>1CTeM KpyIIHbIX pe'lHblX 6acceJ1lJUIJ, BHe 3aIDI-
CJiIMOCTJilar a,JJ;MI1lIHCTpaTHBHbIX rpaHI1Q. B 0CTJiI, 6acceimum.lI2 cor.na-
nIeHJil.fl .&JUi BO)J;HOJ;f CJilCTeMbI ,lICIJDKHb1 mp8.'I'b TY >Ke po.IIb, 'lI"O JII .l10roBOpbl
BO,I\OnoJlb30BaHI-1H WIH or,l\eJlbHbIX BO,!\HbIX OObeKrOB. Ho Y <JTJiIX «6accefulO-
BblX,l\OroBOpoB»,D;aJKe no Ha3BaHJOO cBOeM)' 6o.nee xa-
paIIT€P, qeMY ,l\OroBOpoB1.H.3roTeM6o.JIeeBmKHOnaroMY,
'lI'O Ha11Ia crpaHa pacno.naraeT KpyIIHeInmlMJil no npoTmKeHHOCTJII or llCTO-
KGB,l\O yc'I'bJ'IpeKaMJil EBpa311J1 (Bo.rrra, 05b, F.m1cei1, JIeHa) J1 oo.rra.naeT)'IDI-
1\aJIbH0i1 BQ3M()jt\H()CTb!O peur€HJiI.fI Baa\HeiiunIX 3ItOJO'O-3ltOtt:IM1N€CJt1'IX
npo6.neMHa ocHoBe6acceiiHoBOCQ no cBOeMY xapaKT€pyynpaBJIeID1H. Y,Aaq-
HbIi1 DIllin' 6acceI1HJB(I'() ynpaBJIeID-lJ'l B POCCID-I OTHOCHTCJ'I K COBeTCKOM)'
BpeMeHJ1, HO B ycnoBI1J'IX ,AeMOi\pa PocunI nepBble 
corJJallieHIDl6h1JIJII3aKJIlO'IeHbI B 1993-1994 IT. K 2003 f. J1X 6bLJIO llOp;m1ca-
HO O:KOJio.v;ByX ,A€CHTKOB no Kpyrnrei-1un1M: BO,!\Hb1M CI1CTeMaM POCCI1I1.
B paMKaX GacceftHoBoro corJJallIeHl1H crnmmaml KOOP.l\I'fiIal\J1I:IlliWi
6acceii7ioeNi1 coeem, B i\OTOpbIi1: BXO,!\Ml1 npe,lJ;CTaBm'E'JII1 He TOJIbi\O 4>e-
,Aepa.m.HbIX JIIOpraHoBroCY.l1apcreeHmiiBnaCTI1, HO JIIOp-
raHOB Mecrnoro caMoynp8Bnemrn, 06eCTBeHHbIX ofu.e.D;>memm J'! BO,l\O-
nOJlb30Barenei1. KpoMe TOro,.J1.IDI  6acceJ1HOBbIX corJJallieHIDi
wnycKaJIOCb CXCJ:\8HJte rpam,l\aHaMJ1 JlllOpJ'!,1J;l1'iecKJfMJ'! MI-1 q:.oH,lJ;OB,
cpe,!\cTBa KOTOpblX npe,lJ;H83HBqeHb! ,!\JlR ocyr.u,ecTBJIeHl1.R Meporrpl1J'l11ri.1
no BOreI'aHOBJIeHI J1 oxpaHe BO)J;HbIX ot"n.eKroB.
)Ionroe apeMH ITpaBl-rreJIbCTBOM PcIJ He 6bLJ! onpe,!\eneH CTaT)'C Gac-
ceHHoBbrx COBeTOB. IIpaKTWleCKJiI nepBblM lllaroM B aTOM HaI1paBJIeHJ:DI
CT8.JIO npHWITl1e nOCTaHOBJIeHJil.flllpaBi1TE'JlbCTBB f'tt! OT 30 HoH6pJ'l2006 r.
N:> 727 ,,0 nop.R.nKe C03}J.aHIUI J1.l1eHTe.1IbHJCT101Gacceil:HrebIx COBeTOB»1 J'!
OT 30 HOH6pJ'l 2006 f. N2 728 «0 rn,n;porpa4Jl'lecKOM J'! BQIJ.OX03IDIC1BeH-
HOM paHcamp0BaHlfl,f reppmopm Poccl1J1CI<Ol141e.r1epBltt1tf JII yrB€pjf{,!\e-
HJIJ'! IpaHl1L\ f5accei.iHoBbIx OKpyroB»2.
1 C3P<b 2006. Nsl49(Y. 2). CT 5224
2 C3P<b 2006. No!49(Y. 2). Cr 5225
-96-

BacceifH:.mde COBeTbI C03,!:(alOTC'JI peWelilleM Pocoo.D;pecypco CpoKOM
Ha 5 JIeT, J1X B03r.naBJIfleTp)'KOBO,!\J1TeJlbTePPJ1TOPI1a.JlhHoroopraHa Poc-
BO,!lpecypcoB, 3aceHHH IIpo'I'OKOJIJIIpyIOTCH, a peweIDfH npl1ID1MaIOTCH
IIpoCTbIM 6om.nn roJlOCOB. B HaCToee BpeMJI B ,naHHbIi1 opraH
BXOJ\HT nOMJ1MO Ha3BalllibIX 3al1ll'repeCOBaHHbIX crOpoH 
06'beeHIDI 1:1 06IqMHbi KOpeHHbIX MaJIO'lJlCJleHHbIX Hapo,!\OB. B 6acceH-
HOBbie COBeTbl BKJIJO'ialOTCH, B TOM "tffiCJIe, npe.D;CItlBJ1TeJIJII POcrrpl1po,!\-
Ha;J;3Opa, f'ocTexHa.n;3opa, Poc::rJ.u\poMera, Pocphl6o.no&-rna, PocceJlb-
X03IIaJJ,3Opa JII TJJ;.  JII nepcolW.Jlbllbril COCTaB COBeTOB
yrnepm,!{ae'l'C'JI POCBO,JJ;peCypCaMK no npe,!\CTaBJleHJIIlO 3amrrepeCOBaH-
HbIX C'I'OpoH.
EacceirnoBHe COBeTbl KOMlleTeHTHO 06CY'KAalOT np06JIeMbi BOJ\OXo-
3HHcTBeHHoro ftOMllJleftCa 6acceHHa, Bblpa6aTbmalOT COrJIaCOBaHHyro
6aCCeHHOByro nporpaMMY COBMeCTHbIX ,!\eilc11JJ1M JII npe,!\CTaBJlJllOT ee
COOTBeTCTB)'1OUJ;WM opraHaM BJIacrl1, ":ITO 3aTeM OTpamaeTCH B 6lOJ\-
meTe pa3JII1'IHblX ypOBHeH. Y,!\a":lHbIMl1 6blJll1.l\eHCTBI1H 6acceiiHoBoro
COBeTa no CeBepHoH JJ;BI1He OTHOCJIITeJIbHO npe.u,npJ1H'l1riij: :qeJlJllOJI03-
HO-6yMa:>KHblX ftOM6MHaTOB - OCHOBHblX 3arpJI3HYlTeJIeH pe'lHoro 6ac-
ceiiHa. COBeT cnoccfcrnoBaJI COBepWeHCTBOBaHMlO He TOJlbKO O'lI1CTKI1
BO)!. HO JII CHIDKeHJUO BO.l\Ornrrpe6neHI1H, BHe,D;peIDIlO 06opOTHbIX CJIIC-
TeM Bo,!\ocHa6JK€HHH, H3"bHTIIIO 1:13 TeXHOJlOrl1'leCKOrO :qMKJla TOKCI1'I-
HbiX BeIl\eCTB.
IIoJlO:1Kl-1TeJlbHblti: OlibIT 6acceiiHoBblX corJIallleHldl 1:1 COBeTOB (OHJ1
MoryT 6b1Tb Kaft MeJKTeppMTOpJ-1B.JIbHbIMI1, Taft JiI MeJKBeAOMCTBeHHbIMM)
HaftOllJleH BO MHOrMX CTpaHaX MJ-Ipa. B pJI.lIe eBpC)lJe-WCKMX roCYAapCTB
(JIcnaHHH, t1JpaHl.\HH) 6accei1HoBbJe KOJIJIemaJIbHbIe OpraHbl flBJIJIlOTCH
KJlIO'ieBblMl1 opraHaMM B YIIpaBJIeH1111 BO,!\HbIM X03HiiCTBOM, JIIMelOT Ha
TO COOTBeTCTBe IHe JII a;J;MI1IDfC1'paTI1BHble nOJIHOMO'iHH.
J1x 3Ha":leHJ1e CTQJlb BeJlHKO, ":ITO OHt-I Hepe,D.KO 06pa3HO, HO OTHW)J.b He
npeyBeJIill'ieHHO, I:IMeHywTCJI «6acceiiiHoBbIMJl napJIaMeHTaMJ1». B oc-
HOBe 3TO-W ,!\eMOftpaTl1'IeCKoi1 CHCreMbi YIIpaBJIeHJ1H JleJKYIT npI1BJ1e'le-
Hl1e Ha ooPJrr€TH(Jj,i OCHOBe npeACTamrreJleJ1 Bcex 3al1HTepeCOBaHHblX
B oxpaHe 11 JIICnOJlb30BaHI1t-1 BOA CTOpOH: rocy,!\apCTBeHHblx opraHOB
pa3J1l-f'iHbIX ypOBHeil, BO,!\0II0JIb30Ba'feJIeH, IIpe.lITIfIlliJ1MaTeJleil, 06-
Il\eCTBeHHOCTt-I. B CIlIA COTPY,l\HH'l€CTBO Me 4Je,!\epaJlbHhIMM JII pe-
I'I10HaJIbHblMl1 opraHaMt-I B c4>epe BOARoro X03JIi1:CTBa Bb!pamaeTCJI He
TQJlbKO B 6acceiiHoBbIX opraaax ynpaBJieHM.fI, HO 11 B cn€qltaJibHbIX 6ac-
ceilHOBblX cor.naweHI1JIX. Taft, Hanpl1Mep, C 1961 r. no pe'lHOi1 CJICTeMe
JJ;eJlaB3p B paMKax 6acceifHoBoJl KOMI1CCJrn JII comaCHO EacceiiHoooMY
,l\OrOBopy COTPY,!\Ht-I'ialOT ":IeTbipe nrraTa 11 epa.rrbHoe npaB11TeJIb--
CTBO. B coce,1\Heii KaHaAe C 1960-x rr. MemJ1Y e,!\epa.1IbIIllMM opraHa-
-97-

MJII JI! npof fu.r.no nO,!\illfcaHO OKOJIO 100 comawemfi-1 no oxpaHe
BO,!\I.
Baccei-1IJ:13lde no.n;xO,!J;bIB ynpaBJIemU1 pOCCJrl1CID1I'IIBO,!\HbIM xoomICT-
ROM He lfC'lepIll>IBalOTCH JU1IlTh 6acceiiHomnm cor.JJaIIIeffif.HMl,f J1 COBeTa-
MJI!. 3To MO:iKHO npocne.n;llTh Ha IIpHMepe Bo.rrmcKo-KaMrnoro JI! AM)'p-
CKoro 6accei1HoB, nocne,!\Hm1: otlJ:VU-\t1aJIbHO npJ13HaH B 1994 r
 Hefinamrro.nyqHw peI1lOHCM. Y.w:e paHee, B 1991 r., 6bLJIa
C03,I1aHa Bo.mKcRaJ'l npl1po.r\OOxpaHHaR IIpoKypaTypa. B Hee BXO,!\MJIO 15
MempeI110HaJIbHldX no,!\pa3,l\eJIemOC TaKoi-1  npoKY-
popCKWIii Ha,!\30p TI03BOJULII BHt1KH)'Tb B cecTBo BOnpoCOB J1 KOI$Jn1K-
TOB. B pe3}'JIbT8Te Bo.rrmcKaJ'l npoKypa-rypa HaKOIIJ1JIa Y"lHbri1: OIIbIT B
JJ;eJIe oxpaHbI npI1pO,!J;bL B 1ffiCTHOCTH, OHa Ha,D;3HpaeT sa C06.ruDJ:\eHUeM He
TOJlbKO BO,ll;HOro, HO H necHoro 3aKOHOTeJIbCTBa. BOJDKCKaJ'l npoKypaTY-
pa B 199B-2000 IT. BWiBJ1JIa B 6accei1He 1171 3aTOllJIeHHoe Hn0JIy3aTon-
JIemme IIJIaBaTeJIbHoe cpe.n;CTBO, nOJIOBlilia H3 KaropblX OKa3aJIaCb 6ec-
X03HbIMIl.
B nepBbIe roAbI XXI B. fOTOBt1JIC$! poetcr «06 3IOC!.OOI1NeCtroM
03)\opoBJIeID-1J.-I peIrn BOJITI1 J1 ee npllTOHOB, a BOCCTaHOBJleJIt1M J1 CQxpaHe-
HHI1 IIpI:JX!,!\HblX  :Bo..rPKCKoro 6acceiiHa». KaK BI1,!\HO H3 Ha-
3BaHWI 3aKOHOIIpOeR'I'a, B HeM B3J'IT sa OCHOBY 6acceillioBHiii npWHQIiIT!
ynpaBJIeHWI, 8 rn 6accei1H K.aK 60JibW3J'1 3fOCOICTeM8 - cBoero
po)J;8 e}J;JlHbrli ofueKT, HaXQJ:\ffil-\JnlcH no.n; Ha6.moJ:\emteM rocy.J18pCTBeH-
HOro KOMlIJleltCHOrO MomrropJ11IT8. O,!\HaRO He,!\OCT8TKt1 38KOHonpoeKTa
RpoKYI'CH B era KpaTKOCTlil J1 OTCbLJIO<rHOM xapaKT€pe DORa aBTOpbl npo-
eKTa He Bbrpa6oTaJDl! B HeM .n;OCTaTO'llioi1 IOpt1,!J;H"lecKOi-1 «Ha'iJIIHKH», 'iTQ-
6b1C'11i1TaTb 3aKOH.J10CTaTO<rHono.
B HacTOflll-\ee BpeMJI B 3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbHoi-1 ,lIyMe Xa6apoBcKoro KpaJ'l
pa3pa6aTblBaeTCJ'I npreKT Q:le.r\epaJThHOl'O 38KOHa «0 paQHOHaJThHOM
B6accei-1HepeIrnAMyp».B3aEOHonpoeKTenpe.D;Y-
CMaTpl.fBaeTCH C03HHe e,[\lllHOH l:J:!ep;epaJIbHOH CHCTeMbi ynpaBneHtUl
I TACI1C KoHCYfibHITHBHaH noMOll\b Mnp POCCHH B 06fiiIC1I1 ynpaBlleHHH BOJ\H"'MH pecypC<lM"
Pocc""CrJJYKTYpa\fl1paWleH"OO,!J.HblM"pecypc:aM"B<JIeAepaw<H(CBOAHbIOT-
eTnObI1bIMeonpocaMJ.2001 Anpenb.C 9-12;Bt>lcrpo6eEA3"OfiOrH'iec-
oo npaao - MOTHBall"" B MSJlQ:\YHapOJ\HOM COTPY/IHH"ecrnS. M.. HaY"<', 2006. C. 112; Yam- r.
BoJ\HblepecypcblCWA'I1JX'6neMblI1CnOllbaOBaH" M..r1porpecc, 1971 C.1BO-IB4
2Bw1orP8.tlOSB.n.1J.eRTeJ1bHOCTbl3orol!aoAI1JX'<YPaT1/PbI
nOI<<I,!\3Opy3aHcnOllHeHHeMBa06oxpaHe(ll(py><alOl1\€iOnpHpoI\HocpeJ\b11l
npaBO.2001N2C.33--42
3Ma-repiII1"'nooKpyrnOMYCTOJJY"KoM"TeTanonp"pW\H"MpecypcaMH
rOCYlIiIpcTSeHHOiOJlyMbll<aTeMyo3a"OHCJ>ep,epaLl"oOn\!qxITe"-
Hl>l'leC"Hx.ecl<MeaCnel(TblH4<:>PMHpoBaHeMe"B-
HO(!MOSnpaBOSOroo6ecne-.eH"HoOT14HOH6DH2002r
-98-

IIpJ1pQD;OOOJJb3OB8ID1eM B 3TOM TpaHCrpaml'iHOM 6accei1He c yqacTIleM
BCeX npJ.1aM)'pCKI1X KpaeB H 06JIaCTei1. Onpe,!J;eJImoTCH Tpe60BaID-IH H or-
 BBO.n;JITCH 3I«J.1IOIWIE'C nacnopTJII3a4l'lH.wm BCeX X03Hi1-
CTBeHHbIX cy6'beKTOB, a TalOKe  ay.rurr. 3anpeH
CTpoJIITeJlbCTBO fX Jill1JIarJIIH B OCHOBHOM PYCJIe peKJII AMyp. ITo 3aMbIC-
:rry pa3pa6ar<rnKOB,  n03Bomrr YCKOplilTb pellleHJile TpaHC-
rpaHJIItIHbIXnpo6JIeM'.
BPaMmlrii,lU1p€KTI-1Be EC 2000/60nO-HOBOMYperyJIJl/PYeTCHynpaB-
JIeID-le BO.rr;HbIM  B EC, npe.n;yCMaTpJilBaH J1H'I"€I'PHPOOa
pa60'1}' Y'lPem.neIDriii: JiI KOMJITeTOB B paMKaX pairoHOB 6acceJIHIE peK
BaCceiii:Hbl peK}(aK  ynpaan:eID-IH BKJIIO'lffiKJl' B ce6H KaK nOBepx-
HOCTHhle, TaR JiI rpyH'IOBbI€ BO)l.bl JJ:nR OT}J:eJIbHbIX 6acceifiroB YCTaHOBne-
RbI J1JlaRbI ynpaan:eID-IH iii n}XJrpaMMbl no YJI)"lllleH:JlllO CCX::TOHHllii BOA
YnpaBJIeHJile pe'-IHbIM 6acceftHoM - HaJilJJ)''lllUUI Mo.n;eJlb He TOJIbKO
.wmH8JIbHbIX, HO JII MepobIX peK11 03ep. HOTaKOe
ynp8.BJIeID1e He 6Y.l\eT  6e3 "ILrraHa OCBoeID-IH BO.l\HbIX H
3eMeJlbHblX pecypCOB pe'iHOro 6acceiWa", KOTOpbIi1 06HOBJ1HeTCH Kam-
.l\bIe 6 JIeT. l(eJib TaIWro IlJIaHa - VKeHJre COBMECrHllMJI ycmn1HMJ1
xO}XJwero COCTOHlillHBo.l\Hoifcpe,!J;bIKoncpoKY.
B BO.l\Hoi-i: CTpaTeIW1 Poccmt .l\0 2020 r.  3anOmeHbl
tpoaamre CJIICTeMbI JiI opraID13aQilli ,l\eH'reJIbHOCTJll 6acceHHOOblX
COBeTOB, KOTOpble Jil3 BDDpJJ) opraHoB n03Tarrno npeBpaTHT-
CHB opraHbl, npHffilMalClIT(Jle npaKTWleCKJlle ynpaB.JIeII'ieCIDte perneHJil.H B
paMKax 6acceiiHoBoro oKpyra.l1MeHHo 6acceHHoBbie COBeTbi craHoRRTCH
KJllQ'IeBblM :3neMeHTOM ynpaBJIeHtUi BO):\HbIM X03.ffi)(."I'B(:f\II11 IIJXIBCWIII-
ItOM peliJll'13aI,IIUI HlIBOi-i: BQl\IIX03.ffi)C'TIJ€HHOi1lIOJIJmllm PCX::CJIIJII
2. MOHHTOPHHr, Y4ET H KOHTPOb
B 05ACTH HcnOb30BAHH H OXPAHbl BO/1
Ha6.Juo.lIenue 3a COCTOJIIIIIeM BOWloro 4>oH,!J;a. MoID-ITOpl1ID' BO.l\HblX
06'beKTOB .HBJIHeTCH COCTaIJHOif: -qaCTblO rocy,l\apCTBelllioro MOHHTopJIIHra
oK1 cpe,IJ;b111 B Toif 11ID'! JlHoif CreneHJII conpJllKaCaH C MOHJII-
TOpJIIHrOM ,IJ;pyrl1X BJ.-U\OB IIpJtpo.lIHI>IX pecypcoB, o&beK'IUB 11 cpe,!J;
Mcrnf'IqJJllif BO.l\HbIX o&beK'IUB - C>1CTeMa Ha6.mo.neHJili-i:, oeHlrn H
nporn03a 113MeHeHHi'i: COCTOHHJilH BO,iJ;HblX o&beK'IUB BRe 3aBUCl1MOCTl1 OT
4>opMbI co6cTBeHHocm Ha HJilx.
, Bo.I1aPOCCH 2W9.NI4(W) C 1.
-99-

B 3amlCHMOCTIf OT 06'beKTOB BbJ,!\eJ1HlOT c.rre.JIY!OJ.IJ;Jlle HanpaBJIeIDIH
MOIDITopl1Hra:
- IIOBepxHOCTllblX BO,!{HblX 06'beK'roB C Y'ieTOM ,IJ;aHHbIX MOHl1TOJnrnra,
ro npJllIIpOB(',IJ;eIDBi pa60T B 06.rraCTJllrn,npOMeTeopOJlO-
1W1 JII CMemHbIX C HeH 06.rraCTlIX;
- COCTORHJIIR.qHa 11 6eperoB BO)Uib1X 06'beK'roB (B J1X'lJIICJI€ - ypoBHeH
BO)J;bI JII 6eperoBOH JIJllHJllJII), a TaKiKe COCTOHIDIH I\(J.JIOOX}JaHHblX 30H;
- nOeMHbIX BO,IJ; C Y'ieTOM ,J\aHHbIX rocypCTBeHllOro MOHl1TOpl1Hra
COCTORHJIIR He,IJ;p;
- HHblX CJIICTeM, B TOM'lJIICJIe rI'C. a TaKiKe ol5DeMoB
BOp;npJllBO,I\JllBOJ\OOTBe,IJ;eHJIIJII.
Ha6JIIO,IJ;eHJIIR OeCTBJ1HlOTCH B rpamlIax 6acceiiHoBHx OKpyrOB C
Y'ieTOM OCOOeHHOCTeH pe:/KHMa BO,!{HblX ofueKTOB, IIX ct>JII3I1KO-reorpacI:)JII-
':IecKJIIX, ME.'CKJIIXJII,IJ;pyrJ1Xoco6eJrnOCTeii.
OpraHJII3aH II Be,IJ;emle MOHJIITopJIIHra OH 4>eJ\e-
paJlbHbIM areJIT<:l'IIOM BO,!{HblX peCypCOB, 4>eJ\epaJlbHbIM areJIT<:l'BOM
no He.up0II0JIb30BalBDO, 4>e,IJ;epaJlbHOH C1I}?K6on no I'Jl,!{poMeTOOpoJlO-
n-IJII JII MOHI1TOpl1Hry oKpyaIOIl-\eM Cpe,IJ;bll1 4>eJ\epaJlbHOH CJly60M no
Ha,IJ;30py B cct>epe npl1pOJ\onOJlb30BamfH C Y'iaCTI1€M ynOJiHOMO':l€H-
HbiX opraHOB JlClIOJIHJIT€JlbHOH BJlaCTJII cy6DeKTOB PoccmICKOH 4>eJ\e-
paJII.
ITpI1 npoBe,!J;eIDfl-'l MOHJll'l"OpJllHl'a JIIClIOJIb3}'IOTCH CBe,IJ;eHJIIR, no.nyqeHHble
Bpe3YJlbTaTeHa6JnoJ1eHJlli;i3aBO)J;HblMJllo6'b€KTaMHl1-
MI1CI1CTeMaMJ1,BTOM'lI1CJIe3afMlfCOOP}')f\eHl1.lIMJ1,,lij)y-
n-IMI1 3amrrepeCOBaHIll:IMU Q:Ie,!J;epaJlbHbJ]loD1 opraHaMI1 I1CIIOJiHIfTe.JJNIOii
MacTl1, C KOTopbIMJII B3aJIIMO,IJ;eMCTByIOT Y'iaCT1IJ11KJII Be,IJ;eHJIIH MOHJllTO-
pl1Hra, a TaKiKe CBe,IJ;eHJIIR, nOJl)"l€HHble B peayJlbTaTe Hafuno,IJ;emriii c06-
CTBeHHll/KaMJII BOlIHbIX o&beKToB, BOJlOIl()JIb3()TeJ1HMI1 11 HE',D;JXJIIOJIb3O-
BaT€JrnMM.
Be}J:eHl1e MOHl1TopMHra  Ha OCHOBe }'HI14Juta4l1l1
nporp8MMHb!X (I'1Hc}:>opM8QHOHHbIX II TexHl1'IecKi1X) cpe,!\CTB, 06ecne'lJll-
B8lOJ.IJ;JIIX COBMeC'IHMOCTb era.ll8HHbIX C .lI8HHblMJll,IJ;pyrnx BI1,!\OB MOHJllTO-
pl1Hra OKpymalOIl-\eM Cpe,!\bI.
OpraHbI J1CIlOJIHI1TeJIb BJIaC'I'JII cy6DeK'roB Poccw1cKojij: 4>e,!\epa-
ltJIIM, yqaCTBYHBopraHtt:aaI.tHJII lIftfMOHJII'I'opJllHI'a:
- opraHJII3YlOT npoBe}J:eHJlle perYAApHblX Ha6.moJ\eHMii 38 COCTOaIDIeM
,AHa, 6eperoB, Jll3MeHeHi1JIMI1 MOpcpoMeTplt:!'IecKi1X ocdieHHOCTeM, COCTO-
HHHeM BO,IJ;OOXpaHHbIX 30H BO,iJ;HblX 06'beKTOB I1JII1 HX ':IaCTei1, HaxO,!\H-
llC-1XCH B Q:Ie,!J;epanbHOJl c06CTBeHHOCTI1 It:! pacrrOJiO<KeHHbIX Ha TeppJll'l'O-
pHH cym,eKTa PcIJ, a TaKiKe BO)J;HbIX 06'beK'roB II f'Ifla1X
coopymeHitii, pacnOJlomeHHblX Ha TepplrropHH cyfrbeKTa PcIJ J1 HaXOAH-
-100-

lltHXCH B c06CTBeHHoCTIf KaK Cy6'beKTOB PcI>, TaK J'! M}'HJnv-mam,HbIX 06-
pa3OB<UDrii;
- ocyw;ecTB.I1HIOTc60p, o6pa60'!'KY, 0606J.IJ;eID-Ie J'!xpaHeID-le CBe,lJ;eIDrlii,
nO.rryqeHHblX B pe3)'JIbTaTe Hafurn:v:\emrlii sa COCTOHID1eM ,lJ;Ha, 6eperoB J'!
 SOH BO 06'beKTOB J'!JU1I1X 'laCTei1, HaXOCR B
4>e.n;ep3JIbHll1 co6cTBeHHocTt1. 11  sa BO)J;HbIMJ1 
IJf,!J;}XYI"eXHR€CKJ-fMII COOpymE'HIDlWf, H8XO,J:I,Hll:g:1MIICH B e:c6cmeHHoc:TH
cy6'beKTOB PcI>, npe,!\cTaBJ1JIIOT J1X B Tepp1'fOpHaJlbllbl opraHbI POCBO,!\-
pecypCOB B COO1'B("I'(."l'-! C ycrnHOBJIEtIHldMJI 40PMaWf J1 nOpR,ZJ;KOM
npe,lJ;CTaBJIeHJ1H ,lJ;aHHbIX, 4xJpMaMJ111 nopMKOM npeJ:lcraBJIeIDtH cBe,!\e-
IDrlii 11 nOpR,ZJ;KOM JrnrPopMaIUtuHOOro 06MeHa, a TaIOKe npe,!\CTaBJIHIOT
CBe,lJ;eHIDI 0 HapynIemmx peiKl1Ma J1cnOJIb30B8.HI1H J3(J,D;OOxpaHlftD( SOH
BOblX OObeKTOB, nOJIy'ieHHbIe B pe3YJIbTaTe emVl pem0-
HaJlbHOro rocY,IJ;apCTBeHHoro KOHTpOJm J'! Ha,JJ;30pa sa JICIIOJIb3I:I3aIDIeM J'!
oxpaHOJf BO,!{HblX OObeKTOB.
C'x:6cmEtnntIafBO,!\HbIX Om.eKTOB J1 BQJ:IOIIO,JIb3O're.ID1 B nopR,ZJ;Ke, yc-
TaH)Wle MJrnnpI1pO,1J;bI Poccro:t:
- Be1JYf yqeT WbeMa aafupa (113'bJ1TI1H) BO,!{HbIX pecypcOB J13 BOblX
06'beKTOB 11 06'beMa c6poca CTO'iHblX BO,!J;Jf (11M) ,D;peH8.jfQ!bIX BO,!J;, I1X Ita-
-qeCTBa;
- Be1JYf peryIDIpHbIe Ha6.mo,!J;emm 3a BO)J;HbIMJII 06'beKTaWf (11X Mop-
ecro1Mll0Co6eHHOCTm.rn:)J1I1Xf3OHaMJ1;
- npe,D;CTaBJllOO B Te opraHbI POCBO,IlpeCYPCOB CBe-
,lJ;eHi1JI, nOJIy'ieHHbIe B pe3)'JIhTaTe TalOOro yqeTa 11, B CQOT-
BeTCTBID1 C HHblMJI40pMo}i 11 n€p.«),IJ;I'NHOCThIO.
rocy,!\apcroellllYii Y'leT BO,JJ;HOro 1JJoH.!\a. rocy,D;apcrneHHtDf BO.IUIbIH
peecTp npe,!\CTaBJIHeT co6o}i CHCTeMaTIf3JIpOBaHHbIi1 CBo,!\,IJ;OK)'MeHTHIJO-
BaHHbIX rne.I\€IIHM 0 BO,!{HblX 06'beKTax, HaxoCR B pa3HbIX 40pMax
co6cTBeHHOCTI1, 06 I1X dCI1OJIb3OBaHJot, 0 pe'IHbIX 6acceRHax, 0 6acceii:ID-
BbIX oKpyrax.
B rocy,D;apcTBeHHOM BO,!{HOM peec-rpe oCyu.J;eCTBJUIeTCH rocy.l\apCTBeH-
HaH peI11VI ,lJ;OroBopoB BO,lJ;OJ1OJIb3OBaHJVI, pelll€ID1Jf 0 IIpe.[IOC'I8B-
JIeID1JlI BOblX 06'beKTOB B IDnb3OBaHJre, nepexo,!\a npaB J1 o6H3aHHocTeii:
no ,AOrOBopaM BQJ:I(JIlOJIb3(HI1JI, a TaIOKe VI ,!\OroBopoB Bo-
'"
l(e.ID1 Be,AeHt-1H BO,!\HOro peeCTpa:
- 11H4x)oe o6ecne'leHl1e KOMI1JIeKCHoro I1CIIOJIb3OBaHl1fl
BOblX o&beKToB, I.1;eJIeBoro I1CIX:1JIb3OB8HIUI BOblX ofueKTOB, J1X ox-
paHbI;
- IIJIaHJ1poB8.HHe 11 paspafXrrKa Meponpwmof no npe
HeraTHBHoroElO3,A€HCTBU.HBO)J;I101erol
-101_

Be.n;emre peec-rpa oc I\Jcoo,JJ;pecypt B COOTBeTCT-
Bnt C BO)J.HblM saKOHO)J;aTeJIhCTBOM 11 3aKOHo.n;aTeJIbCTBOM 05 l1H4x>pMa-
'-tMJ1, IIH$JpM&tIKIHHbIX 'f€XHOJI()nf.HX 11 0 SaJqlllTe 1.
3aKOHO;:J;aTeJIh He TOJIbKOOTHOCwr .r:\OKYMelfl1.1JXJBaHHbl CBe.r:\emrn ro-
cY,l\apc7B€HHOOO BO,l\HOro peec-rpa K rOCYMpcTBeHHblM I-
HbIM pecypcaM OTKpblTOro xapaK'repa (sa J1'KJIlO'1eID1eM I-1II4>oPMaICU'l
orpaHWl€HHOOO ,l\ocryna), HO 11 onpe,!\eMeT npoe.l1YPY nOJIY'lemr.fl J1H-
$JpMaIurn.B Te'lemle mm:! pa60'lJ1X ,IJ;Hei-1 yrIOJIHOMO'1eJIHb1i;i $:,!\epaJlb-
Hbifl opraH IICf1OJIHI1'I'eJH EIJlaCTII npe,flOCTaBJmeT S8.I1HTepeCOBaHHO-
MY JUIL\Y CBe,neHI1.fI 113 rocypcrBeHHoro BOJ\Horo peecrpa I1J1>'1 B
IDICbMeHHoi1 4JopMe H8.npaBJl.fleT eM)' MOTIIBI1pCIBB.IIHWi OTtta3 B npe,!\o-
craBJIeIDBI TaID:!X CBe,!\eHJ-ri1, KaropbIi-1 MmKeT 6bITb 06ma.noBaH Sa:YnITe-
pecOBaHHbIM JJJ-lIJ;OM B CY.r:\e6HOM nopH,!\Ke.
IIpJII 3TOM 3a lIJIary llpe,!\ocTaBJImOTCJi KOID1V! cJle.uyro .r:\oK)'MeH-
TOB:.noroBopblpellIeHJII.flOBOJlHoro
05'beKT8 B n0Jib30BaHJlle, I1Hble ,[IOK)'MeHI'bl, Ha OCHOBaHJIIJ-I KQTOpbIX 003-
HHKaeT npaBO c05c1BeHHocTI1 Ha BOAHbie oI5'beKTbI.m-IDo npaBO nOJTh30Ba-
mmHMH.
B CB.fI3t1 C KOMIlblOTep113alpleH I1H4x>PMaQIDi a npe.nocraBJIeID01 BO)1-
HbIX 05'beKTOB B n0JTh30BaHJlle II.\<I-E"fCJI Ha  cai-ITe
yrII1JlHOMO'leHorG IIpamrre.1II>C'l' p $:,!\epaJIbHoro opraHa I1cnon-
IDITE'.JlbllaI BJIaCTI-:! B I'IH$JpMaltJf£IlHO-TeJIeKOMM)'IDIKaIUIDHHOlI CeTJII
d1HTepHeT». IIp11Bt'.,l\eHHHe nonmKeHJII.fl craTeH BI\ p_ nptl3BaHbI MO-
.r:\epIDf3llJXJBaTh 11 CJ\e.naTb MaKCHMaJIbHO OTKpbITbIM BO.IUIt>IH peeCTp Kax
11H pecypc rocy,JlapcTBa, 'ITO, KOHe'IHO me, He ,nOJlmHO
KacaTbClI ceKpeTHblX CB€JI,€HIrli Tax, Hanp=ep, BPNl JII15yt\JT pacnpo-
C'lpaIDITb Komrn Bcex pernemnl IIpaBJIITeJlbCTBa P,.r:\a ee 11 c IIpJllJla-
raIOLqI1MJIICJi rpa4)J1QecKJIiMJII MaTepJllana.MM, 0 npe,flOCTaBJi€HJIIJII BO)J;HblX
06DeKTOB B nOJlb30BaID:!e WI.fI o5ecJIeqemlH 060POHbI C'lpaHb! 116e30rrac-
HOCTJII I'OCy,l\apCTBa
3aMeHa BOJlHOro Ka)\acrpa BOJ\HbIM peecTpoM narpe6oBa.na lIpill:l.fITI-I.fl
crreQWaJIbHoro rocnuIOBJI€HI1.fI IIpaBH'I'€JIbCTBa Pel> OT 28 arrpeM 2007 r.
NQ 253 «DnopJi,JJ;Ke Be)\eHI1R rocy,l\apcTBeHHoro BO,!\HOro peeCTpa»l.
Peec-rp coJ\epJKI1T pa3,!\eJIb! «Bo)J;Hble 06DeKThi J1 BO,!\Hble pecypcbl»,
«BoJlOnOJTh30BaHJlle» 11 «l1HiPpac-rpYKTypa H8 BO 06'beKTax».
B pa:3,!\e.n «Bo)J;Hble oO'beKThl H BO,!\Hble pecypcbl» peecTpa BKJIl(Jqa-
lOTCJi CBe,!\eHI1R: a 6accefuJoBbIX oKpyrax, a pe'IHblX 6accefuJax, a BO,!\HblX
05'beKT8x, paCnOJlomeHHblX B rpaHJ1Qax pe'IHblX 6acceiihroB, B TOM 'lJIIcne
I C3 P$. 2007 N!!19.Cr 2357
-102-

05 occ6emr::>cT:Hx pemJrMa BOblX oO'beKTOB, I1X $1;3I1Ko-reorpaqu'l'iec-
IUIX, MoP1JoMe-rpWlecrurx II ,D;pyrl1X OCOOeHHOCTHX.
B pa3.I\eJI «Bo.I\OnOJIb30BaHl1e» peecTpa BKJIIO'IalOTCH CBe.I\eID1H: a B0-
yqacTKax; 3oHaXcoc06bIMMycnooJ1HMJfl1xl1cnOJIb3O-
BaID1H (0 BO.I\OOXpaHHbIX 30HaX II  3aLql1THbIX nOJIocax); 05
 BO.I\HblX 05'beKTOB, B TOM'lI1CJIe a m: 11
m1l1; o.n;oroBopaxBO.JI{JI1OJIb3(I3ID1H, BTOM ':UICJIe 05 I1Xrocy-
.n;apcTBeHll(Jii penl nepexo)];e np<m 11 oOH3aHHOCTeH no ,lJ;OroB0-
paM BO)];OII01lb3lJBallWl, a TaIOKe a npeKpall.\emrn JKa3aHHbIX ,lJ;OroBopoB;
o peIIIE'HIIHX 0 npe,[\OCTaBJIeHillI BObIX oO'beKTOB B IIO.JIb3(JBaID1. B TOM
'lI1CJle 05 I1X rocY,l:\apcmeHHOlf pernm.
B pa3.I\eJI «l1HcppaC'rpyK'I}'pa Ha BOblX ol5'bE'I\Tax» peecTpa BtWIO-
'W.lOTCfI CBE'.I\emm 0 BO,I:J.OXOOm'ic'rBeHHtlx CI1CTeMax, rrc I1I1HbIX coopy-
.meHIDlX, paCl1OJlOm€HHblX Ha BOblX c6'beKrnx.
COI'.naCHO ynOMflH)'TOM)' IIOCTaHOBJIemfIO IIpaBJ.freJlbCTBa PcI>, .:I>e.I\e-
paJIbHoe aremCTBO BO.I1JlbIX pecypcOB  nOJIYGae-r 11H4xP-
MalU1lO 113 MJflICeJIbxooa POCCillI, PocpbI6oJIOBCTBa, Pornmpe6a,
POCrI1,llpOMeTa, POCHe.n;p,  POCTex:HB..L\3opa, .:I>e.I\e-
paJIbHOi1 CJIY'K6bl roCYMpCTBeHHOH perncrpaw-rn, KC\J¥lCTpa I1l\aprorpa-
c}:IillI (Pocpeec'I'p).
C6opHxpaHeHl1eCBe.I\eHJrlj-onO)];3eMHbIXBO.!\-
1Ib1X06'beKTaxBCOO'I'BeTCTBIDiC3aROHO,II,aTeJlbCTBOMO
He)1pax. IIp:11 3TOM, cor.naCHO nOCTaHOBJIemno IIpaBMTeJIICI'Ba Pq, «0 no-
pe Be)1eHM roCYMpcTB€HHoro BO)1HOro peecrpa», POCHe.n;pa.n;OJ"OKHbI
IIpe,lJ;OCTaBJUITb B BObrn peeCTpCBe,l:\eHlmonO,!\3eMHbIX BOblXofu,eK-
Tax, B TOM 'illCJle 0511XJ1CIIOJIb3OIIaIDII1, eIDlJfl1 BO.I\OO'I'Be-
.n;€HIDf.
IIuJporpac}::wiecKaH ceTb POCCIDf xapaKTepHa 06J1JD1eM MaJlbIX BO.I\0-
TOKOB II BO)1oeMOB. 3acJIY'KI1B8-IOT rOCY)1apcTB€HHoro yqeTa MaJibie BO.!\-
lIb!e 06'beKTbI, HO 11M He YfI.n;OCTaT(NHOro BHMMaHM co CTOpoHbl
opraHOB BJlaCTJII, a X03IDICTByIOUJ;I1e Cy&beI\TbI He BCer,D;a 3a11HTepeCOBa-
lib! B I1X npo,IJ;yMaHHOM JK'I1OJIb3OBaIDIJ1 II oxpaRe. Bo MHornx penrouax
POCCID'! (B TOM 'illCJle B KPynHbIX ropo,l:\aX, npmopo,!\HbIX 30Rax) MaJlble
peKJI, 03epa, py<IbJ1, po.n;HJlKH, npy,!\bl I1l\apbepbl He 6blJlJ1 OTpameHbJ B
rOCY,lIapcTBeHHOM BO)1HOM I\a,llaCTpe, a aaTeM - B BO)1HOM peecrpe.
B HaCTO.ffil\ee BpeW! C BBe)1eHl1eM rOCY)1apCTBeHHoro BO)1HOro peec-
Tpa B03HI>11\J!a 3a.n;a>m BOCIIOJiHHTb .n;onJI--U;eHHble paHee npo5eJlbl B 1'0-
cy)1apCweHHoM yqeTe BO)];. ,l{aHlIaH 3a.n;a'W. Bbrrel\aeT He TOJlbKO 1>13
«6}'KBbI l1.n;yxa» BI\ PcI>, HO II 113 Heo6xo.D;JfMOCTJII 06ecne':ll1Tb 060CHO-
BaHHYIO 3KmOMWIeCKJlO oQeHKY aKBa.'ropl1H II COnpJDKeHHbIX C IDIMI1
aeMeJlbHblX yqacTKoB. B )1aHHOM CJIyqae BO)1Hbrn peecTp ,lJ;OJIeH 050-
-103-

rar.qaTb rocy,l\apCTBeHHbrn: Ka;:J;aCTp He,l\BH<KJ1MOCTH, He YKJIOHHHCb OT
OTOopameIDUI 3KO.JIOI'W1f'CKI1X xapaKTepJ:lCTJ:lK J:I 3Ha'leHJ.-IR BO.noeMa
J1JIJII BO)J;OTOKa.
Cor.rraCHO CT. 7 4>e,l\epaJIhHoro 33.KOHa ar 24 IOOJUI 2007 T. NQ 22143
«0 rocy,l\apcrBeHHoM Ka)1aCTpe HeABIDKt 1 B rOCy]1apcrBeHHbrn: Ka-
,l\aCTp He)J;BIDKHMOCTJII BHCX'JITC.H )J;onOJIIDITeJIbHbIe CBeHJm 00 y<nfIbIBa-
eMOMMeKTeHe,l\aIDKJIIH)CTIL KJ:IX'lJ1CnyOI'HCX'JITC.HJ:lCBeHJ.-IRO.rrecax,
BO)J;Hb1X OO'beKTax JllJIIHbIX npl1pO)J;HbIX OObeKTaX, pacnruromeHHbIX B npe-
,l\eJIax 3€MeJIbHOI'O yqaCTKa. IIp:I1B€,l\€HHble nruro»reHMR 3aKDHa n03BOJIR-
KIT HaM C)1€JIaTb BhlBO,l\ 0 B3<ll1MHOM o6oral1\€HJ:II1 Ka)1aC'Ipa VKlfM)C-
TI1 J:I pa3JIJll'llibIX «oaHKOB ,lIaHHbIX» no necaM J:I BO)J;aM. B CBOlO O'lepe,!J;b, He
o6oral1\€HHbI€ aa C'l€T BO,l\Horop€ecTpa CBeHJ.-IR rocy]1apcTBeHHoro Ka)1a-
crpa He.n;BIDKHMOCThl 0 KOHKpeTHOM 3eMeJIbHOM )"IaCTKe OKam)'TCJI I1pJII-
.mt60 HeBEpHbIMH. CiHJII He ,l\a,nyrnOJIHOH JII,IJ,O(."fOOepIl1
KapTJllHbl3KOHOMtf'l€OOCJiilleHHOCTJII 3eMJIH, 3Ha'l€HJ.-IRae-
MeJlbHbIX )"IaCTKOB.
KoHTPOJIb3a UDiOJIb3OBIDllleI11UoxpamiiBQA I1€JIhKOH'IpOJIR3aJ:lC-
IlOJIb3()Ba}UfeM JII oxpaHOO BO,l\ - 06ecn€'lJIITb npaBOM€pHO€ IJOBe,lI,€HJie
yqaCTIDlKoB BO)J;Hb1X OTIfillell1£ii. a TalOKe pea.mI3al\J'IlO npaB J:I 06.H3aH-
HOCT€J::i:BO,l\OJI)JIb3OBTeJIeii.
B CT. 36 BK Pel> onpe)J;e.rreHb! 30J\a'lJ1 KOH'IpOJIR, opraHbl JII .1illl\a, ero
0CYl1\€CTBJImDlItJII€, a TaiOK€, '1TO OCOO€HHO Ba>KHO, nOJIH()),UItfJI rocy]1ap-
CTB€HHblX J:lHcn€KTopoB.
OcHOBHa.H 3a,!\a'la BO,!J;HOro KOlITpollii (HOJ\30pa) 3aKJIlO'laeTC.H B 06ec-
n€'l€HJIIJII c05mo,lJ;€HJ1JI TpeOOBaHJIII-1 K JfCIIOJIb3()BaHJ J:I OXpaH€ BO,l1HbIX
OO'beKTOB. Ha3BaHHble Tp€6oBaInm MOryT CQ)J;epmaTbCH KaK B fOCTax,
Bee el1\e )J;eHCTBYW B OOJIaCTJII 6e30IlarnOCTI1, TaK JII B 'f€XH1-1<IeCKJI
perJIaM€HTaX, hlX B c.fIeJ:1epaJIbHOM aaKOHe «0 'reXHJf'I€C-
KOM pery.ID1poBaHJIIJII» 2002 r. IIpo:u;ecc npillUlTJ.-IR TeXHJII'IecIlliX per.rra-
MeHTOB TQJlbKO Ha'laJICJI.
Ba>KHblM Ha1JpaBJJ€HJ:I€M BO,l\HOro KOH'IpOJIR flBJIReTCa npoBepKa co-
5.mo.n:eHJ1H CTOpOHaMJII YCJIOBID1: ,l:\OroBOpa BO,JJ,OII01Ib3O (lIe.ID1, cpo-
KJ1, OObeMbi ooupaeMoi1: BO)J;bI 11 tiP.). CJIeAYeT OTMeTJllTh, 'ITO BO,!J;Hhrn:
KOHTpOJIb HaIIpaBJIeH He TOJIbKO IIpOTI1B HapyrneHJIIH ,norOBopoB BO):\O-
IJOJIh3OBaJilfJIl1JIJllyc.TIOIMii aAMHHHC1paTJIIBHb!XllOCBOei'i:
I1pJllpo,IJ;e, pellieHID1: 0 IIpe)J;OC'1'8BJI1 BO)J;HhlX OO'bemOB B IJ().1Ib3()BaHU€-
Y Hero €CTb ,D;pyrne, I1p<XfJJ'1JIaKTIl'l€CKlte no xapaKTepy, 3a,l(a.'lJ1: He):\o-
I C3P<11.2007.NI!31.CT.4017
-104_

nyrn;eIDfeOCOBO,!\OTIOJIb3OBalllm,06ecTIe-qeIDIelJ.OO--
pocOBec11I01'O lIpOBeJIeIDm a)'KWRIJOB Ha npaBO 3aKJIlO':leIDIH 1l01'OBopa
""",,0Jn00BaEHI<
Ellie OlJ,H8 3<V1a'la KQHTp0JIH - 06ecne-qeHl>1e oco601'0 npaBOBOru pe)Kl1-
Ma HCI1OJIb3OBaHJ1H 3eMeJIbHbIX y-qaCTXOB 1>1 IIHbIX olh.eKTOB He,!J;BH>KJ1Mo-
CTII, paC:IIOJICOReHHbIX B rpaID1Qax BOJ:IOOXP8.HHbI30H II 30H CIIeLlJI8.JIbHOif:
OXpaHbIIICTO'lRJiKOB IDITbeB01'O BO)J;ocHaomemrn.
BamHaH 3a.n;a<ra BO,!\H01'O KOHTpoJUI (Ha.n;30pa), Heyxa3aHHaH IIpHMO B
BKPeI>, -BldHBJIeH1le $iXTOB HapyrneHl1H3aKOHo,!\aTeJIbCTBa II IIpI>1BJ1e-
"leHl1e K arBe'fCTBE:'HHOf JlJ1:Q, BJfHOBHI:lX B IIpaBOHapyrneID1HX.
OnlOIlleHl1.R no IICn0JTh3OBaIDOO J:I oxpaHe BO,!\ IICIlJ,aeTJ,OMCTBeHHbI KaK
Pocnp, TaKOT'laCTI>1.BHaCTOBpeMflOOa
Ha3BaHHblX Hatom opraHa llOJl:'lMHeHbI MJflmpl1pO1 POCCMJi. 0 Ha3BaHHbIX
opnulaX IIpmmI'b1 nOCTaHOBJIeHl1.R IIpaBJ1'l'eJIbCTBa P<P or 30 1-OOJlfI2004 T.
NQ400"aifuIIo.rroifreHl1.RO$>Aeparn.'«)iinopy
B ctP=pe IIJRPQlI.OU)JIb II BHeceID1l1 I13Mem?HI-rif B lJOCTaHOBJIeHJl!e
IIpaBl-rreJibCTBa PoccJ.OCRoJI clJe.z\epalJ;l1I1 or 22 I-OOJlfI 2004 r. NQ 3'70" " or 30
JOOJlH2004r.NQ401"OCJl)"Kfiem3.TeXHo-
JIOI1f'R'KOMJ II aTOMHOMY Ha,!\30py»2.
pOeTKOHTpOJlbIlHa,!\3op:
- 3a l1CIllJIb3OBaID1eM II OXpaHOiii: BO,!\HblX OO'beKTOB;
- 3a Co6.mo.z1eHHeM 3aKOHO):\aTeJIbCTBa PoccmfCKOii 4>e,!\epaWHf H
Mem,nyHapOAHblX HopM II CTaH,!\apTOB B OOJlaCTI>1 MOpCKOiii: cpe)J;bl H
npI>1P0)J;HbIX pecypCOB IJHYfP€HHJ'!X MOPCIDIX BO,!\, Teppl>1TOpmuIbIIOro
MOpH;
- rocYlJ.apcTBeHHbIiii: 3eMeJ1bHb1Jf KOlrrpo.m. B IIpe,1J;enax cBOeiii: KOMIIe-
TeHIV1H, B TOM 'llICJle B  3eMeJIb oc06o OXpaHHeMbIX npllp0)J;-
HbIX Teppm'Oplrii3Ha'leHl1H.
B nOJIHOMO'll1.fl POCTeXH8,!\30pa BXO,!\.flT KOlITpo.m. H Ha,!\30p 3a COOJl}(}-
lJ.eHlI/eMcoopymeHll/fi:II/3KCIIJIyaTIl/-
py1OLIJ;I-1l\o1J11 opIaHI13aqm:lMII/ HDpM II! npaBl.1JI 6esmacHoCTII! rrc. B 3TOM
CMbICJle POCTeXH<VI3op OTBe-qaeT sa onpe,v;eneHHNe, crpaTefiNeCltll!
BaiKHble, aCneKTbl4I}'HKll;J-fOJIJ1POBaHl1H BO,!\H01'O X03Jri.i:C'i'Ba.
Cor.naCHo BK Pel> rocY,1J;apcwell!lble JlHCneKTOpbl JlMelOT npaBO npo-
BepHTb co\'imoJ:\eIDle TpeOOBaIDriii K J1'I1{).JIb3OOaHHlO II! oxpaHe BO,!\HbIX
ofu.eJm:E, COCTaBmITb no pesyJIhTaTIlM npOBepoK aKTb! II! rIpe,!\CTaBJIHTh
I1X lJ..IIR 03EIaBDM.JIeffi1H BOJIOIIOJ!b3OI3aTeJIHM.
, C3P$ 2004. Nil32. Cr. 3347
2 C3P$.20D4.Nil32.Cr 3348
-105-

rocy,l\apcTBeHHble J1lQIeJIT()J::H ,l\alOT 06J13aTeJlbHble .wm IOCIXlJIHeID1H
tcaffitJI 05 ycTpaHem1H BbIJIBJIeHHbIX B pe3yJlhTaTe npoBepoK 113.-
pyIIJeHKi'i, yc.ooEIm I:Icn0JIb30BaHt1.fl BO,l1HblX 05'beKTOB 1:1 KOHTpo.rn1PYlOT
CBOeBpeMeHHOe I:ICnOJIHeHHe }'Ka3aHHblX npeiUIJ1caHl1H. CTOpoHbl ,IJ;oro-
BOpa BO,lI,(IlO1lb3OBaHtfJI yae,l\OMJImoTCJI B I1J1CI>MeHHOfi: $JpMe a pe3YJIh-
TaTax npOBepoK, BbrnBJIE'1IlIHX HapyweID1HX ycnoonii J1CII{)JIb3(EaIDIJI
BO,l1HblX ofueKTOB.
rOCilllcneKTOpbI 1Ipe.n;'bJIBJllfIOT qnf3ll'l€CKHM 1:1 IOpJ.f,!I;W1eCKJ1M JIJ1QaM
Tpe6clBaHl1Jl 0 npoBe,l\eHJU1 1MblX MepoI1J::&fSiT'J:Iiij: no oxpaHe BO,l1-
HbIX 05'beJITOB, a TaKiKe nO,MlOT I1CKI1 B cy.n; 11 ap6JnpamHbrii CY.J\.
B noMOIl\b ItOHTpOJTI1pyIOlQI-fM OpraHaM IIpJ1BJ1etW.lOTCJI Hay'IKJ-IlCCJIeJW-
BaTeJlbCKI1e,TeJlbCK!ilel11J;Pyrneopra.wmnpoBe-
.J\eHJ1JlCaHaJiJ13OB,np05,OCMcrrpoBHBbJ,[\Cl'iJII
B CJIY'ffiJIX aaapIDi Ha BO):\Hb1X OO'beKTaX, KaI"OpbIe, yaM, crryqaKYI"CH
RpOMe TOm, rocy.n;apcTBeHHble HHCIIeKTOJ::H OCMl'IpHBaJOT If, IIpH He-
IMOCTK, MOryr 3a,D;ep*I1BaTb cY,l\a 1:1 .i:\Pyme lIJIaB)"U1e cpe.l\CTBa,
.r:\OIIYCTIWIllJ'1e 3arpH3Hemre HeWrblO, I1HblMM SP€,!J;HblMM 
CTO'lHbIMI1 BO,MMM I1.JII1 MYCOpoM.mIDO He I1p:fHHBlllJte IMblXMep
no npe.n;OTBeHJ1lO TaKOrO 3aI'pfl3HeHHH BO,!J;HblX ofueKTOB. lIaHHoe
mJIHCMJ'llI€ pampocrpaHHf'TCH 11 Ha ItHOC-rpaHHHe cy,l\a.
ComaCHO CT. 24, 25 BK Pel> nepe'ffiH ofueKTOB, nO,l\Jlemax .pe.l\e-
paJIbHOM)' 1:1 perlfOHaIThHOMy KOHTpo.mO, 1:1 nepe'lHH yqaCTBYx B HeM
,l1OJDKHOCTHHX JIt:lQ onpe,l\eJUOOTCH COCI'l"Be'I'CT IIOJIHOMO"lHblMH op-
raHaMl-1 rocy.n;apc::i'BEfIIIOO BJIaCTI'! Pel> I1.JII1 cy6'beKTOB Pel>.
25 ,l\€Ka5psI 2006 T. 6blJIO IIpJ1HflTO I1OC'IaHOBJI€HUe IIpaBUT€JIbCTBIi
Pel> NQ 801 «(Xi yrnepm.n;elOO'l IIOJIomeHHH 05 OHm1 rocy,l:\ap-
CTBeHHoro KOHTpDJlH 1:1 Ha):I30pa 3a I1('IJ(JJlh3Ci!f€M 1:1 oxpaHOO BO,l1HblX
Om.eKTOB» 1. ComaCHO ,l:\aHHOMY aKTY .pe.n;epaJlbHbli1: KOHTpOJIb 11 Ha):I30P
,l\OBepeH POCllPUPOJ\lI8J\30PY, ,l:\aJlee Ha3BaH Kpyr AOJDttHOCTHbIX JIt:lQ
3'fVro opraHa, HBJIJIlOll{ID[CH J1HCneKTopaMl-1 no KOHTpOJllO 1:1 Ha):I30PY 3a
11CT()JIb3OBaHJt:!€M. 1:1 oxpaHoi1 BO,!J;HblX (fu.ettroo. MeponpwITIUI no rocy-
,AapCTBeHHOM)' KOHTpOJllO 1:1 H3)\30py B O'IHOllleHlflf IOpH.!UI'IE'CKItX JIt:lQ 1:1
11H,!J;I1BI1J\jIaJIbHbIX npe.rJ;npJlHJIJ\II8T€Jlei1 npoBOWITCH B COO'I1JeTCTBIrn C
Tpe6clBaHHRMI-1 c1>e,l\epaJIbHOrO 3aKOHa «0 3aIqlllTe lIpaB lOplf.nWIecKJC{
.JIJ1:QI:IIIp€AI1pIHI'1MaT€Jlei1IIpYinpoBe.n;eHJ1JfroCY,l\ap-
CTBeHHoro KOH'IpOJUI (HaJ\30pa)>>.
B CBOlO O':I€pe.IJ;b, no)]; «p=.l\epaJIbHbIi1: ItOH'IpOJib nO.D;IIa.n;alOT BHyrp€H-
IDle MOpCKI1e BOJn>1 1:1 Teppm'OpltaJIbHl)e MOpe POCCMIiI, TpaHcrpaHJ
I C3P<11.2007.NI!1f'l2) Cr 259.
-106-

BO)J;HhI€ OO'b€lIThl, nOBepXHOCTHbI€ BO)J;HhI€ OI'i'b€KTbI Ha T€ppl'1TOpmIX
.n;ByX JII 60JI€€ Cy6'b€K'roB PoccJriK'Koi1 CP€.I\epaL\ffi1, BO)J;HhI€ M€lITh! JII J1IX
"laCTIl, J1ICnOJlb3}'€MbI€ ,[IJIJ'I 060POHbI C1paHbI JII O€30naCIIOCTJII rocy,l:\apCT-
Ba, <l:J€,!J;epaJIhHbIM 'IpaHCnOpTOM JII ::mepreTJlIKOii B 3TO'I' nepe'i€Hb nona-
.I\aKYI' TaIOKe BO)J;HhI€ M€lITh! - CP€)J;a OOJlITamm 8mVij)()MHb!X JII KaT8-
,l1pOMHbIX BU):\OB phro, pblfioxcru::rflCTB€HHbIf' aanOB€,!J;HbI€ 30HbI, OCOOO
oxpaRHeMbIe npJlIlXJ,Il;HN€ TeppJlI'ropJIIJII <l:J€,!J;epa.lIbHOro 3Ha'iewm. KoH-
Tp0JIJIIPYIO'fCJ::r <l:J€,!J;epa.rIbHbIMJII opraHaJloDlI BO.I\HbI€ oO'b€lITbI JII J1IX 'iacTJII:
- HCIIOJIb3YeMH€ ,IVUI HYm,JJ; ropO,!J;OB C HaCeJIeIDIeM B 100 TbICm'i€J!G-
B€K JII 60JI€€;
- JLlliI HYm,JJ; np€JJ:!IPIDIrni1 JII opraHl13ai1, aaOJlIPalOI1I,JIIX (c6pacbIBa-
IO) BO)IJ' oO'b€MOM 60JI€€ 15 MJ!H'; B rOA
BJII060MCJIy'3:a€CJI€)IJ'€T}"i€CTh, 'ITOnpOB€pKaMpa
nO.IlJ!€maTH€ TOJIhKOXCJ3JI:i1CTsyKJUI;I1€ cy6'b€KTbI, HO J1IlIHbIe
rocY,!J;apCTB€HHbI€ JIIJ!JII MYHJIIL\I'IIIaJIbHbre opraHbI, BCT)'IIaIOUI;l1€ B ,IJ;OroBop-
HbI€ amOW€HJIIJ'I. P€'Ib JII.II€T 0 POCBO..n;pecypCax, a TaIOKe a COOTB€TCTB}'IO-
lQJIIX opraHax ItClIOJIIDIT€JIbHOi1 BJ!acrn: cy6'b€IITOB Pel> (MRHJ1CT€pc'I'Ba,
B€.I\OMCTB8.). H€ ,!J;OJDtCHbI «BbIIIEi,!\aTb» 113 nQJUI 3p€HI-1J'I POCIIpHpO,!J;H8.,/:\3Q-
paJlIreOpraHhL
EcJIJII me O,!J;Ha CTopoHa)J;OrOBqJOB BO.I\OnOJIh30BaHJIIf! IWH'IpOIDIPY€T-
CR, 8 ,li;pyraJ'I - H€T, TO H€J!b3J'I I'OBOpJlITb 0 pamronpaBJIIJl CrupOH ,IJ;OroBG-
poB. 3Toro H€JIh3H .I\onyCTJII'!'b, TaR KaK B HaCTOHI.Q;€€ Bp€MH Y 'iaCTHbIX
np€)J;IIpWIrni1 JIIOpnuma81vrn.CHJlIma€TCa ,lJ;OB€PH€ K TaKoM)'cnoco6ype-
ryJUtpOOOHIUI O1EOW€HJlIlf, KaK ,IJ;OroBOp C rocy,lJ;apCTBOM.
CamacHo CT. 10 BK Pel> IIpI1H)',V;vrreJIhHO€ npetq:laIQewle npaBa nOJrb-
3OBaIll-1R BO,!J;HhIM ofu.eK'roM HaCTyIIaeT B CJIY'ffi€ ero HeQe.neBOrO HC1lOJrb-
3OBamm, a TaKiK€ ro HeJliCIIOJIb3OBaHJIIII, HHOro HapYW€HJlIJ'I
BO.I\HOro 3aKOHO)J;aTeJIhCTBa. BbmBHB rpyObIe, H€O)J;HOKpaTHbI€ JII H€ yeT--
paH€HHbI€ Hapym€HJlIJ'I )J;OroBOpOB BQ}J;OIl0.JIh30BaHJII.fl KaKOU-MOO :JII3
craPOH, 30p ,lJ;OJDt\eH B CY,lJ;€6HOM nop.fl,lJ;K€ 1I.}Xf3aTh
paC'I'Opm€HJlIel1JD1I-£3M€HeID1€ ,lJ;OroBopOB  Bc€npl1B€-
]1€HHbI€ B03MO:IKHOCTJII]1OJDKHbI 6hITh o-rpa:m€HhI B npaBlITE'JIhCTBeHHbIX H
B€,IJ;OMCTseHHbIX 8KTaX 0 rocy,!J;apCW€HHOM BO,!J;HOM KOHTp0JI€. IIpJII :noM,
comacHO'i. 5 CT. 10 BKPeI>, npe,IJ;'bHBJ!€IDIIOTpe60saHI-1J'I a IIpeIq)8lQEfOOI
np8B8. I1OJIb3()BaRIIR BO,!J;HhIM OO'b€IITOM ]1(JJ!jKHO npe)J;Lll€CTBOB8.Tb BblH€-
C€HJII€ yrtOJ!HOMOq€HHbIM cprna:;t.f, 3aKJOO'lJIIBlllJIIM ]10I'OBOp, np€pe:m-
]1€HmI BOWnOJIh3(IBaTeJIIO-HapyIlIi1T€J!IO.
Y*€ C€if<mC 1fM€€TCR B03M(J)fCOCICTb ocyw,ecrn.rremrn OOCTB€HHOI'O
KOHTpOJUI B 06JraCTJII H3y'i€IDlJ'I, J1ICIIO.1Ib3OBaHJUI JII oxpaHbI poconlcxJlx
BOpecypcm. 3m npeB €pa.1IbHOM 3aKOH€ or 4 an-
peJlfl2005r.NQ32-cI>3 «060naJIaTe Pom:rikIocn:lc1>e)J;epa-
-107_

»I.CorJIaCHOIlO.1J:»KeHW!MnpHBe,!J;ellllOro3aKoHana-
JIaTa KOIITpO.III1pyeT ,IJ;eHTeJIbHOCTb HCIlOJIIDfI'e.J OpraHOB rocy,IJ;apcr-
BellliOH BJIaCTH JII MecrHoro CaMOynpaBJIeHJIIR JII IIpOBO,!U1T OOLIJ;eCTBeHHj'lO
3KCIIepTl-13Y KTOB JII IIpOeKTOB HOpMaTHBHbIX npaBOBblX aKTOB.
B CBoeH ,IJ;eHTeJlbHOCTJII 06LIJ;ecTBemffiR na.rraTa npJll3BaHa 06ecne<n1Th co-
r.naCOBaHJlle  3Ha'lJllMblX MHTepecOB ,IJ;JUI perneHJIIR BaiKHbIX
BOIlpOCOB 3I\OHOMJII'1€CI\OrO JII COUJl/8JIbHOro pa3BJ11TI1ff, o6ecne<iemm HaUWo-
HaJIbHOH i5EBooacHocTIr. rnpaB JII cBCfxJ,!\ Ipam,!laH PoccJUL
B CJ1JIY Jf3JII:DKf2HHbIX rrOJIomeHJ-ri1 06LIJ;eCTBeHHbrn: KOHTpOJIb B o6JIac-
TJII BO,IJ;HbIX arHOllIemm MOmeT KaCaTbCR, B TOM "IJIICJIe, B03HIfKHOB('IDm,
Jll3MeHeIDIH JII IIpeKpalIJ'IDUI npaB Ha BO.rr;HbIe OObeKTbI. 3anpoCbI JII 3a-
KJOO'1eIDUI 06LIJ;eCTBeHHOH rraJIaTbl He MOryr OCTaBaTbCR 6e3 BHHMaIDIR
opraHOB rocy,IJ;apc'I1J€HllOK BJIaCTJII JII MecTHoro caMoyrrpaBJIeIDIR, XOTR
peweHJIIR rraJIaTbIHeHBJ1HlOTCROOR3aTeJIbHbIMM.
Pa3YMeeTCR, K BO,IJ;HOM}' KOmpOJlIO pa3HO npJll06LIJ;aTb He
TOJIbKO 06LIJ;ecTBeHHyro rraJIary Pocm:iiCKOH cpe,!\epaLlI1Jll, HO JII 06eCT-
BeHHbie rraJIaTbI cy&beKTOB F'occmicRoii c.fIe.nepaIU'JJf. a TalOKe 06eCT-
BeHHble COBeTbl pa3Jlll'lHbIX MJIIIDICTepCTB JII Be,!\OMCTB. B CBH3J11 C 3T11M
3anpOCbl, 3aKJOO'1eHWI JII KOHrp0JIbHbIe MepOIIpI1RTJ-rn 06CTBeHHblX
rra.naT «pa3HbIX ypoBHeH» BnOJllle Moryr OTHOCJIITbCR JII K o6mlcm JIIC-
rr0JIb30BaHIDI JII oxpaHbI BO,!\HbIX 06'beKToB.
3. OC06EHHOCTH YnPABnEHH Hcnonb30BAHHEM
 OXPAHO MAJlblX PEK. roPOJ1CKHX
H nPHropoAHblX BOA
MaJn.le peKU uyaqt;aIOTCfI B oco6oH oxpaue.  JII ,l\aJIeKO
He'laCThKJpe<iHbIX6acceJIHOBJllrro,!\DacceiiHoBHBJlHKYI'CHMa-
JIbIe peKH. B POCCID-I Hac'Ufl'bIBa€TC1l OKOJIO 2 MJlH MaJIbIX pelt «MaJn,IMM» B
HayqHOH .mrreparypeJIIMeHJlOT peKU C IIJIOIOBO,IJ;Oc6opaPP 2 TblC. ro:l-
JIIcpeM pacxO,!\OMBO):\blpp 5'; Ic 3a rrepJllo,lJ; ID13KOroCTOKa
B cpe.n;HeM no POCCJIIJII Ha MaJlbIe peKU npJIIXO,IJ;J-ITCR 5t1,C OO'beMa pe'IHoro
CTOKa JII 800/0 npoTIDKellliOCTJll rn,11pOrpa ce'!'!!. Ha3BaHHble BO)\o-
TOKJllJllMelOTIBXJIIMJII'-lecKOMCOCTaBeBO):\bI.lIeHHbIerroiiMbI,Bo-
PPIIa)J;bI, OOpblBbI, a rroJrffiC - JII pe,IJ;KMX 06J11TaTeJIeti
I C3P$.2005.N!!1S.Cr 1277
2lll6BeHKOM.Ar1D06J1eMblMBI1b1Xpe"PocCII"HCTBIIQ.!J.a:I1J)(Ifu1eM"'HPe-
UJeHM 2009.NII.C.84-87.
-108-

B cl1J1)' CBOJ.-lX pa3MepoB MaJible peKl1 HaJ.-l60Jlee ,l:\OC1yllHbI,l\JIH OCBoe-
HJ1.FII1 x03Hii:CTBeHfmro IfCIDJIh3()Ba}Uffi (B TOM 'lJ1CJle 11,l\J1R BO,lJ;OCHa6jK€-
lIY!JI). OKOMaJiblepeKl1, OC06eHHOB sacyIllIDIBbIX30HaX, HCIIbITbIBaIOT
Ha ce6e 6o.rrbrnyK> :urrponoreHHyIO Haipy:3KY. Ha6.mo)J;aeTC.R l1HTeHCUB-
HOe 3<lI'pfl3HeID1e CTO'iHblMJ-f BO,lJ;aMJ.-I, 1ij:\OXJ.-Il'IIJ1KaTaMY!, HeIlJTenpo.!I,YKTa-
MY!,  BbropocaMJ1. IIpu HapyrneHllill MHom:x Tpe6oBaHJrli:
3aKOHO,lJ;a'reJlbCTBa IIpOUCXOIJ,IIT pacnaWKa J1 3acTpOiiiKa 6eperoB. B Xo)];e
BapBapCKOiii 3Kcn.nyaTaLtJ.-lU 6bIJThI HapyrneHbI I1pJtpo CTOKOO6pasy-
lOe KOMl1JleKCbI (noiiiMbI, Jleca, 6oJlOTa), 'ITO ym.e npJ.-IBeJlo K COKpall.\e-
lIY!1OCTOKaMaJlblX peK6cIJlee 'IeM HanQJIOBJilH)'. MHor:we MaJIbIe peKHnQJI-
HOC'l'blO HC'le3.ID1, "ITO IIpOJ.-ICXOIUIT He TOJlbKO B apJ.1,lJJlblX paiiiOHax. e
B MOCIOCJEIO«)n o6mCTll3a nOJ1TOpa BeRa npeKpaTi-1JIO CBoe CYll.\ecTBOBa-
lIY!e,l:\O 25-30% MaJibIX peK. Bbl3blBaIOT ,na.rreKOJ1.l1;,YlQl-1e noc.rre.IJ;CTBIDI 06-
MeJleHYIe 1i13apacTaHJ1e pyceJi MaJlblX peE\:: OT cfle3BoJKJ.-IBaHI1.fI CTenei1:)];o
CI1JIbHOro .IJ;IDK,J:J;eBoro naBOp;Ka 1i13-3a }'MeHbrneHJ1Jl BMeCTJiMOCTIl ,nerpa-
,W1poBaHHoro pyCJIB.
K coma.nemno, pa6o'l'b1 no O'll1CTKe .IJ;Ha, 3all.\l1Te 6epera, 6oPb6e C 3po-
31leii, BOCCTaHOBJIeIDflO JleCOB B BO,IIOOXp8.HHbIX 30Hax COB€p1LEHHO He
npoBO,!\JITCJI.mrooIIJXJBO,llHTC.R. Me 'reM perneIDIe 3a,l\a-
"'lJII 3aTblMaJlblX peK -rpe6yeTnpOBe,!J;emrn MepolIpI1HTI1iiino BceM}'T€-
'IeHI1lO - «07 J1CTOKa ,1:\0 YCTb.R». fBH()Ji OCTaeTC.R CUCTeMa
HOpMYlpOBaIDIH 1JQI:PII0JIb30BaID1H Ha BO,lJ;oc60pax MaJibIX peR, B€CbM3 BJI-
JlO B€JIYTC.R npoeKTHble pa6o'l'bJ no 06YCTpoiiiCTBY Bo;woxpaHHblX 30H iii
J'!X npl16pe:lKHblX 3ablX noJlOc. IIpaKTI-I'IeCKI1 He paapa6aTbIBaIOTCH
qeJIeBHe nporpaMMbI no BOCCTaHOBJleHI1lO MaJibIX peK PerneHJ1Jl 0 crpo-
JIT€JlbCTBe I1IDKeHepHbIX coopymeIDri1 (B TOM <mcJle rrC) npYlHHMalOTCH
np:w HeOIIpaB.rI3HHO nepeBece 3IOCJH()MI('IecKtIX J1JITepeCOB, a CBMJ1 npo-
elITbl CTpOHTeJIbCTBa He yqJ1TbIBBlOT IIpHpO.[(OOxpaHHbIX 3B):1a'l.
lIaJ:1o npl13HaTb, 'lTO B COBeTCKIrn: nepuo,!\ MHOrl1e MaJIbIe peKl1 6bLID:!
06'beKTOM 3aOOT rocy.napcTBa, OlIeKaJillCb 06ll.\eCTBaMJ.-I oxpaHbI npJ.-lpo-
.IJ:bL B O,IJ;Hofl HpocJiaBcKoi11 06.nacTu y-'JJITblBaJll1Cb 11 OlIeKaJUIICb 06.naCT-
HbIM 06ll.\eCTBOM oxpaHbI npl1po.IJ:b123 MaJible peKl1, BenCH yqeT TaKOBblX
BO 8na)J;IfMJq:ctroii: 06mCTll 11 B KpaCHOMpcKOM Kpae. PeKt:l JIaxOC'l'b,
Cl-1Tb, Co.oolJrIQa, KoTOpoCJIb, HellWl, KpacHaH 11 MHorne .npyrne J1MeJll1
3aMeTH)'IO 3all.\WI'Y. B Te'leIDIe H€CKf)JIbIOtX .IJ;ecHTJ-1J1€T11iii OllY! BXOAMJUI B
ceTb oco6o oxpaHHeMbIX Tep(MIqJJfl1:. B H3H6o.nee l{ellliblX CBOJ.-lX)"IBCT-
KaX T€'IeHI1.fI MaJibIe pettY! J1 J1X npJ.-l6p€:IKHbIe I CTaHOBi-1JIJ1Cb 3a-
IXEeJUflIKBMJf, 3aKa3HI1KaMY!, naMHTHJ1KBMJ1 npl1po.IJ:b1 .
I nblCI1I' /( r 0 nBMmHKa>( I1PPOJ:lbl POCCH M: CBeTC"B POCCH. 1982 C 63-{i4
-109-

.uo 1990 T. B 6cIJlee 200 HOpMaTIfBHbIX npaBOBbIX aKTOB perJIaMeH'l'RpO-
BaJlJ1Cb OTHowemUI B CBH311 C MaJIbIMI1 peKaMl1. O,!!,HaKO, KaK nO,!J;'lepKl1-
BaJIaHaY'lHaH,.lIameBOBp€MJIHaJ16o.nbnreroBlillMaIDUI
roCYMpcTBa JII 051Q€C'TBa K npo6JIeMaTl1Ke MaJIbIX peK 1Illi0rne peKl13KC-
IIJIY8TI1pOBa.IDlCh «1Ia J113HOC»,.lIO yracaHl1H.
B CBoe BpeMJI6blID1 pa3pa6crraHbITaKl1e .IJPKYM€H'I'H.
KaK CXeMbI oxpaHbI BO.ll MaJIbIX pelt 1990 T., nacnopTa «M8JIbIX peR»
(1980-1985 IT.). TeM8TJ11Ka «M8JIbIX peK» IIpI1cyI'CTBOBaJIa B CxeMe KOM-
lIJIeKCHoro I1CIlOJIbaOBaIDVI JII oxpaHbI BO.l\HbIX pecypCOB POCClfl1.l10 2005 T.
(1992 T.), exeMax y.rryqrneHl1H 'ft:'XlIWIeCI«1'O COCTOHID1H JII 6JIaroYCTpOH-
CTBa BO.nOXJ>8HI'fJlDlt JII IIpu6pemHbIX 30H (1970-1980 IT.). BcH 3Ta .lIOKY-
MeHTaqMR 6bIJIa pa3pafuraHa Ha eOJH-OM Ha}"lHoi1oo3e. O.llHaKO sa ,[\Ba
.lIeCHTKa JIeT npoI-f3oWJIJII ycrapeBaHl1e npl1B€,!\eHHbIX AOK}'MeHTOB, IIpI1-
eK0p6HaH YTpaTa «p€'llibIX» nacnDpToB, ROTopbIe oceJlJ1 B pyttax 'l8CT-
HbIX  HaY'IHoe JIICCJle.llOBaHl1e COBpeMemDIU eocrOffill1H peR He npo-
BO)JW1I1, a, 3Ha'll1'l', He 6bIJIa C03,IlaHa P€30HHaJI OCHOBa ,II)lH nO,!\fOl'OBKI1
HOBbIX exeM JII nacnopTOB.
PH,l\ aBTopoB B»,.f\HT KJllOq K pellI€HlliO IIpOIirI€M M8JIblX peR B B0305-
HOBJI€HI11-'1 H86JI10AeHJIIM 3a TI1)J;pOTeXH1-'IQeCRI1MI1 nOKa3aTeJIHMI1 B
)'BH3K€' C 6110Jl1MH, MI1Rpo6JIIOJIOIH'i€CKJ1MI1, TCJKCJIIKOJIOCJIeC-
KI1MI1 Ha6JI1o.ll€HJIIHMI1. 3TO eO'leTalDI€ n03BOJII1T BbIHBI1Tb eTeneHb aH-
TpOnOreHHOrO B03.l1eMCTBJ1H Ha «6J11ory» - Macey OpralDf3MOB, 0611TalO-
I1tI1X B BO.llOTOKe. B CEOIO Oqepe,!1b, perneHl1e np05JIeM M8J1b!X pelt
paCCM8Tp1lE8eTCfI I1M11 H8 qx,He perneHl1.fI 60JIee rJ106aJlbHbIX 3KOJI0f11-
'leCKI1X IIp06JI€M 11 sa.lla'l (c OTxo,!\aMl1, JIeconoca.wtaMI1, ymeCTQ'leHl1e
3KOJI0l'W:lecKoro KOHTpOJIJI). KpOMe Toro, np€.lInOJIaralOTCH KOHKP€T-
HbIe MepOnpHHTIfH no B03Ct'.iHOWI€HI1IO nacnopTI138lV-'1l1 MaJIbIX peR C
IIpI1BJIeqem:!€M llIJlpOKI1X RpyroB 06IQeCTBeHHOCTI1 K npoB€.lIeHl1lO Ha-
finlO,!1eHtd:J: 11 c50py I1H4JOpM8W11i1 05 3TIiIX MaJlbIX, HO IIpIil 3TOM ,lI;OBOJIb-
HO BamHbIX, BOJ\OTOKaX.
MaJILIe peKl1 He nOJlJleiKaT npl1BaTlf3aQIOL IIp05JI€MbI M8JIbIX pelt
HeJlb3H pellIl1Tb, He nOJIOiKJ1B npt',!\eJI «pa:masapl1BaHI1IO» IiIX Ha -qaCT-
Hble IIpy,!\bI H l\8pbepbl. 3aI1pymJlBaID:!e M8JIb!X peR C JIIX IXJCJIe.v:yICIWWI
pa3,!\€JIOM Ha He6o.rrbWlile pyc.nom,re Bo,!\oeMbI npoJllCXO,Il;J1JIO He TOJlbKO
I1p11 COBpeMeHHoi1: KOTTeoti 3aC'lpJibce, HO ente JII I1p11,lI,eHT€.1IbHOCTJll
ROJ1X030B JII COOX03OB. .uo Hamero BpeMeHIiI coxpaHI1JII1Cb npy,lJ.b!, 06pa-
30BaHHble H€KorJ\a J\JIH ce.1lbCKOX03.Hi1CTBeHHblX Hy:a\A O,l\H8KO COBp€-
MeHHbrn arponpoMblIlIJleHHblM JOOMIIJI€J{C yme He H)':a\,!I;aerCH B HI1X. IIpl1
3TOM HbIHeWIUle 'l8CTHble cof:crBeJnnnul 3eMeJIbHbIX y<>aCTKOB, B npe-
.u;eJIax KOTOpbIX pacno.rraralOTCH npYAbI, CMOryr C'IJiITaTb ceOH JIX X03H€-
BaMl1, TQJIbKO eCJJt1 Tocy.u;apCTBQ npll3Ha€T npeKpalQeHt1e cyntec'1'B(E3.-
-110_

HHH MaJIOH peKI1 (j)y'ibH), sanpy,Jla KOTopOH B CBee BpeMfI JII npl1BeJIa It
JLXC03,!J;amno. O,IJ;HaKO,l:\aHHOe peWeHl1e .l\OJImH06bITb He cyfYbeKTI1BHbIM
H npoIf3BOHbHbIM, a HayqHO 060CHOBaHHbIM. IIo3'roM}' AOJDKHO 6bITb KBa-
JllI$fQI1POO<lHHO€ 3alUIICI'IeHHe rJ.-J,IWOJIoroB no BOnpOcy a xapaKTepe cy-
 BOJJ;HbIX o6neJcroB. IIOCKOJIbRY onpe,!\eneHl1e Kpyra BO,Q-
HblX 06'beRTOB, MorYIQIiIX 6b!Tb B 'iacTHOH ccfJcTBeHHocTJII, - AeJlO
rocy,JlapCTBa, a He ':IaCTHbIX.1IJ1q, TO yme sapaHee.l\O o1:IopMJIemrn ':IaCT-
HOH c06cTBeHHoCTI1 Ha 3€M€JIbHbIe }"iaCTKH, OXBa'!HBalOlQll€ Te JllJIJ'!
HHbJe BO.n;oeMbl, rocy,IJ;apcTBelllible opraHbI BJIaCTI1 06H3aHbI apr)'MelITl1-
poBaHHO OIlpeAemtTb JII SaHeCTIf B BO,l:\HbIH peeCTp BI1,I:\ Tom JIIJII1 JllHom
BO,l:\HOm 06'beRTa. B nparl1BHOM c.rryqae B03MO:iKHa npl1BaTl13aqllii }"ia-
CTIWB IIO,D;IIpy1l(€HJ«)H peR", 'ITO CaMO no ce6e .HBJUleTCH HapyweH"eM H
Bbl3blBae-r 01pl1Il;aT€'JlbHble IIOCJJ€,l\CTBJUL
Ha npl1Mepe II€':IaJIbHOii CY.l\b6bl MaJibIX peR, pa3.JJ;€JJHeMbIX H8. PYKO-
TBopHble BQIJ.OeMbl, MruKHO C,I:\eJIaTb JllJllHOH BbIBO):I, Tp€H J113MeHe-
HJ-rlI B 3aKOHO,l:\aT€'JlbCTBe. B l\eJIHX roxpaHI2lB1H I.1;eJlOCTIIOCTl1 BO,l:\aJ'OKa JII
o6ecne'1eID1R {'):IJ:nuH em OXpaHbl 6b1J1o 6b1 OqeHb IJOne3HHM 3anpeTIITb
np.wBaTYl3aql1ID pycJIOBbIX npy.l\OB 11 pycJIOIillX RapbepoB. Cnet\YeT no-
MHJffb, 'ITO pyCJlOBbie Rapb€pbl B03HHKalOT OT .l\06b1'1J1 nOJle3HbIX 11CKO-
naeMbIX Ha )];lIe peKJ1. IIORa B CHJI.Y npo6eJIOB JII li€,lICM)JIOOK COBp€MeHHO-
ro 3aKOHa :n11 BO,l:\OeMbI MOryr 6b!Tb B ':IaCTIIOH co6cTseHlJ(X"l'l'1. .D:J1JI :nom
.l\OCTaTOqHO JIHlllb OpMY!Tb npaBa H8. OXBaTbmaIDIl\I-rii aKBaTopl1IO 3e-
MenbHbIii yqaCTOK.
3atIa- OXp3Hbl II BOCCTaHOBJICHII!I ropo,IJ;CKJIX H npnropo,IJ;HbIX BO,IJ;.
POCCIDICK!1e ropo,IJ;a npaKTw,reCKJI BC€r,IIa C03):1aBa.ID1Cb Ha 6eperax JIIJII1
B6JIJ1311 OT Y.l\06HbIX ,l\JIH ':IeJIOBeKa BO,l:\HbIX 06'beRTOB. JhlTepeCHO, ':ITO
3TII BO,I:\Hble 06'beKTbl BCer,Jla 6bLlll1 y.l\06HbJ .l\.IIH HC1lOJlb3OBaHHfl, HO He-
pe,!J;KOKCpe,!{HI1MJllMaJlbIM:nOaKBaTOpI1i-'lHnrrOLqa,!{l1Bo-
,l:\oc60pa. IIoMl1MO scem npo'lero ClfC'I'eMa BO,l:\HhIX 06'beKTOB CJlJ'Kt1T xo-
poweii OCHOBfJiii ,l\JlfI BO)J;HbIX n}'T€'i1, C03,lJ.8HJIIJI 3eneHoi1 SOHb! ropo):la H
np.wropo):la, ca;J;OBo-naptWBOro KOMIIJleKCa, neconaptWBOro 3all1THoro
nOHCa.
B BO;:uIOM SaKDHO):laTeJlbCTBe POCCI1I1 6b1JIa  $?,!\epaJlb--
HaH co6cTseHHOCTh H8. Bce ropo,!\cKJle BO,!\Hble OObeKThl, KpOMe npY.l\OB H
 Kaphepos. IIpl1 STOM ,JIame OTHOCItre1IbHO He60Jib!lll1e no
]1JIJ1He peKI1 (MoCKBa, HeBa) HaXOJ1.llTCR B $?,!\epaJIbHoA Co6cTBeHHOCTI1,
TeM 6o.rree, ':ITO OHI1 OMbIBaIQT He O,!\!1H cyfu.eKT 41eAepa (roPO):la 4>e-
.l\epaJIbHoro 3Ha':leHHH JII np"MblKaIOlQlile K HJlM 06.rraCTl1). O;:J;HaKO B HOP-
MaJlbHOM C':OC'IOmllD1 IIO,J:J,06m.Jx peR He B MeHbWeH creneHJI3aJIIHTepeco-
BaRbI 11 cyD'beKTbI 4Ie.z1epal\ID'l (B 'laCTHOC'IU, ropoA<l $',l1€p8JIbHOI'O
3Ha':leHHH), 11 MYHtfi-ltma.JIbHble 06paaosaHJUL B JI3B€CTHOi.i Mepe JIIHTepec

pernOHaJlbHbIX H MYHHIJWI8JIbHbIX OpraHOB BJIaCTI'! K BO,!\HbIM OTHOWem'l-
JIM B npe,!J;eJlax HX 30HbI  MruKeT 6bITb y,!\OBJIeTBOpeH B
paMKaX ,l\eficTByrol1\ero 3aKOHo.n;aTeJlbCTBa. Be,!\b BR PIl> npe):1yCMaTpI-'l-
BaeT .v,e.rreI11pOB3ID1e $?,!\epaJlbHbIX nOJlllOMO'lJ1i1 no npemuo
BO,qRbIX 06DeKTOB B IIOJIb3OIJaHIte cym,eKTaM PIl>.
HeCOBeprneHHa J-I1-1Hcp:,pMal\I-'IOHHafl6a3a,  ynpaB-
JleHl1e BO.n;Hbll\orn  B ropo,!\CKoi1'lepTe. CrrymaI..qHi1 no.n;cnopbeM
AJlj'I BO,qROro peeCTpa, BO,!\Hbrn Ka.n;acrp Benc)'! OK0J10 70 JleT, ero ,MHHble
Heo,!\HoKpaTHO o6HoBJm.Jrnu. Ho 3TOT «6aHK ,MHHbIX» TaK H QCTaeTCR He-
nOJlllblM, coo6ll\aR CBOK) HenomlOTY peecTpy. .l{ame B 'lepTe ropo):\oB-Me-
ranOIDfCOB MaJlble BO,!\OTOKJ'l JII BO,!\oeMbI He HallIJlJll ,!\OJDfaIoro OTpameHl1H
B BO,qROM peeCTpe. npJIIMepOM MomeT CJIYm'lTh r. CaHKT-nerep6ypr, l',IJ;e
no):\06HhIX BObIX 06DeKTOB MAoro, HO BOnpOC 06 JIIX JllHBeHTapM33.qI-'IJII
el1\e He peweH .
3KruIOlWlecKOe 03,!\opOBJIeHl1e KpynHbIX ropO,!J;OB Tpe6yeT BbiCBO-
6om,n;eHI-ffl 3aK.JIIO'l€HHHX B Tpy5bl BOAOTQI\OB, OKYJIb'I)'pJ1B8HHH OTpa-
60TaHHbIX KapbepOB, BOCC03,l\aHl'1H 3eJleHbiX 30H. B pOCClfiiCKW{ ropo-
,l\ax CJleJI.YeT He ,l\onYCKaTb 3acTpoAKy 6eperOB B)10Jlb peK - 3TO
IT03BOJIHeT C03.n;aTb «xopl1,!\Opbl ITpoB€'Ip1BB.lllmJo. I[eJl€c()o6pa3HO qx,p-
MRpoBaHue l{eJloii: cen1 TeppJil'TOpffi1: JII aKBaTOpml, He TOJIbKO 6J1aro-
npJIIHTHbIX ,IJ,JIH petq)€8l{l'1H, pbiOOJIOOCTBa, cnopra, HO JII 6.nar0TB0pHHX
,lJ,JlJI ropO,!J;CfOOii:cpe,!\bL no,!\06HaJI C€Tb 3KOJlOlW-leCKJII3Ha':lI1Mb1X Teppl1-
TOpffi1: .u;OJDKHa llII1pOKO OXBaTblBaTh KaK ropo):\, TaK J-I np11l"Opo):\H)'IO 30-
HY. B Ka':lecrBe npl1MepoB MOiKHO npHBeCTJII ,!\Ba crapblx eBpone:i1CKJ1X
ropo):\a - CTpac6ypr (cppaHl{l1J1) JII I[K>pJIIX (lIIBeifitapl1J1). B CTpac6ypre
6b1Jl pa3pa6oTaH 1:1 peaml3YeTCJI «3eJleHo-ronyfuii TIJlaH». B.n;OJlb KaHa-
JlOB JII peK TJlHyrCJI «3eJleHble KJIJ1HbJI» 1:1 «npeAMeCTbJl-Ca,Ilbl», .HBJlHIO-
IltJII€CJI npl:lpO.n;HbIMI1 napKaMI1, a pelJHbIe noii:MblI:I nyra nOJlyql-'lJlJ1 CTa-
TYC npl1poiJ.HbIX pe3epBaTOB. .lI:oJlI'oe BpeMli I[K>pJIIX 6b1Jl nfi'aHTCf«)ii
L"I'pOim.rrI, rAe CBO,!\11JIJII «Ha HeT» 3eJleHbIe JII ceJIbCKOXro.HH::r-
BeHHble 30Hbl, eCTeCTBeHHble BO)I;O'I'OlQL 3aT€'M B peKpeal{l10HHbIX H
3KCJJiOI'K'I€CIl{eJlHX OK0J10 5W paHee nOM€ll\eHHbIX B TPyDbl 
06'beK'TOB OCB a 30Hbl OT,l\bIXa CBJI3bIBaJIJIICb 'lepe3 pea6>-r-
Jll'ITI1poBaHHb!e peKI1 C COXpam1BIIDIMlICH Ha ropHblx CKJiOHaX JIE'CHbIMJI
MaCCI1BaMI1. npJIIMe'IaTeJlbHO, ':I'TO 3eJleHbie 30HbI J-I OT'laCrn BO,!\Hble aK-
BaTOpl11-'1 HaXOJ1.llTCfl B se.n;eHI1JII €AI-'IHOro opraHa - YnpaBJleHI-ffl C8)10B 1:1
1 BfrJlttO<JlHB,C,"fJIJ,On"'TKa,r\aCTpoBflCWt",xofu.eo<mBME!ranOJ1ca(HaOjWlMe-
pefCaHI(T-f1eoreD6ypraJ.OHrpeccpa!SOTHI((IBBCWtOroTeJl>ICbI
J1O<J1aAOB M..2( I.C 103-104.
-112-

JIaH)J;W*oB 1 . TmU'IM 06pa30M, «seJIeHO-ro.ny6ble TIJIaHbl» npe,!J;)'CMaT-
pMBalOT KOMllJIeKC MepOnpH.flTlm. no BOCCTaHOBJIeHlliQ I'OpO,!\CKI-1X J:!
npl-1ropO,!\HhIX JIaH,1\IlIa<!YrOB. KaK npe,!\CTaBJI.fIeTCR, «3eJIeHO-I'0Jly6hIe
TIJIaHbI» amyaJIbHbI 11 AJIJI PocoBL
RnaCTI1 I'. MOCRBbI HaM€T11JIJII npeBpaLIJ;eID'le ceBepo-BOCTOKa CTOJiJ'ILIhI
B O)J;l-1H 6o.nbw:&1 nijJ;ponapK. Cpa3y 12 TeppJITOpJ.ril, JIemaLIJ;HX no 6epe-
!'aM HY3bI, JlHxo6opKl1, qepMflHKl-1 11 pe'iJlllKl1 J1'lK11, IIp-fClIooo6neHbl
AJIJI OTro>IXa, pa3BJIeQeHIDlI1 cnOpTMBHhIX 3aHmMM rop<»t\aH 2
4. npOEKTHPYEMA MOI\Enb
PA3BHTH BOI\HOro X03CTBA POCCHH
BO,!\llaH crpa'I"eI'IUI POCCI1I1I1 BbI3QBbI XXI B. B06.naCTI-l-
CTBeHHOM ,!\eH'I'€JThHOCTIf npUHHM310TCH roCY):la nporpaMMbl,
IIJIaHhl, ,l\Olcrp1fHb1, e onpe,!\eJIeHH)'JO Mo,!\eJIb pa3BIITIDI
OTeqeCTBeHHoro BO)1HOro xoasrlicTBa.
20 aBrycTa 2009 I'. B qeJIHX tre. 1iI3MeHeHKH COCTIIJllfIiIH
BO,!UIOro xo3IDicTBa npe3M,D;H)'M HpaBlfT€JIbCTBa Pip o,!\oOpliIJI BO)J;llJIO
CTpa-remlO)10 2020 I'. 3aTeMIlOCJIOBaJIOpaCnOpIDK€'IDIe npamrenbCT-
Ba PtP OT 27 aBrycTa 2009 r..M 1235-p (06 IK BO,!\Hoti: cTpa-
Tel'liIM Poc 41eAepaw.rn Ha neplilo'!\)1o 2020 r. 11 nJIaHa Meponplil-
mMMnoeeopDI»3_
BMecre c oi1 CTpa:rerne» 6b1J1 pa3pa60TaH lI.naH Mep:mpJ1H'l'J1i1 no
peaJrn3aIJ;ID'l oi1 CTpaTeI'liIM POCCIDIClWii 41e,!\epaDW-f Ha neplilo,!\ )10
2020 I'. B Ha3BaHHOMTIrraHe J1MeeTCH pa3,!\eJI I «CoBepIIHrI'BOB<Ullte HOpMa-
TIiIBHOI'O npaBOBOrO p_lll-1M> 6yiJYl' no.zqx:6HO paCCMOTp€'HhI
OTeJThHbIel1, IIOJIroKeHl1R liIycraHOBKI1 &,!\Hoti: CTpareIID'lPocCl1l1.
J1TaK, ):lame He HBJlHHCb 3aKOllOM, Bo,!\HaH CTpaTentH 6Y,!J;€T BJIJ-1HTb
Ha BO,!J;Hhle npaoooTIIDwemm 11 pa3BlilTlile BO)J;HOrO X03mICTBa. 3To 06yc-
JIOBJIeHO TeM, 'ITO B He» npe.n;ycMUI'J)€ HeMaJible I13MeHeID'lH B npaBe-
BOM perY.III1pOB<UOO'I BO)J;HbIX OTHOllleHJnl KaR Ha ypoBHe 3aKOHOB, TaR J:!
Ha ypoBHe n3KTOB-
&,!J;HaH CTpaTemJI Pocom HanpaBJIeHa Ha BO,!\opecypCHoe o6ecn€'-Ie-
ID'Ie KOHl-1;e ,!J;OJITOCpO'-IHoro --3I«JH(MJ.{q€CKOl'O pa3Blmm
13apy6e>l:HbIOnbITJ:1BHf1OPe<pepaTl<BHbIX)!(}IPffi\IIOBE!I"HI1TIt1.{1xpaHilI1PHPQl1l>H
l1pHpo.!1HblXpecypcoB. M..2001 N!l10C.70;2ool NI11 C75
2 a.o.nO","OCO\aOra3eTB.2oo5.N!!05(148)
3 C3P<t1.2009.N!l36.CT.4362
-113-

Poccm1cm:Jji tlJe.JJ;epawll1Ha neplilo)];]102020 TO)];a, yrnepm,I\eHHOMpaCnO-
pIDKeHI1eM lTpaBItTeJIbC'I'Ba PCPar 17 HruIDpJ'/200B T. NQ 1662-1'.
Bo)J;HaH CTpaTenm 3aRpellJIHeT 6a30BbIe npJUlL(lnIbI roCy,JlapCT-
BeHHoH nOJH1TI1KI1 B 06JIaCUI J-ICnOJIb30BaHI1fl J-I oxpaHbI BO]1HbIX oD'b-
eRToB, npe]1ycMaTplilBaeT nplUUITlf€ J-I peaJIl-13a'-tl1lO ynpaBJleH'I€CKIiIX
peIIIelDm no coxpaHeHIiIKJ BO)J;HblX 3KOClilCTeM, o6ecn HaM-
6o.numm COI-ttmJJbHldii J-I :31OCJHOMKtI€ClUIH 3tl>cpeKT, II C03.JJ;aHI1€ yCJIO-
BI1H AJIH 3tl>cpeRTIfilHOrO B3al1MO,IJ;€HC'IBIm yq8.CTHmtOB BO,IJ;HbIX OTHO-
llleH11i-i.
OcHOBHbIMJI KTOpaMJI HfOH3JIbHOCO  BO)J;HblX
pecypCOB HBJIHlO1'CH:
- np:fMeHeID1E' yCTapeBIlll1X BO,IJ;O€MKJ1X npol-13Bo,!\CTBeHHbIX T€'XHOJIO-
rni-i;
- BI:oIC()RIm ypoBeHb nOTepb BO,!\bI I1p1il '!J)aHCI1OIYruIXERe;
- He,IJ;OCTaTO'IHaJI CTeneHb 0CTI'1 Bo,!\o3a60pHbIX coopyme-
HJ1i1CI1CTeMaMJI}"ieTa;
-arcY'rerBI1es4xPeKT!iIBHblXMeXaHJf3M{E.,CTI1M)1'JIJI-
pyKJll.\WX 61i13HeC K aKTI1BHOM)' BHe.npeHJ1KJ nporpeccIlBHbIX BO,!\oc6epera-
 TexH(JJI(JnI:K IIpDIf3BQJ:ICTBa, CI1CT€M o60poTHoro J-I nOBTopHo-no-
cne,IJ;OBaT€'JIbHOro BO.JJ;ocHa6meHHJIJ-I coKpall\eHJfIOHenpoIT€JIbHblX
mYrepbBO,!\bL
JJ;eq)Jru;wr BO)UIbIX pecypCOB B ar]1eJIbHbIX peI1l()Ha"{ crpaHbI B03ID1Ka-
eTBocHoBHoMBenepl1oLB:x3mfiCHUB€Hlt€,IJ;e(j)a06yc-
JIOBJIeHO CJIe,!\JlOJ.lC-'!MM IIplI'll1H8.MJIf.
- HepaBHOMepHOCTb pacnpe.neneIDIH BO.n;Hb1X pecypcoB no T€'PPlilTO-
pmrP()C()o1j'ICIriicI>e.L\epaWlli;
- OrpaHM'!:€HHOCTb peryJIJlpYIOll.\WX B03MO)ttHOcreH 
]1JUI Y]10BJIeTBOpeHMfl pecypaiOH nO'l'pE'6oocTu HaceJIeHJ-1Jl, npOMbnIlJl€H-
HOCTJ1, CeJIbCKOrO X03ID1cma, pbIDHOro X03..!rliCTBa, BH)'Tp€llliero BO,!\HOro
TpaHcnopTa.
ITo ypOBHlQ ]1oc'I)'TIa HaCeJIeHHII K CIiICT€MaM l{€H'I'p8.JIJ'IB8.HH()I'O BO-
]10CHa6meHIiI.fI PoocmkKa.fl cI>e.L\epawm YC'I)'TIaer pa3BHTbIM CTpaHaM, B
KOTOpblX 3T()T nOKa3aTeJIb COCTaBJIHeT 90-95% J-I60JIee.
113 o6Il\ero o&beMa BO,!\bI, no,!\aBaeMoH B II;€HTpaJThl30I3<HllibIe CI-1CTeMbI
HaCeJIeHHbIXn}'HKTOB, '1epe3CJ11CTeMbIBO
nponycxaeTCJ'/ He 6o.nee 59'"""0, B CeJIbCKI1X HaCeJIeHHbIX n;yHKTax 3TOT 110-
Ka3aTeJIb He IIpeBbnnaeT 2W.... DKOJIO 27% BO,!\03a60poB J-I3 nOB€p."{H)l"f-
HbIX J1C'TO'IIIJfKOB BO,!\OCHa6:m:eIDUI He J-IMeKYf He06xo,IJ;J1MOro lWMIIJIeKCa
O'illCTHbIX coopymeHJ-liii:, B'roM 'IJICJle 16<0 He 0CHaIl{€HH 06e33apa:m:J-1Ba-
lOIl\I-1MJ1 YCTaHOBlUlMJL

npl10pvrreTHblM mnpaBJI€HI1eM COBepllieHC'I1J(E8HI1H rocY.MpCTBeH-
H01'O ynpaBJIeHHfl HBJIHeTCR peaJIl13aLJ;l1H CJIelQTIOlW1X npe.DyCMUrpEfl-
HbIX Bo;:nIblM KO.n;eKCOM pcp MeXaHI£3MOB
- pa3pa60TKa CXeM IroMIIJIeKCIDrO JIICII0JIb30BaHI1H JII OXpaHbI BO):!HblX
06'beKTOB;
- pa3pa6orKa HOpMaTI1BOB l1cnyCTI1Moro B03]1eHcTmiH Ha BOe
06'beKTbI,}"iJII'lNOO peI1fOIl8.1IbHb Occ6eHHoc'I1f JII 
Hble XapalITeplfC'rnKJf BO,!\HbIX 06'beKTOB;
- pa:3pa6orKa HOBbIX JII aK'I}'aJll13aLC-tH cyw;ecTIJYIOx npaBI1JI JIIC-
IJ01IbOOBaHltHBQJ:IOXP3HJIIJIJIIIlI;
- Be.I\eHl1e roCY.J\apCTBeHlI01'O MOHl1TOpl1HTa BO,!\HblX 06DeIITOB;
- $)pMI>1pOBaHl1e e,D;l1Hoi1 JllH4>opMalOHHJ-8HaJIJmf'ECKOi1 CI1CTeMbI
ynpaBJieHl1Jl BO,l\OX03ffiICTIJeHHbIM KOMlIJleKCOM Ha OCHOBe poCCI1i1CKOro
pernCTpa rJ-UlPOTeXHI1'IecKI1X CoopymelOOl JII fOCY.MpCTBeHlI01'O BO;:nIOro
peec-rpa.
IIpHHIJ;l1lIJ1aJlbHO BamHbIMJI! HBJlHIO'I'CR JllH'l'erpaLC-tH B CMCTeMY rocy-
.J\apcTBeHlI01'O ynpaBJIeHl1H 6acceiiiInJHx COBe'I'OB, JIIX alITl1BHoe y<IacTl1e B
pearocY.Mpc1'BeHHUl1 nOJIJ1TI.1Kl1Bo6naCTl1BO;J;HbIXO'I1«JIIafJrl.
B cc}:Iepe MeilQIyHapo,!J;Horo cOTpy.v;HW'lecrna HE'dixo.v;ttMo ,D;06I11'bCH
yCJIIJIeHI1H pOJll1 PtxcJ.rliicKoi1: tlJe,D;epaLU1l1 B pellleID1J1 l'J106a.n:bHb!X npo-
MeM B 06J1acrn oxpaHbI JII J1CII()JIb.3(GlU! BO,!\HbIX pecypcoB nyreM aK-
TI'1BIfm:y<IaCTI1HB.J\eHTeJIbHOCTI1Meapo;:nIblXopffiHl3a-
HJIMnOI1tl1XCJI npofineMaMI1 Bo.n;onOJIb30B8HUJI, B paMKax .nbHOCTJ1
CO.IlJlY'f\-eCTBa H€3aBI1CIIMblX fOCY.MPCTB,  opraHl13aLJ;l1J1
cOTpy,l\HI1'IeCTBa JII EBpa3wicKoro 3KOHol\llJ1'-jecKOro c:oc6.u.ecma rrpl1lU1-
MaTh 6o.nee aKTl1BHoe y<IacTI1e B peureIDDfCTBeHlillX npo6JIeM
UeHTpaJIbHoi1 A3J1J1.
OcHOBHble HayqHble 3a;J;a'll1 B o6J1acrn C03,II.aHJVl3KOJIOrnqecKJII JII aKO-
HOMWIeCKtf c6ocK:EaHHoro ynpaBJieHMJI  KOMILJIeK-
COM HarrpaBJreHb! Ha:
- COBepWeHCTBOBaHl1e cYll{eCTBy1OlqVIx JII C03,!\a.HI1e HOBbiX opraHl13a-
OHHbIX MexaHI13MOB ynpaBJi€ffi:lH B BO;:nIOM XD.'3IDicTIJe;
- COBepW€HCTBOBaHJte :3I\OHOMJftI€CKI1X MeTO,!\OB 11 MeJI8HJ13MOB paW1-
OHaJIbHOro;
- rnBHllI€RIfe o60CHOBaHHOCTI1 IIpIHR'ntH perneHI1i1 IIpIii KOMlIJleKC-
HOM ynpaBJleHID1 BO.I\Of CI1CTeMaMlii Ha acHoBe COBp€-
M€HHbIX 3H8H11i1 0 TexHOJIorW'leCKi1X npoQeccax JII 3lIDJHIf'H<I€CItJ1X no-
CJle,!\cTBl1JIxJllXpea.ID13al.!Int;
- pa3BI1'I1'1e HaJ'iHblX OCHOB MOHl1TOpl1HTa BO;J;Hb1X Om.eKTOS.
IIp:fiJreMm, KOMIIJIeKCHOfO Hay<IHoro cfx:cHoBaImR, nplil-
MeHeHl1.f1 cOBpeMeHHoi1 na6opaTOpHOJl6a3b1 J-I pa:3BMTU.f[ J-IH4>opMaLJ;l10H-
-115-

HbIX TeXHO.1IOI1'nI, .HBJlfIeTCH 06ecne'ieHJlle KOHTJXmH J1 ynpaBJIeHIDI Ka'ie-
CTBOM BO)J;b1 B BO)UIbIX 06'beKTaX, qx,pMI1pOBaIDIe HaY'lliblX OCHOB CY!CTe-
Mbl HOpMJ1POBamtH, a TalOKe nOY!CK npopbIBHblX IJbICOIID'I'eXHnt'IHbIX
perueHml n03BOJIHIOIlI;I-1X Ha aeHOBe HOBblX 3HaIDDf .I1:0CTWlb Tpe6yeMbIX
CTapTOB Ka'iecTBa BO)J;bL
06ecne<reHJfe pellleHI-1R HayqHblX 3a)\a'l Tpe6yeT Hapaml1BaHI-1R no-
TeHl\l-W.JIa J-fCCJle.I\OBaTeJlbCKI1X opraffif3awrn It C03MID1JI ytJIOBJ1Il ,l\JIH
IIpmlJle'ieHI-1R MOJlO)J;bIX HaY'lliblX Ka.I\P0B B II;eJlHX nO,!l,!\epmaIDIH It pa3-
BY!TI-1Rcyu::J;ecTB}'IOIlI;I-1XHa}"iHblXIllIWJI
rapaHTHpOBaHHoe 06ecne<1eHJ1e nmpe6HOCTY! KOHOMillGl B BO.I\HbIX pe-
cypcaxTpe6YeT6e3yc.rroBHorolXEbllIl('ffi1HItCIIOJlb30Ba-
ID1JI pecypcoB, C!umteHJUI BCI,[\OEMJOOCTII 13I3OJICTBa I1pOMbIllIJIeHHoi-1 J1
i-1npo,IJ;yKlJ;l1J1,H€lIpOI1:ml)rreJIbHblXnc)'repbBO)J;bl.
Hal16o.rrbwyro aK'ryaJlbHOCTb ::ITO HanpaBJleHY!e J1MeeT ,l\JIH p<ufoHoB C
HanpameHHbIM  6aJIaHcoM. f.I\e COEpal1tI2ID1e MaC-
urraOOB BOID1JI orpaHJl'IeHHW!: BO.I\HbIX pecypCOB B ecrorlii
ooopoTn03BOJIHeT cOXpamITb ycroi{tIrrnocTh BO)UlbIX:3KOCHCTt'M.
B pe3YJIbTaTe COKpall.\eHJ1H o6Iq11X 06'beMOB J13'bJITmI BOIX pecyp-
COBJ1J1XIDIHB TeX1KJJIOfIf<£CJOCJMI1pOL\eccenporrOpL\I'!OHaJIb-
HO C o6'beMbI O'lJ1CTKJII CTO'lHb1X BO)J; H KOJIJ1'ieCTBO sarpH3-
HmOll.\Y!X Bell.\eCTB, nOC'I)'II<HOIll;I-1X B BO)J;Hble 06'beKTbI. CoKpaII{eHHe J1
 nmepb B  J1 pacrrpe,I{eJD-rreJIbHbIX CeTHX
CHmRaeT pY!CK pa3BWI'1-1R TaKt1X onacHbIX I1pOQeCCOB. KaK I1OJt1'OI1l!€IB
CeJlI11'€6HbIX Teppwropn:ii, sarpJI3HeIDIe nO,1\3eMHblX BOA
OcHOBHbIM HanpaBJleHY!eM nOBbIllleHI-1R pal.!IOIaJIbHOCTII BO)J;OIIOJlb-
SOBaHI-1R HBJlHeTCH 3KOHOMmeCKoe cnrnynY!pOBaHJ1e COKpall.\eHY!H
y;z:J;€JIbIIOrO pe6neHI-1R, HenpoH3BO,I],JIT€.1IbHll nOTepb BO)J;bI J1
BHe.I\peHI-1R BQ[Ioc6eperaK1lUfX 'f{"{l{Wl{JDm.
CHwKeHtre y,l:\eJIbHoro IIO'Ipe6.neHIDl BO)J;HblX pecypcoB B TeXHQJIom-
'1ecKt1X npoL\eccax ,l:\OCTl1I'aeTCJI paClIDlpEEY!eM nClIOJlb3OI!3HJUI CY!CTeM
o60p0THoro J1 nOBTOpHO-IIOC.Jre,I{UBaTeJlbHoro BO)J;ocH86memm, BHe.I\pe-
IDIeM BO.I\oc6eperaroII.J;I{X TeXHO.:JiOl1-BI B I1pOMbIWJI€HHOCTIf J1 CeJibCKOM

B 3'M1X II;eJIHX He06xo)J;ID'lo:
- ycTaHOBWI'b nporpec<'HBHyJO I11K8.JIY I1JIaTb! sa H3'bHTY!e BO)J;HblX pe-
CypCOB CBepx ycra.HOBJIeHHHX HOpM BOAOIIOTpe6.neIDIH;
- BBeCTI1J1broTHble CTaBrtI1 I1JIaTblSa J13'bJl'l'l1e BO)J;HblX pecypCOB B qe-
JlffK <lJymw;vrOlDtpOBaHIlJI CI1CTeM o60p0THoro J1 I1OB"IQPHJ-IIOC.JIe,l:J.(E-
TeJlbHoro Bo.n;OCHafuKeHl-1R;
- 06eCIIe'll1Tb JlbI'OTHoe Kpe}J;!f'I'CEaHJIe Of.I1:e.JIbHbIX Me(>rnp:lJITIDf no
crpowreJlbc'l'BY, peIOCHC'IpyKIDI J1  C11C111£M o6oJ:x>rm-I.oro u
-116-

1W6mopr-w-eoOoctia6JJceHlL.II,q:>DCIITeJIbHblXCI1CTeMI1
BHe,n;peHl1JO lfUIHl,lX MaJIOBO.n;HbIX TeXHOJIOI1ul Ha ycJIOBIUIX CHI1-
.7KeHHblX IIp:JlJ;eHTHhIX CTaBOK 3a Kpe.IJ;I1T C IK'IIOJIb3OBalllteM Me'\aHli3MJB
cy6cJWtpOBaIDlH 11 IIpE'..l\OC'faBreM qaC'IWllioi1 I1JII11I0000oi1 KOMIIeHCa-
 IIpOl-IeH'I1IDi'i: CTaBKl1 6aHKOBCKoro Kpe,lJ;l1Ta 11 ..aCTI1 ero CTOI1MOCTI1 3a
CqeT 6KJJIjKeTHhIX Cpe,!\CTB I1p11 yc.mmnl, 'lTO KpeJnITbl I1pl1BJIeKaIOTCfl Ha
I1pwXipeT€HJ1e COBpeMeHHhIX TI?'rnOJIOI'Iri 11 TeXHI1'I€CKI1X cpe,!J;CTB;
- 06eCIIe'iHTb Ha OCHOBe HOBe:Hnn1x TeXHOJIOrn<>ecKIIX perneHJrll pe-
KOHCTp}'Kl-\I1lO 11 MO,!J;epHl13aI.\11lO HaXO.wm-\l1XCH B rocy,/-\apcmeHHOO cOO-
CTBeHHOCTl1 TpaKTOB BOJ-\OIIOJ-\a'lJil B QeJUIX CHIDKeHl1H ncrrepb BOJ-\bI;
-peaJIl130BaTbI{()MIIJIeKC f'IeCKIlXl1ap;MJ1IDK."fJJaTJ1BHb1XMep,
BTOM 'lJiICJienO.AlfqxpepeHL\I18.l\ID1BO,I:\HoroHaJIOraI1CTaBOKIIJIaTbl3a 3a-
6cp (113'bJITl1e) BO,!-\HbIX pecypCOB, CTI1M)'m-tpOBaHl1JO npt6cpHoro }"ieTCl
BO,!-\HbIX pecypCDB 11 IIpOnaraH,!J;e HeOOxo,l],JlMOCTI1 06OPY,!J;DBaHl1ff .?KJfJIDro
q,oH,!\a C'leT'iI1KaMl1 BO,l:\bI, OOecne'il1Th o6opy,lJ.{J3aHlte CMCTeMaMl1 }"ieTCl
BO,l:\bIBBO,I:\I1MbIX06DeKTOBKaIDITaJIbHOro
- BKJIlO'IJ1Tb 3a6op (113'bHT11e) BOJ-\HbIX pecypCDB ,nJIH opornemm 3e-
MeJib C€JIbCKUX03.mICTBeHHOro Ha3ffiWeHI1H B nepe<leHb BI1AOB IIJIaTHoro
BQl:PIOJIb3OBaHJ1H C npHM€HeHl1eM 3KOHOMH'iecKJil o6ocHoOOHHblX CTaBOK
IIJIaTbi B QeJ1Jlx CTI1M)'m-tpoBaW1H COKpall\eHl1H 1I0Tepb BO B AIIK.
,noCTl1m€Hl1e IIOl"ICIlIJIeHH CTpaTerl1'leCKI1X QeJIei1 B ycnommx co-
BpeMeHHoro uwfJop.Ma'iJUOJj1-fU() 06utecn-wa H 6e3 Ocy:ll.\eCTB-
JleHl1H CI1C'f€MHCM pa6crrb! no npocB€lltemoo I1I1Hcp::,PMWpOBaHl1lO Hace-
JleHl1H,EIKJII{)tjIBce6.RpellleHl1eCJIeJlYIOllC-1X3a)\a..:
- BOCIDITaHl1e no.n;paCTalOllIero nOKOJI€H11JI B COOTI3€'I'C'IHBI C npJ1:H:W1-
naMl1 6epe:IKHoro CiI'HOIllelDm K BO,I:\HbIM 3f\OCJtCTeMaM 11 pm.J;110HaJ:!bHOro
HClIOJib30BaW1H BO,!-\HbIX pecypcOB;
- IIpOBe./:\eIDte C I1CIlOJIb3OOaIDteM cpe,!\CTB MaccoBOi1 l1Hcp::,pMal-\l1l1
IIpOCBe'TIrreJIbCIOCIi 11 pa3'hfUf!f'I't'.!IbH()ti pa6arbl C Hace.neHMeM 11 fut:3HeC-
fnoBonpocaMHCf"()JIb3()BaHml1oxpaHb[Bo,I:\HbIX06'beKTOB;
- nO.llAep:ltOOl COQI18..JIbRbIX IIJX!eKTOB (npoBe,!J;eHl1e 
pa6oT), oplf€HTIfJXJBaHl Ha YJIY'iLII€Hl1e COCTOHID:!H BO,!-\HbIX ol'i'heKTOB;
-CJ6ecneqeHl'teI1Hcp::,HaCeJleHI1HOCOCTOHID1JIIBO,!-\HbIX
3KOCI1CTeM 11 06I1CTO'iHJ-1EaX I1X 3aI'pH3H€HI1H.
O)f(Jf,!1aeTCH, "TO pea.m.caa1.tMH Bo,!\HOH CTpaTerID-I 6Y.l1eT cnocc6cTBo-
BaTb c6aJIaHCI1pOBaHHOM)' COQMaJlbHO--3ItOHa.nNeCJroMY paamf'T1UO CTpa-
RbI, nO.llA€p:>t\aHl1lO BbiCOItIII'O ypoBHH npoMBOJIbCTBeHHOi1, npoMblllLJIeH-
HOi1 JI! 3HepreTn<>ecKOi1 6e30naCHOCTI111 peaJilt3aWDf KQHCTl1'I}'WfCHHbIX
npaB rpam,D;aH Ha furaronpl1JlTH)'lO OKp)')KCllOlI-\)'1O cpe,IJ;y. I1HbIMI1 CJIDBa-
MM, pea.m13aQJIH Bo,II.HOH CTpaTenm POCCMJ'! nJ3B01IIfT c.n;eJIaTb Bajf{Hb]jii
mar Ha II)'T11 C03,l\aHt1fl «ae.neH011» SIOCIHOMJOOL

Oi5DeM OOecne':lemm BO,IJ;HhIMJ'! pecypcaMl-f nOTpe6HocTei1 HaceJIeWIH
JII mpaCJIei1 <JKOHOMJllIDl! B 2020 ro)I.y COCTamrr:
npceJIbCKorox03ffikrna -27;
npI*KX-13K;
IIp€,IJ;lIpmfrnii B c<l>epe TeIIJt:lBOii JII aTOMHoiii ;,mepreTI1KJll -42;
IIp€.wrpJfHI'Jliii:B c<l>epe IIpOH3BOAC1'Ba -15K.
3Tanbl JII 3IroIIOJW1I-me xapaKTepl1CTl1Kl1 BoJIHOii CTpaTernn Poe-
CJIIH. BO,IJ;H}'l0 cTpaTen'110 npe,IJ;nOJIara€TCH peaJIJ.'I30BaTb B .l\Ba :3Tana.
B paMKaX nepBOro 3Tarra (2009-2012 IT.) 06eClIe'lliBaeTCH C03,[IaHJte yc-
JIOBJ.'Iiii: ,l\JIH ycroWnrnoIU pa:m:wrIDI BQJ:IOX03HJ1cmemIOro IWMIIJleKca JII
IIp€AYCMaTJJJ-'lBaeTCH peam'l3aQMH M€p(IIpJ'IH'I'J no CJIe,!]ylOIl.\UM Ha-
rrpaBJIeHI1HM:
- cOBepllI€'HCTBOBaIDl€ HopMa'I1IBHClI rrpaBOBOH 6a3bI B cc})epe JIIC-
n0Jlb30BaHID! JII OXpaHbI BO,IJ;HbIX 06'beIITOB;
- COBepllEHcrJ3lJBaIDte CHCTeMbI IUcY.l\apCTBellllOro ynpaBJIeHID! BO-
.l\OX03-.!rliCTBeHHbIM
-ffi3l!,aIllleHa.nemHbIXMexam,BHep;pem'leJIIH-
IIUB8.l{IHIHHbIXTeXHOJIOI'Miino  no. a TaK-
me YCl1JIeIDIe oxpaHhI JII YJIY'UlieHl1e Ra':lecTBa BO,IJ; B BO)J;HhIX 00be1CTax.
Ha nepBoM 3Tane HaM€':I€HhI MepOnpHflTI1H no IIOBHlllE.'IDUO 3aIl.\U-
ll\€HHOCTHHaCeJIeHIDIOTHeraTHBHoroCTBI'1HBOA JIHKlU1HHa-
KOIIJIeHlVro  Bpe,Ila JIIITJBHIIIEtfJOO BO,IJ;oo6eCII€':IeHHOCTH
OT}J;eJIbHhIX perlDiOB p cpeAepaw.rn-
B paMKaX BTOpOro 3Tana (2013-2020 IT.) npl1Opl1TeTHbIMJ1 HanpaBJIe-
HJ'IJII\fi'!Bo,D;HOHCTpaTel'Jlln.HBJUllOTCH:
-MO.lI€PBOKOMlIJIeKCa,06ecn€':lJ1BalOLQ,aH
CIDDKeID1€ mrrponoremroM HaIpy3KJ'1, ,IJ;OCrnmeIDfe BbICOKOro ypoBHH 3a-
I4HIl\€HHOCTI1 HaceJIemm OT HeraTI'lBHoro B03,I:IciiL"I'BJIIH BOA B TOM ':II1CJ1e
 JII 6e30naCHocrn I'i"I}:IpOT€XHPreCKHX COOpymeHJ.'Iiii:, paQHO-
HaJlli3aqMlO El())\QfIOJIb3()B8HJI JII CHi-PKE'HJ'Ie BO;J;oeMltOCTI1 3KOH()MUK.i"I,
Bl\JllO'<aH crpol1TeJIbCTBQ 1'1 peKOHCTpyKl.\11IO CeTeBoro X03Jrii:crea BO,IJ;O-
cHa6memmlf BO,IJ;OOrne,!\eHIDI, JllHctJpaCrpyKTyphIBO,lIOU))J;I'OTOIIKJ'1J110':ll1-
CTKI1 CTO'ffibIX BO.u;
- OlIepemalOll\ee pa3BHTHe Ha)"IHO-TeXHJl'iecEOii If T€XHOJIOI'Il'iecEOii
6a3hloroICOMIIJlelCca.IllJIIpoKoeBHe.z1P€IDf€pa3paiaThI-
Ba€MbIX JIIHHOBaQJIIOHHhIX TeXHOJI()l1di;
- 06ecne'iE'HJ'le BQIJ.OX03m1c'rn€ffiO'O IOOMIlJIeKca K.BaJIJ1$tqM}XEaH-
HhOO:lKa,IlpaMl1;
- ()€IDf€ HaIIpaBJI€HHii npaKTW'IecK.Oi1 pe8.JIH3aL\HH ICOHKY-
peHTHhIX npet1MY'-LleCTB pocctfiicI«:ro  nOTeHqHaJIa Ha
BHeIliHI1X phIHKaX.
-118-

no npe,!J;BaplfI'€.1IbHCli 01.1;eHKe, OO o!.YbeM pecypcHoro 06ecne<reHJ1.H
pEWIJf Mvmrii: Bo.I:\Hoii: CTpaTeI'ID1 COCTaBJlH£'T 662,4 MJIP,!J;
py6nei1, BTOM 'lI-1CJIeCpeACTBaaJIbH(I"06IO)l)KeTa -480,9 MJIP,!J;py6-
JIei1, cpe,!J;cma OlO.IPKe'I'OB cy&beKTOBPOCCJri1cKoi1CPe,lleIJ11MeC'I1IblX
OlO.IPKe'I'OB - 114,6 MJIPA py6.neii:, BH ItCTO'llUIKOB - 66,9
MJIP,!J; pyUneit npe,IJ;l10naralOTCR TaIOKe ID1JIarHble rrpoeKTbI, OCHOBaHHble
Ha C'.8M01»fHdHClf]XE8HHJII. PerneHI-fR B paMKaX Bo,IJ.Hoii: CTpaTerJlllil B on-
pe.D:eJJeHHOJI Mepe npezvnpeJI;eJIHT  K KOMIIeHcaL!JIDHHblM
no cBoeM)' xapamepy nnaTemB.M.
BoAHB-R cTpaTeIWI paCC'lJITaHa Ha MO.n;epHJ13aI.\11lO pocoB1ctroii: 3KO-
HOMJIIKI1 C eJlbIO CHJ1meHI-fR Bo.n;oeMKOCTI1 BBn Ha 4Cf"{' JII 3ROHOlV!Jfl1 arre-
ItTpo3Heprl1Jll Ha c)'MMY 60JIee 20 MJIP,!J; pyfuIeii: B ro,!\. KpoMe TOro, O,!J;HOi1
113 3a,naQ Bo,!J;l:lOii: CTpaTeI'ID1 RBJIReTCR BCeMI:'pHO€- CHIDKeHJlle 8HTponG-
relllioii: Harpy3KJ1 Ha BO)J;bI POCCJIII1 nocpe,!J;CTBoM BHe,!J;peHmI HOBblX Tex-
HOJIOrIDi.
J1Jrrepecllo, 'iTO B OCHOB}' Bo,!J;l:lOii: CTpaTernl1 He 3anOmeHO cyI.II;eCT-
BeHHoe IIDBUIIIeHJte Ha.IIOI"OEIOI't ,QaBJIeHIDI Ha peanhHI>IiI ceKTOp Harnei1
SIOCHOMJfKH. n03TOM)' npe npl1MeHRlOe OOBpeM 060-
py.l\OBaHl1e JII He .n;onyCKalOLW1e npeBbIIlleIDlR HOpMaTl1BOB BO.l\OnOJlb30-
BaHHfl, He 6Yro'T IIJIaTl1Tb aa EIO,lPIIOJIb3OBaRIte I'Opaa.n;o 60J1brne yme YC-
TaHOBJIf2HHbIX cyMM. B CBOro O'Iepe,!J;b, xoaIDicTByIoIIJ;l1M cy6DeKTaM,
paCXO11C-1M BOro' C npeBbnneHl1eM HOpMaTl1BOB, npl1,lJ;eTCR IIJIaTMTb
3Ha'll1'feJIbllHe nnpallJbL C 2016 r. 6Y,!J;eT BBe.l\eHa e.n;J1HaR LlITpa4JHaR
CTaBKa - 120-KpaTHaR C'I'OIDIIOCTh Tapl1c}:1a, KOTOpbrn: J-IC'IJIICJIJIeTCR 113 coor-
HOrneHl1R KOJII-1'leCTBa 3arpR3HR1OIIJ;I1X BeeCTB Ha e)J;JllHl1Qy OObeMa BO)J;bL
lcnocoonpe,l\arBpaTl1Tb3Tl1y6bITKJ1-ymecemacB.nC»Kl1'l'b
.l\eHbI11BW2THbIecoopymeHJ1R.IIo
MlU'O'll£JIeHHbIM npe.rr;nplliITl1Hl\o1npl1,lJ;eTCR B.nOIKl1Tb,l\O 720 MJIP,!J; py6.rrei1.
B TO me BpeMR OOeIQaHO tpOBaIIHe npoQeHTHbIX CTaBOK Kpe,!J;l>1Ta
Ha 3aKynKY cOBI:.eMeHHoro opynoBaHIDl, npe rocy,Qapcr-
BeHHblX rapaHTI-1I1 no.l\ 3al1MbI .
TaKl1M d5pa30M, Bo;:I;Ha.H cTpaTeIWI HanpaBneHa Ha yaeJlWleHl1e 3KO-
HOMJ'ItI€ClOCIr B03;:J;eij-c-rBI1R KaK LlITpac1llibIx caHKWrll sa npaBOHa.pylLIe-
HI1R, TaK JII nooll\PeIDlii: (JlbroTbl no Kpe,!J;l>fTGBaHl1IO, a TaIOKe no nJIaTe 3a
IIO.JIh3()IIaHJ BO)I;Hb1Mlil oIh,eKTaMJ1) 3KQJIorl138q11J1 x03RfICTBa. B pe3YJlb-
TaTe CI1CTeMa OXpaHbI BO.l\ nOJIY'illT HOBhle, 6o.rree COBeJXLIeHHHe 4>I1HaH-
COBble CnrnyJlbI, '1TO COOTBeTCTBYeT OITbrry Be.IJYlII;l1X aapy6e>KHbIX rocy-
.l\apCTB.
1 pr 2009 N!! 154.20aBrycTa:2009.N156.21"l!f)'CTa
-119-

KaK npe,!\CTaBJIJleTCH,  B HaCTOJll.Q;ee I3peMJI ID13KY!e
nrrpa<}:lHble caHKW1M 3a  npaBOHapyrneHlliI OOec'--1eHl1Ba-
lOT 3Ha'letille HOCTH npa opraHOB, npMBJieKa-
X BI1HOBHbIXKOTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1. CneAoBaTeJIbHO, MMHlIMJHa-
Ka3amm, He COOTBeTCTBYlOJI 3Ha':lY!TeJIbHOMY 3KOJIOrYI'leCKOMY
yr.u;ep6y, eCTb HecnpaBe,!\.IDfBoe 1IDI>lOarne IIpIfPO,1¥JOxpaHlriI -
QMJ1 rocy,!\apCTBa.
lIaJIo I1pJ.13HaTb, 'ITO TOJIbKO peaJIbHOe npHMeHeHWe 3KOH:JMtP<€CKlt:
Ol4)'TI1MbIXurrpa4>HbIXm,yxy.v;waIOeen
HeA06poC'OB€CTHO[(J llJ;ero cy6'beKTa, n03BOJTIlIT ,.[\OfurrbCJI yc-
neXOB B ,!\eJIe OXpaHbI BOA I1MeHHo TaKO" nO,n;x:o,!\ 3aJIM<:eH B Bo,wIO"
CTpaTerID1,.[\o 2020 r. ECJTIII HapyIID1Te.rm 6y.n;yr cypoBo ,,6mb py6JIeM», TO
p,rrJl X03HJ1c'rnyIoIl\ero cy6DeKTa HapyrnaTb  TpefxmaID1JI
OKame-rCH pa.3Opl1TeJIbHo.
Tor,Ila. cnel\J.1aJIJ-fCTbl B BO,!\HOM IIpaBe 6y1JYf He 6e3 y,l\OBOJIbC'lBI-
KOHCTamp(maTb :Ha'l8Bll!:IDiCJI HOBbm STan pa3ID1TlliI npaBOBoro pery.ID1-
p:maID1JI BO,!\HbIX OTHoweHJrii:'.
1 aBOnIOLjIOBO}J,HorollpallO"'O>KH0I13I"'HTbIlOpa6owTrC11opM-
poBaHel1pa:JBHTeBQAHoronpaBaPoccIH"CfleKTblJ M.re-
plJJJ,eLl,201O.
-120-

nHTEPATYPA
KOHI1EnI1H. MOHOrPA<!JHH
1) KoHQenLtI.fJ.1 pa3BHIW'! pDCUIW«ro3aKOHO,!\aTeJIbCTBa I nD,!\ pe;!l. T.H. Xa-
f:pfe&M, lOA TUX{)Ml1IXJBa, Ion. ()pno&:Kr:ro. M fopo)J;en,2OlI4.
2) p'f!M60 JI.M. OcHQBHbIe npo6JIeMbI COBe'I'OOCI'O BO)WOro 3aKOHO)\aTeJIb-
CTBa. Jl: 113):1-00 JIfY. 1948-
3) KM6ac06 D.C. TecpeTWi€CKI(€ OCHOBhI rrpaBa rIOIIb3CEaHI1H BO):l3.MJI B
CCCP. M: Ha)'Ka, 1972.
4) Boaw0608 c.A. u iJp. Pea.1013atum npas cofJcTBeHmCI'J1 Ha nplfpo,!U[bIe
pecypcbL MoHorpacplUt M: IOpI-lC'M>, 2007.
5) &.cwn,eoo M.B. IIy6.nwnn.re 11 tffiCTIlble I1HTepeCbl B arooon1'reCKOM
npase. MOHorpal}:llUL M.: 113):1-Bo:MTY, 2003-
6) KMUlfUWH'KO T.r. 4>0pr.mp0saHne}j e BOMOro npaBa Paccm!
(ny6JIWlHbIeJl'iaCneKTbI). M.: ropo,!\eQ, 2010.
7) Bumpy;c H.E. 06I$H Teopl1H IOpl1,lWleCKoi1 0TBeTCTBeHH0CTI MOHO-
rpa4Jrnr. M: HopMa, 2009.
B) faAU'H-OBCI«IJl E.A. Teope'T'WJecEJlIe JII MeTQlI,01ICOlqecroie npofuIeMbI 3e-
MeJlbHbIXnpaBOO'I'HOW€HJdi.M J13I1CII;cpl:lp-
Ma«KoH1p3IIT',2009.
9)&.IE.A.npano-McmmaQill1BMem,I\JlffiPO'!\-
HOM COTPYJnDI'lE'CTEIe M: Ha)'Ka, 2006.
KOMIlEHT APHH H nOC05H
lO)IIl\oMMeHTapl1fil\Bo;!\HoMYKo,!\eKcyPoccJnicKojiq:.e)J;e-
paWlI1! no,!!; pe,!\. O.JI. ,l{y60BIfK. M.: 3KCMO, 2007.
11) RoMMeHTapl1fi K Bo;woM)' KO,I\€KC)' Pocorl'IUOCJII4JeAepaQI1I1 (nocraTei-i-
HbIti) I CAEorom060s, fA BOJIKOB,]1,.o. CMBaKOB.M: He.n6"" IIpocrreKT, 2007.
12}TWtO!PeeBJI.A.IIpaBOBbleOCHOBbI€Hill'IJ1
00CJIel\CTBW1 Bpe,!{Horo BOO,I\eiicTBilRBO,lI. CapaTOB: I13,l1-EO <pry BITO Capa-
TOBCKOA rAY. 2004.
13} 3aLqlITa IIpaB Ha IIpHpO,!J;Hble pecypcbl. HayqHO-npaK'I'K'IECKOE noco-
6i11e / nOJ!. pe,ll. CA Eoro.mo6OBa. M.: lOpatiT, 200B.
14) Bozomo606 c.A., Cuea'KOO Jl,.D. Bo,l\HOe 3aKOHO,l\aTeJIbCTBO B BO!1pocax
ill OTBeTax. HaYQHO-npaKTWif"CK(t" noc06l1e M: J13I1CIT; ecRaR
4JI1PMa «ROHTpaKT», 2009.
-121_

HAY4HbiECTATbH
15) Epoc.iIaec1wii JI.M. Yp5aVI J1 npaBOBaJ'l oxpaHa KalJeCTBa BO,!\ B
CIlIA / / iKypHaJl 3apy6eiKHOro 3aKOIIOJ\iI.TeJIbCTBa 11 cpaBHJrI€JIbHCI npa-
BOBe)\eHl1H.BbIIIYCK 12007.NQ8.C. 8-15
16) BmqJM M.A. HOBblj.j BO,!UIbIH KO.n;eKC: npofuIeMbI" np06eJIbI / /3KO-
.nDIWI€CKOe npaBo. 2006. M4. C. 24-25.
17)&r.cmopo/5etfE.A.OrpaHWIeHWIBfunt3J1BO.znn,IXo6'beK-
TOa/ /Ha)'K3,BJIaCTbJ106meCTBOnepeJJ;JIJ1QOMOrraCHoCTeiiJ'!
pI1CKOB. C60pID1K HBY'ffibIX MaTepJlJaJIOB Bcep:xnrlfCKOii HayqHo-npaK'IWlec-
KOi1KOHtPePeHl\ID115-17 OKTH6pH 2007 r. / CapaTCJBCKJ1ii ry 11M. Hr. qepHhI-
llieBCKOrO / rIOA pe,!\..n;.B. MJ1xeJlR, AB. J1BaHosa, T.IO.  CapaTOB,
2007.C.68-70.
18) H'G.i1.UHU1te1tKO T .f. 0 BO)UlOM o60poTe / / 3aKOHoJ\aTeJ1hCTBO 11 3KOHO-
MJ1Ka.200B.M9.C.63-71.
19) KG.i1.U1iU1le1lKO T.r_ HOBbn1 BO)(Hbrn: KO)\eKC P<P (np06J1eMbI 11 nep-
crreKTI>1BbI) /1 TpaHcnopTHoe npasQ. 2007. M 2. C. 2-11.
20) CU8U1OCI6 Jl,.a. Bo)J;HbIW KO)J;eKC 2006 T.: HOBeJIJIbI Jl3alIa'-Ji1 npJ1MeH€HlliI / /
JKypHaJI poccm"icKOro npaBa. 2007. M 1. C 95-101.
21) CU8U1roSll..0. IIpaaoBaH oxpaHa BO,!\ B ca€Te BO)lHoi1 C'rpaTeI11l1 Poc-
CMJ1 / / JKypHarrpoccmlcKoronpaBa. 2010. M2.C. 5-12.
22) Xayc7TIJ)B JI..E. IIy6JIWlHo-npaBOBbIe JJ;oroBOpb! B npnpo.I1OI1OJIb-
HID1//npaso.2003.M5.C.12-20.
MATEPHAbl nAPnAMEHTCKHX CYWAHH
H l\PyrHX 05UjECTBEHHbiX <l>OPYMOB
23) MaTepHa.1Ibl K nap.naMeH'I'CIOOVI c.rrywamUIM rocY,D,apC'T'BeHHOi1 
4le1\epaJIbHOro Co6pamm Ha TeMY. e:&xc-ra1KmneHl1e liIoxpaHa BO.qHblX olh,-
eKTOB. A1cr'ya.m.mde BonpOCbI ynpaBJIemm iii npaBOBoro 06erne'IeHJ1R» M., 21
MapTa 2002 r.
24)MaTepl1aJIbInap.rraMeH'I'CKI1XCJI)'lilllHI1i-rl,lJ,yMbl4>eJle-
paJIhHOTO Co6pamm Ha TeMY: «0 Haq>1(flaJIbHJit nporpaMMe 1R
1IIHaJlO.lITOCPO'-1H)'IOnepcIIeKTI1IJY».M.18MaR2003r.
25)C60pIDIKMaTepJ13JlOB K3aCeIDIIO «XPYTJIoroCTOJIa» Ha TeMY: «KOH-
C'TIITyWlJ'I PocCJn1cJrojj <1JeAepaW:II11i1 pa3BI1TI1e 3KOJJJrwrecKOI"O npasa». M:
J1Hcrmyr rocy,AapcrBa iii npasa PAH. 2005.
26) rocy,D,apCTseHHaH J(yMa epaJIbHoro co6paIDIJ'I e-
PaQI1I1. CTeHorpaMMa 3aCe)\aHIDl. EIQJLIIeTeHb NQ 189 (903) OT I HOJ'lfipH 2006 r.
-122-

27) MaTepl-laJlbIMeiKJJ.YH3.poinmAKoHtPepeHI.\ID1 (S;D;BYX TOMaX): "YCTO!1:-
'rnBoe pa3mrrne: npJ1po,lla'ieJIOBeK» (npoBeJ:J;eHa MIIP P<P J1
ToprOBD-I1pOMhIllIJIeII naJIaTOi1 P<P). M., 2006.
28}IIpaBoIHanpl-l]XlinlliIepecypCbIJ1:;w:pcPeKTIffiHOCTbnpJ1-
ur. C6opHJ1K Te3UCOB ;D;OKJIa,!\OB J1 BbICTyn.rr€Hl1i1 1m HayqHD-
npmmNE'CKf"i,lKoHq:,epeHl\1-IJ113-14anpeJm 2000 f., f. MocKBa {COCT. C.A Eo-
roJIlolXm, 11.J1. IIrnpc}K.opa;n;,.n:.o. CMBaKOB. M: I13nCII, fY3, 2006.
29) Nla:repl>ffiJIbI napmMeHTCKl1X CJIylllaIrni1 rocY1IapcTBeHHOi1 /1,yMbI
rl>e1lepaJlbHoro Co6paHIfH P<P Ha TeMy: "AKTyaJlbHbIe npofuIeMbI IIpaBOBOro
pery.1IJ!f.lUB3Hi'1 sonpocoB 5RUJIOOIJI fOpo,nOB». M, 26 JOOHJ'i 2008 f.
30} fapMOHiI3aW1H 5Ii01IOI"WI€CKJ CTaH,AapToB II (fSC II). IIpoM€*y-
TO'-IHwfi ar'JeT. BJlOK ,neHTeJIbHOCTIi 8-IIpJ1po,nooxpaHHbIe pa3peWeHJ1H.
llporpaMMa COTPY)J.Hl1'-lecTBa EC-PoccwL 200B.l1Kmb.
31) IIpaBo c06CTBeHHOCTfl Ha 3eMJIIO B POCCIDI JI! EC: npaBOBble npo6.rreMbL
C60pHl-IK craTeR I arB.pe,n. J1A J1KOInDll\aH. M.: BoJrrepc KriyBep, 2009.
3HUHKJlonEA. COBAPH. cnPAB04HHKH
32) PeiiMepc H.CP. IIpl1poJlOIIOJlb3osaHl1e. CJloaapb-CnpaSO'-lHI1K. M
1990.
33} P03aJWff H_n. u itp. pOTeXHK'-lecKlile COOPY)K€HIfH. M' AqxmpoM-
H3'!\aT,19B5.
34) )fCe.aeJ1UI.IW6 r.B. u itp. fl1ZIpOJICDLII. rn1ij)OMeTplfH JI! perymtpOBIDllle
CTOKa. M_ RoJloc, 19B4. C 24-32.
35} fopo,lla PoccwL KJlone,!\IfH {no'!\ pe,n. r.M JIarrrrQ. M_ BJJlblIIaH
poccwicKaRne,!\JUl, 1994. C 351.
36}feo€CKI1i1::nn.pI'J€CKIDiCJIoBapb.IIoHRTI1HJlTepMl1HbII
no,!\pe,D;.A<p. TpeunuuroBa. M: CoBeTCKaJ'!5tiL[I 198B
37) feorpa$l'!ecKflH :mqI1ItJIOIIeWf'leCKl1i1 CJlOBapb feorpacpwtecro.re
Ha3BaHIfH {IIO,!\ pe,!\. A.<P. Tpelllln-uwsa. M.: COBeTCKaH3HqIIJKJIOrr€,!\IfH, 19B9.
3B} MOpcKOH 3I'IECKJDicJIOBapb. B 3 T.{no,!\pe,D;. B.B EMflT-
pl1eBa. JI.. Cy}lOC'l1XJeHJle, 1991. C 93, 94.
39} PCP.M.ITpaBoBHeCHCTeMbI CTpaHMHpa. CnpaBO'ilD1K M
IOpl1,!\l1<JeCKaR JlwrepaTypa, 1993.
-123-

cYBHMT£I11wo
/_....'O \
I ( TET i
\ J

"'"

ornABnEHHE
BBE,Q,EHIiIE _.
rnaaa 1 06IJ.WI XAPAKTEPI1CTI1KA
nPABOBoro PE>KI1MA BOHOro IJ)(IH,qA
1.8oJ\HoenOIlIHHKal1npallO........... .........5
2. npaBO C06crBeHHOCTH Ha BOp,Hble 06beKTbi H nopp,oK I1OIIJXIIIaHH HMH ..... .14
3.HpaJpeUJHTe.nbHble
MeXaHH3Mbi peryl1HpoBaHHR Bo,!\OnOJlb30BilHH ..........................23
..3
rnaaa 2 PA3nw.jHb1E Bl1JIbI Hcnonb30BAHHR BO
1. accH4JHKa4H>lI-!CIIOIJ>3CEiIH>lBOp,Hblxo6beKTOB.
HaH6oJ1eellpHClpl-lreTHapasHCJel1AHOCTbBOJ\OnOJlb30BilHHR ................40
2. C6POCCT()<jHbIXH,lJ,peHOOI(HbIXBOp,:oco6eH-iocm
npaIlOBoroperyJlHpOBilHH>lHnepCne"THBolH>I__...____..._lI2
3. npaBOBbleeOnpoCbICTpOTenbCTBilH3KCn.nyaTaL.lH
rI1.DJXlTeXHHYeCKHxcoopy>t<eHHHHBOJ\OxpaHHJ1HLl.I.................. ...45
4.HeBop,Hblxo6beKTOB,/J,J14eneH3HE'p"eTMI(I1,
TpaHcnopTa,...........................................54
5.HeI!O)J,Hblxo6beKTOB,/J,I1HHblxLle.neH ...59
rnaaa 3 nPABOBMI OXPAHA BO iii OTBETCTBEHHOCTb
3A HAPYWEHIiIE EE TPE60BAHI1t1
1. 06U<11eBOnpocolnpaBOBOHOxpattblBOJ\HOr04>oH,lla ...69
2. CneLjHaJ1bHbleBonpocblnpaIlOBoHoxpaHbIBOp, ..........................16
3.lOpH,!l,l1YecKaR3al1apyweHHjlI!Op,Hor03al(OHop,aTe.nbCTBa.....1I5
rnaaa4 rOCY,nAPCTBEHHOE vnPABnEHIiIE
B 0611ACTI1 BOHoro X03RtlCTBA (nPABOBbIE ACnEKTbI)
1. 06!4i1J'1xapataep1CTHKaynpasneHHH HCn0J1b30BaHHeM 11 OxpaHOH BOJI ........93
2. MottHrqJMHl",yYeTHKOHTponbB06naCTHHCnOnb30BaHHRHOxpaHoIBo,!\ ......99
3.0co6eHHOCTHynpaaneHH>ll1cnonb30BaHHeMI10xpaHOHManbIXpeK,
fOpop,cKHXHnprOpop,HbIXBOp, ..... ....... ...... ...................108
4. rlpoeKTl1pyeMaJI Mo,!\el1b pa3BTR eOJ\Horo X03HCTBa POCCH ............ .113
nliiTEPATYPA
KOHl\enl\H, MOHOrp<$HH ... ___... ____... ____... ____.. ____... ____... .121
KoMMeHTapH H noco6>1 ...... ...... ........ ...... ....... ....... .....121
HayYHbieCTaTbH ....................................122
MaTepHaJlblnapllilMetiTD<lCJlYUJaHHH
H,o,pyrHX4>opyMOB.....................................122
H,CI10Bap,CnpasCl'lHHKH.................................123
-124_

CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION....................................................... .3
Chapter 1 GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS OF LEGAL REGIME
OF INVENTORY OF WATER RESOURCES
1 Waterllldustry;poliCYi!f1dlaw ........................................5
2 Ownershlpol water obJects and the processol their use. .. .14
3 Contractual and Ilcensll1g control mechanism of use of water resolI"CeS .......23
Chapter 2 DIFFERENT TYPES OF USE OF WATER RESOURCES
1 Classification 01 use 01 water objects and the most priority type
01 useolwater I'eSCU'CeS ...__....___....___....__....____...... ...40
2 DUmplllg 01 sewage and drail1 waters: pecufiaritles 01 legal control
andprospectsolltsdevelopment...................................._42
3 Legalmattersolbuildmganduseolwaterworks
andwaterslorages .___....___....__....___....____...___...____...45
4 Use of water objects to the alms 01 energetics,
transport,raltlng ..... .............................................54
5 Use of water obJects to the other purpeses ..... ....... ....... ...... ....59
Chapter 3 LEGAL PROTECTION OF WATER
AND LIABILITY FOR ITS VIOLATION
1 General matters 01 protection 01 water . ...._.......... ......... ...69
2 Special matters of prolectlon 01 water __.... ____... ____.. ____... ____.. .16
3 Legal liability for violation of water legislation ...........................85
Chapter 4 PUBLIC MANAGEMENT IN THE RANGE OF WATER INDUSTRY
(LEGALASPECT)
1 General d1aractenstics 01 management 01 use and protectIOn 01 water. . . . . . . .93
2 Moniloring,reglstratlon,controlintherangeofuse
and protection 01 water _....__....___....___....__....___...... ...99
3 Peculiarities 01 management 01 use and protection 01 small fiVerS,
city and suburban water ...........................................108
4 PrOject model 01 development 01 water Illdustry in RussIa. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .113
LITERATURE........................................................ .121
-125-

CI1BaKoB,tl_O_
nPABOBOE PErYllltIPOBAHItIE BQQCJ'lOI'b3CBAJIII<
"".-
115419,MOCI(ea.y.n..1I
www.JIXISIZdEI.ru. e-ma y.book@mail.fu
Te.n.(495j979.7028,926.7525
<I>opMar60><90j16.rapH..-rypaJoomaIC
ne'laTbo4>cerHaH.6)IMara<Xj>ceruilSl
T"JX!'K500""3.1le" 11.8,0