Author: Алексеев В.П.
Tags: антропология этнография археология этногенез
ISBN: 5-02-009932-5
Year: 1989
Text
ARA;D;EMllH HAYl\ ccCP -A It
"
OT
EnEHME MCTOPI1M
( "'----'-'
B.IT.ArreKceeB
l1CTO Pl1QECKNI
AHTPOnOnO I11JI
11 3THOfEHE3
I
MOCKBA «HAYKA» 1989
EER 28.7
A 47
Perr;eH3eHTbI:
'1JIeH-IwppecnoHp;eHT AH CCCP f. M. EOHfAPA-JIEBMH,
p;OKTOp IICTOpII'IeCKIIX HayK r. JI. XI1Tb
AJleKCeeB B. II.
A 47 IIcTopHqecKaH alITpOnOJIOrHH H 8THorelIe3.- M.: HaYKa, 1989-.., c.
ISBN -5-02-009932-5
IIpOHIIKHOBeHIIe B IICTOpIIIO OIIlIpaeTCH He TOJIbKO Ha rrpO'lTeHl'Ie IIIICbMeHllbIX
p;OKYMeHTOB II II3Y'leHIIP pa3rro06pa3HbIX pe3YJIbTaTOB ):1eHTeJIbrrOCTII '1eJIOBe'leCT-
Ba. M3MeHeHIIH cPII3II'IeCKOrO TIIIIa caMIIX JIIOp;eH Ha llpOTHmeHIIII pa3HbIX IICTO-
pIIqeCI(lIX 3IIOX C:ryntaT lOIl\HbIM IICTOqIIIIIWJ\I IICTOpnqeCIWfJ I!IIcP0pMal\IIII, OTKpbI-
BalOT HaM p;peBHIIe KOHTaKTbI Me1Kp;y Hbme Hepop;CTBerrHbIMII Hapop;aMII, II03BOJIHIOT
YBII):1eTb p;peBHIIe MIIrparr;IIII l'I Orr;eHl'ITb IIX MaClliTa6bl. B KHIIre paCCMaTpIIBaIOTCH
IIp06JIeMbI peKOHCTpYKrr;IIII 3THOrPHP'fII'IeCKOrO rrpOl\PCca Ha OCHOBe aIITpOIIOJIOrII'Ie-
CKIIX p;aHHbIX.
A'1H aHTpo::rOJIOrOB, 3THorpacPOB, apXeOJlOrOB, IICTOpIIKOH.
A 0508000000-320 600-89- II
042(02)-89
ISBN -5-02-009932-5
EER 28.7
cg M3,ll,aTeJIbcTBo «HaYKa», 1989 r.
IIPE.D;IICJIOBnE
B KIIHre « qeJIOBeK: 8BOJIIO:qIIH II T3KCOHOMIIH» 3BTOp C06P3JI H 06IIOBHJI CBOH
p360TbI, BbInOJIHeHHbIe no e}J;IIHOMY nJIalIY, HO ny6JIHKOBaBIIIIIeCH ,ll,0 3Toro B
BII,ll,e OT}J;eJIbHbIX CT3TeH B p33IIbIX II3,ll,aIIHHX. np06JIeMbI 8BOJIIO:qHll II TaKCO-
HOMHII HCKon3eMbIX rOMHHII,ll, II pac COBpeMelIHoro qeJIOBeK3 6bIJIII P3CCMOT-
pelIbI B HeH IIa OCHOBe BceH cOBoKynlIocTII MopcpOJIOrHqeCKHX, reHeTHqeCKIIX,
n3JIeOlITOJIOrIIqeCKHX H naJIe03HTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKHX }J;3HlIbIX, T. e. BceH IIaKOn-
JIelIlIOH II }J;OCTyIIHOH 6HOJIOrH"'IeCKOH HH<P0PM3:qHH. n03TOMY B IIIHpOKOM
CMbICJIe CJIOB3 KIIHr3 « qeJIOBeK: 8BOJIIO:qHH H T3KCOIIOMHfl» BXO,ll,HT B p3MKII
'foro 06IIIIIplIoro Kpyr3 BonpOCOB, KOTopbIe C IIe,ll,3BIIIIX nop CTaJlII 06'be,ll,HIIHTb-
CH nO}J; Ha3BaHIIeM 6HOJIOrHH qeJIOBeKa.,
}J;a1I1I3H RHIIra, no <popMe II X3paKTepy MaTepHaJIa nOBTopHH npe,ll,bI)J;y-
m;yIO, IIOCBHIIJ;eHa COBceM HHOMY Kpyry np06JIeM. B HeH C}J;eJI3IIa nonhITK3
nOK333Tb, KaK pe3YJIbTaTbI aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIX IICCJIe,ll,OBaHHH MOryT 6bITb
npHMelIelIbI npH peKOIICTpYK:qHII IICTOpHqeCKOrO npo:qeCC3, K3KOBbI B 3TOH
ccpepe nYTII H B03MomIIOCTH, qTO 3TII pe3YJIbT3TbI MorYT )J;aTb npHIIl(IInH3JIb-
lIO HCTOpHqeCKOMY 3HalIHIO II K3KOB3 HX pOJIb B BOCCTalIOBJIelIHH KOIIKpeT-
lIbIX HCTOpIIqeCKIIX cHTya:qHH. ECTeCTBeIIIIO, HTor 06pa60TKH 3IITpOnOJIOrIIqe-
CKHX H naJIe03IITpOnOJIOrII"'IeCKHX MaTepH3JIOB nO}J; 3THM yrJIOM 3pelIHH TeM
BeCOMee, qeM IIIHpe 8TH M3TepII3JIbI OXB3qelIbI H qeM OIIH pa3IIo06p33IIee B
'feppHTOpH3JIbIIOM II XpOIIOJIOrHqeCKOM OTIIOllieIIHH. n08TOMY Ha CTp3IIHl(3X
KIIHrH 06cym}J;3IOTCH 8TIIorelIeTHqeCKHe CHTY3:qHH B eBponeHCKOM Q3CTH
CCCP, IIa KaBK33e, B Cpe,I:\IIeM A3HH, B CII6IIPH, K 8TOMY o6cym,ll,eHHIO npH-
BJIeqelIbI 3HTpOnOJIOrHqeCKHe II36JIIO,I:\eIIIIH, OTIIOCHm;HeCH K ,I:\JIHTeJIblIoMy OT-
pe3KY BpeMeHH - OT 3nOXH 6pOlI3bI }J;O COBpeMeIIIIOCTH.
Bce CK333HIIoe CBH,ll,eTeJIbCTByeT 0 TOM, qTO OCIIOBII3H TeMaTHK3 KHHrH
CMbIKaeTCH C HCTOpHqeCKOH np06JIeM3THKOM, nOqeMy CJIOBOCO"'IeT3IIHe «HCTO-
pHqeCKaH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH» H BbIIIecelIO B ee 33rJIaBHe. Ho HCnOJIb30B3IIHe
3IITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKHX ,I:\alIlIbIX B HCTOpH"'IeCKOM IICCJIe,I:\OB3IIIIH IIeB03MOiRII0 B
nOJIIIOH Mepe 6e3 ,I:\oCTaTOqIIOrO nOIIHMaHIIH TeOpeTHqeCKIIX 3cneKTOB HCTO-
PHKO-3IITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOH peKOIICTpYK:qIIH. n08TOMY C3MOH npo:qe)J;ype 8THO-
relIeTH"'IeCKOrO HCCJIe,ll,OB3IIHH C HCnOJI.b30BaHHeM 3HTpOnOJIOrHqeCKHX H n3-
JIe03IITpOnOJIOrH"'IeCKHX ,ll,3IIlIbIX y,I:\eJIHeTCH Mil oro BIIHMaIIHH, II ee paCCMOTpe-
IIHe 06p33yeT C3MOCTOHTeJIblIYIO qaCTb, npe,I:\IIIecTByIOm;yIO 3II3JIH3Y KOIIKpeT-
IIbIX 3TlIorelIe30B.
MCTOpHqeCK3H 3IITpOnOJIOrHH onHpaeTCH B CBOHX peKOIICTpYK:qHHX npaK-
'IHqeCKH IIa Bce Tp3,I:\H:qHOIIII0 Bbl)1eJIHeMbIe p33,ll,eJIbI 3IITpOnOJIOrHII - 3IITpO-
norelIe3, paCOBe,ll,elIHe H MopcpOJIOrHIO qeJIOBeK3, CPH3HOJIOrHqeCKYIO 3IITpOnO-
.'IOrHIO. PenepTY3p npII3II3KOB, BOBJIeK3eMbIX B aIITpOnOJIOrH"'IeCKOe
HCCJIe,I:\OB3IIHe, YBeJIHqHB3eTCH ro,ll, OT rO,I:\a, C HIIM BMeCTe p3crnHpHIOTCH Il
rpaHII:qbI IICTOpH"'IeCKOM 3IITpOnOJIOrHII, 3 T3Kme YCIIJIHB3IOTCH ee KOlIT3KTbI C
,ll,pyrHMH 06JI3CTHMH aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO 3IIaHIIH, C reHeTHKOH qeJIOBeK3
Jf T. ,ll,. BonpOCbI B33IIMOCBH3II II pa3MemeB3IIHH 3IITpOnOJIOrHH H reHeTIIKH
qeJIOBeK3.. 6IIOJIOrHH qeJIOBeKa II aHTpOnOJIOrHH, aHTpOnOJIOrIIH H 8KOJIOrIIJI
,3.--' '--:. .-.' , .,
... .<. .
qeJlOBeKa npH06peTaIOT Bce 60JIbillHH TeOpeTHqeCImH HHTepec II Bce OOJIbillYIO
IIpaRTHqeCKyIO 3Ha"'IHMOCTb. OqepKH, aHaJIH3HpYIOm;IIe 8TH BonpOChI, TaKme
BbI,ll,eJIeHbI B cne:qIIaJIblIYIO qaCTb, KOTopaH OTKpbIBaeT KIIHry.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, BeCb HHmeCJIeAYIOm;IIH TeKCT 06'be,ll,HIIHeTCH BOKpyr Tpex
KOII:qeIITpOB: CTpyRTypbI alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOiI HaYKH, ee CBH3en C ,ll,pyrHMH
HayKaMH II MeCTa BIIYTPH ee HCTOpH"'IeCKOH aHTpOnOJIOI'HH; TeOpeTH"'IeCKIIX
np06JIeM II3yqelIHH 8THoreHeTHqeCKHX cHTya IIH C nOMOm;bIO aHTpOIIOJIOrIIqe-
CKIIX MaTepHaJIOB; HCTopHKo-aIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO HCCJIe,ll,OBaIIHH npOIICXOiR-
p;eHHH OT,ll,eJIbHbIX HapO;rrOB II rpynn IIapO}J;OB, B03l1fOmlIOCTeH conOCTaBJIeHIIH .
pe3yJIbTaTOB TaKoro HCCJIe,ll,OBaIIIIH C JIHlIrBHCTIIqeCKIIMH H HCTOPIIKO-KYJIL-
TyplIhIMH ,ll,alIlIhIlIfH H nOCJIeAYIOm;eiI peKOHCTpYKII;IIH KOHKpeTHbIX 8TIIoreHe30R
B :qeJIOM. COOTBeTcTByIO:m;He qaCTII HepaBHOBeJIHKH no 06'beMY, 110 OIIII oTpa-
maIOT peaJIblIYIO nOCJIe}J;oBaTeJIbHOCTb nepexo,ll,a OT o,ll,IIOI'O cTpyKTyplIoro
ypOBHH aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROrO 3IIaHHH K )J;pyroMY npII HcnOJIb30BalIHH 8Toro
3HaHHH B HCTOpII"'IeCKOH HaYKe, nOCJIe,ll,OBaTeJIbHOCTb nepexo,ll,a OT <pYII)J;a.-
MeHTaJIbHbIX np06JIeM aHTpOnOJIOrHH K npHKJIa}J;IIbIlIf, Ha YPoBHe KOTOpbIX ona
BbIcTynaeT O}J;IIOH H3 BamHbIX II Hecym;HX HenoBTopHMYIO HCTOpHqecKYro
HHcpopMa:qHIO BcnoMOraTeJIblIbIX HCTOpII"'IeCKHX ,ll,Hc:qHnJIHH. ABTOPy RameTcH,
qTO HMeHIIO npH TaKoiI opraHH3a:qHH H3JIOmelIHH IIaII60JIee BhlnYKJIO oqep-
qHBaIOTCH CHJIbHhIe CTOpOHbI aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOrO MaTepIIaJIa KaK HCTOpH"'Ie-
CRoro IICTOqHHKa II IIaHOOJIee HCIIO BH}J;HbI MeTO,ll,OJIOrHqeCKHe npIIH:qHnbI H
MeTO,ll,IIqeCKIIe npHeMbI ero H3Y"'IeIIHH.
lfacTb nepBaa
AHTPOIIOJIOrlIH:
HOHTYPbIHAYIlli
TEOPETMlfECROE HACJIE)J;ME 8HfEJIbCA
M AHTPOrrOJIOfMlfECRAH HAYRA
ITpoH3BeAeHHH It MapKCa II B OC06elIIIOCTH <1>. 3IIreJIbCa, B KOTOpbIX CTaBH-
JIHCb np06JIeMbI aIITpOnOJIOrIIH, nepB06bITIIon apXeOJIOrHH, 8THoreHe3a, cOAep-
lliaT npO,ZJ;YMaHIIYIO KOH:qen:qHIO aHTponoreHe3a, qeTKHe CPOPMYJIHpOBKH 0
COOTHomelIHH 6HOJIOrHqeCKOrO H COrr;HaJIbHOrO B qeJIOBe'IeCKOM OOm;eCTBe,
npHMepbI HCnOJIb30BalIIIH aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKHX p;aIIHbIX B KaqeCTBe HCTOpH'Ie-
CRoro HCTOqHHKa. n03TOMY IIX H3Y'IeHHe nOA yrJIOM 3pelIHH AOCTHllieHHH II
nepcneKTHB COBpeMeHIIOH HaYKH OCTaeTCH BeCbMa aKTyaJIbHbIM II npo,ll,OJIiRa-
eT 060ra:m;aTb TeopIIIO aIITpOnOJIOrHH, nOMoraH HaHTII nOAxOA O MHorHlIf
KJIIOqeBbIM H WlCKYCCHOHlIbIM np06JIeMaM cerOAIIHmHero AHH.
B OAHOM H3 pa3AeJIOB nepBoro TOM a «HeMerr;Kon HAeOJIOrIIH)}, KOTOpbIH
HOC lIT Ha3BalIHe «<1>eHep6ax», paccMaTpHBaeTcH pa3BIITHe pa3IIbIX CO IIaJIb-
HbIX IIHCTHTYTOB, BCKphlBaIOTcH ynpaBJIHIO:m;He IIMII 3aKolIoMeplIocTII. AHaJIII-
3n:pYH HBJIeHHe BO BceH ero :qeJIOCTHOCTII, MapKC H 3HreJIbC IIaqHlIaIOT C ero
JICTOKOB - C caMoro <paKTa BhIAeJIelIHH JIIOAeH H3 mHBOTHoro lIfHpa. OHH nH-
mYT: «nepBaH npeAnOCbIJIKa BCHKOH qeJIOBeqeCKOH HCTOpHII - 8TO, ROlIeqlIO,
cym;ecTBoBalIHe mHBbIX qeJIOBeqeCKIIX HHWlBH,ll,OB. n08TOMY nepBbIn ROHKpeT-
HbIn cpaKT, KOTOpbIH nO,ll,JIemHT ROHCTaTIIpOBaIIIIIO,- TeJIeCHaH opraHH3al(HH
3THX IIHAIIBHAOB II 06YCJIOBJIelIIIOe eIO OTHomeHHe HX K OCTaJIbHOn npII-
pOAe» 1.
MbICJIb 8Ta He CJIyqaHHa. B nepBOllf TOMe «!\'anHTaJIa)} It MapRC nOBTO-
pIIJI II yrJIy6IIJI ee: «ECJIH MbI OTBJIe'IeMCH OT 60JIbmerO IIJIII MeHbmero pa3-
BIITHH 06:m;eCTBeHHoro npOII3BO.D:CTBa, TO npOH3BOAHTeJIblIOCTb TpYAa OKameT-
CH CBH3aHHOH C eCTeCTBeHHbIMII YCJIOBHHlIfH. 3TII nOCJIe,ll,IIHe MorYT 6bIT:b
IT;eJIHROllf CBeAeHbI K npHpO,ll,e callforo qeJIOBeKa, K ero pace H T. n., H R OK-
PymaIOm;eH qeJIOBeKa npnpO,ll,e>) 2. TaKHM 06pa30M, H It MapRC II <1>. 3HreJIbC
npHAaBaJIH BamHoe 3HaqeHIIe qHCTO 6IIOJIOruqeCKIIM CBonCTBaM qeJIOBeqe'
CRUX cym;ecTB II npII3HaBaJIII 60JIbmyIO pOJIb 3THX CBOHCTB B IIX 06:m;eCTBeH-
HOH mII3HII II IICTOpHH.
E:m;e 60JIee 3HaMeHaTeJIeH B 8TOH CBH3II OTpbIBOK II3 rJIaBbI «<1>eHep6ax>},
HenOCpe,ll,CTBeHHo CJIe,ZJ;YIO:m;IIii 3a yme :qHTHpOBaHHOH MhICJIbIO 0 TeJIeCHOn
npIIpO,ZJ;e qeJIOBeKa: «MbI 3AeCb He lIfomellf, pa3YMeeTCH, yrJIy6JIHTbCH HH B
II3yqeHIIe <pH3IIqeCKH CBOHCTB CallfHX JIIOAen, HII B II3yqelIHe npHpoAHbIX
YCJIOBIIn - reOJIOrH'IeCRIIX, opo-rHAPorpacpIIqeCKIIX, RJIHlIfaTIIqeCKIIX II IIHhlX
OTlIomeHHn, KOTOpbIe OHII 3aCTaIOT. Ho 8TH OTHomeHHH 06YCJIOBJIHBaIOT He
TOJIbKO n pBOHa'IaJIbHYIO, eCTeCTBeHHO B03HHKmyIO TeJIeCHYIO opraHH3a:qHIO
JIIOAeii, B oc06elIHOCTH paCOBhIe pa3JIIIqHH lIfem,ZJ;y HHMII, HO II Bce ee ,ll,aJIb-
HeHmee pa3BHTIIe - IIJIII OTCYTCTBIIe pa3BIITIIH - no ceH AeHb. BCHRaH HCTO-
pIIorpacpHH AOJImHa IICXO,ll,IITb H3 8THX npHpO,ZJ;HbIX OCHOB II Tex IIX BHAOII3-
MeHeHHH, KOTOpbIM OHII, 6JIarOp;apH ,ll,eHTeJIbHOCTII JIIOp;en, nop;BepraIOTCH B
5
xo e UCTOPHII» 3. B rrpIIBeAelIHOM OTphlBKe rrO,ll,qepKHBaeTCH lIe TOJIbKO 3IIa-
'IeHHe 6HOJIOrH'IeCKOH: rrpIIpO,ll,bI 'IeJIOBeKa ,ll,JIH ero IICTOpIIII, 1I0 H HCKJIIOqIf-
TeJIblIaH pOJIb reorpacpHqeCKIIX cpaKTopOB B rnHpOKOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa )J;JIH
HCTOpH'IeCKOm pa3BHTHH qeJIOBeqeCTBa. CXO)J;IIaH MbICJIb BhIparKena It MapK-
COM B nOMeTKe IIa rrOJIHX K 3TOH rJIaBe «HeMe:qKoH: HAeOJIOrHH»: «JIIOAu
HMeIOT HCTOpIIIO nOTOMY, qTO OIIU ,ll,OJImlIbI npuu3600UTb CBOIO iRH3IIb, H npH-
TOM onpeoe.!Wlll-tH.M 06pa30M. ::ho 06YCJIOBJIelI0 HX cpH3II'IeCKOn opraIIH3a:qHeH,
TaK me KaK H IlX C03IIaIIUeM» 4.
3TH BbIcKa3bIBalIHH coxpaHHIOT CBOIO CHJIy H aKTyaJIbHOCTb ,ll,0 IIaCTOH-
m;ero BpeMeHH, TaK KaK OIIH IIenOcpe,ll,CTBelIlIo 3aTparHBaIOT np06JIeMY, rJIY-
OOKO' BOJIUYIom;yIO Ha npOTHiRelIHII ,ll,eCHTIIJIeTIIH: Cuel(IIaJIIICTOB caMhIX pa3-
Ho06pa3IIbIX 06JIaCTeH: 3IIaIIHH,- rrp06JIeMY, CToHm;yIO, MOiRlIO cKa3aTb,
B elITpe aIITpOnOJIOrIf'IeCKOH IIaYKH H ceii:qac OCTpO AHCKYCCHOIIIIYIO. qa-
CTHhIM aCneI{TOM 8TOH np06JIeMhI HBJIHeTCH Bonpoc 0 3IIaqelIIIIf eCTeCTBeIIIIO-
1'0 oT60pa B COBpeMelIlIoM 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOM 06m;eCTBe.
B 3apy6eiRIIOH IIaYKe np06JIeMa 8Ta pernaJIaCb o IIe)J;aBHero BpeMelIH 60-
JIee HJIH Mellee 0,ll,II03IIaqHO, a caMO pernelIHe OTpaiRaJIO OrpalIHqelIlIO 6HO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIH: nO,ll,xoA K qeJIOBeqeCKOMY 06m;ecTBY. EeccnoplIhlH BhlBOA 0 qeJIO-
BeKe KaI{ iRIfBOTHOM, KaK 6IIOJIOrHqeCKOM cym;ecTBe IIenpaBOMeplIO 8KCTpa-
nOJIIIpOBaJICR IIa cOBOKynlIocTb qeJIOBe'IeCKHX HII)J;HBHAYYMOB, T. e. na 06m;e-
CTBO, r)J;e yJI{€ ,ll,eH:CTBOBaJIH 06m;ecTBelIlIbIe 3aKOIIOMepHOCTII. OTcIO)J;a BbITeKa-
JIO npeYBe.:'IIfqeHHe pOJIII oT60pa, KOTOpbIH: HK06bI lIe nO)J;BepraJICH IIHKaI{IfM
OrpaIIII'IeIIHHM 5. n peyBeJIH'IelIHe pOJIH oT60pa npHBO,ll,HJIO K B03IIHKHOBelIHIO
TeopHH 06 HIITeIICHBIIOH: nepecTpoHKe qeJIOBe'IeCKOrO BII)J;a H 06 H3MeHeHHH
ero rrpHpo)J;hI B 6JIIImaHrneM 6y.n:ym;eM 6.
TaKOH: IIa nepBbIH: B3rJIH)J; nOCJIe OBaTeJIbIIO 6HOJIOrHqeCKHH, a IIa AeJIe
BYJIbrapH3aTopCKHH nOAxoD; K 'IeJIOBe'IeCKoMy 06m;eCTBY lIe MOl' 6bITb npHIIHT
COBeTCKOH IIaYKOH: H BCTpeTHJI B03paiReHHH yme Ha py6eiRe 20-30-x mAOB.
B 3TOT nepHoA em;e TOJIbKO ny6JIHKOBaJIOCb II BnepBbIe KOMMelITHpOBaJIOCb
pYKonHclIoe IIaCJIeACTBO It MapKca II <D. 3IIreJIbCa II IIa'IaJIaCb nepeCTpOH:Ka
TeOpeTII'IeCKHX OCIIOB cOBeTcKoH alITpOnOJIOrHH B CBeTe MaTepHaJIHCTHqeCKOH:
,D;HaJIeKTHKH. COBeTcKHe alITpOnOJIOrH YKa3aJIH IIa orpOMHoe 'IHCJIO qHCTO 06-
m;eCTBeHlIbIX cpaKTopoB, ,ll,eH:CTBYIOm;HX B 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOM 06m;ecTBe, KOTophIe
JIH60 CIIHMaIOT COBceM, JIHOO OCJIa6JIHIOT AeHcTBHe eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT60pa.
OT60p B qeJIOBeqeCKHX KOJIJIeKTHBax COrr;HaJIbIIO onocpeAOBaH. 3TO 6h1JIa 6ec-
cnopHO nporpeccHBlIaH TelI)J;elI HH B pa3pa60TKe np06JIeM TeOpeTHqeCKOH
aIITpOnOJIOrHH, onHpaBrnaHCH IIa OCHOBlIbIe rrOJIOiRelIHH TeopHH )J;HaJIeKTH Ie-
CKoro MaTepHaJIH3Ma. It KOIIKpeTIIOMY alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOMY MaTepHaJIy B
nepBYIO Oqepe,ll,b npHMelIHJIHCb HAeH, H3JIOmelIHhIe B pa60Te 3IIreJIbCa «POJIb
TpyAa B npo:qecce npeBpam;elIHH 06e3bHIIbI B qeJIOBeKa».
nO)J;aBJIHIOm;ee 60JIbrnHHCTBO COBeTCKHX cne:qHaJIHCTOB npHAepiRHBaJIHCb
AO rrOCJIeD;IIero BpeMelIH B3rJIH)J;a, COOTBeTCTBelIHO KOTOPOMY eCTeCTBelIlIbIH:
OT60p B xO)J;e npo:qecca cpOpMHpOBalIHH COBpeMelIHoro 'IeJIOBeKa nOTepHJI CBOIO
{popMo06pa3YIOm;yIO POJIb. ECJIH 011 H coxpalIHeTCH B COBpeMeHIIOM 06m;eCTBe,
TO B OCJIa6JIelIIIOM BH,ll,e. HaH60JIee BeCKHM apryMeHToM B nOJIb3Y HMelIlIO
TaKOH: TO'IKH 3pelIHH IIa pOJIb oT60pa B COBpeMelIlIOM 06m;eCTBe CJIyiRHT OT-
IIOCHTeJIblIaR cTa6IlJIbHOCTb BIIAa Homo sapiens npH HCKJIIO'IHTeJIbHOM npo-
rpecce B TeXIIIIKe IIa orpoMlIollf oTpe3Ke BpeMelIH OT BepxlIero naJIeOJIHTa AO
cOBpeMelIlIocTII 7 . Ho IIapH,ll,y C 3THM nporpeccHBHaH TeH)J;elI:qHH KaK MOiRlIO
nOJIlIee II rJIyoiRe BhIHBHTb 06m;ecTBeIIIIYIO rrpHpo)J;y qe.:'IOBeKa npHBeJIa IIe-
KOTOpbIX cpIIJIOCOcpOB K IIHrHJIHCTII'IeCKOMY oTpH alIHIo KaKOH:-JIu60 pOJIH OT-
60pa y cOBpeMelIHoro qeJIOBeKa BOOOm;e, K nOJIIIOMY OTKa3Y OT aHaJIH3a
OHOJIOrHqeCKHX 3aKolIoMeplIOCTeH: B HCTOpHII qeJIOBe IeCKoro 06m;ecTBa H K
6
3aMelIe HX 06:m;eCTBelIlIbIMH 8. KaK MOiRlIO y6e.D:HTbCH H3 npIIBe,ll,elIlIbIX OT-
pbIBKOB, TaKOH nOp;Xo,ll, npHMO npOTIIBOpe'IHT MbICJIHM <D. 3IIreJIbCa H K. MapR-
ca II He MomeT 6bITb npIlHHT KaK MapKcnCTCKaH TO"'lKa 3peHHH IIa np06JIeMY
COOTHomeHHH co:qHaJIblIOrO H 6HOJIOrIIqeCKOrO B qeJIOBeqeCKOM 06m;ecTBe.
(hOT B3rJIHp; nOJIIIOCTbIO npoTHBOpeqHT H cOBpeMelIlIoMy COCTOHIIHIO IIa-
KOnJIelIlIbIX aHTpOnOJIOrneM 3MnHpWIeCKIIX IIa6JIIO,ll,eIIHH. OTKpbITa H ,ll,o-
BOJIblIO cTporo ,ll,oKa3alIa CBH3b rpynn KpOBH CHCTeMhI ABO C IIaKJIOIIHOCTbIO
K onpe,ll,eJIelIlIhIM 3a60JIeBaIIHHM, B 'IaCTIIOCTH K HlIcpeK:qHOlIlIhIM 9, nop;TBel'iR-
p;elIo MlIorHMH IIa6JIIO)J;eIIHHMH npIIcnoc06IITe.:'IblIOe 3IIaqelIHe alIOMaJIblIbIX
reMorJI06HIIOB, H B nepBYIO O"'lepe)J;b reMorJI06HIIa S 10. Mlloro .D:alIlIbIX H CO-
06paiRelIHM rOBopHT B nOJIb3y Toro, "'IT06bI paCCMaTpHBaTb no,ll, yrJIOM 3pelIHH
p;eHCTBHH CeJIeK:qHOlIlIhIX npU"'IIIII MHoro06pa3He no BceM CHCTeMaM C6aJIaH-
CHpOBalIlIoro nOJlJIMopcpH3Ma, T. e. no cpII3IIOJIOrH'IeCKHM npH3IIaKaM, npeg-
CTaBJIelIlIhIM B COBpeMelIlIOM qeJIOBeqeCTBe B onpegeJIelIlIOM COOTlIomelIHH
pa3IIbIX BapHalITOB 11. JiI3MelIelIIIH no,ll, BJIHHIIHeM oT60pa no BceM 8THM
npII3IIaKaM H,ll,YT )J;OBOJIbIIO HIITeIICIIBIIO, npOHBJIHIOT ce6H IIa HpOTHmelIIIII
neCKOJIbKHX nOKOJIeIIHH, cgBHraIOT xapaKTepHCTHKH rrpH3IIaKOB B norryJIH-
l(HHX B onpe)J;eJIelIlIOM IIanpaBJIelIHH, H n08ToMy HCTOJIKOBbIBaTb HX HlIaqe,
qeM cBHgeTeJIbCTBO cpopMoo6pa30BalIHH, KaK OY)J;TO IIeT IIH cpaKTIIqeCKHX, IIH
JIOrHqeCKHX OCIIOBaIIHM. CJIe,ll,OBaTeJIbIIO, eCTeCTBelIlIhIM OT60p KaK 6HOJIOrHqe-
CKaH 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTb lIe TOJIbKO coxpalIHeT H3BeCTIIoe 3IIa"'lelIHe B COBpe-
MeHIIOM 06m;eCTBe, 110 H HrpaeT B onpe,ll,eJIelIlIhIX rrpeiIeJIax cpopMo06pa3yro-
:m:yIO pOJIb.
O,ll,IIaKO y,ll,eJIblIhIH Bec oT60pa B qeJIOBe"'leCKOM OOm;eCTBe no cpaBlIelIHIO
C COOOm;eCTBaMH iRHBOTlIhIX H3MelIHeTCH npHIIl(IITIHaJiblIbIM 06pa30M 3a CqeT
HCKJIlO"'lHTeJIblIOrO pa3IIo06pa3IIH reorpacpHqeCKOM II CO HaJIbIIOM Cpe,ll,bI qe-
JIOBeKa. II. II. IIIMaJIbI'aY3eII pa3paOOTaJI TeopIIIO TaK Ha3bIBaeMoro cTa6H-
JIH3HpYIOm;ero oT60pa KaK OCIIOBIIOH cpOpMbI, KOTOPYIO OT60p npHIIHMaeT B
lRIIBOTIIOM MHpe 12. CTa6HJIH3HpYIOm;HH oT60p cpHKcHpyeT B KaqeCTBe HTora
CBoero geHcTBHH ROMrrJIeKC npHcnoc06JIeHHH K onpe)J;eJIeHIIOH 3KOJIOrHqe-
CKOH IIHme ItJIII - npH p;OCTaTO"'lIIO 60JIbmOM apeaJIe BIID;a - K onpe,ll,eJIeIIIIO-
MY p;Hana30lIY BlIemlIHX YCJIOBHM. qeJIOBe"'leCTBO lIe 3alIHMaeT onpep;eJIeHIIOH
8KOJIOrII IeCKOM HHmH, eMY npHHa)J;JIeiRHT BCH 3eMJIH, pa3IIoo6pa3He reorpa-
cpHqeCKIIX YCJIOBHH ero mII3IIH yCJIOmlIHeTCH em;e pa3IIo06pa3HeM co:qHaJIb-
HbIX YCJIOBHM 06m;eCTBeIIIIOH mH3IIII pa3IIhIX "'IeJIOBe"'leCKHX KOJIJIeRTHBOB. no-
3TOMY B qeJIOBeqeCKOM 06m;eCTBe OT60p BhIcTynaeT B pacceHBaIOm;eH cpopMe,
BhI3bIBaH O,ll,IIOBpeMeIIHO H3MelIelIHH B caMhIX pa3H006pa3IIhIX IIanpaBJIeIIHHX.
OCTaBaHCb H y qeJIOBeKa cpopMo06pa3YIOm;en CHJIOH, KaK H B mIIBOTIIOM MHpe,
OT6op lIe Bep;eT, CJIeD;OBaTeJIbIIO, K HanpaBJIelIlIOMY H3MelIeHIIIO BHga B :qeJIOM.
MIIKp03BOJIIO:qHH, KaH CeM"'IaC rrpHIIHTO IIa3hIBaTb 8BOJIIO:qIiIOlIlIhIe npe06pa-
30BaHHH B npe,ll,eJIax BHp;a, lIe nepeXO,ll,HT B MaKp08BOJIIO HIO, T. e. B 8BOJlJO-
:qHOlIlIbIe H3MelIelIHH Ha.D:BHp;OBOro ypOBIIH.
COBpeMelIlIoe COCTOHHHe np06JIeMbI oT60pa B "'IeJIOBeqeCKOM 06m;eCTBe
nO)J;TBepiRp;aeT rrp030pJIHBOCTb BhICKa3bIBaHHH K. MapKca H <D. 3IIreJIbCa 0
COOTHomelIHH OHOJIOrH"'IeCKOrO H CO HaJIbHOrO y qeJIOBeKa, 0 pOJIH 6HOJIOrH-
qeCKOH opralIII3a:qHII JIIO,ll,eH B HX HCTOpHH. EOJIee Toro, 3TII BbICKa3hIBalIHH
II ceii"'lac p;aIOT B03MOiRIIOCTb 3aHHTb rrpaBHJIblIbIe TeOpeTH"'IeCKHe n03H:qIIH B
3TOM BamlIeMmeM Borrpoce H KpHTHqeCKH OTlIeCTHCb K TeM KOHl(errl(IlHM,
B KOTOpbIX nOJIIIOCTbIO OTpH aeTCH pOJIb rJIaBlIeMmeM H3 6HOJIOrH"'IeCKHX 3a-
KOIIOMeplIOCTeM - oT60pa B "'IeJIOBeqeCKOM 06m;eCTBe.
TpygoBaH TeopHH alITponoreHe3a 06CTOHTeJIblI0 H3JIOmelIa <D. 3IIreJIbCOM
B Crrel(IIaJIbIIOH pa60Te «POJIb Tpyp;a B rrpo:qecce rrpeBpam;eHHH 06e3bHIIbI B
qeJIOBeKa». AaHHaH pa60Ta Heop;HORpaTHO npIIBJIeKaJIa BIIIIMaHHe alITpono-
7
t
1
I
./
JIOrOB. OHa OKa3aJIa 60JIbllIOe BJIHHHIIe Ha pa3pa60TKY TeOpeTHqeCKHX
np06JIeM aHTpOnOJIOrH"'IeCKOH HaYKH, B nepBYIO Oqepe,ll,b B 06JIaCTH aHTpono-
relIe3a 13. B 3TOM OqepKe H OCTaHOBJIIOCb JIIIllIb IIa IIeKOTOpbIX npHH:qHnHaJIb-
HbIX MOMeHTax 8TOM IIllIpOKO H3BeCTIIOM TeopIIII.
<D. 8HreJIbC IIaMeTHJI onpe,ll,eJIeHHYIO nOCJIe,ll,OBaTeJIbIIOCTb B pa3BHTHH op-
ralIOB qeJIOBeqeCKorO TeJIa, IIrpaBllIHX HaH60JIbllIYIO pOJIb B BbI,ll,eJIeHHII qeJIO-
BeKa II3 iRIIBOTHoro MHpa H B ero 8BOJIIO:qHH. CJIe,[\yeT nO,ll,qepKIIYTb, qTO 8Ta
nOCJIe,[\OBaTeJIbHOCTb 6h1JIa HaMeqelIa TeOpeTII"'IeCKH, TaK KaK B 1876 1'., KO-
r,ll,a 6h1JIa HanHcaHa pa60Ta <D. 8HreJIbCa «POJIb Tpy,[\a B npo:qecce npeBpam;e-
IIHH o6e3bHIIbI B "'IeJIOBeKa)}, He 6bIJIO H3BeCTII0 nOqTH IIHKaKHX HCKonaeMhIX
IIaXO,ll,OK, KOTOpbI€ nOMOrJIH 6bI peROIICTPYHpOBaTb npo:qecc alITponorelIe3a.
O,ll,IIaKO CHJIa TeOpeTHqeCKOrO aHaJIH3a B }J;aIIIIOM CJIy"'Iae OKa3aJIaCb ,[\OCTaTOq-
IIOH:, qT06bI nOJIyqIITb KapTHIIY, KaK nORa3aJIH 60JIee n03,ll,IIHe naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIOrHqeCKIIe OTKphITHH, BnOJIHe a,ll,eKBaTHYIO ,ll,eMCTBHTeJIbIIOCTH.
<D. 8HreJIbC, HMeH B BH,[\y cpOpMHpOBaHHe npHMOH noxO,[\KH, HJIH, KaK
CeMqaC B cne:qHaJIblIOn JIHTepaType npHIIHTO rOBopHTb, opTOrpa,ll,HOCTH, T. e.
nepe}J;BHmelIHe B BbIIlpHMJIelIlIOM nOJIOmeIIHH, nHllIeT 0 TOM, qTO «3TIIM 6bIJI
C;rreJIaH pemalOU,fuii maz ,ll,JIH nepeXO,ll,a OT 06e3bHIIbI K qeJIOBeKY>} 14. BbI,[\e-
JIelIIIe OCHOBIIOM MbICJIH 8TOH cppa3bI RypCHBOM no,[\qepKHBaeT IICKJIIOqHTeJIb-
Hoe 3IIa"'IeIIHe, KOTopoe 8IIreJIbC npH,ll,aBaJI npHMoxom,[\elIHIO KaK nepBOMY H
rJIaBIIOMY llIary IIa nYTH K OqeJIOBeqeHHIO. npH npHMon nOXO)J;Ke PYKa OCBO-
60,[\IIJIaCb ,[\JIH TPY,ll,OBhIX onepa IIH, II IIMelIHO C 8Toro MOMelITa IIa"'IaJIaCb ee
6YPHaH 3BOJIIO:qHH Ha nYTH Bce 60JIee COBepllIelIlIoro npHcnoc06JIelIIIH R
Tpy,[\OBhIM oneparr;HHM, IIa nyTII cpOpMHpOBaHIIH Bce 60JIee COBepllIelIlIoro op-
Talla TpY,ll,a. <D. 8IIreJIbC T:m;aTeJIblIhIM 06pa30M npOCJIemHBaeT 8TY 3BOJIIO-
I\HIO. IIpH 8TOM OH onIIpaeTCH lIe Ha HeII3BeCTHbIn B TO BpeMH naJIeOaHTP"
nOJIOrII"'IeCKHH, a Ha cpaBHHTeJIbHO-aHaTOMHqeCKIIii MaTepHaJI. TOJIbKO nOCJIe
Bblpa60TKH npHMoxom,ll,elIIIH H 06pa30BaHHH nO,ll,BHiRHOH II cnocoonOM K TPY-
P;OBbIM onepa:qIIHM, nO)J;JIIIHHO qeJIOBe"'IeCKOH PYKH, no MbICJIH 8ureJIbca.
«M03r 06e3bHIIbI nOCTeneHIIO npeBpaTHJICH B "'IeJIOBeqeCKHll. M03r, KOTOpbIH
npII BceM CBoeM CXO,ll,CTBe C 06e3bHIIbIIM gaJIeKO npeBOCXO)J,HT ero no Be-
JIIPlIIHe If COBepllIeIICTBY» 15. TaKIIM 06pa30M, TPII nepeqHCJIelIlIhIe CPYH-
}J;aMeUTaJIblIbI€ xapaKTepHCTIIKH cpH3HqeCKOrO TIIna qeJIOBeKa, OTJIIIqaIOm;He
ero B nepBYIO O"'Iepe,[\b OT mHBoTHbIX, 06pa30BaJIIICb He e,ll,HIIOBpeMeIIIIO,
a O,ll,Ha 3a )J;pyrOH:. TaKOBa o,[\Ha II3 OCIIOBHbIX H,[\eH, npoxO,ll,HIIJ;HX qepe3 BCIO
paCClIfaTpIIBaeMYIO pa60TY <D. 8IIreJIbca.
Ha3BalIIIhI€ npH3IIaKII nOJIyqIIJIH B nOCJIe,[\HHe rO,[\bI B alITpOnOJIOrHH IIa-
JIMelIOBalIHe rOMHIIOII,[\IIOH HJIII rOMHHII,ll,HOH TplIa,[\bI. nOCJIe}J;IIee IIaIIMeIIOBa-
HHe JIyqllIe, TaR RaK pe"'Ib II,[\eT HMelIHO 0 qeJIOBe"'IeCKHX, a He 0 qeJIOBeKO-
no,[\06IIhlX MopcpOJIOrHqeCKHX CBOMCTBax. HaXO,ll,KII ROCTHbIX OCTaTKOB HCKO-
IJaeMbIX JIIO}J;eli IIa pa3IIbIX MaTepIIKax CTaporo CBeTa H B AcppHKe npo}J;e-
MOIICTpIIpOBaJIH KOHKpeTHbIe nYTH H TeMnbl cpOpMHpOBalIHH rOMHHH,[\IIOH
TpHa}J;bI, a caMoe rJIaBHOe - BbIHBIIJIH TY me nOCJIe,[\OBaTeJIbIIOCTb B nOHBJIe-
HIIH H pa3BHTIIH npH3IIaKOB rOMIIHH,[\HOH TpHa.D:bI, ROTopaH 6bIJIa TeOpeTHqe-
CKH IIaMeqeHa <D. 8IIreJIbCoM. He HMeH B03MOmHOCTH OCTalIOBHTbCH IIa BceM
Kpyre OTHOCH:m;IIXCH CIO,ll,a BonpocoB, YKamy OCHOBHbIe 16. Y palIIIHX npe,[\-
CTaBHTeJIeH ceMeHCTBa rOMHHH}J; - aBCTpaJIOnHTeROB, Ky,[\a, OqeBII,ll,IIO, CJle-
}J;yeT OTIIOCIITb II npe3IIII,[\maIITpona, npHMoxom,[\elIHe 6bIJIO BnOJIlIe OT"'IeTJIH-
BbUI, HO nponOpl(IIII KHCTII 3aMeTJlO OTJIuqaJIHCb OT COBpeMelIlIbIX, B qaCTHOCTII
6bIJI MaJIO pa3BHT nepBhIM JIY"'I. YKopO"'IeIIIIOCTb nepBoro JIy"'Ia, IIeCOllfHeHHO,
CIIHiRaJIa CHJIY 3aXBa Ta II npenHTCTBOBaJIa nOJIHo:qeIIHOMY HCnOJIb30BalIHIO
PYKII KaR opraHa TpY}J;a. KHCTb apxalITponOB - nHTeKalITponOB II CIIIIaHTpO-
nOB - npe}J;CTaBJIeHa maJIKIIMH cpparMelITaMH, HO cTa6HJIbHaH cpopMa
8
I
I
,
HIIiRlIenaJIeOJIHTHqeCKHX OpY}J,IIM caMa no ce6e CBII.lI;eTeJIbCTByeT 06 YCOBep-
menCTBOBalIIIH KHCTH. HaKoHe , III03r l\OCTIIraeT pa3MepOB M03ra COBpeMeH-
Horo qeJIOBeKa IIa CTa,ll,IIIf HeaH}J,epTaJIb:qa, a BnOJIlIe COBpeMelIlIYIO CTPyKTYPY
npII06peTaeT e:m;e n03JKe, lIa CTa,ll,HII nepexo.ll;a OT IIealI.lI;epTaJIb:qa K qeJIOBeKY
COBpeMeHHoro BII,ll,a.
TaKHM 06pa30M, HOBBiimHe naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrHqeCKHe }J,aIIlibIe IIaXO.ll;HTCH
B nOJIIIOM COrJIaCIIII C TPY,ll,OBOH Teopuell alITponorene3a, C IIa]\Ie IeIIUOH
. 3IIreJIbCOM nepHO.ll;II3a IIeH nOHBJIelIHH H cpOpMHpoBaHIIH B alITponorelIe-
3e cne:qIIcpHqeCKH qeJIOBeqeCKHX qepT. Ho 3BpIICTH"'IeCKaH CHJIa TPY,ll,OBOM
TeopIIH alITponorelIe3a He TOJIbKO B 3TOM. HaK H B np06JIeMe COOTlIomelIHH
OHOJIOrHqeCKOrO II co:qHaJIblIOrO Y qeJIOBeKa, KOII:qen:qHH . 3IIreJIbCa lIe
TOJIbIW 06'hHCIIHeT 3MTIHpHqeCKHe cpaKTbI, lIe TOJIbKO 6e360JIe3IIelIII0 BKJIIOqa-
eT B ce6H pe3YJIbTaTbI IIOBbIX HCCJIe,ll,OBaHIIH, 110 II YKa3bIBaeT nYTb .D:aJIblIeH-
mHX TeOpeTII"'IeCKHX nOHcKoB, YCTalIaBJIHBaeT KpuTepIIH ,ll,JIH o:qeIIKII Tex HJIIf
HlIbIX TeOpeTHqeCKHX B3rJIH,ll,oB, nOMoraeT oT)J;eJIHTb nepcneKTHBlIbIe rHnOTe-
3bI OT TeOpeTH"'IeCKH 6eCnJIO.ll;IIhIX IIJIII COMIIHTeJIblIbIX. . 3IIreJIbC y6e,ll,IITeJIb-
110 OOOCIIOBaJI Te3HC 0 TOM, qTO CTaHOBJIeHHe IICTHHHO "'IeJIOBe"'leCKOH cym;IIO-
CTH, cpOpMIIpOBalIHe qeJIOBeKa pa3YMHoro npOHCXO,ll,HJIII no.ll; nOCTOHlIlIbIM
pemaIOm;HM B03.l1;eMCTBHeM TpY.lI;a, HO Me.ll;JIelIlIO H nOCTenelIIIO, H 3alIHJIIf
rpOMa}J,HbIM OTpe30K BpeMelIII. 3TOT nepHO,ll" Tenepb peKOHCTPYHPyeMbIM Ha
OCIIOBaHHH HCKonaeMhIX HaXO,J:OK, paBeII nO'ITH 3-4 MJIII JIeT. C 8TOM TOqKIf
3pelIHH MaJIOnepCneKTHBlIbIMH ,ll,JIH .lI;aJIblIeMmeM pa3pa60TKH BhIrJIH}J,HT pac-
npOCTpaHeHlIbIe palIbme B HameM JIHTepaType rHTIOTe3bI 0 B03IIHKHOBelIHR
BceM cOBoKynHocTH qeJIOBeqeCKHX CBOHCTB B IIHmlIeM naJIeOJIHTe H 0 .n:OBe-
.lI;elIHH iRIIBOTII000pa3IIOrO COCTOHIIHH BnJIOTb .lI;O nOHBJIelIIIH COBpeMelIlIoro
IeJIOBeKa.
HacaHcb Bonpoca 0 cpopMax nOBe,ll,eIIHH 06e3bHII, ,ll,aBmHX HaqaJIO Ton
BeTBH, KOTopaH Be.ll;eT K qeJIOBeKY, . 3IIreJIbC nHCaJI: «HamH 06e3bHHO-
nO,ll,06HhIe npe}J,KH, KaK yiRe CKa3a1I0, 6bIJIH 06m;eCTBelIlIhIMH mHBOTlIbIMH;
BnOJIHe OqeBH.lI;IIO, qTO HeJIb3H BbIBO)J,HTb TIpOHCXOiR,ll,eIIHe qeJIOBeKa, 3Toro
HaH60JIee 06m;eCTBeHHoro H3 Bcex mHBOTlIbIX, OT IIe06m;eCTBeIIIIbIX 6JIIIiRaH-
mIIX npe.ll;KOB» 17. AHaJIOruqlIaH MbICJIb B em;e 60JIee OT"'IeTJIIIBOH cpopMe
BbIpameHa B H3BeCTHOM nHCbMe . 3IIreJIbCa K n. 31. 31aBpOBY OT 12-
17 HOH6pH 1875 1'.: «Ho, C ,ll,pyroH CTOpOHbI, H lIe Mory COrJIaCHTbCH C BaMH.
qTO ,,60pb6a Bcex TIpOTHB Bcex" 6bIJIa nepBoH cpa30M qeJIOBeqeCKOrO pa3BIITHH.
no MoeMY MlIeIIHIO, o6:m;ecTBe1IHbIH IIIICTHIIKT 6bIJI O.ll;IIHM H3 BamlIenrnHX
pbIqarOB pa3BIITHH qeJIOBeKa H3 06e3bHlIbI. nepBbIe JIIO,ll,H, BepOHTIIO, lliHJIII
CTa.ll;aMH, H IIaCKOJIbKO Ham B3rJIH}J, MomeT npOIIHKHYTb B rJIy6b BeKOB, MbI
HaXO)J;IIlIf, qTO TaR 8TO If 6bIJIO» 18. OrpOMHoe KOJIH"'IeCTBO IIa6JIIO.lI;elIHll IIaL\
mH3IIbIO 06e3bHH B 300napKax, B CTIe HaJIblIhIX TIHTOMIIHKax, a TaKn e IIa
BOJIe nO.ll;TBep,ll,HJIO 3TY TOqKY 3peHHH. nCKJlIO IeIIHH IIeT, a CJIe.ll;OBaTeJIbHO,IIeT
H OCIIOBalIHH D;JIH COMHelIHM B OOm;eCTBeIIIIOM npHpO)J;e BhIMeprnHX IICXOD;IIbIX
cpOpM, p;aBmHX HaqaJIO ceMellCTBY rOMHIIH,ll,. HOCBeHIIO nO}J,TBepiR)J;aeT 8TO H
rHnOTeTHqeCKII peKOIICTPYIIpyeMbIll 06pa3 mH3IIH aBCTpaJIOTIIITeKOB 19.
HecMoTpH Ha 06IIJIHe IIa6JIIO,ll,eHHH IIaL\ cTa)JlIoH mH3IIbIO COBpeMelIHhIX
npHMaTOB, B IIameM pacIIopHmeHHII IIeT nOKa Ha,ll,eiRHOrO RpHTepIfH }J,JIH 3KCT-
panOJIH:qHII nOJIyqeHlIbIX ,ll,aIIHbIX Ha HCKOnaeMbIe cpOpMbI, KaK IIeT H HeTIO-
cpe.ll;CTBeHlIhIx MaTepHaJIOB, KOTophIe n03BOJIHJIH 6bI peKOIICTpYHpOBaTb 06pa3
mH3HH 8TIIX IICKonaeMhIX cpOpM, ,ll,aBmHX IIa"'laJIO rOMIIIIII)J;aM. IT08TOMY TIOKa
He cym;ecTByeT O.ll;H03IIaqlIOro HX HCTOJIKOBaIIHH. B Ka"'leCTBe HCXO,ll,IIOH cpop-
MbI CTa.ll;HbIX B3aIIMOOTHomeHHH, nOCJIymIIBmeH OCIIOBOH .D:JIH B03HHKHOBelIHH
nepB06bITIIoro CTa.ll;a H 3aTeM pO,ll,OBOn opraHH3a IIH, cpHrYPHpYIOT CTa.ll;a C
P;OMHHIIpOBaHIIeM caM:qOB H TaR Ha3bIBaeMOH rapeMIIOH ceMbeH HJIH CTa,ll,i.\l
9
,
6e3 .lI;OMIIIIHpOBaHHH MyiRCKOrO nOJIa 20. O,ll,IIaKO npH JIIOOoiI peKOIICTPYK:qHH
CJIe)J;yeT y IIIThlBaTb npIIBe,ll,elIlIhIe cpYII,ll,aMelITaJIblIhIe YKa3alIHH <D. 3HreJIbCa
IIa 06m;eCTBelIlIhIiI xapaKTep iRH3IIH ,ll,ame Y caMhIX palIlI IIX npe.ll;IDeCTBelIIIII-
KOB IeJIOBeKa.
Hp06JIellla B03IIHKIIOBelIHH MbIIDJIelIIIH II H3hIKa B l(eJIOM .lI;aJIeKO BhIXO,ll,IIT
3a pallfKII aIITpOnOJIOrH'IeCKOH TellfaTIIKH, 110 KOIIKpeTlIaH HHcpopMa:qHH 0 nep-
BbIX 3Tanax HX pa3BIITIIH, nOJIyqaeMaH B pe3yJIbTaTe H3yqelIHH KOCTlIbIX
OCTaTKOB HCKonaeMbIX JIIO,ll,eII, ,ll,aeT. B03l1fOmHOCTb IIa ,ll,aIIIIOM 3Tane XOTH ObI
rIInOTeTII IeCKH peKOIICTpYIIpOBaTb OCIIOBlIhIe cTaWlH cpOpMHpOBalIHH no.ll;-
JIHIIIIO qeJIOBe'IeCKOH peqII II C03IIaIIHH. AIITpOnOJIOrH lIe pa3 npe)J;npHIIHlIfa-
JIH nonhITKII B 3TOllf IIanpaBJIelIHII 21. Kap.ll;IIHaJIblIO BaiRIIhIM B CBH3H C no-
,ll,06IIOH peKOHcTpyKl(IIeH HBJIHeTCH BnepBhIe pa3pa6OTalIIIoe B «HeMe:qKoii
II)J;eOJIOrHII» H 3aTellf pa3BeplIYTOe B pH)J;e .lI;pyrHx Tpy.ll;OB K. MapKca H
<D. 3IIreJIbCa, oc06elIIIo B «POJIII Tpy)J;a B npo ecce npeBpam;elIHH 06e3bHIIbI
B 'IeJIOBeKa», npe.ll;CTaBJIelIHe 0 B03IIHKIIOBelIHII MhIIDJIelIHH H pe'IH KaK
CJIe.ll;CTBIIH 06m;eCTBelIlIoH opralIH3a HII .lI;peBlIeHmnx qeJIOBeqeCKHX KOJIJIeK-
TIIBOB, CJIe,ll,CTBHH caMoro cpaKTa KOJI,'!eKTHBIIOH iRII3IIII IICKonaeMhIX rOMHIIII)J;.
OTCIO,ll,a JIerKO C.lI;eJIaTb BhIBO)J;, 'ITO npe06pa30BaHHe M03ra, yCJIOmlIelIHe MbIID-
JIelIHH H YCOBepIDelICTBOBaHHe peqII IIenOcpe,ll,CTBelIIIO CBH3aUhI C pa3BIITHeM
co:qHaJIblIbIX cpOpllf iRH3IIH IIa npOTHiRelIHII BceH HCTOpIIH nepBoobITHoro 06-
m;eCTBa, a CTporo rOBopH - II IIa npOTHiRelIHH BceH IICTOpIIII 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa.
MeiR)J;Y Tellf 3TO TeopeTwIecKoe nOJIOiRelIHe K. MapKca H <D. 3IIreJIbCa nOKa
cJIa60 peaJIH3yeTcH npII pa3pa6oTKe 8l1fnHpII'IeCKHX ,ll,alIlIhIx II KOIIKpeTlIollf
conOCTaBJIeHIIH cTa)J;HII pa3BHTIIH 06m;ecTBeHlIoII OpraIIII3aIl,IIII II Bcex CO:qH-
aJIbHbIX cpOpllf mH3IIII, C O,(HOH CTOpOIIhI, II 3TanOB pa3BIITIIH MhIrnJIeHIIH II H3bI-
Ka _ C ,ll,pyroH. MOiRIIO Ha3BaTb JIIIrnb OTJJeJIbHbIe H OqelIb 06m;He nonbITKH 22.
O.ll;IIIIM II3 qaCTlIbIX BbIBO)J;OB II3 Tpy,ll,OBoiI TeopIIII alITponorelIe3a HBJIHeTCH
MbICJIb 06 IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbIIOII pOJIII orlIH H ynoTpe6JIelIHH MHCIIOH nIIm;H. 06-
pa60TKa lIfHca C nOMOm;bIO orlIH YBeJIIIqHJIa yCBoHeMocTb nHm;II H TeM caMhIM
IIOBJIIIHJIa IIa 1I3l1felIelIlIe 06l1fella Bem;eCTB B 'IeJIOBeqeCKOM opralIII3l1fe. COOT-
BeTcTByIOm;IIe pa3,ll,eJIbI pa60ThI <D. 3IIreJIbCa «POJIb TpY.ll;a B npo ecce npe-
Bpam;elIIIH 06e3bHHbI B 'IeJIOBeKa» IIeO,ll,HOKpaTlIo HCTOJIKOBbJBaJIIICb,OCooelIlIo
npII rocnO.ll;CTBe )J;orllfaTII3l1fa B 6HOJIOrHH, KaK CBH,ll,eTeJIbCTBO Toro, 'ITO
<D. 3IIreJIbC pa3)J;eJIHJI JIaMapKOBcKHiI npHII:qHn IIenOcpe)J;cTBelIlIoro BJIIIHIIIIH
cpe)J;hI IIa opralIII3l1f. TaKoH ynpom;elIHoiI TpaKToBKe npoTHBoCTOHT BbICKa3hI-
BaHHH <D. 3IIreJIbCa B KlInre «AnTH-)J,IOpMHr», r,ll,e 011, nO,ll,qepKHBaH 6eccMepT-
IIbIe 3aCJIyrH m. JIallfapKa nepe,ll, 6HOJIOrlIeiI, nHIDeT B TO me BpeMH, qTO
KOJIOCCaJIblIOe IIaKOnJIelIHe IIOBOrO cpaKTIIqeCKOrO MaTepHaJIa BIIOJIlIe 3aK01I0-
Mepno BbI3bIBaeT OTXO.ll; OT yCTapeBIDIIX B3rJIH,ll,OB 23.
XIIlIfH3M nIIm;H II XHMH3111 cpe.ll;hI iRH3IIH B eJIOM 6eccnoplI0 BJIHHIOT IIa
XIIlIflIIO opralIII3Ma, no B.:'IIUIHUe 3TO ocym;eCTBJIHeTCH II ocym;eCTBJIHJIOCb B
TOH Mepe, B KaKOII 3TO lIfomuo npOCJIe.ll;IITb, qepe3 OT60p 2 . )J,JIH neplIO.lI;a
.,. CTalIOBJIelIHH qeJIOBeKa 3TO Tellf 60JIee BepoHTHO. n03TOMY nonhITKa YCTaIIoB-
JlelIHH npHMOH CBH3Il MOJIeKyJIHplIbIX uaCJIe.ll;CTBelIlIbIX CTpyKTYP ()J,Hl\ H
. PHl\) C H3l1felIeHHeM XIIMH3Ma opraHII3Ma BCJIe.ll;CTBHe BBe,ll,eIIIIH lIfHCIIOH
nHm;H KameTCH Mile npemp:eBpeMelIlIOH 25. Ha nOBeCTKe )J;IIH - 3a.ll;a'Ia npo-
CJIe.ll;IITb, KaR lIfeHHJIaCb 6HOXHMHH qeJIOBe'IeCKOrO opraHH3Ma B npo:qecce
8BOJIIO IIII B npIIcnOc06JIelIHII K XHMII'IeCKOH )J;HlIaMHKe Cpe.ll;bI iRH3IIH no-
cpe,ll,CTBOM oT60pa.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, TpY.ll;OBaH TeopIIH alITponoreHe3a H ceiIqac CJIyiRHT CTH-
lIfyJIOM nOIICKa HOBhIX nYTeiI IICCJIe,ll,OBaHHH H qpe3BbIqaiIII0 nepCIIeKTHBnbIX
TeopeTHqeCKHX H 8KcnepHlIfelITaJIblIbIX pa3pa60TOK. B. B. rHII36ypr B yno-
MHnyTon BhIIDe CTaTbe COBepIDelIlIO npaBHJIbHO OTlIfeTHJI, 'ITO eCJIH q. )J,ap-
10
BHIIY (CJIe,ll,yeT, KOHeqIIO, )J;06aBHTb II ero nOCJIe)J;OBaTeJIen - T. reRCJIH II
K. CDorTa) npHlIa,ll,JIeiRHT - qeCTb )J;ORa3aTeJIbCTBa iRIIBOTIIOro npOIIc:x:om,ll,eIIHH
'IeJIOBeRa, TO CD. 8IIreJIbC C IIenpeB30n)J;elIlIOH rJIy6IIIIon pa3pa6OTaJI np06JIe-
My ero CTaIIOBJIeIIHH.
3IIaqHTeJIblIbIn HIITepec npOHBJIHJt 011 H R qaCTlIbIM np06JIeMaM alITpono-
JIOrHqeCIWM IIaYI{If II rnHpOKO HCnOJIb30BaJI B conOCTaBJIelIHH C HCTOpIIIW-
3THOJIOrHqeCRHMH MaTepIIaJIaMH IIaKOnJIelIlIhIe crre:qIIaJIHCTaMH )J;alIlIbIe )J;JIH
BOCCTalIOBJIelIHH )J;peBlIenrnero nponIJIoro IIapO)J;OB H HX relIeTH'IeCKHX CBH3eH.
CBII,ll,eTeJIbCTBOM 8Toro IIIITepeca K alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCROn JIHTepaType HBJIH-
IOTCH gBe pa60TbI CD. 8IIreJIbCa, rrOCBHm;elIlIbIe )J;peBlIen HCTOpHH 8BponenCRHX
HapO)J;OB,- «p'peBIIHH HpJIalI)J;HH» II «K IfCTOpIIH )J;peBIIHX repMalI:qeB». B IIa-
qaJIe nepBon H3 IIHX CD. 8IIreJIbC )J;aeT xapaKTepIICTIIKY HCTO'IIIHROB, )J;OCTyn-
IIbIX B ero BpeMH II rrpIIrO)J;IIbIX )J;JIH peKOIICTpYK:qHH )J;peBlIero npornJIoro
HpJIalI)J;CRoro IIapo)J;a. Cpe)J;H rrpOqHX galIlIbIx yrroMIIlIaIOTCH HM II aIITpOnOJIO-
I'IlqeCRHe. HCnOJIb3YH cpegHeBeROBbIe XpOIIHKH, CD. 8IIreJIbC Tm;aTeJIbIIO BbI-
6paJI H3 IIIIX CBH)J;eTeJIbCTBa 0 CBeTJIOBOJIOCOCTH KeJIbTCKOro IIaCeJIelIIIH HpJIalI-
)J;HH yme B 3noxy Cpe)J;HeBeKOBbH. 011 yqeJI TaKme C006m;elIlIbIe H HHTep-
npeTHpOBalIlIbIe T. reKCJIH CBe)J;eIIHH 0 TeMIIOI1HrMeIITHpOBaIIIIOM 3JIeMelITe B
COCTaBe IIpJIalI)J;:qeB, KOTOpbIe 6bIJIH 06IIapO,ll,OBalIbI B rry6JIIIqlIOn JIeK:qIIH, CO-
CTomnrrenCH B MalI'IeCTepe 9 HIIBapH 1880 r. T. reRCJIH TOJIRyeT 3TOT 3JIe-
MelIT KaK peJIHRTOBbIH OCTaTOK RaRon-TO 6acKcKoH rrpHMeCH, H CD. 8IIreJIbC
npHcoe)J;HIIHeTCH K IIeMY.
3IIaMelIaTeJIeII BblBO)J;, KOTOpbIH 3aKJIIOqaeT H3JIOmelIHe alITpOnOJIOrHqe-
CKIIX )J;alIlIhIX B pa60Te «p'peBIIHH HpJIalI)J;HH»: «O)J;II lKO K TOMY BpeMelIH,
KOr,ll,a 0 nOHBJIelIIIH IIpJIalI)J;:qeB B HCTOpHH MomllO rOBopHTb C onpe)J;eJIelI-
IIOCTbIO, OIIH YiRe CTaJIH OgIIOpO)J;lIbIM, rOBopHm;IIM IIa KeJIbTCKOM H3hIKe IIa-
pO)J;OM, H MhI C Tex nop IIHrJJ:e 60JIbrne lIe IIaXO,ll,IIM qyme3eMIIhIX 3JIeMeIITOB,
3a HCRJIIOqelIHeM 3aXBaqelIIIbIX IIa BOHlIe HJIII KynJIeHHbIX pa60B, no 60JIb-
IDeH 'IaCTH alIrJIOCaKCOB» 26. npHMeqaTeJIblIOCTb 8Toro BbIBO)J;a COCTOHT B
TOM, qTO CD. 8IIreJIbC HIITYHTHBIIO, HMeH B CBoeM pacnopHiKeHHH JIHrnb OT-
PbIBOqlIbIe CBe)J;eIIHH 0 BapHa:qHHX cpII3IIqeCKOrO THna HpJIaH)J;CRoro IIapoga,
npegBocXIITHJI npe)J;cTaBJIelIHe 06 aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM egHlIcTBe HpJIalID,l(eB.
COBpeMeHlIaH alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKaH C'beMKa TeppIITopHH HpJIalI)J;HII, pe3YJIbTa-
TbI ROTopon 6bIJIH orry6JIHROBalIhI yme B Cepe,lJ,IIlIe IIarnero CTOJIeTIIH, BbIHBII-
JIa H )J;oRyMelITaJIblIO rro)J;TBepgHJIa 3TO e)J;HIICTBO 27, a 3aoglI0 nOKa3aJIa, qTO
B3aHMogeHcTBHe cy6cTpaTa H cynepcTpaTa B CJIOmelIHH HpJIalI)J;CKoro IIapOD,a
6bIJIO npo:qeCCOM aRTHBlIbIM H )J;JIHTeJIblIbIM. HMeHHO 9TQ H HMeJIO CBOHM
CJIegcTBIIeM alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKYIO rOMorelIIIOCTb.
Ha nepBbIX CTpalIII:qax paOOTbI «K IICTOpHH gpeBIIHx repMalIl(eB» CD. 811-
reJIbC, peKOIICTpYHPYH HCTOpHKO-3TIIOJIOrHqeCKYIO cHTya:qHIO B l{eHTpaJIblIOn
EBpone nepe)J; nOHBJIelIHeM repMalICKHX nJIeMelI, Yi1eJIHeT 60JIbrnOe BIIHMaIIIIe
apXeOJIOrHII II naJIeOaIITpOrrOJIOrHII, TaR KaR HMelIUO 8TH IIaYKU npH OTCYTCT-
BHH nHCbMelIlIhIX HCTOqlIJoIKOB )J;aBaJIH eMY IIe06XO)J;HMYIO HlIcpopMa:qIIIO. MeTO-
p:OJIOrHqeCKOMY H MeTO)J;HqeCKOMY 3IIaqelIHIO 3Ton paOOTbI CD. 8IIreJIbCa )J;JIH
II3yqelIIIH gpeBlIeH HCTOpIIH EBponbI nOCBHm;elIa cne:qIIaJIblIaH CTaTbH 28.
Cogepi-Kam;HnCH B lIen Te3HC 0 TOM, qTO CD. 8IIreJIbC BhIcTynaeT B pa60Te 0
repMaH:qax RaK RBaJIHcpH:qHpOBalIlIhIH cne:qHaJIHCT B 06JIaCTII nepB06bITIIOH
nCTopHH EBponhI, MomlIO nO)J;TBepgHTb H IIa6JIIO,ll,eIIHHMH IIa)J; cnoc06aMH
IIcnOJIb30BalIHH HM alITpOrrOJIOrHqeCRHX )J;alIlIbIX 0 )J;peBlIenIDeM, )J;orepMalI-
CKOM eBponenCKOM IIaCeJIeIIHH.
OTRa3aBIDHCb OT orrpegeJIelIlIbIX BbICRa3hIBalIHH no nOBogy cpH3H'IeCKOrO
06JIHKa IIIImlIenaJIeOJIHTHqeCKOrO IIaCeJIelIHH EBponbI BBH)J;y cpparMelITaplIO-
CTH HaXO)J;OR, CD. 8HreJIbC npH paCCMOTpeHHH BepXlIerraJIeOJIHTHqeCRHX JIIO)J;eH
11
onHpaeTCH YiRe IIa 60JIee onpe;n;eJIelIlIbIM H 60JIee pa3IIOoGpa3IIbIH MaTepHaJI.
K 1881-1882 n., Ror,ll,a 6bIJIa Hanncalla pa60Ta «K HCTOpHH ;n;peBIIHX rep-
MalIl(eB», B EBpone yiRe 6b1JIO OTRpbITO IIeCROJIbKO CKeJIeTOB BepXHenaJIeOJIH-
THqeCROrO HaCeJIeIIIIH. HeRoTopbIe 3JIeMelITbI ero RYJIbTypbl C6JIHiRaJIIICb C
;jCRHMocaMH. B rrOJIIIOM COOTBeTCTBHH C ypOBlIeM IIaYRH CBoero BpeMelIH
(1). 8IIreJIbC cqHTaJI, "'ITO 3TH 3JIeMeHTbI nOHBHJIHCb B [(elITpaJIblIOn EBpone
C ceBepo-BoCToRa. H3MelIelIHe RJIHMaTa EBponhI IIa rrpoTHmeHHH qeTBepTHq-
1101'0 nepHo;n;a, CMelIa TenJIOrO RJIHMaTa IIa 60JIee XOJIO;n;IIhIH npH rrepexo)J;e OT
HHiRIIerO naJIeOJIHTa K BepxlIeMY 6bIJIH ;n;oRa3alIbI yme B IIailleM CTOJIeTHH 29.
nepeXO;n;H R IIaCeJIelIIIIO :mOXH IIeOJIHTa H 6POII3bI, (1). 8IIreJIbC illHpOKO
HcnOJIb3yeT pe3YJIbTa TbI naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIX HCCJIe;n;OBaIIHH P. BHPXO-
13a II r. llIacpxaY3elIa. 8IIreJIbC c;n;eJIaJI nonbITKY onpe;n;eJIHTb 3THHqeCRYIO
npHHa;n;JIeiRBOCTb HeOJIHTHqeCKOrO IIaCeJIeIIHH; 011 BbICKa3bIBaeT rrpe)J;nOJIome-
IIHe, qTO COBpellfelIIIbIM peJIHKTOM 3Toro IIaCeJIelIHH HBJIHIOTCH 6aCRH H qTO,
CJIe;n;OBaTeJIbIIO, 0110 rOBOpIIJIO IIa ;n;OHII;n;oeBponeHCKHX H3bIRax. MIIOrOqIICJIeH-
IIbIe HCCJIe;n;OBaIIHH rrO;n;TBep;n;HJIH cpaRT cpaBIIHTeJIblIO n03;n;IIerO npOHHRIIOBe-
IIHH HII)J;oeBponen:qeB IIa EBporreHCRHn MaTepHR 30. qTO RacaeTCH H3BeCTII0-
ro MopcpOJIOrHqeCROrO cBoeoGpa3HH pH;n;a IIaXO,ll,OR no PeHIIY, TO (1). 8IIreJIbC
COqYBCTBelIlIO :qHTHpyeT MHelIHe r. llIacpxaY3elIa 0 BOCTOquOM npOIIcxom;n;e-
HHH npe;n;CTaBJIelIIIOrO 3THMH Haxo;n;RaMH IIaCeJIeIIHH. J1 3TOT BhIBO;n; no;n;-
TBepiR;n;aeTCH COBpellfelIHbIlIfH ;n;alIlIbIMII: pe3yJIbTaTbI npOBe;n;elIlIbIX yme B no-
CJIe;n;IIHe ;n;eCHTHJIeTHH HCCJIe;n;OBaIIHn RaR naJIeOaIITpOrrOJIOrHH, TaR H IIbIIIe
mHBym:ero IIaCeJIeHIIH [(elITpaJIblIOn EBponbI nORa3aJIH B03MOiRIIOe IIaJIHqIIe
q,JIeMeIITOB BocTOqlIOrO npOHCXOiR;n;eIIIIH, KOTopbIe HCTOJIROBbIBaIOTCH Hrror;n;a
E;lR CBH;n;eTeJIbCTBO ;n;peBlIeH MOlIrOJIOH;n;IIOn npHMeCH 31.
,:,jOrreIIHBaH reHeTHqeCRYIO CBH3b IIaCeJIelIHH 3nOXH'IIeOJIHTa II 6pOlI3bI C
cQJ3pe M elIlIbIlIf, (1). 8nreJIbC no;n;qepRHBaeT TY 60JIbillYIO pOJIb, KOTOPYIO
Ch.1rpaJIO ;n;peBlIee HaCeJIeHHe B CJIOiRelIHH COBpeMelIHoro, HeClIfOTpH IIa rrpo-
1i\HKIIOEe IIIIe IIa ;n;aIIHYIO TeppHTopHIO llJIeMeH ReJIbTCROro H repMalICRoro npo-
IICXOJ;K eHHH. 011 llHilleT: «KeJIbTCROe rrepeCeJIelIHe JIIIillb qaCTHqlIO BbITeCIIII-
JIp 01\a3aBillHXCH Ha ero nYTH 06HTaTeJIeH CTpaHbI; ocooelIlIo B lOiRHOH H
3ana;n;IH)II; TaJIJIHH nOCJIe;n;uHe H Tor;n;a em;e COCTaBJIHJIII OOJIbillYIO qaCTb IIa-
CeJIeIlIUI,.:XO.TH H IIa nOJIOmelIHH yrlIeTelIlIon paCbI, II nepe;n;aJIH no IIaCJIe;n;CT-
BM CQJ3PI}¥Ii\HIIOMY IIaCeJIelIHIO CTpoelIIIe CBoero TeJIa» 32. TaRIIM 06pa30llf,
B . 13 )J;a;HHOM 'CJIyqae nO;n;qepKIIYThI IIepaBIIOMeplIocTb npo:qecca 3TlIorelIe3a,
01;CYT.<Ci':f BH t),,;napaJIJIeJIH3Ma B pacorelIeTHqeCKHX H H3hIROBhIX npo:qeccax,
coxpa:tIeIIJIe! CYOCTpaTrrbIx HBJIelIHII B cpH3IIqeCKOM THne yiRe nOCJIe YCTalIoB-
JIeHHH rocnO,ll,cTBa repMalIcKIIx H3bIROB.
ij' IhaK. ;)(1),,. 8Hre.JIbC illHpORO II BcecTopolIlIe HCnOJIb30BaJI alITpOnOJIOrHqe-
<nme :O;>o/ iHpI i 1\or)J;a OIIII lIfOrJIH nOMOqb eMY peRolIcTpYHpoBaTb C06hITHH D,a-
.n;eROIJ3, JI<;TopMqeC;RQro rrpornJIoro, OTIIOCHm;IIecH R 3noxe 6ecnHcbMelIIIoH IICTO-
pIIIJ !le,.'IpBe If\cr,t;la<,!J]pHMeIIHH alITpOnOJIOrHqeCRHe MaTepHaJIhI B 8TlIorelIeTH-
qeCI{lf. x :. II cJIe;Ilio;aa.E;IIHx, 011 OTMeTHJI pH;n; BaiRIIbIX MOMeIIToB, HMeIOm;HX
npHII:qI):J;I.:i!I;wtBIIOe; ;3f,LalIeIIHe. CaM cpaRT B03l1fOiRIIOCTH 3TIIorelIeTHqeCKOrO HC-
TOJI1\O ( aJIeOaH pOnOJIOrHqeCRHX MaTepHaJIOB 6h1JI HOBOCTbIO BO BTopon
V:0JIOInm: :;rrpoprJ!-orQ.. Be1\a. (1). 8IIreJIbC peRolIcTpYHpOBaJI C HX nOMOm;bIO
CYOCTp!\;rEhIf\, pemmT013bIe JIBJIelIHH B aHTpOnOJIOI'IPIeCROM COCTaBe cOBpellfeH-
JrbIX,- apO;n;OB, ,nOEa1'Hl,-J.IneCOBna;n;eIIHe JIHIIHH relIeTIPIeCRHX CBH3eH, BOCCTa-
HaBJI .JI aIlC II-qeCEIIMH HCCJIe;n;OBaIIIIHMH H rrpH II3yqelIHII pacoBon
llpHlIa;n;JIeiRIIOCTH, qTO HBJIHeTCH CJIe;n;CTBHeM HecoBna)JelIJIH pacbI H H3hIRa.
IIQ3,,:!,Q¥Y, fI'.IW0r.eIl. TIIqeCRIIe, ,'IICCJIerrOBaFlHH (1). 8IIreJIbCa HMeIOT 3IIaqJfTeJIb-
HpIM j !T;eQIW'q -q,epRIfij; >; IITepef:; n 13 3TOH Crrel(HaJIblIOn 06JIaCTH HCTOpHqeCKOH
IlfITpqnOi[r9};'IpiI;.! ..'u...."u.j,.'ljfii' '-' L
12
* * *
Pe3IOlIfHPYH BCe H3JIOmeHHOe, lIfbI lIfOmeM CKa3aTb, qTO He TOJIbKO «)];HaJIeK-
THKa rrpHpO;IJ;bI» CD. 3IIreJIbCa II B rrepBYIO Oqepe)J;b cpparllfeHT ee «POJIb TPY-
p;a B npo:qecce npeBpam;eHHH 06e3bHIIbI B qeJIOBeKa», HeO)J;IIORpaTIIO rrpH-
BJIeRaBrrmn BIIHlIfaHHe aHTpOrrOJIOrOB, HO H «Hellfe:qKaH Hp;eOJIOrHH», HarrHcaH-
IIaH CD. 3IIreJIbCOM COBMeCTHO C K. MapRCOM, a TaRme 3TIIoreHeTHqeCKHe
TPygbI CD. 3IIreJIbCa cO)J;epmaT lIfHOmeCTBO H)J;en:, rrpep;CTaBJImom;Hx 3IIaqJ:J-
TeJIbHyIO :qeIIIIOCTb )J;JIH pa3pa60TRH MeTO)J;OJIOrHqeCKHX OCHOB alITpOrrOJIOrIIqe-
CKon HayEH. BKJIap; CD. 3IIreJIbCa B nOCTpoeHHe TeopHII aHTpOrrOJIOrHH He
HCqepnbIBaeTCH 6eccnopHOH II 06m;errpH3HalIHon 3aCJIyrOll: C03)J;aHHH TpYP;OBon
TeopIIH alITponoreHe3a, HO COCTOHT TaKme B yCTaHOBJIeSHH KOIITypOB H B3a-
HMlIhIX rpalIHl( 6HOJIOrHqeCRHX H COl(HaJIbHbIX 3aKOHOB B HCTOpHH 06m;eCTBa
H B pa3pa60TKe nYTeH HCrrOJIb30BaHHH pe3YJIbTaTOB aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIX HC-
CJIe)J;OBaHHn B KaqeCTBe HCTOqHHKa 3THorelIeTHqeCRon: H, B 60JIee illHpOROM
CMhICJIe CJIOBa, HCTOpHqeCKon: HHcpopllfan;HH.
1 MapKC K., lht8eJ/,bC t!J. CO'I. 2-e HS)];. T. 3. C. 19.
2 TaM 1Ke. T. 23. C. 521.
3 TaM 1Ke. T. 3. C. 19. BTOpaH <I>pasa IIpHBe)];ennOD: JJ;HTaTbI B pyxonHCH BnreJIbCa nepe-
'1epKHYTa.
, TaM 1Ke. C. 29.
5 CM., nalIp.: Dobzhansky T. The present evolution of man II Sei. Amer. 1960. Septem-
ber; Idem. Mankind evolving. The evolution of the species. New Haven; L., 1962.
6 Wiercinsky A. Zagadnienie tempa ewoljucji cech kraniometrycznych u Hominidae II
Kosmos A (PRL). 1956. Rok. 5. S. 4; Bo.n..fl1iCKuii H. HeKoTopbIe IIp06JIeMbI MeXanJISMa
II cPaKTopoB 3BOJIIOl\1II1 '1eJIOBeKa II BOllp. aHTpOIIOJIOrIIH. 1957. oM 6; Idem. Przebieg i
ewolucji czlowieka II Kosmos A (PRL). 1957. Rok. 6. S. 4. <
7 BlIepBbIe, HaCKOJIbKO MHe 1I3BeCTHO, Ha 3TO YKaSaJI .fl. .fl. POrHnCKlID:. CM.: Poem".
CKuii H. H. BbICTYIIJIeHlIe Ha cOBelJJ;aHHII, nOCBHlJJ;eHHOM np06JIeMe IIpOHCX01K)];enHH
Homo sapiens II RpaT. co061JJ;. I1H-Ta 3THorpacPIIII AH CCCP. 1950. BbIII. 9.
8 CM. 00 3TOM: A.n.eKceeB B. A. HeKOTopbIe IIp06JIeMbI anTponorenesa II BOllp. cPHJIOCO-
cPmL 1959. oM 11.
9 O;(llH 1I3 0630pOB: Vogel F. Anthropological implication of the relationship between
ABO blood groups and infections II Proc. VIII Intern. Congr. Anthropol. and Ethnol.
Sci. Tokyo, 1968. Vol. 1.
10 C1>L, HalIp.: 9if;poUMC01i B. n. "YlIpaBJIHIOlJJ;lIe MexaHIISMbI BOSHIIKnOBeHHH aHTIITeJI B
CBeTe p;aHHbIX reHeTIIKH IIMMYHIITeTa H 61I0XIIMHH anOMaJIbHbIX reMorJI06lIHOB 'IeJIO-
BeKa II Ilp06JIeMbI KlI6epHeTIIKlI. M., 1961. BbIII. 6.
11 0630P j:\aHHbIX II rlIlIOTes CM.: 9if;poUMC01i B. n. BBej:\enHe B Mej:\Hl\HnCKYIO reHeTlIKY.
M., 1968.
12 IlepBbIll na6poCOK TeoplIlI CM.: mMa.n.b8ayae1i H. H. CTaOHJIII3HPYIOIJJ;IID: OT60p II ero
MecTO cpep:1I cPaKTopoB 3BOJIIOl\1I1I II J!\YPH. 061JJ;. OIIOJIOrlIlI. 1941. T. 2, J\l'g 3. IloJIHoe
HSJI01KeHlIe CM. B KH.: mMa.n.b8ayae1i H. H. (l>aKTopbI 3BOJIIOl\HH (TeopHH cTa6HJIJISH-
pyrolJJ;ero oT60pa). M.; JI., 1946; 2-e HSp:. M., 1968.
13 CJ\i., Harrp.: runa6ype B. B. 8HreJIbC II aHTpOrrOJIOrlI1! II IlplIpo,I1a. 1946. oM 4.
1 MapKc K., 91i8e.n.bc (fl. CO'l. 2-e HSp:. T. 20. C. 486.
15 Ta:\I 1K". C. 490.
16 Ilop:p06Hee 06 3TOM CM.: A.n.eKceee B. n. BOSHIIKHoBeHHe 'IeJIOBeKa H 061JJ;eCTBa II Ilep-
B06bITHoe 06IJJ;eCTBo. M., 1975.
17 Mapnc K., 91i8e.n.bc (fl. CO'l. 2-e IISp:. T. 20. C. 488-490.
18 TaM 1Ke. T. 34. C. 138.
19 EMy 1I0CBHIJJ;eHa orpOMHaH JIHTepaTypa. Op:IIH HS nOJIHbIX 06S0POB: Brain C. Some as-
pects of the South african australopithecines sites and their bone accumulations II Ear-
ly hominids of Africa. N. Y., 1978.
20 06sop p:aHHbIX H rlIlIOTes CM.:. (flaiin6ep8 JI. A. "Y HCTOKOB COl\lIoreHesa. OT CTap:a
06e3bHH K 06IqIIHe p;peBHllX JIIO;J:elI. M., 1980.
21 CM., nalIp: BY1iaK B. B. IlpoHcxo1K,I1eHHe pe'IH 110 p:aHHbIM aHTpOnOJIOrlIII 1/ IlPOIICX01K-
,I1enHe '1eJIOBeKa II p:peBnee paCCeJIeHHe '1eJIOBe'leCTBa. M., 1951. (Tp. I1n-Ta 3THorpa-
cPHJI AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 16); On 3/Ce. Pe'lb II IInTeJIJIeKT, CTa,I{JIJI IIX pasBHTIDI B aHT-
1.3
ponoreHese II IiCRonaeMbIe rOMIIHHp:LI II npOlIcxo»\p:eHlIe 'leJIOBeRa. M., 1966. (Tp. IiH-
Ta 3THorpacPHII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 92).
22 KO'leTIWBa B. H. 3BOJIIOl\IIH Mosra B CBHSII C nporpeCCOM MaTepHaJIbHoii: RYJIbTYPbI II
Y IICTOplIKOB '1eJlOBe'leCTBa. M., 1964; 01ia :!ICe. OCHOBHbIC 3TanbI 3BOJIIOl\IUl J\I03ra II
MaTeplIaJIbHOlI KYJIbTYPbI ):1peBHlIx JIIO):1eii: 1/ Borrp. aHTpOIIOJIOrlIlI. 1967. BbIlL 26. Teo-
peTIIQeCKOe YKa3aHne Ha 3aBllCIIMOCTb YCJI01KHeHIIH KOHCTPYKTlIBHbIX cPO pM HSbIKa OT
pa3BlITIIH TeXHIIKII CM.: A6aeB B. H. H3bIK KaK lI;']:eOJIOI'IIH II R3blI{ KaK TeXHIIKa II H3bIK
II J\lbIIIIJIeHne. 31., 1934. T. 2.
23 MapKc K., [)1iZeJ/,bC (fl. CO'l. 2-e IISp:. T. 20. C. 74.
2 CM., Hanp.: A.n,eKceee B. n. feorpacPHH 'leJIOBe'leCRIIX pac. M., 1974; Ou 3/Ce. feorpa-
cI»H'IeCRlle O'lam cPOpMlIpoBaHIIH 'leJIOBe'leCKHX pac. M., 1985.
25 rOXMa1i H. H. IIp06JIeMbi aHTponoreHesa B Tpyp:ax RJIaCCHROB MapRCHSMa H COBpeMeH-
HaH aHTpOIIOJIOrHH II Te3. p:OKJI. rO):1II'IHOlI HaY'!. cec. 31eHIIHrp. OTp:-HIIH I1H-Ta 3THO-
rpacP HH AH CCCP, Maii: 1968 r. 31., 1968.
26 MapKc K., [)UZMbC (fl. CO'l. 2-e IISp:. T. 16. C. 511.
27 Hooton A., Dupertius C. The physical anthropology of Ireland II Pap. Peabody Mus.
Archaeol. and ethnol. Cambridge (Mass.), 1955. Vol. 30.
28 K.n,eu1i JI. C. (DPHP:PHX 8HreJIbC RaR IICcn:ep:OBaTeJIb paHHerepMaHcRoro 06IT(eCTBa J!
COB. 3THOrpacPIIH. 1970. oM 5.
29 I1CTOplIIO npep:CTaBJIeHHii: 0 RJIIIMaTe '1eTBepTH'IHOrO nepHop:a, HSJI01KeHHYIO C pasHblx
nOSIIl\Hii:, CM.: nuf)On.n,U'lKO H. r. 0 JIep:HHRoBOM neplIop:e. RlIeB, 1946. BbIII. 1;
(fl.n,U1iT P. 31ep:HIIRII H lIaJIeoreorpacPHH nn:eii:cTOl\eHa. M., 1963.
30 06sop p:aHHbIX 0 cyOcTpaTHbIx HBJIeHHHX B HHp:oeBpolIeii:cKllx HSbIKax CM.: illumM.a-
pee B. (fl. O'lepKII 110 HCTOpHII H3LIROB I1CIIaHHII. M.; 31., 1941; reopeueB B. IiccJIep:o-
BaHHH no cpaBHIITeJIhHO-HCToplI'IeCRoMY HSbIROSHaHHIO. M., 1958; Hep081iaK B. n.
IIaJIeo6aJIRaHcRHe HSbIRH. M., 1978.
8i q e60KcapoB H. H. MOHrOJIOIIp;HbIe 3JIeMeHTLI B HaCeJIeHHH I.\eHTpaJIbHoii: EBpOIIbll/
MaTepHaJIbI 110 aHTpOIIOJIOrIrn BOCTo'lHoii: EBpOlIbI. M., 1941. (Y'IeH. sarr. MfY;
Bbill. 63).
32 MapKc K., [)1iZe.n,bc (fl. CO'l. 2-e HSp:. T. 19. C. 445-446.
AHTPOllOJIOfI1JI:
HEKOTOPbIE I1TOfM 11 llEPCllEKTMBbI
MCCJIE,l];OBAHMJ/t
P ACIDIIPEHIIE fP AHIII.\ HAYKII
'Ma Bcex 06JIaCTeH aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCROn IIayKII alITponorelIe3 npHBJIeKaeT BHH-
MalIHe IT CneUHaJIHCTOB, H pHAOBhIX "<II1TaTeJIeH, IIIITepecYIOm;IIXCH cpUJIococp-
CKHMII rrp06JIeMaMH MHp03)JaIIHH. IIIHpORO pacrrpocTpalIeHlIoe rrpe,Il;CTaBJIeHHe
06 alITponorelIe3e KaR 0 HaYRe, lIe HMeIOm;en nepcneKTHBbI (q. ;r:I,apBHH
;n;OKa3aJI npoIIcxom,Il;elIHe qeJIOBeKa OT 06e3hHlIhI, CD. 8IIreJIbC ,Il;OKa3aJI, qTO
0110 ocym;ecTBHJIOCb nOA BJIHHHHellf TpY,II;a, qTO me HCCJIep,OBaTb ;n;aJIbille?),
onpoBepraeTcH npocThIM cpaBlIelIIIeM RIIHrII ;r:I,apBHlIa «11 pOHCXOiR,II;eIIHe
qeJIOBeKa H nOJIOBOH OTOOp», H3;n;aHHon B 1871 1'., C JII060H COBpeMelI-
lIon RIIHroH Ha 3TY TeMY 1. Cpe)],II MIIOrOqHCJIeHlIbIX IICRonaeMhIX npHMaTOB
OTKphITbI cpOpMbI, IIaH60JIee 6JIII3KIIe K qeJIOBeRY, BbIHBJIelIbI 3TarrbI ero cpop-
MIIpOBaIIIIH, YCTalIOBJIelIa TOqlIaH XpOIIOJIOrIIH :::nHX :cnanOB, rrOJIyqelIhI CBe;n;e-
IIHH 0 HaJIIFIIIH HeCROJIbKIIX TynIIKoBbIX BeTBen, pa3BHBaBillIIXCH napaJIJIeJIb-
HO C rJIaBHbIM, MarIICTpaJIbHbIM IIanpaBJIelIIIeM qeJIOBeqeCROH 3BOJIIO:qHII, 110
no TeM HJIH IIlIbIM npHqHlIaM BbIMeprnHX, IIapHCOBalIa KapTHlIa cpaBIIHTeJIb-
Ilo-alIaTOMII"<IeCRoro COBeprneHCTBOBaHHH OT)Je.:'IblIbIX opraHOB H CHCTelll qeJIO-
Be"<IeCRoro TeJIa, BCKphITbI )JBIImym;He CHJIbI H 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTH 8BOJIIOl(HH
qeJIOBeKa. I1IITepeC K 3TOH 06JIaCTH OCTaeTCH orpOMHbIM, B IIellf OTpamelIO
J13BeqHOe CTpeMJIelIIIe JIIO;n;eH K neOiRII;JaHlIbIM OTKpbITHHM II IIOBOMY 3IIaIIHIO.
B OTBeT IIa cnpoc paCTeT H rrpep;JIOmelIHe - 06m;He BorrpOCbI npOHCXOiR-
14
.,
J\eIIHH "<IeJIOBeKa nOCTOHlIlIO OCBem;aIOTCH lIe TOJIbRO B CTaTbHX, HO H B KIIH-
rax nonYJIHplIorO xapaKTepa. OIIH BhIXO,ll,HT C MaJIbIMII HHTepBaJIallUI H, KaR
npaBHJIO, qYTKO pearHpYIOT Ha IIOBbIe IIaXO;n;RH H H3MeHeHHH B TpaRTOBRe
'Toro HJIIi HlIoro Bonpoca.
Ha npOTHmelIIIH nOCJIe;n;IIHX 20 JIeT MbI 6blJIH CBH;n;eTeJIHMH Kap;n;HHaJIb-
Horo II3l\IelIe1IHH BO B3rJIH;n;aX IIa p;peBIIOCTb qeJIOBe"<IeCROrO pO,ll,a, npapop;HIIY
qeJIOBe"<IeCTBa II paulI He 3TanhI OqeJIOBeqeIIHH, CBH3alIIIoro C celIca:qHOlIlIhIMH
Haxo;n;KaMH B BOCTOqlIOH AcppHRe. ECJIH CqHTaTb HaqaJIOM nO,ll,JIIIIIIIO qeJIO-
Be eCKoro 06rqecTBa H3rOTOBJIeHHe OPy;n;HH Tpy;n;a, TO B03paCT eJIOBeqeCTBa
C 3TIIMH IIaXO,ll,KaMH YBeJIHqHJICH 60JIee qeM BTpoe. OCTalIRH HCKonaellfbIX
rrpe;n;ROB qeJIOBeKa, 06IIapYiRelIHbIe B AcppHKe, 3aCTaBHJIII HMelIlIO ee CqHTaTb
TeM ROIITHlIeIITOM, Ha ROTOpOM BnepBhIe npOH30IDJIO Bblp;eJIeHIIe qeJIOBeKa H3
iRIIBOTIIOro l\IIIpa. HaxoP;KH BblIIy;n;HJIH OTKa3aTbCH OT ROHl(en:qHH «M03rOBoro
py6HKOlIa», CorJIaCIIO ROTOpOH M03r HcnhITaJI 3IIaqHTeJIblIOe YBeJIIIqeHHe H
YCJIOmlIelIHe CBoeH CTPYRTyphI npH rrepeXO,ll,e R Tpy;n;OBOH ;n;eHTeJIbIIOCTII.
B !{aqeCTBe TaKoro «py6HKOlIa}) CJIymHJI 06'beM M03ra B 800 CM 3 . ORa3a-
f
JIOCb, qTO npH o6'bel\Ie M03ra, IIelIaMIIOro npeBbIIDaIOm;eM 600 CM 3 , npe;n;OR
'COBpeMeHHoro qeJIOBeKa CMor nepeHTH K II3rOTOBJIelIHIO npocTeHrnIIx opy;n;HH,
yme 6ypyqH npHMOXO;n;HIIJ;HM cym;ecTBoM co cB060;n;IIon BepxlIeH ROlIeqIIOCTbIO,
C npOTHBonOCTaBJIHIOm;HMCfl 60JIbIDHM naJIb:qeM 2. HaMeTHJIaCb onpep;eJIelIlIaH
nOCJIep;OBaTeJIbIIOCTb B cpOpMIIpOBaHIIH TaR IIa3bIBaeMOH rOMHIIHp;IIOn TpHa;n;bI.
TeclIoe nepenJIeTelIHe alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKHX C nonYJIHl(IIOlIlIo-relIeTHqeCKII-
MIl, cpII3HOJIOrHqeCKHMH, Mep;HRo-reorpacpIIqeCKHMH HCCJIep;OBaIIHHMH cnoc06-
CTBOBaJIO IIaKOnJIelIIIIO MlIomeCTBa cpaKTOB 0 caMOM aKTHBIIOM BJIHHIIHH mII3-
nenlIOH Cpe,ll,bI (reorpacpHqeCROH 060JIOqKH H 6HoccpepbI) IIa opralIH3l1f qeJIO-
BeKa H 0 pOJIH 3Toro BJIHHIIHH B paCOBon H nonYJIH:qHOHIIOH ;n;HcpcpepelIl(IIa-
l(IIII H p;IIlIaMHRe. AHTpOnOJIOrII BCKpbIJIH H npOCJIep;HJIH B p;eTaJIHX MlIorHe
MexalIH3MbI nOBe;n;eIIHH opraHII3Ma "<IeJIOBeKa B 3aBHCHMOCTII OT HaCJIep;CTBeH-
HbIX cpaKTopOB, eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT60pa, nonYJIHl(IIOIIIIOH CTPYRTypbI qeJIOBe-
qeCTBa II cpep;OBbIX B03;n;eHCTBHn. O)J;IIaRO BCH 3Ta rpOMa;n;IIaH no 06'beMY,
no pe3YJIbTaTaM II no 3IIaqelIHIO )JJIH CMeiRlIbIX ;n;IIC:qHnJIHII pa60Ta OCTaeTCH
MaJIOH3BeCTIIOH rnIIpOKIIM Kpyral\I qHTaTeJIeH-IIeCnel(HaJIHCTOB, TaK RaK olla
HOKa pe,D,KO OCBem;aeTCH IIa CTpalIH:qax norryJIHplIbIX H3;n;aIIHn, B03Mom1I0,
II3-3a IIeTpa;n;II:qHOIIIIOCTH TeMaTHKH H MaJIOH aKTIIBIIOCTH caMHX alITpo-
nOJIOrOB.
nOCJIe OTKphITIIH K. JIalI;n;rnTeHlIepOM B 1900 r. qeThIpex rpynn KpOBII
.y "<IeJIOBeKa npornJIO 60JIee 20 JIeT, npemp;e qeM 6hIJIO OC03IIalI0 HCRJIIOqHTeJIb-
Hoe 3IIaqelIHe 3Toro OTKpblTIIH ;n;JIH aIITpOnOJIOrHH. B 1919 r. BbIrnJIa CTaTbH
JI. rHprncpeJIb,D,a 0 pa3JIIIQlIOH qaCTOTe rpynn KpOBII y pa3IIhIX Hapop;OB, qTO
nOCJIymIIJIO TOJIqKOM R pa3BHTIIlO aIITpOnOJIOrII"<IecKoII cepOJIOrIIH, 1I3yqaIOm;eH
pacnpep;eJIeHHe rpynn KpOBII y npep;cTaBIITeJIeH pa3HbIX pac H IIapO;n;OB.
rpynnbI KpOBH HlIorp;a IIa3bIBaIOT apHTpo:qIITaplIhIMH cpaRTopaMH KpOBH.
I1x XHMHqeCKaH CTpYKTypa ;n;o CHX nop OCTaeTCH lIe BnOJIlIe HClIon. CqH-
TaIOT, qTO 3TO nOJIIICaXapHp;bI, IIaXO;n;Hm;HeCH IIa nOBepXIIOCTII KpaClIbIX KpO-
BHlIhIX TeJIe:q - 3pIITpOl(HTOB. OIIII C03;n;aIOT cne:qHcpHqecKYIO ;n;JIH Kam;n;oro
opraHII3Ma BIIYTpelIlIIOIO 6HoxHMH ecKYIO cpe,D,y, HMeIOT pernaIOm;ee 3IIaqelIHe
npH nepeJIIIBalIIIH KpOBH, qaCTHqlIO 06YCJIOBJIHBaIOT H36IIpaTeJIblIYIO YCTon-
qIIBOCTh KO MHorHM 3a60JIeBaIIHHM, nOCKOJIbKY BhIpamaIOT rJIy6HIIHhIe cpH3HO-
JIOrIIqeCKIIe peaK HII HMeHIIO ;n;alIlIoro opraHH3Ma, a HX qaCTOTa B nonYJIH-
l(IIII - rpynnOBYIO CPH3HOJIOrIIqecKYIO cne:qIIcpHKY. I13yqelIIIe rpynn KpOBII
y rrpe;n;cTaBHTeJIen pa3IIbIX pac H IIapO)J;OB 03IIaMeIIOBaJIO, CJIe;n;OBaTeJIbIIO,
Ha aJIO IIOBOrO HanpaBJIelIIIH alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIX HCCJIe)J;oBaIIHn-cpH3HOJIO-
THqeCROH aIITpOnOJIOrHII.
F
15
I
AHTpOnOJIOnIH Ha npOTHiReHHH lIfHOrHX p;eCHTIIJIeTHn 6bIJIa nOqTH nOJl-
HOCTbIO MopcpOJIOrHqeCROH IIaYROH II nOJIb30BaJIaCb lIfoPCPOJIOrHqeCRIIlIfH
MeTop;allfH. B n;eHTpe BHHlIfalIHH alITpOnOJIOrOB CTOHJIa cpopllfa, CTpYRTypa, no
COqeTalIHIO II qIICJIY CTPYKTypHbIX 3JIellfelITOB BbIp;eJIHJIIICb ROIICTHTyn;IIOHHbIe
II paCOBbIe TIInbI 3ellfJIII. To, qTO 3TO lIe TOJIbKO pa3IIbIe cpOpllfbI, HO II pa3HbIe
CPYH HOlIaJIblIhle CHCTellfbI, qTO cpH3IIOJIOrHH IIerpa, mHBym;erO B TponHRax,
OTJIIIqaeTCH B RaRIIX-TO HHTHlIflIhIX npo:qeccax OT cpII3HOJIOrHH 3CRHlIfoca,
mHBym:ero 3a 110JIHplIbIM Kpyrollf, qTO IIOCIITeJIb nHRIIHqeCROH KOIICTHTYl(HH
HlIfeeT OC06bIH 06MeH Bem;eCTB B cpaBlIelIHII C aCTeIIHROllf, yrap:bIBaJIOCb HH-
TYHTHBIIO lIflIorHlIfH RpynlIeHmHMH alITpOnOJIOraMII npomJIoro BeRa, IIanpH-
lIfep 11. EpOK3. HJIH H. H. Me'lHHKOBbIM, 110 P;JIH nOp;TBepiRp;eIIHH 3TIIX
reHHaJIblIbIX p;orap;OR He 6hIJIO p;alIlIbIx. 110cJIe H3yqelIHH pacrrpep;eJIelIIIH
qaCTOTbI rpynn RpOBH BO lIflIorHX TbICHqaX nonyJI HH 3eMIIoro mapa alITpo-
nOJIOrHH nepeCTaJIa 6bITb TOJIbRO MopcpOJIOrHqeCROH HaYROH H npeBpaTHJIaCb
B HaYRY MOpcpOcpH3HOJIOrIIqeCRYIO, IICCJIep;yIOm;yIO lIe TOJIbRO CPOPMY, IIO H
CPYIIR:qIIH Ha ypoBlIe OTp;eJIbIIOrO opralIH3l1fa H Ha nonYJIH IIOIIIIOM ypoBlIe.
qeTbIpbMH rpynnallfH KpOBII, OTRpbITbIlIfH K. J1alIP;mTenuepollf, lIe HCqep-
nbIBaeTCH cepOJIOrH'leCROe pa3IIo06pa3He qeJIOBeqeCTBa. CeHqaC OTRphlTO
60JIee P;BYX p;ecHTRoB CHCTeM H 60JIee nHTHp;ecHTH cpaRTopoB BHYTPII HX.
He Bce OIIII op;HHaRoBo BamlIbI B CPYHR:qHoHaJIbIIOllf OTlIomelIIIH, lIfHorHe
BCTpeqaIOTCH pep;Ro H n03TOllfY CJIa60 H3yqeHbI. Gp;HaRo HCIIO, qTO nOBepx¥
HOCTb apHTpo:qHTOB npe)],cTaBJIHeT C060H nOJIe CJIOmlIeHrnHx 6HOXHMIIqeCKHX
peaR:qIIH, OTBeTCTBeHHhIX 3a lIflIorHe BamlIbIe <pH3HOJIOrHqeCRHe oc06eHIIOCTII
qeJIOBeqeCROrO opraHH3Ma. I1pII nepeJIHBalIHH IIenop;xop;HIIJ;eH rpynnbI KpOBH
MorYT B03HHRaTb THmeJIbIe OCJIOmlIeHHH co CMepTeJIblIbIM HCXOP;OM; alIellfIIH,
eCJIH cynpyrII HeCOBlIfeCTHlIfbI no OP;HOMY H3 cpaRTopoB CHCTeMhI pe3Yc,
onaclIa p;JIH lIfaTepH II IIOBOpOmp;elIlIoro. Po JIb p:pyrIIx RpOBHlIbIX cpaRTopOB
nORa MaJIO HCCJIep;OBalIa, n03TOMY B03l1fOmlIbI IIOBbIe HeomHp;aHlIbI€ OTKpbITHH.
WH3HOJIOrHqeCRaH aHTpOnOJIOrHH He HCqepnbIBaeTCH H3yqelIHellf rpynn
KpOBH. CTpoelIHe 6eJIKOB ChIBOpOTKH KpOBH lIe Mellee CJIOiRIIO. BbIJIH OTKpbI-
TbI TPH cpOpMbI 6eJIROB_ - raMMa-rJI06YJIHlIbI, ranTorJI06IIIIbI H TpalIccpepII-
HbI .:::-co-CBOIn\nr()COObIlIfH CPYHR:qHHMH Ramp;aH, a rJIaBIIOe - C OCo6bIlIfH
cppaR HHlIfH, HanOllfIDIaIOm;HMH no CPII3HOJIOrHqeCROH aRTHBHOCTII rpynIIbI
KpOBII 3. rellforJI06IIII, OTBeTCTBelIlIbIH 3a p;hIXaTeJIbIIYIO CPYIIK:qHIO KpOBII
(nepelloc RHCJIOpOp;a no RpOBHIIOMY PYCJIY), HMeeT, nOllfHMO IIOpMaJIblIOH
cpOpMbI, em;e IIeCKOJIbRO aIIO:\f8JIbHbIX. AIIOllfaJIblIbIe cpOpl\fbI rellfOrJI06HIIa
pacnpOCTpaHelIbI npeHMym;ecTBelIlIO B TpOnHqeCROllf rrOHce, qTO BhI3BaIIO, 'lI0-
BH,ZJ;HlIfOllfY, HX BbICOROH YCTOllqIIBOCTbIO R IIlIcpeR:qIIHlIf, B 'laeTIIOCTII R lIfaJIH-
pHII . Bce qeJIOBeqeCRHe nonYJIH:qHH pa3JIHqaIOTCH no qHCJIY BXOP;HIIJ;HX B iIx
COCTaB JIIOp;eH, Om;ym:aIOm;HX BRYC oc060ro Bem;ecTBa - <!>eIIHJITHORap6a-
MHp;a 5. nOHBHJIHCb p;alIHbIe 06 alIaJIOrHqlIOH p;IIcpcpepeH:qHa:qHII pac II IIapo-
P;OB no cpepllfeHTHoH aRTHBIIOCTH, COCTaBY ymHoH cepbI H T. p;. Ccpepa cpII3IIO-
JIOrHqeCROH aHTpOnOJIOrHH, CJIep;OBaTeJIbIIO, mHpoRa II pa3IIo06pa3Ha.
qpe3BbNaHII0 nepcneRTHBlIbIM ORa3aJIOCb TaRme HCnOJIb30BalIHe peHT-
relIocpoToMeTpllH. PelITrelIocpoTollfeTpIIqeCRaH lIfeTo)],HRa 6bIJIa npHcnoc06JIeHa
P;JIH orrpep;eJIeHHH cOp;epiRalIHH lIfHlIepaJIbHbIX Bem;ecTB B ROCTHX in vivo,
T. e. y mHBoro qeJIOBeKa, B nOJIeBhIX YCJIOBIIHX. Gila n03BOJIHJIa nOJIyqn:Tb
p;alIlIbIe 0 npo:qeccax MHlIepa:IblIOrO 06MelIa B pa3IIhIX nonymIl(HHx. Co)],ep-
maHIIe lIfIlHepaJIOB B CReJIeTe rrpHMo 3aBHCHT OT cop;epmalIHH IIX B nHm;e II
oRpYiRaIOm;eH cpep;e, npep;CTaBJIHeT co6on em;e oP;IIY HIITb, cBH3hIBaIOm;yIO
'lJeJIOBeIm C npHpop;OH 6.
1.6
.-....
.... .'# .
-----
fEHETUqECKJUi nOJ(xoJ(
KaR 3TO Ha nepBbIH B3rmlp; HII napap;OKCaJIbIIO, HlIfelIHO cpH3HOJIOrO-aHTpono-
JIOrH'IeCRHe HCCJIep;OBaIIHH CBH3aJIH alITpOnOJIOrHIO H relIeTHKY. COBepmelIHO
OqeBIIp)IO, qTO p;eTH noxomH Ha pOp;HTeJIeH 60JIbme, qellf Ha qymIIx JIIOp;en,
qTO qeJIOBeR coxpalIHeT CBOII paCOBhle npII3IIaRH, nepeCeJIHBIIIIICb B p;pyryro
CTpaIIY, qTO Y IIerpa pomp;aeTCH IIerp, a Y lIfOlIrOJIa - lIfOlIrOJI. vb 3TIIX cpaR-
TOB JII060H qeJIOBeR MomeT Cp;eJIaTb BbIBOp;, 'ITO BlIemHHe oc06elIHocTH qeJIO-
BeqeCROrO opralIH3l1fa, B TOllf qnCJIe II paCOBbIe npII3IIaRH, He npH06peTeHLI
B npo:qecce iRII3IIII p;aHHoro 'IeJIOBeRa, a nOJIyqelIhI HlIf no HaCJIep;CTBY OT
npep;meCTBYIOm;ero nOKOJIeIIHH. Ho p;aJIbme mHTeHCRHX Ha6JIIO,ll,eHHn H o6m;e-
1'0 BbIBOD;a 0 HaCJIep;CTBelIlIon npHpop;e BHemlIHX cpOpllf H CTPYKTyphI qeJIO-
BeqeCROrO TeJIa, C)J;eJIaIIHOrO em;e B npomJIOllf BeRe, p;eJIO He nomJIo: CJIHmKOllf
CJIOmlIbIlIfH OKa3aJIHCb nYTII nepep;a'III no HaCJIep;CTBY 3THX npH3IIaROB, HX He-
B03MomlI0 6bIJIO YJIOmHTb B npOCTbIe 3aROHbI MeHp;eJIeBCROn HaCJIep;CTBeH-
IIOCTH.
Cym;ecTBelIlIbIH mar Bnepep; 6L1JI cp;eJIaII nOCJIe nOHBJIelIIIH rHnOTe3bI
nOJIHMepIIH, CCPOPllfYJIHpOBaHIIOH mBep;CRHlIf relIeTHROM r. HIIJIbCOIIOM -8JIe.
CorJIaCIIO en, nOp;aBJIHIOm;ee 60JIbmHIICTBO MOPCPOJIOrHqeCRHX npH3HaROB
onpep;eJIHeTCH B CBoeH IIaCJIep;CTBelIlIon nepep;aqe MlIorHMH reHaMH, KaiRp;bIH
H3 ROTOphIX p;eHcTByeT Ha npH3IIaR cpaBIIHTeJIblIO cJIa60. ,l..(eHCTBHe Bcex
TaRHX relIOB paBHOBeJIHRO, _ P;]I;IITHBIIO, T. e. CYMMHpyeTCH. I1pII3IIaK B KOlIeq-
HOM IITore H cpopllfHPyeTcH RaR pe3YJIbTaT TaRon CYMMaplIOH peaK:qHH Bcex
ynpaBJIHIOm;HX ero HaCJIep;CTBeIIIIOH nepeJJ:a'Ien relIOB. qeM 60JIbme reHOB
J]:eTepMHHIIpYIOT HaCJIe)],CTBeIIHO npH3IIaK, TeM TpYJ]:IIee Y.:'IOBHTb B ero BapHa-
:qHHX npOCTbIe MelIJ]:eJIeBCKHe OTlIornelIHH. T_IfnOTe3a nOJIHMepHH, MlIomeCT-
BelIlIOCTH HaCJIep;CTBelIlIbIX 38)J,aTROB, J]:JIH lIfHor IIX npH3naKOB nOTpe60BaJIa:
npH CBoeH npaRTHqeCKOH peaJIH3a:qHH pa3pa60TRH J]:OBOJIbIIO CJI01KIIOrO MaTe-
MaTHqeCKOrO annapaTa. npHMelIelIHe ero B OTJ]:eJIbHbIX CJIyqaHX J]:aJIO B03-
MOiRlIOCTb KOHRpeTIIO pernHTb Bonpoc 0 qHCJIe relIOB, ROIITpOJIHpYIOm;HX npH-
3IIaR, 110 TaRoe pemelIHe lIe BcerJ]:a MomllO IIanTH. 1103TollfY rHnOTe3a nOJIH-
MepHH nOJ]:BepraeTCH P;O CHX nop RpHTHRe, nOCKOJIbKY 3IIa'IHTeJIblI0 ynpom;aeT
J]:enCTBHTeJIbIIOCTb: relIbI qaCTO B3aHMo)],eHCTBYIOT a)J;p;HTHBIIO, J]:aBaH cYlIfllfap-
HhIn 3cpcpeRT, HO caMH OIIH B CBoelI CPYIIR:qIIOlIaJIbHOn CHJIe IIepaBIIOBeJIHRH.
8TO 06m;ee npe,ll,CTaBJIelIHe lIe npeBpaTIIJIOCb, Op;IIaRO, em;e B 3aROlIqelIIIYIO
rIInOTe3Y H lIe MomeT 6bITb npOTHBonOCTaBJIelIO rHnOTe3e nOJIIIMepHH, ROTO-
paH OCTaeTCH nORa ep;HIICTBelIlIon YJ]:OBJIeTBOpHTeJIbIIO 06 HCIIHIOI:qeH HaCJIe-
J]:OBaHHe MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCRHX oc06elIHocTeii:.
Q}H3HOJIOrHqeCRaH alITpOnOJIOrIIH cpa3y npeoJ]:OJIeJIa Bce TPYJ]:IIOCTH, C RO-
TOpbIMII CTaJIRHBaJIaCb RJIaCCrrqeCRaH aIITpOnOJIOrHH, II lIe nOTOMY, qTO olla
pacnOJIaraJIa 60JIee lIfOm;HOH lIfeTop;HKoH, a npOCTO B CHJIY HlIoro xapaKTepa
npII3IIaKOB, C ROTOpbIMH HlIfeJIa J]:eJIo. Y me nepBbIe nocellfeHlIbIe IIa6JIIOp;eIIHH
II8)J, HaCJIeJ]:OBaIIHeM rpynn KpOBH II 6eJIROB CbIBOpOTRH nORa3aJIH, qTO 3aROlIbI
HX HaCJIep;CTBelIlIoH nepeJ]:aqH cpaBIIHTeJIblIO npOCThI: CHCTeMa ABO 06YCJIOB-
JIHBaeTCH, IIanpHMep, TpeMH relIaMII IIJIH TpeMH aJIJIeJIblIbIMH cpopMaMH 0)],110-
1'0 reHa ()J;JIH BbI60pa lIfemJ]y p;BYlIfH 3THlIfH B03MOiRIIOCTHMH HeT p;alIlIbIX H B
paCnOpHiRelIHH cOBpeMelIlIoH IIaYKH), J]:Be :iI3 ROTOpbIX KOJ]:OMHlIaHTlIbI, oJ]:IIa
pe:qeCCHBlIa. ,l..(PyrHe CHCTellfbI rpynnoBbIX cpaKTopoB RpOBII p;eTepMHIIHpYIOTCH
qam;e Bcero J]:ByMH relIallfII HJIH P;BYlIfH aJIJIeJIblIbIMII cpopMallfH op;IIoro rella.
TaKon THn IIaCJIeJ]:OBaIIHH npOHBJIHeTCH II B HaCJIeJ]:cTBeHlIon nepep;aqe 6eJI-
ROB CbIBOpOTKH RpOBH - ranTorJIo6HIIOB, H B HaCJIeJ]:CTBeHIIOH J]:eTepllfIIHa-
:qHII BRYCOBOH qYBCTBHTeJIbHOCTII R cpeIIHJITHORap6aMHp;y. I1paBJ]:a, J]:JIH MHO-
rHX CIICTellf, HanpIIMep CHCTellfbI pe3YC, HJIH P;JIH rallfllfa-rJI06YJIHIIOB 3aKOHLI
rr
17
"
1
HX IIaCJIe;n;OBaIIHH CJIOiRHee: OIIII ;n;eTepMIIIIHpyIOTCH IIeCROJIbKHMH relIallfH,
110 Bce paBIIO qHCJIO 8THX relIOB OrpalIHQeHIIO H rro;n;;n;aeTCH yqeTY.
)];JIH TaKHX rrpII3IIaKOB, ImR CTenelIb MHlIepaJIH3a:qHH ROCTHRa H Bo06m;e
lIfHlIepaJIblIbIH 06MelI, 3aKOlIbI IIaCJIe;n;CTBeIIIIOH nepe;n;aqH lIe YCTalIOBJIelIhI B
CHJIY CJIOiRlIOCTII caMHX rrpH3IIaKOB, 110 eCTb OCIIOBaHHe )J;YMaTb, qTO OIIH
IIOCHT TOT iRe xapaKTep, qTO II 3aROlIbI IIaCJIe;n;OBaIIHH MopCPOJIOrHqeCKHX npH-
3IIaKOB. Pa3JIHqlIbIe rpa;n;a:qHII lIfHlIepaJIH3a HH CBH3alIbI O;n;Ha C ;n;PyroH IIe-
npephIBlIbIMII nepexo;n;allfII, 06pa3YIOT TaK IIa3hIBaeMYIO TpalIcrpeCCHBIIYIO HJIH
IIerrpepbIBIIYIO H3MelIqIIBOCTb, H, CJIe;n;OBaTeJIbIIO, MHlIepaJIH3a:qHH nOJIIIMeplIa
ITO CBoeH HaCJIe;n;CTBelIlIon npHpO;n;e. Ho B :qeJIOllf 60JIbmHIICTO rrpH3IIaKOB,
C KOTOphIMII HMeeT ;n;eJIO CPH3HOJIOrHqeCKaH aHTpOrrOJIOrHH, OTJIHqaIOTCH cpaB-
IIHTeJIbuO rrpOCTOH IIaCJIe;n;CTBelIlIon CTPYKTYPOH H npHrO)J;IIhI ;n;JIH relIeTHqe-
CKoro alIaJIII3a. 8TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO cnoc06CTBOBaJIO CTbIKOBRe aIITpOnOJIOrH-
qeCKIIX HCCJIe;n;OBaIIHH C rronYJIH:qHOlIlIo-relIeTHqeCKHlIfH qepe3 cpH3HOJIOrHqe-
CKYIO aIITpOnOJIOrHIO.
j
nOnYJIHI(HOHHbut no):(xo):(
HIITelICHBlIaH pa60Ta B 06JIaCTH rronYJIH IIOIIIIOH CTPYKrypbI pac H BH)JOB
paCTelIHH H iRHBOTlIbIX, npOBop;HBrnaHCH BO lIflIorHX CTpalIax, rrpHBeJIa R
nepeCTpOlme KOII elI HII BlIp;a, K 3allfeHe npeiRlIHX KJIaCCIIqeCRIIX npep;CTaB-
JIelIHn TeopHeH nOJIIITHrrIIQeCKOrO CJIomlIoro BHp;a, BHp;a, no BbIpamelIHIO
H. H. BaBHJIOBa, KaK CHCTeMbI cpOpllf. BHD: npH TaROM nO)JXon;e lIe nOTepHJI
CBoeH reorpacpII'IeCKOn H ,ZJ;aiRe IIfOPCPOJIOrWIeCIWH cne:qHcpIIKH, 110 nepeCTaJI
6bITb 8JIeMeHTaplIOH e;n;HHII:qeH 3BOJIIO:qHH. E,ll,HIIHl(eH CTaJIa nonYJIHl(HH,
rpynna oc06eH, CBH3alIIIhIX 60JIee TeClIbIM pOACTBOM B CHCTeMe BH,ll,a IIJIH -
nOTeHl(IIaJIbIIO CTpeMHm;HXCH R POP;CTBY (60JIbrnaH BepOHTIIOCTb CI{pem;HBa-
IIHH BIIYTPH TaKon rpynrrbI, qeM 3a ee npe;n;eJIaMH). B IIaCTOHm;ee BpeMH no-
rrYJIH:qHOlIlIaH CTpYKTypa II3yqelIa ;n;OCTaTOqIIO xoporno ;n;JIH MlIorHX BH,ll,OB,
a B 8BOJIIO:qHOIIIIOH 6IIOJIOrHH B03IIIIR IIOBbIH pa3;n;eJI, TpaKTYIOm;HH TeopHIO
nonYJIHl(IIH.
B alITpOnOJIOrHH IIe06XOAHlIfOCTb norrYJIH HOlIlIoro nop;xo;n;a HIITYHTIIBIIO
om;ym;aJIaCb p;aBIIO, 110 rrOCJIeAOBaTeJIblIOe BBep;elIHe ero 3aTpyp;IIHJIOCb MIIO-
rIIMII cne:qHcpHqeCKHlIfH Tpy;n;IIOCTHMII: CJIOJKHOCTbIO H nO;n;BHiRIIOCTbIO nony-
JIH:qHOIIIIOH CTPYKTyphl, IIaJIHqHeM cne:qHcpHqeCRHX P;JIH qeJIOBeKa relIeTHqe-
CI{IfX 6apbepOB CO HaJIbIIOrO xapaKTepa, CJIOmlIOCTbIO H pa3IIOlIanpaBJIelI-
IIOCTbIO (B relIeTHqeCKOM OTlIomelIHH) 6paqlIOH CTPYKTyphI, npOIIHl(aeMOCTbIO
Bcex relIeTHqeCRHX 6apbepOB. Ho IIa npOTHiRelIIIII rrOCJIep;IIHX ;n;eCHTHJIeTIIH
TPYP;IIOCTII BBe;n;eIIHH nonYJIH:qHOlIlIoro no;n;Xo;n;a B aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOe HCCJIe-
p;OBaIIHe rrOCTenelIIIO npeOD:OJIeBaIOTCH, H 011 CTaJI OCIIOBlIbIM rrpH paCCMOTpe-
IIHH alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO COCTaBa 3ellflIoro mapa. Bo MlIorHX paHolIax onpe-
,ll,eJIelIa qHCJIeIIIIOCTb, a qaCTHqlIO II HepapxHH norrYJIHl(HH, nOJIyqaeMaH HH-
cpopllfa:qHH 0 BapHa:qHHx MopcpOJIOrHqeCRHX H CPH3HOJIOrHqeCKHX npH3IIaROB
IIenpeMelIHo npHBH3h1BaeTCH K nonYJIH:qHHM H paccMaTpHBaeTcH nop; yrJIOllf
3pelIHH BIIYTpHnonYJIH:qIIoIIHon CTPYRrypbI - pop;cTBelIlIbIx B3aIIMOOTlIome-
HIIn, ROTOphIe 06'bHCIIHIOT KOIIl(eIITpa:qHIO qaCTOT relIOB no MOlIoMeplIbIM rrpH-
3IIaKaM II 3aKOlIbi BIIYTpHnonYJIHl(HOHIIOro pacnpep;eJIeHIIH nOJIHMeplIbIx npH-
3IIaKOB. AIITpOnOJIOrHqeCKHn alIaJIH3 CTalIOBHTCH aBTOMaTH'<IeCKH relIeTHqe-
CKHM, a TaR KaR 6HOJIOrHH qeJIOBeRa H3BeCTlIa, nOmaJIYH, JIyqrne, qeM JII060ro
;n;Pyroro H3 IIbIIIe cym;ecTBYIOm;HX BH;n;OB, TO MlIorIIe aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRHe
IIa6JIIO;n;eIIHH CTalIOBHTCH, MO;n;eJIblIhIMH B 06m;en 6HOJIOrHH. II' IIX qHCJIY OT-
IIOCHTCH H3yqelIIIe HIITelICIIBIIOCTII relIeTHRo-aBTOMaTHqeCKHX npo:qeCCOB B
H30JIHpOBalIIIbIX norryJIH:qIIHX, nOBep;elIIIe reHOB IIa OKpaIIIIaX OHRYMelIbI, 3a-
BHCHMOCTb cpOpM paco06pa30BalIHH OT xapaKTepa KOII eIITpa:qHH relIOB H T. p;.
I
I
18
ECTECTBEHHbHl OTEOP II CO IIAJIbHbIE 3AKOHOMEPHOCTJI
CHIITe3 CPH3HOJIOrHqeCKOrO, relIeTH"<IeCKOrO H rronymI:qHOlIlIoro acneKTOB HC-
CJIe,ll,OBaIIHH npHBeJI K 06HOBJIelIHIO MeTOp;OJIOrHqeCROn 6a3bI aIITpOrrOJIOrHH,
K OTIW3Y OT MHorHX KOIIl(err:qHH H Tpap;II:qIIOlIlIbIX B3rJIHp;OB, R IIOBbIM cpyu-
p;aMelITaJIblIbIM 0006m;elIHHM, IIanpHMep R H3MelIelIHIO BO B3rJIHp;aX IIa pOJIb
eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT60pa B qeJIOBeqeCROM 06m;eCTBe. np06JIeMa 3Ta nepemIIJIa
MlIoro CTap;HH B CBoeM pernelIHH, 06cYiRp;aJIaCb C KpaHneH OCTpOTon, npHBJIe-
KaH BIIILMalIHe JIIOp;eH, p;aJIeKHX OT IIaYKH. I1CKJIIOqHTeJIblIaH nporpeCCIIBHOCTb
OCIIOBlIoro Tpyp;a q. ,l..(apBIIHa 0 npOHcxomp;elIHII qeJIOBeKa COCTOHJIa B TOM,
qTO 011 rrOKa3aJI OrpalIHqelIlIYIO pOJIb eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT60pa B qeJIOBeqeCKOllf
06m;eCTBe H rrOJIaraJI, qTO OCIIOBIIYIO pOJIb CbIrpaJI 3p;eCb nOJIOBOH OT60p.
Tpyp; q. ,l..(apBHlIa BbIrOp;IIO OTJIIIqaJICH OT BbIrnep;IDIIX pallee RIIHr T. reKCJIH
H K. CDorTa, B KOTOphIX 3am;Hm;aJIOCb iRHBOTIIOe rrpOHcxomp;elIHe qeJIOBeKa
IIa OCIIOBe p;apBIIIIH3Ma, 110 lIe 06IIapYiReHa Cnel(HcpHKa rrpo:qeccoB alITporro-
relIe3a. Op;IIaKO OCTOpOiRlIbIn nop;xop; q. ,l..(apBHlIa He 6bIJI rrOp;XBaqeII ero
nOCJIep;OBaTeJIHMH, B rrepBYIO Oqepep;b 8. reKKeJIeM, BepHBIDHM B IIenOrpeIDH-
MOCTb H Bce06m;IIOCTb p;apBHIIOBCKoro yqelIHH, 110 lIe yqHTblBaBIDHlIf orpaHII-
qelIHn, IIaRJIap;blBaeMhIX .IIa qeJIOBeKa 06m;ecTBoM. B p;ORJIa.D:aX, CTaTbHX,
RIIIIrax 011 paCCMaTpHBaJI npOIICXOiRp;eIIHe MlIorHX cyry60 qeJIOBeqeCRHX HII-
CTHTYTOB CRB03b npH3l1fY YCTaHOBJIelIHbIX q. ,l..(apBHlIoM 3aKolIoMeplIoCTeH,
H B nepBYIO Oqepep;b CKB03b rrpH3MY eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT60pa. HenoBHlIlIhIH B
C03p;aIIHH KOII:qerr:qHn, a6COJIIOTH3HpOBaBID1fX pOJIb eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT60pa B
qeJIOBeqeCKOM 06m;ecTBe. reKReJIb nopO)1HJI, Op;IIaKO, l(eJIYIO nJIeH)J;Y nOCJIep;o-
BaTeJIen, C03p;aBrnHX H nponaralIp;HpOBaBrnIIX co:qHaJI-p;apBIIIIH3M.
YBJIeqelIHe CO HaJI-p;apBHIIII3MOM MOrJIO 6hI 6bITb npHOCTaIIOBJIeIIO, eCJI1f
6bI TPYP; CD. 8IIreJIbCa «,l..(HaJIeKTHKa npIIpOp;bl», B qaCTIIOCTH CTaTbH «POJIb
Tpyp;a B npOl(eCce rrpeBpam;elIHH 06e3bHIIbI B qeJIOBeRa», IIanHCalIIIaH B
1873-1876 1'1'., 6bIJI cpa3Y ony6JIHKOBalI. I13JIOmelIlIaH B 3Ton rJIaBe TPY)10-
BaH TeopHH alITporrorelIe3a KaK pa3 H 6a3HpOBaJIaCb IIa OrpalIHqelIHH 6HOJIO-
rHqeCKIIX H nOp;qepKHBaIIHII co:qIIaJIblIbIX 3aKolIoMeplIocTeH B 3BOJIIO:qHII qe-
JIOBeKa, rrpeiRp;e Bcero TPYP;OBOH p;eHTeJIbIIOCTH. ECTecTBelIlIhIH oT60p CTa-
EImCH Ha rrop;"<IIIlIelIlIoe lIfeCTO H B npo:qecce alITponoreHe3a, H B qeJIOBeqeCKOM
06m;ecTBe Bo06m;e.
K COlliaJIeIIHIO, pa60Ta 8IIreJIbCa YBHp;eJIa CBeT qepe3 50 JIeT rrOCJIe Ha-
ITHCaHHH H n03TOMY lIe CMOrJIa nOBJIHHTb Ha nOCJIe,ll,OBaTeJIeH co:qHaJI-p;apBH-
IIH3Ma. 8TO yqelIHe oTrryrHBaJIO MlIorIIX OTRpOBelIlIO rnoBHIIHcTH"<IeCIWH,
alITHrYMalIHCTHqeCIWH IIanpaBJIeIIIIOCTbIO, 110 B Ton IIJIH IIIIOH Mepe pa3JJ:eJIH-
JIOCb nOqTH BceMH KpynlIbIMII aHTpOnOJIOraM1f B ROII:qe XIX - IIaqaJIe
XX B. Ka3aJIOCb eCTeCTBeIIIIbIM, qTO qeJIOBeK - nOpOiRp;elIHe mHBOTlIoro
MIIpa - nOp;qHlIHeTCH BceM 3aROIIOMepHOCTHM, rOCnO)1CTBYIOm;HM B 3TOM
:r.mpe. npaBp;a, qeJIOBeR nOpO,ll,II.TI RYJIbTYPY, ROTOpOH Y iRHBOTlIbIX IIeT, KYJIb-
Typa KaI{ 6YP;TO pa3BHBaeTCH rro CBOHM 3aKOlIaM, lIe HMeIOm;HM OTIIOIDelIHH
R e(iTeCTBelIlIoMY oT60py, 110 TaKHe oroBopKH IIOCHJIH rrOJIOBHlIqaTbIH xapaR-
Tep H IIIIqerO Bcepbe3 lIe MeIIHJIH.
BYJIbraplIbIH co:qHaJI-JJ:apBHHHcTCKHM nO)J;xop; lIe yp;OBJIeTBOpHJI yqelIhIX,
II IIa ero cpolle CCPOpMHpOBaJIaCb KOIIl(err:qIIH, corJIaCIIO ROTOpOH pO JIb eCTeCT--1
BelIlIoro OToopa p;OJIiRlIa 6hITb OrpallIIqeHa JIHIDb p;enCTBHeM ero IIa CPH3H-
qeCKIIe oc06elIIIOCTH qeJIOBeKa. Pa3 qeJIOBeR - B OCIIOBe CBoeH iRHBOTIIOe, TO
MopcpOJIOrHH H cpH3HOJIOrHH ero onpep;eJIHIOTCH eCTeCTBelIlIOIICTOpHqeCKHMII
3aKOIIOMepHOCTHMH, H3 ROTOphIX OT60p HBJIHeTCH rJIaBlIeHIDeH. 8Ta ROII:qen-
:qHH OTJIHqaeTCH IIaY"<II10II CTporOCTbIO H nOCJIep;OBaT8JIbIIOCTbIO I'[ lIe IIMeeT
HHqerO 06m;ero C co:qHaJI-p;apBHHH3MOM. Olla pa3p;eJIHeTCH B HaCTOHm;ee Bpe-
19
I
-
II: . '
I
;r)
lIfH BCellfH IIJIH rrOqTH BCellfH nporpeCCHBHbIMH allfepHRalICKHMH II 3ana;n;HO-
eBponeHCKHMH yqelIbIMH. ECTeCTBeIIHO, qTO npH3IIalIHe gencTBHH oT60pa
aBTOMaTll eCRH npegorrpe;n;eJIHeT OTBeT IIa Bonpoc 0 HaCTOHIqeH H 6ygym:en
3BOJIIO:qHH qeJIOBeRa: ;n;a, olla H;n;eT cemac, 6ygeT II;n;TH II B ;n;aJIblIen-
IIIeM, H COBpellfelIIIbIH BHg qeJIOBeRa YCTynHT MeCTO ;n;pyrOMY, 60JIee rrpo-
rpeCCHBIIOllfY BH)J;y, CCPOpMHpYIOm;eMYCH IIa ero OCIIOBe.
B COBeTCKOH alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOn JIHTepaType OTMeqeHO, qTO MlIorIIe CO-
:qHaJIblIhIe cpaKTopbI ClIfHrqaIOT ;n;enCTBHe eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT60pa. Ha 3TOllf
OCIIOBalIHH CCPOPMYJIHpOBalIa ROII:qen HH, CorJIaCIIO ROTopon oT60p ;n;encTByeT
B qeJIOBeqeCROM OOm;eCTBe B OCJIa6JIelIIIOllf BH;n;e II nOTepHJI CBOIO cpopMo06pa-
3YIOm;yIO POJIb. qeJIOBeR, npon;n;H epe3 lIfaRp03BOJIIO:qHIO, cpOpMHpOBalIHe
HOB oro BII;n;a, BCTynHJI B nepHO;n; lIfHKp03BOJIIO:qHH, RorJJa H3MelIelIHH Rap;n;H-
IIaJIblIOrO xapaKTepa rrpOHBJIHIOTCH TOJIbKO Ha ypOBlIe rrorrYJIH:qHH. K coma-
JIeHlIIO, 8Ta KOII enl(HH, pa3;n;eJIHellfaH MlIorHMII COBeTCRHMH alITpOnOJIOrallfH
H cpHJIOcocpaMH, BYJIbrapH3HpOBaHa B OT;n;eJIblIbIX cpHJIOCOcpCKllX CTaTbHX,
B KOTOpbIX rrpH npHMOllf rrpelIe6pemelIHH cpaRTaMH Boo6m;e OTpH:qaJICH eCTeCT.
BeHlIbIH OT60p B qeJIOBeqeCROM 06m;eCTBe.
())H3HOJIOrHqeCRHe H relIeTHqeCKHe IIa6JIIO;n;eHHH n03BOJIIIJIII BlIeCTH B 3TY
IWlIuen:qHIO cym;ecTBelIHhIe ,ZJ;06aBJIeIIHH: 6bIJIH BCKphITbI npOl(eCCbI CeJIeK:qHH,
II)J;YJIJ;He B - eJIOBe IeCROM 06m;eCTBe, H IIa ROIIRpeTlIbIX npIIMepax nORa3alIa
HX HIITeIICHBIIOCTb. npO:qeCCbI H,IJ;YT no rpynnaM RpOBH CHCTeMbI ABO, IIOCH-
TeJIH ROTOpbIX YCTOHqHBbI IIJIH, Ha060pOT, CRJIOlIlIbI R pa3IIbIM 3a60JIeBa-
IIHHlIf - HIIq,eR:qHOlIlIhIM (qYMa, ocna), paKY meJIygRa H gneHa;n;:qaTHnepCT-
HOH KIIIIIRH. B03Mom1I0, H gpyrIIe rpyrrnhI RpOBH TaKme OTpamaIOT pe3HC-
TelITIIOCTb R pa3JIHqlIbIM 3a60JIeBaHHHM. HaJIHqHe alIOMaJIblIbIX reMorJI06HIIOB
B TpOnHqeCROH 301le, B qaCTIIOCTH TaR IIa3hmaeMoro reMorJI06IIIIa S, rrpHBO-
gHT B rOM03HrOTIIOH cpopMe K THmeJIOH alIellfHH co CMepTeJIblIbIM HCXO;n;Ollf
B palIlIellf geTcTBe. npH TaROH cHTya:qHH rell alIOMaJIblIOrO reMorJI06HHa
;n;OJImeII 6bIJI 6bI 6hICTpO HCqe3IIYTb, FO 011 nO;n;;n;epiRHBaeTCH Ha ;n;OBOJIbIIO
BbICOROM ypOBlIe B CBoeH ROII:qeIITpal(HH H3-3a Toro, qTO reTep03HrOTa, rro-
BH;n;HMOMY, 60JIee YCTOnqHBa R IIIIIpORO pacnpOCTpalIelIlIon B TpOnHqe-
CKHX paHOlIax lIfaJIHpHH, qeM IIOCHTeJIb IIOpMaJIblIOrO reMorJI06HIIa y.
8TO CBH;n;eTeJIbCTByeT 06 aKTIIBIIOCTII npOl(eCCOB oT60pa B qeJIOBeqeCROllf
06m;ecTBe, 0 TOM, qTO OT60p BO MlIorHX CJIyqaHX ;n;enCTByeT lIe Mellee HIITelI-
CHBIIO, qellf B MHpe iRHBOTlIbIX. OJJlIaRo OTOOp y qeJIOBeRa gencTByeT B HlIon
cpopMe. qeJIOBeR npaKTIIqeCRH e;n;HIICTBeIIHbIH H3 ROCMOnOJIHTHqeCRHX BHgOB,
3aCeJIHIOm;HX BCIO rrJIalIeTY. ECTecTBelIIIoe pa3IIo06pa3He Cpe,l],bI ero mIf3H1I
;n;OnOJIIIHeTCH HCKyccTBelIHbIM - CJIOiRlIOCTbIO co:qIIaJIblIOH cpe;n;bI, ROTOPYIO
C03;n;aeT 06m;eCTBo. B 3THX YCJIOBHHX lIfarIICTpaJIblIOe IIarrpaBJIelIHe eCTeCT-
BelIlIoro oT60pa, B KOTOpOllf ocym:ecTBJIHeTCH ero ;n;enCTBIIe no OTlIomeHHIO RO
BceM BH;n;aM paCTelIIIH H iRHBOTlIbIX, pacrragaeTcH IIa IIeCROJIbRO HanpaBJIe-
IIHH. 8TO 03IIaqaeT, qTO RaRaH-TO MOpcpOcpH3HOJIOrIIqeCRaH oc06elIlIOCTb,
nOJIe3IIaH B O;n;HIIX CJIyqaHX, CTalIOBHTCH 6e3pa3JIHqlIOH HJIII ;n;ame Bpe)J;HOH
B ;n;pyrHx. OT60p BbICTynaeT y qeJIOBeRa He B BH;n;e RaTaJIH3aTOpa pa3BHTHH,
a B BHge ;n;p06HTeJIH. CTa6HJIH3HpYIOm;aH cpopMa OT60pa, YCTalIOBJIelIlIaH
II. II. IIIMaJIbraY3elIOllf, ClIfelIHeTCH pacceHBaIOm;en. IIIITelICHBHO H,ZJ;ym;IIH OT-
60p B qeJIOBeqeCROM 06m;eCTBe 06eCneqHBaeT H YCHJIHBaeT lIe gocTHrHyToe
B Xo;n;e npegmeCTBYIOm;eH 3BOJIIO:qHH 6HOJIOrHqeCROe egHlIcTBO qeJIOBeqeCRO-
ro BH;n;a, a ero pa3IIo06pa3He. A TaK RaR cpega mH3IIH JIIO;n;en qpe3BbIqaHHO
IIeCTa6HJIblIa, nO;n;BHiRlIa, H HarrpaBJIelIHH ;n;eHcTBHH oT60pa 6bICTpO lIfeIIHIOTCH,
OH He CTHMYJIHpyeT e;n;HlIoro 3BOJIIO:qHOlIlIoro pa3BHTHH qeJIOBeRa, lIe rrpIIBO-
,ZJ;HT R BH;n;OBon nepeCTpOHKe H, CJIegoBaTeJIblIO, R MaRp03BOJIIO:qIIH.
20
r
BeJIIIKa TaKiRe pO Jib 6HOJIOrHqeCROH a)J;anTa HH Y qeJIOBeRa 8. B :II3yqe-
HIIH 3TOH np06JIeMbI COBpeMelIHaH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH TeCIIO CMhIRaeTCH C lIfeD;H-
D;IIIICROH reorpacpHeH. A)J;anTIIBHbIe npIIcnoc06JIeHHH npOHBJIHIOTCH RO MHO-
TIIM 3JIellfeHTallf cpep;bI: R 3JIellfeHTallf lIfepTBOH npIIpO)J;bI, R reorpacpIIqeCROll
060JIOqKe B Y3KOllf ClIfbICJIe CJIOBa H R 6IIOC<pepe. KJIHlIfaTHqeCRaH H npIIpo,ZJ;-
HaH 30lIaJIbHOCTb HaXQ)J;IIT OTpamelIHe B BapHaD;IIHX pa3l1fepOB H nponop-
D;HH TeJIa, B nIII'lIfeHTaD;HII, rnHpIIlIe IIoca. B TpOnHqeCROM nOHce cocpe)J;OTO-
1:J:elIbI IIonYJIH HH C TaRHMII oc06eIIHOCTHMII, RaR TellfHaH nHrMeHTaD;HH,
IIIIIpOKIIH HOC, ;rrOJIIIXOllfOpcplIbIe (YJJ;JIHHeIIHbIe) nponopD;HH TeJIa, B YMepeH-
HOM II XOJIO)J;HOM nOHcax - C npOTHBOnOJIOmlIbIMH. ITpH conOCTaBJIeHHH
alITpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIX oc06elIHOCTell 3CKIIMOCOB H orHe3eMeJIb eB npe)J;npIIHH-
MaJIaCb nonbITRa )J;ORa3aTb cym;ecTBoBalIIIe 6IInOJIHpHbIX pac, TaRHX JIOKaJIb-
HbIX paCOBbIX ROM6HHa IIH, KOTOpbIe CXO,ll,IIbI II 06pa30BaJIHCb no,ZJ; BJIHHHIIellf
npHcnoc06JIelIHH K O)J;HHaROBbIM YCJIOBIIHM O,ZJ;Horo nOHca B ceBepHOM H IOm-
HOM nOJIyrnapIIHx 9.
A)J;anTIIBlIbIe CBH3H qeJIOBeqeCTBa C 6Hoccpepon lIfOiKHO nop;pa3)J;eJI:IITb Ha
)J;Ba RaHaJIa - HenOCpe.D:CTBeHlIoe BJIIIHIIHe IIa qeJIOBeRa H O)J;HOBpeMeHHO
qaCTII1:J:IIaH nepe,ZJ;aqa qepe3 Hee BJIHHIIHH ROCHOH npHpO)J;bI. IToCJIe)J;HIIH RaHaJI
Ha3BaII TpaHCMHCCHBIIOH CPYHKD;HeH 6HoccpepbI. Henocpe)J;cTBeHHoe cpopMo06-
pa3YIOm;ee BJIIIHHIIe OIIoccpepbI Ha qeJIOBeqeCRIIH opralIH3l1f BH)J;HO BO lIflIorHX
cpH3HOJIOrII1:J:eCRIIX a)J;anTa HHX, B pa3HOH IIlIfllfYIIOJIOrHqeCROH pe3HCTeIITHOCT:II
paCOBbIX TIInOB, B 06pa30BalIIIH MHorIIX HX MopcpOJIOrHqeCRHX CBOHCTB XOTH
6bI 1:J:aCTIIquo B pe3YJIbTaTe npIIcnoc06JIelIHH R nlIm;eBOllfY pemIIMY. TpaHc-
lIfHCCIIBlIaH CPYHR H 6IIoccpepbI HCHee Bcero BbIHBJIHeTCH B nepe)J;aqe qepe3
6HOTIIqeCRHH cPaRTOp He)J;OCTaTRa HJIII H36bITRa lIfIIRp03JIeMeHTOB, a TaKme
B ROH eIITpal\HH HX B HOpMaJIblIbIX npe)J;eJIax. MIIlIepaJIblIaH IIaCbIm;eHIIOCTb
CReJIeTa onpe)J;eJIHeTCH nYTeM peHTrelIocpOTOllfeTpIIII, HaXO)J;HTCH B TeCHOH CBH-
3H C COOTBeTCTBYIOm;HMH ROII eHTpa IIHMII lIfIIRpO- H lIfaRp03JIeMeHTOB B npH-
POJJ;IIOH cpe)J;e. Qepe3 6IIOTIIqeCKIIll nIIm;eBOH cpaRTOp 3TII KOII eIITpa IIH OT-
pamaIOTCH H B cpopMo06pa30BaHIIII, BJIIIHH Ha pOCT H pa3MepbI rOJIOBbI.
8TH CBH3H )J;eMOIICTpIIPYIOT 3aBIICIIMOCTb qeJIOBeqeCKOrO opraHH3l1fa OT
cpe)J;bI ero mII3IIH, CJIOmlIOCTb H pa3IIo06pa3He a)J;anTIIBlIbIX npHcnoc06JIelIHH
R IIeH, pOJIb 3TIIX npIIcnoc06JIelIIIH B paco06pa30BaHIIII H )J;IIcpcpepelI Ha H:II
nonYJIH IIH. OCBoelIIIe OHRyMelIbI qeJIOBeROM H paCCeJIeHHe ero He 6bIJIH 6e3-
60JIe3HelIHbIM npo eCCOM, OIIII conpOBom)J;aJIHCb lIfyqIITeJIbHOH nepeCTpOHKOH
opraHH3Ma npII conpIIKOCIIOBelIIIH C IIOBbIMII, nenpIIBbIqlIbIMH YCJIOBHHMII.
Me)J;H HHCKaH reorpacpIIH, nporH03IIpYIOI:qaH BRyne C aHTpOnOJIOTHen nep-
cneKTIIBHOCTb 3aCeJIeHIIH IIOBbIX H cJIa60 OCBoeHlIbIX paHolIoB, 6a3HpyeTcH IIa
npOIIIJIOM onbITe 6HOJIOrHqeCROH a)J;anTa HH qeJIOBeqeCTBa, npeJJ;OTBpam;aeT
CJIIIIIIROM CHJIbHbIH ypoH, ROTOpbIH MOl' 6bI 6bITb HaHeceH qeJIOBeqeCROllfY
opraHII3l1fY He3HaROllfhlMH YCJIOBIIHMH cpe,ZJ;bI.
:
F
<
,
E
,
t-
l
.
t
3THorEHETHQECRH:A: ACIIERT
-
ITpOOJIeMa CBH3H 6IIOJIOrHqeCRHX II CO IIaJIbHbIX 06m;HOCTeH, reorpacpIIqeCROe
COBna)J;eHHe rpaHH:q pac H HapO)J;OB MlIoro )J;eCHTIIJIeTHH npHBJIeRaIOT BIIIIMa-
HIIe yqelIbIX. B XIX B. lIe BIIJJ:eJIII pa3UIIl{bI Mem.n:y pacoBon, 3THHqeCKOH :II
JIIIHrBIICTIIqeCROH KJIaCC:IIcpHKa HHMII qeJIOBeqeCTBa: lIfHOI'Ile aHTpOnOJIOI'Il BbI-
)J;eJIHJIH RpynlIbIe paCOBbIe CTBOJIbI no cpH3IIqeCRHlIf npH3HaRallf H MeJIRHe
paCOBbIe nO)J;pa3)J;eJIeHIIH no H3bIROBOH npHHa)J;JIeiRIIOcTH. TaR nOHBHJIIICb
HII;IoeBponeHcKaH, CJIaBHIICRaH, repMaHcRaH, cpIIlIcRaH, TIOpRcRaH 11 JJ;PyrIIe
«H3bIROBbIe» paCbI 1o .
"
I'
t
21
!,
AHTpOnOJIOrII TpeTbero penxa, YTBepm)J;aH TOiR)J;eCTBa paCbI II HapO)J;a,
paCbI II H3bIKa, npII)J;aBaJIII pemaIOm;ee 3HaqelIHe paCOBhIM MOMeHTaM B IICTO-
pIIII KYJIbTypbI. O.D:IIaRO npaKTIIqeCIme )J;eHCTBIIH IIeMe KIIX paCIICTOB Ha-
CTOJIbKO no.[\opBaJIII Bepy B HX TeOpeTIIqeCKIIe B3rJIH)J;bI, qTO lIflIorIIe 6YPiRya3-
HbIe yqeHbIe Booorne CTaJIII OTpII:qaTb HaJIHqIIe KaKOH-JIII60 CBH3H MeiR)J;y
paCOH II H3bIKOM, paCOH II IIapO,ll,OM. TaROll: HHrHJIII3M npHBeJI K OTPbIBY
alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO IICCJIe)J;OBaHIIH OT HCTOpHqeCROrO, OTpII aTeJIbIIO CKa3aJI-
CH IIa pa3BHTIIH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH, JIHmIIB ee HCTOpIIqeCKOll: nepcneRTHBbI.
B pe3YJIhTaTe RPHTIIKII paCIICTCRHX COqIfHeHHH HeMe RIIX aHTpOnOJIOrOB,
npeO.[\OJIeIIIIH npHMOJIIIHell:HOrO paCII3Ma II npOTIIBOCTOHBmero ellfY JIerROBec-
Horo HIIrIIJIII3Ma, KOIIRpeTIIOll: HCCJIe.D:OBaTeJIbCROll: pa60TbI 6bIJI CCPOPMYJIIIpO-
BaH npIIH IIn OTCYTCTBIIH npHqIflIlIOll: CBH3II MeiR)J;Y paCOBbIMH II 3TIIIIqeCKH-
MIl IIJIH H3bIROBbIMH 06m;IIOCTHMII, 110 nORa3aHa B03MOiKHOCTb HCnOJIb30BaHIIJI
IIlIcpopMa HII 0 nepBbIX )J;JIH peROIICTpYR:qIIH BTOpbIX, OTKpbIT nYTb OT aHTpo-
nOJIOrHqeCRHX BbIBO,ZJ;OB R IICTOpHqeCRIIM peKOHCTpYR:qIIHM. PaCOBbIe, 3THII-
qeCRIIe II H3bIROBbIe 06I:qHOCTII CPOpMIIPYIOTCH Ha onpe)J;eJIeHHbIX TeppHTO-
pIIHX, ROTOpbIe, CJIe)J;OBaTeJIbIIO, CJIymaT CBH3yrom;IIM 3BeHOM MeiR)J;Y IIIIMII.
TeM He Mellee CqHTaJIOCb, qTO reorpacpIIqeCRHe rpaHH:qhI BCex 3TIIX HBJIelIHH
lIe COBna)J;aIOT, qTO HapO)J; npe,ll,CTaBJIeII IIeCROJIbKIIMII caMOCTOHTeJIbHbIMII
paCOBhIMII THnaMH, a RaiR,ll,aH paca OXBaThlBaeT IIeCKOJIbKO IIapO,ll,OB.
TaRaH TOqKa 3pelIHH He MOr.:'Ia 06'bHCHIITb MHorIIe cpaRTbI. 06m;eII3BeCTHO
RYJIbTyplIoe H 3TIIH'leCKOe cBoe06pa3IIe HnOH:qeB. Ho OHO He OrpalIHqIfBaeTCH
H3bIKOM II RyJIbTYPOH, lIe Mellee cBoe06pa3IIbI HnOH:qbI H no CBoeH aIITpOnO-
JIOrII'leCKOH xapaRTepIICTIIKe 11. Oc060e MeCTO B RJIaCcIIcpHKa IIII HapO)];OB
KaBKa3a 3alIIIMaIOT HapO)J;bI eHTpaJIbHbIX npen;ropHH rJIaBHOrO KaBRa3cRoro
xpe6Ta - roplIbIe rpynnbI rpY3HII, KapaqaeB bI H 6aJIRap bI, oceTIIlIbI. 3TO
KJIaCCHqeCRIIe npe)J;CTaBIITeJIH BbIcoKoropHoH RyJIhTYPbI. npaB,ZJ;a, rOBopHT
oceTIIlIbI Ha O)J;IIOM H3 IIpalICKHX H3bIKOB, 6aJIRap hI H KapaqaeB hI IIa O)];IIOM
II3 TIOpRCRIIX H3bIROB, HO eCTb BeCKIIe OCIIOBalIIIH nOJIaraTb, qTO npe)];RII IIX
rOBOpIIJIII IIa KaBRa3CRIIX H3bIRaX H nepexo)J; I1X Ha TIOpKCRyIO peqb npOII30-
meJI cpaBHIITeJIblIO He)J;aBIIO. M .[\JIH eIITpaJIhIIORaBRa3CRIIX HapO)J;OB xapaR-
TeplIa oc06aH KOM6IIlIa HH aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX qepT 12. T:mIIlIf oopa30M,
CYI:qeCTByeT IIellfaJIO CJIyqaeB COBna)J;eIIIIH rpalIII 3TIIIIqeCRHX H aIITpOnOJIO-
rIIqeCRIIX 06m;IIOCTeH.
06'bHClIe1IHe 3TIIM CJIyqaHM )J;aeT ROH enn;IIH MOP;YCOB 3THoreIie3a, CorJIaC-
HO KOTOpOll: 3TII006pa30BalIIIe npOIICXO.[\IIT HeO)J;IIHaKOBO, 3aBIICIIT OT ROH-
KpeTIIOH HCTOpII'leCROH cIITya HII. Cym;ecTByeT HeCKOJIbRO TIInOB 3THorelIe-
3a 13. nonYJIH IIOlIlIbIH nO,ll,xo)J; 3HaqIfTeJIblI0 06JIerqaeT nOIIIIMaHHe 3TIIX
npo eccoB. ECJIII nonYJIH IIH IIJI:II rpynna nonYJIH IIH .[\JIIITeJIbIIOe BpeMH
IIaxo.[\IITcH B YCJIOBIIHX II30JIH HII, B pe3YJIbT3Te BIIYTpHnonYJIH IIOHlIbIX 6pa-
ROB C03,ll,aeTCH 06m;HOCTb relIocpolI)];a H cpopMHpyeTcH CBoeoopa3HaH aHTpono-
JIOrII'leCKaH ROM6HlIa HH :II O)J;IIOBpeMeIIHO C 3THM IIHTerpIIpYIOTCH 3TIIHqeCRHe
oc06eHIIOCTH - oopa3yeTcH CBOH .[\IIaJIeKT, CRJIa)J;bIBaIOTCH RYJIbTYPlIhIe Tpa-
.[\H IIII, nCHXIIqeCKIIH CTepeOTIIn II 3TIIIIqeCKOe caMOC03HaIIIIe. MlIaH HCTOPH-
qeCKaH cIITya IIH HMeeT MeCTO npH MIIrpa IIHX, CMemeIIIIH, Me)J;JIeIIIIOM pac-
CeJIeIIHII. B 3TIIX YCJIOBIIHX, RaK npaBIIJIO, lIe 06pa3yeTcH COBna.[\eIIIIH rpaHHn;
paCOBbIX KOMnJIeKCOB H 3TIIIIqeCKIIX 06pa30BaHIIH. COBepmeHHO oc06bIe npo-
eCCbI HMeIOT MeCTO B CJIY'lae STIIIIqeCROH, H3bIKOBOH II alITpOnOJIOrnqeCROn
HenpephlBHOCTII, npII nepeKpbIBalIIIH )J;Pyr )J;PyroM 6paqlIbIX CBH3eH II B03-
MOllilIOCTII YCTalIOBIITb pa3JIIIqIIe JIIIrnb MeiI,)J;Y Y)J;aJIeIIHbIMH )J;Pyr OT .[\Pyra
RYJIbTYPHbIMH HJIII H3bIKOBbIMII HBJIelIIIHMH H BapHa IIHMH alITpOnOJIOrIIqe-
CRHX npII3IIaKOB. rpalIII hI Melli)J;Y 6JIII3KIIMH HBJIelIIIHMII He YCTaHaBJIHBaIOT-
CH, II OIIII IIe3aMeTHO nepeXO)J;HT .D:Pyr B )J;pyra, RaR II aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRHe
-
-
I
t
22
BapIIa IIII. B )J;aIIHOM CJIyqae reorpacpIIqeCKOe COBIIa)J;eHIIe aHTpOnOJIOrH-
qeCKIIX II 3THIIqeCRIIX KaTeropIIn cpIIRcIIpyeTcH JIHIIIh B npe eJIax Bcen Tep-
pHTOpIIH, r)J;e rocnO)J;CTByeT 3THIIqeCKaH, H3bIKOBaH H aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKan:
HenpepbIBIIOCTb.
OT AHTPOIIOJIOrll1l R 3R30AHTPOIIOJIOrllll
"'
T
HeCROJIbRO CJIOB B CBH3H CO "SceM CRa3alIIIbIM o. 6YAym;eM cpII3IIqeCKOrO TIIna
qeJIOBeKa. 113 TeopHH paCCeIIBaIOlI{erO oT60pa JIerKO C)J;eJIaTb BbIBO)J; 0 HeB03-
MonUIOCTII pe3KOH nepeCTponKH cpII3IIqeCKIIX ocooelIlIOCTeH COBpeMelIlIoro qe-
JIOBeKa B 6Y)J;ym;eM. IT pOTIIBOpeqIIe MeiR)J;y cTa6IIJIbHOCTbIO cpII3IIqeCROrO 06-
JIIIKa qeJIOBeKa II orpOMHhIM IIOTOKOM HHcpopMa IIH, KOTOpbIH IIaBaJIIIBaeTCH
Ha IIero, CHIIMaeTCH rIIIIOTe30H KOJIJIeKTIIBlIoro IIf03ra. CorJIaclIo eH, HIICPOp-
Ma IIH aTa YCBaIIBaeTCH II IIepepa6aThlBaeTcH lIe O)J;IIIIM qeJIOBeROM, a KOJI-
JIeRTHBaMII JIIO)J;eH, qIICJIelIlIO Bce YBeJIHqIIBaIOm;IIMIICH: 3Ta TpIIBHaJIblIaH
H)J;eH, YBbI, qaCTO 3aOhlBaeTCH. npH nOCTOHlIlIOM COBeprneHCTBOBalIHH RaHa-
JIOB IIlIcpopMa IIII II 06Y'I8IIHH MOffiHO Ha.Il;eHTbCH, 'ITO qeJIOBe'I8CTBO ROJIJIeR-
TIIBlIbIMII YCIIJIIIHMII cnpaBIITCH C IIeH H B 6ygym;eM, RaK OHO CnpaBJIHJIOCb
C IIeH B npOIIIJIOM. O)J;IIaKO lIe CJIe)J;yeT 3a6bIBaTb, qTO MHeHIIe 06 OTIIOCII-
TeJIbHOH CTaOII.TIbIIOCTH cpII3HqeCKOrO TIIna qeJIOBeKa B 6Y)J;ym;eM npe)J;CTaB-
JIHeT COGon aKCTpanOJIH HIO IIa oY)J;ym;ee )J;alIlIbIX, nOJIyqelIHbIX npH II3yqe-
HIIII npOrnJIOH IICTOpIIII qeJIOBeqeCTBa. TaRIIe 3RCTpanOJIH HH qaCTO 6bIBaIOT
ornII60qlIhI. Haxo.Il;HI:qHecH B IIarneM pacnopHffielIIIII CBe.Il;elIHH 06 aBOJIIO HH
MbICJIHm;HX cym;ecTB OrpaHHqelIbI e)J;IIIIIIqlIhlM npIIMepOM HaIIIen nJIalIeThI.
TeOpeTlI'IeCKHe OCIIOBbI 3K30aHTpOnOJIOrHH COBepIIIelIlIO lIe pa3paooTalIhI,
II B aTOM OTlIornelIIIH alITpOnOJIOrH )J;aJIeKO OTCTaIOT OT 3R306IIOJIOrOB. Teo-
peTIIqeCKaH pa3paOOTKa aToH np06JIeMaTIIKlI C IICqepnhlBalIIIeM, RaK cenqac
npIIIIHTo qaCTO nIIcaTb, npocTpaHcTBa JIOrIIqeCRIIX B03MomHocTen B )J;aIIIIOH
TeMe qpe3BbIqaHII0 nepcneKTIIBlIa.
,.-
,
.
r;:
t
l!-
I
t
I-
f
.<
t CM., HalIp.: BYHafi, B. B. Pop; Homo, ero B03HIIKHOBeHlle II IIOCJIep;YIOlI\aH 3BOJIIOl\IIJI.
M., 1980; Wolpoff M. Paleoanthropology. N. Y., 1980; Lewin R. Human evolution: An
ill. introd. Oxford, 1984.
2 0630p II aHamI3 p;aHlIbIx: XpUCa1iOBa E. H. 8BOJIIOl\IIOHHaH MOPcPOJIOrllH CKeJIeTa
-ieJIOBeKa. M., 1978.
3 CnUlfb H B. A. IIOJIIIMOPcPII3M cPepMeHTHbIX II p;pyrlIx OeJIKOB KpOBII II IIX 3Ha'ieHlIe [[PII
perneHIIII PHAR aHTp0110JIOrII'IeCKIIX rrp06JIeJ\I II MOPcPOJIOrIIH 'le;rOBeKa II 1KIIBOTHbIX.
AHTpOIIOJIOmH. M., 1974. T. 6.
4 Livingstone F. Abnormal hemoglobins in human populations. Chicago, 1967.
5 HaKOrrJIeHbI OOIIIlIpHbIe p;aHHbJe, K C01KaJIeHIIIO p;o CIIX IIOp He CBep;eHHbJe Boe.n;IIHO.
CTapaH CBop;Ka: Schwidetzky I. Ergiinzte Karten fUr Hautleistenmerkmale und PTC-
Schmeckfahigkeit I I Homo. 1966. Bd. 17, H. 1.
8 AJ/,efi,CeeBa T. I1. ElIoreOXIIMIDI II IIpOOJIeMbI aHTpOrrOJIOrlI1I /I COBpeMeHHbIe 3a.n;a'llI II
np06JIeMbI olIoreOXIIMHII. M., 1979. (Tp. ElIoreoXlIM. JIao.; T. 17).
7 CM.: 3ifJPOUMCOH B. n. I1MMYHoreHeTIIKa. M., 1971.
8 AJ/,efi,CeeBa T. I1. reorpacl>H'leCKaH cpep;a II OIIOJIOrlIH '1eJIOBeKR. M., 1977; OHa :!ICe.
Ap;arrTIIBHbIe IIpOl\eCCbI B '1eJIOBe'leCKIIX 1I0IIYJIHl\IIHX. M., 1986.
9 AJ/,efi,CeeB B. n. AHTpOIIOJIOrlI'IeCKOe CBoeOOpa3IIe KopeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH AMeplIKII II
OIIOIIOJIHpHbIe paCbI (0 CBH31I aHTponOJIOmlI C reorpacl>lIeii) IIOT AJIHCKII p;o OrHeHHoii
3eMJIII. M., 1967.
to I1CTOplIIO pa3paooTKII pacoBoH RBaJIIIcl>IIKal\1I1I CM.: Schwidetzky I. Grundlagen der
Rassensystematik. Wien; Ziirich, 1974.
it JIeBuH M. r. 8THII'IeCKaH aHTpOIIOJIOrlIH HrroHIIII. M., 1971.
12 CM. 06 3TOM: q. 3. HaCT. KII.
13 A.nenceeB B. n. llCTOpll'leCKaH aHTpOnOJIOrIlH. M., 1979.
f
t
"
,
R--
t.
.
i
f
f
r
23
rOPM30HTbI AHTPOrrOnOrMM
AHTPOrrOJIOrlm - MOP«I>OJIOrnqECKAH HAYKA
Tpa)J;H HOHHoe nO)J;pa3)J;eJIeHHe aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOH IIaYRH, oc06elIII0 illIIpOKO
pacnpOCTpaHeHHoe B COBeTCROH JIHTepaType, nO)J;pa3YMeBaeT BbI)J;eJIelIIIe B ee
COCTaBe Tpex OTIIOCIITeJIbHO caMOCTOHTeJIbHbIX 06JIaCTeH - MopcpOJIOrIIH, alIT-
ponorelIe3a II paCOBe)J;eHIIH. npe)J;MeT paCOBe)J;eHIIH lIe IIym)J;aeTCH B cne:qH-
aJIblIOM pa3'bHCHeIIIIII - 011 HceH H3 caJ\;IOro Ha3BaIIIIH; aHTponorelIe3 - 01'-
pOMlIaH OOJIaCTb np06JIeM, CBH3alIHbIX C 6IIOJIOrIIqeCKIIMII acneKTaMH npOHC-
xom)J;elIIIH qeJIOBeRa; lIfopcpOJIOrIIH npe)J;CTaBJIHeT C060H yqeHIIe 0 BapIIa IIHX
CTpoelIIIH OT)J;eJIblIbIX opralIOB qeJIOBeqeCKOrO TeJIa, cpII3IIqeCROM pa3BIITHH H
ROIICTIIT IIII qeJIOBeRa. OTJIHqIIe MopcpOJIOrIIII OT alIaTOMIIII 3aRJIIOqaeTCH B
TOllf, qTO aHaTOMa IIHTepecyeT HopMa, cpe)J;IIIIH TIIn, alITpOnOJIOr iRe 3aHIIMa-
eTCH OTRJIOHelIHHMII OT Hero, HO OTRJIOlIeHHHMH He naTOJIOrIIqeCKOrO xapaKTe-
pa, a HOpllfaJIblIbIMII BapHa HHMH, MepOH H3MelIqIfBOCTH qeJIOBeqeCROrO opra-
IIH3Ma. AlIa TOM IIm;eT B MHoro06pa3IIII IIII)J;HBII)J;yaJIbHbIX xapaRTepHcTIIR 06-
m;ee, e)J;IIlIoe, aIITpOnOJIor, OTBJIeRaHCb OT 3Toro 06m;ero, II3yqaeT caMO
MHoro06pa3He.
113 CKa3alIIIOro YiRe BH)J;HO, qTO alITpOnOJIOrHH - nayKa B nepBYIO Oqe-
pe)J;b MopcpOJIOrIIqeCRaH, T. e. IIayKa 0 CTpoelIHH II3yqaeMbIX 06'beRTOB, a He
00 IIX CPYIIK:qHOHaJIbHbIX CBOHCTBax. CTapoe )J;eJIelIIIe Bcex 6IIOJIOrIIqeCRIIX
HaYK Ha MopcpOJIOrIIIO - HaYRY 0 CTpoelIIIH iRIIBbIX cym;ecTB II cpII3HOJIO-
rIIIO - HaYRy 06 IIX CPYHR HoIIIIpoBaIIIIII, iRII3IIe)J;eHTeJIbHOCTH ceiiqac BO
IIflIOrOllf nOTepHJIO CBoe 3Ha'IeIIIIe, CJIIIrnKOllf TeCIIO nepenJIeJIIICb c06CTBelIHO
MopcpOJIOrIIqeCRHe HCCJIep;OBaHHH C CPYHR:qIIOlIaJIbHbIlIfII. Ho no Tpa)J;H:qIIH H
no co06paiReHHHlIf Y,ZJ;06cTBa R HeMY qaCTO npII6eraIOT )J;O CIIX nop. fOBOpH 0
aHTpOnOJIOrIIII RaR 0 MopcpOJIOrII'IeCKOH IIaYRe, H ynOTpe6JIHIO TepMIIH «MOP-
cpOJIOrHH» B 3TOllf nOCJIe)J;IIeM CMbICJIe. CJIe,ZJ;oBaJIO 6bI, ROHeqIIO, TO, qTO B aHT-
pOnOJIOrIIH Ha3bIBaeTCH MopcpOJIOrIIeH, Ha3bIBaTb RaR-TO nO-)J;PyrOMY, HO 3Toro
nORa lIe C)J;eJIaIIO, H n03TOMY IIymlIo nOMHIITb 0 MIIOr03HaqHOCTH TepllfIIlIa.
I1TaK, aHTpOnOJIOrHH - HaYRa MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCKaH. OCIIOBHOH MeTO)J; HCCJIe-
p;OBaIIIIH - BblHBJIelIIIe cpOpMbI, CTPYKTYPbI. ho - npenapIIpOBaHHe II rIICTO-
JIOrHqeCKHe cpe3bI, Kor)J;a H3yqaeTCH CTpoeHHe BHYTpelIlIHX opralIOB qeJIOBe-
'IeCROrO TeJIa; II3MepelIIIe H onIIcalIIIe, Ror)J;a IICCJIe,ZJ;yeTcH CTpoeRIIe BHernlIIIX
cpOpM qeJIOBeqeCROrO TeJIa, CKameM, paCOBT.Te qepTbI Toro IIJIH ulloro HapO)J;a.
nOSTOMY, TaR me aR MHRp06IIOJIOra H rIIC'fOJIOra npe)J;CTaBJIHIOT 06blqHO 3a
MIIKpOCKonOllf, 3IITOllfOJIOra - C Ca'IKOM, reOJIora - C KaHJIOM, CIIMBOJIOM pa60-
TbI alITpOnOJIOra Ha npOTHffielIIIU MIIOrIIX JIeT 6bIJI, )J;a :II CeII'IaC OCTaeTCH
IIpRyJIb. lIepTem IIPRYJIH nOMem;aeTCH 06bIqlI0 Ha 06JIOmKe Bcex RIIIIr no
MeTO,ll,IIKe aIITpOIIOJIOrIIII. O)J;IIaRO CHJ\;IBOJI 3TOT )J;aBRO YCTapeJI.
HOBbIE BEHHHH
I '
,
'ij
AIITpOnOJIOrHH 3a nOCJIe)J;IIIIe 50 JIeT CHaqaJIa Me)J;JIeIIIIO, a nOTOM Bce 6bICT-
pee II 6bIcTpee CTaJIa nepeCTpaIIBaTbCH, HaCbIm;aTbCH cpII3IIOJIOrHeH, MOp.pOJIO-
rUqeCKHe MeTO)J;bI B npe)J;eJIax aHTpOnOJIOrIIII CTaJIII TepHTb CBOIO lIfOHOnOJIHIO.
3TO HaqaJIOCb C 1918 r., C 3allfeqaTeJIbIlOrO OTRpbITIIH JI. fIIprncpe.:'Ib)J;a, c)J;e-
IaIIHOrO IIM Ha COJIOHIIRCROM cppolITe. IIpoH3Bo)J;H nepeJIIIBaHIIe RpOBII, OIl 3a-
UeTIIJI, qTO npe)J;CTaBIITeJIII pa3IIbIX HapO)J;OB OTJlIIqaIOTCH )J;pyr OT )J;pyra
pa3JIIIQlIbIlIf npo eHTHbIM COOTlIornelIIIeM II3BeCTIIbIX Tor)J;a rpynn KpOBH CH-
CTeMbI ABO. C Tex nop OTRphITO OROJIO 30 Ile3aBIICIIMhIX CHCTeM 3pIITpOQH-
TOB KpOBH, cne:qHcpHqlIbIX 6IIOXHMIIqeCKII :II nepe)J;aIOm;IIXCH no HaCJIe)J;CTBY.
*1'
24
;:c
.
To IIJIH IIlIoe npo eHTlIoe COOTHOIIIelIHe 3TIIX CIICTeM - TaRaH iRe CTOHKaH
6IIOXIIMIIqeCRaH xapaRTepIICTIIKa pa3HbIX nonYJIH HH, RaR II rpynnoBoe COOT-
EOIIIelIHe ABO. TaKme 6IIOXIIMIIqeCRH cne HcpHqHbIMR H HaCJIe)J;CTBeIIHO
{)6YCJIOBJIeIIHbIMH OKa3aJIIICb II 6eJIRH CblBOpOTRH RpOBII, THnbI reMorJI06IIlIa,
YIIIlIaH cepa, OT)J;eJIblIbIe BRYCOBbIe peaR IIH. A onpe)J;eJIelIHe Bcex 3TIIX TH-
nOB, RaR JIerKO nOHHTb ,ll,ame HeCne IIaJIIICTY, HeB03MomlI0 C nOMOm;bIO Hp-
1\YJIH; )J;JIH Hero Tpe6YIOTCH xoporno 060PY)J;OBaIIHbIe JIaOOpaTOpIIH, XHMIIRa-
JIHII, npIIMelIelIIIe HOBelIIIIIIX 6IIOXHMII'IeCKIIX II CPII3IIOJIOrHqeCRIIX MeTO)J;OB-
O)J;IIIIM CJIOBOllf, Bce TO, qTO OTJIHqaeT CPynR IIOHaJIbHOe CPII3IIOJIOrHqeCROe IIC-
CJIe)J;OBaIIIIe OT lIfopcpOJIOrIIqeCRoro.
BMeCTe C cpH3IIOJIOraMH alITpOnOJIOrII BKJIIOqIIJIIICb ceii:qac B H3yqelIIIe
npOOJIe fbI a)J;anTa IIII, T. e. npIIcnoc06JIelIIIH 'IeJIOBeqeCKOrO opralIII3Ma R
pa3IIbIM YCJIOBIIHM CYI:qeCTBOBaIIIIH - BbICOKoropbIO H BJIamlIbIM HII3IIlIallf,
nYCThIHe H ceBepHbIM paHOlIaM. HapHJ],Y C KJIIIMaTOllf TYT lIe lIfeHbrnee 3IIa'Ie-
HIIe npII06peTaeT cpaRTOp reOXIIMII'IeCKIIH - IIeJ],OCTaTOR IIJIII II36bITOK MIIKpO-
3JIeMeHTOB B nOqBe, BO)J;e, nIIm;e, Bo06m;e BO BceH ORPYiRaIOlI{eH 'I8JIOBeRa
npIIpO)J;Hon cpe)J;e. YCTaHOBJIeHa 3aBIICIIMOCTb nJIOTHOCTII KOCTII OT cO)J;epma-
HHH KaJIb IIH B oRpymaIOm;eH cpe)J;e, a TaRme pa3IIII a B CKOpOCTH KpOBOTOKa
Y IIapO)J;OB KpaHHero CeBepa H YMepelIHbIX II TpOmr'IeCKIIX CTpaH. AIITpono-
JIOrIIH npaRTIIqeCKII yme npeBpaTIIJIaCb B MOpcpOcpII3IIOJIOrHqeCKYIO HayRY,
II ocpII:qHa.rrblIbIM npII3HaHIIeM 3Toro CTIIXIIHIIO ocym;ecTBIIBIIIerOCH npeBpam;e-
HIIH HBHJIaCb opraHH3a IIH IIOBOH cne:qHaJIbHOH ceK HII cpII3IIOJIOrII'IeCROH
alITpOnOJIOrHH Ha VII MeiR,ZJ;JTHapO)J;HOM ROlIrpecce alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRHX H 3T-
HorpacpIIqeCRHX HaYK B MOCRBe B aBrYCTe 1964 r.
JJ;eJIelIIIe aHTpOnOJIOrIIH Ha TPH pa3)J;eJIa - )J;aHb YCTapeBIIIeH Tpa)J;II HH.
BbI)J;eJIeHIIe CPII3HOJIOrHqeCROH aHTpOnOJIOrIIII B caMoCTOHTeJIbHbIn pa3,ZJ;eJI yme
ocym;ecTBHJIOCb 1, H COBepIIIelIHO He06xo,ZJ;HlIfO Y3aROHIITb ero H B onpe)J;eJIe-
nHII aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRoii: HaYEH.
Mom;IIoe pa3BIITHe aIITpOnOJIOro-cpII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX IICCJIeD;OBaHHH, orpollf-
HbIn IIHTepec R IIIIM IIepa3pbIBII0 CBH3aHbI C ycnexaMII aHTponoreHeTHRII. no-
J(aBJIHIOI:qee 60JIbrnIIHCTBO II3yqeHHbIX ,ZJ;O CIIX nop cpII3IIOJIOrII'IeCRIIX CBOHCTB
qeJIOBeqeCROrO opralIII3l1Ia IIMeeT cpaBIIHTeJIhlIO npOCTYIO IIaCJIe)J;CTBeIIHYIO
CTPYRTYPY, IIlIbIlIfII CJIOBallfII, ynpaBJIHeTCH B cBoeii: IIaCJIe)J;CTBeIIIIOH nepe)J;a-
"'Ie O)J;HIIM IIJIII IIeCKOJIbKIIlIfII relIallfII. TaRHe CJIY'IaII JIerRO IICCJIe.D:oBaTb, no-
3TOMY OHH XOpOIIIO II3yq8IIbI, a TOqlIaH IIH.popMa HH 0 HaCJIe)J;OBaHHII npH-
3IIaROB BO MlIorOM 06JIerqaeT alITpOnOJIOry II3yqeHIIe paCOBbIX pa3JIIIqIIH,
YCTaHOBJIeHHe npOIIcxom)J;eHIIH IIapo)J;a no aHTpOnOJIorII'IeCRHM )J;alIlIbIlIf
11 T. )J;.2 MopcpOJIOrHqeCKHe oc06eHIIOCTII qeJIOBeqeCROrO opralIH3l1fa HCCJIeJ],O-
BalIhI CO CTOpOlIbI IIaCJIe)J;CTBeHHOCTII 3Ha TeJIb1I0 xyme, 3aROlIbI nepeJJ;a IIX
no HaCJIe,ZJ;CTBY OqeHb CJIOmHbI. rIInOTe3, qaCTO YM03pHTeJIbHbIX, 3,ZJ;eCb, R CO-
maJIeHHIO, nORa 60JIbIIIe, qellf TOqlIO YCTalIOBJIeHlIbIX R npOBepelIlIbIX cpaRTOB.
n 03TOllfY B nonbITRax relIeTHqeCROrO OClIfbICJIeHHH MopcpOJIOrHqeCRHX pmmlI-
'IHii: MemJ(Y pa3HhIMII TIInallfH 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa - paCOBbIMII HJIII ROIICTH HO-
HaJIbHbIlIfH - IIHTYH:qHH Bce em;e npeOOJIaJ],aeT Ha.D: 3HaIIIIeM. A CPII3IIOJIOrH-
'IeCRaH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH )J;aeT aHTpOnOJIOry B 60JIbIIIOM ROJIIIqeCTBe relIeTIIqe-
CRYIO IIlIcpopllfa HIO, B ROTOpoiI 011 TaK HymJ],aeTCH. -
MopcpOJIOrIIH, aHTponorelIe3, paCOBe)J;eIIIIe, CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKaH aIITpOnOJIO-:
rHH - qeTbIpe pa3)J;eJIa BMeCTO Tpex, HaJIH O 3HaqHTeJIblIbIH CRaqOR Bnepe)J;.
ITo)J; BJIIIHHHeM CPH3IIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX II reHeTIIqeCRIIX HCCJIe)J;oBaHIIH H3MelIHJIOCb
caMO lIfbIIIIJIeIIHe aHTpOnOJIOrOB, xapaRTepHbIM .D:JIH Hero CTaJI II npIIH IIn )J;H-
HallfII3Ma, C03IIaHIIe nO,ZJ;BIImHOCTH, TeKY'IeCTH rpaHIIq MeiR)J;Y alITpOnOJIOrHqe-
CKHMII HBJIeIIIIHMII. Oc06elIII0 3allfeTHa nepeCTpOHKa MbIIIIJIeHIIH B paCOBe)J;e-
ERH, r)J;e )J;HaJIeRTRRa, HOBaH J(IIHallfHqeCKaH KOH:qe HH npIIBeJIH R nOJIIIOMY
11
Ii:"
..
L
t
(
!.\
t
I
r
,"
,
f,
25
.
r
/
(
'J
HIIcnpOBepmeHHIO CTapbIX ROII en IIiI: BlIfeCTO IIeH3MeHHbIX pac CTapbIX aBTO-
pOB, cym;ecTBoBaBIIIIIX HK06hI B Ra:\l€IIIIOM BeKe TaK me, RaR H ceiIqac, H xa-
paKTepII30BaBIIIIIxcH TeMH me OTJIIIqIITeJIblIbUIH npII3IIaRaMII, nOHBIIJICH CHa-
qa.TIa B3rJIH)J; Ha pacy KaR IIa «3nII30)J; B 3BOJIIO IIII» \ a 3aTeM IIIIrIIJIlICTH-
qeCKOe oTpIIqalIIIe peaJIblIOCTH pac Boo6I:qe.
CTP"YRTYPHbIE YPOBHH HCCJIEAOBAHHH
-t-
nO)J;BIIiRIIOCTb rpalIII MeiR)J;Y MlIorHMH 06'beRTaMIl, II3yqaeMbIMlI aHTpOTIOJIO-
rHell, TeClIaH CBH3b Bcex MOpcpOcpII3IIOJIOrII'IeCRHX npo eccoB B '-l€JIOBe'IeCKOM
opralIII3Me B npe)J;eJIax nonYJIH:qIIH, a CJIe)J;OBaTeJIbIIO, II HeRoTopaH HeOTIpe.D:e-
JIelIlIOCTb rpalIH lIfem)J;Y OT)J;eJIbHhIMII pa3)J;eJIaMH alITpOnOJIOrIIII 3aTpY)J;IIHIOT
TOqlIOe onpe)J;eJIelIIIe HaYRII H COCTaBJIHIOm;HX ee OTpaCJIeH. 06paTIIMcH, IIa-
nplIlIfep, K MIIlIepaJIII3a IIII CKeJIeTa qeJIOBeKa - pelITrelIocpoToMeTpIIH n03BO-
JIHeT II3Y'IaTb 3TY oc06elIIIocTb in vivo. Onpe)J;eJIHeTCH npII 3TOM CTenelIb
HaChIm;eIIIIOCTII RocTeH RaJIb:qIIeM, T. e. BeJIIIqIIlIa KaK 6Y)J;TO 6IIOXIIMIIqeCKaH.
Ho KaJIb IIII npe)J;cTaBJIHeT C06011 B CKeJIeTe IIenOcpe)J;cTBeHlIbIII CTpOlfTeJIb-
IIbIiI MaTepHaJI, onpe)J;eJIHIOm;IIH ero npOqHOcTb. npIIBJIeqelIIIe 6HOXIIMII'IeCKO-
1'0 nOKa3aTeJIH CJIymHT B KOlIeqHOM CqeTe oOJIee TOIIKOMY nOIIIIMalIHIO CTPYR-
TyphI ROCTII, a 3HaqHT - eJIHlIf MopcpOJIOrIIH, a lIe cpII3IIOJIOrHII 'IeJIOBeKa.
Ho eCJIH 3TO lIfopcpOJIOrIIH, TO MopcpOJIOrIIH, npIIII HnIIaJIbHO OTJIIIqaIOI:qaHCH
OT CTapOH, )J;JIH ROTOpOH OCIIOBlIbIM II, nOiRaJIyiI, ep;IIIICTBelIlIhIlIf lIfeTO)J;Ollf IIC-
CJIe)J;OBaIIHH 6bIJIO II3MepelIIIe II onIIcalIIIe BlIeIIIHen cpOpMbI. KY)J;a iRe OTlIeCTH
IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIe TaKoro po)];a - K MopcpOJIOrIIH IIJIII K cpII3IIOJIOrII'-l€CKOH alITpo-
nOJIOrHII? Cpa3Y B03IIIIRaIOT cnopbI, lIflIoro IIX 6bIJIO npII nO)J;rOTOBKe K
VII Mem)J;YHapo)J;IIOllfY KOlIrpeccy alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX II 3THorpacpIIqeCKHX
IIaYK, Kor)J;a pacnpe)J;eJIHJIIICb )J;OKJIa)J;bI no ceR IIHlIf.
BbIXO)J; H3 3Toro TpY)];IIOro nOJIOiRelIHH npe,ZJ;cTaBJIHeTCH lIflIe lIe B BhID;eJIe-
HIIH em;e o)J;IIoro HJIII IIeCKOJIbKIIX callfOCTOHTeJIblIbIX pa3)J;eJIOB IIaYKII,
a B nOJIIIOH nepecTpoHRe RJIaCcHcpHKa IIII alITpOnOJIOrIIII Bo06I:qe, B npIIII:qII-
TIHaJIbHO HOBOllf nO,ZJ;xo)J;e K BbI)J;eJIeIIIIIO COCTaBJIHIOm;IIX ee pa3)J;eJIOB, OCIIO-
BalIHOllf Ha o elIKe ypoBlIeH H3yqelIHH OIIOJIOrII'IeCKHX ocooelIlIocTeH qe.:'IOBe-
Ra. PacclIfoTpelIIIe npIIpO)];IIhIX HBJIelIIIH II npo eCCOB B 3aBIICIIMOCTH OT ypOB-
IIeH, ua ROTOpbIX OIIH npOHBJIHIOTCH II.TIH npOIICXO)J;HT, IIIHpOKO BOIIIJIO B 6HO-
JIOrHIO BlIfeCTe C KII6eplIeTII'IeCKHlIfH lIfeTO)J;allfII II CTpeMJIelIIIeM nepelIeCTH IIa
6IIOJIOrHIO )J;OCTIIiReIIIIH B n03HalIIIII CTPyKTypbI ynpaBJIHIOm;HX CIICTeM. <DYII-
,ZJ;allfeuTaJIbHaH II)J;eH ypoBlIel1 opralIH3aqIIII iRHBOrO II ObIJIa BbI)J;BIIIIYTa )J;JIH
ycneIIIlIoro aUaJIH3a pa3JIIIqlIhiX ynpaBJIHIOm;HX CIICTellf B iRIIBOII npIIporre".
KJIaCcIIcpHRa IIH Bcex 6HOJIOrIIqeCKIIX IIaYK nOKa em;e lIe nepeCTpoelIa Ha
3TOiI OCIIOBe, XOTH OT)J;eJIblIble nonbITKII YiRe eCTb. B alITpOnOJIOrHII OHa
n03BOJIHeT C03)J;aTb OqeUb nepcneRTIIBIIYIO H BUYTpelIlIe IIenpOTIIBOpe'IIIBYIO
KJIaCCIIcpIIKa IIIO OO'beKTOB IICCJIeD;OBaIIIIH, a C IIeIO BlIfeCTe II rrapaJIJIeJIblIO ell
paCnO;rOiRIITb II3Y'IaIOm;IIe IIX OTpac.TIn HaYKII B pa3YMIIOII nOCJIeJJ;OBaTe;rbIIO-
CTII. HIIiReCJIeJJ;YIOm;HlIf BapIIalITOllf K.:'IaCCIIcpHKa IIII XO'IeTCH rrpHBJIe'Ib BIIU-
lIfalIIIe K 3TOiI nOKa <<IIe06eTOBaIIII011 3ellfJIe» npe)J;CTaBJIeIIIIII, K nJIO)J;OTBopno-
MY nOIIcRy B IIanpaBJIelIIIII, JIeiRam;ellf IIa lIfarIICTpaJIblIOH )J;opore pa3BIITIIH
6IIOJIOrIIII.
M O.lleKY.IlflpHbLU ypoeeHb. C OTKphITHellf 6IIOXIIlIfII'IeCKIIX MexaIIII3MOBlIa-
CJIe)J;CTBeIIIIOCTH II relIeTIIqeCKOrO KO)J;a STOT ypOBelIb )J;JIH 6HOJIOrHH CTaJi 0)];-
IIIIlIf II3 OCIIOBlIhiX. Ho B pacrnHcppOBKe HaCJIeJJ;CTBeluIOCTII lIfopcpOJIOrII'IeCRIIX
H CPII3Ho.JIOrII'IeCKIIX CTPYRTYP BbICIIIIIX opralIH3l1fOB ycnexII IIfOJIeKYJIHpIIOiI
6IIOJIOrIIII H yme - 6HOXHlIfIIqeCKOH relIeTIIRH )J;OBOJIbIIO CKpOllflIhI. Bce iRe no
OTlIornelIIIIO R 'IeJIOBeKY lIfOiRlIO na3BaTb, IIanpIIlIfep, TaKoe )J;OCTIIiRenUe,KaK
26
r.
BbIHClIelIHe 6IIOXIIMII'IeCKIIX rrpO:qeCCOB, JIeiRam;IIX B OCIIOBe B03IIIIKIIOBelIHH
IIaCJIe)J;CTBelIlIhIX auOMaJIIIH rellforJI06IIHa. IIOIIIIMalIHe TOIIKHX 3aROIIOMepII0-
CTeH IIaCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH npII3IIaKOB IIe06XO)J;IIMO alITpOnOJIOry, n03TOMY pOJIb HB-
.TIeIIIIH, IICCJIe)J;yeMbIx IIa MOJIeKYJIHplIOM ypoBne, nOCTOHlIlIO B03paCTaeT,
II B ;nOH ccpepe alITpOnOJIOrIIH Bcer.[\a 6Y)J;eT TeCHO conpHKacaTbCH H )J;aiR6
nepenJIeTaTbCH 06JIaCTHMII IICCJIe)J;OBaIIHH C arITpOnOrelIeTIIKOH 5.
K .IlerO'lHblU ypoeeHb. Tm;aTeJIblIbIe pa60TbI no rIICTOJIOrII'IeCKOMY CTpoe-
IIHIO opralIOB y rrpe)J;CTaBIITeJIeII pa3IIbIX pac lIe BbIHBIIJIH pa3JIII'IHII MeiR)J;y
HIIMII. fJIaBlIhIH acneKT IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH IIa KJIeTOqnOM ypOBlIe - cpaBIIHTeJIb-
IIO-alIaTOMII'IeCKIIH, npe.[\OCTaBJIHIOm;IIII IIlIcpopMa IIIO B OCIIOBIIOM )J;JIH OCBe-
J eIIIIH npOOJIeMaIITponorelIe3a.Oc06eIIIIOBeJIIIK03IIaqeIIIIe.pa60T no KJIe-
TO'IHOii CTpyRType 103ra. Cen'-IaC STO !IOKa 'IYTb .TIH He e)J;IIIICTBeIIUbIII crroc06
npOHIIKIIOBeHIIH B STanhI cpOpMIIpoBalIIIH lIf03ra y .D:peBlIeHIIIIIx npe)J;KOB 'Ie-
.JIOBeKa 6.
TnaHeeblU ypoeeHb. 3a nOCJIe)J;IIIIe rO.D:hI STOT ypOBeHb II3yqeIIIIH 'IeJIOBe-
'IeCKOrO opraUII3Ma npHBJIeR oc060e BIIIIMaHIIe II npaKTII'-IeCKII OcpOpllfIIJICH B
caMOCTOHTeJIblIhIH pa3)J;eJI MopcpOJIOrHIl 'IeJIOBeKa. HMeIOTCH B BH)J;y MHoro-
qHCJIelIlIbIe pa60TbI 0 KOMnOlIelITax TeJIa H IIX COOTHOIIIeIIIIHX. MeTO,[(IIKa BbI-
HBJIeHIIH TRalIeBbIX ROMnOlIeIITOB, IIX CBH3II C ROIICTIITY IIOHaJIblIbIMII TIIna-
MIl, pa3JIII'IHH B COOTlIornelIIIII ROMnOlIelITOB y pa3IIbIX pac, xapaKTepIICTIIRa
ROMnOHelITOB TeJIa - Bce 3TO 06CYiR)J;aeTCH C npHBJIe'IelIHeM orpOMlIoro 3KC-
nepHMelITaJIblIOrO MaTepIIaJIa. BBII.[\y O'-Iellb 60JIbrnOrO TeOpeTIIqeCKOrO II
npaKTII'IeCKOrO (KJIIIIIIIKa) 3IIaqeHIIH STIIX pa60T MaCIIITa6 HX IIenpephlBHO
paCIIIIIpHeTCH 7. 1l0maJIYH, IIMeHIIO B 3TOH ccpepe alITpOnOJIOrIIII IIHTeIICIIB-
HOCTb npIIMelIelIHH caMhIX pa3HOOOpa3IIhIX TOIIKHX 6IIOXHMII'IeCRIIX, cpH3IIO-
JIOrH'IeCKIIX II 6HocpH3II'IeCKIIX lIfeTO)J;OB oc06elIno BeJIHRa 8.
OPZalLHblU (cuCre.MHblU) ypoeeHb. EMY nOCBHm;eII OC06bIH pa3)J;eJI MOpcpO-
:IOrHII 'IeJIOBeKa - MepOJIOrIIH, HJIII yqelIIIe 0 BapIIa IIHX B CTpoelIHH OT.[\eJIb-
HbIX opralIOB 9. II paCOBbIH, H relIeTH'IeCKIIH, II 3BOJIIO HOHHbIH acneKThI
npe)J;CTaBJIenbI IIa 3TOM ypoBHe, TaK KaK CTpoelIHe OT)J;eJIbHbIX opralIOB II HX
CIICTeM BapbIIpyeT no pacaM, OHO II3MelIHJIOCb B npo:qecce alITponoreHe3a H
COCTaBJIHeT OCHOBY, nepBII'IlIbIH 3MnHpHqeCRIIII MaTepIIa.rr )J;JIH YCTalIOBJIelIIIH
3aKOHOB IIaCJIe)J;CTBeIIIIOH nepe)J;aqII 10. It 3TOMY me ypOBIIIO CJIe)J;yeT OTlIeCTH
H nOKa pe)J;KHe B alITpOnOJIOrIIII (qam;e C 3THM npIIXO)J;IITCH CTaJIRHBaTbCH B
alIaTOMIIII) CJIY'IaII II3yqelIIIH cOBOKynlIocTII CIICTeM opraHOB, HanpIIMep an-
napaTa onopbI IIJIH ,ZJ;BIImeIIIIH.
OpzaHu3MeHHblU ypoeeHb (H. B. THMocpeeB-PecoBcKHH Ha3bIBaJI ero OH-
TorelIeTHqeCKIIM). qeJIOBeK RaK 6IIOJIOrH'IeCKIIII opralIII3M - OCIIOBIIOII 06'beKT
RHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOrO II3yqe1IIIH. C 3TIIM COrJIaClIbI Bce. JIerRo nOHHTb, 'ITO
'IeJIOBeR RaK eJIoe II3yqaeTCH C caMbIX pa3IIhIX CTOpOII. Oc06hIn pa3)J;eJI MOp-
40JIOrHlI - COMaTOJIOrHH - nOCBHm;eII II3Y'IeIIIIIO BlIernlIHX cpOpM qeJIOBeqe-
CKoro TeJIa II qeJIOBeqeCKOrO opralIII3Ma B eJIOM. B IIee BXO.[\HT, nOMIIMO Me-
TO)J;IIRH II3MepelIIIH II onIIcaHHH BlIeIIIIIIIX cpOpllf, Bce 60JIee qaCTHbIe CTOpOlIhI
orpoMlIoH II OqelIb BaiRlIOH np06JIeMhI IIIITerpa HH: aHaJIH3 MOpcpOcpII3IIOJIO-
rHqeCRHX COOTHOIIIeHIIH II KOIICTIITY IIOlIlIbIX TIInOB, COCTaBJIelIIIe xapaKTepII-
CTHKII cpH3IIqeCROrO pa3BIITIIH II nponop IIH TeJIa, Y'IelIIIe 0 eIITpe THiRe-
CTR TeJIa 11. OTII xapaRTepIIcTIIKH C RaiR.[\hIM rO.[\OM fIMeIOT Bce 60JIee cym;e-
CTBelIIIoe 3IIaqeHIIe B Me,ZJ;II IIlIe (ROIICTIITY HOlIaJIblIaH npeL\pacnOJIOiRelI-
IIOCTb R 3a60JIeBaIIIIHM) II B cnopTe (cnopTHBlIaH Me)J;II:qIIlIa II cnopTIIBlIaH
aHTpOnOJIOrIIH 12). BamlIbI OIIII II KaR OCIIOBa )J;JIH IICnOJIb30BalIIIH aIITpOnOJIO-
rIIqeCKIIX J:\aUHhIX B JIerROH npOMbIrnJIelIlIOCTII (C03)J;aIIHe CTalI)J;apTOB pa3JIIIq-
HbIX I13)J;eJIIIII).
,.
i
e:'t
r
i.-
t
r
r
r
(
;.
r..
f
27.
.
Ii "
,.
B paCOBe)J;eHIIII ,ZJ;OJIroe BpeMH CqIITaJIOCb, qTO paCbI npe)J;CTaBJIHIOT C060H
COBoKynHocTb JIIO)J;eH O)J;IIOpO)J;Horo cpII3HqeCROrO THna. Paca npOCTO CYMMa
cpH3HqeCKH OqeHb CXO)J;HbIX HII)J;IIBH,ZJ;YYMOB, H nOTOMY MomlIO onpe)J;eJIIITb HII-
)J;IIBH)J;yaJIbHYIO npIIlIa)J;JIemlIOCTb R pace B RaiR)J;OM OTJ]:eJIbIIOM CJIyqae. Ta-
KHM 06pa30M, paCOBbIn aHaJIH3 ,ZJ;OJImeH 6bIJI 6bI OC eCTBJIHTbCH TaKme Ha
ypOBHe opraHII3Ma. TaR 3TO )J;o CHX nop H )J;eJIaeTCH B HeRoTopbIX pa60Tax,
onpe eJIHeTCH pacoBbIH THn IIII)J;HBH)J;YYMa B COOTBeTCTBHH C cIIcTeMon paco-
BOH KJIaCcIIcpHRa IIH, 3aTeM nO,ZJ;c TblBaeTcH npo eHTlIoe COOTlIomeHHe 3TIIX
TIInOB II HCCJIe)J;yeMbIe rpynnbI cpaBIIHBaIOTcH no 3TOMY npo eHTHollfY COOTHO-
melIIIIO. O)J;IIaRO MHorHe )J;eTaJIblIbIe aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKHe H oc06eHHo norrymI-
IIolIlIo-relIeTIIqeCRIIe HCCJIe)J;oBaHIIH nORa3aJIH, qTO THn HII)J;HBII)J;YYlIfa HeJIb-
3H OTom)J;ecTBJIHTb C pacoII (06'be)J;IIlIeIIIIe IIeCKOJIbKHX norryJIH HH), qTO
oT)J;eJIblIbIe npH3IIaRII qeJIOBeqeCROro opraHII3Ma COqeTaIOTCH B npe)J;eJIax HH-
,ZJ;IIBH,ZJ;YYMa HHaqe, 'IeM B npe)J;eJIax pacbI, II qTO paca, CTaJIO 6bITh, He npoc-
TO CYMMa IIH)J;IIBII)J;YYMOB, a HeRaH COBORyrrHOCTh, B npe)J;eJIax ROTOpOH ,ZJ;eii-
CTBYIOT CBOII, TOJIbRO eH npIICYI:qIIe 3aKOIIOMepIIOCTII. B 3TOllf CMbICJI TaR Ha-
3bIBaeMOH nonYJIH IIOIIHOH KOH en HH paCbI, 3aBoeBblBaIOm;eH CeHqaC Bce
60JIbme CTOpOlIlIIIROB II 3aRpenJIelIHOH B )J;ORyMeIITax Mem,ZJ;YlIapo)J;HhIX COBe-
m;aHIIH 3KcnepTOB IOHECKO, npOBe)J;elIlIhIX B MOCRBe B 1964 r. II B napH-
me B 1966 r. C TOqKH 3peHIIH 3TOH ROII en IIII onpe)J;eJIelIIIe paCOBoro TIIna
HH)J;IIBII,ZJ;YYMa JIHmelIO ClIfbICJIa, a 3HaqIIT, npo eCCbI paco06pa30BaHHH )J;OJIiR-
HhI paCCMaTpHBaTbCH He IIa YPOBHe opraHII3Ma, a IIa )J;pyrOM, OOJIee BbICOKOM
ypOBlIe 13.
Bce nepe CJIeHHbIe YPOBHH H3Y'IeIIHH qeJIOBeqeCROrO opraHH3Ma B COBO-
RynlIocTH HAeaJIblIO COOTBeTCTBYIOT TOMy cO)J;epmaIIIIIO, ROTopoe BRJIa)J;bIBaeT-
CH B nOHHTIIe MopcpOJIOrIIH, HO OIIII BKJIIOqaIOT H Mlloroe )J;Pyroe. qTO HHRaK
He MomeT 6bITb BMem;eIIO B ee Y3RIIe paMRH,- .pH3HOJIOrIIqeCKIIH acneKT,
6HOXIIMIIqeCRHe np06JIeMbI, aHTponoreHeTHRY. IT03TOMY lIflIe RaiReTCH, qTO
06m;ee nOHHTHe MopcpOJIOrHII nOTepHeT ClIfbICJI, npaRTII'IeCKII 0110 HaqIIHaeT
TepHTb ero yme B HaCTOHm;ee BpeMH, H BCH COBoRynHocTb HBJIelIHH II npo-
eCCOB, H3Y'IaeMbIX Ha YPOBlIe opraHH3Ma II HHme, a TaKiRe npIIrO)J;IIbIe )J;JIH
3Toro MeTO)J;bI 6Y)J;YT rpynnHpoBaTbCH B HeCROJIbRO pa3)J;eJIOB B 3aBIICIIMOCTlI
OT ypOBIIH H3yqeHHH. JIerRo nOHHTb, 'ITO BBe,ZJ;eHHe .paRTopa BpellfeHH npH-
AaCT JII060MY H3 3THX pa3)J;eJIOB CBH3b C np06JIeMOH npOIICXOiR)J;eIIIIH qeJIOBe-
Ka, ROTopaH 6Y,ZJ;eT 06paCTaTb Bce 60JIbmHM CJIOM acneKTOB II )J;eTaJIeH. no
MoellfY rJIy60ROllfY y6em,ZJ;eHHIO, IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIe 3TOH np06JIeMbI npeBpaTIITCH
H3 pa3,ZJ;eJIa aHTpOnOJIOrIIII B ROMnJIeRCHyIO .D:HcqHnJIIIIIY, BRJIIOqaIOI:qYIO pa3-
HbIe MeTOAbI, a 3aTellf, MomeT 6bITb, H B cOBoRynHocTb IIaYK. II celrqac 06m;IIe
np06JIeMbI aHTponoreHe3a pemaIOTCH C nOllfOm;bIO qeTBepTHqlIOM reOJIOrIIH,
apXeOJIOrHH H ,ZJ;pyrHx ClIfemHbIX HaYR. 06m;IIM 6Y)J;eT TO, qTO H3MelIelIIIe CPII-
3HqeCROrO THna qeJIOBeRa BO BpeMelIII H3-3a MaJIOqIICJIeHHOCTII II cpparMelI-
TaplIOCTII HCKonaellfhIX HaXO)J;OK )J;OJIro em;e 6Y,ZJ;eT II3yqaTbCH caMoe 60JIbmOe
Ha ypoBHe HH)J;HBII,ZJ;YYMa. ITpaRTHqeCKH pe% II)J;eT II nOH)J;eT, nO-BII)J;IIMOMY,
B 6YAym;ellf 0 CHCTeMHOM ypOBHe, Be,ZJ;b OT HCRonaellfbIX JIIO)J;eH coxpalIHeTCH
TOJIbRO CKeJIeT, a npe)J;CTaBJIelIHe 0 CTpoeHHH Toro HJIII IIlIoro npe)J;Ka qeJIOBe-
Ra B qeJIOllf CaMO no ce6e - IITor 3RCTpaIIOJIH HII. HeRoTopaH 'IaCTb pa60T,
BbmOJIHeHlIbIX Ha naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKHX MaTepIIaJIaX rJIy60KoH )J;peBIIOCTH,
HO OTIIOCHI:qHXCH yme R qeJIOBeRY COBpeMeHlIoro TIIna, K )J;peBHeHmHlIf STa-
nallf ero cpOpMHpoBaHHH, TaRme He BbIXO,ZJ;IIT 3a pallfRII CIICTeMlIoro IIJIH B
JIyqmeM CJIyqae opraHII3MelIIIoro ypOBHH, TaR RaR IIPH MaJIOH qIICJIelIHOCTH
ApeBHHX CReJIeTOB OHH He )J;aIOT IIlIcpopMaI1;IIII, .C nOllfOm;bIO ROTOpOH MomlIO
6bIJIO 6bI paccMaTpIIBaTb H pemaTb BonpocbI nonYJIH IIOlIlIoro xapaRTepa.
J];aJIee MbI paccMaTpHBaeM rpynnOBhIe pa3JIII'IIIH lIfem)J;Y JIIO)J;hMH, IIJIH,
28
.
RaK JIyqrne CJIe)J;OBaJIO 6h1 rOBopIITb, pa3JIHqIIH Mem)J;Y rpynnaMH JIIOp;eH. 3TO
06JIaCTb paCOBe)J;eIIIIH B COBpellIelIlIOllf nOHIIMaIIIIH, 110 onHTb <lTO nOHHTIIe
yme, qeM Te npe)J;CTaBJIeHHH, KOTOpbIe CRJIa)J;bIBaIOTCH npII pacnOJIOmeHIIR
06'beRTOB IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH no eCTeCTBelIlIbIM ypOBIIHM IIepapXIIH. PaCOBe)J;eHHe
IIlIor)J;a Ha3bIBalOT 3TIIIIqeCROH aIITpOnOJIOrIIeH, HO KaRoe OTlIomeHIIe R <lTHH-
'leCROH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH B Y3ROM CMbICJIe CJIOBa HMeIOT 3RcnepIIMeHTbI, nOCBH-
m;elIlIbIe BbIHClIelIIIIO a,ll,anTHBIIOH pOJIH paCOBbIX npII3HaRoB? A 3TO HeCOM-
HelIlIO pacoBe)J;eHIIe, p,a eI:qe o)J;IIa H3 rJIaBlIeHmnx paCOBep;qeCRHX np06JIeM.
O.[\IIaRO HeKOTOphIe qaCTlIbIe BonpOCbI, HanpIIlIfep npHJIOmeHHe aHTpOnOJIOrH-
qeCRIIX )J;aHlIbIX K pemelIIIIO Bonpoca 0 npOIIcxom)J;elIHII Toro IIJIH HHoro Ha-
po.[\a, )J;eHCTBIITeJIbIIO eJIeC006pa3HO 6bIJIO 6bI BblIIeCTH 3a paMKH paCOBe-
)J;eHIIH, c06CTBelIII0 TeopHH paCOBe,ZJ;eHHH OIIII HHqerO IIJIH rrOqTH HIIqerO
He ,ZJ;aIOT.
Ha)J;opraHII3MelIlIhIX ypOBlIeH TaRme IIeCROJIbRO.
IIonY.Ilfl"LfUOHHbLU ypoeeHb. CTPYRTypa JII060H rpynnbI JIIO)J;eH, CBH3alIlIbIX.
pO)J;CTBOM, BhIpamaeTCH B TeCIIOTe pO)J;CTBelIlIbIX CBH3eH, T. e. B ROJIII'leCTBe
pop;CTBeIIHbIX 6paROB no OTHomeHIIIO K OOI:qeMY IIX CJIY, B cne IIcpHKe
,ZJ;eMorpacpIIqeCKIIX nORa3aTeJIeH, B IICXO)J;IIOH cne IIcpIIKe reHocpOH)J;a. II30JIH-
pOBaHlIbIe rpynnbI, B qaCTIIOCTH, OTJIIIqaIOTCH O'lellb cBoe06pa3IIbIMII COOTIIO-
IlIelIIIHMH qaCTOT MlIorHX relIOB II aCIIMMeTpIIeH pacrrpe)J;eJIeHHH MopcpOJIOrH-
qeCRHX (nOJIHrelIlIbIX) npH3IIaKOB. O)J;IIIIM CJIOBOM, Ram)J;aH norryJIH:qHH-
cne IIcpIIqeCKOe COqeTalIrre OT)J;eJIblIhIX reHOMOB (reHmf - cOBoRynHocTb Bcex
reHOB )J;alIlIoro opraIIH3Ma), npe)J;CTaBJIHeMhIX OT)J;eJIblIbIMII IIII)J;IIBII)J;YYllfaMII.
:JT1iU'leCKUU ypoeeHb. HeOOXO)J;HMOCTb BbmeJIelIIIH 3Toro ypOBIIH, RaR OT,
paiRaIOm;erO IIHTerpa IIIO B npe.[\eJIax IIapo)J;a (ero COCTaB, npOHcxom)J;eIIIIe,
paCCeJIelIIIe, oc06elIIIOCTII MaTepIIaJIblIOH H )J;YXOBHOH KYJIhTyphI H KYJIbTYPIIO-
HCTOpIIqeCKIIe B3aIIMOOTIIOllieIIIIH), IIaIIMelIee O'leBH)J;IIa. Ha npOTHmelIIII'L
MHorHX JIeT nporpeCCIIBlIbIe alITpOnOJIOrII Bcex CTpaII MIIpa 60pOJIHCb npOTIIB
paCIICTCRIIX II)J;eH npIIqHHIIOH CBH3II paCbI II H3bIRa. nepBbIH 3Tan 3TOH 60pb-
6bI - orYJIblIOe OTpIIIWHIIe RaROn-JIII60 3aBIICIIMOCTII Mem)J;Y HIIMII. nOTOllf
ObIJIO 3aMe'leII0, qTO H3bIR H paca HaXO.[\HTCH B OqeHb CJIOiRlIbIX B3aIIMOOT.,
HorneIIIIHX, B OCIIOBIIOM ROCBelIlIbIX, onpe)J;eJIHeMbIX TpeTbeH COCTaBJIHIO-
m;elI - TeppIITopHeH, Ha ROTOpOH pacnpOCTpaHeHbI. EbIJIa ,ZJ;ORa3aHa TaRiRe
60JIbrnaH 3aBHCHMOCTb paco06pa30BaTeJIbHbIX npo eCCOB OT CO HaJIblIbIX
II30JIIIpyIOm;HX MexaHII3MOB: BepOIIcnOBe)J;aHHH, 3II)J;oraMHoro xapaKTepa pO)J;O-
BbIX OTHornelIHH (06bIqaH 3aKJIIOqaTb 6paRlI BnyTpH )J;aHlIon 06m;HIIIIOH rpyn-
nbI). n03TOMY paCOBbIH COCTaB Toro IIJIII IIlIoro IIapo)J;a, ROJIIIqeCTBO COCTaB-
JIHIOm;IIX ero 3JIeMelITOB II IIX COOTlIornelIIIe cne IIcpHqlIbI H B Kam.[\OM OT-
AeJIbHOM CJIyqae onpe)J;eJIHIOTCH IICTOpIIqeCKIIM npOrnJIhIlIf HapO)J;a.
MOiReT nOKa3aTbCH, qTO, TaK me RaR H 3THH'IeCRHH ypoBelIb rpynnHpoB-
RH alITpOrrOJIOrIIqeCRIIX )J;aHlIbIX, )J;OJIiReH 6bITb BbI)J;eJIeH ypOBelIb IIX rpynnH-
pOBRII no CO IfaJIbHOMY HJIII npocpeCCHOHaJIbHOMY npH3HaRY, qTO IIa nepBbIn
B3rJIH)J; II IIaXO,ZJ;IIT ce6e BbIpamelIHe B pa60Tax, nOCBHm;eHHbIX aHTpOnOJIOrH-
qeCKIIM oc06elIHocTHM npe)J;cTaBHTeJIeH pa3JIIIqHhIX npocpeccIIOHaJIbHbIX HJIII
.[\ame rnHpe - co:qIIaJIhHbIX rpynn. Ho nORa Bce 3TH pa60TbI He BCRpbIJIII
cne IIcpIIqeCKHX RaKOIIOB II3MeH BOCTII B TaRIIX rpynnax, a TaM, r)J;e aBTOpb1
CTpeMHTCH 3TO C)J;eJIaTb, cpaRTIIqeCKHe )J;alIlIhle em;e Hep,OCTaTO'lHbI II npOTIIBO-
peqIIBbI. n03TOMY, lIe OTRa3bIBaHCb OT B03MOa\HOCTH BbI)J;eJIeIIHH TaKoro
ypOBHH B )J;aJIhHeHrnellf, nORa CJIe,ZJ;yeT OT IIero B03n;epmaTbCH. II HaROlIe ,
nOCJIe,ZJ;Hee: alITpOnOJIOrHqeCRHe IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH npe.D:CTaBHJIII MHoro npHMepOB
CJIOiRlIOrO COCTaBa HapO,ZJ;OB H3 HeCKO.lIbKIIX paCOBbIX 3JIeMelITOB H, Ha060pOT.
npOHBJIeHIIH O)J;Horo H Toro me 3JIeMelITa B COCTaBe pa3HbIX HapO)J;OB. nO'le-
MY me 3THHqeCKHa ypOBeHb paCClIfaTpIIBaeTCH BCJIe,ZJ; aa nonYJUII{HOHHbIM II
t.
t-
"'.
r
"
,.
29
.
"....
,:
nepe)J; CJIe)J;yIOm;IIM 3a HllM paCOBbIM? npH IIa 3Toro B COOTHomeHHH 3THH-
qeCRHX II paCOBbE 06m;IIOCTeH: qIICJIO IIapO)J;OB KOJIeOJIeTCH, no pa3IIbIM no)J,-
CqeTaM, BORpyr TbICH'III ", qIICJIO paCOBhIX THnOB B pa3IIbIX KJIaCCIIcpIIRa-
qHHX lIe npeBbImaeT IIeCKOJIbKHX )J;eCHTKOB 15. 113 3Toro npOCToro conOCTaB-
JIelIHH BII)J;HO, 'ITO paCbI B nO)J;aBJIHIOm;eM 60JIbmHIICTBe CJIyqaeB COOTBeTCTBY-
roT 60JIee BhICOKOMY ypOBIIIO 06'be)J;IIlIeIIHH alITpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX 06'beKTOB,
qeM 3TIIHqeCRIle rpyrrrrHpOBKH.
/ PaC06bLU yp06eHb. IIocJIe Toro KaK B aIITpOnOJIOrHII YTBepJJ:HJIaCb MbICJIb
06 IIepapXIIII pac, nO.D:OOIIOlr COrrO.D:'IIIlIeHIIIO THnOB, RJIaCCOB, OTpH)J;OB, ce-
MelrcTB, pO)J;OB, BIr,[J,OB lliHBOTlIbIX II paCTelIIIlr, )J;eJIamiCb MHorOKpaTHbIe no-
nhITKII ee IICTOJIKOBaIIIIH. HanooJIee pacnpOCTpalIelIlIbIM If, nO-BH)J;IIMOMY,
npaBIIJIblIhIH cnoc06 TaRoro IICTO.TIKOBaHHH cpIIJIOrelIeTII'IeCKIIII - rpynnIIpoB-
Ka B COOTBeTCTBIIII C 06m;IIM rrpOIIcxom)J;eHlreM. HapH)J,y C 3TIIM MOiRlIO IIa-
MeTIITb H )J;pyron nYTb, 3aKJIIO'IaIOmIIlrCH B nonbITKe YBH)J;eTb II oxa-
paKTepH30BaTb cBoe06pa3IIe pac o)J;IIoro cHcTeMaTII'IeCKOrO ypOBIIH. ABTOp
BhID;eJIHeT ABa TIIna, IImI MO)J;Yca, II3MelI'IIIBOCTII IIa paCOBOM YPOBlIe - TH-
nOJIOrII'IeCKHH II JIOKaJIblIhIii:, HO 3TIIM, BII)J,IIMO, lIe IIC'IepIIhlBaeTCH IIX MIIO-
ro06pa3He 16. npH TIInOJIOrH'IeCKOM MO)J;yce rpynnoBaH If3MelI'IIIBOCTb, IIMeH
reorpacpH'I€CKHe 3aKOJlOMepHOCTlI, COCTaBJIHeT 60JIee rnHpOKHe CO'IeTaHlIH H
paChr C.TIaraIOTCH II3 norryJIHqIIII. IIpH JIOKaJIblIOM MO)J;yce II3l1felIqHBOCTb alI-
TpOTIOJIOrIIqeCKHX npH3IIaKOB reorpacpII'IeCKH IIe3aKOlIOMeplIa II OT)J;eJIblIhIe
nonYJIH IIII lIe rpynnHpYIOTCH B OOm;HOCTII OOJIee BbICOKoro nopmJ,Ka. B03-
:\fOiRlIhI H nepeXO)J;HbIe CJIyqaII. TaKIIM 06pa30M, KaiR)J;aH paca IIMeeT CBOIO
06JIaCTb pacnpOCTpalIelIIIH, CBOIO CTPYKTYPY (T. e. CBOH IIa60p CJIaraIOm;IIX ee
nonYJIH IIH II IIX COOTlIornelIIIe, onpe)J;eJIHIOmHe 3anac ee H3MelIqIIBOCTH),
no-pa3IIOMY CBH3alIa C )J;pyrIIMlI pacallfII. Bce 3TO - BbIpaiReIIIIe cne IIcpIIKH
3aROIIOB, JIeiRam;IIX B OCHOBe cpOpMIIpOBalIIIH pac, CJIe)J,OBaTeJIbHO, npaBOMep-
IIOCTH BhI)J,eJIeIIIIH e e II Ha)J;nonYJIH HOIIHoro ypOBIIH IIIITerpa IIII alITpono-
JIOrHqeCKIIX OO'beKTOB H npo:qeCCOB.
llPorH03
ITepecTpOHRa rpynnIIpOBRH 06'beKTOB aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCROrO IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH II
RJIaCCIIcpIIKaUHII Haymi Ha IIOBOlr OCIIOBe, C Moeii: TOqRH 3peIIIIH,- )J,eJIO
6JIIIiRaHmerO 6Y)J;ym;ero, rrpo ecc, KOTOpbIH CTHXIIHIIO rrpOHCXO)J,IIT YiRe ceH-
qac. 3a)J;a'Ia COCTOHT B TOM, 'IT06bI OC03IIaTb 3TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO II crroc06-
CTBOBaTb )J;aJIbHeHmeMY pa3BIITIIIO npo ecca. qTO iRe KacaeTCH 60JIee )J,a.:'Ie-
Koro nporlI03IIpOBalIHH, TO 0110 )J;OJI}RIIO onIIpaTbCH IIa COBeprnelIIIoe 3IIalIHe
3aKOlIOB pa3BIITIIH IIaYRII. nOKa B03MOiRII0 BbICKa3aTb JIHrnb 60JIee IIJIH Me-
Hee npaB)J;oIIo)J;06IIbIe rIInOTe3bI. OT XpOIIOJIOrII'IeCRoro nporlI03IIpoBaHliH CJIe-
,ZJ;yeT cpa3Y me OTRa3aTbCH: rHnOTe3bI onpaB):(bIBaIOTcH IIlIor)J;a B BbICOKOll
CTerrelIH, HO pe)J;Ko ORa3bIBaeTCH YJJ:aqlIhIM npe)J;cKa3amre )J;aT OTKphITIIlr. no-
3TOMY oyp:y rOBopHTb 06 06m;IIX TelI)J;eH HHX pa3BIITIIH aIITpOnOJIOrIIH.
Mile KameTCH, qTO TPH rrp06JIeMbI oco6elIII0 aKTyaJIblIbI B rr03HalIIIH ca-
lIfbIX cpYII)J;aMeHTaJIblIhIX 3aROlIOB 6HOJIOrHH 'IeJIOBeKa II rJIy60qaHrnHX CBH3elr
'IeJIOBeqeCKOrO opralIH3Ma co cpe)J;oH. 8TO, Bo-nepBhIx, II3BJIeqelIIIe ropa3)J;0
60JIee nOJIIIOH IIlIcpopMa IIH 6IIOXIIMIIqeCROrO, cpH3IIOJIDrH'IeCKOrO H IIlIoro
nopHAKa H3 MopcpOJIOrH'IeCKIIX IIa6JIIO)J;eIIIIH rrpIIMelIIITeJIblIO K pa3BIITHIO 'Ie-
JIOBeKa B npOmJIOM (IIlIhIMII CJIOBaMII, nepexo)J; B aIITporrorelIe3e OT CIICTeM-
Horo H opraHlIoro ypOBHH II3Y'IelIIIH K 60JIee IIII3RHM YPOBIIHM), BO-BTOPhIX,
BCKpbITIIe caMhIX IIHTIIMlIhIX npo eccoB XIIMII'IeCKOrO B3aIIMo)J;eii:cTBIIH BIIYT-
pII 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOrO opralIII3Ma II B 06MelIe ero Bem;ecTBoM II 3IIeprHelr co cpe-
.D:olr (T. e. nepexo)J; MOJIeKYJIHplIOrO II KJIeTOqlIOrO YPoBHeM Ha opraIlIIbIlr H
:30
;-
opraHII3MeHHhIn) II, HaROHe:q, B-TpeTbIIX. n03HaHIIe reHeTIlqeCRIIX MeXaIIII3-
1\fOB B nOJIHOM 06'beMe, OTRpbITIIe 3aROlIOB reHeTIIqeCRoii: 06YCJIOBJIeHHOCTII
TRalIelI, OpraHOB H IIX CIICTe1\f. Ceii:qaC eCTb B03MOmHOCTb paCCMOTpeTb KaiR-
AYIO II3 3TIIX np06JIeM H HaMeqaIOm;IIeCH B IIX pellieHIIII TeH)J;eH:qIIH C II3BeCT-
HOn 06'beRTHBHOCTbIO, B O)J;HIIX CJIyqaHX OnIIpaHCb IIa yme npOBe)J;elIHbIe IIC-
CJIe)J;OBaIIIIH, B )J;pyrIIx - ,ZJ;OMhICJIHBaH IIMeIOm;HeCH IIaOJIIOAeIIIIH, B pa3YMIIbIX
npe]:J;eJIax cpaHTa3IIpYH.
KOCTII, KOTOphIe apXeOJIOrH H aHTpono.JIOrII II3BJIeKaIOT npII paCRonRax
)J;peBIIIIX norpe6elIIIii, CJIymaT )J;JIH peKOHCTpYK:qIIII caMbIX pa3Hooopa3HhIX
oc06eHHOCTeH 6IIOJIOrIIqeCROn opraHII3al(IIII )J;peBHeHlliIIX npe)J;KOB qeJIOBeRa:
nOMII1\fO aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO THna, onpe)J;eJIHeTCH 6IIOJIOrIIqeCKHii: B03paCT,
BOCCTaHaBJIIIBaIOTCH pOCT II IIpOnop:qIIII TeJIa, xapaKTepII3yeTcH, npaB,ZJ;a OqeHb
npII6JII13IITeJIbII0, cpII3IIqeCROe pa3BIITIIe. no CTepTOCTII 3y60B II CTpoeHIIIO
qeJIIOCTeii: 1\fOmHO ROCBeHHO CY)J;HTb 0 xapaKTepe nIITaHIIH. nOHBIIJICH B aHT-
pOnOJIOrIIqeCROn JIIITeparype )J;aiRe OC06bIii: TepMIIII - «6IIOJIOrIIqeCRaH peROH-
CTPYR:qIIH», 0003HaqaIOm;IIii: nOJIyqeHIIe nepeqIICJIeHlIbIX nOKa3aTeJIeii: Ha OC-
HOBe H3MepeHIIH II onIIcalIIIH CKeJIeTa. Ho TOqHOCTb, a rJIaBHOe, MaClliTa6
TaKoii: 6IIOJIOrHqeCROH peROHCTpYR:qIIII nORa em;e OqeHb HeBeJIIIKII. HIIKaRoro
CKOJIbRO-HII6Y)J;b nO)J;po6Horo npe)J;CTaBJIeHIIH 0 CTpoeHIIII, CPYHR:qIIOHIIpOBaHlIH
p;pyrHx opralIOB II CIICTeM qeJIOBeqeCROrO TeJIa OHa He npIIHOCIIT IIJIII, Bepuee
CKa3aTb, nOqTII He npIIHOCIIT. J];JIH IICTOpIIII aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO COCTaBa qe-
JIOBe"<I€CTBa, naqlIlIaH C BepXHero naJIeOJIIITa, 3TO HeOOJIblliOII np06eJI, TaR KaR
3aMeTHhIX II3MelIeHIIII B CTpoeHIIII COBpeMelIHoro qeJIOBeRa 3a nOCJIe)J;IIIIe 25-
28 TbIC. JIeT He npOl130lliJIO. Ho 3TII II3MeHeIUIH Ha npOTHiReHIIII Bcero aHTpo-
noreHe3a orpOMHhI, a CY)J;IITb 0 HIIX MhI MOiRe f TOJIbKO no HaqaJIbHOMY II KO-
He"<IHoMy 3BelIbHM - qeJIOBeKOo6pa3HhIM 06e3bHHaM II COBpeMeHHOMY qeJIOBe-
RY. nYTII II npIIqlIIIhI 3TIIX II3MeHeHIIII, OqeBH)J;HO, MomHO 6Y)J;eT BhlHCIIIITb
C nOMOm;bIO )J;BYX IICTOqIUIKOB IIHcpopMa:qIIH.
O)J;IIH 113 HIIX CBH3aH npeIIMym;ecTBeHHO C ycnexaMII MOPCPOJIOrIIII. Tm;a-
TeJIbHOe II3yqeHIIe MeCT npIIKpenJIelIIIH MhIlli:q IIa ROCTHX npn BceM, Ka3a-
JIOCb 6hI, TOJIbRO cne:qIIaJIbHOM IIHTepece TaROH pa60ThI pelliaeT cpaBHIITeJIb-
IIo-aHaTOMIIqeCRYIO np06JIeMY Rap)J;IIHaJIbHOn BamHOCTH - BOCCTalIOBJIenHH
cTpoeHIIH 1\IYcRYJIarypbI. lliIIpOBaH Macca TeJIa, oc06eHHo mIIp Ha BHYTpeH-
HIIX opraHax, OTIIOCIITeJIbHO He3aBIICIIMa OT ROCTHKa. BecbMa BepoHTHo, 0)J;-
HaRo, qTO YCTaHOBJIelIIIe TOqHOH MephI 3TOII 3aBlICIIMOCTII nOMomeT no pa3-
BHTIIIO CReJIeTa CO<\TaBJIHTb cym)J;eHIIe 0 pa3BIITIIII mIIpa. PacrnIIpeHIIe TeMa-
TIIKII II MacrnTa6a 1\fOpcpOJIOrIIqeCRIIX HCCJIeJJ:oBaHIIii: npIIBe.n:eT B I{olI e ROII OB
K onpe)J;eJIeIIIIIO pa3MepoB II COOTIIOllieHIIH BHYTpeHHIIx opraHoB y npe)J;cTa-
BIITeJIelI pa3HhIx TIIIIOB TeJIOCJIOiRlIeHIIH. CJIe)J;OBaTeJIbHO, no IIpOnop:qIIHM II
MaCCIIBHOCTII CReJIeTa )J;peBHIIx JIIO)J;eII MomllO 6Y)J;eT CY)J;HTb 0 cTpoeHIIII II
pa3Mepax BHYTpeHHIIx opraHoB, IIX pacnOJIOiReHIIII no OTIIOllielIHIO APyr K
.n:pyry, npOCJIe)J;IITb 3BOJIIO IIOHHhIe JIIIIIIIII IIX pa3BIITIIH. ITo cTpoeHIIIO 3H)J;0-
KpaHa (CJIenRa BIIYTpeIUleii: nOJIOCTH qepenlIoii: Kopo6KH, cooTBeTcTBYIOm;ero
cpopMe If pa3MepaM 1\1031'8) YiRe cenqac BOCC03)J;aIOT IIeROTOphIe OqeHb cym;e-
CTBeUHbIe oc06eHHOCTII MbIlliJIeHIIH )J;peBHIIX JIIO)J;eii: II CTpoeHIIH IIX opraHOB
qYBCTB 17. Ha)J;o )J;YMaTb, qTO B03M01RHOCTI1 B 3TOii: 06JIaCTH .D:aJIeRO He IIC-
qepnaHbI, oc06eHHO npII O)J;HOBpeMeHHOM YCOBeprneHCTBOBaHIIIf MeTO.D:IIKII
rIICTOJIOrIIqeCROrO II rIICTocp1I3IIOJIOrIIqeCROrO H3yqeIUm M03ra y qeJIOBeRa II
Q6e3bHH.
J];pyroH HCTOqIUIK IIHcpopMa:qIIII 0 CPYHR:qlIOHIIpOBaHIIII pa3HbIx opralIOB If
IIX CIICTeM B aHTponoreHe3e - npeHMym;ecTBeHHO cpII3IIOJIOrIIqeCRHii:. 8BOJIIO-
:qIIOHlIaH cpII3IIOJIOrHH, C03)J;aHHaH B OCHOBHOM TpY)J;aMH COBeTCRoro yqeHOrO
Jl. A. Op6eJIH II ero lliKOJIbI, IIaROnIIJIa 60JIblliOe ROJIIIqeCTBO cpaKTOB, CBII)J;e-
,
.
t
t
fit'
t
I.
31
\'-'
TeJIbCTBYIOm;IIX 06 3BOJIIO:qIIII CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKllX CPYHm:t;IIn, 0 nYTJIX II TIIn8X
:ux nepecTpollKH, 0 mIIpOlwll a)J;arrTIIBHOCTII CPH3HOJIOrIIqeCKHX pe8m:t;IIii Y
pa3HbIX BI1JJ;OB mIIBOTHbIX H 06 IIX YCTOnqIIBOCTII B npe)J;eJIax op:Horo BII,ZJ;8 1.8.
J];JIH qeJIOBeRa CPII3HOJIOrIIqeCKHe rrpe06pa30BaHIIH B npo:qecce 3BOJIIOIJ;HII
6bIJIII ep:Ba JIH He OCHOBHbIMII, TaR KaR IIMeHHO OHII onpe)J;eJIHJIII II3MeHeHIIH
rrOBe)J;eHIIH II YCOBepmeHCTBOBaHIIe nCIIxocpII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKOll ,ZJ;eHTeJIbHOCTH.
EOJIee TOHKoe, BHIIMaTeJIbHOe H )J;eTaJIbHOe H3yqeHIIe BbIcmell HepBHOll )J;eH-
TeJIblIOCTII qeJIOBeR006pa3HbIX 06e3bHH II eJIOBeRa B cpaBHIITeJIblIOM acneK-
Te BbIHBIIT IIHTeHCIIBHYIO )J;IIHaMURY MHorIIX CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCRIIX II rrCIIXIIqe-
CRIIX CPYImIJ;Hii:, 0 ROTOpOH MbI CellqaC He IIMeeM npep;CT8BJIeHIIH.
.H YBepelI, qTO 06a IICTOqHIIKa IIHcpopMa:qIIII 0 rrpe06pa30BaHIIII MOPCPOJIO-
rHqeCKIIX CTPYRTYP II oc06eHII0 CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCRIIX CPYHK:qIIii: B rrpo:qecce aHT-
porroreHe3a - MopcpOJIOrIIqeCRIIn (cpII3IIOJIOrIIqeCRaH IIIITeprrpeTa:qIIH MOpcpO-
JIOrIIqeCRIIX cpaKToB) II c06cTBelIII0 CPII3HOJIOrIIqeCRIIII - COJIbIOTCH B OCOObIll.
rrocBHm;eHHbIii: Crrel(IIaJIblIO qeJIOBeRY pa3)J;eJI 3BOJIIOl(IIOHHOll cpII3IIOJIOrIIII, 6y
)J;ym;ee HaIIMeHOBaHIIe KOToporo CelIqaC em;e HeII3BeCTHO, HO KOTopbIn Terrepb
MomHO YCJIOBHO Ha3BaTb rraJIeocpII3IIOJIOrIIelI "<I€JIOBeRa.
qeJIOBeK, KaK II JII060e )J;Pyroe iRIIBOe cym;ecTBo, Hepa3pbIBHO CBH3aH co
cpe)J;oll. C rrnm;en rrOCTOHHHO BBO)J;IITCH orrpep;eJIeHHOe KOJIIIqeCTBO XHlIfHqe-
CRIIX Bem;eCTB, KOTOpbI€ COOTBeTCTBYIOm;IIM 06pa30M HarrpaBJIHIOT rrpo:qeCCbI
06MeHa B opraHII3Me; )J;bIxaHIIe II BBO)J;IIMbW Bem;eCTBa orrpe)J;eJIHIOT ero 3Hep-
reTIIKY. CocTaB B03)J;yxa Ha rrJIaHeTe OTHOCHTeJIbHO rrOCTOHHeH, a rr03ToMY
3HepreTIIqeCRIIe pe3Y.:'IbTaTbI RIICJIOpOJJ:Roro 06MeHa 60JIbme 3aBIICHT B Kam-
p:OM OT)J;eJIbHOM CJIyqae OT caMoro opraHII3Ma, qeM OT rroTpe6JIHeMOrO RIICJIO-
pO)J;a. HeJIb3H CRa3aTb Toro me 0 rrIIm;e, TaK KaK ee XIIMIIqeCKIIH COCTaB II
KaJIOpIIIIHOCTb pa3JIIlqaIOTCH OqeUb CIIJIbHO, HanpIIMep, r)J;e-HII6YP:b Ha 6epery
nOJIHpHbIX MopeH II B TpOrrIIqeCKIIX 06JIaCTHX, B rrYCTbIHHX :u BbICOKoropHbIX
pallOHax. npaB)J;a, B HaCTOHm;ee BpeMH II.!I:eT npo:qecc YIIIIcpIIKal(IIII IIIIm;eBoro
pa:qlIOHa Ha orpOMHhIX TeppIITopIIHX, II 3TIIM rrpo:qeCCOM OXBaqeHa 60JIbmaH
qaCTb qeJIOBeqeCTBa. O)J;HaKO Bop:a HeO)J;IIHaROBa no XIIMIIqeCKoMy COCTaBY B
pa3HbIX pallOHax 3eMHoro mapa, II )J;ame npII YHIlcpII:qIIpOBaHHOM rrIITaHIIII C
Hei!: BBO)J;HTCH B opraHII3M qeJIOBeRa Bem;eCTBa, crre:qHcpIIqeCRIIe ,ZJ;JIH Kamn;oro
pallOHa. B. II. BepHa)J;CRIIM 6bIJIa OTRpbITa 3Ta rrOJIHaH II HepaCTopmIIMaH 3a-
BHCIIMOCTb opraHII3MOB OT XIIMlm 3eMHOll KOpbI, C03)J;aHbI 6IIoreOXIIMHH :u
yqeIIIle 0 6IIoccpepe. Ero nOCJIe;J:OBaTeJIII II yqeHIIKII A. n. BIIHorpap:OB H
E. E. nOJIbIHOB rrORa3aJIII reorpacpIIqeCROe cBoe06pa3IIe reOXIIMIIqeCKIIX rrpo-
:qeCCOB B B03)J;ellCTBIIII Ha mIIBbIe opraHII3MhI, C03)J;aJIII yqeHIIe 0 JIaH)J;macpT-
IIOI1 reOXIIMIIH II 6HoreOXIIMIIqeCKHX rrpOBHII:qIIHX. BJIIIHIIIIe XIIMIIII cpe)J;hI Ha
mII3Hb II ee rrpOHBJIeHIIH, BJIIIHHIIe, npIIypOqeHHOe K orrpe.D:eJIeHHOll reorpa-
CPIIII, OTpamalOm;ee crre:qIIcpHRY MeCTa, CTaJIO HeocrropHMbIM cpaRTOM B COBpe-
MeHHOll HaYKe, C HIIM HeJIb3H He CqIITaTbCH rrpII 1I3yqeHIIII JII06hIX 6IIOJIOrII-
qeCRIIX HBJIeHHii:, B TOM qIICJIe II 6IIOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeKa.
Me)J;II:qIIHCRIIe II aHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCRlIe Ha6JIIO.D:eHIIH n03BOJIHIOT KOHKpeTII-
3IIpOBaTb 3TY MbICJIb. II36bITOR HJIII Hep:ocTaToK MIIKp03JIeMeHTOB B nOqBe,
Bop:e, oKpymaIOm;en cpe)J;e B :qeJIOM rrpIIBO.D:IIT qaCTO K THiReJIhIM rraTOJIOrIIqe-
CRIIM rrOCJIe)J;cTBIIHlIf. 8H)J;eMIIqeCKIIH 306 HBJIHeTCH xopomo II3yqelIHhIM, 110 He
e)J;IIHCTBeHHbIM rrpIIMepOM TaRIIX 3a60JIeBaHIIH. IIHTepecHee, op:IIaRO, p:py-
roe - He rraTOJIOrIIqeCRIIe COCTOHHIIH, BbI3bIBaeMhIe rrOJIHhIlIf OTCYTCTBIIeM,
IIen;OCTa TROM HJIII rrepeII36bITROM Toro IIJIII IIHoro XIIMIIqeCKOrO 3JIeMeHTa B
opraHII3Me qeJIOBeKa, a HOpMaJIbHaH II3MeHqIIBOCTb cO)J;epmaHIIH 3TIIX 3JIe-
MeHTOB, BapbIIpOBaHIIe IIX B He60JIbmIIX rrpe,ZJ;eJIax Y JII060ro 3)J;opOBoro qeJIO-
BeRa, TO, qTO B 6IIOXIIMIIII Ha3bIBaeTCH 6IIOXIIMIIqeCKOll IIH,ZJ;IIBII,ZJ;yaJIb-
IIOCTbIO 19. IIHTepecHo II COqeTaUIIe 3TIIX IIH)J;IIBII,ZJ;yaJIbHOCTen B rronyJIH:qIIH,
.
.
-.
i
J
A
,
-
,1
.
1
.;
C._J
-'
I
,;
j
1
.
.
32
'>
rpynne nonYJlH:qIIii:, Y 1] perrCTaBl1TV;refi O]J:HOii: paCbI. Y CTaHOBJIeHO, qTO MeiR-
nonY:IHl(UOIlHbIe p33JIIPlIIH IJpOHlWHIOTCH B XHMIIqeCKlIX xapaRTepIICTIIKaX
RpOBlI - cO)J;epiRaHHII 6eJIKOBbIX cppaR nII, XOJIeCTepIIlIa, KaJIbn;HH B KOCTHX
II EO :\fTIOTIfX I1,PyrIIx XII1\IIIqeCKIlX CBOHCTBax. I1nor)J;a OHII YBH3bIBaIOTCH C
reOXH1\UPIeCROII xapaRTepIlCTHKOH pai'wlIa, IlHor]J:3 HeT. 11 B 3TOM nOCJIe)J;HeM
CJIY'Iae UPIlqlIIIhI IIX OCTaJOTCH HenCllhIIIUI, HO 3H3qelIIIe IlX B cpopMo06pa30-
BaHIIlI O'IeBH)J;HO: OUII npej],CTaIJJIHIOT cooon BbIpaiReHIW rJIy6IIHHbIX npo ec-
COB H 'Ie.'IOBC'JeCKOM opraUIl3Me, COCT3B.JIHIOT, IIO-BIl)J;IIMOMY, qepe3 06Mell
Ben eCTB OCHOBY H3MeII'UIBOCTIl BOOOm;e. HeJIb3H He BIIJIeTb B IIX IICCJIe)],OBa-
HUH nepOSOL!: K 60Jlee BbICOIWMY ypOBnIO nOHIIMaIUIH B3auMocBH3eii: BHYTPII
opraHU3Ma qeJIOBeIm, a TaRlRe ero 3aBIICIIl\fOCTb OT cpe)J;bI iRII3HII, OT MHOrJTX
COCTaBJIHIOm;IIX ee KOMJ10HeHTOB, HeJIb3H He )J;YM3Tb, qTO OYPIIOC pa3HUTIIe
BToro p33 le.;ra uaYKII rrOB.;!e'IeT cepHIO npIIHn;IIIJUaJIbHO HOBbIX OTKpbITIIII II
C03)IaCT CPYHD;3MeHT )1';UI nOBOH TeopIIII 3I1TpOnOreOl(eH030B 20. f[ cr':JlOlIeH
J yl\IaTb, qTO BTa 06JI3CTb aIlTpOnOJIOrIIqeCIWH HaYKII - ee MOiRlIO Ha3BaTb
3HTpOTIOXIll\UWii: - CO BpeMeHeM npeBpaTIITCH B O.D:IIII JI3 OCHOBHhIX ee pa3-
LleJ!OH, nOTOMY qTO OHa )J;3eT B03MOiRHOCTb lIe TOJIbRO onIIChIBaTb aHTpOnOJIO-
rH'IeCKlIe 06'bCJ{ThI, 110 rOpa3)10 60JIce IlIUpOKO, 'IeM Tenepb, aHaJIII3IIpOBaTb
HX nOHB.rreHIIe, npIIqIIHbI IIX II3MeHeHHiI - O)J;HIIM CJIOBOM, IIX 3BO.JIIO HIO.
AHTponOXIIMIIH OTBeTIIT Ha BonpOCbI, CBH3alIHbIe C BJJIlHIIIIeM cpeJJ;bI IIa
cpopMo06pa30naHIIe. Ho Y nOCJIell,IIero eCTb em;e O)J;IIII acneKT, e)J;Ba JIII He 60-
JIce BaambIH, - reUeTIIqeCKIIH. I13BecTIIoe B 06JIaCTII nepe)J;aqII no HaCJlel{CTBY
6nc.rrOrII'WCKIIX ocooeHHocTelI 'ICJIOBeKa BO MHoro )J;eCHTROB, COTeH pa3 MeHb-
me neII3HeCTuoro. I13BccTHa reneTIIKa HeROTophIX cpH3IIOJIOrII'IeCKITX npH3IIa-
ROB, HO HeII3BeCTubI 3aIwnbI HaCJIe)J;CTBeIIHOH rrepell,a'III MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKllX
rrpII3II3KOB, KOJIHqeCTBO yrrpaBJIHJOlI IIX IIMII renOB, crrocoobI IIX B3aIIl\IO.D:eii:-
CTBIIH. H3BeCTIIa reHeTIIKa MlIorHX HaCJIeJJ;CTBeHlIbIX 60JIe3HeH, no HeII3BeCT-
IIO, KaK rrepe)J;aIOTCH no IIaCJIe,'],CTBY IIOpMaJIbHbIe BapIIa:qIIII II Bo06m;e K3K
nO)1}],epiRIIBaeTCH B reHeTIIKe TIInOBaH IIOpMa. MeiRII,Y TeM )J;eJIo lIe TOJIbKO B
TOM, qTO 6e3 3H3HIIH Bcex 3TIIX 3aKOHOB MbI JIIIilleHbI B03MomlIOCTII pacrnII-
pnTb paMKII lIIe)J;IIKo-reHeTlIqeCRoii: ROHCYJIbTal(IIII n npeBpaTIITb ee B reHe-
TIPl€CKYIO, T. e. rrpe)J;CRa3bIBaTh He TOJIbKO nOHBJIeHIIe RaROH-HII6Y.D:b IIaCJIeJ];-
cTBelIHoiI 3HOMaJIHII, 110 II nOHBJIeHHe Tex IIJIH IIHhIX HOpMaJIbHbIX CBonCTB B
311,OpOBOM COCTOHHHH, 6e3 naTOJIOrUqeCRHX HaPYillerrIIII. J];PyrIIMH CJIOBaMII,
ceii:'Iac yme MomHO rrpe)J;cRa3aTb rraTOJIOrII'ICCKOe HapYillelIIIe, eCJIH reHOTII-
IIh! paJ1IITeJlcii: oTHrOm;eHbI Bpe.D:HbIMII renaMH, 110 HeB03MOiRHO rrpell,cTaBHTb
ceoe, RaRIIM 6Y)1eT peoeuOK, eCJIII Y pO)J;IITeJIeii: HeT reHOB, Hecym;HX aHOMa-
';UIH, KaKHe Y Hero 6y.n:YT BOJIOCbI, rJIa3a, RaROBa B l(eJIOM 6Y)J;eT ero
BIIClIIHOCTb.
Ha nepBbIii: B3rJIHII, BTO cyry60 aRaJ];eMUqeCRaH IIp06JIeMa. B IWnl(e ROH-
l(OB JIIOJJ;II - He iRIIBOTHbIe: eCJlII BaJKIIO 3IIaTb, RaK IIJIeMerrHoii: (japan 6Y)J;eT
IIepC;];aBaTb CBOII KaqeCTBa rrOTOMCTBY, TO .D:JIH qeJIOBeKa 3TO lIe upeIl,CTaBJIH-
eT oc060ro IlUTepeca. Ho TaKoe YTBepiRD;eHne cnpaBeD:JIIIBO, rrOKa qeJlOBeR
paCCMaTpIIBaeTCH RaR CHHOHIlM 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa, KaK 06m;ecTBo B u,eJIOM. J];.'1H
OTJ],eJIblWrO me qeJIOBeIm, )J;JIH HIIJJ:IIBII,ll,YYMa B 60JIbrnIIHCTBe CJIyqaeB COBceM
He 6e3pa3JIII'IHO, uOXOiRII HJIII HerrOXOiRII na nero 6YII,YT ero ,ZJ;eTII. MhI HaTaJl-
KUB3eMCH 3,L1,eCb Ha OOJIbrnyIO 06m;eCTBeIIIIYIO rrp06JIeMY, TeCHO cBH3aHHYIO C
I10HHTIIC I JIHqHOrO CqaCTbH; eCTL :VIHoro JIlOiJ,eII, He;1;OBOJIbHbIX CHoelI Buern-
IIOCTbIO, KOTopbIe COBceM lIe mam.D:YT rrepe,ZJ;aBaTb CBOII He)J;OCTaTRII rrOTOMCT-
BY. J];a II cpe)J;II reHOB OTl(a II MaTepII MorYT 6hITb COqeTaHIIH, KOTOphIe OKa-
mYTCH ne6JIarOrrpIIHTHbIMII H rrpIIBeiJ,YT K )J;IIcrapMOHIIHM.
EBrCHHKa npe)J;JJaraJIa meCTOKHH, B3HTbIn H3 CeJIbCKOX03HnCTBeHIIon rrpaR-
TIIKII pe:qerrT - Hymell IIo)J;6op: eCJIII nOTeH:qHaJlbH Ie pOp;IITeJIII He nop;xop;HT
.
k
'
"
..
."
r
".
I
r
f'
f
,
2 B. II. AJIeHCeeB
33
/\
-"
-
)J;pyr K )J;pyry no CBOIIM HaCJIe,ZJ;CTBeHlIbIM KaqeCTBaM, OIIH He ,ZJ;OJIiRHbI HMeTb
)J;eTeH. MHoro rOJIOCOB pa3.n:aBaJIOCb ,ZJ;ame B nOJIb3Y HaCIIJIbCTBeHHon cTepH-
JIII3a:qIIH JIIO)J;en C HeiReJIaTeJIbHbIMH HaCJIe)I;CTBeIIHbIMH 3a,ZJ;aTKaMII. ROHeqHO,
3TO 6eCqeJIOBeqHO, aMOpaJIbHo.
Ho, OTBepraH eBrmUIRY, TPY,ZJ;HO He BepIITb B B03MomHOCTb pa3YMIIoro
3KcnepIIMelITaJIbHOrO B03)J;enCTBIIH Ha HaCJIe)J;CTBeHHOCTb qeJIOBeKa B 6Y)J;Y-
m;eM. Momno cnpoclITb: npII qeM 3)J;eCb aHTponOJIOrHH, Be)J;b peqb II)J;eT 0
cyry60 reHeTII ecKoM np06JIeMe? O)J;HaKo II3yqeHIIe 3aKOlIOB HaCJIe CTBeIIHoK
nepe aqII B03MomHO TOJIbKO nOCJIe Toro, KaK .n:eTaJIblIO BbIHCHeHbI MOpcpOJIO-
rIIqeCKaH cTpyKTypa II CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKOe 3HaqeHIIe IIaCJIemreMOro CBoIIcTBa.
n03TOMY nepexo,ll, OT alITpOnOJIOrIIII K aHTponOreHeTIIRe ocym;eCTBJIHeTCH
OqeHb nJiaBIIO, a B 6YAy eM ero, Ha,ZJ;O nOJIaraTb, BOBce He 6Y,ZJ;eT. AIITpono-
JIOrml, 060ra eHlIaH reHeTIIqeCKIIMH MeTO.D:aMH, npH06peTeT KOJIOCCaJIblIOB
3IIaqeHIIe B npaKTIIKe RaK HaYKa He TOJIbKO 0 cpopMo06pa30BalIIIII II npoIlc-
XOm.D:eHIIH qeJIOBeKa, HO II 0 cnoc06e C03HaTeJIbHOrO H36aBJIeHIIH ero OT re-
Ji( TIIqeCKH 06YCJIOBJIeHHbIX IIcrapMOIIHn pa3BIITIIH.
MTaK, naJIeocpII3IIOJIOrHH, aHTponOXIIMIIH H aHTponoreHeTIIKa C ropa3,ZJ;O
60JIee MOm;IIhIMII, qeM cenqac, cpe)J;CTBaMH. B03 eHCTBIIH Ha HaCJIe)J;CTBeIIHOCTb
qeJIOBeKa - BOT rJIaBIIbIe IIanpaBJIeHIIH, no KOTOpbIM 6Y.D:eT, C Moen TOqRH
3pe1IIIH, pa3BIIBaTbCH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH B IIe,ZJ;aJIeKOllf 6y)J;ym;eM. ECJIII 3TO em;e
He caMa )J;eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTb, TO BO BCHKOM CJIyqae nepcneKTIIBbI, IIenOcpe)J;CT-
BeHHO BbITeImIOm;IIe II3 Hee. ]J,YMaH 0 HIIX, MbI OCTaeMCH B paMKax peaJIb-
HOM On;eIIlUI IIaillIIX B03MOiRHOCTeH B n03HalIIIII 6IIOJIOrHU qeJIOBeKa II ero
MeCTa B npupoJJ:e. Ho TPY.D:IIO OTKa3aTb ce6e B y)J;OBOJIbCTBIIII nOMeqTaTb, He
OrJIH)J;bIBaHCb Ha cerO)J;IIHrnIIIIM )J;eHb, He 0 HaYKe 3aBTpaillHero )J;IIH, a 0 TOM,
KaKOM OHa 6Y.D:eT B 3Py HacTyrrJIeHIIH qeJIOBeKa Ha KOCMOC II YCTaHOBJIeHHH
CBH3II C BIIe3eMHbIMII n;IIBIIJIII3a:qIIHMII.
npe)J;CTaBJIeHIIH 0 pacrrpOCTpalIeHIIII iRII3HII BO BCeJIeHHOH II 0 BHe3eMHhIX
IIBIIJIII3an;IIHX yme BhIillJIII 3a paMRII KOMneTeH:qHII nIICaTeJIen-cpaHTaCTOB.
8K306IIOJIOrIIH (IIaYKa 0 iRII3HII B KOCMoce) - qaCTb KOCMIIqeCROM 6IIOJIOrHH;
OT)J;eJIbHbIe ee acrreKTbI pa3pa60TalIbI ,ZJ;OBOJIbIIO rrO)J;p06HO: yqelIIIe 0 6IIOCcpe-
pe, HanpIIMep, rrpeBpam;aeTCH B qaCTb KOCMOJIOrIIII, 6IIoccpepa paCCMaTpIIBaeT-
CH ImK KOCMIIqeCKOe HBJIeHIIe. MOiRHO )J;YMaTb, qTO mII3IIb B )J;pynIx MIIpax
II pa3YMHbIe cpOpMbI MaTepIIH B03HIIKaIOT He TOJIbKO Ha OCHOBe 6eJIKOBbIX
TeJI. Ho )I;aiRe eCJIII orrIIpaTbcH IIa KOH:qerr:qIIIO, corJIaCIIO KOTOpOII OCHOBOM
mII3HII B KOCMoce HBJIHeTCH 6eJIOK, TO II Tor)J;a OCTaeTCH 06illHpHoe rrOJIe )J;JIH
pa3MhIillJIeHIIII, KaKOlla CTpYKTypa II cpII3IIOJIOrIIH pa3YMHbIX opralIH3MoB B
HHbIX YCJIOBIIHX THroTeHIIH, pa)J;Ha:qIIII, 3JIeKTpOMarlIIITHoro nOTeH:qlIaJIa nJIa-
HeTbI, COJIHeqIIOrO IIJIII IIHoro 06JIyqeHIIH, XlIMII3Ma IIHOrrJIaueTHOn 6IIoccpepbI.
IIycTb pa3MhIillJIeHIIH Ha 3TH TeMhI nOKa HeKOIIKpeTHbI, HO He IICKJIIOqeIIO,
qTO IIM rrpIIlIa)J;JIemIIT 6Y,ZJ;ym;ee, H Tor,ZJ;a B :qerrII aHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKllX HayK
rrOHBIITCH em;e o)J;IIO 3BeHO - 3K30aHTpOnOJIOrIIH.
npII TaROM rrOIIIIMaHHII nepcneKTIIB pa3BIITIIH aHTporrOJIOrIIH TepHeT CBoe
e)J;IIIICTBO. 8TO 3aKoHoMepHO, nOCKOJIbKY C yrJIy6JIelIIIeM 3HaHIIH JII06aH OT-
paCJIb HayKII npeBpam;aeTcH B KOMrrJIeKC 60JIee IIJIII MeHee Y3KoCne:qIIaJIH3II-
pOBaHlIbIx )J;IIC:qIInJIIIH. TQ, qTO aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH rroM,ZJ;eT no TOMY me rryTH,
cBII,ZJ;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 ee HeIICqeprraeMbIx B03MomHOCTHX.
S CM., Banp.: Physiological anthropology. N. Y., Toronto, 1975.
Z CYII:\eCTByeT neCKOJIbKO 06CTOHTeJIbHhIX CBOAOK. TeopeTH'IecKaH CTopOHa AeJIa OCBe-
II:\ena 6: Cavalli-Sforza L., Bodmer W. The genetics of human populations. San Fran-
cisco, 1971. KOHJ(peTHbIe AaHHblC CM.: J1iourant A., Kopec A., Domaniewska-Sobczak K.
Distribution of human blood groups and other polimorphisms. L., 1976.
II Hulse F. Race as an evolutionary episode II Amer. Anthropol. Vol. 64. 1962. N 5.
34
-
4 Han60JIee TeOpeTII'IeCRM r.TIYOOROe 1I3JI01KeUHe: TU.Mofljeee-PeCOBCKUU H. B. 0 BeROTD-
pbIX npHHl\lIrraX RJIaCClIcPII1mI\IIH OHOXopo.TIOrll'leClmX e):1IIHlIrr, II Tp. "YpaJI. cf>IIJI. AH
CCCP. CBep;n;JIOBCK, 1961. T. 27; TU.MofljeeB-PecoBcKuu H. B., Bop01tlfOB H. H., H6.!L0-
KOB A. B. KpaTRIID: o'iepR TeoplIlI 3BOJIIOl\IIII. M., 1969; 2-e n3):1. M., 1977.
5 IIepBaH cf>OPMYJIllpOBRa: Zllckerkandl E. Perspectives in molecular anthropology II
Classification and human evolution. Chicago, 1963. EOJIee nOJIHOe 113JI01KeHHe: A.'leK-
ceee B. n. MOJIeKyJIHpHaH aHTpOnOJIOrHH. M., 1974.
6 JIIITepaTypa pa3pOCJIaCb ;n;o rpOMa):1HbIX pa3MepOB II He OXBa'leHa nOIm COBpeJ\IelIHbL\r
CIIHTe30M. O):1HH 1I3 BaH60JIee rrOJIHbIX 0630POB: IIleB'le1iKo 10. r. Pa3BHTHe IWpbI
M03ra '1eJIOBeRa B CBeTe OHTO-cPIIJIOreHeTHQeCKIIX COOTHOIlIeHlIii. M., 1972.
7 HalI60JIee HOJIHbIM CBOA cPaRTII'IeCRlIX ):1aHHbIX II TeOpeTH'IeCRlIX pa3pa6oTOK, HpaB):1a
Y1Ke He BRJIIO'laIOII:\HD: HOBYIO JIIITepaTypy: Body composition. P. I-II II Ann. N. Y.
Acad. Sci. 1963. Vol. 110.
.g Techniques for measuring body composition. Wash., 1961; Human body composition:
Approaches and applications. Oxford; L., 1965.
9 HaHOOJIee nOJIHOe 1I3JIOa\eHlIe: Martin R. Lehrbuch der Anthropologie in systemati-
scher Darstellung: In 3 Bd. Jena, 1928; pacIlI. 1213):1.: Martin R., Saller K. Lehrbuch der
Anthropologie in systematischer Darstellung: In 4 Bd. Stultgart, 1957-1966.
10 KJIaCCH'leCROe OHHcaHlIe HalIOOJIee TIIIIII'IHbIX BaplIal\IID: CM.: IIleBKY1ieHKo B. H.,
rece.'leBU'l A. M. TlIlIoBaH aHaTOMIIH '1eJIOBeRa. JI., 1935.
H Humangenetik: Ein kurzes Handbuch: In 5 Bd./Hrsg. P. Becker. Stuttgart. 1964-
19G9, 'leTHep;LIii Tmr ;JToro PYKOllO,'lCTB<J, namIcaHIIbIlI P. KHYCC:l:laHIIOJII, l\eJIIIIWJ\! 1I0-
CBHll\eH IIHTerpaTHBHbIM xapaRTepIICTIII{aJ\! '1eJIOBe'leCKOrO TeJIa.
12 CM., HalIp.: CTpoeHlIe TeJIa II CHOpT. M., 1968; TY.MaMlH r. C., MapTupocOB 9. r. Te-
JIOCJI01KeHlIe H cnopT. M., 1976; Eiben O. The physique of woman atWets. Budapest,
1972.
1.3 EOJIee nO):1pOoHOe OCBeII:\eHlIe 3Toro Bonpoca: A.!LeKCeeB B. II. K OoocHoBaHIIIO nOHy-
JIHIIIIOHHOD: ROHl\errl\1I1I paCbI II I1p06JIeMbI 3BOJIIOl\HH '1eJIOBeRa II ero pac. M., 1968.
'14 OAIIH 1I3 HalIOOJIee nOJIHbIX COBpeMeHHbIX nOAC'leTOB: Bpyn C. 11. HaCeJIeHlIe MlIpa:
3TH0):1eMorp. cnpaB. M., 1986.
'15 ABa HaH60JIee HOJIHbIX 0030pa 3THX RJIaCclIcPIIRal\IIM: Eickstedt E. Geschichte der an-
thropologischen Namengebung und Klassifikation (unter Betonung der Erforschung
von Siidasien) II Ztschr. Rassenk. 1937. Bd. 5, 6; Schwidetzky I. Grundlagen der Ras-
sensystematik. Wien; Zurich, 1974.
16 A.'lenCeeB B. n. MO):1YCbI pacooopa30BaHIIH II reorpacf>H'leCROe paCHpocTpaHeHlIe reHOB
paCOBbIX nplI3HaKOB II COB. 3TBorpacf>IIH. 1967. JII2 1.
17 O;n;HH 1I3 npHMepOB n0):106HOM peROBCTpYKl\HII: KO'leTKOBa B. 11. I1aJIeOHeBpOJIOrHH.
M., 1973.
'18 COBpeMelIHoe H3JI01KeHlIe: 3BOJIIOl\IIOHHaH cf>II31I0JIOrIlH. JI., 1979. 'lJ. 1.
19 A.!LeKCeeB B. n. AHTponoreorr,eB03bI - CYII:\HOCTb, THIIOJIOrHH, p;IIBaMHRa IIIIplIpoAa.
1975. oM 7.
'20 I10;n;p06Hee 06 3TOM: A.!LeKCeeB B. II. reorpacf>H'leCRlIe O'iarlI cf>opMllpoBaHIIH '1eJIOBe-
qeCRIIX pac. M., 1985.
i
,.
t
(,
r
t
.
,
1';',
II!f
AHTPorronOfMH M MOp OnOrMH
(B CBH3M C Y'lJe6HOM KHMroM no MopqJOJIOrMM 'lJeJIOBeKa 1)
Ha npOTHII\€HIIII HeCROJIbKIIX )J;eCHTIIJIeTIIH Ha PYCCKOM H3bIKe He BbIillJIO HH
oJ],Hoii KHIIrII, KOTopaH Cne IfaJIbHO 6bIJIa ObI rrocBHm;eHa 0630PY MopcpOJIOrIIII
qeJIOBeKa. nOCJIe.)J;Hee no BpeMeHH II3JIOiReHIIe OCHOB MopcpOJIOrHH qeJIOBeKa,
IIO)J,rOTOBJIeuHOe BbI)J;aIOm;IIMCH COBeTCKIIM aUTpOrrOJIOrOM B. B. EYHaKOM,
,6bIJIO If3)J;a1I0 B 1941 r. 2 M3BecTHbIM )J;onOJIlIelIIIeM K Hell HBJIHeTCH BbIille)J;-
maH Tor)J;a II\€ RIIIIra B. B. BYHaKa 0 MeTO.D:HKe alITpOnOJIOrnqeCRnX IICCJIe-
,ZJ;OlJaHnH 3. B TpIIiR)J,hI nepeII3)J;aBaBilleMCH 3a rrOCJIe)J;HIIe TPII .D:eCHTHJIeTIIH
nOlI pa3UhIMII IIa3BaHIIHMII yqe6HIIKe aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH KpaTKIIll 0630p MOpcpO-
JIOrIIII qeJIOBCRa HanIIcan M. r. JIeBIIHbIM, HO :)TOT 0630p B CBH3II C xapaK-
'TepoM H3)J;aHIIH, paCCqHTalIHbIM Ha oCBem;eHIIe npOOJIeM aIcITponorelIe3a H
pacoBe)J;eHIIH, HOCIIT rrpelIMym;ecTBeHHo o6aoplIhlH xapaKTep II He IIMeeT ca-
MOCTOHTeJIbHOrO 3HaqeHlIH I..
35
2*
COBepIIIeHHO eCTeCTBeHIIO, qTO HOBaH RHIIra no MOPcpOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa
(B npe)IHCJIOBIUI CKa3alI0 aiRe: «...nopBoe B CCCP nOCOOIIe 110 TeOpeTIIqO-
CIWH MopcpOJIOrnI! qeJIOBeKa»!), Hocmu;aH CBOJJlbIii: xapaRTep, npIIBJIeKaeT K
coue rrpHCTaJlblIOe BHIIMaHIIe. (:lTo 06'bHCIIHeTCH He TOJIb1W C\fH:orOJleTHIIM omII-
)J;aHIIC:\I [JOg06HOII KHIIrII, ROTopaH MOrJIa 6u CYMMIIpOBaTb HaRonIIBIIIlIeCH
RonKpeTubTe 3HalIIIH II nO BeCTII yme )J:OCTnrHYTbIe TeOpeTIJqeCI{IIe IITorII, 110
II TeM. qTO RHIIra HanIIcaHa 60JIbIIIHM KOJI.TIeKTIIBOM BeiIym;IIX cnerr;IIan:n-
CTOB -' alITpOnOJIOrOB II anaTOMOB, OHa II:lf€eT rpIIcp ::YIIIIIIICTepCTBa BbICIIIero
II cpe)J;Hero Cne IIaJIhlIOrO 06pa30BaHIIH CCCP, peKOMeH YIOm;ero ee B KaqO-
CTBe YTfe6HOrO nOCOOIIH (D;JIH CTY)J;eIITOB 6nOJIOrIIqeCRIIX cneI IIaJIbHOcTeii:
ByaOB), Y IIeo COJlIIglIbIii: 06'be:lJ - 27 rreTfaTHbIX JIIICTOB, OHa rrOCBHm;elIa na-
MHTII Kpyrmoro COBeTCKoro aHTpOnOJIOra, OJIrOJIeTHerO )J;IIpeKTopa I1HCTH-
TyTa aHTpOnOJIOrIIII Mr¥ BCeBOJIO)J;a neTpOBHTfa HKIIMOBa, CROHqaBIIIerOCH
3IIMOH 1982 r. ECTb eru;e O HO 06CTOHTeJlbCTBO, OOeCneqIIBIIIee ycnex KUIIrIl.
,lJ,oCTIDKeHIIH relIeTlIIUT 11 IIonYJIH:qlIOnHoii: <pn3I10JIOI'IIII TfOJIOBeKa Ha BpeMH
3aCJIOHIIJIII JJ:BlIfKeIIIIe MbICJIII B 06JIaCTII MopcpOJIOrIIII, II OT HOBOii: IunUII no
MOP(POJIOI'IIII qeJIOBOKa IICBOn:LHO iR)J;YT 06cym)J;eHIIH mHBOTpenem;ym;IIX IIp06-
JIOM: COOTHOIIIelIIIH MopcpOJIOrIIII II relIeTlmH, cpelIeTIIqeCRIIX Ha6JIIO eHIIH II
HX pOJIII B peKolIcTpYKl(I1II reHe3IIca nonYJIHrr;IIii:, COOTHOIIIeHIIH KOHCTIITy:qIIO-
HaJIbHhIX TIInOB C paCOBhIMII, npOHBJIeHIIH pa3HbIX cpOpM CIIMMeTpIIII B 06-
II\e:\I rIJIaHe CTpoeHIIH II B CTPYKTYPHbIX 3JIeMeHTax qeJlOBeqeCROrO Te.TIa,
CPYHR IIOHaJIbHoro IICTOJIKOBaIUfH MopcpOJIOrHTfeCKIIX oc06elIHocTeH COBpe-
MeIIHoro qeJIOBeKa, OTCYTCTByIOm;IIX Y ero rrpeD;ROB, H T. )J;. ,
KHIIra COCTOIIT II3 )J;BYX RpynlIbIx qaCTeH - 06m;eii: II qaCTlIOii: MOpcpOJIO-
rIIlI. TpaKToBKa 06m;eii: MOPIPOJIOrIIII COCTaBJIHeT TpeTb KHIIrII H BRJIIOqaeT
IIHTb rJIaB, nOCJIe)J;OBaTeJIbHO OCBOm;aIOm;IIX OCHOBlIhIe npIIII IlITbI COBpeMeH-
HbIX MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCKIIX IICCJIe OBaIIIIii:, IIpo:qeCChI pOCTa, pa3MepbI II CTPyK-
TYPHhIe 3JIeMeHTbI rOJIOBhI, pa3MepbI II npOlIop IIII TeJIa, COCTaB TeJIa II ROII-
CTHTy:qIIOHaJIblIbIe TIInu. B BOCbl\fII rJIaBaX qaCTHoii: MopcpOJIOrIIII MaTepIIaJI
opraHII30Ban no aHaTOMIIqeCROMY npIIH IIIIY - onopnO-,ZJ;BIIraTOJIblIbIII arrna-
paT, BHYTpeHHIIe opraHbI II T. )J;. MlIorIIe II3 3TIIX pa3)J;eJlOB B BbIcIIIeii: CTe-
neHII co epmaTeJIbHbI, IICnOJIb3YIOT 60JIbIlIYIO IIlIcpopMa:qHIO 0 BapIIa:qHHX CO-
OTBeTcTByIOm;IIX CIICTeM npII3HaROB H BI{JIIOTfaIOT pe3YJIbTaTbI COOCTBeHlIbIX
oplIrIIHaJiblIbIX HCCJIe)J;OBanIIH aBTopOB. 06CTOHTeJIbHYIO TpaRToBKy pa36IIpae-
MbIX BonpOCOB MOiI\IIO HalITII B rJIaBaX, nOCBHm;eHUbIX pa3Mepallf II nponop-
IIHM TeJIa, aKCeJIepa:qIIII, KoncTIITy:qIIOHaJIbHbIM ra6IITycaM. BapIIa IIHM CTPYK-
TypHbIX 3JIe:\IeHTOB CKOJIeTa, 3y6aM. B 3TIIX rJIaBaX HaJIIIqeCTByeT 3HaqIITeJIb-
HbIn MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKIIII MaTepIIaJI II COOTBeTCTBYIOII\IIII eMY IIIlIpOlUfH
\:paBIIIITeJIbIIO-:lfOPCPOJIOrIIqeCImii: nO)J;xop: H I3yqaeMbIM HBJIeH HM (KpOMe
V'aCCMOTpelInH IIOp:\IhI, npe)J;CTaBJIeH nmpOKIIH cneRTp BapIIarr;IIII, xapaKTep-
HbIii: )J;.TIH COBpel\l€IIHOrO qeJIOBeKa II ero IICKonaeMhIX npe)J;ROB, nOKaaaHa II
npIIypOqeHIIOCTb IIX R paCOBbIM, ROIICTIITY II(maJIbrrbIM II npocpeCCIIOlIaJIbHhIM
rpyrrnaM) .
II Bce iRe RHIIra B :qeJIOM pa30"<IapOBbIBaeT. JJ:eJIO He TOJlbRO B MeJIRIIX 01'-
poxax, nponYCRax II B OT)J;eJIbHbIX lIe O'IeHb y aqHhIX cpOPl\IYJII1pOBRax. TaK,
Ha c. 14 rOBopIITCH, qTO r. <D. JJ:e6err; B 1940-x rO)J;ax yCTaHOBHn: C no-
MOII\bIO IlaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX Ha6JlIO eIIIIii: paCIlIIIpCIIT1e qepena "<ICJIOBe-
Ka B XOJ],C BpeMoun, T. e., nonpocTY rOBopH, OTI{PbIJI HBJIeHIIe 6paxIIKecpaJII1-
3a IIII. Ha caMCM \eJIe r. <D. ,lJ,c6o MHoro c)J;eJIaJI )J;JIH n03HaHlIH KOHKpeT-
HUX cpOpM npOHBJIOIIIIH opanmecpaJIII3al(IIH B pa3HbIX 06JIaCTHX TeppIITopIUI
CCCP II nOl Bepr HHTopecHoii RpIITIf'IeCKOH peBII3IIII npe)J;JIOmelIHhIe panee
rIInOTe3bI npIIqIIH 6paxIIKecpaJIII3a IIII, HO caMO HBJIeuIIe o6cym)J;aJIOCb
aHTpOnOJIOraMII em;e B ROH:qe npOIlIJIOrO CTOJICTHH. Pa3 eJI 0 pa3Mepax rOJIO-
36
"*
,
l
[
t
I
.
BbI COCTOIIT cpaRTHqeCKlI JIIfllib H3 nepeqHH OCHOBlIbIX pa3MepOB, qTO l\fOiRHO
HaHTH B JII060M MeTOp;lIqeCROM PYKOBO.D:CTBe; rpaHn hI IIrea\TpynnoBoii: II3MeH-
qIIBOCTII BO MHOI'JIX C.:'IyqaHX .D:aHbI BeCb.\fa npII6JIII3IITe.'IbHO (c. 35-36, 40).
npII xapaRTepIICTIIRe MHrI>IIX Tllallen JIII:qa OTCYTCTByeT RaRaH-JIIIOO xapaR-
TepHCTIIRa cpOpMhI JIIIl(a B e,'IOM, ropIf30HTaJIbHOrO II BepTIIRaJIbHOrO JIIlD.e-
BOl'O npocpHJIH. npII paCCMOTpelIIIH lliIIpIIHhI nOqKII npIIBe)J;eH CJIe)J;YIOm;IIH ne-
peqenb (C. 202): IIerpOII)J;bI, eBponeoII)J;hI, cpII)J;a\IIII bI, aHHaMIITbI, IIH)J;IIn bI,
apa6hI (!). B nepBhIX JJ:BYX c:ryqaHX peqb IIp;eT 0 pacax, B cJIyqae cpII)J;mIIii:-
l(eB II apa60B - 06 3TIIIIqeCKIIX 06m;IIOCTHX, qTO KacaeTCH aHHaMIITOB, TO 3TO
YCTapeBlliee IIaHMenOBaHIIe Tenepb Bo06m;e He ynoTpeOJIHeTCH, TeC\f 60JIee qTO
OHO HOCI1JIO cOOIIpaTeJIbHhIH xapaKTep; c06IIpaTe,'IblIbIM H He necym;IIM HIIRa-
KOII 3THIPWCROii: IIHcpopMa:qIIH HBJIHeTCH H Tep"'fIIH «HHp;IIn:qhI».
MaRCIIMaJIbHbIii: 06'bel\f M03ra y apxalITpona yRa3aH B 1400 CM 3 II npII-
nncaH qepeny II3 (}>oHTelliBap;a (c. 264). Ha caMOM )J;eJIe 3TOT qepen, 06Ha-
pYiReHHbIH B OP;HOii: II3 4JpaH:qY3cEIIX rr em; ep, npIIHap;.lIemaJI HeaH.D:epTaJIbn;y
rrporpeCCIIBHoro TIIna, a peqb p;OJIiRHa II)J;TH 0 qepene co CTOHHIDI BepTelli-
CeJIelli B BenrpIIH. KCTaTII rOBopH, HaBepHoe, CTOIIJlO 6bI npIIBeCTH, nOMIIMO
CYMMaplIoro 06'beMa M03ra y HeaH)J;epTaJIb eB (c. 265), II D.IICPPbI )J;JIH MYiR-
qIIH II iReHm;IIH - BeJ.(b pa3HIIl(a ;:J;OCTIIraJIa 200 CM 3 .
B rJIaBe 0 nOKpoBax npH 0630pe MeTO)J;OB onpep;eJIeHIIH nIIrMeIITa IlII lIe
rOBopIITCH 0 pa3pa60TaHHhIx B IIOCJIe)J;HIIe .D:eCHTIIJIeTIIH ,ZJ;OBOJIbHO TOqlIhIX
cpII3IIqeCKIIX MeTO)J;ax xapaKTepHCTIIRII BeTHOCTII. He IIa ocb MeCTa )J;JIH
paccMoTpeHIIH MIIlIepaJIII3a:qIIII CKeJIeTa qeJIOBeKa II TpaRTOBRll Bcex CBH3aH-
HhIX C 3TIIM rrp06JIeC\f. He CRa3aHO, qTO npOOJWMa YPoBHen opraHII3a:qIIII iRII-
Bon MaTepIIII, ROTopon yp;eJIHeTCH Mecf'0 IIa nepBbIX CTpaHIIl(aX KIIIIrll
(c. 5-8), yme )J;eCHTIIJIeTlIe 06cymp;aeTcH B 8HTponOJlOrlIqeCKOn JIIITepaType.
Bce nepeqIICJIeHHOe, KOHeqIIO, p;oca)J;IIO, 110, nOBTopHIO, rJIaBHOe He B OT-
)J;eJIbHbIX ynym;eHIIHx, a B onpe)J;eJIeHHOn HanpaBJIeHHOCTII KHHrH, OTpaiRalO-
IIJ;eii: BeCbMa cBoe06pa3IIOe nOHIIMaHHe MopcpOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeRa, CBep;eHIIB ee B
3IIaqIITeJIbHoii: Mepe npOCTO K aHaTOMIIH. nOqTII BO Bcex rJIaBaX, nOCBHm;eH-
HbIX qaCTHOH MOPCPOJIOrIIII, 60JIbllie rrOJIOBIIHbI MeCTa 3aHIIMaeT aHaTOMHqe-
CRIIII MaTepIIaJI, IWTOpbIii: II3JIOmeu B cne:qIIaJIbHbIX aHaTOMIIqeCIDIX pyKO-
BO)J;CTBax II CIICTeMaTIIqHee II nOJIHee. I1Horp;a, HanpIIMep B rJIaBe 0 MbIlli:qax,
011 COnpOBOiR)J;aeTCH cepbe3HbIMII CBep;eHIIHMII cpaBHIITeJIbHO-aHaTOMIIqeCROrO
xapaRTepa, 110 3Ta qaCTb COCTaBJIHeT CRopee HCKJIIOqeHIIe, B OCTaJIbHbIX CJIY-
qaHX TaKue CBe)J;eHIIH npIIBO)J;HTCH pe)J;RO. Ha c. 5 rOBOpIITCH, qTO «MeiRp;y
TepMIIHaMII ..aHaTolluIH" II ,,1fOpcpOJIOrHH" CYIIJ;eCTByeT He TO:rbKO ceMaHTlIqe-
CRoe, 110 H CIIIhICJIOBOe pa3JIIPlIIe, IIOCKOJIbKy MOpcpOJIOI'Im BKJIIOqaeT B ce6H
aHaTOMIIIO H Bce p;pyrIIe HaYRII, II3yqaIOm;IIe opraHII3al(IIIO II pa3BHTIIe iRII-
BbIX cpOpM H CIICTel\U. .IJ:a'Ke He 06cymp;aH 3TY CPOp"'fYJIIIpOBKY no cym;ecTBY
II lIe rOBopH 0 IIaJIIPIIlII Crre IIaJIbHbIX 3a)J;aq B MopcpOJIOrnqeCKOM HCCJIep;OBa-
HIIII, He CBO)J;IIMbIX Hn K aHaTOMIIqeCRIIM, HII K cpaBHIITe:rbHo-aHaTOMIIqeCKIIM,
CJIe)J;OBaJIO omlI)J;aTb, "'ITO aHaTOl\mqeCRIIe )J;aHHbIe B COOTBeTCTBIIII C 3TOII )J;eK-
Jlapa:qIIen ,ZJ;OJIiRHbI ObI.'I1I 6bI 3aHHTb nO)J;qIIHeIIHOe nOJIOiReHlIe. MeiRp;y TeM,
RaK YiRe rOBOpIIJIOCb, BO Bcex qaCTHbIX rJlauax IIX nop;aqa BhIXO)J;IIT Ha nep-
BhIij nJiaH.
O)J;HOCTopOHHe BhIrJIH)UIT II nepeqeHb OTeqeCTBeHHbIX nCCJIe;J:OBaRHii:,
BHeClliIIX BKJIa)J; B pa3BIITIW MopcpOJIOrIIH,- cpe.n:II )J;OBOJIbHO .D:JIIIHHOrO pH)J;a
aHaTOl\fOB TaM HalliJIOCb MeCTO JIIIllib OP;HOMY aHTpOnOJIOry B. B. EYlIaKY.
3apy6emHhIe yqeHbIe Ha3bIBaIOTCH TaM iRe 60JIbllie B COOTBeTCTBHII CO CTe-
rreHbIO IIX II3BeCTIIOCTII, qeM B COOTBeTCTBIIII C I1X )J;eii:cTBIITeJIblIbIMH 3ac.lIY-
raMH B II3Y'IeIIIIJI . MopcpOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeRa. 113 nHTIf nepeqIICJIeHHbIX
A. XpJ.\JIIIqRa II It 3aJIJIep pa60TaJIII rrpeIIMYIIJ;eCTBeHRO B 06JIaCTII paCOBe,ZJ;e-
t
t
37
I
HHH, A. BaJIJIya 6bIJI Ha IIpOTHiReHHH pH)J;a )J;eCHTHJIeTIIn O)J;HHlIf 1I3 Be.D;yIIl;I1X
IfCCJIe.D:OBaTeJIeH IICKonaeMbIX cpO pM qeJIOBeKa. A rj],e II. BpoKa, n. TOIIIIHap,
R. M. B3p, K nIIpCOH, AiR. MopaHT II )J;pyrIIe RPYIIlIbIe npe,ZJ;CTaBIITeJIH aHr-
JUIncRoii: 61I0MeTplIqeCKOn rnROJIhI? HeT, IIMelIaMII aHaTOMOB, nyCTb aiRe BbI-
.n:aIOm;IIXCH, HHRaR HeJIb3H OrpaHHqIITb CIIHCOK C03JJ;aTeJIen MopcpOJIOrIIII qe-
JIOBeRa, KaK IIeJIb3H OrpalIIIqIITb HMH nO)J;06IIbIn iRe CIIIICOR yqelIbIX, pa3pa-
oaTbIBaBlliIIX npOOJIeMbI 06m;eH MopcpOJIOrIIII.
Ho II 3TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO MOiRHO eCJIII He onpaB aTb, TO IIOHHTb, yqHTbI-
BaH aHaT0ll1IIqeCRYIO Cne IIaJIII3al(HIO O.D:Horo H3 pe,ZJ;aRTopOB RHIIrH -
B. A. HIIRIITIOKa. O IIaRO COBceM yiRe He06'bHCHIIMbIM BbIrJIH)J;IIT IIOJIHOe
OTCYTCTBIIe B KHIIre pH;rra pa3)J;eJIOB, KOTophle Tpa II HOHHO II cnpaBe JIIIBO
BXO HT B MopcpOJIOrIIIO, COCTaBJIHH IIeOT'beMJIeMbIe ROMnOlIeHTbI ee CMbICJIOBO-
1'0 cOJJ:epiRaHIIH. R qIICJIY BalImelIlliIIX II3 3THX pa3)J;eJIOB CJIe yeT OTlIeCTH
paCCMOTpeHIIe 1I3MeIITIIIBOCTII, qTO )J;aBIIO yme COCTaBJIHeT cpYH)J;aMeHTaJIbIIYIO
rJIaBY He TOJIbRO cpaBIIIITeJIblIOH II norrYJIHl(IIOHHoii: IIwpcpOJIOrIIII, HO H 3BO-
JIIO IIOHHoro yqeHIIH, reHeTHKII H 6IIOMeTpHII, cO)J;epiRaTeJIbHbIH II CTaTIICTII-
qeCRIIii: alIaJIII3 RoppeJIHu;IIOIIHbIX cBH3eii:, 06eCneqIIBaIOm;IIX e HHCTBO opra-
IIII3Ma, oe3 qero JII06aH TpaKTOBRa MOpcpOJIOI'IIII Bo06m;e TepHeT CMbICJI,
HaROHe , yqeHIIe 0 CIIMMeTpIIII, CTOJIb lUHpOKO npOHIIKrnee B CaMhIe pa3HO-
06pa3HhIe OIIOJIOrIIqeCKIIe .D:IICl(IIfIJIIIHbI, B nepBYIO Oqepe b IIMeHHO B MOpcpO-
JIOrIIIO, II HeOJJ:HOKpaTIIO npIIBJIeKaBlliee YiRe BHIIMaHIIe II aHTpOnOJIOrOB.
nepeqIICJIeHHhle IIfHOII TeMbI - He CJIyqaii:HhIII IIa60p np06JIeM, OHII co-
CTaBJIHIOT caMYIO CYTb MopcpOJIOrIIII RaK HaYRlI, B TOM qIICJIe II MopcpOJIOrIIH
"IeJIOBeKa. B3aIIMOOTIIOllieHIIH MeiR)J;Y MopcpOJIOrIIen II alIaTOMIIeH qeJIOBeKa He
B TOM, qTO MopcpOJIOrHH nOrJIOIu;aeT anaTOMIIIO, KaR HBcTByeT II3 npIIBe)J;eH-
HOii: BbIllie IITaTbI co c. 5, a B TOM, qTO aHaTOMIIH II3yqaeT HOPMY, CTalI-
apTlIbIii: TIIn qeJIOBeqeCKOrO TeJIa, rrOqeMY II Ha3hIBaeTCH HOpMaJIbHOn, Tor.D:a
KaR MopcpO.:'IOrIIH IICCJIe)J;yeT cpOpMbI II 3aKOHbI II3MeHqIIBOCTII, BCIO cOBoKyn-
HOCTb BapIIal(IIii: qeJIOBeqeCKOro TeJIa B CPYII IIOHaJIbHhIX, reorpacplIqeCKHX II
BpeMeHHJ';ix npOHBJIeIIIIHX. II03TOMY HeT MopcpOJIOrIIII TaM, r)J;e HeT rrOHHTIIH 0
3aKOlIOMepHOCTHX 3Ton II3MelIqIIBOCTH B pa3HbIX CHCTeMax qeJIOBeqeCROrO op-
raHII3Ma, r e He oxapaRTepII30BaHbI pa3HhIe rpyrrnbI IIJIII TIInbI npH3HaKOB,
He npIIBO.D:HTCH MHoro06pa3HbIe cnoc06bI IIX KOJIIIqeCTBeHHon xapaRTepHCTII-
RII. Bce nepeqIICJIeHHble B HaqaJIe 3Toro OqepRa RHIIrII J];aBaJIH 06 3TOM 60-
JIee HJIII MeHee nO.D:p06HOe rrpe CTaBJIeHIIe. A CeHqaC 06CTOHTeJIblIaH TpaRTOB-
Ka Bcex 3TIIX BonpOCOB 6bIJIa 6bI oc06eHHo YMeCTHa If B CBH3II C ocpopMJIeHII-
eM nonYJIHl(IIOHlIoii: MopcpOJIOrIfII, II B CBH3II C pa3BIITIIeM relIeTHKH, KCTaTII
CKa3aTb BO MHorOM 06H3aHHbIX CBOIIMII YCIIexaMH HMeHHO COBeTCKIIM IICCJIe-
)J;OBaTeJIHM. nOnYJIH:qIIOHlIaH MopcpOJIOrIIH II aHTponorelIeTIIKa HaCqIIThlBaIOT
YiRe HeCKOJIbRO TbICHq ny6JIIIKa:qIIii:, II3yqeHHIO xapaKTepa H3MelIqIIBOCTH
lIfHorHX npII3HaKOB nOCBHm;eHO e)J;Ba JIH MeHbllie pa60T, II TaKOH orpOMHbIH:
6araiR 3HalIIIH OCTaeTCH B CTopOHe, eCJIII He II3JIaraTb yqeHlIe 06 II3MeHqIIBO-
CTII B Rypce MopcpOJIOrHII qeJIOBeRa!
He MeHee BaiRlIO II He MeHee 06CTOHTeJIbHO pa3pa60TaHO B MopcpOJIOrIIII
qeJIOBeKa II yqeHIIe 0 KOppeJIH IIHX npII3HaKOB, T. e. 0 B3aIIMOCBH3II OT)J;eJIb-
HbIX opraHOB II CIICTeM, a TaKllW xapaRTepII3yIOm;HX IIX napaMeTpOB MeiR)J;y
C0601I, 0 cne HcpIIKe 3TOii: CBH3II, ee CPYH IIOlIaJIbIIOM 3HaqeHHII H CTeneHII
ee o:qeHRII. npIIIIl(IIII KOppeJIHl(IIII opraHOB, YCTalIOBJIeHHbIn BnepBbIe B cpop-
MYJIIIpOBRe, 6JIII3ROn K COBpeMeHHOH m. RIOBbe, pa3pa6aTbIBaJICH 3aTeM MIIO-
rIIMII MopcpOJIOraMII; ero IICKJIIOqIITeJIbHOe 3HaqeHIIe RaK Mom;Horo cpe)J;CTBa
cpaBHIITe.:'IbIIO-lIfOpcpOJIOrlIqeCROrO II 3BOJIIO:qIIOIIHoro alIaJIlI3a HpRO npO)J;eMOH-
CTpIIpOBaHO B KJIaCCIIqeCKlIX TpY)J;ax A. H. CeBep:qOBa H II. II. illMaJIbraY3e-
Ha. Cnoc06bI KOJIIlqeCTBeHHoii: o eHKH, OCHOBbI ROTOpOH 6hIJIII 3aJIOiReHbI
38
I
r
"
cppaH Y3CKIIM MIIHepaJIOrOM O. EpaBe H aHrJIII'HCKHM MaTeMaTIIKOM II 6HO-
JIOrOM It nIIpCOHOM, cpa3Y iRe 6bIJIH IIIIIpOKO IICnOJIb30BaHbI B aHTpOnOJIO-
rIIII; II IIMelIHO aHHbIe 0 BeJIIIqIIHaX R03cpcpH lIeHToB ROppeJIHl(IIH Mem y
npII3HaKaMII B pa3H006pa3IIhIX qeJIOBeqeCRIIX IIonYJIH IIHX IIOCJIymIIJIII OCIIO-
Bon .D:JIH IIcpcpepeHl(IIpOBaHHoro IIO XO)J;a R nOIIIIMaHIIIO BHYTPIIBII)J;OBbIX KOp-
peJIH HII II BII.D:OBOll II3MeHqIIBOCTII COBpeMeHHoro qeJIOBeRa B l(eJIOllf. no
CYTII )J;eJIa, eCJIII He JJ:aBaTb aHaJIII3 KOppeJIHTIIBHOn II3MelIqIIBOCTII, yqeHIIe 0
KOIICTIITY:qlIOHHbIX ra6IITYCax TaKme OCTaeTCH 6e3 OIIOpHhIX IIOIIHTIIn. O)J;HHlIf
CJIOBOM, He CRa3aTb 0 KOppeJIH IIHX - 3HaqIIT He CKa3aTb 06 O HOM II3 l(eHT-
paJIbHhIX HBJIeHIIll, II3yqaeMbIX 06m;en MopcpOJIOrIIen, H cepbe3HO 06eJJ:HIITb
H3JIOmeHIIe MopcpOJIOrIIH 'IeJIOBeKa.
Pa3pa60TKa IIp06JIeM 6HOJIOrIIqeCKOH CIIMMeTpIIII HaXO)J;IITCH B HaCTOHm;ee
BpeMH Ha IIO 'beMe. RaK II Bcer)J;a B TaRIIX CJIyqaHX, B30pbI 06pam;aIOTcH R
IICTOpIIII HaYKH H BCIIOMIIlIaIOTCH pa60TbI, 3a6bITbIe IIJIII MaJIO 06paII{aBIIIIIe
Ha ce6H BHIIMaHIIe MlIorHe )J;eCHTIIJIeTIIH. Ho He MeHee IIHTelICIIBHO ocym;ecT-
BJIHeTCH II BbI)J;BIIiReIIIIe HOBbIX IIpIIHl(IInOB. COBceM He.D:aBHO IIpIIMeHIITeJIbHO
R 3BOJIIOl(IIII 6HOJIOrHqeCKIIX 06'beInOB 06cym)J;aJIIICb IIpIIH:qIIIIbI KOlIcpOpMHOH
cIIMMeTpIIII II IIpIIBe,ZJ;eHbI )J;ocTaTOqHO y6e)J;HTeJIbHhIe ,ZJ;aHHbIe, CBH.D:eTeJIbCT-
BYIOm;IIe 0 ee 3HaqIITeJIbHOll pOJIII B MopcpOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeKa 5. MOiRHO IIOKa
BbImII.D:aTeJIbHO OTHOCIITbCH R pe3YJIbTaTaM 3THX HOBenmIIx IICCJIe OBaHIIH,
HO Be b 6IIJIaTepaJIbHaH cIIMMeTpIIH II3BeCTHa )J;aBHo, ee pOJIb oCBem;eHa BO
MHorIIX pa60Tax, yme CTaBIIIIIX KJIaCCIIqeCKIIMII, lIfHoro nlICaJIOCb 06 H3MeHe-
HIIH xapaRTepa 6IIJIaTepaJIbHOII CIIMMeTpIIII IIPII nepeXO.D:e K npHMOXOiR eIIIIIO
H Bo06m;e B IIpOl(eCCe cpOpMIIpoBaHIIIIH IIO)J;JIIIHIIO qeJIOBeqeCKOn opraHII3a HH
B xo e aHTpOIIoreHe3a. R COmaJIeHIIIO, II 3TOT KOMIIJIeKC BonpOCOB OCTaJICa
6e3 KaKOrO-JIII60 OCBem;eHIIH.
A 06cYiR eHIIe reHeTIIqeCRIIX OCHOB MopcpOJIOrHH? A aHaJIII3 COOTHome-
IIIIH MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKHX II CPYIIR:qIIoHaJIbHhIX IIJIII CPII3IIOJIOrHqeCKIIX oc06eH-
HOCTeH qeJIOBeqeCKOrO opraHII3Ma? A paCCMOTpeHlIe cpaKTopoB MopcporeHe3a
B l(eJIollf? A CIIHTeTIIqeCRIIn 0630p MopCPOJIOrIIqeCKIIX aCIIeRTOB CTapeHIIH q -
JIOBeKa? 060 BceM 3TOM TaKme HeT HII O.D:HOrO CJIOBa. BII IIMO, pe)J;aKTOplaI
KIIIIrII (a, OqeBII)J;HO, HMeHHO OHII HBJIHIOTCH aBTopaMII npe IICJIOBIIH R Hen)
rrpem.D:eBpeMeHHO IIa3BaJIII ee «nepBbIM B CCCP noc06IIellf no TeOpeTHqeCROH
lIfopcpOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeRa». RHIIra 3Ta JIIIIIIeHa BHYTpeHHero e)J;HHCTBa II He
OXBaThlBaeT 06mIIpHoro Kpyra BonpOCOB, 3aHBJIeHIIOrO B Ha3BaHIIII. OHa
IIpe)J;CTaBJIHeT C060H cKopee II36palIIIhIe rJIaBbI aHaTOMIIII qeJIOBeKa, C 3JIe-
MeHTaMII cpaBHIITeJIbHOll aHaTOMHH II aHTpOIIOJIOrHII. nO.D:JIHHHaH «MopcpOJIO-
rIIH "IeJIOBeKa» e e OJImHa 6bITb BanIIcalIa.
,
-l.'
".;
t Moplf!oJlorlIH '1eJloBeRa/IIoA peA. E. A. HIIRIITIORa, B. II. 'lITe:I(OBa. M., 1983.
2 BY1ian B. B., HecTpyx M. (})., P02111iCnUU H. H. AHTpOllOJlOrIlH. M., 1941. Pa3,I1eJI, no-
cBH eBBbIH MopIf!OJlOrlIlI, HalllIcaB B. B. EynaRoM.
II Bynan B. B. AHTpolloMeTplIH: (IIpaRTH'lecRIIH RYPC). M., 1941.
i Poeuncnuu H. H., JIeBun M. r. OCHOBbI aBTpOllOJlOrlIlI. M., 1955; Onu 31Ce. ABTPOIIOJlo-
rlIH. M., 1963; 01iU 31Ce. AHTpOllOJlOrIIH. M., 1978.
5 lIeTyzoB C. B. EIIOMeXaHlIRa, 6IIOBIIRa II cIIMMeTpIIH. M., 1981.
fEHETllqECRllE ACllERTbl AHTPOllO OrllM
npOMemYTOqHOe nOJIOiReHIIe alITpOnOJIOrlIII MeiR,ZJ;y )J;Hc:qHnJIIIHaMII ryMaHII-
TapHoro II 61I0JIOrH'IeCROrO l(IIKJIOB, np030pJIIIBO 01'MeqeHHOe em;-e B npoIlI-
JIOM BeKe .p. GHreJIbCOM, CTaHOBIITCH Bce 60JIee OqeBII)J;HbIM no Mepe pa3BH-
TIIH HaYRII. C O,'J;Hon CTOpOHbI, aHTpOnOJIOrHH Ha npOTHiReHIIII Hallero
CTOJIeTHH OpraHlIqeCIDI BKJIIOqlIJIa B ceOH lIfeTO)J;IIRII II pe3YJIbTRTbI HCCJIe)J;O-
BaHIIn MlIorlIX OHOJIOrIIqeCKIIX 06JIaCTell 3IIaHIIH. 1I3ocepoJIorHH, IIanpIIMep,
T. e. II3yqeHIIe rpynnoBbIX cpaKTopOB KpOBII, cpa3Y iRe nOCJIe CBoero B03HIIK-
HOBeHIIH If pa3pa60TRlI COOTBeTCTBYIOm;eII lIIeTOp;IIKH 3aHHJIa orpOlvHIOe lIIeCTO
B aHTpOnOJIOrnqeCKOll HaYKe, II CeHqaC YiRe lIlOiRlIO CRa3aTb, qTO aHTpOnOJIO-
rII BHeCJIn, nml\aJIyH, 66JIbrnlIH BRJIa,ZJ; B IICCJIe;:t;OBaHHe BapHa:qUII rpynnoBbIX
cpaKTopOB KpOBII no 3eMHOMY llapy, qeM Me,ZJ;IIRII. IIonymIl(IIOIIIIO-relIeTIIqe-
cRlIe MeTO)J;hI II nOAX0.D:bI npH06peJIII cpYH)J;al\IeHTRJIbIIOe 3HaqelIIIe BO Bcex
aIITpOnOJIOrlIqeCKIIX: pa60Tax, cym;ecTBeHHO TpaHccpopMHpOBa.lIU TeopIIIO alIT-
pOnOJIOrIIqeCKOH HaYRII, H 6€3 TaKHX nO.D:XO)J;OB HeB03MomHO CeHqaC npe,ZJ;-
CTaBIITb ce6e pa3pa60TRY np06JIeM CPII3IIOJIOrHqeCROn aHTpOnOJIOrI1lI, paCOBOH
RJIaCCIIcpIIRa IIII IeJIOBeqeCTBa II T. )J;. Bce 3TO MOCTbI, CBH3hlBaIOm;IIe alITpo-
nOJIOrlIIO C 06llHpHbIM ROMnJIeKCOM 6IIOJIOrIIqeCRlIX p;lIc:qHnJIIIH.
C p;pyroH CTOpOIlbI, O)J;HaRO, qeM rJIy6me pa3pa6aTbIBaeTCH 6IIOJIOrIIqeCRaH
IICTOpIIH Homo II Bxop;Hm;ero B Hero BII.D:a COBpeMeHlIoro qeJIOBeRa, TeM HC-
IIee CTaHOBIITCH OrpaIIIIqeHIIOCTb qIICTO 6HOJIOrIIqeCKOrO nO;:t;xo)J;a KO Bcellf,
)J;aiRe 6IIOJIOrnqeCKIIM, HBJIeHIIHM B I€JIOBeqeCKOllf 06m;eCTBe II He06xo;rrIIMOCTb
nOCTOHlIlIoro yqeTa COl(IIaJIbHOll npupO)J;bI qeJIOBeRa }J:aiRe B Cnel(HaJIbHbIX
MopcpOJIOrIIqeCRIIX II cpII3IIOJIOI'IIqeCRHX IICCJIe)J;OBalInHx. HURaROH )J;HHaMII-
qeCKIIH acneKT 6IIOJIOl'1I1I qellOBeKa HeB03MomHO nOlUITb II IICTOJIKORaTb, He
yqHTbIBaH TaRIIX cpYH;:t;aMeIITaJIblIbIX CBonCTB qeJIOBeqeCTBa, KaR ero pacce-
JIenHe no BceH 3eMHOll nOBepXIIOCTII, HaJIIIqIIe BHYTPII 06m;eCTBa CO IIaJIbHbIX
6apbepOB B BIIp;e H3blEa, 3THIIqeCRlIX rpalIII:q II p;pyrIIx JJ:IIcpcpepeHl(IIpYIOIU;IIX
cpaKTopOB. Tpyp:OBaH ,n:eHTeJIbHOCTb qeJIOBeRa II T. )J;. TaRIIM 06pa30M, CO:qII-
aJIbHbIii:, ITJIH, KaR CelIqaC npIIHHTO qam;e nIIcaTb, COl(IIOJIOl'IIqeCIUIH, no.D:xOP;
)J;OJIiReH npOHH3bIBa Tb JII060e IICCJIe,ZJ;OBaHlIe no 6UOJIOrlIH qeJIOBeKa, eCJIII
TOJIbRO OHO CTaBIIT cBoeii: eJIblO He npOCTYIO KOHCTaTal(IIIO cpaRTOB, a IIX
)J;IIHaMIIqeCEOe IICTOJIROBaIIHe.
B 06m;e1I cpopMe Heo6xo)J;IIMOCTb TaKoro nO.D:xo)J;a HOO.D:IIORpaTHO II COBep-
lleHno cnpaBe)J;JIlIBO nOCTYJIHpOBaJIaCb BO lIfHorIIX pa60Tax. COBeTCKlIe aHTpo-
nOJIOrIf nOCJIep:OBaTeJIbHO ocym;eCTBJIHIOT ero B CBOIIX IICCJIe)J;OBaHIIHX, He-
CMOTpH Ha TO qTO KOImpeTHoe npOCJIeiRIIBaHHe B03)J;eHCTBIIH COl(lIaJIblIbIX
3aROHOB Ha cpOpMIIpOBaHIIe 6IIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX CBonCTB qeJIOBeKa conpHmelIO co
MHorIIMII II TeOpeTIIqeCRIIlIfII II npaKTHqeCKIIMH TPY)J;HOCTHMII. B TO iRe BpeMH
IIHKaKOII Tm;aTeJIbHhIH II rJIy60KHii aHaJIII3 3THIIqeCKIIX B3alIMooTHollelIIIH
Hen031110iReH 6e3 yqeTa pacoBoII cIITya:qIIII, HIIKaRoe IICCJIe.D:OBaHIIe no 3THO-
reue3Y II 3THIIqOClWn IICTopnIl He MOiReT 6hITb nO-HaCTOHm;eMY ROMnJIeKClIbIM
II Bce06'beMJIIOm;IIM 683 npnB.lIeqelIIUI alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIX )J;auHbIx, T. e.
B KOII-eqUOM CqeTe )J;aIIHbIx 0 6IIOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeRa. B Kpyrax lIeCne IIaJIIICTOB
pa3p;aIOTCH nlIol')J;a l'OJIOca 0 B03MOiRHOCTII II3MeIIelIHH 6HOJIOl'IIqeCllIIX CBOllCTB
qeJIOBeqeCRHX nonYJIHn;nii: 3a o)J;IIO- )J;Ba nOROJIeIIIIH, qTO HR06bI JIIIllaeT aIIT-
ponOJIOl'nqeCEIIe lJ,aHHhle IIX npemllero 3IIaqeHIIH. HIIme c.D:eJIaua nonbITKa
nORa3aTb, qTO 1I3yqaeMhIe aIITpOnOJIOraMII MOpcpOJIOI'IIqeCKIIe II cpII31I0JIOl'IIqe-
CRIIe oc06eHHOCTII reHeTIIqeCRII 06YCJIOBJIeHbI, qTO 6IIOJIOrIIQeCKIIe CBOllcTBa
nonYJIH HII TeCIIO nepenJIeTaIOTCH co MlIorIIMII acneKTaMII HX iRII3HII, qTO
pe3YJIbTaTbI IICCJIeJJ;OBaIIHll B 06JIacTII 6IIOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeRa 060ram;aIOT Kap-
TIIIIY qeJIOBeqeCROII nCTopIIII.
40
--
"tJEJlOBEK KAR llPE)J;MET rEHETH"tJECKOrO 113Y"tJEHIUI
OrpOMHbIe ycnexII relIeTIIRII B IIaCTOHm;ee BpeMH CBH3alIbI B OCIIOBIIOM e
II3yqelIIIeM relIeTIIqeCKHX MeXaIIII3;\lOB BUpYCOB H 6aKTepIIn. IhIelIlIO reHe-
TIIKa BIIPYCOB, B qaCTUOCTII 6aKTepIIocpara, ,ZJ;aJIa OCHOBHOii: ?IIaTepUaJI )J,JIH
pacrnIIcppOllKII relIeUIqeCROrO KO,ll,a, a pa60Tbl C. EelI3epa IIa 6aKTepIIocpare
OTKpbIJIII nYTb K ;cmcnepUMelITaJIbHOMY p;ORa3aTeJIbCTBY C.:'IOiKIIOII npIIpO)J,bI
rena i. T cneXII MOJIeKYJIHplIOII relIeTIIRII OKa3aJIII BJIIIHIIIIC IIa reHeTHKY
mIIBOTlIbIX II paCTeHHll, 3naqUTeJIblI0 II3MelIHJIII eCJIII He nYTb IICCJIe,ZJ;OBaIIIIH,
TO BO BCHKOM CJIyqae rrOHIIMalIIIe MuorIIX np06JIeM - Hac,;w)J;oBaIIIIR I-IOpMbI
peaRl(IIII, HaCJIe,ZJ;cTBeHlIoro IIMMYHIITeTa II T. ,ZJ;. .ltfeJIOBeR KaK relIeTHqeCRHH
06'beKT TaRiRe UMeeT CBOIO cnel(ucpmry, BbIpamaIOm;YIOCH KaR B !vWpcpOJIO-
rIIqeCKIIX II cpII31I0JIOI'lI'IeCKIIX oc06elIHocTHX qeJIOBeqeCKOrO opraIlH3Ma, TaR
II B CTenelIIl ero II3yqeIIHOCTlI.
nOCJIe,ll,IIee 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, XOTR II npe)J,CTallJIHCTCH IIa nepBbIH B3rJIH,ZJ;
BTopOCTeneHlIbIM, II?lleeT npUMelIIITeJIbrro K 06m;eii relIeTIIRe orpoMlIoe 3IIa-
qelIue. BpHp: JIll IIaH;:reTcR em;e O)J,HII BIrr(, II3MeHqIIBOCTh ROToporo 6hIJIa 6bI
II3yqelIa C TaRoII nO.llHOToii: II Tm;a TeJIhIIOCTbIO. 8Rcnep,H:qIIu aIITpOnOJIOrOB,
npoBe)J,elIlI.bIe IIa npoTHllieHIlIl nOCJIe,ll,IIIIX 50-70 JIeT BO Bce yrOJIKII 3eMIIO-
1'0 illapa, C06paJIII orpOMlIhIe lIfaTepIIaJIhI no reorpacpnqeCKOH II3MelIqIIBOCTH
MopcpOJIOrnqeCRIlX npH3IIaIWB qeJIOBBKa, n03BOJIIIJIH BbI,ZJ;eJIIITb IIX reorpacpH-
qeCKHe COqeTaIUIH - qeJIOBeqeCI{IIe paChI, ,ZJ;aJIH B03MomlIOCTb naMeTIITh II B
06m;IIX qepTaX peillIITb np06JIeMbI HX IIepapXIIII II relIeaJIOrHqeCRHX B3aHMO-
OTlIoilleHIIii: 2. 3a nOCJIe,];HlIe 30 JIeT rnupOKO pa3BeplIYJIOCb II3Y'IClIue pacoBoii:
cpu3IIOJIOrIIII, nOKa3aBIIIee OT'leTJIIIBbIe npaBnJlhlIOCTII B reorpacpIIqeCROllf
pacnpOCTpalIenUII MlIorIIX CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX npII3IIaKOB 3. HapH,ll,Y C <lTIIM B
alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX IICCJIe)10BaHHHX, KaK H B Me,ll,IIl(IIIICRIIX II cpII3IIOJIOrnqe-
CRIIX. npnCTaJIblIOe BIIIIMalIIIe y;reJIHJIOCb U y;o:eJIHeTCH np06JIeMe KOIICTIfTY-
l(IIOlIaJIbHhIX pa3JIII'llIn II IIX CBH3II C TIInaMII BhIcilleii: IIepBuOH )J,eHTeJIhIIO-
CTII . B 06m;eH cpopllle <ITa np06JIeMa, nO-BII)1IIMOMY, TOJIbKO II 1II0meT 6hITb
?eillella alITpono.1l0raMH II Me,ZJ;IIRaMII, TaR KaR Y qeJIOBeRa THnbI IIepBHhIX
peaKl(IIii: H nCIIXOlIepBHhIe MexaHH3MhI II3yqelIbI rOpa3T(0 60JIee )1eTaJIbIIO,
1:JeM Y mIIBOTlIbIX.
BOJIbillOe qIICJIO naJIeOnTOJIOrIIqeCRIIX IIaXO,ll,OK n03BOJIHeT napIICOBaTh B
OOm;IIX qepTaX KapTIIIIY H3MelIeHlUf cpII3IIqeCKOrO TIilla qeJIOBeKa BO BpeMe-
IIII 5. CpaBHIITe:lbuo-alIaTOI\IIIqeCRIIe II 8M6pIIOJIOrnqeCRIIe IICCJIe)10BaHHH
OTKpbIJIII B03MOlliIlOCTb YCTalIOBJIeHIIR MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCKIIX 3aKOUOMeplIOCTeii
ero <lBOJIIOI(II1I 6. C nOMOm;hIO II3yqelIIIH ;J:peBlIeHrnIIX OPY.D:UH TpY,ZJ;a II iRH3HI1
)1peBIIIIX JlIO)1eH BOCCTalIaBJIIIBaIOTCH OCHOBlIhIe <lTanhI pa3BIITIIH COl(IIaJIbIIOH
opran-Haal(IIH nepB06hITIIbIX qeJIOBeqeCKHX KOJIJIeKTIIBOB, IIX 3KOlIOMIIqeCKIIe
II 3TIIlIqeCRIIe B3aIIMOOTlIorneHIIH, pOCT UX qHCJleHHOCTII, xapaRTep paCceJIe-
HHR. pOJIb CMerneH;uH B <lTIIX npoI(eCcax 7. TaKIIM 06pa30M, II IICTOpIIH qe-
JIOBeqeCROrO BH,'Ja, TaR iRe KaR II ero reorpacpIfH II MopcpOJIOrIIH, H3yqelIa
JIyqrne, qeM HCTOpIIH JlI060ro BII)1a 1KIIBOTlIhIX.
TaKaH nOJIlIaH IIIIcpopllfaU;UH 0 TIInax II3MenqIIBOCTH qeJIOBeRa, I1X pacnpe-
p;e.;IeUlIII BO Bpe!vreJ I1 II B npOCTpaHCTBe, a qaCTIIqlIO II 0 npHqHlIaX 3THX
II3MeneHIIll C03;IaeT OCHOBY ,ZJ;JIH I13yqelIIIH lIIIIOrIIX relIeUI'IeCKIIX np06JIellf Ha
60JIBe BblCOROIlI ypOBlIe, qellf <lTO B03MomlI0 B relIeTIIR8 mHBOTHbIX. H' HX
qUCJIY OTIIOCHTCH IIaCJIe)1CTBelIlIbIe IIapymelIIIH MeTa60JIII3Ma, XpOMOCOMIlbIe
8IIOl\IaJIIIII II a6eppal(IIH, re1l>IOrJIOOUIIonaTIIII II IIaCJIe)1CTEeHlIbIe IIapYillelIIIR
CBepThmaHIIH RpOllII. 6eJIKOB H cpeplllelITOB nJIa3MhI (Bce 3TO Ha YPOBHe
opralIII3Ma) 8, 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTII B reorpacpIIqeCROllf pacnpOCTpaHelIHII relIOB
(relIoreorpaqmR) 9, pOJIb II30JIHl(IIIf B IfIITelICHBHOCTII relIeTImO-aB TOMa TIIqe-
?c
."
.i
41
CKIIX npOl(eCCOB, OTHOCIITeJIbHaH pOJIb nalIMHKCIIII H H30JIRl(IIII B npo:qeccax
paC006pa30Ba1IIIH, CKOpOCTL" MYTIIpOBalIIIH (BCe 3TO Ha nOnYJIHl(IIOIIIIOM
YPOBlIe) 10. n03TOMY aIITpOnOJIOrII IeCKIIH II alITponorelIeTII IeCRIIH MaTepIIa-
JIbI Bce 'Iam;e BKJIIO IaIOTCH B CBO)1KII no 06m;eH reneTHKe H npe)1CTaBJIHIOT
COOOH OCHOBHbIe )1alIHbIe P;JIH aHaJIII3a H pemelIIIH l(eJIoro pH)1a Kap)1IIlIaJIb-
HbIX BonpocoB 11 .
Tenepb HeCKo.lIbKO CJIOB 0 Ka'IeCTBenlIoH CneIwcpIIRe RaR 06'beKTe reHeTH-
"'IeCKOrO II3Y'IeIIIIH. Olla JIemIIT B era COl(IIaJIbIIOii npIIpo)1e. C nOHBJIelIIIeM
06m;eCTBa II pa3B1fTIIeM COl(I1aJIbHhIX oTlIornelIHH B 6HOJIOrH'IeCRHe 3aKOHO-
MeplIocTH BMernHBaIOTCH IIOBbIe TpaHccpopMIIpYIOm;IIe I1X MOMelITbI 12. B HX
qIICJIe - OCBoeHIIe npaKTII'IeCRII BceH nJIalIeThI 1\ HeOrpaHH'IelIHOe CMerne-
HHe MeiR,ZJ;Y pacaMH H CTHpalIHe rpalIJf:q paCOBbIX apeaJIOB, B3aIIMonpOIIIIKII0-
BeHIIe II B3aIIMOBJIIIHHIIe RyJIbTYP, YCIIJIelIIIe TeXIIIIqeCROH OClIam;eHIIOCTH,
OTRphIBaIOm;ee neorpalIIIqelIlIhIe B03MO}I{IIOCTH IIIrpal(IIII reHOB, - O)1HHM CJIO-
BOM, Bce rrpe)1II, OCbIJIKH C03.D:aIOm;IIe cHTya:qIIIO nalIMHKCIIH 11,. IIpIl IIeH
npOCJIeiRHBaIOTCR nYTII lIiUrpal(IIH relIOB Ha orpOMlIhIe paCCTOHHIIH, H3Y'IaIOT-
CR IIX cTa6IIJlblIOCTb II II3MelIelIIIe TeMna MYTllpOBaHIIH npII MHl'pa:qHII, BhI-
HBJIHIOTCH Oqal'II IIaH60JIee HHTeHCHBlIbIX ROHl(eHTpal(IIH relIOB H xapaKTep
B3aIIMoCBH3II MeiRL\Y HIIIIIII, nepeKII)1bIBaeTCH, TaRIIM 06pa30M, MOCT MeiR)J;Y
l'elIenrKoii:. C O)1IIOH CTOpOlIhI, CIICTeMaTIIROH H TaKCOlIoMIIeii: - C )1PYI'OH.
8II;:{Ol'aMIUI, B3aIlMOOTTaJIRIIBaUIIe IIap0)10B, rOBopHm;HX IIa pa3IIhIX H3hIKax,
1I oco6elIHO IIa H3bIKax pa3JIHqlIhIX H3bIKOBhIX ceMeH, RaCTOBbIe CHCTeMhI,
HMym;ecTBelIlIaH )1IIcpcpepeHl(Hal(IIH, npHIIa)1JIeiRHOCTb IX pa3IIbIM pe.llIIrIIHM
)1elIcTByroT B npOTHBOnOJIOiRlIOM HanpaBJIelIIIH - C03)1aIOT TaR Ha3hIBaeMYIO
COl(IfaJIbHYIO I130.TIH I1IO 15. Cnel(HcpHRa ee COCTOIIT B TOM, 'ITO olla 3UaqHTeJIb-
HO pacrnIIpHeT 6a3Y ,ZJ;JIH CYIKL\eIIHR 0 MO)J;eJIHX reHeTH'IeCRIIX 6aphepOB, ,ll,II-
IIaMIIKe I1X p;eHCTBHR BO BpeMelIH, cpopMax HX BJIIIHHIIH IIa l'eHBTHqeCRYIO
CTPYKTYPY nony.TIHl(IIII. TaRIIM 06pa30M, Bce acneRTbI nonYJIH:qHOIIHOH I'ene-
TIIKH cym;ecTBenlIO 060I'am;aIOTCH )1HIIHhIMII, nOJIyqeHlIhI II1 B ," a TpOnOJIOrH-
qeCKHX H alITponoreHeTIIqeCKUX IfCCJIe.n:OBaIIIIHX.
l'lTaR, Cnel(HcplIRa qeJIOBeKa B RaqeCTBe l'eneTHqeCKOrO 06'heRTa C{)CTOIlT
B ero COl(IIaJIbIIOCTII, npe)1CTaBJIHIOm;eM C060H npe,ll,nOChIJIKY )1JIH B03HHKHO-
BelIIIH MHorIIX l'elIeTIIqeCRif.X: HBJIelIIIII Ha norryJIH I10IIIIOM YPoBHe, H B nOJI-
110M I13YQeIIIIOCTH TIIIIOB H3MelIqHBOCTII qeJIOBeqeCROI'O Opl'aHH3l1fa, 'ITO no-
3BOJIHeT )J;eTaJIH3IIpOBaTb l'elIeTIIqeCKIIe npol(eCCbI, B 06m;eH cpopMe H3yqelI-
HhIe Ha )1pyrIIX 06'beKTax.
3HA'IEHIfE AHTPOnOJIOflI'IECKHX ,D;AHHbIX
,D;JlH rEHETlI'IECKHX IICCJlE,D;OBAHIlII
0110 oc06eHno qeTRO npOHBJIHeTCH B IICCJIe)10BaIIIIRX norryJIHI(IIOIIIIO-l'eHeTII-
qeCKOrO xapaKTepa, n03TOMY C IIIIX l(eJIeCOOOpa3IIO II HaqaTh. AHTpOnO.:'IOrHH
BIIOCIIT oc06elIIIo cym;ecTBelIlIbIii: BKJIa;:J; B 06m;yIO relIeTIIKY nonYJIH lIii: no
nHTII JIIIIIIIHM: npIIpO)1hI l'elIlIbIX 6apbepoB, CTPYRTYPhI H30JIIIpOBalIIIbIx 110-
nYJIHu;nH. qHCJIeUHOCTII nonYJIHl(HH B CBH3I1 C HX l'elIeTnqeCKOH CTPYRTYPOH,
xapaKTepa H CTeIIeHII BHYTPHBII)10BhIX pa3JIHquH, I13yqeHHH reorpacpHH relIOB
B YCJIOBHRX naIIMIIRcIIH, T. e. nalIoHKYMelIlIOI'O ClIfemeHHH.
B OpralInqeCROM MIIpe Bce l'elIeTHqeCmIe 6apbephI, T. e. npeIIHTcTBYIOIIXHe
cKpem;IIBaHIfIO II TeM callfhIM pacnpocTpalIelIIIIO 1'8IIOB <paKTopbI, HMeIOT reo-
rpacpIIq.JCI{YIO IIJIII CPII3IIOJIOl'UqecRYIO npIlpo,ll,Y. HlIbIMM CJIOnaMH, 3TO JIH60
KaKOe-IIH6Y)1b Cepbe3IIOe l'eorpacpIIqeCROe npenHTcTBIIe, MemaIOm;ee" TaKCOIIY
paCCeJIHTbCH, IIJIJI cBoeo6pa3HaH 3ROJIOl'IIqeCKaH IIIIma. onHTb CBO,ll,HMaH R
Onpe)18JIeIIHOH Cnel(ncpIlK8 reol'pacpHqeCKOH Cpe)1bI, JIII60 pa3HIIl(a B cTpoelIHH
42
r
;.
:tI CPYIIK:qHOIIIIpOBaIIHII penpO,ll,YRTHBIIOH CHCTeMbI j6. Y qeJIOBeKa 3IIaqelIHe
BTOpOrO cpaKTOpa paBHO HYJIIO, a 3IIaqeHIIe nepBoro CIIJIblIO CIIHiReHO H3-3a
npaRTIIqeCRH nOqTH 6e3rpaHIIqlIOH crrOC06IIOCTH npe0)10JIeBaTb reorpacpHqe-
CKHe 6apbephI )J;alKe IIa paIIl-IIIX CTa,ZJ;HHX pa3BIITHH 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa (1KII3IIb B
Tu6eTe II AII)1ax IIa BhICOTe 60JIee qeM 4000 lIf, 3aCeJIelIHe ApKTHKH H nyc-
ThIIIb, paCCeJIelIIIe qeJIOBeqeCTBa 110 OCTpOBaM THxoro oKealIa).
TeM 60JIblliYIO pOJIb npH06pemr cpaKTopbI, ROTOpbIe 06'be)1HHHIOTCH no-
IIHTHeM COl(I1aJIbIIOH I130JIHl(I1I1. 8TO npe1K,ZJ;e Bcero onpe.o:eJIelIHhIe COl(I1aJIb-
HhIe OTlIornelIIIH, npOHBJIHIOm;I1eCH B co6cTBelIIIo 8II,ll,OraMIIIf, T. e. B 06h1qae
3aKJIIOqaTb 6paKII BIIYTPH O)1HOrO CeJIelIIIH I1JIII rpynnbI CeJIeIIIIH I1JIII, IIaKO-
He:q, BUYTPII onpe)J,eJIelIlIhIX 06m;ecTBeIIlIhIx rpynn; B KaCTOBOM CTpoe, KaK,
HarrpIlMep, B MII)1I1II, r)1e Bee 06m;eCTBO pa3)1eJIelI0 IIa KaCTbI, lIe 6paqyIO-
m;I1eCH Melli)1Y c060ii:; B IIMym;ecTBeIIHoH )J,HcpcpepelI:qIIa:qHII, npH KOTOpOH
8IIp;OraMIIH 6hwa Mellee cTporoii, qeM B npe,ll,rnecTBYIOm;I1X CJIyqaRX, HO Bce
iRe HapyrnaJIaCb p,OCTaTOqHO pe,ZJ;Ro. BTOphIM Ba1KHeHrnIlM cpaRTopoM, cno-
C06cTBoBaBlliIlM COl(UaJIblIoii: H30JIHl(HII, 6bIJI H3bIKOBhlH, a CJIe)10BaTeJIbII0,
II 3TIIIIqeCKHH. MIIoro06pa3He H3bIKOB, a C HIIMH BMeCTe II Hapo,ZJ;oB ()1I1CP-
cpepeHl(Ha HH B 3TIIX ccpepax lIe napaJIJIeJlblIa, 110 6JIII3Ka II qaCTO nepe-
Kpem;UBaeTcH) C03;:t;aJIO II pe;:t;rrOCbI.TIKII P;JIH cpOpllfHpoBalIHH OT)J,eJIblIbIX JIO-
RaJIblIbIX OqarOB reHHoro cBoeo6pa3I1H IIaqIllIaH, nO-BII)1I1l1lOMY, C 3UOXII nep-
B06bITHoro CTa,n,a. HaKon-el(, napaJI.TIeJIblIO C 8THIIqeCKHM )1eii:cTBOBaJI H
AencTByeT cpaRTop nnIXOJIOrIlqeCKHii:, ycyry6JIHeMhIH qaCTIIqHO peJIIIrIl03IIbIM,
IIOJIIIOe nOHIIlIfalIue II EWHRpeTII3a I1H ,ZJ;eHcTBIIH ROTOphlX 6y,ll,YT B03MOiRlIhI,
OqeBIf)J;IIO, TOJIbKO nOCJIe pa3BepTbIBalIIIH I1CCJIe)1oBaIIIIH B 06JlaCTIl COl(I1aJIh-
IIOH U 3TuIIqeCIWH nCIIXOJIOrIIII 17.
Bce 8TH Cnel(IIcpIlqeCKII 06m;eCTBelIlIhIe relIlIhIe 6apbephl, HX CJIOiRlIOe
nepenJIeTelIUe, I1X TeRyqeCTb ):\aIOT B03MomlIOCTb I13yqa Tb reUeTUqeCKIIii: CO-
CTaB COBpeMelIlIoro qeJIOBeqeCTBa, C O)1HOH CTOpOHbI, B KOIIKpeTlIhIX nonYJIH-
HHX, C )1pyroH - B ,ZJ;IIIIaMIIRe. nepBOe OTKphIBaeT )J,opory R ropa3,ZJ;0 60JIee
Tm;aTeJIbIIOIlIY, qeM y paCTeHIIH If mIlBOTlIbIX, I13yqeHIIIO TaKHX BarI,IIelumn:
relIeTIIqeCKllX HBJleHIIH, KaK 8cpcpeKT PaHTa (BJIHRIIIIe I1CXO)1HbIX pa3JIUqIlH
B reIfOcpOII,ZJ;e IIa )1IIcpcpepeH Hal(I1IO IIonYJIHl(IIH), nOCTeneHIIOe nepepaCTalIIIe
JIOKaJIbHhIX MeiRrronYJIHl(I10IIHhIX pa3JIIIqHii: B pa3JIIIqJ:JR 60JIee BhICOKoro
TaKCOHOMIIqeCRurO pallra - paCOBhIe, B33I1MIIOe BJITlHlIIIe H3buWBon II CO:qH-
8JIblIOH ,ZJ;IIij>cpepelIl(uaWfII qeJlOBeKa. BTopoe n03BOJIHeT nOHHTb )1eii:cTBIIe
3THX HBJIelIHH II I1X pOJlb Ha pa3IIbIX 8Tanax EfCTOpIlqeCKOro pa3BHTIIH qeJIO-
BeqeCTBa, UpH pa3JIIIqHhIX 06m;eCTBeHII0-3ROIIOMIIqeCKHX cpopMal(I1HX, B YC-
JIOBIIJIX aBTOXTOlIlIoro pa3BUTIIH, RaR, IIanpIflVrep, B UepBIIqlIbIX 3eMJIe)1eJI1>-
qeCKII:\: Oqarax cy6Tpomn;OB EBpa3I1H, HJIII rrpIl nOCTOHlIlIOM paCCeJIeHIIJI,
IIanpUlIIep B AMepHRe. OqelIh BhICOKaH CTenelIb I13yqeIIIIOCTII KOIIRpeTIIOH
IICTOpIIII OT,ll,e.TIhHbIX qeJIOBetJ:eCKIIX rpyrrn C03)J,aeT BeJIIIROJIenlIYIO npe;rrrrOChIJI-
RY )J.ITR npOBepRII nepeqIlCJIelIlIhIX relIeTIIqeCRIIX MO)J,eJIeH.
CTpYKTypa MaJIblX H30JIIIpUnaHHbIX rronYJIH:qHH C oc06elIIIhlM ycnexollf
H3yqaeTCH npIl nepeMeIu;elIIIII IIe60JIblliIIX rpyrrn II8CeJIeHlIH Ha )1pyryIO Tep-
pIITOpHIO, r)J,e OHII rrorra::raroT B IIHyIO H3bIlmBYIO II pe.:'IlIrIl03IIYIO cpe,ZJ;y,
a TaRiRe B ropHblX MeCTIIOCTHX. AIITpOnOJIOrnqeCRlIe IICCJIe)J;OBaIIHH TaRHX
H30JIHTOB nORa3a.ITII, 'ITO CTpYKTypa I1X caMLIM nenocpeD;CTBelIHhlM 06pa30M
BmIHeT IIa renocpOfI.'1,. B I130.-rHTax nOBhIlliaeTCH qnc.ITO pOJJ:CTBeIIHhIx 6paKOB
II. CJIerrOBaTeJIhHO. pe3Ro YBe.ITIIqIIBaeTCH K08cpcpIl I1eIIT IflI6pH)1I1IIra. 8TO 06-
CTOHTeJIbCTBO BbI3bIBaeT TaR Ha3hIBaeMYIO H30raMeTaI(IIIO - npe06JIarraHHe
rOllI03HrOTIIhIX cpOPM Ha)J; reTep03I1rOTUbIMH II, KaR CJIe,ZJ;CTBII8 3Toro, BbIHB-
JIelIIIe B cpeHOTlme pel(eCClIEOB 18. BUYTpHrpynnoBoe pacnpe)1eJI8IIHe nOJIII-
cpaKTOpHaJIbUhIX npH3HaROB (a K I1X qIlCJIY OTHOCIITCH nOp;aBJIHIOm;ee 60JIb-
{
;..,
.{
43
llumCTBO MopiPOJIOrIIqeCKHX npIl3IIaKOB) npII 310M TeM 60JIbme OTRJIOIIHeTCH
OT HOpMaJIbIIOrO, qeM TeCHee IIH6pII,ZJ;HlIr 19. TaRIfM oopa30M, no CTeneHH
p,ecpopMal(HII BUYTpurpynnoBoro pacnpep;eJIelIIIH MOllilIO CYP;IITh 0 )1peBHOCTH
II30.:'IH HII, - 8T a B3anJ\f03aBIICIIMOCTb 6hIJIa ocooeHIIO nO,'J,p06IIO II3yqeHa
IIMelIIIO IIa alITpOIIOcl0rnqeCKHX )1aIIHbIX 2u.
MOlIocpaKTOpUaJIbHhIe npu3HaKII (K HX qHCJIY OTIIOCHTCH 60JIbmIIIICTBO
cpII3IfOJIOrU I€CKnX oc06eHIIOCT8II), rrO)1BepllielIlIhIe reHIIOMY .Il;peii:cpy, IIa'IIIHa-
lOT B YCJIOBIIHX II30.TlH:qIIII. u3MelIHTbCH B npOTlIBOrrO.JIOiRUhIX IIaUpaBJIeHIIHX
,ZJ;ame B 6.lIU3KOpO,'J,CTBeIIIIbIX rpynnax 21. ::ho cnoc06cTByeT IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbIIO
mupOKOMY pa3Maxy II3MelIqUBOCTH no MOHocpaKTOpHaJII,lIhL\f npU3IIaKaM B
3TnIIqeCRIIX rpynnax, nO,ll,BepiIWlIlIhIX )1:enCTBIIIO II30JIH I111. 3TH rrpOl(eCChI
II3yqelIhI oco6eHII0 xopomoBlIeKoTophIX II30JIHpOBaHHhIx peJIIfrII03IIbIX 06-
m;IIlIax KalIa)1bI, Ha HOBoH rBIIIIee n OCTpOBax MIIRporre3HH 2\ B COBeTCKOM
COI03e - B ,[I,arecTalIe H Ha IlaMupe. 06m;IIH BhIBO)1 HCCJIe)10BaIIIIH no CTPYI{-
Type qeJIOBeqeCI{IIX nonYJIH:qHn, IIMGIOm;IIH CPYlI.II;aMelITaJIbHOe 3IIaqerme )1JIH
06m;eH relIeTIIKIi, CBO.Il;IITCH R TOlliy, qTO II3MeHelIIIe nonYJIH:qHoIIHOH CTPYR-
TYPbI OKa3hIBaeT cym;ecTBeRHoe BJIHHIIIIe IIa nOJIIIMepHhIe (MopcpOJIOrHqe-
CKIIe) II MOIIOMeplIbIe (MlIorIIe cpn3IIOJIOrHqeCKIIe II 6IIOXIIMIIqeCIUW) oc06eH-
IIOCTII opraIIIl3Ma. ,l],oRa3alIlIbIH ,ll,JIH qe.lIOBeKa BhIBO,ZJ; coxpalIHeT, nO-BIIp;IlMO-
MY, cnpaBe)1JIIIBOCTh H )1JIH 1K1lBOTlIhIX.
AHTpOnOJIOrnqeCKIIe )1alIlIhle rr03BOJIIIJIII T&KiRe YBH3aTb BHYTpelIlIIOIO
CTPYKTYPY qeJIOBeqeCRHX nonYJIHIJ;HH C IIX 'lHCJIeHIIOCTbIO, BbIHBIITb TeMII
YMeHbrnelIIIH CTeneHII pO,ll,CTBa B 3aBHCIIMOCTH OT pOCTa qHcm:mUOCTlI H no-
Ra3a TI" npn KaRoii: qIICJIeHIIOCTII YMelIbmaeTCH BepOHTIIOCTh ,ll,eii:cTBHH rene-
THRo-aBTOMaTIIqeCKIIX npOl(eCCOB II HanpaBJIelIlIOrO O)1HOCTOpOHHero II3MelIe-
HIIH npII3IIaKOB 23. 3Ta np06JIeMa, BamlIaH II ;rrJIH TeopIIII 8BO.lIIOl(IIH, II )1JIH
06m;eH reHeTIIKH, npIIBJIeRaeT 60JIbllIOe BIIIfMaHIIe 300JIOrOB H relIeTuKoB, HO
Bce npHMelIHeMbIe B 300JIOrlIH MeTO.D:hI onpep:eJIelIHH qIICJleIIIIOCTII. npHpO)1HhIX
rpynrrlIpoBoK 1KIIBOTlIhlX OCIIOBalIhI IIa KUCBeUlIhIX Ha6JIIO)J;eIIlIHx, IIlII )1aJIeKO
p;o TOqnOCTH alITpOnOJIOrIlqeCKIIX II ,ll,eMOrpacpnqeCKIIX )J;auHhIx, onepupyIO-
m;HX qaCTO pe3YJIbT&TaMII nOrOJIOBHOii nepenIIcH, oc06eull0 KOr,ll,a aHTpono-
JIOrIIqeCKOe I13yqelIUe RaKOH-JIH6o rpynnhl cOnpOBOiR,ll,aeTCH BbIHClIelIIIeM re-
IIeaJIOrUqeCKIIX R3aIIMooTII0IlieHIIH.
np06JIeMa BIIYTpIIrpynnoBbIx 06'be;rrIllIeIIIIM (I I1X o:qeflKH, cpaRTopoB BIIYT-
pIIBII)J;OBOH )1IIcpcpepelIl(lIal(IIII II .Il;BIIiRym;IIx CIIJI 3Toro npol(ecca - OD;IIIIlII
CJIOBOM, np06JIeMa T8I{ na3bIBaeMoH MIIKpo::mo.lIIOu;uH - oJJ;Ha II3 OCIIOBIIhIX B
8BOJIIO HOlIuOM yqelIIIII II 06m;eii: reIIeTIIKe. II onHTL aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIe
)1alIHhIe IIecYT cym;ecTBelIlIYIO IIlIcpopllra IIIO )J;JIll paccMoTpeIIIIH H perneHIIll
aToH np06JleMhI. H3yqelIHe cpOpMIIpOBalIIIfI 'Ie.TJOBeqeCKHX pac y6e,ll,HTeJIbHO
IIOJ{a3aJIO apeaJIbHOCTb BIIYTPHBIIIIOBbIX nO)J;pa3)18cIeHIIH H nO)J;qepKIIYJIO em;e
pa3 nOnqUlIeIIHbIH xapaKTep CIIlIfII&TpnqeCKOrO cpOpllfOoopa30BalIIIH no cpaB-
HeHIHO C aJIJIOnaTpH'IeCRIIlII 24.
B iRUBOTIIOM MHpe nO)1BII;rJ:hI IIJIH IIepapXnqeCKH IIoI(qIflIeHHI,Ie IIM 60JIee
IIH3RHe TaRCOIIOIlIIIqeCKIIe rpynIIbI cKpem;IIBaIOTcH OqeHb pe.Il;lw H 60JIblUeH
qaCTbIO Ha oRpaHlIax CBonx apeaJIOB, eCJIII apeaJIbI 3TH conpIIKacaIOTCH. llo-
3TOMY H3yqelIUe reHeTIIKH CRpem;HEaIIIIH nO)J;BHp:OB H em;e 60JIee IIII3KHX
TaRColIOllfllqeCRIIX eI(IIIIH:q IIa 300JIOrHqeCKOM lIfaTepIIaJIe B03MOiRHO TOJIbRO B
IICRYCCTBeHIIO C03;J:alIlIhIX yCJIOBHHX 8RcnepHMelITa H IIeII36eiRIIO OrpalIIIqelI-
110. lleJfnp.e TeCRaH IICTOpIIH lI'IIIOrO pa3 CTa.TIKIIBa.:'Ia rrpeIJ;CTaBHTeJIeH pa3IIhIX
pac. OO'beJ:IIHHH IIX BO Bee HOBbIe II IIOBhIe 3THIf1l€CRIIe 06m;IIOCTH, II03TOMY
06pa30BaJIIICb 06mHpHhIe ROHTHnreHThI CMemalIlIoro HaCeJIelIIIH B CeBeplIOll
AcppHRe, nepeI(Heii: A3JIII II HII)1IIH (HapO,ll,hI, B cpII3HqeCKOM 06JIIIKe KOTO-
phIX CMeInaHhI eBponeOIID;HbIe II IIerpOIIf],IIbIe qepTbI), B npnypaJIhe, 3aypaJIb€
,
:1
".
,
"
1
j
.,
1
.
I?!
j
,",
'.
1
i
.
,
44
.,
"
'J
'!J
j
"
-:-J
H Cpe)1HeH A3HH (IIapo)1h1, aIITpOnOJIOrIlqeCKIIe oc06eIIIIOCTH KOTOpbIX cm,
JKIIJIIfCh npII C feIIIeIIIIII eBpOneOIl)1Hoii: II MOlIrOJIOIl,ZJ;HOH pac), B II.elITpaJIblIOH
H I01KIIOH Al\<WpIIRe (eBponeOII)1HO-aMepIlKaIICIUre MeTIIChI, qaCTUqlIO C IIer-
pOII,ll,IIoii: npIlMeCbIO) 25. AHTpOlIOJIOrIlqeCROe If aHTponorelIeTHqeCKOe I13yqe-
IIIIB 3THX TeppIlTopUH BCKphlJIO )1I1IIaMIIKY npIl3HaKOB npH BIIYTPIlBII,ZJ;OBOM
CRpem;I1BaIIHII, IIOKa3aJIO, qTO npII OTCYTCTBUH ,ZJ;OMIIHIIpOBaIIIIH CMernaHlIbIe
rpynnbI no nO,ll,aBJIHIOm;eMY 60JIbIIlIIIICTBY npH3IIaKOB 3aHIIMaIOT MeCTO Mem-
)1Y I1CXO)1HbIMIf rrponopl(I10IIaJIbuO I1X Y,ZJ;eJIbHOMY Becy, BlIeCJIO IIOBbrn H
.oqelIh 3IIa'IIITe.'1hIIbIII MaTepIlaJI B 06CYIK.D;eIIIIe rrpOOJIeMhI reTep03I1Ca 26.
0'1 BIIYTPIIBII)J,OBoro CMeilleHIIH JIOrIrqlIO nepeiiTH K 06CYiR,ZJ;eHIIIO peaYJIh-
TaTOB naIIMIIKCIIH, T. e. IIeOrpalIHqeHIIOrO naHonKYMeHlIoro CRpem;HBaIIHH
npe)J,CTaBIiTeJIeii: pa3HhIX pac, npe,ZJ;nOChIJIKa )J;JIH KOToporo 3aJIOmena B ca-
MOH HCTOpIIII qeJIOBeqeCTBa. AHTpOnOJIOrIlqeCIUIn MaTepUaJI npO)J,eMOIICTpH-
pOBaJI pa3IIbIH xapaRTep reorpacpHqeCKOH II3MelIqIIBOCTII B 3aBIiCIIMOCTH OT
CTenelIH I130JIH HH OT)J,eJIblIbIX 3TIIIIqeCRHX rpynn )J;PYl' OT )1Pyra. ECJIII 3T8
H30JIH HH BeJIIIKa, TO reorpa.pIlqeCKIIe I13MeHeHIIH OT,ll,eJIblIbIX npH3IIaKOB
npOIlCXO)J,HT CKaqRaMII, a caMII rrpIl3IIaRII CRJIa)1hIBaIOTCH B TaK IIa3bIBaeMbIe
alITpOnOJIorIlqeCRHe TIIIIhI, T. e. KOMrr.rreKChI He npUqUIIIIO MOPCPOcpH3I10JIOrII-
'IeCRIf, a IfCTOpIlqeCKII CBH3alIIIbIX MeiR,ll,Y c06oii: npIl3IIaROB. ECJIII iRe 3TOH
I130JIHl(III1 IIeT I1JIII olla CJIa6aH, TO npIl3HaKII MeHHIOTCH nOCTenelIHO II OCHOB-
HYIO pOJIb HaqUlIaeT I1rpaTb JIORaJIbHaH I13MelIqUBOCTb OT MlIornx CJIyqaii:HhIx
npIIqUH. BMeCTO reorpacpIlqeCRIIX TIIIIOB - BapIlal(I1I1, He CKJIa)J,blBaIOm;I1eCH
B ROMnJIeRC. 8TO Ha6JIIogeuHe, C)J,e.:'IaHlIoe IIa OClIonaUHH alIamI3a alITporro-
JIOrIlqeCKIIX ,ZJ;aHlIhIX. CBH3auo C BorrpocaMH 0 cpopMax BIIYTPIlBH)10BOH II3MeH-
'IIIBOCTII Bo06m;e H 0 3aROlIOMeplIOCTHX reorpacpUqeCROrO pacrrpOCTpaHelIHH
relIOB 27. ,l];JIH relIoreorpacpUII alITpOrrOJIorIlqeCKIIH MaTepIlaJI rrpocTO HeOl(e-
HIIM.
He IIa norryJIH UOIIIIOM ypoBlIe, a IIa ypomIe opralIII3Ma alITpOnOJIOrHqe-
CKHe IIa6JlIOrreHIIH TaKiRe cymecTBeHIIO BaiRHbI )J;.rrH 06m;eii: relIeTIIRII. ,l];e-
TaJlblIOe I13Y IeHIIe MlIorIlX BaiRIIhIX oco6eHIIOcTeH opraIIII3Ma, pa3JIHqaIO-
m;HXCH Y npe)1cTaBIITeJIeH pa3IIhIX pac, B03l1IOIRIIO TOJlhKO Y qeJIOBeRa BBIIL\Y
IIaJlIIqHH )1eTaJIblIoii: I1Hcpopl\fa I1H 0 ero MOpcpOcpu3IfOJIOrIl'IeCROM cTaTyce IT
MacIDTa6HocTII caMoro OO'beKTa. Oco6eHHOCTH nIlrMeIlTal(HII II CTpoeHHH MHr-
RIIX TKaHei1 JIIIu;a, BapHaU;III1 rrORpOBOB H CReJIeTa. naJIbl(eBhIe II JIa)101I1IhIO
Y30PbI, rpynnhI RpOBII Tm;aTe.lJhHO lICC.rre)J;OBalIbI reHeTIIqeCKII II ;:J:a.lJH u;elIHbIe
CBe)1eIIIIH 0 MexalIII3Me nac_Te;10BaIUIH, KOTOpbIe 'faCTO IIfOrYT 6hITb nepeHe-
CelIbJ II IIa mHBOTlIhIX 28. B o6meii: relIeTHRe Bcer.']:a 60JIbUJYIO pOJIb Hrparr
6JIII3Hel(OBhIii 1\IeTO;O:. T. e. I13Y I€uIIe CXOI\CTBa II pa3JIII IIIii: O,ll,HOHii:l(eBhIX
6JIH3IIel(OB B cpaBlIelIHII C pa3IIOHHn:eBMMII 6mI3Hel(al\fH U pOJJ:IIhIMI! 6paTbH-
MIl II ceCTpaMII. 8TO MDm;HbIii: JIHC-rpYMeIIT o eIII,n pO.'II1 cpe,'J,hI II HaCJIe)J;CT-
BeHHoii: 06YCJIOBJIelIIIOCTII B cpOpMIIpoBalIIIII cpelIOTIIna. lIo I1MeIIIIO B alITpo-
nOJIOrIlII H alITporrorelIeTIIKe 011 npuMelIHeTcH e IIaII60.rrhrnHM ycnexoM II
npIllIocIIT Bce 60JIbille rrpoBepelIlIhIx CBH;:J:eTe.TIbCTB B nOJIb3Y IIac.rre;J;cTBeHIIo-
1'0 )1eTepMIIIIIIpoBaIIIIH ocooelIHOCTeH, 0 reIIeTII IeCKOH npIlporre KOTOphIX
paIIbrne He n0)103peBaJIH, HanplflIWp KpOBHIIOro ;o:aBJIeIJIIH, xapaKTepa cep-
)1eqHOrO pHTMa, OTpaiRaIOm;erOCH B 3JIeKTpOI.ap,lIIOrpal\fM8, H )J;p.29 AIITpOn{)-
JIOrIlqeCKHe ,ZJ;alIHhIe rr03BOJIIIJIH TaRiRe rrOKa3aTb HenOJIHYIO reIIeTII IeCRYIO
O,ZJ;IIOpO,ZJ;HOCTb Jl:ame O,ll,HOHH eBbIX 6.'1I13He OE. ::HHM 6hIJI BlIeceH IIOBhlH Me-
TO,ZJ;IIqeCKHii: acneRT B IICnOJIb30BalIIIe 6JIII3IIe OBOro IIWTo.n:a upn rerJeTnqe-
CKIIX HCCJIe)10BaIIIfHX, a O,iIHOBpeMeHIIO I13I1IeHHJIaCh II oom;erelIeTIIqeCKaJl
TeopHH 3Toro Bonpoca 30.
HaROlIe , nOCJIelIHee: BeJIHIra pOJIb I13yqelIHH reHeTlrqeCRH )J;eTepMHIIIIpO-
BaIIHbIX naTOJIOrnlI y qeJIOBeKa .Il;JlH pernelIIIH M:Tcrux rrpOOJIeM relIenmIl.
45
-
H oc06elIII0 cpeHOrelIeTI1RH. Peqb II)1eT 0 XpOMOCOMlIhIX a6eppa mIX II l\<fHOrO-
'IHCJIelIlIhIX HaCJIe,ll,CTBelIlIhIX IIapyrnelIHHx 06Mella 31. IIhipORoe pacnpOCT-
palIelIue XpOMOCOllfHbIX aoeppa:qnll npii pa3HOo6pa3IIhIX naTOJIOrUqeCKHX CO-
CTOHIIIIHX Bce 60JIee OqeBII)1nO BbIHBJIHeTCH Ul\feHIIO npH anTponoreHeTIIqeCKIIX
II lIfe,ll,IIKO-reHeTnqeCKUX UCCJIe,ZJ;OBaHHHX. MeTol\lIRa l(IITorelIeTIIqeCROrO IIC-
CJIe,ZJ;OBaHIIH KJIeTOK qeJIOBeKa npII06peTaeT, TaKHM 06pa30M, 06m;erelIeTIIqe-
CKoe 3IIaqelIIIe. To me M01hIIO nOBTopIITL II npo IIaCJIe)1CTBelIlIbIe 60JIe3IIII
06MeHa H MeTO)J.IIKY ux IIBY IeHIIH. HapyrnenIIe HaRorO-TO <!Tana 6IIOXUMH-.
qeCKOrO CIIHTe3a - 06m;IIii: 3aROII 06pa30BaIIIfH JII060ii: IIaCJIe,ll,CTBelIlIoii: naTO-
JIOrIIH B opraHHBMC, B TO "he Bpel\IH coxpalIeHIIe THnHqlIOn 3TarrHOCTII 6HO-
CHIITe3a -IIerrpeMelIHoe YCJIOBHe 06pa30BaHHH IIOpllfaJIblIOrO npII3IIaKa.
Qepe3 IIapyrneHHH 6HOXIIMIIqeCKOrO CUIITe3a H3yqaeTCH HOpMaJIhlIaH nOCJIe-
,ZJ;oBa TeJIblIOCTb 6IIOXUMUQeCRIIX peaRl(IIH B opraIIII3i\Ie, II Me)1IIl(IHICKoii: relIe-
THRe, ROTopaH HBJIHeTCH qaCTLIO alITponoreneTIIRII, npIIHa)1JIeiRiiT 3)1eCb e)J;Ba
JIH He nepBoe CJIOBO.
AHTPOnOJlOnrn II rEHETIIRA B IIX B3AIIMOCBH311
B nacTOHm;ee BpeMH 06m;IIlIf MeCTOM CTaJIO YTBeplK)1eIIIIe, qTO IIOBLIe 06JI8CTH
HCCJIe}J;OBaIIIIH B03IIIIKaIOT U npHIIl(IInIIaJIhlIhIe OTRphITIIH J eJIaIOTCJI IIa CThI-
Rax IIaYR. IIpeBocKo,ZJ;IIbIM npHMepoM TaRoH IIOBOH 06JIaCTH, B03HIIKIIIeH IIa
CThIRC alITpOnOJIOrIIII II relIeTHKu, HBIIJIaCb II30CepOJIOl'IfH qeJIOBeKa. C 0)1-
IIOH CTOpOlIbI, olla II3yqaeT TeppIITOpIIaJIblIhIe BapIIa IIII rpynn RpOBII, 6eJI-
ROB CbIBOpOTKH, TIInOB reMorJI06IIIIa II n03TOMY TeCIIO CBH3alIa C cpH3IIOJIO-
rIIeH, a qepe3 IIee II C 06m;eH aIITpOnOJIOrIIeH, B ROTOpoii: II3yqelIIIe reorpa-
cJ>H'IeCKOH H3MelIqHBOCTII qeJIOBeKa no caMbIM pa3HOOOpa3IIbIl\1 npII3naRaM
3alIUMaeT O)1HO H3 OCIIOBHbIX MeCT. C )1pyroH CTOpOlIbI, Bce IIJIII nOqTlI Bce
H30CepOJIOrHqeCKHe cpaKTophI OTHOCHTCH R qIfCJIY MOlIollfeplIhIx cHcTeM, npe,ll,-
CTaBJIHIOT C060H BeJIIIROJIenlIhIe MO;rreJIH )1JIH nonYJIHl(HoIIIIO-reIleTIIqeCKHX
IIa6JIIO,ZJ;eIIIIH, II3yqaIOTCH, cco6eHHo Ha nonYJIHl(lIouIIOM YPoBlIe, C rrOl\Wrn;hIO
relIeTHqeCRlIX 1I1eTO,ll,OB, If nO<!ToMY II30CepOJIOrIIIO qeJIOBeKa B paBHoii: CTe-
nelIII MOllilIO CqUTa Th IIerrOcpe)J;cTBelIlIo cBH3alIIIoH C alITponOrelIeTIIROH,
a qepe3 IIee - H C 06m;eii: reHeTIIKoH. STOT cBoe06pa3HbIii: CHIITe3 aIITpOnO-
JIOrIIII H relIeTIIKH 3HaqHTeJIhlI0 060ram;aeT HarnH TeOpeTIIqeCKHe npe)J;CTaB-
JIelIIIH B 06JIaCTII 6IIOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa II ero 3BOJIIOl(IIII II Op;IIOBpeMeIIHO pac-
mIIpHeT IIamii 3HalIIIH 0 )1eHCTBIIII 06m;ereHeTII I€CRIIX 3aROHOMepIIOCTeH.
npIIMepaMH TO MY MorYT CJIYiRIITb 6aJIaHCIIpOBaHIIhIll IIaCJIe,n:CTBeHHhIH nOJIII-
IIWpcpH3M, CeJIeKTIIBIIOCTb rpynn RpOBII, UK 8BOJlIOl(HH no,ll, BJIIIHHHeM 60JIe3-
IIeH, 3cpcpeRT reHeTlIRO-aBTOMaTIIqeCKHX npOll:eCCOB lIa ORpaIIlIax OHKYMeHbI.
o 6aJIalICIIpOBalIHOM HaCJIe)1CTBeIIIIOM nOJIIIl\WpcpH3Me y qeJIOBeRa MIIO-
1'0 nHCaJIII, H nOJIIIlIwpcpII3M 110 rpynnaM Rpomi qaCTO npIIBOJ(HTCH B RaqeCT-
Be npIIMepa aTom HBJIelIIIH B 06m;erelIeTIIQeCKUX PYROBO,ll,CTBax. OHO COCTOHT
B TOM, qTO B nonYJIHl(llll B npe)J;eJIaX Ram.o:oro nOROJIeHHH npOHBJIrreTCH IIe-
CROJIbRO cpeIIOTHnOB, COOTHornelIHe MefK)1Y ROTOpbIMII, eC.TIII lIe ,a:eHCTBYIOT
IIpOl(€CChI nanpaBJIelIHOrO II3MelIelIITJI npII3IIaROB, OCTaeTCH nOCTOHIIHbIM.
HaqIflIaH C onIIcaBmero II RJIaCcucpIIl(HpOBaBIIIero 3TO HBJIeHIIe E. <Pop,ll,a 32 -
68JIalICnpOB81IIIhIH IIaCJIe;rrCTBeHHhIH nOJIIIMopcpII3M TpaKTyeTcH yqelIbIMH KaK
pe3YJIbTaT onpe)1eJIelIHOro oT60pa, .o:eHcTByrom;ero B HanpaBJIemIII IIOCTOHHIIO-
1'0 coxpaHelIIIH reTep03HroTIIoH cpOPMLI 33 . Y qeJIOBeKa y)106HCe Bcero pac-
CMoTpeTb ero IIa npHMepe ynoMHlIaBrnerocH BbIrne alIOMaJIblIOrO reMorJI06II-
IIa S. .TaR RaR rOM03HrOTa no reMorJI06IIHY S CMepTeJIblIa B palIlIeM B03-
paCTe, TO qaCTOTa rella )J;OJIiRlIa 6bIJIa 6hI y6hIBaTb OT nOKOJIelIIIH R nOKOJIe-
IIHIO. Mea')1Y Tellf aToro HeT H TaM, r)1e reH S BbIHBJIeIl B norryJIHl(HHX,-'
-
46
t
E TpOIIIIqeCKOH AcppIIKe, IIa lOre ApaBIIHCKoro nJIaTO, Ha EaJIRalIaX II B JIII-
.,ll,IIH. B 3aRaBKa3be 011 COXpalIHeTCH IIa cTa6IIJIblIOllf ,ZJ;OBOJIbIIO BhICOROM ypOB-
lIe If qaCTOTa IIOCIITeJIbCTBa COCTaBJIHeT B IIeROTOphIX rpYIIIIaX 25-30%.
06"bHClIe1IIIe 3TOro napa.Il;OKCaJIblIOrO cpaKTa ORa3aJIOCb B03MomlIhIM TOJIbKO
TOr)1a, ROr.Il;a 6hIJIa 3aMeqelIa CBH3b lIfeiR.IJ;y IIOCHTeJIhCTBOM reMorJI06HIIa S
fI pe3HCTelITIIOCTbIO R MaJIHpIIII. ORa3aJIOCh, ITO reTep03IIrOThI no reMOrJIO-
6IIIIY S, nO-BII,ZJ;IIMOMY, 3HaqIITeJIblI0 oOJIee YCToii:qIIBhI K MaJIHpIIII, qeM
HOpMaJIhIIbIe OC06II. TaKIIM 06pa30M, B KaiR)J,OM nOROJIelIIIII ocym;eCTBJIHeTCH
CeJleRl(IIH reTep03IIrOTIIhIX cpOPM H qaCTOTa IIOCIITeJIhCTBa alIOMaJIhlIOrO re-
MorJI06IfHa nop;)1epnUfBaeTCH IIa cTa6HJIblIOM ypoBlIe, ,ZJ;eTepMlIHHpOBaIIIIOM
HIITelICIIBIIOCTbIO )1eii:cTBIIH oT60pa 3 .
AlIaJIOrUqHbIH npol(ecc IlMeeT MeCTO II no OTlIorneHIIIO R ,ZJ;pyrHlIf cpopMaM
:8nOMaJIblIhIX reMorJI06I1HOB, oc06elIIIo DO OTHornelIIIIO R TaK IIa3bIBaeMoMy
cpeTaJIbHOMY reMorJI06IIIIY, rell coxpalIelIIIH KOToporo B rOM03IIrOTHOM CO-
CTOHIIHII BbI3bIBaeT CMepTb B paHHeM B03paCTe, a reTep03IIrOTa no 3TOMY
reny, nO-BIIp;IBIOMY, TaKiRe CTpa.D:aeT o)J,Hoii: II3 cpO pM reMOrJIOOIIIIOnaTIIH-
TaJlaCCeMHeH, nOBbIrnaIOm;eH YCTOHqIfBOCTb R 3apaiReHIIIO MaJIHpIfeH. Ho eCJIII
Obi IIac.TIe)1CTBelIlIhIii: nOJIHMopcpH3M npOHBJIHJICH TOJIbKO B CTpoemm MOJIeRY-
.JIbI rellfOrJI06IIlIa, ero pOJIb B 6IIOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeRa, BajI IIaH H B 3TOM c.rryqae,
6hIJI8 6bI Bce me OrpaHllqelIlIOH. MeiR,ZJ;Y TeM eCTb IIeIWTOpbIe OCHOBalIIIH no-
JIaraTb, qTO 011 paCDpOCTpalIelI Y qeJIOBeI a OqeHb mIIpOKO H, B qaCTIIOCTII,
IIM MOn{IIO 6YJJ:eT 06"bHCIIIITb COOTHomelIIIe qaCTOT relIOB lIflIorIIX, eCJIH lIe
Bcex rpynnoBhIX 4>aRTopoB KpOBH H TiinOB CbIBOpOTRII, IIeRO'IOpbIX cpII3IIOJIO-
TII IeCRIIX nOKa3aTeJIeii:, IIanpIIMep BRYCOBOH qYBCTBHTeJIblIOCTH K cpeIIIIJITIfO-
Rap6aMIf.IJ;y II T. p;.35 npaB)1a, CeJIeKTIIBlIhIH MexalIH3M P;JIH nO,ll,aBJIHIOm;erO
60JIbrnIllICTBa 3TIIX npH3HaKOB em;e lIe OTKphIT, 110 caJl.fO IIX pacnpe,ZJ;eJIerrIIe
B pa3HbIX 3TIIIIqeCKIIX n TeppIITOpIlaJIbIIbIX rpyrrnax 38CTaBJIHeT nO,ZJ;03peBaTb
.B03MOiRIIOCTb ero 06"bJIClIeIIIIH IIa OCIIOBe CeJleRl(IIII.
3)J;eCb YMeCTIIO CKa3aTb IIeCKOJIbRO CJIOB 0 Tex CJIyqaJIX, KOTOphIe eCJIH H
lIe MorYT CqIITaTbCH C'Iporo ,l],OKa3aIIHbIMH, TO BO BCHROM CJIyqae BhIrnJIII II3
CTa)1HH YM03pHTeJIbHOrO 06CYiR,ll,eIIHH n IIMeIOT nO)1 C060H neROTOpyIO cpaRTH-
"'IeCRYIO 6a3Y. Peqb noii:.II;eT 0 rpynnax RpOBH cnCTeMbI ABO. TaK RaR 3T3
CHCTeMa H3BeCTIIa Y1Ke )J,aBHO H IIanOOJI03e Tm;aTeJIbHO II3yqeHa. IIIICaJICCh
IIeO)1HOKpaTIIO Ha OCIIOBaIlIUJ MIIOrOqnCJIeHHbIX ,ll,alInbIX, co6palIIIhIX R TOMY
me B pa3JIHqlIhIX CTpalIax, qTO JIH a C rpynnoH KpOBH 0 npII6J1II3IITeJIblI0
B nOJITOpa pa3a qam;e, qeM IIOCHTeJIII p;pyrHx rpynn, 3a6oJIeBaIOT H3BOH me-
.JIYP;K8 H )1BelIa,ZJ; a TnnepCTHOH KIIillKH. B npOTHBOnOJIOmHOCTb 3TOllfY HOCH-
TeJIII rpynnbI A npe)1pacnOJIOmelIbI, nO-BH,ll,I1MOMY, K paRY iReJIY.Il;Ra. TaRHM
06pa30M, IIOCHTeJIhCTBO Tex H.TIII HHbIX rpynnoBbIX cpaKTopoB CBH3alI0 C
lIpe06JIa)J;aHHeM IIMMYHHTeTa R pa3IIhlM 3a60JIeBalIHHM H, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO,
IIMeeT CeJIeKTHBHOe 3HaqeHIIe 3 r..
Em;e 60JIee IIIITepeCHbI cpaRTbl, I1JIJIIOCTpIIpYIOm;ne CBH3b rpynn RpOBII
CHCTeMhI ABO C IIlIcpeK HoHlIhIMH 3a60JIeBaIIIIHMII, TaK RaK nOCJIe)J;HIIe xa-
p8RTepH3YIOTCH )1IIlIaMHKoii: II mHpOKH f apeaJIOllf pacnpOCTpalIelIIIH. 8Tnx
waRToB IIeMHOrO, If IIX nORa IIe.TIb3H CqfITaTb OKOIPIaTe.TIbIIO 6eccnoplIhIMH,
110 OIIII CBII)1eTeJlhcTBYIOT Bce iRe. 0 IIeKoTopoH pe3IICTelITHOCTH K 3apaiRe-
IIHIO ocnoH, KOTOpOH OTJIHqaIOTCH HOCIITeJIII rpynnhl B. B 3TOM CJIyqae MbI
conpIIKacaeMCH C np06JIeMoii: 3BOJIIOl{IIn rpynn RpOBIf nO)1 BJiIIHIIIIeM 3a60-
JIeBaHHii: - np06JI03Moii: IICKJIIOqIITe.TIbIIOrO 3IIaqe1IHH. }J;eHcTBIITeJIblIO, O IarII
pacnpOCTpalIeIIIIH ;rralIlIoH HlIcpeK HH HaXO)1HTCH B I01KlIoii: II BOCTOqHOii:
A3IIH, a HaCeJIeHHIO 3TOH TeppHTopHII RaR pa3 II CBOJICTBeulIa BhICORaH
qaCTOTa rpynnhI B. OTKphIBaeTcH, CJIe;r:OBaTe.lIbHO, B03M01KHOCTb 06"bHCHIITb
caMO reorpacpHqeCROe pacnpOCTpalIelIIIe BapIIa:qHH rpymlbI B D;eHcTBHeM ce-
47
e
JIeKTHBlIoro cpaKTopa- ee npeIfMym;ecTBoM B YCJIOBIfHX IJ;JIHTeJIbHOii H no-
CTOHIIIIOH onaCIIOCTII 3apamelIHH ocnOH, MlIoro pa3 OCYlII.eCTBJIHBmeHCH.
npaB)J,a, MemlIY apeaJIaMII lIaIl60JIee BhICOKIIX qaCTOT B II IIaIl60JIee IIIITelI-
CIIBIHJrO pacnpOCTpaIIeIUTH IIIIcpeKl(I1I1 IIeT IIOJIIIOrO IIapaJIJIeJI1I3Ma: caMaH
BhlCOKaH KOIIl(enTpa:qHH rpynnhI B - B MOHrOJIIIII, rlIe ocnbI KaK 6YlI TO
Bo06m;e IIeT, 110 napaJIJIe. T IH3l\1 TaKoro pO,ll,a II B IIpIlIIl(lIne lIe MOiReT 6hITb
nOJIlIhIM. COBeprneIIHO O'IeBIf.D:IIO, qTO IIapH)J,y C CeJIeKTIIBlIbIM cpaKTopOM
J];eHCTBYIOT II RaKIIe-TO .D;PyrIle: pa3IIIIl(a B nepBOlIaqaJIhHOll KOlIuenTpaI IIIf
relIOE, H30JIIIpyIOm;I1e McxaIIII3MhI II T. 1I.. KOHl(eIITpal(I1H rpynnhI B MOrJIa
II YCHJIIITbCH nOlI. BJIIIHHIIeM CeJIeKl(HH Y naCeJIelIIIH IOiImoii: II BOCTOqHOH
A3HII, Y ,ZJ;peBlIero IIaCeJIeHIIH 3Torr TeppIlTopIfII olla 6bIJIa, CJIe)J,OBaTeJIhIIO,
lIflIorO IIIIiRe 37. TaKoe npe;JnOJI01KelIIIe xopomo 06'bHCIIHeT pe3Roe nOHIIiReHIIe
ROH:qeIITpal(I1H rpynnhI B y aMepHKalIcmrx IIIIJ eii:l(eB - nOTOMKOE ,ll,peBlIeH-
rnero IIaCeJIeUIIH A3HaTcRoro MaTepIlH:a.
Bce I13JI01KennbIe lIalIlIbIe nO;rrBO)J;HT C)J;Ba JIH lIe K rJIaBIIOMY Bonpocy qe-
JIOBeqeCRoii: aBo.ITIO I1I1: KaKOBa pO JIb eCTeCTBelIlIoro oT6opa B cpOpMooopa30-
BalIIIII y cOBpeMelIlIoro qeJIOBelm? Cym;ecTBYlOm;HO TOqKH 3pelIlUl IICqepnhI-
BaIOT Bce TeOpeTIIqeCKH )J,onycTIIMhIe B03MOiRIIOCTII - OT npIl3IIalIIIH OToopa
rJIaBIIOH lIBIImym;eii: CIIJIOll If3McueHIlH COBpeMelIuoro qeJIOBeRa, TaK iRe RaK
H mIlBoTlIbIX, T. e. OT nOJIlIoii CBOllIlMOCTIf B aTOM OTHornelIlIII qeJIOBeKa K
iImBOTIIbIM, 1I0 nOJIlIoro OTpH aIIIIH pOJIH oT60pa 18. npe)J;hIlIYIIJ;I1e npIlMephI
y6eiRlIaIOT B TOM, qTO CeJIeKTIIBlIhIe npo eCChI HMeIOT MeCTO II B COBpeMelIlIOM
06m;eCTBe II pO JIb I1X lIe TaK YJRe raJIa.
KaR I1X o:qeIIIITb? C'IIITaTb, qTO eCTeCTBelIlIhI:ll OT60p Me)J,JIeIIIIO If nOCTe-
IIeIIHO, 110 HeYKJIOlIlIO npe06pa3yeT alITpOIIOJIOrIlqeCKHH TIIn COBpeMeUlIoro
'IeJIOBeqeCTBa B KaKOM-TO onpe,ll,eJIelIlIOM IIanpaBJIelIIfH, qTO rpynna RpOBH B
IIanpIlMep, EbITeCIIHT II 3aMelIIfT y 6YlIym;ero qeJIOBe'IeCTBa Bce OCTaJIbIIbIe?
nOKa J(JIH TaR oro npe)J;nOJIOnmlIIIH lIeT IIIIRaKIIX cpaKTIIqeCKHX OCIIOBaHHH.
Ha060poT, cOBpeMelIlIoe qe.:'IOBeqeCTBO coxpalIHeT HCRJIIOqHTeJIbHOe Mlloro06-
pa3I1e no BceM J\wPCPoJIOrnqeCRIIM II CPIl3HOJIOrIlq€CRIIM npII3IIaRaM, KOTopoe
lIe YMelIbmaeTcH Ha npOTHJReHHH nOCJIe)J;IIIIX ThICHqeJIeTIIH. npIIqIllIa ero B
nOJIIIcpYIIRl(IIOlIaJIbIIOCTn nO)J,aBJIHIOm;erO 60JIbrnIllICTBa npIl3IIaKOIi II B OqelIb
CJI01KIIOH 06m;ecTBelIHon II npIlpoJl,IIoii: 06cTalIoBRe, B KOTOpOll iRIIBYT 'IeJIO-
BeqeCKHe nonYJIHl(I1II. B 3TITX YCJIOBIIHX OTOOp lIeHcTByeT no-pa3IIOllfY Ha
OlI HH II Te ille npH3HaKII B pa3JIHqlIhIX paHolIax Oii:KYIIf€IIhI, BbI3hIBaH lIe
cTa6I1JIII3al(I1IO cpIl3I1qeCKOrO TIIna II ero ClIBIIr B onpelIeJIelIlIOM IIanpaBJIe-
lIIfH, a CIICTeMY C6aJIalICIIpOBalIIIoro relIeTHqeCKOrO pa3IIo06pa3IfH. MOiReT
6bITb, TaRoe pa3IIo06pa3I1e HBJIHeTCH OlIHIIM H3 IIe06xo)J;I1MhIX YCJIOBIIH pa3BII-
TIIH l(I1BIIJIII3a III1 II nporpecca?
nOCJIelI HIIH Bonpoc. KOToporo HeJIh3H lIe KOCIIYTbCH B CBH3If C II30cepo-
JIOrIleli qeJIOBeRa,- relIeTIIKo-aBTOMaTHqeCKIIe npol(ecChI Ha oKpaHlIax OHKY-
MelIbI 39. I1x IIpIlIIl(I1nIlaJIbIIOe OTJIIIqIle 01' relIeTIIRo-aBTOMaTlIqeCKIIX npo-
:qeCCOB, lIellCTBYIOm;I1X B H30JIHpOBalIIIhIX paHOHax elITpaJIblIbIX OOJIacTeii,
CRaiReM, EBpa3I1If, 3aRJIIOqaeTCH B pe3YJIhTaTax: B I elITpaJIblIbIX OOJIaCTHX:
OHH c031IaIOT pa3IIo06pa3I1e npIl3HaRa, B OKpaHIIIIhIx - ero elIIIlIoo6pa3He.
Momllo Ha3BaTb IIeCKOJIbKO npIlJ\f€pOB 3Toro: pe3Koe yMelIhmelIHe qaCTOTbI
rpynn KpOBH B H N y aMepIIRalIcKIIx IIII,ll,eii: eB, TaRoe iRe pe3Koe YllIelIbrne-
IIHe qaCTOTbI rpynnhI M y aBCTpaJIIIii:l(eB If JJ:p. npIlqIIlIa aToro HBJIelIHH JIe-
mIlT, OqeBHJ];IIO, B CJIyqanlIOH O)J;IIOpO,!I;IIOCTII I1CXO)J,IIbIX rpynlI. 'Lho me RacaeT-
CH rpYIIIIbI B, TO )J;onOJIIIIITeJIbHOH npIIqIIHOH MOr.ITO CJIYiRIITb CUHTHe B YC-
JIOBHHX allfepHRaHCKoro ROIITHlIeHTa oT60pa Ha pe3IICTeHTIIOCTb R ocne,
KOTopoe, RaK yme rOBOpIlJIOCb, IIO-BIIJ];HlIfOMY, nOlI;rrepnumaJIo BbICORyID
ROII eHTpa:qHIO rpynnhI B B BOCTOqlIOH A3HH, If BbIm;enJIelIIIe pe eccHBlIoro
48
t
rcna, onpC;J:eJIHIOm;erO IIaCJIe,ZJ;OBaHIfe rpynnhI B, B YCJIOBIfHX H30JIH:qHII B CO-
OTHCTCTHllll C 3aIWIIOllI H. 11. BaBIfJIOBa O.
thaI{, II30CepOJIOI'IfH - .D:HCl(IfIVIIIna, B03IIIfRillaH Ha CThIRe alITpOnOJIOrIfH
If I'elleniRIf, HlIeC.TIa, RaK l\ihI y6eD;IfJIlICh, cym;ecTBelIHO IIOBbIe acneRTbI II B
cpaJWIPIeCRYIO II n TeOpeTH'leCRYIO 6a3Y RaR aIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCROH, TaK H re-
IIeTIPIeCKOII naYI(II II HarJIH;1ITO ,'IC:I'IOHCTpIfpyeT nJIO;J,OTBOpHOCTb CQ'IeTaHHH
II B3aIlMonpOHIIRIIOBeIIIIH anTpOnOJIOHI'IeCRIIX H relIeTIIqeCKIIX MeTO,ZJ;OB.
,
,
,
i
3IIA qEHHE rEHETHqECKIIX ;rJ;AIIIIbIX
B AHTPOnOJIOrHqECKHX HCCJIE;rJ;OBAHIfHX
Co npeMeII 8. fCRKeJIH pO;J,CTBO opramf1IeCKIIX 1jJ0pllf BhIHBJIHJIOCL C IIOllIO:W;bIO
3IIallIelIIIToii: :3BOJIIOl(HOHIIOii: TpIla)1hI - 8M6pno.IJOrIIH, cpaBnIlTeJILIIOH alIaTO-
MUll If IIaJleOIITOJIOrIlII. IIHbIlIfII CJIOBallIII, B pacnopH1KeHIIH I1CC.:'Ie,ZJ;OBa TeJIeH,
BOCCTaHaBJIllnaBillIlX npOIlCXOiRp;eIIIIe H POlICTHelIlIhIe B3aIlMOOTIIornelIIIH op-
ranIlqeCRIIX <pOP:VI, ObI.:'III ,ll,Ba MeTO,ZJ;a - MopcpOJIOrIIqeCRIIii:, 6a3I1pOBaBillIIHCH
B OCIIOBHOM IIa cpaBIIIITeJIblIOH aHaTOMIIII H 8M6pHOJIOrHH, II I1CTOpnqeCRIIH,
6a3IIpOBaBrnIlHCH IIa naJIeOHTOJIorHII. H' COiRaJIeIIIIIO, B alITpOnOJIOrIlH :3Ta
TpHa.D:a IIHKor)J,a lIe IIMeJIa OOJIbillOrO 3IIaqeIIIIH, npIIqIiHa qeMY - Cnel(I1cpIfRa
3BOJIIO:qIIII '.IeJIOBeKa, npOTeKaBillaH, eCJlII BbIpamaTbCH TaRCOIIOlVIIIqeCI{I1,
B npc)J;eJIax O)1HOrO pO)1a, H MaJIbIH MaCillTa6 pa3J1IIqHH Melli)1Y BIIYTPHBII,ll,O-
BbIlIfll 1l0;:J:paaD;eJIeIIIIH:V1lI COBpellIeIIHOrO qeJIOBeqeCTBa pacaMII.
8M6pHOJIOrIlH II03BOJIHeT BCKpbITb cpIfJIOrelIeTII'.IeCRIIe B3anMOOTHomeHIIH
rpynnhI, TOJIbKO Ror)J,a PCqh II,ll,eT 06 Y3JIOBhIX MOllIeIITax ee 8BOJlIO I1n, Kpyn-
IIbIX IIepecTpoHKax ee opraHII3al(I1H B )1peBHOCTII. 110BTOpeillIe cpH.TIOrelIeTH-
qeCKIIX B3aIIMooTIIoillelIHH B HH,ZJ;I1BH)1yaJIbIIOM pa3BHTIIH, aaROII peRanIlTY-
JIHl(I1H MIOJI.TIepa - reRReJIH ocym;eCTBJIHIOTCH C MIIOrOqHCJIelIlIbIMII BbIlIa)1e-
IIHHMII OT,ZJ;eJlhlIhIX cTa)J,I1H II JIIfillb B 06m;I1x qepTaX 41. BhI)J,eJIelIIIe 'IeJIOBeRa
H3 mIlBOTlIoro MIIpa npeD;CTaBJIHeT c060ii: C TOqKH apeHIIH reOJIOrIlqeCKOH
I1CTOpIlIl IIaCTOJlbRO noa,ZJ;IIee HBJIeIIIIe, qTO 0110 MOrJIO 6bI IIaHTII OTpamelIIIe
.TIIIrnb IIa nOCJlellJIIIX CTa; IIHX 8M6pIloreIIe3a, 110 B iJ,eHCTBIITeJIbIlOCTH lIe OT-
pa3IIJIOCh B IlIlX, 'faR I{aR npol(eCC 8£OJIIO IIII pO)J,a II BII)1a CJIHmKO I MeJIKO-
MaCillTa6eII B OTlIomelIIIII oom;eii: nepecTpoii:KH MopcpOJIOrIlqeCROH CTPYKTYphI,
qT06hI 6bITI, aacpIlRcHpoBalIlIbIM B I1JI,ZJ;IfBII,ZJ;ya.lIbIIOM pa3BIITHII. nO:3TOMY 8M-
6pIlOJIOrIlH qeJIOBeRa npII Bcen CBoeH I13yqeIIIIOCTII ,ll,aeT OTIIOCIfTeJIblIO MaJIO
P;JIH BOCCTalIOBJIelIHH OCHOBHbIX 3TanOB aHTponorelIe3a. TOM Mellbille I1HCPOp-
Mal(HH olla npHHocIIT rrOKa paCOBe,ll,eHIIIO.
naJIeOIITOJIOrI!:qeCKaH IfCTOpIIH qeJIOBeRa YiRe M01KeT 6hITb B 06m;HX qep-
Tax IIanIlCalIa ITa OCIIOBalIHII IIeCKOJIbRHX )1eCHTKOB IICRonaeMbIX IIaXOJ(OR,
)J;eTaJIhlIOe H3yqerIIIe KOTOphIX n03BOJIIIJIO l-rapIlCOBa Tb cpIl3HqeCRIIii: 06JIIIK
,ll,peBHeii:rnnx JlIO)1eH. 06rnnpnbIe naJIeOaIITpOnOJIrH'.IeCRHe MaTepIlaJIbI I1a pa3-
HOBpellIeHlIbIX 1\I0rHJIbIIIIROB, )1aTIIpyeMhIx HaqIIUaH C 8IIOXII BepXlIero naJIeo-
JIIITa II KOlIqaH COBpeMeIIIIOCTbIO, nOIlIOraIOT BOCCTaHOBIITb npOHCXO}f{D;eIIIIe H
nCTopIlIO COBpeMelIUbIX pac 2. TaKIIM 06pa30M, eC.TIII He c06CTBeHII0 naJIeOII-
TOJIOrIIqeCKOe, TO £0 BCHKOM CJIyqae 6JIII3ROe eMY no xapaKTepy I1CCJIe)J,OBa-
IIIIe I1rpaeT 60JIbillYIO pOJIh B YCTalIOBJIeHIIH OCIIOBlIhIX 3TanOB pa3BHTIIH qe-
JIOBeRa. PO)J,CTBO pac YCTalIaBJIIIBaeTCH IIa OCIIOBaHIIII OqelIb 06CTOHTeJIblIOrO
113yqeIIIIH I1X IIIOpcpOJIOrHII H CPIl3IIOJIOrUH. OT TpHa)1hI, CJIe,ZJ;OBa TeJIhIIO, OCTa-
IOTCH JInrnb )1Ba COCTaBJIHIOIJ-\IlX ee KOMnOlIeIITa. Ho I1X BceCTopOlIlIee HCnOJIb-
30Ba1IIIe, B03M01KIIOCTh II rpalIII hI BO MlIorOM onpe,ll,eJIHIOTCH xapaKTepOM
relIeTIlqeCKOrO I1CTOJIROBaIIIIH lVwpcpOJIOrIlqeCKOrO lIJIH ?lfOpcpocpn3I10JIOHIqe-
CRoro CXO)J;CTBa, TaR KaR B naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIlH MOPCPOJIOrnqeCI{I1H RpIlTepnH
TaKme HBJIHeTCH OCIIOBHbIM. npOIlJIJIIOCTpIlpOBaTb Bce CK.aaalIlIoe MOiRIIO,
-;..
!
49
/
I
I
npOCJIe,ZJ;IIB, KaK 3aMelIa HenpaBHJIhlIbIX relIeTIIqeCKIIX npep:CTaBJIeIIIfH 0 3ua-
qelIHIf Tex IIJIII IIlIhIX MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCKIIX CTPYKTYP npaBIIJIbHhIMH npII6JIIfiRa-
JIa HaC K BhIHBJIelIHIO IICTI1IIBbIX pO,ll,CTBelIlIhIX B3aIfMOOTlIomelIIIH paCOBbIX
TIInOB. 3a IIeIIMelIIleM MeCTa OrpaHIIqYCh .Il;BYMH npIIMepaMII - BbI)J;eJIeHI1e f
pa3IIhIX 110 xapaKTepy IIaCJIe.Il;CTBelIlIOll 06YCJIOBJIeHIIOCTH rpynn npII3HaKOB
H YCTalIOBJIeHIIeM TaRCOIIOMHqeCROH IIepapXlIII npH3HaKOB.
IIepBhIH acneRT OqeUh TeCHO CBH3aH C MeTO.Il;I1KOH aIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKHX IIC-
CJIe)10BaIIIIH Boo6Il e, qeM II onpe,ZJ;eJIHeTCH ero IICKJIIOqIITeJIblIOe 3uR'IeIIIIe.
Em;e B KOIIl(e npomJIoro BeRa 6hIJIO 3aMeqelI0, qTO BCe oc06enlIOCTII qeJIO-
BeqeCROrO opralIH3l\fa n0)1pa3)1eJIHIOTCH no xapaRTepy II3MeHqHBOCTII IIa )1Be
KaTeropIIH - aJIhTepBaTHBIJbI8 npII3IIaKH H TpalIcrpeCCIIBlIhIe (RCTaTH CKa-
3an" yme nOTOllf 8'1'0 0606m;eIIlIe 6h1JIO nepeHecelIO IIa II311-IenqHBOCTb B op-
ralIHqeCROM MIIpe Bo06m;e). IIepBhIe - npII3IIaKII C npephIBIIcToii: H3MenqII-
BOCTbIO, BTopbIe - C IIenpepblBHoii: 43. Pa3BHTIIe reneTIIqeCKIfX 8KcnepIIMeH-
TOB H relIeTIIqeCROn TeopIIII U03BOJIHJIO YBH3aTb xapaKTep II3MelIqIIBOCTH
npII3IIaROB If xapaKTep I1X uaCJIe)1CTBeJITIoii 06YCJIOBJIeIIIIOCTII. OKa3aJIOCb,
qTO aJIbTepua THBlIhIe npII3IIaRII lIaCJIe)1CTBeIIHO )1eTepMIIIIHpYIOTCH qam;e Bce-
1'0 ,ZJ;BYMH IIJIII TpeMH IIaCJIe)1CTBelIlIbIMH cpaI{TOpaMU, HBJIHIOTCH MOHOMeplIbI-
lIfH, TpalIcrpeCCHBlIhIe - MuorHMII, KaiR,ZJ;hIH II3 KOTOpbIX HeceT paBUYIO C
OCTaJIblIhIMH )10JIIO HaCJIe.Il;CTBelIlIOH IfucpopMaUIIIf. 8TH npII3HaRII IIOJIIIMep-
HbIe. .D:aJIblIeHrnee pa3BIfTIIe aIITponO.TIOrIfqeCKHX IICCJle)10BaIIHH IIORa3aJIO,
qTO K nepBoii: RaTeropuII oc06euHocTeii: qeJIOBeqeCKOrO opralIH3Ma OTIIOCHTCH
nO)J;aBJIHIOm;ee qIIC.ITO cpH3IIo.TIOrIIqeCKUX xapaKTepIIcTIIR, rpYlInhI KpOBU II
6eJIKII ChIBOpOTKII, CTpYRTYpa reMorJI06IIIIa, nIIrMeHTa IIH 4\ KO BTOpoii:-
nOqTH Bce MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKIIe oco6e1I1IOCTII, T. e. CTpoelIHe TKalIen JIIru;a,
CTpoeHIIe CKeJIeTa II T. )1.45
RaROB OTIIOCUTeJIbHhIH yrJeJIblIbIll Bec 06eIIX rpynn npII3IIaKOB B YCTaIIOB-
JIelIHH pO,ll,CTBa auTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX TIInOB II, c.ITe,ZJ;OBaTeJIbIIO, R aIITpOnOJIO-
rHqeCKOM alIaJIII3e? B u;eJIOM H Te II )J;pyrIIe .Il;OJIambI xapaKTepII30BaTb alI-
pOnOJIOrHqeCKIIH TIIn B COBoKynlIocTII Bcex ero OTJIIIqIITeJIblIhIX qepT, H no-
3TOMY B IIaCTOHm;ee BpeMH npIf alITpOnOJIOnIqeCKOM II3YQeHHH IIaCeJIelIIIH
RaROH-HII6YP;b TeppIITopHII CTpeMHTCH KaR IIlOiRlIO 60JIee rnIIpOKO oXapaKTe-
pII30BaTb ero If MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKIf H cpII3IIo.TIOrIIqeCKH 46. O,ZJ;lIaKO npH3IIaRII
BTOpOH rpynnhI - TpalIcrpeCCIIBHhIe no CBoeH H3MeuqHBOCTH, IIOJIIIMepHbIe IIO
CBoeH IIaCJIe)1CTBeIIHOH 06YCJIOBJIelIIlOCTII - 60JIee cTa6II.TIblIbI BO BpellfelIH,
MeHee nO)J;BepmelIbI cJIyqaii:IIhIM II3MelIeHHHM ". XOHI reHeTIIKo-aBTOllfaTH-
qeCKHe npo:qecchI B 1I30JIIIpOBalIHhIx nonYJIHl(HHX 1I )J;encTBYIOT IIa 06e KaTe-
ropHII npH3IIaKOB, 110 HX BJIHHIIIIe IIa H3MelIelIIIe MOIIOMBplIMX npH3IIaKOB
3IIaqlITeJIblI0 60JIhIIIe. B naJleOalITpOnOJIOrIIH npaKTIIqeCRH TOJIbKO C IIOJIHMep-
HhIMH npH3HaRallfII H npIIxO)1uTCH IIMeTb ,ll,eJIo, TaK Kal{ MOIIOMeplIhIe npH3IIa-
KII 6HOXHlIfIIqeCROrO xapaKTepa nOKa Heonpe)1emIMhI lIa CReJIeTe: OCYllIeCTB-
JIHeMhIe B HacTOHm;ee BpellfH nonbITKH BhIHCHHTh rpynnhI KpOBH IIa IfCKonae-
lIfhIX ROCTHX BOCHT em;e nOlfcKoBhIH xapaRTep II lIe 3aIIH.ITII nOKa CKOJIbRO-
HH6y)1b 3allfeTIIoro MeCTa B alITpOnOJIOrUqeCKIIX II aHTponoreHeTIIqeCKHX
IICCJIe,ZJ;OBaHHHX .8.
Ra3aJIOCb 6hI, CYM1\UIpOBaHHe pa3JIIIqIIH no BceM nOJIHMepHhIM npH3H8Rallf
)J;OJIiRIIO ,ll,aTb nOJIlIoe npe.Il;C1'aEJIelIIIe 06 HX MaCIIITa6e Me/K;:J,y cpaBHHBaeMbI-
lIfH nonyJIH:qHHMII B eJIOM, 110 3TO 6hIJIO 6hI TaR, eC.JIH 6bI npII3HaKH lIe
6hIJIH CBH3alIhI Memp;y c060ii: IIWPcpOcpH3IIOJIOrIIqeCRIIMH KOppeJIRuHHMII.
B 8TOM CJIyqae pa3JIHqIfH no MHorIIlIf npII3HaKallf qaCTO CBO)1HTCH K pa3JIHqUIO
no OIlIIOMY npII3HaRY. IIo:3ToMY P;JIH o elIKII CTenelIH 6.'1II30CTII cpaBHIIBaeMLIX
rpynn qaCTO HCnOJIb3YIOTCH pa3pa60TaHHhIe na npOTHiReIIIIH IIOCJIeIJ;IIHX
,ZJ;ecHTIIJIeTIIH ,ZJ;OBOJIbHO CJIOiRHhIe CTaTIICTIIqeCKIIe npHellfhI, B OCIIOBe KOTOphIX
50
1
".
:rreiRl1T YCTaHOBJIelIl1e MopcpOJIOrl1qeCKOH 6JIH30CTII npII IICIWIOqenIIII B3aIIMII0
49
KOppCJIIIpYIOm;UX npl13IIaKOB IIJIII, Bepuee rOBopH, rrpn yqeTe 3TOU CBH3II .
IIOCJIe Toro RaI, npO)ICJIalIa 3Ta onepal(HH, lIfomno CTaTIICTIIqeCRIl o:qeHIITb II
CTeneIIb CXOJJ:CTBa IIJTII pa3JIIIql1H no MOIIOMeplIbIM npJf3HaRaM, 110 nOJIyqelI-
HaJI IfHCPOpl\Ial(IIJI II3-3a OTMeqeHIIOH nO.D:BIIiRIIOCTI1 lIfOHOllfCplIbIX xapaRTepHC-
TIIR 6Y.D:eT yme BTopOCTcneIIIIOH. AIITpOIIOJIOrII lIe II"-IeJIII 6hI B03MOiRIIOCTII
npOBeCTIl )J;eMapRal(IfOIIIIYIO JIHmiIO MeiR):(Y )J;BYMJI RaTerOpIIJIMII npIl3IIaROB
II nOIIHTb IIX pa3IIYJO naCJIeJJ:CTBelInyIO CTPYKTYPY, a CJIe;rrOBaTeJIbIIO, II nOJIY-
'IaTb )I06pORaqeCTBeIIHYIO JflIcpOpIlIa IIIO 0 pO.D:CTBe rpynn, lIe )J;IIcpcpepeH II-
PYH npII3IIaRII, eCJIH 6w rCHeTIIqeCRHe HCCJIe.D:oBaIIIIH lIe II03BOJIIIJIII C.D:eJIaTb
3TO C OOJIbrnOH TO'IIIOCTbIO.
IIpaRTUqeCKII yn,e 3TO npOTIIBOnOCTaBJIelIlie n:BYX BII.D:OB OTJIIIqJ:fTeJIbHbIX
oc06elIHocTeH qeJIOBeqeCROrO opraIII13Ma npUBO)IIIT Hac RO BTOPOMY "BaiRIIO-
MY acneRTY rrpIIJIOmeIIIIH reHeTIIqeCKIIX )J;aUHbIX R alITpOnOJIOrIlqeCRIIM IIC-
CJIe):(OBaIIIIJIM - K YCTanOBJIeIlliIO TaRCOnOMl1qeCKOH IIepapXIIII 3THX oc06e1I1I0-
CTeII, IIX COnO;(qIIlIeIIIIIO npII BbI,ZJ;eJIeHIIII BnyTpIIrpynnoBhIX nO.D:pa3.D:eJIeHIfn
qeJIOBeqeCTBa. Ha 3ape B03IIIIKIIOBelIIIJI aIITpOnOJIOI'Im, BO ETOpOll qeTBepTII
npoulJIOrO BeRa, U3BecTHbIii: IIJBe,'J,CRIlll anTpOilOJIOr A. PeTl(UYC npe;:J:JIOiRJIJI
pa3JJ:eJIIITb Bcex JlIO)J;eii: ua ):(JIlIuIIOrOJIOBbIX - ,ll,OJIIIXOKecpaJIOB II RpyrJIOrOJIO-
BbIX - 6paXIII{ecpaJIOB 50. OCHOBaUIIeM )IJIH TaRoii: KJIaCCIIcpIIRal(IIII nOCJIYillII-
JIa 60JIbrnaH II3l\IenqIIBOCTb cpOpMbI rOJIOBbI y npe,'J,CTaBI1TeJIeH pa3IIbIX pac.
HJIaCCIIcpIIRal(IfII 3Ta OqelIb ObICTpO nplIBIIJIaCb BBnJJ:Y Y.D:06CTBa II OqCBII)J;IIOH
JlerROCTII. a IIaIIBIIaJI Bepa B 3HaqelIIIe cpOplllhI rOJIOBbI .D:JIH BbI,ll,eJIeUIIH paco-
BbIX TIIIIOB qeJIOEeqeCTBa COXpaHJIJIaCb .D:O lIe.D:aBnero BpeMeHII. Mnorl1e aHT-
pOIIOJIOrII'IeCRnC TlIIIbI, CXOLJ,ubIe BO Bcex CBOIIX npII3IIaKaX, 06'bJIllJIHJIIICb
pa3IIbIMII no npOIlCXOR{.D:8HIIIO 113-3a pa3JIUqIIll, ,ll,ame IIe60JIbillHX, B cpopMe
rOJIOBbI, II, IIa060pOT, alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIe TlInhI, IIOXOiRIIe cpOpMOH rOJIOBbI,
110 pa3JIIIqaBrnIIeCH .D:pyrIIMII oc06eIIIIOCTHMII, CqHTaJIIICb relIeTIIqeCRII 6JIII3-
KUMI1.
MeiRn:y TOM iJ,aJIbHeHrnl1e IICCJIe)J;OBaHIIH nORa3amI, qTO Ha CPOPMY rOJIOBhI
BJIJIJIIOT "'fHornc 06CTOHTe.'lbCTBa lIe TOJlbRO reHeTlIqeCROrO xapaRTepa. Olla
OqeHb 3aBIICIIT OT 1I3MelIenUll, ,ll,aR,e CJIyqaHHbIx, B CROpOCTII pOCTa, OT aBII-
TaMHII03a B )J;eTCROllf B03paCTe, na 6a3e ROToporo pa3BIIBaIOTCH paXIITIIqe-
CKIIe HBJIeIIIIJI, OT cnoc060B YXO.D:a 3a pe6eUKOM, B 'IaCTHOCTII OT nOJIOiRelIIIH
ero B ROJIbI6eJIII II ee TlIna. M3BeCTIIbI CJIY'IaII, Ror)J;a rOJIOBIIOn YRa3aTeJIb
(OTlIornelIIIe rnnpIIlIbI rOJIOBbI R ee ):(JIHlIe) pe3KO B03paCTaJI y B3pOCJIOro
IIaCeJIeHIIJI norryJIH 1I11 TOJIbRO nOTOMY, 'ITO B aToH nonYJIH IIII JJ:JIH yxo):(a 3a
IIOBOpOiRn:eulIbIM IICnOJIb30BaJIaCb Cne IIaJILHaH KOJIbI6eJlb, R KOTOPOH pe6e-
HOK KpenKO npI16IInTOBbIBaJICH 51. CJIe)J;OBaTeJlbIIO, 3TOT yRa3aTeJIb OqelIb
HeYCTOllqunbIH, II3MeIIHIOIIJ;IIHCH no.D: B.JIIIHIIIIeM cpe)J;bI npn:nIaK, II n03TOMY
Bce BLIBO):(bI 0 relIeTIIqeCROM pOJJ:CTBe paCOBbIX TIInOB, CrreJIaHHbIe IIa OCIIOBC
paCCMOTpelIIIH OJ];Horo 3Toro nplI3uaRa, MorYT OKa3aTbCH II qaCTO OKa3bIBa-
mICb nenpaBOlIfepHbIMI1. 8TO 06CTOJITeJIbCTBO B ROlIeqlIOM IITOre II npITBeJIO K
OqeHb cnepmaIIIIOMY ero IICIIOJIb30BauIIIO B paCOBbIX KJIaCCIIcpI1Kal(IIHX.
nOllfHlIfO )IalIlIbIX, CBIIJJ:eTeJIbCTBYIOm;HX 06 II3MeHelIIIHX rOJIOBIIOrO YR1l3a-
Te.:'IJI nOT( BJIIIJIIIIIeM Cpe.D:bI, 0 ero IIeBbICOKOH, RaK npIIIIHTO rOBopIITb B aH-
TPoIIOJIOrIIII, TaKCOHOMIIqeCKOll eIIIIOCTII rOBopIIT II xapaRTep ero reorpacpII-
qeCROro pacnpe,'J:eJIeIlIIH. 3JJ:CCb MbI CTaJIRIIBaellfCH YJKe C reHoreorpacpIIeH,
KOTopaH caMa no ce6e, 6e3 KaROH-JIII60 ,ll,OnOJIIIIITc.JIbIIOII IIlIcpopMa IIII 0 3a-
BIICIIMOCTH rOJIOBIIOrO YRa3aTeJIH OT cpeJJ:OBbIX B03JJeHCTBHH lIforJIa 6bI CRa-
3aTb Hallf, 'ITO 3TOT npII3IIaR He IIMeeT 60JIbrnOrO 3HaqelII1H B YCTalIOBJIelIIIH
pO.D:CTBeHHhIX B3aIIMOOTIIOillelIliH paCOBbIX TIIIIOB. Onpen:eJIelIlIbIe BapHal(IIII
rOJIOBIIOro YRa3aTeJIH lIe IIMeIOT CnJIOilllIbIX ROMnaKTlIbIX apeaJIOB, on pa -
51
,
I
i
i
.1
npe.D:8JIHeTCH .D:IfCnCpcno B reorpacpIfqeCROM OTlIOrnemfIf '2. MeiR}:(Y TeM pac-
npOCTpalIeHIfe O}IIIOpO}:(IIbIX BapIIal(IfH IIa 60JIbrnlIX IIJIOm;a.D:HX, OTpaiR8IOm;eC
pacnpOCTpanenue O (IIOPO;WbIX relIOB, rOBopUT n 06m;eH cpopMe 0 TOM, qTO
COOTneTCTBYIOIlJ;8H Bapua IIH B03IIUKJIa l(aBIIO (qeM illupe OHa pacnpUCTpanc-
na, TeM 60JILllIC Bpel\IeHII l\JlH 8Toro nOTpe6oBaJIOCb) 11 .D:0CTaTOqIIO YCTOHqU-
Ba, qT06hT conpOTUBJIHTbCH cJIyqaii:IIbIM cpeD;OBhIM B03.D:eHCTnIIHM, IInaqe 1'0-
BOpH, iReCTKO reneTIIqeCKII ,aeTepMIIIIIIpORalIa 53. STIr 06CTOHTeJIbCTBa 3IIa-
qIIT8JILnO YBeJIIPIlIBalOT ee TaKCOHOl\fIPIeCKuii BCC. BMecTo qJOpl\IM rOJIOBbI B
COBpeMelIlIon aIITpOnOJIOrIIII YQIITbIB8IOTCH TOHRIfe .D:eTaJIIf CTpoelIIIH JIIIl(a II
IIORpOBOB 54. TaKIIM oopa30M, 11 B ::JTOM CJIyqae relIeTIIqeCltIm naOJIIOD;eIIIIH IIO-
3BOJIIIJIII aUTpOIIOJIOraM CYU.(€CTnCIIIIO yconeprneIICTBonaTb CBOIO MeTO,ll,IIKY H
npII6JIII3IITb K peaJIblIOH JJ:eIICTBIITeJIbHOCTII TeOpeTIIqeCmIe ROH:qenl(IIII, oc-
HOBblBaIOIl.(IICCH lIa c06palIHbJX C IIOMO:m;bIO ;nOH MeT0.D:IfKII cpaInax.
HeT B03MOiRnOCTII cnel(uaJIbHO OCTalIaBJIIIBaTbCH IIa npIfMepax, KOTopbIe
npOIIJJJIIOCTpIIpOBaJIII 6hI, RaK IIaKOnJIenIIe reIIeTUqeCRHX 3IIalIIIH BJIIIHJIO II
BJIIIHeT lIa If3l\IelIe1IIIe npe.D:CTaBJIeHIIii 0 npOIICXOiR.D:eIIIIII qeJIOBeRa. CRameM
TOJIbKO, qTO YCT8HOBJIeIIIIe YCTOIIqIIBOCTII, 3IIaqlITeJIbuOH cTa6IIJIblIOCTII BO
BpC.MeIUI MIIOrIIX rpynn nOJIIIl\fepIIbIX npII3IIaKOB YKpenIIJIO 3HaqeHIfe MOPWO-
JIOrII'leCKOrO RpHTepJIH II B aHTponorelIe3e: IIPII nhIHCIICIUIII po.a;CTBeIIUblX
B3aIIMOOTHOillCIIlIH IfCRonaellIbIX cpOPM JIIOJJ:eII MOiRlIO BbIJ(eJIIITb npII3IIaKII C
BhICOKIIM TaKCOIIOllfIIqeCKIIM BeCOM, CXOJ(CTBO no ROTOpbIM ,ll,CHCTBIITeJIbIIO
OTpaiRaeT pea.:'IblIOe relIeTIIqeCKOe POP:CTBO 55. B 3aRJIIOqeHIIe MOfJUIO CRa-
3aTb, qTO lIe TO;;JbKO alITpOnOJIOrIIH reHeTIIKe, 110 II, Ha060pOT, reHeTIIKa aHT-
pOnOJIOI'IUI OKa3bmaeT cym;ecTBelIlIYIO IIOllfOm;b B IIIITepnpeTa:qIIJI cpaRTOB II
pa3pa60TRe 06m;IIX KOII enl(IIii KaK B 06JIaCTII paCOBep:eHIfH, TaK 11 B 06JIa-
CTII alITponorelIe3a, If ,lame B Tex pa3;l;eJIaX, r)J;e COI03 IIIeiR)J;y IIIIMII lIe npII-
BO;J:IIT R C03.D:aHIIIO IIOBbIX HaYK, KaI{ B CJIyqae C II30CepOJIOrIICH, Oil opra-
HIIqeII.
I
AHTPOIIOJIOrlm II rEHETHRA B HX BJIHHHIm HA OBIIJ;ECTBO
npII Ol(eIIRC 06Iu;eCTBelIlIoro 3H8qeIIIIH TOH IIJIII IIlIOH 06mtCTII IIayRIf IIYiRlIO
pa3JIIIqaTb .D:Ba :\'Wl\IeIITa: MeCTO, KOTopoe naYRa peaJILIIO 3alIIIMaeT B CIIJIY
onpe)J;eJIeHlIbIX KOHKpeTubIx npIIqIIII II ROTopoe HepeD;KO He COOTBeTcTByeT
no CBoeMY MacrnTa6y ee n03MOiRnOCTHM, If TO MeCTO, KOTopoe OHa .D:OJImlIa
6bIJI8 6bI 3alIIIlIfaTb B COOTBeTCTBIIIJ co CBoeH TeOpeTIIqeCROH II npaKTIIqeCROM
pOJIbIO. MhI OCTaHORIIMCH IIMCIIIIO 118 nOCJIe.D:IIeM CJIyqae, TaR KaK OH npe)J;-
CTaB.:'IHeTCH naII60JIee aRTyaJIblIbIM. 0 TeClIoii CBH3If alITpOnOJIOrIIII C rene-
TIIROI. II3pHP:HO 3a6hIJIII, a BMeCTe C 8TIIM 3a6hI.J:1I II 06 IIX 06u.\ecTBelIHoM
3IIaqeHIIII.
0110 npOHBJIHeTCH B )J;BYX OCHonnbIX acneRTax. nepBbIH - TeOpeTIIqeCROe
lIfIIpOB033PCIIqCCROe 3UaqelIIIe alITpono.lIOrIIII II aIlTpOnOreHCTIIRJI, J(aIOm;ee
B03MOiRIIOCTb qeJJOBeRY OC03IIaTb CBoe IICTOpIIqeCKOe MeCTO B 8BOJIIO IIOnIIOM
npOl(eCce Ha nJIalIeTe, B3neCIITb peaJIblIYIO BepOHTHOCTb cym;eCTBOBaHIIH BIIe-
3eMIIbIX I..(IIBIIJIII3a IIii:, o eHIITh 3aKOlIOMepnOCTII 6IIOJIOrIIqeCRoii: 8BOJIIOl(IIII
IIO.D:06IIhIX qeJIOBeRY cym;eCTB II npe)l.eJIhI OTRJIOlIelIIIll IIX CPII3IIqCCROrO CTpoe-
HIfH OT 06pa3a COBpeMelIHbIX JIIO;'J,eH, nOTIHTb B3aIIlIfnyIO pOJIb 6HOJIOrIIqeCRO-
1'0 11 CO IIaJIbHOrO B COBpeMelIlIOM 06m;eCTEe, npeJIBIID;eTb, IIaRone . 6YD:Ym;ee
pa3BIITIIe cpII3IIqeCKOrO TIIIIa COBpellfeUHoro qeJIOBeRa 56. 060ra:m;eHlIbIe re-
IIeTIIqeCRlIMII Ha6JIIOJJ:eIIIIHMJI npe.D:CTaBJIeHIIH 0 cpIIJIOrelIeTIIqeCKllX B38IIMOOT-
HOilleHIIHX II reneTIIqeCKJIX CBH3HX .D:peBUeHrnIIX 11 COBpeMeUIIblX alITpono-
JIOrIIqeCRIIX TIInOB COCTaB.:'IHIOT TY 6IIOJIOrIIqeCKYIO OCHOBY, Ha ROTOPYIO
52
llaJIOaamCH. n03:'IHee OTOpBanllUlCb QT IIee, IlCTOpIlqeCKIIii: npoQecc. IlCTOpIlIO
.D:peBIIellrnero qClIOBeqeCTna He nOIIHTb, ec.;n;r lIe nOMHIITb Bce BpeMH, qTO
nporpccc B OOJIaCTII ItYJIbTypbI IIa npOTHmelIIHI ncero IIII1KIIero naJIeOJIIITa
conpOllOIK.'J,a;rICH IIHTenCUBTTbIM pa3BIITneM cpII3I1qeCrWro Tuna IIOCIITeJIeH
RYJIbTyphI - ;'J,peBlIeiirnIIX JlIO;J,eH, KOTopoe .D:O KaKOII-TO CTeneUII 6bIJIO npe,'J;-
nOCbIJIKOIJ KYJILTypuoro paanUTUH. II TOJlbRO C nOHBJIeHIleM qeJIOBeKa COBpe-
MeHnoro Tlina ;=na CBH3b pa30pna.lIaCb 57.
J];pyroij acneKT 06u-ieCTBenHoro 3IIaqeIIIIH aHTpOnOJIOrUII Il relIeTlfKII B
IlX B3aUMOCBH3II - cyry60 rrpaRTIIqeCKIIH. PacnpocTpalIelIue II yqeT BpeJJ,-
HbIX lIIYTal(uii, npe0.D:o.;;:elIlle TeII,'J;eIIl(IIIl K pO.D:CTBeHI-lbIM 6paKaM B MaJIhIX
Il30JIIIpOnaHHbIx IIOnYJIH IIHX, relIenIqeCKaH KOHCYJlbTal(IlH no CIlCTeMaM,
B IWTOPhIX rrepexo;'l; pe eccIlBlIbIX r.::mOB B rOM03IIrOTtIOe COCTOHIIIIe MarKeT
npllBeCTII K THmeJIhIM OCJlOrt\:H€IIIIHM II .D:ame R CMepTII, IIeCOBMeCTHMOCTb
lIfaTepH II nJIo,ZJ;a no CIICTeMaM KpOBII (IIanpIlMep, no CIICTeMe pe3YC), II3YQe-
HIle BJIIIHuUH qllc.lIelIlIOCTU OTJJ,eJIbJ;bIX 8TImq€CItIlX rpynn na IlX p:eMorpaqm-
qeCRYIO CTPYKTYPY, HCnOJlb30BalUIe aIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX If reUeTIlqeCKIIX
)J,aIIHbIX ,ll,JIH 60pb6bI C Bpe)J;I-lbIMII 6hITOBbUIII Il peJlIIrII03HbIMII nepeiRIlTKa-
lIflf - BOT .D:aJleKO lIe nOJIlIhIII nepe'IeHb BaiRHeHrnIIX npaKTHqeCRIIX 3a.D:aq,
nepa3p.3rnIlMbIX 6e3 rnIlpoRoii IIlIcpOplVIal(lfIl, npe.D:OCT8BJIHeMOH anTpOnOJIOrH-
'IeCKU:\fII II reneTIIqeCRIIMII IICCJI€;rJ:onaIIIIHMII 58.
CBH3b 8TIIX IICCJIe.D:OBaHlIii MeiR,ZJ;Y c060ii, CBH3b TeClIaH II HenocpeJJ:CTneH-
lIaH, OC03IIana BO Muorux CTpanax 59. B aIITpOlIOJIOI'llIO YiRe illIlpOKO npo-
HHRJIII Il em;e IllIfpe npOIIIIKaIOT reHeTIIqeCRIIe M'eTO,ZJ;bI, aHTponorelIeTHRa II
06:m;aH relIeTIIKa IIIITeHCnnHO nOJIb3YIOTCH aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIMIl ,ZJ;aUlIhJMII 60.
MeiR!J:Y Tellf B IIarneH CTpane, HeCMOTpH ,'J;8iRe lIa 6bICTpoe pa3BunIe relIeTII-
Rlf 3a nOCJle,ZJ;uIIe rOAM, alITponOrelIeTlIKa pa3pa6aThIBaeTCH JIIIrnb B IIeKOTO-
pbIX CBOIIX pa3)J,eJIaX, CBH3alIlIbIX C Me)J;IIl(IIIIOH. qTO iRe KacaeTCH norryJIH-
nUOHIIOH relIeTIutII, TO olla pa3BIIBaeTCH Me)J;JIeUIIO, HeClIfOTpH na, R83aJIOCb
6h1, orpOMHbIe B03I1fOiRIIOCTII, ROTOPbI€ npe)J;OCTaB.;IHIOT en allTponOJIOrUqeCKIIe
IlCCJle.D:OBaEIIH. ITOJIb3a B3aIIMonpolIIIKHOBeHHH relIeTIIqeCKIIX II aIITpOnOJIOrll-
QeCRIIX MeTOJ],OB, nJIO)J,OTBOpIIOCTb YBH3I_II 06m;erelIeTlPleCKIIX (I[ aIITpOlIOJIOrII-
"IeCKIIX IWH enQI1n, y1Ke )J;OCTlIrUYTbIe CPYII)J;aMeUTaJIbnbIe pe3YJILTaThI TaROH
YBH3KII B BII;J;e rpOMa.D:IIbIX YClIeXOB IIOBOH, B03HIIKrneH Ha I1X CThIRe )J,IIC Hn-
.TlI1Hhl - I130CepOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeKa, a TamKe relIoreorpacpIlII IIeCOMlIelIlIbI.
MOiRlIO IIa.D:eHTbCH, 'ITO J],aJIbUeHrnee pa3BIITIIC I1CCJIe)J,OBaIIHH B YKa3aHIIbIX
nanpaBJIeHIIHX 06craniT aIJTpOnOJIOrIIIO. [J B qaCTHOCTn paCOBeJ],eIIIIe, C O.D:-
110M CTOpOHbI, alITpolIoreneTIIKy II 06m;yIO relIeTIIRY - C )J;PyroH, IIOBbIMU
nJIo)J,oTBOplIbIMII KOHHen IIHMII II ;'J,OCTIIiReIIIIHMII.
1 Benser S. Fine structure of a genetic region in bacteriophage II Proc. Natur. Acad.
Sci. Wash. (D. C.), 1955. Vol. 41: Idem. On the topologv of genetic fine structure II
Ibid. 1959. Vol. 45. CJIep;yeT nOiI'IepKHYTb, '1TO CJI01KHoe. CTpOeHII(' reHa 6bIJIO rrO'lTII
40 JIeT Ha3a,[( npe,I1CKa3aHO 3aMe'1aTeJIbHbJM COBeTCKIIM reHeTIIKOM A. C. CepeOpOBCKIIM.
CM.: Cepe6poBcnuz'i. A. C. BmmHlle reHa purple Ha crossing-over Me1K,[(Y black H
cinnobar y Drosophila melanogaster II lliYPH. :mcrrepIIJII. OIIOJIOrlIlI. Cep. A. 1926.
T 2, BbJlI. 1/2; 01i :J/Ce. IICCJIep:oBalure cTyrrerr'lRTo,"o aJIJIe:ImwPcPlI3Ma If Ta:u 1Ke. 1930.
T. 6, BbIrr. 2; Cepe6poBcnuu A. C., /{y6ulIu1i H. n. IfCKyccTBeHHoe rrOJIY'leHHe MYTa-
l.\lIll II rrp06JIeMa reHa II ¥crrexlI :mcrrepml. OHOJIOrllll. 1929. BbIlI. 4. A. C. Cepe6poB-
ClmH - THrrH'IHbIH Y'IeHbIii-pOMaHTIIK, OH BHec orpOMHbIlJ BKJIa,[( B TeOpeTH'leCKYIO re-
EeTlmy II 06oraUI.'I ee pnp;mI cPYH;:\a:\IeHTa:rbHbIx ROHl.\errl\lIii. C.: lllanupo H. 1I. Ha-
lIIHTII A. C. CepeopoBcKoro II reHeTIIKa. 1966. oM 9; Ma.ulIioBcKuu A. A. R Borrpocy 0
rrYTHX HCCJIe,[(OBaHHH YCJIOBHH TBOp'leCKOrO npOl\eCca II HaY'lHOe TBOp'leCTBO. Moo 1969.
2 I1C'IeprrbIBaIOIIIlle CBO,I1KII HaKOrrJIeHHbIX ;\IaTeplIaJIOB OTCYTCTBYIOT. qacTH'IHO ;)TOT rrpo-
6e.1J 3arrOJIHeH B cJIe,[(. 1I3,'];.: Eickstedt R. Rassengeschichte der Menscheit. Stuttgart.
1934; BiaSlltti K. Ri'zze i popoli deUa tena: In 4 vol. Torino. 1959-1960; Lllnd.mon B.
Umriss der Rassenkunde des Menschen in geschichtlicher Zeit. Koppenhagen, 1952;
53
Idem. Geographische \nthropologie. Stuttgart, 1968; AAencecB B. n. reorpacPlIH 'Te-
JIOBe'leCKlIX pac. M., 1974.
3 MOllrant A. The distribution of human blood groups. Oxford, 1954; Walter H. Die
Bedeutung der serologischen Merkmale IiiI' die Rassenkunde II Die neue Rassenkunde
jHrsg. I. Schwidetzky. Stuttgart, 1962; Harrison G., Weiner J., Tanner I., Barnicot N.
Human biology: An introd. to human evolution, variation and growth. N. Y.; L.. 1964;
pyc. lIep.: Xappucon J{:!IC., Bau1iep J{:!IC., Tannep J{:!IC., Bap1iunoT H. ElIo':IOrnH '1eJIOBe-
Ka. M., 1968; Prokop O. Lehrbuch del' menschlichen Blut- und Serumgruppen. Leip-
zig, 1966; Boponoe A. A. ::hHoreorpacPrrH OCHOBHbIX TlInOB ranTorJI06IIHa - CbIBOpo-
TO'IHoro OeJIKa KpOBII II COB. 3THorpacPHH. 1968. oM 2. 3TlI 06JIaCTIl aHTpOnOJIOrnn nplI-
B.lIeKalOT ceii'lac BHII)!aHne BO BceJ\! J\IIIpe, II JIIITepaTypa pacTeT c cPaHTaCTll'leCKOii
6bICTpOTOii.
4 1I0cJIe lIepBbIX pa60T 3. Rpe'lMepa, BQ MHorOM CKJIOHHOrO, O,I1HaKO, R RpaHHIIM B3rJIH-
)J;aM, 1I0HBIIJIIICb CTaTblI, 1I0CTaBrrBllilIe npOOJIeMY B pa)!KII TO'lHOro 3KcnepIDIeHTaJIb-
Horo IICCJIep;OBaHmI. CM.: POZU1iCKUU H. H. MaTeplIaJIbI no HCCJIe)J;OBaHHIO CBH31I Te-
JIOCJI01KeHIIH II MOTOplIKII II AHTpOIIOJI. 1KYPH. 1937. J'l1; 3; MaAunoBcKuu A. A. 3JIeMeH-
TapHbIe ROppeJIHI.(1I1I II 1I3MeH'IIIBOCTb '1eJIOBe'leCKOrO opraHII3Ma II Tp. I1H-Ta l\IITOJIO-
rlIlI, rlICTOJIOrlIH II 3M6pIIOJIOrlIlI. 1948. T. 2, BbIll. 1. HeCKOJIbKO IIHOH acrreRT npooJIe-
MbI paccMoTpeH B KHlIre H. H. PorHHcRoro, B rJIaBe «0 TlIlIax xapaKTepa II IIX 3Ha'le-
HHII B TeoplIlI aHTponoreHe3a». CM.: PozuncKuu H. H. IIp06JIeMbI aHTponoreHe3a. M.,
1969. .
& 0611ilIpHbIe CBep;eHIIH 06 IICKorraeMbIX HaXO)J;Kax CYMMllpoBaHbI: Heberer G. Die Fossil-
geschichte del' Hominoidea II Primatologia: Handbuch del' Primatenkunde/Hrsg.
H. Hofer, A. Schultz, D. Starck. Basel; N. Y., 1956; Piveteau J. Primates. Paleontolo-
gie humaine IllTraite de paleontologie. P., 1957. T. 7; Gieseler W. Die Fossilgeschich-
te des Mencshen II 1)ie Evolution dn Organismen. Stuttgart, 1959. Bd. 2; HCKOrraeMbIe
rOMIIHII):1bI II npOIICX01K)J;eHlIe '1eJIOBeKa II Tp. I1H-Ta 3THorpacPIIII AH CCCP. H.C. M.,
1966. T. 92; AAenceeB B. n. lIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrlIH 3eJ\IHoro lIIapa II cPOpMlIpoBaHlIe
'1eJIOBe'leCKHX pac. HaJIeOJIIIT. M., 1978.
6 CM.: POZU1icnUU H. H. IIpOOJIe)lbI aHTporroreHe3a. rJI. II.
7 Becb OTHOCHIT(IIHCH cIO)J;a MaTeplIaJI pa30pocaH rro COTHHM cnel\lIaJIbHbIX cTaTeH H Mo-
HorpacP lIH . B Ka'leCTBe CBOP;OK, )J;aJIeKO He nOJIHbIX. HO cO)J;ep1KaIT(HX OCHOBHYIO 6110-
JIJWrpacP lIIO , CM.: Social life of early man II Viking fund publications in anthropology.
N. Y., 1961. N 31; rpUZopbeB r. n. Ha'laJIo BepXHero rraJIeOJIIITa II npOIICX01K)J;eHHe
Homo sapiens. JI., 1968; Hpllpop;a II pa3BlITIIe rrepB06bITHoro 06IT(eCTBa Ha TepplIToplIlI
eBporreHcKoii '1aCTII CCCP. M., 1969 (cTaTblI A. A. BeJIH'IKo II M. ,lJ,. rB03p;oBep,
r. II. rpllropbeBa II A. H. POra'leBa); Bu6unoB C. H. HeKoTopbIe acrreKTbI rraJIe03KO-
JIOrlI'IeCKOrO MO)J;eJIlIpOBaHIIH rraJIeOJIIITa II COB. apXeOJIOrIIH. 1969. oM 4.
8 CBO)J;KII ,I1aHHbIX II JIIITepaTYPY CM.: 3ifjpOUMC01i B. n. BBe)J;eHlIe B Me)J;IIl\IIHCKYIO reHe-
TIIKY. M., 1968; l(01i10XOB B. B. EIIOJIOrll'leCROe J\1O)J;eJIIIpOBaHlIe HaCJIep;CTBeHHbIX 60-
JIe3HeH '1eJIOBeKa. M., 1969; OCHOBbI l\IIToreHeTIIKII '1eJIOBeKa. M., 1969; Hp06JIeMbI Me-
iI lI l\IIHCKOii reHeTIIKII. M., 1970; HepcrreKTIIBbI Mep;IIl\IIHCKOH reHeTIIRH. M., 1982.
9 RpaTKlIH 0030P OTHOCHIT(IIXCH CIO,I1a np06JIeM CM.: AAeKceeB B. n. reHoreorpacP lIH '1e-
JIOBeKa II HaYKa II'Ie.:rOBe'leCTBO. M., 1968.
10 HaH60JIbIllee BHIIMaHlle B aHTporroreHeTIIKe Bcerp;a IIpllBJIeKaJIII 1I30JIHl\IIH H ee BJIIIH-
Hlle Ha reHeTII'IeCKYIO CTpYKTYPY rrorrYJIHl\IIH. Pe3YJIbTaTbI KOHKpeTHbIX IICCJIep;OBaHlIii
nI. B CJIep;. pa60Tax: rU1ia6ypz B. B. rOpHbIe Ta,I11KIIKII: (MaTepIIaJIbI no aHTpOIIOJIO-
rHII Tap;1KIIKOB RapaTeI'lIHa II .D:apBa3a). M.; JI.. 1937; r:lass B., Sacks 111., Jahn R.,
Hess C. Genetic drift in a religious isolate: an analysis of the causes of variation in
blood group and other gene frequencies in a small population II ArneI'. Natur. 1952.
Vol. 86, N 828; Readings on race. Springfield (Ill.), 1960; Hainline J. Polulation and'
genetic (serological) variability in Micronesia II Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 1966. Vol. 134,
art. 2; Giles E., Walsh R., Bradley M. Microevolution in New Guinea; the role of ge-
netics drift Ii Ibid.: l'aoJICueB A. H. AUTpOIIOJWrIIH :uaJIbIX IIonYJlH lIii: ]J,arecTana.
Maxa'lKaJIa, 1971; PbPlKoe /0. r. AHTpOnOJIOrlIH II reHeTIIRa H30JIlIpOBaHHbIX nonYJIH-
l\IIH (I1peUHlIe 1I30JIHTbI HaMllpa). M., 19C9. OOIT(aH nOCTaHOiJRa Bonpoca: Glass /J.
Genetic changes in human population, especially those due to gene flow and genetic
drift II Adv. Genet. N. Y., 1954. Vol. 6. CIITyaJ:(HH naHMHKCHII II ee pOJIb B paco06pa-
30BaHIIII MCCJIep;OBaHbI 3Ha'lHTeJIbHO MeHbIlle. 06IT(ee paccMoTpeHlle IIpOOJIeMbI CM.:-
AAeKceeB B. n. MOP;YCbI paco06pa30BaHIIH II reorpacPlI'leCKOe pacnpoCTpaHeHIIe reHOB
paCOBbIX apII3HaKoBIICOB. 3THorpacPlIH. 1967. oM 1.
11 CM., Ha'1p.: A y6UliU1i H. n., r.7e.M601{KUii H. .1. renenIKa nOIIY:Ull\lIii If CeJIeK I I HH
M., 1967. .D:aHHbIe 0 reorpacPII'IecKQ)I pacnpocTpaHeHlI1I rpynn KpOBII Y '1eJIOBeKa HC-
IIOJIb30BaHbI )J;JIH OCBeIT(eHIIH pOJIII reHeTIIRo-aBTOMRTlI'leCKIIX npOl\eCCOB B YCJIOBIIHX.
OTCYTCTBIIH CeJIeKl\1I1I (rJI. IV. C. 62-70).
54
A
[
12 Ha 9TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO 06paTIIJIII BHIIMaHlIe He3aBIICIIMO J\Pyr OT J\pyra HeCKOJIbKO
IIccJIeJ\oBaTeJIeli, paCCMOTpeBIIIIIX ero C pa3HbIX TO'leK 3peHIIH: P03U1iCKUU H. H. IIp06-
JIeMa rrpOIICX01KJ\eHIIH Homo sapiens II Ycrrenr COBpeM. 61I0JIorlIII. 1938. T. 9, BbIII. 1
(4); 01i :!ICe. HeKoTopbIe rrp06.lIeMbI rr03J\HeiiIllero 9Talla 3BOJIIOl\1I1I '1eJIOBeKa B cOBpe-
MeHHoii aHTpOrrOJIOrllll II Tp. I1H-Ta 3HTOrpacPIIII AH CCCP. H. C. M.; J1., 1947. T. 2;
HpeJMt1iCnUU B. A. IIepexoJ\ OT Be,[(YJ::l\eii pOJIII oT60pa K BeP;YJ::l\eii pOJIlI Tpyp;a II YClIe-
XII cOBpeM. 61I0JIOrlIlI. 1941. T. 14, BbIlI. 2(5); J{aBuOel-tKOe C. M. 3BOJIIOl\IIOHHO-reHe-
TM'IeCRMe rrp06JIeMbI B HeBpOrraTOJIOrlIlI. J1., 1947.
13 OHO HaIlIJIO OTpaTh:eHlIe B "Ienllll 0 IIOOCcPepe. CM.: YClIeXII COBpeM. OHOJIOrulI. 1944.
T. 18, BbIlI. 2. TepMIIH 3aHMCTBOBaH Y E. J1epya: Le Roy E. L'exigence idealiste et Ie
fuit d'evolution. P., 1927. B IIp;eaJIIICTH'IeCKOM J\yxe ero pa3BIIBaJI H. TeiiJIp p;e IIIap-
p;eH B RHlIre «<1JeHOJ\IeH '1eJIOBeKa» (M., 1965; 2-e 1I3,[(. M., 1987). 0 ero MIIpOB033peHIIH
CM.: n./tY:!ICa1iCKIlU T. HeKOTOpbIe '1epTbI B033peHIIii TeiiHpa J\e IIIapp;eHa IIOT 3pa3Ma
POTTepJ\aMcKoro p;o EepTpaHa PacceJIa. M., 1969. B COBpmIeHHOii HaYKe rrOHHTlIe 0
HooccPepe 3aHIIJ\raeT Bce 60JIbIlIee MeCTO. CM., Harrp.: YpcY./t A. iI.. OCBOeHlIe KOCMoca:
<1JIIJIOc.-MeTOp;OJI. II COl\1I0JI. acrreRTbI. M., 1967; Tp YCOB 10. n. HOHHTlle 0 HooccPepe II
IIplIpoJ\a II 06J::l\eCTBo. M., 1968 (rrp06JIeMbI HooccPepbI RacaIOTCH II p;pyrHe CTaTbH
C60pHHRa); A./teKceee B. n. OT 1KIIBOTHbIX - K '1eJIOBeKY. J1ereH,[(bI, cPaKTbI, HaYKa. M.,
1969; On :!ICe. CTaHOBJIeHlle 'IeJIOBe'leCTBa. M., 1984.
u BorrpOCbI 9TH He rrOJIY'lHJIH, op;HaKO. P;O CIIX rrop CKOJIbRO-HIIOYJJ:b rJIYOOKOll: Ha "IHOii
pa3pa60TRH.
15 HpeKpaCHblii IIplIMep 9Hp;oraMIIII KaK reHeTH'IeCROrO 6apbepa HaOJIIOp;aeTCH. B ,I1are-
CTaHCKIIX CeJIeHIIHX. CM.: JIaBpoe JI. 11. 0 rrpH'IIIHaX J\IHorOH3bI'IIIH B J];areCTaHe II
COB. 3THorpacPlIH. 1951. N2 2.
16 Borrpoc rrO'lTII IIC'IeprrbIBaIOJ::l\e paccMoTpeH O,[(HII I 1I3 KpYIIHeiilIIIIx cOBpeMeHHbIx Teo-
peTIIKoB 3BOJIIOl\IIOHHOro Y'IeHIIH - 3. Mall:pm1. CM.: Mayr E. Animal species and evo-
lution. Cambridge (Mass.), 1965; pyc. rrep.: Maup a. 300JIOrH'IeCKIIll: BlIP; II 3BOJIIOl\HH.
M., 1968.
17 B 06J::l\eii cPopMe IIp06JIeMa He oocY1Kp;aJIaCb CKOJIbKO-HII6YP;L rro'[(pOOHO, O'ieBII,[(HO, 110-
TOMY, '1TO OHa TpeoyeT P;JIH CBoero rrpOHCHeHIIH KOJIJIeKTIIBHbIX YCIIJIIIH MbICJIII reHe-
TlIKOB II IICTOpIIKOB, peJ\RO rrplIXoJ\HID;IIX B Ha "IHbIiI KOHTaKT. 0 JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIX re-
HeTII'IeCKIIX 6apbepax crrel\lIaJIbHO CM.: Hulse F. Linguistic barriers to gene - flow II
ArneI'. J. Phys. Anthropol. N. S. 1957. Vol. 15, N 2. 3THII'IeCKIIH !}JaKTop B Ka'leCTBe
reHeTH'leCKOrO 6apbepa Y'lIITbIBaeTCJI BO Bcex ROHRpeTHbIx IICCJIep;OBaHIIJIX rro aHTpo-
rroreHeTIIKe (CM., B '1aCTHOCTII, pa60TbI, rrepe'lIlCJIeHHbIe B rrpIIMe'l. 10). 3TO TeM 60JIee
He06xop;lIJ\w, rrOCKOJIbRY pOJIb crrel\lIcPlI'IeCRH reorpacPH'IeCKIIX 6apbepoB y '1eJIOBeKa.
RaR y1Ke YKa3bIBaJIOCb, HeBeJIIIRa. IIpep;lIoJIaraJIocb, HarrpHMep, '1TO PellH CJIY}JmT cy-
J::l\ecTBeHHbIM reHeTII'IeCKlIM 6apLepoM, pa3ileJIJIIOJ::l\IIM HaCeJIeHlIe o60llx 6eperoB. CM.:
Wolf lrI. Del' Rhein als Heirats - lInd Wandergrenze 1/ Homo. 1951t Bd. 7, H. 1. 1l03:\-
Hee 9Ta TO'lKa 3peHHH CTaJIa ocrrapllBaTbcH, II, rro-BII,[(H IOMY, BrrOJIHe crrpaBep;JIIIBO,
B CBeTe BHOBb c06paHHbIX p;aHHbIX. C r.: fV"lter /l., Amdt-Hflnser A. Populationsge-
netische Untersuchungen im Mittelrhein - Gebiet II Homo. 1967. Beih. 2.
18 qacTHbIH CJIY'laII OTKpbITorO II CcPopMymIpoBaHHoro H. 11. BaBIIJIOBbIM 3aKOHa OTHe-
celIIIH pel\eCClIBIIbIX reHOB Ha OKpaIIHY BJIp;OBOrO apeaJIa: BaBu./toB H. II. feorpacPII-
qeCKlIe 3aKoHoJ\IepHOCTlI B pacIIpe,[(eJIeHlIII reHOB KYJIbTypHbIX paCTeHJIlI 1/ HpHpop;a.
1927. oM 10. OH jRe BIIepBble rrpIIJ\IeHHJI 9TOT 3aKOH J. '1eJIOBeKY, YKa3aB Ha cpaBHII-
TeJIbHO CBeT.rrylO IIIIrMeHTal\IIIO HypllcTaHl\l'B KaI. Ha pe3y:rbTaT BHerrIHero BbJHBJIe-
HIIH pel\eCCIIBHbIX renOB B YCJIOBIIHX II30JIHl\HIL ClVI.: BaBu.wB H. II., Bynunu'l l1.. ll,.
3eMJIep;eJIb'leCKIIH AcPraHHcTaH. J1.. 1929. H03}J\e C rr03Hl\IIll: 3Toro 3aKOHa 6bIJIII 06"1>-
JICHeHbI oc06eHHocTu IIIIr reHTaQlIIr HaCeJIeHIIH CeBepHoii EBpOIIbI (lJ e6or.:ca-
pOB H. H. 113 IICTomllI CBl'TJIbIX paCOBbIX TIIIIOB EBpa3IIII 1/ AHTpOIIOJI. }J\ypH. 1936.
;jIj 2), ,l],arecTaHa (Faa.JICUeB A. r. HPOlICX01Kp;eIIHe Hapop;oB J],arecTaHa rro ,I1aHHbIM
aHTpOrrOJIOrllll. Maxa'IKaJIa, 1965). BcelI EBporrbI (A./teKceeB B. n. feHeTIIKa II aHTpo-
1I0JIOrlIH 1/ HaYRa II 1KH3Hb. 1969. oM 9).
19 3TO Ba1KHOe JIB:reHlle 6blJI0 npO,I1eJ\IOHCTpllpOBaHO II TeOpeTH'IeCKII 06'bJICHeHO
M. B. l'IrHaTbeBbIM. CM.: IJ31iaTbeB M. B. CTaTIICTII'IeCKHe KOHCTanTbI B 1I30JIlIpOBaH-
HOll: rrorrYJIHl\IIII II AHTpOrrOJI. 1KYPH. 1937. oM 2: On :!ICe. lICCJIe,[(oBaHIIH rro reHeTII'Ie-
CROMY anamI3Y rronYJIHl\IIll: II ¥'1eH. 3arr. Mf}T. 1940. BbIll. 34.
"20 TaRoe IICCJIep;OBaHue ObIJIO crrel\lIaJIbHO oCYJ::l\eCTBJIeHO 10. f. PbI'IKOBbIM rrplI reHH-
TeJIbHO K ,I1peBHOcTII 1130JIJID;1I1I Ha RaBRa3e II IIaMIIpe. CM.: Pbt'lKOB 10. r. AHTpOIIO-
JIOrII'IeCKOe IICCJIe,[(oBaHlIe rrpol\ecca 1130JIHl\1I1I Ha IIaMlIpe II RaBKa3e JI J];OKJI. Ha
VII Me}J\JJ:YHap. KOHrp. aIITpOIIOJI. II 9Trrorp. HaYK. Moo 1964; On :!ICe. AHTpOrrOJIOrlIH
II reHeTIIKa 1I30JIIIpOBaHHbIx rroIIYJIJIl\IIH (fJI. VI).
.21 CM.: naCeKOB B. n. 0 HeKOTopbIX pe3YJIbTaTaX p;eiiCTBIIH 1I30JIHD;1I1I II Borrp. aHTpo-
rrOJIOrlIlI. 1967. BbIrr. 27.
55
:;
r
22 CM.: Kirk R. PopIIlation genetic studies in Australia and New Guinea ff The biology
of human adaptability. Oxford, t 967.
23 !jYHan B. B. 1131wH'IUBOCTb cmra'!II'1eCKIIX nplI3HaKoB B MaJIbIX IIonYJIHl\IIHX Il IIpO-
OJIeMbI TaKCOHO!I1I1I /1 ,D,oKJI. Ha \' II Mem;rYHap. I>OHrp. 3IITpOIIOJI. II 3THorp. IIay It;
(i1i :!ICe. 113Y'lelIlIe 1IaJIbIX nonymIl\IIM B aIlTpOrrOJIOrIIU II Ronp. aIITpoTTOJIOI'IIII. 1965.
BblTT. 21; }f{o.Moea B. If. l\IaTepUaJILI IIO 1I3Y'leHIIIO I>pyra 6pa'lHLIX CBH3err B pYCCKmI
rraCeJIeHIIII II TaM jRe; A.MHceeB B. n. IIonYJIHl\IIOIIIIaH CTpYKTypa '1eJIOBe'leCTBa II
IICTOpII'IeCIiaH aIITpOHOJIOrlIH II COB. apXeOJIOrIIH. 1970. .\12 4.
2 A.wHceee B. n. 0 Hl'KOTOpbIX rrOJIOfKeHIJHX pacoBoro aHaJIII3a:,! BOIIp. aIITpOnOJIO-
rIIII. 1962. Bun. 9; 01i :J/Ce. R OoocHoBaHIIIO IIonYJIHI:\IIOIIHOH KOHl\enl\IIJI paCbI II IIpo-
OJIC1IbI 3BOJIIOl\1I11 '1c.:rOBPKa II ero pac. M.. l!16S.
25 CrrpJ:(IIaJIbHbLX paOOT, IIOCBHll\eIIIIUX rraHOJIKY1IeHHOMY OU30PY paCOBbIX TIIIIOB CMe-
marrHoro IIpOJICX01Kp;eHHH, HeT. ,l],aHlIbw 0 IIITX 1I0amo rrO'leplmYTb B paOOTax, YRa-
3aHHbIX B npHMe'l. 2. B p;OnOJIrreHHe R mDI C1I.: Garn S. Human races. Springfield
(IlL), 1962.
26 CBOAKY MeTpll'lPCKIIX p;aHHbIX rro CMemaHHbUI rpyurraM C1L: Trevor I. Rase crossing
in man II Eugen. Lab. Mem. Cambridge, 1953. Vol. 36. 0 reTl'p03lICe CJ\L: Hlllse F.
Exogamie et heterosis II Arch. suisse d'anthropol. gen. 1957. T. 22.
27 <!JOpMbI BrrYTpIIBIIP;OBOii 1I3MeH'IIIBOCTII II xapaKTep reorpacPll'leCKOrO pacrrpOCTpaHe-
HIIH reHOB IIamJIlI OTpaaH'HlIe B cPOPMYJIllpOBKe rIIIIOTe3bI 0 Mop;ycax pacooopa30Ba-
HIIH. Cu.: AAenceeB B. n. MO,I1yCbI pacooopa30BaUIIH II reorpacPlI'IeCKOe pacrrpOCTpa-
HeHlIe reHOB paCOBbIX npJI3HaKOB.
28 CYIl\eCTByeT HeCKOJIbKO CBOiJ:OK rro reHeTIIKe OTJWJIbHbIX rrpIl3HaKOB, HalIp.: Handbuch
del' Erbbiologie des Menschen. Bd. 2. Methodik. Genetik del' Gesamtperson. B., 19'10;
Gates R. Human genetics. In 2 vol. X. Y., 1946; Humangenetik: Ein kurzses Hand-
blIch: In 5 Bd.jHrsg. P. Beckel'. Stuttgart, 1964-1969.
29 OOIl\YIO xapaRTepUCTIIKY OJIII3Hel\OBOrO MeT0JJ:a HCCJIep;OBaHIIH CM.: Ka1iaeB II. 1I.
BmI3Hel\bI: (O'lepKIJ rro BorrpocaM MHOrOrrJIO,I1I1H). M.; J1., 1959; OH :!ICe. BJIII3HeI{bI II
reHeTIIKa. J1., 1968.
30 BOAOlfNOU M. B. BmI3Hel\OBbIrr MeTOp; II rrpOOJIeMaIl3MeH.IIIBOCTII reHOB II AHTpOnOJI.
}J'YPH. 1937. oM 2.
31 CM. npHJ\Ie'l. 8. J1I1TepaTypa, Op;IIaKO. pacTPT C IICKJIIO'IJITeJIbHOM ObICTpOTOH, II Ka}J{-
):1bIM HOBbIii HOMep JII060ro reHeTII'IPCKOrO 1KyplIa.:ra rrpllHOCllT HOBbie cPaKTbI.
32 Ford E. Polymorphism and taxonomy /1 The new systematics. L.; Oxford, 1940; Idem.
Polymorphism II BioI. Rev. 1945. Vol. 20.
33 BOJIee rr03p;Hee oocY1K,I1eHIIe rrpOOJIeMbI C Y'IeTOM cOBpeMeHHoro COCTOHHIfH HaYKII
CM.: Allison A. Aspects of polymorphism in man II Cold Spring Harbor Symp. on
Quant. Bioi., 1955. Vol. 20.
3 CM. 0630pbI. npaBp;a Y1Ke YCTapeBmlle: Vogel F. Blutkrankheiten und ihre Bedeu-
tung 1/ Bpr. iiber die 6. Tag. Dt. Ges. Anthropol. in KieI 19;)8. G6ttingcn; B.; Frank-
furt a. M., 1959; BopoHoB A. A. AHOMaJIbHbIe rmlOrJIOOIIIIbI II Bonp. aHTpOnOJIOrllll.
1964. BbIlI. 17.
35 reorpacPlI'IeCKOe pacrrpOCTpaHeHHe 9TIIX IIplI3HaKOB n0,I1p06HO oCBell\eHo B paoOTax.
IIpIIBe):1eHHbIx B IIpIIMe'l. 3.
36 0030pbI CM.: Roberts T. The anthropological significance of the relationship between
blood groups and disease II Bel'. iiber die 6. Tag. Dt. Ges. Anthropol. in Kiel. 1958;
Clarke C. Blood groups and disease II Progress in medical genetics. N. Y., 1962; Pyc..
IlI:p. B KH.: llirepn If. OCHOBbI reHeTI!KII '1eJIOBeKa. M.. 1965.
37 TaKaH rllrrOTe3a 1I3JI01KPHa n aprYMeHTllpOBaHa B CT.: HO"'WPOBU'i H. Il., Pbl'inoBIO. r.
CnCTeMLI ABO (H) rpynII KpOBII II IIMMYHIITPT K ocrre: (R npOOJIeMe cPaKTopOB npo-
cTpaHcTBerrHoro pacrrpe):1eJIeHIIH rpynII KpOBII y '1eJIOBeKa) II Bonp. aHTpOIIOJIOrlIlI.
1966. BbIII. 23.
38 Dobzhansky T. The present evolution of man II Sci. ArneI'. 1906. Vol. 203, N 3: Idem.
Mankind evolving. New Haven. 1962; AAenceeB B. A. HeKoTopbIe npOOJIeJ\IbI TeopnlI
aHTporroreHe3a II BOllp. cPIIJIOCOcPlIlI. 1959. N2 11.
39 Orru Crrel\IIaJIbHO paCCMOTpeHbI: Poeuncnuu H. H. 3aKOHOMepHOCTII rrpOCTpaHCTBeII-
HOro paCllpOCTpanelIlIH rpYlI1I KpOBI! y '1eJIOBPKa: (R npOOJIeMe aHTpOnOJIOrll1I «ORpa-
IIHHbIX nap0):10B») II Tp. I1H-Ta 9THorpacPHII AH CCCP. H.C. M.; J1., 1947. T. 1.
o 06 3TmI crrel\II3JIbHO CM.: AAel,ceeB B. n. reHoreorpacPlIH 'IeJIOBeKa.
H CM.: lli.Ma. b2aYBell If. II. OpraHII3M KaK D;eJIoe B UHp;lIBIJJ1yaJIbHOM U IICTOpll'leCROM
pa3BlITUlI. M.; J1., 1942; On Jlce. IIpOOJIeMbI )'13pBlIHH3Ma. M., 1946. IIepe1l3)'1aHITH 3TUX
KHlIr ObIJIII ocym;eCTBJIeHbI B 1969 H 1982 r.
2 OOll\en CBO):1KII rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrll'leCKIIX MaTepllaJIOB neT. "IlaCTIT'IHO 3TY pOJIb BbI-
rrOJIHHIOT KHHrII K RYHa. CM.: Coon C. The races of Europe. N. Y., 1939; Idem. The-
origin of races. L., 1963. }J;JIH TeppuToplI1I CCCP: j/,e6elf r. W. IIaJIeoHTporroJIonu£
CCCP II Tp. JIH-Ta 3THOrpacPIIII AH CCCP. H.C. M.; J1., 1948. T. 4.
Ii-
I
I
I
I
i
I:
I
.
j
I
I
.1
,
-.d
I
I"
I
t
I
56
43 CM.: ByuaK B. B. AHTpOIIOMeTpHH. M., 1941.
44 0030p reHeTII'IeCKIIX Haomo,[(eHIIH, KpOMe KHlIrll A1K. XappHCOHa, A1K. BaHHepa H JW.,
CM.: Dallsset J. Immunohematologie biologique et clinique. P., 1956; pyc. rrep.: J{oc-
ce lK. IlMMYHoreMaTOJIOrIIH. M., 1959.
45 <DaKTbI c06paHbI B KHHraX, rrepe'llICJIeHHbIX B rrpIIMe'l. 28. TeopeTlI'IecKlIii 0630p ClI1.:
Eynan B. B. 0 HeKOTopbIX Borrpocax rerreTII'IeCKOrO aHaJIII3a HenpepbIBHo BapbIIpyIO-
II\IIX rrplI3naKOB y '1eJIOBeKa II AHTpOIIOJI. mypnaJI. 1937. M 3.
H C:\1., Harrp.: A survey of somf' genetical characters of Ethiopian tribes II ArneI' J.
Phys. AnthropoL N. Y., 1962. VoL 20, N 1; A.'lenCeeB B. II., EClleeo.1ellCnaa 10. if.,
1'OXJ.ta1i H. If., /f.aeblooBa r. !rI., JKO.MOBa B. H. AHTpOIlOJIOl'II'IeCRIIe IICCJIe,[(OBaHIIH
Ha JIerre II COB. 3TIWrpacP1IH. 1968. .1\'£ 5; PbPlnOB 10. r., mepe,MeTbcea B. A. llorry-
JIHl\IIorrII3H reHeTIIKa a:reYToB ROJ\I3HJJ:OpCKHX oC'rpoBoB II Borrp. aHTpOIIOJIOrlIlI. 1972.
BbIII. 40, 41; The tlaxcaltecans: prehistory, demogTaphy, morphology and genetics II
UniY. Kans. PubL Anthropol. 1976. oM 7; Alexeeva T. I., Aleuev V. P., Batse-
vich V. A., Klevtsovll N. l.. Chikisheva T. A. Tuvinians: anthropo-ecological study II
Colleg. anthropoL 1984. Yo!. 8, N 1. C pacmIIpeHueM rrporpaMMbI CBH3an 1I RO':IJIeK-
TIIB1I3M lICCJIe,[(oBaHHH, KOTopoe Y1Ke He J\W1KeT ocyr:n;eCTBJIHTbCH CHJlaMII 0):11101'0 'Ie-
JIOBeKa.
47 CM.: A.lte1,CeeB B. n. AHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCKlIe p,aHrrble 0 npOOJIeJ\Ie rrpolIcxoaqemm Ha-
CeJIeHlm l\eHTpaJIbHbIX rrpe,[(ropIIlI RaBKa3CKoro xpe6Ta II AHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCIUIH c60p-
HlIK, IV. M., 1963. (Tp. IlH-Ta 3THorpacPIIII AH CCCP. H.C.; T. 82). TaM 1Ke CM. JIII-
TepaTypy.
"8 0630pbI: Garlick I. Blood groups and prehistory II Science in archaeology. N. Y.,
H)6; ; nepeBOB'lUliOB Ii. B. l< rrpOOJIeMe orrpe,[(eJIeIHU! rpyrrrroCrrel\HcPlI'IecKHx BelI\eCTB
KpOBII B IICKorraeMOM MaTepnaJIe II BOllp. aHTpOrrOJIOrlllI. 1971. BbIll. 38; On :!ICe. Orrpe-
p;eJIeHlle rpYIIII KpOBII B IICKOlIae WM MaTeplIaJIe II TaJ\I 1Ke. 1974. BbIII. 50.
49 CBO;:lKII: Hieber E. Grundriss del' biologoschen Statistik. Anwendungen del' mathe-
matischen Statistik in Naturwissenschafte und Teclmik. 6. AufL Jena, 1967; Idem.
Mathematische Grundlagen del' Genctik II Genetik: Grundlagen, Ergebnisse und Pro-
bleme in Einzeldarstellungen: Beitrag. Jena, 1967. MaTeMaTT!'1CCmnI MeTo,[(aM B au-
TpOrrOJIOrIIII crrel\IIaJIbHO nOCBHlI\eHbI pa60TbI: l1utaTbeB !rI. B. CTaTHCTU'IeCKllii Me-
TOp, B aHTpOrrOJIOrUII II IIpOOJIeMbI ,[(eMorpacPII'IeCKOH CTaTIICTUKII. M., 1959; Knuss-
mann R. Moderne statistische Yerfahren in del' Rassenkunde II Die neue Rassenkun-
de/Hrsg. I. Schwidetzky. Stuttgart, 1962; J{epa6un B. E. MHorOJ\IepHaH 61I0J\IeTplIH
p;.1U! aHTpOrrOJIOrOB. M., 1983.
50 Retzills A. Dber die Schadelform der Nordbewohner II Miillers Arch. Anat. 1845.
51 HepBaH pa60Ta, r,[(p HpOOJIeMa 6bma rrOCTaBJIeHa co BceH OCTpOTOH H rrOJIY'lIIJIa rroa-
TOMY p;a1Ke HeCIWJIbKO O,[(HOCTopoHHee pemeHIIe: }HUpOB E. B. Pa3HoBII,[(HOCTlI opaxn-
J(ecPaJIlIII II RpaT. co06r:n;. I1H-Ta nCTopnII MaTepllaJIbHOH KYJIbTypbI, 1941. BbIII. 10.
CM. TaKllie: /f.e6el.f r. W. R Bonpocy 0 BJIIIHHHlI IICKyccTBerrnOH p;ecPopMal\IIII Ha 1'0-
JIOBHOlI YKa3aTeJIb: (1I0 1I0B0,I1Y CTaTbU E. B. JKIIpoBa «Pa3HOBII,I1HOCTII 6paXIIKecPa-
mill) II Ta:\I }I\e. 1947. BbIII. 14; Ewing F. Hyperbrachycephaly as influenced by cul-
tnral condition II Pap. Peabody Mus. ArneI'. Archaeol. and EthnoL Cambridge (Mass.),
1950. Vol. 23. X 2; raoJICueB A. 1'. 0 BJIHHHHH KOJIbIOC;JU (oenuma) Ha BeJIII'IHHY
rOJIOBHOrO YKa3aTeJIH y p;eTeii II RpaT. cooor:n;. I1n-Ta ;'JTHOrpacPIIII AH CCCP. 1963.
BbIII. 28: Pbl'lnOB 10. r. 0 p;ecPoP:\IaUlIT! rOJIOBbI B CBH3lI C OObI'IaH In YXO.:ja 3a p;eTb-
MlI I I TaM 1Ke. 1957. BbIII. 27; On :!ICe. AHTpOrrOJIOrlIH II reneTlIKa 1130JIllpOBaHHblx rro-
IIYJIHl\lIii. rJI. IV: 0 COOTHorneHHlI lICKyccTBeHHoH ,[(ecPop:\Ial\lIlI rOJIOBbI II rrplIpok
HbIX KpaHIIOJIOrU'IeCKIIX oc06eHHOCTeH.
52 .D:OBO.l:bHO no ,poorrbre KapTbI rraHoi:JRY:\IeIIHoro II J\IaTepmWBOr(, pitcnpeJJ:eJICHIIH ro-
JlOiJnOI'O yHa3iJ', e.;m ObI.IT1I orrYUJIIIKOBaHbJ yme B lIepBbIX CBO,'\IJhIX TP.Y;:(3X no aHTpo-
nOJIOrmI :VUlpa. C:\L, Harrp.: Ripley W. The races of Europe. L., 1900. BOJIee rr03p;HlIe
KapThI CM.: BillSlltti R. Razze i popoli della terra. Torino. 1940. T. 1. C rrepBoro (13-
,I1aHHH rraHOlJKYMCHHaH KapTa P. EHaCYTTII rrepCIle'laTaHa: Eickstedt E. Die Forschung
am Menschen. Physiologische und morphologische Anthropologie. Stuttgart, 1944.
Bd.2.
3 Ha 3TO OOCTOJITeJIbCTBO BrrepBbJe YKa3aJI r. <D. ,lJ,eoel\ 6e3 yrro:\llInaHIIH, npaB,[(a, re-
HeTII'IeCKOH rrpCp;UOCbIJIKII. CM.: J{e6elf r. W. AHTpOrrOJIOI'II'IeCKHe UCCJICp;OBaHIIH B
Ra I'IaTCKOH OOJIaCTH II Tp. I1H-Ta 3THorpacPIIII AH CCCP. H.C. M., 1951. T. 17.
50 CM.: Hpxo A. II. ¥HllcPHK3L\IIH onpe;:(eJIeHIlii MHrKIlX 'IacTeii JIlIIW II AIITpOrrOJI. 1KypH.
1932. oM 1.
5 113MeHeHlle IIop;X0JJ:a OT'IeTJIIIBO rrpOHBJIJIeTCH rrpII corrOCTaBJIeHlUI cOBpeMeHHblx pa-
60T (CM. rrpHMe'l. 5) II cTapblx CBO,[(OK. 113 rrOCJIep;HlIX oc060 IIHTepeCHbI: Werth E.
Der fossile Mensch. Grundziige einer Paliianthropologie. B., 1928; Keith A. New dj,,-
coveries relating to the antiquity of man. N. Y., 1929. .
57
"
1;
l
56 TeOpeTII'IeCKIIe aClIeKTbI, CBH3aHHble c BHe3eMHbIMII n;HBIIJIII3al\IIHMII, pa3paoa TbUIa-
IOTCH C Ka1K)J;bIM rop;OM IIHTeHCIIBHee, II }];JIH HIIX p;a1Ke rrpe}];JIOfI\en rro anaJIOrIIII C
9K3001l0JIOrllelI Tep IHH «3K30COl\IIOJIOrlIH». KOTOpbIlI aBTOpy, rrpaBJJ:a, B OObI'IHOM
CJIOBoyrroTpeOJIeHlI1I Ka,I1:eTCH lIe COBceM rrpaBOJ\IepHbEII, TaK KaE pe'lb lIJJ:eT rrOKa He
o BHYTpeHHen: CTpYKType I!HbIX l\lIBII.TIII3an;UlI. a nUillb B OCHOBHOM 0 rrpOOJIeMe ROH-
TaKTOB C HlIMII. CM.: mn.aOBcnuu II. fl. BceJIeHHaH, 1K1I3Hb, pa3YJ\I. M., 1965; BHe3eM-
Hble n;lIBHJIII3an;IUI: Tp. COBell\. B EIOpoKaHe 20-23 "'IaH 1964 r. EpeBaH. 1965: BHe-
3eMHble l\HBIIJIII3al\IIII. IIpOOJIeMbI Ie1K3Be3p;HoII CBH3II. M., 1969. 8K30aHTpOnOJIOrIIH
1I0Ka He CYll\eCTByeT )J;a1Ke B BH)J;e ClICTeMbI npe)J;nOJI01KeHn:iI.
EY,I1Yll\eMY pa3BIITIIIO '1eJIOBeKa rrOCBJIll\eHO J\lRoro paOOT, paCCMaTpIIBaIOll\lIX ero
JIIIOO KaK IIpO)J;OJI1KeHlIe rrpOillJIon: 9BOJIIOn;IIII, JIIIOO KaR ee 3aTyxaHlIe. Wiercinski A.
Evolutionary rate of craniometric traits in Hominidae II Acta palaeontol. pol. 1956.
Vol. 1, N 3; CM.: Bo.aJl1icnuu H. HeI>OTOpble npOOJIeMbI MexaHII3Ma II cPaKTOPOB 9BO-
JIIOl\IIH II COB. 9THorpacP1IH. 1957. oM 3; Wolanski N. Ieszeze w sprawie skokowosci
w ewolucji form ludzkich oraz nierownomiernosci tempa rozwoju il Przegl. antropol.
1957. T. 2, sz. 2; Idem. Zagadnienie etapowosci w ewolucji form Iudzkich II Ibid.
1958. T. 24, sz. 1; Po;;uncKuu H. H. 00 3Tarrax II TeMlIax 9BOJIIOl\IUI rOMIIHIIp; il COB.
3THorpacPIIH. 1957. oM 6; BblcTpoB A. n. HpOillJIOe, HaCTOHll\ee, 0YiIYll\ee qeJIOBeRa.
JI., 1957; A.n,enceee B. n. 0 CROpOCTII 3BOJIIOl\IIII B IIpe)J;enax ce IellcTBa rOMlIHII)J;11
}J;OKJI. Ha VII Me1K,I1YHap. KOHrp. aHTpOrrOJI. II 3THorp. HaYK; On :!ICe. OT 1KIIBOTHbIX-
K '1eJIOBeKY. JIereH):1bI, cPaKTbI, HaYKa.
57 3TO rrOJI01KeHlIe pa3paOaTbIBaeTCH C caMbIX pa3Hblx CTOpOH II CTaJIO OOll\errplIHHTbIM
B COBeTCKOIT JIIITepaType. HepBbJe paOOTbI YKa3aHbI B rrpIIMe'l. 5.
58 JIIITepaTypa, 1I0CBHIl\l'HHaH BceM 3TIIM BonpocaM, HeOO'bHTHa. qacTII'IHO xapaKTep
rrpooneM OCBell\eH: 3ifjpou.MC01i B. n. HorrYJIHl\1I0HHaH reHeTIIKa '1eJIOBeKa II HeRO-
Topble rrpOOJIeMbI Me,I1I1l\I1HCHOlI reHeTIIKII II feneTIIKa. 1967. oM 11; TU.ManOB B. J/,.
feHeTIIKa II Me}J;lll\I1Ha II TaM 1Ke. 1968. oM 1. CM. TaK1Ke rrpIIMe'l. B.
59 A.aenceeB B. n. TeopIlH pacoBe,I1eHIIJI Ha VII Mea\,J,YHapop;HoM ROHrpecce aHTpono-
JIOrll'leCKIIX II 3THorpacPII'IeCKlIX HaYK II COB. 9THorpacP1IH. 1965. oM 2.
60 A.aeKceeB B. n. <1JaKTopbI pacooopa30BaHIIH, MeTO)J;bI paCOBoro aHamma. rrpHHl\I1IlliI
paCOB:bIX RJIaCCIIcPIIRal\IIIT II TaM 1Ke. 1964. N2 4; Methods and theories fo anthropo-
logical geneticsjEd. M. Crawford, P. Workman. Albuquerque, 1973; Current develop-
ments in anthropological genetics: In 2 vol./Ed. J. :\iielke, M. Crawford. N. Y.,
1980-1982.
:,
I!.
;t
ii!
I:
'Il-
I"
!
Ii
rEHETMRA M AHTPOrrO OrMH
rEHorEOrPA«I>HqECRHE llPABHJIA,
YCTAHOBJIEHHblE H. H. BABHJlOBbIM
renHaJIblIbIii relIeTIIR, O,ZJ;IIII If3 C03;:J;aTeJIeii reHoreorpacpHII - HIfROJIaH MBa-
HOBIIq BaBIIJIOB nopamaeT IIac, JIIO;:J;eH CJIeP;YIOm;ero nOROJIeIIIIH, He TOJIbRO
THTalIIIqeCRIIM pa3l1faXOllf TBOpqeCTBa, 110 H mnpOTOH lIfhICJIII, Bce06'beMJIIO:m;IIlIf
xapaRTepOM 0606m;eIIIIH. He BhI3bIBaeT cOllflIelIIIH 06:m;e6IIOJIOrIIqeCKOe 3IIa-
qeHIIe 3aKOlIa rOMOJIOI'II'IeCRIIX pH.D:OB B HaCJIe.D:CTBelIlIoii II3MelIqIIBOCTII,
HClIa IfCRJIIOqIfTeJIblIaH pO JIb B reHoreorpacpIIII 3aROlIa OTTeClIelIIfH pel(eCCIfB-
IIblX relIOB na OKpaIIlIhI BII)J;OBoro IIJIII nO,ll,BIfp;OBoro apeaJIa. IIocJIe;:J;IIHR 3a-
ROIIOllfepnOCTb C IIOJIIIOH OTqeTJIIIBOCTbIO npOHBIIJIa ce6H, RaK MbI y6eAIfMcH,
B cpOpMIIpoBalIIIII qeJIOBeqeCRIIX pac.
IIepBoe co06:m;elIIfe 0 BbICTeCHeHHII pe eCCIIBlIbIX relIOB Ha OKpanlIY apea-
JIa H. M. BaBIIJIOB ony6JIIIROBaJI B 1927 1'., Rorp;a 011 IIeYTOMIIlIfO nYTerneCT-
BOBaJI, c06HpaH lIfaTepIIaJIhI 0 RyJIbTYpHbIX paCTelIIfHX BO Bcex yrOJIRaX 3eM-
Horo mapa, II B ero rOJIOBe B OCIIOBlIblX qepTaX YiRe CJIOiRIIJIaCb 3HaMelIIITaH
BnOCJIe;:J;CTBIIII TeopIIH ]:\eIITpOB npOIfcxomp;elIIIH RyJIbTYPHbIX pacTelIIIH. Ap-
ryllfelITa:qIIH 3TOH TeopHII He lIforJIa 6bITb C,ll,eJIalIa B JIa60paTopIIII. OHa Tpe-
60BaJIa Bce HOBbIX II IIOBblX nOJIeBbIX IIa6JIIO)J;eIIIIH, H H. M. BaBIIJIOB e3)J;IIJI
IIOqTII 6e3 nepepbIBa II3 cTpaHbI B cTpaHY, C lIfaTepIIRa IIa lIfaTepIIR, c06IIpaH,
onIIcbIBaH, II3yqaH RYJIhTypHYIO cpJIOPY H npIIellfbI 3ellfJIep;eJIIIH. TpYP;IIo nepe-
58
5.
-qIIC.;rIITb CTpalIbI, ROTOpbIe OH npOeXaJI Ha MarnlIlIe, BepXOllf, nporneJl
nernKOM,- B IICTOpIIH HayRII lIfaJIO nyTernecTBeHHIIROB, ROTopble TaR IICKOJIe-
CIIJII1 6bI 3eMIIOH map. MlIorIIe 3aMeqaTeJIhHble pa60TbI CBOH OH nIICaJI B 3RC-
JJe)J;II IIHX. B 8Rcne,ZJ;II IIH iRe, Ha napoxop;e B Cpe,ll,H3eMIIOllf lIfope, 6bIJIa Ha-
IIHcalIa CTaTbH 0 3aKOHax reorpacpIIqeCROrO pacnpep;eJIelIIIH relIOB RYJIbryp-
IIbIX paCTelIl1ll, B ROTOpOH cop;epa\aJIaCb CPOPMYJIl1pOBRa 3aROHa OTTeCHeHHH
peI eCCIfBlIbiX renOB lI3 l(eHTpa cpopMo06pa30BalIl1H. B nHChMe R .D:pyrOMY BH-
"ZJ;aIOm;eMYCH ,ll,eHTeJIIO PYCCKoro eCTeCTB03IIaIIlIH - BJIa,ll,IIlIfIIpy MBaHOBUqy
BeplIa)J;CKOMY, nOCJIalIlIOM B 1927 r. 113 CeBeplIOH ACPPIIKH, BaBIIJIOB llHCaJI:
«lIOIIHJI npaBI1JILIIOnn B reorpacpnqeCKOl\f pacnpe)J;eJIelIIIII cpO pM B npe,ll,eJIax
BI1.D:0B: y6bIBalII1e }J:OMIIlIaIITOB R nepIIcpepIIII OT l(eHTpOB. 8TO 06'bHCIIHeT lIfHO-
roe, )J;a<Re ,ZJ;JIH qe:IOBeKa» 1.
B qeM CYTb 3Toro 3aROlIa? 011 npOCT H nOIIHTelI, KaR npOCTbI H nOIIHTHhI
Bce o606m;e1I11H H. II. BaBIfJIOBa. IJ;elITp BII.D:OBOro I1JIH nO,ll,BII,ll,OBoro apeaJIa
HBJIHeTCH apelIOII IIaII60JIee IIIITelICIIBlIoro cpOpMooGpa30BaTeJIbHOrO npo:qecca.
ho 6bIJIO YCTalIOBJIeIIO em;e q. .n;apBI1IIOM. B J:(elITpe apeaJIa nOCTOHlIlIO B03-
HIIKaIOT IIOBbIe lIfYTal(IUI, IIapyrnaIOm;IIe relIlIoe paBIIOBeCIIe H C03p;aIOm;IIe
npe}J:nOChIJIRH )J;JIH BeqHOrO If3MelIelIIfH reIIOTIIIIOB. MYTa IIII 3TII )J;0MIIlIaIITlIhI,
T. e. nepep;aIOTCH no IIaCJIe.D:CTBY rrepBOMY iRe nOROJIeHI1IO nOTOMROB. IIo-
'CTOHlIlIoe B03III1KIIOBeHIIe IIOBbIX MYTa nH YCHJII1BaeT ,ll,eHCTBl1e eCTeCTBelIlIoro
oT60pa II yCRopHeT npo ecc BII)J;O- II paco06pa30BalIIIH. B 8TIIX YCJIOBIIHX pe-
l(eCCI1BHbIe MYTa IIII lIe l\lOryT BbI)J;epa;:aTb KOlIltypeHJ:(1111 C )J;OMIIlIaHTlIbIMI1.
OIIII nepeXO.D:HT B CRpbIToe COCTOHIIIfe II IIaqIInaIOT BbITeCIIHTbCH II3 l(elITpa
BI1}J:OBoro IfJIII nOI(BI1)J;OBoro apeaJIa 60JIee YCTOHql1BbIMII II npl1cnOC06JIeHlIbI-
III )J;OMIIlIaIITlIbIMII cpopMaMH. Pe eCCIIBlIbIe iRe OTO)J;BIIraIOTCH OT l(eIfTpaJlh-
IIhIX paHOIIOB, OT l(elITpaJIblIOrO oqara cpopMo06pa30BalII1H Bce p;aJIbrne II
.D:aJIbrne H B ROII:qe KOII:qOB 3alIIIlIfaIOT uepl1cpepl1IO apeaJIa. 3)J;eCb, B YCJIOBIIHX
II30JIHI1;HII, BepOHTIIOCTh BCTpe pel(eCCIIBlIbIX cpOpM B npoJ:(ecce CRpem;IIBa-
IIIIH 3HaqIITeJIblI0 YBeJIII BaeTCH, H OIIII nepeXO,ll,HT H3 CKphlToro reTep03II-
TOTlIoro COCTOHIIIIH B rOM03IIrOTIIOe, T. e. npOHBJIHIOTCH BO BlIernlIOCTIf opra-
HI13MOB, B cpenOTIIne.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, CTpyRTypa reorpacpIIqeCROrO apeaJIa JII060H cpOpMhI HlIfe-
€T, COrJIaCHO H. 11. BaBIIJIOBY, CJIe}:\YIOm;IIH BII,ll,: B l(elITpe apeaJIa npo:qBe-
TaIOT }:\OllfIIIIaIITlIbIe cpOpMhI, IlK ORpYiRaIOT pel(eCCIIBlIbIe reTep03IIrOThI, IIaRO-
Hel(, RpalfIIIOIO nepIIcpepIIIO apeaJIa 3alIIIMaIOT pe eCCIIBHbIe rOM03IIroThI.
Pa3YMeeTCH, ne cpa3Y nOHBIIJIOCb TaRoe Rap)J;IIlIaJIblIOe 0606m;elIl1e. nO,D:-
cTynbI K HeMY OhIJIII Cp;eJIalIhI IIa IIeCKOJIhRO JIeT palIbrne. HaM BaiRlIO 8TO
OTMeTIITh nOToMY, qTO OIIH CBH3alIbI C alITpOnOJIOrl1qeCKHMII IIa6JlIOp;eIIIIHMII
H. 11. BaBIIJIOBa, BCer,ll,a npIICTaJIblIO IIIITepecoBaBrnerocH I1CTOpIlell qeJIOBe-
-qecRoH RYJIbTypbI II cpOpMIIpoBaHIIeM alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX TIInOB.
1924 ro,ll,... He60JIbrnoll 8Rcnep;II IIolIlIbIII OTpH)J;, npe,D:Bo)J;IITeJIbCTByeMbIn
H. 11. BaBIIJIOBhIM, nYTernecTByeT no A<praIIIfCTaIIY. CoocTBelIIIo, OTpH)J;-
<lTO CJIIIrnROM rpOMKO CRa3a1I0: C H. II. BaBII.:'IOBhIII TOJIbRO arpOIIOM-MeJII10-
paTOp .n;. .n;. BYRIlIIIIq, CeJIeK HOlIep B. H. JIe6e,ll,eB II O)J;IIII IIJIII .D:Ba npOBO)J;-
IIIII\:a. H. 11. BaBIIJIOB CqaCTJIIIB: y Ke IIeCKOJlbKO JIeT 011 MeqTaJI nonaCTb B
AcpraHIIcTalI, CTpaHY )J;peBlIeHrneH 3eMJIe,ll,eJlbqeCROH KYJIbTypbI, II IIaKOHel(
ocym;ecTBI1.'1 CBOIO MeqTy. 011 pa60TaeT C IICRJIIOql1TeJIblIbIM IIanpH KeIIIfeM,
RaR Bcer)J;a, }J:06l1paeTcH )J;O caMblX TPY,D:IIOLJ:OcTynlIhIx BbICORoroplIhIX CeJIeHl1ll,
ROJIJIeK 110IIIIPYH 06pa3J:(hI ca)J;oBoH, oropo,ZJ;IIOll II nOJIeBOn RYJlbrypbI. 8TO
ero OCIIOBHoe 3a1IHTl1e. Ho B ccpepe ero BIIIIMalIIIH II ,ll,pyroe: 8TIIorpacpIIH
nocem;elIHhIX lIIeCT, cpII3IIqeCRIIH TIIII IIaCeJIelIHH pa3HbIX paHolIoB, 3TIIIIqeCRI1e
B3anMOOTIIornelIIIH MIIOrOqIICJIelIlIbIX IIapO,D:OB II 8THorpacpHqeCRIIX rpynn. Bce
;:ITO 3anIICbIBaeTCH B ,ll,IIeBIIHKH, 3aneqaTJIeBaeTCH IIa cpoTOnJIeIIKY, qTOObl 060-
59
,j/
'I CV .
o ,
, ':
t
"
:11
I
i
I"
:.j
!
n;
..
,:
,I
"
..
i
,1
1
i
f
"
1
,,\
'.. \
' ',
:--
raTIITh ero 6YAym;IIn OTqeT 06 3RCne,ll,If IIII 6ec elIlIbIlIfII reorpaqmqeCKHMH,
alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIMIl II 3TlIorpacpHqeCRII IIf na6JIIO,ll,eIIIlHMII.
Ha ceBepO-BOCTOKe CTpanbI 3Rcne,J,II IIH C orpOMlIbIM TPY.D:OM nepe6IIpa-
eTCH CRB03b nOqTIl IIenpeO)J,OJIIDfbIe nepeBaJIbI B HypIICTaII, IfJIII, RaK ero
na3bIBaJIH palIbrne, HacpIIpJICTalI, Ha BbICOTY 3500-4000 M. TaM II3YQaeTCH
cRY)J;IIOe II Ma.:'IOMo:m;IIOe, 110 OqeHb opIIrIlHaJIblIOe BbIcoRoroplIoe 3eMJI8.D:eJIIIe.
H. M. BaBIIJIOBa IfIITepecyeT, O.D:HaKO, He TOJIbRO 3eMJIe.D:e.:'IIle: mIITeJIII rop-
HypIICTalI bI - IIa pep,KOCTb cBoe06pa3IIbI no CBoell KYJIbrype, no CBoeMY
6bITY. OIIII OTJIHqaIOTCH .D:aiRe OT CBOIIX 60JIee HII3KO iRIIBYIIJ;IIX cocep,eH.
Ho em;e 60JIbrne OTJIIIqIIe B aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKO I TIme. HypIICTalIl(hI CBeTJIO-
rJIa3bI, qTO oc06elIII0 IIe06bIqlI0 B CTpalIe KpaHlIe TeMlIhIX, qeplIOBOJIOCbIX If
qeplIONra3bIX JIIO)J;ell.
H. M. BaBIlJIOB ObIJI BHHMaTeJIblIbIM IIa6JIIO.D:aTeJIeM, 011 npOCTO 3acpIIRCII-
pOBa.:'I 3TOT cpaKT B CBoeH na:MHTII II BepIIY.:'ICH K IIeMy, Ror.D:a nO,ll,BO.D:IIJI IITO-
rII CBoero nYTerneCTBIIH.
B 1929 r. BhIrnJIa B CBeT IIanIICalIHaH H. II. BaBIIJIOBbIM COBMeCTHO co
CBOHlIf TOBapII:m;eM no IIYTerneCTBIIIO JJ:. JJ:. BYRIIIIIIqeM TOJICTaH nper{paCIIO
II3.D:aHlIaH RlInra «3eM,rre;:J;e:IbqeCKIIII AcpranIICTaII». OHa, l\WiRHO CRa3aTb,
BnepBbIe OTKpbIJIa eBponellCROMY MIIPY orpmIIIYIO CTpaIIY. II lIe TOJIbRO co
CTOpOlIbI RYJIbTYPbI 3eMJIe)J;eJIIIH. reOllfopcpOJIOrIIH II JJ:eJIelIIIe CTpalIbI HB JIaH)J;-
macpTlIbIe 301IbI, RJIIDfaT II OOTalInRo-reorpacpIIqeCRIIe paHOlIhI, IICTOpnH 3eM-
JI€;:J;eJIIIH B c.BH3n C pa3BIITIIeM ;JpeBIIIIX IIBIIJIII3a:qIIH Ha TeppIlTopIlII Acpra-
HIICTalIa - Bce 3TO no.rryqUJIO nO.D:p06IIYIO II rJIy60RYIO xapaKTepIIcTIIRy.
JJ:aiRe 0 pe3YJIbTaTaX IIa6JIIO)J;aBrnIIXCH HlIf B AcpralIIICTalIe paCRonOR cppalI-
nY3CKIIX apxeO.:'IOrOB H. M. BaBHJIOB CYMeJI HanIIcaTb 3aXBaThIBaIO:m;e IIIITe-
peclIo. Cpe)J,II npOqIlX paHOIIOB 6bIJI oxapaKTepH30BaII II HYPIICTaII - CTpalIa
rop II OTIIOCIITeJIbHO CBeTJIOrJIa3bIX JIIO;n;eH. .H nIlrny (<OTIIOCIITeJIbIIO CBeT.:'IO-
rJIa3bIX», qT06bI Y qIITaTeJIell lIe C03)J;aJIOCb BneqaTJIelIHH, qTO IIypIICTalI bI
Bce Bo06:m;e cepOrJIa3bI IIJIII rOJIy60rJIa3bI. B nepe;n;IIeH A3IIIf TaRaH B03MOiR-
HOCTb npocTo llCKJIIO'IelIa Bcell IICTopIIeH aHTpOnOJIOfIIqeCRIlX TIInoB, OTIIO-
CHlI\IIXCH K IOiRlIOll BeTBH eBpOneOH.D:IIOH pacbI. Ho npo:qeHT JIIO)J;eH C CepbIl\fH
n rOJIy6h1l\fH rJIa3aMII Cpe.D:II IIypIIcTalI eB .D:OBOJIbIIO BbICOR. HCTaTII cKa3aTb,
06'beKTIIBlIoCTb IIa6JIIO;n;eIIIIH H. M. BaBIIJIOBa II ero nOJIlIoe COOTBeTCTBIfe
,ZJ;eiicTBIITeJIbIIOCTIl nO)J;TBep)J;IIJI B 1937 r. A. XeppJIIIX, npHBe)J;H TOqlIbIe alITpo-
nOJIOrIfQeCKHe H3MepelIIfH 2.
H YCJIyraM H. II. BaBIIJIOBa 6hIJIa rIInOTe3a, mIIpORO pacnpOCTpalIelIlIaH
B TO BP€MH (IIl\feIOm;aH XOiR.D:elIIIe If CeIIqac), 06 OqelIb 06rnIIp1I0l\I apeaJIe
ceBeplIoH paChI B .D:peBIIOCTII, 0 ee aRTIIBHOM xapaRTepe H KYJIbTypTperep-
CKOH pOJIII ee npe)J;cTaBIITeJIeH. MOiRHO 6bIJIO YBlmeTh nOTOllfKOB ceBeplIoH
paCbI II B IIypIfCTalI ax. Ho H. M. BaBIIJIOB pernIITeJIblIO BbICRa3aJICH npOTIfB
3TOll rIInOTe3bI, lIe HaXO)J;H )J,JIH IIee onopbI HII B IICTOpIIRo-:JTIIOrpacpIIqeCKHX,
HII B JIIIlIrBIlCTIIqeCRIIX cpaRTax. 06'bHClIeIIIIe, IIlIf npe,ZJ;JImKeIIIIOe, OnIIpaJIOCb
Ha II3HlI\IIOe npIIJIO KeHIIe R ;JaIIIIOMY ROIIRpeTHoMY CJIyqaIO 3aROlIa OTTeClIe-
IIIlH IIa ORpaIIIIY apeaJIa pe eCCIIBlIbIX relIOB. ORpaIflIa apeaJIa - 3TO He
TOJIbKO paHOII, reorpacpII'IeCRIf IIaH60JIee Y.D:aJIeHlIbIH OT eIlTpa paco- mHI
BII.D: 00 6pa30BaIIIIH. JII060e BbICOKoroplIoe nJIaTO MOiReT 6bITb npnpaBlIelIO no
CBoeMY p;ellCTBIIIO IIa npo:qecc cpopllfo06pa30BaHIIH R ORpaIIHe apeaJIa, TaR
KaR 0110 BCer.D:a npe.D:CTaBJIHeT C060H «3aROYJIOR» II C03JJ;aeT np e .D: n OCbI.lIRII
)l;JIH H30JIHI(IfII. CBeTJIbIe rJIa3a Y qeJIOBeRa - pe eCCHBlIbIH npII3IIaR, ycry-
naIOm;IfH B nepBOM nOKOJIelIIIII qep1IOrJIa30CTII. COBeprnelIIIO eCTeCTBeHIIO,
'ITO rpynnbI UYPIICT8Hl(eB, OTTeClIelIlIbIe B rophI IIa BhICOry 3000-4000 M,
fIOnaJIII Tallf B TaKHe me YCJIOBIIH, RaR eCJIII 6hI OHH ORa3aJIIICb B II30JIH IIH
Ha ORpaIIlIe apeaJIa eBpOneOII.D:IIOn paCbI. OTCIO,ll,a pO,ll,CTBelIlIbIe 6paRH, H8-
I
1
60
i
f
KOnJIelIHe pe:qeCCHBlIbIX relIOB B KaffiLJ;OM nOCJIe)IYIOm;eM nOlWJIeIIIIII, nOBbI-
menHaH BepOHTIIOCTb HX BCTpeqII npH Kam)];OM 01Iepe)];IIOM CJIyqae 3aKJIIOqe-
HHH 6paKa, a CJIe)];OBaTeJIbHO, H nOBbImeHHaH BepOHTHOCTb I1X nepeXo)];a H3
CKpbIToro COCTOHHIIH B HBHoe, II3 reTep03III'OTIIOrO B rOM03IIrOTIIoe C nOCJIe-
)];yIOm;HM npOHBJIelIIIeM B cpeuonme. K OO'bHClIeIIIIIO cBoe06pa3IIH aHTpOnOJIO-
rH1IeCIWrO nma II ero cpOpMHpOBalIIIH 6bIJIa nplnreneHa relIenI1I€CI>8H H)];eH,
H OnbIT ee npIIMelIelIIIH OKa3aJICH OqeHb y)];aqlIbIM H y6e;J:I1TeJIblIbBL
nOIICK OTpaiEelIIIH 06ru;erelIenIqeCKIIX 3aKOlIO:\feplIOCTeH B aIITpOnOJIOrH-
qeCKIIX )];aIIHbIX 6bIJI CTIIMymIpoBaII IIa 3ana)];e pa60TaMII :qeJIOII nJIeHD;bI II3-
EeCTlIbIX MaTeManmOB, relIeTIIKOB II TeOpeTImOB 3BO.:'IIO IIII - C. PaiiTa,
]J;iE. <PIImepa, P. X3JI.D:alIa. O.D:IIaIW OIIII nO.D:XO)];HJIH IW BceM 6IIOJIOrIJ1IeCKIIM
HBJIelIIIHM qepe3 HCKyccTBelIHO C03)];alIlIbIe MaTeMaTII'IeCKIIe MO)];eJIII. OTCIOfJ,a
HapH)];Y C IIeCOMlIelIlIbIMn )];OCTHmeIIHHMII OIIII nOJIyqIIJIII II :qeJIbIH PH)]; cpop-
MaJIblIbIX pe3yJIbTaTOB. H. M. BaBIIJIOB IICXO;J:JIJI II3 orpOMlIoro KOJIII1IeCTBa
aMnIIpHqeCKIIX cpaKTOB, )];06bITbIX I1M JIIIqIIO. He COCTaBIIJI IICImIO'leIIIIH II
I\:paTKIIH BbIXO)]; ero IIa c:qelIY HaYKII B pOJIH alITpOnOJIOra. 011 caM 3a.MeTIIJI
H OnIICaJI ulITepeclIbIlI cpaKT, nOCJIYiIDIBmIIll OCIIOBalIIIeM )];JIH l\IaCTepCIwro
oom;e6I10JIOrHqeCKOrO II IICTOpnqeCKOrO alIamI3a, OCIIOBaHIIeM )];JIH 6JIecTmue-
1'0 0606ru;eIIHH. nOaTOMY nYTb, no KOTOPOMY OH npomeJI, OKa3aJICH qpe3BbI-
'IalIIlO nJIOfJ,OTBOplIbIM.
B 1936 r. nOHBIlJIaCb CTaTbH H. H. Qe601\:capoBa, B KOTOpOH aBTOp CyM-
MIIpOBaJI orpollfIlbIH JIIITeparyplIhIH MaTepHaJI, pe3YJIbTaTbI CBOIIX c06CTBelI-
HbIX IICCJIefJ,OBaIIUH II IICCJIe)];OBaIIIIH )];PyrIIx COBeTCKHX alITpOnOJIOrOB B oOJIa-
CTII alITpOnOJIOrHII ceBepa eBponeHcKoH qaCTII CCCP 3. 8Ta CBO.D:Ka CTapbIX
II IIOBbIX )];alIlIbIX nOCJIYiKHJIa 6a30H )];JIH nOCTpoelIIIH HOBOH II OqelIh y)];a'I-
IIOH, BOme)];rneH nOTOM BO Bce aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIe MOlIorpacpHII II Y'leOHIIKII
KJIaCCIIcpHKa:quII IIapO)];OB CeBeplIOH EBponbI no cpII3IIqeCKIIM npII3IIaI\:aM,
a TaImm )];.:'IH KpIITII'leCKOrO nepeCMOTpa npemlIIIx B033pelIIIH IIa HX relIeTII-
qeCI\:He B3aIIMOOTlIomeHIIH. Ho npII BceM 60JIbmOM 3HaqelIIIII aTIIX )];OCTIIme-
IIIIH )];.:'IH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH EBpOIIbI H Y 1 IelIHH 0 pacax pOJIh 3TOH CTaTbII )];JIH
IIameH TeMbI, O;J:naKO, B )];pyroM - B nonbITI\:e npO)];OJIiEHTb JIHIIHIO TeopenI-
qeCKIIX nOIICKOB, IIaqaTbIX H. M. BaBIIJIOBbIM, H npe;J:JIOiRIITb alIaJIOrHqlIOe
renenIqeCIWe 06'bHClIe1IIIe HBJIeHIIIO )];enIInreHTa HII y HapogoB CKaHfJ,IIIIaBIIII.
IIIBe.D:bI, HopBem bI, cpIIIII-fbI, )];aTqalIe, IIpJIalI)J;:qbI, cpapep:qbI, IICJIaII.D: hI.
mOTJIaII)J;:qhI, pYCCKHe ceBeplIblx palfOlIOB - Bce npe)];CTaBIITeJIII ceBepIIOH BeT-
BII eBpOnemI)];OB IIJIII ceneplIOH paCbI OTJIHqaIOTCH CBeTJIhIMII rJIa3aMII H BO-
JIOCaMII. Y O)];IIIIX IIapop:OB IIII)];HBII.D:YYMbI co CBeTJIbIMII rJIa3aMH H BOJIOCal\III
COCTaBJIHIOT )];Be TpenT - 3TO KJIaCCIIqeCKIIe IIpe)];CTaBIITe.:'III ceBeplIOH paCbI,
TaKHe, KaI\: rnBe.D:bI IIJIII IIOpBem bI. B COCTaBe .D:pyrIIx IIX qIICJIO nonnmaeTCH
)];0 Ol IIoiI TpeTlI, no Bce paBIIO IIaCeJIelIUe npIIJIeraIOm;Ux K CKalI.D:HlIaBHII
06JIaCTeII 3UaqIITeJIblI0 CBeTJIee, qeM HapO)];bI OCTaJIhlIbIX paHOIIOB EBponhl.
H. H. Qe60I{CapOB npe)];JIOiIDIJI TO me 06'bHClIeHHe npHqIIII 3Toro HBJIeIIHH,
ITO II H. M. BaBIIJIOB )];JIH nOCBeTJIelIIIH rJIa3 y IIaCeJIelIIIH 3ana)J;IIbIX OTporOB
rHII)];YKyrna. CKaH.D:IIlIaBIIH lIe TOJIbKO OI\:paIIlIlIbIH paiIOH EBponbI, 3TO O;r:(IIII
113 Y1IaCTKOB ceBeplIOH OI\:paIIlIbI OHKYMelIbI - BceH 06IfTaeMOH qaCTH nJIaHe-
TbI. ECJIH rOBopIITb 0 BhlTeClIelIHII pe eCCHBlIhlX relIOB y qeJIOBeKa H3 elI-
TpaJIbubIX 06JIaCTeH paco06pa30BalIIIH, TO 0 CKalI.D:lIIIaBCIWM nOJIYOCTpOBe
HYiRlIO rOBopIITb B nepBYIO Oqepe)];b. CY)];H no apXeOJIOrIIqeCKIBI )J;aIIIIbIM, 011
UbIJI 3aCeJIeII He panee Me30JIIITa H nOToMy lIe BXO)J;IIJI B nepBOlIaqaJIblIhIH
apeaJI cpOplllIIpOBalIIIH eBpOneOIID,IIOII paCbI, JIemaBmHII, HecmIIIelIlIO, IOffilIee.
reorpacpIIqeCKII 011 BbI)];BIIIIYT )];aJIeIW IIa ceBep, OTJIIJ1IaeTCH CypOBbIMII KJIH-
MaTHqeCKIIlIIlI YCJIOBIIHl\HI ;:J,a em;e OT)J;eJIeII OT IJ;elITpaJIblIOH EBponbI Ha 60JIb-
mOM npOTHmelIIIII EaJITIIHCKIIM MopeM. nOHHTHO H O'IeBII)];HO, qTO Me)];JIeH-
61
1 i
"
1:"
t
,
:r
i
n
J<"
noe II nOCTenelIHOe 3aCeJIeHHe nOJIYOCTpOBa YHOCIIJIO II3 :qeHTpaJIbIIbiX o6JIa-
cTei'f EBponhl MyTa:qHII CBeTJIOrJIa30CTII II CBeTJIOBOJIOCOCTII (Tome, no BceH
BepOHTIIOCTII, pe:qeCCIIBlIoro npII3IIaKa), II OHII nOCTeneHIIO HalmnJIIIBaJIIICI>
Bce B OOJILlliIlX II 60JIblliIIX KOHI(eIITpaI(HHX Ha ceBepe. A IIaROnIlBlliIlCb, CTa-
JIH npOHBJIHTb ce6H B alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOM THne IIaCeJIelIIIH B rrO.D:aBJIHIO eM
60JIblliIllICTBe CJIyqaeB.
TaKoBa IWII:qenI(HH H. H. qeooKcapona, BnOJIlIe COOTBeTCTBYIOm;aH IIa-
IlIIIM 311aIUfHM 0 MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCKIIX oc06eHIIocTHX COBpeMelIlIoro IIaCeJIeHHH
CImlI.D:IIIIaBlUl:. OHa XOpOlliO OO'bHCIIHeT B03IIHKIIOBelIIIe 3TIIX oco6eIllIocTeii,
Y'fHThlBaeT Bce HMeIOm;IIeCH CBep:eHIUI 0 3aCeJIelIHII CKaH.D:IIIIaBCIWro no.:'IY-
OCTpOBa TJeJIOBeKOM II npe.D:CTaBJIHeT c060n npIIJIOiReHIIe Hp:eH H. M. BaBlIJIOBa
J{ 06'bHClIellIlIO alITpOnOJIOrIlqeCKIIX HBJIelIIIII Bee, Tal\: CKa3aTb, I\:JIaCCIIqe-
CKOllf, qHCTOM BII.D:e: Be.D:L peqb B .D:aIIIIOM CJIyqae H.D:eT )J;eIIcTBHTeJIbHO 06 OI\:-
paIIlIe oIIKYMelIbI, a CJIe)J;OBaTeJIbIIO, II 06 OKpaHHe BIID;OBoro II paCOBoro apea-
JIOB B nOJIIIOM 3IIaqelIIIII 3Toro CJIOBa. TaImM 06pa30M, npIlMep ,lJ;eIICTBIIH
9.!TeClIeIIlm peI(eCCIIBHbIX reHOB IIa OKpaIIHY apeaJIa B CKaH,lJ;IIIIaBIfII
HBJIHeTCH, eCJIH MOiRlIO TaK Bblpa3IITbCH, 60JIee xpecToMaTllllH:bIM, 60JIee HP-
KIIM II y6e)J;I1TeJIbHbIM, 60JIee COOTBeTCTBYIOm;I1M MexalIII3My ,lJ;eIICTBIIH 3aIWlIa,
IeM npIlMep, npIlBe,lJ;elIlIbIH caMHM H. M. BaBHJIOBbIM.
I
.
(/
\
rEHorEorp AtI>lIH II tI>OPMIIPOBAHIIE EBPOIlEOIIJJ;OB
KaK HII IIIITepeClIbI II HPKII Bce 3TII cpaKTbI II co06paiReHHH, KaK HII npHBJIe'
KaTeJILlIhJ OHH rnIIpOInIM OXBaTOM, CIIHTe30M II 6HOJIOrIIqeCKIIX II I1CTOpHqe.
CKIIX HBJIelIIIII B 0,'],110 :qeJIoe. MOiReT 6bITb, lIe CTOHJIO 6bI nOCBHm;aTb 11M OT-
)J;eJIbIIYIO CTaTbIO, eCJIH 6bI lIe a6COJIIOTIIaH y6eiR)J;elIlIOCTb aBTopa B TOM, qTO
3TO lIe npornJIoe, a IIaCTOHm;ee H ,lJ;ame 6YAYm;ee aIITpOITOJIOrIIII, ee CTOJI60-
-nOH nYTL, qTO npIlMelIelIIIe reHeTII reCKHX 3alWHOMeplIOCTen I\: I1CTOJIKOBaIIIIIO
alITpOnOJIOrIlqeCKHX cpaKTOB OTKpbIBaeT lliIlpOKIIe B03MomlIOCTH )J;JIH Kap)J;II-
IIaJIbIIbIX 0606m;eIIHH, qTO, IIaKOHe:q, OTKpbITbIH H. M. BaBIIJIOBbIM 3aKOII
MOiReT HaliTH B aHTpOnOJIOrHII ,lJ;aJIbHeHlliee npIIJIOiRelIIIe. nOCJIe,lJ;IIee XOTeJIOCL
6bI nOKa3aTb Ha npIlMepe npOIIcxom)J;elIHH H cpOpMHpOBalIHH eBpone-
bH,lJ;HOn paCbI.
qTO npe,lJ;CTaBJIHeT C060H CeHqaC eBpOneOIl,lJ;HaH paca B :qeJIOM RaK onpe-
,lJ;eJIeUlIaH eD;IIIIH:qa alITpOnOJIOrIlqeCKOH KJIaCCIIcpHKa HH, KaK MopcpOJIOrnqe-
CKoe e.D:I1HCTBO? Ee rrpep:CTaBIITeJIHM CBOHCTBelIHbI CHJIbHO BbIcTynaIOm;HII y3-
KHII IIOC, BbICOKoe nepeHOCbe, pe3KO npocpIIJIHpOBaHlIoe JIII:qO, TOIIKIIe ry6bI,
npHMbIe HJIII IImpOKOBOJIIIIICTbIe MHrIUIe BOJIOCbI. no cpaBHelIHIO C IIerpOIl)J;a-
MIl H )laiRe C MOlIrOJIOIIp:aMII eBponeOHp:bI ropa3p:0 60JIee CBeTJIOIWiRII, CBeTJIO-
BOJIOChI II CBeTJIOrJIa3bI, npHqeM IIOCJIe,lJ;Hee cnpaBep:JIHBO ;rrame D;JIH iRIITeJIeH
Cpe,lJ;II3eMII0IlfOpbH, nepe.D:HeH H Cpe,lJ;Hen A3HH - HaII60JIee TeMIIOrJIa3bIX
JIIOn;eH Cpe,lJ;H eBpOneOH,lJ;OB. COBepllieHlIo eCTecTBelIlIbIII II 3aKoHoMeplIbIH BbI-
BO)J; I13 3Toro MopcpOJIOrHqeCIWrO ep:HlIcTBa 3aKJIIOqaeTCH B YTBepm,lJ;eHHH
reHeTUqeCKOrO pO,lJ;CTBa II eJJ:IIlIoro rrpoIlcxom;rrelIlfH eBpOneOH.D:II:bIX TllnOB.
O.D:IIaKO y alITpOnOJIOrOB IIeT COrJIaCHH B nOHHMaHHH nYTeH B03IIHKIIOBeHHH
eBpOneOII,lJ;IIOH paCbI. B COOTBeTCTBHH C O,lJ;HOH TOqKOn 3pe1IHH, nOJIyqHBllieH
H3HMelIOBalIIIe MOlIo:qeHTpllqeCKOH, Bce pachl cOBpeMelIlIoro qeJIOBeKa npoII-
30lliJIII B nepe,lJ;IIeH A3IIII OT HeliTpaJIblIbIX cpOpM IIealI,lJ;epTaJIb:qeB, 06'be.D:H-
HHBrnIlX npIl3IIal\:H Bcex Tpex 60JIbrnIlX pac; COrJIaCHO p:pyrolI rHnoTe3e, HR-
3BalIIIoH nOJIII:qeIITpIlqeCKOII, Kamp:aH paca BOCXO,lJ;HT K OC060H rpynrre He-
aUn;epTaJIb:qeB, npomIlBaBrnHx Ha TOM iRe KOIITlmeIITe. ABTOp pa3,lJ;eJIHeT
IIOJIH:qeIITpwrecKyIO rHnOTe3Y, HCXO,lJ;H H3 IIecoMHeHHoii MopcpOJIOrHqeCIwii:
npeeMCTBelIlIOCTH Mem,lJ;y eBpOneOH,lJ;aMH H eBpOneHCRI:lMH HeaHp:epTaJIh:qaMH,
i
,
.)J i
62
Mem,IJ;Y MOlIrOJIOII.D:lIbIMH pacaMII H CIIlIalITponOM, a TaKme II3 apXeOJIOrHqe-
CIUIX ,IJ;alIlIbIX, pIICYIOm;IIX RapTIIHY nOCTenelIlIoro rrepeXO,IJ;a OT IIHmlIerO na-
JIeOJIHTa K BepXlIeMY He TOJIbKO B IIepe,IJ;HeH A3HII, HO H B EBpone, KlfTae.
JOro-BOCTOqlIoiI A3HIf H T. ,IJ;. C )J;PyroH CTOpOlIbI, BalliHbIM npe.D:CTaBJIHeTCH
IIeCOMlIelIlIbIH cpaKT 60JIbmeH 6J1II30CTH eBpOneOH,IJ;OB R IIerpOIf,IJ;aM, qeM K
MOIIrOJIOH,IJ;aM, nO,IJ;TBeplK,IJ;aeMOH KaK IIaJIHqHeM npOMemYTOqHOH aBCTpaJIOIf,IJ;-
HOII pacbI II nmpOIaIM pacnpocTpalIelIIfeM IIerpO-aBCTpaJIOIf,IJ;OB B BepxHeM
naJIeOJIHTe IIa lOre EBponbI II eBponeOH,IJ;OB B Me30JIIfTe B CeBeplIOH AcppHIte,
TaK II cpOpMIfpOBalIIIeM pacoBbIx npII3IIaKOB B npo:qecce pOCTa. ()J,eTII IIerpon
II eBponeH:qeB 60JIbme nOXOiRII ,IJ;Pyr IIa )J;pyra, qeM B3pOCJIbIe IIerpbI H eBpo-
neiI:qbI. MOlIrOJIOIf,IJ;bI, IIa060pOT, OTJIIIqaIOTCH OT ,IJ;pyrIfx pac CIfJIhHee Bcero
IIMelIlIO B ,IJ;eTCKOM B03pacTe ".) 06m;ee npOIfCXOm,IJ;eIIHe eBpOneOIf,IJ;OB If He-
rpOH,IJ;OB BeCbMa BepoHTlIo, II 0110 ,IJ;eIICTBIfTeJIbIIO MomeT BOCXO,IJ;IfTb K nepe,IJ;-
HeH A3IIH, r,IJ;e IIaH,IJ;elIbI CKeJIeTbI IIealI,IJ;epTaJIb:qeB, KOTOpbIM CBoHCTBelIHbI
ObIJIH II eBpOneOIf.D:IIbIe H HerpoH)J;IIbIe oc06eHlIocTH.
B 3TOii IfCXO.D:IIOH rpynne IIeaII)J,epTaJIh eB H eBpOneOIIp;IIhh) II llerpoH,IJ;-
IIhIe qepTbI 6bIJIH BbIpaiRelIbI, O.D:IIaKO, cJIa6ee, qeM y cOBpeMelIlIbIx pac.
<I>opMIIpoBalIIfe TlfIlIfqlIO eBpOneOH,IJ;IIOH KOM6IfHanIfH npH3IIaKOB, KaK MbI ee
3IIaeM Tenepb, npOIfCXO,IJ;IfJIO, OqeBH,IJ;IIO, no,IJ; BJIIfHIIIIeM MlIorHX cpaItTopOB V
IIaqHlIaH C 3nOXII BepxlIero naJIeOJlIITa. B nepBYIO Oqepe)J;b 3TO - BJIIfHIIIIe
CMemelIHH rpynn nepe,IJ;IIea3IfaTcIwro npOIfCXOm.D:eIIIIH C eBponeiIcKIfMIf IIe-
alI.D:epTaJIhnaMH; 06 3TOM rOBopHT CII blIoe BhlcTynalIIIe Hoca y npe.D:CTaBH-
Te eH eBpOneOII,IJ;HOH paCbI, TaIWe me, KaK H y eBponeHcKHx HealIn;epTaJIb:qeB.
06 aTOM me CBH,IJ;(JTeJIhCTByeT H OqelIb pa3BIfTbIH pe.:'Ibecp IIa MlIorHX palIHIfX
BepXlIenaJIeOJIIfTIfqeCmIX qepenax II3 EBponbI - oc06elIlIocTb, TIIIHIqlIaH ,IJ;JIH
eBponeHcmIx IIeaH.D:epTaJIb:qeB. KpoMe CMerneIIIIH C MeCTIIbIMH rpynnaMH
HealI,IJ;epTaJIb eB, CJIe,IJ;yeT yKa3aTb Ha npIfcnoc06JIeHIfe It CypOBbIM YCJIOBIfHM
IIpIfJIe,IJ;IIIfKOBOH EBponbI: Y3KHII HOC OrpaHHqHBaJI O.D:HOBpeMeHHoe B)J;bIxalIIfe
60JIbmOrO KOJIH"IJeCTBa XOJIO,IJ;IIoro B03,IJ;yxa If 3am;Hm;aJI HOCOrJIOTKY. HaIwlIe:q.
B B03HIIRIIOBelIHH xapaKTepHOH ,IJ;JIH eBpOneOII,IJ;IIOH paCbI nIIrMeIITa HH, IIe-
COMlIeIIIIO, BeJIHRa pO b relIoreorpacpHqeCKIfX 3aKOIIOMepIIOCTeH.
EBponeOlIAlIaH paca nO,IJ;pa3,IJ;eJIHeTCH Ha ceBepHYIO If IOmlIYIO BeTBIf. Ce-
BepHaH BeTBb - 3TO IIaCeJIelIIfe CKaH)J;IfHaBIfH, HCJIaH,IJ;IIH II H pJIaH)J;HIf, AlIr-
irnif, - ce'B eplIbIx pallOHOB r.n;p H <I>pr, <I>IIH HII,IJ;IIH, npIf6aJITIfHCKHX pecny6-
JIIIK COBeTCRoro COI03a, ceBeplIbIX paHOIIOB eBponeHCRon qaCTH PC<I>CP.
IQ mHbIe e BponeOIf)J,bI - aTO IIaCeJIelIHe ceBeplIOH "IJaCTII HII)J;HH, AcpralIHCTa-
IIa, HpaHa H TYP HlI, apaOOH3bIqlIbIX CTpaH, TYPKMelICIWH H A3ep6a H .D:1KaH-
CKOH, ApMHIICKOH H rpY3IIIICIWH CCP, JOiRlIoiI HTaJIIIH II JOmHoiI <I>palI HH.
HcnalIIfII II nOpTyraJIIfII. 06JIaCTII, npOMelI{YTOqHbIe Mem,IJ;y 3TIfMH 301IaMH.
3alIHTbI IIaCeJIeIIIfeM, IWTopoe 3aHHMaeT B alITpOnOJIOrIfqeCKOH IwaCCHcpHRa-
:qHH cpe,IJ;IIee MeCTO Mem,ZJ;y ceBeplIbIMH II IOmHbIMII eBpOneOII,IJ;aMIf. Bo Bcex
nepeqHCJIelIlIhlX CTpalIax aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIe npH3IIaKH CHJIblIO BapbHpyIOT,
BbI,IJ;eJIHIOTCH MeCTHbIe aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKIfe TlfIlhI. Ho lIe COCTaBJIHeT IIII Ma-
JIelirnero TpY,IJ;a ,IJ;aiI\e .D:JIH Hecne:qHaJlIICTOB OTJIII'lHTb, IIanpHMep, rpY3IflIa
HJlII apMHlIlfIIa OT IIIBe,IJ;a no BHernHeMY BII,IJ;Y C nepBoro B3rJIH)J;a.
O,IJ;IIaKO BapHa:qIfH Bcex IIpIf3IIaKOB, xapaKTeplIbIx ,IJ;JIH MeCTHbIX eBpOIIeo-
II)J;IIbIX THnOB, IfMelIlIO IfM If CBoHcTBeIIHhI, OIIH He OXBaTblBaIOT IIeCKOJIbKIIX
HapOilOB IfJIH rpynn HapO,IJ;OB, 06HapymHBaIOT, RaK rOBopHT aHTpOnOJIOrH, MO-
3aHqHOe pacnpe)J;eJIeHHe Ha reorpacpIIqeCKOH ImpTe. E,IJ;IfHCTBelIlIbIe npIf3IIaKH.
npOTHBonOCTaBJIHIOm;Ife HaCeJIelIHe _ceBepa II IOra EBpOIIbI, pa3,IJ;eJIHIOm;Ife ce-
BepHbIX H IOmHbIX eBpOneOH,IJ;OB,- npIf3HaKH nHrMeIITa IIH, :qBeTa rJIa3, BO-
JIOC II KomII. AIITpono orH pbHHO, IIa nepBhlX nopax, H 6h1 CIm3a , npOCTO
HccTynJIeHHO HCKaJIH em;e RaKHe-HHt'\Y,IJ;b qepThI, C nOMOm;hIO ROTOpbIX MOllmo
,/
63
"
PIIC. 1. reorpacPH'IeCRHe BapHaqlIH qBeTa R01KH Ha TeppHTopHH EBpOfibI
1 - O'IeHb CBeTJIaH Roma (nOi\aBJIHIOmee npeo6.rrap;aHHe OTTeHROB 1-12 no IIma.rre <1>. JIymaHa);
2 - HeCHo.rrbRO oo.rree TeJ\IHaH Roma (P;OBOJIbHO 'IaCTO BCTpe'IaIOTCH OTTeHRH 13-15)
UbIJIO 6bI OTJIHqHTb CeBeplIbIX eBpOneHneB OT IOmlIbIX, CeBeplIyIO, HJIH 6aJITHH-
CKyIO, BeTBb eBpOneOIlp;IIOII paCbI OT IOiRHOII, I1JIII Cpe)J;I13eMIIOMOpCKOH. nO-
HCInI 6bIJIIl Tm;eTlIbI: OIIH TaK H lIe yBelIqaJIIICb ycnexoM, lIe HarnJIOCb IIII
op;noro npH3IIaKa, KpOMe minfeIITa I1I1, BapIla I1H KOToporo OTJInqa.:'IIICb 6bI
CTporo 3aIWIIOMeplIbIM pacnpe)J;eJIelIHeM IIa KapTe EBpOnbI. A TaK IWI, nIlrMelI-
'Ta I1H .D:peBlIero IIaCeJIelIIIH OCTaeTCH HeIl3BeCTIIOM, TO IIeH3BeCTIIbIMII OCTa-
IOTCH II JJ;peBIIHe apeaJIbI ceBeplIbIX II IOiRlIbIX eBponeOIl)J;OB, I1X COOTHornelIIIe
Ha eBponeii:cIwH reorpacpIlqeCIwii: KapTe B palIlIHe 3nOXIf cpOp""UIpOBaIIHH eB-
poneoIlp;Hoii: paCbI.
R'aK iRe pacnpe)J;eJIelIbI ceii:qac reorpacpIIqeCKH Bce TPH npIf3IIaKa, OTpa-
maIOm;ne pa3BHTIIe nHrMelITa? HaH60JIee TeMHOKomIle JIIOP;H iRIIBYT B ceBep-
uoil 'IaCTH HU.D:I1H, AcpralIIICTaHe, TYPKMeHcIWII II A3epoaHiJ,iRanCJWH CCP,
B apa6CKIIx cTpalIax. nepCbI, apMHHe, rpY3HIIhI II p;pyrHe napo)J;bI R'aBI(a3a,
rpeKII, 60JIrapbI, IOiRIIbIe IITaJIbHHU;bI H cppalI:qY3bI, I1CnalI bI II nopTyraJIb:qbI
60JIee CBeTJIOIWiRH. XOTH H KamYTcH TeMIIOIWiRHMII npH cpaBlIelIIfII, CKaiReM,
C pycclmMII. BcnOMIIJUI HTaJIbHIICKHe cpIIJIbMbI - pa3Be repoII B IIHX He npo-
H3BOP;HT BneqaTJIeIIJIe OqelIb TeMlIbIX JIIO.D:eH? A Be)J;b B HIIX p;eHcTBYIOT JIIO,'];I1
lIe TOJIbIW H3 lOiRIIOH, 110 II I13 CeBeplIoii: HTaJIIIH, IIaCeJIelIHe KOTOpOH 3a-
MeTIIO CBeTJIee IOiRlIbIX IITaJIbHH:qeB. Em;e 60JIee CBeTJIYIO KOiRY HMeIOT ce-
64
r:
.
0'
.::8'"
tII°
ffif
E:::3 I rrrnn 2
H1ffiI3
PRe. 2. reorpacPR'IeCKIIe BapIIaU1I1I n;BeTa BOJIOC Ha TeppIITopIIII EBpOlIbI
1 - MeHbllIe 50% TeMHbIX Bonoe (oTTeHHII 27,4-8 IIO IImane 3. <I>lIllIepa); 2 - 30-80% TeMHbIX
Bonoe; 3 - f)onbIIIe 80% TeMHblX Bonoe
BeplIbIe cppalIl(Y3bI H 6eJIbrHH:qbI, IIeM:qbI IOllilIbIX H eHTpaJIbHbIX paHOIIOB EB-
ponbI, xopBaTbI II CJIOBeH I>l, BenrpbI, qeXH, CJIOBaKH, YKpaIIII:qbI, pYCCKIIe
IOmlIbIX 06JIaCTeil. PYCCKHe eHTpaJIblIbIX paHOIIOB, 6eJIOPYCbI, nOJIHKII, IIeM-
:qbI ceBeplIhIX 06JIaCTelI 1I0qTlI TaK me CBeTJIOKOmII, KaK. II CKalI)];HHaBbI, ROTO-
phle COCTaBJIHIOT nOCJIe)];HIOIO cTynelIb B nmaJIe OTTeHIWB :qBeTa KomII,-
y HnK nHrMelITa OTKJIa,ZJ;bIBaeTCH OqelIb MaJIO (pIfC. 1). RapTbI pacnpOCTpa-
HelIIfH pa3JIHqlIbIX OTTelIKOB BeTa BOJIOC H rJIa3 - OT caMoro TeMlIoro )];0
caMoro CBeTJIOrO - y IIaCeJIelIIfH EBpOIlbI MaJIO OTJIIfqaIOTCH OT KapTbI pac-
npOCTpalIeIlIIH :qBeTa KOiRH (pHC. 2, 3). TaKHM 06pa30M, B EBpone MomHO
BbI)];eJIIfTb KaR 6bI IIeCIWJIbKO 3011 C IOra IIa ceBep, If IIaCeJIelIIfe KaiR)];OH no-
CJIe)J;YIOm;eH 60JIee ceBeplIoH 30lIhI 6y)];eT 3aMeTHO 60JIee CBeTJIOKOiRIfM, CBeT-
JIOrJIa3bIM II CBeTJIOBOJIOCbIlIf, qeM HapO,lJ;bI, npolliHBaIOm;He B npe)];mecTBYro-
m;eil 301Ie.
OT MopcpOJIOrHH Tenepb 06paTIfMcH K reorpacpHH H paCCMOTpIIM reorpa-
cpIflIecKIIe OqepTaHIfH CTaporo CBeTa, H B qaCTIIOCTII EBpa3I1If. ECJIH cpop-
MHpOBaHHe eBpOneOIf.D:IIOH pachl HJIH Toil KOM6HHa:qHH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
npH3IIaKOB, Ha OCIIOBe KOTOpOH CcpOpMHpOBaJIaCb eBpOneOH)];HaH paca, npo-
nCXO)];IIJIO B nepe)];Heli A3IfIf, TO EBpony C nOJIlIbIM OCIIOBalIIIeM MOiRHO
pacCMaTpIIBaTb no OTlIomeHHIO R 3Ton 30lIe RaR :rrepHcpepHnHyIO 06JIaCTL.
3 B. n. .A.rreHeeeB
65-
0'
g10
,
o EB"
. .
"
.
't
II I
1 IEffi3 3
[ill] 2 fmEI 4
PIIC. 3. reorpacPH'IeCRlIe BapHaIlIIH l\BeTa mas Ha TeppHTopHII EBpOlIbI
1- CBeTJIbIe rJIasa (oTTeHlU1 9-12 no nIRaJIe B. B. BYHaKa), BCTPe'laroTcH f)OJIl,IlIe, 'leM B 60%
CJIY'laeB; 2 - 40-60% CBeTJIbIX rJIas; 3 - 20-39,9% CBeTJIbIX rJIas; 4 - MeHbille 20% CBeTJIbIX
rJIas
ITepeAHHH A3HH JIemHT B :qeHTpe CTapOrO CBeTa, B panOHe COnpHKOCHOBe-
HHH BCeX TpeX MaTepHKOB, B TO BpellfH KaK EBpOna BbIrJIH IIT qy OBHI:qlIbIM:
no BeJIHTIHHe nOJIyoCTpOBOM e HlIoro MaTepIII\:a EBpa3nII. C 3Ton TOqKII 3pe-
HIIH JII060nbITHO, TITO HaII60JIee HHTelICHBHaH p;eIIIIrMeHTa:qHH xapaKTepHa B
EBpone He P;JIH HaCeJIeHIIH BceH ceBeplIon 301IbI, a HMelIHO P;JIH IIapO)J;OB CKalI-
JJ;HHaBHH, T. e. )J;JIH Tex IIapOp;OB, KOTOpbIe yp;aJIelIbI OT :qelITpa CTaporo
CBeTa - nepep;HeH A3IIn IIa Han60JIbmee paCCTOHIIHe. ITpIIMeTIaTeJIbHa H no-
CJIep;OBaTeJIbIIOCTb, nOCTenelIlIOCTb nOCBeTJIelIHH BOJIOC, rJIa3 n KOiRn JIIO eH
B IIanpaBJIelInH Ha ceBepO-3ana)J; OT nepep;HeH A3HH, qero IIeT BO Bcex OCTaJIb-
HbIX HanpaBJIeIIHHX.
ECJIII qHTaTeJIb em;e He orap;aJICH, Ryp;a KJIOHHT aBTOp, TO, BO BCHKOM
CJIyqae, 011 no rOTOBJIeII K 3TOMY: aBTOp nOJIaraeT, qTO ep;nIICTBelIlIbIM
yp;aTIHbIM 06'hHClIeHHellf BCex OTMeqelIlIbIX cpaKTOB, II npHTOM 06'hHClIeIIHeM,
He Tpe6yrom;IIM IIHRaRHX p;OnOJIHIITeJIbHbIX rHnOTe3, MomeT CJIymHTb relloreo-
rpacpHqeCRaH Hp;eH H. M. BaBIIJIOBa 06 OTTeCHeHHH pe:qeCCHBOB B nepncpepH-
qeCKHe paHolIbI II3 :qelITpa apeaJIa. I(BeT Komn TaKme, nO-BHp;HMoMy, pe:qec-
CHBlIbIH npII3HaK, KaK H OCTaJIbHbIe oc06elIlIocTH, CBH3alIIIbIe C )J;enIIT'MeHTa-
:queH. BCH p;enIIrMeIITa HH BbIcTynaeT, TaKHM o6pa30M, e HHbIM KOMIIJIeKcoM.
66
XOTH K nOJIIIOH p;eIIHrMeIITa:qIfII H npIIBOp;HT HaKOnJIeHHe B relIOTHIle IIeCROJIb-
RIIX pe:qeCCHBlIbIX relIOB. OTTeClIelIHe HX B OKpaIIHlIbIe 06JIaCTH nOJIHOCTbIO
{)6'bHCIIHeT, nOqeMY B EBpone :qBeT BOJIOC, rJIa3 II KOiRII CBeTJIeeT C IOra IIa
c.eBep (nOCTenelIlIoe OTTeClIelIHe OT elITpa paco06pa30BaIIHH), nO"IJeMy HaH-
60JIbrnaH p;enIIrMeHTa:qlfH xapaKTepHa .D:JIH IIaCeJIelIlfH CKalIp.:IIlIaBIfII (IIaH-
(iOJIbrnee yp;aJIelIHe OT :qelITpa paco06pa30BaIIIIH), IIOqeMY 3TOT npo:qecc npo-
HBIIJICH IIMelIlIO npH cpOpMHpOBaHIIH eBpOIIeOIIp;HOn paCbI, a He KaKOH-JIH60
IfIlOM (cBoe06pa3IIOe reorpacpHqeCKOe IIOJIOmelIIIe EBponbI KaK nOJIYOCTpOBa
MaTepIIKa EBpa3IIH H, CJIep.:OBaTeJIbIIO, reorpacpIIqeCKaH npep;nOCbIJIRa P;JIH
H30JIH IIII). Ihm" 3aKOII BbITeClIeHHH pe:qeCCIIBlIbIX MyTa:qHH IIa ORpaIIHY
BHp;OBoro HJIII paCOBoro apeaJIa, 3aKOII, p;eHCTBHe KOToporo 6JIIICTaTeJIhHO
IIJIJIIOCTpIIpOBalIO npHMeHHTeJIbHO R qeJIOBeI,Y IIa npIIMepe HaCeJIeHIIH 3anap;-
Horo rHII,ll,YRYrna II CKaH)J;IIHaBHH, MomeT 6h1Tb pacnpOCTpaHeH H Ha ropa3-
,ZJ;O 60JIee 06ru;ee HBJIelIHe - B03HHKIIOBeHHe H cpOpMIIpOBalIHe op;Horo H3 OC-
HOBHbIX paCOBbIX CTBOJIOB COBpeMelIlIoro qeJIOBe"IJeCTBa. felIoreorpacpHH H
IIonYJIH:qHOHHaH reHeTHKa BHOCHT 60JIbIIIOH BKJIap; B pa3'bHCHeHHe H nOHH-
MaHHe qpe3BbIqaHII0 BaiRlIOH np06JIeMbI paco06pa30BaHHH, H OP;IIIIM II3
I1IfOHepOB BHeceHIIH HX MeTop;OB H 3aKOHOB B alITpOnOJIOrHIO BhlcTynHJI nOqTH
60 JIeT IIa3ap; HHKoJIaiI IIBalIOBIIq BaBIIJIOB.
f. <1>. .D:e6e:q paCCI>a3bIBaJI aBTopy, qTO, noroBopHB C H. II. BaBHJIOBhlM
nOJIqaca, 011 3anOMIIHJI :3TOT pa3roBop IIa BCIO m:H3Hb - TaKHMH rJIy60RHMH
H TOHIrnMH 6bIJIH CYiK)J;eIIIIH H. II. BaBIIJIOBa no BonpocaM aHTpOnOJIOrHH,
3THorelIe3a, p;peBlIeH IICTOpHII. OrpoMlIbIH YM, aKKYMYJIHpoBaBIIIIIn rp alI .D: H0 3-
IIbIe no 06'beMY II pa3IIo06pa3HbIe 3HaHHH, OTKphlJI 06m;IIe 3aKOlIbI, p;eHcTBYIO-
I:qHe IIa Bcex ypOBHHX mII3HII H B3aIIMop;eHcTBHH 6HOJIOrHqeCKHX CHCTeM, 3a-
KOlIbI, IIIlIpOKO npIIMeHHMbIe H K 06'bHCHeHHIO 6HOJIOruqecKHx oc06elIHocTen
"IJeJIOBeKa.
1 IIl'IcbJlia H. 11. Bamr,lOua K B. n. BepHap;cRo;\lY /1 feHeTI'IRa. 1966. 2 8. C. 141.
2 Herrlich A. Beitrag zur Rassen- und Stammeskunde der Hindukusch-Kafiren. Deut-
sche in Hindukush. E., 1937.
g e601;,capoB H. H. 113 I'ICTOpl'l1'l CBeTJIblX paCOBbIX TI'IIIOB EBpa31'1II II AHTPOIIOJI. 1KYPH.
1936. NQ 2.
-& IIop;60pRY JII'ITepaTypHbIX p;aHHbIX CJ\I.: Pozu1icnuu H. H. ]{ Borrpocy 0 B03pacTHblx II3-
MeneHIIHX pacoBblx IIpII3HaKoB Y '1eJIOBeKa (B YTPOOHOM lIepIIOp;e II B p;eTcTBe) /1
AHTporroJIOrII'IeCRI'IH C60PHIIR, II. M., 1960. (Tp. HH-Ta 3THorpacPIIII AH CCCP. H.C.;
T.50).
3HA 1:IEHME TPY OB H. M. BABMJIOBA
JIH TEOPETM1:IECKOfi AHTPOrrOJIOr M
AIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKaH IIayKa op;IIHaKOBO TeCHO CBH3aHa KaK C IICTopHen, TaK
II C 6HOJIOrHeH. Pa3BHTHe aHTpOnOJIOrH'leCKHX THIIOB qeJIOBeqeCTBa, HX npo-
HcxOilip;elIHe II B3alIlvIOOTIIOIIIeHHH IIeOTp.:eJIIIMbI OT HCTOpHII IIapOp;OB, IIX 8T-
HIIqeCKIIX CBH3eH H MIIrpa:qIIn. B HCTOpIIH aHTpOnOJIOr "IJepnaeT 60raTbIH Ma-
TepHaJI P;JIH CBOIIX IIa6JIIO,ll,eIIIIII, a IflIorp;a II 0606m;eIIHH, II60 6e3 HCTOpHqe-
cKOll IfHcpopMa:qIIH OCTaIOTCH "IJaCTO IIenOIIHTHbIlIfII MlIorHe aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKHe
cpaKTbI. Ho B TO iRe BpeMH 6IIOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa - qaCTh 06m;eH 6IIOJIOrHH,
OHOJIOruqeCKHe 3aKOHbI coxpalIHIOT CBOIO BJIaCTb Hap; qeJIOBeIWM H B HOBOM,
npe06pamelIIIOM BHp;e - B co:qHaJIbHOH cpep.:e npOp;OJImaIOT OKa3bIBaTb B03-
p;eIICTBIIe Ha relIeTHqeCKHII COCTaB nonYJIH:qHn, a CTaJIO 6bITb, H IIa IIX 6IIO-
JIOrIIqecKyIO ,ZJ;;KHaMIIKY. n03TOMy alITpOnOJIOrHH OqelIb qYBCTBHTeJIbHa R ,ZJ;O-
67
3*
CTHmeHIIHM 06m;e6IIOJIOrIlqeCKOH MbICJIll H qYTKO pearIlpyeT IIa II3MelIelIIIe
nOJIOiRelIIIH B 06JIaCTH TeopHH 8BOJIIO:qllH, yqeHHH 0 reorpacpHqeCKOH I13MeH-
'lIIBOCTII, nonYJIH IfOIIIIOH relIeTIIKII II T. )];. Oc06elIII0 BeJIIIKO 3HaqelIIIe .D:JIH
alITpOnOJIOrIlIl Kap)J;IfIIaJIblIbIX 6HOJIOrII IeCKIIX 0606m;eIIIIH, C.D:eJIalIlIbIX 3a
nOCJIe)];HIIe ,qecHTHJIeTIIH II CBH3aBrnHX TeCIIO H IIepa3pbIBII0 relIeTIIKY C 06m;eli
TeopIleH 3BOJIIO:qlfOlIlIoro npo:qecca, IIIIbIMII CJIOBaMH, 3aJIOiRIIBlliHX cpYIIiJ,a-
MelIT yqelIIIH 0 relIeTII IeCKIIX OCIIOBax 3BOJIIO:qIlII.
HayqHoe TBOpqeCTBO HIIKOJIaH MBalIOBIIqa BaBIfJIOBa npe)J;cTaBJIHeT C060H
O)];HY H3 BbICO'IanlliIIX BeplliHH B 6I10JIOl'IIH XX B. reHeTIIK II reorpacp, I1CCJIe-
)];OBaTeJIb KYJIbTYPHOH cpJIOpbI H TeopeTlm 3BOJIIO:qHII, cpIlTOIIaTOJIOr H arpolIoM,
H. M. BaBIIJIOB Ha HarnIlX rJIa3aX B 3IIOXY I1CKJIIO IIfTeJIbIIOH )];HcpcpepeH:qIIa-
:qIIH IIaYlm BOCKpeClfJI 3II I1KJIOne.D:I13M, KOTOpbIH, Ka3aJIOCb 6bI, yme 6e3Bo3-
BpaTlIo yllieJI B npOlliJIOe. nOMIIMO nepe IIfCJIeHlIbIX 06JIaCTeli 3IIaIIIIH, BIma)];
B KOTopbIe H. M. BaBHJIOBa nO)];aBJIHIOm;e rpOMa)];elI, B ero pa60Tax MO'hHO
llaHTH HeIlC IepnaeMOe KOJII1:qeCTBO qaCTHbIX IIa6JIIO)];eIIIIH, KacaIOm;IIXCH II
HCTOpIIH 3eMJIep:eJIIIH, II BJIHHIIIIH eCTecTBelIlIoreorpacpIlqeClmX YCJIOBnlI IIa
06pa3 lliIl3IUI qeJIOBeKa. II BOCCTalIaBJIIIBaeMOII no apxeoJIOrIlqeCKIIM lIaMHT-
IIIIKaM )];peBlIelI I1CTOpIlIl Toro I1JIII IIIIoro IIapo)];a, II 8TlIorpallnuI. ECTecTBelI-
110, qTO MbICJIb yqelIoro Talwro MacrnTa6a 06pam;aJIaCb I{ ca fhIM iPYII;:\3MelI-
TaJIblIbIM np06JIeMaM 6I1oJIorIlIl II BlIeCJIa B HX 06cya{):J.eIIIIe II)J;eu I1CKJIfO'III-
TeJIblIOrO 3IIa'IeIIIIH. M3 IIIIX caMbIll,fH BaiRlIbIMH no nmpoTe OXBaTa CPaI{TOB
H rJIy6IfIIe npolIIIKlIoBelIIIH B np06JIeMY HBJIHIOTCH TeopIlH reH eIITpoB, 3aKOH
OTTeClIelIHH pe eccHBoB IIa oKpaIIIIY BII.D:OBOro apeaJIa H 3aROII rOMOJIOrIIqe-
CRHX PH)];OB B IIaCJIe.D:CTBeIIIIOH H3MelIqIlBOCTII. 0606m;eIIIfH TaKoro ypOBIIH
BbIXO)];HT 3a paMIU1: Tex cpaKTOB, C nOMOm;bIO KOTOpbIX OIIII 6bfJIII OTI{PLITbI
H. M. BaBHJIOBbIM, BbIX0.D:HT 3a paMIm ;rraiRe 6I10JIorlfII H MorYT 6bITb nJIo;:\o-
TBopno HcnOJIb30BalIbI B CMemlIbIX 06JIaCTHX 3IIaIIIIH, B qaCTIIOCTH B alITpono-
JIOrIfIf: nepBLIe )];Ba - )];JIH npOIIIIRIIOBelIHH B 3aIwlIOMeplIOCTH cpOpMupOBalIlfH
aHTpOnOJIOrUqeCIWrO COCTaBa qeJIOBeqeCTBa, TpeTbe - .D:JIH nOHlnIaIIIIH 3aKO-
HOB I13MelIqHBOCTII qeJIOBeqeCIWro opralIII3Ma II pa3BIITIIH yqeHIIH 0 npoIlcxom-
)];eIIHH qeJIOBelm.
3RCllE,lJ;I1I{IUI
06cTalIoBKa aKTIIBHon HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIblIOH mH3IIH C )];eTCTBa oKpYiRaJIa
H. M. BaBIfJIOBa 1. 8TIIM MOiRlIO 06'hHCIIIITb OTqaCTH TOT CPaI{T, qTO II 6paT
HIIKOJIaH, CepreH, II ceCTpbI, AJIeKCaH.D:pa II JIIIWlH, CTaJIII I{pynlIbIMII eCTe-
CTBOHcnbITaTeJIHMU. CaM HIIKOJIaH MnalIOBIIq no IIaCTOHIIIIIO OT:qa OKOlIqlfJI
HOllfMepqeCKOe yqHJIHm;e, B KOTOpOM B OTJIIIqHe OT KJIaCCHqeCKHX rIlMIIa3uH
lIe npenop:aBaJIIICb p:peBlIIIe H3bnm - JIaTIIIICKIIH II rpe IeCKIIH, 110 3aTO 6bfJIO
XOpOlliO nOCTaBJIelIO rrpenO)];aBalIHe OCHOBlIbIX 3ana)];IIOeBpOneHCKHX H3bmOB.
a KpOMe Toro, y)];eJIHJIOCb 60JIhrnOe BIIIIMalIue cpH3HI{e, XIIlIfIIIf, p:pyrIlM eCTe-
CTBelIlIbIM )J;I1c:qHnJIHHaM, BeJIIICb npaKTIIKYMbI IIO HIIM, nOOm;pHJIIICb caMO-
CTOHTeJIbHbI€ 3aHHTHH yqam;IIxCH. MMelIHO 3TII 06CTOHTe.:'ILCTBa np06YAIIJIH
y H. M. BaBIfJIOBa paHHIOIO JII060Bb K eCTeCTB03HaIIHIO, onpe.D:eJIImrnyIO ero
iRII3IIelIIIbIII nYTh, H B TO me npeMH BocnpelIHTCTBOBamr ero IIocTynJIeHIIIO B
YIIIIBepCHTeT, TaK KaK Oll lIe XOTeJI TepHTb ro.D:, qT06hI nO.D:rOTOBIITbCH H C;J:aTb
3K3aMeII no JIaTHHCKOMY H3bmy. H. M. BaBIfJIOB 3aIWHqIlJI MOCKOBCIUIH CeJIb-
CKOX03HHCTBelIIIbIII IIHCTIITYT 2.
EHorpacp HIIKOJIaH MBaIIOBH'Ia lliHBO onIICbIBaeT TY IIIITeJIJIeKTyaJIblIYIO
aTMoccpepy, B KOTOpOH IIpOXO)];IfJIII ero IOlIorneCKIIe rO)J;bI H B KOTOpOli 3apo-
)];HJIaCb IIeyeMHaH cTpacTb K KHHre, IIpOHeCeHlIaH qepe3 BCIO iRII3IIh: «AoM
BaBHJIOBbIX... 6bfJI pa3)];eJIeII Ha )];Be qaCTII. nOJIOBHHY )J;oMa 3alIIIMaJIH PO.D:H-
68
TeJIII. lliIIJIII OIIH no onpe.D:eJIelIlIOMY pacnopH)],KY, COOJIIO)],aH CBOH )],aBIIIIe
npIIBbIqIUI. ApyraH nOJIOBIIlIa npIIHa.D:JIeiRaJIa )],eTHM, KOTOpbIe BeJIII COBep-
IIIelIUO IIIIYro mII3IIb. qero TO.:'IbIW 3)],eCb lIe 6bIJIO: ceTKII C rep6aprreM II ce-
Mena caMbIX pa3IIo06pa3IIbIX paCTeHIIH, JIynbI, IIOBeHrneH CIICTeMhI MIIKpOCKon,
BceB03MOiRIIbIe npenapaTbI, npHrOTOBJIelIIIbIe )J;JIH npOCMOTpa IIO)], MlmpOCKO-
nOM, IWPTbI, IUIIIrII... CTapIIIIIIbIe H IIoBeihnero II3)J;aIIIIH IUIIIrII Ha PYCCROxf,
cppaHI Y3CIWM, alIrJIIIIICIWM, IIeMeT KOllf, IITaJILHIICKOM II .D:Pynlx H3I,u;:aX no
nCTopIIII IIaYlm, paCTeIIIIeBO.D:CTBY, apXeOJIOrIIII, reorpacpIIII, IICKYCCTBY, onII-
calIIIe nYTerneCTBIIH II MlIorIIe .D:PyrHe» 2. TamIM oGpa30M, It qTelIIIIO aIlIOII "
pa3IIo06pa31I0H JIIITepaTypbI Ha IIIIOCTpaHlIbIX H3bIhax, B TOM 'IIICJIe H IIecne-
:qHaJIbIIOII, H. M. BaBIIJIOB IIpIIBbm C IOlIorneCKIIX JIeT, em;e )],0 nOCTYIIJI H
B BhIcrnee yqe6IIoe 3aBe.D:eIIIIe.
B IfHCTInYTe, a TaKme paOOTaH noc,lIe ero OKOII'IaIHIH B JIa60paTopIUlX II
Ha CeJIeKU;HOlIlIbIX CTalI:qlfHX AlIrJIIfIf II <DpalI:qHII, H. M. BaBIIJIOB npII06peJt
o6rnIIpHbIe 06m;e6IIOJIOrIIqeCIme 3IIaIIIIH, )J;OCKOIJaJIbIIO II3Y'lIIJI KYJILTypnyIO
cpJIOPY. B 8TII iRe rO.D:bI 6bIJIII 3aJIOmenbI OCIIOBbI Toro IICIWIO'IIfTeJIbIIOrO IfH-
Tepeca K reorpacpIIII KYJIbTYPlIbIX paCTeIIIIII, KOTCpbIH Rcer)J;a OTJIII'IaJI
H. M. BaBIIJIOBa II KOTOpbIH n03BOJIIIJI eMY n03me C03)],aTb Y'IeHIIe 0 u;eIITpax
npOIICXom.D:eHlfH OCIIOBIIhIX BII)J;OB ItYJIbTYPIIbIX paCTelIIIii. O;J,II3 II3 COTPY)J;IIII:q
H. M. BaBIIJIOBa no BceCOI03HOMY IIIICTIITYTy paCTeJIIIelJOL\CTBa - A. IO. Ty-
nlfIWBa C006m;aeT, '1TO, CY.D:H no ero nIICbMaM, OCIIOBIIble KOIITYPbI Y'IeHlfH
o npOIICXOiR.D:eIIIIII KYJILTYPlIbIX paCTelIIIH OcpOpMIIJIHCb K 1916-1917 rr.
CaMa II.D:eH lIe MOrJIa B03IIImlIYTb oe3 rnIIpOqaHrnerO 3II3KOMCTBa C IICTOplfIW-
3TIIorpacpIIqeCKOII H reorpacpII'IeCIWn JIIITepaTypoH, 6e3 conOCTaBJIeIIIIH co6-
CTBelIlIO arp060TaHIIqeCKIIX IIa6JIIO)],eIIIIH C reorpallmqecKIIM pacnpOCTpaHe-
HIIeM no 3eMJIe .D:peBlIelmIIIx U;IIBII.'III3a:qIIii, C IIcTopIIel1 IIX paC BeT3 II yna.D:-
Ka, C pe3YJIbTaTaMII IICCJIe)],OBaHIIH x03HiicTBa II arpIIKyJIbTypbI .D:peBuelflliIIx
HapO)],OB.
A. 10. TymmoBa OCTaBIIJIa IIaM )],paro eHlIoe CBII)J;eTeJIbCTBO 06 IIIITepece
HIIKOJIaH MBaIIOBII'Ia It 3TIIorpaiPHII H apxeOJIOrmI YiRe B Te rO)J;bI. JIeToM
1916 r. 011 no p.:opore B 3KCneL\IIU;IIIO B nepCHIO 3aeXaJI Ha TYPKecTalIcKYIO
onbITIIYIO CTalIl{IIIO, r.n:e A. IO. TynHKoBa npOBO.D:IIJIa JIeTIIIOIO npaItTIIKy,
H npOmIIJI TaM IIeCKOJIbIW )],IIeH, TJ3yqaH KYJIbTYPlIbIe paCTeIIIIH Y36eKIICTalIa
KaK IIa Cal'>fOH CTalI:qIIII, Talt II B MaprnpYTax no OItpYiRaIOm;IIM paHOlIaM.
HecMoTpn 113 IICTWIOqlITeJILIIO IIanpHmelIlIYIO pa60TY II IIe)J;OCTaTOK BpeMelIII,
Jl.lIIoro CII.:'I 6hIJIO Y.D:eJIeno oGCJIe)J;OBaIIIIIO CeJILCIWX03HiicTBelIHoro IIIIBeIITapH,
Tm;aTeJIbIIOMY OCMOTPY )],OMOBII )J;OMarnlIeli YTBapII Y36eIWB, IIX cpOTorpacpII-
pOBaIIIIIO. A em;e qepe3 ro)], H. M. BaBIIJIOB c006m;aeT eH II3 MOCI{BbI: «C3-
Moe IIIITepecIIoe - 3TO :reK IIII BaJIeplfH EpIOcoBa 0 p.:peBlIeHrneH ItyJIbType
'IeJIOBeqeCTBa... M co)],epiRaIIIle H cpopMa IIa 5. 8relICltaH KYJIbTypa BCH miK
iIDIBaH» 5. Peqb II)],eT, nO-BIIL\HlIfOMY, 06 II3BeCTIIOH pa60Te B. H. BpIOcoBa,
cop.:epiRaBrneli OqelIh rrOJIlIhIH II KBaJIIIcpII IIpoBaIIlIbIH 0630p pe3YJILTaTOB 110-
nelirnIIx paClwnOK B Cpe.D:II3eMIIOMopCIWM 6accelme II IIOCBHm;elIlIoH )],OKa3a-
TeJIhCTBY cym;ecTBoBaIIIIH ATJIaIITH)J;bI.
CJIe)],bI 3TIIX pa3H006pa3IIJ,IX IIIITepeCOB II IIOCTOHIIIIhIX 3alIHTIIII HCToplfeH
II apXeOJIOrIIeH BIf.D:IIbI II B nepBbIX pafioTax H. 11. BaBII.:'IOBa 0 rrpOIICXOiR-
)],eIIIIII ItYJIbTyplIbIX pacTelIIIH, npe)J;rneCTBOBaBrnIIX IIOHBJIelIIIIO ero 3IIaMeIIH-
TOH KIIIITII «IJ;eIITpbI npOIICXOiI,)J;eIIIIH ItYJILTYPlIbIX paCTeIIIIn» II IIanIICalIHbIX
em;e B MocKBe, )],0 nepee::ma B CapaToB II 3alIHTlfH TaM Kacpe)J;pbI qaCTIIOro
3eMJIe.D:eJIHH If CeJIeIt:qHII. Bo BCTYIIIITeJIblIOII JIeKU;IIII K KypCy 'IJaCTIIOro 3eM-
JIe)],eJIIIH, npOqIITaHHOH Ha CapaToBcKIIX BblcrnIIX CeJIbCIWX03HlIcTBeHIIbIx
Rypcax B celITH6pe 1917 r., cpa3Y iRe nOCJIe nepee3)],a, OH rnIIpOKO IICnOJIh-
3yeT H3BeCTIIYIO KHIIry M. M. MeqlIIIKOBa «IJ;IIBIIJIII3a:qIIH If BeJIIIKHe IICTD-
69
pnqeCKlIe peKH», conOCTaBJIHeT 'IHCJIO IfcnOJIb3yeMbIx B 3eMJIe.o;eJIHIf paCTelIIIH
C 3TanaMH pa3BIfTHH :qIIBHJIII3a:qHH, OTMeqaeT 6e.o;IIOCTb ItYJIbTYPIIOH cpJIOphI
B rocy.o;apCTBax ApeBlIero BOCTOKa H 3IIaqIfTeJIblIOe YBeJIIIqelIIfe BBe.D:elIlIbIX
1\ KYJIbTYPY BH.o;OB 3a nOCJIe)J;IIIIe CTOJIeTHH, oc06elIII0 nOCJIe 3nOXH BeJIHKHX
reorpacpIIqeCKIIX OTRpbITIfn H OCBoelIIfH AMepIIKH eBponeH aMH 6. B CTaTbe
o npOIICXOiR.o;elIIfH KYJIbTYPIIOH pmII, ony6JIHIWBaHIIOH B TOM me ro.o;y If CO-
,u;epmam;eH nepBYIO CPOPMYJIIIpOBKY II 060CIIOBalIIIe TeopHH 0 npOIlIIKIIOBelIIIII
meKOTopbIX 3JIaKOB B KyJIhTYPY H3 3acopHIOm;IfX nOJIH COpHHKOB IIa npHMepe
pmH, apXeOJIOrIIH, a TaKiRe IICTOpIIqeCKaH JIIflIrBIICTIIlta npep:CTaBJIeHbI eI:qe
mHpe 7. 3p:eCb If CCbIJIKa IIa CBIf.o;eTeJIbCTBO nJIHIIIfH Kaft IIa nepBoe onpe-
;.o;eJIeHHOe C006m;eHIfe 0 noceBax pmIf, H ItpIfTIIqeCKaH o:qelIKa paCKonOK 3IIeO-
JIHTH'IeCKHX CTOHIIOK BO <PpalI:qIfII, BO BpeMH KOTOpbIX HK06bI 6bIJIII IIaH;.o;eHbI
o6yrJIelIIIbIe 3eplIa pmIf. Ha3BalIHH pmn B H3bIKax COBpeMelIlIbIX IIapO)J;OB
TIepe;.o;IIeH A3HH, IfMeIIYIOm;IfX pOiRb «TpaBOH, 3acopHIOm;eH nrneIIH Y», pac-
MaTpHBaIOTCH B KaqeCTBe cym;ecTBelIlIoro aprYMelITa B nOJIb3Y 3am;Hm;aeMOH
TeopIIH. MOJIOP:OH aBTOp B Kypce Bcex IICTOPHIW-3TIIOJIOrIfqeCKHX rrp06JIeM,
XOTI> CKOJIbKO-IIIf6y;.o;b COnpltKaCaIOm;HXCH C IIenOcpe;.o;CTBelIIIbIM npe;.o;MeTOM ero
IICCJIe;.o;OBaHHn.
B CapaTOBe B peIWp;.o;IIbIe p:JIH Toro THmeJIOrO BpeMelIH CpOKII 6bIJIa IIa-
.na1hella )J;eHTeJIbIIOCTb Kacpe)J;pbI, nop:06palIbI y re6IIbIe noco6IfH, c06paHa
60nbmaH 6H6JIHOTeKa IIa IIeCKOJIbKHX HHOCTpalIlIbIX H3bIKax. II onHTb B IIee
BXO;.o;HT lIe TOJII,KO Cne IfaJIblIaH JIIfTepaTypa, 110 H KIIIIrH no 06m;eH 6IIOJIO-
rHH, reorpacpIfIf, HCTOpIfII KYJIbTypbI. K 3TIfM rOAaM OTIIOCIfTCH .o;ome.D:rnee
P;O HaC CBHAeTeJIbCTBO 0 JIIIqlIOH 6II6JIHOTeKe H. II. BaBIIJIOBa, OCTaBJIelIHOe
A. r. XIIlIqYK: «EH6J1IIOTeIta yp:IfBJIHJIa lIe TOJIbKO KOJIIIqeCTBOM, HO If IIO;.o;-
60pOl\f KIIH!'. B HeH 6bIJIH npep:cTaBJIeHbI, ItpOMe cne:qIfaJIbHOH arpOIIOMHqe-
CKOH JlIITepaTypbI II IIeCIWJIbKIfX 3II:qIfKJIOnep:IIH, ImHl'II no reorpacpIfH, CPH3II-
ICe, XIf:\IIIIf, cpIfJIOCOcpIfIf, IfCTOplfII IICKyCCTB, Me.D:II:qHHe If Bce, KaiReTCH,
KJIaCCIfKH MIfpOBOH JIIITepaTypbI» 8. B 3TH ro;.o;bI HIfKoJIan IIBalIOBIIq H3yqaJI
JIaTHIICKUII H3bIK, qTo6bI B no.o;JIIIIIIIIfI{aX 'IIITaTb .D:peBlIepUMCKIfX eCTeCTBO-
JICnbITaTeJIeH, H 3TO 6bIJIO e;.o;IfHCTBelIHoe BpeMH, Iwr.o;a JIa60paToplfH ero 6bIJIa
3aKpbITa lIe TOJIbKO ;.o;JIH nOCTopOIIIIIIX, HO II p:JIH 6JIHmaHrnIfX COTPY.D:HIIKOB 9.
A ero JIeKU;HH HpKO OTpaiRaJIH 60raTeilmHH 3anac IIaKOnJIelIlIbIX 3IIaHHn:
Ii HIIX arpOIIOMHH, RYJIbTypHaH 60TaHIIKa H HCTOpHH 3eMJIe;.o;eJIbqeCIWH KYJIb-
TypbI Bcer;.o;a no.o;aBaJIHCb Ha rnIfpOqaHmeM cpoHe IIapo;.o;IIOH iRIf3IIII B pa3HbIe
noxn HCTOpHH qeJIOBeqeCTBa. ApyraH COTpy;.o;HH:qa H. II. BaBIIJIOBa BcnOMII-
H8eT: «Ka3aJIOCb, qTO KaiRAI,IiI CJIyrnaTeJIb CTalIOBIfJICH Y'IaCTHIIKOM ::mcne-
P;H:qHH no Cpe;.o;HeH A3HH, KaBKa3Y, KpbIMY, nepCIIH II AcpralIIIcTaHY,
nocem;an 3RcnepIIMelITaJIblIYIO 6a3Y E3TcolIa nO)J; JIOH;.o;OHOM C ee YlIlmaJIb-
Hon KOJIJIeK HeH 3JIaKOB, c06palIIIbIx co Bcero 3eMIIoro mapa. Macca cpOTO-
I'pacpHH 3HaKOllfIIJIa C xapaKTeplIbIMIf 3JIeMeHTaMII JIalI;.o;macpTa CTpalIbI, cene-
HHHMH If ropo;.o;aMIf, C 6hITOM mIfTeJIeH, IIX HpaBaMH, 8TIIIIqeCKIIMII TIInaMII,
t>PYiJ:HHMII npOIf3BOACTBa, mIfBOTlIbIMH H paCTeIIIIHlIfII, MY3bIKaJIblIbIMII HH-
CTpYMelITaMIf H T. .0;.» 10
C06CTBelIIIbIe pa60TbI HIIKOJIaH IIBaHOBHqa, OTHOCHIIJ;IIeCH K 3TOMY nepHo-
;.o;y, co;.o;epmaT IfIlTepeClIbIe BbIBOp:bI 0 3IIaqelIIfII IfCTopIIKo-apXeOJIOI'IIqeCRHX
p;alIlIbIx ;.o;JIH BOCCTaHOBJIeHIIH ;.o;peBlIeH IfCTOpIfH KYJIbTyplIOH cpJIOpbI. B 60JIb-
mOH ItIIIfre, nocBHm;elIHon ItYJIbTYPlIbIM pacTelIHHM HIfiRHero nOBOJImbH, OH
nHCaJI 06 orpOMlIbIX KOJIOIIII3a:qIIOHHbIX nOTOKax, npoxo;.o;IfBmHX qepe3 IOiRIIO-
pYCCIme CTenII B ;.o;peBHOCTH, nepeqIfCJIHH rYIIIIOB, aBapOB, CJIaBHH II 60JI-
rap 11. KacaHcb BJIIIHIIIfH 3THX KOJIOHIf3a IIOHHbIX nOTOKOB Ha paCTHTeJIbHbIH
COCTaB nOJIeH HHmlIero nOBOJImbH, H. II. BaBHJIOB YKa3bIBaJI Ha BOCTOqlIOe
npOHcxomp;elIIIe OT;.o;eJIblIbIX KYJIbTYPlIbIX pacTeHIIH. HaII60JIee HPRHH, no ero
70
MHeIIIIIO, npHMep - nOJI6a-3MMepa (Triticum dicoccum), llIIIpOKO pacnpo-
cTpalIelIlIaH B npe.D:eJIax apeaJIa paCCeJIeHHH TaTapCKOI'O, qYBamCKOI'O II 6am-
}{IIpCKOro HapO)I,OB. J],JIH H. II. BaBIIJIOBa 3TO y6e.D:IITeJIblIbIH aprYMelIT B
nOJIb3Y Toro, qTO nOJI6a 6bIJIa npIIHecelIa Ha BOJIry TIOpKOH3bl'IHbIMII npe.D:-
KaMH 3TIIX HapO.D:OB, (mpHMep IfCKJIIO'IIITe.:'IbIIOrO BJIIIHIIIIH B BbI60pe RYJIbTY-
pbI He TOJIbKO IfCTOpIIqeCKIIX YCJIOBHH, 110 II 60JIee 3JIeMelITapHoH cpOpMbI
IIX - 3TlIorpacpII'IeCKIIX cpaRTOp0B>). PacnpocTpalIelIIIe nO.D:COJIHe'IHIIK3 B
HHmHeM nOBOJl1Kbe .D:eMOHcTpIIpyeT orpOMIIYIO pOJIb )J;JIH paCCeJIelIIIH KYJIb-
TYPHbIX pacTelIIIH no 3eMHOH nOBepXHOCTH TaRoro rpalI)J;H03Horo HCTOpIfRO-
reorpacpIIqeCKOrO C06bITIIH, KaK OTKpbITHe HOBOI'o CBeTa.
Ho, nOCTOHlIlIO IIOMIIH 06 IfCTOpII'IeCKIIX npo eccax IIPII II3Y'IeIIIIIJ COCTa-
Ba, npOIICXOm.D:eIIIfH If pacnpOCTpalIeIIIIH RYJIbTYPIIOII paCTHTeJIbnOCTII 3eM-
Horo mapa, H. II. BaBIfJIOB OTqeTJIIIBO OC03IIaeT orpalIIf'IelIlIhle B03MomnOCTH
HCnOJIb30BalIIfH IICTOpIf'IeCKllX If apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIX .D:aHlIbIX npII yCTaIIOBJIe-
HIIII nYTeiI npOIfCXOmiJ,eIIIIH RYJIbTyplIbIX paCTelIIIM. B 3TOM CKa3aJIaCb Tpe3-
BOCTb YMa 60JIbrnOrO yqeHOrO, lIe CKJIOlIlIOrO 060JIbll aTbcH O.D:IIOCTOpOIIHIIM
nO.D:XO.D:OM .D:ame npH OOJIbmOH YBJIe'IeIIIIOCTH. n03JI,IIee HMelIlIO 3a npeIIMy e-
CTBelIIIoe IICIIOJIb30BalIHe apXeOJIOrIIqeCKIIX H IICTOpII'IeCKIfX MaTepIIaJIOB II
CBOHX TPY.D:ax H. II. BaBHJIOBbIM 6bIJI nO,ZJ;BeprlIYT RpIITHRe AJI'b.pOHC J],eKaR-
.D: OJIb , ero npe;rrmeCTBelIlIHK no IICCJIe.D:OBaHIIIO npOHCXOm.D:eIIIIH RYJIbTYPIIOR
cpJIOpbI. B npOTIIBOBec A. J],eRaH,ZJ;OJIIO H. II. BaBIIJIOB nIICaJI B 1923 r.:
«ApXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIe, HCTOpIIqeCRHe H JIllIIrBIICTIf'IeCKIIe JI,aHRbIe MaJIOnpnro)I,-
RbI .D:JIH pemelIIIH Bonpoca 0 IIpOHCXOm.D:eIIHII OT,ZJ;e.:'IblIbIX BII,ZJ;OB, T.aR
RaR 06blqlI0 BII.n:bI nmelIII bI lIe pa3JIII'IaIOTCH II nYTaIOTCH apXeOJIOTa m 11
cpIIJIOJIOraMII, H n03ToMy eD;IIIICTBeIIHbIM, B CY IIOCTrr HaHUOJIee 'TO'IHbIM
MeTO.D:OM )J;JIH onpe)J;eJIelIIIH l(elITpa npOIIcxom,ZJ;elIIIH OTD;eJIbHbTX iBHD;iJB nme-
IIIf:qbI HBJIHeTCH MeTO)J; 60TaIIHKo-reorpacpIIqeCKHiI, COCTOHm;HH B onpe)I,eJIe-
IIHH apeaJIOB pa3IIOBII.n:IIOCTeH .D:aIIHOrO BH.D:a, B Haxom,ZJ;elIIIII :qelITpa pa3IIO-
06pa3IIH 60JIbIIllIHCTBa II3BeCTIIbIX cpOp:\f» 12. IITaK, mIIpORO npIIBJIeKaH IICTO-
pHKo-apXeOJIOrHqeCKIIe )J;alIlIbIe, H. II. BaBIIJIOB C caMoro IIa'IaJIa KoppeRTH-
pOBaJI IIX C nOMOm;bIO pe3YJIbTaTOB c06CTBeHHbIX arpOOOTaIIII'IeCRHX IICCJIe.D:O-
BaHIIH; B 3TOM cBoe06pa3IIe II nJIO)J;OTBOpIIOCTb ero MeTOJI,a 13.
C nepee3.D:OM B JIeHHlIrpa.D: H opraHII3a IIeH B 1924 r. BceCOI03IIOI'O
rrHCTHTYTa npHRJIa.D:HoiI 60TalIIIKH II IIOBbIX RYJIbTYP, ,ZJ;IIpeKTopOM ROToporo
OH 6bIJI IIa npOTHmeHIIII 16 JIeT, Ha'IaJICH B mH3IIH H. II. BaBHJIOBa IIOBbIH
nepIIO)J; rpalI.D:II03HOH no MacmTa6y IIayqHoiI H opralIII3al(IIolIHoiI D;eHTeJIb-
HOCTII. Ocy eCTBJIeHlIbIe HM 3KClIe.D:H:qHH OXBaTIIJIH CBbIme 40 CTpaII rr
060raTHJIIf MHPOBYIO IIaYRy lIe TOJIbKO .D:eTaJIblIbIM 3HalIIIeM KYJIbTYPHOii
cpJIOpbI nocem;elIlIbIX paiIolIoB, 110 H IfcTopHeiI 3eMJIe.D:eJIIIH B CBH3IJ C IICTO-
prreiI l(IIBIIJIII3a IIII, a B IIeKOTOpbIX CJIY'IaHX n03BOJIIfJIII BHeCTII KoppeRTIIBbI
B npe.D:CT BJIeIIIIH 06 IICTOpII'IeCKIIX B3aHMOOTHomelIHHX .D:peBIIIIX IIBIIJIII3a-
HH, yme CJIOiRIIBIIllIeCH IIa OCIIOBalIIIII pe3YJIbTaTOB apXeOJIOrIIqeCKllX pac-
RonOR. EoraTa H pa3H006pa3IIa c06palIHaH BO BpeMH 3TIIX 3KCIH .D:IIIJ;Hii
rrlIcpopMa IIH 0 3eMJIeJI,eJIbqeCKOiI 3THorpacpIIH: cIIoc06ax 06paooTRlI 3eMJIH,
npOCTeHmIIX IIpIIeMaX IIppIIra IIII, CeJIbCKOX03HHcTBelIIIoM IIIIBelITape, IIC-
nOJIb30BaHHH npII 06pa60TKe 3eMJIII na rrOJIHX .D:0MarnIIIIX mIIBOTlIbIX. Ho
rrpem.D: e 'IeM rOBopIITb 00 3TOM, CJIe.D;yeT y.n:eJIHTb BHHMalIIfe TPY)J;Y H. II. Ba-
BIIJIOBa 06 OCHOBHbIX elITpax npOIfcxom,ZJ;elIHH KYJIbTyplIbIX pacTelIHiI, ROTO-
pbIH OTpamaJI 3IIaHIIH, HaROnJIelIHbIe K IIa'IaJIY 20-x rO.D:OB 1&. B IIeM 6hIJIll
qaCTH'IIIO Y'ITeHbI TOJIbKO pe3YJIbTaTbI 3Kcne,ZJ;If IIH B AcpralIIICTalI. ::ho COqIf-
HeHIIe HenOBTopIIMO no 60raTcTBY HCnOJIb30BaHIIoro MaTepHaJIa H pe.D: KOH
JIOrHRe B ero CHCTeMaTH3a HII. IICKJIIO'IHTeJIbIIO nOJIHO 6bIJIa IICnOJIb30BaHa
;JJIi[TepaTypa no rrcTopHH aeMJIe)I.eJIHH, B TOM qHCJIe H apXeOJIOrII'IeCRaH.
71
nOCJIe Toro RaR 60TaHIIKo-reorpacpH'IeCRHn MeTO)J; 6bIJI nO.D:IIH'I Ha IIPHH-
ITIIHaJIbHO HOBYIO cTyneHb caMIIM H. II. BaBHJIOBbIM Hero Y'IeIIIIKaMII,
nOCJIe C03.D:aIIHH ,ZJ;IIcpcpepeHl(HaJIbIIOH reorpacpHII RYJIbTypHI>IX paCTelIHH 15
apXeOJIOrH'IeCRIIe, JIIIlIrBIICTH'IeCRHe H HCTOpII'IeCRHe .D:alIlIhle npH06peJiH OCO-
60e 3IIa'IeIIIIe. H. II. BaBIIJIOB nHCaJI, qTO, (mpIIYPO'IelIlIbIe R onpe,ZJ;eJIelIIII>IM
60TaHH'IeCRHM BII)J;aM, OHII MorYT IIHOr.D:a 3IIa'IIITeJIbII0 AOIIOJIIIIITb H yrJIY-
6IITb CBe)J;eHHH 0 npOmJIOM KYJIbTyplIbIX paCTeHHM») 16.
II3JII06JIeHHOe HM conOCTaBJIelIIIe BbIBO.D:OB II3 60TaIIIIKo-reorpacpII'IeCKllX
IT IICTopH'IecRIIx IICCJIe,ZJ;oBaHIIH H H3BJIeqelIHe II3 TaRoro COIIOCTaBJIelIHH
HOBOM IIHcpopMal(IIII 6bIJIII O'IeHb nJIo,ZJ;oTBOplIhI. npH pacclIfOTpeIIIIII IIpOHC-
xOmp;elIHJI XJIe6HOrO 3JIaRa .D:peBHHX HapO.D:OB - nOJI6bI-3MMepbI H. II. BaBH-
JIOB 06paTIIJI BHIIMalIIIe IIa TO, 'I TO CeM'IaC OHa npe.D:CTaBJIelIa B OCIIOBHOM B
KYJIbType Tex IIapO,ZJ;OB, ROTOpbIe AO IIe.D:aBlIerO npomJIoro CTOHJIH, a IIeROTO-
pbIe H Tenepb CTOHT Ha cpaBIIIITeJIbHO HII3ROH cTYlIelIH 06 ecTBeHlIoro pa3-
BHTIIH: B nOBOJIiRbe - 3TO TIOpKcRIIe HapO.D:I>I, IIa KaBRa3e - Hap0.n:bI l(eIIT-
paJIbIII>IX npe.D:rOpIIM, B IIcIIalIIIH - 6acRH, B II paKe - Kyp.n:bI, B 8cpIIonIIH-
nepB06bITIIhIe roplIbIe nJIeMelIa. Olla COXpaIIIIJIaCb, no MHeHIIIO H. II. BaBH-
JIOBa, C rJIy60RoM p:peBIIOCTH BMeCTe C OTCTaJIbIM 3eMJIe,ZJ;eJIb'IeCKIIM YR;;Ja.D:OM
11 apXaHqeCRHMII 06bI'IaHMII. 1I3BeCTIIaH 3RCne.D:II:qIIH o.n:IIoro If3 6JIHmaMmIIX
ero COTPY.D:IIHROB - B. E. IIIIcapeBa B MOHrO;;JIUO BI>IHBIIJIa orpOMHoe pa3IIO-
06pa3IIe cpOpM npoca, 'ITO HBIIJIOCb aprYMelITOM B IIOJIb3Y cym;ecTBelIlIbIX Teo-
pITM 0 ero npOIICXOiR)J;eIIIIII II3 IJ;eHTpaJIbIIOM If BOCTO'IIIOH A3HII. H. M. Ba-
BHJIOB ,],OKa3aJI, 'ITO npoco npO.D:BImYJIOCb B EBPOIIY II3 A3HH BMeCTe
C RO'IeBbIMII IIapO,ZJ;aMH, II aprYMelITIIpOBaJI 3TO mnpORIIM ero pacnpOCTpalIe-
HHeM Y IIIIX, npHCIIOC06JIeIIIIOCTbIO R npOII3paCTalIIIIO B pa3III>IX 3ROJIOrH'Ie-
CKIIX YCJIOBIIHX, 'ITO TaR BaiRHO npH RO'IeBmf 6bITe, RaKOlIel(, cnoc06HOCTbIO
BI>I3peBaTb B pa3Hoe BpeMH rO)J;a.
B CBH3II C npOIICXOm.D:enIIeM IIepBIJqlIbIX, IIaH60JIee paHO Bomep;rnHX B
RYJIbTYPY paCTelIIIH oc06elIII0 HHTepeClIa nOCJIep;OBaTeJIbIIOCTb 3TanOB ORYJIb-
TypHBaHIIH ROIIOnJIIf. nOBCeMeCTHOe pacnpOCTpalIelIIIe ROIIOnJIH BbI3Ba.il0 OCO-
6eHHO nl>IIIIHOe pa3BIITHe ee BORpyr MeCT JRHJIbH, Ha Y.D:06peHHOM oT6pocaMII,
60raToii neperHoeM nO'IBe. «KOlIrJIOMepaT cpOpM .D:HROM ROHOnJIH,- nHCaJI
H. II. BaBHJIOB, - ...conpOB07l\.D:aJI qeJIOBeRa B ero ROqeBbHX, B ero paCceJIe-
HHH no CTapOMY CBeTY. KOHOnJIH 6pOCaJIaCb B rJIa3a nepB06bITHOMY 06HTa-
TeJIIO CTaporo CBeTa, mJIa 3a IIHM no nHTaM, IOTHJIaC1> OROJIO ero XlImHHbI
IT caMa npe.D:OCTaBJIHJIa eMY CBOII YCJIyrII») 17. Bo BpeMJI 'IaCTbIX rOJIO.D:OBOK
qeJIOBeR He MOl' He 06paTIITbCH R YCJIyraM 3Toro paCTeHIfH, 6eCC03IIaTeJIbHO
oT6IIpaH cpOpMbI C IIeOCbmaIOm;IIMIICH RPynlIl>IMH nJIO;rraMH, )J;aBmHe IIaqaJIO
RYJIbTyplIl>IM pacaM. Y CTalIaBJIIfBaJI MeCTO H BpeMH BBe.D:eIIHH KOHOnJIH
B RYJIbTYPY, H. II. BaBIIJIOB BOCnOJIb30BaJICJI caMbIMH pa3IIo06pa3IIbIMH IICTO-
pIT'IeCRIIMH .D:aIIHbIMH: IIeII3BeCTHOCTbIO ee B JJ:peBHeM ErHnTe, r.D:e lIe 06Ha-
PYiRelIO IIIIRaRIIX CJIep;OB BOJIOKlIa neHbRH, OTCYTcTBHeM ynoMHHaHIIH ee B
EH6JIHH H Y I'epo.n:OTa, 110 3aTO rJIy60KoM ;rrpeBIIOCTbIO IICTO'IIIHROB co CBe.D:e-
HHHMH 0 ee BbIpam;IIBaIIIIII B IIH.n:IIH H IUITae. TaR YCTaHaBJIIIBaeTCH a3HaT-
CRHll 0'181' ORYJIbTypI1BanIIH ROHOIIJIH, qTO IIo.n:TBepiR)J;aeTCJI H JIIfHrBIfCTn:qe-
CRII: Ha3BaHHH ROIIOnJIII eCTb B calICKpIITe H B .D:peBHeRIITaHCROM H3bIKe.
YqHTbIBaH xapaRTep paCCeJIelIIIH 3Toro paCTeHHJI, H. II. BaBHJIOB npHmeJI
R BbIBO.n:y 0 nOJIH:qeHTpHqeCROM npOIICXOm,ll,eHIIH RYJIbTYpHbIX pac, 0 He3a-
BITCHMOM BBe.D:eIIIfH ROIIOnJIH B RYJIbTYPY Ha TeppIITopHH A3HH B pa3IIbIX
MeCTax.
B RHHre 0 l(eHTpax npOHcxom,ZJ;eHITJI RYJIbTyplIbIX paCTeHIIH H. II. BaBIT-
JIOBbIlIf 6bIJI npe.D:JIOmeH nepBbIM BapIIaHT naHoiiRyMelIHoH CIICTeMbI cpOpMO-
06pa30BaTeJII>HbIX o'wrOB KYJIbTYPIIOi cpJIOpbI. ConOCTaBIfB ITX C cyI:qeCTBD-
72
BaBmIIMH TOr.D:a npe.D:CTaBJIeHIIHMH 0 .n:peBlIellmeM npOmJIOM qeJIOBe"IeCTBa
If nepBbIX rOCY.D:apCTBax, OH BHec B HHX cym;ecTBeHHbIe RoppeRTHBbI, YKa3aB
Ha caMOCTOHTeJIbHOCTb If .D:peBIIOCTb IIBHJIII3a:qIfH B BOCTOqlIOH A3HIf,
Ha .D:peBlIne 3TanbI pa3BHTHH 3eMJIe)J;eJIHH H RYJIbTYpl>I B 3aRaBRa3be, Ha He-
3aBHCIIMhIM OT CTaporo CBeTa npo ecc HCTOpIIqeCKOrO pa3BIITHH B D;eIITpaJII>-
HOM AMepIIKe II Ha AII,ZJ;HnCROM Haropbe. Bce 3TO 6bIJIII CBeiRlIe H OpHI'H-
IIaJIblIble MbICJIII, onepeiRaBmIIe CBoe BpeMH II nO,ZJ;TBepm)J;eIIHbIe BnOCJIe,ZJ;CT-
BIIII IICTopII"IeCKOM HaYKOH. R' HX 'IIICJIY OTnOCIITCH H YTBepm.D:eIIIIe, Tor)J;a
npe.D:nOJIOmIITeJIbIIOe, 0 rJIy60RoM .n:peBIIOCTII 3eMJIe)J;eJIIIH, 0 B03HHRHOBeHHH
ero B .n:peBlIeMmyIO 3noxy pa3BIITIIH qeJIOBe'IeCTBa, Ha Py6eme Me30llIITa II
HeOJIHTa. Ho, nOmaJIYM, HaII60;;Jee Balliell .D:JIH nCTopIIRa elITpaJIbHbIll BhIBOll;
RIIHrH 0 TOM, 'ITO OqarII B03HHKIIOBeHIIH 3eMJIe.D:eJIPIeCROM KYJIbTyphI C)J;BH-
HYThI (no cpaBlIeIIIIIO C O'IarallfH )J;peBlIeHmIIX IIBHJIII3a IIM, paCIIOJIaraIO-
m;HXCR B ,ZJ;OJIIflIaX peR) B roplIbIe MeCTHOCTII, qTO lIfeCTO npOIIcxom)J;elIHH
IIaCeJIelIIIH 3TIIX ,ZJ;OJIIIII CJIeDyeT IICRaTb B oKpymaIOm;IIX roplIbIX paHOlIaX.
nOMIIMO 60TaIIHKo-reorpacpIFIeCKIIX aprYMeHTOB, B nOJIb3Y 3TOH TOqKII 3pe-
HHH H. M. BaBHJIOB upIIBeJI H IfCTOpII'IeCKIIe: HeB03l1fOmlIOCTb ocym;ecTBJIelIIIH
TIppIIra IIII B )J;OJIHlIaX 60JIbmIIX peR 6e3 YCTalIOBJIelIIfH p;ecnOTII'IeCKOH
BJIaCTII H HCIIOJIb30BalIHH TPY.D:a pa60B, B TO me BpeMH cpaBIIIfTeJIblIaH JIer-
KOCTb 06 eCTBeIIHOM opralIIf3a IIH opomelIHH B ropHbIX paMOlIax, r,ZJ;e peRH
caMOTeKOM MorYT 6bITb OTBe.n:elIbI Ha nOJIe.
R'IIIIra H. II. BaBHJIOBa npH BceH CBoeH 6OTalIIIKo-reorpacpHqeCKOii IIa-
upaBJIelIlIOCTH 3Ha"IHTeJIblIa II C TO'lKH 3pelIIfH HCTOpIIKO-3THorpacpIIqeClWH,
B pH,ZJ;e CJIY'IaeB olla KOppeKTITpyeT BhIBO)J;bI IICTopIIKo-apXeOJIOrII"IeCKIIX H
3THorpacpII'IeCRIIX IfCCJIe.D:OBaIIHM. A. M. rOpbRHM nIICaJi 22 HIOHH 1927 r.
n. C. R'oralIY B CoppelITo: «Ha ;rrIIHX H uOJIY'IIfJI IIeCKOJIbKO KIIIIr, H3.n:alIlIbIX
C03,ZJ;alIlIbIM no IIIIII IIaTIIBe BJIap;IIII1lfpa IIJIbH"Ia "IIIICTIITYTOM IIplm.:'Ia IIOM
60TalIIIKII If IIOBbIX RYJIbTYP", npO'IHTaJi TPY,ZJ; rrpocp. H. II. BaBIIJIOBa "D;eIIT-
pbI npOIICXOm.D:eIIHH KYJIbTypHbIX pacTeHIIM", ero .D:OKJIa)J; 0 ,,3aRoHe rOIlWJIo""
rH'IeCRHX PH,ZJ;OB", npOClIfOTpeJI "R'apTY 3ellfJIe)J;eJIIIH CCCP" - KaR Bce 3TO
TaJIaIITJIIIBO, RaR 3IIa'IIITeJIbII0» 18.
3RClIe,ZJ;IID;IIH BTOpOM nOJIOBHlIbI 20-x - IIaqaJIa 30-x rO)J;OB paCilllIpIIJIJiI
H 6e3 TorO orpOMHYIO cpaKTHqecRYIO 6a3Y 0606m;eIIIIM, c.n:eJIaHHbIX H. M. Ba-
BHJIOBbIM.
Ocym;eCTBJIeHIIOe JIeTOM II ocelIbIO 1924 r. IfYTemeCTBHe no AcpraHHcT8-
HY 6bIJIO nO)J;p06HO onIIcalIO yqelIbIM JIIImb qepe3 nHTb JIeT 19. 3TO nOHHTHO:
MapmpYT npoJIeraJI IIO BceM cTpalIe, 6bIJI c06paH orpoMlIbIH MaTepHaJI KaR
arp060TaHIIqeCKOrO H 3KOHOMII'IeCROrO, TaR H 3TlIorpaQ)H"IeCROrO xapaRTepa.
rpOMa)J;IIbI c06palIIIbIe KOJIJIeR:qIIII. B ,ZJ;IIIIJIOMe, conpOBOm.D:aBmellf 30JIOTYIO
Me.D:aJIb IIMelIII npmeBaJIbCKOrO, ROTOpOM H. II. BaBIIJIOB 6bIJI HarpaiRp:eH
B 1925 r. BCeCOI03IIbIM reorpacpHqeCKHM 06 ecTBoM, 6bIJIO CKa3a1I0: «3a reo-
rpacpHqeCKIIH IIo.n:BIIr». B RIIIIre «3eMJIe)J;eJIbqeCRIIH AcpraHIIcTaIl», IIpel1;cTaB-
JIHIOm;eH C060M CJII IIRJIOlIe)J;HIO He TOJIbRO arpOIIOMII'IeCRHX, HO H reorpa4>II'-
qeCRHX CBeJJ:eIIHM 06 AcpralIHcTalIe, 60JIbmOe MeCTO 3aHIIMaeT H c06cTBeHIIo
3THorpacpIIH.
Cne:qIIaJIblIaH rJIaBa B HeH IIOCBHm;eHa 0630PY 3THH'IeCKOrO COCTaB3.
AcpralIIfcTalIa II TeM O"IelIb cpparMeHTapHbIlIf IICTOpII'IeCKIIM II apXeOJIot'H'Ie-
CKIIlIf CBIIl1;eTeJIbCTBaM 0 .D:peBHeM npOmJIOM CTpaHbI, ROTOpbIe 6bIJIH H3BeCTHI>f
R TOMY BpeMelIH. npIIBe.n:elIbI ;o:aHlIbIe 0 qHCJIelIHOCTH H paCCeJIeHHII KaR
caMHX HapO.D:OB, TaR II BXO)J;Hm;IIX B IIX COCTaB nJIeMeHHbIX I'pynn; RpaTKO,
HO BbIpa3HTeJIbHO onIIcalIbI oc06elIIIOCTII 6bITa, X03HMCTBa, RYJIbTYPbI; yno-
MHIIYTO 0 Bcex Tex 3TlIorpacpn'IeCKllX H HCTOpHTJ:eCRHX cpaRTax, 'RO'lOpLI6
lIforYT 61>ITb HCIIOJIb30BaHbI .D:JIH pemeHHH np06JIellfbI npOHcxom}J;elIlItI Hapo- <
73
I
1!,OB. ABTOp, RaR II BO BCeX )J;PyrHx CJIY'IaHX, IICqepnl>IBaIOm;e 3IIaeT JIHTepa-
'ryPY, lIe 3a6hIBaeT HII o.n:IIoro JIIITepaTyplIoro C006m;eIIHH (IIanpHMep, YKa3a-
tIIIH M. C. AH)J;peeBa IIa IIIIOpO,ZJ;IIbIH CYOCTpaT B COCTaBe Ta,ZJ;1ImROB) ,
tIO JII060e C006m;eIIHe nO,ZJ;TBepiR,ZJ;aeT CBOIIMII Ha6JIIO.D:eHHHMII. TaK, 011 OTMe-
TIIJI pe3Koe OTJIIf'IIIe CeJIbCKOX03HHCTBelIIIOH JIeKCIIKII Ta,ZJ;iRIIKCKOro fl3bIKa 01'
APyrIIx HpaHCKIIX H3I>IROB, rrO.D:TBepm,ZJ;aIOm;ee BbIBO,ZJ; M. C. AII)J;peeBa, YCTa-
tIOBJIeHHbIH npII alIaJIII3e )J;PyrIIx 3THorpacpH'IeCRIIX MaTepIIaJIOB. ,l],JIH HYPII-
CTalI:qen 3TlIorpacpH'IeCKHe IIa6JIIO eIIIIH H. II. BaBIIJIOBa .n:o CIIX nop coxpa-
tIHIOT 3IIaqelIHe rrepBOIICTO'II1HKa HCKJIIOqnTeJIblIOH BaiRIIOCTII: onIIcalIbI
1I0CTpOMKH II TIInbI IIOCeJIeIIIIM, CeJIbCKOX03HHCTBelIIIbIH HIIBeJITapL, 3aUHTIIH
tIaCeJIelIIIH; OTMe'IelIbI pa3JIIIqHH MeiRP:Y OT,ZJ;eJIblIbIMII RHillJIaKaMH B fT3hIKe
H ObITe, 3anIIcalIa JIeKCIIKa KacpIIpCKIIX )J;IfaJIeRTOB, cpOTOI'pacpIIHMH IIJIJIIOCT-
pHpOBaII alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIH TIIII HypHCTalII(eB.
II3BeCTIIbIH R TOMY BpeMelIH apXeOJIOrIIqeCRHn MaTepHaJI, CBe,ZJ;eIIHbIH H
HCnOJIb30BalIIIbIH H. II. BaBIIJIOBbIM, lIe II03BOJIHJI .D:peBIIOCTb :qIIBIIJIII3a:qIIH
B AcpraHIICTalIe OTlIeCTII .n:aJIee Py6eiRa HOBOH 3p1>I. ,l],JIH ceBepHbIX paMOHOB
AcpraHHCTalIa 3TOT XpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCKHM Py6em IIailleJI IIO,ll,TBepmJJ:eIIIIe H npH
H3Y'IeIIIIII RYJIbTypnoH cp.:'IOpbI: olla lIe IIOCIIT caMOCTOHTeJIbHOrO xapaKTepa.
Ho B IOiRHbIX panollax II BOCTO'IlIbIX 06JIaCTHX, npHJIeraIOm;IIx K naKIICTaIIY,
BbUIBHJIOCb IICRJIIOqIITeJIbIIOe pa3IIo06pa3IIe RYJIbTYPlIbIX pacTelIIIM, OOIIJIHe
3II)J;eMOB (T. e. pacTelIIIH MeCTlIoro npOIICXOiR)J;eIIIIH), CBII.D:eTeJIbCTBYIO ee 0
JIpeBlIeM O'Iare 3eMJIep:eJIbqeCKOH RYJIbTypbI, O'IelIb palIlIellf pa3BIITHII 3eMJIe-
AeJIbqeCROH l(HBHJIH3al(HH. HIIRaRIIx apXeOJIOrHqeCRHX CJIe)J;OB 3TOH I(IIBIIJIH-
3aI(IIII IIaH)J;elIo Tor,ZJ;a lIe 6bIJIO, II H. II. BaBIIJIOB c)J;eJIaJI CMeJIOe npe)J;noJIo-
iRelIHe: «OTCYTcTBHe apXeOJIOrIlqeCKHX ,ZJ;oKyMeIIToB, CBH3alIIIbIX 06hIKIIoBelIHo
C ropo)J;aMII, C I(IIBIIJIIf3a IIeM B npHlIfoM CMbICJIe 3Toro CJIOBa, He eCTb em;e
nenpeMelIlIoe .n:ORa3aTeJIbCTBO OTCYTCTBHH B .D:aIIIIOH CTpaHe .n:peBlIeH 3eMJIe-
)J;eJIb'IeCROH RYJIbTypbI, 60JIee paHlIeH, 'IeM paccMoTpelIHbIe BbIille naMHTIIHRIT
IIepBbIX BeKOB )J;O IIailleH 3phI. CpaBIIIITeJIbHO-reorpacpH'IecRlIi, 60TaIIIIRo-
arpOHOMII'IeCRIIH alIaJIII3 TaKITX paHolIoB, KaK repaT, RaH.D:arap, IOrO-J'lOCTOq-
HbIM AcpraHIIcTaII C ero roplIhIMII )J;OJIIIlIaMII, IIHTelICHBHbIM THnOM 3eMJIe.D:e-
JIIIH II qpe3BI>I'IaMII0 60raThIM opIIrIIlIaJIbHI>IM IIa60pOllf COpTOB nOJIeBbIX H
oropO,ZJ;nbIX pacTeHIIH, 3aCTaBJlHeT cpIIKcIIpoBaTb BHHMalIIIe IIcTopIIRa 3eMJIe-
;J:eJIIIH IIa 3TOH 'IaCTII A3HH II nOIIbITaTbCH npolIIIRHYTb B rJIy6b HCTO-
pIIH AcpraHHcTalIa, OIIpe.'Ie.;IHeMOH apXeOJIOrII'JecRHMH .D:ORYMeHTaMH» 20.
ApxeOJIOrIT'IeCKIIe OTKpbITHH nOCJIe)J;YIOm;IIX JIeT, RaR II3BeCTHO, OTlIeCJIH ,a:aTY
IIa'IaJIa 3eMJIe.n:eJIb'IeCROM RYJIbTypbI B AcpraHIICTalIe R IV TbICH'IeJIeTHIO
AO II. 3. IT 6JIecTm:o;e no,a:TBep.n:IIJIH npe.D:nOJIOiRelIIIe BaBIIJIOBa 21.
3a AcpralIHCTalIOM B 1925 r. nOCJIe.D:OBaJI Xope3M, pe3YJIbTaTbI arpo-
60TaIIII'IeCROrO 06CJIeLWBalIIIH KOToporo 61>IJIH orry6JIHROBalII>I 'Iepe3 'IeTbIpe
rO)J;a 22. H. II. BaBIIJIOB II 3)J;eCb Bepell ce6e: OH HaqHHaeT C YKa3aHIIH Ha
HMeIOm;HeCH HCTOpII'IeCRIIe CBe)J;eHIIH, CYMMHpoBalIlIbIe B. B. EapTOJIb,a:OM IT
YBOJl:m:o;rre IICTOpHIO XHBIIIICKOI'O oa3Hca B cepe)J;HHY I TbICH'IeJIeTIIH .D:O H. 3.
B pa3.n:eJIe 0 )J;bIIIHX CRa3aHO (CO CCbIJIROH Ha IICTOpH'IeCRHe HCTO'II1HRH)
o TOM, qTO IIX BhICOKIIe Ra'IeCTBa 6bIJIH II3BeCTHbI RIITaH aM em;e BO II B. .n:o II. 3.
AIIaJIH3 COCTaBa B03.n:eJIbIBaeMI>IX paCTelIHH nORa3a.rr HecaMOCTOHTeJIbHbli
xapaRTep XHBIIIICKoro 3eMJIe,a:eJIb'IeCROrO O'Iara. Ha OCIIOBalIIIII Cxo,a:CTBa
cpOpM 011 CBH3bIBaeTCH C nepBHqlIhIM O'IarOM, JIOKaJIH30BalIIIbIM B BOCTO'JIIOM
H lOiRHOM AcpralIIICTalIe H 3ana,ll,IIOM IIIIJJ:IIII. MIIOrOJIeTHIIe pa60TbI Xope3M-
CKOM apxeOJIOrO-3THorpacpII'IeCKOM 3Kcne)J;II HH nO)J;TBep)J;HJIH 3TOT BbIBO,a:.
C nOMOI bIO apxeOJIOrIl'IeCKOro MaTepIIaJla 6bIJIO .n:ORa3aII0, 'ITO Xope3M IIO,a:-
;D;epmHBaJI B .D:peBIIOCTH HIITelICHBHbIe CBH3II C 60JIee IOiRlIbIMII paHOlIaMH.
"YBeJIII'IHJlCH H YCTalIOBJIelIlIbIM C nOMOm;bIO apXeOJIOrII'IeCRIIX p:ORYMeHTOB
74
B03paCT XOpe3MIIHmWH :qHBHJIlI3a IIII MIIIIHMYM lIa 1500-2000 JIeT, qTO He
MeHHeT, BnpO'IeM, npaBHJIbHOCTH nOJIOmeHHH 0 npOHCXOiR.n;eHHll 3ellfJIe.n;eJIHJI.
B Xope3Me no,ZJ; BJIHHlIlleM I01H:HbIX RYJIbTYPHbIX B03)J;eHCTBHH.
Ocym;eCTBJIelIlIaH B 1926-1927 1'1'. 3Rcne,ZJ;ll IIH B CTpaHbI Cpe;J;ll3eMHo-
MOpbH II B 3cpIIonIIIO 6bIJIa HCRJIIO'IllTeJIbHO nJIO,ZJ;OTBopHa B OTHomeHHll RaE
60TaIIII'IeCRIIX, TaR H 3TlIorpacpH'IeCKllX pe3YJIbTaTOB. 3a)J;YMalIlIbIH nYTe-
meCTBeHIIIIKOM 0606m;aIOm;IfH TPY)J; «3eMJIe.Il;eJIbqeCKaH A6IICCIIIIIfH» lIe 6:bIJi
HanIIcalI, 06 3Kcne,ZJ;H IIII COXpaHIIJICH JIHillb RpaTKIIlr OTqeT, a 3KClIe)J;H:qHOH-
HbIe C60PhI 6bIJIII 'IaCTII'IIIO 06pa60TalIbI H H3.D:alIbI B RIIHre «nilleIIH:qLll
A6IfCCIIIIHII}), HanHcalIlIoii KOJIJIeKTIIBOM aBTopOB no.D: PYKOBOACTBOlli II npn:
6JIIIiRaHilleM yqaCTIIH H. M. BaBIIJIOBa 23. Ho H3 ero nepenHCKH C COTPY)J;-
IIIIKaMH I1HcTHTYTa pacTelIIIeBo.n:cTBa BO BpeMH 3Rcne.n:II:qIIH, II3 RpaTRHx
.D:IIeBIIHKOBI>IX 3anIIceH, coxpalIIIBillHXCH cpoTorpacpHH BH.n:IIO, 'ITO H B 3cpno-
nIIII II B Cpe,ZJ;II3eMHoMopbe H. II. BaBHJIOB 3aIIIIMa.rrCH He TOJIbKO arp060Ta-
HIIKOH, 110 II CeJIbCKOX03HHCTBelIHOH 3TIIorpacpIIeH 2 . r JIy60KyIO ,ll,peBIIOCTb
3cpHonCKoro elITpa npOHcxom;rrelIIIH RYJIbTypHOH cpJIOpbI 011, RaK BCer.D:a,
aprYMeHTHpOBaJI lIe TOJIbRO 60TaIIII'IeCKHMII, 110 H apXeOJIOrII'IeCRHMH Ha6JIIO-
AeIIIIHMH, a IIMelIlIO cpaBIIIITeJIblIO paHHIIM B03paCTOM coxpalIHBIIIIIXCH
apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIX nallfHTIIIIKOB B ARCYMe.
IIIITepec R IJ;eIITpa.TIbIIOll A3HH Y H. II. BaBIIJIOBa oc06elIII0 YCIIJIHJICIl
nOCJIe acpralICKoro rryTeillecTBIIH, TaR RaK YCTalIOBJIelIHe ceBepO-BOCTO'llI:bIX
rpaHHD; nepe,ZJ;IIea3IIaTCRoro :qelITpa npOIICXOiR.D:eIIIIH RYJIbTyplIbIX paCTeHHH.
eCTeCTBeIIHO, CTaJIO O.n;IIOH 113 nepBOO'Iepe.n:IIbIX ero IIayqHI>IX 3aAaq.
B 1929 r. 6bIJIa IIpOBe.n:elIa 60,jJbillaH 3Kcne)J;H:qIIH, OXBaTIIBrnaH Bce OCIIOBHbIe
3eMJIe)J;eJIbqeCRHe paHolIbI CHII:q3HHa 25. R'aR H Xope3M. OH OKa3aJICH 6e.n:eH
3II.D:eMaMH. H. I1. BaBIfJIOB nIICaJI 0 60raTbIX pe3YJIbTaTaMII HCCJIe,ZJ;OBaHllHX
A. CTeHlIa, C. <P. OJIb)J;elI6ypra H .D:PyrHx Y'IeUbIX, OTKpbUlillIIX B 3eMJIe)J;eJIb-
'IeCRlIX oa3IIcax BeJIHKOJIenlIYIO RYJIbTYPY, IIaMeTHBillIIX RapaBalIlIhle nYTR,
no KOTOpbIM illJIa TOprOBJIH R'HTan C PIIMOM II Cpe)J;Hen A3IIen. Ho ero co6-
CTBelIlIl>I€ C60PbI B03,ll,eJIbIBaeMbIX pacTeHHH, cpaBIIIfTeJIblIO 6eJJ:HbIe. lIe Mor-
JIH, RaR B AcpraHHcTalIe, npHBecTH K MbICJIII 0 e e lIe BCRpbITbIX llJIaCTaX
HCTOpHH KYJIbTypbI H 3eMJIe.n;eJIHH. O.D:IIaKO BaBIIJIOB BblHBHJI BJIHHHIIe 101'0-
3ana)J;IIOH A3HH H R'IfTaH Ha cpOpMIIpoBaHHe 3eMJIe.n:e.TIb'IeCROH RYJIbTypLI
IJ;elITpaJIblIOH A3IIII, 'ITO xopomo corJIacyeTcH C npe.Il;CTaBJIelIIIeM 0 npe06JIa-
.D:aIOm;IIX IIanpaBJIeHIIHX RYJIbTyplIl>IX H 3THII'IeCRIIX cBH3eH; OTlIfeTIIJI, qTO
oropO,ZJ;IIaH RYJIbTypa B CHH 3HlIe Haxo.n:IITCH npeHlIfym;ecTBelIHo B PYRax KO-
peH eB, ,ZJ;YlIraII H RHTaH eB - Hapo.n;OB BOCTOqlIorO IIpOIICXOiR.n:eIIIfH; nOK3-
3aJI uO'ITII nOJIHOe TOiR.n:eCTBO IICnOJIb3yeMbIx 3.n:eCb CeJIbCROX03HHcTBeHHLIx
OpY.D:IIH co cpe,ZJ;IIea3HaTCKIIMII. OKOIlqaTeJIbHbIH BbIBO)J; 0 60JIbillOH OTCTaJIoCTH
II RpaHlIell 6e.D:IIOCTH n;elITpaJIblIOa3HaTcRoro 3eMJIe.n;eJIHH 6bIJI aprYMeHTHpo-
Ball II Me,ZJ;IIRo-reorpacpH'IeCKII TeM, 'ITO Mory'IHe xpe6TbI OT)J;eJIHJIH CHII:q3HH
OT OCTaJiblIbIX paHOIIOB II 06YCJIOBHJIII OTlIOCIITeJIblIYIO 6e30lIaCIIObTb ero B OT-
HOillelIIIH 1I1lI0I'IIX HlIcpeK:qIIOIIHbIX 3a60JIeBalIIIll, pacnpOCTpalIelIHbIX B Acpra-
HllCTaHe II IIpalIe.
B )J;BYX 06IillIpubIX aMepUKaHCKIIX 3RClIe,ll,IID;IIHX 1930 II 1932-1933 rr.
H. II. BaBIfJIOB II3yqIIJI 3eMJIe)J;eJIIIe ellA, nO'ITH Bcex CTpaII IJ;eIITpaJIbHoi:
H IOmlIoH AMepHRH 26. OH nO'ITH IICqeplIbIBaIOm;e IICIIOJIh30BaJI II3BeCTHYIO
Tor.n:a JIHTepaTYPY no 3aCeJIeHIIIO AMepHRH, no .D:peBlIelIrnHM :qeHTpaJII>HOaMe-
pHRaHCKHM II IOmlIoaMepIIRalICRIIM IIBIIJIH3a IIHM. BbI.D:eJIIIB ,ZJ;Ba caMObTOH-
TeJIblIbIX :qeHTpa B03HIIKIIOBelIIIH KYJIbTypHbIX paCTelIHM - :qeHTpaJIbHOaMe-
pHRaHCRHM H aHAnHCRIIH, 011 nORa3aJI orpOMHoe 3Ha'IeIIHe reorpacpH'IeCKOl'6
cpaRTopa B pa3BIITIIH 3eMJIe,ll,eJIbqeCROH RYJIbTYPbI HMeHHO B 3THX paMOHax.
npH YCTaHOBJIeHIIH :qeHTpOB B03HHRHOBeHllH II paCCeJIelIIIH OTAeJILlibIX BH.n;O.
75
I
«YJIhTYPlIbIX paCTeHIIH IIM illIIpOKO upIIBJIeKaJIHCb MaTepIIaJIbI apXeOJIOI'H'Ie-
CI,HX paCROnOK. MaTepHaJIhI, C06paHIIbIe B AMepHRe, n03BOJIIIJIH H. II. Ba-
BJ'WOBY )J;OnOJIIIIITeJILHO aprYMelITHpOBaTb CBOIO TeopIIIO 0 B03IIHKIIOBe-IIIIH
ae!VlJIe.D:eJIIIH B roplIbIX paiIolIax II3 IIelIOJIIIBIIOH RYJIbTYPbI, 0 BTOpTf'IIIOM
xapaKTepe OpOillaei\fOrO 3ellfJIe.Il;eJIIIH. C06CTBeHII0 60TaIIII'IeCKIIe IIa6JI10,'J,eIIIIH
61>IJIII nOIIOJIlIelIbI IICKJIIO'IHTeJIbIIO T aTeJIblIbIM II3yqeIIHeM upIIeMOB 3eMJIe-
AeJIIIH B COBpellfelIlIYIO 3IIOXY, CeJIbCKOX03HHCTBelIHOH 3TIIorpacpHII IIII.n:eIICKHX
3THH'IeCKIIX rpynn, a TaKme OCIIOBlIbIX 3TanOB I1X pa3BHTIIH no apxeo.rrorII-
'IeCRHM MaTepIIaJIaM. n03TOMY ;rrBe OCIIOBlIbIe CTaTbH H. II. BaBIfJIOBa 06
allfepIIKalICKHX IIYTerneCTBHHX IIpe.n:CTaBJIHIOT C060H lIe TOJIbKO 06pa3 bI
arp060TalIHqeCKOrO onIIcalIIIH TeppIITopIIH, HO II 3aMeqaTe.TIblIbIe IICTOpIIKO-
ClTfIOrpacpH'IecRIIe O'IepKII allfepIIRaHcKoro 3eMJIe.D:eJIIIH B CBH3H C HCTO-
pIIeH qeJIOBeqeCKOH KYJIbTyphl.
EO.:'IbrnOe KOJIII'IeCTBO qpe3Bhl'IaiIII0 IIIITepeClIl>IX H BamlIl>IX MbICJIeiI IICTO-
pIIKO-3TIIOJIOI'H'IeCKOI'O xapaKTepa CO)J;epiRIITCH II B )J;PyrIIx TPYiJax H. H. Ba-
BmIOBa: ero MOHOI'pacpHHx 0 KYJIbTYPIIOiI cpJIope TypKMeHIIH, Ta.D:lIUIKIICTalIa
II R'IIprH3IIII, CTaTbHX 0 3eMJIe)J,eJlIIH BO MlIorHX paiIolIax R'aBRa3a, HIIOIIIIII
Ii IIa TaHBalIe 27. OrpOllfIlbIM lIIITepec R IICTOpIIKO-3THorpacpH'IeCKoiI npo6JIe-
MaTIIKe, RO BceM HBJIelIIIHM 'IeJIOBe'IeCROH KYJIbTypbI B rnIIpOKOM CMhICJIe
CJIOBa, IIIITaBillIIiIcH IIenpepbIBlIbIM II3Y'IeIIIIeM HCTOpIIqeCKOiI, apXeOJIOrHqe-
CKOH, JIIIlIrBIICTH'IeCKOH JIIITepaTypbI 28 , nOCTOHHlIoe If OqelIb TI aTeJIbHOe
conOCTaBJlelIIIe pe3YJIbTaTOB c06CTBeHIIbIX IICCJIeD;OBaIIIIiI cyme II3BeCTIIbIMH
cpaKTaMII RYJIbTYPIIOH II 3TIIII'IeCKOH IICTOpIIH qeJIOBe'IeCTBa, illHpOKIIiI reo-
rpacpHqeCRIIiI no.D:XO.Il; R up06JIeMe B03IIHKHOBelIIIH H pa3BIITHR eHTpOB 3eM-
JIe,[leJIIIH - Bce 3TO .n:eJIaeT TPY,ZJ;bI H. II. BaBIIJIOBa 6ec e1IHbIMH ,ZJ;JIH IICTO-
pIIKa II JII060ro Cne IIaJIIICTa, corrpIIRacaIOm;erOCH B cBoeiI IIayqlIOll pa60Te
C np06JIeMaMII IICTopII'IeCKoiI IIayRII. )J;JIH alITpOnOJIOrOB OHII oc06elIII0 3Ha-
'IIIMbI, TaK KaK II3Y'IeIIIIe RYJIbTYPIIOiI cpJIOpbI, RaK II aHTpOnOJIOrIIH, CBH3aHO
C MHpOM lIe TOJIbRO 6IIOJIOrIIII, HO II HCTOpHH, IIaX0.D:HTCH Ha Py6eme IIaYR
M IIOTOMY qepnaeT IIa6JIIO.D:eIIIIH II lIfaTepHaJI .D:JIH BI>IBO)J;OB H3 pa3HbIX 06JIac-
TeiI 3IIaIIIIH.
II,EHTPbI IIPOIICX01K]J;EHIIH RYJIbTYPHOn c1IJIOPbI
Bce nepeqIICJIelIHhle 3Kcne.n:II IIH H .n:eTaJIblIOe JIHqlIOe 3IIaKOMCTBO C KYJIb-
TYPIIOiI cp.rrOpOH pa3JIIIqlIhlX CTpaII lIe MOrJIH lIe H3MeHHTb nepBOHaqaJIbHYIO
cxeMY eIITpOB upOIICXOm.Il;elIIIH RYJIbTYPlIl>IX paCTeHHiI, ony6JIIIROBalIHYIO
H. I1. BaBIIJIOBbIM B 1926 r. B .D:OKJIa,ZJ;e IIa BCeCOI03IIOM C'be3)J;e ITO relIeTHRe,
CeJIeKD;IIII, cellfeHOBO)J;CTBY H nJIellfeHIIOMY mHBOTHOBO,ZJ;CTBY, C)J;eJIaIIIIOM IIM B
1929 1'., 3Ta cxeMa 6bIJIa pacrnIIpelIa 3a C'IeT BbI,ZJ;eJIeIIHH B Cne HaJIblIbIiI
elITp IIII)J;IIH 29. Oc06eHII0 Rap.n:IIlIaJIblIOiI peBH3IIII reorpacpIlH €IITpOB, HJIIf
O'IarOB, npOIICXOiR)J;eIIIIH RYJIbTYPIIOH cpJIOpbI 6bIJIa nO.D:BeprlIYTa Y'IeHbIM
qepe3 IIeCKOJIbRO JIeT B pa60Te, cO)J;epiRam;eH II3JIOmeHIIe II apryMeHTaD;HIO
06m;eH TeopIIII CeJIeI{ IIH C 60TalIIIKo-reorpacpIIqeCKOiI TOqRII 3peHHH 30. R'o-
JIIIqeCTBO l(eHTpOB 6hIJIO ,ZJ;oBe.D:elIo ,ZJ;0 BOCbMH B CTapoM II HOBollf CBeTe.
nepe.D:IIea3HaTCRHH l(elITp 61>IJI nO.D:pa3,ZJ;eJIeH Ha .D:Ba - c06cTBelIHO nepe)J;He-
a3HaTCRHi, BRJIIO'IaBillHiI IIpaH H 3aRaBKa3be, H cpe.Il;IIea3IIaTCRHiI (neH.II;-
iRa6, AcpraIIHCTalI, R'aillMIIp, Tap:iRHKIICTaII H npHTHHbrnaHbe). TaRiRe 6bIJI
nO)J;pa3)J;eJIeR Ha ABa II aMepIIKalICRHiI l(eIITp, BIIYTPII KOToporo 6blJIH BbI.n:e-
JIelIbJ )J;Be callfOCTOHTeJIblIbIe 06JIaCTH - :qelITpaJIblIOaMepHRalICRaH II alI.n:IIH-
CKaH (IIepYBHaII0-3KBa)J;opo-60JIIIBIIHCRaH) 31. HapH)J;y C 3TIIMH BoceMbIO
OCHOBHI>IMH OqaraMH 6bIJIII oxapaKTepII30BalIbI B 60TaHIIRo-reorpacpH'IecKoM
O,!,IIOilleIIIIH em;e TPII .D:0nOJIIIIITeJIblIbIX: MII.II;O-MaJIaHCKIIH, qHJIOaHCRIIH H 6pa-
.3I;IJIbCRO-IIa parBan:cKHH.
76
Ho H 3Ta cxeMa He CTaJIa OROHqaTeJIbIIOH. B CTaTbe, 0lIy6JIHKOBaBflOM
He3a}J;OJIrO .n:o CMepTH, H. M. BaBIIJIOB OTRa3aJICH OT BM.D:eJIeIIHH nepe)J;He-
a3HaTCKoro H cpe,ll,IIea3IIaTCRoro eIITpOB, 06'be,ZJ;HIIIIB HX B O.D:HH, HO n0.D:pa3-
.D:€JIIIJI ero Ha TPI1 BTOpH'IHhlX o'18ra: COOCTBeIlHO nepe,ZJ;Hea3IIaTCKHH, KY,ZJ;a
BOllIJIa II Cpe.n:HHH A3IIH, RaBKa3CKHH II ceBepO-3ana.D:IIOHII.D:HHCRHH 32. B 3TOM
me pa60Te 6bIJI ,ZJ;IIcpcpepelI IIpOBaB II eIITpaJIbIIOaMepHKaHCKIIH :qeIITp, B CO-
CTaBe KOToporo, IIO MbICJIII H. M. BaBHJIOBa, JIOKaJIH3YIOTCH TPII o'18ra: c06-
CTBeIlIIO QeIITpaJibIIOallfepHKaIICRIIH, ropHbIH IOmlIoallfepHKaHCKHM II BeCT-
HII,ZJ;CKIIH OCTpOBIIOH. aJIblIeiinIee pa3BHTHe arpOOOTalIHRH H apXeOJIOrHH B
n;eJIOM rrO,ZJ;TBep,ZJ;IIJIO caMOCTOHTe:rrbIIOCTb H rJIy60RYIO }J;peBIIOCTb Bcex YCTa-
HOBJIeHIIbIX Y'IelIbIM :qeIITpOB 33.
JIH npe)J;CTaBIITeJIeM CMemlIl>IX IIaYK BaiRlIa, O)J;IIaKO, lIe CTOJIbRO ROII-
RpeTlIaH reorpacpIHI caMHX :qeJlTpOB rrpOIICXOiR}J;eIIIIH, CKOJIbKO TO co.n:epiRa-
HIIe, ROTopoe BKJIa,ZJ;bIBaJI H. M. BaBHJIOB B 3TO nOIIHTHe. B 1926 r. 011
IIIICaJI 0 elITpax rrpOHCXOfK)J;eIIIIH KaK 00 06JIaCTHX C IIIITelICHBHOM cpelIoTH-
nHqeCI,OII II3l1felI'IHBOCTbIO, xapaKTepII3YIOm;HXCH aKTIIBlIbIM BII.II;b- H cpOpllfO-
06pa30Ba1IHeM, 110 caMH npIIqHlIbI 3TIIX npo eCCOB 6bIJIH eMY e e IIeHClIbI.
O)J;HaKo yme 'Iepe3 ro.D: nOHBIIJIaCb pa60Ta, B ROTOpOH 61>IJIO nOKa3aIlO, qTO - --,
:qeHTpbI IIpOIICXOiR)J;eIIIIH KYJIbTyplIOM cpJIOpbI O,ZJ;IIOBpeMeIIIIO HBJIHIOTCH eIIT- \
paMH oH eIITpan;HH A,?MHlIaIITHbIx aJIJIeJIeM (T. e. TaROH cpOpMbI rella, npH \
ROTOpOIl onpe.D:eJIHeMbIH HM npII3IIaR npOHBJIHeTCH yme B CJIe.n:YIOm;eM IIOKO- ,
JIeHHH B OTJIHqHe OT pel(eCCIIBlIoro reBa), 06JIaCTHlIIII YCKopelIIIH H IIHTeIICIIq1H-
Ra:qIIH 1fYTan;nOlIlIbIX npo eCCOB 34. MMelIlIO B 3'1'0 BpeMH OcpopMIIJIaCb B pa-
GOTax H. M. BaBIIJIOBa HOBaH TepMHIIOJIOrIIH, 011 CTaJI YIIOTpe6JIHTb TepMIIII
« eHTp ROHn;eHTpa HH reHOB», HJIH «relI eIITp», OCTaBIIB TepMIIII (wqar» )J;JIH
BTOpII'lHbIX eIITpOB, BI>I)J;eJIflIOm;IIXCH B rpalIII ax OCIIOBlIbIX 06JIaCTeM cpOpllIO-
06pa30BaHIfH. B TeopIIH H. M. BaBHJIOBa 0 :qmITpax relIIIOM ROH:qeIITpa:qnn
ObIJI c,ZJ;eJIaII IIepexo)J; 0'1' H3yqaeMOM OOTaHIIRaMH-cpJIOpIICTaMH II arpOIIOMallfII
cpeIIOTHnH'IeCKOH H3MelI'IIIBOCTII RYJIbTyplIhIX paCTelIHH K ee relIeTH'IeCKIIM
npIIqHlIaM, nepeXO.Il; OT reorpacpIIII II3l1felI'IIIBOCTH, IIJIH cpelIoreorpacpIIH, R re-
HoreorpacpIIH. H. M. BaBIIJIOBa - BlIIeCTe C A. C. Cepe6pOBCRIIM, npe.D:JIOmIlB-
IIIHM 061I YIO CPOPMYJlIlpOBRy rpaIIHn;, MeTO.D:OB II IIpe.D:MeTa relIoreorpacpIIH,-
MOiRHO C'IIITaTb OCIIOBaTeJIeM 3TOH OOJIaCTH 6IIOJIOrIIII.
KaK BCHRoe RpYlIlIoe TeOpeTllqeCROe 0606m;eHHe, TeopIIH reIIIWIITpOB,
npe.D:CTaBJIelIHe 0 .D:HCRpeTHOCTII (npepbIBIICTOCTII) cpopMo06pa30BaTeJIblIOrO
npo ecca II CIICTeMlIoCTH (T. e. 3aROHOMepHOM paClIpOCTpalIeHHH) 06JIaCTeM
ROII eIITpal(HH II pa3peiRelIIIH reHOB MOryT 6bITb HCnOJIb30BalIbI B CMemlIbIX
06JIaCTHX 3HaIIIIH. KOlIeqHO, HeJIb3H rOBopIITb 0 IIpHMOM IIapaJIJIeJIII3Me relI-
n;eIITpOB C 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTHMH reorpacpH'IeCROrO pacnpOCTpaHelIHH )J;PyrHx
6HOJIOrII'IeCKHX HBJIeHHH, B .D:aIIIIOM CJIY'18e 'IeJIOBe'IeCRIIX pac. PaCbI 'IeJIO-
BeRa IIeH3MepHMO .D:peBlIee caMbIX CTapbIx IIepBH'IlIbIX :qeHTpOB npOIIcxom}J;e-
IIHH RYJIbTYPlIbIX paCTeHHH, II eCJIH H MomllO rOBopIITb 0 IIapaJIJIeJIH3Me, TO
011 npOHBJIHeTCH TOJIbKO no OTHornelIIIIO K JIORaJIbHbIM alITpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKHM
TIInaM, K lIIaJIbIlIf, IIJIH reorpacpH'IeCRIIM, pacaM, RaR OHII '18CTO IIa3bIBaIOTCH
B aHTpOIIOJIOI'IIqeCKOM JIHTepaType. ApeaJI IOmHbIX MOHrOJIOII)J;OB B 06m;IIX
'IepTaX COBlIa.D:aeT C IOrO-BOCTOqIIOa3IIaTCRIIlIf n;eIITpOM; 06JIaCTb q10pllfIIpOBa-
HIIH )J;aJIblIeBOCTO'IHbIX MOHrOJIOH.n:OB COOTBeTcTByeT BOCTO'IlIoa3IIaTCKOMY
llelITpy; )J;JIH IIaCe.:'IeIIHH n;eHTpaJIblIbIX II ceBepHbIX paHOHOB MII.II;IIII, BOCTO'I-
HbIX II IOiRlIbIX paHOIIOB AcpralIIICTaHa, IOmlIbIX paHOHOB Cpe.D:IIeH A3IIH,
T. e. IOmHOa3I1aTCRoro :qeHTpa B IIIIIpOROM CMbICJIe, xapaRTeplIa ROM6IIlIa HH
npH3HaKOB, IIOJIyqHBiliaH HaIIMelIOBalIHe IIH.D:O-acpraIICROM paCbI. I1epe.n:IIe-
a3HaTCRaH, HJIH apMeIIOH.D:HaH, ROM6HHa:qHH npH3IIaROB paClIpOCTpaHeHa B
77
npep;eJIax 3ana.n:Hoa3HaTCKoro :qeIITpa; HaCeJIeHHe 3cpHonHII (3cpII0IICRlIK
:qeHTp) B 60JIbmHHCTBe alITpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIX RJIaCCHcpIIRa:qHM BbI,ll,eJIHeTCH
TaRiRe B OC06yIO pacy B npe.D:eJIax TPOllHqeCKOrO, HJIH HerpOH.D:HOrO, CTBOJIa.
npH BceM HenOJIHOM 1I3yqeHHOCTH IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM II IOiRHOH AMepHRII B
aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOllf OTlIomeHHII MomlIO Bce me CRa3aTb, qTO B npe.D:eJIax
aMepHKalICRIIX :qeIITpOB RopelIHbIe 3THHqeCKIIe rpynnbI TaRme xapaRTepII-
3YIOTCH onpe.n:eJIeHHbIM cBoe06pa3IIeM 35.
G,ZJ;IIaRO 3IIa'IHTeJIbII0 60JIee BaiRlIO He 3TO 06m;eII3BeCTHoe BTOpII'IIIOe-
COBna)J;eHlIe, npOHcxop;HI ee, OqeBII.D:HO, 3a C'IeT npH6JIH3HTeJIblI0 O.D:IIOBpe-
MeHlIoro B03IIHRIIOBeHIIH B HeOJIIITe nepBHqlIbIX 3eMJIe.D:eJIb'IeCRHX :qeHTpOB II
Tex aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX ROMIIJIeRCOB, ROTopbIe Ha3bIBaIOT MaJIblMII pacaMII.
HaH60JIbmee 3IIa'Ie1IIIe IIMeeT TeOpeTH'IeCRaH CTopoHa pa60T H. II. BaBIIJIO-
Ba, nORa3 HM Ha orpOMHOM MaTepHaJIe p;HcKpeTHOCTH 4JopMo06pa30BaHHH If
CBH3aHHoro C HHM MHoro06pa3IIH B CO'IeTaHHHX H ROHJ: eHTpa:qHH reHOB.
TaRoM nop;xo)J; npII IICTOJIROBaHIfH aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIX .D:aHH@X qpe3B@qaHH
IIJIO.D:OTBOpelI, yme CeM'IaC n03BOJIHeT BRJIIOqHTb B ccpepy IICCJIe)J;OBaImn lIfBO-
rHe HOBbIe acneRTbI aIITpOnOJIOrH'IeCRHX HBJIeHHM II 06em;aeT p;aTb 3Ha'IH-
TeJIbHbIe pe3YJIbTaTbI B 6Y,ZJ;ym;eM.
B OTHomeHIIH TepllfIIIIOJIOrHII CJIe,ZJ;yeT CRa3aTb, '1TO npHMeHHTeJIblIO R
_ aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKOH HCTOpIIH 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa npe)J;nO'ITHTeJIblIee ynoTpe6JIHTb
,/ TepMHII «o'Jar paco06pa30BaHIIH», a He «l(eHTp paco06pa30BaIIIIH». nOCJIeJJ:-
HHH TepMIIH IIanOMIIlIaeT-Q reOMeTpHqeCROM TO'IRe H, IIO-BII.n:HMOMY, BITOJIIIe-
npIIrO)J;eII .Il;JIH 0603IIa'IeHIIH paHOHOB npOIICXOiR.n:eIIIIH KYJIbTYPIIOM cpJIOpbI,
3aHHMaIOm;HX cpaBHIITeJIblIO He60JIbmIIe apeaJIbI. He TO O'IarII pacooopa30-
BalIIIH y 'IeJIOBeKa: OIIH 6bIJIH .D:OCTaTO'II10 06mHplIbI II IIpIIypOqelIbI ,ZJ;aiRe K
06JIaCTHM C IIeO,ll,IIOpO.D:HOH reorpacpH'IeCROH xapaKTepIICTHKOH. B nOJIb3Y
TaRoro B3rJIH;rra MOiRlIO npHBeCTH )J;OCTaTO'II10 BeCRIIe KOCBeHlIbIe co06paiRe-
HHH: OTHOCHTeJIbHYIO He3aBHCHMOCTb qeJIOBeqeCRIIX ROJIJIeKTHBOB OT YCJIOBHH
Cpe.D:@ .D:ame IIa 3ape HCTOpIIII, B HHiRlIeM naJIeOJIIITe, H, RaR CJIe,ZJ;CTBHe
3Toro, a TaKme 3RCTeHCHBHOCTII IIepB06bITHOM OXOTbI H c06IIpaTeJIbCTBa, HX
HCRJIIOqHTeJIbHYIO nO.D:BII7I\HOCTb. Ho eCTb II npHMbIe ,ll,OKa3aTeJIbCTBa: pa3JIII-
'JIIH B xapaRTepe HIImlIenaJIeOJIIITHqeCROH IIIIAYCTpHII, CRJIa,ZJ;bIBaIOm;IIeCH B
06mIIpHbIe reorpacpII'IeCRIIe npOBHHD;HII, OTJIII'IaIOm;IIeCH O.D:Ha OT .n:pyroM cpop-
MaMH OPYP;IIH H I1X pa3HbIM npo eHTHbIM COOTlIomeHHeM (HIImlIenaJIeOJIIITII-
qeCRHe RYJIbTypbI ACPPIIKII, HanpHlIfep 36); MIIrpa:qHH Ha npOTHmelIIIH Bcero
RaMelIlIoro BeRa )J;aiRe C lIIaTepHRa Ha MaTepHR 37; YKa3aHHH B apXeOJIOrH-
'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIaX 3nOXH lIfe30JIIITa H HeOJIIITa IIa MemnJIeMeHIIOM 06-
Mell 38. )J;OCTaTOqHO 06mIIpHbIe apeaJIbI COBpeMeHHbIX pac, 3aCeJIelIIIe 'IeJIO-
BeROM caMbIX pa3H006pa3IIbIX B cpII3HRo-reorpacpIIqeCKOM OTlIomeHIIH paHO-
IIOB - xapaRTeplIoe HBJIeIIHe "IeJIOBeqeCIWM IICTOpIIII Ha'IIIlIaH co BpeMelIIf
OCBoeHHH BCel] OMRYMeHbI, T. e. C 3IIOXH Me30JIIITa BO BCHKOM CJIY'Iae,
a BeCbMa BepOHTIIO, II paHbme.
HaKOBbI npe.D:IIOChIJIKII ,ZJ;JIH BbI.n:eJIeIIIIH O'IarOB paco06pa30BaIIIUI? IIx TPII:
Cnel(IIcpIIqeCKIIM xa paKTep, a IIIIorp;a II ,ZJ;HCKpeTHOCTb lVIOPcpOcpII3IIOJIOrH'Ie-
CROM II3MelI'IIfBOCTH 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOrO opralIH3Ma B pa3IIbIX palIOlIax 3eMIIoro
mapa, .D:IICRpeTlIocTb reorpaqmqeCKOM cpeAM II B3aIL\fOCBH3aIIIIOCTb 3TIIX
.D:BYX RaTeropHH. MOpcpOJIOI'Il'IeCKaH II3MeH'IIfBOCTb 'IeJIOBeKa, ee reorpacpIIqe-
CRaH npIIypOqelIHOCTb II .n:nCKpeTlIbIe npOHBJICIIIIH nO :(TBepiRD;eHbI BceH COBO-
RynHOCTbIO alITpOnOJIOrnqeCRIIX IICCJIe.D:OBaIIHM BO MlIorIIX paHOlIax 3eMHoro
mapa 39.
Pa3JIHqIIH BIIYTPH qeJIOBeqeCTBa B BeJIHqIIlIaX cpII3IIO OrIlqeCKHX npII3Ha-
ROB IIpIIBJIeKJIII BIIIIlIIaHIIe JIHmb B IIamellf CTOJIeTIIII, IIOCJIe IIepBOM MIIpOBOM
BOMlIbI. C Tex nop c06pall KOJIOCCaJIblIbIH MaTepIIaJI 0 Bapna:qHHX 3pIITpO-
18
D;HTaplIbIX OC06elIHOCTeM RpOBH, 6eJIKOB CbIBOpOTRH, CTpOeIIIfH reMorJI06HHa,
o XHMHqeCROM COCTaBe ymlIoH Cepl>I, 0 cBoe06pa3lIH BRYCOBbIX peaR:qHM 40.
KaR npaBlIJIO, cplI3lIOJIorlI'IeCRHe oc06elIHOCTH opralIH3Ma, HCCJIe)J;yeMbIe
aHTpOrrOJIOraMH, ORa3bIBaJIIICb npH3HaKaMH C HCHOH HaCJIe)J;CTBeIIHOM CTPYR-
TYPOH, OlIpe,ZJ;eJIHeMOH O)J;IIHM-.D:BYMH, MaRCHMYM TpeMH IIaCJIe.D:CTBelIlIbIMlI
aRTopaMlI. HecMoTpH Ha HaJIIIqlIe )J;aIIIII>IX, CBH,ZJ;eTeJIbCTBYIO lIX 0 3aBHCH-
MOCTII IIeROTOpbIX CPlI3IIOJIOrIIqeCRlIX xapaRTepIICTlIK RpOBH (rpYlInbI KpOBlI
CHC'l'ellfbI ABa, reMorJI06HII) OT HlIcpeR HolIlIhIX 3a60JIeBaHHM u, B :qeJIOM
aHTponocpII3lIOJIOI'IIqeCKIIe CBOHCTBa 06IIapymHBaIOT OTIIOCHTeJIbHyIO aBTOHO-
MHIO OT Cpe.D:OBbIX B03.D:eMCTBHH.
He Mellee qeTKII npocTpalIcTBeHlIbIe rpaHIID;bI OT,a:eJIblIbIX 3JIeMelITOB
reorpacpIIqeCROH cpe,a:bI. Y'IeIIHe 0 30lIax IIplIpO)J;bI B. B. )J;oKyqaeBa HMeJIO
CBOII;\fII MIIOrU'IIICJIelIlIbIMH CJIe.D:CTBHHMH TeopHH RJIIIMaTHqeCRHX rrOHCOB,
reorpacpIIqeCRlIX H JIaH.D:macpTlIbIX 3011, nOJIHYIO If Tm;aTeJIbIIYIO xapaKTepHCTII-
RY nOBepXIIOCTII 3eMIIoro mapa H npH3eMHOH aTMoccpephl no OT,ZJ;eJIblIhIlII,
COCTaBJIHIOm;IIM reorpacprr'IeCKYIO cpe,ZJ;y KOMIIOHeIITaM, BbI eJIeHIIe OT.n:eJIblIbIX
TaRCOIIOMHqeCKIIX e,ZJ;lIIIII JIalI,ZJ;macpTlIo-reorpacpH'IeCROrO paHOHHpOBalIHH If:
I1X conO.D:'IIIlIeIIIIe 42. Y'IeHHe E. E. nOJIhIIIOBa 0 reOXI1MIIH JIaH,a:macpTa JIer-
.JIO B OCHOBY 6yplI0 pa3BIIBaIOI eHCH CeMqaC JIalI.D:macpTIIOH reOXIIMIIH 43,
a BJlIUIIIIIe 3Toro acneKTa reorpacpII'IeCROH Cpe.D:hI Ha opralIlI3M OTpa3IIJIOCb B
C03.D:aHIIlI TeopIIlI 6HoreOXHlIfIIqeCKIIX npOBlIlI IIH 44. B eJIOM, TaKIIlII 06pa-
30M, reorpacpII'IeCRaH cpe.D:a npe.D:CTaBJIHeT C060M lIe O.D:IIOpO.n:IIbIM cpOII .n:JIH
Bcex npoTeKaIOm;lIX IIa 3ellfIloH nOBepxHocTH npo eccoB, a IIO.n:BHmIIYIO )J;H-
lIaMIIqecRYIO cIIcTelllY pa3IIhIX KOMlIolIelIToB, B KOTOpOH TOT lIJIlI lIHOII ROlll-
TIOlIelIT npII06peTaeT B 3aBIICHMOCTH OT YCJIOBIIM MeCTa II BpeMelIH B CHJIY
3aROlI01lleplIOCTeH pa3BIITIIH caMOM reorpacpII'IeCROM cpe,a:I>I IIpe06JIa)J;aIOm;ee
3IIa'IeIIIIe.
TpeTbH upe.D:nOCblJIKa O"IarOB paco06pa30BalIlIH - HelIocpe)J;CTBelIIIaH
CBH3b reorpacpII'IeCROH II3MeH'IIIBOCTll "IeJIOBeqeCKOrO opralIII3Ma II ,ZJ;IICRpeT-
IIbIX 3JIeMeHTOB reorpacpH'IeCKOH cpe,ZJ;bI - TaRme MOiReT 6bITb nO.D:TBepm.D:e-
IIa pH.n:OM ,ZJ;aIIIIbIX, XOTH IIORa IIX lIe O'IelIb MlIoro H ;rraJIblIeMrnee IIaKOnJIelIIIe
lWTOPbIX RpaMlIe iReJIaTeJIbHO. ho YBH3Ra CO cpe)J;IIerO)J;OBbIlIflI TeMnepaTY-
paMII BapHa lIH mIIpIIlIbI Hoca, lI3MepeHIIoH IIa iRIIHOM, a TaRiRe illIIpHlIbI
rpymeBII,ll,HOrO OTBepCTIIH, II3111epelIIIOH IIa 'Ieperre, HClIoe 30naJiblIOe paclIpe-
)J;eJIelIlIe mIIpIIHbI Hoca B npe.n:eJIax CeBeplIoM II IOJRIIOH AMepHKH, reorpacpH-
'IeCKIIe 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTII B pacnpei'J;eJIelIIIH IJ,BeTa BOJIOC H rJIa3, :qBeTa KOiRlI,
lpOplllbI BOJIOC, TOJIm;IIlIhI ry6, cpOpMbI T'OJIOBbI. B O.n:IIHX CJIY'IaHX CBH3b
pacnpe,ZJ;eJIelIIIH npII3HaRa IIa TeppIITopIIII 3ellflIoro mapa C reorpacpIIqeCKOM
30lIaJIbHOCTbIO rrOJIyqIIJIa Y.n:OBJIeTBOpIITe LlIoe CPYIIK IIOlIaJILHOe IICTOJIKOBa-
IIHe (nIIrMeIITa IIH, mIIplIHa Hoca, TOJI lIlIa ry6), B )J;pyrIIX - OCTaeTCH He
O"IelIb nOIIHTIIOM (cpopMa BO.lIOC) &5.
HapH)J;Y C OTMeqeHIIbIMII oc06eIIIIOCTHMIf: CXO]J;HI>IM THn reorpa«lm:qeCROrO
paclIpe,ZJ;eJIeHIIH 3acpIIRcHpoBaII II .D:JIH nponop IIH TeJIa, a TaKiRe )J;JIH pOCTO-
BeCOBblX oTHomelIIIH. IIx CBH3b C 30lIaJIblIOCTbIO IICTOJIKOBalIa KaR O)J;IIO II3
cpe.n:CTB nO.D:.D:epiRaIIIIfl cOBepmeIIHoro TelIJIOBOrO rOMeOCTa3a 'IeJIOBeqeCKOrO
opranII3Ma B pa3IIbIX YCJIOBIIHX cymecTBoBaHlIH 46. MlIor e aHTpOIIOJIOrH
paCCMaTpIIBaIOT Bce 3TII a,a:arrTHBHbIe IIplI3IIaKII KaK CBII,'JeTeJIbCTBO aKTIIBIIO
npO.D:OJIiRamm;erOCH npIICIIOC06JIeIIIUI K cpe)J;e B COBpeMelIIIOlli 06m;eCTBe, a CJIe-
,a:OBaTeJIbIIO, II IIIITeHCIIBHO ,a:eHCTBYIOm;ero p:aHJIeIIIIH CeJIeK IIII. npOTHB TaKOH
'TO'IRII 3pelIHH npIIBO,ZJ;HJIIICb MlIorlIe B03pamelIIIH RaR cpaKTH'IeCKOrO, TaK J2!
TeOpeTHqeCROrO IIOpH]J;Ra. ----,
0'Iarpaco06pa30munfH - 3TO y"IaCTOR 3eMIIOH nOBepXIIOCTII, IIa KOTOpOllf
npOD;ecc paco06pa30BaHHH--OTJIII'IaeTCH onpe)J;eJIenlIOM cneD;IIcpHRon. all MO-
79
II
meT 6bITb OTrpaHHqeH reOMopcpOJIOrHqeCRHMH, JIalI,ZJ;macpTlIbIMH HJIII BO.D:HbIl\fH
py6emaMII, C03.D:aIOI HMII npe)J;nOCbIJIRy )J;JIH II30JIHI:(IIII npOiRHBaIOm;HX B
npe.D:eJIax 3Toro yqaCTRa 3TIIHqeCI{HX rpynn II ]J;JIH npOHBJIelIIIH cnen;HcpH'Ie-
CKHX C.D:BHrOB B II3MeHqHBOCTH npH3HaROB. TaRHM 06pa30M, oqar paco06pa-
30BaHHH npe,ZJ;CTaBJIHeT C060M KaR 6bI reorpacpIIqeCRYIO apelIY )J;JIH OlIpe.D: e -
JIeHIIOH .D:HCRpeTHOM e.D:HHHn;I>I II311f€IIqIIBOCTII, ee reorpacpH'IeCKIIII apeaJI. lIo
011 IIfOmeT H He HMeTb HClIbIX rpaUII B reorpacpIIqeCKOM ClIfbICJIe, eCJIH
3THIIqeCKIIe rpYlInbI, npomIIBaIOI ne B npe.n:eJIax 3Toro O'Iara, II30.1IIIpOBalIbI
OT OCTaJIbHhIX CO HaJIbII0-H3bIKOBbIMII, IIOJIHTIIqeCKHMII rpaHIIn;aMH, 3TlIorpa-
cpHqeCKHMII Tpa.D:II HHMII H T. .D:. O'Iar paco06pa30BalIIIH II B 3TOllf c.'1y'rae
IIpIIypOqeII R onpe.n:eJIelIlIOM TeppHTopIIII, HO rpalIIIn;aMII eMY CJIYrt aT lIe
reorpacpII'IeCKIIe py6emH, a rpalIH bI pacupOCTpalIeHIIH Tex CO naJiblIbIX
"HBJIeIIIIM, KOTopbIe BbICTYlIaIOT B Ka'IeCTBe relIeTIIqeCRIIX 6apbepOB. HaKOlIen;,
npII OT'IeTJIHBOM npIIcnoc06IITeJIblIOCTII paCOBoro KOMIIJIeKCa rpaHIf bI O'Iara
paco06pa30BalIIIH onpe)J;eJIHIOTCH npe,ZJ;eJIaMH paClIpOCTpalIeHIIH Tex 3.1IeMelI-
TOB reorpacpIIqeCKOM cpe,ZJ;bI, IWTOpbIe BbI3B"_JIIf upIIcnoc06JIeHHe. OlIn TaRme
lIfOryT lIe COBna.D:aTb C reOllfopcpOJIOrII'IeCKIIlIfH, JIaH,ZJ;macpTlIbIMII H rll.D:pOJIOrH-
qeCKIIMII pyoeiRaMH, XOTH O'Iar paco06pa30BaHIIH II B TaKOH cHTya HII OCTa-
eTCH B nepBYIO oqepe.D:b reorpacpHqeCKIIM nOIIHTIIeM. B IIeM CJIIIBaIOTCH Boe-
.D:IIIIO, CIIIITe3HpYIOTCJI rrpe.n:CTaBJIeIIIIH 0 ,ZJ;IICKpeTIIOM xapaKTepe II3I1felI'IIIBO-
CTH, IIpepbIBIICTOCTII reorpacpnqeCROM Cpe.n:bI H TeClIaH CBH3b lIfem,'J,y IIIIMII,
IIenOCpe;rrCTBeHnoe BJIIIHIIIIe reorpacpII'IeCROrO cpaRTopa Ha IIpo:qecc pacoo6pa-
30BalIIIH Y qe.TIOBeKa 47.
Pa3YMeeTCH, O'IarII paco06pa30BalIIIH IIMeIOT pa3IIhIH B03paCT H reorpa-
CPHH IIX MelIHJIaCb OT 3IIOXII R 3IIOxe. :=ho 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO n03BOJIHeT rOBO-
pIITb 06 onpe.n:eJIelIlIOlr IIepapXlIIf O'IarOB, BbI,ZJ;eJIHTb IIepBH'IIIhle II BTOPIIq-
IIbIe OqarII paco06pa30BalIIIH. 06pa30BaBrnIIecfl upH 3aCeJIelIIIII ollKYMelIhI.
HClIo, O,ZJ;IIaIW, 'ITO IIpo ecc paco06pa30BalIIIH He IIpeKpaTIIJICH C 3aCeJIe-
IIIIeM Bcen OlmYMelIbI. MYTal(IIII, H30JIH IIH, CMemeHHe IIOCTOHHuO npIIBOJJ;HJIII
K cpOplVIIfpOBaIIIIIO ROBhIX CO'IeTaHIIM aIITpOIIOJIOrHqeCKIIX npII3IIaROB, I IIII-
Kor;rra lIe IIpeRpam;aBrneHCH AIIcpcpepelIl(Ua IIII OT;J:e.TIblIhIX IIOIIYJIH IIii: II IIX
rpYIIII. B. B. EYlIaK BbI.D:BIIIIYJI .D:ame 'Ipe3BhlqaMUO IIJIO)J;OTBOPIIYIO, C Moen
TO'IRH 3peHIIH, II.D:eIO 3TaTIIIOCTII paco06pa30BalIIIH, BbI)J;e.TIeHIIH B paco06pa30-
BaTeJIblIOM IIpo ecce oT,ZJ;eJIblIhIX 3nox, OTJIH'IaIOI IIXcH cBoeH cne:qIIcpHKOH 48.
B COOTBeTCTBIIH C 3TIIM lIfomlIO BbI)J;eJIHTb TpeTIIqHbIe, 'IeTBepTH'UlbIe U em;e
OOJIee MeJIKIfe II n03JJ:IIIIe o'rarII paco06pa30BaIIHH. AIITpOnOJIOrrrqeCKUe )J;aH-
HbIe .D:JIH YCTalIOBJIerrIIH KOIIKpeTIIOM reorpacpUH 3TIIX O'IarOB, IIX MOpcpOcpH-
3IIOJIOrII'IeCKOH, relIeTHqeCKOM, HCTOpIIKO-3BOJIIO HOHIIOH xapaKTepIICTHRH
c06IIpaIOTCH EO Bcex CTpalIax MIIpa &9.
Bce 3TO nOKa3bIBaeT IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbIIOe 3Ua'IelIIIe relIoreorpacpIf'IeCRHX
II)J;eH II 0606m;e1IHH H. 11. BaBIIJIOBa )J;JIfl pa3pa60TKH TeopIIII paCOBe.J;eIIIIH.
nepelIeCeIIHhle IIa aHTpOnOJIOrII'IecKHM MaTepHaJI, OHII oooram;aIOTcH HOBhIMII
IIa6JIIO,ZJ;eIIIIHlIfH II BbIBO.D:aMII, IIpII06peTaIOT ,ZJ;onOJIIIIITeJIbIIOe 060cIIoBalIIIe II
II03BOJIHJOT BBeCTII B reorpacpIIIO pac HOBbIe nJIO)],OTBopHble II)J;eH.
B pa60Tax 0 relIeTII'IeCKOM IICTOJIKOBalIIIII elITpoB cpop"'I006pa30BalIHH
H. M. BaBIIJIOB c.II;eJIaJI em;e 0)],110 KpYlIlIoe TeOpeTHqeCKOe 0606m;eIIHe, oJIe-
CTm e aprYMelITHpoBaB ero CBOIIlIfH 60TaIIH'IeCRHlIfH IIao:IJOlJ:eHIIHlIfII. qeHTpbI
cpopMoo6pa30BalIIIH, a CJIe.n:OBaTeJIbIIO, II ROII eIITpa IIH feHOB aKKYMy.'1IIPY-
lOT BIIYTPII ce6H, RaR YiRe rOBOpIIJIOCb, IIpeIIMym;ecTBeHHo )J;oMIIlIalITlIbIe aJI-
JIeJIII. H. M. BaBIIJIOB caM IICnOJIb30BaJi 3TO 0606m;€IIIIe ;I,JIH 06'bHClIeIIIIH CBeT-
JIOH nIIfllfeHTa IIH IIypIIcTalIn;eB, 'ITO 3aTellf 6bIJIO IIo)J;TBepiR)J;eHo TOqHbIMII
alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIMII IIa6JIIO)J;eIIIIHlIfII 50. H. H. Qe60KcapOB IIepelIeC ero H8
cpOpMHpOBaHIIe ceBeplIOII BeTBII eBpOlIeOII.n:OB 51, aBTOp - IIa upo ecc <POP'-
80
;
lIfIIpOBaHIIH eBpOneOIl)J;OB B :qeJIOM 52. B npe.n;meCTBYIOm;eM O'IepRe 3Ta npo-
6JIellfa paCCMOTpelIa cne:qIIaJIbno.
AIIaJIII3IIpYH OTKpbITYIO H. II. BaBIIJIOBbIM 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTb no OTlIome-
nIIIO K paCOBbIM npII3HaKaM, YMeCTHO CKa3aTb 0 TOM pacmHpelIIIII CMbICJIa,
KOTopoe BKJIa)J;bIBaeTCH Tenepb B TepMIIII « OK I1 IIlIlIbIe IIapO)J;bD). H. H. Po-
rIIIICKIIH nOIm3a.:'I, qTO IIa OKpalInax oHKYMelIbI )J;eHcTBYIOT CIIJIblIee, 'IeM B
:qelITpaJIblIbIX paHolIax, relIeTIIlw-aBTOllfa TII'IeCKHe npo:qecchl (npII'IIfIIa-
rop a3 .D: 0 60JIee CHJIblIaH II30JIH:qIIH) H nO::JToMY IIaCeJIelIlIe oKpaIIlIlIblx 30H
'Iam;e Bcero OTJIHqaeTCH cBoeo6pa3IIbIMII COOTlIorneHIIHMH B KOIIl(eJITpal(HII
OT)J;eJILlIhIX reHOB 53. Ho Te me relIeTHKo-aBTOMaTIf'leCKue npOl(eCCbI npmIB-
.1IHIOT ceoH nOBcIO)J;Y, r.n;e B npOl(ecc paco06pa30BalIHH BMeillIInaeTCH COl(IIaJIb-
HaH IIJIII reorpacpII'IecKaH II30JIHl(IIH, IIanpHMep B ropIIbIX paHoHax. nO::JTOMY,
rOBopH 0 TaK lIa3bIBaeMhIX OKpaUIIHhIX HapO)J;ax, IIymHo no.n;pa3YMeBaTL 1I0)J;
HIIMII He TOJIbKO RapO)J;hI, 3aIIIIMaIOm;He nepIIcpepHHlIhIe OOJIaCTH OIIKYlIIeUbI,
RO II Bce Rapo.n;bI, RaXO)J;Hm;HeCH B YCJIOBIIHX se()!'pacpII'IeCKOH II30.lJ:Hl(IIH
Bo06m;e, B 'IaCTIIOCTII B BbICOKoroplIbIX paHonax )J;ame -i(eIITpaJiblIhTX oO.iIa-
CTeH CTaporo CBeTa. OHII BhITeClIelIhI da npe.n;eJIbI OCIIOBlIbIX nYTelr pacnpo-
cTpalIelIIIH 'IeJIOBeLJeCKOH KYJIbTYPbI H IIfJUpa:qIIH relIOB rrH'rYTb lIe B lIIenb-
men cTerrcIIH, 'f€M KaKIIe-IIu6YiJ,b 3TIIlI'leCKIfe rpyrrnbI KpanHero CeBepa EB-
pa3HH If JIll OrlIeuuolI 3elVwII. II paKTH'lecKIf II caM H. II. BaBHJIOB IBreJi B
BII.D,Y 3TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, Kor.n;a rrpIIMeJIH.iI YCTalIOBJIelIlIOe IIIII relloreorpa-
cpII'IecKoe npaBIIJIO K 06'bHCIICIIIfIO aIITpOnOJIOrH'IeCKIIX oco6elIIIocTeH HYPH-
CTaHl(eB - Hapo.n;a, npomHBaIOm;ero He IIa I{paHHeH rrepHcpepHII, a B l(elITpe
onKYMenhI, 110 H30JIHpOBaIIHoro OT ,iJ,PyrIIx napO)J;OB HenpOXO)J;HlIIhIMH xpeOTa-
MIl H BhICOKoroplIhIMIf, 'Ipe3BhIqalmO TPy.n;IIo.n;ocTynlIbIMII nepeBaJIaMJI.
npH TaKOM nOD;XO.D,e HBJIelIHe OTTCCIIeHHH pe eCCHBlIbIX aJIJIeJIeir JIa OK-
paHIIY BII.D:OBOrO, nO)J;BH.D,OBoro IfJIH paCOBoro apeaJIa npIIoopeTaeT rraHoiIKY-
MelIlIoe 3IIa'IeIIIIe, rrpeBpam;aeTCH B O.D,IIY H3 caMhIX BamlIbIx relIoreorpaCr II -
'IeCKHX 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTeH B paCOBe.D:elIHll 'reJIOBeKa, nOllIoraeT HCTo.--mOBaTb
pH)J; cpaKTII'IeCKlIX IIaOJIIO)J;eIIHn, KOTOphIe ne MorYT 6hITb y.n;OBJIeTBOpHTe.lJ:bIIO
rrOIIHTbI 6e3 rrpIIB.:'Ie'IeIIHH relIoreorpacpHIf. 3aKOII H. II. BaBJIJIOBa 06'LHCHH-
eT, IIarrpHMep, oe3 BCHRHX .n;orrOJIIIHTeJIbIIbIX I'ImOTe3 reorpmprFreCKoe parnpo-
CTpalIelIHe rrHrMeIITa:qHH B 60JIee HJIII Mellee 3aMKIIYThIX paHOlIax BbICOKO-
ropbH.
8TIIH'IeCKIIe rpynrrbI, npomHBaIOm;He rro 06e CTOpOlIbI rJIaBIIOrO KaBKa3-
CKoro xpe6Ta, B 3TIIH'I€CKOM H JIHlIrBIfCTH'IeCIWxr OTlIonreIiIIII, KaK H3BeCTHO,
qpe3BbI'IaH1I0 pa3IIOOOpa3IIbI: ::JTO TIOpKH - 6aJIKap:qhI JI Kapa'IaeB:qbI, IIpalI-
:qbI - oceTIfHhI, KapTBeJIbl - Bce BbICOKOrOprrbIe 3TlIOrpacpII'IeCKIIe rpymIbI
rpY3IIIICKoro HapO)J;a, 3TO, IIaKOIIel(, npe.D:CTaBIITeJIII 1faXCKOH, IIJIH BeHlIax-
CKOH, H aBapO-alI.D,O-.D,H)J;OHCKon H3bIKOBhIX cellIen. Ho B aIITporrOJIOI'II'IeCKOM
OTROmeRHI'I 8TO - e)J;IIRoe IIaCeJIelIIIe, IIOCIITeJIII OqelIb CXO)J;Horo rro Bcen Tep-
pIfTOpHIf CBoero pacrrpocTpalIelIHH TaR IIa3bIBaeMoro l@BKacHolIcKoro TIIna.
AIITpOnOJIOrH'IeCKOe CXO)J;CTBO Bcex rrepe'IHCJIelIlIhIX IIapO.D:OB TaK BeJIIIKO If B
TO me BpeMH TaK pa3JIH'I1IbI OHH no H3hIKy II KYJILTyplIbIM Tpa)J;H:qHHlIf, 'ITO
rrpOTIIBOpe'I1Ie 3TO lIe MOrJIO lIe npIfBJIe'Ib npIICTaJrbHoe BIIIIMaIIlIe K npOO.:'Ie-
Me npOlIcxom)J;eIIHH KaBKaCHOIICKoro THrra. Olla paCCMaTpIIBaJIaCb B TeCIIOH
CBH3H C 06m;IIMII KOIIl(errl(HHMH pacorelIe3a IIapo.n;OB KaBKa3a, II pernelIIIe ee
OTpa3HJIO nOIIIIMalIHe 06m;llX BorrpOCOB relIe3IIca eBpOIIeOH.n;IIOn paCh!.
fpY3HHCKIIe aIITpOrrOJIOrII. BrrepBhIe OTKphIBmIle KaBKaCHOHCKHH THn,-
M. r. A6)J;ymeJIIImBIIJIII II A. H. HaTIImBIIJIII YKa3aJIH IIa ero MopcpOJIOrH-
'f€CKOe cBoe06pa3IIe, IIa OTCYTCTBHe alIaJIOrIfH 3a rrpe.D,eJIaMII KaBKa3a, ITa
ero KOMnaKTHbIH apeaJI 5&. 8TII HCXOP;IIbIe rrOJIOiReHHH, aprYlIIelITrrpOBalIlIhIe
orpOllfRbIllf aRTponOllfeTpH'I€CRHM MaTepHaJIOM no IIapO)J;aM U:elITpaJIhlIOrO
81
1
v
,
KaBKasa, saROHOMeplIO npIIBeJIII IIX K BbIBO.n;y 06 aBTOXTOIIHOM npOHCXOiR.n;e-
IIHH 3Toro TIIna. TaKaH TO'IRa speHHH XOpOIIIO COrJIaCOBblBaJIaCb C HSbIKOBbIM
cBoeoopasHeM nO)J;aBJIHIOm;erO OOJIbIIIHIICTBa npe)J;cTaBIITeJIerr KaBKaCHOIICKoro
TIIlIa. 11cKJIIOqeHHe COCTaBJIHIOT OaJIKap:qbl, KapaqaeB:qbI II oceTIIlIhI, 1I0 )J;JIH
HIIX KaK pas eCTb BeCKHe OCIIOBalIHH IIpeJJ:IIOJIaraTb cpaBIIHTeJIblIO nos)J;nee
3TIIHQeCKOe o.popMJIelIHe II lIepexop: IIX IIeIIOcpe)J;CTBelIlIhIX .n;peBlIerrIIIIIx IIpe)J;-
ROB, rOBopHBIIIHX IIa MeCTlIbIX KaBKa3CKHX H3bIKax, IIa HpalICKYIO H TIOpK-
CKYIO peQb B 3IIOXY cpe)J;IIeBeKOBbH 55. [JpOTIIBOnOJIOiRlIaH TO'IKa spelIIIH 6bIJIa
BbI)J;BIIIIYTa r. <1>. ,l];eOel(OM, HCXO)J;HBIIIHM II3 3aKOlIOMeplIOCTerr reorpacpIIQeC-
CKoro pacnpe)J;eJIeHHH IIIIrMeIITal(HH Ha TeppHTopHH KaBKa3a, OTHOCIUeJIbIIO-
ro 1I0CneTJIelIIIH :qeIITpaJIbIIOKaBKa3CKHX II ceBepOKaBKa3CKHX IIapo.n;OB no
cpaBHeIIllIO C 3aKaBKa3CKHMH 56. r. <1>. ,l..I,eoe:q BhICKa3a.:'I IIpe)J;IIOJIOmeIIHe 0
lIaJIHQIIH ceBeplIOH npHMeCII Y HapO)J;OB CeBeplIoro H IJ;elITpaJIbnOrO KaBKa3a.
HaXO)J;HCb B H3BeCTIIOM COOTBeTCTBlIH C MopcpOJIOrII'IeCKHMH .n;alIlIhIMH, rHno-
Te3a ::JTa TeM lIe Mellee BCTYIIaJIa B IIpOTHBope'IHe C pe3YJIbTaTaMII HCTOpHKO-
apXeOJIOrH'IeCKHX HCCJIe)J;OBaIIHH, CBH)J;eTeJIbCTBYIOm;HX 0 caMOCTOHTeJIbHO I
I"y:rLTypHOM pa3BIITIIII IIapO)J;OB KaBKa3a H IIe3Ha IHTeJIbIIO TH lI.iIH ,",:lme
IIOJIIIOM OTCYTCTBHH HCTopH IeCKIIX CBITSeH C ceBepIIbIMII parrOllaMII B 31I0XY
HeOJIHTa If 6pOH3hI.
8TO IIpOTHBope IHe MOiReT OhITb npeO)J;OJIeIIO, eCJIII C IHTaTb KaBImCHOII-
CKIIiI THn MeCTlIbIM, CcpOpMHpOBaBrnHMCH oe3 BCHKOH ceBeplIOII IIpHMeCH, 1I0
B YCJIOBHHX H30JIHl(HII. A 3TO, B CBOIO OQepe)J;b, lIe MOrJIO lIe npIIBeCTH R
o.;m3Kopo)J;cTBelIlIbIM 6paKaM, YCHJIeHlIhIM em;e IIIHpOKO paClIpOCTpalIelIlIblM
OOhIQaeM 3II)J;oraMHH, K BhIm;enJIeHHIO pel(eCCHBlIbIX aJIJIeJIerr. T. e. K HBJIeHH-
}1M, YCTauOBJIelIlIhIM H. 11. BaBIIJIOBbIIIf. relIoreOrpa HqeCKafl 3aKOIIOllfep-
HOCTb H. 11. BaBUJIOn<l, KaR H Bcrr:Hoe .n;pyroe relIoreorpacpH'IeCKOe HBJIeIIIIe,-
3aROII Eeporr:TlIoCTlIhIM, lIe IIOCrr:m;HII CTporo )J;eTepMHIIHpOBalIlIoro xapaKTepa,
11 B IIOJIIIOM COrJIaCHH C 3THM Beporr:THOCTHbIM CTaTIICTH'IeCKHM ero rrpOHBJIe-
IInelll I-Iaxo.n;HTCH cpaKT cpaBIIHTeJILHO TeMIIOM nIIr IeIITal(IIII CBaHon - O'IeUb
BbcoKcroplIorr H npOiRIIBaIOm;eM OTIIOCHTeJIblIO .n;aJIeKO K cenepO-3aIIa)J;Y
rpynnhI, ROToparr: )J;OJIrrma 6b1JIa 6hI B lIepnyIO Oqepe)J;b nO)J;BeprIIYTbcrr: ceBep-
EhBI BJIHHIIHHM, eCJlII 6hI OIIH 6bIJIH. no rHIIOTe3e ceBeplIoH nplIMeCII n co-
CTaBe IIpep:cTaBHTeJIeM KaBKaCHOIICKoro THna TeMlIarr: IIIIrMenTal(IIH CBaUOB
ne06'T,rr:cHH1.I8; C rrOllfOm;hIO rHnOTe3hI npe06JIa.D:aHHH pe eCCHBOB B YCJIOBIIHX
Il30JIHJ IIII OHa OO'brr:CIIIIMa BnOJIlIe, TaK KaK CTaTHCTIIqeCKIIH xapaRTep
ilaKOlIa H. 11. BaBHJIOBa lIe HCKJIIOQaeT, a, na060pOT, 1I0jJ,pa3YMeBaeT onpe-
)];e.rrelIlIoe 'IHCJIO CJIY IaeB OTKJIOlIelIHrr OT IIero. Calif 0 iRe OO'LHClIeIIHe IIO-
CneTJIelIHH IIHrMeHTa:qIIH II BhICOKoropHhIX KaBKa3CKHX IIapO)J;OB C IIOMOm;bIO
IIpOl(eCCOB, IIponCXO)J;IIBIIIIIX 6e3 y I8CTIIrr: KaKOrr-JIH60 IIpHMeCII, l1a6aB.'1HeT
lIac OT npOTHBOpe'I1IH C HCTopHKo-apXeOJIOrWIeCKHlIfH .n;aHlIhIMH. Meurr:eT Ta-
KaH TO IKa 3pelIHrr: II IICTopII IeCKYIO nepClIeKTHBY, OCB0601R)J;arr: OT IIelIpeMen-
HhIX IIOIICKOB ceBepnhIX CBH3eII, KOTOphIX MOrJIO BOOOm;e lIe 6hITb 57.
C alIaJIOrII I1IOrr cIITyal(Herr 1I3MelIeIUIH HCTOplI IeCKOrr IIInepnpeTal(HH
alITpOIIOJIOrWIeCJUIX IIaOJIIO)J;eIIIIiI IIpHXO.n;HTCH CTaJIKHBaTbcrr: IIa BaJIKalIaX
IIPH 3naJIII3e aIITpOnOJIOrH IeCKIIX oc06elIHOCTeiI HaCeJIelIIIH roplIhIX parrOIIOB
EOJIrapHH. OOm;aH alITpOnOJIOrWleCKaH C'beMKa Bo:rrapHH, npoWme (elIlIaH
M. nOIIOBhHf, BbIHBH:ra 30lIY neKoToporo nOCBeTJIelIHH IIHrMeIITal(lIH B oOJIa-
CTH POJJ:on 58. nOCRO.TJbKY MaTepUaJIhI, ROTophIe ony6J1IIKOBaJI M. nOnOB,
C06IIpaJIHCb opHra.n;orr II2MepHTe.rrerr, rrOCTOJIbKY OCTanaJ[OCh H3BeCTIIoe COMlIe-
IIHe B cpaBIIIIMOCTH c06palIIIoro H, CJIe.n;OBaTeJILHO, B 06'LeKTIfBnOCTH ::JToro
naomOJ],eIIHH. O)J;lIaKO 0110 6hIJIO 1I0)J;TBepmJJ:eII0 A. nYJIHIIOCOM, pa60TaBrnIIM
IIO rTII no Bcex parrOHax BOJIrapHH H co6paBrnIIM OOJILIIIOrr MaTepIIaJI no
alITpOnOJIOrIIrr OOJIrap, lIe BbI3bIBaIOm;IIn COMHelIHiI B cpaBHlIMOCTJI MeTo.n;H-
I
I,
82
RII, II B nepBYIO Oqepe,ZJ;b B onpe)J;eJIeHIIII OnIICaTeJIbHbIX npII3IIaKOB 59.
M. nOnOB HCTOJIKOBaJI nOCBeTJIeHHe nIIrllfeUTal(HII B PO,ZJ;onax KaK CJIeACTBlle
CJIaBHHCKoro IIJIH cppaKHHCKoro BJIHHHHH. npIf 3TOM OH OnHpaJICH IIa co06-
m;eIIHH )J;peBIIIIX aBTOpOB, nHcaBillIIX 0 TOM, 'ITO cppaKHH:qhl 6h1JIH OTnOCII-
TeJIblIO CBeTJIOrJIa3bI H CBeTJIOBOJIOCbI. 113 alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKHX cpaKTOB 6b1JI
CAeJIaH cym;ecTBelIlIhIM HCTOpHqeCKHM BhIBO)J;. .
O)J;llaKO eCJIH rOBopIITb 0 BJIHHIIHII CJIaBHII, TO 0110 )J;OJImIIO npOHBJIHTbCH
O)J;HIIaKOBO no BceH BOJIrapIIH, a lIe TOJIbKO B PO)J;onax, HlIaqe IIenOIIHTIIOH
CTaHOBHTCH CJIaBHIIOH3hl'IHOCTb Bcex 60JIrap. B KYJIbTyplIOM OTIIOillelIIIH 06-
JIaCTb Po;rron TaKme He 06IIaPYlliHBaeT ocoGo 3aMeTIIoro B03)J;eMCTBHH CJIaBf,fH-
CKOH KYJIbTypbI. fHnOTe3a cppaKHMCKoro BJIHHIIHH onHpaeTCH Ha )J;alIHhIe 0
CBeTJIOn [lIIr;\feUTa:qHII cppaKHrr:qeB, caMII no ce6e COMIIHTeJIblIhIe: pHlIfJIHne H
rpeKH cpaBIIIIBaJIII CPP3KHrrl(eB C HaCeJIelIHeM c06CTBelIIIOH pO)J;HlIhI, 3aHHlIfa-
IOm;HM ITO HIITelICHBIIOCTH U;BeTa BOJIOC, r.;la3 H ROiRII MeCTO, 6JIH3KOe K Rparr-
IIeMY B npe.D:eJIax EBponbI. ApeaJI, KOTOphIH 3alIHMaJIH cppaKHM:qbI, T3KiRe 3a-
CTaBJIHeT C IIe)J;OBepHellf OTlIeCTHCb K Co06lI\eIIHHM 06 IIX CBeT.jIOH nHrMelITa-
:qHH, HCXOAH H3 06m;HX alITpOITOJIOrWleCKHX co06paiRelIHM. B KparrlIeM CJIY-
qae MOiRlIO rOBopHTb 0 IIeKOTOpoM TeIIAelI:qHH K nOCBeTJIelIHIO nHrMeIITal(IIII,
a ee He)J;OCTaTOqIIO, qT06b1 06'bHCIIHTb alIaJIOrHqlIYIO oc06elIIIOCTb COBpe1len-
IIoro IIaCeJIelIHH B PO)J;onax. fHITOTe3a aBTOM3TH'IeCKOrO nOCBeTJIeHIIH B YCJIO-
BIIHX H30JIH:qIIH H36aBJIHeT Hac OT Bcex 3THX TPY)J;IIOCTeH, a O)J;HOBpeMeIIUO
OCB060iRAaeT H OT HCTOpH'IeCKOrO BblBOAa 0 KaKHX-TO cBoe06pa3IIbIX nYTHX
cpOpMHpOBalIHH 60JIrap B 06JIaCTH PO)J;on. IIx 3TIIH leCKoe cBoe06pa3He B H3hI-
Ke H RYJIbType lIe naCTOJILKO BeJIHKO, qT06hI onp3B)J;aTb TaKorr BhIBO.D:. TaKlIM
06p330M, II B )J;aIIIIOM cJIYqae, yqHTblBaH AenCTBHe 3aKOIIOMepIIOCTII, OTKpbI-
Toil H. II. BaBHJIOBhIM, 3aMelIHB Tpa)J;H:qHOIIHbIH nO)J;xo)J; relIoreorpacpHqeCKHlIf,
lIfbI B COCTOHIIHII 06'bHCIIHTb cpaKTbI H npHBeCTH HX B COOTBeTCTBHe .D:Pyr c
.n;pyrOM.
OTTECHEImE PEI(ECCIlBOB HA ORP ABHY APEAJIA
AlIaJIOrH'lHOe npe06JIa)J;alIHe pel(eCCHBHhIX 3.:'IJIeJIeli IIa OKp3HIIax OHKYlIfelIbI
MomHO npOCJIe,ZJ;HTb He TOJIbRO )J;JIH ITHrllfeHTa:qHH, 110 H )J;JIH MlIorHX )J;pyrHx
npH3HaKOB, IIaCJIe)J;CTBenHO AeTepMHIIIIpOn3IIHhIX MaJIbIlIf qIICJIOM relIOB.
npeiR)J;e Bcero CJIe)J;yeT 06paTIITbCH K TaKOH nOJIIIO H3Y leIIIIOH CHCTeMe re-
IIOB, KaK rpynnhI KpOBII ABO. npeAJIOiRelIlIaH em;e B cepe)J;IIHe 20-x rOD;OB
(D. BeplIillTeHIIOM rHnOTe3a IIaCJIe.D:OBaIIHH 3THX rpYITIT rrOJIb3yeTcH Bce06m;HM
npII3Ha1IIIeM.
Onpe)J;eJIelIIIe HaCJIe)J;CTBelIlIhIX cpaKTopOB KpOBII CHCTellfhI ABO BOrnJIO B
npaKTHKY aIITpOnOrelIeTH'IeCKHX HCCJIeJJ:OBaIIHrr C 1919 r. H IIaC IIITbIBaeT,
TaKHM 06pa30M, 60JIee nOJIYBeKa, 3a KOTopble ObI.:'IH 1I3Y lelIhI ThICH IH nOIIY-
JIHl(HH BO Bcex, )J;3iRe caMhIX 3a6pornelIlIbIx, yrOJIImx 3eMIIoro mapa. Co6-
palIlIhIe )J;alIHhIe n03BOJIIIJIH C03AaTb ITaHoHKYMeIIHhIe KapThI reorpacpH'IeCIWrO
pacnpe.D:eJIelIHH a.:'IJIeJIen. KOIITpOJIIIpYIOm;IIX CHCTellfY ABO 60. Ha 3TuX I{ap-
Tax OTqeTJIHBO BH)J;HbI O IarH KOII eIITpa nu II pa3peiRelIHH COOTBeTCTBYIOm;nx
aJIJIeJIeH, H OHII npe)J;CTaBJIHIOT IIeO eHHi.\lhIii IICTOqHHK HlIcpopMa HH AJIH ITO-
IIHMalIIIH relIoreorpacpIIqeCKOH npIIpO)J;bl Tex 3aKOIIOMepHocTeTi., KOTOpbIe
ynpaR7HIOT reorpacpH I€CKInf p3cnpeiJ,eJIeIIHei.\I ClTHX aJIJIe.rrerr.
PaCCMOTpelIIIe MlIoro pa3 ITy6JIHKOBaBilleHCH KapTbI pel(eCCIIBlIoro aJIJIeJIH
r (KOIITPOJIHpYIOm;ero lIaCJIe)J;OBalIHe rpynITbl 0) 06IIapymHBaeT COBeprnenlIO
OT leTJIHBYIO KapTHIIY. HaHMeHbrnaH KOII eIITpa HH 3Toro aJIJIeJIH naiJ,aeT IIa
:qelITpaJIblIhIe paHOlIbI EBpa3HII. n pe)J;JIaraJIOCb MlIoro rHITOTe3 0 :qelITpax
B03IIHRHOBelIIIH aJIJIeJIeH rpynIThI ABO. HeIWTophIe II3 3THX rIIITOTe3 IIMeJIH
IICXO)J;IIbIM nOJIOmelIHeM npe)J;CTaBJIelIHe 0 caMOCTOHTeJIblIOCTH :qeHTpOB
83
B03IInKIIOBelIHH aJIJIeJIH; aBTOphl TaKHX rHrrOTe3 BhI)J;eJIHJIH TPH nepBHqlIhle
pachl no rpynnal\I KpOBH: eBponeOHp;OB II rrerpOH)J;OB C rrpeOOJIa)J;alIHeM rpyn-
IIhJ A, a3uaTCKHX 1\I0IIrOJIOII,ll,OB C npe06JIa)J;aHHeM rpynrrhI B II aMepIIKaHOH-
.D:OE C npeOOJIa)J;alIHeM rpynnbI O. Hu oD;IIa H3 3TUX rIIITOTe3 He Mor.na, O)J;-
IIaKO, 060HTHCL 6e3 p;OrrOJIHIITeJIblIhIX npep;nOJIOmelIHH npH 06'bHClIeHHII
KOHl(eIITpa:qHH COOTBeTcTByrom;HX aJIJIeJIei! y MlIorIIX Hapop;OB 3e1\1JIII. npo-
THBOpe'IIIT TaI{8H nOCTalIOBKa Bonpoca n npep;CTaBJIeuHIO 0 eJ],HIICTRe HaCJIep;-
.cTReHHoro cpaKTopa, OHpep;emlIOm;ero HaCJIep;CTBeIIIIYIO nepep;a IY CHCTeMbI
ABU. MeiR.D:Y TeM CTOlIT JIHillb npHIIHTb rHnOTe3Y B03HHKIIOBeUHH Bcex
aJIJIeJIell 3Toro rella B l(eIITpaJIblIbIX paHolIax CTaporo CBeTa, p;OrrOJIIIHB ee
3aTel\I relIoreorpacpH IecKoH KOHl(enIJ.UeH H. n. BamfJIOBa,- H IIap;06uOcTb B
KaKHX -Jmoo )J;onOJIIIHTeJIbHbIX npep;nOJIOiRelIHHX OTna)J;aeT. HaUl\IelIbrnaH
KOIIl(eHTpal(IIH aJf.TIeJIH r B l(elITpe Ec>pa3IIu CTalIOBIlTCH nOIIHTHOIJ, TaK KaK
:eno O"Iar reHooopa30BalIIIH, B KOTOpOM iJ,OMIfHalITHble amIeJm npCOOJIa)J;aIOT.
no Mepe yp;a.TJeHHH OT 3Toro o rara BO Bcex HanpaBJIeIIIUIX KOIIl(eIITpa:qIIH
aJL'IeJUI r nOCTerreHHO B03paCTaeT. B EBpone olla BCJIUKa Ha caMOM c;:cspe
Chau,rIlIlIaBIUI, B IIpJIalI)J;Hu, B rrpn6pemHhIx pai!olIax 3arrap;IIOH EBporrhI; olla
3al\IeTIIO IIo)J;CKaKHBaeT B AcppuKe, OCOOelIITO B l(eIITpaJIbI-IhIX pai!olIax, r.D:e
B YCJIOBHHX TpOnH'IeCKOrO JIeca npe)J;IIOCbIJIKH JJ:JIH H30JIH:qIIH H npOHBJIelIIIH pe-
:qeccuBlIoro aJIJIe.'IH ocooelIlIo BeJIIIKH.
TaK me pe3Ko KOH:qeIITpa:quH YBeJIH'IHBaeTCH B CeBcplIOII A3HU H B AB-
CTpaJIIIH. npII'IJIlIa 3Toro YBeJIIl IeHIUI HClIa: rro Mepe yp;aJIelIHH OT oqara
reHo06pa30BalIIIH BhIm;enJIelIIfe pe ecCIfBlIoro aJI.:'IeTIH npoHcxoiJ,lI1' Bce c 60JIb-
mell IfHTenCIfBIIOCTbIO. OcooeHHO pe3KO 31'0 3al\IeTHO IIa AMepIIKalICKOM :\IaTe-
pm;:e, rp;e ero KOHJJ,eHTpa IUI CTalIOBHTCH rrO.D:aBJIHIOm;elI. B OOJIbrnIfIICTBe
nonymIl(Hi! IJ;eIITpa.;ILnOII H IOiRlIOii AMepHKH, B HaII60JIbrneH yp;aJIeuHOCTIf
OT O Iara relIoo()pa30BaIIHH. pe eCCHBUbIH aJIJIeJIb nO ITlI IIOJIIIOC1'bIO BhITeCnHJI
p;OMHHanTlIhIe II KOII eHTpa HH ero OJIH3Ka HJIH p;ame COCTaBJIHeT 100%.
TaI>:Hl\I oopa30M, 011 3alIHJI TO nOJIOiRelIHe, KaKoe rre 3arrHl\IaIOT B l(eHTpe
oiiu,Yl\IeHhI p;ame jJ,Ol\IHlIalITlIbIe aJIJIeJIH. KapTHlIa rrOCJIeJ],OBaTeJIbIIOrO IIa-
paCTaHHH KOII:qeIITpa:qIIH 3Toro aJIJIeJIH 01' :qelITpa K rrepHcpepHH HaCTOJIbKO
JIOnI IHa If npaBIIJIblIa, IIaCTOJIbKO lIe CO,JepmHT HCKJIIO IelInII, £ITO TPYP;IIO OT-
.D:C.taTbCH 01' l\IbICJIII: B reorpacpH'IeCKOl\I pacnpOC1'palIelIHH a.:fJIeJIerr CIICTeMbI
ABO HBJIenne OTTeCIICIIHH pe eCCHBOB H3 l(elITpa reHoo6pa30BalImI IIrpaJIO
pemaIOm;yIO pOJIb.
CnCTel\Ia ABO - He e)J;HIICTBelIlIaH, K 06'bHClIeIIIIIO reorpacpHII KOTOpOH
MC mllo C ycrreXOl\I npHBJIe'Ib 3aKOII H. II. BaBHJIOBa. He Mellee )J;eMOIIC'rpaTIIB-
ITO B 3TOM OTlIcrnelIHH reOrpa(I>II IeCKOe pacnpe)J;eJIeHHe aJIJIeJIeii, p;eTepMHHH-
pYlOm;HX nepep;aT=y no IIaCJIep;CTBY rpyrrn KpOBH P. fell oopa3yeT p;Ba aJIJIe-
JIH - P H p, If3 IWTOPhIX P HBJIHeTCH )J;OMHlIaIITlIhIM. KOIIl(eIITpa:qHH 3THX
amTeJIeH II3Y IelIa B MelIbilleM 'IHC.:'Ie nonYJIH HH rro cpaBlIelIuIO C KOIIl(eIITpa-
nci! aJIJICJIelI CIICTeMbl ABO, IJ rrOTOxIY KapThI HX reorpacpIf'IeCKOro pac-
npe)J;eJIelIHH Mellee nO)J;pOOlIhI. O CIIX nop nYOJIHKOBaJIHCL JIHillL KapThI reo-
rpacpnII aJIJIeJIH P 01, 110 IIPII aBTOMaTlIqeCROH 3aBHCIfMOCTH, KOTopaH cym;e-
cTByeT Memp:y KOIIl(eIITpal(HHMH P II p, KapTa aJIJIeJIH p 6Y)J;eT nepeBeplIYTOH
RonHeH YiRe onYOJIHKOBalIlIbIX KapT. CeHqaC KOJIH IeCTBO )J;aHlIhIX ;ma nITe.lIL-
110 YBe.'1II'IUJIOCb (pIIC. 4). :qeIlTp KOIIl(elI1'pa IIH )J;Ol\lIIlIaUTIIOro aJIJIeJIH P-
AcpPuKalIcKulI MaTepHK. B EBporre, nepe)J;IIei! II IOiRIIOi! A3HII yp;eJILlIhIii Bec
)J;OIlIHnalITlIoro H pel(eCCHBlIoro aJIJIeJIeH npIIo.'1H3IITeJIbII0 op;HnaKOB. Ho
KOJTl(eIITpal(IIH nOCJIep;HerO pe3KO B03paCTaeT B OT.D:eJIblIbIX rpyrrrrax KopelIlIhIX
3BCTpaJIHluJ,eB, no Bcei! HOBoi! fBIIIIee, y CHOHpCRIIX IIfOlIrOJIOHp;OB, no BceMY
ceBepy CeBeplIoH AMepHKH. nOCKOJIbKY pe eccHBlIbli! aJIJIeJIb IIHrJJ:e He yc-
neJI BbITeCHHTb )J;OMHlIaIITlIbIn nOJIIIOCTbIO, KaK 3TO OhIJIO B CHCTCMe ABO,
84
'60 150
/
40
, -
\\
-. "':..
a
01
@)2
()3
4
.5
'50
40
Poco 4. reorpacPH'IeCKHe BapHaIJ;IIO aJIJIeJIH' p (B %)
I - '),2- 30,5; :! -- 0,6-('('.9; 3 - (,5.0-59.3; 4 - 59,4-73,7; 5 - 73,8-88,1
,
I
i
;
,
l
1 10
I
I
,
t
B :qeHTpaJIblIhlX n: IOmHbIX panollax CeBeplIoii. AMepIIKH, B [(elITpaJIblIOn
AMepIIRe, y HeRoTopbIX n:II)J;eHcRIIx rpynn IOmlIoH AMepHKn: ROH:qeIITpa:qn:H
pe:qeccIIBHoro aJIJIeJIH onHTb nOHHmaeTCH, a ROH:qeIITpa:qHH .n;OMHHaUTlIoro no-
BbrrnaeTCH .n;o ypOBHH eBponencKIIx BeJIH'llfII.
IIO-Bn:.n;IIMOMY, B reorpacpIfII OT)J;eJIblIbIX aJIJIeJIeH IIapH,ZJ;y C relloreorpacpn-
qeCKHMH 3aRolIoMeplIocTHMH H3BecTIIYIO pOJIb IIrpaeT XpOIIOJIOrII IecKIIH MO-
MeIIT, 3rroxa IIX nOHBJIeIIHH, T. e. Y)J;aJIeHIIOCTb cooTBeTcTBYIOm;eH MYTa:qHII
OT cOBpeMelIlIocTH, II BpeMH, IIe06xo)J;H1\fOe IIa npoTeKalIHe Te I1.:'III IlIIhlX
relIoreorpacpII I€CKIIX rrpo:qeCCOB. He HCKJIIO IeIIO, qTO CTenelIb H30.:'IHl(IIH,
B KOTOpOH Haxop:IIJIHCb no OTIIOilielIHIO .n;pyr K )J;pyry IIII)J;eHcKHe II.'IeMelIa
CillA H [(eHTpaJIbHOH AMepHKH, MelIbrne, IeM B KaHa)J;e, qTO npH coxpalIe-
HIIII B ,ZJ;OCTaTOqIIOM npo:qeHTe CJIY IaeB )J;OMHlIalITlIoro aJIJIeJIH P oc.'1aOIIJIO
TeMn BhIm;enJIeIIHH pe eccHBlIoro aJIJIeJIH H rrOBeJIO K rroBToplIoMy YBeJIIIqe-
HIIIO KOII:qeIITpa:qIIH P. K COmaJIeIIHIO, MbI nOKa JIHilielIhI B03MOa{HOCTH cy-
.n;HTb CROJIbKO-IIH6y.n;b TOqlIO 0 BpeMelIH B03IIHKIIOBelIIIH OT)J;eJIblIhlX rpynn
RpOBn: H Bo06m;e Tex ITJIII HHhIX BapHa n:H CPH3HOJIOrHqeCRHX npH3IIaKOB. B03-
Bpam;aHCb K KOIIKpeTlIoH reorpacpHH rpynnbI KpOBH P, MomHO 3aTO CKa3aTb C
nOJIIIOH orrpe.n;eJIeIIIIOCTbIO, qTO B yCJIOBIIHX pe3KoH, rrO'ITH nOJIIIOII II30.'I HII,
B RaRHX .n;o He)J;aBlIero BpeMeHH IIaXO)J;HJIHCb TaeiRubIe IIapO)J;hI CnoIlpn II )J;O
CHX nop HaXO)J;HTCH IIaCeJIelIHe HOBOII rBIIlIeH, ROII eIITpa:qHH peIJ,eCCHBlIoro
aJIJIeJIH p pe3Ro nO)J;cKaKIIBaeT. HaJIH:qo, CJIe.D:OBaTeJIbIIO, Ta me 3aKolIoMep-
BOCTb OTTeCHeHIIH pe:u;eCCIIBa H3 :qelITpa relI006pa30BaIIHH II KOH eIITpa:qIIH
ero Ha nepn:cpepn:H.
nepe)J;aqa no HaCJIe)J;CTBY CIICTeMhI rpyrrrrhI KpOBH KeJIJI .n;eTepMIIHIIpyeT-
CH, KaK H P, .D:BYMfl aJIJIeJIHMH, II3 KOTOphIX K-)J;OMHlIaIITubIII II K-
pe:qeCCHBlIbIH. KOII eIITpa:qHH .n;OMHlIaIITIIOrO aJIJIeJIH .n;ame B Tex IIorrYJIH-
:qHHX, ROTOpbIe OTJIIIqaIOTCH ero MaKCHMaJIbuOH qaCTOTOII, O IelIb neBeJIHKa II
COCTaBJIHeT 4-5 % (TOJIbKO B O.n;IIOM CJIyqae - 12 % ). B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3TH:\f
BeJIlIRa, Ha060poT, BepOHTHOCTb CJIyqaHlIoft nOTepII .n;OMHlIaHTlIoro aJI.:'IeJIH H
3allfeHbI ero pe:u;eccn:BHbIM. ha BepOHTIIOCTb BO Mlloro pa3 60JIbrne, IeM B
npe.n;bI.D:ym;HX CJIyqaHX, KOr.D:a p:O:\fIIIIaIITlIhIe relIh! B :qelITpax IIaII6o.'IbIUeH
CBoeH ROH:qeHTpa:qIIII 6bIJIH xapaKTeplIhI _ ,ZJ;JIH nOJIOBHlIhI HJIII 60JIbilielI £IaCTH
norryJIfl:qHH. Bce iRe H B 3TOM CJIyqae reorpacpHqeCKOrO pacnpeD;eJIelIIIH pe-
:qeCCIlBlIoro aJIJIeJIH 06IIapymHBaIOTcH BnOJIlIe OT IeTJIHBbIe npaBHJIbHOCTH 62
(pIIC. 5). HaHMelIbrnaH KOIIl(eIITpa HH ero IIa)J;aeT Ha IIaCeJIelIIIe EBporrbI,
f)J;e Haxop:HTCH elITp IIaH60JIbilierO ypOBIIH )J;OMllIIalITlIoro aJIJIeJIfl, a BO Bce
IIanpaBJIelIHHX OT 3Toro elITpa IIapaCTaeT yp:eJIbIIbIH Bec pe eCCIIBlIoro
aJIJIeJIH, B nO.D:aBJIHIOm;eM 60JIbrnHIICTBe rronYJIH:qHH COCTaBJIHIOm;erO 100%
relIocpoH)J;a nonYJIH HH. ABa IICKJIIOqeHIIH H3 3Toro npaBHJIa -6YIIIMelIhI II
HII.D:eHl(bI Bpa3HJIHH - He MelIHIOT 06m;eH RapTHHbI, TaK RaR relIoreorpacpII-
qeCKIIe 3aKoHoMepHocTH, KaK yme yKa3hIBaJIOCb, npe)J;cTaBJIHIOT C060H BbI-
pamelIHe BepoHTlIoCTHhIX CTaTIICTIIqeCKHX npo:qeccoB, npH KOTOpbIX IIeH30eiR-
IIhI oT)J;eJIbHbIe CJIY IaHHhIe OTKJIOlIeHIIH OT OClIoBlIon TelIJJ:elIl(HH.
reorpacpIIH rpynrrbI KpOBH JIIOTepaII H3Y IeHa TaKme He O IeHb nOJIIIO,
KaR H TOJIbKO qTO pa306palIHOH rpynrrbI KpOBH Ke::IJI, qTO CBH3alI0 C HX
cpaBIIIfTeJIblIO IIe)J;aBIIHM OTKpbITHe1\1. Bce iRe 06m;ee npe)J;CTaBJIeHIIe 0 reo-
rpacpIPIeCKOM pacnpeJJ:eJIelIIIH aJIJIeJIeH rella, onpeJJ:eJIHIOm;erO naCJIeJJ:CTBelI-
IIYIO nepe)J;aqy rpyrrnbI KpOBH JIIOTepalI, MomllO COCTaBHTb na OCIIOBalIIIII yme
ony6JIHKOBaHIIhIx )J;aHHbIX (pHC. 6). 8THX aJIJIeJIeH )J;Ba - Lu a H Lu b , H3 KO-
TOphIX nepBbIH JJ:OMHlIaHTelI. Ero MaRCHMaJIblIaH KOII eIITpal(HH lIe npeBhIIIIa-
eT 8-9 %, H n03TOMY no OTIIOilielIIIIO K nellfY OCTaeTCH cnpaBe)J;JIH1IbIlIf Bce
TO, qTO CKa3alI0 BbIIIIe 0 B03MomlIOCTH CJIY IaHIIOrO HCqe3IIOBelIIIH aJIJIeJIH
I
86
0___\
' \ --
_/
.5 /-
40
01
I 2
i ()3
L__
40
..
o
1)4
150
-"
",
120
40
a
PHC. 5. reorpacPH'IeCKlIe BaplIaIJ;IIH aJIJIeJIH K (B %)
I - <97,0; 2 - 97,0-97,9; 3 - 98,0-98,9; 4 - 99,0-99,9; 5 -100,0
40
40
//
v... ...
01
2
()3
4
85
PIIc. 6. reorpacPrr'leCKHe BaplIaqlIlI aJIJIeJIH Lu B (B Qlo)
, - <93,9; 2 - 94,0-95,9; a - 96,0-97,9; 4 - 98,0-99,9; 5 - 100,0
. .
.. '.
-.--- . ' -...
.-
.. , '"'. n_ ,..' '_
R. U:eHTp ROH eHTpa HH aJIJIeJIH Lu a - EBpona H AcppIIKa, 3a IICKJIIOqeIIM-
eM IOmlIbIX paHOHOB. HaCeJIelIHe ceBeplIbIx H :qelITpaJIblIhIX paHOIIOB A3IIaT-
CKoro MaTepHKa, K cOiRa.rreuuIO, nOKa O IeHb nJIOXO II3Y IeII0 na rrpe)J;MeT
KOUIJ,€IITpa:qHH aJIJIeJIeM Lu a II Lu b . Ho B IOmlIOH A3HH H B ABCTpaJIHH, IIa
lOre ACPPHKH, B CeBeplIoH H IOmlIoH AMeplme Y)J,eJIblIbIH Bec pel(eCCHBHoro
aJI.'1eJIH pe3KO YBeJIH'IlIBaeTCH, )J;OXO)J;H BO MlIorHX nonYJIHl(HHX )J,O nOJIIIOrO,
CTonpo eUTlIoro BbITeClIeHHH HM )J,OMHlIalITHoro aJIJIeJIH. 8TO onHTb cJIyqaii
3Ha IITTeJIbIIOrO npe06JIa)J;alIHH KOII eIITpa:qHH pel(eCCHBlIoro aJIJIeJIH Ha ne-
plHpepHH rro cpaBlIelIHIO C B03MOiRubIM eHTpOM rerro06pa30BanHH, r)J,e no-
BbIIITeIIO, IIa060pOT, OTIIOCHTeJIblIOe CO)J;epi-lmIIHe B relIocpolI)J,e nonYJIHl(HH )J;O-
MHlIaHTIIOH cpOpMbI.
CIIcTeMa rpYIITlhI KpOBH JIbIOHC II3yqelIa reorpacpIIqeCKH em;e 60JIee IIe-
rromro, qeM )J;Be npe)J,bI;J:yIIJ;He. KapTa reorpacpH recKoro pacrrpe)J,eJIeHHH aJI-
.:'IeJIeM TaKiRe IIanOMHHaeT npe)J;bI)J;ym;He, 110 KaR 6bI B 3epKaJIblIOM oT06pa-
iReHILII (pIIC. 7): pe:qeccHBlIhIH aJIJIeJIb Le" KOII:qeHTpHpyeTcH B EBpone,
TOr.D:a KaK [10 BceH OCTaJIblIOH oHKYMelIe npe06JIa)J,aeT .D:OMHlIaHTHbln aJIJIeJIb,
B ABCTpaJIHII II AMepHKe )J,OCTHraH B cBoeH KOIIl(eIITpa:qHH 100 %. Ha nep-
BhIli B3rJIHD: 3)J;eCb IIapyrnaeTcH YCTalIOBJIelIHaH H. II. BaBHJIOBbIM 3aROHO-
MepIIOCTb, HO TaKoe BneqaTJIelIIIe MOiReT OhITb II 06l\faI-I IHBbIM, eCJIH yqeCTb,
qTO rJIaBlIbIM rrpH paccMoTpelIHH rrpaBHJIbHOCTeH B reorpacpH recKoM pacnpe-
)J,eJIeIIHII relIOB HBJIHeTCH lIe o:qeHKa l(elITpaJIblIhlX H nepIIcpepIIqeCKHX pan-
OHOB oHKYMelIhI Bo06m;e, a BbI,ll,eJIelIHe rrepIIcpepIIqeCKIIX paiioHoB no OTlIome-
HHIO K :qelITpaM relI00opa30BalIIIH. Momllo C)J,eJIaTb npe)J;nOJIOmeIIHe, qTO B
IIOCJIe)J;IIeM CJIy rae :qeIITpOM oblJIa TeppHTopIIII, IIanpHMep, IOiRlIOH II IOro-
BOCTOqHOn A3HH. OTTY)J,a HCXO)J;naH Konl(eIITpal(HH (100% HJIH nOqTII Ta-
haH iRe KOII:qenTpal(IIH )J,OMHHaIITlIoro aJIJIeJIH) 6bIJIa nepenecella B AMepH-
hY II ABCTpaJIHIO. n pH CTOIIpo:qeIITIIOM npeOOJIa)J,alIHII )J,OMIIITarrTlIoro aJIJICJIH
He C03)J;aeTCH, eCTeCTBeIIIIO, IIHKaKIIX npe)J;I10CbIJIOK )J;JIH Bblm;eIIJIeIIIIH pe:qec-
CIIBil B YCJIOBIIHX H30JIH:qHII rrpOCTO B CHJIY ero OTCYTCTBHH. TaM iRe, r,ll,e
c.'Iy raHlIo 011 ORa3aJICH npe)J;cTaBJIelIlIbIM XOTH OhI B MaJIOM npo:qelITe CJIY-
qaeB B IIcxo)J,IIOn rpyrrrre, H30JIH:qIIH, )J,ame OTIIOCIITeJIbHaH, cpa3Y me IIpl'I-
BO):(IIT K YBeJIII IeIIIIIO ero Y)J;eJIbIIOrO Beca. npHMep TOMY - )J,aHKH BoplIeo,
HBalI:qbI II MaopH. IIcxQ)J;IIbIe rpynrrbI, 3aCeJIHBmHe EBpony, o reBII)J,Ho, TaKme
!DfeJII! KaKoH-To, nycTb OqelIb IIe60JIbmOM, npo:qeHT pe:qeccIIBHoro aJIJIeJIH.
ECJIII paccMaTpHBaTb IOiRlIYIO II IOro-BoCTOqIIYIO A3HIO KaK :qelITp )J,OMI'I-
IIilHTlIhIX MYTa HH, TO EBpona B npe)J,eJIax CTaporo CBeTa, ROlIeqIIO, npe)J,-
CTaBJIHeT C060H [10 OTlIomelIHIO K 3TOMY :qelITpy rrepIIcpepIIIO. 8THM, rrO-BI'I-
JJIMOMY, II MomllO 06'bHCHHTb 3IIaqHTeJIbHOe H nOBceMeCTHoe B EBpone
nOBbImelIIIe raCTOTbI pe:qeccHBlIoro a.rr.:IeJIH. 0 pacnpe)J;eJIeHHH ero B AcppII-
fie B :qeJIOM CY)J;HTb TPY)J,IIO H3-3a He)J,oCTaTKa )J,alIlIbIx, HO n-erpbI 3ana)J,IIOR
AcppIIKH C6JIHmaIOTCH C eBponeiicKHMII IIapo,ZJ;aMH.
AlIaJIOrH II10e paccym)J;elIHe npe)J,cTaBJIHeTCH BrrOJIHe npaBOMepHbIM H
;:I.-III 06'bHClIeIIHH reorpacpIIqeCKOrO pacrrpe)J;eJIelIHH aJIJIeJIeH rpynnbI RpOBI'I
LJ:aCPCPH (pIIC. 8). ECJII'I :qeIITpOM MYTIIpOBaHIIH 3Toro rella H, CJIe)J,OBaTeJIb-
HO, :qeIITpOM KOII:qeHTpa:qHII ero ,ZJ;OMHIIaIITHoro aJIJIe.:'IH C'II'ITaTb IOiRlIYIO
II IOro-BoCTOqIIYIO A3HIO, TO JIerKO npe)J;CTaBIITb ce6e, ITO HCXO)J;HaH KOII-
n:eIITpa:qIIH OblJIa nepelIecelIa B AMepIIKY H ABCTpaJIHIO, r)J;e I'I COXpalIHJIaCb
.:10 IIaCTom:qero BpeMelIII. OTTeClIelIIIe pe:qeCCIIBlIoro aJIJIeJIH Ha nepHcpepIIIO
B CTapOM CBeTe BhI3BaJIO 3IIaqHTeJIblIOe CIIIImelIIIe raCTOTbI )J,OMHlIaHTHoro
II YBeJIIIqelIHe KOII eIITpal( I pe:qeCCIIBHoro aJIJIeJIeH B EBpone H oc06eHIIO
B AcppIIKe. B AcppIIKe 0110 em;e 60JIee 3aMeT1I0, qeM B EBpone. E,ZJ;IIHCTBeH-
HhL\f HCRJIIOqelIIIeM H3 3Toro npaBIIJIa HBJIHIOTCH CaaMbI IIa KpaHlIeM CeBepe
EBponbI, HO CJIe)J,bI IIX 3aBe)J,OMO BOCTOTfHOrO npOIIcxom)J,eHI'IH npOHBJIHIOTCH
89
150
40
40
\ \\
- - - \
/
o
@).
. "t::>:
---
0'
4
@)2
85
()3
150 40 40
160 150
PRC. 7. reorpacPnqeCKlIe BaplIaIllI1I aJIJIeJIH Lea (B %)
1 - 0-13,4; 2 - 13,5-26,9; a - 27,0-40,4; 4 - 40,5-53,9; IJ - 54,0-67,4
o
/
-. .
., . .
MO '
>- ,
. --
-
.
..,..,... . .,
-
- . . ' . ".- . , . ...... r . ...,...".. . . . . , .
o
o
Puc. 8. reorpacPlI'IeCKl1!e BaplIan;1I11! aJIJIeJUI FyB (B %)
J - 0-19,9; 2 - 20,0-39,9; 8 - 40,0-59,9; 4 - 60,0-79,9; 5 - >80,0
I
I
II B ,Z:\pyrIIx npII3HaKax KaK fOpq,OJIOrIPIeCKOrO, TaK II CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKOrO no-
pH,Z:\Ka. He IfCKJIIO'IeIIO, '1TO HeI;:OTopoe nOHUiReHIIe 'IaCTOTbI pe eccIIBHoro
a.:'IJIeJIH B EBpone rro cpaBrreUIIIO C Aq,pmwii: TRKiRe OOH3ano CBOIIM npoIIc-
XOIR)JeHIIeM 60JIee TeCIIbIM KOHTaKTaM C BOCTOqIIbIMII MOHrOJIOII)JHbIMII norry-
JIH:qIIHMII.
AaHHhIe 0 reorpa(!mqeCI1:0M pacrrpoCTpaHeHIIu rpyrrilbI KpOBU KII)J:I
IIeJIb3H UCrrOJIb30BaTb U3-3a ux rreilOJIHOTbI U q,parMeHTapHocTII. reorpaq,IIH
reHa, onpe)JeJIHIOm;erO naCJIe,Z:\CTBeHHYIO nepe,Z:\a'IY rpyrrnbI KpOBII Allero,
ero rrpenMym;ecTBeIEIaH KOII eHTpa IIH B ,Z:\oMIIHaHTHoH q,opMe B IJ.eHTpaJIb-
IIoii: II IOmHoii: AMepIIKe cBHiIeTeJIbCTByIOT 0 ero cpaBHIITeJIbHO rr03)J,HeM
B03HIIKIIOBeHIIII B rrpe;J;eJIax AMepUKII. yiRe nOCJIe rrepeCeJIeHIIH 3UaqIITeJIb-
IIhIX Macc IIaCeJIeUIIH Ha AMepuKaHcKIIii: MaTepIIK. B ,Z:\06aBJIeHUe KO BceMY
yme CKa3aHIIOMY 0 reorpaq,UqeCKOM pacrrpocTpalIeHIIII rpynnoBbIX q,aKTopoB
KpOBII no 3eMHoH nOBepXIIOCTII [] 0 rrOA'I1IHeHuIf ero reHoreorpacpIPI€CKoii:
3aKoHo IepHocTII, OTKpbITOH H. II. BaBIIJIOBbIM, IIIOiRHO npIIBecTII em;e O;:UIH
KOCBelIlIhIH apryMeuT, oTpamaIOm;IIlrcH Ha reorpaq,IIII CUCTeMbI MN II 6eJI-
Kon CbIBOpOTKII - ranTOrJIOOIIlIoB. II rpyrrrrhI KpOBII CIICTeMbI MN, U ran TO-
rJIOOUHbI IfMeIOT CXO;:J:HbIii: nin Hac.;ren:onaHIIH, 0Y)JyqII ,ZJ;eTepMIIlIupOBalIbI
,ZJ;BYMH KO)J;OMIIHaHTIIhIl\III a,.JIeJIHMII, T. e. aJIJIeJIHMU, KOTopbIe lIe no,Z:\aBJIHIOT
,Z:\pyr ,Z:\pyra. B OTuorneHIIU 3TIIX cnCTeM IIeJIb3H rr03TOMY rOBopIITb 0 .Il;OMII-
HalITHbIX IIJIII pe eccHBlIbIX aJIJIeJIHX. O'IeBII,Z:\HO, eCJIlI npe,Z:\rrOJIaraTb BJIIIH-
Hue nepncpepUqeCKOrO nOJIOiReHHH 3THII'IeCKUX rpyrrn II II30JIH IIII IIa 3TU
CIICTeMbI, ero CJIe,Z:\yeT OfKII,Z:\aTb B YBeJIII'IeHIIII AOJIlI OI(HOH II3 rOM03IIrOT
IIJIII 06eIIX BMeCTe. Ha reorpacpIPI€CKOH RapTe aJIJIeJIeii: rarrTol'JI06HHa BII)1-
110 3UaqUTeJIbHOe yneJIUqeHIIe npO eHTIIOii: AOJIII o,Z:\uoro II3 aJIJIeJIeH B Ce-
BepHOH A3UH, B ceBepHbIX paii:oHax CeBeplIOH AMepIIKU, IIa HOBon fBII-
uee 63. HaooopoT, ImII eIITpa IIH ,ZJ;pyroro aJIJIeJIH rro;:t;CKaKIIBaeT IIa rrooe-
peiRbe 3anaJJ;HoH AcpPIIKII, B elITpaJIblIbIX panollax AcppIIKaHcKoro MaTepIIRa,
B IJ;eHTpaJIbHoii: AMepIIKe. Bce 3TO paii:olIbI, II30JIIIpOBaHIIbIe JIII60 reorpa-
cpIIqeCKII" JIII60, ,Z:\O ne.Il;aBHerO BpeMeHII, CO IIaJIbHO.
To me II C CIICTeMOH MN. AJIJIeJIb ill ROII:qeHTpIIpyeTcH B COCTaBe KopelI-
Horo IIaCeJIeHUH 06eIIx AMepIIK, AOCTIIraH MaKCIIMYMa y IIHn:eH eB IOra CllA,
IJ;eIITpaJIbHoii: AMepIIKII, ceBepHbIX rocy,Z:\apCTB IOmHoii: AMepuKII. MaKcII-
MYM KOH enTpa uu aJIJIeJIH n rraAaeT IIa KopeHlIoe HaCeJIelIIIe AncTpaJIIIII,
3aTeM u,Z:\eT naceJIelIue Aq,pIIKU. Bce OCTaJIbHbIe panOIIhI 3eMHoro mapa
C pa3BIIToII ropo,Z:\cKOH IIBUJIII3a IIeH, C ropa3,Z:\0 60JIee IIIITeHCIIBlIbIMII B
IIeJIOM CBH3HMII Memn:y 3THIIqeCKIIMII rpyrrrraMu 3aHIIMaIOT rrpOMeiRYTOqlIOe
IIOJIOiReHIIe MeiR,Z:\y 3TIIMII ,Z:\BYMJJ uOJIIOCaMII.
l:lTaK, 3aKOH H. II. BaBIIJIOBa npIIMeHIIM He TOJIbRO K 06'bHClIeHIIIO reo-
rpaq,IIqeCKOrO pacrrpe.D:e,.eHIIH rrIIrMeHTa IIII y qeJIOBeKa, HO II K reorpaq,IIII
rpynrr KpOBlI. OYPHO pa3BIIBaIOm;eii:cH B nOCJIeAHIIe 20-30 JIeT II ,Z:\aBmelI
60JIbllIOe KOJIII'I€CTBO cBe,Z:\eIIIIH, HIIKor,Z:\a, IIaCROJIbKO Mile II3BeCTHO, He pac-
CMaTpIIBaBrnIIXCH B paMKax 3Toro 3aKOHa. C nOMOm;bIO 3aKOHa H. 11. Ba-
BII,.OBa, KaK MbI y6e,Z:\IIJIIICb, JIerKO 06'bHCIIHIOTCH MHorIIe cpaRTbI relloreorpa-
cpUU qe.:'IOBeKa, II, 60JIee Toro, B 3TIIX cpaKTax 011 rrOJIY'IaeT ROBoe, OqelIb
yoe,Z:\UTeJIbHOe HO,Z:\TBepm,Z:\eHIIe. B BhIcrnelI CTenelIU rrepcneKTUBIIOH npeL\-
CTaBJIHeTCH ,Z:\aJIbHeii:rnaH pa3paOOTKa 3Toro 3aKOHa IIa aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKml
MaTepIIaJIe.
I
,
t
,
I
I
92
rOMOJIOrIPIECRHE PH)J:LI
B HACJIE)J:CTBEHHOII H3MEHQlIBOCTII
OTKpbITIIe II q,OPMYJIlIpOBIm 3aKOlIa rOIlIOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX pH,o:OB B IIaCJIeACTBeH-
HOii: II3MeIl'IlIBOCTII - lIepBoe lIa BpeMeJU1 II a,o:HO I13 lIaIl60JIee 6JIeCTHm;IIX
,o:OCTIIiReHlIH H. II. BaBIIJIOBa B TeOpenI IeCKoii: 6IIOJIOrIIII. 8Ta cpOpMy.1JUpOB-
Ra, BlIepBbIe IIP03BY IaBrnaH C TPII6YHhI III BcepoccIIHcKoro C'be3,o:a Ce.:'IeK-
I10HepOB, COCTOHBrnerOCH B CapaToBe B 1920 r.,6blJIa 3Ha'IIITeJIbII0 yrJIy6JIe-
IIa B ,o:aJIblIeHmeM, aprYMeHTIIpOBalIa He TaJIbRO orpOMHbIM KOJIl1 I€CTBaM
IIa6JIIO,ll,eHIIii: Ha,o: lIapaJIJIeJIbHoii: 1I3MeIl'IHBOCTbIO BII,ZJ;OB II pac KYJIbTypHbIX
pacTeHIIii:, 110 II y6e;J,IITeJIbHbIMII IIpIIMepaMII alIaJIOrIIqlIoii: U3MeHqHBOCTU
Y ,o:IIKIIX paCTeHIIH II Y iRIIBOTHbIX 6\ 3aKOH rOMOJIOrIlqeCKIIX PHAOB B,o:OXIIO-
BIIJI IICCJICJJ:OBaTeJIeH Ha IIOIICKU TaKIIX pH;rrOB Y caMbIX pa3JIII lHbIX apranII3MaB,
B caMbIX pa3HbIx, ,o:aJIeKO OTCTOHm;I1X ,o:Pyr OT ,o:pyra BeTBHX OpraIIIIqeCKOrO
Mllpa II n03BOJIuJI IIOKa3aTb ropa3,o:o 60JIee rnIIpOKae, IeM npe,o:lIOJIaraJI calif
H. n. BaBIIJIOB, pacnpOCTpaHeHIIe rO;\IOJIOrIPIecKaii: I13MeJI'IIIBOCTII 65. npII-
'IIIHM ee, JIeiRam;I1ii: B ocnOBe ee MexanII3M CHaqaJIa lIe 6blJIII HCHb! aBTOpy
3aKOHa II3-3a orpalIUqenIIbIX B03MomnOCTeu TeOpeTHqeCKOU 6I10JIOrIIII B Ha-
qaJIe 20-x ro,o:OB, 110 B KOH e cBoeli HaY'IHOH ,o:eHTeJIbllOCTI1 OH HIICaJI:
«npIIpO)J;a 3TOH rOMOJIOrIIqeCKoii: II3MelI IIIBOCTII 3aKJIIOqaeTCH, IIO HameMY
IIOIIIIMaIIIIIO, npem,o:e Bcero B pO)J;cTBe, B e,o:IIHCTBe reueTIIqeCKoii: CTPYKTYPbI
6JIIImaHrnIIx BU,o:OB II pO,o:OB. C ,o:Pyroii: CTOpOHbI, olla HBJIHeTCH pe3YJIbTa-
TaM ,o:eii:cTBIIH YCJIOBIIii:, oT60pa B olIpe,o:eJIelIlIOM HalIpaBJIeHIIII, B olIpe,o:eJIeH-
IIbIX YCJIOBIIHX» 66. HeCKOJIbKIIMII CTpaqKaMII ,o:aJIbme B TOii: iRe pa60Te OH
BbIpa3I1JICH em;e 60JIee OlIpe,ll,eJIeHHO 0 HE.:'IenIlHX rOMOJIOrIIqeCKoii: U3"'IenqU-
BOCTII: «B O,o:IIIIX CJIY IaHX OIIII IIMeIOT IIO)], c060ii CBOHCTBO relIOB, a B rrpy-
rIIX - cpeIIOTIIIIII'IeCKIIe CBonCTBa». Ceii:qac Bce 60JIee pacnpOCTpaHHeTCH
MbIC.:'Ib 0 rOMOJIarIIII reIIOTIIIIOB, JIeiRam;eii: B OCHOBe rOMOJIOrII IeCKOfI II3MeH-
qIIBOCTII 67.
B CTaTbe 06 YClIexax COBeTcRoii: relIeTIIKII 3a 1I0JIBeKa M. E. JI06ameB
Ha3BaJI qeTbIpe KpynHeii:mIIx TeOpeTI1'IeCKIIX a606m;eHIIR, B03HIIKmIIe Ha
OCHOBe rCMOJIOrIPIeCKIIX pR)],OB: Teopmo eIITpOB IIpOIlCXOiR)],eHIIH KYJIbTYP-
HbIX pacTeIIIIH caMoro BaBIIJIOBa, TeopHIO lIa paJIJIeJIII3Ma rIlCTOJIOrIIqeCKIIX
CTPYI{TYP A. A. 3aBap3HHa, TeopIIIO 11. n. IIaBJIoBa 06 YUIIBepCaJIbllOCTII
MexalIII3Ma ,ZJ;eii:cTBIIH YCJIOBHOrO peq,JIeRCa Ha pa3HhIX cpJIJIOreHeTII IecKIIx
ypOBIIHX pa3BIITIIH iRIIBOTHOro MIIpa, JIpIIH IIII OJIIIrOMepII3a IIII - YMelILme-
IIIIH qIICJIa opraHOB B 3BOJIIO IIH MHarOKJIeTOqHhIX, YCTaHOBJIeHHhIii: ,l],ore-
JIeM 68. TpIl 1I0CJIe)],HIIe 3aKoiIOMepHOCTII UMeIOT Herrocpe)],CTBelIHoe OTHome-
HIIe K IeJIOBeKY. O,o:HaKO paCCMOTpeHue IIX Bcex HeB03MOiRIIO B paMK8X
CTaTbII, II II03TOMY OrpaHIIqIIMCH TOJIbKO npIIH IIIIOM OJIIfrOMep1I3a:quu.
B. A. ,l],oreJIb, O,o:IIII [13 KPYIIHeHrnnx II aBTopIITeTHeHrnHX ClIe IIaJIJTCTOB
ITO 6eCII03BOIIOqHbIM,BBeJI npIIH I1n IIOJIIIMepII3a IIII, T. e. YBeJIIIqeHIIH
'IIfCJIa rOMOJIarII IH!>IX opraHOB KaK Be)],ym;ero MO,ZJ;yca 3BOJIIO HII Y IIpocTeii:-
rnIlx 69. IIMeHHo 3TO 0606m;elIlIe MOiRIIO paccMaTpIIBaTb B n:aqeCTBe nepRO-
1'0 3Tana B pa3pa60TKe TeopIlII OJIHrOMepII3a III1 opraHoB B 3BOJIIO IIII
MHOrORJIeTO lHbIX. CcpOPMYJIIIpOBauH3H IT03me, 3Ta TeopIIH ,o:aJIa B0311HJiR-
1I0CTb YCTaHOBIITb IIpIIH IIIIIIaJIbIIYIO pa3IIII Y B MopqJOJIOrIIqeCKoii: 3BO.:JIO-
IIII O)],HORJIeTOqHbIX II MIIOrOKJIeTO IHbIX 1KIIBOTHbIX 70. OHa BbIpaiRaeTCH
B TOM, ITO Y 1I0CJIe,o:HIIX IIPOIICXOJ\IIT COKpam;eHHe qIICJIa rOMOJIOrIIqlIbIX
opralIOB IIO Mepe nO)],'beMa no 3BOJIIO IIOIIHOH JIeCTHII e. AprYMeHTIIpYH 3TO
IIOJIOiReHIIe B pHJJ;e CTaTeH, ]J;oreJIb IIOCBHTII.1J 3aTeM Cne IIaJIbHYIO MOHorpa-
.pIIIO 3TOMY MOAYcy q,IIJIOreHeTII'IeCKIIX IIpe06pa30BaHIIii: II IIpOCJIe;rrII.TJ ero
BO Bcex KJIaCCaX mlI.BOTHoro lIfupa 71. B OT)],eJIbHbIX RJIaCCaX, B qaCTIIOCTH
93
t
t
to.
""--,
'l "v'
"
.,
\
Ij'
)
-".'
I
\I' .l
f, tv '",
,,;0 \ \f
, SU\
/"
Y MJIeKOllIITaIOm;IIX, ero MomHO rrpOCJIe,ZJ;IITb no OTpH]];allf. I1pIIMeIIHTeJIJ>Ho
K rrp06JIeMe alITporroreHe3a pe'Ib ,ZJ;OJImII8 II]];TII, OqeBIIJJ:HO, 0 rrorrCKax TaKIIX
pH)J,OB rOMOJIOrII'IHbIX opraHOB, KOTOpbIe o01I8pymIIBa.TJII 6bI pe]];YK HIO B OT-
pH]];e npIIMaTOB, rrO]];06HO TOMY KaK OIIH 06IIapymIIBaIOT TaRYIO pep;yK:q:IIIO
B .o:pyrIIx OTpH]];aX rro Mepe rrepeXo]];a OT 60JIee HII311IIIX B 3BOJIIO IIOIIIIOM
rrO.:'IOmeIIIIII cpOpM K 60JIee BbICOKIIM.
Y rrpIIMaTOB MomllO IIa3BaTb rro Kpaii:IIeii lIfepe TPH crrCTeMbI, B 3BOJIIO-
:qlIOHHOM pa3BHTIIII KOTOpbIX MomlIO OTMeTIITb YKa3alIIIYIO 3aKOIIOMepIIOCTb:
CKeJIeT, 3y6bI II xpmwcoMlIbIii: arrnapaT. Pe]];YK IIiI qIICJIa rOMOJIOrlIqlIhIX
opr8HOB B CKeJIeTe 3aMeTHa, IIaqIIlIaH C rrOJIyo6e3bHII II ROlIqaH BbICllIIIlIfH
06e3bHlIaMII H qeJIOBeKOM, B qIICJIe rr03BOlIKOB H pe6ep 72. OHa HeBeJIHKa,
BbIpaiRaeTCH B COKpam;eHIIII rr03BOlIIWB Ha O)J;IIII-p;Ba, 110 Bce me IIMeeT
MeCTO. IiICKJIIOqeHIIe COCTaBJIHeT XBOCTOBOH OT]];eJI n03BOIIOqHIIKa, BrrOJIlIe
pa3BIITbIii: y nOJIy06e3bHII H IIH311IIIX 06e3bHH, 110 rrOJIHOCTbIO OTCYTCTBYIO-
IIII Y BbIcrnIIX 06e3bHH II Y qeJIOBeKa. nO]];BepiReHbI OJIIIrOMepII3aIJ;II1I B
OTpH]];e rrpIIMaTOB II KOCTII qeperra: JI06IIaH KOCTb, cornHIIK, MeiRqeJIIOCTlIaH
ROCTb, 06pa3YIOm;IIeCH H3 pa3IIbIX 3M6pHOHaJIbHbIX 3aKJIa,ZJ;OK; y Y3ROlIOChIX
06e3bHII IIa6JIIOJJ:aeTCH CJIIIHHIIe HOCOBbIX RocTeii:.
AlIaJIOrIIqHbIM 06pa30M yMeHbllIelIIIe qIICJIa rOMOJIOrHqlIbIX opralIOB OT-
qeT.:'IIIBO 3aMeTII0 B 3BOJIIO IIII 3y6Hon CIICTeMbI. IiIcxo,ZJ;IIoe qIICJIO 3y6oB
y rrpIIMIITIIBHbIX MJIeKOrrIITaIOm;IIX rrOKa lIe MOiReT 6bITb YCTaHOBJIeHO C rrOJI-
IIoii: onpe]];eJIeIIIIOCTbIO. B COOTBeTCTBIIII C pa3HbIMII rIInOTe3aMII 3TO qIICJIO
ROJIeOJIeTCH OT 44 ]];0 60. B OTpH]];e rrpIIM8 TOB, KaK II y rrpe]];CTaBIITeJIeH
nOI(aBJIHIOm;erO 60JIbllIIIHCTBa OCT8JIbHbIX OTpH.n:OB, 3TO IICXO)J,Hoe ROJIIPIeCT-
BO 3y60B pep;y IIpOBaIIO B TOH IIJIII ImOH Mepe. Y rrpIIMaTOB rrOCJIep;OBaTeJIb-
IIbIH pHI( pe)J,YK Im qIICJIa 3y60B 06HapymIIBaeTCH Ha'IImaH C rrOJIY06e3bHII
II ROHqaH qeJIOBeKOM 73. nO-BIIAHMOMY, B O]];IIH PH]]; C 3TlIlIf HBJIelIIIellf MOiR-
110 IIOCTaBIITb II YM8HbrneHHe -qnCJIa 6yropKoB Ha meBaTeJlbHOH IIOBepXHOCTH
3y60B, KOTopoe Xapa'KTeplIO ;rrJIH rroc:rreJJ:OBaTeJIbHOrO 3BOJIIO:qIIOHlIoro pH]];a
,ZJ;peBHeHmIIX II p;peBIIIIX rOMIIHII]];, KOHqaH COBpeMelIHbIM qeJIOBeKOM 7".
B OTpH)J;e rrpIIMaTOB, CJIe]];OBaTeJIbIIO, BKJIIOqaH II COBpeMelIHoro qeJIOBeRa,
OJIIIrOMepII3a IIH 3YOOB H,ZJ;eT rrapaJIJIeJIblIO OJIIIrOMepII3a IIII rOMOJIOrIIqHhlX
BJIeMelITOB CKeJIeTa.
Oc06elIII0 BaiRHO YMeHbmelIHe qHCJIa XpOMOCOM, KOTopoe IIerrOCpe]];CTBelI-
110 3aTparIIB8eT IIaCJIe)J,CTBenlIbIii: arrrrapaT KJIeTKH. Y nOJIy06e3bHH H IIH3-
mIIX 06e3bHII qIICJIO XpOMOCOM KOJIe6JIeTCH BOKPYI' 70, y BbIcmIIX qeJIOBeRO-
06pa3IIbIX COKpam;aeTCH';rro 48 75 . Y qeJIOBeKa ,ZJ;O 'IIe]];aBlIerO BpellfelIII
II8CqIITbIBaJIlI TaKiRe 48 XpOMOCOM, H, CJIe,ZJ;oBaTeJIbIIO, IIH 0 KaKOH OJIIIrO-
MepII3a IIII XpOMOCOM IIa upOTHmeHIIH IICTOpHII ceMenCTBa rOMIIIIII,ZJ; He rrpH-
XOIUIJIOCb rOBopIITb. Ho COBpeMeIIHaH, 60JIee TO'IHaH lIfeTO,ZJ;IIKa IJ;IITOJIOrIIqe-
CRIIX IICCJIep;OBaHIIH uplIBeJIa K II3MelIelIIIIO 3TOii: IIcppbI: IIOBbIe IICCJIe]];OBaIIIIH
nOKa3aJIII, qTO CTapbIe orrpe]];eJIelIIIH 6bIJIH omII60'IlIbI H qTO ]];eii:cTBIITeJIbHOe
qIICJIO XpOMOCOM Y qeJIOBeKa paBIIO 46 76 . TaKIIM 06pa30M, II B XPOMOCOllf-
nOM anrrapaTe BII)J,IIa OTqeTJIHBaH OJIHrOllfepII3a:qHH rOMOJIOrHqlIbIX 3JIeMelITOB
Ha rrpOTHmelIIIII 3BOJIIO:qIIII OTpH]];a rrpIIlIfaTOB H ceMeHCTBa rOMIIIIH,ZJ;.
O]];IIHaKoBbIii: MO]];YC cpIIJIOrelIeTIfqeCRHX II3MelIelIIIn B OTpH,ZJ;e npHMaTOB
H ceMeiicTBe rOMlIIIII]]; C .n:pyrIIMII OTpH,]];allfII, IIeCOMlIeIIIIO, CBII,ZJ;eTeJIbCTByeT
o rrpOHBJIelIrrII rOMOJIOrIIqeCKIIX pH,ZJ;OB B HaCJIe,ZJ;CTBeIIIIOH H3MelI'IIIBOCTII
:II 3]];eCb, 0 cnpaBe,ZJ;JIHBOCTH 3Toro 3aROlIa H. IiI. BaBIIJIOBa B npHJIOiReHIIH
R BbIcmIIM cpopMaM mIIBOTIIOI'O lIfHpa. O,ZJ;IIaRO 3Ta rOMOJIOrIfqeCKaH II3MeH-
qIIBOCTb :II OTpameHIIe ee B nOCJIe,ll,OBaTeJIblIbIX pH]];aX II3MeHelIHn 3allfeTIIbI
H np:II cpaBHeIIlIII ropa3,ZJ;0 60JIee 6JIII3KIIX q,OpM yme BHYTPH caMoro ceMeii:-
CTBa rOMIIHII,ZJ;. Cym;ecTByeT II3BeCTIIbIH napaJIJIeJIII3M MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKIIX Ba-
94
pJIal(IIii: COBpellfelIHbIX pac II ,D:peBIIIIX cpOpM IICRonaeMbIX JIIO,D:eH. JIonaTo06-
pa3HbIe pe3 bI II YIIJIOm;eIIHOCTb JIII eBOro CKeJIeTa Y CIIlIalITpOIIa H Y
OT,D:eJIbHbIX IIaXO,D:OK rraJIeOalITpOIIOB B BOCTOqHOH A3IIII rrOBTopHIOTCH B
KpaHIIOJIOrII'I€CKOM TIllIe COBpeMelIlIbIX MOnrOJIOII,D:OB; CIIJIblIO BbIcTynalOII{He
IIOCOBbIe KOCTII xapaKTepHbI O,D:HOBpeMeIIIIO ,D:JIH COBpeMeHHbIX eBpOneOII,D:OB
II eBpOIIeHCKlIX IIealI,D:epTaJIb eB. Pa3JIIIqHbIe reorpaqmqeCKIIe rpynnbI eBpo-
neHCKIIX IIealI,D:epTaJIb eB ,D:IIcpq,epeH IIpyIOTCH B nepBYIO Oqepe,D:b no COOT-
IIOllIelIIIIO pa3MepOB JIII eBOro CReJIeTa II qepeHIIOn Kopo6KII, nO,D:06IIo TOMY
KaK pa3JIIIqaIOTCH Mem,D:y C060H COBpeMeHlIbIe paCbI. BII,D:OBaH HepecTpoii:Ka
HPII nepexo,D:e OT naJIeOaHTpOHa K 'IeJIOBeKy COBpeMelIlIoro TIIIIa OTpaiRaeT.
rrO-BII,D:IIMOMY, TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, 'ITO nO,D:aBJIHIOm;ee 60JIbIIIIIIICTBO relIOB
COBpeMeHlIoro qe.lIOBeKa MYTIIpyeT CXO,D:HbIM 06pa30llf C relIaMII HaJIeOalITpo-
rra 77.
IIapaJIJIeJIbHbIe pH,D:bI B II3MelIqIIBOCTII npOHBJIHIOTCH II HPII COHOCTaBJIe-
IIIIII pac Homo sapiens, oc06elIHo eCJIII 3TO COHOCTaBJIelIIIe He TOJIbKO
rrpOBO,D:IITb Mem,D:y COBpeMeHHbIMII paCOBbIMII BapIIaHTaMII, 110 II y'I€CTb CO-
OTBeTCTBeHHO ,D:peBHIIe paCOBbIe TIIHbI. B 3TOM CJIyqae, OqeBII,ZJ;HO B COOTBeT-
CTBIIII C YKa3alIIIbIMII H. 11. BaBIIJIOBbIM npIPIIIHaMII rrapaJIJIeJIblIbIX H3Me-
HeHIIii:, 60JIbllIe rrpIIXO,D:IITCH rOBopIITb 0 cpelIOTIIIIIIqeCKIIX CXO,ll,CTBax,
06pa30BaBllIIIXCH KOIIBepreIITIIO. Bo BCHKOM cJIY'Iae, q,elIoTIInHqeCKIIH napaJI-
JIeJIII3M BTOpIIqlIOrO rrpOIICXOiR,D:eIIIIH IIHKaR IIeJIb3H IICKJIIOqaTb rrpII cpaBRe-
HIIH MeiR)Jy C060lI pacoBbIx BapIIalIToB BUYTPII 60JIbrnIIX pac. He 3aTparII-
BaH rrpII'IIIlIbI rrapaJIJIeJIbHbIX II3MelIeHIIH, MOiRlIO YRa3aTb Ra HX llIHpOKoe
pacrrpocTpaHeHIIe BIIYTPII Bcex 60JIbrnIIX pac, oc06elIII0 eCJIII onIIpaTbcH lIe
Ha rrpII3IIaKlI, no ROTOpbIM B OCIIOBIIOM BbI,D:eJIHIOTCH 60JIbllIIIe pacbI, a IIa
rrpII3HaKII 60JIee RII3Roro TaKCOIIOMIIqeCROrO pallra. TaK, B rrpe,ZJ;eJIax Bcex
60JIbllIIIX pac BbI,D:eJIHIOTCH llIIIpOROJIH bIe II Y3KOJIII bIe, BbICOKOJIH bIe H
HII3ROJIII:qbIe, 6paxIIKpalIHbIe H ,D:OJIIIXOKpaHlIbIe, BbICOKOrOJIOBbIe H IIII3KOrO-
JIOBbIe BapIIaHTbI. B COCTaBe IOmlIbIX TpOrrII'I€CKIIX TIIrrOB, rrpII BbI):t;eJIemIH
KOTOpbIX BhlcTynaHIIe IIOCOBbIX KocTeH II yrrJIOm;eHHOCTb JIII eBOro CKeJIeTa
He IIMeIOT 3Haqe1IIIH. BCTpeqaIOTCH CaMbIe pa3IIo06pa3IIbIe COqeTaIIIIH: C OT-
HOCHTeJIblIO ynJIOm;elIlIbIM JIII eBbIM CKeJIeTOM II yrrJIOm;eHHbIMII IIOCOBbIMII
KOCTHMII, C pe3KO npoq,IIJIIIpOBalIlIbIlIf JIII OM II BbIcTynaIOm;IIM HOCOM. npe,o:-
CTaBIITeJIII aMepIIKaIIOII,D:Hoii: BeTElI B COCTaBe MOHrOJIOII,D:OB IIanOMIIlIaIOT
eBponeHCKIIe paCbI rro rrpoq,IIJIIIpOBaIIHOCTII JIII:qeBoro CKeJIeTa B ropII30H-
TaJIblIOH rrJIOCKOCTII H BbIcTynaHIIIO HOCOBbIX ROCTeH. BOJIee CBeTJIOKOiRIIe II
60JIee TeMHOKOiRIIe TIlIIbI xapaKTepHbI, KOlIe'IHO B pa3IIoii: CTenelIII, II ,D:JIH
eBporreOII,D:OB II ,D:JIH MOHrO.iIOII,D:OB, ,D:aiRe ,D:JIH HerpOn,D:OB 78.
npIIMepbI MOiRHO 6bIJIO 6hI YBeJIIIqIITb, HO B 3TOM HeT He06xo,D:nMOCTH.
BaiRHO ,D:pyroe - Ham;yrraTb TBep,D:hIH MOCT ,D:JIH rrepeXO,D:a OT MOpq,0.'10rIPIe-
CKOH II311f€IIqIIBOCTII K reHeTIIqeCKOH. npIIBe,D:elIlIbIX ,D:alIlIbIX ,D:OCTaTOqHO,
qT06bI YTBepiR)J;aTb: rOMOJIOrnqeCKne pH,D:bI rrpOHBJIHIOTCH II B II3MelI'I1IBOCTII
qeJIOBeKa, B HeH OTpamaIOTCH, TaKIIM 06pa30M, 06m;IIe 3aKOUOMeplIOCTII II3-
MelIqIIBOCTII TaK me, KaK 06m;IIe 3aKOHOMepHOCTII reorpaq,IIII OTpaiRaIOTCH
B reorpacpIIqeCKOM paCIIpe,D:eJIeHIIII alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX rrpII3IIaKOB rro 3eM-
IIOMY llIapy.
Bce TPII OCIIOBHhIX o606m;emIH H. 11. BaBIIJIOBa - TeopIIlO [fJHI eHTrOB,
3aROII OTTeCHeHIIH pe eCCIIBOB Ha OKpaIIHY BII,D:OBOrO apeaJIa, 3aKOII rOMOJIO-
rIIqeCKIIX pH,D:OB B HaCJIe,D:CTBeHlIoii: II3MeHqIIBOCTn - MOiRHO C ycrrexoM
IICrrOJIb30BaTb B aIITpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKOM IICCJIe,D:OBamIII. ]J;aJIbHeHllIaH pa3pa60T-
Ka IIX Ha aIITpOuOJIOrIIqeCKOM MaTepnaJIe - aKTyaJIblIbIH II rrJIO,D:OTBOplIbIii:
nYTb, KOTOpbIII MomeT npIIBeCTII K cepbe3HbIM TeOpeTIIqeCKIIM ,D:OCTIIiRe-
RIIHM.
95
1 CM.: KeJtep B. CepreH BaBIIJIOB. M., 1961.
2 BaBu.rwB H. If. 113 BocrrOMIIHaHIIH 0 H. H. XYP;HKOBe 1/ C60PHlIK HaY'IHbIX pa60T II BOC-
IIO:\IIIHaaIIll, nOCJ;}llI\eIIIIbIX lIa:\UITIl rrpoq,eccopa HIIKOJIan Hm-':OJIaeBII'Ia XYP;HKOBR.
M., 1929.
3 PeBeWKOBa A. If. HIIKOJIaH I1BaHoBlI'I BaBIIJIOB, 1887-1943. M., 1962. C. 12-13.
(, PHP;OM C H. M. BaBIIJIOBbIM: Co. BocrrOMIIHaHIIH. M., 1963. C. 50-51.
5 TaM 1Ke. C. 51.
B BaBu.!toB H. If. COBpeMeHHble 3ap;a'llI CeJIbCKOX03HHcTBeHHoro pacTeHlIeBop;cTBa IIM36p.
Tp. M.; JI., 1965. T. 5. ,D;JIH paooT, BOmep;IIIIIX B flTO 1I3p;aHlIe, rrepBolI3p;aHIIH MHOH He
YKa3blBaIOTcn.
7 Ou :!ICe. 0 rrpOHCX01Kp;eHIIII KYJIbTypHOH p1K1I II TaM 1Ke. M.; JI., 1962. T. 3.
6 PHP;OM C H. M. BaBIIJIOBI>IM C. 65. Crrel\lIaJIbHO 0 paooTe B CapaToBe CM.: KOPOTKO-
Ba T. If. H. M. BaBIIJIOB B CapaToBe (1917-1921). CapaTOB, 1978; Oua :!ICe. llP;TII BIle-
peiJ,1I m1I3HII. CapaToB, 1987.
9 PHP;OM C H. 11. BaBIIJIOBbIM. C. 68.
10 TaM 1Ke. C. 55.
11 BaBu.!!oB H. If. TIOJIeBble KYJIbTypbI IOro-BocToKa 1/ M30p. Tp. M.; JI., 1960. T. 2.
12 Ou :!ICe. R rr03HaHlIIO MHrKIIX rrlIIeHIIl\ (clIcTeMaTIIKo-reorpacPlI'IeCKHH flTIOp;) II TaM me.
C.398.
13 0 HIIX CM.: KOMapoB B. JI. TIpoIICX01Kp;eHlIe KYJIbTYPHbIX pacTeHIIH. M.; JI., 1938;
CTaulioB B. JI. 113 IICTOpllII Borrpoca 0 npOIICX01Kp;errIIII Ky.'lbTypHbIX paCTeHIIlI (P. Bpo-
YH - A. ,D;eKaHp;OJIb - H. BaBlIJIoB) II BorrpOCbI 3BOJIIOQIIII, olIoreorpaq,HII, reHeTlffiII II
CeJIeKl\lIlI. M.; JI., 1960.
U BaBu.wB H. 11. IJ;eHTpbI rrpOIICX01Kp;eHHH KYJIbTYpHbIX pacTeHIIH II 1130p. Tp. T. 5. CM.
TaK1Ke: Ou J/Ce. 0 BOCTO'IHT,JX I eHTpax rrpoIIcxonqeHIIH KYJIbTypRb1X paCTeHIIH II Ho-
BbIlI BocToK. 1924. oM 6.
15 CM. 06 3TOM: IfnaTbeB H. If. 0 p;lIcPcPepeHQHaJIbHOH reorpacPlIlI KYJIbTYPHbIX pacTeHIIii:
B paooTax H. 11. BaBIIJIOBa II BonpocbI flBOJIIOl\IIII, olIoreorpacPlIlI, reHeTIIKII II CeJIeK-
l\lm; 01i :!ICe. ,D;lIcPcPepeHl\lIaJIbHaH CIICTeMaTIIKa II p;lIcPcPepeHl\HaJIbHaH reorpacPlIH
pacTeHIIH. MIIHCK, 1971.
16 BaBu.!toB H. If. IJ;eHTpbI rrpolIcxomp;eHIIH KYJIbTYPHbIX pacTeHIIH. C. 19.
17 TaM me. C. 89.
18 rOpbKUU A. M. Coop. CO'l.: B 30 T. M., 1955. T. 30. C. 26.
'9 BaBu.!!oB H. If., BYKuHu'l J{. J{. 3eJ\1JIep;eJIb'leCKHH AcPraHlIcTaH 111130p. Tp. M.; JI.,
1959. T. 1. BOJIee 1I03p;Hlrn, rrOCMepTHO orrYOJIIIKOBaHHbIH 0030P rrYTelIIeCTBIIH: BaBu-
.!tOB H. If. TIHTb KOHTIIHeHTOB. IIoBecTb 0 rrYTelIIeCTBIIHX B rrOIICKax HOBbIX pacTeHIIH.
M., 1962; 2-e 1I3p;. JI., 1987.
20 BaBu.!tOB H. If., BYKU1iU'l J{. J{. YKa3. CO'l. C. 102.
21 C:\I., Hanp.: CapuaHuiJu B. If. ,D;peBHlIe 3eMJIep;eJIbl\bI AcPraHIICTaHa. M., 1977.
22 BaBu.!toB H. If. B03p;eJIblBaeMble pacTeHIIH XIIBIIHcKoro oa3lIca: (BoTaHIIKo-arpoHOMII-
'1eCKHH O'lepK) 111130p. Tp. T. 2. CM. TaK1Ke: 01i :!ICe. TIHTb KOHTHHeHTOB.
23 01i :!ICe. COBeTCKaH flKcrrep;IIl\IIH B AOIICCIIHIIII 1/ M30p. Tp. T. 5. CM. TaK1Ke: OH :!ICe.
TIHTb KOHTIIHeHTOB: CYPUHOB B. M., CPaiJeeB JI. A. AcPPIIKaHCKIle flKcrrep;IIl\1I1I H. M. Ba-
BIIJIOBR /1 O'iepliI1 HCTOpIJII PYCCIWlr 3TIlOrpacPIIII, cPOJIbIWOfJ1JCTln;n II aHTpOrrOJIOnIII,
V. M., 1974. (Tp. I1H-Ta flTHorpacPlI1I AH CCCP. H.C.; T. 102).
2& PHp;OM C H. 11. BaBIIJIOBbIM. C. 183-189.
25 HaBU.WB H. If. POJIb IJ;eHTpaJIbHOlI A3IIII B rrpOIICX01K,'1errHII ItYJIbTYPHbIX paCTeHIIH
(rrpe.o;BapIITeJIbHOe COOVlI\eHIIe 0 pe3YJIbTaTaX 3Rcne II ruI B J (eHTpaJIbHYIO A3InO B
1929 1'.) II M30p. Tp. T. 2; OH :!ICe. TIHTb KOHTIIHeHTOB.
26 BaBu.!!oB H. If. MeKclIKa II IJ;eHTpaJIbHaH AMepIlKa KaK OCHOBHOii: l\eHTp rrpolIcxomp;e-
HIIH KYJIbTYPHbIX pacTeHIIH HOBoro CBeTa II M30p. Tp. T. 2; OH 1Ke. BeJIIIKIle 3eMJIep;eJIb-
'1eCKHe KYJIbTYPbI P;OKOJIYMOOBOH AMeplIKII II IIX B3alIMOOTHomeHIIH II TaM 1Ke. CM.
TaK1Ke: OH :!ICe. IIHTb KOHTIIHeHTOB.
27 Ol\eHKY pe3YJIbTaTOB OOTaHII'IeCKHX flKCrrep;IIl\IIH BaBIIJIOBa B l\eJIOM CM.: rpYMM-
rp:!ICUMau.!tO A. r. B rrOIICKax paCTIITeJIbHbIX peCYPcoB MlIpa: (HeKOTopble Hayq:Hble
IITOrlI rryremecTBIIH aKap;eMIIKa H. M. BaBIIJIOBa). M.; JI., 1962; 2-e 1I3p;. 1987; IIonoB-
CKUU M. Hap;o crrelIIlITb. TIYTelIIecTBIIH aKap;eMIIKa H. H. BaBIIJIOBa. M., 1968; Pea-
1iun C. HlffiOJIaH BaBlIJIoB. M., 1968. B CBH31I C rrpa3p;HOBaHlIeM 100-JIeTIIH co P;HH P01K-
p;eHIIH H. H. BaBIIJIOBa ero OCHOBHbIe paooTbI ObIJIII rrepelI3p;aHbI B 'IeTblpex COOPHII-
Kax: HMMYHIITeT pacTeHIIH K IIHcPeKl\IIOHHbIM 3aOOJIeBaHIIHM. M., 1986; TIpolIcxomp;e-
HlIe II reorpacPHH KYJIbTypHbIX pacTeHIIH. JI., 1987; 3aKoH rOMOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX pHP;OB B
HaCJIep;CTBeHHoH 1I3MeH'IIIBOCTII. JI., 1987; TeOpeTII'IeCKHe OCHOBbI CeJIeKl\IIII. M., 1987.
,D;JIH MHorlIX paccMaTplIBaeMblx B CTaTbe BorrpOCOB Ba1KHa ero rreperrlIcKa, KOTO-
paH elI\e 1Kp;eT crrel\lIaJIbHOrO aHaJIII3a: BaBu.!toB H. If. 113 3rrlICTOJIHPHoro HaCJIep;IIH
1911-1928 1'1'. II Hayq:Hoe HaCJIep;CTBO. M., 1980. T. 5; OH :!ICe. 113 flnlICTOJIHpHOrO Ha-
CJIep;IlH 1929-19401'1'. II TaM 1Ke. M., 1987. T. 10.
96
28 06 flTOM CM.: POCKUH A. RapaBaHbI, )J;OpOI'l'I, KOJIOCbH. M., 1932; Bapa1iOB II. A. OoaH-
HIIe Y'leHoro: (IIaMHTl'I HIIKOJIaH I1BaHoBl'I'Ia BaBl'IJIoBa) II BorrpocbI 3BOJIIOI(IIII, 61I0-
reorpacPlIII, reHeTIIKH l'I CeJIeKI(IIII; PH)J;OM C H. 11. BaBIIJIOBbIM; BorrpocbI reorpacPlI lI
KYJIbTypHbIX pacTeHIIH II H. 11. BaBIIJIOB. M.; JI., 1966.
H. 11. BaBIIJIOB )J;yMaJI 1I0CBHTIITb CBOl'I CIIJIbI B )J;aJIbHeHmeM rrop:rOTOBKe KPYIIHbIX
TPY)J;OB 110 IICTOpIIl'I 3eMJIep;eJIl'IH, B TOM '1IICJIe MOIIOrpacPIIH 110 IICTOpII!I 3eMJIep;eJIb'le-
CKoii KYJIbTypbI EBporrbI II 3eMHOI'O mapa. CM.: BaXTeeB l1>. X., JIe6eiJeB J{. B., JIun-
wUlf C. EO. AKa,qeMIIK HIIKOJIaH I1BaHOBII'I BaBIIJIOB 1/ BaBIIJIOB H. M. M30p. Tp. T. 1;
CU1icna1/, E. H. H. 11. BaBIIJIOB KaK reorpacP (no JII!:'1HbIM BOCIIOMl'IHaHIIHM) II ll3B. Bce-
COI03. reorp. O-Ba. 1963. T. 95, Bbm. 1.
29 BaBu.!wB H. If. IIp06JIeMa IIpOIICX01K,qeHIIH KYJIbTypHbIX pacTeHIIH B COBpeMeHHoM 110-
HlBIaHIIII II 1136p. Tp. T. 5.
30 01i :!ICe. EOTaHIIKo-reorpacPlI'IeCKHe OCHOBbI ceJIeRQIIII: (Y'IeHIIe 06 I!:CXOP;HOM MaTe-
pl!:aJIe B CeJIeKI IIII) II TaM 1Ke. T. 2.
31 BbI,I1eJIeHlle B rrpep;eJIax Ooel'IX A1Iepl'IK P;BYX qeHTpoB BrrepBble rrpOII3BegeHo IIM B
1932 r. CM.: BaBu.!wB H. If. IIpooJIeMa IIpOI!:CX01Kp;eHIIH MIIpOBoro 3eMJIep;eJIIIH B CBe-
Te COBpeMeHHbIX IICCJIep;OBaHIIH 1/ 1136p. Tp. T. 5.
32 01i :!ICe. Y'IeHl!:e 0 rrpOIICX01Kp;eHIIII KYJIbTypHbIX pacTeHIlii IIOCJIe ,l];apBlIHa II TaM 1Ke.
CM. TaK1Ke: 01i :!ICe. IIHTb KOHTl'IHeHTOB; A. enceeB B. n. CTaHOBJIeHlle '1eJIOBe'leCTBa.
M., 1984.
33 CM., HalIp.: CU1icna1/, E. H. RYJIbTypHaH cPJIopa ,l];peBHero ,l];Bype'lbH (MeconOTaMIIH) II
113B. Pyc. reorp. O-Ba. 1961. oM 5; OHa :!ICe. Y'IeHl'Ie H. 11. BaBIIJIOBa 06 IICTopIIKo-reo-
rpacPII'IeCKIIX o'larax pa3BIITIIH RYJIbTypHOII cPJIOPbI II BorrpocbI reorpaqJIIII KYJIbTYP-
HbIX paCTeHI!:H I!: H. 11. BaBIIJIOB; JIuculfb 1ia r. H. OpomaeMoe 3eMJIep;eJIIIe 3110XII
flHeOJIIITa Ha lOre TypKMeHIIII. M., 1965; OHa :!ICe. CTaHOBJIeHlIe I!: pa3BIITIH' opomaeMO-
1'0 3e1megeJIIIH B I01KHOII TYPRMeHIIII. M., 1978; JIuculfb 1ia r. H., IIpUUfene1inO JI. B.
IIaJIe03THOOOTaHII'IeCKHe HaXO)J;KI!: RaBKa3a II EJIlIiKHerO BocToKa. M., 1977; B03HHK-
HOBeHlle II pa3BIITIIe 3eMJIep;eJIIIH. M., 1967; JKynoBcKuu n. M. RYJIbTYPHble paCTeHIIH
l'I !IX Copo,qI!:'1I!:. JI., 1964; OH :!ICe. HeRoTopble 1I0JIYBeROBble IITorII II3Y'1eHIIH ?oIllpOBOii:
reorpacPIIII I!: flBOJIIOI(l'IOHHbIX 3aKoHoMepHocTeH reHI(eHTpOB KYJIbTYPHbIX pacTeHlIll
RaR OCHOBbI C03,qaHIIH B CCCP IICxo,qHoro MaTepllaJIa )J;JIH CeJIeRQlI1I II feHeTl'IRa. 1967.
oM 10.
COJ\lHeHl'IH, BblCKa3aHHble B OTHomeHHII p;peBHOCTl'I flcPl'IOrrCKOro I(eHTpa (Tu-
TOB B. C. IIepBoe OOll\eCTBeHHoe pa3p;eJIeHIIe TpY)J;a. ,l];peBHellml'Ie 3eMJIep;eJIb'leCKlle
II CKOTOBo,q'leCKlle rrJIeMeHa II RpaT. COOOIl\. I1H-Ta apxeoJIormr. 1962. BbIll. 88), He 1Ie-
HHIOT oOll\ell KapTIIHbI.
3& BaBu.n.oB H. If. feorpacPlI'IeCKIIe 3aRoHoMepHOCTl'I B pacrrpe,qeJIeHI!:II reHOB KYJIbTYPHbIX
paCTeHIIII II Tp. 110 npllRJI. 60TaHl'IRe l'I CeJIeKI(IIII. JI., 1927. T. 17, BbIII. 3; OH :!ICe. MII-
pOBble qeHTpbI COpTOBbIX 60raTCTB (reHOB) KYJIbTypHbIX paCTeHlIll /1 II30p. Tp. T. 5;
01i :!ICe. feorpacPII'ICCll:aH JIOKaJIII3aIWH reHOB nmeHIII( Ha 3e11ROM mape II Ta)I 1Ke.
35 CM. JIIOOYIO oomlIpHYIO CBOP;RY no paCOBep;eHIIIO, Harrp.: Eickstedt E. Die Rassenges-
chichte der Menschheit. Stuttgart, 1934; Coon C. (with Hunt E.). The living races of
man. N. Y., 1965.
36 0630p: A.n.UJIWH A. ,l];OI!:CTOplI'IeCKaH AcPpIIRa. M., 1960.
37 CM., Hanp.: IIpOIICX01K,qeHl!:e '1eJIOBeKa I!: ,qpeBHee paCCeJIeHIIe '1eJIOBe'leCTBa. M., 1951.
(Tp. I1H-Ta flTHorpacPIIII AH CCCP. H.C.; T. 16).
38 IIop;oop cPaRToB CM.: K.n.apn r. ,lJ,oIIcTOpl!:'1eCKaH EBporra: 3ROHOMII'IeCKIIH o'lepK. M.,
1953; KO.n.blfOB JI. B. IDIIHaJIbHbIH lIaJIeOJIIiT l'I Me30JIIIT I01KHOlllI BOCTo'IHOll IIp1I6aJI-
TIIKII. M., 1977.
39 IIaHollRyMeHHble KapTbI J\IHOrl'IX rrpII3HaKOB, He OTpa1KalOll\l'Ie, rrpaB,qa, Bcen rrOJIHOTbI
HaKOrrJIeHHbIX )J;aHHbIX, CM.: Lundman B. Umriss der Rassenkunde des Menschen in
ge chichthchel' Zpit. Koppenhagen. J932; Idem. Geogranhische ,\nthl'opogie. Stutt-
gart. 1968; Biaslltti R. Razze i popoli della terra: In 4 vol. Torino, 1959-1960.
(,0 Y1Ke eCTb oomllpHblC CBO,qRl'I p;aHHbIX: MOllrant A. The distribution of human blood
groups. Oxford, 1954; MOllrant A., Kopec A. Domaniewska-Sobczak K. Distrihution of
human blood groups and other polimorphisms. L., 1976; Die neue Rassenkunde/Hrsg.
I. Schwidetzky. Stuttgart, 1962; Schwidetzky I. Erganzte Karten fUr Hauptleisten-
merkmale pml PTS SchmackIeigkeit /i Homo. 196fi. Bd. 17, H. 1; Prokop 0., Uhlen-
bmck G. Lehrbuch der menschlichen Blut- und Serumgruppen. Leipzig, 1966.
41 0030p cPaRTOB l'I rIIrrOTe3 CM.: [)rJjpOUMCOH B. n. I1J\IMYHoreHeTIIKa. M., 1971.
42 M3 1I0CJIep;Hl'IX KHl'Ir Ha ::ny TeMY CM.: Mu.n.bnoB l1>. H. 1D1I31!:'1eCRaH reorpacPlIH: COBpe-
MeHHoe COCTOHHlIe, 3aKOHOMepHOCTII, rrp06JIeMbI. BopoHe1K, 1981.
43 CBOP;KY ,qaHHblx CM.: nepe.n.bMa1i A. If. feOXIIMIIH JIaHAIlJacPTa. M., 1966.
u BU1ioepaiJoB A. n. ElIoreOXIIMlI'leCRIIe IIpOBIIHI(l'III II Tp. 106IIJIeHHOII ceCCIIII, rrOCBH-
ll\eHHOii CTOJIeTIIIO co P;HH p01K,I1eHIIH B. B. ,l];oKY'laeBa. M.; JI., 1949; 01i :!ICe. Elloreo-
XIIJ\III'IeCRl'Ie rrpOBl'IHI(IIl'I II ux pOJIb B OpraHU'IeCKoii: aBOJIlOqlIJI II feoxlIMIIH. 1963.
4 B. II. AmmceeB
97
Iii
;M 3; l(oBa,n,bcnuu B. B. HOBbIe HanpaBJIeHl'IH l'I sap;a'lII Ol'IOJIOrl'I'IeCROH Xl'IJ\IlIII CeJIL-
CROX03HHCTBeHHbIX mllBOTHbIX B CBHSl'I C l'I3Y'IeHl'IeM 6l'IOreOXl'IMII'IeCKIIX IIpOBIIHl\IIH.
M., 1958; ON :!ICe. reOXIIMII'IeCRaH 3RoJIOI'IIHIIIIpIIpo)J.a. 1964. oM 3; ON :!ICe. reoxl'IlIm-
'1eCRaH 3KOJIOrl'IH. M., 1974.
45 IIOJIHbIH IIO)J.OOP )J.aHHblx C YKa3aHl'IeM JIIITepaTypbI M01KHO HaHTl'I: Schwidetzky 1.
Neuere Entwicklungen in del' Rassenkunde des Menschen II Die neue Rassenkunde.
46 CBo)J.Ra )J.aHHLIX II JIIITepaTypbI: A,n,enceeBa T. If. reorpacPlI'leCRaH cpep;a II 6l'IOJIOrl'IH
'1eJIOHeRa. M., 1977.
47 A,n,e1;;CeeB B. n. reorpacPl'IH 'IeJIOBe'leCRIIX pac. M., 1974; 01i :!ICe. reorpacPII'IeCRII
O'iarlI cPOpMl'IpOBaHl'IH '1eJIOBe'leCRl'IX pac. M., 1985.
4S BY1ian B. B. 'leJIOne'IeCRIfe paCDI II UYTII IIX 00pa30BaHII11 II COHo 3TIlOrpacPIIH. 19;);).
oM 1.
49 IIepBbIe c1JOPMYJIlIpOBRII rl'IrrOTeSbI O'iarOB pacooopa30BaHIIH CM.: A,n,eKceeB B. n. BbI-
cTynJIeHlle Ha Cl'IMlI03nyllle «lDaRTopbI paco06pa30BaHl'IH, MeTop;bI paCOBoro aHaJIII3a"
rrpIIHl\II11bI paCOBbIX RJIaCCIIcPl'IRal\l'IH» II BOllp. aHTpOrrOJIOrl'III. 1965. Bbm. 20; ON :!ICe.,
K 06ocHoBaHllIO rrorrYJIHl\IIOHHOH ROHl\errl\l'Il'I paCbI II IIpOO$MbI 3BOJIIOl\IIIf '1eJIOBeKa
II ero pac. M., 1968; ON :!ICe. Cl'I6l'Ipb RaR o'lar pacooopaSOBaHl'IH II IIp06JIeMbI l'ICTOpII-
'1eCROH 3THorpacPl'I1I l'I aHTpOrrOJIOrlll'I ASIIII. M., 1968.
50 Herrlich A. Beitrag zur Rassen- und Stammeskunde del' Hindukusch-Kafiren II Deut-
sche in Hindukusch. B., 1937; J{e6elt r. l1>. AHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKlle IICCJIe)J.OBaHIIH B AcP-
raHIlCTaHe II COB. flTHorpacPlIH. 1967. oM 4.
51 q e60KcapOB H. H. 113 l'ICTOpIIII CBeTJIbIX paCOBbIX THIlOB EBpaSl'I1I II AHTPOIIOJI. 1KYPH.
1936. oM 2.
52 A. eKceeB B. n. reHeTIIRa l'I aHTpOrrOJIOrlIH II HayRa II 1K1I3Hb. 1969. oM 9. CM. TaR1Ke,
IIpe;:\brp;YII'\IIH pa3p;eJI flTOH RHIIrIl.
53 POZU1icnuu H. H. 3aROHOMepHOCTII rrpOCTpaHCTBeHHoro paClIpep;eJIeHIIH rpynrr RpOBl'I Y
'1eJIOBeKa: (K rrpOOJIeMe aHTpOIIOJIOrl'Il'I «ORpal'IHHbIX HapOp;OB») II Tp. I1H-Ta 3THorpa-
cPlIlI AH CCCP. H.C. 1947. T. 1.
54 HaTUlUBU,n,u A. H., A6iJYlUe,n,ulUBu,n,1l M. r. IIpep;Bapl'ITeJIbHbIe p;aHHble 00 aHTpOIIOJIO-
rll'leCRIIX IICCJIep;OBaHIIHX rpysIIHCKoro Hapop;a II KpaT. coooII'\. I1H-Ta 3THorpacPIIII AH
CCCP. 1955. T. 22.
55 CM. 06 flTOM: A,n,eKceeB B. n. HeROTOpbIe rrp06JIeMbI rrpOIICX01Kp;eHl'ISI OaJIKapl\eB l'I Ra-
pa'iaeBlWB B CBeTe p;aHHbIX ilH1pO:IO.iIOrIlII II 0 rrpOIICXOlli;J;eHIII1 Ga';IKap eB II Kapa'la-
eBl\eB. HaJIb'll'IR, 1960; ON :!ICe. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCRlle p;aHHble R rrpOIlCX01Kp;eHIIIO oce-
Tl'IHCROrO Hapop;a II IIpOIICX01K)J.eHlIe OCeTl'IHCKOrO HapO)J.a. OPP;1KOHl'IRII,o:3e, 1967.
56 J{ e6e lt r. l1>. AHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKIIe IICCJIe,o:OBaHIIH B ,l];arecTaHe II AHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKl'IH
C60PHl'IR, I. M., 1956. (Tp. I1H-Ta flTHorpacPlI1I AH CCCP. H.C.; T. 33); 01i :!ICe, AHTpO-
rro:rrorlI'IeCRlle TIIlIbI II Hapo,o:bI KaBRa3a. M., 1960. T. 1.
57 IIo,o:pooHee 00 3TOM CM.: A,n,enceeB B. n. AHTpOIIOJIOrlI'IeCKlIe p;aHHblC R rrpOOJIeMe
rrpOIlCX01K,o:eHIIH Hace:rreHlIH l\eHTpaJIbHbIX rrpep;rOpl'IH KaBRascKoro xpeoTa II AHTPO-
rro:rrOIWleCKIIH C60PHIII>, IV. M., 1968 (Tp. I1H-Ta 3TIIorpacPIIII AH CCCP. H.C.; T. 82).
58 nOnOB M. (COBM. C MapROBbIM r.). AHTpOIIOJIOrlIH Ha 6'bJIrapCRl'Ie napo,o:. C., 1959.
T. 1: IDII3H'IeCKII 06JIIIK Ha O'bJIrapl'ITe.
59 IIpe,o:BaplITeJIbHOe COOOII'\eHIIe CM.: POlllianos A. AHTPOlIo:rrOI'II'1eCRIIH COCTaB Hapo,o:oB
Ha TeppIITOplll'I Me1K,o:y 3reHCKIIM MopeM II ,l];ynaeM II I Congr. intern. etud. Balkan.
et sud-est europ.: Res. commun., ethnogr. et arts. Sofia, 1966.
60 MOllrant A. Kopec K., Domaniewska-Sobczak K. The ABO blood groups. Comprehen-
sive tables and maps of world distribution. Oxford, 1958.
61 Walter H. Die Bedeutung del' serologischen Merkmale IiiI' die Rassenkunde II Die neue
Rassenkunde. BOJIee rrop;p06HaH RapTa: A,n,enceeB B, n. reHoreorpacPIIH '1eJIOBeKa II
ee 3aKOHOMepHOCTII II HaYKa lI'Ie:rrOBe'leCTBO. M., 1968.
62 Walter H. Die Bedeutung del' serologischen Merkmale IiiI' die Rassenkunde. TaM 1Ke
II RapTbI reorpacPlI'IeCKOrO pacrrpocTpaHeHII11 aJIJIeJIelI rpyrrrr RpOBII, ROTOpbIe 6YP;YT
YIIOMHHYTbI p;aJIbme. IIpIIBOP;lIJ\lblC 3,o:ecb RapTbI ,o:olIOJIHeHbI lIS pa3HbIx l'ICTO'lHIIROB.
63 Bopo1iOB A. A. 3THorpacPIIH OCHOBHbIX TIIIIOB rarrTOrJIOOIIHa - CbIBOpOTO'lHoro 6eJIKa
RpOBII II COB. 3THorpacPl'IH. 1968. oM 2; A,n,uMoBa M. M. reHoTllrrbI II cPeHoTIIrrbI rarr-
TorJI06l'IHa II reHeTl'IRa. 1968. T. 4. oM 8.
oI. 17 avilov N. The low of homologous series in variation II J. Genet. 1922. VoL 12, N 1;
BaBu,n,oB H. If. 3aKoH rOJ\IOJIOrH'IeCRIIX pH,o:OB B HaCJIep;CTBeHHoH II3MeH'IIIBOCTII II
M30p. Tp. T. 5.
ti5 CM., Harrp.: IfnaTbeB A. H. 3aKoH rOMOJIOrH'IeCRIIX pHP;OB B HaCJIep;CTBeHHoH 1I3MeH-
'JIIBOCTII II ero c.rIe,lCTBIIH I! Co. nay'l. Tp. EeJIoPYc. C,-X. aKa". rOpRII, 1967, T. 49;
BIIOJIOrl'IH l'I arpOTeXHIIKa CeJIbCKOX03HHcTBeHHbIX RYJIbTyp; f(upnUlt1iUnOB B. C. ro-
MOJIOrlI'IeCKaH HaCJIep;CTBeHHOCTb l'I flBOJIIOl\l'IH casaHa (Cyprinus carpio L.) II reHc-
Tl'IRa. 1967. oM 2; BopoNltoB H. H. 3BOJIlOQllH rrIlII'\eBaplITeJIbHOH Cl'ICTeMbI rpbI3YRO&
(MblIlIe06pa3Hbre). HOBocIIonpcR, 1967.
98
116 BaBu.!!oB H. If. BbICTYIIJIeHlle Ha CUBell\aHIIII IIO reHeTIIRe l'I CeJIeRl(lI11 111130p. Tp.
T. 5. C. 397.
ti7 0 cOBpeJ\IeHHOM rrOHIIMaHl'III rOMOJIOrII'IeCROH l'I3MeH'lIlBOCTII CM.: Bopo1iljoB H. H.
o roMOJIOrIIQeCKOH: II3J\ICH'IIIBOCTII II IIpOOJIeMbI KII6epHenIKII. M., 1966. BbIII. 16.
.ti8 J]o6auteB M. E. IIoJIBeRa cOBeTCKOH: reHeTl'IKII /I reHeTIIKa. 1967. oM 10. C. 25.
-4;9 Dogel W. Polymerisation als ein Prinzip del' progressiven Entwicklung boi Protozo-
en II BioI. Zentr.-BI. 1929. Bd. 49, N 8.
. 70 J{oee.!!b B. A. OJIl'IrOMepII3al\l'IH rOMOJIOrll'lHbIX opraHOB RaK rrpe06JIap,aIOIl\IIH IIp UH l\l'I1I
rrporpeccIIBHoil: 3BOJIIOl\l'III y MHOrOKJIeTO'lHbIX II Apx. aHaTOMl'Il'I, rl'ICTOJIOrl'I1I II 3M6pl'Io-
JIorl'Il'I111936. T. 15. oM 3.
11 j{oee.!!b B. A. OJIllrOMepIl3al\l'IH rOMOJIOrll'lHbIX opraHOB KaK Op,l'IH l'I3 rJIaBHbIX rryreil:
3BOJIIOl\IIl'I 1KIIBOTHbIX. JI., 1954.
-72 CM.. Hang.: JKaoeHoB B. H. CpaBHIITeJIbHaH aHaTOMIIH npIIMaTOB. M., 1962.
73 ; .viiHhIe cpOP !Y':lbI pa3Hblx ClIC1 e1laTIIQeCI,IIX rpYlI1I npUJ\IiHOB rrpIIBeL(eHbI n Iia1K:\O.\f
KPYIIHOM PYROBop,CTBe rro rrpIlMaTOJIOrl'IlI.
H 3y6oB A. A. IIopHp,oR pep;YRl\l'III 6yropRoB II rrplIo6peTeHIIe Y30pa KOpOHRII rrOCTOHH-
HbIX IUlllilIIIX .\IOJUlpOB '1eJIOBeR3 rrpII lIepexo;J:e OT IIHTII6yropIioBoro TIIIIa K Tpex6yrop-
KOBmlY IIVn Me1Kp,YHap. Romp. aHTpOrrOJI. II [!THOrp. HaYK. M., 1964.
-15 CM., Harrp.: Kuape.!!.!!u B. BbICTYIIJIeHl'Ie Ha CIIMII03I1Y'\Ie «IIpo6JIeMa rpaHl'I Me1KAY 1Kl'I-
BOTHbIMII II '1eJIOBeROM» II Borrp. aHTpOrrOJIOrl'IlI. 1965. Bblll. 19; Chiarelli B. Caryolo-
g;P comparee et evolution clwz les singes catarrhina II Tp. YII Melli;J:YHap. KOHrp.
aHTpOrrOJI. l'I 3THOrp. HayK. M., 1968. T. 3.
76 3TOT cPaliT 6bIJI YCTaHOBJIeH B 1956 r.
'77 BOJIblllOII MaTepl'IaJI p,JIH CY1Kp,eHIIH 06 f!TOM COp;ep1KIITCH B RH.: Coon C. The origin
of races. L., 1963.
'78 0630P cPaKTOB CM. B JIIOOOH: RpynHOil: CBop,Ke rro paCOBOMY COCTaBY 3eMHoro lIIapa,
H 'JaCTHOCTII B KHIIrax, YKa3aHHbIX B rrpl'IMe'l. 35.
3RonOfMH qEnOBEKA
(B3f JIH,D:bI aHTpOnOJIOfOB)
B3rJIH.II;hI, 1I3JIOmeHHbIe B 3TOM BbIMblrnJIeHHOM pa3rOBope, IIeo,o:HoKpaTHo
'CJIYlIHIJIlI II npOnOJIiRaIOT CJIymlITb TeMoii: o6CYiR,o:eHlIH B JIlPIHbIX 6ece,o:ax
II yCTHbIX ,o:ncKycclIHx alITpOnOJIOrOB II npe,o:CTaBnTeJIeii: CMe,KHbIX cne-
naJIbHOCTen t. K COiRaJIeHIIIO, oun lIe IIOJIyqIIJIII, 3a IIeMIIOrIIM IICKJIIOqe-
IIIIeM, CROJIbKO-IIII6y,o:b nOJIlIOrO OTpaiReHHH B ne'IaTH. 'ITO 3aCTaBJIHeT Hac
npIIGernYTb R lIe COBceM 06bIqHOii: <IJopMe II\: OCBem;eIlIIH. 'TaKaH cpopMa no-
3BOJIHeT qeTKO O'lepTIITb Rpyr 06CYiR,o:aeMhIX BOIIpOCOB, oxapaKTepII30BaTb
KOIIKpeTlIbIe IIp06JIeMbI II BbIHBIITb OCHOBlIbIe pa3JIII'IIIH MeiR,o:y BbICKa3bIBae-
MbIMII TO'lKaMII 3peHIIH aHTpOnOJIOra-KJIaCCIIKa (K), aHTpOIIOJIOra-pOMaIITII-
Ka (P), aH TpOnOJIOra-cpII3IIOJIOra «([J) H aIITpOIIOJIOra-aIITpOIIOrelIeTIIKa (A).
K. MelIH IIopamaeT oOIwIIe uOBbIX HaIIpaBJIelIIIII B HallieH IIaYKe, COIIpO-
BOiRp,8IOm;eeCH IICnOJIb30BaHIIeM rpOMaAHoro 'lIICJIa HOBbIX IIonHTIIH II Tep-
MIIIIOB, JIOMKOii: CTapbIX, yCTaHoBIIBlliIIXCH B3rJIH,o:OB II npeTelI3IIeH Ha pac-
lliIIpelIIIe rpalIlI HaYKII, ocpopMJIeHIIe ee HOBon CTPYKTypbI, OTKpbITIIe
KamIX-TO npIIHl(IIIIIIaJIbHO IIOBbIX ccpep HCCJIe,o:oBaHIIii:. KOlIeqlIo, iRlIBeM MhI
B anoxy HayqHO-TeXHII'IeCKOH peBOJIIO IIII, xapaKTepII3YJOm;eHcH ue06bIqlIbIM
pacrnIIpelIIIeM TeXHII'IeCKIIX B03MomIIocTeH II npIfH IInIIaJIbHOn rrepecTpolI-
ROii: HayqHOrO MbIrnJIeIIIIH. nepe;rroBoii: Kpaii: HaYKII, TaKIIe ,o:HC III1JIlIlIbI.
KaK cpII3IIKa, XIIMIIH, MOJIeRYJIHpHaH 6IIOJIOrIIH, ,o:eikTBIITeJIbHO, MeHHIOT CBoe
JIII O p:an'€ He OT ro,o:a K rop:y, a npHMO OTO ,IJJIH KO )J;I1IO. 3HaqeHlIe me
HallieH 06JIaCTlI qlICTO aKa,o:eMIIqeCKOe, eCJIH He C'IIITaTb pa3MepHoii: TIIIIOJIO-
rnlI, IICIIOJIb3yeMon ,o:JIH IIym,o: JIerKOH npOMbIrnJIeIIHOCTH. TaKoii: aIITpOnOJIO-
rIIH OCTaIIeTCH H Bnpe,o:b - IICCJIe,o:OBaHIIe 6IIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX CBOIICTB qeJIOBeKa
.JIemIIT CJIIIlliKOllf ,ZJ;aJIeKO OT Kap,o:lIIIaJIbHbIX IIIITepeCOB 06m;eCTBa. n03TOMY
99
4*
Bce IIOBmeCTBa KamYTCH HeOlIpaB.II;alIHbIlIfH no cymeCTBY: qaCTJlqHO RCTORH
IIX II BCIO II.JIII lIOqTII BCIO CYMMY IIOBbIX 1!f.Il;eii:, MeTO.Il;OB H .Il;ame pe3YJIbTa-
TOB IIfOJIHIO IIaii:TII B CTapbIX aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIX pa60Tax, ROTOpbIe TelIepb
npe.Il;lIO'lIITaIOT lIe qUTaTb IIJIH qHTaIOT nOBepXIIOCTIIO, qaCTRqlIO me B
alITpOlIOJIOrHIO lIpIIBHOCflTCH qYiR.!I:bIe eii: KOII:qen:qIIII II nO.Il;XO.Il;bI, pa3pymaIO-
m;IIe ee cne uq,HKY.
P. KTO-TO II3 nHCaTeJIen, nO-MoeMy nporn.rroro BeKa, CKa3aJI, qTO HO-
Boe - 3TO npOqHO 3a6bIToe CTapoe. MOiReT 6bITb, B 3TOM BbICKa3bIBalIJIII
eCTb IWKaH-TO JIOrIIKa. ,D;eii:cTBIITeJIbIIO, IIamIIMII npe,ZJ;meCTBeIIHIIKaMII MHO-
roe C)J;eJIaIIO, II Roe-'ITO Cq,OPMYJIIIpOBaHO TIMII TaRIIM 06pa30M, 'ITO B 3TOllf
MomlIO IIaHTII IICTOKII IIOBbIX B033peHIIII. OIIU Ha.Il; MlIorIIM 3a.Il;YMblBaJIJICb,
c06paJIu orpOMIIoe KOJIII'IeCTBO .Il;aHlIbIX, KOTOpbIMII MbI nOJIb3yeMcfl .Il;0 CIIX
nop, Cq,OpllfY.:'IIIpOBaJIlI pHI( £pYHI(aMeIITaJIblIbIX KOII elI IIH. Ho HaYKa II.II;eT
BlIepe.Il; II, 'IeM .Il;aJIbme, TeM 6bIcTpee,- lIe TOJIbKO cpII3IIKa H MOJIeKYJIHp-
Hafl UUOJIOrIIH, HO U aIITpOlIOJIOrIIfl. BepoHTHo, alITpOlIOJIOrIIH pa3BIIBaeTCH
ceii:'Iac .Il;ame 60.nee 6yp1I0. B q,II3IIKe, 6UOJIOrJIII II IIeKOTOpbIX .Il;pyrux IIaYKax
npo ecc q,opMaJIII3a:qIIH 3IIaHIIfl IIacTynHJI yme .Il;aBIIO, a. II8ma IIaYRa lIepe-
mIIBaeT nepIIo}J, pOMaHTIIKII, oTKpblBaeT IIOBbIe, HeXOmelIbIe lIYTU, C03.I1;aeT
TeopIIII, OXBaTblBaIOm;ue B ep,IUIOM CIIHTe3e BCIO CYMMy 3HaHIIii: 0 qeJIOBeKe
II ero MeCTe B Mup03p,aHIifII, lIepeKU.II;blBaeT npO'IHbIe MOCTbI K P,PyrIIM JUIC-
IIII.nHHaM, II3 KOTOpbIX B lIepBYIO Oqepe.Il;b CJIe}J,yeT Ha3BaTb cpII3IIOJIOI'IIIO,
lICIIXO.;IOrIIIO II lIOlIYJIfl IIOHIIYIO reHeTIIKy. AIlTpOnOJIOrIIH nepeCTaJIa ObITb
e,ll,IIHOH HaYKoH, olla CTaJIa KOMlIJIeKCOllf IIaYK, B KOTOpOM ee npeiRHIIe lIOp,-
pa3p,eJIeHIIfl - Mopq,OJIOrIIfl 'IeJIOBeKa, alITpOlIoreHe3 H paCOBeJJ:eHlIe -
3alIIIMaIOT lIOn;qIIHeIIHOe lIOJIOmeHIIe, ,ZJ;aJIeKO lIe IICqeplIbIBafl Bcero KOMlI-
JIeKca. PaBHonpaBlIoe C P,PyrHMH lIOiIpa3;rreJIeHUHMII nOJIOmeHIIe CPII3IIOJIOrH-
qeCKOll aHTpOlIOJIOrIIII 6bIJIO YKa3aHO IIa VII MeiR)J;YlIapOp,IIOM KOHrpecce
alITpOlIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX II 3TlIorpacpII'IeCKIIX IIaYK B MocRBe B aBrYCTe 1964 r.
3anIIMaeT OHa 60JIbrnOe MeCTO II B ocym;ecTBJIeHIIII Mem.Il;YHapop,HbIX npoeK-
TOB IOHECKO - Mem.Il;YlIapo;rrHOH 6IIOJIOrHqeCKOH nporpaMMbI If lIporpaMMbI
« qeJIOBeK II 6IIoccpepa}). qacTo BKJIIO'IaIOT B IIee II3yqelIIIe relIeTIIqeCKIIX
MapIwpOB B qe.JIOBe'leCKIIX nonYJIfl IIRX B IIIIIpOKOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa, HO 3TO
BPH)J JIll BeplIO: 3TO ClIe IIq,IIqeCKOe p,eJIO II lIO lIpIIMeHHeMbIM MeTop,aM, II no
clIoc06aM IIHTepnpeTa.O:IIII cpaKTOB, 60JIee cpopMaJIII30BaHHbIM, 'IeM B P,PyrIIx
06JIaCTHX aIlTpOlIOJIOrIIII, 110 II 60JIee a6cTpaKTlIbIM, lIe OqeHb OTBeqaIOm;IIM
Tpe60B3HIIHM II3yqelIIIH IIMelIHO 'leJIOBeqeCKUX lIOIIYJIH IIii:. Ha MOii: B3rJIH,ZJ;,
nOlIYJIH IIOIIHaH relIeTIIKa qe.:'IOBeKa - TaKOII me caMOCTOHTeJIbnbIH pa3D;eJI
«OMnJI8KCa aIlTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX HayK, RaK II q,II3IIOJIOfII'IeCKaH alITpOlIo-
JJOrUH.
To me Monmo CKa3aTb II 0 MeTO,ZJ;ax. PaHbme, em;e 20-30 JIeT IIa3ap"
aHTpOlIOJIOr BbIe3iRaJI B 3KClIe)JlI IIIO 'IalI e Bcero 0p,1I1I, C pIOK3aKoM, B KOTO-
pOM 6hI.ITU JIIIrnb Ha60p IIpKYJIeii: ,ZJ;a mKaJIa p,JIH OlIpep,eJIeHIIfl BeTa BOJIOC,
rJIa3 U HOiRU. MOp,eJIII A. 11. Hpxo - MYJIHiRII TlIITOBbIX IIOpM BapIIa IIH
MflrKIIX TRaHeH JIII a - 6bIJIII BepmIIHoii: aIlTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOll MeTop,IIKH.
Pa60ThI, B HOTOpbIX p,eJIaJIIICb lIOJ1bITInif OlIpep,eJIelIIIH XIIMIIqeCKOrO COCTaBa
oTJJ;eJIblIbIX KocTeii: CReJIeTa IIJIII IIX MIIKPOCTPYKTypbI, HaCqIITblBaJlIlcb e,ZJ;II-
IIII aMII II BbIrJIH.II;eJIII IIa cTpalIII ax aIITponoJIOrIPIeCKIIX If3p,aHIIii: IIII0pO.Il;-
HbIM TeJIOM. AIITpOlIOJIOr 6bIJI IIWpcpOJIOroM B Tpap,IIl(IIOIIHOM CMbICJIe 3Toro
CJIOBa, II TOJIbKO. TelIepb me K YCJIyraM aIITpOlIOJIOrOB, lIOMIIMO Tpa,ZJ;II:qIIOH-
IIbIX, pa3IIo06pa3lIbIe 6IIOXIIMIIqeCRIIe If rIICTOXIIMIIqeCKIIe, rIICTOJIOrIIqeCKIIe,
CPH3HOJIOrIIqeCKIIe II nCIIxoq,II3IIOJIOrIIqeCKl'Ie, relIeTUqeCRIIe II pelITreHO-
OTPYKTYPHbIe MeTO,ZJ;IIKII, II aIITpOnOJIOrH qpe3BbIqaHHO IIIIIpOKO IICnOJIb3YIOT
HX B CBOIIX IICCJIe,ZJ;OBaIIIIHX. ,lJ,ame lIaJIeOaHTpOlIOJIOrIIH - IIaII60JIee Tpa,ZJ;II-
100
:qIIOlIlIaH 06JIaCTb aHTpOnOJIOrHII - II3l1feHIIJIa CBoe JIII O: OHa Y)J;eJIHeT 60.111>-
llioe BIIIIMaHIIe onpe eJIelIHIO 6HOJIOrIIqeCKOrO B03paCTa HCCJIep;yellfbIx HHWI-
BII.D:YYMOB C nOMOm;bIO 6HOXHlIfII'IeCKHX II MHKpOMopcpOJIOrIl'IeCKIIX lIfeTop;OB,
ROTopoe HBJIHeTCH IIe06XOp;HMbIlIf lliarOllf Ha nYTH K peKoHcTpyR:qIfII naJIeo-
.n:eMorpacpH'IeCKHX cIITya IIH. n03TOMy B JII060M aIITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOllf myplIa-
JIe CTaTbH 0 CeJIeRTHBHhIX npeIIMym;ecTBax Toro IIJIII HlIoro cpeHoTlma no
rpynnaM RpOBII cocep;cTByeT C pe3YJIbTaTaMH 3KcnepIIMeHTaJIblIOrO 1I3yqelIHH
pOJIII OTp;eJIbHhIX MhIlli B OIITorelIeTH'IeCKOllf cpopMo06pa30BaHHII YIepena
y 06e3bHII, IICCJIep;OBaIIIIP 0 relIeTIIqeCRIIX paCCTOHIIIIHX lIfeiR.D:Y nonYJIH IIH-
MIl RaKorO-TO paHOHa - C pa60TOII 0 lIfIIHepaJIII3a IIIf ROCTHRa B CBH3II C
xapaKTepOM nHTalIHH H COp;epiRalIIIeM MIIKp03JIellfeHTOB B nO'IBaX onpep;e-
JIelIlIoro paHOlIa. AHTpono';lOr CeII'IaC - 3TO II cpH3HOJIOr, II relIeTIIK, If p;aiRe
6HOXIIMIIR, 011 - KOMnJIeKCIIIIK, II OTJIH'IaeT ero OT KJIaCCII'IeCKIIX npep;CTa-
BIITeJIeH 3Tnx Cne HaJIbHOCTeH, paOOTaIOm;IIX Hap; 'IeJIOBeKOllf, JIHllib Tpap;II-
HOIIHoe CTpeMJIelIIIe C IIC'IepnhlBaIOm;eH nOJIIIOTOH OXBaTnTb TeppIITOpHaJIb-
HbIe BapHa IIH 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOrO BIIp;a II nOHHTb IIX cpOpMIIpOBalIHe B CBH3II
C relIeTII'IeCRHMH B3aIIlIfOOTIIOllielIIIHMH C P;PyrIIMH BIIp;allfH H YCJIOBIIHlIfH
cpep;bI.
Bce 3TO n03BOJIIfJIO BbID;BIIIIYTb II aprYllfelITIIpOBaTb HeCKOJIbKO OYIelIb 06-
DJ;IIX KOII en IIH, IIanpIIMep ROII en HIO 3KOJIOrIIII 'IeJIOBeKa. B eJIOllf 3KO-
JIOrIIH 'IeJIOBeKa OXBaTbIBaeT O'leHb lliIIpORIIH Kpyr BonpOCOB, ropa3p;0 60JIee
lliIIpOKIIH, qellf aHTpOnOJIOrHH B Y3KOM ClIfbICJIe CJIOBa. ho lIfOpcpOcpH3IIOJIO-
rIIqeCKaH II relIeTH'leCKaH ap;anTa HII, II3Y'IaellfbIe aHTpOnOJIOrallfH; CO IIaJIb-
HbIe a)J;anTa HII R cpep;e II op;Horo 06m;eCTBelIlIoro ROJIJIeKTHBa K p;pyrOMY;
H3Y'laeMhIe 3TlIorpacpaMH, reorpacpaMII II COl(IIOJIOraMII; np06JIeMhI co:qHaJIb-
HO-TeXIIIfqeCKOrO nporpecca, B RoplIe nepeCTpaHBaIOm;ero CO IIaJIbIIYIO H
IIPIIPOMYIO cpe,p;y, np06JIeMhI, CTOHIIJ;He B HaCTOHm;ee BpeMH B II;elITpe Bcen
COBpeMelIlIOH IIaYRII If TeXIIHKH II IICCJIe.D:yellfbIe n03TOMY npep;CTaBIITeJIHMII
pa3IIhIX Cne HaJIbIIOCTeH. AIITpOnOJIOrII CBOIIlIfH ROIIKpeTlIhIMII IICCJIep;OBaHHH-
MIl II TeOpeTH'leCKIIMII pa3pa60TKallfH BHeCJIII 3IIa'IIITeJIblIhIH BRJIap' B TaKoe
lIlIfeHIIO nOIIIIlIfaHIIe 3ap;a'I, rpalIH II npOOJIeM 3KOJIOrHIf qeJIOBeKa.
K. BarnH co06paiRelIIIH 06 060ram;eHIIH TeMaTIIKII COBpellIeIIHOII alITpo-
nOJIOrHH H HCnOJIb30BalIIIH lIfHorIIX HOBbIX MeTop;OB BeplIbI JIHllib OT'IaCTII.
o KaROH IIOBOH cpII3IIo.TIOrH'IeCKOH aHTpOnOJIOrHII lIfOiReT HP;TII pe'Ib, eCJIH
nepBhle pa60ThI 06 ap;anTHBlIoH npIIpop;e paCOBhlX npn3HaKOB nOHBIIJIIICb B
Ha'IaJIe 20-x rop;OB, a nepBaH CPOPllfYJIIIpOBKa callfOH H)J;eII npIIlIap'JIeiRHT em;e
M. RaIITY? Torp;a iRe, B 1919 1'., 6bIJI OTKphIT cpaKT pa3JIH'IHH 'IeJIOBeqeCRIIX
nonYJIHrr;nH no cpelIoTHnaM CIICTeMbI ABO. EIIOXIIMIIIO II C.TPYKTYPY P;JIHH-
IIhIX KOCTeH KOlIeqHOCTeH 06CTOHTeJIbHO IICCJIep;OBaJIII YiRe 40 JIeT Ha3ap;.
RaRIIM 6hI 60raTCTBOM IIa6JIIOJJ:emiH HH pacnOJIaraJIII COBpeMelIlIbIe alITpono-
relIe3 H paCOBep;elIHe no cpaBlIelIIIIO C Tellf, 'ITO IIaXOp;HJIOCb B nx pacnopH-
melIIIII IIeCKOJIbKO .n:ecHTHJIeTHH IIa3ap;, OCHOBlIhle Hp;eII B 3TIIX 06JIaCTHX-
mIIBOTlIoe npOHCXOlli]J;eIIHe 'IeJIOBeKa, CTap;HaJIblIbIII xapaRTep alITponoreHe3a,
IIealIp;epTaJIhCKaH cpa3a B 3BOJIIO HH 'IeJIOBeKa, HepapxHH paCOBhIX npH3IIa-
ROB II pac - p;aBIIO CCPOPMYJIHpOBalIbI II p;OKa3aHhI.
Oc06elIII0 6ecnepcneKTIIBHbIMH II TeOpeTII'IeCRH COllfIIHTe.:'IblIbIMII lIfHe Ra-
mYTCH Hp;eH HOBOH 3ROJIOrIIH 'IeJIOBeRa H Bo06m;e BbIp;eJIelIHe 3Toro Kpyra
BonpOCOB B KaqeCTBe caMOCTOHTeJIhlIOH OTpaCJIII 3HaHHH, npIIJJ:aHIIe ep;IIIICT-
Ba CYMMe pa3IIo06pa3HhlX cpaKTOB II rnnOTe3. MeiR,ZJ;y 6HOJIOrH'IeCKOH ap;an-
Ta IIeM qeJIOBe'IeCRHX nonYJIH nH II IIX CO HaJIbHOH ap;anTa HeH K npIIpop;-
HOH cpep;e H APyr K p;pyry HeT HH'IerO 06m;ero. Y CJIOmlIelIIIe CO IIaJIbIIOR
cpep;bI - TeMa COII;IIOJIOrOB, 3KOHOMHCTOB, HCTOpIIKOB, II olla He IIMeeT HHRa-
Roro OTHOllieHIIH R 6nOJIOrIIH RaK COBpeMeHHoro qeJIOBeKa, TaK Hero npep;-
101
I
ROB. BOnpOCaMIJ yCJIOiRHelIHH npIJpO;lJ;HOii Cpep;bI II ee pa3pyrneHIJH 1JeJIOBe-
'IeCRIIMII KOJI.;reKTHBaMH 3alIHlIfaIOTCH reorpacpbI. 3KOIIOMHCThI, 300JIOrn,
60TaIIIIKII, 110 HHRaR lIe aIITpOnOJIOrII. BY.D:YIT\ee pa3BIITHe 'IeJIOBeqeCKHX KOJI-
JIeKTIIBOB B TaROH H3MelIelIHOH CO HaJIbIIOH H npHpo.n:IIOH cpep;e - 60JIbrne
Bcero np06JIellfa CKJIap;bIBaIOm;eHCH CeH'IaC CPYTYPOJIOrIIH, a He RaKHX-TO
ROHRpeTlIhIX HaYK C YiRe onpeD;eJIHBIIIIIMCH npeII:\IeTOllf HCCJIep;OBaIIIfH. BbI-
p;e.rrenue 3KOJIOrIIU 'IeJIOBeKa KaK OT)J;eJIbIIOH ccpepbI 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOrO 3IIaIIHH-
p;alIb Mop;e, UD;ym;eH CO CTOpOlIbI 6ypmya3Hol1 IIaYKII, calif 0 ynOTpe6JIeHlIB
TepllfIIlIa <<3KOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa» eCTb ne3aKOlIHoe nepelIecelI:IIe IIa qeJIOBeqe-
CKoe 06m;eCTBO TepllfUIIOJIOrIIH, HMeIOm;eII ClIfbICJI TOJIbKO no OTHornelIHIO R
co06m;eCTBallf iRUBOTlIhIX. TaRoe CJIOBoynoTpe6JIelIHe, KCTaTH CKa3aTb, IIe-
O)J;HORpaTIIO nop;BepraJIOCb RpIITIIKe B COBeTCKOH cpHJIOCOCPCKOH H Mep;II IIII-
CKOll JIIITepaType.
W. HeJIb3H COrJIaCIITbCH HII C OP;HHM 1I3 Bac, XOTH lIfOH CIIlIfnaTl1H 60JIb-
rne IIa CTopOlIe P, paryIOm;ero 3a ROMnJIeKClIhIH nop;XOil. )J;eHCTBHTeJIbIIO,
6rrOXUMHH II MIIKPOCTpYKTypa YIeJIOBeqeCKOrO CKeJIeTa II3Y'IaIOTCH YiRe 60JIb-
rne 40 JIeT. Ho pa3Be 3a 3TH 40 JIeT IIH'IerO lIe IIpOII30rnJIO H pa60TbI IIa-
rnIIX COBpeMelIHHKOB B 3TOH 06JIaCTH He OTJIUqaIOTCH cym;ecTBeHIIO H p;aiRe
-npHII IInIIaJIbIIO OT CTaTeH COpOKaJIeTlIeH .n:aBIIOCTH? B nepBbIX aIITpOnOJIO-
rIIqeCKIIX IICCJIep;OBaIIIIHX IIa 3TY TeMY CTaBIIJIaCb 3ap;a'Ia onpe)J;eJIelIMH TIIIIO-
-BOH IIOpMbI, xapaKTeplIOH P;JIH Homo sapiens, T. e. npIII\IeplIO Ta iRe 3a)J;a-
qa, RaRaH Bcerp;a CTOHT nepep; alIaTOllfaMn. B JIyqrneM CJIyqae nOJIY'IelIlIhIe
pe3Y JIbTaThI paccMaTpIIBaJIIICb B cpaBIIIITeJIblIO-alIaTOllfIfqeCKOllf acneKTe H
I2ICTOJIKOBbIBaJIHCb cpHJIOrelIeTII'IecKH. I1CCJIe)J;oBalIlfH nOCJIeIIIIHX JJ;BYX D;eCHTW-
JIeTIIH BbfHBIIJIII pa3IIo06pa3IIe 'IeJIOBeqeCKHX nonYJIH Hll no' ypmmIO MIIlIe-
paJlIl3a HH CKeJIeTa, OTpaiRaIOm;eMY II 6IIOXIIMII'IecKYIO xapaKTepIIcTIIKY,
H MIIKpOMopcpOJIOrH'IecKYIO CTPYKTYPY KOCTII: cO)J;epiRalIHe RaJIb HH II IIaCbI-
m;eIIIIOCTh ;rrpyrIIMII MHKp03JIeMelITaMH - BaiRlIaH CTPYKTyplIaH xapaKTepI2I-
CTHKa YIeJIOBe'IeCKOrO CKeJIeTa, B TO iRe BpeMH 3TO, eCTeCTBeIIIIO, H 6UOXIIMII-
qeCKI-IH nOKa3aTeJIb. BbfHBJIelIIIOe pa3IIo06pa3ne YBH3aHO C reOXIIMH'IeCKIIM
COCTOHIII1eM COOTBeTCTBYIOm;HX reorpacpHqeCKI-IX paHOHOB, npOCJIemelIhI nYTb
nocTyn.rreIIIfH lIfIIRpO- H MaKp03JIeMeHTOB C BOP;OH H nIIm;eH B opraHH3M
'IeJIOBeKa, UX 06MeII II KOII eIITpa IIH B opralIII3Me, HX CPYIIK IIOlIaJIhlIaH
pOJIb KaK CTUMYJIHTOpOB IIJIII p;enpeccopoB pOCTOBbIX npo eccoB.
ho JIHrnb OP;HII npHlIfep HCCJIep;OBaIIHH XOTH U BaiRIIOrO, 110 ep;I2IHCTBeH-
1101'0 npII3HaKa. TaKHe rrpIIlIfepbI MOiRlIO YMIIOiRaTb D;O 6eCROHe'IIIOCTII-
lIe B IIIIX p;eJIo. Ra'IeCTBelIlIo HOBbIH nop;xop; K IIIITepnpeTa HII npII3IIaKa,
yCTaHOBJIeHIIe ROIIKpeTIIOH CBH3H MeiRp;y pa3IIo06pa3Hellf npH3IIaKa I2I TeM:II
II.JIII UlIhIMII reOXIIMUqeCKI-1MII, KJIHMaTIIqeCKI-1l1fH II .D:pyrulIfH CBOllCTBallfH nPH-
pOD;IIhIX 3011 B npeileJIaX ero apeaJIa - BOT qTO npnlI:qHnIIaJIblIO OTJIHqaeT
HOBhIe pa60ThI OT CTapbIX. TaROH nOIIXOP; p;aJI B03MOiRIIOCTb YBIIJJ;eTb reorpa-
cpIIqeCRYIO npnypO'IelIHOCTb COqeTaUIIII npII3IIaKOB - ap;anTIIBlIbIX TIInOB,
npHcnoc06I2ITeJIblIhIX no CBoeH npnpo.n:e II pacnpep;eJIelIlIhIX no 3ellfHOH no-
BepXIIOCTII B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3aKOlIOllf reorpacpH'IeCKOH 30HaJIhIIOCTH.
K. no IIarneMY lIflIelIIIIO, ap;anTHBHhIe THnbI CKopee npIIMep O'IelIb BbICO-
Koro ypOBIIH IIaY'IIIOH a6CTpaK HII, KOHCTPYR:qHH Yllfa, a lIe peaJIhlIO cym;e-
CTByIOm;ee HBJIeIIIIe.
W. ECJIII aD;anTHBlIhIX THnOB lIe CYIT\eCTByeT, TO RaR 06'hHCHHTb, qTO
HBHO cym;ecTByeT CBH3b lIfemJJ;y lIfOpcpOcpH3IIOJIOrHqeCKIIMlI oc06elIIIOCTHMH
nonYJIH nH, KOTOphIe IIaCeJIHIOT KaKOH-IIH6YP;b reorpacpU'IeCRIIH nOHC,
H cpII3IIKo-reorpacpH'IeCKHMH oc06elIIIOCTHlIfH 3Toro nOHca? Ap;anTHBlIhIe
THnhI HlIfeIOT 30lIaJIblIOe pacnpOCTpaHelIHe. B03l1fOm1I0, IIMelIHO B 3TOllf CO-
CTOIIT pa3rap;Ka Toro Bonpoca, IIa KOTOphIH IIeT nOKa 0p;II03IIa1JIIOrO OTBeTa,-
I
102
Bonpoca 0 COOTIIOmeHHH paCOBbIX H a)];aUTIIBHhIX TIInOB. BeCbMa BepOHTHO,
qTO a)];anTHBlIhIe THnhI - 3TO 30lIaJIblIbIe paCbI, IIMeIOIIlIIe ImJR)J;aH ROIIBep-
relITlIoe rrpOHcxom)J;eIIIIe, 110 B TO iRe BpeMH 3aHHMaIOm;IIe 60JlbmIIe apeaJlbI.
BpeMH HX cpOpMIIpOBanHH, O'IeBH)];IIO, OTIIOCHTCH K pa3IIbIM XpOIIOJIOrIIqeCKIIlIf
anoxaM pa3BHTIIH qeJIOBe'IeCTBa: B TpOnHqeCRnX II cy6TpOnHqeCKHX paHOHax
3eMuoro mapa, 3aCe.:'IelIlIbIX C callfhlX palIIIIIX nepIIop:OB HIIiRIIerO naJIeOJIII-
Ta, a)];arrTIIBlIhIe TIIrrhI 06pa30BaJlHCb cpaBHHTeJlblIO paHO, B ApKTIIKe-
cpaBHHTeJIbHO rr03)];IIO. B CTapOH JIIITepaType 060 Bcellf 3TOM He OhIJIO HH
0)];1101'0 CJIOBa. He rOBopH yiRe 0 relIeTH'IeCKHX acneKTax Bcex 3THX np06-
JIeM, eJIOM MaCCIIBe pa60T, nOCBHm;elIlIhIX relIeTHqeCKIIM MapKepallf y 'IeJIO-
BeKa, pa60T, B KaKOH-TO Mepe BbI3BaBrnHX R iRH3IIlI norrYJIH HOHHYIO ROH-
rr;err IIIO pacbI, )J;O KaKoM-To CTenelIH OTBeTCTBelIHbIX Bo06m;e 3a nepecTpoHKY
IIamero MhlmJIelIIUI IIa nOIIYJIH IIOlIlIbln JIaJ..\.
CJIomeII Bonpoc 0 rpalIII ax 3KOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeRa, H 3TO, 1I0iRaJIYll, e)];HH-
cTBeHlIbIH, XOTH II CPYII)J;aMeIITaJIbHhIH rrYHKT, B KOTOpOM H paCXOiRycb C P.
Crre IIcpIIKa 3KOJIOrIIII qeJIOBeKa 6yp:eT yTepHlIa, eCJIH nO)];pa3YMeBaTb rroJ..("
IIeH TaKoH rnHpoKHll Rpyr BorrpocoB, KaKOH o'Iep'IeII P. Hallfe'IelIlIbIe HM
TellfbI IIe06hI'IalllI0 IIIITepeClIhI, 110 HX paccMoTpeHIIe paCna)];aeTCH, Ha IIWH
B3rJIH)];, rro pa3IIhIM HayRaM. B TO iRe BpeMH He lIfory COrJIaCIITbCH II
C BaMH B OTKa3e 3KOJIOrHII qeJIOBeKa (II HaYKe H TepllfIIIIY) B rrpaBe Ha
cym;ecTBoBaHHe, B o elIRe ee TOJIbKO KaR MO)];bI, IIlIcrrIIpHpOBalIHOH 3apy6eiR-
IIbIlIfH pa60TaMII. Pa3YllfeeTCH, B 3KOJIOrHH mHBOTlIbIX MlIoro crre:qHcpIIqeCRIIX
MeTo.n:OB, B 3KOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa, Ha060pOT, lIfHoro cBoe06pa3HH B HIITepnpe-
Ta IIII MaTepIIaJIa; CO HaJIbHaH npIIpop:a 'IeJIOBeKa HaKJIa)J;bIBaeT MOm;HYro
ne'IaTb Ha BeCb xapaKTep 6IIOJIOrH'IeCKIIX a)];anTa nH, 110 3TO 06CTOHTeJIhCT-
BO lIe HBJIHeTCH HerrpeO)];OJIIIlIfbHI rrpenHTCTBHeM p:JlH yrroTpe6J1elIHH B 060IIX
CJIyqaHX 0)];1101'0 TepMHlIa, npIIJIaraeMOro B rrepBOllf CJIY'Iae K iRIIBOTlIbIlIf,
BO BTOpOllf K 'IeJIOBeKY. OrpalIIIqfiTeJIblIOe nOHHMalIHe 3ROJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa,
YCTalIOBJIelIHe ee paMOR TOJIbRO B npe)J;eJIax 6IIOJIOrnqeCKHX II CO IIaJIbHhlX
aJ],anTa HH )];aIOT )];OrrOJIIIIITeJIbHOe TeOpeTHqeCKOe rrpaBO ynoTpe6JIHTh 3TOT
TepMIIH, 3n IIeHlIfelIIIeM nOKa JIY'Imero. HanOMIIIO orrpeJ],eJIeHIIe 3KOJIOrHII,
J],alIlIoe aBTopOllf TepMIIHa II caMoro rrOIIHTHH 8. reKReJIellf: no)]; 3KOJIOrIIen
OH nOIIIIMaJI OTlIomeHHe mHBOTlIoro K cpe;rre H K )];pyrHM mIIBOTHbIM II pac-
TeIIIIHlIf. HYiRlIO 6JIIIiRe )];epiRaTbCH 3Toro RJlaCCH'IeCROrO onpeJ],eJleIIIIH. BBO-
J..\H B Hero OTMe'IeIIIIOe BbIme OrpalIIIqelIHe II nOMIIH, qTO B CBH3H C Oom;e-
CTBelIlIOH npIIpOJ],OH 'IeJIOBeKa B ero 3ROJIOrIIH OCHOBlIoe MeCTO 3aHHlIfaIOT
He IIII)J;IIBH.n:YYllfbI, a rronYJIH HII IIJIH )];pyrIIe CO HaJIblIbIe H 6IIOJIOrIIqeCRIIe
rpynrrbI (COBoKyrrlIocTH nonYJlH HH, paCOBbIe 06m;IIOCTH, IIapo.n:bI II T. J],.).
MomHO CCPOPMYJIHpOBaTb 06m;ee onpe)J;eJIeIIHe: 3ROJIOrHJI 'IeJIOBeKa - HaYRa
o 6IIOJIOrHqeCKlIX n CO IIaJIblIhlX aJ..\arrTa HHX R cpeJ],e Ha rpynnoBoM ypOB-
lIe. B3aIIMOOTIIomelIHH lIfeiR)];y 'IeJIOBe'IeCRHMII KOJIJIeKTIIBaMII II3yqaIOTCJI
lIflIorHMH J],pyrHMH HaYKaMII, II HX lIe IIymlIo BBO)];IITb B 3KOJIOrIIIO 'IeJIOBe-
Ka. lllIbIMII CJIOBaMH, 3TO HaYKa 06 aJ],arrTa:qIIHX, a lIe 0 ROOa)];arrTa HHX B
'IeJIOBeqeCROM 06m;eCTBe.
P. 8TO IICKYCCTBelIlIoe CYiRelIHe npeJ],lIfeTa 3KOJIOrHII'IeJIOBeKa. BbI IICRJIIO-
'meTe II3 onpe)];eJIelIHH 8. reRKeJIH BamHeHmyIO qaCTb.
W. .H BhIIIrpbIBaIO B HCIIOCTH onpe)];eJIelIlIH rpaHH HaYKII II, B 'IaCTHO-
CTII, onpe)];eJIelIIIH caMoro rrpe].l,lIfeTa IICCJIe)];OBaHIIH. B3aIIMOOTHOmelIIIJI
lIfem)];y 'IeJlOBe'IeCRHlIfH KOJIJIeRTIIBaMII IIe06hIqaHHO CJIOiRlIbI, 3TO II RYJIbTYP-
IIbIH 06MelI, II BOHlIbI, II lIflIoroe .n:pyroe. ECJlH RYJIbTYPlIbIH 06MeH C 60Jlb-
mHlIf TPY)];OM em;e lIfOiRlIO nQ)];BeCTII nO)J; rrpe)];lIfeT 3KOJIOrIIH, TO YiR BOHnbI-
HHKaK. 3)];eCb H)];eT pe'Ih 0 RaKOH-TO rrpHH IInIIaJIbHO HHOH cpopMe MemKOJI-
JIeKTHBlIbIX ROHTaKTOB.
103
G. TpY)J;HO nO)J;BeCTH nO)J; 6IIOJIOrIIqeCKOe ITOHHTHe 3ROJIOrIIH CO:qHaJIbHhIe
MeXaIIII3M.bJ B3aIIlIfOOTIIorneHIflI KOJIJIeKTHBOB JIIO;rreM.
W. n03TOMY H If IICRJIIO'IaIO MemrpynnOBbIe KOIITaKThI H3 3KOJIOrIIH qe-
JIOBeKa, OCTaBJIHH B ee paMRax JIl1rnb II3y'IeHHe BJIlUIIII1H npHpop:nOH Cpe.D:bI
Ha qeJIOBe'IeCKHe rpynnhI H, B CBOIO O'Iepe)J;h, HX peaK:qHIO IIa cpe)J;Y.
A. )J;OJliRelI npII3IIaThCH, 'ITO MOH TOqKa 3pelIHH He 6Y)J;eT cnoc06CTBO-
EaTb KOllfIIpmmCCIIOlIfY 3aBepIIIelIIIIO pa3ropeBIIIerOCH cnopa, olla aJIbTeplIa-
nnma no OTIIOIIIeHHIO KO BceM BhlCKa3alIIIbIlIf B3rJIH)J;aM Ha cym;IIOCTb, rpa-
IIIIl(bI II npe)J;MeT I1CCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH 'IeJIOBe'IeCROM 3KOJIOrIIH, a TaRme Ha ee
MeCTO B KOllfllJIeKCe aHTpOnOJIOI'l1'IeCKI1X HayK. npeTK)J;e 'reM rOBopIITb 06
3TOM, cKamy IIeCKO.JIbRO CJIOB 0 )J;PyroM, 0 TOllf, qTO BOJIlIyeT IIac Bcex II C
qero IIa'IaJICH IIaIII pa3roBop,- 0 COBpellfelIHOM 3Tane B pa3BHTIIlI alITpono-
JIorI1U u ero OTIIOIIIelIIIII R npe)J;bIp:ym;eMY. TOJIbRO B CBeTe 06m;IIX CPOp fY-
JIIIpOBOI{ 0 CTpYKType aIITpOIIo.JIOrII'IeCROrO 3IIalIHH B eJIOllf IIlIfeeT CMbICJI
npII3uaBaTL IIJIII OTpII aTb caMOCTOHTeJIblIOe CYlQeCTBOBalIIIe 3KOJIOrHII qeJIO-
BeKa, paCCYffi,J,aTb 0 ee MeCTe BIIYTPII 3TOH CTpYKTYPhI, BKJIIO'IaTb alITpono-
JIOrIIIO B 3KOJIOI'lIIO, RaK 3TO c)J;eJIaJI KOJIJIera P, I1JIII, IIa060pOT, 3KO.JJOI'l1IO
B aIITpOIIOJIOrHIO, KaK 3TO ;rreJIaeT KOJIJIera W.
W. AIUpOnOJIOrIIH Ii 3KOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa, C MoeH TO'IKII 3peJUIH,- calif 0-
CTOJITeJIblIhIe OTpaCJIH 3IIaIIIIH, JIUrnh 'IaCTII'IIIO nepeCeKaIOm;I1eCH B Tex 'Iac-
THX KaiR)J;OH 113 IIHX, KOTophIe CBH3aJIbI C II3yqelIHeM 6IIOJIOrH'IeCKIIX ap:arr-
Ta IIii:. HX xapaRTepa, 3TanOB cpOpllfHpOBalIHH H T. )J;.
A. CJIe)J,OBaTeJILIIO, H Bac lIe nOIIHJI. ECJIII rOBopIITb 0' COBpeMeHIIOM 3Ta-
ne pa3BHTHH alITpOnOJIOrIIH II )J,PyrHx 6IIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX ,IJ;IICl(HnJIIIII, H3Y'IaIO-
IQI1X 'IeJIOBeKa, TO B rrepBYIO O'Iepe)J;h HYffiHO rOBopIITb 0 relIeTH'IeCKOM nO)J;-
xO)J;e R 6HOJIOrIlI1 qe.rrOBeKa. hOT relIeTII'IeCKIIH nO)J;xo)J, BblHBJIHeTCH He TOJIh-
KO B TOM, 'ITO .IICCJIe,ZJ;OBaIIO 60JIbIIIOe qHCJIO npH3IIaKOB C II3BeCTIIbIM THnOllf
HaCJIe)J;OBaIIHH H B pHp:e CJIY'IaeB nepexo)J; OT cpelIOTHna K reHoTIIrry ocym;e-
CTBJIHeTCH aBTOllfaTHqeCKH. 011 )J;aiRe He B TOM, 'ITO )J;JIH MlIorlIX CHCTeM
relIeTI1qeCRHX MapKepOB OTKphITbI npIIcnoc06IITeJIhlIbIe lIfexaHH3MbI, a TaR
Ha3bIBaeMbIH IIaCJIeL\CTBelIlIhIii: 6aJIalICHpOBalIIIhlH no.rrHMopcpH3l1f npH3IIaeTCH,
H BnOJIlIe cnpaBe)J;JIlfBO, O)J,HIIM II3 MarHCTpaJIblIbIX nYTeH cpopllfo06pa30BalIlIH.
HeCMOTpH Ha TO 'ITO pa3JIH'IHH MeiR,ZJ;Y rpynnaMH JIIOlJ;eH no CIICTeMe ABO
lJ;eIICTBHTeJIhHO OTKpbIThI JI. fHpIIIcpeJIb,ZJ;ToM 55 JIeT Ha3a)J;, KaK 06 3TOM 1'0-
BOpI1Jl G, HhIHeIIIIIIIH ypoBelIb H3Y'IeHIIH HCKJIIO'II1TeJIbIIOrO pa3IIo06pa3lIH
qeJIOBeqeCKOrO opralIII3l1fa no rpynnallf RpOBH, 6eJIKallf CbIBOpOTKH, cpepMelI-
TaTIIBHbIlIf peaK:qIIHM HII B ROJIHqeCTBeHlIollf, HII B Ka'IeCTBeIIIIOllf OTIIOIIIelIIIH
HecpaBIIHlIf C TeM, qTO 6bIJIO IIeCROJIbKO lJ;eCHTHJIeTHH Ha3a)J;. .H BHiRy 3Ha-
'IeHHe relIeTHqeCKOro nO,ZJ;Xo)J,a npeiR)J;e Bcero B callfOH nepecTpoHKe alITpo-
rrOJIOrIfqeCKOrO MhIIIIJIeIIIIH, OC03IIalIHH nonYJIH IIOIIIIOH CTPYKTYPhI 'IeJIOBe-
qeCTBa, B nepeBo)J;e Bcex HJIII nO'ITH Bcex HCCJIe)J;oBaIIHH Ha norrYJIH:qlIolIlIhIn
ypOBeHh, IIaKOlIe , BO BCKphITHH KOJIOCCaJIbHOrO relIeTH'IeCROrO Mlloro06pa-
3IIR qeJIOBe'IeCTBa, B CJIOmHOCTH H MIIOrOJIIIlIeHIIOcTH nYTelI cpOpMIIpoBalIIIH
relIocpolI)J;a 'IeJIOBe'IeCKIIX norryJIHl(HM IIa Bcex 3Tanax IICTOpHII qeJIOBe'IeCTBa.
K. <DIIJIOrelIeTH'IeCRHH II Bo06m;e reHeTUqeCKIIH acneKT B IIIHpOKOM
ClIfhICJIe CJIOBa, BhlHClIeHHe npOHCXOm)J,eIIHH 6HOJIOrIIqeCKHX 06m;HOcTeH, 6Y)J;b
TO paCbI IIJIH TeppHTOpHaJIhHhre rpynnhI L\peBIIHX JIIO)J;eH, Bcer,ll,a 3alIHMaJIH
60JIbIIIOe MeCTO B aIITpOnOJIOrHqeC.l\HX HCCJIe)J;OBaIIIIHX C caMoro IIa'IaJIa HX
ocpopMJIelIIIH B RaqeCTBe caMOCTOHTeJIblIOH )J;HC:qIIIIJIIIlIhI, T. e. C Cepe.D:IIHhI
rrpOIII.lIOrO BeKa. BcnOMHIITe OCHOBaTeJIen PYCCKOH alITpOnOJIOrIIII It M. E3pa,
A. n. EOrlJ;aHOBa - Mlloro CHJI :II BIIHlIfaHIfH y)J;eJIHJIII 01I1I relIe3Ifcy pa3JIII'I-
IIbIX paCOBhIX THnOB. A. n. Eor)J;aHoB em;e B 70-x rOL\ax npOIIIJIOrO BeKa
c.pOPllfYJIHpOBaJI rrpIIHlJ;Hn H3MeHeHHH pacoBhlx npH3IIaKOB BO BpeMelIII. nep-
104
BhI€ cpHJIOreHeTII'IeCRIIe IfCCJIe)J;OBaHIIH T. reKCJIH II R. <PorTa, 3aTellf npo-
)J;OJImelIlIhI€ 8. reRKeJIel\f, r. IlIBaJIb6e, E. }J;I06ya, A. M3COllf, r. Oc60p-
HOllf, ¥. rperopII, <P. Ball).l;elIpalIxollf, B HaCTOHm;ee Bpe fH ycrrernHo pa3BH-
BaIOTCH <P. RJIapKOllf XaY3JIJIOllf, r. ReIIHrCBaJIb)];TOllf, r. ¥JIJIbpHXOM,
lIflIorHlIfH COBeTCKIIlIfII alITpOnOJIOrallfIf. OIIH 6a3IIpYIOTCH Ha RJIaCCIIqeCRHX
MopcpOJIOrH'IeCKHX lIfeTO)];aX, cpaBIIIfTeJIblIOllf HCTOJIROBalIHH BhIHBJIelIHbIX
lIfopcpOJIOrII'IeCKIIlIf IIa6JIIO)];eHIIellf pa3JIHqHH B CTpYRTypax CKeJIeTa H )];pyrHx
CHCTellf H rrOJIY'IaIOT OT'IeTJIHBbIe relIeTIIqeCRIIe BbIBO)J;hI: IIaJIH O relIeTH'Ie-
CKHII rrO)J;xOA B nOJIHOM CMbICJIe 3Toro CJIOBa 6e3 BCHROH relIeTIIKH, 6Y)J;b TO
relIeTIIKa ITII.n:HBIf.n:YYIlIa IIJIH nonYJIHII;HOlIlIaH.
A. HeB03l1fomHo OTpIfII;aTb )J;OCTIImeIIHH cpaBHHTem,Hon ?wPWOJIOI'lIH B pe-
ROIICTPYR HII OCHOBlIhlX 3TanOB alITporroreHe3a H )J;peBHeHIIIHx CTa)];IIH paco-
06pa30BaHHH, H H YBepeH, 'ITO HIIKTO H3 MOIIX KOJIJIer-aIITponOreHeTHROB
l')Toro lIe )J;eJIaeT. Ho HYiRlIO He 3a6bIBaTb H 0 )];Pyrollf: Tpe60BalIHH K c.TeneHII
060CHOBaHIIOCTH BbIBO,)];OB nOCTOHIIHO paCTYT B Xo.n:e HaY'IIIOrO pa3BHTHH II TO,
'ITO Y)J;OBJIeTBOpHJIO IIaIIIHX npe)];IIIeCTBeHHHROB, He lIfOiReT Y)J;OBJIeTBOpHTb
Hac, RaiReTCH HeTOqHbIlIf, He)J;OCTaTOqHO aprYlIfeHTHpOBaHlIbIM. JII060H callfbIH
-060CIIOBaIIHbIII BhIBO,ll" aprYlIfeHTHpOBaHHbIH lIfopcpOJIOruqeCKHlIfII ,ll,aHHbIMII,
06H3aTeJIeH II y6e)J;HTeJIeH TOJIbKO )];0 Tex rrop, nOKa lIfbI 6eaorOBOpOqHO Be-
pHlIf B TO, 'ITO JII06bIe MopcpOJIOrH'IeCRIIe CTPYKTYPbI reHeTH'IeCKH )];eTepllfII-
HHpOBalIhI .H IIerrpellfeHIIO OTpamaIOT relIe3HC rpyrrll. 8TO HHKor)J;a He 6bIJIO
C'I'poro AOKa3aiIo .n:JIH cpOpllf BH)];OBOrO H BHYTPHBII)];OBOrO ypOBWI. BeCbllfa Be-
pOHTlIhIlIf RameTCH )];ame rrpe)];rrOJIOmeIIHe, COrJIaCHO ROTOPOllfY qellf IIHiRe TaR-
COIIOllfII'IeCmrH paHr Tex HJIH IIlIbIX cpOpllf, Tellf MelIbIIIYIO pOJIb III'paeT B IIX
CHCTellIaTHKe MopcpOJIOrHH. MopcpOJIOrII'IeCKOe 060CHOBalIHe CHCTellfaTHKH
6JIH3KIIX cpOpllf orrHpaeTCH Ha MeJIRHe MopcpOJIOrH'IeCRHe )];eTaJIH, a OHIJ B CIIJIb-
IIOH CTenelIII rrO)J;BepmelIhI BJIHHHHIO Cpe)];hI, CXO)];CTBO B HIIX 'IaCTO npe)J;CTaB-
JIHeT C060ll pe3YJIbTaT KOHBeprelIII;HH. Bce TPY)J;IIOCTH BII)J;OBOH H BIIYTPHBII-
)];OBOH CIJCTellfa'£IIKH HpRO )J;ellfolIcTpHPYIOT OrpalIH'IelIIIOCTb lIfopcpOJIOrHqeCKOrO
rro)lxo)J;a )J;ame B ero relIeTII'IeCKOH cpopllfe. Bo BCHKOllf cJIY'Iae, HHKTO CeII'IaC
lIfopcpOJIOrIIeH B CHCTeMaTHKe IIII3IIIHX KaTeroplIH lIe OrpaIIH'IHBaeTCH, a B
alITpOrrOJIOrHII lIfhI HMeeM )J;eJIo B rrepBYIO OqepeAb C TaKoH cHcTellfaTIIRoH.
P. TaRoe paccYiR)J;elIIIe rro)J;phlBaeT Bepy B O)J;HY H3 OCIIOB KJIaCCIIqeCKou:
6IIOJIOrIIII.
N. A Bepa B CIIJIY lIfopcpOJIOrHII RaK OCIIOBhI peKolIcTpYK HH relIeTlIqeCKHX
B3aHlIfooTIIOIIIeI?-IIll KpyrrlIhIx TaKCOIIOB Bce iRe OCTaeTCH IIerroKoJIe6HlIfoH.
A. MhI rro)J;!lIIMaeM H paCCIIIaTpIIBaellf Bce 3TII BonpochI lIe B 06meH cpop-
life, a rrpJUreHIITeJIblIO R 3aD;a'Iallf II B03l1fOiRHOCTHlIf HallIeH IIaYKH. COBepIIIeH-
110 O'IeBII)];IIO, qTO Bce cpIIJIOrelIeTHqeCKHe peKoHcTpyKl(HH B alITponorelIe3e
IIMeIOT CBOIIM OCIIOBamIeM OT'IeTJIHBO HecpopllfYJIHpyeMYIO, CKPhlTYIO. Bepy B
relIeTHqeCRYIO 06YCJIOBJIeHHOCTb IICCJIeAyellfbIx H rrpHBJIeRaellfbIX B 3THX pe-
KOIICTPYK:qHf.iX Mopcp1"lJIOrII'IeCKHX CTpyKTYP. Mem)];y Tellf TaKaH relIeTII'IeCKaH
06YCJIOBmiiuIOcTh - rHnOTe3a. COBpellfeHlIaH rronYJIH IIOHlIaH reHeTIIKa 'IeJIO-
BeKa rrpe)];JIaraeT BMeCTO Bephl 3IIaHIIe, n ee peKolIcTpYK IIII relIeTlIqeCKIIX
cIITya IIH orrIIpaIOTCH Ha TOqlIhle cpaKThI, a He IIa npe)];nOJIOmeIIHH.
Crre HcpIfKa nO)J;06Horo TO'IIIOrO relIeTH'IeCKOrO rro)J;Xo)];a HCIIO BH)J;Ha B pe-
IIIelIlIII TOH np06JIellfbI, 0 ROTOpOH MhI cero)J;IIH Mlloro rOBOpIIJIH, - rrp06JIeMhI
rpalIII II cym;ecTBa 3KOJIOrHII 'IeJIOBeRa. MOiRlIO COrJIaCHTbCH C OrpalIIIqelIII-
ellf 3aAa'I 3KOJIOrHH qeJIOBeKa JIIIIIIb B3aHlIfOOTIIornelIHHlIfII 'IeJIOBe'IeCKHX KOJI-
JIeKTIIBOB C rrpHpO)J;IIOH Cpe)];OH. npH TaKOllf OrpaHIIqelInII 60JIee qeTRO rrpo-
cTyrraIOT KOHTYPhI rrpe)J;MeTa IICCJIe)J;OBaHHH H orrpe)J;eJIeHHee Oqep'IHBaeTCH
npOTHBorrOCTaBJIeHHe 3ROJIOrIIII 'IeJIOBeKa )J;HC IIrrJIHHallf IICTOpII'IeCKOrO II;HK-
JIB - c06CTBeHHO IICTOpHII, 3KOHOllfHRe H rrOJIIITlIqeCROU: 3ROHOMIIH, CO IIOJIOmH
105
/
I1: 3TlIorpacpIIrr, IICCJIe YIOm;IIlIf KaiR)WH C<i BoeH CTOpOlIbl H C rrplIlIfeHelIIIeM
CBOIIX lIfeTOf],OB Bce pa3IIo06pa3IIe OTIIOrneH12IH II CBH3elI MeiRf],y 'IeJIOBe'IeCKII-
MIl KOJIJIeKTIIBallfH. B3aIIlIfOOTIIOllielIIIH lIfeiRD.Y 06m;eCTBOllf H rrpHpO)J;IIOH cpe-
JJ:oii:, 0 ROTOpblX rOBopIlT (]J, Tpe6YIOT yTOYlHeIIIUI, TaK KaK OTlIornelIIIH 3TII
nO'ITII 6e3rpalIllqlIhI II B ROH e KOIIl(OB f],aiRe nOJIeT qeJIOBeKa B KOClIfOC lIfOiR-
110 IIOf],BeCTII IIOf], B3aIIlIfOOTIIOllielIHH 'IeJIOBeKa H Cpef],bl. (Jj rrpef],JIaraeT orpa-
HIIqIITh 3TII OTlIornelIIIH 6IIOJIOrII'IeCKlIMH II CO IIaJIbHbIMII af],anTa:qHHlIfII K
npllpOJJ:HOII cpe)J;e; eCJIII OCTaBaTbCH B paMRax Harnen IIaYKII, pe'Ib p:OJIiRlIa
IIf],TII, CJIef],OBaTeJIbIIO, 0 6HOJIOrHqeCKIIX af],arrTa HHX. nOCJIef],IIl1e rrOIIIIMaIOT-
CH, K COmaJIeIIIIIO, O'IelIh rro-pa3IIOMY B cym;eCTBYIOm;eH cpH3IIOJIOI'lIqeCROH H
1\fef],HKO-reorpacpIIqeCKOn JIHTepaType: HapHP:Y C KJIaCCl1qeCKIIM, l1f],ym;HM OT
06m;en 6IIOJIOrIlII rrOIIIIIIIaIIIIellf af],arrTa IIH KaK relIeTII'IeCKl1X npHCIIOC06JIelIl1H
vblTyeT II .n:pyroe IIOHHMaIIIIe, CorJIaCIIO ROTOPOMY a)J;arrTa IIH eCTb KpaTKO-
BpeMeHlIaH CPII3IIOJIOrl1qeCKaH peaRl(IIH, 06eCIIeqIIBaIOm;aH rOMeOCTa3. .D:JIH
.aIITpOIIOJIOra OYIeBHf],IIO, 'ITO CJIe.n:yeT pa3rpaHIIqJ:fTb 3TH f],Ba HBJIeIIIIH, nO)J;06-
110 TOllfY KaK 9TO yme 6blJIO Cf],eJIaIIO 40 JIeT Ha3arr B. B. CTalI'IIIIICKIIM,
IiI coxpalIIITb TepllfJIlI «af],anTa IIH» JIHllib 3a Tparrl1l(IIOlllIbIM nOIIIIMaIIHellf.
Bpe:uelIllhIe cpH3HOJIOrH'IeCKIIe Cf],BIIrH rrpl1II:qIIIIHaJIhHO HlIoe HBJIelIIIe lIO
cpaBlIeHIIIO C relIeTuqeCKIIMII af],arrTa HHMII, MbI IIlIfeeM rrpaBO B )J;aIIUOM CJIY-
"'18e rOBopIITb JIIIrnb 0 IIaCJIef],CTBeIIHOllf aKKJIHMaTH3a IIOIIIIOM 3cpcpeKTe. He
BCHKaH 6IIOJIOrHqeCKaH af],anTa IIH (B KOII e KOII OB aKKJInMaTH3a HH TOiRe
RpaTKoBpeMelIlIaH af],arrTa IlH), a JlHrnb CYMMa relIeTH'IeCRH ,06YCJIOBJleHHbIX
H rrepef],aIOm;HXCH rro IIaCJIe)J;CTBY peaK HH COCTaBJIHeT rrpe)J;MeT 3KOJIOrlIH qe-
JlOBeKa B TOH ee 'IaCTH, KOTopaH IIOrpalIIIqna C ero 61I0JlOrIIeH. M3yqaTb me
aKRJIIIMaTH3a HOIIHble Cf],Bl1rH f],eJIO cpII3IIOJIOrOB, Me)J;IIKOB, HO lIe alITpo-
nOJIOrOB. EHOJIOrHqeCKHn acneRT 3KOJlOrIIII 'IeJIOBeKa Hepa3pbIBHO CBH3aH C
.aIITponoreHeTIIKoH, f],aiRe 60Jlee Y3KO - C II3yqelIHeM reHeTIIqeCKIIX MapKepoB.
(]J. Barne npef],.lIOmeIIHe pa3rpaHl1'Il1BaTb relIeTII'IeCKHe a.n:anTa 1I1I l1 aK-
KJIInIa TII3a IIII OqeHb BaiRlIoe. l1 ero, HeCOMHeIIIIO, IIYiRHO npHIIHTh. Op:IIaKO
MlIeIlIIe 06 OC060H pO JIll reHeTH'IeCKHX lIfapKepOB B 3KOJIOrIIII 'IeJlOBeKa IIe-
BeplIO. 3TO - HCKyccTBelIHoe CYiReHIIe rpalIl1 3KOJIOrI2IH qeJIOBe«a II nOIIH-
'fHH relIeTIIqeCKOn ap:anTa HII. MhI II3Y'18ellf OCIIOBIIOH 06l1felI, COf],epiRalIIIe
6eJlKOBbiX cppaKl(HH KpOBII, lIfHlIepaJIl13a l1IO CKe,'!eTa,- IIeCOMlIelIIIa IIaCJIef],-
CTBelIlIaH rreTepMIIIIa HH 3THX cpYHf],allfeIITa.'1bHbIX oco6elIIIOCTen 'IeJIOBe'IeCRO-
1'0 OpraIIl13I1Ia, XOTH ROIIKpeTlIbIe CPOpMhl TaROH f],eTepllfIlIIa.u;HI2I nOKa IIel1a-
BeCTlIhl. 3TO JIIIllib OAlIa CTopOlIa f],eJIa. .D:pyraH - caMa YCJIOBIIOC'Tb nOIIHTIIH
Tella II relIeTn'IeCKOH 06YCJIOBJIelIIIOCTH npH3IIaRa IIpHMelInTeJILIIO K 'IeJIOBe-
Ky. qellf JJ:aJIbllie Mbl npO)J;BIIraellfCH B l13yqelIl11I rpynn KpOBII n I2IX reHeTI2I-
Kl1, .lIanpIIMep, TeM 60JIbllie BCnJIhIBaeT cpaKTOB, IIJIJIIOCTpIIpyIOm;HX 3IIa'IIf-
TeJIblIYIO relIeTHqeCKYIO CJIOiRHOCTh KaiR)J;OH H3 Cl1CTeM, BIIYTPH KOTOpblX OT-
RpbIBaIOT Bce IIOBhle H HOBbIe relIeTIlqeCRl1e cpaKTOphl. CJIOmlIOCTb CHCTellf
ABO II pe3yc - orrIIII H3 npHlIfepoB. AIITponorelIeTIIKII lliHpOKO l1CnOJIh3YIOT
40PMYJIbI BhI'IIICJIeIIIIH reHlIblX 'IaCTOT p, q II r no qaCTOTe cpeHoTIInoB npI2I
pa60Te C HaH60.rree pacIIpocTpalIeHlIhIMH CbIBopOTRallfH, 110 nOJlyqaeMbIe BeJIH-
qHlIhI cyry60 YCJIOBlIbI II3-3a Toro, 'ITO Kam,ll,blH H3 3THX HaCJIep:CTBelIlIbIX
tPaKTopOB paCIIaf],aeTCH .lIa pHf], 6Q.1Iee 'IaCT.lIbIX. To, 'ITO BbI npef],JIaraeTe,
JII2Irnb KaiRym;aHcH 06'heKTHBH3a IIH npef],MeTa 3KO.'IOrIIl1 qeJIOBeRa.
A. 3TO - CTpe!\f.:'IeIIIIe R TO'IHOCTH, a Barn nop:xof], npl1f],aeT 3KOJIOrHl1 qe-
.1I0BeKa paCnJIhIB'IaThle O'IepTaIIllH, JIIIrnaH ee TeM caMbIM onpef],eJIelIHOH
cIIe ncpIIKlT .
K. Ham cnop Bce. 60Jlee YXOD;HT B ccpepy O'IeHb 06m;IIX a6cTpaR IIII <pH-
.TIOcocpcKoro xapalnepa. B HTore 3KO.'10rnH qeJIOBeKa - TaRaH a6cTpaKl.(IIH,
KOTopaH JIIlrnelIa KaKOrO-JIH60 KOIIKpeTlIoro COf],epiRallIIH.
106
P. Mile npep;CTaB.TIHeTCH, 'ITO crrop O'IelIh KOlIcTpyKTHBeH, HarnH BhICRa-
3bIBarrIIH He TOJIbKO rrpOHCIIHIOT B3aIIMIIhle rr03H HI2I, HO II crroc06CTBYIOT BbI-
HClIelIIIIO IICTIIlIbI. Oc06elIHO HHTepeCHbIMII II 3aCJIymIIBaIOm;HMII BHIIMalIHJl
6bIJIII Bce C006paiReIIIIH 0 MeCTe 3KOJIOrHH qeJIOBeRa He IIap; alITpOnOJIOrHeii
I2I He BIIYTPH ee, a napaJIJIeJIblIO, PHAOM, TaK, qT06hI ccpepbI I2IX HHTepeCOB
qaCTHqlIO nepeCeKaJIHCb, HO lIe HaKJIap;hlBaJII2ICb nOJIIIOCTbIO o.n: II a Ha .D:pyryIO.
)].aJIblIeHrnIIe IICCJIep;OBaHIIH, 6e3YCJIOBII0, p;OJImlIbI nOKa3aTh, HaCKOJIbKO Ta-
Roe pa3L\eJIelIHe ccpep )J;enCTBIIH YJ(06IIO B KOHRpeTnoH pa60Te H npaKTHqe-
CKH ocym;ecTBHlIfO.
B nopy rrOIICRa cpO pM, CTalIOBJIelIIIH H pa3BIfTHH IIOBOll HayRII nOp;06IIbIe
p;HaJIOrII lIfOryT OKa3aTbCH HaH60JIee nJIo,ll,OTBOpHbIMH npI2I CPOPllfYJIHpOBaHHII
ee OCHOBlIhIX rrpHIIII;HnoB H 3ap;aq.
t 0 cOBpeMeHHoH ROHCTpyKTI2IBHOH paooTe B 06JIaCTI2I 3ROJIOrI2II2I, B TOM '1I2ICJIe I2I 3ROJIo-
rI2I1I 3BOJIIOI\IIOHHOH, I2I 0 ee OTHOmeHI2II2I R 3ROJIOrI2II2I '1eJIOBeRa MorYT j:\aTb rrpej:\CTaBJIeHI2Ie
CJIej:\YIOlI\lIe I2I3j:\aHI2IH: reorpacPlI'IeCK.lie aClIeRTbI 3ROJIOr.li.li '1eJIOBeRa. M., 1975; OR-
pym:aIOlI\aH cpe,I1a .Ii 3j:\opoBbe '1eJIOBeRa. M., 1979; 3ROJIOl'I2IH I2I 3BOJIIOI\.liOHHaH Teo-
p.liH. JI., 1984; MouceeB H. H. 'IeJIOBeR, cpej:\a, 06II\eCTBo. M., 1982; MouceeB H. H.,
A.n.e1>ca1i8pOB B. B., Tap1>o A. M. 'IeJIOBeR .Ii OI2IOCcPepa. M., 1985; rUpello1> (]J. H. 3RO-
JIOrIIH. I{I2IB.liJI.li3al\.liH. HooccPepa. M., 1987.
rrOrrY HQMOHHAH CTPYHTYPA qE OBEqECTBA
M MCTOPMqECHAH AHTPOrrO OrMH
P AMRH HCTOPl1'IECROn AHTPOIIOJIOnIH
B COBeTcKOH aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOH JIIITepaType )J;aBHO HaMeTHJIOCb p;eJIelIHe
aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCKOH IIayKH IIa TPII pa3J(eJIa: alITponoreHe3, paCOBep;eHue H
?IOpcpOJIOrIIH. PacoBeJJ:eIIHe, B CBOIO OqepeJ],b, B COOTBeTCTBHH C TpagIf IIeH
)J;eJll1TCH IIa )J;Be BeTBII - II3yYI€IIHe p;peBlIero IIaCeJIeIIHH, T. e. naJIeOalITporro-
JIOrIIH, H H3y'IelIIIe cOBpellfelIHoro IIaCeJIeIIHH, T. e. 3TIIII'IeCKaH aIITpOrrOJIOrHH.
MIIOI'D;a nOCJIeJJ:IIIIH TepllfHII ynoTpe6mIeTCH RaK CIIHOIIHM pacoBep;eHHH, 'ITO
JIHmeHO ClIfbICJIa, TaR RaR B paCOBeJ(elIHe BXOP;HT lIflIorlIe np06JIellfbI, B OCIIOB-
110M 6HOJIOrH'IeCROrO xapaKTepa, BbIXOp;Hm;He 3a npe)J;e,'!bI 3TIIH'IeCKOll alITpo-
nOJIOI'IfII B y3KOllf ClIfhICJIe CJIOBa (T. e. IIaYKH 06 alITpOrrOJIOrHqeCKOllf COCTaBe
HapogoB ReMJIII). TaRoe pa3rpalIHqelIIIe paCOBep;eHHH Ha )J;Be COCTaBHhIe 'IaCTII
C03JJ:8eT TPYJJ:IIOCTII, TaK RaK B 3ana)J;HoenponeHcKoII II all-repHRalIcRolI JIHTe-
paType nO)J; rraJIeOalITpOrrOJIOrIIell rrOIIHlIfaeTCH Bo06m;e H3Y'IeIIHe p;peBlIero
IIaCeJIelIIIH Bile 3aBHCIIMOCTII OT Toro, OTHOCHTCH JIll; OHO K BII)J;y COBpeMelI-
1101'0 'IeJIOBeKa IfJIH K IICRorraeMhIM cpopllfallf. Ho rrOllfI2IlIfO 3TOll qIICTO cpopMaJIb-
IIOH TpYJJ:HocnI, MhI CTaJIKnBae fCH B 3TOM c.TIY'Iae II C TPYJ(HOC.TbIO TeOpeTII'le-
CKOH, a IIlIfeHIIO C HeonpaBp;alIlIbIM npOTIlBonOCTaBJIelIIIeM MeTop;OB II3Y'IeIIIfH
CKeJIeTOB, CRamel\l, IIeOJIIITII Y leCKoro If IIIIiRlIerraJIeOJIIITHYI€CROrO BpeMelIH,
Ylero IIa ca fmI )J;eJIe IIeT: If3YYI€IIIIe IIX pa3JIIIqaeTCH TOJIbKO IIporpallfMOII II3-
1>f€peIIIIll. C APyroH CTOpOHbI, 3TIIIIqeCKaH aIITpOnOJIOrIIH, nop: KOTOpOH nop;-
pa3YMeBaeTCH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH COBpeMelIHhIX Hapop;OB, HeMhICJIHMa 6e3 aHaJIH3a
I1X npomJIoro, T. e. 6e3 naJIeOaIITpOrrOJIOrHII.
npII TaKOll KJIaCCIIcpIIRa:qHH ,l],JIH HCTOpH'IeCROH aHTpOnOJIOrIIII Bo06m;e
IIeT MeCTa B CIICTel\f€ aIITpOrrOJIOrrr'IeCKHX 3HaIIHH. aHa He COOTIIOCIITCH rrOJI-
IIOCThIO C paCOBe)J;eIIIIeM, TaR KaK IICTOpH'IeCKHe BorrpOCbI pernaIOTCH C no-
MOm;bIO aIITpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKHX p;alIlIhIX I2I Torp;a, Rorp;a pe'Ib I2Ip;eT 0 )J;peBHI2IX
107
"
TOllfIIHHgax. nOqTII 40 JIeT Ha3ag C. n. TOJICTOB npegcRa3aJI, qTO IIerrocpe,ll,-
CTBeUlIble rrpep;KII qeJIOBeKa )J;OJIiRlIbI OhIJIH 6bITb lIfHcoe)J;IIbIlIfH cym;ecTBallfII
H, CJIe)J;OBaTeJIbIIO, 3alIHlIIaTbCH OXOTOH 1. I13yqeHHe lIfopcpOJIOrIIH II oopa3a
mII3IIH aBCTpaJIOrrHTeKOB 1l0)J;TBep)J;IIJIO 3TY rHrrOTe3Y 2. Be3pa3JIIPIeH JIII TOT
.paKT, qTO aBCTpaJIOUIITeKII 3alIIIlIfaJIIICb OXOTOll, )J;JIH rrOIIHIIIaIIIIH HR'IaJIbHbIX
:3TanOB pa3BIITITH X03HHCTBa, T. e. )J;JIH 'IHCTO HCTOpII'IeCKOH npOOJIeMhI? BII-
,lJ.IIlIfO, IIeT. I1l1feeT JIll 3IIa'IelIIIe )J;JIH IICTOpIIKOB rraJIeOJIIITa ypOBelIh YllfCTBeH-
IIoro pa3BHTIIH HaCeJIeIIIIH, BOCCTalIaBJIHBae"IbIlr C IIOllfOm;bIO CJIerrKOB BIIYT-
pelIlIell rrOJIOCTII qepeUHOH Kop06RH - 3H.B;OKpaHOB? BH)J;IIMO, IIlIfeeT, eCJIH
npIIIIHTh BO BIIIIlIfalIIIe TO, KaKoii HIITepec BbI3BaJIH paOOThI B. II. RO'IeTKo-
BoiL pa3BIIBaIOm;ell II nponaralIp:HpYIOm;eII y IIac 3TY crre HaJIhlIYIO 06JIaCTb
.aIITpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKOH HaYKH. RaK IIfOiRlIO CY)J;HTb 0 rrpo)J;OJImIITeJIbIIOCTII iRH3-
HII )J;peBIIHx rOMIIIIHp:, ypoBlIe )J;eTCKoII clIfepTlIocTH B IIIIlliHellf rraJIeOJllne HJIII
o COOTHomelIHH nOJIOB B rrepB06hITIIOM CTa.n:e? TOJIhKO C rrollfOm;hIO aHTpono-
.JIorIIqeCKIIX .n:aHHblx. TaKIIlIf oopa30llf, HCTOpHqeCKHe cBep;elIIIH MmKIIO II3-
BJIeqb II3 alITpOrrOJIOrIIYlecKoro MaTepIIaJIa lIe TOJIhRO B TOllf cJIy'Iae, KorLIa
MbI HlIfeeM ,lJ.eJIo C cOBpellfelIlIbIM YIe.TIOBeKOllf, 110 H Torga, Korga HCCJIe,lJ.YIOTcH
ero rrpe,D:KII. CJIe)J;oBaTeJIbIIO, IICTOpII'IeCRaH aIITpOrrOJIOI'IUI - a no)], IIeH I.(eJIe-
cOOOpa3IIO rro)J;pa3YlIfeBaTh BCIO cOBoKyrrlIocTb aIITpOrrOJlOrII'IeCRIIX IIa6JIIo)J;e-
HIIll, H3 ROTOpbIX MOiRlIO H3BJIeqb HCTOpII'IecKYIO IfHcpopMa HIO (TepMHH
«HcTOpIIqeCKaH aIITpOrrOJIOrHH» ocooelIlIo llInpoRo yrroTpeOJIHeTCH B IIeMe -
ROH JIHTepaType, HO TaM rroD; IIHM rro)J;pa3YMeBaeTcH H3yqelIIIe aIITpOrrOJIOrH-
qeCKOrO COCTaBa cOBpellfelIlIhIx II )J;peBIIIIx IIapo)J;oB B CBH3II C 3THIfqeCROR
IIcTopIIeH, T. e. qaCTh paCoBe,D:eHIfH),- XpOJlOJIOrIIqeCKII mHpe paCOBe,lJ.eHHH,
OXBaThIBaeT II pacoBe)J;elIHe II alITporrorelIe3. Ho B TO me BpeMH olla He BKJIIO-
'IaeT OHOJIOrH'IeCKYIO np06JIeMaTHKY. BXO,D:Hm;yIO B 3TH ,ll,Ba pa3)J;eJIa, IIJIII,
TOqHee rOBopH, BKJIIO'IaeT JIHllIb Te 6HOJIOrIIqeCRHe BorrpOCbI, ROTOpbIe Hepa3-
pbIBIIO CBH3alIbI C pemelIIIeM IICTOpIIqeCKIIX 3a,D:a'I.
RaKHlIf MaTepIIaJlOM pacrrOJIaraeT HCTOpHqeCKaH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH? 3TOT lIfa-
TepIIaJI pa3IIOOOpa3eII IT, qTO caMoe rJIaBIIOe, OTpamaeT TaKlIe CTPYRTyphI
qeJIOBe'IeCKOrO opralIII3Ma, ROTOphIe IIaCJIe,aYIOTCH He3aBIICIIMO. 3TO 03IIa'IaeT,
"'ITO relIeTIIqeCRIIn BbIBOg, orrHpaIOm;IIIICH B OCHOBHOM Ha alITpOIIOllfeTpIIqe-
<moe IICCJIep:OBaIIIIe, MomeT OhITh nponepell C rrOMOm;bIO )J;alIlIbIX 0 rpyrrrrax
KpOBII, .D:epMaTOrJIIIcpIIKII, O.IJ;OHTOJIOrHH, II3Y'IeIIIIH CPII3IfOJIOrIIqeCKHX peaK-
IIll. COBnaD;eHHe pe3YJIbTaTOB HCCJle)J;OBaIUfH pa3IIhIX CHCTeM B 3IIaqIfTeJIblIOll
Mepe YBeJIIIqIIBaeT ,D:OCTOBepIIOCTb BbIBop;a 0 reHeTIIqeCKOM pogcTBe IICCJIe,lJ.ye-
MbIX 3THHqeCKIIX rpyrrrr. n03TOMY aIITpOnOJIOrH II CTpellfHTCH Cell'IaC KO Bce-
MepHOMY paCllIIIpelIIIIO rrporpallfllfbI rrOJIeBbIX OOCJIe)J;OBaIIHH, BKJIIO'IaH B Hee
Bce IIOBbJe II IIOBble npII3HaKH.
Hapo.IJ;bI npnypaJIhH H 3arrap:IIOll CHOITpH OO'be)J;HIIHIOTCH B aHTpOrrOJIOrII-
"tJeCKIIX KJIaCCIIcpIIKa IIHX B ypaJIbCRYIO rpyIIny aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKHX THnOB,
3aIIIIMaIOru;yIO rrpm.feiRYTOqlIOe rrOJIOiRelIHe lIfem,D:y eBporreoITgaMlf H lIfOlIrOJlOH-
)J;al\lII. CpeAII aHTpOrrOJIOrOB )J;aBIIO H)J;eT cnop. RaKOBO ero npOIICXOiR)J;eIIHe:
HBJIHeTCH JIlT OHO CJIe)J;CTBIIeM JJ:aBlIero CMellielIlIH lIIeJK)J;Y eBporreOH)J;aMIT H
MOlIrOJIOIT,IJ;aMH, IIJIII B OKpeCTIIOCTHX ¥paJIbCROrO xpe6Ta H3gaBIIa cpOpMHpO-
BaJIaCh npOll-IeiRYTO'IlIaH ROllf6IIlIa IfH rrpH3HaKOB, coxpalIIIBllIaH IIe)J;I1cpcpepelI-
IUIpOBaHIIOCTh rro OTHOllielIHIO K 06eHM pacaM. He)J;HcpcpepeH HpOBalIlIble
rpynnbI OOhI'IIIO 3alIIIMaIOT cpeglIee nOJIOiRelIHe MeiR,D:y KpaHHHMII cpopMaMII
.1IIIllIb no OTD;eJIblIbIM npII3IIaRaM, BbIXOD;H rro ,lJ.pyrI1M 3a rrpe)J;eJlhI II3MelIqH-
BOCTII B 3TIIX KpalfIIIIX rpyrrrrax. I13yqelIIIe Y30pa naJIb eBhIX II JIa,D:OHHhIX
JIIIHIIH Y IIapO)J;OB nOBOJIiRhH rrOKa3aJIO, qTO OIIII 3aHIIMaIOT no IIellfY, TaK iRe
Ri:(K II no CTpoelIlIIO .1IH a, npOMeiRYTO'IIIOe MeCTO MeJH)J;y MOlIrOJlOII,D:aMH II
eBpOneOI1J],allfII 3. 3TlIlIf HaOJIIO;J;eIIIIeM OhIJIII cephe3HO YKpenJIelIhI n03H IIH
I
108
CTOpOlIlIHKOB ClIfellialIHoro rrpOIICXOiR,IJ;eIIIIH rrpe,IJ;CTaBHTeJIeH ypaJIbCROn pathI,
.a CJIe,IJ;OBaTeJIhHO, HCTOpHRO-3TIIOJIOI'II'IeCKHe BbIBO,IJ;bI 0 cpOpMIIpOBaHIIII Hapo-
,IJ;OB npIlypaJIbH H 3ana;:(HOH CH6IIpII B rrpo:qecce ClIfemeHIIH 3TIIHqeCKIIX 3JIe-
lIfelITOB 3arra,IJ;IIOro II BOCTO'lIIOrO rrpOIICXOiR,IJ;eHIIH.
npe,IJ;lIfeTOllf CTpaCTlIhIX crropOB IIa rrpOTHiRelIHII lIflIorHX JIeT 6bIJIO rrpOIIC-
XOiR)],eHHe IIaCeJIelIHH RalIapCKIIX OCTpOBOB. C Rellf TOJIbIW He CBH3bIBaJIHCb
ero relIeTIIqeCKHe HCTOKH! Em;e II Terrepb, B '1aCTHOCTH, BCTpe'laIOTCH rronbIT-
I,IT rrpeYB:.JJIII'IHTb TPY,IJ;IIOCTIl, C KOTOpbIMII CTaJIKIIBaeTCH IICCJIeil;08aTeJIb 3THO-
reHe38 ryaH'IeH, H npe,IJ;CTaBIITb rrOCJIe,IJ;IIHX KaK OCTaTRII ,IJ;peBlIero HaCeJIeHIIH
MHcpH'IeCROH ATJIaIITH,ll,hI '. MeiR,ZJ;Y TeM, lIfopcpOJIOrH'IeCKII ryalI'IH O'iellb
CXO)J;HbI C )J;peBHHlIfH iRHTeJIHlIfH CeBeplIOH AcppIIKH - BbICOKOpOCJIhIlIfH II lIfac-
CHBHhIMII. 8TII oc06elIIIOCTH 3aCTaBHJIII IIeROTOphIX IICCJIe,IJ;OBaTeJIell 3THoreHe-
3a II cpH3WIeCRoro THna HaCeJIelIlfH RaHapCRHX OCTpOBOB BH,IJ;eTb B HeM rrOTOllf-
KOB KpOllIalIbOII:qeB EBpOrrbI. HallfeTHJIOCh rrpOTHBopeque MeiR)J;y pe3YJIbTaTa-
MIl aHTpOrrOJIOrIf'IeCKIIX, C O)J;IIOll CTOpOIIhI, IICTOPIIRO-3TIIOJIOruqeCKllX II JIHHr-
BIICTII'IeCKllX HCCJIe;:J:OBaIIHH - C )J;pyroll, rrOCJIe,IJ;IIHe BbfHBHJIII relIeTIIqeCKIIe
CBH3II MeiR;:J:y ryalIqallfH H HaCeJIelIIIellf CeBepHOH ACPPIIRH. IIocJIe Toro KaK B
CeBeplIOII AcpplfKe y,IJ;aJIOCh IIaHTH y ,IJ;penlIero IIaCeJIelIHH aHaJIOrII'IlIbIe aH-
'rpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKHe oc06errnOCTII, rrpOTIIBOpe'IHe 3TO OTnaJIO. Ho rrOCJIe,IJ;HIIlIf II
OqelIb BeCKIIM aIITpOnOJIOr'IeCKIIM )J.OKa3aTeJIbCTBOllf ceBepoacpplIKalICKoro
npOIICXOIH,IJ;eIIIIH ryalI'Ielr nOCJIYiRHJIO onpe,IJ;eJIeHHe rpyrrn KpOBH CIICTellfbI
ABO y MYMIIll H3 rrem;eplIhIX rrorpe6eHHll RaHapCRIIX OCTpOBOB. Pacrrpe,IJ;eJIe-
HIIe 3TIIX rpynn KpOBII ORa3aJIOCb rrO'lTH TOiR;D;eCTBelIlIbIlIf alIaJIOrHqlIOllfY pac-
npe)J;eJIelIIIIO B CeneplIOll AcppIIKe 5.
B CBH3H C 'opIIrHHaJIhlIbIlIfH rIInOTe3aMlI XeHep)J;aJIa OiRHBHJlCH IIHTepec K
nyTHM 3aCeJIelIIIH nOJIlfIIe3IIH. npOTlfB 3aCeJIelIIfH IIOJII1IIe3HII B IIarrpaBJIelIHII
C BOCTOKa IIa 3anap: 6hIJIH npIIBe)J.elIhI caMhIe pa3IIo06pa3HbIe, B TOM '1HCJIe
II aIITporrOJIOrII'IeCKHe, aprYllfelITbI 6. 113yqelIIIe O.n:OIITOJIOrII'IeCKHX oc06eHHO-
CTeH pa3IIbIX OCTpOBHbIX rpynII rrOJIHHe3IIlll(eB rrORa3aJIO, qTO -qaCTOTa JIOrraTO-
06pa3HhIX pe3 OB YMelIbmaeTCH no IIaIIpaBJIeHIIIO C 3arra;D;a IIa BOCTOR,
T. e. OIl;OHTOJIOrII'IeCKIIe ;D;alIlIbIe IIaXO,IJ;HTCH B f)OJIbmeM COOTBeTCTBIIH C rJiIrro-
Te30ll 3aCeJIeHHH nOJIIIHe3IIII II3 IOro-BocTO'lHOH A3HH, '1ellf C npOTIfBOrrOJlOm-
HOll CTOpOlIhI 7 .
IIPOBJIEMbI HCTOPHqECROIt AHTPOIIOJIOrHH
3a 3TlIlIfJiI rrpIIMepallfH yra,IJ;hIBaI01CH ROIITYPbI np06JIeM, pemaellfhlX IICTOPII-
qeCROlr aHTpOrrOJIOrlIell, II rryTII IICUO.llh30BaIIIIH aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCRHX p:alIlIhIX
AJIH HCTOpHqeCRIIX peKOIICTpYK IIH.
llepuo8uaalju5l UCTOpUU nep606b T1iOeO o6UfeCT6a. OTlIecelIHe R rOMHHH-
]:laM 1I0BbIX HCRorraellfhIX IIaXO)J;OK, C)J;eJIalIlIhIX JIHRH B BOCTO'IIIOll AcppHRe,
II pacnpOCTpalIHIOm;aHCH TelI,IJ;elI HH BlWIOqaTh aBCTpaJIOllifTeKOB B Ce;\fellCTBO
rOMHIIII.n: OTO)J;BHraIOT HaqaJIO 'IeJIOBeqeCKOH HCTopIIn BrJIy6b rrOqTII B 2 pa3a
110 cpaBlIelIIIIO co CTaphIMH ,IJ;aTaMH 8. Cym;ecTBelIlIbl pe3YJIbTaThI aIITpOrrOJIO-
TII'IeCKHX HCCJIe.n:OBaIIHH H )J;JIH BhfHCHelIHH XpOIIOJIOrH'IeCRIIX rpalIII OT)JeJIb-
:IIhIX 3TaIIOB, BhI,IJ;eJIHellfhIX BHYTPH IICTUpHH rrepB06hITHoro 06m;eCTBa. HOBhIe
HaXO,IJ;RH H BIII1MaTeJIhlIOe H3yqeHHe lIfopcpOJIOrIIII CTaphIX CTepJIII pe3KyIO
rpallb lIfeiR)JY JIIO)J.bllfII IIealI,IJ;epTaJIbCKOrO II COBpeMelIlIoro BIIII;OB, qTO IIaxo-
AIITCH B rrOJIHOM COrJIaCI1II C BbIHBIIBmHlIfCH 60raTCTBOllf MYCTbepCROH RYJIhTy-
phI, HaJIIJqHeM TeppIITOpH8.JlbIIOll ;D;HcpcpepelI Ha HH, HaJIIIqIIeM iRIIJIIIm; B
1\IYCThepCRoe BpeMH 9. AmI BbI.n:eJIeIIIIH 3IIOXII cpe)],IIero naJIeOJIIITa B IICTOpIIH
;D;peBHeRallfelIHoro BeKa aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKHe ;D;aHlIhIe rr03TOllfY lIe Mellee 3Ha'IH-
1\IhI, qellf apxeoJIOI'IrqeCKHe.
109
I
I
.!
llpoucxoJICfJenue :MbLUl.lW1{Ufl U pel{u. II3Y'IeIIIIe RaMeHHGrO HIIBelITapH
,ll,peBlIerraJIeOJIIITII'IeCKHX CTOHIIOK H cp:eJIalInhIe IIa ero OCHGBe KaKIIe-JIrr60>
RGCBelIlIhIe CGG6paiReUIIH He MGrYT )1aTb CKGJIbKO-HH6Y)J;b rrGJIlIbIe CBe)J;eIIIIH
06 3Tanax pa3BIITIIH IIIblmJIelIIIH II 0' BpeMeUII B03IIIIKrrGBelIIIH 3BYKGBGH pe'IH.
)].aiRe IIeCOMlIeUlIhIH cpaKT rrepe)J,aYIH TeXHH'IeCKHX IIaBbIKGB GT rrORGJIelIIIH I '
rrGKGJIeIIIIIO, IIa 'ITG G6paTIIJlI1 BlIlIMaHHe reneTIIK MGpraII II IIG3p:IIee apxeo-
JIGI' qaHJI)J; (a rrepe)Ia'Ia TeXIIIIqeCKHX TpaJJ:Hl(IIII B HH}KHeM naJIeGJIHTe IIeco-
MlIeUHa, RGJIb CRGpG cpIIKcHpyeTcH rrOBTGpHeMGCTb IIIIBeIITapH), lIe rrGMGraeT
YCTalIOBIITh BpeMH rrOHBJIelIHH 3BYRGBGH peYIII, TaR KaK G6Y'IeIIHe MGrJIO B
npIlII I1rre Gcym;eCTBJIHTbCH H 6e3 Bee, TGJIbKO C nOMOm;bIO rrGKa3a, KaK Y
6GJIblliIIIICTBa iRIIBOTlIbIX. EMIICTBelIlIhIH mpHIIWH MeTG)J; - H3y'IelIHe lIfGPCPG-
JIGrIIII )J,peBlIelllliHX H )J,peBIIHX JIIO)J,eH H CPYIIK IIOlIaJIbIIOe HC1'OJIKGBaHHe OT-
MeqerrlIbIX pa3JIIIqHH. Ha 3II)J,GRpalIaX CHHaHTpona IIa6JIIO)J,aeTCH pe3Koe B3)J,Y-
TIle B G6JIaCTII CGe)J,HHeIIHH JI06HGii:, BIICO'IIIOll H TeMeHIIGH )J,GJIell, OTCYTCTBO-
BaBlliee Y nHTeKaHTporra. IIMeHHo B nGH G6JIaCTH COCpe.D:GTG'IelIhI apTIIRYJIH-
IIoHHhle eHTpbI peqII H CJIyxoBble eHTphI to. YKa3alIHGe B3)J;YTIIe TPY)J,HO
HCTOJIKOBbIBaTb HlIaqe, qellf RaK cBII)IeTeJIbCTBG BG3HHKIIGBelIHH IIMelIlIO Ha
3Ton cTa)J,HH 3BYKOBOH pe'III.
PeKollcrpYKljUfl rpyfJoeou U COljUU/[bllOU JlCU311U fJpeeneuUlux 20. IU1iUfJ.
ApXeOJIOrIl'IeCKHe )J,alIlIbIe BamHbI npH H3Y'IeIIIIH HCRorraeMbIX rOMHIIH)J, BO
MlIorHX OTIIOllieIIIIHX. B rrepBYIO O'Iepe)J,b H HMeIO B BH,ZJ;Y apXeOJlOrIlYIeCKlIe
cBH)J,eTeJIhCTBa CPYIIK HGHaJIbIIOH HepaBHG eIIIIOCTH PYK rraJIeGalITpOrra H
rrpeIIMyrn;ecTBelIlIoro rrOJIb30BalIHH HlIf npaBGH PYKOH ft. Pa3HGG6pa3He cpOpllf
KaMeHlIoII IIII)J,ycTpnH B rpGTe RHHK-RG6a B CG'IeTaIIIIH C MGpcpOJIGrH'IeCKGn
rrpIIlIfHTHBIIOCTbIO KHHK-K06HI1 a BbI3BaJIG K mH3IIH, rrG-BII)J;HlIfOllfY, BTIGJIIIe-
crrpaBe)J,JIHBYIO rHrroTe3Y 4YIIK HGlIaJIbIIOrG BGCrrGJIlIelIIIH 3TGH rrpIIlIlIITHB-
IIGCTII 3a CqeT .n:orrGJIIIIITeJIbIIOrO pa3BIITHH MhIlliI.(, rrpHBO.n:Hm;HX B )J,BIIllieIIHe'
60JIhlliOH rraJIe t2. Ho, C .n:Pyron CTGpOlIhI, pa3BHTIIe Tex HJIII IIlIhIX MGpcpO-
.rrornqeCKHX CTPYKTYP B rrpo ecce aHTpGrrOreHe3a, GC06eHHo RHCTIJ PYKH If:
I\IG3ra, nGMGraeT G eIIHTh BG3l1fOiRIIGCTII .TJ:I06GH HCKOrraeMGll cpGpMhI B 1131'0-
TGBJIelIHH GpY)J,IIII TpY)J,a H TeM caMbIM rrG3BOJIHeT rrGIIHTb rrpIlqJlIIbI rrepexo)J,a
K 60JIee BhICOKGH TeXHHKe G6pa6GTKII KaMIIH. qTO RacaeTCH peKGIIC1'pYR IIH
CG HaJIhIIGH Gpra1III3a HH rrepBo6bITIIOrG CTa)J;a, TO' Heo eHHMbIH IIIaTepIIaJI p:JIH
3Toro )J,aJIO II3yqelIHe CTPYKTYPhI rrGJIGBhIX rpyrrrr qeJIOBeKGG6pa3IIhIX G6e3bHH.
B RGlIeqlIGM I1TOre MGrYT 6hITb C)J,eJIalIbI .n:Ba BhIBG)J,a: a) B3aIIMGGTIIGllieHHH
MelliJJ;y 'I.crelIaMII rrepBG6h1TrrGrG CTaJ(a OhlJIII rIl6KII II rrG)J,BHiRlIbI, CTa.D:O .rrerKO
pearIIpOBaJIO IIa YBeJIH'IeIIHe II YMelIbllielIHe YIIICJIeIIHGCTH, nGJIGllielIHe JII06Gro
'IJIelIa CTa.n:a, GCGGelIHo IIa rrepBbIX rropax, lIe 6bIJIO CTpGrO GrrpeJJ;eJIelIlIhIlIf;
6) B3aIIMGGTHomeIIl1H MeiR)J,Y qJIelIallfIl CTa)J,a 6bIJIII He 6ecrropH)J,G'IlIbI, a per-
JIaMeIITHpGBalIbI. hOT nGCJIe)J;IIHH BbIBO)J; 3aCTaBJIHeT C COMlIenHeM OTlIeCTHCh
R rrpe)J;cTaBJIelIHIO 0' rrepHG)J,e 6eCrrOpH,ITOqlIbIX rrOJIOBbIX ROHTaKTGB, rrpe)J,lliecT-
BOBaBlliellf CTa.D:Y,- rrpe)J,cTaBJIeIIHIO, em;e 6bITYIOm;eMY rro)J,'Iac Ha cTpalIIII.(aX
3TIIGrpacpII'IeCROH JIHTepa1'YPhl.
lla/[eofJe:M02pagJUR. B oTp:eJIhlIbIX oc060 6JIarOrrpIIHTIIhIX CJIyqaHX MOiRIIO'
IICrrOJIb3GBaTb cyry6G IICTGpIlqecKYIO HHcpopMa I1IO .'J,JIH BocCTalIOBJIeHIIH p:e-
MorpacpII'IeCKHX rrGKa3aTeJIeli B )J;peBHIIe 3rrGXII. HaIlpIIMep, IIa)J,I1IICII Ha)J,rpo-
6Hll Heop:HGKpaTIIO IICCJIe)J,GBaJIIICb KaR rrpe)J,MeT rraJIeGp:ellfOrpacpIIYlecKIIx pac-
'IeTGB. HG .n:JIH BOCCTaHOBJIelIHH )J,HHaMHKII rraJIeo.n:el\fOrpacpIIqeCKIIX nOKa3aTe-
JIeH GT 3nOXII R 3nGXe, eCJIII peqb IIJJ;eT 0' 6ecrrIIchMelIIIblx rrepHG)J,ax HCTOplIH
'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa, rrpIIrG)J,eII TOJIbRO rraJIeOalITpGnOJIGrHqeCKIIH MaTepIlaJI. Orrpe-
.n:eJIeHIIe IIIIp:HBH,ZJ;yaJIbIIOrO 6HGJIOrHqeCKGrG BG3paCTa oT)J,eJIblIbIX IICKGnaellfbIX
Haxop:oK n03BOJIHJIO rroKa3aTb, 'ITO Cpe.n:HHH npG)J,GJIiRHTeJIbIIGCTb iRII3IIII .n:peB-
HeHlliHx II p:peBHIIx JIIO)J;eH 6bIJIa 3HaqII'reJiblIG IIHme cOBpellfelIlIGH H lIe rrpe-
110
BhIllIaJIa 20 JIeT 13. I1IIhIMII CJIOBaMH, IeJIOBeK B nO)J;aBmrIOm;eM UOJIbllIIIIICTBe
<CJIrraeB, ep,Ba CTaB npUrOp;IIhIM p,JIH npO)J;OJIiReIIIIH pO.Il;a, YMupaJI. B BepXlIeM
naJIeOJIUTe npop,OJIa,UTeJIbnOCTb jJ{If3HII YBeJIU IIIJIaCb IIa IIeCIWJIbKO JIeT,
110 Bce pallIIO npO.D:OJIiRaJIa OCTaBaTbCH Ipe3BbIqalfIIO IIII3KOH. TIepeXO,ll,H )J;JIH
cCpaBJIeHIIfI K p,aHlIhIM 60JIee n03.I1;HUX ;mox, MbI CTaJIRIIBaeMCH C JII060nbITIIhDiI
cpaRTOM: cpe;J,HHH npO;rrOJImIITeJIbHOCTb iIUI3IIU B HeOJIIITe, B 3noxy 6pOlI3hI U
meJIe3a OCTaeTCH OOJIee IlJIII Mellee nOCTOHIIHOII - OKOJIO 30 JIeT. OTJJ,eJIblIbIe
CJIyqau YBeJIIlqelIIIH cpeJJ;IIeM npO.Il;OJIiRIITeJIblIOCTII iRU3III1 no cpaBlIeIIIlIO C 00-
.JIee palIIIIIM BpeMelIeM lIe lIfelIHIOT 06m;eH KapTlIIIhI g. 11 TOJIbRO npu npu-
OJIHmelIIIII K COBpeMelIlIOCTIl npo.n:OJHRUTeJIbHOCTb mII3IIU pe3IW B03pOCJIa.
I1TaR, IIa npOTHiRelIHU nCTopUII qeJIOBeqeCTBa IIaOJIIOJJ:aeTcH OTqeTJIIIBOe IIa-
paCTalIue )J;JIIITeJIbIIOCTU mII3HU, 110 TeMn 8Toro IIapaCTalIIUI IIepaBIIOMepeH.
O a3U pa36UTUR U6U U3a uu. lUIIpORO pacnpocTpalIelIlIoe H B oom;eiI
40pMe HpaBIIJTblIOe YTBepiRJJ;elIue IIe3aBUCIIlIfOCTII cpOpMIIpoBaHIIH pac II 3TIIII-
I€CRIIX 06m;IIOCTeli p,OJImIIO 6hITb ClIfHrqelIO rro OTlIomelIUIO K palIIIUM 3noxallf,
TaK I{aK pa3IIhle TeMnbI pa3BUTHH Tex II )J;pyrux em;e lIe ycne.'1II IIapYUIIITb
reorpacpIPIeCROe COBna)J;elIue, npoIIcTeKaBllIee 3a C I€T cpOpMHpoBalIuH H 3T-
HII I€CRUX 06m;HOcTeM, U paCOBhTX TlmOB B onpe)J;eJIelIHbIX yCJIOBUHX reorpacpH-
IeCKOH Cpep,bI. HaMe raIOm;HecH apXeOJIOrIl'IeCKU pa3JIII THH MemD;y 3ana.Il;OM
U BOCTOROllf EBpa3IIII B snoxy IIIIiRIIerO rraJIeOJIIITa IIaXOp,HT BeCKoe nO)J;TBepiR-
p,elIue B alIa,'!U3e lIfopcpOJIOrIIII UCKonaeMhlX IIaxop,OK Mllorooopa3ue apxeo-
.JIOrIIqeCKHX KYJIbTYP B 8noxy BepXlIero naJIeOJIUTa, BbIHBJIHIOm;eeCH B OCUOB-
110M B pa3IIhIX TpaIIII IIHX 06pa60TRII KpeMIIH, COBna.Il;aeT C lIfopq)OJIOrUqeCKII-
MIl pa3JIUqIfHlIfU BepXlIenaJIeOJIUTUqeCKllX JIIOI\eIJ 15. )J,JIH 3nOXII IIeOJIUTa H
OpOlI3bI MhI OTlIfeqaeM P;JIH MlIorux 06JIaCTell OlmYMelIbI IIaJIII IIIe cBoe06pa3-
HhIX alITpOnOJIorUqeCKUX TIIIIOB, C6JIHiRaIOm;UXCH B OCIIOBlIbIX npU3IIaKaX C
COBpeMeuHhIMU. )J,JIH 3THX OOJIaCTeli no aHTpOnOJIOrII I€CKUM .Il;alIHhIlIf IIaMeqa-
eTCH npeeMCTBeIIlIOCTb OT 3noxu GpOlI3bI JJ;O COBpeMeIIIIOCTII. 8TO - 3aKaB-
R83be, IOmIIaH TYPKMeIIIIH, TIpu6almaJIbe (IIa3hTBaIO TOJIbRO paHoHhI CCCP).
'TaKuM oGpa30M, alITpono.lJOrUqeCRIIII lIfaTepUaJI raCTIlqlIO n03I10.TIHeT nO)J;-
TBep)J;uTb IICTOPHKO-8TIIOJIOrUqecRIIe BbIBO,[\bI, a qaCTIlqlIO ,ll,aeT IIOBYIO HII-
'cpopMa IIIO 06 WIarax pa3BUTIIH 'leJIOBe'1eCTBa.
POaCTBO apeellUX HapOaOe. TpYJJ;IIo YBII;:J:eTb CKOJIbKO-IIUGY.Il;b 3allfeTHoe
oCXOp,CTBO MeiR.II;y naMHTIIImaMU HlIflIOM H KaTaKOM6IIoii KYJIbTYP CeBeplIoro
HaBKa3a H ,ZJ;peBIIHMII norpe6elIIIHlIfH 8nOXH GpOlI3hI CallfTaBpcRoro MOrUJIb-
IIUKa. Memp;y TeM alITponOJIOrII IeCRoe CXOJJ:CTBO rpynn IIace.lJeIIUH, OCTaBIIB-
llIero 8TU naMHTIIIIRII, IIeCOllflIelIIIO, II ooe OHU npOTIlBOITOCTaBJIHIOTCH 8TIIIIqe-
oCRIIlIf rpyrrnaM 8nOXII 6POII3hI, npomHBaBmuM IIa TeppUTopIfII PYCCKOH paB-
IIIIlIbI. C .Il;PyroH CTOpOlIhl, IIaCeJIelIUe, OCTaBUBmee Ea.rraIIOBCRIIII MOrIlJIbIIMK,
qeTKO OTJIIPraeTCH OT cocep,IIux rpyrrn II cGJIllmaeTCH C IIaCeJIelIUeM CeBeplIo-
ro HaBKa3a U 3aRaBRa3bH. Tpyp,IIo YBII)J;eTb 06m;ee B acpalIacbeBcRon II Ta-
'rapcKoII RYJIbTypax MUIIYCUIICKOII ROTJIOBIfIIhI, HO pO.Il;CTBO IIaCeJIeIIUH, OCTa-
1!IIBmero TY U p,pyryIO KYJIbTYPY, B CBeTe alITpOnOJIorUqeCRIIX IICCJIep,OBaHIIll
HeCOMlIeIIIIO. TaKue rrpUMephI MOiRHO Obl.:'IO 6bI YMIIOfRaTb p,o oeCKolIe fIIocTH.
06m;UH BhTBO.D: II3 IIUX TOT, 'ITO .II;.lJH BblHClIelIIIH relIeTu reCRoro pOI\CTBa ,ll,peB-
IIIIX IIapOp;OB alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIll MaTepIIaJI qaCTO BajJ{IIee IICTOpIIqeCRUX IIa-
{)JIIO)J;eIIHll H lIe l\IOiReT ObITb IICKJIIO'IeH, KaI{ 3TO IIlIorp,a p,eJIaeTCH p,o CHX
HOp, II3 KOMnJIeRCa p,IICl(HnJIIfII, H3yqaIOm;IIX 3TIIorelIe3 p,peBIIUX IIapO)J;OB.
MU3pa uu e UCTOpUU nepeo6blTHOZO o6UfecTea. 0 pomi aHTpOnOJIOfUqe-
'CKUX MaTepUaJIOB B BOCCTalIOBJlelIUH lIfnrpa UII B nepB06bITnOM OOm;eCTBe
nHCaJIOCh WIelIb MlIoro II y6eJJ;IITeJIblI0 16. Mile OCTaeTCH TOJIbKO npUBeCTH
npHlIfepbI, OTpaiRaIOm;Ue IIOBhIe IICCJIe,ll,OBaIIUH U lIe cpurypupoBaBmIle AO cux
nop B 8TOll CBH3II. K IIX 'lIICJIY OTHOCHTCH: npO IIKIIOBelIlIe eBponeOH)J;OB B
111
i
!
j'
I
I
I
I
danaJJ;IIYIO MOlIrOJIlIIO IIa Py6eiRe 3nOXII OpOlI3bI H meJIe3a 17, npOHIIKHOBe-
HlIe eBpOneOII,ll,OB B npII6anKaJIbe II TYBY B :moxy cpep:IIeBeKOBbH 18, rrpo-
HIIKIIOBelIIIe aBCTpaJIOIIp:OB B ,ll,OJIlIIIy XyalIx8 B HeOJIIITe 19 II T. ,ll,.
AeTOXTOHlwe npoucxoJ/Coellue coepe:MellllblX llapoooe. I1CnOJIb30BaTb HC-
TOpIfKo-wrlIorpacpIIqeCKIIe, apXeOJIOnI IeCKIIe II TeM 60JIee JIlIIIrBIICTIIqeCKIIe
p:alIlIbIe ,ll,JIH rrOHCKOB npOIICXOm,ll,eHIIH IIapop:OB II )J;OKa3aTeJIhCTBa IIX aBTO-
XTOlIIIoro CPOpMIIpOBaIIIIH IIa TOH IIJIII nil on TeppIITopHII OqelIb TPY.D:IIO. B03-
MOiRlIOCTII JIHlIrBIICTIIqeCKOro IICCJIeP;OBaIIHH OrpalIHqelIhI B 8TOM OTIIOIIIeHHH
IIaJIHqneM nIICbMelIlIbIX naMHTIIHKOB, KYJIbTypa if{€ qaCTO H 6hICTpO MelIHeT
CBOi!: 06JIHK B CIIJIY COl(IIaJIbII0-3KOHOMIIqeCKIIX npIIqIIII. MemJJ;y TeM alITpo-
nOJIOrHqeCKIIe npII3IIaKII B pH.II;e CJIyqaeB OKa3hIBaIOTCH BeChMa YCTOII IIIBbIMH.
MOif{IIO nOCJIe,ZJ;oBaTeJIbHO npOCJIe,lJ;HTb OTqeTJIHBYIO rrpeeMcTBelIHoCTb alITpono-
JIOrHqeCKIIX oc06elIlIOCTen, BO BCHKOM cJIyqae OT 3IIeOJIIITa ;rro COBpeMelIlIocTH,
B rpY3IIII II ApMeIIHIf, IIa TeppIITopIfII RIfTaH H EnmTa 20. MeiR,ZJ;Y TeM
KYJIbTyplIaH npeeMCTBelIlIOCTb ;rraJIeKO lIe 6eccnoplIa, a B ErHnTe KameTCH
,ZJ;aiRe II IIeBepOHTlIon: CJIIIIIIKOM MHoro IIc,TopIIqec,KHX 6YPb npOlIeCJIOCb IIa;IJ;
;rrOJIIIIIOn HIIJIa 3a nHTb TbICH IeJIeTHII. TIpII H3Y'IeIIIIII 8THorelIe3a apa60H3hIq-
1101'0 IIaCeJIeIIIIH COBpeMeHHoro EnIIITa p:alIlIoe 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO CJIe,ZJ;yeT yqu_
ThlBaTb H BII,lI;eTb B 8TOM HaCeJIelIlIII lIe nepeCeJIelIl(eB H3 IIepe,ZJ;IIeli A3HH.
a nOTOMKOB MeCTlIoro IIaCeJIelIIIH 8rrOXII IIeOJIIITa, ,l],peBlIero, Cpe,ll,IIero H Ho-
BOl'O l(apCTB.
POOCTeo coepe:MellllblX llapoooe. Ifc.CJIe,ZJ;OBaIIHe 3TIIorelIe3a H aIITpOnOJIO-
rIfqeCKOro COCTaBa COBpeMelIbIX IIapO,ll,OB nOKa3aJIO, qTO KYJIbTyplIoe II JIHH-
rBIICTIIqeCKoe pO,ll;CTBO JIIO,ll,ei!: lIe Bcer;rra COOTBeTcTByeT IIX p:eHCTBIITeJIbIIOMY
pOp:CTBY no npOIICXOiR,lI;eIIIIIO, HX 06m;eMY relIocpolI,ZJ;Y. XaKacbI rOBopHT Ha
TIOpKCKOM H3bIKe, Mem.,lI;Y TeM alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRII OIIH 06IIaPYif{IIBaIOT HaH-
60JIbIIIee CXO,ll,CTBO C npe,ll;cTaBIITeJIHMH ypaJIbCKOH rpynnhI alITpOnOJIOrIfqe-
CRIIX nIIIoB, T. e. C 3ana,Il;IIOCH6IIpCKHMII IIapO,ll;aMH, rOBopHm;IIMH IIa yrop-
CKHX II CaMO,ll;HIICRIIX H3hIRax. BaJIKapl(hI H KapaqaeBl(bI Tome rOBopHT rro-
TIOpKCKII, 110 MOPCPOJIOrII IeCKII C6JInmaIOTCH C roplIhIMH rpY3IIIIaMII, IIHry-
IIIaMH, qeqelIl(al\ilH, 3THHqeCKHMII rpynnaMH 3ana,ll,HOro ,l],arecTalIa, T. e. e
l(eIITpaJIbIIORaBKa3cKIIMII Hapop:aMH, rOBOpHm;IIMH IIa RaBKa3CKHX H3hIKax.
To me MomllO nOBTopIITb H npo IIpalIOH3hlqHhIX oceTHII. <DIIlIlIoH3hlqlIaH
Mopp:Ba rop a3 .D:0 60JIbIIIe cxo,ZJ;IIa C COCe.D:IIHMH TeppIITOpIIaJIblIbIlIfII rpynrraMH
pyccKoro IIapo,Il;a, qeM C ;rrpyrHMII CPIIIIIIOH3bIqlIbIMII HapO.D:aMII. POJIb alITpo-
nOJIOrII IeCKIIX p:alIlIbIX, CJIe,Il;OBaTeJIhIIO, BeJIIIKa ,ll,ame B TOM CJIyqae, Kor;IJ;a
IIaJIIIl(O, KaK 8TO HMeeT MeCTO npIf H3yqelIIIH COBpeMeHlIbIX HapO)J;OB, nOJIHaH
If IIeOrpalIHqelIlIO YBeJIH-qIIBaIOm;aHCH IICTOpIIKO-3THorpacpnqeCKaH IIIICPOp-
Mal(HH.
I
I
I
II
IIOIIY.JIHI{IlH
qTO me OTJIHqaeT COBpeMelIlIhIe aIITpOnOJIOI'IIqeCKIIe HCCJIe;rrOBaIIIIH H .npH;IJ;aeT
IIM IICKJIIOqHTeJIbHOe cBoe06pa3He? TIpemp:e Bcero nonYJIHl(HOlIlIhIII no,ZJ;XO.D: R
pacaM H IIapO,ll,aM. TIoCJIe,ll;.IIIIH 03Haqae-r yqeT Tex pO,ll,CTBeHlIhIX B38HMOOTHO-
meHlln, KOTophle C03;IJ;aIOTCH BIIYTPH TeppHTOpHaJIblIhIX rpynn, IIapO,ZJ;OB, pa-
COBbIX rpynn CIICTeMOII 6paqlIhIX CBH3en H 06pa3YIOm;IIMIICH na ee OCIIOBe
6paqHbIMIf KpyraMII. 8TH 6paqlIhle RpyrH OrpalIHqHBaIOT oJJ;IIy OT ,lI;pyron no-
nYJIH:qIfH - He60JIblliIIe rpynnbI JIIO,ll,eII, CBH3alIIIbIx Meif{,ll,y C060lI onpe,ll;eJIeH-
HOH cTenelIbIO pO,ll,CTBa.
TIonYJIHl(IIH - CJIomlIoe HBJIeIIIIe, If, BH,lI;IIMO, n03TOMY OHO BhI3hIBaeT MIIO-
1'0 cnopOB II p:ame He,ZJ;oYMelIlIbIX BonpOCOB. nOIIHTIIe nonYJIHl(HII CO)J;epmHT
MlIoro CKphITbIX TOIIKOCTen, 0 KOTOpbIX C.:'Ie.n:yeT XOTH 6hI ynoMHHYTb. CTe-
112
nellb pO,a:CTBa BIIYTpn nOnYJIHl(IIH MOiRlIO TOqlIO rpHKCIIpOBaTb C nOMOm;bIO
TaK Ha3hIBaeMoro K03cpcpUl(IIe1ITa IIlIopII)J;HlIra, T. e. npOl(elITlIoro COOTnome-
IIHH 6paKOB Men,JJ,y ,a:BOIOpO,ll,IIbIMII 6paThHMII H ceCTpaMH no OTlIomeIIIIIO I,
oorneMY qIICJIY 3aK.'1IOl.IelIlIhIX 6paKOB. TamUI 06pa30M, ,ll,JIH cpaBlIeHHH nony-
JIH IIII MeiR,a:y C060lI cym;ecTByeT TOqRaH Mepa, 110 TaIWH lIfepbI IIeT )J;JIH cpaB-
IIeIIIIH IIapOiJ,OB. .f[ corJIaCeH C 10. B. BpOMJIeeM B TOM, qTO Ta IIJIH HHaH
CTenelIb 3II)..(oraMHII npe;:\CTaBJIHeT C060lI O)J;IIII II3 3TIIHqeCKIIX onpe)..(eJIIITe-
JIell 21, HO Y)..(OBJIeTBOpnTe.:'IblIaH Mepa CTenelIII 3II.D:OraMlfII BIIYTPII 06mHpHhIX
rpynn nonYJIHl(IIll, KOTOphIe II COCTaBJIHIOT IIapO)J;bI, nOKa OTCYTCTByeT.
n upe.D:JIOnnITh ee lIe TaK npOCTO, BejJ;b cpe)J;IIIIH Km:lcpcpH IIelIT )..(JIH IIapo)..(a
6yp.eT npe)..(CTaBJIHTh c0501! cpIIKl(IIIO, TaR HaK OTp:eJIblIbIe cOBoKynlIocTH no-
nYJIHl(III! BIIYTpn IIapO.D:OB 3aBe)J;OMO xapaKTepII3YIOTCH pa3IIOII CTeneHbIO 6pa'l-
HOll aBTOIIO iIIII. ITo 3TOll iRe npIIqHlIe IIeJIh3H nOKa cpaBIIIIBaTb MeiRP:Y CO-
GOll IIapo.D: B l(eJIOM C JII060lI Bxop.Hm;eH B ero COCTaB nonYJIH IIell IIJIH rpyn-
nOll nonYJIH IIH. "YiRe Cell'IaC MomlIO npe)..(nOJIaraTb, qTO cpe)..(IIe3TIIHqeCKaH
Mepa opa'TIIoro pO)..(CTBa IIaII)J;eT BbIpaiI\:€IIIIe B KaKOH-TO CIICTeMe IIemmeliIlbIX
ypaBHelIIIll CO MlIorIIMII nepeMelIlIbIMH, 110 KOIIKpeTlIaH cpopMa TaKOH CIICTe-
MbI OCTaeTCH HeHCHOH.
HaKOBbI pa3MephI II xapaKTep nonYJIH HH? OHH pa3JIHqlIbI B pa3IIhIX 06-
JIaCTHX OHKyMelIhI B 3aBIICIIlIfOCTII OT )..(BYX npOTIIBOnOJIOiRlIO IIanpaBJIelIHbIX,
110 B3aIIMII0 CBH3alIIIhlX B .D:eHCTBlfII npn'fIIlI - CTenelIII II1I6pII)..(IIlIra H IIH-
TelICHBIIOCTH CMerneIIIIH. MII6pIIAHIIr B03IIIIIWeT aBTOllfaTHl.leCKH: BepOHTIIOCTb
pO)J;CTBelIlIhlX 6paKoB YBeJIIIqIIBaeTCH C na)J;elIIIeM qIICJIelIlIOCTII nonYJIHl(IIII.
"Y CIIJIelIIIIO IIlI6pII)J;IiIlra Bcer,ll,a cnoc06cTByeT H CO IIaJIblIaH II30JIH IIH, HMeIO-
m;aH MeCTO BIIYTPH IIo)..(aBJIHIOm;erO 60JIbIlIHIICTBa nonYJIH IIH. "(:lTo KacaeTCH
qHCJIelIlIOCTII nonYJIHl(IIR, TO Bonpoc 3TOT lIe HCCJIe)..(OBaII no BceMY 3eMIIOMY
IIIapy CKOJIbKO-IIH6YP.b IIop.p06IIo. B. B. BYlIaK npep:JIonnIJI IIa OCIIOBalIIIH II3Y-
l.IeHIIH l.IIICJIelIIIOCTII nonYJIH IIn Y PYCCKoro CTapOiRIIJIbqeCKOrO HaCeJIelIIIH
CH6IIpII Tpn RaTeroplfII }lJIH IIonYJIH IIOIIIIOH qHCJIeIIHOCTH: )..(0 1500 qeJIO-
BeK - U30JIHT. OT 1500 )..(0 4000 l.IeJIOBeK - )..(eM H CBhlilie 4000 qeJIOBeK-
rpynna JJ:eMO 22. CaMa TepllfIIIIOJIOI'IIH CBIIJJ:eTeJIbCTByeT 0 TOM, qTO 3TIIM
nOIIYJIfl IIHM pa3IIOH qIICJIelIlIOCTII npHp.aeTCH IIepapXIIl.leCKOe 3IIaqelIHe.
Mem.D:Y TeM TaKaH IIepapXUH nonymI IIII eCJIII II onpaB)..(alIlIa IIa )..(eJIe,
TO )..(aJIeKO lIe Bcer)J;a. B JJ:areCTalIe, IIanpIIMep, npII rocnO)J;CTBe 3II)..(oraMIIK
BIIYTPII CeJIeIIIIll Bce OIIH JJ:OJImlIbI paCCMaTpIIBaTbCH KaK II30JIHTbI. Ho cpe)..(K
CeJIelIHH eCTb H TamIe, "tJHCJIeIIIIOCTb KOTOphIX 3aMeTII0 npeBhlmaeT 1500 qe-
JIOBeK, XOTH 3II,a:oraMUH Bce paBIIO coxpalIHeT 3a IIIIMII rrOJIOmelIIIe 3aMHHY-
ThIX II30.:'IHTOB. C )..(pyroll CTOpOHbI, OIIU lIe 06'be)..(IIIIHIOTCH B 60JIee KpynlIhIe
rpynnhI 6pal.IIIhIlIfII KpyraMII. Ha PYCCKOH paBIIIIlIe nOJIlIhIe II30JIHTbI pe)J;KIf
H nony.lIH HOlIlIaH CTpYKTypa COCTOIIT II3 60JIee KpynlIbIx rpynn. KOTOphIe
B. B. BYlIaK IIa3hIBaeT BCJIe)..( 3a aMeplIKalICKUMH IICCJIe)..(OBaTeJIHMII )..(eMaMIf
II rpynnaMH )J;eMOB.
CRa3alIIIoe lIe 03lIaqaeT, qTO H OTpu aIO nepapXIIIO B nonYJIHl(IIOHIIOll
CTpYKType. HaJIII"tJIIe ee npe.D:CTaBJIHeTCH COBepmelIIIO OqeBIIJ],IIbIM J],aiRe Teo-
peTIIqeCKII, TaK KaK IIepaBIIOl(eIIIIOCTh pa3IIhIX relIeTIIqeCKllX 6apbepOB He
BbI3hIBaeT COMIIeIIIIII, TaR me RaK H UX pa3IIaH npOIIII aeMOCTb. O):(HO )..(eJIO -
jl,IIaJIeKTHhle pa3JIIIqIIH II KYJIbTYPIIO-IICTOpIIqeCKaH Tpa)..(II IIH, KOTOphIe, XOTH
II COCTaBJIHIOT relIeTIIqeCKHII 6apbep, Bcerp.a npOIIII aeMbI, H COBceM )..(pyroe
)..(eJIO - IIeupeO)..(OJIIIMhIe IIJIH TpY)..(IIonpeO)..(OJIIIMhIe cpH3IIKo-reorpacpIIqeCKHe
6apbephI IIJIII 06hI"tJall 8II)..(oraMIIII, C03)J;aIOm;IIe relIeTIIqeCKIIH 6apbep orpOM-
11011 MOm;IIOCTII. COOTBeTCTBelIlIO If nonYJIH HII, OT)..(eJIHeMbIe OT )J;pyrux pa3-
IIhIMII relIeTH"tJeCKIIMH 6apbepaMII. pa3.lIIIqaIOTCH no rrpOl(elITy BI,JIIOqaeMhIX
B Hx COCTaB IIIIOpO)..(HbIX JIHl(, no CTenelIH HH6pH)..(IiIlra, )..(JIlfTeJIbIIOCTIf H30JIH-
113
I
114
1J;IIII II, IIaKOlIel(, no qIICJIeIIIIOCTH. B03MomlIOCTII nOCTpoelIIIH IIepapXIIII no-
nYJIHl(IIH HCXO;UI II3 3TIIX IIpIIIIl(IIIIOB nOKa MaJIO IICCJleJ],OBaHhI, 110 TOJIbRO
,OIlII, o reBIIJJ:IIO, II 1I0JIOiRaT OCIIOBY KJIaCCIIcpIIRal(IIII nonymmHII, ROTopaH OT-
pa3IIT IIX COIIOp,qIIlIeIIIIe, peaJIblIO CYIIIeCTBYIOm;ee B J],eIICTBIITeJlbIlOCTH.
KaKOB IICTopH reCKIIiI 8cpcpeKT H3yqelIIIH aIITpOnOJIOrII IeCKoro COCTana Ie-
.JIOBeqeCTna IIMeHHO IIa nOIlYJIH:qlfOIIHOM YPOBlIe? qTO IIOBOrO BIIOCIIT 8TOT
nOIlYJIH IIOlIlIbIll YPOBelIb, IIanpIIMep, B II3Y IeIIIIe IIpOOJIeMhI 3THorelIe3a no
cpaBHelIIIIO C KJIaCCIIqeCRIIM IlOp,XOJ],Ollf CTapOll aIITpOnOJIOrIIII? ECTh JIll CMhICJI
TpaTIITb CIIJIbI Ha Tpyp,oeMKIIe 1I0rryJIHl(IIOlIlIhIe IICCJIeJ],OBallIIH, IIMeH B BII)J;e
lWIIWIIIOii: eJIII OCBem;eIIIIe IICTOpIIqeCKOII IIp06JIeMaTIIKII? CpeJ],II 60JIbmOrO
TmCJIa CTPYKTyplIhIX II llrYH IIOlIaJIbHhIX npII3HaKOB qeJIOBeqeCKoro opralIII3-
Ma I{ HaCTOEm;eMY BpeM€lUI BhIJ],eJIeIIO IIeMaJIO MOlIocpaKTOpIIaJIblIbIX, T. e. yn-
paBJIHeMhIX B IIaCJIep,CTBeIIIIOH nepep,aqe OjJ;IIHM IIJIII ,Il;BYMH relIaMII. B 3aMR-
HYToil UOUY;IHL(IIII KOIIUCHTpaL(IIH TaKIIX rellOB aBTOMaTII reCKII YBeJIlPUfBaeTCH
IJJIlI YMelIbmaeTCH, ITO 6hlJI0 1I0Ka3alI0 IIa pa3IIbIX MaTeplIaJIaX II nOJIY-
mJIO B aMeplfKaHCKon relIeTIPIeCKOH JIHTepaType IIaIIMeHOBalIIIe relIlIoro
.D:pellcpa, B COBeTcKoii: - reHeTHKo-aln'OllfaTII reClmx npOl(eCCOB. B COOTBeTCT-
BIfIf C YBeJIIf !eIlHellf HJIII YMeHbIIleIIIIel\I KOIIl(eIITpal(IIII reHOB YBeJIII !HBaeTCH
IIJIH YMelIbmaeTCH, KOlIeqlIO, II BhlpaiRelInOCTb Tex IIJIH IIlIhIX npII3IIaKOB.
AIITpOnOJIOrlI IeCKoe IICCJIe,ZJ;9BalIlIe Ha nonYJIHl(IIOIIIIOM ypOBlIe ImK 6hI no-
BTopHeT 8TOT nYTh, 110 B oopaTIIOM nopH,II;Ke: II3Y IeHHe BapHa IIH npH3IIaROB
B IlonYJIH:qIIHX II03BO.T!HeT COCTaBHTb npep,CTaBJIelIlfe 06 IIX renlIOII KOII elI-
Tpa IIH II 0 ee II3MeHeHHII BO npeMelIII, a 011 a, B CBOIO Oqepe,Il;b, CJIymIIT p,JIH
BOCCTaIIOB.T!eIIIfH IIX IWIII{peTIIOH IICTOpIIII.
B. B. rIIlI36ypr, 1I3y raH pacnpe.D:eJIeHIIe rpynll KpOBH CIfCTeMbI ABO B
OT,ZJ;eJIblIhIX CeJIelIHHX roplIoro Tap,mIIKHcTalIa, nOJIY IIIJI l(IICPPhI, nOqTII COOT-
BeTCTBYIOm;IIe aMnJIlITyp,e Ko.;reoaIIIIll B KOIIl(eIITpal(IIII rellon CIICTeMbI ABO
110 BceMY 3eMIIOMY mapy 23. IIM II .n:PyrIIMH IICCJIe,ll,OBaTeJIHMII 8TO cnpaBep,-
JIIIBO paCCMaTpIIBaJIOCh B CBH3II C 8cpcpeKTOM II30JIH HII, qTO nOp,TBepiRp,aeTCH
II ,rr:IIaJIeKTHhIl\I lJIelIeIIIIel\f Tap,iRIIRCKOro H3hIKa B roplIhlX paii:ollax, II 3IIa-
mTeJIbIIOII p,IIcpcpepelIl(Hal(IIeII nallfIIpcKIIX H3bIKOB. Ho caM no ce6e ,ZJ;aHlIhIII
BbIBOp, MaJIOBarl,eH B IfCTOpIIqeCKOM OTlIomeIlIIII, TaR KaK IICTOpIIqeCKH 3IIa-
IIIM lIe caM cpaRT YCTaHOBJIeHIIH H30JIllpOnalIIIOCTII IICTOpIIqeCKOro npo ecca
B TOM IIJlI1 IIIIOM paii:olIe, a cpaBIIIITeJlblIaH o elIKa CIIJIhI J],eIICTBIIH H30.aH IIII
B 3TOM II cocep,IIHX paii:oHax. TI03iRe 6hlJI0 nOKa3alI0, ITO II30.T!Hl(IIH IIa ITa-
Mllpe IIMeeT 60JIee 1I03)J;lIee npOIlcxom)J;elIHe no Cp<l.BlIeIIllIO C OqelIb )J;peBlIeH
II30JIH IIeH OTp,eJIblIbIX nonYJIHl(HII B npeD;eJIax .D:arecTaHa 2". STOT BhIBOp,
6bIJI nOJIy reII lIe TOJIbKO C nOllfOm;bIO H3yqelIIIH MOlIocpaKTOpHaJIhlIbIX npII3IIa-
KOB, 110 II npII paCCMOTpeHlIH II3MelI'lIIBOCTH nOJIllcpaKTOpIIaJIbHhIX npII3IIaKOB,
KOTophIe TaKme pe<l.rIIpYWT Ha yCJIOBIIH II30JIH IIII. 3aKJIIO relIlfe 0 60JIbmeH
.p,IIcpcpepelIl(Ha IIII p,areCTaIICKIIX nonYJIH lfn no cpaBlIellHIO C lIaMIIpCRIfMH
HaXO)J;IITCH B nOJIIIOM COrJIaCHII C IICKJIlO'IIITeJIhIIOII H3bIKOBOH JJ:pOOIIOCTbIO
J'oplIoro .D:arecTalIa, T. e. nOJIyqaeT rrop,TBepm)J;eIIHe co CTOpOHhI JIHlIrBIICTH-
qeCKHX p;alIlIhIX. ECJIlI iRe TaKIIX AOnOJIIIIITeJIblIhIX )J;alIllhIX HeT, TO aHTpono-
JIOrJIqeCKHe IIaOJIIOp,eIIIIH CJIymaT ep,lfHCTBelIlIbIM IICTWIIIIIKOM IIHcpopMan;IIH
o BpellfelIH 060c06JIelIHH TOH IIJIII IIIIOii: 8TIIIlqeCKOH rpynnhI. B aHTpOIlOJIOrHH
eCTb IIeCKOJIbKO KJIaCCIIqeCRHX 1I0IIy.:rHl(IIOlIlIbIX MOp,eJIeII, IIa KOTOphIX I13Y-
'IelIbI CHJIa p,enCTBIIH II30JIH IIII If ee BJIIIHnIIe IIa II3MelIqIIBOCTb IIpH3IIa-
KOB 25. Pe3YJIbTaTbI If3yqelIIIH TaKIIX lIfop,eJIen II nOJIyqelIHhIe npII 8TOM CTalI-
p,apTlIhIe napaMeTpbI CBH3H Mem.)J;Y BIIYTpIfIlony.T!H HOlIlIhIMH 3cpcpeKTaMH H
KOIIKpeTlIoi] HCTopHell COOTBeTCTBYIOm;IIX nonYJIHl(lfll MorYT 6bITb IICnO.:'Ib30-
BalIbI II HCnOJlb3YIOTCH KaK OCIIOBa ,ll,JIH )J;aJIbHeIIIIIIIX IICCJIe,ll,OBaIIHII B 3TOM
HalIpaBJIelIlfH.
II' . ' .
!
I
I
Cym;ecTBelIIIO II )J;pyroe: norryJIHl(TIOIIIIOe IICCJIeiJ,OBaHHe alITpOrrOJIOrnqe-
CKIIX oc06eHIIOCTeH B CBH3II C .D:eMOrpacpII eCROH CTPYKTypon 6pocaeT CBeT
IIa o eHKy ,ll,IIcpcpepelI IIpOJmlIlIon nJIOJJ;OBIITOCTII pa3HbIX nOTIYJIH Hii:. A 31'0,
B CBOIO Oqepe)J;b, BeIleT 3a c060n B03MOiRIIOCTb npOIlIIKIIOBelIIIH B caMYIO IfH-
TIIMIIYIO CTOPOIIY paco06pa30BaHIIH: nOCJIe)J;OBaTe:ILIIOCTb H CIWpOCTh pacnpo-
CTpalIelIIIH pa3nhIX npII3IIaKOB B nonYJIHl(IIHX. I1CTOpIIqeCKaH 3IIa IIIMOCTb
.D:aHlIhlX TaKoro pOAa BeJIUKa npII OO HClIeIIHII qUCJIelIlIOCTH npeACTaBIITeJIen
pa3JIIlqlIhIX pac. qTO RacaeTCH )J;IIcpcpepelI IIpOBaIIIIOII nJIOJJ;OBHTOCTII nonYJIH-
IJ,HlI, nOKa IIeT CKOJIbKO-IIII6YJJ;b y6eD:IlTeJIblIhIX AalIlIhIX 06 1I3IIaqaJIblI0 He-
o;:(HlIaKoBoll nJIO)J;OBHTOCTII npe.D:CTaBIITeJIeII pa3IIbIX paCOBhIX TImOB. Olla
CHJIblIO KOJIe6JIeTCH B pa3JIII IIIhIX COl(HaJIbII0-8KOIIOMIIqeCKIIX yCJIOBIIHX H 3a-
BIICHT OT MIIOI'IIX COl(IIaJIblIhIX H nCIIXOJIorIIqeCKIIX rrpIIqIIII. ROJIe6alIHH no-
Ka3aTeJIen nJIOJJ;OBIITOCTII, KOTOpbIe MoryT 6bITb YCTalIOBJIeHhI B xop:e rrony-
JIH IIOlIlIhIX HCCJIe,ll,OBaIIIIH, 6YAYT cIIoc06cTBoBaTb 60JIee TOqUOMY Onp AeJIe-
nIIIO 8TIIX npU IIII 26.
BocnpnlIHMaeMoe yme IWK aKCIIOllfa npIIBbIqlIOe yTBepiRAelIIIe cpOpMHpO-
BalIHH all'rpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO COCTaBa IIapoAa IIa 6a3e pa3JIIIqlIbIX pacoBbIx TII-
nOB BnepBble npn06p€'raeT npII yqeTe nonYJIHl(IIOIIIIOro cpaKTopa IWHKpeTlIbIH
CMhICJI. TOJIbKO OH n03BOJIHeT B3BeCIITh y):(eJIblIhIH Bec Toro IIJIIf IIlIoro KOllfn-
JIeKCa pacoBbIx npII3IIaROB B OTAeJIhlIhIX TeppIITOpnaJIhlIbIX II clTlIOrpacpIIqe-
CKIIX rpynnax Toro IIJIII IfIIoro IIapoAa. TaK COCTaBJIeHbI )IeTaJIblIhle KapThI
alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIX npII3IIaKOB .D:JIH TeppHTopIIII paCCeJIelIIIH pyccKoro IIapo-
,],a, YKpaHII eB, cpIIIIHOH3hI IIIhIX IIapo):(oB, HapO.D:OB RaBKa3a II TIpII6aJITIIRu.
OAlIaRO CTenelIb relIepaJIH3al(IIII IIX TaKOBa, ITO IIapo,a:hI paCCMaTpIIBaJIHCb
l\aK COCTOHm;IIe II3 CTalI)IapTlIhIX, paBIIOMeplIO paCCeJIelIIIbIX B npOCTpalICTBe
nony.ITHl(IIH, KaK paBIIOnJIOTlIhIe B OTlIomeIIIIII 6paqlIoro pO.Il;CTBa. <PaKTOp
nepapXIIII norrymI IIn npII npeAllIeCTBYIOm;IIX c60pax anTponOJIOrnqeCKIIX
}IaTepnaJIOB JIII60 COBceM lIe y IIIThIBaJICH, JIII60 y IIIThIBaJICH JIIIllIb B MaJIOII
CTenelIII. TeopeTII IeCl\IIn OTXO)J; OT nOIIIIMalIIIH IIapOAa KaK cOBoKynlIocTII
O.Il;IIOpOAlIhIX n paBIIOMepHO pacnpeD:eJlelIlIhIX B npOCTpalICTBe nonYJIHl(IIn
y}Re npOII30meJI, IIO npaKTII IeCKIIe llIarH no c60py COOTBeTcTByIOm;HX HOBOB
ROH en IIn 3MnHpn IeCKIIX .Il;alIlIhIX TOJIbKO IIaqIIlIaIOTCH.
nA EoAHTPonO OrHqECRAHnOnY H HH
1I3Y IaH COBpe}IeIIIIOe IIaCeJIelIIIe na nonYJIH IIOIIIIOM ypoBlIe, alITpOnOJIOr 3a-
BHcnT caM OT ce6H n opralIII3yeT CBOII IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH B COOTBeTCTBIIII C 110-
BbIl\III npUIIl(IInaMII. He TO B naJIeOalITponOJIOrIIII, rAe MaTepIIaJI c06npaeTCH
,],0 CHX nop B OOm;eM-TO CJIY IallIIO, npH apxeOJIOr:uqeCKIIX paCKonKax MOI'IIJIh-
IIHROB. ApXeOJIOrIIqeCRIIe iRe paCKonRH, l(eJIbIO KOTOphIX 6bIJI 6bI Cnel(HaJIb-
110 COop naJIeOaIITponOJIOrII IeCKHX IWJIJIeK Hn, qpe3BhI aliliO peARH. 8TO 06-
CTOHTeJIbCTIJO 06 HCHHeTCH MaJIO HCJIeHIIOCTbIO Ka)J;pOB naJIeOaIITpOnOJIOrOB.
BJIaAeIOm;HX l\IeTO)J;IIKOll caMOCTOHTeJIblIhIX paCKonOK, II OTCYTCTBIIeM 3aHIITe-
peCOBaHIIOCTII apxeOJIOrOB B paCKonKax MOrIIJIhIIIIKOB, AaIOm;IIX npeIIMym;ecT-
BelIHO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII IeCl\IIiI MaTepHaJI II MaJIYIO apxeOJIOrn IeCKYIO HII-
cpopMal(IIIO. OD:UaKO IIOIIIIManIIe nC:UXOJIOrII IeCKIIX II 06 eKTHBlIhIX rrplIqIIII
B03IIIIKIIOBelIIIH TaKoro nOJIOiRelIIIH Cal\fO no ce6e lIe HCnpaBJIHeT ero. MeiRAY
TeM IICCJIe)],OBaIIIIe naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOro MaTepIIaJIa IIa nonYJIHl(IIOIIIIOM
ypOBlIe TaKilie n03BOJIHeT nOJIyqUTh pH,ll, .D:OnOJIIIIITeJIhlIhIX ,a:alIlIhIX, oe3 RO-
TOpbIX cenqac yme IIeB03MOiRIIO npe,ll,CTaBIITb ce6e alITpOnOJIOrIIqecKyIO pe-
ROlIcTpyR nIO ApeBlIero HaCeJIeIIHH.
TIpem,ll,e Bcero, RaROBO nOIIHTIIe nonYJIH:qHH npnMelIIITeJIblIO K naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKoMY MaTepHaJIY? npHMbIX MeTO,ZJ;OB onpe,a:eJIeIIIIH qHCJIeIIIIO-
115
!
,;
CTH H CTPYKTYPhI D,peBlIlIX nonyml:qIIii:, eCTeCTBeIIIIO, HeT. B OOm;eM MOiImO
paCCMaTpHBaTb KaK nOUYJIHl(IIIO nOrpeOelIHbIX IIa O;UIOM KJIa)J,OIIm;e, 110 npH
3TOM nyiRlIO npIIIIIIlIfaTb EO EIIHMalIIIe npOD:OJIiIUITeJIbIIOCTh ero CPYHKl(IIOIIII-
pOBaHIIH. ECJIII olla 3HaqIITeJIblIa, TO MbI CTaJIKIIBaeMCH C HBJIelIuellf. lIe ECTpe-
qaIOm;HlIfCH npII If3Y IeHHII COBpellfelIHoro Hace.TIeHIUI,- C norry.TIH IIeii: KaK OhI
npO.D:OJImeIIIIOII, pa3BepHYTOH BO BpellfemI, npHqellf B IIee BXO)J,IIT 3IIaqUTeJIbHO
OOJIbmee HfCJIO relIepal(lIii:, IeM B COBpe feHIIYIO. TIpII Ol(eHKe npOD,OJIiRIfTeJIh-
IIOCTII mn3IIH, oc06elIHO eCJIII IIeT .Il;aIIHhIX 0 ee pe3IWlIf H3l1felIenUII. 3'1'0 06-
CTOHTeJIbCTBO He IIMeeT 3Haqe1IHH. O,'J,HaKO UpII onpe.Il;eJIelIIIH IIICJIeHIIOCTII
.Il;peBIIIIX nonYJIHl(IIII IIa OCHOBe KOJIII IeCTBa IIorpeoelIIIII lIa KJIaJ{OIIm;ax, OCO-
6elIno IIa 60JILmIIX, nymlIO nOCTOHlIlIO nOllflIHTb 00 8TOM, I'r06hI He nOJIyqIITb
3aBhIIDCHIIbIC l(IIqJPhI. TWIIIhIe apXeOJIOrIIqeCIUre lIfeTOD:hI onpeD:eJlelIHH .Il;JIII-
TeJIblIOCTH IICnOJIh30BalIIIH Tex IIJIII HlIbIX KJIa.Il;6IIm; nOKa lIe pa3pa60TalIhI,
II n03TOllfY, eCJIII EIeT npOTIIBonOKa3aIluii: (06bI IaiI OT,ZJ;eJIbIIOrO OT B3pOC.:IhIX
norpe6elIIIH )J;eTeii:, cne IIqJIIqeCKaH MYiRCKaH IIJIn meIICI{8H BhI60pKa II T. .II;.),
3a nonYJIHl(IIIO lIfomlIO YCJIOBIIO npUHHTb cOBoRynHocTb JIlOD:eii:. noxopOHelI-
IIbIX B OT.II;e.:'IbUOM IIe60JIbIDOllf IIWrIIJIbIIIIKe, COCTOHm;ellf H3 neCKOJIbKHX rre-
CHTKOB norpeOeHIIII. MOrIIJIbIIIIK, eCTeCTBeUIIO, .Il;OJIiReH 6hITb paCKonaII nOJI-
HOCTbIO. a naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIH MaTepIIaJI II3 Hero co6paIl callfhIM Tm;a-
TeJILlIhIM 06pa30llf, BKJIIO IaH CKeJIeThI II3 D:eTCKIIX II lIfJIa.Il;eH IeCKIIX
3axopOlIelIIIH. 8TO, KOlIe'IHO, 6Y)J;YT lIe norryJIH IIII B IlOJIIIOllf ClIfhICJIe CJIOBa,
a cy6- HJIH lIflfKpononymIl(IIII, 110 IIlIfeHIIO OIIIf II COCTaBJIHJIII, Ha.Il;O JJ;YMaTb,
RII3IDYIO cTynelIL norryJIHD,IIOIIIIoii: .Il;IIcpcpepeIlI Ifal(IIH IIa palIIIIIX CTa)J,IIHX pa3-
BIITIIH qeJIOBeqeCTBa.
nepBbIii: 3Tan nonYJIHl(IIOHUOro IICCJIep:OBaIIIIH B naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrHII IIa-
qIIHaeTCH C yTOqlIelIIIH rpalIIIl( 3TIIII IeCKIIX 06m;IIOCTeH H BbI.II;eJIelIHH lca:R Mom-
110 60JIee lIfeJIKIIX II rOllforelIlIhIX rpynn Ha naJIeOalITpono.TIOrIIqeCKOM MaTe-
pHaJIe. HanpIIMep, JJ;peBJIHlIe IIa npOTHiI',eIIIIII lIfHorIIX JIeT CqHTaJIHCb
npe.Il;CTaBHTeJIHlIfII IDIIpOKOJIIIl(ero MaCCIIBlIoro II D:JIHHHOrOJIOBOrO TIIna II npo-
TIIBonOCTaBJIHJIIICb B 8TOM OTHomelIIUI .Il;pyrHlIf BOCTOqHOCJIaBHIICKIIM nJIellfe-
IIallf. Pa36HBKa no xapaKTepy I10rpe6eIIIIII. n03BOJlIfJIa BbI)J,eJIHTh rpynrry BO-
JIhIIIHII. II OKa3aJIOCb, qTO onHcaHlIhlii: THn xapaK'repeH IIMelIlIO )J,JIH IIIIX.
q TO ,He KacaeTCH COOCTBelIHO ,ZJ;peBJIHH, TO OIIH IIa caMOM )J,eJIe 6blJIH 60JIee
IDIIpOKOrOJIOBhI, IeM MbI .Il;YMaJIII )J,O CIIX nop, II C6JIIImaJIIICh C TIIBep al\1H 27.
ITOC.TIe paCKonOK lIfOrIIJIbRIIKa y OKYlIeBa YJIyca C. A. TenJIOYXOBhIlIf, lIfO-
rIIJIbHHKOB y c. EeJIbThIpbI II norpe6elIIIH y C. ACKII3 A. H. JIHncKHM 6bIJI
c)J;eJIaII BhIBOJJ; 0 IIaJIIIqIIII B COCTaBe IIaCeJIelIIIH acpaHaCbeBCKOH RYJIbTypbI
lIfOlIrOJIOH)J,Hon npIIlIfeCII. BbIBO)J, 8TOT nOJIyqIIJI .Il;OnOJlIUfTeJIbIIOe nO)J,TBepm-
,ZJ;eIIIle nOC.:'Ie H3yqeIIIIH qepenOB II3 paCKonalIlIoro A. H. JIIIncKHM MorIf,'!b-
RIIKa Tac-Xa3aa. O.Il;IIaKO nOCJIe paCKonOK RpaCIIOHpCKOll apXeOJIOrIIqeCKOH
3Kcne,a:IIl(IIell nOD: PYKOBOD:CTBOM lVI. n. fpH3IIOBa lIfOrIlJIbIIIIKa "lJepHoBaH-VIII
If BbI,a:eJIeIIHH OKYlIeBCKOH RY.:'IbTyphI y,a:aJIOCh OCYIDeCTBHTb OOJIee IeTRyIO aT-
pH6yl(HIO norpe6elIIIll, II3 KOTOpbIX npOIICXO.D:HT qepena C lIfOlIrOJIOII)J,HOll
npHMeCbIO, If nOKa3aTb, ITO Bce OIIH npe)J,CTaBJIHIOT lIe acpalIaCbeBCKoe,
a ORYlIeBCKoe HaCeJIelIIIe 28. TIo,a:C IeT BIIYTpHrpynnoBhIX KOppeJIHl(IIH B cepIfII
II3 cpe)J,IIeBeKOBoro lIfOrIIJIblIHKa Tp-Ee,ll,apH IIa AJITae, paCKOllalIHoro
M. f. EJIbKHlIbIM, n03BOJIHJI BhIHBIITh .D:Ba alITpono.rrorIIqeCIUIX ROMllOHeIITa,
npHIIHBIDIIe yqaCTIre B cpOpMIIpOBalIIIn lIfeCTlIoro IIaCeJIeIIHH, - eIITpaJIbIIO-
a3IIaTCKHH, npOIIIIKaBIDIIH, OqeBH,a:HO, H3 TYBhI II MOlIrOJlIIII B 3noxy cpe)J,IIe-
BeKOBhH, H MeCTlIhIll, BOCXOp:Hm;HII K IIaCeJIemiIO npe)J,roplIoro A.TITaH CRIIcpO-
capMaTCKoro BpellfelIIf 29.. 8TH TPH npIIlIfepa nOKa3bIBaIOT, KaK BaiRlIO nepe-
BeCTII naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKHe IICCJIe.D:OBaIIIIH Ha nonYJIH IIOlIlIhlH ypoBelIb
If OT cOHOCTaBJIeHIIH CYllfMaplIhlx naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIlqeCKIIX )J,alIlIhlx no IIa-
- .
:1
116
CeJIeIIIIIO apXeOJIOrIIqeCKIIX KYJIbTYP nepellTH K cpaBlIelIIIIO OT,ll,eJIblIhIX MO-
TIIJIblIlmOB, a TO H 60JIee MeJIKIIX rpynlI, Bhlp,eJIHeMhIX lIO KYJIbTyplIbIM oco-
6elIIIocTHM BIIYTPH MOrIIJIbIIIIKOB, T. e. B KOlIeqlIOM lI'l'ore K conOCTaBJIelIIIIO
alITponOJIOrIIqeCKHX oc06elIIIocTeH OTp,eJIblIhIX nonYJIHl(IIll.
He Mellee BeJIIIKa pOJIb nonyJIHl(IIOIIIIOro YPOBIIH II B lIaJIeOp,eMorpacpII'le-
CKHX IICCJIep,OBaIIIUIX. B lIpIIIIl(IIlIe MOiRlIO npOII3BO,ll,HTb naJIeOp,eMorpacpIIqe-
CKIIe paCqeTbI H IIa OCIIOBalIIIII OlIpep,eJIelIHH IIII,ll,IIBH,ZJ;yaJIbIIOrO 6IIOJIOrIIqe-
CKoro B03paCTa B CYMMaplIhIX naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX cepIUIX. TaK
lIOCTYlIIIJI r. .D:. Eep,ll,bUlieB C )J;aHHbIMH H. C. P030Ba II MOIIMII no AJITae-
CaHHCKOMY IIarOpbIO, HCnOJIb30BaB cO)J;epiRaBmIIeCH B IIamHX paOOTax onpe-
.D:eJIeIIHH B03paCTa IIa CReJIeTaX B3pOCJIbIX JIIO,ll,en 30. ECJIH nepeBeCTII ero
paC IeTbI npOl(eHTIIOro COOTHomeIIIUI JIHl( pa3IIhIX B03paCTHbIx KaTeropIIH B
ro.n;a, TO OKameTCH, qTO Cpe,ll,IIIIH B03paCT IIaCeJIelIHH OTJJ;eJIbHbIX KYJIbTYP B
MIIIIYCIIIICKOII KOTJIOBIIlIe ObIJI CJIe)J;YIOm;HH:
AcPaHaCbeBCKaH KYJIbTypa 33,3 r. (24) TarapcKaH » 37,2 r. (241)
AHp,poHoBcKaH » 35,7 JI. (21) TamTbIKcKaH » 43,3 r. (21)
RapacYKcKaH » 32,7 Jr. (28) HaceJIemIC XVIII-XIX BB. 38,2 r. (181)*
STII p,alIlIhle, wleBlIp,IIO, 3aBhlmeHbI H3-3a OTCYTCTBIIH B UIIX CBep,eHIIH 0
,ZJ;eTCKOII cMepTlIocTII. Ho p,ame B TaKOM BII)J;e OIIII BhIHBJIHIOT IIeKOTopyIO TelI-
.n;elI IIIO K II3MelIelIIIIO npO.D:OJIiRHTeJIbIIOCTII iRII3IIII lIPII cpaBlIelIIIH lI03AHIIX
3nox C 60JIee paIIIIIIMII. EOJIee elIlIhIMII HB.:'IHIOTCH cBe)J;elIIIH no OTp,eJIblIhIM
MOrIIJIbIIIIKaM. B KaqeCTBe npIIMepa npIIBeP,Y paCqeThl npo.rrOJIIl,HTeJILllOCTII
mH3IIII p,JIH Tpex MOrIIJIblIHKOB acpalIaCbeBcKoii KyJIbTYPbI, pacKonalIlIbIx nOJI-
HOCTbIO IIJIII nOqTH nOJIIIOCTbIO:
IIO,I1cyxaHlIxa
KapacYK III
AcPaHacbeBcKaH ropa
18,7 JI. (9)
24,1 r. (39)
33,1 r. (23)
BH.D:HhI OTqeTJIIIBhle pa3JIH IIIH B B03pacTe 3axopolIelIIIhIx B OT.D:eJIhUhIX
MOrIIJIbIIImax. STII pa3JIlIqHH CTaBHT pHp, IICTOpHqeCKIIX II 3TIIorpacpIIqeCKIIX
BonpocoB: 0 B03MomlIOCTH pa3IIbIX OObIqaeB 3axopolIelIIIH, B IaCTIIOCTH pa3-
)IeJIhHOrO lIorpe6eIIIUI ,ll,eTell II B3pOCJIhIX (oc06elIIlo B CBH3II C MOrIIJIbIIIIKa-
MH B TIo)J;cyxalIlIxe, COCTOHBmIIMII B OCIIOBIIOM II3 ,ll,eTCRIIx norpe6eHlIll) 31,
o 3axopOlIelIIlhIX pa3IIOrO CO IIaJIblIoro ypOBHH, 06 YCJIOBHHX iRII3HII,
II B qaCTIIOCTH lIIITaIIHH, B CBH3II C npeOOJIap,alIIIeM CROTOBOACTBa IIJIH 3eM-
JIep,eJIHH B X03HllcTBe. .D:IIcpcpepelIl(HpOBannbIe p,alIlIhle ropa3,ZJ;0 60JIee HIICPOp-
MaTIIBlIhI, qeM CYMMaplIhle, lIO Bcell KYJIbType B l(eJIOM.
R HacToHm;eMy BpeMelIII ony6mmoBauo IIeCKOJIbKO pa60T, Cne IIaJIhlIO no-
C,BHm;elIlIbIX naJIeOp,eMorpacpIIqeCKOII xapaKTepIIcTIIKe OT)J;e.TlbHbIX nO.'1HOCTbIO
IIJIII nOqTH nOJIIIOCTbIO pacKolialIHhlx MorHJIhHHKOB. STO cpep,ueBeKOBbIe MO-
BIJJblIHKH TITym II EJIe,ll, B lOrOCJIaBIIII 32, ReplIYCTa, XamIM6a-Qepem II
<DOlIhOp, B BelIrpIIH 3\ PeKaII B fepMalICKOII .D:eMoKpaTII IeCKOH PecIIy6-
.'lIme 3\ MIIKYJIbqIIl(e B qexOCJIOBaKIIII 35 H ;.J.p. R COiRaJIeIIHIO, B CO-
BeTCKOH JIIITepaType TaKIIe ,ll,alIlIbIe ep,IIIIH'IIlbI. HanpHMep, IIpIIBe,ll,elIlIbIe
IIIf1PbI cpep,IIero B03paCTa norpe6elIIIbIX B acpalIaCbeBCKHX MOrlIJiblIHKaX
fOlKlIO cpaBIIIITb TOJIbKO CO Cpe,ll,IIIIM B03paCTOM 3axopOlIelIIIbIX B lIe nOJI-
IIOCThIO paCKOlialIlIOM BhIXBaTIIHCKOM MOrHJIblIHKe TplIIIOJIbCKOH KYJIbTypbI.
011 paBeH 20;5 rOJJ;a 36. npOHCTeKaeT 3TOT IIep,OCTaTOK CBep,eIIIIII 0 naJIeop,e-
1fOrpacpIIII p,peBlIero IIaCeJIelIHH CCCP II3-3a OTCYTCTBHH nOJIIIOCTbIO paCKO-
llalIlIhIX MOrIIJIbIIIIKOB, B KOTOpbIX 6hIJI 6hI c06pall BeCb naJIeOaIITpOnOJIOrH-
* 3AeCI. II AaJIee B cK061\ax yRasaHo 'IIICJIO Ha6mop,emrii.
117
J
qeCKHn MaTepHaJI, np1IrO,ll,IIbIH p:JIH naJIeop:eMorpacplIqeCKHX peKOIICTpYK IIiL
ECJIII IIOJIOiReHIIe lIe H3MelIIITCH II naJIeOalITpOIIOJIOrHqeCKIIll MaTepHaJi 6yp:eT
IIo-npemlIeMY c06IIpaTbCH 60JIee 1IJIH ;\f€IIee CJIyqalmo, TPYP:IIO OmII.D:aTb OT
nero KaKOH-JIII60 HOBOR IICTopII IeCKOII IIlIcpopMal(1UI. HCTOpIIH alITponoaorII-
qeCKIIX TIInOB CCCP B rrpIIIIl(IIIIIIaJIblIhIX qepTaX BblHBJIelIa npep:IIIeCTBYIO-
m;IIMII IICCJIep:OBaIIIIHM1I. HaKOnJIelIlie IIOBbIX lIfaTepIIaJIOB IIa npeiHlIeM ypOB-
He MOi:IWT JIIImb qTO-TO p:06aBHTb K yme H3BeCTIIOH KapTHlIe. MeiR,ll,Y TeM
nJIalIOMeplIhlii: c60p naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKHX p:alIlIhIX B nOJIIIOM BIIp:e II 06-
pa60TKa HX nop: pa3IIbIMII yrJIaMH 3peIIIIH n03BOJIHT YBH3aTb pe3YJIbTaTbI HX
1I3yqelIIIH C apXeOJIOrIIqeCKH BOCCTalIaBJIIIBaeMbIlIfH YCJIOBIIHMII mII3IIH p:peB-
Hero rraCeJIelIHH, ypOBlIeM X03HllCTBa, COl(IIaJIbIIOII C'rpYKTypoit 06m;eCTBa, T. e.
co BceMH TellfII np06JIeMaMII, IICCJIe,ll,OBaIIIIe KOTOpbIX TaK yrJIy6mleT IICTOPII-
qeCKYIO KapTIIIIY.
MTaK, alITpOnOJIOrIIH nepeIIIJIa CellqaC IIa nonymIl(1IOlIlIbrn ypOBelIb IIC-
CJIep:OBaIIIUI. TIonymI IIolIlIhIII nop:xop: R II3Y'leIIHIO COBpeMelIlIoro HaCeJIelIHH
n03BOJIIIJI IIaMeTIITb KOIITyphI IIOBbIX TeM, B npep:eJIax KOTOpbIX alITpOnOJIOr
lIfOiReT npIIllTII IIa rrOMOm;b HCTOPIIKY H 3THorpacpy, IIanpHMep B Ol(elIKe pOJII!
H30JIH 1III B cpOpMIIpoBalIlIH Tex IIJIII 1IIIbIX 8TIIIIqeCKIIX 06m;IIocTeii. Ho p:mI
Toro qT06bI nepelIeCTII norryJIHl(HOlIlIhIH nop:xo,ll, IIa H3yqelIIIe p:peBlIero IIace-
JIeIIIIH, aIITpOnOJIOr, B CBOIO Oqepep:b, IIYiRp:aeTCH B nOllfOm;II apxeOJIora. nOJI-
Hoe IICCJIep:OBaIIHe ppeBIIIIX MOrIIJIblIHKOB B rrpOl(eCce paCKonOK H Tm;aTeJIb-
HhIH c60p Bcex 6e3 IICKJIIOqelIHH KOCTlIhIX OCTaTKOB II3 rrorpe6elIHH 6hIJIH 6h1
xopomIIM OTBeTOM IIa npII3hIB 0 TaKoH nOMOm;H.
BbIBO]J;bI
1. nop: TepMIIlIoM «IIcTOpHqeCKaH aIITpOnOJIOrIIH>} aBTOp nOIIIIMaeT BCIO COBO-
KynlIocTh alITponOJIOr1PIeCKIIX 3IIaIIIIii:, II3 KOTOphIX MOiRlIO II3BJIe Ib HCTOPH-
IecKyIO IIlIcpopMal(HIO, Bile 3aBIICIIMOCTII OT Toro, K KaKOMY rrepIIOp:y IICTOplIIf
qeJIOBeqeCTBa 8Ta IIlIcpopMa 1UI OTIIOCIITCH.
2. Ha npOTHmeIIIUI rrOCJIep:IIIIX 20-30 JIeT alITporrOJIOrII BBeJIII B CBon
JICCJIep:OBaIIIIH nonYJIH IIOlIlIbIll cpaKTOp, qTO Kap,ll,IIlIaJIblIO H3MelIIIJIO II IIIeTO-
P:1IKY II MeTop:OJIOrIIIO aIITpOrrOJIOrH IeCKoj:I IIaYK1I. 3IIa IelIlie nonYJIH 1IOUrroro
ypOBIIH B aHTporrOnOrIIqeCKIIX HCCJIep:OBaIIIIHX oc06eHII0 nop:qepKIIBaeTCH TeM
06CTOHTeJIbCTBOM, ITO C pa3BIITIIeM relIeTIIKH OKa3aJIOCb B03MOiI IIhIM BhIHBIITb
Y IeJIOBeKa npII3IIaIUI C MOlIocpaKTOpIIaJIblIbIM IICCJIep:OBaIIIIeM, T. e. p:eTepMII-
IIIIpOBalIlIhIe B CBoeH lIaCJIep:CTBeIIIIOII rrepe)J;aqe O)],IIIIM IIJIII p:BYMH rerraMII.
OIIII rrop:Bepi:IWlIbI BIIYTp1fIIonynHl(1IOHlIhIM 3cpcpeKTaM, no pe3YJIbTaTallf KOTO-
pbIX MomlIO CYJJ:IITb 0 KOIIKp€'rIIOH IICTOpHII nonYJIH HII II COCTaBJIelIlIbIX II3
IIHX 3TIIIIqeCKIJX rpynn, 0 BpeMeIIII cpOpMIIpOBaIIHH, 3Tanax p:IIcpcpepelIl(Ua-
l(HII, relIeTIIqeCKIIX KOIITaKTax C p:pyrIIMH rpynna m II T. p:.
3. qeJIOBe IecKIIe rronynHl(IIII OTp:eJIelIhI op:IIa OT )J;pyroii: relIeTIIqeCKIIMIf
6apbepaMII. TIomITIIe relIeTII IeCRoro 6apbepa HMeeT B qeaOBeqeCKOM oOIl1;e-
CTBe OC06hIll CMhICJI, TaK KaK B Ka IeCTBe TaKOBhIX, nOMHMO reorpacpIIqeCKIIX
py6emen (peKII, rOpHhIe xpe6TbI, pa3IIhIe JIalIp:macpTHbIe 30IIhI), BhlcTyrraIOT
COl(HaJIblIhIe cpaKTophl: 8TIIH IeCKHii:, H3hIKOBOH, 8TIIOKYJIbTYPlIhIH, peJIIIrII03-
IIhIH, COl(IIaJIbII0-8KOJJOMU IecKIIll H p:p. C ,ll,pyroH CTOpOlIbI, 6HOJIorII IeCKHe
cpaKTopbI TepflIOT y qeJIOBeKa 3IIa IeIIIIe relIeTII IeCKIIX 6apbepoB, TaK JmK
pe'Ib IIp:eT 0 ep:1IIIOM nalIoHI{yMelIlIoM BII)J;e, BIIYTPII KOToporo IIeT 6IIOJIOrH Ie-
CKHX npenHTcTBIIII K Chpem;IIBaIIIIIO (OTCYTcTBue II36IIpaTeJIblIOCTII B MeiRpa-
COBhIX 6paKax) . TaKIIM 06pa30M, nonyJIHl(HH OTJIllqaIOTCH op:IIa OT p:pyrolr
rpaHII aMII, CTaBHm;HlIfII npemITcTBHH R pacnpOCTpalIelIIIIO Tex lInH IIHbIX
relIOB. BIIYTPII nonYJIHl(IIII cB060,ll,IIoe CKpem;IIBaIIIIe M€)HP:Y ee qJIelIaMII paB-
118
HOBepOHTIIO BO BCeX IIanpaBJIeIIHHX. B 3aBllCllMOCTII OT IIeO)]:lllIaKOBOH IllITe 11-
HBIIOCTII ,ll,eHCTBHH pa3IIh1X relIeTHqeCKHX oapbepOB cym;ecTByeT lIepapXllH.
norryJIH Hll (MHKporronYJIHl(llH, cy6norrYJIHl(llH, 60JIbIDHe nonYJIHl(IIH, )]:eMh1,
pa3IIbIe 3TIIIlqeCKlIe II p,pyrIIe COl(llaJIblIbIe 06IDIIOCTll). Pa3JIlI IHH MeiRp,y 8'ra-
maMII ;WOll lIepapXllH IIeOp,HlIaKOBbI IIa pa3HbIX TeppllTopllHX Ii, KpOMe Toro,
EbIpamelIbI lIe OqelIb OTqeTJIHBO, OTpa}RaH IIea6COJIIOTIIbIH xapaKTep relIeTH-
'1.JeCKllX 6apbepOB KaR )J;llcpcpepelI:qHpYIOIl1;IIX rpaIIII .
4. AIITpOnOJIOI'IIqeCKOe II3Y'leIIIIe COBpeMelIlIoro IIaCeJIelIHH alITporrOJIOr
ocym;eCTBJIHeT caM H nOTOMY opralIII3yeT ero B COOTBeTCTBIIII C IIOrryJIH IfOH-
HbIMII npIIIIQImaMII. TaK KaK nonYJIHl(IfII npe)J;CTaBJIHIOT C060ll IIII3mllII ypo-
BellI, paCOBOH KJIaCCIIcpllRa IIH qeJIOBeqeCTBa, TO II alITponOJIOrH 1eCKoe IICCJIe-
,ll,OBaIIIIe JII060n TeppllTopHH onHpaeTCH HMelIlIO IIa IIHX. 3aTeM B I{a IeCTBe
CJIep,YIOm;HX cTynelIeH paCOBOH KJIaCCllcpIIKal(IIH BbI)J;eJIHIOTCH aIITponOJIOrH Ie-
CKHe TIInbI HJIII rpynllbI nonymIl(IIH, rpyrrIIbI alITpOIIOJIOrllqeCKIIX THnOB, lIfa-
JIbIe II 60JIbIDIIe paCbI. Bce OIlll HBJIHIOTCH BbIpaiRelIllel\I pa3IIOH llIITeHCIIBHO-
TH CMemeIIIIH relIOB BIIYTPH pa3JIllqlIh1X TeppHTOpHaJIblIbIX rpynn II nOTOMY
1\fOrYT 6bITb HcrrOJIb30BalIbI p,JIH BOCCTalIOBJIelIllH IICTopnn 8TIIHqeCKHX o6m;IIo-
CTell, BXOp:Hm;HX B COCTaB 8TIIX rpynII.
5. B alITpOnOJIorIIqeCKOM II3yqelIHII p,peBlIero IIaCeJIelIHH alITpOnOJIOr 3a-
BllCllT OT apxeOJIora, npep,OCTaBJIHIOm;erO eMY aIITpOnOJIOI'IIqeCKllll MaTepHaJI.
TIoCJIep,IIHll qam;e Bcero co6lIpaeTcH CJIyqalllIO B npOl(ecce apXeOJIOrII'leCRIIX
paCKonOR H nOTOMY IIenpIIrOp,eII p,JIH nOIIYJIH IfOIIIIOH peKolIcTpYK IIH (IIOP,
HeH CJIep,yeT nOIIIIMaTh BOCCTalIOBJIelIHe He TOJIbKO alITpOIIOJIorIIqeCKHX OCO-
6elIIIOCTen p,aIIIIOH nonymJl(IIll, 110 H ee p,eMorpacpHqeCKOll CTPYKTYph1: yp,eJIh-
Horo Beca pa3IIh1X nOKOJIeIIHH, npop,ommrreJIblIOCTH mll3IIH, ypOBIIH ,ll,eTCKOll
CMepTIIOCTll, cpepTIfJIblIOCTH H T. p,.). He06xop,IIMa nOJIlIaH paCROIIRa ApeBIIIIX
RJIa.:r6Hm; CO COOpOM Bcero IIaJIeOalITpono.TIOrHqeCKOrO MaTepllaJla, BKJIIO IaH
KeJIeThI p,€'reH H MJIa.D:elIl(eB. OTp,eJIblIhIe onbITbI TaKHX paCKonOR II COOTBeT-
C:rBYIOm;ell alITpOnOJIOrllqeCROll 06pa60TKH naJIeOalITponOJIorHQeCKlIX MaTC-
pllaJIOB H3 IIllX YiRe p,aJIlI xopomIIe pe3YJIbTaTbI (IICCJIeP,OBalIllH aIITpOnO,'IO-
rOB BelIrpHH, repMalICROH .D:eMoKpaTIlqeCROll Pecny6JIIIKlI H p,pyrIIx CTpalI).
TIOJIIIOCTbIO paCRonalIlIbIe lIfOrIIJIblIHKH p,peBlIero IIaCeJIelIIIH IIa TepplrropllII
CCCP, npll KOTOph1X 6hIJI 6bI c06pall BeCb aHTpOnOJIOrllqeCKlIll MaTepHaJI,
rrORa ep,IIlIIIQlIbI, ITO C03p,aeT 3IIaqIITeJIblIhIe Tpyp,IIOCTH B IICIIOJIb30BalIIIII pe-
3YJJhTaTOB II3yqelIIIH naJIeOalITponOJIOrIIII CCCP ,ll,JIH HCTOpHqeCKllX peKOH-
mpYKl(lIll.
I TO.aCTOB C. n. I1pOOJIeMbI P;Op0,I10BOrO OOll\eCTBa /1 COB. ;JTHOrpacPHH. 1931. oM 3/4.
2 0630p IICCJIep;OBaHHll CJ\L: HnlulOB B. ,no ABCTpaJIOIIIITeKoBble (Australopithecinae) 1/
HCKonaeMble I'OMIIHH,1bI H rrpoIIcxoilqeHHe '1eJIOBeKa. M., 1966. (Tp. I1H-Ta 3THO-
rpacPHII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 9 ).
3 r.wf}';'OBU T. J{. OCOOeHIIOCTII p;ep!IIaTOrJIHcPHKII HeKOTopbIX Hapop;HOCTeii CCCP /1
COB. aHTpOrrOJIOI'IIH. 1957. .1\-;' 1.
I, lKupoe H. C/J. ATJIaHTIIp;a. OCHoBHble rrpOOJIeJ\IbI aTJIaHTOJIOrHII. M., HJ64.
'i Schwidetzky I. Die vorspanische Bevolkerung der Kanarischen Inseln. Anthropolo-
gische Untersuchungen. Gottingen; B.; Frankfurt a. M., 1963.
6 P02unc,;,uu H. H. 0 rrepBOHa'laJIbHOM 3aCeJIeHHH I10':IIIHe3HII /1 COB. 3THorpacPlIH. 1966.
oM 5; On :!ICe. 0 rrpOIICX01Kp;eHIIII rrOJlIIHe3IIiil\eB if I1poo.:reMbI aHTporrO!IOrIIII II IICTO-
plI'IeCKOII 3THorpacPIIH A3IIII. M., 1968.
7 Riesenjeld A. Shovel - shaped incisors and a IpW other dental featres among the
native peoples of the Pacific 1/ ArneI'. J. Phys. Anthropol. N. S., 1956. Vol. 14, N 3.
11 CBOP;KY p;aT 01.: IfBa1ioea /1. f{. reOJIOBI'IeCKIIii BoapacT IICKOrraeJ\IOro 'IeJIOBelm.
M., 1965.
9 CJ\I., Harrp.: I1cTopHH rrepBOOblTHOrO OOll\eCTBa. OOll\IIe BOrrpOCbI. I1pOOJIeJ\ILI aHTpo-
rrOCOl\IIOreHe3a. M., 1983; lIcTopnH rrepBoobITHoro 06ll\eCTBa. 3rroxa rrepBOOblTHOH
pOP;OBOll 06ll\HHbI. M., 1986.
119
I
I
i1
,I
10 POZU1iCKUii E. E., JJeBU1i M. r. OCHOBbI aHTpOrrOJIOrlIlI. M., 1955.
11 CeMeHoB C. A. CJIe):1bI paooTbI Ha 0pY;rJ,FlHX II ):10Ka3aTe:rbCTBa paooTbI HeaHp;epTaJIbl\eB
rrpaBOll: PYKOH II KpaT. co061l\. HH-Ta apxeOJIonm. AH CCCP. 1961. BbIrr. 84.
12 01i :!ICe. 0 rrpoTFlBorrOCTaBJIemm 60JIbmOrO rraJIbl\a PYKII HeaHp;epTa.JIbCKOrO '1eJIO-
BeKa II TaM iRe. 1950. BbIlI. H.
12 Vallois H. La duree de la vie chez l'Homme fossile II Anthropologie (France). 1937.
T. 47, N 5/6.
1& Poccer 3. ITpOIWCC cTapeHIIH HaCeJIemIH. M., 1968.
15 AJI,eKCeee B. n. 0 rrepBII'IHOH p;lIcPcPepeHl\Flal\IIFI '1eJIOBe'leCTBa Ha pacI.!. lIepBII'IHbIe
O'larll pacooopa30BamIH II COB. 3THorpacPHH. 1969. M 1; 01i :!ICe. 0 rrepBII'IHOII P; lI cP-
cP e peHl\lIal\1I1I '1eJIOBe'leCTBa Ha paCbI. BTOpll'llThIe o'iarIl pacooopa30BaHHH II TaM
1Ke. 1969. oM 5.
16 J{e6e,,? r. (/J., JJeBuH M. r., TpoiflUMoBa T. A. AHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCKIIll: MaTepFlaJI aK IIC-
TO'lHIIK Fl3yqeHIIH BorrpOCOB 3THoreHe3a I I TaM 1Ke. 1952. oM 1.
17 TYM.3H J{. BorrpocbI 3THoreHe3a MOHrOJIOB B CBeTe ):1aHHblx lIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrnFl:
ABTOpecP. ;a;FlC. n. KaH):1. IICT. HaYK. M., 1985.
18 rOXMaH 11. 11. Cpe):1Hea3HaTCKaH KOJIOHIIH B IIpFl6aHKaJIbe IllIpooJIeMbI aHTpOrrOJIO-
rHFI If IICTOpll'leCKOII 3THorpacPIIII A3I1I1. M., 1968; AJI,eKCeeB B. n. "tJeperra 113 My-
CYJIbMaHCKFlX rrorpeoeIIIIII B Tyne Ii ¥'1eH. 3arr. TYBIIH. Hayq.-IICCJIep;. IIH-Ta H3bIK3.
JIFlT., IICTOpFlFl. 1960. BbIII. 8.
13 Yen Yin. Neolitic human skeletons unearthed at Hua-Hsien, Shensi/lVertebr. pale-
asiat. 1962. N 2.
2J A. eKceeB B. n. AHTpOrrOJIOrll'leCKlIe ):1aHHbIe R rrp06JIeMe rrpOIlCX01K):1eHIIH HaCeJIe-
HIIH l\eHTpaJIbHbIX rrpe;a;roplIiJ KaBKa3cKoro xpeoTa II AHTpOrrOJIOrlI'leCKlIH COOPHIIK.
IV. M., 1963. (Tp. HH-Ta 3THOrpacPFlII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 82).
21 BpoMJI,eii /0. B. 3moc II 3Hp;oraMFlHiICoB. 3THOrpacPlIH. 1969. oM 6.
22 B Y1iaK B. B. 113Y'leHHe MaJIbIX rrorrYJIHl\III1 B aHTpOrrOJIOrlI1I II BOlip. aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH.
M., 1965. BbIII. 21.
23 rUH36ypz B. B. rOpHble Ta):11KIIKFI. MaTeplIaJIbI rro aHTpOrrOJIOrlIII Tap;1KIIKOB Kapa-
TerFlHa II ,lJ,apBa3a. M.; JI., 1937; 01i :!ICe. I130reMOarrJIIOTFlHal\IIH Y ropHbIX Ta):11KII-
KOB II AHTPOrrOJI. 1KYPH. 1934. oM 1/2.
2 PWiKOB /0. r. AHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKoe IICCJIep;OBaHlIe rrpOl\eCca I130JIHl\HH Ha lIaMlIpe
II E\aBKa3e II Tp. VII. Me1Kp;YHap. KOHrp. aHTpOrrOJI. II 3THorp. HaYR. M., 1968. T. 1.
2' TIepBaH Fl3 TaKlIX paOOT, CTaBIIIaH B rrOJIHOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa KJIaCCII'IeCRoII: Glass B.,
Saeks M., Jahn E., Hess Ch. Genetic Drift in a Religious Isolate: an Analysis of
tlw Causes of Variation in Blood group and other Gene Frequencies in a Small
Population II Yearbook of physical anthropology, 1952. N. Y., 1954. Vol. 8.
26 Schwidetzky I. Grundziige del' Volkerbiologie. Stuttgart, 1950.
27 AJI,enceeea T. H. 3THoreHe3 BOCTO'lHbIX CJIaBHH IIO ):1aHHbIM aHTpOIIOJIOrnll. M., 1973.
28 MaKCliMeHKoB r. A. BrrycKHbIe MOrFlJIbI oKYHeBcKoro 3Talia B acPaHacbencKFlx KYP-
raHax II COB. apXeOJIOrFlH. 1965. oM 4; IlBa1ioea JJ. A. 0 IIpOHCX01Kp;eHIIII 6paxlIKpaH-
HOro KmmOHeHTa B COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIIH acPaHacbeBCKOll: KYJIbTYPbI II COB. 3THorpa-
cPIIH. 1966. .1\1 3.
29 A,'leKceee B. n. 1I03;rJ,HFle KO'leBHIIKII KY3Hel\KOll: KOTJIOBIIHbI IIO ;rJ,aHHbIJ\1 rraJIeOaHTpo-
1I0JIonm II KpaT. co061l\. HH-Ta 3THorpacPIIFI AH CCCP. 1960. BbIII. 35.
3" BepoMlliee r. J{. 3KOJIOrO-reHeTII'IeCKHe cPaKToPbI cTapeHFlH II ;rJ,OJIrOJIeTIIe. JI., 1968.
31 IIHTepecHlI B 3TOll: CBH311 rFllIOTe3a M. II. rpH3HOBa 00 OCOObIX p;eTCKIIX KJIan;UII£l\aX
Y p;peBHero Hace:reHFlH CIIOlIpII. C I.: rpR31iOB M. n. UCTOpIIH ):1peBIflIX llJIeJ\IeH OOlf
IIO paCKOIIKa)1 UJIII3 C. BOJIbmaH Pe'lKa II MaTeplIaJIbI II nCCJIC):10BaHIIH IIO apxeOJIO-
rHFI CCCP. lVI., 1956. T. 48.
n Ivanisek F. Staroslavenska necropola u Ptuju. Ljublana, 1951; Kastelie J., Skerlj B.
Slavanska necl'Opola na Bledu. Ljublana, 19:50.
3" Nemeskeri I., Acsadi Gy. Torteneti demografiai vizsgalatok a Kerpusztai XI cz-i
temeto anyagaboi II Archaeol. Ertes. 1952. N 2; Idem. PalaodemograIische Probleme
am Beispiel des friihmittelalterlischen Graberfeldes von Halinba-Cseres Rom. Yesz-
prem (Ungarn) II Homo. 1957. Bd. 8, N 3; Die spatmittelalterlische Bevolkerung
von Fony6d II Anthropol. nung. 1963. Vol. 6, N 1/2.
Ii Schott L. Zllr Palaodemographie del' hochmittelalterlischen Siedlung von Reckahn.
(OTl'!;eJIbHbIII OTTIICK, 6/1'.)
35 Shloukal :fl. Heidnische Elemente im Leben IeI' Bevolkerung des groJ3mahrischen
Mikuli'ice auf Grund del' Befunde an Begrabnisstatten II Homo. 1962. Bd. 13, N 3.
Sf Be. UKaHOBa M. C. AHTpOIIOJIOrlI'leCKHH MaTepIIaJI BbIXBaTIIHCKoro )lOrn:rbHIIKa II
MaTepIIaJIbI II IICCJIep;OBaHIIH rro apxeOJIorlI1I CCCP. lVI., 1961. T. 84.
I
I
f20
MCTOPMQECRAH AHTPOrrO OrMH:
IIPOB EMbI M IIEPCIIERTMBbI
MECTO nCTOpnqECROn AHTPOrrOJIOrnn
B CnCTEME AHTPOrrOJIOnnr
AIITpOnOJIOrIUI B xo)),e pa3BIITHH .fleO)),HOKpaTHO «MeHHJIa CBoe JIH:qO»: OHa TO
BbICTynaJIa qHCTO MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKOn )),IICl(IInJIIIHOH, 6JIII3KOH K aHaTOMHH,
II noaTOMY, eCTeCTBeIIIIO, OrpalIIIqIIBaJIa Kpyr IICCJIe)),OBaIIHH TpaKTOBKOH JIIIllib
OIIOJIOrHqeCKHX oc06eUIIOCTeH qeJIOBeKa; TO B BII)J;e cpIIJIOCOcpCIWH aIITpOnOJIO-
rHIf BXO)),IfJIa B qlICJIO ryMaHIITaplIhIX .D:lIc:qHnJIIIH, HaqIIlIaH paCCMaTpIIBaTb
cpIfJIOCOiPCKYIO cym;IIOCTb qeJIOBeKa II HrlIopIIpYH ero 6IIOJIOI'IIqeCKlIe CBOHCT-
Ba. B 060HX CJIY'IaHX 3TO 6bIJI OTXO)), OT Tpa.D:IIJJ;IIolIlIoro 06JIIIKa HaYKII. Ee
TJIaBlIbIe 3a)J;aqII B CBoe BpeMH CcpOpMyJIHpOBaJiII OCIIOBaTeJIII IIayqlIOH alITpo-
IIOJIOrHII H.-CD. BJIIOMeII6ax, K. M. Bap, n. BpoKa, IT. TonHHap H )),p.:
iJTO - II3yqelIIIe npOIICXOiR)J;eIIIIH qeJIOBeKa II eCTecTBeHlIoIICTOpHqeCKOH )),1I-
IIaMIIRII qeJIOBeqeCTBa. B COOTBeTCTBIIII C TaRIfM ee nOIIIIMalIIIeM aIITpOnOJIO-
TIIH CTaJia OC03IIaBaTbCH KaK 6HOJIOrIIqeCKaH IIaYRa (CTOHm;aH B O)),IIOM PH.D:Y
C 300JIOrlIeH II 60TaIIIIKoH), OCIIOmIaH oc06elIIIocTb KOTOpOH 3aK,'IIOqaeTCH B
TOM, qTO B CBOIIX KOIIKpeTlIbIX IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIfHX olla llinpOKO HCnOJIb3yeT nc-
TOpIIKO-3TIIOJIOrIPIeCKIIe H apXeOJIOrHqeCKIIe JJ;aIIHbIe. M nOlIbIHe B CTpalIax.
l')J;e pacnpOCTpalIelI alIJ'.TmHCKIIH H3bIK, B OT,,'IHqlIe OT 06m;eeBponeHCKon Tpa-
;J:1I IIII alITpOnOJIOrIIIO 06"be)),IIIIHIOT (BMeCTe C 3TIIOJIOI'lIeH II apXeOJIOrIIeH)
B «aIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKYIO TpIIa)),y» II no)),qepKIlYTO Ha3hIBaIOT cpII3IIqeCKOn alIT-
pOnOJIOrlIeH.
HCTOpIIqeCKIIH acneKT alITponOJIOrlIqeCKllX HCCJIe)),OBaIIIIH Tpa)),II IIOlIelI
.;J:JIH PYCCROH IIaYKII. 06m;eIf3BeCTelI, IIanpIIMep, BbI)),aIOm;IIHCH BKJIa)), KapJIa
MaKCIfMOBIIqa B3pa B pa3IIhIe pa3.D:e.TJ:hI 61I0JIOrIIII; cpe)),II npoqero 011 CTaJI
nlIOlIepOM aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX IIcc.TJe)),OBaIIIIH B POCCHIf, opralI1I30BaB lliIIpO-
hHH c60p KpalIIIOJIOrlIqeCRIIX MaTepIIa.rrOB no IIapo)),aM POCCIIII H caMOCTOH-
TeJIbHO npOBe)),H II3yqeHHe naJIeOalITpOIIOJIOrlIqeCKIIX KOJIJIeK IIH 1I3 paCKonOR
CRHcpCKIIX II )),pyrnx KypralIoB IOra HallieH CTpalIbI. Pe3YJIbTaThI aIITpOnOJIO-
rlIqeCKIIX H3Mepe1I1IH, BO MlIorOM YCOBepllielICTBOBalIlIbIX K. B3pOM, conOCTaB-
HJIIICb IIM C IICTOpIIqeCRHMII CBe)),eIIIIHMII 0 )),peBIIHX IIapo)),ax II apXeOJIOrlI-
qeCKIIMII IIa6JIIO,ZJ;eIIIIHMII. AlIaTOMHqeCKHH Ka6IIIIeT POCCIIHCKOH AKa)),eMIfH
HaYK, KOTOpbIH K. M. B3p B03raaBnJI, CTaB aKa)),eMIIKOM, 6bIJI nepelIMelIOBalI
lIO ero 1I1I1I IIaTIIBe B AIITpOnOJIOI'IIqeCI{HH Ka61I1IeT. n03iRe ero KOJI.TJ:eK IIII
COCTaBIIJIII OCIIOBY aIITpOnOJIOI'IIqeCKOro c06palIlIH MY3eH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH II
iJTIIOrpacplIH AH CCCP B JIelIlIlupa)),e.
HIITelICHBlIoe pa3BIITHe B nOCJIe)J;IIIIe TplI )),eCHTHJIeTIIH nonYJIH IIOIIHOH
tP1I31I0JIOrlIlI, H3Y'IelIlIe a.D:anTIIBHbIX npo eCCOB B qe.TJ:OBeqeCKHX nonYJIH:qIIHX
npIIBeJIII K BhI)J,eJIeHIIIO B KaqeCTBe caMOCTOHTeJIblIOH 06JIaCTII 3IIalIlIH CPH-
3IlOJIOrHqeCKOH aHTpOnOJIOrlIII I1JIII 6HOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa. B HalliH ,ZJ;IIII Ha MIIO-
THX MeJ-K.D;yuapO)),IIbIX H OTeqeCTBeUlIhIX CIfMn03lIYMax rOpHqo )),e6aTIIpyeTcH
Bonpoc 06 OTlIomeHlI1I aTOll IIOBOH 06JIaCTII 3IIaHlIH K )),pyrHM TpaJJ;If HOlIlIhIM
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIM MeTO)J;aM H no)),xo)),aM (KJIaCClIqeCKOH aHTpOnOJIOrHII).
If XOTH )),0 CIIX nop np06JIeMY IIeJIb3H CqlITaTb OKOlIqaTeJIblIO pemelIlIOH, IIa)),o
Y'fIfTbIBaTh TOT cpaKT, qTO 1I3Y'lelIlIe CPlI31I0JIOrlIqeCKllX II IfMMyIIOJIOrlIqeCKHX
oc06eHHOCTeH BIIYTpelIlIeH cpe)),hI opralIIf3Ma (IIanpIIMep, rpynn KpOBII If ChI-
BOPOTOqlIhlX KOMnOlIeIITOB) IIaCqIfThIBaeT YiRe IIeCKOJIbKO )),eCHTIfJIeTIIH; II TO
iKe MomlIO CKa3aTb 06 HCCJIe)),OBaIIlIH a)),anTIIBlIoH CPYIIK 1I1I paCOBbIX npII-
3IIaKOB qeJIOBeKa. IT03TOMY HeT IIH TeOpeTnqeCKIIX, IIH npaKTHqeCKIIX OCIIO-
121
.-
£aIIIIH IIpOTIIBOnOCTaBJIHTb 6IIOJIOrIIIO qe.:'IOBeKa aIITpOnOJIOI'IflI. Bce TO, qTO
IIblIIe nOlIlIMaeTCH KaK 6II0JIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa, npe,IJ,CTaBJIHeT c060n 3aKOIIOMep-
HbIH pe3yJIbTaT BHYTpelIlIero pa3BlITlfH IIMelIlIO aIITpOIIOJIorII'IeCKOH IIayRII,
aHTpOIIOJIOrlIIO CerO,IJ,IIHilIHerO ,IJ,HH, 060ram;e1I1IYIO nonymm;IIoHlIbIMII II cpII3IIO-
JIOrlIqeCKIIMII MeTop;aMII, IIaChlm;eHHyIO 3BOJIIOI{1I01IIIbIMII KOII en IIHMII, y,IJ,e-
JIHIOm;yIO orpOMlIoe BHIIMalIlIe IICCJIep;OBaIIHIO np06JIeM COOTUOlIIelIIIH 61I0JIO-
rlIqeCRIIX II CO IIaJIblIbIX cpaKTopOB B cpOp:\<flIpOBaIIIflI IICKonaeMhIX npe,IJ,KOB.
qeJIOBeKa, a TaKiRe COBpeMelIlIoro BIIp;a Homo sapiens II qeJIOBeqeCKIIX pac.
TaK KaK 3TII BbIKJIa,IJ,KII MorYT BCTpeTIITb B03pame1IIIH, CTOIIT 3aMeTIITb
qTO IIX neJIb3H CqlITaTb IIOBbIMII. <D. 8IIreJIbC, KacaHCb cO;:J:epmalIlIH aHTpo-
nOJIOrlI1I II ee MeCTa B CIICTeMe HaYK, nlICaJI B npep;IICJIOBIIII K nepBoMy II3-
,IJ,aHIIIO KIIIII'II «npOIICXOiR,IJ,eIIIIe ceMblI, qaCTIIOH c06cTBeHIIocTII II rocyp;apcT-
Ba)}, qTO B IIOIIHTlIe (<IIpOII3BOp;IITeJIblIhIe CIIJIbI 06m;eCTBa)} BXO,IJ,HT lIe TOJIbKO
0PYP;IIH npoII3Bop;cTBa, 110 II caM qeJIOBeK, ero BocnpOII3BO.Il;CTBO, npop;OJIiRe-
nIle qeJIOBe'IeCKOrO pO.Il;a 1. AHTpOnOJIOrIIH KaK pa3 II IIpeJJ;CTaBJIHeT C060H
IIayKy 0 qe.:'IOBeKe KaR 0 qaCTII npOII3BO.Il;HTe.:'IblIbIX CIIJI 06m;eCTBa. II03TOMY
lIe TOJIbKO MopcpOJIOrlIqeCmf€ oc06elIIIocTlI OT.II;eJIblIbIX qeJIOBeqeCKIIX rpynn II
HII.II;IIBII.D;yyMOB, OlIpe.Il;emlIOm;lIe IIX cpII3IIqecKYIO .Il;eecnoC061I0CTb (TO, qTO B
alITpOnOJIOrlIII Tpap;II IIOIIIIO IIa3h1BaeTCH cpII3lIqeCKlIM pa3BIITIIeM qeJIOBeKa).
HO II IIX CPII3IIOJIOrlIqeCRlIe CBOMCTBa, o6IIapymlIBaIOm;IIe rpynnOBYIO ,IJ,lIcpcpe-
pelIl(lIaI{IIIO II reorpacpHqeCKYIO II3MeHqIIBOCTb, nonYJIHI{IIOlIlIaH CTpyKTypa
qeJIOBeqeCKOrO BIIp;a, .Il;eMOrpacplIqeCKaH WlHaMIIKa qeJIOBeqeCKllX nOIIyJIH-
IWM - Bce 3TO cpYlI.II;aMelITaJIblIhIe np06JIeMbI COBpeMelIHOH aHTpOIIOJIOI'Hqe-
CROM HaYKII, pa3pa6aTbIBaeMbIe KaK 3a py6emoM, TaK II B IIalIIeM CTpalIe.
B CIICTeMe AKaJJ:eMlflI IIayK CCCP 3TII np06JIeMbI pa3pa6aTbIBaIOTCH B OT.II;e-
JIe alITpOIIOJIOrlI1I MIICTIITYTa 3TIIorpacplIII AH CCCP H B alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX
JIa60paToplIHX IIeKOTOpbIX pecny6JIIIKalICKllX aKap;eMIIH IIayK.
Onpe.Il;eJIIfB on'heM II CO.Il;epiRaHIIe alITpOnOJIorIIII KaR IIeKOeH CIICTeMhI
IIaYK, paCCMOTpIIM, KaKoe nOJIOmelIlIe B HeH 3alIIIMaeT IICTOpIIqeCKaH alITpo-
nOJIOrIIH. TepM1I1I «IICTOpHqeCKaH aIITpOnOJIOrlIH» nOHBIIJICH IJ;OBOJIhlIO p;aBIIO:
011 BCTpeqaeTCH B alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOII JIIITepaType yiRe B nepBbIe .Il;eCHTIIJIe-
THH IIalIIerO BeKa. O.Il;HaKO B TeqelIlIe MHorIIX JIeT nO;:J: HCTOplIqeCROH alITpo-
nOJIOI'IreM nO,iIpa3YMeBaJIaCb JIlIlIIb KaKaH-TO 'IaCTb naJIeOaIITpOnOJIOrIIII, 3a-
HIIMaIOm;aHCH If3yqeHlIeM JIIO)J;eH, iRIIBIIIIIX B cpaBIIlITeJIbHO n03.I1;IIlIe neplIO.Il;hI
HCTOplIII - B 3noxy 6pOH3bI, palIlIero meJIe3a H Cpep;IIeBeKOBbH. MlIhIMII CJIO-
BaMII, IICTOpHqeCKaH alITpOnOJIOrIIH B COOTBeTCTBIIII C 3TlIM ee nOHIIMalIIIeM
OXBaTbIBaJIa JIIIlIIb neplIO.Il;bI IICTOpIIII, npe.Il;CTaBJIelIlIbIe nlICbMelIHbIMII naMHT-
HIIKaMlf. Ho Be.Il;b naJIeOalITponOJIOrIIqeCKOe IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIe JIIO.II;eii:, mIIBIIIIIX
CKameM, B IIepHO.Il; palIlIero IIeOJIIITa, HII IIO MeTO)J;IIKe, IIII no cym;ecTBy CBoe-
lIfY lIe OTJIII'IaeTCH OT H3yqelIlIH KOCTlIbIX OCTaTKOB JIIO.II;eH 60JIee 6JIlI3KlIX R
HaM 3nox. n03TOMY OrpalIlIqelIIIe IICTopIIRo-aIITpOIIO.:'IOrlIqeCKOrO IICCJIe.Il;OBa-
HIIH JIIIlIIb paMKaMII (<IIIICbMelIlIbIX 3noX» II TeOpeTII'IeCKIf If npaKTlf"<IeCRII
HeOIIpaBp;aHIIO.
MomHo 6bIJIO 6bI II.II;eIITlIcplI:qIIpOBaTb IICTOplIqeCKYIO alITpOnO.:'IOrlfIO C
naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrlIe:ii: (1I3Y'IelIlIeM .Il;peBHero IIaCeJIelIlIH 3eMJIII) II npOTHBO-
nOCTaBHTb ee IfCCJIe,IJ,OBaIIIIIO COBpeMelIlIoro IIaCeJIeIIIIH, qTO B COBeTCKOII JIlI-
TepaType 0603IIaqaeTCH KaK 3TIIlIqeCKaH aIITpOIIOJIOrHH. Ho II 3TO 6YD;eT IIe-
BeplIO, II60 3TIIIIqeCKaH alITpOIIOJIOrHH BO MlIorOM IIOMoraeT peKOIICTpYIIPO-
BaTb nYTII 3TIIorelIe3a 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa, a B paMKII naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIIII HeB03-
MOiRlIO BKJIIOqlITb paCCMOTpelIlIe II OI{eIIKY OCTaTKOB IfCKonaeMbIX IIpe,IJ,KOB
'IeJIOBeKa, TaK KaK 3TH IICCJIep;OBaIIIIH Tpe6YIOT Cne lIaJIhlIOrO IIO.Il;XOp;a (B CO-
BeTCKOM alITpOnOJIOrlIqeCKOH JIHTepaType 3Ta 06JIaCTb 3HalIIIH 060CIIOBalIIIO
BbI)J;eJIHeTCH B OC06bIH pa3.I1;eJI - alITponorelIe3, IIJIII Y'IelIlIe 0 IIpOIICXOlli,IJ,e-
122
HIIII qeJIOBeKa). Ho TaK KaR npH HCCJIeJJ;OBaIIIIII OCTaTKOB HCKonaeMoro 'IeJIO-
BeKa If3BJIeKaeTCH elIlIaH IICTOpIIqeCI{aH IIIIcpopMaJJ;IIH, IIaJIeOalITporrOJIOrIfH
nOqTII eJIIIKOM BKJIIOqaeTCH B ccpepy IICTOpIIqeCKDH alITpOrrOJIorIIH (IfCKJIIO'Ie-
BIle COCTaBJIHeT JIIIllb naJIeOrraTOJIOI'IIH, II60 olla JIIIllb B IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbHhIX
cayqaHX JJ;aeT IICTO pIfqecRyIO IIlIcpopMa:qIIIO). nOJJ;qepKlIeM, O)J;HaKO, 'ITO HCTO-
pIfqeCKaH alITpOnOJIOrlIH no CBOIIM XpOIIOJIOrlIqeCKILVI paMKaM 3IIa'IIITeJIbII0
nmpe IIaJIeOaIITpono.'10rIIII, If60 OXBaTbIBaeT BCIO IfCTOplIIO 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa, Ha-
qlIHaH C 3nOXH nOHBJIelIHH nepBbIx rOMIIHIIJJ; II KOlIqaH cOBpeMelIIIbIM 'IeJIO-
BeqeCTBOM.
cDYHJ];AMEIIT AJIbHbIE I1POBJIEMbI
llCTOPHqECKOnAHTPOrrOJIOrHH
B cTaTbe, rrocBHm;eHlIoH )J;lIlIaMHKe nonYJIH IIOlIlIoii: CTpyRTYPbI qeJIOBeqeCT-
Ba, If B 06m;eM 0630pe HCTopIfKo-aIITpOnOJIOrHqeCIwii: IIaymI 2 aBTOp 3TIfX
CTpOK nbITaJICH onpeJJ;eJIHTb, KaEYIO IICTOplI IeCKyIO IflIcpopMal(HIO (If no Ra-
EIIM rrp06JIeMaM) MOnum 1I3BJIeqb H3 alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCIWrO 3IIaHIIH. ::ho pe-
KOIICTPyK IIH TpygOBOII, COJJ;IIaJIbHOH If ,iIYXOBIIOH iRII3IIlI IfCKonaeMhlX npeJJ;-
hOB qeJIOBeKa, IIaqaJIblIhIX :nanOB pa3BlITlIH H3bIKa, pemelIlIe BorrpOCOB, CBH-
3alIIIbIX C nepII0JJ;1I3a Heii: IICTOplI1I nepB06bITIIoro 06m;eCTBa, paCCMOTpelIlIe
pOJIII aBTOXTOlIlIoro pa3BHTHH II MIIrpa IIH B IICTOplI1I qeJIOBeqeCKOH RYJIbTY-
JihI II cpOpMlIpOBaH1I1I IIapO)J,OB, IfCCJIe.D:OBaIIIIe np06JIeM pO)J;CTBa JJ;peBIIIIX H
COBpeMelIlIhIX IIapO)J;OB, BhlHBJIeHlIe IICTOKOB paCOBbIX IIpeJJ;paCCYJJ;ROB B HCTO-
pHIf 06m;eCTBa II 60Pb6a C IIHMII. OJJ;IIaKO IIPH BceH cBoeii HCKJIIOqHTeJIblIoii
llCTOpHqeCKOH BamHOCTIf Bce 8TO - IIpHKJIa)J;HhIe IIp06JIeMbI, HBJIHIOm;HeCH,
CTporo rOBopH, pa3IIbIMII cpopMaMII nplIJIOmeIlIIH pe3YJIbTaTOB alITpOnOJIOrlIqe-
CEoro alIaJIlI3a K 3a)J;a IaM II eJIHM I1CTOplIqeCKOrO IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH. HapH)J;Y C
;JTIfM IICTOpIIqeCRaH aHTpOIIOJlOI'I1H IIMeeT II CBOH COOCTBelIlIhIe, OpralIHqeCRIf
TOJIbKO eii: npHcym;He IIp06JIeMbI, OT ycrrelllIoro pellelIlIH KOTOpbIX eJIIIKOM
3aBlIClIT IIporpecc B IICnOJIb30BaHIIlI alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOrO MaTeplIaJIa KaK HC-
roplIqeCKOrO HCTOqUHKa. nepen:JJ;eM K IIX paCCMOTpeHIIIO.
OL(IIa If3 BaiRlIelUIIIfX - np06.!leMa MopfjO.!102U'-leCKOU OUlWMUKU 'le.!loee'le-
crea. 113yqelIIfe naJIeOalITponOJIOrlIqeCKIIX MaTeplIaJIOB npOllJIhIX 3nox n03-
1!OJIHeT peKolIcTpYIIpOBaTb cplI3IIqeCKlIe oco6elIHocTII )J;peBIIIIx JIIOJJ:eH. OJJ;IIO
..IImb cYMMaplIoe cpaBHelIIIe 3TlIX oc06elIHocTeH B JJ;eJIOM no OHKYMelIe rr03-
BOJIHeT BhIHBIITb onpeD;eJlelIlIbIe TelIJJ;elI HII B JJ;lIlIaMIIKe cplI3lIqeCKOrO TlIna
cOBpeMelIlIbIx JIIOJJ:eH If IIX rrpeJJ;KoB. Em;e 60JIee 3cpcpeKTIIBII0 BhIHBJIelIlIe C
IIOMOm;bIO )J;HcpcpepelI IfpoBalIlIoro nOJJ;xo)J;a JIOKaJIblIOrO cBoe06pa3lIH cpIf3Hqe-
CKHX oc06elIlIocTeii: JIIOJJ;en: nYTeM cpaBlIelIlIH XpOHOJIOrlIqeCKII pa3IIOBpeMelI-
UbIX naJJeOaIITpOnOJIOI'IIqeCmIX cepIfii: IIaxoJJ;oK B rrpeJJ;eJIax KpynlIhlx reorpa-
qmqeCKHX paii:olIoB. Y CTalIaBJIIIBaH relIeTlIqecRyIO npeeMcTBelIlIocTb 3TIIX
pa3IIOBpeMelIIIhIx cepIIH IIa OCIIOBe BbIHBJIeIlIIH I1X crre HcpHqeCKOrO MOpcpOJJO-
IIIqeCKOrO CxoJJ;cTBa II IfCTOPIfKO-KYJIbTyplIbIX JJ;alIlIbIx, npe)J;ocTaBJIHeMbIX ap-
xeOJIoI'Iren:, MOiRlIO onpe)J;eJIIITb 8TanhI MOPCPOJIOrHqeCKOii JJ;HlIaMHKII rpynII
o. 1O)J; en: , CBH3alIIIhIX MemJJ;y C060H npeeMcTBelIlIocTbIO nOKOJIeIlIIH If pOJJ;cTBelI-
HbIMII B3aIIMOOTlIomeUIIHMII.
KaKOBbJ iRe IITorlI naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrlIqeCKOro 1I3yqelIlIH np06JIeM MOpcpO-
.,orIIqeCKOH )J;lIlIaMHRIl qeJIOBeqeCTBa? HaROnJIeUlIaH 3JJ;ecb IIIIcpopMa IIH
CTOJIb BeJIIIKa, qTO B npeJJ;eJIax CTaTbII MOn{IIO KOCIIYTbCH (JJ;a H TO BeCbMa
uerJIo) JIHllb OCIIOBlIbIX. IIan60JIee BamlIbIX rrp06JIeM.
,lJ;peBlIeiilllIe IfCKOnaeMbIe OCTaTRH IIpeJJ:KOB qeJIOBeKa IIMeIOT, KaK 1I3-
BeCTIIO, B03paCT 3-4 MJIII JIeT, 110 01I1I KpaHlIe cpparMelITapbI, JJ;a II IIaXO)J;KU
';;'OBOJIhIID pe)J;KII, rr03TOMY )J;aIOT rrpeJJ;CTaBJIelIIIe 0 CTpoelIIIH JIIIllb eJJ;IIIIIf'I-
123
HhIX cy6'beKTOB. MaCCOBbIn MaTepIIaJI, nOna)J;aIOm;nH B pyKII aIITpOnOJIOrOB.
HaqHlIaeTCH C 3IIOXII Me30JIHTa. O)J;IIaKO KaK 6bI HII 6bIJIlI cpparMelITaplIbI Ha-
XO)J;RII OCTaTROB caMhlX )J;peBIIIIX npe)J;KOB qeJIOBeRa, OIIII nOKa3bIBaIOT )J;lIlIa-
MIIRY II3MelIeHlIH IIX cpII3lIqeCIWrO TIIlIa IIa npOTHiRelIlIH HeCKOJIbRIIX MIIJIJIIIO-
IIOB JIeT. A 3TO, B CBOIO Oqepe)J;b, n03BOJIHeT BhlHBIITb IIeKOTOphIe cpYII)J;aMelI-
TaJIbHbIe TelI)J;elIUIIII lIfopcpOJIOrIIqeCROrO pa3BlITHH qeJIOBeRa, KOTOpbIe B
ROHeqHOM IITore npIIBeJIII K cpOpMlIpoBalIlIIO ero cOBpeMelIlIoro BII)J;a.
BbI)J;eJIeHO IIeCKOJIbKO TaKIIX TelI)J;elIl(IIH, KaiR)J;aH rpynna KOTOphIX IIpe06-
JIa)J;aJIa Ha pa3JIIIqHhIX XpOIIOJIOnlqeCRIIX 3TalIax IICTOplIII qeJIOBeKa II ero
npe)J;RoB. ECJIII paccMaTplIBaTb aHTponorelIe3 C MopcpOJIOrlI'IeCKOIi TOqRII 3pe-
HHH, TO B nepIIO)J;, HaqaBlImliCH C MOMeHTa BbI)J;eJIeIIIIH qeJIOBeKa II3 iRIIBOTIIO-
1'0 MIIpa II 3aBepilllIBilllIIICH IIOHBJIeHIIeM Homo sapiens, rrpe06JIa)J;aJIII
)J;Be TelI)J;elIJJ;IIII - cpOpMIIpoBalIue «rOllfIIIIII)J;IIOH TplIa)J;bI» II 3II ecpaJIII3a IIH.
B alITpOnOJIOrlIqeCKOH JIIITepaType B rOllfIIIIIID;IIYIO TplIa)J;y BKJIIO'IaIOTCH TPII
HalI60JIee xapaKTeplIbIe oc06elIIIocTII MopcpOJIOrII'IeCKOH opralIII3a 1I1I 'IeJIO-
BeKa, B COBOKynlIocTII OTJIIIqaIOm;lIe ero OT )J;pyrnx MJIeROnIITaIOm;IIX: Bep-
TIIRaJIblIOe nOJIOmelIlIe TeJIa II cBH3alIIIhIH C 3TlIM xapaKTep IIOXO)J;KII; oc060e
CTpO€Ime RUCTII PYKU C 60JIhilllIM naJIbl(eM, npoTIIBOCTOHm;IIM OCTaJIbHbIM,
'ITO C03)J;aeT B03MomHOCTb TOIIKO MalIIInYJIlIpOBaTb npe)J;MeTaMII; 60JIbmoii
06'beM M03ra C ero CJIOiRHOH II JJ:lIcpcpepelIl(lIpOBalIlIoli CTPYRTypOIi. TIaJIeOaHT-
pOnOJIOrII'IeCKlIe )J;alIlIbIe 0 palIlIIIx Upe.D:CTaBIITeJIHX ceMellcTBa rOMHIuI)J;,
06'be)J;IIIIHIOm;ero Bcex npe)J;KoB 'IeJIOBeRa, n03BOJIIIJIH YCTalIoBIITb nOCJJe)J;OBa-
TeJIblIOCTb 06pa30BalIIIH 3TIIX Mopcpo.rrorIIqeCRIIX CTpyRTyp, rroKa3aTb, Qepe3
RaKlIe MopcpOJIOrIIqeCRIIe 3TarrhI rrpomJIo cpOpMlIpoBalIIIe 'IeJIOBeRa cOBpeMelI-
Horo BII,ZJ;a. npOl(eCC 3IIJJ;ecpaJIII3al(UII - YBeJIHqemlH MaCCbI M03ra H YCJIom-
HelIlIH ero BIIYTpeHlIeli CTpyKTypbI - CTa.rr HaH60JIee IIIITelICIIBlIhIM rrpII CTa-
HOBJIemm pO.D:a Homo II BII)J;a Homo sapiens. Ho OH conYTcTBOBaJI H BceMY
alITpolIorelIe3Y B JJ;eJIOM, u60 JIIIlrrb nOCTOHIIHoe nporpeCCIIBlIoe pa3BlITIIe
lIf03ra MOrJIO 06ecneqIfBaTb yCJIOmlIeHHe nOBe)J;eIIIIH qeJIOBeRa, C03)J;aBaTb B03-
MOiRHOCTn )J;JIH Toro, qT06bI 011 CTaJI crroc06eII cOBepillaTb Bce 60JIee pa3IIO-
06pa3IIbIe TPY)J;OBbIe onepa IIII.
nOHBJIelIlIe OKOJIO 40 ThIC. JIeT Ha3a)J; 'IeJIOBeKa COBpeMelIlIoro BH)J;a, Homo
sapiens, npnBeJIO K MopcpoJIornqecRoli cTa6IIJIII3a HII ero BII,iIOBhIX npII3Ha-
ROB, 110 BMeCTe C TeM He HCRJIIOqHJIO TelI,ZJ;elI IIH lIfopcpOJIOrlIqeCKOrO pa3BHTIIH.
KOTopoe IIepIIO)J;IIqeCRII OXBaThlBaJIO pa3JIIIqlIhIe 60JIee IIJIII Mellee 3IIaqUTeJIb-
HbIe rpyrrlIbI 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa. ABe TaKIIe TelI)J;elI IIH - 6paxIIKecpaJIII3a lU!
(oRpyrJIelIlIe rOJIOBhI 'IeJIOBeRa) II rpaJJ;IIJIII3aJJ;HH (YMeHbillelIHe MaCCIIBHOCTH
CReJIeTa) 6bIJIII xapaRTepHbI JJ:JIH BIIJJ:OBOH 8BOJIIOUlIlI COBpeMelIlIoro qeJIOBeRa
B :qeJIOM; OIIII IIOCTOHIIIIO corryTcTBOBaJIH IIpOJJ;eccy MopcpOJIOrlI'IeCKOH )J;Hcpcpe-
peH:qIIa:qIIII qeJIOBeqeCRIIX 1I0rrYJIH IH. TpeTbH TeH)J;elI IIH MopCPOJIOrlIqeCRIIX
H3MelIelIIIll - aRce.;repa IfH npOHBHJIaCh JIHillb B nOCJIe)J;IIIIe )J;eCHTIIJIeTIIH;
olla 6bI.rra BblHBJIelIa rJIaBHhIM 06pa30M B npoJJ;ecce If3yqemfH yp6aIIIf3lIpO-
BaHlIhlX qeJIOBeqeCKIIX KOJIJIeKTIIBOB B BbICOIwpa3BIITbIX IIII)J;ycTpHaJIbHhIX
CTpalIax.
np06JIeMbI, CBH3aHIIbIe C )J;IIIIaMIIKoH II pacnpocTpaHeHHeM Bcex 3TIIX TelI-
)J;eH IIH, em;e cpaBIIHTeJIblIO He)J;aBIIO 6bIJIlf rrpe)J;MeTOM OCTphlX P:ucHyccnII
cpeJJ:II Me)J;IIKOB H aIITpOIIOJIOrOB. CeHqaC me MomHO C'IIITaTb )J;lIlIaMIIRY II
pacnpocTpalIelIlIe JIORaJIblIhIX TelI)J;elI IIH MopcpOJIOrII'IeCKllX II3MelIelIHH B 06-
m;IIX 'IepTaX BhIHClIelIlIbIMII.
n po:qecc 6paxlIRecpaJIIf3al(1I1I CTaJI oc06elIII0 IIIITelICIIBHO npOHBJIHTLCH
nplIMeplIO co cpe)J;IIeBeKOBbH; B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH 011 OXBaTIIJI npaRTHqeCRH
1I0)J;aBJIHIOm;yIO 'IaCTb COBpeMelIlIbIX 3TIIII'IeCKIIX rpyrrn. O)J;IIaKO nepBbIe nplI-
aHaKH 6paxlIKecpaJJlI3a:qIIII Ha6JIIO)J;aIOTcH 3IIaqIITeJIblI0 palIbme, IIa «3ape qe-
124
JIOBeqeCTBa»: olla CTaJIa npOHBJIHTbCH em;e Y IIpe)J;CTaBIITeJIeH IIeKOTOpbIX JIO-
KaJIblIhIX rpynn HCKonaeMbIX rOMIIIIHJ],. rpa:qIIJIII3a:qHH IIaqaJIa IIIITelICIIBHO
pa3BlIBaTbCH em;e B 3noxy IIeOJIHTa, a 3aTeM cnopaJ],II'IeCRH npOHBJIHJIa ce6H
B OT)J;eJIblIbIX IIOnYJIH:qIIHX J],peBlIeMUIIIX IIpeJ],KOB qeJIOBeKa. HaKOlIe:q, aKce-
;Iepa IIH - YCKopelIlIoe nOJIOBOe C03peBaHlIe H HIITeIICIIcpIIKaJJ;IIH pOCTa - 3TO
B OCIIOBIIOM HBJIelIlle IIOCMe)J;IIIIX IIeCKOJIbRHX J],eCHTHJIeTIIH. O)J;IIaKO OT)J;eJIb-
HbIe aKCeJIepa IIOlIlIbIe CJ],BIIrlI CPIIKCHPYIOTCH rraJIeOalITpOIIOJIOrIIqeCRII II B
60JIee palIlIee BpeMH, IIanpIIMep B onpeJ],eJIelIlIhIX paHOlIax EBponbI B nepH-
OJ], cpeJ],IIeBeROBbH.
npII'illlIa nOHBJIelIlIH Bcex 3TlIX MIIKp03BOJIIO IIOIIHbIX BIIYTPlfBlI)J:OBbIX
TeHJ],elI:qIIII KpoeTCH B onpeJ],eJIelIlIbIX OIITorelIeTHqeCKIIX cp:BlIrax - YCKope-
HIIII (IIJIII iRe 3aMeD;JIeIIIIII) pOCTOBhIX npOJJ;eCCOB noJ], BJIIfHIIIIeM IIepBlIo-ry-
MOpaJIblIbIX, 3IIJ],OKpIIIIHbIX, TpocpIlqeCKIIX II IfIIbIX cpaKTopOB. B 060CIIOBalIHH
iJTOrO BaiRlIOro nOJIOmelIlIH 3IIaqlITeJIblIYIO pO JIb ChIrpaJIII TPY)J;hI BbIJJ:aIOm;erO-
CH COBeTCT{OrO alITpOnOJIOra B. B. BYlIaKa.
J13yqelIIIe npo eCCOB pOCTa, I1X pOJIII B OIITorelIeTlIqeCROM pa3BlITlIII qe-
.:rOBeKa B l(eJIOM, I1X XPOIIOJIOrIPIeCKOH II JIOKaJIbHOH cne:qIIcpIlRII II CBH3II CO
cpe)J;oH (BKJIIO'IaH H cpeJ],Y cOJJ;I1aJIbIIYIO) BbIJ],BIIraeTCH cOBpeMelIlIoM IICTOpH-
Ko-aIITpOnOJIOrn IecKoH IIaYKoH IIa nepBbIII nJIaH, I160 HMelIlIO 3TII MCCJIe)J;OBa-
HHH cnoc06cTBYIOT yrJIy6JIelIlIIO IIaIIlIIX 3HaHHn 06 OCIIOBlIbIX nplIqlIlIaX II
qJaKTopax MOpcpOJIOI'IIqeCKOH J],IIHaMIIRII 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa.
C paCCMaTpIlBaeMoH np06JIeMoH TeCIIO CMhIKaeTCH II np06.fl,eMa MOpf}jO.fl,O-
ZU'leCKOU ouf}jf}jepeHlfualfuu U UHTezpalfuu 'le.fl,Oee'leCKUX nonY.fl,fllfuu. 06m;aH
6I10JIOrHH II alITpOnOJIOrlIH onpe)J;eJIHIOT IIOnYJIH HIO KaK rpynlIY JIIO)J;eH, CBH-
3alIIIbIX KaKIIM-JIII60 pO)J;CTBOM. nonyJIH I1H pa3J],eJIHIOTCH TaR IIa3bIBaellIhIMII
relIeTIIqeCKIIMII 6apbepaMlI - onpeJ],eJIelIlIbIMII CO I1aJIblIbIMII IIIICTIITYTaMII,
rrpeIIHTCTBYIOm;IIMH IIJIII 3IIa'IHTeJIbII0 3aTpyJ],IIHIOm;IIMII MeiRnorryJIH IIOlIlIbIe
6paKII, reorpacpIl'ieCKIIMII py6eiRaMII, KYJIhTYPlIhIMII Tpa)J;I1JJ;IIHMH H J],PyrIIMII
«I>aKTopaMII. npII IIenpOIIII aeMbIX IIJIII MaJIOnpOHH aeMbIX relIeTHqeCKIIX
6apbepax nonYJIH IIII 3aMKIIYTbI H coxpalIHIOT CBOIO caMOCTOHTeJIhlIOCTb IIa
npOTHmeIlIIII MlIorlIX nOKOJIeIIIIH; nplI rrpOHII:qaeMhIX - nonYJIH HII «pa3MhI-
BaIOTCH» II 6bICTpO IIepeCTaIOT cym;ecTBOBaTb. OJ],IIaKO IIapH)J;y C qeTKOM no-
nYJIH IIOIIHOM CTPYRTypOM, xapaKTeplIOH J],JIH IIaCeJIeIlIfH MlIorlIX paHOIIOB
3eMJIII, B HeKOTopbIX 06II1IIplIbIX 06JIaCTHX B CIIJIY OC06bIX IICTOplIqeCKIIX
nplIqlIlI IIaCeJIelIlIe OTJIlIqaeTCH aMopcpHbIM nonYJIH I10IIHbIM COCTaBOM: BIIYT-
plI ero lIe 06pa3yeTcH pO)J;CTBelIlIhlX rpynnIIpOBOK )J;OCTaTOqIIO 60JIbIIlOrO OO'b-
eMa. TaKIIM 06pa30M, norryJIHJJ;IIOHHaH CTpYKTypa qeJIOBeqeCTBa - 3TO He
TOJIbKO MlIorOKOllfIIOlIeHTHaH, 110 II aCIIMMeTpHqHaH CHCTeMa, OTpamaIOm;aH
BCIO CJIO}!{IIOCTb ROHRpeTIIOH IICTOpHII OTJ],eJIbHbIX qeJIOBeqeCKIIX KOJIJIeTnIlBOB.
CJIOmlIOCTb nonYJIHJJ;:IlOIIHon CTPYKTYPbI qeJIOBeqeCTBa, KOTopaH IIaXOJ],IIT
OTpaiRelIlIe II B MopcpOJIOrIIH qeJIOBeKa (MIIOrO'IIICJIeIIHhIe I1CCJIe)J;OBaIIHH
BCKpbIJIII BIIOJIlIe qeTRHe pa3JIIIqlIH MeffiJJ:Y norrYJIH IfOlIrrbIMII rpynnIlpoBRallfII
qeJIOBeqeCTBa no MlIorHM MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCRIIM IIpIl3IIaKaM - POCTY, Becy, npo-
nop IIHM TeJIa, pa3MepaM rOJIOBbI II JIIIJJ;a, BaplIa IIHM CTpoelIIIH MHrKIIX TRa-
IIeH JIII a, IIIIrMeIITa I1H), BbI3BaJIa IIpO)J;OJImaIOm;YIOCH J],O CIIX IIOp )J;HCKyC-
CHIO, CBH3alIHYIO C OlIpe)J;eaelIlIeM paCOBoro COCTaBa qeJIOBe'IeCTBa.
06'be.D;IfIIelIlIe rronYJIH IIii B HaJ],IIOnYJIH:qIIOHlIhIe 06m;HOCTII - pachl npo-
BO.D;IITCH IIa OCIIOBe yqeTa lIflIorlIX BamHhIX np1I31IaKOB. OJ],IIaKO .D;O cera Bpe-
MeHH oT6op 3THX npH3HaKoB CIIJIblIO 3aBIICIIT OT TeOpeTII'IeCKIIX YCTanoBoK
Toro IIJIH HHoro IICCJIeJ],oBaTeJIH, H60 nOKa em;e IIeT eJ],IIIIoro MHelIlIH no 3TlIM
BonpocaM. n03TOMY cOBpellfelIlIhIe yqelIbIe no-pa3HoMY onpe)J;eJIHIOT qIlCJIO
IICXOJ],IIbIX pacoBhIx 3JIeMelITOB «IIa IIlIiRlIeM 3Tame» pacoBoH KJIaCcncplIKa-
}\HH - Ha ypoBlIe JIORaJIbHbIX pac I1JIII cOBoKynHocTeH aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKllX
125
...
THnOB, qIlCJIO KOTOpbIX KOJIe6JIeTCH OT 20 p;o 50. ECTeCTBeHIIO U03TOMy, qTO
HeT ep;IIIICTBa B3rJIH.D:OB II npII onpep;eJIelIlIII 60JIee (<BhlCOKHX 3TaiRell» paco-
DOH KJlaCClIcpIlIm I1I1. IIIKO.:'IbIIOe npe)J;cTaBJIelIIIe 0 p;eJIeIIIIII cOBpeMelIlIoro qe-
JlOBeqeCTBa Ha TPII 60JIbmUe pacbI pa3p;eJIHeTCH JIIImb HeOOJlbmOH qaCThIO
JICCJIep;OBaTeJJeII; 60JIbmlIHCTBo iRe yqelIhIX npII;JepmuBaIOTcH I1HhIX cxeM pa-
COBOl I rpynnlIpoBKII IIaCeJIelIUH 3eMJIII, OO'be)J;IfHHH JIIOp,eH B )J;Be, qeTbIpe I1JIII
JJ:ame nHTb RPYlIlIbIX paCOBhIX 06m;IIOCTeI1. ECTh II CTOpOlIlIlIRII lIJ(elI 0 IIe3a-
BUClIlIfOM npOIIcxom)J;eIIlllI pa3.:'IIIqlIhlX JIOKaJIblIbIX pac, 06 I1CRyccTBeIIIIOCTII
I1X OO'be)J;lIlIeIIIIH B KaRlIe-JIII60 OOm;IIOCTII oOJIee BhICOKoro TaRCOIIOMIIqeCRO-
1'0 paIIra.
Bce 3TII IIeHCIIOCTII IIpOIICTeKaIOT II3-3a Toro, qTO «IIIIBeIITapII3aI:t;IIH» JIO-
RaJIblIhIX pac, BXOJJ:HIl\I1X B COCTaB COBpell1eHHOrO IeJIOBeqeCTBa, a TaKiRe cno-
C06bI IIX rpyrrnIlpoBRII IIepa3phIBII0 CBH3aUbI C pemelIlIeM MlIorIlX CJImKlIhIX
reJIeTIIqeCRIIX BorrpOCOB, B TO BpeMH KaK relIeaJIOrIlH qeJIOBCTIeCRHX pac npu
Bceii: oomlIpnocTII naKon.'1eIIIIOll ulIcpopMa ulI OCTaeTCH IIORa em;e OqeHb CJIa-
60 pa3paooTalIlIoH. 11llfelIII0 nOToMy orpOMlIoe 3IIaqelIIIe IIMeeT nOJIyqelIIIe II
BBe)J,eUIIe B IIayqlIhlH 060POT IIOBhIX naJIeOaIITpOnOJIOrIl IeCKIIX MaTepIlaJIOB,
ocooelIIIo Tex, qTO OTRpbIBaIOT apXeOJIOrlI nplI paCKOIIRax MorlI.'IbHIIROB, OT-
HOCHm;IIXCH K paHIIlIM 3noxaM I1CTOpIIII qe.iIOBeqeCTBa. JIlImb nOCTOHlIlIoe co-
BepmenCTBOBanIle MeTO)J;OB II3B.lIeqelIIIH C nOMOm;bIO 3TIIX MaTepUaJIOB JJ:0nOJJ-
HHTeJIblIOH relIeTHqeCKOll IIlIcpopMaI:t;IIIf II03BOJIlIT B 6Y)J;ym;eM )J,OCTaTOqIIO
nOJIIIO If rJIyooKo npe)J;CTaBIITb Bce npOI:t;eCChI paCOBoro relIe3I1Ca qeJIOBe-
1JeCTBa.
II p06JIeMa paCOBoro relIe3lIca BaiRlIa lIe TOJIbRO caMa no ce6e, ee peme-
HlIe II03BOJIlIT rrO-IIOBOMY nOJJ:ollTII II K IIOlIlIMalIlIIO )J;pyrlIx BaiRIIbIX I1CTOpU-
qeCKIIX BonpOCOB. B qlICJIe I1X - onpe).IeJIelIlIe I1CTOpIfqeCRIIX KOIITaRTOB MeJR-
;::t;y JIaCeJIelIlIeM pa3IIhIX I1CTOpIIKo-3TlIorpacplIqeCKIIX paHolIoB, pemelIIIe MIIO-
rlIX np06JIeM 3TIIoreHe3a II 3TIIlIqeCROll IICTOpIIII, BhIHBJIelIIIe JIOKaJIbHOrO
cBoeo6pa3I1H pa3BlITIIH JJ:peBlIeHmero qeJIOBeqeCTHa IIa pa3IIbIX ROIITlfHelITax,
a TaKine B npe)J;eJIax KPYlIlIbIX rBorpacplIqeCRIIX 06JIaCTeii:.
Mop<J)OJIOrlIqeCRaH )J,HlIaMIIKa qeJIOBeTIeCTBa conpOBOmp,aJIaCb ero fjU3uO-
.!lOZU'leCKOU iJuna tuKOU, 1I3yqelIlIe KOTOpOH - Op,IIO I13 cym;ecTBeHlIhIx IIa-
npaBJIelIlIlI IICTO pUKo-aIITpoII0.'10rlIqeCKIIX IICCJIep;OBalIlIll.
PeROIICTpYK IIH cpII3IfOJIOrlI IeCROH )J,lIlIaMIIRII qeJIOBeqeCTB3 IICKJIIOqHTeJIh-
HO TpY)J;Ha. Bo-uepBbIX, B OOJIblIIIfHCTBe CJIyqaeB qpe3BbIqalllI0 CJIOiRlIO onpe-
p;eJIHTb XpOHOJIOrlIqecRyIO peTpocneKTIIBY CPH31I0JIOrIIqeCKHX II3MeHeIIHH:
nOqTH Bce 3TanbI HanpaBJIelIlIhIX I13MelIelIHll 1JeJIOBe1JeCTBa npaRTHqeCRH BOC-
CTalIaBJIIIBaIOTCH IICCJIe)J;oBaTeJIHMII lIe rrYTeM IIpHMbIX Ha6JIIO).IelIlIll, a C no-
MOm;bIO KOCBelIlIbIX co06paiRelIlIll, onHpaIOm;HXCH IIa BaplIa 1I1I cpII31I0JIOrlIqe-
CRUX nplI3IIaROB B HhIIle iRlIBym;IIX nonYJIH IIHX. BO-BTOpbIX, Tpe6YIOT p;aJIb-
HeHmeii: pa3paOOTKII H COBepmelICTBOBalIIIH MeTO)J,bI onpep;eJIelIIIH (lla OCIIOBe
JI3yqeIlIlH I1CKOnaeMbIX ROCTeH) rpynnOBbIX cpaKTopOB KpOBII, cO)J;epiRaIIlfH B
I1IIX MIIRp03JIeMelITOB H MIIlIepaJIOB, BbfHBJIeUIIH IIO)J,JIIIIIIIOii: npUiRlf3lIelIlIOli
CTPYRTYPhl KOCTII II T. p,. (XOTH 3)J,eCb yme nOJIyqeHbI 06IIaJJ:emIIBaIOm;lIe pe-
3YJIbTaThI). II IIaROlIe , B-TpeThHX, Tpyp:IIOCTb TaKOll peROHCTpYR 1I1I CBH3alIa
H co CJIOiRlIOCTbIO caMoro npo ecca CPIl3IIOJIOrlIqeCKOH p,unaMIIKII TIeJIOBeqe-
CTBa. IhBecTlIo, qTO B03)J;encTBIIe nonYJIH IIOIIHo-relIeTHqeCKHX cpaKTopoB Ha
If3MelIenlIe CPlI3IIOJIOrlIqeCKlIX npH3HaKoB BO MlIorOM 3aBIICeJIO OT nonyJIH II-
OIIIIOII CTPYRTyphI qeJIOBeqeCTBa; nOCJJep,IIHH me, RaK OTMeqa.TIOCh palIee, Ha
rrpoTHmelIlIII BceH UCTOpHII qeJIOBeTIeCTBa nOCTOHIIHO H IIHTelICIIBIIO I13MeIIH-
JIaCb. Bce 3TlI MOMeHTbJ D;eJIaIOT 1I3yqelIlIe cpII3IIOJIOrHTIeCKoii: )J;lIlIaMIIKII qe-
JIOBeqeCTBa qpe3BhlqalllI0 TPY)J,IIOH npOOJIeMOH; IICTOpHqeCRaH alITpOnOJIOrIIH
HaX0.D:I1TCH JIHmb IIa IIa1JaJIbIIOH cTa)J,IIII ee pa3pa6oTKH.
126
PaCCMOTpIIM ));alIlIbIe, KOTOpbIe B OlIpe));eJIeHHOH Mepe MorYT 6bITb IICnOJIh-
30BalIhI nplI H3yqeHIIII IIeI{OTOPhIX acneKTOB 3TOH np06JIeMbI. HhIIIe TOqlIO
yCTaIIOBJIeIIO, qTO Ha npOTHiReHIIII BceH JICTOpIIH qeJIOBeqeCTBa lIe 6hlJI0 0));-
IIOlIanpaBJIelIlIhIX II3MeHelIlIH B rpYIInOBbIX cpaKTopax KpOBII; B 3TOM OTIIOlIIe-
HIflf COXpalIKIaCb JIOKaJIblIaH cne:qncplIKa rpynII IIaCeJIeIIHH. TaRIIM 06pa30M,
B KaiR)J;hIH onpe));eJIelIlIbIH MOMelIT IICTOpIIII qeJIOBeqeCTBo npe));CTaBJIHJIO CO-
60H 06m;IIOCTb, reTeporelInyIO 110 relIaM rpynn KpOBII.
Ha OCIIOBalIIIII IIaKOIIJIelIlIbIX K lIaCTOHm;eMy BpeMelIII MIIOroqIICJIelIlIbIX
cpaKTOB MomlIO, IIanplIMep, YTBepm));aTb, qTO rrpIIlIa));JIemlIOCTb JIIO));eH K Ka-
IWH-JIII60 rpynne KpOBII, BXO));Hm;en B clIcTeMy ABa, IIenOcpe)J;cTBelIlIo CBH-
3alIa C HK; npe));pacnOJIOiRelIIIeM IIJIII IIMMYlIlITeTOM K olIpe)J;eJIelIlIbIM 3a60JIe-
BaIIIIHM. STO nOJIOiRelIlIe nOKa em;e lIe )J;oKa3alI0 no OTIIOInelIIIIO K ));pyrHM
CIICTeMaM KpOBII, 110 ));YMaeTcH, 'ITO 0110 B BbIclIIeH CTelIelIII BepoHTlIo. ECJIII
J,eJIO 06CTOIIT IIMelIlIO TaK, TO no.lInMopcpn3l\f qeJIOBeqeCTBa no rpynnoBbIM
cpaKTopaM KpOBII (KaK II JII06aH ,ZJ;pyraH cpopMa relIeTHqeCKoro nOJIIIMopcp1I3-
a) CTalIOBHTCH qeTKOH BII)J;OBOH xapaKTepIICTIIROH pa3JIIIqlIhlX ero nonYJIH-
unn. BII));IIMO, IIMelIHO 3TOT cpaKTOp 06eCneqlIBaeT BbUJIIIBaeMOCTb nonYJIH lIn
B OlIpe)J;eJIelIlIhIX npnpO));IIhIX YCJIOBIIHX. TaKIIM 06pa30M, rIInOTe3bI relIeTIIKOB
20-30-x rO));OB 0 HaJIlIqIIII y )J;peBlIeHlIIero qeJIOBe'leCTBa KaKIIX-TO IIen3BeCT-
IIbIX cepOJIOrIIqeCRIIX cpaKTopOB (CBH3alIlIbIX C IIMMYHIITeTOM), 0 3aMem;eHIIII
IIX C TeqelIIIeM BpeMelI1I COBpeMelIlIhIMH cpaKTopaMII, 0 KaKOH-TO 06m;eBII)J;0-
BOH nalIOHKYMelIlIOH )J;IIIIaMIIKe cpII31I0JIOrlI'IeCKnX oc06elIIIOCTeH BblrJIH)J;HT
IIhIIIe ));OCTaTOqIIO IIenpaBIJ;OnO));06IIo. CJIe));yeT, O)J;IIaKO, OTMeTIITb, qTO II B
rrpOmJIOM 6bIJIa BnOJIlIe BepOHTlIa JIORaJIblIaH ));IIlIaMIIKa IIaCeJIelInH no rpyrr-
rraM KpOBII; npOHBJIeHIIH 3TIIX IIpOJJ;eCCOB MorYT 6bITb npOCJIemelIbI IIa pH));e
IIpHMepOB, lIe JIlIlIIeHlIbIX, npaB)J;a, II3BeCTIIOll rIIIIOTeTIIqIIOCTII.
PaCCMOTplIM )J;Ba IIplIMepa, IIJIJIIOCTpIIPYIOm;IIe IIpIIBe)J;elIlIbIe BbIlIIe nOJIO-
iI\eIIIIH. rpynna KpOBIl B CHCTeMbI ABa npe06JIa));aeT y IIaCeJIelIHH A3HaTCKO-
ro MaTepHKa, K TOMY me olla Tpal nl(IIOIIIIO CqIITaeTCH xapaKTeplIOH )J;JIH MOII-
roJIOII));OB. Ho npe06Jla));aeT olla H IIa TeppHTopHH MII)J;I1II, B TOM qlICJIe B
CeBeplIon MII)J;IIII. MHCTIITYT 3TIIorpacpIlII AH CCCP H MII));HHCKIIH CTaTIICTII-
'leCKIIH IIIICTIITYT npOBeJIH B ceBeplIbIx H ceBepo-3ana)J;IIbIX 06JIaCTHX MII));HH
HeCKOJIbRO COBMeCTlIhIX alITpOIIoreHeTlIqeCKllX 3KclIe)J;If IIH, nOKa3aBlIIIIx, qTO
dHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCKIIH COCTaB IIaCeJIelIlIH 3TlIX 06JIaCTeH CJIOiRIIJICH B npo ecce
J::mTeJIbIIOrO CMeIIIelIIIH eBpOneOII));IIbIX II IIerpoII)J;IIbIX 3JIeMeIITOB, HO eBpo-
IIeOII)J;hI no qIICJIelIlIOCTH 3IIa qHTeJIblIO IIpeBbIlIIaJIII IIerpOII)J;OB 3.
M3BeCTHO, 'ITO ));JIH A3IIII xapaKTeplIbI IICKJIIOqIfTeJIblIaH cKyqeHHOCTb IIa-
ce:IeIIHH, HIITeHCIIBlIoe )J;eMorpacpHqeCKOe ));aBJIeIIHe, BbI3BalIIIOe pa3BlITIIeM
3e 1JIe)J;eJIHH C rJIy60Kon )J;peBIIOCTII. Bce 3TO nplIBeJIO K TOMY, qTO B A3lIH
B03IIIIRaJIlI onaClIeHIIIHe O'larH qYMhI II ocnbI, ROTOpbIe, pa3BHBaHCb B nalI-
J:e fIIIO, BhlIIJIeCKIIBamiCb IIa orpOMlIbIe TepplIToplflf H ));ORaTbIBaJiIICb ));0 EB-
pOlIhI. KaK nOKa3aJIlI MIIOroqlICJIelIIIbIe IIa6JIIO));eIIIfH H HCCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH, II qYMa
II ocna - 3TO IIH<peK IIH, no OTIIOlIIelIIIIO K KOTOphIM IIOCIITeJlII rpynnbI B OT-
:mqaIOTCH nOBbIlIIelIlIOH pe3lICTelITIIOCTbIO (conpOTIIBJIHeMOCTbIO). aCHOBbIBa-
HCb IIa 3TlIX cpaKTax, IIeKOTOpbIe relIeTIIKH BbI)J;BIIIIYJIII I'IIIIOTe3Y, CorJIaCIIO
KOTOpOH B oqare qYMIIOH H OClIelIHOH HHcpeKJJ;HIf HOCIITeJlII rpynn A, a If
AB, IICnbIThIBaH nOCTOHHlIoe ));aB.'!eIIIIe oTpIf aTeJI:bIIOH CeJIeKl(lIlI, nOCTeneH-
30 IfCqe3aJIII, B TO BpeMH KaK IIOCIITeJIH rpynrrhI B, 06JIaJJ:aBlIIlIe rrOBLImelIlIOH
1HIMYlIIIOH YCTOHqIIBOCTbIO, COXpaIIHJlIICb. STOT npoJJ;ecc (KaK If 60JIbmIIHCT-
EO )J;pyrHx MIIKp03BOJIIO IIOIIHhIX IIpo eCCOB) COBeplIIaJICH C IIeBbICOKOH CKO-
poCTbIO, O));IIaKO IIa IIpOTHmelIlIH IIeCKOJIbKIIX TbICH'IeJIeTHH 011, BII,ZJ;IIMO, nplI-
Be.'! R npe06JIa)J;alIIfIO B COBpeMelIlIOH MII)J;Iflf HaCeJIelIHH C rpynlIoH KpOBH B,
c ee onpe));eJIHIOI:qHM reHOM q. CJIe));OBaTeJIbHO, 3TOT. paHOH MomHO CqIITaTb
127
paHOIIOllf HanpaBJIelIHoro If3MelIelIHH Ha rrpOTHiRelIIIII IIeCKOJIbKIIX TbICH'IeJIe-
TIIH COCTaBa IIaCeJIelIlIH no rpynnaM KpOBII. CJIe,ZJ;yeT orOBopHTbCH, qTO 3TO
nOKa TOJIbKO npe,ZJ;IIOJIOmelIIIe 0 BepOHTIIOM pa3BIITHII CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX npo-
:qeCCOB; 0110, 6eccnopHO, TpeoyeT )J;aJIblIelUrreH pa3pa60TKIf. If 60JIee BeCKHX
OCIIOBalIlIlf.
,D;pyroii: rrpIfMep. ¥ HH)J;eHl(eB AMeplIKH rrOqTII CTonpOJJ;elITlIoe npe06JIap,a-
RIle IIOCIITeJIeH rpynlIhI KpOBII O. B CH6IfpIf TaKme 06IIapymelI0 IIeCKOJIbRO
MaJIOqlICJIelIlIbIX rpynII IIaCeJIeIIIfH, OT.:'IlIqaIOm;IIXCH 3TOii: oc06eHIIOCTbIO.
M:VleIIHO n03ToMy 6bIJIO BbICKa3alI0 npe)J;nOJIOmelIlIe, qTO IIa'IaJIO BceM KopelI-
HhIM IIonyJIH IfHM AMepIIRH )J;aJIa KaKaH-TO 1I3 TaKIIX MeJIKUX rpyrrn. nop,ou-
HaH nmOTe3a, op:IIaRO, BCTynaeT B nponmopeque C MopcpOJIOrH IeCKIIMIl na-
OJIIO,ZJ;eIIUHMII If C p,aIIlIbIMII 0 )J;eMorpacpJPTCCKOH ,[J,IllIaMIIKe, C KOIIKpeTIIDIl\fIf
CBe)J;euIIH:vm 0 nyTHx paCCeJIeHIIH JIIo)J;eii: C TepplITopIlII A3IflI B AMeplfKY,
fopa3;J,o 60JIee BepOHTlIbIM npe)J;CTaBJIHeTCH, qTO npe06JIa)J;alIlIe y RopelIlIoro
naCeJIeUIIH AMeplIKII rpylIlIbI 0 - 3TO pe3Y.JIbTaT MuorOTbICWIeJIeTlIerO MIIK-
pmmOJIIOl(IIOlInOro npo ecca, npIfqlIIIOH IWToporo MOl' 6hITb Kalwii:-To II03me
IfCqe3IIYBlIIIIii: IIlIcpeK IIOlIlIbIn cpaKTOp, nplIBe)J;IIIIIn K OTplIl(aTeJIbIIOH CeJIeK-
I 1I1I 1I0CIfTeJIeii: rpynn A II B. npaB,ZJ;a, UpIf TeOpeTIfqeCKOII B03MOiRIIOCTIf
)J;ellcTBIfH TaKoro cpaKTopa 011 IIIIKorp:a lIe 6hIJI 06IIapY}KelI. EOJIee BepoHTlIhlM
npe)J;cTaBJIHeTCH (RaK IIeKor)J;a nhITaJICH apryMelITIIpoBaTb 3TO aBTop cTaTblI)
IflIoe, qlICTO relIeTlIqeClme 06'bHClIeIIIIe. ,D;YMaeTcH, qTO B 3TOM cJIyqae Mom-
110 npIlMelIlITb relIoreorpacpIIqeCKOe npaBIIJIO H. M. BaBIIJIOBa 0 BbIm;en:relIlIlI
pe eccIIBlIhIX relIOB Ha oKpalIHax BIID;OBoro apeaaa. M3BecTHo, 'ITO rell r, KO-
TOphlii: onpeD;eJIHeT IIepe.n;a'IY no IIaCJIe)J;cTBY rpynnhI KpOBII 0, HBJIHeTCH pe-
JJ;eCCIfBlIhIM no OTlIomelIIIIO K )J;ollfIfHalITHbIM relIaM p If q, p,eTepMlIlIlIpYIOm;HM
IIaCJIe)J;cTBeIIIIYIO nepe)J;aqy rpynn A If B. M3BecTII0 TaKiRe, TTO AMepIfRalI-
CKIfH KOIITlIlIelIT HBJIHeTCH oKpalIlIlIoH 06JIaCTbIO oii:KYMeHbI, II II03TOMY IIa-
3BalIHbIe BbIme npOl(eCChI MOI'.'III npOTeKaTb TaM oc06eull0 aKTIIBIIO. KaKoe
6bI 1I3 3TlIX 06'bHCUeIIIIH IIII nplIuHTb, IIeCOMlIelIHO o)J;IIO - B AMepIIKe IIa
npoTH}JwIIIIII COTen nOROJIelIlIii: npOIICXOp,IfJIO Mep,JIelIIIOe IIanpaBJIelIlIOe II3Me-
HeHlIe KOII eIITpaJJ;IIII reua r II cpelIoTlIna rpynnhl O.
nplIBe)J;elIlIbIe nplIMepbI nOKa3bIBaIOT xapaKTep HBJIelIIIH, OTIIOCHm;IIXCH R
qJII31I0JIOrlIqeCROH )J;lIlIaMIIKe, o)J;IIaKO 01I1I )J;aJIeKO lIe IICqepnbIBaIOT IIocJIep,-
BIlX. Pa3IIOOUpa3HbIe IfCCJIe)J;oBaIIIIH CPIf3IfOJIOrHqeCKlIX oc06elIIIocTeH cOBpe-
1IfelIHbIX nonyJIH Ifii: BblHBIIJIII )J;OBOJIbIIO TeclIYIO CBH3b CTPYRTYPUhIX KOMno-
IIelITOB TeJIa (B nepBYIO Oqepe)J;b napaMeTpoB CKeJIeTa) C IIHTelICIIBIIOCTblD re-
MOIT03TlIqeCKOH (IfJIH KpOBeTBopHoii:) CPYIIK:qIIII, C cO)J;epmalIIfeM raMMa-rJI06y-
.:'IlfHOBOH 6eJIKOBOH cppaK IIH B ChlBopoTKe KpOBH, KOTopaH nO)J;)J;epmIIBaeT
I1M;VIYII0,'10rIIqecKyIO pe3I[CTeIITlIocTb, a TaKiRe C KOIIJJ;euTpaJJ;lIell MIlKp03JIe-
MelITOB B KOCTHOH TKalIlI. 8Ta CBH3b MOiReT 6bITb 3KCTpanOJIlIpOBalIa IIa Bpe-
lIfelIIIYIO )J;IfHaMIIKY q,If3IIOJIOrlIqeCKHX nplI3lIaKoB: B pa3JIlIqnbIX reorpacpuqe-
CRIIX pailollax no alIaJIOrlIU C MopcpOJIOrIIqeCRIfMII If3MeuelIIfHMIf MOiRlIO IIpep,-
HOJIaraTh IIanpaBJIelIlIbIe H3MelIelIlIH nepeqHCJIelIlIhlX CPlI31I0JIOrlIqeCKIIX
xapaKTepIfCTIIK.
CJIe.D:yeT nOp,qepKlIyTb, qTO CPlI3IIOJIOrlIqeCKlIe pa3.:'IlIqlIH MeiR)J;y nonY.JIH-
:l(IIHMII lIe Meuee IIOKa3aTeJIblIbI, qeM MOPCPOJIOrIIqeCKIf€. HanpIIMep, eCJIII
01I1I UpOHBJIHIOTCH B TaK IIa3hIBaeMbIX relIeTII'IeCKIIX MapKepax, T. e. cpII3IIO-
.JIOrIIqeCKIIX npII3IIaKaX C TOqlIO II3BeCTIIbIM TlInOM IIaCJIe)J;OBaIIHH, TO MorYT
)J;aTb )J;OBOJIbHO TOqlIOe npe)J;CTaB.rreIIIIe 0 relIeTIf IeCKIIX B3alIMOOTIIomelIJUJX
MeiR)J;y pa3JIIIqlIbIMlI uonyJIHU;IIHMIf; npOHBJIHHCb iRe B IfMMYIIOJIOrlIqeCKIIX
CBOHCTBax, 01I1I nOKa3bIBaIOT IIYTH a)J;anTaJJ;IIIf onpep,eJIelIlIbIX IIonYJIHl(IIH K
IIpHpO)J;IIOH cpe)J;e.
128
Borrpoc 0 Ha)),rrOnYJIH IIOlIlIbIX 06m;IIOCTHX, 06'be,ZJ;IlIIHeMbIX cplI31I0JIOrlIqe-
CRIIMII xapaKTepIICTIUWMIJ, BbI3BaJI )),JIlfTeJIbIIYIO )),IICKyCCllIO, KOTopaH rrpO)),OJI-
iRaeTCH )),0 ClIX nop. OTMeTII f 3HaqIfTeJIbHOe pacxom)J;elIIIe T01JeK 3pe1IIIH-
OT nOJIlIoro OTpm::t;alIlIH KaRIIX-JIlI60 CPH3IIOJIOrIIqeCKlIX cBoiicTB, xapaKTeplIbIX
)),JIH onpe)J;eJIelIlIhlX paCOBhIX 06m;HOCTeii, )),0 ypaBIIlIBaIlIIH CPlI31I0JIOrllqeCKIIX
II MOp!fJo.1JOrlIqeCKllX xapaKTeplICTIIK, BbI)),eJIeIIIIH CPH3HOJIOrlIqeCKIIX pac
II T. )J;. OJJ;HaKO yme ceiiqac COBepIIIeHHO HCIIO, qTO .B 6JIlI3RnX nonYJIHl(IIHX
BapIIa IIII MlIorlIX cpII3IIOJIOrH'IeCKlIX npII3IIaKOB IIe3IIaqlITeJIblIhI, II II03TOMY
3TlI )),alIlIbIe BIIOJIlIe nplIrO)),lIhI )),JIH BbI)),eJIeIIIIH paCOBbIX rrp1I31IaKOB. OTJIIIQIIe
CPII3IIOJIOrTIqeCRlIX nplI3HaKOB OT MOPCPOJIOrlI.qeCKIIX COCTOIIT JIHmb B TOM, qTO
OIIII lIe MorYT cpIIKCIIpOBaTbCH BIf3yaJIblIO (IIpOCTbIM rJIa30M, C nOMOm;LIO cpaB-
HIITeJIblIO 3JIeMelITaplIbIX IIIKaJI): IIa)J;nonYJIHl(IIOlIlIbIe 06m;HOCTII MorYT fihlTb
BhI)J;eJIelIbI cpII3IIOJIOrII'IeCKII JIIImL B JIa60paToplIbIX yCJIOBIIHX, B pe3YJIbTaTe
o6pa60TKlI c06paHIIbIX paHee i aUJIhIX.
OCIIOBIIOH lITOI' nouy.1JH IIOIIUhIX IICCJIep,OBaIIIIii (BR.'1IOqaH II CPH31I0,rlOrlI-
'-leCKlIe xapaKTepIICTllKII) - YCTalIOBJIelIlIe cpaKTa reorpacpIIqeCKOrO HeCOBna-
)),eIlIfH !fJII3IIOJIOrlIqeCKIIX II MOPCPOJIorIlqeCKIIX IIa.D:IIonYJIHI:t;IIOlIlIbIX 06m;IIo-
CTelI. nO,nOMY BIIOBb CTaJIa aKTyaJIbHOn 3a)J;a'la BbI)),eJIeIIHH caMOCTOHTeJIblIbIX
paCOBbIX 06m;IIOCTeH B COCTaBe COBpeMelIlIoro qeJIOBeqeCTBa, onpe)J,e.1Je-
IIIIH IIX relIeTlIqeCKIIX B3aIIMOOTHomeIIIIH. MlIorlIe )),eCHTllJIeTIIH IICCJIe)),OBaTe-
JIll B03.1JaraJIII IIeMaJIhIe Ha)),eiR)J;hI IIa TO, '1TO C IIOMOm;bIO )),IIcpcpepelII:t;IIpOBalI-
110m nO.D:xo)J;a K OT)J;eJIblIhIM nplI3IIaKaM MOa\IIO 6Y.D:eT nOCTpOlITh «IfepapXllIO
pac», pa3IIhIe 3TamII KOTOpoii CMorYT OTpa3HTb CJIOmlIhIe reorpacplIqeCKlIe
113aIIMOOTHomeHIIH MeiIqy OT;J,eJIblIbIMII npII3IIaRaMH. OAlIaKO ceiiqac CTarro-
BlITCH Bce 60JIee OqeBII;:t;HhIM, qTO TaKYIO lIepapxuIO nocTpOIITb IIeJIL3H. nOKa
BhlHBJIelIa reTeporelIlIocTb 60JIbIIIlIX pac no relIeTlIqeCKlIlIf MapKepaM. nOHB-
JIHeTCH Bce 60JIbIIIe oClIoBalIHH )J,JIH BhlBO)J,OB B nOJIb3Y ll)J;eII 0 )),HcKpeTlIocTII
nepB06hITHOII OlfRYMelIbI, 0 MHOiReCTBelIHOCTlI IICXO)J;IIbIX CTBOJIOB pacoBoii
)J,lIcpcpepelI IIa IIII, 0 TOM, '1TO ee IIeJIb3H CBeCTH JIHIIIh K )J;ByM-TpeM H )J,aiRe
K '1eTbIpeM-nHTH 60JILmIIM pacaM. TaKHM 06pa30M, CPII3IIOJIOrIIqeCKaH lllICPOp-
fal(IIH OqelIb YCJIOmlUIJIa pemelIlIe np06JIeMbI paCOBOH CTPYKTypbI qeJIOBe1Je-
CTBa, no O)J,IIOBpeMeIIHO ona me 3HaqlITeJIblIO OOOraTllJIa ee II cnaCJIa IIac OT
H3JIlIIIIIIeli CXeMaTIf'-II10CTII B peIIIelIIIH 3TOH TPYJJ;IIOH np06JIeMbI.
Hame 0603peUIIe cpYII)J,aMeIITaJIblIbIX IIp06JIeM IICTOplIqeCKOH aIITpOIIOJIO-
rlIlI 6Y)J,eT IIenOJIlIhIM, eCJIII lIe CKa3aTb HeCKOJIbKO CJIOB 0 ae tOzpafjjU'ieCKOU
f}unaMuKe 'ie.fl,Oee'ieCTea. ;:ho OCHOBIIOii IIpe)),MeT 1I3yqelIlIH oc060ii IIayqHOn
..1.lIC IUIJIIIHhI - naJIeO)J,eMorpacpIIII. B CBOIIX II3bICKalIlIHX naJIeO)J,eMorpacpHH
'IaCTIIqIIO onnpaeTCH Ha JJ:alIHhIe rrHCbMelIlIbIx IICTOqHllKOB, 110 rrpH peKOIICT-
pyKl(IIII )J,eMorpacpHqeCKIIX napaMeTpOB HaCeJIelIHH )J;OIIIICbMeIIJIhIX 3IIOX IICTO-
plIlI qeJIOBeqeCTBa olla rrCnOJIb3yeT naJIeOaIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIll MaTeplIaJI H B
3TOH cBoeii '1aCTII CTbfRyeTcH C IICTOprrqeCKOH allTpOnOJIOrnelI.
IIaJIeOalITpono.TIOrlIqeCKOe lICCJIe)J;OBalIlIe He MOllieT .D:aTb TO'lHhIe OCIIOBa-
HIIH )J;JIH onpe)J;eJIeHIIH qIICJIelIlIOCTII B pa3JIllqlIhle IICTOpIIqeCKHe IIepnO)J;bI OT-
.:reJIblIhlX qeJIOBeqeCKlIX ROJIJIeKTIIBOB II qeJIOBeqeCTBa B I:t;eJIOM; 3Tll BbIBO)J,bI
OCHOBhlBaIOTCH lIa naJIe03KOJIOrrrqeCRlIX paCqeTaX II KOCBelIHhIX C006paiRelIlI-
HX. 3aTO naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIH MaTeplIaJI He3aMeIlIIM npH peKOIICTpYK-
1I1I1I )J,pyrlIx JJ:eMorpacpIIqeCKllX IIapaMeTpOB - ypOBHH )J;eTCKoii CMepTIIOCTII,
rrpO)J,o.TIiRHTeJIbIIOCTlI iR1I31IIf, qaCTOThI CMeHbI nOROJIeHIIH II To )),. Ha OCIIOBe
<lTOrO MaTepIIaJIa YiRe ceiiqac MOiRlIO C)J,eJIaTb )J,Ba BamlIbIX BhIBO)J,a. nepBbIH
1I3 IIIIX COCTOIIT B TOM, qTO mlIpOKO paClIpOCTpalIeJIHoe pallee MlIelIlIe 0 no-
CTerrelIlIOM yBeJIIIqelIlIH rrpOD;om-KIITeJIbIIOCTH mII3IIH JIIO)J,eli Ha rrpOTHj-KelIllH
rrCToplUI lIe COOTBeTcTByeT 3MnIIplIqeCKlIM IIa6JIIO)),eIIIIHM. Y CTaIIOBJIeIIO, qTO
.JJIHTeJIbIIOCTb iRlI31I1I O)),Horo nOKOJIelIlIH rrpll6JIH3IITeJIblI0 paBlIa 25 ro)),aM;
5 B. n. AJICRCCCB
129
TaKOM OHa coxpaHHeTCH OT nepB06bITIIOCTH O 3noxII cpep:neBeKOBbH. A 3TO
03IIaqaeT, IIanplIMep, 'ITO, Bo-nepBbIX, TaR Ha3hIBaeMaH HeOJIIITlIqeCKaJI peBO-
JIIOl(IfJI, C KOTOpOM IfCCJIe)),OBaTeJIH pallee Tpap:II HOIIIIO CBJI3bIBaJIII If3MeHelIIfe
OCIIOBlIhIX )J;eMorpacpH<IeCRIIX IIapaMeTpOB, IIa caMOM )),eJIe lIe OKa3aJIa CROJIbKO-
IIIf6YP:b Om;YTIfllwro BJIIIJIIIIIJI IIa yBeJIIfqelIIIe npO)),OJImIITeJIbIIOCTH mII3HH,
'ITO, BO-BTOphIX, pOCT 06m;eH qIfCJIeIIIIOCTII IIaCeJIelIlIH 3eMJIH BnJIOTb )),0 3nOXII
cpep:IIeBeI{OBbJI npoIIcxo)),IfJI JIIIillb 3a CqeT YMelIbillelIIIJI )J;eTCKOM cMepTHocTH.
BTOpOH BbIBO)J; RaCaeTCJI COOTHOmelIlIJI npo)),OJIiRIITeJIbIIOCTII mH3HII MymqHH
II melIm;lIlI. BhfJIClIelIO, qTO BO Bce npep:illecTByIOm;Ife 3nOXII B OTJIIfqIIe OT
cOBpeMelIlIocTII MymqIfHbI 6bIJIlI HeCKOJIbKO )J;OJIrOBeqlIee melIm;IIH. 8TO, 110-
BII)J;IIMOMY, 06'hJICIIJIeTCJI KaK pa3HbIM IIOJI01KelIlIeM MymqIfII II me IIH B XO-
3JIMCTBe (rJIaBlIbIM 06pa30M TeM, qTO melIm;lIlIhI IIOCTOJIIIIIO npe6bIBaJIII B aHTIf-
caIIIITaplIbIx yCJIOBHJIX )J;peBlIlIx IIOCeJIKOB), TaK II onaClIbIMII OCJIOmlIeIIIIJIMIf,
conpoBomp:aBillHMIf p:eTOpOiRp:eHlIe, C KOTOpbIMII B CBoe BpeMJI lIe MOrJIII 60-
POTbCJI.
IhaK, MopcpOJIOrIIqeCKaH p:IIlIaMHKa 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa, WlCPcpepelIJJ;HaJJ;IIJI II HH-
Terpa IIJI qeJIOBeqeCKIIX nonYJIJI IfH no MopcpOJIOrIfqeCKIIM npII3IIaKaM, CPIf-
3IIOJIOrHqeCKaJI p:lIlIaMIfKa, )),IIcpcpepelI:qHa IfJI H HIITerpa:qIIJI nonYJIJI IIH no
CPlI3IIOJIOrlIqeCKIIM IIpII3HaKaM, p:eMorpacpIfqeCRaH )J;IfIIaMIfKa 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa-
BOT Te CPYII)J;aMeIITaJIbHbIe np06JIe1IbI IfCTOplI<IeCROH aIITpOnOJIOrIfII, 6e3 YC-
nemlIOH pa3pa60TKH KOTOpbIX IIeB03MOmlI0 )),OCTaTOqIIO nOJIHO peillIITh MIIO-
rIle HCTOplI'IeCKlIe Up06JIeMbI.
B 3aKJII01JeIIHe IIeJIb3JI He CKa3aTb, 'ITO HCCJIe)J;OBaTeJIbCKIfe YCIIJIIfJI, IIal(e-
JIelIHbIe IIa pa3peillelIlIe Bcex 3TIfX np06JIeM, pa36pocalIhI no MIIOrlIM yqpem-
p:eIIIIJIM. 06 aKap:eMlIqeCKIfX IIIICTHTYTax YiRe ynOMlIlIaJIOCb BbIme, 60JIbIIlaJr
pa60Ta rrpOBop:lfJIaCb II npOBO)),IITCJI B MHcTIITYTe aHTpOnOJIOrlI1I II IIa Kacpe)),-
pe alITpOnOJIOr1I1I MOCKoBcKoro YIIIfBepcrrTeTa, 3alIlIMaIOTCJI :nOH TeMaTIIKOH
H MlIorIfe reHeTIfqeCKlIe JIa60paTopHIf. 0 nOJIb3e Koop)),lIlIa 1I1I COBeTCKHX IIC-
cJIep:onalIIfH B 3TOH 06JIaCTIf, KaK If 0 60JIee TeCIIOH CBJI31I IIX C COOTBeTCT-
BYIOm;HMII IfCCJIep:OBaHIIJIMII 3a Py6eiROM, oc06eHIIo B C0JJ;lIaJIIICTIfqeCKIIX CTpa-
IIax, lIe UPHXOP:IITCJI rOBopHTb, H II03TOMY IIa3peBmeH 3a)J;aqeM 6bfJIO 6bI
C03p:a1IHe KaKorO-TO Koop)J;IIlIaJJ;IIOHlIoro JJ;elITpa B BH)),e COBeTa no IICTOplIqe-
CRIfM rrp06JIeMaM alITpOIIOJIOrlIqeCROH HaYKH B CIfCTeMe AKa)),eMIIIf IIayK
CCCP.
! Map,;c K., 31i2e.nbC (]J. CO'l. 2-e 1I3}J;. T. 21. C. 25-26.
2 CM.: A.ne,;ceeB B. n. IlorrYJIHl\lIoHHaJJ CTpYKTypa '1eJIOBe'leCTB3 II IICTOplI'IeCKafI
aHTpOrrOJIOrlIH II COB. apXeOJWrIIH. 1970. oM 3; 01i :!ICe. I1cToplI'IecKaH aHTpOIIOJIOrIIH.
M., 1979.
qaCTII'IHO pe3yJIbTaTbI 3TOM: paooTbI oCBeIl:\eHbI B IIYOJIIIKal\IIHx: A68Yllte.nUlltBU-
.nu M. r. 0 COBMeCTHbIX cOBeTCKU-IIH}J;IIM:CKliX aHTpOrrOJIOI'II'IeCKIIX IICCJIe}J;oBaHIIHx
(KaJ\lIIaHIIH 1971 r.) /1 BecTH. AH CCCP. 1972. oM 1; HOBbIe }J;aHHbIC K aHTpOIIOJIOl'IIII
CeBepHoii IIH,I1I1I1. Pe3YJIbTRTbI COBe'fCIW-IIH}J;lIfICKIIX IICCJIep;OBaHIIM: 1971 r. M., 1980;
A68Yllte.nUlltBu.nU M. r., A.nenceeB B. n., ApYTWlLOB C. A., Ce.Malltno If. M. COBJ\IeCT-
HbIC cOBeTCKO-IIH}J;IIM:CmIC aHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCKIIe IICCJIe}J;OBaHIIH B IlH}J;1I1I B 1974--
1975 rr. II COB. 3THOrpacPIIH. 1976. oM 6.
I
f30
$'
-
8BOJIIOIJ;110HHhIE ACIIEKThI
AHTPOIIOJIOrMli PEBHErO HACEJIEHMH
IIOCTAIIOBRA BOIIPOCA
Up06JIeMa SBOJIIOl(HH COBpeMeHlIoro qeJIOBeKa 3aHHMaeT B HaYKe cerO,ZJ;HHm-
:nero ,ZJ;IIH qpe3BbllJaHHO cBoe06pa3Hoe 1I0JIOiRe1IIIe. C O.D:IIOH CTOpOlIbI, OqeBII-
)J,eH ee BbI,ZJ;aIOm;HHCH TeOpeTIIqeCKIIH II npaKTII'leCfiIIH HHTepec, C ,ll,PyroH-
MHorHe HCCJIe,ll,OBaTe.'IH CqIITaIOT STY np06JIeMY MIIHIIWH, a xapaKTepHblH AmI
Homo sapiens IWlIfnJIeKC npH3HaKoB cTa6H.JIblIhIM II BhIme,ZJ;mHM H3-nO)];
..KOHTpOJIH 3BOJIIOI\HOHlIbIX 3alwHoMepHocTeH. npOTIIBOnOJImKlIOCTb nO,ll,XO.D:OB
onpe,ZJ;e.JIfleT, eCTeCTHelIHO, II OCTPOTY .D:IlCKYCCHII.
IIepeopHenTHpoBKa BIIHMaHHH cOBpeMelIlIoH IIaYKH Ha BIIYTPIIBII,ZJ;OBYIO
)];HHaMHRY Bhl3BaJIa K 1I\H3IIH KOMnJIeKC BonpocoB, 06'be,ZJ;HIIHeMhIx nOHHTHeM;
lIfHI{P03BOJIIOl(HII. l-\:aK H3BeCTHO, qaCTO MHKpOSBOJIIOl(Hfl npoTIIBonOCTaBJIHeT-
CH l\laKpOSBOJIIOI IIII, T. e. ::JBOJIIOIUIH B Tpa,ll,Ill(HolIHO 1 CMhICJIe - U3MeHeHIIHlIf
IIa)J;BH.D:OBOrO ypOBIIH. He BXO,ZJ;H B cym;ecTBo ,ll,HCKYCCHII, OTllfeqy )J;Ba MO-
MeHTa:
a) IIeCOnOCTaBHMOCTh lIfacmTa60B H pe3YJIbTaTOB MHKpO- II MaKpOaBOJIIO-
l(HH, B03MomlIoe npOHBJIelIHe B TOH H ,ZJ;PyroH pa3HhIX 3aKOHOMeplIOCTeH IWII
pa3JIHqlIOR HIITeHCHBIIOCTH ,ll,eHCTBHH O,ZJ;IIHX H Tex lIW 3aJ\OHoMepHocTelI;
6) pa3BepThIBalIIIe SBOJIIO:qHOHHoro npOl(ecca IIa 6a3e lIfHKpOSBOJIIOl(HOII-
HhIX nepeCTpOeK. BTopoe 06CTOHTeJIhCTBO BonpeRII nepBOMY n03BOJIHeT CqII-
TaTb BIIYTPIIBH,ZJ;OBYIO ,ZJ;IUIaMHRY SBO.JIIOl(HOHnoH, qeM H onpe)J;eJIHIOTCH IIa-
3BaHIIe II TeMa pa3)];eJIa.
B IIeM nOH,ZJ;eT peqb JIIImb 0 Tex H3l1felIe1IHHX, ROTOphIe npOIICXO)J;HJIlI B
paMKax BH)];a COBpeMeHHoro qe.JIOBeRa, T. e. B paMKax MHRpOSBO.JIIOl(HII Homo
sapiens. Ha)];IJH)];OBaH TaKCOIIOllfHH H ,ll,HlIaMHKa rOMHIUI,ZJ;, npol(ecc alITponore-
IIe3a B u;eJIOM, B TOM qHCJIe H np06JIeMa npOHcxom)J;elIHH COBpeMeHlIoro qeJIO-
BeKa, BhIXOJ\HT 3a npe,ll,eJIbI MHKpOSBOJIIOl(HH B Y3KOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa. Olla
OXBa TblBaeT yqeT H3l1fenelIHH pa3Maxa H3MelIqHBOCTII npII3HaKoB BO B pellfelIII,
T. e. ,ll,HlIaMHKy BII,ZJ;OBOH H3MelIqHBOCTH, H3yqelIHe rJIy6HIIhI BHYTpHBlmOBOH
J;IIcpcpepelIl(Hal(HH, T. e. cnel(HcpIIKII qeJIOBeqeCKHX nonYJIHl(HH, CTPYKTYPY
RIIYTPHBH.iJ:OBOH II3MenqIIBOCTIf, T. e. TaKCOHOMIIqeCROe npoCTpaHCTBo qeJIO-
BeqeCKOrO BII,ll,a, HanpaBJIeHlIhIe H3MelIelIHH npH3IIaKOB BO BpeMeHH, HaKolIe:q,
BlIellIHIIe BH,ll,OBhIe II BIIYTpeHHIIe IIonYJIHl(HOHnO-CeJIeKTIIBHhIe II MYTaI\IIOII-
IIhIe cpaKTophl Bcex STIIX H3MeHeIIIIR.
OCHOBHbIM IICTOqlIIlKOM CBe,ll,eIIIIH no STHM BonpocaM HBJIHeTCH naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKHH MaTepHa.JI. Ero peRoIICTpYKTI:TBlIbIe B03MOiRIIOCTII Tpe6y-
lOT Cnel(HaJIbHOrO OCBem;eIIIIH II nOTOMY OCTaBJIeHhI 3a npe,ll,eJIaMH H3JIOiRe-
HHH. npH nepeXo)];e K COBpeMelIlIOH snoxe MOffiHO npHB.JIeqL COMaTO-
JIOrHqeCKHe ,ll,alIlIhIe, 1I0 conOCTaBJIelIHe HK C naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKIIMII
3aTpY,ZJ;lIeno. relIoreorpacpHqeCKaH HlIcpopMal(HH lIe HMeeT npHMOH BpeMeHIlOH
nepcneKTHBbI, H nOSTOMY Bce reHoxpOIIO.JIOrHqeCKlIe C006paiRelIIIH lIe BbIXO-
,ZJ;HT 3a npe,ZJ;eJIbI 60JIee IIJIH Mellee npaB,ZJ;ono,ZJ;06IIbIX rIInOTea.
P A3MAX BIInOBon II3MEHQIIBOCTII
Pa3Max H3MelI IHBOCTH xapaKTeplIhlX ,ll,JIH BII,ZJ;a npH3HaKOB 3aBHCIIT OT npe)J;-
mecTBYIOm;eH ero HCTOpHH, llIHpOThI apeaJIa, ,ZJ;HcnepCIIOCTH SKOJIOrHqeCKOn
HHmH HJIH cOBoKynIlocTH SKOJIOrHqeCKHX IIIlm, MIIOrOqIICJIelIlIOCTII 06pa3YIO-
'1l1;IIX BII)J; nonYJIJI:qHH. COBpellfeHlIoe qeJIOBeqeCTBO IIlIfeeT ,ZJ;JIHTeJIbIIYIO H
131
5*
Ta6JIHn;a 1
Pa3Max H3MeH'IHJlOCTH npH3HaKoB y '1eJIOBeKa H MJIeKOIIHTaIOID;HX *
E
COBpeMeHHhIM 'IeJIOBeK BYPbIM Me):\Be):\h BponeHCKHlI KpOT
,0 '0<:"
0'
.9i - -
<:I <:I
IIpH3HaK min-max sr min-max S min-max 's .9
I';; I 's I
:::: 8
'" '" '"
S S S
l\1ymcKHe '1epena
ITonepe'lHblii: 1\HaMeTp 126,1-152,6 21,0 134,0-174,0 29,9 15,9-17,3 8.8
'1epenHoii: Kopo6KH
]J;JIIIHa OCHOBanlIH 90,5-107,6 18,,9 273,0-357,5 31,0 28,4-32,0 12,7
JIHn;a
" CKYJIOBaH ffiHpHHa 121,2-146,3 20.7 187,9-249,8 32,9 11,2-12,3 9.8
meHcKHe '1epena
ITonepe'lHbIii: 1\HaMeTp 124,0-145,0 16,9 103,0-153,5 49,0 15,7-17,2 9,6
'1epenHoii: Kopo6KII
]J;JIHHa OCHOBanlIH 87,2-101,0 15,8 237.0-292,6 23,5 27,3-30,7 12,5
JIHn;a
CKYJIOBaH mlIplIHa 114,4-138,0 20,6 147,0-192,0 30,6 11,0-12,5 13,6
* )J;aHHhIe no MJIeKOnHTaIOlI\HM B3RThI H3 hH. Oenee C. H. 3BepH BOCTO'lHOM EBponbI H CeBepHoi\:
A3HH. M.; JI., 1928-1931. T. I-II.
i.
,
,!
CJIOiRHYIO npe)J;meCTBYIOm;yIO HCTOpHIO, OXBaTbIBaeT B CBOellf paCrrpOCTpaHelIHH
BCIO 3eMJIIO H mIIBeT rr08TOllfY rrOqTH BO BCeX IIa3eMHbIX 8KO.JIOrHqeCKllX IIH-
max, rrpe,ll,CTaBJIeHlIbIX IIa nJIalI€Te, COCTOHT H3 lIfHorHX TbICHq, a lIfomeT
6hITb, H )J;eCHTKOB TbICHq rronYJIH:qHn.
Bce 8TH 06CTOHTeJIhCTBa ,ll,OJImlIbI BhI3bIBaTb HHTelICHBIIYIO H3MeHqIfBOCTI>
H, CJIe,ll,OBaTeJIhHO, 60.JIhrnyIO allfrrJIHTYAY KOJIe6alIHH OT)J;eJI'bHbIX npH3IIaKOB.
AJIH npOBepRH 8Toro npe)J;IlOJIOmeIIHH pa3Max H3l1felIqHBOCTH COBpeMelIlIorv
qeJIOBeKa conOCTaBJJeII no rOMOJIOrHqlIbIM npH3IIaRaM C H3MelIqHBOCThIO MJJe.
RonHTaIOm;HX (Ta6JI. 1). gJIH corrOCTaBJIeHHH HCrrOJIb30BalIbI .D:alIlIbIe no H3,
MelIqHBOCTH qeperra, TaR RaK, Bo-rrepBbIX, OH Hcc.JIe,ll,OBaII JIyqrne, 'IeM OCTaJIb-
IIOH CKeJIeT, BO-BTOPhIX, 011 pa3BHBaeTCH Y Bcex MJIeJ{orrHTaIOm;HX rro 60JIe(
HJIH Mellee CXO)J;HOMY nYTH, rr08TOMY B ero ?tlOpcpOJIOrHH MelILrne OTpamaeTCJI
IIeO)J;HHaKOBaH H3MelIqHBOCTh O)J;IIOHMeIIHhIX npH3IIaIWB Y npe)J;CTaBHTeJIell
pa3IIhIX BH)J;OB. B 06m;eM BH)J;IIO, qTO COBpeMelIlIhIH qeJIOBeK OTJIHqaeTCH BbI-
COKHM ypOBlIellf H3l1feHqIfBOCTH B pHAY MJIeKOrrHTaIOm;HX.
OTMe'IeHllbIe npHqHlIhl BbICOIWH BapIIa6e.JIbIIOCTH rrpH3IIaROB COBpeMeIIIIO-
1'0 BH,ZJ;a qeJIOBeKa II3MeIIHJIHCb B HIITelICIIBHOCTH CBoero ,ll,eHCTBHH IIa npOTH-
melIHH HCTOpHH qeJIOBeqeCTBa. IIJIom;aD:b rrepB06bITHOH OHKYlIfeHbI CRaKHYJJa
B BeJIHqIfHe B nepIIO,ZJ; OT BepXlIero rraJIeOJIHTa ,ll,0 HeOJIHTa, HMeHIIO 3a 8TO
BpeMH 6bI;J.[a OCBoelIa npaRTHqeCKH BCH nJIaHeTa, HO TeMrrhI OCBoeHHH TPYD:IIO-
,ZJ;ocTynlIbIx 3KOJIOrHqeCKJfX HIlrn, KOHeqIIO, nOCTOHlIlIO B03paCTaJIH no Mepe
pa3BIITHH npOH3BO)J;I1TeJIhlIhIX ClIJI H pOCTa TeXHUqeCKHX B03MOiRrrDCTeH.
llHCJIO qeJIOBeqeCKHX rronYJIH:qHH 3HaqIUeJIblIO B03pOCJIO B xOD:e HCTOpHH.
113 orpOMIIOll naJIeO)J;eMorpacpHqeCKOH JIHTepaTyphI BblTeKaeT HeorrpOBepmn-
lifO, 'ITO qIICJIeHIIOCTb qeJIOBeqeCTBa YBeJIHqHJIaCh, HaqHHaH C IIIImlIero rra-
JIeOJIIITa, MHIIIIMYM B ThICHqy pa3. napaJIJIeJIhHO pa3BHBaJIaC'b TelI,ZJ;eHl(HH K
YBeJIHqelIHIO rronYJIH:qHH 3a CqeT ,ll,eHCTBHH IIHTerpaTIIBHhIX MexaIIH3MOB, no-
II
. :
132
CTenelIIIO YCHJIHBaBrnHXCH B n03)J;IIIIe 3nOXH IICTOpHH qeJIOBeqeCTBa no
cpaBHelIHIO C paIIIIHMII.
C ,ZJ;pyroH CTOpOHhI, .D:OCTaTOqIIO lIfOm;HbIe relIeTIIqeCKHe 6apbepbI npo)J;OJI-
maIOT aKTHBIIO .D:eHCTBOBaTh II B COBpellfelIHYIO snoxy. OP:HU H3 IIHX - no-
JIIITIIqeCKHe rpalIH:qhI - cpaRTOp, HBIIO YCHJIIIBaIOm;HHCH B CBoeM )J;eRCTBIIH C
snOXH cpe,ll,ueBeROBbH. fImTOMY, XOTH nO.D:CqeTOB qHCJIa .D:peBIIHX nonYJIH Hii
B pa3IIhIe 3nOXII, B TOM qHCJIe H B COBpellfeHIIYIO, nORa He npOH3Be)J;eII0, HeT
OCHOBalIHH nOJIara Th, qTO Mem,ll,Y qHCJIOM nonyJIH Hii II qHCJIeHIIOCThIO qeJIO-
BeqeCTBa coxpalIHeTCH nOCTOHlIlIoe COOTHOilleHne. B03pocrnee B npe,ZJ;eJIax qe-
JIOBeqeCTBa qHCJIO nonyJIH:qHH HBJIHeTCH O)J;Hon H3 llpIIqHII relIernqeCROrO
pa3Ho06pa3HH.
Ha paHHHX STanax qeJIOEeqeCKOH HCTOpIIII HaJIHqHe relIeTIIqeCKOrO 6aph-
epa Mem)J;Y nonyJIH:qHHMII Bcer,ZJ;a HJIH nOqTIf Bcer,J,a npHBO,ZJ;H.rro R )J;eRCTBHIO
eHTp06eiRlIbIX, II TOJIhRO :qeIITp06emlIbIX, CIIJI. B COBpeMeHIIYIO SIIOXY TaKaH
cIITyal(HH COCTaBJJHeT HCKJIIOqelIHe II coxpaHHeTCH JIIfrnh B TPY.D: IIO )J;OCTynlIhIx
paHOHax. B nO)J;aBJIHIOm;eM me 60JIbillHHCTBe CJIyqaeB pa3,ZJ;eJIelIlIbIe reHeTIIqe-
CKIIlIf 6apbepOM nonYJIH IIII BXO,ZJ;HT B rpalIH:qbI 60JIee illHpOKOH 06m;IIOCTH,
H nOSTOllfY B HIIX HapHAY C :qelITp06emlIhIMH nOCTOHIIHO pa60TaIOT H eIITpo-
CTpeMIITeJIblIhIe TelI,ZJ;elI:qlill. qIICJIO reneTHqeCKHX 6apbepoB pa3HOI'O YPOBHH
lIfOiReT 6bITb B OT)J;eJIblIbIX CJIyqaHx )J;OBOJIbIIO 60JIbillHlIf, 3THM nonyJIHl(HOII-
IIaH CTpYKTypa COBpeMeHlIoro qeJIOBeqeCTBa IICRJIIOqHTeJIblIO YCJIOiRIIHeTCH.
CJIe,ll,OBaTeJIbHO, HepapXIIqeCKaH CIICTeMa nonyJIH IIH, KOTopaH II COCTaBJIHeT
qeJIOBeqeCTBO KaK :qeJIoe IIa RaiR,ZJ;OM oTpe3Ke ero IICTOpIIH, IIa ypOBlIe RaiR-
)J;oro CHlIxpOIIHoro cpe3a, IIenpepbIBHO 060ram;a.rracb aJIBlIfeHTaMH, qTO TOiRe
cnoc06CTBOBaJIO relIeTHqeCROMY pa3IIo06pa3HIO.
nOCJIe Bcero CKa3alIIIoro OqeBH,ZJ;IIO, KaR TpY,J,HO HIITepnpeTIIpOBaTb )J;aH-
IIhIe 0 pa3Maxe H3MeHqHEOcrn B pa3HhIe 3nOXII O)J;II03IIaqlIbIM 06pa30llf
(Ta6Jl. 2). It STOllfY npIIMeillHBaeTCH IIepaBIIOMeplIaH naJIeOalITpOnOJIOrIIqe-
CKaH II3yqeHHOCTh 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa no snoxallf. Bce me no OCIIOBlIbIM npII3Ha-
RaM, ROTopbIe 06bI'I1I0 npe,ZJ;CTaBJIelIbI B nporpaMMax KpalIHOJIOrIIqeCRHX pa-
60T, He3aMeTII0 RaRHX-JIH60 3aKOlIOMeplIhIX H3MelIelIHM B pa3Maxe II3MelI'IH-
FOCTH, CYiRelIHH HJIH, IIa060pOT, pacrnHpelIHH aMnJIIITY,ll,bI ROJIe6aIIIIM.
AJ\fIIJIIITY)J;a He OCTaeTCH, KOHeqHO, nOCTOHIIIIOH, 110 IIeT HIIKaRHX JJ:ORa3a-
TeJIbCTB TOMY, qTO ee H3MelIenHH no snoxaM He HBJIHIOTCH CJIyqaHlIbIMH II
B TOR lIfepe, B KaROM OIIH OTpaiRaIOTCH B HMeIOm;HXCH )J;aIIHhIX, lIe onpe)J;e-
JIHIOTCH em;e xapaKTepOM BhI60pRH.
OTIIOCHTeJIbHOe nOCTOHIICTBO pa3Maxa BII)J;OBOH II3MelIqHBOCTH no RpaIIIIO-
JIOrH'IeCKHM npII3HaRaM, )J;OCTynlIbIM AJIH aHaJIH3a, naXO;:J:IITCH B COrJIaCIIH C
illHpORO pacnpOCTpaHelIlIhIlIf npe,ZJ;CTaBJIelIHeM 0 cTa6HJIhlIOCTII BH.D:a Homo
sapiens. Ho TaRoe nOCTOHIICTBO IIa nepBblH B3rJIH)J; BCTynaeT B npoTHBope-
qHe C IIeCOlIurelIlIO peaJIblIO cym;ecTBYIOm;HMII II IIeo)J;HoKpaTlIo HCCJIe)J;OB8II-
IIhIMH HBJIeIIIIH:\fH H3l1felIelIHH npII3uaKoB BO EpeM€IIH. PacnpocTpalIelIHYIO
rHnOTe3Y, corJIaCIIO ROTOpOH HanpaBJIelIHble H3:\IeIIBIIIIH no OT)J;eJIblIhIlIf
npH3IIaRallf HOCHT nalIoHRYlIfelIlIhIH xapaKTep \ TPY,ZJ;IIO COrJIaCOBaTb C SlIf-
nHpIIqeCRHM IIa6JIIO)J;eHIIeM 0 HelIanpaBJIelIlIOCTII KOJIe6armR pa3l1faXa MeiR-
rpynnoBoH H3MeHqHBOCTU B npe)J;eJIax BH,ZJ;a OT 3nOXH R snoxe. ECJIH 6bI 3Ta
KOII:qen IIH 6bI.rra cnpaBe)J;JIHBa, CJIe,ZJ;oBaJIO 6bI OiRH)J;aTb onpe,ZJ;eJIeHIIOro CABII-
ra lIe TOJIbRO B MUPOBhlX cpe,ZJ;IIIIX, 110 II B npe)J;eJIax MeiRrpynnoBhIx ROJIe-
6a.IIHH.
HanpoTHB, npIIIIHB' rIInoTe3Y JIOKaJIblIOCTH JlI06bIX IIanpaBJIelIlIbIX H3Me-
HeIIHR, JIerRO nOHHTb coxpalIelIHe OTIIOCHTeJIbHOrO nOCTOHIICTBa Memrpynno-
BOH allfnJIHTY)J;h1. B npo ecce IIanpaBJIeHlIblX H3l1felIeHHH npoIIcxo)J;HT 3aMem;e-
HHe pacoBbIx BapHaIITOJ3 C onpe)J;eJIeHlIbIlIfH lIfopcpOJIOrIIqeCKHMH xapaK-
133
'l'a6JIHn;a 2
Pa3l\JaX 1I3MeH'IIIBOCTII nplI3HaRoB y cOBpeMeHHOI'O '1eJIOBeRa B pa3HbJe anoxlI.
l\1ymcRlIe '1epena
IIpH3HaR
I H I 3noxa paH- 1 3nOxa CpeA- ! XIX - Haqa-
MeSOJIHT 3no JI ;O:SbI Hero 3,:e:1e- HeReROBbH JIO XX B.
1. IIpOP;OJIbHLIH AlIa- 181,8-197"5 177,7-197,7 174,3-194..7 172,0-195,0 164,3-191.3
J\IeTp
8. lIorrepe'lHbIH AHa- 133,6-146,1 134,0-155,3 132,4-157,4 135,4-153,3 126,1-152,6
MeTp
17. BbICOTHbIH AHa- 134,8-144,0 127,4-149,1 129,5-143,7 127,5-142,6 123,4-146,9
J\IeTp OT 6a3IIOHa
45. CKYJIOBaH mnplI- 124,2-150,0 126,0-153,5 123,6-144,7 128,5-144,5 121,2-146,3
Ha
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa 63,6-75,5 64,9-80,0 66,7-77,2 69,0-77,8 61,4-82,5
JIJiIn;a
TepIICTIIRaMH )J;pyrHMH, qTO C)J;BHraeT 06m;He cpe)J;IIHe, HO 3TO 3aMem;elIHe
OrpalIHqeHO TeppIITopHeH 60JJbrneH HJIH MelIbllieH nJIOm;a)J;H. Ha IIIIOH TeppH-
TOpIIIf npo ecc H,ll,eT rrO-D;pyrOMY HJIH .D:aiRe B 06paTIIOM IIarrpaBJIelIHH
(6paXHKecpaJIH3al HH - .D:OJIHXORecpaJIH3al(HH, rpa:qHJIII3a:qI'[H - MaTypH3al(Ha
I'[ T. .D:.), B pe3YJIbTaTe qero H )J;OCTIIraeTCH paBHOBeCHe. BMeCTO O,ll,IIOlIarrpaB-
JIelIlIoro MOpcpOJIOrHqeCKOrO C)J;BHra B xapaKTepHCTHKe paCOBhlX BapHIITOB H
H3MelIelIHH 06m;eBH)J;OBhlX cpe)J;Hnx npOHCXO I'[T nOCTOHIIHO rrepepacrrpe)J;eJIe-
HHe 3TIIX BapIIalITOB BnyTpII cTa6H.lIblIbIX BH.D:OBhIX rpaHHl( H3l1felIqHBOCTH.
CTEIIEHb l\10PcOOJIOrWIECROn CIIEI1IIcI>IIQHOCTII
nOIIYJIHl1IIfi
Bce npe)1llieCTBYIOm;ee 3aROHOMepHO rrO.D:BO)J;HT Hac R cpYII)J;aMeIITaJIbIIOllfY
Borrpocy qeJIOBeqeCKOH MHKp03BOJIIO HII - rJIy6HHe )J;HcpcpepeH:qHa:qHH qeJIO-
BeqeCKOrO BH,ZJ;a, ROTopaH TOJIbKO H MOmeT 6bITb aD,eKBaTIIO o elIeHa He B
CHHXpOIIIIOM, a B )J;HaxpOHIIOM IIJIalIe. Borrpoc 3TOT CTOHf Ha rpaHH TaKCOIIO-
lIfHH H yqelIIIH 0 MHKp03BO.lIIOIJ:HH, O)1HHaKOBO BaiReII rr03ToMy KaK .D:.ITH 3BO-
JIIO HOIIHoro cpHJIOreHeTHqeCKOrO nO)J;xo)J;a K )J;HlIaMIIKe Homo sapiens, TaK If
JIH BhIHClIelIHH relIeaJIOrHqeCKIIX oTlIornelIHH pacoBblx KOllfII.'IeKCOB.
,[1;0 IIe.D:aBlIerO HpeMelIII e)J;HHCTBeIIIIhlM crroc060llf Ol(emHI B3aHMIIbIX pac-
CTOHIIHII MeiR)J;y norrYJIH:qHHMH H rpynrrallfII norrYJIHl(HH 6blJI0 onpe.D:eJIeHHe
3TH X paCCTOHIIHH (<lIa rJIa301\». AIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKaH JIHTepaTypa 3arrOJIIIelIa
BbIBO)J;aMH 0 6JIH30CTH Tex H.ITH HlIhIX paCOBbIX rpyrrn lIfem)J;y C060H, OCHOBaH-
HhIMH Ha MOpcpOcpH3HOJIOrHqeCKHX, a qam;e Bcero IIa MOPCPOJIOrHqeCKHX )J;alI-
HbIX. Ha 6a3e npe)J;CTaBJIeIIHH 0 IIeO.D:HlIaKOBOH 6JIH30CTH )J;pyr R )J;pyry rro-
rry.ITH HII H paChI 06'beD,HIIHIOTCH B 60JIee BhICOKHe TaKCOIIOMHqeCKHe KaTero-
pHH. He COCTaBJIHIOT HCKJIIOqeHHH H TaK IIa3bIBaeMbIe 60.ITblliIIe pachI, .D:JIH
ROTOpbIX BbI.D:BHUYTbI MHOrOqHCJIelIHbIe H rrpHMO rrpOTHBono.ITOIKlIhIe rHnOTe3bI
HX 06'be)J;IIlIelIlfH.
RaKoBa 3BpHCTHqeCRaH u;eIIIIOCTb TaKoro rro)J;xo,ll,a? He OTpH aH HHTYH-
TIIBlIbIX Ol(eHOK, JIeiRam;HX B ero OCIIOBaIIHH, oc06eHHo IwrD,a OIIH rrpOH3-
BO HTCH BbIcoRoKBa.TIHcpH:qHpoBaIIIIhIMII HCCJIe.D:OBaTeJIHMH, CJIe ye1' Bce me
CQHTaTb ero rrpep:BapHTeJIblIhIM. nORa lIe )J;ocrnrIIYTO no.ITIIOH .D:OrOBOpeIIIIOCTH
HH rro O,ZJ;IIOMY CKOJIhRO-IIH6Y)J;b KpyrrHoMY TaKCOHOllfHqeCKoMY Bonpocy, II.
134
I
OqeBH,ll,HO, )J;OCTHiReIIHe TaKoii: )J;orOBopeIIHOCTII BOSMomlIO TOJIbKO npn nepe-
xO,ZJ;e IIa IIOBbIn MeTO)J;IIqeCKHH YPOBeHb.
nepeXO.D: IIa 3TOT YPOBelIb )J;aeT nOKa MelIbmyIO IIlIcpopMal(HIO, TaR RaR
OHa ROH:qeHTpIIpyeTcH B OCIIORHOM BOKpyr o:qelIKH cpeII8TIIqeCKOH, a He relIe-
THqeCKOH 6JIHSOCTII. Ho 3aTO OHa BbIpamaeTCH B KOJIHqeCTBeHlIhIX e}J;IIHHl(ax
H n03TOMY n03BOJIHeT OTORTH OT cy6'LeKTHBII3Ma. Peqb H,ZJ;eT 0 MHoro06pa3-
HhIX cnoc06ax CYMMapHoro conOCTaBJIeHHH no MlIorHM npH3HaKallf, nOCTpoeH-
IIhIX B COOTBeTCTBHH C COBpeMeHlIhIM ypOBlIeM CTaTHCTHqeCKOH TeXHHKH C
yqeTOllf HX pa3IIOR IfSMelIqHBOCTIi II cpH3HOJIOrHqeCKOH KOppeJIH HH Mem,ll,y
HHMII. nOJIyqaeMbIe C nOMOlll;bIO 3TIIX cnoc060B cpeHeTHqeCKHe paCCTOHIIHH
eCTb KOJIHqeCTBelIlIaH Mepa ,ZJ;IIcpcpepeH:qHa:qUH norryJIHU;HM.
HaII60.JIbmee pacnpOCTpalIelIHe B KpalIHOJIOrHH nOJIyqHJI cnoc06, pa3pa60-
TalIlIbIH JI. neHp030M. CeHqaC yme MOiRlIO IIaCqIITaTL .D:eCHTKH pa6OT, B RO-
TOpbIX OH HCnOJIb30BaII )J;JIH alIaJIH3a. qacTHqlIO TaKoe BIIHMalIHe K 3TOMY
cnoc06y 06'LHCHHeTCH TeM, qTO OH )J;aeT B03MmRIIOCTb cy,n:HTb OT)J;eJIbIIO 0
CXO,ll,CTBe no pa3l1fepaM II cpopMe, B OCIIOBHOllf me - Tellf, qTO OH, coxpalIHH
Bce rJIaBHbIe npeIIMym;eCTBa )J;pyrHx cnoc060B, lIe Tpe6yeT IIe0603pHlIfOH CTa-
TIICTHqeCROH pa60TbI. C nOMOm;bIO cnoc06a JI. nenpOsa ocym;eCTBJIeHO HCCJIe-
}J;OBaIIHe, nOCBHm;eHlIoe )J;IIlIaMIIKe cpeHeTlIqeCKHX paCCTOHHHH 2.
Pe3YJIbTaTbI 3Toro HCC.JIe)J;OBaIIHH npO)J;eMOIICTpHpOBaJIH HeO)J;HHaKOBYIO Be-
JIHqHHY cpelIeTUqeCKHX paCCTOHIIHR B paSlIbIe 3nOXH HCTOpHJiI qeJIOBeqeCTBa
H saROIIOMeplIbIH xapaKTep HX HSMeII8IIHM. Ha ypOBlIe pa3IIOBpeMeHIIbIX CIIH-
XpOIIHhIX cpe30B OT 3nOXII 6pOlI3hI ,ZJ;O Cpe,ll,HeBeKOBbH 6bIJIH BblqHCJIelIbI cpe-
HeTHqeCKHe paCCTOHHHH MeiR,ZJ;y OT)J;eJIbHbIMII sana)J;HoeBponeHCRHMH norryJIJI-
J:{HJIlIfH. OKa3aJIOCh, qTO OIIII 3aROlIOMepHO YMeHbmaIOTCH no lIfepe npII6JIH-
iRelIHH K COBpeMelIlIOH 3noxe, IIacTynaeT RaK 6hI C6JIHmelIHe nonYJIH:qnn
MeiR)J;y C060H. 8TO cym;eCTBelIHbIH apryMelIT B nOJIbSY HCRJIIOqHTeJIblIOH pOJIH
CMemeHHJI B nOCJIe)J;IIHe CTOJIeTIIH H II,ZJ;yrqen napaJIJIeJIbHOH C IIIIM ROIICOJIH-
,n:a:qIIH.
O.D:naRO npII B)J;YMqHBOllf OTnomelIHH R 3TOllfY na6JIIO)J;eHHIO BH}J;IIO, qTO
eMY IIeJIb3H npH)J;aBaTb Bce06m;ee SHaqeHHe If 3RCTpanOJIIIpOBaTb ero C Hace-
JIelIHH EBponbI IIa BeCb 3eMII011: map. MhI nOMIIHM 60JIee HJIH M8IIee IIe3aRO-
nOMepUhIe ROJIe6aHIfH pa3l1faXa MemrpynnoBoH H3MeHqIIBOCTH B paSHbIe 3no-
XH. naHOHKYMenHOe YllfeHbIIIelIIIe cpelIeTHqeCKIIX paCCTOHIIHH, eCJIH 6bI 0110
}J;eHCTBHTeJIbHO HIIIeJIO MeCTO, )J;OJIiRIIO 6hIJIO 6bI aBTOllfaTHqeCKH nO}J;BeCTH R
CYiRelIHIO BH)J;OBOH H3MeHqHBOCTH H YMelIbmelIHIO pa3IIoo6pa3HH RaR pas no
TeM npH3IIaKaM, no KOTOphIM BhlqHCJIHIOTCH cpeneTHqeCKHe paCCTOHIIHJI.
I1MeHHo 3TIf npIl3HaRH npe.D:CTaBJIelIhI B Ta6JI. 2. KOJIh CKOpO TaKoro cYiRe-
IIHH lIe Ha6JIIOp;aeTCH, nOJIyqelIlIbIe BhIBO.D:bI )J;JIH ,n:HlIaMIIKH cpelIeTHqeCKHX
npH3IIaROB B 3ana,lJHOH EBpone, IIa)J;o rrOJIaraTb, IIMeIOT JIOKaJIhlIOe 3HaqeUIIe
H lIe lIforYT 6bITb pacnpOCTpanelIhI 3a ee reorpacpHqeCKHe rpanHl(h1. Ha )J;PY-
rHX TeppHTopHHX, nO-BH.D:HMOMY, MOrJIO HMeTb MeCTO He OCJIa6JIeIIHe, a YCH-
JIelIHe ypOBIIH .D:HcpcpepelI Ha HH. p;ORaSaTeJIbCTBO 3TOMY HMeeTCH, BO BCH-
KOM CJIyqae, )J;JIH TeppHTopHH ASHH, r)J;e rnJIO lIe YMeHbmeHHe, a YBeJIHqelIHe
cpelIeTHqeCRIIX paCCTOHIIHH B xO)J;e pacorelIeTHqeCROrO npOl(eCca 3.
B nOJIh3Y TaROH JIOKaJIbIlOH HeO}J;HopO.D:IIOCTII YPOBIIH )J;IIcpcpepelI:qHa:qIIH
nonYJIHl(HR CBH}JeTeJIbCTBYIOT II cpeHeTUqeCKHe paCCTOHIIHH, nOJIyqelIlIhIe ,n:JIJI
O)J;Horo CIIHxpOlIlIoro cpe3a. Peqb II)J;eT 0 RpaHHOJIOrHqeCKHX lIfaTepHaJIaX B
OCIIOBIIOllf XVIII-XIX BB., OTIIOCHm;HXCH R IIapO)J;aM BOCTOqlIo-EBponeHcKoH
paBIDIlIhI H HaBKasa. II B TOllf II )J;Pyrollf CJIyqae BbI6palI0 no 13 rpynII".
B nepBOM CJIyqae 3TO rpynn:bI, npe)J;CTaBJIHIOm;IIe nenocpe)J;CTBelIlIhIX npe)J;KOB
COBpeMelIHoro PYCCRoro naCeJIeHIIH, BO BTOpOM RaiR.D:aH rpynna npeD;CTaBJIH-
eT oT}J;eJIblIhIH IIapo)J; HJIH caMOCTOJITeJIbHOe 3TIIorpacplIqeCROe IIO)J;pa3)J;eJIeIIHe.
135
<1>elIeTHqeCRHe paCCTOJIHHJI BbIqIICJIJIJIIfCL C nOllfOIIJ;bIO CPOPMYJIDI JI. nelIp03a.
B Ram)J;OH rpynne C II3BeCTIIbIMH HaTJImRallfIf MOiRHO BII)];eTb nonyJIJI:qIIIO,
TaK KaR Ha K8BKa3e B RaqeCTBB relIeTIIqeCKOrO 6apbepa BbIcTynaeT STHIIqe-
CRHH cpaKTOp, Ha BOCTOqHo-EBponeHCKOH paBHIIlIe - reorpacpIfqeCKIfH.
<1>elIeTHqeCKl1:e paCCTOJIIIIfH Mem,ll,y BceMH RaBRa3CKHMIf nonyJIHI(HHMH pe-
lliIfTeJIhlIO 60JIbrne no BeJIHqHlIe H no cpopMe, qeM MeiR)];Y BOCTOqIIOeBpOneH-
CKHlIfll. AJIH <I>OPllfYJIDI JI. neHp03a, RaK II )J;JIH )J;pyrIIx IITorOBbIX CPOPMY.:'I
lIfHorOMepHoro alIaJIII3a, IIeT nORa Y,ZJ;OBJIeTBOpHTe.JIbIIOH CHCTeMbI Oll,eHKII
OlliII60K, HO H 6e3 IIee HCIIO, qTO MaClliTa6 pa3JIHqHH .D:aeT nOJIIIYIO B03MOiR-
IIOCTh rOBopHTb 0 pa3HOM ypOBHe )J;IIcpcpepelI:qHal(IIH L(BYX COHOCTaB;:meMbIx
cOBoKynHocTeH nOHYJJH:qHH. Pa3 BH;r(OB8H L(HcpcpepelIl(lfa IIH IIeO)];HlIaKOBa B
CHlIxpOlInOM cpe3e, CJIeL(OB8TeJIbII0, olla lIe HL(eT O):\HOlIanpaBJIelIIIO H B )J;Ha-
XpOlIlIOM n.lIalIe, lIHTerpa HH H )J;e3HIITerpa:qIIH CMeHHJIIf L(pyr ,ZJ;pyra B 3aBH-
CIIMOCTH OT COl(IfaJIhHO-SROHOMHqeCKHX Ii KYJIbryPIIO-IfCTOpUqeCKHX npHqIfII.
RaK CJIe,ZJ;yeT IITIIOCHTbCH B CBeTe STHX Ha6JIIO)J;eIIIIH H BbITeKaIOm;HX If3
HIIX C006paiReHHH K cy.ru;eCTBYIOm;IfM TOqRallf 3pelIHH IIa HeHTpaJIblIbIH xa-
paRTep HCXOL(HbIX npe)J;ROBbIX ROMnJIeRCOB ,ZJ;JIH MHorHX paCOBbIX THnOB?
Bo-nepBbIX, Bce TaRHe TOqKH 3pelIHH HYiR.D:aIOTCH B )J;onOJIIIIITe.JIbIIOH apry-
lIfeIITal(HH, OCIIOBalIlIOH yme He Ha BII3yaJIblWH, a IIa 60JIee TOqHOH o:qelIKe
lIfopcpOJIOrHqeCKHX KpHT'epIfeB. BO-BTOphIX, IIeiiTpaJIbHOCTb no npH3IIaRaM oc-
1I0BIIoro KOMnJIeKCa, KOTOphIH TOJIhKO II COXpalIHJICJI B npOl(eCce pa3BHTIIH
BIf)J;&, MOrJIa conpOBOiR,ll,aTbCH pe3KoH Cne IfaJIH3a HeH no HlIbIM npII3lIaKaM,
TaKiRe CKJIa,ll,hIBaBlliHMCH B reorpacpHqeCKHe ROMnJIeRChI, CTepThIe 3aTellf no-
CJIe,ll,YIOm;HMH 3TanaMH pacoo6pa30BalIHH. B-TpeTbHx, HaKOlIe , OT)J;eJIblIbIe
MapKIIpYIOm;He pacy npH3HaKH If )J;aiRe HX COqeTalIHH )J;OCTHraIOT CHJIbIIO:rO
pa3BHTIfH IIa cpolle lIeHTpaJIblIOrO B :qeJIOM ROMnJIeKCa, IIaqIIlIaH C caMbIX palI-
HJIX STanOB pacoo6pa30BalIHH.
RaROB 06m;HH BbIBO)J; H3 Bcero CKa3alIHoro? nOXOiRe IIa TO, qTO rJIYOHII3
BH)J;OBOH )J;HcpcpepelIl(IIa:qIIII lIe YCIIJIHBaJIaCb B xO)J;e qeJIOBeqeCROH HCTOpHH,
qTO YCIIJIeIIlIe HJIH OCJIa6JIelIHe .D:IIcpcpepelI Ha IIH HMeJIO MeCTO JIHrnb B npe-
.D:eJIax OT)J;eJIbHbIX TeppHTopIIH H orpalIHqelIlIbIX OTpe3KOB BpeMelIH, HIITe-
rpaTHBlIhIe H )J;e3HIITerpHpYIOm;Ife npo:qeCCbI, CJIeJJ:OBaTeJIhIIO, B KaKHX-TO
npe)J;eJIax ypaBlIoBeIllIIBaJIH )J;pyr )J;pyra. Bo BCHKOM CJlyqae, naJIeOalITpono-
JIOrHqeCKaH IfCTOpHH qeJIOBeqeCROrO BII)J;a lIe .D:aeT 06paTHDIX npIfMepOB, CBIf-
)J;eTeJIbCTBYH 0 JIOK8JIblIOCTH npOHBJIeHHH pa3UhIX YPOBHeH )];HcpcpepelI {fa:qHII.
IIpIf STOllf H C03IIaTeJIblI0 OCTaBJIHIO B CTopOlIe MIIOrOJIeTIIIOIO .D:HCRYCCHIO 06
HCTOJIKOBalIHH MopCPOJIOrHqeCKHX oc06eHIIocTeH BepXlIenaJIeOJIHTIIqeCKHX JIIO-
)];eH, TaK KaK OHH lIe nO,ZJ;)J;aIOTCH nOKa 0D;II03IIaqHOH o eHRe, KOTopaH 6blJIa
6bl cBo60.D:IIa OT cy6'beKTHBlIoH OKpaCKII If )J;aBJIeHHH 06m;IfX H 60JIee IIJIH Me-
IIee YM03pHTeJIblIhIX B3rJIH)J;OB.
XAP AKTEP BII,rJ;OBon II3MEHQIIBOCTII
Bonpoc 0 CTpYRrype BHYTPHBIf.D:OBOH If3MelIqIfBOCTII qeJIOBeKa HeO,ll,IIORpaTIIO
CTaBHJICH B JIIITepaType, 110 OCBem;aJICH JIIfllih no)]; RaRIIl\1-IIH6Y.D:b onpe)];eJIeH-
HhllIf yrJIOllf 3peHlfH If npeHMym;ecTBelIlIO IIpH IfCCJIe,ll,OBaIIHH SMnHpHqeCRHX
.D:alIlIhIX. AlIrJIHiicKHMH 61f0MeTpHKaMH 6blJIa ROIIKpeTHO nORa3alIa pa3lIH a B
xapaKTepe {f IIanpaBJIelIHII BIIYTpHrpynnoBoH H MemrpynnoBoH II3MelIqHBO-
CTH, B OCIIOBIIOM PYCCKHMH IfCCJIe)J;OBaTeJIHMII 3Ta pa3IIHu;a 6bI.JIa IfCnOJIb30Ba-
Ha B l(eJIHX paCOBoro alIaJIII3a II pa3pa60TalIDI cnoco6bI ee yqeTa.
O,ZJ;IIaRO CTpYKTypa BH)J;OBOH If3MeHqIfBOCTII qeJIOBeRa B :qeJIOM lIe 6hlJIa,
HaCKOJIbKO lIflIe II3BeCTII0, npeAMeTOllf paCCMOTpeIIHH. ¥qIIThlBaH npeHlIfym;e-
136
CTBeHIIO rrOnYJIH:qHOIIHYIO CTPYRTYPY qeJIOBeqeCTa, CJIe yeT paCCMaTpHBaTb
ee RaK qaCTlIbIn c;rryqaH MeJfirpynnoBoH II3MelIqHBOCTII Bo06w;e, npII KOTOpOM--
IIH3rnHM SJIellfelITOllf, 06pa3YIOm;IIM MemrpynrroBoH pH)J;, ero SJIeMelITapHOII
HqeHKOll HBJIHeTCH norrYJIHl(HOlIlIaH cpe HHH. TaRHM 06pa30M, Bonpoc 0 CTpoe-
HHH BH)J;OBOH HSlIfelIqIIBOCTII qeJIOBeKa - STO Bonpoc 0 xapaKTepe MeiRrpyn-
nOBoro pacnpe)J;eJIeHHH nonYJIHI\IIOlIlIbIX cpe)J;HHX no Ram)J;OMY rrpH3IIa 'Y.
COBepmeHIIO OqeBHjJIIO, qTO IIa TaKOH Bonpoc lIe lIfOiReT 6hITb 0)J;II03IIaq-
Horo OTBeTa. Pacrrpe)J;eJIeHIIe npII3IIaKOB C ,ZJ;IICKpeTlIhIlIf BhlHBJIenHeM, oc06elI-
HO IIcrrbIThlBaIOm;HX .n:eHCTBHe oT60pa, BPHp: JIH ocym;eCTBJIHeTCH no O)J;HOMY
TIIrry, 3)J;eCb B03MOiRIIbI CaMbIe pa3IIo06pa3HhIe MOi{HcpHKa:qHII RpIIBbIX lIfem-
rpynrrOBoro pacrrpep:eJIeHIIH. Ho STOT 06m;HH CJIyqaH JIeiRIIT 3a rrpe)J;eJIaMII
paCCMOTpeIIIIH: 06blqHO npep:CTaBJIelIHhIe B KpaHIIOJIOrHqeCIm:x npOrpaMlIfaX
npH3IIaKII TpalIcrpeCCHBlIbI II B COOTBeTCTBHII C HaH60JIee pacrrpOCTpaHelIHon
rIInOTe30H nOJIHcpaKTOpHaJIblIbI B CBoeH IIaCJIe CTBeHHOH OCIIOBe.
B rrpHII Hrre HlIfelIIIO iIJIH TaRHX npH3IIaKOB HaH60JIee BepOHTlla MO)J;eJIb
HOpMaJIblIOrO HJIII OJIHSKOro K IIOpMaJIblIOMY pacrrpe)J;eJIeHHH. Ho He HCRJIIO-
qelIO II )J;pyroe - TaKoe pacnpe,ZJ;eJIelIHe MeiRrpynrroBoH IISMeHqHBOCTII BIIYTPH
BH)J;a, IIPH ROTOpOM olla 06pasyeT PHiIhI napaJIJIeJIbHbIX BapIIa:qHH, HarrOMII-
IIaIOm;IIe rOMOJIOrHqeCKHe pH)J;bI B HaCJIe)J;CTBeIIIIOH II3l1feHqIIBOCTH. IIaJIeoalI-
TpOIIOJIOrHqeCKHH MaTepHaJI no p:peBIIIIM snoxaM )J;JIH npOBepKH 06eIIX MO)J;e-
JIeH MaJIOrrpIIrO,ll,eII B CIIJIY BbI60pOqlIOCTH H rrOJIlIoro OTCYTCTBHH BO lIfHorHX
lIfeCTax OHRYMelIbI. Ho RpaHHOJIOrIIqeCKHe )J;alIlIhIe rro 6JIH3KHM R COBpeMeIIHO-
CTH snoxaM OCTaTOqIIO rrOJIHbI, qT06bI COCTaBHTb RpHBbIe MemrpyrrnoBoro
pacrrpe,ll,eJIeHHH rro MlIorHM HpHSlIaKaM.
CepHH BhI6pflHhI C TaRHM paCqeTOM, qT06hI 60JIee HJIH Mellee paBHO-
lIfeplIO OXBaTHTb OHRYMeHY, XOTH KpalIHOJIOrHqeCKHH MaTepnaJI C TeppIITopHK
EBpOHbI Bce paEIIO rrO,ll,aBJIHeT qHCJIeHHO BhI60pKH MaTepHaJIOB C )J;pyrHx
TeppHTopnH. nOJ)"IIrOHbI qaCTOThI COCTaBJIelIbI )J;JIH OCIIOBlIbIX )J;HaMeTpOB qe-
peHIIOH Kop06KII II JIH:qeBoro CKeJIeTa (pHC. 9). BII)J;IIO, qTO XOTH OIIH II )J;e-
cpOpMIIpoBaHbI no cpaBHeHHIO C IIOpMaJIbHhIlIf paCHpe)J;eJIeIIHeM, 110 OT.JIHqHH
OT HOpMaJIbHOrO pacrrpe)J;eJIelIHH CTaTHCTHqeCKH IIe,ll,OCTOBepHhI. nOSTOllfY MO-
,ll,eJIb IIOpMa.JIbIIOrO pacnpe)J;eJIelIHH rrOKa, MOiRlIO CqHTa Tb, HBJIHeTCH HaHOOJIee
rrpHro)J;IIOH ,D,JIH onHcalIHH MeiRrpynrroBoH H3MelIqIIBOCTH rpalIcrpeCCHBHhIX
npH3IIaROB BlIYTPH qeJIOBeqeCKOrO BHjJa.
B rrpIIHl(Hrre TRKOH BhIBO)J; xoporno COBrra)J;aeT C YCTaHoBHBmeHcH Tpa II-
I\IfeH paCClIfaTpIIBaTJ. cpopMoo6pa30BaHHe TpaHcrpeCCHBHhIX rrpH3HaKOB KaR
pe3y.JIhTaT )J;ellcTBIIH MHOI'HX COCTaBHhIX rrpHqHII. HII uaCJIejJCTBelIIIaH 06yc-
JIOBJIeHIIOCTb, IIH cpe)J;OBhIe B03JJ:eHcTBHH, HH CeJIeKTHBIILIn npo ecc lIe BLI-
)JBlIraIOTCH Ha "l\IeCTO cpYII,ll,alli€IITaJIbHOH rrpHqHHhI, OKa3bIBaH rrpe06JIa,ZJ;aIOII{ee
BJIHHHHe Ha cpopllfo06pa30BaHHe. Ha06opoT, reHeTllqeCKaH OCIIOBa Bos)J;eHcT-
ByeT qepe3 l\IIIOrHe IIeSaBHCHMbIe cpaKTopbI, cpe)J;a - qepes MlIorHe He3aBH-
CHMbIe rrepeMeHlIhIe, oT60p - qepe3 DbIpa60TKY lIfnoro06pa3IIhIX H, nO-BH)J;H-
MOlllY. npHMO npOTIfBOnOJIOiRlIhIX npncnOC06JIelIIIH. TOJIbRO TaKIIM 06pa30M II
lIfOmlIO 06eCrreqIITb B03HHKIIOBelIIIe KOlIeqlIOro scpcpeRra 3TOI'0 pasII006pa3HH
npnQUH B BHiIe HOpllfaJIbHOrO pacnpe)J;eJIeHHH.
<DYII)J;aMeHTaJIhlIoii npoo"'IeMOll B SBOJIIO:qHOUHOH 6HOJIOrHH qeJIOBeRa, IIe-
IIocpe,JcTBelIlIo cBH3aHHoll C H3yqelIHeM p:peBlIero IIaCeJIeIIIIH, OCTaeTCH BLI-
HCIIeUIIe nyTeH cpOpl\HIpOBaHIIH HMelIHO TaKoH, a lIe IIHOH Mei-KrpynnoBoH
CTPYKTyphI BnyTpHBII;:WBOH II3:!\IeHqHBOCTlI TpaHcrpeccIIBlIbfX rrp1I3IIaKOB y
qeJIOBeKa cOBpf;MelIHoro BIIiIa. B03IIIIK.rra JIH TaKaH CTpYRTypa BMeCTe C rro-
HB.rreHHeM cOBpeMeHHoro 'I€JIOB8Ka, 06paSOBaJIaCb JIH olla E xO)J;e ero IICTOpHH,
KaKOBO ee IIIeCTO B cpopMo06pa30BalIHII B l(eJIOM? Bce 3TO BonpochI, IIaCTOH-
TeJIblIO Tpe6YIOm;IIe pemeHIIH. Ho TOJIbRO Ba nepBbIx saBIICHT OT nporpecca
1:37
N
n
5/1 .f/1
///1 t/J
J/1 J/1
Ii! 21l
//1 1/1
.II /1
f If
IfF!,J 1711.J 1100J Ifl,J If!,J Ilu,l IJl,! m;1 11/'/,1 1.f1l,1
J/1 .f/1
1//1
J/1 J/1
2/1 2/1
1/1 1/1
/J /J
117,11 131,11 13.f,1I US/I 11fJ, If IT Il,f,l 11f,Z IJJ,Z IJ1,1 1111,1 11fff,1 1f.F
IIJ,II 111,1
w,t
0/1
of, II 0.f,1/ ff5',1/ 7J,1/ 17// IfI,I/ Iff
PIIC. 9. llOJIlIrOHbI nanoHKYMeHHbIX
J\Ie1KrpYlIlIoBbIX '1aCTOT OCHOBHbIX
KpaHIIOl\ICTplI'IecKIix nplI3HaKoB. MY1K-
CKlIe '1epena
1 - np0)10JIbHbIM )1HaMeTp '1epenHOH RO-
poiiIm (B MM);
8 - nOnepe'lHbIH )1HaMeTp (B MM);
17 - BbICOTHblit )1HaMeT}) OT 6a3HoHa
(BMM);
45 - cHYJIOBaH 1IIHpHHa (B MM);
48 - BepXHHJI BbICOTa JIHu;eBOro CReJIeTa .
(B MM),
n - t.IHCJIO cepRll
IIomrroHbI onnpalOTCJI Ha BapHaU;Hn COOT-
BeTCTBYIOIu;HX npH3HaHOB B 235 HPaHHOJIO-
rH'IeCHHX cepHHX, XpOHOJIOrH'IeCHH OJIH3-
HHX H COBpeMeHHOCTH H oOJIee HJIH MeHee
paBHoMepHo pacnpe)1eJImoIu;HXcH no 3eM-
HOM nOBepXHOCTH
7/1
:i
.F/1
-'Ill
J[l
2/1
III
/J
It
naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrHqeCRHX HCCJIeAOBaIIIIH. PemeHIfe IIOCJIeAHerO BOrrpOCa 60JII,-
me ynHpaeTCH B He,ZJ;OCTaTOqHYIO paapa60TalIHOCTI, 3BOJIIO:qHOHII0-reHeTHqe-
CKOll TeopHH B aHTponOJIOrHH.
HAllP AB.JIEHHbIE H3l\1EHEHHH llPII3HAKOB BO BPEl\1EHII'
I,
HarrpaBJIelIHI,IM H3MelIelIHHlIf I1pH3IIaROB BO BpeMelIH rrOBe3JIO 60HI,rne, qeM
paCCMOTpelIHI,IlIf BI,Ime Tellfallf,- IIM rrOCBHIIJ;eH PH)]; pa60T 06m;ero xapaRTepa
If TpaRTYIOm;HX p;IUIal\fIfh-Y IIarrpaBJIelIHI,IX H3MeHeHHll IIa OT,ll,eJII,lIbIX TeppH-
I
138
TOpHHX. R nOCJIe.Il;HHM OTIIOCHTCH HCCJIeAOBalIHH IIanpaBJIeHHI,IX H3MBIIelIHH B
CeBepHOH AMepHKe, HnOIIIIII, rpY3HH, BOCTOqHOH npIIOaJITUKe, Ha TeppIITO-
pHIl CCCP B :qeJIOIlL nepBI,Ie npe CTaB.JIeHI,I pa60TaMH, B KOTOpI,IX paCCMOT-
pelIhI OOm;He npIIqHlIhI TaRIIX BpeMelIHI,IX C,ZJ;BIIrOB 5.
06m;HH HTor Bcex JJ:O CIIX nop npOBe.Il;eHlIhIX HCCJIeAOBalIHH CBOAIfTCH R
/
TOMY, qTO IIanpaBJIelIlII,Ie II3MelIeHHH npOHBJIHIOTCH no ,ZJ;BYM KOMnJIeKCaM
npH3IIaKOB - ropH30lITaJIhlII,Il\f pa3MepaM qepenlIOH Kop06KII H nonepeqHhIM
pa3l1fepaM JIHl(eBoro CKe.JIeTa. OIIH, nO-BIIAHMOMY, IIe3aBHCIIMhI BO BpeMelIII:
II3MeHeHIIH B llIHpOTHhIX pa3Mepax JIH:qeBoro CKeJIeTa naJJ:aIOT B OCIIOBIIOllf IIa
3noxy IIeOJIHTa II OPOH3hI, H3:\f€HeHIIH B COOTlIornenHHX ropH30lITaJII,lII,IX AHa-
MeTpOB rOJIOBhI - IIa 3noxy cpe,ll,HeEeKOBhH.
BI,Irne yiRe rOBOpIIJIOCI, 0 HeCOrJIaCOBaHHOCTH nfIIOTe3hI nalIOHRYMelIlIoro
pacnpOCTpalIeHIIH IIanpaBJIelIlIhIX H3MeHelIHH C IIa6JIIOAelIHHMH 06 OTIIOCH-
TeJII,IIOH cTa6IIJII,llOCTII xpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX KOJIe6alII1H BH,ll,OBOH H3MelIqHBOCTH.
OnpoBepraeTcH 3Ta rHnOTe3a II npHMI,IMH .Il;aIIHhIMII 0 reorpacpII<IeCKI1X KOJIe-
oanHHX B IIanpaBJIeHHH H3M€lIeHHH. ECTI, TeppHTopUH, B npeAeJIax KOTOphIX
IIa npOTHiRelIHII ThICHqeJIeTHH He3aMeTII0 3aROlIOllfeplIhIX II3l1felIelIHii: B rnHpH-
lIe JIH eBOro CKe.JIeTa, HanpHMep AOJIIIHa HHJIa; IIa APyrHx npH conOCTaBJIe-
IIIIII BapHaI(HH IIIIIpHIII,I JIHl(a y COBpeMelIIIoro II Apemrero IIaCeJIeHHH MI,I
cpHKcHpyeM lIe cymeHHe, a paCIIIupeUIIe JIH:qeBOI'O CKeJIeTa, IIanpHlIfep B paB-
HnHlIhIX paHouax rpY3I1H. TaKHlIf 06paaoM, rpa:qIIJIH3a HH - no BceM AalI-
HI,IM, IIIHpOKO pacnpocTpaHeHlIoe, MOiReT 6I,ITI" ame npe06JIa.D:aIOm;ee IIa-
npaBJIelIHe BpeMeHlIhIx H3MeHeHHH. IIO He e.o:HnCTBeHlIoe Aame B npeAeJIax
EBpa3IflI U TeM 60JIee lIe nalIoHKYJ\F.HlHoe.
To iRe MOiRlIO nOBTOpIfTI" o qeBH,ll,II 0, II npo 6paxIIKecpaJIH3a HIO. Ha cpo-
lIe 3Toro AeHCTBUTeJIhHO 06m;ero HBJIeIIIIH, CKaiHeM, B npe.o:eJIax EBponhI .n;ne-
COlIalICOM BI,IrJIHJ(HT conOCTaB,TIeHHe peaYJIhTaTOB COMaTOJlOrHqeCKUX IfCCJIe.n;o-
BanHH COBp.JMeIIHOro HaCe;rreHHH IIIBeHl(apuH H RpaIIHOJIOrIIqeCKOrO II3yqelIHH
ero Ha MaTepnaJIax H3 occyapHeB nOCrre,ll,IIHX CTOJIeTIIH: conOCTaBJIelIHe 3TO
BhIHBJIHeT Om;YTH:\IYIO AOJIHXoKecpaJIH3a IIIO. TaKH:\f o6pa30M, II ropH30lITaJIh-
III,Ie pa3:\rephI qepenlIOH Kop06KH He H3MeHHIOTCH B XOAe EpeMeHII O.Il;H03Haq-
HhIM oopa30M, KaK AYMaJIH HeKOTopI,Ie aBTopHTeTHhIe IICCJIeAOBaTeJIH palII,rne.
06 3TOM iRe CBH.II;eTeJIhCTBYIOT H coxpaHIIBIIIHeCH na cOBpeMeHHoH KapT€
rOJIOBIIOrO YKasaTe.JIH 06mUpHhIe OCTpOBa ,ll,OJIIIXoKecpamIH, ROTOpI,IX, nqe-
BHAIIO, He 6I,IJIO Ohl, 6y,UI, npo ecc 6paxHKecpaJIH3al(HH Bce06m;HM.
BhlHBJIeHUOe BceMH nepequc.rrelIlIblMH II MHorUlIfH APyrHMII pa60TaMH lIfHO-
ro06pa3He nYTeH IIanpaBJIelIHhIX I13MelIe1IHH calif 0 no ce6e CBHAeTeJII,CTByeT
'J MlIomeCTBeHHOCTII BbI3hIBaIOm;HX 3TO HBJIelIIIe npHqUII. TIOHCK HX BeJICH AO
rnx nop B OCIIOBHQ;\1 B pal\fKaX MopcporeHeTHqeCKOrO paCCMOTpeIIlIH npOOJIe-
],Ih!. HauooJIee OOm;aH rHnOT€3a onIIpaeTCH Ha YBH3KY UanpaBJIeHHI,IX H3Me-
neRHH co CKOpOCTI,IO pOCTOBhIX npo eCCOB II nOJIOBOrO C03peBaHIIH 6. C IIHMII
:rerKO YBH3hIBaeTCH H .JIOKaJILHOe B XpOIIOJIOrIIqeCKOllf OTHorneIIHH, HO mHpOKO
npOHBIIBrneeCH B EBpone 3a nOCJIe;:J:uee CTOJIeTHe HBJIelIHe YBeJIUqelIHH ,ll,.JIHHI,I
TeJIa.
I1cKJIIOqeHIIeM B pH.lY l\lOpcporelIeTHqeCKITX pa60T. TpaKTYIOm;IIX npHqHHI,I
nanpaBJIeHEI,IX H3MenejIIIii:, HBJIHeTCH nOnhITlt8 npIIBJIeqh K I1X 06'bHClIeIIIIIO
CeJIeKTHBHhIe MexaUII3MhI 7. B COOTB"eTCTBHII C 3TOH TOqKOH 3pelIHH rpa-
I{HJII,RhIe IIIIlJ,HBII.'J.YYMhI IIpII06pe.JIu II3BeCTHoe npeIIMym;ecTBo no cpaBHelIHIO'
c MaTypH30BaHHblMH C ncpeXOJJ:Ol\1 K 3eMJIe,ZJ;eJIHIO, KaR 60,;[ee npHCnOCOOJIelI-
nI,Ie K nopOm.Il;aeMhL\f 3e:\IJIeJJ;eJIIIelll CJIOiRlII,IM CO IIaJII,HhIM OTlIomeHIIHM.
B TaKoH cpopMe CeJIeKTlIBHOe OO'bHCHeHIIe HanpaBJIelIlII,IX II3MelIelIIIH BI,I-
rJIHAIIT CJIIIlllKOM YM03pUTeJIhHhIlIl II npHMOJIIfHeHlIhIlIf.
139
I
O,ll,IIaKO CeJI€l\:THBHI,IH rro,ZJ;xo A MOiReT 6I,ITI, YCIIJIeII KaK rrpHMhIMH IIa6JIIO-
.D:eIIHHMH, TaK H KOCBelIHI,IMH coOOpameHHHMH, OCHOBalIlII,IIIIH Ha lIe rrpHB.rre-
RaBIIIIIXCH AO CHX rrop B :nOR CBH3H epH3Ho.JIOrHqeCKHX ,ll,aHHhIX. B RaqeCTBe
nepBhIX MorYT epurypHpOBaTI, ,ZJ;aHHhIe 0 CBH3I1 ,ZJ;BHraTeJIbHOH aKTHBIIOCTH C
ROHCTHTy:qHOIIHhIM ra6HTYCOM 8. 8TH AalIHI,Ie CBH,ll,eTeJII,CTBYIOT 0 TOM, qTO B
npIIHl(IIIIe cym;eCTBYIOT 3a A aqII, ROTOp:bIe JIIOAII pa3IIhIX KOIICTHry:qHH BhIIIOJI-
HHIOT nO-pa3IIOMY. ACTeUHKII, BqaCTHOCTH, Ra;KeTCH, 60JIee «paHIfMhl>} B
nCHXHqeCROM OTIIOlIIeIIHH H OCTpee pearHpYIOT IIa JIIOOYIO IIeCTaHAapTIIYIO CH-
Tya:qHIO. B eJIOM TaKaH IIeYCTOHqHBOCTI, nCHXHKH He MOiReT CqHTaTI,CH no-
JIOiRIITeJIhHhIM RaqeCTBOM IIH rrpIf KaROM TIIrre X03HHCTBa H KYJII,ryphI. Ho
BBe)J;elIIIe B RYJII,TYPY 3eMJIe,ZJ;eJIIIH II B )J;aJIhHeHlIIee pa3BHTHe 06m;ecTBelIHhlx
OTIIOlIIelIHH caMO no ce6e OCJIa6JIHJIO ce.rreKTHBlIhle rrpo:qeCCI,I, E TOM qHCJIe II
(>TpII:qaTeJII,HYIO CeJIeK:qHIO. B03MOiR1I0, OCJIa6JIelIHe rrOCJIeAlIeR H crroc06cTBO-
BaJIO nOCTeIIeIIlIollfY pacnpOCTpalI€IIHIO rpa:qIIJII,llhIX IIII,ZJ;HBHAYYMOB H 3aMe-
m;eIIHIO HMH MaCCHBHI,IX.
qTO KacaeTCH epH3HOJIOrIIqeCRHX IIa6JIIO.II;eIIIIH, TO H3 HHX ,ZJ;Ba, IIa,ZJ;o p:y-
MaTI" IIMeIOT HenocpeiICTBelIlIoe OTIIOlIIelIIIe K relIe3HCY HanpaBJIelIlII,IX H3Me-
HeIIHH. nepBOe COCTOHT B TOM, qTO COAepmaHHe raMMa-rJI06YJIHlIOBOH eppaK-
HH B KpOBHIIO:fl CI,lBopOTKe CBH3alIO 06paTIIOH ROppeJIH:qHeH C pa3MepaMH H
BeCOllf Te.rra 9. TaK KaK STa eppaK:qIlH BhIllOJIHHeT epYIIK:qHIO 6IIOJIOrHqeCKOH
3am;HThI II YCHJIHBaeT HMMYHOJIOrHqeCRYIO pe3IICTeIITIIOCTI" oT60p, IIaIIpaBJIeH-
HI,m B CTOPOIIY coxpaHelIlIH HH.II;HBII,ll,YYMOB C nOBhIlIIeIIHI,IM cOI(epmalIHeM
raMMa-rJI06YJIHIIOB B nJIa3Me KpOBH, BI,I3hIBaJI ROCBeUHO H YBeJIHqelIIIe rrpo-
l,eHTa JIHIJ, rpa:qHJlI,lIoro CJIOa\eHHH.
napaJIJIeJII,IIO MOrJIO YM8III,rnaTI,CH 3IIaqeHHe CKeJIeTa KaK oqara rOMe-
nos3a, nOJIHO oCBem;elIlIoe B IIaCTOHm;ee BpeMH He TOJIhKO C epYHRl(HOlIaJII,IlOH
III cpaBIIIITeJII,II0-epII3HOJIOrIIqeCKOH, 110 H C aBOJIIO IIOHIIOII TOqKH 3pelIHH 10.
¥MelII,lIIelIIIe MaCCI,I CKeJIeTa B IIpo ecce qeJIOBeqeCKOll SBOJIIO IIH rOBopIIT 0
TOM, qTO qaCTh rOMenOSTHqeCKOll 4:>YIIK I1H OH rrepe,ll,aJI APyrHM opralIaM.
BepOHTIIO, STOT IIpo:qecc rrpOAOJIiRaeTCH II B SBOJIIO:qHH Homo sapiens.
nOA:bITOmHBaH H3JIOmelIHOe BI,IlIIe, IIeOOXO.D:HMO IIOA'IepKIIYTI,:
a) aMIIJIHTYAhI KOJIe6aHHH cpeAIIHx KpanHOJIOrHqeCKHX npH3HaKoB 60JIee
IIJIII Mellee cTa6HJII,lIhI B pa3III,Ie 3IIOXH HCTOpIfII 'IeJIOBeqeCTBa;
6) rJIy6HIIa ,ll,Hep4:>epelI:qHa HH IIonYJIH:qIfH OTJIII'IaeTCH JIOKaJII,lIhIM CBoe-
06pa3HeM, HO He YBeJIIIqIIBaeTCH B xO)J;e BpeM€IIH;
B) rrorryJIH:qHOIIHhle cpeJJ:IIHe rro KpaIIHOJIOrHq'3CRIIM IIpII3HaRaM n0D;qHIIH-
IOTCH 3aKOlIY IIOpM3JIhHOrO pacnpeAeJIelIHH. OCTaeTCH neHCIII,IM, CepOpMHpOBa-
JIaCI, JIH TaKaH CTpYKTypa BIIYTPIIBH.II;OBOH II3MelIqHBOCTII B xO,ZJ;e 3BOJIIOl(HII
Homo sapiens HJIJI B03IIHRJIa BMeCT.3 C UHM;
1') IIarrpaBJIeHlIhIe II3l1IelIelIHH IIpH3lIaKoB pa3HoTHnHI,I B pa3JIHqlIblX paiio-
Hax oiIKYMelIbI. B IIX B03IIHKIIOBeHIIH, IIO-BH.II;HMOMY, 3IIa'IIfTeJII,Ha pOJII,
epH3IIOJIOrHqeCKIIX IIPHqIUI.
npHBeAelIlII,Ie nOJIOa\eHIIH JIerRO cOrJIacYIOTcH C IIpeACTaBJIeHIIeM 06 oc-
JIa6JIelIHH epopMo06pa3YIOm;eH pOJIH OT60pa B qeJIOBeqeCKOM 06m;ecTBe. Ho
OIIH COrJIaCYIOTCH II C .Il;PyrHM rrpe,ll,CTaBJIeIIIIeM, corJIaCIIO ROTOPOMY OTOOp lIe
OCJIa6eBaeT, HO npHIIl(HnHaJIhIIO MelIHeT epOPMY CBoero AeHCTBHH B qeJIOBeqe-
CROM 06II{eCTBe. R CBH3H C pa3Ho06pa3HeM SKOJIOrIIqeCRHX IIIIIII 011 BI,lcTyrra-
eT B pacceHBaIOm;eH epopMe, nOCTOHlIlIO C03.D:aBaH IICKJIIOqHTeJII,lIhln rrOJIH-
MOpepII3M qeJIOBeqeCKHX nonYJIH Hii BnYTpH cTa6HJII,lIblX BH,ZJ;OBI,IX rpalIIIU.
CrrpaBeAJIHBOCTI, TaKoro IIpeACTaB:IeIIIIH 0 pOJIH OToopa nop:TBepmAaeTcH 3a-
Be.Il;oMO 3aCBHAeTe.:'II,CTBOBaIIHhIMH tf>aRTaMu CHJIbHOrO ero BJIUHIIHH IIa Auua-
MHRY Mllorux rrpH3IIaKoB.
II
,
140
1
t J{e6elJ. r. W. 0 HeKOTOpbIX HarrpaBJIeHIIHX 1I3MeHeHlIii B CTpOeHlI1I '1eJIOBeKa COBpe-
MelIHoro BIIAa II COB. 3THorpacPlIH. 1961. oM 2.
:2 Schwidetzky I. Die Abnahme del" Unterschiede zwischen europiiischen Bevolkerun-
gen vom 5. vorchristlichen bis 2. nachchristlichen JahrtausendllHomo. 1968. Bd. 19,
H.1/2.
2 A. e1;CeeB B. n., Tpy6HuKoBa O. B. HeROTOpbIe IIp06JIeMbI TaKCOHOJlIlIIf II reHeaJIOrlI1I
a3IIaTCKlIX WHrO.:IOIIAOB (KpaHllmleTpIIH). HOBOCIIOllpCK, 1984.
4 A. enceeB B. n. IIpOIICX01K,I1eHlIe Hapop;OB KaBKa3a (KpaHIIOJIorH'leCKOe IICC;;!ep;OBa-
1I1Ie). M., 1974.
5 CBOAKY p;aHHbIX II OIIOJIlIorpacPlIIO CM.: A. eKceeB B. n. K cPII3IIOJIOrlI'IeCKOMY 00'1>-
HCHeHIIIO cPeH('l lCHa rpdl\Il.Ul3au,UII il BOHp. 3HlpOIIo:ronUl. 1.9;)1. BblII. :>1.
" B YHan B. B. CTPyKTYPHblC II3 IeHeHIIH 'leperra B IIpOIwcce 6paxlIKecPaJIlI3aI(1I1I II Tp.
V BcecoI03. C'1>e3p;a aHaTOMOB, rIICTOJIorOB 11 3M6pIIOJWroB. JI., 1951.
7 Schwidetzky I. Das Grazilisierungsproblem II Homo. 1962. Bd. 13, H. 3.
.8 P02UHcnuu H. H. MaTepnaJIbI no IICCJIeAOBaHIIIO CBH311 TeJIOCJI01KeHIIH II MOTOplIKIf II
AHTpono;;!. 1KYPH. 1937. oM 3.
A. eKceeBa T. H. 1I3MeH'IIIBOCTh OCHOBHbIX KOMIIOHeHTOB TeJIa '1eJIOBeEa B 3aBIlCII-
JlIOCTII OT ypOBHH JIlInIIp;OB B CbIBopoTKe KpOBII 3AopoBoro 'leJIOBeKa II MOPcP o -qJII3I!0-
.:IorH'leCRlIe IICCJIe,I1oBaHIIH B aHTponOJlOrlIlI. M., 1970.
H Kop:m:yeB n. A. feMorJIOOIIH. CpaBRIITeJIblIaH cPII31I0JIOrlIH II OIlOXIIMIIH. M., 1964.
t
j
3Al\.1I10QEHIIE
IIpeAbI)J;ym;He OqepKH, IIaIlIICalIlII,Ie B pa3IIOe BpeMH II C paCqeTOM IIa pa3-
JIHqlIYIO ayAIITopIfIO, B :qeJIOM, no MI,ICJIIf aBTopa, ,ZJ;aIOT .D:0CTaTOqIIO MHoro-
CTopolIuee npeACTaBJIeHIIe 0 nOHIIMaHIIII HM rpanII:q npeAMeTa cBoen IIaYRH,
ee MeCTa cpeAII ,ZJ;pyrIIx pOAcTBelIHI,Ix IIayqHI,IX AIfCl(IInJIHH II ee BnyTpelIlIero
cO.D:epiRaHHH. OAllaRO, nOiRa.uyn, He6ecnOJI€31I0 3aKOlIqIlTI, II3JIOiReIIIIe, cepop-
MYJIIIpOBaB IIeCKOJII,KO 06m;HX nOJIOiReHHn, BblTeKaIOm;IIX, KaK lIflIe KaiReTCH,
H3 TpaAIIl(IIOIIHhIX B3rJIH A OB IIa 06'bellI H COAepiRalIHe alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOrO
3IIalIHH H B TO me BpeMH no B03MOiRIIOCTH YQHThlBaIOm;HX COBpeMelIlIhIe TelI- I
J];elIl(IIII B ero pa3BIITHII.
npeiRAe Bcero CJIeAyeT nO,ZJ;qepKHYTI" qTO aBTOp He pa3p;eJIHeT RpaiiHo-
CTelI npOTIIBOnOJIOiRHI,IX nO,ZJ;xop:OB K COAepiRalIHIO alITpOnOJIOrHqeCKOn HayRll,
npOHBHBIllHXCH B nOCJIe,ZJ;HHe rO.D:I,I: B OAIIOllf CJIyqae peqj, Hp;eT 0 IIe06XO,ZJ;H-
MOCTH paCCMaTpIfBaTI, alITpOnOJIOrHIO KaK CHCTellfY I1JIH ROMnJIeJ\C naYI_.
o npeBpam;eHHII alITpOnOJIOrHH B CHHTeTIIqeCROe qeJIOBeK03IIalIHe 1, B APY-
rOM - 0 coxpalIeHIIII alITpOnOJIorIIII B ee npeililIeM BIlge H nop:qepKHBaHIIH
aKTya.iII,IIOCTII IIMeHHO TaKOII ee TpaKTOBRIf 2. B nepBOM cJlyqae HaJlHl(O CTH-
paHIIe cnel(IIeplIKH alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO 3HanHH If B TO iRe BpeMH nonblTKa
C,ZJ;eJIaTI, 1I3 aHTpOnOJIOrHH KaKYIO-TO IIaAHayKY C BeCI,Ma IIeonpep;eJIelIlIhIMH
OqepTaUIlHMII, BO BTOpOM CJIyqae He npIIHlfMaIOTCH BO BHIIMaHHe IIJIII IIeAO-
CTaTOqlIO yquThIBaIOTCH npOHCXOAHm;IIe B pea.iII,IIOH AeHCTBHTeJII,IIOCTII C06bI- ... . ..
TIIH, CBIIgeTeJII,CTBYIOm;ne II 0 He06'bHTIIOM paCIllIIpelIIIII TeMaTIIKII IICCJIe.D:O- :JI!
BaTeJII,CKOiI pa60TbI, If 0 nepecTpoiiK-3 MhlrnJIeHHH aIITpOrrOJlOrOB, II 0 pa3BIITlIH
BnyTpH caMOH alITpOnOJIOrHH HOBhIX MeiRAIIC IImlIIIIaplIblx cepep. llcTIIHa, .
nO-BHWlMOMY, JIeiRIIT rAe-TO nocpe;:J;IIlIe H 3aKJIIOqaeTCH B TOM, qTOObI IIPH .
OnpeAeJIelIHII MeCTa aHTpOnOJIOrlIH cpeJJ:H APyrHx IIaYK coxpamITI, ee caMO-
CTOHTeJlI,HOCTI, H B TO me BpeMH lIe 3aKpI,IBaTI, rJIa3a Ha BHOBh B03HHRIlllIe
IT p;OCTaTOqIIO 6YPHO pa3BIIBaIOm;IIecH HanpaBJIelIIIH IICCJIe;:J;OBaIIHn.
l.JTO 3TO 03HaqaeT KOHRpeTIIO? L(YMaIO, qTO MOiRlIO paCCMaTpHBaTh alITpo-
nOJIOrHIO KaK IIaYI{Y, H3yqaIOm;yIO, KaK 06 3TOM HeO,ZJ;IIOKpaTIIO n cOBepIllelIlIo
cnpaBe.n:JIIIBO nHCaJIII B. B. EYHaR, M. r. JIeBIIH H H. H. PorHHcKIIII, BaplIa-
HII eplI3HqeCKOrO THna rOMHHH;:J; B npocTpaHcTBe H BO BpellfeHH, a TaI{ilie
6HOJIOrHqeCRHe H COl(HaJII,HhIe epaKTophI ux epOpMupoBaHIIH. Ho C pacrrmpeHH-
eM II oc06elIHO yrJIy6JIeHHeM npeAMeTa H3YQeHHH II cl>opMHpOBaHHeM IIOBbIX
141
,
nO,ZJ;XO)J;OB K HeM)" IIeH36eiRII0 060ram;eHIIe CTPyKTYPI,I alITpOnOJIOrHH II 06pa-
30BaHHe IIOBhlX CTPYKTyplII,IX HqeeK BIIYTPU Hee, II n03TOMY Tpa,n,II lIOIIHoe
nOJJ;pa3JJ:eJIeIIIIe aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOIf IIaYKII IIa alITporroreIIe3, paCOBe)IeHIIe H
MopcpOJIOrHIO qeJIOBeKa BhIrJIH)J;HT YiRe He)J;OCTaTOqHhIM. PeaJILIIO cym;eCTBY-
lOT II pa3BHBaIOTCH CPII3HOJIOrIIqeCKaH anTponOJIOrIIH II reHoreorpacplfH qeJIO-
BeKa, aKTIIBHO CPYIIKl(I10IIIIPyeT rrplIKJIal\lIaH anTpOrrOJIOrIIH, IIaMeqaIOTCH
KOIlTYphl IICCJIe)J;OBaIIIIH norry.lIH IIOIIIIOH CTPYKTYPI,I qeJIOBeqeCTBa, rrOCTenelI-
HO BbI3peBaeT KaK caMOCTOHTeJII,IIOe HarrpaBJIeUne aHTpOrrOJIOrnqeCKaH TaK-
COIIOMIIH II T. ,ZJ;. TaKHM 06pa30M, lIe OTpIll(aH e,ZJ;IIIICTBa cO)l,epmaHIIH alITpo-
nOJIOrHH, H BHmy B 3TOM CO,ll,epiRaHHII Bce 60JIhrnee H 60JIhIllee MHoroo6pa3IIe.
OT CPOPMYJIIIPOBKII ,nol'O nOJIOiReIlIfH 3aKOHOMepeII rrepexo,ll, K )J;PyrOMY,
a HMeHHO K He06xorrIIMOCTlI OTMeTIITI, Bce 60JIeB OqeBII)J;IIYIO neonpe)J;eJIeH-
HOCTI, rpaHII , OT)J;eJIHIOm;IIX aHTpOrrOJWrIIIO OT p:pyrIIX CIIIeiRHhIX 06JIaCTeli
3HaIIIIH. 8TO 06CTOHTeJII,CTBO HII B RoeH Mepe IIeJII,3H cqIITaTI, OTJIHqlITeJII,HOn
qepTOII COBpeMeUIIOH TelI)J;eH HII B pa3BHTIIII TOJII,IW aHTpOrrOJIOrlIqeCKOH IIay-
RII, 0110 B 3naqIIT8JIhHOII CTerrerrIl xapaKTeplIO )J;JIH COBpeMelIHoro 3Tarra pa3-
BIITIIH HayqHbIX 3IIaHIIII B I:(eJIOM, CBIIJJ:eTeJII,CTBYH H 0 pacTym;en pa3pernaIO-
m;eH 3cpcpeKTIIBIIOCTII HayqIIhIX MeTO,ll,OB, rrepernarlIBaIOm;HX rpaHIIl(hI
OTlJ:eJII,lIhIX lJ:IIC IIrrJIIIII, R 0 Bce 60JIee BhICOKOM ypOBlIe IIJ[Terpa HII Teope-
THqeCKIIX KOII err IIH. Pa3MI,InaHlIe nOrpalIlIqlII,IX ccpep H IIHTepeCYIOm;eM
Hac CJIyqae IIaXO,ll,HT OTpameIIIIe II B B03UIIKHOBelIlIH II pa3BHTIIII TaKIIX
06JIaCTeli 3HaIJIfH, ROTOpbIe HOCHT lIalIlIIeIIOBaUIIH cnopTIIBHOH, Me,ZJ;II IlIICKOH
aIITpOrrOJIOrIIII, alITpOrrOJIOrIIH MaTepIIHCTBa II MJIa)J;elIqeCTBa H T. JJ:., H B IIe-
B03MOiRHOCTII OTlIeCTH TO II.1J1I IIHoe KOIIRpeTlIoe HCCJIe)J;OBaHHe K TOIl ImH
HIIOH RJIaCCIIcpHKal(I10HHOII py6pHKe.
CKaiReM, 06CJIep:OBaHlIe KaKon-TO H30JIUpOBaHIwn rrorrYJIHl(HII no IIa60py
reneTHqeCKHX MapRepOB - qTO 3TO, alITpOnOJIOrlIH HJIH rrorrYJIHl(IIOHHaH relIe-
TIIKa qeJIOBeKa? Momllo 6h1JIO 6I,I, IlaBepHoe, )J;orOBopIITI,CH 06 OTHecelIIIH
TaKoro IICCJIe,ZJ;OBaHIIH K ccpepe aHTpOrrOJIOrIlII HJIll rrorrYJIHl(I10IIHOll relIeTHKH
B 3aBIICIIMOCTII OT e.lIeH. KOTopbIe CTamIT rrepep, C060H II pernaeT aBTOp, HO
B npHIIl(lIne 3TO Bce paBliQ 6bIJIO 6bI HCKyccTBeHlIoH Orrepal(IIen. A eCTeCT-
BelIHee nOJIaraTI" qTO MbI CTaJIKIIBaeMCH 3lJ:eCh C IIOrpaHHqlIOII 3011011 MeiRJJ:Y
,ll,BYMH HaYKaMII, 30HOll, IWTopan rrpep:CTaB.lIHeT c060n He cTporyIO. ,ll,e-
MapKa IfOHHYIO JIIIIIIIIO, a .n:OCTaTOqHO rnHpOKoe rrpOCTpalICTBO B3aIIMonpo-
IIIIKHOBeUIIH MeTo.n:OB II TeOpeTIIqeCKIIX KOII err I1II. fl'cTaTII CRafJaTI" peaJIh-
lIaH p:eIIcTBIITeJII,UOCTI, )J:8.BIIO YiRe peIllIIJIa Ilp06JIellfY JJ:ecpIIIIIIl(IIII rrpaKTIIqe-
CKII, XOTH B TeOpeTIlqeCKOII JIIITepaType npOlJ:OJIiRaIOTCH CrrOpI,] 0 TOM, B Ka-
RIIX B3alIMOOTUOIllelIIIHX IIaX0.D:HTCH MeiRlJ:y C060H rronYJIH IIOHnaH relIeTlIK8
qeJIOBeKa II aIITpOrrOJIOrIIH.qacTI, MaTepIla.rra, II3JIaraeMOro 13 yqe6UIIKax 3TIIX
lUI, cIJ,IIrrJIIfII HBJIHeTCH 06m;eH. MaTeplIaJI 3TOT rroBTopHeTcH B alITpOrrOJIOrHqe-
CRIIX yqe6UlIKax II B yqe6IIhIX PYIWBo)J;cTBax rro rronYJIH IfOIIIIOII reHeTIIR8
qeJIOBeRa. To i-Re MOiRlIO CI,a3aTI, C rrOJIIII,IM rrpaBOM II rrpo cepI,e3UI,Ie CBO.n:-
III,le pa60TI,I CTporo IIayqHOrO cO)J;epmaHIIH. Bblpa3IITeJII,lII,Ill rrplIMep-
cpaBlIeHIIe cO)J;epiRaHIIH TpeThero 1I3.n:aHIfH II3BeCTIIoro PYROBO,ZJ;CTBa P. MapTH-
Ha, BbIIlle.fl,rnerO nOlJ: pe.n:aRI:(lIeH K. 3aJIJIepa \ C COrrepiRaHHeM JII060li KJIaC-
CHqeCKOII KHHrII rro norryJIHl(IIOIIIIOII relIeTIIKe qeJIOB£>Ka 4.
npIIMepI,I nO)J;06IIoro pO,ZJ;a MOiRHO 6hIJIO 6h1 JIerKO YMHOiRIITI" 110 II H3
IIpe)J;rneCTBYIOm;ero 1I3JIOiRelIIIH HCHa crrpaBeJJ;JIHBOCTb CCPOPMYJIIIpOBaHHoro
Te3Hca 0 pa3MhITOCTH II H3BeCTIIon IIeorrpeJIeJIelIIIOCTII rpaHII aUTpOnOJIOrIIH
CO MHorHlIfII CMeiImI,IMH IIaYKaMII. B 3TOM IIeT IIIIqero TpeBOiRlIOro, 3TO-
CJIe.D:CTBHe TelI,ZJ;eH IIIf IIayqHOro pa3BIITlIH cerop:IIHIllHerO )J;IIH: )J;lfcpcpepeH II-
PYHCI" 3HaHHe CTaHOBIITCH B TO iRe BpeMH Bce 60JIee eJIOCTHI,IM II HIITer-
plIpOBaHHI,IM.
t
,
142
HaKOIIe
, Cym;ecTByeT em;{) OWlH BamHbIH MOMeIIT, 0 KOTOPOJl.f lIe06XO.!!:II-
MO CKa3aTI,: KJI8CCIIcpIIKa:qIIH JIl060H HaYKII, B TOM qHC.rre II aHTpOIIOJIOI'IIII lIa
COBpellfeHIIOM :nane pa3BHTIUI, qT06bI 6hITI, ,ZJ;OCTaTOqnO 60I'aTOlr, 3BPlICTlIqlIOii
H OTpaiRaIOm;eH ,ZJ;eiicTBIITeJIhHOe M1I0I'006pa3lIe IIalIpaBJIeIUIH HayqlIOI'O pa3-
BlITlU!, .!!:OJIiRlIa CTaTI, MIIOI'OMepHOlr, a lIe JIlIIIeHnOlr. IhIbIMlI CJIOBaIlUr, B03-
MomHI,I B3anMop:OIIOJIHHIOm;lI{) K.TIaCCIIcplIKa
lIOHHI,Ie cxeMbI, OlIlIpaIOm;HeCH
IIa pa3HI,Ie HCXO.!!:III,Ie IIplIH
lInhI. He npeTelIp:YH na nOCTpoelIne lICqepnI,IBaIO-
m;eH MHorolllepnoH KJIaCclIcpHI{a
HlI aIITpOIIOJIOI'lIH lIa npe,ZJ;blp:ym;IIx CTpa-
IIH
aX, H nOnI,lTaJICH TeM lIe Mellee ;rraTI, npe,ZJ;CTaBJIelIIIe 0 TOM, KaKlIe Ha-
IIpaBJIenlIH ee pa3pa6oTKlI nalI60JIee nepClIeKTIIBI,I. HaMeqeHbI TPII TaKllX
HalIpaBJIeTIlIH: Tpa,ll,II
nOUHoe JIlIIIeHIIOe, IIpn KOTOpOM KJIaCClIcpIIKa
IIOHHaH
cxeMa CTpOIlTCH B COOTBeTCTBIIlI C 06JIaCTHMlI 3HaIHIH II BI,I,ll,eJIHIOTCH lIfOp-
40JIOI'lIH qeJIOBeKa, aHTpOII0I'eUe3, paCOBep:eIIIIe, cpII3lIOJIOrII'IeCKaH aHTpono-
JIOI'lIH; ClICTelllHo-cTpyKTypHoe, B COOTBeTCTBIIlI C KOTOpbIlIf KJIaCClIcpIII{a
IIH
OTpamaeT CTPYKTYPHble ypOBHII rrpe,ZJ;MeTa lIcc.lIe)J;OBaHlIH II CallfOI'O IICCJIeJJ;O-
BamUI, BIIYTPlI TaKOH K.:'IacccpIIKa
lIlI HaXO,ZJ;IIT ce6e lIfeCTO, HanpIIlIfep, lIfOJIe-
KYJIHpHaH aHTpOIIOJIOI'I1H 5; u;eJIeBOe, T. e. yqlITI,lBaIOm;ee IIpIIKJIap:Hble
eJIII
II 3ap:aQII, CTOHm;IIe npII IICII0.JII,30BalIlIlI aIITpOrrOJIOI'IIQeCKOI'O lIfa TepIIaJIa,
CKaiReM, KaK lICTO'IIIlIKa lICTOpnQeCKOlr lIlIcpopMa
lIII II npeBpam;aIOm;lIe 3TOT
lIfaTepIIaJI n IIpep:lIfeT 1I3yqelIlIH lICTOpIIQeCKOH aHTpOIID.'IOI'IIlI 6.
B npIIH
IIrre lIfHOI'OlIrepHaH KJIaCClIcplIKa
lIH, pa3YllfeeTCH, lIe IICQepnhIBa-
eTCH rrepeQIICJIeHHI,IlIflI acneKTallflI. MOiRHO, nO-BII)J;lIlIfollry, 6hIJIO 6h1 norrI,I-
TaTI,CH nOCTpOlITI, KJIaCClIcplfKa
IIOIIIIYIO cxeMY nOD;pa3.D:eJIeUIIH aHTpOrrOJIOI'lI-
QeCKOH IIaYKII, orrnpaHCI, Ha IfCnOJIh3yellfhIe lIfeTO.!!:hI lICCJIe.!!:OBaHIIH IIJIlI Ha
CTeneHI, rrpIIlIfeHelIlIH MaTeMaTlIQeCKOI'O arrnapaTa II cpopllfaJIlI3a
lIlI,- nO,ZJ;06-
HhIe cxellfhI lIfOI'YT 6hITI, Qpe3BhIQalIIIO rrOJIe3HhI .D:JIH KaKIIX-TO Cne
IIaJII,HhIX
I{eJIeH, oc06elIHO Tenepb. B CBH3II C TelIp:eH
lIelr pa3BlITlIH cpopMa.'1I13a:qlIlI
3B8UIIH Bo06m;e. Ho .D:aJII,UeHrnaH .!!:eTaJIlI3a
IIH KJIaCCIIcpIIKa
IIOHHhIX cxellf
aHTpOrrOJICI'I1II, eCTeCTBeIIHO, pe3YJIhTaT 6y.!!:ym;ero pa3BnTlIH caMOH HaYKII
RaR caMOCTOHTeJII,HOH 06JIaCTII 3IIaHIIH, a TaKiR£> .D:aJII,lIeiirnIIX IICCJIe.D:OBa-
TeJII,CKlIX YClIJIIIH, Cnel(lIaJII,HO Ha
eJIeIIIII,IX Ha pa3pa60TKY np06JIeM KJIaCCII-
cpHKa
lIIf HaYKlI. no rJIy6oKOMY y6emrrelIlIIO aBTopa, nplIH
Im II;OrrOJIHIITeJII,-
HOCTH H. Eopa HBJIHeTCH B 3TOH 06JIaCTH O)J;HOH lI3 OCHOEIII,IX MeTOrrOJIOI'H-
qeCRIIX npe)J;nOCI,IJIOK 7.
! CJlI., Harrp.: AllallbeB B. r. 0 rrpOOJIeMaX cOBpeMeHHoro 'IeJIOBeR03HaHIIH. M., 1977.
2 3y60B A. A. CO}J;epmaHIIe rrOHHTIIH «aHTpOrrOJIOrlIm) Ha cOBpeMeHHoM ypoBHe pa3-
BIITIIH II IIHTerpaI(IIII HaYRII B CCCP II COB. 3THorpaqllIH. 1982. oM 2; /{y60Ba H. A.
o HeRoTopbIX acrreRTax cO}J;epmaHIIH aHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCROII HaYRII II COB. 3THorpaqllIH.
1983. oM 6.
3 Martin R., Saller K. Lehrbuch del' Anthropologie in systematischer Darstellung mit
besonderer Beriicksichtigung del' anthropologischen Methoden. Bd. I-IV. Stuttgart,
1957-1965.
& CM.: Race R., Sanger R. Blood groups in man. Oxford: Edinburgh, 1970; Cavalli-
Sforza L., Bodmer W. The genetics of human populations. San Francisco, 1971.
A.lenceeB B. n. MOJIeRYJIHpHbIe acrreRTbI aHTpOrrOJIOrlllI. M., 1974: Zllckercandl E.
Perspectives in molecular anthropology ilClassification and human evolution. Chi-
cago, 1963; Goodman Ill., Tashian R. (ed.). Molecular anthropology. Genes and pro-
teins in the evolutionary ascent of the primates. N. Y.- L.. 1975.
6 BbrrDe 6bIJIII CcPOpMy.TIlIpOBaHbI KaR cPYH,I1aJlICHTa.TIbHblC, TaR II rrpIlR':Ia}J;Hble rrpo6:rmIbI
IICTOpll'leCROII aHTpOrrOJIOrll1l. ,l],OIIOJIHIITeJIbHO CM.: A.
enceeB B. n. I1CToplI'IecKaH
aHTpODOJIOrIIH. M., 1979: Oll :!ICe. 3THoreHe3. M., 1986.
7 CTaTbII II BbIcTYIIJIeHIIH Ha 3TY TeMY co6paHbI B CoopHIIRe: Bop H. ATo:\IHaH cP lI -
3IIRa II '1eJIOBe'IeCROe rr03HaHlIe. M.. 1961. CJlL Tahilie: (/Jon B. A. KmHToaaH cP lI -
3IIRa II cP0JIOcm!'1Cl\Ue rrp06JIeMbI Ii Boap. q1l1JIOcocPlIn. 1971. .I¥!! 3. i:ha CTaTbH IT£,-
perre'laTaHa B RH.: Bop H. 1136paHHble HaY'IHblC TPY;J:bI. T. II: CTaTbII 1925-1961.
M., 197'1.
qacTb BTOpaH
TEOPETMqECRME IIPOEJIEMbI
8THOrEHETMQECRMX PEROHCTPYRQIIM
EII:J;E P A3 0 TIOCT AHOBRE TIPOBJIEM
8THOrEHE3A
ROMllJIERC BAYK H O]J:HA HAYKA
I
B CBHSII C lllIpOKIIM paSBepTbIBaHIIeM IICCJIep;OBaHIIH IIO 3THII'IeCKOH IICTOpiiD
HapOp;OB CCCP II MeCTOM, KOTOpOe SaHIIMaIDT B 8TIIX IICCJIegoBaHIIHX np06JIe-
MbI IIpOIICXOmp;eHJIH OTp;eJIbITbIX IIapogoB, TeOpeTII'IeCKaH paSpa60TKa BOIIpO-
COB 8THOreHeSa B COBeTCKOH HCTOpII'IeCKOH .IIIITepaType SaHIIMaeT CYIIJ;eCT-
BeHHOe MeCTO. "Y'IeHIIe 0 CMeHe 06IIJ;eCTBeHHO-<JKOHOMII'IeCKIIX <pOpMaI{HH
HaIIIJIO KOHKpeTHOe OTpameHIIe B nOIIbITKe BbI}J;eJIIITb OCHOBHble 8TanbI 8THII-
'IeCKOH IICTOplIII 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa 1. OTp;eJIbIIble TeOpeTII'IeCKlIe np06JIeMbI
3THOreneSa - He06xogIIl\IOCTb KOMIIJIeKCHOrO nop;xop;a K <JTHM np06JIeMaM,
yp;eJll.HbIH BeC paSHbIX MaTepHaJIOB B OCBeIIJ;eHIIII 3THOreHeTII'IeCKOrO IIpO-
I{eCca, COOTHOlleHIIe IIIICbMeHHbIX HCTO'IIIIIKOB II 8THOrpa<pII'IeCKIIX, apXeOJIO-
rII'IeCKIIX, a TaKme aHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX - Heop;HOKpaTHO OCB0IIJ;a-
JIIICb B COBeTCKOH HCTOplI'IeCKOiI II 8THorpa<pII'IeCKOH JIIITepaType 2. KOHKpeT-
HaH pO Jib paSHbIX MaTeplIaJIOB B KOMnJIeKCUOH paspa60TKe BOIIpOCOB IIpOIIC-
xomp;eHIIH Hapop;OB TaKme npO,D;eMOHCTplIpOBaHa B CneIJ;IIaJIbHbIX pa60Tax:
aHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCIWrO, CHameJ\f,- B CTaTbe r. «P. )J,e6eIJ;a, M. r. JIeBIIHa II
T. A. TpO<pIIMOBOH S, apXeOJIOrII'IeCIWrO - B CTaTbe II. H. TpeTbHKOBa \
JIIIHrBIICTH'IeCKOrO - B CTaTbe f. C. KHa6e 5.
KasaJIocb 6bI, nOCJIe Bcex YK<lS<lHHbIX pa60T HeT IIym}J;bI CHOBa BOSBpa-
m:aTbCH KO BceM 8TIIM BonpocaM. TeM He MeIIee pasH060H, KOTOpbIII BbIHBJIH-
eTCH }J;ame BO BSrJIHp;aX CneIJ;IIaJIHCTOB, KaK TOJIbKO saTpamBaIOTCH 8TuoreHe-
TII'IeCKIIe TeMbI, He MomeT 6bITb OCTaBJIeH 6es BHIIMaHHH. XapaHTepua B
8TOM OTHOIIIeHIIII KHIIra «P. II. «PIIJIIIHa 6, nOCBHIIJ;eHHaH paCCMorpeHUID npo-
IIcxom.r:reHIIH BOCTO'IHOCJIallHIICKIIX HapO,J:OB nop; yrJIOM speHIIH JIIIHrBIICTII'Ie-
CKIIX gaHHbIX. KHIIra nplIBJIeKaeT BHHMaHIIe TIIJ;aTeJIbHbIM aHaJIIISOM 3TllX
p;aHIIbIX, IIHTepeCHOH nOCTaHOBKOH IJ;eJIoro pH.r:ra BonpOCOB II, HecmIHeHIIO,
IIpep;CTaBJIHeT orpOMUbIH IIHTepec P;JIH CneIJ;lIaJIIICTOB, B TOH IIJIII HHOH Mepe
COrrpIIJ{aCaIOIIJ;IIXCH co CJIaBHHCKIIM ;:JTIIOreHeSOM. Ho BonpeKII TeOpeTII'IeCKO-
MY TeSIICY 0 IIeo6xoD:IIMOCTII KOMnJIeKCHOro IIop;XO}J;a K pelleHIIIO 8THoreIIe-
Tll'IeCKIIX IIp06JIeM, ):(OKa3aHHOMY II npaKTII'IeCKII ycnellHbIMlI pi'nYJIbTaTa-
MII COIIOCTaBJIeHIIH paSHbIX }J;aHIIbIX, aBTOp 06'bHBJIHeT, 'ITO nOCJIeIl.uee CJIOBO
B 8THOreHeTlI'IeCKIIX IICCJIegOBaHIIHX OCTaeTCH sa JIIIHrBHCTII'IeCKIIM aHaJIIISOM.
IIplI 8TmI OH IICXO.r:rIIT IIS Toro, TITO OCHOBHbTl\I 8THII'IeCKIIl\I onpe;J;CJIJITeJIeM HB-
JIHeTCH HSbIK.
IIpIIMepbI O}J;HOCTopOHHero IICnOJIbSOBaHIIH KaKorO-HII6YAb O}J;Horo BJII}J;a
IICTOpII'IeCKHX IICTO'IHIIKOB MomHO YBeJIII'IHTb. TaK, TOJIbKO Ha OCHOBaHIIII
apxeOJIom'IeCRIIX p;aHHbIX 'IaCTO paCCMaTpIIBaIOTCH OTp;eJIbHble MOMeHTbI B
p;peBHeiI: IICTOplIH JIH}J;oeBpOIIeHCKHX Hapop;OB II pellaIOTCH np06JIeMbI IIX npo-
Hcxomp;eHIIH. Sp;eCb l\fOmHO YIIOMHJIYTb pa60TbI A. fl. EpIOCOBa 7, B KOTOpbIX
144
.r:reJIaIOTCH OTBeTCTBeIIIIble BbIBOp,bI 0 IIpapOp;IIHe II p,peBHIIX MlIrpaIJ;IIHX IIHAO-
eBpOneHIJ;eB Ha 6ase CpaBUeHHH apXeOJIOrlI'IeCROrO IIHBeHTapH paSJIII'IHbIX
KYJIbTYP IOra eBpOneHCKOH 'IaCTU CCCP. MemP,Y TeM KaK pas B 8TOH 06JIaCTII
JIIIHrBHCTIIKa HaKOnIlJIa 60JIbllOe KOJIII'IeCTBO gaHubIx, npOJIIIBaIOIIJ;HX CBeT Ha
TeMJ:bIe CTpaUHQbJ HJIJJ;OeBpOneHCKoii IICTOpUII 8. B peSYJIbTaTe R 6eC'IIICJIeU-
HbIM rUlIOTesaM uHgoeBpoueiicKOH npapOJJ;llHbI 9 npU6aBIIJIaCb eIIJ;e op;Ha,
060CHOBaHuaH, KaK JI OCTaJII,JIbIe, JIIIllib 'IaCTI,IO BceM COBOKYIIHOCTII p;aHHblx II
n08ToMY ue MorYIIJ;aH IIpeTeH,lIOBaTb Ha nOJInyID y6eIDITeJIbHOCTb.
MbI BIIIDIM, 'ITO 06cymJJ;eHIIe nYTeI1:, 3TanOB H <pOpM 3TUOreUeTII'IeCKIIX
IICCJIeJJ;OBaIIIIH aKTyaJIbHO II B HacTOflllJ;ee BpeMH. HIIme p,eJIaeTCH nOIIbITKa
KpIITII'IeCKII paCCMOTpeTb yp;eJIbHbIH Bec pasHblx MaTepIIaJIOB B peIIIeHlIu
8THoreHeTU'Iecmrx sap;a'I U onpep;emITb nYTH IIX conOCTaBJIeHIIH.
HCTOPHqECRHEPAMKH
3mOrElIETHqECROrO HCCJIE.D:OBAHHH
Ha nepBbIH BSrJIHg KameTCH, 'ITO 3THOreUeTII'IeCKIIe BonpoCbI MomHO pe-
lliaTI, C IIOMOIIJ;bIO OJ(HIIX TOJIbKO IIIICbMeHHbIX IICTO'IHIIKOB, oc06euHo B Tex
CJIY'IaHX, Korp;a IIX 'IIICJIO BeJIIIKO, a <pOpMupoBaHIIe 3THII'IeCKOH cneIJ; II <p IIKII
HapoJJ;a naJJ;aeT Ha nosJJ;HIOID 3noxy. TaK, HanpIIMep, IIIICbMeHHbIe IICTO'IHHKII
.r:r aIDT BOSMomHOCTb 06CTOHTeJIbHO HCCJIeJJ;oBaTb MuorIIe npoIJ;eCCbI 8THII'IeCKOM
IICTOplIII PYCCKoro Hapop;a 10. AHaJIOrlI'IHbIM 06pasoM Bemma IIX pOJIb B IIS-
Y'IeHIIII 8THoreHesa, cKamellI, MuorlIX HapoAoB CeBepIIoro KaBKasa, CJIO<RHB-
JIIIIXCH TaKme BO II TbTCH'IeJIenIII H. 3. 11 B IIOCJIeJJ;HeM CJIY'Iae, npaBp;a, KO-
JIII'IeCTBO nlICbMeHHbIX IICTO'IHIIKOB MHoro MeUblle, 'IeM B IIepBOM, n OHII CO-
AepmaT B CIIJIY CBoeH CIIeIJ;II<pHKII (HeMeCTuoe nponcxomgeIme) MHoro JIaKYH.
Op;uaKO BOSMomUOCTII IICIIOJIbSOBaHHH nIICbMeHHbIX IICTO'IHIIKOB BO MIIorOM
onpeAeJIHIOTCH IIX npoIIcxomgeHII::JM II xapaKTepOM, IIHbIMII CJIOBaMII, npHuaJJ;-
JIemaT OUII TOMY Hapogy, npOHCXOmJJ;eHlIe KOToporo IISY'IaeTCH, IIJIII ero CO-
CelIHM, naXOp;UJIIICb JIH 8TH cocegIJ C HHM B gpymecTBeHHbIX OTHOIIIeHTIHX IIJIII
BO Bpamn:e6IIbIX. HeflcHoe IlSJIORieUIle II HenOJIHOTa coxpaHHaCTII nIICbMeIIHblX
naMHTHIlKOB ycyry6JIHlOT TPyp,HOCTII HX nCTOJIKHOBarnIH 12.
OLlHaKO OCHOBHble He;WCTaTKIJ nIJCbMeIJIIbIX IICTO'IHIlKOB P;JIH IJ;eJIeH 3THO-
reHeTIl'IeCKOrO IlCCJIep;OBaHIIH JIemaT game lIe B 8TOM. OHH SaKJIIO'IaIOTCH B
IIX KpaHHeH BbI60pO'IHOCTIJ no OTHOlleIIHID K sa<pIIKCIIpOBaHHbIM B IIIIX
HBJIeHIIHM HCTOpU'IeCKOH mIISHlI. Muorne BamHble n IIMeIOIIJ;Ile 3THII'IeCKOe
SHa'IeHIle oc06eHHocTII HSbIKa U KYJIbTypbI IIapoAa He HaxogHT B HllX OTpa-
meHIIH, He rOBopH yme 0 BXOAHllJ;IIX B ero COCTaB 8Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX H Tep-
pHTOpIIaJIbHbIX rpynnax. JIeTonlICIJ;bI 'IaCTO ue OCTaHaBJIIIBaIOTCH ua HIlX npo-
CTO nOTOMY, 'ITO B IIX rJIasax 3TII OC06SHHOCTII He urpalOT IIIIKaKOH pOJIII,
p;aJ-Re B TOM CJIY'Iae, eCJIIl OHTI nIIlliYT 0 CBoellI c06CTBeHHOM Hapop;e. ECJIlf
me MbI nOJIbsyeMcH JIeTOnIICHbBIlI CBlI)J:eTeJIbCTBaMH cocep;eH, TO TeM 60JIee
OHII no CBoeH HenOJIUOTe II npOTlIBOpe'IllBOCTU HeJJ;OCTaTO'IHbI ,T:(JIH CKOJII,KO-
HII6YJJ;b 06CTOHTeJIbIIOrO cymneHIlH, - BcnOMHIIIII TOJIbKO nOJIeMIIKY no IIOBO-
gy Mepii 13, 6YPTaCOB a, Xa3ap 15. A Begb 3TO HapOiJbI cpaBUIlTeJIbHO 6JIIIS-
KIIe K COBpeMeHUOCTII; npn YiIaJIeJIIIH OT HaIJJIIX gHeH cy6'beKTIlBllSM B
nOlIbITKax oTomAeCTBJIeHIIH 8TUII'IeCKIIX HaIIMeHOBaHIIH, BCTpe'IaIOIIJ;IIXCH B
paSHbIX llCTO'IHIlKaX, yneJIII'IIlBaeTCH TaK me, KaK II B OTHOIIIeHIIII IlX K on-
peAeJIeHHbIM HSbIlWBbIM ceMbHM. Ho ecmI )J:aJ-Re JIeTOnIICeIJ; II <pIIKcIlpyeT
KaKYIO-HJI6Y;J;b BaJ-KJIYIO ):(eTaJIb HSbIKa IIJIII MaTepIIaJIbHOH KYJIbTypbI, TO OIl
.r:reJIaeT 3TO B TaKOH <popMe, ROTopaH He gaeT BOSl\lOmHOCTII IICnOJIbSOBaTb IIX
B a,eJIaTeJIbHOH Mepe. TaJ\IIM 06paSOM, OCHOBHOH HeTIOCTaTOK IIOAaBJIHIOIIJ;erO
60JIbIIIIIHCTBa nIICbMeIlHbIX naMHTIIIIKOB SaKJIIO'IaeTCH B (<DIISKOH KBaJIII<pIIKa-
145
QIlII» IIX aBTOpOB C TO'IRH SpeHIlH COBpeMeHHOH HaYKII - cop;epmallJ;aHCH B
(lIlX HH<pOpMaIJ;IJH IIMeeT CJIIIIIIROM MHOrO npOOeJIOB. 8TO Jf{e OTHOCHTCH II R
reorpa<pll'IeCRIIM OnIICaHUHM, WJRYMeHTaM XOSHHCTBeHHOH OT'IeTHOCTII II T. ,TJ;.
Bce CKaSaHHOe B nO.TInoe Mepe pacnpOCTpaIIHeTCH )J,aiRe Ha p;OKYMeHTaJIh-
HbIH IICTOpII'IeCRllii MaTepIIaJI noc.TIep;uero TbICH'IeJIeTIIH. Ho Be):(b saJJ;a'Ia
8THoreHeTII'IeCROrO llCCJIe)J,OhanllH COCTOIIT lIe TOJIbRO B TOM, 'ITOObI npOCJIe-
P;IITb )J,HHaMllKY 8TUII'IeCRIIX npOQeCCOB B pa"'IRax YCTaHOBHBIIIeHCH 8THII'Ie-
CKOH OOIIJ;HOCTII, a npeJf{ge Bcero B TOM, 'iTOObI BbIHBIITb ee IlCTOKII H onpe-
p;eJIIITb 3THII'IeCRIIe KOMnOUeHTbJ, npIIHHBIIIIIe Y'IaCTIIe B Be <P0pMIIpOBaIIIIII.
TaKIIM oopaSOM, pe'Ib I{OJImna II)J,TH 0 npoQeccax H HBJIeJIUHX, npOHBUBIIIIIX-
CH ropaSIIO panee nOCJIeJ.l,HerO TbJCH'IeJIeTIIfI. IIo OTHOIIIeHHID K 8TIIM 3noxaM
JJllCbMeHHbIe IICTO'IHURII eIIJ;e oOJIee <pparMeHTapHbJ II npOTIlBOpe'IIIBbI. Mem-
P;Y TeM II OHII He CTaBHT IIpeJJ;eJIa 8TuoreHeTII'IeCKOMY llCCJIegOBaHIIIO. Ha
TeppIITopIIHX, HBJIHIOIIJ;UXCR eCTeCTBeHUbJMII IlSOJIHTaMII, 3THII'IeCKIIe npo
IJ;eCCbI 'IaCTO IIpOIICXOP;HT saMRHYTO II Ha npOTHmeHIIH TbICH'IeJIeTUH He llC-
nbITbIBaIDT SIIaTIIITeJIbHbIX BJIllHHIIH co CTOpOUbI. I1CTORII 3THII'IeCRIIX OOllJ;HO-
CTeH B TaRIIX CJIY'IaHX BOCXOJ],HT IIHorp;a K 8IIOXe 6pOHSbI, a TO H I\ OOJIee
paHueMY BpeMeHII. B Ra'IeCTBe npIIMepa MOIRHO HaSBaTh HapOJJ;bI. HaCeJIHIO-
IIJ;IIe lJ;eIITpaJIbHbIe npep;ropl,H r.;raBHoro KaBRascRoro xpeOTa. 00 IIX npouc-
xomgBHIIIl nIlCbMeHHblX IICTO'IHIIROB npOCTO HeT - Hll -qymIIX, JIll MeCTUbIX.
TaRIIM oopaSOM, HpllypO'IeHUOCTb 8THoreueTU'IeCRIIX npOQeCCOB R paSHbIM
nepIIO)J,aM BpeMeUII Y paSJIII'IHbIX HapogcB II, CJIegoBaTeJIbHO, IIIIIpORIIe paM-
RH 8THoreHeTII'IeCROrO IICCJIeJJ;OBaUIIH caMII no ceoe OrpaHII'IIIBaIDT BOSMom-
HOCTb IICnOJIbSOBaHIJR B HeM IICTOpII'IeCKIIX gaHllbIx B Y3KOM CMbICJIe CJIO-
Ba - peSYJIbTaTOB IISY'IeHIIH JIeTOHIICUblX naMHTHIIIWB II JJ;PyrIIx nlICbMeH-
HbIX p;OKYMeHTOB. POJIb 3TIIX IICTO'IUIIROB BeJIIIKa LlJIH 3nOXII cpe)J,HeBeKOBbH,
HO OrpaHll'IeHUa p;.TIH 3nOXII paHHero /ImJlesa ('IaCTII'IHO H OpOHSbI) II npaR-
TII'IeCKII paBHa UYJIIO )J,JIH 60JIee paHUIIX :::ITanOB HCTOpIIIl 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa
(IIclmIO'IeHIIe COCTaBJIHIOT JIIIIIIb OOJIaCTII p;peBHeBOCTO'IUbIX QIIBIIJIIISaIJ;IIH).
1131>11\ RAK 3THHqECRHII OIIPE)J;EJIIITEJII>
TOT <paRT, 'ITO RSbIR HBJIHeTCR OP;HIIM IIS rJIaBHbIX 3THII'IeCRIIX OIIpep;eJIIITe-
JIeH, OOllJ;eIISBeCTeH II He HymrraeTcH HII B p;OKaSaTeJIbCTBaX, HM B oocymJJ;e-
HUll. B nogaBJIHIOllJ;eM OOJIbIIIIIUCTBe CJIY'IaeB HSbIROBaH npMuagJIemHOCTb COB-
nap;aeT C caMocosuaUIIeM II, TaRUM oopaSOM, 8TII Hap;emUbIe KpIITeplIH 3THoca
)XeHCTBYIDT COrJIaCOBaHHO. IICI\JIIO'IeHUH, npOUCTeRaIOIQIIe OObI'IHO sa C'IeT
HeHOpMaJIbHbIX YCJIOBIIll. B KOTOpbIe nOCTaBJIen TOT IIJIII IIHOH Hapop; 'IallJ;e
Bcero IIOJIIITIIKOll HaIJ;IIOHa:rbHoii P;IICKpUMIIuaQUII, cpaBHIITeJIbHO pep;RII. HalI-
oOJIee RpRIIH lIpIJMep 3TOMY - HerplITHHcRIIH Hapop; B CIIIA. rOBOpHIQIIH Ha
aHrJIIIHCKOM HSbme, IIO B pesYJIbTare paCIICTCKOH nOJIHTIII\ll rrpaBIITeJIbCTBa
COSHaIOIIJ;IIH ceoH caMocToHTe.TIblIOH e):(IIHIIu;eH B paMRax aMepIIRaHCROH ua-
IJ;IIII. <D. II. <DIIJIIIH. rro-BIIp;IIMOMY, npaB Ror)J,a mIlleT 0 pe,!J,ROCTII TaRlIx
HBJIeHIIH II 0 npeIIMYIQeCTBeHUOH nprrypO'IeHHOCTII IlX K 8IIoxe KaIIIITaJIIISMa.
Ho lIS 8Toro Bce me He CJIegyeT, 'ITO JIlIlIrBIICTll'IeCRlIe ,!J,aHUbIe HBJIHIOTCH
pellaIOIIJ;IIMII, RaK OH npeJJ;llOJIaraeT, B JIIOOOM 8THII'IeCROM IICCJIe)]:OBaHIIII.
Ha'IaTb C Toro, 'ITO O'IeHb 'IaCTO nepexop; Ha HOBbIH HSbIK He conpOBom-
p;aeTCH CMeUOH HaCeJIeHIIH, T. e. HOBbIH HSbIR BocnpIIHIIMaeTCH B peSYJIbTa-
Te KYJIbTypHoro, a He 8THII'IeCKOrO BSaIIMOgeHCTBIIR 16 0 OcooeHHO 'IeTKO
3TO MomHO IIpoc.TIegMTb B Tex CJIY'IaHX, Korp;a p;Ba BCTYIIIIBIIIMX B KOHTaKT
HapOlJ;a saMeTHO paSJIII'IaIOTCH no aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCRoMy TIlny ll, CJIe,!J,o-
Bare.TIbnO, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKII€ gaHIIbIe MorYT npIIHTII Ha nOMoIIJ;b B IIsY'Ie-
IIHII 8THll'IeCKIIX npOIJ;eCcoB. Xapar{TepUbIe IIpIIMepbI TOMY ua KaBKase-
146
6aJIRapIJ;bI, Rapa'iaeBl bI, OCeTIIUbI II aSep6aHp;maHQbI, 0 'IeM 6ygeT CKaSaHO
nO.D;p06Hee )J,aJIbIIIe.
BTOpOH HeJJ;OCTaTOR JIIIHr13IICTlI'IeCRIIX MaTeplIaJI013, ropasgo 60JIee cYllJ;e-
CT138HUbIH, SaRJIIO'IaeTCH B HX HenOJIIIOTe, KaI, TOJIbRO MbI IIepeXOp,IIM R
gpeBIIIIM 8nOXallI. IIpa13rra, 8TO He OTHOCIITCH R BeJIIIRIUI IJ;llBIIJIIISaIJ;IIHM ApeB-
IIOCTII, HSbIRII IWTOPbIX I1SY'IeIIbI ue xyme CJBpeMeHIIbIX. Ho no cpaBHeIIHIO
C orpO:MHLL\I 'IIICJIO I j pe13IIIIX HapOJ].013 erIlnTHue IIJIII aCCHpIIHU;bI coc-raBJIH-
lOT IIII'ITOa UOe MeHI>lTIIIIICTBO. Bo Bcex me )],pyrnx CJIy'IaHX HaXO)IHllJ;IIeCH B
IIarneM pacnopHmeHIIII JJ;aHHbIG TaR013bI, 'ITO JJ;OnYCRaIDT CaMble paSJIII'IHbIe
TOJIROBaIIHHo BcnOMHIIM 13 Ra'IeCT13e npII:\Iepa ;UICRYCCIIlO 0 pOJl,CT13e p,peBUIIX
HSbIROn IIepe.D;HeH ASHII C II6epO-RaBRaSCRIIMII 17 I1JIII 0 H3bIROBOH npIluag-
:remHOCTII ):(OpHMCRoro II JJ;orpe'IeCROrO HaCeJIemlH AneUHllHCKoro II BammH-
CRoro nOJIyoc-rpOBOB 18. EOJIblTIIIHCT130 CBep,eJIIIll 0 )],peBHHx HSbIKax, H9
IIMeBlTIIIX CBoeH nIICbMeuHOCTIl, )J,OIIIJIOJJ;O Hac B nepep,a'Ie cocep,eH, 'IaCTO ue
nonIIMaBlTIIIX 3TIIX HSbIROB, 'ITO ellJ;e 60JIee ycyry6JIHeT I1X HegocTo13spHOCTb.
IIpa13):(a, TOJIbRO 'ITO npII13e):('8HHble npIIMepbI KacaIOTCH nbIMeplTIIIX HSbI-
ROB, II, RaSaJIOCb 6bI, eCJIII H3bIR JJ;omII.TI )],0 conpeMeHHOCTII II IJMeeTCH BOS-
MomnOCTb IIpII13JIe'Ib )],JIH anaJIIISa nOJIUble .D;aIInbIe 0 ero COCTOHHIIII, TaRIIe
J.IICRYCCIIH IICh.;fIO'If'HbL O,lIHaRO 3TO ue BcerJJ;a BepHo. TaR, HaHplIMep, ne-
CMOTpH Ha 'IpeS13bI'IaIIHO TIIJ;aTeJIbnO c06pannbIe II IIOJIHbIe MaTepIIaJIbI He
TO.TIbRO no apMHUCKOMY JIIITeparypuOMY HSbIRY - aIIIxapa6apy, no II no ero
,;J;IIaJIeRTaM, JJ;O CliX lIOp O):(HII IICCJIe.D;onaTeJIII OTHOCHT ero R IIImoe13poneHCROH
H3bIROBOH ceMbe II YCTaHaBJIIIBalOT ero pOJICTBO C JJ;peBHIIMU BbIMeplTIIIMII
HSbIRaMII BaJIRaUCROro no.TIYOCTpOBa H., Torp;a KaI{ p,pyrne naxop,HT 13 HeM
)fOllJ;HbIM u6epO-KaBRaSCRIIII CYOCTpaT 20. Ho IIame eCJIII OCTa13IITb B CTopOHe
TaRIIe CnOpUbIe CJIY'IaII, 'IIICJIO ROTOpbIX 13 06llJ;eM cpa13HIITeJIbHO He13eJIIIKO,
neCMOTpH Ha rpOMaJJ;UbIe ycnexll cpa13HIITeJIbIIO-IICTOpU'IeCROrO MeToga B 130C-
CTan013JIeHIIII JJ:peBHIIX pe'IeBbIX <pOPM BbIMeplTIlIX HSbIROB-OCHOB, nOJIY'IaIO-
IIJ;IIeCH p. ROUCTpYKQrnI rrame B IIpeJl,eJIax XOpOlTIO lISY'IeUIIbIX HSbIROBbIX ce-
)reH neJIbSH C'IIITaTb nOJJTIOCTbIO HaJJ;emHbIMII. A 6es ;noro IIeJIb3H C'IHTaTb-
HajIemHbIMII H SaR.1IIO'IeHIIH 0 pO;J;CTBe JJ;peRIIIJX H3bII\OB MejI{)],Y C060H.
HaRoHeIJ;, CJIeayeT OTMeTIITb II TO OOCTOHTeJIbCTBO, "ITO JIHHr13IICTlI'IeCRIIK
coc-raB game XOpOIIIO IISY'IeHHOH B 3TOM OTHOUIeHIIII EBponbI, oc06eHHO na-
CeJIH13lTIIIX ee gpe13uIIx HapogoB, IICCJIei\OBau He naCTOJIbRO, 'ITOObI Momrro,
ObJJIO lICKJIIO'IIITb CYllJ;eCTB013aUIIe 13 lIpOIIIJIOM KaKIIX-TO HeIIS13eCTHbIX HSbIROB
II game JISbIROBbIX CeMeH. 06paIIJ;aIOT Ha ceOH 13HIIMaHIIe 13 8TOM CBHSII He-
HCHOCTb TonOHIIMIIRII Bo.TIrO-ORCRoro Memp,ype'IbH II TPYJJ;UOCTH ee IICTOJIRO-
3aHHH C nmroUJ;blO COBpeMeIIHbIX HSbIR013. MomeT 6bITb, RaK npe)J;nOJIaraeT
E. A. CepeopeHHIIR013 21, MbI CTa.'IRIIBaeMCH SrreCb C BbIMepIIIIIM CTpoeM pe'IIIo
A B 8TOM CJIY'Iae HCCJIeJJ;013aTeJIb-JIIIHr13IICT, RaR IIpa13IIJIO, 6eCCIIJIeH OC13eTIITb.
reHeTIl'IeCRIIe CEHSH BbIMepUlero HSbIRa. nOTOMY 'ITO B ero pacIIopHmeuIIII Ha-
XOITHTCH .'IIHIIb O'IeHb HenOJIIIbIe JJ;aHHbIe, J],OCTaBJIeHIIble TononlIMIIKoH II, CJIe-
J013aTe.'TbUO, no HeooxogIlMocTII BbIOOpO'IHbIe II HOCHIIJ;IIe O'IeHb CIIeIJ;lI<pII'Ie-
CI.;IIII xapaRTep. KCTaTII CRasaTb, nOIIblTRII IICTIOJIbS013aTb B TaRoII cIITyaIJ;IIII
.iIJIlr13IICTII'IeCRHe gaHHble II HenpeMeHHO COrJIaC013a-rb IlK CO CHemIIbIMlI,
B 'IaCTHOCTII C apxeOJIOnPleCI I1MII, IIplIBeJIII HeROTopbIX IICCJIeIJ;OBaTeJIeH K
TmlY, 'ITO na npOTHmeHIIII UeCROJIbRIIX JIeT OUH BbICRaSbIBaJIII npHMO npOTII-
EOnOJIOmHble rIITIo-reSbI 22 .
HeC"hO.'IbRO CJI013 0 TOnOHII:\IIIRe II ee pOJIlI E 3TuoreUeTII'IeCRIIX IICCJIeJJ;O-
S3HIIHK. TonOHIIMIIRa npeJ],CTa13JIHeT C060H, HeCOMHeHHO, lIIOIIJ;Hoe cpegcT130'
.JoUapymeHIIH p,peBHIIx 3THII'IeCRHX IIJIaCTOB Ha TOH IIJIII HHOH TeppiiTopIIII.
TaR, Hallplulep, pacnpocTpaHeuIIe 6a:rTIIIICKOII TonOHIIMIIRII B BepxHeM IIo-
J.HPnpOBbe 23 - <paRT 'IpeS13bI'IaHHOH BamHOCTII gJIH 8THII'IeCROH IICTOplI1I CJIa-
147
.
,
BHn II 6aJITOB II EbIHCHeHIIH IIX BsaIIMOOTIIOIIIeHIIH. IIpIIMepbI TaKIIX <paRTOB
MmInIO 6bIJIO ObI nplIBeCTII BO MHomeCTBe. Ho HegocTaToK TOfiOllllMII'IeCKllX
MaTepIIaJIOB COCTOIIT B TOM, 'ITO OllII B no,rraBJIHIOllJ;eM 60JIblliIIHCTBe CJIY'IaeB
ue MorYT 6bITb gaTIlpOBanbI. IIpaBp;a, IIHorga npii TIIJ;aTeJIbHOM aHaJIII3e na-
SBaHIIH MomHO YJIOBllTb B UIIX RaKlIe-TO <pOpMbI CJIOBOIISMeHeHllH, npllYpo-
qellHhIe B IICTOpIIH HSbIKa R onpe)XeJIeHHOMY nepIIO):(Y 21,. Ho TaRaH BOSlVIOm-
UOCTb CRopee IICR.TIIO'IeHIIe, 'IeM npaBIIJIO. B IJ;eJIOM JRe nOCJIe YCTaHOBJIeHIIH
C nOMOIIJ;bIO TonOHIIMII'IeCRHX JJ;aHHbIX <paHTOB npIICYTCTBHH Tex IIJIII HHbIX
uapop;OB Ha IICCJIep;yeMoH TeppiiTopIIll AJIH onp geJIeHIIH BpeMeHII IIX npe6bI-
BaUIIH Ha Hell Bce paBllo uymuo nplI6eraTb K <paKTII IeCKOMY MaTepllaJIY
CMemHbIX AIICIJ;IIITJIIIH.
IIO)1bITOfhIIBaH cRasauHoe, MOiliHO YTBepmI{aTl" 'ITO SHa'ieHlIe HSbIRa RaR
3THII'IeCROrO onpegeJIIITe.TIH B cOBpeMeHHYID 8noxy ellJ;e He JJ;aeT HaM npaBa
paCCMaTplIBaTb IIMenHO JIlllIrBIICTIITleCHIIe p;aHHhIe B Ka'IeCTBe OCHOBHOH 6aSbI
P;JIH 3THoreHeTIITIeCKIIX IIOCTpoeHIIH. TaKoe IIpeyneJIII'IeUUOe IICnOJIbSOBaHIIe
op:Horo BIIp;a IICTOplI'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIKOB B YIQep6 P;PyrlIM BonpeRII MHeHIIIO
HeKoTopbIX HSbIROBegoB MomeT npllBeCTII ue K 06'beKTIIBIISaIJ;IIII 8THII'IeCKOrO
IICCJIegoBaHllH, a K ero OgUOCTOpOHHOCTll II nOTepe IIH<popMaIJ;1I1I BMeCTO CTpO-
r{)H II nomIOH oIJ;eHRll 8THII'IeCKOrO npoIJ;ecca. Ho II npoTIIBOnOJIOmHaH Teu-
geuIJ;IIH 6bIJIa 6bI uelIpaBIIJIbHa: B pHJI,e CJIy'IaeB JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKllH MaTepIIaJI
p;aeT peIIIaIOllJ;ee p;OKaSaTeJIbCTBO nponCXOm;1,eHllH Hapop;OB Ha onpep;eJIeHUOH
TeppllTopHII.
3THorp A HTIECRHE .D:AHHbIE H 3THOrEHE3
3Ha'ieHlIe 3THorpa<pH'IeCRIIX )J,aHublx l .1IH xapaKTepHCTIIRII 8THll'IeCROrO JIIIIJ;a
JII060ro Hapoga O'ieBII;J,HO. B HeROTopbIX CJIY'IaHX oc06eHHOCTII RYJIbTYPbI M
6bITa He MeHbllie BhIpamaIDT :JTHII'IeCKYIO cneIJ;lI<pllRY, 'IeM HSbIK. IIo8TOMY
8THorpa<pII'IeCHIIe MaTepHaJIbI H IIX TIIJ;aTeJIbHbIH aHaJIIIS llrpaIOT orpOMHYlO
pOJIb B JII06011 cepbesHoH 8THoreHeTll'IeCROH pa60Te. 8TO onpeJJ;eJIHeTCH IJ;e-
JIbIM pH)JOM OOCTOHTe,TIbCTB.
BamHeHIIIee IIS UllX - APoonocTb 3TIIorpa<pII'IeCKOH xapaKTepIICTIIRII II
BOSMomHOCTb HeOrpaUIIqeHHO ee YBeJIII'IIITb, Korga pe'Ib IIJJ;eT 0 cOBpeMeHHoM
HaCeJIeUIIII. B 3TOM OTHOIIIeHIIII 8TIIorpa<pII'IeCRlle MaTepIIaJIbI He YCTynaIDT
mmrBIICTII'IeCKIIM llaHHbIM 0 COBpeMeHHbIX HSbIRaX, ;:J,alOIIJ;IIM npegcTaBJIeHlIe
o HSbIRe BO BceM MHoro06paSIIII ero p;IIaJIeKTOB. 8Ta nOJIHOTa nOSBOJIHeT Rap-
Torpa<pllpOBaTb 8THorpa<pU'IeCRIIe Ma TepIIaJIbl. npOCJIegIITb rpaHIIIJ;bI Ram):(orc
KYJIbTypHoro HB.TIeIIllH II T. p;. BTopoe 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO - CTOHKOCTb II OTHO-
CIITeJIbHaH HeIISMeHUOCTb MHorIIX 06bI'IaeB, coxpaHIIBIIIlIxCH nO'ITII P;O cOBpe-
MeHHOCTII, HO YXOgHIIJ;IIX ROpUHMll B ce,rryIO p;peBHOCTb 25. TpeTbe - COCTOIIT
B TOM, 'ITO no ypOBlIIO CBoero 06llJ;eCTBeHHoro II RYJlhTypHoro paSBIITIIH ;\mo-
rIle HapOJJ;bI HaXO)J,HTCH IIJIII HaXO):(IIJIIICb AO caMoro nOCJIeJJ;HerO BpeMeHII Ha
cTyneHHx nepB06hITlI006IIJ;IIHHOrO CTpOH, Torp;a KaK ,rrPyrIIe, HanpIIMep Hapo-
P;bI COBeTCKoro COIDsa. Y'IaCTBYIDT B CTpOIITeJIbCTBe COIJ;lIaJIIISMa. TaKIIM
06paSOM, nepep; rJIaSaMII conpeMenHoro 8THorpa<pa He CO CTpaHIIQ p;peBHIIJ..
PYRonIIceH II He BOCCTanOBJIeHHaH no <pparMeHTapHbIM )XaHHbIM HSbIRa, a SplI-
MO, BOO'IIIlO npoxogIIT nO'ITII BCH naHopaMa 3THH'IeCKOrO paSBIITHH, IIPOp;9-
JIaHHOrO 'IeJIOBeROM ua npOTHmeHHII BceH CBoeH IICTOpllii.
Ho, C P:PyroH CTOpOHbI, npIIMeHeJIlle 8THorpa<pII'IeCKllX p;aHU:bIX B 8THore-
HeTII'IeCRIIX IJ;eJIHX HeBOSMomHO 6es MHorIIX orOBopOK. OCHOBHaH IIp06JIeMa,
KOTopaH BCTaeT B 3TOH CBHSII,- COOTIIOIIIeUHe CTa;:J,lIaJIbHOrO II IICTOpH'IeCRO-
ro, 'ITO Tpe6yeT )J,JIH CBoero peIIIeHIIH 'IaCTO 60JIbIIIOrO KOJIII'IeCTBa gaHHblx
B Kan{,rrOM oTge.rrbHOM c.rrY'Iae. I1MeHHo ne,rrOOIJ;eHRa TPygHocTeH 3TOH np06-
JIeMbI npllBOp;HJIa MuorIIX, HanpIIMep aMepIIKaHCRIIX, IICCJIe):(OBaTeJIeH J{ YCTa-
148
HOBJIeHIIIO reHeTII'IeCRIIX CBHSeH Memp;y 8TIIII'IeCF. IIMII rpynnaMII ua OCHOBa-
HIIH CXOp;CTBa II B HX 06IIJ;eCTBeHHOM CTpOe 26. 3p;eCb HBJIeHIIH, IIMeIOIIJ;He
CTagIIaJIbHbIH XapaKTep, 6es )J:OCTaTO'IHbIX <paRTII'IeCKIIX OCUOBaHIIH paCCMaT-
pIIBaIOTCH RaI, nOKaSaTeJIb reHeTll'IeCHOrO pO):(CTBa.
IIp06JIelVIa COOTHOIIIeHllH CTap;lIaJIbHOrO II IICTOpH'IeC$OrO HaIIIJIa CBoe pe-
meHIIe B rIInOTese XOSHHCTBeHHO-KYJIbTYPUbIX TIIIIOB II IICTOpHKO-8THorp a <p lI -
'<IeCKIIX 06JIaCTeH, paspa60TaIIUOH B eOBeTCKOH 8THorpa<pHII 27. OHa cBlIge-
'Te.TIbCTByeT, RCTaTII CRasaTb, 0 TOM, 'ITO HBJIeHHH, HOCHIIJ;IIe cTagHaJIbHbIH
xapaKTep, He OrpaHII'IIIBalOTCH TOJIbRO 06llJ;eCTBeHUbIM CTpoeM, HO saHIIMaIOT
DOJIblliOe MeCTO II B MaTepIIaJIbHOII KyJIbType, oc06eHHOCTII ROTOpOH OTpamaIDT
ypOBeHb II <pOpMbI XOSHHCT a. Ha 3TOM OCHOBaHIIII II BbIp;eJIHIOTCH XOSHHCTBeH-
nO-RYJIbTYpHbIe TllnbI, CXOP;CTBO KYJIbTypbI B npep;eJIax KOTOpbIX OTpamaeT
ne 06IIJ;HOCTb npoIIcxomgeHJIH, a op;HHaROBbIII ypoBeHb 06IIJ;eCTBeHHoro pas-
BHTIIH II Op;IIHaKOBble <pOpMbI npIIcnoc06JIeHIIH K cpep;e. CneQII<pII'IeCRlIe 'Iep-
TbI, onpegeJIHIOIIJ;IIe nplIHagJIemHOCTb Hapop;a K TOMY IIJIII IIHOMY XOSHIICTBeH-
HO-KYJIbTypHOMY TIIny, eCTeCTBeIIHO, MaJIO 'ITO p;aIOT P;JIH BbIHCHeUIIH ero
IIpOIIcxomp,eHIIH. R TOMY me KOHKpeTHoe BI"UJ;CJIeHlIe 3JIeMeHTOB XOSHllCTBeH-
HO-RYJIbTypHoro TIIIIa H IICTOpHRO-8THorpa<pH'IeCKOII OOIIJ;HOCTII B 60JIbIIIIIHCT-
Be CJIy'IaeB 'IpeSBbI'IaHHO saTpyp;HHTeJIbHO, TaK KaK RJIaCCII<pIIKaQIIH XOSHH-
CTBeHIIO-KYJIbTYpHbIX TIInOB B npegeJIax Rcero seMHoro IIIapa IIORa paspa60-
TaHa JIHllib B 06IIJ;IIX 'IepTaX 28. B IJ;eJIOM MbJ IIMeeM p;OCTaTO'IHO rro):(pOOHoe
:BTHOrpaqnI'IeCKOe paHOHlipOBaHIIe mlillb gJIH OTp;eJIbHbIX 06JIaCTelI seMHoro
mapa, 'ITO IIORa 3aMeTIIbIM 06paSOM OrpaIIll'IIIBaeT BOSMomUOCTH IIcnOJIbSOBa-
HHH 3THorpa<pII'IeCHOrO MaTepHaJIa B Ka'IeCTBe HCTOpII'IeCROrO IICTO'IHHRa.
OgHaRo 8TH BpeMeHHbIe TPYJJ;HOCTII, saBIICHllJ;lIe OT COCTOHHIIH IISY'IeHHO-
CTII npep;MeTa, no caMOMY CBoeMY xapaKTepy npeXO)J:HIIJ;II. ropasp,o 60JIee cy-
'llJ;eCTBeHHbI TPY):(HOCTII, npOHCTeRaIOIIJ;lIe IIS xapaRTepa caMOH 8THorp a <p IIH
KaR HayKII. MHoroe IIS Toro, 'ITO HBJIHeTCH 'IpeSBbI'IaHHO BamHbIM B HCTOPII-
RO-8THorpaQJU'IeCROM OTHOllieHIIU, 6eSBOSBpaTHO YIIIJIO us 6bITa, He OXBa'IeH-
Hoe CBoeBpeMeHHO 3THorpa<pII'IeCKUM HCCJIep;OBaHIIeM. B Tex CJIY'IaHX, Korp;a
]J.JIH nOJIY'IeHIIH IIH<popMaIJ;IIH 06 8TIIX YIIIep,llilix HB.TIeHIIHX MomHO npII6er-
HYTb K CO'IIIHeHUHM, HanlIcaHHbIM HeCROJIbRO BeROB Hasarr, II K IICTOplI'IeCRIIM
]J.OHYMeHTaM, 'iallJ;e Bcero OKaSbIBaeTCH, 'iTO cOJJ;epmallJ;aHCH B HHX IIHQJopMa-
IJ;IIH BbI60p0'Iua II HenOJIHa. CpaBHIITeJIbHO-liCTOpII'IeCROe conOCTaBJIeHe
)J;aHHbIX, OTHOCHIIJ;IIXCH K paSIIbIM Hapop;aM, MomeT p;aTb 6JIeCTHIIJ;IIe pesy.TIb-
TaTbI B peKoHcTpyKQIIU OCUOBHbIX 8TanOB pasBIITIIH XOSHIIcTBa II 06IIJ;eCTBeH-
Horo CTpOH Hapoga, HO He Bcerga JJ;OCTaTO'IHO )J:JIH BOCCTaIIOBJIeHIIH ROHRpeT-
HbIX p;eTaJIeH ero 8THII'JeCKOII IICTOpIIIJ II ero npOIIcxomJJ;eHIIH. TaRIIM 06pa-
30M, caMa «COBpeMeIIHOCTb» 8THorpa<pnII KaK HaYKII OrpaHH'IliBaeT ee
EOSMonmOCTII B clj>epe 3THoreHeTH'IeCKOrO IICCJIegoBaHliH.
Ha OCUOBaHliH Bcero CRasaUIIoro IOmHO SaRJIIO'IIITb, 'ITO 8THorpa<pIIH B
OTHOIIIeHlI1I ee IIpIIMeHeUHH B 3THoreHeTII'IeCROM HCCJIe)XOBaHIIII HaXOp;IITCH
B HeCKOJIbHO JIY'IllieM nOJIOmeHIIII, 'JeM IICTOpIIH II JIIIHrBIICTIIRa. CpaBHIITeJIb-
Ho-nCTOpWIeCROe conOCTaBJIeHlIe B 06JIaCTII 8THorpa<pIIII AaeT B pHp;e CJIy'IaeB
DOJIee TBepP;YIO OCHOBY P;JIH peROHCTpYRIJ;HII p;peBHIIX <pOpM KYJIbTYPbI II 6bITa.
'<IeM B 06JIaCTlI HSbIKOSHaHIIH P;JIH BOCCTaUOBJIeUIIH p,peBHIIX <pOpM HSbIRa.
XpOHOJIOrlI'IeCKIIH gIIanasoH ee IIIupe, 'IeM nCTOpII'IeCRIIX IICTO'IHIIKOB. Ho II
OHa He MomeT SarJIHHyTb B p;aJIeROe npOIIIJIOe OTp,eJIbHOrO Hapop,a, npllOT-
KpbITL saBecy Hap; IICTORaMII 3THoreUeTII'IeCROrO IIpOIJ;eCCa 6es 60JIbIIIOrO
IICJIa rlInOTes II p,OnOJIHIITe.TIbHhIX ):(oIIYIIJ;eHIIH. IIOCJIe)J:HlIe 'IaCTH'IHO He MO-
rYT 6bITb 060CHOBaHbI C p;OCTaTO'IHOH 06CTOHTeJIbHOCTbID B CIIJIV COCTOHHIIH
caMOH 8THorpa<pII'IeCKOH HaYRII, a 'IaCTII'IHO Tpe6YIOT II BcerAa 6YP,YT Tpe60-
BaTb IIpIIBJIe'IeHIIH CMemHbIX p,IICIJ;IIIIJIIIH.
149
t
I
POJIb APXEO.IOrHH
B aTHOrEHETMqECROl\1 HCCJIE;a:OBAHHH
h
BOSMomHOCTII apXeOJIOrII'IeCKOrO IICCJIegoBaHIIH B 8TOM HaIIpaBJIeHlIll npaK-
TII'IeCKII 6eSrpaHII'IHbI, TaI{ KaK IICTOpIIH 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa Ha'IaJIaCb C IISrOTOB-
JIeHllH OPygllH Tpyga, a ):(peBHeiIIIUIe 06paSIJ;bI IIX P;OIIIJIII, RaK IISBeCTHO,
;AO uaCTOHIIJ;ero BpeMeUII II nogBeprHyTbI 06CTOHTeJIbHOMY IISY'IeHIIIO. TaKllM
06pasoM, B MaTepIIaJIaX apXeOJIOrIIII KaK pas II npep;CTaBJIeHbI Te p;peBHeii-
llille 8nOXII IICTOplI1I 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa, B KOTopble C TPyP;OM npOHIIKaIOT 3THO-
rpa<pIIH H HSbIKOSHaHIIe. OP:HO 8TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO caMO IIO ce6e 06YCJIOBJIII-
BaeT llX nerrpexogHIIJ;YIO 3THoreHeTII'IeCKYlO IJ;eHHOCTb.
IIoJIHoTa HaXOD:HIIJ;IIXCH B pacnopHmeHIIII IIcc.rre;AOBaTeJIeH apXeOJIOrII'Ie-
CKIIX gaHHblx II BOSMomHOCTb IIX llCnOJIbSOBaHIIH B 8THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX QeJIHX
saBIICHT, nOMIIMO KOJIll'IeCTBa paCRonaHUbIX rraMHTHIIKOB, OT IIIlIpOTbI IIX XpO-
HOJIOrll'IeCHOrO glianaSOHa. lleM 60JIbIIIIIH XpOHOJIOrll'IeCKIiH OTpeSOK OXBa-
TbIBaeT HaJIII'IHbIH MaTepIIaJI, TeM npOIIJ;e yJIOBIITb npeeMCTBeHHOCTb Mem):(y
OT;AeJIbUbIMIi 8TanaMII, TeM JIer'Ie, CJIe)J:OBaTeJIbHO, CTaBIITb II paspeIIIaTb BO-
npOCbI 0 MeCTHOM llJIIi nplIIIIJIOM npOIIcxom;AeHIIII oTgeJIbHbIX KOl\IIWeHCOJ3 II
IIX OTHOCIITeJIbJIOII XpOHOJTOrlIli. Pasyr.meTCH, II IIInpOKIiH TeppIITOpllaJIbHbIH
OXBaT nOBbIIIIaeT ;AOCTOBepHOCTb II nJIOp;OTBOpHOCTb conOCTaBJIeHIIH. KpoMe-
Toro, OU ;'J,aeT BOSl\'[')JImOCTb HapTorpa<pupOBaTb oTgeJIbHble TiinOJIOrn'Iecmre.
oc06eHHOCTli IIHBeHTapH II OCyrIJ;eCTBIITb rrepexo;:J: OT TlinOJIOrII'IeCKOrO nSY'Ie-
HUH j:(aUHbIX KOMnJIeKCOB K auaJIlisy llX pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH B npOCTpaHCTBe 29.
B 06llJ;eM Bce 8TII saJJ;a'Ili JIerKO peIIIalOTCH, Korga HaKOnJIeU gocTaTO'IHbIII
MaTepIIaJI. B Tex me OOJIaCTHX, r;Ae ero eIQe MaJIO, TaKoe COCTOHHlIe npeg-
CTaBJIHeT C060H BpeMeHHoe HBJIeHlIe II nplI Hag06uocTII MomeT GbITb JIerK()
npeoj:(OJleHo npII orrpe;AeJIeHIIOH saTpaTe BpeMeIIll, CIIJI II T. g. JlIHbIMII CJIOBa-
MII, IIenOJIHOTa <paKTII'IeCKIiX p;aHHbIx B JII060H 06JIaCTII apXeOJIOrHII - Bpe-
MeUHbJH 8Tan, He SaBIICHIQIIH OT ee xapaKTepa.
fopasj:(o 60JIee 6ecnepcneKTIIBHa BbI60pO'IHOCTb apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIx
npoIICTeKalOIIJ;aH liS cneIJ;lItPIIHII pacKarrbIBaeMbIx naMHTHllKOB. B pesYJIbTaTe
Tparll'IeCKOH rlI6eJIli IIoMneII II fepKYJIaHYMa, KOHcepBIIpYIOIIJ;erO geHcTBIIH
nenJIa II .rraBbI, }J;OHeClliero ;AO Hac B IJ;eJIOCTII JJ;peBJIlle nOCTpOHKII, oj:(emgy,.
YTBapb, game lUJIIJ;Y - O;AHIIM CJIOBOM, BCIO nOJIHOTY MaTepnaJIbHOH KYJIbTY-
pbI HaCeJIeHIUI JJ;peBuero ropoga, B pacnopHmeHlIe apxeOJIOrOB nocTynlIJI YHII-
KaJIbHbIII MaTeplIaJI. 06bI'IHO p;peBHIIe nOCeJIeHIIH npeKpaIIJ;aIOT CBoe CYIIJ;eCT-
llOBaHIIe BuesanHO BCJIegcTBIIe saBoeBaHIIH BparOl\I II pasrpa6JIeHIIH, a '-IaIIJ;e-
Bcero nomapa. HCHO, 'ITO npli 8TOM OO.JIblliIIHCTBO mliJIbIX II xosHiicTBeIIHbIx
rrocTpoeK BMeCTe C COJJ;epmallJ;IIMIICH B HIIX npeJJ;MeTaMIi 6bITa rII6ueT, a TO,
'-ITO OCTaeTCH, npe;ACTaBJIHeT C060H CJIY'IaHHYID BbI60PKY. B TOM me CJIY'Iae.
eCJIII nOCeJIeHlIe <PYHRQIIoHIIPyeT p;OCTaTO'IHO iJOJIro, nOCJIegYIOIIJ;IIe nOKOJIeHIIH
YIIII'ITOmaIOT c.rregbI mllSHIi npeJJ;bID:yrqIIx, qTO TaKme He cnoc06cTByeT CO-
xpaHeHIIIO apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKOrO IIUBeHTapH 60JIee II.peBIIIIX 8nox. IIpaB;:J:a, IIHor-
Ail II pacKonKIi MHOrOCJIOHUbIX nOCeJIeHIIH gaIDT IIpeRpacHble pesYJIbTaTbI.
CTOIiT BcnOMIIIITb IIHTepecHYIO nOrrbITKy onpegeJIeHIIH 8THII'IeCKOII npliHag-
JIemHOCTH ,n:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH MOCKBbI ua OCHOBanJIII aHaJIIiSa apXeOJIOrII-
'IeCl\Oro MaTeplIaJIa, nOJIY'IeHHOrO npli pacRonKax KpeMJIH 30. Ho B IJ;eJIOM
TaKIIe YJJ;a'IH HeMHOrO'IIICJIenUbI.
EIIJ;e 60JIee BbI60po'IUbI apxeOJIOrI'PIeCKlie MatepnaJIbI, npegcTaBJIHIOIIJ;IIe'
co60ii peSYJIbTaT KypraHHbIX paCKonOK Ha'IaTb C Toro, '-ITO 06bPIaII Tpyno-
COrrGI{eHIIH 6bIJI IIIlIpOKO pacnpOCTpaHeH B 3noxy meJIesa BO l\IHOrIIX OGJIaCTHX.
IIpaBgao B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH ge;ralOTcH IIonbITKII IICnOJIbSOBaTb JJ;JIH apxeo-
JlOrlI'IeCIWrO aIIa;;UI3a II norpe6eHIIH C TpynocommeHIIeM 31, HO OHII IIOKa.
Ii:
lit
150
ue BbIXOP;HT sa paMKII IIHTepeCHbIX B MeTOp;II'IeCROM OTHorneHIIII, HO cnopHbIX
npeiJ,nOJIOmeHIIH. COBeprneHHO O'ieBIIp:HO, 'ITO nOJIY'IaIOIIJ;aHCH npII 3TOM ana-
JIIISe IIH<popMaIJ;IIH Bcerp;a 6ygeT O'IeHb OrpaHII'IeHHOH. )J,aJIee, norpe6eHIIH
MorYT ObITb JIIIIIIeHbI nOJIHOCTblO norpeOaJIbHOrO IIHBeHTapH. IIpIIMep TOMY-
MOrIJJIbHIIRII TaRoro TIIna B TYBe, ROTopbIe IIMeHHO no 3TOH nplI'IIIHe p;OJIro
He MOrJIII 6bITb iJ,aTIIpOBaHbI 32 . CaM no ceoe 8TOT <paKT CBIIp:eTeJIbCTByeT 0
TOM, 'ITO CTpeMJIeUlIe OOeCne'IIITb nOKOHHIIKa B sarpOOUOH JI{IISHII BceM He-
OOXOgIIMbIM He HBJIHJIOCb Bce06IIJ;IIM II IIHorp:a SaMeHHJIOCb IIHbIMII IIp;eOJIorlI-
'IeCRIIMII npep;CTaBJIeHIIHMII. IIo IIHBeHTapIO, ROTOpbIH nOIIap:aJI B norpe6eHlIe,
MomHO, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, CYP;IITb .TIIIIIIb 0 HeKOTopbIX RaTeroplIHX BeIIJ;eH. 8TO
He SHa'lIIT, 'ITO IIM HeJIbSH nO.TIbSOBaTbCH B 3THorpa<pII'IeCRHX IJ;eJIHX. MHoro-
'IHCJIeHHble II yCIIernubIe nonbITRII yCTaHOBJIeHIIH CBHSII paSJIH'IHbIX rpynn
KypraHHbIX MOrIIJIbHIIROB C JIeTOnlICHbIMII BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCRIIMII nJIeMeHaMII,
Ha'iaTble A. A. CnlIIJ;bIHbIM 33 II npop:OJImeHHbIe COBeTCKIIMH apxeOJIOraMII,
onpOBepraIDT JIlOOOH HIIrIIJIIISM no OTHOIIIeHIIIO K RypraHHbIM iJ,peBHOCTHM.
B KOHQe ROHIJ;OB MHorIIe rpoMagHbIe paSiJ,e.TIbI apXeOJIOrlIII nOCTpoeHbI Ha lISY-
T1eUIUI RypraHHbIX naMHTHIIROB. Ho p,aHHbIe, Ha KOTOpbIX OCHOBaHbI 8TII IIC-
CJIeJJ;OBaHIIH, OCTaIOTCH HenOJIIIbIMH.
,1J,pyrolI BamHbIH <paKT - HepaspaOOTaHUOCTb RpliTepIIeB p:JIH BbIp:eJIeHIIH
3THlI'IeCKIiX 06IIJ;HOCTeH Ha apXeOJIOrlI'IeCROM MaTeplIaJIe 3 . 06bI'IIIO eiJ,IIH-
-CTBeHHbIM RpIITepIIeM nCnOJIbSOBaHIIH KaROH-JIIIOO TnnOJIOrlI'IeCROH ocooeHHO-
CTH apXeOJIOrH'IeCROrO IIHBeHTapH B Ka'IeCTBe 3THH'IeCROrO onpep:emITeJIH
HBJIHeTCH ee saROHOMepHoe reorpa<pII'JeCKoe paCIIpeiJ,eJIeHne. Ho 3TO OOCTOH-
TeJIbCTBO IIpn BceH CBoeH BamHOCTII He HBJIHeTCH peIIIaIOIIJ;IIM. Bep;b XOSHH-
CTBeHHO-RYJIbTypHble THllbI, RaK MbI suaeM no 8THorpa<pWIeCROMY MaTepnaJIY,
TaRme xapaRTepnSYIOTCH SaROUOl\IepHbIM reorpa<pII'IeCRIE\I pacnpeJ(eJIeHI1eM,
HO OIIII He COBnap:aIOT C 8THII'IeCKIIMH OOIIJ;HOCTHMII. TaR II na apXeOJIOrll'Ie-
-CKOM MaTepIIaJIe: rrpemAe 'IeM KJIaCTb KaKOH-TO npllSHaR B OCHOBY reHeTII'Ie-
CROH RJIaCCII<pIIRaIJ;IIII, CJIeayeT p:oKasaTb caMY BOSMomHOCTb BbIAeJIeHIIH 8T-
HII'IeCRIIX egIIHIIIJ; C nOMOIIJ;bIO 8Toro nplISHaKa, 'ITO aeJIaeTCH He Bcerp;a.
B IJ;eJIOM np06JIeMa p;aJIeRa OT CBoero OKOH'IaTeJIbHOrO perneHIIH.
He cnacaeT nOJIOmenlIH, XOTH BO l\IuorliX CJIY'IaHX II IIcnpaB.'lHeT ero, rnII-
pOKoe conOCTaBJIeHIIe apXeOJIOrII'IeCKllX II 8Tuorpa<pH'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX, ROTopoe
CeH'IaC npO'IIIO BOIIIJIO B npaKTIIRY COBeTCRIIX apXeOJIOrII<IeCRIIX IICCJIegoBa-
HIIH. IIpOlICXOAIIJIO 3TO IIOTOMY, 'ITO 3Ha'ieHIIe Tex IIJIII IIHbIX ocooeHHocTeH
B RY:IbType B Ra'IeCTBe 8THII'IeCKIIX onpegeJIIITe,TIeH MeHHeTCH OT 3nOXH K
8IIoxe II B paSHbIX KOHRpeTHo-nCTOplI'IeClmX yCJIOBIIHX. II03ToMY pesYJIbTaTbi
3THorpa<pHQeCHIIX IIITYAIIH, eCJIII p;ame OHII 6bIJIII ObI 60JIee o()uagemHBalo-
Il.\IIMII, UeJIb3H oesorOBOpO'IHO pacnpocTpaHHTb Ha apXeOJIOrlI'IeCRIIe MaTe-
pIIaJIbI.
He npIIXO):(IITCH COMHeBaTbCH B TeCHOH CBHSII apXeOJIOrIIII II 8THorpa<p«II.
GIIpe):(eJIeHHO MoaalO CRasaTb, 'ITO apxeOJIOrIm - 3TO 8THorpa<plIH, OIIPOKIIIIY-
TaH B npOIIIJIOe. Ho oua HaIIOMIIHaeT 3THorpa<pIIIO, lIS ROTOpOH nO:IIIOCTbID
llCIWIO'IeHbI JII06bIe npegcTaBJIeHIIH 0 HapOiJ,e, 3THorpa<pIIIO, B ROTOpOH HeT
JIIOp:eH, a OCTaJIIICb TOJIbRO npep;MeTbI ObITa, XOSHHCTBeHHbIe 0PYP;IIH, no-
-CTpOIIKII - OP;UIIM CJIOBOM, MaTepIIaJIhHaH RYJIbTypa B IIIlIpOKOM CMbICJIe
CJlOBa. CllJIa apXeOJIOr1I1I B TOM, 'ITO OHa op;Ha IIS Bcex nepe'IIICJIeHHbIX
,IJ.HCIJ;IIIIJIHU HenocpegcTBeHHo npOHIIRaeT B npOIIIJIOe, CJIaOOCTb - B TOM, 'ITO
ona HaXOalIT TaM JIIIIIIb IICRameUHbIe II HenOJIUble OTpameHIIH 8THH'IeCKIIX
npOIJ;eCCOB p:peBHOCTIl. IIpo apxeo.1:DrH'IeCKIIH MaTepllaJI BPHJJ; JIH MomHO CRa-
3aTb, 'ITO OH (<HeM», KaR 8TO p:eJIaeT <D. II. <DIIJIIIH. Op;HaRO HeCOMueHHO,
'ITO 3TOT MaTeplIaJI rOBopIIT (mOJIyIIIenOTOM».
151
AHTPOnOJIOrHqECRHnMATEPHA
RAK HCTOPHqECRIIn HCTOqHHR
TaH HaK 8Ta np06JIeMa 06CTOHTeJIbHO paCCMOTpeHa B IJ;eJIOM pHge pa60T, orpa-
HII'IyCb oTgeJIbUbIMII MOMeHTaMII, BamlIbIMII JJ;JIH HaIIIeH TeMbI. AHTpono.TIo-
rII'IeCHIIII MaTepIIaJI npII CBOeM HOMnJIeHCUOM IICnOJIbSOBaHIIII, T. e. IIPII HaJIII-
'IIIII naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCHIIX, HpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCHIIX II COMaTOJIOrII'IeCHIIX p,aH-
HbIX, OXBaTbIBaeT npaHTII'IeCKII BCIO IICTOpIIIO 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa II C 8TOH TO'IHII
SpeHIIH BbIrOilHO OTJIII'IaeTCH OT TeX BIIJJ;OB IICTOpII'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIHOB, KOTO-
pbIe MbI yme paCCMOTpeJIII. IIpaBp,a, 'IeM p,peBJIee 8nOXa, TeM HOJIII'IeCTBO
MaTepIIaJIOB MeHbIIIe, a coxpaHHOCTb IIX xyme, HO B KOHe'IHOM IITore HMeIO-
IIJ;IIeCH JIaHYHbI, KaH II B 06JIaCTII apXeOJIOrIIII, HOCHT BpeMeHHbIH xapaHTep
II 6YP;YT HenpeMeHHO SanOJIHeHbI B xop;e p;aJIbHeHIIIeH pa60TbI. PaSYMeeTCH,
SHa'ieHIIe aUTpOnOJIOrJI'IeCHIIX p,aHHbIX JJ;JIH paSHbIX 3nox HeogIIHaHOBO. H,
HanpIIMep, HeT Hag06HocTII npII6eraTb K IIX nOMOIIJ;1I B Tex CJIY'IaHX, Horp;a
TOT II.TIll IIHOH IICTOpH'IeCHIIH npOIJ;eCC npeKpaCHO p;OKYMeHTlIpyeTcH p;py-
rHMII BllgaMII IICTOpII'IeCKIIX IICTO<IHIIKOB. KpacHope'IllBbIH npIIMep nplIBeJI
r. <D. )J,e6eIJ;, CIIpaBep;JIIIBO YHasaB, 'ITO CMeIIIUO nplI6eraTb H nOMOIIJ;1I aHTpo-
IIOJIOrHH P;JIH p;OKaSaTeJIbCTBa SaCeJIeHIIH CII6IIpII PYCCKllMII B XVII B.3
II08TOMY aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKHe IICCJIep;OBaHIIH npOCTJIpaIOTCH 06bI'IHO Ha rJIY-
60KYIO p,peBHOCTb, BCHpbIBaH TaKIIe CBHSII II 06IIJ;HOC,TII, CJIep;bI KOTOpbIX yme
YTepHHbI IICTOpIIeH, 8THorpa<pIIeH II JIIIHrBIICTIIKOH. Ho B IJ;eJIOM Bce me
aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCHIIH MaTepIIaJI JIY'IIIIe, 'IeM JII060H p,pyroH, nOMoraeT B YCTa-
HOBJIeHHII npeeMCTBeHUOCTII COBpeMeHHoro II p;peBHero HaCeJICHIIH.
KasaJIocb 6bI, BbICOHaH npegcTaBIITeJIbHOCTb aHTpOnOJIorJI'IeCKIIX p,aHHbIx
II BOSMomHOCTb oxapaHTepllsoBaTb C HX nOMOIIJ;bIO HaCeJIeHIIe p;peBHeHIIIIIx
;mox llCTOpHII qeJIOBe'IeCTBa 6eCnOJIeSHbI, eCJIII IIplIHHTb lliIIpOKO pacnpocTpa-
HeHHbIH II npaBIIJIbHbIll TeSIIC 06 OTCYTCTBIIII npII'IIIHHOH CBHSII Memp,y <pIISII-
'IeCHIIMII ocooeHHocTHMII Hapop,a, C OP;HOU c'TOpOHbI, II ero HSbIKOM II HYJIb-
TYPOH - C P,PyroH, T. e. Memp;y paCOH II HaIJ;IIeH. Ho OTCYTCTBIIe npII'IHHUOH
CBHSII He npIIBOJJ;IIT HenpeMeUHO K OTCYTCTBIIIO reorpa<pH'IeCHIIX COBna;o:eHIIH,
BOSHIIKIIIIIX B xop,e IICTOpIIII. BOSMomHOCTb IIIIIpOHoro IICnOJIbSOBaHIIH aHTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCHIIX MaTepIIaJIOB B Ha'IeCTBe IICTOpH'IeCHOrO IICTO'IUIIHa 06YCJIOBJIH-
BaeTCH TeM 06CTOHTeJIbCTBOM, 'ITO MosaHHa aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCHIIX TlInOB CRJIa-
p,bIBaeTCH B CneIJ;II<pll'IeCHIIe KOMnJIeKCbI Y Hamgoro napop,a, 'ITO OHa onpep;e-
.'1HeTCH HOHHpeTHO-IICTOpII'IeCHllMH YCJIOBIIHMII II OTpamaeT npmIcxomp,eHIIe
rr 8THH'IeCHYIO IICTOpIIlO Hapop;a. PaSYMeeTCH, B Hell HaXOJJ;HT OTpameHlIe
JIIIllib Te HCTOpII'IeCHIIe npOIJ;eCCbI, KOTopbIe CBHsaHbI CO C IeIIIeHHeM npen-
c,TaBIITeJIeII paS.TIII'IaIOIIJ;IIXCH Memp;y C060H <pIISIFreCKliX KOMnJIeKCOB. Ho TO
me call10e MomHO CKasaTb H 00 8JIeMeHTax HSbIKa II Hy.;rbTypbI: npII OTCYTCT-
BIIII paSJIII'IIIH Memny HIIMII 3THOreHeTII'IeCKOe HCCJIe;:J:OBaHIIe HeBOSMOtRHO.
IIoMIIMO npoHIIKHoBeHIIH B rJly6oKYlO p,peBuocTb, aHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCKOe IIC-
c'JIe;:J:oBaIIlIe IIMeeT TO npeIIMYIIJ;eCTBO nepep; IICTOpII'IeCKlUI, 8THorpa<pH'IenaIM
H JIIIHrBHCTII'IeCKIIM, 'ITO 'Ie TKO <pIIKcHpyeT npIIMeCb IIHOpO;O:HbIX 8THII'IeCKIIX
8JIeMeHTOB. Y me 6bIJIO OTMe'IeHO, 'ITO nOHBJIeUIIe HOBbIX 8JIeMeHTOB B HSbIKe
II KYJIbType COBceM He 06HsaTe.TIbHO CBIIp;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 npIITOKe HOBoro Ha-
c,eJIeHIIH: OHH MOrJIII BOSHIIHHYTb II BCJIegcTBIIe HYJIbTypHoro BsaIIMO;J,eHCTBIIH.
Ho nOHBJIeHUe UOBoro aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKoro KOMnJIeKCa, sa HeMHorHMll IICKJIIO-
'IeHIIHMII, uerrpeMeHUO rOBopIIT 0 npIIMeCII HOBoro HaCeJIeHIIH, TaR KaK Kor.ln-
JIeKC 8TOT pacnpOCTpaHHeTCH nplI nepeCeJIeHlI1I JIlOp;eH JIII60 B peSYJIbTaTe
6pa'IHbIX KOHTaKTOB. B 3TOM SaKJIIO'IaeTCH rpOMap;Hoe SHaqeHIIe aHTpOnO:IO-
rlI'IeCKOrO xlaTeplIaJIa KaH TOHKoro IIH}J;IIKaTOpa MlIrpaIJ;IIH, oc06eHHO B p;peB-
nlIe 3nOXII, 'ITO HeBOSMomHO BbIHCHHTb c nOMOIIJ;bIO p;aHHbIX npyrIIX HaYK.
1 ""?
-
IIcm/lflUJl
J1UIIZ#UC-
mUKIZ
.lmll/lZfllZ -
flu/{
I!PX£U/lU-
ZU./!
IIltl7TjlUHU-
/lUZU./!
J/1/lXIZ .JfCC/l£JIZ
.
"
:';;:
-- ;//; -
/:. .'
-;'<
1l mb/CJll/C/lCmUC /foJ.
J/1/lXIZ U/tU/fJb/
IIc/l/Tum
" ('.
../ ./.
i)
W
';(;;
/lU/T£/l/lUI7T
Puc. to. Pa3pelliaIOII{aH clloc06HOCTb pa3HbIX Bll OB IICTOpliTIeCKIIX
llCTOTIHllKOB .
BemIRo OHO H JJ;JIH BOCCTanOBJIeHIIH JJ;eMOrpa<pII'IeCROH CTPYRTyp:bI nonYJIHIJ;IIll
n Bo06IIJ;e gJIH perneHIIH np05JIeM naJIeop:eMorpa<pHII. IIpaBAa, P;JIH nOCJIep;HIIX
':J:BYX TbICH'IeJIeTIIH C He60JIbIIIIIM Hel\IaJIYIO pOJIb IIrpaeT Ta naJIeOp;eMOrpa-
<pII'IeCKaH HH<popMaIJ;IIH, ROTOpyID MomHO IISBJIe-"Ib IIS aHaJIIISa I1IICbMeHHbIX
nCTO'IHIIROB, HO p;.TIH 60JIee p;peBHIIX nepIIop;oB naJIeOaH1'pOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIH Ma-
TeplIaJI HBJIHeTCH ep;IIHCTBeUHoH Hap;emHoll 5asoH IIaJIeogeMorpa<pII'IeCKIIX
peKoHcTpYKIJ;IIH.
C JJ;PyrolI CTOpOHbI, HeJIbSH He OTMeTIITb, 'ITO IIHorga aHTpOnOJIOrlIH AaeT
OCHOBaHllH npeJl,nOJIaraTb HeIISMeUUOCTb II npeeMCTBeHHOCTb HaCeJIeHIIH, CTa-
6IIJIbHOCTb IICTOpII'IeCROrO paSBHTIIH, TorAa KaK Ha caMOM p;eJIe npOIISOIIIJIa
CMeHa HSbma II KyJIbTypbI. 8TO npOIICXOP;HT JIJI60 B Tex CJIY'IaHX, Korga CMe-
IIIHBaIOIIJ;IIeCH lIapogbI, KaK yme YRaSbIBaJIOCb, npIIHaAJIemaT R OAUOMY II
TOMY me aUTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOMY TlIny, JIII50 nplI nepexop;e Ha P:PyroM HSbIK C
n BocnpIIHTIIII HOBbIX KYJIbTypHbIX HaBbIROB nop; BJIllHHIIeM KOHTaRTOB C 60-
.iee BbICORopaSBHTbIM HaCeJIenIIeM, HO 6es 6pa'IHbIX cBHseH C HIIM. KOHTpOJIb
co CTOpOIIbI CMemHblX p;aHHbIX cOBepIIIeHHo He06xop;IIM II uap; aHTpOnOJIOrII-
"'leClHIM MaTeplIaJIOM, HeCMOTpH Ha ero IIIIIpORIIM XpOHOJIOrII'IeCRHH glIanasoH
"II Henocpep:CTBeHHYID CBHSb II HepaspbIBHOCTb onpeiJ;eJIeHHbIX KOM5IIHaIJ;IIH
2.HTpOnOJIOrll'IeCRHX TIInOB C onpegeJleHHbIMII 8THII'IeCKIIMH 06IIJ;HOCTHMII.
ROMIIJIERCHOCTb J];AHHbIX H HX COIIO,lJ,qHHEHHE
He06xo IIMOCTh ROMn.TIeRCHOro IIogxOJJ;a R np06JIeMaM 8THoreHesa B CBeTe
CKasaHHoro HaCTOJIbRO O'ieBII)XHa, 'ITO C05JIIOgeHIIe :3TorO Tpe60BaHIIH Momuo
06'bHBIITb IIepBbIM YCJIOBlIeM ycnexa B IIX peIIIeHIIII. BTopoe YCJIOBlIe-
TpeSBbIll Y'IeT Toro, 'ITO peaJIbHO MomHO omIIp;aTb OT Ra}R}J;oro BIIp:a IICTOpll-
"'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHHROB. Ha npllJIaraeMOH cxeMe nORasaHO IIX HalI50JIee paSYM-
I-IOe, C TO'IRII speHIIH aBTopa, COnOA'IIIHeHlIe (pIIC. 10).
I To. cToe c. flo HeKoTopbIe IIp06JIelllbI BcellUlpHoii: IICTOplIII B CBeTe gaHHblx COBpe-
MeHHoii IICTOpII'IeCKOII 3THorpag)IIII II Bonp. IICTOplIlI. 1961. M 11.
- Tm;apee C. Ao K 1l0CTaHOBKe np06JIeM 3THoreHe3a II COB. 3THorpag)IIH. 1949. M 3;
JIeeun M. F. oTHorpag)II'leCK.Ile II aHTpOllOJIOrlI'IeCKIIe .MaTepIIaJIbI KaK IICTOpII'leCKIIU
153
,II
"
HCTO'IHlIK (K MeTOiIOJIOTlIII R3YlleHHlI RCTOpRII 6eCIIIICbMeHHbIX HapogoB) I I TaM me.
1961. ;M 1.
3 1/,e6elf Fo ([>., JIeeuu M. F., TpoifJUMoea To A. AHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCKIIH MaTepRaJI RaR
RCTO'IHIIR II3Y'-IeHIIH BOHpOCOlJ 3THoreHe3a II Ta l me. 19520 ;M 1.
... TpeTbRKoe fl. H. oTHoreHeTII'IeCRIIII HpOl\eCC H apXeOJIOrlIH II COB. apXeOJIOrIIH. 1962.
.N£ 4. C !. TaKme: Ethnoarchaeulogy. No Y., 1979.
5 Kna6e F. C. CJIOBapHble 3alIMCTBOBaHHH R 3THoreHe3 II BOHpo H3bIR03HaHRH. 1962.
.N£1.
([>u.aun ([>0 ll. OGpa30BaHIIe H3bIRa BOCTOllHbIX CJIaBHH. Mo; JI., 1962.
BplOcoe A. H. K BOHPOCY 06 IIHgoeBpoHeiicKoIl np06JIellIe II COB. apXeOJIOrIIHo 1958.
.N£ 3; On 3/Ce. 00 3RcrraHCHR «h-YJIbTYP C 60eBbulH TorrOpa m}) B ROHl\e III TbICH'Ie-
JIeTIIH go H. 3. II TaM me. 1961. .N£ 3.
s CM. R3 HOBeiillieII JIIITepaTypbI: HepoanaK B. flo HHgoeBpoHeHCRlIe H3bIRII II CpaBHII-
TeJIbHO-HCTOpJI'IeCROe II3Y'IeHlIe H3bIROB pa3HbIX ceMeII. Mo, 1981.
9 0030p II KPIITI1KY ClI!.: Caffiponoe B. A. IIpoo.!IeMa IIH]:\oeBpOHeIICRoii IIpapoglIHbI. Op]:\-
mOHIIRHg3e, 1983.
10 CMo, Harrp.: lj epennuu JI. B. MCTOplI'leCRl1e YCJIOBRH g)OplllHpoBaHRH PyccKoii: Hapo!!:-
HOCTR ):\0 ROHl\a XV B. II BOHpOCbI g)Op I1IpOBaHRH PYCCROH HapO]:\HOCTH II Hal\l1l1.
M.; JIo, 19580
I' A.1eKceeea E. II. }J;peBHHH H cpe}.J;HeBeRoBaH RCTOplIH Kapa'iaeBo-qepReccRII: (BOlI-
pOCbI 3THII'IeCKOrO II COl\HaJIbHO-3ROHOMJI'IeCKOrO pa3BIITI1H) 0 M., 1971.
1" MHOrO'IJICJIeHHbIe rrplI IepbI CM.: JIuxa'tee 1/,. C. TeRCTOJIOrRH. Ha lIIaTeplIaJIe PYC-
CRoii JIRTepaTypbI X XVII BeKOB. JIo, 1983.
13 FoplOnoea E. no K Borrpocy 0 rr.!Iel\IeHHOii IIpIIHa.n:JIemHOCTR JIeTOrrRCHoii MepH II KpaT.
COOOlI{o MH-Ta 3THorpag)nR AH CCCP. 1953. BbIll. 17.
14 rO.'lb.MCTen Bo B. EYPTaCbI II KpaT. co061I{0 MH-Ta IICTOpRR MaTepHaJIbHOii KYJIbTypbI.
1946. BbIrr. 13; A.wxoea A. n. K BOHPOCY 0 6YPTacax II COBo 3THorpag)IIH. 19490 .N£ 1.
10 ApTaMonoe 1110 n. MCTOpllH xa3apo JIo, 1962; On 3/Ceo OTRpbITRe Xa3aplIH: (MCTOpR-
Ko-reorpag)II'IeCRJIii 3TIO]:\) 0 Mo, 19660
16 A.aeKceee B. fl., EpO.M.'leu /00 B. K II3YlleHRIO pOJIII HepeCeJIeHHH HapogoB B g)OpMIl-
pOBamHI HOBbIX 3THIIlleCRRX OOII{HOCTeII II COB. 3THorpag)HH. 1968. M 20
l' 0030p CM.: llbRKonoe no Mo J:I3blRlI }.J;peBHeii IIepe]:\HeII AaRII. M., 1967.
18 CBO]:\KR gaHHblx R 61I6JIROrpag)RIO CM.: Funihtli JIo A. H3bIR gpeBHeiilliero HaCeJIe-
HIIH IOra EaJIRaHCROro HOJIYOCTpOBao <DparMeHT IIHgoeBpoHeiicRoii OHmIaCTRRRo M.,
1967; On 3/Ce. }J;peBHeHlliaH OHOllIaCTHKa BOCTO'IHbIX EaJIRaH: (<DpaRo-XeTTO-JIYBlIii-
CRlIe II g)paRO-lIIaJIOa3RHCRlIe 1I30rJIOCCbI). COg)RH, 1981.
19 1/,3/CaYKRn r. B. ApMHHCRIIH R }.J;peBHlle RH)J;oeBporreiicKRe H3bIKII. EpeBaH, 1970. Ha
apM. H3.
2" KananlfRU F. A. MCTOpRRO-JIRHrBHCTlI'leCKlIe pa60TbI. EpeBaH, 1956.
>.1 Cepe6pelinuKoe B. A. BOJIrO-ORCRaH TOHOHRMHRa Ha TeppHTopliH eBpolIeiicIwH 'Ia-
em CCCP II Borrp. H3bIK03HaHRH. 19550 ;M 6.
:.!.2 CMa, Harrp.: TpeTbRl'i06 II. H. BOCTO'lHOCJIaBHHCKlie TIJIeMeHa. M.; JL, 19-48; 2-e 113;1:.
M., 1953; Ou 3/Ce. MTorli apXeOJIOrH'IeCROrO H3Y'-IeHRH BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKRX rrJIellIeH /
}J;OKJI. IV MemgYHap. C'be3ga CJIaBIICTOB. Mo, 1958; On :!/Ceo IIo CJIegaM gpeBHRx CJIa-
BHHCRRX HJIeMeHo JIo, 1982.
23 Tonopoe B. Ho, Tp y6a'tee O. Ho JIRHrBRCTII'IeCRIIH aHaJIII3 rRgpOHRMOB BepxHero
IIogHerrpoBbH. M., 1962.
a IIo)J;oop g)aRToB CM.: HUKonoe B. A. BBe]:\eHHe B TOIIOHRMHh-Y. M., 1965.
2:i CM., HaHp.: 3.aaTKoecKaR T. 1/,. 0 rrpOIIcxom]:\eHRR HeRoTopbIX 3JIeMeHTOB KYKepcKoro
06pHga Y 60JIrap: (K Borrpocy 0 g)paRlIllcRIIX Tpa]:\IIl\IIHX Y Hapo]:\oB IOro-BOCTo'IHoii
EBpOHbI) II COB. 3THorpag)RHo 1967. JI& 3.
2 CM., HaHpo: Kroeber A. Cultural and natural areas of Northern North America. Ber-
keleyo 1939.
27 0630p Hp06JIeMbI CM.: A.aeKceee Bo fl. CTaHOBJIeHHe 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa. M., 1984.
l IIOCJIe!!:HIIll BapRaHT RJIaCcllg)HKal\RR CM.: AnfJpuanoe B. B., fj e6oKcapo6 H. Ho Xo-
3HiicTBeHHo-RYJIbTYPHbIe TRrrbI II IIp06JIeMbI IIX RapTorpag)RpoBaHRH II COB. 3THorpa-
g)I1H. 1972. J\i1! 2.
2> CM., Harrp.: M onzauT A. JI. 3a]:\allH II B03MomHOCTR apXeOJIOrlIlleCKOIl RapTorpag)RR.
COBo apXeOJIOrRH. 1962. ;M 1.
3J Pa6unoeu't Mo T. 06 3THlI'leCROM COCTaBe HepBOHa'IaJIbHOrO HaCeJIeHRH MOCRBbI.
COB. 3THorpag)IIH. 1962. .N£ 2.
'" Chochol 10 Anthropologicky rozbor ludskych zarovych pozustatku z luzickych pohi'e-
bist v Usti Jlad Labem - Sti'ekove II a v Zirovicich, okl'o Cheb. II Plesl Eo Luzicki.
kultura v severozapadnich Cechah. Pr., 1961; A.ael£ceeea T. 11. AHTpOHOJIOrlIlleCRlIfi
aHaJlII3 ROCTHblX OCTaTROB H3 MOrRJIbHHROB C TpynocOm1f..eIlIIHlIIR llepHHXOBCKOii RYJTb-
TYPbI II COB. apXeOJIOrHH. 1975. .N£ 1.
I
154
32 Fpa't A. 1/,., He'taeea JI. F. RpaTKlIe llTorli IICCJIe]:\OBaHD apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKOrO OTpH]:\a
TKSlio II Y'IeH. 3an. TYBIIH. Hayq.-IICCJIe]:\. llH-Ta H3bIKa, JIHT. II HCTOpllll. KhI3bIJI,
1960 0 Bblli. 80
11 CnulfbLu A. A. PaCCeJIeHlIe ]:\peBHepyccKllX nJIeMeH no apXeOJIOrlI'IeCRllM ]:\aHHbIM /I
/KYPH. M-Ba Hap. HpOCBelI{eHllHo 1899. J\l'2 8.
iI KaMel-lelfl-Wu Ho C. ApXeOJIOrll'IeCKaH KYJIbTypa - ee onpegeJIeHlIe II IIHTepnpeTa-
l\llH II COB. apXeOJIOrllH. 1970. N! 2; Klteuu J1. C. IIp06JIeMa OHpep;eJIeHIIH apxeoJIo-
rJil'IeCROH KYJIbTYPbI I I TaM me.
",5 1/,e6elf r. flJo AHTpOHOJIOrlI'IeCKlle llccne]:\OBaHllH B KaM'-IaTCROH 06JIaCTll II Tp. IIH-Ta
3THorpag)llII AH CCCP. H. C. M., 1951. T. 17.
o PA3JUrrU1I1
CI1HXPOHHOrO 11 JJ;HAXPOHHOrO CPABHEHI1H
3THOrPA I1qECRI1X HB EHI1n
IIOCT AHOBKA IIPOBJIEMbI
IIpIIMeUemIe MeToga gII<p<pepeuQupoBauHoro CIIIIxpouuoro II gIIaxpoHuoro
nogxOJJ;a R MaTepIIaJIaM <pO.lIbRJIOpIICTIIRII BCJIe]],CTBIIe cBoe06pasIIH 8TOH OT-
pac Jill IICTOpH'IeCROH uaYRII BCTpe'IaeT PHg He rrpeO):(OJIeUHbTX eIIJ;e TPYP;IIOCTeM.
J];JIH IISY'IeUIIH <pOJIbRJIOpa RaR IICTopnRO-8Tuorpa<pII'IeCROrO HBJIeHIIH He06xo-
)J;IIMbI npep;BapIITeJIbUaH paspa60TRa II YTO'IIIeUIIe 8Toro MeTo):(a B 06IIJ;e-
8Tuorpa<pII'IeCROM aCIIeRTe, 'ie:\IY II IlOCBHIIJ;eu B OCUOBHOM 8TOT pasJJ;eJI.
CIIUxpouuoe cpaBHelIIIe oIIIIpaeTcH Ha XpOUOJIorII'IeCRII oAuoBpeMeHHbIe
pH):(bI <paRTOB IIJIII TaKIIe, ROTopble YCJIOBUO npegIIOJIaraIOTCH XpOIIOJIOrII'Ie-
CRII o):(uoBpeMeuubIMII. IIpII ):(IIaxpolIuoM IIogxOJJ;e cpaBHIIBaIOTcH Te me pHgbI
.{)gUOP0):(UbIX <paRToB, HO OTuOCHIIJ;IIeCH K pasIIbIM XpOIIOJIOrII'IeCRIIM cpesaM.
B IIepBoM cJIY'iae IIepeJJ; IICCJIegoBaTeJIeM CTOIIT saga'Ia BbIHcueUIIH BsaIIMuoM
CBHSII IICCJIegyeMblx HBJIeUIIH, IIX cIIcTeMuocTII, T. e. IIpIIlIagJIemUOCTII R og-
UOpOglIbIM IIJIII pasHopogHbIM RaTeropIIHM 60JIee BbICORoro nOpHJJ;Ra, BO BTO-
pOM - IIX gIIHaMIIRII BO BpeMeUII. B IIepBOM CJIY'Iae QeJIbID IICCJIegoBauIIH
HBJIHeTCH TIIIIOJIOrII'IeCROe IIOCTpoeHIIe, BO BTOpOM - IICTOpII'IeCRoe. COOTBeT-
CTBeIIUO 8TOMY B <pIIJIOCO<pCKOH mITepaType 'IaCTO IIIIllIYT 0 TIIIIOJIOrII'IeCROM
J'[ IICTOpIJ'IeCROM MeTo):(ax, P;O RaROH-To CTeIIeHII IIX IIpOTIIBonOCTaBJIHH, IIJIII
B 60JIee llIIIpOROM CMbICJIe - 0 p;IIaJIeRTII'IeCROM egIIucTBe JIOrII'IeCKOrO II IIC-
TOpII'IeCROrO 1.
I1UTyIITIIBHO ocosuaHuoe eIIJ;e B aUTH'IUOH <pIIJIOCO<pIIII paSJIII'IIIe MemAY
CIIuxpOUIIeH II gHaxpouIIeH 6bIJIO OT'IeTJIIIBO C<POPMYJIIIpOBaIIO rrpIIMeUHTeJIblIO
R saga'IaM OT)J,eJIbHOH uaYRII SaMe'IaTeJIbUbIM llIBel1QapCRHM JIIIHrBIICTOM
q>. ge COCClOpOM, IIpIIJIOmIIBllIHM ero R IICCJIe)J,OBaUIIIO HSbIIWBbIX HBJIeUIIll 2.
B C6IIJ;eH JIIIUrBIICTIIRe 8TO paSJIII'IIIe IIplIBIIJIOCb II ORaSaJIOCb 'IpeSBb.I'IaHlIO
nJIO)XOTBOpUbIM, TaR RaK OUO BIIepBble IIOSBOJIIIJIO He TOJIbRO 'IeTRO ocosuaTb,
lIO II IICCJIegoBaTb CIICTeMUOCTb pe'III, BbIHBIITb BxogHIIJ;IIe B ee COCTaB rpaM-
MaTII'IeCRIIe CTPYRTypbI, IIOJIY'IIITb KapTIIHY IIepapXII'IeCROrO conO)J,'iIIUeHIIH
BbICRaSbIBaUIIH lIT. g. CeH'IaC B JIIIUrBIICTII'ieCROM IICCJIegoBaIIIIII paS:IH'iHe
CHUxpOUHoro II gIIaxpoHuoro conOCTaBJIeUIIH HBJIHeTCH <PyugaMeHTa.;rbUbIM
MeTogII'IeCRIIM Tpe60BaHIIeM, C06JIIO):(eHIIe ROToporo gaeT BOSMomuocTb IIC-
nOJIb30BaUIIH pHga 06IIJ;IIX npIIHQIIITOB nepexop;a OT IICTOpIIII HSbma R ero
cOBpeMeuHoMY COCTOHIIIIIO II Ha060pOT 3.
llJIOgOTBOpUOCTb TaKoro paSJIII'IeUHH Ha MaTepIIaJIe HSbma COBepIIIeUHO
eCTeCTBeHUO IIpIIBOgIIT R BOIIPOCY, B RaROM Mepe OUO IIpIIMeUIIMO R HBJIe-
HHHM KyJIbTypbI, II B nepBYro O'Iepep;b K TeM, KOTopbIe IICCJIegYIOTCH 8THO-
155
rpa<pJIeH. O'IeBJIp;UO, CaMbIM CYIIJ;eCTBeHHbIM KpJITepJIeM BOSMOmHOCTJI P;JI<p-
<pepeHQJIaQJIJI CIIHXpOHHOrO JI p;JIaXpOHHOrO CpeSOB HBJIHeTCH CJICTeMHOCTb
TeX HBJIeHJIH, KOTOpble IIOp;BepraIOTCH paCCMOTpeHJIIO. B CaMOM p;eJIe, IIpep;-
CTaBJIM ce6e, 'ITO IICC.:rep;yeMbIe <paKTbI JII060ro IIopHp;Ka He TOJIbKO B HameM
COSHaUIIJI, HO II B p;enCTBIITeJIbHOCTII He CKJIap;bIBaIOTCH B CIICTeMY, T. e. no
CYTII CBoeH He 06paSYIDT saKOUOMepuoro egIIHcTBa. B 8TOM CJIY'Iae IIX CJIH-
xpOHHoe paCCMOTpeUIIe ue BbIHBIIT HIIKaRJIX OIIJ;YTIIMbIX cBHseH MeIKP;Y UJIMH,
a SUa'IIIT, II KaIKgbIH <paKT B CBoeM BpeMeHuoM CTaUOBJIeUIIII p;OJImeu pac-
cMaTpIIBaTbcH oTgeJIbUO, BHe CBHSJI c P;PyrJIMII. HaIIpoTIIB, IIpJI paCCMOTpe-
HUH JII060H CIICTeMbI B KaIKp;bIH MOMeHT BpeMeHH MbI BbIgeJIHeM ee <PYHRQllO-
HaJIbHOe MeCTO B 60JIee 06IIJ;eH CIIeTe:\IHOH KaTeropIIII JI IIpOCJIeIKIIBaeM ee
JISMeUeHIIH BO BpeMeUII '.
BOIIpOC 0 CIICTeMHOCTJI 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOH 'KYJIbTypbI BOSHJIK BMeCTe c paSBJI-
TIIeM B HaYRe CHCTeMHoro MblmJIeHIIH II ocosuaHHeM 'IpeSBbI'IaHUO llIIIpOKJIX
c<pep ero npIIMeueUIIH. He IIMeH BOSMOmUOCTJI, ga JI He06xop;IIMOCTll OCTauaB-
JIIIBaTbCH Ha 8Tallax paspa60TRII COOTBeTCTBYIOIIJ;IIX IIgen, YKaIKY IIS IIOCJIeg-
HIIX pa60T Ha JICCJIep;OBaHIIH 8. C. MapRapHHa S, B KOTOpbIX cgeJIaHa nonbIT-
Ka npOaHaJIIISIIpOBaTb OTUOCHIIJ;JIeCH K 8TOH np06JIeMe <paKTbI, paccMoTpeTb
caMY IIp06JIeMY TeOpeTII'IeCKII II gaTb IIOJIOJ:I{HTeJIbHOe ee pellIeHJIe, T. e. IIO-
KasaTb CIICTeMHbIH xapaKTep peSYJIbTaTOB 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOH geHTeJIbHOCTII II B
IJ;eJIOM CIICTeMHOCTb KaTeropIIH KYJIbTypbI. B PYCJIe TaKoro pellIeUIIH JIeIKIIT
IlgeH CJICTeMUOCTJI 8THoca, paspa6aTbIBaeMaH TaKIIMII paSJIJI'IHbIMII no CBOIIlVf
BSrJIH)Xa"'f IICCJIegoBaTeJIHMJI, KaK JI. H. fYMIIJIeB 6 II 10. B. BpOMJIeH 7
aprYMeUTaQIIH IIpegcTaB.:reHIIH 06 3Tuoce JI Bcex IIHTerpHpyeMblx HM HBJIe-
UJIHX KaK 0 crYCTKe JIu<popMaIJ;JIII, OCYIIJ;eCTBJIeHUaH C. A. ApynoHoBbIM II
H. H. lle60KcapoBbIM B, II T. p;. Cop;eplKauJIe 3TIIX pa60T p;aeT OCHOBaHlle
IIpegIIOJIaraTb, 'ITO He TOJIbKO 'IeJIOBe'IeCKaH KYJIbTypa Bo06IIJ;e, HO II KaKIIe-TO
BxogHIIJ;JIe B ee COCTaB KOMIIoHeHTbI, HaIIpJIMep cYMMa HBJIeHIIn, OXBaTbIBae-
MbIX IIOHHTJIeM Hapo}:(uoH KYJIbTYPbI (no):(pasYMeBaeTCH B }:(aHuoM CJIY'Iae He
IlgeH uapO}:(UOCTII KaK 06paIIJ;eHIIe K nIITaTeJIbHOH HapogHoH IIO'IBe B IICTOplIll
MUorJIX BbICOKOpaSBJITbIX KYJIbTYP, oc06euHo IIOJIUO paspa60TaHuaH Ha
MaTepJIaJIe PYCCKOH JIIITepaTYPbI 9 , a uapoguaH KYJIbTypa RaK HBJIeHJIe 8THII-
'IeCROrO nJIaHa), npe):(cTaBJIHIOT C060H CIICTeMbI pasHoro HepapXII'IeCKOrO
ypOBUH, OTJIII'IaIOIIJ;HecH KaIKgaH cBoeH OC060H CTPYKTYPOH.
B paMKax TaKoH KOHCTaTaIJ;JIII CIICTeMHOCTII 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOH KYJIbTYPbI.
a TaKIKe CIICTeMHOCTII 8THoca IIOUHTJIH CIIHxpouuoro JI gJIaXpOUHoro cpaBue-
HIIH IIpII06peTaIOT OC06bIH ueTpIIBHaJIbHbIH CMbICJI IIpIIMeHJITeJIbUO K aHaJIH-
sY 8Tuorp a <p II 'IeCKJIX HBJIeUIIH, a JIX paccMOTpeHJIe CTaHOBJITCH HaCYIIJ;uOH
sa}:(a'IeH B IIsY'IeHIIII 60JIee 06IIJ;eH IIpo6JIeMbI reueSIIca MHOrJIX oc06eHuoCTeH
Hapo}:(uOH RYJIbTypbI II gpeBHOCTJI IIX llCTOpJI'IeCKOH peKoucTpYKIJ;JIJI. ECJIII
RYJIb'l'ypa II 8TUOC CIICTeMHbI, TO, BeCbMa BepOH'lHO, MorYT 6bITb CIICTeMHbI
H P;PyrHe BXO)XHIIJ;JIe B KYJIbTYPY KOMIIOHeHTbI, HaIIpIIMep Hapop;Hoe IICRyCCTBO
II IIopoIKgaIOIIJ;JIe ero nCIIXOJIOrII'IeCKIIe II 8TUII'IeCKIIe IIpeW TaBJIeHIIH, COBO-
RYIIUOCTb IIOJIOIKIITeJIbHbIX suaHIIH, 06paSYIOIIJ;IIX JIH<popMaQllOHHoe nOJIe TOH
IIJIH llHOH 8TUJI'IeCKOH llJIJI KYJIbTYpHOH 06IIJ;UOCTII, II T. p;. KaRoBbI 8TJI CHCTe-
MbI II RaKOBa CTeneHb JIX COIIOp;qIIHeHJIH, CKOJIb peSKO BblpalKeUbI llX rpaUJIQbI
II qTO npollcxogHT B nOrpaHJI'IHbIX 06JIaCTHX Memgy HJIMJI, KaK BbICOK ypo-
BeUb JIX JIHTerpaQIIJI JI KaROBa IIX CTpYRTYpa, HaKoueQ, eCTb Jill B 'IeJIOBe'Ie-
CIWH KYJIbType 6eccTPYKTypHbIe 06JIaCTll? Bce 3TO BOIIpOCbI, Ha KOTopble B
cYIIJ;eCTBYIOIIJ;eH RYJIbTypoBep;qeCKOH II 8Tuorpa<pJI'IeCKOH TeOpeTJI'IeCKOH JIll-
TepaType IIOKa neT OTBeTa.
A MeIKP;Y TeM COBepIIIeHHO O'IeBIIp;HO, 'ITO IIPII CIICTeMHOM IIop;xop;e CJIH-
xpOHHoe cpaBueHIIe JIMeeT CMbICJI TOJIbKO B IIpep;eJIax pH)J.a WaKTOB, OTHOCH-
156 .
llJ;IIXCH K OP;UOH CIICTeMHOH KaTerOpIIII (OTpIIQaH CIICTeMUblH J10P;XOP;, MbI
IIpaKTII'IeCKJI JIIIIIIaeMCH TeOpeTII'IeCKOH BOSMomlIOCTII 06'bHCUIITb 8MIIIIpII'Ie-
CKII 6eCCIIOpUYID 6eCIIJIO):\UOCTb CpaBUIITeJIbUOrO MeToga npII npIIMeUeUIIII K
paSHOpOp;IIbIM <paKTRM). )J,IIaXpOHHOe CpaBReHIIe TaKme B IIepBYID O'Iepep;b
8<p<peRTHBUO B paMRaX p;JIIITeJIbHOCTII cyIIJ;eCTBOBaUIIH Toil IIJIII IIHOH CIICTe-
MbI. Ho He p;aeT Jill OUO RaKIIX-JIII60 rrOSUaBaTeJIbUbIX IIepCIIeKTIIB npH BbIXO-
ge sa 8TII paMRn, CRameM, IIPII cpaBHeUIIII paSHopOD;UbIX HBJIeUIIH, OT-
IIOCHIIJ;IIXCH K OglIOH II TOH me c<pepe I{YJIbTypbI? HanpIIMep, apXeOJIOrII'IeCKII
):\ORYMeHTIIpOBaRuoro CBaHuoro mIIJIIIIIJ;a HeOJIIITII'IeCKOrO BpeMeUII II Tpap;II-
I IIOHHbIX eBpOIIelICKlIX TIIIIOB mIIJIIIIIJ;a 10. IIJIII II;J;eOJIOrII'IeCKIIX IIpegcTaBJIeUIIii
UeOJIIITIPleCRHX OXOTUIIROB II pbI60JIOBOB IInn6aHKaJIbH, KaK OUII sa<pIIKCIIpO-
BaHbI B IICKYCCTBe, II Mllpa IIgeH TYRrYCO-MaUb'ImypcRIIx uapO):\OB CII6HPII,
BCRpbITblX 8TlIorpa<pII'IeCKIIMH Ha6moJJ;eUIIHMII B XIX - ua'IaJIe XX B. 11
B npaKTII'IeCKIIX IICCJIegoBauIIHX TaKIIe cpaBueuIIH <PIIrYPIIPYIDT O'IeUb 'IaCTO.
Ho OCHOBUOH BOIIpOC Bce me OCTaeTCH npII 8TOM 6es OTBeTa: KaKoH xpouo-
JIorII'IeCKIIH paspbIB MaKCIIMaJIbHO P;OIIYCTIIM Memgy COIIOCTaBJIHeMbIMII HBJIe-
IIIIHMII npII TaROM cpaBueHIIII II B 'IeM JIemaT KplITepIIII BOSMOJf{UOCTII IIJIll
HeBOSMomUOCTII caMoro cpaBueUIIH, IIUbIMII CJIOBaMII, KaKOBbI XpOUOJIorlI'Ie-
CKlIe paMKII IIpogYKTIIBHoro IICnOJIbSOBaUIIH cpaBUIITeJIbHO-llCTOpII'IeCKOrO
MeTop;a? 12
CHHXPOHHOE CP ABHEHHE
CIIUxpOHHoe cpaBueuIIe IIpegIIOJIaraeT oWIoBpeMeHHocTb cpaBHIIBaeMblx HB-
JIeHIIH. OguaKo rrpaRTH'IeCKH IIOJIUaH op;uoBpeMeHuocTb cpaBHIIBae Iblx HBJIe-
HIIH B 8THorpa<pHII He):\ocTIImIIMa, 'ITO CBHsalIO C ):\eHcTBIIeM P;BYX 06'beKTIIB-
HbIX <paKTopOB. IIepBbIH IIS UIIX COCTOIIT B p;JIHTeJIbUOCTII 6bIToBaHIIH MUO-
rIIX 8JIeMeUTOB KYJIbTYPbI. KaKIIe-To Tpap;IIQllII saCTpoHRII, HaIIpIIMep, coxpa-
UHIOTCH 6es IIsMeueuIIH MHUIIMYM ua npoTHmeuIIII ):\ecHTHJIeTIIH, 'ITO geJ\wu-
cTpIIpyeTcH p;aHHbIMll no BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHcKoMY mHJIIIIIJ;Y II mIIJIHIIJ;Y ):\PyrlIx
uapop;oB EBponbI l3 , TOT IIJIH HUOH nOKpOH op;emp;bI, oc06eHII0 eCJIII OU BOSUIIK
B pesyJIbTaTe IIPIICIIOC06JIeUIIH K CypOBbIM yCJIOBHHM cpegbI, KaK 8TO IIMeJIO
MeCTO Y Hapop;OB CII6HpII II ApKTII'IeCKOrO II06epembH AMepllKH, O'IeBIIp;UO,
COXpaUHJI CBOH IIOJIeSUble oc06eHUOCTII 6es cepbeSUbIX IIsMeueuIIH CTOJIe-
TIIHMH 14.
BTOpOH 06'beKTHBUbIH <paRTOP, BCJIe):\CTBHe KOToporo ueBOSMomHO P;OCTII-
meUHe nOJIIWH CIIUXPOUUOCTH, SaRJIIO'IaeTCH B cIIoc06e <PHRcaQHII 8THorpa<pH-
'IeCRIIX <paRToB. KaR 6bI HII 6bIJI 06'beKTIIBen IICCJIe):\OB3TeJIb B IIOJIeBOH pa-
60Te, R RaROH 6bl IIOJIHOTe c60pa IIu<popMaQIIII ou HII CTpeMIIJICH, Bce paBUO
OU <pIIRcIIpyeT TY IIJIII IIHYIO KYJIbTYpUYID oc06elIUOCTb B OIIpe):(eJIeHUbIH IIe-
pIIOg BpeMeUII, ROIIRpeTHO rOBopH, B rop; CBoeH 8KcnegIIQIIII. IIo OTHOIIIeHIIIO
K nocTpoHRaM MomeT 6bITb <pIIKcIIpoBau rOg cosgauIIH, uo II TO C OrpaIIII'Ie-
HHJJMII II 'IaIIJ;e Bcero TOJIbKO B TOM CJIY'Iae, Korga 1I0CTpOHKa BosBegeua ua
npOTHmeHIIII mIISUII O):\IIoro, Muoro - gBYX IIOKOJIeUHH IIepep; rogoM IIa6JIIO-
p;eHHH. IIo OTHOlIIeUIIIO K npep;MeTaM op;emp;bI TaKaH <PIIKcaQIIH yme HeBOS.
MOJf{Ua IIJIII BOSMomHa JIIIlIIb B pep;KIIX CJIY'IaHX II COBceM ueBosMomua, Rorga
geJIO RacaeTC-H HBJIeUIIH gyXOBHOH KYJIbTypbI. TO'IHOCTII p;aTIIpOBKII He IIOMO-
raeT II TIInOJIOrnsaQIIH KOHRpeTHbIX Ha6JIIO):\eUIIH, II BbI):\eJIeUIIe CTPYRTYPUbIX
RaTeropHH KYJIbTypHbIX HBJIeUIIH: 8KCTpaIIOJIHQIIH IIeIIs6emuo CBHsaua C Ha-
PYlIIeUIIeM CHHXPOUIIll B oTgeJIbHbIX CJIY-'IaHX, BpeMH BOSIIIIKUOBeUIIH Bbl):(e-
JIeUUbIX CTPYKTypUbIX KaTeropIIH OCTaeTCH HeorrpegeJIeHHbIM, a caMII KaTe-
ropIIII IIpe):\CTaBJIHIOT C060H peaJIbUO cYIIJ;ecTBYIOIIJ;IIe, HO He BOIIJIOIIJ;eUUbJe
B peaJIbHbIX e):\IIUII'IlIbIX 06'beKTaX TeOpeTII'IeCKIIe ROUCTpyRIJ;HII, npOIISBOJIb-
HO paSMeIIJ;aeMbIe HaIIIHM cosuaHIIeM B CIIDXPOHUOH nJIOCROCTII. OTMe'IeHUble
157
TPYAIIOCTII OCTaIOTCH B CIIJIe II IIPII IIOJIbSOBaHlI1I CTapOII 8THOrpa<pH'IeCKOii
JIIITepaTYPOH, TaK KaR MUOrlIe lIS C006IIJ;aeMbIX eID cBegeulIH Bo06IIJ;e TPYAHO
AaTlIpOBaTb. IIosToMY, rOBOpH 0 CIIHXPOHUOM CpaBUeHIIII, HymHo ue yny-
CI{aTh IIS BII):(Y, 'ITO CIIUXpOHHOCTb 8Ta OTHOCIITeJIbHaH II OXBaTbIBaeT 06bI'IHO
caMoe MaJIOe HeCKOJIbRO p;eCHTROB JIeT.
TaROH BpeMeUHOH IIHTepBaJI II nplIUHT BO MuorlIX IICc.rre,1J;OBaUIIHX, IIo-
CBHIIJ;eUHbIX ROURpeTUOlllY cpaBueUIIIO Tex IIJIII IIHbIX oc06eIIIIOCTeH KYJIbTYPbI
IT 6bITa B 3IIOXY, 6J1IISKYIO K COBpeMeUHOCTII. IlpIIMepoM TOMY HBJIHIOTCH IIC-
ropIIRO-8THorpa<pII'IeCRHe aTJIaCbI, ns):(aBaeMble BO MuorlIX CTpauax. B gBYX
IIsgauHblx TOM ax IICTOpIIRO-8TIIOrpa<pII'IeCROrO aTJIaCa «PYCCRlIe,), nOCBHIIJ;eH-
HbIX fIUIJIIIIIJ;Y, ROCTIOMY II 'IaCTII'IUO opua:\'reuTy Ha ROCTIOMe, CHHXPOHIISII-
PYJOTCH na6mOJJ;eHIIH, OTUOCHIIJ;IIeCH R IIOCJIeAHeii 'IeTBepTII XIX - )XopeBOJIIO-
lJ;IIOUHbIM rogaM XX B., T. e. OXBaTbIBaIOIIJ;IIe IIeplIOA IIpHMepHO B ITOJICTO-
JIeTIIH 15. IlplI6JIIISIITeJIbHO TOT me glIanasoH BpeMeUII IISY'IaeMbIX II
KapTorpa<plIpyeMblx HBJIeUIIH (pe'Ib IIp;eT, paSYMeeTCH, 0 BpeMeHH I1X <pIIRca-
lJ;IIII. a He ObITOBaHIIH, KOTopoe Mor JIO 6bITb SUa'IIITeJIbUO 60JIbIIIe) xa paR-
Tepeu 60JIbllieH 'IaCTbID II g.rrH aTJIaCOB eBponeHCRIIX CTpaH 16. CJIomuee 00-
CTOIIT JJ;eJIO C MaTeplIaJIaMII IICTOPIIRO-8Tuorpa<pII'IeCROrO aTJIaCa CII6IIplI, CO;:.-
}J;aIIHoro Ha OCIIOBe IISY'IeHIIH KOJIJIeKIJ;IIH, ROTopbIe 6bWII c06pau.bI
npeHMYIIJ;eCTBeHuo BO BTOpOH rrOJIOBIIHe XIX - IIepBbIX )IeCHTIIJIeTIIHX XX B.,
HO peSYJIbTaTbI IICCJIe.lOBaHIIH KOTOpbIX SKCTpaIIOJIIIpOBaHbI Ha 8TIIII'IeCKYIO
cIITyaQIIIO, CJIOmlIBIIIYIOCH B CII6IIpII K npuxogy PyCCRIIX, II RapTOrpa<pIIpo-
BaHbI B COOTBeTCTBIIII C 8TOH clIryaIJ;IIeH 17 0 AHaJIOrlI'IUbIH nYTb, HelIs6em-
HbIII II3-Sa ue06xop;IIMOCTII CUHTb nOSAHee BJIIIHUIIe eBponeHCKoro paCceJIeUIIF!.
ObIJI IIs6paH II npII HOIIbITRax KapTorpa<plIpOBaTb HaHOHRYMeUHoe pacnpo-
CTpaHeHIIe Tex IIJIII IIHbIX SJIeMeUTOB RYJIbTYPbI TpaglIQIIOIIHhIX OOIIJ;eCTB.
npeAIIpIIHHTbIX B CTapbIX ueMeQKIIX KOMneUAIIYMax, cosgaHHblx rrpegcTaBu-
TeJIHMII KYJIbTYPUO-IiCTOplI'IeCKOH IIIKOJIbI 18, a TaKme B 60JIblliOM CBOgHOM
oosope nog pegaKQIIeH P. ElIaCYTTlI, BbIJJ;ep»mBIIIeM B llTaJIHII TpII IIs):(aUIIH 19 0
TaM TaRme Ha6JIIOAeHIIH 8TUorpa<pOB, cAeJIaUUbIe BO BTOpOII rro.rroBIIHe, Aallie
'IaIIJ;e B IIOCJIep;HeH 'IeTBepTII npomJIoro - Ha'IaJIe uarnero CTOJIeTIIH, IIepe-
HeceUbI Ha 8THII'IecRYID KapTY nepIIoga AO Ha'IaJIa lliIIpOROH eBponeHcKoii
BKcnaUCIIII. He'Iero II rOBopIITb, 'ITO IIoA06uaH 8RCTpanOJIHQIIH BBOgiiT AO-
nOJIHIITeJIblIbIH MOMeHT ueonpegeJIeHUOCTII B CIIHxpoHHoe cpaBlIeHIIe, II CO-
BepllieHuo O'IeBlIguo, 'ITO MOMeUT 8TOT JIIIllib 'IaCTII'IUO npeOAOJIeBaeTCH sa
C'IeT AJIIITeJIbUOCTII OTUOCIITeJIbUO cTa6IIJIbHorO cYIIJ;eCTBOBauIIH MHorIIX 8JIe-
MeHTOB KYJIbTypbI.
q TO me BbIHBJIHeT CIIHxpOHuoe cpaBueUlIe p;ame IIPII Bcex OTMe'IeUUbIX
EblIIIe OrpaHII'IeHIIHX? IlpemAe Bcero OUO BbIHBJIHeT MHoro06paSIIe JIOKaJIbHbIX
BaplIaIITOB JII060ro HBJIeUIIH KYJIbrypbI, CKameM, <pOpM OPyglIH Tpy):(a, Ba-
plIaUTOB COQlIaJIbUOH opraUlIsaQIIII IIJIH OCIIOBUbIX oc06eUUOCTeH Tex IIJIII p;py-
rlIx naACTpOe'IHbIX HBJIeHIIH. TOJIbKO IIaUOHRYMeHUbIH OXBaT JIORaJIbHbIX TU-
nOB RYJIbTYPHOH oc06eHHOCTII AaeT BOSMomUOCTb npe)ICTaBIITb Ha sa):(aunO}I
OTpeSRe BpCMeUII ('IaIIJ;e Bcero OJIIISKOM K COBpeMeUHOCTII) Bce Muoro06paSIIf
onpeJJ;eJIeHHOH KYJIbTypUOH oc06eUHOCTII B paSUbIX JIORaJIbUbIX RYJIbTypax.
paSJIII'IHbIX STHII'IeCKIIX 06IIJ;HOCTHX II T. p;.
8TOT peSYJIbTaT 6bIJI OC03IIaH eIIJ;e Ha sape HaY'IHOrO neplIop;a B IICTO-
pIIII 8Tuorpa<plIlI. [(eJIbID IICCJIegoBaHIIH C'IIITaJIOCb RaK Momuo 60JIee nOJIUoe
onlIcaHlIe MaTeplIaJIbHOH II AYXOBUOH RYJIbTYPbI IIepBOObITHbIX uapOAGE
c nepeueceUIIeM, Korp;a 8TO ObIJIO BOSMomuo, IITOrOB TaRoro onIIcaUIIH na reo-
rpa<pH'IeCKYID KapTY. 8TO 6bIJIO xapaKTepuo II gJIH 8BOJlIOQIIOUHOH mKOJIbI 2-.
n AJIH aHTponoreorpa<pII'IeCKOrO HanpaBJIeHIIH 21, II AJIH IIIKOJIbI KYJIbTypHbIX
KPyroB 22. IlocJIeAUeH Mbl 06HsaHbI oc06euHo IIIlIpORIIM IIcnOJIbSOBaHIIeM
158
KapTbI II CIIHXpOUUOro KapTOrpa<pIIpOBaHIIH 23. MeTOp; KapTOrpa<pIIpOBaHIIH
6bIJI nepeUeCeH II B apXeOJIOrIIIO, rp;e OH IICIIOJIbSOBaJICH P;JIH geMoHCTpaQIIII
reorpa<pII'IeCKOrO paCnpOCTpaHeHIIH oTgeJIbHbIX RYJIbTypHbIX 8JIeMeUTOB (IIpe-
IIMYIIJ;eCTBeUUO TIIIIOB KepaMIIHII II oTgeJIbHbIX geTaJIeH IIorpe6aJIbHOrO KOMII-
JIeRCa) B CIIUXPOHHbIX naMHTUIIKaX 2\ 3aAa'Ia COSUaTeJIbHOrO II IIOCJIegoBa-
TeJIbHOro CpaBUeUHH KapT, OTHOCHIIJ;XCH R apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJIaM pas-
DOra BpeMeHH, npII 8TOM, RaK IIpaBIIJIO, lIe CTaBIIJIaCb.
3Ua'IIITeJIbUbIM IIIarOM BIIepeJJ; 6bIJIO COOTneceHIIe peSYJIbTaTOB KapTorpa-
<pIIpOBaUHH KYJIbTypHbIX 8JIeMeHTOB C 8THII'IeCKOH RapTOH. IIo CYTII ):(eJIa,
HMeHUO TaRoe COOTHeceUIIe nOCJIyIKIIJIO TOJI'IKOM K o<pop 1JIelIIIlO 8Tuoreorpa-
tPIIII, KOTopaH QeJIIIKOM HBJIHeTCH TBOp'IeCKIIM gocTIIIKeHIIeM PYCCKOH H COBeT-
CROH uaYKII. KaR 8TO 'IaCTO 6bIBaeT ua IIepBbIx IIopax, HORoe UanpaBJIeUHe
HCCJIegoBaHIIll BblrJIHgeJIO gocTaTO'IHO ar.IOp<pubL\I, TaK KaK He 6bIJIII OC03uaHbI
ero geHcTBIITeJIbHble rpaHIIIJ;bI, IIpe)1MeT IICCJIegoBaHIIH 25.
)J,aJIbUeHnraH ero paspa60TKa IIIJIa KaK no JIIIUHII BbI'IJIeUeUIIH 'IeTRIIX
ROUTypOB COOTBeTCTBYIOIIJ;eH IIpOOJIeMaTIIKII, TaK II IIO nYTII 060raIIJ;eHIIH 8T-
Horeorpa<pIIII MeTogaMII, paspa60TaHUbIMII B CMeIKHbIX HaYRax,- KapTorpa-
<pII'IeCKIIM, geMorpa<pII'IeCKIIM II T. g.26 Ony6JIIIKOBaHHaH B 70-x rop;ax
06IIIIIpuaH CBO)J:uaH pa60Ta no 8THoreorpa<pIIII, cogepIKaIIJ;aH 06CTOHTeJIbHOe IIS-
JIOmeHIIe TeOpeTH'IeCKHX BOIIpOCOB 8TOM uaY'IHOH gIICQIInJIIIUbI II ee MeTogo-
JIOrIIII, IIJIJIIOCTpIIpOBaUHaH 60JIbIIIIIM 'IIICJIOM paSJIII'IHbIX IIO o<popMJIeHIIIO
KapT, )J;aeT P;OBOJIbHO nOJIUoe npep;CTaBJIeUHe 0 COBpeMeHHOM COCTOHUIIII SHa-
HIIH B 8TOH 06JIaCTII 27.
CIIHxpOUIIoe cpaBueUIIe, eCJIH OUO OCYIIJ;eCTBJIHeTCH ua OCUOBe MaCCOBbIX
gaHHbIx II npoeRTIIpyeTcH ua KapTY, BOCCTaUaBJIHBaeT apeaJIbI oTgeJIbHbIX Ba-
pHaUTOB KYJIbTypHbIX oc06eUUOCTeH, IIOMoraeT IIOUHTb, paCIIpOCTpaHeHbI JIH
8TH BapHaUTbI lIa mHpOKIiX nJIOIIJ;ap;HX IIJIH 'IepeCIIOJIOCUO, a TaKIKe ollpege-
JIHTb xapaKTep rpaHHQ MeIKP;Y apeaJIaMH, xapaKTep nepexoAa OT o):(Horo THna
K APyroMY - nJIaBHblH n nocTeneuublH IIJIII pesRHH II npepbIBIIcTbIH. CTapaH
MOHorpa<pIIH II. II. KynrHepa gaeT JJ;O CIIX IIOp ue npeBSOHJJ;eUHbIH IIO IIOJIUO-
Te p;aUHbIX pas60p xapaKTepa rpauIIQ MeIKP;Y apeaJIaMH paSJIH'IHbIX TIIIIOB
HBJIeUIIH MaTepIIaJIbUOH KYJIbTYPbI B 8TUII'IeCKII cMemauuoH SOHe 28. IIpH
COIIOCTaBJIeHHH C 8THII'IeCKIIMII rpaHHQaMH BIIP;HO, cOBIIagaeT JIH paCIIpOCTpa-
ueUIIe JII060H KYJIbTYPUOH 'IepTbI C apeaJIOM O):(Horo Hapoga HJIH OXBaTbIBaeT
UeCKOJIbRO Hapop;OB, HBJIHeTCH JIll, CJIegoBaTeJIbUO, p;aHuaH KYJIbTypHaH 'Iep-
Ta 8THll'IeCKH CIIeIJ;H<pH'IHOH IIJIH UeHTpaJIbHOH.
HaKOHeQ, IIpoIIsBegH CIIHxpouuoe cpaBHeUIIe paSHbIX KyJIbTypUbIX oc06eu-
HOCTeH H conOCTaBJIHH peSYJIbTaTbI, KapTorpa<pH'IeCKH COOTUOCH rpaUIIQbI
pacIIpocTpaHeHIIH RaIKAoro BapHaHTa p;aHHoH RYJIbTYPHOH 'IepTbI C apeaJIaMH
JIOKaJIbUbIX BapIIaUTOB APyrHx npHSHaKOB, MbI BbIHBJIHeM RYJIbTypUbIe KOMn-
JIeKCbI, OQeHHBaeM CTeIIeHb HX BblpalKeHUOCTII II onHTb, HO yIKe ua IIUOM
ypOBHe, OTBe'laeM Ha BOllpOC 06 HX 8THH'leCKOH CIIeIJ;H<pIIKe IIJIII HeHTpaJIbIIO-
CTII. IIepBbIM 0606IIJ;eHIIeM peSYJIbTaTOB CHUxpouuoro cpaBHeUHH Ha ypOBue
ROMIIJIeKCOB 6bIJIa IIAeH KYJIbTypUbIX apeaJIOB 29, p;aJIbUeHnree IICTOJIROBaUIIe
8TH ROMnJIeKCbI 1l0JIY'IHJIH, KorAa IIPH COIIOCTaBJIeHIIII C 8TUH'IeCROH KapTOH
OUII CTaJIII paCCMaTpHBaTbCH KaK IICTOpHKO-8THorpa<pII'IeCKHe 06JIacTH, OTpa-
IKaIOIIJ;He IICTOpH'IeCKYID IKIISHb HapogoB 30.
ECTb eIIJ;e OgIIU aCneRT OQeUKH TaKIIX KYJIbTypUbIX KOMnJIeKCOB, KOTOpbIH,
IIO-BHgHMOMY, OTKpbIBaeTCH CHUXPOHUbIM cpaBHeHHeM. CXO}J;HbIe reorpa<pH'Ie-
CKHe YCJIOBHH (XOTH CXOgCTBO 8TO II He 6bIJIO IIop;BeprUYTO aUaJIHSY) IIopom-
):(aIDT CXOgHbIH xapaKTep XOSHHCTBeUHOH p;eHTeJIbHOCTII, a ua ee OCHOBe, KaK
CJIeACTBHe OIIocpep;OBaHHoro eID IIpHCnOc06JIeHHH K reorpa<pII'IeCROH cpep;e,
BOSHHKaIDT nOXOIKHe 'IepTbI KYJIbTYPbl, 060SHa'IaeMbIe KaK XOSHHCTBeHHO-
I
:
159
RYJIbTYPUble TIInbI 31 . ABTop YCMaTpllBaeT sapogbIIII lIgell JIaugIIIa<pTHO-
reorpa<pII'IeCROH 06YCJIOBJIeHUOCTll XOSHHCTBeUUO-KYJIbTYPHOH p;eHTeJIbHOCTII
'IeJIOBe'IeCCTBa B CTapbIX <pOPMYJIIIpOBKaX B. r. Boropasa-ToHa 32 II JI. C. Bep-
ra 3\ eCJIII IIX oCB060gIITb OT IISBeCTHOH npHMOJIIIHeHUOCTII. CaM no ce6e
XOSHHCTBeUUO-KYJIbTYPHbIH TIIII He eCTb 8JIeMeUTapHoe HBJIeHIIH, OH OXBaTbI-
BaeT MHorIIe AeHCTBIITeJIbHO 8JIeMeHTapUbIe H'IeHKII - aUTpOIIOreOIJ;eHOSbI,
COCTaBJIHIOIIJ;IIe CTPYKTypHoe egIIHcTBO XOSHHCTBeUHoro KOJIJIeKTllBa II 8KC-
IIJIyaTIIpyeMoH II f cpeAbI 3 ". Ho Bce me conOCTaBJIeTIIIe peSYJIbTaTOB CIIH-
xpOHHoro cpaBUeUTIH 8Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX HBJIeUIIH C naHOHRYMeHUOH RapTOH
JIaII;rJ:llImpTHbIX SOH IIOSBOJIHeT KaK 6YP;TO YJIOBIITb TeHgeUQIIII KY.J:bTypHOH
a;:J,anTaQIIII 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa 35.
Bce CRasaUHoe cBIIp;eTeJIbCTByeT C O'ieBII):(HocTbIO, 'ITO HlI lIS O]J;UOH onepa-
IJ;IIII CIIIIxpOHIIoro cpaBHeHIIH ue BbITeRaIDT aBTOMaTII'IeCIm p;IIaxpoHHble BbI-
BOJJ;bI, T. e. BbIBOAbl 0 reHe3l1ce, BpeMeUII qJOpMIIpoBaHIIH II 8Tanax IISMeHe-
HUH CIIHXPOUHO paCCMaTpIIBaeMbIX HBJIeHIIH. MomeT 6b1Tb, IUleIIHO HOSTOMY
IICTOpIIKII I{YJIbTYPbl II 8THorpa<pbI II npIIoeraIDT CTOJIb OXOTUO R apXeOJIOrIIII
npII peRoHcTpYKQIIU ):(peBHocTII SJIeMeUTOB MaTepIIaJIbUOH II JJ;YXOBUOH KYJIb-
TYPbl, a TaRme BpeMellii <pOpMIIpOBauIIH cOQIIa:lbubIX IIHCTIITYTOB 36. IIepe-
XOA OT CIIUXpOllIIII K gIIaxpoHllII Tpe6yeT cneQIIaJIbHOrO aUaJIIISa, HO, IIepep;
TeM KaK paccMoTpeTb ero <pOpMbI, lIeOOXOJJ;IIMO O'IepTIITb B03l\WmnOCTll
II rpauIIIJ;bI gIIaxpouHoro cpaBHeuIIH, K KOTOPOMY MbI II nepexogIIM.
AllAXPOHHOECPABHEHHE
B IICTOpIIII 8THUJIOrII'IeCROH MblCJIII yme ObIJfa IIonbITKa npaRTII'IeCRII oCY-
IIJ;eCTBIITb gIIaxpoIIlloe cpaBueHIIe II IICnOJIbSOBaTb ero pesYJIbTaTbI ):(JIH BOC-
CTaUOBJIellIIH reHeSIIca OTp;eJIbHblX 8JIeMeHTOB KYJIbTYPbI. Pe'Ib IIgeT 0 paoo-
Tax 8. T8HJIOpa II ero nOCJIegoBaTeJIelI - npe):(cTaBIITeJIeH OCHOBaHUOH IIM
3BOJIIOIJ;IIOUHOH IIIKOJIbI 37 . CpaBueUIIe B STlIX paOOTax IIPOIISBOgII.l:OCb na
OCUOBe OXBaTa, IIO BOSMomIlOCTII, Bcex BapIIallTOB aUaJIIISIIpyer.wro SJIeMeHTa
II pacnOJIOmeHIIH IIX OT npOCToro K CJIOmIIOMY. ¥CJIOmHeUIIe <pOpMbI II CTPYK-
TYPbI IIpHpaBIIIIBaJIOCb K BpeMeHHOH gIIuaMIIKe, H TaRIIM 06paSOM nOJIyqaJICH
3BOJllOQIIOHllblH pHg, nOCTpoeHIIe KOToporo OIIIIpaJIOCb Ha conOCTaBJIeHIIe
o):(HOBpeMeHHblx AallHblx; <paRTII'IeCRII HMeJI MeCTO nepexog OT CIIIIXPOUIIII K
AiiaxpOHIIII, 110 C IIOMOIIJ;bIO HegocTaTO'IUO IIpIIrogUblX gJIH SToro cpegcTB.
n08TOl\IY IIOCJIe):(OBaTeJIbllblii 8BOJIIOl(IIOUIIbIH IIOp;XOg B 8THorpa<pIIII, BbI-
pamaBmHHCH B IIOHIIMaUIIII 8BOJIIOQIIII JIIIllIb KaR MOHOTOHHoro IIepexoga 01
npOCToro R CJIOmHOMY, 6YP;Y'III RpynUbIM gocTIImeIIIIeM uaYRII gJIH CBoero
BpeMeUII, IICTIOJlbSOBa.ITCH B gaJIbHelIllieM C orOBopRaMII, II MbI ):(O.1JmHbI no):(-
'lepKUYTb SJJ;eCb ero OrpaUII'IeHIIOCTb.
"LITo B ):(eHCTBIITeJIbUOCTII He06xoJJ;IIMO ]J;JIH AIIaxpOIIIlOro nOJJ;XOiW, KaRIIe
MaTepIIaJIbl uymubI .o,JIH TIpOBeiJeUIIH ero n fRiiSUb? IIpemJJ;e Bcero STuorpa-
<pII'IeCRIIe ROJIJIeKQIIII II .o,aHHbIe Ua6JIIOp;eUlIii, OTUOCHIIJ;IIeCH R paSUbIM ne-
pIIOJJ;aM, OXBaTbIBaIOIIJ;IIM 60JIbmOH OTpeSOK BpeMeUII. 3aTeM nOJIIIOTa ROJIJIeR-
IJ;IIH II Ha6JIIOJJ;eHIIII, JIII60 nOSBOJIHIOIIJ;IIX SanOJIUIITb IICCJIeP;yeMbIH nepIIOp;
HenpepbIBUblMII pHgaMII <paRTOB, JIII60 JJ;onYCRaIOIl(IIX B HIIX mfllIb HeOO.1Jb-
IIIHe .1JaRYHbI. COBepllIeUIIO O'ieBIIp;UO, 'ITO TaRaH IIOJIUOTa eCJIII II )J;OCTIIlliIIMa,
TO ITO OTUOllieHIIIO JIIIllIb K oTgeJIbHbIM HeOOJIbmIIM TeppIITopIIHM II lIa rrpo-
THJ:I{eUIIII cpaBUIITeJIbUO OrpaUII'IelIHOro XpOHOJIOrII'IeCROrO OTpeSRa. Ho II B
aTOM CJIY'Iae IIOJIY'IaIOIIJ;HeCH peSYJIbTaTbI lIe.o,OCTaTO'IHO BbIpaSIITeJIbHbI.
06paTIIMCH B Ka'IeCTBe rrpIIMepa R BOCTO'IUOCJIaBHHCROMY fRIIJIIIIIJ;Y, ueno-
CpegcTBeuHaH <PIIRcaQIIH KOToporo MomeT 6bITb gOBep,eua go ua'IaJIa XIX B.,
I
t
.
-
,
160
eCJIH me rOBOpIITb 0 QepKOBUbIX IIOCTpOHRax, TO P;O KOHQa XVII B. MbI ro-
BOplIM B IIOCJIeglleM cJIY'Iae 06 OTUOCIITeJIbUO MaCCOBOM MaTeplIaJIe, oTAeJIb-
IIble KaMellllble xpaMbI 60JIee paHHero BpeMelllI, KaK IIpaBIIJIO, HenOBToplIMO
IIuAHBlIgyaJIbHbI (BosMomHo, OUII II Bo06IIJ;e 6bIJIII MaJIO'IIICJIeUubI), II B rro-
CBHIIJ;enIlOH IIM orpoMuOH JIIITepaType ueT e):(IIuoro IIOHIIMaHIIH IIX reHeSlIca
II gHuaMIIKII OTpameUUbIX B IIIIX apXIITeRTypHbIX CTIIJIeH 38. C Ha'IaJIa XIX B.
MOJI{HO npOCJIep;IITb KaKlIe-TO IISMeUeUIIH, 110 BpeMH, Ha IIpOTHmeUlI1I KOTO-
poro MomHO <pIIKclIpoBaTb 8TII IISMelleHIIH, IIC'IepIIbIBaeTCH 150 rop;aMII 39.
J\pxeOJIOrlI'IeCKII IISBeCTUO II XOpOIIIO IISY'IeHO BOCTO'IUOCJIaBHHCKoe 1KIIJIIIIQe
BIIOXII cpegHeBeKoBbH 40, HO yrJIy6JIeuIIe IIu<popMaQIIII P;O 8nOXII cpe):(ueBe-
IWBbH CTaJIO BOSM01KHbIM TOJIbKO C IIpIIBJIe'IeUlIeM apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX MaTeplIa-
JIOB II peROHCTpYKQIIH, T. e. C BbIXOgOM sa paMRII c06CTBeHIIO 8THorpa<pIIII.
I1cTOplI'IeCKII sacBlIgeTeJIbCTBOBaHHoe paCCeJIeUIIe BOCTO'IHbIX CJIaBHH Ha Tep-
pIITOpIIII, paIIee sauHToH <pIIUUOHSbI'IlIbIM HaCeJIeHIIeM, IIOSBOJIHeT 06'bHCHIITb
cplIlICKlIe 8JIeMeIITbI B BOCTO'IUOCJIaBHUCKOM 1KIIJIIIIIJ;e KaK uaCJIep;IIe gOCJIaBHH-
CRoro cy6cTpaTa, HO II 8TOT BbIBog nOJIY'IaeT IIpaBa rpa1KgaHcTBa TOJIbRO nplI
OIIope ua 06IIJ;eIICTOplI'IeCRYID IIU<popMaQIIIO. Bce CKasalluoe 0 BOCTO'IUOCJIa-
BHHCROM 1KIIJUIIIJ;e M01KHO IIOBTOplITb II 06 IICTOpIIII KOCTIOMa BOCTO'IUOCJIa-
BHHCKHX Hapop;OB 41.
06paIIJ;aHCb R p;IIaxpOUHOMY cpaBHeHIIIO gaHHbIx 06 06IIJ;eCTBeHuoM CTpoe,
MbI He M01KeM IICnOJIbSOBaTb apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKlIe gauHble, II eCJIII MbI ga1Ke
IIMeeM 0 HeM B peA'IaHllIIIX CJIY'IaHX HeIIocpep;CTBeUHYID IIH<popMaQIIIO, TO
OHa OIIHTb-TaKII HBJIHeTCH IITorOM He c06CTBeHUO 3THorpa<pII'IeCKOrO, a TIIJ;a-
TeJIbUOrO <pHJIOJIOrH'IeCKOrO aHaJIIISa, B nepBYID O'iepegb TepMIIUOJIOrIIII pop;-
CTBa. IIplIMepOM MorYT CJIY1KIITb COQHaJIbUble OTuOIIIeHIIH B KIITaHCKOM
06IIJ;eCTBe, KOTopble BBII):(Y HaJIII'IHH IIHCbMeHUbIX IIaMHTHIIKOB M01KUO peROU-
CTpYIIPOBaTb C IIsBeCTHbIMII OrpallII'IeUIIHMII lIa IIpOTH1KeHIIII Tpex TbICH'Ie-
JIeTIIH 42.
llaIIJ;e 1Ke Bcero c06CTBeHUO 8THorpa<pII'IeCRIIe CBeAeHIIH 0 ):(IIIIaMIIKe CO-
IIIIaJIbHbIX OTIIOIIIeHIIII, OCHOBaUUble Ha uenocpeJJ;CTBeHUOM 8THorpa<pII'IeCROM
Ha6JIIOgeu1IH, a ue IISBJIe'IeUHble IIS nlICbMeUIIbIX IICTO'IUIIKOB II auaJIlIsa
IIIICbMeuHbIx p;ORYMeHTOB, OrpaHII'IHBaIOTCH UeCKOJIbKIIMII gecHTIIJIeTIIHMII.
B Ka'IeCTBe IIplIMepa ComJIIOCb lIa IIOIIbITRY peKOHCTpYRQlI1I glIHaMIIRII 06IIJ;e-
CTBeuuoro CTpOH Y 8CRIIMOCOB, 6aSIIpYIOIIJ;eHCH ua cpaBHIITeJIbUOM COIIOCTaB-
JIeHlI1I II KpIITII'IeCKOM auaJIlIse IISBJIe'IeUHbIX IIS 8THorpa<pII'IeCKIIX OT'IeTOB
IIOJIeBbIX pa60THIIKOB CBep;eUIIH 0 COQlIaJIbHbIX OTUOllIeIIIIHX BIIYTPII oTgeJIb-
nbIX TeppIITOpIIaJIbUbIX rpynn 8CRIIMOCOB 43. B peSYJIbTaTe 6bIJI cJJ;eJIau BbI-
:BOA 0 rOCIIOJJ;CTBe Y 8CKIIMOCOB B IIpomJIOM pOJJ;OBOrO CTpOH II paSJI01KeUIIII
ero B npoQecce paCCeJIeHIIH, KOTopoe, O'ieBII):(uo, 6bIJIO MuorocTYIIeH'IaTbIM II
TH1KeJIbIM B 8KCTpeMaJIbUbIX YCJIOBIIHX ApRTIIKII. Ho TaRoH BbIBO):( BbIrJIH):(IIT
IIOJIHOCTbID HeocnoplIMbIM, TOJIbKO eCJIII 6esorOBOpO'IUO IIpIIIIHTb s4><peRTIIB-
nOCTb MeTop;a IIepemIITRoB B BOCCTaUOBJIeUIIII npOIIIJIoro, T. e. paccMaTpIIBaTb
JII060e apXalI'IHOe no <popMe HBJIeIIIIe TOJIbKO RaK UaCJIegIIe IIpOIIIJIOrO II rrOJI-
HOCTbID OTKasaTbCH OT BOSM01KUOCTII apXalI'IUbIX IIO <popMe IIHHOBaQIIH 44,
PaSpeIIIaIOIIJ;aH CIIJIa 8Toro MeTo):(a lIa paSUbIX 8Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX MaTeplIaJIaX
TeOpeTII'IeCKII HegocTaTO'IUO IICCJIe):(OBaHa, HO HCHO Y1Ke, 'ITO ero IIpHMeHe-
nile HY1Kp;aeTCH B OrpaUII'IeHIIHX. II AeHCTBIITeJIbHO, IISY'IeHlIe CIICTeM pop;-
CTBa aSIIaTCKIIX 8CKIIMOCOB C BOCCTaUOBJIeUIIeM nOJIUbIX pOP;OCJIOBUbIX B pas-
HbIX TepplITOplIaJIbUbIX rpYIInax IIORaSaJIO, 'ITO TaKIIe CIICTeMbI pogcTBa
UOJIbIIIe COOTBeTCTBYIDT He pOP;OBOMY CTpOID KaR IICXOgUOH MogeJIII, a CIICTeMe
:mgoraMubIX rpYIIn 45. IIocJIegHeH 60JIbIIIe COOTBeTCTBYIDT II JJ;aHUble 0 xa-
paRTepe <pIISII'IeCKIIX paSJIII'IIIH Memp;y OTAeJIbHbIMII IIOIIYJIHQIIHMII 3C-
KIIMOCOB 46.
6 B. II. AJIeRCeeB
161
KaK MbI BIIgIIM, BOSMOmHOCTII p;IIaXpOHUOro CpaBHelJIIH C06CTBelIUO 8THO-
rpa<pII'IeCKIIX MaTep.llaJIOB O'IeUb orpaUII'IeUUbI. IIosToMY B nOnbITKaX peROU-
CTPYRQIIII 8TUOrpa<pII'IeCRIIX HBJIeUIIH IIpOmJIOro 3Tuorpa<pbI-CIIeQlIamICTbI
npH6eraIOT OXOTHO, RaK yme ynoMIIUaJIOCb, K gauubIM CMemUbIX AIICIJ,IIJIJIIIU.
Ho HX IIpIIBJIe'IeHHe BbIXOP;IIT sa paMRII ):(IIaxpOHuoro cpaBueUIIH B ;:;THorpa-
<pIIII, 0 KOTOpOM IIp;eT pe'Ib.
BJIHHHHE I'EOI'P AwHqECROn CPE,lJ;bI
HA 3THOI'P AwlJqECKHE HBJIEHHJ:I
Bblme yme rOBOpIIJIOCb 0 KOHQeIIQIIII, npllSHaIOIIJ;eH SUa'IIITeJIbHOe BJIIIHUlle
reorpa<pII'IeCKIIX YCJIOBIIH, B KOTOpbIX JIpOmllBaeT Hapog, ua ero XOSHHCTBO
II RYJIbTYPY II BbIJIIIBIJIeHCH B npegcTaBJIeHlle 0 XOSHHCTBeUUO-KYJIbTYPIIbIX
TIIIIax II aHTponoreOQeHosax. )J,a II TeOpeTII'IeCRII, game eC:III OTRasaTbCH OT
IIOJIOmeUIIH reorpa<pII'IeCROrO geTepMIIUIISMa, IIpOHBJIHBmllXCH B paSUbIX <pop-
Max B HaYRe 0 KYJIbType IIa npOTHmeUIIII ABYX CTOJIeTIIH \ TPygIIO npep;-
CTaBIITb ce6e IIOJIUYIO aBTOUOMUOCTb KYJIbTypHoro paSBIITIIH OT reorpa<pII'Ie-
CKOH cpep;bI lIe TOJIbKO Ha paHUIIX, UO II Ha IIOSgHIIX 8Tanax MCTOpllII 'IeJIO-
Be'IeCTBa. KOUKpeTUble <pOpMbI TaKoro BJIIIHUIIH reorpa<pH'IeCROH cpegbI ua
XOSHHCTBO II KYJIbTYPY, eCTeCTBeuuo, O'ieUb Muoro06paSUbI, CJIOmHbI II He
AO KOHQa BbIHB:IeHbI p;o CIIX IIOp 8.
HeROTopble aCIIeI{TbI 8Toro BJIIIHHIIH, op;uaKo, O'IeBllp;UbI II OTMe'IeUbI B
IICCJIep;OBaUIIHx no XOSHHCTBeHuO-KYJIbTypUOH TllnOJIOrllll. XapaKTep JIalIg-
ma<pTa He MomeT ue onpe):(eJIHTb UanpaBJIeHIIe XOSHIICTBa, a rocIIogcTBYIO-
IIJ;lIe B npeAeJIax 06mIITOH 'IeJIOBe'IeCRIIM ROJIJIeKTIIBOM 8JIeMeUTapHOH JIaHJJ;-
IIIa<pTlIOH eglllIlIQbI 6JIarOIIpllHTIIble IIJIII ue6JIarOIIpIIHTUbIe gJIH Hero YCJIO-
BIIH - IIUTeUCIIBHOCTb XOSHHCTBeUUOH geHTeJIbUOCTII. B y'IeUHII 06
arpoQeuosax paspa60Taua CllCTeMa 3uepreTII'IeCKOH xapaKTepllCTIIKII IIUTelI-
CIIBUOCTII XOsHHcTBeHuoH p;eHTeJIbUOCTII 9, K COmaJIeHIIIO IIcnOJIbSOBaUuaH
IIOKa TOJIbKO npII auaJIIIse BbICOKopaSBIIToro CeJIbCKOro XOSHHCTBa. Eglluoe
HanpaBJIeHlle XOSHHCTBeUUOH ):(eHTeJIbHOCTII cos):(aeT npegnoCbIJIKII P;JIH npo-
HSBogcTBa cxo):(uoro XOsHHcTBeuHoro IIUBeIITapH. Muorlle JIaHp;ma<pTuble oco-
6eUUOCTII (KJIIIMaT, HaJIII'IlIe CTpOIlTeJIbHbIX MaTepllaJIOB) BMeCTe C xapaRTe-
pOM XOSHHCTBa (OCegJIbIM, IIOJIYKO'IeBbIM, RO'IeBbIM) OIIpe):(eJIHIOT B RaRIIX-TO
npegeJIax KOIICTPYRQIIIO mIIJIIIIIJ; II TIIII OJJ;eJ:I{gbI.
CBHSH Hap;CTpOe'IUbIX HBJIeHHH C reorpa<pII'IeCROH cpegoH II XOsHHcTBeu-
HOH aRTIIBUOCTbID eIIJ;e CJIomuee II pasuo06pasHee, uo II B c<pepe uagcTpoHKII
Momuo saMeTIITb KaKIIe-TO oTpameuIIH reorpa<pII'IeCKIIX YCJIOBIIH mllsull
II HaIIpaBJIeHIIH ):(eHTeJIbHOCTII JIIOp;eH. HaQeJIeuuaH ua mllBOTHbIX MarllH
OXOTUHROB H CKOTOBOJJ,OB, pllTyaJIIIsaQIIH seMJIeAeJIb'IeCROrO KaJIeugapH If
arpapHaH MarHH SeMJIegeJIbQeB HBJIHIOTCH TOMY IIpIIMepoM. B c<pepe HCRYC-
cTBa, KaK 6bI ouo UH 6bIJIO CTHJIIISOBaUO (a <paKTopbI <pOpMHpoBauIIH CTHJIH
XOTH II OCTaIOTCH uegocTaTO'IIIO HSY'IeUUbIMII, UO, IIO-BHgIIMOMY, B CBOIO O'Ie-
pegb, BKJIlO'IaIDT KaRHe-TO Bosp;eHcTBIIH CpeJJ;bI), oTpamaeTcH ua60p mHBOT-
HbIX, COCTaBJIHIOIIJ;IIX npegMeT pasBe):(euIIH IIJIII OXOTbI. B SeMJIegeJIb'IeCKHX
06IIJ;ecTBax HsoopaSIITeJIbHOe IICKYCCTBO 06bI'IHO eIIJ;e 60JIbme CTIIJIH30BaHo,
SUa'IIITeJIbHOe MeCTO B HeM SaUII:lfaeT paCTIITeJIblIbIH opuaMeUT. MUOrO'IIIC-
JIeHHble II y6ep;IITeJIbHbIe IIpllMepbI TOr.ry, KaK Cxop;UbIe Ky.lIbTypUbIe HBJIeUIIiI
06paSYIOTCH Ha OCUOBe KYJIbTYPHbIX KOMIIJIeKCOB paSHoro 8TUII'IeCROrO IIpOHC-
xomp;eHIIH BCJIe):(CTBlIe IIpIICnOc06JIeHIIH K CXOgUbIM YCJIOBIIHM reorpmfJI1'Ie-
CKOH cpep;bI, cocpep;OTO'IeUbI B pauee YIIOMHHYTbIX pa60Tax, IIOcBHIIJ;elI-
HbIX XOsHHCTBeuIIO-KYJIbTYPUOH TIIIIOJIOrIIllo
KaKoH BbIBOg, BamubIH AJIH uallieH TeMbI, BbITeKaeT lIS Bcero TOJIbRO 'ITO
162
...
CKasaHHoro? MUOrOCTOpOUUIIe CBHSII RYJIbTYPbI C reorpa<pJI'IeCROH cpegoH,
He Bcerp;a AocTynuble KOHRpeTHOMY Y'IeTY, oc06eHUO IIO OTUOnIeHJIIO K p;peB-
HllM 8IIoxaM, BBO):(HT BO BpeMeuuyID AIIHaMJIRy 8THorpa<pJI'IeCRIIX HBJIe-
HIIH AOIIOJIHJITeJIbUbIII <paKTOp JISMeUeUIIH II TeM eIIJ;e OOJIbme saTpYiJ,HHIOT
)J;JIaXpOHUoe cpaBHeUJIe JI OQeHKY ero peSYJIbTaTOB: BHYTpeUUJIe TeH)J;eH IIll
paSBJITIIH 3THorpa<pII'IeCKIIX HBJIeUJIH JI BJIJIHHJIe IIa HJIX reorpa<pII'IeCKOH
cpep;bI, onocpegoBaHHoe HarrpaBJIeHJIeM XOSHHCTBeUUOH p;eHTeJIbHOCTJI, CTOJIb
Tecuo nepeIIJIeTeHbI, 'ITO pasrpaUJI'IJITb JIX B KamgOM ROHKpeTHOM CJIY'Iae
npaKTII'IeCKII OKaSbIBaeTCH ueBOSMomUbIM. B caMOM p;eJIe, 8TJI BHYTpeHUJIe
TeugeUQJIII paSBIITIIH MorYT ObITb SaMe'IeHbI TOJIbKO npJI cpaBHeHJIJI pHP;OB
XpOUOJIOrJI'IeCKII paSUOBpeMeHUbIX <paKTOB, a IIpJI TaKOM }J;llaxpOHHOM cpaBHe-
HJIJI HeIIocpegcTBeuuoe BJIJIHHIIe cpep;bI ueBOSMomuo Hll IICKJIIO'IIlTb, HII Y'IeCTb
CKOJIbKO-HllOygb IIOJIHO.
I
CROPOCTb 1l3MEHEHHH 3THOI'PAwHQECKHX HBJIEHHR
B IIpep;llIeCTBYIOIIJ;eM JISJIomeUJIJI MbI P;OBOJIbUO 'IaCTO IIpII6eraJIJI K IIOUHTJIIO
3Tuorpa<pII'IeCKOrO HBJIeUIIH, He p;aBaH eMY TO'IHOH JJ;e<pJIUllIJ;JIII. 8TO ObIJIO
BosMomIIo, IIOTOMY 'ITO OHO llCIIOJIbSOBaJIOCb B KOHTeKCTe, B KOTOpOM IIIJIa
pe'Ib 0 BHeIIIHJIX IIO OTHOIIIeUJIIO K 8THorpa<pII'IeCKH f HBJIeUIIHM npoQeccax,
BblpamaIOIIJ;IIXCH B JIX XpOUOJIorlI'IeCKOH p;II<p<pepeHQlIaQIIII II BO BJIJIHHllll Ha
HJIX reorpa<pII'IeCKOH cpegbI. Tenepb, Korp;a MbI IIogomJIJI K IIpOOJIeMe CKO-
pOCTJI IISMeUeUJIH 8Tuorpa<pJI'IeCKJIX HBJIeHllH, T. e. K OP;HOMY IIS aCIIeKTOB
IIX BUYTpeUHeH p;JIHaMIIKJI, HeOOXOAJIMO p;aTb TO'IHOe onpep;e elIlle 8TOMY
nOHHTIIIO.
BOIIpOC 00 8Tuorpa<pII'IeCROM HBJIeUIIJI CBOgIITCH K TOMY, 'ITO B 'IeJIOBe-
-q:eCKOH KYJIbType MomHO C'IIITaTb 8THorpa<pJI'IeCKOH CIIeQJI<pJIROH. HecMoTpH
na SHa'IJITeJIbHbIe paSJIJI'IJIH B IIop;xop;e K IIpep;MeTY II rpaHIIIJ;aM 8THorpa<pIIll
ua npOTHmeUIIII BceH ee IICTOpIIII II B paSHbIX 8THorpa<pII'IeCRIIX mKOJIaX,
P;O HCHOCTII eIIJ;e gaJIeKO, II CIIOpbI 0 npegMeTe 3THorpacplllI, ee OCUOBUbIX
IIpOOJIeMaX II nOrpaUll'IUbIX C P;PyrIIMJI P;IICQIIIIJIllHaMII oo aCTHX Bep;YTCH P;O
CllX IIOp JI p;ame cpegII IIpe):(CTaBIITeJIeH O):(IIOH IIIKOJIbI, HaIIpJIMep COBeTCKOH
8TIIorpa<pJI'IeCKOH 50. OIIpep;eJIeHJIe 8Tuorpa<pIIll RaK uaYRJI 0 HapogHoH
RYJIbType B paSHbIX <POPMYJIIIpOBKax, nOmaJIYH, HaIIOOJIee 'IaCTO <PnrypJIPyeT
B COOTBeTCTBYIOIIJ;eH JIIITepaType, HO II TaKaH TpaRTOBRa He JIC'IeprrbIBaeT
CYIIJ;eCTBa p;e a, TaK KaK B IIOHHTlle HapoguoH KY bTYPbI BXOgHT MHorlle HB-
.JIeUJIH, HaIIpIIMep <pOJIbKJIOp, IISY'laeMbIH cneQJIaJIbHOH HaYKOH, TeCHO CBH-
saHHOH He TOJIbKO C 8Tuorpa<pIIeH, HO II C JIIIUrBJICTIIKOH, <pJI OJIOrlIeH II II-
epaTYPOBegeUJIeM.
ABTOpy KameTCH nepCIIeKTJIBHbIM TaKoH no):(xop; K 8TUJI'IeCKOH cIIeQII<pll-
Re, npII KOTOpOM MbI B IIepBYID O'IepeJJ;b oOpaIIJ;aeM BHllMaHlle Ha <paKTbI
He CXOACTBa, a paSJIJI'IllH Memp;y uapop;aMII. ]:(OCTaTO'IHO TplIBlIaJIbHOe
YTBepmgeulIe, 'ITO 8TUII'IeCKaH CIIeIJ;II<pIIKa BblpamaeTCH B TOM ROMIIJIeKCe
KYJIbTypHbIX II IICIIXOJIOrJI'IeCKIIX ocooeUUOCTeH, ROTOpbIMJI p;aUHbIH uapop;
OTJIll'IaeTCH OT P;PyrJIX, eCTb, ua MOH Bsr Hg, onpaBgaHuoe TeOpeTII'IeCRJI II
ygooHoe npaKTJI'IeCRII pemeHIIe npOOJIeMbI 8THII'IeCKOH cneQII<pIIKJI. 8THO-
rpa<pIIIO MbI oIIpegeJIHeM KaK HaYKY 0 KY bTypUbIX II OT'IaCTll nCJIXOJIOrll-
'IeCKllX paSJIll'IIIHX Memp;y uapOAaMJI. 8TIIM IIOp;'IepKJIBaeTCH, 'ITO 8THII'IeCKaH
IICllXOJIOrllH HapHgy C 3Tuorpa<pJIeH, 8TUII'IeCKOH aUTpono orIIeH, JISY'leHlleM
Hapop;Horo IICKyCCTBa, oopaSYH IIepexop;HYID C<pepy OT 3THorpa<pJIII K P;PY-
rHM HaYKaM, BXOP;JIT B TO me BpeMH B 8THorpa<pJIIO XOTH ObI CBoeH cym;ecT-
HeUUOH 'IaCTbIO, a llMeUHO KOHKpeTHbIMII peSYJIbTaTaMJI 8THOrrCJIXOJIOrJI'IeCRO-
TO IlSV'IeHllH 51. 8Tuorp a <p II 'IeCKOe HBJIeHlIe C 8TOH TO'IKII SpeHJIH eCTb JIIOOaH
I'
i!
I
I
163
6*
I
ftYJIbTypHaJI 'IepTa, a TaKme JII06aJI oc06eHHOCTb B cq,epe KOJIJIeKTIIRHOH IICII
XIIRII (Tpa}J;IIIJ;IIOIlIlble IICIIXOJIOrII'IeCKIIe CTepeOTIInbI, 8TUII'IeCKOe CIlMOCOSHa-
HIIe, cOBoKynuocTb nCIIXII'IeCKIIX nepemIITKOB), KOTOp:ble CneIJ;II<pII'IUbI P;JI1t
Toro IIJIII IIIIoro Hapop;a II KOTOpbIX HeT B iWHIIOH <popMe II B p;aHHbIX CO'Ie-
TaHIIHX Y P;PyrlIx Hapop;OB. ThaR, KYJIbTypIloe II TeCHO CBHsaHHoe G HIIM nCII-
XII'IeCKOe cBoe06paSIIe COCTaBJIHeT OCUOBY TOH OIJ;eHKII 3Tuorpa<pIIII II npep;-
MeTa ee IISY'IeHIIH, BblpamaIOIIJ;erOCJI B 8JIeMeUTapHbIX 3Tuorpa<pIIQeCKIIX
HBJIeIlIIHX II IIX aCCOIJ;IIaIJ;IIHX, KOTopaH SaIIJ;IIIIJ;aeTCH Ha 3TIIX CTpaIIIIIJ;ax.
BbIHBJIHeTCH 3TO cBoe06paSIIe, eCTeCTBeuuo, TOJIbRO 'Iepes CIIUxpOHHoe cpaB-
HeHHe npII Bcex ero OrpaIIH'IeHIUIX, 0 KOTOpbIX rOBOpIIJIOCb BblIIIe.
BOSBpaIIJ;aHCb K np06JIeMe. C<POPMYJIIIpOBaHHOH B SarJIaBHII 3Toro pasp;eJIa,
MbI KaK BbIBOP; lIS Bcero TOJIbKO 'ITO CRasaUIIoro p;OJImHbI npIIHHTb, 'ITO CKO-
pOCTb IISMeIleUHH 3TIlOrpa<pII'IeCKIIX HBJIeHIIH - 3TO CKOpOCTb HapaCTaHIIH
IIJUI, HaooopOT, OCJIa6JIeUHH cBoe06paSIIH KYJIbTypbI II nCIIXIIKH Toro IImI
IIuoro Hapop;a no cpaBHeUIIIO C KaKIIMII-TO p;pyrIIMII, CKameM cocep;IIIIMII,
Hapop;aMII. 3apauee HCUO, 'ITO B 8noxy KOHCOJIIIp;aIJ;IIH CKOpOCTb uapaCTaUIIH
cBoe06paSIIH orpOMHa, B 3noxy saBoeBaIIIIH, eCJIII OUII conpOBomJJ;aIOTCH pas-
PYIIIeHHeM UaIJ;HOIlaJIbHOH KYJIbTypbI saBoeBaHUbIX uapop;OB, Ha060pOT, BeJUI-
Ka CKOpOCTb OCJIa6JIeHIIH 3THII'IeCKOH CneIJ;II<pIIKH. MemJJ;Y 8TIIMII P;BYMH
KpaHUIIMII nOJIIOCaMII pacnOJIaraeTCH nepexop; OT 6bICTpbIX JJ;0 Mep;JIeUUbIX
IISMeHeHIIH 3Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX HBJIeHIIH. BbICTpbIe IISMeueUIIH 06HsaHbI CBOIIM
IIpOIIcxomp;eHlIeM, O'ieBIIp;HO, 3noxaM uaIJ;IIOIlaJIbHOrO caMOYTBepmp;eHIIH If
CTpeMIITeJIbUOrO 3KOUOMII'IeCKOrO nOp;'beMa; YCTOH'IIIBOCTb HaIJ;HOUaJIbHOrO
COSHaHIIH nop;p;epmIIBaeTCH KOH<pJIHKTHbIMII OTUOIIIeUIIHMH C cocep;HMII. KaR
BIIP;IIM, <paKTOpbI, BJIIIHIOIIJ;IIe Ha CKOpOCTb IISMeHeHIIH, Muoro06paSII:bI II C
TPYP;OM IIop;p;aIOTCH Y'IeTY.
ECJIII KouKpeTHO paCCMaTplIBaTb np06JIeMY CKOpOCTII IISMeueUIIH, TO nplI-
p;eTCH npIIsuaTb, qTO B paSUbIX 06JIaCTHX KYJIbTypbI CKOpOCTb 8Ta saBIICIIT
OT paSUbIX npII'IIIU. XOTH 3TO II ue 6bIJIO C<POPMYJIlIpOBaUO B 06IIJ;e1I <popMe,
HO 3Tuorpaq,bI 3MnlIpII'IeCKII npIIIIIJIII K BOSMomHOCTII KJIaCCII<pIIIJ;IIpOBaTh
06JIaCTII KYJIbTypbI no CTeIIeUII YCTOH'IIIBOCTII, OTCIOp;a II IIX yp;eJIbUbIH Bec
B IICCJIep;OBaUIIHX, nOCBHIIJ;eUHbIX peKOUCTpYKIJ;IIII OOIIJ;UOCTII npOIIcxomp;eHIIH
II 06IIJ;IIX 3TanOB 3TUIIqeCKOH IICTOpIIII. HanpaBJIeulIe XOsHHcTBeHIIOH p;eH-
TeJIbHOCTII, HanpIIMep. cnpaBep;JIIIBO C'IIITaeTCH CIIJIbUO SaBIICHIIJ;IIM OT cpeJJ;:bI
II npIIpop;ubIX pecypcoB; CBHsaHHbIe C XOSHHCTBOM aTpII6YTbI MaTepHaJIbUOH
KYJIbTypbI - KOJIeCH:bIH IIJIII rymeBoH TpaucnopT, q,OpMbI CeJIbCKOXOsHHCTBeH-
HbIX OpYP;IIH, OCHOBHOH TIIn mIIJUIIIJ;a, MaTepIIaJIbI, lIS KOTOpbIX IIIbeTCH
op;em;rra, II 'IaCTO p;ame ee nOKpoH - TaKme npep;CTaBJIHIOT C060H BO MIIorOM
HeIIocpep;cTBeuHYID peaRQIIIO ua reorpa<pII'IeCKYID cpep;y, ee p;OJIrOTUO-IIIIIPOT-
HbIe, KJIIIMaTII'IeCKIIe II JIaUp;IIIa<pTHbIe xapaKTeplICTIIKII 52. OTCIOJJ;a BeCbMa
BepOHTuaH BOSMomHoeTb KOHBepreUTuoro BOSUIIKUOBeUIIH 3Tuorpa<pII'IeCI{IIX
HBJIeUIIH, OTUOCHIIJ;IIXCH K 3TIIM C<pepaM KYJIbTYPbI. B COBeTCKOH 3THorp a <p II -
"IeCKOH JIIITepaType B npOTIIBOBec Teup;eUQIIII, OT'IeTJIIIBO BblpameUUOH B aMe-
pIIKaHCKOH 3THorpa<pIIII, Bcerp;a CKenTII'IeCKII OIJ;eUIIBaJIaCb BOSMomUOCTb
reUeTII'IeCKOrO C6JIlIiI eUIIH Hapop;OB ua OCUOBaHIIII cxop;Horo 06IIJ;eCTBeUHoro
YCTpOHCTBa II IIoxomIIX COQIIaJIbHbIX IIUCTHTYTOB, ROUBepreHTHoe npOIIcxom-
p;eHlIe KOTOpbIX TaKme CqIITaJIOCb B BbICOKOH CTeneUII BepOHTHbIM 53. IIO-BII-
;r:t;IIMOMy, 60JIee SUa'IIIMbI P;JIH reUeTII'IeCKOrO auaJUI3a <PYHKIJ;IIOUaJIbUO 6es-
paSJIII'IHbIe p;eTaJIII KOUCTPYKIJ;IIII mIIJIHIIJ;a II nOKpoH oJJ;emp;bI, a TaKme
II P;PyrIIx HBJIeHIIH MaTeplIaJIbUOH KYJIbTypbI, 3JIeMeHTbI opuaMeHTa II opna-
MeHTaJIbUbIe KOMnosIIIJ;IIII, 60raTbIe no Ha60py BXOP;HIIJ;IIX B HIIX KOMnOHeu-
TOB, BeCbMa pasHo06pasubIe meUCKIIe YKpaIIIeHIIH, 06paSIJ;bI uapoJJ;Horo IIC-
KyccTBa, lIS pIITyaJIbUOH cq,epbI - BosMomuo, HanpIIMep, KaKIIe-TO p;eTaJIIf
164
norpeOaJIbUOrO 06pHp;a. KOJIb CKOpO B HIIX npOHBJIHeTCH B nepBYIO O'Iepep;b
cBoe06paSIIe KYJIbTypbI Hapop;a, MbI II p;OJImn:bI OIJ;eUIITb CKOpOCTb IIX IISMe-
HeUIIH. IICIIXOJIOrII'IeCKIIe oc06eUHOCTII, BXOp;HIIJ;IIe B C<pepy :3Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX
HBJIeUIIH (HanplIMep, 8THII'IeCKOe caMOCOSHaHlIe), q,IIKCIIpYIOTCfl C TpYP;OM lJ
IICTOpII'IeCKOH nepcneKTIIBe, IISMeHeHIIH B 3THII'IeCKOM caMOC03uaHIIII p;aJIeKO
He Bcerp;a YJIaBJIIIBaIOTCH ):(ame C nOMOIIJ;bIO aUaJIIISa IICTOpII'IeCKIIX IICTO'IUII-
KOB 5\ II08TOMY H nOJIY'IIITb CKOJIbKO-UII6YP;b 06'beKTIIBUYID IIH<popMaIJ;IIIO 0
CKOpOCTII 3TIIX IISMeHeHIIH npaKTII'IeCKII ueBOSMomHO.
OTp;eJIbUble p;eTaJIII opHaMeHTa coxpaHHIOTCH, O'IeBIIP;U0, Ha npOTHmeIIIIII
TbICH'IeJIeTIIH, SHaMeHYH npeeMCTBeUHOCTb B paSBIITIIII KYJIbTypbI, - Kpacuo-
pe'IIIBbIH npIIMep TaKOH npeeMCTBeUUOCTII B 06JIaCTII BOCTO'IUOCJIaBHUCKOH
KYJIbTypbI p;aeT HaM CTapoe IICCJIep;OBaUIIe B. A. fOpOp;IJ;OBa 0 Capl\IaTCKOM
IIpoIIcxomp;eHIIII ueKOTOp:bIX MOTIIBOB PYCCKoro Hapop;uoro opuaMeHTaJIbUOrO
IICKYCCTBa 55. Ho pe'Ib IIp;eT IIMeHUO 0 MOTIIBax, B 60JIee CJIOmHbIX CJIY'IaHX
cpaBHeHIIH KOMnOSIIIJ;IIH npeeMCTBeUUOCTb ropasp;o Meuee O<IeBIIp;Ua, II p;ame
IIPH COIIOCTaBJIeUUII XpOUOJIOrII'IeCKII OTHOCUTeJIbUO 6JIII3RIIX pHP;OB HBJIeUIIH,
HanpIIMep cpegueBeKoBbIX BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX II PYCCRIIX HapogubIx opua-
MeHTOB, BbIHBJIHeTCH MHoro pasJIII'IIIiI. 8TO cnpaBe;rrmmo II P;JIH MHorlIX P;PY-
rIIX flBJIeHIIH Hapop;HOH KYJIbTypbI p;ame ua PYCCKOM CeBepe, rp;e OUII CO-
XpaUHJIIICb AO uep;aBHero BpeMeUII B MaJIO nOTpeBomeHUOM BIlge 56. IIpii
60JIbIIIOM 'IIICJIe Tpap;IIIJ;IIOHUbIX 8JIeMeUTOB B PYCCROM uapop;HOM mIImIIIJ;e II
PYCCKOH Hapop;UOH op;emge B QeJIOM ua6JIIOp;aIOTCH SaMeTU:bIe XpOUOJIOrII'Ie-
CKIIe paSJIII'IIIH p;ame Ha'IHUaH C XIII-XVI BB. 57 , He rOBopH yme 0 60JIee
pauHeH 3noxe 58. 8TII pa60TbI cop;epmaT 60raTbIH sanac cBegeuIIH II 06 IIS-
MeueHIIHX B p;pyrIIX 06JIaCTHX MaTepIIaJIbHOH KYJIbTypbI OT CTOJIeTIIH K CTO-
JI eTIIIO.
IIpaBJJ;a, B XIII B. PYCCI{3H KYJIbTypa IICII:bITaJIa meCTO'IaHIIIee nOTpHceuIIe
MOUrOJIO-TaTapcKoro uaIIIeCTBIIH II saTeM MOUrOJIO-TaTapcKoro ura; B Ha'IaJIe
XVIII B. 60JIbIIIYIO pOJIb CblrpaJIII IIeTpoBcKIIe peq,opMbI. TeM He MeHee Bce
OTMe'IeHUbIe BbJIIIe IISMeHeUIIH IIMeJIII MeCTO B paMKax ep;IIHOH KYJIbTYpHOH
CIICTeMbI II ue npIIBeJIII K ee paspYIIIeUIIIO. OUII IIap;aIOT Ha IIepIIOp; PYCCKOH
IICTOpIIII, no OTHOIIIeUIIIO K KOTOpOMy p;OKasauo HaJIII'IIIe 06IIJ;epyccKoro caMO-
cosuaHIIH II Bo06IIJ;e CJIOmeHIIe BCJIep; sa p;peBHepycCIwH BeJIIIKopYCCKOH Ha-
POP;UOCTII 59. TaKIIM 06pasoM, npIIMepbI cBIIp;eTeJIbCTBYIOT, 'ITO BHYTpeHHlIe
TeHp;euIJ;IIII pasBIITIIH 3Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX HBJIeUIIH peaJIlIsyIOTCH p;OCTaTO'IHO
6bICTpO II ua npoTHmeulIII UeCROJIbKIIX BeKOB MorYT IIMeTb SUa'IIITeJIbUbIe
IISMeueHIIH. CJIORUlbIe no cBoeH cTpyKType 3Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIe HBJIeUIIH, no-
BII;rIIIMOMY, pep;Ko coxpaHHIOTcH IJ;eJIIIKOM, B IIOJIUOCTbID HeIISMeueUUOM BIIp;e,
p;ame ua IIpoTHmeuIIII HeCKOJIbKIIX CTOJIeTIIH.
IITaK, nO;rraBJIHIOIIJ;eMY OOJIbIIIIIHCTBY 3Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX HBJIeUIIH CBOHCT-
BeHHbI Teup;eHQIIII K OTHOCIITeJIbUO 6bICTpbIM IISMeHeHIIHM p;ame B Tex CJIY-
'IaHX, Korp;a pe'Ib IIp;eT 0 BUYTpeHHeM paSBIITIIII, a ue 0 peSKIIx BHeIIIHIIX
Bosp;eHCTBIIHX - BOHuax, saBoeBaHIIHX II T. p;. B pflJJ;e cJIy'IaeB Momuo onpe-
p;eJIIITb UanpaBJIeUIIe 3TIIX TeHp;eUIJ;IIH nplI cpaBHeuHII Ha'IaJIbUOrO II nosp;-
HeiImero KOMnoueUTOB XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKOrO pHga, uo CKOpOCTb caMIIX IISMeue-
HHH IIPII OTCYTCTBIIII MHorlIX IIpoMemYTO'IHbIX SBeUbeB He YCTanaBJIIIBaeTCH
TO'IHO, TaK KaK, nO-BIIp;IIMOMY, 3Ta CKOpOCTb uepaBHOMepua. BesYCJIOBUO, OHa
paSJIII'IUa Y paSU:bIX 3Tuorpaq,II'IeCKIIX HBJIeUIIH. Bce 3TO, nOMlIMO yme pac-
CMOTpeUUbIX 06CTOHTeJIbCTB, BHOCIIT eIIJ;e op;uY P;OIIOJIHIITeJIbuyID TPYP;HOCTb
B p;IIaxpOHHoe cpaBueuIIe.
I
165
l
o llEPEXO]J;E OT CHHXPOHHOrO CP ABHEHHH
K ]J;HAXPOHHOMY
IIepexop; OT CIIHXpOHHOrO CpaBHeHIIH K p;IIaXpODHOMY B 3TDOrpaq,IIII - 3TO,
CTpOrO rOBOpH, nepexop; OT reOrpa<pIIII TeX 3JIeMeDTOB KYJIbTypbI, KOTOpbIe IISY-
aIOTCH 3TUOrpaq,lIeH, K IIX IICTOpIIH. )J,HaXpODDOe CpaBHeDIIe, KaK MbI y6eJJ;lI-
JIIICb RbIllIe, IIMeeT MHOrO'IIICJIeDDbIe OrpaHII'IeHIIH, npOIICTeKaIOIIJ;IIe De TOJIbKO
OT CJIY'IaHDbIX MOMeHTOB, HanplIMep OT HenOJIDOTbI p;aDHbIX, HO II OT npIIHQII-
IIIIaJIbHbIX IIplI'IHH: lIe P;O KOHQa Y'IIITbIBaeMoro B Kamp;OM KODKpeTDOM CJIY-
'Iae BJIIIHHIIH cpep;bI, Heop;IIHaKOBOH CKOpOCTH IISMeDeuIIH B KOHKpeTDOH CII-
TyaIJ;IIII, 06paTHbIX BJIIIHDIIiI DagcTpOe'IDbIX HBJIeHIIH Ha TeMnbI paSBIITIIH
MaTepIIaJIbDOH KYJIbTypbI II XOSHHCTBa. B CBHSII C 3TIIM npOHIIKHOBeHIIe B
npOIIIJIOe, B IICTOpII'IecKyID p;IIDaMIIRY, C nOMOIIJ;bIO MaTeplIaJIOB COBpeMeDDOH
CTaTIICTIIKII IIpep;CTaBJIHeT C060H 'IaCTO eCJIII De eAHHCTBeHHbIH, TO OCDOBHOH
nYTb peKOHCTpYKQHII HCTOplIlI OTp;eJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB KYJIbTypbI.
CJIep;yeT cpasy me IIOp;'IepKDYTb, 'ITO paSpeIIIalOIIJ;lIe BOSMomHOCTII 3THO-
rpa<pIIII Ha 3TOM nyTII OTDOCIITeJIbDO CKpOMHbI. IIO-BIIP;IIMOMY, ODII peaJIJI-
SYIOTCH IIplI nepexop;e OT CIIHxpOHHoro aHamma K p;IIaxpODDOMY, TOJIbKO eCJIII
pe'Ib IIgeT 0 HBJIeDIIHX, JIemaIIJ;IIX B paMKax ep;IIDOH KYJIbTypHOH CIICTeMbI.
IIplI BbIxop;e sa npep;eJIbI 8TOH CIICTeMbI, B Ka'IeCTBe KaKOBOH MomeT paCCMaT-
plIBaTbCfl KYJIbTYpa op;Doro Hapop;a (B03MomHo, B oTgeJIbDbIX CJIY'IaHX II
rpynnbI 6JIIISKOpOp;cTBeHHblx Hapop;oB), JII060H nepexop; OT CIIDxpoDDoro cpe-
sa K p;lIaXpODDoMY conOCTaBJIeHIIIO, K peRoHcTpYKQIIII p;IIDaMIIKII no CTaTIIKe
OKaSbIBaeTCH 'IpeSBbI'IaHDO CJIOmDbIM, TaK KaK npIIMeIIIIIBaeTcH Macca p;onoJI-
HIITeJIbDbIX - <paKToPOB, p;eHcTBIIe KOTOpbIX DeJIbSH DII npeJJ;BocxIITIITb sapaDee,
HII Y'IeCTb CKOJIbKO-DII6ygb 06'beKTIIBHo. II03ToMY aBTopy, XOTH OH II oTp;aeT
ce6e OT'IeT B SDa eHIIII naDolmYMeHDoro KapTorpa<plIpoBaHIIfl oT):(eJIbHbIX
KYJIbTypHbIX :meMeHTOB P;JIH IICCJIen;OBaHIIH II nOHIIMaDIIH <pOpM KYJIbTypDOH
IIDTerpaIJ;IIII, IIpep;CTaBJIHeTCH 6ecnepcIIeKTIIBHbIM IIpII6eraTb K 3TOH oIIepaIJ;IIJiI
B QeJIHX p;IIaxpoDHoH peKoDcTpYKQIIII. II xapaKTep pacnpocTpaHeHIIH, II ne-
JIII'IIIHa apeaJIa, II TIInbI rpaHIIIJ; MorYT 6bITb npII OTCYTCTBIIII cIIeQHaJIbHOH
)J;onOJIDIITeJIbHOH lIH<popMaQIIII op;IIHaKoBo ycneIIIDo IICTOJIKOBaHbI II KaK Ha-
CJIegIIe KaKIIX-TO p;peBDIIx 3TaiiOB KYJIbTypDOH p;1I<p<pepeDQlIaQIIII II IIHTerpa-
D;IIII, II KaR CJIep;CTBIIe nosp;Hero paCCeJIelIIIH KaKoro-DII6YP;b Hapop;a IIJIII
rpynnbI HapogoB.
B TO me BpeMH B npep;eJIax OP;DOH KYJIbTYPHOH CIICTeMbI TaKOH IIepexop;
BOSMOlRerr II De nopmrmaeT KaKOII-JIII60 cy6'beKTIIBHOCTII. 3aKODOMepDoe yCII-
JIeDIIe IIJIII OCJIa6JIeDIIe B BbIpameDIIII TOH IIJIII IIUOH KYJIbTypHOH oc06eD-
HOCTII MomeT 6bITb IICnOJIbSOBaDO KaK yKasaDIIe Ha xapaKTep II HanpaBJIe-
DIIe paCCeJIeDIIH, IIpepbIBIICTbIH apeaJI C peSKIIMII rpaHIIn;aMII Memp;y OTp;eJIb-
HbIMII napIIaUTaMII KYJIbTypDbIX 8JIeMeDTOB - KaK aprYMeHT B nOJIbSY
p;eHCTBIIH QelITp06emDbIX TeDp;eIIIJ;IIH II IISOJIHIJ;IIII, OOJIbIIIIIe JIOKaJIbDble Ba-
pIIaHTbI BUYTPII 60JIee 06IIIIIpDOH SOUbI - KaR p;eMODCTpaQIIH 06paSOBaDIIH
JIORaJIbDbIX 3Tuorpa<pII'IeCKIIX rpynn nDYTpII ogDoro Dapop;a. Ho IJ;eJIOCTDaH
KYJIbTypDaH CIICTeMa OCTaeTCH He06xo;lJ;IIMbIM q,ODOM II OCHOBOH BCHKOH p;IIa-
XpOHDOII peKOHCTpYKIJ;IIII, OnIIpaIOIIJ;eHCH Ha CIIHXPODHYIO reorpaq,lIIO. CyIIJ;e-
CTBOBaHIIe TaKIIX IJ;eJIOCTHbIX KYJIbTypHbIX CIICTeM He npOCTIIpaeTCH, KaK
IIpaBIIJIO, 60JIbIIIe eM Da OP;DO-IIOJITOpa TbICH'IeJIeTIIH. TOJIbKO B 3TIIX XPO-
HOJIOrII'IeCKIIX npep;eJIax II MomDO rOBoplITb 0 nepexop;e OT CIIDxpODDoro
cpaBDeDIIH K gIIaxpODDOMY. OTJJ;eJIbDble CJIy'IaII paDDIIX 3THoreDeSOB (KIITaH-
IJ;bI, HeKOTOpbIe Dapop;bI KaBKasa, A<praHIIcTaDa, IOmDoH IIDP;IIII II p;p.)
He MeDHIOT JJ;eJIa IIO cyIIJ;eCTBY. ECJIII MbI BbIXOP;IIM sa 3TlI XpODOJIOrH'IeCKIIe
npep;eJIbI, peKODCTpYKIJ;IIH BOSDIIRHOBeHIIH II p;IIDaMIIKII 3TDorpa<pII'IeCKIIX
I
J
r
I'
166
HBJIeUlIH BOSMOmHa TOJIbKO C nOMOIIJ;bIO 3KCTpa3THOrpa<plI'IeCKIIX p;aHUbIX-
apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKHX, JIIIUrBIICTII'IeCKIIX, aHaJIII3a IIIICbMeHHbIX IICTO'IHlIKOB
II T. p;.
Bce CKaSaHUOe HOCIIT, KaK BCHKaH TeOpeTII'IeCKaH <POPMYJIIlpOBKa, Bce me
06IIJ;lIH xapaKTep II Tpe6yeT p;aJIbHeHIIIeH paspa60TKII gJIH Toro, 'IT06bI 6bITb
IIplIJIOmeUHbIM K lICCJIep;OBaUIIIO KOHKpeTUbIX BonpOCOB, saTpOHYTbIX B pa60-
Te, T. e. K nOJIY'IeUIIIO 06'beKTIIBUbIX BbIBOP;OB 0 p;IIuaMlIKe 8Tuorp a <p lI 'IeCKlIX
HBJIeUHH, lICXOp:H lIS Ua6JIIOJJ;eHlIH Hap; IIX CTaTlIKOH, Hap; IIX CTPyKTypHbIMII
OTHOIIIeHIIHMII II reorpa<pII'IeCKIIM pacnpep;eJIeHIIeM B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH.
B 'IaCTHOCTII, SaCJIYlIHIBaeT BHIIMaUIIH paCCMOTpeHIIe cBoe06paSIIH I1SJIOmeH-
HOH TO'IKII speHIIH no cpaBueHIIIO C MeTop;OM (<KOHTpomIpyeMblx cpaBHeUrrH»
npep;JIOmeUUbIM Q;). 8rraHoM 60. Momuo OTMeTIITb, 'ITO IIgeH CIICTeMUOCTII B
CBHSII C ypOBueM HaYKII ero BpeMeUII 6bIJIa 'Iymp;a MbIIIIJIeUIIIO Q;). 8rraua,
paCCMaTpIIBaBIIIero np06JIeMY rpaUlIIJ; nplIMeueHIIH cpaBHIITeJIbIIorO :\IeTOp;a
B KaTeropIIHX CTap;I1aJIblIOrO nop;xoga II nop;pasyMeBaBIIIero nop; 3TlIM cpaB-
HeHlIe B npep;eJIax 06IIJ;eCTB, uaXOp;HIIJ;lIXCH Ha op;IIHaKOBOM KYJIbTYpUO-
XOSHHCTBeUUOM ypOBue paSBlITIIH.
"
I
i
I
o rPAHlUJ;AX AHAXPOHHoro CPABHEHHH
B WJIbRJIOPHCTHRE
KaKoBbI BOSMomHOCTII II rpaUlIQbI rrpIIMeueuIIH Bcero CKasauuoro 0 paSJIII-
'IIIH CIIUXpOHIIII II p;IIaxpOHIIII B 3THorpa<plIII K IISY'IeUIIIO <pOJIbKJIOpa? ABTop
COSUaTeJIbHO OrpaHII'IIIBaJI ce6H ua npe}J;IIIecTBYIOIIJ;HX CTpaHIIIJ;aX IIpeIIMYIIJ;e-
CTBeUHO paccMoTpeHIIeM HBJIeUIIH MaTepHaJILHOH KYJIbTypbI, TaK KaK gYXOB-
HaH cpep;a miiSHII JII060ro 06IIJ;eCTBa 'IpeSB:bI'IaIIHO CJIomua, <PYIIp;aMeUTaJIb-
HbIX IICCJIep;OBaUIIH COQlIaJIbUO-nCIIXOJIOrII'IeCKOrO HanpaBJIeUIIH B 8TOH 06JIa-
CTII rrOKa MaJIO IT O'ieUb MHorIIe aCIIeKTbI OCTaIOTCH ueHCHbIMII. CKJIOUeU,
op;uaKO, P;YMaTb, 'ITO 8THlI'IeCKOe B c<pepe caMocosuaHIIH II Bo06IIJ;e B P:yXOB-
HOH mlISUII JII060ro Hapop;a TaKme HOCIIT CIICTeMUbIH xapaKTep, KaK II gpy-
rHe HBJIeUIIH KYJIbTYPbI Hapoga IIJIII 3TUII'IeCKOH KYJIbTypbI 6 \ II ua Hero
MomeT 6bITb pacnpOCTpaHeuo Bce CKasaUHoe BbIIIIe. TaKIIM 06pasoM, MomHO
IIpegnOJIaraTb 'ITO, H <pOJIbKJIOp, KOJIb CKOpO B ueM npOHBJIHIOTCH 3THIIQeCKaH
cneIJ;II<plIKa II 3THII'IeCKIIe Tpap;IIQIIII 62, BXOP;IIT B CIICTeMY 3Tuoca.
Op;HaKO IIp06JIeMa CJIOmHee, 'IeM oua KameTCH Ha nepBbIH BSrJIHp;.
CIICTeMUbIH xapaRTep <pOJIbKJIOpa KaK 06IIJ;eCTBeUHoro HBJIeUIIH p;OKaSbIBaeTCH
MuorIIMII TeOpeTII'IeCKIIMII II <paKTII'IeCRlIMII paspa60TKaMII 63, HO CIICTeMa
<pOJIbKJIOpa He BXOP;IIT B CIICTeMY 3THoca B Ka'IeCTBe COnOp;'IIIIIeIIUOro CTPyK-
TypHoro KOMnOHeHTa. CKopee CJIep;yeT rOBoplITb 0 nepeCe'IeHIIII HesaBlICIIMbIX
CIICTeM B KaKOH-TO nOrpaHII'IUOH 06JIaCTII, KOTopaH OXBaTbIBaeT MeCTO <p OJIbK -
JIopa B KYJIbType uapop;a II C<pepy 8TUII'IeCKIIX HBJIeUIIH B <pOJIbKJIOpeo II03To-
MY TPYP;UO paSp;eJIIITb BSrJIHp; Ha <pOJIbKJIOpIICTIIKY KaK ua OTBeTBJIeUIIe 3THO-
rpa<pIIII, C TeMII IIJIII IIUbIMII orOBopKaMII p;OCTaTO'IUO IIIlIpOKO npep:CTaBJIeHHbIH
B COBpeMeUUOH JIIITepaType. CIIpaBep;JIIIBO OTMe'IaJIOCb, 'ITO KYJIbTypuo-6bITO-
BaH TpaKTOBKa paSJIII'IUbIX q,OJIbKJIOpUbIX maIIpOB eIIJ;e ue IIOSBO:IHeT no.:I-
HOCTbID BKJIIO'IaTb <pOJIbKJIOp B cq,epy 3Tuorpa<pIIII 6 . Bonpoc 0 cneQII<pIIKe
II caMOCTOHTeJIbHOCTII <pOJIbKJIOpa KaR 06IIJ;eCTBeUuoro HBJIeUIIH HapHp:y C
Hs06paSIITeJIbUbIM TBOp'IeCTBOM, xyp;omecTBeHUOH JIIITepaTYPOH IT T. ):(. 6bIJI
paCCMOTpeu B. E. ryceBbIM, IIpII'IeM ero p;OKaSaTeJIbCTBa onIIpaIOTCH B nep-
BYIO O'iepep;b Ha auaJIIIS 3CTeTII'IeCKOrO ua'IaJIa B <pOJIbKJIOpe 65. <DOJIbKJIOp,
KaK II HSbIK, II MaTepIIaJIbHaH KYJIbTypa, IISY'IaeTCH caMOCTOHTeJIbUbIMII
HaYKaMII. IIepeCe'IeUIIH He JIIIIIIaIDT 3TII p;HCIJ;IInJIIIUbI IIX CneIJ;II<pIIKII-
f67
IT03TOMY JI He peIIIaIOCb IIOKa B CBEne CKaSaHHOI'O 3KCTpanOJIHpOBaTb
paSBIITble RblIIIe co06pameDIIH 06 OrpaDII'IeHDOCTII p;IIaxpOUDoro cpaBHeDIIH
Ha BpeMeDH:bIe pHP;bI <pOJIbKJIOPUbIX <paKToB. <DOJIbKJIOp npep;CTaBJIHeT C060H,
IIO HaIIIeMY MDeHIIIO, oC06yIO CIICTeMY orpoMHoro 06'beMa, Ha'IaBmyID <PYHK-
IJ;IIODIIpoBaTb Ha sape IICTOpIIII, TaR KaK B HeM MorYT 6bITb BCRpbITbI nJIaCTbI
rJIy60KoH p;peBHOCTII, 'ITO II 6bIJIO HeOAHOKpaTDO npogeMoDcTpIIpOBaHO KOH-
KpeTDbIMII IICCJIep;OBaDIIHMII.
8TIIM 06YCJIOBJIeUa He06xop;HMOCTb, Y'IIITbIBaH cBoe06pasIIe q,OJIbKJIOpa,
BbIpa60TaTb cneQII<pH'IeCKYID MeTop;HKY ero IISY'IeDIIH. Op;DaKO 3<p<peKTIIB-
HOCTb p;IIaxpOHDoro nop;xop;a K <pOJIbKJIOpy, TaK me KaK II K 3TDoreorpa<pHII,
TeM He MeDee 6YAeT saBIIceTb OT Toro, HaCKOJIbKO IICCJIep;OBaDlIe OrpaHII'IIITCH
raMRaMII CIICTeMHbIX CTPYKTYP (Dapop; IIJIII rpYIIIIa HapOJJ;OB, CBHsaHIIbIX
K TOMy me IICTOplI'IeCKIIM IIpOIIIJIbIM) . BbIXOP; sa 3TII paMKH IIpIIBegeT
K cy6'beKTIIBlIsMY.
CM., Hanp.: Keopoe B. M. IIpe]:\MeT II B3allMOCBH3b eCTeCTBeHHbIX HayK. M., 1962;
Ou 3/Ce. IIpllHIJ;llll llCTopll3Ma II ero IIpllJIOmeHlle K CllCTeMHOMY aHaJIll3Y pa3BllTIIH
HaYKII II CllcTeMHble llCCJIe]:\OBaHllH: Emero;rJ:HllK, 1974. M., 1974. CneIlIIaJIbHO 0
IIp06JIeJ\Ie TIIITOJIOrlllleCKOrO B 3THorpag)llII CM.: IIpoGJIeMbI TllIIOJIOrHII B 3THorpa-
g)llll. M., 1979.
2 De Saussure F. Cours de linguistique generale. P., 1922. IIepBbIH PYCCKllH nepeBo]:\:
/.{e COCC/Op (jj. Kypc oGlI{eH JIllHrBllCTllRll. M., 19330 COBpeMeHHoe ll3]:\aHlle C 06-
CTOHTeJIbHbIJIIll KOMMeHTapllHMll: /.{e COCC/Op (jj. TpY]:\bI no H3bIR03HaHllIO. M., 1977.
3 JHUPMYHCKUU B. M. 0 CHHXpOHllll II ]:\llaxpOHllll B H3bIR03HaHllll II Bonp. H3bIK03Ha-
HllH. 1958. J\f£ 5; Kocepuy 3. CllHXPOHllH, ]:\IIaxpoHllH II llCTOpllH II HOBoe B JIIIHrBll-
CTllRe. M., 19630 BbIlI. 3; Ky6pRKoea E. C. 0 nOHHTllHX CllHXpOHllll II ]:\HaxpOHllll II
Bonp. H3bIK03HaHllH. 1963. ;N!! 3; 061I{ee H3bIR03HaHlle: MeTo]:\bI JIllHrBHCTlllleCKIIX
llCCJIe]:\oBaHllll. M., 1973.
4 EOJIee lIogp06HO 06 3TOM CM.: JIRnynoe A. Ao B 'IeM COCTOllT CllCTeMHbIH 1l0p:XOg
K ll3Y'IeHllIO peaJIbHbIX 06'beRTOB CJIOmHOH IIpllpOp:bI? II CHcTeMHble llCCJIenOBaHllH:
Emerop:HllR, 1971. M., 1972; Caooecnuu B. H. HeKoTopbIe IIpllHl\llllllaJIbHble IIp06-
JIeJllbI 1l0CTpoeHllH oGlI{eH Teopllll CllCTeMbI II TaM me; B.aay6epe lJ. B., IOfJuu 3. F.
CTaHOBJIeHHe II CYII{HOCTb CllCTeMHoro llo]:\xo]:\a. M., 1973; IOfJun 3. F. MeTo]:\OJIO-
rlIlleCKaH IIplIpo]:\a CllCTeMHoro no]:\xo]:\a II ClI'CTe1lHble llCCJIe]:\oBaHllH: EmerogHllK,
19730 M., 1973; B.aay6epe lJ. B. IJ;eJIOCTHOCTb II CllCTeJ\IHOCTb II CllcTeMHble llCCJIe]:\o-
BaHllH: Emero]:\HllK, 1977. M., 1977; CafJoecKuu B. H. ClIcTeMHbIH IIO]:\XO]:\ II oGlI{aH
TeopllH CllCTeM: CTaTYC, OCHOBHble npoGJIeMbI II nepcneKTllBbI pa3BllTllH II CllcTeM-
Hble llCCJIep:OBaHIIH: Emero)J;HllK, 19790 Mo, 19800
5 MapKapRu 3. C. O'lepRii llCTOpllll RYJIbTypbI. EpeBaH, 1969; Ou 3/Ce. 0 reHe3llce TIe-
JIOBeTIeCKOil p:eHTeJIbHOCTIJ II KYJIbTypbI. EpeBaH, 1973.
6 FYMu.aee J1. Ho Cym.HOCTb 3THHlleCKOii l\eJIOCTHOCTll II BeCTH. JIfY. 1971. ;N!! 24.
7 BpoM.aeu 10. B. OTHOC II 3THorpag)llH. Mo, 1973.
8 ApYTlOuoe C. Ao, g e6oKcapoe H. H. OrHlIlleCKlle IIpOn;eCCbI II llHg)opMan;llH II IIpnpo-
]:\a. 1972. ;N!! 7; OHU ;nee. IIepe]laTIa llH<popMal\llll KaK MexaHll3M cym.ecTBoBaHllH 3T-
HOCOl\HaJIbHbIX II 6ll0JIOrll'IeCRlIX rpYli1i 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa II PacbI II Hapop:bI. M., 1972.
T. 2. IIomaJIyii, HeJIb3H He ynoMHHYTb 3]:\eCb II 06 ll ee CllCTeMHOCTll peJIllrlIll. CM.:
Bacu. bee JI. Co KYJIbTYPHo-peJIllrIJ03HbIe Tpap:lll\llll CTpaH BocToRao M., 1976.
9 C L, Hallp.: JIuxa'leea B. /.{., JIuxa'tee /.{. C. Xy]:\omeCTBeHHoe HaCJIe]:\lle ,[(peBHeil
PYCll II COBpeMeHHOCTb. JI., 1971; JIuxa'lee /.{. Co Pa3BllTlle PYCCKOH JIllTepaTypbI x-
XVII BeROB: OIlOXll II CTllJIllo JIo, 1973.
10 Cp.: MOHeaUT A. ApXeOJIOrllH 3alla]:\HOH EBpOllbI: KaJ\IeHHbIH BeK. M., 1973; TllllbI
CeJIbCKOrO mllJIlIII{a B CTpaHax 3apy6emHoH EBpOlibI. M., 19680
11 CM. 06 3TOM: OK.aafJuuKoe A. II. HeOJIIIT II GpOH30BbIII BeK IIpllGaHKaJIbH. q. 1, 2 II
MaTepHaJIbI II llCCJIep:OBaHllH 110 apXeOJIOrllll CCCP. Mo; .fL, 1950. T. 18.
12 IIpllMeHllTeJIbHO K 3a]:\a'IaM :JTHorpag)HlleCKOrO llCCJIe]:\oBaHllfl pa3HbIe aClleKTbI llC-
nOJIb30BaHllH cpaBHllTeJIbHO-llCTOplIlleCKOrO MeTop:a oGcToHTeJIbHO paCCMOTpeHbI:
Hundson Ch. The historical approach in anthropology II Handbook of social and cul-
tural anthropology. Chicago, 1973; oTHorpag)llH KaR IICTOTIHllK peKoHcTPYKqlIll llC-
TOpllll nepB06bITHoro oGlI{eCTBa. M., 1979.
13 KpOMe C60pHllKa 0 3ana]:\HoeBponeHCKOM II n;eHTpaJIbHOeBpOllerrCKOM mllJIlIII{e, YKa-
3aHHoro B IIpllMeTI. 10, CM.: Xapyauu A. H. CJIaBHHCRoe mllJIlIII{e B CeBepo-3alla]:\-
168
HOM RpaC. BllJIbHa, 1907; JIe6eoeea Ho If. llilIJIlIlI{e II X03HHcTBeHHble nOCTpOllRii
EeJIOPyccROII CCP. Mo, 1929; B.fwMKeucT E. 8. KpecTbHHcKlle 1l0CTpOHRII PYCCKlU,
yKpalIHl\eB II 6eJIO£ycoB II BOCTO'IHOa3llaTcRIIH 3THorpa<pI1'IeCRlIH C60PHllK. Mo, 1956.
(Tpo I1H-Ta 3THorparpmI AH CCCP. Ho C.; To 31).
!4 0 COOTHOllieHllll TpaglIl\lIOHIIbIX 3JIe 1eHTOB II agallTllBHbIX HOBo06pa30BaHllH B RO-
CTIOMe CM.: IIpbLTKoea H. (jj. OgeJR]:\a HapogoB caMogllilcRoH rpYlIlIbI RaK llCTOplI-
TIecKHiI llCTO'IHlIK II0gemga HapogoB C1I6llpn. JI., 1970; Bacu.I!eeu't F. M. IIpoll3-
Bo]:\cTBeHHbIH KOCTIOM 3BeHKOB HlImHeII II IIogRa leHHoii TYHrycoK RaK llCTOplIlle-
CKlIii llCTOTIHIIR II TaM meo 06 OT)J;eJIbHbIX nplIHagJIeamOCTHX ogemgbI, coxpaHHIO-
1I{1IXCH 6e3 3Ha'IIITeJIbHbIX ll3MeHeHlIH Ha IIpOTHmeHlllI orpOMHbIX lIeplIo)J;oB Bpe11e-
HlI, eM.: If eanoe Co Bo CTaplIHHble Tpy6'IaTble IIrOJIbHllRii HapOT(OB ClIOlIplI II TaM me.
!5 PYCCRlIe: MCTOPIIKO-3THorpag)lllleCKllH aTJIaCo 3eMJIep;eJIlle. KpeCTbHHCRaH o]:\em-
]:\a. KpeCTbHHCKoe mllJIlIlI{e: (Cepe]:\llHa XIX - Ha'IaJIO XX BeRa). M., 1967; PyccKlIe:
I1CTOpllRD-3THorpag)1I'IeCKllll aTJIac. 113 llCTOplllI pYCCRoro Hapo.n:HDrO mllJIlIlI{a II
ROCTIOMa. (YKpallieHlIe RpeCTbHHCRllX OMOBll op;em]:\bI): (Cepep;llHa XIX - Ha'Ia-
JIO XX Bo). M., 19700
t6 CM.: BpYK C. If. 061I{eeBpOneHcKllH IICTOpllRo-3THorpa<p1I'IeCRlIii aTJIaC II COB. 3THO-
rpag)IIH. 1970. M 6; On 3/Ce. I1cropllKo-3THorpa<pII'IecKoe RapTorpa<pIIpoBaHlle II ero
cOBpeMeHHble rrp06JIeMbI II COB. 3THorpag)llH. 19730 M 3; OH 3/Ceo 8THOJIOrl1'IeCKlIll aT-
JIac EBponbI II COlIpe]:\eJIbHbIX CTpaH II ApeaJIbHbIe llCCJIep;OBaHllH B H3bIK03HaHIIll II
3THorpag)llII. JI., 1977.
17 I1cTopllRo-3THorpag)II'IecKllH aTJIaC Cll6llpn. M.; JI., 1961.
18 B Ra'IeCTBe npllMepa CM.: PaTlfe.l!b (jj. Hapop;OBep;eHlle. CII6., 1902. T. 2.
19 Biasutti R. Le razze e i popoH della terra. Torino. 19590 Volo 1.
20 113 pa60T, B ROTOpbIX pa3HocTopoHHe paccMaTpllBaIOTcH llCCJIe OBaHllH 3BOJIIOl\llOH-
HOro HanpaBJIeHllH II IIpllBOP;IITCH JIllTepaTypa, CMo: TOKapee C. Ao I1cTopllH 3apy-
6emHoii 3THorpag)llll. M., 1978.
21 B ]:\onOJIHeHlle R YKa3aHHOMY TPYP;y 11>. PaTI eJIH CM.: mYPlf F. I1CTOplIH llepBO-
6bITHOii RYJIbTYPbI. CII6., 1907.
2 lIIiTepaTypa II llCTOpIIKO-KpllTlllleCKIIH aHaJIII3: Heine-Geldern R. One hundred years
of ethnological theory in the German-speaking countries: some milestones II Curro
Anthropol. 1964. Vol. 5, N 5; Voget F. The history of cultural anthropology II Hand-
book of social and cultural anthropology.
23 KJIaCClIlleCRlle pa60TbI: Graebner F. Kulturkreise und Kulturgeschichten II Ztschr.
Ethnol. 1905. Bd. 37; Idem. Methode del' Ethnologieo Heidelberg, 1911; Idem. Ethno-
logie II Anthropolugie: Die Kultur del' Gegenwart, ihre Entwicklung und ihre Ziele o
Leipzig; B., 1923. Abt. 50
2.\ MoneauT Ao JIo 3ap;a'Ill II B03MomHOCTll apXeOJIOrlIlleCROH RapTorpag)llll II COB. ap-
XeOJIOrllH. 1962. M 1.
25 Bo.eopa3-Tan B. Fo PacrrpocTpaHeHlle RYJIbTypbI Ha 3eMJIe: OCHOBbI 3THOr;:p a <p IIll .
M.; JI., 1928.
2d 06 ST01-I CM.: BpY"K C. If., H03J'LOe B. If., JIeeuH M. r. 0 npe)J;MeTe II 3a)J;aQaX STHO-
reorpag)llII II COB. 3THorpag)llH. 1963. M 1; Onu 3/Ce. COBpeMeHHoe COCTOHHlle IICCJIe-
gOBaHHiI 110 3THIIlleCROll reorpa<pllII II feorpa<pllH HaCeJIeHlIH B CCCP: (OcHoBHbm
np06JIeMbI). M., 19640 06 3THoRapTorpag)llll CMo: BpYK C. If., K03.1!oe B. If. OCIIOB-
Hble IIp06JIeMbI 3THII'IeCROii RapTorpa<plllI II COB. 3THorpag)llH. 1961. J\f2 5. B OTHO-
llieHllll nOKa3a pa3Ho06pa3IIH 'CITHlllIeCKIIX RapT II 1l0JIOmeHHbIX B OCHOBY llX BbI-
nOJIHeHIIH MeTogll'IeClmX II rpag)ll'leCKllX IIplleMOB YHllKaJIbHO ll3]:\aHlle: ATJIaC Ha-
pOAOB MlIpa. M., 1964.
<7 IIp06JIeMbI 3THII'IeCKOH reorpag)llll II RapTorpag)IIlI. M., 1978.
28 KymHep IIo If. OTHlllleCKlIe TeppllTopIIll II 3THII'IeCRIIe rpamIl:\bI II Tp. I1H-Ta 3THO-.
rpag)IIll AH CCCP. H. C. M., 1951. T. 15. CTaTbli 0 xapaKTepe JIllHrBllCTlllleCKlIX II
3THorpag)ll'leCKIIX rpaHIII CM.: IIp06JIeMbI KapTorpag)lIpOBaHlIH B H3bIK03HaHllII .I'f
3THorpag)llll. JI., 1974; ApeaJIbHbIe llCCJIe]:\oBaHllH B H3bIK03HaHllll II 3THorp a <p lIll .
JI., 19770
2q Wissler C. The American Indian. N. Y., 1917; Idem. Man and culture. N. Yo, 1923;.
Idem o The relation of nature to man. N. Y, 1926; Kroeber Ao Cultural and natural
areas of native North America. Berkeley. 1939.
J JIeeun Mo F., g e6oKcapoe H. H. X03HHcTBeHHo-RYJIbTYPHble TlIllbI II IICTOpllKO-3THO-
rpag)ll'ICCKIIe 06JIaCTII II COB. 3THorpag)llH. 1955. M 4; AHfJpuaHoe B. B., g e60Kca-
poe Ho H. I1CTOpIIKo-3THorpa<pll'IeCKlIe 06JIaCTll: (IIp06JIeMbI llCTOpIIRo-3THorpag)ll-
lleCROrO paHoHHpoBaHllH) II TaM me. 1975. M 3; Onu 3/Ce. OlibIT llCTOpIIKo-:JTHorpa-
g)lIlleCKOrO paiiomlpoBaHIIH HeKOTopbIX perlIOHOB Ag)pllKll II 3apy6emHoH A3llII II
TaM me. M 4. 0 Heollpe]:\eJIeHHOCTll 1l0HHTllH 061I{HOCTll IICTOplIlleCKOH mll3Hll CM.:
A.aeKceee B. II. MCTOplIlleCRaH aHTpOllOJIOrllH. M., 1979.
169
I
t
I
.
t
r
3! IIepBYIO OTTIeTJII1BYIO g)OPMYJIHpOBKy CM.: ToltcToe C. II. 01lepKII nepBOHaTIaJIbHOrO
IICJImla II COB. 3THorpag)IIH. 1932. M 2. IIpllMep JIOKaJIbHorO paHoHllpoBaHllH CM.:
JIUUb Ho-xya, TJ e6oKcapoe H. H. X03HHcTBeHHo-KYJIbTypHbIe TlIllbI KllTaH IloTHo-
rpaqJII'IeCKHH C60pHllK, 110 Mo, 1961. (Tp. I1H-Ta 3THorpag)llII AH CCCP. Ho C.;
T. 23) 0 IIaHoiiKYMeHHoe pailOHllpoBaHlle CM.: TJ e6oKcapoe H. Ho, TJ e6oncapoea JIo A.
Hapo.n: bI , pacbI, RYJIbTypbI. Mo, 1971; AnfJpuanoe Bo Bo, TJe6oKcapoe Ho H. X03HllCT-
BeHHD-KYJIbTypHbIe THIIbI H IIp06JIeMbI I1X RapTorpag)llpoBaHIIH II COB. 3THorpag)IIH.
1972. M 2.
32 Boeopaa-Tau B. Fo PacnpOCTpaHeHlle RYJIbTYPbI Ha 3eMJIe.
33 Bepe JI. C. JIaH]:\lliag)THo-reorpag)lIlleCKIIe 30HbI CCCP. M.; JIo, 1931. q. 1.
3 06 aHTpolioreou;eH03ax CM.: AlteKCeee B. II. AHTpOnOreOl\eH03bI - CYII{HOCTb, THIlO-
JIOrllH, ]:\llHaJ\1llKa II IIpllpo]:\a, 1975. M 7; IOfJuu 8. F. CllcTeMHbIe IIp;elI B 3THorpa-
g)llll I I TaM me.
35 B I\eJIOM 0 np06JIeMe CM.: Man in adaptation. Chicago, 1968. Vol. I, II.
36 MemP;Y TeM 06JIaCTb <<HeMOTbD) apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKHX MaTepllaJIOB p;OCTaTO'IHO 06IImpHa,
II 0 Hell 1l0CTOHHHO CJIep;yeT 1l0MHIITb. 06 3TOM CM.: MoneaiiT A. JIo ApXeOJIOrlI-
TIeCRlIe RYJIbTYPbI II 3THlIlleCKIIe 061I{HOCTll II Hapo]:\bI A3lIlI II A<pPHKH. 1967. M 1;
Apew,llu F. KYJIbTYPHO-llCTOplIlleCRlIII 1l0gXOp; K H3Y'IeHHIO 3THll'-IeCKliX 061I{HOCTeH
B apXeOJIorHH /1 MeTo]:\OJIOrlIlleCKlle IIp06JIeMbI lICCJIep;OBaHliH 3THHlleCRHX EYJIbTYp.
EpeBaH, 1978; Klteuu JI. C. ApXeOJIOrliH II 3THoreHe3: (HOBbIH 1l0]:\X0p;) II TaM me;
ApYTIOHoe Co A., Xaaanoe Ao M. IIpooJIeMa apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX KplITcplieB 3THH'IeCKOH
Cllel\llg)llRlI II VIII KpyrrHoBcKlle 'lTeHllH: Te3. ]:\OKJI. HaJIb'IllR, 1978; Ouu 3/Ce. Ap-
XeOJIOrlI'IeCKlle KYJIbTYPbI II X03HHcTBeHHo-RYJIbTypHbIe TlIllbI: IIp06JIeMa COOTHOllie-
HllH II IIpOOJIeMbI TllIIOJIDrllll B 3THorpag)lIll. M., 1979; Onu 3/Ce o IIp06JIe1\ia apxeOJIO-
rlllleCRIIX RpllTeplleB :JTHll'-IeCKOII Cnel\H<plIRII II COB. 3THorpag)HH. 1979. M 60
3'/ Teiiltop 8. AHTpOllOJIOrllH: (BBep;eHlIe R ll3Y'IeHllIO lleJIOBeRa II l\HBllJIlI3al\HlI). CII6.,
1908; On 3/Ce. IIepB06bITHaH KYJIbTypao M., 19390 OOII{YIO xapaKTepHCTlmy paGoT
:JBOJIIOl\lIOHHOH llIROJIbI CM.: TOKapee Co Ao IIcTopHH 3apyoemHoH 3THorpag)HlIo
38 CMo, Hallpo, RJIaCCII'IeCRlIe paOOTbI: BoponUH Ho Ho 30p;'IeCTBO CeBepo-BoCTO'IHOH
PyClI: B 2 T. M., 1961-1962; Kapeep M. K. ,[(peBHlIH RHeB. M.; JI., 1961. T. 2;
On 3/Ce. HOBropog BeJIIIKHH: ApxllTeRTypHbIe naMHTHIIRII. M.; JI., 1966.
39 CM. yRa3aHHYIO BblIlle pa60TY E. 8. EJIOMKBllCT.
'" Boponun H. H. 7RllJIlIlI{e 11I1cTopllH KYJIbTypbI ,[(peBHeH PYCll: ,[(6MOHTOJIbCKIIII ne-
plIOp;. M.; JI., 1951. T. 1: MaTepllaJIbHaH KYJIbTypa; Pa6unoeu'l Mo r. 7RIIJIlIlI{a II
01lepRii PYCCKOH KyJIbTYPbI XIII-XV BeKOB. M., 1970. q. 1: MaTepllaJIbHaH KYJIb-
Typa; FpoMoe F. Fo 7RHJIllII{e II O'iepKll PYCCKOH RYJIbTYPbI XVI Bo Mo, 19770 L{. 1.
H KYrP TUU B. A. MaTepllaJIbHaH KYJIbTypa PYCCKOH MelI{epbI. M., 19260 110 1; Maclto-
ea T. Co HapogHaH op;emp;a PYCCRHX, YKpallHl\eB II oeJIOPycoB B XIX - HallaJIe
XX Bo II BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCRlIH 3THorpa<pII'IeCKlIII C60PHliKo Mo, 19560 (Tpo I1H-Ta :1T-
Horpag)lIH AH CCCPo H. Co; T. 31). Cp.: AplfuxoecKuii Ao B. Ogelliga 11I1cTopllH
RYJIbTypbI ,[(peBHei!:- PYClI: ,[(oMoHrOJIbCRlIH llepllop;. T. 1; Ou 3/Ce. Op;emp;a II 01lepKII
PyccKoll RYJIbTYPbI XIII-XV BeROB. 11. 1; FpoMoe 1'0 1'. PyccRaH o]:\emp;a II O'iepRII
PyccKoii RYJIbTypbI XVI B. qo 1.
42 KplOKoe M. B. CllCTeMa pogcTBa RllTaHl\eB: (8BOJIIOl\llH II 3aKOH01\1epHOCT11). M.,
1972; OH 3/Ce. oTHorpag)ll'IeCKHe <paKTbI KaR llCTO'IHIIR ll3Y'IeHIIH nepB06bITHOCTll:
IIpOOJIeMa RpliTeplleB cTagllaJIbHoll rJIy6lIHbI II 8THorpa<plIH KaK llCTO'IHlIK peRoH-
CTPYKl\llII llCTOpllll rrepBOObITHDrO 06II{eCTBa. M., 1979.
's (jjaiin6epe JI. A. 061I{eCTBeHHbIn CTpOII 3CRlIMOCOB II aJIeYToB: OT MaTepllHcRoro
po]:\a R coce]:\cRoH 061I{lIHe. M., 1964.
M 0 COOTHOllieHHH Tpap;IIl\lIll II HHHOBal\llH RaK B u;eJIOJ\1, TaR II Ha KOHKpeTHbIX IIpll-
Mepax ]:\llHaMllKII OT)IeJIbHbIX RYJIbTYP CM.: ApYTlOuoe Co A. COBpeMeHHbIH 6bIT
HIIOHl\eB. M., 1968; On 3/Ce. MexaHll3MbI YCBoeHllH HOBoBBep;eHllH B 3THllTIeCKOH KYJIb-
Type II MeTO]:\OJIorH'IeCRlIe IIp06JIeMbI llCCJIep;OBaHllH <JTHI1'IeCRlIX KyJIbTYpo EpeBaH,
1978.
';5 g .!leH08 M. A. R xapaKTepnCTIIKe COu;naJlbHOif opraHlI3aIJ;1I1I a311aTCKHX 9CKIIMOCOB II
IX Mem]:\ynap. ROHrp. aHTpOnOJI. II 3THorp. HayR: ,[(OKJI. COB. geJIeraU;llll. M., 1973.
'6 AlteKCeee B. II., Altenceeea T. If. I1cTOpll'-IeCRlIe aClleKTbI aHTpOnOJI<JrlllleCKOH P;ll-
HaMlIRll II p;ll<pg)epeHl\llal\llii HaCeJIeHllH EepllHroJ\'lOpbH II IIcToplIH, apXeOJIOrllH II 3T-
Horpag)llH Hapo]:\oB ,[(aJIbHerO BocToKa. BJIa]:\llBocTOR, 1973. BbIn. 1; AlteKCeee B. II.,
Baltyeea T. C. MaTeplIaJIbI 110 KpaHlWJIorlIll HaYKaHcRlIx 3CKlI1\IOCOB: (K p;lIg)g)epeH-
l\llal\llii apKTlIlleCKOH pacbI) II COB, 3THorpag)llH. 1976. N2 1; Alexeev V. The genetic
structure of Asiatic Eskimos and coastal Chukchis compared to that of American
arctic populations II Arct. Anthropol. 1979. Vol. 16, N 1.
i7 CM. Hallp.: Huntington E. Civilisation and climateo New Haven, 1926; Man's role
in changing the face of the earth. Chicago, 1936; II ]:\po
170
8 qacTHbIII IIpliMep TaKoro CJiUifiliurU II l'vIHOrocrylleH'laTorO BJIllHHllH CM.: KpynnuK If. Ifo
CTaHOBJIeHlle KpyrrHoTa6YHHoro OJIeHeBO]:\CTBa Y TynP;pOBbIX HeHl\eB II COB. 3THorpa-
g)llH. 1976. M 6.
. 9 Cl'vl., Hallp.: YCKoe A. If. Arp06ll0l\eH03 KaK 06'beRT IICCJIe]:\OBaHIiH II YlipaBJIeHllHII
EllOJIOrlIlleCRlle CIiCTeMbI B 3eMJIep;eJIllll II JIeCoBogcTBe. Mo, 1974.
5" IIepBoe yrroMllHaHlle 0 HeH CMo: To.acToe Co II. COBeTCRafl lliKOJIa B 3THorpa<pllll II COB.
3THorpag)llH. 19470 M 4. 0 cop;epmaHllll 3THorpag)IIH B l\eJIOM II 6ll6JIliorpa<pIIIO CM.:
BpO.MMU 10. B. 8THOC II 3THorpag)IIH; Handbook of social and cultural anthropology.
51 00 3Tmi CM., Hallpo: KopoJlee Co If. BonpocbI 3THOnCI1XOJIOrlill B paGoTax 3apy6emHbIx
aBTopOB: (Ha MaTeplIRJIaX CTpaH A3llll). Mo, 19700
52 B E\alleCTBe npliMepOB lO,RHO YKa3aTb Ha 00lI{errpll3HaHIIoe 3Ha'ieHlIe TeIIJIOrO ra-
TepllaJIa B 3llMHeH op;emp;e HapO OB Cll6llpli II CeBepa, KOHCTPYKTllBHO crrel\llg)lIlle-
CRllH Tllll mllJIlIII{a BO lHorllX ropHbIX paHOHax II T. ]:\.
53 OTgeJIbHbIe rrpllMepbI CM.: I1H]:\elll\bI AMepllKII II Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP.
H. C. M., 1955. T. 25.
M Bce CBfl3aHHbIe C ;)TII J TpygHOCTH )J;el'vlOHCTplIpyeT pa60Ta: TJ epenHun JI. Bo HCTOpH-
TIeCRlIe YCJIOBllH g)OpMlIpoBaHllH PYCCKOH Hapop;HOCTll p;o KOHl\a XV B. II BOllpOCbI g)op-
MlIpOBaHllH PYCCKOll HapogHocTll II HallI1lI. M.; JI., 1958.
55 Fopooljoe Bo Ao i'J,aRocapMaTcRlle peJIllrll03HbIe 3JIeMeHTbI B PYCCKOM Hapop;HOM TBOp-
'IeCTBe II Tp. foco HCTo MY3eH. 1926. BbIll. 1; CM. TaKme: Pbz6aKoe B. A. H3bI'IeCTBO
p;peBHllX CJIaBHH. M., 1981.
56 CMo, Hallp.: /l,unljec JI. Ao ]:(peBHlIe TIepTbI B PYCCKOM HapO]:\HOM llCKYCCTBe II MCTOPllH
KYJIbTYPbI i'J,peBHeH PYCII: i'J,oMoHrOJIbCKIIH llepllO]:\. M.; JI., 1951. T. 2: 061I{eCTBeHHbrH
CTpOII II ]:\YXOBHaH RYJIhTypao
57 Pa6unoeu'i Mo F. lliIIJIIlll\a; ApljuxoecKuu A. B. Op;em]:\a (1970); FpoMoe F. F. llill-
JIlIII{e; On 3/Ce o PyccKaH op;emp;ao
58 Boponun H. H. llilIJIlIlI{e; ApljUXOeCKuu A. Bo Op;em]:\a (1951).
S9 KpoMe YKa3aHHoH CTaTbll l£. B. qepellHIIHa, CM.: /l,anu.aoea 9. B. MCTOplllleCRlIe YCJIO-
BllH pa3BlITllH PYCCKOIl HapO]:\HOCTII B llepiiog 06pa30BaHllH II YKpellJIeHllH l\eHTpaJIll-
30BaHHoro rocygapcTBa B POCCIIII II BonpocbI g)OpMllpoBaHllH PYCCROH HapO]:\HOCTll II
Hal\llll. Mo; l£., 1958.
60 Eggan F. Social anthropology and the method of controlled comparisons II Amer.
Anthropol. 19560 Vol. 56, N 6; CM TaKme: Idem. The social organisation of the Wes-
tern Pueblos. Chicago, 1950; Idem. The Cheyenna and Arapaho in the perspective of
the plains: ecology and society liThe American Indian: perspectives for the study of
social changeo Chicago, 1966.
61 IIpll BceH HellpllBbI'IHOCTII TepMIIHOJIOrlIlleCKOrO COTIeTaH1{Jl «3THI1'IeCKaH KYJIbTypa,}
OHO Bce 60JIbllie BXOP;llT B mlI3Hb II yrroTpe6JIHeTCH HapaBHe C BbIpameHllH 1II «xyp;o-
meCTBeHHaH RYJIbTypa,), «P;YXOBHaH KYJIbTypa» II T. ]:\0 CM.: gucToe K. B. BbIpameHlle
3THll'IeCKOH KYJIbTypbI II MeTO]:\OJIOrl1lleCRlIe IIp06JIeMbI llCCJIe]:\OBaHllH 3THlllleCRlIX
RYJIbTYP. EpeBaH, 19780
62 CM. oc06eHHO: /l,o.azaT Yo B. JIllTepaTypa II g)OJIbKJIOp: (TeopeTll'leCKlIe aClleKTbI).
M., 1981.
63 TOKapee C. A. 0 3aga'IaX 3THorpag)lIlleCKOrO ll3y-qeHllH Hapo]:\oB llH ycTPllaJIbHbIX
cTpaH II COBo 3THorpag)IIH. 1967. J'l'2 5.
61, BpoM.aeu 100 B. OTHOC II 3THorpag)llH.
65 rycee B. E. 8CTeTllKa g)OJIbKJIOpa. M.; JI.. 1967.
8THOrEHETI1QECRI1E I1PE}J;AHI1H,
JIMHrBMCTMQECRME }J;AHHbIE,
AHTP0I10JIOrMQECRMn MATEPMAJI
OBOCHOBAHHEXAPARTEPACOllOCTABJIEHHR
IIp06JIeMbI 8TDoreHesa B nacToHIIJ;ee BpeMH npIIBJIeKaIDT BDIIMaUIIe Bce 60;ree
IIIIIpoKoro Kpyra cneQlIaJIIICTOB II peIIIaIOTcH Da OCDOBe Bce 60JIee pasDo06-
paSDbIX p;aHHbIX, IICIIOJIbsyeMblx B Ka'IeCTBe IICTOplI'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHHKOB.
OD:UaKO B IIogaBJIHIOIIJ;eM OOJIbIIIIIHCTBe CJIY'IaeB 3THoreDeTII'IeCKIIe npOQeCCbI
O'IeIIb CJIOlliHbI II OTJJ;eJIeDbI OT HaCTOHIIJ;erO IIJIOTHOH saBecoH BpeMeHII,
171
pasopBaTb KOTOpyID nopOH De yp;aeTcH p;ame C nOMOIIJ;bIO Bcex 3TIIX p;aD-
HbIX. II03TOMY, C OP;DOH CTOpOHbI, Kpyr npIIBJIeKaeMbIX IICTO'IHIIKOB Bce pac-
IIIJIpfleTCH, a C p;pyroH - )],eJIaIOTCH nOnbITRII TeOpeTII'IeCRII OCMbICmITb
06'beM IID<popMaQIIII, IISBJIeRaeMOii lIS IICTO'IUIIROB paSDbIX BII)],OB, II TaKIIM
06pasoM XOTJI 6bI npII6JIII3IITeJIbHO YCTaHOBIITb CTeneDb IIX HH<popMaTIIB-
HOCTII 1.
B OP;HOH lIS npep;IIIeCTBYIOIIJ;IIX pa60T aBTop cp;eJIaJI IIonbITKY COIIOCTaBIITb
pesYJIbTaTbI apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIX, 3TDorpa<pII'IeCRIIX, JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIX II aDTpo-
IIOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX IICCJIep;OBaDIIH, a TaKme nORasaHIIH nlICbMeHDbIX IICTO'IDIIROB 2.
PeSYJIbTaTOM 3Toro conOCTaBJIeIIIIH CTaJIa rpa<pII'IeCKaH cxeMa C nOKaSOM
p;lIanaSODa BpeMeHII, Da npOTHmeHIIII KOToporo coxpaHHeT 3<p<peKTIIBDOCTb
IICTOpII'IeCKaH IIH<popMaQIIH, II3BJIeRaeMaH lIS Kamgoro conOCTaBJIeUHOrO C
p;pyrIIMII BIIp;aMII IICTOplIqeCKOrO IICTO'IHIIRa. HaIIOOJIbIIIIIM 8TOT giianasoH
OKaSaJICH y aHTpOnOJIOrII'leCKIIX p;aHHbIX: naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIH yrJIY6JIHeT ero
P;O 3nOXH HIImuero naJIeOJIIITa, Da'IIIDaH C 3nOXII no RpaHDeii Mepe MeSOJIIITa
MbI IIMeeM yme cepIIHDbIe MaTeplIaJIbI, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCROe IICCJIep;OBaDlIe CO-
BpeMeDuoro 'IeJIOBeKa nOSBOJIHeT peKODCTpYIIpOBaTb C06bITIIH cpaBHIITeJIbDO
HegaBDero npOIIIJIOrO II p;ame COBceM 6JIII3RIIe R COBpeMeDHOCTII.
Op;DaRO OT TaRoro 06IIJ;ero cpaBDeHIIH peSYJIbTaTOB, nOJIY'IaeMbIX paSDbIMII
OTpaCJIHMII IICTOplI'IeCKOH HaYKII II CMemDbIMII ):(IICQIIIJJIIIDaMII, nopa nepexo-
P;IITb K ropasp;o 60JIee p;eTaJIbHOH II TIIJ;a TeJIbHOH OIJ;eHKe IIX peKODCTpYK-
TIIBDbIX BOSMomHOCTeH, K onpeJJ;eJIeDIIIO ypOBDH TOH XpODO:IOrII'IeCKOH rJIy-
6IIHbI, P;O KOTOpOH ODII nOSBOJIHIOT P;OHTII, K BbIHBJIeHIIIO CTeneHII Hap;em-
DOCTII caMOH peKODCTpYRIJ;IIII.
8THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX naomop;eDIIH yme CeH'IaC DaROnJIeDO gOBOJIbIIO MDoro,
'IaCTII'IHO OHII IIpOTIIBOpe'IIIBbI, 'IaCTII'IHO O)],DOSDa'IHbI, II sa)],a'Ia COCTOIIT ue
TOJIbKO B IIX KOJIII'IeCTBeDDOM YBeJIII'IeDIIII, DO II B IIX 06'beKTIIBIISaIJ;IIII. Ees
TaROH 06'beRTIIBlIsaQIIII npOCToe HaROnJIeHIIe p;aHDbIX He CMomeT nogDHTb Hac
Ha CJIeJJ;YIOIIJ;YIO CTyneIIb B IIX IICTo:rROBaIIIIII. 8TOT pasgeJI nOCBHIIJ;aeTCH
CIIeIJ;IIaJIbHO cpaBDeHIIIO JIIIDrBIICTII'IeCRIIX II aUTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX Ha6JIIO)],eUIIH
C 3TDoreHeTII'IeCKOH IIII<popMaQlIeH, cogepmaIIJ;eiiCH B npeJJ;aHIIHx paSHbIX
Hapop;OB 06 IIX IIpOIICXOmp;eHIIII. TaRIIe npep;aHIIH eCTb npaRTII'IeCKII y I;;am-
goro Dapop;a, OHII MDoro pas IICnOJIb30BamlCb B pasHo06pasDbIx 3TuoreDeTII-
'IeCKIIX llCCJIep;OBaHIIHX, HO, K COmaJIeDIIIO, nOKa De CYMMlIpOBaDbI p;OJImDbIM
06pasoM. 06'bHCHHeTcH no TeM, 'ITO llC'IepnaTb BCIO CYMMY OTHOCHIIJ;IIXCH
K 8TOH 06JIaCTII <paKToB DeBOSMomHO De TOJIbRO B KpaTKOH CTaTbe, IIO II B
OJJ;HOH MODorpa<pIIII. B p;aJIbHeiIrneM 6YP;YT YIIOMIIHaTbCH JIIIIIIb OTp;eJIb-
Hble npIIMepbI TaKIIX 8TDoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npep;aHIIH, KODKpeTDO TpaRTyIOIIJ;lIe
npOIIcxomp;eHlIe Toro IIJIII lID oro Hapop;a.
IIo'IeMY JIIIDrBIICTII'IeCKIIe JJ;aHHbIe CneIJ;IIaJIbDO conOCTaBJIHIOTCH C aDTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII II IIX, B CBOIO O'Iepep;b, cpaBHIIBaIOT C 8TDoreHeTII'IeCKIIMII
npep;aDIIHMII? )J,JIH 3Toro eCTb TeOpeTII'IeCKIIe OCDOBaDIIH. IIepBoe lIS DIIX
COCTOIIT B TOM, 'ITO aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe oc06eDHOCTII 'IaIIJ;e Bcero HesaBIICIIMbI
OT ypOBDH II xapaRTepa KYJIbTypbI. C06bITIIH 3TIIII'IeCKOH, COQIIaJIbDOH, p;ame
KYJIbTypDOH H nOJIIITII'IeCKOii IICTOpIIII Hapop;OB OTpamaIOTCH B p;IIDaMIIRe IIX
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX oc06eDHOCTeH, HO npoIIcxogHT ne3aBIICIIMO OT 3TIIX OCO-
6eDDocTelI. IIDbIMII CJIOBaMII, MbI CYP;IIM 06 3THoreuese II 3TDII'IeCKOH IICTO-
pHII - npoQeccax IICTOplI'IeCRIIX - IIa OCHOBaDlI1I TaKIIX <paKToB, KOTopbIe
'IYTKO OTpamaIDT p;IIHaMIIRy 3TIIX npOIJ;eCCOB, JJ;ODOCHT llaMHTb 0 HIIX )],0 Dac
'Iepes MHoro CTOJIeTIIH H game TbICH'IeJIeTIIH, DO caMII He HBJIHIOTCH IICTOPII-
'IeCKIIMII B Y3KOM II CTporOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa.
.HSbIK C IISBeCTDbIMII OrpaDII'IeHIIHMII saHIIMaeT IIop;06Doe me nOJIOmeDIIe.
MDoro DanIIcaHO 0 ero cOQIIaJIbHOH npIIpO.D:e. MDora IICCJIH110BaHIIH nOCBH-
172
1Qeuo II BCKpbITIIIO 6IIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX KOpHeH 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOH pe'IH. Pe'IeBaH geH-
'l'eJIbDOCTb HBJIHeTCH MOIIJ;HeHIIIJIM Cpep;CTBOM KOMMYHIIKaIJ;lIlI, a KOMMYHIIKa-
IJ;IIH 06eCne'IIIBaeT Bce KYJIbTYpDoe pa3BlITlIe 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa. Ho nplI
Bcex COQIIaJIbDbIX acneKTax HSbIKa pe'Ib B ee IIpOCTeHIIIIIX IIpOHBJIeHlIflX
KaK-TO CBHsaDa II C 61I0JIOrlI'IeCKHMII MexaHIISMaMII, II, BOSMomHO, IIMeUHO
n03TOMY npOIIcxomp;eDIIe pe'IlI HeIIOHHTHO II He06'bHCHIIMO 6es nplIBJIe'IeHIIH
p,aHD:bIX lIS 06JIaCTII SOOnCIIXOJIOrlIlI, aHTpOnOJIOrIIII II T. p;.3 TaKIIM 06pasoM,
flSbIK, XOTH II HBJIHeTCH BamDeHIIIIIM IIHCTpYMeHTOM KYJIbTypbI, IIpep;CTaBJIHeT
C060H no OTDOIIIeHIIID K HeH B IICTOKaX CBOIIX He'ITO BHelliHee II C6JIIImaeTCH
B ::nOM OTDOIIIeHlI1I C aHTpOnOJIOrlIeH: npaBga, saBIICIIMOCTb B 3TOM CJIY'Iae
He OP;HOCTOpOHDHH II p;IIHaMIIKa HSbIKa II glIHaMIIRa KYJIbTYpbI BsaIIMO-
06YCJIOBJIeHbI. Bce me cpaBDeHlIe 3<p<peKTIIBHOCTII P;JIH 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX
BbIBOP;OB gBYX 3TIIX BIIgOB IICTOplI'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIROB, OglID lIS KOTOpbIX
IIMeeT cyry60 61I0JIOrII'IeCRIIH xapaKTep (aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIH MaTeplIaJI),
a P;PyroH KOCBeDHO, HO Bce me CBHsaH C 61I0JIOrII'IeCROH nplIpop;OH 'Ie-
JIOBeRa (JIIIHrBIICTH'IeCKIIe p;aHHbIe) , npegcTaBJIHeT 60JIbIIIOH MeTOp;II'IeCKIIH
IIHTepec.
8TIlOreHeTII'IeCKIIe me npep;aHIIH DeCYT B ce6e TY IIH<popMaQHIO, KOTOpyID
caM Hapog nOMHIIT II coxpaHHeT 0 CBOIIX reUeTII'IeCRIIX IICTOKaX II 0 CBoeM
npOIIIJIOM, npaBp;a nponYIIJ;eHHYID 'Iepes KOJIJIeKTIIBHO-IICIIXOJIOrlI'IeCKlIe npep;-
CTaBJIeDIIH, 'Ie pes KOJIJIeKTIIBDoe MbIIIIJIeDlIe. II03TOMY 8THoreDeTII'IeCRIIe
npep;aHIIH IIHTIIMHO CBHsaHbI C 3THII'IeCKIIM caMOCOSDaDlIeM II, rrOmaJIYH,
60JIee, 'IeM p;pyrlIe 3JIeMeDTbI RYJIbTypbI, 8THII'IeCKII cneIJ;II<pII'IHbI. IIx nOJIDO-
Ta II QeHDOCTb paSJIII'IHbI Y paSlIbIX DapOJJ;OB: Y OP;HIIX OUII P;OBOJIbHO CMYT-
HbI; Y P;PyrIIx, HanplIMep Y nOJIIIDesIIIIQeB, ODII, Da060poT, OTJIJI'IaIOTCH
IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbHOH geTaJIbHOCTbIO. MHorIIe KYJIbTypDbIe 8JIe:\IeDTbI, He CBHsaH-
DbIe C caMOCOSDaHlIeM Toro IIJIII IIDoro Dapoga, 06'beKTIIBDO CYIIJ;eCTByroT B
onpep;eJIeHHOH <popMe, <PYlIKQIIOHIIPYIDT II IISMeDHIOTCH BHe saBIICIIMOCTII OT
Tex OTTeHKOB II acneKTOB, B KOTOpbIX OHII BOCIIpHHIIMaIOTCH IICnOJIbSYIOIIJ;IIMII
IIX JIIOP;bMII p;aHHOH IIJIII gpyroH 3THII'IeCKOH npIIDaJJ;JIemDOCTII. 8TDoreHeTII-
'IeCKlIe me npep;aHIIH He CYIIJ;eCTBYIDT 6es 3THoca II 3THII'IeCKOrO caMOC03Ha-
DIIH B OTJIII'IlIe OT aDTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX ocooeHDocTeH II HSbIKa - 3JIeMeHTOB
IIO OTHOIIIeHIIIO K RYJIbType B yRasaDHbIX CMbICJIaX OTDOCIITeJIbDO BHeIIIHIIX,
:3TII npegaHIIH - OP;IIH lIS HalI60JIee xapaKTepDbIX BDYTpeDDIIX 3JIeMeDTOB
KYJIbTypbI IIMeDDO p;aHHoro Hapoga. 8THM II 06'bHCHHeTcH nx BbI60p B Ka'Ie-
CTBe 3JIeMeHTa KYJIbTypbI, COIIOCTaBJIHeMOrO C aDTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIM COCTaBOM
II HSbIKOM.
CJIeP,yeT, nOmaJIYH, nOp;'IepKHYTb eIIJ;e OP;HO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, nplIp;aIOm;ee
TaKOMY conOCTaBJIeDIIID p;OnOJIDIITe;;r:bHbIH MeTOp,II'IeCKHH JIDTepec. 8TDoreHe-
TII'IeCRlIe npep;aHIIH He coxpaHHIOTCH DeII3MeHDbIMH Ha npOTHmeHIIII IICTOplIII
Hapoga, JIIOP;H He TOJIbRO xpaHHT B HIIX naMHTb 0 CBoeM npOIIcxomp;eDIIII,
DO II BDOCHT B HIIX RoppeKTIIBbI B saBIICIIMOCTII OT Toro, KaRIIM ODII XOTHT
BIIp;eTb CBoe npoIIcxomJJ;eDlIe. A 3TO meJIaHHe OIIpep;eJIHeTCH ypOBHM KYJIb-
TYp:bI II 06mecTBeHDoro paSBIITIIH, CJIOmIIBIIIIIMIICH KYJI:bTypDO-6bITOBbIMII
OTHOIIIeIIIIHMII C P;PyrIIMII HapogaMII, p;ame, DaKOHeQ, IICTOpII'IeCI{II 06YCJIOB-
JIeDDbIMII H nepIIOp;II'IeCKII BOSDIIKaIOIIJ;IIMII B onpep;eJIeDH:bIX IICTOplI'IeCKIIX
cIITyaQIIHX BCn:bIIIIRaMII HaQIIOHaJIIISMa II T. p;. )J,pyrlIMH CJIOBaMH, 3THoreHe-
TII'IeCKlIe npep;aHIIH JII060ro Hapop;a He OTJIIIJIHCb B saCTbIBIIIYIO WOPMY, OHII
mlIBYT II IISMeDHIOTCH Ha npOTHmeHIIII IICTOplIlI, npII'IeM IIDorp;a IISMeDeDIIH
3TlI BHOCHTCH COSDaTeJIbDO B yrop;y TOH IIJIII IIHOH nOJIIITII'IeCROH IIp;eOJIO-
rII'IeCKOH gOKTpIIDe. KCTaTH CKa3aTb, IISY'IeHIIe IICTOpII'IeCROH p;IIDaMIIKII
3TDoreDeTII'IeCRIIX IIpep;aDIIH Ha <pODe COQlIaJIbDOH II KYJIbTypHOH IICTO-
pHII TOro IIJIII IIHoro Hapop;a npep;CTaBJIHeT C060H YBJIeKaTeJIbHeHIIIYIO Hay'I-
173
i
HYIO Sap;a'IY, IIMeIOIIJ;YIO n CepbeSHbIH TeOpeTII'IeCKIIH HHTepeC. AHTpOnOJIO-
rII'IeCKIIH COCTaB II HSbIK, HanpOTIIB, OTHOCIITeJIbHO cTa6IIJIbHbI, a pOJIb
C03HaTeJIbHbIX 'IeJIOBe'IeCKIIX p;enCTBIIH B lIX IISMeHeHIIHX 'IpeSBbI'IaHHO MaJIa.
,
:,
llPOCTP AHCTBO 3THOrEHETHqECRHX CHTY A HB
Korp;a cpaBHIIBaIOTCH Memp;y C060II TPII pHp;a HBJIeHIIH, peSYJIbTaTbI cpaBHe-'
HIIH 6YP;YT paSJIII'IHbIMII B COOTBeTCTBIIII C TeM, HesaBIICIIMbI Jill ,[IPyr
OT p;pyra IIJIII saBIICIIMbI 3TII pHP;bI. BblIIIe ynoMIIHaJIOCb 06 orpor.IHoH co-
IJ;HaJIbHOH <PYHKIJ;IIII HSbIKa, C KOTOpbIM TeCHO CBHsaHbI MHorIIe 3JIeMeHTLI
KYJIbTypLI, BMeCTe C HIIM nepep;aIOIIJ;IIeCH II pacnpOCTpaHHIOIIJ;IIeCH. 8THoreHe-
TII'IeCKIIe rrpep;aHIIH, KaK II Bce KOMnOHeHTbI <pOJIbKJIOpa, BblcrynaIDT B HSbI-
KOBOH <popMe. II08ToMY OHII, KOHe'IHO, C HSbIKOM CBHsaHbI, II TPYP;HO BocnpII-
HIIMaTb 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe npep;aHIIH II HSbIK RaK HesaBIICIIMble pHgbI HBJIe-
HIIH. II Bce me H peIIIaIOCb YTBepmp;aTb, 'ITO OHII OTHOCIITeJIbHO HesaBIICIIMbI
XOTH 6bI B OP;HOM, HO B nepBYID O'iepep;b IIHTepeCYIOIIJ;eM Hac OTHOIIIeHIIII-
B TpaKTOBKe npoIIcxomgeHIIH Hapop;a, KOTOpbIH HBJIHeTCH HOCIITeJIeM II TBOp-
IJ;OM 3TIIX npe,a:aHIIH. B 6bITY COSHaHIIe HSbIKOBbIX paSJIII'IIIH HBJIHeTCH op;Hon
IIS BamHbIX npep;nOCbIJIOK OCOSHaHIIH paSHIU{bI npOIIcxomp;eHIIH II, Ha060pOT,
I,;OSHaHIIe 6JIIISOCTII HSbIKa npHBop;IIT 'IaIIJ;e Bcero K SaKJIIO'IeUIIIO 06 OOIIJ;eM
npOIIcxomp;eHIIII. Ho B 3THOreHeTII'IeCKIIX npep;aHIIHX no KaKIIM-TO npII'IIIHaM,
BCKpbITIIe KOTOpbIX BLIXO,[liiT sa paMKII 3TOH CTaTbII, B Ka'IeCTBe cBIIp;eTeJIen
pasHoro npOIIcxom,a:eHIIH <pIIrypIIPYIDT B nOp;aBJIHIOIIJ;eM 60JIbIIIIIHCTBe CJIY-
'IaeB YKasaHIIH Ha pasHbIH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIH TIIn, Ha KaKIIe-TO cBoe06pas-
Hble 06bI'Iaii II HpaBbI, a He Ha paSHbIH HSbIK. B JIIIUrBIICTII'IeCKOM IICCJIe,[lO-
BaHIIII paSHaH HSbIKOBaH npIIHagJIemHOCTb Hapop;OB II CTeneHb IIX pacxom,[le-
HIIH no HSbIKY YCTaHaBJIIIBaIOTCH nOJIHOCTLID HesaBIICIIMO OT Tex IIJIII IIHbIX
npep;CTaBJIeHIIH 06 IIX npOIIcxomp;eHIIII. II03ToMY II MomHO, KaK MHe npe,a:-
CTaBJIHeTCH, rOBopIITb 0 HesaBIICIIMOCTII HSbIKOBbIX Ha6JIIOJJ;eHIIII II 3THoreHe-
TH'IeCKIIX npep;aHIIH. HesaBIIcIIMoCTb IIX OT aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX Ha6JIIOJJ;eHIIH
O'ieBIIp;Ha. IIpemHIIe Heop;HOKpaTHble nonbITKII YCTaHOBIITb npII'IIIHHYID CBHSb
Memp;y aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII oc06eHHocTHMII II HSbIKOBon npIIHa,[lJIemHOCTbID
IIMeIOT JIIIIIIb IICTOplI'IeCKIIH IIHTepec.
IITaK, MLI MomeM npep,nOJIaraTb B Ka'IeCTBe IICXO,a:HOH nOCbIJIKII, 'ITO IIMe-
eM p;eJIO C TpeMH pHp;aMII HesaBIICIIMbIX HBJIeHIIH. llT06bI HarJIHp;Hee npep;-
CTaBIITb ce6e pasHo06pa3IIe cIITyaQIIH, Korp;a, CKameM, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe
IISbICKaHIIH BCKpbmaIDT TO me HanpaBJIeHIIe 3THII'IeCKIIX CBHseH, 'ITO II JIIIHr-
BIICTII'IeCKIIe, a 8THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe npe,n;aHIIH rOBopHT 0 APyroM IIJIII, Ha060-
pOT, aHTpOnOJIOrIIH II JIIIHrBIICTIIKa npIIBop;HT K npOTIIBOpe'IIIBbIM BbIBop;aM
II T. p;., BblpaSIIM 3TII cIIryaIJ;IIII B rpa<pII'IeCKOH <popr.fe (pIIC. 11).
Bce IIX pasHo06paSIIe npii p;aHHOM 'IIICJIe HesaBIICIIMbIX pHgOB Ha6JIIOp;e-
Hiin II paBHOH BepOHTHOCTII llX COBnap;eHIIH II HeCOBnap;eHIIH B 3THoreHeTH-
'IeCKOM IICCJIep;OBaHIIH IIC'IepnbIBaeTCH BoceMbID CJIY'IaHMII, Kam,a:bIH II3 KOTO-
pbIX oxapaKTepiiSOBaH Ha pIICYHKe COOTBeTcTByIOIIJ;IIMII CIIMBOJIaMII II 060SHa-
'IeH BospaCTaIOIIJ;eH pIIMCKOH IJ;II<PPOH. IIopH,[IOK !IX Ha pIIcynKe 60JIee IIJIII
MeHee npOIISBOJIeH, OH Mor 6bITb II .LJ;PyrIIlII. TaKme onpaBp;aHHO, HanplIMep,
6bIJIO 6bI Ha'IllHaTb He CO CJIY'IaH HeCOBnaJJ;eHIIH peSYJIbTaTOB Tpex pHP;OB
HesaBIICIIMbIX Ha6JIIOp;eHIIII - aHTpOnOJIOrll'IeCKIIX, JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIX JJ;aHHbIX
II 8THoreHeTII'IeeKIIX npep;aHIIH, a C npOTIIBOnOJIOmHOrO CJIY'IaH - IIX nOJIHO-
ro COBnap;eHIIH. IIOpHP;KOBble 060SHa'IeHIIH nOMeHHIOTCH Torp;a CIIMMeTpII'IHO
MeCTaMII, HO, nOBTopHIO, 3TO HenpIIHQIIIIIIaJIbHO - B p;aHHOM cJlY'Iae CIICTeMa
OTC'IeTa MomeT 6bITb JII06aH, ropasp;o IIHTepeCHee cop;epmaTeJIbHaH CTopOHa
3HaJIIISlIpyeMbIx ciiTyaIJ;IIH.
I
174
I II III IV
[} [} [} [}
+ +
Jl A Jl + A Jl A J1 A
V VI VII VIII
[} [} [} [}
+ + + + + +
Jl + A' Jl + A Jl A Jl + A
PllC. 11. B03MOmHbIe COOTHomeHllH Memgy pa36llpaeMbIMll Bllp;aMll llcTopllllecKlIx llC-
TOTIHllKOB
.IT - JIHHI'BIICTWleClme ):\aHHble; 3 - 8THOI'pacIJWIeCRlIe ):\aHHhle; A - aHTpOnOJIOI'H'leCRlIe ):\aHHhle;
+ - COBIIa):\eHlIe ):\aHHbIx; - - HeCOBIIa):\eHlIe ):\aHHbIX
IIpemp;e 'IeM rrepeHTII K aHaJIII3Y II IIJIJIIOCTpIIpOBaHIIIO npIIMepaMII KOHK-
peTHbIX 8THoreHeSOB, 06paIIJ;aIO BHIIMaHIIe Ha ciiTyaIJ;IIII V, VI II VII. OHlI
CIIl\IMeTpII'IHbI OTHOCIITeJIbHO SHaKOB. 8TO OSHa'iaeT, 'ITO OP;IIH IIS pHP;OB He-
saBIIClIMbIX HBJIeHIIH COBnap;aeT C gBYMH ):(pyrIIMII no BbIHBJIeHHbIM 3TH ore- .
HeTlI'IeCRlIM CBHSHM, a 3TII nOCJIep;HIIe ue COBnap;aIOT Memp;y C060H. JIerRo
rroHHTb, ITO TaRoe nOJIOmeHIIe npaKTII'IeCKII He peaJIIIsyeTCH. AHaJIOrII'IHble
cIIryaQIIlI, CIIMMeTpII'IHble no SHaKaM «MIIHYC» ('ITO OSHa'IaeT - OP;lIH IIS
pHilOB He COBnap;aeT C P;BYMH P;PYrIIMII, a OHII cOBnagaIDT Memp;y C060H),
BOSMomHbI TOJIbKO nOToMY, 'ITO TaKoe HecoBnap;eHIIe p;BYX pHP;OB Ha6JIIOp;e-
HIIII C TpeTblIM He IICKJIIO'IaeT aBTOMaTlI'IeCRII IIX COBnap;eHIIH Memp;y c060ii,
TorAa KaR p;Ba cJIY'IaH cOBnap;eHHii Memp;y P;BYMH pHp;aMII aBTOMaTII'IeCKII
npIIBo):(HT II K TpeTbeMY CJIY'IaID cOBnageHIIH. TaRIIM 06pasoM, MHoro06pasIIe
Bcex BOSMomHbIX cIITyaQIIii YMeHbIIIaeTcH P;O nHTII. PaCCMOTpIIM IIX no
nopHgKY.
CUTyalfuR I. TpH BIIp;a cpaBHlIBaeMbIX 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIKOB
nplIBogHT K npOTIIBOpe'IIIBbIM pesYJIbTaTaM, T. e. HII aHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCRlIe p;aH-
HbIC, HII 8THoreHeTII'IeCRIIe npeJJ;aHIIH, HII JIlmrBIICTII'IeCKIIe IICCJIep;OBaHIIH He
cosp;aIOT OCHOBbI P;JIH op;HOSHa'IHOrO peIIIeHlIH 3THoreHeTII-rreCRoii np06JIeMbI.
KaK MomeT cosp;aTbCH TaKaH HeOnpep;eJIeHHaH ciiTyaIJ;IIH? OHa MomeT BOS-
HIIKHYTb TOJIbKO B TOM CJIY'Iae, eCJIII peSY:IbTaTbI aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO HCCJIe-
IIOBaUIIH nplIBop;HT K BCKpbITIIIO OJJ:HOII onpegeJIeHHOH JIIIHIIII 3THoreHeTII'Ie-
CKIIX CBHseH, 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe npep;aHIIH - K BCKpbITlIID P;PyroH, a mmr-
BIICTII'IeCKlIH aHaJIIIS HaBop;IIT Ha TpeTbID reHeTII'IecKYID JIIIHIIIO. TaKoe CJIom-
Hoe nepeRpeIIJ;IIBaHIIe BbIBOP;OB paSHbIX p;IICIJ;IInJIIIH BCTpe'IaeTCH B 3THoreHe-
TII'IeCKOM IICCJIep:OBaHlIII He'IaCTO, 1I0 OlIO He IICKJIIO'IeHO, npIIMep 'IeMY npep;-
CTaBJIHeT 8THoreHes CKII<pOB.
reHeSIIC JII060ro Hapop;a P;peBHOCTII enw TpYP;Hee nop;BeprHYTb aHaJI1I3Y,
'IeM rrpOlIcxomp;eHIIe COBper.feHHOrO Hapop;a, II TpYP;HOCTII 3TII yneJIII'IIIBaIOTCH
nponOPQIIOHaJIbllO nepIIOP;Y BpeMeHII, Ha KOTOpbIH 3TOT p;peBHIIH Hapop; OT-
CTOIIT OT COBpeMeHHOCTII. 3gecb IIrpaeT pOJIb II 06IIJ;eII3BeCTHaH HenOJIHOTa
IICTOpII'IeCKIIX cBegeHIIH, II TPYP;HOCTb 3THoreHeTII'IeCKOii IIHTepnpeTaIJ;IIII ap-
XeOJIOrII'IeCKlIX p;aHHbIX 5, II CJIY'IaHHbIH B 60JIbIIIlIHCTBe CJIY'IaeB xapaKTep
naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX MaTepIIaJIOB. CKII<pbI He COCTaBJIHIOT lICKJIIO'IeHIIH,
XOTH nOCBHIIJ;eHHaH IIM JIIITeparypa orpOMHa II Bonpoc 06 HX npoIIcxomp;e-
HIIII paccMaTpIIBaJICH II IIcTopIIKaMII, II apxeOJIOraMII, II JIIIHrBHCTaMII.
HSbm CRII<pOB IISBeCTeH HaM JIlIIIIb no TeM maJIKIIM <pparMeHTaM, KOTopble
p;OHeceHbI P;O Hac rpe'IeCKIIMII IICTO'IHIIKaMII, T. e. B OCHOBHOM no JIlI'lIIbIM
I
175
I
I
!
/
IIMeHaM. ECTeCTBeHHO, 3TOT OHOMaCTII'IeCRIIH MaTepIIaJI TpY,[IeH P;JIH aHaJIIISa.
JIIIPYH CBOIO rnrroTesy OrpOMHOrO apeaJIa H<peTII'IeCKIIX HSbmOB B p;peBHOCTII.
BII)JeJI B CKII<pCKOM HSbme npeIIMymecTBeHHO H<peTII'IeCRIIii HSbIK II IIlITep-
'JIIgeJI B CKII<pCKOM HSbIKe rrpeIIMYIIJ;eCTBeHHO H<peTII'IeCRIIH HSbm II IIHTep-
rrpeTIIpOBaJI ero B nJIane BbIHBJIeHIIH nepep;HeaSIIaTCKIIX II KaBRaSCKIIX aH3-
JIOrIIH 6. TaRoii aHaJIIIS no anpiiopHoCTII IICXOP;HbIX npe,[lnOCbIJIOK II no CJIa-
60CTII H HenOJIHOTe Y'IeTa KOHKpeTHbIX HSbmOBbIX peaJIIIii He CTIIMYJIIIpOBaJI
p;aJIbHeHIIIIIX IICCJIep;OBaHlIH B YKasanHOM HaIIpaBJIeHIIH. AllTOp me HaIIOOJIee
06CTOHTeJIbHOH CBOP;KII 0 CKII<pCKOM H3bIKe - B. II. A6aeB IICXO,[lIIJI IIS rIIIIO-
TeSbI HpaHCKOH npIIHa,[lJIemHOCTII CKH<pOB II CYMeJI nop;TBepp;IITb ee y6e,[lII-
TeJIbHbIMII co06pameHIIHMII 7. )J,aJIbHeHIIIee nop;TBepmgeHIIe npHHa,[lJIemHOCTII
CRII<pCKoro HSbIKa K IIpaHCKoii ceMbe HSbIKOB p;aHO IIM B cpaBHIITeJIbHOM IIC-
CJIep;OBaHllII Ha lliIIpOKOllI <pOHe p;peBHIIX HSbIKOB 3anap;HOH II l(eHTpaJIbHOH
EBpaSIIII 8.
KaKoH me 3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIH BbIBOP; BbITeKaeT HS caMoro <paKTa npHHag-
JIemHOCTII CRII<pCKoro HSbma K IIpaHCKOH HSbIKOBOH ceMbe? 8Ta ceMbH B Ha-
CTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH JIOKaJIIIsyeTcH K IOry II IOrO-BOCTOKY OT OCHOBHoro CRII<PCKO-
ro apeaJIa. HeJIbSH He OTMeTHTb, 'ITO MHorne 8JIeMeHTbI CKH<pCROH B:yJIbrypbI.
II ocooeHHO O):(IIH caMbIH HPKIIH ee 3JIeMeHT - TaK HaSbmaeMbrii CRII<pCRIIR
3BepIIHbrii CTIIJIb, IIMeIOT, no npe06JIap;aIOIIJ;eMY MHeHIIIO, BOCTO'IHOe II IOro-
BOCTO'IHOe npOIICXOm,[leHIIe 9. II03TOMY HaIIOOJIee BepOHTHoe HanpaBJIeHHe
3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX CBHseH P;JIH eBponeHcKIIx CRII<P0B, eCJIII IICXO):(IITb IIS IIH-
<popMaQIIH 00 IIX HSbIKe, a saop;HO II IIS aHaJIIISa IIX MaTepIIaJIbHOH KYJIbry-
pbI,- BOCTO'IHOe II IOrO-BOCTO'IHOe.
06 3THoreUeTII'IeCKHX npep;aHIIHX CKll<pOB ,[IaIDT HSBeCTHoe npep;CTaBJIeHIIe
JIereH,[IbI 0 npoIIcxomp;eHIIII CKII<pOB, npIIBO,[lIIMble fepO,[lOTOM 10. BeCbMa
BOSMomuo, 'ITO 8TII JIereHp;bI cosp;aHbi B rpe'IeCKOH cpep;e, 'ITO OHII OTpamaIDT
KaKIIe-TO cyryoo rpe'IeCKIIe nOHIIManIIe II TpaKTOBKy npOIIcxomp;eHIIH CKII<pOB,
a cpe]J;H nOCJIep;HHX obITOBaJIII IIHble 3THoreHeTII-rreCKIIe npep;aHIIH. B TO me
BpeMH fepop;OTa MomHO C'IIITaTb p;OCTaTO'IHO OO'beRTIIBHbIM aBTopOM B TOll
'IaCTII ero Tpyp;a, rp;e OH nIIIIIeT 0 XOpOIIIO SHaKOMbiX eMY COObITHHX II IISJIa-
raeT JIII'IHbIe HaOJIIOp;eHIIH 11. II03TOMY B IIpIIHQIIne ue IICKJIIO'IeHO, 'ITO nepe-
CRaSbIBaeMble IIM JIereH]J;bI OTpamaIDT II co6CTBeHHO CKH<PCRYIO opIIeHTaIJ;IIIO
B Bonpoce 00 IIX npOIIcxomp;eHIIII. COrJIaCHO 3TIIM JIereH):(aM, CKII<pbI npolIC-
XOP;HT OT O,[lHOrO IIS CbIHOBeH 3eBca IIJIII OT op;Horo IIS CbIHOBeH fepaRJIa II
OT MaTepeH, IIMeIOIIJ;IIX MeCTHoe npOIIcxomp;eHIIe. JIereHp;a 0 npOIIcxomp;eHIIII
CRII<pOB IIS ASIIII TaKme npIIBogiiTCH fepo):(oToM, HO OHa RameTCH r.me IIMeIO-
IIJ;eH MeHbIIIee SHa'IeHHe, TaK KaK OH He YRaSbIBaeT TO'IHO, B RaROH cpe,[le
oua obITyeT. KaK HII TpaKTOBaTb 3TII JIereHgbI, HCHO, 'ITO OHII", XOTH 6bI 'Ia-
CTII'IHO, rrpIIBop;HT K YRasaHIIIO Ha IOro-sanap;Hoe HanpaBJIeHIIe 8THoreHeTII'Ie-
CRIIX cBHseII P;JIH CKII<pOB, 'ITO npoTIIBOpe'IHT P;O IISBeCTHOH CTeneHII OTMe'IeH-
HOMY BblIIIe IOrO-BOCTO'IHOMY HanpaBJIeHIIIO 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX CBHseH, YCTa-
HaBJIIIBaeMoMY JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKII.
IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIH MaTepIIaJI rro CKII<paM HeJIbSH C'IIITaTb p;OCTa-
TO'IHbIM, XOTH OH CeH'IaC yme P;OBOJIbHO BeJIIIR. IIpeIIMyIIJ;ec.TBeHuo OH npo-
IICXO}J,IIT IIS MOrIIJIbHIIROB eBponeHCKIIX CRIICpOB 12, HO BCTpe'IaeTCH II Ha
TeppIITOpIIHX, r,[le rrpOmIIBaJIO, COrJIaCHO IICTOpII'IeCKIIM IICTO'IUIIKaM II CYP;H
no apXeOJIOrII'IeCKllM ,[IaHHbIM, pop;CTBeHHoe HaCeJIeHIIe: B Cpep;HeH ASIIII, Ha
AJITae II B XaKaCIIII 13. KaKoB HaII60JIee TIIIIII'IHbIH aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIH
KOMIIJIeRC P;JIH Bcero 3Toro HaCeJIeHIIH, B nepBYID O'IepelIb, KOHe'IHO, gJIH eB-
porrelIcRIIx CRII<pOB? 8TO 6bIJIII KJIaCCII'IeCKIIe eBponeOlIgbI, OTJIII'IaBnmeCH, RaI{
II nOp;aBJIHIOIIJ;ee 60JIbIIIIIHCTBO p;peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH, yP;JIIIUeHHOH <popMon
rOJIOBbI, OTHOCIITeJIbHO HIISKIIM II IIIIIpOKIIM JIIIQOM, P;OBOJIbHO MaCCIIBUbDI
!&.
176
I !
CKeJIeTOM II CpaBHHTeJIbHO BbICOmIlIi pOCTOM. TOT me ROMIIJIeKC npIIsHaKoB
xapaKTepeH, KCTaTH cRasaTb, sa HeMHorIIMII IICRJIIO'IeHIIHMII, II JJ;JIH POP;CT-
BeUIIOro CKII<paM HaCeJIeHIIH. ECJIII ue npIIHIIMaTb 130 BHIIMaHIIe pa60TbI, no-
CBHIIJ;eHHI.Ie RpaHIIOJIOrIIII CKII<pOB, BbmYIIJ;eHHble eIIJ;e 13 npOillJIOM 13eRe II
YCTapeBillIIE' no cBoerr MeTO):(Ime, TO nepBbIM IICCJIe):(OBaTeJIeM 3Toro ROMnJIeK-
ca 6bIJI f. <Do )J,e6eQ, BI,ICRaSa13illIIH rIInOTesy 0 ero <pOpMIIpOBaHIIII Ha OCHO-
Be eme 60JIee p;peBHero npoToMop<pHoro KOMnJIeRCa, IICXOJJ;Horo )XJIH eBpo-
neOlI):(uoii pacbI Bo06IIJ;e H. He 06cymgaH nocJIep;Heii 'IaCTII 3TOH nIIIOTeSbI,
nOp;'IepKUY ee BbICOKYID BepoHTHoCTb 13 OTHOIIIeHIIH reHeSIIca caMOII CKII<p-
CROH KOM6IIHaIJ;IIII npIIsHaRoB. IICXOJJ;HbIH npoTOROMnJIeKC sa<pIIRCIIpo13aH Ha
Toii me TeppiiTopIIII B 3noxy 3HeOJIJUa II 6pOHSbI MHOrIIMII MaTepIIaJIaMII 15.
KaRoH 3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIII BbIBOJ]; BbITeKaeT IIS reHeTII'IeCKOH CBHSII CKII-
<pOB C HaCeJIeHIIeM 3nOXlI 6pOHSbI, npomIIBaBillIIM Ha TOll me TeppIITopIIII?
OH COCTOIIT 13 TOM, 'ITO cmI<pbI He nOHBIIJIIICb 13 IOmDopyccmrx CTenHX C IOro-
BOCTOKa, KaK MomHO P;YMaTb B COOTBeTc,TBIIII C apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII II JIIIHrBH-
CTII'IeCRIIMII Ha6JIIOJJ;eHIIHMII, He nOHBIIJIIICb OHII H C IOro-aanap;a, KaR saCTaB-
JIHeT P;YMaTb npIIBop;IIMaH Y fepop;OTa JIereHp;a 06 IIX npOIIcxomp;eHIIII,
a CJIOmIIJIIICb Ha TOM me MeCTe, rp;e IIX aaCTaeT HCTOpIIH. AnTpOnOJIOrH'Ie-
CKII:8 MaTepIIaJI He IICKJIIO'IaeT IIHOpOP;HbIX 3THII'IeCRIIX BRJIIO'IeHIIH 13 COCTaB
CKII<pOB, HO npeIIMYIIJ;eCTBeHHoe SHa'IeHIIe npIIp;aeT Bce me MeCTHI.IM IICTOKaM
HX 8THoreHesa. HaJIIIIJ;O, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, HBHaH HeconOCTaBIIMOCTb peSYJIbTa-
TOB naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO IICCJIep;OBaHlIH C JIIIHrBHCTII'IeCKIIM aHaJIHSOM
II 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIMII npegaHIIHMH. )J,JIH TOro 'IT06bI KaK-TO 06'bHCHIITb 3TY
HeCOIIOCTaBIIMOCTb 13 06IIJ;eH <popMe, HymHo paCCMOTpeTb Bce p;pyrIIe cIITyaQIIII,
cosp;aIOIIJ;IIeCH npii cpaBHeHIIII IIuTepecyIOIIJ;IIX Hac Ha6JIIOp;eHIIII.
CuryalfuH II. JIIIHrBHCTII'IeCKIIe II aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe MaTepHaJIbI p;aIOT
COrJIaCOBaHHI,Je nOKaaaHIIH, a 3THoreHeTII'IeCKHe npep;aHIIH Haxop;HTCH B npo-
TIIBOpe'IIIII C HIIMII. B npIIHIJ;IIne rpaHIIIJ;bI aHTpOnOJIOrlI-rreCKoro II JIHHrBIIc,TII-
'IeCKOrO pogcTBa O'IeHb 'IaCTO COBnap;aIOT eCJIII He B p;eTaJIHX, TO 13 06IIJ;IIX
'IepTax. B Ka'IeCTBe npIIMepOB MomHO YKasaTb Ha SHa'IIITeJIbHYro aHTpono-
JIOrII'IeCKYID 6JIIISOCTb P;pyr K p;pyry rrO'ITH Bcex CJIaBHUOHSbI'IHbIX Hapop;OE
(IICK.1IIO'IeHIIe COCTaBJIHIOT JIIIIIIb HeKOTopble OKpaIIHHbIe uapop;bI CJIa13HHCKoro
apeaJIa, HanpIIMep HaCeJIeHIIe BbICORoropHbIX paHOHOB IOrOCJIaBIIII): Ha aHT-
pOnOJIOrII'IeCRYID 06IIJ;HOCTb KapTBeJIbCKIIX, HaXCKIIX II aBapo-aHp;o-p;IIgOHCRIIX
HapOiJ,OB KaBRaaa (B 8TY 06IIJ;HOCTb MomHO BRJIIO'IIITb, npaB):(a, eIIJ;e IIpaHO-
HSbI'IHbIX oceTIIH II TIOpROHSbI'IHbIX 6aJIRapIJ;eB II Kapa'IaeBQeB, HO 60JIee Be-
pOHTeH nepexop; IIX npep;KOB na IIpanCKYIO II TlOpRCRYro pe'Ib Ha Cpa13HlITe.rrb-
HO nosp;HeM 8Tane IIX 3THoreuesa); Ha aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCRYID rOMoreHHOCTb
HnOHCKOro Ha pop;a 16. Op;HaKO BO BCex nop;06UbIX CJIY'IaHX H BO lIiHorIIX P;PY-
rIIX, TaRme IIJIJIIOCTpIIpyroIIJ;IIX COBnap;eIIIIe peSYJIbTaTOB aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX
II JIHHrBIICTII'IeCKIIX J2ICCJIe)WBaUIIII, 8TuoreHeTII'IeCKIIe npep;aHIIH JIIIOO He P;O-
IIIJIII P;O COBpeMeHHOCTII, JIII60 ,o:e<popxmpOBaHbl B nosp;Heiiillee BpeMH HBHO
IISHa'IaJIbHO 'Iymp;bIMII IIM HaCJIOeHIIHMII.
IIpIIMep, c13060gHbIH OT TaKoii p;e<popMaIJ;IIII II n03TOMy 60JIee yp;a'IDbm,
'IeM Bce ynor.IHHYTble,- JIereHp;bI 0 npoIIcxomgeHIIII nOJIIIHeSIIHIJ;eB. 3apaHee
oroBopIOCb, 'ITO H npIIp;epmIIBaIOCb rHnOTeSbI npOIIcxomp;eHIIH nOJIIIHeSIIHQeB
IIS ASIIII II SaCeJIeHIIH OReaHIIII He C BOCTOKa, a C sana):(a.
KaRIIMII <paKTaMII MomHO apryMeHTIIpOBaTb npOIIcxomp;eHIIe nOJIIIHeSIIH-
QeB IIS ASIIII, OCTa13aHCb B par.max aHTpOnOJIOrIIII H JIIIHrBIICTHKII? IIoJIIIHe-
SIIHCRIIe HSblmI 06paSYIDT onpegeJIeHHOe e):(IIHCTBO, xapaKTepHsyeMoe 06IIJ;II-
lIm CTPYKTYPHbIMII oc06eHHOCTHMH rpaMMaTII'IeCKOrO CTpOH H JIeKCH'IeCmIMII
cxomp:eHIIHMH 17. OHII 06'be}J;HHHIOTCH C MaJIaHCRIIM II ueROTopbIMII P;PYrIIMII
HSbIKaMII IOro-BocTo'IHO:8 ASIIII B ep;IIHYID MaJIaHCKO-nOJIlIHeSIIlIcKYID HSbIKO-
177
.
BYIO CeMbIO, IIJIII rpynny. MHOrIIe IICCJIep;OBaTeJIII IIOCTYJIIIPYIDT CyliJ;eCTBOBa-
HIIe 60JIbIIIOH aBCTpOHeSIIHCKOH CeMbII, apeaJI KOTOpOH OXBa TbIBaeT 'IaCTL
IOro-BoCTo'IHOH ASIIII II BCIO OKeaHIIIO (CeMbH 3Ta BKJIIO'IaeT TaKme MeJIa-
HeSIIHClme HSbIKII) 18. MHorne IIS 3TIIX HSbIKOB eIIJ;e nJIOXO IISY'IeHbI caMII
no ce6e, TeM 60JIee HeHCHbI IIX reHeTII'IeCKHe BsaIIMooTHOIIIeH:IIH, n03TOMY OT-
CYTCTByeT 06IIJ;enpIIHHTbIH BapiiaHT IIX KJIaCcH<pIIKaQIIH, HO O'ieBII,[IHO OP;HO:
reHeTH'IeCKIIe CBHSII yKasbIBaIDT Ha npOIICXOm,[leHIIe nOJIIIHeSIIHCKIIX HSbIKOB
II3 IOro-BoCTO'IHOH A3IIII, BKJIIO'IaH II npIIJIeraIOIIJ;IIe OCTpOBa. IIpaB,[Ia, cYIIJ;e-
CTBYIOT IICCJIep;OBaHIIH, 060cuOBbIBaIOIIJ;lIe IIHoe HanpaBJIeHIIe reHeTH'IeCRIIX
CBHseH P;JIH nOJIIIHeSIIHCKHX HSbIKOB - BOCTO'IHOe, nO}J;'IepRIIBaIOIIJ;ee IIX pop;-
CTBO C aMepIIKaHCRIIMII (B nepBYID O'iepep;b C QeHTpaJIbHO- II IOmHoaMepHKaH-
CKIIMII) HSbIKaMII 19. O):(HaKO 60JIbIIIeH 'IaCTbID 3TO CTapble pa60TbI, IIMeIOIIJ;He
JIIIIIIb IICTOpII'IeCKOe SHa'ieHIIe H nO,[lBeprUITIIeCH B CBoe BpeMH y6eAIITeJIbHOH
KpIITIIKe.
MaTepHaJIbI no COMaTOJIOrIIII COBpeMeHHoro' HaCeJIeHIIH IIOJIIIHeSHII pas-
6pocaUbI no MHorIIM pa60TaM, BOe,[lIIHO eIIJ;e He CBep;eHHbIM. COMaTOJIOrII'Ie-
CKIIH Tiin COBpeMeHHbIX nOJIHHeSIIli{QeB OTJIII'IaeTCH B 06IIJ;eM npOTIIBOpe'III-
BbIM CO'IeTaHIIeM npiiSHaROB: Ha MOUrOJIOIIp;OB OHH noxomii 60JIbIIIIIM ynJIO-
fiJ;eHHbIM JIIIIJ;OM, Ha HerpOIIp;OB OReaHIIHCKoro Kpyra - TOJICIT'bIMII ry6aMH :II
aJIbBeOJIHpHbIM npornaTIISMOM, Ha eBpOIIeOIIp;OB - saMeTHO BbICTYIIaIOIIJ;HlII
HOCOM. Bce 60JIbIIIe CTOpOHHIIKOB saBoeBbIBaeT TO'IRa speHIIH, COrJIaCHO KOTO-
pOH nOJIIIHeSIIiicRIIii COMaTOJIOrII'IeCKIIH KOMIIJIeRC 06paSOBaJICH B peSYJIbTaTe
KaRorO-TO p;peBHero CMeIIIeHIIH MOHrOJIOII,[IOB II HerpOII,[IOB 20. ABTOp 3TIIX
CTpOK nbITaJICH aprYMeHTIIpOBaTb IIp;eIO, B COOTBeTCTBIIII C KOTOpOH MOHrOJIO-
IIP;HbIH ROMnJIeKC, npIIHHBIIIIIii Y'IaCTIIe B CMeIIIeHIIII, BblcrynaJI B npOTOMOp<p-
HOH <popMe, 6JIIISROH K TIIXOOReaHCKOH BeTBII, a HerpOHp;UbIH - B <popMe OKe-
aHCROH BeTBII 21. TaKIIM 06paSOM, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIe Ha6JIIO,[IeHIIH Hap;
COBpeMeHHbIMII nOJIIIHeSIIHQaMII TaKme CBHp;eTeJIbCTBYIDT B nOJIbSY IIX npOIIC-
xom,[leHIIH JIII60 B MaTepIIKOBOH 'IaCTII, JIII60 Ha OCTpOBax IOro-BocTO'IHOH
ASIIII.
8TOT BbIBOP; MomeT 6bITb nOp;KpenJIeH II epaBHeHHeM nOJIIIHeSIIHIJ;eB C
aSIIaTCKIIMII Hapop;aMII no ,[IPyrIIM CHCTeMaM npiiSHaKOB. HaII60JIee cop;epma-
TeJIbHaH CBO,[lKa KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCRIIX p;aHHbIX IIO uapop;aM IIOJIIIHeSIIII COCTaB-
JIeHa K. BarnepOM 22. IIOJIbSYHCb MaTepIIaJIaMH 3TOH CBOP;RII, H. H. PorIIH-
CRIIH conOCTaBIIJI nOJIIIHesIIiIIJ;eB no cYMMe KpaHIIO OrII'IeCKIIX npiiSHaKOB C
p;pyrnMII Hapop;aMII II HaIIIeJI, 'ITO OHII 6JIHme Bcero K Hapop;aM IOro-BocTO'I-
HOH ASIIH 23. R HaCTOHII\eMY BpeMeHII HaKOnJIeH 60JIbIIIOH sanac cBegeHIIH 0
reorpa<pII'IeCKOM paCIIpep;eJIeHIIH rpynnoBbIX <paKTOpOB KpOBII B IIOJIIIHe-
SIIII 24. IIx BapIIaQIIII TaKme C6JIHmaIDT nOJIIIHeSIIiiQeB B HaII60JIbIIIeH Mepe
C HaCeJIeHIIeM IOro-BoCTo'IHOR ASIIII 25.
IIpep;aHIIH nommeSIIHQeB 0 CBoeM npOIIcxomp;eHIIH O'IeHb MHOrO'IllCJIeH-
HbI, saIIIIcaHbI B paSUbIX BapiiaHTax II saHIIMaIDT SHa'IIITeJIbHOe MeCTO B IIX
60raTOM <pOJIbKJIOpHOM TBOp'IeCTBe 26. ¥me HeCKOJIbKO p;eCHTIIJIeTIIH 3TII npe-
p;aHIIH CJIymHJIII P;JIH peKOHCTpYKIJ;IIII BpeMeHII II nYTeH 3aCeJIeHHH OCTpOBOB
IIOJIIIHeSIIII. ConOCTaBJIeHHe npep;aHIIH, sanlIcaHHbIx Ha paSHbIX OCTpOBax,
nOSBOJIIIJIO peKOHCTpYIIpOBaTb 92 nOKOJIeHIIH. nOJIIIHeSHIICKHX Bomp;eH H p;a-
TIIpOBaTb SaCeJIeHIIe OCTpOBOB npH6JIIISIITeJIbHO py6emoM HaIIIeH 3PbI 27. llTO
KacaeTCH nYTeH paCCeJIeHIIH II onpegeJIeDIIH OCHOBHoro apXIIneJIara, oTKyp;a
OHO Ha'IaJIOCb, TO B 3TOM OTHOIIIeHIIH nOKa He yp;aJIOCb ,[I06IITbCH op;HOSHa'I-
Horo peSYJIbTaTa. )J,JIH Hac BamHO, op;HaRO, nOp;'IepIUIYTb, 'ITO npep:aHIIH Ha-
SbIBaIDT B Ka'IeCTBe IJ;eHTpa paCCeJIeHIIH TOIl IIJIH IIHOH rpynnbI nOJIHHeSHH-
IJ;eB TO OP;IIH, TO p;pyroH apXIIneJIar, HO MOJI'IaT 06 ASHH II npHMbIKaIOIIJ;IIX
K Hell oCTpoBax KaK 0 p;peBHeHIIIeH npapop;HHe nOJIHHeSIIHIJ;eB.
I
178
8TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, 6bIBIIIee Ha npOTHmeHIIH HeCKOJIbKIIX p;eCHTIIJIeTHH
HenOHHTHbIM, 06'bHCHHJIOCL, KaK TOJIbKO 6bIJI nOJIY'IeH nepBbIH apXeOJIOrII'Ie-
cKIIii MaTepIIaJI HS IIoJIHHesHH, p;aTlIpOBaHHbIH He THnOJIOrH'IeCKH, a C nplI-
MeHeHHeM Tex TO'IHbIX MeTop;OB, KOTOpbIMII pacnOJIaraeT ceiI'Iac apXeOJIOrIIH,
B 'IaCTHOCTII Ca. OKaSaJIOCb, 'ITO OCTpOBa IIoJIHHesHH SaCeJIeHbI 'IeJIOBeKOM
MIIHHMYM Ha TbICH'IeJIeTIIe paHbIIIe, 'IeM npep;nOJIaraJIOCb. TaRIIM 06paSOM,
Ha'IaJIO nepeCeJIeHIIH Ha OCTpOBa IIOJIHHeSIIII OTOp;BIIraeTCH B eIIJ;e 60JIee p;a-
JIeROe npOIIIJIOe, H, eCTeCTBeHHO, 3THOreHeTH'IeCKIIe npep;aHHH yme He B CO-
CTOHHIIH IIH<pOpMHpOBaTb Hac 06 3TOM, oc06eHHO eCJIII Y'IeCTb BCIO CJIOmHOCTb
nYTeH paCCeJIeHIIH no caMOH IIOJIlIHeSHH H HaCbIIIJ;eHHOCTb nos):(HeH HCTOpHH
nOJIIIHesHHQeB, KOTopaH npocTo CTepJIa IIS naMHTH Hapop;a 60JIee paHHHe co-
6bITIIH.
8TO 06'bHCUeHIIe B npIIHIJ;IIne BblrJIHp;IIT p;OCTaTO'IHO JIOrII'IHbIM, Korp;a MbI
CTapaeMCH npOaHaJIIISIIpOBaTb npoTIIBOpe'IIIe, BOSHIIKaIOIIJ;ee B p;aHHOM CJIY-
'Iae npii cpaBHeHIIII paSHbIX BIIp;OB IICTOpII'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIROB. )J,eHcTBIITeJIb-
HO, np06JIeMY 3THoreHesa IIOJIHHeSHHIJ;eB He npOCTO peIIIllTb 6es TaRorO P;O-
nOJIHIITeJIbHOrO 06'bHCHeHIIH, TaK KaK aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKHe II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIe
p;aHHble rOBopHT 0 nepeCeJIeHIIH IIS ASIIII, a 3THoreHeTII'IeCKlIe npep;aHIIH He
BegYT Hac sa npep;eJIbI IIOJIIIHeSIIII. Ho nOKa eIIJ;e He BbI6paHa II He apry-
MeUTIIpOBaHa RaKaH-TO 06IIJ;aH JIIIHIIH OQeHKII TaKIIX ciiTyaIJ;IIH II Tex IICTOPII-
'IeCKIIX MaTepHaJIOB, KOTOpbIe KJIap;YTCH B OCHOBY HX peKOHCTpYRQIIH.
CUTyalfuR III. BbIBOP;bI, IISBJIeRaeMble IIS aHaJIIISa aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
MaTepIIaJIOB II 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npep;aHIIH, COBnap;aIOT, HO ORaSbIBaIOTCH B
npoTIIBOpe'IIIII C JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCRIIM aHaJIlI30M. TaKoBa IIH<popMaIJ;IIH 06 3THO-
renese apMHH, KOTopaH onIIpaeTCH Ha MHOrO'IIICJIeHHble p;aHHble, HaKOnJIeH-
HbIe B 06JIaCTII IISY'IeHIIH Bcex Tpex IIHTepecyIOIIJ;IIX Hac BHp;OB IICTOpII'Ie-
CKIIX IICTO'IHHROB, II n03TOMY p;OCTaTO'IUO KpaCHOpe'IIIBa.
KaROBbI BOSMomHOCTH IICnOJIbSOBaHIIH <pOJIbRJIOpa apMHH B 3THoreHeTII-
'IeCKIIX IJ;eJIHX? <POJIbRJIOp 8TOT HCKJIIO'IHTeJIbHO 60raT II pasHo06paseu, XOTH
II Hep;OCTaTO'IHO IISY'IeH 28. Oc060e MeCTO B HeM 3aHIIMaeT repOII'IeCRIIH 3noc
«)J,aBIIp; CaCYHCKIIH» - OP;HO II3 CORpOBIIIIJ; MIIpOBoro repOH'IeCKOrO <pOJIbKJIO-
pa. C06CTBeUHO 8THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npep;aUIIH Y a pMHH HeT, RaK II Y MHorHX
p;pyrIIx HapO):(OB C p;JIIITeJIbHOH nIICbMeHHOH Tpap;IIIJ;Heii, CJIOmHBIIIIIXCH B rJIY-
60KOH p;peBHOCTII. IIO-BIIP;IIMOMY, 3TII rrpep;aHHH CTepJIIICb nOCJIeP;YIOIIJ;IIMII
C06bITIIHMII 60raTOH nOJIIITH'IeCKOH H COQIIaJIbHOH IICTOpIIII apMHH. II08TOMY
TaK p;parOIJ;eHHbI Te reorpa<pII'IeCRIIe II 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe CBe):(eHIIH, KOTopble
MomHO IISBJIe'Ib IIS repOH'IeCKOrO 3nOCIl. OCHOBHble C06bITIIH, orrIIcaUHble B
HeM, pa3blrpbmaIOTCH B OP;HOH llS MeCTHOCTeH 3ana,gHoH ApMeHIIII, BOKpyr
BepIID-TaJIIIHa, a TaRme 03ep BaH II ¥pMIIH. 8THorpa<pII'IeCRaH Tpa):(IIQHH II
celI'Iac CBHSbIBaeT HaCeJIemre 8TIIX 06JIaCTeH C repOHMII 3noca, TaK KaK TaM
npomIIBaIDT TaK HaSbIBaeMble caCYHCRIIe apMHHe. TaKIIM 06paSOM, B COOT-
BeTCTBIIII C 3nOCOM MomHO 6bIJIO 6bI P;YMaTb, 'ITO OCHOBHoe HP;pO apMHHcRoro
Hapop;a CJIOmIIJIOCb IIMeHHO B 3TOH 06JIaCTII.
AnTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIH MaTepIIaJI B IJ;eJIOM nop;TBepmp;aeT 3TY TO'IRY speHHH.
IIepeJJ;HeasIIaTCKIIe aHaJIOrIIII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIM oc06eHHoCTHM cOBpeMeH-
HbIX apMHH 06IIJ;eIISBeCTHbI 29 . Op;HaKO IICCJIep;OBaHIIH P;BYX nOCJIep;HIIX p;eCHTII-
JIeTIIH nOKa3aJIII, 'ITO cneQII<pII'IeCKIIH KOMnJIeKC COMaTOJIOrH'IeCKIIX npiiSHa-
KOB, CBOHCTBeHHbIH apMHHaM, pacnpOCTpaHeH ropasp;o IIIIIpe, 'IeM npep;nOJIa-
raJIOCb paHbIIIe, II OXBaTbmaeT TaKme BOCTO'IHyro II IOmHYID fpYSIIIO 30.
Ero MeCTHoe npoIIcxomp;eHlIe ceiI'Iac, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, KameTCH eIIJ;e 60JIee
BepoHTHbIM. IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII IecKHe p;aHHble TaKme COOTBeTCTBYIDT npep;-
CTaBJIeHIIHM 0 MeCTHOM npoIIcxomp;eHHII aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKOrO Tiina apMHH.
HaCeJIeHIIe 3nOXII cpep;HeBeRoBbH B HIIX cJIa60 rrpep;CTaBJIeHO, HO IIO 3noxaM
179
paHHero meJIeSa, 6pOHSbI II 3HeOJIIITa eCTb MHOrO'IIICJIeHHble CepIIII 'Iepe-
nOB 31. XapaRTepHaH P;JIH COBpeMeHHbIX apMHH CIIJIbHaH 6paXIIRpaUIIH nQHB-
JIHeTCH TO bKO B 3nOAl! cpep;HeBeROBbH, npH'IeM II B cpep;HeBeROBbe OHa Bb
pameHa cJIa6ee, 'IeM B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH. llTO KacaeTCH APyrIIx TaK HaSbIBa-
eMbIX apMeUOIIp;HbIX oc06eHHocTeH - OCTporo JIIIIJ;eBoro npo<pIIJIH, ep;Ba Jill He
MaRCIIMaJIbHOrO no MHPOBOMY MacIIITa6y BblcTynaHIIH uoca II paSBIITIIH ne-
penOCbH, TO OHII OT'IeTJIIIBO <PIIKCIIPYIOTCH II B p;peBHIIX cepIIHX, 'ITO nOSBO-
JIHeT YBepeHHO rOBopHTb 0 npeeMCTBeHHOCTII HaCeJIeHIIH OT 3nOXII K 3IIoxe,
Ha'IIIHaH C 8HeOJIIITa. BHYTpeHHIIe MIIrpaIJ;HII B paSHble 3nOXII BepOHTHbI, He
IICRJIIO'IeHbI II IIHOpop;Hble BKJIIO'IeHIIH, IIJIJIIOCTpIIpyeMble naJIeOaUTpOnOJIOrII-
'IeCRIIMII p;aHHbIMII C IOmHoro H BOCTO'IHOrO n06epemIIH OS. CeBaH, HO OHII He
MeHHIOT 06meH KapTIIHbI 8TOH npeeMcTBeHHocTII. Ha OCHOBaHIIII naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p;aHHblx MecTHbIH reHeSIIC apMHHcKoro Hapop;a npOCJIemIIBaeT-
CH MIIUIIMYM P;O 3HeOJIIITII'IeCKOrO BpeMeHII.
II TaR, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIH BbIBOp; Haxop;IITCH B COOTBeTCTBIIII C <PO JIb-
KJIOpHOH TpagIIIJ;IIeH H TOJIbKO XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKII yrJIy6JIHeT reHeTII'IeCKYID
IIpeeMCTBeHHOCTb, HaMe'IeHHYID <pOJIbI\JIOpHbIM MaTepIIaJIOM. JIIIHrBHCTII'Ie-
CKIIe me p;aHHbIe HaXO):(HTCH B npOTHBOpe'IIIH H C aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII II C
<pOJIbKJIOpHbIMII. BOKpyr IIOJIOmeHIIH apMHHcKoro HSbIKa cpep;II gpyrIIx HSbI-
ROB p;OJIroe BpeMH 6bIJIII 60JIbIIIIIe cnopbI, HO nOCJIe pa60T H. H. Mappa OH
IIpaKTII'IeCKII 6esorOBOpO'IHO CTaJI BRJIIO'IaTbCH B 'IIICJIO MeCTHbIX RaBKascmIX
HSbIKOB. OP;IIH IIS KpynHeIIIIIIIX SHaTOKOB H IICCJIep;OBaTeJIeH HSbIKa B IICTOPII-
'IeCKOM acneKTe - r. KanaHIJ;HH HaSbIBaJI 3TH HSbIKII aJIapOp;IIHCKIIMII, HO
<paRTII'IeCRH KOHCTpYIIpyeMaH IIM aJIapOp;IIHCRaH HSbIKOBaH ceMbH, no cYIIJ;e-
CTBY, HII'IeM He OTJIII'IaJIaCb OT H<peTH'IeCKOH HSbIKOBOH ceMbII, CKOHCTpyrrpO':
BaHHOH MappOM 32. haBRaSCKIIe 3JIeMeIiTbI B apMHHCROM H3bIKe p;eHCTBIITeJIb-
HO CIIJIbHbI, II MHorHe IIS UIIX BepHO yRasaHbI B pa60Tax CTOpOHHIIROB 6es-
orOBOpO'IHOrO BRJIIO'IelIIIH apMHHCKoro HSbIKa B 'IIICJIO KaBRaSCRIIX 33.
O):(HaKO HapHp;y C 8TIIM (oc06eHHO IIOCJIe OCJIa6JIeHIIH rIIrrHosa KOHIJ;enIJ;IIII
H. H. Mappa) CyrrJ;eCTBOBaJIa TeHJJ;eHIJ;IIH C6JIIISIITb apMHHCKIIH HSbIK C IIHP;O-
eBponeHCKIIMII 3\ B Kpyry IIHp;oeBponeHCKOH ceMbH OH paCCMaTpIIBaJICH 'IaIIJ;e
Bcero RaK H30JIIIpOBaHHbIII 35 . B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH SHa'ieHIIe c06CTBeHHO
KaBRaSCRIIX 3JIeMeHTOB II B rpaMMaTIIRe II B JIeRCIIKe apMHHCRoro HSbIKa He
OTpIIQaeTCH, op;HaKO Bce C 60JIbIIIIIl\I OCHOBaHIIeM YTBepmp;aeTCH ero IIHp;oeB-
poneHCRaH npHHap;JIemHOCTb II BbIHBJIHIOTCH CBHSII C p;pyrIIMH IIHp;oeBponeH-
CKImm HSbIKaMII 36. TaRaH rrOSIIQIIH B OIJ;eUKe apMHHCKoro HSbIKa BbITeKaeT
IIS 60JIbIIIOH pa60TbI, IIpoBegeHHoH apMHHCKIIMII JIIIHrBIICTaMII sa nOCJIegHIIe
rop;bI. haK HSbIK IIH)J:oeBponeHCKIIH apMHHCKIIH HSbIK paCCMaTpIIBaeTCH II B
HOBeHIIIeM <pYHp;aMeHTaJIbHOM 06sope HSbIKOB HapO):(OB CCCP 37.
IIcCJIep;OBaHIIH gBYX rrOCJIep;HIIX fJ,eCHTIIJIeTIIH He TOJIbKO HSMeHIIJIII BSrJIHp;
Ha npIIpop;y II reHeTII IeCRIIe BsaIIMOOTHOIIIeHIIH apMHHCKoro HSbIKa, HO II nos-
BOJIIIJIII BHeCTH p;aJIbHeHIIIIIe YTO'IHeHIIH, HaMeTIm JIIIHIIIO ero reHeTII'IeCKIIX
CBHseH, IIJIII KOHTaRTOB, C p;peBHeHIIIIIMII HSbIKaMII BaJIRaHCROro nOJIYOCTPO-
.Ba, HanpIIMep <ppIIrnIICKIIM 38. IIpaBp;a, BbIHCHeHIIe KOHKpeTHbIX <pOPM 3TIIX
CBHseII, BIIP;IIMO, lIoTpe6yeT p;aJIbHeIUIIIIx gonOJIHIITeJIbHbIX IICCJIegoBaHIIII, HO
<paRT reHeTII'IeCRIIX ROHTaKTOB C ):(peBHIIMII HSbIKaMII BaJIKaHCKOro nOJIYOCT-
pOBa IIpiiSHaeTCH 6eccnopHbIM 39. TaKIIM 06paSOM, JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKaH IIH<pOP-
MaIJ;IIH Ha cOBpeMeHHoM ypoBHe ee IISY'IeHHH He TOJIbKO rrOSBOJIHeT YBHsaTb
apMHHCKIIH H3bIK C IIIIIpORIIM KpyroM IIH}:\oeBponeHCRIIX HSbIKOB, HO II YKaSbI-
BaeT Ha ero BOCTO'IUOCpep;IIseMHOMopCKoe rrpOIIcxomp;eHIIe. 8THoreHeTII'Ie-
CKlIH BbIBOP; II3 3Toro O'ieBIIp;eH: IIHp;oeBpOlIeIICKaH npIIHap;JIemHOCTb ap IHH-
CKoro H3bIKa YBO].l;IIT reHeSIIC apMHHCKoro Hapoga sa npep;eJIbI HbIrreIIIHeH
ApMeHIIII, TaK RaR Ap IHHcRoe Haropbe BPHP; Jill MOiliHO BRJIIO'IaTb B npapo-
180
P;Hny IIHp;OeBpOneHCKIIX HSbmOB, 'ITO KaCaeTCH ROHRpeTHO 6aJIRaHCRIIX CBHSeH,
TO OHH TeM 60JIee SaCTaBJIHIOT JJ;YMaTb 0 HeMeCTHOM npOIICXOm,[leHIIII apMHH.
HaJIIIQO TO me caMoe npOTIIBOpe'IIIe JIIIHrBHCTII'IeCmIX p;aHHbIX aHTpOnOJIOrII-
'IeCRIIM H <pOJIbKJIOpHbIM.
llTO CKasaTb 0 xapaRTepe 8Toro rrpOTIIBOpe'IIIH, He B):(aBaHCb nORa B ero
npII'IIIHbI? IIpii OQellKe cIITyaQIIII II l\1H npe]J;lIOJIaramI, 'ITO 60JIee ,[IpeBHHe
3TanbI 3THoreHesa nOJIIIHesIIHQeB CTepTbI B nRMHTII Hapop;a 60raTbIMII C06bI-
TIIHMII n03,,[IHeHIIIeH IICTOpIIII, ROTopble TOJII,RO II COXpaHIIJIIICb B 3THOreHem-
'IeCKIIX JIereugax. IIo OTHOIIIeHIIIO R 8THoreHesy apMHH MomHO cgeJIaTb TO me
npegnOJIOmeHIIe - C TOH TOJIbRO paSHIIQeH, 'ITO IIpe,[lIIIeCTBYIOIIJ;IIH 3Tan 3THO"
reHesa 6bIJI S,[IeCb MHorocTyneH'IaTI.IH: Oll BKJIIO'IaJI II 4>opr.mpOBaHne aHTpo.
IIOJIOrII'IeCROrO COCTaBa lIa MeCTHOH OCUOBe, II YCBoeHIIe HSbma, KOTOpbIH, II(
HOBeHIIIIIM p;aHHbIM, nOHBIIJICH B ApMeHIIII B Cepe,[lIIne I TI.ICH'IeJIeTIIH P;(.
H. 3. o 06e 3TII CTYIIeHII p;peBHellIIIero 8Tana 8THOreHesa BCKpbIBaIOTCH nOCJIe-
p;OBaTeJIbHO aUTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIMII II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCRIIMII iJ,aHHbIMII, HO He 8THO-
reHeTII'IeCKIIMII npep;aHIIHMII.
TeOpeTII'IeCKII BOSMomeH II npaKTII'IeCRII peaJIIIsyeTcH II npOTIIBOnOJIOm-
HI.III CJIY'IaH: IIMeHHO JIIIHrBIICTIIKa AaeT aprYMeHTbI B rrOJIbSY HesaBIICIIMoro
OT IIHOPOP;lIbIX BJIIIHHIIH MeCTHoro 3THoreHesa, II, HanpOTIIB, aHTpOnOJIOrIIH II
3THOreHeTII'IeCRIIe rrpep;aHIIH n03BO,TIHIOT peROHCTpYIIpOBaTb MIIrpaIJ;IIOHHbIH
npoQecc. IIpIIMep TOMy - 3TDoreHes aHHoB.
He BD;aBaHCb B p:eTaJIII ifJopMIIpoRaHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX oc06eHHocTeH
aIIHoB (KpIITII'IeCRIIH IITor MHorIIM npe,[lIIIecTByIOIIJ;IIM pa60TaM nO,[{BO}J;HT MO-
Horpa<pIIH M. r. JIeBIIHa u, cop;epmaIIJ;aH TaKme H 60JIbIIIOH caMOCTOHTeJIb-
HbIH MaTepIIaJI), OTMe'IY OCHOBUYIO cneQII<pIIKY alIHcRoro KOMnJIeKCa npiiSHa-
KOB. OHa COCTOHT B IICRJIIO'IIITeJIbHO CIIJIbHOM paSBIITIIII BOJIOCHHOro nOKpOBa,
BOJIHIICTOBOJIOCOCTII, nOTeMHeHIIII QBeTa Komii no cpaBHeHIIIO C oRpymaIOIIJ;II-
MIl aHHOB Hapop;aMII. Bce 3TO HeCOMHeHHble aprYMeHTbI B nOJIbSY IOmHI.IX
cBHseH aHuoB, TaK KaR aHaJIOrII'IHbIll KOMnJIeRC, ROHe'IHO CIIJII,Hee BblpameH-
IIbIII, xapaKTepeH ,[IJIH MeJIaHesIIHQeB, nanyacoB II aBCTpaJIIIHQeB. BosMomHo,
IWKlIe-TO ):(peBIIIIe npe,o:CTaBHTeJIH aBCTpaJIOIIp;HOH, IIJIII oKeaHIIHcRoH, BeTBII
HerpmUJ:HoH paCbI, IIpO,[{BIIHynIIIIICb Ha ceBep, H npIIHHJIH Y'IaCTIIe B CJIome-
UIIn CBOHCTBeHHOH COBpeMeHHI.IM aHHaM KOM6IIHaIJ;IIII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
rrpiiSHaROB. )J,PyrIIM 6eCCrrOpHI,IM ROMIIoneHTOM, npIIHHBIIIIIM Y'IaCTIIe B CMe-
IIIeHIIII, ObIJIa KaRaH-TO MOHrOJIOIIp;HaH ROM6IIHaIJ;IIH.
AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIe gaHHI.Ie Haxop;HTCH B nOJIHOM COrJIaCIIH C riinOTeSOM
IOiI\UOrO npmICXOiRJ];eHIIH aHHOB, rJIy60Ko apryMeHTIIpOBaHHOH JI. H. IIlTepH-
6eprOM 2. OH OnIIpaJICH B OCHOBHOM Ha 3THorpa<pII'IeCKYID apryMeHTaIJ;IIIO II
npIIBJIeR cpep;H CBOIIX conOCTaBJIeHIIH II 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe npe,[laHIIH aHHon
o nOHBJIeHIIII IIX C MOpH. IIpep;aHIIH 3TII O'IeHb CXOP;HbI C oKeaHIIHcKIIMII. 8TO
KaK pas TO, 'ITO IIHTepecyeT Hac B HaII60JIbIIIeH CTeneHII B p;aHHOM CJIY-
'Iae, - COBnap;eHIIe 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npep;aUIIH C aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIMH
Ha6JIIOp;eHIIHMII. llTO KacaeTCH nOJIOmeHIIH aHIICKoro HSbIKa cpegii p;pyrnx
HSbmOB, TO OH HBJIHeTCH nOJIHOCTbID IISOJIIIpOBaHHbIM, P;O CIIX nop eMy He 00-
HapymeHo y6eP;HTeJIbHbIX aHaJIOrHH HII B OP;HOM IIS HSbIKOB MIIpa 3. CaM no
ce6e 3TOT BbIBOg He eCTb nOJIHOe ,[IOKaSaTeJIbCTBO MeCTHoro npOIIcxomp;eHIIH
aHHCKoro HSbIRa, HO Bce me OTCYTCTBIIe aHaJIOrIIII JIer'Ie Bcero 06'bHCHIITb
IIMeHHO IIsomlpOBaHHI.IM <pOpMIIpOBaHIIeM B IIpep;eJIax TOH me TeppIITopHH,
r;a:e MbI saCTaeM HSI,m B HaCTOHIIJ;ee Bper.IH. IIaMHTYH 0 TOM, 'ITO 3THoreHeTII-
'IeCRlIe npe,[laHIIH B npep;bI}J;yrrJ;IIX CJIY'IaHX OTpamaJIII KaRIIe-TO cpaBHIITeJIb-
HO nOS,[IHIIe C06bITIIH, MomHO p;YMaTb, ITO IOmHble CBHSII aHHOB 6bIJIII IICTO-
pII'IeCKOH peaJIbHOCTbID eIIJ;e B cpaBHIITeJIbHO Hep;aBHee BpeMH. IIo'IeMy me
TorAa HSbm He COXpaHIIJI HaM HIIRaKIIX BocnoMIIHaHIIII 06 3TIIX CBHSHX?
181
Ep;IIHCTBeHHoe paSYMHOe 06'bHCHeHIIe H BHmy B Hep;OCTaTO'IDOH HSY'IeHHOCTIf
HSbIKOB IOro-BocTo'IHOH ASIIII II OKeaHIIII. IIpii CJIOmHOCTII IIX HSbmOBOrO
COCTaBa TPYP;HO nOpY'IIITbCH, 'ITO B 6YP;YIIJ;eM He 6YP;YT BCKpbITbI peaJIbHbIe
CBHSII aHHClwro HSbIKa C OP;HIIM IIS HSbIKOB IIJIH rpynnoH HSbmOB 8TOro paHO-
Ha. COMHeBaTbCH me B Y'IaCTIIII IOmHoro KOMIIOHeHTa B 3THoreHese aImOB He
npIIXO,[liiTCH.
CUTyalfuR IV. B 3TOM CJIY'Iae K He COrJIaCOBaHHbIM C gpyrHMII p;aHHbIMIf
SaRJIIO'IeHIIHM npHBop;IIT aHTpOnOJIOrIIH. IIpH TaKOM HeCOrJIaCOBaHIIII IICTOPH-
RII IIHorp;a IIIIIIIYT 0 HeCTa6IIJIbHOCTH aHTponOMeTpII'IeCKIIX xapaKTepIICTIIK,
ne06'beRTIIBHOCTII aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX Ha6JIIOp;eHIIH, aprYMeHTIIpYH ::ITO CJIY-
'IaHHbIMH cpaBHeHIIHlIIII 6JIIISRIIX BapIIaIJ;IIH OT,[IeJIbHbIX npiiSHaKOB II T. ,[I.U
MbI He 6yp;eM CJIep;OBaTb sa 3TIIMII cymp;eHIIHMH H paCCMOTpIIM STy HeCOrJIa-
COBaHHOCTb KaK peaJIbHO CYIIJ;eCTBYIOIIJ;ee HBJIeHIIe, OTpamaIOIIJ;ee KaKlle-TO
CTOpOHbI HCTOpII'IeCROH p;eIICTBIITeJIbHOCTII.
TaKoe HeCOOTBeTCTBIIe aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX p;aHHbIX JIHHrBIICTII'IeCRIIlII
Ha6JIIOgeHIIHM II 8THOreHeTII'IeCRIIM npep;aUIIHM MbI IIMeellI B CJIY'Iae 3TUOre-
Hesa oceTIIH. MHe yme npIIXop;IIJIOCb ,[IOBOJIbHO nop;p06uo BbICRaSbIBaTbCH no
8TOH np06JIeMe 20 JIeT Hasap; 45. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKII oceTIIIIbl, HeCOMHeHIlO,
TIInH'IHbIe HOCIITeJIII Toro KOMnJIeRCa npiiSHaROB, KOTOpbIII OXBaTbmaeT Hapo-
gbI, HaCeJIHIOIIJ;He QeHTpaJIbUble IIpep;ropbH rJIaBHOrO KaBRascRoro xpe6Ta.
3a IICRJIIO'IeHHeM 6aJIRapIJ;eB II Kapa'IaeBQeB, 8THOreHes KOTOpbIX no cBoeMy
TIIny, RaR MbI YBIIP;IIM p;aJIbIIIe, cxop;eH C 8THoreHeSOM OCeTlIU, Bce 3TII Hapo-
D,bI rOBopHT Ha OJUWM IIS KaBRaSCKIIX HSbIKOB. TaKIIM 06paSOM, KOMnJIeKC
npiiSHaROB, 0 KOTOpOM IIp;eT pe'Ib,- MeCTHbIH, KaBRaSCKIIH, 'ITO OTpaSIIJIOCb
II B HaIIMeHOBaHIIII ero KaBRaCIIOHCRIIM 46. IIpIIHa):(JIemHOCTb K 8TOMy KOMn-
JIeKcy cBII):(eTeJIbCTByeT 0 <pOpMIIpoBamIH aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCROrO COCTaBa Hapo-
1J;a Ha gpeBHeD: MecTHoH OCHOBe, CJIe,[lOBaTeJIbHO, oceTIIHbI CBHsaHbI HenpepbIB-
HOH npeeMCTBeHHOCTbID nOROJIeHnH C p;peBHIIM MeCTHbIM HaCeJIeHIIeM QeHT-
paJIbHbIX npep;ropIIH rJIaBHOrO KaBRascKoro xpe6Ta.
B IICTOpII'IeCKOH JIlITepaType IIIIIpOKIIM pacnpocTpaHeHIIeM nOJIbsyeTcH
KOHQenIJ;IIH He KaBKaSCRoro, a IIpaHCKoro npOIIcxomp;eHIIH oceTIIH. II paBp;a,
IICTOpIIKII He CTaBHT CeH'IaC SHaK paBeHCTBa Memp;y oceTIIHaMII II IIpaHO-
HSbI'IHbIMII aJIaUaMII - CpC,[IueBeROBbIM HaCeJIeHIIeM ceBepORaBKaSCKHX CTe-
neH, RaK 3TO 6bIJIO p;Ba-Tpii ,[IeCHTIIJIeTIIH nasap; 47, HO Bce me IIpaHCKIIH KOM-
nOHeHT B oceTIIHCKOM 3THoreHese 06'bHBJIHeTCH npe06JIap;aIOIIJ;HM 48. OCTaB-
JIHH B CTopOHe CBep;eHIIH, HSBJIeKaeMble IIS IICTOpH'IeCRIIX IICTO'IHIIROB, KOTO-
pble IIOKa p;aIOT B03MomHOCTb P;JIH car.WH pasHo06paSHOII IIHTepnpeTaIJ;IIH,
HymHo CRasaTb, 'ITO rJIaBHbIM OCHOBaHIIeM P;JIH TaKIIX B3rJIH,[IOB OCTaeTCH 6ec-
crropHaH npIIHa,[lJIemHOCTb oceTIIHCKoro HSbma R IIpaHCKOH HSbIKOBOH CeMbe.
IIpaB):(a, RpynHeHIIIIIH IICCJIep;OBaTeJIb oceTIIHCRoro HSbma B. II. A6aeB BbI-
HBIIJI B HeM SHa'IIITeJIbHbIH MeCTHbIH cy6cTpaT 49, RaK OH c,[IeJIaJI 3TO II no OT-
HOIIIemIIO R <pOJIbRJIOPy 50. Ho Bce paBHO 3TOT cy6cTpaT He MeUHeT B OCUOB-
HOM IIpaHCKoro xapaKTepa oceTIIHCRoro HSbma. OceTIIHCRIIH 8noc «HapTb!>}
ogHoBpeMeUHO npep;CTaBJIeH y MHorIIX Hapop;OB CeBepHoro naBKasa H sanag-
HbIX paHOHOB 3aKaBKaSbH, HO Bce me ero HeMeCTHoe, aJIaHCKOe npOHcxomp;e-
HIIe BeCbMa BepOHTHO 5'.
AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe oc06eHHOCTH oceTIIH CBII,[IeTeJIbCTBYIDT 0 MeCTUbIX
IICTORax 3THoreHesa Ha ero p;peBHeHmeM 3Tane; nepexop; Ha IIpaHCRyID pe'Ib
H YCBoeHIIe IIpaHCROH KYJIbTYPbI ('ITO B IJ;eJIOM 6eCCIIopHO II p;eMOHCTpIIPy-
eTCH QeJIOH cepIIeH 3THorpa<pII'IeCKIIX Ha6JIIOp;eHIIH Hag caMbIMII paSHbIMIf
CTopOHaMH oceTIIHCROH KYJIbTypbI 52) MOrJIII npOIICXO)J:IITb II 6e3 SHa'IIITeJIb-
Horo BRJIIO'IeHIIH IIHopop;Horo HaCeJIeHIIH. TaKIIM 06paSOM, Bce TPII KaTeroplIH
paCCMaTpIIBaCMbIX HaMH <paKTOB OTpamaIDT peaJIbHble C06bITIIH 3THoreHesa II
182
'3THH'IeCKOH IICTOpIIII OCeTIIHCKOrO HapOp;a, HO C06bITIIH 8TH OTUOCHTCH K paa-
HbIM 3TanaM ero IICTOpIIII: Te, KOTopble OTpamaIOTCH B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM
COCTaBe, - JJ;peBHelIIIIIIe, aTe, KOTopble peROHCTpYIIPYIOTCH nplI rrOMOIIJ;1I
JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX II 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npep;aUIIH, - 60JIee nosp;HIIe.
Cocep;HIIe C oceTIIHaMII TIOpKOHSbI'IHble Hapop;bI - 6aJIKapIJ;bI II Kapa'IaeB-
IJ;bI CXOP;HbI C HIIMII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKII. IIM CBOHCTBeHHbI Te me npiiSHaKlI,
op;HOBpeMeHHO TIInII'IHble P;JIH QeHTpaJIbHOKaBKascKIIx Hapop;OB MeCTHoro npo-
IIcxomp;eHIIH 53. IIo aHaJIOrIIII C oceTIIHaMII 3TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO TPYP;HO IIC-
TOJIKOBaTb IIHa'Ie, RaR CBIIlIeTeJIbCTBO MeCTHoro, RaBRaSCKoro npoIIcxomgeHIIH
6aJIRapQeB II Kapa'iaeBIJ;eB 5 . B IIX HSbIRe H. H. MappoM II B. II. A6aeBbIM
BbIHBJIen MecTHbIH, KaBKaSCRIIII cy6cTpaT 55, HO B QeJIOM ero rrpIIHap;JIem-
HOCTb K TIOpRCKOH HSbIROBOII ceMbe 6eccnopua, II BHYTPII 8TOH ceMbii OH sa-
HIIMaeT paBHonpaBHoe MeCTO PH):(OM C P;PyrIIMH TIOpRCKIIMII HSbIKaMII 56.
HapHgy C HapTcRIIM 3nOCOM Y 6aJIRapQeB II Kapa'IaeBQeB eCTb eCJIII He 3T-
HoreHeTII'IeCRIIe B nOJIHOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa, TO <paMIIJIbHble npep;aHIIH, CBHSbI-
BaIOIIJ;IIe npoIIcxomgenne OTp;eJIblIbIX ceMelI C TIOpROHSbI'IHbIMII Hapo):(aMII
ceBepOKaBKaaCKIIx CTeneII, npomIIBaBIIIIIMII TaM B 8noxy cpep;HeBeROBbH 57.
CJIe)J.OBaTeJIbHO, H s):(eCb aHTpOnOJIOrHH rOBopIIT 0 MeCTHOM, a JIIIHrBHCTIIKa
1I <pOJIbKJIOp - 0 npIIIIIJIOM npOIICXOlliJ];eHIIII Hapop;a. II B 8TOM CJIy'Iae npo-
TIIBOpe'IIIe MemJJ;y paSHbIMII IICTOpII'IeCKIIMH IICTO'IHIIKaMH JIerKO nOUHTb,
eCJlII npep;nOJImIITb, 'ITO OHII OTpamaIDT paSHble 3TanbI IICTOplIII 6aJIKapIJ;eB
H Kapa'iaeBIJ;eB: aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p;aHHble - p;peBHeHIIIIIH 3Tan, JIIIHrBH-
CTIIRa II <pOJIbIWOP - nosp;HeHIIIIIH, OCyrrJ;eCTBIIBrrmHCH 6ea SHa'IIITeJIbHbIX
6pa'IHbIX KOHTaRTOB C IIUOpOP;HbIM TIOpROHSbI'IHbIM HaCeJIeHIIeM, HO nop; ero
DrpOMHbIM KYJIbTypHbIM BJlIIHHHeM.
B cIITyaQIIII IV BOSMomHO H TaKoe nOJIOmeHIIe, Korp;a HMeHHO aHTpono-
JIOrII'IeCKIIe ):(aHHble HaBop;HT Ha MbICJIb 0 npIIIIIJIOM npoIIcxom,geHIIII, Torp;a
RaK JIIIHrBIICTIIKa H 3THoreHeTII'IeCKHe npep;aHIIH nOMoraIDT npOCJIep;HTb
MeCTHbIe IICTOKH 8THoreHesa. IIpIIMepoM MomeT CJIymIITb 8THoreHeTII'IeCKaH
HH<popMaIJ;IIH 06 3CKIIMocax. OHa ceiI'Iac p;OBOJIbHO nOJIHa, OXBaTbmaeT nO'ITII
Bce TeppiiTOpIIaJlbHble rpynnbI 3CKIIMOCOB, paa6pocaHHble no orpOMHOMy apea-
JIY OT Kpa-iiHero ceBepO-BOCTOKa ASIIII P;O rpeUJIanp;IIII, H p;onYCKaeT XpOHO-
JIOrH'IeCKOe p;aTIIpoBaHIIe 6JIarOp;apH xopOIIIeMY COCTOHHIIIO apXeOJIOrII'IeCKOH
)J;ORYMeHTaQIIII.
H. H. lle60RcapOB BbICRaSbIBaJI nJIOp;OTBOPHYID np;eIO 0 pacnap;e p;peBHeH
MOHrOJIOIIp;HOH 06IQHOCTII Ha p;Ba CTBOJIa-TIIXOoKeaHcKIIx H KOHTIIHeHTaJIb-
HbIX MOHrOJIOIIp;OB 58. 8Ta IIp;eH nOJIY'IIIJla npIISHaHIIe BO MHorIIX nOCJIeJJ;YIO-
IIJ;IIX KJIaCCII<pIIRaQIIHX MOHrOJIOIIp;HOH paCbI H B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH nOJIbsyeT-
CH nop;p;epmROH cpep:n COBeTCKIIX aHTpOnOJIOrOB 59. COrJIaCHO aTOH IIp;ee, apK-
TII'IeCKIIe MOHrOJIOIIp;bI 06'bep;IIHHIOTCH II TaKCOHOMII'IeCKII II reHeTH'IeCKII C
IOmHbIMII II BOCTO'IHbIMII, 06pasYH TIIxooKeaHcRIIH CTBOJI H npoTIIBonocTaB-
JIHHCb KOHTIIHeHTaJIbHbIM rpynnaM MOHrOJIOIIgHblx nonYJIHQIIH. COMaTOJIOrII-
'IeCRlIe aprYMeHTbI B nOJIbsy TaKoro 06'bep;IIHeHIIH - cpaBHIITeJIbHO TeMHaH
Koma y 3CKIIMOCOB, KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe aprYMeHTbI - SHa'IIITeJIbHbIH 06IIJ;llH
II aJIbBeOJIHpHbIH rrporHaTIIsM Ha 3CRIIMOCCRIIX 'Iepenax. TaRIIM 06pasoM,
aHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCKIIe oc06eHHocTII 3cmIMocoB, HecoMHeHHo, yKasbIBaIDT Ha HX
IOmHoe npoIIcxomp;eHIIe.
8CKIIMOCCKIIH HSbIK 06'bep;IIHHeTcH C aJIeYTcRIIM B IISOJIIIpOBaHHYID 3CKO-
aJIeYTcRyID ceMbID 60. 06a HSbIRa 06HapymHBaIDT peaJIbHble rpaMMaTII'IeCKIIe
II JIeRCII'IeCKIIe napaJIJIeJIII, HO He IIMeIOT HHKaKIIX aHaJIOrIIH C p;pyrlIMII HSJ:.I-
KaMII. IIx IISOJIIIpOBaHHoe nOJIOmeHHe HaBop;IIT Ha MbICJIb, 'ITO 8CKIIMOCCKIIH
HSbIR, a C HIIM H Hapop; 06paSOBaJIHCb rp;e-TO B rrpep;eJIax Toro me apeaJIa,
KOTOpbIH OHH saHIIMaIDT B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH, II 'ITO IIHOpop;Hble BJIHHHIIH IIr-
183
pamI B IIX CTaHOBJIeHlI1I MfIHIIMaJIbHYro pOJIb. 8THoreHeTII'IeCRIIe npep;aHIIJl
8CKIIl\IOCOB, oc06eHHo 6oraTo npep;CTaBJIeHHbIe B ny6JIIIKaIJ;IIHX K. PacMycce-
Ha 61, TaKme He BbIBOP;HT 3CKIIl\IOCOB sa npeJJ:eJIbI IIX HbIHeIIIHero apeaJIa.
Y HeROTopbIX TeppIITOplIaJIbHbIX rpynn 3CKIIMOCOB, HanpIIMep, Y 3CRIIl\IOCOB
TIIrapbI, eCTb npep;aHIIH 0 npIIIIIeJIbIJ;aX, ROTOpbIMII nyraroT p;eTeH; JII060nbIT-
HO, 'ITO Y npIImeJIbIJ;eB KaMeHHbIe rJIaaa, a IICKYCCTBeHHbIe rJIasa B op6IITax
HeCROJIbRIIX 'IepenOB HallJJ:eHbI B norpe6eHIIHX Py6ema HameH 3pbI B IImIY-
TaI\:CROM MOrIIJIbHIIRe, pacnOJIOmeHHOM 6JIIIS TIIrapbI 62. Ho npIIIIIeJIbIJ;bI B
3TIIX npe):(aHfIHX BocnpIIHIIMaIOTCH He KaR JIIO):(II, 'Iym):(bIe 3CRIIMocaM II IIMeIO-
IIJ;IIe COBepIIIeHHO OTJIII'IHOe OT 8CIUlMOCOB npOIIcxom):(eHIIe, a RaR JIIO)XII,
'Iym):(bIe JIIIIIIb ):(aHHOM TeppIITOpIIaJIbHOH rpynne; BO BCHKOM CJIyqae, B npe-
p;aHIIHX HeT cBe):(eHlIH 06 IIX IIHOH 3THII'IeCKOH npIIHaJJ:JIemHOCTII. CJIe):(oBa-
TeJIbHO, HSbIK II JIereHp;bI 0 npOIIcxom)XeHfIII JIer'Ie IIHTepnpeTlIpOBaTb B paM-
Kax aBToxToHHOH, a He MIIrpaIJ;IIOHIIOH rIInOTeSbI 3CKIIMOCCKoro 3THoreHesa.
KaK MOrJIa cos,rraTbCH TaRaH CIuyaIJ;IIH, npII KOTOpOH B naMHTII Hapop;HOH
He COXpaHIIJIOCb HIIRaKIIX BocnOMIIHaHIIH 0 nepece eHIIII IIS p;pyrIIX 06JIa-
cTeH? Ee MomHO 06'bHCHIITb TOJIbRO O)XHIIM - TeM, 'ITO rrepeCeJIeHIIe npOIISO-
IIIJIO OqeHb p;aBHO II sa npOIIIep;IIIee nOCJIe Hero BpeMH He TOJIbKO HapO}J;HaH
naMHTb ycneJIa sa6bITb 0 HeM, HO II HSbIK ycneJI npII06peCTII RpaHnIDID CTe-
lIeHb cBoe06paSIIH. JIeKcIIKo-CTaTIICTII'IeCKIIe cnoc06bI p;aTlIpoBaHIIH BpeMemT
pacxomp;eHIIH pO):(CTBeHHbIx HSbIKOB )J;aIOT ):(JIH 3CRIIMOCCKoro II aJIeYTCKoro
p;aTY B 3000 JIeT, T. e. py6em II II I TbICH'IeJIeTIIH P;O H. 3. 63 COBpeMeHHble
apXeOJIOrII'IeCRlIe OTRpbITIIH YBO):(HT IICTORII 3CRIIl\IOCCROH KYJIbTYPbI TaKme B
rJIy60KYID ):(peBHOCTb 6". IIOMIIMO apXeOJIOrII'IeCRIIX MaTepIIaJIOB, JIDIIIb aHT-
pOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe oc06eHHocTH P;OHOCHT ):(0 Hac naMHTb 0 npOIIcxo,rrIIBmIIX IIC-
TOpII'IeCKIIX C06bITIIHX, B 'IaCTHOCTII 0 nepeCeJIeHlI1I C IOra [...]
CuryalfuH VIII. COBna)J;aIOT nOKasaHlIH Bcex Tpex aHaJIIISIIpyeMblx HaMII
BIIP;OB IICTOpII'IeCRIIX IICTO'IHllKOB. 8Ta cIITYaIJ;IIH cosp;aeTCH B xo.rre cpaBHII-
TeJIbHO npOCToro 3THoreHesa, II 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe C06bITIIH peRoHcTpYIIPYIOT-
CH B 3TOM CJIY'Iae C lIaIIMeHbnmMII saTpygHeHIIHMII. MomHo 6bIJIO 6bI npIIBe-
CTII P;OBOJIbUO MHoro npIIMepOB COBnap;eHIIH paSJIII'IHbIX p;aHHbIX, HO MbI
orpaHII'IIIMCH OgHIIM, BbI6paB ero sa nOJIHOTY HaKOnJIeHHOH yme CeH'IaC IIH-
<popMaIJ;IIII. Pe'Ib IIp;eT 0 HRYTax. Ha OCHOBaHIIII TOJIbKO IICTOpII'IeCKIIX CBIIp;e-
Te bCTB MomHO nOJIaraTb, 'ITO 06JIaCTb paCCeJIeHIIH HRYTOB no JIeHe II e&
npIITORaM nOCTOHHHO YBeJIII'IIIBaJIaCb Ha npOTHmeHIIII nOCJIe)XHIIX CTOJIeTIIH 65.
A. II. ORJIa,rrHlIROB, CYMMIIpOBaB caMbIe pasHo06pasHbIe p;aHHbIe, HapIICOBaJI
O'IeHb y6eWITeJIbuyIO Ra PTIIHY 3THoreHesa HRYTOB, IIX <pOpMupoBaHlIH Ha oc-
HOBe TaK HaSbIBaeMbIX RypMRaHCI{llX nJIeMeH, npomIIBaBnmx B CeBepHoM
IIpIIOaHRaJIbe II 3a6aHRaJIbe, II IIX nOCTeneDHoro paCCeJIeHIIH no JIeHe C IOra
Ha ceBep, saHHTIIH IIMII HIImHero Te'IeHIIH RpynHblx II MeJIRIIX npIITOROB JIe-
HbI 66. 8TII rrpOIJ;eCCbI rrOJJ;p06HO npOCJIemeHbI apXeOJIorlI'IeCRII II oCBeIIJ;eHbI
IICTOpII1IeCRIIMII IICTOlIHfIKaMII. Ho CYIIJ;ecTBeHHYID pOJIb B ):(oRaSaTeJIbCTB&
IOmHoro npOIIcxom):(eHllH HRYTOB IIrpaeT B Tpy):(ax A. II. ORJIa,rrHfIKOBa II
HRYTCI\:IIH <pOJIbRJIOp. IIpep;aHIIR HKYTOB 06 IIX npOIIcxom)XeHIIII PIICYIOT rra-
HopaMY O'IeHb nmpORIIX II MHorOCTopOHHIIX CBHseH C IOrOM 67. IIpIIHa):(JIem-
HOCTb HI{YTCIwro HSbma R ceMbe TIOpRCRIIX HSbIKOB, B IJ;eJIOM pacnpOCTpaHeH-
HOII IOmHee II sanap;Hee, Ta'Kme ):(ORaSaTeJIbCTBO IOmHoH OCHOBbI HRYTCKoro
3THoreHesa.
Ho HRYTbI He):(oCTaTO'IHO XOpOIIIO IIsY'IeHbI B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCROM OTIIOIIIe-
HIIII. CTapbIe ny6mIKaIJ;IIII r. JI. reKRepa, <D. H. KOHa II II. II. MaHHOBa H6
MorYT Y):(OBJIeTBOpIITb Hac CeH'IaC B MeTOp;II'IeCROM OTHomeHIIII 68 . Han60JIee
nO HbIe no MaTepIIaJIY pa60TbI M. r. JIeBIIHa II II. M. 30JIOTapeBoII HBJIHIOT-
CH npe):(BapIITeJIbHbIMII ny6JIfIKaIJ;IIHMII II p;aIOT JIIIl!Ib O'IeHb 0606IIJ;eHnyID xa-
184
paI{TepIICTIIKY HaCeJIeHIIIO OT)J;eJIbHbIX paHOHOB 69. HaCeJIeHlIe lOamoH HRY-
TlUl IICCJIep;OBaHO nOKa TOJIbRO B O}J;HOM nOCeJIRe 70. Bce me MOIRHO YTBep-
IR)XaTb, 'ITO HRYTbI B IJ;e:rOM, XOTH II BRJIIO'IfIB B ce6a RaRIIe-TO 3JIeMeHTbI
cy6cTpaTHoro npOIIcxomp;eHIIH, npIIHa):(JIemaT Tel\I He MeHee R IJ;eHTpaJIbHO-
aSIIaTCKOII rpyrrne nonYJIHIJ;IIH - TOH caMOH, K KOTOpOH nplIHap;JIemaT 6YPH-
TbI II TYBIIHIJ;bI. POP;CTBO HRYTOB C 6YPHTa III nO]J;TBepIR]J;aeTCH II RpaUfIO.:IO-
TII'IeCRII 71. TaRIIM 06pasoM, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCI\:IIH l\IaTepIIaJI rrpIIBOIUIT R Ta-
ROMY IRe TO'IHO BbIBOP;Y, 'ITO II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCRIIe Ha6JIIO):(eHIlH II <pOJIbKJIOp.
COBna)J;eUIIe BbIBOP;OB, BbITeRaIOIIJ,IIX lIS paSHbIX Ha6JIIOJJ:eHIlH, 06'bHcHHeT-
CH B )J:aHHOM CJIY'Iae, nO-BIlgIIl\IOMY, TeM, 'ITO MbI IIMeel\I ):(eJIO C npOIJ;eCCaMII
cpaBnIITeJIbHO HerJIy60RoH ):(peBHOCTII, OTCTOHIIJ;IIMII OT COBpel\IeHHOCTIl Ha TbI-
CH'IeJIeTlIe, MHoro Ha nOJITOpa. ECTeCTBeHHO, qTO npII 3TOM Be TOJIbRO aHTpo-
nOJIOrIIqeCKaH II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKaH xapaKTeplICTIIRII Hapop;a, OTHOCIITeJIbHO
cTa6IIJIbHbIe (oc06eHHo nepBaH), OCTaIOTCH HeIISlVIeHHbIMII, HO II npe):(aHIIH
Bapop;a 0 CBoeM npOIIcxOlli)XeHIIII oTpamaIOT IJ;eJIbHYIO KapTIIHY 3THoreHesa,
a He ee OTp;eJIbHbIe p;eTaJID, xpOnOJIOrII'IeCRII rrpIIYpO'IeHHbIe R nosp;HeIIIIIIIl\I
BTarraM 3THoreHesa. CTeneHb COrJIaCIIH peSYJIbTaTOB paSHbIX BIIP;OB IICTOPII-
-qeCI\:oro IICCJIep;OBaHIIH, HaIJ;eJIeHHOrO Ha peIIIeHIIe 3THoreHeTIIqeCKIIX npo6JIeM,
eCTb, O'ieBIIp;HO, <PYHRQIIH XpOHOJIOrIIII 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npOIJ;eCCOB.
Ilrozo6ble aaMelfaHUH. IlTaK, nepep; HannlMII rJIaSaMII npOIIIJIII nHTb BOS-
MomHbIX cIIryaIJ;IIH, C KOTOpbIMII MbI CTaJIRIIBael\ICH B 3THoreHeTIIQeCKIIX IIC-
CJIe):(OBaRIIHX nplI cpaBHeHIlII BbIBOP;OB lIS Tpex paSHbIX BIIP;OB IICTO'IHIIROB:
aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX MaTeplIaJIOB, JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX II 3THoreHeTII'Ie-
CRIIX npep;aHIIH. MomHO 6bIJIO 6bI saMeTIITb, 'ITO nOCJIep;HlIe 'IaIIJ;e Bcero OC-
BeIl\aIOT KaRIIe-TO cpaBHIITeJIbHO nosp;HIIe 3TanbI 3THoreHesa, Torp;a RaR Ha
DCHOBaHIIII nepBbIX ):(BYX IICTO'IHIIROB l\IOIRHO CYAIlTb 0 ero paHHIIX CTa):(IIJIX.
B JIIITeparype pacnpOCTparreHa TeH):(eHIJ;llH CnOplITb 0 cpaBHIITeJIbHOH 3<p-
$eKTIIBHOCTII paSHbIX BII)XOB IICTopII-qeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIKOB, Kor):(a pe'Ib IIp;eT 06
3THII'IeCRIIX np06JIeMax, npII'IeM cnop 'IaIIJ;e Bcero peIIIaeTCH B nOJIbSY Toro
nCTOpII'IeCROrO IICTO'IHfma, KaI\:IIl\I rrpo<peccIIOHaJIbUO BJIa):(eeT aBTOp 72. 0):(-
HaRO caMa nOCTaHOBRa Borrpoca KameTCH ynpoIIJ;eHHoII: 8THorenes HaCTOJIbRO
CJIOIRHbIH II l\IHOrOCToponHIIH npoQecc, TeppfITOpIIaJIbHbIe II XpOHOJIOrIPIeCRIIe
paMKII ero IICCJIe):(OBaHIIH TaR mIIpORII, "ITO HeJIbSH naSBaTb RaROH-TO pe-
malOIIJ;IIH <paKTOp B ero ):(fIHaMIIRe II BbI6paTb rJIaBHYIO onopy B ero peKOH-
CTPYI\:IJ;IIII. IIepcneRTIIBHee P;PyroH nop;xo):(, OTpaIRaIOIIJ;IIH p;1I<p<pepeHIJ;IlpOBaH-
HYlO OIJ;eHRY paSHbIX TIIIIOB IICTOPfPIeCIUIX IICTO"IHIIKOB B SaBIICIIl\IOCTII OT
TeppIITOpIIaJIbHbIX YCJIOBIIii II XpOHOJIOrII'IeCmIX 06CTOHTeJIbCTB.
llTO MomHO CRasaTb npII TaROM no):(xo):(e 0 paCCMaTplIBael\IbIX HaMII
IICTOpII'IeCRIIX IICTO'IHIIRax? CTaOII.TIbHOCTb aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX xapaRTe-
pIICTIm, oc06eHHO no l\IOp OJIOrII'IeCRIIM npIISHaRaM, yme HeO]J;HORpaTHO OT-
Me"IaJIaCb II 06'bHcHHeTcH IIX cJIa60H nO):(BepmeHHOCTbIO HanpaBJIeHHOH ce-
JIeRIJ;IIII II B TO IRe BpeMH ):(OCTaTO'IHO 'IeTRO BbIpameHHOH HaCJIep;CTBeIIUOH
OCHOBOH. II03TOl\IY OHD npIIrogbI ):(JIH XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKII O'IeHb rJIyOOKIIX pe-
ROHCTPYRIJ;IIH, P;JIH BOCCTaHOBJIeHIIH IIJIII ):(JIH <pIIRCaIJ;IIH II OIJ;eIIRII MaCIIITa-
60B l\IIIrpaIJ;IIII HaCeJIeHIlH B 8noxy RaMHH II 6poHsbI. Ho TaKaH cTa6IIJIb-
HOCTb II TOT <paRT, 'ITO RaRIIe-TO acneRTbI 8THOreHeTIPIeCKIIX npOQeCCOB
MorYT He saTparIIBaTb aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIH COCTaB (HanpIIMep, nepe):(a-qa
HSbma IIJIII OT):(eJIbHbIX RYJIbTypHbIX 8JIeMeHTOB), IIlVIeIOT II CBOIO OTpIIIJ;aTeJIb-
HYIO CTOpOHy; B aHTpOnOJIOrIpIeCI\:IIX oc06eHHOCTHX 'IaCTO cJIa60 OTpamaIOT-
CH C06bITIIH He):(aBHero npomJIoro, no MacIIITa6aM CBOIIM CpaBHIIl\IbIe C C06bI-
TIIHMII rJIy60KOH p;peBHOCTII IIJIII p;ame npeBOCXO):(HIIJ;IIe IIX, HO He saTpOHYB-
mIle aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO COCTaBa IIJIIl He ycneBnnle eIl\e IISMeIUITb ero.
II08TOl\IY neT a6COJIIOTHOrO OTBeTa Ha Bonpoc 0 SHaQeHlI1I aHTpOnOJIOrIIQe-
185
.,
I
CKIIX p;aHHbIX B 3THOreHeTII'IeCROM IICCJIep;OBaHIIII: OHO BeJIIIRO, KOrp;a pe'Ib
IIp;eT 0 paHHIIX 8TanaX 3THOreHeSa, II 'IaCTO YMeHbIIIaeTCH B peROHCTpYR-
IJ;IIII nOSp;HIIX ero 3TanOB.
II pOTDBOnOJIOlliHbIH rrOJIIOC SaHIIl\IaIOT, nO-BII):(I1MOMY, 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe
rrpe):(aHIIH. OHII co):(epmaT ):\parOIJ;eHHble cBegeHIlH 0 C06bITIIHX, OTCTOHIIJ;IIX
OT COBpeMeHHOCTII Ha cpaBHIITeJIbHO HeOOJIbITIOM XpOHOJIOrII'IeCROM paCCTOH-
HIIII, HO, MomeT 6bITb, n03TOl\IY II He <pIIRcIIPyeMblx p;pyrIIl\III IICTO'IHIIRaMII,
TaK KaR OHD ue ycneBaIOT IISMeHIITb COOTBeTCTBYIOIIJ;lIe 3TIIII'IeCRIIe xapaR-
TepIICTliKII. OIWH'IaTeJIbHOe <pOpl\IIIpOBaHlIe 3THII'IeCROrO JIIIIJ;a MHorIIX Hapo-
):(OB na):(aeT Ha 8noxy cpe)XHeBeROBbH II ):(ame Ha OOJIee rrOS)XHee BpeMH,
n03TOMY ):(JIH IIX 3THoreHesa (HanpIIMep, BOCTO'IHbIX CJIaBHH, MOIIrOJIOB II oy-
pHT, HeROTopbIX HapO):(OB CeBepHoro KaBKasa, TYBliHIJ;eB II HapO):(OB AJITaH
Ii T. p;.) 'IpeSBbI'IaIIHO BamHbI COObITIIH I1X nOS):(HeH IICTOpIIlI, npaRTII'IeCKII
nOCJIe):(Hero TbICH'IeJIeTIIH. IIal\IHTb 06 3TIIX C06bITIIHX xopomo coxpaHHIOT
3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIe npe):\aHIIH. To OOCTOHTeJIbCTBO, 'ITO JIereDp;bI 0 npOIIcxom-
p:eHIIII HapO):(OB ):(OXO):(HT ):(0 Hac, RaK rrpaBIIJIO, B ):(e<popr.IIIpOBaHHOl\I BII)Xe,
He p;eJIaeT 3TOT BII):( IICTO'IHIIRa MeHee SHa'IIIMbIM. JIIOoble ):(ome)XlliIIe ):(0 Hac
lIS npOIIIJIOrO MaTepIIaJIbI TaRme He nOJIHOCTblO OTpamalOT ):(eIICTBIITe.TIbHOCTb
II TpeOYIOT KpIITII'IeCKOrO aHaJIIIsa.
JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCRIIe ):(aHHbIe saHIIMaIOT npm1elliYTO'IHOe nOJIOmeHIIe. HaJIII-
TIlle IIIICbMeHHbIX nal\IHTHIII\:OB npIIJJ;aeT eMY XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKYIO nepcneRTIIBY.
YXOP;HIIJ;YIO B 3noxy nOS):(HeH OpOHSbI, HO npaKTII'IeCRII CROJIb-HIIOY):(b nOJIes-
HaH IIH<popMaIJ;IIH, ROTopaH MomeT ObITb MOOIIJIIISOBaHa B 3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIX
IJ;eJIHX, CYllJ;eCTByeT TOJIbRO na'IIIHaH C I TbICH'Ie.TIeTIIH P;O H. 8., T. e.
C 3noXII paHHero meJIesa. TOJIbKO C 8Toro BpeMeHII II ROH'IaH 3nOXOH nos)X-
Hero cpe):(HeBeROBbH, nO-BII)XIIMOMY, MOryT ObITb rrOJIHOIJ;eHHO IICnOJIbSOBaHbI
JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCRIIe ):(aHHbIe ):(JIH OCBeIIJ;eHDH npOOJIel\I 3TDoreHesa; OHII )XalOT
nrnpoKYIO II MHorOCTopOHHIOIO 1IH<popMaIJ;IIIO, II C IIX nOl\IOIIJ;bIO l\IOmnO ROp-
peKTlIpOBaTb peSYJIbTaTbI aHaJIIISa ):(PyrlIx MaTepIlaJIOB.
PaCCMOTpeHIIe paSHbIX 3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIX cIITyaIJ;IIH II BOSMomHOCTeH IIX
peRoHcTpyRIJ;IIII npIIBO):(I1T R BbIBOgy, 'ITO HII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIH MaTepIlaJI,
IIII JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCRIIe ):(aUHbIe, HII 3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIe npe)XaHIIH He IIl\IeIOT
a6cOJIIOTHOrO SUa'IeHIIH. IIx pOJIb OTHOCDTeJIbHa, II OHa MeHHeTCH B saBIICII-
MOCTII OT XpOHOJIOrH'IeCROrO ):(DanaSOHa paCCMa TpIIBael\IbIX npOIJ;eCCOB II CO-
ObI:TIIH. B OCBeIIJ;eHIIII COObITIIH 3rrOXII Ral\IHH II OpOHSbI, nOBTOpHel\I, HeOIJ;e-
HIlMa pOJIb aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX l\IaTepIIaJIOB, 3THoreHeTII'IeCRaH 3 <peRTIIB-
HOCTb ROTOpbIX 'IaCTO nOHIImaeTCH no OTHorneHIIIO R nOS):\HIIl\I IICTOpII'IeCKIIM
":OObITIIHl\I. JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCRIIe p;aHHble ocooeHHO 3<p<peRTIIBHbI JJ;JIH 3rrOXli
paHHero meJIesa II 3nOXII cpep;HeBeIWBbH. HaKoHeIJ;, 3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIe npe-
p;aHIIH TOJIbKO R 8noxe cpe):(HeBeROBLH npDoopeTaIOT HacTOHIIJ;YIO paspelliaIO-
IIJ;YIO CIIJIY II coxpaHHIOT ee BnJIOTb ):(0 nOCJIe):\HDX CTOJIeTIIH.
1 TOKapeB Co A. K nOCTaHOBKe np06JIeM :JTHoreHe3a II COB. 3THorpag)llJI. 19490 M 3;
/{e6elf F. W., JIeBun Mo F., TporfjuMoBa T. A. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIH MaTepllaJI RaR lIe-
TO'IHlIR ]:\JIH ll3yqeHllH BOlipOCOB 3THoreHe3a II TaM meo 1952. M 1; JIeBun M. F. OTHO-
rpag)II'IecRlIe II aHTpOnOJIorHlleCRlIe MaTeplIaJIbI RaR IICTOplI'IeCRIIH IICTO'IHllR: (K Me-
TO OJIOrllll ll3yqeHIIH llCTOpIIII 6ecnllcbMeHHbIx Hapop;oB) II TaM meo 1961. M 1; Funa-
6ypz B. B. HeKoTopbIe np06JIeMbI ll3YlleHllH B3allMOCBJl3ll pacoreHe3a II 3THorene3a /I
TaM me. 1968. M 4.
2 A.!LeKCeeB B. IIo IIpOllcxoiR]:\eHlle HapO]:\OB KaBRa3a: KpaHllOJI. HCCJIe . M., 1974.
3 IIo CYTll 3a nOCJIe]:\Hlle Ba eCHTllJIeTlIfl RPYIIHeHlliue pa60TbI 0 IIpollcxom]:\eHlIu pelIlI
HalilIcaHbI aHTpOnOJIOraMH: BynaK Bo Bo IIpOllcxolli]:\eHlIe pellll no ]:\aHHbIM aHTpOllO-
JIOrllll II IIpollcxom eHlle 'IeJIOBeRa II ]:\peBHee paCCeJIeHlle 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBao M., 1951.
(Tp. I1H-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 16); On 3/Ce. Pe% II IIHTeJIJIeRT, CTa]:\llH
llX pa3BllTllH B aHTponoreHe3e II I1cKOnaeMbIe rOMllH bI II rrpOlIcxom]:\eHlle lleJIOBeKa.
186
I
M., 19660 (Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 92). JIIDIrBllCTll'IeCKIIH aClieKT
np06JIeMbI CMo: JIeoUTbe6 A. A. B03HllKHoBeHHe II llepBOHallaJIbHOe pa3BllTlle H3bIKa.
M., 19630
.fo MHTepecHbIe MbICJIll Ha 3TY TeMY BblCRa3aHbI «D. COCCIOpOM B no rOTOBllTeJIbHbIX Ma-
TepllaJIax R KYpcy 061I{eH JIllHrBllCTllKII, oBe eHHbIx ceiITIac o neTIaTll: Saassure F. de.
Course de lingnistique generale/Ed. critique par R. Engler. Wiesbaden, 1967. Fasco 1,
2; 1968. Fasc. 3. CM. TaR7Ke: C.alOcape6a H. A. TeopllH B CBeTe COBpeMeHHOH JIIIHrBllC-
TllKll. M., 1975.
B npOTllBOBec llillpORO paclipocTpaHeHHbIM onTIIMllCTll'leCKIIM B3rJIH aM OHa BbIllYRJIO
OCBelI{eHa A. JI. MOHraHTOM. CM.: M ouzauT A. JI. ApXeOJIOrlllleCKlle KYJIbTypbI II 3T-
Hll'leCRlIe 06II{HOCTII: (K BOIIPOCY 0 MeTO]:\llRe IICTOpIIRo-apXeOJIOrlllleCKIIX llCCJIe OBa-
HllH) IIHapo]:\bI A3llll II Ag)PllRii. 1967. M 1.
.f! Mapp H. H. CKIIg)CRIIH H3bIR II IIo 3TaliaM pa3BIITllfJ Hg)eTII'IeCROH TeOpm!. JIo, 1926;
Ou 3/Ce. TepMllH «CRlIg)> II Hg)eTII'IeCRllH C60PHllK. JIo,_192 T. 10 06e pa60TbI nepe-
ne'IaTaHbI: Mapp H. Ho M36paHHbIe pa60TbI. M.; JI., 193;:,. To ;:,.
7 A6ae6 Eo 11. CRlIg)CKllll H3bIR II A6ae6 B. 110 OceTIIHCKIIH H3bIR II g)OJIbKJIOp. Mo; JIo,
19490 To 1.
11 Ou 3/Ce. IICTOpIIKO-3THMOJIOrlI'IeCRllfl CJIOEapb oceTIIHCImro H3blRa. M.; JI., 1958. T. 1;
Ou 3/Ceo CRIIg)o-eBponeHcKlle ll30rJIOCCbI. Ha CTbIKe BocToKa u: 3ana]:\ao M., 1965.
'9 JIllTepaTypa 0 CRIIg)CKOM 3BeplIHoM CTllJIe orpOMHa. CBO]:\RII aHHbIX II 6ll6JIllOrpag)llIO
CM.: ApTaMouo6 Mo J1., WopMau Bo CORpOBllll\a CRllg)CRIIX RypraHoB B c06paHIIll fo-
cy]:\apcTBeHHoro OpMIITa7Ka. M., 1966; ApTaMono6 Mo If. COhpOBlIlI{a caKOBo M., 19730
IIonYJIHpHbIe 0630pbI CKIIg)CKOH RYJIbTYPbI CMo: CMupno6 Ao II. CRlIg)bI. M., 1966;
FpaKo6 Bo Ho CRlIg)bI. Mo, 1971. Ao CIIX nop HenpeB30H eHHbIM 110 nOJIHOTe ll3JIOmeHIIH
IICTOplIll CRlIg)cKoro I1Ipa OCTaeTCH CTapbrH TPY]:\: PocToelfe6 M. H. CRIIg)llH II BOCIlOp.
KpIITll'leCROe o603peHlle IlaMfJTHIIROB JIIITepaTypbI II apxeOJIOrll'leCKnx. JI., 19250
10 FepoooT. MCTOpllH B eBHTll RHllTaX. JIo, 1972. C. 188-189.
11 06 3TOM CM.: BOPYX06U't B. Fo HayqHoe II JIllTepaTYPHoe 3Ha'IeHlle Tpy a repo oTa II
repo oTo YKa3. CO'I.
12 KonOYKTop06a T. C. HaCe.:renHfJ HeanoJIfJ CRig)CbRorO 3a aHTpono:wri'IHIUIll ]:\aHII m /1
MaTeplIaJIi 3 aHTponorii Yhp3lHII. KlllB, 19640 BIII!o 3; Onu 3/Cc. AUTpOnOJIOrlIH gpeE-
Hero HaCeJIeHllH YhpallHbI M., 1972; 3Une6U't Fo fl. O'lepRII naJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrlI1I YRpall-
HbI. KlleB, 1967.
3 MaTepllaJIbI C TeppllTopllll Cpe HeH A3llll CYMMlIpOBaHbI: Funa6ypz B. B., TporPUMo-
6a To Ao IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorllH Cpe]:\HeH A3Till. M., 1972. MaTepllaJIbI C TeppllToplIll
AJITafJ II XaRaCllll CYMMlIpOBaHbI: A.I!eKCee6 B. flo IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorHH A.1ITaH 3nOXll
meJIe3a II COB. apXeOJIorllH. 1958. M 1; Ou 3/Ce. IIaJIeoHTponoJIorHH XaKaClIll 3110Xll
7KeJIooa IIC60 MY3eH aHTpOnOJIOrlIll II 3THorpag)llll. 1961. T. 20; Koauulfe6 A. F. AHT,,-
ITOJIOrlIlleCRHU COCTaB II IIpOllCX07KgeHlIe HaCeJIeHIIH TarapcRoH KYJIbTYPbI. JI., 1972.
H. /{e6elf F. W o IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorllH CCCP IITp. MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. H. C.
Mo, 19480 To 4.
15 /{e6elf Fo W. IIaJIeOaHTpOITOJIorlI'IeCRlIe MaTepllaJIbI ll3 norpe6eHIIH CPy6HOH RYJIbTY-
pbI Cpe]:\Hero 3aBOJI7KbH II MaTepllaJIbI II llCCJIe OBaHllH IlO apXeOJIOrllll CCCP o 1954.
T. 42; KOUOYKTopo6a T. Co MaTepllaJIbI no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIll YKpalIHbIIIAuTpollo-
JIOrlI'IeCRllH C60pHIIR. M., 19560 (Tpo MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 33); Fe-
paCUM06a M. Mo qepena ll3 ITOrpe6eHIIH CPy6HOH KYJIbTYPbI B Cpe]:\HeM IIOBOJI7Kbe II
KpaT. co061I{. MH-Ta apXeOJIOrllll AH CCCP. 19580 BbIIl. 71; WuplllTeuu Bo Wo AHTpO-
IIOJIOrll'IeCRaH xapaRTepllcTIIKa HaCeJIeHIIH Hll7KHerO IIOBOJI7KbH B :moxy 6POH3bI II
rra IHTHllRII 3nOXII 6pOH3bI IOra eBponeHcKoii 'IaCTll CCCPo KneB, 1967; 3uue6u't F. II.
O'IepRll IlaJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrllll YRpallHbI; 3uHe6u't F. flo, KpYlf C. 1. AHTponoJIori'IHa
xapaRTepllcTllKa aBHboro HaCeJIeUUH TepliTopi YKpaiHH. ]{niB, 1968; KpYlf C. H.
HaCeJIeHlle TeppllTopllll YRpallHbI 3ITOXII Me]:\ll-6pOH3bI. KlleB, 1972.
f6 JIe6uu Mo F. OTHII'IeCRaH aHTpOllOJIOrIIH HuoHllll. Mo, 1971. He Mory He YRB3aTb Ha
IICKJIIOTIllTeJIbHYIO pOJIb COMaTOJIOrll'IeCKIIX MaTepllaJIOB, c06paHHbIX COBeTCKllMll aH-
TpOIlOJIOrallIll, II B nepBYIO O'Iepe b M. f. JIeBllHbIM, B 060CHOBaHIIll aHTpOllOJIOrlI'Ie-
CRorO e]:\llHCTBa HIIOHCRorO Hapoga.
n 061I{ee onllcaHlIe ITOJIIIHe3IIHCRlIX H3bIKOB CM.: Hapo bI ABCTpaJIllll II OKeaHlIll. M.,
1956. (HapogbI Mnpa. oTHorpag)II'IecRlIe O'IepRn).
18 IIpe JIo7Keuo HeCKOJIbRO BapllaHToB RJIaCcllg)IIRaD;HIIo 0630P llX CM.: fl Y'tK06 II. H
ClIcTeMbI RJIaCcllg)llRaD;llH oKeaHllHCRlIX H3bIKOB II 3THOJIllHrBllCTll'leCRaH RJIaCcllg)ll<
RaIIllH Hapo oB OReaHllll II H3bIKll IOro-BocTo'IHOH A31IH. M., 1967.
f9 IIo 60pRy cBe eHllH 06 3TllX pa60Tax CMo: Heyerdahl Th. American Indians in the
Pacific. L.; Stockholm; Oslo, 1952 0
:20 TaKYIO TO'IRY 3peHllH BbIpa3llJI, HaIIp., f. «D. Ae6eD;. CM.: /{e6elf Fo W. OnbIT rpag)ll-
'IeCKOrO ll306pa7KeHllH reHeaJIOrll'leCKOH RJIaCcllg)llKaD;nll TIeJIOBe'IeCRlIX pac II COB. 3T-
Horpag)HH. 1958. ;M 4.
187
J.
-
21 AJLeKCee6 B. fl. reorpag)llH TIeJIOBeTIeCKIIX pac. M., 1974.
22 Wagner K. The craniology of the oceanic reces II Skr. Norske vid.-akad. Oslo. Kl. I.
1937. N 2.
23 PoaunCKUU Ho Ho 0 npOllCxomp;eHllli nOJIllHe3llHI(eB (no aHTpOllOJIOfll'leCKIIM aH-
HbIM) II IIp06JIeMbI aHTpOllOJIOrllll II llCTopll'leCKOII 3THorpag)lllI A3lllI. M., 1968.
24 CBO RY aHHI.IX II 6ll6JIlIorpag)llIO CM.: Simmons R. Blood group genes in Polinesians
and comparisons with other Pacific peoples II Oceania. 1962. Vol. 32, N 3. IIepene-
TIaTaHO: Peoples and cultures of the Pacific. N. Y., 1968.
25 PoaunCKUU H. H. 0 npOlIcxom eHllll nOJIIIHe3llHI(eB; On 3/Ce. 0 nepBOHa'IaJII.HOM 3a-
CeJIeHllil ITOJHIHe3IIll (no MaTepllaJIaM aHTpOflOJIOrllll) II COBo 3THorpag)llH. 1966. ;Ni! 5.
26 CRa3RII II :vm.pI.I OReaHIIII. 1\1., 19700 OomylO xapaRTepucTIIKy «poaLKJIOpa nOJIllHe3I1ii-
I(eB aeT CTaTbH E. M. MllJIeTllHCRoro, npewroCJIaHHaH 3TOMY ll3 aHIIIO II co epmalI{aH
YRa3aHllH Ha OCHOBHYIO JIllTepaTYPY.
27 061I{ee npe CTaBJIeHlIe 06 3TIIX paC'IeTaX II 0 CBH3aHHbIX C HllMll IIp06JIeMax ae'l
RHlIra Te PaHrll Xllpoa (II. EaKa) II npe;J:nocaaIInaH eii CTaTI.H C. A. TOKapeBa. CM.:
Te Panau Xupoa. MOpeliJIaBaTeJIH COJIHellHOrO Bocxo a. M., 1950. YRa3aHllH Ha Ho-
BeHlliYIO JIllTepaTYPY no apXeOJIOrllll, oTo BllraIOlI{yIO BrJIy6I. aTY 3aCeJIeHllH IIoJlit-
He3llll, CM.: TYMapKun /1.. /1.0 Typ XeHepp;aJI II IIp06JIeJ\1a 3aCeJIeHllH IIoJIHHe3lllll1
ABCTpaJIllH II OKeaHllHo MCTOplIH II COBpellleHHOCTbo M., 1970.
28 061I{ee IIpe CTaBJIeHlIe 0 HeM aIOT ]:IBe 3aMellaTeJII.HI.Ie ny6JIIIKaI(llll If. A. Op6eJIlI.
C't\r.: Op6e.LU 11. A. BacHlI cpe;J,HeBeKoBoII Ap IeHIIII. Mo; JI., 1956; On 3/Ceo EacHII cpeA-
HeBeROBoii ApMeHIIII il .H30p. Tpo: B 2 T. 1\10' 1968. To L
29 CM. 06 3TOM pa60TY B. B. EynaKa, o CllX nop coxpaHIIBlliyro B 3TOM OTHOllieHllll Bce
CBoe 3Ha'IeHlle: BynaK B. B. Crania Armenica. MCCJIe]:lOBaHlle IlO aHTpOnOJIOrllll IIe-
pe HeH A3llll II Tp. AHTpOnOJI. Hayq.-llCCJIe]:l. llH-Ta npll I Mry. 1927. BbIIl. 2.
30 CBO Ry aHHblX CM.: A68yme.auuf,6u.au Mo F. AHTpOnOJIOrIm peBHero II cOBpeMeHI!O-
1'0 HaCeJIeHIIH rpY3llll. T6llJIIICII, 19640 CM. TaRme: On 3/Ceo 06 aHTpOnOJIOrll'leCKOM
COCTaBe cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHllH ApMeHllll II AHTpOnOJIOrlllleCKIIH C60PHllK, IV. M.,
1963. (Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 82).
31 Ta6JIll'IHYIO CBO]:lRY II 61I6JIIIOrpag)1I10 CMo: AJLeKCee6 Bo fl. IIpollcxom eHlle HapOAOB
KaBRa3a.
32 OCHOBHI.Ie pa60TbI ro RallaHl\HHa ITO H3blRY II llCTOpllll apMHH c06paHbI B ClleI:[llaJII.-
HI.IH C60PHIlRo CM.: KanaHlJRn F. MCTOpllRO-JIllHrBllCTll'IeCRUe pa60TI.I. EpeBaH, 1956.
33 }J;OCTaTOllHO no p06HO llCTOpllH ll3yqeHllH apMHHcKoro H3bIKa OCBelI{eHa 3. r. TYMa-
HHHOMo CMo: TYManRn 90 r. ApMHHCRIIH H3blR II COBeTcKoe H3I.IR03HaHlle 3a 50 JIeT.
M., 1967.
34 0 HeM CI\I.: Feopaue6 Bo MCCJIegOBaHllH no cpaBHllTeJIbHO-IICTOpllTIeCRoMy H3blR03Ha-
HllIOo M., 1958.
35 CM., Hanp.: AaaRn 9. Eo BBe]:leHlIe B H3I.IR03HaHIIeo EpeBaH, 1960.
36 /1.3/CaYKRn Fo B. YpapTcKuHll IIH]:IOeBpOneHCRIIe H3I.lRll. EpeBaH, 1963.
37 TYManRn.9o r. ApMHHCRUH H3bIR II H3I.lRll Hapop;OB CCCP. Mo, 19660 T. 1.
38 Feopaue6 B. YRa3. CO'I.
39 /1.3/CaYKRn F. B. ApMHHCKllH II ]:IpeBHlle llHp;OBponeHCRlIe H3blRIl. EpeBaH, 1970. Ha
apMo H30, pC3. pyC., aHrJI.
40 /1.3/CaYKRn Fo Bo O'iepRII 110 llCTOplIll OIIllCI.MeHHoro lleplIO}J,a apMHHCRoro H3I.lRa.
EpeBaH, 1967.
u JIe6un Mo F. «Dll31I'IeCRaH aHTpOnOJIOrllH II IIp06JIeMI.I 3THoreHe3a HapO OB }J;aJII.He-
1'0 BocToRa II Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. H. C. Mo, 1958. T. 36. 0 BapllaI(IIHX
rpYUlI RpOBII II epMaTOrJIIIg)IIRe aHHoB CMo: Schwidetzky I. Neuere Entwicklungen
in del' Rassenkunde des Mcnschen II Die neue Rcssenkunde/Hrsg. 1. Schwidetzky.
Stuttgart, 1962.
42 mTepn6epa J1. H. AHHCRafl IIp06JIeMa/i C6.MY3eH aHTpOnOJIOrllli II 3THorpag)i!UI.
1929. To 8.
43 CaM JIo H. IIITepH6epr OTI\IellaJI HCKOTopI.Ie llapaJIJIeJIU B CTpYRType aHHCRoro II aBCT-
paJIIIHCRIIX H3I.lROB, HO OHII CJIY'IaHHbI II nym]:laIOTCH B npOBepRe, 'IT06I.I llX MomBO
6I.IJIO TpaRTOBaTI. B reHeTU'IeCROM ITJIaHe.
U CMo, Hallp.: JIa6po6 JIo 11. Rapa'iaH II EaJIKapllH O 30-x rO OB XIX B. II RaBRa3cRllH
3THOrpag)II'IeCKllH C60pHllK. Mo, 1969. To 4. C. 73.
45 AJLeKCee6 B. II. AHTpOllOJIOrlI'IeCRlIe ]:IaHHbIe K npOllCXOm]:leHIlIO OCeTllHCRoro Hapo-
]:Ia II IIpOllcxom eBlIe OCeTllHCKoro BapO]:la: MaTepllaJII.I HaYll. cec., 1l0CBHll\0 np06JI.
3TBoreHe3a OCeTllB. Op moHllKII 3e, 1967. RpaBllOJIOrll'leCKlIe MaTepllaJIbI, Ha KOTO.
pI.Ie H Tor]:la npellMYlI{eCTBeHHO OnllpaJICH, TenepI. ll3 anI.I nOJIHOCTI.IOo CI\I.: AJLen-
cee6 Bo II. ITpollcxom):\eHlle Hapo oB RaBRa3ao TaM ,Ke H 3THorCHeTH'IeCRlIii RO'\I-
MeHTapllH, II oII6JIllOrpag)IIH Ilpe):\llieCTBYIOlI{llX pa60T.
46 CBO):\RY COMaTOJIOrlllleCRllX MaTepIIaJIOB no RaBRaCIIOHcROMy Tiiny CMo: A68ymeJLum-
6UJLU M. F. AHTpOnOJIOrllH gpeBHero II cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH rpy3IIIIo
r
I
I
188
n CM., HaIlp.: Banee6 3. Ho Cpe]:\HeBeRoBaH AJIaHIIHo CTaJIIIHlIplI, 1959.
i8 Fae.aouTu 10. C. AJIaHbI II BonpOCbI 3THoreHe3a OCeTllH. T6IIJIllCII, 1966.
9 A6ae6 B. N. IIpoIIcxom]:\eHlIe II RyJIbTypHOP npOlli:roe oceTI1H no aHHI.IM H3HI,a
(JIllHrBIICTII'IeCROe BBegeHlle B IICTOpllIO oceTIIHCRoro HapOga); On 3/Ce. 0 B3aIIMOOT-
HOllieHIIII IIpaHCROro II KaBRa3CRoro 3JIe IeHTOB B oceTIIHCROM II A6ae6 B. No Oce-
TllHCRllH H3bIR II g)OJII.RJIOp. M.; JI., -1949.
50 A6ae6 B. II. MCTOplI'IeCROe B HapTcKml 3noce II HapTcRIIH 3noc. ]J;3aY IIKay, 1949.
CM. TaKme: On 3/Ceo 3Ha'ieHlIe II npOlIcxom]:\eHlIe CJIOBa rong II A6ae6 B. II. OceTllH-
CRIIH H3bIR II «pOJII.RJIOpo
51 ]J;llCKYCCllIO BOKpyr 3TOH np06JIeMbI CM.: CKa3aHIIH 0 HapTax - anoc HapO OB RaB-
Ra3a. M., 1969.
52 Ka.!LOe6 B. Ao OCPTIIHI.I: MCTo-3THorp. nCCJIcg. M., 1970.
53 l{3/Can6epuoae Fo Ko BblcTynJIeHlle IIa ceCCllli no npollcxom.n:eHIIIO 6aJIRapl\eB II Rapa-
'IaeBl\eBIIO IIpoIIcxoilqeHlIll 6aJIRapl\eB II Rapa'iaeBl\eB. HaJII.'IIm, 1960.
5 A. eKcee6 B. fl. HeRoTopbIe IIp06JIeMI.I npolIcxom emlH oaJIRapD;eB II Kapa'iaeBl\eB
B CBeTe ;'];aHIIbIX aHTpOnOJIOrIIII II 0 npollcxolli]:\enlIll 6aJIRapD;eB II Rapa'iaeBD;eB.
55 Mapp Ho Eo EaJIRapO-CBaHcRoe CKpell\eHlIe II )J:ORJIo AH CCCP. 1929. IIepene'IaTaHo:
Mapp H. Eo 1I30paHHI.Ie pa60TI.I. JIo. 19370 T. 4; A6ae6 B. II. 061I{I[e 3JIeMeHTbI B
H3bIRe oceTI!H. OaJIKapl\eB II Rapa'iaeBl\CB II H3I.lK II MI.IlliJIeHue. JI., 1933. T. 1.
56 BaCKU1W6 H. A. BBe Hlle B ll3yqeHlle TIOpRCRllX H3bIKOB. M., 1969.
57 CMo, Hanp.. co. «0 npOlIcxom]:\eHlIll 6aJIRapl\eB II l\apa'iaeBl\eB».
58 g e60Kcap06 Ho H. CeBepHI.Ie RIiTaHD;I.I II ux COCe]:\II: (lICCJIe]:\OBamle no 3THII'IeCROH
aHTpOnOJIOrlIll BOCTO'IHOH A3llll) II RpaT. co061I{. MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. 1949.
BbIn. 5.
59 l{e6elf F. (jJ. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'leCRlIe IICCJIe]:\OBaHlUI B Ra I'IaTCI;oH 06JIaCTII II Tp. MH-Ta
3THorpag)llu AH CCCP o Ho Co 1951. T. W; .;le6un :110 Fo 3THlllleCKaH aHTpOnOJIOTIIIT
II np06JICMa 3THoreHe3a Hapo]:\oB ]J;aJII.HerO BOCTORao Mo. 19580
60 Meno614 uKo6 Fo A. OCKIIMoCCRO-aJIeYTCRaH rpynna 11.H3bIRII Hapo]:\oB CCCP. JI.,1968.
To 5.
61 CmICOR pa50T K PaCl\IycceHa, co CpmalI{IIx g)OJII.RJIOpHI.Ie MaTepllaJIbI no 3CRIIMO-
caM, orpmlPHo YRamy OCHOBHI.Ie KHlIrlI: Rasmussen K. People of the polar North.
L., 1909; Idemo Intellectual culture of the Iglulik Eskimos. Copenhagen, -1929; Idem.
The Netsilik Eskimos. Social life and spiritual culture. Copenhagen, 1931; Idem.
Intellectual culture of the Copper Eskimos. Copenhagen. 1932; Idem. The Mackenzie
Eskimos. Copenhagen, 1942; Idemo The Alaskan Eskimoso Copenhagen, 19520
62 Rainey Fo The whale hunters of Tigara II Anthropol. Pap. Amer. Mus. Natur. Rist.
19470 Vol. 41, pt. 1.
63 CM., Hanpo: C600em Mo R Bonpocy 0 nOBbIllieHllli TO'IHOCTll B JIeKCIIKO-JIIIHrBllCTll-
'IeCROM ]:\aTlIpoBaHIIII II HOBoe B JIllHrBIICTIIRe. M., -19600 BbIn. 1.
6 0630p OTRpI.ITI.IX naMHTHIIKOB II cYlI{eCTByIOII{IIX rlInOTe3 CMo: Bandi H. Uhgeschichte
del' Eskimo. Stuttgart, 1965; (jJaun6epe JIo .110 HaCeJIemIC fpeHJIaH]:\1I1I BO II TI.ICH-
'IeJIeTIIII go H. 3.- I TbICH'IeJIeTIIII H. 3. II OT AJIHCRII ]:\0 OrHeHHOH 3eMJIIIo MCTOplIH
II 3THorpag)llH CTpaH AMepllRiio Mo, 1967; On 3/Ceo O'iepRII 3THll'leCROH llCTOpllll 3a-
py6erRllOrO CeBepa (A mICRa, I'laHa]:\cRaH ApI..TllRa, JIaopa]:\op, fpen:wH]:\IIH). Mo, 1!J71.
65 ]J;OCTaTO'IHO cpaBHIITI. llJIOlI{a]:\I. apeaJIOB CeH'IaC II B XVII B. CM.: l{O.!Leux B. O.
PO]:\OBOII II nJIm.IeHIIOll coCTaB HapO]:\OB CII6IIpII B XVII BeRe II Tp. MH-TIt 3THorpa-
g)IIII AH CCCPo H. C. 19600 To 550
66 ON.wonUK06 Ao no IIpOIllJIOP HKYTlIll ]:\0 nplICoep;IIHemIH R PyC,CROMy rocy apCTBY II
MCTOplIH HKYTIIII. HRYTCK, 1949. T. 1; On 3/Ceo HKYTIIJI ]:\0 npllcoe]:\IIHeHIIH K PyCCKO-
My rOCY)1apCTBY II MCTOpIIH HRYTCROH ACCP. M.; JIo. 1955. To 1-
67 CM.: HOC06 Mo Ho IIpep,KII HKYTOB no IIpe]:\aHIIHM nOTmlROB II C60pHIIR Tpyp;OB IIC-
CJIe]:\OBaTeJII.CROrO 061I{eCTBa «Caxa R3CKIIJI3»0 HRYTCR, -19260 T. 3 Bo.!LO C. N. IIpolli-
JIoe HRYTOB go nplIxo]:\a pyCCRIIX Ha JIeHY (no npegaHIIHM HKYTOB 6I.IBill. HKYTCRO-
1'0 oKpyra) IITp. HaY'Io-llCCJIe]:\. IIH-Ta. npII CHR HACCP. 1937. T. 4.
68 FenKep To JIo R xapaRTepIIcTI1Ke g)H3wrecRoro TlIua HRYTOB 113arro BOCTo-CII60 OT]:\-HllH
pyco reorpo O-Ba. 18960 To III, BI.llio 1; KOH (jJo Ho 1l>1I3IIo.:rorlI'IeCRlIe II 3THO;r0I'll-
'IeCRUe ]:\aHHbIe 06 HRYTax: (AHTpOnOJI. O'IepR). MIIHYCIIHCK, 1899; Mauno6 IIo fl.
HKYTI.I (no MaTepllaJIaM f. JIo feKKepa) II Pyco aHTponoJI. mypH. 1902 0 M 4.
69 JIe6un M. F. AHTpOnOJIOrll'leCRllll TlIll HKyTOB II RpaT. co061I{0 MH-Ta 3THorpag)IIll
AH CCCP. 1947. BbIll. 3; 30.!LOrape6a No M. TeppliTOplIaJII.HbIe BapllaIITbI aHTpono-
JIOrll'IeCROrO TlIna HRYTOB II 8THoreHe3 II 3THII'IeCKaH IICTOplIH Hapo]:\oB CeBepa. M..
1975.
70 A. eKcee6 B. flo, Bene60.!LenCKa5t 10. l{., FOXMan II. II. II gp. AHTpOnOJIOrll'IeCKlle nc-
CJIe]:\OBaHIIH Ha JIeHe II COB. 3THorpag)llH. 19680 M 5.
71 l{e6elf F. (jJ. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRlle IICCJIC]:\OBaHIIH B RalllllaTCKOii OOJIaCTll.
I
I
I
I
189
72 IIpm,iepoM MOmeT CJIymlITI. BBO HaH rJIaBa RHlIrll «D. II. «DIIJIllHa «06pa30BaHlIe H3bI-
Ra BOCTOTIHbIX CJIaBHH» (M o ; JI., 1962), B ROTopon OCHOBnaH pOJII. B peRoHCTpYRD;lIll
3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX cIITyaD;IIH nplinlIcI.IBaeTcH JIIIHrBIICTIIRe. Ta me nplI6JIII3IITeJII.HO
CyMMa coo6pameHIIli pa3BHBaeTCH B RH.: ([Ju.lLun ([Jo fl. IIpolIcxomgeHHe pYCCRoro,
YKpalIHCKoro II 6CJIOpyccRoro H3blKOB: I1cT.-glIaJIeRTOJI. O'IepK. JIo, 19720
rrA EOAHTPorro orMH M MCTOPMH
nA EOAHTPonO OrHqECRMHMATEPHAJI
RAR I1CTOPl1qECRIm I1CTOQHHR
IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIH - Ta 'IaCTb aHTpOrrOJIOrIl'IeCROH HaYRII, KOTopaH saHII-
MaeTCH IIsY'IeHIIeM <pIISII'IeCIaIX oco6eHHoCTeH )XpeBHero UaCeJIeHIIH. IIpe):(-
CTaB:reHIIe 06 8TIIX oc06eHHocTHx l\IOmHO nOJIY'IIITb, IICCJIegyH IWCTHble
OCTaTRII JIIOp,eH IIS norpe6eHIIH paSUbIX 3nox, paCCl\IaTpIlBaH peaJIIICTII'IeCRIIe
B.HTpOrrOl\Wp<pHbIe IIs06pameHIIH, 1I0llie):(IIIIIe P;O Hac, 'IIITaH rrIICbl\IeHHbIe IIC-
TO'IHIIKII, co):(eplliaIIJ;IIe co061IJ;emm 0 <pIISII'IeCROM TIIne p;peBHIIX Ha pO):(OB.
TOJIbKO B nepBOM lIS 8TIIX CJIY'IaeB HSBReRaeMaH IIH<popMaIJ;HH p;OCTaTO'IUO
rrORHOIJ;eHHa II pasHo06pasHa. JII060e IIso6pallieHIIe 'IeJIOBe'IeCIWrO mIQa,
6YP;b TO PIICYHOR Ha Ral\IHe II KepaMIIRe IIJIII ROCTHHaH II Ral\IeHHaH CRYJIbn-
Typa, HeceT 3JIel\IeHT YCJIOBUOCTII, IIHor):(a saBegOl\IO IICKamaeT xapaRTepHble
TlInOJIOrnqeCRlIe 'IepTbI B COOTBeTCTBIIII C rocnO):(CTBYIOIIJ;IIMII B TOM IIJIlI
JIHOM 06IIJ;ecTBe CTDJIeM II nOHIIMaHIIeM co):(epmaHIIH IICRYCCTBa. HraHacaHbI,
HarrpIIl\Iep, cpe):(II CII6IIpCRIIX HapO):(OB OTHOCHTCH K HaIl60JIee MOHrOJIOII):(HbIM,
HO IISrOTOBJIHBlliIIeCH IIMII )XO ue):(aBHero IIpomJIoro p,epeBHHHble RYKTIbI pn-
TyaJIbHOrO HaSHa'ieHIIH OTJIII'IaIOTCH MOp;eJIIlpOBaHHbIMII BblcTynaIOlIJ;lIMII HO-
cal\II1 BnOJIHe eBponeOII):(uoro TIIna.
ABTop JII060ro IIIICbl\IeHHOrO IICTO'IHIIKa, co06IIJ;aH 0 <pIISIIqeCKOM TlIne
P;Pyroro Hapop;a, TaRme IIl\IeR B Ka'IeCTBe RpIITepIIH OIJ;eHKII <pIISII'IeCRIIII 06-
JIIIR COOTe'IeCTBeUHIIKOB. (DIISII'IeCKII 6JIIISRIIe aBTopaM OIIIIcaHIIH HapO):(bI
He nona):(aJIII B C006IIJ;eHIIH, KaR He 06paIIJ;aBmIIe Ha ce6H BHIIMaHIIH, OTRII-
'IIIH HOCIITeJIeH IIHoro KOMnJIeRCa <pIISII'IeCI\:IIX npIIsHaKoB npeYBeJIlIlCIIIBamlcb.
TaR, B IICTOpII'IeCROII JIIITepaType YRopeHIIJIaCb, B 'IaCTHOCTII, JIereH):(a 0
.n.peBHeM eBponeolIp,DoM CBeTJIOBOJIOCOM II CBeTJIOrJIaSOl\I HaCeJIeHlI1I IJ;eHT-
paJIbHOn ASIIII, cos):(aHHaH KIITallcKIIMII JIeTOnIICIJ;al\III \- JIereH):(a, no):():(ep-
mIIBael\IaH II oT)XeJIbHbIMII cOBpeMeHHbIMII IICCJIe):(oBaTeJIHMII.
IIaJIebaHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIH MaTepIIaJI JIIlmeH 8TDX Hep;OCTaTKOB, TaR RaJ{
OB ):(aeT He ROCBeHHYIO, a npHMYIO IIH<popl\IaIJ;IIIO 0 <pIISII'IeCRIIX oc06eHHo-
CTHX p,peBHIIX nonyJIHIJ;IIH, IIX paCOBOM TIIne II <pIISII'IeCROl\I pasBIITIIII,
xapaKTepe pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH B TOM IIJIII IIHOM 06IIJ;eCTBe 60JIesHeH, HaKOHeIJ;,
o p;el\IOrpa<pIIlCleCKIIX nOKaSaTeJIHX - COOTHOllieHIIII IIOJIOB, npOJJ;OJImIITeJIbHO-
CHI mIISHII, ):(eTCROH Cl\IepTHOCTII. KOHe'IHo, II nplI IIsyqeHIIII CReJIeTOB He-
o6xo}J;HMo nplI6eraTb B pHp;e CJIY'IaeB R KOCBeHHbIM 3KCTpanOJIHIJ;IIHM, HanpII-
Mep B OTHOIIIeHIIII IIlIrMeHTaIJ;IIII, HO B IJ;eJIOM IICnOJIbsyeMaH B naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIorlI1I CIICTel\Ia IIsMepeHIIH ):(OCTaTO'IHO IIOJIHO xapaKTepIIsyeT OCHOBHble
Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCRIIe II paCOBble oc06eHHOCTII. TaKIIM 06pasoM, nOJIY'IaeMaH
IIH<popMaIJ;IIH 06'beRTIIBHa II Ha):(emHa 2.
PaSJIII'IIIH Mem):(y Hapo):(aMII B IJ;BeTe BOJIOC, rJIas II KomlI 06IIJ;eIIsBecT-
JIbI. KpynHble pacoBbIe ):(eJIeHIIH - MOHrOJIOIIp;bI, HerpolI):(bI II eBponeOII}J;bI
pesKo OTJIII'IaIOTCH p;pyr OT p;pyra, p;OCTaTO'IlIO O'ieBII):(HbI II OTJIII'IIIH Hapo-
AOB, npIIHap;JIelliaIIJ;IIX K OP;HOH II TOH me pacoBoH 06IIJ;HOCTII. B cOBpeMeH-
HOII aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII 3TIIl\I paSJIII'IIIHM rrpII):(aeTcH nepBocTeneHHoe SHa'ieHlle.
190
n ORII 'IaCTO CJIymaT P;JIH BbI):(eJIeHIIH MeJIKIIX paCOBbIX KaTerOpIlH. Hapop;bI
CI{3H):(IIHaBIIII, HanpIlMep, rrpe):(CTaBIITeJIII ceBepHOH paCbI, IIJIII ceBepHOH
BeTBIl eBponeOII):(OB, IIMeIOT CBeTJIyIO nIInteHTaIJ;I1IO, mIlTeJIII Cpe):(IIseMHO-
MopClwro 6acceiIna, OTHOCHITJ;I1eCH K CpelUIseMHOMopCIWH pace, IIJIII IOlImolf
BeTBII eBponeoHgoB, OTJIII'IaIOTCH CBeTJIOH IwmeH, HO TeMHbIMII BOJIOCaMII II
rJIaSaMII.
B ):(peBIUlX norpe6eHIIHX HeCROJIbKO pas 06HapymIIBaJIII OCTaTKII BOJIOC.
OUII, KaR npaBIIJIO, IIMeIOT CBeTJIbIH I1JIII pbImIlH IJ;BeT. 8TO He pas cJIymII-
o p;oKaSaTeJIbCTBOM IIIIIpoKoro pacnpocTpaHelIIIH B ):(peBHocTII npe):(cTaBIITe-
JIeH ceBeplIoH pacbl ):(aJIeRO OT MeCT IIX cOBpeMeHHDrO paCCeJIeHIIH. IIsBecT-
HaH rIlnOTesa T. XeHep)XaJIa 0 npIIMeclI ceBepHoH pacbI y ):(peBHIIx nepyaH-
IJ;eB II 06 IIX pacnpOCTpaHeHnII no TIIXOMY OReaHY C BOCTOKa Ha sanag
onIIpaeTcH IIMeHHO Ha Haxo):(RII CBeTJIbTX BOJIOC B ):(peBHenepyaHcRlIx norpe-
6eHIIHx pasHoro XpOHOJIOrII'IeCROrO BospaCTa 3. Memgy TeM Heop;HORpaTHO
6bIJIO nORasaHo, 'ITO npII lJ;JIIITeJIbHOM npe6bIBaHIIII B SeMJIe BOJIOCbI TepHIOT
cBoII eCTecTBeHHbIH IJ;BeT, TeMHbIII nIIrMeHT nepexo):(IIT B CBeTJIbIH . ll08TO-
MY aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIe OCHOBaHIIH rIInOTesbI XelIep)XaJIa npIISpa'IHbI, II ee
ueraTIIBHaH OIJ;eHRa B CBeTe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX p;aHHbTX COBna):(aeT C
MHeHIIeM npeP;CTaBIITeJIeH ):(pyrIlx ):(IICIJ;IIIIJIIIH.
IJ,BeT BOJIOC HeBOSMomHO peROHCTpYIIpOBaTb, ):(ame eCJIII OCTaTKII IIX HaII-
p;eHbI npII paCKonRax. Cymp;eHIIH 0 nIIrMeHTaQIIII p;peBHIIX JIIOp;eH IJ;eJIIIIWM
OCHOBaUbI Ha IWCBeHHbIX lIaHHbIX - aHaJIOrIIHX C COBpeMeHHbIMII nonYJIH-
IJ;IIHl\III, IICTOJIIWBaHIIII nIICbMeHHbIX IICTO'IHIIROB II T. p;. Ho BO Bcex OCTaJIb-
nbIX CJIy'IaHX naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIPIeCRIIH MaTepIlaJI ):(aeT Ha):(emHYIO IIH<pOP-
MaQIIIO 0 <pIISII'IeCROM TIIrre ):(peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH.
8JIeMeHTapHoII e):(IIHIIQeH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIl'IeCKOro IICCJIe):(OBaHIIH HB-
JIHeTCH CReJIeT OT):(eJIbHOrO 'IeJIOBeRa. OJJ;HaRO nOJIY'IaeMaH npII 3TOM IIH<pOP-
MaIJ;IIH RpalIHe orpaHII1IeHHa. )J,ame BOCCTaHOB;;IeHIIe MHrI\:IIX TRaHeH JIIIIJ;a
no 'Iepeny II nOJIy'IeHIIe IIH):(IIBIIgyaJIbHOrO nopTpeTa He MeHHIOT ):(eJIa. llpo-
IISBO):(IIBIIIlIeCH B Ha'IaJIe BeRa aHrJIIIHCKIIMII aHTpOnOJIOral\III nOnbITKII BOC-
CTaHOBIITb IIH):(IIBlIgyaJIbHbIH 06JIIm KpoMBeJIH II MIIJIbTOHa, TPY):( IITaJIbHH-
IJ;a <D. <DpaceTTo no peRoHcTpYRIJ;1I1l nopTpeTa )J,aHTe, HaROHeIJ;, pa60TbI
M. M. repaclIMoBa no BOCCTaHOBJIeHIIIO BHemHero 06JIIIRa IISBeCTHblX IICTO-
pII'IeCKIIX JIIIIJ; IIHTepeCHbJ II IJ;eHHbI no CBOIIM peSYJIbTaTaM 5. Ho JJ;JIH IICTO-
pIIII, CTporo rOBopH, He CTOJIb BamHO, KaROB 6bIJI npO<pIIJIb )J,aHTe, Bocne-
TbIH BJIOKOM B CTIIXOTBopeHlI1I «PaBeHHa» «<TeHb )J,aHTe C npo<pIIJIeM OpJIII-
HbIM 0 HOBOH mIISHII MHe noeT»), IIJIII KaR BblrJIH):(eJI BJIa):(IIMIIp MOHOMax.
llo):(06Hble perWHCTpYKIJ;IIII IIH):(IIBIIp;yaJIbHbIX nopTpeTOB nplI BceM IICKJIIO'III-
reJIbHOM IIHTepece R HIIM MaJIO )XaIOT IICTOpII'IeCROMY SHaHIIIO.
IIcnOJIbsyeMaH B naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIII CIICTeMa I1Sl\IepeHIIH CReJIeTa II
'Iepena 'IeJIOBerm nOSBOJIHeT nepeHTII lIa rpyrrnoBoH ypOBeHb peROHCTpYK-
IJ;IIII, T. e. nOJIY'IIITb cpep;HIOIO Mop<pOJIOrIf'IeCRYIO XapaI\:TepIICTIIKY COBoKyn-
HOCTII JIIDgeH no MHorIIM npIISHaKaM. 8TO )XoCTIIraeTCH C nOMOIIJ;bIO npIIMe-
HeIIIIH BapIIaIJ;IIOHHO-CTaTIICTII'IeCKIIX MeTop;OB. BOJIee CJIOmHble BonpOCbI
nCTalOT B CBHSII C BbIJJ;eJIeHIIeM cOBoKynHocTeH JIIOlIelJ, KOTopbIe nO;:J,JIemaT
HCCJIe):(OBaHIIIO. B pesyJIbTaTe COBMeCTHoro npomIIBaHIIH 'IJIeHOB IICTOpII'Ie-
CKII 06pasoBaBmeHcH rpynnbI II SaImIO'IeHIIH Mem)Xy HIIMII 6paRoB Ha npo-
THiReHHII pH):(a nOKOJIeHIIH 06pasyeTcH onpe):(eJIeHHaH CTeneHb pO):(CTBa
BHYTPII TaROH rpynnbI, CBOHCTBeHHaH IIMeHHO eH II onpeJJ;eJIHIOIIJ;aH xapaR-
Tep BHYTpIIrpynnoBoH IISMeH'IIIBOCTII npII3HaROB. IIo):(06HbIe rpynnbI nOJIY-
'IIIJIII HaIIMeHOBaHIIe nonYJIHIJ;lIH 6. 8TO nOHHTIIe HBJIHeTCH KJIIO'IeBbIM II B
06IIJ;eH nonYJIHIJ;IIOHHOH reHeTIIRe, II B nonYJIHIJ;IIOHHOH reHeTIIRe 'IeJIOBeKa,
II B aHTpOnOJIOrIIII, nOToMY 'ITO norrYJIHIJ;1I1I npe):(CTaBJIHIOT C060H 8JIeMeHTap-
191
Hble 6IIOJIOrlIqeCKIIe H'IeHlm BIIp;a, II Ha ypOBHe nOrrYJIHIJ;IIH npemp;e BCerO
npOHBJIHeTCH ):(IIHaMIIRa aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIX npIISHaKOB. IIplI IISY'IeHIIII CO-
:BpeMeHHOrO HaCeJIeHIIH rronyJIHIJ;nlI YCTaHaBJIIIBaIOTCH JIernO - 3TO rpynnbI
JIIO):(eH, 06'be):(IIHeHHbIx no TeppIITOpIIaJIbHOMY, 3THorpa<pIIQeCKOMY IImI 3THII-
lClecKoMy npIISHaRY; B naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII BbI):(eJIeHlIe nonYJIHQIIH CJIOmHee,
HO II naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCKOe IICCJIe):(OBaHIIe HerrpeMeHHO ):(OJImno 6bITb
nonyJIHIJ;IIOHHbIM, 'IT06bI 6bITb 3<p<peRTIIBHbIM B IICTOpII'IeCROM OTHOIIIeHIIII.
CReJIeTbI JIIOp;eH ):(peBHIIX 8nox )X06bIBaIOTcH npII apXeOJIOrII'IeCRIIX pac-
RonRax l\IOrIIJIbHIIKOB paSHoro XpOHOJIOrlI'IeCROrOBospaCTa. JIIO):(eH, saxopo-
HeHHbIX B OP;HOM MOrIIJIbHIIRe, MomHO C IISBeCTHbIMII OCHOBaHIIHl\I1I C'IIITaTb
npe):(CTaBIITeJIHl\III O):(HOH norrYJIHQIIII. KaSaJIOCb 6bI, eCJIII l\IOrIIJIbHIIK paCRO-
naH nOJIHOCTbIO, TO MomHO nOJIY'IIITb Mop<pOJIOrlI'IeCRYIO II p;eMorpa<pII'Ie-
CKYIO xapaKTeplICTIIRY nonYJIHIJ;IIII, IWTopaH npOBOAIIJIa saxopOHeHIIH B ):(aH-
HOl\I MOrIIJIbHIIKe. O):(HaKO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe nonYJIHIJ;IIII OTJIIIQaIOTCH
OT COBpel\IeHHbIX TeM, QTO OHII KaK 6bI npOp;OJImeHbI BO BpeMeHII, TaK KaK
MOrIIJIbHIIRII QaIIJ;e Bcero IIcnOJIbSOBaJIIICb Ha npOTHmeH1I1I HeCKOJIbKIIX nORO-
JIeHIIH. IIx TO'IHOe 'IIICJIO OCTaeTCH HeIISBeCTHbIM, II n03ToMy naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCKIIH MaTeplIaJI nOR a MaJIOnpHrOp;eH P;JIH onpep;eJIeHIIH 'IIICJIeHHOCTII
TOH IIJIII IIHOH rronYJIHIJ;1I1I B XpOHOJIOrlI'IeCROM OTpeSKe BpeMeHII, rragaIOIIJ;eM
na O):(HO nOKOJIeHIIe. IIo TOH me npII'IIIHe orrpe):(eJIeHIIe 'IIICJIeHHOCTII nace-
JIeHIIH TOH IIJIII IIHOH TeppIITopIIII C nOl\IOIIJ;bIO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIX ):(aH-
HbIX p;OCTaTO'IHO YCJIOBHO. Ho P;PyrIIe l\IOp<pOJIorII'IeCKIIe II ):(eMorpa<pII'IeCRlIe
napaMeTpbI Ha nonyJIHIJ;IIOHHOM ypOBHe BOCCTaHaBJIIIBaIOTCH C ):(OCTaTO'IHOM
CTeneHbIO Ha):(emHOCTII.
Paspa60TaHbI BeCbl\Ia 3<p<peKTIIBHbIe CTaTIICTII'IeCRlIe crroc06bI cpaBHeHIIH
nonyJIHIJ;IIH KaR no oTgeJIbHbIM npIISHaKaM, TaK II no IIX CYMl\Ie. 8nI cno-
c06bI p;aIOT OCHOBaHIIH CY):(IITb 0 CTerreHII l\IOp<pOJIOrII'IeCROrO CXO)XCTBa IIJIII
paSJIII'IIIH Memp;y ):(BYMH IIJIII HeCROJIbRIIl\III nonYJIHIJ;IIHMII. Mop<pOJIOrlI'IeCRIIe
oc06eHHOCTII CKeJIeTa II 'Iepena 'IeJIOBeI\:a HaCJIe):(CTBeHHO 06YCJIOBJIeHbI,
II OT onpep;eJIeHIIH IIX Cxop;CTBa MomHO nepeHTII R YCTaHOBJIeHIIIO reHeTII'Ie-
CKoro pop;CTBa. lIl\IeHHO 3TOT rrepexop; II nOSBOJIHeT IICnOJIbSOBa Tb naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCIUre p;aHHbIe HapHgy C IICTOpIIKO-KYJIbTYPHbIl\III ):(JIH peIIIeHIIH
3THoreHeTII'IeCRIIX np06JIeM.
Bce CKasaHHe OCTaeTCH cnpaBe):(JIIIBbIM II npII nepexo):(e C norrYJIHIJ;IIOH-
Horo ypOBHH Ha 60JIee BbICORIIH. MOrlIJIbHIIKII O):(IIHaKOBOH KYJIbTYPHOH nplI-
Ha;J;JIemHOCTII 06bI'IHO OTHOCHTCH R e):(IIHOH apXeOJIOrII'IeCROH RYJIbType IIJIII
K e):(IIHOH KYJIbTypHO-IICTOpII'IeCKOH 06IIJ;HOCTII 7. IIpII HaJIII'I1I1I Mop<P0JIOrlI-
'IeCROrO Cxop;CTBa Memp;y rpynnaMII, OCTaBIIBIIIIIMII OTp;eJIbHbIe MOrIIJIbHIIKII,
MomHO, CYMMIIPYH ,rraHHbIe, nOJIY'IIITb 0606IIJ;eHHoe npe):(CTaBJIeHIIe 06 aHTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCKOM TlIne HaCeJIeHIIH apXeOJIOrII'IeCROH KYJIbTYPbI IIJIII RYJIbTYPHO-
IICTOpIIQeCKOH 06IIJ;uocTII. AHaJIOrlI'IHbIM 06pasoM MomHO nOJIY'IIITb cYl\Il\Iap-
HYIO xapaKTepIIcTIIRY HaCeJIeHIIH JII060H TeppIIToplIlI, BnJIOTb p;o KpynHblX
reorpa<pII'IeCKIIX paHOHOB. IIplI YCTaHOBJIeHIIII MOP<POJIOrlI'IeCKIIX paSJIII'IIIH
Memgy JIIOP;bMII, noxopOHeHHbIMII B OTp;eJIbHbIX MOrIIJIbHIIKaX, saKOHOMepeH
BbIBOP; 06 aHTpOnOJIOrIIQeCKOH reTeporeHHOCTII HaCeJIeHIIH TOH IIJIII IIHOH
apXeOJIOrII'IeCKOII RYJIbTYPbI IIJIII RYJIbTYPHO-IICTOplI'IeCKOH 06IIJ;HOCTII, 0 CJIO-
iReHIIII ero Ha OCHOBe aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX KOMnOHeHTOB, IIMeIOIIJ;IIX paSHoe
npOlIcxomp;eHIIe.
o paSHOM npOIIcxom):(eHIIII MomHO rOBoplITb II no OTHOIIIeHIIIO K JIIO):(HM
saxopOHeHHbIl\I B O):(HOM MOrIIJIbHIIKe, eCJIII B HeM 06HapymeHbI IIH):(IIBII-
;a,YYMbI C paSHbIl\I1I aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII oc06eHHOCTHMII. )J,eMOHCTpaIJ;IIH
rOMoreHHOCTII IIJIII reTeporeHHOCTII rpynnbI, npOIICXO):(HIIJ;eH lIS op;Horo MO-
rIIJIbHIIKa, nOSBOJIHeT OIJ;eHIITb, cop;epmaJIa Jill nonyJIHIJ;IIH, oCTaBIIBmaH MO-
192
rIIJIbHIIK, npIIMeCb IIHOpO):(HbU KOMrrOlIeHTOB, IIJIII OHa Op;HOpO}J;Ha B 61I0JIO-
rll'IeCROM OTHOIIIeHIIII. B nepBOM CJIY'Iae nplI BOSl\IOIRHOCTII YCTaHOBIITL
npOIICXOIR):J;eHlIe IIHOpO}J;HOH npllMeCII MbI nOJIyqaeM YRasaHlIH Ha HanpaBJIe-
Ulle 8THOreHeT:II'IeCROrO nmICKa, BO BTOpOM IIMeel\I npaBO rOBopIITb 0 Hesa-
BIICIIMOM OT nOCTopOHHIIX BJIIIHHIIH <pOpl\IIIpOBaHIIII nonYJIHIJ;IIII 8.
IITaR, B xo):(e naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCROrO IICCJIe):(OBaHIIH YCTaHaBJIIIBaeTCH
CTeneHb OIIOJIOrII'IeCROrO pO):(CTBa l\IeIR):(Y rpynnal\I1I JIIO):(eH, OTHOCHIIJ;IIMIICH
K paSHbIl\I KYJIbTYpHo-apXeOJIOrII'IeCI\:IIM KOMnJIeRCaM, a SHa'IIIT, BOSl\IOIRHO,
paSJIII'IaIOIIJ;IIl\IIICH II 3THII'IeCKII. TaRIIM 06pasol\I, naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCRIIH
MaTeplla.J IICnOJIbsyeTcH npII pellieHIIII 3THOreHeTII'IeCRIIX np06JIeM. IIaJIeo-
):(el\IOrpa<pII'IeCRIIe ):(anHble KOCBeHHbIl\I 06pasoM nOSBOJIHIOT CYJJ;IITb 06 YPOB-
He mIISHII II CIWpOCTII CMeHbI nOKOJIeHIIH, a 3Ta nOCJIe):(HHH ):(el\IOrpa<pII'Ie.-
CRaH XapaI\:TepIICTIIKa HenOCpei'J,CTBeHHO CBHsaHa co CIWpOCTbIO IISMeHeHIIH
MHorlIX COIJ;IIaJIbHbIX HBJIeHIIH. TeM Cal\IbIM naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIH MaTe-
pllaJI npeJJ;CTaBJIHeT c060H BcnoMOraTeJIbHbIH IICTOpII'IeCRIIH IICTO'IHIIR C ):(0-
BOJIbHO BbICOROH paSpemaIOIIJ;eH cnoc06HoCTbIO, npIIqeM pOJIb ero TeM 60JIb-
IIIe, "IeM ):laJIbIIIe MbI OTXO,I:(IIl\I OT COBpeMeHHOCTII. Oc06eHHo BeJIIIRa ero
pOJIb B PeIWHCTPYKIJ;IIII C06bITIIH 6ecnlIcbMeHHoH IICTOpllII 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa.
PEKOHCTPYR JI OqAfOB ABTOXTOHHoro P A3BIITIIJI
KaRYIO IRe )XonOJIHIITeJIbHYIO IIH<popMaIJ;IIIO npIIHOCIIT naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlI'Ie-
CRIIII l\IaTepllaJI B cpaBHeHIIII co BceMII ):(PyrlIl\I1I BIIp;aMII IICTOplI'IeCKIIX
IICTO'IHlIIWB? BbI60p npllMepOB 6y):(eT y6e):(IITeJIbHee, eCJIII He OrpaHII'III-
BaTbCH O)XHOH RpynHoH 06JIaCTbIO, a paccMoTpeTb naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIe
l\IaTepllaJIbI liS HeCIWJIbKIIX paHoHoB C paSHbIl\I1I 8ROJIOrII'IeCRIIMII YCJIOBIIH-
l\III. TaR, B CTenHbIX palIOHax XaRacIIII, no cpe):(HeMY Te'IeHIIIO EHllceH II
A6aRaHY, IIl\IeeTCH OrpOl\IHOe 'IIICJIO paSHOBpel\IeHHbIX RypraHHbIx l\WrIIJIbHII-
ROB, OXBaTLIBalOIIJ;IIX ):(JIIITeJIbUbIH nepIIO):( Bpel\IeHn - OT 3HeOJIIITa ):(0 3no-
XII nOS):(Hero Cpe):lHeBeIWBbH. MHorIIe liS HIIX paCKonaUbI II JJ;aJIII 06IIIIIpHbIe
naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrll'IeCRIIe ROJI.rreRIJ;IIII. HaII60JIee MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbI l\IOrIIJIbHIIRII
TarapCROH RYJIbTYPbI, OTHOCHIIJ;eHCH K CKII<PCKOMY BpeMeHII 9. OHa xapaKTe-
pIIsyeTcH RypraHaMII paSHOH BeJIII'IIlHbI C orpOMHLIl\1II MeHrIIpaMII (KYJIbTO-
BbIMII nal\IHTHIIKaMII) Ha HIIX. IIHBeHTapb norpe6eHIIII npe,I:(CTaBJIeH 6aHo'I-
HbIMII cocy):(aMII, 60JIbIIIIIM Ha60pOM 6poHsoBoro opymlIH nosp;HIIX <pOPM-
KIIHIRaJIaMII, 60eBbIMII TOnOpal\III, BCTpe'IaIOTCH meJIeSHble BeIIJ;II. B 06IIJ;eM
no TIIlliI'IHaH RYJIbTypa palmero meJIeSHOrO BeKa, Rorp;a 6poHsa eIIJ;e
IIIlIpORO IICnOJIbSOBaJIaCb ):(JIH IISrOTOBJIeHIIH 0PY1RIIH II OPY):(IIH, a meJIeSHbIe
npe):(MeTbI 6blml pe):(RII II JJ;OporII.
EIIJ;e K. II. fOpOIIJ;eHRO B Ha'IaJIe BeRa 06paTIIJI BHIIMaHlle Ha TO, 'ITO
'Iepena IIS TarapCRIIX MOrIIJIbHnROB eBponeOII):(HbI, II cpaBUIIBaJI IIX CO CJIa-
BHHCRIIl\III to. Bce rrOCJIegyIOIIJ;IIe IICCJIe):(OBaHIIH TarapcRoH RYJIbTypLI rrog-
TBep)J;IIJIII ero BbIBO,I:( 0 eBponeOII):(HOM TIIne TarapCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH H. 3ua-
'IeHlIe 8Toro BbIBop;a COCTOIIT B TOM, 'ITO mIIpORIIII MaCCIIB eBponeOIIp;OB 6bIJI
npeJJ;CTaBJIeH sa p;Be C nOJIOBIIHOH TbICH'III JIeT P;O COBpeMeHHoCTII Ha TeppII-
TOpIIII, ROTOPYIO HaCeJIHIOT CeH'IaC xaRaCbI - JIIO):(II l\IOHrOJIOII):(Horo 06JIIIKa.
o npOIIcxo1R):(eHIUI TarapCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH BbICRaSbIBaJIIICb paSHbIe rIInOTe-
SLI, HalI60JIee pacnpOCTpaHeHHaH lIS HIIX cBoJJ;IIJIaCb K npe):(CTaBJIeHIIIO 0
nepeCeJIeHIIII ero oTRy):(a-To C sana):(a, IIS paHOHOB cOBpeMeHHoro paCceJIe-
HIIH eBponeolI):(OB, CKopee Bcero, lIS CTenHbIX paHOHOB BOCTO'IHOH EBpOnbI.
O):(rraRO OT 8Toro npe):(nOJIOmeHIIH npIIlliJIOCb oTRasaTbCH, RaK TOJIbRO
6bIJIII orrIIcaHbI CReJIeTbI JIIO):(eH 3HeOJIIITII'IeCROH a<paHaCbeBCROH KYJIbTYPbI
TOH me 06JIaCTII 12. OCTpO):(OHHbIe COCYP;bI lIS nJIOCKIIX, BbIJIOmeHHbIX Ral\I-
i
!
i
I
I
j
j
i!
I
7 B. II. AJIeHCeeB
193
I
:1 1 .
HHMII KypraHoB, COBCeM MaJIO 6pOHSOBbIX BeIIJ;eH - BOT OCHOBHbIe XapaKTe-
pIICTIIKII, peSKO OTJIII'IaIOIIJ;IIe ee OT TarapCKOH KYJIbTypbI. HII 0 KaKOH
Onpep;eJIeHHOH KYJIbTypHOH rrpeeMCTBeHHOCTII Memp;y HaCeJIeHlIeM 3TIIX JJ;BYX
KYJIbTYP rOBopIITb He npIIxop;IITCH. B TO me Bpel\IH a<paHaCbeBCKaH nony-
JIHIJ;IIH MOp<pOJIOI'II'IeCKII OKaSaJIaCb HaCTOJIbKO CXOP;HOH C TarapCKOII, qTO 3TO
aBTOMaTII'IeCKII npep;peIIIaeT nOJIOmIITeJIbHbIH OTBeT Ha Bonpoc 06 IIX pop;-
CTBe II npOIIcxom):(eHIIII TarapCKoro HaCeJIeHIIH OT a<paHacbeBcKoro. TaKIIM
06pasoM, npii OTCyTCTBIIII KYJIbTypHOH npeeMCTBeHHOCTII HaJIIIIJ;O <pIISII'IeCKOe
POJJ;CTBO, cBIIgeTeJIbCTBYIOIIJ;ee 06 aBTOXTOHHOM paSBIITIIII TarapCKoro HaCeJIe-
nIIH Ha OCHOBe a<paHaCbeBCKoro II 0 npeel\ICTBeHHOCTII HaCeJIeHIIH XaKaCIIII
C Ha'IaJIa II TbICH'IeJIeTIIH P;O H. 3. BnJIOTb P;O pyoema HaIIIeH 3pbI. 8Ta npe.-
eMCTBeHHOCTb TeM 60JIee yp;IIBIITeJIbHa, 'ITO B TO BpeMH Ha 8TOH TeppiiTopIIII
CYllJ;eCTBOBaJIII ellJ;e lIBe apxeOJIOI'II'IeCKIIe KYJIbTypbI - aHp;pOHOBCKaH II
RapaCyi{CKaH, HaCeJIeHIIe KOTOpbIX OTJIII'IaJIOCb IIHbIl\III aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIl\III
'IepTaMII.
CJIep;yIOIIJ;IIH npIIMep nepeHOCIIT Hac B JIeCHYIO II JIeCOCTennyro SOHbI
BOCTO'IHOH EBponbI II CBHsaH C <pOpMIIpOBaHIIeM BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKoro Ha-
CeJIeHIIH. 8THoreHes BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX HapOJJ;OB, npep;CTaBJIHIOIIJ;IIH COOOH,
KaK IISBeCTHO, OP;HY lIS CJIOmHeHllIIIX np06JIeM 3THII'IeCKOH IICTOplIlI EBpo-
nbI, nOpop;IIJI rpOMap;HyIO JIIITepaTYPY II MHoro rllnOTes, 'IaCTO npOTIIBOpe-
'IaIIJ;IIX op;Ha JJ;PyrOH. II CeH'IaC npOp;OJImaIOTCH cnopbI 0 npapop;IIHe C.rraBHH.
HaII60JIee pacnpOCTpaHeHHbIM B COBeTCRoH JIIITepaType HBJIHeTCH npep;CTaB-
JIeHIIe 0 npapop;IIHe CJIaBHH B IJ;eJIOM B IIpIIKapnaTCKOH 06JIaCTII, 0 paCceJIe-
HIm npep;KOB BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX Hapop;OB oTTyga II 06 Y'IaCTIIJI B IIX
3THoreHese MeCTHbIX, oaJITIIiICKIIX II <pIIHCKIIX nJIeMeH. 06sop OTHOCHIIJ;IIXCH
K 3TOH np06JIeMe apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIX <paKTOB B conOCTaBJIeHIIII C IICTOpIIKO-
3THorp a <pII'IeCKIIMII II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIl\III cop;epmIIT KHIITa B. B. CeJJ;oBa,
nop;Bop;HIIJ;aH IITor KaK COBeTCKIIM, TaK II sapy6emHbIM IICCJIep;OBaHIIHM 13.
COOTHOIIIeHIIe p;OCJIaBHHCKoro cy6cTpaTa II CJIaBHnCKoro cynepcTpaTa OCTaeT-
CH HeHCHbIl\I, If MnorIIe KOHKpeTHble pa60TbI cneIJ;IIaJIIICTOB paSHoro npO<p II -
JIH nOCBHIIJ;eHbI BbIHCHeHIIIO pomI MeCTHoro cy6cTpaTa B <pOpl\IIIpOBaHIIII
BOCTO'IHbIX CJIaBHH, XOTH pOJIb 3Ta nOKa npep;CTaBJIHeTCH ne O'IeHb SHa'III-
TeJIbHOH.
ITaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIiI MaTepIIaJI B 8TOH cIITyaIJ;HII IIpII06peTaeT OCo-
60e SHa'ieHIIe, TaK KaK nOSBOJIHeT npOCJIep;IITb IICTOpIIIO <pIISII'IeCKIIX npeJJ;-
KOB BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKlIX napop;OB P;O 3nOXII 6pOHSbI. OCYllJ;eCTBJIeHHbIe
T. A. TpO<pIIMOBOH II T. II. AJIeKCeeBOH CBOP;KII naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
p;aHHblx no BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIM Hapop;aM oXBaTbIBaIOT Bce BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHH-
CKIIe nJIeMeHa a. Ony6JIIIKOBaHHble nosme CTaTbII MaJIO 'ITO JJ;06aBIIJIII K
3TIIM paOOTaM 15. K COmaJIeHIIIO, naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOI'IIH HaCeJIeHIIH BOCTO'IHO-
EBponeHcKoH paBHIIHbI KOHIJ;a I TbICH'IeJIeTIIH P;O H. 8.- I TbICH'IeJIeTIIH H. 3.
IISBeCTHa nJIOXO, HO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOI'IIH HaCeJIenIIH paHHeH nopbI paHHero
meJIeSHOrO BeKa (CKII<pCKoe BpeMH) II 3nOXII 6pOHSbI IISY'IeHa p;OCTaTO'IHO
nOJIHO.
Kamp;oe lIS cpep;neBeKOBbIX BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHnCKIIX nJIeMeH OTJIII'IaJIOCb
cBoe06paSIIeM, KOTopoe npOHBJIHJIOCb B paMKax BnOJIHe onpeJJ;eJIeHHOrO KOMn-
JIeKCa npiiSHaKOB. Ero MomHO C'IlITaTb Ha ypOBHe JIOKaJIbHOH paCbI ):(OCTa-
TO'IHO rOMoreHHbIM, II OH 6bIJI xapaKTepeH P;JIH BOCTO'IHbIX CJIaBHH B IJ;eJIOM.
Ha6JIIOJJ;aeTCH SHa'IIITeJIbnOe CXOP;CTBO 3Toro TIIna C TeM aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIM
BapIIaHTOM, KOTOpbIH sa<pIIKCIIpOBaH B CKII<pCKllX MOrIIJIbHIIKax ITpII'IepHO-
MOpbH 16. CXOP;CTBO 8TO, op;HaKO, ne MomeT 6bITb IIHTepnpeTIIpOBaHO KaK
YKasaHIIe Ha reneTII'IeCKOe pOp;CTBO. Pe'Ib, paSYMeeTCH, He IIp;eT 0 npHMOM
npOIIcxomp;eHllII BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX nJIeMeH OT CKII<pOB - TaKaH IIHTeprrpe-
I
I
"
i
194
TaIJ;llH 6bIJIa 6bI CJIIIllIKOM npHMOJIHHeHHOH. Ho HeCOMHeHHO, 'ITO 66JIbIIIaH
'IaCTb HaCeJIeHIIH, npOmllBaBlllerO B IOmHOpYCCKllX CTenHX B cepep;IIHe I TbI-
CH'IeJIeTIIH P;O H. 3., HBJIHeTCH <pIISII'IeCKIIMII npep;KaMII BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX
nJIe1\IeH 8nOXII Cpep;HeBeKOBbH. MeCTHbIe IICTOKII 3THOreHeSa OTOp;BIIraIOTCH,
CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, 60JIbllle 'IeM Ha TbICH'IY JIeT.
Op;HaKO OHII MOryT 6bITb yrJIy6JIeHbI eIIJ;e 60JIbllle. IIaJIeoaHTpOnOJIOrIIJI
KYJIbTYP 8nOXII 6pOnSbI B CTenHbIX II JIeCOCTenHbIX paHOHaX BOCTO'Ino-EBpO-
neHCKOH paBHIIHbI IISY'IeHa p;OCTaTO'IHO XOpOlliO 17. C He60JIbIIIIIMII MOP;II<pII-
RaIJ;IIHMII HaCeJIeHIIe 3TIIX KYJIbTYP 06HapymIIBaeT TO me CO'IeTaHIIe MOP<PO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIX npIISHaKOB, 'ITO II CKII<pCKIIe nonYJIHIJ;IIII. <VOpMIIpOBaHIIe aHTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCKIIX oc06eHHOCTeH CKII<pOB npII SHa'IIITeJIbHOM Y'IaCTIIII HaCeJIeHIIH
8nOXII 6pOHSbI, oc06eHHO nosp;HeH 6ponSbI, npep;CTaBJIHeTCH COBepIIIeHHO
neCOMHeHUbIM. TaKIIM 06paSOM, IICTOKII <pOpMIIpOBaHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO
TIIna BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX HapOJJ;OB MorYT 6bITb p;OBeJJ;eHbI P;O cepegIIHbI
II TbICH'IeJIeTIIH P;O n. 3. 8TO OSHa'iaeT, 'ITO aBTOXTOHHble OCHOBbI BOCTO'IHO-
CJIaBHHCKoro 8THoreHesa peKOHCTpYIIPyIOTCH C nOMOIIJ;bIO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII-
'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX Ha npOTHmeHIIII MIIHIIMYM P;BYX TbICH'IeJIeTIIiI.
rOpHble 06JIaCTII B nOJJ;aBJIHIOIIJ;eM 60JIbIIIIIHCTBe CJIy'IaeB 6bIJIII SOHaMII
IISOJIHIJ;IIII, BbISbIBaBIIIeH rJIy60Kyro 3TnOKYJIbTypHYIO II HSbIKOBYIO p;n<p<pepeH-
IJ;IIaIJ;IIIO. CeBepHbIH KaBKas II 3aKaBKaSbe npep;CTaBJIHIOT C060H XOpOllIIIH
npII1\Iep TaKoII SOHbI C 60JIbIIIIIM pasno06paSIIeM KopeHHbIX HapO):(OB, IIX HSbI-
KOBOH II KYJIbTYPHOH Heop;HopOP;HOCTbIO. HaKOnJIeHHble p;aHnble IICTOpIIKO-
KYJIbTypHoro II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKOrO xapaKTepa cBIIgeTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 TOM, 'ITO
npeAKII MHOrIIX COBpeMeHHbIX KaBKaSCKIIX Hapop;OB npIIHeCJIII C C060H HSbIK
II pH):( KYJIbTypHbIX 3JIeMenTOB npII SaCeJIeHIIII TeppIITopIIII KaBKasa Ha paR-
HbIX OTpeSKax IICTOpIIII. TaKOBbI apMHHe II asep6aIIp;iHaHIJ;bI B 3aKaBKaSbe,
oceTIIHbl, Kapa'iaeBIJ;bI II 6ammpIJ;bI na CeBepHOM KaBKase. Ho nOp;aBJIHIO-
IIJ;ee 60JIbllIIIHCTBO MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbIX KaBKaSCKIIX Hapop;OB rOBopHT ua MeCT-
HbIX, RaBKaSCKIIX HSbIKax, He IIMeIOIIJ;IIX HCHblX aHaJIOrIIH sa npep;eJIa1\III
KaBRasa 18, II xapaKTepIISYIOTCH B BbICOKOH CTeneHII CneIJ;II<pII'IeCKOH, c<pop-
MIIpOBaBllIeHCH B ropHOH MeCTHOCTII II BO MHorOM CXO):(HOH RYJIbTYPOH 19.
KaKoBa pOJIb naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX JJ;aHHblX no OTHOIIIeHIIIO R p;eMOH-'
CTpaIJ;IIll MeCTHblX OCHOB 3THoreHesa KaBKaSCKIIX napop;OB? CTeneHb IISY'IeH-
nOCTII naJIeOaUTpOnOJIOrIIII KaBKasa p;aJIeKO ne COOTBeTcTByeT 1\IaCIIITa6y Tep-
pIITOpIIII II ee JIaHp;IIIa<pTHoMY pasHo06pasIIIO, n08TOMY B p;aHHOM CJIY'Iae
3<p<peKTIIBHo KOMnJIeKCHOe paCC1\IOTpenIIe KaK c06cTBeHHo naJIeOaHTpOnOJIO-
rII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB, TaK II peSYJIbTaTOB aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO 06CJIep;OBa-
HIIH COBpeMeUHoro HaCeJIeHIIH. B npewopnbIX II ropHbIX paHoHax IJ;eHTpaJIb-
HOH 'IaCTII KaBKascKoro xpe6Ta npomIIBaIOT llapO):(bI, Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKII BeCbMa
CXO):(HbIe II 06HapymIIBaIOIIJ;IIe cBoe06pasHblH ROMnJIeKC aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
npIIsnaKOB, nOJIY'IIIBIIIIIH HaIIMeHOBaHIIe KaBKaCIIOHCKoro (no rpYSIIHCKOMY
HaIIMeHOBaHIIIO KaBKasa - KaBKacIIoHII) 20. 8TOT KOMnJIeKC npIISHaKOB
OXBaTbIBaeT He TOJIbKO Hapop;bI, rOBOpHIQIIe Ha KapTBeJIbCKIIX, p;areCTaHCKIIX
]il HaXCKIIX HSbIKax, I{ HeMy OTHOCHTCH II oceTIIHbI, rOBopHIQIIe Ha OP;HOM
IIS IIpaHCKIIX HSbIKOB, 6aJIKapIJ;bI II Kapa'iaeBIJ;bI, rOBOpHIIJ;IIe nO-TIOpKCKII.
TaKIIM 06paSOM, KaBKaCIIOHCKIIH KOMnJIeKC, IIJIII, KaK ero 'IaCTO HaSbIBaIOT
B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOH JIIITepaType, TIIn, IIMeeT 0611IIIpHbIH apeaJI II npIIBH-
3aH K HaII60JIee TIInII'IHbIM II llIIIpOKO pacnpOCTpaHeHHbIM RaBKaSCKIIM JIanp;-
IIIa<pTaM.
KaKoBo npOIIcxomJJ;eHlle KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna? HBJIHeTCH OH MeCTnbIM
Ha KaBRase IIJIII npIIHecen BMeCTe C npIIXop;OM B IJ;eHTpaJIbHbIe paHOHbI
rJIaBHOrO KaBKascKoro xpe6Ta IIHopop;Horo naCeJIenIIH? Ha 8TOT C'IeT BbI-
CKasaHO HeCKOJIbKO rIInOTes, B OCHOBe KOTOpbIX JIemlIT OTCYTCTBIIe OIIJ;YTII-
I
195
7*
I
MbIX aHaJIOrnH B naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM Ma TepIIaJIe no BceMY KaBKasy
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIlM oc06eHHOCTHM COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH. Ha 3TOM OCHO-
BaHIlII BbICKaSbIBaJIaCb MbICJIb, 'ITO KaBKaCIlOHCKIIH KOMnJIeKC npIISHaKOB eCTb
nosp;Hee 06paSOBaHIIe, C<pOpMIlpOBaBIIIeeCH 'IYTb Jill He B 3IIOXY nosp;Hero
cpep;HeBeKOBbH 2\ a 3TO OSHa'IaeT, 'ITO p;aHHble 0 HeM HeJIbSH IICnOJIbSOBaTb
P;JIH cymp;eHIIH 06 aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOH p;IlHaMIIKe B rJIy60KoH ):(peBHOCTII.
8TOMY npOTIIBOpe'IIlT, op;HaKO, TOT 6eSYCJIOBHbIH <paKT, 'ITO J\,wP<P0JIOrIl'IeCKII
CXOP;HbIH C KaBKaCIIonCKIlM KOMIIJIeKC npiiSHaROB sa<pIlKCIIpOBaH B OT,l],eJIb-
IIbIX paHOHax CeBepHoro KaBKasa II 3aKaBKaSbH B 3noxy 6pOHSbI 22.
BbICKaSbIBaJIaCb II IlHaH MbICJIb - 0 TpaHc<popMaIJ;IIIl aHTpOnOJIOrIl'IeCKIlX
npiiSHaKOB BO BpeMeHII Ha TeppIITopIlII KaBKasa, npII KOTOpOH TeM He Me-
nee npiiSHaeTCH reHeTII'IeCKaH IIpee1\ICTBeUHOCTb COBpeMeHHoro II p;peBHero
HaCeJIeHIIH 23. Op;HaKO TaKOH nop;xop; TPY):(HO COBMeCTIlTb C 06'beKTIIBHbIMII
Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKIlMII na6JIIOP;eHIlHMIl: reHeTIl'IeCKaH npeeMCTBeHHOCTb nOCTy-
JIIlpyeTcH, HO OHa ne MOif\eT ObITb JJ;OKasana, KOJIb CKOpO Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKIIe
oc06eHHOCTII nop;BepraIOTCH SHa'IIlTeJIbnbIM IISMeHeHIlHM. rOpas,l],O 60JIee
BepoHTHo p;pyroe npep;CTaBJIenIIe, KOTopoe Y'IIlTbIBaeT naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrII'Ie-
CKIle aHaJIOrIlII cOBpeMeHHoMY HaCeJIeHIIIO B 8noxy 6pOHSbI. BamHo II TO
OOCTOHTeJIbCTBO, 'ITO npe):(CTaBIlTeJIII KaBKaCllOHCKoro TIIna 'IpeSBbI'IaIIHO no-
xomii na BepXHenaJIeOJIIlTII'IeCKOe naCeJIeHIIe EBponbI II nepelIHeH ASIIII.
TaKIIM 06paSOM, B nOCIlTeJIHX KaBKaCIIOHCKoro KOMnJIeKCa aHTpOnOJIOrlI'Ie-
CKIIX npiiSHaKoB Momno BII,l],eTb nOTOMKOB p;peBHeHIIIero HaCeJIeHIlH, sace-
JIIlBIIIerO TeppiiTopIIIO KaBKasa eIIJ;e B 8noxy naJIeOJIIlTa. HIlKaKIl1\III p;py_
rIlMII BIl):(aMll IlCTOpn'IeCKIlX IICTO'IHIlKOB MeCTnbIe IICTOKII 3THoreHesa
KaBKaSCKIIX Hapop;OB He IOrYT 6bITb p;OBep;eHbI JJ;O CTOJIb rJIy60KOll JJ;peB-
HOCTII.
IIpIlBeJJ;8HHble npIIMepbI nOKaSbIBaIOT, 'ITO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIlH Ma-
TepIlaJI 'IpeSBbI'IaHHO Bamen P;JIH Toro, 'IT06bI BOCCTaHOBIlTb MeCTHbIe IICTO-
Kii <pOpMIIpOBaHIIH Tex IIJIIl IlHbIX Hapop;OB II npOCJIe):(IlTb IIX 8THoreHes
P;O rJIy60KoH JJ;peBHOCTII. IIpII BbIXo):(e sa XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKIle paMKII IIIlCMIeH-
noro IIepIlop;a IlCTOpIIII 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa BamHOCTb naJIeOanTpOnOJIOrIl'IeCKOrO
MaTepIlaJIa He MeHbIIIe, 'IeM apXeOJIOrll'IeCKOrO, OHII BsaIIMHO OOOraIQaIOT
p;pyr p;pyra.
Ii!
tl
PEIWHCTPYRD.IUI ,[(PEBHHX MHrp AD.Hn
ITpOCJIep;IIM Tenepb BOSMomHOCTII IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIl'IeCKIIX p;aHHblx B pe-
KoncTpYKQIlII MIlrpaIJ;IloHHbIX npOIJ;eCCOB, IlCnOJIbSYH npIlMepbI B TeppIITo-
pIlaJIbHOM OTHOIIIeIIIlII 6JInSKIle K npIIBep;eHHbIM. Ho npemp;e HymHo nOp;'IepK-
nYTb paSJIIl'IIIe Mem):(y HBJIeHIlHMIl, KOTopble 'IpeSBbI'IaHHO BamHbI JJ;JIH p;aJIb-
neHIIIero IISJIOmeHIIH, HO Hep;OCTaTO'IHO 'IeTKO p;II<p<pepeHIJ;IlpYIOTCH B
IICTOpIIKO-8THorp a <p n 'IeCKOH II aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOH JIIITepaType. Pe'Ib nJJ;eT 0
He06xop;IlMOCTII paSJIIl'IaTb MIlrpaIJ;IlOHHbIH nOTOK KaK nepeCeJIeHIIe Ha HO-
BYIO TeppiiTopIIIO 60JIbIIIIIX Macc JIIOp;eH, KOTopoe MomeT 6bITb II O):(HoMoMeHT-
nbIM, II p;OCTaTO'IHO npoJJ;OJImnTeJIbHbIM BO BpeMenII, II aHTpOnOJIOrIl'IecKyIO
P;Il<P<PYSIlIO, IIPII KOTOpOH IIJJ;eT Mep;JIeHHaH II IlHorp;a npo):(OJImaIOIIJ;aHcH MHO-
1'0 nOKOJIenIIH IIH<pIIJIbTpaIJ;IlH JIIO):(eH C TeMII IIJIIl IIHbIMII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKII-
MIl npiiSHaRaMII B IIHYIO aHTpOnOJIOrIl'IecKyIO cpep;y. 3a C'IeT KaKorO-TO
npOIJ;eHTa 6paKOB, SaKJIIO'IaeMbIX B 8TOM CJIY'Iae Mem):(y HOCIITeJIH1\I1I pas-
HbIX aHTpOnOJIOrIl'IeCKIIX npiiSHaKOB, BblpameHHOCTb 3TIlX npiiSHaKOB )Cle,l.J,-
JIeHHO YCIlJIIlBaeTCH B npe):(eJIax Tex TeppIITopIlH, rJJ;e OHn He 6bIJIIl npe,l],-
CTaBJIeHbI paHbIIIe. ECJIII P;II<P<PYSIIH II):(eT op;HOHanpaBJIeHHO, TO B KOIIIJ;e
IWHQOB BblpameHnOCTb IIHopO):(Horo KOMIIJIeKCa aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIlX npiiSHa-
196
KOB p;OCTIITaeT TaKOH CTeneHII, 'ITO OU JIerKO <pIIKcIIPyeTcH B xop;e naJIeO-
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO IICCJIep;OBaUIIH.
B:bIIIIe OTMe'IaJIOCb, 'ITO B XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKOM npOl\IemyTKe Memp;y a<pa-
HaCbeBCKIIM II TarapCKIIM HaCeJIeHlleM B MIIHYCIIHCROH KOTJIOBIIHe no 6epe-
raM' EUIIceH II ero npIITOKOB npOmIIBaJIII JIIOP;II eIIJ;e P;BYX KYJIbTYP 8nOXII
OpOHSbI-aHJJ;pOHOBCROH II RapaCYRCKOH. B OTHOIIIeHIIII aup;pOHOBCKOH KyJIb-
TYp:bI peSYJIbTaTbI IIsy emIH apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIX II naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
MaTepIIaJIOB COBna):(aIOT. HaII60JIee BepOHTHaH 06JIaCTb ee <pOpl\IIIpOBaHIIH-
sanap;HbJe II QeHTpaJIbubJe paHOHbI Ka3axcTaHa, a TaKme IOmHoe IIpII-
ypaJIbe 2 . AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIe oc06enHOCTII aHp;pOHOBCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH
3TIIX paHOHOB 6JIIISI{Il K aHTpOnOJIOrrr'IeCRoMy TIIny aHgpOHOBCKIIX nonyJIH-
IJ;IIH MIIHYCIIHCKOH KOTJIOBIIHbI, HO aHgpOHOBCKIIe MOrlIJIbHIIRII KasaxcTaHa
n IIpIlYpaJIbH OTHOCHTCH K 60JIee paHUel\IY BpeMeHII, 'IeM pacnOJIOmeHHble
no 6eperaM EHllceH. TaKIIM 06paSOM, npIIIIIJIOe npOIIcxomp;eHIIe au):(pOHOB-
lWB MIIHyCIIHCROH KOTJIOBIIH:bI 60JIee 'IeM BepOHTHO. KaKoH-To KOHTaRT
Memp;y a<paHaCbeBCRIIM II aHgpOHOBCRIIM HaCeJIeUIIeM, 6e3YCJIOBHO, CYIIJ;eCT-
BOJ.laJI, 0 'IeM rOBopIIT HaJIII'IIIe a<paHaCbeBCKIIX no CBOel\IY Mop<pOJIOrlI'Ie-
CKOMY TIIny 'IepenOB B aHp;pOlIOBCROH RpaHllOJIOrII'IeCKOH cepIIII, 'ITO ObIJIO
OTMe'IeHO r. cD. )J,e6eIJ;OM 25. A<paHaCbeBCKoe HaCeJIeHIIe, Ha OCUOBe KOTO-
poro C<popMIIpOBaJIOCb TarapCKoe, npOgOJImaJIO npomIIBaTb B RaKIIX-TO
paHOHax MIIHYCIIHCROII KOTJIOBIIHbI II B 3noxy CYIIJ;eCTBOBaHIIH aH;:J:pOHOBCROH
KYJIbTYPbI. Ho naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIH B p;OnOJIHeHIIe K apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKIIM Ha6mo
p;eHIIHM npIIHOCIIT 1l0KaSaTeJIbCTBO TOMy, 'ITO B MIIHyCIIHCRIIX CTenHX B 8no-
xy paSBIITOH oponSbI nOHBIIJICH SHa'IIITeJIbHbIH MaCCIIB HOBoro HaCeJIeHIIH,
npIIrnegHIerO no CTenUOH nOJIOce C sanap;a.
HaCeJIeHIIe anOXII nosp;HeH 6pOHSbI, IIMeHyeMoH KapaCYRCKOH, TaKme HB-
JIHeTCH npllIIIJIbIM, HO caMa np06JIeMa ero npOIIcxomp;eHIIH CJIOmHa II He no-
JIY'IIIJIa OgHOSHa'IHOrO peIIIeHIIH B apXeOJIOrll'IeCROH II naJIeOaUTpOnOJIOrII'Ie-
CROH JIIITepaType. C. B. MCeJIeB npHBeJI 60JIbIIIOe 'IIICJIO aHaJIOrIIII KapaCYK-
CROH KyJIbType B KYJIbTypax 8nOXII OpOHSbI CeBepHoro KIITaH II nocTyJIIIpOBaJI
ee npIIHIJIOe lOrO-BOCTO'IHOe npOIIcxomp;eHIIe ):(JIH MIIHyCIIHCKOH KOTJIOBII-
HbI 26. Y6emp;eHHbIH ero apryMeHTaMII, r. cD. )J,e6eQ TaRme CBflSbIBaJI npo-
IIcxomp;eHIIe KapaCYKCRoro naCeJIeHIIH C nonYJIHIJ;IIHMII ceBepHbIX paHOHOB
KIITaH II C npO):(BlImeHIIeM IIMeHUO IIX B MIIHYCIIUCKYIO KOTJIOBIIHY 27. 0):(-
HaRO XOTH CpegII KapacyKIJ;eB II 6bIJIa Ue60JIbHIaH MOHrOJIOIIp;HaH npIIl\IeCb,
HO B IJ;eJIOM IIX MO}KHO OTHeCTII K 'Ie TKO BblpameHHbIM eBponeOIIp;aM.
Ha 8TOM OCHOBaHIIII, a TaKme nOCJIe conOCTaBJIeHIIH Bcero KOl\InJIeRCa MOp-
<pOJIOrn'IeCRIIX npIISHaROB 6bIJIO BbICRasaHO MHeHIIe, 'ITO KapaCYKCKoe Hace-
JIeHIIe MIIUYCIIHCROH IWTJIOBIIHbI IIMeJIO ue roro-BOCTO'IHOe npOIIcxomp;eHIIe,
a IOro-sana):(Hoe II BOCXO):(IIT B CBoeM reHeSIIce K p;peBHeMY HaCeJIeHllIO Ka-
saXCTaHa II CpeJJ;HeH ASIIII. TOMY 6bIJIII uaH):(eHbI naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe
p;oKaSaTeJIbCTBa, II rIInOTesa 3Ta IIoJIy'IIIJIa nOJJ;JJ;epmKY B HOBeiIrneH cBop;Ke
no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII KapaCYKCROH KYJIbTypbI 28 .
llIICJIO KapaCYKCRIIX MOrIIJIbHIIKOB TaKOBO, 'ITO OHII CBIIgeTeJIbCTBYIOT:
B MIIHYCIIHCKOH ROTJIOBIIHe B 3noxy nosp;ueH 6pOHSbI nOHBIIJICH eIIJ;e OllIIH
MOIIJ;UbIII MaCCIIB UOBoro HaCeJIeHIIH II, CJIe):(OBaTeJIbHO, nOCJIe nOHBJIeHIIH
a<paHaCbeBQeB sp;eCb IIMeJIa MeCTO yme TpeTbH 06HIIIpHaH MIIrpaQIIH. IIaJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIH MaTepIIaJI nOSBOJIIIJI npaBIIJIbHO onpeJJ;eJIIITb IICXOgHbIe
paHoHbI II HanpaBJIeHIIe 3TIIX MIIrpaQIIiI.
197
AHTPOIIOJIOrHQECRAH }J;H(f)(f)Y3HH
I
3THoreHes BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKHX HapOp;OB CTaJIKHBaeT HaC C HBJIeHlIeM, KOTO-
poe BbIllie 6bIJIO HaSBaHO aUTpOnOJIOrII'IeCIWH P;1I<P<PYSHeH. Pe'Ib Hp;eT 0 npo-
Hcxom):(eHIIII Toro KOMIIOHeHTa B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM COCTaBe BOCTO'IHbIX
CJIaBHU, KOTOpbIH ue CBHsaH npeeMCTBeHHO C aUTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII oc06eH-
HOCTHMII ):(peBuero aBTOXTOHHoro UaCeJIeHIIH II HBJIHeTCH npHIIIJI])lM. B no-
HIIMaHIIII reHeSIIca 3Toro KOMnOHeHTa BeJIIIKa pOJIb KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX JJ;aH-
HbIX no cOBpeMeHHoMy IIJIH 6JIIISKOMY K cOBpeMeHHocTII HaCeJIeHIIIO. IIsy-
'IeHIIe KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKOrO TIIna PYCCKIIX, YKpaIIHIJ;eB II 6eJIOPycCOB
nOKaSaJIO, 'ITO OHII B IJ;eJIOM OTJIII'IaIOTCH OT BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX nJIeMeH
3nOXII Cpe,l],HeBeKOBbH HeKoTopbIMII Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII p;eTaJIHMII, B KOTO-
pbIX noxomll Ha cpep;HeBeKoBble uonYJIHIJ;IIII IIS apeaJIa cOBpeMeHHblx sana,l],-
UOCJIaBHHCKIIX uapOJJ;OB 29. 8TII npllSHaKH B COBpeMeHHOM HaCeJIeHIIH BbIpa-
meHbI 60JIee CIIJIbUO, 'IeM cpe):(H Cpe,l],HeBeKOBbIx BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX nJIeMeH.
KaK 8TO 06'bHCHIITb? IIO-BIIP;IIMOMY, IIPII <POpMIIpoBaHIIII BOCTO'IHOCJIa-
BHUCKHX HapoJJ;oB SUa'IIITe:rbuaH pOJIb npIIHaJJ;JIemaJIa 8JIeMeHTaM, npIIllIJIbIM
IIS 06rneH CJIaBHHCKoH npapo):(IIHbI. IIomaJIYH, HaIIUOJIbIIIee 'IIICJIO CTOPOH-
UIIKOB IIMeeT rIInOTesa npIIKapnaTcKoH npapop;IIHbI CJIaBHH, nouIIMaeMoH B
IIIIIpOKOM CMbICJIe, T. e. C BKJIIO'IeHIIeM B Hee II coceJJ;HIIx 06JIaCTeH. CneIJ;II-
<pII'IeCKIIe 'IepTbI Cxop;cTBa cOBpeMeHHblx BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHHCKIIX Hapop;oB co
CpeJJ;UeBeKOBbIM HaCeJIeHIIeM IIpIIKapnaTcKoro apeaJIa TaKme cBIIJJ;eTeJIbCT-
ByroT B nOJIbsy npIIKapnaTcKoH npapop;IIHbI CJIaBHH. HIIKaKIIe IIIICbMeHHbIe
IICTO'IHIIKH He C006IIJ;aIOT 0 nepeCeJIeHIlli 60JIbIIIIIX MaCCIIBOB HaCeJIeHIIH lIS
06JIaCTII CJIaBHHCKOH npapO,l],IIHbI ua TeppIITopllIO BOCTO'IHOH EBponbI. Cp;BIIr
B aHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCKOM TIIne COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH no cpaBHeHIIIO C 8IIO-
XOH cpeJJ;HeBeKOBbH MomHO 06'bHCHIITb, TOJIbKO IIPIIHHB rIIIIoTesy 0 MeJJ;:reH-
HOH IIH<pIIJIbTpaIJ;IIH HOBoro, npIIllIJIOrO HS npIIKapnaTCKIIx pallOHOB HaCeJIe-
HIIH Ha npOTHmeHIIII nepBbIx BeKOB II TbICH'Ie:reTIIH H. 8. II 0 ero 6pa'IHbIX
KOHTaKTax C MeCTHbIMII IIOIIYJIHIJ;IIHMII, aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIiI COCTaB KOTOpbIX,
KaK 6bIJIO nOKasaHO BbIIIIe, BOCXO):(IIT K HaCeJIeHIIIO 8nOXII UpOHSbI. TaKoe
MeJJ;JIeHHOe IIpOHIIKHOBeHIfe UOBbIX 8TUII'IeCKIIX 8JIeMeUTOB, aUTpOnOJIOrII'Ie-
CKII OTJIll'IaIOIIJ;IIXCH OT aBTOXTOHUbIX, llIe,l],llIee Ha IIpOTHmeHIIII MHorIIX rrOKO-
JIeHIIH, He MeHHH peSKO Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKUX oc06eHHOCTeH MeCTHoro 8THII'Ie-
CKoro KOMnoueHTa, TpaHc<popMIIpyeT IIX B TO me BpeMH B onpep;eJIeHHOM
HanpaBJIeHIIII. TaKllM oupaSOM, 8THoreues BOCTO'IHOCJIaBHUCKIIX HapO,l],OB
npe,l],CTaBJIHeT COUOH C aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOH TO'IKII speHIIH IIpOQecc aBTOXTon-
Horo paSBIITIIH Ha'IIIHaH C 3IIOXII IIOS):(HeH 6pOHSbI, HO conpOBom):(aBIIIIIHCH
aHTpOnO.TIOrU'IeCKOH .D:II<p<pYSIIeH C IOro-sanap;a, npIIXOp;HIIJ;eHCH Ha nepBble
BeKa II TbICH'IeJIeTIIH H. 8.
ECJIII, paCCMaTpIIBaH IICTOpIIIO CTeIIHbIX nJIeMeH MIIUYCIIHCKOH KOTJIOBII-
IIbI B 8noxy 6pOHSbI, IICCJIe,l],OBaTeJIJI CTOJIKHYJIIICb C HeCKOJIbKIIMII MaCCOBbI-
MII MIIrpaQIIHMII, a npII paCCMOTpeHIIII 8THoreHesa BOCTO'IHbIX CJIaBHH-
C aHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCROH P;II<P<PYSIIeH, TO Ha TeppIITopIIH KaBKasa HaJIIIQO He-
CKOJIbKO nO'ITII npOMemYTO'IHbIX CJIY'IaeB - KOJIII'IeCTBeHHO MaJIOMOIIJ;UbIe
MHrpaIJ;IIII, MaJIO saTpOHYBIIIIIe <pIISII'IeCKIIH TIIn MeCTuoro HaCeJIeHllH, XOTH
II OTJIOmIIBIIIIIeCH B HSbIKe II KYJIbType. Oc06eHHo HCHble npuMepbI TaKIIX
MIIrpaQIIU: ):(eMoHcTpIIpyeT 3THoreHes oceTIIH, 6aJIKapIJ;eB II Kapa'IaeBQeB.
B nepBOM cJIy'Iae pe'Ib II):(eT 0 BHep;peHIIII B aBTOXTOHHbIH KaBKaSCKIIH Mllp
IIpaHCKoro 3JIeMeHTa, BO BTOpOM - TIOpKCKoro.
EIIJ;e B. <D. MIIJIJIep nOKaSaJI IIpaHCKyIO OCHOBY oceTIIHCKOH KYJIbTYPbI
II 6eccnopHyIO npIIHa,l],JIemHOCTb oceTllHCKoro HSbIKa K IIpaHcKoH rpynne
HSbIKOB 30. II CeH'IaC OH paCCMaTpIIBaeTCH KaK OP;llH IIS BXOP;HIIJ;IIX B
198
npaUCKyro BeTBb IIHp;OIIpaUCKIIX HSbIKOB. O,l],HaKO JJ;aJIbHeHllIIIe IICCJIe):(OBaHIIH
npOp;eMOUCTpIIpOBaJIII He,l],OCTaTO'IHOCTb O):(HOSHa'iHO IIpaHCROH rIInOTeSbI,
BbIHBIIB SHa'IIITeJIbHbIH aBTOXTOHHbIH nJIaCT B OCeTIIHCKOH KyJIbType II ue Me-
Hee SHa'IIITeJIbHbIH CYOCTpaT B OCeTIIHCROM HSbIRe ". AHTponoJIorII'IecRoe
06CJIep;OBaHIIe COBpeMeHUbIX oceTIIH, a TaKiRe IISY'IeUIIe IIX RpaHIIOJIOrll'Ie-
CKoro TIIna p;aJIII peSYJIbTaTbI, KOTopble nOSBOJIHIOT nop;):(epmaTb BbIBO):(bI,
CJJ;eJIaHHbIe IICCJIep;OBaTeJIHMII RyJIbTypbI oceTIIH II IIX HSbIKa, C TOH JIIIllIb
paSHllQeH, 'ITO orpOMHaH pOJIb MeCTHoro cy6cTpaTa BbIHBJIHeTCH aHTpOnOJIO-
rII'IeCKIIMII p;aHHbIMII C 60JIbllIeH OT'IeTJIIIBOCTbIO. OceTIIHbI HBJIHIOTCH TIIIIIIq-
HbIMII npep;CTaBIITeJIHMII aBTOXTOHHoro RaBRaCIIOHCRoro TIIna, 0 KOTOpOM
rOBOpIIJIOCb BbIllIe, npII'IeM OT,l],eJIbHbIe xapaRTepHbIe 'IepTbI ero BblpameUbI
eIIJ;e CIIJIbHee, 'IeM y p;pyrIIX uapop;OB, HaCeJIHIOIIJ;IIX IJ;eHTpaJIbHble paHOHbI
r JIaBHOrO KaBRascRoro xpeoTa.
ECTb Jill KaKIIe-JIII60 JJ;ORaSaTeJIbCTBa HeMeCTHOH npIIMeCII B aHTpOnOJIO-
rII'IeCKOM COCTaBe oceTIIHCRoro Hapop;a? IIcTOpII'IeCRIIe IICTO'IHIIKII C006IIJ;aIOT
00 IIpaHOHSbI'IUbIX Cpe,l],HeBeROBbIX aJIaHaX, IIMeBIIIIIX, nO-BIIp;IIMOMy, cpe):(He-
aSIIaTCKoe npOIIcxomJJ;eHIIe II SaCeJIHBllIIIX YliJ;eJIbH CeBepHoro KaBKasa,
B TOM 'IIICJIe II HbIDellIHeH OceTIIII. Mop<p0JIOrII'IeCKII OHII CYIIJ;eCTBeHHO OT-
JIll'IaJIIICb OT UOCIITeJIeH RaBKaCIIOHCRoro KOMnJIeKCa npIISHaROB, II n08TOMY
IIX 6pa'IHbIe KOHTaKTbI C MeCTHbIM HaCeJIeUIIeM, 6YP;b OHII Sna'IIITeJIbHbIMII,
He MOrJIII He CRasaTbCH B IISMeHeHIIII <pIISII'IeCKOrO TIIna MeCTHoro naceJIe-
TIIIH. Memp;y TeM TaRIIe IISMeHeUIIH He rrpOCJIemllBaIOTCH 32. 06'bHCHeHIIe
3Toro MomeT 6bITb JJ;BOHKoro po):(a: JIII60 aJIaHCRaH 8THII'IeCRaH cpe,l],a 6bIJIa
MaJIO'IIICJIeUHa no cpaBHeHIIIO C MeCTHOH, 'ITO BeCbMa BepOHTHO, JIII60 IIs-sa
KaRIIX-TO C0IJ;IIaJIbUbIX OrpaHII'IeHIIH aJIaIIbI He BCTynaJIII B 6paKII C MeCT-
HbIMII npep;KaMII COBpeMeHHbIX oceTIIH. B TO me BpeMH nOJIIITII'IeCROe roc-
nogcTBo gaJIO IIM BOSMomHOCTb uaBHsaTb MeCTHOMY HaCeJIeHIIIO CBOll HSbIK,
a C HIIM nepep;aTb II MHoro KYJIbTypHbIX 8JIeMeHTOB. COBpeMeHHble oceTIIHbI
<pIISII'IeCRII HBJIHIOTCH ue nOTOMRaMII npIIllIJIbIX aJIaH, a nOTOMKaMII MeCT-
HbIX nJIeMeH, rOBopIIBIIIIIX pauee Ha O):(HOM IIS KaBKaSCKIIX HSbIROB. AJIaH-
CKIIH cynepcTpaT B HSbIRe II KYJIbType XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKII He yXOP;IIT rJIy6me
3nOXII paHHero cpeJJ;HeBeKOBbH. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p;aHHbIe CBII,l],eTeJIbCT-
BYIOT 06 OTHOCIITeJIbHOH MaJIOMOIIJ;HOCTII aJIaHCKOH MIIrpaIJ;IIII IIS Cpep;HeH
ASIIll Ha CeBepHbIH KaBKas.
AHaJIorII'IHbIe peSYJIbTaTbI p;aeT naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIH Kapa'IaH II BaJIKa-
pIIII. M Kapa'IaeBQbI II 6aJIKapQbI He MeHee TIInII'IHble IIpeJJ;CTaBIITeJIII KaB-
KaCIIOHCKoro TIllIa, 'IeM oceTIIHbI, II 1I03TOMY eCTb Bce OCHOBaUIIH TaRme C'III-
TaTb IIX rrpHMbIMII nOTOMKaMII MeCTHoro p;peBHero UaCeJIeHIIH. Ho npoHIIKHO-
BeHIIe TlOpKCKIIX KO'IeBHIIKOB, CKopee Bcero KIIn'I lKOB, B yIIJ;eJIbH Kapa'iaH
II BaJIKapIIII B nepBble BeKa HaIIIero TbICH'IeJIeTIIH npIIBeJIO K nepexop:y 'Iac-
TII MeCTIIoro HaCeJIeHIIH ua TIOPKCKYIO pe'Ib II K SHa'IIITeJIbHoMy paSBIITIIIO
TIOpKcKoro KOMnOHeHTa B ero KYJIbType. IIO-BII):(IIMOMY, Ha TIOpKCKIIH HSbIR
nepellIJIa 'IaCTb CBaHOB 3\ KOTopble II COCTaBIIJIII MeCTHylO OCHOBY KaK Ka-
pa'iaeBCKOro, TaK II 6aJIKapCKOro 8THoreuesa. TIIIIII'IHOCTb 6aJIKapQeB II Ka-
pa'IaeBIJ;eB KaK HOCIITeJIen RaBKaCIIOHCKoro KOMnJIeKCa npIIsHaKOB II OTCYTCT-
Blle B IIX aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOM COCTaBe RaKOH-JIII60 IIHOpO):(UOH npIIMeCII II
sp;eCb rOBopHT 0 MaJIO'IIICJIeHHOCTII TIOpKCKIIX MIIrpaHTOB, nepeCeJIIIBIIIIIXCH
B yIIJ;eJIbH IIS CTenHbIX palIOuoB.
IITaK, naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIH MaTepIIaJI nOSBOJIHeT peKOHCTpYIIpOBaTb
MaCIIITa6bI II xapaKTep l\IIIrpaQIIoffilbIX nOTOKOB II aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOH P;II<p-
<PYSIIM, a TaKme OlIpe):(eJIHTb IIX HanpaBJIeHIIe. MCnOJIbSOBaHIIe ero ,l],JIH 8TIIX
IJ;eJIeH OJJ;IIHaKOBO 8<p<peKTIIBHO II P;JIH p;peBHIIx 8nox, II P;JIH Cpe)VIeBeKOBbH.
199
I
YCTAHOBJIEHHE BPEMEHII ROIIRPETHbIX 3THOrEHE30B
B OP;HOI! IIS paHHIIX pa60T 0 nYTJIX IICnOJIbSOBaHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p;au-
HbIX npII IICTOpII'IeCKIIX peROHCTpYKIJ;IIHX ObIJIa C<POPMYJIIIpOBaHa MbICJIb 0
TOM, 'ITO HOBbIe aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIle npIISHaKII He MorYT BOSHIIKHYTb 6es
nOHBJIeHIIH JIIOJJ;eII - HOCIITeJIeH 3TIIX npIISHaROB (BOSMomHbI, npaBp;a,
11 IICRJIIO'IeHIIH sa C'IeT JIOKaJIbHO cTyneH'IaTbIX opaKOB B KOHTaKTUbIX SO-
Hax), Torp;a RaR HSbIK II RYJIbTypa pacnpOCTpaHHIOTCH II 6es nepeCeJIeHIIH
JIIO,l],eH 3 . 8TIIM BnepBble 6bIJIO 06paIIJ;euo BHIIMaHIIe ua cneQII<pIIRy aHTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCKOrO, B TOM 'IIICJIe II naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrI!'IeCKOrO, MaTepIIaJIa.
M p;eHCTBIITeJIbHO, oOHapymeHIIe Tex IIJIII IIHbIX aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX KOMno-
HeHTOB B COCTaBe RaKOrO-JIII60 HapO)J,a YRaSbIBaeT Ha npe06JIap;aIOIQYIO JIII-
HIIIO CBHselI II Ha MeCTO, rJJ;e CJIOmIIJlIICb 3THII'IeCRIIe rpynnbI, npIIHHBIIIIIe
Y'IaCTIIe B ero <pOpMIIpOBaHIIII. JIIOP;II He npIIXO):(HT 6es H3bIKa II I{YJIbTypbI.
BbIHBJIHe1\Ible C nOMOIIJ;bIO cpaBHIITeJIbHo-RYJIbTypuoro IT JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCROrO
llCCJIe,l],OBaHIIH CBHSII nOJIY'IaIOT, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, (mpOnllcRY».
OfJ,HaRO oc06eHHo BamHa p0JIb naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB B
yCTaHOBJIeHIIII BpeMeull 8THoreHeTII'IeCROrO npoQecca. 8THorpa<pII'IeCRIIe II
JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIe ,l],aUHble He IIMeIOT npHMOH XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKOH peTpocneRTII-
BbI, II CYlIIITb 0 BpeMeHII BOSHIIRHOBeHIIH Toro IIJIII IIuoro 3THorp a <p II 'IeCKOrO
HBJIeHIIH IIJIII HSbIKOBOH oc06eHHocTII (p;ame npII HaJIII'IIIll nIICbMeHHocTII,
<PIIRCIIPYIOIQeII JIIIIIIb JIIITepaTYPnyIO HOpMy II He <PIIRCIIpYIOIIJ;eH p;IIaJIeKT-
HbIX paSJIII'IIIH) MomHO JIIIIIIb KOCBeHHbIM nYTeM C BeCbMa 60JIbIIIOH npII6JIII-
SIITeJIbHOCTbIO. Y CTaHOBJIeHIIIO BpeMeHll 06paSOBaHIIH KYJIbTypHbIX oc06eH-
uocTeH nOMoraeT apXeOJIOrII'IeCKOe IICCJIep;OBaHIIe, HO npHMoe conOCTaBJIeHIIe
8THorp a <p II 'IeCKIIX II apXeOJIOrII'IeCRIIX Ha6JIIOp;eHIIH - ):(ocTaTO'IHO CJIOmHaH
sap;a'Ia, MHoroe sp;ecb OCTaeTCH HeHeHbIM. IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIH me
MaTepIIaJI O,l],IIHaKOBo 8<p<peRTIIBeH RaK 8THoreHeTII'IeCRIIH IICTO'IHIIK IIa Bcex
XpOHOJIOrII'IeCRIIX 3Tanax IICTOpIIII 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa II npII ):(ocTaTO'IHOH nOJIHO-
Te ):(aeT IIH<p0pMaIJ;IIIO, ROTOpyIO HeJIbSH IISBJIe'Ib llS ):(PyrIIx IICTOpII'IeCRIIX
IICTO'IIIIIKOB.
TaK, IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe MaTepIIaJIbI IIS IOmHoH CII6IIpII nOMoraIOT
peIIIIITb np06JIeMbI, KOTOpbIe BOSHIIKalOT npii paCCI\IOTpeHllII 8THoreHesa aJI-
TaHcKoro, xaKaCCKoro II TYBIIHcKoro Hapop;OB. B. lIaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH 8TII ua-
pO,l],bI HBJIHIOTCH oOJIee IIJIII MeHee TIInn'IHbI1\III npep;cTaBIITeJIHMII MOHrOJIOIIp;-
HOII paCb!. Ho B ;moxy 6pOHSbI II paHuero meJIesa (06 8TOM yme IIIJIa pe'Ib
npIIMeHIITeJIbIIO R TeppIITopIIII XaKacIIII) Bce AJITae-CaHucKoe Haropbe 6bIJIO
saHHTO UOCIITeJIHMII eBponeoIIp;HoH KOM6IIHaQIIII npIISHaROB. IIMeIOIIJ;IIecH
p;aHHble cBII):(eTeJIbCTByIOT 0 TOM, 'ITO apeaJI eBponeOII):(OB OXBaTbIBaJI B TO
BpeMH II sana):(Hble palIOHbI MOHrOJIIIII 35. CTaHOBJIeHlle aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKO-
ro COCTaBa TIOpKCm!X Hapop;OB AJITae-CaHHCRoro HaropbH, a CJIegoBaTeJIbHO,
II saBepIIIeHIIe IIX 8TuoreHesa na,l],aIOT ua I TbICH'IeJIeTIIe P;O H. 3.- I TbICH'Ie-
JIeTIIe II. 8.
B 8noxy cpe,o:HeBeROBbH B XaRaCIIII npOmIIBaJIO HaCeJIeHIIe, He YCTynaB-
IIIee COBpeMeHHoMy no ypOBHIO BblpameHIIOCTII MOHrOJIOIIJJ;HbIX oc06eUHOCTeH.
Ho na py6eme HaIIIelI 8pbI HaCeJIeHIIC CJIep;YIOIIJ;eH sa TarapCKOH, TaIIITbIR-
CKoii KYJIbTYPbI OTJIII'IaJIOCb OT TarapCRoro JIIIIIIb HeSHa'IIITeJIbHbIM YBeJIII'Ie-
HIIeM MOUrOJIOII):(HOH npIIMeCII. 8TO OSUa'IaeT, 'ITO <pOpMIIpOBaHIIe OCHOBHbIX
oc06eHHOCTeH aUTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO COCTaBa xaRaCCRoro Hapop;a IIIJIO Ha IIpO-
THmeHIIII I TbICH'IeJIeTIIH n. 3. B npOIJ;eCce CJIIIHHIIH MeCTHbIX, eBpone011p;HbIX
II npIIIIIJIbIX, 1\IOnrOJIOIIgHbIX 3JIe1\IeHTOB. 8TO CJIIIHUIIe He MOrJIO He conpo-
Bom):(aTbCH KYJIbTypHOH KOHCOJIII):(aQIIeH II TIOpRIIsaQIIeH aBTOXTOHHoro P;O-
TIOpKCRoro UaCeJIeHIIH. TaKIIM 06paSOM, uaII60JIee IIHTeUCIIBHbIH npoIJ;ecc
200
dTHoreHesa B MIIHYCIIHCKOH KOTJIOBIIUe COCTOIIT OT COBpeMeHUOCTII MIIHIIMyM
Ha TbICH'IY - nOJITOpbI TbICH'III JIeT 36.
IIHaH cIITyaQIIH IIl\IeJIa MeCTO lIa TeppiiTOpIIII TYBbI no BepxHeMy Te'Ie-
HHIO EHIIceH. IIaJIeOaUTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIe l\IaTepIIaJIbl 8nOXII nosp;HeH 6pOHSbI,
paHHero meJIesa II paHHero cpep;HeBeKOBbH JJ;OCTaTO'IHO MHOrO'IllCJIeHUbI,
'IT06bl no HIIM COCTaBIITb rrOJIHOIJ;eHHoe cymJJ;eUIIe 0 p;IIHaMIIKe aHTpOnOJIOrII-
'IeCKIIX TiinOB TYBbI 37 . IIOp;aBJIHIOIIJ;ee IIpe06JIalIaHIIe eBpOIIeOIIp;OB HeCOM-
HeHHO, XOTH HeOOJIbIIIaH MOHrOJIOII):(HaH npIIMeCb II <pIIKcIIpyeTcH B pHge CJIy-
'IaeB. 8Ta nOCJIe):(HHH 6bIJIa BblpameHa B COCTaBe TIOpKOB He 60JIbIIIe, 'IeM y
HaCeJIeHIIH CKII<pCKorO II rYIIHo-capMaTCKoro BpeMeHII. He YCIIJIIIBaeTCH oua
II B IIepBble BeKa Harnero TbICH'IeJIeTIIH. TOJIbKO B nOCJIeMOHrOJIbCKOe BpeMH
B naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX cepIIHx npOCJIemIIBaeTCH TOT KOMnJIeKC npII3Ha-
KOB, KOTOpbIH xapaKTepeH P;JIH COBpeMelIHbIX TYBIIHQeB. lis 3Toro BbITeKaeT,
'ITO OH ciPopMIIpOBaJICH B MOHrOJIbCKOe BpeMH II IIMeHHO K TOMY BpeMeHll II
CJIe):(yeT OTHOCIITb saBeprneHIIe 8THoreHesa TYBIIHCKoro BapOga.
IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIH AJITaH llSY'IeHa SHa'IIITeJIbHO xyme, 'IeM rraJIeOaUTpo-
nOJIOrIIH XaKaCIIII II TYBbI. COBceM MaJIO p;aHHbIX 0 HaCeJIeHIIII CKII<pCKoro
II rYUHO-Capl\IaTCKOro BpeMeHII, HeJJ;OCTaTO'IHO MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbI II naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIOrII'IeCKlle KOJIJIeKQIIII TIOpKCKoro 11 MOHrOJIbCKOrO BpeMeHII. Bce me II
8TOT OrpaHII'IeHHbIH MaTepIIaJI IIOSBOJIHeT Cp;eJIaTb HeKOTOpbIe BbIBOgbI.
B CKII<PCKYIO II rYHHo-capMaTcKYIO 3nOXII TIInII'IHble eBponeOIIj],bI II KJIaCCII-
'IeCKIIe MOHrOJIOIIp;bI IJ;eUTpaJIbHOaSIIaTCKoro npOllcxom):(eHIIH cOCYIIJ;eCTBOBa-
Jill P;Pyr C JJ;pyrOM. B nOCJIeP;YIOIIJ;IIe BeKa IIMeJI MeCTO IIHTeHCIIBHbIH rrpOIJ;eCC
MeTIIcaIIIIII, 'ITO npIIBeJIO K rOJl,WreHIIsaIJ;IIII <pIISII'IeCKOrO Tiina HaCeJIeUIIH II
<pOpMIIpoBaHIIIO ):(BYX KOMnJIeKCOB Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKIIX npII3HaKOB - TIInII'IHO
MOHrOJIOII)J;Horo B ropax II MOHrOJIOIIp;HOro C eBponeoIIp;HoH npIIMeCbIO B npeg-
ropUbIX paHOHax 38. <POpMIIpOBaHIIe aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX ocooeHHOCTeH aJI-
TaIIIJ;eB naJJ;aeT, CJIeJJ;OBaTeJIbHO, npIIMepHO Ha TO me BpeMH, 'ITO II CJIOmeHlIe
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO Tllna xaKaCOB. IIapaJIJIeJIbuo IIIJIO <pOpMIIpoBaHIIe cne-
QII<pII'IeCKIIX OTJIII'IIIH OTj],eJIbUbIX 3THorpa<pII'IeCKIIX rpynn, BXOP;HIIJ;IIX B co-
CTaB aJITaHCKOro HapOga. MOrIIJIbHIIK Yp-BeJJ;apII, p;aTIIpyeMbIH VIII - IX BB.
H. 8., ):(aJI cepIIIO 'IeperrOB, OJIIISKO HanOMIIHaIOIIJ;IIX <pIISII'IeCKIIH Tiin KYMaH-
gIIlIIJ;eB 39. I1HbIMII CJIOBaMII, KOHCOJIII,'J;aIJ;IIH aJITaHCKOro Hapolla Ha OCHOBe
oopaSYIOIIJ;IIX ero 8THorpa<pII'IeCKIIX rpynn He CTepJIa HeKOTopbIX aHTpOrrOJIO-
i'II'IeCKIIX paSJIII'IIIH Mem):(y HIIMII, a BpeMH 06paSOBaHIIH 3TIIX paSJIII'IIIH
yXOP;IIT B I TbICH'IeJIeTIIe H. 8.
PaCCMOTpeUHble CJIy'Iaii - rrpIIMepbI nosp;HIIX 8THoreHeSOB. B JJ;pyrIIx
CIITyaQIIHX naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIH MaTepIIaJI YKaSbIBaeT, HanpOTIIB, Ha
paHuee <pOpMIIpOBaUIIe uapop;a, HanpIIMep KIITaIICKoro. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIH
COCTaB RiiTalIQeB IISY'IaJICH Heo):(uoKpaTIIO, II 8TII IICCJIep;OBaHIIH nORaSaJIII
JIaJIYIO JIOKaJIbHYIO gII<p<pepeHIJ;IIaUJIlO Mop<pOJIOrll'IeCKIIX npiisHaKoB Ha
TeppiiTopllii BOCTO'IHOH ASIIII. IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p;aHHble no p;peBHe-
MY UaCeJIeHIIIO KIITaH He O'IeHb MUOrO'IIICJIeHHbI, HO Bce me onIIcaHO He-
CKOJIbKO cepIIH UeOJIIITII'IeCKOrO BpeMeHII IIS paHOHa IISJIY'IllHbI XyaHX3.
HeoJIIIT 8Toro paHOHa cnpaBeJJ;JIIIBO oIJ;eHIIBaeTcH KaK KOJIbI6eJIb gpeBHeKII-
TaHcKoH QIIBIIJIIIsaIJ;IIII; HeOJIIITII'IeCKOe HaCeJIeHIIe 3Toro paHOHa He 06uapy-
mIIBaeT Mop<p0JIOrII'IeCKIIX OTJIII'IIIH OT cOBpeMeHHoro, II n03TOMY l\Iemp;y
UII:\III MomHO npOBeCTII UllTb reHeTII'IeCKOH npeeMCTBeHHOCTII ua npOTHmeHIIII
nHTII TbICH'I JIeT. IIpII 3TOM IIMeHHO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIiI MaTepIIaJI
npIIHOCIIT peIIIaIOIIJ;ee JJ;OKaSaTeJIbCTBO aBTOXTOHHOCTII KIITaHcKoro 8TuoreHe-
sa, TaK KaK apXeOJIOrII'IeCKaH npeeMCTBeHHOCTb C HeOJIIITa P;O COBpeMeHHO-
CTII BOCCTaHaBJIIIBaeTCH He 6es TpY)J;a AO.
MHOrOJIeTHIIe pacKonKII MOrIIJIbUbIX naMHTUIIKOB pasHblx 3nox B p;OJIllHe
201
HIIJIa HaKOIIIIJIII OrpOMHbIe KOJIJIeKIJ;IIII naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIa-
JIOB, OXBaTbIBaIOIIJ;IIX p;IIHaMIIKY aHTpOnOJIOrll'IeCKllX TIInOB B ErllIITe OT ueo-
JIIITa JJ:O COBpeMeHHOCTII u. 8TII Ma TepIIaJIbI ,l],eMOHCTpIIPYIOT IICKJIIO'IIITeJIb-
HYIO cTa6uJIbUOCTb aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX IIpIISHaKOB B p;OJIIIHe HIIJIa II IIOSBO-
JIHIOT paCCMaTpIIBaTb MeCTHOe HaCeJIeHIIe Kamp;OM IICTOpII'IeCKOM 8IIOXII KaK
IIOTOMKOB HaCeJIeHIIH npe):(IIIeCTBYIOIIJ;erO BpeMeHII. HII HaIIIeCTBIIe rIIKCOCOB,
UII nepeXO,l], Ha apa6CKYIO pe'Ib B 3IIOXY cpep;HeBeKOBbH He BbISBaJIII OIQYTII-
MbIX IISMeHeHIIM B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM TIIne MeCTHoro HaCeJIeUIIH. COBpe-
MeHHoe apa6CKoe HaCeJIeUIIe ErIInTa CBHsaHO JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKII II KYJIbTYPHO
C HaCeJIeHIIeM ApaBIIMCKoro nOJIYOCTpOBa - SOHOM apa6CKOM JJ:IIacnopbI B
8IIOXY cpeAHeBeKOBbH, HO <pIISII'IeCKllMII npe)J;KaMII erIIneTCKIIX apa60B 6bIJIII
JIIO)J;II, npomIIBaBIIIIIe B ):(OJIIIUe HIIJIa eIIJ;e B HeOJIIITII'IeCKOe BpeMH. B p;aH-
UOM CJIY'Iae naJIeOaIITpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKHM MaTepllaJI p;aJI BOSMomHOCTb OTOP;BII-
HYTb Ha'IaJIO 8THorenesa apa60HSbI'IHOrO HaCeJIeHIIH ErIInTa MIIHIIMYM ua
IIIeCTb TbICH'I JIeT OT COBpeMeHHOCTII.
TaKIIM 06paSOM, naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI op;IIHaKOBO 3<p<peR-
TIIBeH B ):(aTIIpOBKe 8THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npOIJ;eCCOB, Ha'IIIHaH C 3nOXII HeOJIII-
Ta II KOH'IaH nOSJJ:HIIM cpeJJ:HeBeKOBbeM. ConOCTaBJIeHIIe naJIeOaUTpOnOJIOrH'Ie-
CKIIX p;aHHbIX co CBep;eHIIHMII 0 COBpeMeHHOM UaCeJIeHIIII p;aeT BOSMomHOCTb
peROHCTpYIIpOBaTb JIIIHIIII reHeTII'IeCKOM rrpeeMCTBeHHOCTII. HaKoueIJ;, TeppII-
TOpIIaJIbIWe cpaBHeHIIe IIOMoraeT BOCCTaHOBllTb HanpaBJIeHIIe MIITpaQIIOHUbIX
nOTOKOB II OIJ;eHIITb IIX MaCIIITa6bI.
1 IIogp06HbIH 0630p C0061I{eHllH KllTaHCKllx JIeTOlillCeH eM.: FpYM-Fp3/CUMau.ao F. E.
IIo'IeMY RIITaHl\bI pllCyroT geMoHoB pbDKeBOJIOCbIMII?: (K Bonpocy 0 Hapogax 6eJIo-
RYPOH paCbI B CpegHeII A311lI). CII6., 1899; On 3/Ceo 3anagHaH MOHrOJIIIH 11 YpHH-
xailcRIIH RpaHo JI., 1926. T. 2.
2 CI1CTeMa 1I3MepeHlIll onllcaHa: Martin Ro, Saller K. Lehrbuch del' Anthropologie in
systematischer Darstellung: In 4 Ed. Stuttgart, 1957-1965.
3 Heyerdahl T. American Indians in the Pacific. L.; Stockholm; Oslo, 1952.
JIIITepaTypa 0 Bapllal\IUIX IHlrMeHTa BO.;rOC 'Ipe3llbI'IaiiHO 06llillprrao CMo, B qaCTHOCTlI:
_Baqeeu Bo Ao OT03JIeKTpOKOJIOpIIMeTpll'ICCROe olipegeJIeHlIe CTelIeHII nlIrMeHTal\llll
BOJIOC TYBIIHl\eB B cpaBHIITeJIbHOM OCBelI{eHlIll II AHTpOlID-3ROJIOrll'IeCRl1e IICCJIegoBa-
HIIH B TYBeo M., 1984.
5 FepacuJ>we M. M. OCHOBbI BOCCTaHOBJIeHIIH JIlll\a 110 TIepellY. M., 1949; On 3/Ceo Boc-
CTaHOBJICHlIe JIIIl\a lIO 'Iepeny II Tp. HH-Ta 3THorpag)1I11 AH CCCPo H. C. M., 1955.
T. 280 TaM me CM. 0630p npeglliecTByrolI{lIX pa60To
6 Ha 3TY TeMY CYlI{eCTByeT 60JIblliaH JIIITepaTypa. Hall60JIee 1l0JIHYro CBO]:lKy :JTOH JIll-
TepaTypbI CMo: Cavalli-Sforza L., Bodmer Wo The genetics of human populations.
San Francisco, 197"1.
7 B COBeTCROl1 apxeOJIOrll'IeClmH JIllTepaType TIalI{e Bcero ynoTpe6JIHeTCH rrepBbIH ll3
3TIIX TCpMIIHOB. 0 KYJIbTypHO-IICTOpllqeCROH 061I{UOCTII rOBopHT B CJIYTIae HaJIllTIllH
lliupORoro apeaJIa OgHOTlIlIHbIX rraMHTHJJ:ROB II BblHBJIeHIIH JIOKaJIbHbIX BaplIaHTOB
BHYTPII 3Toro apeaJIa - Tal.OBbI HMHaH, a6alliCBCRaH II aHgpoHoBCRaH KYJIbTypHO-
IICTOpllTIeCRlIC 061I{HOCTIIo
B IIplIMepOB TOMY B lIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrll'IeCKOH JIIITepaType MHoro, oc06eHHO 110 OTHO-
llieHlI10 K 30naM ApeBHero CMelliculIH eBpo:.reollgoB II MOHrOJIOIlgQB. CMo, HalIpo: Fun3-
6ypz Bo B., TpotfJUMoea T. A. IIaJIeOaHTpOlIOJIOrIIH CpeNIerl A3IIH. M., 1972.
9 0630pbI naMHTHIIROB II aHaJIII3bI apxeOJIOrllTIeCKOrO IIlIBeIlTapH CMo: g ,/[enoea H. D.
IIpoIIcxomgeHlle II paHHHH IICTOpllH Ta!'apCKOH KYJIbTYPbI. M., 1967; MapTb!1l0e A. H.
JIecocTelIHaH TarapCRaH KYJIbTypa. HOBOCll6l1pCK, 19790
10 FopoUfenKo Ko /1. KypraHHble TIepelia MIlHyclIHcKoro oRpyrao MIIHYCIIHCK, 1900.
11 IIocJIegHHH cBogKa gaHHbIX: K o3unqee Ao Fo AHTpOllOJIOrlITIeCKIIH COCTaB II IIpOIlC-
xomgeHlle HaCeJIeHllH TarapCKoH KYJIbTypbI. JI., 19770
12 /{e6eq r. w. AHTpOlIOJIOrlI'IeCRlIe TllllbI MllHYCllHCRoro KpaH B 3110XY pogoBoro
CTpOH II AHTponoJI. »IYPH. 1932. M 1.
13 Ceooe B. B. BOCTOTIHble CJIaBHHe B VI-XIII BB. M., 1982.
14 TpotjJuMoea T. A. KPIlBII'III. BHTIITIII II CJIaBHHCKlIe llJIeMeHa IIogHerrpoBbH 110 gaH-
HbIM aHTpOllOJIOrllll II COBo 3TlIOrpag)IIH. 1946. .N!! 1; A,/[eKceeea To H. oTHoreHe3 BD-
CTOTIHbIX CJIaBHH 110 gaHHbIM aHTpOnOJIOrllll. Mo, 1973.
202
f5 CeOoe B. B. II: naJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrlIII BOCTO'IUbIX CJIaBHH II IIp06JIeMbI apXeOJIOrlIlI EB-
pa3IIll II CeBepHOH AMepllRll. M., 1977; On 3/Ce. Pe3YJIbTaTbI ll3YlleHllH TIepellOB II Ce-
gOBa M. B. JIpOIIOJITI 3aJIeCCImH. M., 1978.
16 3uneeult r. fl. OTIepR naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrllll YRpaIIHbI. KlIeB, 1972; Kon8YKTopO-
ea T. C. AHTpOllOJIOrllH gpeBHero HaCeJIeHIIH YRpalIHbI. M., 1972.
17 K COmaJIeHlIIO, HMeIOlI{aHCH lIHg)OpMal\lIH He cBegeHa BoegllHoo BbI60pOTIHyIO 6ll6mlO-
I'pag)lIIO CM.: Bunak V. Rassengeschichte Osteuropas II Ressengeschichte del' Mensch-
heit. Miinchen; Wien, 1976. Liefo 40
18 IIoHBllJIllCb YRa3aHllH Ha pOgCTBO ceBepoRaBRa3cRIIx H3bIROB C CKHD-Tll6eTCRIIMlI, HO
3Tll llpegllOJIOmeHJ!(H OCTaroTCH UOR3 l'IIIlOTeTllllHbIMlI. CM.: CTapocTun Co A. IIpaeulI-
ceilcRaH peRoHcTpYRl\llH II BHelliUlIe CBH3ll eHllceilcRlIx H3blEOB II KeTcRllH C60PHIIRo
AHTpOllOJIOrIIH, 3THoI'pag)IIH, MIIg)OJIOrIIH, JIllHrBllCTIIRa. JI., 1982; On 3/Ce 0 flIlloTe3a 0
reHeTll'IeCRIIX CBH3HX CIIHD-Tll6eTCRlIX H3bIROB C eHlIceHcRllMll II ceBepORaBRa3CRIIMll
H3bIRaMll II JIlIuI'BllCTlllleCRaH peROHCTpYKl\llH II gpeBHeilrrraH llCTOplIH BOCToKa: Te3.
II gOKJI. KOHg)o Mo, 1984 0 o 4: J],peBuellITTaH H3LIROBaH clITyaIlIIH IJ BOCTO'IUoti A3I1l1.
19 CMo: HapogbI KaBKa3a: B 2 To M., 1960-1962.
20 HaTUWeU.I!ll A. 110' A68ywe.l!uweu.I!u 1110 r. IIpegBaplITeJIbUbIe gaHUbIe 06 aUTpOrrOJIOI'll..
TIeCKllX llCCJIegoBaHllHX I'pY3IIucKOro Hapoga II KpaT. co061I{. MH-Ta 3THoI'pag)IIll AH
CCCP. 1955. BbIII. 220
21 raU3/Cuee A. r. J],peBHee HaCeJIeHlIe J],aI'eCTaHa. M., 1975.
22 A.aeKceee B. ll. IIpollcxoiKgeHlle Hapop;OB KaBKa3a: (KpaHIIOJI. llCCJIeg.). M., 1974.
23 A68ywe.auweu.au M. r. AHTpOIIOJIOI'IIH gpeBHeI'O II COBpeMeHHOI'O HaCeJIeHIIH rpY3llll.
T6llJIllCll, 1964.
2 CMo: CMupnoe Ko (/)0' KyabMuna Eo Eo ITpolIcxomgeulIe IIHgolIpaul\eB B CBeTe HOBeH-
IIIIIX apxeOJIOrH'IeCKIIX OTKpbITllH. M., 1977.
25 /{e6elf r. (/). YRa3. COTI.
26 Kuce.aee Co Bo ;O:peBUHH IICTOpllH lOiKHOH ClI6lIpll. M., 1951.
27 /{e6elf r. (/)0 IIaJIeoaHTpOIIOJIOI'llH CCCP II Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpag)llll AH CCCP. H. C.
M.; JI., 1948. T. 4.
28 PbzKywuna r. Ao HaceJIeulIe cpe;J:HeI'O EHllceH B KapaCYKCKYIO 3IIOXY II IIaJIeoaHTpo-
IIOJIOI'llH Cll6llpll. HOBOCII6IIpCR, 1980.
29 A.aeKceee B. II. IIpollcxoiKgeHlle HapogoB BOCTOTIHOH EBporrbI: (KpaHllOJI o llCCJIego).
Mo, 1969.
30 Mu.n..aep Bo (/)0 OceTIIHCKlIe 3TIOgbI: B 3 TI. M., 1881-1887.
31 A6aee Bo Ho OceTIIHCKlIH H3bIK II g)OJIblmop. M.; JI., 1949. T. 1.
32 IIogp06Hee 06 3TOM cr.r.: A,'leKceee Bo flo AUTpOIIOJIOI'I1'IeCRlIe p:aHUbIe 0 npolIcxomge-
HIIII oceTllHCKOI'O HapO;J:a II MaTeplIaJIbI HaYllo cec., IIOCBHII{. 3THOI'eHe3Y oceTllH. Opg-
iKOHllRlIg3e, 19670
33 A.aeKceee B. fl. HeROTopbIe llp06JIeMbI IIpollcxomgeHllH 6aJIKapl\eB II Kapa'iaeBl\eB R
CBeTe gaHHbIX aHTpOllOJIOrllII 110 llpolIcxomgeHlIlI 6aJIRapl\eB II Kapa'iaeBl\eB. HaJIb-
TIllK, 1968.
3 /{e6elf r. (/)., Deeun Mo r., TporfiUMoea To Ao AHTpOllOJIOI'll'IeCKllH MaTepllaJI KaR llC-
TOTIHllR ll3YlleHlIH BOIIpOCOB 3THOI'eHe3a I I COB. 3THOrpag)llH. 1952. ;M 1.
35 A.n.eKceee B. flo HOBbIe galIHbIe 0 eBporreolIgHoH pace B IJ;eHTpaJIbHOll A3IIll II EpOH-
30BbIH II meJIe3HbIH BeR Cll6llplI. HOBOCIIOllpCK, 1974; MaMonoea H. H. AHTpOIIOJIOI'II-
TIeCKllH TlIll gpeBHeI'O HaCeJIeHllH 3arrap;Holl MOHI'OJIIIII no ;J:aUHbIM llaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIO-
rlIlIllMccJIegoBaHlle IIO naJIeOaTpOllOJIOI'lIlI 11 RpaUIIOJIOrHlI CCCP. JI., 1980. (C6. My-
3eH aHTpOIIOJIOI'llll II 3THoI'pag)llII AH CCCP; To 36) 0
36 A.n.eKceee B. IIo IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOI'IIH XaKaclIlI 3rrOXll iKeJIe3a II C6. MY3eH aHTpollo-
JIOI'IIH II <JTHOI'paqJlIII AH CCCPo Mo; JI., 1961. To 200
37 rOXMan Ho H. IIpollcxomgeulIe l\eHTpaJIbHOa3I1aTCKOH paCbI B CBeTe UOBbIX rraJIeOaH-
TpOllOJIOI'll'IeCKIIX MaTeplIaJIOB II MCCJIegoBaul1e no lIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOI'llll o ..; A,qeKce-
ee B. II. KpaTKoe ll3JIOiKeHIIe llaJIeOaHTpOllOJIOI'llll TYBbI B CBH3ll C llCTOpll'IeCKIIMll BO-
rrpocaMll II AHTpOlIO-3KOJIOrlllleCRlIe IICCJIe;J:oBaHI1H B TYBeo
38 A.aeKceee B. No IIaJIeoaHTpoII<JJIoI'I1H AJITaH 3IIOXll iKeJIe3a II COB. aHTpOllOJIOI'llH. 1958.
;M1.
39 On 3/Ceo KOTIeBHllKII RY3Hel\KOH KOTJIOBllHbI lIO gaHHbIM IIaJIeOaUTpOlIOJIOI'llll II RpaT.
coo61I{. MH-Ta 3THOI'pag)llll AH CCCP. 1960. BbIIl. 35; On 3/Ce. K cpegHeBeKoBoH lla-
JIeOaUTpOllOJIOI'lI1I KY3Hel\ROH KOTJIOBHHbI II M3B. JIa60 apxeOJIo IICCJIego KeMepoBo,
1974. BbIII. 5.
o IIogp06Hee CM.: TIe6oKcapoe H. H. OTHlllleCKaH aHTpOIIOJIOI'llH KIITaH (paCOBaH MOp-
g)OJIOrllH COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHllH). Mo, 1982.
u Morant G. A study of Egyptian craniology from prehistoric to roman times II Bio-
metrica. 1925. Vol. 17, pt. 1/2; Batrawi A. The racial history of Egypt and Nubia II
J. Anthropol. Inst. Gr. Brit. and Ireland. 1945. Vol. 75; 1946. Vol. 76; Nielsen O. The
Nubian skeleton throng 4000 years. Kobenhavn, 1970.
203
3ARJIIOQEHHE
ABTop rJIy6oKo y6emgeH JI Hap;eeTCH, 'ITO 8TO OT'IeTJIIIBO BblpameHO B O'Iep-
KaX, o6pasYIOIIJ;JIX BTOpyIO 'IaCTb KHllrll: JISY'IeHIIe 8THOreHeSa, BXOp;HIIJ;ee CeM-
'IaC B C<pepy 8THOrpa<pII'IeCKOM HaYKJI, Ha CaMOM p;eJIe BBJIP;Y CJIOmHOCTII II
MHOrOCTOpOHHOCTII rrpOIJ;eCCa, He06xo)J;IIMOCTJI KOMIIJIeKCHOrO K HeMy nop;xop;a
npegcTaBJIHeT C060M npe)XMeT CaMOCTOHTeJIbHOrO IICCJIegoBaHIIH JI p;OJImHO
CTaTb OC060M p;JICIJ;IIrrJIIIHOM, KOTOpaH aKKYMYJIIIpOBaJIa ObI pesyJIbTaTbI pas-
HbIX 06JIaCTelI SHaHIIH, cBogIIJIa JIX B ep;llHOM TeOpeTII'IeCKOM CllHTeSe, orrpe-
p;eJIJIJIa paSpeIIIaIOIIJ;yro CJIJIY paSHbIX BIIgOB llCTOpII'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIKOB, pas-
pa60TaJIa MeTogll'IeCKlle rrpOIJ;egypbT IIX llCnOJIbSOBaHIIH. TIoKa 8Ta CaMO-
CTOHTeJIbHaH OOJIaCTb SHaHJIH TOJIbKO CKJIagbIBaeTcH Ha CTbIKe 8TIlOrp a <p IIJI ,
a pxeOJIOrJIll, JICTOpJI'IeCKOM aHTpOrrOJIOrlIll, naJIeOJIJIHrBllCTllKII II llCTOplI'Ie.
CKoro IICTO'IHllKOBep;eHJIH, CKJIagbIBaeTcH B OCHOBHOM B xop;e JISY'IeHllH KOHK-
peTHbIX 8THoreueSOB, XOTH JI BbI}J;BIIHYJIa yme HeROTOpbIe TeOpeTJI'IeCKIIe rro-
JIOmeHJIH P;OBOJIbHO BbICORoro ypOBHH o606IIJ;eHJIH KOHRpeTHbIX 8MrrJIpJI'IeCRJIX
p;aHHbIX.
KaR 6yp;eT HaSbIBaTbCH 8Ta o6JIacTb SHaHIIH? 8THorOHIreM? TepMJIH no-
HBIIJICH B 30-40-x rO)J;ax, IIHorp;a BbIIIJIbIBaeT H CeM'IaC, HO ynoTpe6JIHeTCH B
llHOM SHa'ieHIIJI II gOBOJIbHO pep;KO, BJIP;llMO, lis-sa CBoeM JICRYCCTBeHHOCTII.
8THoreIIeSOOJIOrlleII? 8TO rrOJIHOCTbID COOTBeTCTBOBaJIO 6bI npe):(MeTY IICCJIego-
BaHIIH - «Y'IeHIIe 0 IIpoIIcxomgeHIIJI HapO)J;OB», HO TepMJIH npJI BceM CBoeM
CMbICJIOBOM TO'IHOCTII rpoMosgOR II, IIOmaJIYM, HeYRJIIOm. OJJ:HaRO geJIO, pa-
SyMeeTCH, He B TepMllHe, XOTH JI 3TO BamHO, a B cogepmaTeJIbHOM CTopOHe
HOBOM )XIICIJ;IInJIIIHbI, B ooOraIIJ;eHllII r.reTOp;OJIOrll'IeCROM JI MeTogH'IeCKOM 6aSbI
HaymI 06 8THoreHese, KOTopaH nOKa eIIJ;e p;eJIaeT rrepBbIe rnarlI.
Hapog - CTPYRTYPHO CJIOmHOe, MHorOKOMrrOHeHTHoe o6pasoBaHlle, 0 'IeM
MHoro II cO)J;epmaTeJIbHO HarrJICaHO 1, n08ToMy yme caMO BbIHBJIeHlle ero
ROMrrOHeHTOB B CllHXpOHHOM cpese, B KaROM-TO IICTOpII'IeCmIM MOMeHT CY-
IIJ;eCTBOBaHIIH HapOJJ:a rrpegcTaBJIHeT C060M saga'IygocTaTO'IHO 60JIbIIIOM
CJIOmHOCTII. OHa TeM 60JIee yCJIOmmIeTCH, Rorga BOSHJIRaeT He06xogIIMoCTb
BgIIaxpoHHOM rrogxop;e I{ 8THII'IeCRoMgllHaMIIKe, B npOCJIemJIBaHIIll reHeTII-
'IeCRIIX IICTOROB BbIHBJIHeMbIX BHYTPII Hapoga CTPyRTYPHbIX KOMrrOHeHTOB.
)J,onOJIHllTeJIbHaH TPYJJ:HOCTb cosgaeTcH pasHoxapaRTepHocTbIO CaMJIX JICTOKOB.
qTO BamHee P;JIH onpegeJIeHIIH reHeSIIca - HerrpepbIBHoe reHeTII'IeCROe pO)J;-
CTBO B pHJJ:e nOKOJIeHIIM, T. e., HHbIMII CJIOBaMJI, 6IIOJIOrII'IeCKaH rrpeeMCTBeH-
HOCTb, ROTOpyIO aBTOp, rrOmaJIYM, IIepeOIJ;eHIIBaJI B CBOIIX paHHllX pa60Tax,
IIJIII HSbIKOBaH rrpJIHa)J;JIemHOCTb, KYJIbTypa, car.IOCOSHaHJIe II HeRoTopble
IIHble QeHHOCTHble oplleHTaQIIJI B 8THII'IeCROM nCJIXOJIDrllJI? 8Tll JI pHP; p;py_
rIIX nOD:OOUbIX BonpOCOB eIIJ;e npe,1J;CTOIIT peIIIIITb.
IIcRJIlO'IIITem>Ho BamHbI B CBH3II C 8TDoreIIeTII'IeCROM peRoHcTpYRIJ;JIeM
JJ:Be np06JIeMbI, CBHsaHHble Melli)J;Y COOOM, HO B TO me BpeMH JIMeIOIIJ;JIe II ca-
MOCTOHTeJIbHOe SHa'IeHIIe, - onpeJJ:eJIeHUe HllmHeM rpaHJIIJ;bI XpOHOJIOrII'Ie-
CKOM r JIy6IIHbI Tex IIJIJI JIHbIX p;aHHbIX, llCnOJIbsyeMbIx B Ka'IeCTBe 8THoreHe-
TII'IeCROrO IICTO'IHIIRa, JI OQeHRa peROHCTpYRTIIBHbIX BOSMomHOCTeM caMllX
p;aHHbIX, BKJIlO'IaIOIIJ;aH, KOIIe'IHO, II IIX 8THoreHeTD'IeCKYIO peTpOCneRTJIBY.
llTO KacaeTCH onpegeJIeHIIH XpOHOJIOrII'IeCROM rJIy6JIHbI CaMJIX p;aHHbIX, TO
CJIep;yeT IIMeTb B BIIgy, 'ITO OHa lIe cOBnagaeT llJIll He nOJIHOCTbIO COBnap;aeT
C XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKOM rJIy6HHoM 8THOreHeTII'IeCKOM peROHCTpYKIJ;lllI. ApxeoJIorJI-
'IeCRIIe JI naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRlle MaTepIIaJIbI, HanpJIMep, RaK yme rOBoplI-
JIOCb BblIIIe, JIJIJIIOCTPIIPYIOT BeCb IICTOpJI'IeCRJIM npoQecc B IJ;eJIOM, Ha'IllHaH
C caMbIX paHHJIX ero 8TanOB, no He HeCYT HenocpegcTBeHHOM 8THJI'IeCKOM
JIH<popMaIJ;IIII, OHa JISBJIeKaeTCH JIHIIIb KOCBeHHbIM nYTeM.
204
TaKOM rrYTb, TeOpenl'IeCml nOJIHOCTbIO onpaBIJ;aHHbIM, He npJIBO}J;JIT, O}J;-
naKO, K O}J;nOSHa'IHbIM peSYJIbTaTaM. CKameM, aBTOp rrbITaJICH aprYMenTIlpO-
BaTb naJIII'IIIe 8THII'IeCKOM }J;II<p<pepeHIJ;IIaIJ;IIJI Ha'iJIHaH C 8rrOXII HJImHero
naJIeOJIIlTa, npaKTJI'IeCml C ca
IbIX nepBbIX rnarOB 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa nOCJIe BbI)J;e-
JIeHIIH lIS mIIBOTHoro MJIpa 2. Ho ero TO'IKa spenIIH CTOJIT cKopee OCOOHH-
KOM, )J;PyrJIe IICCJIegoBaTeJIII OTHOCHT Ha'IaJIO 8THooopaSOBaHJIH K oOJIee nosg-
HIIM 3rroxaM '. TIoKa He ygaJIOCb HaMTJI TBepgbIe JI )J;orrYCKaIOIIJ;JIe npOBepKY
KpJITepIIII, C rrOMOIIJ;bIO KOTOpbIX Bonpoc r.romeT ObITb perneH ogHoSHa'iHO.
KaSaJIOCb ObI, gocTaTO'IHO nOJIHaH JI OO'beKTJIBHaH IIH<popMaIJ;IIH 00 8THJI-
'IeCKOM }J;JI<p<pepeHIJ;IIaIJ;JIII norra)XaeT B HarnJI PYKII Ha'IIIHaH C rrOHBJIeHIIH
MaCCOBbIX nJICbMeHHbIX IICTO'IHJIKOB, T. e. C III TbICH'IeJIenm )J;O H. 3. Ho II
OHJI Ha )J;eJIe OKaSbIBaIOTCH OOMaH'IJIBbIMII: oOIIapo)J;oBaB 60JIbrnOe KOJIII'IeCT-
BO 8THOHIUWB, OHM He HanOJIHHIOT JIX KOHKpeTHbIM KYJIbTypHbIM cogepmaHII-
eM II He )J;aIOT BOSMOmHOCTJI nOHHTb, game npJI HaJIII'IIIII cepbeSHOM JICTO-
pII'IeCKOM KPIITIIKII IICTO'IHllKoBeg'IeCKOM oaSbI, K KaKoMy ypOBHIO 3THII'Ie-
CKOM gII<p<pepeHIJ;IIaIJ;llII IIJIII K KaKOM <popMe 8THJI'IeCKOM OOIIJ;HOCTII 8TJI
8THOHIIMbI MOryT ObITb npIIypO'IeHbI. B }J;aHHOM CJIY'Iae Y}J;OBJIeTBOpJITeJIbHaH
II 60JIee IIJIJI r.renee O)J;HOSHa'IHaH JICTOpll'IeCKaH peKOHCTpYKIJ;llH game goc-
TIIraeTCH Ha oOJIee OJIIISKOM K COBpeMeHHOCTJiI JI XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKJI oOJIee nos}J;-
HeM OTpeSKe BpeMeIIII, 'IeM IICTOpII'IeCKOe BpeMH, K KOTOpOMy OTHOCIITCH
caMO Ha'IaJIO IIH<pOplVIaIJ;IIOHHOro nOTOKa, BbITeKaIOIIJ;erO lIS IISY'IeHIIH Tex
JIJIJI llHbIX MaTepllaJIOB. BeCbMa BepOHTHO, 'ITO B 06IIJ;eM <popMe cnpaBe)J;JIIl-
BbIM OKameTCH npeJJ;IIOJIOmeHlle, COrJIaCHO KOTOPOMY 8<p<peKTIIBIIaH 3THore-
HeTII'IeCKaH peKoIIcTpYKQIIH C nOMoIIJ;bIO Tex IIJIII IIHbIX iJ,aHHblx npIIYpO'III-
BaeTCH K oOJIee nosgHeMy BpeMeHll, 'IeM XpOHOJIOrll'IeCKaH rJIyoIIHa CaMJIX
}J;aHHbIx.
IIepexogH K rrp06JIeMe cpaBrnITeJIbHOM 8<p<peKTIIBHOCTJI pasHblx BJI}J;OB
gaHHbIx, llCnOJIbsyeMbIx B 8THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX peKoHcTpYKIJ;JIHX, CJIegyeT
nO)J;'IepKHYTb, 'ITO perneHJIe 8TOM npOOJIeMbI SaBJICJIT OT OIJ;eHKII cpaBHIITeJIb-
Horo SHa'ieHIUI Tex IIJIII JIHbIX KOMIIOHeHTOB 8THoca JI ero OCHOBHbIX npIIsHa-
KOB. B 8THorpa<pIIll, JICTOpII'IeCKOM }J;eMorpa<pIIII JI COIJ;IIOJIIIHrBJICTJIKe rrpo-
gOJImaeTCH )J;IICKyCCllH 0 TOM, 'ITO HBJIHeTCH orrpe}J;eJIHIOIIJ;llM B BbI}J;eJIeHJIll
Hapoga - HSbIK, caMOCOSlIalIIle, HapogHaH KyJIbTypa II T. }J;. He npIIBogH
MHOrO'IIICJIeHHOM JIIITepa TYPbI, B 'IeM HeT B )J;aHHOM KOHTeKCTe Heooxo}J;JIMO-
CTll, OTMe'IY JIllIIIb, 'ITO IIOKa Bonpoc peIIIaeTcH B saBIICIIMOCTJI OT IInOCTaSJI-
pOBaHIIH O)J;IIoro JIS nepe'IIICJIeHHbIX IIJIM eIIJ;e II gpyrllx 8JIeMeIITOB 8THII'Ie-
cKoll cneIJ;JI<pIIKII. Mem)J;Y TeM Tenepb yme cOBeprneHHo O'IeBIIJJ:HO. 'ITO B
6ygyIIJ;eM MomeT ObITb nocTpoena O}J;HOSHa'iHaH CIICTeMa CrreIJ;ll<pll'IeCKIIX oco-
oeHHocTeM JII060ro Hapoga, B COOTBeTCTBIIJI C JIepapXIIeM KOTOpOM nOCJIe}J;o-
BaTeJIbIIO pacrrpegeJIHIOTCH pasHbIe Bll)XbI IICTOpJI'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHJIKOB, nOSBO-
JIHIOIIJ;IIX OCYIIJ;eCTBJIHTb 8THoreHeTII'IeCKIIe peKoHcTpYKIJ;llII. TIYTb K cosgaHJIIO
TaKoII CIICTeMbI, no MlIeHllIO aBTopa, JIemIIT B }J;aJIbHeMrneM 060raIIJ;eHIIII na-
IIIero nOHIIMaHIIH KOHKpeTHbIx 8THorenesoB, K paccMoTpeHIIIO KOTOpbIX C rro-
MOIIJ;bIO IICTopIIKo-aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKJIX MaTepJIaJIOB MbI JI nepexogJIM.
1 CM., Hanp., RH.: BpOM.aeu 10. B. OTHOC II :JTHorpag)IIH. Mo, 1973; On 3/Ce. COBpeMeHHI,Ie
npo6JIe
n,I 3THorpag)lIlI: O'iepIUI TeOp111I 11 IICTOplI11. Mo, 1981; On 3/Ce. O'iepRI1 TeOp111I
3THoca. M., 1983.
2 A.aeKceee B. II. 0 CaMOM paHHeM :JTane pacoo6pa30BaHHJ! H :JTHOreHOOa 1/ OTHOC B
O-
RJIaCCOBmI II paHHeRJIaCCOBOM 06II{eCTBe. Mo, 1982.
3 CM., Hanp., .n:pyrl1e CTaTbli B TOll me RHlIre.
"lJacTb TpeTMI
MCTOPMRO-AHTPorrO
OrMqECROE
M3YQEHME
ROHRPETHbIX 8THOrEHE30B
K MCTOPM"lJECKOn MHTEPITPETAQMM
PE3Y
bTATOB M3Y"lJEHMH
ITA
EOAHTPOITO
OrMM CTEITEn EBPA3MM
B CKM<DCKOE BPEMH
BBE)J;EHIIE
JI1060e llCCJIep;OBanIIe IIop;06Horo pop;a HalJIIHaeTCJI C 0603HalJeHIIJI reorpa<pII-
lJeCHIIX II XpOHOJIOrI1lJeCRIIX rpaHIIll, TeMhI. XpOHOJIOrIIlJeCRU MbI OrpaHIIlJII-
BaeM ce6H VII - III BB. p:o H. 3. (sa IICRJIlOlJeHIIeM OT)J,eJIbHbIX CJIYlJaeB Ha-
JIH
IHH 60JIee rrosp;HIIX p;aHnbIX II BOSMomIIOCTII IIX 3RcTparro:IJIll,IIII), IIOTOMY
1JTO UMenHO B 3TOM XpOHOJIOrIIlJeCHOM p;uaIIaSOHe MomllO rOBopIITb 0 1JeTRO
apXeOJIOrII1JeCRII BblpameHHoM OTHOCIITeJIbHO ep:I1HOM HYJIbType B Mem):(ypelJbe
AHerrpa- AOHa, CHH<pCHOM B Y3ROM CMbICJIe CJIOBa, U 0 SnalJHTeJIhHOM RYJIb-
TypHOM Cxop:CTBe co CRU<pCHOM KYJIbTYPOM, apXeOJIOrII
reCHII BCHpbIBaeMoM Ha
orpOMIIhIX CTerrHblX npocTopax Ha BOCTOR OT apeaJIa cRII<lJOB, BIIJIOTb )J,O
EHuceH. IIoCJIe):(Hee COOTBeTcTByeT lJaCTO YIIoTpe6JIJIeMoMY nOHJITIIlO CHU<pO-
cII6upCROM 06IQHOCTII.
feorpa<pUlJeCRHe rpaHIII{hI Tpe6YlOT oc060ro paccMOTpeHIIJI. B paMHax
cOBpeMenHhlx JIaHp;ma<pTHblx 30H TeppIITopUIO 0'1' ,l];YHaJI )J,O BOCTOlJHOM
MOHrOJIHII saHIIMalOT CTeIIU (pIIC. 12). C ceBepa R HIIM IIpUMhIRalOT JIeco-
CTeIIHhIe JIaIIp;rna<pThI, C lOra - nOJIyrrYCThIHHhIe U IIYCThIHnble. B ll,eJIOM OHJiI
06pasYlOT 3ROJIOrII1JeCHyro HIIrny, JIII60 6JIarOIIpIIHTHYlO P;JIJI paSBIITIIH ROlJe-
Boro CHOTOBO):(CTBa, JIII60 Bo06m;e HpHrop:HYlO P;JIJI OCBOeHUJI lJeJIOBeHOM
TOJIbHO IIPH paSBIITHH 3Toro HarrpaBJIeHHH XOSHMCTBeHHOM p;eJITeJIbHOCTII.
feorpa<pUlJeCHIIe IIpep;eJIbI 3TOM 3ROJIOrUlJeCROM Hurnu CTOJIb orpOMHbI II B
TO me Bpe
IJI rrOCTOHHHhI, lJTO MHOrOJIeTHIIM CIIOp reorpa<pOB II nO
IBOBep;OB
paSHhIX IIarrpaBJIeHHIi 0 TOM, HacTynaeT JIII CTerrh Ha JIec, JIec Ha CTenb,
IIJIU IIX BsaIIMOOTHOrneHHJI Ha rpaHIIll,e xapaRTepIISYlOTCH ll,IIHJIU1JnOCTbIO,
'repJIeT P;JIJI Hac CBoe 3Ha
reHue, TeM 60JIee lJTO COBpel\WHHaH T01JHa 3peHIIJI
CBOp:UTCH I{aR 6Y)J,TO H rrpIISHaHUlO nSBeCTfIOM cTa6IIJIbHOCTU II JIeCOCTeIIHOM
II CTerrHOM SOH BO BpeMeHII '. IIocJIe)J,Hee He IICRJIlOlJaeT, rrpaBp;a, RaHUX-TO
He06paTUMhIX IISMeHeHIIM JIaHp;rna<pTa B npep;eJIax OTp;eJIbHbIX YlJaCTHOB:
JI1060rrhITHhIM npUMep TaHoro IISMeHeHIIJI rrpe)J,CTaBJIJIeT C060M fIIJIeJI fepo-
p;oTa - p;OCTaTOlJHO 06rnIIpHaJI sOHa, nOHphITaJI JIeCOM, npeBpaTUBrnaJICJI
HhIHe B orpoMHhIM IIeClJaHhIM MaCCIIB 2.
fpaHIIll,hI JIeCOCTeIIHOM II CTenHOM SOH C IIpIIJIeralOm;IIMII R HUM C lOra
yqacTRaMU IIOJIynYCThIHb U p;ame IIYCTbIHb He npep;orrpep;eJIHlOT, O)J,HaRO,
aBTOMaTIIlJeCRH rpaHHll, '1'01'0, lJTO rrop:paSYMeBaeTCJI IIOp; CRU<p0-CII6IIpCROH
06m;HOCTblO B pa60Tax apxeOJIOrOB II UCTOpUROB. ROlJeBOM MIIp EBpaSIIU B
D;eJIOM rnIIpe 3TOM 06m;HOCTU 3. 3anap;HaH rpaHUll,a OTlJeTJIHBO YCTanaBJIIIBa-
206
. a
0 6
PIIC. 12. I'eorpaq,II'leCROe pacnpOCTpalIeHlle JIaHArnaq,ToB cTeneii II nYCTbIRb EBpa31111 II
pacnpocTpaHeHIIe 1I1OrllJIbHIIROB, )J.aBllillX naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIPIeCKIrif MaTepllaJI (reHepamI-
30BaHO no KHllre: cDu3I1Ro-reorpaq,II'IeCKIrif: aTJIaC lIHIpa. M., 1964. C. 75)
a - MOrHJIbHHR; 6 - cOBoh-ynHocTb MHorHX MOrH.TIbHHROB
I - CTenH YMCPCHHO ROHTHHeHTaJIbHOrO RJIHMaTa; II - CYXHC CTcnH ROHTHHCHTa.TIbHOrO R.TIHMaTa;
III - cyxHe CTenH pe:mo ROHTHHCHTaJIbHOrO RJIHMaTa; IV - nOJIynycTbIHH H nycTbIHH ROHTHHeH-
TaJIbHOro R.TIHMaTa; V - nOJIynycTbIHH ROHTHHeHTa.TIbHOrO RJIHMaTa; VI - nycTbIHH ROHTHHCH-
T3JlbHoro RJUIMaTa
MOrH.TIbHHRH: 1 - HHRO.TIaCBRa; 2 - RYT; 3 - HHROnOJIb; 4 - SOJIOTaH Ba.TIRa; 5 - HHROJIaCBRa-
RaaaI1ROe; 6 - HCanO.TIb CRH(jJCRHit; 7 - SaBcTHoc; 8 - TarHcReH; 9 - YitrapaR; 10 - YCTb-By-
ROHb; 11 - TapbIM-RaH; 12 - IIaMHpCRaf! I; 13 - ARGeHT; 14 - TY8RTa H rnHGc; 15 - Rypait H
Y.TIaH;:J,pbIR; 16 - TarapCRaf! RYJIbTypa (O'lep'lCHa npHMcpHaH nJIOll\aAb pacnpocTpaHcHHH Tarap-
CRHX MOrHJIbHHROB) .
eTCH npII cpaBHeHUll aHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCRIIX oc06eHHOCTeM nonYJIHll,IIM, rrpouc-
XOp;Hm;IIX lIS naMJITHUHOB, )J,uarHOCTnpyeM:bIX HaR <ppaRUMCRlle U CHII<p CRue .
Pa60Ta 3Ta, IIpOBe)J,eIIHaJI M. C. BeJIIIHaHOBOM 4, O'l.''IeTJIUBO rrORaSaJIa SHa-
'IUTem,nylO rpall,IIJIbHOCTb <ppaHIIlm;eB rro CpaBHeflIIlO CO CRU<paMU, 'ITO nop;-
TBepmp;alOT If apXeOJIOrll'IeCRUe p;aHHhIe. A. II. MeJIlOROBa, aBTOp CIIell,uaJIb-
HOM MOHorpa<pIIu 06 HCTOpII'IeCHUX BsaIIMOOTHorneHIIHX CRII<p CRUX II <ppa-
RIIMCHIIX IIJIeMeH, crrpaBep;JIUBO rrurneT: «3p;ecb p;OCTaTO'IHO JICHO BhIpameH
CJIY'IaM, Horp;a rrOHHTUH ,,3THOC" II "HYJIbTypa" COBrrap;alOT» 5. 3arrap;HYlO
rpaHIID,y TeppIITopIIII, ROTopaH p;OJImHa 6hITb nO,.r:\BeprHYTa HarneMY aHaJIUSY,
COCTaBJIHeT, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, IIop;HecTpoBbe.
IIaJIeOaIITpOIIOJIOrU'IeCRIIe )J,aHHbIe rrOSBOJIJIlOT TaRme p;OCTaTO'IHO 1JeTRO
orrpep;eJIIITh BOCT01J:HYlO rpaHIIll,y CRII<p0-cu6IIpCROM 06m;HOCTU. IIsBecTHoe
C006m;eHIIe fepo)J,oTa 0 «CTeperym;IIX SOJIOTO rpII<paX» B COOTBeTCTBIIH C rnu-
pOHO pacrrpocTpaHeHHhIM MHeHIIeM n:Jorpa<pII'IeCRII COOTHOCUTCJI C AJITaeM.
lIs TeRCTa C006m;eHIIH HCHO, 'ITO pe'Ib up;eT 0 HecHu<pcRIIX rrJIeMeHaX, HO
pacRoIIHII, B nepBYlO O'Iepep;b C. II. pYP;efIRO 6, M. II. fpH3HOBa 7 H
C. B. RUCeJIeBa 8, BhIJIBHJIU B ropHhIX paMOHax AJITaJI RYJIbTYPY BeChMa
6JIUSRylO H RYJIbType eBporreMCHIIX CRII<pOB. Em;e )J,aJIbrne Ha BOCTOR, B MII-
HYCIIHCROM HOTJIOBIIHe Ha EHucee H B oRpymalOm;ux ee C ceBepa U 3ana)J,a
06JIaCTJIX, CXO..r:\HhIM RYJIbTypH:bIM HOMrrJIeHC 6bIJI BCHp:bIT B naMJITHIIRaX Ta-
rapCROM RYJIbTYp:bI 9. AnaJIOrII'IH:bIM RYJIbTYPH:bIM ROMnJIeRC IISBeCTeH U B
TYBe 10. Ho HaR pas B TYBe B 3'1'0 BpeMJI <pIIRcIIpyeTCJI Om;YTIIMaJI MOHro-
JIOUp;HaJI npIIMeCb ", ROTOpaJI cJIa60 npOCJIemUBaeTCJI B HaCeJIeHIIH Tarap-
207
.
1
CROM HYJIbTYPhI. Em;e p;aJIbrne Ha BOCTOH M:bI rronap;aeM B apeaJI paCCeJIeHUJI
rrpep;CTaBUTeJIeiI MOHrOJIOIIp;HOM paCbI 12 . OTJIIIlJaeTCH 3'1'0'1' apeaJI U HYJIb-
TYPHO 13. OlJeBII,IW0, EmIceM COCTaBJIHJI B npe,LWJIax IOmHoM CII6upII Py6em
npOHIIHHOBeHIIH eBpOIIeOII)J,OB B BOCT01JIIOM HarrpaBJIeHIIII II ero MomHO YC-
JIOBHO rrpIIHHTb sa BOCT01JHYlO rpaHIIll,y paCCMaTpUBaeMOM rraMU TeppUTopUII,
XOTJI rparUIll,a 3Ta MeHee lJeTRaH, lJeM sarrarrHaJI, II MhI 6YJJ,eM BhIHym));eHhI
BhIX0,LWTb 3a ee Upep,eJIhI.
B IIpOll,eCCe rrpep;rneCTBYIOm;ero IISYlJerIHH p;OCTaTOlJHO 06rnUpH:bIX naJIeo-
aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCmIX M3Teplia.rrOB II3 UHTepeCYlOm;eM Hac SOHhI yme HaROnJIeH
pJI)); naOJIlOp;eUUM reHeTU1JeCHOrO xapaRTepa. Em;e A. II. Bor)J,aHOB OTMeTIIJI
p;JIIIHHOrOJIOBOCTb lJeperrOB, rrpOIICXOP;JIIll,IIX us CRII<pcmn MOrIIJI YHpaIIHhI,
II CXOP;CTBO IIX co CJIaBJIHCHIIMII 14. Ero BhIBOP; 6bIJI rrop;TBepmp;eH f. $. ,l];e-
6eIJ;OM, OIIIIcaBrnIIM CRII<pCRue MaTeplIaJIbI lIS Cpep;Hero IIpII;:J;IIerrpOBbJI II
CeBepHoro IIpIIlJepHOMOpbH, rrpOIICXOp;Hm;ue lIS CTaphIX paCROIIOR II II03TOMY
He IIMelOm;IIe 6esYHopIISHeHHhIX p;aTIIpOBOH 15. OH IIORaSaJI HaJIIIlJIIe 6paXII-
RpaHrroro 3JIeMeHTa II aprYMeHTIIpOBaUHO BhICHa3aJICH B IIOJIb3Y MeCTfIOrO
rrpOIIcxomp:eUIIH CHII<pCHorO naCeJIeHIIH Ha OCHOBe CTennhIX rrJIeMeH 3IIOXII
6pOHShI EMY me npIIHap;JIemlIT II KplITIIlJeCROe paCCMOTpeHIIe pa60ThI
A. IIIJIIIll,a 16, B ROTOpOM 6bIJIII OIlIIcaHhI 1Jeperra lIS MapIIIJ;hIHCRIIX HypraHoB
6mm OJIbBIIII. MeTpIIlJeCHaJI xapaRTepIICTIIRa lJeperrOB 6hIJIa OCYII\eCTBJIeHa,
)J,eMCTBIITeJIbHO, RpaMHe He6pemHO, lJTO p;aeT BOSMomHOCTb rrOJIbSOBaTLcH elO
JIIIrnb B MaJIOM CTerreHU. ABTOp HaII60JIee rrOJIlIOM CBOP;HU no HpaHIIOJIOrIIII
cmI<pOB - T. C. ROHlJ,YRTopOBa cym;ecTBeHHO ROHRpeTIISUpOBaJIa BhIBOp:bI
f. $. ,l];e6ell,a 0 CXO,LWTBe CRII<pOB C IIpep;rneCTBYlOm;IIM HaCeJIeHIIeM 3rrOXII
6pOHShI, BBep:JI CTaTIICTII1JeCROe corrOCTaBJIeHIIe II IIOHasaB, 1JTO HaII60JIbrnee
CXOP;CTBO CBH3bIBaeT ceplIII cmI<pOB II cepIIII CPy6HOM HYJIbTypbI YHpaIIHbI II
IIOBOJImhJI 17.
IIo BOCTOlJHhIM 06JIaCTJIM, B lJaCTHOCTII, no ceBepHhIM paMOHaM Cpep;HeM
Asuu, MhI IIMee I MHorO nIC;[eHnhle IICCJIep;OBaHIIJI, IIOCBHm;eIIH:bIe RaR 0'1'-
)J,eJIbIIhIM cepIIHM 3IIOXU 6pOHSbI, TaR II 60JIee rrosp;HUM, npOIICXOp;Hm;UM IIS
TaR HaShIBaeMhIX caRCRIIX MOrIIJIbHIIHOB. Mop<p0JIOrIIlJeCRU 3TII cepUII MomHO
BhICTpOIITb B P;OBOJILHO nOC.TIe)J,OBaTeJIbHbIM pJID" Ha OCHOBe HOToporo 6bIJI
C<POPMYJIIIpOBaH IITorOBhIM BhIBOP; B BIIp;e rIIrrOTeSbI reHeTIIlJeCHOM rrpeeMCT-
BeHHOCTfI Memp:y HaCeJIeHUeM cmI<pCRoro BpeMeHII U IIpep;nreCTBYlOm;IIM Ha-
CeJIeHIIeM 3IIOXII 6pOH3bI 18 . O;'),HaRO HaCeJIeHIIe 3IIOXU 6pOHSbI caMO 6bIJIO
p;OCTaTOlJHO Heop;Hopo):(IIO B aHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCHOM OTfIOrneHIIU 19, nOlJeMy ru-
IIOTe3a IIpeeMCTBenHOCTII He IIClJepnhIBaeT BceM IIp06JIeMhI reHeSIIca caHCRO-
ro HaCeJIeIUIH Cpep;HeM ASIIII U Tpe6yeT p:aJIbHeMrneM ROHHpeTIISall,IIU. IIpaR-
TII IeCRU B TaROM me COCTOJIHIIII HaXOLUITCH U Borrpoc 0 rrpOIIcxomp;eHIIU Ta-
rapCRoro HaCeJIeHIIJI MI1HYCIIIICROM ROTJIOBIIHhI. B paOOTax f. $. Ae6ell,a JiI
MOIIX 6hIJIa c):(eJIaHa IIorrhITRa rrOHasaTb IIX Mop<P0JIOrU1JeCROe CXOP;CTBO C MII-
nYCIIUCHIIMU acpaHaCbeBll,31\UI II 06'bJICHIITb ero 06m;UM reHe3IICOM 20. CTa-
TUCTIIlJeCHOe corrOCTaBJIeHHe B ll,eJIOM IIop;TBepp;UJIO Hau60JIbrnylO 6JIIISOCTb
MIIUYCIIHCRIIX Tarapll,eB C MIIHYCUHCHIIMU me a<paHaCbeBll,a III, HO npu IIC-
nOJIb30naHIIII IIpIISHaROB C p;eMCTBIITeJIbHO BhICOHIIM paSrpaHU1JUTeJIbHbIM
3cp<peHTOM HaII60JIbrnaH 6JIUSOCTb <pIIRcIIpyeTcH B CJIYlJae cpaBHeHUJI MHHY-
CHHCHIIX Tarapll,eB II HasaXCTaHCHUX aHp;pOHOBll,eB ceBepHhIX, ll,eHTpaJIbHbIX II
BOCTOlJHbIX paMOHOB paCCeJIeHIIJI 21. ,l];aJIbHeMrnee IICCJIep;OBaHIIe BceM npo-
6JIeMhI, 01J:eBUp;HO, He06xop;IIMO.
RaR BllP;IIM, B IIpOll,eCCe USYlJeHIIH rraJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIU CHu<pCRoro BpeMe-
fIU B rrpe)J,eJIax apeaJIa, rpaHUll,bI HOToporo 6bIJIU HaMelJeHbI Bhlrne, orrucaHbI
II UCCJIe)J,OBaHbI 06rnIIpHhIe MaTepIIi\JIhI. IIpii p;OCTaTOlJHO )J,eTaJIbHOM pac-
CMOTpeHUII OHII MorYT ;'),aTb OCHOBY )J,JIJI nop;xop;a RO MHorIIM np06JIeMaM JiI
208
fIX perneHUH. R 1J:UCJIY TaRIIX np06JIeM OTHOCJITCJI TIInOJIOrM1JeCHIIH IIJIII no-
rrYJIHll,IIOnHbIM xapaHTep aHTpOrrOJIOrII1JeCROH p;II<p<pepeHll,IIall,IIU B RbIopaH-
HOM apeaJIe II B HaSBaHHoe BpeMJI, reHeTUlJeCRIIe ROHTaKTbI C HaCeJIeHIIeM
3rrOXII 6pOHShI, BOSMOII\HhIe rrepeCeJIeHUJI C sarrap;a Ha BOCTOR II HaooopOT,
l\IIIOrIIe acrreHThI rraJIeo):(eMorpa<pIIU II peHOHCTpYHll,IIII 3IWJIOrUlJeCROM HIIIIIU,
naHOHell" Oll,eHHa paspaOOTaHHhIX rrpeIIMym;ecTBeHHO Ha apXeOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX
MaTepIIaJIaX rIIrrOTea npOIIcxomp;enIIH CRII<pOB II pop;CTBeHHbIX IIM IIJIeMeH.
Ho rrpemp;e - HeCROJIbHO CJIOB 0 HaII60JIee ll,eJIeCOOOpaSHhIX cnocooax BbIoopa
M opraHusall,IIII p;aHHbIX P;JIJI nO;'),OOHbIX cpaBHIITeJIbHbIX IICCJIep;OBafIIIH.
MOI'HJIbHIIRII, ,l];ABIDIIE ,l];OCT ATOqHO IIPE,l];CT ABIITEJIbHblff
IIAJIEOAHTPOIIOJIOI'lIqECRlIfiMATEPIIAJI
CJIOBOCOlJeTaHUe «)J,OCTaTOlJHO rrpep;CTaBIITeJIbHhIM» ne llMeeT op;HOSHalJHOrO
C lhICJIa B afITpOnOJIOrII1JeCHOM JIIITepaType, oc06eHHO IIO OTHorneIIIIlO R naJIeo-
aHTpOrrOJIOrUlJeCHIIM BbIoopHaM, JiI p;IIRTyeTcH Sap;alJaMII II xapaRTepOM IIC-
CJIep;OBaHUJI. R YCJIOBHO rrpIIHIIMalO HIImHlOlO rpaHIIll,y lJIICJIeHHOCTII B 5 Mym-
CHIIX II 4 meHCRIIX HaOJIIoJJ.eHIIJI (IICHJIlOlJeHIIH orOBopeHbI OCOOo), He IIMeJI
BOSMomIIOCTU aprYMeHTIIpOBaTb ee HIIlJeM, RpOMe cooopameHUJI 0 HpallHeH
MaJIOlJIICJIeHHOCTU HaXOp;JIm;IIXCH B HarneM pacnOpJImerIIIU BbIOOpOR ;'),ame rrpII
3TOM OlJeHb HeCTporOM YCJIOBIIII.
B TO me BpeMH BhIOOpRU lIS MOrIIJIbHIIHOB rrpUHJIThI sa 3JIeMeHTapHhIe
ep;IIHIIll,bl, COCTaBJIHlOm;IIe OCHOBY )J,JIJI paCCMOTpeHIIJI reorpa<pIIlJeCROM IIaMeH-
1JUBOCTU IIpIISHaROB. IIorrYJIJIll,IIOHHaJI TOlJHa SpeHIIJI npu BceM YCJIOBHOCTII
oTomp;eCTBJIeHUJI MOrUJIbHUHa C IIOIIYJIJIll,UeM SaCTaBJIHeT oTp;aTb IIM npep;-
rr01J:TeHIIe B IIpoTIIBoBec cYMMapHoMY rrop;xoP;Y, B COOTBeTCTBIIU C ROTOpbIM
OIIYOJIIIROBaHa OOJIhrnaJI lJaCTb MaTepIIaJIOB. IIpu 'I.'aROM nop;xo)J,e cepuII 00-
paaoBaHbI C ep;uHcTBeHHOM ll,eJIblO YBeJIU1JeHIIJI IIX lJIICJIeHHOCTII B COOTBeT-
CTBIIII C reorpa<pH1JeCHIIM palioHIIpOBaHIIeM, oOJIee IIJIJiI MeHee YCJIOBHhIMII
cOBpeMeHHhIMu ap;MIIIIucTpaTIIBHhIMII rpaHIIll,aMu JiI T. p;. II BO MHorIIX CJIY-
lJaJIX He COOTBeTCTBYlOT peaJIbHbIM UCTOPURO-3THII1JeCRIIM II )J,ame IICTOpIIRO-
XOSHMCTBeHHhIM rpaHIIll,aM B p;peBHOCTU.
HIIme p;aeTCJI IIepelJeHb UCrrOJIbSOBaHHbIX MOrIIJIbHIIHOB C YHaaaHIIeM He-
OOXOP;UMOM apxeOJIOrUlJeCROM II OIIOJIUOrpa<pIIlJeCROM IIH<popMall,IIU.
H UKOJlae6Ka (OiJeccKaH o6.IL.). MOrIIJIbHIIH OOHa PymIIJI TIIrrIIlJHO CHU<p-
CHIli] HYJIbTypHhIM ROMnJIeRC U p;aTIIpyeTCJI IV - I II BB. p;o H. 3. 22 Becb
IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrU1JeCHIIM MaTepIIaJI pecTaBpupoBaH II orrIIcaH M. C. BeJIllRa-
HOBOM 23. H rrpIIcoep;IIHHlOCb R ee RpIITIIlJeCRIIM aaMelJaHIIJIM no nOBOP;Y ce-
pIIU C TeppUTopIIU II PYTCHO- ,l];HeCTpoBCHoro Mem)J,ypelJbJI, onYOJIUROBaHHoii
A. ,l];oHIIlJeM B 30-x rop;ax, HeCMOTpH Ha '1.'0 1JTO 3Ta cepUJI <pIIrypIIpOBaJIa B
CBOJJ;HOM paOOTe f. $. Aeoell,a II OhIJIa IICnOJIb30BaHa B HalJeCTBe cpaBHII-
TeJIbHOM B OP;HOM US MOIIX pa60T: rraMHTHIIHII, lIS ROTOpbIX npOUCXOP;JIT OT-
p;eJIbHbIe lJepena, He YRasaHhI, ,L\aTIIpOBHa rr03TOMY OC'I.'aBJIHeT meJIaTb JIY1J-
rnero, caMa CepIIJI HOCIIT COOpHbIM xapaRTep. OHa, eCTeCTBeHHO, IICHJIlOlJeHa
IIa paCCMOTpeHUJI. COOpHbIM xapaHTep HOCUT II n03TOMY TaHlI\e He IICrrOJIbSO-
BaHa HeOOJIbrnaH cepIIH lIS ,l];ooPyp;mII U TpaHCIIJIbBaHUII C TeppUTOpI1H Py-
MhIHUU, OIIIICaHHaJI PYMhIHCRIIMII IICCJIe)J,OBaTeJIJIMII U <purypupyrom;aJI B
cpaBHUTeJIbIIhIX TaOJIIIll,aX HHIIrII M. C. BeJIIIRaHOBOM.
KYT U{1-tenponeTpo6cKaH o6.IL.). MaTepIIaJI IISYlJeH T. C. ROH)J,YKTOPOBOii
JiI BHJIlOlJeH elO B CBOP;HbIe cpep;Hue no CRII<pCHOM cepuu ua II pUlJepHOMOpCRUX
CTerreM 2\ MOrUJIbHIIH, oTRyp;a rrpOUCXO)J,HT lJepena, OhIJI paCRonaH ,l];. T. Be-
peSOBll,OM 25. OH COCTOHJI He TOJIbHO US CRII<pCRUX naMJITHUHOB, BHJIlOlJaJI
IIorpeOeHUJI 3nOXII OpOHSbI II, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, <PYHRll,IIOHIIpOBaJI ;'),OCTaT01J:HO
209
p;OJIroe BpeMH. MH)J,IIBIIp:yaJII,Hhle IISMepeHIIH lJeperrOB OIIYOJIIIROBaH:bI
T. C. ROHp,yRTOpOBOM B CIIell,IIaJII,HOi paOOTe 26. B CIIUCHe MeCTOHaXOmp;eHUII
MOrIIJIMIIIROB C IIaJIeOafITpOIIOJIOrII IeCRIIM MaTepIIaJIOM B CBOP;HOM paooTe
1972 r. OHa YRaSI,IBaeT, lJTO HS 3'1'01'0 MOrIIJII,HIIHa IIMeeTCJI 16 rrpIIrO)J,HI,IX K
IISYlJeHIIlO CReJIeTOB - 7 MY1KCHIIX U 9 meHCHIIX (c. 23), HO B paoOTe 1974 r.
OIIYOJIIIHOBaHbI IIHp;IIBII)J,yaJII,HhIe U3MepeHITH TOJIhHO 5 MymcKux II 7 meH-
CRIIX 'IepenOB Jl,aJIeRO He rrOJIHOM coxpaHHOCTII (C. 78-85). R COmaJIeHIIlO,
YHasaHO JIIIrnI, ux IIpoucxomAeHIIe I13 ,l],IIerrporreTpoBcROM OOJIaCTU U IIp;eH-
TU<pIIll,IIpOBaTI, IIX C lJeperraMII IIMeHHO lIS RYTa MomHO JIIIrnI, C IIOMOm;I,lO
crrHCRa IIHBeHTapnhlX HOMepOB B RHHre 1972 r. IIo onYOJIHROBaHHhIM IIHP;H-
BII)J,yaJII,HI,IM I13MeperrIIJIM BUlJIICJIeHhI cpe)J,Hue, <PIIrypUPYlOm;IIe B TaOJI. 3.
HUKOnOJlb (J(T-lenponerpoecKaH o6Jl.). MaTepIIaJI npoUCXOP:UT II3 paCRO-
nOH HeCROJII,RIIX IICCJIep;OBaTeJIeM, ocyru,eCTBJIeHHhIX IIMII B 30-x rO)J,ax 27. OH
1JaCTII IHO rrorIIO BO BpeMJI BeJIIIHOM OTe IeCTBeHnOM BOMHhI, HO Cp;eJIaHHbIe
f. $. ,l];eOell,OM U3MepeHIIH rro He6oJIbrnOM rrporpaMMe COXpaHIIJIUCb II 6hIJIII
orrYOJIIIHOBaHhI T. C. ROHp,yHTOpOBOM 28. CoxpaHIIBrnaHCH lJaCTb MaTepnaJIOB
6hIJIa rrOBTopHO IISMepeHa f. II. 3UHeBIIlJ, ROTopaH D,OrrOJIHUTeJII,HO IISYlJUJIa
TaHme HeCROJIbRO lJeperrOB, He nonaBrnIIX B PYHII f. $. ,l],eoell,a. B peSYJIb-
TaTe elO onYOJIUHOBaHhI cpep;HHe IIO MymcRuM U meHCHIIM lJepenaM, OIIHpa-
lOm;IIeCH Ha II3MepeHHhIM elO MaTepUaJI U na USMepeHUH f. $. Aeoell,a 29
(f. II. 3UHOBIIlJ He nnrneT, npaBp;a, nOJIYlJIIJIa JIU OHa 3TII IISMepeHIIJI 0'1'
caMoro f. $. ,l],eoell,a UJIII BOCrrOJIhSOBaJIaCI, CTaTbell T. C. RonP;YRTopOBOM,
rp;e OHU OhIJIII OIIYOJIIIROBaH:bI 30). T. C. ROHP;YHTopoBa OTMeTIIJIa B CBoeM
RHIIre 1972 1'., lJTO B onpep;eJIeHIIII rrOJIa II B ll,U<ppOBOM xapaRTepIICTfIRe
Mem)J,Y f. $. ,l];eoell,OM U f. II. 3IIHOBIIlJ IIMelOTCH B OTp:eJIbHhIX CJIYlJaHX
paCXOmp;eHUJI. O IeBIIP;HO, Y f. II. 3IIHOBII I, paooTaBrneM II03me U paCIIOJIa-
raBrneM BceM nOJIHOTOM IIH<popMall,uII, ObIBrneH H B pacrrOpJImeHIIU f. $. Ae-
oell,a, OhIJIU RaHue-TO OCHOBaHUJI P;JIJI U3MeHeHHJI U MeTpUlJeCROM xapaR'repII-
CTIIHII, II IIOJIOBOM npIIHap;JIemnOCTII.
30JlOraH BaJlKa (XepCOT-lCKaH o6.IL.). 8TOT H TPII nOCJIeP;YlOm;UX IIaMJIT-
HIIRa XpOHOJIOrIIlJeCHH BhIXOP;JIT 3a HIImHlOlO rpaHUll,Y HaMelJeHHOrO HaMII
BpeMenHoro Py6ema - III B. p;o H. 3. MOrIIJIMIUH B 30JIOTOM BaJIRe UCCJIe-
p;OBaJICH HeCHOJIbHUMII apxeOJIOraMII, OOJIbrne Bcero M. M. BJI3bMIITIIHOll,
II p;aTHpyeTcH HOHll,OM I T:bICHlJeJIeTIIJI p;o H. 3.- HalJaJIOM H. 3. M. M. BHSI,-
MIITIIHa Ha OCHOBaHUII RYJIbTypHOM xapaHTepucTIIHH MOrUJIbHIIRa C1JIITaeT,
1JTO OB 6hIJI OCTaBJIeH rrpeIIMym;ecTBeHHo n03p;fIeCRII<pCRUM HaCeJIeHIIeM, HO
BHJIlOlJaBrnIIM B CBOM COCTaB HeOOJII,rnOM rrpOll,eHT capMaTCRIIX H HeROTophIX
I1H:bIX 3JIeMeHTOB 31. Becb naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCRIIM MaTepIIaJI II3 pacRonoR
MOrIIJIbHIIRa OhIJI OIIYOJIIIHOBaH T. C. ROH):(YHTOPOBOM B crreI{UaJIbHOM paoo-
Te 32, Ha ROTOpyro M:bI U orrIIpaeMCJI.
HUKOJlaeeKa-K aaalfKoe (XepCOT-lCKaH o6.IL.). IIepBbIll naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrH-
qeCRUM MaTepIIaJI lIS 3Toro MOrIIJIMIIIHa, OlJeHb HeOOJIbrnOM U oOIIapymeHHhIM
em;e M. 8oepToM B HalJaJIe BeRa, orrYOJIUROBaJI A. IIIJIUll, 33, HO, rro MHeHIIlO
M. 11. BJISbl\IIITIIHOM, OTHOCIITeJIbHO TOlJIIyro p;aTupoBRy UMeJIU JIIIrnb p;Be
TpeTII lIS OIIIIcaHHbIX UM lJeperrOB. PaHbrne, B 1JaCTHOCTII B paHHHX paOOTax
M. 86epTa H A. III JIUll, a, MOrllJIbIIIIR HaShIBaJICJI HlmOJIaeBRa, HO ero TOIIO-
rpa<pHlJeCROe paCIIOJIOmeHIIe Memp;y CeJIaMU HUHOJIaeBHa II RaSall,ROe cnpa-
Bep;JIUBO npIIBeJIO H U3MeHeHIIlO HaSBaHIIH. He rrOCJIep;HlOlO pOJIb IIrpalOT II
cooopaiKeIIIIH yp;OOc.TBa: B Op;eccHoM OOJIaCTU IISBeC'l.'HhI p;pyrHe naMHTHllHII
C HaUMeHOBaHueM HIIHOJIaeBHa. AaTuPyeTcH MOrHJIbHUR IIepBhIMU BeHaMll
H. 3., B lJaCTHOCTII 8. A. ChIMOHOBUlJ )J,aTIIpyeT ero I -in I BB. H. 3. 34 Becb
IIaJIeOaIITpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCHIIM MaTepUaJI II3 MOrIIJIbHIIRa ObIJI 06paooTaH
T. C. ROH):(YRTOPOBOM, II rrepBhIe pesYJIbTaT:bI 3TOM oopaooTRu OhIJIII
210
BRJIlOlJeIIhI B ee HHIIry 1972 r. Ho saTeM B CBJISII C nOJIBJIeHIIeM p;OCTaT01J:-
RO 06rnIIpHblx HOBhIX p;aHHbIX naJIeOaH'rpOnOJIoruu MOrHJIbHURa HUHOJIaeBRa-
RaSall,HOe (ihIJIa nOCBHm;eHa cnell,IIaJIbHaJI MOHorpa<pIIJI, B ROTOpOM 6bIJIH
ony6JIIIROBaHhI H un)J,IIBII)J,yaJIbHhle p;aHHbIe 35.
H eano.ab CKuifjcKUU (KpblMCKafl 06.a.). MOrIIJIhHIIR UMee'l.' CJIOmHbIM CO-
CTaB H, CTporo rOBOpJI, 06pasyeT rpynny CUHXPOHHhIX naMJITHIIHOB, no BceM
BepOHTHOCTII OTpamalOm;IIX COll,uaJIbHYlO CTpaTH<pIIRaI{UlO OCTaBIIBrnero ero
HaCeJIeHHH. IIocJIep;Hee BhITeRaeT RaR HS OTHOCUTeJIbHOH CUHXPOHROCTII no-
rpe6eHIIM B MaBSOJIee II HaMeHHhlX CHJIerraX, C o):(noM CTOpOHhI, H B rpYHTO-
BbIX HMax - c p:pyroM, TaR H HS 06napymeHHoro B MaBSOJIee IIHBeHTapH U
caMoro xapaHTepa saxopOHeHUH B MaBSOJIee 36. Becb IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJe-
cmIM MaTepIIaJI 6bIJI orrIIcaH T. C. ROH)J,YHTOPOBOM B yme YIIOMHHaBrneMCJI
Bhlrne CTaTbe. TaM me nOMem;eHhI II IIHp;IIBu):(yaJIbHhIe IIsMepeHIIH. T. C. ROH-
p,yRTopoBa OTp;eJIbHO orry6JIUROBaJIa MaTepIIaJI lIS rpYHToBbIX MOrUJI U rro-
rpe6aJIbIIbIX CHJIenOB. IIapa):(oRCaJIbHbIM 06pasoM lJeperra nOCJI8p;HeM rpyrrnhI
Menhrne, lJeM nepBoM, XOTH 06bI1JHO 60JIee BbICORIIe CJIOH 06m;eC'I.'Ba (a no-
rpe6aJIbHhIe CHJIeIIhI, HecoMHeHHo, rrpUHap;JIemaT CHII<pCROM sHaTu) IIMe:IU B
p:peBHocTII B CBJISU C 60JIee OrrTIIMaJIbHhIMII YCJIOBUJIMU 1f\HSHII U JIYlJrnIIe
rrORaaaTeJIII <pIISIIlJeCROrO paSBII'I.'UJI. Op;HaRO cepuJI lIS CRJIeIIOB H MaBSOJIeJI
MaJIOlJIICJIeHHa II paSJIIIlJIIJIM B paaMepax HeJIbSJI npIID,aBaTb SHalJeHIIH: CTa-
TIICTUlJeCRU OHU He):(ocToBepHbI. II03TOMY B Ta6JIMD;e <PIIrypIIpylO'I.' cYMMapHhIe
)J,aHHhIe.
3aeeTlwe (KpliLMCKafl 06.a.). IIpOBO):(HBrnaH pacRorrRu 3Toro MOrUJIbHIIHa
H. O. Borp:aHoBa nOJIaraeT, 1JTO OH OXBaTbIBaJI B CBoeM <PYHHll,UOHUpOBaHIIH
HeCROJIhRO CTOJIeTIIM H MomeT 6hITb )J,aTupoBaH I B. p;o H. 3.- III B. H. 3. 37
PaaHo06paaHbIe TIIIIhI MOrIIJIbHbIX coopymeHuM U He MeHee pasHo06paSHhIM
MOrIIJIbHbIM IIHBeJnapb CBII):(eTeJIbCTBYlOT B nOJIbSY rIIrrOTeShI paSH03THHlJ-
HOCTU HaCeJIeHIIJI, OCTaBIIBrnero MOrUJIbHHH. CHU<pCRIIM HYJIhTypHhIM 3JIeMeHT
B HeM, BO BCJIHOM CJIYlJae, lJYBCTByeTCJI p;OCTaTOlJHO CIIJIbHO. Orry6JIIIROBaB-
rnaH rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrUlJeCHIIM MaTepIIaJI f. II. 3IIHeBUlJ nOp;lJepHUBaeT, Ha-
060POT, Mop<pOJIOrII1JeCROe ep;IIHCTBO HaCeJIeHUJI 38, lJTO MomeT 6bITb UCTOJI-
HOBaHO HaH )J,ORaSaTeJIbCTBO cym;ecTBOBaHUJI TaM ep;UHOM nonYJIHll,IIH.
B COOTBeTCTBIIU C BbI6paHHbIM B:bIrne HpUTepHeM lJIICJIeHHOCTII B 5 Mym-
CRIIX U 4 meHCRUX Ha6JIlOp;eHUJI MomHO 6bIJIO 6hI BRJIlOlJHTb B Ham 06sop
orry6JIIIROBaHHbIM MaTepUaJI HS paCHonOH B 06JIaCTU cpep;nero Te1JeHHJI
,l];OHa 39. Ha OCHOBaHIIII orry6JIIIHOBaHH:bIX f. <P. Ae6ell,OM IIH):(IIBup;yaJIbHhIX
)J,aHHhIX MomHO 6hIJIO 6hI BhIlJUCJIIITb Cpep;HJile P;JIJI lJeperrOB HS MOrIIJIbHIIHa
MacTlOrIIHo. Op;HaRo 06JIUR RYJIbTypbI a)J,eCb He BrrOJIHe CHU<pCRIIM H BOCXO-
P;IIT CRopee R JIOHaJIbHO MeCTHhIM Tpap:IIll,IIHM 3rrOXH 6pOHSbI. HaCeJIeHHe
cpep;Hero 'I.'elJeHUH ,l];oHa B IIHTepeCYlOm;ylO Hac 3rroxy - CIIpMaTbI aIITHlJHhIX
aBTopOB - OTJIUlJaJIOCb, rrO-Bup;IIMOMY, p;OCTaTOlJHO peSRO H OT CRII<pOB II OT
cap:\faTOB U MOrJIO IIMeTb yrpo-<pIIHCRoe rrpoucxomp:eHIIe 40. RpoMe Toro,
ny6JIIIRall,IIJI f. $. ,lJ,e6ell,a 6esHap;emHo rroCTpap;aJIa Hs-sa HeaRHypaTHoll
HoppeHTopcHOM pa60TbI, ocym;ecTBJIeHHOM yme rrOCJIe cMepTII aBTopa,- ua
Hee BhIIIaJIa Ta6JIIIll,a JIIIll,eBhIX pasMepoB JiI OCTaJIIICb JIIIrnh p;aHHhIe no cRy-
JIOBOM rnHpIIHe. IIo <popMe 1JeperrHOM Rop06RU, HaR 3'1'0 BII)J,HO IIS coxpaHHB-
rneMCJI 'I.'a6mIll,hI, Mop<pOJIOrIIlJeCRIIe paSJIUlJIIJI MeJH)J,y p;HerrpOBCRUMII CRu<pa-
MU U HaCeJIeHIIeM ,l];oHa SHalJII'I.'eJIbIIbI. IIo CTpoeHUlO JIIIll,a, rrpaB)J,a, CYP;JI no
TeRCTY f. $. ,l];e6ell,a H ony6JIUROBaHHbIM IIM rpa<pURaM, paSJIII IIIH Mem):(y
HIIMU HeT. Bce me MaTepHaJI 3'1'0'1' BBII)J,y YHasaHHbIX 06CTOJIT8JIbCTB ll,eJIe-
co06pasHee B )J,aHHoM cJIYlJae MCHJIlOlJIITb.
,l];aJIbrne B onpep;eJIeRIIII npHBJIeHaeMhIx naMJITHIIROB MhI ll,eJIUROM saBU-
CIIM OT COCTOJIHUJI paspa60'l.'KH apxeoJIOrM1JeCHUX )J,aHHblx H HH<popMall,IIH,
211
J."
11
j
.
I
'-
J7i:SBJIeRaeMOM lIS nIICI,MenHhIX IICTOlJHHHOB. HeCMOTpJI fIa SaBep;OMO P;OBOJII,HO
)J,JIUTeJIhHOe rrpe6hIBaHUe CKII<pOB Ha CeBepHOM RaBRase U B 3aHaBRaSI,e,
a TaHme Ha BOSMOmHOCTI, rIIIIOTeTIIlJeCHII CBJI3aTI, C HIIMH pJIP; naMHTHIIHOB 41,
6eccnopHo cmI<pCRIIX MOrIIJII,HIIHOB B IIpep:eJIax RaBHasa, IIO-BIIp;IIMOMY, P;O
CUX IIOp rrORa He 06HapymeHo, a CJIep;OBaTeJIMIO, OTCYTCTBYlOT II COOTBeTCT-
BYlOm;IIe rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrUlJeCRUe MaTepUaJIhI. YrrOMJIHYTaJI TOJII,HO lJTO ap-
XeOJIOrIIlJeCHaH II rrIICI,MeHHaH UH<popMall,UH rrepeHOCUT Hac p;aJII,rne, B npe-
p;eJIhI caRCHoro MIIpa Cpep;HeM A3UII. R COmaJIeHIIlO, B oIIy6JIIIHOBaHHhIX
IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX p;aHHhIX TaHme HeMHoro TaRUX, ROTOphIe MorYT
6bITI, rrpIIypOlJeHl>I R OT)J,eJII,HhIM MOrHJII,HIIRaM, II B nO)J,aBJIJIlOm;eM CBoeM Mac-
ce onII COCTaBJIHlOT cpep;HIIe rro CYMMapHhIM cepIIHM. IIoMHJI 06 OTHOCIITeJII,-
HOM 3THUlJeCHOM OP;HOpOP;HOCTU cpep;HeaSIIaTCRUX caROB II YCJIOBHOCTII OTHe-
ceHIIH R HIIM Tex IIJIII IIHhIX naMHTHUROB, CJIep;yeT OrpaHIIlJUTI,CJI, rrO-BIIp;UMO-
MY, CJIep,YlOm;IIMII MOrIIJII,HURaJ\IU.
T aZUCKell (K abl.fL-O p{)UllCKafl 06JL.). B cepUH pa60T C. II. TOJICTOBa )J,OC-
TaT01JHO rnIIpORO II MHorOCTopOHHe 6l>IJIU oxapaHTepIISOBaHhI RyJII,TypHI,Ie OCO-
6eHHOCTII caRCHIIX rrJIeMeH IIpIIapaJII,JI 42. PaCHOrraHHI,IM rrpeIIMym;eCTBeHHO
M. A. MTIIHOM MOrIIJII,HUR TarIICHeH - OP;UH US TaRIIX caRCRux rraMHTIIIIROB,
IISYlJeHIIe HOToporo rrOMOrJIO SHalJIITeJII,fIO paCrnllpIITI, II yrJIy6IITI, IIpep;-
CTaBJIeHIIH, OCHOBaHHhIe Ha 60JIee paHHIIX pa60Tax C. II. TOJICTOBa 43. ,l];a-
TIIpyeTCJI OH VII - V BB. P;O H. 3. IIaJIeoaJuponOJIOrUlJeCRIIM MaTepUaJI II3
Hero 6I,W )J,Ba m)J,I,I orrIIcaH T. A. TpO<pIIMOBOM 44 II saTeM BOrneJI B CBOP;HYlO
pa60TY B. B. fUHs6ypra II T. A. TpO<pUMOBOII rro rraJIeoaJupOrrOJIOrIIII Cpep;-
HeM A3IIII, Ha HOTOpylO JI BI,Irne yme CCbIJIaJICH. lKeHCRIIe Ha6JIlOp;eHIIH 06'b-
ep:IIHeHbI BBII)J,Y MaJI01JIICJIerrHOCTU C p;aHHhIMI2I rro CJIeP;YlOm;eMy MOrIIJII,HIIHY
n rrpe,rIC'TaBJIeHhI B Ta6JIull,e BMeCTe.
YuzapaK (K 3blJl-Op{)U7-lCKafl o6JL.). PacrrOJIOmeHHl>IM HeBp;aJIeRe 0'1' rrpep;bI-
p;ym;ero, 3'1'0'1' MOrIIJIMIIIR p;aTIIpyeTCJI TeM me BpeMeHeM - VII - V BB. P;O
H. 3. 45 MomHo P;YMaTb, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, lJTO pelJb up;eT 06 op;HoBpeMeHHo
npomIIBaB.rnux rpYIIrrax pop;CTBeHHoro HaCeJIefIUJI. HaJIuque IIpe)J,MeTOB TaR
HaShIBaeMoro CHII<pCHoro 3BepIIIIoro CTIIJIJI, crrell,u<pUlJeCROrO ROHCHoro y60pa
II COOTBeTCTBYlOm;ero opymIIH, T. e. ROMrrOHeHTOB «CHII<pCROM Tpuap;hI», )J,aeT
Bce OCHOBaHIIH BIIp:eTb B 3TOM HaCeJIeHIIU 3THUlJeCHIIM 3JIeMeHT, pop;CTBeHHl>IM
eBpOIIeMCROMY CRII<PCHOMY. IIaJleoaHTponOJIOrUlJeCRUM MaTepUaJI US YMrapa-
Ha orrIIcaH B YHasaIIHhIX pa60Tax T. A. TP0<pUMOBOM.
Y CTb-BYKOllb (BOCTO'l1l0-K aaaXCTallCKafl o6.1l.). MOrUJIbHIIH paCRanhI-
BaJICJI C. C. qepHIIHoBhIM U A. M. Opa36hIeBl>IM 46. ,l];aTupoBRa ero 60JIee
II03)J,HHH, 1JeM p;BYX npep;bIp;ym;IIx MOrIIJIbHIIHOB, - V-IV BB. )J,O H. 3. CYP;JI
no xapaRTepy I1HBeHTapH, OCTaBUBrnaH ero rpyrrrra BeJIa rrpeIIMym;ecTBeHHO
ROlJeBOM 06pas mIISHU. He60JIhrnOM IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCHUM MaTepUaJI US
Hero 6bIJI OIIucaH B. B. fIIH36yproM 47. C. C. qepHIIRoB BhICHaSaJI npep;rro-
JIO, meIUIe lJTO HypraHhI, COCTaBJIHIOm;IIe MOrUJIbHIIH, npIIHap;JIemaJIII pHP;OBO-
MY HaCeJIeHUlO, Torp;a HaR BomLIu rrJIeMeHU 6hIJIIi 3axopOHeHbI lOmHee, B 60-
I-aTl>IX HypraHax qUJIUHCROM AOJIIInI,I. B 3TmI CJIYlJae H He60JII,rnOM cepIIII us
Y CTI,-BYROHH CJIep;OBaJIO 6bI rrpII6aBIITb lJeperra lIS qIIJIHHCRIIX HypraHoB,
lJT06hI IIOJIYlJIITb OP;HY norrYJIHll,IIonHYlO Bl>I60PHY. R COmaJIeHUlO, IIpep;rrOJIO-
meHlIe 3'1'0 TPYP;HO ROHRpeTHO rrOD,TBepAIITb, U n03TOMY OCTopomHee orpaHU-
lJIITbCH IISMepeHIIHMU lJepenOB, rrpoucxoP;Hm;UX Herrocpe):(CTBeHHO US Y CTb-
BYROHCRoro MOrIIJIbHIIRa.
TapbMl-Kafl (TaUlayacKafl o6JL.). 8'1'0'1' MOrIIJIbHHH BHJIlOlJeH B Ham 06-
sop C USBeCTIIOM YCJIOBHOCTI,lO. On paCHonaH B. M. BaMH6epr II OTHeceH R
naMJITHIIRaM BbIp;eJIeHHOM elO RYlOcaMCROM HYJII,TYPl>I 48, HOTOPYlO OHa BRJIlO-
lJaJIa B rnIIpORIIM Rpyr caRCRHX naMHTHUHOB Cpe;'),HeM ASIIII, a cBoe06paSHe
, I
212
06'bHCHJIJIa rrpUMeCblO lOmHhIX HYJIbTYPHhIX 3JIeMeHTOB. IIpH nOJIHOM rry6JIH-
Rall,IIII naMHTHIIROB B. M. BalIH6epr IISMeHIIJIa CBOlO TO'IRY SpeHUJI II CBHShI-
BaeT Terrepb IIOHBJIeHIIe 3TOH RYJIbTYPbI Ha TeppiiTOpUU ,lJ,peBHero XopeSMa
C rrepeCeJIeHIIeM 3THII1JeCROM rpyrrrrhI IIS ceBepHhIX 06JIaCTeM MpaRa 49. Op;-
HaRO 3Ta HOBaJI TO'IRa SpeHIIJI BCTpeTIIJIa BospameHUH 50, B ROTOpbIX c<pop-
MYJIIIpOBaIIa rrOp;D,epmRa rIIrrOTe3bI npeHMym;ecTBeHHO MeCTHoro, caRCHoro
UpOIIcxomp;eHlIH HYlOcaMCHOM RYJIbTYPhI. RpOMe YIIOMJIHYToro MOrIIJIbHIIRa,
l\CTaTII CHa3aTh xapaRTepiiSOBaBrnerOCJI pasHo06paSIIeM <pOpM rrorpe6aJIbHbIX
cooPymeHIIM, 6hI:I paCHOIIaH em;e O;'),IIH - MOrIIJIbHIIH TYMeR-Ru'IH)J,mIIH. OH
pacrrOJIOmeH rrpUMepHO B 40 HM 0'1' MOrIIJIbHURa TapbIM-RaJI II BOSHUR paHb-
me ero npII6mISlITeJIbHO Ha CTOJIeTIIe: rrepBhIll lIS HIlX p;aTIIpyeTCJI VII-
VI BB., BTOpOM - VI - V BB. p;o H. 3. IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrn'IeCHIIM MaTepUaJI
1IS 060IIX MOrlIJIbIHmOB OIIIIcan T. A. TpO<pIlMOBOM, HO BBIIP;Y MaJIO IUCJIeH-
HOCTII 1JeperrOB lIS MOrIIJIbHURa TYMeR-RII'IIIp;mHH HCIIOJIbsyeTCJI TOJIbHO Ma-
TepIIaJI II3 MOrUJIbHIIHa TaphIM-RaJI 51.
[JaMupCKaR I (Foplw-BaiJaxzuallcKaR o6./L.). 8'1'0'1' MOrUJIbHIIR, HaR U rro-
CJIe)J,YlOm;UM, OTHOCIITCH R 06rnllpHoM rpyrrrre saxopoHeHIIM, paCHorraHHhIX na
TeppIITopIIU BOCTO'IHOrO IIaMIIpa A. H. BepHrnTaMOM 52. OTReceHue MOrIIJIb-
HIIHa H HO IeBOM caRCROM RYJIbType He BbISbIBaeT COMHeHUM. RpaHUOJIOrII'Ie-
. CHIIM MaTepIIaJI 6hIJI onIIcaH B. B. fHHs6yproM 53. Op:HaRO OH BRJIIO'IIIJI B
oIIy6JIIIROBaHHbIe IIM cpe)J,Hue no MymcRoM rpYIIIIe e,)J,UHll1J:HbIe 'Iepella U3
.D,pyrIIx MOrIIJIbHUHOB, II n03TOMY MymCRIIe cpep;HIIe, <PurypIIpyrom;IIe )J,aJIee
B Ta6JIIIll,e, rrepeC'IUTaHbI no ony6JIIIROBaHHbIM IIM IIHp;IIBIIp;yaJIbHhIM p;aHHbIM.
BpeMJI 6bITOBaHIIJI MOrIIJIbHIIHa OXBaThIBaeT ,)J,OBOJIbHO p;JIUTeJIbHhIM OTpeSOH:
panHIIe HypraHbI A. H. BepHrnTaM p;aTUpOBaJI V-IV BB., IIosp;HIIe - II-
I BB. p;o H. 3. RypraH 10 3Toro MOrUJIbHIIHa B. A. JIUTBUHCHIIM p:aTIIpyeT
p;ame VI B. p;o H. 3. 54 qepena npOHCXOP;JIT H lIS paHHUX JiI H3 nOS)J,HIIX Ryp-
raHOB, HO 3TUM 06CTOHTeJIbCTBOM IIpU MaJIO'IIICJIeHHOCTU cepuu rrpIIXOp;IITCJI
npeHe6pe'Ib.
AK6euT (Fopllo-BaiJaxZUal-lCKaR o6./L.). A. H. BepHrnTaM B OT'IeTe, Ha HO-
TOpbIM MbI TOJIbRO 'ITO COCJIaJIHCb, )J,aTHpOBaJI 3TOT MOrIIJIbHIIR, RaR JiI nop;aB-
JIHlOm;ee 60JIbrnlIHCTBo aHaJIOrII1J:HhIX eMY rraMJITHUROB, V-IV BB. p;o H. 3.
II03me OH C)J,BIIHYJI HIImHlOlO rpaHIIll,y Ha OP;HO CTOJIeTIIe II CTaJI p;aTIIpOBaT:b
caRCRIIe HypraHhI BOCTO'IHOrO IIaMIIpa VI-IV BB. P;O H. 3. 55 II031Ke IIOHBJiI-
JIOCb rrpep;JIOmeHIIe BepHYTbCJI H rrepBOHa'IaJIbHOM, HeCHOJIbRO 60JIee nosp;HeM
II YSROM p;aTIlpOBRe A. H. BepHrn'l.'aMa 56. B. A. JIIITBIIHCHUM, B ll,eJIOM CorJIa-
rnaHCb B ll,IITIlpOBaHHOM pa60Te C 3TOM p;aTIIpOBROM, HeCROJIbHO pacrnupHeT ee
U npe;'),JIaraeT p:aTY V-III BB. ;'),0 H. 3. MhI rrpIIHlIMaeM IIMeHHO ee, HaR rro-
CJIep;mOlO U OCHOBafIHYlO Ha ropasp;o 60JIee rrOJIHbIX, 'IeM Y A. H. BepHrnTaMa,
p;aIIHhIX, B TOM 'IUCJIe II rro AR6eUTCROMY MOrIIJIbHIIHY, rrOJIY'IenHbIX B xop;e
caMOCTOHTeJIbHbIX paCROrrOR. IIepBaH He60JIbrnaJI rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlI IeCRaJI
ceplIJI II3 paCHonOR AH6eIITCRoro MOrIIJIbHHRa, rrpIIBe3eIIHaJI eIll,e A. H. BepH-
rnTaMOM, 6hIJIa orrIIcaHa B. B. fIIHS6yproM 57, 'Iepena lIS paCRorrOH B. A. JIlIT-
BUHCHoro II3Y IeHhI II oIIy6JIIIHOBaHhI T. II. RIIJITHIIHOM 58. Orry6JIIIROBaHbI
TOJIbHO cYl\L'llapHble rro aBTopaM (OT;'),eJIhHbIe MaTepIIaJIbI B. B. fllH36ypra II
T. II. RIIJITRIIHOM) II, HaH lITor, IIO caRaM BOCTO'IHOrO IIaMIIpa B eJIOM, HO
HMelOm;ueCH B pa60Tax UIIp;IIBIIp;yaJIbHhIe IISMepeHUJI OT):(eJIbHhIX 1JepenOB no-
3BOJIlIJIII rrOJIY IIITb cpe)J,HIle rro UHTepeCYlOm;eM:y Hac MOrllJIbHUHY.
TyaKTa II mu6e (FOpllO-A./LTaUCKaR aeT. o6./L.). BBHP;y MaJIO'IUCJIeHHOCTII
rraJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrU'IeCRUX MaTepIIaJIOB C TeppuTopIIU fopHoro AJITaJI II OP;HO-
BpeMeHHo ux 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOM Mop<P0JIOrU1JeCROM Crrell,II<p uRu , orrpep;eJIHlOm;eM
IIX BamHOCTb B cpaBHUTeJIbHOM corrOCTaBJIeHIIU, p;aHRbIe 06'bep;UHeHbI, 'ITO
213
,;
CTaJIO B03MOmHhIM 6JIaro)J,apJI TeppiiTopuam,HOH H HYJIbTypROH 6JIUSOCTII
IIaMJITHHHOB. M B 3TOM CJIYlJae MhI He nOJIYlJaeM CROJIbHO-Hu6Y):(:b npep;CTaBH-
TeJIbHOM meHCHOM rpYIIrrbI. II pu BbI1JIICJIeRIIH cpe)J,HHX rro MymCHUM
lJepeIIaM IICnOJIbSOBaHa 'I.'aRme BeJIIIlJHna CHYJIOBOrO p;IIaMeTpa, onpep;e-
JIeRHaJI Ha MymcHoM 1J:epene U3 BToporo Barnap;apCHoro HypraHa, pacnOJIO-
meRHoro II06JIIISOCTU 0'1' TY3HTbI U IIIII6e. Bonpoc 0 ,)J,aTupOBRe nOCJIep;RerO
HypraHa BbI)J,epmaJI ;'),JIUTeJIbHYlO ,L\UCHYCCUlO, HalJIIRaJI C nepBoll rry6JIIIHall,UII
aBTopa paCROIIOR M. II. rpHSHOBa, OTHecrnero HypraH H HalJaJIY H. 3.5
TaHaJI p;aTIIpOBHa 6hIJIa nOMepmaRa MHOrHMII aBTopUTeTHbIMU IICCJIep;OBaTe-
JIJIMII, C. M. Pyp;eHHo B ll,HTHpOBaHHhIX pa60Tax BOSpamaJI IIpOTIIB Hee, OT-
HeCJI HypraH H nepBOM nOJIOBIIHe IV B. p;o H. 3. CeMlJaC nOCJIe 06pa311,OBhIX
IIO Tm;aTeJIbHOCTII pa60T JI. JI. BapHOBOM Borrpoc MomHO ClJUTaTb 6esorOBO-
p01JHO perneHHbIM B rrOJIb3Y V-IV BB. p;o H. 3. 60 TaHIIM 06pa30M, U XpORO-
JIOrIIlJeCHIIe rrpoTIIBOIIORasaHIIH P;JIJI 06'bep:IIneHIIH MaTepIIaJIa us TY3RTbI II
IIIII6e OTIIap;alOT. IIocJIe rry6JIURall,IIU IISMepeHMM no RpaTROM nporpaMMe B
CBOP;HOM pa60Te no naJIeoaJuponoJIoruu CCCP r. $. ,l],e6ell,a lJeperra II3
TY3HThI 6hIJIII IIsMepeHbI nOBTopHO rro 60JIee nOJIHOM rrporpaMMe 61. MSMepu-
TeJIbHhIe p;aHHhIe em;e 06 OP;HOM lJeperre HS TY3HThI II OIIIIcaHIIe lJepeIIa H3
BToporo Barnap;apcRoro RypraHa orry6JIUROBaHbI C. M. PY)J,eHHo B 1960 r.
qepen H3 IIIII6e BHJIlOlJeH B nOp;ClJeT no IISMepeHIIJIM r. $. ,l];e6ell,a.
Kypau U Y JLaHIJpbn. (FOP1-l0-A.fLTaUCKaR aeT. o6.IL.). IIo TOM me npIIlJUHe-
MaJIO II1CJIeHfIfJCTU MaTepIIaJIa - B )J,aHHoM cJIYlJae ocym;eCTBJIeHO 06'bep;UHe-
Hue ero us rraMJITHUHOB, paSp;eJIefIHbIX p;eCJITRaMII RIIJIOMeTpoB. Ho OHII
6JIIISRU XpOHOJIOrIIlJeCHU U RYJIbTypHO, nepeBaJI Memp,y RypaMcHoll H qYM-
CHOM p;OJIUHaMII JIerRO rrpeOp;OJIUM, MOP<P0JIOrM1JeCHUe oc06eHHOCTH HaCeJIeHIIJI
IIpaRTUlJeCRII rrOlJTII Tomp;eCTBeHHbI, II n03ToMY yCJIOBHO ero MomHO OTHeCTIf
H OP;HOll IIonYJIJIll,IIu. MOrIIJIbHHR RypaM 06CTOHTeJIbHO oxapaHTepiisoBaH B
MOHorpa<pIIII pacRonaBrnero ero C. B. RIICeJIeBa 62, aBTOp paCHOIIOH Y JIaH-
p;pbIRCHOrO MOrIIJIbHIIRa - B. A. Ry6apen ony6JIHHOBaJI JIUIIIb npe)J,BapUTeJIb-
HhIe C006m;eHIIH 63. ,l];JIJI BhIlJIICJIeHUJI cpep;HIIX (CROJIbRO-Hu6YP;b npep;CTaBH-
TeJIbHhIe p;aHHbIe IIMelOTCJI TOJIbRO rro MymcHIIM lJepeIIaM) 6hIJIU HCnOJIb30Ba-
HbI MOIl II3MepeRIIJI lJepenOB us RypaJI 64 (p;o 3'1'01'0, RaH II lJepena U3,
TY3HTUHCRIIX RypraHoB, OHII 6hIJIU no HpaTHOM nporpaMMe II3MepeHbI
r. <P. ,l];e6ell,OM) II crrell,uaJIbHaJI rry6JIURall,IIH no lJepenaM H3 YJIaH)J,phIRa 65.
Ms nOCJIe):(Hero MOrIIJIbHIIHa IIMeeTCJI )J,onOJIHIITeJIbHbIM IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrulJe-
CHUM MaTepIIaJI II3 pacHorroR B. ,l];. Ry6apeBa nOCJIep;HIIX JIeT, rrORa Re
OIIIIcaHHbIM II xpanHm;IIMCJI B MHCTHTYTe UCTOPUII, <pIIJIOJIOrIIH U <pIIJIOCO<pIIH
CII6IIpcRoro OTp;eJIeHfIJI AH CCCP B HOBOCH6IIpcHe.
TazapcKaR KYJlbTypa (XaKaccnaR aeT. o6Jl.). 8'1'0 TOT pep:RIIM B naJIeOaH-
TpOrrOJIOrIIII CJIYlJaM, Horp;a aHTpOrrOJIOr CTpap;aeT He 0'1' ne)J,OCTaTRa U p;e<p eR -
TOB MaTepHaJIa, a OT ero 06IIJIUJI. ECJIH MbI BBe)J,eM B Ham 0630p Bce p;aHHbIe
rro OTp;eJIbHhIM TarapcHuM MOrIIJIbHIIHaM, '1.'0 OHU 1I0p;aBJIT BClO OCTaJIbHYlO
IIH<popMall,IIlO. Pa3JIIIlJIIJI Mem):(y norrYJIJIll,IIJIMII, OCTaBUBrnUMU MOrHJIbHIIRU
Heop;HoHpaTHo OTMelJaJIUCh 66, HO Mop<p0JIOrUlJeCHU OHU HeSHalJUTeJIbHbI,
He HOCJIT HarrpaBJIeHHOrO xapaRTepa II reorpa<pU1JeCHU MaJIOOTlJeTJIUBhI, no-
3TOMY IIHTeprrpeTall,IIJI IIX Bcerp:a BbIShIBaJIa P;HCHYCCIIlO, He IIOJIyqIIBrnYIO
O;'),HOSHalJHOrO pasperneHUH P;O CUX rrop. To me, BnpOlJeM. MomHO nOBTopIITb
U npo apXeOJIOrIIlJeCHIIe BapIIaHTbI BHYTPII 'I.'arapCRoII HYJIbTyphI 67 . B 06m;eM
HecMoTpH Ha Bce OTMe IeHHbIe Mop<pOJIOrIIlJeCHIIe paSJIU H, OlJeBIIp;HO, lJTO
no):(aBJIJIlOm;ylO Maccy TarapcRoro HaCeJIeHUJI Ha Bcex 3Tarrax ero pa3BUTUJI
COCTaBJIJIJIII )J,JIIIHHOrOJIOBbIe YMepeHHo MaCCIIBRbIe eBpoIIeoIIp;bI, lJTO :II Haxo-
,L\UT oTpameHIIe B 06m;ux cpep;HIIx no rpoMa):(HoM TarapcHoM cepIIII, Haxo)J,JI-
meilcJI HbIHe B HarneM pacnopHmeHUH 68. OHII II <PurYPIIpyroT B Ta6JIIID;ax
214
XOTJI paCCMOTpeHIIe BCerO TarapCRoro HaCe eHIIJI B RalJeCTBe ep;UHOH nony-
.JIHll,UU, HOHelJHO, YC OBHO.
BbIrne yme 6bIJIO YIIOMHHYTO 06 Om;Y'I.'IIMOM Mop<po OrUlJeCROM cBoe06pa-
3IIU HaCeJIeHHJI, OCTaBIIBrnero CUHXPOHH:bIe nepelJIIC eHHbIM MOrIIJIbHbIe na-
MHTHUHII B TYBe. A06aB 1O, lJTO HS HIIX rrOJIYlJeH rpoMap;HbIH IIO 06'beMY II
pa3II006paSHhIM rro HY bTypHOH npIIHap; emHocTu na eoaHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCKHH
MaTepIIa , He TO bRO He IISYlJeHHhIM, HO II He pas06paHHbIM rrO HOCTblO P;O
CIIX rrop. ITpep;rneCTBYlOm;ne IICCJIe)J,OBaHIIJI BbIJIBU H He 'I.'OJIbRO Mop<po orH-
1JeCROe cBoe06paSIIe TYBIIHCRoro HaCe eHIIJI CRII<pCRoro BpeMeHU no cpaBHe-
HHlO C TarapCHIIM, HO II ero saMeTHbIM RpaHIIO OrIIlJeCRUM nO IIMop<pHSM 69.
II pu Ha UlJIIU TaRoro IIOJIIIMOP<PUSMa, OlJeBU)J,IIoro yme IIO HMelOm;UMCJI 1J:pes-
BbIlJalIHO OrpaHIIlJeHHhIM <paHTIIlJeCHUM p;aHHhIM, MomHO omIIp;aTb, lJTO HOBbIe
06II bHhIe MaTepua bl, yme P;06bITble paCRorrRaMU U mp;ym;He uCCJIep;OBaTe b-
CROll 06pa60TRII, cym;ecTBeHHo pacrnnpHT Harnu 3HaHHJI 06 aHTponO OrIIqe-
CHOM COCTaBe Hace eHnH TYBhI B CRII<pCRoe BpeMJI, a B 3TUX 06CTOHTe bCTBax
JI106aJI 3HCTparrO JIll,IIH IIH<popMall,IIII, rrO Y1JeHHOM Ha OCHOBe IISYlJeHIIH He-
60JIbrnOrO MaTepIIaJIa lIS op;Horo H H p:ame HeCHOJIbRUX MOrUJIbHIIHOB, Ha TYBY
B ll,e oM 6yp;eT HenpaBoMepHoM. IT03TOMY BCH np06JIeMa na eoaHTpOIIOJIOrIIII
TYBhI II MOHro IIu B CHII<pcRoe BpeMJI OCTaBJIeHa B p;aHHoM cJIYlJae sa npe-
p;e aMu paccMOTpeHUJI )J,o CIIell,IIaJIbHOrO IICCJIep;OBaHHJI, HOTopoe onnpaJIOCb
6bI Ha opIIrIIHa hHhle BHOBb )J,06bITbIe p;aHHhIe.
PacrrpocTpaHeHue MorII bHuROB, HS ROTOpbIX IIpOHCXO)J,JIT IICnOJIbSOBaHHMe
cepuII, rrORa3aHO Ha pIIC. 12. Cpep;HIIe no cepIIHM CYMMIIpOBaHbI B Ta6 . 3, 4.
IIporpaMMa IIsMepeHIIM CTaHp;apTHa II nOlJTU ll,eJIIIHOM orrpe)J,e He'l.'CJI Ha60-
pOM rrpII3HaROB, 06:bI1JHO <PIIrYPUpYlO1I1;HX B COBeTCRIIX RpaHIIO OrU1JeCRIIX
rry6 IIRall,HJIX noc e)J,HUX JIeT, I1CKJIlOlJeHIIe COCTaBJIHlOT BhIlJHC eHHhIe IIO
cpep;HHM lJepeIIHOM U IIll,eBOH MOP;Y U - reOMeTpIIlJeCRIIe cpep;Hue Tpex lJe-
penHbIX paSMepOB B nepBOM c yqae H ;'),BYX JIIIll,eBbIX BO BTOpOM.
II
rEorp A«I>lIqECRAH II3MEHqllBOCTb
reorpa<pUlJeCRIIM MeTOp;, T. e. paCCMO'I.'peHIIe JiI Oll,eHRa 3aROHOMepHOC'I.'eH B
reorpa<pIIlJeCHOll IISl\IeHlJIIBOCTU OTp;e bHbIx IIpIISHaROB, rnupORO I1CIIOJIbsye-
MhIM BO MHorIIX aHTporrO OrIIlJeCRIIX pa60Tax, 06HapymIIBaeT <peHOTHnII1Je-
CHIIe pa3JIUlJIIJI Memp;y cpaBHuBaeMhIMu rpYIInaMH U )J,aeT HapJI)J,Y c. HeROTO-
pbIMH )J,onOJIHIITe bHbIMH TeOpeTIIlJeCKHMU co06pameHUJIMU MaTepUaJI P; JI
IIOCTpoeHIIH reHea.TIOrITlJeCHUX rIInOTes. Op;HaHO crr ornHoe HapTorpa<pupOBa-
HIIe Bcex IIpep;CTaB eHHbIx B rrporpaMMe rrpIISHaROB IIrneHO CMbIc a, 'I.'aH HaR
no MHorUM lIS HIIX cpaBHHBaeMhIe rpyrrrrbI JIII60 3aBep;OMO He paSJIUlJalOTCJI,
JIu60 paSJIUlJIIH Memp,y HIIMU He BblXOP;HT sa paMRII CJIYlJaMHbIX.
BhI60p npIISHaROB )J, H HapTorpa<pupOBaHIIH npep;rro araeT np0ll,ep;yPY
Oll,efIHU UX U3MeH1JnBOCTII. MomHo 6hWO 6hI P;YMaTb, lJTO caM pa3Max HSMeH-
lJIIBOCTII, T. e. aMrr IITYD,hI Ho e6aHUM 0'1' MJilHIIMYMa P;O MaHcuMYMa, noc y-
lliIIT I e HM TaROM Oll,eHHII, HO Mop<pO OrII1JeCRIIM CMbICJI, a r aBHoe, a6co-
JIlOTHaJI Be UlJIIHa IIpII3HaHOB C IIrnHOM paSJIUlJHbI, lJT06bI HX Ho e6aHHJI
MomHO 6hWO cpaBHUBaTh BnpJIMYlO (Ta6 . 5, 6). qacTo rrO bSYlOTCJI OTHO-
rnerrIIeM aMn IITY)J,bI Ro e6aHull rrpHSHaHa R HaHMeHbrneM Be UlJnHe, sa<pHR-
cIIpoBaHHoM B cpaBlIIIBaeMhIX rpynnax, HO, nOMIIMO '1.'01'0 lJTO Ha SHaMeHaTe b
p;eMcTBYlOT CJIYlJaMHbIe IIpIIlJIIHbI, BJIHJIHUe HOTOpbIX He bSJI YlJeCTb, saBe)J,OMO
IISBeCTHO, 1JTO paSMepbI C MaJIOM a6COJIlOTHOM Be U1J:MHOH BapbupYlOT ropas-
;'),0 60 ee SHalJIITe bHO, lJeM C 60JIbrnoll. )J;eMcTBIITe bHo, H B HarneM CJIYlJae
MemrpYIIIIOBaJI aMIIJIIITyp;a Ro e6aHIIM, BhlpameHHaJI B npOll,eHTaX MUHUMaJIb-
HhIX BeJIIIlJUH npJilSHaHOB, oc06eHHO SHa1JU'I.'eJIbHa )J,JIJI CUMO'I.'M1JeCRIIX II
215
.-
--
N
.......
0:>
1. IIpOAOJIbHbIM AIIaMeTp 187,0 (18) 180,5(4) 188,5(16) 184,8 (23) 185,6 (66) 185,4 (65) 185,5 (23) 178,2(6)
8. IIonepe'IHbIM AilaMeTp 139,5 (18) 138,8 ( ) 139,8(15) 139,2 (24) 139,8 (66) 139,5 (62) 140,2(24) 144,3(6)
17. BbIcoTHbrn AuaMeTp OT 6a3uoHa 134,7 (14) 128,0 (1) 136,1 (9) 134,6 (17) 133,9 (62) 135,7 (41) 132,0 (13) 132,0(2)
8 : 1. qepenHoii Ylm3aTeJIL 74,7 (18) 76,9 (4) 74,8 (15) 75,2 (23) 75,4(66) 75,4 (62) 75,5 (23) 81,3 (6)
!i-
1.8.17. LlepellHoM MOAYJIL 152,0 * 147,5 * 153,1 * 1:>1,3 * 151,5 * 152,0 * 150,9 * 150,3 *
9. HauMeHbIIIaJI IIIupuIIa JI6a 97,1 (19) 97,0(5) 98,5(13) 95,0(23) 96,6 (69) 9(\,2 (60) 98,8 (23) 97,6 (7)
32. ¥roJI JI6a 80,1 (15) 83,6(5) 85,2 (8) 81,7(20) 83,6 (63) 83,8 (42) 82,3(11) 79,0(3)
5. .D:JIIlHa OCHOBaHIIH 'Iepena 101,6 (15) - 103,1 (9) 100,4 (17) 101,0(59) 102,2 (:15) 101,4(13) 105,0(2)
40. .D:JIUHa OCHOBaHIIJI JIul\a 96,1 (15) - 97,5 (8) 96,2(14) 96,6(58) 97,2 (23) 99,5(10) 98,0(2)
40 : 5. ¥Ka3aTem, BbIcTynaHUJI JIul\a 94,6(15) - 94,3 (8) 95,5(14) 95,8 (56) 95,7 (13) 97,1 (10) 93,4(2)
45. CII:YJIOBaJI IIIHpUHa 133,3(15) 132.,4 (5) 135,1 (10) 132,9 (23) 133,1 (fi5) 133,1 (50) 133,7 (13) 139,8(5)
45 : 8. I'0pu30HTaJIbHbIii iPal\IIOl\epe6paJIbHbIii: 96,2 (17) 94,6 (4) 96,6 * 96,4 (22) 95,3 (65) 95,2(47) 95,4 * 96,8 *
YKa3aTeJIb
48. BepXHJIJI BbICOTa milIa 71,7 (18) 70,8(5) 71,2(11) 69,7 (21) 71,6 (68) 71,3 (53) 72,4(19) 74,4 (5)
48 : 17. BepTUKaJIbHbIM iPal\uol\epe6paJIbHbIii: YKa- 52,9 (15) 59,4(1) 52,3 * 51,8 (15) 53,5(61) 53,3 (34) 54,8 * 58,8 (2)
3aTeJIb
48 : 45. BepxHIIii JIUl\eBOM Ylm3aTeJIb 53,2(15) 53,6 (5) 54,5 (8) 52,1 (20) 53,7 (64) 53,6(44) 53,1 (11) 53,2 (5)
tf 45.48. JIIIIWBOii MOAYJIb 97,8* 96,8* 98,1 * 96,2* 97.,6 * 94,9 * 98,4 * 102,0*
51. IIInpuHa Op6HTbI OT rof (JIeB.) 41,7 (15) 41,2 (5) 41,6 (5) 41,3 (21) 41,3 (68) 40,7 (54) 42,5(17) 45,6(5)
52. BbIcoTa Op6HTbI (JIeB.) 32,6(16) 33,8(5) 32,5 (12) 32,9 (21) 32,9 (68) 32,9 (57) 33,3 (18) 35,9 (5)
52 : 51. Op6HTIIbIi'I YKa3aTeJIb OT rof (JIeB.) 78,3(15) 82,0(5) 79,0(5) 79,8 (21) 80,2(68) 81,0(53) 78,9 (5) 73,4 (6)
54. IIIHpHna Hoca 25,2 (16) 24,8(5) 24,3 (9) 24,9(19) 24,8 (68) 24,8 (52) 25,4 (17) 27,2 (5)
55. BbIcoTa HOca 51,5 (18) 50,0(5) 50,0(10) 50,0(20) 51,5 (67) 50,7 (51) 51,8(18) 55,4(5)
54: 55. HOCOBOii: YII:a3aTeJIb 49,0(16) 49,8 (5) 48,8 (9) 49,8 (19) 48,9(67) 48,9 (50) 48,7 (16) 49,1 (5)
72. 06ll\Hll yrOJI JIHl\a 87,7 (15) 84,0(5) 85,5 (8) 85,5 (18) 85,6 (61) 84,6 (34) 84,4(12) 88,3 (3)
74. ¥roJI aJIbBeOJIHpUoii qaCTII JIIIl\a 77,7 (15) 81,0(4) 83,5 (2) 82,2(14) 83,2 (55) 82,1 (30) 76,0(4) 79,0(3)
75 (1). ¥roJI HOCOBbIX IwcTeii K JIHHHH npoiPIlJIJI 31,8 (12) 32,5 (2) 35,6 ( 10) 32,8 (12) 32,4 (50) 29,8 (27) 32,6 (9) 25,3 (3)
77. Ha30MaJIHpIIbIii yroJI 135,4(17) 138,2 (5) '140,7 (4) 13(\,7(20) 137,2 (64) 137,6 (51) 139,6 (13) 144,6(4)
Lzro'. 3nroMaKCHJIJIHpHbUi yroJI 125,5 (14) 130,5(4) 130,0(3) 124,0 (18) 125,5 (64) 124,,6 (33) 127,5(13) 133,6 (4)
DS. .D:arl:pHaJIbUan BbICOTa 14,0(13) 11,5 (2) 12,0(3) 13,8 (7) 12,9 (38) 12,5(12) 12,7 (13) 11,6 (2)
DS : DC. .D:arl:pHaJIbHbIii Yll:a3aTeJIb 65,9 (13) 58,0(2) 57,6 (3) 59,5 (7) 57,3 (38) 56,2 (12) 57,3 (13) 58,7 (2)
SC. CHMOTH'IeClmH IJLICOTa 6,1 (13) 4,2 (3) 4,5 (5) 4,3 (15) 4,7 (60) 4,3(44) 4,7 (14) 3,8 (5)
SS: SC. CHMOTHqeClmii: YII:a3aTeJIb 61,4 (13) 51,9 (3) 51,1 (5) 52,3 (15) 56,1 (60) 48,3(44) 48,0(14) 51,9 (5)
,
Ta6JIul\a 3
CpeAHue pa3MepbI u YRa3aTeJIU CRuiPCRux '1epenOB no MOTUJIbHURaM. MymcRlIe '1epena
/ HI1ROJIaeB- / /H I SOJIOTaH I HI1ROJIaeBRa- / HeanOJIb
IIpl1sHaR Ra RYT I1ROnOTIb 6aJIRa RaSaljROe CUI1WCRI1M
IsaBeTHOC / Tal'l1CRCII
IIpl13HaR
'l'a6JIHQa 3 (rrpoAomI\eHue)
I Y11rdpaR I YCI Y- J T'W 1- I :::r
AROCI1T
TY3HTa
11 illHoe
I Rypafi I
11 YJIaH.r\-
pHR
TarapCRaH
RYJIbTypa
N
.......
..;J
1. IIpOAOJIbHbIH AuaMeTp 188,0 (7) 178,4 (8) 184,3 (6) 186,7 (7) 194,5(13) 189,8 (5) 183,9 (7) 186,9 (319)
8. IIOrrepe'IIIbIH ,[\uaMeTp 150,4 (7) 142,7 (8) 139,7 (7) 132,9 (7) 133,8 (13) 147,8 (5) 144,1 (7) 140,6 (293)
17. BbICOTIIbIii ,[\uaMeTp OT oa3uoHa 143,7(3) 130,0 (7) 141,7 (6) 136,3 (6) 134,3 (9) 135,8(5) 135,2 (6) 135,9(256)
8 : 1. 1Iepemloii YKa3aTeJIb 79,9 (7) 80,1 (8) 75,7 (6) 71,1 (7) 68,9 (13) 78,0(5) 78,6 (7) 75,3 (285)
V-
1.8.17. lIeperrlloH MOAym> 159,6 * 149,0 * 153,9 * 150,1 * 151,8 * 156,1 * 153,0 * 152,8 *
\}. HauMeIIbIIIaH IIIIIpIIHa JIoa 98,9 (7) 98,9 (8) 99,2 (6) 91,5 (6) 94,9 (9) 101,4(5) 96,4 (7) 98,8 (346)
3 . YroJI JIoa 82,0(4) 78,0(8) 83,5 (4) 81,3 (6) 79,4 (8) 80,8(4) 84,5(6) 82,3 (252)
5. AmIHa OCHonamIH 'Iepena 109,0(3) 102,0(7) 101,2(5) 102,2 (5) 107,2(10) 106,2 (4) 102,8 (6) 105,0(258)
40. AmIIIa OCIIonaHUH JII1l\a 101,0(3) 98,0(7) 95,2(5) 95.,6 (5) 101,4 (9) 100,5(4) 98,2 (6) 101,7 (223)
40 : 5. YKa3aTeJIb nbIcTynaHIIH JII1l\a 92,7 (3) 96,1 (7) 94,3(5) 93,5 (5) 95,5 (9) 96,9 (4) 95,6 (6) 96,9 (224)
45. CI\YJIOnaH IIIIIpIIHa 143,5(6) 140,1 (9) 138,2 (5) 126,5 (6) 130,2 (10) 146,8 (6) 136,2 (6) 137,6(224)
45 : 8. I'opII30HTaJIbHbIM wal\IIol\epe6 paJIbHbIM 95,4 * 98,5 (8) 97,1 (5) 95,7(6) 97,8(10) 98,7(5) 95,2 (6) 97,9 *
YKa3aTeJIb
48. BepxHHH BbICOTa JIul\a 76,7 (6) 71,9 (9) 71,8 (8) 75,4(7) 75,3 (1O) 79,2 (5) 69,8 (6) 71,8(290)
48 : 17. BepTIIKaJIbHbIll Wal\IIOl\epeOpaJIbHbm YI{3- 53,8 (3) 55,5 (7) 50,9 (6) 54,9(6) 55,6 (8) 54,3(5) 51,7 (6) 52,8 (217)
3aTeJIb
48 : 45. BepxHuii JIIIl\eBOM y.I{33aTeJIb 53,6 (6) 51,4(9) 51,7 (5) 59,1 (6) 58,1 (9) 58,3 (5) 51,4 (6) 52,3 (208)
if 45.48. JIIIl\eBOM MO,[\YJIb 104,9 * 100,4 * 99,6* 97,6* 99,0* 107,8 * 97,5 * 99,4*
51. IIIupuHa Op6UThI OT m f (JIeB.) 44,7 (6) 44,0(9) 42,4 (8) 41,0(li) 43,0(12) 45,1 (4) 43,1 (6) 43,4 (273)
52. BbIcoTa Op6UTI,I (JIen.) 32,,7(6) 33,7 (9) 33,6 (8) 31,2 (6) 34,8(11) 36,4 (5) 33,9 (6) 32,8 (301)
52: 51. Op6IITHbIM YKa3aTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 73,4 (6) 76,5 (9) 79,5 (8) 83,3 (n) 80,9 (11) 79,3 (4) 75,9 (6) 75,8(270)
54. IIIIIpIIHa Hoca 26,8 (6) 25,8 (9) 25,5 (8) 23,9 (7) 2.4,8(11) 26,4 (fi) 25,3(6) 24,9(304)
55. BbICOTa Hoca 5:1,1 t6) 61,9 (9) 56,8 (8) 54,4 (7) 54,8(11) 56,2 (5) 52,0(6) 51,6 (311)
54 : 55. HOCOBOJ1: YKa3aTeJIb 50,1 (6) 49,7 (9) 45,1 (8) 43,9 (7) 45,5(11) 47,3(5) 48,9(6) 48,3(301)
72. 06Il llll yroJI JIIIl\a 87,0(4) 84,4(8) 87,3(4) 84,0(6) 85,0(7) 88,0(4) 85,5 (6) 85,1 (241)
74. YrOJI aJIbneOJIHpHOM 'IaCTII JIIIl\a 78,5(4) 70,G(8) 80,5(4) 68,0(5) 76,2 (5) 79,0(3) 81,2 (5) 80,2 (210)
75 (1). YroJI HOCOBbIX IWCTeii K mIHllII npOWllJIH 28,0(3) 26,4 (8) 29,3(4) 34,3 (U) 35,3 (9) 24,8 (4) 25,6 (5) 30,5 (234)
77. Ha30MaJIHpHbIJ1: yrOJI 140,4(6) 141,0 (8) 135,9 (7) 137,6 (5) 137,2 (9) 146,7 (3) 146,0(7) 140,3 (275)
Lzm'. 311roMaI{CI1JIJIHpIIbIM yroJI 136,9 (4) 133,1 (8) 126,9 (7) 124,3 (6) 128,0(10) 137,0(3) 134,6 (5) 128,7 (247)
DS. [l,aIqHIaJIbHaH nbICOTa 13,6(4) 13,1 (7) 11,8 (6) 11,7 (6) 12,7 (6) 12,4 (3) 11,8(5) 12,4 (253)
DS : DC. AaKpllaJIbIIbIii YKa3aTeJIb 59,2 (4) 59,2 (7) 58,2 (6) 70,7 (6) 59,8(6) 55,4 (3) 62,3 (5) 59,1 (253)
SC. CUMOTI1'IeCI{3H BbICOTa 4,8 (4) 5,2 (7) 5,1 (7) 4,6 (7) 5,2(11) 4,4 (3) 4,3 (6) 4,5 (279)
SS : SC. CIIMOTl'I'IecmrU YI\a3aTeJIb 50,2 (4) 51,9 (7) 59,5 (6) 55,5 64,3(11) 57,4 (3) 53,0(6) 53,4 (279)
* IIH}J.eRC cpe}J.HI1X.
--
. ......,. -.
'>6
Ta6JIuqa 4
Cpeiwue pasMepbl U YKasaTeJIU cKmpcKux 'IepenOB no MOrUJIbHUKaM. iKeHcKue 'Iepena
IIpll:JHaR
IHflR aeB-1
3aBeTHoe
I HflRorrORb I
I HI1ROJIaeBRa- 1
Ra3atjROe
30JIOTaH
BaJIRa
HearrORb
CRlH}JCRflll:
RYT
N
.....
00
1. II pOAOJIbHblii AnaMeTp 180,9 (18) 181,5 (6) 178,9(11) 176,8 (37) 176,3 (57) 177,4 (24) 179,4 (22
8. IIOIrepe'IHbIH AnaMeTp 136,7 (18) 134,8 (6) 133,6 (11) 136,2 (38) 136,1 (57) 135,2 (24) 135,3 (23
17. BbICOTHbIH AnaMeTp OT 6aauoHo 129,7(10) 126,3 (3) 128,6 (8) 128,4(34) 127,8(56) 130,9 (22) 135,2 (15
8 : 1. lJepenHoii YI{aaaTeJIb 75,6 (18) 74,4(6) 74,8(11} 77,0(39) 77,2 (57) 76,3 (24) 75,1 (22
1.8.17. lJepenHOll MOAYJIb 147,5 * 145,7 * 145,4 * 145,7 * 145,3 * 146,4 * 148,6 *
9. HanMeHbIIIaH mnpnHa JI6a 94,8 (18) 95,1 (7) 92,6(11) 93,5 (37) 93,8(60) 94,5 (25) 94,,3 (23
32. YroJI JI6a 82,9 (9) 84,5 (6) 84,1 (7) 85,2 (29) 85,4(49) 87,4(16) 84,0(12
5. Amma OCHOBaIIlIH qelJena 96,7 (10) 95,0(1) 95,5 (7) 95,9 (31) 94,6 (54) 95,5(19) 98,9 (13)
40. AmnIa ocnOBaHIIH mII a 92,7 (7) 87,,0(1) 91,9 (6) 91,2 (25) 89,7 (47) 90,5 (H) 93,8(12
40: 5. YI{aaaTeJIb BblcTynaHUH JIlII\a 94,6 (6) 91,6 (1) 96,1 (5) 95,0(25) 95,2(47) 95,0( 16) 94,5 (12
45. CKYJIOBaH IllnpnHa 125,0(11) 124,9 (7) 123,3 (7) 124,3 (35) 124,,8 (56) 125,7 (23) 125,0 (18)
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa JInn;a 67,2 (12) 66,3 (6) 66,8 (7) 66,4 (32) 67,7 (57) 67,1(22) 68,7 (19
48 : 17. BepTnKaJIbHblii wan;non;epe6paJIbHhIii YKa- 52,7 (8) 52,7 (2) 52,9 * 51,6 (28) 53,0(53) 51,6 (19) 50,8 *
aaTeJIb
48 : 45. BepxHnH mln;eBoii YKaaaTeJIb 53,7 (9) 54,1 (6) 54,2 (7) 54,7 (32) 54,3(54) 53,9 (21) 53,9 (15
11 45.48. JInn;eBoii MOAYJIb 91,6 * 91,0 * 90,8 * 90,8 * 91,9 * 91.8 * 92,7 *
51. illnpnHa Op6UTLI OT mf (JIeB.) 40,3(11) 39,4(6) 39,0(3) 40,0(31) 40,1 (55) 39,8 (21) 40,3(19
52. BhIcoTa op6nThI (JIeB.) 33,3(11) 32,9 (6) 33,7 (8) 32,8 (31) 32,9 (55) 32,7 (21) 32,3(20
52 : 51. Op6UTHbIH YKaaaTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 82,7 (11) 83,1 (6) 84,6 (3) 81,9 (31) 82,0(55) 82,2 (21) 81,0(17
54. illnpuHa Hoca 23,8 (11) 23,8(6) 23,5 (8) 23,8 (27) 24,2(53) 23,f) (22) 24,3 (19
55. BblcoTa Hoca 49,5(12) 48,8 (6) 49,5(8) 48,5 (30) 48,9 (56) 48,6 (22) 48,5 (19)
54 : 55. HOCOBOH YI{83aTeJIb 47,8 (11) 48,6(6) 47,5 (8) 49,3 (27) 49,5 (53) 48,8(22) 50,3 (19)
72. 06m;nii yroJI JInn;a 84,6 (7) 85,2 (6) 84,2 (7) 84,7 (25) 85,5(46) 85,6(17) 84,2 (14)
74. YroJI aJIbBeOJIHpHOH qaCTn JIIln;a 73,8 (7) 83,0(4) 72,0(1) 80,1 (17) 82,4 (42) 81,3(14) 73,1 (7)
75(1). YroJI HOCOBbIX IwcTeH I{ JIIIHnU npOWUJIH 25,5 (6) 27,0(4) 25,3 (H) 27,2 (19) 29,5(32) 25,8(14) 28,0(9)
77. Ha30MaJIHpnbIH yrOJI 139,5 (10) 135,7(6) 140,0(1} 137,4(30) 138,0(50) 138,9 (21) 139,8(15}
Lzm'. 3UrOMaI\CI'IJIJIHpHhIll: yroJI 127,3 (8) 127,8(6} 132,0(1) 124,6 (21) 126,8(48) 125,3(18) 129,1 (16)
DS. AaKplIaJIbHaH BblCOTa 12,5 (6) 11,3 (3) 12,5(1) 12,1 (9) 11,9 (28) 11,2 (6) 11,,5 ( 17)
DS : DC. AaI{pnaJIbHbIll: YKa3aTeJIb 60,6(6) 51,1 (3) 69,4(1) 56,5 (9) 55,4 (28) 51,8 (6) 50,9(17)
SC. CnMOTnqCCI{aH BblCOTa 4,5 (6) 3,3 (5) 4,0(1) 3,9 (25) 3,9 (47) 3,9(19} 4,1 (17)
SS : SC. CnMOTnqeClmH YKa3aTeJIb 48,3 (6) 37.,2 (5) 61,5 (1) 44,4(25} 48,6(47) 43,6 (19) 41,8(17}
IIpI13HaR
Ta6JIH a (npOp;Oml\eHne)
I1T :r I YCTb-EYROHb I TapbIM-RaH I IIaMI1pCnaH I I AR6eI1T
TarapCRaH
RYJIbTypa
N
.....
<:D
1. IIpOAOJIbHbm AHaMeTp 177,9 (7) i7(j,7 (6) 179,3(4) 176,2 (5) 182,5 (4) 179,0(247)
8. IIonepe'lHbIii AnaMeTp 136,7 (7) 138,7 (6) 140,8 (4) 129,8 (5) 131,5 (4) 135,0 (223)
17. BbICOTHbIll AnaMeTp OT ua3HoHa 127,2 (4) 127,4(5) 133,0(3) 129,5(4) 130,0(1) 130,1 (205)
8 : 1. qepenHoM YI,a3aTeJIb 77,5 (7) 78,6 (6) 77,5 (3) 73,7 (5) 72,9(4) 75.5(216)
V-
1.8.17. qepenHoii MOAYJIb 146,1 * 146,2 * 149,7 * 143,6 * 146,1 * 146,5 *
9. HanMelIbIIIaH IIInpnHa JIua 97,6 (7) 95,8 (6) 94,2(5) 94,0(5) 93,5 (4) 95,8 (264)
32. YrOJI JIua 84,0(4) 82,2 (6) 84,3(4) 82,7(3) 77,3 (3) 83,8(211)
5. AmlHa UCHUBaHllH 'leVlcma 94,2(4) 99,2 (5) 99,7(3) 95,0(4) 97,0(2) 100,3 (201)
40. AJInHa OCIIonamUI JlII a 91,7 (4) 100,0(4) 95,0(3) 93,3 (3) 91,0 (2) 98,6 (172)
40 : 5. YKa3aTeJIb BLIcTynaHnH JIII a 97,4(4) 101,3 (4) 95,4 (3) 96,9 (3) 93,8 (2) 98,3 (170)
45. CltYJIOBaH IIIHpHHa 129,0(4) 133,8 (6) 124,3 (4) 122,,2 (5) 125,8(4) 128,4 (192)
48. BepxHHH BbICOTa JIn a 72,4 (5) 70,6 (5) 88,4(4) 94,4(5) 95,6 (4) 95,1 *
48: 17. BelJTHI{aJIbHbIii wa IIO CJJeUpaJIbHbIn YKa- 57,0(4) 54,3 (4) 66,4(5) 72,0(5) 67,5 (4) 68,6(218)
3aTeJIL
48 : 45. BepxIInM JIII eBoii yI{a3aTeJIL 5u,2(4) 52,1 (5) 52,6 (3) 55,7 (4) 54,6(1) 52,8 (172)
V 45.48. JIn eBon MOAYJIb 96,6 * 97,2 * 53,7 (4) 58,9(5) 53,8 (4) 53,4(171)
51. IIInpHHa opunTbI OT mf (JIeB.) 42,6 (5) 43,0 (G) 90,8 * 93,8 * 92.1 * 93,9 *
52. BbIcoTa opunTbI (JIeB.) 33,4(5) 33,7 (6) 38,6(5) 40,3 (4) 41,5 (4) 42,1 (227)
52 : 51. OPUHTHLIM yI{a3aTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 78,7(5) 78,3 (6) 32,2 (5) 35,0(4) 32,2 (4) 32,9 (249)
54. IIInpHHa Hoca 25,4 (5) 26,4 (5) 83,4 (5) 87,0(4) 77,8 (4) 78,5 (226)
55. BbIcoTa Hoca 54,0(5) 50,4 (5) 24,0(5) 22,6(5) 25,8 (4) 24,2 (242)
54 : 55. HOCOBOii Ylm3aTeJIb 47,1 (5) 52,3(5) 49,4 (5) 51,2 (3) 49,0(4) 49,4 (248)
72. OUll\nii yrOJI JlII a 86,3 (4) 81,0(5) 48,9(5) 44,2 (3) 52.3 (4) 49,1 (237)
74. YrGJI aJILBeOJIHpHOM 'laCTH JIH a 86,0(3) 86,6(5) 86,0 (3) 81,7 (3) 84,7(3) 83,9 (189)
75(1). YroJI HOCOBbIX RocTen K JInHHH npOwnJIH 22,0(4) 24,8(5) 83,7 (3) 71,7 (3) 72,3 (3) 77,3(170)
77. Ha30MaJIHpHbIM ymJI 144,2(4) 141,0 (6) 27,0(3) 30,7 (4) 35,0(4) 26,3 (185)
Lzm'. 3urGMaKCUJIJIHpHblii yrOJI 130,8 (4) 130,0(5) 137,5 (5) 137,0(3) 142,3 (4) 140,5(216)
DS. AaKpnaJILHaH BblCOTa 11,3 (2) 11,2 (5) 124,8(4) 128,2 (4) 127,0(4) 128,2 (207)
DS : DC. Am'ImaJIbIIbIn Ylm3aTeJIb 51,6 (2) 53,7 (5) 8,0(3) 12,6 (3) 13,7 (4) 11,2 (196)
SC. CUMOTU'leClmH BbICOTa 3,8(4) 4,2 (5) 36,7 (3) 55,3 (3) 64,9(4) 55,1 (195)
SS : SC. CUMOTU'leCKnM yI{a3aTeJIb 52,0(4) 48,0(5) 3,2(4) 3,6 (3) 5,7 (4) 3,9 (226)
31,9 (4) 42,0(3) 52,1 (4) 46,9 (226)
* MHII,eRC CpeIl,HI1X.
--
Ta6JIm a 5
PaaMax UaMeH'IUBOCTU npuaHaROB. MymcKue 'Iepena
1. ITpO,IJ;OJIbIIbIR gIIaMeTp 178,2-194.,5 9,1 267,2
8. ITonepeqHbIll guaMeTp 132,9-150,4 13,2 350,0
17. BbICOTllbIII gIIaMeTp OT 6aaIIoHa 130,0-143,7 10,5 279,6
8: 1. qepenHoR y!{aaaTeJIb 68,9-81,3 18,0 387,5
3_ 147,5-159,6
}'1.8.17. LlepellHoR MOgYJIb 15,0 398,0
9. HaIIMeIIbiliaH IIIIIpIIHa JI6a 91,5-101,4 10,8 225,0
32. YroJI JI6a 78,0-85,2 9,2 194,6
5. AJIIIHa OCHOBaHIIH 'Iepella 100,4-109,0 8,6 209,8
40. AJIIfHa ocnOBaHIIH JIUn;a 95,2-101,7 6,8 132.,7
40: 5. YKaaaTeJIb BblcTynaHIIH JIIIn;a 92,7-97,1 4,7 110,0
45. CKYJIOBaH IIIIIpIIHa 126,5-146.8 16,0 398,0
45: 8. I'OPUaOHTaJIbHbrn ilJan;IIon;epe6paJIb- 94,6-98,7 4,3 107,9
HbIll YKaaaTeJIb 69,7-79,2
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa JIIIn;a 13,6 231,7
48: 17. BepnmaJIbHbIR ilJan;IIon;epe6paJIbHbIR 50,9-58,8 15,5 239,4
YI{aaaTeJIb
48:45. BepxHIIll JIIIn;eBOll YKaaaTCHL 51,4-59,1 15,0 244,4
I }' 45.48. JIIIn;eBoR MOgYJIb 94,9-107,8 13,6 300,0
51. illupuHa Op6IITbI OT mf (JIeB.) 40,7-45,6 12,0 272,2
52. BblcoTa Op6IITbI (JIeB.) 32,5-36,4 12,0 205,3
52 : 51. Op6IITHbIll yRaaaTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 73,4-83,3 13,5 198,0
54. illIIpIIHa Hoca 23,9-27,2 13,8 183,3
55. BbIcoTa Hoca 50,0-56,8 13,6 234,5
54:55. HOCOBOH YKaaaTeJIL 43,9-50,1 14,1 151,2
72. 06ru;IIii yroJI JIIIn;a 84,0-88,3 5,1 148,3
74. YroJI aJILBeOJIHpHOH qaCTU JIIIn;a 68,0-83,5 22,8 254,1
75(1). YroJI HOCOBbIX KocTeR K JIIIHIIII npo- 24,8-35,6 43,5 234,8
ilJIIJIH
77. HaaOMaJIHpHbIll yroJI 135,4-146,7 8,3 256.8
Lzm'. 3IIroMaKCIIJIJIHpHbIll yroJI 124,0-137,0 10,5 240,7
DS. AanpIIaJILHaH BbICOTa 11,5-14,7 27,8 213,3
DS:DC. AaI{PIIaJILHLrn YKaaaTeJIL 55,4-70,7 27,6 187,7
SC. CIIMOTIIqeCKaH BbICOTa 3,8-6,1 60.5 255,6
SS: SC. CII1\IOTIIqeCKrrll yRaaaTeJIL 48,0-64.,3 34,0 139,3
max-min max-min
IIpl1aHaR min-max min , % Sat ,%
p;aRpllaJIbHbIX BbICOT II YRasaTeJIeM, a TaRme P;JlH yrJla BbIcTynaHIIH HOCO-
B:bIX ROCTeM, T. e. lIJIJI npII3HaROB C MaJIOM a6COJllOTHOM BeJIII1JIIHOJI.
q T06:bI IIs6aBllTbcH OT B:IllJIHllH a6COJllOTHbIX pasMepoB, aMIIJIJilTyp;a ROJle-
6aIIlliI BhIpameHa B npoll,eHTax cTaHp;apTHoro RBap;paTH'IeCRoro OTRJIOHeHIIJI.
qTO 6:bI mI IIllCaJlOCb 0 HenpaBOMepHocTII BbIpameHllJI MemrpynnoBoM llSMeH-
'IllBOCTII 'Iepes BeJIll'IllHY BHYTpIIrpynnoBoro RBa,L\paTll'IeCROrO OTHJIOHeHIIH,
BosMomHo, OHO OCTaeTCJI 60Jlee eMRllM MacrnTa60M P;JlH JlORaJlbHOM Memrpyn-
nOBoII llSMeH'IllBOCTII, 'IeM npocTO 06m;eMllpoBoM pasMax Bapllall,llM. CTaH-
p;a pTILbIe BeJIII'IllHbI RBap;paTll1JeCRIIX OTRJIOHeHIIIT BSJITbI lIS Ta6JIllll, f. $. ,l];e-
220
Ta6JIuqa 6
Pa3Max U3MeH'lUBOCTU DpU3HaROB. JKeHcRue 'lepena
It
max-min max-min
IIpl1aHaR min-max min ,% Sat , %
1. IIpO,[lOJIbHbIM ,[IuaMeTp 176,2-182,5 3,6 108,6
8. IIonepe'lHbIll ,[IIIaMeTp 129,8-140,8 8,5 229,2
17. BbICOTHbIM ,[IIIaMeTp OT 6asuoHa 126,3-135,2 7,0 189,4
8:1. qepenHoM ynaaaTeJIb 72,9-78,6 7,8 178,1
3_
Vl.8.17. qepenHoM MOAYJIb 143,6-149,7 4,,2 158,4
9. HaIIMeHbIlIaH illupUHa JI6a 92,6-97,6 5,4 116,3
32. YroJI JI6a 77,3-87,4 13,1 273,0
5. AJIIIHa OCHOBaHIIH 'lepena 94,2-100,3 6,5 156,4
40. AJIIIHa OCHOBaHUH JIUn;a 89,7-100,0 11,5 219,1
40 :5. YRaaaTeJIb BbIcTynaHuH JIuqa 93,8-101,3 8,0 187,5
45. CI{YJIOBaH illIIpHHa 122,2-133,8 9,5 241,7
45: 8. I'opIIaOliTaJIbHbIM cpaquon;epe6paJIb- 88,4-96,6 9,3 215,8
HbIM YI{aaaTeJIb
48. BepxHHH BbICOTa JIuqa 66,3-72,4 9,2 160,5
48 : 17. BepTIII{aJIbHbIll cpan;IIoqepe6paJIbHbIll 50,8-57,0 12,2 187,9
YRaaa TeJIb
48: 45. BepxHIIM JIIIqeBoM YKaaaTeJIb 52,1-58,9 13,1 215,9
V 45.48. JIIIn;eBoM MOAYJIb 90,8-97,2 7,0 187"1
51. IIIIIpIIHa Op6IITbI OT mf (JIeB.) 38,6-43,0 11,4 258,8
52. BblcoTa Op6IITbI (JIeB.) 32,2-35,0 8,7 147,4
52: 51. Op6HTHbIR YRaaaTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 77,8-87,0 11,8 184.,0
54. IIIHpIIHa Hoca 22,6-26,4 16,8 223,5
55. BbIcoTa Hoca 48,5-54,0 11.3 203,7
54: 55. HOCOBOM YKaaaTeJIb 44,2,-52,3 18,3 197,6
72. 06IIWR yroJI JIIIqa 81,0-86,3 6,5 182,8
74. YroJI aJIbBeOJIHpHOll 'laCTII JIIIqa 66,6-86,0 29,1 318,0
75(1). YroJI HOCOBbIX ROC Tell R JIIIHIIII npo- 22,0-35,0 59,1 282,6
(fJIIJIH
77. HaaOMOJIHpHbIll yroJI 135,7-144,2 6,3 193,2
Lzm'. 3IIrOMaRCIIJIJIHPHbIR yroJI 124,6-130,8 5,0 114,8
DS. Aar{pIIaJIbHaH BbICOTa 8,0-13,7 71,3 438,5
DS:DC. AaRpIIaJIbHbIR YRaaaTeJIb 36,7-64,9 76,8 333,7
SC. CIIMOTII"'IeCRaH BbICOTa 3,2-5,7 78,1 357,1
SS: SC. CIIMOTH'leCRUM YRaaaTeJIb 31,9-52,1 63,3 172,6
II
III
6ell,a 70. MCRJIlO1JeHIIe COCTaBJIJIlOT 06a MOP,YJIJI - lJepeIIHOII JiI JIIIll,eBOII, ,L\JIJI
xapaRTepIICTIIRll BHYTpIIrpYIInoBoM IISMeHlJIIBOCTII ROTOpbIX B JIIITepaType
HeT ,L\anH:bIX. 3a CTaH)J,apTHbIe BeJIll1JllH:bI npllHJIT:bI B p,aHHOM CJIY1Jae BeJIll1JJ'{-
HhI KBap,paTll1JeCHllX OTHJIOHeHIIM aTIIX npIISHaROB B cepIIH BOCT01JHOJIaThIIII-
CRIIX lJepenOB XVIII B. lls-nO,L\ JIyp,SbI, npoIIcXO)J,JIm;IIX JilS op;Horo RJIa,L\6IIID;a.
KBap;paTII1JeCROe OTRJIOHeHlle lJepenHOro MO)J,YJIJI p,JIJI MymcHIIx lJepeIIOB
(43 Ha6JIlO,L\eHIIJI) paBHO 3,04, P;JIJI J-!{eHCRllX - 3,85, RBa)J,paTII1J:eCROe OTRJIO-
HeHIIe JIIIll,eBoro MOP;YJIJI p,:w MymcHllx lJepenOB - 4,30, P;JIJI meHCRIIX - 3,42.
PaccMaTpIIBaJI nOCJIeiJ.HIIM cToJI6ell, Ta6JI. 5, MbI BJilp;IlM, lJTO P;JIJI nJITH
221
,
npIISHaROB MemrpynnOBbIe BapIIall,IIII npeBbIrnalOT TPII CTaH)J,apTa IIJlII paBH:bI
eMY: lJepenHOro MOP;YJIJI II CRYJIOBOM rnupllHbI (paBHaJI, OTHOCllTeJlbHaJI aM-
nJIIITyp;a), lJepenHOro YHasaTeJIJI, nOnepelJHOrO p;IlaMeTpa lJepenHOM Rop06RH,
JIllll,eBoro MOp,yJIJI. C:Iep,ylOm;lle nJITb npIISHaROB B nOpJI)J,Re YMeHbrneHIIJI
MemrpynnoBoM aMnJIllTYP;bI Bapllall,IIM: BbICOTHbIM p;naMeTp lJepeIIHOM Hop06-
Hll, rnIIpIIHa Op6IITbI 0'1' MaHCllJIJlO<PPOHTaJIe, npOP;OJIbHbIM p;IIRMeTp lJepeIIHOM
Rop06RII, CIIMOTIIlJeCRaJI BbICOTa, yrOJI aJIbBeOJIJIpHOM lJaCTII JIllll,eBoro CReJIe-
Ta. IIo OTHorneHlllO H nOCJIe)J,HeMy IIpIISHaRy HeJIbSH sa6bIBaTb 0 CJIOmHOCTII
ero IISMepeHIIJI II 0 BOSMomHOM HecpaBHIIMOCTII IISMepeHIIM paSHbIX aBTopOB,
IICRYCCTBeHHO YBeJlIIlJllBalOm;eM MemrpYIIIIOBYlO aMrr:IIITYp,y ero BapIIall,llM.
B 06Ill,eM HaII60Jlee IISMeHlJIIBbIMII B MemrpYIIIIOBOM MacrnTa6e OHaSbIBalOTCJI
06m;lle paSMephI 1JepeIIHOM Rop06HII JiI JIllll,eBOrO CHeJIeTa. RapTIIHa 3Ta He
nOBTOpJIeTCH, R COmaJIeHIIlO, B paCIIpep;eJIeHIIII aMnJlIITY)J, MemrpYIInOBbIX HO-
JIe6aHIIM OTp;eJlbHbIX npllSHaROB B meHCRllX CepllJIX. IIoCJlep;HIIM cToJl6ell,
Ta6J1. 4 )J,eMoHcTpIIpyeT, lJTO rpynrry llS IIHTll HaII60JIee llSMeHlJllBbIX npllSHa-
HOB COCTaBJlJIlOT IIpIISHaHll, xa paRTepIISYIOm;lle Bapllall,IIll HOCOBOM 06.TIaCTll,-
p;aRpIIaJlbHbIe BbICOTa II YRasaTe:Ib, CIIMOTII1JeCRllM YHasaTeJIb II yroJl BbICTY-
IIaHIIH HOCOBbIX ROCTeM. R HIIM IIpII6aBJIJIeTCJI yrOJI aJIbBeOJlJIpHOM lJaCTII
JIIIll,a, HO MbI yme YIIOMllHaJIII 0 BOSMomHOCTll XOTJI 6bI lJaCTIIlJHO IICRYCCTBeH-
HO saBbIrneHHOM I1SMeH1JIIBOCTII ero Bapllall,llM. JIllrnb B CJle)J,YlOIll,YlO rpYIIrry
lIS IIJITII IIpIISHaHOB IIOIIa)J,alOT p;Ba 06Ill,IIX paSMepa lJeperra II JlIIll,a-rrone-
pe1JHbIM JJ:llaMeTp lJepenHOM Rop06RII II CHYJlOBaJI rnllpIIHa. 06HapymIIBaeTCJI,
CJle)J,OBaTeJlbHO, paSRbIM paSMax HSMeHlJllBOCTII B O)J,HIIX II Tex me IIpllSHaRax
Ha MymcHIIx II meHCHIIX lJepenax.
CBoe06paSIIe paCIIpe)J,e:IeHIIH paSMaxa IISMeH1J:UBOCTII HeJIbSH TpaHTOBaT:b
I1Ha1Je, KaK BbIpameHlle Mop<poreHeTIIlJeCRIIX saROHOMepHOCTeM, JIemam;I1X B
ocrrOBe IIO:IOBOrO )J,IIMOp<pIISxIa. 06hI1JHO IIPII BCJIRllX cpaBRIITe:IbHbIX corro-
CTaB.TIeHllJIX CTaJIO Tpa)J,llll,llOHHbIM IIpeHe6peraTb meHCHllMll cepIIHMII II onll-
paTbCJI TOJIbRO Ha MymcHIIe BbI60pRII. O)J,HaHO, B npllHll,IIIIe 3Ta Tpap;llll,llJI
HII1JeM He OIIpaBp;aHa, RpOMe CTpeMJIeHIIH R 06JIer1JeHIIlO aHaJIIIsa. O)J,HOBpe-
MeHRO, rrpaB)J:a, )J,OCTllraeTCH II ero HerrOJlROTa. II03TOl\i}' MbI B )J,a:IbHeIIrneM
6Y,L\eM paCCMaTpllBaTb Bapllall,lIll II B MymcHIIx II B meHCRllX CepllJIX, CTa-
paHCb npII KOHKpeTHbIX pacoreHeTHlJeCRIIX BbIBO)J,ax He OT,L\aBaTh IIpe)J,rr01JTe-
HIIH HII TeM, Hll ,L\pyrllM.
PaSMax IISMeHlJllBOCTII IIPII BceM CBoeM BamHOCTII He)J,OCTaTOlJeH caM no
ce6e )J,:IH xapaRTepIICTllKU MemrpYIInoBoM I1SMeHlJllBOCTII npllSHaHOB.
B npIIH IIIIe MORmo npep:CTaBIITb ce6e XOTJI TaKaH cJilTyall,IIJI n HelJaCTO
pea.TIIIsyeTCJI Ha IIpaRTllHe, 1JTO IIpIISHaR BapbIIpyeT 60JIee IIJIII MeHee MOHO-
TOHHO II JlIIrnb B O)J,HOM llJIll )J,BYX rpyrrrrax IIMeeT peSRO OTJllllJalOIll,lleCJI SHa-
lJeHllH, 1JTO 06YCJIOBJIllBaeT SHa1JllTeJlbHbIM paSMax IISMeHlJIIBOCTII. He MeHee
BamHbI II03TOMY IIpaBll:IbHOCTII B caMOM reorpa<pll1JeCHOM paCIIpe,L\eJleHIIII
npIISHaHOB, KOTopbIe BbIJIBJlJIlOTCJI HapToM. PaccMoTpllM CHalJaJla reorpa<p II -
lJeCRlle BapIIall,llll Tpex Hall60Jlee II3MeHlJIIBbIX IIpIISHaROB B MymcHllx ce-
pIIJIX - lJepeIIHOro MO)J,YJIJI, CHYJIOBOM nmpJilHhI II lJepeIIHOro YRasaTeJIJI. qTO-
6bI COS)J,aTb e)J,llHo06pasHYlO OCHOBY P;JIJI RapT, MemrpynnoBaH aMnJIJilTYP;a
YC.TIOBRO rrOp;eJIeHa BO Bcex CepllJIX Ha IIJITb IIHTepBaJlOB.
Ha RapTe lJepeIIHOro MO)J,YJIH P;JlH MymcRllx lJepeIIOB (pIle. 13) BII)J,Ha HOH-
ll,eHTpall,UJI O)J,HOpOJJ:HbIX Bapllall,llM B IIplllJepHoMop:be, XOTJI RaR pas p;Be co-
ce)J,HIIe cepIIII - lIS RYTa II HllHOnOJIJI - paSJlll1JalOTCH Ha )J,Ba RJIaCCOBbIx
I1HTepBaJla. BOJlee saMeTHa p;IIcnepCIIH IIpIIsHaRa B Cpep;HeM ASIIll, Ha <p OHe
HOTOpOM 06pam;aeT Ha ce6JI BHIIMaHlle CXOP;CTBO IIaMIIpCRIIX cepIIM. AHaJlO-
rII1JHaH )J:IIcnepCIIJI xapaRTepHa II )J,JIH BOCTOlJHhIX paMOHOB paCCMaTpIIBaeMOM
TeppIITopIIII. Op;HaHO B Cpe)J,HeM ASllII OHa, nO-Bllp;IIMOMy, Bce me Cll:IbHee:
222
PHC. 13. I'eorpaq,H'IeCKaH H3MeH'IHBOCTb 'IepenHOro MO;a;YJIH. MymCI He 'Iepena
1 - 147,5-149,9; 2 - 150,0-152,4; 3 - 152,5-154,9; 4 - 155,0-157,4; 5 - 157,5,,-159,9
II
PUC. 14. I'eorpaq,U'IeCI aH H3MeH'IIIBOCTb CI{YJIOBOU: lliIIpHHbI. MymcKHe 'Iepena
1 - 126,5-130,5 MM; 2 - 130,6-134,6 MM; 3 - 134,7-138,7 MM; 4 - 138,8-142,8 MM; 5 - 142,9-
146,9 MM
cepllll lIS 6acceMHa Cblp)J,apbII OTJIII'IalOTCH O,L\Ha OT p;pyroM Ha TPII RJIaCCOBbIX
IIHTepBaJIa.
Ha CJIe)J,YlOIll,eM KapTe CRyJIOBOM rnnpIIHbI B MymCRllX cepllHX (pIIC. 14)
MbI CTaJIRllBaeMCJI C TOM me MOHOTOHHOM RapTIIHOM Bapllall,IIM B IIpII'IepHO-
Mopbe, r)J,e Bce cepIIII, sa IICHJIlO'IeHIIeM OP;HOM, IIona)J,alOT B O)J,IIH KJIaCCOBhIM
JilHTepBaJI. IIO'ITll O,L\llHaHoBbI IIO CHYJIOBOM rnIIpIIHe II IIaMIIpcRIIe cepIIII.
B ceBepHbIx paMOHax Cpe)J,HeM ASllII U Ha TeppIITopllII AJITaJI II XaHacllII
pasHIIll,a Memp;y CepIIJIMII p;ocTIIraeT )J,BYX RJIaCCOBbIX IIHTepBaJIOB. TaRllM
06pasOM, IIOBTOpJIeTCH p;o IIsBeCTHoM CTeneHII TO me reorpa<pII'IeCRoe pacnpe-
p;eJIeHlIe, 'ITO H IIO 'IeperrHOMY MO)J,YJIlO.
1:lepenHoM YRasaTeJIb, HaR npaBIIJIO, ,L\OBOJIbHO 3Ha'IUTeJIbHO Bap:bJilpyeT B
coce)J,HIIX nonYJIHll,llJIX. B ,L\aHHOM CJIy'iae npII'IepHOMOpCRIIe rpynnhI OnJITb
223
PHC. 15. reOrpaWH'leCRaH HaMen'lHBOCTl> 'lepemroro YI\aaaTeJIH. MymcRne 'lepena
1 - 68,9-71,3; 2 - 71,4-73,8; 3 - 73,9-76,3; 4 - 76,4-78,8; 5 - 78,9-81,3
Ii
PHC. 16. I'eorpawn'leCRaH HMen'lHBOCTl> 'lepemroro MOP;YJIH. JlI:eHcRHe 'leperra
1- 143,6-144,8; 2 - 144,9-146,1; 3 - 146,2-147,4; 4 - 147,5-148,7; 5 - 148,8-150,0
o)J,nopop:H:bI ('I'. e. OTHOCJITCH H O)J:HOMY II TOMY me RJI3.CCOBOMy IIHTepBaJIY,
sa llCHJIlO'IeHlleM O)J,HOII). O)J,HOPO)J,RbI II )J,Be na:MIIpCRlle RbI60pRII (pIIC. 15).
OrrJITb Ha ceBepe Cpe,'J:Heii ASIIll U B IOmHoM Cll6llPII paSJIII1JllH 60.TIbrne 1I
p,ocTIIralOT )J,BYX RJIaCCOBhIX IIHTepBaJIOB. COIIOCTaBJIJIJI Tpll paccMoTpeHHbIe
RapTbI, IIO-Bll)J:llMOMY, MomHO c)J,eJIaTb BbIBOP;, 'ITO CHII<pCRoe HaCeJIeHlle IIpII-
'IepnOMOpbJI II caRCHoe HaCeJIeHIIe IIaMllpa xapaRTepllSOBaJIllCb onpe)J,eJIeH-
HbIM l\wp<p0JIOrll1JeCRllM e)J,llHcTBOM B Ramp;oM oT)J,eJIbHOM cJIY'Iae, Torp;a HaI{
B )J,Pyrux paMOHax IIMeJIa MeCTO llSBeCTHaJI reTeporeHHocTb.
B RaHoM-To Mepe 3TO Ha6:I1O)J,eHIIe MomHO IIO,L\TBepp;IITb paCCMOTpeHIIeM
RapT reorpa<pII'IeCROrO paCIIpe)J,eJIeHllJI Tex me npIISHaROB B meHCRUX cepll-
JIx. OHII, RaR BII)J,HO lIS Ta6J1. 4, B pH;:J;e CJIY'IaeB )J,OCTaTO'IHO MaJlO'IIICJleHHbI,
II rr03TOMY pOJlb CJIY1JaMHbIX Bapllall,IIII S)J,eCb B ll,eJIOM, HOIIe'IHO, 60JIbrne.
HeJlbSJI, RaR YHaSbIBaJlOCb BbIrne, omII)J,aTb II CHOJIbRO-Hll6YP;b IIOJIHOro co-
224
<:;';;'7f
/
/,.."..,.,.'
l..
.0.0 J
01
()4
02
.5
<DB
PRC. 17. I'eorpaqH1:'IeCRaH R3MeH'IMBOCTb CI{YJIOBOi!: IllMPMHI.I. JlI:errcRMe 'Ieperra
1- 122,2-12q,5 MM; 2 - 12q,6-126,9 MM; 8 -127,0-129,3 MM; 4 -129A-131,7 MM; 5 - 131,8-
134,1 MM
.:c.
'>.
/.......A...j...-Jo'
."...
.
j"""
<5'f
."...
/,.>v.''''''
l,.
.0.01
,,-".
01
()4
02
.5
<DB
Pnc. 18. feOrpaWH'IeCRaH M3MeH'IMBOCTb 'IepeIIHOro YKa3aTeJIH. JlI:encRHc 'leperra
1- 72,9--7Q.0; 2 - 7q,1-75,2; 3 - 75,3-76,Q; 4 -76,5-77,6; 5 - 77,7-78,8
BIIa;:J:eIIIIH BapIIall,uii IIO 060llM nOJIaM. Bce lIW Ha RapTax reorpa<plllJeCHIIX
Bapnall,IIII 1JepeIIHOro MOP;YJIJI (pIIC. 16), CHYJIOBOM rnllpIIHbI (pllC. 17) II lJe-
penHoro YRasaTe.Tm (pIIC. 18) B meHCRIIX rpYIIIIax BII)J,HO, lJTO naMIIpCRIIe
cepnn JIII60 nOJIIIOCTbIO O,L\HOpO)J,HbI B MacrnTa6e BhI6paHIIoM Oll,eHRII rpyn-
IIOBOII )J,II<p<pepeHll,IIall,IIu (O)J,llH II TOT me RJIaCCOB:bIM llHTepBaJI), JIII60 pas-
JIII1JalOTCJI HeSHa1JIITeJIbHO (coce)J,HIIe RJIaCcbI); IIO )J,BYM npllSHaRaM (lJepen-
HOMY MO)J,YJIlO II CRYJIOBOII rnIIpJilHe) us Tpex 6JIIISHII Mem)J,Y C060M MHorIIe
rpynn:bI II pIIlJepHOMOpbJI; HaROHell" no BceM TpeM IIpllSHaRaM npaHTlllJeCRII
Tom)J,eCTBeHH:bI cepIIII us 6acceMHa C:bIpp;apbII. IIpII OTCYTCTBIIII p;aHHhIX 0
meHCRllX CepllJIX C TeppllTopIIll A,TITaJI HeT BOSMomHOCTII nOJIHOCTblO oll,e-
HUTb xapaHTep rpynIIoBoM )J,ll<p<pepeHll,IIall,llll B IOmHoM CU6IIpII II BOCTOlJHOM
RasaxcTaHe, HO BII)J,HO, lJTO CepllJI TarapcHoM HYJIbTYPbI II lJepeml lIS MOrIIJIb-
HllHa Ycn-BYRoHb OTJIIIlJalOTCJI APyr OT p;pyra no P;BYM npIISHaRaM (CHYJIO-
8 B. II. AJIeRCeeB
.225
J
\--'\1\ '\ .f '(, I)
/) (
- f '
_--==c \ 'o'1 rJ
' .. t? ' q '" Y pa ..
... 'Yo
tJ
r. .....
, /"
B""
-- .......
"">-
\"
01
1)4
02
.5
(1)3
Puc. 19. I'eorpaqHZI'leCKaH 1ZI3MeH'lIZIBOCTL lIaKplZIaJILHOH BLICOThI. 7ReHcKlle 'leperra
1 - 8-9,1 MM; 2 - 9,2--10,3 MM; 3 - 10,q-11,5 MM; 4 - 11,6 12,7 MM; 5 - 12,8-13,9 MM
Puc. 20. I'eorpacplZI'leCKaH 1ZI3MeH'lIZIBOCTL CIZIMOTU'leCKOH BbICOTbI. 7ReHcKlZIe 'leperra
1- 3,2-3,7 MM; 2 - 3,8-q,3 MM; 3 - q,q-q,9 MM; 4 - 5,0-5,5 MM; 5 - 5,6-6,1 MM
BOM rnllpllHe II lJepenHOMY YRasaTeJIlO) Ha p;Ba RJIaCCOBhIX uHTepBaJla. HaJlll-
11,0, CJIe)J,oBaTeJIbHO, Bce me llsBecTHhIM, XOTJI II He OlJeHb lJeTRO BhlpameHHhIM
napaJIJleJIUSM B xapaKTepe reorpa<pUlJeCHUX Bapnall,llM paccuaTpUBaeMhIX
npUSHaHOB B MymcHllx n meHCHllX rpynnax.
B meHCRUX rpynnax Hall60JIee llSMeHlJUBbI p;aRpllaJII.HaJI BbICOTa, CllMO-
TlllJeCHaJI BhICOTa II )J,aHpllaJIbHhIM YRasaTeJlb, T. e. npuSHaHu, oTpamalOm;ue
BhlcTynaHne HOCOBhIX ROCTeM. OTHOCllTeJIbHO CllJIbHOe U cpe)J,Hee BbIcTynaHue
HOCOBhIX HOCTeM, BhlpamaeMoe )J,aRpllaJlbHOM BhICOTOM (pllC. 19), xapaRTepHO
P;JIH HaCeJIeHIIJI IIplllJepHoMopbH, 6acceMHa Chlp):(aphu II IIaMupa, Tor)J,a RaR
B IOmHoM CII6npu U Ha AMY)J,apbe )J,aRpllaJlbHaH BhlCOTa cpe)J,HJIH n MaJIaJI.
IIo CUMOTUlJeCHOM BhlCOTe (pllC. 20) Bce paCCMaTpllBaeMbIe HaMIl cepllll 0'1'-
JllllJalOTCH MaJIbIMn UJlll cpe)J,HUMll BeJlIIlJHHaMll (nOCJIe)J,IIlle IIpe06JIa)J,aIOT).
U TOJlI.RO B MOJI)J,aBUll II Ha IIaMIIpe MbI CTaJIRUBaeMCH C )J,BYMH cepllHMII.
226
=f
/.
/.,....,,.,..-
t,.
. {).e 1
"-,,.
01
{)4
02
e5
<D3
POCo 21. I'eorpaqnZIQeCKall lIaMeHQIZIBOCTb p;aKplZIaJIbHOrO YKaaaTeJIll. 7ReHcKlZIe Qeperra
1- 36,7-q2,3; 2 - q2,q-q8.0; :3 - q8,1-53,7; 4 - 53,8-59,q; 5 - 59,5-65,1
[""
<=,f
,..-.Y'"
/.>v.'
i.,.
.e.01
......
01
{)4
02
e5
<D3
PIIC. 22. I'eorpaq)JZIQeCKall lZIaMeH'lI'IBOCTb p;aKplZIaJIbHOH BhICOTbI. MymcKlZIe Qeperra
1 - 11,5-12,1 MM; 2 - 12,2-12,8 M. ; :3 - 12,9-13,5 MM; 4 - 13,6-1q.2 MM; 5 -1q,3-1q,9 MM
OTJlll1JalOm;llMllCH O)J,Ha HeHOTOpbIM. BTOpaJI SHa1JUTeJIbHhIM YBeJIU'IeHUeM Cll-
MOTU'IeCHOM BhICOThI. A BeJIll'IUHhI ,L\aHpUaJIbRoro YHa3a TeJlH (pllC. 21) )J,u<p-
<pepeHll,llpylOT Bce rpyrrnhI Rarro)J,06IIe Toro, HaH ORll )J,ll<p<pepeHll,llpYlOTCJI C
rrOMOm;blO Bapllall,UM )J,aHpllaJIhROM BbICOThI. 8'1'0 OSRa1JaeT, 'ITO B IIpu'IepRo-
Mopbe, 6acceMRe CbIpp;apbu U Ra IIaMllpe CRORll,eHTpupOBaRhI 60JlbrnUe n
cpe)J,Hue BeJlll'IllHhI, Ra AMY)J,apbe )J,aHpUaJlbHhIM YRa3aTeJIb MaJIhIM, B Boc-
TO'IHOM RasaxcTaHe - cpe)J,HllM. OTJIU'IUe HapThI )J,aHpllaJlbHOM BbICOThI OT
HapThI )J,aHpllaJlbROrO YHasaTeJlJI B 06JIaCTHX lOiKRoM Cu6upu COCTOHT TOJlbHO
B TOM, 1JTO p;aHpllaJIbRbIM YHa3aTeJlb CBll)J,eTeJlbCTByeT 0 SRa'IUTeJIbHOM BbI-
cTynaHllll HOCOBhIX ROCTeM y TarapCHoro HaCeJleRllJI, Torp;a HaH p;aRpllaJlbHaH
BhICOTa B 3TOM CJIY1Jae cpe)J,HJIH.
Tpu TOJIhHO 'ITO paCCMOTpeRRhle Ha pTbI YMeCTRO conOCTaBllTh C aHaJIO-
rll1JRhIMll RapTaMU reorpa<pU'IeCHUX BapUall,UM Tex me IIpUSHaROB B MymcRHX
227
8*
PIiIC. 23. I'eorpa«fJliI'leCRaH 1iI3MeHqHBOCTb CIiIMOTIiIQeCROH BbICOTbI. MymcRHe Qeperra
1 - 3,8-q,2 MM; 2 - q,3-q,7 MM; 3 - q,8-5,2 MM; 4 - 5,3-5,7 MM; 5 - 5,8-6,2 MM
PIiIC. 24. I'eorpa«fJIiIQeCRaH 1iI3MeHQliIBOCTb lIaRpliIaJIbHOrO YRa3aTeJIH. MymcRliIe Qeperra
1- 55,q-58A; 2 - 58,5-61,5; 8 - 61,6-6q,6; 4 - 6Q,7-67,7; 5 - 67,8-71,8
cepllHX. JIoRaJlbRaH MOSa:J2[lJROCTb 6pOCaeTCJI B rJIaSa Ra HapTe p;aRpIIaJlbHOH
BhICOThI (pnc. 22): B npU1JepnOMOpCRllX rpynnax ORa II MaJlaH, II )J,OBOJIbRO
60JIbrnaH, rpynnhI us 6accelIHa Chlp)J,apbll U C ITaMupa OTJlnlJalOTCH ;:J;pyr OT
):(pyra II 3)J,eCb II TaM Ra Tpll RJlaCCOBbIX URTepBaJla, 06m;aH JlORaJlbRaJI P;IIC-
nepCIIJI Ra 3ana)J,e, CJle)J,OBaTeJIbHO, He MeHbrne, 1J:eM Ha BOCTORe, CRopee ):(ame
HeCHOJIbRO 60Jlbrne, TaH RaH paSJlIIlJllJI MeiK)J,Y IepenaMll TarapcRoM HYJIhTypbI
U llS MOrllJlbHRa YCTb-BYROHb )J,ocTnralOT Bcero ):(BYX HJIaCCOBhIX llRTepBaJIOB.
Ha RapTe CllMOTUlJeCROM BbICOTbI (pllC. 23) MaJIhIe BeJIll1JllHbI ROHll,eHTpIIpy-
lOTCH Ha sana)J,e II Ha BOCTOHe. BOJIbrnaH BblCOTa Ra sana)J,e xapaHTepHa )J,JIJI
O)J,HOM rpYIInhI, Ha BOCTOHe TaKHX BeJlIIlJllH Bo06ll\e HeT, II )J,aiKe cpe)J,RJIJI
BeJlII1JIIIIa CBOMCTBeRRa JIIIrnh lJepenaM ns MOrllJIbRUHa YCTb-BYHOHb. Te me
cpe)J,Rlle SHalJeRUJI npe06J1a)J,alOT B Cpe)J,ReM ASllll. B 06m;eM reorpa<plllJeCRIIe
BapIIall,llU B 3TOM cJIYlJae ):(OCTaT01JHO Reonpe)J,eJleHHhI. AaRpllaJlbHhIM yRasa-
228
Ta6JIuqa 7
CYMMapnan panroBan xapaRTepucTuRa cepuii. MymcRRe 'Iepena
naMHTHIiR
1JepeIlHofI
MOP,Y<Ib
CRy:rOBan
IIIl1pl1Ha
I 1J:epenHoH I BbIcTynaHue o-
YRaaaTeJIb COBblX ROC Ten
HIZIROJIaeBl,a 3,00 2,00 3,00 4,00
RYT 1,50 2,00 3,00 1,67
HIZIKOnOJIb 2,50 2,00 2,50 2,33
30JIOTaH EaJIRa 2,00 1,50 3,,50 3,00
HIZIROJIaeBRa - Ra3an:Roe 2,00 2,00 3,50 2,67
HeanOJIb CRIZI<pcmrii 2,50 2,00 3,00 2,17
3aBeTHoe 3,00 2,00 2,50 2,17
TarlZIcReH 2,00 3,50 4,50 2,00
YiirapaR 3,50 4,00 4,50 2,83
YCTb-BYROHb 2,00 4,50 5,00 2,67
TapbIM-RaH 4,00 2,00 2,00 1,33
IIaMlZIpcRaH I 1,50 1,00 1,00 3,50
AR6elZIT 2,00 1,50 1,00 3,67
TY9RT a II 1II1ZI6e 4,00 5,00 4,00 1,,67
Rypaii IZI YJIaHAPbIR 3,00 3,00 4,00 2,00
TarapcRaH RYJIbTypa 3,00 3,00 3,00 2,50
TeJIh (puc. 24) MaJlO )J,06aBJlJIeT R CRasaIIHOMY: rrpU'IepHOMOpCHue rpynnbI
OTJIII'IalOTCJI He60JII.rnUMU BeJlll'IllHaMU yRasaTe;m, HO B MOJl)J,aBIIu OH ):(OBOJlI.-
IIO 60JlhrnOM, BeJIUHU paSJIll'IllH Mem)J,y )J,BYMH naMIIpCHllMll rpynilaMll, Ha ce-
Bepe Cpe)J,HeM ASllH U B IOmHoM CII6upu rrpe06J1a)J,aIoT MaJlhle II cpe)J,HIIe
BeJlII1J:UHhI. TaRIIM 06pasoM, eCJlu Oll,eHHBaTb B ll,e.TIOM reorpa<pH1JecRYlO llS-
MeH1JllBOCTb npUSHaHOB, MaRCUMaJIhHO USMeH'IUBhIX B iKeHCHllX CepIIJIX, CJIe-
p;yeT CHasaTb, 'ITO OHa He 06HapymIIBaeT SHa'IUTeJlbHbIX npaBII'lbHOCTeM,
a MymcHIIe rpyrrilbI )J,ll<p<pepeHll,UPYIOTCH UHa'Ie, 1J:eM meHCHlle. lIToI', CJleD,O-
BaTeJlbHO, IIOJlY'IllJlCH ):(ame MeHee Brre1JaTJIJIlOm;UM, 'IeM npll paccMoTpeHuu
npUSHaHOB, MaRCllMaJlbHO ll3MeH1J:llBhIX B MymcHllx rpynnax.
q T06bI BBeCTll RaHOM-TO rrpocToM HOJIU'IeCTBeHHbIM HpllTepIIM B Oll,eHRY
pasHoHanpaBJIeHHhIX BapIIall,llM, npOU3Be;:J;eH nO)J,C1JeT paHrOB (cooTBeTcTBYlO-
m;IIX HJlaCCOBhIM llHTepBaJIaM 0'1' 1 ):(0 5) CYMMapHO no 060IIM nOJIRM U TO-
IIorp a <p ll1Je cHu 6JIll3HIIM IIpUSHaRaM (Ta6J1. 7). ITpaHTn1JeCHU pe'Ib II)J,eT 0
CYMMupOBaHUH paHrOB IIO )J,aHpUaJlbHOM BhICOTe, CaMOTU1JeCROM BhlCOTe U
)J,aHpllaJIbHoMY YHasaTeJllO, TaR RaR 1J:epeilHOM MO)J,YJlb caM HBJIHeTCJI reHepa-
JlIISOBaHHOM xapaHTepIICTllROM, a 'IepenHOM YRasaTeJlI. U CRYJIOBaJI rnIIpIIHa -
<PYHRll,IIOHaJlbHO caMOCTOJITeJIbHhIe xapaHTepIICTUKII RaR no OTHorneHUlO )J,Pyr
H p;pyry, TaH II no OTHorneHllIO H 'IepenHOMY MO)J,YJIKJ. CJlOBeCHhle OOOSHa'Ie-
HUJI paHrOB CJIe)J,YlOm;ue: 1 - MaJlOe llJlII cJla60e paSBIITue rrpIISHaHa; 2-
):(OBO,lII.HO MaJIOe, )J,OBOJII.HO cJla60e, YMepeHHoe; 3 - cpep;Hee; 4 - )J,OBOJII.HO
60JIbrnOe, )J,OBOJlbHO CllJlI.HOe, SHa'IUTeJlI.HOe; 5 - 60JIbrnOe UJlII CII:IbHoe.
ROMOllHllPYJI )J,aHHhIe Ta6JI. 5 C )J,aHHhIMU 0 reorpa<pU'IeCROM nOJIOmeHIIIi[
MOrllJlbHIIROB, MomHO HaMeTUTI. JlOHaJlbHbIe rpynnoBhle CO'IeTaHUJI npII3Ha-
ROB, ROTOphIe RaR 6Y)J,TO IIepeHphIBalOT pasHoHanpaBJIeHHYlO Cnell,ll<pllRY no-
.1I0BhIX pa3J1U'IllM. B ITpll'IepHO IOpbe HOHll,eHTpllpyeTCJI C01J:eTaHlle YMepeH-
HbIX IIJIU cpe)J,Hux pasMepoB "Ie penH OM Rop06Rll, )J,OBOJII.HO YSRoro JIIIll,eBoro
CHeJIeTa, cpe)J,Hero IepeilHOro YHasaTeJlH U cpe)J,Hero BhlcTynaHuH HOCOBhIX
HocTeM. ,l];Be cepuu BbI)J,eJlJIlOTCJI Ha <poHe 3TorO CO'IeTaHUJI JIORaJII.HOM cne-
229
ll,II<pIIHOII: CepllH llS RYTa, OTJlII1J:alOm;aJICH MUJlbIM BhlcTynaHueM HOCOBhIX
HOCTeM II CHOpee MaJlhIMII paSMepaMll lJepenHOM Hop06Rll, II CepllJI llS HllHO-
JlaeBRll, OTJIUlJalOm;aHCJI CHOpee )J,OBOJlbHO CllJIbHhIM BhlcTynaHlleM HOCOBbIX
HOCTeM. 3aMeTHO )J,pyroe COlJeTaUlle npllSHaHOB <pllHcllpyeTcH B 6aCCeMHe CbIp-
)J,apbll, B BOCTOlJHOM RaSaXCTaHe II Ha AJITae: pa3MephI lJepenHOM Rop06RII
BapbIIpYlOT 0'1' YMepeHHbIX )J,O SHa1J:llTeJIbHbIX, rnIIpUHa JlIIll,eBOrO CReJleTa
cpe)J,HJIJI IIJIU 60JlhrnaH, 1JepenHOM yHasaTeJIb SHalJIITeJlbHhIII IIJIII 60JlbrnOM,
BbIcTyrraHue HOCOBbIX HocTel1 )J,OBOJIbHO cJla60e UJlII cpep;Hee. TpeTbe C01JeTa-
HIIe npe)J,CTaBJleHO TOJlbHO O)J,HOM cepIIeM - U3 MOrllJlbHIIHa TapbIM-RaJI B
6acceMHe AMY)J,apbll. 8TO 1Jeperra C )J,OBOJIbHO 60JlbrnllMll pa3MepaMu 1JepeII-
HOM HOpOOHll, no )J,OBOJlbHO YSHUM Jlllll,eBhIM CHeJleTOM, YMepeHHoM BeJIII1III-
HOM lJeperrHOro yHasaTeJlJI II cJla60 BhlcTyrralOm;llMII HOCOBhIMU ROCTJIMII.
qeTBepToe COlJeTaHUe - 3'1'0 06e rraMIIpCRIIe cepIIU: CHopee MaJlhIe paSMepbI
lJepeIIa, ySHoe JlIIIJ.O, MaJIhIM lJeperrHOM YHa3aTeJIb, )J,OBOJILHO CllJIbHOe BhI-
CTyrraHlle HOCOBhIX HOCTeM. HaHOHell" )J,OCTaT01JHO HeMTpaJlbHO IIO OTHorneIIllIO
RO BceM )J,pyrllM CepIIJIM IIOJIOmeHUe lJepenOB TarapCHOM KYJlbTypbI, 06J1a)J,alO-
m;IIX cpe)J,HUMU nOHaSaTeJlJIMU no BceM rrpllSHaRaM.
MTaH, llTorOM ImpTorpa<pIIpOBaHUJI JIBJlJIeTCJI BhI)J,eJleHlle B COCTaBe CHll<pO-
caHCHoro HaCeJleHUJI rrJITU JIOHaJlbHbIX ROMnJleHCOB, xapaRTepUSYIOm;UXCJI
Mop<pOJIOrII1J:eCROM cnell,ll<puHoll II IIpllypOlJeIIIIhIX R onpe)J,eJleHHhIM apea-
JIaM,-rrplllJepHOMOpCHOI'O, aMY)J,apbIIHcHoro, naMupcRoro, HasaXCTaHCHO-aJI-
TaMcHoro II eHuceMcHoro.
PACOI'EHETllqECROEIICTOJIROBAHIIE
nepexo)J,JI 0'1' <peHoTIInlllJeCHOM xapaHTepllcTllRII U JIOHaJlbHOM IIpIIypOlJeHHO-
CTU BbI)J,eJIeHHhIX ROMIIJleHCOB H IIX reHeTII1JeCROM llHTeprrpeTaIJ.IIII, MhI, eCTe-
CTBeIIHO, )J,OJImHhI BbIMTU 3a paMluI paccMaTpIIBaeMoro MaTepUaJIa II BOCIIOJlb-
30BaTbCJI BCeN! HaHOnJIeHHhIM OrrhITOM HaH B II3YlJeHUU aHTpOnOJlOrII1JeCHOrO
COCTaBa )J,peBHero naCeJleUIIJI CCCP, TaH U B paspa60THe 06m;llX TeOpeTIIlJe-
CHllX BonpocoB pacoBe)J,eHllJI, B nepBYlO OlJepe):(b BonpocoB pacoBoM RJIaCCII-
<pIIH811,UII II nOJIOiKeHHbIX B ee OCHOBY reHeTlllJeCHIIX npllHll,llnoB. TaHIIM 06-
paSO!\I, MhI He CTaBllM nepe):( C060M sa)J,alJY npOaHaJIII3llpOBaTb naJleOaHTpo-
rrOJIOrII IeCHUM MaTepllaJl, oxapaHTepllsoBaHHhIM BhIrne, a XOTIIM rrpUJlOmIITb
H 3TOMY MaTepIIaJIY pJI)J, 06m;llX rrpUHll,llrrOB II rrOJIOmeHllM, BhITeHalOm;IIX llS
npe)J,rnecTBYlOm;IIX pacoreHeTIi1J:eCHUX runOTes. Op,HllM lIS TaHIIX npUIIll,u-
nnaJIbnbIX IITorOB npe)J,rnecTBYlOm;IIX uCCJle)J,oBaHIIM JIBJlHeTCH YCTaHOBJIeHlle
TllrrOJlOrII1JeCHOM pacoBoM HJlaCCll<pIIHall,UU, 3J1eMeHTapHhle e)J,llHllll,bI HOTO-
pOM - JlOHaJIbHhle pacoBhle BapuaHThI IIJlII JIORaJIbHbIe rpynnhI nonYJlHll,llM
npe)J,cTaBJIJIlOT COGOM HaCJIe)J,cTBeuHhlx HOCllTeJleM onpe)J,eJleHHbIX ROM6IIHa-
ll,UII pacoBhlx 1JepT.
npUlJepH01>WpCHIIM BapllaHT, HecoMHeHHo, Haxo)J,IIT ce6e MeCTO B COCTaBe
eBponeou)J,HoM pacbI. TaR II paCCMaTpUBaJIII 3'1'0'1' ROMnJIeHC nprrsnaHOB OIIII-
C8Brnlle IIpIIlJepHOMOpCHlle CepllJI UCCJle):(OBaTeJlII M. C. BemmaHOBa,
r. $. ,D;e6ell, II T. C. ROH)J,YHTopOBa. PeSHoe nOHumeHlle nepeHOCbH Ha 1J:e-
pellax IIS RYTa MomHO 6hIJIO 6hI paCCMaTpllBaTh HaH CBU)J,eTeJlbCTBO HaJIUlJUJI
B 3TOM cepIIU MOHrOJlOllp;HOM npUMeCII, HO HOCOBbIe ROCTll B ll,eJIOM BhlcTynalOT
CUJlhHO, He MeHbrne, lJeM B )J,pyrux cepllHX, lJTO )J,eMOHcTpllpyeTCJI yrJloM HO-
COBbIX ROCTeM H JIUHUII JlUll,eBoro npO<pIIJIJI. a JlIIll,eBOM CHeJleT CIIJIbHO npO<pll-
mlpOBaH. 06a npUSHaHa xapaHTepHhI ,L\JIH eBponeOll):(OB II COBeprneHHO He-
xapaHTepHhI )J,JIJI MOHrOJlOU)J,OB, n03TOMY II rOBopllTb 0 MOHrOJlOll):(HOM rrpII-
MeCII B cepIIII US RYTa HeT oCHoBaHIIM, a nOHllmeHlle IIepeHOCbJI CJle)J,yeT
paccMaTpuBaTL HaR JIOHaJIbHOe OTRJlOHeHue. Ha ClJeT JlOHaJlbHOl1 IISMeHlJll-
230
BOCTU HymHo OTlIeCTll, Bll,L\UMO, II yCllJIeRIIe BhlcTynaRllJI HOCOBbIX HOCTeM
B CepIIII llS HllROJlaeBHII. ITpe):(rneCTBYlOm;IIe llCCJIe)J,OBaHllJI BhIJIBIIJIII I1CRJllO-
'IUTe:IbHhIe TPY)J,HOCTU B p;II<p<pepeRll,Uall,llIl ceBepHbIX U lOmHhIX eBpOneOU,L\OB
Ra RpaIIIIOJlOrIl1JeCHOM MaTepllaJle n OTCYTCTBue TBep)J,hIX HpUTepIIeB )J,JlJI 0'1'-
HeceHIIH Tex UJIU IIHbIX HpaIIllOJIOrll1J:eCRllX cepUM H 6aJlTUMCROM IIJlll cpe)J,ll-
seMIIOJ\IOpCHOM BeTBll eBponeOII)J,OB H. II03TOMY ReT OCROBaHllM )J,uarROCTIIpO-
BaTb npU1JepROMOpCHUM BapllaHT B IIpe)J,eJIax 3TIIX )J,BYX BeTBeM, HO MomHO
OTMeTUTb BCJle)J, 3a nepelJllCJIeRRhIMII Bhlrne aBTopaMII ero 60JlbrnOe CXO)J,CTBO
C MOP<P0JlOrIl1JeCHUM TUrrOJ\1 npep;rneCTBYlOII(erO !IaCe:IeHllJI.
COBeprneHHO HeCOMHeHHa npIIRa)J,JlemHOCTb R eBpOIIeOII)J,ROM pace naMUp-
CHllX cepIlM. RpaMRHJI CTerreRb )J,OJIllXOHpaHIIII B C01JeTaHUII C OlJeRb YSHllM
:IIIll,eBhIJ\1 CHeJleTOM II OlJeHb CUJlbHOe BhlcTynaIIIIe ROCOBhIX HOCTelI C6JIIImalOT
na:\IIIpCHUM BapuaRT co MRorUMU CepUJIMH C TeppIITopIIII Cpe)J,RelI ASllll,
RaBHasa U rIepe)J,ReM ASIIll II )J,alOT BOSMomROCTb C llSBeCTHOM yC:IOBHOCThlO,
HORelJRO, HaR 06 3TOM TOJlbHO lJTO rOBOpUJlOCb, )J,llarHOCTIlpOBaTI. ero RaR
cpe)J,useMHoMopCRllM B COCTaBe eBponeOIl)J,OB. ITO-Bll)J,llMOMY, BHYTPI1 eBponeo-
H)J,HOM paChI HaXO):(IIT ce6e saHOHOMepHoe MecTO II TpeTIIM, aMyp;apbuRcRUM
BapuaHT. HeHoTopoe nORIImeRue BbIcTynaRllH ROCOBhIX ROCTeM no cpaBHeHIIlO
)J,ame C npll1J:epHOMopCHIIJ\III eBponeOll)J,aMII, YCTynalOm;IIMII B 3TOM OTIIorneHIIll
IIaMupCHUM, He conpOBom):(aeTCJI ynJlom;eRHOCTbIO Jlllll,eBoro CHeJIeTa, B BhIC-
rneM CTerreRll xapaHTepHOM )J,JIJI CII6IIpCHllX MOHrOJlOIIL(OB 72. O)J,HaHO 60Jlbrnlle
paSMepbI lJepeIIROM HOpOORll B C01JeTaHIIII C YMepeHHOM IIIllpIIROM JIllll,eBOrO
CHeJleTa II )J,OJIUXOHpaRlleM 06paSYlOT cBoe06paSRhIM HOMnJIeRC, HOTOphIM TPY)J,-
HO )J,IIarROCTupOBaTb B rrpe)J,eJIax eBponeou)J,Roll paChI, OTHeCJI ero H ceBepROM
llJlU IOiKHOM BeTBll, II HOTOphIM, nymRo ):(YMaTb, IIMeeT caMOCTOJITeJlbHhIll TaR-
COROMu1JeCHull CTaTYC.
IIo cpaBReRlllO cyme paCCMOTpeHRbIMI1 Bhlrne TpeMJI BapIIaRTaMII lJeT-
BepThIM BapllaRT, npe)J,CTaBJleHRbIM Ha Chlp)J,apI.e, B BOCTOlJROM Ra3axCTaRe
II Ra AJITae, SaRUJ\IaeT oc060e :\IeCTO. Yme HR C01J:eTaHllH npusIIaHoB, npe)J,-
CTaBJleHHhIX B Ta6J1. 5,- 60JlbrnOM rnUpIIHI.I Jlllll,eBoro CReJleTa, pe3HoM 6pa-
XllHpaHllllll YMepeRRoro BhlcTynaHllJI ROCOBbIX ROCTeM - Bll)J,HO, lJTO MhI UMeeM
S)J,eCb aHaJlOrHlO MOHrOJIOll)J,HOMY ROMrrJIeHcy npllSHaHOB B ero ll,eIITpaJlbRO-
aSIlaTCHOM BapIIaHTe. 06 3TOM me CBU)J,eTeJlI.CTBYIOT Ii npe)J,CTaBJIeHRhIe B
TaOJl. 3, 4 )J,aRHhle 0 ropIISOHTaJlbROM npo<pIIJle JIuu.eBoro CHeJleTa B 3TllX ce-
PllJIX, OTJlUlJaIOII(UXCJI pasHoM CTeneRhlO ynJlom;eRnOCTII. CpaBHIIBaJI 3'1'0'1'
ROMnJIeRC npUSHaHOB C COBpel\IeHHhIMII HpaHllOJlOrII1JeCmIMH BapllaRTaMll, JIer-
HO YBll)J,eTb ero CXO)J,CTBO C lOmROCllOIIpCHOM ROM6uRau.IIeM npllSRaHOB, llMelO-
m;elI CMernaHRoe IIpOUCXOiKll,eHUe II C<pOpMIIpOBaBrneMCJI IIa orpOMROM TeppUTO-
pUU 0'1' MOHrOJIllll Ha BOCTOHe O Ra3aXCTaRa IIa sana)J,e, Ha1J:IIHaJI C 3nOXll
py6eiIm nOS)J,ReM 6pOH3hI - paRRero meJlesa. PaCCMaTpHBaeMhIM HaMU XpO-
ROJIOrIIlJeCHllM OTpeSOH - BpeMJI UHTeHCIIBRoro <pOpMllpOBamIJI 3TOM HOM6ll-
Hau.uu IIpUSRaHOB, II, MomeT 6bITL, UMeHIIO n03TOMY cepllll llS TarllCHeRa,
YMrapaHa, YCTb-BYHOHJI II aJlTalICHllX RypraHoB OTJllllJalOTCJI )J,pyr 0'1' )J,pyra
BapUall,UJIMU TO O,L\ROrO, TO )J,pyroro npllSRaHa, 06HapymuBaJI HSBeCTHYlO
rpynliOBYlO IIec6aJIailCUpOBaIIIIOCTb TunOBOM RO I6uRau.I1U npllSHaROB II HeO)J,II-
RaHOBYlO CTerreHb ee BbIpameRHOCTII B OT)J,eJlbHhIX IIonYJIHll,llJIX.
HeMTpaJIbROCTb, OTMelJeRRaJI Bhlrne )J,JlJI nJITOrO, eRuceMCHoro BapllaHTa,
rrpe)J,CTaBJIeHHOrO B lJepenax TarapCHOM HYJIbTyphI, COCTaBJIJIeT B TO me BpeMJI
xapaHTepRYlO CIIell,I1<pIIHY 3'1'01'0 HOMnJIeRCa - no BceM lJeThlpeM rrpUSHaRaM
B Ta6J1. 5 TarapCRaJI CepllJI 3aHIIMaeT B BhI6paHRoM MacrnTa6e Bcex CHll<pO-
caHCHUX cepIIM CTporO cpe)J,UHHoe nOJIOmeHIIe. TaH me HaH )J,JIJI npIIlJepRO-
MopCHoro U aMY)J,apbllHCHoro BapllaRTOB RameTCJI BepOJITRhIM ux npOIICXOiK-
p;eHlle 0'1' MeCTRbIX RpaHIIOJIOrIIlJeCKUX HOMnJleKCOB 60JIee paHHero BpeMeHll,
231
I
eHIIceMCHUM BapllaHT aHaJIOrlllJHhIM 06paSOM UMeeT CBOll UCTORU, nO-BII,L\IIMO-
MY, B HpaHUOJIOrlllJeCmIX BapllaHTaX, npe)J,CTaBJIeHHbIX B HaCeJIeHUU 6aCCeM-
Ha BepXHero EHIICeJI 3noxu 6pOHSbI.
3THOI'EHETllqECRIIE liTOI'll
IIpe)J,rneCTBYlOm;llM IIaJleOaHTpOIIOJIorUlJeCRllM aHaJIII3 nOSBOJIJIeT BbICHaSaTbCJI
no HeHoTophIM acrreHTaM 3THoreHesa H 3THIIlJeCHOM llCTOpllll CRll<po-caRCHux
nJIeMeH, HOTophle YiKe 6hIJIll neo)J,HoHpaTHo npe)J,MeToM ):(llCHYCCUII B apxeo-
JlOrIPleCHOll, nCTOpIIlJeCROM II IICTOpIIKO-3THOJIOrnlJeCHOM JIUTepaType II no
HOTOphIM ):(0 CUX nop He ):(OCTHrHYTO nplleMJIeMOrO COrJIarneHllJI Memp;y llC-
CJIe)J,OBaTeJlJIMU 73.
IIpem):(e Bcero BCTaeT Bonpoc 0 npOIIcxom)J,eHIIU CHll<pOB ITpIIlJepHOMOpbJI,
IIJIII CHU<pOB B YSHOM CMbICJle CJlOBa. BllOJlOrIIlJeCROe e)J,IIHCTBO UX HeCOMHeH-
IIO U CBII)J,eTeJlbcTByeT 0 e)J,llHCTBe UX npOIIcxom)J,eHIIJI. Bbnne yme rOBOpu-
JlOCb, lJTO nOlJTll Bce UCCJle;rJ:OBaTeJIU, pa60TaBrnlle Ha)J, naJleOaHTpOnOJlOrlllJe-
CHUM MaTepUaJlOM HS CRU<pCRUX MOrIXJIbHIIROB IIpH1JepHOMopbJI, OTMe1JaJIU ero
3HalJIITeJlhHYlO 6JIllSOCTb H naJIeOaHTpOIIOJlOrlllJeCHUM MaTepIIaJlaM llS norpe6e-
HIIM 3nOXll 6pOHShI B CTerrHhlX paMoHax eBpOneMCRoM 1JaCTll CCCP. Oc06eHHo
BemIRO 3'1'0 CXO):(CTBO Mem)J,Y CRII<pCHIIMU naJIeOaHTpOnOJlOrn1JeCHUMll MaTepIIa-
JlaMII II aHaJlOrlllJHhIMII MaTepIIaJIaMII U3 norpe6aJlbHhIX naMJITHllROB CPy6HOM
HYJIbTyphI. BllOJlOrn1JeCHOe eL(IIHCTBO nplllJepHOMOpCHllX CHll<pOB, 0 ROTOpOM
MbI TOJlbRO lJTO rOBOplJ.1IH, C<pOpMupOBaJlOCb, CJle)J,OBaTeJlbHO, e:II\e B 3noxy
6pOHShI IIpll6J1IISUTeJlbHO Ha TOM me TeppIITOpuU, Ha HOTOpOM MhI saCTaeM
ero B CRII<pCHoe BpeMH, nO-Bu)J,IIMOMY, B He)J,pax HaCeJleHllJI CPy6HOM RYJlbTY-
phI. TaHIIM 06pasoM, pesYJIbTaThI naJIeOaHTpOnOJlOrUlJeCHllX llCCJle)J,oBaHllM no-
SBOJIJIlOT nO)J,p;epmaTb rUIIoTesy CJIOmeHHH CRII<pCROII HYJIbTYPhI IIa 6ase cPy6-
HOM HYJIbTYPHOM 06m;HOCTll, rnIIpoHo aprYMenTIlpOBaHIIYlO B HeCHOJIbHllX
<PYH)J,aMeHTaJIhHhIX apXeOJIOrIIlJeCKUX nCCJIep:oBaHUJIX ".
IIepexo)J,JI )J,aJIee OT c06cTBeHHo CRII<pOB H CRll<po-caRCHoM 06m;HOCTII B ll,e-
JlOM, 06paTHM BHllMaHlle B nepBYlO OlJepeD,b Ha caHOB IIaMIIpa. RaH yme ro-
BOpHJIOCh, nepe)J,HeasHaTcHlle aHaJIOrllU (B rnllpoRoM CMhICJle CJlOBa, C BHJllO-
1J:eUIIeM aHTpono.lonI ecRux oc06eIIHocTeM MHorux )J,peBHllx cepllM C Teppu-
TOpHII RaBRasa II Cpe):(HeM ASIIU) llX Mop<pOJIOrII1JeCHoMY Tuny 01JeBU)J,HbI.
RaH Momrro IIIITepIIpeTllpOnaTb :no aHTpOnOJlOrII1JeCHOe Ha6mo)J,eHue B llCTO-
plllJeCROM IIJIaHe? BOJlee 1JeM BepOJITHO, 1JTO npe;rJ:cTaBllTeJlU 3TOM ROM6uHall,llU
npH3HaHoB npOHIIRJIII Ha TeppIITopUlO RaBHasa II Cpe)J,HeM ASHU em;e B 3Heo-
mITe .fl, BO BCJIHOM cJIYlJae, rnupoRo 6hIJIU pacrrpocTpaHeHbI s)J,ecb B 3IJOXy
6pOHShI 75. II03TOMY B oll,eHHe np06J1eMhI SaCeJIeHIIJI IIaMllpa caHCHUMU nJIe-
l\IeHa:MH naJIeOaIITponOJlOflllJeCHlle gaHHhle 6eCCllJlbHhI: OHO MOrJIO llMeTb MeCTO
II C ceBepO-BOCTORa, HaH rrOJIaraIOT TaRIIe aBTopUTeTHhIe IICCJIe)J,OBaTeJlII cpe)J,-
HeasuaTCRIIX )J,peBHOCTeM, HaH A. H. BepHrnTaM n B. A. JIUTBIIHCRllM (caR-
CRIIe IJJIe1IeHa ITaMupa npep:CTaBJlHIOT C060M B 3TOM CJIY1Jae lOro-sana):(HbIM
<popnOCT caRCHoro HOlJeBoro MlIpa), lJepes AJlaMCRIIM xpe6eT, AJIaMCHYIO )];0-
JIIIHy n nepeBaJIbI 3aaJlalICROro xpe6Ta, II C lOra, lJepe3 )J,OJlllHY BaxaH)J,apbll.
Ho B OOOIIX CJIY1JaJIX IICXO;J;Hoe nepe)J,HeaSIIaTCHoe npOUCXOif\)J,eHlle naMupCHllX
caHOB B CBeTe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOfII1JeCRIIX Ha6JIlO):(eHIIM MomHO C1JllTaTb Heco-
MHeHHhIM.
fIpOIIcxom)J,eHIIe TOM ROM6llHall,llII npllsHaHoB, ROTopaH npe.n:cTaBJleHa B
l\IOrIIJlbIIIIHe TapbIM-RaJI Ha AMY)J,apbe, He OlJeIIb JICHO. B coce)J,HeM C Ta-
phIM-I\aJI MOrllJIbHUHe TYMeH-Rll1Jll)J,iKUH, ns ROToporo IIpOUCXO)J,JIT HeCHOJlhRO
MymcRux lJepenOB, MbI CTaJlHUBaeMCH C em;e 60Jlee HpynHhIMll paSMepaMll
lJepeIIHOM Hop06HU, HO ROM6IIHall,llJI npII3HaROB B u:eJlOM He nOBTOpJIeTCJI, TaR
232
RaH 1J:epena lIS TYMeH-RlllJU)J,mllR IIMelOT ropas)J,o 60JIee BhlcTynalOm;IIe HO-
COBhIe ROCTU. HeOJIIITIIlJeCRUe lJepena lIS 3'1'01'0 MOrIIJIbHllRa npII TOM me BbI-
CTYIIaHUU HOCOBhIX ROCTeM ropasp;o 60JIee rpall,llJIbHhI 76 . CRYJIOBaH rnupllHa
Ha lJeperrax US 060llX MOrIIJIbHllROB - TaphIM-RaJI U TYMeH-RulJII)J,iKIIR-
npll npllHJITOM HaMll MacrnTa6e OHaSaJIaCb cpe)J,HeM (MymcHlle 1J:epena) II
MaJIOM (JReHCKUe lJepena), HO B ll,eJIOM )J,JIJI eBponeoll)J,Horo HOMnJIeHCa OHa
CRopee 3HalJIITeJIbHaJI. B HalJeCTBe IIpIIeM.::IeMOII aHaJIOnIII (oc06eHHO lJepe-
naM llS CRll<pCRUX norpe6eHIIM TYMeR-RlllJll)J,iKIIH) MomHO HaSBaTb HeCHOJIbHO
01JeHh MaCCUBHhIX II 60JIbrnUX lJepenOB llS paHHero TYJIXapCH,oro MOrllJIbHURa,
OTJIUlJaIOm;UXCJI O):(HOBpeMeHHO peSHO BhlpameHHhIMU eBponeOll)J,HbIMU OCO-
6eIIHOCTJIMU 77. O)J,HaRO cym;eCTBYlOT U paSJIU IIIH Mem)J,Y 06ellMU CepllJIJ\UI no
MHorIIM npU3HaHaM, a TaH HaR lJepenOB B 060IIX cJIYlJaJIX MaJIO, OCTaeTCJI He-
JICHhIM, B RaHoII Mepe 3TU pa3.::III1JIIH CJIY1J:aMHhI, a B HaHOM saROHOMepHbI. Ho,
HaR yme rOBOpllJIOCb, caMOCTOJITeJIbHOe npOllCXOiI{)J,eHIIe aMY)J,apbIIHCHoro Ba-
pllaHTa BeCbMa BepOJITHO, OHO ll)J,eT, IIO-BII):(llMOMY, 0'1' HaHOM-TO I'pynnbI
cpe):(HeaSllaTCHoro HaCeJIeHIIH 3nOXll 6POH3bI, a 3'1'0 OSHa1J:aeT, 1J:TO B COCTaBe
CHll<po-caHCHllX nJIeMeH EBpaSllll MO)f;HO Bhlp;eJIUTb em;e O,L\HY caMOCTOHTeJI:b-
HYlO rpynrry.
B CBJISU C IIH<pllJIhTpall,lleM MOHrOJIOll)J,HhIX 3JIeMeilTOB B 3THll1JecHylO cpe-
,L\y, HaCeJIJIBrnylO 6acceMH Chlp)J,apbll, BOCTOlJHbIM RasaXCTaH U ropHbIe paMO-
RbI AJITaJI, BnOJIHe eCTeCTBeHHO nOCTYJIllpOBaHIIe RYJIbTYPHhIX CBJISeM BOCTOlJ-
Horo npOIIcxom)J,eHUH. MCXO)J,H US naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX )J,aHHblx, MomHO
He TOJIbRO )J,YMaTb 0 TOM, lJTO npou.ecc (<BeJIllROrO nepeCeJIeHllJI HapO)J,OB» Ha-
lJaJICJI Ha HeCHOJIbHO CTOJIeTllM paHbrne, lJeM OH sa<pllRcupOBaH CBU,L\eTeJIbCT-
BaMU IICTOplllJeCRUX llCTOlJHllHOB 78, HO II BhICRasaTbCH B nOJIhSY T01J:HII spe-
HIIJI Tex UCCJIe)J,OBaTeJIeM, HOTOphIe BU)J,JIT B RYJIbType caHCRIIX IIJIeMeH Ra3ax-
CTaHa II AJITaJI MHorue "IepThI ll,eHTpaJIbHOaSIIaTcRoro npoucxom)J,eHllJI 79.
qTO me RacaeTCH nepe):(HeasuaTCHllX BJIUJIHIIM B MOTUBax II <popMaJIbHO-CTll-
JIllCTlllJeCRIIX oc06eHHOCTHX BemIHOJIeIIHhIX 06paSll,OB CHII<pCHoro sBepIIHoro
CTllJIH US HypraHoB RasaxcTaHa II AJITaH 80, 0 HOTOpbIX HeMaJIO HanIIcaHO,
TO llX CJIe)J,yeT, nO-Bllp;UMOMY, Oll,eHIIBaTb HaR peSYJIbTaT ToprOBhIX ROHTaHTOB
II HYJIbTYPHOM )J,ll<P<PYSUll. AHaJIOrnlJHOe SHalJeHUe, Ha)J,O ):(YMaTh, UMeeT B
<paHT HaJIII1JllJI Y caHOB AJITaJI JIOrna)J,eM nepe)J,HeaSIIaTCHoro IIpOIIcxom,L\e-
HllJI 81.
OCTaeTCH CHasaTb HeCROJIbHO CJIOB 0 reHeTlllJeCRIIX llCTORax HaCeJIeHIIJI,
cosp,aBrnero TarapcRylO HyJIbTYPY B MllHYCTIIICHllX CTerrJIX. r. $. ,l];e6ell, yRa-
ShIBaJI I1a llCHmOlJIITeJIbHOe CXO)J,CTBO TarapCHOM cepUII C cepIIeM 3HeOJIllTll-
lJeCHOM a<paHacbeBcHoM RYJIbTypbI 82. ABTOp HaCTOJIm;eII pa60TbI c)J,eJIaJI no-
nhITRy aprYMenTupOBaTb HaJIU1JIIe reHeTUlJeCHOIr CBHSU Mem)J,y rrUMll 83.
A. r. RosIIHu.eB, OCHOBhIBaJICL Ha CYMMapHOM cTaTHCTU1JeCHOM conOCTaBJIe-
Hllll, He OilpOBepraeT, no cym;eCTBY, 3TU BhIBO)J,hI, HO YHaShIBaeT na <paRT
SrralJllTeJIhHOrO CXO):(CTBa Tarapll,eB U C HeHOTophIMU )J,PyrllMu lOmHOCII6llp-
CHIIMll II RasaXCTaHCHllMll CepUJIMU 3rroxn 6pOHSbI II paHHero meJIesa 84.
RaH 6bI TaM HB 6hIJIO, MomHO )J,YMaTb, lJTO IIpep,HU Tarapll,eB OT)J,eJIllJIUCb 0'1'
eBponeMCHIIX rpynrr em;e B 3noxy 6pOH3bI U TarapCHoe HaCeJIeHIIe UMeeT ca-
MOCTOJITeJIbHOe no cpaBHeHIIlO C npU IepHOMOPCHU;\IU CHII<paMII npOUCXOiI{)J,e-
Hue, XOTJI II OCTaeTCJI eBponeOU)J,HbIl\l. BeccnopHo caMOCTOJITeJIeH ero reHesuc
B IIO cpaBHeHIIlO C ):(pyrUMll nepelJIICJIeHHbIMU BbllIIe rpYIInaMu caHCHoro Ha-
CeJIeHllH.
RaHoB 06m;llH BhIBO)J, llS Bcex npuBep;eHHbIx conOCTaBJIeHUM II co06pame-
HUM? BonpeRII MHeHlllO Tex uCCJIep,OBaTeJIeM, ROTOpbIe Bll)J,HT reHeTll IeCRlle
UCTOHII CRU<p0-CII6llpCHIIX, UJIU CRll<po-caRCHllx, RYJIbTYP B e)umOM 3THlllJe-
CHOM cpe)J,e II cpaBHUTeJIbIlO OrpaHlllJeHHOM TeppllTopllU 8", naJIeOaHTpOnOJIO-
233
I
rIIlJeCRlle )J,aHHhIe )J,alOT BOSMomHOCTb nO):()J,epmaTb ,L\pyrylO rllnoTesy: CHII<pO-
caHCRaH, llJlU CRll<p0-Cll6upCRaJI, RYJlbTypHaJI 06:II\HOCTb He 06pasyeT reHeTU-
lJeCHOrO e)J,IUICTBa II CJIOmllJlaCb Ha 6ase HeCHOJIbHIIX paSHhIX no npOllcxom-
)J,eHIIlO aHTpOrrOJIOrUlJeCRU cBoe06pasHhlx HOMrrOHeHTOB, HOTophle U 3THlllJe-
CHll MOrJlH cym;ecTBeHHO OTJIUlJaTbCH )J,pyr 0'1' )J,pyra.
IIAJIEO,l);EMOI'P A lIqECRIIE HABJIIO,l);EHIIH
B pas,L\eJle, nOCBJIm;eHHOM 06m;eMY 06sopy rrpo)J,OJlmUTeJlbHOCTU mUSHII )J,peB-
Hero HaCeJIeHIIJI CCCP 86, H npIIBeJl ll,II<PPhI cp8)J,Hero BospaCTa CMepTII )J,JIJI
CRU<pOB fI capMaTOB YHpaUHbI II IToBOJImbJI, a TaHme )J,JIJI caROB ITaMllpa U
TarapCHoro HaCeJleHUJI MIIHYCIIHCROM ROTJlOBllHbI. 8TlI ll,II<PPbI ROJle6aJlIICb
B IIHTepBaJIe 34-44 JIeT, ROHll,eHTpllpYJICb, HaR Ha MO)J,aJlbHOM BeJlIIlJllHe,
rrplHIepHO Ha 40 rO)J,ax, rrplllJeM Mym1JUHhI YMIIpaJlII Ha 4-5 JIeT IIosme meH-
m;llH. CTaTbJI A. r. ROSllHll,eBa 87, Cnell,IIaJlbHO nOCBJIm;eHHaJI ):(eMorpa<pIIII
TarapCHUX MOrUJlbIUmOB, He U3MeHIIJla npe)J,CTaBJl8IIUJI 0 B03paCTe CMepTll
BSpOCJloro HaCeJIeHUH II nO)J,TBep)J,UJla <paHT 60JIee paHHeM CMepTII meHCHOM
lJaCTll IIorrYJIJIIJ.llII. C Y1JeTOM )J,eTcHoM CMepTHOCTII IJ.u<ppa npO):(OJImIITeJIbIIO-
CTII mllSHII COCTaBIIJla 26,5 rO)J,a. Bce 3'1'0 B IJ.eJlOM COOTBeTcTByeT )J,aHHhIM
no )J,pyrIIM naMJITHUHaM 3I10XII palmero meJlesa II 6pOH3hI U OTpamaeT TOT
CTaTYC ypOBHJI mIISHII II 6hITOBbIX YCJlOBUM, HOTOphIM 6hIJI, nO-BII)J,UMOMY,
06bI1JeH )J,JIJI 3'1'01'0 XpOHOJlOrlllJeCHOrO OTpe3Ha llCTOpllII lJeJlOBelJeCTBa. MHhI-
MU CJIOBaMll, II c06CTBeHHO CHU<phI, II CHll<po-caHCHue nJleMeHa CTeneM EBpa-
SUII B rnupOHOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa mUJIII IIe xyme, HO II He JIY1Jrne )J,pyrlIx Ha-
pOD,OB, XpOHOJlOrU1J:eCRll llM npe)J,rneCTBOBaBrnIIX IIJlII npomUBaBrnllX C HllMII
O)J,HOBpeMeHHO.
B HaCTOJIm;ee BpeMJI, Hor)J,a T. C. ROHP;YRTopoBa ony6J1uRoBaJla CBOII
IIH)J,IIBll)J,yaJlbHhle IIsMepeHllJI CHII<pCHllX lJepenOB, a TaRme Cp;eJlaHHhIe 810
BospaCTHhle onpe)J,eJIeHUJI 88, nOJIBIIJlaCb B03MomHOCTb 060raTllTb paHee ll3-
BeCTHhle )J,aHHhIe. B )J,onOJIHeHlle R HeanOJllO CRll<PCROMY MomHO BhIlJllCJIllTb
cpe)J,HUM BospaCT CMepTU em;e )J,JlH )J,BYX MOrUJlbHIIHOB py6ema H. 3.-
30JlOTOM BaJIHII U HllHOJIaeBRll-Rasall,Roe, nOJlbSYJICb TeMU me npIIHll,una-
MU paClJeTa, ROTOpbIe ll3JIOmeHhI B MoeM CTaTbe no naJleO)J,eMorpa<pUII CCCP.
,D;aHHbIe rro HeanOJIlO CHII<PCHOMY, oIIy6JIUROBaHHbIe B 3TOM CTaTbe, npUBO-
):(JITCJI S)J,eCb nOBTopHO pa)J,u nOJlHOThI llSJlOmeHllH:
HearrOJIb CKIUpCKlZIH
»
30JIOTaH Eam,a
»
HIZIROJIaeBIm- Ra3aI\ROe
)}
(MymqIZIHbI)
(meHID;HHbI)
(MymqHHbI)
(aieHID;HHbI)
( MymqlZIHbI)
(meHID;HHbI)
43,4(71)
34,6 (25)
47,7(25)
38,9(43)
48,3 (69)
43,2 (62) *
Ms 3'1'01'0 pH)J,a ll,U<pP BU):(HO, lJTO cpe)J,HllM BospaCT CMepTU B CRU<pCHUX
nOIIYJIJIIJ.UJIX 6hIJI p;ame HeCROJIbRO Bhlrne, lJeM cpe)J,u oRpymalO:II\llX llX Ha-
pO)J,OB. MomHO 6hIJIO 6bI ,L\YMaTb, lJTO 3'1'0 npOllCXO):(llT sa ClJeT '1'01'0, lJTO B
HarneM pacnOpJImeHIIU HaXO)J,HTCJI )J,aHHhle no nOS)J,HllM rpynnaM CHII<pCHoro
HaCeJleHUH, CllHxpOHHoro capMaTaM, U lJTO H HalJaJIY H. 3. npO)J,OJlmUTeJILHOCTb
lliIISHll HeCHOJlbRO YBeJlUlJIIJIaCb no cpaBHeHUlO C Ha1J:aJlOM paHHero meJIeSHO-
1'0 BeRa. O)J,HaRO ll,II<PPhI no 06'be):(IIHeHHOM cepUll paHHllX CRII<pOB HumHero
IIo)J,HenpoBbJI, npuBe)J,eHHhle B MoeM CTaTbe no IIaJleo)J,eMorpa<pllII CCCP no
,L\aHHhIM r. II. 3UHeBlllJ, XOTH MeHbrne, lJeM no 30JlOTOM BaJlRe Ii HUHOJlaeB-
* B cRo6Rax - qlZICJIO Ba6JIIOJI,eHI'IH. CpeJl,WlH npoJl,OJImlZITeJILBOCTb mlZI3BIZI - B rop;ax.
234
He-Ra3all,ROe, HO He HaCTOJlbRO, 'IT06bI npll)J,aBaTb eM saHoHoMepHhIM HarrpaB-
JleHHhIM xapaRTep. B 06m;eM nO)J,TBepm):(aeTCJI MhICJIb 0 6J1arOIIOJIY1JrrOM )J,e-
Morpa<pII'IeCHOM cTaTyce CHII<pCHllX nonYJlJIll,IIM. iReHm;llHbI, RaR II BO Bcex
)J,pyrIIx rpynnax, JI,IIJIU MeHLrne.
CepIIll IIS 6acceiIHoB AMY)J,aphll II Cblp)J,apblI, HaR U cepIIll llS ropHhlx
paMoHoB AJITaJI U IIS BOCTO'IHOrO RasaxcTaHa, CJlUrnHOM MaJIO'IIICJIeHHbI, 'ITO-
6hI MomHO 6hIJIO ocym;ecTBllTb CHOJIbHO-HU6Y)J,h y6e)J,uTeJlLIIhle naJleO)J,eMO-
rpmpU'IeCHUe paC1JeThI. Ho ony6J1IIRoBaHHhle T. II. RIIJITHUHOM 89 UH)J,llBll-
)J,yaJlbHhIe )J,aHHhIe If ocym;ecTBJleHHhle elO UH)J,llBII)J,yaJlLHhIe BospaCTHhle on-
pe)J,eJleHIIJI ,L\81OT - TaHYlO BOSMOJImOCTb )J)IJI naMIIpCHllX caHOB. IIo )J,aHHbIM
B. B. rllHs6ypra B CTaTbe no naJIeo)J,eMorpa<pIIII CCCP npllBe):(eHa )J,JlJI caHOB
IIaMllpa BeJIII'IIIHa Cpe,L\HerO BospaCTa CMepTU 41,6 ro):(a (29 Ha6J11O)J,eHIIII):
,L\JIJI Mym1JIIH - 38,3 rO)J,a (19 Ha6JIlO)J,eHUII), )J,JlH meHm;IIH - 47,8 rO)J,a
(10 Ha6J11O):(eHuII). MCnOJIbsYJI )J,aHHhle T. IT. RllHTRIIHOM, MbI nOJIy'IaeM )J,JlJI
cYMMapHoM cepIIll caHOB IIaMIIpa cpe)J,HuM BospaCT CMepTll 39,7 rO)J,a y Mym-
'IUH (48 Ha6JIlO)J,€HIIll), 42,2 rO)J,a y meHm;IIH (37 Ha6J1lOAeHIIII) 11 40,8 rO)J,a
06m;llM no 060IIM nOJlaM (85 Ha6J11O)J,eHIIM). JI1060nhITHo, 11 IIPII 60Jlee nOJl-
HhIX )J,aHHhIX _COXpaHUJlaCb OTJlII1JalOm;aJICJI 0'1' 06hI'IHOM cUTyall,IIH 60JIbrnelI
npO)J,OJImIITeJlbHOCTll JI\IISHII meH:II\UH no cpaBHeHlllO C MyJI,1JUHaMll: BII)J,IIMO,
CypOBbIe yCJIOBUJI ITaMIIpa YCUJIIIBaJlll oT60p B MymCHoM 'IaCTU nonyJlJIIJ.UII
II ypaBHllBaJlII p;eMcTBlle <paRTopOB, onpe)J,eJlJIBrnllX paHHlOIO CMepTb meHm;llH
(oCJIOmHeHllH nOCJIe pO)J,OB, aHTllcaHIITapHoe COCTOJIHIIe )J,peBnux nOCeJIHOB).
IIpu MaJlO'IIICJleHHOCTI1 cepllM U3 MOrllJlbHllHOB IIaMIIpCHaJI I II AR6ellT BeT
CMhICJla BhI'IIICJlJITb cpe)J,HIIM BospaCT CMepTll )J,JIJI OCTaBIIBrnl1X UX nonY:IJI-
UllM: MbI nOJlY'IllJlU 6bI CJIY'IaMnhle ll,ll<PPhI. Ho B ll,eJIOM HeJlbSJI He saMeTllTb
HeHOTopoe YMeHbrneHIIe npO)J,OJImUTeJlhHOCTll mllSHI1 y naMllpCHIIX caHOB no
cpaBHeHlllO C npII'IepHOMOpCHUMU CHll<paMII. IIaMllp eCTb ITaMllp, XOTJI nOJlY-
lIeHHhle ll,ll<PPbI He BbIXO)J,JIT sa paMHll Bapuall,UM )J,JlJI 3TOM 3nOXII.
BospaCTHhle onpe eJleHIIJI, OCY:II\eCTBJIeHHhle A. r. ROSIIHIJ.eBbIM 90, l\IOrmI
6bI pacrnllpIITb IWJlII'IeCTBeHHYlO 6asy D,JlJI nOJIyqeHIIJI cpe)J,nux IJ.u<pp no
TarapcRoM RYJlbType, HO B 3TOM HeT 60JlLrnOM He06xo)J,IIMOCTll, TaH RaH npll-
Be)J,eHHhIe B MoelI CTaTbe no naJIeo):(eMorpa<puu CCCP ll,ll<PPhI TaHme OCHOBa-
HbI Ha )J,OCTaT01JHOM HOJlIIqeCTBe Ha6JTlO)J,eHllM. ,l];JlJI Tpex cTa)J,llM TarapcHoM
RYJIbTyphI cpeJ],HlllI BospacT cMepTII rrpu 06bI'IHOM COOTHorneHllll )J,JlH Mym-
'IIIH II menm;IIH (Mym'IllHhI yMIIpaJlII HeCROJlbRO nosme meHm;UH) Bapbupy-
eT B npe)J,eJIax 33,9-37,2 rO)J,a, T. e. JIBHO Hllme, 1JeM B rpynnax CIIHXPOH-
Horo HaCeJleHllJI, B TOM 'IUCJIe II Ha IIaMllpe. 01JeBU)J,HO, B ):(aHHOM CJIY'Iae
)J,eMCTBOBaJlII HaHue-TO JIORaJlbHhle <paRTOphI, xapaHTepHhle )J,JIJI 6accelIHa
EHIICeH. TeM 60Jlee 'ITO HaCeJTeHIIe npIIeHllceMclmx I,yJTLTYP 3rrOXll 6pOH3bI
TaHme OTJIII'IaJlOCb yRopO'IenHhIMII cpoHaMII mIISHll no cpaBHeHulO C HaCeJle-
HIIeM eBpoIIeMcHllx CTerreM '1'011 nophI.
IIo)J,BO)J,JI lITOI', MomHO OTMeTllTb HaJlll'IUe He60JIbrnUX, HO peaJlbHhIX pas-
JIU'IUM B rrpO)J,OJlmllTeJlbHOCTII mllSHll OT)J,eJlbHhIX rpynn BHYTPII CHII<p o - caH -
CHoro apeaJla, XOTJI npll1JUHbI 3TIIX paSJlll'IUM, RopeHHm;IIeCH B Me):(IIRo-reorpa-
<pII1JeCROM cIITyall,llll, 6hITOBhIX YCJIOBIIJIX II B 06m;eM ll,URJle BceM mllSIIU,
nOHa OCTaIOTCJI HeJICHbIMII.
B OTHorneHllll BOCCTaHOBJTeHllJI )J,pyroM BamHOM naJleO)J,eMorpa<pII'IeCIWM
xapaHTepIICTllHll - 1J:MCJIeHHOCTll HaCeJleHllJI naJIeOaHTpOIIOJlOrIIJI )J,O CllX nop
B nO,L\aBJIJIlO:II\eM 60JlbrnlIHCTBe CJlY1JaeB He npllHOCllT HIIHaHOM llHllJOpMall,uu
(lls-sa OTCYTCTBIIJI nOJlHOCThlO paCHonaHHbIX MOrIIJlbHllHOB, II3 ROTOphIX 6bIJI
6hI c06paH BeCb ROCTHbIM MaTepllaJl), II n03TOMY npllXO)J,IITCJI oplleHTIIpOBaTbCJI
Ha BhIBO)J,hI, C)J,eJlaHHhle Ha OCHOBe ROCBeHHbIX )J,aHHhIX, B 'IaCTHOCTII peSYJIh-
TaTOB apXeOJIOrII'IeCKHX paCHonOR. TaH, B. A. JIUTBIIHCRIIM nOJIaraeT, 'ITO Ha
,
235
I
BOCTO'IHOM IIaMupe npOmUBaJIO B CHU<pCHOe BpeMJI npIIMepHO 10000-15000
'IeJIOBeH 91, XOTJI OCHOBaHUJI UMeHHO P;JIJI TaKOM ll,U<PPhI OCTalOTCH He O'IeHb
JICH:bIMII. MIIHIIMYM HeCHOJIbHO p;eCHTHOB T:bICJI'I 'IeJIOBeH o.o;HOBpeMeHHO rrpo-
mIIBaJIO, HaL(O .o;YMan, B 6accefIHe ,l];Herrpa. B npOTUBHOM cJIy1Jae CHU<phI He
MOrJIU OhI rrpOTIIBOCToarb MOm;HOM apMUII ,l];apUJI rUCTacna 'IUCJIeHHOCTblO B
HeCHOJIbHO COT ThICJI1J 'IeJIOBeH 92.
qTO me HacaeTCH HaCeJIeHUJI TarapCHOH HYJIbTyphI, TO MHe HeU3BeCTH:bI
HaHUe-JIu60 nonhITHU onpe)J,eJIeHUJI ero 1J:MCJIeHHOCTU. B cBo)J,He C. B. Rllce-
JIeBa yrroMuHalOTcH no pasHhIM IIOBO)J,aM 30-35 TarapCHUX MOrUJIbHllHOB.
llpII6mISIITeJIhHO 10-15 CTaJIII )J,onOJIHHTeJIhHO USBeCTHhI IIOCJIe paCHOIIOH
A. H. JIuIIcHoro. OHOJIO 40 MOrIIJIhHUHOB, 06HapymeHHhlx COTpy.o;HUHaMU
RpaCHOJIpCHOM 3Hcrre;D;IIll,IIU MHcTuryTa apxeOJIorUII AH CCCP, nepe'IUCJIeHhI B
CBO,L\Re A. r. ROSIIHll,eBa, U3 HIIX eCTb rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCHIIM MaTepUaJI.
Pas.'HephI HypraHHhIX rpyrril paSJIII'IHhI - npUMeM cpe.o;Hee 'IUCJIO HypraHoB
B rpyrrIIe paBH:bIM 10. HaYHe, CJIe)J,oBaTeJIbHO, IISBeCTHO CeM'IaC OHOJIO
1000 TarapcmIX HypraHoB, paCHonaHHhIX B MUHYCUHCHOM HOTJIOBUHe. llocJIe
O'Iem, 60JIhrnIIX IIO MacrnTa6aM pa60T RpaCHOJIpCHOM 3Hcrre)J,IIll,uu TPY)J,HO o:u;e-
HUTb, 'ITO II3 TarapCHUX rraMJITIIllHOB OCTaJIOCb HeIISBeCTHbIM II Hesa<pIIHcll-
pOBaHH:bIM, - )J,JIH 3Toro HymHo mp;aTb IIOJIHOM ny6JIUHa:U;IIu MaTepIIaJIOB.
Ho IIpe)J,rrOJI01RUM onHTb, 'ITO paCHorraHa O)J,Ha )J,eCJITaH 'IaCTb. Cpe)J,Hee 'IUCJIO
3axopOHeHilhIX B KypraHe npUMeM sa 10 1J:eJIOBeK Tor.o;a, CJIe,L\OBaTeJIhHO,
B MUHYCIIHCHIIX CTerrHX 6hIJIO B03Be)J,eHO 10000 TarapCHIIX HypraHoB II B
HUX saxopOHeHO 100000 'IeJIOBeH - npilMepHaH 'IUCJIeHOCTb TarapCHoro Ha-
CeJIeHIIJI 3a Bce BpeMH ero cym;ecTBOBaHIIJI. IIpu BpeMeHU cym;ecTBOBaHIIJI
TarapcHoM HyJIbTypbI B rrHTb CTOJIeTUM II )J,JIUTeJIbHOCTII IIOHOJIeHUJI B 25 neT
(HanO)',IHHalO - 26,5 rO)J,a IIO A. r. R03IIHll,eBY) MhI IIPUXO.o;UM H BhIBO)J,y, 'ITO
B MIIHYCUHCHIIX CTerrJIX e,L\IIHOBpeMeHHO rrpOmUBaJIO 5000 'IeJIOBeH. IJ;II<ppa
HameTCH saHIImeHHoM, HO IIpe)J,JIOmlITb HaHofI-Hll6y)J,b .o;pyrOM rro)J,xo)J, )J,JIJI
IIaJIeOp,eMorpa<pII1J:eCHOM peHoHcTpyHD;Hu CeM1J:aC Tpy.o;HO.
YPOBEHb iK1I3I111 II OBECllEqEHHOCTb IIII Ea
BosMomHocTII naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrII1J:eCROrO IICCJIe)J,OBaHllJI CeM'IaC TaHoBhI, 'ITO
OHO He )J,aeT rrpHM:bIX )J,aHHhIX )J,JIJI cym)J,eHIIH 0 Tex MOMeHTax, HOTOphIe BbI-
HeceHhI B SarOJIOBOH. Ho HOCBeHHaJI BOSMomHOCTb Cy.o;UTb 06 3TOM, 01JeHb 01'-
paHU'IeHHaJI IIpaB)J,a, OCTaeTCJI - 3'1'0 COCTOJIHIIe <pU3II'IeCHOrO paSBIITIIH,
a TaHme Me)J,llHo-6uO:IOI'II'IeCmrM CTaTYC IIcc.rreAyeM:bIX .o;peBHUX rrorrYJIJIll,IIM.
MaCCOBbIe IISMeplITeJIhHhIC )J,aHHhIe 0 paSBUTUll CHeJIeTa llMelOTCJI no rrpII-
'IepHOMOpCHUM CHII<paM II HaCeJIeHUlO TarapCHOM HYJIbTYPhI 93 . B. B. rUH3-
6ypr OrpaHII1J:HJICJI orrUCaTeJIhHOM xapaHTepUCTIIHOM CHeJIeTa rraMIIpCHUX ca-
HOB: «,l];mIlIa TeJIa Mym'IUH BbIrne cpe)J,Hero. POCT meHm;IIH BapbIIpyeT 60JIb-
me - OT Hume cpe)J,Hero ,L\o BbIrne cpe)J,Hero. IIoJIoBaJI .o;u<p<pepeHll,upoBHa Ha
HOCTJIX, HaH II Ha 'Ieperrax, xoporno BhlpameHa. ROCTll meHm;IIH TOHHIIe, rpa-
:U;UJIbH:bIe>) 94. TaHaH xapaHTepUCTUHa MaJIOIIplIro.o;Ha )J,JIJI cpaBHIITeJIbHOH
o:u;eHRH. Ho eCJIll OIIIICaTeJIbHO oxapaHTepusoBaTb pesYJIbTaThI u3MepIITeJIb-
HOrD IISY'IeHIIJI CHeJIeTOB CHII<pOB IIpll'IepHoMopbJI II npIIeHIIceMcHux Tarap-
ll,eB, TO onllcaHIIe 6Y)J,eT 6JIIISKUM - B 060lIX CJIY'IaJIX HaCeJIeHUe 6bIJIO
cpe)J,Hero pOCTa ()J,JIUHa TeJIa B OT.o;eJIbHhIX IIorrYJIJIll,UJIX HOJIe6aJIaCb OT 165
.0;0 168 CM) U OTJIU'IaJIOCb cpaBHIITeJIbHO rpall,IIJIbH:bIM CJIOmeHU8M. Hu B npo-
IIOP:U;IIJIX TeJIa, Hll B pasMepax OT)J,eJIbHhIX ROCTelI He sa<pUHCIIpOBaHbI OTHJIO-
HeHUH OT CTaHp;apTHhIX BeJIM1JUH, 'ITO CBu.o;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 p;OCTaT01J:HOM cHa6-
meHUU nIIm;eM Ii[ HOpMaJIbHOM paSBIITIIU B )J,eTCHOM BospaCTe. MJICO II MOJIO'I-
H:bIe npo.o;YHThI COCTaBJIJIlOT OCHOBHhIe npo.o;YHThI rrUTaHIIJI npu CHOTOBo.o;'Ie-
236
.<
CHOM XOSJIMCTBe II HOlJeBOM 06pa3e mlI3HII (repOP;OT npJIMO nnmeT 00 aTOM
IIO OTHorneHlllO H npM1JepHOMOpCHllM CRU<paM), ll, nO-BIIp;IIMOMy, IIX 6hlP;0 .0;0-
CTaT01J:HO II Ha J]:HeIIpe II Ha EHIIcee. BeCbMa BepOJITHO, 1J:TO II Ha TeppIITO-
plIll BOCT01J:HOrO IIaMllpa yCJIOBllJI .o;JIJI CHOTOBo.o;CTBa y IIaMllpCKHX caHOB
OhWll )J,OCTaTOlJHO 6JIal'OIIpllJITH:bI: BOCTOlJHOIIaMIIpCHIIe IIaCT6llm;a BO MHorOM
YHllHaJIhHhI II 06eCIIelJIIBalOT BhICOHIIM HarYJI CHOTa 95.
PeSYJIbTaT:bI IIaJIeOrraTOJIOrlllJeCHOrO llsyq:eHIIJI CHeJIeTOB llS MOrIIJIbHllHa
HllHOJIaeBHa-Ra3all,CHOe 96 II lIS MOrll:IbHIIHOB TarapCHOM RYJIbTYPhI He CBll-
p;eTeJIhCTBylOT 0 HaHllX-JIll60 oc060 TJImeJIhIX yCJIOBIIJIX mUSHll HaCeJIeHIIJI 97.
B crrIICHe IIaTOJIOrUlJeCHUX HapymeHuM CHeJIeTa 60JIbmOe MeCTO 3aHIIMalOT
TpaBMaTIIlJeCHIIe IIoBpem):(eHUJI, BOSHIIHaBnme B xO)J,e BoeHHhIX CTOJIHHOBeHIID:.
Ho B OCTaJIbHOM naJIeOrraTOJIOrII'IeCHaJI cIITyall,IIJI cpe.o;II TarapD;eB He O:bwa
He6JIarorrpUJITHOM IIpll cpaBHeHUll C ll3BeCTHhIMll HaM MaTepIIaJIaMll rro )J,PY-
rIIM 3rroxaM II .o;pyrllM 3THUlJeCHUM rpyrrIIaM. MomHO ;'),yMaTb, lJTO He xyme
OHa 6hIJIa II y eBporreMCRUX CHII<pOB, XOTJI IIpll OTCYTCTBllll IIpJIMhIX Ha6JIlO-
):(eHUM TaHaJI MhICJIb OCTaeTCJI He)J,OHaSaHH:bIM rrpe)J,rrOJIOmeHlleM.
3ARJIIO'lEHIIE
IIpIIBe.o;eHHbIM 06sop rrOHaS:bIBaeT, 1J:TO, HeCMOTpJI Ha 06uJIue yme IIMelOm;ero-
CH MaTepUaJIa, B HarneM pacnOpJImeHIIU OTCYTCTByeT llH<popMaD;IIH, He06xo.o;II-
MaJI )J,:IH perneHUJI MHorllX BamHbIX BOIIpOCOB. He)J,ocTaTOlJHO IIOJIHbI )J,aHHbIe
o paHHUX 3Tarrax paSBIITllH aHTpOrrOJIOrUlJeCHOrO TIIna IIpUlJepHOMOpCRUX CI{lI-
<p OB , MaJI01J:IICJIeHH:bI cepUll caHOB Cpe)J,HeR ASUII II AJITaJI. IIpaHTII1J:eCHJI
TOJIbRO BbI60pOlJHYlO IIH<popMall,lllO M:bI llMeeM 0 CTpoeHllll CReJIeTa paSJIIIlJ-
HhIX CHII<po-caHcRux nJIeMeH. To, lJTO MhI SHaeM, rrO:IY IeHO He IIpU IIorrYJIJI-
ll,llOHH:bIX BhI60pHax (OT,L\eJIbIlhIe MOrUJIbHIIKH), a Ha OCHOBe paCCMOTpeHUJI
CYMMapHhIX cepIIM, OXBaThIBalOm;IIX 06mUpHhIe TeppllTopIIll. COBeprneHHO
eCTeCTBeHHO, lJTO II p;OOhITaJI TaHllM oopa30M CYMMa CBe.o;eHllM 0 rraJIeo.o;eMO-
rpa<p Ull U rraJIeOIIaTOJIOrlIll )J,peBHero HaCeJIeHIIJI CTpa.o;aeT MHorUMII np06eJIa-
MII. Bce 3TU IIp06eJl:bI II HenOJIHOTa HamllX sHaHMM B 06JIaCTII naJIeOaHTpono-
JIOrUll orpOMHoro CHII<po-capMaTcHoro Mupa B mI1pOHOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa MoryT
OhITb IIpeO,L\OJIeHhI TO:IbRO B xO)J,e p:aJIhHellrneM a pxeoJIOrM1JeCHOM pa60ThI-
paCHorrOH Ha CHOC RpyrrHhlx MOrIIJIbHIIHOB Ha paSHbIX TeppUTOpUJIX C rrOJIHbIM
C60POM IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrII1J:eCHOrO MaTepIIaJIa. Tor,L\a MomHO 6Y)J,eT rrepeMTII
II H Oll,eHHe reHeTU1J:eCKHX pa3JIUlJIIM Mem)J,Y oTL(eJIbHhIMll rrorryJIJIll,IIJIMII, OII-
pe,L\eJIJIJI reHeTIIlJeCRUe MapHephI Ha CReJIeTe, HalJaJIO lJeMY (HO rrOHa B CyM-
MapHhlx BhI60pHax) rrOJIOmUJIll pa60nI M. B. IIepeBoslJllHoBa 98.
1 CM., Hanp.: MU/LblW8 (fl. H. JIecocTenL PycCKoii paBHHHLI. M., 1950; Oil 3/Ce. IIpHPOA-
HLIe 30HbI CCCP. M., 1977.
2 MU/LblW8 (fl. H. PYKOTBopHble JIaHAmacIJTbI. PaCCKa3 06 aHTponoreHHLIx KOMIIJIeKcax.
M., 1978.
:! TpH COBpeMeHHbIX 0630pa Ha pa3HbIX CHHXpOHHbIX cpe3ax CM.: Xaaa1l08 A. M. Co-
IJ;HaJIbHaH HCTOpIIH CRHcpOB. OCHOBHbIC np06JIeMbI pa3BHTIIH APeJJHIIX ROqeBHIIKOB eB-
pa3IIiicKlIX cTeneii. M., 1975; Maplw8 r. E. ROqeBHIIKH A3IIII. CTPYKTypa X03HiicTBa
H 06m;ecTBeHHoii opraHH3aIJ;HH. M., 1976; Khazanov A. Nomads and the outside world.
Cambridge, 1984.
4 BC/LUlWli08a M. C. IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrHH IIpYTcKo-,J:IHecTpoBcKoro MemAypeqLH. M., 1975.
5 Me/LIOK08a A. If. CKHcfJIDI H cfJpaKIIiicRHii: MHp. M., 1979. C. 250.
I; PyiJellKO C. If. RYJILTypa HaCeJIeHHH I'opHoro AJITaH B cKHcfJcKoe BpeMH. M.; JI., 1953;
Oil 3/Ce. RaJILTypa HaCeJIeHHH IJ;eHTpam,Horo AJITaH B cRlIcfJcKoe BpeMH. M.; JI., 1960.
7 rpSla1l08 M. n. IIa3bIpbIKcKIIii KypraH. M.; JI., 1937; Oil 3/Ce. IIepBLIii: IIa3bIpbIKcRlIii:
RypraH. JI., 1950.
8 KUCe/Le8 C. B. ,J:IpeBHHH IICTOpIIH IOmHoii CH6HpH. M., 1951.
237
1
I
9 g .aeH06a H. D. IIpOllcxomp;emle II paHHHH IICTOpliH ImeMeH TarapcRoH RYJIbTypbI.
M., 1967; MapTb Ho6 A. If. JIecocTenHaH TarapcRaH RYJIbTypa. HOBOCH6IIpCR, 1979.
10 HOBeHrnaH CBop;Ra naMJITHHROB: [(b a.aaco6 D. P. )J,peBHHH Tyna (01' HeOJIIiTa .[(O IX B.).
M., 1979. .
11 A.an;cee6 B. II. OCHoBHbIe 3TanbI IICTOpHH aHTpOnOJIOrlI'leCRIIX THnOB TYBbI II COB.
3THorpaqmH. 1962. M 3; OH 3/Ce. KpaTRoe 1I3JIOmeHIIe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlI1I TYBbI B
CBH31I C IICTOplI'leCRIIMIi BonpocaMIi II AHTpOnOJIOro-3ROJIOrH'leCRHe IICCJIep;OBaHIiJI B
TYBe. M., 1984.
12 TOXMaH If. If. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'leCRlIe MaTeplIaJIbI 1I3 nJIIITO'lHbIX MOrliJI 3a6aHRaJIbH II
C6. MY3eH aHTpOnOJIDrlI1I II 3THorpaqmH AH CCCP. M.; JI., 1958. T. 18; MaMoHo6a H. H.
K aHTpOnOJIDrlI1I rYHHOB 3a6ailI\aJIbH (no JlIaTeplIaJIaM MorlIJIbHIIRa qepeMyxoBaj[
nap;b) II PacoreHeTII'leCRlIe npOn;eCCbl B 3THH'leCROII IICTOpHIi. M., 1974.
13 Or;.aaOHur;06 A. II. 8noxa nepBo6bITH0061I\IIHHOrO CTpOH Ha TeppliToplI1I EYPHT-MoH-
roJI1I1I II HCTOpIIJI EYPHT-MoHrOJIbCROii ACCP. YJIaH-Y;:t,;), 19,)4. 'f. 1; OH :JIce. fplIno.[{bI
3a EaHRaJIOM II COB. apXeOJIOrIiH. 1959. M 3; [(oHo6a.ao6 II. B. XYHHY B 3a6aImaJIbe
(norpe6aJIbHbIe naMHTHlIIm). YJIaH-Y.[{3, 1976.
14 BozoaH06 A. II. 0 MOrliJIaX CRH«I>o-capMaTCROH cnOXIi B IIoJITaBcROH ry6epHIIII II 0
RpaHIIOJIOrlI1I CRII«I>OB II AHTpOnOJIOrlI'leCRaJI BbICTaBRa 1879 ro.[{a. M., 1880. (];l3B. O-Ba
JII06HTeJIeII eCTeCTB03HaHIIH, aHTpOnOJIOrHII II 3THorpaqmlI; T. XXXV, 'l. 1, Bbill. 1-3).
15 ll.e6elf T. (/J. IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorHH CCCP II Tp. IIH-Ta 3THorpa«I>1I1I AH CCCP. H. C.
M.; JI., 1948.
16 Schlitz A. Die Grabhiigel auf dem Gute Maritzyn II Prahist. Ztschr. 1913. Bd. 5, H. 1/2.
17 [(OHoyr;Topo6a T. C. AHTpOnOJIOrliH .[{peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH YRpaIIHbI. M., 1972.
18 TUHa6ypz B. B., TpoifiuMo6a T. A. IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorHH Cpep;Heii A31I1I. M., 1972. TaM
me II 61I6JIliorpaqmH 60JIee paHHIIX pa60T.
19 C I., Hanp.: A.aer;cee6 B. II. AHTpOnOJIOrliH aH;J:pOHOBCROii RYJIbTYPbl II COB. apXeOJIOrlIlI.
1967. M 1.
20 ll.e6elf T. (/J. IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrliJI CCCP; A.aer;cee6 B. II. IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrliH XaRa-
CIIII 3nOXli meJIe3a II C6. MY3eH aHTpOnOJIOrliH II 3THOrpa«I>1I1I AH CCCP. M.; JI., 1961.
T.20.
21 [(oaUHlfe6 A. T. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'leCRlIii COCTaB II npOHcxomp:eHlIe HaCeJIeHHH TarapCROII
RYJIUYPbI. JI., 1977.
22 Me.aIOr;06a A. If. IIOCeJIeHlIe II MOrlIJIbHIIR CRH«pCRoro BpeMeHII Y C. HIiROJIaeBRa.
M., 1975.
23 Be.aur;aHo6a 111. C. YRa3. CO'l.
24 [(OHoyr;Topo6a T. C. ¥Ra3. CO'l.
25 Bepea06elf ll.. T. P03RonRII RypraHHoro JlIOrlIJIbHHRa enOXH 6POH31I Ta cRi«I>cbRoro 'lacy
B c. KYT II ApxeoJIori'lHII naJlIbHTRII YPCP. KnIB, 1.960. T. 9.
26 Konduktorova T. S. The ancient population of the Ukraine (from the mesolithic age
to the first centuries of our era) II Anthropology. Brno. 1974. T. XII, N 1-2.
27 Tpar;o6 B. H. CRH«pCRlIe norpe6eHHH Ha HIiROnOJIbCROM I\YpraHHOM nOJIe II MaTepHa-
JIbl IICCJICp:OliaHIiH no apxeOJIorlI1I CCCP. M., 1962. M 115. Ta 1 me CM. YRa3aHliH Ha
npep;rneCTBYIOlI\lIe pa60TbI. CM. TaRme: OH 3/Ce. CRlI«I>bI. M., 1971.
28 [(OHoyr;Topo6a T. C. HaCeJIeHHH HeanOJIH CRII«I>cbRoro 3a aHTpOnOJIori'lHRMIi p;aHlI-
MII II MaTepiaJIIi 3 aHTpOnOJIorii YRpaiHU. KIIIB, 1964. BHn. 3.
29 3UHe6U't T. II. O'lepRII naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlI1I YRpalIHbI. KneB, 1967.
30 B cnlICRe JIIiTepaTypbl R RHlIre r. II. 3IIHeBII'l 3TOii CTa'fblI HeT.
,31 B.flBbMUTUHa M. If. 30JIOT06aJIROBClmH MOrIIJIbHIIR. KlIeB, 1972. TaM me CM. 0630P
II 6H6JIliorpa«I>IIIO npep;rnecTBYIOII\IIX pa60T.
32 [(OHoyr;Topo6a T. C. IIi3Hi cRi«I>1I Ha HimHboMY )J,Hinpi (3a aHTpOnOJIori'IHIIMIi MaTe-
piaJIaMIi 30JIOT06aJIRiBCbRDrO MOrlIJIbHIIRa) II MaTepiaJIIi 3 aHTpOnOJIorii YRpaiHII.
KIIIB, 1971. Bbill. 5. ]i[Hp:IIBIIP:yaJIbHbIe H3MepeHIIH ony6JIIiROBaHbI: Konduktorova T. S.
The ancient population of the Ukraine.
33 Schlitz A. Die Schadel aus dem Xekropole von Nikolajewka II Prahist. Ztschr. 1913..
Bd, 5, H. 112.
J4 Cb MOH06U't 9. A. Paclwlllm. HIiROJIaeBCRoro MOrHJIbHIIRa Ha HlImHeM )J,Henpe II RpaT.
co061I\. ]i[H-Ta apXeOJIOrliH AH CCCP. 1969. BMn. 119; OH 3/Ce. KYJIbTypa n03p;HIIX CRII-
«POB H 'IepHHXOBCRlIe naMHTHIiRIi B HHmHeM IIplIp:HenpoBbe II IIp06JIeMM CRII«I>cRoii
apxeOJIorlIli. M., 1971.
35 KOHoyr;ropo6a T. C. 1IJ1I31I'leCRHii Tlin JIIOp;eH HlImHero IIplIp;HenpOBbJI Ha py6eme Ha-
rneH 3pM (no MaTepHaJIaM MOrlIJIbHIIRa HIiROJIaeBRa-Ka3an;Roe). M., 1979.
'36 06 3TOM cnen;lIaJIbHO CM.: my.ablf II. H. MaB30JIeii HeanOJIH CRII(fJcRoro. M., 1953.
37 BozoaH06a H. O. MOrlIJIbHIIR I CT. P;O H. e.- III CT. H. e. 6iJIJI C. 3aBiTHe Eax'llicapaii-
CbRoro paHOHY. KIIIB, 1963.
38 3iHe6u't T. II. )J,o aHTpOnOJIorii MOrlIJIbHIIRa 6iJIH C. 3aBiTHe B KpHMY II MaTepiaJIIi 3
aHTpOnOJIOri'i YRpaiHII. KHiB, 1971. BMn. 5.
238
39 pe6elj 1'. (fJ. qepena 1f3 RypraHOB Cpe).l,HerO IIOlIOHbH II HaCeJleHlfe Cpe).l,HerO )J;OHa B
CRIf.pCROe BpeMH. M., 1969.
40 JIu6epo6 II. p. CaBpOMaTbI JIII ClipMaTbI? II HaCeJIeHlIe Cpe).l,HerO )J;OHa B CRII.pCROe
BpeMH.
41 00 :3TOM CM.: Kp ynHo6 E. H. 0 nOxo).l,ax CRII.pOB 'Iepe3 RaBRa3 II BOnpOCbI CIDI.pO-
CapMaTCROH apXeOJIOrlili. M., 1954; OH 3/Ce. )J;peBHHH IICTOpliH CeBepHoro RaBRa3a.
M., 1960; BUHozpaoo6 B. B. l(eHTpaJIbHbIii II CeBepo-BoCTO'IHbIH RaBRa3 B CRII.pcRoe
Bpmur (VII - IV BeRa AO H. 3. BOnpOCbI 1I0JIIITIf'IeCROII IICTOplIll, 3BOJIIOJJ;IIIf RYJIbTYP
II 3THOreHC3a). I'p03HbIH, 1972; l1.n.bUHCIWR B. A., TepeH03/CKUH A. 11. CRII.pIIH VII-
IV BB. ).1,0 H. 3. RIICB, 1983; KYK.n.uHa H. B. 8THorpa.pIIH CRII.p1I1i no aHTII'IHbnI IICTO'I-
HIiRaM. JI., 1985.
42 To.n.cr06 C. II. IIpliapaJIbCRlIe CRII.pbI II Xope3M II COB. 3THorpa.pIIH. 1961. M 4; On
3/Ce. IIo ).I,peBHIIM ).I,eJIbTaM ORca II HRcapTa. M., 1962; OH 3/Ce. CpCAHea3IIaTCRIIe CRII.pbI
B CBCTe HOBeIIIIIIIX apXCOJIOrlI'IeCIDIX OTRpbITIiR II BCCTH. APCBHCIl IICTOplIli. 1963. .N2 2.
43 To.n.cr06 C. II., I1ruHa M. A. CaRli HII30BbeB Cb!p).l,apbli (no MaTeplIaJIaM TarliCRe-
Ha) II COB. apXCO.iIOrllH. 1966. ,1\'£ 2; BUutHe6cKaR O. A., llruna Jf. A. PaHHIIC caRll
IIpliapaJIbH II IIpoOJICMbI CRII.pCROll apxcoJIorlI1I. M., 1971. (MaTeplIaJIbI II IIccJIe).l,. no
apxcoJIorIIII CCCP; .N2 177).
u TpofjjUMo6a T. A. IIpliapaJIbCRlIe caIDI: (RpaHIIOJI. O'IepR) II MaTeplIaJIbI Xope3McRoR
3RcneAIIJJ;IIII. M., 1963. BbIII. 6; OHa 3/Ce. PaHHIIC caIDI IIpliapaJIbH no AaHHbIM naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrlI1I II Anthropos N. S. Brno, 1967. N 11.
45 BUutHe6CKaR O. A. RyJIbTypa caRCRIIX nJIeMeH HM30BbeB CbIPAapbli B VII-V BB. AO
H. 3. no MaTepMaJIaM "YHrapaRa II Tp. Xope3M. apXeOJI.-3THorp. 3RClIeAIIJJ;MII. M.,
1973. T. 7.
46 g epnUK06 C. C. PaOOTbI BOCTO'IHo-Ra3aXCTaHCROH apXeOJIOrM'IeCROH 3RcncAIIJJ;1I1I B
1956 r. II RpaT. co06ru;. I1H-Ta MCTOpMII MaTeplIaJIbHOll RYJIbTypb!. 1959. BbIll. 73.
47 TUH86ypz B. B. R aHTpOnOJIOrll1I paHHIIX RO'IeBHMROB BOCTO'IHOrO Ra3aXCTaHa ('Iepe
na V-IV BB. ).1,0 H. 3. 1I3 MOrlIJIbHIIRa "YCTb-BYROHb) IIAHTponoJIorM'1ecRIIH COOpHIIK,
III. M., 1961. (Tp. I1H-Ta 3THorpa.pIIM AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 21).
48 BauH6epz B. 11. RyrocallcRaH RyJIbTypa paHHero iRCJIC3HOrO BCRa B IIplicapaRaMbIIll-
CROR ).I,eJIbTe AMYAapbli II "Y cneXM Cpe).l,Hea3IIaTCROR apXCOJIor1I1I. JI., 1975. BbIll. 3.
49 BaUH6epz B. 11. IIaMHTHIiRH RyIOcallCRoH RYJIbTypbI II RO'IeBHIIRIi Ha rpaHMJJ;ax Xo-
pe3Ma M., 1979. (Tp. Xope3M. apXeOJI.-3THOrp. 3RCne).l,III(IIM; T. 11).
50 HrUHa M. A. 01' pCAaRTopa II TaM iRe.
51 TporfJUM06a T. A. RpaHMOJIOrH'1eCRMe MaTeplIaJIbI 1I3 MOrlIJIbHIIRa T)'MeR-RM'1MAiRMR II
COB. 3THorpa.pllH. 1974. .N2 5; Ona 3/Ce. qepcna 1I3 norpeocHlIi'r RyIOcaHcRoH RyJIbTY-
pb! B :lIOrIlJIbHIIKaX TyMeR-RII'lIiAiRIiR n TapbIM-RaH II RO'ICllHlIliII Ha rpaHImax Xo-
pC3:1Ia.
52 BepHutraM A. H. I1CTopIiRo-apXeOJIOrlI'ICCRlIe O'IepIDI l(eHTpaJIbHOrO THHb-IIIaHH M
IIaMlIpO-AJIaH II MaTepMaJIbI If IICCJIC).I,oBaHIiH no apxeoJIorlI1I CCCP. M.; JI., 1952.
M 26.
53 TUH86ypz B. B. MaTeplIaJIbI R naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrMIi BOCTO'IHbIX palIOHOB CpeAHeH A31I1I
(rYHHbI II caIDI THHb-IIIaHH, AJIaH II lOiRHoro IIaMnpa) II RpaT. COOoru;. IIH-Ta 3THO-
rpa.pMM AH CCCP. 1950. Bb!II. 11.
M JIur6uHcKuU B. A. ApeBHlIe RO'IeBHMRII «RPblIIIII MlIpa». M., 1972.
55 BepHUf.raM A. H. CaRli IIa1'lHpa//BecTH. JIPCBHCii MCTOplIli. 1956..N2 1.
56 Ba6aHcKaR To T., 3aonenpo6cKuU EO. A. ApXeOJIOrlI'IeCRIIC MCCJICAOBaHIiH A. H. BCpHIII-
TaMa Ha I1aMlipe B 1956 r. II ApXeOJIOrH'1eCRHe paooTbI B Ta).l,iRMRIICTaHe B 1956 r.
CTaJIIIHaOaA, 1959. BmI. 4.
57 TUH86ypz B. B. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'ICCRan xapaRTepMCTluta caROB lOiRHoro IIaMHpa II RpaT.
coooru;. I1H-Ta IICTOplI1I MaTCplIaJIbHOH RYJIbTYPbI. 1960. BbIII. 80.
58 KURrKUHa T. II. MaTeplIaJIbl R IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrlI1I TaAiRIIRIiCTaHa. AYIllaHoe, 1976.
59 TpR8H06 M. II. PaCROIIRIi RHHiRCCRoi'r MOrliJIbI Ha AJITae II qeJIOBcR. 1928. .N2 2/4.
60 BapK06a JI. JI. RypraH IIIMoe II BOlIpOCbI ero ).I,aTllpOBRII II ApXeOJIOrM'IeCRIIR COOpHIiR
JI., 1978. Bb!II. 19; OHa 3/Ce. IIorpeoeHIIH ROHeH B RypraHe IIIn6e II TaM iRe. 1979.
BbIll. 20; OHa 3/Ce. RypraH IIIlIoe. IIpeAMeTbI MaTeplIaJIbHOH RYJIbTYPbI 1I3 IIorpeoaJIL-
HOll RaMepbIIITaM iRe. 1980. BbIll. 21. TaM iRe OIlOJIMOrpa.pMJI IIpe).l,mecTBYIOru;HX
paOOT.
61 A.n.eKcee6 B. II. IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrMH AJITaJI 3IIOXH iReJIe3a II BOllp. aHTpOnOJIOrlIli.
1958. M 1.
62 Kuce.n.e6 C. B. "YRa3. CO'I.
63 Ky6ape6 B. p. HOBbIe HaXO).l,RII 3noxli paHHIIX RO'IeBHIIROB B I'OPHOM AJITae 110'IepRM
COI(MaJIbHO-3ROHOMFI'IeCROll II RyJIM'YPHOH iRII3HM CIiOliplI. HOBOCIIOHPCR, 1972; 01£ 3/Ce.
PaooTbI B I'opHOM AJITae II ApXeOJIOrM'1eCRlIe OTIqJbITIIH, 1975 r. M., 1976.
64 A.n.eKcee6 B. II. IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrliH AJITaJI 3noXH meJIe3a.
239
65 AJleKCeee B. II. R naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOnm I'opHoro AJITaH B 3IIOXY paHHero meJIe3a II
ApxeoJIonm CeBepHOii H l(eHTpaJIbHOii A3HII. HOBOCHOHPCK, 1975.
66 l{e6elf T. (fl. ElI:\e pa3 0 6eJIOKYPOH pace B l(eHTpaJIbHOH A3HIIIICoB. A3I1H. 1931.
J¥!! 5/6; AJleKCeee B. II. AHTpOIIOJIOrH'!ecKlie p;aHHbIe 0 JIOKaJIbHbIX pa3JIH'!IIHX Hace-
JIeHHH TarapcKoH KYJIbTypbI II IIepB06bITHaH apXeOJIOrHH CHOHpH. JI., 1975; Koaun-
lfee A. T. ¥Ka3. co'!.
67 Cp., HalIp.: If Jlenoea H. D. ¥Ka3. co'!.; MapTbmoe A. If. R BOIiPOCY 0 npollcxomp;eHHII
TarapcKoH KYJIbTypbI II ];I3B. JIa6. apxeoJI. HCCJIep;. ReMepoBo, 1967. Bbm. 1; On :JICe.
COBpeMeHHble np06JIeMbI 113yq:eHIIH TarapcKon KYJIbTypbI II TaM me. 1970. BbIII. 2.
68 Koaunlfee A. T. Ka3. co'!.
69 B p;OIIOJIHeHHe K paOOTaM, YKa3aHHbIM B IIpHMe'!. 11, C)I.: AJ!eKceee B. II. IIaJIeoaH-
TpOIIOJIOrH'!eCKHi'1 MaTepHaJI CKHq,CKOro H capMaTCKoro BpeMeHH C Tep-
pHTOpHIi TYBbI II ¥'!eH. 3alI. TyBIiH. HaY'l.-HCCJIep;. HH-Ta JI3bIKa, JIIiT. H HCTOPHH. RbI-
3bIJI, 1959. BbIli. 7. ¥Ka3aHHe Ha HaJIH'!He pa3HbIX THIIOJIOrH'!eCKH '!epclIoB B Kypra-
Hax CKHq,cKoro BpeMeHH cop;epmHTcH yme B IIepBOH paooTe IIO IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrHII
TYBbI: I{ e6elf T. (fJ. R IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrHII TYBbI II RpaT. COOOII:\. ];IH-Ta 3THorpaq,HII
AH CCCP. 1950. Bbm. 10.
70 0IIy6JIHKOBaHbI: AJ!eKceee B. II., l{e6elf T. (fJ. RpaHHOMeTpHH. MeTop;HKa aHTpOIIOJIO-
rH'!eCKHx HCCJIep;OBaHlIH. M., 1964.
71 06cymp;eHHe IIpOOJIeMbI CM.: AJ!eKceee B. II. reorpaq,IIH '!eJIOBe'!ecKHX pac. M., 1974.
72 3Ha'leHHe IIpH3HaKOB, xapaKTepH3YIOII:\HX YIIJI0lI:\eHHOCTb JIHn;eBOro CKeJIeTa B roplI-
30HTaJIbHoi'1 IIJlOCKOCTH, P;JIH p;narHOCTHI,H MOHrOJlOHp;HOro HmllIJleKCa npOJ;e"'lOHCTpH-
pORaHO IJO MHDrHX paOOTax. 06Il!Hii HTDr CM.: l{e6elf T. (fJ. OrrbIT KpaHHmIeTpH'!ecKoro
OlIpep;eJIeHHH P;OJIH MOIITOJIOIIp;HOro KOMIIOHeHTa B CMemaHHbIX rpYlinax HaCeJIeHIIH
CCCP II I1pOOJIeMbI aHTpOIIOJIOrHII 11 HCTOplI'leCKOH 3THorpaq,HH A3HII. M., 1968.
73 0030p pa3Ho06pa3HbIX To'!eK 3peHHH Ha 3THoreHe3 CKHq,OB H YKa3aHHH Ha HCTO'!HII-
KH H JIHTepaTYPY CM.: Minns E. Scythians and Greeks. Cambridge, 1913; PocToe-
lfee M. If. CKHq,HH H Bocliop. RpHTH'!ecKoe o603peHlle IIaMHTHHKOB JIHTepaTYPHbIX H
apXeOJIOrII'leCKII.l(. IIr., 1925; TpaKoe B. H., MeJ!IOKoea A. If. 00 3THH'!eCKHX H RYJIb-
TYPHbIX pa3JIII'lHHX B CTenHblX II JIeCOCTelIHbIX OOJIaCTHX eBpolIellCKOJi 'IaCTII CCCP B
cKIIq,Clwe Bpe:\IH II BO:lpOCbl cKHq,o-capMaTcKoll apXeOJlOrlIlI. M.. 1954; IIo3pe6oea H. H.
COcToHHlIe .rpOOJJeM CKlfq,o-capMaTcRoii apXeOJIOrllII R KOHq,epeHI IIIf H];IMR AH CCCP
1952 r. II BOlIpOCbI CKllq,o-capMaTcKoi'! apXeOJIOrHH; Xaaalwe A. M. YKa3. co'!.; Paee-
CKUU If c. ()qepKH Hp;eOJIOrHH CKHq,o-caKcKIIX IIJIeMeH: OlIblT peKOHCTPYKn;HH CKIlq,-
CKOi'1 MHq,OJIOrlili. M., 1977; PbL6aKoe B. A. repop;oToBa CKHq,IIH: ];IcT.-reorp. aHaJIH3.
M., 1979.
74 TpaKoe B. H. CKHq,bI; On :JICe. PaHHHll meJIe3Hbli'1 BeK (KYJIbTYPbl 3arrap;HOH II IOro-
BOCTO'!HOH EBpOlIbI). M., 1977; ApTa.ltonoe M. If. RHMMepIIHn;bI H CKHq,bI (01' IIOHBJIe-
HHH Ha HCTopH'!ecKoH apeHe p;o KOHn;a IV B. p;o H. 3.). JI., 1974.
75 Rpmw YKa3aHlIOi'! Bb=e CBOP;KH B. B. fHll30ypra H T. A. Tpoq,m.lOBoH, IIO IIaJIeOaH-
TpOnOJIOrliH Cpep;HeH A3HH CM.: AJ!eKceee B. II. IIpoHcxomp;eHHe Hapop;OB RaBKa3a:
(RpaHIIOJI. HCCJIep;.). M., 1974.
76 Tporfiu.ltoea T. A. HeOJIIITII'!ecKHe '!epena KeJIbTeMIIHapcKoH KYJIbTypbI H3 MOrHJILHH-
Ka TYMeK-RH'!IIp;mHR B ceBepHoH TYPKMeHIIIII18THorpaq,HH II apXeOJIOrHH Cpep;HeH
A3HH. M., 1979.
77 KURTKuna T. II. qepelia 3IIOXH 6pOH3LI C TeppHTopHH IOro-3alIap;Horo Tap;mIlKHcTa-
Ha /I MaHp;eJIbmTaM A. M. IIaMHTHIiKH 3nOXH 6POH3bI B IOmHOM Tap;mIlKlicTaHe. JI.,
1968. (MaTepHaJILI II IICCJIep;. IIO apXeOJIOrHH CCCP; J¥!! 145).
78 CM. 00 3TOM: Debetz G. Paleoanthropologie de l'Eurasie septentrionale II VI Congr.
Intern. des sci. prehist. et protohist.: AOKJI. COB. p;eJIeran;HH. M., 1962.
79 Hall60JIee IIOJIHaH CBO)J;Ka AaHHbIX: KuceJ!ee C. B. ¥Ka3. co'!. .
80 RpOMe KHIIr C. ];I, Pyp;eHKo, YKa3allHblX B npHMe'l. 6, CM.: PyoenKo C. If. I'0pHOaJITaH-
CRIIe HaxoP;RH H CKHq,LI. M.; JI., 1952; On :JICe. ];ICKYCCTEO AJITaH II IIepep;Hei'1 A3IIH
(cepep;Hlla I TblCH'!eJIeTHH p;o H. 3.). M., 1961; On :JICe. CHoIIpcKaH KOJIJIeKn;IIH IIeT-
pa I II ApXeOJIOrliH CCCP. CEOP; apXeOJIOrH'!ecRlIx HCTO'!HIIKOB, A 3-9. M.; JI., 1962;
AKuUlee K. A. RypraH ];ICCLIK. ];ICKYCCTBO caROB Ra3aXCTaIm. M., 1978; TpRanoe M. II.
ApmaH. l(apcKHH KypraH pallHecRIIq,cKoro Bpe:\IeIlIl. JI., 1980.
81 BUTT B. O. JIomap;H I1a3LlpbIKCKliX KyprallOB II COB. apXeOJIOrHH. M.; JI., 1952. T. 16.
Cp.: Il,aJ!Kun B. If. R II3yq:eIlIIIO JIOmap;eH H3 KypralloB AJITaH II MaTepllaJILI H IICCJIe-
p;OBaHliH IIO apXeOJIOrHH CCCP. M., 1952. J¥!! 24.
82 l{e6elf T. (fJ. IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrliH CCCP.
83 AJ!eKceee B. II. IIaJIeOallTpOIIOJIOrliH XaKaCHli 3IIOXH meJIe3a.
84 Koaunlfee A. T. ¥Ka3. CO'!.
85 CM., Hanp.: lfJlenoea H. D. CKIIq,CRIIH OJIeHb II MaTepHaJIbI II HCCJIep;OBaIlHH IIO apxeo-
JIOTlIH CCCP. M., 1962. J¥!! 115; ApTaJownoe M. If. CORpOBIIlI:\a caKOB.
86 AJ!eKceee B. II. IIaJIeop;eMorpaq,HH CCCP II COB. apXeOJIOTIIH. 1972. J¥!! 1.
240
87 Koauulfe6 A. r. ]J;eMOrpaqJlIH TarapCKllX MOrliJILHIIKOB II COB. 3THorpaqmH. 1971. J¥!! 6.
88 Konduktorova T. S. The ancient population of the Ukraine; KouiJYKTopo6a T. C. IIJII-
SHqeCKIIH: THrr JIIop;eH: HHamero IIpHp;HenpoBLH Ha py6e>Ke HameH: 3pLI.
89 KUSlTKuua T. II. MaTeplIaJIbI K rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHII Tap:>KIIKIICTaHa.
90 Koauulfe6 A. r. ¥Kas. COq.
91 JIUT6UUCKUU B. A. ¥Kas. COq. C. 182.
92 TepoiJoT. IICTOpliJI B P;eBHTIi KHlIrax. 31., 1972. C. 209.
93 ll.e6elf r. rJJ. IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorliH CCCP; KouiJYKTopo6a T. C. AHTpOrrOJIOrliH p;peBHero
HaCeJIeHlI1I ¥KpalrHbI; Dua :J/Ce. IIJIISlIqeCKIIH: Tlirr JIIOp;eH: Hliamero IIplIp:HerrpoBbH Ha
py6eme Hamen 3pLI. CM. TaKme: ll. e6elf r. rJJ. 06 HsyqeHlI1I .pIISlIqeCKOrO paSBIITHH
p;peBHIIX Hapop:OB lITes. P;OKJI. Ha sacep;aHHIIX, rrOCBHm;. IIToraM nOJIeBbIX IICCJIep;.
1963 r. M., 1964. B 3TOH: CTaTLe nplIBep;eHLI p;aHHble 0 Bece p;peBHlIx norryJIHIJ;IIII, B TOM
qlICJIe CKII.pCKI1X, OCHOBaHHbIe Ha 3KCTparrOJIHIJ;1I1I BapUaIJ;lIll rrOrrepeqHbIX paS IepOB
p:JIIIHHblX KOCTen. l(1I.pPLI 3TII MorYT HMeTL JIlimb oplIeHTHpOBOqHOe SHaqeHlIe, TaK KaK
MeTO}], BCTpeqaeT cepbeaHble BoapameHIIII: C:1I.: A eKcee6a T. D., K06a euno B. 10.
MOp.pO.pYHKIJ;IIOHaJIbHaH xapaKTeplIcTHKa nocTKpaHlIaJILHOrO CKeJIeTa aaHaTCKIIX 3CKII-
MOCOB II IIaJIeoaHTporroJIorliH CH6Iqm. M., 1980.
94 Tuua6ype B. B. MaTepHaJILI K naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrliH BOCTOqHbIX paH:OHOB Cpep;HeH: AaHII.
C.89.
95 CM., Hmp.: CTamOK06U't K. B. PaCTIITeJIbHbIH: rrOKpOB BOCToqHOrO IIaMlIpa 113arr.
BcecolOs. reorp. O-Ba. H. C. M.; JI., 1949. T. 10; AeaxanSlnlf D. E. OCHoBHble rrp06JIeMLI
.plIalIqeCKOH: reorpa.plIloI IIaMlipa. ]J;ymaH6e, 1966. q. 2.
96 KouiJYKTop06a T. C. IIJHaIl'IeCKHH: THrr JIIOp;eH: HH>KHerO IIplIp;HerrpoBLH Ha py6e>Ke
Hamen 3pbI.
97 Pox uu ll.. T. BOJIeaHIi p:peBHlIx JIIOp;en (KOCTII JIIOp;eH: paaJIII'IHbIX 3rrox - HOpMaJIb-
HLle H naTOJIOrHqeCKH H3MeHeHHble). M.; 31., 1965; Koumuu T. A., Mupeaauao6 M. 3.
HeKoTopble aa60JIeBaHIIII y JIIOp;eii TarapcKon KyJIbTypbI II Mall. 31aG. apxeoJI. HCCJIep:.
ReMepoBo, 1967. Bbm. 1. B 3TOH: pa60Te ony6JIHKOBaHbI Ha6JIIOp;eHIIH H ceplien Ha
THcyJIbCKOrO MOrHJILHHKa, pacnOJIO>KeHHOro Ha TeppHTopHIi HLIHemHeH: ReMepoB-
CKOll 06JI.
98 IIepe6oa'tuKo6 D. B. Orrpep;eJIeHHe rpynn IqJOBH B HCKorraeMOM MaTeplIaJIe II Borrp.
aHTpOnOJIOrHII. 1975. BLm. 50; On :J/Ce. Onpep;eJIeHlre rpyrrn KpOBIi CHCTeMLI ABO y
HaCeJIeHHH eBpaaHncKIIx cTeneii I TLICIl'IeJIeTHH p;o H. 3.: ABTope.p. p;HC. ... KaHp;.
HCT. HayK. M., 1976.
HEROTOPbIE IIPOEJIEMbI IIPOJiICXOJRAEHIUI
EAJIRAPQEB JiI RAPA AEBQEB
B CBETE AAHHbIX AHTPOIIOJIOfJiIJiI
BBO]J;HbIE3AMEqAHHH
tlOrrpOChI, CBJISaHHhIe C llCrrOJIbSOBaHlleM aHTpOnOJIOrUlJeCHOrO MaTepUaJIa B
n,eJIJIX UCTOpII1J:eCROrO IICCJIe)J,OBaHUJI, C O)J,HOH CTOpOHhI, II BOSMomHOCTU 3THII-
lJeCHOM aHTpOrrOJIOrllU HaH BcnOMOraTeJIbHOM JilCTOpUlJeCHOH )J,IICll,llrrJIIIHbI-
C )J,pyroM, paCCMOTpeH:bI B CTaTbe r. $. Ae6eua, M. r. JIeBIIHa II T. A. Tpo-
<pIIMOBOM, Ha HOTOPYlO Bhlrne HeO)J,HOHpaTHO )J,eJIaJIIICb CChIJIHll. O)J,IIIIM lIS OC-
HOBH:bIX nOJIOmeHllM 3TOM CTaThII JIBJIHeTCJI 6eCCrropHhIM Tesuc 0 HaJIlllJIIII
HOCBeHHOM CBJISll Memp;y JIBJIeHIIJIMII IICTOplllJeCHOrO rrOpJI)J,Ha - RYJIbTypOM
II JIS:bIROM II aHTpOrrOJIOrUlJeCHUMll TllnaMU. PelJb ll)J,eT B )J,aHHOM CJIYlJae 06
UTpa1ReHIIll 06m;eCTBeHHO-IICTOplllJeCHUX rrpOll,eCCOB B <paHTax aHTpOnOJIOrIIll.
3Ha1J:eHIIe llCCJIe)J,OBaHIIJI aHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCHIIX oc06eHHOCTeM COBpeMeHHoro
HaCeJIeHIIJI MomeT 6hITb nOHasaHO Ha rrpllMepe HapO,L\OB ,l];arecTaHa. Corro-
CTaBJIeHUe paCOBoro Tllna )J,BYX HapO,L\HOCTeM TlOpHCHOM JIShIROBOM ceMbII-
HOraMll,eB II HyMbIROB IIOHaS:bIBaeT, lJTO nepBhIe JilMelOT B CBoeM COCTaBe sa-
MeTHYlO MOHrOJIOIIp:HYlO rrpllMeCb, B TO BpeMJI HaH y BTOphIX OHa nOJIHOCTbIO
OTCYTCTByeT '. IIoCHOJI:bRY 06a HapO)J,a npllHa)J,JIemaT H HlmlJaHCHOM rpynne
TlOpRCROH JI3bIROBOM ceMbII, CJIep;yeT npep;nOJIaraTb, lJTO IIX <pOpMupoBaHlle
241
I
CBJISaHO C 6JUI3HIIMII B 3THIIlJeCHOM OTHorneHUU TlOpHCKHMU HapO,L\HOCTJIMII
cpe)J,HeBeROBhJI. $aRT lIaJIll1J:IIH OT IeTJIIIBO BhlpameHHOM MOHrOJIOII)J,HOM npll-
MeCll B paCOBOM COCTaBe HOraMll,eB nOSBOJIJIeT IIpeArrOJIOmIITh, 1J:TO OHa 6hIJIa
He B MeHbrneM, eC.1JII He B 60JIl,rneM CTerrelIll BbIpameHa U Y I1X TlOpROHSbI1J:-
HhIX IIpe,L\HoB. A TaH HaH HYMbmIl xapaHTepII3ylOTCJI IIOJIHbIM OTCYTcTBueM
MOHrOJIOll)J,HOM npUMeCll, He OTJIIIlJaJICh B 3TOM OTHorneHIIII 0'1' CBOllX UHOJISbI1J:-
IIbIX coce)J,eM - )J,aprIIHll,eB, BOSMomHOCTb I1X nepexop:a Ha TIOpRCRyro pe Ih
6es BRJIlO1J:enUJI B CBOM COCTaB SHalJIITeJIbHOrO HOJIIIlJeCTBa TlOpRCRIIX nepe-
CeJIeHll,eB, T. e. IIYTeM rrpOCToro saIIMCTBOBaHIIJI nHoro JISLma, HameTCH BeCb-
Ma BepOHTHOM. TaROH BhIBOp: MomeT 6bITb CAeJIaH TOJIhRO Ha OCHOBaHIIU pac-
CMOTpeHIIH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCRUX p:aHHhIX II IIOJIHOCTblO corJIacyeTCJI C peSYJIb-
TaTaMII 3THorpa<pII1J:eCHOrO IICCJIe):(OBaHIIH, rOBOpJIm;ero 0 HYJIbTYPHOM 6JIII30-
CTII RYMhmOB H ,L\PYrIIM HapO)J,aM AareCTaHa 2.
Bce CHasaHiloe UJIJIIOCTpIlpyeT BOSMomHOCTII IICIIOJIbSOBaHIIJI aHTpOnOJIO-
rll1JeCHIIX )J,aHIIbIX B Ha1J:eCTBe IIOJIHOll,eHHoro I1CTOpII eCHoro llCT01J:HIIHa. OA-
HaHO IICTOpIIlJeCROe UCCJIe)J,OBaHlIe, B CBOlO 01J:epe)J,L, IIpe)J,'bJIBJIHeT aHTpOnOJIO-
rllII HeROTOphIe TpeooBaHIIH, OCHOBHhIM II3 HOTOpbIX JIBJIHeTCJI HOMrrJIeRCHOCTb
npUMeHJIeMhIX )J;JIJI perneHIIJI llCTOpIIlJeCRIIX BonpOCOB aHTpOnOJIOrU1J:eCRIIX
MaTepIIaJIOB. IIaJIeOaHTpOlIOJIOrIIlJeCRIli\ mTepIIaJI nOMoraeT YJIOBIITl> IISMeHe-
lIIle Tuna BO Bpe IeHIl H npII conOCTaBJIeHUH C p:aHHbIMII CMemHbIX ):(UCIJ,UIIJIIIH,
B nepBYlO OlJepe)J,b apXeOJIOrIIII, OTBeTIITb Ha Bonpoc 0 ero rrpU1J:MHaX, HO OH
B CIIJIy CBoeM cnell,u<plmII 6eCCIIJIeH IIPII perneHIIU IIp06JIeMhI IIpOIIcxom)J,eIUIH
COBpeMeHHhIX HapO)J,OB. MCCJIe)J,OBaHIIe COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIJI pIIcyeT Hap-
TIIHY paCIIpOCTpaHeHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCRIIX TIIIIOB IIO TeppIITopIIII, HO He
nOMoraeT IIPII orrpe,L\eJIeHIIU IIX )J,peBHOCTII II 3TaIIOB <pOpMIIpOBaHIIH. TaHIIM
06paSOM, TOJIl>HO corrOCTaBJIeHIIe Tex II ,L\pyrIIx p:aHHbIX )J,aeT BOSMomHOCTb
IIepeMTII 01' IICTOpIIII TIIIIOB H IIX TeppIITOpIIaJIbHoMy pacrrpe)J,eJIerrUlO B na-
CTOJIIIJ,ee BpeMJI II IlCIIOJIbSOBaTb IIOJIylJeHHyro llH<popMaIJ,IIlO )J,JIJI pasperneHUJI
UCTOpII1J:eCRllX BOIIpOCOB.
O):(HaRO IIpJIMOe corrOCTaBJIeHIIe o eHb saTpY)J,HIITeJIbHO lIs-sa paSHoro
xapaHTepa IIOJIY1J:aeMbIx: B 060llX CJIY1JaJIx CBe)J,eHuM. II03TOlHY B rrpoll,eCce
conOCTaBJIeHIIJI oc060e SHalJeHIIe rrpII06peTaeT uSY1JeHlle HpanUOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX
oc06eHHocTeM COBpeMeHHoro IIaCeJIeHIIH, HOTopoe JIBJIJIeTCJI MOCTOM npII
IIepexo)J,e 0'1' COMaTOJIOrII1J:eCROrO MaTepIIaJIa H IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCHoMy U
3Ha1J:IITeJIbHO YMeHbrnaeT ornII6HY rrpII IIX ROHHeRCIIII. R COmaJIeHIIlO, rnIIpo-
Hoe BBeneHIIe RpaHIIOJIOrII1J:eCHIIX MaTepIIaJIOB rro COBpeMeHHOMY IIJIII 6JIII3-
IWMY R COBpeMeHHOCTII HaCeJIeHIIlO B npaHTuRy aHTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCHIIX pa60T
HalJaJIOCh JIIlrnb B rrOCJIep:HIIe ,L\eCJITIIJIeTIIH, II B 3TOM 06JIaCTII MbI UMee1\1
eIIJ,e MHoro IIp06eJIOB. R lJIICJIY TaHIIX rrp06eJIOB OTHOCIITCJI II IIOlJTU nOJIHOe
OTCYTCTBIIe l\faTepIIaJIOB no RpaHUOJIOrIIU OaJIRapll,eB II RapalJaeBll,eB. II03TO-
My B p:aJIbHeMrneM IISJIOmeHUll MbI BhIHym)J,eHbI OrpaHUlJUTbCH paCCMOTpeHII-
eM COMaTOJIOrII1J:eCHIIX II naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrII1JeCRIIX )J,aHHbIX, npIIBJIeHaJI )J,aH-
HbIe 0 MaJI01J:IICJIeHHOM 6aJIRapCHOM cepUll JIIlrnb B RalJeCTBe BcnOMOraTeJIbHbIX.
COMA TOJIOI'lIqECI\:IIE ]J;AHHbIE
MSY1J:eHIIe <pII3UlJeCHUX oc06eHHocTeM HaCeJIeHIIJI RapalJaH II BaJIRapUll 6bIJIO
Ha1JaTO em;e B npOrnJIOM BeHe P. $. <pOH 8pHepToM, llsMepIIBrnllM nJITb Ha-
pa1J:aeBll,eB 3. B ROHll,e XIX II B HalJaJIe XX B. OHO 6hIJIO npop:OJImeHO pa60-
TaMll H. A. BbIpy60Ba \ M. II. IIaIITlOxoBa 5, C. COMMhe 6 II M. C. III,YHII-
Ha 7. O)J;HaHO MaJIOe ROJIll1J:eCTBO na6JIlO)J,eHIIM, UHaH IIO cpaBHeHIIlO C COBpe-
MeHHOM l\;IeTO,llJIHa II3MepeHIIH II OTCYTCTBIIe ,L\OCTaTOlJHO xoporno cpaBHIIMbIX,
242
T. e. c06pannhIX C C06JIlO,L\enUeM Tex me l\;IeTop:U1J:eCRIIX rrpueMOB, )J,annhIX IIO
,L\pyrllM napO)J,aM CeBepnoro RaBHasa )J,eJIalOT MaTepIIaJI, rrpe)J,CTaBJIennhIH
nepelJIICJIennhIMII IICCJIeAOBaTeJIJIMII, MaJIonpurOAHhIM ,L\JIJI yrJIy6:Iennoro
aIITporrOJIOrIPIeCHOrO anaJIII3a. II03TOMY B )J,aJIhneMrneM IISJIOmenIIU JI 6y)J,y
orrupaTbCH TOJIbRO IIa c06pannbIe B 1926-1928 1'1'. p:aIInhIe B. 11. JIeBuna 8,
lJ;OCTaTO IHO rrO:Ino OXBaT:bIBalOIII,IIe 3TnII1J:eCIHIe rpYIInhI CeBepnoro RaBHasa
II BrrOCJIeACTBIIII Borne)J,rnIIe B pJI)J, CBO)J,nbIX pa60T 9. IIoMIIMO nOJIHOThI,
60JIhrnIIM )J,ocTouncTBoM 3TIlX MaTepIIa:IOB JIBJIJIeTCJI TaRme TO, 1J:TO onn CO-
6panhI O)J,IIUM IICCJIe)J,OBaTe:IeM, T. e. npaRTU'IeCHII IIOJIHOCThlO cpaBnllMbI.
II pII paSrpanII1J:eHIIII MOnrOJIOII.o:nhIX II eBporreOIIp;nhIX rpyrrrr oc060e SHa-
lJenIIe npII06peTalOT omlCaTeJIbnbIe UJIIl Ra1J:eCTBenHbIe npIIsnaHII - llHTen-
CUBnOCTb TpeTlllJnOrO BOJIOCJIHOrO rrORpOBa, CTpoenIle rJIaSnOM 06JIaCTII.
IInTenCIIBnOCTb IIIIrMeHTall,llU II T. )J;. Ha TeppIITopIIII RaBRasa rrORaSaTeJIIl,
xapaRTepIISYlOIII,ue IIHTenCIIBnOCTb IIIIrMenTall,IIIl, TepJIlOT CBOlO ll,ennOCTb, TaR
RaH n01J:TU BeCb RaBHas BXO)J,IIT B 30ny paCIIpOCTpanenIIJI TeMnoIIIlrMenTIlpO-
BaHnbIX TIInOB, MaJIO OTJIIIlJalOm;IIXCJI B 3TOM OTnornenIIII 0'1' TIIrrIIlJHbIX Mon-
rO:IOIlp:OB. TeM 60JIhrnIIM IIHTepec llMeeT cpaBnenIIe IIO npIIsnaRaM, xapaRTe-
pII3YlOm;IIM pOCT TpeTU1JnOrO BOJIOCJInoro nOHpOBa II CTpoenIIe rJIaSnOM 06JIa-
CTII, B lJaCTnOCTn rrpUCYTCTBIIe CRJIa.o:HU Bepxnero BeRa.
B. 11. JIeBIIHhIM ony6JIUROBano rrpOll,eHTHOe COOTnornenIIe cy6"eHToB co
CJIa6bIM, Cpe,L\HIIM II ClWbnbIM paSBIITIIeM BOJIOCJInoro rrOHpOBa, 6es YHasaUllJI,
onpeAe.lIJIJICJI ml on Ha JIIlll,e IIJIll Ha TeJIe. TaH IIJIU IIHalJe, TpeTUlJHhIM BO-
JIOCJInOM IIORpOB na JIIlll,e, 01J:eBllp:no, JIBJIJIJICJI ocnOBnbIM MepIIJIOM OTneCenllJI
IICCJIe)J,OBaHHoro R TOll IIJIU llnOM HaTeropllII paSBIITIIH npIIsnalm. IIpII 060-
sna eHIIII cJIa60ro, cpep:nero II CIIJIhnOrO pOCTa BOJIOC COOTBeTCTBenno 6aJIJIa-
MU 1, 2 II 3 MbI IIOJIyqaeM Tpex6a:IJIbnylO rnHaJIY P;JIJI OIIpe)J,eJIeHIIJI 3'1'01'0
npII3n8Ra, npaB)J,a OT:IU1J:alOm;YlOCJI 0'1' COBpeMennOM IIJITIl6aJIJIbnOM, no ,L\alO-
III,YlO BOSMomnOCTb YJIOBUTb pa3Hllll,y Memp;y COIIOCTaBJIJIeMbIMII rpyrrIIaMII
rrpII BbIlJIICJIenUll cpe,L\nero 6aJIJIa IInTenCIIBHOCTU pOCTa TpeTII1JnOrO BOJIOCJI-
nom nOHpOBa. KapalJaeBll,bI II 6a:IRapll,hI OT1J:eTJIllBO ,L\II<p<pepenll,IIpYlOTCJI 0'1'
nOraMll,eB, C6JIllmaJICb C OCTaJIhnhIMU rpYIInaMU CeBepnoro RaBHasa:
RapaqaeBIJ;:bI
EaJIKapn;:bI
Horaiin;:bI
UUarrcyrn qCPHOMOpCKHe
IUarrcyrH KyoaHCKHe
EmepyXH
2,28 (208)
2,21 (153)
1,38(108)
2,20 (79)
2,21 (77)
2,28 (89)
qCMrYH
AOa).l,3CXH
EeCJJeHeeBl\:bI apMaBHpCKHe
BeCJJCHCeBn;:bI 3eJJCHQYKcKHe
RaOap).l,HHn;:bI
AOa3HH:bI
I'opcKHe eBpeH
2,25 (73)
2,36 (98)
2,16 (39)
2,13(63)
2,32 (82)
2,12 (94)
2,30 (57)
TaHIIM 06pasoM, paccMoTpenIIe paSBIITIIJI TpeTUlJnOrO BOJIOCJInoro nORpo-
Ba y pasnhlx napo)J;nocTeM CeBepnoro RaBHasa rrpIIBO,L\llT H BhIBOAY, 1J:TO
xapaRTepnbIM )J,JIJI HoralIll,eB oC:Ia6:IennhIM pOCT BOJIOC, JIBJIJIlOm;IIMCH CJIeACT-
BueM naJIII1JllJI B IIX COCTaBe saMeTHOM MOHrOJIOII)J,HOM IIpIIl\;IeCII, OTJIIl1JaeT IIX
ne TOJIhHO OT ap;DlreMCHIIX II Ha6app:IInCHUX, HO II 0'1' .o:pyrIIx TlOpRCHIIX 3'1'-
nII1J:eCRIIX rpYIIII CeBepnoro RaBRasa. BaJIRapll,hI II Rapa1J:aeBll,bI ne 06Hapy-
mIIB, alOT CJIeAOBaTe:IbnO, no 3TOMY npIIsHaRy CIIell,u<pU1JeCIHlX YHJIOnenllH B
naIIpaBJIenIIU npII6JIumenllJI H 60JIbrnOlI MOnrOJIOII)J,nOM pace.
COIIOCTaB:IeHIIe IIpOll,enTa HaJIII1JIIJI CHJIa)J,RII Bepxnero BeHa Menee IIORa-
SaTeJIhIIO, nOCHOJIbHY orry6JIUHOBalInhIe B. M. JIeBIIHhIM rro 3TOMY npIIsnaHY
)J,aHnhle, BU)J,UMO, He BIIOJIne 6esynpe1J:HbI B MeTo)J,IIlJeCROM OTnornenIIII. Op;-
HaHO II s)J;ecb MhI IIMeeM lJeTHlIe pa3JIIllJllJI Mem)J;y nOraIIll,aMU, C O)J;noM CTO-
243
1
.t
I
ponbI, II 6aJIHapll,aMll II HapalJaeBll,aMH - C )J,pyroii:
RapaTJ:aeB.qbI 46,4 (207) qeMrYH 53,3 (75)
Bammp.qbI 37,2(156) A6ap:3exH 31,7(101)
Horaii:l!bI 61,1 (108) BeCJIeHeeB.qbI 3eJIeHTJ:YKcRHe 56,9 (65)
IIlancyrH TJ:epHOMOpcRHe 26,0 (73) I a6apP:HH.qbI 53,1 (81)
IIlancyrn Ky6aHcRHe 41,0(78) A6a3HHbI 65,9(91)
Bmep:YXH 45,4(97) rOpcKlle eRpeH 13,3(60)
PaccMoTpeHue IIpOll,enTnOro pacnpe ellenUJI CHJIa RU BepxHero BeRa TaH-
me npuBo;a:IIT H SaRJIlOlJeIIUlO 06 OTCYTCTBIIll Y 6aJIHapll,eB II RapalJaeBll,eB
MOHrOJIOIIp:noM IIpIIMeCII, RaH II COIIOCTaBJIenlle IIX C ,L\pyrIIMU rpYIIIIaMII IIO
POCTY TpeTII1JHOrO BOJIOCJIHOrO IIORpOBa.
B Ra1J:eCTBe oom;ero BhIBo;a:a lIS Bcero CRasaHnoro MomeT 6hITb BbIp;BIInYTO
nOJIOmenIIe 0 TOM, lJTO Rapa1J:aeBll,bI II 6aJIHapll,bI, no;a:06no HYMhIRaM, nepe-
rnJIII na TlOpHCRyro pelJb, ne BHJIlO1JIIB B CBOM COCTaB 3HalJIITeJIbnOrO HOJIll-
1J:eCTBa TlOpROH3hIlJHhIX 3JIeMeHTOB. MHhIMII CJIOBaMII, TlOpHIISall,IIJI RapalJaeB-
ll,eB II 6allRapll,eB IIO JI3:bmy JIBIIJIaCb pesyJIbTaTOM I;:YJIhTypnoro BsaIIMo;a:eM-
CTBUH, a ne reneTII1JeCHOrO pO,L\CTBa C TlOpHCHIIMll napO)J,aMII cpep:neBeHOBbJI.
B. 11. JIeBuH IIIIcall, lJTO IIO anTpOrrOJIOrlllJeCRIIM OCOOeHlIOCTJIM Rapa'Ia-
eBll,bI U 6aJIHapll,hI He OTJIU1J:alOTCJI 0'1' )J,pyrllx BOCT01J:noa)J,bIreMCHIIX rpyrrII.
MMeBrnIIeCJI paSJIU1JIIH 6hIJIII OCTaBJIenhI 6es BnIIManIIJI lIs-sa neBOSMomnOCTH
OIIpe;a:eJIllTb IIX TaHCOnOMIIlJeCRUM panr BBll)J,y nOJIHOrO OTCYTCTBUJI cpaBHU-
MhIX MaTepUaJIOB IIO ocnOBnhIM 3TnII1J:eCHIIM rpYIIrraM 3aHaBHaSbJI. IIepBaH
ny6llIIHall,IIJI 3TIIX MaTepIIaJIOB, HaR II annbIe IIO napop:aM u:enTpaJIbHOM
1JaCTll CeBepnoro RaBHa3a, nOSBOJIUJIa BbIp:eJIIITb cBoe06pasnhIM <mpIITepeH-
CHUM» BapIIanT cpe;a:ll IInrymeM II oceTun, OTJIUlJalOm;IIMCJI OOllbrnIIMU Bellll-
lJIInaMII ,L\JIIInbI TeJIa II lJepeIIHOro YHa3aTeJIJI II HpynnhIMll paSMepal\;III
JIIIll,a 10. 06rnIIpnhIe MaTepUaJIhI no BceM rpY3IInCKHM rpYIInaM, c06paHHbIe
MnCTUTYTOM 3RcnepllMenTaJIbnoii Mop<pOJIOrIIII AH fpYSllnCIWM CCP, I10Ra-
samI, 1J:TO xapaHTepnhIM ,L\JIH «IIpUTepeHCRoro» BapuanTa ROMrrJIeHC IIpIIsna-
HOB B 60JIee 1J:MCTOM BU)J,e pacnpocTpanen B lOmnbIX II lOro-sarra;a:nbIX
paMonax II OXBaThIBaeT MHorue rpysHnCRlIe rpYIIIIbI, IIpomllBalOm;IIe na lOm-
HbIX CRJIOnaX RaBHascRoro xpe6Ta 11. B paooTax rpysIIncHnx anTpOnOJIOrOB
OH rroJIY1JIIJI naSBaHlIe RaBRaCIIonCHoro BapnanTa. ConOCTaBJIenIIe 6aJIRapll,eB
II Rapa1J:aeBll,eB C ropnhIMu OCeTIIHCHUMU II ceBeporpysllncHIIMII rpYIIIIaMu IIO
BbI)J,eJIJIlOm;llM IIX npIIsnaRaM - ,L\JIJilne TeJIa, rOJIOBHoMY YRasaTeJIlO II IllIIpII-
He JIIIll,a - paS'bJICHHeT HaIIpaBJIeHIIe pa3JIIIlJIIM, )J,II<p<pepenll,llpYlOm;UX rrep-
BhIX 0'1' ceBepOHaBHaSCHIIX napO,L\nOCTeM a6xaSO-a,L\bIreMCHOM JIShmOBOrr
rpyrrnhI.
IIo )J,JIune Tella ap:hlreMCHue napO HOCTII, neCMOTpJI Ha naJIlllJIIe OTp:eJIb-
nbIX cpaBHllTeJIbnO BhICOROpOCJIbIX rpYIIII, xapaHTepllSYlOTCJI cpe)J,nIIMll Be-
JIII1J:IIHaMII. Rapa1J:aeBll,T>I II 6aJIHapll,hI C6JIIImalOTCJI no 3TOMy npII3HaHy C
rrpe,'],CTaBIITeJIHMII <<RaBHaCIIonCHoro» BapIIaHTa:
IIlancynl TJ:epHOMOpcRHe 168,8 (80) RapaTJ:aeB.qbI
IIlancyrH Ry6aHcKHe 166,7 (80) BaJIRap.qbI
Bmep:yxH 165,9(99) CBaHbI
qeMrYH 168,2 (76) IIrnaBbI
A6ap:3cxH 165,5(101) XeBcypLI
Bec.rreHeeBI\LI apMaBHpCKHe 168,6 (38) TyrnIIHbI
Bec.rreHeeRl!bI 3eJIeHTJ:YRCRHe 166,0 (65) PaTJ:lII[.qbI
Ra6apP:HH.qbI 166,8(81) OceTHHbI HpaiPcRHe
A6a3HHbI 166,6(92) OCeTHHbI p:maBCRHe
Horaii:.qbI 164,5 (109)
244
167,9(211)
166,9 (314)
167,4(101)
168,7 (105)
168,3 (97)
168,8 (84)
169,3(103)
170,0 (102)
171,4(100)
AHaJIOrU1J:nbIe peSYJIbTaT:bI MhI IIOJIYlJaeM npn paCCMOTpenIIU BapITall,ull
rOJIOBnOrO yHasaTeJIJI. M rro 3TOMy IIpusnaHy 6aJIHapll,hI IT HapalJaeBll,bI C6JIII-
malOTCJI C rOpH:bIMIT oceTIIHCRIIMIT IT ceBeporpysunCHUMIT rpYIInaMIT, OTlJeTJIIT-
BO )J;II<p<pepenll,IIpYJICb 0'1' coce)J,HITX a)J;bIreMCHUX napop;nocTeii:
Illarrcyrrr qepHOMOpCKne
Illancyrrr Ry6aHCKne
BmeAyxn
qeMryn
A6aA3PxlI
BeCJ::crreeBIJ;IiI apMaBrrpCKne
BeCJieHeeBIJ;LI SeJIeHqYKCKlIe
Ra6apAIIHIJ;IiI
A(,aSHHLI
HoraifIJ;IiI
79,0 (80)
79,8(80)
79,1 (99)
78,5 (76)
80,7 (101)
83,0 (38)
82,6(65)
83.1 (81)
83,4 (92)
84,2 (109)
RapaqaeBn;LI
BaJIKap.n;LI
CBaHLI
IImaBLI
XeBcypLI
TymnHLI
PaqrrHI{IiI
OceTIIHIiI npaq,cKlIe
OceTrrHLI AmaBCKlIe
p
,
85,1 (211)
84,6 (314)
86,2(101)
86,5(105)
83,2 (97)
85,4 (84)
86,7 (103)
84,5 (102)
85,2(100)
OcooeHno nORaSaTeJIbHhIe pesYJI:bTaT:bI nOJIYlJalOTCJI npII COIIOCTaBJIeHIIII
no CRyJIOBOM IDHpIIHe JIIIll,a. fopn:bIe rpynrrhI OCeTIIII II fpYSIIII xapaRTepII-
aYlOTcH IICRJIlOlJIITeJIbnO BhICOHIIMII BeJIJil1J:MnaMIT norrepelJnoro )J,uaMeTpa JIHll,a,
ne yCTyIIalOm;HMII IIJIIT MaJIO YCTyrralOm;ITMIT paSMepaM 3'1'01'0 )J,IIaMeTpa y
CIIOIIpCHITX MOHrOJIOII)J;OB. TaHIIM oopaSOM, B 3TIIX paMonax M:bI lIMe eM OlJar
IDIIpOHOJIIIll,eCTII, naXO)J;JIm;IIM ce6e anaJIOrIIII: TOJIbHO sa IIpeAeJIaMII apeaJIa
pacnpOCTpaHeHIIJI eBpOHeOIIAnOM 60JIbrnOM paChI. B CBJISII C 3TITM CXO)J,CTBO
IIJIII paSJIUlJITe IIO BeJIITlJIIHe CHYJIOBOrO )J,IIaMeTpa npIT06peTaeT oc06oe SHa-
1JenIIe.
BaJIHapll,bI 1I oc06enno Hapa'IaeBll,hI ITJ'.IelOT OlJeHb rnIIpOHoe JIIIll,O, ne YC-
TyrraH B 3TOM OTnOrnenIIIT HaBRaCITOnCKHM IT ropnooceTUHCRIIM rpYIIrraM.
Bce aAhITeMCHIIe napop;HOCTII, IT )J,ame noraMll,:bI, Y HOTOpbIX nOBbIrnenIIe
rnIIpOTHhIX paSMepOB JIIIll,a JIB:IJIeTCJI CJIep:CTBueM MOHrOJIOII)J,HOM npITMeCU,
xapaHTepITsylOTCJI saMeTno MeHbrnUMII BeJIII1J:HnaMU CHYJIOBOrO )J;uaMeTpa:
IUallcyrH qepHOMOpcKHe
Illarrcyrn Ky6aHcKne
BmeAyxrr
qeMryn
A6aAsexn
BeCJIeHeeBIJ;IiI apMaBnpcKlIe
BeCJIeHeeB.n;LI SeJIeHQYKcKne
Ra6apAliHIJ;IiI
A6asIIHLI
Horaii.n;LI
141,0 (80)
141,0 (80)
141,0(99)
141,0 (76)
144,0(101)
146,0(38)
144,0 (65)
144,0(81)
145,0 (92)
H6,0 (109)
RaJJa'1aeB.n;IiI
Bammp.n;LI
CBlIHLI
IImaBIiI
XeBCypLI
TymnHIiI
PaqHHu;LI
OceTlillLI Hpaq,cKrre
OceTIIHLI AmaBCKrre
148,0(211)
147,0(314)
147,1 (101)
146,5(105)
146.6 (97)
146,5 (84)
147,6(103)
147,2 (102)
147,9(100)
IIpOCMOTp IIpII)3e)J,enHbIx ll,U<ppOBbIX ,L\aHn:bIX nOHashIBaeT, 1J:T0 y neHOTO-
phIX a)J,bIreMcHux rpyrrrr rrpOJIBJIJIlOTCJI Mop<pOJIOrIIlJeCRIIe oc06eHnocTH, xapaR-
TepnhIe )J,JIH HaBHaCIIonCRoro BapITanTa. TaR, lJepnOMOpCHlIe rnaIIcyrII, 1J:eMry:u
Ii[ apMaBIlpcRue 6eCJIeHeeBll,hI OTJIIT1J:alOTCJI OTHOCITTeJIbHOM B:bICOHOpOC-
JIOCTblO, apMaBUpCRIIe 6eCJIeneeBll,hI II a6aSHH:bI IIMelOT cpaBHIITeJIbHO rnHpo-
Hoe JIIIll,O IT 60JIbrnOM rOJIOBnOM YRasaTeJI:b. Op;naHO BapITall,IIIT OTp;eJIbHbIX
IIpIISHaHOB B HaIIpaBJIeIIUIT rrpIT6JIIImeHUJI R RaBHaCIIonCHOMy BapIIaHTY ne
ITMelOT '1'01'0 SHa1J:enIIJI, RaH cp:BIIr IISMeH1J:IIBOCTIT no BceMY HOMnJIeRCY TaH-
COHOMIT1J:eCHIT n,eHn:bIX npIIsnaHOB. IIocJIe)J,nuM B ,L\OCTaT01J:HO OT1J:eTJIIIBOM
<popMe aaMeTeH TOJIbHO y 6aJIHapll,eB II HapalJaeBll,eB. 8'1'0 )J,aeT BOSMomnOCTb
BhlCHasaTb IIpe,L\IIOJIOmenITe 0 TOM, 'ITO B aHTpOrrOJIOrIT1JeCHOM OTnornenIIII
6aJIHapll,hI II RapalJaeBll,hI JIBJIJIlOTCJI npe)J;CTaBIITeJIJIMII RaBHaCITOnCROro Ba-
245
i
plIanT a eBpOIIeOllp;HOlI OOJIbrnOM paCbI II C6JIUmalOTCH C ropHhIMU oceTUHCRII-
MU U ceBeporpysuncHuMU rpyIInaMII. TaHuM 06pa30M, IIpU pernenIIu BOIIpO-
COB 3Tnorene3a napop;OB Rapa1J:aH U BaJIHapIIII CJIe):(yeT UMeTb B BII]J;y, 1J:TO,
IICXO):(H US ):(aHnhIX anTpOIIOJIOrUII, IIpe):(IIOJIOmenue 06 06m;ux npep;Rax 6aJI-
Hapll,eB U Hapa1J:aeBll,eB, C o):(noM CTOpOHbI, U ropHhIX oceTUH II rpY3UH-
C p;pyroM, IIpe):(CTaBJIHeTCH 60JIee BepOHTnbIM, lJeM 06m;ee IIpoucxomp;enue c.
TlOpRCHIIMII II a6xaso-a):(hueMcHIIMII HapO):(HOCTHMU CeBepnoro RaBHa3a.
t
nAJIEOAHTPOnOJIOI'lIqECRIIE ;rJ;AHHbIE
B cBo,L\noll pa60Te no naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIU CCCP f. $. Ae6ell,a 6hIJIH
OIIucanhI JIUrnb TpU HpanUOJIOrIIlJeCRUe cepIIII C TeppUTOpUU CeBepHoro RaB-
Rasa 3noxu cpe):(neBeHOBbJI - lIS MOrIIJIbnURa Xapx B OCeTIIH, MOl'IIJIbIIIIHa
Ay6a-lOpT na TepPuTopIIIIQe1J:eno-HilrYilieTIIU II IOrUJIhHII!"a MOm;eBaH 6aJIHa
B n pIIHy6anbe. IIo1J:TU sa 40 JIeT, IIporne,L\IIIux IIOCJIe IIy6JIUHall,UU 3TOM
pa60TbI, nOJIomenue USMenIIJIOCb: 6hIJIU onucanbI MaTepUaJIbI us neCHOJIbHIIX
cpe):(neBeHoBhIx MOrIIJIbnUROB Ha TeppuTopIIU CTaBpOnOJIbH, qepHeccIIu,
OceTIIII II AareCTana. Ho TeppuTopUII Ra6ap,L\uno-BaJIHapUII ne OlJenb nOBe3-
JIO B unTepecylOm;eM Hac OTHorneHUII U B 3TII rO):(hI: BCHphIThIe TaM MOrIIJIb-
HUHU, ):(aBIIIIIe IIaJIeOanTpOIIOJIOrII1J:eCHUM MaTepUaJI, OTnOCIIJIUCb R MeCTnOMY,
nO-BU):(UMOMY p:OTlOpHCHOMY, naCeJIenUlO, U TOJIbHO paCROIIHU Bepxne1J:ereM-
CHoro MOrUJIbnUHa npnneCJIU He60JIbrnylO cepulO 1JepenOB, ROTophIe Momno
paCCMaTpIIBaTb HaH IIpuna):(JIemaBrnIIe cpep;neBeHOBbIM npep;RaM 6aJIHapll,eB 12.
MOrIIJIbHIIH 3'1'0'1' 6hIJI paCHonaH B 1960 r. f. II. Mone 6mm Bepxnero
-QereMa (Ra6ap,L\IIHo-BaJIHapuH), B MeCTnOCTU JIIIruT, II OTnecen K
VII-XII BB. n. 3. 13 J1:. M. qelJenOB ;LJ:aTUpOBaJI ero XIII-XIV BB.1
E. II. AJIeHCeeBa (ycTnoe C006m;eHue) 3anHJIa npOMemYT01J:nylO nOSIIll,IIlO II
OTnOCIIT MOrUJIbHUH H X-XII BB. He IIpep;pernaH Bonpoca 06 OHOH IaTeJIb-
HOM ):(aTe MOrIIJIbnUHa, TeM 60JIee TO nOJIYlJeHnbIll lIS Hero apXeOJIOrIIlJeCHIIM
MaTepIIaJI OKOH1J:aTeJIbnO He onucan, ero CJIep,yeT, IIO-BU,L\U1\WMY, Bce me pac-
CMaTpUBaTb HaR nOS;LJ:neCpeD,neBeHOBbIM. nop;paSYMeBaH nop, 3TUM nepBhIe
BeHa II ThICHlJeJIeTUH H. 3.
qepena US Bepxne1J:ereMCHoro MOrUJIbnllHa OTJIU1J:alOTCH npu a6COJIlOTnOM
BhIpamenHOCTII eBpcrreOII,L\nbIX oc06enHOCTelI rnIIpORIIM JIIIll,eBhIM CHeJIeTOM,
1J:epennaH Kop06Ha TaHme 60JIee mIIpOHaH, 1J:eM y naCeJIenUH, OCTaBUBmero
Mnorue ,L\pyrue MOrIIJIhnUHU Ha TeppUTopIIU CtmepHoro RaBHasa. CJIeD,CTBU-
eM 3Toro HBJIHeTCH saMeTHoe YBeJIU1J:enue 1J:epennoro yHasaTeJIH. Ono B MeHb-
rnell CTeIIenlI npOHBJIHeTCH Ha menCHUX lJepenax, no BapUall,UII npusnaHOB
B j-RenCHIIX cepUHX Bo06m;e B 1I0):(aBJIHlOm;eM 60JIbIlIIInCTBe c.lIYlJaeB Menee
lJeTHJI. TaHIIM 06paSOM, MbI UMeeM RpyrJIOrOJIOBOe II mUpOHOJIUll,ee naceJIe-
IIue, T. e., CJIe):(OBaTeJIbnO, TOT HOMnJIeRC IIpIISHaHOB, ROTOpbIII 1\WmeT 6bITb
c6JIumen C rnIIpOHOJIUll,bIMU U HpyrJIOrOJIOBbIMU eBponeoIIp,aMII IJ;enTpaJIbnOrO
RaBHa3a - HaBHaCIIonCHUM TunoM, 0 HOTOpOM rOBOpUJIOCb na rrpe):(blp,ym;ux
CTpannll,ax. TaHuM 06paSOM, IICXO!J,H US naJIeOanTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCHUX na6JIlOp;e-
HUM, Momno ,L\oCTaTOlJnO onpe):(eJIenno YTBepm):(aTb, lJTO 1I0nyJIHI(UH, OCTaBUB-
rnaH MOrUJIbnUR y Bepxnero qereMa, npIIna):(JIemaJIa H MecTnoMy 3TnUlJeCHO-
My nJIaCTY.
JI. M. JIaBpoB co CCbIJIROII na II. f. AHpuTaca, f. M. Mone II II. M. Mu-
sueBa nUcaJI 0 «SHalJIITeJIbnOM npOll,enTe MOnrOJIOII):(OB» B COCTaBe rpynnhI,
OCTaBUBrneM Bepxne1J:ereMCHUM 1\WrIIJIbnIIK 15. HCHO, lJTO pelJb u):(eT 0 IIO-
BepxHocTnoM BIIsyaJIbnOM BnelJaTJIenUU, ROTopoe unorp;a nop;BO,L\uT ):(ame
npo<peccIIOHaJIOB. B p;annoM CJIY1J:ae 3'1'0 06Man1J:UBOe Bne1J:aTJIenUe BOSnUHJIO
3a ClJeT 3na1J:UTeJIbHOM rnupunhI JIIIll,eBoro CKeJIeTa BepXnelJereMCHux lJepenOB.
246
B pa60Te JI. M. JIaBpoBa lJpe3BbIlJaMHaH JIa6UJIbHOCTb aHTpOnOJIOrU1J:eCRUX
ROMn eRCOB y npe):(HOB 6aJIHapll,eB U Rapa1J:aeBll,eB p;OHaShIBaeTCH cpaBHenII-
eM cpe):(nux B ):(a eHO pacnOJIOmenHbIX o,L\na OT ,L\pyroM ceBepOHaBRaSCHUX
rpynnax IIO CJIY1J:aMnO BbI6panHbIM II 3aBe):(OMO ):(UHaMII1J:HbIM rrpIISHaHaM.
Memgy TeM, Hor):(a aHTpOIIOJIOrII nIIrnYT 0 cTa6uJIbHOCTII anTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCHOrO
'I' IIII a , no):(pasyMeBalOTCH ne OT):(e bHhIe npII3naHU, a HX COlJeTaHUH. IIo HIIM
lEe npOIISBOp:IITCH II cpaBnenue.
B <peBpaJIe 1974 r. H IIMe B03MomHOCTb IIcc ep;OBaTb nOBbIM naJIeOaHTpo-
IJOJIOrII1J:eCmIM MaTepUaJI B ceHTope apxeoJIoruu Ra6ap):(IIHo-BaJIHapCHOro
HaY1J:nO-IICCJIe,L\OlJaTeJIbCHOrO uncTIITyTa B HaJIb1Jlme, rrocTynHBlliuM lIS pac-
HonOR nOCJIe):(nux eT. MaTepUaJI aTOT IIPOUCXO):(IIT U3 Tpex MOrUJIbHImOB,
paCIIOJIOmennhIX B ropHoll sone Ra6ap):(UHo-BaJIHapUII II RapalJaeBO-qepHe-
CUII,- RYPHoHTCHoro, TarnJIbI-TaJIUHcRoro II RapT-iKypTcHoro. IIpaI{THlJe-
CHII TOJIbKO us rrepBoro MorrWbHUHa B HarneM pacIIopHmeHIIu Haxo):(uTcH
He60JIbrnaH cepuH; OCTaJIbnbIe MOrIIJIbnIIHU Ilpe,L\cTaBJIenbI JIHllib e,L\unII1J:IlhI-
MII lJepenaMu. IIorpe6eHIIH RypnoHTcHoro MOrUJIbnIIHa ):(aTupYlOTCH XIII-
XVII BB. 16 , ):(Ba OCTa bnbIX MOrUJIbHIIHa pacHonaBrnIIll ux M. M. MusueB
):(aTIIpyeT XV-XVI BB. (TarnJIhI-TaJIa) II XIV-XV BB. (RapT-iKYPT).
M. M. qelJenOB, 06cym):(aH C aBTopoM np06JIeMY p;aTupoBHII 3TUX ,L\BYX MO-
TIIJIbnIIHOB, BbICHaSaJI npe):(nOJIo;'RenIIe, lJTO OHU MOrJIH BosnIIHnYTb na O):(IIn-
J(Ba BeHa IIosme. TaHuM 06pasoM, pelJh BO Bcex Tpex CJIYlJaHX II,L\eT 0 xpo-
HOJIOrUlJeCHU rrpIIMepno cIIHxponnoM naCeJIeHIIU, OTCTOHm;eM OT cOBpeMenHo-
CTU He 60JIbrne 1JeM Ha nOJIOBuny TbICHlJeJIeTIIH.
OCIIOBHhIe MeTpU1J:eCHUe xapaHTepIIcTuHH uCCJIe,L\oBannbIx lJepenOB npe,L\-
CTaB enbI B Ta6JI. 8. Mnp;uBII,L\yaJIbHbIe USMepenIIH oIIy6:rruHoBaHhI B cne-
ll,IIa hnOll pa60Te 17. fJIaBnOM oc06enHocTblO, ROTopaH 6pocaeTcH B rJIa3a
IIpU paCCMOTpenIIII MaTepIIaJIa HS MOrUJIbHIIHa I\YPHoHT, HBJIHeTCH SHa1J:IITeJIb-
HaH rnupIIna JIUll,eBoro CHeJIeTa. 8Ta oc06ennOCTb COlJeTaeTCH C 01J:enb CIIJIb-
nOM BbIpameHnocTblO eBponeou)J,nbIx rrpusnaHoB H TeH,L\enll,UM H pacrnIIpenIIIO
TO OBbI. Becb TaHoM HOMIlJIeRC, xapaRTepHbIll ,L\JIJI MnorIIX Hapo):(oB :U;enTpa b-
Horo RaBHasa B cOBpeMeHnylO 3IIOXY, 6hm CBollcTBeH ux npe):(HaM U B 3IIOXY
cpe):(neBeHoBbH. Mc,cJIe,L\oBaBrnull MOrIIJIbnUR RypnoHT M. M. MIIsIIeB BhI-
CRasa IIpe):(no omeHue, lJTO on OCTaB eH 6aJIHapll,aMII, Henocpep;cTBenHhIMu
npe.L\HaMU COBpe Iennoro naCeJIeHIIH - 6aJIHapll,eB BepxoBbeB -qepeHa, r,L\e
pacnoJIomen MOrIIJIbnIIH. IIa eoanTpOIIOJIOrUlJeCHUe na6JIlO):(enuH nO):(TBepm):(a-
10'1' 3'1'0 npeD,nOJIOmenIIe. HaXO):(Hm;aHCH B nallieM pacrropHmenuu cepIIH 1Je-
penOB US nos):(nux 6aJIHapCHIIX CHJIenOB 01J:enb cxop;na C HypnoHTcROM cepIIeM
IIO BceM ocnOBIIbIM npusnaHaM 18, lJTO TaHme CBu):(eTeJIbCTByeT B nOJIbsy
npIInap:JIemHOCTU MorIIJIbnIIHa RypnoHT H Hpyry 6aJIHapCRUX MOrUJIbnUHoB.
RaHOBO OTnornenue IIOS):(Hecpe):(neBeHOBoro Hace eHIIH, rrpomUBaBrnero B
BepXOBbHX qepeHa II USBeCTnoro HaM anTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCHU no MOrUJIbnIIHY Ryp-
lIOHT, H naCeJIelIIIlO neCHO bHO 60JIee pannero BpeMeHU, npomIIBaBllieMy B
BepXOBbJIX qereMa? MHbIMII C OBaMn. HaHOBO OTnornenue cepuu IIS MOrUJIb-
HUHa RypnoHT H lJepenaM US BepxnelJereMCRoro MorU bnUHa? BepxnelJereM-
("Hue lJepena TaHme OT II alOTCH 60JIbrnOM rnupIInOM ull,a H CIIJIbnOM BbIpa-
mennocTblO eBpOIIeou,L\nbIX oc06ennOCTeM, T. e. TeMU me anTpOIIOJIOrU1J:eCHII-
MU 1J:epTaMU, 1JTO U 1J:epena US RypnoHTa H COBpeMennaH 6aJIHapCHaH cepIIH.
Momno p,yMaTb, 1J:TO B BepxoBbHX qereMa TaRme npomuBa II npe):(Hu 6aJIHap-
n;eB, HaH U B BepxoBbHX qepeRa, U lJTO BepxnelJereMCHUM MOrUJIbnUH npep;-
CTaBJIHeT C060M 60JIee pannlOlO CTa,L\ulO UX <pOpMupOBaHUH II UCTOPUU, 1J:eM
RypnoHTCHIIM. RaH U B naCTOHm;ee BpeMH, Memgy naceJIenUeM 3TIIX ):(BYX
ym;eJIUM 3nOXH cpe):(neBeHoBbH neBosMomno npOCJIe):(uTb nUHaRoM aIITpOIIOJIO-
rUlJeCROll pasnIIll,hI. R COmaJIeHIIlO, neT naJIeOanTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCKHX p;anHbIX no
247
,.
I
Ta6JIHqa 8
Cpe mte paslUepbI H YlmsaTeJIH 'IepeIIOB HS lUOrHJIbHHKOB Bepxueii EaJIKapHH
MymcRltC 'leperra meHCRHe 'leperra
IIpH3HaR BepxHHH J BepxHHH I
1J:erei\! RYPHOHT qereM RYPHOHT
1. IIpo.rWJIbHbIH HaMeTp 184,0(3) 183,1 (7) 174,,0(4) 184,0 (3)
8. IIOnepeqHbIH HaMeTp 150,0(3) 145,0(7) 140,0(4) 139,7(3)
17. BbICOTHbIH p;HaMeTp OT 6asIIoHa 132,5 (2) 136 4 (7) 133,0(4) 132,3 (3)
8: 1. qepenHoH YKasaTCJIb 81,8 (3) 79,2 (7) 80,7 (4) 76,1 (3)
3__
f1.8.17. qepeIIHoH MOP;YJIb 154,1 * 153,6 * 148,0 * 150,4 *
9. HalIMeHbmaJI illHpHHa JI6a 98,5(4) 100,7(7) 94,8 (4) 101,0 (3)
32. YrOJI JI6a 81,7(3) 83,1 (7) 82,0(4) 85,0(3)
5. ]J.JIHHa OCHOBaHHH qepena 106,5 (2) 102,3 (7) 99,5(4) 100,0 (3)
40. ]J.mIHa OCHOBaHIDl mrqa 99,5 (2) 98,0(5) 94,2(4) 94,0(3)
45. CKYJIOBaH IIIlrpHHa 138,7(3) 137,,4 (7) 126,2(4) 129,0 (3)
45: 8. rOpHSOHTaJIbHbIH <paqlIon;epe6paJIb- 92,6 (3) 94,8 (7) 90,3(4) 92,4 (3)
HbIH YKasaTeJIb
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa JIHn;a 72,8 (4) 72,6 (5) 64,2 (4) 73,0(3)
48: 17. BepTHKaJIbHltlll: <p a qHon;epe6paJThHbIll: 55,2 (2) 52,6(5) 48.3(4) 55,2 (3)
YKasaTeJIb
48 :45. BepxHnii JIHqeBOll: YKasaTeJIb 52,2 (3) 52,9 (5) 50,9(4) 56,5 (3)
f 45.48. JIHqeBOll: MOP;YJIb 100,5 * 99,9 * 90,0* 97,0*
51. IllHplIHa Op6HTbI OT mf (JIeB.) 42,2(4) 43,9 (7) 39.9(4) 43,0(3)
52. BbIcoTa Op6HTbI (JIeB.) 32,5 (4) 35,6 (7) 31,2 (4) 35,0(3)
52 : 51. Op6HTHbIll: YlmsaTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 77,0(4) 80,4(7) 78,6 (4) 81,4 (3)
54. IIIHpHHa Hoca 25,2(4) 26,6 (7) 24,5(4) 24,0(3)
55. BblcoTa Hoca 55,0(4) 52,7(7) 48,5(4) 55,0(3)
54: 55. HOCOBOll: YKasaTeJIb 45,9(4) 49,5 (7) 50,5(4) 43,7 (3)
72. 06m,Hll: yrOJI JIHn;a 88,0(3) 85.4(5) 87,5(4) 85,5 (2)
74. YroJI aJIbBeOJIHpHOll: 'IaCTH JInqa 84,0(3) 86,0 (5) 82,0 (2) 87.5 (2)
75 (1). YroJI HOCOBbIX KOCTell: K JIHHHH npo- 30,2(4) 35,0(5) 27,5 (2) 33.0(2)
cPHJIH
77. HaSOMaJIHpHbIll: yrOJI 139,8(4) 139,7 (7) 138,2(4) 140,7 (3)
Lzm'. 3HroMaKCHJIJIHpHbIll: yrOJI 128,2 (4) 128,4 (7) 127,5 (4) 121,0(3)
DS. ]J.aKpHaJIbHaJI BblCOTa 13,0(4) 13,0(7) 11,8(4) 12,5 (3)
DS:DC. }J;aKpHaJIbHbIll: yRasaTeJIb 65,1 (4) 68,3 (7) 55,8(4) 66,0(3)
SC. CHMOTHqeCKaH BbICOTa 4,7 (4) 4,7 (7) 4,1 (4) 4,4 (3)
SS: SC. CHMOTHqeCKHll: YKasaTeJIb 58,2(4) 48,9 (7) 40,1(4) 51,1 (3)
* I1HlJ;eRC CpelJ;HHX.
npe)J,rneCTBYIOm;UM nepIlop;aM, HOTOp:bIe nOSBOJIIIJIU 6bI HaM peRonCTpYIIpOBaTb
60JIee rJIy60HIIe xpOnOJIOrII'IeCRUe UCTORU <pOpMupoBaHIIH Toro HOMnJIeHCa
npIIsnaHOB, 0 HOTOpOM up;eT pe'Ib.
B CBHSII C I1CHJII01J:UTeJIbnOH pOJIbIO, ROTOpyIO I1rpaJIo aJIaHCROe naceJIe-
HIIe cTeneM II rrpe):(ropuM CeBepHoro RaBRasa B CJIomenuu HYJIhTypbI II 3THH-
'IeCHIIX oc06ennocTeM ceBepORaBHaSCRIIX Hapop;OB, ne6ecnoJIesno sap;aTb BO-
npoc: RaROBO RonHpeTHo 6bIJIO IIX 3na'IenlIe B <pOpMupoBanIIII aHTpOnOJIOrIl-
1J:eCRIIX oc06enHocTeM 6aJIRapll,eB, ORaSaJIII JIII aJIaH:b! Ha HUX RaHoe-nII6Y):(b
BJIUHHIIe, T. e. BCTynaJIII JIll OHII B 6pa'InhIM HOHTaRT C npe,L\HaMu 6aJIHapll,eB
248
JWU neT? CBOMCTBennhIM aJIanaM RpaHUOJIOrIIlJeCHIIM ROMnJIeHC 6hIJI COCTaB-
:IeH p;JIUnnOM lJepeIInOR Rop06ROM, YSHIIM II OTnOCUTeJIbnO BbICoRUM JIIIll,eBbIM
CReJIeTOM npII peSROM BbIpamennOCTU eBpOIIeOII):(HbIX oc06eHnOCTeM II OTCyT-
CTBUU RaHOII-JIu60 MOnrOJIOUp;nOM npUMecu. IIbITaHCb OTBeTIITb Ha 3a,L\aHnbIM
EbIrne Bonpoc II conOCTaBJIHH RpanUOJIOrII1J:eCHIIe oc06enHOCTII naCeJIenUH,
OCTaBIIBrnero aJIanCRIIe II 6aJIHapCHIIe naMHTnIIHU, MbI npIIxop;UM R BhIBOP;Y,
"ITO B COCTaBe cpep;neBeHOBoro naCeJIenUH BepxneM BaJIHapIIU He saMeTno
HIIRaHIIX CJIep:OB npIIMecu Toro ROMnJIeHCa npusnaHOB, ROTOpbIM 6bIJI xapaH-
TepeH P;JIH aJIan. Cpe):(II TeppIITOpITaJIbnbIX rpynn COBpeMennbIX 6aJIHapll,eB
TaHme ne1; TaHIIX, HOTopbIe BbIp;eJIHJIUCb 6bI YSHOJIUll,eCTbIO. TaHIIM 06paSOM,
Ha Bonpoc 0 BJIUHHUII aJIan Ha CJIOmenIIe anTpOnOJIOrU1J:eCROrO COCTaBa cpe):(-
JIeBeHOBoro naCeJIenUH ropnOM SOHbI Ra6apAIInO-BaJIRapUII nymno nOHa,
,L\O IIOJIYlJenUH HOBbIX MaTepUaJIOB, Morym;IIx USMenIITb 3'1'0 3aRJIIOlJenIIe, 0'1'-
EeTIITb OTpUll,aTeJIbno.
TaHOM BhIBO):(, nap,o p;YMaTb, cnpaBe):(JIUB U P;JIJI TeppUTopUII Rapa1J:aH.
IIOCHOJIbHY apeaJI paCCeJIeHUH aJIaH OXBaThIBaJI B RaHOM-TO Mepe II TeppUTO-
pIIIO COBpel\Iennoro RapalJaH, nOCTOJIbHy MhI BnpaBe npep;nOJIaraTb, lJTO CBOM-
CTBennbIM IIM ROMnJIeHC npIl3naROB 6bIJI xapaRTepen II P;JIH cpep;HeBeHOBoro
naCeJIenUH, sanIIMaBiliero 06JIaCTb paCCeJIenUH COBpel\IelInbIX Rapa1J:aeBll,eB.
TaH RaH onII, HaH MbI y6e,L\UJIIICb, TmRe IIMeIOT peSHO 6paXIIHpaHnyIO lJeperr-
HYIO Hop06Hy II rnupOHUM JIIIll,eBOM CRe;;reT, OOm;UM IITorOM conOCTaBJIeIIIIff
naJIeOanTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCHUX II COMaTOJIOrIIlJeCHIIX )J,annhIX HBJIHeTCH HonCTaTa-
I(UH <paHTa OTCYTCTBIIH npeeMCTBennOCTII Mem,L\y COBpeMennhIMII HapalJaeB-
I(aMII U aJIanaMII. YBeJIIITJeIIUe 1J:epeIIHOro YHasaTeJIJI y COBpeMeHnoro HaCeJIe-
HUH lIO cpaBnenIIIO C ,L\peBnUM, sa<pUHcupOBannoe P;JIH MnorIIX 06JIaCTeM
CCCP, ne HBJIHeTCH apryMenToM npOTUB yHasannoro reneTUlJeCHOrO pa3pbI-
Ba, II60 ono Bcerp;a COIIpOBom,L\aeTCH yMenbrnenIleM mIIpOTnbIx paSMepOB
JIIIll,eBorO CHeJIeTa, Torp:a RaH B paCCMaTpIIBaeMOM CJIYlJae OTJIIIlJIIH Hapa1J:a-
eBll,eB U 6aJIHapll,eB 0'1' cpe)J,neBeHOBoro HaCeJIenUH U,L\YT B 06paTnOM HanpaB-
JIeHIIII.
OBCYjK,a:EImE Cym;ECTBYIOm;IIX I'IIIIOTE3
BOJIbrnOe HOJIlIlJeCTBO cym;ecTByIOm;I1X B JIIITepa Type runOTes 0 npOIIC-
XOrt ,'],enIIH 6aJlImpll,eB U HapalJaeBll,eB caMO lIO ce6e CBUp;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 CJIom-
nOCTH rrp06JIe IbI. HeHOTOphIe lIS nIlX, nanpUMep lJernCHaJI rIIrrOTesa
11. A. fUJIb):(enrnTep;Ta 19 UJIR rynncHaH rUIIOTesa m. IIIap):(eHa II A. JIaM-
6epTII 20, UMeIOT B naCTOHm;ee BpeMJI JIUrnb IICTopIIorpa<pII1J:eCHUM IIHTepec II
He nym):(aIOTCH B cnell,uaJIhIIOM 06cym,L\eHUU. .D:pyrIIe, HaH, naIIpIIMep, runo-
Tesa. paCCMaTpIIBaIOm;aH COBpeMeHnoe naCeJIeHIIe RapalJaH II BaJIHapUII RaR
{)CHOJIHII nOJIlJIIm; TIIMypa, MoryT yp;a1J:no 06'bHCnHTb npOIIcxomp:enue 0'1'-
p;eJIbnbIX HapalJaeBCHIIX U 6aJIHapCKHX <paMUJIUM, HO He pernaIOT np06JIeMY
3TnoreHesa 6aJIRapll,eB U Hapa IaeBll,eB B ll,eJIOM 21. HeT nym):(bI OCTanaBJIII-
EaTbCH II IIa runOTese c06CTBenno Typell,HorO IIJIII RpbIMCHoro npOIICXomp;e-
HIIH rrOCJIep:nIIX, HaH OCIIOBannOM TOJIbHO IIa p:aHnbIX <pOJIbHJIOpa, UMeIOm;ero
saBe):(OMO BTOpU1JnOe npOIIcxom,'],eIIIIe, U IIOJInOCTbIO IIpOTIIBOpelJaIT\eM I1CTO-
pII1J:eCHIIM ):(anHbIM 22. B HalJeCTBe COJIu,L\no 060cnOBaIInbIX UCTOpIIlJeCHUMII II
,L\pyruMII ):(anIIbIMU MOryT paCll,enIIBaTbCH runOTeShI TIOpHCHoro II aJIanCHOro
IIpOIIcxomp;eHIIH Rapa1J:aeBI(eB 11 6aJIHapll,eB. R UX 06cym):(enuIO "II ,L\OJIiHnbI
6bITb B nepBYIO OlJepe):(b npIIBJIelJenbI peSYJIbTaThI anTpOIIOJIOrIIlJeCHOrO IIC-
CJIe,L\OBanUH.
OCIIOBIIbIM aprYMenTOM B IIOJIbSY TIOpHCHOM rUIIOTeSbI JIBJIJIeTCJI npIlHap;-
.JremHOCTb HShIRa HapalJaeBI(eB U 6aJIHapll,eB R TIOpRCROM HSbmOBOM ceMbe,
rp;e on sanUMaeT MeCTO B RMn1J:aHCHo-orYSCROM, UJIM nOJIOBell,HOM, IIop;rpynne
249
KHnlJaKCHOM rpynnhI BMeCTe C HUn1J:aHCHUM, RapaUMCHIIM U HyMhmCHUM H3bI-
RaMU 23. ApyroM TIOpHCHHM HShIR CeBepnoro RaBHasa - noraMCRUM BMeCTH
C HapaHa:maHCHUM U HasaXCHHM HSbmaMU npuna):(JIemUT H RIIn aRCHo-no-
raMCHOM rrop;rpynIIe HIIn1J:aHCROM rpynrrhI TIOpcmIX HShmOB. CaM no ce6e
<paRT npHnap;JIemnOCTII Hapa1J:aeBo-6aJIHapCHOro U noraMCHoro HSbmOB R
pasnbIM HShmoBbIM no):(rpynnaM onpOBepraeT noralICHIIM BapIIanT TIOpHCHOM
rnnOTeSbI HapalJaeBO-6aJIHapCHOro 3TnoreIIesa 24. AnTpOnOJIOrUlJeCHUM MaTe-
pHaJI npUHOCUT ,L\onOJInHTeJIbnyIO aprYMenTall,UIO B nOJIbSY OTCYTCTBUJI npJI-
MOM reneTH1J:eCHOM CBHSII Mem,L\y noraiIu,aMu, C op;nOM cToponhI, U 6aJmapll,a-
MII U Kapa1J:aeBIJ;aMH - C ,L\pyroM. HaJIII1JIIe y rrepBblx CIIJIbHOM IOnrOJIOII,L\nOM
npuMecu pesHo OTJIIIlJaeT ux 0'1' BTOpbIX, Y HOTOpbIX IOnrOJIOu,L\naH npIIMecb
nOJInOCTbIO OTCYTcTByeT. TaHuM 06pasoM, noraMcHuM BapuanT TIOpHCHOM ru-
1I0TeShI p;oJImen 6bITb OCTaBJIen, HaR urnopupYIOm;IIM cym;ecTBennhIe paSJIII-
lJUH Mem)J,y noralIll,aMII U 6aJIHapO-Hapa1J:aeBll,aMU IIO HSbmy U <puSU1J:eCHHM
oc06eHnocT HM.
X. O. JIaMnaHoB C006m;aeT, lJTO B Hapa1JaeBO-6aJIRapcHOM <pOJIbHJIOpe 6bI-
TyeT JIereH):(a, BbIBO,L\Hm;aH npe,L\HoB Hapa1J:aeBll,eB II 6aJIHapll,eB lIS p;peBnero
ropop;a Ma;o:maphI II ClJIITaIOII(aH UX npe;O:HaMH xasap 25. OlJeBU):(HO, lJTO OC-
IIOBHhIM apryMenToM B IIOJIbSY npoucxom):(enUH RapalJaeBll,eB U 6aJIHapll,eB
0'1' xasap HBJIHeTCH npHsrranrre ropop;a Ma,L\maphI xasapCHIIM. TaHaH T01J:Ha
<JpenIIH p;eMCTBUTeJIbnO BbICHaShIBaJIaCb B HalJaJIe XX B. f. H. IIpospuTeJIe-
BbIM 26. O):(naHO apxeOJIOrU1J:eCHIIe paCHonRU B. A. fOpO)J,ll,OBa B IIpep;eJIax
l'opo;o:a Ma;O:J[{3phI 27 U Tm;aTeJIbnOe conOCTaBJIenUe Bcex co):(epmaII(UXCH B
IIl1CbMenIIhIX IICTOlJnUHaX CBe,L\enUM 0 HeM, npOUSBe,L\ennoe T. M. MUHae-
BOM 28, nOHaSaJIU, 1J:TO ropo):( Ma,L\/KapbI HBJIHJICH O,L\nUM lIS SOJIOTOOp,L\hIH-
CKHX ropop;OB, Bpe IJI paCll,BeTa ROToporo na)J,aeT Ha XIV B. TaHuM 06pasoM,
XOTJI U neT OCHOBanUM OTpIIIJ;aTb, 1J:TO nOTOMHII xasap IOrJIII COCTaBJIHTb on-
pe,L\eJIennbIM npOll,eHT naCeJIeHUH ropop;a, 3'1'0'1' <paHT em;e ne HBJIHeTCJI p;ORa-
SaTeJIbCTBOM reHeTUlJeCHOII CBH3II p;peBnux xasap U COBpeMennbIx 6aJIRapll,eB
H Hapa aeBll,eB. XasapcmIM BapHanT TIOpHCHOM runOTeSbI Hapa1J:aeBO-6aJIHap-
CHoro 3THorenesa nymp:aeTCH, CJIe,L\OBaTeJIbHO, B ,L\OnOJInUTeJIhnOM apryMeH-
Tall,IIU, II II03TOMy IHenue X. O. JIaMnanoBa 0 TOM, 1J:TO «xasapCHIIM 3JIeMenT
HBJIHeTCH O,L\HUM US rJIaBnbIX 3JIeMenTOB B 3TnU1JeCHOM COCTaBe Rapa1J:aeBll,eB
U 6aJIHapll,eB» 29, BbIrJIH):(UT MaJIoy6e,L\UTeJIbnbIM.
AHTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCHUe p:annhIe TaHme ne nO)J,TBepmp;aIOT xasapcRyIO runo-
Tesy. Oc06enHOCTII <pH3II1JeCHOrO TIlIIa xasap MorYT 6bITb BOCCTanOBJIeHbI Ha
ocnOBanUII HSY1J:enIIH 06I1IIIpnOrO naJIeOanTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCHOrO MaTepnaJIa, P;O-
6hITOrO npu paCHonHax xasapCHOM RpeIIOCTU CapHeJI 30. On CBU)J,eTeJIbCTBY-
eT 0 TOM, 1J:TO paCOBhIM COCTaB xasap xapaHTepUSOBaJICH naJIII1J:UeM saMeTHOM
MonrOJIou,L\HOll npII:\IeCII. ITpaBp;a, ona nesaMeTna B MaTepUaJIe, npOIICXOP;H-
m;eM lIS 60JIbrnOrO Hyprana, HO BIIOJIne OTlJeTJIHBO IIpOHBJIHeTCH Ha lJepenax
US MaJIhIX HypraHoB, IIO MnenuIO M. M. ApTaMonOBa TaHme OCTaBJIennbIX
naCeJIeIIHeM ropo):(a. PeSYJILTaTbI UCCJIe):(OBanUJI HpanUOJIOrII1JeCHOrO MaTe-
puaJIa COrJIaCYIOTCH C C006II(eIIIIHMU nUCbMenIIbIX UCTOlJnUHOB, CorJIacno RO-
TOpbIM HapuHaTypnoe IIs06pamenIIe ll,apH xasap, BbICTaBJIeHnOe na CTeHH
ropo,L\a T6UJIUCH nepcaMU IIPII ocap;e ero xasapaMU, OTJIU aJIOCb HaH pas YT-
pUpOBHOM MOnrOJIOUp;nbIX rrpIISHaHOB 31. B HalJeCTBe KOCBennoro aprYMenTa,
rOBopHm;ero 0 naJIU1J:HII MOHrOJIOIIp;nOM npUMecu B COCTaBe xasap, MomeT
paCCMaTpUBaTbCH U naJIII1J:He MOnrOJIOH,L\nOM npHMecu y naCeJIenIIH Cpe,L\neBe-
HOBoro HpbIMCHoro ropO,L\a Xepconeca, r,L\e CTOHJI xasapCRUM rapnuson 32.
Bce 3'1'0 nOSBOJIHeT c):(eJIaTb BbIBO):(, '1'1'0 C anTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCHOM TOlJHII speHUH
reHeTU1JeCHaH npeeMCTBennOCTb Memgy xasapaMU, C op;nOM CToponbI, H Ha-
pa1JaeBll,aMU U 6aJIHapll,aMU - C ):(pyroll, XOTH U ne UCRJIlOlJena IIO.lIIIOCTbIO,
250
HO Ma OBepOHTna BBUP;Y naJIUlJIIH MOnrOJIOII,L\nOM npUMeCU Y nepBbIX I1 OT-
CYTCTBIIH ee Y BTOpbIX.
06 OTCYTCTBUII reneTUlJeCHOM rrpeeMCTBennOCTU Memp;y cpep;neBeHoBhIM
HaCeJIeHIIeM ropo,L\a Map;mapbI U cOBpeMennbIMu 6a Hapll,aMU Momno rOBO-
PUTb C no nOM OIIpe,L\eJIennOCTbIO. MSY1J:enue HpanIIOJIOrUqeCHOM ROJI eHll,IIU,
(',06pannoM B. A. fOpO):(ll,OBbIM npu paCHOIIHax CpeIJ,HeBeHOBoro MorU bHUHa
B ropO,L\e Map;JRapbI, II cpaBnenue ee C HpanHOJIOrHlJeCHIIMU MaTepua aMII C
Bo rII, OTIIOCHm;HMUCH H xasapaM II naCeJIeHHIO 30JIOTOOp):(hIHCHIIX ropO):(OB,
nop:TBep,L\U II IIpunap; emnOCTh ropo):(a H 1J:nCJIY SOJIOTOOPAbInCHUX 33. Cne-
ll,IIaJIbnOe cpaBnenue C 6aJIHapCHOM HpanIIOJIOrII1J:eCHOM cepIIeM npo,L\eMOnCT-
pHpoBa o OTCYTcTBIIe Mop<p0JIOrUlJeCHoro CXO):(CTBa Mem,L\Y Hace eHueM Ma)J,-
wap U npe,L\CTaBUTeJIHMII 6aJIHapCHOro napo)J,a, a CJIep;OBaTe bno, II OTCYTCT-
Bue Memp;y nUMU reneTIIlJeCHOrO pop:cTBa.
RUnlJaHCKUII BapuanT TIOpHCHOM runOTeSbJ aprYMenTIIpoBan ropas):(o 60JIee
COJIH,L\no, qeM Bce npe,L\bI,L\ym;ue 3\ B nO bSY 3TOM rUIIOTeSbI CBU,L\eTeJIbCTBY-
JOT H3hmOBhIe II 3Tnorpa<pII1JeCHUe (B lJaCTnOCTU, COBnap:enIIe IIorpe6aJIbnhIX
06PHp:OB), HaH II c06CTBenno ITCTOpIIlJeCHUe, p;annhIe. CaM IIO ce6e anTpOIIO-
JIOrII1J:eCHUM MaTepIIaJI TaHme ne ,L\aeT B03MomnOCTU BospamaTh IIpOTIIB IIPJI-
Moro pO;:J;CTBa HIInqaHOB C 6aJIHapll,aMII II HapalJaeBll,a1\III IIpOCTO B CIIJIY nOJI-
Horo OTCYTCTBUH CBe,L\enUM 0 <pUSIIlJeCHOM Tune HIIn1JaHOB. Op:naHO paccym-
J\enue, npUBe}1ennOe npu paCCMOTpeHUII HoraMCHOM U xasapCHOM runOTes,
ne TepHeT CBoero snalJenUH U B )J,annOM CJIYlJae. HaJIIIlJIIe OT1J:eTJIUBO BbIpa-
'mennOM MOHrOJIOu):(nOM rrpIIMeCII B COCTaBe HoraMll,eB, rrpep;CTaBJIHIOm;IIX CO-
.6011 rpyrrny, B 06Ill,eM saHHMaIOm;yIO IIpoMemYT01J:nOe Mem,L\y eBponeoup:aMu
IT MOHrOJIOIIp;aMII nOJIOmenIIe, SaCTaBJIHeT rrpep:nOJIaraTb, lJTO npIIHa,L\ emnOcTb
R KHII1J:aHCHOll BeTBU TIOpHCHOM HShIIWBOM ceMbU U BbIpamennocTb MOnrOJIO-
M,L\nblx oc06ennocTeM B aHTpOnOJIOrUlJeCHOM Tune HBJIHIOTCH na TeppIITopIIII
CeBepnoro RaBHasa c e,L\CTBIIeM ep;uHoro UCTOpUlJeCIWrO rrpoll,ecca. OTCYTCT-
BIIe y 6aJIHapll,eB II Hapa1J:aeBll,eB MOnrOJIOII)J,IIOM IIpIIMeCII MernaeT, CJIeJ],OBa-
TeJIbnO, IIOJIHOCThIO npunHTb HIInlJaHCHYIO rIIrroTesy. ApyrHM HOCBennbIM ap-
ryMenToM, CBu,L\eTe bCTBYIOm;UM IIpOTUB nee, HBJIHeTCH 6JIUSHOe CXO):(CTBO
anTpoIIO OrII1J:eCHOrO TIIIIa HapalJaeBll,eB II 6aJIRapll,eB C <pUSII1JeCRHM TIInOM
ropHblx OCeTIIH II ropHhIX rpynn rpYSIIH. IIOCHOJIbHY B OTHornenIIII noc e):(-
nIIX ne cym;ecTByeT HII MaJIeMrnUX naMeHOB na CBHSb UX C RIInlJaRaMU, HeT
OCHoBanuM nOJIaraTb, lJTO 6 IISHoe CXOP;CTBO ropHblx rpYIIn rpYSUII II OceTIIu
C 6aJIHapll,aMII II HapalJaeBll,aMU no anTpOnOJIOrU1JeCHUM oc06ennoCTHM IIMeeT
CBoeM rrpUqIIHOM 06m;ee npoIICxom,L\enue 0'1' HIIIIlJaHOB. TaHHM 06paSOM, anT-
pono orIIH, He pacno araH B 3TOM cJIYlJae npHMbIMU p:annbIMU, rrOSBOJIHeT
Te:\1 He Menee HpUTUlJeCHII OTneCTIICb H runOTese HUn1J:aHCHOro IIpoucxomp;e-
HUB COBpeMennbIX TIOpHCHUX HapO,L\HOCTeM RapalJaH U BaJIHapIIII Ha ocnOBa-
HHH HOCBennbIX co06pameHUM. XOTH <paHT npoucxom):(enIIH COBpeMennoro
RapalJaeBo-6a.TmapCHoro HSbma 0'1' IIOJIOBell,Horo SaCBIID,eTeJIhCTBOBan ll,eJIbIM
pHp:OM rrUCbMennbIX IICTOlJnUHOB II B naCTOHIll,ee BpeMH MOJReT ClJUTaThCH
6eccnopnbIM, BeCbMa BepOHTno, lJTO cpep;u npHMbIX npe,L\HOB Hapa1J:aeBll,eB II
6aJIHapll,eB HHIIqaIUI COCTaBJIHJIU nIIlJTOmnOe 1\IenbrnHnCTBO. B CBeTe ,L\aHnbIX
aIITpOnOJIOruu HIIn1JaHCHaH rHIIOTesa ,L\OJImna nonIIMaTbCH, CJIe,L\OBaTeJIbnO,
CHopee HaH BhIpamenue UMeBrnero MeCTO HYJIbTypnoro BSaII1\1O,L\eMCTBIIH,
a ne reneTII1J:eCHOrO pO,L\CTBa.
H. XO,L\neB BbICHaSaJI npe):(nOJIOmeHUe 0 npOIICXOm,L\enUII 6aJIHapll,eB OT
op;noro us ROJIeH HaBRaSCHUX 6YJIrap 35. IIosme ono 6hIJIO IIO)J,,L\epmano
B. $. MUJIJIepOM 36. 06a aBTOpa OCHOBhIBaJIUCb npeIIMym;ecTBenHo Ha COB-
IIa,L\enuu n eMeHnbIX nasBanIIM. PasYMeeTcH, COBna,L\enIIe TaHoro po):(a ne 1\10-
meT CJIymIITb Jl,OCTaT01JHO BeCHUM aprYMeHTOM B nOJIbSY reHeTIIlJeCHOrO
i
251
0,
I
I
i,
pO,L\CTBa. PaCCMOTpenUe IIaJIebanTpOIIOJIOrII1J:eCROrO MaTepUaJIa U3 CeJIbCRUX
6YJIrapCHUx MOrIIJIbnUHOB IIoBoJImbH 37 U COOCTBenno BOJIrapIIH 38 nORaS:bI-
BaeT, 1J:TO P;JIH 6YJIrap 6hIJI xapaRTepen eBpOIIeou):(nbIM TUn, OTJIIIlJaBrnUMCJI
YMepennOM 6paXUHpanHeM U OTHOCIITeJIbHOM rnIIpOROJIIIll,eCTbIO, T. e. Te:MII
oc06ennOCTHMU, ROTophIe BbIpameH:bI H B Tune RapalJaeBll,eB U 6aJIHapll,eB.
Op;naHO a6COJIIOTnhIe paSMephI rnupunbI JIull,a, TaH me RaR II p;uaMeTpa 1'0-
JIOBhI, Y nepBbIX Bce me saMeTHO MeIIbrne, lJeM y BTOpbIX. 8nOXaJIbnaH H3-
MenlJIIBOCTb, sa<pIIHCIIpoBanHaH P;JIH MHorIIX IIpusnaHoB, up;eT CRopee no JIII-
HIIll Yl\IenbrnenUH, a He YBeJIII1J:enIIH a6COJIIOTnhIX paSMepOB. TaRIIM 06pasoM.
B cJIY1J:ae npusHaHIlH 6YJIrapCHOlI rUIIOTe3bI MbI ):(OJIJKHbI p;onycTuTh USMene-
nIIe anTpOnOJIOrUlJeCHIIX npusnaRoB B 06paTHoM 06bIlJnoMY nanpaBJIenUIO,
lJTO B CBeTe 06mux co06pamenuM npe)J,cTaBJIHeTCH MaJIOBepOHTHbIM. BhIcRa-
saHnoe B nOCJIe):(nee BpeMH IIpe):(IIOJIOmenue 0 TOM, lJTO B COCTaBe 6YJIrap
6hIJIU aJIaHCRUe IIJIeMena 39, npUnll,UIIHaJIbnO He MeHHeT OTnornenUH R 6YJI-
rapCHOM rUIIOTe3e, nOCHOJIbHy npII3naHue IInOM 3TnIIlJeCHOM II HShmOBOM
npllHa)J,JIemnOCTII 6YJIrap ne ynll1J:TOmaeT <paHTa OTCYTCTBIIH IIpeeMCTBenHO-
CTII Mem,L\y nUMII U 6aJIHapll,aMII U Rapa1J:aeBll,aMII B anTpOnOJIOrII1JeCRllX OCO-
6ennOCTHX.
IIoJInaH paspa60THa Bonpoca 0 B03MomnOM CBHSII RapalJaeBll,eB II 6aJIRap-
ll,eB CO Cpe,L\neBeHOBbIMU aJIanaMII OTCYTCTByeT B IICTOpIIlJeCHOM JIIITepaType.
Op;naHO cym;eCTBYIOT MnOrOlJIICJIennhle UCTOlJnURU, naSbIBaIOmIIe naceJIenue
Rapa1J:aH U BaJIRapUII aJIanaMU B 3noxy, Hor,L\a TaM yme mUJIU IIpep;RII Ra-
paqaeBll,eB II 6aJIRapll,eB, T. e. nOCJIe XIII B. 40 ConOCTaBJIeHUe naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIOrUlJeCHIIX MaTepUaJIOB 3IIOXII Cpe,L\neBeHOBbH, IIpIInIIChIBaeMbIX aJIaHaM.
C peSYJIbTaTaMII COMaTOJIOrUlJeCHOrO IICCJIe,L\OBanHH 6aJIRapll,eB U Hapa1J:aeB-
ll,eB p;aeT BOSMomHOCTb HpIITUlJeCHII OTHeCTUCb I1 R 3TOM runOTe3e. He OTpIIll,aJI
nOJInOCTbIO y'IaCTUH aJIanCROro HOMnoneHTa B 06pasoBanuII RapalJaeBO-6aJI-
RapcHoM napO,L\nOCTII, CJIe):(yeT nOp;lJepHnYTb, lJTO no):(aBJIHIOm;ee 60JIhillUnCTBO
npe):(HOB COBpeMennbIX HapalJaeBll,eB II 6aJIHapll,eB ):(OJI;.I,no ObIJIO npuna,L\-
JIemaTb I{ ,L\pyrOMY anTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCHoMy Tllrry, lJeM TOT, ROTOp:bIM, IIO-BIIP;II-
MOMy, 6bIJI IIpe06JIa):(aIOm;UM B Cpe,L\HeBeROBOM aJIaHCROM naCeJIeHIIU. IIpaB-
p;a, RaBHacuonCRUM BapuanT, xapaHTepnbIM ,L\JIJI 6aJIHapll,eB II HapalJaeBll,eB,
npep:CTaBJIeH II y ropnbIX rpynn oceTIIn. IIOCJIe):(nIIe, TaH me HaH U oceTIInbI
IIJIOCHOrOpbH, no HSbIRy, HaH uSBecTno, HBJIHIOTCH IIpHMbIMU nOTOMRaMII
aJIan 41. Op;naRO, nOCHOJIbRy B cpep;neBeHoBbIx MOrIIJIbnUHaX OceTuu, IIPII-
na):(JIemam;llX aJIanaM, npe):(cTaBJIen TO'T me YSHOJIUll,hIM, YMepenno p;JIunno-
rOJIOBhIM Tun, lJTO II B ,L\pyrux paMOHax CeBepnoro KaBHasa, II B 3TOM
CJIY1J:ae neT ocnOBanUM IIOJIaraTh, 1JTO "RaBRaCUOHCHIIM" BapIIaIIT BOCXO):(IIT R
aJIanaM.
ITPOllCX01R):(enue HaBHaCIIonCHoro BapIIanTa 6Y,L\eT nop;p06HO paCCMOTpeno
B CJIe):(yIOm;eM 01J:epHe. TaH HaH on IIpIIypOlJeH R ropnbIM paMonaM IJ;enT-
paJIbnOrO U CeBepnoro RaBHasa, TOJIbRO paCHonHII ,L\peBHUX MOrUJIbnIIHOB B
3TIIX palIOnax nOMoryT BhIHcnIITb ero renesuc. O)J,IIaRO CIIeuu<pUlJeCHIIe OCO-
6eHnOCTH 3'1'01'0 TIIna U ero BbIpamennOCTh y ropHbIX rpynII OceTUII, fpy-
SIIU II qepHecIIll yme CeM1J:aC rrOSBOJIHIOT nOCTaBIITh Bonpoc 0 HaHOM-TO 06-
meM ROMrrOHenTe, Borne,L\rneM B ux COCTaB. H. .fl. Mapp naSbIBaJI 3'1'0'1' ROM-
IIOHenT H<peTU1J:eCHUM. B TOll 06m;eM iPopMe, HOTOPYIO rrpu06peJIu ero npep;-
CTaBJIenllH 0 «H<peTu):(ax», nOTOMHaMU ROTOp:bIX, IIO ero MneHUIO, HBJIJIJIUCb
6ypIIrnRu na IIaMIIpe II 6aCHI'l na llIIpeneMcHoM IIOJIyocTpoBe, onu He Bblpa-
maIOT nIIHaHOM HonHpeTHOM UCTOpU1J:eCHOM peaJIbHOCTII. Op;naHO B npUMeHe-
nllll R IInTepeCYIOm;eMy Hac Bonpocy IIp06JIeMa RaHorO-TO 3TnU1J:eCROrO cy6-
CTpaTa, neCBO,L\UMoro H yme ynoMHnYTbIM, npII06peTaeT IIsBecTnyIO aHTyaJIb-
nOCTb. MomeT 6hITb, HaIIpIIMep, IIMeHHO C HIIM CBHsano cpaBHIITeJILnO
252
I:
MaOJIUpOBannoe IIOJIOmenIIe CBaHCROrO HSLIRa B CIICTeMe HapTBeJIbCRUX HSbI-
HOB. BOSMOmnO, lJTO UMennO C HIIM CBHSaHO U naJIII1J:Ue 06m;ero CJIOH B oce-
TUHCHOM II Rapa1J:aeBO-6aJIHapCHOM HSbIRaX, He CBop:UMoro nII R TIOpHCROM,
nIl R IIpanCHOM JIeHCUHe 42. TaHIIM 06pasoM, Cnell,II<pII1JeCHUe oc06ennocTII
anTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCROrO TIIIIa 6aJIHapll,eB IT HapalJaeBll,eB naBop;HT Ha MbICJIb 0
ue06Xo,L\UMOCTII nOIICHOB I1X reHeTIIlJeCHIIX cBHaeM B IIepBYIO OlJepe,L\b co
CBanaMU U ):(PyruMu BhICOROl'OpHbIMII rpynnaMII CeBepnoM fpYSIIU, nOCROJIb-
RY Hcno, 1JTO B <pOpMupOBaHIIII nOTOMHOB aJIaH, RaROBhIMII HBJIHIOTCH oceTII-
HbI, 06mUM cy6cTpaT, 0 ROTOpOM M):(eT pe1J:b, urpaJI nOp;lJIInenHYIO pO:!b.
PesYJIbTaTbI UCTOpUlJeCHOrO uCCJIep;OBanIIH HaR 6YP;TO 6hI nop;TBepm):(aIOT
naMelJeunyIO JIUHllIO cOIIOCTaBJIenIIM. JI. M. JIaBpoB npUBeJI y6e):(uTeJIbnhIe
p;oHaSaTeJIbCTBa pacCeJIenUH CBanOB lIO BaHcanCHOMY ym;eJIbIO B XVII B. 43
IIpe6bIBanue CBanOB B BepXOBbHX Ry6auu, nO-BU,L\IIMOMy, OTnOCUTCH R 60-
JIee panneM 3IIOXII U ,L\aTupyeTcH nOHa OlJenb npIIOJIIISUTeJIhHO, nepuop;OM
Mem,L\y XIV U XVII BB. 4 He UCHJII01J:enO, CJIe):(OBaTeJIbIIO, lJTO na TeppUTO-
pUll ropnoM 1J:aCTU nhIHernnux Rapa1J:aeBo-QepRecIIu U Ra6app;uno-BaJIHa-
prm CBanbI COIIpIIHaCaJIIICb C IIOJIOBll,aMU, SaCeJIUBrnIIMII, HaH YTBepmp;aeT
JI. M. JIaBpoB, 3TY TeppUTOpUIO IIO,L\ HaIIopoM TaTapO-MOnrOJIbCHUX opp; B
XIII B. fUIIoTesa, corJIacno ROTOpOM lJaCTb CBanOB BOCrrpUnHJIU HIIII1J:aHCRMM
HShIR U OCTaJIIICh B yRasannbIX paMOHax, y):(alJno paspernaeT Te Tpy):(nOCTII,
C HOTOpbIMII CTaJIRMBaIOTCH Bce OCTaJIbnhIe rIInOTeSbI RapalJaeBO-6aJIHapCROro
3Tnorenesa npII anaJIIIse UX B CBeTe aHTOB anTpOnOJIOrIIII. B paMRax 3TOM
rIInOTeSbI HaXO,L\IIT ce6e MeCTO U u):(eH 6aJIRapO-CBancHoro HShIROBOrO CHpe-
m;enIIH, C ROTOpOM Bce-TaHU neJIbSH He ClJllTaTbCH, XOTH ona II 6hIJIa BbICHa-
sana H. .fl. MappoM yme Torp;a, ROr,L\a on CTaJI «MappIICTOM)) 45. TaH IIJIU
I1nalJe, paCCMOTpeHue BceM COBORYIInOCTII anTpOIIOJIOrUlJeCHUX p;anHbIX, UMeIO-
m;IIX OTnornenue H np06JIe Ie npoucxom)J,enIIJI 6aJIRapll,eB U Rapa1J:aeBll,eB,
npUBop;IIT H BhIBO):(y, 1J:TO IICTOpIIlJeCHOe IICCJIe,L\OBanue ):(OJI/Kno UP;TU no JIU-
HIIII BhIHBJIeHIIH Cnell,II<pUlJeCHUX CBH3eM TIOpRCHIIX napO,L\HoCTeM RapalJaH II
BaJIHapUU C ropHbIMu rpynnaMII OceTuu U fpYSIIU, II B IIepBYIO OlJepeAb
CBaneTuu.
BbIBO]J;bI
1. RapalJaeBll,bI II 6aJIHapll,bI OTHOCHTCH R eBporreoII):(HoM 60JIbrnOM pace II ne
UMeIOT B CBoeM COCTaBe HIIHaHUX CJIe):(OB MOnrOJIOUp;nOM npIIMeCII.
2. BnYTpII eBpoIIeou)J,noM paCbI Hapa1J:aeBI(hI U 6aJIHapll,hI OTnOCHTCH R
HaBHacuonCHOMY BapuanTY, npe,L\CTaBJIennOMY B naII60JIee lJUCTOM Bup;e y
ropnbIX rpYIIII OceTUU U CeBepnOM fpYSUII.
3. OTCYTcTBue B COCTaBe RapalJaeBll,eB U 6aJIHapll,eB MOnrOJIOIl,L\noM IIPIl-
Mecu ,L\aeT BOSMO/KnOCTb HpUTUlJeCRU OTHeCTUCb H TIOpHCHOM rIlIIOTeae Rapa-
lJaeBo-6aJIHapCHOro 3Tnorenesa, a COIIOCTaBJIenUe COMaTOJIOrU1JeCRIIX Ha6JIIO-
p;enuM C IIaJIeOanTpOnOJIOrIllJeCHIIMU SaCTaBJIHeT OTBeprHYTb II aJIancHyIO
rUIIoTesy.
4. PaCCeJIeHIIe npep;cTaBIITeJIeM HaBHaCIIonCHoro BapIIanTa - CBanOB B
pallone HbIHernnero 06UTanIIH 6aJIRapll,eB U HapalJaeBll,eB B 3noxy cpep;neBe-
ROBhH, HaH U nOJInoe Tomp;eCTBo UX anTpOIIOJIOrII1J:eCHUX oc06ennOCTeM, IIO-
SBOJIHeT npe)J,nOJIaraTh, 1J:TO O<popMJIenUe TIOpHCHIIX HapO,L\nOCTeM hapalJaH II
BaJIHapIIU 6bIJIO IIpOll,eCCOM nepexop,a lJaCTH CBanOB UJIU, BOSMomno, RaHOM-
JIII60 ,L\pyroM BhICOHoropHOM rpynnbI MecTnoro naCeJIeHIIJI na RUnlJaRCHIIll:
HShIR.
5. IIpe):(JIaraeMaH rUIIOTesa Tpe6yeT cnell,uaJIbnOrO I1sylJenIIH IICTOpUlJe-
CHIIX IICTOlJHIIROB, RaH U 3Tnorpa<pU1J:eCHIIX II HShIROBbIX MaTepUaJIOB, B ll,e-
.'lHX BCHpbITUH cnell,I1<pU1JeCHUX CBHseM HapalJaeBo-6aJIHapll,eB II CBanOB,
253
a TaHme opraHM3aU:UII paCHOII01J:HbIX pa60T Ha TeppMTopUM KapalJaH, BaJI-
RapIIU II ropHbIX paMOHOB fpysuu, peSYJIhTaTOM HOTOpbIX p;OJImHO HBMTbCJI
HaHOrrJIeHUe naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrUlJeCHIIX II I{paHUOJIOrUlJeCHIIX MaTepUaJIOB II
BbIHCHenue reHesuca HaBHaCUOHCHoro BapuaHTa.
1 MUI>.aaute6cIWR H. H. HeROTOpbIe MaTeplIaJIbI no aHTpOnOJIOrlI1I HapO,lJ,OB .D:arecTa-
Ha II KpaT. COOOlI\. IIH-Ta 3THorpal!>IIII AH CCCP. 1953. BbIII. 19.
CM., Hanp.: rao:J/Cue6a C. m. KYMbIRII: HCT.-3THorp. IICCJIe,lJ,. M., 1961.
CPoH-3pl>epT P. CPo AHTpOnOJIOrlI'!eCRlle IISMepeHIIJI RaBRaSCRIIX HapO,lJ,OB II onlIcam!!.'
IIsMepeHHblx cYO'beRTOB II.HsB. KaBRas. OT,lJ,-HIIJI Pyc. reorp. O-Ba. TIII!>JIlIC, 1884-
1885. T. 8.
4 Bb!py606 H. A. OT'leT 0 nOeS,lJ,Re Ha KaBRas JIeTOM 1890 rO,lJ,a II Tp. aHTpOnOJI. OT,lJ,.
O-Ba JIIOOIITeJIeM eCTeCTBOSHaHIIJI, aHTpOnOJIOrIIII II 3THorpa1!>IIII. M., 1890. T. 12, BbIII. 9.
5 IIaHTIOX06 ll. ll. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'!ecRIIe HaOJIIO)J,eHIIJI Ha KaBRase. TIII!>JIIIC, 1983.
6 Sommier S. Note volanti sui Karatciai ed alcune misure di Abasa. Kabardini e Aba-
sekh II Arch. anthrop. e ethnol. Firenze, 1901. Vol. 31.
7 I11,YI>UH ll. C. MaTepIIaJIbI ,lJ,JIJI HsyqeHlIJI Rapa'!aeBn;eB II Pyc. aHTpOnOJI. mypH. 1913.
M 1/2.
8 JIe6uH B. ll. 3THo-reorpaI!>II'!eCRoe pacnpe,lJ,eJIeHHe HeROTopbIX paCOBbIX npHSHaROB y
HaCeJIeHIIJI CeBepHoro KaBRasa II AHTpOnOJI. mypH. 1932. M 2.
9 Hpxo A. ll. KpaTRIIM oosop aHTpOnOJIOrII'!ecRoro HsyqeHIIJI Typen;RIIX HapO,lJ,HocTeM
CCCP sa 10 JIeT (1924-1934) II TaM me. 1936. M 1; BYHal> B. B. AHTpOnOJIOrII'!eCRIIM
COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIJI RaBRasa II BecTH. I'oc. MyseJI I'PYSIIII. TOIIJIHCII, 1947. T. 13.
10 BYHal> B. B. YRas. co'!.
11 HaTuut6U.au A. H., A6oyute.auut6u.aU M. ll., A6oyute.auut6u.aU M. r. MaTepIIaJIbI 3RC-
ne;J;IIl\IIH 1950 rOiJ:a no aHTpOnOJIOrlUI COBpelVIeHHoro HaCeJIeIUIH I'PYSIIHCRO[i CCP II Tp.
HH-Ta 3RcneplIM. Mopl!>OJIOrHII AH I'CCP. TOIIJIIICII, 1953. T. 4; HaTuut6u.aU A. H., A6-
oyute.auut6u.aU M. r. IIpe,lJ,BapIITeJIbHble ,lJ,aHHbIe 00 aHTpOnOJIOrlI'!eCRIIX IICCJIe,lJ,OBa-
HIIHX rpYSIIHCRoro HapO,lJ,a II RpaT. cooom;. HH-Ta 3THorpal!>IIII AH CCCP. 1955. BbIII. 22.
12 A. eI>Cee6 B. II. fIpOIIcxomrreHIIe HapOn;OB KaBRasa: (KpaHlIOJI. IICCJIe,lJ,.). M., 1974.
TaM me CBO,lJ,Ra ,lJ,aHHbIX no cpe,lJ,HeBeRoBoMY HaCeJIeHIIIO CeBepHoro KaBRasa II OIIO-
JIlrorpal!>IIH.
13 Onpb!utl>O O. JI. PaHHexpIICTIIaHCRlIM MOrIIJIbHIIR B ceJI. BepXHlIM qereM KE ACCP
(pacRonRII 1960 r.) II COOPHIIR cTaTeM no IICTOpIIII Kaoapn;IIHO-EaJIRapIIII. HaJIb'!IIR,
1961.
14 g e'leHO 6 ll. M. .D: peBHOCTII HaOap,lJ,IIHO-EaJIRapIIII. HaJIb'lIIR, 1969.
15 JIa6po6 JI. ll. Kapa'!aM II EaJIRaplIH ,lJ,0 30-x rO,lJ,OB XIX B. II KaBRascRIIM 3THOrpal!>lI-
'!ecRIIM COOpHIIR. M., 1969. T. 4. C. 73.
16 Muaue6 ll. M. Cpe,lJ,HeBeRoBble RaMeHHbIe HID;IIRII B BepxHeif EaJIRapIIII II COB. apxeo-
JIOrIIH. 1971. M 4.
17 A. eI>Cee6 B. II. K naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHII Ka6ap,lJ,IIHO-EaJIRapIIII 3nOXII nOS,lJ,HerO cpe,lJ,-
HeBeROBbH II ApXeOJIOrlIH II BonpOCbI ,lJ,peBHeH IICTOpIIII Ka6ap,lJ,IIHO-EaJIRapIIII. HaJIb-
'lIIR, 1980. BbIII. 1.
18 A.ael>Cee6 B. n. IIpOIICXOm,lJ,eHIIe HapO,lJ,OB KaBRasa.
19 rU. bOeHutTeoT ll. A. I'eorpal!>II'!eCRoe H CTaTIICTII'!eCRoe onIIcaHIIe I'PYSHII II KaBRa-
sa. ClIo.. 1809.
20 mapOeH iR. lIYTerneCTBIIe RaBaJIepa IIIap,lJ,eHa no 3aRaBRaSbIO B 1672-1673 rO,lJ,ax II
KaBRP3. BeCTH. TnI!>JIlfC, 19()". N2 8; .J1a.M6epTtL A. OrHIcaIIlle I{OJIXlf;:J;bI IIJIlI MlfHrpc-
JIlIll II 3an. O,lJ,ec. O-Ba HCTOplflf If ,lJ,peBHOCTII. O,lJ,ecca, 1877. T. 10.
21 JIaunaHo6 X. O. K lfCTOpHII Rapa'!aeBl\eB II OaJIRapn;eB. qepReccR, 1957.
22 TalVI me.
23 BaCI>al>06 H. A. KJIaCclfl!>lfRan;lfH TIOpRCKHX HSbIROB B CBHSII C lfCToplf'!eCROH nepIIO-
,lJ,lfSan;lfeM lfX pa3BlfTlfH H l!>opMIIpoBaHlIH II Tp. HH-Ta HSbIR03HaHIIH. M.. 1952. T. 1;
Oil, :J/Ce. BBe,lJ,eHlfe B II3yqeHlle TIOpRCRIIX HSbIROB. M., 1962; 2-e HS,lJ,. 1969.
24 CM. OlfOJIlfOrpaI!>IIIO: JIaunaHo6 X. O. YRas. CO'!.
25 TaM me.
26 IIpoapure.ae6 r. H. Ma)J,mapbI - O,lJ,IIH HS ,lJ,peBHeiIIIIIIx ropo,lJ,OB CeBepHoro HaBRasa.
CTaBpOnOJIb. 1906.
27 rOpOOlf06 B. A. PeSYJIbTaTbI apXeOJIOrlf'!eCRIIX IICCJIe,lJ,OBaHHH Ha MeCTe paSBaJIIIH
r. Ma,lJ,mapbI B 1907 ro,lJ,Y. M., 1911.
28 MUHae6a T. M. 30JIOTOOp,lJ,bIHCRIIH ropO,lJ, Ma,lJ,map II MaTepIIaJIbI no H3yqeHIIIO CTaB-
pOnOJIbCROrO RpaH. CTaBpOnOJIb, 1953. BbIII. 5; OHa :J/Ce. O'!epRlI no apXeOJIOnUI CTaB-
pOnOJIbH. CTaBpOnOJIb. 1965.
29 JIaunaHo6 X. O. YRa3. co'!. C. 9.
254
I
:so runa6ype B. B. AHTpOnOJIOrll1JeCI\IIe MaTepI!aJIbI R rrp06JIeMe rrpOlfCX01l\,lJ,eHI!H Hace-
JIeHlIR XasapCRoro RaraHaTa II C6. MyseH aHTpOrrOJIOnm: I! 3THorpa<pl!l! AH CCCP.
M.; 31., 1951. T. 13; CTaTblI 31. r. BYI!'l, B. B. rI!Hs6ypra II B. B. IDlIpIIITeHH, orry6JII!-
ROBaHHbIe B: Tp. BOJIro-]J,oHcROII apxeOJI. 3Rcrre,lJ,I! I!I!. M.; JI., 1963. T. 3. (MaTepI!a-
JIbI II IICCJIe,lJ,. no apxeOJIorI!I! CCCP; M 109).
31 ApTa.MOH08 M. ll. O'lepRlI ,lJ,peBHeHIIIeiI IICTOplIlI xasap. 31., 1936.
32 /l,e6elf r. <P. AHTpOrrOJIOrI!'leCRlIH COCTaB Cpe,lJ,HeBeROBbIx rOpO,lJ,OB KpbIMa II C6. My-
seH aHTporrOJIOrlIII II 3THorpa<pI!II AH CCCP. M.; 31., 1949. T. 12.
33 A.WKcee8 B. Ii. IIpOH<:XOfIi;J;eHlIe HapO;:J:on KaBlmsa.
3 Ca.MOU.W8U'l A. H. KaBRas I! Type RlIH llHrp. BaRY, 1926; JIaunaHo8 X. O. YRas. CO'l.;
JIa8poB JI. ll. IIpOI!CX01l\)J,eHlIe Ra6aPAlIH eB I! SaCeJIeHlIe I!MII HbIHeIIIHeH TeppIITO-
pIlI! II COB. 3THorpa<pI!H. 1956. N2 1.
35 XOOHeB H. 3aMeTRII 0 ,lJ,peBHIIX HaSBaHI!HX RaBRaSCRIIX HapO,lJ,OB II KaBRas. 1867. N2 45.
36 Mu.a.aep B. <P. OCeTI!HCRIIe 3TIO,lJ,bI. q. III II Y'leH. san. MocH. YH-'l'a. 1887. BbIII. 8.
37 repaCU.MOBa M. M. CReJIeTbI ,lJ,peBHI!X 60JIrap lIS paCRorrOR y c. KaH6eJIbI II Tp. IIH-Ta
3THorpa<plII! AH CCCP. H. C. M., 1956. T. 33.
38 Ba.wH M., Boe8 n. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'leCRlIe MaTepIIaJIbI OT HeKpOrrOJIa rrpII HOBII rraaap II
lIsB. lIO apxeOJI. IIH-Ta I. CO<p1IH., 1955. KH. 20.
39 MepnepT H. H. K BOlIpOCy 0 ,lJ,peBHeHIIIlIX 60JIrapCRlIX rrJIeMeHax. KasaHb, 1957.
40 CM. 6lIo.:IlI0rpaiPIIIo: .J1aunaHo8 X. O. YRas. CO'l.
41 A6ae8 B. ll. OCeTIIHCRIIH HSbIR II <POJIbRJIOp. M.; 31., 1949. T. 1.
42 OH :J/Ce. 06m;I!e 3JIeMeHTbI B HSbIRe OCeTI!H, 6aJIRap eB II Rapa'laeB eB II HSbIR II MbI-
IIIJIeHI!e. 31., 1933. T. 1.
43 JIaBpo8 JI. ll. PacceJIemIe CBaHOB Ha CeBepHoM KaBRase ,lJ,O XIX B.II KpaT. coo6m;.
IIH-Ta 3THorpa<pI!I! AH CCCP. 1950. BbIIl. 10.
44 TaM 1I\e.
45 Mapp H. H. BaJIRapO-CBaHCRoe CRpem;eHI!e IllIs6p. pa60TbI. JI., 1937. T. 4.
AHTPOIIOJIOrlfllECRME ,ZJ;AHHbIE
M IIPOMCXOm,ZJ;EHME OCETMHCROrO HAPO,ZJ;A
IICTOPIIH 113YQEHIIH
Ha1J:aJIo aHTpOnOJIOrII1J:eCHOrO uSY1J:eHJ1£H Hapo,L\OB RaBHasa nap;aeT Ha 80-e
rO)J,bI IIpOrnJIOro BeHa. R 3TOMy me BpeMeHH OTHOCIITCH U Ha1J:aJIO aHTpono-
MeTpUlJeCHOrO HSYlJeHIIH oceTUH. OHO CBHsaHO C ):(eHTeJIbIIOCTbIO P. <1>. 8p-
HepTa, Ha rrpoTHmeHuu HeCHOJIhHIIX JIeT saHUMaBrnerOCR aHTponOMeTpueM
MHorIIX ceBepoHaBHaSCHHX U saHaBHaSCHHX Hapo):(oB. Cpep;II npo1J:UX OH IIpO-
U3BeJI aIITpOnOMeTpIIlJeCHIIe HSMepeHI£H 16 oceTIIH 1. O):(HOBpeMeHHO C
P. $. 8pHepTOM Ha RaBHase pa60TaJI 8. lliaHTp. OCHOBHbIM ero SaHHTlIeM
6hIJIO UCCJIe,L\OBaHIIe apxeOJIOrU1J:eCHUX naMHTHUHOB RaBHasa, HO OH B COOT-
BeTCTBIIH C Tpa):(Hll,IIeM HOMIIJIeHCHOCTU, rocno):(cTBoBaBrnelI B HaYHe 0 1J:eJIO-
BeHe B HOHll,e npornJIoro CTOJIeTUH, TaHme npOIlSBO,L\UJI aHTpoIIOMeTpHlJeCHOe
IISYlJeHUe COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHUH. I1M HSYlJeHO 18 oceTIIH 2. HapH,L\Y C
aHTporrOMeTpH1JeCHUMII Ha6JIIOp;eHUHMlI nepBbIe rnaru RaBHasclwM aHTpOnOJIO-
rIIu, HaH II Bo06m;e aHTpOrrOJIOrII1J:eCHOM HaYHII, CBHsaHbI U C BusyaJIbHbIMU
BnelJaTJIeHIIHMU 0 <pII3UlJeCHOM Tune HapO):(OB RaBHasa Bpa1J:eM, 3THorp a <p OB ,
npaBIITeJIbCTBeHHhIx 1J:IIHOBHUHOB, BoeHHbIX, IIYTerneCTBeHHIIHOB. Cpe,L\U Ha-
6:IIO,L\eIIHM mIlSHU U 6bITa HaBHaSCRHX Hapo,L\oB, uHorp:a BamHbIX Ii IInTepec-
HbIX ,L\ame ceiIlJac, uHor,L\a nOBepXHOCTHbIX, BCTpe1J:aIOTCH U oT,L\eJIbHhIe sa-
Me1JaHHH 06 ux <pHSIIlJeCHOM Tune, aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH RaH 6bI HesaMeTHO BbIpac-
TaeT us 3THorpa<pUH. B RalJeCTBe IIpHMepa P;JIH OceTUII YHamy IIYTeBOM
OlJepH R. H. POCCUHOBa 3.
Ha nOCJIe,L\Hee ):(eCHTIIJIeTUe npornJIoro BeHa na,L\aeT HalJaJIO II paCll,BeT
,L\eHTeJIhHOCTU P;BYX aHTpOIIOJIOrOB, MHoro c):(eJIaBrnHX P;JIH IISY1JeHUH aHTpo-
nOJIorIlIl KaBRa3a B ll,eJIOM II OceTUII B lJaCTHOCTU,- H. B. fUJIhlJeHHO II
255
Ii
M. M. IIanTIOxoBa. H. B. fIIJIb1J:enRO OROH1J:MJI BOeHHO-Mep;MD;IInCRyIO aRap;e-
MIIIO B IIeTep6ypre, 6hIJI O):(HIIM lIS nepBhIX YlJeHIIROB HSBeCTHoro PYCCKoro
aHTpOnOJIOra, npo<peccopa Ra<pep;phI HOpMaJIhHOM aHaTOMIIII BoeHHO-Mep;II-
D;lInCROM aRa):(eMIIII A. M. TapeHell,ROI'O 4 II IIepBhIM Sam;IITIIJI P;ORTOpCRyIO
p;HCCepTall,IIIO no aHTpOIIOJIOrIIII. 06'beMIICTaJI p;IIccepTaD;IIJI ero 6hIJIa nOCBJI-
m;ena aHTpOIIOJIOrlIII oceTIIH 5. MaTepHaJI ):(JIJI Hee H. B. fIIJIhlJeHRO c06paJI
Cpe,L\II BOenHOCJIymam;IIX na RaBR3se. B OTJIWIIIe 0'1' P. $. 8pRepTa II
8. IllaIITpa, B pacnOpJImeHIIH ROTOphIX 6hIJIII JIHrnb e):(IIHIIlJHhIe Ha6JIIO.o:e-
HIIJI nap, aHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCRIIM TIIllOM oceTIIH, H. B. fIIJIh1J:eHRO IISYlJIIJI
200 1JeJIOBeR - 06rnIIpnhIM P;JIJI TOro BpeMeIUI MaTepHaJI. ECJUI YlJeCTh, lJTO
nporpaMMa IISMepenIIM ero 6hIJIa 01JeHh no):(p06na II BRJIIOlJaJIa onpe):(eJIeHIIJI
neCROJIhKIIX ):(eCJITROB ne TOJIhRO MOP<P0JIOrIIlJeCRHX, HO II <pIIsIIOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX
npiiSHaROB, TO Momno CRasaTb, 1J:TO pa60ThI H. B. fIIJIblJeHRO TaR II He
6hIJIII npeBSOMP;eHhI p;o peBOJIIOll,IIH no cBoeMY RalJeCTBenHoMY II ROJIlIlJeCT-
BeHnoMY ypOBIIIO. IIpaB):(a, M. 11. lIaHTIOxoB IISMeplIJI 258 oceTIm B IOmHoH
OceTIIII (MaTeplIaJI c06IIpaJIcJI cpep;II npIIshIBnhlx), HO IICnOJIhSOBannaJI IIM
nporpaMMa IISMepenHM BRJIIOlJaJIa onpe.o:eJIeHIIH Bcero JIIIrnh HeCROJIhRIIX
npIISHaROB 6. Op;naRO P;OCTOIIHCTBO MaTepIIaJIOB, c06paHnhIX M. M. IIanTIO-
XOBhIM, SaRJIIOlJaJIOCh B ):(pyrOM - B rnHpOROM OXBaTe Hapop;OB CeBepnoro
RaBRasa II 3aRaBRaShJI, HOTOphIM nOSBOJIHJI npOIISBeCTII cpaBneHlIe anTpono-
JIOrIIlJeCRIIX oc06ennOCTeM paSHhIX Hapop;OB II P;O RaROM-TO CTeneHH BhIJIBIITb
IIX aIITpOnOJIOrIIlJeCROe cBoe06paSIIe. Oc06enno BhIl'Op;HOe BnelJaTJIeHIIe B
3TOM OTIIOrnenHII npOIISBO):(IIT 0606Ill,aIOIll,aJI pa60Ta M. M. IIanTIOXOBa, BhI-
me):(rnaJI na Py6eme npornJIoro H Hamero CTOJIeTMM II OCHOBanHaJI na IISMe-
peIUIJIX 60JIee lJeM 10000 1J:eJIOBeR 7. Ho TeOpeTIIlJeCRHe nOJIOmeHIIJI 3'1'01'0
C01JIIHenIIH OTCTaIOT p;ame 0'1' ypOBIIJI PyccROll HaYRII '1'01'0 BpeMenll II cop;ep-
maT B sapO):(hlrne Te paCIICTCRlle BSrJIJI;:J;hI, ROTOphIMII 11. M. IIanTIOxoB TaR
nelJaJIhnO npOCJIaBHJICH B nOCJIeP;YIOIll,Ue rO):(hI.
KaROBhI TeOpeTII1JeCRIIe IITorii Bcex 3TIIX IICCJIep;OBanHM? Oll,enRa IIX MO-
meT 6bITL 06'be):(IIHena C paCCMOTpenIIeM IICTOpUU anTpOnOJIOrUlJeCKOrO IISY-
1JenHJI oceTUH B HalJaJIe XX B. (p;O 1917 1'.), TaR RaR TeOpeTIIlJeCI{UM
ypOBenh PYCCRIIX aIITpOnOJIOrlI IeCRHX IICCJIep;OBanMM na RaBRase ne marHYJI
sa 3TII rO):(hI Bnepe):( CROJIbRO-nu6Y):(h SaMeTIlhIM 06paSOM, a nOBhIX nOJIeBhIX
IIa6JIIO)J,enIIM, c60pa HOBhIX anTponOMeTplI1JeCRHX MaTepIIaJIOB He npOIISBOP;II-
JIOCL. H. B. fIIJIblJeHRO, OTMeTIIB RpaTRoe ynoMIIIIanIIe AMMHanOM Mapll,eJI-
JIHnOM CneTJIOBOJIOCOC,TII aJIan, oc060 OCTanOBIIJICJI na Te iHOM IIIIl'J\renTaD;IIII
oceTIIn. On IIOJIaraJI, lJTO nOTeMnenIIe oceTIIn no cpaBnenIIIO C aJIanaMII BhI-
SBalIO orernenlIeM C MOnrOJIaMII IIJIII TaTapaMII. TaRIIM 06pasoM, no ero
MnenlIIO, B COCTaBe oceTlIn MomeT 6hITh OTMelJena MOnrOJIOII)J,HaH npIIMecb.
R aHaJIornlJUoMY BhIBogy JIpIIrneJI A. H. XapysIIn, ne npoIIsBo):(HBrnHlI caMO-
c,TOJITeJIbnLIX IICCJIe):(oBanlIlI cpep;II OCeTIIn, HO conocTaBIIBrnIIll pesYJIbTaThI
IIsMepenIIli: H. B. fIIJIblJenRO C IIsMepenlIHMH TIOpRCRIIX Hapop;oB, c):(eJIanHhI-
MII ):(PyrIIMII IICCJIe)J,oBaTeJIJIMII. On yme onpe):(eJIenno BhICRaShIBaJICJI B nOJIb-
sy '1'01'0, lJTO MOnl'OJIOII):(naH nplIMecb B COCTaBe oceTIIII 06JISaHa CBOIIM npo-
IIcxomD,eIIIIeM CMernenIIIO IIX C TlOpRCRIIMII napo):(aMII 8. B CBo):(nOM pa60Te
no aIITpOlIOJIOrIIII POCCIIII A. A. IIBanoBcRIIM nO):(1JepRnYJI cBoeo6pasIIe aHT-
pOnOJIOrII1JeCIWrO TIIna oceTIIH II 060c06JIenHOe nOJIOmeHIIe IIX cpep;II ):(pyrIIx
Hapop;oB CeBepnoro RaBRasa II 3aRaBHaSbJI 9. On BbI):(eJIIIJI OC06hIM oceTIIn-
CRIIM BaplIanT II YKaSaJI na CXO):(CTBO ero C apMJInCRIIM Ii Ra6app;IInCRIIM.
B CJIep;YIOm;eM 0606Ill,aIOIll,eM pa6OTe, OXBaThIBaIOm;eM yme HaCeJIeHHe Bcero
seMHoro mapa, A. A. MBaHOBCRIIM BhI):(eJIIIJI OCeTIIHO-Ra6ap):(IIHCRYIO anTpo-
nOJIOrlI IeCRYIO 06Ill,HOCTb, npII):(aB 3TIIM 60JIbrnee SnalJenHe, no ero MnenIIIO,
aIITponOJIOrII IeCROMY CXO):(CTBY Mellip,y OCeTIIHaMII II Ra6app;IIHll,aMII II RaH
256
Ii
6hI nOA'IepRHYB 8TIIM IIX reHeTIIlJeCROe pO):(CTBO 10. Ho BhIBOP;hI A. A. IIBa-
HOBCROrO, OCHOBaHHhIe Ha <pOpMaJIhHOM CTaTIICTM1JeCROM aHaJIIISe, He BCTpe-
TIIJIII C01J:YBCTBeHHoro OTHOrneHllJI B PYCCROM HayHe, Heop;HORpaTHO nop;Bep-
raJIHCh RplITIIRe II OCTaJUICh Hap;OJIrO npIIMepOM Toro, RaR a6CTpaRTHhIe Ma-
TeMaTlIlJeCRIIe yMcTBOBaHIIJI, OTopBaHHhIe 0'1' ROHRpeTHoro MaTepIIaJIa JiI
npIIJIaraeMhIe R He MY Ha He):(OCTaT01J:HO npo<peCCllOHaJIhHOM ypOBHe, SaBOp;JIT
IICCJIep;OBaTeJIJI B TynlIR 11.
06Ill,aJI Oll,enRa POJIII,BCeX nepelJlICJIeHHhIX pa60T B HCTOplIII aHTpOnOJIO-
rlllJeCHOrO IIsYlJeHHJI oceTllH onpep:eJIHeTCJI HarneM Oll,eHRoM MeToi'JOJIOrIIII II
MeTo):(llRII p;OpeBOJIIOll,IIOHHhIX IICCJIe):(oBaIIIIM B 06JIaCTII pacoBep;eHIIJI Bo06-
m;e H He MOiKeT 6hITb BhICOROM - Bce 3TII pa60ThI npep;CTaBJIJIIOT B HaCTOJI-
m;ee BpeMJI JIIIrnb IICToplIorpa<plIlJeCRIIM IIHTepec. MeTOp;OJIOrlIlJeCRII OHII
RpaMIIe HeCOBeprneIIHhI, XOTJI aBTophI II UCnOJIhSOBaJIJil aIITponOJIOrM1JeCRHH
MaTeplIaJI He TOJIbRO P;JIJI BhIp;eJIeHIIJI II xapaRTepIICTIIRII aHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX
TunOB, HO H P;JIJI YCTaHOBJIeHIIJI pO):(CTBa MeiKP;Y HIIMII, HO p;eJIaJIOCb 3'1'0
OlJeHh HeCIICTeMaTIIlJeCRH, Ha OCHOBaIIIIH CJIYlJaMHO BhI6paHHhIX IICXOP;HhIX
nOJIOiKeHIIii, HHorp;a npII 3TOM IICnOJIhSOBaJIIICh <popMaJIhHhIe CTaTIICTM1JeCRIIe
nplIeMhI. OTCIO):(a II npOIISBOJIhHhIe BhIBOP;hI 0 HaJIH1J:UH MOHrOJIOII):(HOH npII-
MeCJiI B COCTaBe oceTIIH, 0 pop;CTBe IIX C Ra6ap):(IIHll,aMII, 'ITO He nop;TBepp;II-
JIOCb B xop;e p;aJIhHeMrnllX IICCJIep;OBaHIIM. HelJeTROCTb MeTOp;OJIOrIIlJeCRllX
yCTaHoBOR OTpaiKaJIa MeTO):(lIlJeCRYIO CJIa60CTh npOBop;IIMhIX HCCJIe.r:\OBaHIIii:
B nOp;aBJIJIIOIll,eM 60JIhrnIHICTBe CJIYlJaeB BeCh c06paHHhIM MaTepIIaJI 6hIJI
RpaMHe MaJIOlJllCJIeH (pa60ThI P. $. 8pRepTa H 8. IllaHTpa), nporpaMMa IIS-
MepeHIIM OTJIII1J:aJIaCb HenOJIHOTOH (pa60ThI II. II. IIaHTIOxoBa), p;aHHhIe pas-
HhIX aBTopOB BCJIe):(CTBIIe nplIMeHeHIIJI B nOJIe paSJUIlJHhIX npIIeMoBIIsMepeHIIlI
6hIJIII nJIOXO cpaBHIIMhI P;Pyr C p;pyrOM. B nporpaMMe llsMepeHIIM nOlJTII 0'1'-
CYTCTBOBaJIO onpep;eJIeHIIe TaR HaShIBaeMhIX OIIllCaTeJIhHhIX npIISHaROB, T. e.
CTpOeHIIJI OTp;eJIhHhIX p;eTaJIeH JIJilll,a, a IIMeHHO OHII JIBJIJIIOTCJI OCHOBHhIMJiI
npII BhIp;eJIeHIIII II RJIaCCll<pHRaD;IIII aHTpOnOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX TIInOB II YCTaHOBJIe-
HIIII IIX reHeTIIlJeCRIIX BsaIIMOOTHomeHIIH. IIcRJIIO'IeHIIe COCTaBJIJIJIa HaII60JIee
nOJIHaJI pa60Ta H. B. rIIJIb'IeHRO, HO c06paHHhIH JilM MaTepIIaJI nOBJilCaJI B
Bosp,yxe lIs-sa OTCYTCTBllJI aHaJIOrJillJRhIX cpaBHIITeJIhHhIX p;aHH:bIX. BOJIhnmM
He):(OCTaTROM Bcex ):(opeBOJIIOD;IIOHHhIX ny6JIIIRaD;IIM no aHTpOnOJIOrIIII oceTHH
6hIJIO TO, 'ITO HX <pIISJillJeCRIIe oc06eHHOCTH paCCMaTpIIBaJIIICh CYMMapHO, 6es
nonhITRII BhIJIBIITh aHTpOnOJIOrM1JeCROe cBoe06pasIIe OTp;eJIbHhIX TeppIITOpII-
aJIhHhIX II 3THorpa<pM1JeCRIIX rpynn. B 06Ill,eM, nOBTOpJIIO, IICnOJIbSOBaTh aHT-
pOnOJIOrll1J:eCRHM MaTepIIaJI no OCeTIIHaM, c06paHHhIH ):(opeBOJIIOD;IIOHHhIMll
IICCJIep;OBaTeJIJIMII, B HaCTOHm;ee BpeMJI 1JpeSBhIlJaMHO TPYP;HO.
B nepBoe nOCJIepeBOJIIOIUIOHHoe p:eCJITIIJIeTIIe OCHOBHoe BHIIMaHHe 6hIJIO
y):(eJIeHO YCOBeprneHCTBOBaHIIIO MeTOiJ:IFIeCROM CTOpOHhI aIITpOnOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX
IICCJIe):(oBaHHM. IllIIpORaJI paspa60TKa np06JIeM Mop<pOJIOrllii lJeJIOBeRa, ocy-
m;eCTBJIeHHaJI B IIIIcTHTYTe aHTpOnOJIOrIIII npII MOCIWBCROM rocy):(apCTBeHHOM
YHIIBepCIITeTe no):( PYROBO):(CTBOM B. B. BYHaRa, IIOSBOJIIIJIa Bhlpa60TaTh HaII-
60JIee ll,eJIec006pasHYIO nporpaMMY paCOBe):(lJeCRIIX IICCJIep;OBaHIIM, B ROTOpOH
OCHOBHoe MeCTO SaHJIJIII onIICaTeJIhHhIe npiiSHaRII. ,l];JIJI RaiKp;oro npIISHaRa
6hIJIII npep;JIOiKeHhI lJeTRaJI RJIaCclI<pIIRall,IIJI ero BapIIall,IIM II Y):(06HhIe cno-
C06hI <pIIRCall,HII IIX npJil nOJIeBOM 3Rcnep;Illl,IIOHHOM pa6OTe. Bce 3'1'0 saCJIY-
iKIIBaeT cnell,IIaJIhHOro ynoMHHaHIIH IIOTOMY, lJTO C C06JIIOP;eHHeM 3TIIX MeTO-
p;lIlJeCRIIX npIIHll,IInOB pa60TamI B 1925-1927 rr. Ha RaBRase Bce 3RCneD,IIll,JilII
MHcTHTYTa aHTpOnOJIOrIIII. OXBalJeHhI 6hIJIH OCHOBHhIe HapO):(hI RaR CeBepHo-
ro RaBRasa, TaR Ii 3aRaBHaSbJI, B TOM lJIICJIe II oceTIIHhI. Ho ROJIHlJeCTBeHHO
coopaHHhIH MaTepIIaJI He npeBhIrnaJI C60PhI H. B. fIIJIhlJeHRO - B HeM Bce
oceTIIHhI 6hIJIII npep;CTaBJIeHhI CYMMapHO - II R TOMY »te OCTaJICJI Ha npo-
I
I
I
9 B. II. AJICRCCCB
257
TJIiKeHIIII 20 JIeT Heorry6JIUKOBaHHI,IM. IIo CYTII geJIa, HeOCBoeHHI,IMII II He-
JilCrrOJII,SOBaHHI,IMII OCTaJIIICI, TaRiKe nepBhIe gaHHI,le rro pacrrpep;eJIeHIIIO
rpyrrrr RpOBII Y oceTIIH, orry6JIIIROBaHHI,Ie E. M. CeMeHcRoM B BIlge RpaTKoM
Ta6JUIlJHOM CBOgKII 12. CBO;D;Ra 3Ta cogepiKIIT cBegeHIIJI TOJII,KO 0 pacrrpege-
JIeHUII reHeTIIlJeCRIIX <paKTOpOB CIICTeMI,I ABO II B HaCTOJIm;ee BpeMJI, Rorga
OTRphIThI geCJITRII gpyrIIx CIICTeM, rrpeL(CTaBJIJIeTCJI YCTapeBrneM. RpOMe
Toro, Bce 3THorpa<pIIlJeCKUe rpyrrrrI,I B COCTaBe oceTIIHCRoro Hapoga npegcTaB-
JIeHhI B Hell CYMMapHO, KaK II B COMaTOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX MaTeplIaJIaX; no OHa Bce
»te ;D;onYCRaJIa cpaBHeHIIe cepOJIOrM1JeCROM xapaKTepIICTHKII oceTIIH C TaRO-
BOM p;pyrIIx ceBepoRaBKasCRIIx II saKaBKaSCRHX HapO;D;oB, lJTO, ogHaRo, He
6I,IJIO cgeJIaHO.
AHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCKIIe MaTepIIaJII,I, c06paHHI,Ie 3RcrregHll,HJIMII IIHcTIITYTa
aIITpOrrOJIOrIUI Ha CeBepHOM RaBKase, B TOM lJIICJIe II B OceTIIU, 6I,IJIII orry6-
JIHKOBaHI,I YiKe rrOCJIe OTelJeCTBeHHoM BOMHI,I B CTaTI,e B. B. BYHaKa 13.
Ho SHalJeHlIe ee He TOJII,KO B 3TOM. B. B. BYHaR nOL(BeJI lIT or BceM rrpeg-
rneCTBYIOm;UM HCCJIegoBaHHHM II Ha OCHOBaHIIII c06paHHI,IX HM caMIIM II gpy-
rIIMII gaHHI,Ix paspa60TaJI II rrpegJIOiKUJI ygalJHYIO RJIaCcII<pHKall,IIIO aIITpOrrO-
JIOrIIlJeCKIIX TIIrrOB CeBepHoro RaBRasa II 3aKaBRaSI,JI. IIplIMeHIITeJII,HO R
HarneM TeMe 60JII,maJI sacJIyra B. B. BYHaRa SaKJIIOlJaeTCH B TOM, ITO on
ygeJIIIJI 60JII,rnOe BHIIMaHIIe BapIIall,lIJIM rnIIpUHI,I JIIIll,a - rrpHSHaRa, KaR
ORaSaJIOCI, nOTOM, pernaIom;ero SHalJeHUJI gJIJI ;D;uarHOCTIIRII aHTpOrrOJIOrlIlJe-
CRIIX TIIrrOB Ha RaBKase - U BhI;'),eJIUJI Crrell,IIaJII,HI,IM rrpHTepeKCRHM BapIIaHT,
npegcTaBHTeJIII ROToporo OTJIUlJaIOTCJI rnupORHM JIIIll,OM II MaCCIIBHOCTI,IO lJe-
pena. BapIIaHT 3TOT RaR pas II JIOKaJIIISOBaH, no MHeHHIO B. B. BYHaKa,
npelIMym;eCTBeHHO B 3THorpa<pIIlJeCRIIX rpynrrax oceTHHCKoro Hapoga. Ho II
B pacrropHiKeHIlII B. B. BYHaRa, HeCMOTpJI Ha TO lJTO OH BBeJI B HaYlJHI,IM
060POT MHoro HOBI,IX ;D;aHHhIX, He 6I,IJIO IIClJepnI,IBaIOm;IIX MaTepIIaJIOB rro
BceM HapogaM RaBRasa, aHTpOnOJIOrM1JeCRIIM TIIrr RaiKp;oro Hapop;a paCCMaT-
pUBaJICJI CYMMapHO, rpaHIIll,I,I BI,IgeJIeHHI,IX aIITpOnOJIOrHlJeCRIIX TImOB 6I,IJIII
HaMelJeHI,I n08TOMY JIlIrnI, npU6JIIISIITeJII,HO II He OTJIIIlJamICI, gocTaTOlJHOM
lJeTROCTbIO. IIocJIe pa60ThI B. B. BYHaRa, OlJeHI, 06CTOJITeJII,HOM II rJIyooRoM
no COL(epiKaHHIO, CTa:IO oc06eHHo JICHO BHgHO, lJTO Ha OlJepegII CTOIIT IISYlJe-
HIIe aHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCROrO COCTaBa RaBKasa BO BceM MHoro06pasIIH TeppHTO-
pIIaJII,HI,IX BapHall,HM, T. e. OXBaT aHTpOnOJIOrHlJeCKIIM HCCJIeiJ,OBaHueM OCHOB-
HhIX 3THorpa<pIIlJeCRIIX rpynn Bcex HapO;'),OB RaBKasa, BI,I.r:\eJIeHIIe, xapaRTe-
pHCTIIRa. BhIJICHenIIe reHeaJIOrII IeCHIIX BsaIIMOOTHorneHIIM He TOJII,HO OCHOB-
HI,IX aHTpOnOJIOrU IeCHUX TIIrrOB, no H JIORaJII,HI,IX BapIIaHTOB B COCTaBe 3TIIX
THnOB. iho MepOnpIIJITIIe OCYIll,eCTBJIJIJIOCI, Ha npOTJIiKeHHII nOCJIe.r:\HUX 15 JIeT.
COMATOJIOrIm II TIIIIOJIOI'lIqECRAH XAP ARTEPIICTIIRA
HaH6oJII,rnyIO pOJII, B TaHOM CrrJIOmHOM aIITpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCHOM o6CJIeP;OBaHI2II2I
Hapop;OB RaBRasa, BRJII01JalOm;eM MaJII,Ie HapogI,I Ii .r:\aiKe MeJIRIIe 3THorpa-
<pH1JeCHIIe rpynrrI,I, CI,lrpaJUI MHOrOJIeTHHe 3Rcrrep;Ull,IIII IIHcTHTYTa 3Rcrrepn-
MeHTaJII,HOM MOp<pOJIOrIHI AHa.r:\eMIIII HaYH rpYSIIHCROM CCP rrog PYROBOP;CT-
BOM A. H. HaTIIIIIBIIJIH II saTeM M. r. A6gyrneJIIIrnBHJIII "'. IIpaRTIIlJeCRII
TOJIbRO ,l];arecTaH II Asep6aM;D;iKaH OCTaJIHCb He 06CJIegoBaHHI,IMII 3Kcrrep;u-
ll,UJIMII rpYSIIHCRHX aIITporrOJIOrOB, BCJI OCTaJII,HaJI TeppiiTOpIIJI RaR CeBepHoro
RaBRasa, TaR II 3aRaBRaSI,JI 6hIJIa OXBalJeHa C rrpIIMeHeHHeM HOBefuneM aHT-
porrOMeTpIIlJeCROM MeTogIIHII. HapogI,I Asep6aMp;iKaHa 6I,IJIH uCCJIep;OBaHI,I B
3TII iKe rO;D;I,I asep6aMgiKancRIIMII aHTpOrrOJIOraMII, pa60TaBrnHMII rr0.r:\ PYRO-
BOP;CTBOM r. $. ,l];e6ell,a 15. HaROHell" HapO;'),I,I ,l];arecTaHa 6I,IJIII IISYlJeHI,I
'IaCTII1JnO r. cD. Ae6ell,OM 16 II saTeM A. r. ra;D;iKIIeBhIM 17, BI,IrO.r:\HI,IM OT-
258
JUI'UIeM pa60TI,I KOTOpOrO 6I,IJIO TO 06CTOJITeJII,CTBO, 'ITO OH C06IIpaJI cepo-
JIOrII'IeCKIIe II ):(epMaTOrJIII<pM1JeCKJ2Ie ):(aHHI,Ie 18. TaKIIM 06paSOM. B peSYJII,Ta-
Te BCeM 3TOM 60JII,mOM MHOrOJIeTIIeM p;eJITeJII,HOCTH y):(aJIOCI, BrrepBI,Ie rrOJIY-
'IIITI, MaTepIIaJII,I, p;OCTaTOlJHO nOJIHhIe P;JIJI p;eTaJII,HOM Mop<pOJIOrIIlJeCKOM xa-
paRTepIICTIIKH KaBKaSCKJIX HapO):(OB, II COCTaBIITI, IIClJeprrI,IBaIOm;ee rrpep;CTaB-
JIeHIIe 0 BapIIall,IIJIX aHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCKHX TIInOB Ha RaBKase BO BceM IIX
MHoro06paSIIII.
B 1950 r. M. r. A6):(ymemlrnBHJIII H r. K ,l];iKaH6epHp;se IICCJIe):(OBaJIII
rpyrrrry oceTIIH-TyaJIl'll,eB B ,l];iKaBcKoM paMoHe IOro-OceTIIHcKoM AO 19. IIc-
CJIep;OBaHHe rrpOIISBO):(IIJIOCI, B CeJIeIUIJIX ReMYJII,Ta II JIecopII. B 1951 r. OlIII
pa60TaJIH B CeBepo-OceTIIHcKoM ACCP II IICCJIep;OBaJIII rpyrrny oceTIIH-p:IIrop-
D;eB B IIpa<pcKOM paMoHe (ceJleHHJI JIecKeH II TOJIp;srYH) II rpyrrrry oceTIIH-
HpOHll,eB B fHSeJII,p;OHCKOM paMoHe (ceJIeHIIJI HIIiKHJIJI CaHH6a, MaMpaM):(ar,
}:(syapHRay) 20. HaROHell" B 1956 r. HMH iKe 6I,IJIII nOBTopHO IISYlJeHI,I oce-
TIIHhI-TyaJII,D;hI B :U;xHHBaJIbCROM paMoHe IOro-OceTJilHcRoM AO 2\ TaKIIM
06paSOM, P;JIJI CYiKp;eHIIJI 06 aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCROM TIIrre rpYSHHcKoro Hapo):(a B
HarneM paCrrOpJIiKeHIIII eCTb p;aHHI,Ie rro 'IeTI,lpeM 3THorpa<pIIlJeCRIIM H Tep-
piiTOpIIaJII,HI,IM rpyrrnaM - P;BYM ceBepooceTIIHCRHM II ):(BYM IOrooceTIIHCRIIM;
C nOMOm;bIO TaRoro MaTepl2laJIa TPYP:HO CY):(IITI, 0 JIOKaJIbHI,IX Bap«aD;IIJIX aHT-
pOrrOJIOrIIlJeCRIIX npIISHaROB rro OTp;eJII,HI,IM CeJIeHIIJIM, 'ITO He6esI,IHTepecHo.
eCJII2I YlJeCTIr CTerreHb I2IS0JIJIll,12II2I CeJIeHI2IM, HO OH p;OCTaTOlJeH P;JIJI BI,Ip;eJIeHI2IJI
II Oll,eHRII ROMnJIeRCOB npIIsHaRoB, xapaRTepHhIx p;JIJI RaiKp;oM lIS 3THorpa-
q,IIlJeCRIIX rpynn. Bo BCJIROM cJIYlJae, TOJII,RO 3TH p;aHHhIe JiI nOSBOJIJilJIII Brrep-
BbIe nOCTaBJilTb JiI paCCMOTpeTI, Bonpoc 0 e):(I2IHCTBe IIJIII. Hao6opOT, CJIOiKHOCTH
B.HTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO COCTaBa oceTIIHCRoro Hapop;a.
IIp:eJI B. B. BYHaRa 0 BI,Ip;eJIeHIIII JiI caMOCTOJITeJII,HOM rrOJIOiKeHIIII B aHT-
pOrrOJIorIIlJeCROM CIICTeMaTIIRe Hapop;OB RaBKasa oc06oro rrpIITepeRCRoro Ba-
pIIaHTa, IIJIII TIIna, nOJIYlJHJIa BceCTopOHHee nO):(TBepiK):(eHIIe II p:aJII,HeMrnee
pas BlITHe B HOBI,IX MaTepIIaJIax. B BI,ICORoropHI,IX paMOHax IJ;eHTpaJII,HOrO
RaBKasa 6I,IJI BI,UIBJIeH HOBI,IM aHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJeCRIIM TIIrr, OTJIIIlJaIOIll,IIMCJI
60JII,rnIIM Mop<pO;WrIIlJeCRIIM cBoeo6paSIIeM. On rroJIY1IHJI, RaR HSBeCTHO, HaII-
MeHOBaHIIe RaBKaCIIOHCRoro OT rpYSHHCRoro HaSBaHHJI RaBRasa. TepMIIH 3TOT
HeJII,SJI rrpHSHaTI, OlJeHb yp;alJRI,IM, TaR RaR RaBKaCHOHCRJIM TIIrr pacnpOCTpa-
HeH p;aJIeRO sa npep;eJIaMII ropHI,IX paMOHOB OAHOM TOJIbRO fpYSIII2I, HO, BO
BCJIROM CJIY'Iae, OH BOnIeJI B aHTpOrrOJIOrIIlJecRyIO JIIITepaTYPY II B HaCTOJIm;ee
BpeMJI JIBJIJIeTCJI 06m;enpIIHJITI,IM; rrpII 3TOM 06m;errpIIHJITOCTI, TepMJma He
OrpaHHlJlIBaeTCJI TOJII,RO RpyraMII aHTpOrrOJIOrOB, TaR RaR HS aHTpOnOJIOrII-
lJeCKOM .fHTepaTYPhI OR rrpOHIIR B apXeOJIOrIIlJeCKYIO H HCTOpIIlJeCRYIO. Pac-
npOCTpaHeH RaBRaCIIOHCKIIM THrr cpe):(H HapO):(OB paSHhIX HShIROBhIX ceMeM-
OT lJepKeCOB, 6aJIKapll,eB II KapalJaeBll,eB Ha sanan;e p;o aBapll,eB, aH):(o-ll,YH-
TIIHCKIIX napo):(oB H JIaRll,eB Ha BOCTORe. Ho OCHOBHOM ero apeaJI HeCROJII,RO
YiKe, TaK RaR Y BOCTOlJHI,IX lJepKeCOB H JIaRll,eB OH rrpe):(cTaBJIeH B BIIp;e
rrpiiNIecII. ECJIII nepe1J:HCJIJITI, Bce Hapop;I,I, OTHOCHm;IIecH R 3TOMY TIIrry,
C sana,1;a Ha BOCTOR. TO HYiKHO HaSBaTI, 6aJIKapD;eB II RapalJaeBll,eB, Bce rop-
HI,Ie 3THorpa<pHlJeCRlIe rpyrrrrhI rpYSHHCRoro Hapop;a - CBaHOB, palJIIHD;eB,
rrrnaBOB, MTIIYJIOB, ryp;aMaKapll,eB, TyrnHH, xeBcypOB, ceBepHhIX II IOiKHI,IX
OCeTIIH, qelJeHll,eB, HHryrneM, aBapll,eB, Bce aHp;O-ll,YHTJilHCRHe Hapop;I,I. TaKHM
06pasoM, rrpaRTlIlJeCRII Bce Hapo):(I,I, 06JlTaIOm;IIe Ha 60JlbrnOM BI,ICOTe B rrpe-
p;eJIax rrpe):(ropHM fJIaBHOrO RaBRascRoro xpe6Ta, BRJIIOlJaIOTCJI B COCTaB
JToro THna.
B lJeM MOP<POJIorIIlJeCROe cBoeo6paSIIe RaBRaCIIOHCRoro TIIrra? IIepelJIIC-
JIeHHI,Ie Hapo):(hI OTJIIIlJaIOTCJI BhICORIIM pOCTOM (cBblrne 168 CM), OlJeHI, Mac-
CIIBHI,IM lJeperrOM, lJpeSBI,IlJaMHO 60JIbrnOM rnIIplIHoM JIIIll,a, RpyrJIOM rOJIOBOH.
259
9*
..
t .
OcoGeHHo p:eMOHCTpaTIIBHbI II GpOCalOTCH B rJIa3a OTJIII'IIIH 0'1' p:pyrHx Hapo-
P:0B KaBKa3a ITO mIIpIIne JIIII(a. HapOJl,bI KaBRa3a Bo06Il{e p:OBOJIbIlO mIIpo-
KOJIIIl{bI B npep:eJIax eBponeOIIp:HOM paCbI; npaBp:a, cpep:II KaBKa3CRIIX Hapo-
p:OB BCTpe'IaIOTCH II Y3KOJIIII(bIe rpynnbI, HanpIIMep YP:lInbI, HO OHII COCTaB-
JIHIOT MeHLmIIHCTBO. TeM GOJIee yp:IIBIITeJIbHa mIIpOKOJIIIIJ;eCTb npe;J,CTaBIITe-
JIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna - no cpaBHeHlI10 C p:pyrJIMII Hapop:aMIl KaBKa3a
JIIII(O mIIpe y HIIX B cpep:HeM Ha caHTIIMeTp. 11IIbIMII CJIOBaMII OTJIII'IlIe IIX
0'1' p:pyrlIx KaBKa3CKIIX Hapop:OB no mIIpIIHe JIIIIJ;a COOTBeTcTByeT no a6CO.TIIOT-
HOll BeJIn'IlIHe aMnJIIITyp:e KOJIeGaHIIH 3Toro npII3HaKa B npep:eJIax BceM eB-
poneOIIJ],HOM paCbI, a caMII KaBKaCIIOHl(bI c6JIIImalOTCH C CIIGIIpCKII:\III MOHro-
JIOIID,al\1lI, ):(JIH KOTOpbIX OqeHb GOJIbmaH mIIpIIIIa JIIII(a npep:CTaBJIHeT COGOiI
OJ],IIII II3 caMbIX xapaKTepHbIX aHTpOIIOJIorIIqeCKIIX npII3HaKOB. IIIIIpIIHa JIlIIJ;a
CBH3aHa C pOCTOM II MaCCIIBHOCTblO qepena, KaK rOBopHT aIITpOnO:IOrII, BbI-
COKOM BHYTplIrpynnoBoM KOppeJIHI(IIeM, T. e., IIHbIMH CJIOBaMlI, :I1O)J;1I BbICO-
Koro pOCTa C MaCCIIBHbIM qepenOM 'IaIl{e OTJIII'IaIOTCH IIIIIpOKIIM :IIII(OM, <reM,
HaoGopoT, JIIOp:rr l\IaJIeHbKoro pOCTa C MaJIOMaCCIIBHbIM, IIJIII, KaK rOBopHT B
aIITpOnOJIOrlIlI, rpaI(IIJIbHbIM, qepenOM. Bce TplI npII3HaKa BbIpamalOT IIHTeH-
CIIBHbIM pOCT CKeJIeTa B I(eJIOM, qTO, o reBII,IJ:HO, xapaKTepHO p:JIH npep:CTaBIITe-
JIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna BooGIl{e. ,l];pyroM OTJIII'IIITeJIbHbIM nplI3IIaR KaBKa-
CIIonI(eB npII cpaBHeHIIII C p:pyrIIMII KaBKa3CKIIMII Hapop:aMII - OTHOCIITeJIb-
HaH p:enIIrMeHTaI(IIH, T. e. HeKOTopoe nOCBeTJIeHIIe BOJIOC !if rJIa3.
Bce II3Y'IeHHbIe STHorpa<pHqeCKIIe II TeppIITOpIIaJIbHbIe rpynnbI oceTIIH-
CKoro Hapop:a HBJIHIOTCH KJIaCCII'IeCKIIMII npep:CTaBIITeJIHMII KaBKaCIIOlICKoro
TIIna. 11M CBOMCTBeIIIlbI BbICOKIIM pOCT, KpyrJIaH <popMa repenIIOM KOpoGKII,
60JIbmaH, BepHee, O'IeHb GOJIbmaH mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;a, 3aMeTHoe nOCBeTJIeHIIe
BOJIOC H rJIa3 no cpaBHeHHIO C Hapop:aMH 3aKaBKa3bH. ITo mIIpIIHe JIIIIJ;a
oceTIIHbI ,l];maBCKoro paMOHa IOro-OceTIIHCKOM AO 3aHIIMalOT Ha KaBKa38
KpaMIIee nOJIOllieHIIe, HMeH MaKCIIMaJIbHO mIIpOKoe JIIII(O no cpaBHeHIIIO co
BceMII OCTaJIbHbIMII KaBKa3CKIIMlI Hapop:aMII. Y p:IIrOpIJ;eB H ocoGeHHo HPOH-
I(eB II B p:pyroll rpynlIe, y TyaJIbIJ;eB, JIMI(O HeCKOJIbKO yme, HO TaKme qpe3-
BbI'IaMHO mIIpOKoe, TIInII'IHOe p:JIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro KOMnJIeKCa npII3HaIWB.
Ha OCIIOBaIIIIII pa3HIII(bI B CKYJIOBOM mIIpIIIIe, paBHoM 2 MM, 'ITO COCTaBJIHeT
He GOJIee Op:HOM nHTOM pa3HIIIJ;bI Mem;u:y npep:CTaBIITeJIHMII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro
THna II p:pyrIIMII KaBKa3CKIIMII Hapop:aMII, M. r. AGp:ymeJIlImBIIJIII CD,eJIaJI
BbIBOp: 0 pa3HOM TF!TOTeHIIII pa3JIH'IHbIX STHorpa<pII'IeCKIIX rpynn OCeTJIH no
aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIM nplI3IIaKaM, C'IIITaH p:IIropIJ;eB II TyaJIbI(eB TIIIIII IHbnIII
KaBKaCIIOHIJ;aMII, a B IIpOHI(ax BIIp:H CMemaHHYIO aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRYIO rpyn-
ny, Mop<pOJIOrn'IeCKIIM TIIn KOTOpOM CJIOmII:ICH B npoI(ecce MeTnCaI(IIll KaB-
KaCIIOHCKoro THna C p:pyrIIMII ceBepOKaBKa3CKIIMII II 3aKaBKa3cmUIll aHTpo-
lIOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII TIInaMII, B qaCTHOCTII nOHTHMCKIIM 22. OTCIOp:a GbIJI cp:eJIaH
H BTOpOU BbIBOp: 0 GOJIbmeM BJIIIHHHII Ha HlIX Toro KOMlIJIeKCa lIplI3HaKOB,
KOTOpbIM GbIJI lIpep:CTaBJIeH y aJIaH. O,IJ:HaKO eCJIH lIO p:pyrIIM lIpII3HaKa;u,
CJIymaIl{IIM p:JIH xapaKTepIICTHKII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TlIlIa,- POCTY, :\IaCCIIBHO-
CTII 'IepelIa, 'IepelIHOMY YKa3aTeJIIO, IJ;BeTY BOJIOC II rJIa3 - MemlJ,y Bce:\III
II3Y'IeHHbIMrr oceTIIHCKIIMH rpynnaMII II rrpOHBJIHIOTCH HeKOTopbIe pa3JIII'IIIH,
TO OHII He HOCHT 3aKOHOMepHoro xapaKTepa, He CKJIap:bIBaIOTCH B onpep:e-
JIeHHbIe KOMnJIeKCbI. Ha STOM OCHOBaHIIII MomHO BbICKa3aTbCH B nOJIb3Y
ep:HllCTBa aHTponOJIOrH'IeCKorO COCTaBa oceTIIIICKoro llapop:a II He npIInIICbI-
BaTb HaGJIIOp:aeMOM pa3HIII(e B mlIplIHe JIIIIJ;a Memp:y IIpOHI(aMII, C Op:HOM
CTOpOHbI, p:IIrOpIJ;aMII II oceTIIHaMII ,l];maBcKoro paMOHa IOro-OceTIIHCKOM
AO - C p:pyroM, TaKCOHOMII'IeCKOrO lITeM GOJIee pacoreIIeTII'IeCKOrO 3Haqe-
HHH. 8'1'0 TeM GOJIee onpaBp:aHHO, 'ITO oceTIIHbI U;XIIHBaJIbCKOrO paMOHa He
60JIee mIIpOKOJIHIJ;bI, <reM oceTIIHbI-IIpOHIJ;bI. MHbIMII CJIOBaMII, pa3HIII(a B
260
mHpHHe JIIIIJ;a Memp,y P:BYMH TepplITOpIIaJIbHbIMII rpyrrrraMII oceTIIH-TyaJIbIJ;eB
HH'IYTb He MeHbme, <reM Memp,y IIpOHIJ;aMII H p:lIrOpIJ;aMH.
RaKOBO STHII'IeCROe 3Ha'IeHIIe Toro <paKTa, qTO oceTIIHbI OTHOCHTCH K
KaBKaCIIOHCKOMY TlIrry? OHO BeJIHKO. OCHOBHYIO pOJIb B orrpeD,eJIeHHH JJ:peB-
HOCTH KaKoro-HIIGYP:b aHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKOrO rrpH3HaKa HrpaeT, rrOMIIMO naJIeo-
aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKHX MaTeplIaJIOB, TeppHTopHH ero pacnpOCTpaHeHHH: qeM
60JIbme II KOMrraKTHee TeppIITopIIH Op:HOpOp:HbIX BaplIaIJ;IIM, TeM OHII iJ,peBHee,
TaK KaK JJ;JIH HX pacrrpOCTpaHeHHH rro GOJIbmOM TeppIITopHII rrOTpe60BaJICH
p:JIIITeJIbHbIM rrpOMemYTOK BpeMeHII. ITpep:CTaBIITe:III KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THrra
3aHIIMalOT Ge3 rrepepbIBa, Ge3 KaKHX -JIII60 IIHOpO,IJ:HbIX BKJIIO'IeHIIM oomIIpHYIO
oGJIaCTb 0'1' qepKecIIII Ha 3arrap:e p:o U;erITpaJIbHOrO ,l];arecTaHa Ha BOCTOKe.
8'1'0 03Ha'IaeT, 'ITO rroTpeGoBaJIOCb MHoro BpeMeHII, qTOObI KaBRaCIIOHCKaH
KOMoIIIIaIJ;HH rrpII3HaKOB, B03HIIKrrYB rp:e-TO BHYTPII STOM oo:raCTII, pacrrpocT-
paHIIJIaCb Ha COTHII KIIJIO:\IeTpOB B TPY,IJ:Ho):(ocTyrrHbIx BbIcoKoropHbIx MeCT-
HOCTHX. ECJIII IICXOD,IITb 113 reorpa<pIIII KaBKaCHOHCKoro TlIIIa, TO CllJIOmHoi'r
xapaKTep ero apeaJIa CBIIp:eTeJIbCTByeT B p:orrOJIIleIIIIe K p:peBHOCTH TaKme II
o MeCTHOM ero IIpOIICXOffi,D,eIIIIII, TaR RaK B rrpOTIIBHOM CJIY'Iae rrpII 3aCeJIe-
HHH HbIHeillHeM TepplITopIIII B cpaBHIITeJIbHO He,IJ:aBHee BpeMH KaBRaCIIOHIJ;bI
BCTpeTHJIIICb GbI C MeCTHbIM HaCeJIeHlIeM II BMeCTO CnJIOmHOrO apeaJIa MbI
IIMeJIII GbI CJIOmHYIO reOI'pa<pII'IeCKYIO M03almy pa3HbIX KOMrrJIeKCOB. ,l];PyroM
aprYMeHT B rrOJIb3Y MeCTHoro npolIcxomAeHIIH, a 'IaCTII'IHO II rJIyGoKoM p:peB-
HOCTII KaBKaCHOHCKoro TIIrra - ero Mop<pOJIOrII IeCKoe cBoeoGpa3lIe. OTJIH-
'IaHCb 0'1' p:pyrlIx KaBKa3CKHX Hapop:OB GOJIbillOM illIIpIIHOM JIIIIJ;a II HeCKOJIbKO
GOJIee CBeTJIOM rrIIrMeHTaIJ;lIeM, rrpep:CTaBIITeJIII KaBKaCIIOHCRoro TIIrra TeM He
MeHee B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM OTHomeHIIII TlIrrII'IHbIe KaBKa3IJ;bI, T. e. oGHa-
pymIIBalOT B CBOHX <pII3II'IeCKHX rrpII3HaKax Bero aHTporrOJIOrlI'IeCKYIO ClleIJ;II-
<PHKY, xapaKTepHYro P:JIH Hapop:OB RaBKa3a B IJ;eJIOM. coxpaHeHIIe B IIX aHT-
pOnOJIOrH reCKOM TIIrre HeKOTopbIX rrpOTOMOp<pHbIX ocooeHHOCTeM - eIl{e Op:IIH
aprYMeHT B rrOJIb3Y GOJIbmoi'r p:peBHOCTH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TlIrra. TaKHM oGpa-
30M, BKJIlOqerrIIe oceTIIH B 'IIICJIO rrpep:CTaBHTeJIei'r KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THna rrpII-
BOp:IIT K BbIBOD,y, ITO IIX aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIM TIIrr C<pOp:\1HpOBaJICH B rJIyGo-
KOM p:peBHOCTII H npIIOJIII3HTeJIbHO Ha TOM me TeppIIToprrII, Ha KaKOM oceTH-
HbI rrpmI{IIBalOT II B HacTOHIl{ee BpeMH. Op:HaKO, p:JIH Toro 'ITOGbI nOHHTb
sTHoreHeTII'IeCKOe 3Ha reHHe SToro <paKTa B nOJIHOM oG'beMe H npaBHJIbHO
IICTOJIKOBaTb B CBeTe aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIX STHII'IeCKYIO IICTOpIIIO
oceTHHCKoro Hapop:a, HeoGxop:IIMO paCCMOTpeTb npOIICXOffi.'JeHIIe KaBKaCIIOH-
CKoro THrra, H3JIOmIIB CYIl{eCTBYIOIl{lIe rlIrrOTe3bI II KpIITH'IeCKII pa30GpaB
<paKTII'IeCKIIe p:aHHbIe H TeOpeTH'IeCKIIe cooGpameHHH, Ha KOTopbIe OHII OIlH-
paIOTCH.
113JIOmeHHbIe cooGpameHIIH JIerJIII B OCHOBY BbIBop:a A. H. HaTHmBIIJIH
II M. r. AGp,ymeJIHmBHJIII oG aBTOXTOHHOM rrpOHcxomp:eHIIII KaBKaCHOHCKoro
THrra, KOTOpbIM GbIJI BnepBbIe C<POpMyJIIIpOBaH B paGoTe, rrOCBHllJ;eHHOM rrpep:-
BapIITeJIbHOMY cooGIl{eHHlO oG aHTpOnOJIOI'II'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIx, coGpaHHbIX SKC-
rrep:IIIJ;HeM IIHCTIITyTa SKcrrepHMeHTaJIbHoi'r MOP<POJIOrHII AKap:eMHII HaYK
rpY3HHCKOM ccP B 1954 1'.23 IT03me OHH GbIJIII pa3BHTbI M. r. AGiJ,ymeJIlIm-
BHJIH B CneIJ;IIaJIbHOM paGoTe, nOCBHIl{eHHOM aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII oceTnHCKoro IIa-
pop:a H OCHOBaHHOll Ha pa3paGoTKe II aHaJIII3e p:aHHbIX rro 'IeTbIpeM llepe'IIIC-
JIeHHbIM rpyrrnaM oceTHH 2". Ho rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKHll MaTepHaJI, eCJIII
rOBopHTb 0 p:peBHIIX srroxax, B 'IaCTHOCTII 06 srroxe GpOH3bI, II3BecTHbIll
npeIIMYIl{eCTBeHHo C TeppHTOplIH rpY3IIII II TaKffie II3Y'IeHHbIM M. r. A6p,y-
meJIIImBIIJIII, He nop:TBepilip:aJI BbIBop:a 0 rJIyGoKoM p:peBHOCTH KaBRaCIIOHCKO-
ro TIIrra: HaCeJIeHHe rpY3lIII B snoxy GpOH3bI 6bIJIO rpaIJ;IIJIbHbIM II Y3KOJIH-'
:qbIM 25. ITpaBp:a, BeCb HMeBmIIMCH B HaJIII'IHII llaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKIIM
I
261
MaTepIIaJI rrpOIICXOp:IIJI H3 caMTaBpCKOIO MOrIIJIbHIIKa H, CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO,
IIMeJI Y3KOJIOKaJIbHOe 3Ha'IeHIIe, He Mor GbITb npep:CTaBIITeJIbHbIM p:JIH xapaK-
TeplICTIIKII HaCeJIeHIIH BceM rpY3IIII, a TeM GOJIee ee ropHbIX paMOHOB, HO OH
OCTaBaJICH ep:HHCTBeHHbIM. ITO-BHP:IIMOMY, IIMeHHO STa OrpaHII'IeHHOCTb p:aH-
HbIX, IIOJIHOe OTCYTCTBHe IIX no OTHomeHIIIO K Hace.TIeIIIIIO ropHbIX pallOHOB
II BbI3BaJIII CJIe)];YIOIIJ;IIM mar - rrorrbITKY oGocIIoBaTb p:peBHOCTb II aBTOXTOH-
Hoe rrpOHcxomp:eHlIe KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIrra C rrOMOIl{blO HaJIIIqHOrO MaTepHa-
JIa H3 caMTaBpCKoro MOrIIJIbHHKa. ITepBbIM marOM Ha STOM rrYTII HBIIJIOCb
npep:rrpIIrrHToe M. r. AGJJ;ymeJIIIllIBIIJIII paCCMOTpeHIIe H3MeHeHHH KpaHIIOJIO-
flI'IeCKIIX rrplI3HaKOB BO BpeMeHII Ha TeppHTopHII rpY3HII 26. IT pH conOCTaB-
JIeHIIII pa3HonpeMeHHbIX cepHM II3 caMTaBpCKoro MorIIJIbHHKa H cpaBHeHIIII
IIX C GJIII3KOH K COBpeMeHHOCTII cepIIeM rpY3IIHCKIIX qeperrOB eMY y aJIOCb
rrOKa3aTb, 'ITO mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;a He YMeHbmaJIaCb B rr03):(HIIe srrOXH rro cpaBHe-
HIIIO C paHHIIMII, KaK B P:PyrHx pallOHax cccP, a YBeJIIIqIIBaJIaCb. TBepp:aH
KOHCTaTaI(IIH aToro <paKTa OTKpbIJIa B03MomHOCTb OG'bHCHHTb mIIpOKOJIIIIJ;eCTb
KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna cBoeoGpa3HbIM HarrpaBJIeHIIeM II3MeHeHlIM mHpHHbI
JIIIIJ;a Ha TeppHTopHH rpY3IIII BO BpeMeHII. IToCJIe HIIM STarr Ha STOM rrYTII
COCTaBIIJIO HCCJIeD,OBaHIIe M. r. AGp:ymeJIHmBIIJIII, B KOTOpOM cp:e;::raHa no-
rrbITKa rrOKa3aTb rrOJIHOe Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKOe CXOP:CTBO Memp,y xeBCYPCKOll ce-
pIIeM XVI-XVII BB. (xeBcypbI TaKme KJIaCCII'IeCKIIe rrpep:cTaBIITeJIII KaB-
KaCIIOHCKoro TlIrra) II cepIIHMII II3 caMTaBpcKoro MOrHJIbHIIKa BO Bcex npII-
3HaKax, KpoMe mIIplIHbI JIIIIJ;a 27.
113JIomeHHaH TO'IKII 3peHIIH He MOrJIa rrOJIHOCTblO yp:OBJIeTBOpIITb H3-3a
II3BeCTHoro HrrrIIJIII3Ma, KOTOpbIM rrpOHBHJICH B Hell rro OTHomeHIIIO K MOP<PO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIM p:aHHbIM. ,l];JIH npH3HaHIIH "reHeTH'IeCKOrO pogcTBa p:peBHero Ha-
CeJIeHIIH U;eHTpaJIbHOH KapTJIII H COBpeMeHHbIX npep:CTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCIIOH-
CKoro TIIrra HymHo GbIJIO rrpeHeGpe'Ib pa3HHIJ;ell B rrrrrpHHe JIHIJ;a, IIpeBbI-
malOIl{eM caHTIIMeTp H COOTBeTCTBYIOIl{eM pa3JIII'IIIHM Mem,IJ:Y KpaHHIIMH
BapIIaHTaMII eBporreOII)];HOM paCbI B STOM rrpII3HaKe. HeKOTopbIM npOTeCT BbI-
3bIBaJIO H TO oGcTOHTeJIbCTBO, TO KaBKaCIIOHCKHll THn BbIBOp:IIJICH II3 '1'01'0
KOMHJIeKCa rrpII3HaKOB, KOTOpbIM GbIJI xapaKTepeH p:JIH HaCeJIeHIIH paBHIIH-
HbIX paMOHOB rpY3lIII B snoxy GpOR3bI. Memp:y TeM rOpHbIe pafWHbI GbIJIII B
::moxy GpOH3bI yme 3aCeJIeHbI 'IeJIOBeKOM, 0 <reM He)J,BYCMbICJIeHHO CBIID,e-
TeJIbCTBYIOT II CTapble Haxop:Im, II HOBbIe paCKorrKII. cneIJ;II<pIIKa caMTaBp-
CKoro MOrIIJIbHIIKa KaK KJIaD,GlIIl{a ropop:CKoro nOCeJIKa H, MomeT GbITb,
p:ame KHHmeCKOM p:pymHHbI TaKme rrpep:OCTeperaJIa rrpOTHB rrpIIHHTIIH rIIrro-
Te3bI pop:CTBa p:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH paBHHHHOM rpY3HH II COBpeMeHHoro Ha-
CeJIeHHH ropHbIX paMOHOB. IToaTOMY aBTOp BbICKa3aJI HHYIO rHnOTe3Y rrpo-
IICXO}KgeHIIH KaBKaCHOHCKoro TIIrra, KOTopaH B OCHOBe CBoeM He OTJIII'IaeTCH
0'1' rlIrrOTe3bI M. r. AGp:ymeJIIImBHJIII, TaK KaK TaKme onlIpaeTCH Ha npeJJ;-
CTaBJIerrlIe 0 rJIYGoKoM p:peBHOCTII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna, HO B KOTOpOM rro-
IIHOMY rrOHIIMalOTCH rrepBbIe STarrbI ero <pOpMHpOBaHHH 28. MaCCIIBHOCTb H
mlIpOKOJIHIJ;eCTb - rrpII3HaKH, KOTopbIe GbIJIII xapaKTepHbI p:JIH p:peBHeMmIIX
rrpep:CTaBIITeJIeM eBporreOIIp:HOM paCbI, eBporreMCKoro HaCeJIeHIIH BepXHero na-
JIeOJIIITa II Me30JIIITa. EMY CBOMCTBeHHa 6bIJIa TaKme HeKOTopaH yrrJIOIIJ;eH-
HOCTb BepXHeH qaCTH JIIIIJ;a - oc06eHHOCTb, npOHBJIHIOIIJ;aHCH II Y COBpeMeH-
HbIX KaBKaCIIOHIJ;eB. 8'1'0 CXOp:CTBO Memp:y p:peBHeMmHMII eBponeOIIJJ;HbIMII '1'11-
naMII II I{aBKaCIIOHCKIIM BapIIaHTOM HaBop:HT Ha MbICJIb oG HX CneIJ;II<pIIqe-
CKOM pop:CTBe. KaK HCTOJIKOBaTb ero? OqeBHp:HO, TOJIbKO C nOMOIl{blO
npeD,rrOJIOmeHIIH 00 IICTOKax KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THrra B p:peBHellmeM RaCeJIeHHII
eIl{e KaMeHHoro BeKa, xapaKTepHbIe aHTponOJIOrII'IeCKIIe qepTbI KOToporo
COXpaRIIJIIICb B YCJIOBHHX BbICOKoropROM H30JIHIJ;IIH. B COOTBeTCTBIIII C STOM
rIIIIoTe30M p:peBHeMmlIe npe)];CTaBHTeJIJI KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TlIrra rrOKa npocTo
262
He HaMp:eHbI 1I3-3a nJIOXOll II3BeCTHOCTII II MaJIbIX MacmTaGoB paCKonOK na
MHTHIIKOB snOXII HeOJIIITa II 6pOH3bI (He rOBopH yme 0 GOJIee paHHIIX) B
BbICOKoropbe.
KaKaH II3 )];BYX nepe'IIICJIeHHbIX rHIIOTe3 IIpOHcxomp:eHHH KaBKaCIIOHCKO-
1'0 TIIrra - M. r. A6p,ymeJIlImBIIJIII HJIII B. II. AJIeKCeeBa - OKameTCH crrpa-
Be):(JIJIBOM, rrOKameT GY):(YIl{ee. ,l];a p:eJIO JJ;ame H He B STOM, ropa3JJ;0 BamHee
P:Pyroe: COrJIaCHO oGeHM rIIrrOTe3aM, KaBKaCIIOHCKIIM TIIrr, KaK STO C rrOJIROM
orrpep:eJIeHHOCTblO BbITeRaeT H3 ero MOp<pOJIOrII'IeCKOH CneIJ;II<pIIKII II xapaKTe-
pa ero reorpa<pH'IeCKOrO pacrrpOCTpaHeHIIH, HMeeT aBTOXTOHHoe npOIIcxom-
JJ;eHHe II rrpep:CTaBJIHeT COGOH p:peBHIOIO <popMaIJ;IIIO B COCTaBe eBpOneOH)J,HOM
paCbI. ITpIIMeHIITeJIbHO K STHoreHe3Y oceTIIH STO 03HaqaeT, ITO HX <p II3II -
'IeCKHe npep:KH npOmIIBa:III Ha TOll me TeppIITopHII, Ha KaKOM OHII rrpomII-
BalOT B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH, yme HeCKOJIbKO TbICH'IeJIeTIIM Ha3ap:. ¥TO'IHHTb
STY JJ;aTY II3-3a OTCYTCTBHH rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX MaTeplIaJIOB nOKa He-
B03MomHO, HO xapaKTep ee, BO BCHKOM CJIY'Iae, yCTaHaBJIHBaeTCH TO'IHO: pe'Ib
JJ;OJImHa IIp:TII He 0 CTOJIeTHHX, a IIMeHHO 0 HeCKOJIbKIIX TbICHqeJIeTIIHX aBTO-
XTOHHoro pa3BHTIIH B npep:eJIax BbICOKIIX npep,ropIIM rJIaBHorO KaBKa3CKoro
xpeGTa. JITaK, MeCTHoe npOHcxomp:eHIIe II aBTOXTOHHoe pa3BIITHe Ha rrpOTH-
llieHIIH TbICH'IeJIeTHM - BOT rrepBbIM II OCHOBHOM BbIBOp:, KOTOpbIM MbI MomeM
cp:eJIaTb B pe3YJIbTaTe paCCMOTpeHHH aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIX, Korp:a
rOBoplIM 0 rrpep:Kax oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a. ITpoGJIeMa oceTIIHCKoro STHoreHe3a
B CBeTe aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB H corrOCTaBJIeHIIH - rrpoGJIeMa
MeCTHaH, ceBepOKaBKa3CKaH.
KPAHBonorB ECKBEBAPBAD;BB
IIepBbIM KpaHHOJIOrII'IeCKHM MaTepHaJI C TeppIITopHH OceTIIH GbIJI orrHcaH
A. A. IIBaHoBcKHM - TeM caMbIM HCCJIep:OBaTeJIeM, KOTOPOMY npIIHap:JIemIIT
Heyp:a'IHaH norrbITKa aHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCKOM KJIaCCH<pIIKaIJ;IIII Hapop:OB POCCIIH II
orrpep:eJIeHHH MeCTa B HeM oceTIIHCKoro Hapoga 29. 8'1'0'1' MaTepIIaJI npOIICXO-
p:HT II3 CKJIenOBbIX 3axopoHeHlIM B YIl{eJIbHX ceBepHoM OceTIIH, rrJIOXO p:aTII-
pOBaH, oGpaGoTaH C rrOMOIIJ;blO YCTapeBmeM MeTop:IIKH (rrporpaMMa II3Mepe-
HIIH A. A. IIBaHoBcKoro GbIJIa O'IeHb MaJIa H CIIJIbHO OTJIHqaJIaCb 0'1' COBpe-
MeHHoM) II K HaCTOHllJ;eMY MOMeHTY nOTepHJI nO'ITII Bce CBoe 3HaqeHHe.
cJIeP:YIOIIJ;aH rryGJIIIKaIJ;IIH 'IeperrOB H3 CKJIerrOB ceBepHOM OceTIIlI 6bIJIa ocy-
IIJ;eCTBJIeHa M. A. MIICIIKOBbIM. IIo OTHomeHHIO K HeH rrO'ITII Ge3 H3MeHeHHM
MomHO rrOBTopIITb xapaKTepIICTIIKY, TOJIbKO qTO p:aHHYIO paGoTe A. A. IIBa-
HOBCKoro: JJ;aTHpOBKa orrHcaHHbIX M. A. MIICHKOBbIM 'IeperrOB OCTaBJIHeT llie-
JIaTb JIY'Imero, rrpHHHTaH IIM rrporpaMMa H3MepeHIIM He BKJIIO'IaJIa II3Mepe-
HHM MHorIIX BalliHbIX p:eTaJIeM CTpoeHIIH JIHIJ;eBOrO CKeJIeTa, HaKOHeIJ;, caM
MaTepIIaJI B IJ;eJIOM He GbIJI p:OCTaTOqHO MHOrOqIICJIeHHbIM 30. 8THMH )J,BYMH
IICCJIep:OBaHHHMH, OqeHb HeCOBepmeHHbIMH p:ame C TO'IKII 3peHlIH HaYKH
Toro BpeMeHII, IICqeprrbIBaeTCH TOT BKJIaJJ;, KOTOpbIM BHeCJIII PYCCKIIe aHTpo-
nOJIOrII B H3yqeHHe KpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCKOrO TIIna HaCeJIeHlIH OceTHII p:o peBO-
JIIOIJ;IIII.
3Ha'IIITeJIbHOe rrpHGaBJIeHHe p:aHHbIx B STOM oGJIaCTH OTHOCHTCH yme K
COBeTcKoMY rrepHO)];y, K 20-M rOJJ;aM, Korp:a SKcrrep:HIJ;IIeM I1HCTIITYTa aHTpo-
nOJIOrHII rrpII Mry nop: PYKOBOP:CTBOM B. A. Ky<pTIIHa GbIJIII pacKorraHbI
CKJIerrbI Ha TeppIITopIIII paCCeJIeHIIH oceTHH-HpOHIJ;eB. B rrpoIJ;ecce STIIX pac-
KorrOK GbIJIO p:OGbITO CBbIme COTHII 'IeperrOB, KOTopbIe GbIJIII H3MepeHbI Op:HIIM
H3 cTyp:eHToB-p:IIrrJIOMHIIKOB Ka<pep:pbI aHTpOrrOJIOrIIlI MOCKoBcKoro rocyp:ap-
CTBeHHoro YHIIBepcHTeTa. Ero II3MepeHIIH BOmJIII B CBOP:RYIO paGoTY no
llaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHII cccP r. (D. ,l];eGeIJ;a 31. Ho 8'1'0'1' MaTepHaJI, rrepBbIM Ma-
263
TeplIaJI 110 KpaHIIOJIOrHII GJIlI3KorO K conpCMeHHOCTII HaCeJIeHIIH OceTIIII,
OTIIOCII CH TOJIbKO K O,IJ:HOM STHorpa<pII'IeCKOH rpYIIrre B COCTaBe oceTIIHCKoro
HapO,IJ:a. ITOSTOMY, GYP:Y III rrplIrogHoH p:JIH CYMMapIIoro corrOCTaBJIeHIIH C
KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIMH MaTepIIaJIaMH no P:PyrIIM Hapop:a:\I, cepIIH H3 paCKonOK
B. A. RY<PTIIHa He yp:OBJIeTBOpIIJIa nOJIHOCTblO IIOTpeOHOCTb B p:OCTaTO'IHO
MHorO'IHC:IeHHbIX II OXBaTbIBalOIIJ;IIX Bce STIIorpa<pII'IeCKIIe rpyrrIIbI KpaHIIO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIX ,IJ:aHHbIX no oceTIIHaM; paCKorrKII n03,ITHIIX CKJIerrOB B CBH3II C
STIIM Tpe60BaJIII rrpop:OJImeHIIH, 'ITO GbIJIO cp:eJIaHO, rrpaBp:a TOJIbKO 'Iepe3
20 JIeT, B 1947 H 1949 rr., B. B. BYHaKoM, BrrepBbIe ,IJ:oGbIBmHM KpaHIIOJIO-
rII'IeCKIIe cepIIII C TeppHTopIIII paCCeJIeHIIH Bcex Tpex sTHorpa<pH'IeCKIIX
rpynrr B COCTaBe oceTIIHCKoro Hapoga - IIpOHIJ;eB, p:IIrOpIJ;eB II TyaJIbIJ;en 32.
B. B. BYHaK 06CJIep:OBaJI CKJIerrbI Bcex rJIaBrreMmIIX YIl{eJIIIM ceBepHOH Oce-
TIIII, a TaKme CK;IenbI B p:OJIlIHe p. JIIIaxBbI II coGpaJI CBbIme 300 'IepeIIaB
B3pOCJIbIX JIIOp:eM - HeOIJ;eHIIMbIM MaTeplIaJI p:JIH II3Y'IeHIIH KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKO-
1'0 TIIna HerrOCpegCTneIIHbIX II GJIlImaMmIIx npep:KOB oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a.
MaTepllaJI STOT rrOCJIymIIJI rrpep:MeTOM oGcToHTeJIbHOM nyGJIJIKaIJ;IIH, B KOTO-
pOH K ero aHaJIII3Y GbIJIII TaKme mIIpOKO nplIBJIe'IeHbI rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrII'Ie-
cmre D,aIIHbIe 0 p:peBHeM HaCeJIeHIIII ceBepHoro KaBKa3a B l{eJIOM.
ITapaJIJIeJIbHO C SKcrre,IJ:IIIJ;IIHMII B. B. BYHaKa, COOpbI KOToporo rrOrraJIII B
MY3eM aHTporrOJIOrIIII II STHorpa<pIIII AH cccP B JIeHIIHrpap:e, aHaJIOrII'IHbIe
SKcrrep:II HII rrpOBO,ITIIJIIICb Ka<pep:pOH HOpMaJIbIIOM aHaTOMIIII Mep:IIIJ;IIHCKOro
IIHCTIITYTa B Opp:nwmiKIIp:3e, B KOTOpbIX rrpIIHHMaJIII Y'IaCTIIe JI. ,l];. raGOJIa-
eB II K. X. BeCJIeKOeBa. B OTJIIIqlIe 0'1' SKcnep:III(IIH B. B. BYHaKa STII
SKCIIep:IIIJ;IIII pa60TaJIlI TOJIbKO B YIl{eJIbHX CeBepHOll OceTlIII H OXBaTIIJIII
TeppIIToplI1O paCCe:IeHIIH IIpOHIJ;eB II p:HrOpIJ;eB, HO no STIIM rpynnaM GbIJIII
c06paHbI O'IeHb GOJIbmlIe KOJIJIeKIJ;IIII. cGOpbI JI. ,l];. ra60JIaeBa OCTaJIIICb He-
orryo.rrIIIWBaHHbIMH, HO K. X. BeCJIeKOeBa oGHapogoBaJIa qaCTb coGpaHHbIX ero
MaTepIIaJIOB 33. HaKOHeIJ;, M. r. Aop:ymeJIllllIBIIJIII rrOBTopHO II3Y'III:I KOJIJIeK-
I(IIIO E. A. KY<PTIIHa C nOMOIl{blO MeTop:II'IeCKHX rrpIIeMOB, COOTBeTCTBYIOIl{IIX
conpeMeHIIOMy ypOBHIO aHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCKOH HaYKII: Ha 'Iepenax II3 paCKonOK
E. A. Ky<pTIIHa IIM BnepBbIe ObIJIH II3MepeHbI MHorIIe npII3HaKII, 'Ipe3BbI'IaH-
HO Bamnble ,IJ:JIH paCOBOH p:IIarHOCTIIKII 34.
Bce rrepe'IIICJIeHHbIe ceplIII, p:oGbITbIe B OCHOBHOM pacKonKaMII B. A. Ky<p-
THHa, B. B. BYHaKa, JI. ,l];. raGOJIaeBa II K. X. BeCJIeKOeBOM, a TaKme npo-
IIcxogHIl{IIe II3 CJIY'IaHHbIX CGOpOB, xpaHHTCH B MY3ee aHTponOJIOrHII npII
MOCKOBCKOM rocygapcTBeHHoM YHIIBepCIITeTe, MY3ee aHTpOnOJIOrIIII II STHO-
rpaqnrII AH cccP B JIeHIIHrpap:e, IIa Ka<pep:pe HOpMaJIbHOrr aHaTOMIIII Me-
,IJ:IIIJ;IIHCKOro IIHCTIITYTa B Opp:moHHRIIp:3e II Ha Ka<pep,pe HOpMaJIbIIOH aHaTO-
MIIII Mep:IIIJ;IIHCKoro IIHCTIITYTa B Op:ecce. ABTOp nOBTopHO IICCJIep:OBaJI Bce
cepIIlI, B pHge CJIY'IaeB nOJIHOCTblO II3MeplIB MaTepIIaJI no GOJIee nOJIHOll npo-
rpaMMe (MY3eM aHTpOnOJIOrIIII JI sTHorpa<pIIII AH cccP B JIenHHrpap:e),
IIHorp:a OrpaHII'InBmIICb p:onOJIHIITeJIbHbIMII 1I3MepeHIIHMH HeKOTopbIX nplI-
3HaKOB, II B qaCTHOCTII nOBTopHO onpe,IJ:eJIIIB Bce onHCaTeJIbHbIe IIpII3HaKII B
IJ;eJIJU YHmlmKamIII MeTop:IIKII. HeIwTopbIe KOJIJIeKIJ;IIII 6bIJIII II3Y'IeHbI Bnep-
BbIe (MaTepIIaJIbI JI. ,l];. raGOJIaeBa, KOJIJIeKIJ;IIII Ka<pep:pbI HOpMaJIbHOM aHa-
TOMIIII O,IJ:eCCKOro MegIIIIcTIITYTa). TaKHM oGpa30M, B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH CBe-
p:eII IIOJIHOCTbTO BeCb HMelOllJ;IIHCH B MY3eHX cOBeTcKoro cOlO3a MaTepIIaJI no
RpaHIIOJIOrIIII, II oceTIIHCKIIe KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe cepIIII MorYT C'IIITaTbCH ep:-
Ba ;III He caMbIMII l\iHOrO'IIICJIeHHbIMII cepIIHMH Ha TeppIITopIIII cccP, YCTY-
IIaR B 3TOM JIIImb MaTeplIaJIaM no H:paHIIOJIOrIIII pYCCKoro Hapop:a 35.
cepIIII C TeppIITopIIM paCCeJIeHIIH Kamp:OM STHorpa<pII'IeCKOM rpyrrnbI oce-
TIIH npOIICXOp:HT II3 CKJIenOB HeCKOJIbKIIX CeJIeHlIll, 'ITO YBeJIIIqIIBaeT HX
npeD,CTaBIITeJIbHOCTb. ITo OTHomeHIIIO K IIpOHCKOM TeppHTopIIII STO CKJIenbJ
264
BOKpyr Ce:IeIIllII JIaIJ; (KypTaTIIHCKoe YIl{eJIbe, p:OJIIIHa p. (DIIarp:OH), caHII-
Ga, Xyccap-XIIHIJ;ar, ,l];mIIMapa II ,l];apraBc (rH3eJIbp:OHCKoe YIIJ;eJIbe, D,OJIIIHa
p. rII3eJIbp:OH), U;MII II 3apaMar (AJIarlIpCKae YIl{eJIbe, p:OJIIIHa p. APlJ,OH).
ApeaJI paCCeJIeHIIH p:lIrOpIJ;eB lIpep:CTaBJIeH B KpaHIIOJIOrll'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIaX
cepIIHMII H3 CKJIelIOB y CeJIeHHH KYMGYJITa, YaKaIJ;, MaX'IeCK, (DacHaJI H Ma-
IJ;YTa (,l];lIropcKoe YIl{eJIbe, p:OJIIIHa p. Ypyx). Haxop:HIl{lIeCH B HameM pac-
nopHw,eHlI1I KpaHIIOJIOrlI reCKIIe cepIIII II3 IOiImOM Oce'1'IIII lIpOIICXOp:HT II3
CKJIenOB BOKpyr CeJIeHIIH BepxHee 8pMaHII. BepxHee POR. KOHTaHTO. BIIeTII II
8.r\IICCII (YIl{eJIbe p. BOJIbmaH JIIIaXBa). tJ,aTIIpOBKa Bcex STIIX cepIIH nOKa
MomeT ObITb npOII3Bep:eHa TOJIbKO B p:OCTaTO'IHO mIIpORIIX lIpep:eJIax - 0'1'
XIII p:o XVIII B. H. i:J. OCHoBaHlIeM p:JIH Hee HBJIHeTCH IIpOII3Bep:eHHaH
JI. IT. ceMeHoBbIM pa3GlIBKa CKJIelIOB Ha TPII TIIna - nop:3eMIIbIM, nOJIYlIOp:-
3eMHbIM II Hap:3eMHbIM - II OTHeceHHe HX K pa3HoMY BpeMeHII: nOD,3eMHbIO
CKJIenbI BbIp:eJIeHbI B Ka'IeCTBe HalIGOJIee paHHeM rpYlInbI, Ha.r\3eMHbIe-
B Ka'IeCTBe HaIIGOJIee lI03.r\HeH 36. AOCOJIIOTHbIe p:aTbI - XIII-XVI BB. p:JIH
nOJIynop:3eMlIbIX CKJIelIOB, XVI - XVIlI BB. p:mI lI03p:HHX lIOJIynop:3eMHbIX II
Ha)J,3eMHbIX CKJIenOB. HeCKOJIbKO JIeT Ba3a.r\ STa KJIaCcII<pIIKaIJ;IIH CKJIenOBbIX
lIOrpeOaJIbHbIX coopymeHHM II IIX OTHOCIITe:IbHaH p:aTHpoBKa GbIJIII lIop:TBepm-
p:eHbJ E. 11. RpYlIHOBbIM II B. A. KY3HeIJ;OBbIl\i Ha HOBOM, ropa3p:0 oOJIee
nOJIHOM MaTeplIaJIe 37. He CJIep,yeT 3a6bIBaTb '1'01'0 oGcToHTeJIbCTBa, qTO lIe-
nOJIb30BaHIIe CKJIenOB pa3HbIX TIInOB OCYIl{eCTBJIHJIOCb Ha npOTHmeHIIII p:JIII-
TeJIbHbIX lIpOMemYTKOB BpmleHII; 'ITO Kpallulle ,lJ,aTbI pa3HbIX lIO KOHCTPYKl{HH
CKJIelIOBblX coopymeHIIH 3axop:HT p:pyr 3a p:pyra H, CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, B p:eMcT-
BIITeJIbHOCTII IIMeJIO, nO-BII,J,II:UOMY, MeCTO cocymecTBoBaHHe pa3HbIX TIIlIOB
norpeOaJIbHbIX lIaMHTHIIKOB; 'ITO p:aTIIpOBKII rrpOIICXOJJ;HIl{IIX H3 HIIX KpaHIIO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIX cepHM He IIMeIOT, CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, aGcOJIIOTHOrO 3Ha'IeHIIH,
a caMH cepHII He MorYT 6bITb nOJIHOCTblO lIpOTIIBOlIOCTaBJIerrbI op:Ha p:pyroll,
KaK XpOHOJIOrH'IeCKH pa3HOBpeMeHHbIe. Ho B IJ;eJIOM YKa3aHHaH apxeOJIOraMII
nOCJIep:OBaTeJIbHOCTb B03Bep:eHIIH CKJIelIOB, KOHe'IHO, OTpa}KaeT OCHOBHbIe
STalIbI llCTOpIIII lIorpeGaJIbIIbIX coopymeHIIM, a C HeH II nOCJIeD,OBa'1'e.lIbHOCTb
nOKOJIeHIIH GJIIImallmIIX npep:KOB oceTIIH, 0 KOTOpbIX l\'[bI CYP:IIM lIO 3axopo-
HeHHbIM B CKJIenaX CKeJIeTaM. I1MelOIl{IIMCH B HameM pacnopHmeHHII KpaHIIO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI B pHp:e CJIY'IaeB MomeT GbITb pa3GlIT lIa ceplIII II3
GOJIee paHHIIX nOJIYlIop:3eMHbJX II GOJIee n03D,HIIX Ha,IJ:3eMHbIX CKJIelIOB (cepIIII
1I3 CKJIelIOB y CeJIeHIIH MaX'IeCK, HarrpHMep), B pHp:e CJIy raeB TaKYIO pa3-
GIIBKY npOII3BeCTII HeB03MomHO, TaK KaK npII cGope 'IepenOB He OTMe raJIaCb
KOHCTPYKIJ;IIH norpeGaJIbHbIX coopymeHIIM. Ho B IJ;eJIOM MaTepIIaJI p:OCTaTOq-
HO onpep:eJIeHHO p:aTIIpoBaH, 'ITOObI ero MOmHO GbIJIO IIClIOJIb30BaTb p:JIH xa-
paKTeplIcTHKII KpaHIIOJIorII'IeCKOrO TIIrra GJIII3KlIX K cOBpeMeHHocTII }KIITeJIeM
ceBepnoH II IOmHoM OceTIIII.
KaKoBbI KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe ocoGeHHocTII oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a B IJ;eJIOM II
COCTaBJIHIOIIJ;IIX ero sTHorpa<pII'IeCKIIX rpynn? ITpemp:e Bcero GpocaeTcH B
rJIa3a qeTKaH BbIpameHHocTb nplI3HaKOB eBpOneOlIlJ:HOM paCbI, He II03BO:IHIO-
IIJ;aH rOBopIITb HII 0 KaKOM MOHrOJIOIIp:HOM npIIMeCII, p:OBOJIbHO pe3KaH IIpO-
<pIIJIlIpOBKa JIIIIJ;eBOrO CKeJIeTa B roplI30HTaJIbHOM nJIOCKOC'1'll II OqeHb CIIJIbHOe
BbIcTynaHlIe HOCOBbIX KOCTeM no OTHomeHIIIO R nJIOCKOCTII JIHIJ;eBorO CKeJIeTa,
T. e. KaK pa3 Te nplI3HaKII, KOTopbIe COCTaBJIHIOT Hau60JIee xapaKTepHbIe
CBOHCTBa rrpep:CTaBIITeJIeH eBponeOIIp:HOM paCbI, .r\alOT B03MOrKHOCTb BKJIIO'IIITb
oceTIIH B Kpyr p:pyrlIx KaBKa3CKIIX Hapop:OB, ,IJ:JIH KOTOpbIX TlInlI'IHa B IJ;eJIOM
'IeTKaH BbIpameHHOCTb eBponeOHp:HbIX 'IepT. 113 cneIJ;II(IIII'IeCKHX IIpH3HaKOB
06paIl{alOT Ha ceGH BHIIMaHlIe 'Ipe3BbI'IaMHO GO:IbmaH mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;eBOro CKe-
JIeTa II HeKOTopaH ero ynJIOIl{eHHOCTb B BepXHeM 'IaCTII - xapaKTepHble Kpa-
HIIOJIOrH'IeCKHe OTJIlI'IIIH KaBKaCHOHCKoro TIIna. R qIICJIY TaKHX OTJIHqIIM
265
I
CJIep:yeT OTHeCTII II GpaXIIKpaHIIIO, T. e. KpyrJIyro iPOPMY 'IepeIIlIOM KOpOGKII,
'leTKO BbIpaiI{eHHYIO Ha OCeTIIHCKIIX 'Ieperrax. TlIrrlI'IHO KaBKaCIIOHCKIIM rrpII-
3HaKOM HBJIHe'1'CH II 'Ipe3BbI'IaHHO CIIJIbHOe pa3BIITlIe 'IeperrHOro peJIbe<pa-
HaD,6pOBHbIX p:yr, HaJJ;nepeHOCbH, COCIJ;eBHp:HbIX OTpOCTKOB II )];pyrHx MeCT
rrpIIKperr.:reHIIH 'IeperrHbIX MbImIJ;. O,IJ:HII II3 STllX npII3HaKOB rrOBTopHIOT TY
IIH<popMaIJ;IIIO, KOTopaH GbIJIa nOJIY'Iena npII II3Y'IeHHII COBpeMeHHoro Hace-
JIenIIH,- <popMa rOJIOBbI, mIIpIIHa mIIJ;a; p:pyrIIe He nOBTopHIOT BapHal{IIM
Ke<paJIOMeTplI'IeCKIIX npII3HaROB II HBJIHIOTCH caMOCTOHTe:IbHbIMII - c.TerreHb
yrrJIOIl{eHHOCTII JIIIIJ;a B ropII30HTaJIbHOM nJIOCKOCTII, peJIbe<p 'Iepena. ITo
STIIM rrpII3HaKaM, TaK me EaK II no p:pyrIIM, rrOBTOpHIOIl{IIM Ke<paJIOMeTpII'Ie-
CKIIe, oceTIIHCKIIe 'Ie perra oGHapymIIBalOT rrOJIHOe CXOp:CTBO C 'IepenaMH GaJI-
KapIJ;eB, xeBcypoB, IIHrymeH, BbICOKOropHbIX JIaKIJ;eB - p:pyrIIx THnH'IHbIX
rrpe):(CTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THna. TaKIIM 06pa30M, KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKaH
xapaKTepnCTHKa KaBKaCIIOIICRoro TlIrra OKa3bIBaeTCH HII'IYTb He MeHee orrpe-
p:eJIeIIHOM B l\iOp<p0JIOrII'IeCKOM CMbICJIe, <reM COMaTO:IOrII'IeCKaH. He MeHee
qeTKO O'IepqIIBaeTCH no KpaHIIOJIOrHqeCKIIM p:aHHbIM II ero apeaJI B IJ;eHT-
paJIbHbIX npep:ropbHx rJIaBHOrO KaBKa3cKoro xpeGTa. KpaHIIOJIOrHqeCKIIH:
MaTepHaJI p:aeT, CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, p:onOJIHIITeJIbHbIe II O'IeHb BeCKlIe ):(ORa3a-
Te:IbCTBa IIpHHap:JIemHOCTII oceTIIH K KaBKaCHOHCKOMY TlIny, cBoeoGpa3HH
Mop<pOJIOrH'IeCKOrO KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna, ero reorpa<pII'IeCKOM JIOKaJIII3aIJ;IIH
B BbICOKIIX npep:ropbHx U;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a.
cOMaTO:IorII'IeCKIIe p:aHHbIe, orryGJIHKOBaHHbIe rpY3lIIIcKHMII aHTpOnO:IOra-
MH, GbIJIH c06paHbI, KaK OTMe'IeHO BbIme, B 1950, 1951 II 1952 rr. HeCMOT-
pH Ha BbICOKIIM MeTop:II'IeCKIIH YPOBeHb paOOTbI 3Kcrrep:IIIJ;HH IIHCTHTYTa
SKcrrepIIMeHTaJIbHOH Mop<p0JIOrIIII AKap:eMHII HaYK rpY3IIHCKOH ccp, HymHo
CKa3aTb, 'ITO caMO COCTOHHIIe aHTpOnO:IOrII'IeCKOH MeTop:HKII (IIMeIOTCH B
BII)];y MeTO)J,bI H3Y'IeHIIH COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH - H3MepeIIIIe II orrIIcaHIIe
lliIIBbIX JIIOp:eM) CeHqaC He MomeT IICKJIIO'IIITb HeKOTopOM cyG'beKTIIBHOCTII
pe3YJIbTaTOB IICCJIep:OBaHIIM, npOII3Bep:eHHbIX B pa3HbIe ro)J,bI. ITpIIqIIHa STO-
MY - cp:BHr B OIJ;eHKe onIICaTeJIbHbIX npII3HaKoB. 8'1'0'1' He,IJ:OCTaTOK aHTpono-
JIOrII'IeCKOH MeTop:IIKII npeop:OJIeBaeTCH rrpIIMeHeHIIeM CIIeIJ;lIaJIbHbIX IImaJl
H <poTorpa<pIIH, nOBTopIIbIMII SKcne,IJ:IIIJ;IIHMII B OgHlI II Te me paMoHbI, KaK
MomHO GOJIee mIIpoKIIM OXBaTOM pa3HbIx HapOJJ;OB, no B03MOlliHOCTII pa3JIH-
'IalOIl{IIXCH CBOIIMII Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII ocooeHHocTHMII, rrpII 3KCneiJ,IIl{IIOH-
HOH pa60Te Ha rrpoTHmeIIIIH O,D,lIoro nOJIeBOrO ce30na. XOTH rrepBoe 1I3 3TlIX
YCJIOBIIM - npHMeHeHIIe mKaJI II <pOTorpa<pIIII - 6bIJIO COG.'IIO)J;eHO, HO caMO
KOJIII'IeCTBO II3Y'IeIIHbIX rpynrr IICKJIIO'IHJIO B03MomHOCTb rrOBTopnoro IICCJIego-
BaHIIH. ITOSTOMy, XOTH MeTOD,ll'IeCKIIe pacxomp:elIIIH Memp:y orrpeD,eJIeHIIHMH
pa3HbIX JIeT B p:aHIIOM CJIY'Iae II MaJIOBepOHTHbI, OHM lIe MorYT 6bITb IICKJIIO-
'IeHbI rrOJIHOCTblO. KpaIIIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p:aHHbIe CB060;rJ:HbJ 0'1' BCHKoro cyG'beK-
THBII3Ma H cp:BIIrOB B MaCITITaGe OI(eHRII npII3HaROB, 1I03TOMY cpaBlIeHIIe
KpaHIIOJIOrIPIeCKIIX rrplI3HaROB Bcex Tpex STHorpa<pII'IeCKIIX rpynn oceTIIHCKO-
1'0 Hapop:a MomeT GbITb IIpOII3Bep:eHO C rrO:IHOH 06'beKTHBHOCThlO. 8TO cpaB-
HeHl1e IIop:TBepmp:aeT TOT BbIBOP:, KOTOpbIM GbIJI C;J,eJIaH rrpII paCCMOTpeHIIII
COMaTOJIOrH'IeCKHX )];aHHbIX: aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIH THrr oceTIIHCKoro Hapaga B
OCHOBe CBoeM Op:IIH H He oGHapymIIBaeT 3aMeTHbIX BapIIaIJ;IIM, KOTOpbIM Mom-
HO GbIJIO GbI rrpIIrrIIcaTb pacoreHeTII'IeCKOe 3rra'IeHIIe. ITpaBp:a, II Ha KpaHHO-
JIOrHqeCKOM MaTepIIaJIe BbIHBJIHeTCH pa3HIIIJ;a Memp:y oceTIIHaMH-TyaJIbIJ;aMH
II oceTIIHaMII-HpOHIJ;aMII B mIIpIIHe JIHIJ;a, HO OHa COCTaBJIHeT rrpIIGJIII3IITeJIb-
HO JIHmb 2 MM. B p:pyrIIx KpaHIIOJIOrlI'IeCKHX ocoGeHHocTHX HIIRaKOII pa3-
HIII(bI HeT, BepHee rOBopH, OHa He BbIXOp:HT 3a rpalIIIIJ;bI CJIY'Iai'rHbIX KOJIe-
6arrlIM. He rpynrrIIpylOTCH STII pa3JIII'IIIH B orrpe;rJ:eJIeHHbIe KOMrrJIeKCbI II npII
cpaBHeHIIH cepHM H3 CKJIerrOB OTp:eJIbHbIX CeJIeHIIM C TeppIITopIIeM pacceJIe-
266
HIIH IIpOHIJ;eB, p:lIrOpIJ;eB II TyaJIbIJ;eB. IIOSTOMY Ha OCHOBaHHH KOHIJ;eHTpaIJ;IIII
HaIIGOJIbmei'r mHpIIHbI JIHIJ;a B TyaJIbCKHX ceplIHX MomHO rOBopIITb 0 HaHGo-
JIee pe3Koi'r II 'IeTKoi'r BbIpameHHOCTII oc06eIIrrocTei'r EmBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIrra
y oceTIIH-TyaJIbIJ;eB, HO IIpOHIJ;eB n p:HrOpIJ;eB npII STOM TaKme HeT OCHOBa-
HIIi'r IICKJIIO'IaTb II3 'IIICJIa ero TIIlllI'IHbIX rrpep:CTaBIITeJIeM.
B IJ;IITIIpOBaHHoi'r paGoTe, CneIJ;IIaJIbHO rrOCBHIl{eHHon aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOM
xapaKTepIICTIIKe oceTIIH, M. r. AGp:ymeJIlImBIIJIIJ IIIICaJI 0 P:BYX KOMrrOHeH-
TaX B COCTaBe IOmHbIX oce'1'IIn - ceBepHOM, rro rrpOIICXo}KD,enIIIO KammCIIOH-
CKOM, II IOmHOM, no rrpOIIcxomp:eHIIIO KapTBeJIbCKOM. Borrpoc oG IIX OTHOCII-
TeJIbHoi'r p:peBHOCTII GbIJI pemeH B rrOJIb3Y KapTBeJIbCKOrO KOMnOHeHTa, KOTO-
POMY GbIJIa rrplIrrlIcaHa HaIIGOJIbmaH p:peBHOCTb, Torp:a KaK OTHOCIITeJIbHO
KaBKaCHOHCKoro KOMrrOHeHTa rOBOpIIJIOCb, 'ITO Ha TeppIIToplIlI IOmHoll Oce-
TIIIJ OH CYIl{eCTByeT He GOJIee TbICH'III JIeT. IIpII TaKOll nOCTaHOBKe BOllpoca
HaCeJIeHIIe IOmHoi'r OCeTIIII paccMaTpIIBaJIOCb, XOTH oG STOM rrpHMO II He ro-
BOpIIJIOCb, B Ka'IeCTBe KapTBeJIOB, Bome,IJ:IIIIIX B COCTaB oceTIIH cpaBHIITe:Ib-
HO n03p:HO, H OTpbIBaJIOCb, CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, 0'1' HaCeJIeHIIH ceBepHOll OceTIIII;
eMY rrplIrrIICbIBaJIHCb ocoGbIe STHII'IeCKHe CYP:bObI, OCOObIM nYTb <pOpMlIpOBa-
HHH. Memp:y TeM HII COMaTOJIOrII'IeCKIIM, HII KpaHIIOJIOrlI'IeCKIIII MaTeplIaJI
He p:aeT apryMeHToB p:JIH nop:p:epmKII Te3IIca 0 CJIOmHOCTII aHTpOrrOJIOrlI'Ie-
CKoro COCTaBa oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a, a HaoGopoT, CBIIp:eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 ero
eD,IIHCTBe. 8'1'0 B paBHoE Mepe crrpaBe)J;:IIIBO KaK no OTHomeHlI1O K oceTllHaM
B I(eJIOM, TaK II rro OTHomeHIIIO K Kamp:oi'r II3 BXOp:HIl{IIX B COCTaB oceTIIH-
CKoro Hapop:a sTHorpa<pII'IeCKHX rpyrrrr. HCHaH II 'IeTKaH BbIpameHIIOCTb
ocoGeHrrocTell KaBKaCHOHCKoro TIIrra y oceTHH-TyaJIbIJ;eB - TIInII'IHbIX KaB-
KaCHOHIJ;eB, B KaKOM-TO Mepe, MomeT ObITb, p:ame GOJIee KaBKaCIIOHIJ;eB, LIeM
HpOHIJ;bI H p:HrOpIJ;bI,- TeM GOJIee 3aCTaBJIHeT BbICKa3aTbCH rrpOTIIB rrpep:-
CTaBJIerrIIH 0 CJIO}KeHIIII aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOrO TIIrra TyaJIbl{eB B pe3Y:IbTaTe
CMemeHIIH KaBKaCIIOHCKIIX II 3aKaBKa3CKlIX SJIeMeHTOB, rrpaTIIB rlIIIOTe3bI nx
ocoGoro rrpOHcxomp:eHIIH rro cpaBHeHIIIO C p:pyrHMII oceTIIHCKIIMII rpyrrrraMJI,
B rrop:p:epmKY Te3IIca oG 06Il{eM II ep:nrrOM npoIJ;eCce pacorene3a II 8TrroreHe-
3a Ha TeppIITOpIIII ceBepHoM II IOmHOi'r OceTIIII.
B 3aKJIIOqeRIIe )Toro pa3p:eJIa YMeCTHO CKa3aTb HeCKOJIbKO CJIOB 0 rrpIIH-
IJ;HrraX cpaBHeHHH KpaHlIOJIOrIJ'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB 1I3 CKJIerrOB C pe3YJIbTa-
TaMIl IICCJIep:OBaHIIH COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH OceTHH. 3a rrOCJIep:HIIe He-
CKOJIbKO CTOJIeTHM Y oceTIIH rro cpaBHeHlI10 C IIX GJIIImai'rmIIMII rrpep:KaMII
YBeJIHqIIJICH 3aMeTHO rOJIOBHOM YKa3aTeJIb, T. e. rOJIOBa CTaJIa KpyrJIee,-
rrpOII30me:I rrpoIJ;eCC GpaXHKe<paJIII3aIJ;IIII, xapaKTepHbIll IIa rrpOTHfI\eHHII rro-
CJIeD,Hero THCH'IeJIeTIIH p:JIH MHorlIX paMOHOB cOBeTCKoro cOlO3a, 3arrap:rroi'r
EBporrbI H p:pyrIIx oGJIaCTeM OMKYMeHbI. Ho nOMIIMO cpaBneHIIH YKa3aTeJIeM,
T. e. COOTHomeHIIM pa3MepOB Ha 'Ieperrax II rrplI II3MepeHIIII mlIBbIX JIlop:eM,
cpaBHIIBalOTCH II caMII pa3MepbI C rrOMaIl{blO BBe;J:eHHH YCJIOBIIbIX rrorrpaBOK
Ha TOJIIl{IIHY MHrKHX TKaHeM, KOTopbIe BbI'IIITaIOTCH II3 BeJIII'IIIHbI pa3MepOB,
orrpe,IJ:eJIeHHbIX Ha mHBOM cy6'beKTe, rrJIII, Ha060pOT, rrpIIGaB:IHIOTCH K BeJIII-
'IIIRe pa3MepOB qeperra. ,l];JIH CKYJIOBOi'r mlIplIHbI T3KaH IIorrpaBKa rrpIIHHTa
B 8 MM 38. ECJIII nOJIb30BaTbCH STOM nonpaBKOM, TO MomHO rrOAYMaTb, qTO
HaCeJIeHIIe OCeTIIIJ srrOXII B03Bep:eHIIH CKJIerrOB, T. e. Bcero JIlImb HeCKOJIb-
KO BeKOB Ha3ap:, GbIJIO GOJIee Y3KOJIIIIJ;bIM, <reM COBpeMeHHoe. Ha STOM OCHO-
BaHIIII 6bIJI p:ame cp:eJIaH BbIBOp: 0 pacmIIpeHIIII JIIIIJ;a Y oceTIIH rrapa:IJIeJIbHO
C YBeJIH'IeHIIeM rOJIOBHOrO YKa3aTeJIH, T. e. Ha rrpOTHmeH1I1I rrOCJIep:HIIX CTO-
JIeTliM 39. Ho rrpII conOCTaBJIeHIIII O HOpO)J,HbIX KpaHIIOJIorII'IeCKIIX II COMaTO-
JIOrlI'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIX rro mnplIHe JIIIIJ;a, BbIGpaHHbIx C TaKIIM paC'IeTOM, 'ITO-
GbI GbITb TBepp:o YBepeHHbIM B TOM, LITO OHII OTHOCHTCH K OD,HOM II TOM me
8THII'IeCKOii rpYIIne, BIIP:HO, qTO rrpeD,JIOmeHHaH rrorrpaBKa 3aHIImeHa II p:OJIm-
I
267
Ha 6bITb YBeJIII'IeHa p:o 10-11 MM: IIMeHHO Ha STY BeJIlI'IIIHY B Cpep:HeM
pa3JIII'IaIOTCH KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe II CO;\iaTO:IOrII reCKlIe HaOJIlOgeIIIIH. KCTaTII
CKa3aTb, rIIIIH03 STOM 3aHlImeHHoM IIoIIpaBKII CKa3bIBaJICH Ha IIpoTHmeHIIII
pHlJ,a JIeT, Korp:a IIpll II3Y'IeHIIII KpaHIIOJIOI'II'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB no IJ;eHTpam:.-
HOKaBKa3CKHl\I HapO,IJ:aM, IIpep:cTaBIITeJIHM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIIIa, Bce BpeMH
BbI3bIBaJIII Hep:oYMeHIIe OTHOCIITeJILHO MaJIbIe IJ;II<PPbI mIIplIHbI JIIIIJ;eBoro CKe-
JIeTa Ha 'Iepenax no cpaBHeHHIO C cOBpeMeIIHbIM HaCe:IeHIIeM. B. B. BYIIaK
B IJ;IITIIpOBaHHoi'r BbIme paGoTe, nocBHllJ;eHHOll KpaHIIOJIOrlI1I oceTIIH, OTHOCIIJI
p:ame cepIIII II3 CR:IenOB R 60.'1ee Y3RO:IIIIJ;eMy, 'IeM KaBKaCIIOHcKIIM, nOHTIIi'r-
CKOMY TIIny. Tenepb S'1'O He;::!;0YMeHIIe oTHap:aeT, a C HIIM oTHap:aeT II HeoG-
XO,IJ:IIMOCTb B p:onOJIHIITeJIbHOII, Hago cKa3aTb, B CBeTe Bcex IIMelOIl{HXCH
aHTpOHOJIOrH'IeCKIIX <paKTOB D,OBO:IbHO CTpaIIHOM II IICKYCCTBeHHOM rlIHOTe3e
pacmIIpeHHH JIHIJ;a Y npep:KOB oceTIIH 3a HeCKOJIbKO nOCJIep:HIIX CTOJIeTIIll.
rBIIOTE3A CEBEPHbIX AHAJIOrB:A:
cBoeoGpa3He KaBKaCHOHCKoro TIIna TaK BeJIIIKO, qTO Hp6GJIeMa ero MeCTa B
aHTpOIIOJIOrWleCKOM KJIaCCII<pIIKaIJ;IIII npIIBJIeKaeT BHIIMaHIIe MHorHX IICCJIe-
p:OBaTeJIeM, HCTOJIKOBbIBalOIl{IIX ero no-pa3HOMY. B CBH3II C YKa3aHIIeM Ha
paCilllIpeHIIe JIHIJ;a Y npep:KOB oceTIIH B n03p:HIOIO SHOXY CTOIIT rIIHOTe3a ce-
BepHoro HpOHcxomp:eHJIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna Ha ceBepHOM KaBKa3e, Coo-
CTBenHO rOBopH, p:ame He rHnOTe3a, a MHeHlIe, TaK KaK OHO BbICKa3aHO B
HeCKOJIbKIIX <ppa3ax Ge3 ocoGoi'r aprYMeHTaIJ;IIII 40. KOJIb CKOpO, op:HaKO,
TaKoe MHeHIIe cyIIJ;eCTByeT, OHO p:OJImHO GbITb pa30GpaHo HapH,IJ:Y C p:pyrlI-
MII B03MOlliHbIMII rIInOTe3aMII, II IIMeHHO nOCJIe 0630pa KpaIIIIOJIorII'IeCKIIX
,IJ:aHHblx no oceTHHaM, TaK KaK OHII BaRmbI B nepBYIO O'Iepep:b p:JIH OIJ;eIIKII
SToro MHeHIIH. OHO GbIJIO nop:p:epmaHO H. H. MIIKJIameBCKOM B paGoTax no
naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIlI ,l];arecTaHa. B Ka'IeCTBe napaJIJIeJIII KaBKaCIIOHCKOMY
TIIny OHa YKa3aJIa Ha KpaHIIOJIOrH'IeCKIIe cepHII II3 capMaTCKIIX MOrIIJIbHII-
KOB 3anap:Horo KaBKa3a, HIImHero IToBOJImbH II Y KpaIIHbI 41. B nOJIb3Y ce-
BepHoro npolIcxomp:eHIIH KaBKaCIIOnCKOI'O TIIna r. (D. ,l];eoeIJ; npuBop:IIJI CJIe-
i YIO IIe aprYl\IeHTbI: GOJIbmaH rrrrrpIIHa JIIIIJ;a, mIIpoKo IIpep:cTaBJIeHHaH Y
p:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH PYCCKOi'r paBHIIHbI, II OTHOCHTeJIbHO CBeTJIaH nIIrMeHTa-
IJ;IIH, KOTopaH, no ero MHeHIIIO, CTaBIIT KaBKaCIIOHCKIIe rpynnbI Ha npaMe-
mYTO'IHOe MeCTO Memp,y HaCeJIeHlIeM 3aKaBKa3bH H BOCTO'IHOM EBpOIIbI.
IT03me OH, KaK MbI nOMHHM, OTKa3aJICH 0'1' nepBoro aprYMeHTa, YKa3aB Ha
B03MomHOCTb cpaBHIITeJIbHO n03):(Hero pacmIIpeIIIIH JIIII(a y Herrocpep:CTBeH-
HbIX npep:KOB oceTHH, a 3HaqIIT, H y OJIHmaMmIIX npep:KOB p:pyrIIx KaBKa-
CIIOHCKIIX Hapop:OB. H. H. MIIKJIameBCKaH YCMOTpeJIa B ero To me 3peHIIH
Ha ceBepHoe npOIIcxomp:eHIIe KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TlIna npOTIIBOpe'IIIe C BbICKa-
3aHHbIM B CBOP:HOi'r pa60Te no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII cccP MIIeHueM 0 MeCT-
HOM npOlIcxomp:eHlilI KOMGIIHal{IIII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX rrpII3HaKOB, xapaK-
TepHOM p:JIH 'IepenOB II3 Xapxa, II oG IICTOKax ee B HaCe:IeHIIII ceBepHoro
KaBKa3a B snoxy paHHero fKeJIe3a II p:ame GpOH3bI. ITpoTIIBOpe'IIIe STO,
op:HaKO, KamyIIJ;eeCH, TaK KaK nepeCeJIeHIIe (eCJIII C'IIITaTb IIMeHHO ero OC-
HOBHbIM <paKTOpOM B npOIJ;eCce <pOpMHpOBaHIIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna) C Tep-
pIITOpIIH PYCCKOM paBHUHbI Ha ceBepHbIM KaBKa3 MOrJIO IIMeTb MeCTO B Go-
JIee paHHee BpeMH - HaIIpHMep, B ROHIJ;e HeOJIIITa IIJIII B snoxy paIIHei'r
6pOH3bI. BbIme 6bIJIO OTMe'IeHO, qTO B HameM pacnopHmeHIIII HeT p:OCTaTO'I-
HO BeCKIIX <paKTH'IeCKIIX OCHOBaHHll nOJIaraTl:., qTO illlIpIIIIa JIIIIJ;a y npe):(-
CTaBIITeJIei'r KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna npep:CTaBJIHeT c06arl n03p:IIIOIO, a He p:peB-
HIOIO ocoGeHHOCTb. MomeT GbITb, STO p:ei'rcTBIITeJIbHO aprYMeHT B nOJIb3Y
ceBepHoro npOIIcxomp:eHIIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna C OTHOCIITeJIbHO CBeTJIoi'r
llIIrMeHTaIJ;IIeM?
268'
AHaJIOrII'IHble B033peHIIH Ha npOIICXOmD,eHIIe II IICTOpIIIO aHTpOnOJIOrII'Ie-
CKIIX TlInOB ceBepHoro KaBKa3a C<POPMYJIHpOBaJI B. B. BYHaK B paOOTe no
KpaHIIo:rorlIII oceTIIH. XapaKTepHbIe ocoGeIIHocTII mlIpOKOJIIlIJ;erO n 6paXII-
KpaHHoro ('IIITaH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro Y P:PyrIIx aBTopOB) TIIna HaIIGOJIee qeTKO
BbIpameHbI, C ero TO'IKII 3peHIIH, B cepIIHX 113 YIIJ;eJIbH p. APMXII, T. e. IIH-
rymcKIIX. Mop<pOJIOrH'IeCKIIe aHaJIOrlIIl eMY Haxop:HTCH B COCTaBe D,peBHero
naCeJIeHIlH Ha ceBepe, B IOmHbIX, CTenHbIX paHoHax eBpoIIeHcKoH 'IaCTII cccP,
IlO ,l];OHY !if HIImHeMY Te IeHHIO BOJIrII. ITpaBp:a, B. B. BYHaK C'IIITaeT, KaK
yme GbIJIO OTMe'IeHO BbIme, qTO TIIll STOT npep:CTaBJIeH Y oceTIIH JIlITIIb B
BIID,e npIIMeCII, p:OBOJIbHO, OD,HaKO, 3HaqIiTeJIbHOM, HO STO He MeHHeT CYTII
JJ;eJIa: npIIHaD,JIemHOCTb OCeTIIH K KaBKaCIIOHCKOMY TIIny p:eMOHcTpIIpyeTcH
BceM cOBoKynHocTblO IIMelOIl{IIXCH Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIX, B STOM MbI
yme yGegII:IIICb, II TO'IKa 3peIIlIH B. B. BYHaKa CTOIIT OC06HHKOM.
ITpemp:e Bcero HeCKOJIbKO CJIOB 0 3IIa'IeHIIII IJ;BeTa BOJIOC II rJIa3 p:JIH YC-
TaHOBJIeIIIIH ceBepnoro npOlIcxomp:eHIIH HaCeJIeHIIH U;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a.
TOT <paKT, qTO OHO 3aHIIMaeT npOMemYTO'IHOe nO:IOmeHIIe MeffiL\Y IIapop:aMII
3aKaBKa3bH H BOCTO'IHOM EBponbI (npaBp:a, GJIIIme K nepBbIM), He BbI3bI-
BaeT COMIIeHIIH, II, CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, II3BeCTHoe OCHOBaHIIe YTBepmp:aTb, 'ITO
B COCTaBe Hapop:OB - rrpep:CTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THna eCTb npIIMeCb
ceBepHbIX SJIeMeHTOB, KaK GYP:TO GbI lIMe eTCH. Ho, C p:pyroH CTOpOHbI, 06pa-
Il{aeT Ha ceGH BHIIMaHIIe TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, qTO B npep:eJIax paCCeJIeHIIH
Ca;\IIIX KaBKaCIIOHCKIIX Hapop:OB nIIrMeHTaIJ;IIH He YCIIJIIIBaeTCH C ceBepO-3a-
naiJ,a Ha IOrO-BOCTOK, 'ITO HenpeMeHHO IIMeJIO GbI MeCTO, eCJIII GbI nOCBeTJIe-
HIle BOJIOC II rJIa3 GbIJIO CJIep:CTBIIeM npIIMeCH SJIeMeHTOB ceBepHoro npOIIC-
xomp:eHIIH: npOmIIBalOIl{IIe Ha 3anap:e KaBKaCIIOHCKoro apeaJIa CBaHbI II rop-
HbIe paqIiHIJ;bI OTJIII'IaIOTCH KaK pa3 cpaBHIITeJIbHO TeMHOM nlIrMeHTaIJ;HeM.
8'1'0'1' <paKT HeJIb3H OG'bHCHHTb C TO'IKII 3peHIIH ceBepHoM rHnOTe3bI npOIIC-
xomp:eHIIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THna, HO OH JIerKO oG'bHCHHeTCH B paMKax rIIno-
Te3bI II30JIHIJ;IIII, 3aIIJ;IIIl{aeMOM aBTopOM. B GIIOJIOrHII II aHTpOnOJIOrHII xopomo
II3Y'IeHbI npOIJ;eCCbI II3MeHeHIIM nplI3HaKOB B YCJIOBIIHX II30JIHIJ;IIII B pe3YJIb-
TaTe CJIY'IallHbIX cp:BIIrOB,- npOIJ;eCCbI, nOJIY'IIIBmlIe Ha3BaHIIe reHeTIIKO-
aBTOMaTII'IeCKIIX. ITpH C:IY'IaHHbIX C)J,BIIrax B II3MeH'IlIBOCTII pe3KIIe pa3:III-
'IIIH B OT,IJ:eJIbHbIX nplI3HaKax MOryT oGpa30BaTbCH B npeD,eJIax 3aBegoMo
pop:CTBeHHbIX rpynn, eCJIH STII rpynnbI mHBYT B YCJIOBIIHX II30JIHIJ;IIII. ITpII-
MepOM TOMY (KCTaTII CKa3aTb, 'Ipe3BbI'IaMHO p:JIH Hac BamHbIM, nOTOMY 'ITO
OH Tome OTHOCIITCH K ropHOM MeCTHOCTII) CJIymaT pe3KIIe pa3JIII'IIIH B CO-
OTHomeHIIH rpynn KpOBII CIICTeMbI ABO Memp:y mIITeJIHMII OTp:eJIbnbIX na-
MHpCKIIX ceJIeHIIii 42. TaKIIMII reHeTIIKo-aBTOMaTII'IeCKHMII npOIJ;eCCaMII B
YCJIOBIIHX II30JIHIJ;IIII II Mon,no OG'bHCHIITb KaK nOCBeTJIeHIIe nlIrMeHTaIJ;IIII y
npep:CTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna B IJ;eJIOM, TaK H coxpaHeHlIe TeMHOll
nHrMeHTaIJ;IlII Y CBaHOB II ropHbIX pa'IIIHIJ;eB. ITpII TaKOM IIop:xop:e, onpaB-
p:aHHOM reHeTH'IeCKII, nOCBeTJIeHIIe BOJIOC II rJIa3 TepHeT 3Ha'IeHIIe aprYMeH-
Ta B nOJIb3Y ceBepHoro npOHCXOmD,eHHH KaBKaCHOHCKoro TIIna.
AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe TIInbI gpeBHeMrnero HaCeJIeHHH BOCTO'IHO-EBponeH-
CKOM paBHIIHbI npOmJIII B CBoeM pa3BlITIIII 'Iepe3 Te me STanbI, 'ITO II p:peB-
HeMmIle npep:CTaBIITeJIIl eBponeOIIp:HOM paCbI BooGIl{e: OHII OTJIII'IaJIIICb Mac-
CIIBHOCTblO, mIIpOKOJIHIJ;eCTblO II CIIJIbHbIM pa3BIITlIeM 'IepenHOro peJIl>e<pa,
T. e. TeMII npH3HaKaMII, KOTopbIe xapaKTepHbI H p:JIH COBpeMeHHoro KauKa-
CIIOHCKoro TIIna. cpep:II HaCeJIeHIIH HeCROJIbKHX KyJIbTYP 9nOXII HeO IlTa II
6pOH3bI, <pH3II'IeCKIIM THn KOToporo H3BeCTeH no rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOl\iY
MaTepIIaJIY (HMHaH, rl:aTaKoMGHaH, cpy6HaH, <paTbHHOBCKaH II aGameBcKaH
Ry I>TYPbI), IIpaKTII'IeCRII TOJIbKO <paTbHROBCKaH rpynna OTJIII'IaJIaCb OTHO-
CHTeJIbHOM Y3KOJIHIJ;eCTblO 43. qTO me KacaeTCH OCTaJII>IIbIX qeTbIpex, TO JIIOp:II,
269
i
"
OCTaBIIBmIIe STII KYJIbTypbI, KOHIJ;eHTpIIpOBaJIII B CBoeM <pII3II'IeCKOM TIII1e Bce
nepe'IIICJIeHHbIe ocoGeHHocTII II Ha nepBbIM B3rJIHp: MOI'YT C'IIITaTbCH npOTO-
TlInOM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro BapIIaHTa. TaKoe CXOP:CTBO HBJIHeTCH KaK 6Y,IJ:TO ap-
rYMeHTOM B nOJIb3Y ero ceBepHoro npOIICXOni:p:eHIIH,- TeM aprYMeHTOM,
KOTOpbIM He CMOrJIa nOCJIYlliIITb nIIrMeHTaIJ;IIH. IIpaB)];a, COBpeMeHHbIe Kpa-
HIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe cepIIII II3 IJ;eHTpaJIbHbIX npeiIropIIII rJIaBHOI'O KaBKa3CKoro
:x;pe6Ta HeCKOJIbKO 60JIee Y3KOJIIIIJ;bI II rpaIJ;IIJIbHbI, <reM cepIIII snOXII SHeOJIII-
Ta II GpOH3bI, a 'IepenHOM YKa3aTeJIb Y HIIX HaMHoro BbIme, HO TaKOBbI
Bo06IIJ;e nOCTOHHHbIe OTJIIIqIIH 60JIee n03p:HIIx 'IepenOB OT 60JIee paHHIIx-
pe3YJIbTaT HanpaBJIeHHbIX npoIJ;eccoB OGIIJ;IIX II3MeHeHIIM aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
npII3HaKoB BO BpeMeHII. B CKII<pCKYIO snoxy MaccIIBHbIM II mIIpOKOJIIIIJ;bIll
eBponeOIIp:HbIM TIIn He npOCJIemIIBaeTCH Ha TeppIITopIIII BOCTO'IHOii EBpO-
nbi - CKII<pbI 60JIee Y3KOJIlIIJ;bI II rpaIJ;IIJIbHbI, a ,IJ:JIH xapaKTepIICTIIKII P:PY-
rIIX STHIIqeCKIIX rpynn B HameM pacnopHllieHIIII HeT naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'Ie-
CKlIX MaTepIIaJIOB, HO 3aTO p:JIH capMaT OH HBJIHeTCH OCHOBHbIM no BceM
TeppIITopIIII IIX paCCeJIeHIIH 4". ECJIII cpaBHIITb <pII3II'IeCKIIe oc06eHHOCTIi
capMaT C KpaIIIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII npII3HaKaMII HapogoB, npIIHap:JIemallJ;IIX K
KaBKaCIIOHCKOMY TIIny, TO 3,IJ:eCb TPYP:HO 3aMeTIITb p:ame Te pa3JIII'IIIH, KOTO-
pbIe GbIJIII OTMe'IeHbI npII conOCTaBJIeHIIII KaBKaCIIOHIJ;eB C rraCeJIeHIIeM sno-
XII 6pOH3bI. capMaTbI 6bIJIII 60JIee rpaIJ;IIJIbHbI, <reM HaCeJIeHIIe snOXII Heo-
JIIITa II GpOH3bI, II OTJIII'IaJIIICb KpyrJIoii <pOPMOM 'IepenHOM Kop06KII, nOSTOMY
II CXOgCTBO IIX C KaBKaCIIOHIJ;aMII 60JIbmee. Ha 3'1'0 Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKOe cxog-
CTBO II OnIIpaJIIICb npellige Bcero nepe'IIICJIeHHbIe IICCJIep:OBaTeJIII, <POPMYJIII-
PYH rIInOTe3Y reHeTII'IeCKOrO pO)ICTBa ,IJ:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH BOCTO'IHOM EBPO-
IIbI II COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH npe,IJ:rOpIIM IJ;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a.
11 Bce me, HeCMOTpH Ha TaKoe Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKOe CXOD,CTBO, I'IIIIOTe3a STa
BbI3bIBaeT cepbe3HbIe COMHeHIIH. Ha'IaTb C '1'01'0, 'ITO npII C0I10CTaBJIeHIIII
C )];pyrIIMII CIIHXpOHHbIMII cepIIHMII II3 MOrIIJIbHIIKOB CTenHOM nOJIOCbI EBpa-
3IIII B COCTaBe capMaT BbIHBJIHeTCH HeGOJIbmaH, HO OT'IeTJIlmaH MOHrOJIOIIg-
HaH npIIMeCb, KOTOpOM HeT Y HapogoB ceBcpHoro KaBKa3a, B TmI 'IIICJIe II
Y oceTIIH. 1l0STOMY, 1l0-BIIgIIMOMY, JIIIIJ;eBOM CKeJIeT Ha capMaTCKIIX 'Iepenax
60JIee ynJIOllJ;eH B HIIlliHeM 'IaCTII, 're:VI Ha 'Iepenax 6aJIKapIJ;eB, oceTIIH, IIH-
rymeM - HapogoB KaBKaCIIOIICKoro TIIna. Ho geJIO game ne B STOM - MOH-
rOJIOII):(HaH npIIl\IeCb MOrJIa B KOHl{e KOHIJ;OB paCTBopIITbCH 3a D,Be TbICH'III
JIeT 0'1' py6ellia H. s. p:o COBpeMeHHOCTII, XOTH TaH:oe npegnOJIOmeHIIe II
IIpOTIIBOpe'IIIT 06llJ;ereHeTII'IeCKIIM co06pallieHIIHM,- a B OTCYTCTBIilI KaKOM-
JIII60 CneIJ;II<pIIKIi B OTMe'IeHHOM cxogcTBe HaCeJIeHIIH SIIOXII SHeOJIIITa II
6pOH3bI II capMaT C Hapop:aMII U;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a. 8'1'0 - CXOgCTBO B
npep:eJIax BeTBII MaTypII30BaHHbIX, O'IeHb MaCCIIBHbIX eBponeOIIJJ:OB, CXOD,CTBO
CKopee TIInOJIOrII'IeCKOe, 'Ie:VI reHeTlI'IeCKoe. OnIIpaHcb Ha Hero, MomHO
6bIJIO 6bI C TaKIIM llie ycnexoM BeCTII reHe3IIC KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TlIIIa 0'1' Heo-
JIIITlI'IeCKOrO HaCeJIeHIIH YKpaIIHbI, Me30JIIITII'IeCKOrO HaCeJIeHIIH ceBepHOM
A<PPIIKII II <DpaHI(IIII II T. ;1. KCTaTII CRa3aTb, IIl\IeHHO r. <D. ,l];e6eIJ;, BbI-
CKa3aBmIIMCH 3a ceBepHoe npOIICxOmD,eHIIe KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TlITIa, GOJIee,
<reM KTO-JIII60 p:pyroM, CTapaJICH IIOKa3aTb, 'ITO mIIpOKOJIlIIJ;eCTb II MaCCIIB-
HOCTb - 06llJ;IIe Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKIIe CBOIICTBa Bcex fJ,peBHIIX BapIIaHTOB eBpo-
neOII,IJ:HOM paCbI, 'ITO Bce COBpeMeHHbIe eBponeOIID,HbIe TIITIbI npOmJIII 'Iepe3
CTaD,IIIO, xapaKTepII30BaBIIIYIOCH TaKIIMII npII3HaKaMII. Ho B TaKOM CJIY'Iae
3a'IeM BeCTII npOIICXOllip:eHIIe HaCeJIeHIiH U;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a II3 BOCTO'l-
HOM EBponbI, He npOllJ;e JIII rrpeiIIIOJIOII';IITb, 'ITO lIpe)J,KII COBpe:VleHHbIX KaB-
Ka3CKIIX Hapop:OB OTJIII'IaJIIICb Tel\III llie npOTOMOp<pHbIMII MOp<pOJIOrlI'IeCKIIMII
epTaMII, 'ITO II npe)];KII Hapop:OB BOCTOqHOeBpOneIIcKIIx? 8'1'0 6bIJIO 6bI JIO-
rIPIHee. 11 Torp:a HeII36ellieH BbIBO)J, 06 IICKYCCTBeHHOCTII rIInOTe3bI ceBepHO-
"",
):",
,.
270
It
1'0 rrpOIICXOmp:eIUIH KaBKaCIIOHCKOrO TIIrra II 0 npaBOMepHOCTII, 60JIee CTpO-
rOM <paKTII'IeCKOM II JIOrII'IeCKOM 060cHoBaHHocTII rIIrrOTe3bI ero MeCTHoro
IIPOIIcxollip:eHIIH. TaK MbI 1l0JIY'IaeM B03MOlliHOCTb eIIJ;e pa3 II C eIIJ;e 60JIb-
mIIM OCHOBaHIIeM BbICKa3aTbCH B rrOJIb3Y aBTOXTOHHoro npoIIcxomp:eHIIH
oceTIIHCKoro HapO)];a - HOCIITeJIH aToro TIDIa.
llAnEOAHTPOllOJIOrHqECKBECOOBPA*EHBH
ECTb JIll KaKIIe-JIII60 npHMbIe naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIe ,IJ:OKa3aTeJIbCTBa rJIY-
,60KOM )];peBHOCTII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna Ha ceBepHoM KaBKa3e, II B 'IaCTHO-
CTII B OceTIIII? ITaJIeoaIITpOrrOJIOrIIH KaBKa3a cp:eJIaJIa 3Ha'IIITeJIbHbIe marH
B rrOCJIep:HIIe rop:bI, HO npII IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbHOM STHII'IeCKOM rrecTpoTe, KOTopaH
UbIJIa xapaKTepHa p:JIH KaBKa3a BO Bce srroxII, II rrpII FJIy60KOll II30JIHIJ;IIII,
pa306llJ;aBmell HaCeJIeHIIe OT)J;eJIbHbIX paMoHoB, KOJIII'IeCTBO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIO-
rII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB Bce ellJ;e OCTaeTCH Hep:ocTaTO'IHbIM, II rpynnIIpYIOTCH
OHII B OCHOBHOM rro cpaBHIITeJIbHO p:ocTynHbIM MeCTHOCTHM (TPYP:HO,IJ:OcTyn-
HbIe paMoHbI, HanpIIMep ,l];areCTaH, BbIcoKoropHaH rpY3IIH, OCTalOTCH npaKTII-
'IeCKII ne OXBa'IeHHbIMII rraJIeOaHTpOlIOJIOrlI'IeCKIIM IICCJIe,IJ:OBaHIIeM) 45.
IlOSTOMY npII nonbITKe npOCJIep:IITb reHe3IIC cOBpeMeHHbIx aHTpOnOJIOrII'Ie-
KIIX TIInOB HylliHO npII6eraTb K MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbIM sKCTpanOJIHIJ;IIHM, BbI3BaH-
HbIM eIl{e II II3MeHeHIIeM aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX rrpII3HaKoB BO BpeMeHII. IIPII pac-
MoTpeHIIII reHe3IIca KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna II rrO,IJ:bICKaHIIII eMY naJIeOaHTpo-
llOJIOrII'IeCRIIX aHaJIOrIIM He06xop:IIMO oTpemIITbCH npelli)];e Bcero 0'1' O,IJ:HOro
npII3HaKa - qepenHOro yKa3aTeJIH: IICKorraeMbIe <pOpMbI KaBKaCIIOHCKorO
'TIIna, eCJIII CYP:IITb no aHaJIOrIIII C 06bI'IHO Ha6JIIOp:aeMbIMII II3MeHeHIIHMIi qe-
penHoro YKa3aTeJIH BO BpeMeHH, )];OJIlliHbI 6bITb p:OJIIIXOKpaHHbI.
cpep:HeBeKoBoe HaCeJIeHIIe ceBepHoro KaBKa3a, 0 KOTOpOM MbI MOllieM
YP:IITb no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIM cepIIHM II3 MOrIIJIbHIIKOB py6ellia I-
II TbICH'IeJIeTIIM H. 8. II na'IaJIa II TbICH'IeJIeTIIH, 06HapymIIBaeT TOT llie
IIarra30H II3MeH'IIIBOCTII B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX npII3HaKax, qTO II COBpeMeH-
Hoe. HanpliMep, STHIIqeCKaH rpynna, OCTaBIIBmaH MOrIIJIbHIIK ,l];y6a-IOpT II
'qe'IHe, OTJIIIqaJIaCL IICKJIIO'IIITeJIbHOM Y3KOJIIIIJ;eCTblO 46. cpaBHIITeJIbHO Y3KO-
.JIIIIJ;bIM 6bIJIO II HaCeJIeHIIe qepKecIIII 47. C p:pyroM CTOpOHbI, IDIIpOKOJIIIIJ;bIM
:MaCCIIBHbIi''r TIIn, aHaJIOrII'IHbIII KaBKaCIIOHCKOMy, BbIpallieH OT'IeTJIIIBO B ce-
pIIHX II3 MOI'IIJIbHIIKa B MOllJ;eBOM 6aJIKe Ha Ky6aHII 48, II3 MOrIIJIbHIIKa Ha
ropop:IIIIJ;e BepXHIIM ,l];mYJIaT 49, II3 MOrIIJIbHIIKa Xapx (,l];apbHJIbCKOe
:yIIJ.eJIbe, 4 KM 0'1' qMII) 50. OcoGeHHo JIIoGonbITeH He60JIbmOM naJIeOaHTpo-
:nOJIOrII'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI II3 Xapxa - MOI'IVlbHIIKa, pacrrOJIOmeHHOro cpaBHII-
'TeJIbHO BbICOKO B ropax II B TO llie BpeMH OTHOCHllJ;erOCH He K npIImJIOM,
aJIaHCKOM, a K MeCTIIOII KYJIbType no KOHCTPYKIJ;IIII norpe6aJIbnbIX coopyllie-
HIIII (KaMeHHbIe HllJ;IIKII) 51. qepena II3 Xapxa OTJIlI'IaIOTCH npII CIIJIbHOM
BbIpameHHOCTII eBporreOIIp:HbIX oc06eHHOCTeM MaCCIIBHOCTblO, GOJILmOM 'mII-
'pIIIIOM JIIIIJ;eBOro CKeJIeTa, BbICOKIIM 'IeperrHbIM YKa3aTeJIeM. TaKIIM 06pa30M,
OTJIII'IIITeJIbHbIe 'IepTbI KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIrra, BKJIlO'IaH II BbICOKIIM qepenHOH
YKa3aTeJIb, COBepmeHHO OT'IeTJIIIBO BblpameHbI B COCTaBe cpeJ],HeBeKOBoro
HaCeJIeHIIH, 'ITO TaKni:e rr03BOJIHeT OTBeprHYTb Te3IIC 0 pacnIIIpeHIIII JIIII(a y
'oceTIIH Ha lIpOTHllieHIIII ITOCJIegHIIx CTOJIeTIIM. YXOgH BrJIYGb ellJ;e Ha O)J,HO
TbICH1IeJIeTIIe, go CKII<po-capMaTCKOM snOXII, MomHO OTMeTIITb HaXOD,KH ep;II-
HII'IHbIX InlipOKOJIlIIJ;bIX MaCCIIBHbIX 'IeperrOB B OTp:eJILHbIX MOrIIJIbIUiKaX ce-
nepHoro KaBKa3a, HO lIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIH cenepHoro KaBKa3a SToro ne-
pIIoga Bo06llJ;e 6a3IIpyeTcH nOKa Ha CJIY'IaMHbIX Ii O'IeHb MaJIO'IIICJIeHHbIX
MaTepIIaJIax. ,l];peBHocTb mlipOKOJIIIIJ;erO II MaCCIIBHoro KOMITJIeI{Ca npII3HaKOB
B 3aKaBKa3be MOllieT 6bITb yrJIy6JIeHa p:o cepep:IIHbI I TbICH'IeJIeTIIH p:o H. a.
271
I
(rPYHTOBbIe nOrpe6eHIIH C BbITHHYTbIMII KOCTHKaMII II3 MIIHreqaypa) 52 II
)];allie go pyGemaII IIITbICH.Ie:reTIIiI p:o H. s. (KypraHbI Ha IOrO-BOCTO'I-
HOM noGepellibe 03. ceBaH) 53. 06llJ;IIM lITOI' naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX IIC-
CJIep:OBaHIIM K HaCTOHIIJ;eMy BpeMeHII CBOp:IITCH, CJIep:OBaTe:IbHO, K KOHCTaTa-
IJ;IIII cpaBHIITeJIbHO 60JIbmOM p:peBHOCTII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro Tiina B ropax
KaBKa3a, XOTH IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCI{IIll MaTepIIaJI nOKa He p:aeT B03MOlli-
1I0CTII YBepeHIIO rOBopIITb 0 TaKOM rJIy60KO:ll p:peBHocTII :3'1'01'0 TIIna, KaK
KOCBeHHbIe co06pameHIIH, OCHOBaHHbIe Ha paccMoTpeHIIII ero Mop<pOJIOrII'Ie-
cKoii CneIJ;II4JIIKII II apeaJIa pacnpocTpaHeHIIH.
Oc060 CJIeP:yeT OCTaHOBIITbCH Ha HaXOD,Ke 'Iepena qeJIOBeKa 6JIII3 qIIaTY-
pbI (lll\iepeTIIH). HaMp:eHHbIM BMeCTe C qepenOM apXeOJIOrII'IeCKIIii IIHBeHTapb
n03BOJIHeT, no MHeHIIIO r. K. rpnrOJIIIH, p:aTIIpoBaTb norpe6eHIIe SHeOJIIITII-
'IeCKIIM BpeMeHeM 54. EllJ;e p:o Toro, KaK 'Iepen 6bIJI onIIcaH 8. H. ,l];maBa-
XIImBIIJIII, aBTOp IIMeJI B03MOlliHOCTb OCl\IOTpeTb ero B MY3ee IIHcTIITYTa
sKcnepIIMeHTaJIbHOM MOP<POJIOrIIII AH rpY3IIHCKOM ccp II C JII06e3HOro pa3-
pemeHliH M. r. A6gymeJIIImBIIJIH IICnOJIb30BaTb sry Haxop:KY B ne'IaTIl D,JIH
oGocHoBaHIIH CBoero npep:CTaBJIeHIIH 0 p:peBHOCTII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THlIa Ha
IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM KaBKa3e 55. qeperr p:eMCTBHTeJIbHO OTJIII'IaeTCH IICKJIIO'IIITeJIb-
HOM MaCCIIBHOCTblO II WIIPHI10M JIHIJ;eBOrO CKeJIeTa, CIIJIbHbIM pa3BIITIIeM 'Ie-
perrHoro peJIbe<pa II rrOSTOMy BrrOJIHe nO,IJ:XogIIT Ha pO JIb :meO.ITIITII'IeCKOM
anaJIOrIIII COBpeMeHHbIl\i cepIIHM, OTHOCHIl{IIl\iCH K KaBKaCIIOHCKOMY TIillY.
B KHIIre no alITpOrrOJIOrIIII rpY3IIII M. r. A6gymeJIIImBIIJIII, KpIITIiKYH rro-
3IIIJ;IIII aBTopa, oc060 OCTaHOBIIJICH Ha B03MOlliHOCTII TaKOM IIHTepnpeTaIJ;IIII
HaxogKII B qIIaTYpe II BbICKa3aJICH npOTIIB Hee; OCHOBaHIIH p:JIH TaKOII KPII-
TIIKII - HeD,OCTaTO'IHaH TO'IIroCTb p:aTIIpOBKII II ep:IIHIPIHOCTb HaxogKII.
qTO KacaeTCH rrepBoro 06CTOHTeJIbCTBa, TO, HeCMOTpH Ha paCKonKY norpe-
6eHIIH pa60qIIMII npii CTpOIITeJIbHbIX paGOTax II n03TOMY HegocTaTO'IHYIO
gOKyMeRTaIJ;IIIO, <paKT Haxop:KII mJIII<poBaHHbIX KaMeHHbIX OPYP:IIII II SHeOJIII-
TII'IeCKOM KepaMIIKII BMeCTe C eperrOM HeCOMHeHeH, a IIMeHHO 8TII rrpe)J,Me-
TbI II onpep:eJIHIOT ero XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKYIO )];aTY. EP:IIHII'IHOCTb Haxop:KII
npe):(OCTeperaeT npOTlIB Toro, 'ITo6bI IICnOJIb30BaTb ee p:JIH OKOHqaTeJIbHbIX
BbIBOgOB, TOJIbKO II Bcero; B TO me BpeMH OHa cyIIJ;eCTByeT II, He HBJIHHCb
pemalOllJ;IIM aprYMeHTOM, nop:TBepllip:aeT npep:CTaBJIeHIIe 0 gpeBHocTII MOP<P O -
JIOrII'IeCKIIX OTJIIIqIIM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIlla, OCHOBaHHoe Ha KOCBeHHbIX CO-
06pam:eHIIHX, a nrHopIIpOBaTb ee 6bIJIO GbI, KaK npep:CTaBJIHeTCH aBTOpy,
He06'beKTIIBHO. ABTOP He BIID,IIT n08TOMY OCHOBaHIIM p:JIH OTKa3a 0'1' CBoero
npelliHero B3rJIHp:a Ha 3TY Haxop:KY KaK Ha nepBoe, nyCTb He OKOH'IaTeJIb-
Hoe, HO CYllJ;eCTBeHIIoe, p:OKa3aTeJIbCTBO cTa6IIJIbHOCTII xapaKTepHoro p:JIH
KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna KOMnJIeKCa MOP<POJIOrII'IeCKIIX rrpII3HaKOB, Ha'IIIHaH
MIIHIIMYM C 8noxII HeOJIIITa.
,l];PyroM BbIBOp:, KOTOpbIM n03BO.ITHIOT cgeJIaTb naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe
)];aHHbIe, KacaeTCH reHeTII'IeCKIIX B3aIIMOOTHomeHIIM cpep:neBeKOBoro aJIaH-
CKoro II COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH OCeTIIII. YM03pIITeJIbHO MomHO 6bIJIO 6bI
npep:nOJIaraTb, qTO aJIaHbI, KOTopbIe, no MHeHIIIO MHorIIX IICCJIe)J,OBaTeJIeM,
CbIrpaJIII CTOJIb pemalOllJ;YIO pOJIb B CJIOmeHIIII oceTIIIICKoro Hapo;::!;a (a no
MHeHIIIO HeKOTopbIX - npOCTO MOI'yT paCCMaTplmaTbCH KaK npHl\IbIe npep:KII
oceTIIH 56), OTJIIIqaJIIICb TaKIIM llie <pII3II'IeCKIIM TIIrrOM, qTO n COBpeMeHHoe
HaCeJIeHIIe OceTIIII. TaKIIM 06pa3Q I, CXO)J,CTBO Mem)];y IUIMII no <p II3II 'IeCKIIl\i
npII3HaKaM GbIJIO p:allie 60JIbmee, 'IeM CXO)J,CTBO Mem)J,y capMaTaMII II oceTII-
HaMIl. Op:naKO rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIM l\IaTeplIaJI n03BOJIHeT 6e3 BCHKIIX
06IIHHKOB OTBeprHYTb STO COMHIITeJIbHOe npe)];nOJIOmeHIIe. Bce MOrIIJIbHIIKII,
KOTopbIe :\;iOmHO C rrO:IHbIlIi OCHOBaHIIeM npIInIIcaTb aJIaHaM Ha ceBepHOM
l aBKa3e (BaMTaJI-qenKaH, Y3yn-KOJI, AgIIIOX II p:p.), p:aJIII KpaHIIOJIOrIIqe-
272
CKIIe CepIIII, OTJIII'IalOIIJ;IIeCH IICKYCCTBeHHO p:e<pOpl\IIIpOBaHHOll 'IepeIIHOM KO-
P06KOM II Y3KIiM JIIIIJ;eBbIM CKeJIeTOM 57. IlCKYCCTBeHHaH p:e<pOpMaIJ;IIH rOJIO-
BbI CrreIJ;II<pIIqeCKII aJIaHCKOro Tlirra (KCTaTII CKa3aTb, B IJ;eJIOM rrO,IJ:TBeplligalO-
Il{aH rlirrOTe3Y cpeglma3IIaTCKoro rrpOIIcxomp:eHIIH aJIaH, TaR KaK HaIIGOJIbmaH
KOHIJ;eHTpaIJ;IIH 06bI'IaH TaKOM p:e<popMaIJ;Im rrap:aeT Ha p:peBHee H8CeJIeHIIe
cpe,IJ:HeM A3IIII) - KYJIbTypHaH qepTa, KOTopaH MOrJIa II IIC'Ie3HYTb 3a TbI-
CHqy JIeT, OTp:eJIHIOIIJ;IIX cpegHeBeKoBbe 0'1' COBpeMeHHOCTII. Ho Y3KOJIlIIJ;eCTb
II rpaIJ;IIJIbHOCTb 3aCTaBJIHIOT C'IliTaTb aJIaIl rrpe,IJ:CTaBIITeJIHMII IIHoro aHTpo-
rrOJIOrII'IeCKOrO Tlirra rro cpaBHeHIIIO C COBpel\IeHHbIMII oceTliHaMli. E,IJ:IIHCTBeH-
Hoe IICKJIlOqeHIIe cpep:II aJIaHCKliX MOrlIJIbHIIKOB 06pa3yeT 3MellCKIIii: MOrliJIb-
HIIK, qeperra II3 rrorpe6eHIIM KOToporo HeCKOJIb"hO 60JIee mlipOKOJIIIIJ;bI, <reM
p:pyrIIe aJIaHCKlie cepIIII. Ho qeperrHOM YKa3aTeJIb Ha STIIX 'IepelIaX TaKllie
BbIme, qeM Ha aJIaHCKHX, OHII l\IaCCIIBHee, II rrOSTOMY B COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIlH,
OCTaBIIBmero STOT MOrIIJIbHIIK, MOlliHO rrpep:nOJIaraTb npIIMeCb KaBKaCIIOH-
CKoro TIIrra. IIMeHHo STO rrpeD,rrOJIOmeHIIe II Cp;eJIaJIII aBTopbI onIIcaHliH II
rrepBOM ny6JIIIKaIJ;IIII KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKOrO MaTepIIaJIa II3 ::JToro MOrIIJIbHIIKa 58.
3THOrEHET ECKBECOOBPAmEHBH
Terrepb, nOCJIe TorO KaK paCCMOTpeHbI Bce Haxop:HIIJ;IIeCH B HameM pacno.
pHmeHIIII aHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKIIe p:aHHbIe, IIMelOIl{IIe OTHomeHIIe K npoIIcxomge-
HIIIO oceTIIHCKoro Hapoga, II BbIHCHeHa KapTliHa aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO COCTa-
Ba KaK gpeBHero, TaK II COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH OceTIIII II OKpYllialOIIJ;IIX
paMOHOB, HacTyrrIIJIO BpeMH nO,IJ:BeCTII STHoreHeTII'IeCKIIe IITorII, cp:eJIaTb Te
BbIBOp:bI 0 npOIIcxOllip:eHluI oceTIIH, KOTopbIe BbITeKalOT II3 aHTpOrrOJIOrIIqe-
CKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB. 113 <paKTa )];peBHOCTII II aBTOXTOHHoro <pOpMIIpOBaHllH
KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIrra Yllie 6bIJI CD,eJIaH BbIBOp:, qTO oceTIIHbI npep:CTaBJIHIOT
C060M nOTOMKOB MeCTHbIX STHII'IeCKIIX rpynrr, HaCeJIHBmIIX U;eHTpaJIbHbIM
KaBKa3 C rJIy60KoM p:peBHocTII. To 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, 'ITO TIIrr STOT npe,IJ:CTaB-
JIeH y Hapop:OB B OCHOBHOM KapTBeJIbCKOM, HaXCKOM II aBapo-aHp:O-D,IIgOIICKOM
H3bIKOBbIX ceMeM, cBIIgeTeJIbCTByeT 0 TOM, 'ITO MeCTIIbIe STHII'IeCKIIe rpyurrbI
rOBOpIIJIII Ha Op:HOM II3 MeCTHbIX KaBKa3CKIIX H3bIKOB. cepbe3HbIe MOp<p OJIO -
rII'IeCKIIe pa3JIII'IIIH Memp:y aJIaHaMII II COBpeMeHHbIMII KopeHHbIl\III lliIITeJIH-
MIl OCeTlIII, OTCYTCTBIIe CneIJ;II<pII'IeCKOrO Cxop:CTBa Melli)];Y HIIMII II capMaTa-
MIl He galOT B03MOlliHOCTII npIIHHTb rIInOTe3Y, COrJIaCHO KOTOpOM npe)];KaMII
oceTIIH 6bIJIII IIpaHOH3bI'IHbIe HapogbI. KaK npIIMIIpIITb STII TBepp:o YCTaHOB-
JIeHHbIe aHTpOrrOJIOrIIeM II He BbI3bIBalOIl{IIe COMHeHIIM <paKTbI C IIpaHOH3bI'I-
HOCTblO oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a? Ep:IIHCTBeHHoe yp:OBJIeTBOpIITeJIbHOe oG'bHCHe-
HIIe 3aKJIIO'IaeTCH B TOM, 'ITO MbI ):(orrYCKaeM nepexog npegKoB oceTliH
C MeCTHOM KaBKa3CKOM Ha IIpaHCKYIO pe'Ib Ha KaKOM-TO OTpe3Ke IIX JICTO-
pUII. Bce p:pyrIIe 06'bHCHeHIIH He BbIp:eplliIIBalOT KPIITIIKII C TO'IKII 3peHIIH
aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX <paKTOB.
Korp:a npOII30meJI rrepexop: oceTIIH Ha IIpaHCKYIO pe'Ib C MeCTHOM Rall-
Ka3cKoM, ,IJ:OJImHbI pemaTb JIIIHrBIICTbI II IICTOpliKII, a He aHTpOnOJIOrII.
AHTpOnOJIOrIIH He pacnOJIaraeT npHMbIMII )];aHHbIMII 0 H3bIKOBOM npIIHagJIem-
HOCTII Tex HapO;::!;OB, <pII3II'IeCKIIM TIIn KOTOpbIX OHa II3Y'IaeT, II nepexop: OT
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIX R BbIBO,IJ:aM IICTOpIIKO-STHorpa<pII'IeCKOrO II
JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKOrO xapaKTepa OCyIIJ;eCTBJIHeTCH B aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM IICCJIe-
p:OBaHIIII no aHaJIOrIIII. BocnpIIHTIIe HOBOi'I, IIpaHCKOM pe'III rrpegKaMII oceTIIH
Mor o IIMeTb MeCTO KaK B snoxy paHHero cpep:HeBeKOBbH, snoxy npOIJ;BeTa-
HIIH aJIaH Ha ceBepHOM KaBKa3e, TaK n B 60JIee paHHIIM nepIIOp: - BO Bpe-
l\IH npOHIIKHOBeHIIH CKII<po-capMaTCKliX nJIeMeH Ha ceBepHbIM KaBKa3 59 .
B nepBOM CJIY'Iae CJIep:OBaJIO 6bI OmlI,IJ:aTb 3HaqIITeJIbHOrO BJIIIHHIIH aJIaH Ha
273
I
<p II3II 'IeCKIIM TIIrr OCeTIIH. Mem)];y TeM B HaJIIIqHbIX )];aHHbIX OHO He BbIHB-
JIHeTCH, HeCMOTpH p:allie Ha TO, qTO aJIaHbI, KaK yme 6bIJIO OTMe'IeHO BbIme,
pe3KO OT II'IaJIIICb lIO aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKHM oc06eHHOCTHM 0'1' MeCTHoro Hace-
JIeHIIH, Ii rrpIIMeCb xapaKTepHoro p:JIH HIIX TIIrra CKa3aJIaCb 6bI 3aMeTHbIM
06pa30M Ha <pII3II'IeCKOM CTpoeHIIII oceTIIH. C p:pyroM C'fOpOHbI, capMaTbI
OTJIII'IaJIIICb OT OCeTIIH 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO MeHbme, II noaTOMY capMaTCKYlO nplI-
MeCb y oceTIIH OTpIIIJ;aTb Ha OCHOBaIIIIII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX ,IJ:aHHbIX HeT HII-
KaKoii B03MOlliHOCTII: eCJIII p:allie capMaTCKIIii fmeMeIIT COCTaBJIHeT B COCTaBe
oceTIIH HeCKOJIbKO npOIJ;eHTOB no CBoeMY ygeJIbIIOMY Becy, ero He yD,aeTCH
BbIHBIITL C nOMOIl{blO IIMelOIIJ;IIXCH MaTepIIaJIOB, TaK KaK aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH nOKa
He pacrrOJIaraeT MeTogaMII p:JIH pa3JIII'IeHIIH Mop<pOJIOrII'IeCKII 6JIII3KIIX TII-
nOB. 113 SToro CJIe)];yeT, qTO pe3YJIbTaTaM aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO aHa.T[II3a
60JIbme COOTBeTcTByeT rIIrrOTe3a IIpaHII3aIJ;IIII npep:KOB oceTIIH 'Iepe3 capMaT,
a He qepe3 aJIaHOB (TPYP:HO npep:CTaBIITb ceoe, 'ITO TaKOM BalliHbIM B IICTO-
pIIII lIapOD,a npOIJ;ecc, KaE nepeXO)]; Ha IIrrylO pe1Jb, MomeT npoIIcxogIITb 6e3
npHMbIX 6paKOB Memp:y HOCIITeJIHMII n06elli,IJ:eHHOrO H3bIKa II H3bIKa-noGep:II-
TeJIH, a B STOM CJIY'Iae p:orrYllJ;eHIIe 0 npIIMeCII capMaTCKoro aJIeMeHTa GOJIb-
me COOTBeTcTByeT, KaK MbI nbITaJIIICb nOKa3aTb, aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOMY COCTa-
BY COBpeMeHHbIX oceTIIH, <reM rIInOTe3a aJIaHCKOM npIIMeCII) 60. Ho, pa3YMe-
eTCH, OKOH'IaTe bHbIM BbI60p npIIHap:JIemIIT JIIIHrBIICTaM II IICTopIIKaM.
TIepexop: npep:I\OB oceTIIH - MeCTHbIX nJIeMeH, rOBoplmmIIX Ha KaBKa3-
CKIIX H3bIKax, Ha IIHYIO pe'Ib - pe'Ib npIImJIOrO Hace eHIIH - He eD,IIHII'IHOe
C06bITIIe B IICTOpIIII Hapop:OB ceBepHoro KaBKa3a. C aHaJIOrII'IHbIM npOIJ;ec-
COM MbI CTaJIKIIBaeMCH npII paCCMOTpeHIIII npOIICXOm,IJ:eHIIH 6aJIKapIJ;eB II
Kapa'IaeBIJ;eB - TOllie TIInII'IIIbIX rrpep:CTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna.
Bce cpep:HeBeKOBbIe Hapop:bI, 0'1' KOTOpbIX 6aJIKapIJ;bI II Kapa'IaeBIJ;bI MOrJIII
nOJIy'IIITb CBOM TlOpI\CKIIM H3bIK, pe3KO OTJIIIqaJIIICL 0'1' HIIX no cBoeMy <pII-
3II'IeCKOMY Tiiny II HIIKaK He MorYT paCCMaTpIIBaTbCH B Ka'IeCTBe IIX <pII3II-
'IeCKIIX npep:KOB. ITOSTOMY rro OTHomeHIIIO K npe):(KaM 6aJIKapIJ;eB II Kapa-
'IaeBIJ;eB OCTaeTCH C;J,eJIaTb TOT me BbIBOg, KaKOM MbI C,IJ:eJIaJIII no OTHome-
HIIIO K rrpe)];KaM oceTIIHCKoro HapO;J,a, - OHII rOBOpIIJIII II3Ha'IaJIbHO Ha O)]:HOM
II3 MecTHbIX, RaBKa3CKIIX H3bIKOB II JIIImb B arroxy cpe;J,HeBeKOBbH nepemJIII
Ha IIHYIO peqb, B ,IJ:aHHOM CJIY'Iae TIOPKCKYIO el.
I
!
HEKOTOPbIE IIEPCIIEKTBBbI }J;AJIbHERffiBX BCCJIE}J;OBAHBR
113 npep:bI)];yIIJ;ero pa3p:eJIa HCHO BII;J,HO, 'ITO aBTOp, IICXOp:H II3 aHa II3a
aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB, npII,IJ:aeT pemalOIl{ee 3Ha'IeHIIe MeCTIIOMY,
KaBKa3cKoMy cy6cTpaTY B STHoreHe3e oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a II CqIITaeT BTO-
PII'IHbIMII, HeIIcxop:HbIMII II HeII3HaqaJIbHbIMII IIpaHCKIIe SJIeMeHTbI B ero
KYJIb1'Ype II ero IIpaHOH3bI'IHOCTb. B lIOJIb3Y TaKOM rIITIOTe3bI MomIIO 6bIJIO 6bI
nplIBeCTII pe3YJIbTaTbI II3Y'IeHIIH oceTIIHCKoro H3bIKa, BbIHBJIHIOIIJ;ero B HeM
MeCTHbIM, KaBKa3CKnll KOMrrOHeHT (IICCJIep:OBaHIIH B. 11. A6aeBa), HaJIII'IIIe
Ha TeppIITopIIII OceTIIII TonOHIIMIIKII, HeoG'bHCHIIMOM II3 IIpaHCKIIX H3bIKOB
(IICCJIeD,OBaHIIH A. ,l];. U;araeBOM), 06IIJ;eKaBKa3CKIIe SJIeMeHTbI B HapogHoM
mIIJIIIIIJ;e ropHbIX paMOHOB OCeTlIJI (paGOTbI M. 11. ,l];maH)];IIepII, r. M. JIe-
lliaBa II H. $. TaKoeBoM), apXeOJIOI'II'IeCI\IIe MaTepIIaJIbI, C nmiOIIJ;blO KOTO-
pbIX MomHO npOCJIeD,IITb npeeMcTBeHHocTb MaTepIIa bHoi'I KYJIbTYPbI B Oce-
TIIII BnJIOTL )];0 arrOXII 6pOH3bI (MHOrOJIeTHIIe IICCJIegoBaHIIH E. 11. KpynHo-
Ba II B. A. KY3HeIJ;OBa) , HaKOHeIJ;, oTgeJIbHbIe cOBnageHIIH MOTIIBOB
OCeTlIHCKOI'O Hapop:Horo IIcKyccTBa C rpY3IIHcKIIM (paGoTbI MHorIIX aBTopoB-
B. A. AJI60pOBa, K. A. BepJIagIIHoM, B. 11. )JOJIIIg3e, IT. B. MaMYJIOBa).
Op:HaKo Bce aTII p:aHHbIe C03HaTeJIbHO. OCTaBJIeHbI 6e3 paCCMOTpeHIIH, TaR
274
KaK Ha CeCCIIII, rrOCBHllJ;eHHOM KOMnJIeKCHOllIY 06cymD,eHIIIO rrp06JIeMbI rrpo-
IICXOmp:eHIIH oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a, OHII IIC'IepnbIBalOIIJ;e npep:CTaBJIeHbI B APY-
rIIX p:OKJIap:ax. ABTOp BIIgIIT CBOIO 3ap:aqy B 60JIee rrOJIHOM cyMMIIpoBaHIIII
aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIX npIIMeHIITeJIbHO K np06:reMe oceTIIHCKoro STIIO-
reHe3a II rrOSTOMY OCTaHOBIITCH B 3aKJIIOqeHIIe Ha TOM, qTO )];OJIlliHO 6bITb
ellJ;e cp:eJIaHO B 06JIaCTII aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII OceTIIII II CMelliHbIX paMOHOB.
ITpep:bIP:YllJ;IIM 0630p rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII OceTIIII nOKa3aJI, qTO CKOJIbKO-
HII6YP:b MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbIM naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI II3 ceBepHOM
OceTIIII MbI IIMeeM TOJIbKO no Cpe)];UeBeKoBoMy HaCeJIeHIIIO, p:a II TO 60JIbme
paBHIIHHbIX 06JIaCTeM, a He BbICOKOropHbIX yIIJ;eJIIIM. MOrIIJIbHIIKII SIIOXII
6pOH3bI II palmero llieJIe3a gaJIli nOKa ep:IIHIIqHbIe 'Iepena IIJIII OqeHb He-
MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbIe cepIIII, HerrpIIrop:HbIe gJIH oGcToHTeJIbHOrO aHaJIII3a H
IICKJIIO'IalOIIJ;IIe B03MomHOCTb 0p:H03HaqHOrO pemeHIIH Tex IIJIII IIHbIX Bonpo-
COB reHe3IIca II IICTOpIIII aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX TIIrrOB. qTO KacaeTCH TeppII-
TOpIIII IOlliHOM OceTIIII, TO OHa, HeCMOTpH Ha IIHTeHCIIBHO pa3BOpa'IIIBalO-
IIJ;IIeCH apXeOJIOrII'IeCKlie IICCJIe)];OBaHIIH (B nepBylO O'Iepep:b HylliHO Ha3BaTb
pa60TbI B. B. TexoBa), npep:cTaBJIHeT C060M nOKa «6eJIoe nHTHO» B naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM OTHomeHIIII. 3allOJIHeHIIe SToro 60JIbIDOrO np06eJIa, Ha-
KOnJIeHIIe llaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKliX MaTepIIaJIOB no p:peBHeMmeMY HaCeJIe-
HIIIO ceBepHoM II IOmHoM OceTIIII, no cpep:HeBeKoBoMY HaCeJIeIIIIIO IOnmoM
OceTIIII II ropHLIX paHoHoB ceBepHoM OceTIIII - HacyIIJ;HaH 3ap:a'Ia naJIeo-
aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII II apXeOJIOrIIII KaBKa3a, OT ycnemHoro pemeHIIH KOTOpOM 3a-
BIICIIT s<p<peKTIIBHoCTb IICnOJIb30BaHliH aIlTpOrro:rorII'IeCKIIX gaHHbIx B pa3pa-
60TKe STHoreHeTII'IeCKliX np06JIeM.
ITaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIII MaTepIIaJI HaKanJIIIBaeTCH 'IallJ;e Bcero Me,IJ:JIeH-
HO, B xop:e MHOrOJIeTHIIX apXeOJIOrII'IeCKliX IICCJIe,IJ:OBaHliM. Melligy TeM MaTe-
pIIaJIbI no aHTpOnOJIOrIIII cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH c06IIpalOTcH OGbI'IHO
nJIaHOMepHo, peryJIHpHbIMII SKcrrep:IIIJ;IIHMII, KOTopbIe MorYT CTporo nJIaHII-
pOBaTbCH. OpraHII3aIJ;IIH TaKHX sKcnegIIIJ;IIII TaKme HacyIIJ;HaH 3aga'Ia
aHTpOnOJIOrIIII KaBKa3a B IJ;eJIOM II OCeTIIII B 'IaCTHOCTII, HaCTOHTeJIbHaH He-
06XOP:IIMOCTb 6JIlilliailmlix JIeT, TaK KaK B yme coGpaHHbIx gaHHbIx IIO co-
BpeMeHHoMY HaCeJIeHIIIO Bce ellJ;e MHoro np06eJIOB, a B IJ;eJIOM pHp:e acrreK-
TOB OIIII OD,HOCTOpOHIIII II OTCTalOT 0'1' COBpeMeHHoro ypOBHH TpeGoBaHIIM,
HeCMOTpH Ha TO qTO 6bIJIII c06paHbI 10-12 JIeT Ha3ap:. ITOSTOMY pe'Ib p:OJIm-
Ha IIp:TII KaK 0 pacmIIpeHIIII reorpa<pIIII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKliX IICCJIep:oBaHliM
B OceTlill II cocep:HIIX paMoHax, TaK II 0 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOM nOnOJIHeHIIII rrpo-
rpaMMbI IICCJIegoBaHIIM. PacmIIpeHIIe reorpa<pIIII - STO OXBaT aHTpOnOJIOrII-
'IeCKliMII II3MepeHIIHMII KopeHHbIX lliIITeJIeM Bcex OCHOBHbIX yIIJ;eJIlill KaK
ceBepHoM, TaK II IOmHoM OceTIIII, qT06bI Kamgoe yIIJ;eJIbe 6bIJIO rrpe;J,cTaB-
JIeHO B HamliX )];aHHbIX P:BYMH-TpeMH II3Y'IeHHbIMII rpYIInaMII. cOBepmeHHo
eCTeCTBeHHO, qTO p:JIH nOJIHOIJ;eHHoro aHaJIII3a c06paHHbIx MaTepIIaJIOB nOHa-
P;06HTCH O):(HOBpeMeHHO c06paHHbIe ,IJ:aHHbIe no 6JIIIlliaHmIIM COCe)];HM oce-
TIIH - IIHrymaM II 'IeqeHIJ;aM, Ka6ap,IJ:IIHIJ;aM, 6aJIKapIJ;aM II Kapa'IaeBIJ;aM,
TymIIHaM, xeBcypaM, MTIIYJIaM II ryp:allIaKapIJ;aM, IImaBaM, paqIIHIJ;aM. Pac-
mIIpeHIIe nporpaMMbI aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX 06CJIegoBaHIIM CBH3aHO KaK C
B03MOlliHOCTblO IICnOJIb30BaHIIH HeKOTopbIX TpaD,IIIJ;IIOIIHbIX MeTO,IJ:OB, 1I0Ka
eIIJ;e He npIIMeHHBmIIXCH Ha KaBKa3e npII nOJIeBbIX IICCJIegoBaHIIHX IIJIII
npIIMeHHBmIIXCH JIlimb B MaJIOll CTeneH"H, TaK II C rrOHBJIeHIIeM HOBbIX Me-
TOD,OB. Ha npOTHmeHIIII nOCJIegHIIX gecHTIIJIeTliM OOJIbmIIe YCIIeXII cgeJIaJIa
p:epMaTOrJIII<pIIKa, T. e. 1I3Y'IeHIIe rraJIbl{eBbIX Y30POB II JIa):(OHHbIX JIIIHIIH
qeJIOBeKa, a TaKllie 06JIaCTb, KOTopaH ocooeHHO 6YPHO pa3BIIBaeTCH celi'Iac
II KOTOPYIO MomHO Ha3BaTb <pII3IIOJIOrII'IeCKOM aHTpOnOJIOrlIeM. K HeM OTHO-
CHTCH II3Y'IeHIIe rpynll KpOBII y pa3HbIx pac II Hapop:OB, 6eJIKOB CbIBOpOTKII
275
I
II TIIrrOB reMorJI06IIHa, orrpep:eJIeHIIe )];pyrIIX <pII3IIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX IlOKa3aTe-
JIeH - 6IIOXIIMIIII CJIIOHbI, )];BIIraTeJIbHbIX peaKIJ;IIM II T. )];. ITo BceM STIIM
nOKa3aTeJIHM 06HapymIIBalOTCH BrrO;IHe 'IeTKIIe pa3JIII'IIIH KaK Melligy Hapo-
)];aMII, TaK II Mellip:y rrpep:CTaBIITe.'IHMIl pa3HbIX aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX TIIrrOB,
a CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, OHII MorYT 6bITb IICrrOJIb30BaHbI B STHoreHeTII'IeCKOM IIC-
CJIep:OBaHIIII C TaKOM llie yGep:IITeJIbHOCTblO II S<p<peKTIIBHOCTblO, C KaKOM
IICnOJIb3YlOTCH B HeM pe3YJIbTaTbI II3Y'IeHIIH CTpoeHIIH MHrKliX TKaHeM JIlIIJ;a.
c60p TaKIIX ,IJ:aHHbIX ):(aCT B03MOlliHOCTb 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO oGoraTIITb Harny IIH-
<popMaIJ;lIIO 0 <pII3II'IeCKnX rrpII3HaKax oceTIIHCKoro napoga, OCHOBHbIX npII-
qIIHaX IIX II3MeHeHIIll II STarr ax <pOpMIIpOBaHIIH II, TaKIIM 06pa30M, BHeceT
MHoro HOBbIX p:eTaJIeM B TY KapTIIHY STHoreHe3a oceTIIH, KOTopaH CeM'IaC
06pIICOBbIBaeTCH Ha OCHOBaHIIII aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB. B CJIY'Iae
opraHII3aIJ;IIII rrOCTOHHHO ):(eMCTBYIOIl{eM sKcrregIIIJ;IIII, KOTopaH pa60TaJIa 6bI
Ha rrpOTHllieHIIII JIeTHIIX MeCHIJ;eB Kamp:oro nOJIeBOrO ce30Ha, c60p STIIX gaH-
HbIX MOlliHO 6bIJIO 6bI OCYllJ;eCTBIITb 3a Tpii ro;r:a.
B 3AID;BTY BCnOJIL30BAHBH AHTPOnOJIOrWIECKBX }J;AHHLIX
B 3THOrEHETBQECROM BCCJIE}J;OBAHBB OCETBH
B npOI(ecce 06CYlli;r:eHIIH apryMeHTIIpOBaHHbIX BbIme nOJIOmeHIIM Ha ceCCIIII
no sTHoreHe3Y OCeTIIH, npomep:meM B Opp:mOHIiKlI;r:3e B 1966 r.,- ep:IIHCTBeH-
HOM ceCCIIII, nOCBHIIJ;eIIIIOM STOM np06JIeMe B IJ;eJIOM, GbIJIO BbICKa3aHO He-
CROJIbKO KpIlTII'IeCKIIX 3aMe'IaHIIM B aD,pec aHTpOrrOJIOrOB, OCHoBbIBaBIIIIIxCH
Ha 06llJ;IIX cooGpallieHIIHx. ITpII STOM c06CTBeHHO <paKTII'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI
He 3aTparlIBaJICH HII Op:HIIM II3 KpIITIIKOB. XOTeJIOCb 6bI nocrynIITb Ha060-
pOT - paccMoTpeTb STII 06IIJ;IIe co06pallieHIIH nop: yrJIOM 3peHIIH Tex <paKTII-
'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIx, KOTOpbIMII pacrrOJIaraeT aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKaH HaYKa. ECJIII
CYMMIIpoBaTb Bce B03pameHIIH, TO OHII CBO)];HTCH K TpeM nYHKTaM.
1. OTpIIIJ;aHlIe MIIrpaIJ;IIM. MHe He COBceM nOHHTeH STOT ynpeK. HII OJJ;IIH
II3 aHTpono:rorOB He MomeT OTpIIIJ;aTb II He OTpIIIJ;aeT MIIrpaIJ;IIII BooGlIJ;e;
Ha060pOT, MHorIIe MlirpaIJ;IIII B rrepB06bITHOM 06IIJ;eCTBe YCTaHaBJIIIBalOTCH
JIlimb Ha ocnOBaHIIII naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIITIeCKIIX p:aHHbIX. YKalliY Ha paCceJIe-
HIIe IOmHbIX TIInOB B CTenHbIX paMOHax eBponeMCKOM 'IaCTII cccP B snoxy
BepXHero naJIeOJIIITa II Me30JIIITa, Ha paCCeJIeHIIe eBponeOIIp:OB B IOmHOM
cII6IIpII B srroxy 6pOH3bI, Ha pacrrpOCTpaHeHIIe MOHrOJIOIIp:OB B snoxy Reo-
JIIITa JJ;O BOCTO'IHOM ITpII6aJITIIKII Ii IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM repMaHIIII IT T. A.
Ha npliMepIITeJIbHO K U;eHTpaJIbHoMY KaBKa3Y aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p:aHHMe
p:alOT OCHOBaHIIe p:JIH oTplIIJ;aHIIH MIIrpaIJ;IIII C ceBepa II D,JIH yTBeplliJJ;eHIIH
aBToxToHHOM rIIIIOTe3bI rrpoIIcxollip:eHIIH IJ;eHTpaJIbHOKaBKa3cKIIx HapO,IJOB,
B TOM 'IIICJIe II OCeTIIH. 06 STOM CBIIJJ:eTeJIbCTBYIOT II IICTopIIKo-aTHorpaq,II-
qeCKlie p:aHHbIe - IICKJIlOqIITeJIbHOe cBoeoGpa3IIe II e,IJ:IIHCTBO KYJILTypbI rop-
HOKaBKa3CKIIX Hapop:OB, II p:aHHbIe H3biKOBbIe - cBoeoGpa3IIe KaBKa3CRIIX
H3biKOB II OTCYTCTBIIe B HIIX aHaJIOrIIM IIHJJ;oeBponeMCKIIM II <pIIHCKIIM H3M-
KaM PYCCKOM paBHIIHbI II 1l0BOJImbH.
2. IIpoTIIBonOCTaBJIeHIIe IIpOHIJ;eB II )];IIropIJ;eB. 8'1'0 Hep:opa3YMeHIIe.
AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p:aHHbIe p:alOT B03MOlliHOCTb 06'be)];IIHIITb IIpOHIJ;eB II D;II-
ropIJ;eB, n03BOJIHIOT rOBopIITb 06 IIX aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOM Tiine KaK 0 <reM-TO
I(eJIOM, 'ITO 06'bep:IIHHeT Bce TPII STHorpa<pII'IeCKIIe rpyrrnbI (IIMeIOTCH B BH):(y
He TOJIbKO IIpOHI(bI II p:IIropIJ;bI, HO II TyaJILIJ;bI) B COCTaBe oceTIIHCKoro
HapOD,a.
3. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p:aHHbIe HKOGbI npOTIIBOpeqaT IlCTOpII'IeCKOM KOH-
IJ;errIJ;IIII. KaKoM KOHIJ;errIJ;IIII? Ony6JIIIKOBaHbI qpe3BbIqaMHO 60JIbmIIe, pa3HO-
CTopOlIlrne MaTepIIaJIbI, KOTOpbIe CBII,IJ:eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 TOM, qTO KYJILrypa II
276
:H3bIK oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a npe)]:CTaBJIHIOT C060ll CJIOlliHbIM npOTIIBOpe'IIIBbIM
KOMnJIeKC. rOBOpIIJIOCb 0 TOM, qTO aHTpOnOJIOrII pa3):(eJIHIOT KOHIJ;enIJ;IIIO
cyryGo KaBKa3CKoro npOIIcxomJJ:eHIIH oceTIIH II He XOTHT CqIITaTbCH C IIpaH-
CKIIMII CBH3HMII. 8'1'0 Hecepbe3HbIM ynpeR. cOBpeMeHHbIe oceTIIHbI rOBopHT
Ha IIpaHCKOM H3LIKe - STO <paKT, C KOTOpbIM HIIKTO He MomeT He C'IIITaTL-
CH. Bonpoc 0 TOM, KaK 8TOT <paKT YBH3bIBaeTCH C p:aHHbIMII Mop<pOJIOrIIH.
AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKlle )];aHHbIe CBIIJJ:eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 TOM, 'ITO oceTIIHbI 6JIII3KII,
pO,IJ:CTBeHHbI HapO,IJ:aM QeHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a II 'ITO aJIaHCKOe HaCeJIeHIIe
pe3KO 0'1' HIIX OTJIII'IaJIOCb. 113 8Toro HeJIb3H cgeJIaTb HIIKaKoro p:pyroro BbI-
Eoga, KpOMe '1'01'0, 0 KOTOpOM H rOBOpIIJI: <pII3II'IeCKIIe npep:KII oceTIIH go
nOHBJIeHIIH aJIaH, npIIHecmIIX IIpaHCKYIO pe'Ib, rOBOpIIJIII Ha O.D;HOM II3 KaB-
Ra3CKIIX H3bIKOB. TOJIbKO nOCJIe '1'01'0 KaK 8'1'0'1' MeCTHbIM KOMnOHeHT npIIRHJI
rrpaHCKYIO pe'Ib, 3a H3bIKOM nOTHHYJIaCb KYJIbTypa. ITOSTOMY nOHHTHO, qTO
ceii'Iac IICTOpIIqeCKIIe II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKIIe p:aHHbIe cBIIgeTeJIbCTBylOT 0 MeCT-
HOM cy6cTpaTe MeHbme, 'IeM aHTpOllOJIOrII'IeCKIIe. Ho aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIe
):(aHHbIe rOBopHT 0 TOM, qTO 6paqHbIe CBH3II aJIaHCKOro II MeCTHoro HaCeJIe-
HIIH eCJIH II IIMeJIII MeCTO, TO y,IJ:e.TJ:bHbIM Bec IIX 6bIJI HIIqTOmeH. II IUIKaKIIX
gpyrIIx BbIBOp:OB B HaCTOHllJ;ee BpeMH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI cp:eJIaTb
He gaeT.
MHe XOTeJIOCb 6bI CKa3aTb B 3aKJIIO'IeHIIe, 'ITO MbI )];OJIambI, KaK MHe Ka-
;ReTCH, YCIIJIIITb pa60TY B 06JIaCTII II3Y'IeHIIH STHoreHe3a oceTIIHCKoro Hapo-
)];a. B HaCTOHIIJ;ee BpeMH GYPHO pa3BIIBalOTCH MHorIIe HOBbIe oGJIaCTII aHTpo-
1l0JIOrII'IeCKOM HaYKII - p:epMaTOrJIII<pIIKa, II3Y'IeHIIe rpynrr KpOBII, 3y6HOM
CIICTeMbI qeJIOBeKa II T. p:. Bce STII oGJIaCTII D,OCTaBJIHIOT cepbe3HYlO 8THO-
reHeTII'IeCKYIO IIH<popMaIJ;IIIO, II 6e3 HIIX TPY,IJ:HO CeM'IaC IIpegcTaBIITb ce6e
JIIOGoe STHoreHeTII'IeCKOe IICCJIe,IJ:OBaHIIe, OCHOBaHHoe Ha aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX
MaTepIIaJIax. HaKOrrJIeHIIe TaKIIX )];aHHbIX, KOTopoe JIerIW l\IOmHO opraHII30-
BaTb Ha TeppIITopIIII OceTIIII, 6bIJIO 6bI cepbe3HbIM BKJIaD,OM B II3Y'IeHIIe
3THoreHe3a oceTIIHCKoro Hapop:a.
i 8pKepT P. tP. AHTpOIIOJIOnl'IeClme HSMepemm HeKoTopLIX RaBRaSCRIIX Hapop;oB H DIm-
caHIIe HSMepeHHbIX cy6'beKTOB II BSB. RaBKas. OTP;-HHfI Pyc. reorp. O-Ba. TI'IIIJJIHc,
1882-1883. T. 7, 8; Erkert R. Kopfemessungen kaukasischer Volker II Arch. Anthro-
pol. Bd. XVIII-XIX. Braunschweig, 1891.
2 Chantre E. Recherches anthropologiques dans Ie Caucase. P.; Lyon, 1887. T. IV. CpaB-
HeHHIO pesYJILTaTOB Hs:\mpeHHii: P. <1>. 8pRepTa H 8. IIIaHTJ)a (nOCJIep;HIIH HSp;aJI'laCTL
CBOHX MaTepIlaJIOB B HeCROJILImX npep;BapHTeJIbHLIX c006m;eHHflx) nOCBflm;eHa cner:\ll-
aJIbHafl CTaTbfl: 3azypCKUU JI. II. AHTpOnOJIOrll'leCIme HSMepeHIIfI RaBKaSCRHX Hapo-
P;OB, npoHsBep;eHHLIe P. <1>oH-8pRepToM H 8. IIIaHTpoM /I BSB. RaBKas. OTP;-HIIfI Pyc.
reorp. O-Ba. TI'IIIJJIIIC, 1883. T. 8.
3 POCCUKOB K. H. IIoesp;Ra B IOro-sanap;HYIO 'laCTL ropHoII OceTlnI II ;l];arecTaH II TaM me.
1886-1888. T. 9.
'" A. B. TapeHeI(KIIii: nop;rOTOBIIJI HS CBOIlX Y'IeHIIROB I(eJIYIO nJIeflp;y aHTpOnOJIOrOB, co-
6I1paBlliIlX aHTpOnOJIOrIf'IeCRIIe MaTepHaJILI B BoeHHLIX 'laCTflX II sam;IITIIBlliIlX }];OR-
TOpCIme p;IICCepTaI(IIII no aH1'ponOJIOr:!'[I'!. 0 ero p;eflTeJILHOCTII CM.: HBallOBCKUU A. A.
A. M. TapeHeI(KIIH II Pyc. aU1'ponoJI. mypH. 1905. N! 3/4. CnIlCOR aHTpOIIOJIOrIf'IeCRIIX
p;IICCepTaI IIii ero Y'IeHIIKon, n EOTOpOlll ;'];IIccepTal\WT H. B. fIIJIh''!eHJW IIO p;aTe CBoe-
ro BLIxop;a B CBeT saHIIMaeT nepBoe MeCTO, CM.: l(e6elf r. tP. 8THII'leCRafl aUTpOnOJIO-
rIlfl B paGoTax pyCCRIIX aHTpOnOJIOrOB KOHl\a XIX II Ha'laJIa XX neRa (IIeTep6yprcRafl
H 1I1OCROnCRaR UJKOJIbI) I/O'lepRII IICTOpIIII PYCCROH STHOrpaifnnI, IJIOJILRJIOpIICTIIKII II
aHTpOIIOJIOl'IlIl, 11// Tp. IIH-Ta aTHorpalJlIIII AH CCCP. H. C. M., 1963. T. 85.
5 rUJtb'lellO H. B. MaTepIlaJILI }];JIfI aHTpOnOJIDrIIII RaBKaSa. CII6., 1890. T. I: OceTIIHLI.
OCHOBHLIe BLIBOP;LI STOll pa60TLI OlIy6JIIIKOnaHLI: rUJtb'leIlKO H. B. AHTpOIIOJIOrIf'Ie-
CImH O'iepR oceTIIH II IIpOTOROJILI sacep;aHIIii: Pyc. aHTpOnOJI. O-Ba IIpIl IIeTep6ypr.
YH-Te sa 1890-1891 rr. CII6., 1892.
6 IIallTlOxoB H. H. AHTpOIIOJIOrll'leCIme Ha6JIIO}IeHIIR Ha RaBKase 1/3an. KaBRas. OTP;-
HIIR Pyc. reorp. O-Ba. TIIIJIJIIIC, 1893. RH. 15; Oil 3/Ce. AHTpOIIOJIOrIf'IeCKIIe TIIIILI RaB-
Rasa. TIIIJIJIIIC, 1893. YIaCTJ, co6paHHLIx IIM MaTepIlaJIOB 6LIJIa onyUJIIIROBaHa paHee:
277
On ;nee. 0 pOCTe neROTOpIJX nJIeMen 3aRaBRMCRoro Rpafl II Me}];. c6. TIIiIJJIlIe, 1889-
.M 50.
7 IIannoxoe H. H. PacLI RaBRa3a II RaBRa3cRIIM RaJIeH}];apL. TIIiIJJIIIC, 1900.
8 Xap Y3UH A. H. 0 BJIIIHHInI TIOpRCROM RpOBlI Ha lIpaHCKIlii Tim OceTlIH II M3B. O-Ba JIIO-
6IITeJIeM eCTeCTB03HaHIIf!, aHTpOIIOJIOrIlII II 3THorpaiIJIIII. M., 1890. T. 18.
9 H eanoecrmu A. A. 06 aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCROM COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIIfI POCCllII 1/ TaM. me. 1904.
T.W5.
10 On ;nee. HaCeJIeHIIe 3eMHoro mapa: (OIILIT aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCROM RJlaccIIiIJIIRaJ:(IIII) II
TaM me. 1911. T. 121. CM. TaRme: On ;nee. )J;06aBJIeHIIe R «HaCeJIeHIDO 3eMHoro ma-
pa» II TaM me. 1913. IIPIIJI.
11 06 3TOlll CM.: l{enYPlwBcKUU E. M. 0 RJIaCcIIiIJIIRaJ:(IIII 'IeJIOBe'IeCRIIX pac II HeRoTopbIX
3ap;a'IaX aHTpOIIOJIOrIIII B POCCIIII 1/ ECTecTBo3HaHIIe II reorpaiIJIrH. M., 1912. RH. 2;
Py8enKo C. H. ITo nOBO}];y OnIJTa aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCROM RJIaCcIIiIJIIRaJ:(IIII HaCeJIeHII11
3eMHoro mapa A. A. MBaHoBcRoro II Emerop;HIIR Pyc. aHTpOnOJI. O-Ba. CII6., 1913.
T.4.
12 CeMenC1>aR E. M. B3yqeHIIe rpYIIII RpOBII Hapop;OB RaBRa3a II COB. 3THOrpaiIJlUI. 1936.
.M 4/5.
13 BynaK B. B. AHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIM COCTaB HaCeJIeHllfi RaBRa3a 1/ BeCTH. roc. MY3efl
rpY3I1II. 1946. T. 13.
U IIoJIHafi cBop;Ra co6paHHLlx p;aHHLIX: A68yute,n,uuteu,n,u M. r. AHTpOnOJIOrIIfI )];peBHero
II cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIfI rpy:mII. T6IIJIIICII, 1964. TaM me IIOJIHaH 6II6JIIIorpaiIJIIfI
IIpe}];BapIITeJILHLIX C006m;eHIIM.
15 C06paHHIJe MaTepIlaJIIJ 6LIJIII CHa'IaJIa oIIy6JIIIROBaHLI JIIIIIIL 'IaCTII'IHO: K aCUMO-
Ba P. M. AHTpOlIOJIOrlI'IeCROe llCCJIep;OBaHIIe cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH RYPIIHCI;OM
P;OJIIIHIJ II Bonp. aHTpOIIOJIOrIIII. 1960. BIillI. 5. B HaCTOflm;ee BpeMH OHII BLIIIIJIII B ne-
'IaTII B BIIp;e OTp;eJILHOM MOHorpaiIJIIII: KacuMoBa P. M. AnTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCRIIe IICCJIep;O-
BaHIIH cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIfI A3ep6aMp;maHa. EaRy, 1975.
16 l{e6eLf r. w. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRHe IICCJIep;OBaHIIfI B )J;areCTaHe II AHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIM
C60PHIIR, I. M., 1956. (Tp. I1H-Ta 3THorpaiIJIIII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 33).
17 ra8;neueB A. r. R 3THII'IeCKOM aHTpOlIOJIOrIIll HapO}];OB ;:J;areCTaHa 1/ BOlIp. aHTpOlIOJIO-
rIIII. 1962. BbIII. 12; On ;nee. ITpoIIcxomp;eHIIe Hapop;OB )J;arecTaHa (lIO }];aHHLIM aHTpo-
lIOJIOrIIII). MaXa'IRaJIa, 1965.
18 ra8;neuee A. r. )J;aHHLle no }];epMaTOrJIIIiIJIIRe HapO)];OB )J;arecTaHa 1/ Bonp. aHTponOJIO-
rIIII. 1962. BIillI. 9; On ;nee. )J;aHHIJe no rpYIIIIaM RpOBII HapO)];OB )J;areCTaHa I/TaM me.
1964. BIJII. 17; On ;nee. AHTpOnOJIOrIIfI MaJIIJX nOIIYJIflJ:(IIM )J;arecTaHa. MaXa'IRaJIa,
1971.
19 IIepBafi ny6JIHR fI: Baruuteu,n,u A. B., A68yute,n,uuteu,n,u M. II., A68yute,n,uuteu-
,n,u M. r. MaTepIIaJIIJ 3RCne)];IIJ:(IIII 1950 rop;a no aHTpOnOJIOrIIII COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIe-
HIIfI rpY3I1HCROii CCP 1/ Tp. MH-Ta 3RcnepIIM. MopiIJOJIOrIIII AH rccp. T6IIJIIICII,
1953. T. 4.
20 ITepBafi IIy6JIIIRaJ:(IIfI: Onu ;nee. MaTepIIaJILI R aHTponOJIOrIlII rpY3IIHCRoro Hapop;a 1/
TaM me. 1955. T. 5.
21 IIepBafi ny6JIIIRaJ:(IIfI: A68yuteJtuuteu,n,u M. r. YRa3 .CO'I.
22 On ;nee. OCeTIIHIJ: (AHTpOIIOJI. O'IepR) II Tp. BH-Ta 3RCnepIIM. MopiIJOJIOrIlII AH rccp.
T6IIJIIICII, 1957. T. 6.
23 HarUutBu,n,u A. H., A68yute,n,UutBu,n,U M. r. MaTepIIaJIIJ aHTpolIOaOrll'IeCROiI 3RClIe,rrII-
J:(IIII 1954 r. MHcTIITYTa 3RcIIepIIMeHTaJILHOii MoPiIJOJIOrIIII AH rpy3CCP II VII Hayq.
cec. BH-Ta 3RclIepIIM. MOPiIJOJIOrIIII 1956 r.: Te3. P;OKJI. T6IIJIIICII, 1956. CM. TaRme:
Onu ;nee. IIpep;BapIlTeJIbHLle p;aHHIJe 06 aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCRIIX IICCJIep:OBaHIIflX rpY3IIH-
CRoro Hapop;a 1/ RpaT. coo6m;. BH-Ta 3THorpaiIJIIII AH CCCP. 1955. Bm!. 22. TepMIIH
«RaBRaCIIOHCRHM TIIm) BlIepBLle IIOflBIIJICH B pa6oTe: Onu ;nee. OCHOBHLIe IITorII aHTpo-
nOJIOrIl'IeCKIIX 3Rcnep;IIJ:(IIii 1950, 1951 II 1952 rr. BH-Ta 3RCIlepIIM. MopiIJOJIOrllII AH
I'pY3CCP 1/ Te3. P;ORJI. Ha BIJe3p;HOM HayqH. cec. BH-Ta 3RCIIepIlM. MopiIJOJIOrIIII B
r. EaTYMII, T6IIJIIICII, 1954. 06 aBTOXTOHHOM IIpOIICXOm}];eHIIII RaBRaCIIOHCRoro TIIlIa B
3TOM pa60Te He rOBopIITCH.
24 A68yuteJtuuteu,n,u M. r. OceTIIHLI: (AHTpOnOJI. O'IepR).
25 On ;nee. R naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIII CaMTaBpCRoro MOrIIJILHIIRa. T6IIJIIICII, 1954.
26 On ;nee. R 3IIOXaJILHOM II3MeH'IIIBOCTII aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCRHX IIpII3HaROB 1/ RpaT. co06m;.
I1H-Ta 3THorpaiIJIIII AH CCCP. 1960. BLm. 33.
27 On ;nee. YIepeIIa II3 II03P;HIIX lIorpe6eHIIii CaMTaBpcRoro MOrIIJILHIIRa I/Tp. BH-Ta 3R-
cIIepIIM. MOPiIJOJIOrIIII AH rccp. T6IIJIIICII, 1960. T. 8.
28 A,n,eKceeB B. II. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCmre )];aHHbIe R IIp06JIeMe npOIlcxomp;eHIIfI HaCeJIe-
HIIfI J:(eHTpaJILHLIX IIpe)];ropIIii RaBRMCRoro xpe6Ta II AHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCRIIii C60PHIIR,
IV. M., 1963. (Tp. BH-Ta 3THorpaiIJIIII AH CCCP. H. C., T. 82).
29 lleanoecKuu A. A. YIepeIIa II3 MOrIIJILHIIROB OceTIIII II B3B. O-Ba JII06IITeJIeii eCTeCT-
B03HaHIIfI, aHTpOnOJIOrIIII II 3THorpaiIJIIII. M., 1891. T. 21, BIillI. 5.
278
30 Mucw;oe M. A. MaTepnaJIbI }];JIJI aHTpOIIOJIOnm OCeTIiH. O}];ecca, 1916. IIpe}];BapITTeJIL-
Hoe C006m;eHlIe CM.: Mucwwe M. A. AHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCKITe CBe}];eHIIJI 06 oceTIIHax /I
IIpOTOKOJIbl SaCe}];aHIiH IT OT'IeTbI PyccKoI'o aHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCKOI'O O-Ba sa 1909 (1910-
1911) - 1912 I'I'. CII6., 1912. OI(eHKy pa60T A. A. MBaHoBCKoI'o II M. A. MlIcliKoBa B
COOTBeTCTBlin C YPOBHeM paSBIITIiJI lI:paHIIOJIOI'IIIl B KOHI(e XIX - Ha'IaJIe XX B. CM.:
A e1iceee B. II. MCTOPllJI lI:paHIIOJIOI'IIII HapO}];OB BOCTO'IHOii: EBpOIILl II RaBKasa /I
O'IepKII IICTOplI1I PYCCKoii: 3THoI'paiIJIIII, iIJOJIbKJIOPIICTIiKII II aHTpOIIOJIOnIlI, III. M.,
1965. (Tp. MH-Ta 3THoI'paiIJIIII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 91).
31 .l{e6e/f r. (j). IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIJI CCCP IITp. I1H-Ta 3THoI'paiIJIIII AH CCCP. H. C.
M.; JI., 1948. T. 4.
32 Byna1i B. B. YIepeIIa liS CKJIeIIOB I'opHOI'O RaBKasa B CpaBHIITeJILHo-aHTpOIIOJIOI'If'Ie-
CKOM OCBem;eHIIII /I C6. MyseJI aHTpOIIOJIOnm: II 3THorpaiIJIIII AH CCCP. M.; JI., 1953.
T.14.
33 BecJte1ioeea K. X. RpamwJIGrIIJI OceT1I1I II IIpolIcxomp;eHIIe OCeTIIHCKOI'O HapO}];a II MSB.
CeB.-OceT. HMM. Opp;moHIIIillp;se, 1957. T. 19.
34 A6oyute uuteu u M. r. MaTepIIaJIbl K KpaHIIOJIOI'IIII RaBKasa II Tp. MH-Ta 3KcIIep1iM.
MopiIJOJIOI'IIII AH rccp. T6IIJIIICII, 1955. T. 5.
35 A e1iceee B. II. IIpolIcxomp;eHlIe HapO}];OB RaBKasa: (RpaHIIOJI. IIccJIe}];.). M., 1974.
Cp.: On 3/Ce. IIpoIIcxomp;eHlIe Hapop;oB BOCTO'IHOH EBPOIIbI: (RpaHlion. IIccneA.).
M., 1969.
36 Ce.Menoe JI. II. ApXeOJIGrII'IeCIille II 3THoI'paiIJII'IeCKlie paSblCKamm B MHI'yureTlI1I B
1925-1927 I'I'. II MSB. MHI'ym. HMM. BJIaAIIKaBKas, 1928. T. 1; On 3/Ce. 8BOJIIOI(HJI IIH-
I'ymcRlIX CBHTIIJIHm; II Tp. CeKI(IIII apXeOJIOI'IIH Poc. accoI(. Hayq.-IICcJIep;. IIH-Ta 06-
m;eCTB. HaYR. 1928. T. 4; On 3/Ce. ApxeoJIOI'If'IeCRlIe pasblCRaHIiJI B CeBepHoH OceT1I1I /I
MSB. CeB.-OceT. HMII. ,IJ;say}];mIIRay, 1948. T. '12; On 3/Ce. lIs IICTOplI1I pa60Tbl MyseJI
RpaeBep;eHIIJI CeBepo-OceTIIHcRoH ACCP IIO IIsyqeHIIIO IIaMJITHIIKOB :MaTeplIaJILHoii:
RYJILTYPLl CeBepHoIl OceTIIII. J(say}];mIIRay, 1952.
37 Rpynnoe E. 11. ApXeOJIOI'II'IeCKIle IIaMJITHIIIill BepxoBLeB p. TepeR II 6acceHHa p. CYH-
mil II ApxeoJIOI'If'IeCIillll C60PHIIR. M., 1948, (Tp. roc. MCT. MyseJI; BbIII. 17); Ryane-
/foe B. A. AJIaHCIille IIJIeMeHa CeBepHoI'o RaBRasa /I MaTeplIaJIbI II IICCJIep;OBaHIiJI IIO
apxeoJIoI'lin CCCP. M., 1962. M 106.
3'8 BMeHHO TaRaJI BeJIIf'IIiHa IIOIIpaBKII He OCHOBaHa Ha RaRIIX-JIIT60 TO'IHblX aHaTOMII'Ie-
CIillX IIJIII peHTI'eHOJIOnI'IeCIillX IICCJIep;OBaHIIJIX II BLl6paHa CKopee Ha OCHOBamrn
06II(1Ix rrpep;CTaBJIeHlIii 0 TOJIm;IIHe MHI'RIIX TRaHeii: IIO BceMY JIIII(Y.
39 .l{e6e/f r. (j). AHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCRlIe TIIIILl II Hapop;Ll RaBRasa. M., 1960. T. 1.
4.0 On 3/Ce. AHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCIille IICCJIep;OBaHIiJI B J(aI'eCTaHe.
4.1 MU1i,n,auteeC1iMt H. H. HOBLle IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCRlIe MaTeplIaJILl C TeppliToplI1I J(a-
I'eCTaHa II MaTeplIaJIbI IIO apxeOJIOI'1I1I J(aI'eCTaHa. MaXa'IRaJIa, 1959. T. 1; Ona 3/Ce.
AHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCRIIII COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIJI J(aI'ecTaHa B aJIaHO-XasapcRoe BpeMJI /I BOIIp.
aHTpOIIOJIOI'IIII. 1960. BbIII. 5.
42 runs6ypa B. B. rOpHLle Tap;mIIRII: MaTepnaJIbI IIO aHTpOIIOJIOI'lI1I RapaTeI'IiHa II J(ap-
Basa. M.; JI., 1937.
'3 06 3TOM CBIIp;eTeJILCTBYIOT II HOBLle MaTepnaJILl: .l{enucoea P. H. HOBLle p;aHHble 06
aHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCROM TIme HaCeJIeHIIH iIJaTLJIHOBCROii RYJILTYPLl II COB. 3THoI'paiIJnJI.
1966. M 4; Ona 3/Ce. AHTpOIIOJIOI'IIJI p;peBHHx 6aJIToB. PnI'a, 1975.
'4. RpoMe CBOP;HOii pa60TLl r. cI>. J(e6eI(a IIO aHTpOIIOJIOI'HIi CCCP, CM.: [(onoY1iTOpO-
ea T. C. MaTepHaJILl IIO IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOI'lI1I YKpaIIHLl II AHTpOIIOJIOI'If'IeCRHii C60PHIIR,
I. M., 1956. (Tp. MH-Ta 3THoI'paiIJIIH AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 33); Ona 3/Ce. AHTpOIIOJIOI'HJI
p;peBHeI'O HaCeJIeHIIJI YKpaHHbI (I TblCH'IeJIeTlie' p;o H. 3.- cepep;HHa I TLlCJI'IeJIeTIiJI
B. 3.). M., 1972; Ona 3/Ce. AHTPOIIOJIOnIJI HaCeJIeHHJI YRpaIIHLl MeSOJIHTa, HeOJIIiTa II
3IIOXH 6pOHSLl. M., 1973.
'5 06sop IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOI'HH RaBRasa, p;OBe}];eHHLlii:, IIpaBp;a, He P;O CeI'Op;HJIIIIHeI'O P;HJI,
MomHO HaiiTII B Tpex pa60Tax aBTopa: Alexeev V. A study of the paleoanthropology
of the Caucasus /I Reports and communications by archaeologists of the USSR. M.,
1962; AJte1iceee B. II. BTOI'H IIsyqeHHJI IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOI'lin RaBIffisa II MCT.-iIJIIJIOJI.
mypH. 1963. M 2; On 3/Ce. IIpolIcxomp;eHlIe Bapop;OB RaBRasa.
4.6 .l{e6e/f r. (j). IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOnOI'HJI CCCP.
4.7 A,n,e1iceee B. n. RpaHIIOJIOI'n'IeCRlIe TIiULl cpep;HeBeRoBoI'o HaCeJICHIiH CeBepHoI'o RaBKa-
sa II COBpeMeHHaJI aHTpOIIOJIOI'IiJI. M., 1964. (Tp. MOCR. O-Ba HCIILlTaTeneii: IIplIpOP;bI;
T.14).
'8 .l{ e6e/f r. (j). IIaJICOaHTpOIIOJIOI'IiJI CCCP.
49 A,n,e1iceee B. II., Bec,n,e1ioeea R. X. RpaHIIOJIOI'II'IeCKaJI xapaRTepliCTIiRa cpep;HeBeRO-
BOI'O HaCeJIeHIIH OceTIIII II Cpep;HeBeKoBhle lIaMJITRIIKH CeBepRoii OceTl'm. MaTepllaJIbI
II IICCJIep;OBaHIiJI IIO apXeOJIOI'lI1I CCCP. 1963. M 114.
50 IIepBaJI IIy6JIIIRaI(IIJI: .l{e6e/f r. (j). IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOI'IiJI CCCP. HeROTopLle BamRbIe
p;ono.TIHlITeJILHLle IIpIISRaKII 6bIJIH nS}IepeHLl aBTOpOI\I. KpOl\Ie IIepe'IIICJIeHRblX lIW-
I
I
279
.-
rHJIhHHKOB, mHpOKOJIlIT\hle 'Iepena npOHCXOJlJIT HS OTJleJIhHhIX MOrHJIhHHKOB ]:{areCTa-
Ha. C1L CTaTbII H. H. MIIWH\IlIenCI\OH, nepe'lUCJIeHHble BJ,[]lle.
51 CM.: KYSHelfOe B. A. YKaS. CO'I.
52 KacuJltoea P. M. AHTpOnO.iIOrU'JeCIWe HCCJIe):\OBaUUe 'Iepe:rOB HS MUHre'Iaypa (B CBRSU
C HSY'IeHHeM 8THOreHeSa aSep6aHJlHmHCKoro HapOJla). BaKY, 1964.
53 IIpeJlBapUTeJILHOe C0061I(eHUe CM.: A.ae1;ceee B. fl. 0 JlBYX rpYIInaX HaCeJIeHHH Ap-
MeHHU B 8noxy 6POHSLI II paHHerO meJIeSa II MSB. AH Apl\ICCP. 06II(eCTB. HaYKII.
1964. .N£ 1.
54 CM.: l1.JiCaeaXUUleU.aU a. H. HOBaH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCKaH HaXOp;Ka B rpYSIDI ('Ie-
pen 'IHaTypCKoro 8UeOJIHTH'IeCIWro 'IeJIOBeKa) II Tp. MH-Ta 8KcnepIIM. Mopli>OJIOrUH AH
rccp. T6HJIIICH, 1964. T. 11.
55 CM. pa60TLI aBTopa, nepe'IHCJIeHHLle BLIIlIe.
56 ClI-I., rranp: Baneee 3. H. Cpep;HeneKoBaR AJIaHUR. l(xIDIBaJIU, 1959.
57 IIpe,lIBapuTeJILHYIO ny6JIHKaI"(UIO p;aHHbIX CM.: A.aeliceee B. fl. RpaHHOJIOrH'IeCKHe
TIDIbI cpep;HeBeKOBoro HaCeJIeHHH CeBepHoro RaBKasa.
58 A.aeliceee B. fl., Bec.aelioeea K. X. YKas. CO'I. Ha Kali>eJlpe HOpMaJILHOH aHaTOMUH Me-
P;HU;HHCKoro HHCTHTYTa B 0PJlmoHHKup;se xpaHHTCH elI(e He onucaHHbIH K[>aHHOJIOrH-
'IeCKHH MaTepUaJI liS 3MeHCKoro MOrHJIbHHKa, KOTOpbIH mJleT CBoeR ny6JIHKaU;IDI H
IIOSBOJIUT npOBepHTL 8TO npep;nOJIOmeHHe.
59 ApxeOJIOrH'IeCKHR O'IepK 0 capMaTax B BOCTO'IHbIX paRoHax CeBepHoro RaBKasa CM.:
BunozpafJoe B. B. CapMaTLI CeBepo-BoCTO'IHOrO RaBKasa II Tp. TIe'I.-MHrym. Hayq.-
IICCJIep;. HH-Ta. rposHbrii, 1963. T. 6.
60 TOMy eCTb U JIHHrBHCTH'IeCRlIe CBHL(eTeJlbCTBa B BHp;e CKIIli>o-Capl\IaTCKHX 8JIe IeUTOB B
oceTHHCKOM HSLIKe: A6aee B. H. CKHli>o-eBponeRCKHe HSOrJIOCCLI. Ha CTLIKe BOCTOKa
H 3anaJla. M., 1965.
61 IIop;p06Hee 06 8TOM CM.: A.aeliceee B. fl. HeRoTopLle np06JIeMLI npOHCXOmJleHHH 6aJI
Rapu;eB H Rapa'IaeBu;eB B CBeTe p;aHHLIX aHTpOnOJIOrHH II 0 npOHCXOmJleHHH 6aJIKapu;eB
H Rapa'IaeBU;eB: MaTepHaJILI Hayq. cec. no np06JI. npOHcxomp;eHHH 6aJIKap. H Rapa-
'IaeB. HapoJloB. Ha'IL'IHK, 1960. TaM me npHBeJleHLI H HeROTopble li>aRTLI HS HCTOpHH,
HSLIKOSHaHHH, 8THorpali>HH H p;pyrHX CMemHbIX JlHCU;IDIJIUH, nOJlTBepmp;aIOII(He HSJIO-
meHHYIO TO'IKY speHHH. CM. TaRllie npe,lImeCTByIOlI(HH pasJleJI.
AHTPOIIOJIOrIP:IECRI1E AHHbIE
R IIPOEJIEME IIPOI1CXOlli EHI1.H
HACEJIEHI1.H IJ;EHTP AJIbHbIX IIPE rOPI1n
RABRA3CRoro XPEETA
COCTOHHBE MATEPBAJIOB
I
HaCeJIeHIIe pa3JIII'IHbIX palloHoB KaBKa3a p:aBHO HBJIHeTCH 06'beKTOM IIHTeR-
CIIBHbIX aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX IICCJIep:OBaHIIM 1. 8'1'0 - CJIep:CTBlie KaK cBoe06-
pa3Horo nOJIOmeHIIH KaBKa3a rra CTbIKe P:BYX MaTepIIKoB, TaK II CJIOmIlOCTII
3THIIQeCKIIX npoIJ;eCCOB Ha KaBKa3e, P:JIH BbIHcrreHIIH IICTOplIli KOTOpbIX IIC-
nOJIb30BaJIIICb caMbIe pa3If006pa3HbIe ,IJ:aHHbIe. Op:HaKo aHTpOlIOJIOrWIeCKIIe
MaTepIIaJIbI Bcex p:opeBOJIIOIJ;IIOIIHbIX SKClIei'J,IIIJ;IIlf, B CBoe BpeMH CblrpaBmile
onpeJIeJIeHnyIO pOJIb, B HaCTOHIl{IIll MOMeHT He Y,IJ:OBJIeTBOpHIOT IICCJIep:OBaTe-
JIeM II3-3a CBoeM MaJIO'IIICJIelIHOCTII, MeTop:OJIOrII'IeCKOrO HeCOBepmeHCTBa II
OTCYTCTBIIH ,IJ:aHHbIX lIO MHornM OIJIICaTeJIblIbDI rrpII3HaKaM, KOTOpbDI Tenepb
npilgaeTcH IIepBOCTelIeHHoe 31IaQeHIIe.
Pe3YJIbTaTbI IICCJIe,IJ:OBaHIIM COBeTCKIIX aHTpOnOJIOrOB 3a nepIIOp: p:o OTe-
QeCTBelfHOll BOMHbI CYMMIIpOBaHbI B paOOTe B. B. BYHaRa, CO,IJ:epmaIIJ;ell
TaE{JRe 06IIIIIpHbIe MaTepIIaJIbI no aHTpOnOJIOrIIII rpY3IIHCKIIX II apMHRCRIIX
rpYIIII, c06paIlHbIe aBTopOM 2. cpe,IJ:II IIHrymeM II oceTIIH B. B. BYHaK BbI-
p:eJIIIJI npIITepeKCKIIll BapIIaHT, xapaKTepII3YIOIIJ;IIMCH OOJILIDIIMII pa3MepaMII
JIIIIJ;a, BbICOKIIM pOCTOM II BbIpameHHOM 6paXlIKe<paJIIIell. BbIp:eJIeHIIe 3Toro
BapIIaHTa HBIIJIOCb llepBbIM HaMeKOM Ha cBoe06pa3IIe aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKOrO
280
TlIIIa ropHbIX rpynn U;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a. O,IJ:HaKO OTCYTCTBIIe p:anHbIX
no ropHbIM rpynIIaM rpY3IIII He ,IJ:aBaJIO B03l\WmnOCTII onpe,IJ:eJIIITb ero Mec-
TO B paCOBOM CIICTeMaTIIKe HaCeJIeHIIH KaBKa3a.
ITOBOpOTHbIM nYHKT B II3Y'IeIlIIII aHTpOnO.ITOrIIII HapO,IJ:OB KaBKa3a CBH3aH
.c ,IJ:eHTeJIbHOCTblO aHTpOnOJIOrII IeCKoro OTp:eJIa IIHCTIITYTa SKCIIepIIMeHTaJIb-
HOM Mop<pOJIOrIIII AKa,IJ:eMIIII HaYK rpY3IIHCKoii: ccp. B npOIJ;eCce SKcne,IJ:II-
IJ;IIOHHbIX IICCJIep:oBaHIIii 1950-1960 rr. rpy3IIHCKIIl\UI aHTpOnOJIOral\III GbIJIII
II3Y"IeHbI Bce STHII'IeCKIIe rpynnbI HaCeJIeHIIH ceBepIIoro KaBKa3a, rpY3IIiI
Ji[ ApMeIIIIII, qTO n03BO.TIIIJIO nO,IJ:OMTII K 060cHoBaIIIIoMY cym):(eHIIIO 0 CTene-
HII IIX CXO):(CTBa II pa3.ITII'IIIH II K mIIpOKOMY IICnOJIb30BaHIIIO aHTpOnOJIOrII-
eCKIIX ):(aHHbIX ,IJ:JIH pemeHIIH STHOreHeTIPICCIHIX np06JIeM 3. B COCTaBe Ha-
.ceJIeHIIH U;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a BbI,IJ:eJIeH KaBImCIIOHCKIIli TIIn, R IWTOPOMY
6bIJIII OTHeceHbI oceTIIHbI, a II3 KapTBeJIbCKIIX rpYIIn - CBaHbI, IImaBbI, pa-
qIIHIJ;bI, xeBcypbI, MTIIYJIbIJ;bI, rY,IJ:aMaKapIJ;bI, MoxeBIJ;bI, KIICTIIHbI II TymIIHbI.
AHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIe IICCJIep,OBaHIIH B ,l];arecTaHe, npOII3Bep:eHHbIe r. <D. ,l];e-
6eIJ;OM, nOKa3aJIII, qTO KaBKaCIIOHCKIIM TIIn npe,IJ:CTaBJIeII II B HaCe:IeUIIII 3a-
nap:Horo ,l];arecTaHa cpep:II aBapIJ;eB 11 aH,IJ:IIMCKIIX rpynn 4. HaKOHeIJ;, aHTpo-
nOJIOI'IIqeCKOe II3y<reHIIe 3anap:HbIx COce,IJ:eii: STHorpa<pWIeCKIIX ropHbIX rpy-
.3IIHCKIIX rpynn - TIOPKOH3bIqHbIX 6aJIKapIJ;eB II Kapa'IaeBIJ;eB, npOBe,IJ:ermOe
B 1958 r. M. r. AGp:ymeJIIImBIIJIII II r. K. ,l];maH6epIIp:3e, n03BOJIIIJIO OT-
HeCTII IIX TaKme K KaBKaCIIOHCKO:\IY TIIny 5. K aHaJIOrIIqHOMY BbIBO,IJ:y npII-
meJI II aBTOp 6 npII paCCMOTpeHIIII MaTepIIaJIOB B. II. JIeBIIHa 7. TaKIIM 06-
pa30M, CneIJ;II<pIIqeCKOe Mop<pOJIOrWIeCKoe CXOp:CTBO 06'be,IJ:IIHHeT, nO-BIIp:IIMO-
MY, Bce IIJIII nO ITII Bce rpynnbI HaCeJIeHIIH KaBKa3a, npOmIIBalOIIJ;lIe no
OTporaM IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM qaCTII KaBKa3CKoro xpe6Ta.
B qeM OHO npOHBJIHeTCH? OTBeT IIa STOT Bonpoc ,IJ:aeT cpaBHeHIIe pa3-
JIII'IHbIX IIpeACTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna Mem,IJ:y C060H.
B Ta6JI. 9 npep:CTaBJIeHbI npII3HaKII, nOCJIymIIBmIIe ):(JIH BbI,IJ:eJIeHIIH KaB-
KaCIIOHCKoro TIIna. K IIX qIICJIY OTHOCHTCH BeJIIFIIIHa ,IJ:JIIIHbI TeJIa, 60JIbmIIe
pa3MepbI IIpOp:OJIbHOrO II oc06eHHo nOnepe'IHOrO ,IJ:IIaMeTpOB rOJIOBbI, COOTHO-
IDeHIIe KOTOpbIX p:aeT BbICOKIIM qepenHOM YKa3aTeJIb, orpOMHaH IDIIplma
JIIIIJ;a, B IIpe,IJ:eJIax eBpOneOII,IJ:HOM paCbI HaXO,IJ:HIIJ;aH aHa.ITOI'IIII TOJIbKO y 'J:ep-
HOrOpIJ;eB 8, II HeKOTopaH TeHp:eHIJ;IIH K nOCBeTJIeHIIIO nIIrMeIITaIJ;IIII, KOTopaH
BbIpamaeTCfl B 3na'IIITeJIbHOM no cpaBHeHIIIO C ,IJ:pyrIIl\III KaBKa3CKIIMII rpyn-
naMII npOIJ;eHTe IIH,IJ:IIBII,IJ:yYMOB co CBeTJIbIMII OTTeHKaMII rJIa3. B 06Il{eM,
eCJIII IICKJIlOqIITb TeHp:eHIJ;IIIO K ):(enIIrMeHTaI(IIII, Bce STII npII3HaKII HBJIHIOT-
CH <PYHKIJ;IIeM IIHTeHCIIBHOCTII pOCTa. TaKIIM 06pa3mI, IIHTeHCIIBHbIll pOCT
opraHII3Ma B p:aHHOM CJIyqae CJIe,IJ:yeT, nO-BIIp,IIMO:\IY, CqIITaTb paCOBOM
oc06eHHOCTblO, CJIep:CTBIIeM KOTOpOE HBJIHIOTCH 60JIbmIIe pa3MepbI rOJIOBbI II
JIIIIJ;a.
HeKOTOpylO aprYMeHTaIJ;IIIO B nOJIb3Y TaKOM TpaKTOBKII STIIX oco",eHHO-
CTeM :\IOmHO nOqepnHYTb II3 paCCMOTpeHIIH paHrOBbIX KOS<P<PIIIJ;IIeHTOB Mem-
rpynnoBOll CBH3II Memp:y HIIMII (Ta6JI. 10). K03<P<PIIIJ;IIeHTbI CBH3II ,IJ:JIIIHbI
TeJIa C p:IIaMeTpaMII 'IepenHOM Kop06KII II mIIplIHOM JIIIIJ;a IIMelOT nOJIOmII-
1'eJIbHbIM 3HaK II coxpaHHIOT Te me BeJIII'IIIHbI, KOTopbIe xapaKTepHbI p:JIH
KOS<P<PIIIJ;IIeHTOB BHYTpIIrpynnoBoM II3MeHqIIBOCTII. MbI He II:\IeeM 3,IJ:eCb,
CJIe,IJ:OBaTeJIbHO, 06bIqHOrO HapymeHIIH BHYTpIIrpynnoBoII II3MeWIIIBOCTII. Ha-
GJIIO):(aeMbIe pa3JIII'IIIH Mem,IJ:y rpynnaMII JIerKO 06'bHCHHIOTCH KOJIe6aHIIHMll
pOCTa.
ITlIrMeHTaIJ;IIH, pa3YMeeTCH, He CBH3aHa HenOCpe,IJ:CTBeHHOM iPYHKIJ;IIOHaJIb-
HOM KOppeJIHIJ;IIeM C pOCTOBOM TeHp:eHIJ;IIeM opraHII3Ma. ITpaB,IJ:a, HeJIb3H
IICKJIIO IIITb HaJIIIqIIe KOCBeHHOM CBH3II. T. ,l];3epmIIKpaM-Pora.'IbClmii: II
M. OJIeKeBIIq nOJIyqIIJIII IIHTepeCHbIe p:aHHbIe 0 KOppeJIHIJ;IIII IIHTeHCIIBHOCTII
281
Ta6JUlqa 9
ConOCTaBJIeHUe paS. T 1BQHI>lX rpynn KaBKaCUOHCKoro Tuna. Mym'IBlIhI
I(BC>T rJIaa
npo- qepen-
)];mma iJ,O;Jb- nonepeq- HOM CHYJIOBOfi
rpynna TeJIa HbIH HbIM ,JJ;Ha- YHaaa- iJ,HaMeTp CBeT- CMe- Cpe,JJ;-
,JJ;na- MeTp TeJIb JIbIe, % lliaH- HHfi
MeTp HbIC, % 6aJIJI
EaJIKapD;M* 168,1 186,6 l61,3 86,4 145,0 8,0 77,0 1,07
RapaQaeBqbI 168,0 189,0 161,6 85,4 147,0 14,9 81.1 0,89
OceTHHb uropqM 170,0 189,9 160,3 84,5 147,2 12,8 63,7 1,11
OceTuHM-uPoHD;M 168,,0 188.9 157,9 83,,7 145,2 15,0 60,0 1,10
OceTHHM }J;maBcKoro p-Ha 171,4 188,2 160,4 85,2 147,9 8,0 67,0 1,17
OCeTUHIJ I{xHHBaJIbCKO- 169,6 185,0 159,0 85,9 145,8 15,0 68,0 1,02
ro p-Ha
RBeMo-cBaHM 169,8 190,9 158,1 83,1 146,4 3,8 76,8 1,16
3eMo-cBaHM 167,4 188,2 162,1 86,2 147,1 6,9 70,3 1,16
IImaBbI 168,7 187,4 161,9 86,5 146,5 12,4 72,4 1,03
XeBcypM 168,3 191:8 159,7 83,2 146,6 16,6 74,0 0,93
qarMa-TyIIIHHM 168,8 188,1 160.6 85,4 146,5 18,5 64,8 0,98
I{oBa-TymuHM 169,6 190,9 158,7 83,2 145,9 15,5 69,0 1,00
PaQUHqM ropHMe 169,3 185,4 160,6 86,7 147,6 3,9 70,9 1,21
PaQUHD;M paBHuHHMe 168,1 187,7 156,6 83,6 145,5 10,6 56,7 1,12
MoxeBD;M 169,8 190,9 158,8 83,3 146,5 12,0 62,0 1,14
MTUYJIbn;M 168,7 189,2 157,7 83,3 145,1 11,8 64,7 1,12
ry aMaKapn;:bI 167,7 188,4 158,4 84,2 146,0 8,3 70,4 1,,13
RUCTUHbI 168,3 186.0 158,0 85,1 144,3 11.8 76,4 1,00
ABapD;:bI Sana E],IX pail- 167.0 183,9 158,2 86,0 145,6 16,7 59.5 1,07
OHOB
ABapD;:bI npoQnx paiiOHOB 169,3 183,3 158,4 86,4 144,2 8,0 66,0 1,18
AH Hii:D;:bI 168,1 184,3 156,3 84,8 144,,5 15,0 67,5 1,02
EOTJIUXn;:bI 167,2 183,7 159,2 86,7 145,7 9,9 67,9 1,12
rO o6epHHq:bI 168,6 182,5 159,1 87,2 145,4 9,1 67,,5 1,14
RapaTHHD;DI 169,0 183,8 158,4 86,2 145,2 6,8 64,1 1,22
AXBaxH 167.1 185,2 157,4 85,0 145,4 27,1 60,5 0,85
RBaHap,HHD;:bI 169,4 181,6 156,2 86,,0 145,0 8,2 57,7 1,26
'£leMaJIUHD;:bI 169,3 182,9 158,8 86,8 146,3 16,3 57,5 1,10
TUHAHHD;:bI 168,7 180,6 158,6 87,8 146,1 10,0 60,0 1,20
llIIrMeHTaIJ;IIII c <POPMYJIOll KpOBli CliCTeMbI ABO 9. IToCJIe)];HHH, KaK II3BeCT-
HO, HBJIHeTCH CTOllKOM xapaKTepIICTImOM IIHp:IIBIIp:yaJIbHOM 6HOXHl\iIIH opra-
HII3Ma. A 6IIOXIIMHH, IlO-BII)];IIMOMY, BJIliHeT Ha ero pO CT. Ho HeB03MomHO
B HaCTOHIl{ee BpeMH YJIOBIITb CBH3b Memp:y llIIrMeHTaIJ;IIell II IIHTeHCHBHOCTblO
pOCTa, eCJIli p:ame OHa II IIMeeT MeCTO. TaKHM 06pa30M, IIOCBeTJIeHIIe IIIIr-
MeHTaIJ;IIII y npe)];CTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKoro THna CJIe,IJ:yeT paCCMaTpHBaTb
HaK He3aBIICliMbIM paCOBbIM npII3HaK BbICOKoro TaKCOHOMIIqeCKoro 3Ha'IeHIIH,
)];OnO:IHHIOIIJ;IIll xapaKTepIICTliKY Mop<pOJIOrIIQeCKOrO cBoe06pa3IIH TIIna.
cYP:H no BeJIIIqIIHe II HanpaBJIeHlllO CBH3II, nOCBeTJIeHlIe nIIrMeHTaIJ;IIII co-
npOBOm,IJ:aeTCH yneJIII'IeHIIeM pa3MepOB rOJIOBbI, oc06eHHO npO,IJ:OJIbHOrO Ha-
MeTpa, HO YMeHbmeHIIeM ,IJ:JIIIHbI TeJIa. cJIe,IJ:OBaTeJIbIIO, BHYTPII caMoro KaB-
KaCIIOHCKoro Tlina xapaKTepHbIe p:JIH Hero npII3HaKII He 06pa3YIOT KOMn:IeK-
282
Ta6mrqa 10
Roa!JIqlHqHeHTbI paHroBoH KOppeJIHqHH OCHOBHbIX ):\HarHOCTHqecKHX npH3HaKoB
KaBKaCHOHCKoro Tilna. MymqHHbI
npOiJ,OJIbHblH nOnepe'lHbIfi CHYJIOBOH I(BeT rJIaa
npH3HaH )];JIHHa TeJIa )J;HaMeTP )J;HaMeTp iJ,HaMeTP ( cpeiJ,HHH
6aJIJI)
)J;JIHHa TeJIa -
IIpO):\OJIbHbIH AlIal\1eTp 0,155 -
IIOnepeqHbIH p,HaMeTp 0,102 0,202 -
CRyJIOBOH AHaMeTp 0,279 0,453 0,690 -
l(BeT rJIa3 (cpep,HHH 0,362 -0,315 -0,090, 0.014 -
6aJIJI )
ca, pacnpe,IJ:eJIHHCb M03aIIqHO B pa3HbIx rpYIInax. 8'1'0'1' <paKT HaXO):(IIT ce6e
nO,IJ:TBepllip:eHIIe II IIPII paCCMOTpeHIIII reorpa<pIIqeCKOI'O paCIIpe)];eJIeHIIH 0'1'-
p;eJIbHbIX IIpII3HaKOB. TaK, aHp:IIMcKIIe rpYUIIbI 3anap:Horo )J;arecTaHa II aBap-
IJ;bI JIMelOT 3aMeTHO MeHbmIIe pa3MepbI IIpOp:OJIbHOrO p:IIaMeTpa rOJIOBbI, qeM
ropHbIe rpYIIIIbI rpY3IIH, II, nO-BII,IJ:IIMOMy, OTJIII raIOTCFf 0'1' HIIX, XOTH II
O IeHb He3HaqIITeJIbHO, YBeJIIIqeHIIeM KOJIII'IeCTBa IIH,IJ:IIBIIP:YYMOB co CBeTJIbI-
MIl rJIa3aMli. Ho IIO P:PyrIIM IIpII3HaKaM pa3JIIIQIIH OTCYTCTBYIOT.
AHaJIOrIIQHbIM 06pa30M CBaHbI II ropHbIe paQIIHIJ;bI BbIp:eJIHIOTCH OTHOCII-
TeJIbHO TeMHbIM IJ;BeTOM rJIa3. O,IJ:HaKO OHII HII'IYTb He 60JIee BbICOKOpOCJIbI,
illIIpOKOJIIIIJ;bI II 60JIbmerOJIOBbI, eM OCTaJIbHbIe rpYIIIIbI, OTHOCHIl{IIeCH K
KaBKacIIoHcKOMY TIIIIY. MOlliHO 6bIJIO 6bI P:YMaTb, QTO Ha 3arra):(e TeppIITo-
pIIII, 3aHHToll npep:cTaBIITeJIHMII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIIIa, IJ;BeT rJIa3 TeMHee,
QeM Ha BOCTOKe 10. Ho cpep:II 3ana,IJ:HbIX COCe)];ell CBaHOB - 6aJIKapIJ;eB -
II oc06eHHo KapaQaeBI(eB IIpOIJ;eHT CBeTJIOrJIa3bIX )];OBOJIbHO BbICOK.
rBIIOTE3bI npOBcxom)J;EHBH RABRACBOHCRoro TBIIA
COBepmeHHO eCTeCTBeHHO, qTO npOIIcxomp:eHIIe STOM cBoe06pa3HOll KOMGlIHa-
IJ;IIII IIpII3HaKOB HBIIJIOCb npe)];MeTOM mlipoKoro 06CYlli)];eHIIH. BbIJIII npep:JIO-
meHbI )];Be rIIIIOTe3bI - aBTOXTOHHaH II MlirpaIJ;IIOHHaH.
AnToxToHHaH rIIIIOTe3a BIIepBbIe 6bIJIa BbICKa3aHa A. H. HaTlimBIIJIli II
M. r. A6)];ymeJIlimBIIJIli B 1956 r. OTMeqaH KpaMHee IIOJIOmeHIIe, KOTopoe
3aHliMaeT KaBKaCIIOHCKIIM TIIII CpeD,II p:pyrIIX KaBKa3CKliX TlirrOB no IJ;eJIOMY
pHP:Y IIpII3HaKOB, OHII IIIICaJIII, 'ITO «Bxop:HllJ;IIe B ero COCTaB rpynnbI IIpep:-
CTaBJIHIOT C060M rrOTOMKOB a60pIIreHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH KaBKa3CKliX rop» 11.
8Ta TO'IRa 3peHIIH IIOJI IIJIa p:aJIbHeMmee 060CHOBaHlie B pa60Te M. r. A6-
)];ymeJIliIDBliJIH, IIOCBHIIJ;eHHOM aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKOMY TIIIIY oceTliH 12. ITo ero
MHeHIIIO, Tlirr oceTIIH-IIpOHIJ;eB CJIOmIIJICH B IIpOI(eCCe CJIIIHHIIH npe):(CTaBIITe-
JIeM MeCTHoro KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna II. aJIaHCKOro HaCeJIeHIIH, TIIII oceTIIH-
)];IIropIJ;eB II HaCeJIeHIIH IOmHoM OceTIIII COXpaHHJI <pII3II'IeCKlie oc06eHHOCTII
)];peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH IIpe,IJ:rOpIIM KaBKa3CKoro xpe6Ta. )J;OKa3aTeJIbCTBOM
aBTOXTOHHoro IIpOIIcxom):(eHIIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIrra HBJIHeTCH KOl\IIIaKTHbIM
apeaJI B IIpep:ropbHX IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM qaCTII KaBKa3CKoro xpe6Ta II OTCYTCTBlie
HCHbIX aHaJIOrIIM eMY Ha KaBKa3e II 3a ero rrpe,IJ:eJIaMli.
BceCTopOHHHH aprYMeHTaIJ;IIH STOM rIInOTe3bI 3aTpY,IJ:HeHa rrOqTII IIOJIHbIM
OTCYTCTBIIeM rraJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrII'IeCKliX MaTepIIaJIOB C TeppliTopHH IJ;eHT-
283
paJIbHoro KaBKa3a. 113yqeHHbIM M. r. A6p:ymeJIlimBIIJIli MaTepIIaJI II3 caM-
TaBpCKoro MOrIIJIbHIIKa n03BOJIHeT cp:eJIaTb 3aKJIIO'IeHIIe, 'ITO HaCeJIeHIIe
paBHIIHHOM rpY3IIII B SIIOXY 6pOH3bI II paHHero meJIe3a OTHOCIIJIOCb K P:JIIIH-
HOrOJIOBOMY II Y3KOJIIIIJ;eMy eBpOIIeOIIp:HOMY TIIny 13. HaCeJIeHIIe ceBepHoro
I\'aBKa3a B STY SIroxy, nO-BII,IJ:IIMOMY, OTJIIIqaJIOCb cpaBHIITeJIbHO BbICOKIIM
qepenHbIM YKa3aTeJIeM II MeHbmeM rpaIJ;IIJIbHOCTblO 1". Op:HaKO STOT BbIBO)];
OCHOBaH Ha paCCMOTpeHIIII e,IJ:MHII'IHbIX Haxop:OK II HOCIIT cyry60 npe,IJ:BapII-
TeJIbHbrii xapaKTep. B KaqeCTBe ep:IIHcTBeHHoM y6e,IJ:IITeJIbHOM aHaJIOrIIII KaB-
KacIIoHcKOMY TIIny MomeT CJIymIITb TOJIbKO Mop<pOJIOrM'IeCKMM TIIn qepeIIOB
3IIOXM II03p,Hero Cpe)];HeBeKOBbH, P:06bITbIX npM pacKoIIKax MOrIIJIbHMKa Xapx
B OceTIIII 15. Ho IIX TaKme MaJIO, II OHII OTCTOHT OT cOBpeMeHHoCTII IIpII-
6mI3IITeJILHO Ha TbICH'Iy JIeT, Tor,IJ:a KaK KaBKacIIoHcKMll TIIII IIMeeT, O'Ie-
BIIp:HO, ropa3p:0 60JIee p:peBHee npOIIcxom):(eHIIe.
ITpoII3Bep:eHHoe M. r. A6p:ymeJIMmBMJIM conOCTaBJIeHIIe pa3HoBpeMeHHbIx
llaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX cepliM II3 caMTaBpcKoro MOrIIJIbHIIKa B !J;eJIHX
BbIHBJIeHIIH p:IIHaMMKM npII3HaKoB BO BpeMeHII npliBeJIO ero K MHTepecHoMY
BbIBOP:y 0 TOM, qTO IIpOIJ;eCC rpaIJ;IIJIII3aIJ;MII, xapaKTepHbIM )];JIH p:pyrIIx 06-
JIaCTeM cOBeTcKoro cOlO3a 16, He IIMeJI MeCTa Ha TeppMTopIIII rpY3IIM 17.
Ha060pOT, qepeIIHbIe cepIIII 3nOXII 6pOH3bI OTJIM'IaIOTCH 0'1' B3HTbIX )];JIH
cpaBHeHMH KpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX cepIIM rpY3IIII XV-XVII BB. MeHbmIIM CKY-
JIOBbIM p:lIaMeTpOM, 60JIee npHMbIM JI60M, MeHee pa3BMTbIM Ha,IJ:6pOBbeM
II 3HaqIITeJIbHO 60JIee HII3KIIM qepenHbIM YKa3aTeJIeM. 8'1'0 MomeT 6bITb no-
Ka3aHO KaK na OCHOBaHIIII IIpOCToro cpaBHeHMH cpe):(HIIX BeJIIIqIIH OT)];eJIb-
HbIX cepIIM, TaK II npII nOMOIIJ;II rpa<pIIqeCKOrO BbIpameHIIH pa3HMIJ;bI Memp,y
HIIMII.
IToBbImeHIIe 'IepenHOro YKa3aTeJIH YKJIap:bIBaeTCH B paMKII npOl{eCca
6paxIIKe<paJIII3aIJ;IIII II COBna)];aeT C 06bIqHO Ha6JIIO,IJ:aeMbIM HanpaBJIeHIIeM
pa3JIIIqIIM no 'IepenHOMY YKa3aTeJIIO Mem,IJ:y paHHIIMII II II03)];HII IM cepIIH-
MIl 18. Ho no BceM p:pyrMM npII3HaKaM HanpaBJIeHIIe pa3JIMQIIM npOTMBono-
JIOmHO 06bIQHO Ha6JIIOp:aeMoMY. ITOCKOJIbKY apxeOJIOrWIeCKIIe II UCTOpII'Ie-
CKlie p:aHHbIe He )];alOT OCHOBaHIIM npe,IJ:IIOJIaraTb OTCYTCTBIIe IIpeeMCTBeHHO-
CTII Mem,IJ:Y rpynnaMII HaCeJIeHIIH, OCTaBIIBmero pa3HOBpeMeHHbIe norpe6eHIIH
caMTaBpCKoro MOrIIJIbHIIKa, M. r. A6,IJ:ymeJIIIllIBIIJIII ):(eJIaeT BbIBOp: 0 CBoe-
06pa3HbIX nYTHX SnOXaJIbHOM TpaHc<popMaIJ;IIII aHTpono.lIOrIFIeCKIIX IIpII3Ha-
KOB y p:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH rpY3IIII. ITp06JIe Ia npOIIcxom.o:eHIIH KaBKaCIIOH-
CKoro TIIna npII STOM He 3aTparliBaeTCH. O,IJ:HaKO OQeBII,IJ:nO, QTO, KOJIb
CKOpO OTJIIIqIIH COBpe reHHbIX rpY3MH paBHIIHHbIX paMOHOB OT HaCeJIeHIIH
snOXII 6pOH3bI MorYT 6b1Tb 06'bHCHeHbI KaK CJIe,IJ:CTBIIe STOM 3aKoHoMepHo-
CTII, nOCJIep:HIOIO MomHO pacnpOCTpaHIITb II Ha ropHbIe STHorpa<pII IeCKMe
rpynnbI rpY3IIHCKoro Hapop:a.
IIHaH TOqKa 3peHIIH Ha npoMCxOm,IJ:eHIIe KaBKacIIoHcKoro TIIna 6bIJIa
BbIp:BIIHYTa r. CPo ,l];e6en:oM 19. XapaKTepHoe p:JIH KaBKaCIIOHCKMX rpynn no-
CBeTJIeHIIe nMrMeHTaIJ;IIM OH CTaBliT B CBH3b C pacnpOCTpaHeHMeM SJIeMeHTOB
BOCTO'IHOeBpOneMCKoro npOMcxomp:eHIIH. AHaJIOrII IHOe 06'bHCHeHlIe r. CPo ,l];e-
6eIJ; p:onYCKaeT II p:JIH B03HIIKHOBeHIIH mlipOKOJIIIIJ;eCTM, YKa3bIBaH Ha pac-
npOCTpaHeHIIe mIIpOKOJIIIIJ;bIX TIIIIOB no BceM TeppIITopMII BOCTO'IHOM EBpO-
nbI, B cKaHp:IIHaBIIII II cpe):(II eBponeoII;'J:Horo HaCeJIeHIIH IOmHoM cH6IIpli B
SIiOXY 6pOH3bI II paHHero meJIe3a. O,IJ:HaKo OH He IICKJIIOQaeT nOJIHOCTblO
Toro HanpaBJIeHIIH B SnOXaJIbHOM II3MeH'IIIBOCTII npII3HaKOB, Ha KOTopoe 06-
paTIIJI BHIIMaHIIe M. r. A6p,ymeJIlimBIIJIII, II C IMTaeT IDMpOKOJIIII(eCTb II
KpyrJIOrOJIOBOCTb oceTIIH n03p:HIIM 06pa30BaHlIeM, B03HMKmIIM Ha npOTHme-
HIIII IIOCJIe;J:HIIX CTOJIeTIIll. 06Il{IIM BbIBOp: TeM He MeHee OCTaeTCH HeII3MeH-
HbIM; IIprr IICCJIep:OBaHIIII BOIIpOCOB npOIICXOllip:eHIIH KaBKaCIIOHCRIIX rpynn
284
r. <D. ,l];e6eIJ; peKOl\IeH):(yeT «I1MeTb B BIIP:Y TaIDKe II CBH3II C ceBepHbIMII 06-
JIaCTHMII, B nepBYIO Oqepe)];b, OqeBIIp:HO, C TeppIlTopIIeM PYCCKOM paB-
HIIHbI» 20.
B IJ;eJIHX rrOJIHOTbI I13JIOmeHIIH CJIe,IJ:yeT YIIOMHIIYTb, 'ITO B CBO):(HOi'r pa60-
Te rro rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIII cccp r. <D. ,l];e6eIJ; CqIlTaJI, 'ITO mnpOKOJIIIIJ;bIM
6paXIIKpaHHbIM TIIll, rrpe,IJ:CTaBJIeHHbIM B Xapxe, I1MeeT MeCTHoe rrpoIlcxom-
p:eHIIe II BOCXO)];IIT K TIITIY HaCeJIeHIIH CKII<po-capMaTCKoro BpeMeHII, a MomeT
6bITb, II srroxII 6pOH3bI. Ho, pa3YMeeTcH, 1l0):(ooHaH TOqKa 3peHIIH He I1CKJIIO-
'IaeT ,IJ:OnYIl{eHIIH 0 nepeCeJIeHIIII rrpe,IJ:CTaBIITeJIeM SToro TIIrra Ha TeppIlTO-
pIlIO ceBepHoro KaBKa3a B 60JIee paHHee Bpej\IH II BOIIpeKII l\UleHIIIO
H. H. MIIKJIameBCKOM 21 He rrpOTIIBOpeqIIT 60JIee n03p:HIIM BbICKa3bIBaHIIHM
r. <D. ,l];e6eIJ;a, pa306paHHbIM BbIme.
rIIrroTe3a r. <D. )J;e6eI(a 0 IIpOIICXOIR):(eHIIII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna ObIJIa
rro):(,IJ:epmaHa H. H. MIIKJIameBCKoM Ha OCHOBaHIIII I1CCJIe)];OBaHIIH IIaJIeO-
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX MaTepIlaJIOB C TeppIITopIIII ,l];arecTaHa 22. B Ka'IeCTBe
napaJIJIeJIeM KaBKaCIIOHCKOMy TIIrry OHa YKa3bIBaeT IIa 'IeperrH@e cepIIII I13
capMaTCKIIX llorpe6eHIIM 3ana,IJ:HOrO Ka3aXCTaHa 23, HIImHero IIOBOJImbH 24
II YRpaIIHbI 25 . O,IJ:HaKO BOIIpOC 0 BpeMenn rrpOHIIKHOBeHIIH SToro TIIna Ha
ceBepHbIM KaBKa3 OCTaeTCH OTKpbITbIM II3-3a IIO ITII rrOJIHOrO OTCYTCTBIIH
naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKIIX MaTepIlaJIOB snOXII HeOJIIITa II OpOH3bI.
I
AKTbI, KOTOPblE CJIE,l],YET yqBTbIBATb
IIPB OECYJKJJ;EHBB rBIIOTE3bI M. r. AEJJ;YIIIEJIBIDBBJIB
ITOCKOJIbKY aBTOXTOHHaH rIlrrOTe3a HaIlOOJIee nOJIHO aprYMeHTIIpoBaHa
M. r. A6,IJ:ymeJIIIIIIBIIJIII, OHa B p:aJIbHei'rmeM II3JIOmeHIIII 6Y,IJ:eT <PIIrYPIlPO-
BaTb no,IJ: ero I1MeHeM. PaCCMOTpIIM KpIlTII'IeCKII TOT l\IaTepIIaJI, Ha OCHOBa-
HIIII KOToporo cp:eJIaHO 3aKJIIOqeHIIe 0 cBoe06pa3lIII B TeqeHIIII npOIJ;eCCOB
SnOXaJIbHOrO II3MeHeHIIH IIpII3HaKOB Ha TeppIlTopIIII rpY3IIII.
B nepBYIO Oqepe,IJ:b CJIe,IJ:yeT OTMeTIITb. qTO MaTepIIaJI STOT rrpOIICXOp:IIT
I13 O,IJ:Horo MOrIlJIbHIIKa. ITpaB,IJ:a, caMTaBpCKIIM l\WrIIJIbIIIIK CbIrpaJI BbI):(alO-
Il{YIOCH pO JIb B II3yqeHIIII KaBKa3CKIIX p:peBHOCTeM 26, a ero norpeOaJIbHbIe
KOMIIJIeKCbJ ,IJ:O CIIX rrop I1MeIOT rrepBOCTeIIeHHoe 3HaqeHIIe B KaqeCTBe OCHO-
BbI p:JIH BbIpa60TKU XpOHOJIOrIlqeCKOM mKaJIbI srrOXII 6pOH3bI II paHHero me-
JIe3a He TOJIbKO p:JIH rpY3I1I1, HO II p:JIH Bcero 3aKaBKa3bH 27. OAHaKo I1CKJIIO-
'IIITeJIbHOe 3HaqeHIIe naMHTHIIKa II BbICOqaMmIlM xY,IJ:OmeCTBeHHbIM ypoBeHb
HaMp:eHHbIx B HeM npe,IJ:MeTOB KYJIbTYPbI II IICKyccTBa eIl{e He p:alOT OCHO-
BaHIIII rrepeHOCIITb Ha6JIIO)];eHIIH II BbIBOp:bI, cp:eJIaIIIlbIe npIl II3Y IeHIIII SToro
MaTepIIaJIa, Ha pa3BIITIIe MaTepIlaJIbHOM KYJIbTypbI Bcex p:peBHIIX STHIIqe-
CKIIX rpyrrn, npomIlBaBmlIX Ha rpY3IIHCKOM TepplITopIIrr. He lICKJIIO IeHO,
qTO 06JIaCTII p:peBHeM KapTaJIIIHIIII B snoxy 6pOH3bI xapaKTeplI30BaJIIICb
orrpe,IJ:eJIeHHOM STHlIqeCKOM CneI(II<plIKoM, XOTH, MomeT ObITb, II MeHee pe3Ko
BbIpameHHoM, qel\I B 60JIee rr03,IJ:HeO BpeMH. Bo BCHKmi cJIY'Iae, apXeOJIOrII-
'IeCKIIll MaTeplIaJI nycTb nOKa npIIrJIymeHHo, HO rOBopIIT 0 HaJIII IlIII JIOKaJIb-
HbIX BapIIaHTOB KYJIbTypbI HaCeJIeHIIH OT,IJ:eJIbHbIX paMonOB rpY3IIII B :moxy
6pOH3bI 28 . BeCbMa BepOHTHO, 'ITO naJIeOaInpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIe AaHHbIe, eCJIII ObI
OHII 6blJIII nOJIyqeHbI B pe3YJIbTaTe aHaJIII3a TIOKa OTCYTCTBYlOmero MaTepIIa-
JIa II3 MHorIIX Y,IJ:aJIeHHbIX ,IJ:Pyr 0'1' ):(Pyra MOrIlJIbTIlIKOB, n03BOJIIIJIII 6bI CO-
CTaBIITb IIHYIO KapTlIHY )];lIHaMlIKlI lI3MeHeHIIH npII3HaKOB no snoxaM II He
rrpOTlIBonOCTaBJIHTb TeppIIToplIlO rpY3IIII P:PyrluI OOJIaCTHM cOBeTCI;oro
c0103a. M. r. A6p:ymeJIlIIIIBIIJIlI caM rrIImeT, 'ITO «npOTlIB MaJIOqIICJIeHrrOCTII
HamIIX ceplIM B03palliaTb He rrpIIxop:lITCH, II, MomeT ObITb, HIIKTO TaK HBHO
He OIIJ;ymaeT He06xop:IIMOCTb IIX TIOIIOJIHeHIIH, KaK MbI» 29.
I
285
I
fill
fllu
JIl5
flll/
JIlJ
fllZ
Jill
JIl!!
!I!I
/\
/ .
. \
/ .
. \
r-J.----"
/ /
/ .
/ /
/ .
/ .J
/ /'
/./"
t
-!
--- Z
---J
ZIlIlIl
JIlIlIl
Il
fllllll
Z Illlll
f Illlll
1/
lllllll
PRC. 25. BpeMeHHli\e H3MeHelnm IDHpHHbI JIHn;eBOro CReJIeTa Ha TeppHTopHH rpY3HH
3AeCb 11 Ha pl1C. 26-32: 1 - CHYJIOBaH IIIltpl1Ha; 2 - BepxHHH IIIl1pI1Ha; 3 - cpeAHHH IIIl1pl1Ha
)J;pyroM MOMeHT, KOTOpbIM HeJIb3H He IITbIBaTb,- COIJ;IIaJIbHbIM ypOBeHb
3axopOHeHHbIX. caM <paKT, qTO MIJ;XeTa Ha py6eme ll()BOM SpbI npeBpaTII-
JIaCb B CTOJIIIIJ;y 116epIIMCKoro KHHmeCTBa (a caMTaBpCKIIM MOrIIJIbHIIK KaK
pa3, IlO-BIIP:IIMOMY, II HBJIHJICH KJIa)];6IIIl{eM p:JIH MI(XeTbI), CBII,IJ:eTeJIbCTByeT
o TOM, qTO norpe6eHIIbIe B caMTaBpCKOM l\IOrIIJIbHIIKe BPH,IJ: JIII OTHOCII:IIICb
K KpeCTbHHCKOMY HaCeJIeHIIIO. ITo BceM BepOHTHOCTII, STO 6bIJIli ropomaHe,
B OCHOBHOM TOprOBI(bI II peMeCJIeHHIIKII, a TaKme KHHllieCKaH ):(pymIIHa.
B STIIX 06CTOHTeJIbCTBaX CJIe):(yeT omIIp:aTb 3p:eCb CneIJ;IIaJIbHYIO BbI60PKY,
Cnel{II<plma KOTOpOM, OqeBIIf],HO, eIl{e YCIIJIIIBaJIaCb STHIIqeCKOM neCTpOTOM,
xapaKTepHOM )];JIH nOCeJIeHIIM ropop:CKoro TIIna. KOHeqHO, YCJIOBIIH mII3HII
B nOCJIep:HIIX B 3HaqIITeJIbHO MeHbmeM CTelleHII OTJIIIqaJIIICb 0'1' YCJIOBIIM
mII3HII KpeCTbHHCKoro HaCeJIeHIIH, <reM B HaCTOHIl{ee BpeMH. B COOTBeTCT-
BIIII C STIIM II pa3JIII'IliH B <pII3IIqeCKOM TIIne rOpO,IJ:CKOrO II CeJIbCKOrO Hace-
JIeHIIH 6bIJIII, nO-BII,IJ:IIMOMY, 3aMeTHO MeHbme 30. Ho Bce me IIX HeJI'b3H
COBceM OCTaBIITb 6e3 BHIIMaHIIH. TaKIIM 06pa30M, STOT <paKT TaKme npe)];o-
CTeperaeT npOTliB CJIIImKOM pacmIIpIITeJIbHOM TpaKTOBKII BbIBOD,OB, nOJIyqeH-
HbIX B pe3YJIbTaTe II3 eHIIH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOrO MaTepIIaJIa II3 caM-
TaBpCKoro MOrIIJIbHIIKa.
IToCJIe STIIX npep:BapIITeJIbHbIX 3aMeqaHIIM 06paTIIMCH K paCCMOTpeHIIIO
pe3YJIbTaTOB conOCTaBJIeHIIH pa3HOBpeMeHHbIX cepIIM II3 caMTaBpCKoro MO-
rIIJIbHIIKa. MaJIoe KOJIIIqeCTBO <repenOB OTp:eJIbHbIX rreplIO,IJ:OB 3aCTaBJIHeT
06'bep:IIHIITb IIX B OOJIee KpynHbIe rpynnbI no TbICWIeJIeTIIHM. M. r. A6p:y-
meJIIImBIIJIli npOII3BO,IJ:IIJI 06'bep:IIlIeHIIe, nOJIyqaH apII<pMeTlI'IeCKYIO cpe,IJ:HIOIO
Be.'III IlIHY II3 BeJIIIqIIH, xapaKTepHbIX ):(JIH COOTBeTCTBYIOIl{IIX XpOHOJIOrIIqe-
CKIIX rpyrrn. Op:HaKO KOJIII IeCTBO l\iaTepnaJIa He oCB060m,IJ:aeT npII STOM 0'1'
BJIIIHHIIH CJIyqaMHbIX KOJIe6aHIIM cpep:HIIX no OTp:eJIbHbIM nepIIop:aM Ha 06-
Il{IIe Cpe)JJIlIe no TbICH'IeJIeTIIHM. ITOSTOMY IJ;eJIeC006pa3Hee, rrO-BIID,IIMOMY,
BOCrrOJIb30BaTbCH B3BemeHHbIM1I cpe):(HIIMII no TbICH IeJIeTIIHM. O,IJ:HOBpeMeH-
no C STIIM IIHTepeCHO BBeCTII B aHaJIlI3 ,IJ:aHHbIe 06 SnOXaJIbHOM II3MeHeHIIII
ne TOJIbKO CKy.:rOBoro p:IIaMeTpa, HO II p:pyrIIx pa3MepOB, orrpe,IJ:eJIHIOllJ;IIX
mnpIIHY JIIIIJ;a,- BepxHeM II Cpe)];HeII llInpIIHbI. cooTBeTcTBYIOIl{IIe BeJIWIIIHbI
npep:CTaBJIeIIbI B Ta6JI. 11 31. OHII me BbIpameHbI II rpa<pIIqeCKII Ha pIIC. 25.
IIpII nOCTpoeHIIII rpa<pIIKa BeJIIIqIIHbI HaII60JIee paHHeM cepIIII II TbICWIeJIe-
TIIH ,IJ:O H. S. IIpIIHHTbI 3a 100 % .
286
cKYJIOBaH mIIpIIHa MymCKIIx qepenOB YBeJIlI1UIBaeTCH Ha rrpOTHmeHIIII
npII6JIII3IITeJIbnO Tpex C nOJIOBliHOM TbICH'I JIeT 60JIee <reM Ha 4 %, CKYJIO-
BOM p:IIaMeTp meIICKliX - Ha BeJIIIqIIHY 3aMeTHO MeHbmylO. 06paIIJ;aeT na
ce6H BHIIMaHlie TeMn HapacTanliH ero B meHCKliX rpynnax. ITo cpaBHeHIIIO
C ceplieM II TbICHqeJIeTIIH p:o H. S. OH YBeJIIIqIIEaeTCH B cepIIII I TbICH'IeJIe-
TIIH p:o H. s., 3aTeM nap:aeT nOqTII p:o nepBOnaqaJIbHOM BeJIII'IIIHbI II onHTb
nOBblmaeTCH B cepIIII, OTHOCHIl{ellCH K nenOCpe,IJ:CTBeHHbIM IIpe)];KaM cOBpe-
MeUHbIX rpY3IIH II p:aTIIpyeMoM XVI-XVII BB. H. s. TaKliM 06pa30M, sno-
XaJIbHOe II3MeHeHIIe CKYJIOBOM mIIpIIHbI He npeD,CTaBJIHeT COOOM npOIJ;eCca,
IIp:YIIJ;ero B O,IJ:HOM HanpaBJIeHIIII. Moamo 6bIJIO 6bI ,IJ:YMaTb, qTO HepaBHOMep-
HOCTb ee HapaCTaHIIH - HBJIeHIIe KalliYIl{eeCH II npOIICTeKaeT npOCTO II3 Ma-
JIOI'D 'IIICJIa Ha6JIIOp:eHIIM II conpOBOllip:alOIl{eM ero CJIY'IallHOCTII BbIOOpKII.
O)];HaKO KOJIII1IeCTBO meHCKIIX qepenOB, HaXO,IJ:HIIJ;IIXCH B HaIDeM pacnopHme-
HIIII, HeMHorIIM MeHbme, qeM KOJIIIqeCTBO MymcKIIx, p:alOIl{IIX 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO
60JIee HCHYIO KapTliHY. cJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, eCJIli eIl{e yqeCTb, 'ITO llepIIO):(bI 3a-
MeTHoro II3MeHeHIIH CKYJIOBOM mIIpIIHbI COBnaAalOT B MymcKoM II sI,eHCKOM
rpynnax, npIIxop:IITCH npII3HaTb IIMelOIIJ;IIeCH ,IJ:aHHbIe He)];OCTaTO'IHbIMII p:JIH
OKOH'IaTeJIbHOrO cym):(eHIIH.
BepXHHH mIIpIIHa JIIII(a B MymcKoM rpynne YBeJIIIqIIBaeTCH B COBpeMen-
nylO snoxy no cpaBHeHIIIO C snOXOM 6pOH3bI IIpIIOJIII3lITeJIbHO Ha 4%, T. e.
npliMepHO Ha CTOJIbKO me, Ha CKOJIbKO YBeJIII'IIIBaeTCH CKYJIOBOll p:IIaMeTp,
B meHCKOM - nOCJIe 3aMeTHoro nOBbImeHIiH B I TbICH'IeJIeTIIII p:o H. S.,
naooopoT, YMeHbmaeTcH, XOTH II He3IIaqIITe:IbHO. XOTH MymcKIIe lIepena 00-
JIee MHor01IIICJIeHHbI, qeM meHCKIIe, pa3HIIIJ;a B KOJIIFIeCTBe HaOJIIOp:eHIIII
B MymcKoM II meHcKoM rpyrrnax He,IJ:OCTaTOqHO BeJIIIKa, LIT06bI OTp:aTb IIpep:-
nOqTeHIIe nor'>a3aHIIHl\I no OAHOMY II3 nOJIOB. TaKIIl\I 06pa30:VI, II SrrOXaJIb-
HbIe BapIIaIJ;IIII BepxHei'r mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a He ,IJ:alOT B03MomHOCTII c):(eJIaTb TBep-
p:bIM BbIBO)]; 0 pacmIIpeHIIII JIIIIJ;a B rr03p:HIIe snOXII no cpaBHeHIIIO C paH-
HIIMII.
HarrpaBJIeHIIe II3MeHqIIBOCTII cpep:Hell mIIpIIHbI JIIII(a nOBTopHeTCH y
MymCKIIX II meHCKliX qepenOB. Pe3Koe YBeJIII1IeHIIe sToro pa3Mepa B cepIIHx
I TbICH1IeJIeTIIfl H. s., nO-BIIp:IIl\IOMY, MomeT CqIITaTbCH peaJIbHbIM <paKToM.
O,IJ:HaKO BO II TbICHqeJIeTlIlI H. s. Cpe,IJ:HHH mIIpIIHa .TrIIIJ;a YMeHbIDaeTcH,
II ee BeJIIIqIIHa JIIImb He3HaqIITeJIbHO rrpeBbImaeT BeJIII1IIIHY SToro pa3l\Iepa
Ha 'Iepenax snOXII 6pOH3bI. cTaTIICTIIqeCKII STII pa3JIlI'IIIH He BbIAepmIIBalOT
KpliTepIIH p:OCTOBepHOCTli. B p:aHHOM CJIyqae :VlbI Ha6:IIO):(aeM, CJIe,IJ:OBaTe:Ib-
HO, IIHyro KapTIIHY, qeM npli paCCMOTpeHIIII npep:blp:YIIJ;IIX pa3MepOB. IIpli rra-
paJIJIeJIII3Me II3MeHqIIBOCTII caMa BeJIII1IIIHa pa3Jrr L IIIM He CBII,IJ:eTeJIbCTByeT
o pacmIIpeHIIII JIIII(a npli npII6JIlimeHIIII R COBpeMeHHOll anoxe.
KaK II3BeCTHO, nOrrepe'IHbIe pa3MepbI JIrrI(a CBH3aHbI ,IJ:OBOJIbHO 60:IbmOM
MOP<P0JIOrIIqeCKOll KOppeJIHIJ;IIeii. KOs<p<pIIIJ;IIenTbI CBH3II npep:CTaBJIeHbI
B Ta6JI. 12 )];JIH P:ByX MOnrOJIOII,IJ:HbIX II Tpex eBpOneOII)];HbIX cepliM. B cepIIHX
apMHH II xaKaCOB OHII BbIqIICJIeHbI no orrYOJIIIKOBaHHbIM IIH,IJ:IIBII):(ya:IbHbIM
)];aHHbIM 32, p:JIH cepIIII xaHTOB IICnOJIb30BaHbI neony6JIliKOBaHHbIe 6JIaHKII
II3l\IepeIIlIM M. r. JIeBliHa 33, BeJIII'IIIHbI CBH3II B ceplIII oceTliH II B cepIIII
erIIrrTHH XXVI-XXX ,IJ:IIHaCTIIM, p:aTIIpYIOIl{eIICH py6ellimI HOBOH SpbI, B3H-
TbI II3 pa60T B. B. BYHaKa 8i II K. llIIpcoHa II A. ,l];eBIIH 35. MbI BII,IJ:IIM,
'ITO Bce KOs<P<PIIIJ;IIeHTbI IIMelOT nOJIOlliIITeJIbHbIM 3HaK II KOJIe6JIIOTCH BOKpyr
BeJIII1rrIHbI 0,5. 8'1'0 CBIIp:eTeJIbCTByeT 0 D:OBOJIbHO 3HaqIITeJIbHOM CBH3II Bcex
pa3MepOB II 0 B3aIIMoonpep:eJIHIOIIJ;eM BJIIIHHIIII IIX ,IJ:pyr Ha p:pyra B rrpoIJ;ec-
ce pOCTa. O,IJ:HaKO MemrpynrroBbIe COOTHomeHIIH Memp:y paCOBbIMII npII3na-
KaMII qaIIJ;e Bcero, KaE: II3BeCTHO, He COBrra,IJ:aIOT C BHYTpIIrpynrroBbDUI,
qTO 6bIJIO OTMeqeHO eIIJ;e B Ha'IaJIe BeKa aHrJIliMCKliMII OIIOMeTpIIKal\UI 36,
287
Ta6JIHD;a 11
ConOCTaBJIeBHe paSBOBpeMeBBI>IX KpaBlIOJIOI'II'leCKHX cepHH ns CaMTaBpCKOrO
MOrHJIbBlIKa no mHpHRe JIHD;a
t XpOHOJIOrI1'IeCHnH nepnop; 143. BepxHflfl [45. CHYJIOB3H /46. Cpep;Hflfl
lliIIpllHa JIIIl\a lliHpliHa lliIIpliHa JIIIl\a
MymcKHe 'Iepena
IIOSAHHH 6pOHsa, 3Tan I (XV-XIV BB. AO H. 3.) I 101,6 (5) 128,0 (2) 90,0(3)
IIOSAHHH 6poHsa, 3Tall II (XIII-XII BB. AO H. 3.) 105,5(4)
IIepexo.IJ; OT 6pOHSbI K meJIesy (XI - IX BB. AO 107,7(9) 130,8 (4) 94,3 (4)
H.3.)
II TbICH'leJIenW AO H.3. (CYMMapHO) 102,0(18) 129,8 (6) 92,4 (7)
IDHpoKoe OCBoeHHe meJIesa (VIII- VI BB. 106,7 (14) 128,3(4) 94,7 (6)
AO H. 3.)
PaHHe3JIJIHHHCTH'leCKOe BpeMH (V-III BB. 102,0(1)
AO H. 3.)
IIOSAHe3JIJIHHHCTH'leCKoe BpeMH (11-1 BB. 104,0(5) 131,7 (3) 91,7 (3)
AO H. 3.)
I TbICH'leJIeTHe AO H.3. (CYMMapHO) 105,8 (20) 129,7 (7) 93,7(9) ,
IIOSAHHH anTH'lHOCTb (I-III BB. H.3.) 102,6 (5) 129,0(1) 94,7 (3)
PaHHee cpeAHeBeKOBbe (IV-IX BB. H. 3.) 108,0 (8) 133,7(3) 100,5 (7)
I TbICH'leJIeTHe H.3. (CYMMapHO) 105,9 (13) 132,5(4) 98,7(10)
PycTaBcKaH cepHH (XVI-XVIII BB. H. 3.) 106,2 (29) 135,4 (27) 93,8 (27)
meHcKHe 'lepena
IIOSAHJlH 6poHsa, 3Tall I (XV-XIV BB. AO H. 3.) 101,4(7) 122,5(4) 90,8 (4)
IIOSAHJIJI 6poHsa, 3Tall II (XIII-XII BB. AO H. 3.) 98,7(3) 121,0(1) 88,5(2)
IIepexoA OT 6pOHSbI K meJIesy (XI-IX BB. AO 103,7(3) 91,0(1)
H.3.)
II TbICH'leJIeTHe AO H.3. (CYMMapHO) 101,3(13) 122,2(5) 90,1 (7)
IDHpoKoe OCBoeHHe meJIesa (VIII- VI BB. 105,3 (4) 125,0(2) 91,0 (2)
AO H. 3.)
PaHHe3JIJIHHHCTH'leCKOe BpeMJI (V - III BB.
AO H. 3.)
IIOSAHe3JIJIHHHcTH'lecKoe BpeMJI (11-1 BB. 101,6 (5) 124,0 (2) 91,0 (3)
AO H.3.)
I TbICH'leJIeTHe AO H.3. (CYMMapHO) 103,2(9) 124,5 (4) 91,0(5)
IIOSAHJIJI aHTH'lHOCTb (I-III BB. H.3.) 101,0(5) 122,3 (3) 91,0(5)
PaHHee cpeAHeBeKoBbe (IV-IX BB. H. 3.) 103,5(4) 125,0(1) 96.3 (3)
I TbICH'leJIeTHe H. 3. (CYMMapHO) 102,1 (9) 123,0(4) 93,0 (8)
PycTaBcKaH cepHH (XVI-XVIII BB. H. 3.) 100,7(23) 124,9 (21) 90,5 (22)
a 3aTeM nop:TBepllip:eHo na OCHOBaIUIII IICCJIe)];OBaHIIH ,IJ:06pOKa IecTBeHHoro II
l\UIOrO IIICJIeHHOrO MaTepIIaJIa E. M. qenypKOBCKIIM 37 II A. H. Hpxo 3;.
MomeT 6bITb, OTCYTCTBIIe IIapaJIJIeJIII3Ma B SnOXaJIbHbIX II3MeHeHIIHX Bcex
Tpex )];IIaMeTpOB mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a Ha TeppiiTopIIII rpY3IIII 06'bHCHHeTCH IIX
IIHbIM no cpaBHeHIIIO C BHYTpIIrpynnoBbIM MemrpynnoBbIM COOTHOmeHIIe)('
ECJIII STO p:ellCTBIITeJIbHO TaK, nenpaBOMepHbIM npep:CTaBJIHeTCH npop:eJIaHHOe
HaMIl cOBoKynHoe paCCMOTpeHIIe STIIX npII3HaKOB.
jI,JIH BbIHcneHIIH COOTHomeHIIH l\Iea>:,IJ:y BHYTpIIrpynnoBoM II MellirpynIIo-
1'!OM II3MeHQIIBOCTblO nOnepeQHbIX p:IIaMeTpOB JIIIIJ;a OblJIII BbI'IIICJIeHbI paHro-
BbIe KOS<P<PIIIJ;IIeHTbI MemrpYllnOBOM CBH3II Mem,IJ:y HIIMII (Ta6JI. 13). ITo-
CKOJIbKY p:IIHaMIIKa paco06pa30BaTeJIbHOrO npoIJ;eCca, KOTOPYIO KaK pa3 II
BbIpamaeT MellirpynnoBoe conOCTaBJIeHIIe, IIMeeT CBOIO Cnel{II<pIIKY Ha paa-
288
Ta6JIlqa 12
Koa4J4>uqlleHTI>I BHYTpllrpynnoBoii IwppemIqmI nOnepeqHbIX pa3MepoB ;'lHqa.
MymcKHe 'lepena
CepI1H
CRy.:lOBaH IIII1pl1-
Ha - BepXHHH 1II11-
pI1Ha JllIJ:ja
CRYJIOBaH IIIl1pl1Ha-
Cpe)I.HHJI IIIl1pl1Ha
JlI1l\a
BepXHHH IIIHpl1Ha
JIHl\a - CpeiJ,HHH
IIIl1pl1Ha JIIUja
.
XaKaCbI
XaHTbI
ApMHHe
OCeTIIHbI
EnWTHHe XXVI - XXX AH-
HacTHH
0,667:1:0,042
0,741:1:0,051
0,491:tO,077
0,598:1:0,049
0,601:1:0,077
0,587 :1:0,072
0,462:1:0,109 *
0,397:1:0,020
0,592:1:0,049
0,568:1:0,074
, B Ta6JII1l\e B. B. BYHaRa ROJII1'leCTBO Ha6mo,JJ;eHI1H no OTileJIbHbIM Roa!jJ!jJI1l\HeHTaM ROJle6J1eTCH
OT 52 ,JJ;O 70. npH BbI'lHCJleHHH OIII116RH I1CnOJIbaOBaHa HaHMeHbIllaH BeJlH'lI1Hao
Ta6JHqa 13
Koa4J4>HqneHTI>I MemrpynnoBoii KOppeJHqJIIl nOnepeqHbIX pa3MepoB Haqa
Mymcillie qepena
CRYJlOBaH IllHpHHa- CRYJIOBan Illl1pHHa - BepXHHH IImpHHa JlH-
TeppHTopl1H BepXHHH llI11pHHa JlI1l\a cpeiJ,HHH Illl1pHHa JlI1u;a l\a - cpeiJ,HHH IllHpl1Ha
JlI1l\a
RaBKa3 0,055(11) 0,743(11) 0,261 (11)
Cn6I1pb 0,639(31) 0,553(31) 0,556 (31)
EBporra 0,908 (13) 0,717(33) 0,626(13)
:III'IHbIX TeppliTOpIIHX, BbI IIICJIeHlIe KOS<P<PIIIJ;IIeHTOB ObIJIO npOII3Bep,eHO 0'1'-
.J;eJILHO )];JIH STHIIqeCKlIX rpynn cIIOIIPII, EBponbI II KaBKa3a. B Ka IeCTBe
::IIaTepIIaJIa ):(JIH BbIqIICJIeHIIH IICnOJIb30BaHbI KpanIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p:aHHbIe,
ony6JIIIKOBaHHbIe IIO HapO,IJ:aM cII6IIpII r. cD. ,l];e6eIJ;OM 39, H. C. P030-
BbIM 40 II aBTopOM 4\ no Hapop:aM EBponbI ,l];. MopaHTOM 4\ B. MaK,IJ:OHeJI-
:IOM 43, B. XYK 4\ M. HHrOM 4", K. cKpaMHepOM 46, 11. J:R'IIJIHHCKaCOM II
A. IOprYTIICOM 4\ M. C. AKIIMOBOM 48 II K. ID. MapK 49, no Hapo):(aM KaB-
l;a3a B. B. BYHaKOM 50, M. r. A6p,YIIIeJIIImBIIJIII 5\ K. X. BeCJIeKOeBOM 5\
P. M. KaCIIMOBOM 53 II aBTopOM 54. ITpII BbI IIICJIeHIIII KOS<P<PIIIJ;IIeHTOB Melli-
rpynrroBoM KOppeJIHIJ;IIII ,IJ:JIH Hapop:OB cII6IIpII IICnOJIb30BaHbI TaKme ,IJ:aHHbIe
H. H. J\IIIKJIameBCKOM 0 KIIprII3ax 55 II )J,aIIIIbIe B. B. rIIH36ypra II H. r. 3aJI-
!mH)]; 0 Ka3axax 56, p:JIH HapO):(OB EBponbI H KaBKa3a - neonyGJIIIKOBaHHbIe
D;aHHbIe aBTopa 0 BOCTOqHbIX JIaTbIIIIax, PYCCKIIX II YKpaIIHIJ;ax. MaTepIIaJIbI
pa3JIII IHbIX IICCJIe,IJ:OBaTeJIelI no O,IJ:HIIM lITeM me HapO,IJ:aM CYMMIIpOBaHbI.
1'I3-3a OTCYTCTBIIH p:aHHbIX 0 BepXHeM II Cpe,IJ:HeM mIIpIIHe JIIII(a B GOJIbmIIH-
CTBe cepIIii no HapO)];aM cII6IIpII IICnOJIb30BaHbI BeJIIFHIHbI 6IlOp6IITaJIbHOI'O
II 3IIrOMaKCIIJIJIHpHOrO p:IIaMeTpOB. OTCYTCTBIIeM )];aHHbIX 0 BapIIaIJ;IIHX cpep:-
HeM mlIpHHbI JIIIIJ;a B MaTepIIaJIaX no HapO,IJ:aM 3ana)];HOM EBponbI 06'bHCHH-
eTCH II pa3Hoe KOJIII IeCTBO cepIIM, no KOTOpbIM BbI'IIICJIeHbI OT)];eJIbHbIe
K03<p<pIIuueHTbI KOppeJIHI(IIII ,IJ:JIH eBponeMCKIIX Hapop:OB.
PaCCl\IOTpmme npIIBe,IJ:eHHbIX K03<p<pIII(IIeHTOB paHrOBOM KOppeJIHI(IIII no-
:Ka3bIBaeT, 'ITO MemrpynnoBoe COOTHomeHIIe MelliAY nonepe IHbIMII )];IIaMeT-
paMII JIIIIJ;a coxpaHHeT nOJIOmIITeJIbHbIM 3HaK. BeJIIIqIIHbI KOS<p<PIIIJ;IIeHTOB,
10 B. n. AJIeRCeeB
289
Ill>IqIICJIeHHbIe no CIIOCOOY paHrOB, He BlIOJIHe conOCTaBIIMbI C BHYTpnrpyn-
nOBbIMII. Bce llie MOlliHO YTBeplli,IJ:aTb, "1'1'0 CTeneHb TeCHOTbI CBH3II npII
MemrpynnoBoM conOCTaBJIeHIIII MaJIO II3MeHIIJIaCb no cpaBIIeHIIIO C BHYTpn-
rpynnoBbIM. 8'1'0 03Ha'IaeT, 'ITO pa3HIIIJ;a MelliP:Y rpYllnaMII no Bce l llpII3IIa-
KaM, onpep:eJIHIOIl{IIM mIIpIIHY JIIIIJ;a, He HBJIHeTCH CJIe,IJ:CTBIIeM pacooopa30-
BaTeJIbHOrO npOIJ;ecca, a OTpalliaeT JIIImb MOP<pOJIOrII"IeCKYIO 3aBIICIIl\lOCTb
MelliP:Y llpII3HaKaMII. caMII no ceGe op:HOIIMeHHbIe MeffirpynTIOBbIe K03<P<PII-
IJ;IIeHTbI BapbIIpYIOT p:OBOJIbHO 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO. Ho, nO-BII,IJ,IIl\iOMY, ,IJ:JIH HIIX xa-
paKTepHa GOJIbmaH omIIGKa, II, KpOMe TOro, pa3HIIIJ;a l\IeiR,IJ:Y IIIIMII He oGHa-
pYlliIIBaeT onpe,IJ:eJIeHHOM HallpaBJIeHHOCTIf: CKYJIOBaH mIIpIIHa C BepXHeM
mIIpIIHOll II nOCJIe,IJ:HHH co Cpe,IJ:Hell mIIpIIHOll HaIIMeHee TeCHO CBH3aHbI Ha
KaBKa3e, HO BeJIII"IIIHa CBH3II CKYJIOBOM mIIpIIHbI co Cpe,IJ:HeM Ha KaBKa3e
HaIIGOJlbmaH. TaKIIM oGpa30M, HaXO,IJ:HIl{IIeCH B HameM pacnopHllieHIIII ;::!;all-
HbIe CBII,IJ:eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 nO'ITII nOJIHOM napaJI.TIeJIII3Me MellirpYllnOBOII II
BHYTpIIrpYlInOBOM II3MeHqIIBOCTII mIIpOTHbIX pa3MepOB JIIIIJ;a. OTCYTCTBIIe
napaJIJIeJIII3Ma B SnOXaJIbHOM II3MeHeHIIII IIX Ha TeppIITopIIII rpY3IIII lIe CBO-
p:IITCH, CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO, K BJIIIHHIIIO KaKIIX-TO paco06pa30BaTeJIbHbIX rrpOIJ;ec-
COB. ITO-BII,IJ:IIMOMY, ero CJIep:yeT paCCMaTpIIBaTb KaK aprYl\IeHT npOTIIB rIIno-
Te3bI 0 npHMOJIIIHeMHOM II3MeHeHIIII mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a BO BpeMeHII Y ,IJ:peBHero
HaCeJIeHIIH rpY3IIII.
,l];Pyroll cnocoG OIJ;eHKII 3aKOHOMepHOCTeM II3l\IeHeHIIH mIIpIIHbI JIlIlJ;a BO
BpeMeHII Ha TeppIITopIIII rpY3IIII 3aKJIIO'IaeTCH B CpaBIIeHIIII IIX C TeMnaMII
II3MeH'IIIBOCTII onpep:eJIHIOIIJ;IIX ITIIIPIIHY JIIIIJ;a npII3HaKOB Ha ,IJ:PyrIIx TeppII-
TOpIIHX. C STOM IJ;eJIblO IJ;eJIeC006pa3HO IICnOJIb30BaTb MaTepIIaJI, npn nOMO-
IIJ;II KOToporo r. <1>. ,l];eGeIJ; rJIaBHbIM 06pa30M II 060CHOBaJI CBOIO KOHIJ;enIJ;IIIO
SnOXaJIbHOrO CYllieHIIH JIIIIJ;a, - naJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrII'IeCKIIe cepIIII C TeppIITO-
pIIII AJITae-caHHCKoro HaropbH II HIIlliHero ITOBOJIllibH 57. AJITae-caHHCKoe
Haropbe MomeT ObITb npep:CTaBJIeHO P:BYMH cepIIHMII paHHeiI GpOH3bI II paH-
Hero llieJIe3a - a<paHaCbeBCKOM II TarapCKOM 58; HIImIIee IToBOJIllibe - TaKllie
P:BYMH cepIIHMn paHHeM n ll03,IJ,HeM 6p01I3bI. IToCJIep:HIIe COCTaBIIJIIICb 1I3
MaTepIIaJIOB M. M. repaCIIMOBOM 59, B. B. rIIH36ypra 60, H. IV1. rJIa3KO-
BOM II B. IT. "£lTeIJ;OBa 6\ r. <1>. ,l];e6eIJ;a 62 II Heony6JIIIKOBaHHbIX p:aHHbIX
B. B. <1>IIpmTeMH 63 (Ta6JI. 14). MaTeplIaJI KOJIlI'IeCTBeHHO 3Ha'IIITe:IbHO npe-
BbImaeT TOT, KOTOpbIM GbIJI B paCllopHmeHlIlI r. <1>. ,l];e6eIJ;a, HeCpaBHIIl\I
OH B STOM OTHOITIeHIIlI II C MaTepIIaJIaMlI no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII rpY31III,
1I nOSTOMY Bce C,IJ,eJIalIHbIe llPII ero paCCMOTpeHIIII 3aKJIIO'IeHIIH MorYT CqII-
TaTbCH oGcToHTe:IblIO aprYMeHTIIpOBaHHbIl\III. ,l];JIH HarJIHp:HOCTII pe3YJIbTaTbI
COIIOCTaBJIeHIIH npe,IJ:CTaBJIeHbI TaKme rpa<pII'IeCKlI (pIIC. 26 II 27). TaK iRe
KaK II ,IJ:JIH TeppIITopIIII rpY3IIlI, rpa<pIIKII nOCTpoeHbI He no aOCOJllOTHbIM
pa3MepaM, a Ha OCHOBaHIIII npOIJ;eHTHOro COOTHomeHIIH BeJIII'IIIH, nOCJIYlliIIB-
mIIX p:JIH COllOCTaBJIeHIIH CepIIM. 3a 100% llplIHHTbI BeJIII'IIIHbI cepIIE II3 MO-
rIIJILHIIKOB a<paHacbeBcKoM II HMHOM KYJIbTYp.
YMeHbmeIIIIe nOnepe'IHbIX pa3MepOB JIIIIJ;a Y MYlliCKIIX 'IepenOB Tarap-
CKOM snOXII no cpaBHeHIIIO C a<paHacbeBcKoM ceplIeM BbIpameHO qpe3BbI'IaM-
HO OT'IeTJIIIBO. IToCJIe,IJ:OBaTeJIbHOCTb YMeHbmelIIIH llPII nepeXO,IJ:e 0'1' GOJIee
paHHIIX SIIOX K GOJIee n03,IJ:HIIM CBIIp:eTeJIbCTByeT B nO b3Y npHMOJIIIHellHOro
II paBHOMepHoro npOIJ;eCca rpaIJ;IIJIII3aIJ;IIII. E,IJ,IIHcTBeHHbIM IICKJIIO'IeHIIel\I HB-
JIHeTCH YBeJIII'IeHIIe BepxHeM mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a B MymcKoM cepIIII TpeTbeM CTa-
p:IIII TarapcKoM snOXII no cpaBHeHlIlO C npe,IJ:bI,IJ:ymeM. O,IJ:HaRo pa3HIIIJ;a HII'I-
TomHa, II D,ame IIPII GOJIbmOM 'IIICJIeHHOCTII cepIIM BTOpOM II TpeTbei'r cTap:IIM
Tarapa elO MOlliHO npeHeGpe'Ib.
AHaJIOrII'IHI>IM 06pa30M IT3MeHHlOTCH pa3MepbI II Y llieHCKIIX qepelIOB.
HCKJIIO'IeHIIe COCTaBJIHIOT qepena TpeTbeM CTap:IIII, Y KOTOpbIX Bce TPII 1l0-
290
Ta6JI1n a 14
CorrOCTaBJIeHlIe pa3HOBpe IeHHhIX KpaHlIOJIOI'II"IeCKlIX ceplIii C TeppliToplIlI
AJITae-CaHHcKom HamphH II Hlmmem IIoBOJDI{hH no wlIplIHe ::I1Iqa
XpOHOnOrnqeCRnH nepnoA 143. BepxHHH IIIn-1 45. CRynoBan /46. CpeAHHn IIIn-
pnHa nnn;a IIIHpnHa pnHa nnn;a
MymcKlIe "Iepena
AcpaHaCheBCRaH RYJIhTypa 110,2(14) 140,3(13) 99,3(12)
Tal'apCKaH RYJIhTypa, STarr I 109,3(102) 138,1 (99) 97,5(89)
» » STan II 109,1 (63) 138,0(62) 97,1 (43)
» » STan III 109,2 (27) 134,7 (19) 96,6(21)
HMlIaH RYJIhTypa 110,2 (9) 14Q,2 (16) 96,9(11)
CpyoHaH KYJIhTypa 108,5(46) 135,5 (51) 96,2(40)
iKeHcKlIe "Iepena
AcpanaCheBCRaH KYJIhTypa 106,8 (12) 132,2 (13) 95,2 (6)
Tal'apCRaH KYJILTypa, STan I 106,4 (69) 129,6 (60) 93,4(62)
» » STan II 104,3(44) 128,6 (44) 92,2 (38)
» » STan III 104,5(11) 130,3 (12) 94,4 ( 11)
HMnaH KYJILTypa 106,5 (2) 126,7(3) 91,0(3)
CpyonaH KYJIbTypa 103,1 (26) 125,6(31) 91,7 (26)
llepe'IHbIX p:IIaMeTpa JIIIIJ;a 60JIbme, 'IeM B cepIIII BTOpOM cTap:IIII. OcooeHHo
3aMeTHbI pa3JIII'IIIH no CKYJIOBOll II cpep:HeM BbICOTe JIIIIJ;a. BecbMa BepoHTHo,
'ITO OHII IIMelOT CJIY'IaMHbIM xapaKTep II npoIIcTeKalOT IICK.'IlOqIITeJIbHO II3-3a
MaJIOrO KOJIII'IeCTBa qepenOB TpeTbell cTap:IIII. HeJIb3H, npaBp:a, 3aGbIBaTb II 0
B03MOlliHOCTII IIHOrO OO'bHCHeHIIH: KaK pa3 K 3TOMY BpeMeHII OTHOCIITCH YBe-
JIII'IeHIIe yp:eJIbHOrO Beca MOHrOJIOIIp:HOll IIpIIMecH B HaCeJIeHIIII TarapcKoM
KYJIbTypbI, KOTopaH B CIIJIY KaKIIx-To, cKopee Bcero CJIY'IaMHbIX, npII'IIIH no-
BeJIa K YBeJIII'IeIIIIIO mIIpoTHbIX pa3MepoB JIIIIJ;a IIMeHHO B llieHcKoll cepIIII.
B oGIl{eM II B TOM II B P:PyroM CJIY'Iae p:aHHbIe 06 II3MeH'IIIBOCTII mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a
Y MYlliCKIIX rpynlI, OCHOBaHHbIe Ha 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO GOJIee MHOrO'IIICJIeIIHOM Ma-
TepIIaJIe, OqeBIID,HO, GOJIee npe,IJ:CTaBIITeJIbHbI II p:alOT OCHOBaIlIIe cp:eJIaTb BbI-
BOp: 0 3aKOHOMepHOM xapaKTepe 31I0XaJIbHOrO II3MeHeHIIH mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a y
,IJ:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH MIIHYCIIHCKOM KOT.JIOBIIHbI. ITPHMOJIIIHeMHOCTb II paBHO-
MepHOCTb SToro npOIJ;eCca BbIpallieHbI ropa3p:0 60JIee 'IeTKO, <reM Ha TeppIITO-
plIII rpY3IIII.
IT pII paCCMOTpeHIIII SnOXaJIbHOM p:IIHaMIIKII npll3HaKOB Y ,IJ:peBHero Hace-
JIeHIIH HIImHero ITOBOJIllibH CJIep;yeT IIMeTb B BII,IJ:Y, 'ITO p:JIH CYlliD,eHlIH 0 HeM
B HameM pacnopHllieHIIII Haxo,IJ:HTCH TOJIbKO )];Be cepIIII. TeM He MeHee pe-
3YJIbTaTbI conOCTaBJIeHIIH p:OCTaTOqHO onpep:BJIeHHbIe. B rpYlIne MYlliCKIIX
qepenOB YMeHbmeHIIe aGcOJIIOTHOM BeJIII'IIIHbI xapaKTepHO p:JIH Bcex Tpex AIIa-
MeTpOB mnpIIHbI JIIII(a B snoxy CPy6HOM KYJIbrypbI no cpaBHeHIIIO C HMHOM.
B llieHCKOM rpynne Ha6JIIOp:aeTCH yneJIII'IeHIIe cpepJ'l'eM mIIpIIHbI JIIII(a Y qe-
pelIOB CPy6HOM SIIOXlI. Op:IfaKO llieHCKaH cepIIH 'IepelIOB HMHOM KYJIbTYPbI
Bo06Il{e COCTOIIT II3 eD,IIHII'IHbIX SK3eMnJIHpOB, II nOSTOMY Bce pe3YJIbTaTbI CO-
nOCTaBJIeHIIH llieHCKHx cepIIM BPH,IJ: JIII MorYT C'IIITaTbCH ocoGeHHo y6ep:IITeJIb-
HbUIII. Bce llie HeJIb3H He OTMeTIITb, 'ITO CKYJIOBOM ):(IIaMeTp II BepXHHH
mlIpIIHa JIlIlJ;a Y llieHCKIIX 'IepelIOB CPy6HOM snOXII MeHbme, <reM Y llieHCKIIX
qepellOB HMHOM KYJII,rypbI, II '1'1'0 pa3JIII'IIIe 1I0 BepXHeM mIIpIIHe JIIIIJ;a MelliP:Y
HIIMII D,OBOJIbHO 3Ha'IIITeJIbHoe. TaKIIM 06pa30M, II Ha TeppIITopIIII HIIlliHBro
IToBOJImbH 3aKOHOMepHOCTb SnOXaJIbHOrO II3MeHeHIIH nOnepe'IHbIX )];IIaMeTpOB
291
10*
I
c/ t- Poco 26. Bpel\IeHHbIe 03-
MeHeHOJI IDnpIIH:bI JHI e-
lllll BOl'O CIWJIeTa Ha TepplI-
----, I TOplI1I MIIHYCIIHCROii: ROT-
!If! '....., \. JIOBIIH:bI B 3IIOXY OpOH3:bI II
, \ paHHel'O JRCJIeaa
!II!
!ll 'V
!lb
JIlIlIl ZIlIlIl !Il/J/J /J J./J1l1l 2/J/J/J I/J/J/J . /J
0'" ¥ .- POCo 27. BpeMeHHbIe 1I3-
---
I/J/J MeHeHOJI IDOpnH:bI mm;e-
I !III BOl'O CReJIeTa Ha Teppo-
" TOpOII HOJRHel'O IIo-
" BOJIJR:bJI B 3IIOXy OpOH3h1
1111 "-
"-
jJ "-
"-
lib
J/J/J/J 2/J/J/J !/J/J/J J /J1l1l 2/J/J/J !/J/J/J
JIIIIJ;a BbIpameHa 'IeTqe, <reM y p:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH, OCTaBIIBmero caMTaBp-
CKIIH MOrIIJIbHIIK. cJIe)];OBaTeJIbHO, <paKTbI, Ha KOTOpbIX OCHOBbIBaeTCH rrpep:-
CTaBJIeHIIe 0 pacmIIpeHIIII JIIII(a B GOJIee 1I03,IJ:HIIe SIIOXII rro cpaBHeHIIIO C
paHHIIMII Ha TeppIITopIIII rpY3IIII, MeHee ,IJ:eMOHCTpaTIIBHbI, <reM aprYMeHTbI
B rrOJIb3Y rIIlIOTe3bI rpaIJ;IIJIII3aIJ;IIII JIIIIJ;eBOrO CKeJIeTa Y p:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH
AJITae-caHHCKoro HaropbH II HIIlliHero ITOBOJIllibH. ITOJIaralO, qTO STO IIpe,IJ:-
CTaBJIeHIIe HYm,IJ:aeTCH B ClleIJ;IIaJIbHOM p:onOJIHIITeJIbHOM 060CHOBaHIIlI.
WARThI, ROTOPbIE CJIE):(YET yqBTbIBATb
llPB OBCYjKJ:(EHBB rBIIOTE3bI r. W. ):(EBED;A
Pa3BIIBaeMbIe r. <P. )1eGeIJ;OM B3rJIHp:bI 0 HallpaBJIeHIIII II TeMnax SrrOXaJIbHO-
ro II3MeHeHIIH IIpII3HaKOB He IICKJIlOqaIOT, KaK II3BeCTHO, IIpe,IJ:CTaBJIeHIIH 0
pa3HbIX <popMax SToro IIpOIJ;eCCa Ha pa3JIII'IHbIX TeppIITopIIHX II B pa3JIII'IHbIX
:t)THII'IeCKIIX rpyrrrrax 6". TaK, r. <P. ,l];eGeIJ;, OrpaHIIqIIBaHCb JIIImb TeppIITO-
pIIeM cOBeTCKoro cOlO3a, YKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO npOIJ;eCC GpaXIIKe<paJIII3aIJ;IIII IIH-
TeHCIIBHO ,IJ:eMCTBOBaJI B norrYJIHIJ;IIHX, OTHOCHIl{IIXCH K IOmHOll BeTBII eBpo-
lIeOII,IJ:HOll II MOHrOJIOIIp:HOM pac. B TO llie BpeMH rro IIpII3HaKal\I, xapaKTe-
PII3YIOIIJ;IIM MaCCIIBHOCTb 'IepelIa, p:peBHIIe rrpe,IJ:CTaBIITeJIII MOHrOJIOII)J;HOll
paCbI II IOlliHOM BeTBII eBpOlleOII,IJ:HOM He OTJIII'IaIOTCH 0'1' COBpeMeHHbIX. TJIIm-
HIIM pa3 CBlIAeTeJIbCTBYH 0 He3aBIICIIMOM Te'IeHIIII IIpOIJ;eCCOB GpaXIme<paJIII-
3aIJ;IIII II rpaI(IIJIII3aIJ;IIII, 'ITO GbIJIO rrOKa3aHO TaKme Ha OCHOBaHIIII aHaJIII3a
MellirpynrroBbIx KOppeJIHIJ;IIM 65, STII ,IJ:aHHbIe rOBopHT 0 TOl\'[, 'ITO YMeHbmeHIIe
MaCCIIBHOCTII qepella, II B 'IaCTHOCTII mIIpUHbI JIIIIJ;a, IIPH rrpII6JIIIllieHHII K
COBpeMeHIIOM Siioxe He MomeT C'IIITaTbCH CKOJIbKO-HII6YP:b 06IIJ;eM TeHp:eH-
IJ;IIeM, xapaKrepHOM )];JIH qeJIOBeKa COBpel\IeHHOrO BIIp:a. qTOGbI He 6bITb rOJIO-
CJIOBHbIM, nplIBe):(y ,IJ:Ba IIpIIl\Iepa, BbIXOAHIIJ;IIe 3a IIpep:eJIbI cOBeTCKoro cOlO3a.
Op:IIH II3 HIIX OTHOCIITCH K SnOXaJIbHOM ):(IIHaMIIKe rrpII3HaKOB Ha TeppIITopIIII
GeBepHoro I-\IITaH, p:pyroM - K aHaJIOrIIqHOMY HBJIeUIIIO Ha TeppUTopIIII ErIIII-
Ta II Hy6IIII. Peqb lloi'r,IJ:eT TOJIbKO 0 cneIJ;IIaJIbHO IIHTepeCYIOIl{e:u Hac npII3Ha-
Ke - mIIpIIHe JIIIIJ;a.
292
d"
IDI
IDI
IDD
Sf
S6
S7
JUUD
,
-- ---
................... --""""'--.........
.....-------- ----.
-- ---
-,--
1-
-----
ZDDD
IDDD
D
IDDD
IDDD . lDDD
IDDD
D
IDDD
ZDDD
PIIC. 28. BpeMeBHliIe 1I3MeBeHIIH illIIpIIHbI JIlII\eBoro CReJIeTa Ha TeppuTopUU CeBepHoro
HUT all
,l];JIH conOCTaBJIeHHH c KpaHHOJIOrIIqeCKIIMII MaTepIIaJIaMII no COBpeMeH-
HbIM KIITaMIJ;aM B IJ;eJIHX BbIHCneHIIH SIlOXaJIbIIOH )];IIHaMIIKII aHTpOIIOJIOrH'Ie-
CKIIX npII3HaKOB Ha TeppIITOpIIIJ ceBepHoro HIITaH npIIrO,IJ:HbI )];OBOJIbHO 06-
mIIpHbIe naJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrII'IeCKIIe ceplIH II3 1I0rpeGeHIIM snOXH HeOJIIITa n
6pOH3bI, pacKonaHHbIx If. AH,IJ:epCCOHoM B npOBIIHIJ;IIII raHbcy B 1921-
1924 rr. 66 OHII 6bIJIH onyGJIIIKOBaHbI ,l];. BJISKOM 67. K COmaJIeHIIIO, ):(aTIIpOB-
Ka MHorIIX II3 paCKOllaHHbIX 1I0rpeGeHlIM He 6bIJIa p:OCTaTO'IHO OT'IeTJIIIBOM,
IIO'IeMY ,l];. EJISK ony6JIIIKOBaJI ,IJ:aHHbIe oTp:eJIbHO no qepellaM SIIOXII HeOJIIITa
II no cYMMaPHoM cepIlII SIIOXII HeOJIIITa II 6POH3bI 68 . IIO-BII,IJ:IIMOMY, npII'III-
HOM SToro HBIIJIOCb II HeGOJILITIOe KOJIIl'IeCTBO XOpOITIO COXpaHIIBITIIIXCH 'Iepe-
nOB snOXH 6pOH3bI, IlMeBmIIX JIIIIJ;eBOM CKeJIeT. cBO,IJ:KY nO'ITII Bcex KpaHIIO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB no COBpeMeHHbIM KIITafuJ;aM npOII3BeJI H. H. e-
GOKcapOB 69. B 'IaCTHOCTII, IlM llie CYMMIIpOBaHbI ,IJ:aHHbIe no KpaHIlOJIOrIIII
ceBepHbIX RIITaMIJ;eB Ha BceM TeppIITopIlII IlX pacnpOCTpaneHHH 0'1' 3anaD,HOrO
KIITaH ,IJ:O MaHL'IlliYPIIII. OAHaKO MbI B IJ;eJIHX GOJIee CTpororo oTGopa IaTe-
pIIaJIa II ,IJ:OCTlImeHIlH 60JIbmeM conOCTaBIIMOCTII ,IJ:aHHbIX no )J,peBHe,IIY II CO-
BpeMeHHOMY naCeJIeHIIIO BOCnOJIb3yeMcH KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII cepIIHMII TOJIb-
KO C TeppIlTopIIIl coGcTBeHHO ceBepHoro KIITaH. 8'1'0 MaTepIlaJIbI, Ony6JIIIKO-
BaHHbIe n. HoraHeII 70, K. XaGepepoM 7\ M. PaMx'epOM 72, A. llIYJIbI(OM 73,
K. HaKaHO 74, ,l];. EJISKOM 75 II H. H. qeGoI{CapOBbIM 76. 3a IlCKJIIO'IeHIIeM
p:aHHbIX H. H. eGoKcapoBa, Bce OHII <PIIrypIIpyroT B CBO)];HOM paGoTe r. IIIII-
MbI 77 . HeCKOJIbKO qepellOB, OITIICaHHbIX A. KaTp<pameM II E. AMII 78, He BKJIIO-
'IeHO B nop:CqeTbI II3-3a HeHCHoro npOIlcxomp:eHIIH.
,l];OIIOJIHIITeJIblIaH TPyp:HOCTb conOCTaBJIeHIIH ):(aHHbIX no KpaHIIOJIOrIIII CO-
BpeMeHHoro II p;peBHero naCeJIeHIIH ceBepHoro KIITaH 3aKJIIO'IaeTCH B TOM,
'ITO B ,IJ:aHHbIX ,l];. EJISKa, OTHOCHIIJ;IIXCH KaK K naCeJIeHUIO snOXII HeOJIUTa U
OpOH3bI, TaK II K cOBpeMeHHbIM KIITaMIJ;aM, OTCYTcTByeT xapaKTeplIcTIlKa
BepxHeM mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a. Bl\IeCTO Hee npIIBe,IJ:eHbI BeJIII'IIIHbI GIIop6IITaJILHOll
mIIpIIHbI. C IJ;eJILIO nOJIY'IIITb oGbI'IHOe COOTIIomeHlIe Melli,IJ:Y P;BYMH STIIMU
neJIIIqIIHaMII II BbI'IIICJIIITb BepxHlO1O mllpIIHY JIIIIJ;a IIPII nOMOIl{H lIMelOIl{eII-
CH GIIop6IITaJIbHOM mHpIIHbI B cepIIHx, B KOTOpbIX ,IJ:aHIIbIe 1I0 HeM OTCYT-
CTBYIOT, BbIqIlCJIeHbl pa3HIIIJ;bI Melli)"IY BepXHeM II OIIOpOIITaJIbHOM mIIpIIHOM B
24 COBpeMeHHbIX lIJIII GJIII3KIIX K COBpeMeHHOCTII KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX cepII-
HX 79 (TaGJI. 15). K COlliaJIeHIIIO, HellOJIHOTa KpaHIlOJIOrII'IeCKIIX nporpaMM II
OTCYTCTBIIe B HIIX 8TIIX pa3MepOB npIIBeJIII K pe3KoM BbI60pO'IHOCTII MaTe-
pIIaJIa - nOqTIl Bce IlCIIOJIb30BaHHbIe HaMII cepIIII OTHOCHTCH K eBponeOIIp:HOMY
II MOHrOJIOIIp:HOMY paCOBbIM CTBOJIaM. Ep:IIHcTBeHHoe lICKJIIO'IeHIIe COCTaBJIH-
10'1' aBCTpaJIIIMIJ;bI, 0 KOTOpbIX, KCTaTlI rOBopH, lIMelOTCH p:aHHbIe JIIImb no
MYlliCKOMY nOJIY. XapaKTepHaH )];JIH HIIX pa3HIlIJ;a HBJIHeTCH MaKCIIMaJIbHOM,
Op;HaRo Ha 3TOM OCHOBaHIIII He CJIep;yeT )];YMaTb, 'ITO BKJIIO'IeHIIe B nO,IJ:cqe'l
293
Ta6JIu a 15
CooTHomeHue Mem y BepxHeii H 6nop6uTam,Hoii mupuHoii JIlIJ::t;a B paaJIH'l1Th1X
KpaHUOJIOI'U"IeCKUX cepuJIx
rpynna
MymcRne 'Iepena
3. BepXHrrH I 3 (1). Bnop- I
IIInpIIH8 -m1(a 6UTa.:rbHarr Pa3HU1(a
. IIIupnHa
meHCRue 'Iepena
3 Bepx- I 3(1). Bu- \
. op6nTarrb-
HRR IIIH- HaR IIIHpH- Pa3HH1(a
pHHa JIH1(3 Ha
RO'leBHIIKll 3a6aft- 107,0(37) 99,3(38) 7,7 102,9 (20) 95,0(21) 7,9
RaJIbJI IX-XIII BB.
Ra'lIlHIt;bI 107,4(47) 99,6(45) 7,8 101,6 (57) 94,9 (57) 6,7
CaraftIt;bI 105,6 (31) 98,4(31) 7,2 102,4 (34) 95,2 (34) 7,2
Roft6aJIbI 107,3 (26) 100,2 (25) 7,1 102,4 (21) 95,1 (21) 7,,3
EeJIbTblpbI 105,5(46) 99,1 (46) 6,4 101,9 (36) 95,7 (36) 6,2
IIIOPIt;bI 103,7 (32) 96,5 (32) 7,2 101,5 (26) 94,3 (26) 7,2
CeJIbRynbI 108,6(45) 99,5(43) 9.1 102,1(23) 94,7 (20) 7,4
"LIYJIbIMCKlIe TaTapbI 105,5(45) - 97,4 (37) 8,1 101,9 (29) 95,8 (29) 6,1
RIIp rIl3bI 107,8(43) 99,6(43) 8,2 103,1 (43) 94,4 (43) 8,7
BOCTO'lHble JIaTbIIDll 106,2(46) 99,4(46) 6,8 100,4(45) 94,1(45) 6,3
<DHHHbI 106,7 (71) 98,9 (71) 7,8 100,9 (22) 93,5(22) 7,4
"YRpa.IIHIt;bI 106,2(102) 99,5(101) 6,7 102,0(35) 96,0 (33) 6,0
tIe'leHIt;bI 106,7 (10) 100,1 (10) 6,6 100,2 (13) 94,7 (13) 5,5
IIHrymll 107,4(48) 99,,7 (44) 7,7 100,6(14) 93,8(14) 6,8
OceTHHbI-I1pOHD;bI 105,2 (181) 97,7 (168) 7,5 100,6 (91) 93,8 (90) 6,8
OceTIIHbI-P;llroPIt;bI 106,8(48) 99,0(40) 7,8 100,8(29) 94,0 (26) 6,8
OCeTIIHbI-TyaJIbIt;bI 105,6(39) 97,8(40) 7,8 102,3 (21) 93,4 (20) 8,9
Ap;bIl'eftIt;bI 106,5 (67) 99,6 (62) 6,9 101,0(34) 94,4 (33) 6,6
XIV-XVI BB.
A6xa3bI 104,5 (39) 97,1 (33) 7,4 100,1 (18) 92,9(14) 7,2
Ap;ma pIt;bI 107,2 (27) 98,2 (27) 9,0 100,6 (13) 94,3(16) 6,3
rpY3llHbI 106,2 (29) 98,8 (28) 7.4 100,7 (23) 95,1 (22) 5,6
ApMJIHe 105,3 (90) 98,0 (82) 7,3 101,3(47) 92,2 (43) 9,1
A3ep6aftp;maHIt;bI 107,0(13) 99,1 (13) 7,9 102,7 (6) 95,9 (6) 6,8
XIV - XVII BB.
ABCTpaJIllftD;bI 110,5 (102) 101,1 (102) 9,4 - - -
Cpep;H1UI pa3HlIlW - - 7,6 [24] - - 7,0 [23]
(B RBap;paTHbIX cRo6-
Rax - ROJIII"IeCTBO ce-
pIlft)
GOJIbmerO KOJIlI'IeCTBa HerpoIIJJ;IIbIX cepIIM MOrJIO 6bI II3MeHIITb 3aMeTHbIM 06-
pa30M BeJIII'IIIHY IIonpaBKII. Be,IJ:b GOJIbmIIHCTBo IIX xapaKTepII3yeTcH rpa-
IJ;IIJIbIIbIM CTpoeHIIeM II eCJIII II OTJIII'IaeTCH 0'1' 'IepenOB MOHrOJIOII,IJ:OB II eBpo-
neorqoB, TO CKopee B CTOPOHY, npOTIIBOllOJIOmHYIO TOM, B KOTOpylO OTJIII'Ia-
IOTCH 0'1' HIIX 'Iepena aBCTpaJIIIMIJ;eB. TaKInI 06pa30M, nOJIy'IeHHbIe BeJIII'IIIHbI
nonpaBoR p:JIH 060IIX nOJIOB CJIe)];yeT, 1l0-BII,IJ:IIMOMY, C'IIITaTb ,IJ:oCTaTOqHO
6JIII3KIIMII I{ p:eMCTBIITeJIbHbIM COOTHomeHIIHM.
B03BpaIIJ;alOCb K paccMoTpeHIIIO ,IJ:aHHbIX no ceBepHOMY KIITalO, KOTopbIe
CYMMIIpoBaHbI C Y'IeTOM YKa3aHHbIx lIonpaBoK (Ta6JI. 16) II, KpOMe '1'01'0,
IIpe,IJ:CTaBJIeHbI B rpa<pII'IeCKOM <popMe (pIIC. 28) . 11:3-3a OTCYTCTBlIH p:aH-
HbIX no meHcKoM cepIIII HeOJIIITII'IeCKOrO BpeMeHII OCHOBa rpa<pIIKa pa3JIII'IHa
npII conOCTaBJIeHIIII MymCKIIX II llieHCKIIX CepIIM. B lIepBOM CJIY'Iae 3a
100 % npIIHHTbI BeJIIl'IIIIIbI HeOJIIITII'IeCKOll cepIIII, BO BTOpOM - cYMMapHoM
294
Ta6JIIIqa 16
COnOCTaBJIeHlIe pasHoBpeMeHHMx XpOHOJIOrlI'IeCRIIX ceplIH C TeppliToplI1I CeBepHoro
KIiTaH 110 mupHHe JIlIqa
1 43. BepxHHH IIIH- I
pHHa JIHI{a
45. CRYJIOBlliI
IIIHpHHa
1 46. CpelJ,HHH IIIH-
pHHa ;IHI{a
XpOHOJIOrHQeCRHH nepHoA
HeOJIHTll'IeCRaJI :moxa
onoxa HeOJIHTa II OpOH3M CYMMapHO
COBpeMeHHaH :moxa
104,2(22)
103,3(39)
102,,3 (114)
MymcKlle 'Iepella
1 130,7 (19) I
132,2 (37)
133,5 (247)
iKeHcKlIe '1epella
101,4 (12)
102,0(32)
99,1 (210)
HeOJIlITIl'IeCRaH :moxa
3noxa HeOJIlITa II 6pOH3M cYMMapHo
COBpeMeHHaH :moxa
99,5(11)
99,0(14)
125,8(10)
126,6 (27)
95,0(10)
95,1 (22)
cepIIII HeOJIHTa H GpOH3bI. 113BecTHbIe B03pameHIIH MOrJIa BbI3BaTb ):(aTIIpoB-
Ka HeOJIlITH'IeCKOM cepIIII Cepe,IJ:IIHoM III, a 06'bep:IIHeHHoM cepUII HeOJIIITa II
GpOH3bI Cepe,IJ:IIIlOM II TbICH'IeJIeTIIH )J,O H. s. O):(HaKo TaKaH cxeMaTII3aIJ;IIH
,IJ:onyIl{eHa IIpOCTO II3 coo6pameHIIM Y)J,06CTBa, Tel\I GOJIee qTO CD,BHr B p:aTII-
pOBKe lIa HeCKOJIbKO CTOJIeTHM B TY IIJIII IlHYIO CTOPOHY rrpII arraJIH3e ,IJ:IIHa-
MHKII rrpII3HaKOB BO BpeMeHII rrpaKTII'IeCRII He IIMeeT HIIKaKoro 3Ha'IeIIIIH.
BeJIII'IIIHa C)J,BlHOE B OT,IJ:e.JIbIIbIX IIpII3HaKax 3aMeTIIO GOJIbme Ha MYlli-
CKIIX 1Jeperrax B cpaBHeIIIIH C meHCRIIMH. TaK KaK MyllicKIIe cepUII 3Ha'III-
TeJIbHO OOJIee MHOrOqIIGJIeHHbI, Ra3aJIOCb GbI, II3MenellIIe BeJIII'IIIHbI OT)];eJIb-
HbIX rrpII3HaKOB IIPII cpaBIIeHiHI MYlliCKUX 'IepellOB ,IJ:O.JIIRIIO paCCMaTpIIBaTbCH
KaK )];OKa3aTeJIbCTBO rrpOHBJIeHIIH IIpOIJ;eCCa <3nOXaJIbHbIX U3MeHeHIIM. O,IJ:HaKO
HarrpaBJIeHIIe STIIX II3MeneHlIM rro OTp:eJIbHbIl\I rrpII3HaKaM pa3JIII'IHO. TaK,
BepXHHH mIIpIIHa JIlIIJ;a 1l0CJIep:OBaTeJIbHO YMeHbmaeTCH no Mepe rrpIIGJIIIllie-
HlIH K COBpeMeHHOM SlIoxe. cKYJIOBaH mIIpIIHa, Ha060pOT, TaK me IIOCJIep:o-
BaTeJIbHO YBeJIH'IIIBaeTCH. cpe,a:HHH mnpHHa .TIIIl{a YBeJIII'IIIBaeTCR Ha O'IeHb
He3Ha'IIITeJIbHYIO BeJIII'IIIHY B 06'beAlIIIeHHOM cepIIII srrOXII HeOJIIITa II 6pOH3bI
110 cpaBHeHIIIO C 'IepeIIaMII HeOJIlITII'IeCROrO EpeMeHII. O'IeBII)J,HO, 'ITO IIPII CO-
1I0CTaBJIemIII 'IepenOB HeOJIIITn'IeCKOrO lIeplIO,IJ:a, C O,IJ:HOM CTOpOHbI, II snOXII
6pOH3bI - C P:PyroM, pa3HIIIJ;a GbIJIa 6bI 3aMeTHO 60JIbme. B COBpeMeHHYIO
snoxy Cpe,IJ:IIHH lIIIIpIlHa JIlIIJ;a GOJIee <reM na 2 MM YCTynaeT BeJIH'IIIHe SToro
pa3Mepa B cYMMapHoM cepHII HeOJIIITa II GpOH3bI. TaKIIM oGpa30M, Ha TeppII-
TOpIIII ceBepHoro KIITaH He HaGJIIOD,aeTCH OlIpep:eJIeHHbIM 06pa30M HanpaB-
JIeHHOrO YMeHblIIeHIIH IIJIII HapacTaHIIH pa3l\JepOB, xapaKTepII3YIOIIJ;IIX mIIpII-
HY JIIIIJ;a, IIPH conOCTaBJIeHIIII cepHM pa3Horo Bpel\IeHII. OHII CBH3aHbI OTPII-
IJ;aTeJIbHOM MellirpynnoBoM KOppeJIHIJ;IIei'r, 'ITO, npIIHIIMaH BO BIIIIMaHIIe
nOJIOlliIITeJIbHbIII xapaKTep CBH3II Memp:y HIIMII, nO-BIIp:IIMOMY, CBII):(eTeJIbCTBY-
eT. HeCMOTpH Ha ,IJ:OCTaTO'IHO GOJIbmOe KOJIII'IeCTBO Ha6JIIOP;eHIIll B OT,'],eJIbHbIX
corrOCTaBJIeHHbIX cepIIHx, 0 CJIY'IaMHOM xapaKTepe HaGJIIOAaeMbIx pa3JIII'IIIM.
8'1'0'1' BbIBO,IJ: MOllieT GbITb 1I0):(TBepm,IJ:eH II paCCMOTpeHIIeM ,IJ:aHHbIX 0 llieH-
CKIIX 'Iepenax. IIpaB,IJ:a, BepXHHH mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;a B COBpeMeHHYIO snoxy
MeHbme, <reM B SIiOXY HeOJIIITa II 6pOH3bI, a CKYJIOBaH mIIpIIHa 60JIbme, T. e.
MbI IIMeeM TO llie COOTHomeHIIe, 'ITO II B MYlliCKIIX rpYlIllax. Ho BeJIIIqIIHa
pa3JIII'IIIM HII'ITOmHa. IIpOTIIBOrrOJIOlliHOe HallpaBJIeHIIe II3MeHeHIIM rro rrpII3-
HaKaM, CBH3aHHbIM TeCHOM <PYHKIJ;IIOHaJIbHOll II MemrpYllliOBOM 3aBIICIIMOCTblO,
TaKme, KaK TOJIbKO 'ITO OTl\Ie'IaJIOCb, rOBOpliT, CKopee Bcero, oG IIX CJIY'Iall-
HOM xapaKTepe. cpe,IJ:HHH mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;a IIpaKTII'IeCKII COBceM He II3MeHHeT-
295
CH Ha rrpOTHllieHIIII 4000-5000 JIeT. TaKIm 06pa30M, II npIIBJIe'IeHIIe K aHa-
JIII3Y p:aHHbIX 06 SnOXaJIbHOH ,IJ:IIHaiume B meHCKIIX rpynlIax He p:aeT B03-
MomHOCTIl YJIOBHTb KaKIIe-JIIIGo 3aKOHOMepHbIe cp;BnrII B 3TIIX rrpII3HaKax Ha
TeppIITopIIH ceBepHoro KIITaH 3a nepIIOp: 0'1' HeOJIIITa )];0 COBpeMeHHOCTII.
lVlaTepIIaJIbI 110 KpaHIIOJIOrIIII ):(peBHero II conpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHlIH ErIIn-
Ta II Hy6llII ,IJ:OCTaTOqHO MHOrOqlICJIeHHbI KOJIII'IeCTBeHHO II OXBaTbIBalOT 06-
mnpHbIII nepHO,IJ:, npnOJIII3IITeJIbHO 7000 JIeT. IIpaBAa, lIe EO Bcex CJIyqaHx
MOlliHO npOCJIeAIITb HerrOCpe,IJ:CTBeHHYIO rrpeeMCTBeHHOCTb MelliD,Y D,peBHIIM II
COBpeMennbIM HaCeJIeHIIeM, 1I0CJIe,IJ:Hee, rrO-BII,IJ:HMOMY, IICrrbITaJIO p:OCTaTO'IHO
IIHTeHCIIBHoe BJIIIHHHe STHH'IeCKIIX rpyrrll oKpymalOIl{IIX oGJIaCTeM. Ho IIPII
06IIJIIIII KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB II3 ,IJ:peBHIIX MOrIIJIbHIIKOB pa3HbIX
SIiOX B STOM II HeT 60JIbmoi'r HeoGxop:IIMOCTII. KOJIII'IeCTBO <!TIIX MaTepIIaJIOB
)];aeT TaKllie B03MomHOCTb IIpOII3BecTII conOCTaBJIeHIIe pa3HoBpeMeHHbIx p:aH-
HbIX oT;:(e:IbHO P;JIH HIImHero ErIIIITa, BepxHero ErnnTa II HyGIIII.
KpaHIIo.ITOrH'IeCKlIe p:aHlIbIe II3 norpe6eHIIM p,o,IJ:HHaCTH'IeCKOI'O BpeMeHlI B
HIIlliHeM ErIIrrTe OTCYTCTBYIOT. E,IJ:IIHCTBeHHoe IICKJIIO'IeHIIe COCTaBJIHIOT
e,IJ:IIHII'IHbIe 'Iepella II3 rrorpeGeHHM y cepIIM):(bI 80 , HO p;aHHbIe 0 HIIX OCTaIOT-
CH Heony6JIIIKOBaHHbIMII. 8rroxa I ,IJ:IIHaCTIIII rrpep;CTaBJIeHa 'IepenaMII II3
caKKapbI, orrIIcaHHbIMII A. EaTpaBII II ]];. MopaHTOM 8\ srroxa IV - V ,IJ:IIHa-
CTHE - HeCKOJIbKIIMH cepIIHMII, OIIIIcaHHbIMII IT. BpOKa, A. TOMCOHOM II
]];. 1\'1aKIIBepOM. ]];aHHbIe 0 HIIX rrpIIB.g,IJ:eHbI B CBOP:HOM pa60Te ]];. MopaH-
Ta 82. ceplIH 'IeperrOB II3 MOrIIJIbHHKa IX P;IIIIaCTIIII Y CeJIeHIIH ce):(MeHT
6bIJIa onIIcaHa T. By 83, orpOMHaH cepHH XXVI-XXX p;IIHacTIIM II3 06mIIp-
Horo HeKpOIIOJIH B rII3ax - H'o ITIIPCOHOM II A. ,[J,eBIIH 84. ]];aIIHbIe 0 He-
MHOrOqIICJIeHHOM CeplIn SJIJIIIHIIC1'II'IeCKOro rrepIIOD,a, II3MepeHHOM II. BpOKa,
orryGJIIIKOBaUbI ]];. MopaHTOM 85. OIIIICaHHbIe A. BepI(IIHbCKIIM 'Ie perra SToro
neplIO,IJ:a II3 oa3IIca cIIBa 86 He BKJIIO'IeHbI B corrOCTaBJIeHIIe, TaK KaK OHII
npOIICXO,IJ:HT II3 06JIaCTII, y):(aJIeHHOM Ha 3Ha'IHTeJIbHOe paCCTOHHIIe 0'1' P:OJIII-
UbI HIIJIa, OTKYp:a rrpOIICXOP;HT OCTaJIbHbIe, 60JIee ,IJ:peBHIIe cepIIII. ]];JIH corro-
CTaBJIeHIIH C rrOCJIe;rHlIMH llpIIBJIe'IeHbI ,IJ:aHHbIe 0 q'3perrax II3 KorrTCKoro
KJIa,IJ:GIIIl{a B OKpeCTHOCTHX KaIIpa, C II3BeCTHOM BepOHTHOCTblO ):(aTIIpyeMoro
II TbICH'IeJIeTIIeM H. S.87 Bo Bcex llepe'IIICJIeHHbIX nyGJlIIKaIJ;IIHX OTCYTCTBYIDT
II3MepeHIIH BepxHeM mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a II He BcerD,a rrpIIBO,IJ:HTCH pe3YJIbTaTbI II3-
MepeHIIM ilieHCKIIX 'IepellOB. IIoSTOMY KOJIH'IeCTBO cpaBHIIBaeMbIX rpynn He-
op:IIHaKOBO rro 060IIM llOJIaM (Ta6JI. 17, pIIC. 2!1).
B MYiliCKOM rpyrrrre 'Iepena II3 KonTCKoro KJIa):(GIIIIJ;a 06HapYlliIIBalOT He-
KOTopoe YMeHbmeHIIe CKY.TIOBOrO p:HaMeTpa rrpIl cpaBHIIIur C CepIIeM snOXII
I ,IJ:IIHaCTIIII. Op:HaKo :'1'1'0 YMeHbmeHIIe He HOCIIT 3aKOIIOMepHoro xapaKTepa.
IIoJIIIroH II3MeH'IIIBOCTII CKYJIOBOM llIIIpIIHbI oGllapYlliIIBaeT p:ne BepmIIHbI, rra-
p:alOIl{IIe Ha CepeD,IIHbI III II I TbICH'IeJIeTIIM ,IJ:O II. S. ECJIII pa3JIII'IIIH Mellip:y
cepIIHMII I II IV - V ,IJ:IIHaCTIIM OCHOBaHbI Ha cpaBHeHIIII HeCKOJIbKIIX ):(e-
CHTKOB 'IepenOB II IIX rrpII'IIIHOM MomeT 6bITb CJIY'IaMHOCTb BbI60PKII, TO TaKoe
rrperrllOJIOmeHHe He oG'bHCHHeT YBeJIII'IeHIIH CKYJIOBOrO p:IIaMeTpa B cepIIII
SIIOXII XXVI -XXX ArrHaCTIIM, COCTOHIl{eM II3 HeCKOJIbKIIX COT 'IepenOB, rro
cpaBHeHIIIO C cepIIeM srrOXII IX ,IJ:HHaCTIIH. I13MeneHIIH cpe,IJ:uei'r IIIIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a
BO BpeMeHII IIMelO1' oWIee 3aKoHoMepnbIM xapaKTep. Ho II B ):(aHHOM npII3Ha-
Ke Mbl BII,IJ:IIM pe3Koe. IIOCTIIralOIIJ;ee nO'ITII 3 % nepBOHa'IaJIbllOH BeJIII'IIIHbI,
YMeHbmeHlle B snoxy IX ,IJ:IIHaCTIIII, 1I0C.1Je 'Iero HanpaBJIeHIIe II3MeH'IIIBOCTH
MeHHeTCH Ha npoTIIBOnOJIOmHOe II cpe):(HHH mIIpIIHa JIIIl{a onHTb YBeJIII'IIIBa-
eTCH B cepHII II3 HeKpOrrOJIH B rII3ax.
1I3MeHeHIIH B llieHCKOM rpYllne, COCTOHIl{ell, IIpaBp:a, JIIImb II3 Tpex pa3-
HOBpeMeHHbIX cepIlM, 06HapYlliIIBalOT orrpeL(eJIeHHYro nOCJIe,IJ:OBaTeJIbHOCTb rrpII
corrOCTaBJIeHIIII OOJIee rr03D,HIIX cepIIM C GOJIee paHIInMII. Ho OTJIII'IIIH KonT-
296
IUJ
IUl
IUI
IUU
YY
Yll
Yl
'1UUU JUUU lUUU IUUU
l
r
.-
-
a'
/"".
/'
:/"" '
,p'
U
fUDU
lUUU JUIIU
II
JIIUU
PUC. 29. BpeMeHHhre U3MeHeHHH IIIHpHH:bI JIHqeBoro CIWJIeTa Ha TeppHTopHH HHamero
EmnTa
CKIIX 'IepenOB 0'1' 'IepenOB 3nOXII IX ,IJ:HHacTIIII He OOHapYlliIIBalOT napaJIJIe-
JIII3Ma C MYlliCKIIMII rpynlIaMII. cpe,IJ:HHH mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;a YBeJIIIqIIBaeTCH IIO'ITII
Ha 4 % nepBOHa'IaJIbHOM BeJIH'IIIHbI, CKYJIOBaH ITIlIpIIHa Ha KOIITCKIIX 'Iepenax
MeHbme, qeM Ha 'Iepenax 3nOXII XXVI - XXX )];IIHaCTIIM, HO Y nOCJIeAHIIX
CKYJIOBOll )];IIaMeTp YBeJIH'IIIJICH no CpaBH'eHIIIO C CepIIell IX ,IJ:IIHaCTIIII Ha
3,5 MM. TaK KaR 'IIICJIeHHOCTb llieHCKIIX cepIIM HeHaMHoro YCTynaeT 'IIICJIeH-
HOCTII MylliCKIIX, HeT OCHOBaHIIM npeHe6peraTb 3TIIMII HaGJIIO,IJ:eHUHMII II IIpn
cymp:eHIIII oG SnOXaJIbHOM II3MeHeHHII mIIpIIHbI _ JInIJ;a OCHOBbIBaTbCH TOJIbKO
Ha AaHHbIX no MYlliCKIIM cepIIHM. cOBOKYnHOe paCCMOTpeHIle p:aHHbIX no
nOJIaM npIIBop:IIT K BbIBOP:Y 06 OTCYTCTBIIII SnOXaJlbH:bIX II3MeHeHIrll B mIIpIIHe
JIIIIJ;a Y HaCeJIeHIIH HIIlliHero ErHnTa.
Ha TeppIITopIllI BepXH€rO ErIIIITa He paCKaIIbIBaJIOCb n03,IJ:HIIX KJIap:GIIIIJ;,
KOTopbIe GbIJIII ObI CIIHXpOHHbI RonTCKOMY KJIap:6IIIIJ;Y GJIII3 Kallpa. ITOSTO-
MY HaII60JIee 1I03P;HHH H3 HaXO,IJ:HIl{IIXCH B HameM pacnopHmeHIIII cepIIM C Tep-
pIITOpIIII BepxHero EnIIITa OTHOCIITCH K nepBbIM BeKaM HameM SpbI. 3aTo
3p:ecb 6bIJIH pacKollaHbI MllOrO'IIICJIeHHbIe MOrIIJIbHIIKII p:o,IJ:I1HaCTII'IeCKOrO
-BpeMeHII, p:aTHpyeMbIe V-IV TbICH'IeneTlIHMII p:o H. s. TaKIIM 06pa30M, IIe-
pIIOp: BpeMeHII, Ha IIpOTHllieIIlIII KOToporo MbI MOllieM npOCJIep;IITb II3MeHeHIIe
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOrO TIIlIa p;peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH, TaK me KaK II B HHmHeM
ErIInTe, OXBaTMBaeT npIIGJIII3HTeJIbHO OKOJIO 5000 JIeT.
Ta6JIHqa 17
ConOCTaIlJIeHlIe pa3HoBpeMeHHbIx KpaHHOJIOrH'IeCRIIX cepHii C TeppHTopHH
HHmHero ErHIITa IIO wHpHHe JIHqa
MymcRlIe '-Iepena meHCRlIe 'lepena
XpOHOJIOrlI'leCRIIM neplIOIJ; i5. CRyJIOBaH 146. Cpel\HHH 45. CRYJIOBaH 146_ Cpel\HHH
IIIIIplI!Ia IIIlIpHHa JIII",a IIIlIpHHa IIIlIpliHa JIII",a
I )J;HHaCTHlI 127,8(14) I 96,5 (25) - -
IV - V gHHacTHH 129,7 (47) - - -
IX )J;HHaCTIIH 127,2 (29) 93,9 (37) 117,3 (25) 89,4(28)
XXVI -XXX )J;HHaCTHH 128,7 (785) 95.2 (877) 120,9 (500) 91,6 (581)
8JIJIHHIICTII.'IeCKHM 126,0 (13) - - -
BJIH3KOe K COBpeMeHHOCTH HaCeJIe- 125,8 (57) 95,3 (56) 120,6 (26) 92,9(26)
HHe oRpecTHocTeM Ranpa (KonTbI)
297
?
If/If
IIIJ
1111
fll!
filII
!/!l
,fllllll '1111111 JIIIIII 1111111 !1I1111 II JIIIIII Ifllllll JIlIlII 2111111 fllllll
Poco 30. BpeMeHH:bIe 03MeHeHlUI IDlIplIHbI JI eBOrO CReJIeTa Ha TeppIITOplIH BepxBero
ErnllT a
]];aHHbIe 0 MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbIX cepIIHx p:op:IIHaCTII'IeCKOro lIepIIop:a, OIIIIcaH-
HbIX pa3HbIMII 311 TopaMII, 6bIJIII CYMMIIpOBaHbI 11.. MopaHTOM 88. OUII rOBopHT
o CYIl{eCTBeHHOM pa3HIII(e cepIIM II3 pa3JIII'IHbIX MOrIIJIbHIIKOB no MBorIIM
IIpH3HaKaM, II B 'IaCTBOCTII no mIIpIIHe JIIIIJ;a. O,IJ:HaKO, TaK KaK caMII MOrIIJIb-
HIIKII pacnOJIOmeHbI BnepeMelliKY, a apXeOJIOrII'IeCKHM MaTepHaJI II3 HIIX Be
cBIIp:eTeJIbCTByeT 06 STHII'IeCKOM HeO)];HOpO,IJ:HOCTII HaCeJIeHIIH, STII pa3JIIIqIIH
MorYT 6bITb, 1I0-BIIJJ;IIMOMY, OTHeceHbI 3a C'IeT CJIY'IaMHOCTM BbI60pKl:I, 1l0-
CMepTRoro oT60pa II T. ,IJ:. Bo BCHKOM CJIY'Iae, 3)];eCb OHII paCCMaTpIIBalOTCH
CYMMapHO II nOJJ;pa3,IJ:eJIeIIbI TOJIbKO XpOHOJIOrH'IeCKII. K paHHeMY llepUO)];Y
)];op:IIHaCTII'IeCKOM snOXII OTHeceHbI MaTepIIaJIbI II3 MOrIIJIbHIIKOB B 8JIb-AMpe,
KOBaMIIJIe, Bei'rT-AJIJIHMe II Harap:e 89. K HIIM IIpIICoe,IJ:UHeHbI MaTeprraJIbI II3
Bap:apIIMCKoro MOrIIJIbIIIIKa, 0lIy6JI1IKOBaHIlbIe B. CTOCCIIrep 90 II ]];. MopaH-
TOM 91. cpe,IJ:HIIM nepIIOJJ; p:op:IIHaCTII'IeCKOM snOXII npep:CTaBJIeH MaTepIIaJIaMII
II3 HaraJJ;bI, ony6.lIIIKOBaHHbIMII c. (}:>occeT 92. K n03AHeMY llepIIO)];Y OTHeceHbI
cepIIII II3 8JIb-AMPbI, 8JIb-XOIJ;aHa II Xy. ]];JIH nOJIY'IeHIIH p:OCTaTOqHO npep:-
CTaBIITeJIbHbIX MaTepIIaJIOB 1I0 ):(IIHaCTH'IeCKOMY BpeMeHII II lIepBbIM BeKaM
HameM SpbI CYMl\IIIpOBaHbI 06mHpHbIe ,IJ:aHHbIe, ony6mmoBaHHbIe ]];. MopaHTOM
no II3MepeHIIHM pa3HbIX aBTopOB n. K HIIM nprrGaBJIeHbI pe3YJIbTaTbI II3Me-
peHITM ]];. ]];eppII 'IepenOB SIlOXH XI JJ;IIHaCTIIlI, onyGJIIIKOBaHHbIe A. BaTpaBII
If ]];. MopaHToM D". naK II B MaTeprra.rrax 1I0 HIImneMY ErIInTY, B HameM
pacnopHllieHlIII BeT p:aHHbIX 0 llieHCKIIX 'Iepenax MHorIIX ,mox (Ta6JI. 18,
pIICo 30).
BepxHHH mIIpIlHa Ha MymcKIIx 'Iepenax 31I0XII I - II D,IIRacTIIM MHoro
60JIbme, <reM Ha p:O,IJ:IIHaCTrr'IeCKIIX. B snoxy XVIII -XXI ,IJ:rrHaCTIIM OHa
YMeHbmaeTCH, HO JIIImb Ha 1. MM, 'ITO caMO no ceGe rOBopIIT 0 CJIyqaMHOM
xapaKTepe OTMe'IeHHOM pa3HIIIJ;bI. B 06Il{eM, eCJIII conOCTaBJIHTb pa3HoBpeMeH-
HbIe cepIIII TOJIbKO no BepxHeM mrrpIIHe JIIII(a, MOlliHO cKa3aTb, 'ITO cepIIH
60JIee II03JJ;Hero BpeM€HII 3aMeTHO 60JIee mIIpOKOJIIIIJ;bI, <reM p:op:IIHaCTII'IeCKaH.
8'1'0'1' BbIBO):( MOllieT 6bITb nOBTopen II npII paCCMOTpeHIIII BapIIaIJ;IIM cpeJJ;HeM
IllIIpIIHbI JIIII(a - C TOM JIIImb pa3HIII(eM, 'ITO MacmTa6 pa3JIH'IIIM no STOMY
npII3HaKy MelliAY 'IepellaMII SIiOXII Ha'IaJIa HOBoro IJ;apCTBa II ,IJ:oD,IIHaCTII'Ie-
CKIIMII 3Ha'IIITe.1IbHO MeHbme, <reM 1I0 BepXHeM mIIpIIHe JIlIlJ;a. JII060nbITHO,
'1'1'0 MaKCIIMaJIbHaH BemI'IIIna pa3Mepa II B STOM CJIY'Iae <pIIKcIIpyeTcH B ce-
pIIII 3nOXII I - II ,IJ:IIHacTIIll. Pe3Koe ynemI'IeHIIe CKYJIOBOM mrrpIIHbI OTMe'IaeT-
CH B SIiOXII I - II -II XXVI )];IIHacTrrM. Ho Ha 'Iepenax nepBbIX BeKOB Hamell
SpbI CKYJIOBaH mIIpIIHa YMeHbmaeTCH nO'ITII ,IJ:O BeJIII'IIIHbI, xapaKTepHoM ):(JIH
p:O)];IIHaCTII'IeCKIIX cepIIM. B 06Il{eM eCJIII II MORmo rOBopIITb 0 KaKOM-TO npo-
IJ;eCce SIIOXaJIbHOrO II3MeHeHHH mnpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a Y ,IJ:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH BepxHe-
1'0 ErIIIITa, TO OHO npOHBJIHeTCH CKopee B YBeJIII'IeHIIII IIIIIpOTHbIX ):(IIaMeTpOB
298
Ta6JIIIqa 18
ConOCTaBJIeHlIe pa3HoBpeMcHHbIX KpaHIIOJIOI'II"ICCKIIX CCplID: C TCpplITOp1I1I
BCpXHCI'O El'lIllTa no WlIplIHC JIIfqa
MymcKHe qepena meHClme qepena
XPOHOJ!orHqeCRHfi nepHop; 46. Cpep;- 46. Cpep;-
43. BepXHJUI 45. CRYJIOBaH Hfifl lliH- 45. CKYJIOBaH HHH lliH-
llIHpHHa JIHqa llIHpHHa pHHa llIHpHHa pHHa
;nnw JIHqa
OAlIHaCTII"ICCKIIH paHHlIH 101,8 (34) 125,9 (123) 94,5(76) 117,9(39) 91,4(51)
» cpeAHlIH - 125,6 (53) 95,8 (82) 117,0(63) 92,5(113)
» 1I03AHIIH - 125,7 (111) - - -
I - II AlIHaCTlI1I 106,0(37) 130,2 (72) 97,3 (33) - -
VI-XII » - 125,5 (207) 95,5 (38) - -
XII-XV » - 126,4(61) - - -
XVIII - XXI » 105,0(25) 1215,4(401) 95,6(164) 121,2(77) 91,6 (71)
XXVI » - 130,0 (20) - - -
:3 JIJIlIHlICTII'leCRlIH - 128,2 (99) - - -
DCPBbIe BeRa HOBOH 3pbI - 127,5 (46) - - -
JIIIIJ;eBOrO CKeJIeTa. lIo, C P:PyroM CTOpOHbI, pa3JIII'IIIH MelliP;Y 'Ieperral\1II lIep-
.BbIX BeKOB HameM SpbI II p;op:iuraCTII'IeCKIIMII CJIHmKOM HII'ITOlliHbI, 'ITOObI IIM
MOlliHO ObIJIO IIpnp;aBaTb cepbe3Hoe 3HaqeHIIe.
BapIIaIJ;IIII mMpoTHbIX pa3MepoB JIIIl!a B llieHcKoll rpynne TaKme Hep:ocTa-
TO'IHO onpeD,eJIeHHbI. cKYJIOBaH mlIpIIHa B cepIIII Cpe,IJ:HeM nopbI p:O,IJ:IIHaCTII-
'1feCKoro BpeMeHII YMeHbmaeTcH 1I0 cpaBHeHIIIO C paHHeH, cpep:HHH mIIpIIHa
JIHIJ;a YBeJIII'IIIBaeTCH. B SIIOXY Ha'IaJIa HOBoro IJ;apCTBa cpep;HHH mIIplIHa
JIIII(a, Hao60pOT, YMem,maeTCH, CKYJIOBaH mIIpIIHa YBeJIIIqIIBaeTCH. B 06Il{eM
06a pa3Mepa 60JIbme B ceplIII XVIII-XXI )];IIHaCTIIll no cpaBHeHlI10 C
)];op:IIHaCTII'IeCKIIMII. Ho pa3IIIlI(a He ):(OCTIIraeT CTaTIICTII'IeCKII peaJIbHbIX Be-
JIII'IIIH p:ame no CKYJIOBOMY AIlaMeTpy. B Cpe)];HeM mIIpIIHe JIIII(a OHa IIpaK-
TII'IeCKII OTCYTCTByeT, 6Y,IJ:Y'III paBHa 0,2 MM. TaKIIM 06pa30M, II B STOM CJIY-
'Iae MbI npIIXO,IJ:HM K 3aKJIIO'IeHIIIO 06 OTCYTCTBIIIl O YTIIMbIX CI(BIIrOB B mII-
pIIHe JIIIIJ;a Y HaCeJIeHIIH D,peBHero ErIInTa.
IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCRUe MaTepIlaJIbI no ):(peBIIeMY H3CeJIeIUllO Hy6IIII
CYMMIIpoBaHbI A. BaTpaBII 9". IhI IlCnOJIb30BaUbI II nepeC'IIlTaHbJ ,IJ:aHHbIe
Bcex npe,IJ:meCTBYIO IlX aBTopOB, 3a IICKJIIO'IeHHel\I ):(aHHbIX 0 'IepellaX :moxn
XII-XIII ,IJ:IIHaCTIIM Il3 KepJ\IbI, OllIlcaHHbIX M. KOJIJIeT 96. ITOCROJIbKY ony6-
JIIIKOB3HHaH A. BaTpaBII cepIIH snOXII VII -XVI ):(IIHacTIIM p:OCTaTO'IHO MHO-
rO'IIICJIeHHa caMa no ceGe, MOllino BOCnOJIb30BaTbCH ero ,IJ:aHHbIMIl 6e3 CYM-
l\IIIpOBaHIIH IlK C p;aHHbIMII M. l{oJIJIeT, 'reM GOJIee 'ITO 1I0c.JIe,IJ:HIIe OTHOCHTCH
K HaCeJIeHIHO GOJIee IOmHoM TeppIITopIIII. HaH60JIce paHHHH II3 IIpeACTaBJIeH-
HbIX B pa60Te A. BaTpaBII cepIIll OTHOCHTCH K snoxe llepBbIX )];IlHaCTIIM, HaIl-
GOJIee n03p:HHH p:aTIIpyeTcH III-VI BB. H. 3. TaKIIM oGpa30M, MaTepIIaJI
OXBaTbIBaeT p:OCTaTO'IHO IIpO,IJ:OJIlliIITeJIbHbIH nepIIOp: - 3000-3500 JIe'1'
(Ta6JI. 19, pIIC. 31). l{ COlliaJIeHIIIO, OTCYTCTByeT xapaKTepIICTIIKa BepxHeM
mIIpIIHbI JIHI(a, nO'IeMY IIPIIXO)];IITCH OrpaHlI'IIIBaTbCH paCCMOTpeHIIeM )];BYX
)];PyrIlx mIIpOTIIbIX )];IIaMeTpOB.
ITpII cpaBHeHIIII p:peBHIIX II 1I03P:HIIX cepIlH HaOJIIO)];aeTCH OT'IeTJIIIBOe
YMeHbmeHHe KaK CKYJIOBOM, TaK II Cpe)];HeM mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a II Ha MYlliCKIIX II
Ha llieHCKIIX 'Iepenax. Ho pa3JIII'IIIH B 06Il{eM HeBeJIIIKIl, TaK, CKYJIOBaH mII-
299
t
1/1/
l!l!l
!III
!II!
gy
!l5
?
---\
\
\
JIIIIII
ZII!l1l
1111111
II
J 1I!l1l
Z!lll!l
l!lll!l
!l
".
PHC. 31. BpeMeHIffiIe H3MeHeHHJI IDHPHHLI mm;eBoro CKeJIeTa Ha TeppHTopHH Hy6HH
1!l1
l!ll
l!l!l
!If
III!
S1
r
0'
,--..-..-------.-.-
/
/
'-
".. '-- -.-.-
"--_-=:.:::.--.:::.-.:::.-
--
--
--
Ill!lll
II
ZIIIIII Illllll
Illll!l
1111111
1111111
II
1!l1J/J
1111111
PHC. 32. BpeMeHIffire H3MeHeHHJI JIHI\eBoro CKeJIeTa Ha TeppHTopIDI ApMeHHH
pIIHa B llieHcKoll rpynne YMeHbmaeTcH JIIimb Ha 0,6 % nepBOH8q8JIbHOll ne-
JIIi'IlIHbI. ]];lIHaMIIKa 1I3MeHeHliH 060IIX mlIpOTHbIX )];IIaMeTpOB JIIiIJ;a TaKllie He
OqeHb OT'IeTJIlIBa. JIoMaHaH KpIIBaH 1I3l\IeHeHIIH CKYJIOBOrO )];llaMeTpa B MYlli'
CKOM rpynne IiMeeT )];Be BepmllHbI, na)];alOIl{IIe Ha :mOXII IV-VI II XVIII-
XXX p:nHacTIill. Y HaCeJIeHlIH IV-VI )];IIHaCTIIll Be.:rII'IIIHa CKYJIOBOll mIIplI-
RbI ):(allie BbIme, <reM B cepIIII nepBbIX )];IIHacTIIll. To llie C8Moe COOTHOilieHIIe
MbI IIMeeM B llieHCKOM rpynne. ITO-BII)];IIMOMY, HecMoTpH Ha cpaBHllTeJIbHO
He6mIbmoe KOJIII'IeCTBO 'IepenOB II MaJIYIO BeJIII'IHHY pa3HIIIJ;bI, OlIO He MomeT
6bITb OTHeceHO TOJIbKO 3a C'IeT CJIY'IaMHOCTII BbI60pKll. Ha llieHCKIIX 'Iepenax
OTHOCIITeJIbHO BbICOKlIe BeJIII'IlIHbI CKYJIOBOro )];lIaMeTpa, npeBbImalOIIJ;IIe ero
pa3Mep B cepllII 3 OXII nepBbIX ):(IIHaCTlIM, <PIIKCIIPYIOTCH BIB. H. S. 8no-
XaJIbHOe 1I3MeneHlle Cpe)];HeM mliplIHbI JIIIIJ;a TaKm8 He HOCIiT 3aKOHOMepHoro
xapaKTepa. TaKIiM 06pa30M, neKOTopoe YMeHbmeHIIe nOnepeqHbIX )];IIaMeTpOB
JIHIJ;a O'IeBII):(uo TOJIbKO npII conOCTaBJIeHllII BeJIll'IIIH, xapaKTepHbIX ,IJ:JIH H8-
'Ia.!IbHOrO II KOHe'IIIOrO Py6ellieM paCCMaTpliBaeMoro OTpe3Ka BpeMeHll. qTO llie
KacaeTCH paBHOMepHOCTII 113MeHeHIIH, TO OHO BbIpameHO ropa3):(0 MeHee 0'1'-
qeTJIIIBO, <reM, CKaa{eM, Ha TepplIToplIII HIImHero ITOBOJIllibH.
8T1IX BI.I60pO'IHbIX npHMepOB, KaK MHe npe)];C'raBJIHeTCH, )];OCTaTO'IIIO )];JIH
'1'01'0, 'IT06bI YTBeplli)J,aTb, qTO TeH)];eHIJ;IlH K YMeHbmeHIIIO mlipOTHbIX ):(llaMeT-
pOB JIIIIJ;a Y COBpeMeHlIbIX HapO)];OB no cpaBHeHlllO C )];peBHIIMII He HBJIHeTCH
Bce06Il{ell Ii IIMeeT Mlloro IICI{JIIO'IeHHii. ECTeCTBeHHO 6blJIO 6bI npep;nOJIO-
n\IITb, 'ITO OTCYTCTBIIe y6ep:nTeJIbHbIX p;OKa3aTeJILCTB HaJIIi'IIIH npOTIIBOnOJIOlli-
HOM TeH)];eHIJ;IIIi HBJIHeTCH, CKopee Bcero, pe3YJIbTaTOl\I Hep;OCTaTOqHOCTII )];8H-
HbIX. C STOll TO'IKII 3peRliH nonbITK8 M. r. A6p;ymeJIIIIIIBIIJIM BbIHBIiTb H8
300
Ta6JUII a 19
COIIOCTaBJIeHHe pa3HoBpeMeHHbIx CpaHHOJIOrH'1eCKHX cepHii C TeppHTopHH Hy6HH
no IDnpIlHe JIIIu;a
MymcRIre 'Iepena meHCRHe 'Iepena
XpOHOJIOrH'IeCRHfi nepHog \
45. CRYJIOBaH 46. Cpel1HHH 45. CRYJIOBaH j 46. CpeJ\HHH
IImprma IImpHHa JIHL\a IImprma IIIHPHHa JIHL\a
IIepBble p)IHaCTIIII 127,5 (68) 96,0 (34) 118,7 (36) 91,5(19)
IV - VI » 128,2 (18) - 119,1 (17) -
VII - XVI » 125,4(84) 94,8 (57) 118,2 (92) 92,6(65)
XVIII- XXX » 126,6 (78) 94,3 (85) 119,5 (85) 91.8 (80)
I -II BB. HOBOii apbI 126,0(106) 94,8 (110) 119,2(92) 91,6 (92)
III-VI BB. » 123,7 (62) 92,7 (56) 118,0 (58) 89,8 (43)
Ta6JI a 20
COIIOCTaBJIeHHe pa3HoBpeMeHHbIX RpaHIIOJIOrIl'1CCRHX cepIlii C TeppIlTopIlH
ApMeHIIII no IDnpHHe JIHu;a
XpOHOJIOrH'IeCRHfi nepHog 43. BepxHHH 45. CRYJIOBaH 46. CpeJ\HHH
IIIHpHHa JIHL\a IIIHpHHa IIIHpHHa JIHL\a
MymcKHe '1epena
BlIoxa cpegHeii 6pOH3bI 107,7 (19) 133,2(59) 95,2(19)
BlIoxa paHHero mCJIe3a 106,7 (31) 132,7 (28) 93,7 (31)
COBpe IeHHbIe apMHHe 105,3(90) 133,3 (79) 94,4(82)
iKeHcKHe '1epena
BlIoxa cpeAHell 6pOH3bI 101,5 (10) 123,7 (23) 88,4(10)
BlIoxa paHHero meJIe3a 101,8 (24) 122,7 (23) 90,2 (22)
COBpeMeHHbIe apMHHe 101,3(47) 124,3 (39) 90,4(38)
RaBKaae aony, B KOTOpOll npOHBJIHJIaCb 6bI TeH):(eHIJ;IIH K YBeJIII'IeHIIIO JIIIIJ;e-
BbIX paaMepoB, IIMeeT orpoMHoe 06Il{ee aHa'IeHIIe, HeCMoTpH Ha Hep;OCTaTO'I-
HYIO <paKTII'IecKYIO p;oKaaaTeJIbHOCTb. O)];HaKO <paKTlIqeCKIIll MaTepIIaJI, KOTO
pbIiI MOllieT 6bITb llCnOJIbaOBaH D,JIH 060CHoBaHIIH npe):(CTaBJIeHIIH 0 RaBKa3e
EaK 06 06JIaCTII CneIJ;II<pII'IeCKIiX 3aKoHoMepHocTeM B SnOXaJIbHOll )];lIHaMIIKe
neKOTopbIX npII3HaKOB, pacmIIpHeTCH npII paCCMoTpeHIIlI naJIeOaRTpOIIOJIOrII-
eCKIIX )J,aHRbIX 0 p;peBHeM HaCeJIeHllII ApMeHIIII II COIIOCTaBJIeHIIll IIX C
KpaHlIOJIOrII'IeCKIIMII )J,aIIHbIMIi no cOBpeMeHHbIM apMHHaM.
ITaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrllqeCKIIll MaTepnajI 3nOXII 6pOH3bI npOIICXOP;IIT IIa no-
rpe6eHIIM snOXII n03,IJ:HeiI 6pOH3bl, pacKonaHHblx B 1956-1958 rr. Y CeJIeHIIH
JI'IameH Ha IOrO-3ana)J,HOM n06epeiKbe oa. ceBaH. 113 SToro me paMOHa
npOHCXOD,IIT 'IaCTb MaTepIIaJJa snOXII paHHero llie;;re3a, II3Y'IeHHaH B. A. Tep-
MapTHpOCHlIOM. ]];PyraH qaCTb, IICCJIep;OBaHHaH aBTopOM, IIpOllCXO IIT II3 KYP-
raHOB, paCnOJIOllieHHbIX BOCTOqnee, Y CeJIeHIIH Hopap:ya 97. HaKOHel , ):(JIH no-
.uyqeHllH GOJIee npep:CTaBHTeJIbHbIX p:aHHbIX STII MaTepIIaJIbI CYMMIIpOBaHbI C
MaTepnaJIaMII, P;06bITbIMII II3 RypraHoB BOCTO'IHOll 'IaCTll IOmHoro n06epembH
oa. ceBaH II onllcaHHbIMII B. B. BYHaKOM 98. ]];aHHbIe 0 COBpeMeHHOM apMHH-
CKOll KpaIlIIOJIOI'rrqeCKOll cepIIll B3HTbI IIa pa60TbI M. r. A6p:ymeJIlimBIIJIII 99
(Ta6JI. 20, pIIC. 32).
301
-
Bce TPII IDlipOTHbIX pa3l\Iepa Ha 'IepenaX paHHero llieJIe3HOrO BeKa MeHb-
me, <reM B ceplIll SIiOXII 6POH3bI. BepXHHH mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;a Yl\IeHbmaeTCH II B
nOCJIeP;YIOllJ;ee BpeMH. O)J,HaKO BeJIlI'IIiHa pa3HllIJ;bI O'IeHb MaJIa. CKYJIOBOlr
.l\llal\IeTp II cpep:HHH mlipliHa .TIIIIJ;a YBeJIlI'IIIBaIOTCH B COBpeMeHHYIO snoxy no
cpaBHeHlllO C snoxoii paHHero llieJIe3a II, TaKIiM 06pa30M, npaKTH'IeCKII OIIHTb
,n:OCTIIraIOT BeJIll'IIIH, xapaKTepHbIX )J,JIR HaCeJIeUIIH snOXII n03D,Helr 6pOH3bI.
B 06II eM OTJIII'IIlH COBpeM8HHbIX apMHH 0'1' p;peBHero Hace.TIeHllH snoxII 6pou-
3bI no mIIpliHe JIIIIJ;a CTOJIb He3HaqIITeJIbHbI, 'ITO 0 KaKOM-JIII60 3aKOHOl\IepHOl\I
113l\IeHeHIIll SToro npM3HaKa Ha TepplITopllII ApMeHllII He MOllieT 6bITb II
pe'IJT .
cxop;HaH KapTHHa MOllieT 6bITb OTMe'IeHa II B iIieHCROM rpynne. OTJIH'IIIH
llieHCKOlr cepllII COBpeMeHHblX apl\IHH 0'1' llieHCKliX 'IepenOB snOXII 6POH3bI
MaJIbI no aGcOJllOTHOii BeJIII'IHHe 1I He nOBTopHIOTCH no pa3HbIM npII3HaKaM.
IlCKJIIO'IeHIIe COCTaBJIHeT cpe):(HHH IDllpIIHa JIllIJ;a, BeJIII'IHH3 KOTOpoii B CO-
Bpel\IeHHOll cepHII 60JIee <rel\I IIa 2 % npeBbImaeT aHaJIOrH'IHbIii pa3Mcp Ha
'Iepenax snOXIi GpOH3bl. Ho :JTO JIHmHIIM pa3 cBll):(eTeJIbCTByeT npoTIiB rIIno-
Te3bI rpaIJ;IIJIH3aIJ;IIll B npIIl\IeHeIIHH K TeppHTopHII ApMeHIIII.
llocJIe paccM0TpeHHH Bcex npHBe):(eHHbIx MaTepHaJIOB BoaHIIKaeT pHp; BO-
npocoB. TaK, B 'IaCTHOCTII, BbI3bIBaCT COl\IHeHIIe B03l\WlliHOCTb conOCTaBJIeHIIH
p;aHHblx no pa3IIbIl\I snoxaM ;J:JIJI nOKa3a Toro llJIH IIHoro HanpaBJIeUIiH sno-
XaJIbIIbIX II3MeHeHIIll, Korp:a He ):(OKa3aHa CTporaH npeeMCTBeHHOCTb IICCJIe-
P;yel\Ioro HaeeJIeHMH. ]];eMCTBlITeJIbHO. 6eccnopHbIe p;OKa3aTeJIbCTBa npeeMCT-
neHHOCTIl JIaCeJIeHIIH na npOTHiKeHIIlI TbICH'IeJIeTliM Ha I136paUHbIX HaMIi Tep-
pliTOpITHX OTCYTCTBYIOT. ]];a I1X, KaK llpaBllJIO, II He MomeT GbITb 113-3a
<pparMeHTapHOCTII HaXO HIIWXCH B HameM pacnopHllieHIIII IICTOpH'IeClnIX
IICTO'IJIHKOB. Ho C InmeCTIiUi'I ,D,OJIeM BepOHTHOCTII nOCJIep;UIIe Bce llie n03BOJIH-
10'1' C eJIaTb IIeKOTOpbIe BbIBOiJ,bI.
ITpelli)J,e Bcero CIIMnTOMaTII'IHbI caMlI no ceGe pe3y.TIbTaTbl conOCTaBJIeHllH
naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX II KpaHHOJIOrIIqeCKIIX )J,aHHbIX. OHII cBIIp;eTeJIbCTBY-
10'1' 0 nOqTII nOJIHOM TOlliAeCTBe TiinOB ApeBHero II cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIII
II B ceBepHOl\I KIITae, II B ErIInTe, II B ApMeHIIII. Pa3IlIIIJ;a Me}I>: Y HIIMII npo-
HBJIHeTCH TOJIbKO B COOTHomeHllll ropII30HTaJIbHbIX p:IIaMeTpoB 'IepenHOM
KopoGKII. BeJIH'IIIHa qepemwro YKaaaTeJIH B cOBpeMeHHoM apMHHcKOll cepIIII
3Ha'IllTeJIbHO npeBbImaeT ero BeJIII'IIIIIY Ha 'IepeIIaX snOXlI n03p:Hei'I GpoHabI
II paHHero meJIe3a, pa3JIH'IIIe B STOM npHaHaKe MelliP:Y KonTaMII II )J,peBHIIl\I
HaCeJIeHIIeM ):(OJIIIHbI HIiJIa, C OP;HOll CTOpOHbI, II ceBepHf>IMIi RIITaMIJ;aMII II
D,peBHHM HaCeJIeHIIeM ):(OJIIlIIbI XyaHxs - C P:PyroM, 3al\IeTHO MeHbme, IIO II B
TOM II )J,pyroM CJIY'Iae OHO MomeT GbITb 06'bHCHeHO KaK CJIep;CTBIIe ileMCTBY-
lOllJ;ero C pa3HOM IIIITenCHBHOCTblO npoIJ;ecca 6paXHKeq,aJIII3aIJ;IIII II He Tpe6y-
eT p:onYIIJ;eHIIH 0 npHMeCII HHbIX THnOB.
I1cTOpll'IeCKIIe J aHHbIe B 06llJ;OM TaKme cBllp;eTeJIbCTBYIOT cKopee B nOJIb-
BY rIInOTe3bI npeeMCTBeHHOCTM )J,JIH Bcex STIIX TeppIITopIIM. Bo BCHKOM CJIY-
<rae, npeeMCTBeHHOCTb naCeJIeHHH pa3HbIX snox BeCbMa BepOHTHa na npOTH-
meHIIII Tex nepIIO OB, B rpaHlIIJ;ax KOTOpbIX MbI npOH3BO HJIH conOCTaBJIeHIIe
naJIOOaHTpOnOJIOIII'IeCKIIX II RpaHllOJIOrll'IeCKIIX p;anHbIX. TaKIiM 06paaoM, 0'1'-
CYTCTBMe KaKHX--JIII6o H3l\IeHeHIIM B CTpoeHlIII JIIIIJ;a Y HaCeJIeHIIH ceBepHoro
RIITaH, ErIInTa H ApMeHllll na npOTHllieHHll TbICH'IeJIeTllM, nO-BIID,IIMOMY, He
MomeT GbITL oG'bHCHeno 3a C'IeT nplll\IeCII mIIpOKO;;TIIIJ;bIX TIInOB, npIIBHeceH-
HbIX Ira STII TeppiiTopIIll B 60JIee n03p;HIIe snOXIi naCeJIeHIIeM IIHoro npOIIC-
XOllip;eHIIH. KCTaTII rOBopH, ap;eCb YMeCTHO YKaaaTb Ha TO, qTO STOT npOIJ;ecc
ne CbIrpaJI CKOJIbKO-IIlI6YP;b 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOM pOJIII II Ha TeppIITopHIi rpY31III.
r. c. qIITaH nplIBOilIIT p;aHHbIe 0 nepeCeJIeHIIII npep;CTaBIITeJIeM ropHbIX
B'I'lIOrp a <pII<IecIU1X rpynn rpY3IIHCKoro napop;a Ha paBHIIHY 100. Ho OHII Bcer-
302
p;a COCTaBJIHJIIi HlI'ITOmnOe J\IeHbmHHCTBO no OTHomeHIIIO KO BceMY HaCeJIe-
HIIIO rpY3HH. ITOSTOMY OTMe'IaeMOe Ha llaJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrII'IeCKOM MaTepIIaJIe
caMTaBpCKoro MOrIIJIbHIIKa OTCYTCTBIIe YMeHbmeHHH nOnepe'IHbIX lJ:lIaMeTpOB
JIlIIJ;a BpH;:J; JIll MOlliHO nOCTaBllTb B CBHaI. C npHMeCblO mrrpOKOJIIIIJ;bIX npep:-
CTaBIITeJIelI ImBKacrrOHCKoro '!'fIlla.
r. <D. ]];eGeIJ; 3aMeTIIJI, qTO yMeHbmcHIIe mIIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a II MaCCHBHOCTII qe-
perra COBnaAaeT C nepexo)J,Ol\I K aeMJIeD,eJIIiIO. ITo ero MHeHHIO, aHTpOnOJIOrII-
eClme pa3JIII'IIiH Memp:y HaCeJIeHIIeM snOXII HeOJIIITa II GpOIIabI, OTIIOCHIl{IIM-
CH K IOlliHOM II ceBepHOM BeTBHM eBponeOII)J,HOII paCbI, MorYT 6bITb nOCTaBJIe-
RbI B CBH3b C TeM oGcToHTeJIbCTBOM, qTO B03HIIKHOBeHIIe ael\IJIe)J,eJIIIH B
IO,KHbIX paMmIaX OTHOCIITCH K 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO GOJIee paHHeMY npel\IeHII 101.
ECJIH ObI STO HaOJIIOiJ,eHIIe nOATBepp;IIJIOCb, MOlliHO 6bIJIO GbI rOBopIITb 0 BJIIIH-
HUll <p o pl\1HPyeJ\IOM Cal\IIIM 'IeJIOBeKOl\I oGIl{eCTBeHHOM cpe)J,bI Ha ero <p II3II -
'IeCKIIM TIIn. B 'IaCTHOCTII, l\IO,fiHO GbIJIO 6bI YTBeplli):(aTb, 'ITO B ceBepHOM
KIITae, ErlinTe II Apl\IeHIIII anOXaJIbHOe II3MeHeHlle npll3llaKOB He OTMe'IaeT-
CH npOCTO 1l0TOMY, 'ITO HaCeJIeHIIe STIIX TeppIITopIIM nepeUIJIO K 3eMJIe)J,eJIIIIO
B snOXII, npe):(meCTBYIOIl{IIe 'reM, I{ KOTOpbIM OTHOCIITCH Raxop;Hll lIllCH R 111'1-
meM pacnopHllieHIIII MaTepllaJI. O):(HaKO llMeIOTCH <paKTbI, He YKJIap:bIBaIOIIJ;IIe-
CH B paMKII npe CTaBJIeHIIH 0 BJIUHHIIII OllpeD,eJIeHHOrO 06paaa mH3HII II nII-
TaHHH, CBH3aHHoro C 3eMJIeAeJIbqeCKIIM xoaHllCTBOM, IIa HHTeHCIIBHOCTb
npOIJ;eCca rpaIJ;HJIII3aIJ;IIII. HeKOTopbIe IIa HIIX OTMeqeHbI CaMIIl\I r. <D. ]];e-
6eIJ;0l\1. 8'1'0 - rpaIJ;IIJIbHOe cTpoeHIIe CKeJIeTa nIIrMeeB, HIIKorp;a He 3aHIIl\IaB-
mIIXCH 3eMJIe):(eJIIleM, II Y3KOJIHIJ;eCTb HeKOTOpbIX MeaOJIIITII'IeCKIIX cepHM II3
cpe):(II3el\IHOMOpbH, OTHOCHII\lIXCH K snoxe, Kor):(a 3eM.TIeJ eJIIIe TOJIbKO 3apom-
p;aJIOCb 102. 1J:HCJIO nOCJIep;HIIX l\lOllieT 6bITb YBeJIIIqeHO 3a C'IeT qepenOB 113
Me30JIIITII'IeCKIIX MOrHJIbHIIKOB Y KpaIIHbI 103.
IlaJIeOaIITpOnOJIOrH'IeCKHe MaTepIIaJIbI HeOJIllTII'IeCKOrO BpeMe HH C Teppn-
TOpIIII EBporrbI TaKllie He no Bcex CJIY'IaHX COOTBeTCTBYIOT KOHIJ;enIJ;HII
r. <D. ]];eGeIJ;a. 8KOHOMIIKa II X03HllCTBO HeOJIIITll'leCKIIX nJIel\IeH IIIBeIJ;IIII II
HopBerrIII, C OAHOM CTOpOHbI 10" II ceBepHbIX pallOHOB BOCTOqHOM EBpOllbI,
B 'IaCTHOCTII ITpIIOHe}KbH,- C P:Pyroll 10", p;oCTaTOqHO CXO)J,HbI. MomHo yTBeplli-
aTb, 'ITO 3eMJIep;eJIIIe He IIrpaJIO B 060IIX CJIY'IaHX CKOJIbKO-HII6YP:b cy-
Il{eCTBeIIHOM pOJIIi. MemP:Y Tel\I pa3JIII'IIIH B aHTpOllOJIOrII'IeCKOl\1 TIIne Hace-
JIeHHH oGelix TeppliTopHM p;OCTaTO'IHO D,eMOHCTpaTIIBHbI.- IIpaBp:a, C TeppIITO-
pIIII HopBerHH B HBmeM pacnopHmeHIIII Haxop:HTCH eAIIHll'IHbIe 'Ie pella 106,
HO cepHH II3 HeOJIIITII'IeCKHX MOI'lIJIbHIIKOB IIIBeIJ;IIII II IIpIIOHellibH ):(OCTaTOq-
HO l\ITIOrOqIICJIeHHbI, qTOGbI COCTaBIITb 0 HIiX onpe)J,eJIeHHOe CYlliJ eHIIe 107.
HeonpeAeJIeUlIbI pa3JIII'IITH B X03HllCTBe II B TeX CJIyqaHX, Korp;a conOCTaB-
JIeHIIe pa3HOBpel\IeHHbIX MOrIIJIbHHKOB KaK GYP;TO 6bI p;aeT B03MOlliHOCTb YJIO-
BlITb ::mOXaJIbHbIe II3MeHeHIIH OTp;eJIbHbIX npIl3HaKOB. TaK, TPYP;HO YTBeplli-
)J,aTb, 'ITO 3eMJIe):(eJIIIe 3aHHMaJIO GOJIhIlIOe MeCTO B X03HMCTBe TarapIJ;eB no
cpaBIIeHIlIO C a<paH3CbeBIJ;aMll B MIiHYCIIHCKOll KOTJIOBIIHe, a OXOTa nOTepHJIil
JIH lUJX nOqTII BCHKoe aHaqeHIIe 108, 'Iero HeJIb3H, npaBp:a, nOBTopIITb no
OTHomeHHIO K HMHOM II cpyGHoii KYJIbTypal\I HIImHero ITonOJImbH 109. Bce
STO He p;aeT B03l\IOlliHOCTII npII3HaTb, qTO OTMe'IeHHaH Bblme cTa6IIJIbHOCTb
npII3HaKOB Y HaCeJIeHIIH ceBepHoro KIITaH, ErIIIITa, ApMeHIIII rrpOHCTeKaeT
TOJIblW 3a C'IeT Toro, 'ITO II3MeHeHIIH, aHaJIOrlIqHbIe IIaMenenIIHM na J PyrHx
TeppIITopHHX, llMeJIII 3)J,eCb MeCTO B GOJIee paHHee BpeMH II He nOJIyqIIJIII 0'1'-
pameHIIH B IIl\IelOIIJ;eMCH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM l\IaTepIIaJIe. UO-BII)J,IIMOMy,
OHa YKa3bmaeT KaK Ha pa3HbIM xapaKTep npOIJ;eCCOB SnOXaJIbIIorO II3MeHeHlIH
B 3aBIICIIMOCTII 0'1' l\IeCTa II Bpel\IeHll, TaK II Ha B03MOlliHoc'rb coxpaHeHIIH IIPII
orrpe)J,eJIeHHbIX YCJIOBlIHX onpep:eJIeUHbIX BeJIII'IHH npII3HaKOB Ha llpOTHllieHIIll
p;JIIITeJIbHOrO nepIIO)J,a.
303
I
8'1'0 aaImlO'IeHIIe nOaBOJIHeT KpHTII'IeCKII OTHeCTTiCL K BbIBOP;Y r. cD. ]];e-
6eIJ;a 0 nOHBJIeHlllI npe)J,cTaBHTeJICM KaBKaClIOHCKoro TlIna IIa HbIHemHeM Tep-
pIITOpIIII IlX p3CCeJIeIIlIH B peaYJIbTaTe MIIrpaIJ;IIII 113 60JIee ceBepHbIX 06JIa-
cTeii. ECJIII OTDJIe'IbCH 0'1' rlinOTe3bI nOBceMeCTHoro CYllieHHH JIIIQa, JIer-
KO MomHO npe)];CTaBllTb ce6e, 'ITO xapaKTepHaH )];JIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna
mIIpOKOJIHIJ;eCTb IIMeeT MeCTHoe npOlICXOlliD,eHlIe II oGpa30BaJIaCb IIJIll, Bep-
[fee, COXpaHIIJIaCb C )J,peBHOCTII CKopee B pe3YJIbTaTe 1I30JIHUIIll. KCTaTII ro-
BOpH, eCJIIi 3aIIJ;IIIl{aTb TY TOqKY apeHIIH, 'ITO SnOXaJIbHOe 113l\IeHeHHe mHpIIHbI
JIlIIJ;a Ha KaBKa3e nO)J,'IHHeHO OGbI'IHbIl\I 3aKOIIOl\IepIIOCTHM, TPY)];HO 06'bHCHllTb,
nO'IeMy nepeCeJIIIBmneCH C ceBepa rpynnbI COXpaHHJIH B YCJIOBIIHX haBKa3a
60JIbmHe mlipOTIIbIe )];IIaMeTpbI JIIIIJ;eBOrO CKeJIeTa. ITOTOMY 'ITO B BbICUKorop-
HbIX paMouax OHn He CMOrJIH nepeMTll K 3eMJIeAeJIlllO? Ho, Bo-nepBbIX, STHO-
rpa<pH'IeCKIIe rpyrrnbI rpY3nlICF.:oro Hapop;a, npOlliHBalOIIJ;lle Ha paBunIIe, TaK-
me lll\IelOT 60JIbmyIO IIIHPIiHY JIIIIJ;a 110; BO-BTOpbIX, KaK l\IbI yme y6e)J,IlJIIICb
BbIme, Tel\InbI rpaIJ;IlJIIl3al!IIII He Bcer)J,a COBna)];aIOT C TOM IIJIH IIHOM <pOpMOM
X03HMCTBeHHoll )];eHTeJIbHOCTII.
HeKOTopaH p;enHrid'eHTaIJ;IIH npep;CTaBHTeJIell KaBKaclloHcKoro Tllrra TaKllie,
KaK MHe KallieTCH, He MOllieT C'IHTaTbCH GeccnopHbIM )J,OKa3aTeJIbCTBOM rrpII-
MeCH SJIel\IeHTOB ceBepnoro rrpOIICXOllip;eHllH. ECJIII GbI STO 6bIJIO )];eMCTBII-
TeJIbHO TaK, KaK )J,YMaeT r. cD. ]];e6eIJ;, CJIe):(oBaJIO GbI olliII)J,aTb 3aKoHoMepHo-
ro reorpa<pII'IeCKOrO pacnpe)];eJIeHllH npll3HaKoB rrIIrMeHTaIJ;IIII, T. e. YCIIJIe-
HIIH HHTeHCHBHOCTII IJ;BeTa BOJIOC II rJIa3 no HanpaBJIeHlllO C ceBepo-3ana):(a
Ha IOrO-BOCTOR. KaK Yllie GbIJIO OTMe'IeHO, Ha caMOM )];eJIe SToro HeT. ITpaBp;a,
caMbIe 3aIIa):(HbIe npe)J,CTaBHTeJIII SToro Tllna - Kapa'IaeBIJ;bI CO)];eplliaT B CBO-
eM COCTaBe )J,OBOJIbHO 60JIbmOM npOIJ;eHT CBeTJIOrJIa3bIX IIH)J,IlBll)J,YYl\IOB II 33-
HIIl\IaIOT no STOl\IY rrpII3HaKY MeCTO, GJIll3KOe K BepXHllM rpaHHIJ;aM 113l\IeHqn-
BOCTlI B npeAeJIax KaBKaCIIOHCKOI'O TIilla (CM. Ta6JI. 9). BOJIee CBeTJIOrJIa3bI-
Mn OKa3bIBalOTCH JIlimb TymllHbI, aBapIJ;bI 3anap:HbIX paMoHoB, HeKOTopbIe
rpyrrnbI oceTIIH II aH)J,o-)];II)J,oMIJ;eB. Ho 3aTO CBaHbI II ropHbIe pa'IIIHIJ;bI xapaR-
TepIIaYIOTCH HaII60JIee TeMHbIl\I BeTOM rJIaa cpep:H KaBKaCIIOHCKIIX rpynn.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, MOlliHO npeD,nOJIaraTb, qTO IIaOJIH IIH, 'IaCTO oKa3bIBalOllJ;aH
orpoMHoe BJIIIHHIIe Ha KOHIJ;eHTpaIJ;IIIO Tex IIJIIi IIHbIX BapiiaHToB npIIaHaKoB
C npocToll HaCJIe)J,cTBeHHoM CTPYKTYPOM 111 (a nHrMeHTaIJ;IIH rJIa3 HBJIHeTCH
IIMeHHO TaKIIM rrpll3HaKOM 112), CbIrpaJIa II3BeCTHYro pOJIb II B )];aHHOM CJIY-
qae. A pa3 MbI ):(OIIYCKael\I BJIllHHIIe 1130JIHIJ;IIII, JIOrII'IHO npe):(rrOJIOmIITb, qTO
OHO" MOrJIO CKa3aTbCR He TOJIbKO B YCllJIeHIIll IIHTeHCIIBHOCTII nIIrMeHTaIJ;IIII
rJIaa Y CBaHOB II ropHbIX paqHHIJ;eB, HO II B nOCBeTJIeHIIII rJIa3 Y OCTaJIbHbIX
npe)J,CTaBllTeJIeM KaBKaCHOHCKoro TIIrra. ]];onYIIJ;eHIIe 0 npliMeCIi CBeTJIOnHr-
MeHTHpOBaHHbIX ceBepHbIX SJIeMeHTOB BOCTO'IHOeBpOneMCKoro npoIIcxomAe-
HIIH npe)];CTaBJIHeTCH, CJIe)];OBaTe.TIbHO, II no OTHomeHIIIO K IJ;BeTY rJIa3 lla-
JIllmHIIM.
BOJIbmOe 3Ha'IeHHe p:JIH 06cym):(eHllH IIHTepeCYIOIIJ;eM Hac TeMbI IIMelOT
nCTopHKO-STHorpa<pII'IeCKHe )J,aHnbIe. ITPIi rrpIIHHTHII I'lmOTe3bI 0 npIIxop;e
STHII'IeCKIiX rpynn, OTHOCHIl{IIXCH K KaBKaClIoHcKOMy Tllrry, C ceBepa CJIep:y-
eT omIIp;aTb, qTO B STHorpa<pIIqeCKIIX MaTepIIaJIaX, <pOJIbKJIOpe, )];aHHbIX H3bI-
Ka Mbl HallAeM MIIOrO'IIICJIeHHbIe CBllileTeJIbCTBa llX CTenHoro npOlIcxomp:e-
HIIH II npelliHero npOlliliBaHIIH Ha paBHIIHe. OilHaKO TaKIIe CBll)J,eTeJIbCTB3
neMHOI'O'IIICJIeHHbI H KpaMIIe <ppar IeHTapHbI. 8THorpa<pII'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI
rOBopIIT 0 TOM, 'ITO KYJIbTypa HapO)];OB, HaCeJIHIOIl{IIX npe):(ropbH IJ;eHTpaJIb-
HOM 'IaCTII KaBKa3CKoro xpe6Ta, npeACTaBJIHeT C060M cBoeoGpa3HbIll ROMn-
JIeKC, OTJIIIqalOIIJ;IIllCH II)];eaJIbHbIM npIIcnocoGJIeHIIeM K CJIOlliHbIM II TPY)];HbIM
YCJIOBIIHM BbICOKoropbH, "'ITO Bce STII Hapop:bI, MeTa<popII'IeCKII BbIpamaHCb,
He rOCTII, a X03HeBa rop 113. 06 ST011 llie CBII)];eTeJIbCTBYIOT II peaYJIbTaTbI
304
lIaY'IeHIlH <pOJIbKJIOpa STIIX HapO)];OB 114. qTO me KacaeTCH )];aHHbIX HabIKa,
TO, KOHe'IHO, IIpaHOH3bI'IHOCTb oceTIiH II TlOpKOHabI'IHOCTb 6aJIKap eB 1I Ka-
pa'IaeB eB B 06llJ;eM MorYT 6bITb llCnOJIb30BaHbI KaK )];OKa3aTeJIbCTBO IlX npII-
m:Ioro nponCXOllip:eHIIH. Op:HaKO, Bo-nepBbIX, B KYJIbType II H3bIKe STIiX Ha,
pOp:OB BbIHBJIHeTCH MOllJ;HbIM nJIaCT CBH3eM C MeCTHOM STHll'IeCKOM cpep:oM,
KaBKascKHM cyGcTpaT 11", BO-BTOpbIX, nepexo)J, HapO)];a Ha HOBbIM H3bIK l\1O-
}KeT oCYIl\eCTBJIHTbCH BCJIe):(CTBIIe KYJIbrypHoro II nOJIIITH'IeCKOrO BJIIIHHIIH,
a COBCel\I He 06H3aTeJIbHO STHII'IeCKOrO B3aIIMOAeMCTBlIH H6, B-TpeTbIIX, HaKO-
HeIJ;, npHHa)J,JIelliHOCTb K IIpaHCKoii H TlOpKCKOll H3bIKOBbIM ceMbHM Ha KaB-
Ra3e MomeT 6bITb llCTOJIKOBaHa KaK AOKa3aTeJIbCTBO npIIGJIIl311TeJIbHO B paB-
HOM CTeneHll II ceBepHoro II IOlliHoro npOIICXOmD,eHIIH 117. TaKHl\I 06pa30M,
IICTOpIIKO-STHorpa<pII'IeCKHe II JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKHe MaTepIIaJIbI He AaIOT npHl\IbIX
p:aIIHbIX )J,JIH nop:TBeplli)J,eHllH rIInOTe3bI r. <1>. ]];e6eIJ;a.
]];JIH ee oGocHoBaHIiH MOlliHO 6bIJIO GbI IICnOJIb30BaTb p;aHHbIe 0 CKII<pO-
Capl\IaTCKOl\I BJIlIHHHll Ha KYJIbTYPY HapO)J,OB ceBepHoro KaBKa3a 118. KaK II3-
BeCTHO, 11. A. ]];lliaBanImBIIJIII nOJIaraJI p;allie, qTO CKH<po-capMaTCKHe nJIe-
MeHa 6bIJIII no HabIKY pO)];CTBeHHbI rpyaIIHaM, II caM TepMIIH «Capl\IaT» nbI-
TaJICH 06'bHCHllTb 113 a):(bIreMCKllX, HaXCKIIX II JIearIIHCKoro H3bIKOB. OH nIICaJI,
'ITO «CKII<PbI II capMaTbI, KaR STO C )];OCTaTO'IHOM O'IeBII)J,HOCTbIO BbIHCHHeTCH
nplI nOMOllJ;II HeCOMHeHHoro JIeKCII'IeCKOrO l\IaTepIIaJIa, npIIHa):(JIem:aJIII JIHmh
K ceBepOKaBKaaCKllM ap:bIreMCKO-qe'IeHO-JIearIIHCKlll\I HapO)J,HOCTHM» 119. Op:-
HaKO TO'IKa apeHIIH 11. A. ]];lliaBaXHmBllJIII He nOJIY'IIIJIa CKOJIbKO-H1I6YP;b
y6e)J,HTeJIbHOrO nO)];TBepmp:eHIIH II OR OCTaJICH B O)J,IIHOqeCTBe 120. Oc06eH-
Hoe 3Ha'IeHIIe )J,JIH ee onpOBepmeHllH IIl\IeJIIi pa60TbI B. 11. A6aeBa, yGeJJ:ll-
TeJIbHO )J,OKa3aBmero lIHAoeBponeMCKIIll xapaKTep CKII<pCKoro H3bIKa II ero
npIIHa):(JIelliHOCTb K HpaHCKOM H3bIKOBOM ceMbe 121. TaKIiM 06pa30M, BbIHB-
JIHeTCH C nOJIHOll onpeAeJIeHHOCTblO, 'ITO CKII<pCKIIe n capMaTCKlle nJIeMeHa
6bIJIH IIHOPO)];HbIM BKJIlO'IeHlleM B MeCTHYIO KaBKa3CKYIO STHII'IeCKYIO cpe)J,Y II
He npHHHJIII 3Ha'IllTeJIbHOrO Y'IaCTIIH B CJIOllieHIIII COBpeMeHHbIX HapO):(OB
KaBKaaa, aa llCKJIIO'IeHIIel\I. MomeT GbITb, oceTIIH. KpoMe '1'01'0, II3 BceM COBO-
KynHocTIi llMeIOllJ;HxCH )J,aHHbIx BbITeKaeT, qTO IIX pacnpocTpaHeHIIe orpaHII-
qIIBaJIOCb npep,ropHbIMII paMoHaMII II He 3aXBaTbIBaJIO BbICOKoropHbIX 06JIa-
CTeM 122. qTO llie KacaeTCH HeKOTopbIX MeCTHbIX ceBepOKaBKa3CKIIX nJIel\IeH,
TaKme, KaK nOJIaraJI 11. A. ]];lliaBaXIImBIIJIII II CeMqaC nOJIaraeT r. A. MeJIll-
KIImBIIJIll, <PIIrYPIIpOBaBmIIX B IICTOqHHKaX nop: coGIIpaTeJIbHbIl\I Ha3BaHIIeM
CKII<po-capMaTOB 12\ TO OIlII, OqeBII)];HO, He IIMelOT OTHomeHIIH K rrp06JIel\Ie
STHHqeCKIIX cBH3eM HaCeJIeHIIH KaBKa3a C HaCeJIeHIIeM BOCTO'IHO-EBponeM-
CKOM paBHIIHbI. llx CJIe)J,bI B 3aKaBKa3be yKaabIBalOT JIlimb Ha STHII'IeCKIIe
B3aIIMo)J,eMcTBIIH Hapop:OB ceBepHoro KaBKa3a II 3aKaBKa3bH, HOCIIBmIIe, no-
BII)J,IIMOMY, 60JIee JIOKaJIII30BaHHbIM xapaKTep II He BbIXO)];lIBmIIe no CBoeMY
3HWIeHlllO 3a paMKll ):(peBHeM IICTOpIIII STIIX pallOHOB. KOCBeHHbIM aprYMeHT
npOTIIB rlinOTe3bI r. <1>. ]];eGeIJ;a BbITeKaeT II3 paCCMOTpeHIIH reorpa<pII'IeCKO-
ro nOJIOllieHIIH STHII'IeCKIIX rpynn, OTHOCHIl{IIXCH K KaBKaCIIoHcKOMy TIIny.
OHII 3aHllMalOT HaIIGOJIee TPY):(HO)J,OCTynHbIe paMOHbI KaBKaaCKoro xpe6Ta 124.
cJIOlliHO OG'bHCHIITb, nO'IeMy mIITeJIII paBHHHbI, KaKOBbIMII, O'IeBIIp:HO, HBJIH-
JIIICb, no r. <1>. ]];eGeIJ;Y, npe)];KII COBPeMeHHbIX KaBKaCIIOHCKIIX rpynII, aaHH-
JIII IIMeHHO STy TeppIITopIIIO II KaKIIM oGpaaoM OHII cyMeJIII OCBOIITb ee.
.IT. 11. .ITaBpoB nIImeT 0 TOM, qTO KIITI'IaKII II aJIaHbI, CbIrpaBmlle GOJIbmylO
pOJIb B STHoreHe3e oceTHH, GaJIKapIJ;eB II KapaqaeBIJ;eB, 3aHHJIII BbICOKoropHbIe
06JIaCTII noD, )];aBJIeHIIeM pa3rpOMIIBIDIIX IIX MOHrOJIbCKIiX opp; 125. Ho STO co-
6bITIIe OTHOCllTCH K ropaap;o GOJIee noap;HeMy BpeMeHII, qeM o<popMJIeHIIe KaB-
KaCIIOHCKoro TIIrra, n He IIl\IeeT K HeMY Henocpep;CTBeHHoro OTHomenIIH. To
me caMoe MomHO CKaaaTb II 0 SKcnaHCIIII rYHHOB. qTO me KacaeTCH HaCIIJIb-
305
CTBeHHbIX nepeCeJIeHHM IJ;eJIbIX HapoAoB B GOJIee paHHIOIO snoxy BCJIep;CTBIIe
C06bITIIM, nOp:oGHbIX rYHHCKOMY II MOIIrOJIbCKOMY HameCTBIIHM, TO OHII P;JIH
paCCMaTpIIBaeMOM TeppHTopIIH MaJIOBepOHTHbI II, BO BCHKOM CJIY'Iae, He nOA-
TBepmp:alOTcH IIpHMbIMH <paKTaMII.
rBIIOTE3A B30JIHD;n:n:
AHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKlie p;aHHbIe )J,alOT B03l\IOmHOCTb nop;oMTII K aHaJIII3Y npoG-
JIeMbI npoHcxolli)J,eHllH KaBKaCllOHCKoro Tiina II C ApyrOM CTOpOHbI. H IIMelO
B BIIP:Y Yllie OTMe'IaBmeeCH BbIme BJIlIHHIIe II30JIHIJ;IlII. OCHoBHaH ocoGeH-
HOCTb IIpep;cTaBIITeJIen KaBKaCllOHCKoro Tuna, OTJIII'IalOIl{aH IIX 0'1' P:PyrIIx
eBponeOllp:HbIX rpynn II npH)J,alOllJ;aH KaBKaCIIOHCKOMY TlIny IICKJIIO'IllTeJIbHOe
cBoe06pa3IIe cpeAII p;pyrIIX eBpOIIeOIIp;HbIX TlInOB, - OOJIbmaH mIIpIIHa JIIIIJ;a
C6JIIIlliaeT llX C )J,peBHHMll npep;CTaBIITeJIHMII eBponeOIIp:HOM paCbI. KaK 113-
BeCTHO, Ha TeppIITopIIII 3anap:HOM EBponbI mHpOKOJIllIJ;bIM TIIn 6bIJI npeoGJIa-
.n:alOllJ;IIM B HaCeJIeHIIII BepXHeIIaJIeOJIIITH'IeCKOrO II Me30JIHTII'IeCKOro BpeMe-
nii 126, Ha TeppiiTopHIi BOCTO'IHOM EBponbI OH COXpaHHJICH II B snoxy HeOJIII-
Ta II 6pOH3bI 127 . B pa3HbIX paGoTax STOT Tlln nOJIy'IIIJI HaHMeHOBaHIIe
«KpOMaHbOHCKoro B mIIpOKOM CMbICJIe CJIOBa» 128, «naJIeOeBpOIIeMCKoro» 129
II T. p;. ITOMIIl\IO 60JIbmOM mlIpIIHbI JIIIIJ;a B CO'IeTaHIiH C ero He60JIbmIIMII BbI-
COTHbIMII p:rIaMeTpaMII, OIl xapaKTepII30BaJICH HeKOTopOM ynJIOllJ;eHHOCTblO JIll-
IJ;eBOrO CKeJIeTa Ha ypOBHe Ha30MaJIHpHbIX TO'IeK 130. IIHTepeCHO oTMeTlITb,
qTO TaKoe CO'IeTaHlie npII3HaKoB xapaKTepno II ):(JIH KpaHIIOJIOrH'IeCKIIX cepIIi'r
RaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna. OcoGeHHo HpKO OHO BbIpameHO B xeBCYPCKOM cepHH,
KOTopaH, nO-BIIp;IIMOMY, B HaIIGOJIee qIICTOM BIIp:e coxpaHHeT oc06eHHOCTlI
KaBKaCHOHCKoro THIIa, Tor)J,a KaK, CKameM, no OTHomeHlllO K oceTIIHCKIiM ce-
pIIHM II3 CKJIenOB TPYP:HO IIOJIHOCTblO IICKJIlOqIITb BJIIIHHIIe aJIanCKOro SJIeMeH-
Ta 131. Pa3YMeeTCH, B <popMe 'IepenHOM Kop06KII pa3JIIIqHH npep;CTaBHTeJIeM
KaBKaCIIOHCKoro II na.rreoeBponellCKoro TIInOB )J,OCTaTO'IHO p;el\IOHCTpaTllBHbI.
Ho STO II nOHHTHO, eCJIII y'IeCTb 3HaqeHIIe IIHTeHCIIBHO p;eMcTBoBaBmIIx Ha
KaBKa3e npOIJ;eCCOB GpaxHKe<paJIII3aIJ;IIll.
K COmaJIeHIIIO, <pparl\IeHTapHOcTb naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrllqeCKIIX p;aHHbIX no'I-
Tn nOJIHOCTblO JIIImaeT Hac B03MomHOCTII npO)J,OJImIITb nOIICKII aHaJIOrIIM
J\aBKaCIIoHcKOMy Tllny Ha TeppiiTopIIlI KaBKa3a. OHH eCTb, HO p;peBHOCTb UX
B oGIIJ;eM He npeBbImaeT TbICH'III JIeT. KpoMe '1'01'0, nOqTII Bce OHH OTHOCHTCH
K TeppiiTopIIHM, He BXOP:HllJ;IIM HenOCpeD,CTBeHHO B apeaJI KaBKaCIIOHCKoro
TllIIa. 8'1'0 cepIIll 113 cpep;HeBeKOBbIX MOrllJIbHIIKOB ITpIIKyoaHbH 132, ceBep-
HOll OceTllII 133, ]];arecTaHa II A3ep6aMAlliaHa 134. 113 HIIX TOJIbKO MOrHJIb-
HIIKII y Xapxa II 3l\IeMCKOM B ceBepHOM OceTIIll paCnOJIOllieHbJ B paMOHe, KO-
TOpbIM II CeM'IaC BXOlJ:llT B 30HY pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH KaBKaCIIOHCKoro TIIna. HCHbIe
aHaJIOrHII eMy B naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIiX MaTepIIaJIaX 60JIee paHHHX snox
OTCYTCTBYIOT. Ho Bce me MOlliHO OTl\IeTllTb HeCKOJIbKO cepIIll, P;JIH KOTOpbIX
xapaKTepHbI cpaBHllTeJIbHO 60JIbmHe BeJIIIqIIHbI mlIpOTHbIX pa3MepOB JIuIJ;a.
8'1'0 qepena II3 MOrIIJIbHHKOB paHHero llieJIe3HOrO BeKa II3 IJ;aMaKaGepp;a II
HOpalJ:Y3a II Ha IOrO-3ana)J,HOl\I Gepery 03. ceBaH 135, II3 rpynnoBbIX MOrIIJIb-
HHKOB MllHre'Iaypa 136 II II3 HeKOTopbIX e):(IIHIIqHbIX norpe6eHIIll ceBepHoro
KaBI<83a 137. I1HTepecHaH HaXO):(Ka ObIJIa cp:eJIaHa B HeOJIIITIIqeCIWM norpeGe-
HIIII, paCKonaHHOM rpY3IIHCKIIMII apxeOJIOraMII B npep;ropHOM IIMepeTIIII. ]];0-
6bITbIM B HeM 'Iepell IICCJIeD,OBaH M. r. A6p:ymeJIlImBIIJIIl 138 . OH xapaKTepII-
3yeTcH MaCCIIBHOCTblO, GOJIbmllMII pa3l\IepaMII 'IepenHOll KopOGKII, orpOMHOM
mIIpIIHOM JIIIIJ;a. JII060nbITHO, 'ITO norpe6eHIIe, II3 KOToporo npOIICXOP;IIT STOT
qepeII, GbIJIO OTKpbITO B 06JIaCTII, HenocpegcTBeHHO npHMbIKalOIIJ;eM K 06JIac-
THM, 3aCeJIeHHbIM npe)J,CTaBIITeJIHMII KaBKaCIIOHCKoro Tllna.
I
306
ITepe'IllCJIeHHbIe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrM'IeCKIIe MaTepIIaJIbI, HeCMOTpH Ha CBOIO
HenOJIHOTY, nOaBOJIHlOT c):(eJIaTb OP;IIH BalliHbIH BbIBOP;, IIMelOllJ;IlM HeIIocpe)J,CT-
BeHHoe OTHomeHlle K IIameH TeMe. H HMelO B BII)J,Y pacnpOCTpaHeHIIe mllpo-
KOJIlIIJ;bIX TllIIOB B pa3IIbIX oGJIaCTHX KaBKa3a, nO-BIIp:lIMOMY, C rJIyGoKoM
p;peBIIOCTJI. KaK HII nO)J,xop:HTb K pemeHHIO BOIIpOCOB llX reHeTII'IeCKHX B3aM-
MOOTIIomeHIIM, MOlliHO YTBepm.n:aTb. 'ITO KaBKa3 BXO)J,IIJI B 30HY paCIIpOCTpa-
HeHlIH mlipOKOJIIIIJ;bIX TIInOB GOJIbmOM eBponeOIIp;HOH paCbI Ha'IHHaH no KpaM-
HeM Mepe C HeOJIIITII'IeCIWrO BpeMeHH, a cKopee Bcero, C snOXII nOHBJIeHllH
3,!J;ecb 'IeJIOBeKa cOBpeMeHHoro BIIp;a. KOMnaKTHbIM apeaJI KaBKaCHOHCKoro
THna B HaCToHllJ;ee BpeMH II ero IIprrypO'IeHHOCTb K BbIcoKorOpHbIl\I paHoIIaM,
a TaKllie Mop<pOJIOrH'IeCKOe cBoe06pa311e SToro TIIna He n03BOJIHIOT C'IHTaTb
ero IIoa)J,HIIM 06pa30BaHHeM. C p;pyrOH CTOpOHbI, IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOI'II'IeCKIIe
)J,aHHbIe TaKme CBII)J,eTeJIbCTBYIOT CKopee B IIOJIb3Y npep;IIOJIOllieHllH 0 ero
p;peBHeM npOIICXOllip:eHIIII. BeCbMa BepOHTHO, qTO paCKonRII p;peBHHX MO-
rllJIbHIIKOB B npep;ropbHX U;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKaaa p:OCTaBHT HaM naJIeOaHT-
pOnOJIOI'II'IeCKIIM MaTepIIaJI, KOTOpbIM pemIIT STOT Bonpoc C He06xop;IIl\WM on-
pe)J,eJIeHHOCTblO. Ho M CeH'IaC rIInOTe3a 0 mIIpOKOJIMIJ;eCTH p:peBHero HaCeJIe-
nliH IJ;eHTpaJIbHbIX npep,ropIIM KaBKa3cKoro xpe6Ta II KOHCepBaIJ;IIII ST01'1
oc06eHHocTII BCJIep;CTBIIe II30JIHIJ;I1II B CIIeIJ;II<pIIqecKIIx YCJIOBIIHX BbICOKoropbH
npep:CTaBJIHeTCH BeCbMa npaBp;oIIop;oGHOM. 1l0-BIIP;IIMOMY, ropHbIe sTHorpa<pH-
qeCKIIe rpynnbI rpyaIIHcKoro Hapop;a II IIX cocep;II coxpaHHIOT ocoGeHHocTII
CBoero aHTpOIIOJIOrll'IeCKOrO Tllna C snOXII aaCeJIeHIIH STOM TeppIITopllM 'Ie-
JIOBeKOM COBpeMeHHoro BIIp:a.
06paTIIMCH K STHorpa<pII'IeCKIIM ):(aHHbIM. OHII CBII):(eTeJIbCTBYIOT oG IIa-
BeCTHoM OGllJ;HOCTM KYJIbTypbI Hapop:oB, OTHOCHIl{IIXCH K KaBKaCHoHCKOMY
Tllny. Bo l\IHOrOM STa OGllJ;HOCTb npoHCTeKaeT, no BceM BepoHTHoCTll, BCJIep;-
CTBlie CXOP;HbIX <pll311Ko-reorpa<pM'IeCImX YCJIOBIiH CYIl{eCTBOBaHIIH II op:MHaKo-
Boro ypOBHH 06Il{eCTBeHHOI'O pa3BIITllH. TaK, OTMe'IaeMOe cpe)J,II ropHbIx ST-
HOI'pa<pII'IeCKIiX rpYlln rpY3IIHCKoro Hapop;a CXOP;CTBO MHorIIX oGllJ;eCTBeHHbIX
IIHCTIITYTOB, CKopee Bcero, peaYJIbTaT '1'01'0, 'ITO OHII CTOHT Ha O)J,HOM ypoBIIe
pa3BIITliH npoH3Bo)J,lITeJIbHbIX CIIJI II npoIIaBop:CTBeHHbIx OTHomeHnM 139.
B IIaBeCTHOM Mepe 3a C'IeT KOHBepreHTHoro pa3BIITMH B CXOP:HbIX YCJIOBIIHX
CYllJ;eCTBOBaHIIH l\IOmeT GbITb OTHeceHO II CXOP;CTBO B KOHCTPYKIJ;IIII mIIJIIIllJ; Ha
06mllpHOM TeppliTopIIll CBaHIIII, ropHOH PaqII, XeBCYPIIM M TymeTHll 14o .
Op;HaKO 3)J,eCb Yllie BbIHB:IHIOTCH qepTbI, CBIIp;eTeJIbCTBYIOIIJ;Me II oG OGllJ;HOCTII
rrpOIICXOllip;eHMH. BOJIee HPKIIM npIIMep CneIJ;II<pII'IeCKIIX CBH3eM, 06'be,LJ,IIHHIO-
IIJ;llX STII HapOJ bI, MOllieT GbITb HaHp;eH B <pOJIbKJIOpe ropHbIX rpY3IIIICKllX
rpynn w. ITpII STOM BalliHO OTMeTllTb, qTO 6bITYIOllJ;lIM B ropHbIX paMOHax
rpY3IIII OXOTHII'IHH snoc )J,OHOCIiT )J,O COBpeMeHHOCTII rJIyGoKYIO apxaliKY.
HaII60JIee apXaII'IHbI CBaHCKIIe CIOllieTbI, aaTeM paqIIHCKIIe II ropIJ;eB BOCTO'I-
HOM rpY3IIII.
113Y'IeHIIe Tpap:I1IJ;IIOHHbIX <pOpM 6bITa Y ropHbIX STHorpa<pII'IeCImX rpyrrn
rpY311HCKoro HapO)J,a II Hapop;HOCTeM 3anap:Horo AareCTaIIa TaKme rr03BOJIHeT
rOBopIITb 0 p;peBHOCTII II apXaIIqHOCTII CYIl{eCTBYIOIIJ;IIX 06bI'IaeB, BbIHBJIHeT
MOllJ;HbIM llJIaCT pop;OBoro CTpOH, BOCXOp;HllJ;ero, nO-BIIp:nMOl\IY, K rJIyGoKoM
p;peBHOCTll 142. AHaJIOrIIqHbIM 06paaOM STO HBJIeHIIe MOllieT 6bITb OTMe'IeHO II
Y IIX TIOPKOH3bIqHbIX cocep;eM, TaKme OTHOCHIIJ;IIXCH K KaBKaClIonCKOMY
TIIny,- KapaqaeBIJ;eB II 6aJIKapIJ;eB, II Y P;PyrMx rrpep:CTaBIITeJIeM SToro
TIIIIa - OCeTIIH 143. XOTH caMII no ce6e 06bIqaII II COIJ;IIaJIbHbIM CTpOH KaKllX-
JIII60 Hapop;OB He p;alOT npHMbIX ):(aHHbIX )J,JIH YCTaHOBJIeHIIH reHeTII'IeCKIIX na-
paJIJIeJIeM, OHII MorYT CBIID,eTeJIbCTBOBaTb 0 qpe3BbI'IaMHO apXaII'IBCKOM ypoB-
He KYJIbTYpHoro paaBIITllH, 0 npomIIBaHHII B GJIII3KOM cocep:CTBe II B CXOP:HbIX
yCJIOBIIHX reorpa<pHqeCIWH CpeD,bI, 0 MHoroBeKoBoH II30JIHIJ;IIII, a IIMeHHO STO
307
II BamHO P;JIH HaC B )J,aHHOM CJIY'Iae. B Ka'IeCTBe AOIIOJIHIlTeJIbHOrO apI'YMeH-
'fa B nOJIb3Y II30JIHIJ;IIll XOTeJIOCb GbI YKa3aTb Ha H3bIKOBOM MaTepIIaJI, Ha
II30JIUpOBaHHoe nOJIOllieHlle CBaHCKOI'O H3bIKa B CIICTeMe KapTBeJIbCKIIX H3bI-
IWB 1". ITOCKOJIbKY II B KYJIbType CBaIIbI BbIp:eJIHIOTCH HaII60JIbmeM apXaII'I-
HOCTblO cpep:ll )J,pYI'IIx rpY3IIH-rOpIJ;eB, He CBII):(eTeJIbCTByeT JIll 060c06JIeHHOe
nOJIOmeHlle CBaHCKoro H3bIKa 0 TOM, 'ITO IIMeHHO CBaHbI HBJIHIOTCH IIOTOMKa-
MII ApeBHeMmIIX STHII'IeCKIIX I'pynn, aaCeJIHBmIIX BbICOKoropHbIe parrOHbI
IJ;eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa3a? MOllieT GbITb, Tor)J,a aGxa30-cBaHCKIIe H3bIKOBbIe
CXOlli)J,eHIIH 145 II IICTOpllKO-TonOHllMIIqeCKIIe p:aHHbIe 0 npeGbIBaHIIII CBaHon
IOmHee TeppIITopIIll IIX TenepemHeI'O paCCeJIeHIIH 146 MomHO IICTOJIROBbIBaTb
B nOJIb3Y IOlliHoro nYTII 3aCeJIeHUH BbICOKOI'OpHbIX oGJIaCTeM KaBKa3a? Ho
3p:eCb MbI BCTynaeM B c<pepy )J,oI'a)J,OK.
Y llie Heop:HOKpaTHO yKaabIBaJIOCb, qTO Ha nYTII npIIHHTIIH I'IiIlOTeabI oG ST-
HII'IeCKOM pO)J,CTBe npeACTaBIITeJIeM KaBKaCllOHCKoro Tiina CTOIiT H3bIKOBaH
npIIHa)J,JIelliHOCTb oceTIIH, GaJIKapIJ;eB II Kapa'IaeBIJ;eB. C )J,pyrorr CTOpOHbI,
GbIJIO OTMe'IeHO, 'ITO B IIX KYJIbType MOllieT 6bITb BbIp:eJIeH KOMnJIeKC HBJIe-
IIIIM, HaJIIIqIIe KOTOpoI'O rOBopliT 0 Bxom)J,eHIIII B IIX COCTaB KaBKaaCKoro cy6-
CTpaTa. PaccMoTpIIM STy np06JIeMY 1l0p;poGHee.
ITpelliD,e Bcero OCTaHOBIiMCH Ha <paKTax, OTHOCHllJ;IIXCH K oGJIaCTII HabIKa.
OceTIIHcKlIE H3bIK 6bIJI nO)J,BepI'HYT nO'ITII IIC'IepnbIBalOllJ;eMy aHaJIII3Y B MHO-
rOqIICJIeHHbIX IICCJIep:OBaHIIHX B. 11. A6aeBa. OKa3aJIOCb, 'ITO npII 6eccnopno
IIpaHCKOM xapaKTepe rpaMMaTIIKII 1'1 JIeKCIIKII OH OTJIII'IaeTCH ocoGeHHocTHMll,
YKa3bIBalOllJ;IlMIi Ha B3aHMo)J,eMcTBIIe C KaBKa3CKliMli H3bIKaMIl 147 . K IIX 'IIIC-
JIY OTHOCHTCH HeKOTopbIe Mop<pOJIOI'll'IeCKHe II CHHTaKCll'IeCKIIe <pOpMbI, a TaK-
me 3aIIMCTBOBaHIIH B oGJIaCTII JIeKCllKIi. MHorIIe 113 HUX IIMelOT CneIJ;Il<pIIqe-
CKIIM xapaKTep II BOCXO)J,HT K CBaHCKOMY H3bIKY 148. B. 11. AGaeB llOJIaI'aeT,
'ITO lIpaHOHebI'IHbIe npeARII oceTllH, 1l0-BU)J,IIl\IOMY aJIaHbI, 3aCTaJIII B I'opax
MeCTHbIe nJIeMeHa, rOBopIIBmlle Ha KaBKa3CKliX HabIKax, II BKJIIO'IIIJIII IIX B
CBOM COCTaB. B KaqeCTBe apryMeHTa B nOJIb3Y TaKOM rIIllOTe3bI OH npUBop:lIT
II HeKOTOpbIe sTHoI'pa<pll'IeCKIIe <paKTbI149. B p;OnOJIHeHIIe K nIIM MOlliHO YKa-
aaTb Ha mIIpoKoe pacnpOCTpaHeHIIe B ropHoM AliropuII TonOHOMII'IeCKIIX Ha-
aBaHIIM C CY<P<PllKCOM - CK, IIMelOIIJ;UX H<peTII'IeCKOe npOllcxomiIeHIIe 150.
B cOBoKynHocTIi C aHTpOnOJIOI'II'IeCKIIMII p;aHHbIMII Bce llepe'IIICJIeHHbIe <paK-
TbI, nOKa3aTeJIbHbIe 1I caMII no ce6e, npII06peTalOT GOJIbmOM Bec II BPHP: JIll
MorYT 6bITb IICTOJIKOBaHbI KaK CJIY'IaMHbIe. 1l0-BII)J,IlMOMY, rIInOTe3a MeCTHOI'O
KaBKa3CKoro llJIaCTa B STHoreHeae oceTIIH, KOTOpbIM B CBeTe peaYJIbTaTOB
llCCJIe):(OBaHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrU'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX C GOJIbmOM )J,OJIeM BepOHTHOCTU
CJIep;yeT Ha3BaTb KapTBeJIbCKIIM, OTpalliaeT peaJIbHYlO p;errCTBIITeJIbnOCTL U
p:OJIlliHa yqllTbIBaTbCH npII pemeHIIII np06JIeM sTHoreHe3a oceTllHCKOI'O Hapo-
p:a. Ee BamHOCTb P;JIH llHTepecylOllJ;eI'O Hac Bonpoca onpep:eJIHeTCH TeM oG-
CTOHTeJIbCTBOM, 'ITO OHa yp:a'IHO 06'bHCHHeT, KaKlIM oGpa30M llpaHOH3bI'IHbIe
oceTUHbI COXpaHIIJIIi aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKllM TIIn, cGJIlimalOIl{IIM IIX C ropHbIMII
;)THOI'pa<pllqeCKUMlI rpynnaMII rpyallHcKoro Hapop;a.
BaJIKapIJ;bI II Kapa'IaeBIJ;bI TaKme He OTJIU'IaIOTCH, KaK yllie OTMe'IaJIOCb,
no CBoeMY aHTpOnOJIOrll'IeCKOMy TIIny 0'1' rpyaIIH-ropIJ;eB. O)J,HaKO no H3bIKY
OHII cGJIIImalOTCH C KapaliMaMII II KYMbIKaMII 15t. 113 BbIMepmIIX H3bIKOB K
Rapa'IaeBO-6aJIKapCKOMY HabIKY HaIIGOJIee GJIII3KO CTOHT nOJIOBeIJ;KIIM II )J,peB-
HeGOJII'apCKUM 152. Ha STOM OCHOBaHIIII npeoGJIa)J,alOllJ;ee 3Ha'IeHIIe B paapa-
OOTKe BonpOCOB npOIICXOllip;eHIIH OaJIKapCKOI'O II KapaqaeBCKOro HapO)J,OB no-
JIY'IUJIa TlOpKCRaH I'UIIOTeaa, npep;CTaBJIeIIHaH B P;BYX BapIIaHTax - Klln'IaK-
CKOM II GOJIrapCKOM 153. Op;HaKO STa I'IInOTeaa CTaJIKIIBaeTCH C pH):(OM
TPyp:HOCTeM npII paCCMOTpeHIIll aHTpOnOJIOI'IIqeCKIIX )J,aHHbIX 154. He Y'IllTbI-
BaeT IIX II aJIaHCKaH rIInOTe3a, TaKllie llMelOllJ;aH pHp: C'fOpOHHIIKOB 155. OCHO-
308
BbIBaHCb Ha STIIX p;aHHbIX, aBTOp BbIP;BHHYJI rHnOTe3Y I\aBl\a3CKoro cy6CTpaTa
B STHoreHe3e 6aJIKapl!eB H Kapa'IaeBIJ;eB 156. B Ka'IeCTBe pop;CTBeHHOH IIM
KOHKpeTHOH KapTBeJIbCKOH rpynnbI 6bIJIH lIa3BaHbI CBaHb!.
Pa3YMeeTCH, 3Ha'IeHIIe 060HX STIIX YTBepllip;eHHH HepaBHOIJ;eHHO. 1l0JIHoe
TOllip;eCTBO aHTpOIIOJIOrHQeCKOrO THIIa 6aJIKapIJ;eB H KapaqaeBIJ;eB. C OP;HOH
CTOpOHbI, H ropHbIX STIIOrpa<pHqeCKHX rpynii rpY3IIH - C p;pyroM, caMO no
ce6e 6e3 BCHKOM p;OnOJIHIITeJIbHOM apryMeHTaIJ;HH 3aCTaBJIHeT npH3HaTb HaJIH-
I1e MOllJ;HOrO KaBKa3CKoro cy6cTpaTa B STHoreHe3e 6aJIKapCKOro II Kapa'IaeB-
CKoro Hapop;OB. ITo MHeHIIIO aBTopa, 6aJIKapIJ;bI II Kapa'IaeBIJ;bI npep;CTaBJIHIOT
C060M CBaHOB, no TeM IIJIII IIHbIM npII'IIIHaM nepemeD,mIIX Ha HeCBaHCKYIO
pe'Ib. 8'1'0, KOHe'IHO, rIIIIOTe3a. op;HaKO OHa IIOJIY'IaeT HeKOTOpylO OIIOPy KaR
B H3bIKOBbIX, TaK II B IICTOpIIKO-STHorpa<pII'IeCKIIX p:aHHbIX.
IlCTOpII'IeCKIIe p:aHIIbIe IT TonOHIIMIIKa cBII)J,eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 TOM, 'ITO CBaHbI
B XIV-XVII BB. npOlliIIBaJIII B BepXOBMIX Ky6aHII II no BaKcaHY, T. e. Ha
7eppiiTopIIH, 3aHHToM B HaCTOHllJ;ee BpeMH Kapa'IaeBI(aMIl II 6aJIKapIJ;al\HI 157.
8'1'0 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO )J,aeT H3BeCTHble OCHOBaHIlH P;JIH YBH3KH IIMeHHO C HIIMH
MeCTHoro KaBKa3CKoro CJIOH B 6aJIKapcKoM H3bIKe 158. B p:06aBJIeHIIe K STO-
MY MOlliHO YKa3aTb Ha HeKOTopbIe STHOreHeT"H'IeCKIIe npe)J,aHIIH 159, 06llJ;He
.paMIIJIIIH 160 , Ha CXO)J,CTBO HeKoTopbIX SJIeMeHTOB KYJIbTYPbI II 06llJ;YIO Tep-
MIIHOJIOrIIIO lliIIJIIIIl{a II X03HMcTBeHHbIx nOCTpOeK. O)J,HaKo, )J,allie eCJIII C'III-
7aTb Bce STII <paKTbI He)J,ocTaTO'IHbIMII )J,JIH OKOH'IaTeJIbHOrO cY}Kp:eHIIH no
Bonpocy 0 pop:cTBe Kapa'IaeBCKOro II 6aJIKapCKOro Hapop;oB, C OP;HOM CTOpO-
HbI, II CBaHOB - C p:pyroM, 6eccnopHo, KaK Yllie OTMe'IaJIOCb, IIX rJIy60Koe
pO)J,CTBO, BbIHBJIHeMOe aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIMH ):(aHHbIMII, C rOpl!aMH-rpY3IIHal\UI
Bo06Il{e. IIMeHHo STO 3aKJIIO'IeHlle HMeeT p:JIH Hac HaII60JIbmee 3Ha'IeHIIe II
n03BOJIHeT, KaK H npH paCCMOTpeHIIII npOIICXOllip:eHIIH oceTIIHCKoro HapO)J,a,
nOHHTb cBoe06pa3Hoe rrepeKpeIl{IIBaHIIe ):(BYX STHoreHeTIIqeCKIIX KOl\ITIOHeHTOB
B npOIJ;eCce npOIICXOlli)J,eHIIH 6aJIKapIJ;eB II Kapa'IaeBIJ;eB, O):(IIH H3 KOTOpbIX,
60JIee n03)J,HIIM, CbIrpaJI pemalOIl{YIO pOJIb B 06pa30BaHIIII Kapa'IaeBO-6aJIKap-
CKoro H3bIKa, a p;pyroM, BOCXOP;HllJ;IIM K rJIy60KoM )J,peBHOCTII, HaJIOlliIIJI OTne-
qaT OK Ha <pOpMIIpOBaHIIe IIX <pH3II'IeCKOrO TIIna.
IITaK, COBoKynHoe corrOCTaBJIeHIIe aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX, JIIIHrBIICTII'IeCKHX
II IICTOpIIKO-STHorpa<pII'IeCKIIX )J,aHHbIX npIIBop;IIT K BbIBOp:y, 'ITO Hapop:bI, Ha-
CeJIHIOllJ;He BbICOKoropHbIe paMOHbI IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM qaCTII KaBKa3CKoro xpe6Ta,
06HapYlliIIBalOT B CBoeM aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM TIlne II B CBOIIX KYJIbTypHbIX
oc06eHHOCTHX pH;::!; napaJIJIeJIeM, KOTopbIe MorYT 6bITb yp:aqHO 06'bHCHeHbI
TOJIbKO 06llJ;HOCTblO IIX npOHcxomp;eHIIH. TaKIIM 06pa30M, HCXO)J,H II3 mIIpOKO
aprYMeHTIIpOBaHHoro B rrOCJIep;HIIe rop;bI Y'IeHIIH 0 X03HMCTBeHHO-KYJIbTYPHbIX
TIInax II HCTOpIIKO-STHorpa<pH'IeCKIIX 06JIaCTHX 161, M:&I HMeeM B03l\WlliHOCTb
BbIp:eJIHTb Ha STOM TeppIITopIIII IICTOpIIKO-STHorpa<pII'IeCKYIO 06llJ;HOCTb, K KO-
TOpOH CJIep:yeT OTHeCTII Kapa'IaeBIJ;eB, 6aJIKapIJ;eB, oceTIIH, ropIIbIe STHorpa<pII-
qeCKHe rpynnbI rpY3IIHCKoro Hapo)J,a, aBapIJ;eB II aH,!J;O-):(II):(OMCKHe IIJIII aHp;o-
IJ;e3CKIIe Hapo)J,HoCTII 3aIIap:Horo AareCTaHa. ApeBHeHmIIe apXeOJIOrII'IeCKHe
Haxop:KH, C)J,eJIaHHbIe B paMOHax, 3aCeJIeHHbIX STIIMII Hapo,!J;aMH, OTHOCHTCH K
snoxe 6pOH3bI 162 . Ho HeCOMHeHHO, qTO OHII 6bIJIII 3aCeJIeHbI B 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO
GOJIee paHH1010 SIIOXY. 1l0JIaralO, qTO 06IIJ;HOCTb Bcex nepe'IIICJIeHHbIX Hapop;OB
BOCXOP;IIT K srroxe 3aCeJIeHIIH STIIX paHoHoB qeJIOBeKOM COBpeMeHHoro BIIp;a
II HBJIHeTCH CJIe)J,CTBIIeM H30JIHIJ;IIII B yCJIOBIIHX TPYP:Hop:ocTynHoro BbICOKO-
ropbH.
,
,I
309
BbIBOl];bI
1. BaJIRapn;bI, RapaqaeBn;bI, OCeTJIHbI, rOpHbIe 9THOrpa<plIqeCRlIe rpynnbI rpy-
31IHCROrO HapO.D;a, aBapn;bI II aH.D;0-n;e3CRIIe HapO.D;HOCTII 06HapymlIBaIOT cne-
n;II<pIIqeCROe CXO.D;CTBO B aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIX npII3HaRaX, n03BOJIHIOID;ee OTHe-
CTlI lIX R ep;IIHOMY TIIIIY. B pa60Tax rPY3IIHCRIIX aHTpOnOJIOrOB 9'1'0'1' TIIn no-
JIyqlIJI HalIMeHOBaHlIe RaBRaCIIOHCROrO II TaRIIM BOrneJI B alITpOnOJIOrlIqeCRYIO
JIIITepaTYPY. 0'1' .D;PyrlIx TIInOB eBpOneOII,L(HOll paCbI OH OTJIlIqaeTCH pH.D;OM
CBOeOOpa3HbIX OCOOeHHOCTeII, 1I3 ROTOpbIX HaII60JIee XapaRTepHOll HBJIHeTCH
OOJIbillaH llIIpIIHa JIlIn;a, Ha nepBbIII B3rJIH.D; C6JIlImaIOID;aH npep;CTaBIITeJIei1:
9TOrO TlIna C npe.D;CTaBIITeJIHMlI MOHrOJIOII.D;HOll paCbI.
2. rlInoTe3a 0 cnen;lI<pIIqeCROM HanpaBJIeHIIII 9nOXaJIbHbIX II3MeHeHIIII
aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX npII3HaROB, II B qaCTHOCTII llIIpIIHbI JIIIn;a, Ha TeppIITo-
pIIII KaBRa3a, OTJIIlqalOID;eMCH OT OObIqHO Ha6JIIOp;aeMOro Ha TeppIITopIIII Co-
BeTCRoro COI03a, OCHOBaHa Ha BbIOOPOqHOM II ROJIIlqeCTBeHHO Hep;OCTaTOqHOM
MaTepIIaJIe II Hym,L(aeTCH B .D;OnOJIHIITeJlbHOII aprYMeHTan;IIII. llpIIMeHeHIle
nOlI rIInOTe3bI R ROHRpeTHoII npOOJIeMe npOIICXOmL\eHIIH RaBRaCIIOHCRoro
TIIIIa BCTpeqaeTCH C TPY.D;HOCTHMII <paRTIIqeCROrO II TeOpeTIIqeCROrO nopHL\Ra.
3. rIInoTe3a 0 npOIICXOJRi'J;eHIIII RaBRaCIIOHCRoro TlIna B pe3YJIbTaTe nepe-
CeJIeHlIH C ceBepa i'J;peBHlIX npep;cTaBlITeJIell naJIeOeBpOnellcRoro TIIna eBpo-
neoIIp;Holl paCbI B ropbI KaBRa3a OCHOBaHa Ha CRpbITOM npe.D;nOJIOJReHIIII 0
BceooID;HocTII .D;ellCTBIIH npon;ecca rpan;IIJIII3an;IIII II HeB03MomHOCTII HaIITII 00-
JIaCTb, r.D;e 9TOT npon;ecc He npOHBJIHJI ObI ceOH C .D;OCTaTOqHOM onpe.D;eJIeH-
HOCTbIO. MeJRi'J;Y TeM conOCTaBJIeHIIe .D;peBHIIX II COBpeMeHHbIX RpaHIIOJIOrIIqe-
CRIIX cepIIII C TeppIITopIIII CeBepHoro KIITaH, ErII?ya II ApMeHIIII, no
OTHOillenIIIO R ROTOpbIM MomHO HaCTaIIBaTb Ha HaJIIlqIIII HenpepbIBHOll reHe-
TIIqeCROll npeeMCTBeHHOCTII, nORa3bIBaeT, '1'1'0 O.D;IIHaROBbIe BeJIIIqIIHbI llIIpIIHbI
JIIIn;a TOqHO TaR me, RaK II .D;pyrIIx npII3HaROB, MOryT coxpaHHTbCH oe3 3a-
MeTHbIX II3MeneHIIM Ha npOTHJReHIIII HeCROJIbRIIX TbICHqeJIeTIIM. MCTOPIIRO-9T-
Horpa<pIIqeCRIle II JIIIHrBIICTIIqeCRIIe .D;aHHbIe TaRme He nO.D;TBepm.D;aIOT MII-
rpan;IIOHHYIO rIInOTe3Y.
4. llpep;noJIoJReHIIe 0 TOM, '1'1'0 KaBRaa He BXO.D;IIJI B OOJIaCTb IIHTeHCIIBHO-
ro p;ellCTBIIH npon;ecca rpan;IIJIII3al(lIII, n03BOJIHeT BbI.D;BIIHYTb rIInOTe3Y 0
<pOpMIIpOBaHIIII RaBRaCIIOHCRoro TIIna Ha TOll me TeppIITopIIII; RaRYIO OH 3a-
HIIMaeT B HaCTOHID;ee BpeMH, B pe3YJIbTaTe ROHcepBan;rIIT alITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX
ocooeHHOCTeII p;peBHellillero HaCeJIeHIIH, BOCXO.D;HID;ero, B03MOJRHO, R 9noxe
HeOJIIITa IIJIH BepXHero naJIeOJIIITa II OTHOCIIBillerOCH R naJIeOeBpOnellCROMY
TIIny eBponeOIIllHOM paCbI. M30JIHn;IIH B TPY.D;HO.D;OcTynHbIx palloHax BbICORO-
OpbH cnoc06CTBOBaJIa ROHcepBan;IIII 9TIIX ocooeHHocTell. IIo Bcell BepoHTHo-
CTII, CJIep;CTBIIeM II30JIHn;lIII HBJIHeTCH HeRoTopoe nOCBeTlleHlIe nIIrMeHTan;IIII
npeL\CTaBIITeJIell, RaBRaCIIOHCRoro TIIna no cpaBHeHIIlO C Hapoi'J;aMII 3aRaB-
Ra3bH. .D:aHHblx 0 TOM, '1'1'0 :IIX npe.D;RII B n;eHTpaJIbHbIX npe.D;rOpbHx KaBKa3-
CRoro xpei5Ta nOHBIIJIIICb C ceBepa IIJIII C IOra. He IIMeeTCH.
5. AHaJIII3 IICTOPIIRo-9THorpa<pIIqeCRIIX II JIIIHrBIICTIIqeCRIIX MaTepIIaJIOB
.D;aeT B03MomHOCTb BbIHBIITb RaBRa3cRIIII cyocTpaT B COCTaBe oceTIIHCRoro,
6aJIRapCROro II RapaqaeBCROro HapO.D;OB. TaRIIM 00pa30M, Hapop;bI, OTHOCH-
ID;IIeCH R RaBRacIIoHCROMY TIIny, MOryT ObITb OO'be.D;IIHeHbI He TOJIbRO Ha OC-
HOBaHIIII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIX ,L(aHHbIX, HO II Ha OCHOBaHIIII IICTOPIIRO-RYJIb-
TypHbIX ocooeHHOCTell. 1l0cJIeL\HIIe TaRme rOBopHT 0 rJIy60RoM .D;peBHOCTJf
9TIIX HapO.D;OB II IIX MeCTHOM npOIICXOJR,L(eHIIII. Bce 9'1'0 n03BOJIHeT Bblp;eJIIITb
B n;eIITpaJIbHbIX palloHax KaBRa3cRoro xpeoTa oc06yIO IICTOpIIRo-9THorp a <p II -
qecRYIO OOJIaCTb, R ROTopoM CJIeL\yeT OTHeCTII npomlIBaIOID;IIe B Hell IIpaHO-,
TlOpRO- II RapTBeJIOH3bIqHbIe HapO.D;bI Ha OCHOBaHIIII OOID;HOCTII IIX npOIIcxom-
.D;eH:IIH.
310
1 II 6aH06CKUU A. A. 06 aHTpOIIOJIOrHqeCROM COCTaBe HaCeJIeID'm POCCHH II Tp. aHTpOIIOJI.
OTp;. O-Ba JII06HTeJIeH eCTeCTB03HaHIIH, aHTpOIIOJIorHH H 3THOrpaq,HH. :M., 1904.
T. XXII. CM. TaRme: Haruw6u.ltu A. H., A6iJywe.ltuw6u.ltU M. ll., A6iJywe.ltuw6u-
.!!u M. r. :MaTepHaJII>I 3RCIIep;HI{HH 1950 rop;a IIO aHTpOIIOJIOrHH cOBpeMeHHoro Hace-
JIeHIIH rpY3HHCROH CCP /I Tp. MH-Ta 3RcIIepHM. Mopq,OJIOrHH AH rccp. T6IIJIHCII,
1953. T. 4.
2 BYHaK B. B. AHTpOIIOJIOrFlqeCRIIH COCTaB HaCeJIeHHH 1\aBRa3a /I BecTH. rOC. MY3eH
rpY31IH. T6IIJIlICH, 1946. T. XIII-A.
:I Haruweu.ltu A. H., A6iJywe.ltuw6u.ltU M. ll., A6iJywe.ltuw6u.ltU M. r. ¥Ra3. COq.; Ha-
rUW6U.ltU A. H., A6iJywe.!!uw6u.ltU M. r. OCHOBHI>Ie HTorlI aHTpOIIOJIOrlIqeCRHX 3RCIIe-
P;HI(IIH 1950, 1951 H 1952 rr. MH-Ta 3RCIIeplIlIIeH. lIWpq,OJIOrIIlI AH rccp /I Te3. P;ORJI.
Ha BI>Ie3P;HOH Hay<!. cec. HH-Ta 3RClIepHM. Mopq,OJIOrHH B r. EaTYMH. T6HJIHCH, 1954;
OHU 3/Ce. :MaTepHaJIbl R aHTpOrrOJIOrFm rpY3IIHCROrO Hapop;a /I Tp. MH-Ta 3RcrrepHM.
Mopq,OJIOrHH AH rccp. TOHJIIICH, 1955. T. 5; OHU :JICe. TIpep;BapHTeJII>Hble p;aHHI>Ie 06
aHTpOIIOJIOrlIqeCJ.mx IICCJIep;OBaHHHX rpY3HHCRoro Hapop;a 111\p. coo6Iq. MH-Ta 3THO-
rpaq,IIH AH CCCP. 1955. BbIlI. 22; OHU :JICe. :MaTepHaJII>I aHTpOrrOJIOrlIqeCROii 3Rcrrep;H-
I{IIH 1954 r. HH-Ta 3RcrreplIM. MOpq,OJIOrIm AH rccp /I Te3. P;ORJI. Ha 7-f! cec.
MH-Ta 3RcrreplIM. MOpq,OJIOrIIH. T6HJIHCH, 1956; A6iJywe.ltuw6u.ltU M. r. 1\ BO-
npocy aHTpOnOJIOrIIlI YAI1HOB /I COOOIlI. AH recp. T. XVII. TUUJIJICII, 1956. .1\1> 5;
OH :JICe. OceTHHbI: (AHTporrOJI. OqepR) /I Tp. IIH-Ta JRCIIepHM. Mopq,OJIorHII AH rccp.
T6IIJIHCH, 1957. T. 6; OH :JICe. 06 aHTpOIIOJIOrIIqeCROM COCTaBe cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIe-
HHH rpY3HH II TaM me. T6IIJIHCII, 1958. T. 7; AX6.tteiJuaHu O. M. 1\ aHTpOIIOJIOrHH RO-
peHHoro HaCeJIeHHH Ap;mapcRoH ACCP II Te3. P;ORJI. Ha BI>Ie3P;Hoii Hay<!. cec. MH-Ta
3RCIIepl1 1. Mopq,OJIOnm B r. EaTYMII; OH ;)/ce. H aIITpOllOJIOrInr r,opCHHoro HaCeJIeHHH
Ap;mapCROH ACCP. EaTyMH, 1957; p:JICaH6epuiJae r. K. K aHTpOIIOJIOrHH COBpeMeHHoro
HaCeJIeHIIH ropHoII IIOJIOCI>I ceBepo-3amlp;HoH rpY3IIH «<cBaHI>I>}) II Te3. P;ORJI. Ha BbI-
e3p;HOH Hay<!. cec. I1H-Ta 3RCIIepHM. Mopq,OJIOrHH B r. EaTYMII; OH :JICe. A6xa30-ap;I>I-
reHCKIIe B3aIIlIIOOTHOIlIeHIIH B CBeTe p;aHHbIX aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH /I Te3. p;ORJI. Ha 7-H cec.
MH-Ta ;mCrreplI 1. 'IOpq,OJIOrIIU; OH :JICe. H arrTpOrrOJIOrIIII aoa3IIH II Tp. HH-Ta 3RcrrepliM.
Mopq,OJIOrliH AH rCCF. TOUJIIICII, 1962. T. 10; OH ;)/ce. B3auMooTHorneHI'IH
a6xa30B C KapTBeJIbCKUMII II ap;bIreiicRHMH 3TID'IqeCRII.'\1lI rpyrmaMli B CBere
p;aHHI>IX aHTpOIIOJIOrIIlI /I TaM me. T6HJIHCH, 1963. T. 11. CBop;Ra n;aHHbIX: A6p;yrne-
JIIIlliBHJIII :M. r. AHTpOrrOJIOrlIH ]qJeBHero II COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHHH rpY3HH. T6lIJIII-
CH, 1964.
4 pe6eq r. (/). AHTpOrrOJIOrHqeCRlIe HCCJIep;OBaHIIH B J:(areCTaHe II Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpaq,HII
AH CCCP. H. C. T. 33. :M., 1956.
5 p:JICaH6epuiJae r. K. 0 rrpOHcxomp;eHHlI 6aJIIillpI(eB II RapaqaeBI(eB /I :MaTepIIaJII>I Ha-
y<!HOH ceCClIH rro rrp06JIeMe rrpOHCXO}K}J;eHlIH 6aJIKapCROrO II RapaqaeBCROro Hapop;OB.
HaJIbqHK, 1960.
6 A.!!eKcee6 B. II. HeROTOpbIe rrp06JIeMI>I rrpOHcxomp;eHIIH 6aJIRapI{eB H RapaqaeBI(eB B
CBeTe p;aHHbIX aHTpOrrOJIOrHII /I TaM me.
? JIeeuH B. ll. 8THo-reorpaq,lI'IeCROe paCIIpep;eJIeHHe HeROTopbIX paCOBbIX rrplI3HaROB Y
HaCeJIeHHH CeBepHoro 1\aBRa3a /I AHTporrOJI. mYPH. 1932. ;N2 2.
8 Coon C. The Races of Europe. ;'II. Y. 1939.
9 Dzierzykmi-Ro{falski T., Olekiewicz IJI. Barma oczu i wlosow a grupy krwi II :Materialy i
prace anthropologiczne. N 44. Wro law, 1958.
10 CM.: A6iJywe.ltuw6u.ltU M. r. 06 aHTpOrrOJIOrlIqeCROM COCTaBe COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIe-
HHH rpY3IIII.
11 HarUW6U.ltU A. H., A6iJywe.ltuw6u.ltU M. r. :MaTeplIaJII>I aHTpOrrOJIOrlIqeCROH 3KCIIep;II-
I(HH 1954 r. MH-Ta 3RCIIepIIM. Mopq,OJIOrIIlI AH rpY3CCP. C. 24.
12 A6iJywe.ltuweu.ltu M. r. OCeTHHI>I: (AHTporrOJI. OqepR).
13 OH :JICe. 1\ rraJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrHH CaMTaBpCRoro WrHJIbHHRa. T6IIJIIICH, 1954; OH :JICe.
IIaJIeOaHTpOrrO!IOrHqeCRIIH MaTepHaJI H3 rr03p;HIIX rrorpe6eHIIH CaMTaBpcRoro MOrHJIb-
HIIKa II Tp. MH-Ta 3RcrrepIIM. MOpq,OJIOrIIlI AH rccp. T6IIJIIICII, 1960. T. 8.
u pe6eq r. (/). IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIorlIH CCCP IITp. MH-Ta 3THorpaq,IIlI AH CCCP. H. C.
T. 4. :M.; JI., 1948.
15 TaM me.
16 Debetz G. F. Certains aspects des transformations somatiques de l'Homo sapiens II
Communications de la delegation sovletIque au VI congres intl'rnational des scien-
ces anthropologiques et ethnologiques. :M., 1960; pe6eq r. (/). 0 HeROTopbIX HarrpaB-
JIeHlIHX II3MeHeHHH B CTpoeHHlI qeJIOBeRa COBpeMeHHoro BIIp;a II COB. 3THorpaq,HH.
1961. ;N2 2.
17 A6iJywe.ltuw6u.ltU M. r. 06 3rrOXaJIbHOH II3MeHqHBOCTH aHTpOrrOJIOrlIqeCRlIX rrp:n3Ha-
ROB II1\paT. co06Iq. MH-Ta 3THorpaq,1I1I AH CCCP. 1960. BmI. 33.
18 Weidenreich F. The brachycephalization of recent mankind /I Southwestern Journal
of Anthropology. 1945. Vol. 1, N 1; pe6eq r. (/). TIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrHH CCCP; By-
HalO B. B. CTPYRTYPHbIe H3MeHeHHH 'leperra B rrpoI(ecce 6paXHReq,aJIII3aI(IIH II Tp. V
311
I
t
'h
BceCOI03. C'Le3p,a aHaTOMOB, rlICTOJIOrOB II 8M6pIIOJIOrOB. JI., 1951; Ou :!ICe. qepell 'le-
JIOBeRa II CTa)J;1I1I ero q,OpMlIpOBaHIIJI y IICROliaeMbIX JIIOp,eH II cOBpeMeHHbIX pac II Tp.
MH-Ta 8THorpaq,1I1I AH CCCP. H.C. :M., 1959. T. 19.
19 pe6elf r. (j). AHTpOIIOJIOrlI'leCRlle IICCJIep,OBaHHJI B )J;areCTaHe; Ou :!ICe. AHTPOIIOJIOrII-
'lecmIe TIIlIbI II Hapop,bI l\aBRa3a. :M., 1960. T. 1.
20 pe6elf r. (j). AHTpOIIOJIOrII'leCRlIe IICCJIep,OBaHIIJI B )J;areCTaHe. C. 214.
21 MUK.ftaw,eeCKa5£ H. If. AHTpOIIOJIOrlI'leCRIIH COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIJI )J;areCTaHa B aJIaHO-Xa-
3apCRoe BpeMJI II BOlip. aHTpOIIOJIOrlIlI. 1960. BbIli. 5.
22 Oua :!ICe. HOBbIe IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrlI'leCRlle MaTepIIaJIbI C TeppliTopIIII )J;areCTaHa II :Ma-
TeplIaJIbI IIO apxeOJIorlI1I )J;areCTaHa. :MaXa'lRaJIa, 1959. T. 1; Oua :!ICe. AHTPOIIOJIOI'lI'le-
CRIIH COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIJI )J;arecTaHa B aJIaHO-Xa3apcRoe BpeMJI.
23 ruua6ypz B. B., (j)upw,rellu B. B. :MaTepIIaJIbI R aHTpOIIOJIOrlI1I p,peBHero HaCeJIeHIIJI
3alIap,Horo l\a3aXCTaHa II C6. :MY3eJI aHTpOIIOJIOrliH II 8THorpaq,IIII AH CCCP. :M.; JI.,
1958. T. 18.
2 pe6elJ r. (jJ. :'\faTeprraJ!bI IIO IIaJIeOaHTporrOJIOrHii CCCP (Hlmmee TIoBOJImbe) II AHTpO-
rrOJI. mypH. 1!J: 6. .N!> 1; Oil, JlCe. TIaJIeOaHTpouo.;wrIm CCCP.
25 KOUOYKropoea T. C. :MaTeplIaJIbI IIO IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIII YRpalIHbI II AHTpOIIOJIOrH'le-
CRIIH C60PHIIR, I. :M., 1956. (Tp. MH-Ta 8THorpaq,IIII AH CCCP. B.C.; T. 33)..
26 nuorpoeCKuu B. B. ApXeOJIOrliJI 3aRaBRa3bJI. JI., 1949.
27 KyifJTUU B. A. ApXeOJIOrII'leCRHe paCROIiRII B TpIIaJIeTII. T. 1: OIIbIT IIeplI0p,1I3aI(lIli
IIaMJITHliROB. T6IIJIIICII, 1941.
28 Bepoaeuuw,eu.ftu H., pJICaeaxuw,eu.ftu I1., p:!ICauaw,ua C. MCTOPHJI fpY3IIII. q. 1:
C p,peBHeiirrmx BpeMeH p,o Ha'laJIa XIX BeRa. T6IIJIIICII, 1946.
29 A6oyw,e.ftuw,eu.ftu M. r. 06 8IIOXaJIbHOH H3MeH'lHBOCTII aHTpOIIOJIOrH'leCRHX IIpII3Ha-
ROB. C. 97.
30 TIo 8TOH IIp06JIeMe IIMeeTCJI orpOMHaJI JIIITepaTypa. CM., HalIp.: 1J e6oKcapo e H. H. (])II-
3II'leCRIIH THII RHTaHl(eB pa3JIH'lHbIX cOI(lIaJIbHbIX rpYllII II AHTPOIIOJI. mypH., 1935.
oM 1.
31 A6oyw,e.ftuw,eu.ftu M. r. IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrH'leCRHH MaTepIIaJI 1I3 II03p,HIIX IIorpe6eHIIii
CaMTaBpcRoro MOrIIJIbHIIRa.
32 ByuaK B. B. Crania Armenica. :M., 1927; AAeKceee B. n. KpaHIIOJIOrliJI xaRaCOB B CBJI-
3II C BOlipocaMII HX IIpOIICXOmp,eHIIJI II Tp. Kn:prH3. apXeOJI.-8THorp. 8RClIep,III(IIII. :M.,
1960. T. 4. BeJIH'lIIHbI CBJI3H cRYJIOBOII rrmpHHbI C BepxHeH II cpep,HeH IIIIIpliHOH JIIIl(a
B apr,UIHcRoIl H xaHTcRoii cepmIX B3HTb! H3 paBoTbI: POiJUUCKUzl H. H. BeJIH'lIIHa II3-
MeH'lliBOCTII II3MeplITeJIbHbIX rrpH3HaRoB 'lepeIIa II HeROTOpbIe 3aRoHoMepHocTII IIX
ROppeJIJIl(IIII y 'leJIOBeRa II ¥'leH. 3alI. :MfY. 1954. Bbm. 166.
33 XpaHJITCJI B MHCTliTYTe aHTpOIIOJIOrIIII :Mf¥. TIpliHomy rJIy60RYIO 6JIarOp,apHOCTb p,II_
peRl(HII HHCTIITYTa 3a pa3pemeHHe BOCrrOJIb30BaTbCH HMH.
3 ByuaK B. B. qepell 'leJIOBeRa II CTap,IIII ero q,opr,mpOBaHIIJI y IICROliaeMbIX JIIOp,eH D
COBpeMeHHbIX pac.
35 Pearson K., Davin A. On the biometric constants of the human skull II Biometrica.
1924. Vol. XVI, pt. 3-4. Tabl. 5.
36 Fawcette C. D. A second study of the variation and correlation of the human skull,
with special reference to the Naqada crania II Biometrica. 1902. Vol. 1, pt. 4; Jacob S.,
Lee A., Pearson K. Preliminary note on interracial characters and their correlation
in man II Biometrica. 1903. Vol. II, pt. 3.
37 T sche pourko ws ky E. Contribution to the study of interractial correlation II Biometri-
ca. 1905. Vol. IV, pt. 3; Ou JlCe. feorpaq,II'leCROe paClIpep,eJIeHIIe q,OPMbI rOJIOBbI H
l(BeTHOCTII RpeCTbJIHCROrO HaCeJIeHIIH IIpeHMym;ecTBeHHO BeJIHROpOCCHII B CBJI3II C
ROJIOHH3an:IIeH ee CJIaBJIHaMH II H3B. O-Ba JII06IITeJIeH e.CTeCTB03HaHIIJI, aHTpOIIOJIOrliH
II 8THorpaq,HII. :M., 1913. T. CXXIV. BbIli. 2.
38 Hpxo A. ll. faHp,mIIHcRHe TIOpRII II AHTpOnOJI. mypH. 1932. oM 2; Ou :!ICe. TypRMeHbI
Xope3Ma II CeBepHoro l\aBRa3a I I TaM me. 1933. ;N2 1/2; Ou JlCe. 0 HeRoTopbIX BOIIpO-
cax pacoBoro aHaJIH3a II TaM me. 1934. ;N2 3.
39 pe6elf r. rI>. AHTpOIIOJIOrII'leCRHe IICCJIep,OBaHliJI B l\aM'laTCROH 06JIaCTII II Tp. MH-Ta
8THorpaq,IIH AH CCCP. H.C. :M., 1951. T. 17.
o Poaoe H. C. :MaTepIIaJIbI IIO RpaHIIOJIorlI1I 'lYJIbIMl(eB II CeJIbRYIiOB II AHTpOIIOJIOrH'le-
CRIIH C60PHIIR, I. :M., 1956 (Tp. MH-Ta 8THorpaq,HII AH CCCP. B.C. T. 33).
U A.fteKCeee B. n. l\paHIIOJIOrIIJI xaRaCOB B CBJI31I C BOlipocaMII IIX IIpOIICXOmp,eHIIJI.
2 Morant G. M. A preliminary classification of european races based on cranial mea-
surements II Biometrica V. XX - B. 1928. P. 3-4; Ou JlCe. A. contribution to the Basque
craniometry /.1 Biometrica. Vol. XXI. 1929, pt. 1-4; Ou ;)/ce. A study of the recently
excavated Spitalfields crania/lBiometrica. 1931. Vol. XXIII, pt. 1-2; CM. TaRme:
Stoessiger B. N., Morant G. M. A study of the crania in the vaulted ambulatC\ry of
Saint Leonard's Church, Hythe II Biometrica. 1932. Vol. XXIV, pt. 1-2.
312
4.3 Macdonell W. R. A study of the variation and correlation of the human skull, with
special reference to English crania II Biometrica. 1904. Vol. III, pt. 2-3; On :JICe.
A second study of the English skull, with special reference to Moorfieds crania II
Biometrica. 1906. Vol. V, pt. 1-2.
,, Hooke B. G. S. A third study of the English skull, with special reference to the Far-
rington street crania II Biometrica. 1926. v.o1. XVIII, pi. 1-2.
45 Yaung M. The West scottish skull and its affinities II Biometrica. 1931. Vol. XXIII,
pt. 1-2.
46 Schrei,!er K. Zur Kraniologie del' Lappen. Oslo, 1931-1935. Bd. I-II; Idem. Crania
Norvegica. Oslo, 1939. Vol. I.
47 Zilinskas f., furgutis A. Crania lithuanica (XX amsiaus ir iskastines lietnviq kaulw-
les) II Acta medicinae facultatis vytauti magni universitatis. Kaunas, 1939. Vol. V.
Fasc. 3.
48 AnUJltoea M. C. TIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIPIecmre MaTeplIaJIbI C TepplIToplI1I qYBaIIICROii
ACCP II KpaT. co06II:\. MH-Ta 8THorpa.p1I1I AH CCCP. XXIII. 1955; Ona :JICe. KpamIOJIO-
rlIH cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH MOpp:OBCROii II MaplIllcRoll ACCP II KpaT. co06II:\. MII-
Ta 8THorpa.p1I1I AH CCCP. 1958. BbIII. 29; OHa :JICe. KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCRaH xapaRTeplIcTII-
Ra MOpp:BbI-8p3II II Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpa.pIIlI AH CCCP. H.C. T. 13. M., 1960.
49 Mapn [(. 10. TIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOI'lIH 3CTOHCROII CCP IITp. MH-Ta 3THorpa.pIIII AH CCCP.
H.C. T. 32. M., 1956.
50 Bynan B. B. qeperra II3 CRJIeIIOB ropHoro KaBIffi3a B cpaBHIITeJIbHo-aHTpOIIOJIOrlI'Ie-
CROM OCBeII:\eHIIII II C6. MY3eH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII II 8THorpa.pIIII AH CCCP. M.; JI., 1953.
T.14.
51 A6oyzue./l,uzueu./l,u M. r. MaTeplIaJIbI R RpaHIIOJIOrIIII KaBRa3a II Tp. MH-Ta 8RcrreplIM.
Mop.pOJIOrIIII AH rccp. T6IIJIlIclI. 1955. T. 5.
52 Bec./l,enoeea [(. X. KpaHIIOJIorlIH oceTIIH II IIpOlIcxollip:eulIe oceTIIHCRoro Hapop:a II M3B..
CeB.-OceT. HayqH.-IICCJIep:. IIH-Ta IIM. Opp:lliOHIIRIIp:3e, 1957. T. 19.
53 [(acu.Moea P. M. AHTpOIIOJIOrlI'IeCROe IICCJIep:OBaHlIe 'IeperrOB II3 MIIHre'Iaypa (B CBH3II
C II3Y'IeHlIeM 3THoreHe3a a3ep6aii;:J;lliaHcRoro Hapop:a). BaRy, 1960.
54 A./l,enceee B. II. AHTpOIIOJIOrlI'IeCRlIll TlIrr ap:bTrOB B 8rroxy II03p:Hero cpep:HeBeRoBbH II
MaTeplIaJIbI IIO apxeOJIorIIII Ap:bITelI. MallRoII, 1961. T. 2.
55 Mun./l,aZUeeCnaR H. H. KpaHIIOJIOrlIH Ri'rpI'lI30B II Tp. KlIprlI3. apXeOJI.-3THorp. 3Rcrre-
p:III\IIII. M., 1959. T. 2.
56 run36ype B. B., 3a./l,nuno H. r. MaTeplIaJIbI R RpaHIIOJIOrIIII Ra3axoB (B CBH3II C BO-
rrpocaMII 3THoreHe3a) II C6. My:JeH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII II 8THorpa.pIIII AH CCCP. M.; JI.,
1955. T. 16.
57 pe6elj r. llJ. TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrlIH CCCP.
58 A./l,enceee B. II. TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrlIH AJITae-CaHHcRoro HaropbH 3IIOXII HeOJIIITa II
6pOH3bI II Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpa.pIIII AH CCCP. H.C. M., 1961. T. 21; OH :JICe. TIaJIeOaHTpo-
IIOJIOI'lIH XaKaCIIII 3IIOXII llieJIe3a /1 Co. MY3eH aHTpOIIOJIOI'lIlI II 8TIIorpa.pHII AH CCCP.
M.; JI., 1961. T. 20.
59 repacU.Moea M. M. qepeIIa II3 IIorpeoemlii CpyOHOll RYJIbTYPbI B Cpep:HeM TIoBOJIlliLe
II KpaT. co06II:\. IIH-Ta IICTOpIIII MaTeplIaJIbHOll RYJIbTypbI. 1958. BbIII. 71.
60 rUH36ype B. B. 8THII'IeCKlIe CBH3II p:peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH CTaJIHHrpap:CRoro 3aBOJIllibH II
MaTepIIaJIbI II IICCJIep;OBaHIIH IIO apxeOJIorIIII CCCP. M., 1959. N! 60.
61 r./l,a3nOea H. M., Tfreljoe B. II. TIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCKlIe MaTeplIaJIbI HlIlliHeBOJIlliCRO-
1'0 OTpHp:a CTaJIIIHrpap;cKoii 8Kcrrep:III\IIII II MaTeplIaJIbI II IICCJIep:OBaHIIH rro aHTporro-
JI01'IIII CCCP. III., 1960. N! 78.
62 P e6elj r. llJ. MaTeplIaJIbI IIO IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIII CCCP (HlIlliHee TIoBOJIllibe); On :JICe.
TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKlIe MaTeplIaJIbI II3 IIorpe6eHIIllCPYOHOll RYJIbTYPbI Cpep:Hero
3aBOJIllibH II MaTeplIaJIbI II IICCJIep:OBaHIIH IIO apxeOJIorIIII CCCP. M., 1954. N! 42.
63 IIcKpeHHe rrplI3HaTeJIeH B. B. (])IIpIIITeiiH 3a IIX IIpep:ocTaBJIemre.
6 Debetz G. F. Certains aspects des transformations somatiques de I'Homo Sapiens;
pe6elj r. llJ. 0 HeKoTopbIX HaIIpaBJIeHIIHX n3MepeHIIII B CTpoeH1I1I 'IeJIOBeRa COBpeMeH-
H01'O BIIp;a.
65 pe6elj r. llJ. TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrlIH CCCP.
36 Anders. on .J. C. Preliminary report on archaeological research in Kansu II Memoirs
of the Geological Survey of China. Ser. A. Peking, 1925. N 5; Idem. Children of the
YeHow Earth. L. 1934.
67 Black D. A study of Kansu and Honan aencolithic skulls and specimens from later
Kansu prehistoric sites in comparison with North China and other recent cran:a II
Palaeontologia Sinica. Ser. D. Peking, 1928. Vol. VI. Fasc. 1. TI03llie 6bIJIII orryOJIIIKo-
BaHbI II )J;PY1'lIe MaTeplIaJIbI, lIwp.pOJIOrII'IeCKII IIOBTopHIOII:\ne C He60JIblTTTDIn Mop:n.plI-
RaI\nHMII TOT llie KOllHJJIeKC. BnOJInOrpa.pIIIO n CBOP;KY p:aHHbIx CM.: [(pronoe M. B.,
COrPpoHoe M. llJ., Tf e6m;capoe H. H. l];peBHlIe KIITallI\bI: IIpOOJIel\!bI 3THoreHe3a. M.,
1978.
I
-
313
J
t> P6'Ib l1p,eT JIIIIIIb 0 pa3Mepax, xapaKTepII3YIOIqIIX mIIpIIHY JIIIn;a. lIo HeKoTopbIM p;py-
rIIM IIMeIOTCJI p;aHHbIe II OTp;eJIbHO 0 cepIIII 'IeperrOB :moXII 6pOH3bI.
69 q e60ncap06 H. H. OCHOBHbIe HarrpaBJIeHIIJI pacoBoii p;mp!f>epeHn;IIaD;HII B BOCTO'IHOii
A3IIII II Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpa!f>IIII AH CCCP. H.C. M.; JI., 1947. T. 2.
"/0 Koganei J. Messungen an mannlichen Schinesen-Schadeln II International Central-
blatt fur Anthropologie und Verwandte Wissenschaften. 1902. Bd. VII.
71 Haberer K. A. Schadel und Skeletteile aus Peking. Jena, 1902.
72 Reicher M. Untersuchungen iiber die Schadelform del' alpenlandischen und mongoli-
schen Brachycephalen II Zeitschritf IiiI' Morphologie und Anthropologie. 1913-19[4.
Bd. XV-XVI.
73 Schultz A. H. Anthropologische Untersuchungen an der Schadelbasis. Ziirich, 1917.
71, Nakano C. Measurements of skulls from Peiping II Zurenkai Zassi. X.XV. N 11. 1920.
75 Black D. A study of Kansu and Honan aeneolithic skulls and specimens from later
Kansu prehistoric sites in comparison with North China and other recent crania.
76 q e60ncap06 H. H. OCHOBHbIe HarrpaBJIeHHJI pacoBoH p;II!f>!f>epeHn;IIan;IIII B BOCTO'IHOH
A3IIII.
77 Shima G. Anthropological study of the Chinese skull obtained from the suburbs of
Fushun, Manchuria II Journal of Anthropological society of Tokyo. 1933. Vol. XLVIII,
N 550.
78 Quatrefages A., Hamy E. Crania Ethnica: les Cranes des races humaines. Paris, 1882.
79 Wagner K. The Craniology of the Oceanic races II Skrifter utgitt av det Norske Viden-
skaps-Akademi i Oslo I. Mat.-Naturv. Klasse. Oslo, 1937. N 2; BYMn B. B. qepella II3
CKJIerrOB ropHoro l\aBKa3a B cpaBHIITeJIbHO-aHTpoIIOJIOrII'IeCKOM oCBeIqeHIIII; A68yme-
.aum6U.au M. r. MaTepIIaJIbI K KpaHHOJIOrIIII l\aBKa3a; P0306 H. C. MaTepIIaJIbI rrQ
RpaHlIOJIOrIIII 'lYJIbIMn;eB H ce:fbRyTlOn; J]unJwme6cnaR H. lrI. I pDHHOJfOrIUl RIIprII30n;
KaCU.M06a P. M. AHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKOe IICCJIep;OBaHIIe 'IeperrOB II3 MIIHre'Iaypa (B CBJI-
3II C II3Y'IeHIIeM 3THoreHe3a a3ep6aHp;maHcKoro Hapop;a); A.aencee6 B. n. l\paHIIOJIO-
rIIJI xaKaCOB B CBJI3II C Borrpoca llI IIX IIpoIICXOmp;eH.lIJI; OH 3/Ce. AHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKllH
TIIII ap;blrOB B 3IIOXY II03p;Hero cpep;HeBeKOBbJI; Ma.MOH06a H. H. l\O'IenHIIRli 3a6aH-
KaJIbJI IX-XIII BB. IIO p;aHHbIM IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIII II AHTpoIIo.:rorII'IeCRIIii C60PHIIR,
III. M., 1961. (Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpa!f>IIII AH CCCP. H.C.; T. 21). l\poMe 3Toro, IICIIOJIb-
30BaHbI p;aHHbIe aBTopa IIO KpaHHOJIOrIIII !f>IIHHOB, BOCTO'IHbIX JIaTbImeH II YII:pmIH-
n;eB: CM.: A.aencee6 B. n. IIpoIIcxomp;eHIIe Hapop;oB BOCTO'IHOH EBporrbI: (l\paHIIOJI.
IICCJIep;.). M., 1969.
80 Coon C. The Races of Europe; Batrawi A. M. The racial history of Egypt and Nubia.
Pt. II: The racial relationships of the ancient and modern populations of Egypt and
Nubia II Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland. 1946.
Pt. II. Vol. LXXVI.
81 Batrawi A. M., Morant G. M. A study of a first dynasty series of egyptian skulls from
Sakkara and of an eleventh dynasty series from Thebes II Biometrica. 1947. Vol.
XXXIV, pt. 1-2.
82 Morant G. M. A study of egyptian craniology from prehistoric to roman times II Bio-
metrica. 1925. Vol. XVII, pt. 1-2.
83 Woo T. L. A study of seventy-one ninth dynasty egyptian skulls from Sedment /I
Biometrica. 1930. Vol. XXII, pt. 1-2.
M Pearson K., Davin A. On the biometric constants of the human skull.
85 Morant G. M. A study of egyptian craniology from prehistoric to roman. times.
86 Wiercinski A. Racial analysis of ancient crania from the Siwah oasis II Acta Facul-
tatis Rerum Naturalium Universitatis Comenianae. Bratislava, 1961. Vol. V. Fasc. III-
VI.
87 Fawcett C. A second study of the variation and correlation of the human skull. with
special reference of the Nagada crania.
88 Morant G. M. A study of egyptian craniology from prehistoric to roman times.
89 MMeeTCJI B BIIP;y IOmHoe KJIap;6mn;e B Harap;e.
90 Stoessiger B. N. A study of the Badarian crania recently excavated by the British
school of archeology in Egypt II Biometrica. 1927. Vol. XIX, pt. 1-2.
H Morant G. M. A study of pre dynastic egyptian skulls from Badari based on measure-
ments taken by Miss B. N. Stoessiger and Professor D. E. Derry II Biometrica. 1935.
Vol. XXVII, pt. 3-4.
92 Fawcett C. A second study of the variation and correlation of the human skull, with
special reference to the Nagada crania.
93 Morant G. M. A study of egyptian craniology from prehistoric to roman times.
91, Batrawi A. M., Morant G. M. A study of a first dynasty series of egyptian skulls...
95 Batrawi A. M. The racial history of Egypt and Nubia. Pt. 1: The craniology of Lower
Nubia from predinastic times to the sixth century A. D. II Journal of the Anthropolo-
gical Institute of Great Britain and Ireland. 1945. Vol. LX.XV, pt. 11.
314
96 Collett M. A Study of twelfth and thirteenth dynasty skulls from Kerma (Nubia) II
Biometrica. 1933. Vol. XXV, pt. 3-4. TI03me 6I,IJIlI ony6JIJIROBaHJ>I 06IIIIIPHbIe MaTe-
plIaJIJ>I, Mop!f>OJIOI'II'leCKlI, op:HaKO, nOBTOpJIIOII(IIe rrpep:I,Ip:y:m;IIe: Nielsen O. The Nubian
skeleton through 4000 years (metrical and non-metrical anatomical variations).
Kobenhavn, 1970.
97 A.aenceee B. II. TIpoIIcxomp:eHlIe Hapop:OB l\aBl\a3a: (l\paHIIOJI. IICCJIep:.). M., 1974.
l];amThIMII 0 pa3Mepax 43 II 46 JI 06JI3aH f. A. A3II3JIHY.
98 BYHan B. B. tJeperra meJIe3HOI'O BeKa 1I3 CeBaHCROI'O paITOHa ApMeHIIlI II Pyc. aHTpo-
rrOJI. mypH. 1929. T. 17, Bm!. 3/4.
99 A6oyzue.auzueu.au M. r. MaTeplIaJII,I R RpaHIIOJIOI'IIII KaBRa3a.
100 Tschitaia G. Sur l'agriculture de montagne en Georige IIl];ORJI. COB. p:eJIeraqIIII Ha
VI Memp:YHap. Romp. aHTpOnOJIOI'OB II 3THOI'pa!f>oB. M., 1960.
tOI Debetz G. F. Certains aspects des transformations somatiques de I'Homo sapiens;
jJe6elj r. (/). 0 HeROTOpJ>IX HanpaBJIeHIIJIX II3MeHeHIIIT B cTpoeHlI1I 'leJIOBeRa cOBpeMeH-
HOI'O BIIp:a.
1U2 ll,e6elj r. (/). qeperra II3 3IIIma.rreOJIIITH'leCRoro MOTIIJII,HIIlm y c. BOJIOlilCROI'O II COb.
3THOI'pa!f>lIJI. 1955. ;N2 3.
103 KOHoynTopoea T. C. IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOI'II'leCKIIe MaTepIIaJIJ>I II3 Me30JIIITII'leCROrO MO-
rIIJII,HIIRa BaCIIJII,eBRa I II COB. aHTpOrrOJIOI'IIJI. 1957. ;N2 2; HnuMoe B. II. HaCeJIeHIIe
eBpOrreITCROIT 'laCTII CCCP B rr03p:HeM naJIeOJIIITe II Me30JIIITe II Borrp. aHTpOnOJIOI'IIII.
1961. Bbill. 7; rOxMaH 11. 11. HaCeJIeHIIe YRpaIlHI,I B 3rroxy Me30JIIITa II HeOJIIITa:
(AHTpOrrOJI. O'lepR). M., 1966.
t04 Childe V. G. The dawn of european civilization. London, 1950 (pyc. nep.: g au.ao r.
Y IICTOROB eBponeITCROIT l(IIBIIJIII3al(IIII. M., 1952).
105 rypulia H. H. OJIeHeOCTpOBCRIIIT J\fOrIIJII,HIIR II MaTepIIaJIJ>I II IICCJIep:oBaHIIJI rro apxeo-
JIOI'IIH CCCP. M.; JI., 1956. ;N2 47.
106 Schreiner K. E. Crania norvegica. Vol. II I/lnstituttet for sammentignende kulturfor-
skning. Ser. B. Vol. XXXVI, N 2. Oslo, 1946.
107 Retzius G. Crania suecica antiqua. Stockholm, 1900; Furst C. Zur Kraniologie der
schwedischen Stein zeit II Svenska Vetenskaps Akademie Handlingar. 1912. Vol. 49.
N 1; HnuMoe B. II. AHTpOnOJIOI'II'leCRIIe MaTepIIaJIJ>I II3 HeOJIIITII'leCKOrO MOI'IIJII,HIIRa
Ha IOmHoM OJIeHI,eM oCTpoBe II C6. MY3eH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII II 3THOI'pa!f>IIII AH CCCP.
M.; JI., 1960. T. 19.
108 Kuce.aee C. B. l];peBHJIJI IICTOplIJI IOmHoIT CII6IIpII. M., 1951.
109 Kpye.aoe A. II., lloozaeljnuu r. B. Pop:oBoe 06II(eCTBo cTerreii BOCTO'lHOii EBpOnI,I II
H3B. fAMMR. M.; JI., 1938. BI,m. 119. O'lepRII IICTOpIIH CCCP (rrepB06I,ITH006II(IIHHJ>IIT
CTpOJr II p:peBHeITIII:lIe I'ocYl1apCTBa). M., 1956.
110 C:\f. rrepe'lIICJIeHHI,m BI,IIlle pa60TJ>I no aHTpOrrOJIOI'IIII HaCeJIeHIIJI fpY:!lIII.
111 rUHa6ypz B. B. fOpHI,m Tap:mIIRII. M.; JI., 1937; 11zHaTbee M. B. CTaTIICTII'leCRIIe
ROHCTaHTl>I B 1I30JIIIpOBaHHOIT rronYJIJIl(IIII II AHTpOnOJI. mypH. 1937. ;N2 2; OH :JICe. Hc-
CJIep:oBaHIIJI no I'eHeTlI'leCRoMY aHamI3Y nonymIIl;IIii II Y'leH. 3arr. MfY. 1940. BJ>Irr. 34;
P02Ulicnuu H. H. 3aKoHOlIrepHoCTII npOCTpaHCTBeHHOI'O pacnpep:eJIeHIHI rpyrrn RpOillI
y 'leJIoBeRaIITp. HH-Ta 3THorpa!f>IIII AH CCCP. H.C. T. 1. M.; JI., 1947.
112 CBOp:Ry OI'pOll!:HOIT JIIITepaTYPJ>I rro 3TOMy Bonpocy CM.: Gates R. R. Human genetics.
N.Y., 1946. Vol. 1.
113 rapoaHoe B. K. Hapop:J>I l\aBRa3a II O'lepRII 06II(eii 3THOI'pa!f>IIII. A3IIaTCRaJI 'laCTI,
CCCP. M., 1960. C. 5-154; Hapop:I,I l\aBRa3a. M., 1960. T. 1.
114 HapTCRIIIT 3rroc. Opp:moHIIRIII13e, 1957.
115 A6aee B. 11. OceTIIHCRIIIT JI3bIK II !f>OJII,RJIOp. M.; JI., 1949. T. 1; 0 rrpOIIcxomp:eHIIII
OaJIKapl(eB H Impa'laeBl(eB: (;\-laTeplIaJIJ>I naY'lHOJr ceCCIIlI no npooJImre npOJIcxOJu ,e-
HliJI 6aJIRapCROI'O II Rapa'laeBCROI'O Hapop:oB). HaJII,'llIR, 1960.
116 jJe6elj r. (/)., JIeeuH M. r., TpoifJUMoea T. A. AHTpOrrOJIOI'II'leCRIIIT J\!:aTepIIaJI RaR IIC-
TO'lHIIK II3Y'leHIIH BonpocoB 3THOI'eHe3a II Te3I1CI,I COBeII(aHIIJI no MeTop:OJIOI'IIH 3THO-
I'eHeTII'leCKIIX lICCJIeiJ;OBaHIIIT. M., 1951; OHU :JICe. AHTpOnOJIOI'II'leCKIIIT MaTepIIaJI RaR
IICTO'lHIIR II3Y'leHIIJI BorrpocoB 3THOI'eHe3a II COB. 3THOI'pa!f>IIJI. 1952. ;N2 1; JIeeuH M. r.
::hHorpa!f>II'leCIDIe II aHTpOnOJIOI'lr'leCIDIe J\!:aTepIIaJIJ>I RaR IICTOpII'leCRIIIT IICTO'lHIIR (R
MeTop:OJIOrIIII II3Y'leHIIJI IICTOpIIII 6eCrrIICI,MeHHJ>IX Hapop:oB) II TaM me. 1961. ;N2 1.
117 Bacnanoe H. A. TIOpKcKIIe JI3I,mII. M., 1960; OpaHcnuu 11. M. BBep:eHIIe B IIpaHcRYIO
MII!f>OJIOI'IIIO. M., 1960.
118 Mu.a.aep Bc. (/). OceTIIHcKlIe 3TIOp:I,I. M., 1881-1887. tJ. I-III; jJ:JICaeaxuzueu.au H. A.
OCHOBHI,m IICTOpIIRO-3THOJIOI'II'leCRIIe np06JIeMH IICTOpIIH fPY3IIII, l\aBRa3a II BJIlIm-
HeI'O BocToKa p:peBHeiimeii 3rrOXII II BecTH. p:peBHeii IICTOpIIII. 1939. ;N2 4; A6aee B. 11.
OceTIIHCRIIIT JI3I,m II !f>OJII,RJIOp. T. 1.
U9 jJ:JICaeaxuzueu.au 11. A. OCHOBHJ>Ie IICTOpIIKO-3THOJIOI'II'leCKIIe rrp06JIeMH IICTOpIIII fpy-
311II, l\aBRa3a II BJIIImHerO BocToRa p:peBHeiiIIIeii 3rrOXII. C. 44.
:i
,I
ii
.j
315
I;
I
i.
I
120 Rona6aoae C. C. 0 TaK Ha3I,maeMI,IX «XeTCRO-1I6epIIHCKlIX» H3hIKax II Borrp. H3hIR03Ha-
HIIH. 1955. N2 4.
121 A6aee B. H. CRII<PCKlIH H3hIK, OCeTIIHCKIIH H3hIR II <pOJII,RJIOp. T. 1.
122 TaM me; Heccen A. A. HeKOTOpI,re rraMHTHIIKII VIII-VII BB. JIO H. 8. Ha CeBepHOM
l\aBKa3e /I BorrpOChI CKII<po-capMaTCKOH apXeOJIOrlIlI. M., 1952; Kpynnoe E. H. ,Z:(peB-
HHH IICTOplIH II RYJII,Typa l\a6aPJII,I. M., 1957; On 3/Ce. ,Z:(peBHHH IICTOplIH CeBepHoro
l\aBRa3a. M., 1960; 0 rroxoJIax cIm<poB 'Iepe3 3aImBRa3I,e CM.: Rpynnoe E. H. 0 rro-
xOJIax CKII<pOB 'Iepe3 KaBRa3/1 BorrpochI CKII<po-capMaTcKoII apXeOJIOrIIII; fluorpoe-
cnuu B. B. CRII<pI,I II JIpeBHIIH BOCTOR /I COB. apXeOJIOrIIH, 1954. T. 19; On 3/Ce. BaH-
CRoe I(apCTBo. M., 1959; pbRnon06 If. M. HCTOplIH MIIJIIIH. M.; JI., 1956.
123 Me./l,UnUm6U./l,U r. A. 0 npOIICXOmJIeHIIII rpY3IIHCRoro HapOJIa. T6IIJIIICII, 1952; Ou 3/Ce.
l\ IICTOplIII JJ;peBHeii: rpY31IlI. T6lIJIIIClI, 1959. .
124 IIx BceCTopOHHIOIO reorpa<pII'IeCRYIO xapaRTepIICTIIRY CM.: Bepz JI. C. reorpa<pII'IeCKlIe
30HI,I COBeTCRoro COI03a. M., 1952. T. 2.
125 JIaepoe JI. If. TIpolIcxOmJIeHlIe Im6aPJIIIHI(eB II 3aCeJIeHlIe IIMII HI,memHeH TepplITo-
pIIII /1 COB. 8Tnor}Ja<pIIH. 1956. M 1; U Ii Jlce. I1polIcxomAemre 6a"JI apI(en II Rapa'Iaen-
I(eB IIl\paT. co06lI(. HH-Ta 8THorpa<p1I1I AH CCCP. 1959. BhIrr. 32; On 3/Ce. 0 HeROTO-
pMX 8THorpacpU'IeCRIIX ,'];aHHbIX no Bonpocy npOllcxomp,eHIIH 6a'IRapl\eB II Kapa'Iaell-
l\eB /1 0 rrpoIIcxoaqcmm oammpi\cB II Rapa'IaeBI{en.
126 Morant G. M. Studies of palaeolithic man. Part IV: A biometric study of the upper
palaeolithic skull of Europe and of their relationship to earlier and later types //
Annales of eugenics. L., 1930. Vol. 4, pt. 1-11; Boule M., Vallois H. Lcs Hommes fos-
siles. P. 1952; Hnu.Moe B. II. HaCeJIeHlIe eBponeHcRoH 'IaCTII CCCP B n03)J;HeM naJIeo-
JIIITe II Me30JIIITe.
127 pe6elJ r. llJ. TIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlIH CCCP; On 3/Ce. COBpeMeHHoe COCTOHHlIe rraJIeOaH-
TpOrrOJIOrIPIeCKIIX HCCJIeJIOBaHIIH B CCCP II Te3. )J;OKJI. Ha cec. OTA. IICT. HaYR II IIJIe-
HyMa HH-Ta IICTOplI1I MaTeplIaJII,HOH RYJII,TyphI. M.; JI., 1956; On 3/Ce. OCHOBHI,re IITorII
rraJIeOaHTporrOJIOrII'IeCKlIX IICCJIeJIOBaHIIH B CCCP /I ,Z:(mm. COB. JIeJIeral\1I1I Ha V Mem-
JIYBap. Romp. aHTporrOJIOroB II 8THorpa<pOB. M., 1956.
128 pe6elJ r. llJ. TIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIH CCCP.
129 A./l,enCee6 B. II. IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlIH AJITae-CaHHCKoro HarOpI,H 8nOXII HeOJIIITa II
6pOH3M II AHTpOnOJIOrIPIeCKlIH C60PHlIR, III. M., 1961. (Tp. IIH-Ta 8THorpa<p1I1I AH
CCCP. H. C.; T. 21).
130 Hnu.Moe B. II. Ha'IaJII,HI,re 8TarrM 3aCeJIeHlIH BOCTO'IHOH TIplI6aJITIIKII /I Tp. HH-Ta
8THorpa<p1I1I AH CCCP. H. C. T. 32. M., 1956; On 3/Ce. 0 JIpeBHeH !>IOHrOJIOIIJJ;HOCTII B
EBpone IIl\paT. co06lI(. HH-Ta 8THOrpa<p1II1 AH CCCP. BMrr. 28, 1957. On 3/Ce. roplI-
30HTaJII,HaH rrpo<pIIJII1poBaHHOCTI, JIIII{eBOro oTJIeJIa 'Ieperra Y cOBpeMeHHI,IX II JIpeBHIlX
JIIOJIeii: II Borrp. aHTpOnOJIOrlIlI. 1960. BI,m. 4; On 3/Ce. rOplI30HTaJII,HaH npo<pIIJIIIpoBaH-
HOCTI, JIIII{eBOrO 'Iepena Y COBpeMeHHI,IX II JIpeBHlIx JIIOJIeH /I Acta facultatis rerum na-
turalium universItatIs comenianac. Bratislava, 1961. T. V. Fasc. III-IV; By/wn B. I].
qepen 'IeJIOBeKa II CTaJIlI1I ero <pOpMHpoBaHIIH Y IICKorraeMMX JIIOJIei! n co peMeHHI,IX
pac; lI,yu TJ en-Ro. ,Z:(aHHI,re rro roplI30HTaJII,HOH rrpo<pIIJIlIpOBaHHOCTII JIIII{eBoro CReJIe-
Ta IICKonaeMMX JIIOJIeH /I Borrp. aHTpOnOJIOrIIII. 1960. BMrr. 1.
131 A./l,eliCeC6 B. II. ITpouCXOiK;J,eHue naPO'rOB KallRa3a.
132 pe6elJ r. llJ. TIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrrm CCCP.
133 TaM me; A./l,enceee B. fl., BeC./l,enOe6a R. X. KpaHIIOJIOrlI'IeCKaH xapaRTeplICTIIKa cpeJI-
HeneROBoro HaCeJIeHIIR OceTuII II MaTepIIaJIM H lICCJIegonaHIIH no apXeOJIOrIIII CCCl'.
M., 1963. M 114.
134 Mun./l,ameeCnaR H. H. HOBI,re rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRlIe MaTeplIaJIM C TepplIToplIII ,Z:(a-
reCTaHa; Ona 3/Ce. AHTpOIJOJIOrII'IeCKIIH COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIH l];arecTaHa B aJIaHO-Xa3ap-
CKoe Bpel'>IH; KaCU.M06a P. M. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCROe IICCJIep;OBaHIIe 'IeperrOB 1I3 MIIHre-
'Iaypa (B cnH3II C II3Y'IeHlIeM 8THoreHe3a a3ep6ai!:p;maHcRoro Hapop;a).
135 A./l,enceee B. II. TIpolIcxomp;eHlIe Hapop;oB l\aBKa3a.
136 RaCU.M06a P. M. AHTpOnOJIOrn'IeCROe IICCJIep;OBaHIIe 'IepenOB II3' MIIHre'Iaypa...
137 pe6elJ r. llJ. TIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIH CCCP; Bynan B. B. qeperra 1I3 CKJIenOB ropHoro
l\aBRa3a B cpaBHIITeJII,HO-aHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCROM OCBelI(eHIIII.
138 M. r. A6AyrneJIlImBlIJIlI rrpep;OCTaBIIJI B MOl' pacrropHmeHlIe CBOII Heony6JIIIKOBaHHMe
iI3MepemIH ,.noro 'Iepena, 3a 'ITO rrpIIHOIny eMY rJIy60KYIO 6JIarOp;apHOCTI,. TI03me 'Ie-
pen 6MJI orrlIcaH: CM.: p3/Ca6aXUm6U./l,U 9. H. HOBaH naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCKaH HaxOP;-
1m B fpY3IIII II Tp. HH-Ta ,:mcnepIIM. !>IOP<POJIOrlIlI AH rccp. T6IIJIIICII, 1964. T. 11.
139 Xapaoae P. JI. l\ Borrpocy 0 TeppIITOplIaJII,HO-o6lI(IIHHI,LX OO'bep;IIHeHIIHx y rpY3IIH-
ropI(eB IIl\paT. co06lI(. MH-Ta 8THorpa<p1I1I AH CCCP. 1958. Bbm. 29. Bce CKa3aHHoe
3p;eCI, II p;aJII,me 06 apXaII'IeCKOH KYJII,Type ropCRIIX Hapop;OB OTHOCIITCH R p;OpeBOJIIO-
I{IIOHHOMY rrpOIIIJIOMY.
140 p3/Canouepu 111. If., JIeJICaea r. H. ApxlITeRTypa ropHoH rpY31I1I. M., 1940; Po6anufJ-
ae A. If. HOBI,re 'IepTI,I cOBpeMeHHoro rpY3lIHCKoro RpeCTI,HHCHOro mlIJIIIlI(a 11 COB.
316
3THorpa!f>IIJI. 1961. ;N!! 1; On 3/Ce. mlIJUIrn;e H HaCeJIeHHe ropn;eB fPY3HH B npOIIIJIOM H
HaCTOJIrn;eI\I II I{p1<T. coo6rn;. MH-Ta 3THorpa!f>rlH All CCCP. 1!:J62. BblIL 36.
141 Bupca.!Laoae E. B. M3 HCTOpHH OXOTHll'IberO 3IIoca B fPY3IIII II l\paT. coo6rn;. MH-Ta
3THorpa!f>IIII AH CCCP. 1958. BbIII. 29.
11.2 JlHTepaTypa 0 ropHLlX 3THorpa!f>H'IeClmX rpyIIIIax rpY3HHCRoro Hapop;a H Hapop;HOCTHX
3aIIap;Horo l];arecTaHa orpOMHa. CM., Hanp. KOea.!Le6CnUU B. CTpaHa CHerOB n 6aIIIeH
(CBaHHJI). JI., 1930; Mana.!LaTuR C. ll. II3 CTaporo Hapop;Horo 6bITa IIIIIaBOB II COB.
3THorpa!f>HJI. M., JI., 1938. T. 1; On 3/Ce. XeBcypeTII: (JilCT.-aTHorp. O'lepI{
p;OpeBOJIIOn;rIOIlHoro ObIT a xeBCYPOB). T6IIJIHCH, 1940; .llanen JI. B. C.,lC-
P;bI pop;oBoro CTpOJI Y MTHYJIOB II COB. 3THorpa!f>HJI. M., JI., 1939. T. 2; Ona 3/Ce. COn;H-
aJIbHbIe OTIIOllieHIIJI MTHYJIOB II l\paT. cooorn;. IIH-Ta 3THorpa!f>HlI AH CCCP. 1946.
BbIII. 1; Hapop;bI KaBIill3a.
g3 CTyoeneljnaR E. H. l\ BOIIPOCY 0 !f>eop;aJIII3Me II paocTBe B l\apa'Iae XIX B. (IIO He-
ROTOpbIM apxHBHbIM j],oRYMeHTa:u) II COB. 3THorpa!f>HH. 1937. J\1! 2, 3; JIa6po6 JI. 11.
M3 rroe3j],Im B 13a;mapHIO II TaM IRe. M.; JI., 1939. T. 2. KOea.!Le6CnUU M. Jl. COBpe:ueH-
HbIH 06bI'IaH n p;peBHHH 3aROH. 06:wlHoe npaBo oceTHH B HCTOpHRo-cpaBHHTeJILHOM
oCBern;eHIIII. M., 1886. T. 1, 2.
II.!. Mapp H. H. fp;e cOXpaHHJIOCb CBaHCRoe CRJIOHeHHe? II II3B. AH. CTI6., 1911; On 3/Ce.
3aHMcTBoBaHHe 'IHCJIHTeJIbHbIX B JI!f>eTH'IeCIUlX JI3bIRaX II II3B. AH. CTIo., 1913; On 3/Ce.
II3 Iloe3p;OK B CnaHHIO (JIeTOM 1911 II 19121'1'.) iiXpHcTHaHcRH1' BOCTOR. T. II. BbIIT. 1;
CIIo., 1913; On 3/Ce. TIJIeMeHHOH COCTaB HaCeJIeHHJI l\aBKa3a IITp. l\OMHC. no H3yq.-
nJIeMeIlHoro COCTana. TIr., 1920. BbIIl. 14. no rJIOTTOXpOHOJIOrH'leCRoMY MeTop;y OTXOJR-
p;eHHe CBaHCRoro OT rpY3Hno-ranclwro ep;HHCTBa iJ,aTHpyeTCJI He II03p;nee 'IeM Iwn-
n;OM III - Ha'1aJIOIIJ II TbICJI'IeJIeTIIJI ,'.\0 H. 3. CIvr.: K.!LUMOe A. l'. 0 rJIOTTOXpOHOJIO-
rH'IeCKOM MeTop;e p;aTHpOBKH pacnap;a npaJI3bJRa II BOIIp. H3bIR03HaHIIJI. 1959. N2 2.
g5 TJ apaR If. 06 OTHomeHIIII a6xa3CRoro H3bIRa K n!f>eTII'IeCRIIM II MaTepIIaJIbI no JI!f>e-
TH'IeCROMY JI3bIR03HaHlIIO. CTI6., 1912. T. IV; Mapp H. H. l\ BOIIpOCy 0 IIOJIOIReHlIJI
a6xa3clwro H3bIRa cpep;H H!f>eTH'IeCRHX II TaM IRe. CTIo., 1912. T. V; Oil, 3/Ce. II3 JIIIHr-
BHCTH'IecROH nOe3p;RJI B Aoxa3IIIO (R 3THOJIOrH'IeCRJIM BOIIpocaM) II H3B. AH. CII6.,
1913; On 3/Ce. A6xa30Bep;eHHe H aoxa3bI (R BOIIPOCY 0 npoJICXOIRp;eHHH a6xa30B H 3T-
HorOHIIII BOCTO'IHOH EBpOIIbI) II BOCTO'IHbIH C60PHHR. JI., 1926. T. 1.
g6 Mapp H. H. H!f>eTII'IeCRIIe 3JIeMeHTbI B JI3bIRax ApIv!:eHHH, IV II II3B. AH. CTI6., 1911;
On 3/Ce. Ty6aJI-RaHHCRIIH BRJIap; L CBaHCROM I I TaM IRe. CTI6., 1912; On 3/Ce. II3 noe3p;OR
B CBaHHIO; Oil, 3/Ce. l\ p;aTe 3MHrpan;HH MOCOXOB H3 ApMeHHH B CBaHHIO II II3B. AH.
CTIo., 1916; Op6e.!Lu ll. A. ropop; 6JIlI3Hen;OB «]J,HocRypHap;a}) n IIJIeMJI B03HHn; «xeHHO-
XII}} II JJ\MIIIT. CHa., 1911; .}Je.!LUnUUl6UJlU l'. A. K RCTOpIIII ApeBHeij rpY3HH.
g7 A6aee B. ll. OceTHHcRIIe 3THH'IeCRlIe TepMHHbI iron, allon II H!f>eTH'IeCKIIH C60PHlIR.
JI., 1927. T. 5; On 3/Ce. l\ xapaRTepHCTHRe COBpeIv!:eHHoro oceTHHCRoro JI3bIRa II H!f>e-
Tll'IeCRlIli. JI., 1932. T., OH ;ilce. [Ioe3.r\T>3 I{ BepXOBbJIl\1 Ky6aHII, 13a!\cana II
qepeRa II H3bIK II MbIIIIJIeHHe. JI., 1933. T. 1; On 3/Ce. 0 JI3bIRe IOmHbIX OCeTIlH II H3bIRl!
CeBepHoro l\anRa3a H ]J,arecTaHa. M.; JI., 1935. T. 1; Oil, 3/Ce. 0 B3aHMOOTHOllIeHHH
HpaHcRoro H RaBRa3CRoro 3JIeIv!:eHTa B oceTHHCROM II OceTHHCRJIH JI3bIR JI !f>OJIbRJIOp.
T. 1; Oil, 3/Ce. TIponcxomp;eHHe H RYJIbTypHoe npOIIIJIOe oceTHH no p;aHHbIM H3bIRa II
TaM IRe. CM. TaRIRe: Mapp H. H. Ossetica-Japhetica II M3B. AH TIr., 1918.
gB A6ae6 B. ll. TIoe3p;Ra B CBaHeTHIO II TaM me.
g9 Oil, 3/Ce. 3Ha'IeHlIe JI IIpOHcxomp;eHHe CJIOBa allu-ton II Tall! me; Oil, 3/Ce. 3Ha'IeHJIe H
npoIIcxomp;eHHe CJIOBa rong II TaM me. CM. TaRIRe: Tanoeea H. W. II3 JICTOpHH oce-
TIIHCRoro ropHoro mHJIFlrn;a I I COB. 3THorpa!f>HH. 1952. ;N!! 3.
150 l(b 2ae6aA. W. 113 TOIlOHIunIKH H rHp;pOHIUnIl>H 3alia):\Hoii Ocenm i1113B. CeB.-OceT.
HaY'I.-nCCJIep;. HH-Ta. OPP;IROHHRHp;3e, 1960. T. 22, BbIn. 1.
151 Bopoenoe A. K. l\apa'IaeBO-OaJIRapCRHH JI3bIR II H!f>eTH'IeCRIIH C60PHHR. JI., 1932. T. 7;
Oil, 3/Ce. O'Jepm! Kapa'laeBO-6aJIRapCKOlf rpaMlIlaTHlm II JI3bIRH CenepHoro l\alJRa3a II
]J,arecTaHa. JI., 1935. T. 1; Bacnanoe H. A. l\JIaCcH!f>HRan;HJI TIOpRcKnx JI3bIROB B CBJI-
3H C HCTOpII'IeCROH nepHOp;H3an;:rreH HX pa3BHTHJI H !f>opMHpOBaHlIJI II Tp. IIH-Ta H3bI-
R03HaHHJI AH CCCP. M., 1952. T. 1; Oil, 3/Ce. TIOpRcRHe JI3bIRH.
152 Bacnano6 H. .A. BbICTVIIJIeIme Ha HayqHolI ceCCHH IIO IIpOOJIel\m IIpOIICXOIR}J;eHIIJI
OaJIRapCKOro H Rapa'Ia"eBCRoro Hapop;OB II 0 npOHcxomp;eHIIH 6aJIRapn;eB H Rapa'iaeB-
n;eB; CaTTaee A. X. TIpoHcxomp;eHHe OaJIRapn;eB H Rapa'IaeBn;eB no p;aHHbIM JI3bIRa II
TaM me.
,53 OUROp cyrn;eCTBYIOrn;IIX rIIIlOTe3 CIvr.: JIaunaHo6 X. n. l\ HCTOpHII Rapa'IaeBn;eB II oa.rr-
Rapn;eB. qepReccK, 1959; JIa6poe JI. ll. TIpoHcxoSKp;eHIIe 6aJIRapn;eB H Rapa'IaeBn;eB.
151. A.!LenCee6 B. If. HeROTopbIe np06JIeMbI npOHCXOIRp;eHIIJI 6aJIRapn;eB H Rapa'IaeBn;eB B
CBeTe p;aHHbIX aHTpOnOJIOrHH.
155 A6ae6 B. ll. 06 aJIaHCROM cy6cTpaTe B 6aJIKapO-Rapa'IaeBCROIl! JI3bIRe II 0 npOHCXOIR-
p;eHHH OaJIRapn;eB H Rapa'IaeBn;eB; A.!Lenceeea E. n. HeROTOpbIe 3aMe'IaHHJI no Bonpocy
npOHcxomp;eHIIH 6aJIRapn;eB H Rapa'IaeBn;eB no p;aHHhIM apXeOJIOrHH.
,:
-.
317
I
I
156 A.ae1\:ceee B. JI. HeKOTOpLle IIpo6JIeMLI IIpOlIcxomp;eHIUI 6aJIKapn;eB II Kapa'laeBn;eB B
CBeTe p;aHHbIX aHTpOIIOJIOI'lIII.
157 JIaepoe JI. H. PacceJIeHlIe CBaHOB Ha CeBepHOM l\aBKaae p;o XIX BeKa IIl\paT. C006ID;.
MH-Ta <JTHorpa!f>1I1I AH CCCP. 1950. BLlII. 10.
158 Mapp H. H. BammpO-CBaHCKoe CKpeID;eHl.Ie IIl];oKJI. AH CCCP. 1929; A6aee B. H.
06ID;lIe <JJIeMeHTLI B JIabIKe oceTIIH, 6ammpn;eB II KapaqaeBn;eB II HabIK II MIillllJIeHlIe.
JI., 1933. T. 1.
159 Mu.a.aep M. rI>. TepCKaJI 06JIaCTb (apxeoJIOrlJ1IeCKl.Ie 3KCKypCIIII) II MaTepl.IaJILI IIO ap-
xeOJIorlI1.I l\aBKaaa. M., 1888. BbIII. 1. C. 79; JIaepoe JI. H. PaCCeJIeHl.Ie CBaHOH Ha Ce-
BepHOM KaBKaae XIX BeKa.
160 Po6anuoiJe A. H. K BOIIPOCY 0 !f>opMe IIOCeJIeHIIJI B CBaHeTIIH II KpaT. C006ID;. IIH-Ta
3THorpa!f>HH AH CCCP. 1958. BLlII. 29; Po6anuoiJe A. If. XapaoiJe P. JI. l\ Borrpocy 0
cBaHcKo-GaJIKapcKIIX <JTHOKYJIbTYPHbIX HaalDIOOTIIOIIIeHIUlX II 0 IIpoIIcxomgeHIIII 6aJI-
KapI(eB II ImpaqaeBI eB.
161 To.acroe C. ll. OqepKII lIepBOHaqaJILHOro HCJIa)Ta II COB. 3THorpa!f>HJI. 1932. 2; Ou
:!ICe. 8THorpa!f>HJI II cOBpeMeHHocTL II TaM me. 1946. 1; JIeeuu M. r., lJ e6onca-
poe H. H. XOaJIllCTBeHHo-KYJILTypHLle THIILI II IIcTopmw-<JTHorpa!f>IIqeCKIIe 06JIaCTH II
TaM me. 1955. 4; Bpyn C. H., KOiJ.aoe B. H., JIeeuu M. r. 0 IIpep;l\!:eTe H aap;aqax
3THoreorpa!f>HII /I TeaHcLI p;OKJIap;OB Ha aacep;aHIIHx, IIOCBJIID;eHHbIX IITOraM IIOJIeBbIX
IICCJIe;:10BaHllir, 1961 r. M., 19f)2.
162 Yeapo6a ll. C. TIoeap;Ka B TImaBHID, XeBcypeTHID H CBaHeTHID II MaTepHaJILI no apxeo-
JIorHH KaBKaaa. M., 1904. T. 10; pezen-Koea.aeecnuu B. E. l\ HCTOplIH meJIeaHOrO IIpO-
lIaBOp;CTBa 3aKaBKaabH (IIO MaTepHaJIaM paCKorrOK qy6epcKoll meJIeaOIIJIaBIIJIbHII-
B. CBaHIIH) II MaB. rAIIMK M.; JI., 1935. Bm.I. 120; Heccen A. 11. l\ BOIIPOCY 0 p;peB-
Hell MeTaJIJIyprIIH Mep;H Ha KaBKaae II TaM me; Mana.aaruR, C. H. XeBcypeTH.
APEBHEfIIIIEE EBPOIIEOMAHOE HACEJIEHME
CPEAHEfI A3MM II ErO IIOTOMH'M
OB30P rllTIOTE3 TIPOIICXOm):(EHIIH
TIAMIIPO-(])EPr AHCl\OH P ACbI
I10CJIe pa60T A. ]II. H pXO II JI. B. OillaHIIHa B Cpei'J;HeM A3IIII 6paxIIRe<paJIb-
HbIe eBpOneOII.D;bI, B COCTaBe ROTOpbIX <pIIRcIIpyeTcH IIHor.a;a n03,L(HHH Mon-
rOJIOII.D;HaH npIIMeCb - Y36eRII II Ta,L(llirIRII, 6bIJIII BbI.D;eJIeHbI B caMOCTOH-
1'eJIbHYIO eL\IIHIIn;y pacoBoll CIICTeMaTIIRII, nOJIyqIIBllYIO HaIIMeHOBaHIIC
naMIIpo-<pepraHCRoll pacbI I IIJIII paCbI Cpe,L(Hea3IIaTCRorO Melli.D;ypeqbH 2. llo
Mepe .a;aJIbHellillero HaROnJIeHIIH MaTepIIaJIOB no alITpOnOJIOrIIII Cpe.a;Hell
A3IIII ee caMOCTOHTeJIbHOe nOJIOmeHIIe B pacoBoll RJIaCcII<pIIRan;IIII HallJIO
MHorORpaTHoe nO.D;TBepm,L(eHIIe II B HaCTOHIl(ee BpeMH npaRTIIqeCRII He BbJ3bI-
lJaeT COMHeHIIH 3. OL\HaRO npOlIcxom.a;eHIIe ROMnJIeRCa np1I3HaROB 9TOll paCbI
Bce eID;e CJIymIIT npe,L(MeTOM .D;IICRyCCIIII, Be.D;yID;ellCH BORpyr HeCROJIbRIIX
rIInOTe3.
1. llpe.D;CTaBIITeJIII naMIIpo-<pepraHCROll paCbI - npeIIMYID;eCTBeHHO no-
TOMRII aH.D;pOHOBn;eB, nO,L(BeprlllIeCH rpan;IIJIII3an;IIII II 6paXIIRe<paJIII3an;IIII 4.
llplI RpIITIIRe 9TOll TOqRII 3peHlIH YRa3bIBaJIOCb Ha BeCbMa 3HaqIITeJIbHYIO
BepOH1'IIOCTb CpaBHII1'eJIbHO CBeTJIOll nIIrMeHTan;UII y aH,L(pOHOBn;eB, qTO BbI-
HBJIHeTCH MaTepIIaJIaMII no aHTpOnOJIOrIIII COBpeMeHHbIX Ra3aXOB 5. TeMHYIO
nIIrMeHTan;IIIO Y36eROB II TaL\mlIROB TPY,L(HO 06'bHCHIITb, eCJIII .a;onYCTIITb 0'1'-
HOCIITeJIbHYIO CBeTJIOrJIa30C1'b II CBeTJIOBOJIOCOCTb .D;peBHero aHL\pOHOBCRoro
HaCeJIeHIIH.
2. ¥ 36eRII II Ta.D;mIIRII - lICROHHbJe npe.a;CTaBIITeJIIf cpe.a;1I3eMHoMopCROi:'J
paCbI, nOTOMRII .D;peBHero Te IHomlrMeHTIIpOBaHHoro II .a;OJIIIXORpaHHoro
HaCeJIeHlIH 6. ¥BeJIlIqeHIIe qepenHOro yRa3aTeJIH na.a;aeT Ha nOCJIeL\HlIe 1'bICH-
qeJIeTIIH. Ho :wa rIInOTe3a He MomeT y.a;OBJIeTBOpIITeJIbHO 06'bHCHIITb nOCTe-
318
neHHbIii: II npOCJIemlIBaeMbIll qaCTO C 60m:'lloM HCHOCTbIO nepeXO.D; 0'1' aHTpO-
nOJIOrIIqeCKHX OC06eHHOCTeM HaCeJIeHIIH aHL\pOHOBCROM RYJIbTYPbI R aHTpOnO-
JIOrIIqeCROMY TIIny 3aXOpOHeHHbIX B TaR Ha3bIBaeMbIX caRCKIIX II YCYHbCRIIX
norpe6eHIIHX Ha TeppIITopIIH Ka3aXCTaHa. 1l0cJIe.D;HlIe RpaHIIOJIOrHqeCRII noq-
TII HeOTJIlIqlIMbI 0'1' COBpeMeHHbIX Y36eRoB.
3. llpeL\CTaBlITeJIII naMlIpo-<pepraHcRoM pacbI - HaCeJIeHlIe, aHTpOnOJIOrII-
qeCRlIll TIIn ROToporo 06pa30BaJICH nOA BJIIIHHIIeM 060IIX <paRTopOB - rpa II-
JI1I3an;IIlI ,L(peBHero aH,L(pOHOBCRoro HaCeJIeH:IIH II 6paxIIRe<paJIII3an;lIH .D;peBHIIX
cpeAII3eMHOMOpn;eB 7.
06e yRa3aHHbIe B nYHRTax 1 II 2 TPY.D;HOCTII 3aCTaBIIJIII HCRaTb 06ID;ee
Mem.D;Y nepe IIICJIeHHbIMII rIInOTe3aMH II B ROH e ROH OB npIIHHTb HX nOqTH
Ha O,L(IIHaROBblX OCHOBaHIIHX. O.D;HaRO B TaROll <popMe IIX 06'beAlIHeHIIH HeT
BHYTpeHHero eAIIHCTBa, ClIHTe3 9TOT OCHOBbIBaeTCH Ha TeOpeT:IIqeCROll npeA-
nOCbIJIRe, nORa eID;e Tpe6YIOID;ell .D;ORa3aTeJIbCTBa,- pa3HbIe no xapaI Tepy H
TeMny <popMo06pa3YIOID;IIe npOn;eCCbI npIIBOAHT R O.D;IIHaROBOMy pe3YJIbTaTY.
llpH paCCMOTpeHlIII npOIICXomL\eHIIH OTAeJIbHbIX rpynn, BXO.D;HID;IIX B COCTaB
naMIIpo-<pepraHcRoll paCbI, HCHO, '1'1'0 B O.D;HOM CJIyqae npe06JIaAaJI OD,HH npo-
n;ecc, B .D;pyroM - .D;pyroll. CJIOmHaH np06JIeMa BbI60pa Mem.D;y ,L(BYMH rIIno-
Te3aMII, CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, OCTaeTCH, HO nepeBO.D;IITCH Ha 60JIee HH3RIIll TaRCOIIO-
MHqeCRIIll ypOBeHb, TOJIbRO 11 Bcero.
4. qIICTbIMII :II HaII60JIee xapaRTepHbIMII npe.D;CTaBIITeJIHMII naMlIpo-<pep-
raHcRoM paCbI HBJIHIOTCH He Y36eRH, a Ta,L(mIIRII II HapO,L(HOCTII llaMlIpa 8.
B COCTaBe Y36eROB OHa npeACTaBJIeHa yme B CMellaHHOM BlI.D;e. llpOIIcxomAe-
HlIe ee BOCXOAIIT R .D;peBHellilleMY lIHAoeBponellCROMY, a MomeT 6bITb, Aame R
,L(OIIHAoeBponellCROMY HaCeJIeHIIIO CpeL\Hell A31IH. CY,L(H rro TOMY, '1'1'0 .LIpeB-
HellllIIe ,L(OJIlIXORpaHHbIe ceplIII C TeppIIToplIII CpeD,Hell II llepeAHell A31III CO-
IIOCTaBJIHIOTCH C Mop<p0JIOrlIqeCRIIM TIInOM TypRMeH, MomHO ,L(YMaTb, '1'1'0 aB-
TOp CqlITaeT 6panme<paJIHIO naMlIpo-<pepraHn;eB L\peBHIIM 06pa30BaHIIeM. Ho
npHMo 06 9TOM He rOBoplITCH, II BCH rIInOTe3a celf'Iac, nOCJIe HaROnJIeHlIH 06-
lllIpHbIX naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIX MaTeplIaJIOB no .D;peBHeMY HaCeJIeHIIIO
Cpe,L(Hell A3IIlI, BblrJIHL\lIT He,L(OCTaTOqHO ROImpeTHoll.
5. llpe,L(CTaBlITeJIlI naMIIpo-<pepraHcRoll paCbI - lICROHHbIe 6paxIIRe<paJIbI,
coxpaHHIOID;lIe 9TY oc06eHHOCTb C rJIy60Roll .D;peBHocTlI, B03MomHO, C 9nOXII
6pOH3bI, a TO II HeOJIIITa 9. TaROll B3rJIHA Ha npoIIcxomAeHIIe naMIIpo-<pep-
raHn;eB TaRme BbIrJIHL\HT YM03plITeJIbHbIM, TaR RaR IIpOTIIBOpeqlIT naJIeOaHT-
pOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIM .D;aHHbIM, - Bce 6paXlIRe<paJIbHbIe cepIIII 9nOXlI 6POH3bI npo-
IICXO.D;HT 113 MOrIIJIbHIIROB, paCnOJIOmeHHbIX ,L(aJIeRO 3a npeAeJIaMII Cpe,'J;Hell
A31I1I. CIIen;II<pIIqeCROe pO.D;CTBO naMIIpo-<pepraHn;eB C APyrHMII 6paXIII e<paJIb-
HbIMH BapHaHTaMII B COCTaBe Cpe.D;H3eMHOMopCROll BeTBII eBpOneOII.D;OB, Ha-
nplIMep C apMeHOII,L(aMII, npII3HaHIIe ROToporo JIOrIIqeCRII BbITeRaeT 1I3 9'1'011
rIInOTe3bI, TaRme He AORa3aHo.
I I
i
I I
f,
II
MOPfl>OJlOrllqECKIIE OTJlJIqIlH TIAMIIPCKIIX HAPO.n;OB
OT Y3BEKOB II T Al];jKIIKOB
Bce nepeqlICJIeHHbIe rIInOTe3bI 06'be.D;IIHHeT npII3HaHlIe e.D;HHCTBa aHTpOnOJIO-
rIIqeCROrO TIIna Y36eRoB, TaAm:IIROB H naMIIpcRlIX HapO.D;OB. Pa3JIlIqIIH MemAY
HIIMII CBO,L(HTCH TOJIbRO R pa3Holl llOJIe MOHrOJIOIID;HOro ROMnOHeHTa B COCTaBe
Y36eRoB, C OAHOll CTOpOHbI, :II naMlIpn;eB - C L\pyrOll. B RaqeCTBe 9TaJIOHa '111-
CTbIX npe.D;CTaBIITeJIeII naMIIpo-<pepraHcRoII pacbI <prrrypIIPYIOT 06blqHO rOpHbIe
TaL\mIIRII 1I naMIIpn;bI, B COCTaBe ROTOpbIX MOHrOJIOII,L(HaH nplIMecb npaKTlI'Ie-
CRII OTCYTcTByeT. M. IIIBIIL\en;RaH II 10. r. PbIqROB npHMO nIIllYT 06 9TOM.
Y ,L(pyrIIx lIcCJIeAOBaTeJIeM 9Ta MbICJIb nOL\pa3YMeBaeTcH.
319
,IJ;JIH npOBepR:II ee COnOCTamIM naMUpn;eB :II Y36eROB no OCHOBHbIM rrp:II-
BHaRaM, nOJIb3YHCb CHa'IaJIa RpaHIIOJIOrHqeCRIIM:II MaTepIIaJIaMH. llaM:IIpn;bI
rrpe,L(CTaBJIeHbI ,L(aHHbIM:II no ,L(BYM rpynnaM, nO-B:II,L(:IIMOMy, cepe,IJ;IIHbI II TbI-
CHqeJIeTIIH H. 9.- IIllRallHMn;aM :II HaCeJIeHHIO rOpaHa, rOBopm:n;eMY Ha 6a-
p;aXllaHCROM JJ;IIaJIeRTe Ta,L(iRHRCROro H3bIRa 10; ,L(aHHbIe no RpaHIIOJIOrIIH Y3-
6eROB B3HTbI :II3 CBO,L(HOll CTaTbII B. B. rIIH36ypra 11 (Ta6JI. 21, 22). B Ta6-
JI:IIn;bI He BRJIIOqeHbI onnCaTeJIbHbIe xapaRTepIICTIIRII peJIbe<pa 'Iepena, a TaR-
me BeJIH IHHbI yrJIOB HaRJIOHa JI6a, H60 OHII ,L(aIOT He O IeHb cpaBHIIMbIe 1I
n03TOMY He OqeHb 06 eRTIIBH:bIe pe3YJIbTaT:bI. Ho no CRYJIOBOMy .D;:IIaMeTpy
OqeBH,L(HbI CYID;eCTBeHHbIe pa3JIIIqIIH Mem,L(Y Y30eRaMH H naMHpn;aMH, CBIIp,e-
TeJIbCTBYIOID;IIe 0 MaCCIIBHOCTII JIHn;eBOro CReJIeTa Y nepBbIX no cpaBHeHIIIO co
BTOpbIl\III. 81'0 nO,L(TBepm,L(aeTCH II BeJIII IIIHaMII BepxHeII BbICOTbI JIIIn;a, 3aMeT-
HO 60JIblllIMII B Y36eRCRIIx cepIIHX. Pa3MepbI qepena, oc06eHHO B BbICOTY,
Y rraMHpn;eB B n;eJIOM TaRllie l'.IeHblllIe. HOCOBbIe ROCTH B nal'.II[pCRJ1X cepIIHX
BblcTynaIOT CHJIbHee, JIHn;eBOll CReJIeT 60JIee np0<pIIJIIIpoBaH. TaRIIM 06pa30M,
naMIIpn;bI rpan;lIJIbHee Y36eRoB H Bce npH3HaRII eBpOneOII,L(Holl paCbI Bblpame-
HbI y HIIX ropa3.D;0 60JIee OTqeTJIIIBO.
Ha nepBbIII B3rJIH.D; MomeT nORa3aTbCH, qTO peqb :II,L(eT 0 npII3HaRax, CBH-
3aHHbIX IICTOpH IeCROll ROppeJIHn;IIeM, TaR RaR II3BeCTHO, ITO Bce cH6npCR:IIe :II
n;eHTpaJIbHOa3HaTCRIIe MOHrOJIOII,L(bI OTJIIlqaIOTCH MaCCIIBHbIM CTpoeHIIeM. Bce
.D;aHHbIe no aHTpOnOJIOrHII Cpe,L(Hell A3HII II no 3THII IeCROll IICTOpIIII cpep,He-
a3HaTCRIIX HapO,L(OB COrJIaCOBaHHO rOBopHT, '1'1'0 B COCTaB Y36eRoB BOilleJI MOH-
rOJIOII,L(HbIll ROl'.IIIOHeHT n;eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTcRoro npOHCXOm,L(eJUIH 12. Ho n;eHT-
paJIbHOa3HaTCRIIe MOHrOJIOII,L(bI, pe3RO 6paxIIRe<paJIbHbI 1I HII3ROrOJIOBbL Mea -
,L(y TeM II3 qeTblpex HaXO,L(HID;HXCH B HailleM pacnopmI\eHIIII Y36eRcRIIx cepHII
.D;Be 60.rree ,L(JIHHHOrOJIOBbI, qeM naMnpCRIle, HeCMOTpJI Ha HBHoe YBeJIIlqeHne
,L(OJIII MOHrOJIOII,L(HOII paCbI B IIX COCTaBe. BblcoTa qepenHOll Rop06RII y 60JIee
eBpOneOII,L(HbIX naMIIpn;eB ORa3bIBaeTCH HHme, qeM Y Y36eRoB. TaRIIM 06pa-
30M, RpaHIIOJIOI'll IeCROe cpaBHeHHe nORa3bIBaeT, ITO pa3JIIIqHH Memp,y Y36e-
l\aMII II naMIIpCRIIMII HapO,L(aMH He CBO,L(HTCH TOJIbRO R MOHrOJIOII,L(HOll npHMe-
CII y Y3ueROB. 1l0-BlI,L(IIMOMY, B COCTaB naMlIpn;eB BOilleJI lIHOll eBpOneOII.D;HbIll
ROMnOHeHT, xapaRTepn3YIOID;IIllCH Cpe,L(H npO'IIIX np:II3HaROB rpan;:IIJIbHbIM
CTpoeHHeM JIHn;eBOro CReJIeTa.
K aHaJIOrH'THOMY BbIBO,L(y npHBO,L(IIT conOCTaBJIeHHe COMaTOJIOrHqeCRIIX
,L(aHHblx. OHn MeHee npnrO,L(HbJ ,L(JIH rpynnoBoro CpamIeUIIH BBII,L(Y OqeBHJJ;HbIX
MeTO,L(HqeCRlIX pacxomJJ:eHIIII y pa3HbIX aBTopOB, HO Cpe,L(II CYID;eCTBYIOID;nx
MaTepna.1J:OB eCTb c06paHHbIe Cpe,L(II Y36eROB, Ta,L(lliIIROB II naMHpn;eB O,L(HHM
HCCJIeJ],OBaTeJIeM. llo ,L(aHHblM JI. B. OillaHIIHa 13, rOpHbIe Tap,lliHRII II rraMIIp-
n;bI OT.rrnqaIOTCH 0'1' Y36eROB 3HaqlITeJIbHbIM pOCTOM 60PO,L(bI, Menee pa3BIITOM
CRJIaiJ,Roii BepXHero BeRa, MeHbllIIM rrpOn;eHTOM oc06ell C HaJIHqHeM 3nlIRaH-
Tyca U 60JIee Y3RHM JIIIn;OM (Y36eR:II 141-142 MM, rOpHbIe Ta,L(mlIRII II na-
l\IIIpn;bI 130-140 M:\I). B TO me BpeMH OTMeTIITb RaRIIe-JIu60 OT.rrH IlIH Y36e-
I\:OB 0'1' ropHblx Ta,L(lliIIRoB II naMIIpcRIIX HapO,L(OB B rOJIOBHOM YRa3aTe.JIe He
y,L(aeTCH. MaTepHaJIbI ]{uprH3CROll apxeOJIOrO-3THorpa<pIIqeCI\:oll 3Rcne,'Uln;IIII
TaRme TIORa3bIBaIOT, '1'1'0 pa3HIIn;a Mem,L(y Y36eRal'.III H Ta.D;lliHRaMH npOHBJIH-
eTCH B npU3HaRax, OTpamaIOID;ux .D;OJIIO MOHrOJIOII,L(HOM npIIMeCH, H B lIIIIpHHe
JIIIn;a, HO He3aMeTHa B rOJIOBHOM YRa3aTeJIe a. Melli,L(y TeM Y36eRII npep;CTaB-
JIenbI B MaTepHaJIaX KIIprII3CROll 3Rcnep,IIn;IIII rpynnoll 6e3 PO,L(OBbIX ,L(eJIeHHll,
xapaRTep:II3YIOID;eIICH HaIIMenbillUM BRJIIOqeHIIeM MOHrOJIOH,L(Horo ROMnOHeHTa.
TaRIIM 06pa30M, :II H3 COMaTOJIOrIIqeCRHX conOCTaBJIeHHll BII,L(HO, ITO Ta,L(iRU-
RII, oc06eHHO ropHble, :II naMHpCRIIe HapO,L(bI OTJIIIqaIOTcH 60JIee rpan;IIJIbHbIM
J1IIn;eBbIM CReJIeTOM, :II OTJIIIqUe 3'1'0, CY,L(H no paCCMOTpeHHbIM BbIlle RpaHUO-
JIOrIlqecKIIM ,L(aHHbIM, HeJIb3H 06'bHCHIITb TOJIbRO MOHrOJIOU,L(HOll nplumCblO
320
-
J:I:I
:.-
CD
:>:
CJ
CD
CD
to
Ta6JI1n a 21
COnOCTaBJleHHe ya6eRoB H nal\lHp eB no RpaHHOJIOrH'IeCRHM AaHHbIM. MymcRHe '1epena
¥a6eIm
Muo TIpHsHaH
MapTHHY I CaMapHaHAa I I I'opaHl (bI IIlliHalliHM1(bI
TalliHeHTa ByxapbI ROHaHAa
1 IIpOAOJTLHbIll W!3MeTp 175,1 (296) 178,7 (41) 182,0 (10) 175,0(9) 173,2 (64) 172,2(53)
8 IIOnepC'IHbIH AuaMcTp 145,4 (296) 144,3(41) 146,3 (10) H8,9 (9) 140,8(64) 141,1 (53)
8:1 qppcnnoH YHa3aTeJTL 83,1 (296) 80,8(41) 80,5(10) 85,2 (9) 80,9 * 82,2 *
17 BbICOTHbIH AHaMeTp OT 6a3HoHa 135,8 (293) 136,5(40) 138,8 (10) 131,7(9) 132,3 (64) 131,9 (53)
9 HalIMeIThTIIaH nmplIna JT6a 96,2 (297) 97,1 (40) 95,6(10) 95,7(9) 97,2(64) 95,5(53)
45 CHYJTOBaH nmplIHa 135,0(276) 13fl (38) 134,8(10) 138,1 (9) 132,8 (64) 131,1 (53)
48 BepxHHH BblCOTa JTHIJ;a 73,3(241) 7 ,9 (36) 72,8 (5) 72,1 (9) 70,6 (64) 70,4(53)
48: 45 BepxHuH JTHIJ;eBOH YKaaaTeJTb 54,3 (226) 54,4(34) 53,7(5) 51,4 (7) 53,2 * 53,7 *
75(1) YrOJT BblCTynaHlUI HOCOBbIX HocTeH 26,6 (195) 25,0(17) - 17,5 (2) 29,6 (64) 31,0(53)
77 J-Ia30MaJTHpnbIH yroJT 139,7 (275) 142,9 (15) - 145,2(8) 138,5 (64) 139,8(53)
Lzm' 3urOMaHCI!JTJTHpHbIH yroJT 129,2 (264) 130,4(15) 142,0(5) 126,9 (64) 127,8 (53)
* HHAeI{C cpeAHHX.
N
.....
Ta6JTBI a 22
ConOCTaBJTeHHe yooeRoB H naMHp eB no RpaHHOJIOrH'IeCRHM AaHHbIM. meHcRHe '1epena
¥s6eHH
Muo TIpH3HaH
MapTHHY I CaMapHaHAa I'opaHI(bI IIlliHalliHMI1bI
T alliHeHT a ByxapbI ROHaHAa
x,r'
1 IIpOAOJTbHbIH AlIaMeTp 164,9 (127) 173,3 (9) 172,2(14) 168,7(8) 168,4(35) 167,7(38)
8 IIOrrepe'lHbIH AHaMeTp 141,3(128) 139,3 (9) 144,9 (14) 146,0(8) 134,4(35) 133,6 (38)
8:1 JeperrHoH YHa3aTCJTb 85,6 (127) 80,6 (9) 84,4(14) 86,6(8) 79,9 * 79,7 *
17 BbICOTlIbIH AHaMeTp OT GaalIoHa 130,0 (110) 130,0(9) 134,6 (14) 133,8 (6) 121,1 (35) 127,8(38)
9 HalIMeHLmaH nIlIpHHa JT6a 92,0(110) 94,9(4) 94,2 (14) 90,6 (8) 94,8 (35) 92,0 (38)
45 CI>yJTOBaH nmpliHa 125,3 (123) 126,9 (8) 126,3(14) 131,8 (3) 125,4 (35) 121,6 (38)
48 BCPXHHH BbICOTa JTlIIJ;a 68,0(109) 68,6 (8) 68,9(11) 64,4(6) 67,7 (35) 67,7 (38)
48: 45 BepxHIIH JTIIIJ;eBOH YHa3aTeJTL 54,5(104) 54,0(7) 54,6(11) 49,4 (3) 54,0* 55,7 *
75(1) YroJT BbICTynaHIiH HOCOBbIX KocTeH 21,4(78) 26,5(4) 19,7(3) 27,4 (35) 27,9(38)
77 HaaOMaJTHpHbIH yroJT 142,2(126) 140,0(3) 151,0 (6) 140,0 (35) 139,8 (38)
Lzm' 3nrOMaKCHJTJTHpHbIH yroJT 130,4(122) 127,5(2) 138,2 (5) 128,5 (35) 126,6(38)
.. :IIH.n;eHC cpeAHHX.
B COCTaBe Y36eROB. rIInOTe3a 0 pa3HbIX eBpOneO:II.D;HbIX ROMnOHeHTaX B CO-
CTaBe Y36eROB, C O.D;HOM CTOpOHbI, rOpHbIX Ta.D;JK:IIROB :II naMIIpn;eB - C APyroM,
npeACTaBJIHeTCH He06xo.D;:IIMOll.
KaRoM BbIBO.D; MOmHO C.D;eJIaT:b H3 BCeX 9TIIX <paKTOB :II COnOCTaBJIeHIIll?
B npHHn;IIne 1'.IOJKHO OTRa3aTbCH 0'1' HAeII CBH3:II naMHpO-<pepraHCROll paCbI C
MaCCIIBHbIM aH.D;pOHOBCRIIM THnOM II CqIITaTb, qTO TOJIbRO rpan;:IIJIbHbJe Cpe.D;H-
3el'.IHOMOpn;bI B pe3YJIbTaTe nepeCTpOllRII qepenHOll Rop06RII BO BpeMeHII AaJIII
HaqaJIO TeMHOnIIrMeHTIIpOBaHHbIM 6paX:IIKe<paJIaM, 06'beAIIHHeMbIM nO.D; IIOHH-
T:IIeM naMIIpO-<pepraHCROM paCbI. qHCTbIMII npe.D;CTaBlITeJIHMII 9TOll paCbI HB-
JIHIOTCH rOpHbIe Ta.D;JKHRII II eID;e 60JIbille naMIIpn;bI. OTJIIIqIIe OT HIIX no
CTeneHH MaCCIIBHOCTH Y36eKOB ,L(ellCTBHTeJIbHO MOJKHO OTHeCT:II 3a CqeT
1'.IOHrOJIOHAHOll npHl'.JeCH. Ho B 3'1'01'.1 CJIyqae HenOHHTHO, nOqeMY 60JIee MOH-
rOJIOH.D;HbJe Y36eRII IIMeIOT 60JIee BbICORYIO qepenHYIO Rop06Ry, qel\I na-
MIIpI bI, a lIe Ha060poT?
TIAJlEOAHTPOTIOJlOrllqECRHE COTIOCTABJlEHIIH
B npOTIIBOnOJIOJKHOM CJIyqae - npII nonbITRe YBH3aTb reHe3HC naMIIpo-<pep-
raHcRoM paCbI C aH.D;pOHOBCRIIM TIIllOM - Ha6mo.D;aeTCH xopOllee COOTBeTCT-
BIIe I'HnOTe3bI COCTOHHIIIO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX MaTepnaJIOB. IIpH cpaB-
HeHIII'! RpaH:IIOJIOr:IIqeCRIIX oc06eHHOCTell Ra3aXCTaHCRIIX aHAPOHOBn;eB, cepIIll
:II3 npeAnOJIOJKIITeJIbHO caRO-YCYH:bCRHX naMHTH:IIROB ]{a3axcTaHa :II ]{IIprII-
3IIII II Y36eRcKHx BII.D;eH nOCTeneHHbIll nepexo.D; 0'1' nepBbIX RO BTOpbIM II OT
BTOpbIX R TpeTbIIM; HHbIMII CJIOBaMII, cep:II:II CRII<po-capMaTcRoro Bpel\>JeHil 3a-
nHMalOT npoMemyTOqHOe nOJIOJKeHHe MeJK,L(y aH.D;pOHOBCKOll :II cOBpeMeHHoll
Y36eRcRoll (Ta6JI. 23) 15. TaRHM 06pa30M, BbIBO.D; B. B. rIlH36ypra 0 nOCTe-
neHHOll nepeCTpOMRe Ha TeppIITOpIII'! Ka3axCTaHa aH.D;pOHoBCRoro THna B na-
MHpo-<pepraHCRIIll, IIJIH, RaR OH nIIlleT, npeAnO'lI'lTaH TepM:IIHOJIOrIIIO
JI. B. OllaHHHa, B pacy CpeAHea3:IIaTCROro MeJKJ\ypeqbH, Haxo.D;IIT nOJIHOe
nO.D;TBepJK.D;eH:IIe B <paKTHqeCRIIX AaHHbIX, HaM CellqaC II3BeCTHbIX. II paB.D;a,
npOMeJKYTO'IHOe nOJIOJKeHIIe CKII<po-capMaTCKI21X cepIIM coxpaHHTcH II B TOM
CJIyqae, eCJIII B Ta6JI. 23 MeCTO Y36eRoB 3allMYT naMIIpl(bI. Ho Torlla MbI
.D;OJIJKHbI 6Y,L(eM npe.D;nOJIOJImTb, qTO npon;ecc rpan;IIJIII3an;nn HeOAIIHaKOBO lleJI
B pa3HbIX qaCTHX apeaJIa naMIIpo-<pepraHcRoM paCbI: Ha paBHIIHe OH ORa3aJI
ropa3.D;0 MeHbillee BJIIIHH:IIe Ha nepecTpollRY THna, qeM B ropax. O.D;HaRO BbI-
CORoropHbJe pallOHbI qaID;e 3aCeJIeHbI llIIpOROJIIln;bIM:II II MaTypH30BaHHbIMH
T:IInaMII - YRaJKY JI:IIllb Ha RaBRacIIoHcRIIll TIIn B ropax I(eHTpaJIbHOrO KaBKa-
3a H Ha .D;HHapCR:IIll TIIn Ha BaJIRaHax. TaRIIM 06pa30M, eCJIII MbI IIID;eM e,L(II-
Hyro OCHOBY naMIIpo-<pepraHcKoM paCbI B aHAPOHOBCROM TIIlle, TO AOJmmbI
np:II6erHyTb R .D;onOJIHHTeJIbHOll :II .D;aJIeRO He OqeBII.D;HOll rIIllOTe3e. E,L(HHCT-
BeHHbIM BbIXOAOM H3 npOT:IIBOpe'lI'lll, RaR MHe npeACTaBJIHeTCH, MOJKeT 6bITb
.D;onYID;eHIIe, qTO aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIe oc06eUHOCTII I'OpHbIX Ta.D;JKIIIWB H na-
MHpCRHX HapOAOB CJIOJKUJIIICb Ha :IIHOll eBponeOIIAHOll OCHOBe, qeM y Y3-
6eROB.
IIpe.D;CTaBJIeHIIe 0 .D;BYX eBponeOII.D;HbIX T:IInaX, Ha 6a3e ROTOpbIX C<pOPMII-
pOBaJIIICb Te ROM6IIHan;IIH npH3HaROB, ROTOpbJe 06'beAIIHHIOTCH HbIHe nOA Ha-
3BaH:IIeM naMupo-<pepraHcRoM paCbI, 6JIIIJKe Bcero R rIInOTe3e ee npoucxom-
.D;eHHH, ROTopaH 3aID;IIID;aeTCH T. A. TpO<p:IIMOBOll, B. B. rUH36yproM H yno-
MHHYTa BbIlle, B rryHRTe 3. O.D;HaRO Rap,L(IIHaJIbHbIM OTJIIPIIIeM pa3BIIBaeMoro
3.D;eCb B3rJIH,L(a HBJIHeTCH JIORaJIII3an;IIH reHeT:IIqeCRIIX CBH3ell naMIIpo-<pepraH-
n;eB C pa3HbIMII eBpOneOH,L(HbIMII THnaM:II B npOCTpaHCTBe - CBH3b C npOTO-
MOp<pHbIMII TIInaMII Ha ceBepe II C rpan;IIJIbHbIl\1II Ha IOre. CYID;ecTBeHHo II
paC'IJIeHeHIIe COBpeMeHHbIX naMHpo-<peprann;eB B COOTBeTCTB:II:II C 9THM He
322
Ta6JIHqa 23
CODOCTaBJIeHUe Y36eKoB C APeBHuM HaCeJIeHUeM Ka3axcTaHa U RuprlI3uu
AHiJ,POHOB- CaI<O-YCYHb-
No no TIpHSHal< Cl\aH EYJIb- Ya6el<I1 (Bce
MapTI1HY Typa Ka- CI<I1e naMHT- ropoiJ,a)
saXCTaHa HHI<I1
t
8
8:1
17
9
45
48
48: 45
75(1)
77
Lzm'
MymcKHe qepeDa
I TIpOAOJIbHbIH AHaMeTp
TIorrepe'1HbIll AlIaMeTp
eperrHOll YKa3aTeJIb
BbICOTHbIH AlIaMeTp OT 6a300Ha
HaHMeHbillaJI illHpHHa JI6a
CKYJIOBaJI illHpHlIa
BepXIIJIJI BblCOTa JIHl(a
BepxlIHll JIHl(eBOH YKa3aTeJIb
YrOJI BblcTyrri\lIlIH 1I0COBbIX KOCTeH
Ha30MaJIJIplIbIII yrOJI
,3HrOMaKCHJIJIflplIbIH yrOJI
meHCKHe qepeDa
185,6 (14)
141,5(14).
76,4(14)
136,6 (9)
97,3(14)
138.0 (12)
68,9(14)
50,5(12)
31,4(13)
138,1 (11)
127,4(12)
180,3 (35)
145,0(34)
80,7 (34)
132,7 (26)
98.8(39)
139,2 (39)
71,3(39)
51,6 (39)
29,7 (29)
142,1 (31)
129,9 (34)
175,7(356)
145,4(356)
82,8 (356)
135,9 (352)
96.3(356)
135,0(333)
73,2 (291)
54,2 (272)
26,0(214)
140,0 (298)
129,5 (284)
t IIpOAOJIblIbIH AlIaMeTp 178,4(23) 173,9 (24) 166,2(158)
8 IIOrrepe'1HbIH AHaMeTp 136,5 (23) 140,1 (24) 141,7 (159)
8:1 eperrHoll YKa3aTeJIb 76,7 (23) 80.7 (23) 85,3(158)
17 BbICOTHbIll AIIaMeTp OT 6a300Ha 130,3 (12) 125,5(19) 130,6 (139)
9 HaHMeHbillaJI illHpHHa JI6a 95,0 (22) 93,9 (26) 92,9(157)
45 CKyJIOBaJI IllHpHHa 129,0(18) 128,7 (28) 125.6(148)
48 BepXHJIH BblCOTa JlIIII:a 67,2(21) 69,2 (27) 67,9(134)
48: 45 BepxHHH JIHl(eBOH YKa3aTeJIb 53,1 (16) 54.0(26) 54,3 (126)
75(1) YrOJI BblCTyrramuI HOCOBbIX KOCTeii 25,2(12) 24,3(21) 21,6 (85)
77 Ha3mmJIHpHbIll yrOJI 139,3(14) 142,9(26) 142,5 (135)
Lzm' 3HrOMaKCHJIJIHpHbIII yrOJI 126,7 (15) 130,3 (24) 130,7 (129)
TOJIbRO no CTeneHII BblpallieHHOCT:II MOHrOJIOII.n;HOll npIIMeC:II, HO :II no CTeneHII
MaTypII30BaHHocTll eBpOneO:IIllHOM OCHOBbI.
BJIIIlliaMillaH aHaJIOr!UI TOMY rpan;IIJIbHOMY eBpOneO:II.D;HoMY BapIIaHTY, RO-
TOpbIll npe.D;CTaBJIeH B COCTaBe naMIIpn;eB II ropHblx Ta.n;lli:IIROB, nO-B:II,L(IIMOMY,
MOiReT 6bITb OTMeqena B Mop<p0JIOrIIqeCRlIX oc06eHHocTHX TypRMeH. llo AaH-
HbIM JI. B. OllaHllHa, llIIpIIHa JI:IIn;a Y 60JIbillIIHCTBa TypKMeHcRIIx nJIeMeH
cooTBeTcTByeT llIIpnHe JIIln;a ropnbIx rpynn Ta,L(lli:IIRCROrO Hapo.n;a (139-
140 MM), .n;OCTIlraH B OT.n;eJIbHbIX CJIy'IaHX 138 MM. 8TO TOT Bap:IIaHT cpe,L(:II-
3eMHOMopCROll BeTBll eBpOneOII.D;HOll paCbI, ROTOpbIll 6bIJI BbI,L(eJIeH no.D; :IIMe-
HeM opIIeHTaJIbHOrO (IIJIII BOCTOqHOro) E. Q)IIillepOM :II nO.D;BeprHYT cnen;:IIaJIb-
HOMY, OqeHb nO,L(p06HOMY paCCMOTpeHllIO B II3BeCTHOM pa60Te A. M. Hpxo 16.
CaM JI. B. OllaHllH Ha3bIBaeT ero 3aRaCillIIICRIIM TIInOM, HO npe.n;CTaBJIHeTCH
60JIee y,L(aqHbIM Ha3bIBaTb ero BCJIe,L( 3a B. B. BynaRoM 17 npOCTO RacnIIH-
CRIIM, OTpalliaH B 9TOM HaIIMeHOBaHIIII TOT <paRT, qTO npe.n;CTaB:IITeJIII .n;aHHoro
T:IIna 3aHIIMaIOT Tepp:IITOpIIIO He TOJIbRO R BOCTORY, HO :II R 3ana.D;y 0'1' Kac-
n:IIMCRoro MOpH (a3ep6all.n;lliaHn;bI, 'IaCT:II'IHO IOlliHbJe .D;areCTaHn;bI). ,IJ;peBHeH-
m:IIM:II npe.n;CTaBIITeJIHM:II 9TOro TIIna Ha Tepp:IITOpIIII Cpe.D;HeM A3:IIII, 6e3YCJIOB-
HO, MOmHO C'lI'ITaTI> HaOOJIeH:IIe, aHTpOnOJIOr:IIqeCKl2le oc06eHHocTII ROToporo
323 11*
:II3BeCTHbJ HaM no cepIIHM, npOIICXO.D;HID;IIM :II3 9HeOJIIITHqeCRIIX naMHTHIIROB
IOlliHoll TYPRMeHH:II - Kapa-,l],ene :II -reORCIOpa 18 :II 113 naMHTHIIROB 9nOXII
6POH3bI IOlliHoro Y36eR:IICTaHa - CanaJIJIIITena II p;lliapKYTaHa 19.
P;JIH :IIJIJIIOCTpan;IIII MOP<POJIOr:IIqeCROrO CXO,L(CTBa .D;peBHIIX RacnIIlln;eB :II
COBpeMeHHbIX naMIIpn;eB BOCnOJIb3yeMcH CYMMapHbIM conOCTaBJIeHIIeM ITO
MHomM npII3HaRaM, BblpalliaH pa3H:IIn;y B CTaH,L(apTHbIX BeJIIIqlfHaX RBa,lJ;pa-
TIIqeCRHX YRJIOHeH:IIll. 1l0CJIe,L(HIIe B3HT:bI II3 HeCROJIbRHX RpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCRHX
ny6JIIman;IIII, CO.D;eplliaID;:IIX pe3YJIbTaTbI H3MepeHIIMMHoroqHCJIeHHbIX O.D;HOpO,lJ;-
HbIX cepIIM 2o . .D:Be HaXO.D;HID;IIeCH B HailleM pacnopHmeHII:II naMHpCRIIe cepI'lI'!
CYMMIIpyeM BBII,L(Y :IIX nOqTII nOJIHOrO l'.wp<p0JIOrIIqeCROrO Tom,lJ;eCTBa. MTor
nO.D;CqeTa 6Y.D;eT BblpalliaTbCH n;H<ppoM 0,49, 03HaqaIOID;ell, '1'1'0 B Cpe.D;HeM ITO
O.D;IIHHa.D;n;aTII npII3HaRaM CTpoeHHH JIIIn;eBOro CReJIeTa (H3MepeHHH qepenHoM
Rop06RII He BBO,lJ;HTCH B nO,lJ;CqeT, TaR RaR OHII nO,lJ;BepmeHbI IIHTeHCHBHbThI
:II3MeHeHIIHM BO BpeMeHII) pa3HIIn;a Melli,L(Y CYMMapHOll naMIIpCROll II IOmHO-
TYPRMeHCROll cepIIHMII no 060IIM nOJIaM COCTaBJIHeT 0,49 CTaH.D;apTHoro RBa.D;-
paTIIqeCROrO YRJIOHeHIIH. P;JIH On;eHR:II 9TOM BeJIIIqIIHbI np:IIBe,L(Y Cpe,lJ;H:IIe pa3-
HIIn;bI, BblpallieHHbJe B npOn;eHTax OT BeJIIIqIIH Tex llie CTaH,lJ;apTHbIX RBa.D;pa.
TII'IeCRIIX YRJIOHeHIIll, no CJIeL\YIOID;:IIM cepIIHM (Ha60p npII3HaROB TOT llie, HO
C .D;06aBJIeHIIeM HeCROJIbRHX II3MepeHIIM 'IepenHoM Rop06KII) :
1-2-H CTa}J;IiH TarapcKoH KYJIbTypbI 0,17
CapMaTbI TIOBOJIlliLH - capMaTLI YKpanHbI 0,30
CaJITOBCKIIll: MOrIIJILHIIK - enmTHHe XXVI - XXX }J;IIHaCTnB 0,44
CaJITOBCKliH MOrIIJIbHIIK - 6acKII 0,61
CaJITOBCKIill: MorliJILHIIK - MOHrOJIbI 1,10
M3 9TIIX n;:II<pp BII,lJ;HO, qTO Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCRaH pa3HIIn;a Melli.D;Y naMIIpn;aMII
:II 3HeOJIIITIIqeCRIIM HaCeJIeHIIeM TYPRMeHIIII cooTBeTcTByeT npHMepHo Mac-
illTa6y pa3JIIIqIIll Melli,L(Y OT,lJ;eJIbHbIMII CepIIHM:II Cpe,lJ;II3eMHOMopCROII BeTB:II
eBpOneOII,L(OB. ECJIII yqeCTb, 'ITO Melli,lJ;Y HIIMII JIelliIIT npoMelliYToR BpeMeH:II
nOqTII B 5000 JIeT, TO pa3HIIn;y CJIe,lJ;yeT np:II3HaTb OqeHb He60JIbillOll. K 3TOMY
CJIe.D;yeT np:II6aBIITb e.D;HHbIM apeaJI B npe.D;eJIax IOlliHbIX pallOHOB Cpe,L(Heii
A3:II:II :II HaJIIIqIIe npOMemYTOqHbIX <pOpM: illHpORoe paCIIpOCTpaHeHIIe rpa-
n;:IIJIbHbIX eBpOneO:II.D;OB B 9TIIX paMoHax B 9noxy 6POH3bI, paHHero llieJIe3a :II
BnJIOTb ,L(O Cpe,lJ;HeBeKOBbH ,lJ;el'.IOHCTp:IIpyeTcH MHOrOqIICJIeHHbIMII naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIOrHqeCRIIMII cepIIHMII. Pa3JIHqIIHM B <popMe qepenHOM Rop06RII Mea\,lJ;y
3HeOJI:IITIIqeCRHMII .D;OJIIIXORe<paJIaMH II 6paXIIRe<paJIaMII-naMIIpn;aMII BpH,lJ; JIII
CJIe,L(yeT npII,lJ;aBaTb RaKoe-HH6Y.D;b 3Ha'IeHIIe, TaR RaR OHII COOTBeTCTBYIOT
06bIqHOMY HanpaBJIeHIIIO pa3JIIIqHM Melli,L(Y COBpeMeHHbIM II ,L(peBIIHM HaCeJIe-
HIIeM :II HBJIHIOTCH CJIe.D;CTB:IIeM eCJI:II He naHOllRYMeHHoro, TO, BO BCHROM CJIY-
qae, illIIpORO pacnpOCTpaHeHHoro npon;ecca. KCTaTII CRa3aTb, Yllie ,lJ;aBHeJ OT-
MeqaJIOCb, qTO ropHbJe MeCTHOCTII cnoc06CTBYIOT 6paXlme<paJIH3an;IIII. MOllieT
6bITb, 3THM H MOlliHO 06'bHCHIITb pa3HYIO <POPMY qepenHOll Rop06RII y ropHbIX
Ta,lJ;lliIIROB H naM:IIpn;eB, C O.D;HOM CTOpOHbI, H Y TypRMeH - C ,L(PyroM.
MTaR, npe,lJ;lleCTBYIOID;:IIM aHaJIII3 npHBO,L(IIT Hac R He06xo.D;:IIMOCTH pacqJIe-
H:IITb e,lJ;IIHYIO naM:IIpo-<pepraHCRYIO pacy :II np:IIJIaraTb 9'1'0 nOHHTIIe TOJIbRO R
TOMY BapHaHTY, ROTOpbrH npe,L(CTaBJIeH B COCTaBe Y36eROB :II RaRoM-To qaCTII
paBHIIHHbIX TalllliHROB. qTO me RacaeTCH ropHblx Ta,L(lliIIRoB :II naMIIpn;eB, IIX
CJIe,lJ;yeT BRJIlOqIITb B COCTaB Racn:IIMCRoM paCbI. K aHaJIOrIIqHoMy BbIBO.D;y npH-
llJIa T. ll. KIIHTRIIHa Ha OCHOBaH:IIII paCCMoTpeHIIH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX
MaTep:IIaJIOB C TeppIITOp:IIII Ta.D;JR:IIRIICTaHa 21. .D:peBHee reHeT:IIqeCROe pO,lJ;CT-
BO, BbIHBJIHel'.IOe aHTpOnOJIOrIIell, B 60JIbilleM Mepe CBH3bIBaeT IIX C TypRMeHa-
M:II, 'IeM C Y36eRaMII. PO.D;CTBO 9TO BOCXO.D;:IIT R .D;peBHeMilleMY eBponeOHllHOMY
324
HaCeJIeHlIIO IOmHbIX pallO HOB Cpe.D;Hell A3lIII. C TOqRII 3peHIIH reorpa<pIIlI oqa-
rOB paco06pa30BaHlIH He TOJIbRO nYCTbIHHbIe palIOHbI IOlliHOll TYPRMeHlI:II,
HO II ropHble palIOHbI Ta.D;llilIKHCTaHa, BRJIIOqaH IIaMlIp, HYlliHO paCCMaTp:II-
BaTb, CJIe,L(OBaTeJIbHO, KaR ceBepHYIO nep:II<pepIIlO apeaJIa :IIH,lJ.o-a<praHcRoM
paCbI.
OCTaeTCH CRa3aTb HeCROJIbRO CJIOB 0 npOIICXOlli.D;eHlIII COOTBeTCTBeHHO na-
MlIpo-<pepraHCROll paCbI B TOM Y3ROM CMbICJIe CJIOBa, RaROII MbI npII.D;aeM
9TOMY TepMIIHY, T. e. 0 npoIICxolli,L(eHlIlI OCHOBHoro eBpOneOlI.D;HOrO ROl'.IIIO-
HeHTa, BOllellillero B COCTaB Y36eROB. BbI6lIpaTb MOlliHO npaRTIIqeCRII Melli,L(Y
.D;BYMH aJIbTepnaTIIBaMII - CBH3blO XapaI{TepHOll ,lJ.JIH Y36eROB KOM6IIHan;:II:II
npII3HaROB C aH poHoBCRIIM TIInOM lIJIII rIInoTe30M caMOCTOHTeJIbHOCTII 6pa-
xIIRpaHHoro ROl'.IIIOHeHTa C rJIy60KoII .D;peBHoCTlI. 10. r. PblqROB lIJIJIIOCTplI-
PyeT nOCJIe,L(Hee cpaBHeHIIeM RpaHlIOJIOrII'IeCROrO TIIna Ta,lJ.mlIROB rOpaHa c
RapaCYRCROII ceplIell. 8TY aHaJIOrlIIO MomHO ,lJ.OrrOJIHlITb eID;e HeCROJIbRIIMlI
6panmpaHHbIMII cepIIHMII: lI3 norpe6eHlIll 6e3 BeID;ell Ha TeppIITopIIII TYBbI II
3ana,lJ.HOll MOHromIlI (n03.D;HHH 6poH3a IIJIII paHHee meJIe30) 22, II3 norpe6e-
lIlIll TaR Ha3bIBaeMOll ORYHeBCROll RYJIbTypbI B XaRaCIIII (paHHHH 6pon3a) 23.
C ,L(pyroll CTOpOHbI, IIpe,L(CTaBJIeHIIe 06 II3BeCTHOll CBeTJIOrJIa30CTII aII,L(pOHOB-
n;eB OCTaeTCH He CHHTbIM C nOBeCTRII ,lJ.HH, a 3'1'0 C03llaeT 60JIbllYIO TPY.D;-
HOCTb B YTBeplli,L(eHlIII IIaJIIIqIIH npeeMCTBenHOCTII Mea{,lJ.y HaCeJIeHHeM aH,lJ.po-
HOBCROll RyJIbTYPbI II COBpeMeHHbIM Y36eRCRIIM HapO.D;OM. 1l03TOMY H CRJIO-
HHIOCb R rlInOTe3e 3HaqIITeJIbHOll ,lJ.peBHOCT:II nal'.Ulpo-<pepraHCRoll pacbI II ee
OCHOBHbIX Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCRIIX oc06eHHoCTeM, B TOM 'IIICJIe II 6paXIIRpaH:II:II.
II
BbIBOJJ:bI
1. BXO,L(m:n;IIe B COCTaB naMIIpo-<pepraHcRoll paCbI HapO,lJ.bI pa3JIIIqaIOTCH He
TOJIbRO .D;oJIeM MOHrOJIOII,lJ.HOll npIIMecII, HO II no CTeneHII rpan;lIJIbHOCTII eBpo-
IIeOlI.D;Horo ROMnOHeHTa.
2. EBpOneO:II,lJ.HbIM ROMnOHeHT, npe.D;CTaBJIeHHbIll Y ropHbIX Ta.D;lliIIROB n
naMIIpCRIIX HapOL\OB, BXO,lJ.IIT B COCTaB Cpe.D;II3eMHOMopCROII BeTBII rpan;lIJIb-
HbIX eBpOneOII,lJ.OB II C6JIIImaeTCH C TeM BapIIaHTOM cpellII3eMHoMopCROll rpyrr-
nbI nonYJIHn;IIll, ROTOpbIII xapaRTepeH .D;JIH ,lJ.peBHero H COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIe-
HlIH TYPRMeHIIII. MHbIMII CJIOBaMII, rOpHbIe Ta,lJ.}JmRII II naMlIpn;bI - npe.D;CTa-
B:IITeJIII He naMIIpo-<pepraHCROll, a RacnIIllCROll paCbI, '1'1'0 CBlI.D;eTeJIbCTByeT 06
::ux 60JIbilleM pO,L(CTBe C TypRMeHaMII, HemeJIII C Y36eRal'.UI.
3. B TeoplIII IIpOIICXOlli,lJ.eHlIH naMIIpo-<pepraHcRoll paCbI (nO,lJ.pa3YMeBaH
no.D; Hell mIllb ROl'.IIIJIeRC npII3HaROB, BblpallieHHbIll Y Y36eROB) HaII60JIbillee
3HaqeHIIe II HalI60JIbllYIO nO,L(,lJ.epamy CO CTOpOHbI naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIX
.D;aHHbIX lIMeeT rlInOTe3a 3HaqlITeJIbHOII ,lJ.peBHOCTII 6paXIIRpaHIIlI B COCTaBe
eBponeOII,lJ.OB eCJIII II He Ha TeppIITopIIII Cpe,L(HeII, TO, BO BCHROM CJIyqae, Ha
TeppIITopIIII lJ,eHTpaJIbHOll A3IIII.
1 Hpxo A. H. faHp;1KIiHcRHe TlOpRH (A3epOarr;(lliaHCHan ACCP) II AHTpOrrOJI. lliYPH. 1932.
oN!! 2.
2 QwaHUH JI. B. JJ:aHHbIC K reorpaq,II'IeCKmry pacrrpOCTpaHCHIIIO rJIaBHerrnlIIX aHTpono-
JIOrIl'ICCIH!X npli3HaROlJ HaCeJIeHlIJ1 Cpep;Hcii A311l! Ii onbrT lJbIJlBJICHIIH OCHOBHbrx pa-
COBbIX THnOB CpeP;Herr A3HH II Tp. IV BCCCOI03. C'be3p;a 300JIOrOB, aHa TO MOB H rHCTO-
JIOrOB. KlIeB, 1931.
OH 3/Ce. AHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCRlItl COCTaR HaCeJIeHHH CpcJlHeiI A31III If 3THoreHe3 ee Hapop;oB
EpeBaH, 1957. q. 1.
· FUHs6ypa B. B. Paca Cpe,'\Hea31IaTcRoro MelliJlype'IbH Ii ee npoIIcxollip;eHHe II VII Mem-
P;YHapOP;Hb!rr KOHrpecc aHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCRlIX Ii 3THorpaq,Ii'IeCKHX HaYK M., 1964.
5 FUHs6ypa Bo Bo, /l,e6elJ F. flJ., JIeeuH M. F., l{ e6oncapoe H. H. O'Iepm! no aHTpono-
JIonm KasaxcTaHa II RpaT. co06lI\. IIH-Ta 3THorpaq,HH AH CCCPo 1952. BbIII. 16.
325
j
· J(e6elf r. (/J. OlibIT rpa«Im:'leCKOrO InJ06pallieHlUI reHeaJTOrH'leCIWII ImaccmIJHKaIJ;llB
'IeJTOBe'IeCItlIX pac II COB. 9THorpa«ImH. 1958. .M 4.
1. B ITOC:Ie.D;HHe rop;bI lliH3HH B. B. rllH36ypr TaKllie IIpllCOep;HHllJTCH K 3TOHl, TO'IKe
3peHHH.
· Schwidetzky I. Turaniden-Studien II Abhandlungen der mathematischnaturwissen-
schaftlichen Klasse der Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur. Wiesbaden,
1950. N 9.
"Pwl1'We /0. r. IIpollcxollip;eHHe paCbI Cpe;IHea3HaTCKoro Mellip;ype'lbH II IIp06JTeMbI
aTHH'leCKOII aHTpOIIOJTorIIH Cpep;HeR A3IIH. TamKeHT, 1964. (Hay<!. Tp. TamKeHT.
roc. YH-Ta; BbIli. 235); Ou :JICe. AHTpOIIOJIOrHH II reHeTHKa II30JTHpOBaHHbIx IIOIIYJTH-
IJ;ri (p;peBHHe H30JTHTbI IIaMlIpa). M., 1969.
19 ABTOp OIIIIcaHIIH, 10. r. PbI'lKOB, p;aHHbIMII KOToporo H IIOJTb3yroCb, Ha3bIB1).eT IIX ro-
paHIJ;al\III. CM. TaKllie: P03euifie/!biJ A. 3. Tap;lliIIKOH3bI'lHOe HaCeJTeHIIe COBeTcKoro
Eap;aXIIIaHa: (MaTepHaJTbI no 3THorpa«I>HII II H3bIKy) II COB. 3THorpa«I>HH. 1963. N! 1.
11 ruu36ype B. B. KpaHHOJIOrII'leCI{aH xapaKTepIIcTlma Y36eKoB: (TIo MaTepllaJTaM II3
KJTap;61IIIJ;a illeilxaHTayp B TalImeHTe) II AHTpOlIo:IOrII'leCHHII c60pHIm, IV. M., 1963.
(Tp. IIH-Ta 3THorpa«I>IIII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 3 ).
: Oma1Ulu lI. B. AHTpOITOJTOrII'leCKIIII COCTaB HaCeJTeHHH Cpep;HeH A3IIII II 3THoreHe3 ee
Hapop;OB. EpeBaH, 1958. q. 2.
1:1 Ou :JICe. AHTpOIIOJTOrII'leClnrR COCTaB HaCeJTeHIIH Cpep;HeH A3IIH II 9THoreHe3 ee Ha-
POAOB B CBeTe p;aHHbIX aHTpOIIOJTOrIm IIOmaHHH JI. B., 3e3eHHoBa B. II. BOlIpOCbI
3THoreHe3a Hapop;oB Cpep;HelI A3lIH B CBeTe ;J;aHHbIX aHTpOnOJTOrIIH. TamKeHT, 1953.
I., 3o/!oTapeea H. M. COMaTOJTOrII'leCKIIe IICCJIep;OlJaHIIH B cDepraHCIWH p;OJTHHe II Tp.
KIIprrr3. apXeOJT.-9THorp. 3Hcnep;IIIJ;HII. M., 1956. T. 1.
.,. l];JTH COCTaBJTeHHH Ta6JTIIT bI IICIIOJTb30BaHbI lIIaTepIIaJTbI: ruu36ype B. B. ApeBHee Ha-
CeJTeHIIe l{eHTpaJTbHOrO THHb-illam[ II AJTaH IIO aHTpOnOJTOrII'leCHHM p;aHHbIM II Cpep;-
nea3HaTcKIIH 3THorpa«I>H'lecKHH C60PHIIH, I. M., 1954. (Tp. ];lH-Ta 3THorpa«I>IIH AH
CCCP. T. 21); HC.M.aey/!oe O. HaCeJTeHHe Ka3axcTaHa 01' 9IIOXII 6pOH3bI p;o cOBpeMeH-
HOCTII (IIaJTeOaHTpOITOJTOrH'leCIWe IICCJTe;J;OBaHHe). AmIa-ATa, 1970.
te Hpxo A. H. TypKMeHbI Xope3Ma H CeBepHoro KaBl\:a3a: AHTpOITOJTOrlI'leCHHII O'lepH
o p;JTIIHHOrOJTOBOM eBpOlIeOIIp;HOM HOMIIOHeHTe TypeIJ;KIIx Hapop;HocTen CCCP II AHTpO-
nOJI. lliypH. 1\133. N! 1, 2.
)' B yuan B. B. AHTpOIIOJTOrII'leCHIIH COCTaB HaCe.:IeHlIJI KaBHa3a II BecTH. roc. My:JeH
rpY3IIII. T6HJIHCH, 1946. T. 13.
li rUI/36ype B. B., Tpoifiu.M.oea T. A. qepena 3ITOXII 9He0JI1ITa II 6POH3bI H3 IOlliHOII
TypHMeHIIII II COB. 3THorpa«I>H1I. 1959. N! 1; Tpoifiu.'rl,oea T. A., ruu36ype B. B. AHTpO-
IIoJTorII'lecKIIH COCTaB HaCeJTeHHH IOlliHoii TYPI{l\IeHHH B 3IIOXY 3HeOJTIITa: (TIo Ma-
TepIIaJTaM pacKonoK Kapa-Aene II reoHcropa) II Tp. IOmHo-TYPKMeH. apxeoJI. HOMn-
JIeHC. 3KClIeiJ;IIT IIII. Alllxa6ap;, 1961. T. 10; Fuu36ype B. B., Tpoifiu.M.oea T. A. TIaJIeOaH-
TpOIIOJIOrlIH Cpep;HeH A3HH. M., 1972.
1!} XoiJ:JICaiioe T. R. AHTpOnOJTOrII'leCKHH COCTaB HaCeJIeHHH 9IIOXH 6pOH3bI CalIaJIJIHTelia.
TallIKeHT, 1976; A.1el\:ceee B. n., XoiJ:JICaiioe T. R., Xa.m/!oe X. X. HaCeJTeHHe Bep-
XOBbeB AMyp;apbH no P;aHHbIM ITaJTeOaHTpOrrOJTOrIIIl. TalllReHT, 1984.
23 A/!el\:ceee B. n. AHTpOIIOJIoriH CaJTTiBCHOro MOrIIJTbHHKa II MaTepiaJIH 3 aHTpOIIOJIorii
¥KpaIHII. KIlIB, 1962. BIIn. 2.
:It KURTl\:uua T. n. MaTepIIaJIbI K IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJTOrIIII Tap;mllI{llCTaHa. l];YlllaH6e, 1976.
2.Z A/!el\:ceee B. n. HOBbIe p;aHHbIe 0 eBpOlIeOIIp;HOII pace B l{eHTpaJIbHOII A3HII II BpoH-
30BbIH II llieJTe3HbIH BeH CII6IIpH. HOBOCII6IIPCH, 1974.
Z3 J(e6elJ r. (/J. IIaJIeoaHTponoJTorHH oHYHeBcKoH RYJTbTypbI II TIaJIeOaHTpOllOJTOrIIH CII-
6IIpll. M., 1980.
OIIbIT AHTPOIIOJIOrMQECKOfl OIJ;EHKM
CKYJIbIITYP XAJIqAHHA M AAJIbBEP3MHA
AHTPOTIOJlOrllqECKIIE ACTIEKTbI H3YQEHHH
APEBHEH CKYJlbTITYPbI
B 1977 r. JI :IIMeJI B03MOlliHOCTb 6JIarO,lJ;apH JII06e3HOcTII r. A. ITyra'IeHROBOn
II 8. B. PTBeJIa.D;3e II3 :IITb B TamReHTe 60raTyIO ROJIJIeRD;:II1O cRyJIbnTypbI,
JW6bITYlO np:II paCRonRax ,L(peBH:IIX nOCeJIeHIIM XaJIqaHH II ,IJ;aJIbBep3:IIH, pac-
nOJIOmeHHbIX Ha TeppIITOp:II:II CypxaH.D;apbIIHCRon 06JIaCT:II ¥36eRcRon CCP.
326
CRYJIbnTypa 3Ta 6bIJIa OnIICaHa II H3,lJ.aHa B HeCROJIbRIIX MOHYMeHTaJIbHbIX.
RHIIraX r. A. IIyra'IeHRoBoM \ B ROTOpbIX nO,lJ.p06HO II3JIOllieHbI 06CTOHTeJIb-
CTBa apXeOJIOrIIqeCRIIX paCROnOR naMHTHIIROB, paCCMOTpeHbI BOnpOCbI <PYHR-
n;IIOHaJIbHOrO Ha3HaqeH:IIH, CeMaHTIIqeCROrO cO.D;epamHIIH II xyp;omecTBeHHOro
CTHJIH CRyJIbllrypbI, OCBeID;eHO ee MeCTO Cpe.D;II .D;pyrIIx aHaJIOrIIqHbIX npOII3-
Be.D;eHIIII CRYJIbllTYPHOll nJIaCTIIRII 3JIJIIIHIICTII'IeCROrO BOCTOqHOCpe,L(II3eMHO-
MOpCROrO IICRYCCTBa. ECTeCTBeHHO, 06CTOHTeJIbHOl\IY paCCl\IOTpemHO nO.D;Bepr-
HYTa B HIIX H np06JIeMa reHe31ICa CRYJIbnTypbI RyllaHCROll BaRTpIIII :II ee
B3aHl'.IOOTHOlleHHll C raH,lJ.XapCRIIl\I HCRYCCTBOl\I II HCRyCCTBOM ,L(pyrIIx pallO-
HOB OrpoMHoiir RYllaHCROll IIl'.IIIepIIII.
KpaTRIIe IITOrII l\IHOrOJIeTHerO IICCJIe,lJ.OBaIUIH r. A. llyra'IeHROBOll CKYJIbn-
TypbI XaJIqaHUa II AaJIbBep3IIHa CBe,lJ.eHbI R CJIe,lJ.YloID;eMY: «AHaJIlm nal\IHTHII-
KOB 6aRTpIIIICROrO BaHHIIH BbIHBJIHeT B HeM TplI OCHOBHbIX IICTOqHIIRa, CJIIIB-
llHXCH B e,lJ.IIHbIII llOTOR: npo<peCCIIOHaJIbHOe IICRYCCTBO aHTIIqHorO 6aRTpniir-
CRoro ropo.D;a, BIIIITaHillero BbICORIIe .D;OCTIIllieHIIH rpeqeCROll n;IIBIIJIII3an;II:II,
apxaII3IIpYIOID;YIO cTap06aRTpIIllCRYIO CTPYIO, xpamITeJIeM KOTOpOII 6bIJIO, no-
BH.D;IIMOMY, B OCHOBHOM ceJIO, II, uaROHen;, RYJIbTYPY RO'IeBOll CTenII. B JIyq-
llIIIX 06pa3n;ax 6aRTpIIMCRoro IICRYCCTBa TplI 3TIIX HaqaJIa npe,lJ.CTaIOT B He-
pa3pbtBHOM CIIHTe3e» 2. B CBOIIX IICCJIe,L(OBaHIIHX r. A. IIyraqeHROBa Heop;HO
RpaTHO 06paID;aeT BHIIMaHIIe Ha BbICORIIe peaJIIICTIIqeCR:IIe .D;OCTOHHCTBa n
nopTpeTHOCTb CRYJIbnTypbI XaJIqaHHa, qaCTIIqHO II ,IJ;aJIbBep3IIHa \ II p;allie
IICnOJIb3yeT XaJIqaHHCRIIII MaTepIIaJI B conOCTaBJIeHII:II C HYl\III3MaTIIqeCRIIM
.D;JIH peROHCTpYRn;JUI IIROHorpa<pIIII repaH . . .
BneqaTJIHIOIl(IIll peaJIII3M II nopTpeTHOCTb XaJIqaHHCRIIX CRYJIbnTYP ,lJ.aJIlI
B03l\IOlliHOCTb IICCJIe,lJ.OBaTeJIbHIIn;e OCTaHOBIITbCH II Ha aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKlIX
oc06eHHOCTHX II300pallieHHbIX. qTo6bI ,lJ.aTb nOJIHOe npe,lJ.CTaBJIeHIIe 0 ee
TpaRTOBRe 9Toro Bonpoca, npIIBe,lJ.Y npOCTpaHHYIO n;IITaTY H3 pa60TbI, nOCBH-
ID;eHHOll ImOHorpa<pIIII repaH: «HII O.D;HO JIIIn;O He nOBTopHeT ,lJ.Pyroro, Bce
OUII rJIy60Ro IIH,lJ.IIBII,lJ.yaJIbHbI, nO-BII;],IIMOMY, nopTpeTHbI, nepe,lJ.aBaH B03
paCT, TeMnepaMeHT, nepCOHaJIbUbIe OTJIIIqIIH qepT. A Mem.D;Y TeM aHTpOnOJIO-
I'IIqeCRIIll T:IIn IIX HBHO eL\IIH. XapaRTepHbI ueRoTopoe 3ana,L(aHHe JIIIHIIII ..31:6a
Y cepeJ(IIHbI II pe3Roe naBIIcaHIIe Ha,lJ. nepeHoCIIn;ell, npII,lJ.aIOID;ee JIlln;allI OII-
pe.D;eJIeHHYIO CypOHOCTb, npaBII.:IbHbIll HeRPynHbIll HOC, He60JIbillaH CRYJIaC-
TOCTb, nO.D;RBa,L(paTHOe O"IepTaHUe HIImHell qeJIIOCTII, Bblpa3IITeJIbHbIII pOT .C
npIInYXJIOM HIIlliHell ry60ir. rJIa3a Y,L(JIlIHeHHOro pa3pe3a, HO 6e3 MaJIellillerO
npII3HaRa MOHrOJIbCROII CRJIa;J:RII, o,lJ.HaRO npII oRpaCRe cTaTyi'I cRy.rlbnTop OT-
qepRHYJI BeRII RpacRoM, Y.D;JIUHIIB IIX HeCROJIbRO BROCb !{ BIICKal\I. 3aTbIJIOqHaJI
qaCTb CIIJIbHO YIIJIoID;eHa - B03MOJI{HO, '1'1'0 3'1'0 CBH3aHO He TOJIbRO C oc06eH-
HOCTHMII cal\Ioii: CRYJIbnTYPHoii JIenRII (nOCKOJIbRY <PIIrypbI BXO;:!ILlII B ro-
peJIbe<pHbIe ROl\In03IIn;IIII II rO.1:0BbI nOqTII conpIIKaCaJIIICb CO cTeHoll), HO '11':0
3.D;ecb nepe.D;aeTCH Ta ynJIOID;eHHOcTb, ROTopaH B Ta,lJ.lliIIRCROll, Y36eRCRoH,
YllrYPCRoll cpe,J,e nOJIyqaeTCH B pe3YJIbTaTe npHBH3bIBaHIIH l\IJIa,L(eHn;a R nJIO-o
CRO.D;OIIHOM JIIOJIbRe - 6ellIIRY. BnOJIHe BepoHTHo, '1'1'0 HallIn cRyJIbnTypHbre
rOJIOBbI OTpamaIOT O,lJ.HY :II3 pa3HOBII,lJ.HOCTell IICRYCCTBeHHOll .D;e<popl\Ian;IIII qe-
pena, ROTopaH 6bIJIa CTOJIb TIITIIlqna ,lJ.JIH MHorIIX HapO,L(OB ,L(peBHOCTII. a B TypR-
MeHCROII cpe.D;e COXpaHHJIaCb eID;e ,lJ.0 He;J.aBuero BpeMeHII. M ynJIOID;eHnbtII 3a-
TbIJIOR, H ROCTHoe HaBIIcaHIIe JI6a Ha,L( nepeHOCIIn;eM npII 3aRaTaHHOll <popMe
ero HaBepxy - Bce 3'1'0 l\IorJIO ObITb BbI3BaHO nepeTHlliROll .D;eTCRoro qepena
Cnen;IIaJIbHbIM 6IIHTOM; Y B3pOCJIbIX llie COXpaHHJICH Y3RIIll peMeHb RaR 06H3a-
TeJIbHaH .D;eTaJIb nepexBaTa BOJIOC.
OnIIcaHHble CRYJIbnTypHbIe rOJIOBbI npIIHap;JIelliaT R TOM pacoBoM RaTero-
pIIII, ROTOpyIO aHTpOnOJIOrII IIlIIeHYIOT "eBpOneOII,lJ.HOll pacoM Cpe,lJ.Hea3IIaTCRO-
1'0 Mem,L(ypeTIbJI", C np:IICYID;:IIl\I:II .D;JIH Ollpe,L(eJIeHHOrO nJIeMeHHOro COCTaBa cnoe-
327
"
06pa3IIeM H CXO,l:t;CTBOM 9THIIqeCROrO TIIna fI, OqeBII,l:t;HO, Tpa,L(Hn;IIOHHOM ,l:t;JIH
AaHHOrO nJIeMeH:II nO.D;CTpHJI\ROll paCTHTeJIbHOCTII» 5.
KaROBbI np:IIqIIHbJ 06paID;eHIIH aHTpOnOJIOra R paCCMOTpeHI'IlO XaJIqaHH-
KHX H .D;aJIbBep3HHCRIIX CTaTYll? qacTHqHO OHII YRa3aHbI BbIlle - 3TO IIX
nOpTpeTHOCTb H BbICORaH CTeneHb COBepmeHCTBa B nepe,l:t;a'Ie .D;eTaJIell JIIIn;a.
CRyJI!.nTYPHbJe rOJIOBbI II3 .D:aJIbBep3IIHa BbIIIOJIHeHbI B HeCROJIbRO 60JIee YC-
JIOBHOM ;\IaHepe, HO II B HHX MOmHO BII,l:t;eTb C BbICOROM .D;OJIeII BepOHTHOCTII
nOpTpeTHble H306pameH:IIH. OL\HaRO ,L(eJIO He TOJIbRO B aTOM. IIaJIeoaHTpono-
JlOrIIH BaRTp:IIII Ha Py6eme HailleM 9p:bI, R ROTOPOMY OTHOCIITCH paCCMaTpIIBa-
eMaH CRYJIbnTypa, npe,L(CTaBJIeHa JIIIllb He60JIbillOll cepuell qepenOB II3 pac-
KonOR M. M. .D:bHRoHoBa Ha ropo,l:t;IIID;e Tyn-XoHa, pacnOJIOmeHHOM Ha Tep-
p:IITOpIIII r:IICCapCRoro p-Ha Ta,l:t;mIIRCROll CCP. IIorpe6eHIIH, H3 ROTOpbIX
npOIICxO.D;HT 'Iepena, .D;aTIIpYIOTCH BpeMeIIeM OT I B. .D;O H. 3. ,l:t;0 VIII B.
H. 9. M He60JIbillOe ROJIHqeCTBO ,l:t;06bITbIX naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIX MaTep:IIa-
JIOB, H HX He OqeHb onpe.D;eJIeHHaH .D;aTIIpOBRa B ll:IIpOKI2lX XpOHOJIOrIIqeCR:IIX
npe.D;eJIax JIIIllaIOT 3TY RpaHHOJIOrHqeCRYIO cepIIIO cepbe3Horo 3HaqeHIIH. Mc-
CJIe.D;OBaBllHll ee B. B. rIIH36ypr .D;IIarHOCTIIpOBaJI ee RaR OTHOCHID;YIOCH R
THny Cpe,l:t;Hea3HaTCRoro Mem.D;ypeqbH II OTMeT:IIJI CJIa6yIO MOHrOJIOII.D;Hyro npII-
MeCb 6. Ho nO.D;TBep.D;IITb nOCJIe.D;Hee 3aRJIIOqeHHe TOqHbIMII RpaHIIOMeTpIIqe-
CRIIMH H3MepeHIIHMII He y,l:t;aeTCH, :II OHO OCTaeTCH Bl'[3yaJIbHbIM BneqaTJIeHII-
eM; '1'1'0 me RacaeTCH nepBoro BbIBO.D;a, TO xapaRTep caMOll cepIIII He n03-
ilOJIHeT 3RCTpanOJIIIpOBaTb ero Ha HaCeJIeHIIe oRpya\alOID;:IIX TeppHTopIIM B
npoCTpaHCTBe II JIORaJIH30BaTb BO BpeMeH:II. OT.D;eJIbUbIe e.D;HHHqHbJe HaXO,l:t;RII
MaJIO MeHHIOT ,l:t;eJIO 7.
Ho :II CRY,l:t;HOCTb naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOr:IIqeCROrO MaTepHaJIa B .D;aHHOM CJIyqae
He :IICqepnbIBaeT IIPIIqIIH, ROTOpbJe 3aCTaBJIHIOT 06paTHTbCH R aHaJIII3Y IIRO-
Horpa<pIIII. MHe yme npIIXO.D;IIJIOCb OTMeqaTb ee caMOCTOHTeJIbHOe 3Haqe-
H:IIe 8, B CRYJIbnTypHbIX II mHBonIICHbIX II306pameH:IIHX npOllJIbIX 3nox OT-
pameH 06JIHR iRIIBbIX JIIO,l:t;ell, II OHII .D;OnOJIHHIOT naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRI'Ill
MaTepIIaJI TaR me, RaR ,L(OnOJIHHIOT ero COMaTOJIOrIIqeCRIIe .D;3HHbJe, T. e.
o60raID;aIOT Hac 3HaHueM CTpoeHIIH MHrRIIX TRaHell JIIIn;a, qaCTUqHO II nIIr-
MeHTan;IIU, ROTOpbJe HeOnpe.D;eJIHM:bI Ha qepene II CReJIeTe. 1l09TOMY .D;ame B
Tex CJIyqaHX, KOr,L(a MbI UMeeM 60raTbJe RpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCRIIe KOJIJIeKn;IIU, RaR,
narrpIIMep, C TeppIITopIIII .D:peBHero Er:IInTa, aHTpOnOJIOr:IIqeCROe IICCJIe,L(OBa-
H:IIe .D;peBHeerHneTcRoM cRYJIbnTypbI IIMeJIO 6bI nepBOCTerreHHoe RaR Y3ROMOP-
cJ>OJIOrR'IeCROe, TaR II IICTOpIIRO-3THoreHeTIIqeCROe 3HaqeH:IIe.
1l0.D;xo.D; R CRYJIbnTypHOMY npmI3Be,l:t;eHIIIO RaR R aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRoMy IIC-
TO'IH:IIRY caM no ce6e CTaBUT MHoro np06JIeM. He06xo.D;:IIMO y<IIITbIBaTb II ypo-
BeB!. xY.D;omeCTBeHHOll RYJIbTypbI .D;aHHorO 06ID;eCTBa B TOT HJr:II IIHOM OTpe30R
BpeMeH:II, npe.D;onpep;eJrHIOID;Hii CTeneHb <popMaJIbHOrO COBeplleHCTBa B BOC-
rrpOII3Be,L(eHUH HaTypbI, B TOM qHCJIe II qeJIOBeqeCROrO JIIIn;a; H rocnop;CTBYIO-
Hll CTUJIb, B paMRax ROToporo ROJIe6aHIIH 0'1' CTpeMJIeHIIH R BHeillHeMY
npaB,L(OnOll06IIIO ,l:t;0 nOJIHOrO ero OTpIIn;aHIIH npIIBO.D;HT R npHMO npOTI'lBOnO-
JIOmHbIM xy,l:t;OmeCTBeHHbIM pemeHIIHM; H :IIH,l:t;:IIB:II,L(yaJIbHOCTb TBOpn;a, C03,l:t;alO-
ID;aH 3HaqIITeJIbHbIll ,l:t;IIana30H OTRJIOHeHIIll 0'1' <pOTorpa<pIf1IeCROrO RonIIpOBa-
nIIH H3TYPbI; II orpOMHYIO aMnJIIITY,L(Y B BbI60pe Toro, 'ITO <pHRcupyeTcH
XY,L(OmHIIROM B JIHn;e qeJIOBeRa RaR T:IInII'IHoe. qT06bI C.D;eJIaTb nepBbJe marII
B OCBoeHHH aHTpOnOJIOrOM CRYJIbnTyp:bI RaR aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO HCTOqHIIRa,
MbI OCTaBJIHeM 9TII 06CTOHTeJIbCTBa 6e3 BHHMaHUH, YCJIOBHO :IICXO.D;H U3 Be-
pOHTHoro, XOTfI II He,l:t;ORa3aHHoro, npe.D;nOJIOmeHIIH, '1'1'0 peaJIHCTU'IeCRIIll xa-
paRTep CRYJIbnTypbI B ,l:t;aHHOM CJIyqae (nJIaCTHRa XaJIqaHHa :II .D:aJIbBep3HHa)
C03,L(aeT ,L(OCTaTOqHYIO OCHOBY .D;JIH cym.D;eHHH 06 aHTpOnOJIOr:IIqeCR:IIX oc06eH-
HOCTHX OCTaBIIBllIIX IIX nonYJIHn;Hll.
328
O.D;HaKO nO,lJ.OOHOe IICXO,lJ;HOe nOJIOllieHIIe, n03BOJIHIOID;ee OTBJIe'IbCH 0'1' ne-
pe'I:IICJIeHHbIX BbIlle BOnpOCOB, ROTOpble XOTH :II Ha3peJIII, HO He MOryT 6bITL
Cell'IaC pelleHbI II Tpe6YlOT .D;JIH ,}Toro cOBoRynHblx YCIIJIIIM IICRyCCTBOBe,lJ;OB.
:IICTOpIIROB RYJIbTypbI II aHTpOnOJIOrOB, caMO no ce6e He npe,L(orrpe.D;eJIHeT BLI-
60pa ROHRpeTHOll MeTO.D;:IIRII IICCJIe.D;OBaHIIH. MOlliHO, HanpIIMep, BII3yaJI:bnO
On;eHIIBaTb CXO,lJ.CTBO CRYJIbnTYPHbIX II lliIIBonIICHbIX nopTpeTOB C TeMII :IIJIH
:IIHbIMII paCOBbIMII ROM6IIHan;IIHMII, '1'1'0 HeO.D;HOKpaTHO geJIaJIOCb 9, HO TaRoii
no.D;xo.D; MaJIO OTJIII'IaeTCH 0'1' onpe,lJ.eJIeHIIH paCOBoro TIIna :IIH.D;IIBII.D;YYMa-
npOn;e,lJ.ypbI, OCTaBJIeHHOll cOBpeMeHHoM aHTpOnOJIOrIIell. r. <fl. .D:e6en; BBeJI B
:IICCJIeJ],OBaHIIe TaRoro cnen;II<pIIqeCROrO MaTepIIaJIa, RaR TallTbmCRIIe IIorpe-
6aJIbHbI8 MacRII, Ro:ulqeCTBeHHbIll MOM.eHT, Bblpa3IIB B rpa,lJ.ycax ropII30H-
TaJIbHbIll npo<p:IIJIb Cpe.D;Hero OT.D;eJIa JIIIl(a II nO.D;CqIITaB npOn;eHT BCTpeqaeMO-
CTII HeRoTopbIX Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCRIIX BapIIan;IIll, B nepBYIO Oqepe.D;b B HOCOBOii
06JIaCTII IO . Ha 3TOM OCHOBaHIIII Y,lJ.aJIOCb C,lJ.eJIaTb BbIBO,lJ. 0 6JIII30CTII aHTpo-
IIOJIOrIIqeCROrO TIIna TallTbmCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH R Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCRIIM ROM6IIHa-
n;IIHM, 3a<pIIKCIIpOBaHHbIM Y llOpn;eB II xaRaCOB. Ho <popMaJIII30BaHHbIll no).l;-
XO,lJ. II B 3TOM CJIyqae OXBaTIIJI JIIImb HeROTOpbI8 ,L(eTaJIII CTpoeHIIH MMKHX
TKaHell JIIIn;a.
H3yqEHIIE CKY.lIbllTYP AAJlbBEP311HA II XA.lI HHA
C TIOMOm;bIO COMATOJlOrllQECKOH METOAIIKII
ITpe,L(CTaBJIHeTCH n;eJIeC006pa3HbIM, no B03MOlliHOCTII, nOJIHOCTblO IICnOJIb30-
IiaTb npIIMeHIITeJIbHO R aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOMY II3yqeHIUO cRYJIbnTypbI II3 XaJI-
"IaHHa II .D:aJIbBep3IIHa OnbIT, IIaROnJIeHHbIII B COMaTOJIOrIIII 11. ::no 03HaqaeT-
<pIIKcan;IIIO 3JIeMeHTOB MHrRIIX TRaHeII JIIln;a Ha CRYJIbnType TaK, RaR eCJIH
6bI nepe.D; HaMIl 6bIJI lliIIBOII cy6'beRT, T. e. C nOMoID;bIO 6aJIJIOB, Ram,lJ.bIM :II3
ROTOpbIX OTpalliaeT onpe,L(eJIeHHbIll' BapIIaHT. Pa3YMeeTCH, peqb MOllieT II.D;TH
TOJIbRO 06 onIICaTeJIbHbIX npII3HaRax, II3MepeHIIe CRYJIbnTypbI, RaR JIerRO no-
HHTb, COBeplleHHO 6eCCMbICJIeHHO. .D:allie onpe,L(eJIeHIIe :IIH,iJ;eRCOB, T. e. OTHo-
meHlIll .D;BYX pa3MepOB, HeB03MOlliHO 1I3-3a TPY,lJ.HOCTII <p:IIRCan;IIII TOqeR, n3
ROTOpbIe onIIpaIOTCH pa3MepbI. qTO llie RacaeTCH orrIICaTeJIbHbIX npII3HaROB.
TO OHII, 3a IICRJIIOqeHIIeM HeMHorIIX CJIyqaeB, JIerRO <PIIRCIIpYIOTCH Ha CRYJIbn-
TypHbIX nopTpeTax II onpe,lJ.eJIeHIIH IIX npaRTlIqeCRII nOJIHOCTbIO CpaBH:IIMbI co
CTaH,lJ.apTHbIMII COMaTOJIOrIIqeCRIIM:II ,lJ.aHHbIMII.
O,lJ.HaRO, npem,L(e qeM nepeMT:II R paCCMOTpeHIIIO pe3YJIbTaTOB npIIMeHenHJi
COMaTOJIOrlIqeCROll MeTOJ],IIRII R II3yqeHIIIO XaJIqaHHCRIIX :II ,lJ.aJIbBep3IIHCRDX
CRYJIbnTypHbIX nopTpeTOB, OTMeqy ,lJ.Ba MOMeHTa, ROTOpbIe <PIIRCIIpYIOTCH BH-
3yaJIbHO, - CTpoeHIIe M03rOBoro qepena II nlIrMeHTan;IIIO. 1:13 npIIBe,lJ.eHHOn B
HaqaJIe CTaTbII n;IITaTbI HCHO BIIgHO, '1'1'0 r. A. ITyraqeHROBa Cq:IITaeT BeCbMa
BepOHTHbIM npOHBJIeHIIe ROJIbn;eBOll ,lJ.e<p0pMan;IIII Ha CRYJIbiiTYPHbIX rOJIOBaX
:II3 XaJIqaHHa. B ,lJ.OnOJIHeHIIe R ee aprYMeHTan;IIII MOlliHO YRa3aTb Ha noJIY-
'IeHHYIO C nOMoID;blO 6aJIJIOBOII xapaRTepIICTIIRII (TaOJI. 24) aprYMeHTan;IIIO B
rrOJIb3Y 3Haq:IITeJIbHOll ynJIOID;eHHOCTII JI06HOll ROCTII, conpOBOlli.D;aIOID;eMcH
CIIJIbHbIM Ha.D;6poBbel\I. MumHO 6bIJIO 6bI ,lJ.YMaTb, '1'1'0 TaRIIe nORa3aTeJIlI npo-
nCTeRalOT 3a CqeT cyry60 Imp:IIBII,L(yaJIbHOrO cnoc06a IlX onpe,L(eJIeHI'IH, na 'IT(')
Yllie YRa3bIBaJIOCb B JIIITepaType 12, HO B ,lJ.aJIbBep3IIHCROll nonYJIHn;II:II HeT IllI
Toro, BII ,lJ.pyroro, II BapIIan;IIII, II HaRJIOH JI6a, II pa3BIITIIe Ha,L(6pOBbH He
BbIXO.D;HT 3a npe,lJ.eJIbI COBpel\IeHHbIX Cpe,lJ.HIIX. MOlliHO rrOJIaraTb n09TOMY, '1TO
CJIellbI ROJIbn;eBOll ,lJ.e<popMan;IIII Ha CRYJIbnTypHbIX rOJIOBaX :II3 XaJIqaHHa no'l-
'I'll HeCOMHeHHbI. qTO llie RacaeTCH npOIlCXOlli.D;eHIIH II apeaJIa 9TOM ).I;e<popMa-
l(IIn, HBJIHIOID;ellCH B 3HaqIITeJIbHOM Mepe CJIe.D;CTBIIeM npe6bIBaHIIH B 6eIIIIIKe
B .D;eTCROM B03paCTe, TO apeaJI 9TOT He OrpaHII'IIIBaeTCH TOJIbRO nepe'IIICJIeH-
329
...-- ---
CI)
CI)
o
-- ,
-. .'0 XaJI'IaHH .D:aJIbBep3HH
co I I
: Mym'luHbI }HeHIQUHbI MymQIlHbJ lReHIQHH:6I
IIpu3HaH HJIaccbJ pa3BHTHH npH3HaHa npOl.jCHT npOI1eHT r""" npOI1eHT
'1HCJIO HHJUIQllH QIlCJIO HaJIHqUH 'fUICJIO HaJIlI"1JI1IT '1HCJIO Ha.TIH'IHH
Ha6mo;o;e- IIJII1 Ha15mo;o;e- llIDI Ha6JIIO;O; e- HJIIl Ha6mo;o;e- HJIH
HHfi cpe;O;Hufi Hufi Cpe;o;HHfi HHfi Cpe;o;HIlM HllM cpe;o;Hufi
6aJIJI 15aJIJI 6aJIJI 6aJIJI
POCT 60PO;JJ;bI Cpe;JJ;HlIH (3) 12 85,8 - - 1 100,0 - -
ClIJIbHbIH (4) 1 7,1 - - - - - -
O'leHb CIIJIbHbIH (5) 1 7,1 - - - - - -
Cpe;JJ;Hui\ 6amI 14 3,21 - - 1 3,00 - -
POCT 6pOBeH Cpe;JJ;HJlH uaJIJI 22 :J,OO 9 3,00 2 :J,OO 2 3,00
HaRJIOH JI6a CJlJIbHO HaRJIOHeH (1) 10 43,5 3 33,0 - - - -
CJIa60 HaRJIOHeH (2) 10 4:3,5 3 :33,3 4 57,1 3 50.0
TIPHMOi\: (3) 3 13,0 3 33,4 3 -'12,9 3 50,0
Cpe;JJ;lUIH uaJIJI 23 1,70 9 2,00 7 2,43 G 2,50
Pa3BuTIIe Ha;JJ;6poBbH CJIauoe ( 1) 3 1:J,O 5 55,G 4 57,1 G 100,0
Cpe;JJ;Hee (2) 10 4:J,5 4 -'14,4 2 28,6 - -
CrIJIbIIOe (3). 10 43,5 - - 1 14,3 - -
Cpe;JJ;HIIH 6aJIJI 23 2,30 9 1,44 7 1,57 6 1,00
(D0pMa BOJIOC TIpHMbIe 7 53,9 5 62,5 - - 2 50,0
BOJIIUICTbIe G 46,1 3 37,5 2 100,0 2 50,0
IlIJlplIHa rJIa3HOH lI\eJIH Cpe;JJ;HHH (2) 1 4,5 1 11,1 2 25,0 - -
EOJIbllIaH (3) 21 95,5 8 88,9 6 75,0 6 100,0
Cpe;JJ;HHH 6aJIJI 22 2,95 9 2,89 8 2,75 G 3,00
HaRJIOH rJIa3HOH lI\eJIIJ HapymHbIH yroJI HHme (1) 2 8,7 1 11,1 1 12,5 2 33,4
rOpII30HTaJIbHbIH (2) 12 52,2 5 55,6 7 87,5 3 50,0
HapymIIbIii yroJI BbIIIIe (3) 9 39,1 3 33,3 - - 1 16,6
Cpe;JJ;IIIdi 6aJIJI 23 2,30 9 2,22 8 1.88 6 1,83
8IIIIRaHTYc OTCYTcTByeT 23 100,0 9 100,0 8 100,0 6 100,0
CRJIa;JJ;Ra BepXHero BeRa OTCYTcTByeT 20 95,2 7 77,8 8 100,0 6 100,0
B IIpORCIIMaJIbHOH '1aCTH (p) CJIauaJI (1) - - 1 11,1 - - - -
Cpe;JJ;HHJI (2) 1 4,8 1 11,1 - - - -
Cpe;JJ;HlIH 6aJIJI 21 0,10 9 0,33 8 0,00 6 0,00
CRJIa;JJ;Ra BepXHero BeRa OTCYTcTByeT 20 95,2 7 77,8 8 100,0 6 100,0
B Me;JJ;llaJIbHOH '1aCTH (m) CJIa6aH (1) - - 1 11,1 - - - -
Cpe;JJ;HHJI (2) 1 4,8 1 11,1 - - - -
Cpe;JJ;IIIIH 6aJIJI 21 0,10 9 0,33 8 0,00 6 0,00
CKJIa}J;Ka BepxHero BeRa OTCYTcTByeT 21 100,0 8 88;9 8 100,0 6 100,0
B ;JJ;llcTaJIbHOH '1aCTH (d) CJIa6aJI (1) - - - - - - - -
Cpe;JJ;HJIJI (2) - - 1 11,1 - - - -
Cpe;JJ;HIIH 6aJIJI 21 0,00 9 0,22 8 0,00 6 0,00
Ta6n:uqa 24
OJlocJlHoiinORpoB Ha Jluqe, 06J1aCTI> Jl6a u rJlas
........
- - - .. - --
. .- ..
,.. . . . m._
_.. -,
,.......,.-.c
-
-
" . -
-.. -
Ta6J1un;a 25
I1pO(I>HJlI> JlHn;a H 06J1aCTI> l'y6
....
Xa.rrqaRH .D;a.rrbBep3UI!
MymqUHbI I meHlljHHbI MymqHHbI I meHlljHHbI
IIpH3HaI< RJIaCCbI pa3BHTIID npH3HaI<a npOljeHT npOljeHT rrpOIjel!T npOIleHT
qHCJIO HaJIII'f:IllH qHCJIO HaJIll'tIllH 'tUIC&O naJIJIqJIH -':IJICJIO HaJBlqJIH
Ha6JIIo;re- UJIH lIa6JIIo;I\e- llJUI lIa6JIIo;I\e- JIJUI Ha6JIIo;re- UJIH
Huii Cpe;I\HHii HIm Cpe;I\HHii HId! Cpe;I\H IDt HHM: Cpe;I\I!Htt
6aJIJI 6aJIJI 6aJIJI 6aJIJI
rOpH30HTaJlbHbIH npoqHl:Jlb TIJIOClmH (1) - - 1 11,1 - - ..., -
JlH.qa Cpcp;mIH (2) 1 4,3 1 11,1 - - - -
OCTpbIH (3) 22 95,7 7 77,8 8 100,0 6 100,0
CpCP;HHH uaJIJI 23 2,96 9 2,()7 8 3,00 6 3,00
BbIcTynaIUIc CKyJl CJIauoc (1) 23 100.0 8 88.9 8 100,0 6 100,0
CpCP;HCC (2) - - - - - - - -
CUJIhIlOC (:J) - - 1 11,1 - - - -
Cpe.n;nTlrr uaJ1JI 2" 1,00 9 1,22 8 1,00 6 1,00
,J
BbICoTa BcpxHeH ryobI MaJIa}! (1) 4 19,0 2 25,0 4 50,0 5 83,4
CpC.n;HHH (2) 9 43,0 4 50.0 3 37.5 1 16,6
EOJIbmaH (3) 8 38,0 2 25;0 1 12,5 - -
CpC.n;HHH uaJIJI 21 2,19 8 2,00 8 1,88 6 1,17
BbIcTynamw BCpXHCH l'y6bI ITpoxci'rJIJm (1) 5 23,8 3 42,9 1 12,5 1 16,6
OpTOXCHJIHH (2) 15 71,/1 4 57.1 7 87.5 5 83,4
OIIHcToxcrIJIJm (3) 1 4,8 - - - - - -
Cpc.n;mIH 6aJIJI 21 1,81 7 1.57 8 1,88 6 1,83
«TOJlII\HHa» BepxHcH I'YObI MaJIaH (1) 8 38,0 3 37,5 4 57,1 2 33,4
Cpcp;mur (2) 9 43,0 1 12,5 3 42,9 3 50,0
EOJIbmaH (3) 4 19,0 4. 50,0 - - 1 16,6
Cpc):\mlrI oaJIJI 21 1,81 R 2.13 7 1,43 6 1,89
«TOJlIn;HHa» HHiRHeH ryobI MaJI3H (1) 2 9.5 2 25;0 - - 1 16,6
CPC):\HHH (2) 7 33,4 2 25,0 5 71,4 3 50,0
EOJIbm3H (3) 12 57,1 3 37,5 2 28,6 2 33,4
O'leHb 60JIbm3H (4) --. - 1 12,5 - - - -
Cpe.n;mIH 6row 21 2,48 8 2,38 7 2,29 6 2,17
BJitCTynaHHe nop;6opo):\Ka OTcTynaIOII\HH (1) 1 9.1 1 14,3 .. - - -
CPC):\HHH (2) 1 9,1 3 . 42,9 1 16,6 3 50,0
BbIcTyrraIOII\HH (3) {I R1.8 3 42,8 6 83,4 3 50,0
Cpep;HHH 03JIJI 11 2,73 7 2,29 7 2,86 6 2,50
Ta6J1un;a 26
CTpOCHUC Hoca
XaJl'IaJIH .D;aJIbBep3IJ:H
Mym'lIJ:HbI I }I\eHl.QIJ:HbI Mym'lIJ:HbI I meHl.QHHbI
IIpIJ:3HaR HJIaCCbI pa3BIJ:TIJ:H npIJ:3HaRa npO.QeHT npO.QeHT npO.QeHT npO.QeHT
'1IJ:CJIO HaJIJI'tIIIH '1IJ:CJIO HaJIJI1-lIIH '1IJ:CJIO HaJInqIIH 'llICJIO HaJIJI'fUIH
HaCiJIIo;I\e- IiJIIJ: Ha6JIIo;I\e- IIJIn na6JIIo;I\e- IJ:JIIJ: Ha6JIIo;I\e- IiJIIJ:
HIJ:tt cpe;I\HIill HIJ:1t cpelumt! HIJ:t! CPC;I\11lI1t nun Cpe;I\HIJ:tt
6aJIJI 6aJIJI 6aJIJI 6aJIJI
N
B.bICOTa nepeHOC.bH Cpep;HHH (2) 1 4,3 1 12,5 1 12,5 1 16,6
BOJIJ,maH (3) 22 95,7 7 87,5 7 87,5 5 KI,4
Cpc.n;IIlrii oaJIJI 23 2,96 8 2,88 8 2,88 6 2,83
TIonCpe'lHbIH npo«fJllJI.b IIJIoclUlH (1) 1 4,3 - - - - - -
cnHHRH Hoca Cpcp;uu:ii (2) 2 8,6 1 12,5 3 37,5 3 50,0
OCTpLIH (3) 20 87,1 7 87,5 5 62,5 3 50,0
CpCp;HtIH oaJIJI 23 2,83 8 2,88 8 2,63 6 2,50
IIpo«fJHJI.b ROCTHOH '1aCTH BornYTLIH (1) 1 4,5 - - 1 12,5 - -
CUHHRH Hoca ITpJjIlWll: (2) 15 68,5 6 85,7 6 75,0 5 83,4
BbII1YRJILIII (3) 6 27,0 1 14,3 1 12,5 1 16,6
CPCp;HlIH oaJIJI 22 2,23 7 2,14 8 2,00 6 2,17
IIpo«fJHJI.b XpHIlJ,CBOH '1aCTH BOI'HYT.bIH (1) 2 10,0 - - - - - -
cnHHRU Hoca ITPHMOH (2) 13 65,0 6 100,0 7 87,5 4 66,6
B.bIITYRJI.bIH (3) 5 250 - - 1 12,5 2 :)3,4
Cpep;IIlIll: oaJIJI 20 . 2:15 6 2,00 8 2,13 6 2,33
OOIlJ,HH npo«fJHJI.b CnHHRH BOrHYTbIH . 1 5,0 - - 1 12,5 - -
Hoca ITpHMOH 12 60,0 5 83,4 4 50,0 3 50,0
BbIITYI{JIbIH 7 35,0 1 16,6 3 37,5 3 50,0
TIOJIOmCHHe ROH'IHRa Hoca TIpHIIop;HHToe (1) 8 50,0 2 40,0 4 80,0 2 40,0
rOpH30HTaJIbHOC (2) 4 25,0 3 60,0 1 20,0 3 60,0
OnYIlJ,eHHoe (3) 4 25,0 - - - - - -
Cpep;HHH oaJIJI 16 1,75 5 1,60 5 1,20 5 1,60
TIOJIOmeHHe OCHOBaHHH ITprIITOp;HHTOC (1) 7 43,8 2 40,0 a 60,0 1 20,0
Hoca rOpH30HTaJIbHOe (2) 6 37,5 3 60,0 2 40,0 4 80,0
OnYIlJ,eHHOe (3) 3 18,7 - - - - - -
Cpep;HHH oaJIJI 16 1,75 5 1,60 5 1,40 5 1,80
Ta6JUnw 21
CTpoeHHe RpbIJIbeB Hoca H H03J.qJeii
w
w
w
XaJI'IaHH .D:aJIbBCp3I1H
MymqI1HbI I iRCHmnHbI MymQI1HbI I mCHmnHbI
IIpI13HaH RJIaCCbI pa3BI1TI1H rrpI13HaHa npOI1CHT npOI1CIIT npOI1CHT npOI1CIIT
qnCJIO HaJIII'fUIH QI1CJIO Ha;rmQI1lI QI1CJIO HaJIJPIJIn QI1CJIO HaJIJ!'fUIrr
Ha6mo.u;c- IIJUI Ha6JI1o.u;c- IiJII1 Ha6mo.u;c- I1JII1 Ha6mo.u;c- I1JII1
HIIM: CPCAHI1fi HI1fi cpc.u;HIm HI1M CPC.u;HI1M HI1fi CpeAHI1M
6aJIJI 6aJIJI 6aJIJI 6aJIJI
BbICOTa KpbIJIbeB Hoca MaJIau (1) 3 18,8 2 33,4 3 50,0 3 60,0
CpegHuH (2) 7 43,7 1 16,6 - - 2 40,0
EOJIbillaU (3) 6 37,5 3 50,0 3 50,0 - -
CpegHlIM 6aJIJI 16 2,19 6 2.17 6 2,00 5 1,40
BbIcTynaHHe KpbIJIbeB Hoca MaJIoe (1) 5 31,3 1 16,6 - - - -
CpegHee (2) 4 25,0 2 3:J,4 2 33,4 1 20,0
EOJIbillOU (3) 7 43,7 3 50,0 4 66,6 4 80,0
CpegHlIii 6aJIJI 16 2,13 6 2,33 6 2,67 5 2,80
BblpaiKuHIIocTb KpbIJIbeBbIX CJIa6au (1) 4 25,0 2 40,0 6 100,0 4 80,0
60p03g CpegHuu (2) 6 37,5 2 40,0 - - 1 20,0
CHJIbHaU (3) 6 37,5 1 20,0 - - - -
Cpu HlIii 6aJIJI 16 2,13 5 1,80 6 1,00 5 1,20
CJIHJunre KpbIJIbUBOii 60- HeT CJIHUHHU (1) - - 1 20,0 - - -,c -
p03gbI C Hocory6Hoii ECTb CJIHUHHe (2) 11 68,7 4 80,0 6 100,0 5 100,0
06pa3YIOT IIPUMYIO JUI- 5 31,3 - - - -- - -
HHIO (3)
CpCgInI}I 6aJIJI 16 2,:11 5 1,80 6 2,00 5 2,00
TIOJIOiKeHlIe OCCM H03}JJJeM TIoIIcpc'IHoe (1) 1 11,1 - - - - - -
CpegHc!' (2) 5 55,5 2 100,0 2 50,0 1 33,4
CarHTTam,IIoe (3) 3 33,4 - - 2 50,0 2 66,6
CpegInI}I oaJIJI 9 2,22 2 2,00 4 2,50 3 2,67
(}:J0pMa H03Apeil KpyrJIau (1) 1 11,1 1 50,0 - - 1 33,3
TpeyroJIbH3U (2) 4 44,4 1 50,0 - - 1 33,3
OB3JIbH3H (3) 4 44,5 - - 4 100,0 1 33,4
CpegInI}I 63JIJI 9 2,33 2 1,50 4 3,00 3 2,00
HOH r. A. IIyraqeHRoBoll Y36eRCROll, TaAm:IIRCROll II YllrYPCROll 9THIIqeCROH
Cpe.D;Oll, HO III:lIpORO XBaTbIBaJI B ApeBHOCT:II, IIOMIIMO Cpe.D;Hell A3IIlI, TepplI-
TOplIIO llepe.D;Hell A3lIlI II KaBRa3a. E. B. 1RlIpOB CqIITaJI .D;a.me pe3YJIbTaTOM
,rJ;eIICTBlIJI 6elllIRa B n;eJIOM IIIlIpOKOe paCnpOCTpaHeHlIe 6paXlIRe<paJIlIlI B lle-
pe,L(Hell II Cpe,L(Hell A3lIlI IS, '1'1'0 He HaIIIJIO, npaBAa, nO,L(,L(epiRRII y APyrlIx
IICCJIe.D;OBaTeJIell a. KCTaTlI rOBopH, npOTIIB ynJIOID;eHHOCTlI 3aTbIJIRa RaR
CJIe,L(CTBIIH rOpeJIbe<pHoro xapaRTepa CRYJIbnTYP rOBoplIT II paBHOMepHoe pac-
IIllIpeHIIe rOJIOBbI 0'1' 06JIaCT:II JI6a Ha3aA, HeCOMHeHHO CBII.D;eTeJIbCTBYIOIl(ee 0
6paXlIRe<paJIlIlI.
PaCCMaTplIBaeMbJe CTaTYII 6bIJIlI paCRpalleHbI, II CJIeAbI 9TOll paCKpaCR11
COXpaHIIJIlICb. OHII n03BOJIHIOT AO RaROll-TO CTelIeHII CY.D;IITb 0 nIIrMeHTan;lIII
lICCJIe.D;yeMoro HaCeJIeHIIH. Bo Bcex CJIyqaHX, ROr.D;a MomHO YBepeHHO rOBoplITb
06 9TOM, II rJIa3a, II BOJIOCbI 6bIJIlI 3aRpalleHbI qepHbIM n;BeTOM (n;BeT BOJIOC:
nHTb MymcRIIx cTaTYll II ABe meHCRIIe XaJIqaHHa, oAHa MymCKaH II o)J,Ha
meHCRaH cTaTyII .D:aJIbBep3IIHa; n;BeT rJIa3: AeBHTb MymcRIIx II TPlI meHCRIIe
CTaTYII XaJIqaHHa, 0AHa meHCRaH CTaTYH .D:aJIbBep3lIHa). Pa3YMeeTCH, 9Ta
ORpaCRa He ,L(aeT HlIRaROll B03MomHOCTlI CYAlITb 06 OTTeHRax TeMHoro n;BeTa
BOJIOC :II rJIa3, ROTOpbJe <PIIRCIIPYIOTCH B COMaTOJIOrlIlI. O,L(HaRO He BbI3bIBaeT
COMHeHlIH, '1'1'0 Ha CTaTYHX lI306pameHbI JIIO,L(lI, HBJIHIOID;lIeCJI HOClITeJIHMII
TeMHonlIrMeHTIIpOBaHHoro aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROrO ROMnJIeRCa, OTJIlIqaBillerOCH
IIHTeHCIIBHO qepHbIM n;BeTOM BOJIOC II rJIa3. B COqeTaHIIlI C 6paXIIRe<pamWll H
BlI3yaJIbHO <pIIRcIIpyeMbIM eBpOneOII,L(HbIM CTpoeHIIeM JIIIn;a TaRaH nlIrMeHTa-
n;HH 06pa3yeT ROM6IInan;1I1O nplI3HaROB, .D;ellCTBHTeJIbHO 6JIII3I\YIO R TaR Ha-
3bIBael\IOH pace Cpe)J,Hea3HaTCRoro MemAypeqbH B TpaAHn;HOHHOM nOHHMaHHII
3Toro TepMHHa.
B Ta6JI. 24-27 cBeAeHbI AaHHbIe 0 BapIIan;lIHX onpe,fJ;eJIHBllHXCH onHca-
TeJIbHbIX npH3HaROB. He yrJIy6mIHcb B .D;eTaJIII, IIHTepeCHbIe JIIIllb Cnen;IIaJIlI-
CTaM-aHTpOnOJIOraM, II nOMHH 06 YCJIOBHOCTlI MHorIIX onpeAeJIeHUII Ha CRYJIb-
nTypHbIX nopTpeTax II 0 He60JIbIIIOM qIICJIe Ha6JIIOAeHHll, MomHO CJIeAYIOID;HM
06pa30M cyMMapHo oxapaRTepII30BaTb IIX aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCR1W oco6eHHocTII.
BOJIOCHHOll nOKpOB Ha JIIIn;e y MYiI\'l:IIH pa3BIIT CIIJIbHO, 3HaqIITeJIbHbIII npo-
n;eHT, O'IeBIIAHO, COCTaBJIHJIlI JIIIn;a C BOJIHIICTbIMlI BOJIOCaMII Ha rOJIOBe. rJIa3a
lllIpORO OTRpbITbJe H B nOAaBJIHIOID;eM 60JIbllIIHCTBe CJIyqaeB ropII30HTa.TIbHO
nOCTaBJIeHHbIe, C qpe3BblqallHO MaJIbIM pa3BIITlIel\I CRJIa,'J,RII BepXHero BeRa 1I
nOJIHbIM OTCYTCTBIIeM 9nlIRaHTyca. rOpII30HTaJIbHbIll npo<pIIJIb .'IIIn;a O'IeHb
OCTpbIII, CRYJIbI npaRTIIqeCRII COBceM He BblcTynaIOT. PaCCTOHHlIe 0'1' OCHOBa-
HIIH Hoca 13:0 BepXHeII ry6bI ;:\OBOJIbHO 60JIbIIIOe, BepxHHH ry6a y 60JIbllIIHCT-
Ba opTOXeIIJIIIqHaH, T. e. He BbICTynaeT BnepeA, ooe ryobI YMepeHHO TOJICTbJe,
nO;:J:oopO.D;OR CIIJIbHO BblcTynaIOID;lIll. Hoc C OqeHb BbICORIIM nepeHocbeM, qaID;e
Bcero rrpH IOii:, C npe06JIa,L(aHlIeM BbIHYRJIbIX lpOpM cnIIHKII nOJIOmeHIIe KOHqlI-
Ra II OCHOBaHIIH YMepeHHO npIIIIO)J,IIHTbIe. RpbIJIbH Hoca BbICORIIe II CIIJIbHO
BblcTyrraIOIl(lIe, OrpaHlIqIIBaIOID;IIe IIX 60p03;:J:bI qeTKO MO:IeJIIIpOBaHbI.
P ACOBAH ]J;IIArHOCTIIKA
II rEHE311C HACEJIEHIIH CEBEPHOH BAKTPIIII
OnlIcaHHoe COqeTaHIIe np1I3HaROB, HeCOMHeHHO, CBII,L(eTeJIbCTByeT 0 C:IIJIbHOH
BbIpameHHocTII eBpOneOII,L(HbIX oc06eHHocTell. llonYJIHn;IIII C CIIJIbHOll Bblpa-
meHHOCTbIO eBponeoH.D;HbIX oc06eHHocTell BCTpeqaIOTCH II Ha ceBepe II Ha lOre
apeaJIa paCCeJIeHIIH eBponeOIIAoB, HO TeMHaH nIIrMeHTan;IIH II 3HaqlITeJIbHOe
qIICJIO JilIn; e BOJIHIICTbIMII BOJIOCaMII n03BO.lIHIOT naM onpe.D;eJIeHHO ROHCTaTlI-
pOBaTb, '1'1'0 MbI IIMeeM AeJIO C IOmHoeBponeOHAHbIM cpe,rJ;lI3eMHoMopCRIIM
ROMnJIeRCOM npH3HaRoB. B 0606ID;aIOII\:IIX pa60Tax liD aHTpOnOJIOrH:II :II IIaJIeo-
334
3HTpOrrOJIOrIIII Cpe)J,Hell A3:IIII OH TaR :II Ha3bIBaeTCH t5, XOTH B ROHRpeTHbIX
IICCJIe,L(OBaHIIHX ero qaCTO Ha3bIBalOT BCJIe.D; 3a 8. <DIIllepoM BOCTOqHO-Cpep;II-
3eMHOMopCRIIM 16, He npIIBop;H B p;ORa3aTeJIbCTBO OnpaBi'J;aHHOCTlI TaRoro HaII-
MeHOBaHIIH HIIRaRoro Ha60pa p;IIarHOCTIIqeCRII n;eHHbIx Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCRIIX
rrpII3HaRoB, cnen;II<pIIqHOrO ]:(JIH reorpa<pIIqeCKIIX BOCTOqHOCpe,fJ;II3eMHOMOpCR:IIX
nonyJIHn;IIll B OTJIIIqIIe 0'1' nonYJIHn;IIll 3ana.D;HOrO CpegII3eMHoMopbH. Ha3bI-
BaIOT ero II 3aRacnIIllcRIIM 17, qTO onHTb oTpamaeT qIICTO reorpa<pIIqeCRIIH
no,L(xop; R np06JIeMe reHe3IIca 9Toro ROMnJIeRCa II R BonpocaM pacoBoll Tep-
MIIIIOJIOrII:II.
KaRoBo OTHOilleHIIe 9Toro ROMnJIeRCa R pace Cpe,L(Hea3IIaTCRoro Mem,L(Y-
peqbH, ROTOpyIO Bcn:ep; 3a A. M. Hpxo Ha3bIBaIOT eID;e, 60JIee yp;aqHO B CO-
OTBeTCTBIIII C HOpl\IaMII pyccRoro H3bma, naMIIpo-<pepraHCRoIII8, XOTH 9TO
HaIIMeHOBaHIIe II He CTaJIO ynoTpe6IITeJIbHbIM? Memi'J;Y HIIMII, eCJI:II Tpa.D;IIn;II-
OHHO paCCMaTpIIBaTb HOCIITeJIell naMIIpo-<pepraHCRoro ROMnJIeRCa RaR RpyrJIO-
rOJIOBbIX eBponeOIIiJ,OB C l'.IOHrOJIOII,fJ;noi:i: npIIMeCLIO, HeJIb3H CTaBIITb 3naR pa-
IWHCTBa: COBpeMeHHbIe naMIIpo-ipepraHn;bl, B qaCTHOCTII Y36eRII CypxaH]:(apb-
JIHCROII 06JIaCTII, T. e. mIITeJIII Toro me palloHa, r]:(e 06HapymeHbI naMHTHIIRII,
o ROTOpbIX II]:(eT peqb, ropa3]:(0 60JIee MOHrOJIOII,L(HbI, qeM mIITeJIII ceBepHoll
EaRTpIIH B nOCJIe,fJ;HIIe BeRa ,L(O HOBoll apbI. Y HIIX HIIme nepeHocbe, nJImn;e
II O B ropII30HTaJIbHOll nJIOCROCTII, 3HaqIITeJIbHO CIIJIbHee pa3BIITbI CRYJIM,
3aMeTHee CRJIa,aRa BepxHero BeRa, eCTb 9nIIRaHTYC 19. Ho p;eJIO ,L(ame He B
3TOM. OCHOBHOll :\IOMeHT COCTOIIT B TOM, '1'1'0 naMIIpo-<pepraHCRaH paca nOTe-
pHJIa B HaCTOHID;ee BpeMH CBoe Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCROe e,L(IIHCTBO. He npIIypOqeH-
HbIe R 9THIIqeCRI'!M 06il\HOCTHM, HO TeppIITOpIIaJIbHO p;II<p<pepeHn;IIpOBaHHbIe
JICCJIe,L(OBanIIH BHYTPII ee apeaJIa BbIHBIIJIII 3HaqIITeJIbHO pa3JIIIqaIOIl(IIeCH
IWMnJIeRCbI npII3HaROB 20. Pa3JIII'lI'IH Mem.D;Y HIIMII BIIL\HbI ne TOJIbRO B rOJIOB-
HOM YRa3aTeJIe, 0 qeM BCROJIb3b ynoMIIHaJIOCb II paHbIIIe (no OTHOIIIeHIIIO R
na:reoaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROMY MaTepIIa;rry rOBOpIIJIOCb II 0 pa3Mepax JIIIn;a) 2\
HO II BO MHorIIX p;pyrIIx npII3HaRax. II pOHCXOm,L(eHIIe 9TIIX ROMnJIeRCOB, oqe-
BII,L(HO, pa3JIIIqHo. TamIl\! 06pa30M, HaCeJIeHIIe, npe]:(cTaBJIeHHOe B cRYJIbnTy-
pax XaJIqaHHa II .D:aJIbBep3IIHa, HecMOTpH Ha 6paxIIRe<paJIIIIO, TPYP;HO p;IIar-
HOcTIIpoBaTb RaR OTHoCHIl(eeCH R naMIIpo-<pepraHCRoll pace, IIJIII pace CpeiJ,-
Hea3IIaTCRoro Mea\.D;ypeqbH.
MTaR, nepep; lIaMII TIInIIqHbIe npep;cTaBIITeJIII Cpe,L(II3eMHoMopCROll BeTBH
€BpOneoII.D;oB, R ROTOpOll Ha TeppIITopIIII Cpe,L(HeII A3IIII npIIHHTo OTHOCIITb
TypRMeH 22. O,L(HaRO cpep;II TypRMeH OTqeTJIIIBO <pIIRcIIpyeTcH l'.IOHrOJIOIIp;HaH
npIIMeCb, IIMeIOID;aH, O'IeBII]:(HO, p;BOHRoe npOIICXOm,L(eHIIe II BOCXO,L(HID;aH RaIl:
R MOHrOJIOIIi'J;HbIM ROMnOHeHTaM, BRJIlOqIIBllIIMCH B COCTaB npe,L(ROB TypRMeH
B anoxy CpeiJ,HeBeROBbH, TaR II R 60JIee p;peBHeMy MOHrOJIOIIp;HOMY HaCeJIe-
ITIIIO 23. EBpOneOH.D;HbIll ROMnOHeHT B COCTaBe TypRMeH, npe.D;nOJIOmIITeJIbHO
npeiJ,CTaBJIeHHbIll cepIIHMII 9nOXII aHeOJIIITa II paHHell 6pOH3bI II3 Kapa-.D:ene
JI feORClOpa 2 , OTJIIlqaJICH qeTRO BblpameHHOll ,L(OJIIIXORpaHIIell II TaRme He
M01fWT 6bITb n09TOMy conOCTaBJIeH co Cpe.D;II3eMHOMopCRIIM ROMnJIeRCOM XaJI-
aHHa II .D:aJIbBep3IIHa.
KYJIbTYPHO-IICTOplI'18CRaH 06CTaHOBRa B ceBepHOll EaRTpIIII II oc06eHHO
C06bITIIH, CBH3aHHbIe C caMIIM 06pa30BaHIIeM EaRTpIIllCRoro n;apCTBa, n03BO-
JIHIOT npen;nOJIaraTb 3HaqIITeJIbHOe BJIIIHHIIe rpeqeCROrO 9THIIqeCROrO 9JIeMeH-
'fa, oc06eHHO B npaBHID;IIX Rpyrax 25. llCCJIellOBaHIIe aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROro CO-
CTaBa rpeRoB Ha pa3HbIx TeppIITopIIHX IIX paCCeJIeHIIH npolleMoHcTpIIpOBaJIO
IllIIpoRoe pacnpocTpaHeHIIe pe3Ro BblpameHHbIx eBpOlleOII.D;HbIX, HO 6paxII-
Re<paJIbHbIX ROMnJIeRCOB 26. On:IICaH TaROll ROMnJIeRC B COCTaBe rpeROB
"II H3 RpaHIIOJIOrR'IeCROM MaTepIIaJIe 27. .D:peBHee HaCeJIeHIIe fpen;IIII 9no--
-XII HeOJI:IITa :II 6pOH3bI 6bIJIO ,L(OJIIIXORpaHHbIM 28, HO yme CRYJIbllTypa
I
i
,
I
335
RJIaCCHqeCROrO nepHO.D;a, aHTpOnOJIOr:IIqeCKOe :IICCJIep;OBaHHe ROTOpOH npep;CTO-
:IIT OCYID;eCTBIITb, .D;aeT HaM MHoro 06pa3I1;OB nopTpeTOB RpyrJIOrOJIOBbIX JIIO-
p;ell 29 . llpe,L(CTaBJIHeTCH BeCbMa BepOHTHbIM, '1'1'0 CMelleHHe TaRoro 6paXHRe-
<paJIbHOrO eBponeOII.D;HOrO ROMnOHeHTa, np:IIHeCeHHoro C. TeppHTOpH:II MaJIoM
A3H:II H IOra BaJIRaHCROro nOJIYOCTpOBa, C MeCTHbIM, OCHOBHbIe oc06eHHOCT:II
ROToporo MbI MOllieM npep;CTaBIITb ce6e Ha OCHOBaHHH HCCJIep;OBaHHll, npOBe-
.D;eHIIbIX B IOlliHbIX palloHax Ta.D;lliIIRHCTaHa 30, H 06YCJIOBIIJIO cBoe06pa3He
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRHX qepT JIIO,L(ell, nopTpeTbI ROTOpbIX OTpaiReHbI B CRYJIbnType
XaJIqaHHa :II .D:aJIbBep3IIHa.
KaROBbI reHeTIIqeCRIIe CBH3H MeCTHoro aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO ROMnOHeHTa,
xapaRTepHoro P;JIH HaCeJIeHIIH IOmHoro Ta,L(lliIIRHCTaHa H, HeCOMHeHHO, BO-
lle.D;IIIero qepe3 IIpaHOH3bI'IHbIll «capTCRHll» nJIaCT B 9THoreHe3 Y36eRoB II B
COCTaB COBpeMeHHoro Ta.D;lliIIRCRoro HaCeJIeHHH? B npep;BapHTeJIbHOM co06ID;e-
HIII'! 0 pe3YJIbTaTaX aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO H3yqeHIIH cRYJIbnTypbI XaJIqaHHa H
.D:aJIbBep3IIHa H nOnbITaJICH RpaTRo HaMeTHTb BepoHTHbIll Rpyr aHaJIOrIIll 31 ,
HcnOJIb30BaB onbIT IIcc.rre,L(OBaHHH npe,L(CTaBIITeJIeM TOll JIORaJIbHOll paCbI B CO-
CTaBe IOlliHbIX cpep;II3eMHOl\IOpCRIIX eBponeOIIp;OB, ROTopaH nOJIyqIIJIa HaHMe-
HOBaHHH (<HHp;o-a<praHCROll)} II «IIHp;o-naMIIpCROih} :II R ROTOpOll, RpOMe Ta,L(-
mHROB, OTHOCHTCH HeROTOpbIe Hapop;bI Cpep;Hell A3HII H KaBRa3a, MHorIIe
9THIIqeCRIIe rpynnbI A<praHIICTaHa II nOp;aBJIHIOID;ee 60JIbllIIHCTBO Hapop;OB
CeBepHOII H CeBepo-3ana.D;HOH MHp;HH.
Peqb H,L(eT 0 pa60Te Ha TeppIITopIIH llTaTa MaxapaillTpa, rp;e B 1974-
1975 rr. 6bIJIII onpe,L(eJIeHbI COMaTOTIInbI H onHCaTeJIbHbIe npH3HaRII y 10
9THORaCTOBbIX rpynn. CocTaB 9RClIep;IIn;IIH n03BOJIIIJI 06eCne'lI'lTb ,L(OBOJIbHO
IllIIPORYIO nporpaMMY HccJIei'J;oBaHHM, ROTOpbIe OTpallieHbI B neqaTII JIIlIIIb B
npep;BapHTeJIbHOll <popMe 32. B qaCTHOCT:II, B 'lI'ICJIO 9THX 10 rpynn B Raqe-
CTBe cpaBHIITeJIbHbIX BXO.D;HT TaRI'le pa3HbJe no CBOIIM aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRHM
oc06eHHocTHM HapO,L(bI, RaR napCbI, II3yqeHHble B BOM6ee, H CaHTaJIbI, II3yqeH-
HbJe B ORpeCTHOCTHX KaJIbRYTTbI. Hac, op;HaRO, IIHTepeCYIOT B CBH3H C Hallell
TeMOll B nepByro Oqepe b aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIe oco6eHHOCTH BbICORIIX RaCT-
p;ellaCTXII pHrBe.D;I'l, RaHCTxa npa6xy H qIITnaBaHOB. MM ORa3aJIIICb CBOllCT-
BeHHbI OqeHb TeMHaH nIIrMeHTal(IIH BOJIOC II rJIa3 npH OTHOCHTeJIbHO CBeTJIOll
Rome, pe3RO BblpaiiWHHbIe IOlliHoeBponeOII.D;HbJe oc06eHHOCTII B CTpoeHIIII MHr-
RIIX TRaHell JIIIn;a - CIIJIbHO BblcTynaIOID;Hll HOC, pe3RHll ropII30HTaJIbHbIM
npO<pIIJIb, npHnYXJIbJe ry6bI, HaROHen;, 3HaqHTeJIbHbIII npOn;eHT cpep;H HHX CO-
CTaBJIHJIH IIH,L(IIBII.D;YYMbI C BOJIHIICTbIMII BOJIOCaMII. HaJIIIn;O IWM6IIHan;IIH npH-
3HaROB, 6JIII3RaH R TOIl, ROTopaH C onpep,eJIeHHbIMH MOp;II<pIIRan;IIHMH 3a<pIIR-
CIIpOBaHa Ha CTaTYHX XaJIqaHHa II .D:aJIbBep3IIHa. KaR IICTOpIIqeCRII 06'bHC-
HIITb 9'1'0 Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCIWe CXO,L(CTBO? H BIIlliY eMy JIIIllb O,L(HO 06'bHCHeHHe:
H3 TeppIITopIIII IOmHbIX pallOHOB Cpep;Hell A3H:II P;O py6ellia HaIIIell 9pbI CO-
XpaHIIJIIICb nonyJIHl(IIII, npellRH ROTOpbIX BO II TbICHqeJIeTIIII .D;O H. 9. BXO)IH-
JIII B qIICJIO nJIeMeH, ocyID;ecTBIIBIllIIX MIIrpan;IIIO B IIII,'];IIIO II 06pa30naBIllIIX
TaM BbICORIIe RaCTbI. II Ha OCHOBaHIIII npe,L(llecTByIOID;IIX IICCJIe,L(OBaHIIll MOlli-
HO 6bIJIO rOBopIITb 0 npe06JIap;aHIIII eBpOneOIIi'J;HbIX ROM6IIHan;uii: npII3HaRoB
Cpe.D;II npe,L(CTaBIITeJIell BbICIIIIIX RacT, Herpo-aBCTpaJIOIIllHblX - Cpe,L(H npe.D;-
cTaBHTeJIeII HII3IllIIX 33.
He COCTaBJIHeT Tpyp;a Te3IICHO C<POPMYJIHpOBaTb BbIBOP;bI II3 npep;llecTBYIO-
ID;ero II3JIOllieHIIH:
1) IICnOJIb3yeMaH B COMaTOJIOrIIH MeTO.D;IIRa onIIcaHIIH BapIIan;IIll MHrRHX
TRaHell JIIIn;a C nOMO bIO 6aJIJIOB npIIMeHIIMa R nopTpeTHoll CRYJIbITType It
p;aeT B03MOlliHOCTb 60JIee p;eTaJIbHO, HellieJIH npOCTO BII3yaJIbHOe onIIcaHHe,
On;eHIITb aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRHe oco6eHHocTH JIIOp;ell, 06JIHR ROTOpbIX 3aneqaT-
JIeH B CRYJIbnType;
336
2) CTaTYH XaJIqaHHa H .D:aJIbBep3:IIHa .D;eMOHCTpHPYIOT HHoe COqeTaHHe
npH3HaROB, qeM COBpeMeHHoe HaCeJIeHHe IOmHblX palloHoB Cpep;Hell A3IIH;
OHH 06HapymIIBaIOT BJIHHHHe rpeqeCROrO 3THHqeCROrO 9JIeMeHTa;
3) OCHOBHOll npe.D;CTaBJIeHHbIll B HHX ROMnJIeRC rrpII3HaROB OTpamaeT aHT-
pOnOJIOrIIqeCRHe oc06eHHOCTII nOTOMROB p;peBHHX apHeB H n09ToMy cxop;eH C
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIM TIInOM BbICIIIHX RaCT ceBepHbIX II 3arra.D;HbIX palloHoB
I1H.D:IIII.
Bonpoc 0 TOM, B KaROll Mepe aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIe OC06eHHOCTII CRYJIbn-
TypHbIX nOpTpeTOB XaJIqaHHa II .D:aJIbBep3IIHa OTpamalOT aIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIe
OCOOeHHOCTlI COOTBeTCTBYIOID;ero HaCeJIeHIIH B n;eJIOM (f. A. llyraqeHROBa,
HanpIIMep, He 6e3 OCHOBaHIIll BIIP;HT B HlIX II306pameHlIH npe,L(CTaBHTeJIell
l(apCROll .D;IIHaCTHH II BbICIIIell 3HaTH), BbIXOP;IIT 3a paMRII B03MomHOCTell aH-
TpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO IICCJIep;OBaHIIH II MomeT 6bITb peilleH TOJIbRO C nOMoID;blO
p;aJIbHellIIIIIX paCRonOR II COBoRynHblx YCIIJIIIll IICTOpIIROB II IICRYCCTBOBep;OB.
1 llY20'leHlWea r. A. XaJr<IaHH: K npooJIe:ue xyp;oiKecTBeHHoii RYJIbTypbI ceBepHoil. EaRT-
pHH. TaUIReHT, 1966; Ona :J/Ce. CKYJIbII'rypa XaJIlJaHHa. M., 1977; Ona :J/Ce. Xy):\oiKecT-
BeHHbIe COKpOBFIIlW }J;aJIbBep3HH-TeIle. Jl., 1978; Ona :J/Ce. MCRYCCTBO EaKTpHH <lIlOXH
RyrnaH. M., 1979.
II Y2a'lenlWea r. A. CRYJIbIlTypa XaJIlJaHHa. C. 11.
1 Pougatchenkova G. La sculpture de Khaltchayan II Iranica Antiqua. Leiden, 1965.
Vol. V. Fasc. 2.
llY2a'lenlWea r. A. K HRoHo1'paqmH fepaH: (0 HeRoTopbIX Bonpocax paHHeRymaHcRoH
HCTOpIUI) II BecTH. ):\peBHeii HCTOpHII. 1965. M 1.
5 TaM iKe. C. 132, 133.
6 run36yp2 B. B. TIepBbIe aHTpOnOJIorwrecKHe 1IaTepIIaJIbI R npOOJIeMe <lTH01'eHe3a
EaRTpHII II MaTepHaJIbI II HCCJIep;OBaHHH no apXeOJIOfHH CCCP. 1950. M 15.
7 On :!ICe. AHTpOnOJI01'HlJeCRIIe MaTepHaJIbI R <lTH01'eHe3Y Ta):{mIIKOB II KpaT. cooo .
MH-Ta IICTOpHII IaTeplraJIbHoil. RYJIbTypbI. 1956. BbIII. 61.
8 A.aenceee B. ll. MCTOpHlJeCRaH aHTpOnOJIOrIm. M., 1979.
" Poole R. The Egyptian classification of the races of man II Journal of the anthropo-
logical Institute of Great Britain and Ireland. 1887. T. XVI; Fritsch G. Die Vo]ker-
darstellungen auf den altiigyptischen und assirischen Denkmii]ern II Korrespondenz-
Blatt del' preussischen Akademie del' Wissenschaften. 1902. Bd. XXXIII; Hamy E.
La figure humaine dans II's monuments de I'Egypt ancienne II Bulletin de la socie-
te d'anthropologic de Paris. Ser. 5. 1907. T. VIII; Tpoifju:Moea T. A. KpaHIIOJIOrIIlJe-
CRIll' MaTepHaJIbI H3 aHTIIlJHbIX KpenocTeil. RaJIaJIbI-fblp 1 EI 2 II Tp. Xope3 <. apxeoJI.
<lRCne):\IIl(IIH. 1958. T. 2.
1J If,e6elj r. <P. AHTpOnOJI01'HlJeCKOe IICCJIe):\oBaHHe rrorpe6aJIbHbIX MaCOK TaIIITbIKcROii
RYJIbTypbI (MHHYCHHCRHii Kpaii) II KpaT. co06 . HUll H My3eH aHTpOrrOJIOrHII ;o.lr¥
3a 1938-1939 1'1'. M., 1941; On :!ICe. TIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIH CCCP. II Tp. MH-Ta <lTHo1'pa-
clJHH AH CCCP. T. 4. M.; 31., 1948.
11 Hpxo A. If. ¥HI1clJHKaI(IIH orrpe.f(eJIeHIIH MH1'KIIX lJacTeii JIIIl(a II AHTpOrrOJI. iKYPH.
1932. M 1; Bynan B. B. AHTporroMeTplm: (IIpaRTIIlJecRHii KYPC). M., 1941.
12 3o.wrapeea If. M. AHTpOnOJI01'HlJeCRaH ):{HclJclJepeHI(HaIWH BOCTOlJHbIX caMOAHIII(eB II
AHTpOIlOJI01'IIH H 1'eHoreorpaclJHH. M., 1974.
13 JKupoe E. B. Pa3HOBH.f(HOCTII opaXIIKeclJaJIHH II KpaT. co06 . I1H-Ta HCTOpHH MaTcpH-
aJIbHoil. KYJIbTypbI. 1941. BbIII. 10.
110 If,e6elj r. <P. K Borrpocy 0 BJIIIHHIUI IICKyccTBeHHoil. .f(eclJop Ial(IUI Ha 1'OJIOBHOii YKa-
3aTeJTb II KpaT. co06 . MH-Ta IICTOpHII IaTepHaJIbHOii KYJIbTYPbI. 1947. BbTII. 14.
15 run36yp2 B. B. PaCOBbIe THnbI Cpc.f(HefI A3IIII II IIX clJop:vmpOBaHIle B rrpOl(ecce ;J"fHO-
reHe3a ee HapO.f(OB II TIpOOJIeMbI 3THIIlJeCKoil. aHTpOnOJIOrHII CpeAHeil. A3IIH. TaumeHT,
1964. (Tp. TaIIIReHT. roc. YH-Ta; BbTII. 235); run36YP2 B. B., Tpoifju..,toea T. A.
IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJI01'IIH Cpe.f(Heil. A3HH. M., 1972.
16 Tpoifju:Moea T. A., run36yp2 B. B. AHTpOrrOJI01'HlJeCRIIii COCTaB HaCeJIeHHH IOiKHOil.
TYPRMeHHII B <lnoxy <lHeOJIIITa II Tp. lOiKHo- TYPRMeH. a pxeoJI. <lRCne.f(IIl(IIII. 1960.
T.I0.
17 Owanun JI. B. AHTpOrrOJI01'IIlJeCRIIiI. COCTaB HaCeJIeHHH CpcAHeii A3IIH H <lTHOreHe3 ee
HapO.f(OB. EpeBaH, 1957. q. 1.
18 Hpxo A. If. AHTpOnOJI01'HlJeCKHii COCTaB TypeI(RHx HapoAHocTeii CpeJ(HeiI A3HH II AH-
TpOnOJI. iKypH. 1933. M 3.
19 Has:J/Cu:Moe R. H. AHTpOnOJI01'IIlJeCRHii COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIH CypxaH-l];apbHHcROii 00-
JIaCTH (B CBH3H C HeRoTopbIMH BonpocaMH <lTH01'eHe3a). TaIIIReHT, 1958.
I
I
*
!i
!!
337
J l1eCrp.ftl£06 A. 11. AHTpOnOJIOI'll'IeCl\Oe IICCJIe):jOBamre HeKOTOpbIX rpynn HaCeJIeHIIH
Tap;mIIKIICTaHa 11 Y36eKIICTaHa II COB. c)THorpa«fJ1IH. 1975. ;M 1; /{y6oea H. A. Pacnpe-
l(eJIeHHe aHTpOnOJIOrJITfeCKlrx rrpH3HaROB Ha TeppwropHH CeBepHoro Tap;mIIRHcTaHa II
HeRoTopbIe rrp06JIelHbI aTHH'leCROII IICTOpIIH HapO,TJ;OB l\HIpa. M., 1976; Olia :J/Ce.
I npo6JIe1\Ie cpOp1\U1pOBaHlUI na}IIIpo-cpepraHcRoII pacbI II COB. 3THOl'pacpHH, 1978. ;M 4.
21 TUli36yp2 B. B., TpoifJU-"toea T. A. TIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOnIH Cpe;J;Heii: A3HH.
"2 Omaliuli JI. B. TbICH'leJIeTHHH p;aBHOCTb p;OJIIIXORpamIH Y TypR1\IeH H B031\IOlKHbIe nYTH
ee npmICXOmp;emm II H3B. Cpep;a3R01\ICTapIICa. BbIIT. 1. TamReHT, 1926. Oli :J/Ce. AH-
TpOnOJIOrH'leCRHi\ COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIH Cpe':IHeii A3HH H 3THoreHe3 ee Hapop;oB. EpeBaH,
1959. q. 3.
2. /{e6eq T. (/). l];aHHbIe aHTpOnOJIOHm 0 npOIICXOJR,TJ;eHIIH TYPR1\IeH II COB. 3THOl'pacpIIH.
BbIIT. 6/7, 1947; A..leKceee B. 11. KpaHHOJIOrH'leCKIIe }IaTepIIaJIbI R BTHoreHe3Y TypR-
MeHCROl'O Hapop;a II TIp06JIe1\IbI 3THoreHe3a TypR1\IeHCROro Hapop;a. Amxa6ap;, 1977.
2i TpoifjuMoea T. A., rU1t36yp2 B. B. AHTpOnOJIOrH'leCRHii: COCTaB aaCeJIeHHH IOmHoii:
TYPR1\IeHHII B :moxy 3HeOJIIITa; OliU :!/Ce. TIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOHur Cpep;Heii: A3IIH.
23 CraeUCKUU B. H. KymaHcRaB BaRTpIIH: np06JIe1\lbI HCTOpHH II RYJIbTypbI. M., 1977.
23 llYMilioc A. H. AHTpOnOJIOrII'leCKIIII COCTaB HaCeJIeHlIH rpe.qIIH. feorpacplI'leCRaH
p;IIcpcpepeH.qIIaI IIJj OTp;eJIbIlbIX rrpU3HaROB II Tp. HH-Ta 3THorpacpHII AH CCCP. H. C.
T. 71. 1961.
27 Morant G. The classificatioIl of European races based on cranial measurements II Bio-
metrica. 1928. Vol. XX-B.
28 Boev P. Dit Hassentypen del' Balkanhalbsinsel nnd del' ostiigaischen Inselwelt und
deren Badeutung fiir die Herkunft ihrer Bev6lkerung. Sofia, 1972; Xirotiris N. Ras-
sengeschichte von Griechenland II Rassengeschichte del' Menschheit. (i. Lieferung.
Miinchen; Wien, 1979.
29 Ho.anUliCKUU lO. /{. IIcRycCTBO 3reii:cKOI'o 1\IIIpa II l];peBHeii: rpe.qHII. M., 1970.
30 Omaliuli JI. B. IIpaHcRHe nJIeMeHa 3anap;Horo TIaMHpa. CpaBHIITeJIbHO-aHTpOnOJIOHI-
'leCROe HCCJIep;OBaHHe. TamKeHT, 1937; rUli36yp2 B. B. rOpHbIe Ta,TJ;R{IIRII: MaTepnaJIbI
no aHTpOnOJIOrHH Ta,f\iRHROB KapaTenma H l];apBa3a. M.; Jr., 1937; PbPtKOe lO. 1'.
AHTpOllOJIOI'lIH II reHeTHRa II3o.':mpoB8HHbIX nonY:IHI\IIII (p;peHIIIIe II30.'UlTbI IIa}m-
pa). M., 1969.
3. A..yeKCeee B. 11. TIonbITRa aHaJIII3a aHTH'lHOii CRYJIbnTypbI H3 Cpep;Heii: A3IIII (XaJI-
'laHH II l];aJIbBep3IIH) P;JIH aHTponOJIOHI'leCROii peROHCTpYR.qHH II BceCOI03. Hay'l. CO-
BelI\. (,AHTII'lHaH I\YJIbTypa Cpep;Heii: A3HH II Ka3aXCTaHa». TamReHT, 1979.
3 A6&YlUe.aulUeu.; u 1.1-1. ]'., A.aeKceee B. fl., ApYTIOHoe C. A., l:lc. azy.aoe 0., Ce. alU-
KO IJ. M. COB1\IeCTHbIe cOBeTCRO-HITIJ,IIii:cRHe aHTpOrrOJIOrH'leCRIIe HCCJIep;OBaHIIH B HH-
;WII B 1974-197fi n. II COB. 3THorpa«lJ1IH, 1976. ;M 6.
33 Risley H. Peoples of India. Calcutta, 1915; Guha B. Racial affinities of the peoples
of India II Census of India. 1931. Vol. 1, pt. III; Ethnographical. Simla, 1935; Maha-
lanobis P. C., Majumdar D. N., Rao C. R. Antropometric survey of the United pro-
vinces. 1941. A statistical study II Sankhya. The Indian journal of statistics. 1949.
Vol. 9, pt. 2-3; Majumdar D. N., Rao C. R. Bengal anthropometric survey. 1945.
A statistical study II Sankhya. The Indian journal of statistics. 1958. Vol. 19, pt. 2-
3; Olivier G. Anthropologie des Tamouls du sud de l'Inde. P., 1961.
AHTPOITOnOrMQECKME ACITEKTW
MH OMPAHCKOn ITPOBnEMbI
COMATOJIOfJIqECKIIE ]J;AHHbIE
OTCYTCTBIIe 6eccnopHo npIIypOqeHHOll I\ IIH)J;oIIpaHcRIIM Hapo,L(aM aHTpono-
JIOrII'IeCROll IIH<popMan;IIII HeII36ellino npIIBO,L(IIT Hac R BOCCTaHOBJIeHIIIO
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO COCTaBa IIH)J;OIIpaHCRIIX HapO)J;OB II ero IICTOpIIII KOCBeH-
HbIMII rrYTHMII. TaRIIX nYTell )J;Ba: a) nepeHeceHIIe pe3YJIbTaTOB II3yqeHIIH
aIlTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX oc06eHHOCTeii COBpe IeHHbIX IIpaHCRIIX II IIH,L(OapIIllCRIIX
HapO,L(OB Ha IICTOpIIqeCRII II JIIIHrBUCTllqeCRII 3a<pIIRCIIpOBaHHoe BpeMJI cYIl(e-
CTBOBaHIIH IIH.D;OIIpaHn;eB, T. e. npuMepHo III - HaqaJIO II TbICHqeJIeTIIH
,L(O H. 9.t, qTO, pa3YMeeTCH, Tpe6yeT MHorocTyneHqaTOll 9RCTpanOJIHn;IIII;
6) paCCMOTpeHIIe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrI1qeCRIIX MaTepIIaJIOB, OTHOCHID;IIXCH R
::)1'01i: 9noxe, C TeppIITopIIII B031'.1OlliHOrO paCCeJIeHIIJI uH)J;oIIpaHn;eB, T. e. II3
338
' "
llepe.D;Hell II Cpe;:UIeH A3IIH H IOmHOpYCCRIIX CTeneH. Cpa3Y n{e OrOBOpIOCb,
'1'1'0 TeppHTOpJIH KaBRa3a IICRJIIOqaeTCH II3 paCCMOTpeHIIH BBIIP;Y OqeB:II.D;HOrO
rOCnO.D;CTBa TaM BO II TbICHqeJIeTIIlI .D;O H. 9., RaR H B npep;meCTBYIOID;YIO
9noxy, HOCIITeJIen .D:peBHeIIIIIIIX <pOpM RaBRa3CRIIX H3bIROB 2.
COBpeMeHHbJe IIpaHCRIIe Hapop;bI HBJIHIOTCH HOCHTeJIHMII pa3HbIX aHTpono-
JIOrIIqeCKIIX ROMnJIeRCOB. COMaTOJIOrIIqeCRIIe ;:IaHHbJe 0 HIIX C06IIpamICb Mno-
rIIMII nCCJIep;OBaTeJIHMH, 1I3 ROTOpbIX Ha30BY rJIaBHeIIllIIX: no Hapop;aM
I1paHa OCHOBHOII MaTepIIaJI c06paH r. <PIIJIP;OM 3, no IIpaHCRIIM HapO,L(aM
Cpep;Hell A3IIII - B. B. rIIH36yproM \ JI. B. OillaHIIHbIM" 11. IIIBII)J,en;-
ROll 6 II 10. r. PblqROBbIM \ no IIpaHCRIIM HapO,L(aM KaBRa3a - M. r. A6Jl,Y-
lleJIRlliBIIJIII 8, no Hapop;aM A<praHIICTaHa - r. <P. .D:e6en;OM 9. KpaHIIOJIOrII-
qeCRIIe MaTepUaJIbI no COBpeMeHHbIM IIpaHCRIIM HapOJl,aM ny6JIIIROBaJIIICb
B. B. BynaRoM 10, M. r. A6i'J;YIIIemIllBIIJIH 11, 10. r. PblqROBbIM 12 II aBTO-
pOM HaCTomn;eII F.:HIIrII I3 . B pe3YJIbTaTe C3MII Mop<pOJIOrHqeCRIJe ROl\iIIJIeRCbI
B COCTaBe IIpaHCRIIX HapOJl,OB MOryT 6bITb oxapaRTepH30BaHbI Jl,OCTaTOqHO
nOJIHO; MomHO npOCJIep;IITb II aHaJIOrlIII IIM y p;pyrIIx Hapop;OB.
HaqHeM C Tex ROM6IIHan;Ull npII3HaROB, ROTopbIe npe.D;CTaB.TIeHbI npeIIMY-
Il(eCTBeHHO B cpeJl,e neIIpaHCRIIX HapOJl,OB, a y IIpaHn;eB BCTpeqaIOTCH JIlIllb
CnOpaJl,IIqeCRII. MaCCIIBHOCTb qepena, OqeHb 60JIbllIIe pa3MepbI llIIpIIHbI
JIHn;a, RpyrJIOrOJIOBOCTb, OTHOCIITeJIbHO CBeTJIaH Jl,JIH IOaUIoro Hapop;a nIIrMeH-
Tan;IIH - xapaRTepHbIe aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIe npII3HaRII oceTIIH; TaRoe COqeTa-
HIIe npII3HaROB He 3a<pIIRCIIpOBaHO 60JIbille HII y OJl,Horo II3 :IIpaHCRIIX Hapo-
.D;OB 1 . B TO me BpeMH 9Ta ROM6IIHan;IIH CBOllCTBeHHa MHOrIIM HapogaM
IJ;eHTpaJILHOrO K3Blm3a n. nO-BII.D:IIMOMY, IIMeeT MeCTHoe npOIICXOffilleHIIe.
CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, IIpanOH3bI'IHbJe oceTIIHbI C<P0pMIIpOBaJIIICb Ha MecTHoii: 6IIO-
JIorIIqeCROH OCHOBe II MomeT 6bITb npOCJIemeHa HenpepbJBHaH reHeTIIqeCRaH
npeeMCTBeHHOCTb nOROJIenIIll 0'1' ,L(peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH, rOBopIIBillero Ha RaB-
Ra3CRIIX H3bIRax, R COBpeMeHHbnI oceTIIHaM. TaRaH cIITyan;HH, eCTeCTBeHHO,
HCRJIIOqaeT aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIe oc06eHHOCTII oceTIIH II3 Rpyra Jl,aHHbIX, npII-
rOL\HbIX P;JIH peRoHcTpyRn;IIIif nHi'J;OlIpanCRoro COCTOHHIIH.
I1paHOH3bIqHbJe HapO)JbI IOmIIoro }J,areCTaHa II A3ep6allp;amna - TaTbI II
TaJIbIIIIII IIMeIOT B OTJIII'IIJe 0'1' oceTIIH Y3Roe JIIIl(O II TeMHYIO nIIrMeHTan;IIIO,
eBpOneOII,L(HbIll ROMnJIeRC npII3HaROB BblpameH TaR me ClIJIbHO, RaR II y oce-
TIIH 15. 8Ta ROM6IIIIan;IIH rrpII3HaROB 11 qHCTOM BH,L(e npeJl,CTaBJIeHa TaRme B
pa3HbIX rpynnax a3ep6aIIgmaHcRoro napo.D;a 16, y TypRMeH CeBepHoro KaB-
Im3a II y TypRMeH Cpep;HeII A3IIII 17. B nOp;aBJIHIOID;eM 60JIbIllIIHCTBe pa60T.
nOCBHID;eHnbIX 06ID;IIM BonpocaM aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROll RJIaCCII<pHRan;IIII, OHa
paCCMaTpIIBaeTCB RaR MeCTHaH no npOIICXOm,L(eHIIIO, TeM 60JIee '1'1'0 ell Ha-
XOP;HTCH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRlIe aHaJIOrIIII, BOCXOp;HIl(IIe R IV TbICHqe-
JIeTIIIO p;o H. 9. 18 B 9TOM c.TIyqae TeOpeTIIqeCRII B03MOn{HbI i'J;Be rImOTe3LI:
npe.D;nOJIaraTb (TaR me, RaR II B CJIyqae C oceTIIHaMII), qTO IIpaHII3an;IIH
MeCTHoro cy6cTpaTa HBIIJIaCb CJIei'J;C1'BIIeM pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH IIpaHCRIIX H3bI-
ROB II He conpOBom.D;aJIaCb peaJIbHbIM nepeCeJIeHIIel\1 RaRIIX-TO rpynn Honoro
HaCeJIeHIIH, IIJIII p;YMaTb, '1'1'0 B COCTaBe TaJIbIllell II TaTOB MbI 3aCTaeM aHTpo-
nOJIOrIIqeCKIIll ROMnOHeHT, TIInIIqHbIll ,L(JIH IIpaHn;eB Bo06ID;e II npei'J;CTaBJIeH-
HbIll B COCTaBe II iJ:pyrIIx IIpancRIIx HapoJl,OB. 3aBep;oMo n03,L(HHB TIOpRII3an;IIH
npellRoB a3ep6aII;::J;maHn;eB II TypRMeH II BeCRIIe apryMeHTbI B nOJIb3Y IIX
XOTH 6bI qaCTII'IHoII IIpaHcRoll npIIHap;JIemHOCTII 3aCTaBJIHIOT CRJIOHHTbCH RO
BTOpOII rIInOTe3e. TaRIIM 06pa30M, eCJIII pacnpocTpaneHIIe IIpaHcRoro H3bIRa
B npe.D;eJI3X n;eHTpaJIbHbIX npeL\rOpnII rJIaBHOrO KaBRa3cRoro xpe6Ta npep;-
CTaBJIHeT C060ll CJIe.D;cTBIIe TOJIbRO H3bIROBOll aCCIIMIIJIHn;IIlI, TO B BOCTOqHOM
3aRaBRa3be, MomHO .D;YMaTb, npOmlIBaJIO HaCeJIeHlIe, aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRII pop;-
c,TBeHHoe .D; eBHIIM IIpaHn;aM II HH,L(OIIpaHn;aM.
339
;1
Ha lOr H Ha BOCTOR 0'1' KacnIIH MbI CTaJIRHBaeMCH yme C nO.D;JI:IIHHbIMH
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRnMlI ROMnOHeHTaMlI, Cpe,L(II ROTOpbIX 1I3HaqaJIbHO CRJIa.D;bI-
BaJICH aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIll COCTaB IIpaHCRlIX Hapop;OB 1I ROTOpbIe 6bIJI:II, oqe-
BHP;HO, npeiJ,CTaBJIeHbI II cpep;II Hep;lI<piPepeHn;lIpOBaHHbIX lIHp;OlIpaHn;eB. K co-
maJIeHIUO, XOTH Mop<p0JIOrlIqeCRaH xapaRTepnCTlIRa 9TlIX ROMnOHeHTOB .D;OCTa-
'I' 0 'III 0 HCHa II 06'beRTlIBHa caMa no ce6e, 6Y,L(Y'IlI OCHOBaHHOll Ha
MlIOrOqlICJIeHHbIX 1I pa3Ho06pa3HbIX IIOJIeBbIX Ha6JIIOp;eHlIHX, IIp06JIeMbI HX
reHeTlIqeCRIIX B3aIIMOOTIIOlleHlIll, BpeMeHlI 06pa30BaHIIH II MeCTa B CYID;eCT-
BYlOID;lIX paCOBbIX RJIaCCII<plIRan;lIHX npOp;OJImaIOT BbI3bIBaTb MHoro cnopOB II
He pelleHbI 0,L(H03naqHO B COBpeMeHHOll aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCROll HaYRe. BbI60p
HanOOJIee rrpaB,L(ono,L(06HbIX rlIIIOTe3 lmppeRTlIpyeTcH CTpeMJIeHlIeM 1I36emaTb
RpaIIJUIX TOqeR 3peHIIH 1I oplIeHTlIpOBROll Ha TO, qT06bI <POPMYJIlIpOnaTb
BbIBO,L(bI B p;OCTaTOqHO 06ID;ell <popMe, nOMHH 06 oconoll CJIOmHOCTII II Bam-
HOCTII np06JIeMbI.
HaII60JIee RpynHble 1I3 lIpaHCRIIX Hapop;OB - nepCbI, nallTYHbI, RYP,L(bI,
Ta)J)I,lII{lI - HOClITeJIlI pa3HbIX ROM61IHan;IIll Mop<p0JIOrlIqeCRlIX np1I3HaROB.
TOJIbRO nepCbI 1I nallTYHbI 60JIee IIJIlI MeHee 6JIII3RlI p;pyr R ,L(Pyry B 9TOM
OTHOilleHIIII: IIX OTJIII'IaRJT TeH,L(eHlI,IIH R ,'J,OJIIIXoRe<paJIlIH, Y3Roe JIIIIW II rpa-
n;lIJIbHbIll qepeH, y HlIX TeMHble BOJIOCbI 1I rJIa3a nplI OTHOClITeJIbHO CBeTJIOll
Rome, a TaRme 3Ha'IlITeJIbHbIll BOJIOCHHOll nORpOB Ha JIlIn;e 1I TeJIe 19. B npe-
]J,eJIax 9TOll ROM61IHan;1I1I np1I3HaROB OTMeqeHO MHoro JIORaJIbHbIX BaplIaHTOB,
CBollcTBeHIIblx H OTp;eJIbnbIM l'.IaJIO'IlICJIeHHblM HpaHOH3blqHbIM Hapop;aM,
II 3THII'JeCRlIM rpynnaM Ha TepplIToplIlI I1paHa II A<pranlIcTaHa, HO Bce OHII
Bblp;eJIHIOTCH no C,L(BlIraM B BaplIal(UHX op;Horo-p;BYX np1I3HaROB 1I B n;eJIOM He
napYllaIOT rOMoreHHOCTlI paCCMaTplIBaeMOll ROM61IHan;1I1I Hp1I3HaROB B npe-
p;e.TIax Bcero apeaJIa ee pacnpOCTpaHeHlIH. llpaRTIIqeCRlI 9Ta iRe ROM61IHa-
n;lIH l'.IOmeT 6bITb, C IIe60JIbllIIl'.IlI JIORaJIbHbIl'.IlI pa3JIlIqlIHMlI -- npeJJ;CTaBJIeHa
II B BOCTO'IHOM 3aRaBRa3be cpe,L(lI ynoMlIHaBllIIxCH TaTOB H TaJIbIllell 20 .
OC06bIll Bonpoc - nplIHa,L(JIemHOCTb R 3TOMY ROMnJIeRCY naMlIpCRlIX Ha-
pOP;OB, nplI'JeM 3'1'0 nOHHTlIe TpaRTyeTcH B lllIpOROM CMbICJIe, T. e. BRJIIOqaeT
Hap;)iJ,bl II 3THorpa<plIqeCRlIe rpynnbI, npomlIBaIOID;lIe He TOJIbKO B npep;e-
JIaX CCCP, HO U Ha TepplITopIIII CeBepo-BoCTOqHOrO A<praHlICTaHa. Ha <pOHe
Toro me Mop<pOJIOrlI'IeCRoro CO'IeTaHlIH np1I3HaROB OHII Bblp;eJIHIOTCH 3HaqlI-
Te.TIbHbIM npOn;eHTOM JIlIn; CO CMellaHHbIMII OTTeHRaMlI BOJIOC 1I oc06eHHO
rna3. 1l0p;06HbIll cp;BlIr xapaRTepeH 1I P;JIH mlIBYID;lIx IOmHee II BOCTOqHee
HOClITeJIell p;ap)J,CRlIx H3bIROB 21. TplI-qeTblpe p;eCHTlIJIeTlIH Ha3ap; lICCJIe)J,OBa-
TeJIII IlIICaJIII 0 B03MomHO I BJIlIHHIIII ceBepHOll npIIMeClI Ha CJIOmeHlIe 9Toro
lWMIIJIeRca. O)J,HaRO cell'Iac HalI60JIee pacnpOCTpaHeHHaH II XOpOillO aprYMeH-
TlIpOBaHHaH TO'IRa 3peHlIH CBO)J,IITCH R TO MY, '1'1'0 nOHBJIeHlIe onpe)J,eJIeHHOrO
lICJIa lIH)J,lIBlI)J,YYMOB C OTHOClITe.JTbIlO CBeTJIbIMlI BOJIOCaMII II rJla3aMlI 06H3a-
no CBOIIM npOlICXOfT{p;eHlIeM )1ellCTBlIIO reHeTlIqeCRIIX npOn;eCCOB, npOlICXOllH-
ID;lTX B 3aMRHyTbIX nonYJIHn;IIHX 22, KaROBbIMlI HBJIHIOTCH nonYJIHl(IIlI naMlIp-
cr>HX 1I p;ap)J,CRIIX Hapop;OB (BbICORoropHaH 1I30JIHn;IIH, YClIJIeHHaH 3Hp;oraMHOll
CTPYRTypoii 6paqHbIX RpyrOB). COrJI3CHO 9TOll TOqRe 3peHIIH, OTJIIIqlIH BbICO-
RDrOpHbIX HapO,L(OB ITaMlIpa II CeBepo-BoCTOqHOrO A<praHlICTaHa 0'1' nallTY-
HOB 1I nepCOB HOCHT BTOPlIqIIbIll xapaRTep II He npenHTCTBYIOT IIX 06'b-
e,L(lIIIeHIIIO B ep;lIHbIll pacoBbIll ROMnJIeRC, lIMeIOID;lIll 06ID;ee npOlIcxomp;eHIIe.
3aHIIMaH 06IUlIPHYIO TeppHToplIIO, OH MOllieT CqlITaTbCH OqeHb p;peBHlIM H
lICROHHbIM, BO BCHRCM cJIyqae B npe,L(eJIax M palIa II A<praHlICTaHa. HIIme
MbI y6e,L(lIMCH, '1'1'0 ero apeaJI OXBaTblBaeT TaRme TepplITopIIlO ITaKIIcTaHa
II CeBepo-BocTO'IHOll MHp;lIII.
KYPP;bI 3HaqlITeJIbHO OTJIlIqaIOTCH 0'1' nepCOB H naillTYHOB npaRTlIqeCRU
340
.B OP;HOM, no O'IeHb BamHOM np1I3HaRe - B pa3BIITlIlI BOJIOCHHOro nORpOBa 23.
ECJIlI ,L(06aBIITb R 3TOMY eID;e II <pII31I0HOMlI'IeCRlIe pa3JIlIqlIH, XOTH II 60JIee
CJIaUO BblpameHHbIe, TO HaJIlIn;O HBHoe CXOP;CTBO RYPP;OB C apMHHaMlI, allCO-
pallII'l: I] HeROTopbIMlI TepplITOplIaJIbHblllIII rpynnaMII apa60B, ROTOpbIe HB-
JIHIOTCH HOClITeJIHMII TaR Ha3bIBaeMOll apMeHOIIp;HOll ROM6HHan;HH npH3Ha-
ROB 24. OHa 3aHlIMaeT caMOCTOHTeJIbHOe TaRCOHOMIIqeCROe nOJIOmeHHe H
TaRme HBJIHeTCH, nO-BlIp;lIMOMY, qpe3BblqallHO p;peBHell Ha TeppHToplIH
llepep;Hell A31III 25. HenOJIHaH BblpameHHOCTb 3TOll ROM61IHan;lIII Y RfPP;OB-
apl\IeHOII,L(bI 6paXlIRe<paJIbHbI, B TO BpeMH RaR RYP,L(bI COXpaHlIJIlI P;OJIHXORpa-
HIlIO,- n03BOJIHeT ,L(YMaTb, '1'1'0 apMeHOlI,L(HaH ROMOlIHan;IIH He HBJIHeTCH
IICROHHOll P;JIH lIpaHCRlIX HapO,L(OB 1I "1'1'0 npe,L(RlI RYP,L(OB nplI06peJIII CBOII
xapaRTepHbIe aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRlIe oc06eHHOCTII B npon;ecce n03,L(HeMIIIIIX
6paqHbIX ROHTaRTOB C HelIpaHCRIIMII Hapop;aMlI.
llplIHa,L(JIemHOCTb TaL\mIIRCRoro 1I naMlIpcRlIX H3bIROB R 'llICJIY HpaHcRlIX
qaCTO rlInHOTH'IeCRlI p;ellCTBOBaJIa Ha aHTpOnOJIOrOB, 3aCTaBJIHH npeYMeHb-
lliaTb pa3JIlIqIIH 1I npeyBeJIIIqIIBaTb CXOp;CTBO. B TO me BpeMH Ta.D;mlIRH paB-
HlIHHbIX pallOHOB OqeHb 6JI1I3RII K Y36eRaM 26. Bce 3'1'0 nplIBeJIO R ROHCTPYlI-
pOBaHIIIO aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROll 06ID;HOCTlI, OXBaTbIBalOID;ell 06lllIpHbIll apeaJI
II, no MHeHlIIO MHorlIX Cnen;lIaJIlICTOB, lIMelOID;ell 06ID;ee npOlIcxomp;eHlIe 27.
Op;HaRO ,L(eTaJIbHOe aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROe 06CJIe,L(OBaHlIe Ta,L(mlIRlICTaHa II cpaB-
HeHlIe C IIToraMII aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO 1I3yqeHlIH HaCeJIeHlIH oRpymaIOID;lIx
TepplITopIIll nORa3aJIlI, '1'1'0 ROHCTpYlIpOBaHlIe TaROll 06ID;HOCTII BO MHorOM
HOClIT IICRYCCTBeHHbIll xapaRTep. Ta,L(mIIRlI IOmHbIX pallOHOB 60JIee rpan;HJII>-
RbI II Y3ROJIlIn;bI, 'IeM ceBepHbIX, II ,L(ellCTBlITeJIbHO, nO-BlIp;lIMOMY, MorYT 6bITb
06'be,L(lIHeHbI C naMlIpn;aMlI (OCTaBaHCb, O,L(HaRO, TeMHee IIX) 1I C HaCeJIeHlIeM
A<praHIICTaHa 1I MpaHa B OP;HY TaRCOHOMIIqeCRYlO ep;lIHlIn;y 28. Tap;mlIRII
ceBepHbIX pallOHOB 60JIee llIIpOROJIIIn;bI 1I MaCClIBHbI, 06HapYiRlIBaH peaJIb-
Hyro CBH3b C Y36eRaMlI 29. M Y ceBepIIbIX Ta,L(mIIROB, 1I Y Y36eROB OTqeTJIlIBO
<plIRclIpyeTcH l\IOnrOJIOIIp;HaH nplIMeCb, naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRaH IICTOpIIH
ROTOpOli ,L(OCTaTO'IIIO HCHa 1I ROTopaH BOCXO,],IIT R i\BYM nOCJIep;HIIl'.I TbICHqe-
JIeTlIHM lIX lICTOplIlI. ECJIlI OTBJIe'lbCH OT BJIIIHHlIH 3TOll MOHrOJIOlIp;HOll nplI-
MeClI, TO nepe,L( HaMlI OCTaeTCH ROM6HHan;IIH npH3HaROB, HBHO 06HapymlIBalO-
ID;aH nplI OTHOClITeJIbHO TeMIIOII IlIIrMeHTal(IIII 60JIee ceBepHoe THrOTeHlIe
(MacclIBHoCTb, IIIIIpOROJIIIn;ecTb), qel\I OCHOBHOll, yme paccMoTpeHHbIll, rpa-
n;lIJIbHbIll II Y3ROJIlIn;bIll TeMHonlIrMeHTlIpoBaHHbIll ROMnJIeRC B COCTaBe IIpaH-
n;eB. OH BOCXOP;lIT R paHIIIIM 3nOXal\I IICTOplIlI MeCTHblX aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX
ROMnJIeRCOB Ha TepplITopIIII Cpep;Hell A31I1I, H HeT OCHOBaHlIll COMHeBaTbCH
B IICROHHOll nplIHa,L(JIelliHOCTlI R HeMY Ta,L(mlIROB ceBepHbIX palloHoB Tene-
peillHero IIX paCCeJIeHlIH. K HeMY me OTHOCIIJIIICb II IIpaHOH3blqHble npep;RII
Y36eRoB )10 lIX TIOpR1I3an;IIII 30.
EerJIo paccMoTpeB aHTpOnOJIOrlI eCRlIll COCTaB lIpaHCRIIX Hapop;OB 1I BbI-
HBlIB B HeM p;Ba 1I3HaqaJIbHbIX KOMnOHeHTa - rpan;nJIbHblll II Y3ROJIlIn;bIM,
MaCCIIBHbIll 1I lllIpOROJIIIn;bIll, 06a O'IeHb TeMHble, XOTH 1I pa3JIIIqalOID;lIeCH no
nlIrMeHTan;lIlI (BTOpOll 113 HlIX OTHOClITeJIbIIO CBeTJIee, '1'1'0 nOJIHOCTbIO CO-
TJIacyeTcH C ero 60JIee ceBepHbIM TepplITOplIaJIbHbIl\I nOJIOmeHlIeM 1I HeCROJIb-
RO 60JIee «ceBepHbIM» Mop<p0JIOrIIqeCRlIM 06JIlIROM), l\IbI rrepeXO,L(IIM Tenepb
R paccMoTpeHIIlO aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO COCTaBa lIH,L(OaplIllCRIIX Hapop;OB, Ha-
CeJIHIOID;lIX BOCTOqHbIll llaRlIcTaH, CeBepo-3anaiJ,HYIO, CeBepHYlO 1I qaCTIIqHO
CeBepo-BocTO HYIO MHp;lIIO. OCHOBOll TaRoro paccMoTpeHlIH CJIymaT MHoro-
qIICJIeHHble p;aHHble nOJIeBbIX Ha6JIIOL\eHlIll, c06paHHble MHorlIMII IICCJIep;OBa-
TeJIHMII, HO B nepBYIO Oqepep;b X. PlICJIlI 3\ E. ryxa 32, r. <DlIJIP;OM 3\
H. H. qe60Rc WOBbIM 34 II M. r. A6.D;YIIIeJIIIllBlIJIlI 35. K COmaJIeHIIIO, Rpa-
HIIOJIOrIIqeCRlIll - MaTeplIaJI no IIHp;oaplIllCRlIM Hapop;aM, CYMMlIpOBaHHbIM
.
t
,-
341
H qaCTHqHO onIIcaHHbIM Am. MopaHToM 36, rOpa3}J;O MeHee npep;CTaBIITeJIeH,
qeM MaTepHaJI no IIpaHCRHM Hapop;aM. Bee me H 9TOT He60JIbIIIOll RpaH:IIO-
JIorn:qecRHM MaTeplIaJI, :II, caMoe rJIaBHOe, pe3YJIbTaTbI COMaTOJIOrIIqeCRIIX
HCCJIep;OBaHIIll He OCTaBJIHIOT COMHeHIIH B TOM, '1'1'0 OCHOBHoii rpan;HJIbHbIM
ROMnJIeRC y upaHn;eB HBJIHeTCH O}IHOBpeMeHHO npe06JIa)IaIOID;lIM cpep;lI IIHJJ,O-
aplIllCRIIX HapO,L(OB. H3 ;:noro <paRTa BbITeRaeT 3aRJIIOqeHlIe 0 ,L(OCTaTOqHO
06illlIpHOM apeaJIe rpan;IIJIbHbIX TeMHonIIrMeHTIIpOBaHHbIX eBponeOlIp;OB B
ITepe,L(Hell A31III He TOJIbRO B COBpeMeJUIYIO :moxy, HO 1I B p;peBHOCTH.
HaCeJIeHlIe IOmHbIX II MHorlIX n;eHTpaJIbHbIX pallO HOB MH,L(lIlI OTJIlIqaeTCH
0'1' HlIX, RaR II3BeCTHO, rOpa3,L(0 60JIee TeMHOll Romell, IIIlIpOROHOCOCTbIO,
nporHaT1I3MOM 1I B n;eJIOM npIIHai'J;JIeJRIIT R IIHOMY Kpyry aUTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX
<pOpM. BJIlIHHlIe 3TIIX <PO pM Ha aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIll COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIH CeBep-
HOll MHP;IIlI 6bIJIO ,L(OBOJIbHO 3HaqIITeJIbHbIM II npOHBJIHeTCH RaR cnen;II<plI'IeCRlI
B oT,L(eJIbHbIX palloHax, TaI{ II B n;eJIOM, BblpamaHcb B HeRoTopoM nOTeMHe-
HIIlI nIIrMeHTan;ml KomII y IIHp;oapIIeB, HanpIIMep, no cpaBHeHlIlO C Ta,L(m:II-
RaMII. TaRaH oc06eHHocTb JIerRO 06'bHCHHeTcH uCToplIell lIHlloaplIeR, ROTOpbIe
:II3p;aBHa, no RpallHell Mepe B TeqeHlIe Tpex C nOJIOBlIHOll TbICHq .freT, Ha:xo-
P;lIJIlICb B ROHTaRTe C p;paBIIp;aMlI 37. Il03TOMY MmRHO p;Y.MaTb, '1'1'0 IOfl HaH
(HerpOlIp;HaH, aBCTpaJIOlI,L(HaH, ,L(paBI'I,L(OlI,L(HaH, Bep;p;OU,L(HaH - pa3Hble cne-
n;IIaJIIICTbI ynoTpe6JIHIOT pa3JIlIqnylO TepMlIHOJIOrlIlO) nplIMecb y lIH,L(Oa plIeB
He lIMeeT OTHOIIIeUlIH R CJIOmeHIIIO lIX lIcxop;Horo aHTpOIIOJIOrlI'IeCROrO ROMn-
JIeRCa II npOlICTeRaeT 3a CqeT 3TlIX MHorOBeROBbIX RonTaRTOB. TaROll BbIBOP;
HaXO,L(IITCH B CGrJIaClIlI C <paRTOM 60JIbillOll 6JI1I30CTlI HpaIICRIIX II IIHp;oapIIII-
CRIIX H3bIROB, pa3p;eJIeIHIeM lIX Ha py6eme I I I - I I TbICH'IeJIeTlIii,L(o H. 3.
H 6bIJIbIM pacnpOCTpaHeIIlIeM lIHp;oaplIllCKIIX H3bIROB 1I lIX HOCIITeJIell, nO-RlI-
P;IIMOl\IY, R ceBepy OT ,L(paBlIp;OB 38. IIocJIe,L(HlIe B ceBepHbIX palloHax IIX pac-
CeJIeHlIH (6parYII) caMlI IIOClITeJIlI TOro me ROMnJIeRCa np1I3HaRoB, ROTOpbIll
HBJIHeTCH OCHOBHbBI y npaHn;eB U npeoGJIap;aIOIl(lIM Y IIH,L(OaplIeB 39.
TaRCOHOMlI'IeCRoe 0603Ha'IeHlIe 3'1'01'0 ROMnJIeRCa B aHTpOnOJIOl'lIqeCROll
JIIITepaType Heop;H03HaqHO. Ero Ha3bIBaIOT lIHp;o-naMlIpcRoll II.TIU lIHp;o-a<praH-
CROll pacoM, nO.D;'IepRHBaH reHeTn:qecRyIO 06ID;HOCTb HaCeJIeHlIH BOCTOqnOll
qaCTlI ITepep;Hell A31I1I, IOmHbIX pallOHOB Cpe,L(Hell A31I1I 1I CeBepHOll MH,L(IIlI.
06a HaIIMeHOBaHlIR O,L(lIHaROBO IIIlIpORO pacnpOCTpaHeHbI B cnen;UaJIbHbIX
ny6JIlIRan;lIHX 40, HO BTopoe RameTCH MHe npe,L(nO'ITlITeJIbHee, TaR RaR OCHOB-
Hble oc06eHHOCTlI ROMIIJIeRCa qeT'Ie BblpameHbI y naillTYHOB (6e3 p;enlIrMeH-
Tan;lIII BCJIe,L(CTBlIe npomIIBaHlIH B BbICORoropbe), qeM y naMlIpn;eB. EOJIee
MaCClIBHbIll ROMnOHeHT y ceBepHbIX Ta,TI,llilIROB 0603HaqaIOT RaR naMlIpo-<pep-
raHcRyIO pacy lIJIlI pacy Cpep;Hea3IIaTcRoro Mem.D;ypeqbH, TaRme OTHOClITeJIb-
HO caMOCTOHTeJIbHYIO ep;IIIIIIn;y pacoBoM CIICTeMaTlIRII 41. 06a HalIMeHOBaHlIH
nplIMepHo O,L(IIHaROBO lICnOJIb3YlOTCH B JIIITeparype. MHorIIe aHTpOnOJIOrlI
BRJIIOqaIOT naMlIpo-<pepraHcRlIll ROMnJIeRC B IIH,L(O-a<praHcRYIO pacy B RaqeCT-
Be JIORaJIbHOrO BaplIaHTa", HO 06cym,L(eHlIe n;eJIeC006pa3HOCTlI TaROll TaRCO-
HOMlI'IeCROll onepan;IIII He lIMeeT OTHOlleHlIH R HaIIIell TeMe.
C TpaRTOBIWll p;aHHbIX no COBpeMeHIIbIM lIH,L(OapnllCRIIl\I II lIpaHCRlIM Ha-
pO,L(aM CBH3aHa eID;e O,L(Ha np06JIeMa - lIaJIlI'I1Ie B lICXO,L(HOM nyqRe eBpo-
neOlI,L(HbIX pacoBblx BaplIaHToB, Ha OCHOBe ROTOpbIX CRJIap;bIBaJIlICb aHTpono-
JIOrlIqeCRlIe oc06eHHOCTlI IIH}IOlIpann;eB, HerpOlIp;HbIX II MOHrOJIOlI,L(HbIX
3JIeMeHTOB. B llORa3aTeJIbCTBO nepBoro MOfRHO 6bIJIO 6bI BcnOMHlITb Heop;HO-
RpaTHble YRa3aHlIH Ha HR06bI HerpOlIp;Hble oc06eHHOCTU 6eJIyp;mell. O,L(HaRO
B p;eIICTBlITeJIbHOCTlI CJIe,L(yeT rOBoplITb TOJIbRO 0 HeROTopOM HOTeMHeHIIlI y
HIIX n;BeTa RomII, TaR RaR no BceM p;pyrlIM np1I3HaRaM OHlI He OTJIIIqaIOTCH
OT eBponeOIIp;OB 43. TaRoe nOTeMHeHlIe Romll MOrJIO 6bITb CJIe,L(CTBlIeM KaRlIX-
TO CJIyqallnb X, cpaBHIITeJIbHO n03p;HlIX ROHTaRTOB C 60JIee IOmHbIMII TeMHO-
342
llIrMeHTlIpOBaHHbIMII <pOpMaMII. }:(ORa3aTeJIbCTBOM BTopOrO MOmeT CJIymIITI.
peaJIbHaH MOHrOJIOlIp;nOCTb XiJ.3apa. PeIIIeHIIe ,L(IICRYTlIpOBaBillerOCH B JIlITepa-
Type BOIIpoca 0 n;eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCR01\I IIJIII T1I6eTO-rlIMaJIallCROM npOlIcxom-
p;eHIIII MOHrOJIOlIp;HOCTlI Y xa3apa BbIXOP;IIT 3a paMRlI Haffiero COOOID;eHIIH.
Ho KaR 6bI ero HlI peillaTb, npOHlIRHOBeHlIe MOHrOJIOlIp;OB Ha TepplITopIIIO
HbIHeillHero AcpraHlICTaHa He MomeT 6bITb paHHIIM. OlIO ne nop;TBepmp;aeTCH
IUmaRIIl\HI yoep;lITeJIbUbIMlI naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRIIMII MaTeplIaJIaMII lIJIlI
lICToplI'IeCRlIMlI Ha6JIIO,L(eHIIHMlI. 1l03TOl'.IY Ha Bonpoc 0 UaJIIIqlIII HerpOII,L(HOH
IIJIII MOHrOJIOlI,L(IIOll nplIMeCII B COCTaBe IICXO,L(HbIX aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIX ROMn-
JIeKCOB, IIOCIITeJIHl'.llI ROTOpbIX 6bIJIlI IIHp;OlIpaHn;bI, a TaRme L\peBHlIe IIpaHn;bI
II IIH;J,oaplIII, Hyn Ho OTBeTIITb OTpIIIWTeJILHO: BO Bcex CJIY'IaHX, ROr,L(a 3Ta
npIIMeCL <plIRcIIpyeTcH, JI1I60 OHa HBJIHeTCH p;OCTaTO'IHO n03p;Hell, JI1I60 npe,L(-
nOJIOmeHlIe 0 eo n03p;HeM BTOPIIqHOM npolIcxOm,L(eHlIlI MomHO Cp;eJIaTb C .D;o-
CTaTOqHOll p;OJIell BepoHTHoCTlI.
I
TIAJlEOAHTPOTIOJlor:nQECKAH PETPOCTIEKTIIBA
}:(peBHIIe naJIeOaIITpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIe MaTeplIaJIbI C TeppIIToplIlI I1paHa He60ra-
TbI (Tene-ClIaJIR \ Tene-flIccap 5), ,L(JIH TeppIITopIIII A<praHlICTaHa OHH
nOqTlI OTCYTCTBYIOT' 6 , IIH<popMan;lIH C TepplIToplIlI llaImCTaHa 1I CeBepo-
3anap;Holl MH,L(lIliI npep;CTaBJIeHa JIIIIIIb HeCROJIbRlIMII cepIIHMlI (TlIMaprap-
xa 7, MoxeHp;mo-}:(apo 8, Xapanna 9). Bce OHlI 6e3 IICRJIIOqeH:IIH 06pa-
ID;alOT Ha ce6H BHlIMaHIIe P;BYMH MOp<p0.10rliI'IeCRIIMII oc06elIHocTHMII - pe3Ro
nOp;qepRHYTbIMlI eBpoIIeolIp;HbIMlI npII3HaRal\III 1I 3IIaqUTeJIbUOll rpan IIJIb -
HOCTblO JIlIn;a 50, ROTopaH B OTp;eJIblIbIX CJIY'IaHX IIp1I6JIlIlliaeTCH, nO-BlIp;lIMO-
MY, R MlIPOBOMY MaKClIMYI\IY. ApMeHOlIp;HaH ROM61IHan;lIH npIiI3HaROB, 0 RO-
TOpOll MbI ynoMlIHaJIII nplI paCCMOTpeHHII aHTpOnOJIOr:IIqeCROrO 06JIIIRa Ryp-
AOB, OTJIlIqaeTCH, RpOMe yClIJIenHOrO pa3BlITlIH BOJIOCHHOro nORpOBa Ha TeJIe,
6paXlIRe<paJIlIell. Torp;a RaR Bee UepeqIICJIeHHbIe CepIIITp;OJIlIXORpaHHbI. Ka3a-
JIOCb 6bI, Monmo nOJIOmlITb 3TOT np1I3HaK B OCHOBY OTp;eJIeHIIH p;peBHIIX
IIHAo-a<p raH n;eB II apMeHOlI,L(OB, ROJIb CROpO lIHTeHClIBHOCTL pa3BIITlIH BOJIOCH-
Horo nORpOBa HeB03MomHO <plIRClIpOBaTb Ha naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROM MaTe-
plIaJIe. Ho 6bICTpaH ,L(IiIHaMlIRa <pOpMbI rOJIOBbJ BO BpeMeHlI 06ID;eII3BeCTHa 51;
na TepplIToplIII caMOll ApMeHlIlI yme B 3noxy cpe;J;HeBeROBbH npe06JIap;aIOT
P;OJI:IIXORpaHIIbJe <pOpMbI, '1'1'0 CBlI.D;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 P;OJIlIXORpaHIIII ,L(peBHIIX
npMeHOlIp;OB 52. CJIe,L(OBaTeJIbHO, OT,L(eJIlITb lIX 0'1' lIHp;o-a<praHCROll paCbI
6 3IIOXY CYID;eCTBOBaHlIH IIHp;OlIpaHn;eB HeB031'.IOmHO, HO MaJIbIll yp;eJIbHbI:U Bec
apMeHOlI,L(HOrO ROMnJIeRCa B COCTaBe COBpeMeHHbIX lIpaHCRlIX Hapop;OB p;aeT
B03l\IOmHOCTb npe,L(nOJIaraTb, '1'1'0 BO Bcex nepe'IIICJIeHHbIX CJIyqaHX MbI HMeeM
,L(eJIO C IICROITaeMbIMlI npep;CTaBIITeJIHMII IIHp;o-a<praHCROll paCbI.
Ha TeppIITOplIlI CeBepHoro Tap;mlIRIICTaHa II npIIJIeralOID;lIX R HeMY pallO-
HOB MbI CTaJIRIIBaeMCH B 3noxy 3HeOJIlITa II 6pOH3bI C lIHbIM ROMnJIeRCOM
npII3HaROB, nplI ClIJIbHOll BblpameHHOCTII eBponeOlIp;HbIX oc06eHHOCTell OTJIII-
'"IaIOID;lIMCH MaCCIIBHbIM JIIIn;eBbIM CReJIeTOM 53. OH HBJIHeTCH npe06JIap;aIOID;HM
1I B IOmHopYCCRlIX CTenHX 5 . IIpeeMCTBeHIIOCTb 3Toro ROMnJIeRCa C ROM61I-
Han;IIell npII3HaROB, CBOllCTBeHHOM ceBepHbIM Ta,L(mliIRaM II Y36eRaM, IIJIJIIOCT-
plIpyeTcH XpOHOJIOrlIqeCRlI pa3HOBpeMeHHbIMlI MaTepIIaJIaMII 1I He BbJ3bIBaeT
COMHeHIIll. B 9noxy n03p;Hell 6pOH3bI HOCIITeJIlI 3Toro ROMnJIeRCa npOHlIRaJIII
II B IOlliHble pallOHbI HbIHeillHero Ta,L(llilIRlICTaHa (TYJIxap 55). TaRIIM 06pa-
30M, B naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIqeCRIIX MaTeplIaJIaX MbI HaXO.D;IiIM peaJIbHble ,L(ORa3a-
TeJIbCTBa lICROHHoro <POpMlIpOBaHIIH ceBepHbIX rpynn ,L(peBHlIX IIpaHn;eB Ha
OCHOBe MaCClIBHbIX eBpOIIeOIIp;HbIX ROM6HHan;lIll, OTJIlIqaIOID;lIXCH B 3TOM npH-
3HaRe OT IOmHLIX.
343
B IITOre MbI npHXOp;HM R CJIemrIOID;lIM BbIBO.D;aM. MHp;OIIpaHCR:IIe HapO.D;1>I
<pOpM:IIpOBaJIIICb B aHTpOnOJIOrR'IeCROll cpep;e, COCTaBJIeHHOll .D;BYMH eBpo-
neOH.D;HbIM:II ROMnOHeHTaMII, pa3JIlIqaBilllIM:IICH B MaCC:IIBHOCTH JIlIn;eBOro CRe-
JIeTa. ApeaJI IOmHoro, 60JIee rpan;lIJIbHOrO ROMnOHeHTa conpHRaCaJICH Ha lOre
C Herpo-aBCTpaJIO:IIp;HbIMII <popMaMII. ApeaJI ceBepHoro, 60JIee MaCCIIBHoro
1\OMnOHeHTa OXBaTbIBaJI orpOMHYIO OOJIaCTb IOmHopYCCRHX CTenell, Ka3axcTa-
Ha II ceBepHbIX pallOHOB Cpep;Hell A31I1I, B npep;eJIax ROTOpOll CeBepHbIll :II
IOmHbIll Tap;mIIRlICTaH npep;CTaBJIHJIII C060ll p;aJIeRYIO IOmHYIO nepII<peplIlO.
ITpapop;lIHa IIHp;OIIpaHn;eB B CBeTe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrR'IeCRIIX H aHTpOnOJIOr:II-
'IeCRlIX p;aHHbIX OqepqIIBaeTCH, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, B npep;eJIax 06IIIIIpHoro pallO-
Ha, OXBaTbIBaIOID;ero lOr Cpe.D;HeM A3HII l!I MpaHCRoe Haropbe. fpaHm:J;bI npa-
pOP;lIHbI Ha 3anap;e II Ha BOCTORe OCTalOTCH He OqeHb onpep;eJIeHHbIMII, HO
RameTCH BepOHTHbIM, lICXOiJ,H 113 pe3Roro nepenap;a JIaHp;lla<pTHbIX xapaRTe-
p:IICTIIR 1I 3RCTpaaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRlIX coo6pameHlIII (ycneillHaH p;elllI<pPOBRa
Ha.D;nlICell 1I3 MoxeHp;mo-JJ:apo Ha 6a3e .D;paBlIp;IIllCRlIX H3bIROB 56), '1'1'0 BOC-
TOqHaH rpaHIIn;a He 3aXO.D;lIJIa 3a P;OJIlIHY MHp;a.
Opalic1>uii n. M. BBeJJ;eHlIe B IIpaHcKYIO q,IIJIOJIOrlIlO. M., 1960; Oli 3ICe. I1paHcKlIe
H3bIKlI. M., 1963.
2 f{u1>o6aea A. C. BBep;eHlIe II H3bIKlI Hapop;oB CCCP. T. IV: I16eplIi1cKo-KaBKa3cRlIe
H3bIRlI. M., 1967.
3 Field H. Contribution to the Anthropology of Iran II Field Museum of Natural Histo-
ry. Anth. Series. Chicago, 1939. Vol. 29; Idem. The Anthropology of Iran: the Lower
Euphrates-Tigris Region II Field Museum of Natural History. Anth. Series. Vol. 30.
Chicago, 1949. Pt. 1. N 2.
rUlia6ype B. B. fOpHbIe Tap;iKHKH: (MaTeplIaJIhI IIO aHTpOIIOJIOrlIH Tap;iKlIKOB Rapa-
TerHHa II .D:apBa3a). M.; JI., 1937.
Omaliuli JI. B. .I1paHcKHe IIJIeMeHa 3aIIap;Horo TIaMHpa (cpaBHHTeJIbHO-aHTpOIIOJIOrlI-
'leCKOe HCCJIep;OBaHHe). TawKeHT, 1937; Oli 3ICe. AHTpOIIOJIorlI'lecKHii COCTaB H BOIIpO-
Cbi :3THOreHe3a Tap;lliHKOB H Y36eKcKHX IIJIe1\IeH IOmHoro Tap;iKHTmcTarra. CTamma-
6ap;, 1957; Oli 3ICe. AHTpOrrOJIOrH'lecmIii COCTaB HaCeJIeHHH Cpep;Heii A3III1 II :3THOre-
He3 ee rrapop;oB. EpeBaH, 1957-1959. q. 1-3; Omaliuli JI. B., 3eaeli1>oea B. n.
BorrpocbI :3THOreHe3a Hapop;oB Cpep;Heii A3HH B CBeTe p;aHHbIX aHTpOrrOJIOnm. TawKeHT,
1953.
6 Schwidetzky I. Turaniden-Studien II Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur,
Abhandlungen der mathematisch-naturwissenschaftliche Klasse. Wiesbaden, 1950.
N 9.
7 Pb!'l1>Oe 10. r. AHTporrOJIOnm H reHeTHKa H30JIHpOBaHHbIX rroIIymn Hii: (l];peBHHe
H30JIHTbI IIaM:upa). M., 1969.
B A68yme.aumeu.au M. r. OceTHHbI II Tp. lIH-Ta :3KCIIepHM. lI-wpq,OJIOrHII AH fCCP.
T6IIJIIICII, 1957. T. 6; Oli Jlce. AHTpOrrOJIOrHH p;peBHero II cOBpelleHHoro HaCeJIeHIIJI
fpY3IIII. T6HJIIICH, 1964.
9 Jl.e6elf r. (fl. AHTpOrrOJIOrH'leCKHe HCCJIep;OBaHIIJI B Aq,raHIICTaHe II COB. :3THOrpaq,IIJI.
1967. M 4.
10 BYlia1> B. B. lJeperra II3 CKJIerrOB ropHoro RaBKa3a B cpaBrrHTeJIbHO-aHTpOrrOJIorH'le-
CKOM OCBelI\eHIIII II C6. MY3eH aHTpOIIOJIOrIIII II :3THOrpaq,IIII AH CCCP. M.; JI., 1953.
T.14.
,: A68yme.aume.u.au M. r. MaTepIIaJIbI K KpaHIIOJIOrIIII RaBKa3a II Tp. I1H-Ta :3KCIIepHM.
lVIOpq,OJIOrIIII AH fCCP. T6IIJIIICII, 1955. T. 5.
12 PbL'l1>Oe 10. r. IIPOHCXOiKp;eHlle pacbI Cpep;Hea3HaTcKoro MeiKp;ype'lbH II TIp06JIeMbI :3T'
HII'leCKOii aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII Cpep;rreH A3IIH. TawKeHT, 1964. (Tp. TamKeHT. roc. yrr-Ta;
EbIII. 235).
J3 A.Le1>Ceee B. ll. IIpoHcxoiKp;eHIIe HapoAoB Ram>a3a: (RparrHOJI. HCCJIeA.). M., 1974.
1i> A68yme.aumeu.au M. r. OceTHHbI.
J5 BYlia1> B. B. AHTpOIIOJIOrH'leCKHH COCTaB HaCeJIeHHH RaBKa3a II BecTH. foc. MY3eH
fpY3IIII. T6HJIHCH, 1946. T. XIII-A; Kacwftoea P. M. AHTpOrrOJIorII'leCKIIe IICCJJeAO-
BaHIIH cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH A3ep6aiip;iKaHcKoii CCP. EaKY, 1975.
I.. CJ\I. RHIIry P. M. RaCIIMOBOH, YKa3aHHYlO B IIpeA. rrpIIMe'l.
11 Hpxo A. n. TYPKMeHb) Xope3Ma II CeBepHoro RaBKa3a: AHTpOrrOJIOrlI'leCKlIii O'lepK
o )J;JIHHHOrOJIOBOM eBpOIIeOHp;HOJ\I KOMIIOHeHTe TypeL\KlIx Hap0fJ:HOCTeii CCCP II AHTporr.
iKypH. 1933. M 1, 2.
344
18 A.ae1>ceee B. Tl. l];peBHeHIJlee eBpOrremlp;HOe HaCeJIemIe CpegHeH A3IUI II ero rrOTOM-
KII II IIp06JIelllbI 9THIT'IeCKOii aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII II IIwpq,OJIOrIIIT '1eJIOBeKa. JI., 1974.
19 B p;OrrOJIHeHIIe K paGoTallI r. <DIIJIp;a II r. <D. l];e6eI(a, YKa3aHHbIM B rrpITIIIe'l. 3 II 9,
CM.: Field H. An anthropological reconnaissance in West Pakistan II Paper of the
Peabody museum of Amer. archaeology and ethnology. Cambridge, Massachusetts,
1959. Vol. LII.
29 Kacu. toea P. lIJ. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOe IICCJIep;OBaHlIe COBpell1eHHOrO HaCeJIeHIIJI A3ep-
Gaiip;lKaHchOH CCP.
21 B p;OrrOJIHeHITe K pa60Te r. <D. l];e6eI(a CM.: Herrlich A. Beitrag zur Rassen- und Stam-
meskunde der Hindukush-Kafiren. Berlin, 1937; Jorgensen I. et al. Anthropological
Studies in the Hindu Kush and the Punjab II Folk. Vol. 6. Kopenhavn, 1965.
22 Baeu.aoe H. H., EY1>WiU'/, . . 3eMJIep;eJIb'leCKIIii Aq,raHITCTaH. 31., 1929; raa3/CU-
ee A. r. IIpoITcxolKp;eHITe Hapop;oB l];arecTaHa (rro p;aHHbIM aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII). Maxa'lRa-
JIa, 1965; e6elf r. (/I. OrrbIT rpaq,II'IeCKOrO IT300paIKeHITH reHeaJIOrII'IeCKOii KJIaCCIT-
q,llKaI(ITII qeJIOBeqeCKITX pac II COB. 9THorpaq,ITH. 1958. M 4.
21 A6aywe.auweu.au M. r. AHTpOrrOJIOrIIH ,lIJ>eBHero II cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH rpY3ITIT.
2;' B ilOrroJIHeHITe K TOJIbHO '1TO YRa3aHHoii paooTe M. r. A6p;YlIIeJIIIIJlBITJIIT CM.: Ey-
Ha1> B. B. Crania Armenica: (I1cCJIep;OBaHITe rro aHTpOrrOJIOrIIIT IIepep;Heii A3IIII) II
Tp. HaY'l.-IICCJIep;. IIH-Ta aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII rrpII I Mry. 1927. BbIII. 2.
2; EYHaK B. B. l];peBHeHlIIITe KpaHIIOJIorII'IeClUIe TIIIlbI TIepep;HeH A3IIII II RpaT. co061I\.
HH-Ta 9THorpaq,ITll AH CCCP. 1947. BbIrr. 2.
26 CM. RHIITIT, YRaaaHHbIe B IlpIIMe'l. 5.
2, rUH36ype B. B. PaCOBbIe TITIlbI Cpep;Heii A3ITII II IIX q,OpMIIpOBaHIIe B rrpoI(ecce 9THO-
reHe3a ee HapoJJ;oB II TIp06JIellIbI 9THII'IeCROii aHTpOIIOJIOrIIIT Cpep;HeH A3IIII; OH 3/Ce.
Paca Cpep;HeaaIIaTCRoro )<IeIKp;ype'lbH IT ee IlpOIIcXOIKp;eHITe II Tp. VII MelKp;YHap.
Romp. aHTpOIlOJI. II 9THorp. HaYR. M., 1968. T. 3; rUH36ype B. B., TpoifJUMoea T. A.
IIaJIeOaHTpOIlOJIOrITH Cpep;Heii A3IIII. M., 1972.
28 neCTp5!KOe A. n. AHTpOIlOJIOrII'IeCROe IICCJIep;OBaHIIe HeROTopbIX rpyrrIl HaCeJIeHIIH
Tap;IKIIKITCTaHa II ¥30eKIICTaHa II COB. 9THorpaq,ITfl. 1975. M 1.
2 y60ea H. A. AHTpOIlOJIorII'IeCRaH xapaRTepITCTIIKa HeRoTopbIX rpyrrrr HaCeJIeHIIH
CeBepHoro Tap;IKIIRIICTaHa II BOIlp. aHTpOIlOJIorIIll. 1976. BbIll. 52.
3,] rUH36ype B. B., Tpoifiu. toea T. A. IIaJIeOaHTpOIlOJIOrIIH Cpep;HelI A3IIII.
Jl Risley H. Peoples of India. Calcutta, 1915.
32 Guha B. Hacial Affinities of the Peoples of India II Census of of India 1931. Vol. 1.
Pt. 3. Simla, 1935. B p;OrrOJIHeHIIe CM.: Oliver G. Anthropologie des Tamouls de Sud
de l'Inde. P. 1961.
31 CIII. rrpIUIe'l. 19.
3 '1 e601>capofJ H. H. AIITpOIIOJIOrlI'leCRIIe IICCJIep;OB3HIIH B HH,'],HIT II IIpo6JIeMbI COI(ITaJIb-
HO-3RoHoMH'IecRoii ITCTOpIIIl BHP;ITIT. M., 1971.
;13 A6aywe.mWeU.1U M. r. MaTepIIaJIbI COBMeCTHbIX COBeTCRO-IIH;:WHClUIX aHTpOIIOJIOrIT-
'1eclUIX IICCJIep;OBaHITII B CBeTe oGm;IIX rrp06JIeM reHe3IIca IIHp;0-cpep;II3eMHOllIopCROii
paCbI II COB. 9THorpaq,IIH. 1972. M 6; OH 3/Ce. HOBbIe p;aHHbIe R II3yqeHIIIO reHe3ITCa
ITHAO-Cpep;II3eIlIHOMopCKOII paCbI Bo06m;e II IIHp;o-rra)<IIIpCROH B '1aCTHOCTII II PacoreHe-
TlI'1eCRIIe IlpOI(eCCbI B 9THII'IeCROii IICTOpIIII. M., 1974; A6aywe.auweu.au M. r., A. e1>-
Ceee B. n., ApYT/{)Hoe C. A., CeMaW1>O H. M. COBMecTHbIe cOBeTcRO-IIHp;ITHCRIIe aHTpo-
IIOJIorHqeCRIIe IICCJIep;OBaHIIH B I1HP;ITIT B 1974-1975 n. II COB. 9THorpaq,ITH. 1976. M 6.
36 Morant G. A Study of Certain Oriental Series of Crania Including the Nepalese and
Tibetan Series in the British Museum (Natural History) II Biometrica. 1924. Vol. 16.
Pt. 1-2; Woo T., Morant G. A Preliminary Classification of Asiatic Haces Based on
Cranial Measurements II Biometrica. 1932. Vol. XXIV, pt. 1-2. CM. TaRlKe: A.aeK-
ceee B. n. R RparrIIOJIOrIIII GerrraJIbI(eB II HOBbIe IaTepIIaJIbI K aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII 3arrap;-
HOH I1HJJ:ITIT: Pe3YJIbTaTbI COBeTCRO-IIHAIIHCKIIX IICCJIep;OBaHIIH. M., 1982.
1\, A.leKceee B. n. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIii COCTaB HaCeJIeHITH ,lIJ>eBHeii I1HP;IIII II I1HP;IIH B
p;peBHocTII. M., 1964.
3 CM. rrpIIMe'l. 1.
9 e6elf r. (/I. AHTpOIlOJIOrII'IeCKIIe IICCJIep;OBaHITH B Aq,raHIIcTaHe.
,' OwaHUH JI. B. AHTpOrrOJIOrIT'IeCRIIH COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIH Cpep;HeH A3IIII II 9TrroreHe3 ee
Hapop;OB.
41 rUH36ype B. B. Paca Cpep;Hea3IIaTCRoro MelKp;ype'lbH II ee rrpOIICXOIKp;eHITe; Pbi'/,-
Koe 10. r. IIpOIICXOIKAeHIle paCbI Cpep;Hea3ITaTCKOro IeIKp;ype'lbH.
"2 e6elf r. (/I. OIl bIT rpaq,II'IeCROrO II306paIKeHIIfl reHeaJIOrII'IeCROH RJIaCCIIq,IIRaI(IIII
'1eJIOBe'leCKllX pac.
u e6elJ r. (/I. AHTpOnOJIOrn'leCRIIe IICCJIep;OBaHIIH B Aq,raHIICTaHe.
M Vallois Il. Les ossements humains de Sialk. Contribution a l'etude de l'histoire ra-
cial de l'Iran ancien II Girshman R. Fouilles de Sialk. Paris, 1940. T. II.
e:.5 Krogman W. Racial Types from Tepe-Hissar. Iran. From the Late Fifth to the Early
I
I
!
I';
345
I
Second Millennium B. C. / / Verhandlingen del' Konin!uislc :N ederlandsche Akademie
van Wetteshappen. Amsterdam, 1940. N 2. Vol. 34.
"" Mendrez C. £tude anlhropologique dcs squelettes Mundigak il Bulletin de l'ecole
Francaise d'Extreme Orient. 1966. Fasc. 1. T. LIII.
i,- Bernhard W. Human Skeletal Remains from the Cemetery of Timargarha II Bulletin
of the Archaeological Department of the University of Peshawar. 1967. Vol. III.
!, Sewell R.o Guha B. Human Hcmains II Marshall J. (ed.). Mohenjo-Daro and the Indus
Civilisation. London, 1931.
',9 Gupta P., Dutta P., Basu A. Human Skeletal Remains from Harappa II Bulletin of the
Anthropological Survey of India. Calcutta. 1962. Vol. 9.
5, A68yme.aumeu.1U M. T., A.1eKceee B. fl., Ma.abxoTpa K. '1. K xapm\:TcpUCTIIKe 1'0-
pU30HTaJIbHOro UpOq,UJIH U yrrJIolI\eHHOCTu HOCOBJ,TX RocTeii HeRoTopbIX rpyrrrr Hace-
JIeHUn 3arraAuoii U lOilmoii I1HAuu B :moxu HeOJIUTa U 6pOH3LT / / COBMecTHble co-
BeTcRo-uHp:uiiCIUTe aHTpOrrOJIOrU'leCRlIe uCCJIeAOBaHuH Ha TepplITOpIIlI IIH}:(un B 1974-
1975 n. M., 1978.
5' /l,e6elf r. CP. TIaJIcoaHTporrOJIOrnH CCCP II Tp. I1H-Ta :3THOrpaq,uu AH CCCP. H. C.
M.; 31., 1948. To 4.
5". CM. rrpUMC'l. 13.
53 KURTKUIW T. fl. MaTCpUaJIbI R rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlIII TaAlliURUCTarra. JJ:YllIaH6e, 1976.
or. CIII. rrpUMeq. 51.
,> KURTl,UHa T. fl. qeperra :3rroxu 6pOH3bI C TeppuTopIlU IOro-3arra)J,rroro TaAlliuRucTa-
Ha II MaHAeJlbllITall1 A. M. TIaMHTHuRU :3rroxu 6pOH3bI B IOffiHml Tap;lliIlRucTaHe II
MaTepUaJIbI II UCCJlep:or!aHIIH uo apxeoJIoruu CCCP. 31., 1968. N l45.
5;, KHop030e /0. B. XapaRTepUCTITRa rrporOUHAuIICRoro fl3bIRa II IIpeABapUTeJIbHoe co-
06lI\eHue 06 UCCJIeAOlJamlH rrpoTouH;:(ullcRux TeI\:CTOB. M., 1965.
K AHTPOII0J10flIlI
BOCTOqHOEBPOIIEnCKIIX KAPAIIMOB
B03MOlliHOCTlI nplIBJIe'IeHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRlIX ,L(aHHbIX R pa3pelleHlIIO
ITp06JIeMbI npOlICXOlli;'l,eHlUl RapaIIMOB TeM lllIpe, qeM pa3Ho06pa3Hee 8TlI
p;aHHble. B HailleM paCIIopHllieHlIII qeTblpe rpyuubI MOP<P0<p1I3UOJIOrlIqeCRlIX
BaplIan;lIll, C06paHITbTX B pa3JIlIqHbIX rpYIInax RapalIMOB B pa3Hoe Bpel'.UI,-
lITorlI COMaTOJIOrlI'IeCRlIX 06CJIep,OBaHlIll, RpaHIIOJIOrlI'IecRIIII MaTepIIaJI, p;aH-
Hble 0 BapIIan;nHx rpynn RpOBII, IIH<popMan;lIH 0 COOTnOilleHIIII naJIbn;eBbIX
Y30POB 1I MeCT OROH'IaHlIll JIlIHlIll JIap,OHHOro Y30pa. llpoBep,eHHbIe reHeTII'Ie-
CRlIe IICCJIe,L(OBaHlIH rrORa3bIBa1OT, 'ITa BapIIan;lIlI, OTHocHID;lIeCH R 8TlIM qeTbI-
peM rpynnaM, HaCJIe,L(YIOTCH OTHOCIITe.'IbHO He3aBIIClIl'.IO, 'ITO YClIJIlIBaeT IIX
06'beRTlIBHYIO ueHHOCTb B CJIyqae COBualleHlIH pe3YJIbTaTOB II3Y'IeHIIH pa3HbIX
ClICTeM rrp1I3HaROB. Cpe,L(II 8TlIX CIICTeM RpaHlIOJIOrlIqeCRIIe np1I3HaRII Bblp;e-
JIHIOTCH TeM, "1'1'0 OHlI ,L(OrrYCRaIOT XpOHOJIOrlIqecRyIO peTpocneRTlIBy, 06ecne-
q8IIHYIO B03MOlliHOCTHMII rrpHMoro conOCTaBJIeHIIH C naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIqeCRII-
MII l'.JaTepIIaJIaMlI. TaRIIM 06pa30M, aHTpOnOJIOrIIH KapalIMOB pacnOJIaraeT
II3BeCTHbIM 3anaCOM CBe,L(eHlIll, ROTOpbIe MOlliHO IICnOJIb30BaTb /IJIH peROH-
CTpYI n;IIlI nx aHTponO:IOrIFIeCROrO COCTaBa II ero ,L(IIHaMlIRlI, a CJIep;OBaTe.'Ib-
HO, II aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROll 6a30ll P;JIH paCCMOTpeHIIH RapaIIMCRoro 9THoreHe3a.
COMaTOJIOrlIqeCROe 06CJIe,L(OBaHIIe RapalIMOB 6bIJIO OCYID;eCTBJIeHO
C. A. BaiiceH6eprOM, paUOTaBlllIM Ha IOre POCClIlI 1I B ErnnTe 1. 1I A. H. ITy-
JIHHOCOM, c06paBlllIM Re<paJIOMeTplIqeCRlIe 1I Re<paJIOCROIIlIqeCRlIe ,L(aHHbIe
npeIIMYIl(eCTBeHHO cpep;lI RapalIMOB JInTBbI 2 . MCCJIep;OBaHIIe C. A. BallceH-
6epra. nap;aIOID;ee Ha HaqaJIO BeRa, OnIIpaJIOCb Ha MeTO)J,lIqeCR:IIe nplIeMbI,
ROTopble HeJIb3H C'IIITaTb COBepIIIeHHbIMlI B HaCTOHID;ee BpeAIH. M Bce rt\:e
OP;lIH <paRT, 11M OTMe'reHHbIll, COXpaHlIJI CBoe 3HaqeHlIe P;O COBpeMeHHOCTlI:
KapalI.\lbI 1I eBpelI, IIpOllilIBaBllIIe B ErlInTe, ORa3aJIlICb 3HaqIITeJIbHO TeMHee,
'IeM IIX c06paTbH B IOmIIbIX pallOHax POCCIIlI. CellqaC J\IOlliHO p;YMaTb, qTO
3TO HBU.TIOCb CJIep;CTBIIeM CMelleHlIH C ORpYiRaIOID;IIM HaCeJIeHIIeM, B p;aHHOM
346
CJIyqae C apa6aMII, XOTH HaJIlIqlIe ROH<peCClIOHaJIbHOrO Oapbepa p;OmKHO ObIJIO
BCTaTb Ha nYTII ;:noro npOn;ecca.
A. H. IIYJIHHOC OCYIIIeCTBlIJI Re<paJIOMeTplIqeCRIIe II3MepeHIIH :II Re<p aJIO -
CROIIlIqeCIme HaOJIIO,L(emm Cpe,L(lI RapaIIl'.IOB JIlITBbJ (B KpbIMY lIM ObIJIO
06CJIep;OBaHO TOJILRO BOCeMb meHID;lIH), OnlIpaHCb yllie Ha COBpeMeHHbJll ypo-
BeHb pa3BlITlIH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCROll MeTOjJ;lIKII :II lIMeH 3HR'IlITeJIbHbIll OnbIT
IICCJIep;OBaTeJIbCROll pa60TbI Cpe,L(lI IOmHbIX nOnYJIHn;IIll eBpOITeOlIp;HOll paCbI
(OH rrpOBeJI nepep; 3TlIM aHTpOnOJIOrlP'leCROe 1I3Y'IeIIIIe rpeROB 1I MaRep;OH-
CRUX BaJIaXOB, npOmIIBaBIIIIIX Ha TepplITOplIlI CCCP 3). M A. H. IIYJIHHocy
yp;aJIOCb 06CJIep;OBaTb B TpaRae JInIllb OROJIO 50 RapaIIMOB, HO MaJIOqlICJIeH-
HOCTb oOCJIep;OBaHHblx BOCnOJIHHeTCH nOJIHOTOll nporpaMMbI II3MepeIIlIll 1I Ha-
6JIIOp;eHIIll. JIIIn;o Y MymqIIH 1I meHID;IIH npo<plIJIlIpoBaHo pe3RO, CRYJIbI
BbJCTynaIOT cJIa60, rrepeHOCbe BbICORoe, npe06JIap;alOT IIH,L(IIBlIP;YYMbI C BblnyR-
JIbIMlI HocaMII. llIIrMeHTan;lIH TeMHaH, XOTH 3HaqIITeJIbHbIll npOn;eHT COCTaB-
JIHIOT JIlIn;a co CMellaHHbIMlI OTTeHRaMII n;BeTa BO:IOC II oc06eHHO rJIa3.
A. H. llymJHoc IIlICaJI 0 RaROM-TO IOHrOJIOlI,L(HOM «HaJIeTe}), oplIeHTII-
PYHCb, IIO-BlIP;lIMOMY, Ha cpep;nee pa3BIITJIe BOJIOCHHOro nORpOBa Ha rpYP;:II
Y MY)KTIllH II Ha onpep;eJIeHHble CJIyqalI HaJIII'IHH 3nlIRaIITyca. llpII MaJIOqlIC-
JIeHHOCTIJ lICCJIellOBanHblX JIlIn;a C 3nIIRaHTYCOM COCTaBJIHJOT 8,3 % cpep;n
Mym'IlIH II 11.1 % cpep;lI meHIIIlIH. TaROll npOn;eHT JlIOp;ell C 3nlIRaHTYCOM
He MomeT 6bITb c.rryqallHOCTbIO 1I, p;ellCTBIITeJIbHO, CBlIp;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 HaJIlI-
'IlIII y RapaIIMOB JIIITBbI He60JIbIIIOll MOHrOJIOIIp;HOll npIIMeCII, XOTH YMepeH-
HbIll pOCT BOJIOC Ha rpY,L(II Y MymqlIH caM no ceoe MomeT 6bITb IICTOJIROBaH
II 6e3 IIplIHHTIIH rlIIIOTe3bI MOHrOJIOlIp;HOll npIIMeClI: OCJIa6JIeHIIe 3Toro npn-
BHaRa 1I1'.IeeT l'.IeCTO II B pHp;e IIony JIHn;nii eBponeOIIIJ,HOrO CTBOJIa p;afT{e Ha
lOre, r,L(e B n;eJIOM pOCT BOJIOC Ha rpY,L(II Y MymqlIH lInTeHClIBHee.
OCHOBHOll ROMnJIeRC np1I3HaROB, npep;CTaBJIeHHbIll cpep;lI RapalIMOB,
A. H. llYJIHHOC CqIITaeT nepe,L(Uea3IIaTcRIIM, nO,L(pa3YMeBaH nop; 3TlIM, oqe-
BHp;no, Bblp;eJIenHYJO <D. JIyrnaHoM apMeHoIIp;HYIO ROM61IHan;lIIO np1I3HaRoB.
O,L(HaRO Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCRaH xapaRTeplIcTIIKa nepep;Hea3IIaTcRoro, IIJIII apMe-
HOIIp;Horo, ROMnJIeRCa BRJIIOqaeT B Ra'IeCTBe O.D;Horo 1I3 OCIIOBHbIX np1I3HaRoB
RaR pa3 MaRCIIMaJIbHO ClIJIbHOe pa3BIITIIe TpeTlIqHOrO BOMOCHHoro nORpOBa,
B 3TOM OTHOlleHlIII nepep;Hea31IaTcRIIe nonYJIHn;IIlI YCTynaJOT, MomeT ObITI.,
TOJIbRO allHaM. 1l03TOMY MbI oY.D;eM 6JIIIme R p;ellCTB:IITeJIbHOCT:II, eCJIlI OTHe-
eel\! npep;CTaBJIeHHYJO Y RapaIIMOB ROMoIIHan;lIIO npII3HaRoB R O,L(HOMY 113
BaplIaHTOB IOmHOll BeTBII eBponeOlIp;HOll paCbI. B TO me BpeMH HaJIII'IHe
HHlJ,lIBIIP;YYMOB CO CMellaHHbIMll OTTeHRaMII BOJIOC :II rJIa3 rOBopIIT 0 npIIMecn
O,L(HOrO 113 TeX BapIIaHTOB eBponeOIIp;HOll paCbI, ROTopble OTHOCHTCH R ceBep-
Hoii: BeTBlI lIJIlI 06pa30BaJIlICb BCJIep;CTBlIe CMeilleHIIH npep;CTaBIITeJIen: ceBep-
HbIX 1I IOmHbIX eBponeOlIp;OB. TaRoe CMeilleHIIe Ha'laJIOCb, HaBepHoe, eID;e
B HeOJI:IITe IIJIlI p;ame B Me30JIlITe, CMellaHHble <pOpMbI 06pa3YJOT orpOMHbIM
IIOHC B npep;eJIax apeaJIa eBponeOlI.D;OB Memp;y CRaHp;IIHaBIIell II Cpe,L(II3eMHO-
MopbeM, II IIMeHHO OHII, Hap;o ,L(YMaTb, II nplIHHJIlI Y'IaCTlIe B <pOpMlIpOBaHI'IH
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO COCTaBa RapalIMOB.
KaRYJO p;OnOJIHIITeJIbHyro IIH<popMan;IlJO MomeT p;06aBIITb RO BceMY CRa-
3aHHOMY II3yqeHlIe BaplIan;lIll naJIbn;eBbIX Y30POB II JIap;OHHbIX JIlIHIIll? OHO
6bIJIO oCYID;eCTBJIeHO r. JI. XIITb He C nOMoID;bJO B3HTIIH OTneqaTROB, RaR
9'1'0 OOblqHO npaRTImyeTcH, a na OCHOBe <plIRcan;IIH ;!TIIX BaplIan;IIll Heno-
epe,L(CTBeHHO B nOJIeBbIX YCJIOB:IIHX npII paCCMaTpIIBaHIIII :IIX Ha JIa.D;OH:II
B JIyny \ CaMa aBTOp nOJIaraeT, '1'1'0, MomeT ObITb, 3a CqeT 9Toro MeTop;n-
'JeCRoro npIIeMa CJIep;yeT OTHeCTlI IICRJIIOqlITeJIbHO l'.IaJIbIll npOn;eHT JilIn; C
p;06aBOqHbIMII MemnaJIbn;eBbIM:II TpIIpa.D;nycaMII, C TPYP;OM onpep;eJIHeMbIMn He
Ha o TUeqaTRaX, a Ha JIap;OHHX. Ho :II no .D;PyrIIM npII3HaRaM cBoe06pa3IIe
I
I
h
T.
i
F
H.
347
I)
J
RapalIMOB lICRJIIOqlITeJIbHO, 1I OHO pe3RO Bblp,eJIHeT lIX Cpep,H ,L(pyrlIX HapOllOB
BOCTOqHOM EBpOnbI. BbIBOp, 8'1'0'1' OnlIpaeTCH Ha OrpOMHbIll CpaBHlITeJIbHbIll
MaTeplIaJI, C06paHHbIll 1I 06pa60TaHHbIll r. JI. XIITb lIJIlI nOL\ ee PYROBO,L(CT-
BO I, II 06'beRTlIBHOCTb ero He BbI3bIBaeT HII MaJIelllllIX COMneHlIll.
1l0,L(TBepmp,aeT JIU ROMnJIeRC ,L(epl\IaTOrJIu<plI'IeCRUX BaplIaulIM, 3a<pURClI-
pOBaHHbI:ll Y RapalIMOB, onlIpaIOID;lIllCH Ha COMaTOJIOrlIqeCR:IIe Ha6JIIo,L(eHlIH
BbIBOi'J; 0 npIIHallJIemHOCTu UX R IOmHOll BeTBlI eBpOneOlIiJ,JIOll paCbI? BbICORoe
3Ha'IelIIIe IIH.D;eRCa KaMMIIHca MomeT ObITb IICTOJIROBaHO RaR aprYMeHT
B nOJIb3Y 8Toro BbIBop,a. HaIIpOTlIB, H1I3RaH BeJIlIqIIHa ,L(eJIbTOBOro lIHI:(eRca
npOTlIBOpeqUT 8TOM,\', TaR RaR Ha IOre BeJIlIqIIHbI ,L(eJIbTOBOro IIH,L(eRca MHoro
60JIbIIIe. B 06ID;eM gepMaTOrJIlI<plI'IecRoe cBoe06pa3ue RapalIMoB no cpaBHe-
HlIIO C L\pyrlIMu HapO,L(aMlI BOCTO'IHOll EBponbI He YRJIa,L(bIBaeTCH B rlInOTe3Y
IIX npIIHagJIemHOCTII R IOmHbIM eBponeollgaM. reHeTlIRa IHorlIX rrp1I3HaROB
RomHoro peJILe<pa ,L(aJIeRa 0'1' iI eJIaeMOll HCHOCTlI, HO Cpe,L(II reHeTlIROB, 3a-
HlIMaIOID;lIXCH np06JIel'.IaMlI lIX nepella IJ IIO HaCJIe,L(CTBY, IIIIIpORO pacnpOCTpa-
HeHbI rlInOTe3bI, COrJIaCHO ROTOpbIl\I 3TlI np1I3HaRII geTepMlInlIpYIOTCH He-
60JIbIIIIIM lJ.IICJIOM reHOB. ECJIU 8'1'0 ,L(eiiCTBIITeJIbHO TaR, TO CO'IeTaHlIe rraJIb-
n;eBbIX Y30POB Ii JIap,OHHbIX JIlIHlIll Y RapaIIMOB TaROBO, RaR eCJIlI 6bI onlI
gOJIro rrpOmIIBaJIII B YCJIOBIIHX II30JIHn;1I1I: lIMeHHO Tor.D;a npn3HaRII C npOCTOK
naCJIe,L(CTBeHHOCTbIO, T. e. orrpen;eJIHeMble B lIX HaCJIegcTBeHHOll nepe,L(aqe
orpaHII'IeIIHbIM 'IlICJIOM reHOB, 06HapymlIBaIDT B MaJIOqlICJIeHHbIX nonYJIH-
n;lIHX C,L(BIIrlI B pa3HbIX HanpaBJIeHlIHX 1I CRJIa,L(bIBaIOTCH cBoe06pa3HbIe ROM-
61IHan;IIII, He HaXOiJ,HID;lIe aHaJIOrIIll. B JIlITBY ObIJIa nepeCeJIeHa He3HaqlI-
TeJIbHaH no qlICJIeHHOCTII rpynIIa RapaIIMOB, :IIX II30JIlIpOBaHHoe nOJIOmeHlIe
npe,L(onpe.D;eJIHJIOCb ROH<peCClIOHaJIbHbIM <paKTOpOM, BblcTynaBlllIM B pOJIlI
meCTRoro reHeTIIqeCROrO 6apbepa. TaRIIM 06pa30M, 06ID;IIll BbIBOg 113 gepMa-
TOrJIlI<plI'IeCROrO 06CJIegoBaHIIH RapalIMOB JIlITBbI COCTOIIT B TOM, '1'1'0 reHe-
TlIqeCRaH 1I30JIHn;lIH 6bIJIa OgHIIM 1I3 MOMeHTOB, nOBJIIIHBlllIX Ha <pOpMlIpOBa-
HlIe IIX aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROrO COCTaBa.
ECJIlI IICRJIID'IlITb qpe3BbI'IallHO MaJIOqIICJIeUHbIe gaHHbIe A. H. llYJIHHoca,
TO no rpynnaM RpOBII RapaIIMOB MbI pacrrOJIaraeM lIH<popMan;lIell, c06paHHoll
B npon;ecce Tpex IICCJIegoBaHIIll - C. 3a60JIOTHOrO B KpbHlY" M. Pallxepa 6
II K. .D:llilIHII 7 B JIIITBe. Kamgoe 1I3 8TlIX lICCJIegoBaHIIll OXBaTIIJIO
OROJIO 300 (C. 3aOOJIOTHbIll IICCJIegoBaJI game OROJIO 400) qeJIOBeR :II MomeT
CqUTaTbCH BnOJIUe g06pORaqeCTBeHHbIM B OTHOilleHIIII QIICJIeHHOCTlI II3Y'IeH-
HbIX BbI6opoK. K COmaJIeHIIID, pe3YJIbTaTbI, nOJIyqeHHbIe npII ,L(BYX 06CJIe,rroBa-
HlIHX RapaIIMOB JIIITBbI B 1928 II 1934 rr., ORa3aJIlICb npoTlIBope'IlIBbIMlI,
HecMoTpH Ha TO '1'1'0 npaRTIIqeCRII B nO,L(aBJIHIOID;eM OO.'IbIIIlIHCTBe CJIY'IaeB
B ooe BbI60pRII nonamI OgHlI II Te me lIH,L(lIBIIgYYMbI. Pe3Y.1JbTaTbI K. ):(;.RlIHlI
HaxogHTcH B ropa3go 60JIbIIIeM COOTBeTCTBIIII C 06ID;ell RapTlIHoll BapIIan;lIll
rpynn RpOBlI ClICTeMbI ABO B EBpone II IIepegHell A3IIlI, qeM pe3YJIbTaTbI
M. Pallxepa, nOJIyqlIBIIIerO HeOObPIallHO H1I3KlIM npOn;eHT rpynnbI A. Ho II
nplI corrOCTaBJIeHIIII pe3YJIbTaTOB K. .D:mIIHlI no RapalIMa I JIlITBbI C ,L(aH-
HbIMII C. 3a60JIOTHOrO no RapalIMaM KpbIMa lIMeIOT. MeCTO oIIpe,L(eJIeHHbIe
pa3JIlI'IlIH: YMeHbIIIeHIIe npOn;eHTa JilIn; C rpynnoll A II YBeJIlIqeHlIe C rpyn-
nOll B B JIIITBe IIPlI cpaBHeHlIlI C KpbIMOM.
A. IIYJIHHoc, ony6JIlIROBaBlllIll nepBble CBe.D;eH:IIH 0 ROHlWHTpan;:II:II oTpn-
n;aTeJIbHOrO pe3yca B nonYJIHn;lIlI RapaIIMOB JIlITBbI, nORa3aJI BbICORYIO CTe-
neHb :nOll Ronn;eHTpan;lIII, BbI,L(eJIHIOID;YIO RapaIIMoB cpegII ,L(pyrlIx nonYJIHn;lIM
EBponbI 1I llepegHell A31III. B conOCTaBJIeHlIlI C <paRTOl\I nOBbIlleHlIH y HlIX
rpynnbI B 1I co cBoe06pa31IeM lIX gepMaTormI<plIqeCROrO TIIua 3'1'0 CJIymlIT
eID;e O,L(HIIM YRa3aHlIeM Ha pOJIb reHeTlIqeCROII 1I30JIfln;1I:II B <pOpMlIpOBaHIIlI
aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRlIX oc06eHHOCTell JIIITOBCRlIX RapaIIMOB.
348
ABTOp 3TlIX CTpOR OnlICaJI CepIIIO qepenOB, npoIICXO.D;HID;HX :II3 n03}:\tiIIX
RapaIIMCRIIX RJIap;61IID; KpbIMa 8. B TOll me pa60Te 6bIJIII onIIcaHbI XpaITH-
ID;lIeCH B pa3JIIIqHbIX aHaTOMlIqeCRlIX 1I RpaHlIOJIOrIIqeCRIIX c06paHIIHX qepella
eBpeeB 1I3 IOmHbIX pallOHOB POCC:rIIi, OTHOClIBlllIXCH R rpynne aillReHa31I.
1l0cJIep;HHH ceplIH OqeHb MaJIO'IlICJIeHHa II npOlICXOP;lIT 113 CJIyqallHbIX C60POB,
HO nORa B HailleM pacnopHmeHIIlI HeT 60JIee nOJIHbIX MaTeplIaJIOB no Rpa-
HlIOJIOrlIII eBpeeB BOCTOqnOll EBponbI. BbIJIlI OTMeqeHbI CYID;eCTBeHHbIe MOp-
<pOJIOrIIqeCRlIe pa3JIlIqlIH Memp;y P;ByM.H cepIIHMlI, n03BOJIlIBllIIe npe,L(nOJIa-
raTb pa3UYro reHeTlIqeCRyro nplIHa,L(JIemHOCTb OCTaBlIBmero HX HaCeJIeH:IIH.
KpaHlIOJIOrIIqeCRlIll MaTepIIaJI no RapalIMaM cpaBHIIBaJICH C lllIpORIIM Rpy-
rOM RpaHlIOJIOrWI8CKIIX ceplIll 3nOXII cpep;HeBeROBbH, B nepByro Oqepep;b,
pa3Yl\IeeTCH, 1I3 IOmHbIX pallOHOB BOCTOqHOll EBpOnbI. HaII60JIbillee CXO,L(CTBO
RapalIMbI 06HapymlIJIII C HaCeJIeHlIeM cpe.D;HeBeROBbIX rOpO.D;OB KpbIMa, RaR
1I3BeCTHO, O'IeHb CJIOn{HbIM B 3TIIlIqeCROM OTHOilleHIIlI. 1l0-BlI,L(IIMOMY, HaCeJIe-
HlIe CpelJ:HeBeIWBbIX ropop;OB KpbIMa, B qaCTHOCTII 8CRlI-KepMeHa 1I MaHryn-
KaJIe 9, COCTaBIIJIO TY aHTpOnOJIDrlIqeCRyro OCHOBY, Ha ROTOpOll C<pOPMlIPO-
BaJICH aHTpOITOJIOrlIqeCRlIll TIIII RapaIIMOB B KpbIMY.
Op;HaRO 3TOT BbIBOP; He IICqepIIbIBaeT Bcell CJIOmHOCTII np06JIeMbI CJIOiRe-
HIIH aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO COCTaBa Rapa:IIMCROrO HapO.D;a. 06llIIpHbIe MaTepIIa-
JIbI no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII Xa3apCRoro RaraHaTa, nOJIyqeHHbIe nplI paCRon-
Rax CapReJIa - BeJIOll Bemll 10, nORa3bIBaIOT C nOJIHOll onpep;eJIeHHOCTbIO,
'ITO aIITpOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIll ROMnOHeHT, npep;CTaBJIeHHbIll y pHp;OBoro HaCeJIeHlIH
Xa3apCRoro RaraHaTa (IIMeeTCH B BlIP;y B nepBYro Oqepep;b HeRpOnOJIb
B HaCbIIIlI 17/10), TaRme nplIHHJI yqaCTlIe B <pOpMlIpoBaHIIlI aHTpOnOJIOr:II-
qeCROrO COCTaBa RapaIIMOB KpbIMa. 1l0p;06Hoe RpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCRII YCTaHaBJIII-
BaeMoe CMelleHlIe npII CJIOiReHlIlI aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROrO 06JIIIRa RapaHMOB
.z:\Byx aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRlIX KOMnOHeHTOB, xapaRTepHbIX ,L(JIH pHp;OBoro HaCeJIe-
HIIH Xa3apcRoro RaraHaTa II HaCeJIeHlIH neID;epHbIX rOpO,L(oB KpbIMa, MomeT
6bITb nop;TBepmp;eHO 1I HOBbIMlI naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCI{lIMII MaTeplIaJIaMlI 113
neID;epHbIX ropop;OB, Mop<p0JIOrlIqeCRlI nOBTopIIBlllIMII TOT me ROMnJIeRC nplI
3HaROB, '1'1'0 1I B 8CRlI-KepMeHe :II MaHryn-KaJIe 11.
COMaTOJIOrlIqeCRII <pIIRclIpyeMbIll <paRT nplIHa,L(JIemHOCTII RapalIMOB R IOm-
HOll BeTBII eBponeOlIp;OB C He60JIbillOll nplIMecbro CMellaHHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB
XOpOIIIO corJIacyeTcH C pe3YJIbTaTaMlI conOCTaBJIeHlIH KpaHlIOJIOrIIqeCRIIX H
naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRlIX MaTepIIaJIOB. JIerRo 06'bHCHHeTCH npII 3TOM II B03-
MomHOCTb coxpaHeHlIH He60JIbillOn M(,HrOJIOlIp;HOll nplIMeClI Y RapaIIMOB, RO-
TopaH Ha6JIIOp;aJIaCb y HaCeJIeHlIH Xa3apCRoro RaraHaTa.
B IITOre Bcero CRa3aHHoro Mbl nplIXO,L(IIM R BbIBO,L(Y, '1'1'0 npII paCCMOT-
peUITII BonpOCOB 3THoreHe3a RapalIMOB HymHo Y'llITbIBaTb pHP; MOMeHTOB,
BbITeRaroID;lIx 1I3 1I3yqeHlIH lIX aIITponOJIOrlIqeCROrO COCTaBa 1I ero p;lIHaMlIRlI.
1. AHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCRlIe oc06eHHOCTII RapalIMOB CJIOmlIJIIICb B npon;ecce
CMelleHlIH Tex aIITpOnOJIOrII'18CKlIX 3JIeMeHTOB, ROTOpbIe npe06JIap;aJIII Y Ha-
CeJIeHlIH Xa3apCRoro RaraHaTa 1I neID;epHbIX ropop;OB KpbIMa. 8TO HeOCnOp:II-
MbIll BbIBOP; 113 conOCTaBJIeHIIH RpaHIIOJIOrlIqeCRlIX 1I naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqe-
CRlIX ,L(aHHbIX.
2. KapalIMbI nplIHap;JIemaT R IOmIIoll BeTBlI eBponeolIp;oB, HO IIMeIOT B
CBoeM COCTaBe nplIMecb 60JIee ceBepHblx 3JIeMeHTOB II He60JIbrnyIO MOHro-
JIOlI,L(HYro npIIMeCb. To me CO'IeTaHlIe aHTpOnOJIOrII'leCRlIx 3JIeMeHTOB 6bIJIO
xapaRTepHo ,L(JIH nonYJIHn;lIll, npOiRlIBaBIIIlIx B Xa3apcRoM RaraHaTe. 1l0IIY-
JIHn;lIlI, OCTaBlIBlllIe rreID;epHbIe ropo.D;a KpbIMa, He lIMeJIlI MOHrOJIOlI,L(HOll
nplIMeClI lIJIlI lIMeJIlI ee B 3HaqlITeJIbHO MeHbilleM npOn;eHTe.
3. IIocJIe nepeCeJIeHIIH rpynnbI RapalIMoB B JIIITBY ee aHTpOnOJIOr:IIqeCRRll
COCTaB lICnbITaJI BJIlIHHIIe reHeT:IIqeCROll 1I30JIHn;IIlI.
1
I
I
349
1 Bauce1l6epe C. A. RapaII:UbI II PYC.-aHTpOnOJI. 1I<YPH. 1904. No! 1/2; Weissenberg S. Zur
Anthropologie der nordaIrikanischen Juden II Mitteilungen der anthropologischen Ge-
sellschaft in Wien. 1912. Bd. XLIII.
lly.1RIiOC A. H. R aHTpOnOJlOrIm KapaIIMoB JlIITBbI II RpbIMa II Bonp. aHTpOnOJIOrIIII.
1963. BbTll. 13.
3 llY.!1.RIiOC A. H. AHTpOnOJIOrIFIeCRIIH COCTaB HaCeJIeHIIH rpel\IIII. feorpaqJII'IeCRaH
AIIcpcpepeHl\IIal\IIH oTAeJThHbIX npII3HaKOB II AHTponOJlOrII'IeCRIlii C60PHIIR, III. M.,
1961. (Tp. Urr-Ta ;JTIIOrpacpIIII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 71).
XUTb r. JI. lJ;epMaTOrJIIlcpIIRa HapoAoE CCCP. M., 1983.
5 Sabobotny S. Die Blutgruppen der Karaimen und Krimtschakcn II Ukrain. Zenttal-
Blatt der Blutgruppenforschung. 1928. Bd. III, H. 1.
J Reicher M. Sur les groupes sanguins des Caraimes de Troki et de 'Vilno II Anthro-
pologie. Praha. 1932. T. X.
7 Gini C. Karaimi ai Polonia e Lituania. Genus, 1936. TIOJlHaH cBoAKa reHeTH'IeCRIIX
,'IaHrrbIX no RapaHMaM: Mourant A., Kopec A., Domaniewska Sobczak K. The genetics
of the Jews. Oxford, 1978.
8 A.zez>ceee B. ll. O'IepR npoHcxoiKp;eHHH TlOpRCKIIX HapoAoB BOCTO'IHOH EBponbI B
CBeTe p:aHHbIX RpaHHOJlOrIm II BonpOCLT :nHoreHeaa TJOpKCKIIX rrapOAOB Cpep:Hero TIo-
BOJIiKbH. Ra3aHb, 1971.
" TIaJleOaHTpOnOJlOrII'IeCKIIH MaTepIIaJI H3 HeRpOnOJleH 3TIIX ropoAoB 6bIJI onIIcaH
r. <D. lJ;e6eu;oM. Clio!.: l1.e6elf r. tP. AHTpOnOJIOrWleCKIIH COCTaB rraCeJIeHHH cpeAHeBe-
ROBbTX ropOAOB RpbTMa II C6. MY3eH aHTpOnOJIOrIIII H 3TIIorpacpHII AH CCCP. M.; JI.,
1949. T. 12. CORpalI\eHHbIH TeKCT 3TOH CTaTbII BOIIleJI B cooTBeTcTByrolI\IIH pa3AeJI
ero cBoAHOro TpYAa no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII CCCP. CM.: l1.e6elf r. tP. TIaJIeOaHTpono-
JIGrIIH CCCP. M.; JI., 1948. (Tp. IIH-Ta 3THorpacpIIII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 4).
II' rU1Ia6ype B. B. AHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCRIIe MaTepHaJIbI R np06JIe:ue npoHcxoiKAeHIIH Hace-
;[eHIIH XaaapcKoro KararraTa II C6. MY3eH arrTpOnOJIGrHH II 3THorpacpIIII AH CCCP.
M.; JI., 19 1. T. 13. CM. TaKiKe Tp. BOJIro-p:OHCKOH apXeOJIOrII'IeCROH 3RcneAIIl\IIII.
T. III II MaTepIIaJIbI II IIccJIeAoBaHIIH no apXeOJIOrIIII CCCP. No! 109. M.; JI., 1963.
I. EIIOJIIIOrpacpIIro II KpaTKYro Ta6JIII'IHYro CBOAKY AaHHbIx CM.: A,7ez>ceee B. ll. XapaR-
TepIICTIIKa KparrHOJIOrII'IeCKIIX "IaTepIIaJIOB II3 n03p;HIIx MYCYJIbMaHCKIIX 3axopOHe-
HIIII RpbIMa II IIccJIeAOnarrIIH 110 naJIeOaHTpono.rrorIIII II KparrIIOJIOrIIII CCCP II C6. My-
3eH aHTpOnOJIOrIIII II ;JTHOrpacpIIH AH CCCP. T. 36. 31., 1980. CM. TaRiKe: illee'leli-
z>o A. B. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKaH xapaKTepIICTIIKa cpeAHeneRoBoro rraCeJIeHIIH HIIaOBbeB
BOJIrII: (TIo KpaHHOJIOrII'IeCKIIM MRTepIIaJIaM II3 MOrIIJIbHIIRa XaH-Tro6e) II TaM iKe.
B 3TOii CTaTbe onncarr MaTepIIaJI, rreCYlI\IIII TOT ihe KOllolTIJIeKC npII3HaKOB, 'ITO II Y
oOJlee paHHero HaCeJIeHHH Xa3apCRGrO KararraTa.
o IIPOMCXOmAEHMM APEBHE:ttmErO
EBPOIIEOIIAHOrO HACEJIEHMH
MIIHYCMHCKO:tt KOTJIOBMHbI
II pe.D;lleCTBYIOID;lIe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRIIe IICCJIe.D;OBaHIIH, OCHOBaHHbIe Ha
.D;OCTaTO'IIIO 60JIbillOM MaTepnaJIe, YCTaHOBIIJI:II, 'ITO HaCeJIeHIIe XaRaCCRO-
MIIHYClIHCRIIX CTenell B 9noxy 6pOH3bI OTHOCIIJIOCb R eBpOneOII.D;HOll pace 1.
8'1'0 MomHO CqlITaTb CnpaBe.D;JIIIBbIM .D;ame .D;JIH RapacYRcRoll RYJIbTYPbI, XOTH
ee C03,L(aTeJIII II IIMeJIII B CBoeM COCTaBe He60JIbillyro MOHrOJIOII.D;HyIO npIIMeCb,
HO B nO).l;aBJIHIOID;eII CBoell Macce OTHOCIIJI:IICb R eBpOneOIl.D;aM, 'ITO 6bIJIO no.D;-
TBepiH.D;eHO II B HOBellillell npopa60TRe Bcero naJIeOaHTponOJIOrII'IeCROrO MaTe-
pnaJIa no RapacYRcRoll KYJIbType 2. qTO me RacaeTCH HaCeJIeHIIH a<paHaCbeB-
CROll II aH.D;pOHOBCROll RYJIbTYP, TO HII B pa60Tax r. <D. e6en;a, HII B MOIIX
He ObIJIO onlIcaHO HII O.D;Horo qepena II3 aH.D;pOHOBCRIIX II a<paHaCbeBCRlIX IIO-
rpe6eHIIll, na ROTOpOM MORmo 6bIJIO 6bI OTMeTIlTb MOHrOJIOII.D;HbIe oc06eH-
HOCTII.
MCRJIIOqeHIIe COCTaBIIJIII qepen II3 norpe6eHIIH Y ACRII3a, pacRonaHHoro
II onIIcaHHoro A. H. JIIIncRIIM 3, II 'Iepena Il3 paCRonaHHoro IIM me cBoe06-
pa3Horo norpe6aJIbHOrO naMHTHlIRa Tac-Xa3aa 4. IIplI CIIJIbHOM MaCCIIBHOCTII
II 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOM pa3BIlTIIII HOCOBOll 06JIaCTII OHlI OTJIllqaJIIICb ynJIOm;eH-
350
HOCTblO JIIIn;eBOrO np0<pIIJIH U noc;rrymlIJIII OCHOBaHUeM .D;JIH yCTaHOBJIeHIIH
B COCTaBe a<paHaCbeBCROrO naCeJIeHUH RaROrO-TO npOTOMOp<p HOrO MOHrOJIOII,o:-
Horo TIma. O,o:HaRO nOCJIe HOBbIX paCRonOR KpacnoHpcRoll apXeOJIOrIlqeCROM
9Rcne,o:IIn;UII 6bIJIO nORa3aHO, qTO II B Tac-Xa3aa II B ACI{II3e peqb ,L(OJImHa
:II,L(TII 0 ,o:OCTaTOqUO qeTRO BblpameHHOM RYJIbTYPHOM cBoe06pa3I'!lI naMHTHII-
ROB, ROTOpbIe BMeCTe C BHOBb OTRpbITbIMII KpacHoHpcROM 9Rcne,o:lIn;IIeM
MOrIIJIbHIIRaMU 6bIJIII 06'be,L(IIHeHbI B ORYHeBCKYIO RYJIbTYPY 5. Ee RyJIbTYP-
HaR OOOC06JIeHHOCTb npu cpaBHeHIIII C a<paHacbeBcRoM conpOBom.D;aJIaCb
II 3naqUTeJIbHbIM aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRHM cBoeo6pa3IIeM, '1'1'0 HaIIIJIO no,o:TBepm-
;J,eHlIe B IICCJIe,L(OBaHUII MaCCOBoro naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCROrO MaTeplIaJIa u3
qepHoBoll VIII 6.
KOM6IIHan;UH npII3HaROB, xapaRTepHaH ,L(JIH a<paHaCbeBCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH,
paCCMaTpIIBaJIaCb RaK OL\UH U3 JIORanbHNX BapIIaHTOB ,L(peBHero npOTOMOp -
Horo eBponeOII,L(HOrO ROl'.InJIeRca. Ee OTJI1PIIIH 0'1' aH,L(pOHOBCROM ROM6IIHan;UU
HeCOl'.IHeHIIbI, eCJIII cpaBHIIBaTb aH,L(pOHOBCRoe II a<paHaCbeBCRoe HaCeJIenne
B rrpe,o:eJIax MIIHYC1IHCROll ROTJIOBIIHbI: an;r1pOIIOBn;bI B n;eJIOM 60JIee l'.IaCCIIB-
HbI II qepenHOll yRa3aTeJIb Y HIIX Ha ,L(Be e,L(IIHUn;bI BbIlle. O.D;HaRO II3 0'1'-
,L(eJIbHbIX a<paHaCbeBCRIIX MOrlIJIbHIIROB 'Iepena He ilenee l'.IaCCIIBHbI, qeM 1I3
aHp:pOHOBCRIIX norpe6eHUll (TaRIIe qepena ,i],aJI, Hanpu:VIep, MOrIIJIbHIIR Ka-
pacYR III, naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIM MaTepIIaJI U3 ROToporo BTIepBbIe BBO,i],IIT-
CH B HayqHbIll 060POT B aToM CTaTbe), II pa3JIIFme, CJIe,i],OBaTeJIbHO, CBO.D;UTCH
R He3Ha'IIITeJIbHOll pa3HIIn;e B qepenFiOM yRa3aTeJIe. ECJIII jHe MbI npIIMeM
BO BHHMaHIle BeCb llaROnJIeHHbIll MaTepIIaJI no KpanlIOJIOrIIII aH,L(pOHOBCRoro
HaCeJIeIIUH, npOIlcxo,o:HIl(IIll co BceII TeppIITOp1IH pacnpocTpaHeHIIH aH,o:pOHOB-
CROll KYJIbTypbI, BRJIIOqaH II Ka3axcTaH 7, TO l'.IOp<p0JIOrUqeCRUe OTJIIIqIIH
aH,L(pOHOBn;eB 0'1' a<paHaCbeBn;eB COBceM HeOT'IeTJIUBbI. BNBO,L( f. <P. .D:e6en;a
o Cal'.IOCTOHTeJIbHOM TaRCOHOMIIqeCROM nOJIOmeHIIII aHL\pOHOBCRoro BapIIaHTa
npOToeBponellCRoro, IIJIII, RaR OIl nncaJI, «RpOMaHbOHCRoro B llIIpOROM CMbIC-
JIe», TIBIa He HaXO,i],IIT, CJIe.D;OBaTenbIIO, rrO,i],TBepm,i],eHIIH.
Bonpoc 0 npouCXOm,L(eHuII a<paHacbeBcRoro HaCeJIeU1IH HeO,i],HORpaTHo 3a-
TparIIBaJICH B npemHIIX aHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCRUX pa60Tax. Ho npemL\e qeM nepell-
'1'11 K HeMY HenOCpe,L(CTBeHHo, ,L(OJIa;:eII OHJeTIITL, '1'1'0 B HaCTOHID;ee Bpel'.IP
B HailleM pacnopHnmHIIII 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO 60JIbillee qIICJIO .D;aHHbIX no na.TIeo-
aHTpOIIOJIOrIIU a<panacbeBcRoll RYJIbTypN, 'TeM 20 neT Ha3a,i]" Ror,i],a ObIJIa
ony6JIUROnaHa nOCJIe,L(IIHH CBO,L(Ra naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX MaTepIIaJIOB H3
a<paHaCLeBCRUX MOrIIJIbHUKOB. Bce 9TU iJ,anIIble rrO,i],rOTaBJilIBaIOTCH R TIYt5. m-
R.'2n;IIII B cnen;IIanbHOM 1J3,i],RHUII, II 3.o:eCb HeT B03MomHOCTII IIX ,i],ame nepe J
'IIICJIIITb. OTl\Ieqy, O,L(HaRO, 'ITO HaRonneHIIe MaTepIIaJIa n03BOJIHeT Tenepb
paCCMaTp1IBaTb anTpOnOJIOrIlqeCRlIll COCTaB HaCeJIeHUH a<paHaCbeBCROII RYJIb
TYPN He CYMMapno, RaR aTO ,L(eJIaJlOCb paHbIIIe, a orrupaHCb na xapaRTepJl-
CTIIRII OT,o:eJIbHbIX MOrIIJIbHIIROB. B Ta6n. 28 npIIBO.D;IIM ,o:aHHbIe 0 MymcKHx
qepenHbIX cepnHX 113 Tpex MOrUJIbHIIROB - ,o:BYX C TeppIITopIIII MIIHY-
CUHCROM ROTJIOBUHbI II O,L(HOrO C TepplITopUII AJITaH, ROTOpbIe paHbille He
rry6JIIIROBaJIIICb.
MOrIIJIhHIIR KapacYR III 6bIJI pacRonaH M. H. f Ol\IapOBOll B 1961-
1963 rr. B paMRax KpacHoHpcRoll apxeOJIOrIPIeCROll aRcne.o:IIn;IIII. OCTeOJIOrII-
'IeCRIIll MaTepUaJI II3 9TIIX paCRonOR 6bIJI nepe,L(aH B MY3ell aHTpOnOJIGrUH
II 9THorpa<puII AH CCCP, r,L(e II 6bIJI l'.IHOll pa306paH U H3Y'IeH B 1967 r.
TaM me 6NJI pa306paH II H3Y'IeH MaTepUaJI II3 pacRonoR M. ll. fpH3HoBa
Ha A<paHacbeBcRoii: rope, oCYID;ecTBJIeHHbIX B 1963-1964 rr. qepena :II ROC 'I'll
6bIJIII qaCTlIqHO .D;enaCnOpTII3upOBaHbI B npon;ecce ynaRoBRII II nepeB030R,
II H He Cl'.IOr 6N OTOm,i],eCTBIITb IIX C onpe.D;eJIeHHbIMII norpe6eH1IHMII, eCJIH 6bI
He nOCTOHHHaR nOMoID;b JI. A. MBaHOBOM, B PYRax oTopoii 6bIJIa BCR nOJIe-
351
Ta6JI1n a 28
Cpe,!lHlle pa3MephI cepHii H3 OT,!IeJIbHhIX MOrHJIbHHKOB. MymcIrne 1Jeperra
I
HanMeHOBaHHe MOrHJIbHHRa
IIpH3HaR I YCTb-J{YIOM
RapacYR III I AljJaHacbeBa
ropa
1.. TIpO,!lOJIbHblll LlrIaMCTp 192,6(7) 193,7 (12) 189,2(4)
8. IIorrepe'lHblll ,!IuaMeTp 142,1 (7) 141,2(11) 143,2(4)
17. BhICOTHblii: ,!IIIaMCTp OT 6a3HoHa - 136.0 (5) 136,8 (8) 141,2(4)
5. ):(JIIIHa OCHOBaHIIfl 'leperra 106,4(5) 105,4 (7) 104.8(4)
9. HaIIMeHbIUaH IUupHHa JI6a 97,8(9) 98,5 (13) 102,5(4)
40. ):(JIIIHa OCHOBaHIIH JIIII(a 104,0(4) 103,3 (7) 96,5(4)
45. CKYJIOBaH ulIIpuHa 141.2 (6) 135,4 (7) 136,8(4)
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa JIIII(a 69,9(8) 69,7 (9) 66.3(4)
51. IIIupuHa Op6IITbI OT mf (JIeB.) 43,5(6) 42,5 (5) 43,1 (4)
52. BblcoTa Op6UTbI (JIeB.) 31,6 (8) 31,8(10) 31,1 (4)
54. illupIIHa Hoca 24,9(7) 24,8 (6) 26,0(4)
55. BblcoTa Hoca 51.8 (8) 50,3(9) 48,8 (4)
72. 06II(Ull yrOJI JIUI(eBOrO rrpocI>IIJIJI 86,8 (4) 85,1 (7) 84,5(4)
75(1). YroJI HOCOBhIX IwcTell 37,5(4) 38,4(5) 32,5(4)
77. Ha30MaJIHpHbIll yrOJI 140,3(9) 140,2(9) 135,2(4)
Lzm' 3IIrOMaKCIIJIJIHpHbIll yrOJI 127,2 (6) 125,7 (6) 128,7 (4)
BaH ,L(ORYMeHTan;IIH II, RpoMe Toro, MHOrOqIICJIeHHbIe C.D;eJIaHHbIe B nOJIe <pOTO-
rpa<pIIII ITOrpe6eHIIM.
llplI BblqIICJIeHIIII <pIIrypIIpYIOID;IIX B Ta6JIIIl(e Cpe.D;HIIx no MOrlIJIbHIIRY
A<paHacbeBa ropa 6bIJIII IICnOJIb30BaHbI 1I3MepeHIIH e.D;IIHIIqHbIX paHee ony6-
JIIIROBaHHblX qepenOB 113 paCRonOR C. A. TenJIoyxoBa 1920-1921 rr., npOlI3-
Bep:eHIlbIX Ha TOM me l'.IOrJIJIbHJIRe, HO 0603HaqeHHbIX 11M RaR paCROnR:II
B ERTeHHX. HaROHen;, MOrIIJIbHIIR YCTb-KYIOM paCRanbIBaJICH E. M. Eepc B
1964-1969 rr., II BeCb OCTeOJIOrII'IeCKHll MaTepIIaJI xpaHIITCH B MIlcTIITYTe
IICTOpJIJI, <pIIJIOJIOrJIII II <pIIJIOCO<pJIH CII6IIpcRoro OTp,eJIeHIIH AH CCCP, r.D;e
6bI., HCCJIe,iJ,OBaH B 1976 r.
KaRoBbI Mop<pOJIOrIIqeCRIIe oco6eHHocTII BHOBb ny6JIIIRyeMblx cepIIii?
qepena II3 Y CTb- KYIOMa OTJIIIqaIOTCH HeRoTopbIM nOBbIllenIIeM qepenHOro
YRa3aTeJIH IT OqeIIb BbICOROII 'IepenHOll Rop06ROii:. B npe,L(bI,L(YID;IIX pa60Tax
MHe npIIIIIJIOCb OTMeqaTb HeRoTopoe CXO,L(CTBO aJITallCKHX a<paHacbeBn;eB C
aHgpoHonn;aMII MIIHYCIIHCROll ROTJIOBIIHbI, ROTopoe HapH,L(Y C ,L(PyrIIMH npII-
3IIRRal'.fII Bblpa3IIJIOCb II B YBeJIHqeHIIII BbICOTbI qepenHOll Rop06RII no cpaB-
HeHHIO C MHHYCJIHCRIIMII a<paHaCbeBn;aMII. qepena 113 Y CTh- KYIOMa nO,L(TBepm-
.D;aIOT, '1'1'0, nO-BII,iJ,IIMOMY, JIbI IIMeeM B ,L(aHHOM CJIyqae ,L(eJIO C peaJIbHbIM
HBJIeUIIeM: BbICOTa qepena Y a<paHaCbeBCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH AJITaH 6bIJIa .D;eMcT-
BIITeJIbHO 3aMeTHO 60JIblle, qeM B MIIHYCIIHCROll ROTJIOBIIHe. TaKJIM 06pa30M,
nplI Bcell O,L(HOpO,L(HOCTII a<paHaCbeBCRoro HaCeJIeHJIH no Bcell TeppIITopIIII ero
pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH, nplI RYJIbTypHOll 6JIII30CTII aJITallCRIIX II MIIHYCIIHCRIIX
naMHTHIIROB Bce me cyID;ecTBOBaJI RaROll-TO reHeTIlqeCRlIll pa3pbIB Mem.n;y
)J;BYMH TeppIITOpJIaJIbHbIMII rpynnaMII a<paHaCbeBn;eB, ROTOpbIll II npIIBeJI
R 06pa30BaHIIIO pa3JIIIqlIH B 9TOM npII3HaRe.
B n;eJIOM me RpanIIOJIOrIIqeCRlIll TJIn scex Tpex cepIIll YRJIap:bIBaeTCH nOJI-
HOCTblO B paMRII HallIIX yme CJIOIHIIBlllIXCH npe,iJ,CTaBJIeHlIll 0 BapIIan;IIHX
352
xapaRTepHoro .D;JIH a<paHaCbeBn;eB ROMnJIeRCa npII3HaROB. 8TO MaCCIIBH:bIe
)J;JIIInHOrOJIOBbIe 'Ie pen a C yMepeHHO IIIlIpOKIIM II HII3RIIM JIRl(eBbIM CReJIeTOM,
C HII3RIIl'.HI op6IITaMII H ,L(OBOJIbHO Y3KHM rpyilleBII,L(HbIM OTBepCTIleM. PeJIbe<p
B 06JIaCTH rJIa6eJIJIbI II Ha 3aTbIJIOqHOll ROCTII pa3BIIT CIIJIbHO HJI:II OqeHb
CIIJIbHO, npO<pIIJIb JIHn;eBOro CReJIeTa opTOrHaTH:bln, HOCOBbIe ROCT:II B:bICTY-
naIOT OqeHb CHJILHO, JIIIueBOll CReJIeT B rop1I30HTaJIbHOll nJIOCROCTH IIMeeT
OCTpbIll npO<pIIJIb, oCD6eHHO B CBoell HII1Imell qaCTII. llepe,L( HaMH, CJIe.D;OBa-
TeJIbHO, THnIIqHble eBpOneOII.D;Hble 'Iepena, OTJIIIqalOID;HeCH pH.D;OM npOTO-
MOP<PHbIX oc06eHHOCTell, TIInWIHbIX p:JIH .D;peBHIIX cepHM.
KaR me MomeM MbI OTBeTHTb ceMqac Ha Bonpoc 0 IIpOIICXOffi,i],eHIIII 9Toro
RpaHHOJIOrIIqeCROrO ROMnJIeRCa :II a<paHaCbeBCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH - HOCIITeJIeM
9Toro ROMnJIeRca? B .D;onOJIHeHIIe R TOMY, '1'1'0 6bIJIO CRa3aHO 0 CTpoeHHII
qepena a aHaCbeBn;eB, MomHO OTMeTIITb 60JIbTIIIIe pa3MepbI ROCTell ROHe'I-
HOeTell II IICRJIIOqIITeJIbHO MOID;Hoe CTpoeHHe CReJIeTa B n;eJIOl'.I. A<paHaCbeBn;bI,
RaR H JIIO,L(lI 9TOll 9nOXlI, npomIIBaBIIIIIe B CTenHbIX paMoHax eBponeMcRoll
qaCTH CCCP, RaR 1I nOqTII Bce BepXHenaJIeOJIIITHqeCROe HaCeJIeHIIe EBponbI,
:IIMeJIH BbICOKIIll pOCT II CHJIbHOe TeJIOCJIOme:HIIe. KpaHIIOJIOrHqeCRII OHII TaR-
me 6bIJIII CXO,L(HbI, '1'1'0 II .D;aJIo B031'.IOmHOCTb r. <1>. .D:e6en;y BbI.D;BIIHYTb II
aprYMeHTlIpoBaTb IIL(eIO 0 CYID;eCTBoBaHIIII (mpOMaHboHCRoro B llIIpOROM
CMbICJIe» THna, ROTOpbIll B COOTBeTCTBIIII C ero rIInoTe30I1 OXBaTbIBaJI Bce
.D;peBHIIe nonYJIHn;IIII eBponeolIp,oB 1I 6bIJI IICXO,L(HbIM ,L(JIH ,o:pyrlIx TIInOB B CO-
CTaBe eBpOneOII,i],HOM paCbI 8 . .H npH xapaRTepIICTIIRe .D;peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH
MIIHYCIIHCRIIX CTeneII Ha3bIBaJI 9TOT TIIn naJIeOeBpOnellCRIIM, HO, eCJIII OCTa-
BIITb B CTopOHe 9'1'0 TepMIIHOJIOrII'IeCROe OTJIHqlIe, no CYID;eCTBY nOJIHOCTblO
COJIII,L(apII3IIpOBaJICH C rIlnOTe30ll r. <1>. e6en;a, ROTopaH nOJIY'IIIJIa illIIpORoe
pacnpOCTpaHeHHe B JIIITepaType 9.
KaR B CBeTe 9TOll rIInOTe3bI pHCOBaJIOCb npOIIcxomp,eHHe a<paHaCbeBCRoro
HaCeJIeH:IIH? COBepIIIeHHO OqeBII.D;HO, '1'1'0 OHO MOrJIO 6bITb TOJIbRO pe3YJIbTaTOM
nepeCeJIeHIIH 60JIbIIIIIX Macc JIIO.D;ell C 3ana,L(a, C TeppHTopillI OCHOBHoro apea-
JIa paCCeJIeHIIH npe,L(CTaBIITeJIell eBponeOII,L(HOll paCbI. OCTaBaJICH OTRp:bIT:bIM BO-
npoc OTHOCIITeJIbHO BpeMeHII 9Toro nepeCeJIeHIIH. HaXO,L(Ra a<pOHTOBCRoro
<ppanIeHTa npII Bcell He3HaqIITeJIbHOCTH HOBOM IIH<popMan;HIl, ROTOPYIO II3
Hero l'.IOmHO 6bIJIO 1I3BJIeqb, onpe.D;eJIeHHO nORa3aJIa, qTO Ha EHlIcee, B pano-
He HbIHeIIllIero RpaCHOHpCRa, B 9noxy BepXHero naJIeOJIHTa mHJIII MOHro-
JIOII,L(bI 10 . ]113 9Toro l'.IOmHO 6bIJIO C.D;eJIaTb BbIBO.D;, qTO eBpOneO:IIp;:bI IIOHB:IIJIIIC:b
yme Tor,L(a, ROr,L(a B npIIeHIIcellCRIIx CTenHX mIIJIO HaCeJIeHIIe l'.IOHrOJIOH,o:Horo
06JIIIRa, II '1'1'0 eBpOneOII,L(bI BbITeCHIIJIII ero B JIeCOCTenHble pallOHbI.
lIe6oJIbilloll naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIll MaTeplIaJI II3 norpe6eHIIM JIeCOCTenHO-
ro HeOJIIITa, pacRonaIlHblx BORpyr KpacHoHpcRa 1I 60JIee HJIII MeHee C:IIHXPOH-
HbIX. OqeBH,L(HO, a<paHaCbeBcRIIM l'.IOrIlJIbHIIRaM, 06HapymIIBaeT CMellaHHbIe
qepTbI: O,i],HII qepena IIMeIOT eBpOneOII.D;HbIe oc06eHHoCTII, ,L(pyrIIe OTJIIIqalOTCH
MOHrOJIOH.D;HbIM ROl'.IIIJIeRCOM nplI3HaRoB. IIo.D;06Hoe CMellaHHoe HaCeJIeHlIe
MOrJIO C<pOpMIIpoBaTbCH B npon;ecce npoHHRHoBeHIIH eBpOneOII.D;OB H3 cTeneM
IIO TeqeHIIIO EHlIceH B JIecHYIO 30HY :II 6paqHbIX ROHTaRTOB C MOHrOJIOII.D;H:bIM
HaCeJIeHIIeM Taii:rH.
O.D;HaRO B HacToHID;ee BpeMH nOHBIIJIIICb HOBbIe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCR:IIe
MaTeplIaJIbI, ROTopble, XOTH H He 3aqepKHBaIOT nOJIHOCTbIO B03MomHOCTb
TaROll nOCTaHOBRII Bonpoca, npHHn;lInIIaJIbHO BamHbI .D;JIH 060CHOBaHIIH .D;PY-
rOll rIInOTe3bI. Peqh II,o:eT 0 HaXO,L(RaX a<paHaCbeBCRIIX RypraHoB B MOHrOJIIIII.
IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIe Haxo.D;RlI H3 HIIX e,i],IIHIIqHbI, HO OHII 06Hapy-
mIIBaIOT TOT me Mop<p0JIOrIIqeCRIIll ROMnJIeRC, '1'1'0 II .D;pyrIIe a<paHaCLeBCRIIe
qepena 11.
TaRilM 06pa30M, rpaHIIuell pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH eBpOneOII.D;OB B 3noxy
I,
ii
III
I'
'II
12 B. II. AJlelWeeB
353
9HeOJIIITa 6bIJIII n;eHTpaJIbHble pallOHbI MOHrOJIIIII, '1'1'0 B rIInOTeTHqeCROll
<pOpMe 6bIJIO BbICRa3aHO paHbille 12, HO qTO :IIMeHHO Tenepb HaIIIJIO ,L(ORYMeH-
TaJIbHOe ITOL\TBepm,L(eHIIe. A CTOJIb IIIIlpORoe pacnpocTpaHeHIIe eBponeOII.D;OB
Ha BOCTOR B clIIOXY 9HeOJIIITa ,L(aeT B031'.I01RHOCTb npeL(nOJIaraTb, '1'1'0 II B 60JIee
paHHIIe 9nOXII HaCeJIeHIIe ,L(allm BOCTOqHbIX palloHoB cTenell EBpa3IIH OTHOCII-
JIOCb R eBpOneOII.D;HOR pace, II 06paaOBbIBaJIO Cal'.IOCTOHTeJIbHbIll oqar paco06-
pa30BaHHH B npeL(eJIax eBpOneOII)];HOrO apeaJIa. HaCeJIeHIIe eBponeOII,L(HOrO
06JIIlRa B aTOM CJIyqae M01RHO CqIITaTb L(JIH CTenell no EH:IICeIO :II 3ana.D;HbIX
pallOHOB MOHrOJIIIII H3HaqaJIbHbIM.
B npe,L(eJIax orpOMHoro eBpa3IIllCRoro apeaJIa eBponeOII,!!,OB, BOCCTaHaBJIH-
BaeMoro naJIeOanTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRII, CyID;eCTBYIOT RaRIIe-TO JIORaJIbHbIe BapHaH-
TbI, 06'beL(IIHHIOIl(IIe HaCeJIeHIIe OT,!!,eJIbHbIX apXeOJIOrIIqeCRIlX RYJIbTYP IIJI:II
RYJIbTypHbIX 06ID;HOCTell. C aToM TOqRII 3peHHH rIInOTe3a eL(IIHOrO <<RPO-
MaHbOHCRoro>} TIIna, 0 ROTOpOll ynoMIlHaJIOCb BbIlle, He COOTBeTcTByeT Tene-
peillHeMY ypOBHIO HaIIllIX 3HaHIIM no naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIII EBpa3IIH 13.
A O,L(IIH 113 9THX JIORaJIbHbIX BapIIaHTOB, paCCMOTpeHHbIll BblIIIe H xapaRTep-
HbIll ,L(JIH atPaHaCbeBCRoro HaCeJIeHHH AJITaH II XaRaCHII, B nO'ITII TOiR)leCT-
BeHHOll <popMe TIInHqeH H ,L(JIH HaCeJIeHIIH CIIHXpOHHOll a<paHaCbeBCROll Hl'.IHOH
RYJIbTYPbI, pacnpocTpaHeHHoM 0'1' ¥RpaUHbI ,L(O HIl1RHero 1l0BoJImbH.
B apXeOJIOrII'IeCKOM OTHOilleHIIH naMHTHHRII Hl'.IHOll H a<paHaCbeBCROll RYJIb-
ryp TaRme CXO.D;HbI, IIMeH pH,!!, nOqTII T01R,L(eCTBeHHbIX qepT. TaRIIM 06pa30M,
l'.I01RHO nOJIaraTb, '1'1'0 B CBOHX reHeTIIqeCRIIX IICTORax HaCeJIeHIIe HMHOM II
a<paHaCI,eBCROII RYJIbTYP BOCXO,L(IIT R 06ID;eMY IWpHIO.
He COCTaBJIHeT TpY,L(a nO.D;BeCTII IITor BceMY CRa3aHIIOMY. OH CBO.D;:IITCH
R ROHCTaTan;IIII Tpex nOJIOmeHIIll.
1. B BOCTOqHbIX palloHax cTenHoM nOJIOCbJ EBpa3IIII Mor cYITIeCTBoBaTJ,.
eID;e B ,!!,oa<paHacbeBcRoe BpeMH caMoCTOHTeJIbHbIll oqar paco06pa30BaHIIH, BXO-
.D;HBllIIll B apeaJI <pOpMIIpoBaHIIH eBpOneOII.D;HOll paCbI.
2. XapaRTepHbIll .D;JIH a<paHacbeBcRoro HaCeJIeHIIH ROMnJIeRC npII3HaRoB
IIOBTopHeTCH Y HaCeJIeHIIH HMHOll RYJIbTypbI.
3. BHOJIOrHqeCRIIe IICTOR:II npOHCX01R.D;eHIIH HaCeJIeHIIH aTIIX .D;BYX RYJIb-
TYP MorYT BOCXO.D;IlTb R O.D;HOMy reHeTIIqeCROMY npoToTIIny.
1 If.e6elf r. ([J. PaCOBLIe THllLl HaCeJIemm MIDIYcHHcKoro RpaH B 3ll0XY pOl\OBoro CTpOH /I
AHTpOllOJI. iRypH. 1932. n 2; Oli J/Ce. TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrHH CCCP. II Tp. lIH-Ta 3THO-
rpaqHm: AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 4. M.; JI., 1948. A. eKceee B. II. TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIH AJI-
Tae-CaHHcKoro naropLH 3IIOXH KaMHH II OpOH3Ll Ii TaM lIi:e. T. 71. M., 1961.
2 PbzKymulia r. B. HaCeJIeHHe Cpel\HerO EHIIceH B KapaCYKCKYIO 3IIOXY: (RpaHIIOJI.
O'IepK) II TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIH CII6IIpII. M., 1980.
3 JIunc1'>Uu A. H. AcPaHacLeBcKIIe llOl'peOeHIIH B XaKacIIII II KpaT. cooo . J1H-Ta IICTOpHlJ
MaTepIIaJILHOH RYJILTypLI. 1952. BLIII. 17.
· A. eKceee B. II. 0 6paXHI{paHHOM KOMIIOHeHTe B COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIIH acpaHacLeBcKoH
KYJILTypLl II COB. 3THorpacPIIH. 1961. n 1.
5 MaKCUMeliKoe r. A. BIIYCKHLIe MOrIIJILl OKYHeBCKoro 3TaIIa B acpaHaCLeBCKIIX RYP-
raHax II COB. apXeOJIOrIIH. 1965. oN!! 4; 11ealioea JI. A. 0 IIPOIICXOlIi:l\eHIIII opaxIIRpaH-
HOro KOMIIOHeHTa B COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIIH acPaHacLeBcKoi'r RYJILTYPLl II COB. 3THorp a cP IIH .
1966. n 3.
6 If.e6elf r. ([J. TIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIH OKYHeBCKoii KYJILTypLI II IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIH CII-
6IIpII.
7 A. eKceee B. II. AHTpOIIOJIOrIIH aHl\PoHoBCKOH KYJILTypLlIICoB. apXeOJIorIIH. 1967.
.N 1.
B B l\OIIOJIHeHIIe K ero pa6oTaM, YKa3aHHLlM BLIIIIe, CM.: If.e6elf r. tP. EPIOHH-TIIIIel\MOCT,
Kpo-MaHLOH II COBpeMeHHLIe paCLl EBpOIILI II AHTpOIIOJI. lIi:ypH. 1936. n 3.
9 CM., HaIIp.: rOXMaH 11. 11. HaCeJIeHIIe YKpaIIHLl B 3IIOXY lVIe30JIIITa II HeOJIIITa: (AHTpo-
IIOJI. O'IepK). M., 1966; KOliiJYKTopoea T. C. AHTpOIIOJIOrIIH HaCeJIeHIIH ¥KpaIIHLI Me-
30JIIITa, HeOJIIITa II 3IIOXII 6pOH3Ll. M., 1973.
354
.10 l1. e 6elj r. rJJ. <1>parMeHT JI06HOiI KOCTII 'leJIOBeKa 113 KYJIbTypHOrO CJIOH CTOHHKIiI
AcpOHTOBa ropa II IIO)]; KpaCHOHpCKOM II EIDJI. KOJl,!lIc. IIO 113Y'l. 'leTBepTll'l. lIepllo;o:a.
1946. J\2 8.
'11 MaJKolioea H. H. AHTpOIIOJIOI'H'leCmIiI TIITI ;o:peBHerO HaCeJIemIH 3alIa;O:HOII MOHrO-
JIlIll IIO ;o:aHHbIM lIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrllH 11I1ccJIe;o:oBamm IIO IIiWeOaHTpOIIOJIOrllll II Kpa-
HIIOJIOrI!lI CCCP. C6. MY3eH aHTpOIIOJIOrIm II 8THOrpacpIIll AH CCCP. T. 36. 1980.
"12 A..z.el>ceee B. II. COBpeMeHHOe COCTOHHlle KpaHIIOJIOrll'leCKlIX llCCJIe;O:OBaHlliI B paco-
Be;:\eHllll II BOlIp. aHTpOIIOJIOrHll. 1968. BMII. 30. Oli :JICe. HOBbie )];aHHbIe 0 eBpOlIeOll;O:-
HOll pace B IJ;eHTpaJIbHOiI A31111 II EpOH30BMll II lIi:eJIe3HMll BeK Cn6IIPll. HOBOC1l611pCK,
1974.
.13 TIoAPo6Hee CM.: Oli :JICe. feorpacpllH 'leJIOBe'leCKIIX pac. M., 1974.
K IIPOIICXOJRAEHIIIO
TAlliTbIKCKOrO HACEJIEHIIH
IOJRHOfI CIiBIIPI1
TIAJlEOAHTPOnOJlOfllH TAlliTbIKCKOH KYJlbTYPbI
'IIpoII3Be,o:H peBII3IIIO MIlHYCIIHCRIIX p;peBHOCTell:, C. A. TenJIoyxoB BnepBbIe
BbI.D;eJIIIJI TaillTbIRCRyIO RYJIbTYPY II ,L(aTIIpOBaJI ee py6emoM HOBOll 9pbI. KaR
OqeHb OCTOpml\HbIll :II B,o:yMqIIBbIll IICCJIe.D;OBaTeJIb, OTqeTJIIIBO nOHIIl'.IaBillHII
UenOJIHoTY Haxo,o:IIBllIIXCH B ero pacnopHmeHII:II MaTeplIaJIOB, OH MaJIO OCTa-
HaBJIHBaJICH Ha npOIICXml\L\eHIIH BbI.D;eJIeHHbIX 11M RYJIbTYP, HO B OTHOIIIeHII:II
TaillTbIRCROM c,o:eJIaJI 3aMeqaHIIe 06 yCIIJIeHIIII B HeM n;eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCKIIX
BJIIIHHIIll no cpaBHeHIIIO C MnHYCIIHCROM RypraHHoM RYJIbTypOM I . B .D;aJIbHell-
llIeM 9'1'0 3aMeqaHIIe C. A. TenJIoyxoBa nOCJIylliHJIO OCHOBOll pa3pa60TRII npo-
6JIeMbI npoHCxom.D;eHHH TalliTbIRCROM RYJIbTypbI C npIIBJIeqeHHeM HOBbIX no-
CTOHHHO yBeJIHqHBaIOID;IIxcH ,L(aHHblx - apXeOJIOrIIqeCKHX II naJIeOaHTpono-
JIOrIIqeCRHX.
ApXeOJIOrIIqeCROe IICCJIe.D;oBaHHe TaIIITbIRCRHX naMHTHIIROB B MIIHYCIIH-
.CROII ROTJIOBIIHe aRTIIBHO BeJJ IlOCJIe C. A. TenJIoyxoBa C. B. KIICeJIeB. Ero
cBo,o:HaH pa60Ta oIIpe,o:eJIIlJIa MeCTO TaillTbIRCROll RYJIbTYPbI B IICTOpII:II
CTenHoro MIIpa EBpa3IIII (cpe.D;OTOTJHe 3ana,L(Hblx II BOCTOqHbIX BJI:IIHHIIM, HO
C no,o:aBJIHIOID;IIM npeOOJIa,L(aHIIeM nOCJIe.D;HIIx). CaMa TaillTbIRCRaH RyJIbTypa
6bwa npe,o:cTaBJIeHa C. B. KIICeJIeBbIM B aToll: HCTopII'IeCROM RapnIHe RaR
e,o:HHoe n;eJIoe, a pa3JIIlqIlH B norpe6aJIbHOll 06PH.D;HOCTII l'.IOrnJIbHbIX coopYllie-
HIIll pa3HbIX THnOB 06'bHCHHJIIICb pa3HbIM COn;IIaJIbHbIM nOJIOllieHIIeM 3axopo-
HeHHbIX B HHX JIIO,L(ell 2 .
CJIe,o:YIOID;IIll STan B II3yqeHIIII TaillTbIRCROM RYJIbTypbI CBH3aH C ,L(eHTeJIb-
HOCTblO JI. P. KbI3JIacoBa. OH npmI3BeJI peBH3IIIO Bcex H3BeCTHbIX R cepe-
,L(IIHe 50-x rO,L(OB naMHTHIIROB 3, paCROnaJI pH,L( HOBbIX II BbI,o:eJIIIJI .D;Ba 9JIe-
MeHTa B COCTaBe TaillTbIECROM RYJIbTypbI: npIIllJIbIll 113 :QeHTpaJIbHOM A3IIII,
CBH3aHHbIll C norpe6eHIIHMII B CRJIenaX C TpynocollillieHIIHMn, n MeCTHbIM,
BOCXOJ,HIl(IIII R TarapcRoMy HaCeJIeHIIIO". MeCTHbIM ROl'.IIIOHeHT, npe.D;noJIO-
lliIITeJIbHO yropcRIIII, 6bIJI, no JI. P. KbI3JIacoBY, BbITeCHeH II3 MIIHYCIIHCROii
ROTJIOBIIHbI II JIer B OCHOBY 9THoreHe3a yropCRHX HapO,L(OB 3ana,o:HOll CH6HP:II.
.8Ta KOHn;enn;HH reHeaIIca TaillTbIRCROll RyJIbTypbI BbI3BaJIa BBH,L(Y ee CBH3n C
BalliHeMllIIMII np06JIeMaMII IICTOpIIqeCROll 9THOJIOrIIII 3ana,o:HoM CII6IIp:II
OlliIIBJIeHHYIO ,L(IICRYCCIIIO, II MHorIIe nOJIOmeHIIH JI. P. KbI3JIacoBa BCTpeTIIJI:II
B03paiKeHIIH 5. KCTaTII CRa3aTb, nOMIIMO JI. P. KbI3JIaCOBa, TaillTbIRCRIIe na-
MHTHIIRII ROnaJIII II .D;pyrIIe IICCJIe.D;OBaTeJI:II, p;aBllIIe CE=- aHaJIII3 MHorIIX
355
12*
ih
CTOpOH mII3HII II 6bITa TaillTbIRCROrO HaCeJIeHIIH, aHaJIII3 TaillTbIRCROrO lIe..
RYCCTBa II T. ,[1,.6
AHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROe H3yqeHIIe TaIIITbIKCRoro naCeJIeHIIH llJIO napaJIJIeJIb-
HO C paCllIIpeHlIeM <ppOHTa apXeOJIOrIIqeCRIIX pa6OT. ITepBaH ny6JIIIRan;IIH,
nOCBHID;eHHaH TaIIITbIRCROM aHTpOnOJIOrIIII, 6bIJIa OCHOBaHa, O,[l,HaRO, He Ha
H3yqeHIIII cepIIII qepenOB IIJIH CReJIeTOB II3 TamTbIRCRIIX norpe6eHlIll, a Ha
IICCJIe.D;OBaHIIII aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCROrO THna TaillTbIRCRIIX MaCOR. 1l0JIaraHCb Ha
TO, '1'1'0 MaCRII eCJIH He IIOJIHOCTbIO nopTpeTbI, TO B Macce Bce me OTpaiRaIOT
<pII3JPJeCRIIe qepTbI TaillTbIRCROrO HaCeJIeHHH, r. <P. .D:e6en; nO,[l,OIIIeJI R IIX
1I3Y'IeHIIIO TaR me, RaR nO,L(XO.D;IIT aHTpOnOJIOr R On;eHRe OTJIIIqIITeJIbHbIX OCO-
6eHHocTeii: 'IeJIOBeqeCROrO JIIIn;a 7. ITo ynJIOID;eHHOCTIl JIIIn;eBOro CReJIeTa II
BbICOTe nepeHOCbH TaillTbIRn;bI ORa3aJIIICb CXO,L(HbIMII C xaHTbI II MaHCII. 8'1'0'1'
BbIBO,L( 6bIJI nOBTopeH II B II3BecTHoM CBO,L(HOII pa60Te no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIlI
CCCP 8. TaM OTMeqaJIOCb naH60JIbIIJee CXO,[l,CTBO TaIIITbJT,:CROll cepIlII C ce-
pIIHMII qepenOB xaHTbI II MaHCII - 3aRJIIOqeHIIe, ROTopoe ObIJIO IICnOJIb30BaHO
JI. P. KbI3JIaCOBbIM iJ,JIH nO,L(TBepiR,L(eHIlH cBoell TeopIlII yropcRoro 9THorene-
3a B He,L(pax TaillTbIRCROrO HaCeJIeHIIH MHHYCIIHCROll ROTJIOBHHbI. C ,L(pyroll
CTOpOHbI, r. <P. Ae6en; n;IITlIpOBaJI r. IT. COCHoBCKoro, OTMeqaBillerO IICTO-
pIIqeCRII 3aCnII,L(eTeJIbCTBOBaHHbIM <paRT npOHIIRHOBeHIIH n;eHTpaJIbHOa3HaT-
CRIIX HapOiJ,OB B MIIHYCHHCRYIO ROTJIOBIIHY.
ITepBaH CTaTbH aBTopa, IIOCBHID;eHHaH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrHII TaIIITbIRCROH
RYJIbTYPbI II BRJIIOqaBillaH onIIcaHIIe HeCROJIbRHX HOBbIX TaillTbIRCRIIX qepe-
nOB, COiJ,epmaJIa CRpbIToe npOTHBOpeqIIe. Cpe,L(:II BHOBb OIIJICaHHbIX qepenOB
6bIJIII ,L(na, Ha ROTOpbIX oco6eHHOCTII l(eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCRoro l'.IOHrOJIOIIiUTOro
TIIna 6bIJIII BblpameHbI a6COJIIOTHO OTqeTJIIIBO 9. IToCJIe Toro RaR OHII 6bIJIII
HaM,L(eHbI B TaillTbIRCRHX norpe6eHHHX, BnepBble CTaJIO B03MomHbIM rOBopIITb
o BRJIIO'IeHHH n;eII'fpaJIbHOa3IIaTCRoro 9THIIqeCROrO 9JIeMeHTa B COCTaB Tall-
TbIRCROrO HaCeJIeHIIH C nOJIHOII onpeiJ,eJIeHHOCTbIO. H TaR II TIIICaJI, HO B ROH-
n;e HeOJl.II,L(anHO C,L(eJIaJI TO JIII no HeonbITHOCTII II He,L(OCTaTRY YBepeHHOCTII
B CBOIIX CIlJIaX, TO JIH B HeOJIarOiJ,apHOll nonbITRe npIIMIIpIITb HenpIIMHpHl'.IOe
oroBopRy, RCTaTII CRa3aTb, a6COJIIOTHO anpHopHYIO: «MOHrOJIOIIp:Hble TIInbI
6bIJI:II llHpORO pacnpOCTpaHeHbI B 06JIaCTHX, oRpymaIOID;IIX MIIHYCHHCRYIO
ROTJIOBIIHY He TOJIbRO C IOra, HO H C CeBepa)}. IToTmI. yme nOCJIe Toro
IWR 6bIJIII IIpopa60TaHbI Bce IIMeIOID;IIOCH MaTepHaJIbI no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlI:II
TaIIITbIRCROll RYJIbTYPbI, 9Ta orOBopRa BblpOCJIa B 3aROHqeHHYIO rlInOTe3Y
JIeCHOrO, TaemHoro npOIICxom,L(eHIIH TamTbIRCROrO HaCeJIeHHH, npOHIIRHOBe-
HIm ero B M:IIHYCIIHCRYIO ROTJIOBIIHY B 60JIbillell Mepe C ceBepa, qeM C IOra 10.
BbI,L(BHHYTa 6bIJIa 9Ta rIInOTe3a RaR pa3 B rO,L(bI nOBaJIbHOrO YBJIe'IeHIIH
HII3ROJIIIn;bIM MOHrOJIOII.D;HbIM TIInOM, ROTOpbIll ToriJ,a BbIHBIIJICH BceMII HaJIlIq-
HbIMH ,L(aHHbIM:II B COCTaBe ,L(peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH 3ana.D;HoM II Cpe,L(Hell CII6II-
pII. HII3ROJIIIn;eCTb npII CHJIbHOll BblpameHHocTII l'.IOHrOJIOII.D;HbIX oc06eHHocTeM
CBollcTBeHHa U HeRoTopbIM cOBpeMeHHbIM HapOiJ,aM, n09TOl'.IY II naJIeOaHTpo-
nOJIOrIIqeCRIIe Ha6JIIO.D;eHIIH 0 llUpOROM pacnpocTpaHeHHII HII3ROJIIIn;erO TIIna
npII06peJIII 60JIbrnylO ,L(OCTOBepHocTb. TaillTbIRCROe HaCeJIeHIle OTJIIIqa.lIOCb
rpan;IIJIbHbIM He60JIbllIIM JIUn;OM, '1'1'0 npH YClIJIeHUU MOHrOJIOII,L(HbIX qepT 1I
HaBO,L(IIJIO Ha MbICJIb 06 YBeJIIIqeHIIH MOHrOJIOII,L(HOM nplIMeCII 3a CqeT npUJIII-
Ba RpOBII HII3ROJIlIn;bIX MOHrOJIOITi1,OB. A TaR RaR HII3ROJIUn;bIll l'.IOHrOJIOH,L(-
HbIM TIIn 6bIJI CBOllCTBeH B OCHOBHOM JIeCHbIM, TaemHbIM ITJIeMeHaM, TO II
npOIICXOiR.D;eHIIe TaillTbIRCROH RYJIbTypbI YBH3bIBaJIOCb e ceBepOM, C npOIIIIR-
HOBeHIIeM HOBbIX rpynn HaCeJIeHIIH B MUHYCUHCRYIO ROTJIOBIIHY U3 ceBepHbIX
pallOHOB.
IToCJIe nOHBJIeHHH MHorHX pa60T 6bIJIa orry6JIIIROBaHa CTaTbH H. r. 3aJI-
RBH1(, OcHOBaHHaH Ha OnIICaH:II:II He60JIbillOrO RpaH:IIOJIOr:II'IeCROrO MaTepIIaJIa
356
1I3 II3BeCTHOrO CaJI6bIRCROrO RypraHa, HO B Hell BonpOCbI reHe3IIca TblIIiTbIR-
CRoro HaCeJICHIlH He 6bJ.TIII 3aTponYTbI, .D;a II MaTepHaJI, naXO,L(HBllIIllCH B pac-
IIopmEeHIIIl aBTopa, 6bIJI RpallHe l'.IaJI H <pparMeHTapen 11.
(DH3IIqeCRIIe npII3HaRII TaillTbIRCROrO IlaCeJIeHIIH BbIHBJIHIOTCH oc06eHHO
qeTRO npH conOCTaBJIeHHII C npe,L(lleCTBOBaBIIIHMII eMy Tarapn;al\III. Tall--
TbIRl(bI OTJIIPIaJIlICb 0'1' Tarapn;eB 60JIec rpal(lIJIbHblM qepenOM, 3aMeTHO 60JIee
HII3RIIM 1I RpyrJIbIM. PeJIbe<p qepena pa3BHT y TaillTbIRn;eB MeHbIIIe, qe 1 y
Tarapn;eB. JIIIn;o 6bIJIO y HHX O,L(IIHaROBOll C Tarapn;aMH BbICOTbI, HO 60JIee
Y3Roe. O,iJ,HaRO C 9TIIMH npn3HaRa 1II COe,iJ,IIHHJIaCb 66JIbillaH yrrJIOID;CHHOCTb
JIHn;a H ynJIOID;eHHOCTb Hoca - <paRT B BbICillell CTeneHII CTpaHHbIII, TaR Ran
9'1'11 npH3HaRII xapaRTepHbI ,L(JIH MOHrOJIOlJL(OB, a l'.IOHrOJIOII,L(HOII pace B n;eJIOM
CBOllCTBeH 60JIbllOii: pa3Mep JIIIn;a. OTRpbITIle HII3ROJIIIn;bIX 1.IOHroJIOII.D;OB pa3"-
penrrIJIO 9TII Hep:OYMCHIIH JIHIIIb qaCTHqHO, TaR RaR TaillTbIRCIWe Hace.rrCHIIC
OTJIHqaJIOCb 0'1' TarapCRoro He TOJIbRO MaJIoii: BbICOTOll, HO II l'.IaJIOll lllIpIInoii
JIIIn;a. IlOJIHOCTblO 9Ta cTpaIIHocTb 6bIJIa 06'bflCHCna JJHllib TOr,iJ,a, ROr,ll,a 6bIJIH
OTRpbITbI B COCTaBe D:peBHero HaCeJIOHIIfl IOmHoII II 3ana,L(HOll CII6IIplI aHT-
pOnOJIOrIIqeCRIle BapnaHTbI, 06'beL\HHIIBIIIne B CBOlIX ([HI3II'leCRIIx OCUOCHHO-
CTHX .D;OCTaTOqHO qeTRYIO BblpaffieIIHoCTb MOHrOJIOII,iJ,HbIX qepT C MaJIbIl'.lII pa3-
MepaMH JIIIn;eBOro CReJIeTa. f CT3TH clm3aTb, OTMe'IeIIa ObIJIa 'raRaH ROM6II-
Han;IIH aHTpOnOJIorII'IeCRIIX nplI3naROB y ClIIIxpOHHoro TaIIITbIRcROMY
HaCeJIeHIlfl JIeCHOrO AJITaH, 0 ROTOpOM MomHO CY,iJ,IITb no cepIIII CReJIeTOB,
,L(06bITbIX npH pacRonRax M. ll. rpH3HOBa B ypOqIIID;e BJIIImHIIe EJI6aHbI 12.
8Ta JIIIHIIH conOCTaBJIeHIIll II nOCJIymIIJIa OCHOBaHIIe I ,L(JIH C6JIIImeHIIH
TaillTbIRCIWII cepIIII C JIeCIIbIMII MOHrOJIOII,iJ,aMII II ,L(JIH rIInOTe3bI npOIICXOm,L(e-
HIIH TaillTbIRCRoro HaCCJIeHIIH II3 ,lI,BYX OCHOBHbIX ROMnOHCHTOB - TarapCRoro
II neCHoro MOHrOJIOII,iJ,HOrO no CBoeMY aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROMY TIIny.
II peOOJIa,iJ,aIOID;aH IIpIIMeCb JIeCHOrO ROMnOHeIITa HIlCROJIbRO He npe,L(onpe-
,lI,eJIHeT caMa no cc6e aJIbTepHaTIIBnoe peIIIeHHe Bonpoca 0 npOIICXOiR,lI,eHIIII
MOHrOJIOII,'J,IlOll npIlMCCIl Bo06ID;e. 06HapymeHHe B TaIIITbIRCRIIX l'.IOrIIJIaX 0'1'-
p;enbH:bIX qepenOB, Ha ROTOpbIX ROMnJIeRC n;eHTpaJIbHOa3HaTcRIIx qepT Bblpa-
meH qpe3BblqaIIHO OTqeTJlIIBO, l'.IOiReT CqIITaTbCH .D;ORa3aHHbIM <paRTOM. ITpaB-
,iJ,a, B TaillTbIRCROII ceplIlI TaRIIe qepena e,L(IIHlIqHbI, a CJIe,L(OBaTeJIbHO, II n;eH1-
paJIbHOa3lIaTCRaH npIIMeCb HeBeJIIlRa.
B03nlIRaeT Bonpoc 0 BpeMeHII, Ror,L(a JIeCHOll II n;eHTpaJlbHOa3IIaTCRIIM
ROMnOHeIITbI npHMenrrIBaJIIICb R RopeHHoMY TarapcRoMY HaCeJIeHHIO. IIpo-
HIIRHOBeHIIe n;eHTpaJIbIIOa31IaTcRoro ROl'.IIIOHeHTa l'.IOmHO ,lI,aTHpOBaTb VII-
VI BB. ,L(O H. 9., TaR RaR yme B COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIIR nepBOll CTa,L(IIII Tarap-
cRoM RYJIbTYPbI eCTb He60JIbillaH l'.IOHrOJIOII,L(HaH npIIMecb. Ho OHa RaR 6bI
paCnbIJIeHa no OT,iJ,eJIbHbIM nplI3HaRaM Ha eL\IIHHqHbIX qepenax, II n09TOMY
CY.D;:IITb 0 ee npOIICXOm.D;eHHII TPY.D;HO. To me caMoe l'.IOmHO CRa3aTb H npo
qepena BTOpOll CTa)J,IIIl. MOiRHO YTBepiR)J,aTb, qTO Cpe,L(Il HeCROJIbRIIX COT
qepenOB II3 norpe6enIIII TarapCROll RyJIbTYPbI HeT HII o,ll,Horo, l(eHTpaJIbHO-
a3HaTCRIIe qepTbI ROTvporo 6bIJIIl 6bI TaR me HeocnopIIMbI, RaR n;eHTpaJIbHO-
a3IIaTCRHe oc06eHHOCTII TaillTbIRCRIIX qepenOB, onIIcaHHbIX B l'.IOell pa60Te
1954 r. TaRIIM 06pa30M, npHTOl n;eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCRoro HaCeJICJIIlH npOL\OJI-
maJICfl nOCTOHHHO Ha npOTflmeHIIII ObITOBaHIIH TaillTbIRCROM RYJIbTypbI. ITplI-
6bIBllIIe JIIOD;II HaCTOJIbKO pe3RO OTJIIIqaJIHCb 0'1' MeCTHblX no CBOlIM <pII3Uqe-
CRIIM nplI3HaRaM, '1'1'0 npIl CMeilleHIIH C HHMII OHH, HeCOMHeHHO, TepHJIlI,
XOTH 6bI qaCTIIqHO, CBOIO aHTpOnOJIOrlIqecRyIO cnen;H<pIIRy yme B nepBOM no-
ROJIeHIIII IIOCJIe HaqaJIa CMeilleHIIH. MbI me cTajrRIIBaeMCH B TaniTbIRCROM
HaCeJIeHIIII C HeCOMHeHHbIMII n;eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCRIIM:II MOHrOJIOIlp:aMII 6e3
BCHROll eBponeOII,L(HOII npHMeCII, HeCOl'.IHeHHbIMH npIIlleJIbn;aMII 113 lJ,eHTpaJIb-
HOll A3:II:II, eID;e He IIcnbITaBIIIHMII BJIIIHHIIH CMeilleHIIH C MeCTHbIM eBpo-
J
357
neOII,L(HbIM HaCeJIeHIIel'.I. IITaR, HaqaJIO npOHIIRHOBeHIIH STIIX npHilleJIbn;eB B j
MIIHYCIIHCRHe CTenH nORa HeT aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX OCHOBaHIIll AaTHpOBaTb l
()OJIee paHHIIM BpeMeHeM, qeM III - II BB. ,L(O H. s., T. e. ;moxoM CJIOmeHI'lH
TaIllT:bIRCROll RY JIbTYPbI.
AJIH ,L(aTHpoBRIl nOHBJIeHIIH BToporo, TaemHoro, IIJI:II JIeCHOrO, ROMnOHeH-
Ta Ha AoaRaHe II EmIcee He06xo.D;HMO 60JIee A:II<p<pepeHn;HpoBaHHoe IICCJIe,L(O-
lIaHIIe aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO TIIna TarapCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH, 'leM TOJIbRO pac-
cMoTpeHIIe ero no CTa,L(IIHM pa3BHTHH TarapcRoll RYJIbTypbI. ¥M03pIITeJIbHO
rOBopH, l'.IOmHO C 60JIbIIIOM ,L(OJIell BepoHTHoCTII npe,L(nOJIaraTb, '1'1'0 OTMeqeH-
Hue pa3JIlIqIIH B <pH3U'IeCROM TIlne TarapCRoro II TaIIITbIRCROrO HaCeJIeHIIH
BMHBJIHIOTCH TOJIbRO np:II conOCTaBJIeHHH CYMMapHbIX xapaRTepIICTHR II '1'1'0
B COCTaBe Tarapn;eB 6bIJIII OT,L(eJIbHbIe rpynnbI, ROTOpbIe C6JIIIiRaJIIICb no CBO-
RM aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCRIIM oc06eHHOCTHM C TaillTbIRCRIIM HaCeJIeHHeM. ITp:II
limOrOqIICJIeHHOCTH TarapCROll RpaHHOJIorHqeCROM cepIIH qepena II3 OTAeJIb-
BbIX MOrIIJIbHIIROB, OTJIH'IaIOID;IIXCH OT OCTaJIbHbIX no TIIny, MOrJIII OCTaTbCH
Be3aMeqeHHbIMII, RorAa BblqIICJIHJIIICb 06ID;He cpeAHHe no cepIIII. HeROTopbIM
lIop:TBepm,a,eHIIeM SToro npe,a,nOJIOiReHIIH HBJIHeTCH HeOllUOpO,L(HOCTb Tarap-
CRoro HaCeJIeHIIH no <pOp1Ie rOJIOBbI. r. <1>. .D:e6en; npOII3BeJI nop:CqeT BeJIHqII-
HbI qepenHOro yRa3aTeJIH B cepIIHX qepenOB 113 OT,L(eJIbHbIX l'.IOrJIJIbHHKOB II
nOJIyqHJI 3aMeTHO pa3JIII'IalOID;IIeCH n;II<ppbI I3 . B cepIIHX 113 MOrIIJIbHHROB,
rpynnIIpYIOID;HXCH reorpa<pHqeCRII BORpyr CbI,L(bI, qepenHOll YRa3aTeJIb ORa-
3aJICH BbIIlle, qeM B OCTaJIbHbIX cepHHX. .D:pyrIIMII CJIOBaMH, TarapCRoe Hace-
JIeHHe, 6Y,L(Y'III B n;eJIO 1 ,L(JIHHHOrOJIOBbIM, Ha ceBepe OTJIIIqaJIOCb TeH,L(eHn;IIeM
K RpyrJIOrOJIOBOCTII, a 3HaqIIT, BHYTPII TarapCRoro HaCeJIeHHH CYID;eCTBOBaJI:II
KaKIIe-TO JIORaJIbHble BapIIaHTbI, MeCTHbIe ROM6IIHan;IIII npII3HaROB, xapaRTep-
lIIbIe ,L(JIH OT.D;eJIbHbIX rpynn.
B pa60Te H. r. 3aJIRIIHp:, Ha ROTOPYIO 6bIJIa c,a,eJIaHa CCbIJIRa, onIIcaHbI
JIIIIllb e.D;IIHHqHble qepena TarapCROII RYJIbTYPbI II3 CIIJIbHO orpa6JIeHHOrO
CaJI6bIRCROrO RypraHa, ROTOpbIe BRII,L(y IIX JaJIOqIICJIeHHOCTH HeJIb3H pac-
CMaTpHBaTb RaR OT,a,eJIbUYIO Cep:IIIO. lloSTOMY npII pa30HBRe TarapCROll cepHII
na rpynnbI H onIIpaIOCb Ha ,a,aUHble, ony6JIlIROBaHHbIe B 1961 r.
HeCROJIbRO CJIOB 0 npIIHn;Hnax rpynnIIpoBRII ,L(aHHbIX, T. e. 0 BbI60pe
KpIITepIIeB ,!IJIH BbI,L(eJIeHIIH rpynn B COCTaBe TarapcRoll RYJIbTypbI. HeT Hym-
AU ,a,oRa3bIBaTb, '1'1'0 rJIaBHbIM, oc06eHHo eCJIII MbI XOTIIM BbIHBHTb .D;HHaMHRY
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROrO TIIna TarapcRoro HaCeJIeHIIH BO BpeMeHII, HBJIHeTCH pa3-
tiIIBRa .D;aHHbIx B nepnyIO Oqepe.D;b no apXeOJIOrIIqeCRII YCTaHaBJIHBaeMbIM
CTa.D;:IIHM pa3BIITIIH RYJIbTYPbI, T. e. CYMMIIpoBaHHe .D;aHHbIX no l'.IOrIIJIbHIIRaM
TOJIbRO B npeL\eJIax O,L(HoM cTa,a,IIII. Ho npu nepexo,L(e R npIIHn;IInaM reorpa<p u -
'1ecRoM pa36IIBRII STa O'leBII,a,HOCTb 3aTeMHHeTCH HeRoTopbIMII TPY,L(HOCTHMII.
tITO TaRoe MOrIIJIbHIIR TarapcRoll RYJIbTYPbI B apXeOJIOrIIqeCROM CMbICJIe CJIO-
Ba, BepHee rOBopH, '1'1'0 CqUTaTb MOrUJIbHIIROM TarapcRoM RYJIbTYPbI II RaRyIO
rpynny RypraHoB 06'Le,a,HHuTb nop: STIIM nOIIHTIIeM? JII060My Cnen;IIaJIIIcTY,
pa60TaBilleMY B XaRaccRIIx cTenHx, nOHHTHo, '1'1'0 pa306paTbcH B STOM ,L(a-
JIeRO He TaR npOCTO, RaR RameTCH Ha nepBbIM B3rJIH,L(.
llpem,L(e Bcero B HailleM pacnopHmeHun npaRTIlqeCRII HeT MOrnJIbHIIROB,
ROTopble 6bIJIII ObI IIOJIHOCTblO paCROnaHbI. MCCJIe,a,OBaTeJIII-apXeOJIOrII, orpa-
HHqeHHbIe 'lame Bcero He60JIbIllIIM:II Cpe,L(CTBaMII, RpaTROCTblO JIeTHerO nOJIe-
Boro ce30Ha, TPY,L(HOCTbIO B03BpaID;eHIIH Ha TO me MeCTO B CJIe,L(YIOID;eM ro.D;Y,
Hep:OCTaTROM pa60'IeM CIlJIbI, Bo06ID;e RpaIIHe CJIa6bIMII B03MomHOCTHM:II opra-
H:II3an;IIII HopMaJIbHOM pa60TbI B CTenHbIX palloHax B.D;aJIn 0'1' mIIJIbH, RaR
UpaBIIJIO, He paCRanbIBamI MOrnJIbHHROB .D;O ROHn;a. Ha STO 6bIJIa II eID;e O,L(Ha
npII'IIIHa, L\OCTaTOqHO YBamnTeJIbHaH: Ha nepBbIX nopax BamHee nOJIytIIITb
apxeOJIOrII'leCRYIO xapaRTepIIcTIIRy MHorIIX MOrIIJIbHIIROB, nYCTb npe,L(Bap:II-
358
TeJIbHYIO, qeM IIC'1epnbIBalOID;YIO XapaRTepIIcTIIRy O.D;HOrO MOrIIJIbHIIRa. A npII
MHOrOqIICJIeHHOCTII II pa3Ho06pa3uII naMHTHIIROB apXeOJIOrIIH XaRacIIII II
CellqaC pa3BIIBaeTCH He TOJIbRO BrJIy6b, HO II BllIIlpb.
H'poMe SToro 06CTOHTeJIbCTBa - BbI60pOqHOCTU paCRonOR, HYiRHO yqlITbI-
BaTh U ,L\pyroe, a IIMeHHO npaRTlIqecRyIO HeB031'.JOmHOCTb B n;eJIOM pHp,e c.lIy-
qaeB YCTaIIOBUTb rpaHIIn;bI Cal\IIIX l\JOrIIJIbHIIROB. I{ypraHHble nOJIH XaRaCUII
nepeXO,L\HT O,L\HO B iJ,pyroe U, rJIaBHOe, 06pa30BaHbI pa3UOBpeMeHHbIMII Rypra-
HaMU, XPOHOJIOrIlqeCRaH npUHa,L\JIelImOCTb ROTOpbIX .D;aJIeRO He BCer.D;a l'.JOffieT
6bITb onpeiJ,eJIeHa npII BII3yaJIbHOM paCCMOTpeHIIII norpe6aJIbHbIX coopyme-
H:IIII. IImJTOMY 3a HII3IIIYIO e,L\UHIID;y pa36IIBRII RpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCROrO MaTepIIaJIa
BbIHymiJ,eHHO npIIHHTa cepIIH qepenOB II3 rpynnbI OiJ,HOBpeMeIIHbIX RypraHoB
y Toro IIJIU IIHoro YJIyca BHe 3aBIICIIMOCTII 0'1' Toro, rrpOIICXO,L\UT JIII OHa 113
O,L\HOrO l'.JOrIIJIbHIIRa IIJIII me II3 ,L\BYX, Tpex, XpOHOJIOrUqeCRU OTHOCHID;IIXCH R
O,L\HOII snoxe l'.JOrIIJILHIIROB, pacrrOJIOiReHHbIX BOI{pyr COBpeMeHHoro CeJIeHUH.
TaRaH e,L\uHUn;a .D;lI<p<pepeHn;lIan;IIU ,L\aHHblx, ROHeqHO, OTHOCIITeJIbHO yCJIOBHa,
Sl'.IIIUpUqHa, He YL\OBJIeTBOpHeT JIOrIlqeCKIIM RpIITepIIHM, HO OHa e,L\IIHCTBeHHO
B03MomHa npII COBpeMeHHOM ypOBHe II3yqeHIUI MIIIIYCIIHCROll KOTJIOBIIIIbI B
apXeOJIOrIIqeCROM OTHOIlleIIIIII. 06'be,o:IIHHTb STII cepIIII B 60JIee RpynHbIe
rpynnbI HeT Heofixo,L\IIl'.fOCTII, XOTH OHII II MaJIO'lI'lCJIeHHbI: reorpa<plIqeCRH
MOrIIJlbHIIRII He ROM6IIHIIPYlOTCH B onpen;eJIeHHble rpyrrnbI, a rpynnIIpoBaTL
UX no apxeOJIOrUqeCRIIl'.l npU3HaRaM TaRme HeB031'.JOmHO, TaR RaR 3a,L\aqa
BbliJ,eJIeIIIIH JIORaJIbHbIX BapIIaHTOB TarapCROll RYJIbTYPbI nORa He peilleHa.
B COCTaBe TarapCROll cepIIlI nepnOll CTa,L\lIII BbliJ,eJIeHO O.D;IIHHa,a,n;aTb JIO-
RaJIbHbIX rpynn, OTHOCHID;IIXCH B OCHOBHOM R ceBepHbIM pallOHaM MIIHYCIIH-
CROll ROTJIOBIIHbI. Y qepenOB II3 MOrIIJIbHIIROB Ha TarapCROM OCTpOBe,
y A6aRaHCROll ynpaBbI, CaMOXBaJIa, .D:mecoca, KbI3bIJI-KYJIH, CbliJ,bI, Y CTb-
CbliJ,bI, Y CTb- TeCII, KoqeprIIHa, EaTeHeII U OTRHIIHCRoro YJIyca 3aMeTHO
yneJIIIqeH qepenHOll yRa3aTeJIb no cpaBHeHIIIO C OCTaJIbHbIl'.III. Ho eID;e 60JIee
IWmHoe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCROe Ha6JIIOJ:(eHIIe 3aRJIIOqaeTCH B TOM, 'lTO
napaJIJIeJIbHO C YBeJIIIqeHIIeM qepenHOro yRa3aTeJIH II,L\YT II3MeHeHUH J:(pyrlIX
npII3HaROB - Tex caMbIX nplI3HaROB, no ROTOpbIM TaillTbIRn;bI B nepBYIO oqe-
pe,L\b OTJIIIqaJIIICb 0'1' Tarapn;eB, no KOTOpbIM Bo06ID;e pa3JIIIqalOTCH RpaHUOJIO-
rlIqeCRIIe TIInbI MOnrOJIOIIJ:(HOll II eBpOneOII,L\HOll pac. qepena 113 nepeqIICJIeH-
HbIX MOrIIJILHIIROB OTJIUqaIOTCH HeCIIJIbHOll, HO Bce me 3aMeTHOll ynJIOID;eH-
HOCTblO JIUn;eBOro CReJIeTa B ropII30HTaJIbHOM rrJIOCROCTU, HeROTopOll
ynJIOID;eHHOCTblO JIIIn;eBbIX ROCTeM. TaRIIM 06pa30M, eCJIU cpaBIIIIBaTb RpaHIIO-
JIOrlIqeCRIIe ocooeHHOCTII cepIIll 113 CaMOXBaJIa, KbI3bIJI-KYJIH, .D:lIWCOca,
CbI,L\bI II OTRHIIHCRoro YJIyca U TaillTbIRCROll cepIIII, TO MeiR,L\y HIIMU HaMe-
TIITCH onpeJ:(eJIeHIIOe Mop<pOJIOrIIqeClme CXO,L\CTBO: qepena II3 nepeqIICJIeHHbIX
nHTU MOrUJILHIIROB OTJIU'IaIOTCH 0'1' 'IepenOB U3 OCTaJIbHbIX MOrIIJIbHIIROB ITa
TeM iRe npII3HaRaM, no RaRIIM TaillTbIRCKIIe qepena OTJIIIqaIOTCH OT Tarap-
CIDIx. Cpe.D;II paHHero TarapCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH HaMeqaIOTCH, TaRUM 06pa30M,
.D;Be aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRII pa3JIuqalOID;ueCH rpynnbI: OJ:(Ha - C OTJIIIqUTeJIbHbIMR
MOP<pOJIOrIlqeCRUMII oc06eHHOCTHl'.III c06CTBeHHO TarapCRoro RpaHIIOJIOrlIqe-
CRoro TIIna, J:(pyraH - RpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCRII CXO,L\HaH C TaillTbIRCRIIM HaCeJle-
HIIeM a.
KaR l'.JOmeT 6bITb 06'bHCHeHO STO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO rrpII ero IICTOpIIqeCROM
IIHTepnpeTan;IIU? CJIyqaIIHOCTbIO nO,L\60pa pa3JIIIqHbIX qepenOB B pa3HbIX 1'.10-
rIIJIbHIIRaX, II TOr,L\a l'.JOp<p0JIOrIIqeCRIIe pa3JIII'lI'IH .D;BYX rpynn He nOTpe6YIOT
HURaRoro IICTOpIIqeCROrO ROMMeHTapIIH? Ha060pOT, OHII Tor,L\a rroTpe6YlOT
6IIOJIOrIIqeCROrO ROMl'.IeHTapIIH - HYiRHO 6YJ:(eT 06'bHCHIITb npIIqIIHY UX B03-
HIIRHOBeHUH II UCRaTb ee B reHe3uce paHHeTarapCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH, B c03ga-
HUll Mem.D;y rpynrraMII reHeTIIqeCIDIX 6apbepOB II T. ]J;. MJIII pa3Hm:t;a Mem,L\Y
I
I
359
JWYMH rpynnaMII HaCeJIeHIIH nepBOll CTa.D;:IIII TarapCROll RYJIbTYPbI He CJIY-
allHa II 06H3aHa CBOIIM rrOHBJIeHIIeM :IICTOpII'IeCRIIM IIJIII pacoreHeTIIqeCRIIM
npOn;eccaM? B STOM-TO CJIyqae :II Tpe6yeTcH IICTOpIIqeCRaH IIHTeprrpeTan;IIII
3.HTpOnOJIOrIIqeCR:IIX <paRTOB. llpOTIIB CJIyqaIIHOCTII pa3JIIIqIIII CBII.D;eTeJIbCTBY-
eT TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO, '1'1'0 OH:II rrOHBJIHIOTCH He B O.D;HOM, a B HeCROJIbRIIX
MOrIIJIbHIIRaX II B' Ram,L\OM II3 HIIX 06pa3YIOT O.D;IIH II TOT me ROl\IIIJIeRC,
a TaRme TO, '1'1'0 OHII npOHBJIHIOTCH O.D;IIHaROBO :II Ha MymcRIIx II Ha meHCR:IIX
eperrax. HaROHen;, npOTIIB CJIyqallHOCTII pa3JIIIqIIII rOBopIIT C6JIIImeHlIe BbI-
eJIHeMOrO ROMnJIeRCa npII3HaROB C OTJIIIqIITeJIbHbIMII qepTaMII Mop<p0JIOrIIqe-
CRoro TIIna TaillTbIRCRoro naCeJIeHIIH.
3aKOHOMepHOCTb nOHBJIeHIIH xapaRTepHoro ,L\JIH TaillTbIRn;eB ROMnJIeRCa
npII3HaROB B MIIHYCIIHCROII ROTJIOBIIHe B paHHeTarapCRoe BpeMH l\WmeT
HMeTb TOJIbRO O.D;HO 06'bHCHeHIIe: HaCeJIeHIIe, COCTaBIIBillee STHIIqeCRYIO Oe-
HOBY TaillTbIRCROll RYJIbTypbI, npIImJIO TY.D;a BnepBbIe IIMeHHO B STY snoxy,
Jla meCTb BeROB paHbme, qeM 3aHHJIO npe06JIa.D;alOID;ee nOJIOmeHIIe. CY,L\H no
TOl\IY, '1'1'0 cepIIH 113 nepeqIICJIeHHbIX BbIIlle nHTII MOrIIJIbHIIROB He rrOJI-
HOCTbIO BonJIOID;aeT TaillTbIRCRIIII RpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCRIIll TIIn, a 06Hapym IIB aeT
TOJIbRO C.D;BIIr B HanpaBJIeHIIII npII6JIIImeHIIH R TamTbIRCROII cepIIII, nepBbIe
npe.a;CTaBIITeJI:II 6Y,L\yID;ero MaCCOBoro STHIIqeCROrO s.rreMeHTa 6bIJIII HeMnoro-
IICJIeHHbI. Ho, qT06bI ,L\ORa3aTb, 'ITO IIMeHHO OH:II, TamTbIRn;bI, np:IImJI:II B eTe-
n:II XaKaCIIII B paHHeTarapCRYIO snoxy II ORa3aJIII BJIIIHHIIe Ha MeCTHoe Ta-
rapeRoe HaCeJIeHIIe, MbI .D;OJImHbI HaIITH eJIe,L\bI TamTbIRCROrO aHTpOnOJIOrIIqe-
CRoro TIIna B COCTaBe TarapCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH BTOpOll II TpeTbeII CTa,L\IIll o
H3 meCTII JIORaJIbTIbIX cepIIII BTOpOll CTa.D;IIII II3 MOrIIJIbHIIROB Ha TarapCROM
oeTpOBe, y A6aRaHCROll ynpaBbI, CaprOBa YJIyca, Caparama, KaMbImTbI H
(De.D;opOBa YJIyca nprrl\IeCb TaillTbIRCROll ROM6IIHan;IIII OID;yID;aeTCH qeTRO B
Tpex - Ha TarapCROM OCTpOBe, y A6aRaHCIWII yrrpaBbI II B <De,L\OpOBOM YJIY-
ceo K STOll rpynne npII6JIIImaeTCH II cepIIH II3 CaparaIlla, XOTH B Hell STa
np:IIl\IeCb BbIpameHa cJIa6ee. BbIJIa OHa BblpameHa :II Ha ceBepe (TarapCRIIll
OeTpOB, A6aRaHCRaH ynpaBa), II Ha lOre (<De.D;OpOB YJIYC).
qTO me RacaeTCH HaCeJIeHIIH TpeTbell CTaiJ,IIII TarapeROII RYJIbTypbI, TO
ero aHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCR:IIe qepTbI MOryT 6bITb oxapaRTep:II30BaHbI Ha OCHOBaHI'lII
paCCMOTpeHIIH JIIIIllb .D;BYX Cep:IIll - II3 MOr:IIJIbHIIROB Y He<pTe6a3bI B rrpe.D;e-
JIax r. A6aRaHa :II y lliI3bIJI-KYJIH. 06e ST:II eep:IIII yme MaJIO qeM OTJI:II'Ia-
IOTCH OT TamTbIRCROII. Oe06eHHO CXO.D;Ha e TamTbIReROll eepIIH 1I3 MOrIIJIb-
HHRa Y He<pTe6a3bI. TaRIIM 06pa30M, <paRT epaBHIITeJIbHO paHHero npOHIIRHO-
EeHIIH TamTbIRCROrO STHIIqeCROro ROMnOHeHTa IIJIII, BO BCHROM CJIyqae, Toro
naCeJIeHIIH, ROTopoe B OCHOBHOM C<pOpMIIpOBaJIO ero, BbIHBJIHeMbIll rraJIeOaHT-
ponOJIOr:IIqeeRIIM anaJI:II30M HaCeJIeHIIH nepBoM eTa.D;:IIII TarapcRoM RYJIbTYP:bI,
nOATBepJR.D;aeTeH TaRJRe II npII paCCMOTpeHIIII aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX oc06eHHO-
eTell HaCeJIeH:IIH BTOpOll II TpeTbell CTa,L\IIll.
B03BpaID;aHCb R Borrpocy 0 BpeMeHII rrpOH:IIRHOBeH:IIH JIeeHOrO, TaemHoro,
ROl\IIIOHeHTa, rrpeOOJIa,L\alOID;ero B TamTbIRCROM HaCeJIeHIIII, B MIIHYCIIHCRYIO
ROTJIOBIIHY, MbI MomeM OTBeTIITb: STO rrpO:II30mJIO B panHlO1O TarapeRYIO sno-
xy. Ero nepBbIe HOCIITeJIII 6bIJIII HeMHOrOqIICJIeHHbI, HO yme B snoxy BTOpOM
CTa,L\IIII IIX CTaJIO OOJIbme, a B COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIIH TpeTbell CTa.D;II:II OH npep;-
CTaBJIHJI C060II, OqeBII)]J'!O, npe06JIa,L\alOID;YlO ROM6IIHan;IIIO rrpII3HaROB.
Tenepb, ROr,L\a orrpe.D;eJIeHa OTHOCIITeJIbHaH xapaRTepIIcTIIRa .D;BYX SJIe-
MeHTOB, ecpOpMIIpoBaBmIIx aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIll TIIrr HaCeJIeHIIH TamTbIRCROM
RYJIbTypbI, HymHo nepellTII R paCCMOTpeHIllO nYTeM :IIX npOHIIRHOBeHIIH B
MIIHYCIIHCRYIO ROTJIOBIIHY.
He TaR .D;aBHO npII paCCMOTpeHIII'! n;eHTpaJIbHOa3:IIaTeROro THna :II ero re-
He3IIca aHTpOnOJIOrII M01'JI:II .D;aTb JIIIIllb OqeHb 06ID;:IIM :II rrpII6JI:II3:IITeJIbHbIM
360
OTBeT Ha BOnpOC 0 ero npapO.D;IIHe - OHa HaXO.D;IITCH r.D;e-TO B npe.D;enax
II;eHTpaJIbHOll A3IIII. 1l0TOM nOHBlIJIIICb .D;aHHbIe no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII TYBH
CRII<pCRoro II capMaTCRQrO BpeMeHII, II3 ROTOpbIX CTaJIO HCHO, '1'1'0 B snoxy
6pOH3bI TYBa qaCTIIqHO BXO.D;IIJIa B .D;peBHIIll apeaJI eBponeOII.D;HOll paCbI :II qTO
reorpa<pUqeCRIIe Py6eJRII MeJR,L\y IOJRHOll XaRaCIIell :II 3ana.D;HOll TYBoll npH
Bcell 3TWqIITeJIbHOCTII paCCTOHHIIII He MOrJIII OCTaHOBIITb npIITOR eBpOneOII.D;OB
B TYBY IT3 XmmCITII 15. HaROHen;, B nOCJIe.D;Hee ,L\Ba.D;n;aTIIJIeTIIe nOHBIIJICH He-
60JIbmOll naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIll MaTepIIaJI II3 3ana,L\HOll MOHrOJIIIII, JJ:aT:II-
pyeMbIII snOXOII paHHero JReJIe3a, HO, MOllieT 6bITb, qaCTIlqHO 3aXO.D;HID;IIll Ii
B snoxy 6pOH3bI 16 . CepIIH OTJIIIqaeTCH HeROTopbIMII IIHTepeCHbIMII oC06eHHD-
CTHMII, HO OHII 6e3pa3JIIIqHbI ,L\JIH HaIIIell TeMbI II H He 6y,L\y Ha HIIX OCTa-
HaBJIIIBaTbCH. BalliHO .D;pyroe - STO qepena eBponeOII.D;Horo HaCeJIeHIIH C He-
60JIbmOll MOHrOJIOII,L\HOII npIIMeCblO. CJIe,L\OBaTeJIbHO, 3ana.D;HaH MOHrOJIIIH
TaRJRe .D;OJIJRHa 6bITb IICRJIlOqeHa II3 apeaJIa qIICTbIX MOHrOJIOII.D;OB II OTHece-
Ha CRopee R ,L\peBHeMY eBpOneOlI,L\HoMy apeaJIY. TaRIIM 06pa30M, Yffie He
npeiJ,CT::<BJIHeTCH B03MOlliHbIM COrJIaCIITbCH C HeOT'IeTJIIIBOll 06ID;ell <POPMYJIII-
pOBIWii:, rOBopH 0 30He <pOpMIIpoBaHIIH n;eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTcRoro TIIna, II Cq:II-
TaTb eIO RCIO TeppIITOpIIIO lJ,eHTpaJIbHOII A3IIII. OIIa .D;OJImHa ObITb OrpaHIlqe-
Ha I(eJITpaJIbHOll n BOCTOqHOll MOHrOJIIIeii:. ITpaB,L\a, B HaCTOHID;eenpeMH
nOHBIIJIIICb Roe-RaRIIe ROCBeHHbIe .D;aHHbIe, CBII,L\eTeJIbCTByroID;IIe 0 TOM, 'ITO
eBponeOII.D;bI B snoxy 6pOH3bI He OCTaHOBIIJIIICb B 3anaiJ,HOll MOHrOJIJIII, a npo-
HIIRJIII II ,L\aJIbme. B npIIHl(IIne STO npneMJIeMO II nOHHTHO rOpa3.D;0 60JIbme,
qeM YCTaHOBJIeHIIe qeTROll rpaHIIn;bI MeiR.D;y eBponeOImaMII II MOHrOJIOII,],aMH,
npOXOiJ,HID;eII RaR pa3 no rpaHIIn;e 3anaiJ,HOll II lJ,eHTpaJIbHOII MOHrOJIIIII,-
ne.D;b MeJR.D;y ooeIIMII 06JIaCTHl\1II MOHrOJIIIII COBceM HeT pe3RIIX reorpa<pII'Ie-
CRIIX py6emeII, CROJIbHO-HII6YJJ:b 3aTpYllHHIOID;IIX coo6ID;eHIIe Memgy HIIMII.
Ho .D;aHHbIe 0 eID;e 60JIee ,L\aJIeROM BOCTOqHOM npOHnRHOBeHIIII eBpOneO:II.D;OB
nOlm CJIIIIllROM <pparMeHTapHbI, qT06bI C HIIMII MOJRHO 6bIJIO Bcepbe3 CqI'[-
TaTbCH.
ApeaJI <pOpMIIpOBaHIIH n;eJITpaJIbHOa3IIaTCRoro TIIna, CTaJIO GMTb, He :QeHT-
paJIbHaH A3IIH B n;eJIOM, a :QeHTpaJIbHaH II BOCTOqHaH MOHrOJIIIH. CJIe,L\OBa-
TeJIbHO, n;eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCRIIll TIIn nOHBJIHeTCH B MIIHYCIIHCROll ROTJIOBRHe
B pe3YJIbTaTe nepeCeJIeHIIH JIIO.D;ell 113 lJ,eHTpaJIbHOll II BOCTOqHOll MonroJIII:II.
llepe.D; apxeOJIOraMII STO CTaBIIT oco6ylO 3a,L\aqy: Ror.D;a 6Y,L\YT CROJIbRO-HII6Y.D;b
nOJIHO II3yqeHbI apXeOJIOrIIqeCRIIe naMHTHIIRII MOHrOJIIIII snOX:II paHHero JRe-
JIe3a, IICRaTb Cnen;:II<pIIqeCRIIe CBH3II B apXeOJIOrIIqeCROM :IIHBeHTape TamTbIK-
CROll RYJIbTYPbI, C O.D;HOll CTOpOHbI, CTOHHOR II MOrIIJIbHIIROB I{eHTpaJIbHOM ]I
BOCTOqHOll MOHrOJIIIII - C .D;pyrOII.
HOBbIM naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIM MaTepIIaJI C TeppIITopIIH TYBbI n03BO-
JIHeT paCIllIIpIITb II 060raTIITb ,L\eTaJIHMII TaRiRe nOHIIMaHIIe reHe3IIca TaeJRHO-
ro ROMnOHeHTa. HaXO.D;RII OT.D;eJIbHbIX qepenOB II cepIIll SToro TIIna npIIYpo-
qeHbI 6bIJIII B OCHOBHOM R Taen HbIM pallOHaM, pacrrOJIom:eHHbIM R ceBepy OT
MIIHYCIIHCROll ROTJIOBIIHbI, 06 9TOM yme rOBOpIIJIOCb. Ho rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIqe-
CRIIe IICCJIe,L\OBaHIIH B TYBe BbIHBIIJIII STOT TIIn II Ha lOre 0'1' MIIHYCIIHCROD.
ROTJIOBIIHbI. llepBbDIH TaRIIMII HaXO,L\RaMII 6bIJI:II OT.D;eJIbHbIe qeperra 113 1\10-
rIIJIbHIIRa CRII<pCRoro BpeMeHII B MeCTHOCTII KbI3bIJIraH. C06CTBeHHO rOBopH,
aHaJIOrIIqHaH ROM6IIHan;IIH rrpII3HaROB BCTpeqaJIaCb :II paHbille Ha qeperrax II3
.D:pyrIIx MOrIIJIbHIIROB, HO He npIIBJIeRaJIa R ce6e BHIIMaHIIH. qeperra II3 fuI-
3bIJIraHa rrOCJIym:IIJIII rrepBbIM cpaBHIITeJIbHbIM MaTeplIaJIOM .D;JIH corrOCTaBne-
HIIH C HII3ROJIIIn;bIMII MOHrOJIOII.D:HbIMII cepIIHMII TaeJRHOll CII6IIpH. Ho <eCJIH
HII3ROJIIIn;:bIll MOHrOJIOII,L\HbIll TIIn C eBpOneOII,L\Holl npIIMeCblO pacrrpOCTpaHen
He TOJIbRO R ceBepy, HO II R IOry 0'1' MIIHYCIIHCROII ROTJIOBIIHbI, TO Taeil\HLIi:
KOMnOHeHT Mor rrpOH:IIRHYTb B MIIHYCIIHCRYro ROTJIOB:IIHY He TOJIbRO c CeBe-
I
I
I
361
pa, HO Ii C IOra. CYTII B033peHII.H Ha ero rrpOIIcxom.a;eHIIe rrpe.a;rrOJIOmeHIIe He
II3MeH1IeT - ero <pOpMIIpOBaHIIe B TaemHOll, JIeCHOll rrOJIOce CII6HpII OCTaeT-
01 He3bI6JIeMbIM, HO KOHn;errn;IIH :na 060raIn;aeTCH O,L(HOll BamHOII ,L(eTaJIblO:
rrpOHIIKHYB Ha IOr, B TYBY, JIIO,L(II :noro TIIrra YiI\:e oTTy.a;a MOrJIH npOHIIKHYTb
na A6aKaH. K coma.rreHIIIO, rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIH, BbI,L(BIIHYB rrepe,L( HaMII :ny
nOBYIO B03MOa\HOCTb IICTOpII'IeCKOrO IICTOJIKOBaHIIH alITpOrrOJIOrIFIeCKIIX <paR-
TOB, nOlm He pacnOJIaraeT RpHTepIIHMII BbI60pa l\iem,L(Y ,L(BYMH rIIrrOTe3aMII:
CTapOll - rrOHBJIeHHH TaeJH:HOrO ROMrrOHeHTa B pe3yJIbTaTe rrpHMoro rrepece-
JIeHIIH JIIO,L(ell C ceBepa B MIIHYCIIHCRYIO ROTJIOBlmy II HOBOll - nOHB.rreHIIH
'raemHoro KOMrrOHeIUa BCJIe.D;CTBIIe RpyroBoro )IBIIiReHIIH C ceBepa Ha IOr II
3aTeM yme C IOra B MIIHYCIUICRYIO ROTJIOBIIHY. HYiRHbI ,L(aJIbHei'IliIIIe nOlICRII,
rraJIeOaIITpOrrOJIOrIlqeCRIIe HaXO,L(RII, IIX BHIIl\IaTeJIbHOe II3yqeHHe.
IhaR, rrepe,L( HaMIl rrpe,L(CTaJIa RapTIIHa 9THIIqeCRIIX B3aIiMOOTHOmeH:IIH
.a;3JIeRoiir 9nOXH, nepeCeJIeHIIll II CMemeHIIll, HapIICOBaHHaH C rroMoID;blO na-
JIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCKIIX l\IaTepIIa.rrOB. AHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCRIIll TIIrr TamTbIKCRoro
ROMrrJIeRCa ,L(OCTa:rOqHO e,L(IIH, II BbI,L(eJIIITb B HeM COCTaBJIHIOID;IIe ROl\iIIOHeH-
TbI ORa3a;rOCb B03MOlliHbIM TOJIbRO B pe3yJIbTaTe TID;aTeJIbHOrO aHa;rII3a. Mom-
HO .D;YMaT:b (rrpe.a;rrOJIOmIITeJI:bHO, npaB.a;a), qTO e.D;IIHCTBO TIIna CBII,'];eTeJIbCTBY-
eT 06 IIHTeHCIIBHOM CMemeIUIII, 06 IIHTeHCIIBHOll ROHCOJIII,L(an;IIII, '1'1'0 TaIII-
TbIKn;:bI, CJIe.D;OBaTeJIbHO, rrpe,L(CTaBJIHJIII C060ll He ROHrJIOMepaT OT,L(eJIbHbIX
9TIIorpa<pII'IeCKIIX rpyrrn, pa3JIII'IaBllUIXCH CIIJIbHO no KYJIbType (9'1'0 IIamJIO
6bI OTpamerrIIe B apXeOJIOrIIII) II rr.rroxo IIOHIIMaBmIIX ,L(pyr ,L(pyra, a e.D;IIHOe
HaCeJIeHIIe, pa3JIIIqHbIe rpyrrrrbJ B COCTaBe KOToporo OTJIIIqaJIIICb O.D;Ha 0'1' ,L(PY-
rOll caMoe 60JIbmee ,L(IIaJIeRTHbIMII oco6eHHocTHMII. Ha rrepBbIll Bonpoc, 3a-
,L(aHHbIll B HaqaJIe cTaTbII,- 0 e,L(IIHCTBe IIJIII, HaII60poT, Heo.D;HopOJl,HOCTII
TamTbIKcRoll KYJIbTYPbI :II TamTbIKCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH - HymHo oTBeTHTb, Ta-
RIIM oopa30M, rrOJIOmIITeJIbHO: TamTbIKCRoe HaCeJIeHIIe ObIJIO, rrO-BII,L(IIMOMY,
JJ:ocTaTOqHO ROHCOJIII):IIIpOBaHo B 9THIIqeCROM OTHomeHHII. 8JIeMeHTbI, Ha OC-
HOBe ROTOpbIX rrpOII30mJIa 9Ta ROHCOJIII.D;an;IIH, rrOJIyqIIJIII oCBeID;eHIIe KaR B
CBoeM rrpOIICXOm,L(eHIIII, TaR II BO BpeMeHII rrpOHIIRHOBeHIIH B MIIHYCIIHCRYIO
IWTJIOHIIHY. OCTaJIOCb OTBeTIITb Ha rrOCJIe,L(HRu Borrpoc 113 Tex, KOTopbIe 6bIJIII
3an;aHbI BHaqaJIe: RaROBO 3HaqeHIIe aHTporro.rrorIIqeCRIIX ,L(aHHbIX B BbIHCHeHII:II
BTHII'IeCROrO JIIIn;a TamTbIKCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH, KaROll HOBbIll CBeT 6pocalOT OHn
Ha rrp06JIeMY ero H3bIKOBOll rrpIIHa,L(JIemHOCTII II pOJIII B CJIOmeHIIII cOBpeMeH-
HbIX Hapo.D;OB?
OB 3THHQECKOH TIPIIHAlJ;JlEmHOCTII
HACEJlEIIIIH TAillTbIRCKOH KYJlbTYPbI
CYID;eCTBYIOIn;aH JIIITepaTypa no 9TOll npOOJIeMe OqeHb 06mIIpHa :II IIMeeT
MHOrOJIeTHlO1O Tpa,L(IIn;IIIO. OCHOBHOll ee He,L(OCTaToR, ):lame eCJIII OrpaHIIqIITbCH
nOCJIe,'];HIIMII ny6JIIIRan;IIHMII, - KpallHHH npoTIIBOpeqIIBOCTb, qTO He TOJIbRO
OTpamaeT CJIOmHOCTb orrpe,L(eJIeHIIH H3bIKOBOll rrpIIHa.D;JIea\HOCTII HaCeJIeHIIH
,L(peBHIIX 9nox, HO II CBII.D;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 HerrOJIHOTe Haxo.a;HID;IIXCH B pacrro-
pHmeHIIII IICCJIenOBaTeJIell <paRTIlqeCRIIX l\IaTepIIaJIOB B .D;aHHOM KOHRpeTHOM
c;rryqae. TonOHIIMIIqeCRIIe IICCJIe,L(OBaHIIH, 'Ipe3BbIqallHO BamHbIe ,L(JIH YCTaHOB-
JIeHIIH caMoro <paRTa npomIIBaHrrH Toro IIJIII IIHoro HapO,L(a Ha onpeJJ:e;reHHOll
TeppIITopIIII, 06HapymIIJIII B AJITae-CaHHCROM Haropbe HeCKOJIbRO TorrOHIIMII-
qeCKIIX nJIaCTOB. ]IlcRJIlOqaH TOnOHIIl\iII'IeCRIIe Ha3BaHIIH 3aBe,L(OMO n03.a;Hero
TIOpKCROro II pyccRoro rrpOIIC::OiR,L(eHIIH, MbI CTaJIRIIBaeMCH TaM C ReTCRIIMII,
CaMO.D;IIllCRIIMII II IIH.a;oeBporrer:CRIDUI TonOHIIMaMII, BbIHBJIeHIIbIMII B OCHOBIIOM
p;OJIrOJIeTHIIMII II OqeHb nJIO,L(OTBOpHbIMII IICCJIe,L(OBaHIIHMII A. n. .n;YJIb30Ha 17,
K yropcRIIM TonOHIIMaM, Ha ROTOpbIe 06paID;aJI oc06eHHoe BHIIl\IaH:IIe
362
JI. P. HbI3JIaCOB, A. II. .n;YJIb30H OTHOCIITCH BeCbMa CKenTlI'IeCRII II nOJIara-
eT, 'ITO OHII MorYT 6bITb C ropa3p,0 60JIbmlIM ycnexoM 06'bHCHeHbl 113 KeT-
CKoro H3bIKa. CaM A. IT. .n;YJIb30H 'Ipe3BbI'IanHO OCTopOllieH B o elIKe XpOH6-'
JIOrlI'IeCKOro acneKTa TonOHIIMlI'IeCKIIX IICCJIep,OBaHlIn II Hep,BYCMbICJIeHHO
nlImeT 0 TOM, 'ITO IIX pe3YJIbTaTbl p,alOT OCHOBaHlIe JIUmb p,JIH OTHOCIITeJIb-
Hon, a He p,JIH a6COJIlOTHOn p,aTlIpOBKII. IIoSTOMY, YCTaHOBIIB C nOMOI::qbHt
TOnOlUIMTIKU, KaKlle H3bIKOBbIe ceMblI 6bIJIII TIpep;CTaBJIeHbl B p,peBHOCTII Ha
BepXHeM EHIIcee II A6aKaHe, Mbl p,OJIlliHbl Tenepb nepenTII P;JIH IIX p;aTlIpOB-
KII K paCCMOTpeHUIO pe3YJIbTaTOB apxeOJIOrI1'IeCKIIX II IIHblX conOCTaBJIeHIIB:.
TYT-TO II BbIHBJIHeTCH pa3H060n BO MHeHIIHX no OT.a:eJIbHbIM BonpocaM.
BbICKa3I:.IBaJIOCI:. MHeHlIe, 'ITO p,peBHeMmee xopomo 113Y'IeHHOe HaCeJIeHII6
MIIHYCIIHCKon KOTJIOBUHI:.I - HOCIITeJIII aiPaHacbeBCKUM KYJIbTYPbl - 6bIJIO
iPIIHHo-yropcKIIM 18. MHeHIIe aTO OCHOBbIBaJIOCb Ha conOCTaBJIeHIIII apxeOJID-
rII eCKII YCTaHaBJIIIBaeMOro iPaKTa 60JILIIIOn p,peBHOCTII aiPaHacbeBCRon KYJIb-
TYPbI II OTMeqeHHOro J1. P. Hbl3JIaCOBbIM IIIlIpOKoro pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH iPIIHHD-
yropcKon TonOHUMIIKII B AJITae-CaHHCKOM Haropbe 19. Ho KOJI'I:. CKOpO caMa
HKOObl iPIIHHo-yropcKaH TonOHIIMUKa He HBJIHeTCH 6eccnopHon B OTHomemm:
cBoeM H3bIKoBon npIIHap,JIemHOCTII, KOJIb CKOpO Bbl3bIBaeT COMHeHlle Be pac-
mlIiPpoBKa 113 iPlIHHo-yropcKIIX H3bIKOB II, Ha060pOT, HaMe'Ia.eTCH nyTb pac-
mniPpoBKII 113 KeTCKoro H3bIKa, TO OTIIap;aeT C STUM II OCHOBaHlle p,JIH BKJIIO-
'IeHUH p,peBHIIX aiPaHacbeB eB B 'IIICJIO Hapop,OB, rOBoplIBmllX Ha p,peBlm:x
iPlIHHo-yropcKIIX H3bIKax. AHp,poHoB eB 8. MOJIbHep C'IlITaeT IIpaHOH3bl'IHblM:
Hapop,OM - MHeHlle, KOTopoe pacnpOCTpaHIIJIOCb O'IeHI:. llIlIpOKO II nop;p,epmH-
BaeTCH MHorllMII IICCJIep;OBaTeJIHMII. Ho KaKUe-JIII60 TBepp;ble iPaKTbl npUBe-
CTII B nop,p,eplliKY aToro MHeHIIH TaKme Tpyp,HO: CJIlImKOM p;aJIeKO OTCTOlIT
aHp;pOHOBCKaH anoxa OT anoxlI py6eJ:I\:a HOBon SpbI, Korp;a paCCeJIeHUe H3bIKO-
BbIX ceMelI MomHO, 'tlaCTII'IHO XOTH 6bI, BOCCTaHOBIITI:. Ha OCHOBaHIIII co06r::qe-
Hlln, cop,eplliar::qIlXCH B nlIChMeHHblX IICTO'IHIIKax. TaKIIM 06pa30M, H3bIKOByID
npUHap,JIemHOCTI:. snoxn SHeOJIIITa II paHHeii: OpOH3bl He BCKpbITI:. nOKa c p,o-
CTaTO'IHOn CTeneHblO y6ep,UTeJILHOCTII II 06'beKTIIBHOCTII, JJ;allie mnpo'&o TIOllJr-
3YHCb peTpocneKTIIBHblM MeTop,OM.
o H3bIKOBon npIlHap,JIemHOCTII n03p,Henmero HaCeJIeHIIH cymp,mm:n 60m'r
me, HO IlK MHOrO'IlICJIeHHOCTL TOJII:.KO YCUJIIIBaeT npOTIIBOpe'IlIBOCTb B On;eHKe
cyr::qeCTByror::qIIX iPaKTOB. Ha OCHOBaHIIII STHorpaiPlI'IeCKIIX p,aHHbIX - CXOp,CT-
na B YKpameHIIHX (JIan'IaTble nop;BeCKII) II 0PYlliIIII (KOJIeH'IaTble HomH)
CXop,CTBa B 06pHp,ax (Ka IeHHLIe BopoTa Y HraHacaH, norpe6aJIbHI:.le coop}T1Ke-
HIIH y KapaCYKD,eB) - B. O. .n;oJIrux BblCKa3aJI MbICJII:. 0 caMop,lInCKon H3LI-
KOBOM npIIHap,JIelliHOCTII KapacYKcKoro, a B03MomHo, II TarapCKoro HaCeJIe-
HIIH 20. P. B. HIIKOJIaeB, conOCTaBJIHH KepaMIIKY II IIHBeHTapb n03p,Hux, no-
BIIP;IIMOMy 3aBep,oMo KeTcKllx, naMHTHIIKOB Ha cpep,HeM EHllcee C IIHBeHTapeM
KapacYKcKIIX II TarapcKllx naMHTHIIKOB, CKJIOHeH CJJ:eJIaTI:. 113 aToro conOCTaB-
JIeHIIH BbIBOP;, 'ITO npep;KaMII KeTOB 6bIJIII P;IIHJIIIHbI KIITanCKIIX JIeTOnlICen-
CTaJIO 6bITI:.. no ero MHeHlllO, HaCeJIeHlle KapaCYKCKon KYJIbTypbl 6 p IJIO KeTO-
H3bI'IHbIM 21. B TarapD,ax OH BUD;IIT npHMblX nOTOMKOB RapaCYKCKoro HaCe-
JIeHIIH. AHaJIOrIT'IHO MHeHIIe H. JI. qJIeHOBOII OTHOCIITeJILHO KeTOH3bl'tIHOCTH
KapaCYKD,eB, HO B TarapD,ax OHa BIIP;IIT p,peBHIIX IIpaHQeB, IICXOp,H II3 nOK<'t-
3aHHbIX elO II p;pyrllMu IICCJIep;OBaTeJIHMII IIHTeHCII-':!HbIX CBH3en TarapCKoro
HaCeJIeHIIH C HaCeJIeHlleM Cpe)J,Hen A3UII 22. ITpe6bIBaHue p,UHJIIIHOB B MIIHy-
CIIHCKon KOTJIOBIIHe OHa, onlIpaHCb Ha KIITanCKIIe IICTO'IHIIKIT, p,aTIIpyeT
TOJIbKO cpaBHIITeJIbHO KOpOTKUM neplIop,OM BpeMeHII C III B. p,o H. a. no
III B. H. a., oTKyp;a BnOJIHe 3aKoHoMepHo p,eJIaeTCH BbIBOp, 0 Heo6xop,IIMOCTII
IIp,eHTlIiPIIKa lIn P;IIHJIIIHOB C HaCeJIeHlleM He TarapCKon, a TamTbIKCRoii
RYJIbTypbl.
I
I
I
I
I
.
363
I
HaKon aHTpOnOJIOru'tIeCKlIn KOMMeHTaplln MOlliHO Cp,eJIaTb K STIIM iPaKTaM
U rIIrroTe3aM, ocnOBLIBaHCL Ha naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKOM MaTepllaJIe, Ha
BCT{pbIBaeMblx IIM aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX CBH3HX p,peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH II BblTe-
ImJO UX 113 SToro £Ipep,CTaBJIeHIIHX 0 reHeTU'IeCKIIX B3alIMOOTIIOIIIeHIIHX p,peB-
HIIX HapO,l:\OB? B CBoelI pa60Te rro rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrlI1I XaKaCIIII arroxII RW-
JIe3a H nblTaJICH aprYMeHTIIpoBaTL reHeTII'IeCKOe pOp,CTBO, CBH3blBaIO ee
TarapCKoe HaCeJIeHUe C aiParracbeBCKIIM. OCHoBaHlleM ,l:\JIR aToro HBII:rOCb
nOJIHOe TOllip,eCTBO KpaHUOJIOrll'IeCKOrO TU£Ia TarapCKo:iI II a<I>arracLeBCKon
cepnn. C ,l:\PyrolI CTOpOHbl, B CBoJJ:Hon pa60Te no naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII XaKa-
CIIII snoxII 6pOH3bI 6bIJIII npIIBe,l:\eHbI KaK MopiPOJIOrII'IeCKlle, OCHOBaHHbIe Ha
paCCMoTpeHIIu oc06eHIIoCTen aHTpOrrOJIOrU'IeCKOrO Tllna HaCeJIeHIIH aiParIaCb-
eBCKoM II HMHon KYJIbTYP, TaK If 'IaCTII'IHO apxeoJIOrII'tIeCKlle (CXOp:CTBO rro-
rpe6aJIbHOrO IIHBeHTapH, KypIIJIbHnD,bl II T. P,.) aprYMeHTbl B rrOJIb3y P01(CTBa
aiPaHaCbeBCKoro II ,l:\peBHeHMHoro HaCeJIeHUH, B nOJIb3Y rrpIIxop,a aiPaHacbeB-
n:eB B MIIHYCIIHCKYID KOTJIOBIIHY C 3ana,l:\a, 113 CTenHblX paMOHOB IOJImOM
POCCUII 23. TaKoM BLIBOp, I1pIIBOp:UT K Heooxop,UMOCTU BII,l:\eTb B aiPaIIaCbeB-
D,ax p:peBHllx IIHp,oeBporreMD,eB. BeCbMa B03 IOlliHO, 'lITO STO crrpaBep:JIIIBO U
p,JIH aHp,pOHOBD,eB, TaK KaK OHII nOHBIIJIIICb B CTerrHX XaKaCIIII TaKllie C 3arra-
,l:\a, 113 06JIaCTU, C BOCTOIi:a IIpIIMblKalO eH K rpaHUD,aM paCCeJIeIlUH npe,l:\KOB
aiPaHaCbeBD,eB. TarapCKoe HaCeJIeHUe B CIIJIY ero rrpOIlCXOJI{,l:\eHIIH OT
aiPaHacbeBCKoro TaKme, CJIeJ],OBaTeJILHO, MOlliHO C'IIITaTb IIHJJ:oeBponeMCKIIM,
B03MomHO, KaK II nOJIaraeT H. 31. qJIeHOBa, upaHOH3bI'IHbIM. qTO KacaeTCH
mOiJ:en RapaCYKCKOM KYJIbTYPbl, TO B TOM me pa60Te aBTOp rrblTaJICH rrOKa3aTb,
'ITO OHII nOHBIIJIIICb B MIIHycnHcKon KOTJIOBIIHe He 113 CeBepHoro HUTaH,
a C IOrO-3anap,a, 1I3 KaKIIX-TO IOmHbIX panOHOB Cpep,Hen A31111 IIJIII BOCTO'I-
Horo TypKeCTaHa. B KapaCYKCKOII cepllu OTMe'IeH rrporHaTHbln II mupOKO-
HOCbln 'Iepen HBHO IOmHoro 06JIlIKa. ::hu p,Ba 06CTOHTeJIbCTBa xopomo CorJIa-
CYIOTCH C rrpeD:rrOJIaraeMbIM CXO,l:\CTBOM KeTCKoro H3bIKa C TII6eTo-6I1pMaH-
CKIIMII 2 .
Y!TaK, MeCTHbI'n aBTOXTOHHLIn KOMnoHeHT B COCTaBe TamTbIKCKon KYJIbTY-
pbI, BOCXOp,H UM K TarapCKOII II 'Iepe3 Hee K aiPaHacbeBCKon KYJIbType, eCTb
KaK 6Y,l:\TO HeKOTopble OCHOBaHIIH C'IIITaTb upaHCKIIM.
COBepmeHHO O'IeBllp,HO, '1TO C TeM aIITpOrrOJIOrIf'IeCKIIM KOMrrOHeHTOM B
COCTaBe TaIIITbIKCKoro naCeJIeHIIH, KOTopbIn IIMeeT TaemHoe npOIlCXOllip:eHlIe,
eCTb .Bce OCHOBaHUH YBH3bIBaTb caMO,l:\lInCKYIO TorrOHIIMIIKY Ha TepplITopUII
AJJTae-CaHHCKoro HaropbH. OTCIO,l:\a 3aKOHOMepHO CJIe.a:yeT BbIBOp, 0 caMoep,o-
H3bl'IIIOCTII Toro HaCeJIeHIIH, KOTopoe BbImJIO B Ha'IaJIe pa3BIITIIH TarapCKoii
KYJIbTypbl 1I3 TaemHbIX JIeCOB Ha CTenHble rrpOCTopbl II CblrpaJIO OCHOBIlYIO
pOJIb B CJIOllieHIIII TamTblKCKon KYJIbTypbl MUHYCIIHCKon KOTJIOBIIHbl. Hpyn-
HeMmaH 3aCJIyra B 060CHOBaHIIU TaemHon JIOKaJIII3aD,1I11 npapOp,IIHbl caMop,nii-
D,eB rrpIIHa,l:\JIemnT B. H. qepHeD,OBY 25.
qTO KacaeTCH rrepeCeJIeHII.eB 113 IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM A311II RJIII yme, KaK MbI
nbITaJIIICb YCTaHOBIITb, 113 BOCTO'IHOn MOHrOJIIIII, TO OHII 6bIJIII, nO-BU,l:\IIMO-
MY, HOCIITeJIHMH MOIUOJIbCKIIX llJIU TIOpKCKIIX H3bIKOB, CKopee ,l:\ame TlOpK-
CKIIX, TaK KaK reHeTU'IeCKUe CBH311 HaCeJIeHIIH MUHYCIIHCKon KOTJIOBIIHbl C
TlOpKCKUMII Hapop,aMII lJ,eHTpaJIbHOn A3UII, rrbImHO pa3BIIBmueCH B srroxy
cpeilHeBeKOBbH, MOryT OblTb IICTOJIKOBaHbl KaK BblpameHIIe Yllie IIMeBmeii
MeCTO, paHee YCTaHOBIIBmenCH Tpap,IID,III1. ITlIcbMeHHble naMHTHIIKII YBOP,HT
IICTOplIIO TlOpKCKIIX H3bIKOB TOJIbKO ,l:\0 VII B. H. a., HO HeCOMHeHHO, 'ITO OHII
qJlIKCIIPylOT JIllmb ee nOCJIe,l:\Hlln OTpe30K. TaKOH rro,l:\xo,l:\ BblpamaeTCH B mII-
pOKO pacnpOCTpaHUBmenCH II B 06r::qeM nO'ITII Bce06 eM TeHp,eHD,IIII C'IIITaTb
TlOpKaMII rYHHOB, 06 aTOM CBIIp,eTeJIbCTByeT paCXOllip:eHlle Memp,y OTp,eJIbHbl-
:MII TlOpKCKUMII H3bIKaMU, rroTpe60BaBmee, nO-Bllp,UMOMY, 60JIbme BpeMeHII,
364
'IeM nOJITOpbl TblCH'III JIeT, 06 aTOM me rOBopHT p,IIaJIeKTHbIe pa3JIH'IlIH Mem-
P,Y OTp,eJIbHbIMII nal\IHTHMKaMII VIII B. B pa3Hblx paMoHax II BblcoKIIn ypoBeHb
rpaMMaTII'IeCKOn pa3pa60TaHHocTII ,l:\peBHeTlOpKcKoro H3bIKa, BbIpa3uBmlIncH
XOTH 6bI B ,l:\peBHeTIopKcKOM CTIIXOCJIOmeHIIII 26. IToaTOMY II MomHO npe,l:\no-
JIaraTb, 'ITO KaKlle-TO HapOp,b1 l{eHTpaJIbHOn A3IIII rOBOpIIJIII Ha TIOpKCKIIX
H3bIKax er::qe 'B cepe;l.IlHe I TLICH'TeJIeTliH )l:0 H. a., II BII)..(eTb B HUX npe,l:\KOB
MOHrOJIOIl)..(HbIX, u.eHTpaJIbHOa3l1aTcKflx no CBoeMY aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKoMY TIlUY
nepeCeJIeIID,eB B MIIHYCUHCKYID KOTJIOBlIHY BpeMeHII TamTbIKcKon KYJIbTypbI.
1 Ten.fwyxoe C. A. OrrbIT KJIaCCIIIfJHKa! HH p;peBHIIx IeTaJ1J1lI'IeCRIIX KYJ1bTYP MIIHY-
CIIIICKoro H:paH II MaTepIIaJ1bI rro 9THorpa1fJHII. 31., 1929. T. 4, BbIll. 2.
2 Kuce.f[ee C. B. ApeBHHH IICTOpIIH IOmHoii CII6IIpH II MaTepIIaJIbI H HCCJIeAOBaHHH IIO
apXe0J10rIIII CCCP. M., 1949. N! 9. PacIllHpeHHoe rrepeH3;:(aHIIe: Kuce.ltee C. B.
ApeBHHH IICTOpIIH 1OJ-I>Hoii CI16IIpII. M.; 31., 1951.
3 Kb£8J£aCOe JI. P. ApeBHeiimee CBHp;eTeJ1bCTBO 06 OJIeHeBOp;CTBe II COB. 3THorpa1fJIIH.
'1952. N! 2: On :JIce, CblpCRI1ii 'laa-TaC II COB. apXe0J10rIIH. M.. 1955. T. 24.
Kbl8.1tacoe JI. P. TaIIITbIKCKaH 3rroxa B HCTOpIIH XaKaccRo-MHHYCHHCROH ROTJ10BHHl>I.
M., 1960.
5 JIuncKuii A. H. K Bonpocy 06 HCh0J1b30BaHIIII 3THorpalfJHH AJIH HHTeplIpeTa:L\HH ap-
Xe0J10rII'leCKIIX MaTepIIaJ10B II COB. 3THorpa1fJHH. 1966. N2 1.
6 'YRalli.Y, Harrp.: JIunClwii A. H. HOBbIII BlIP; KaMeHHoro II3BaHHI1H H3 IOmHoii CII6I1-
pH II KpaT. co06m;. HH-Ta 3THorpalfJHII All CCCP. 1955. BbIlI, 59; On :JiCe. lIeKoTopbIe
BorrpOCbI TaIIITblKCKOii KYJ1bTypbl (II B. p;o H. 3.- IV B. H. 3.) B CBeTe CIIOIIpCROlI
3THorpalfJIIII II PipaeBep;'leCRIIii C60PHIIK. A6aKaH, 1956, N! 1.
/l,e6elf r. W. AHTpOrr0J10rII'leCKOe I1CCJ1ep;OBaHIIe norpe6a.TJ:bHbIX MaCOR TaIllTbIRCKOii
KYJ1bTypbI II PipaT. co06m;. 0 HaY'IHbIX pa60Tax. lIaY'l.-IICCJ1e;:r. IIH-Ta H MY3eH aHTpo-
rr0J10rIIII npII Mf'Y. M., 1941.
R /l,e6elf r. W. IIaJ1eoaHTpOrr0J10rIIH CCCP. M.; 31., 1948 II Tp. HH-Ta 3THOrpalfJIIII All
CCCP. II. C.; T. 4.
, A.f[eKCeee B. I1. MaTepIIaJ1bI no naJIeOaHTpOn0J10rIIII HaCeJ1eHIIH MHHYCI1HCROii ROT-
JIOBIIHbI BpeMeHI1 TaIllTblKcKOii KYJ1bTypbI II PipaT. cooom;. HH-Ta 3THorpalfJIII1 AH
CCCP. 1954. BbIII. 20.
10 A.1eKceee B. I1. IIaJIeoaHTponoJ1orI1H XaKaCIII1 3rrOXI1 meJ1e3a II C6. MY3eH aHTpOIIOJIO-
rIII1 II 3THorpalfJIIII AH CCCP. M.; 31., 1961. T. 20.
11 3a.f[KuHiJ H. r. PipaHIIOJIOrII'leCKIIe MaTepIIaJIbI II3 TaIIITbIKCKIIX II TarapcKIIx rrorpe-
6eHI1ii EOJ1bIllOrO CaJI6bIRcKoro KypraHa II COB. aHTpOrr0J10rIIH. 1959. N2 1.
12 A.lteKCeee B. I1. IIaJIeoaHTpon0J10rIIH J1eCHbIX nJIeMeH CeBepHoro AJITaH II KpaT. co-
06m;. lIH-Ta 3THorpalfJI1II All CCCP. 1954. BbIII. 21.
13 /l,e6elf r. W. Em;e pa3 0 6eJIoRypoH pace B lI,eHTpaJ1bHOlI A3I1I1 II COB. A3IIH. 1931.
KH. 5, 6.
H A.f[eKCeee B. I1. AHTpOnOJIOrII'leCKIIe p;aHHbIe 0 J10KaJIbHbIX pa3JII1'lIIHX TarapcRolI
KYJIbTypbl II IIepB06bITHaH apXe0J10rIIH CH6HpII. JI., 1975. HHYro aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IecKYro
HHTepnpeTa:L\IIro J10KaJ1bHbIX rpyrrrr BH)'TPII TarapcKoro HaCeJ1eHI1H CM.: K03uHlfee A. r.
AHTpOrrOJIOrII'leCKIIH COCTaB 11 rrpoIIcxomp;eHIIe HaCeJ1eHIIH TarapcKoH KYJ1bTYPbI. JI.,
1977.
I IIocJ1eII HHH CBop;Ka: A.lteKCeee B. I1. KpaTRoe II3J10lli.eHIIe rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrI1II TYBbl
B CBH3II C IICTOpII'leCRIIMII BorrpocaMII II AHTporrO-3R0J10rII'leCKIIe IICCJIep;OBaHHH B Ty-
lie. M., 1984. TaM me H 6II6J1IIorpa1fJIIH rrpep;IllecTByrom;IIx ny6JIIIKa:L\IIii.
16 A.lteKCeee B. I1. 1I0BbIe p;aHHbIe 0 eBporreOIIp;Hoii pace B lI,eHTpaJIbHoii A3I1II II EPOH-
30BbIii II meJ1e3HbIH BeR CII6IIpII. HOBOCII6IIpCR, 1974.
11 0 KeTCKIIX TorrOHIIMax CM.: /l,y. b30n A. I1. PieTclme TonOHIIMbI 3arrap;Hoii CII6IIpII II
'Y'leH. 3an. TOM. lIep;. IIH-Ta. TOMCR, 1959. T. 18; OH :JiCe. PieTcKIIII H3bIR. TOMCR, 1968.
o caMop;IIiicKIIX TorrOHIIMax CM.: OH :JiCe. AOpyccKoe HaCeJ1eHIIe 3arralIHoii CII6I1pII II
BorrpocbI IICTOpIlII CII6I1pII II AaJIbHerO BOCTOKa. lIoBOCI16I1pcK, '1961. 0 IIHp;oeBponeii-
CKIIX TonOmurax C:\r.: /l,Y.f[b30H A, I1. ApeBHIIe TorrOHlDIbI IOmHoll CI16I1pIl IIHp;oeBpo-
rrelICKoro rrpoIIcXOmp;eHI1H. M., 1964; Oli :JiCe. rIlp;pOHIIMII'leCKIIii apeaJ1 - MaH B IOm-
HOH CII6IIpII II TorrOHHMIIKa BOCTORa. M., 1962.
I" MO.ltbHap 9. IIp06JIeMbI 9THOreHe3a 11 p;peBHeii IICTOpIIII BeHrepcRoro Hapop;a II Studia
Ilistorica Academiae Scientiarum lIungaricae. Budapest, 1955. N 13.
19 PipoMe 0606m;aIOm;eH pa60TbI JI. P. PibI3J1aCOBa, CM. Ta!mm: Kb£3.wcoe JI. P. K Bon-
pocy 06 3THoreHe3e xaRaCOB II 'Y'leH. 3an. XaKac. lIaY'l.-I1ccJIep;. HH-Ta H3bIKa, JIIITe-
paTypbI II IICTOpHH. A6aKaH, 1959. BbIlI. 7.
2 /l, O.ltZUX B. O. 06pHp;oBbIe coopymeHI1H HraHacaH II 3H:L\eB II Kpa T. co06m;. HH-Ta 3T-
HorpalfJIIH All CCCP. 1951. Bl>Ill. 13.
I
,
;
365
31 HUKO.ltaee P. B. HeROTOpbIe BOlIpOCbI'ReTcKoro 3THOreHe3a H P;IIHJIHHCKaH IIp06JIeMa II'
KpaCHOHpCRI1H KpaH: (MaTepI1aJIbI no reorpalfJI1H H HCTOpHH). RpacHoHpcR, 1962.
22 TJ .lteHoea H. JI. IIaMHTHHRH nepeXOp;Horo RapaCYR-TarapCRoro BpmIeHII B MI1HYCHH-
CKOH IWTJIOBHHe II COB. apXeOJIOrHH. 1963. N£ 3; OHa :JICe. IIPOIIcxollip;eHIIe H paHHHH
HCTOpHH nJIeMeH TarapcKoil RYJIbTypbI. M., 1967. 060cHoBaHIIIO CBH3elI TarapcRoH
RYJIbTypbI C CIIHXpOHHbIMI1 cpep;Hea3HaTCRHMI1 KYJIbTypaMI1 nocBHm;eHa cne:L\IIaJIbHaH'
pa6OTa: TJ .lteHOea H. JI. 0 CBH3HX nJIeMeH IOmHoH CII6IIpH H Cpep;HeH A3IIII B CRHIfJ-
CKYJO 3noxy II AORJIap;bJ II co06m;eHI1H apxeOJIOrOB CCCP Ha VII Memp;YHapOp;HOl\I
KOHrpecce P;OIICTOpHROB II npoToIIcTOpHKOB. M., 1966.
23 A.lteKCeee B. I1. IIaJIeOaHTpOllOJIOrHH AJITae-CaHHCKoro HaropbH 3nOXI1 HeOJII1Ta H
6POH3bI II AHTpOnOJIOrII'leCKIIH C60PHIIR, III. M., 1961. (Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpalfJHII AH
CCCP. II. C.; T. 71).
2. COBnap;eHIIe CJIOBapH IWTCKoro II TII6eTO-OIIpMaHCKIIX H3bIKOB 'laCTII'lHO nORa3aJII1:
Ramstedt G. Uber der Ursprung der sogenannten Jenissei - Ostjaken II Journal de
la societe finno-ougrienne. 1907. T. 24; Donner K. Beitrage zur [<rage nach der Ursp-
rung der Jenissei-Ostjaken II Ibid. 1920. T. XXXVII; Idem. Dber die Jenissei-Ostjaken
und ihre Sprachlehre II Ibid. 1930. T. XLIV. 0 IOlliHOM npOHCXOlli.p;eHIII1 KeTOB rro
MaTepHaJIaM 3THorpalfJI1II CM.: BaiiHlUTeiiH C. H. Pi BOIIPOCY 06 9THOrmIe3e ReTOB II
RpaT. co06m;. MH-Ta 3THorpalfJHII All CCCP. 1951. BbIII. 13; A.f[eKCeeHKo E. A. ReTbI:
IIcTOPIIRo-9THorpaIfJII'IecKIIe O'lepKII. 31., 1967.
25 CM. oc06eHHO noc"e;J,HIIe 0606m;aIOm;IIe pa60Tl>I: TJepHelfoe B. H. Pi Borrpocy 0 l'.IeCTe II
BpeJlIeHH 1fJ0pMIIpoBaHIIH ypaJIbCIWii 06m;HOCTII II Congressus Internationalis Fenno-
UgristarIIffi. Budapest, 1963; OH :JICe. Pi Bonpocy 0 CJIOmeHIII1 ypaJIbCKOrO HeO.T[IITa II
IIcTopI1H, apXeOJIOrIIH II 3THorpalfJIIH Cpep;HelI A3I1H. M., 1968; Oli :JICe. Orrl>IT BbIp;e-
JIeHIIH 9THO-KYJIbTypHbIX apeaJIOB B CeBepo-BoCTO'lHOii EBporre 11 CeBepHoii A3HI2I II
IIpOIIcxomp;eHIIe a60pIIreHoB CII6IIpii 11 IIX H3bIKOB. TOMCR, 1969.
26 CTe6.1teea H. B. II033I1H TJOpKOB VI-VIII BB. M., 1965.
ITPOMCXOlliAEHME XARACCROfO HAPO,l];A
B CBET AAHHbIX AHTPOITOJIOfMM
PE3YJIbTATbI AHTPOIIOJIOrHqECKOrO HCCJIE)J;OBAHIIH
COBPEMEHHOrO HACEJIEHHH
06mIIpHbln MaTepIIaJI no aHTpOrrOJIOrlIII cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH XaKacCKoii
aBToHoMHon 06JIaCTU 6bIJI c06paH A. M. .Hpxo B 1925 r. t OH OXBaTblBaeT Bce
::JTHII'IeCKlIe rpyrrnbl xaKaCOB.
ITepBblM STarrOM pacoBon ,lJ,HarHOCTIIKII rpyrrnbl HBJIHeTCH 06bI'IHO orrpep,e-
JIeHlle ee MeCTa B pH,l:\y 60JIbmIIX pac 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa - MOHrOJIOllp,HOn, eBpo-
neolIp,Hon II Herpoup,Hon. Cal\IO c060n pa3YMeeTCH. '1TO rro OTHomeHUIO R
TeppIlTopUIl COBeTCKoro COlO3a pe'Ib M01H:eT Up,TII TOJIbKO 0 ,l:\BYX nepBblX.
A. M. .Hpxo OTHec xaKaCOB K 60JIbmOn MOHrOJIOII,l:\IIOn pace. BbIcTynaH npo-
TIlB KOHD,errD,1I11 r. E. rpYMM-rpmlll\IaMJIO 2 0 KYJIbTYPTperepCKon pOJIII D;JIIIH-
HOrOJIOBOn eBponeOIlD;Hon paCbI B IICTOpUII QeHTpaJIbHOn A31111, OH 06'bHCHIIJI
iPaKT npll6JIIIllieHIlH xaKaCOB no OTp,eJIbHbIM rrpll3HaKaM K eBponemrp,HblM
rpynnaM, II B 'IaCTHOCTII iPaKT nOCBeTJIeHUH nllrMeHTaD,lIl1, no cpaBHeHUIO C
KJIaCClI'IeCKIIMII 1\I0HrOJIOII,l:\aMII He3aBUCUl\IbIl\I OT eBponeOIlp,Hon nplIMeCII npo-
eCCOM napaJIJIeJIbHOn Il3MeH'IliBOCTII. Op:HaKO B p,aJIbHeMmel\I KOlID,enD,IUI
A. M. .Hpxo BCTpeTIIJIa B03pamelIlIH, OCHOBaHHbIe Ha 60JIee nOJIHOM IICnOJIb-
30BaHIlII naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrll'leCKIIX p,aHHbIX II UHOM nOHIIMaHUII reHe3lIca H
B3aIlMOOTHomeHIlH TIIlIOB BHYTPU MOHrOJIOU,l:\HOn paCbl 3 . Bonpoc, CJIep,OBa-
u
TeJIbHO, Hymp:aeTCH B p,aJILHeUmeM oocylli,l:\eHIIII.
BblP,BIIHYB npIIHQurr TaKCOHOMII'IeCIWn HepaBHOD,eHHOCTII paCOBblX npll-
3HaKOB p,JIH Bblp,eJIeHIIH paCOBblX KaTeroplln, T. e. HeO,l:\IIHaKOBOro ux 3HR'Ie-
HIIH ,l:\JIH D,eJIell pacoBon KJIaCcIIiPIIKa lIlI, A. M. .Hpxo npe,l:\JIOllillJI IICrrOJIh30-
BaTb BoceMb npII3HaKoB ,l:\JIH OTp,eJIeHUH eBpOneOIl,l:\HbIx nonYJIHD,lIn OT MOH-
366
rOJIOIIp,HbIX: nIIrMeHTa 1I1O KomII, BOJIOC II rJIa3, iPOPMY BOJIOe rOJIOBbI,
pa3BIITIIe TpeTII'IHOrO BOJIOCHHoro nOKpOBa Ha JIII e, T. e. 60pOp,bI II yCOB, BbI-
CTyrraHlIe CKYJI, IIJIII, HHblMII CJIOBaMII, roplI30HTaJIbHYlO npoiPIIJIlIpOBRY JIII a,
II oc06eHHOCTH CTpoeHIIH MHrKIIX 'IaCTen rJIa3 - HaJIII'IlIe snlIKaHryca II
Clwap,KII BepXHero BeKa. Ha OCHOBaHIIII 06mlIpHblX IICCJIep,OBaHIIn B BOCTO'I-
Hon CH6IIpll r. <1>. Ae6eD, p,onOJIHlW ::JTOT cnlICOK er::qe TpeMH np1I3HaKaMII:
BblCOTOH rrepeHOCbH, rrOrrepe'lHblM rrpoiPIIJIeM crrllHKII Hoca II pOCTOM 6po-
Ben . O;J;HaKo p,Ba nOCJIep,HUX npII3HaKa OTCYTCTBYIDT B nporpaMMe A. M. .H pXO.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, ,l:\JIH p,lIarHOCTlIKII xaKaCCKUX rpynrr B rrpe,l:\eJIax MOH-
rOJIOII,l:\HOrO H eBpOneOII,l:\HOro paCOBbIX CTBOJIOB MorYT 6bITb UCrrOJIb30BaHbl
,l.I.eBHTb npII3HaKOB. QT06bl 1136emaTb BJIIIHHIIH cy6'beKTIIBHOCTII OD,eHKu OT-
,l.I.eJII:.HLIX npII3HaKoB pa3HblMII IICCJIe,l:\OBaTeJIHMU, p,JIH cpaBHIITeJIbHOrO corro-
CTaBJIeHIIH Bbl6paHbl rpyrrnbl, HCCJIe,l:\oBaHHble caMIIM A. M. .HpXO: TYBUHD,bl
II aJITanD,bI B KR'IeCTBe TlInll'lHblX npep,CTaBIITeJIen MOHrOJIOllp,HOll paCbl II
TypKMeHbl-IIoMYTbl Xope3Ma, raH,l:\mIIHCKlle TlOpKII A3ep6an,l:\1:KaHa II pYCCKlIe
AJITae-CaHHCKoro HarOpI:.H 5 B Ka'leCTBe npep,CTaBIITeJIen eBponeOIl,l:\HbIX
rpynrr.
*
t
flUZJ.teliTau;Ufi. OKpaCRa KOllill, orrpe,l:\eJIHel\IaH Ha BHYTpeHHen rrOBepXHO-
CTII rrJIe'la, He iPUKcupOBaJIaCI:. A. M. .Hpxo rrpH pa60Te B Xope3Me II A3ep-
Oan,l:\maHe, rrOSTOMY B Ka'leCTBe cpaBHIITeJIhHLIX MorYT 6b1TI:. IICrrOJIb30BaHbl
TOJIbKO MaTeplIaJIbl no aJITaHD,aM, TYBIIHD,aM II PYCCKIIM. Hllme npHBo,l:\HTCJ1
cpep,Hlle 6aJIJIbl II,BeTa Komll BO Bcex STIIX rpyrrnax B cpaBHeHlI1I co BceMll
rpyrrnaMII xaKaCOB. BeJIII'IUHa 6aJIJIa B03paCTaeT no Mepe YBeJIII'IeHIIH IIHTeH-
CIIBHOCTII nlIrMeIITaD,IIII. ITOSTOMY 66JII:.mlle BeJIH'IIIHbl cpe;'J;HUX 6aJIJIOB rOBO-
pHT 0 60JIee TeMHon Kome, MaJIble - 0 60JIee CBeTJIon. HaR B ::JTOM, TaK II B
,l:\pyrlIx CJIY'IaHX npHBe,l:\eHbl ,l:\aHHbIe rro Mym'tIuHaM.
AJITaii:L\bI
TYBHH:L\l>I
RbI3bIJIb:L\bI
Pia'lIIHI!bI
I
1,12(110)
1,84(87)
1,02 (127)
0,96(200)
Caraii:L\bI
PioH6aJIl>I
EeJIbTl>IpbI
PycclUIe
0,99 (100)
1,00 (38)
1,12 (116)
0,21 (266)
MOHrOJIOII,l:\lII:.Ie rpynrrbl, KaK BU,l:\HO, He xapaKTepII3YIOTCH e,l:\UHCTBOM
B D,BeTe KomII: TYBIIH bl OKa3bIBalOTCH 3Ha'tIIITeJIbHO TeMHee aJITanD,eB. C p,py-
ron CToporrbl, II Te II ,l:\pyrue pe3KO OTJIII'IaIOTCH OT pyCCKUX, IIJllelOr::qIlX O'IeHI:.
CBeTJIylO Komy. Cpep,Hue OaJIJIbI n.BeTa KomlI B xaKaCCIDIX rpynnax nO'ITII
Tom,l:\eCTBeHHbl TeM, KOTOpI:.lH Mbl liMe eM y aJITann.eB. TaKHM 06pa30M, no
D,BeTY KomH xaKaCbI C6JIUmalOTCH C TllrrII'IHbIMII MOHrOJIOII,l:\HbIMII rpyrrIIaMII,
pe3KO OTJIII'IaHCb OT pyCCKIIX.
B Ka'IeCTBe BeJIII'IIIHbl, rrOKaabIBalOr::qeH IIHTeHCIIBHOCTb OKpaCKII BOJIOC,
MOlliHO IICnOJIL30BaTI:. npOD,eHTHoe COOTHomeHIIe, OTpamalOr::qee y,l:\eJII:.Hbln BeG
TeMHblX OTTeHKOB BOJIOC B cpaBHIIBaeMbIX rpyrrnax. AaHHbIe 0 HeM B rpynlIe
']'YP MeH -nOMYTOB OTCYTCTByIDT.
AJITaH:L\bI
TYBIIH:L\l>I
PibI3bIJIb:L\bI
Pia'lHH:L\l>I
CaraH:L\DI
98,2 (168)
97,8 (93)
90,9(111)
95,4(196)
88,2 (85)
Roii6aJIbI
EeJIbTbIpbI
PyccRIIe
TropIDI, raHi.\lli.IIHCRIIe
89,5 (38)
88,2(101)
17,5 (241)
96,4(138)
M3 rrpllBe,l:\eHHblx ,l:\aHHblx HBcTByeT, 'lITO npep,CTaBIITeJIII 60JIbmOn eBpo-
neoIIp,Hon pacbl pe3Ko pa3JIH'IalOTCH rro n.BeTY BOJIOC. rpYIIllbl, OTHocHr::qllecH
K IOmHon BeTBH eBporreOII,l:\HOro pacoBoro CTBOJIa, He yCTynalOT B IIHTeHCUB-
HOCTH nlII'MeHTa 1I1I BOJIOC TIInlI'IHblM MOHrOJIOIIp,aM. Ha060poT, pyccKlIe OT-
367
JIII'IalOTCH KaK OT MOHl'OJIOIIp,HbIX, TaK II OT eBpOneOII,l:\HbIX rrOnYJIH 1I:iI IOmHO-
ro npOIICXOmp,eHIIH BrrOJIHe OT'IeTJIIIBO.
ITo ::JTOMY nplI3HaKy Ka'IIIIJD,bl 6JIII3RII R TYBIIH aM II aJITanD,aM. ,[(JIH
OCTaJIbHblX rpynrr xaKaCOB xapaKTepHO HeKOTopoe, XOTH II MaJI03aMeTHoe, no-
HlImeHlIe Y,l:\eJIbHOrO Beca TeMHblX BOJIOC no cpaBHeHlI10 C aJITanD,aMII II TY-
BIIHD,aMII. OHO TeM He MeHee CJIlImKOM He3Ha'IIITeJIbHO, 'tIT06bI 113MeHUTb O'Ie-
BII,l:\HLIH BLIEOp, 0 TOM, 'ITO rro OKpaCKe BOJIOC xaKaCbI He BbIXOp,HT 3a npe,l:\e-
JIbI BapUaD,IIII MOHrOJIOUp,HbIX TunOB.
]J,JIH xapaKTeplICTIIKII D,BeTa rJIa3 eJIeC006pa3HO, TaK me KaK II p,JIH xa-
paKTepuCTIIKII BeTa BOJIOC, BOcnOJIb30BaTbCH rrpOD,eHTHbIM COOTHomeHlIeM,
nOKa3blEalOr::qIIM YAeJIbHbIn Bec rJIa3 TeMHbIX OTTeHKOB:
AJITaH:L\bJ
TYBI1H:L\bI
KbI3bIJIb:L\bI
Pia'lIIH:L\bI
Carall::L\l>I
83,4(188)
80,4(133)
70,4(128)
79,5 (200)
73,6 (106)
Pioll:6aJIl>I
EeJIbTbIpbI
PyccKHe
TYPKMeHbI-HoMYTbI
TropKII ralIp;lliHll:CRHe
87,8(41)
74,6(114)
5,9 (303)
65,1 (106)
13,8 (203)
ITpe,l:\CTaBUTeJIII 60JIbmOn eBporreOIIp,HOH paCbl TaR me HeO,l:\HOpOp,HbI no
::JTOMY rrpII3HaKY, KaK II no D,BeTY BOJIOC. Op,HaKO caMaH TeMHOrJIa3aH II3
npllBJIe'IeHHblX ,l:\JIH cpaBHeHUH rpyrrIl - TypKMeHbl-IIOMYTbl 3aMeTHO YCTyrra-
lOT B STOM OTHomeHUU TYBIIH aM II aJITaIID,aM. TaKIIM 06pa30M, IIHTeHCIIB-
HOCTb nIIrMeHTaD,IIu rJIa3 ropa3p,0 60JIee 'tIeTKO ,l:\IIiPiPepeHD,IIpyeT eBpOrreOII,l:\-
Hble U MOHrOJIOIIJ],HbIe rrorrYJIHD,IIII, 'IeM IIHTeHCIIBHOCTh OKpaCKII BO.TIOe.
Bce xaKaCCKue rpyrrrrbl norrap,alOT no STOMY rrpll3HaKy B rpaHIIl(bI Ba-
pIIaD,UH MOHrOJIOIIAHLIX rpyrrrr. IIpaBp:a, KbI3blJILIJ,bI, Ka'lIlHD,bl, carai'U{bl II
6eJIbTbIpbI YCTyrralOT TyBuHD,aM II aJITanD,aM, a Iwn6aJIbI rrpeBocxop,HT TY-
BIIrr eB II aJITanu.eB B KOHD,eHTpaD,1I11 rJIa3 TeMHbIX OTTeHKOB.
rJJOpJ.ta BO.aOC ZO.aOBbl. ITOCKOJIbKY rrpe06JIa.a;aHue npHMbIx TyrlIx BOJIOC
XapaKTepHO p,JIH Bcex MOHrOJIOllp,HbIX rpynn CeBepHOH A3UII, npOD,eHTHoe co-
oTIIomeHIIe, oTpamalOr::qee y,l:\eJIhHbIn Bec IIH,l:\IIBIIP,yYMOB C BOJIOCaMU SToro
TlIna B rpynne, IVIOmeT 6blTb UCrrOJIb30BaHO p,JIH aHaJIII3a B TaKon me :l>Iepe,
KaK II Cpe,l:\HIIH 6aJIJI cpOpMbl BOJIOC, ,lIalOr::qun xapaKTepucTIIKy rrorrYJIHD,IIII rro
::JTOMY npu3HaKY B eJIOM. 8TO COOTHomeHlle pacrrpe.a;eJIHeTCH CJIep,ylOr::qllllI 06-
pa30M (onpep,eJIeHlle iPOpMLl BOJIOC B rpynne TypKMeHoB-lIOMYTOB A. M. .Hpxo
He rrpOlI3BO,l:\UJIOCh):
AJIT aH:L\l>I
TYBIIH:L\bI
PiI>I3bIJIbI{l>I
Pia'lHH:L\bI
TIOpKH raup;»mll:cKI1e
75,8 (178)
95,4(65)
59.2 (120)
56,9 (202)
2,1(96)
Caraii:L\bI
PioH6aJIl>I
EeJIbTl>Ipl>I
PycCRI1e
51,0 (102)
58,5(41)
,56,7 (63)
3,4(262)
HaK BIIJJ:HO 113 rrpIIBe,l:\eHHblX ,lIaHHbIX, eBporreOII,l:\Hble rpynnbI pe3KO OTJIII-
'IalOTCH OT MOHrOJIOII,l:\HbIX no iPopMe BOJIOC. Cy6'beKTbl C npHMblMII TyrlIMII
BOJIOCaMII BCTpe'IaIOTCH B eBporreOllp,HblX rrorrYJIH IIHX B e,l:\UHII'IHLIX CJIy'tIaHX,
Torp,a KaK B MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX rpyrrnax OHII COCTaBJIHIOT rrpe06JIap,alOr::qee 60JIb-
mUHCTBO. Bce xaKaCCKIIe rpyrrrrbI OTJIlI'IalOTCH OT TYBIlHD,eB II aJITaH eB
MeHbmen KOH:qeHTpaI(UeH npHMbIX Tyrllx BOJIOC. Ho rrOCJIep,Hlle TaKme He 06-
pa3YlOT O,l:\Hopop,Horo MaCCIIBa II BrrOJIHe orrpe.a:eJIeHHO pa3JIU'IaIOTCH. MacmTao
pa3JIII'IUn Mem,l:\y TYBIIHD,aMII U aJITaiIu,aMII p,ame 60JIbme, 'IeM Memp:y aJI-
Tan aMII II xaKaCCKIIMU rpyrrrraMII. TaKIIM 06pa30M, XOTH xaKaCbl II xapaK-
Tepll3YlOTCH 113BeCTHbIMII OTJIII'tIHHMII OT aJITanl(eB II TYBIIH eB B KOHD,eHTpa-
HII BOJIOC Tllrrll'IHOn ,l:\JIH cII6upCKIIX MOHrOJIOIIJJ:OB iPOPMbl, a6COJIIOTHaH Be-
368
JIII'IIIHa pa3HIID,bl CJIlImKOM He3Ha'IlITeJIbHa, 'IT06bI Cp,eJIaTb BbIBOp, 0 HaJIlI'IUII
y HIIX eBporreOIIp,Hon nplIMeCII. O,l:\HaKO npII oOHapymeHIIII aHaJIOrII'lHbIX
C)J,BlIrOB no p,pyrllM rrplI3HaKaM Bonpoc nOTpe6yeT cne UaJIbHOrO paCCMOTpe-
HIIH.
Hllme npIIBOp,IITCH pacrrpe,l:\eJIeHlIe Cpe,l:\HerO 6aJIJIa iPOpMbl BOJIOC B pac-
CMaTpIIBaeMblX rpynrrax. IIpHMLIe BOJIOCbI, KaK TyrlIe, TaK II MHrKue, 0603Ha-
'IaIOTCH B aHTpOrrOJIOrU'IeCKOn MeTO,l:\IIKe 6aJIJIOM 1, mllpOKOBOJIHIICTble-
6aJIJIOM 2, y3KOBOJIHIICTbIe - 6aJIJIOM 3 II Kyp'IaBbIe - 6aJIJIOM 4. TaKIIM 06-
pa30M, 'IeM MeHbme BeJIII'IIIHa Cpe,l:\Hero oaJIJIa, TeM 60JIbme KOHD,eHTpa UH
I!Hp,IIBIlp,yYMOB C rrpHMblMII BOJIOCaMII U Ha060poT.
Bapua IIII cpep,Hero 6aJIJIa iPOpMbl BOJIOC He nOJIHOCTbIO COOTBeTCTBYIOT
CTerreHII KOHQeHTpaQlI1I rrpHMbIX TyrlIx BOJIOC. TaK, 3aMeTHO pa3JIlPlaHCL rro
BeJIll'IUHe npOD,eHTa npHMblX TyrlIX BOJIOC, aJITanD,bl II Ka'IIIHD,bl, TYBUHD,bI
H Kon6aJIbI IIMelOT O).J;IIHaKOBbIn cpep,HIIII 6aJIJI, rrOJIY'lalOr::qIIIICH 3a C'IeT ypaB-
HIIBaHIIH B 6aJIJIOBOM xapaKTepUCTIIKe npHMblX Tyrux II npHMbIX MHrKIIX BO-
JIoe. Pe3Klle pa3JIII'IIIH B CTerreHII meCTKOCTII rrpHMblX BOJIOC Mem.a:y pyCCKII-
MIl II MOHrOJIOllp,HbIMII rpynrraMIT CTllpaIOTCH, XOTH II He OKOHicraTeJIbHO, IIpll
cpaBHeHlI1I no Cpe,l:\I1eMY 6aJIJIY. Bce me II rrplI STOM npIIeMe corrOCTan.rreIIIIH
Bce xaKaCCKfW rpYIIITbI, KpOMe caranD,eB, C6JIIImalOTCH C aJITaIID,aMII II TYBIIH-
QaMII. CaralIUbl 3aHIIMalOT MeCTo, rrpoMemYTo'IHoe Memp,y OCTaJIbHbIMII xa-
KaCCKUMU rpyrrrraMII II PYCCKIIMII.
Pa3euTue TpeTU'uwzo eO.fWCfll-WZO n01'i,poea 1-La .!lulfe. Pa3BIITlle TpeTII'IrrO-
ro BOJIOCHHOro rroKpoBa Ha JIuu;e, T. e. BOJIOCJIHOrO rroKpoBa, pa3BIIBalO ero-
CH rrplI HacTyrrJIeHIIII nOJIOBOn 3peJIOCTIl, orrpeD.eJIHeTCH IIHTeHCIIBHOCTblO po-
CTa 60POD,bl. OHa iPIIKcupyeTcH rrHTblO 6aJIJIaMU, B03pacTaHlle KOTOpbIX OT-
pamaeT B03pacTaHIIe IIHTeHCIIBHOCTlI pOCTa.
AJlTaHI'\l>I 1,42 (158) Pioi'r6aJIl>I
TYBI1H:L\bI 1,17(101) BeJIbTblpl>I
Pil>I3bIJIb:L\bI 1,41 (104) PycCKIJe
Ka'lHH:L\bI 1,36 (154) TypRMeHbI-IIoMYTbI
Caraii::L\bI 1,59 (73) TIOpKI1 raHp;lliIIHclme
AJITaH:L\l>I
TYBHHI'\l>I
Pil>I3l>IJIb:L\l>I
Ra'lHHI'\l>I
TlOpIDI raHp;lliIIii:cRIIe
1,06 (178)
1,00 (65)
1,08 (120)
1,06 (202)
1,81 (96)
CaraH:L\bI
KOH6aJIbI
BeJIbTblpbI
PycCKI1e
1,12(102)
1,00(41)
1,06(63)
1,15 (262)
1,61 (28)
1,43 (98)
2,91 (225)
3,38 (79)
3,38(198)
-
Bce paccMaTpllBaeMble rpyrrrrbl 06pa3YlOT nOCJIe,l:\OBaTeJIbHbln pH,l:\ OT TY-
BIIHD,eB p,o raH,l:\mlInCKlIx TlOpKOB. rpaHIID,a Memp,y MUHUI\IaJIbHblMII II MaKCU-
MaJIbHbIMII BeJIII'IUHaMII SToro pHp,a npoxop,IIT BnOJIHe OT'IeTJIUBO II cOBrra;:J:a-
eT C rpaHIID,en 60JIbmllX pacoBbIx KaTeroplIn. Bce xaKaCCKIle rpYIIIlbl IIMeIOT
rrpU6JIII311TeJIbHO TY JIm BeJIlI'IlIHY cpe.a:Hero 6aJIJIa pOCTa 60POp,bl, 'ITO II aJI-
TanD,bl. CaranD,bl II KOM6aJIbl HeCI\OJIbKO rrpll6JIlImalOTCH K npe,l:\CTaBIITe:rJIM
eBporreOllp,Hon paCbI, oc06eHHO B cpaBHeHIIU C TYBUHQaMU. O,l:\HaKO BeJIU'III-
na pa3JIII'IHII MeHLme, 'IeM MeJIi,l:\y TypKMeHaMII-IIOMYTaMII 11 raHp,mIlMCKIIMII
TlOpI\aMU, T. e. MerKp,y rpyrrrraMII, rrpIlHaD;JIemar::qUMII K e,l:\IIHOMY paCOBOMY
Turry - IOlliHon BeTBll eBpOrreOlID.IIOIl paCbI. TaKIIM 06pa30M, HeKOTopoe YCII-
JIeHlle pOCTa 60pO,l:\bl y xaKaCOB rro cpaBHeHlI10 C TyBIIHD,aMII, TaK me KaK II
C,l:\BIIrII 113MeH'IIIBOCTII OT,l:\eJIbHbIX nplI3HaKOB B HeKOTopblX rrpe,l:\blp,yr::quX CJIY-
'IaHX, He IOmeT 6e30rOBopO'1H0 TpaKToBaTbCH B KR'IeCTBe nOKa3aTeJIH eBpo-
neOIl):(Hon npIIMeCII.
369
1
-
.
rOpU30HTa'!/'bl-taJl npofjJU'!/'Up06fi,a '!/'ulfa. B03paCTaHlIe Cpep,HerO 6aJIJIa ro-
p1I30HTam,Hon rrpoiPUJIllpOBKII JIIID,a rOBopllT 06 YBeJIII'IeHIIII B rpyrrrre 'IlICJIa
BapllaHTOB C ClIJIbHO npoiPlIJIllpOBaHHbIM B rop1I30HTaJII:.HOn nJIOCKOCTII JIII OM.
AmaH:L\bI
TyBIIH:L\bI
PibI3bIJIb:L\bI
Pia'IIIH:L\bI
CaraH:L\bI
1,11 (145)
1,10 (124)
1,58 (128)
1,67 (206)
1,91 (118)
PiolIOaJIbI
BeJIbTbIpbI
PycCIme
TYfIUvIellbI-HoMYTbI
TIOpKII raHp;lli.IIilcKIIe
1,68(41)
1,87 (105)
2,31 (91)
2,14(107)
2,39 (221)
AJITan bI II TYBIIHIJ;I:.1 pe3Ko OTJIII'IaIOTCH OT OCTaJIbHI:.IX rpynn '1pe3BI:.PIaIJ-
1I0 IIJIOCKIIM JIlID,OM. IT pOTUBOrrOJIOmHbln rrOJIIOC 3aHlIMalOT eBponeOllp,HbIe
rpynnI:.l - pyccIme, TypKMeHbl-IIoMyTbl II raH,lJ,mUIlCKIIe TlOpKIl. ITpoMelliYTO'l-
Hoe rrOJIOmerrIIe xaKaCOB rro STOMY rrplI3HaKy BrrepBble rr03BOJIHeT rrOCTaBIITb
Ha peaJIbHYIO rrO'lBY Borrpoc 0 HaJIII'IUli y HIIX eBporreOIl,lJ,HOII rrplIMeClI. Ha-
JIU'IUe TaKon npliMeCII IIMeHHO BCJIep,CTBlIe HarrpaBJIeHIIH 113MeH'IliBOCTII STO-
ro npII3HaKa He C1\IOr rrOJIHOCTLIO IICKJIlO'IlITb II A. It .H pXO, HecMoTpH Ha 06-
JIWiI xapaKTep CBoen KOHD,enD,UII 6.
M O1iZO.!/,OUOHbW oco6eHHOCTU (3 CTpoeHUU z'!/'a3. HaK 1I3BeCTHO, MOHrOJIO-
IIp,Hble norrYJIHD,IIII OTJIII'IilIOTCH OT eBporreoup,HbIX 60JIbmIIM rrpOD,eHTOM cy6'b-
eKTOB C HaJIU'IIIeM srrlIKaHTyca, T. e. CKJIa,lJ,KII BO BHYTpeHHeM yrJIY rJIa3a,
IIpIIKpI:.IBarO en CJIe3HLIIf oyropoK, II CUJIbHbIM pa3BIITfleM CKJIaJ.J:KII BepXHero
HeKa.
Hume CJIep,yeT pacrrpep,eJIeHUe rrpOD,eHTa HaJIII'IlIH ::JrrIIKaHTyca:
AJITall:L\bI
TyBHH:L\bI
RbI3bIJIb:L\bI
Caraii:L\bI
Pia'lHH:L\bI
47,6(193)
47,0(117)
35,7 (115)
32,7 (101)
48,6(183)
Roii6aJlbI
BeJIbTbIpbI
PyccRIIe
TYPKMeHbI-IIOMYTl>I
TIOpRII raH,lJ,lliIIilcKIIe
63,4(41)
29,6(115)
0,4(275)
6,6{106)
0,9(229)
qacToTa HaJIII'IUH srrIIRaHTyca KOJIeOJIeTCH B ,lJ,OBOJIbHO IlIUPOKUX IIpep,e-
JIax. XaKacbl B Cpe,lJ,HeM 6JIII3KU K TYBuHD,aM II aJITanD,aM. BeJIbTI:.Ipbl II ca-
ranD,I:.I OTJIII'IaIOTCH OT HIIX, rrpll6JIIImalOTCH K rrOKa3aTeJIHM eBporreoup,HoIl
pacbI, Iwn6aJII:.I - HaooopoT. Op,HaKo Bce OHII BrrOJIHe OT'IeTJIIIBO ,lJ,lIiPiPepeH-
IJ;UPYIOTCH OT eBpOneoII}.I,HblX rpynrr.
ITpOD,eHT HaJIII'TIIH CKJIaD,KIJ BepxHero BeKa B 06r::qeM rroBTopHeT KapTuHY
.pacnpep,eJIeHIIH aIIIIKaHTyca:
AJn1JDIIbl 97,3 (1 r.3)
TYI'llH:L\l>I 100.0(117)
I\bl3J.IJIJ.:L\bI £1(j,!1 (115)
Ra'!IfHIJ.bI 95.1 ('183)
Caraii:L\bI 87,6 (101)
H oll:6aJIl>I
BeJIbTbIpl>I
PYCCIUIe
TYPKJlIeHbI-HOMYTl>I
TIOpKII raH!l:lliIIHCmIe
92,7 (41)
87,0(115)
20,7 (275)
67,0(106)
32.8 (229)
EBpOrreOII,lJ,HbIe rpyrrnbl, xapaKTepII3YHCI:. p,OBOJIbHO 3Ha'IUTeJII:.HOn BapHa-
,'6eJILHOCTLIO, IIMelOT BnOJIHe orrpep,eJIeHHI:.Ie OTJIII'IIIH OT MOHrOJIOIIp,HI:.IX. Xa-
f\aCbI B oGII eM He OTp,eJIHIOTCH OT TYBUHD,eB II aJITanD,eB. OTJIU'IIIH caranD,eB
11 6eJILTbIpOB OT OCTaJIhHbIX xaKaCCKIIX rpyrrrr He3Ha'lUTeJILHbI II HaMHoro,
MeHhllIe pa3JIII'IlIn, CYII eCTBYIO UX Mem,lIy PYCCKIIMII II raHp,munCKIIMlI TlOp-
'KaMU, C op,Hon CTOpOJIbI, U TypKMeHaMII-IIOMYTaMII - C ,lJ,pyroII. BaplIa:U;IIJI
::JToro npU3HaRa He p,aIOT, CJIe,lJ,OBaTeJIhHO, OCHOBaHIIH ,lJ,JIH cymp,eHuH 0 Ha-
JIU'IlIlI eBporreOII,lJ,Hon IIpUMeCII B COCTaBe xaKaCOB.
HaOmO,lJ,eHUH, nOJIy'leIIHble npu paCCMOTpeHuII rrpOD,eHTa HaJIII'IIIH CKJIap,-
.'KH BepXHero HeKa, MoryT 6b1TI:. ,lJ,orrOJIHeHbl onpeD:eJIeHIIeM CTerreHII ee pa3-
370
BIITIIH. OHa iPUKclIpyeTcH BO BHYTpeHHeM, Cpe,l:\HeM II BlIemHeM OTp,eJIaX 6aJI-
JIaMII. Ha'iHeM aHaJIU3' C paCCMOTpeHIIH cpeJJ;Hero 6aJIJIa pa3BIITIIH CKJIap,KII Ha
BHYTpeHHen CTopOHe BeKa:
Am a:ii::L\l>I
TYBIIH:L\l>I
PibI3bIJIb:L\l>I
Ra'lHH:L\bI
CaraHI'\l>I
1,76(198)
1,57 (117)
1,18(115)
1,40 (183)
0,79(101)
HOH6aJIl>I
BeJIbTl>Ipl>I
PycCRI1e
TypRMe.iIbI-HoMYTl>I
TroPKII raHp;mIIHcRHe
0.88(41)
0,47 (115)
0.08 (275)
0,48 (106)
0,23(229)
B OTJIII'IlIe OT pacrrpe,l:\eJIeHIIH Bcex rrpep,bI,l:\yI::qllx napaMeTpoB MbI KOH-
cTaTllpyeM 3}:{eCb 3aXOmp,eI!He KpanHllx BaplIaHToB MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX II eBporreo.
II,l:\HbIX rpyrrrr p,pyr 3a p,pyra. XaKacbl, TaK me KaK II rro Cpe,l:\HeMY 6aJIJIY
ropU30HTaJIbHOM rrpoiPIIJIlIpOBKII JIuD,a, 3aHUMalOT HBHO rrpoMemYTo'IHoe rrOJIO-
meHlle Memp,y KpanHuMII 'IJIeHaMII pHp,a - aJITanD,aMII II TYBuHD,aMII, C O,l:\HOn
CTOpOHbl, II PYCCKUMU II raH,l:\mllnCHIIMII TlOpRaMII - C ,l:\pyron. EeJIbTblpbl xa-
paKTepll3YlOTCH ,l:\ame MeHbmen BeJIII'IUHOn cpep,Hero 6aJIJIa, 'TeM TypKMe-
Hbl-IIOMYTbI. ITpaB,l:\a, pa3JIII'IUH HII'ITOmHbl no a6COJIlOTHOn BeJIII'IIIHe, HO
caMbln iPaKT TaKoro pacrrpe,l:\eJIeHIIH YKa3bIBaeT Ha HaJIlI'IUe eBpOrreOII,l:\Hon
rrpllMecII XOTH 6bI B COCTaBe caranD,eB. B TO me BpeMH rro pa3BIITlllO CKJIap,-
KII Ha BHYTpeHHen CTopOHe BeKa Ka'lUHD,bl MaJIO OTJIII'IalOTCH OT TYBUH-
D,eB.
Cpep,Hlln 6aJIJI pa3BIITIIH CKJIap,KII BepXHero BeKa B ee cpe,l:\HeM OTp,eJIe
pacnpep,emreTCH CJIe,l:\YIOr::qUM 06pa30M:
AJIT aH:L\l>I
TYBHHD;l>I
PibI3bIJIb:L\bI
Ka'lHHI!l>I
CaraRI{l>I
1,87 (198)
2,06(117)
1,91 (115)
1,75 (183)
1,35(101)
Roi16aJIbI
BeJIbTbIpl>I
PycCKI1e
TypHMeHbI-IIoMYTl>I
TropRII raHp;mHHcKIIe
1,51 (41)
1,05(115)
0,27 (275)
0.74(106)
0,36 (229)
XOTH OOJIbmaH 6JIU30CTb xaKaCCKUX rpyrrrr C aJITanD,aMII II TYBuHD,aMu It
cpaBHeHulI co CTerreHblO IIX Cxop,cTBa c I1pe.a:cTaBIITeJIHMU eBponeoHp,Hon
pacbl npep,CTaBJIHeTCH cOBepmeHHo HecoMHeHHon, CaranD,bI II 6eJIbTbIpbl onHTb
rrpll6JIumalOTCH K eBporreOllp,HbIM norrYJIHD,uHM II 3aHUMalOT rrpll6JIII3UTeJIbHO
rrpoMemYTo'lHoe rrOJIOmeHIIe MemD,Y KpalIHuMII 'IJIeHaMU pHp,a.
AHaJIOrII'IHbIM 06pa30M pacnpep,eJIHIOTCH BaplIaD,IIII cpep,Hero 6aJIJIa pa3-
BIITUH CKJIa,l:\KII Ha BHemHen cTopoHe BeKa:
A.'lTaH:L\bI
TYBHH:L\bI
PibI3bIJIb:L\l>I
HH'lIIHI!bI
Carai1:L\bI
1.84 ('198
2,10(117)
1,85( 115)
1,65( 183)
1,29 (101)
PioiiGaal>I
Be.'lI.Tblpl>I
Py('cKIJe
TYl'I,MeIJIJ-IIoMYTbI
TIOpI;n rHIIp;lliIIlIcRHe
1,32(41)
1,02( 115)
0.25(275)
0,75(106)
0,36(229)
MbI BII,l:\IIM, 'ITO Kon6aJIbl He OTJIII'IaIOTCH OT caranD,en If 6eJIbTblpOB. 3a-
HIIMalOr::qIIX rrpOMemYTO'lHoe rrOJIOmeHIIe. Ha'IUHD,bI II KbI3bIJIbD,bl 6JIU3KII K
aJITaMD,aM U TYBIIHD,aM. EBporreOlI.a:HbIe rpynrrbI 3aHUMalOT oc060e MeCTO II
BrrOJIHe orrpep,eJIeHHLIM 06pa30M p,IIiPiPepeHII.IIpYIOTCH OT OCTaJIbHbIX. TaKfIM
06pa30M, CTerreHh pa3BIITIIH CKJIa,l:\KII BepXHero seKa, TaK me KaK II pacnpe-
p,eJIeIIIIe Cpe,l:\Hero 6aJIJIa ropU30HTaJIbHOn rrpoiPUJIIIpOBKII JIII a, p,aeT MaTe-,
puaJI p,JIH 06cymp,eHIIH Bonpoca 0 HaJIII'IIIlIlIJIII OTCYTCTBIIII eBponeOIIp,Hon,
rrpIIMeCII Y xaKaCOB.
371
Bblcora nepeHOCbJl. BblCOTa nepeHOCbH orrpeJ(eJIHeTCH 6aJIJIaMII. B03paCTa-
Rile BeJIlI'IIIHbl cpeJ(Hero 6aJIJIa YKa3bIBaeT Ha rrOBblmeHlIe BbICOTbl rrepe-
HOCLn. BapUaD,IIU cpe.a:Hero 6aJIJIa B IIHTepeCYIOr::qux Hac rpyrrnax BIIJ(HbI 113
CJIeAYIOr::qero pacrrpeJ(eJIeHIIH:
AJi1'aR:L\l>I
TYRHH:L\bI
Rl>I3bIJIb:L\bI
Pia1.J:IIH:L\bI
CaraRI'\LI
1,44(149)
1,19(120)
1.63 (128)
1,83 (207)
1,75 (105)
PioII6aJIl>I
BeJIbTl>Ipl>I
PyccKHe
'l'YPRMeHl>I-HOMYTl>I
TropKII raHp;lliHllcKIIe
1,26(41)
1,77 (119)
2,37 (297)
2,17 (107)
2,60 (229)
HOM6aJIbI IIMelOT Hau60JIee rrJIOCKOe nepeHOCI:.e U3 Bcex xaKaCCKIIX rpyrrn
II C6JIIlllialOTCH C TYBIIHD,aMII. )J;ame aJITaMD,bl xapaKTepu3YIoTCH 60JIee BblCO-
KIIM nepeHOCI:.eM, '[eM KOI16aJIhI. )J;pyrue xaKaCCKlle rpyrrrrbl npeBbImalOT aJI-
TanD,en no BeJIII'IIfHe cpeJ(Hero 6aJIJIa Ii 3aHUMalOT rrpoMelliYTo'lHoe nOJIome-
HIIe Memp,y aJITaMD,aMu, TYBuHD,aMu LJ K8ii:oaJIaMII II eBporreollJ(HbIMU norrYJIH-
:U;UHMU. TaKuM 06pa30M, BbICOTa nepeHoChH, TaK me KaK U ropII30HTaJII:.HaH
npOCfHIJIIIpOBKa JIIID,a II pa3BuTIIe clwaJ(KII nepxHero BeKa, HBJIHeTCH TeM nplI-
3HaKoM, Ha KOTOpbIM p,OJImHO 6bITI:. 06par::qeHO BHUMaHue rrpll 06cymp,eHIIII
np06JIeMbI HaJIII'IIIH II y,lIeJILHOrO Beca eBporreoIIAHOIl rrpIIMecu B COCTaBe xa-
KaCOB.
ITpep,bIp,y un 0630p rroKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO KOJIII'IeCTBO npll3HaKoB, no IWTOpblM
xaKaCbI 3aMeTlI0 OTJIII'IaJIIICI:. 6I:.I OT KJIaCCII'IeCKUX npe,lICTaBUTeJIen MOHrOJIO-
IIp,HOM paCbI, HeBeJIIIKO. H IIX '!UCJIY OTHOCHTCH iPopMa BOJIOC rOJIOBbl, roplI-
30HTaJII:.HaH rrpoiPIIJIIlpOBKa JIIID,a, UHTerrCUBIIOCTI:. pa3BuTIIH CKJIarunr BepxHe-
ro BeKa II BLICOTa rrepenoChH. ITo STUM rrpu3HaKaM Bce xaKaCCKue rpyrrnbl
3aTIIIMaIOT rrpoMemYTo'tIHoe nOJIOmeHUe Memp,y B3HTblMII p,JIH cpaBHeHIIH MOH-
rO.TwIIp,HLIMII II eBporreoIIp,HblMU rrorrYJIHD,uHMII. IIo pHp,y J(pyrIIx rrpII3HaKoB
C)JBllrIl B HarrpaBJIeHIIII rrpII6JIumeHIIH K BapllaD,uHM, xapaKTepHbIM J(JIH eB-
poneolIp,HOM pacbI, oonapymllBalOT JlllmL oTJ],eJIbHI:.Ie rpyrrrrbI. TaK, rrOHlImeH-
HbIM npo:u;eIIT HaJIII'!IIH TeMHLIX BOJIOC HMelOT KbI3bIJILD,bI, nOBbIlrreHlle cpep,-
Hero oaJIJIa pOCTa 60pOp,bI xapaKTepHO p,JIH caranD,eB II Kon6aJIOB, rrOHumeHue
npoD,eHTa HaJIII'!UH ::JrruKaHTyca - J(JIH KbI3bIJIbD,eB, caranD,eB II 6eJII:.TblpOB.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, Ka'IIIH:U;I:.l, C op,Hon CTOpOHI:.l, II OCTaJII:.rrbIe xaKaCCKlIe rpyrr-
nbI,- C p,pyron, rro-BIIJ(IIMOMY, xapaKTepu3YlOTCH pa3Hon 113MeH'IIIBOCTblO
TaKCOHOMu'!eCKII BamHI:.IX npu3HaKoB. Borrpoc 3aKJIIo'tIaeTCH B TOM, J(OCTaTO'I-
HO .TIlI neJIIIKI'J Ha6JIIOp,aeMbIe pa3JIU'IlIH, 'tIT06bl Ha IIX OCHOBaHIIlI KOHCTaTII-
pOBaTh HaJIII'!lIe eBponeoup,HOM npUMeCII II C,lJ,eJIaTI:. 3aKJIIO'tleHlle 0 ee pa3HOM
YJ(eJILHOM Bece, HarrpllMep, y Ka'IUHD,eB II caranD,eB.
)J;JIH pemeHUH SToro Borrpoca D,eJIeC006pa3HO CYMMupOBaTI:. rrOKa3aTeJIII rro
OTI eJII:.HbIM npU3HaKaM. C ::JTon eJII:.1O MomHO BOCrrOJIh30BaTbCH nplIeMOM
6aJIJIOBbIX 0603Ha'!errun BeJIII'!UH OT,lIeJII:.HbIX rrpIl3HaKOB. ITo Kam,lJ,OMY npll-
3lIaKY rpynnLI pacnOJIaralOTCH B onpep,eJIeHHOn rrOCJIeJ(OBaTeJII:.HOCTII TaKIIM
06pa30M, '!TOObI MeCTO rpyrrrrbI COOTBeTCTBOBaJIO UHTeHCUBHOCTll HapaCTaHIIH
IIJIU, HaooopOT, YMeHLmeHIIH npU3HaKa rrpu rrepexop,e OT MOnrOJIOllp,HOM paCbI
K eBpOrreOU,lJ,HOM. Hallip,aH rpyrrrra rrOJIy'!aeT COOTBeTCTBYIOr::qun ee rropHJ(KO-
BOMY MeCTY oaJIJI. 3aTeM 6aJIJIOBbIe xapaKTepllCTURII no OTiJ:eJIhHbIM rrpll3Ha-
KaM CYMMUpylOTCH U J(eJIHTCH Ha KOJIII'IeCTBO npU3HaKOB C TeM, 'IT06bl rroJIY-
'!I1TL cpep,HIOIO 6aJIJIOBYlO xapaKTepIlCTURY no BceMy KOMnJIeKCY rrpU3HaKOB.
TaK KaK OaJIJIOBOe onpep,eJIeHUe rpyrrrrI:.I no Kamp,OMY npU3HaKY B03paCTaeT
no Mepe rrepeXO,lJ,a OT BeJIU'!IIH, xapaKTepHbIX ,lJ,JIH MOHrOJIOIIJ(HhIX norrYJIHD,UM,
K BeJIIl'IIIHaM eBporreOllp,HOM paCbl, O'tIeBUJ(HO, 'ITO B03paCTaHue BeJIII'!IIHbl
cpep,HeM 6aJIJIOBOn XapaKTepllCTIIKn rOBoplIT 06 YJ(aJIeHIIII OT MOHrOJIO-
IID;Hon paCbI.
372
HIIllie rrpllBOp,IlTCH pacrrpe)J.eJIeHlle BCeX rpynrr no Ramp,OMY rrpII3HaRY.
IIcKJIlO'Ienlle cp,eJIano p,JIH IJ,BeTa BOJIOe, rrOCROJIbKY OIl, KaR rrORa3bIBaeT cpaB-
HelIHe ranp,llillnCKIIX TlOpKOB C aJITan aMII II TYBllH aMll, He p,lliPiPepeH II-
pyeT IWaCCllQeCRIIX MOHrOJIOllp,OB OT rrpep,CTaBllTeJIen IOlliHon BeTBll eBporre-
OIl,lJ,HOn paCbI, II p,JIH npO eIlTa HaJIllQllH CRJIap,Rll BepXHero BeKa, TaR RaR
STOT nOKa3aTeJIb nOJIHOCTblO 3aMeHHeTCH xapaKTepllCTllKon IIHTeHCIIBHOCTII ee
pa3BJJTllH B pa3HbIX OTp,eJIaX BeRa.
I.(BeT RomH I.(BeT I'na3 IIanHqHe npHMblX TYI'HX Bonoc
'TYBIIH:L\l>I 1 Koii6aJIl>I 1 TYBIIH:L\bI 1
AJITaii:L\l>I 2,5 * AJl T aH:L\l>I 2 AJITaih bI 2
BeJIbTl>Ipl>I 2,5 TYBIIHD;l>I 3 Rl>I3bIJIb:L\l>I 3
Pil>I3l>IJIb:L\l>I 4 Ka'IIIHD;l>I 4 Koii6aJIl>I 4
Roii6aJIl>I 5 BeJIbTl>Ipl>I 5 Ka'llIll:L\l>I 5
Car a:iiD;l>I 6 Ca ra:iiD;l>I 6 BeJIbTl>IpbI 6
Ka'IIIHD;bI 7 HbIl!bIJibD;l>I 7 Cara:iiD;bI 7
PyccKHe 8 TYPRMenbI-lloMYTl>I 8 PyccRHe 8
TropKII raHp;iRH:iicKIIe 9 TropIDI raH):\mll:iicRHe 9
PyccKIIe 10
* J];po6HaH BeJIM'lMHa 6aJIJIOBOiI xapaRTepHCTHRH rrOJIyqaeTCH B TOM CJIyqae, eCJIH )1Be
I'pyrrITbl HMelOT o]:lHHaROBYIO BeJIH'lHHY npn3HaRa. IIx rrOpH)1IWBbIe HOMepa CRJIa]:lb1BaIOTCH II
)1eJlHTCH Ha ]:IBa.
Cpe]:lllHH 6ann .pOpMbI BonDe PoeT 60POilb' I'opH30HTanbHaH
npo.pHmIpOBRa Jllfl.\a
'TyBllHD;l>I t,5 TYBHHD;bI 1 TYBllH:L\l>I t
Ko:ii6aJIl>I 1,5 Ra'IHH:L\bI 2 AJITa:ii:L\l>I 2
AJITa:iiD;l>I 4* Rl>I3l>IJIb:L\bI 3 PibI3l>IJIbD;l>I 3
Ka'IllH:L\bI 4 AJIT aiiI(l>I 4 Pia'IIIH:L\bI 4
BeJIbTbIpl>I 4 BeJIbTl>IpbI 5 Koii6aJIl>I 5
Kl>Il!bIJIb:L\bI 6 Cara:ii:L\l>I 6 BeJIbTl>Ipl>I 6
Cara:iiD;bI 7 Ho:ii6aJIl>I 7 Cara:ii:L\bI 7
PYCCRHe 8 PyccRIIe 8 TypKMeHl>I-llOMYTl>I 8
'TIOpRH raHp;mII:iicRHe 9 TropmI raHp;mII:iicRI1e 9,5 PyccIDIe 9
TYPRMeHl>I-llOMYTl>I 9.5 TropRII raHp;mII:iicmIe 10
* O]:lHHaROBaH BeJlH'lHHa 6aJlJlOBoiI xapaRTepHCTHRH B Tpex nOCJle)10BaTeJlbHbIX rpynrrax MomeT
rroJlyqHTbeH B TOM CJIyqae, eCJlH Bce OHH HMelOT O;UIHaROBYIO Be:IHqHHy npH3HaRa. TOP]:Ia, RaR
H B cJlyqae HarrH'lHH O]:lHHaROBoiI BeJlHqHHbl npH3HaRa B ]:IByX rpynnax, ITOpH]:IROBbIe HOMepa
rpyrrIT CYMMHPYIOTCH H ]:IeJlHTCH Ha TpH.
IIaJIH'lHe 8nHRaHTrea Pa3BHTHe eKJlai\KH Pa3BHTHe cKJIa]:lKII
Ha BHYTpeHHeH CTopOHe BeKa B Cpe)1HeM OT)1ene BeRa
Ro:ii6aJIl>I 1 Am an:L\l>I 1 TYBIIHI(.bI 1
1{a'IllH:L\bI 2 TYBIIH:L\l>I 2 PibI3l>IJIb:L\bI 2
AJITanI(bI 3 Ra'lIIH:L\bI 3 Am an:L\bI 3
'TyBllH:L\bI 4 Itl>I 3bIJIb :L\l>I 4 Ra'lIIH:L\l>I 4
PiLI3bIJIbD;l>I 5 Kon6aJIl>I 5 Ron6aJIl>I 5
'CaraiiD;l>I 6 Carall:I(.bI 6 CaraR:L\l>I 6
BeJIbTl>Ipl>I 7 TypRMeHl>I- IIOMYTl>I 7 BeJIbTbIpl>I 7
"TYPRMeHl>I-llOMYTl>I 8 BeJIbTl>Ipl>I 8 TypRMeHl>I-IIOMYTl>I 8
TIOPRH raHp;iRH:iicmIe 9 TropRH raH):\iRnnCRHe 9 TropRII raHp;iRH:iicRne 9
PyccRHe 10 PyccRHe 10 PyccIDIe 10
373
PaSBHTKe CRHaAKH
Ha BHelIIHeiI CTopOHe BeRa
TYBIIH:L\bI
PiI>I3l>IJIbI'\l>I
AJITaiiI'\l>I
Ka1J:IIH:L\bI
Koii6aJIl>I
CaraRI\l>I
BeJIbTl>Ipl>I
TypRMeHl>I-IIOMYTbI
TropRH raHp;1KIIRCRHe
PYCCRHe
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
BbICOTa lIepeHOCbH
TYBHHI'\l>I
Koii6aJIbI
AJITaHI\l>I
PiI>I3l>IJIb:L\bI
CaraHI'\l>I
BeJIbTl>Ipl>I
Ka1J:IIHI\l>I
TYPRMeHl>I-HOMYTbI
PyccIDIe
TIOpRI1 raH):\lI\IIHCRI1e
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
IhaR, BoceMb rpynrr npep,CTaBJIeHO BO Bcex CJIY'IaHX. TYPKMeHbI-IIOMY-
TbI - B BOCbMII, raHp,llilInCRlIe TlOpKII - B p,eCHTII CJIY'IaHX. MCXOp,H 1I3 SToro,
cpep,HHH OaJIJIOBan xapaRTeplICTIIRa nepB X Bbl'IlICJIeHa no BOCbMII nplI3Ha-
RaM, cpep,HHH 6aJIJIOBaH xapaRTeplICTIIRa BTOpbIX - no p,eCHTII. M3MepeHIIe
MacmTaoa ROJIeOaHIIn BeTa ROllill, npo eHTa HaJIlI'IlIH npHMbIx TyrlIx BOJIOC
II cpep,Hero oaJIJIa iPOpMbl BOJIOC, I10 ROTOpbIM OTCYTCTBYIDT p,aHHble 0 TYPK-
MeHax II TlOpRax, HBJIHeTCH, ROHe'IHO, OTpII aTeJIbHbIM MOMeHTOM MeTop,a B
p,aHHOM ROHRpeTHOM CJIY'Iae. Qp,HaKO, nOCKOJIbKy II Te II P,PyrlIe 3aHIIMalOT
KpanHee nOJIOllieHIIe, IICKJIlO'IeHlIe lIX II3 conOCTaBJIeHIIH ORa3bIBaeT npIIOJIII-
3IITeJIbHO op,IIHaKOBoe BJIIIHHlIe Ha Bce OCTaJIbHbIe rpyn, nbl 'ITO II p,eJIaeT ero
npaBOMepHblM. Bo BCHKOM CJIY'Iae, OHO OOJIee npaBOMepHO, 'IeM IICKJIlO'IeHlIe
II3 paCCMOTpeHIIH Tpex nepe'IIICJIeHHbIX BalliHblX npII3HaKOB, KaKoe nplIIIIJIOCb
ObI p,onYCTIITb nplI 6e3YCJIOBHOM COOJIIOp,eHIIII ep,IIHCTBa MaCIIITa6a.
IToCJIe ::JTIIX npep,BaplITeJIbHbIX 3aMe'IaHIIn nplIBop,IIM paCIIpep,eJIeHlIe cpep,-
HIIX OaJIJIOBbIX xapaKTeplICTIIK paCCMaTplIBaeMblX rpYIIn:
TYBIIHI\bI 1,6 BeJIbTl>Ipl>I 5,8
AJIT aii:L\l>I 2,7 CaraiiI\l>I 6,2
Koii6aJIl>I 3,8 TYPRMeHl>I-IIoMYTl>I 8,0
Kl>I3l>IJIb:L\l>I 3,9 PyccRHe 9,1
Ka'lIIIII'\l>I 4,2 TropKII raH):\1KIIHCIDIe 9,3
HCHO, 'ITO Ta IIJIII IIHaH aOCOJIIOTHaH BeJIlI'IlIHa OaJIJIOBOn xapaRTepIIcTIIKII
HBJIHeTCH pe3YJIbTaTOM oor::qero ROJIII'IeCTBa rpynn Ii caMa no ceoe He MomeT
6bITb nOKa3aTeJIeM HaJIlI'IlIH IIJIII O'TCYTCTBIIH eBponeOIIp,Hon nplIMeCII. ITo-
CJIep,HHH YCTaHaBJIIIBaeTCH Ha OCHOBaHIIII paCCMOTpeHIIH B3alIMHoro pacno-
JIOllieHIIH rpynII. Bce xaKaCCKlIe rpYIIIIbI 3aHIIMalOT npOMemYTO'IHOe nOJIOllie-
HlIe Mellip,y rpynnaMII, B3HT MM B Ra'IeCTBe npep,cTaBIITeJIen MOHrOJIOIIp,HOn
II eBponeoIIp,Hon OOJIbmlIX pac. TaKIIM oopa30M, TeHp,eH IIH, HaMe'IalOr::qaHCH
nplI aHaJIII3e BapIIa IIIJ OTp,eJIbHbIX npII3HaROB, Haxop,IIT nop,TBepllip,eHIIe npn:
CYMMapHOM conOCTaBJIeHIIII no BceMy KOMnJIeRCY nplI3HaRoB. Bce ::JTO p,aeT
p,OnOJIHIITeJIbHbIe OCHOBaHIIH p,JIH nepeCMOTpa 'TO'IKII 3peHIIH A. M. Hpxo Ha
He3aBIICIIMoe OT eBponeolIp,Hon nplIllIeCII iPopMlIpoBaHlIe iPII3II'IeCKOrO TlIna
COBpeMeHHbIX xaRaCOB. ECJIII paHbIlle HeooxOp,IIMOC'Tb nepeC;>IOTpa ::JTon rlIno-
Te3bl ObIJIa CBH3aHa C IICCJIep,OBaHIIHMII HeII3BeCTHoro A. II. Hpxo naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKOrO MaTeplIaJIa C TepplIToplI1I MlInyclIHcKon ROTJIOBIIHbl,
TO nOCJIe npOp,eJIaHHblX conOCTaBJIeHlIn BblBOp, 0 nplICYTCTBlI1I eBponeOIIp,Hon
nplIMeCII B COCTaBe xaKaCOB MOllieT ObITb cp:eJIaH II Ha OCHOBe npep,CTaBJIeH-
HbIX 11M caMIIM pe3YJIbTaTOB aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCROrO IICCJIep,OBaHIIH COBpeMeHHO-
1'0 HaCeJIeHIIH. Yp,eJIbHbIn Bec eBponeOIID;Hon nplIMeCII B COCTaBe xaRaCCKIIX
rpynII, IIO-BIIP,IIMOMY, pa3JIII'IeH. Bo BCHROM CJIY'Iae, caran bI II OeJIbTbIpbI
374
npH5JI1IllialOTCH R eBpOneOHp,HbIM rpynnaM, O'ieBIIp,HO, 50JIbme, 'IeM RbI3bIJIb-
, bI, Ron6aJIbI H Ka'lHH bI. Op,HaKO 50JIee p,eTaJIbHOe paCCMOTpeHHe ::JToro iPaR-
Ta npHp, JIll B03MomHO TOJIbRO Ha OCHOBaHHII COMaTOJIOrH'IeCKIIX p,aHHbIX II
Tpe6yeT IIpIIBJIe'leHHH p,aHHbIX KpaHIiOJIOTIIII.
KP AHHOJIOI'HqECKHR THl1 COBPEMEIUThIX XARACOB
.MaTepHaJIbI no RpaHHOJIOrHH 6JIII3K01'O R COBpeMeHHOCTH HaCeJIeHIiH 6bIJIII
.c06paHbl aBTopOM HaCTOHID,'en pa60TbI COBMeCTHO C apxeOJIOrOM A5aRaHCR01'O
J{paeBep,'IeCK01'O MY3eH A. H. JIHncKHM. B JIeTHHe nOJIeBbIe ce30HbI 1953,
1954 II 1956 1'1'. paCKonKaMH 6bIJIII OXBa'IeHbI RJIap,611r::qa Bcex ::JTHII'IeCRIIX
rpynn xaKaCOB 7. 8THH'IeCKaH npIIHap,JIelliHOCTb II p,aTHpOBKa RJIap,6 YCTa-
HaBJIIIBaJIlICb Ha OCHOBaHHII cyr::qeCTBYIOr::qen Tpap,H HH. Bce OHII OTHOCHTCH
R ROH y XVIII - IIepBon nOJIOBIIHe XIX B.
CJIep,yeT OTMeTIITb, 'ITO MaTepIIaJI no RbI3bIJIb aM, p,06blTbln B IIOCJIeP,HHn
.TOp, paCKonOK xaH:aCCKHX KJIap,6Hr::q, He 06pa60TaH p,o CHX nop, II, CJIep,OBa-
TeJIbHO, Mbl JIlIilleHbI B03MomHOCTH IIPH pacCMoTpeHHII BonpocoB ::JTHoreHe3a
Rbl3bIJIb eB BOCnOJIb30BaTbcH RpaHHOJIOrH'IeCKHMII p,aHHbIMII. MaTepHaJI 110
.6eJIbTblpaM IIMeeT cne IIiPII'IeCKOe npoIIcxomp,eHIIe no cpaBHeHlllO C COMaTO-
JI01'II'IeCKIIMII p,aHI-IbIMII no 6eJIbTblpaM, ony6JIIIKOBaHHblMII A. II. flpxo. Pa60-
Tbl JI. IT. IToTanoBa nOKa3aJIII, '1TO HaCeJIeHIIe MH01'IIX xaKaCCKIIX ceoKoB, 3a-
HIIMalOr::qIIx TeppIITopIIIO 3aIIap,Hblx npIIToKOB BepxHe1'o A6aKaHa, nepeceJIII-
.JIOCb clOp,a C Mpac-cy II IIMeeT illopcKoe npOIICXOllip,eHIIe 8. A. II. flpxo He
.3HaJl ::JToro II BKJIIO'IIIJI B COCTaB 6eJIbTblpOB HaCeJIeHIIe MHorllX ceOROB illOp-
CKoro npOlIcxomp,eHIIH 9. KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIn MaTepIIaJI 110 HaCeJIeHIIIO illOp-
CKIIX ceOKOB 6bIJI c06paH OTp,eJILHO. OH He paCCMaTpIIBaeTCH 3p,eCb, TaR RaR
npOllcxomp,eHIIe BepXHea6aRaHCKIIX illop eB HBJIHeTCH 'IaCTHbIM BonpOCOM
60JIee 05r::qen IIpOOJIeMbI IIpOIIcxomp,eHIIH illop eB Bo06r::qe II He IIMeeT HeIIO-
cpep,CTBeHH01'O OTHOilleHIIH R IIp06JIellIe npOIICXOllip,eHIIH xaKaCOB. TaKIIM 06-
pa30M, HaXOp,HI::qIIeCH B HailleM pacnopHllieHIIII p,aHHbIe no KpaHIIOJIOrIIII
6eJIbTbIpOB OTHOCHTCH R HaCeJIeHIIIO ceOKOB c06cTBeHHo 6eJIbTblpCKoro npOIIC-
xomp,eHIIH.
I13Y'leHIIe 06llIIIPHbIX RpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX IIIaTepIIaJIOB 110 Hapop,aM CII6II-
pII, IIpOII3Bep,eHHoe r. <D. .n;e6e oM, IIOKa3aJIO, '1TO 113 KpaHIIOJI01'II'IeCKIIX
npH3HaKOB p,JIH eJIen KJIaCcIIiPIIRa 1I1I MOH1'OJIOIIp,OB CeBepHon A3IIII MOryT
nOCJIylliIITb BblcTynaHIIe Hoca, illIIpIIHa Hoca [] BepTIIKaJILHaH npoiPIIJIIIpOBKa
JIII a 10. Kamp,aH II3 STIIX oc05eHHOCTen iPIIKcIIpyeTcH HeCKOJIbKIIMII 113Me-
peHIIHMII, II II03TOMY IIX onpep,eJIeHIIe MOllieT C'IIITaTbCH p,OCTaTO'IHO 06'beK-
TIIBHbIM. Op,HaKO nOKa3aHIIH no D;BYM II3 HUX - illIIpIIHe Hoca II BepTIIKaJIL-
HOM npoiPIIJIIIpOBKe JIII a eCJIII II IIw1'YT npIIBJIeKaTbCH npII cymp,eHIIII 0 Me-
CTe rpynnbl B CIICTeMe 60JIbillIIX paCOBblX p,eJIeHUn qeJIOBe'leCTBa, TO B orpa-
HII'IeHHOn CTeIIeHII. II paBp,a, 06r::qeII3BeCTHbI CIIJIbHaH BepTIIKaJIbHaH npoiPII-
JIIIpOBKa II 60JIbillaH IIIIIpIIHa Hoca Ha '1epenax npep,CTaBIITeJIen HerpOIIp,Hon
paCLI. O;:J;HaKO pa3JIII'IIIH B pa3Maxe II3MeH'IIIBOCTII STIIX I1pII3HaKOB y MOHro-
JIOIIp,HbIX II eBpOIIeOllp,HbIX rpynn He O'IeHb onpep,eJIeHHbI. C'IIITaeTCH, 'ITO
p,JIH MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX 'IepenOB xapaKTepHbl B cpep,HeM 66JIbillaH IIIIIpIIHa Hoca
II 60JIee npoiPIIJIlIpOBaI-IHOe B BepTIIRaJIbHOn nJIOCKOCTII JIIID,O, 'IeM p,JIH eBpo-
neOIIp,HblX 11. Op,HaKO MbI IIMeeM p,OCTaTO'lHO OOJIbmOe KOJIII'IeCTBO eBpOIIeo-
IIp,HbIX 1'pYIIII, IIM, elOr::qIIX BO BCHKOM CJIY'lae, He MeIIbmIIe BeJIII'IIIHbI illHpII-
HbI Hoca, '1eM MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIe, BblcTynalOr::qee B BepTIIKaJIbHOn nJIOCKOCTII,
llJIII, KaK npllHHTO Ha3bIBaTb B Cne IIaJIbHOn aHTpOnOJI01'II'IeCKOn JIIITepaType,
Me30rHaTHoe JIII O. B Ka'IeCTBe npIIMepa MomHO COCJIaTbCH Ha RpaHIIOJIOrII-
'IeCKIIn TIIII HaCeJIeHHH RaBRa3a 12 II HeROTopblX IOJRHblX rpYIIn 3ana):l;Hon
375
i
EBpOIIbI I3 . TaRIIM 06pa30M, IICIIOJIb30BaHIIe 3TIIX nplI3HaKOB nplI COIIOCTaB-
JIeHIIII RpynHblx paCOBblX RaTerOpIIn BPHP, JIll HBIIJIOCb 5bI p,OCTaTO'IHO OIIpaB-
p,aHHbIM.
JIIIYIO RapTIIHY MbI liMe eM nplI paCCMOTpeHlI1I pacnpep,eJIelIlIH HeKOTopblX
P,PyrIIx npII3HaKOB, He BKJIlO'IeHHbIX r. «D. Ae6e oM B 'IlIc.rro p,lIiPiPepeH :U-
PYIOr::qIIX p,JIH BbIJJ:eJIeHIIH TIIIIOB BToporo nopHp,Ka Ha TepplIToplI1I C1I61Ipll.
K IIX 'IIICJIY B nepBYIO O'Iepe,lJ,b OTHOCIITCH npoiPlIJIlIpOBKa JIIID,a B roplI30H-
TaJIbHOn nJIOCKOCTII. Ee OIIpep,eJIeHlIe Ha 'IepeIIaX IIpep,cTaBIITeJIen caMbIX
pa3JIII'IHbIX paCOBLIX TIIIIOB IIOKa3aJIO, 'ITO BaplIa 1I1I yrJIOB roplI30HTaJIbI-lOn
npoiPIIJIlIpOBKII BIIOJIHe OT'IeTJIIIBO pa3JIII'IaIOTCH B eBpOIIeOII}.IHbIX II MOHrOJIO-
IIp,I1bIX rpYIInax a. TaKIIM 06pa30M, CTeIIeHb YIIJIor::qeHHOCTII JIII a B roplI-
30HTaJIbI-IOn nJIOCKOCTII MOllieT HBIITbCH 6a3011 ,lJ,JIH CYllip,eHIIH 0 MeCTe KaKon-
JIII60 rpYIIIIbI no OTHOIIIeI;lll1O R eBpOneOIIp,HOMY II MOHroJIOII,lJ,HOMY pacoBbIM
CTBOJIaM. ITpaBp'a, B. B. BYHaR YRa3blBaJI Ha Hep'OCTaTO'IHYIO siPiPeKTIIBHoCTb
IIIlIpORO IIplIMeHHeMoro B IIpaRTIIKe pa50T COBeTCKIIX aHTpOIIOJIOrOB IIpHe a
OIIpep,eJIeHIIH 3IIrOMaKCIIJIJIHpHOrO yrJIa, HJIll, IIHblMII CJIOB3.MII, yrJIa roplI-
30HTaJIbHOn YIIJIor::qeHHocTM HlIlliHero OTp,eJIa JIHIJ;a 1\ II npep,JIaraJI 3aMeHIITb
ero COOTHOIIIeHlIeM pa3MepOB, 6JIIl3KIIM R TOMY, ROTopoe 6bIJIO BBeJ..(eHO
A. CKpenHep 16. OrIHaRO. IIOMIIMO HeIIpaBOMepHOCTII 3aMeHbI op,Horo 1I3Me-
peHIIH, no KOTOPOMY HaKOIIJIeH 60JIbmOn cpaBHIITeJIblILIn IaTepHaJI, p,pynIIV1,
BBep,eHHbIM He TaK p,aBHO II IIO::JTOMY He npep,CTaBJIeHHbIM B 60JILIIIIIIICTBe
RpaHIIOJIOrlI'IeCRIIX IIy6JIIIKa lIn, II B MoPiPoJIorlI'IeCKOM OTHUIIIeHIIH TaKaH
3aMeHa BbIl'JIHp'IIT He O'IeHb OIIpaBp,aHHoiL
ITonbITRa YMeHbmlITb pO JIb yrJIOB ropII30HTaJIbHOH IIpOiPlIJIIIpOBKII JIII a
RaK IIpII3HaKOB BblCOKoro TaKCOHOMIITJ:eCKOrO 3ua'IeHIIH, nplIrOp,ITbIX p,JIH pa3-
rpaHII'IeHIIH 60JIbllIIIX paCOBbIX RaTeropIIn, 6bIJIa Cp,eJIaHa B. IT. HKIIMOBbIM,
nbITaBIIIIIMCH nOKa3aTb, 'ITO HeKOTopbIe rpynIIbl ,lJ,peBIIerO HaCeJIeIIlIH EBpOIIbI
xapaKTeplI30BaJIIICb TaKOH llie CTeIIeHblO roplI30HTaJIbIIOH YIIJIO eHHOCTII
JIII a, RaK II COBpeMeHIIbIe CII6IIpCRIIe MOHrOJIOIIp'bI 17 . Op,HaKO OHa He MomeT
C'IIITaTLCH ,lJ,OKa3aTe:rbHon IUI C iPaKTII'IeCKOn, HII C JIOr:H'IeCKOii CTOpOHbl 18.
Ha IIpOTHmeHlI1I lVIHorlIX JIeT pa3lV1epbl JIII eBOro CKeJIeTa Tar;llie C'IIITa-
JIIICb pa3rpaHII'IIITeJIbHbDIII nplI3HaKaMII ,lJ,JIH KJIaCClI'IeCKIIX IIpe/.l,CTaBIITeJIen
eBpOIIeOIIp,Hon II 11.JOHrOJIOlIp,HOH pac. JIcCJIeP,OBaHlIH r. «D. Ae6e a no naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrIIII HeOJIIITa II UpOH3bI eBpoIIencKoII 'IaCTII COBeTCKoro COI03a, II B
'IaCTHOCTII HlIlliHero ITOBOJIllibH, BBeJIII B HaY'IHbln 060POT UOJILIIIOn HOBbl»
MaTeplIaJI, KOTopbIn 1I3lV1eHIIJI ::JTII IIpep,CTaBJIeHIIH 19. ORa3aJIOCb, 'ITO p,peB-<
Hee eBpOIIeOIIIJ:HOe HaCeJIeHlIe Ha HeKOTopbIX TepplITopIIHX xapaKTepII30Ba-
JIOCb nplI5JIII3IITeJIbHO TaKIIMII llie BeJIlI'IlIHaMII CKYJIOBOro p,lIaMeTpa, RaRon
HMelOT B HaCTOHr::qee BpeMH MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIe rpynIIbl CII5IIpII. IIa COBpeMeHHbIX
npep,CTaBIITeJIeII eBpOIIeOIIp,Hon paCbI aHaJIOrII'IHbIe BeJIII'IIIHbI IIMelOT HeRO-
TOpbIe Hapop,HOCTII CeBepIloro KaBKa3a II ropHbIe rpYIInbl rpY31IH, OTHOCH-
r::qIIeCH R TaK Ha3bIBae IOMY RaBKaCIIOHCKOMY BapllaHTY 20. HaRoHeD" BblCOTa
JIII a Ha 'IepeIIaX HeKOTopbIX COBpeMeHHbIX eBpOneOII,lJ,HbIX rpynII TaRllie 6.:r1I3-
Ra K BeJIII'IIIHaM, 3aiPIIKcIIpoBaHHbIlVI Ha 'IepeIIaX MOHrOJIOIIp,OB CeBepHon
A3IIII. TaK, BbICOTa JIII a y TIIpOJIb eB 21 IIpeBblmaeT aHaJIOrlITJ:HbIn pa3Mep
B cepIIII TeJIellI'HTOB 22. TaKIIM 06pa30M, RpOlVle yrJIOB roplI30HTaJIbHOn IIpO-
iPIIJIlIpOBRII JIII a II IIpII3HaKOB, onpelJ,eJIHIOr::qIIX CTeIIeHL BblcTyrraHIIH Hoca, lVIbi
He IIMeeM RplITepIIeB p,JIH 5e30rOBOpO'IHOrO OTp,eJIeHIIH MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX rpYIIn
OT eBpOneOIIJI;IIbIX. 8TII nplI3IIaKII 5YP.YT IICnOJIb30BaHbI B ,1,aJIbHenmeM.
B OTHomeHIIII cpaBHIITeJIbHOrO lIIaTepIIaJIa O'ieBIIp,Ha llieJIaTeJILHOCTb IIplI-
BJIe'tIeHIIH Tex llie rpYIIII, ROTOpbIe 6bIJIII IICIIOJIb30BaHbI npII COIIOCTaBJIeHIIII
COllIaTOJIOrlI'IeCRIIX p,aHHbIX. Op,HaRO ::JTO YCJIOBlIe He MOllieT 6bITb nOJIHOCTblO
C06JIIOp,eHO II3-3a OTCYTCTBIIH 'IepenOB aJITaHu,eB B KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX c05pa-
376
HIIHX Harnell CTpaHbI. 1I0::JToMY B Ka'IeCTBe SRBIIBaJIeHTa B p,aJIbHenrneM iPII-
rypIIpYIOT p,aIUlbIe no cepIlIl TeJIeHrIlTOB 23. ITPOIIcxollip,eHIIe p,pyrIlx cepIln,
npIlBJIe'leHHbIX B Ka'IeCTBe cpaBIUlTeJIbHbIX, TaKllie He 1V1OllieT C'IIITaTbCH
Toa;:p,eCTBeIIIIbIM npOIlCXOllip,eHIIIO op,HOIIMeHHblX COMaTOJIOrIl'IeCRIIX rpynn.
'TaK, qepena pyq:KIIX c06paHbI npIl paCKonRax KJIap,OIlnw XVIII B. B
r. Ce6ellie ITcKoBcKon 05JIaCTII 2., '1epena a3ep6anp,lliaH eB IIpOIlCXOp,HT II3
norpe6eHIIH XIV - XVII BB. 2 \ a I1e60JIbmaH cepIlH 'IepCnOB TypRMeHoB
Bo06r::qe He :\IOllieT CqIlTaTbCH p,OCTaTO'IHO npep,CTaBIITeJIbI-IOn He TOJIbKO B
CIlJIY CBoen :\IaJIO'lIlCJIeHHOCTII, HO II B CIIJIY He OqeHb HCHoro IIpOIlCXOllip,e-
HIIH 26. TeM He MeHee Bce STII MaTepIlaJIbl p;alOT I13BeCTHYIO B03MOlliHOCTb
B3BeCIITh BapIla5eJIbHOC'fb pa3.:rIl'IHbIX cepIln xaKaCOB B MellirpYIInOBOM Mac-
lIna6e.
FOpU301iTa.ablWfl nporjju.aup081ia .auq,a. BeJIII'IIIHa Ha30MaJIHpHOrO yrJIa
ropIl30HTaJIbIlOn npo<pIIJIIIpOBKII onpep,eJIHeT ynJIor::qeHHOCTb mm;a Ha ypOBHe
q,pOHTOl\IaJIHpHbIX TO'IeK, T. e. B BepXHeM OTp,eJIe. TIeM 60JIbIIIe BeJIlIqIIHa yrJIa,
TeM 60JIee ynJIor::qeIIIIbIM MOllieT CqIlTaTbCH JIIIIW II Ha060pOT. XaRaCCKIIe
rpynnbI BMeCTe C p,pyrIlMII, B3HTbIMII p,JIH COIIOCTaBJIeHIIH, 06HapymIIBalOT
CJIep,YIOr::qee pacnpep,eJIeHIIe:
TYBHH:L\bI 146,6(44)
TeJIeHrHTl>I 149,3 (49)
Ka1J:HHI\l>I 146,3 (45)
CaraH:L\l>I 145,7 (31)
Koii:6aJIbI 145,1 (25)
EeJIbTl>Ipl>I 144,9 (46)
PyccRHe 140,4(86)
TYPRMeHl>I 143,3 (7)
Aaep6aHAmaH:L\bI 135,4(12)
HaR II CJIep,OBaJIO ollilIp,aTb, HaIl60JIbIIIaH II HaIlMeHbmaH BeJIIIqllHbI Ha-
30MaJIHpHOrO yrJIa npep;CTaBJIeHbI He B xaRaCCRIIX, a B cpaBHIITeJIbHbIX rpyn-
nax. ITepBaH nap,aeT Ha TeJIeHrIlTOB, BTopaH - Ha a3ep6anp,lliaH eB. TYBIIH-
bI 3aMeTHO YCTYIIalOT B STOM OTHOIIIeHIIII TeJIeHrIlTaM. Pa3JIIIqIlH xaRaCCRIIX
rpYIIn II TYBIIH eB HeBemIKII. Bce IKe Ron6aJIbI II 6eJIbTblpbI xapaKTepIl3YIOT-
CH CJIa6blM cp,BIIrOM B HanpaBJIeHIIII R eBpOIIeOIIp,HbIM rpyrrnaM, XOTH Mellip,y
IIepBbIMII II nOCJIep,HIIMII OCTaeTCH BnOJIHe onpep;eJIeHHbln pa3pblB. TaRIIM 06-
pa30M, no BeJIIIqIlHe Ha30MaJIHpHOrO yrJIa roplI30HTaJIbHOn IIpoiPIIJIllpOBKl'I
xaKaCbI nonap,alOT B rpaHII bI Baplla lIn 50JIbIIIOIl MOHrOJIOllp,I-IOn pacbI, OT-
JIII'IaHCb, op,HaRO, OT TllnIl'IHblX MOHTOJIOllp,OB HeKOTopblM nOHllmeHIIeM BeJIII-
'IIIHbl ::JToro yrJIa.
BeJIlIqllHa 3I1rOMaRCIIJIJIHpHOrO yrJIa ropIl30HTaJIbHOn npoiPIIJIIIpOBRII OT-
palliaeT CTeneHb ynJIor::qeHHOCTII HllmHero OTp,eJIa JIII a. BOJIbmaH BeJIII'IlIHa
yrJIa rOBopIlT 0 50JIbIIIen ynJIor::qeHHOCTII HIImHero OTp,eJIa JIII a. ITo ::JTOMY
npIl3HaKy paCCMaTpIlBaeMbIe rpynnbl pacnpep,eJIHIOTCH CJIep,YIOr::qIlM 06pa30M:
TYHIIH:L\bI 141,3(42) Ka'IHHI'\l>I 134.2(44)
TeJIeHrIITl>I 134,5 (47) CanJ.ih l>I 132,6 (30)
Koii:6aJIl>I 136,0 (25) PyceKlIe 125,6 (84)
EeJIbTbIpbI 134,6(46) TypJi.MeHbI 127,9(7)
Aaep6aHAmaH:L\bI 123,4(13)
ITo BeJIlIqIIHe 3I1rOMaRCIIJIJIHpHOrO yrJIa TYBIIH bl II TeJIeHrllTbl IIOMeHH-
.JIIICb MeCTaMII B cpaBHeHIIII C nOJIOmeHIIeM no BeJIllqllHe Ha30MaJIHpI-IOrO yrJIa.
Cpep,1I xaRaCCKIIX rpYIIII ROIl6aJIbl I1MeIOT 60JIbIIIYlO BeJIII'IIIHY ::JTom yrJIa,
'IeM TeJIeHrllTbI, Ra'IInU bI II 6eJIbTblpbI He OTJIII'IalOTCH OT nOCJIep,HIIX. TOJIb-
RO caran bl xapaRTepIl3YlOTCH 3aMeTHO 60JIee npoiPIIJIlIpOBaHHblM JIII OM,
nplI6JIllmaHCb B ::JTOM OTHOIIIeHIIII R eBpOneOII)J,HblM nonYJIH IIHM. Bee me
Memp,y HHMII II Hall60JIee nJIOCKOJIII ell eBponeollp,Hon rpynnon - TypRMeHa-
Mil coxpaHHeTCH 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOe pa3JIII'IlIe.
377
1
BblcTynanue noea. CTeneHb BbICTYIIaHIIH Hoca iPIIKcIIpyeTcH TOJIbKO Ha
KpaHIIOJIOrIl'IeCKOM MaTepIIaJIe II3MepeHIIeM yrJIa HOCOBbIX KOCTen R JIIIHIIII
rrpoiPIIJIH, p,aKpIIaJIbHOn II CIIMOTII'leCKOIJ BbICOT II BbI'lIICJIeIIIIeM COOTBeTCT- III
BYIOr::qIIX YKa3aTeJIen. Bce ::JTII npII3HaKII He HaXO HTCR B npHMon ROppeJIH-
IIII p,pyr C. p,pyrOM. )J;aKpIIaJIbHaH II CIIMOTII'leCKaH BbICOTbI OTpallialOT CTe-
neHb ynJIor::qeHHOCTIJ nepeHOCbH, TaK me KaR II p,aKpIIaJIbHbIn II CIIMOTII'le-
CKIIn YKa3aTeJIII. B TO me BpeMH yrOJI HOCOBbIX KOCTen K JIIIHIIII IIPOiPIIJIH
HeIIocpe CTBeHHO OIIpep,eJIReT BbIcTynaHIIe Hoca K nJIOCKOCTII JIII a. TaKIIM
06pa30M, TOJIbKO conOCTaBJIeHIIe STIIX pa3MepOB p,aeT IIOJIHOe IIpep,CTaBJIeHIIe'
o CTpoeHIIII Hoca B HCCJIe yeMon I10nYJIH IIII.
BemI'lIIHa yrJIa IIOCOBblX KOCTelI K JIIIHIIII IIpOiPIIJIH BapbIIpyeT B HamIIX
rpYIInax CJIep,YIOr::qIIM 06pa30l\I:
TYBIIH:L\bI
TeJIeHI'IITl>I
Pia'IIIH:L\J>I
Caraii bI
21,3(20)
23,3 (37)
23,2 (38)
26,9(30)
Pioii6aJIl>I 21,0 (21)
EeJIbTl>Ipl>I 22,2 (37)
PyccRIIe 31.5 (77)
TYPRMeHl>I 30,3 (6)
A3ep6a:iiAmaHl:(.bI 29,6 (9)
XaKaCbI He OTJIII'laIOTCH 3aMeTHbIM 06pa30M OT TIInII'IHbIX MOHrOJIOllp,HbIX
rpynII. Ep,IIHCTBeIIHOe IICKJIIO'leHIIe, KaK II no BeJIII'IIIHe 3IIrOMaKCIIJIJIHpHOrO
yrJIa I'OpII30HTaJIbHOn npoiPIIJIIIpOBKII, rrpep,CTaBJIHIOT caran bI, 3aHIIMalOr::qIIe
npOMemYTO'lHOe IIOJIOmeHIIe Memp,y OCTaJIbHbIMII xaRaCCKIIMII rpynnaMII, TY-
BIIH aMII IT TeJIeHrIITaMII, C op,Hon CTOpOHbI, II a3ep6anp,lliaH aMII - C p,pyron,
II OTJIII'lalO IIeCH KaK OT Tex, TaR II OT p,pyrIIx npII6JIII3IITeJIbHO B paBHon
CTeneHII. Op,I1aKO p,ame no cpaBHeHIIIO C caran aMII eBponeOIIp,HbIe nonYJIH-
IIII 3aHIIMalOT p,OCTaTO'lHO 060c06JIeHHOe IIOJIOmeHlle.
TIepexop,IIM K paCCMOTpeHIIIO BapIIa IIn aRplIaJIbHOn BbICOTbI:
TYBIIHI'\bI 9,3(41) Ko:ii6aJIbI 9,7(26)
TeJIeHrHTl>I 9,2 (49) EeJIbTl>Ipl>I 10.2 (46)
Ka'IlIHD;l>I 10,1 (44) PyccRHe 13,0 (80)
CaraH:L\bI 10,7(31) TypKMeHl>I 12,1(7)
A3ep6aHp;maH:L\bI 14,0(13)
CaMble 60JIbmIIe BeJIII'lIIHbI p,aKpIIaJIbHOn BbICOTbI, COOTBeTCTBYIOr::qlle HaII-
OOJIee BbICTYIIalO eMY IIepeHOCblO, MbI Haxop,IIM B eBponeOIIp,HblX rpYIIIIax.
IT pOTIIBOnOJIOmHbln I10JIIOC 3aHIIMalOT TYBIIH bl II TeJIeHrIITbI. Bce xaRaCCKIIe-
rpYIInbI, XOTH II OTJIII'IalOTCR OT IIOCJIep,HIIX B MeHbIIIeii CTeIIeHII, 'leM OT nep-
BbIX, 3aHIIMalOT Bce me npOMemYTO'lHOe IIOJIOmeHIIe. HaK II no paHee pac-
CMOTpeHHbIM npII3HaKaM, caran bI no p,aKpIIaJIbHOn BbICOTe B HalI60JIbmen
CTeneIIII OTJIIIqalOTCH OT TIInII'lHbIX MOHrOJIOIIp,OB. TaRIIM 06pa30M, BapIIa lI11
::JToro IIpII3HaKa IVwrYT IIpe CTaBIITb CIIe IIaJIbHbIn IIHTepec IIPII 05cymp,eHIIII
IIp05JIeMbI HaJIII'lIIH II yp,eJIbHoro Beca eBponeOIIp,Hon npIIMeCII B COCTaBe xa-
KaCOB.
)J;onOJIHIITeJIbHbIn MaTepIIaJI p,JIH cymp,eHIIH 0 pa3BIITIIII nepeHOCbH y xa-
KaCCKIIX rpynn p,aeT paCCMOTpeHlle BapIIa IIn p,aKpllaJIbHOrO YRa3aTeJIH..
T. e. COOTHomeHIIH p,aKpIIaJIbHOn BbICOTbI II p,aKpllaJIbHOn llIIIpIIHbI:
TYBIIHD;bI
TeJIenTIITl>I
Ka'lIIHI'\bI
CaraHD;bI
42.5(41)
41,5(49)
51,4 (44)
53,5 (31)
Pio:ii6aJIl>I 47,6 (26)
EeJIbTl>Ipl>I 50,5 (46)
PyccKIIe 61,1 (80)
TYPKMeHl>I 59,8 (7)
A3ep6a:iip;maHI'\bI 65,5 (13)
378
;
Bce XaKaCCKlle rpYIIIIbI 3alUIMalOT IIpOMelliYTO'IHOe nOJIOmeHIIe Memp,y TII-
IIlI'IHblMII MOHrOJIOIIp,aMII II eBpOneOIIp,aMII. OTJIII'IIIH caraiIu,eB, Ka'IIIH eB II
OeJIbTbIpOB OT TYBIIH eB II TeJIeHrIiTOB p;ame OOJIbIIIe, 'IeM OT TypRMeHOB.
TOJIbKO Kon6aJIbI OTJIlI'IalOTCH OT TYBIIH eB II TeJIeHrlITOB B MeHbmen CTene-
IUI. 'IeM OT TypKMeHOB. ,l..(aKplIaJIbHbIn yKa3aTeJIb, CJIep,OBaTeJIbHO, BXOp,IIT B
'IIICJIO ITpI13HaKOB, pa3rpaHII'IIIBalO IIX KJIaGClI'IeCRIIX npep,CTaBIITeJIen 60JIb-
IIIon MOHrOJIOIIp,HOH paCbl II xaKaCCKlIe rpynnbl.
ITepeXOp,IIM K paCCMOTpeHIIRJ BaplIa lIn CIIMOTlI'IeCKOn BbICOTbl:
TYBIIHD;l>I 2,8 (43) Pio:ii6aJIl>I 3,5 (26)
TeJIeHrIITbI 3,2 (50) EeJIbTl>Ipl>I 3,8 (46)
Ka'IIIH:L\l>I 3,2 (44) PyccIDIe 4,7(83)
Caraii:D;l>I 3,8(31) TypRMeHl>I 4,1(7)
ABep6aii:p;maH:L\M 5,6(13)
M3 xaKaCCKIIX rpynII TOJIbKO Ka'IIIH bI IIMelOT Ty me BeJIII'IlIHY CIIMOTII-
'IeCKOn BbICOTbI, 'ITO II TeJIeI-IrIITbI. Ho II OHa npeBbIlliaeT aHaJIOrlI'IHbIn pa3-
Mep y TYBIIH eB. Ron6aJIbI, caran bI II 6eJIbTbIpbI OTJIlI'IalOTCH OT TYBIIH eB
e e OOJIbIIIe, 06napYllilIBaH OT'IeTJIIIBOe YBeJIII'IeHlIe CIIMOTlI'IeCROn BbICOTbl.
TaKIIM 06pa30ivr, IIX npOMelliYTO'IHOe IIOJIOllieHIIe no OTHOIIIeHlI1O R 60JILmIIM
MOHrOJIOIIp,HOn II eBponeOII.'J;Hon pacaM no ::JTOMY nplI3HaKY He BbI3bIBaeT
COMHeHlIn. HalIOOJIbIIIee yp,aJIeHIIe OT KJIaCClI'IeCKIIX MOHrOJIOIIp,OB 06Hapy-
llilIBalOT, RaR II ITO HeKOTopblM paHee nepe'lIICJIeHHbIM npII3HaKaM, caran bI.
ITpep,CTaBJIeHlIe 0 BblCOTe HOCOBLIX KOCTelI MOllieT 6bITb p,OnOJIHeHO pac-
CMOTpeHIIelVI CIIMOTlI'IeCKOrO YRa3aTeJIH, T. e. OTHomeHIIH CIIMOTII'IecROn BbI-
>COTbI II ClIlVIOTlI'IeCKOII IIIlIplIHbI:
TYBIIH:L\bI 35,2 (43)
TeJIeHrIITbi 40,4 (50)
Pia'IIIHD;l>I 50,3 (44)
CaraiiD;bI 48,8 (31)
Pio:ii6aJIl>I 42,0 (26)
EeJIbTbrpl>I 52,0 (46)
pYCCRlIe 50,4(83)
TYPRMeHM 53,2 (7)
A3ep6aiip;maH:L\l>I 55,0 (13)
Pa3JIII'IIIH no STOMY nplI3HaRY Me}[{p,y TlInlI'IHbIMII MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIMII II
xaKaCCKIIMII rpYIInaMII He MeHee p,eMOHCTpaTIIBHbI, 'IeM no npep,blp,yr::qeMY.
ITpaBp,a, ,BeJIII'IIIHa YKa3aTeJIH y Kon6aJIOB ep;Ba npeBbImaeT aHaJIOrlI'IHbIn
pa3Mep Y TeJIeHrIITOB, HO OCTaJIbHbIe xaRaCCKlIe rpynnbI o6HapYllilIBalOT
BIIO.'IHe OT'IeT JIIIBbIii cp;BlIr B nanpaBJIenIIlI' nplIOJIIIllieHIIH K eBpOIIeOllp,HbIM
rpynnaM. Y 6eJILTbIpOB BeJIlI'IlIHa YKa3aTeJIH p,allie 60JIbIIIe, 'IeM y pYCCRon
ceplIlI, y Ra'IIIH eB COBIIap;aeT C pa3MepaMII, xapaKTepHbIMII p,JIH PYCCKIIX
'IepenOB. B oo eM, CJIep,OBaTeJIbIIO, MacmTao pa3JIII'IIIn Mellip,y xaRaCCKIIMII
rpynnaMII II B3HTbIMlI p,JIH cpaBHeHIIH MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIMII II eBponeOIIp,HbIMII
nonYJIH IIHMII HeOp,IIHaROB: 110 BeJIII'IlIHaM p;aKplIaJIbHOrO YRa3aTeJIH nepBbIe
OTJIlI'IalOTCH OT eBponeOIIp;OB MeHbme, 'IeM OT MOHrOJIOIIp;OB.
CeMb paCCMOTpeHHbIX RpaHIIOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX nplI3HaKOB p;alOT cyr::qeCTBeH-
HbIn MaTeplIaJI p,JIH cy}[{p,eHIIH 0 ROJIlI'IeCTBe MoPiPOJIOrII'IeCKIIX oc06elUIOCTen,
p,IIiPiPepeH lIpYIOr::qIIX RJIaCClI'IeCKIIX MOHrOJIOIIp,OB CeBepHon A3II11 II xaRac-
CKlIe rpynnbI. TOJIbRO 110 BapIIa IIHM 31IT0l\IaKCIIJIJIHpHOrO yrJIa ropII30HTaJIb-
Hon npoiPlIJIlIpOBKII II yrJIa BbIcTynaHIIH Hoca xaRaCbI He OTJIII'laIOTCH OT TY-
BIIH eB II TeJIeHrIlTOB, IICKJIIO'laH, KOne'IHO, caraiIu,eB, II no STIIM npll3HaRaM
3anIIMalO IIX oc060e MeCTO. ITo OCTaJIbHbIM nplI3naKaM Bce xaRaCCKlIe rpYII-
nbI 3aHIIMalOT npOMelliYTO'IHOe nOJIOmeHlIe Mellip,y TYBIIH aMII II TCJIeHrIITaMII,
'C op,Hon CTOpOHbI, II PYCCKIIl\III, TypKMeHaMII II a3ep6anp,lliaH aMII - C p,py-
ron. ITo p,aKplIaJIbHOMY II CIIMOTlI'IeCKOMY YRa3aTeJIlO OTJIII'IIlH xaRaCOB OT
TypRMeHOB II PYCCKIIX p,ame MeHbme, 'IeM pa3JIII'IIIH IIX C TeJIeHrIITaMII II TY-
379
Blnu aMII. TaKIIM 06pa30M, KpaIIIIOJIOrlI'IeCKlIn MaTt plIaJI MOmeT paCCMaTplI-
BaTbCH KaK OCHOBaTeJIbnbIn aprYM6HT B nOJIb3Y npaBOMepHOCTII nepeCMOTpa
I'lIIIOTe3bI A. 11. Hpxo 06 OTCYTCTBIIIJ eBpOneOIIlJ,Hoii: rrpIIMeCII B COCTaBe xa-
KaCOB.
I1:3RecTHoe IIpep,CTaBJIeHlIe 06 y):(eJIbHOM Bece eBporreolI):(Hon rrplIMeCII B
Ram.a:on 1I3 ::JTHII'IeCKlIx rpynn xaKaCOB MomeT 6bITb COCTaBJIeHO C nOMor::qblO
Toro llie rrplIeMa, KOTopbIn 6bIJI IICnOJIb30BaH IIplI CYMMlIpOBaHlI1I IIOKa3aTe-
JIen COMaTO.1IOrII'IeCRIIX npII3HaKOB. HIIme CJIep,yeT pacnpep,eJIeHIIe rpynrr 110
Kam.a:OMY nplI31IaKY B nopHD;Ke napaCTaHIIH xapaKTepHbIX p,JIH 60JIblliOH
eBpOrreOIIp,IIoM paCbl BeJIlI'IIIH rrplI3HaKa. TaRIIM 06pa30M. 113 ::JTOrO paCIIpe-
p,eJIeHIIH HCHO, '1TO 5aJIJIOBOe 0603Ha'leHlIe 110 Ha3mraJIHpHoMY II 3IIrOMaKCIIJI-
JIHpHOMY yrJIaM ropII30HTaJIbHOn npoiPlIJIlIpOBKII B03pacTaeT no Mepe YMeHb-
llieHIIH aOCOJIIOTHOn BeJIII'IIIHbI yrJIOB, Torp,a KaK no yrJIY HOCOBblX ROC Ten R
JIIIHIIII JIIU eBOro rrpmfmJIH OHO B03paCTaeT rrapaJIJIeJIbHO HapaCTaHIIIO a6co-
JIIOTI-IOn BeJIII'IIIHbI rrpII3I-JaKa.
HaaOluan.npllbJii YI'Oll 3Hl'oIUaRCIIJIJ1HpHbUi yron
TeJIeHrHTl>I 1 BeJIbTblpl>I 6 TYBHHl{bI 1 CaraH:L\bI
TYBIIH:L\bI 2 TypKMeHbI 7 Pi OH6 aJIbI 2 TYPRMeHl>I
Ha'lIIHl{bI 3 PYCCKIH' 8 EeJIbTl>IpbI 3 PyccRIIe
Caraiil{l>I 4 A3ep6aiiAlI\a H :L\l>I 9 TCJIenrHTbI 4 A3ep6aiip;maH:L\bI
Hoii6aJIl>I 5 Pia'lHHl{bI 5
Yron Hoca ]:{aRpHanbHaH BbICOTa
Hoii6aJIl>I 1 CaralIl{bI 6 TeJIeHrHTl>I 1 CaraHl{l>I
TYBHH:L\l>I 2 A3epoaiil1 lliaH :L\bI 7 TYBHH:L\l>I 2 TypI>MeHl>I
EeJIbTl>Ipl>I 3 TYPluIeHl>I 8 KOR6aJIl>I 3 Pycclme
Ha'IIIHl{l>I -4 PyccKHe 9 Pia'IIIHl{bI 4 A3ep6aii):lmaH:L\l>I
TeJIeHrIITbI 5 EeJIbTbIpl>I 5
]:{8KpH8nbHbJiCf > R.aaa Ten b
TeJIeHmTl>I 1 CaraRl{l>I 6
TYBIIJI:L\bI 2 TypKMellbJ 7
KOR6aJIl>I 3 pYCCRIIe 8
EeJIbTl>IpbI 4 A3ep6aiiAmaH:L\l>I 9
Ha'IIIHl{l>I 5
CII.MOTU'IeCR.aJl BbICOT8
TYBHH:L\l>I
TeJIeHrHTbI
Ha'lHHl{l>I
Hoii6aJIl>I
EeJIbTl>Ipl>I
1
2,5*
2,5
4
5,5
CUMOTHQeCKHM YK838Tenb
5,5
7
8
9
TYBHH:L\bI
TeJIeHrHTl>I
Pioii6aJIl>I
Ca raiil{l>I
Ha'IHJIl{bI
1
2
3
4
5
CaralI:L\bI
TypIUrelll>I
PyccRHe
A3ep6aRp;rKallI'\hl
EeJIbTl>IpbI
PyccKHe
TYPRMeHl>I
A3ep6aiiAmaH:L\bI
6
7
8
9
6
7
8
9
6
7
8
9
* HaR H IIPH CYMMHpoBaHHH COMaTOJIOrJPleCRHX AaHHl>IX, p;p06HaH 6aJIJIoBaH xapaRTe-
pHCTHRa IIOJIyqaeTcH B TOM CJIyqae, eCJIH p;Be rpyrrIIl>I HMeIOT Op;HHaROBl>Ie a6coJIIOT-
Hl>Ie BemI'IHHl>I IIpII3HaRa.
380
ITpII CYMMIIpOBaUIIII 5aJIJIOBbIX 0503Ha'IeHlln no Kamp,OMY npII3HaRY He
B03IIHKaeT TPyp,HocTen, IIMeBmIIXCH npH CYMMHpOBaHlI1I 6aJIJIOBblX nOI\a3aTe-
JIen COMaTOJIOrlI'leCKOn IIIKaJIbI, TaK I\aR ROJIII'tIeCTBO conOCTaBJIHeMblX no
Ramp,OMY KpaHIIOJIOrlI'IeCKOMY nplI3HaKY rpynn Op,IIHaROBO. CYMMapHO 5aJI-
JIOBbIe xapaKTeplICTIIKII Ramp,on rpynnbI no BceMY KOMIIJIeRCY KpaHIIOJIOrlI'le-
CKIIX npII3HaKOB BbIrJIH,lJ;HT CJIe,lJ;YIO HM 06pa30M:
EeJIbTl>IpbI 4,6
CaraH l>I 5,4
TypRl'.IeHl>I 7,3
PyccIUIe 8,0
A3ep6aiip;lliaH:L\l>I 8,7
ITOpHp,OK paCIIOJIOmeHIIH xaRaCCKIIX rpynn no KpaHIIOJIOrlI'leCKIIM npIl-
3HaKaM cooTBeTcTByeT IIX pacnpep,eJIeHIIIO BHYTPII COMaTOJIOlTI'IeCKOn IIIKaJlbI.
8TO HB.rrHeTCH JIY'ImlIM p,oKa3aTeJIJ>cTBoM 06'beInIIBHocTII nOJIY'IaeMbIX iJ,aH-
HbIX. Bce xaKaCCKlIe rpynIIbI II npII CYMMIIpoBaHlI1I nplI3HaKoB coxpauHIOT
OTJIII'IIIH OT TYBIIH eB II TeJIeHrIITOB, B3HTbIX B Ka'IeCTBe STaJIOHa.
TaRIIM 06pa30M, paccMoTpeHIIe BapIIa un KpaHIIOJIOrII'leCKIIX IIplI3HaKoB
nplIBop,IIT R BbIBOp,y, 'ITO HeKOTOpbIe OC06eHl-IOCTII cTpoeHIIH MHrRIlX TRaHen
JIII a, ROTOpbIe iPlIKCIIPYIOTCH Ha mIIBOM cy6'beRTe II KOTopbIe A. 11. Hpxo
C'IlITaJI B03HIIKIIIIIMII 6e3 y'laCTIIH ellponeolIp,Hon nplIMeCII, He MOrJIII 06pa-
30BaTbcH B 'lIICTO MOHrOJIOII,lJ;HOn nonYJIH IIII B pe3YJIbTaTe KaKIIX-TO BHYT-
peHHIIX npo eCCOB caMopa3BIITHH. Tpyp,HOCTII, BCTaBaBmlIe nepep, A. II. Hpxo
B OO'hHCHeHIIII IIapaJIJIeJIbHOrO II He3aBIICIIMoro OT eBponeOIIp,Hon nplIMeCII
IIOCBeTJIeHIIH nlIrMeHTa 1I1I y xaRaCOB no cpaBHeHlI10 C TIIIIlI'IHbIMIJ MOHro-
JIOIIp,aMII CeBepHon A3IIJiJ II B03HIIKHOBeHIIH Cp,BIIrOB no JJ:pyrllM npll3HaRaM
B HanpaBJIeHIIII npII6mImeHIIH R eBponeOIIJJ:I1bIM rpynnaM, YBeJIlI'llIBalOTCH II
p,eJIaIOTCH HenpeOJJ:OJIIIMbIMII npII meJIaHIIII nepeHeCTII rlInOTe3Y B 05JIaCTb
aHaJIII3a KpaHIIOJIOrlI'IeCRIIX ,lJ;aHHbIX. ITO::JTOMY B HaCTOHr::qee Bpel\IH. nOCJIe
HaROnJIeIIlIH COOTBeTCTBYIOr::qero MaTeplIa.rra, nymHo OKOH'IaTeJIbHO OTKa3aTbCH
OT I'IInOTe3bI 06 OTCYTCTBIIIJ eBporreolIp,Hon npIIMeclI B COCTaBe xaKaCOB II
C'lIITaTb, 'ITO rIInOTe3a A. II. Hpxo npep,CTaBJIHeT JIlImb IICTOplI'IeCKlIn IIH-
Tepec.
RpaHIIOJIOrIl'IeCKlIe p,aHHble, TaR me RaK II pe3YJIbTaTbI aIITpOnOJIorlI'le-
CKoro II3Y'leHIIH COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH, rOBopHT 0 HeOp,IIHaKOBOM y'laCTIIII
eBponeOIIp,HbIX SJIeMeIITOB B iPOpMlIpOBaII1I1I pa3JIII'IHbIX ::JTHII'IeCKIIX rpynn
xaKaCCKoro Hapop,a. O'leBIlp,HO, 'ITO IIX pOJIL 6bIJIa 66JIbIIIen B STHoreHe3e
caralI eB II 6eJIbTbIpOB, HemeJIII OCTaJIbHbIX xaKaCCKIIX rpYIIII. Op,HaKO caM no
ce6e ::JTOT iPaKT He CBIIp,eTeJIbCTByeT, pa3YMeeTCH, 0 CMemaHHOCTII eBpo-
rreOIIiJ,HOrO KOMnOHeHTa II ero pa3JllI'IIIOM npOIIcxomp,eHIIII. Pe'lb MomeT
IID,TII npOCTO 0 pa3HOM yp,eJIbHOM Bece Op,HIlX II Tex me no npOIICXOmp,eHlIlO'
eBponeOIIp,HbIX ::JJIeMeHTOB B COCTaBe xaKaCCKIIX rpynn.
TYBIIH:L\l>I
TeJIeHmTl>I
Pioii6aJIbI
l\:a'IIIH:L\bI
1,6
2,4
3,0
4,1
P ACOBblE KOMllOHEHTbI BTOPOI'O 110PH)J;KA
COBpeMeHHble npep,CTaBJIeHIIH B 06JIaCTII aHTpOIIOJIOrlI'leCKOn CIICTeMaTIIKII
CII6IIpCKIIX MOHrOJIOIIp,OB OCHOBbIBalOTCH Ha BbIp,eJIeHIIII P,BYX aHTpOnOJIOrlI'Ie-
CKIIX TlInOB, JIMelO IIX CMemaHHoe npOIIcxomp,enIIe, - ypaJIbCKOrO II IOmHO-
ClI6lIpCKoro. R ypaJIbCKOMY TIIIIY OTHOCHTCH caMoep,o- II yrpoH3bI'IHbIe Ha-
porrHOCTII 3aIIap:Hon CII6IIpII - xaHTbI, HeH bI, CeJIbKYIIbI II p,p. 27 HJIacclI'Ie-
CRIIMII npep,cTaBIITeJIHMII IOmHocII611pcKoro TIIIIa HBJIHIOTCH Ra3aXII II KIIprII-
3b1 28 . rIInOTe3a He3aBIICIIMoro OT eBpOneOII,l.IHOn nplIMeCII npOlIcxomp,eHIIH
IOmHOCII6IIpCKOrO TlIna, Bblp,BIIHYTaH A. II. Hpxo, IIOp,BeprJIaCb IIC'IepnbIBalO-
381
lD,en RplITIIKe 29, II B HaCTOHlD,ee BpeMH CMemaHHoe IIpOIICXOllip,eHlIe aToro
TIIITa MOllieT C'IlITaTbCH HeCOMHeHHbIM 30. rlInOTe3a CMemaHHoro IIpOlIcxom-
p,eHIIH ypaJIbCKOrO TIIIIa, BnepBbIe BbICKa3aHHaH B 1941 r. pHp,OM IICCJIep,OBa-
TeJIen, nOJIY'IlIJIa nop,p,epmRY B MHOrO'IIICJIeHHbIX pa60Tax 110 aHTpOnOJIOrlI1I
p,peBHero II COBpeMeIIHoro HaCeJIeHIIH 3ana Hon CII6IIpII 31 II R HacToHr::qeMY
MOMeIlTY TaKllie 1\lOllieT C'IIITaTbCH TBep o YCTaHOBJIeHHbIM iPaKToM. HecRoJIb-
RO JIeT Ha3ap, B. B. BYHaK onYOJIIIKOBaJI CTaTblO, B KOTOpOM OTplI aTeJIbHO
'OTHeCCH R aTOM TO'IKe 3peIIIIH II HaCTalIBaJI Ha Hep,lIiPiPepeH lIpOBaHHOM IIpO-
IICXOllip,eHIIII ypaJIbCKOrO TlIna 3\ op,HaKO OCHOBHbIe nOJIOllieHIIH STon CTaTbll
<cpa3Y rI,e BCTpeTIIJIII yoeP,IITeJIbHbIe B03pallieHIIH 33. TaKIIM 06pa30M, YCTa-
HOBJIeHIIe iPaKTa HaJIII'IIIH eBponeOIIp,Hon npIIMeCII B COcTaBe xaKacOB Tpe6yeT
CpaBl-IeHIIH IIX C npep,CTaBIITeJIHMII ypaJIbCKOrO II IOmHOCII6IIpCKOrO TllnOB.
B Ka'IeCTBe nepBbIx MormI 6bI 6bITb BbIopaHbI xaHTbI II CeJIbKYIIbI, OTHOCH-
lD,lIeCH K pa3HbIM H3bIKOBbIM ceMbHM, HO npIIHa JIelliar::qlle K ep,IIHOMY aHTpo-
IIOJIOrlI'IeCKOMY TlIny, B Ka'IeCTBe BTCpblX - Ra3axII II RIIprlI3bI.
H COmaJIeIIIIIO, npHMoe conOCTaBJIeHlIe Bcex aTIIX rpynII HeB03MomHO, TaR
RaK OHII 1I3Y'IaJIIICb pa3JIII'IHbIMII pa60THIIRaMII, II, CJIep,OBaTeJIbHO, MaTeplla-
JIbI 110 HIIM rrJIOXO CpaBHn1\IbI. A. 11. .Hpxo He pa60TaJI B 3anap,Hon C1I61IplI,
r. «D. Ae6e , ony6JIIIKOBaBmlIn CTaTblO no aHTpOIIOJIOrlllI ce.:rbKYIIoB II xaH-
TbI 3\ He npOII3BOp,IIJI aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX IICCJIep,OBaHIIn Ha TeppIITopIIII
AJITae-CaHHCKoro HaropbH. AJIH npeOp,OJIeHIIH aTon Tpyp,HOCTII MbI p,omHHbl
IIp,TII He nYTeM npH1\lOrO cpaBHeHIIH, a rrYTeM KOCBeHHblX conOCTaBJIeHlIn.
B nepBYIO O'iepep,b IICCJIep,OBaHHble r. «D. Aef)e oM HapbIMCRlIe CeJIbRynbl II
BaXOBCKlIe xaHTbl p,OJIlliHLI ObITb COIIOCTaBJIeHbl C 1I3Y'IeIIHbIMII 11M me Ka3a-
xaMII pa3JIII'IHbIX TepplITOplIaJIbHbIX rpynn *. 8TO p,aCT HaM 113BeCTHoe npep,-
CTaBJIeHIIe 0 BeJIlI'IIIHe pa3JIII'IIIn Memp,y npep,CTaBIITeJIHMII ypaJIbCKOrO II
IOlliHOCIIOIIpCKoro aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCRIIX TIInOB. IToCJIe SToro p,aHHbIe 110 IICCJIe-
p;OBaHHbIM A. 11. .Hpxo xaRaCCKIIM rpynnaM MorYT 6bITb COIIOCTaBJIeHbI C
aHHbDIII no IICCJIep,OBaIIHbIM IIM llie Ra3axaM II KIIprlI3aM 35. 3aKJIIO'IIITeJIb-
HbIM aTanOM cpaBHeHIIH 6y eT OIIpe eJIeHIIe HanpaBJIeIlIIH OTJIII'IlIn CeJIbKY-
nOB II xaHTbl, C O Hon CTOpOHbI, II xaKaCOB - C p,pyron, OT IIpep,CTaBIITeJIen
IOnnlOCII611pCKoro TIIna. ECJIII CeJIbKYIIbI II xaHTbI 6Y YT OTJIlI'IaTbCH OT IIC-
CJIel OBaHHbIX r. «D. Ae6e.u;OM Ra3aXOB B TOM llie HanpaBJIeHIIII, B KaKOM xa-
RaCLI OTJIIIqalOTCH OT KIIpnI30B II rm3aXOB, IICC.TJ:e;']:OBaHHbIX A. 11. .Hpxo, MbI
6YJJ:elVI lIMeTb OCHOBaHIIe YTBeplli aTb, 'ITO xaKaCbI OTHOCHTCH K TOMY me
aHTpOllOJIOrlI'IeCKOMY TlIny, KaKon npep,CTaBJIeH y CeJIbKynoB II XaHTbI.
r. «D. Ae6e IICCJIe OBaJI meCTb TeppIITOplIaJIbHblX rpynn Ka3aXCKoro Ha-
po a: Ka3aXOB IIJIlInCKIIX, BOCTO'IHOKa3aXCTaHCKIIX, KaparaH IIHCKIIX, 3anap,-
HblX, aJIMa-aTIIIICKIIX II IOlliHblX 3". IToCJIep,HlIe, no ero p,aHHbIM, IIMelOT OT-
'IeTJIIIBO BbIpalliermylO nplIlVIeCb naMlIpo-iPepraIIcRoro TlIna, xapaKTepHoro
.p,JIH l1pe06JIa aIOr::qen MaCCbl'.y36eKOB II Tap,fI>IIKOB, II noaTOMY IICI\JIIO'IeHbl 113
paCCMOTpeHIIH. Ha3axII OCTaJIbHbIX rpynII, I>pOlVIe IIJIIrnCKOn, OTHOCHTCH K
rrepBon B03paCTIlOM I,aTeroplIlI, T. e. IICCJIep,OBaJIIICb B B03paCTe 20-25 JIeT,
II {aHHbre 110 HIIM B CIIJIY B03pacTHon p,IIHaMIIKII no 60JIbmlIHcTBY onllca-
* AHTpOnOJIOrIl'IeCRI'Ill: OTpH):\ RHpnI3CROll: ROMIIJIeRCHOii apxeOJIoro-9THorpaqm'leCROll: 3R-
cnep;H:L\HH, pa60TaBIIIeR Ha TeppHTOpl'IH KHprmlHH B 1953-1954 rr. no):\ PYROBO):\CTBOM
r. <1>. .n;e6e:L\a, c06paJI 06IIIIIpHl>Ill: MaTepHaJI IIO aHTpOnOJIOmH pa3JIH'IHbIX rpYIIII Rl'Ip-
rH30B (RpoMe pa60T, IIepe'IHCJIeHHbIX B IIpHMe'I. 32, CM.: 30.ltOTapeea n. M. COMaTOJIO-
rH'IeCRl'Ie HCCJIep;OBamIH B <1>epraHCROll: p;OJIHHe 1/ Tp. KHprH3. apXeOJI.-9THorp. 9Rcne-
;J)lIJrrH. T. 1; i1IuK.wweecKa.n H. H. Pi Borrpocy 00 yp;eJlbHml BOCO .QeHTpa.!IbHOa3IIaT-
CRoro 3JIeMeHTa B 06pa30BaHI'IH aHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCROrO THna Rl'IprHBOB /1 TaM me. T. II.)
Op;HaRO onHcaTeJIbHl>Ie IIpH3HaKH BO Bcex 9THX rpynnax onpeAeJIHJIHCb He r. <1>. ,lI;e-
6en;OM, a H. H. MHRJIaIlleBcRoii. II09TOMY p;aHHl>Ie no HHM HenpHrOp;Hl>I AJIH IIpHMOrO
COIIOCTaBJIeHHH C ):\aHHl>Il'.1I1 r. <1>. ,lI;e6en;a.
382
TeJIblIbIX II 1I3MepIITeJIbHblX nplI3HaKOB He MOryT 6e3 COOTBeTCTBYIOr::qIIX no-
IIpaBOK COIIOCTaBJIHTbCH c p,aIlHbIMII no CeJIbKYIIaM II XaHTbI. I1cnoJIb30BaH-
Hble IIonpaBKII, IIJIII, IIHbIMII CJIOBaMII, COOTHomeHIIH BeJIn'IIIH OTp,eJIbHbIX
npU3HaKOB no B03paCTHblM KaTeropIIHM, npep,CTaBJIeHbl B Ta6JI. 29. GHII BbI-
qUCJIeHbI Ha OCHOBaHlI1I MaTepIIaJIOB B03pacTHon pa36IIBKII pa3JIII'IHblX MOH-
rOJIOIIp,HbIX II eBponeOIIp,HblX rpynlI, cop,epm IIXCH B pa60Tax r. CD. )J,e6e a,.
M. r. JIeBIIHa II A. 11. .Hpxo 37. ITOCKOJIbKY COOTHomeHlIe nepBon II P,BYX'
CTapmlIX B03paCTHblX rpynn y CeJIbRynOB II xaHTbl IIpIIOJIII3IITeJIbHO paBHO'
OTHomeHUIO ep,UHII bl K P,BYM, TaKoe me COOTHomeHlIe IIOJIOmeHO B OCHOBY
IIplI KoppeK IIII onlICaTeJIbHblX II II3MeplITeJIbHblX nplI3HaKOB no pa3JIII'IHblM
rpynnaM Ka3aXOB.
ITOJIY'leHHble p,aHHble npep,CTaBJIeHbl B Ta6JI. 30, 113 KOTopon BIIp,HO, 'ITO'
npep,CTaBIITeJIlI ypaJIbCKOrO II IOJImOCIIOlIpCKoro TIInOB OTJIlPIaIOTCfI Ll,pyr OT
p,:pyra npo eHTOM naJIII'IIIH TeMHblX r JIa3, CTeneHblO ynJIor::qeHHOCTII JIII a B
ropII30HTaJIbHOn nJIOCKOCTII, npo eHTOM JIaJIII'IIIH SIIIIKanTyca II pa3BIITIIeM
pa3JIII'IHbIX OTp,eJIOB CKJIap,KII BepXHero BeKa, p,eTaJIHMII CTpoeHIIH II pa3Me-
paMII Hoca, pa3Mepa III JIII a II rOJIOBbl II p,JIIIHOn TeJIa. Y nepBblX no cpaBHe-
HIIIO co BTOpblMII 60JIee CBeTJIble rJIa3a, 60JIee npoiPlIJIlIpOBaHHoe JIII O, snll-
KaHTYC IIpeLl,CTaBJIeH B 60JIbmeM npo eHTe CJIY'IaeB, CIIJIbHee pa3BIITa CKJIap,-
Ka BeKa B cpep,HeM II HapymHoM OTl\eJIaX, BbIme nepeHOCbe II KOH'IIIK Hoca,
BorHYTble II 1I3BIIJIIICTbIe iPOpMbI 06r::qero npoiPlIJIH Hoca npeOOJIap,alOT Hap,
BblIIYKJIblMII II npHMblMII, MeHbme pa3MepbI JIII a II Hoca, 60JIbme npOp,OJIb-
HblM p,lIaMeTp '1epeIIHOn Kop06KII, HIIme rOJIOBHOn YKa3aTeJIb II MeHbme p,JIII-
Ha TeJIa. TaKIIM 06pa30M, IIHTepeCYIOr::qlIe Hac pa3JIII'IllH Memp,y npep,CTaBII-
TeJIH1\HI ypaJIbCKOrO II IOmHOCII6IIpCKOrO TlInOB BbIHBJIHIOTCH B p,eBHTII OIIlIca-
TeJIbHblX II ceMII 1I3MeplITeJIbHblX IIpn3HaKax. 113 HIIX He O'ieIlb p,OKa3aTeJIb-
HblMII CJIep,yeT C'IIITaTb JIlImb pa3JIII'IIIH B roplI30HTaJIbHOn YIIJIor::qeHHOCTII
JIn a II BblCOTe nepeHOCbH, TaK KaK no OTHOilieHlI1O K HIIM HeT YBepeHHoeTII
B OKOH'IaTeJIbHOn YHII II lIpOBaHHOCTII p,aHHblX II nOJIHOM CHHTIIII BJIIIHHIIH
B03paCTHon 1I3MeH'IlIBOCTII B pe3YJIbTaTe KOppeK IIII. ITo OTHomeHllIO K
OCTaJIbHblM IIplI3HaKaM peaJIbHOCTb pa3JIII'IIIn He BbI3bIBaeT cepbe3HblX CO-
MHeHlIn. ITOSTOMY IIepe'IIICJIeHHble IIplI3HaKII D,eJIeC006pa3HO nOJIOmUTb B
OCHOBY nplI conOCTaBJIeHlI1I xaKaCCKIIX rpynn C npep,CTaBIITeJIHMII IOmHOCII-
6IIpCKOrO TIIIIa (Ta6JI. 31). Heop,IIHaKoBoe KOJIII'IeCTBO IIplI3HaKOB B Ta6JI. 30
II 31 06'bHCHHeTCH OTCYTCTBlIeM B nYOJIIIKa IIHx A. 11. .Hpxo COOTBeTcTBylOr::qIIX
p,aHHbIX. 8TIIM me 06'bHCHHeTCH II 3aMeHa xapaKTepIICTIIKII CTpoemm o6ID,ero
IIpOiPlIJIH cnlIHKII Hoca p,aHHbIMII no CTpoeHUIO KOCTlIon 'IaCTII CIIIIHKII noca,
KOTopbIe MoryT 6blTb IICnOJIb30BaHbl XOTH 6bI B KR'IeCTBe IIpu6JIII3IITeJIbHOrO
aKBIIBaJIeHTa.
)J,JIH xapaKTeplICTIIKII nOCJIep,HIIX IICnOJIb30BaHbl p,aHHbIe 110 'IyncKon
rpYIIIIe Ka3aXOB II KIIprlI3aM THHb-IllaIIH 113 YKa3aHHOII IIy6JIIIKa IIII
A. 11. .HpXO. Pa3JIlPIIIH Memp,y STIIMII rpynnaMII II. xaKacaMII 110 MHorlIM
IIpII3HaKaM IIP,YT B TOM me IIaIIpaBJIeHIIIl, "ITO II Memp,y Ka3axaMlI II npep,-
CTaBIITeJIHMII ypaJIbCKOn rpYIInbl, IICCJIep,OBaHHbIMII r. CD. )J,e6e OM. H '1UCJIY
TaKIIX nplI3HaKOB OTHOCHTCH ropII30HTaJIbHaH IIpoiPlIJIlIpOBKa JIII a, npo eHT
HaJIII'IIIH snIIKaHTyca, npo eHT BbIllYKJIblX iPOpM CIIIIHKII Hoca (IICKJIIO'IaH
Kon6aJIOB), Bce 1I3MeplITeJIbHble nplI3HaKII II B KaKOII-TO Mepe nOJIOmeHlle
KOH'IIIKa Hoca. IT pOTIIBOIIOJIOmHOe HanpaBJIeHlIe pa3JIII'IIIn MbI lIMe eM p,JIH
npo eHTa TeMHbIX OTTeHKOB rJIa3 II npHMblX iPOpM CIIIIHKII Hoca, onHTb IIC-
KJIIO'IaH Kon6aJIOB. ITo pa3BIITIIlO CKJIap,KII BepXHero BeKa B Cpep,lIeM II Ha-
pymHoM OTp,eJIaX II IIpo eHTY BorHYTblX iPOpM cnIIHKII Hoca xaKaCCKlIe rpyn-
nbl 3aHIIMalOT pa3JIII'IHOe nOJIOmeHlIe no OTHomeHlllO K rpynIIaM IOmHOCII-
6IIpCKOrO TllIIa. Y Kbl3bIJIb eB II Ka'IIIH eB CKJIap,Ka BepXHero BeKa pa3BIITa
883
'.;
Ta6JIlI:L\a 29
COOTHOIIIeHue BeJIlrlJ:IIH onHCaTeJIbHbIX H H3MepHTeJIbHbIX npH3HaROB
B pa3HbIx B03pacTHbIx KaTerOpHJlx. Mym'lHllbI
t
B03pacTHaH rpYIIIIa
llpII3HaR
II III
POCT 60PO):\bI * 1,00 1,50 1,90
IJ;BeT rJI83, % TeMHblX 1,00 0,90 0,85
rOpU30HT8JIbH8H npolfJnJInpOBR8 JIn:L\8 1,00 1,00 1,00
3nnR8HTYC, % BaJIH'lIIH * 1.00 0,625 0,125
CKJIap;Ka BepxHero neKa, % H8JIH'lI:lH
BHYTPCHHHH CTopOHa 1,00 0,80 0,60
cpep;HHH OTp;eJI 1,00 0,90 0,90
H8pymH8H cTopoHa 1,00 0,95 0,95
Bl>ICOT8 nepeHocbH 1,00 1,05 1,05
06m;nH rrpolfJI1JIb CIlIIHRI1 Boca
% BorHYTl>IX 1,00 0,90 0,80
% BbIllYRJIl>IX 1,00 1,30 1,60
CooTHoIIIeHlle rrpHMl>IX H I13BnJIlICTl>IX 1,00 0.90 0,90
ITOJIOmeHI1e oceH H03p;pen 1,00 1,05 1.05
ITOJIOlli.eHne ROH'IIIRa Hoca 1,00 1,10 1,15
BbIcoTa BepxHeH ry6bI (onI1CaTeJIbHo) 1,00 1,05 1,15
ITPOIfJI1JIb BepxHeH ry6l>I 1,00 1,00 1,10
«TOJIm;I1H8,) BepxHeH ry6bI (orrHCaTeJIbHo) 1,00 0,90 0,75
«TOJIm;IIHa» HHlli.Hen ry6bI ( 0 rrHe8 TeJIbHO ) 1,00 0,95 0,80
lIaI{JIOH JI6a 1,00 0,90 0,90
Pa3BIITne H8p;6pOBbH 1,00 1,15 1,25
MopIfJOJIOrll'leCR8H Bl>ICOT8 JIH:L\a 1,000 1,019 1,033
CKYJIOB8H IIIIIPI1H8 1,000 1,016 1,019
IInmHe'leJIIOCTH8H IIII1PHH8 1,000 1,018 1,020
BbICOT8 Hoca OT IIIIlli.HerO KpaH 6poBeH 1,000 1,023 1,052
BbICOTa Hoca OT rrepeHocbH 1,000 1,030 1,056
llinplIHa Hoca 1,000 1,018 1,045
ITpOP;OJIbHbIH p;n8MeTp rOJIOBbI 1,000 1,008 1,011
IToIIepe'lHbIH ):\II8MeTp rOJIOBbI 1,000 1,003 1,003
HaIUIeHbIII8H IIII1pI1Ha JI68 1,000 1,000 1,000
)J;JIIIHa TeJIa 1,000 1,000 0,995
* no 3TIIM npII3HallaM B Ta6J1IIl\C 4JIII'YPIIPYlOT COOTHomCHIIH, npIIBcp;CHHLIC r. <1>. .!J:C6CQOM.
CIIJIbHee, qeM y Ra3aXOB II RlIprlI30B, y caran eB, Ron6aJIOB II 6eJIbTbIpOB-
.cJIa6ee. ITo npo eHTY BorHyrbIx iPOpM cnMHRII Boca Ka'IIIH bI, Ron6aJIbI II
.6eJIbTblpbI He OTJIIPIaIOTCH OT rpynn IOmHoCII6IIpCRoro TIIna, RbI3bIJIb bI OT-
RJIOHHIOTCH OT HIIX B TOM me HanpaBJIeHIIII, 'ITO II ypaJIbCRlIe rpynnbI, car an-
1I.bI, Hao60pOT,- B npOTIIBOnOJIOmHOM. HaKoHe , no BbICOTe nepeHOCbH BCe
xaKaCCRlle rpynnbI He OTJIlI'IalOTCH OT Ka3aXOB II KIIprII30B. TaKIIM OtJpa30M,
II3 16 np.H3HaKOB, p,IIiPiPepeH lIpYIOr::qIIX IOmHocII6IIpCKIIH II ypaJIbCKIIn TIInbI
II B3HTblX HaMil B KaqeCTBe OCHOBbI p,JIH conOCTaBJIeHIIH aTIIX TIInOB, xaRac-
.cKIIe rpynnbI no 11, T. e. no 60JIbunmCTBY, npII3HaRaM nonap,alOT B rpaHII bI
BapHa lIiI ypaJIbCKOrO TlIna (Ta6JI. 32). Op,HaKo II OTJIH'IIIHM IIX OT IIOCJIep,-
Hero HeJIb3H He npllp,aBaTL OIIpep,eJIeHHOe 3Ha'IeHIIe.
384
-
-
...
w
TaOJIH:L\a 30
Conoc'raBJtettlte npep;c'r8DB'reneii yp8nLcRoro B IOmHocu6upCJ.wro 'rHnoD no AaHHMM r. «11. j];eOC:L\3. MymttIfttbl
!:"
;:t
>
:0;
8
CD
CD
b;!
CeJIbKynbI XaHTbI RaaaxH
TIpII2HaH HapbIMCHIIe BaXOBCKIIe J BOCTO"t.IHO- I I
IIJIIIHCHIIe Ha33XCTaH- [ HaparaHp;IIII- aanap;HbW aJIMa-
CRIIC CKIIe aTIIHCHHe
POCT fiOPOP;I,I 2,10(60) 1,92 (99) 2,03 (99) 2,17 (G5) 2,02 (1i!0) 2,15 (7i!) 2,26 (83)
I BeT rJma, % TCMTJLJX 33,3 (71) 40,5(126) 50,5 (99) 58,1 (65) 63,7(130) 6G,G (73) 67,2 (83)
fOpH30IITaJIblIaJI npolfJHJIHPOBIW JIH:L\a 1,47 (70) 1,20(128) 1,22 (99) 1,14(65) 1,13 (130) 1,18(73) 1,12 (8: )
SrrHKaIITYc, % IIaJIII'lIUl 25,4(71) 23,6 (128) 19,2 (99) 16,4 (65) 19,7 (130) 15,3 (73) 14,5 (83)
CRJIaAKa BepxIIcro BeRa, % HaJIH'lI1JI 91,5(71) 93,7(128) 95,0(99) - - - -
BnyTpCHIIJIJI cTopoHa 1,20(71) 1,31 (128) 1,49 (99) 1,33 (65) 1,30 (130) 1,29 (73) 1,34(83)
cpep;HI1II OTP;CJI 1,82(71) 1,86 (128) 1,74(99) 1,63 (65) 1,60(130) 1,58 (73) 1,68 (83)
Hapylli.HaJI cTopOHa 1,83(71) 1,86(128) 1,74(99) 1,70(65) 1,67 (130) 1,65 (73) 1,76 (8:.n
BblcoTa rrcpCIIOCbJI 1,67 (70) 1,65 (128) 1,69 (99) 1,45 (65) 1,38 (130) 1,40 (73) 1,39 (83)
06m;IIM rrpolfJI1JIb CITHIIKH Hoca
% BorHYThIX 41,4 (70) 30,5 (128) 3,1 (99) 6,8 (65) 8,1 (130) 7,2 (73) 9,5 (83)
% np JIMLIX 47,2(70) 59,4(128) 77,6 (99) 53,5(65) 61,9 (130) 66,7 (73) 62,7 (8:)
% BbIIIyn:.TIblX - 0,8 (128) 12,2 (99) 29,3(65) 19,9 (130) 18,6 (73) 18,1 (83)
% II3BHJII1CTI>IX 11,4 (70) 9,3 (128) 7,1 (99) 10,4(65) 10,1 (130) 7,5(73) 9,7(83)
IIoJIolli.cHHC oceH H03P;pCM 1,96 (69) 1,95 (127) 1,93(99) 1,95 (65) 1,97 (130) 2,01 (7: ) 1,69 (83)
IIoJIollieHHe ROH'lJma Hoca 1,40(70) 1,55(128) 2,00 (99) 1,89 (65) 2,03 (130) 1,76 (73) 1,91 (83)
BblcoTa BepxHcM ryou (OTlHCaTCJIJ,Ho) 2,33(69) 2,18 (128) 2,19 (99) 2,28 (65) 2,33 (130) 2,39 (73) 2,36 (8:)
IIPOIfJIIJIb BepxHeii ryfibl 1,45 (69) 1,47 (123) 1,37 (99) 1,41, (li5) 1,43 (130) 1,44(73) 1,35 (83)
«TOJI IIIIa)} BepxIIcii ryoI,J (orrIICaTPJIbHo) 1,52 (69) 1,44(123) 1,36 (99) 1,7S ((is) 1,64(130) 1,65 (73) 1,66 (83)
HaKJIOII JIOa 2,69 (70) 2,56(128) 2,42 (99) 2,62 (G5) 2,62 (130) 2,56 (73) 2,58 (83)
Pa3BIITHC Hap;OpOBbJI 1,22 (70) . 1,32 (128) 1,56 (99) 1,22 «(;5) 1,23(130) 1,28 (73) 1,29 (83)
MopIfJOJIOrII'leCI{aH BLlCOTa JII1:L\a 126,7 (71) 129,4(127) 131,3 (99) 131,8 (G5) 131,1 (130) 131,2 (73) 130,7 (83)
CRYJIOBaH IIIHpIIHa 145,2(71) 149,7 (127) 150,0 (99) 1S0,l, (65) 151,0(130) 150,2 (73) 150,8 (83)
IIHlliHe'lemOCTHaH nUIpIIHa 112,9 (71) 115,2 (128) 114,6 (99) 112,6 (65) 114,5 (130) 113,8 (73) 114,S(83)
MopIfJOJIOrH'leCRIIM JIII:L\eBOH YJ{a3aTem, 87,6(71) 86,5(127) 875* 87,6 * 86,8 * 87,4 * 86,7 *
BblcoTa Hoca OT mmmcro Rpan fipoBeM 56,9 (69) 57,8(128) 63',0(99) 60,3 (65) 60,2 (130) 59,9 (73) 57,9 (83)
BblcoTa Hoca OT rrepenocI,H 50,9 (G9) 51,1 (128) 53,0(9 1) 51,9 (65) 52,0(130) 51,2 (73) 50,5 (8:)
IIJHpHHa Hoca 36,2(69) 3G,1 (128) 37,6(99) 38,1 (65) 37,4(130) 37,0 (73) 37,4 (83)
HOCOBOH YKa3aTCJIb OT HHlRrrcro RpaH upoBeii 63,9 (69) 63,S (128) 59,7 * 63,2 * 62,1 * 61,8 * 64,6 *
HOCOBOii YRa3aTeJIb OT ITepeHOCbH 71,3 (69) 71,8 (128) 70,9 * 73,4 * 71,9 * 72,3 * 74,1 *
IIpOp;O.TIbIIbIlI p;IIaMeTp rOJIOBbI 188,8 (71) 192,1 (127) 186,8 (99) 188,0 (G5) 187,5(130) 187,5 (73) 187,1 (83)
IIorrepe'lIIblii p;IIaMeTp rOJIOBbI 153,9 (71) 159,7(127) 159,1. (99) 159,6 (65) 160,1 (130) 159,1 (73) 159,4 (83)
fOJIOBHOll YKa3aTeJIb 81,5(71) 83,2 (127) 85,5 (9) 84,9 * 85,3 * 81,,9 * 85,2 *
aIIMeHbIIIaH rrUIpHIIa JIoa 104,9 (69) 107,2(127) - 107,0(65) 106,0 (130) 105,9 (73) 106,8 (83)
JIHHa TeJIa 1592(68) 1598 (120) 1661 (99) 1640(65) 1638 (130) 1646 (73) 1655(83)
w
00
CJ1
II
A
.. IIHp;eKc cpej:{HIIX.
Ta6JIUI 3 31
ConOCTaBJICHUC xaKaCCIDIX rpynn C npcAcT3BHTWInMH IOmHocH6Hpclwro THna no l\aHHbIM A. H. Hpxo. Mym'IIIHbI
I KhI3h1J1hl\bl I I\a'l11H1\hI I CarattJ.\hI I I\oi!6aJ1hI I BeJ1bTblphl I ,: ;
IIpll:maH
RllprU3hI
THUb-
lllaHbCH:UC
e,.,
00
C)
POCT UOpO}J;bI (y JIH:L\ CTapme 25 JIeT) 1,41 (104) 1,;lli (154) 1,59 (73) 1,61 (28) 1,13 (98) 1,65(10:1) 1,64
l(HOT rJla3, % TeMHbIX 70,4(128) 79,5(200) 73,6(106) 87,8(41) 74,li(114) 54,(j (101-) 55,9(72)
rOpH30rrTaJIbHaH rrpolfJUJIUpOBKa JIII:L\a 1,58 (128) 1,67 (206) 1,91 (118) 1,68 (41) 1,87 (105) 1,38(120) 1,23
SrrI1RaHTYc, % HamPiHH 35,7(115) 48,6 (183) 32,7 (101) 63,4 (41) 29,6(115) 15,5(116) 24,0
CKJIal\Ka BepxHero BOKa, % Haml'II1U 96,5(115) 95,1 (183) 87,6(101) 92,7(41) 87,0(115) 96,5(116) 95,0
BHYTpeHHmi cTopoHa 1,18 (115) 1,40 (183) 0,79(101) 0,88(41) 0,47 (115) 1,22 (116) 1,37
Cpep;HI1H OTp;eJI 1,91 (115) 1,75 (183) 1,35(101) 1,51 (41) 1,05(115) 1,44(116) 1,49
HapymHRH cTopoHa 1,85(115) 1,64(183) 1,29(101) 1,32 (41) 1,02(115) 1,44(116) 1,49
Bl>ICOTa rrepeHOCbH 1,63 (128) 1,83(207) 1,75(105) 1,26 (41) 1,77 (119) 1,34(119) 1,74
IIpolfJHJIb ROCTIWH 'laCTH
% BorHYTblx 6,2(128) 2,4 (207) - 2,4(41) 3,4(119) 3,4(119) -
% npHMLIX 71,9(128) 56,5 (207) 60,0(105) 29,3(41) 73,9 (119) 47,1 (119) -
% BbIIIYKJIbIX 21,9 (128) 41,1 (207) 40,0(105) . . 68,3(11) 22,7 (119)
49,6 (119) -
IIoJIolliorrI1e IWH'lI1Ra HOCR 1,96 (128) 2,08 (207) 2,15(105) 2,27 (41) 1,93(119) 2,15 (119) 2,05
MopIfJOJIOrII'leCRaU BbICOTa mm;a 130,5 (128) 132,7 (205) 130,8 ( 105) 132,3 (41) 131,1 (118) 133,6(120) 133,9 (784)
CRYJIOBaH IIIHpI1Ha 144,0(127) 145,9 (206) 144,5(105) 114,6(41) 143,1 (118) 151,4(120) 149,9 (784)
IIHlliHe'lemOCTnaJI lliI1pIIHa - 113,5 (201) 113,5 (106) 112,1 (41) 112,5 (119) 115,9(120) 113,8 (784)
MopIfJOJIOrII'lOCKIIii JIII:L\CBOH YI>33aTeJIb 90,6(127) 90,9 (205) 90,8(105) 91,3 (41) 91,6(118) 88,2 (120) 89,5 (784)
I3bIcoTa Hoca OT mmmero KpaH 6poBeii: 57,3(128) 60,9(205) 60,8(106) 61,1 (41) 58,8(119) 63,8(120) 62,4(784)
illnpIIHa Boca ;15,9(128) 36,8(205) 37,2(106) 36,9(41) 36,9 (119) 36,7(120) 37,6 (784)
1I0COBOH YRa3aTOJIb OT HIIlli.HerO RpaH 6poBeR 63,3(128) ,60,8 (204) 61,4(105) 59,9(41) 63,5(119) 58,1 (120) 60,9 (784)
IIpOP;OJIbHbIH AIIaMoTp rOJIOBbI 189,9 (127) 188,2 (207) 188,0(106) 192,5(11) 191,4(119) 188,3(120) 188,6 (784)
IIOrrepe'lHblii p;IIaMeTp rOJIOBbI 153,6 (127) 154,3 (207) 153,8 (106) 153,0 (41) 151,5 (119) 160,6 (120) 160,5 (784)
rOJIOBBoHYKa3aTeJIb 80,8(127) 82,1 (207) 82,0(106) 79,8(41) 79,2(119) 85,4(120) 85,2(784)
,l];JII1Ba TeJIa 1597 (122) 1626 (196) 1606 (101) 1624 (37) 1610(116) 1630(105) 1638 (784)
-- O . "" . -- . . ... . - ..'
. -. .-.-
'.
- . .......
. r
.
"
, .., ,
' -' . ' - . " , ,..
' "''''''''! : _ . ""' 9'" . ....... .
.. '> "f" """" ' """"';<!"
,..,.,-......
Ta6JIH:L\a 32
HaDpaBJU mIe OTJIHqIl npe]l;cTaBI1TeJIeil: ypaJlbCROrO THDa II xaKaCCKIIX rpyrrn OT npe]l;CTaBIITeJIeii IOmnoCHoIlpcKoro TIlDa. Mym'lIlHI;i
I (jl:g c rr I ypa m1i1: I HJ.13J>T.TIM\bI I Ka'IHI1I\T,T I CarailI.\u I l{oi16amT IEeJlbTT'TPLI
ITpIIsuaR
w
00
-.:J
I BeT rJIa3, % TeMHblX BblIIIe HHllie BbIIlle BblIIIe BbJIIIe BblIIIe BJ,IIIIe
rOpH30HTaJIbHaH npolfJHJInpOBRa JIH:L\a CJIa6ee CHJIbHee CHJIbnee CllJIbHee CllJII.Hee CIIJIbHee CllJIbIre e
3nHRauTYc, % HaJIll'IlIH lII1llie BblIIIe I3bIIllC BblIIIe BblIIIe BblIIIe BblIIIe
CRJIa]l;Ra BepXHero BeRa, % HaJIHTJ:IIH
cpep;HHii OT]I;eJI CJra6ee CIIJIblIee CHJlbHee CllJII.nee » CJIa6ee CJIauee
HapymHaJI CITopoua » » » » }) }) »
BbICOTa nepeHOCbH lII1llie BblIIIe » » » HHme »
06m;I1ii rrpolfJI1JIL CrrI1IIRH Hoca
% BorHYTblX }) » B blIIIe }) HH>Im }) })
% npHMbIX Bbuue IIHme » BblIIIe BbIllle }) BbIIue
% BbIIIYRJIbIX » » IIH>I\e HIIlli.e IIIIJRe BbIIlle IIIIllie
IIOJIOllieHIIe ROHTJ:IIRa Hoca IIHlli.e BbIIIIC BI,JIUe » » IIIIJRe BbIUle
MopIfJOJIOrll'leCRaH BblCOTa JII1JW BbIIIIe IIH>Im HH>I\e » » » HH}[\e
CRYJIOBaH IIII1pOHa }) » » » » » »
BbICOTa Hoca OT IIOlli.HCro RpaH uponell: }) » » }) » » })
llIllpI1na Hoca » » » » » » »
IIPOP;OJII.Ublii: p;HaMCTp rOJIOBbI Hmlm BblIJTe BbllllC » » BT.TIllC BI,uuc
rOJIOBHOll YKa3aTeJIb BbUUC HlImc Ihm\e HHllie }) HmKe Hm'f\c
J];JIIIHHa TeJIa » » » » }) }) })
-
w
*
".-
, ..-
..-..
HaII60JIee cymecTBeHHOII BaTOn CBH3II HBJIHeTCH pa3H1I a B IIHTeHCIIB-
HOCTII nlIr.MeHTa 1I1I rJIa3. XaKaCbl, IDIeH, KOHe'IHO, 60JIee CBeTJIble rJIa3a, 'IeM
npep,CTaBIITeJIII KJIaCCII'IeCKIIX IVIOHrOJIOIIp,OB, He TOJIbKO OKa3bIBalOTCH 60JIee'
TeMlIOrJIaSbDIII, 'IeM xaHTbi II CeJIbKynbl, 110 II npeBocxop,HT B aTOM OTHome-
HIIII Ka3aXOB II KIIprII30B. MOlliIIO 6bIJIO 6bI npep,nOJIaraTb, 'ITO B IIX COCTaB
B 66JIbme I IIpo eHTe BOmJIII npep,CTaBIITeJIII eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCKoro Tllna
MOHrOJIOIIp,HOn 60JILiliOn paCbl, 'IeM B eOCTaB Ka3aXOB II KlIprII30B. Op;HaKO
eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCKIIn alITpOIIOJIOrlI'IeCKlIn TIIII, nOMIIMO TeMHOrJIa30CTII,
xapaKTeplI3yeTcH IICKJIlO'IlITeJIbHO pe3Kon BbIpameHHOCTblO MOHrOJIOllp,HbIX
oc06eHHOCTeII II 110 MHOrIIM nplI3HaKaM 3aHIIMaeT MeCTO, 6JIII3KOe K BepXHen
rpaHII e II3MeH'IIIBOCTII BHYTPII MOHrOJIOllp,HOn 60JIbmon paCbI. YBeJIII'IeHlIe'
p,OJIII eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCKOro TIIIIa B COCTaBe xaKaCOB nOBeJIO 6bI K YCIIJIeHIIIO
y HIIX MOHrOJIOII,lIHbIX oc06eHHOCTen no cpaBHeHIIIO C npe.a:CTaBIITeJIHMII
ypaJIbCKOrO II lOiImOCII6IIpCKOrO TIIIIOB, 'Iero Ha caMOM p,eJIe HeT. ITpaBp,a,.
npo eHT HaJIII'IIIH SIIIIKaHTyca B xaKaCCKIIX rpynnax BbIDIe, 'IeM y Ka3aXOB
H KIIprII30B, op,HaKO JIIID,O B roplI30HTaJIbHOn nJIOCKOCTII 60JIee npoiPlIJIIIPO-
BaHO. CJIep,OBaTeJIbHO, B p,aHHOM CJIY'Iae OTCYTCTByeT 06bI'IHO IIa6JIIOp,aeMaH
B3alIMOCBH3b Me1K)J,y 1I3MeH'IIIBOCTblO aTIIX nplI3HaKOB IIPII nepexop,e OT MOH-
rOJIOnp,HbIX K eBpOIIeOIIp,HbIM nonYJIH IIHM.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, HeB03MomHOCTb 06'bHCHIITb OTHOCIITeJIbHO TeMHYIO nIIr-
MeHTa 1I1O rJIa3 y xaKaCOB YBeJIlI'IeHlIeM p,OJIII y<raCTIIH npep,CTaBIITeJIen eH-
TpaJIbHOa3IIa TCKoro TIIIIa B iPopMlIpOBaHIIII IIX aHTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKOrO COCTaBa
npIIBOp,IIT K He06xop,IIMOCTII nplI3HaTb, 'ITO TeMHon nlIrMeHTa IIen rJIa3 xa-
paKTepII30BaJICH eBpOIIeOIIp,Hbln TIIII, Bomep,IIIlIn B COCTaB xa:f\aCOB. ITOCKOJIb-
KY OTJIII"I!IH xaKaCOB OT CeJIbKYIIOB II xaHTbI 110 IIlIrMeHTa 1I1I rJIa3 er::qe
60JIbIIIe, 'IeM OT Ka3aXOB II RIIprII30B, II, C p:pyron CTOpOHbl. xaKaCbI no<
60JIbIIIIIHCTBY nplI3HaKOB c6JIIImalOTCH C ypaJIbCKIIMII rpynnaMII, BeCbMa Be-
pOHTHO, TITO eBponeOIIp,HbIe KOMIIOHeHTbI, BOIIIep,IIIIIe B COCTaB ypaJIbCKIIX
rpYIIn II xaKaCOB, xapaKTeplI30BaJIIICb 06r::qIIM KOMIIJIeKCOM IIplI3HaKOB npll'
pa3JIIIQIIII B nlIrMeHTa IIII rJIa3.
B03 IOllino, rrpaB.a:a, II p,pyroe pemeHlle Bonpoca, CBO;:t;Hr::qee pa3JIII'IIIH
Memp,y xaHTbl II CeJIbKYIIaMII, C op,Hon CTOPOHbI, II xaKacaMII - C p,pyron,.
R pa3JIIITIHOMY npOIICX01Kp,eHIIIO BOIIIep,IIIIIX B IIX COCTaB MOHrOJIOllp,HbIX
ROMIIOHeHTOB. TaK, yM03plITeJIbHO M01KHO 6bIJIO 6bI npep,IIOJIOmIITb, 'ITO<
xaKaCbl ciPopMIIpOBaJIIICh Ha 6a3e . eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCKoro TIIna, Tor,lIa KaK
MOHrOJIOllp,HOn OCHOBon p,JIH iPopMlIpoBaHIIH ypaJIbCKIIX rpynn IIOCJIymrrJI 6an-
KaJIbCKIIII TIIII. Op,HaKO TaKaH rIInOTe3a IIpep,CTaBJIHeTCH MeHee 060CHOBaHHOn,.
'IeM npep,bIp,yr::qaH. BblcryIIaHlIe Hoca II roplI30HTaJIbHaH npoiPlIJIlIpOBKa JIII a
xapaKTeplI3YlOTCH y npep,CTaBIITeJIen 6anKaJIbCKOrO TIIlla er::qe MeHbIIIIIMIf
BeJIIITIIIHaMII, <reM y 6YPHT, HKYTOB II TYBIIH eB, OTHOCHr::qIlXCH K eHTpaJIbHO
a3IIaTCKOMY TlIny 38. ho p,OJI1KHO 6bIJIO 6bI IIMeTb CBOIIM pe3YJIbTaTOM ynJIO-
li\eHlIe JIIID,a II Hoca y CeJIbKYIIOB II xaHTbl B cpaBHeHIIII C xaKacaMII II IIpep,-
CTaBIITeJIHMII IOmHOCII6IIpcI-\Oro TlIna. Op,HaKo B p,eIICTBIITeJIbHOCTII BbICOTa
nepeHOCbH B ypaJIbCKIIX rpynIIax 60JIbme, TieM y xaKaCOB, Ka3aXOB II KIIP-
r1l30B, a roplI30HTaJIbHaH IIpoiPlIJIIIpOBKa JIII a CIIJIbHee, 'IeM y Ka3aXOB If
KlIprII30B, II nplI6JIII3IITeJIbHO paBHa npoiPIIJIlIpOBKe JIII a B xaKaCCKIIX rpyn-
nax. MHblMII CJIOBaMII, Mbl He Ha6JIIOp,aeM y ypaJIbCKIIX rpynII YCIIJIeHIIH
MOHrOJIOIIp,HOCTII B Tex npII3HaKax, no KOTOpbIM 6anKaJIbCKIIn TIIn OTJIII'Ia-
eTCH B CTOPOHY YCIIJIeHIIH MOHrOJIOIIp,HOCTII OT eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTcKoro.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, rlIIIOTe3a pa3Hopop,HOCTII MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX KOMnOHeHTOB,
BOIIIep,mIIX B COCTaB ypaJIbCKIIX rpynrr II xaKaCOB, KaK 6yp,TO He Haxop,IIT
nop,p:eplliKII B paCCMOTpeHIIII BapIIa lIn cyr::qeCTBeHHbIX paCOBO-p,lIarHOCTII'Ie-
CKIIX npII3HaKOB. He HaXOp,IIT OHa IIop,TBepmp,eHlIH II B iPaKTe cyr::qeCTBOBa-
388
1-
HIIH IIIlIpOImX CBH3en yrpo-caMop,MMCKIlX Hapop,OB C TepplIToplIeii A.uae-
CaHHClwro HaropbH, a 'Iepe3 Hee, CJIep,OBaTeJIbHO, II C apeaJIOM iPOpMlIpO-
BaIlMH n:eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCKoro TllIIa, HaIIIe.a:IIIIIX OTpallieHue KaK B
apXeOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX 39, TaR II B IICToplIKo-aTHorpaiPlI'IeCKIIX o II H3bIKOBbIA
p,aHHLIX 4\ RpOMe Toro, p,OnOJIHIITeJIbHbIM apryMeHToM B nOJIb3y Toro, 'ITO'
He TOJIbKO MOHrOJIOII;:J;Hbln, HO II eBponeOIIp,HblH KOMnOHeHT, Bomep,IIIIIe B
COCTaB xaKaCOB, xapaKTeplI30BaJIIICb TeMHbIM BeTOM rJIa3, HBJIHeTCH OTCYTCT-
Bile CBH3II Mellip,y CTeIIeHblO BbIpameHHOCTII MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX oc06eHHOCTen H
nOTeMHeHlIeM IIIIrMeHTa IIII rJIa3 y pa3HbiX xaKaCCRIIX rpYIIII. RbI3bIJIb bl,
Ka'IIIH bl II Kon6aJIbl, xapaKTep1I3YIOID,IIeCH YCIIJIeHlleM MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX OCO-
6eIIlIOCTen no BceMy KOlVmJIeKCY npII3HaKOB, He OOHapYlliIIBalOT 110 cpaBHeHIIID
C OCTaJIbHblMII rpYIIIIaMII YBeJIII'IeHIIH IIpo eHTa TeMHblX rJIa3. HaKoHe , pa3-
6IIpaeMaH rIIIIOTe3a, OTBeqaH lIa Bonpoc 0 npOIICXOllip,eHIIII xaKaCCKIIX rpYIIn,.
OCTaB.ITHeT 6e3 BHIIMaHIIH YCIIJIeHlIe nllnleHTa IIII rJIa3 y xaKaCOB B cpaBHe-
HII];! C Ra3axaMll II KllprlI3aMII.
Bblme YKa3bIBaJIOCL, 'ITO 110 pa3BIlTIIlO CKJIRIJ,KII BepXHero BeKa B cpep,HeM
II HapymrroM OTp,e.rrax II no npo eHTY HaJIIPIIIH BorHYTblX iPOpM crrlIHKII Hoca
xaRaChI He OTJIlI'IalOTCH Op,HOpOp,HOCTblO. BOJIee CIIJIbHOe, 'IeM y Ka3aXOB II
KIIpnI30B, pa3BIITIIe CK.rrap,KII BeKa y I\bI3blJIb eB II Ka'IIIH eB xopomo COBna-
p,aeT C IIX 60JIee MOlIrOJIOIIp,HbIM 06JIIIKOM no p,pyrlIM IIpII3HaKaM. Ron6aJIbl
c6JIIIlliaIOTCH 110 aTOMY IIplI3HaRY C 60JIee eBporreoll;qHblMII caran aMII II
6eJILTbIpaMII. OTJIIIqlIH Kbl3blJIb eB II caran eB OT OCTaJIbHblX xaKaCCKIIX
rpYIIII, BLIpamalOr::qneCH B YBeJIJITIeHIIII BorHYTblX iPOpM CIIIIHI\II Hoca y nep-
BbIX II B YMeHbiliCHIIII IIX Y BTOpbIX, B aOCOJIIOTHblX lIiPpax O'IeIIL 1\iaJIbI II
BPHP, Jill OTpallialOT peaJIbIIble pa3JIll'IIIH IVIen';P,Y rpyrrIIaMII. HaKoHe , 3aMeT-
Hoe YBeJIII'IeHlIe IIpo eHTa TeMHbIX OTTCHKOB rJIa3, HaJIII'IlIH aIIIIKaHTyca II
BbIlIYKJIbIX iPOpM CIIIIHIHI Hoca B CO'IeTaHIIH C caMbIM CIIJIbHblM B xaKaCCKllX
rpYIInax pOCTOM 60POp,bI, xapaKTepHoe ,lIJIH KOII6aJIOB, 06pa3YlOT IIpOTIIBOpe-
'IllBbIn KOMIIJIeKC npII3IIaIWB, nJIOXO YBH3LIBalOr::qllnCH C nOJIOllieHIIeM Kon6a-
JIOB [10 p,pyrlIM npII3HaKaM II HBJIHIOr::qlInCH, OqeBIIp,HO, pe3YJIbTaTOM MaJIO-
'IIICJIeHHOCTII STon rpynubI B MaTepIIaJIaX A. M. Hpxo II, RaK CJIep,CTBlIe,
cJIY'IanHOrO rrop,60pa I1eTIIIIII'I1IbIX IIH,'.I,IIBII;:J;YYMOB.
RpalUIOJIOrlI'IeCKIIe p,aHHbIe rr03BOJIHlOT ocyr::qeCTBIITb IIpHMoe COIIOCTaBJIe-
IIlIe JIlO6bIX rpYIIn 6e3 BBe;qeHIIH KaKIIX-JIII60 IIorrpaBOR. .D:JIH cpaBHeHIIH, KaR
II rrpII paCCMOTpeHIIII MaTepIIaJIOB no COBpeMeHHOMY HaCeJIeHIIIO, nplIBJIe'IeH
MaTeplIaJI 110 KpaHIIOJIOrInr Hapop,HocTen ypaJIbCKOrO II IOlliHOCII611pcKoro
aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKllX TllnOB. ]daTepIIaJI no RpaHIIOJIOrlllI ypaJILCKIIX rpYIIII-
xaHTbl, MaHCII, CeJIbKYIIOB II HeH eB 6bIJI ony6JIIIKOBaH r. CD. .D:e6e oM 42 II
H. C. P030BbIM'S, 110 KpaHIIOJIOrlIII Ka3aXOB II KIlprlI30B - B. B. flII136yp-
rOM, H. r. 3aJIKIIHp" O. MCMaryJIOBbIM" II H. H. MIIKJIaIIIeBCKon 45. .D:aH-
Hble no pa3JIII'IHbIM rpYIIIIaM CeJIbKynoB, cop,epmar::qIIeCH B IIy6JIIIKa IIHX
r. CD. .D:e6e a II H. C. P030Ba, cyMMIIpOBaHbI B eJIHX nOJIY'IeHIIH ep,IIHOn
ceplIlI: TO llie caMoe ocyID,eCTBJIeHO II no OTIIOilieHlI1O K p,aHIIbIM no pa3JIII'I-
HbIM rpYIInaM Ka3aXOB, ony6JIIIKOBaHHbBi B. B. rlIH36yproM II H. r. 3aJI-
KllHp,. Ha OCHOBaHIIII nOJIY'IeHHblX TaKIIM 06pa30lVI cpep,HIIX no meCTII rrepe-
'IllCJIeHHbIM Hapop,HOCTHM COCTaBJIeHbI npep,eJIbI BaplIaD,lIn KpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCKIIX
npII3HaKOB, xapaRTepHble p,JIH ypaJIbCKOrO II romHoCII6IIpCKOrO TImOB, KOTO-
pble II IIOJIOmeHbI B OCHOBy COIIOCTaBJIeHIIH C Kallip,on 113 xaRaCCKIIX rpynil
(Ta6JI. 33 II 34).
B 'ra6JIII ax npep,CTaBJIeHO 39 IIpII3HaKOB. rIo IIIeCTII II3 HIIX npep,eJIbI Ba-
pIIa 1I1I ypaJIbCKOrO II IOlliHOCll6IIpCROrO TIIlIOB He 3axop,HT p,pyr 3a p,pyra
RaK B MylliCKIIX, TaK II B llieHCKIIX rpynIIax. R 'IIICJIY aTIIX nplI3IIaKOB OTHO-
cHTCH nOnepe'IHbln, p,IIaMeTp qepenHOn Kop06KII, BblCOTHbln p,lIaMeTp 'Iepen-
i!1
'II"
r
!I:'
I',
f
,.
1: 1
:11
:11
:
i l
I
'!
389
I',
ill'
.,
II!I
.. ''W' ' "'.IIIE" . -.:' ' '',,"" .. ' ' . .. " '.. l 'llJYs1 ' Wf , . T': .. ....,..
TROJIU R 33
tonoCTaBJIedUe xaKaCCKHX rpynn C npeAcTRBHTeHRMu ypaHbcKoro H ID>KHOCHOUpcKoro TunOB no KpaHHOHOrnqeCKHM ARHHbIM. MymcKHe
'lepenR
npII3HaR I Ypa.JJ:bCRHiI THII I IOnmOCII- I Ra 'J;IIHlrbl J{oilOaJ1bl I Caraill.\bI I BeJ1bTblpbI
OHpClmil TIIII
1. n POP;OJIbHbIH AHaMeTp 178,1-183,9 177,5-179;2 181,0(44) 181,3 (24) 177,5(31) 176,2 (45)
8. IIUnepe'lHbIH AlIaMeTp 139,5-146,6 149,5-150,3 147,7(46) 144,6 (25) 148,0 (30) 146,0(45)
17. BbICOTHbIlI p;lIaMeTp OT 6a3HoHa 126,1-133,3 129,4-130,1 133,4(44) 134,3(24) 133,8 (30) 130,9(45)
20. BblCOTHblii p;lIaMeTp OT nopHOHa 108,6-113,0 114,4-117,5 114,9(43) 116,4(23) 114,6 (31) 112,5(45)
5. J];JIIIHa OCIIOBaHI1H 'lepena 98,2-101,8 100,2-105,2 101,7 (44) 102,8(25) 99,6 (30) 99,1 (45)
9. lIaHMeHbIIIaH IllHPlIH3 JI6a 92,8-95,9 94,9-96,1 95,1 (46) 95,2 (26) 93,6 (31) 92,0(46)
32. Yro.JI JIua 79,381,8 79,6-84,2 82,9 (42) 8:3,0 (23) 81,6(30) 80,9 (46)
llaAupoBLe (-1-- 6 no MapTIIHY) 2,83.:\,17 2,95-<\,53 3,4.0(47) 3,23 (26) :\,35 (31) :.1,35 (4.6)
8 : 1. lepenuuii YKaaaTl'JIL 76,1-81,9 K\,4.-84,7 81,5(44) 79,9 (24.) 83,5 (30) 83,0(45)
C,!:) 17 : 1. BbIcoTHo-npOAOJILIIblii Yl\a3aTeJIb 68,6-74,6 * 72,!i--72,9 7;1,7 (41.) 74,2(24) 75,4(30) 74.,3 (.14)
c.o 17 : 8. UbIC01'lIo-lIolIepe'lHblii YRa3aTCJlb 88,0-93,3 * 86,2-87,1 9U,6(44) 92,9 (24) 90,5(29) 89,6(44)
0 9 : 8. JI06IIO-lIOI!Cpe'lHblii YRa3aTeJIb 64.,3-67,9 * 64,4(45) 65,9 (25) 63,4(30) 63,0 (45)
63,6-64,1
40. J];JIIIHa OCHOBaHIIH JIII:L\a 97,5-101,6 96,0-99,7 100,4(35) 99,5(24) 97,7 (29) 95,8(34)
45. CRYJIOBaH lliI1pHHa 135,3-140,2 140,7-142,2 141,2 (44) 139,9 (23) 141,5 (31) 139,3(45)
48. BCPXHHH BblCOTa JIII:L\a 70,5-73,9 74.,3- 75,6 76,6(41) 75,8 (26) 75,0 (30) 73,2 (39)
51. illI1pHHa Op6HTbI OT mf (JIeB.) 41,8-43,7 42,8-44,8 43,3(44) 43,3 (26) 42,2 (31) 42,9(46)
51a. lllIIpI1IIa Op6HTbI 01' d (JIeB.) 39,3-41,2 39,9-40,3 40,4(44) 40,5 (26) 39,6 (31) 40,7 (46)
52. BbIcoTa Op6HTbI (JICB.) 34,1-35,4 34,8-34,9 35,4(45) 35,3 (27) 34,7(31) 34,1 (46)
54.. lllupIIIIa noca 25,O-2H,4 26,6-26,6 25,8 (44) 25,9 (26) 26,3 (31) 25,1 (45)
55. BucoTa noca 52,5-53,8 54,2-56,1 55,2 (45) 51.,9 (26) 54,2 (31) 52,7 (46)
IIepep;HeHoconaH OCTb (1-5 rro BpoRa) 2,17-2,71 2,47-2,70 3,13 (38) 2,58 (24) 2,86 (28) 2,85(41)
DC. J];aRpI1aJIbHaH xOPAa 20,7-23,4 21,6-22,0 20,0(44) 20,5 (26) 20,4(31) 20,3 (4.6)
DS. J];aRpHaJIbHaH BbICOTa 9,4-10,8 10,1-10,3 10,1 (44) 9,7(26) 10,7 (31) 10,2 (46)
SC. CIIMOTII'leCRaH xOPAa 7,1-8,4 8,1-8,8 6,5(44) 8,5(26) 7,9 (31) 7,5(46)
SS. CHMOTIIqeCRaH BblCOTa 2,7-3,7 3,3-3,3 3,2(44) 3,5 (26) 3,8 (31) 3,8(46)
72. Y rOJI rrpO(plIJIH JIHI'\a 06 m;IIH 83,6-86,5 86,5-88,1 86,9 (37) 87,4(23) 85,7(31) 87,9 (39)
- , ,. .- - - . --. " - . . . , ... - " , ' , ., ".- .. -:,' "' ". .... . ,.,..
IIpoAoJIiRemJ:e
73. YrOJI cpep;HeH qaCTII JIH:L\a 86,6-88,5 89,8-91,3 88,6(41) 90,0(24) 87,0 (29) 90,5 (43)
74. YroJI aJIbBeOJIHpHOii qaCTJI JIIlqa 73,7-80,9 75.3-76,3 82,0(37) 78,9 (23) 82,2 (28) 81,0(38)
75 (1). YrOJI HOCOBbIX RocTeii R JIIIHIIH npo4JlIJIH 17,0-23,3 21,0-21.9 23,2 (38) 21,0(21) 26,9 (30) 22,2 (37)
77. Ha30MaJIHpHblii yrOJI 142,1-146,4 145,3-146,0 146,3(35) 145.1 (25) 145,7 (31) 144,9 (46)
Lzm'. 3HrOMaRCIIJIJIHpHbIH yrOJI 132,6-135,8 133,8-136,2 134,2 (44) 136,0 (25) 132,6 (30) 134,6(46)
40: 5. YRa3aTeJIL BbIcTynamIH JIIII\a 97,7-100,8 96,0-98,6 98,6 (35) 96,8 (23) 98,6 (29) 96,8(34)
48 : 17. BepTHKaJIMILlii KpaHIIOlfJar\lIaJIbIlI,IU yJia3aTCJIb 52,6-58,2 57.1-58,4 57.4 (38) 56,2 (23) 56,0 (29) 55,6 (38)
48: 45. BepXIIlIll: JUfl\eHOii YKa3aTCJIL 50,1-53,1 * 53,1.-5:3,3 54,3 (39) 54,2 (23) 53,1 (30) 52,1 (38)
52 : 51. Op6II'fHbIH YRa3aTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 79,5-82,2 80,6-82,3 81,8(44) 81,9 (26) 82,2 (31) 79,2 (46)
52 : 51 a. OPUIITIJblii YKa3aTeJIb OT d (JIeB.) 85,1-87,4 86,7-88,1 87,7(44) 87,4 (26) 87,6 (31) 83,8(46)
54: 55. HOCOBOH YRa3aTeJIb 47,2-51,1 47.5-49,2 46.8 (44) 47,3(26) 48,7 (31) 47,8(45)
DS : DC. ,lJ,aRpIIaJlbnbIii YKa3aTeJIb 45,6-47,9 46,1-48,9 51,4(44) 47,6 (26) 53,5 (31) 50,5(46)
SS : RC. CIIMOTI1'leCKlIii YRa3aTeJIb 36,8-40,4 39,1-41,3 50,3 (44) 42,0(26) 48,8(31) 52,0 (46)
w * IIHp;eRc cpegHHX.
co
-
1- IIpOAOJIbHbIll p;IlaMeTp 167,9-174,4 169,5-172,0 172,9 (56) 174,9(18) 170,4 (32) 171,4 (36)
8. IIorrepe'lHblH p;lIaMeTp 134,2-140,7 144,2-145,1 141,4 (54) 139,6 (20) 143,3 (33) 141,1 (35)
17. BbJCOTITblH 1\lIaMCTp OT 6a:mona 120,6-126,0 124,2-126,1 129,1 (54) 128,0 (20) 125,9 (34) 128,0 (36)
20. BbICO'fIlbIll: AlIaMeTp OT JlOpI1OlJa 101,6-107,5 110,:1-115,:3 112,2(54) 110,5(20) 110,8(34) 110,2 (36)
5. ,lJ,JIIIHa OCIWBaJlI1H 'lcpena 93,8-95,6 91,5-97,5 96,6 (54) 96,5(21) 94,7(34) 95,1 (36)
9. HalIMeHbIllaH IIIIIpnna JIua 88,8-93,5 92,5-95,1 91,4 (57) 92,0 (21) 92,3 (34) 91,2 (36)
32. YI'O.J[ Jloa 82,1-85.0 82,2-85,9 85,9 (53) 84,5(19) 84,7 (33) 85,3(35)
Hap,6pOBl>e (1-6 no MapTIIHY) 1,60-2,06 1,51-1,91 1,88 (57) 2,00 (21) 2,15 (34) 2,17 (36)
8 : 1. tIepenHoii YKa3aTeJIb 77,2-82,4 84,4-85,1 81,9 (54) 79,9 (18) 84,2 (32) 82,5 (35)
TaOJllfl\R 31
COnOCTRBJIeHIIe XatmCCRI1X rpynn C npep;CTiIRWrt',IIflMIi ypa.TJbCKOI'O 11 ltl11\HOCnOIIpcRoro TlmOB
rro RpamIOJrornq('l'IHIJ\I l\<IIIHhl J\l. JK('IIt KlIe ..epcml
I " I K);{(nO('116I1P' ! I .> I u
Ypa.IThCHI111 TlUl CHI' ii 'rI1U I\a 'H1nl\hI I\on6aJlbI CaraIlI\hl
I BeJIbThlphI
llpmlHaH
'r36JUn 3 34. ORoH'JamIe
IIpH31IaH YpaJII)CHlfH I IOlliHOCHOIIP-1 KaqIIH1 bl Kofi6aJIbl CaraHr\bl BeJIbTblPbl
THII Clmfi THII
17 : 1. BblcoTHo-npOp;OJIbHblii YK33aTeJIb 69,2-75,0 * 73,3-73,6 74,8(54) 72,9 (18) 73,8 (32) 74,7 (36)
17 : 8. BJ,JCOTIIO-nOnepe'lHblii YKa3aTeJIb 86,2-92,0 * 86,1-87,2 91.,4 (53) 91,7 (20) 87,9 (33) 90,6 (35)
9 : 8. JIouHo-nonepe'IIIbIii YKa3aTeJIb 63,1-68,6 * 63,9-65,6 64,8 (54) 65,8(19) 64,5 (33) 61,8 (35)
40. JJ:mma OCnOBaIIJIH JIJI:L\a 92,3-96,5 92,1-94,8 95,0(51) 94,3(20) 91.9 (29) 90,7 (35)
45. CRYJIOBaH JIIIIpI1Ha 127,7-130,3 131,7-133,1 131,2 (55) 130,4(21) 131,6 (34) 131,0(35)
48. BpPXHHH BblCOTa mIlIa 63,9-69,5 69,8-71,,2 72,1 (56) 72,0'(22) 70,1 (28) 70,2(36)
51. IIIJIpJIHa OPUHTbI OT mf (JIeB.) 40,6-41,5 40,8-41,7 41,2 (57) 41,6 (22) 41,4 (33) 41,7 (36)
51 a. IIII1pJIHa OPUI1TbI OT d (JleB.) 38,4-39,2 38,4-39,0' 38,7 (57) 39, (22) 38,7(33) 39,1(36)
52. BbJCOTa OPUHTbI (JIeB.) 33,2-34,8 34,2-34,,6 34,6 (57) 35,2 (21) 33,8 (33) 34,1 (36)
54. IfhIpJIIla Hoca 24,6-25,4 24,9-25,4 24.,9 (56) 24,6 (22) 25,3 (33) 24,7 (35)
55. BhlcoTa Boca 48,1-:J1,0 51,0-53,0 52,2(57) 52,5(22) 51,3 (33) 50,5 (36)
Hppe]l;HCIIOcOBaH OCTb (1-5 no BpoRa) 1,98-2,33 1,86-1,89 2,71 (51) 2,6:1(19) 2,77 (30) 2,52 (iU)
DC. lI.aRpHaJILHaH xopp;a 19,6-21,6 20,9-21,1 19,1(53) 18,7 (22) 19,3 (34) 20,3 (;1-1)
C,!:) DS. JJ:aRVl1aJIbJIaJI BI,ICOTa 8,6-9,3 8,4-10,0 9,3 (53) (J,O (22) 9,5 (34) 9,6 (34)
c.o
SC. CJIMIJTI1QeCRaH xu PA:1 7,0-8,3 7,7-9,2 7,0(57) 7,3 (22) 7,5(34) 7,7 (35)
SS. CHMOTI1'leCRaH BbICOT3 2.,1-3,,0 2,7-3,,2 2,7(57) 2,9 (22) 2,9 (34) 3,2 (35)
72. YroJI IJPOqHIJIH mII 3 06mnii 83,8-86,6 85,2-88,4 86,7 (53) 86,3 (20) 87,9 (28) 88,5 (32}
73. YroJI cpe]l;Heii 'l3CTJI JIHI'\a 86,7-89,3 88,1-91,7 88,4 (54) 88,3(21) 89,9 (30) 90,9 (33j
74. YroJl aJIbBeOJIHpHOii 'laCTII JIH:L\3 73,3-78,8 74,2-76,3 82,3 (52) 80,1 (20) 81.8 (28) 80,9 (32)
75(1). YroJI HOCOBbIX RocTeii R JIHHHH npolfJHJIJI 16,4-18,4 19,2-19,3 20,5(54) 21,2(19) 21,6 (28) 19,1 (29)
77. lIa30M3J1HPIIhIii yrOJI 142,8-1.47,4 144,,1-146,0 146,2(57) 14.6,3(21) 145,2 (34) 144,9 (36)
Lzm'. 3HrOMarmHJIJIHpHbIH yrOJI 132,4-135,9 136,1-136,2 133,5(55) 132,7 (22) 134,4 (31) 134,2 (36)
40: 5. YRa33TeJIb BblcTynamm JIH:L\3 98,4-101,0 94,8-97,1 98,3 (51) 97,6(20) 96,8(29) 95,5(35)
48: 17. BepTHRaJIbHbIH Rpa1lH04Ja:L\HaJIbHbIH YR33aTeJIb 50,8-57,0 55,9-56,3 55,9 (53) 56,5 (20) 55,7 (29) 54,9 (36)
48: 45. BepxHHH J!I1JWBOH YK333TeJIb 49,6-53,7 * 52,6-53,4 54,9 (54) 55,3 (21) 53,3 (29) 53,7 (35)
52 : 51. OPUJITHbIH YKa3aTeJIL OT mf (JIeB.) 81,4-84,,1 83,1-83,,5 84,1 (57) 81,4(21) 81,5(33) 81,7 (36)
52: 513. Op6HTIJLIH YI{333TeJIb OT d (JIeB.) 87,3.-88,5 88,8-89,2 89,6 (57) 89,6 (21) 87,3(33) 87,1 (36)
54 : 55. HOCOBOH YKa33TeJIb 49,5-52,3 48,1-48,4 47,8(56) 46,9 (22) 49,3(33) ..... 49,0(35)
DS : DC. lI.aRpI1aJIbHbIH YRa3aTeJlb 43,1-45,7 41,4-47,2 49,3(53) 49,1 (22) 49,3 (34) 47,7(34)
SS : SC. CHMOTH'leCRHH YRa3aTeJIb 33,4-38,4 33,8-39,1 40,5 (57) 40,9 (22) 39,2 (34) 41,9 (35)
.. IIHAeRC cpeAHHX.
_ . - ....- ..f. .. .:.. -. ,... "- ",r." ""'-.d
Hon Iwp06IUI OT nOpIIOHa, 'IepenHOn yKa3aTeJIb, CKYJIOBaH llIIIpIIHa, BepXHf.lJI
BbICOTa mI a II BbICOTa HOca. EcJIII Y'IeCTb, 'ITO pa3HII a B BbIcOTe 'IepenHOH
Kop06IUI OT 6a3IIOHa MeHee 3aMeTHa, 'IeM B BbICOTe OT nopliOHa, a BbICOTa
Hoca CBH3aHa BblCOKon MopiPOJIOrII'IeCKOn KOppeJIH IIen C BepXHen BblcOTOH
JIllI a II, CJIep,OBaTeJIbHO, pa3HII a B BbICOTe Hoca HBJIHeTCH pe3yJIbTaTOM He-
O)J,IIHaIWBOn BbICOTbl ml a, MOlliHO CKa3aTb, 'ITO HaII60JIee p,elVlOHCTpaTIIBHble'
pa3JIll'IlIH Memp,y npep,CTaBIITeJIHIVlII ypaJIbCIwrO II IOmHOCII6IIpCIwro TlinOB,
npOHBJIHIOTCH B llIIIpllHe 'IepemlOn IWpOOIUI II pa31V1epax ml a.
ITpep,eJIbI BapIIa IIn BOCblVlII npII3HaKOB 3aXO;'],HT p,pyr 3a p,pyra JIII60 B;
MymCIUIX, JIII60 B iIieHCIUIX rpynnax, HO B TO llie BpelVlH pa3JIII'IIIH B :3TIIX
npII3HaI\ax 06HapYlliIIBalOT onpep,eJIeHHYIO HanpaBJIeHHOCTb, OL\IIHaKOBYIO y
060IIX nOJIOB. 8TO p,JIIIHa OCHOBaHIIH 'Iepena, HaIIMeHbllIaH llIIIpllHa JI6a, HaII-
MeHbllIaH IIIIIpIIHa HOCOBblX IwcTen, IIJIII, IIHbIMII CJIOBaMII, CIIIVlOTII'IeCI\aH'
xopp,a, 06r::qIIn yroJI npoiPIIJIH JIII a, YTOJI cpep,Hen 'IaCTIf JIII a, 3IIrOMaI\CIIJI-'
JIHpHbIIl yroJI, YKa3aTeJIb BblCTynaHIIH JIII a II Op6IITHbln yna3aTeJIb OT p,aR-
plioHa. YpaJIhCIUIe rpynnbI IIlVlelOT lVleHbmylO BeJIII'llIHY p,JIIIHbI OCHOBaHIIlI
'Iepena no cpaBHeHIIIO C IOmHOCII6IIpcmnm, 60JIee Y3IUIn JI06, 60JIee Y3KIIe
HOCOBbIe KOCTII, 60JIee BbICOKIIe Op6IITbI, lVleHee ynJIor::qeHHbln B ropII30HTaJIb-
Hon nJIOCKOCTII HIImHIIM OTp,eJI JIII eBOro CReJIeTa II xapaKTepII3YlOTCH 66JIb":
llIIIM BbICTynaHIIelVl JIII a Bnepep, B BepTImaJIbHOII nJIOCIWCTII.
Pa3.:rwIIIH B 25 OCTaJIbHbIX npII3HaI\ax He OOHapYlliIIBalOT onpep,eJIeHHOn
HanpaBJIeHHOCTII. BapIIa IIII MymcKIIx rpynII He conpOBomp,alOTCH aHaJIO-
rll'IHbIMII cp,BIIraMII B II3MeH'IIIBOCTII meHCKliX rpynn, JIII60 Ha060pOT. Mno-
rlIe II3 STIlX 25 npII3HaKOB Bo06r::qe xapaKTepII3YlOTCH op,IIHalwBon BeJIII'IIIHOn
B rpynnax ypaJIbcKoro II IOmHocII6IIpclwro TlInOB. ITOSTOMY Bce OHII He npII-
HlIlVlalOTCH BO BHIIMaHIIe npII p,aJIbHellmelVl conOcTaBJIeHIIII XaI\aCCRIIX rpynn
C ypaJIbCIUIMII II IOlliHOCII6IIpCI\IIIVlII.
ITo BeJIII'IIIHe nonepe'lHoro p,IIalVleTpa Bce xaI\aCbl 3aHIIMalOT npOMemYTO'I-
Hoe nOJIOmeHlIe IIJIII nonap,alOT B npep,eJIbl BapIIa IIn ypaJIbCKOrO TIIna. Hall.
60JIbmylO BeJIII'IIIHY nOnepe'IHOrO )J,IIa IeTpa, npII6JIIImalOr::qYIOCH 1\ TaIWBOH
y Ka3aXOB II RIIprII30B, IIMelOT caraiIu,bI, 3a HIIIVlII CJIep,yIOT I\a'IIIH bI. Ho II
OHII He nonap,alOT B rpaHII bl BaplIa lIn IOrKHOCIIOIIpCIwro TlIna. Ha060poT,
no BblCOTe 'IepenIlOII Iwp06KII OT noplIOHa Bce rpynnbI xaI\aCOB OKa3bIBalOTCH
B npep,eJIax II3MeH'IlIBOCTlI IOmHOC1I6IIpCKIIX rpynn. Ep,IIHCTBeHHbIM IICKJIIO-
'IeHlIeM HBJIHeTCH meHCKaH cepIlH 6eJIbTbIpOB, no II OHa B 3IIa'IIITeJIbHO 60JIb-
men CTeneHII C6JIlilliaeTCH C ceplIHMII Ka3aXOB II IUIprII30B, 'IeM C cepIIHMII
npep,CTaBlITeJIell ypaJIbCKOrO TIIna. 1JepenHon YKa3aTeJIb BapbIIpyeT ropa3p,0
MeHee onpep,eJIeHHO, 'IeM BblCOTa 'IepenHOII Rop06RII. Ra'IIIH bI II oc06eHHo
Iwn6aJIbl pe3Ko OTJIlI'IaIOTCH OT Ra3aXOB II IUIprII30B, Torp,a RaR caraM bl,
Ha060poT, C6JIIIiI{aIOTCH C HlIMli. 'BeJIbTbIpbI 3aHIIMalOT npoMemYTO'IHOe no-
JIOllieHIIe.
TaRIIM oopa30M, BapIIa IIII cTpoeHIIH 'IepenHOn ROpOOKII B IICCJIep,yelVlblx
rpynnax He p,alOT B03MomHOCTII OTp,a'l'b npep,nO'ITeHIIe OP,HOMY 1I3 nplIBJIeRae..:
MblX p,JIH conOCTaBJIeHIIH TIInOB. 3alVleTHO OTJIlI'IaHCb OT I\IIprII30B II I\a3axO
no llIIIpIIHe 'IepenHOn Iwp06IUI II no OTHomeHlIlO ee 1\ p,JIIIHe, Bce xaKaCCI\IIe
rpynnbl C6JIIImalOTCH C HIIMII no BbICOTe 'IepenHOn Kopoomr. Caran bl MaJIO'
OTJIlI'IaIOTCH OT IOmIIOC1I61IpCRlIX rpynn no BceM aTIIM np1I3HaI\aM.
Beml'lIlHbI CKYJIOBOrO p,IIaMeTpa cpep,II MymcRIIx rpynn n03BOJIHlOT C6JIII-
3IITb I\a'IIlH eB II caran eB C Ra3axaMlI II RIIprII3a1-IlI, a Kon6aJIOB II 6eJIbTbI-
pOB C npep,CTaBlITeJIHMII ypaJIbcIWrO Tlina. Cpe,ll:II meHCI\IIX rpynn HeT HII op,-
Hon, KOTopaH II IeJIa 6bI BeJIII'IIIHY, np1I6JIIImalOr::qYIOCH R BeJIII'IIIHe aToro pa3-
Mepa B IOmHOCII6IIpCIUIX ceplIHX. Op,HaIW II 3p,eCb HaII60JIee mIIpOIWJIII bIMII
cpep,II xaKaCOB oCTaroTcH rpynnbI caran eB II Ka'IIIH eB. Pa3MepbI BepXHeH
393
BbICOTbI JIII a B CepIIHX Ka'IIIH eB II Kon6aJIOB npeBblmalOT aHaJIOrII'IHYIO
BeJIII'IIIHY Ha I\a3aXCI\IIX II KIIpl'II3cKIIX 'Iepenax. t:Iepena caran eB He 06Ha-
pymlIBaIOT no aToMy npII3HaI\Y OTJIII'IIIn OT 'IepenOB ha3aXOB II KIIprII30B.
To me caMoe l\lOmHO CI\a3aTb II 0 meHcKon cepull 6eJIbTblpOB, Torp,a KaI\
,MymcKaH IIMeeT nOHIImeIIHYIO BblCOTY JIII a, c6JIIIllialor::qyIO ee C cepIIHMII
ypaJIbCKOrO TIrrra. BapIIawUl BbICOTbI Hoca nOBTopHIOT reorpaiPII'IeCKYIO 113-
MeH'IIIBOCTb BbICOTbI JIII a. TOJIbIW 6eJIbTbIpbl nonap,alOT no STOMY npu3HaKY
B rpaHII bl BapIIa IIII ypaJIbCKOrO TIIna, OCTaJIbHbIe rpynnbl He OTJIII'IaIOTCH
.OT I\IIpr1I30B II Ka3aXOB.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, no pa3Mepal\I JIII a B eJIOM caran bl II Ka'IIIH bI MaJIO
'OTJIII'IaIOTCH OT npep,CTaBHTeJIen IOlliHOCII6IIpCKoro TIrrra, OeJIbTbIpbl He BbIXO-
.p,HT 3a npep,eJIbI BapUa IIn ypaJIbCKOrO TIIna, a Iwn6aJIbl 3aHIIMalOT cpep,Hee
nOJIOmeHIIe.
ITepe'IIICJIeHHblMII npU3HaI\aIVIU, I\aK yme YI\a3bIBaJIOCb, IIC'IepIIbIBaIOTCH
(OCOOeHHOCTII, 'IeTKO pa3rpaHII'IUBalOr::que ypaJIbCKIIn II IOn\HOCII6IIpCKIIll TIInbI.
Pa3JIII'lIIH no OCTaJIbHbIIVI npII3HaKaM XOTH II npOHBJIHIOTCH BnOJIHe onpep,e-
.JIellHO, HO yme npu 3aXOn\.a:eHUU I\pallHIIX BapIIaHTOB p,pyr 3a p,pyra. ITo p,JIII-
Me OCHOBaIIIIH 'Iepena xaI\aCCKIIe rpynnbI 3aHUMalOT B oor::qeM npOMemYTO'I-
Roe nOJIOmeHIIe, 3a IICKJIIO'IeHlle:H Kon6aJIOB, xapaI\Tepu3YIOr::qIIXCH 60JIbmOn
Beml'IIIHOn aTOrO npII3HaKa 11 C6JIUmalOr::qUXCH C I\IIprIl3aMII II Ka3axaMII.
H3 QCTaJIbHbIX rpynn onpeJJ:e.:reHHbln cp,BIIr B TOM me HaIIpaBJIeHIIU o6Hapy-
mUBalOT Ra'IIIH bI. ITo BeJIU'IIIHaM naIIMeHbmen mIIpuHbI JI6a Bce xaKaCCKIIe
rpynIIbl He BbIXOJJ:HT 3a npep,eJIbI II3lVIeH'IIIBOCTII ypaJIbCKOro TIIna. L!:onOJIHn-
TeJIbHO npIIBJIeKaeMbIe p,JIH pacnIOTpelIIIH oco6eHHOCTII CTpoeHIIH 'IepenHOH
Ropo6KII YBeml'IIIBaIOT, CJIe;J;OBaTeJIbHO, KOJIII'IeCTBO RpaHIIOJIOrU'IeCKUX npn-
3HaKOB, no KOTOpbIM xaKaCbI C6JIIIlliaIOTCR C npe,lJCTaBIITe,lIHMII ypaJIibCKOrO
'TIIIIa. 8TO 3aKJIIO'IeHIIe l\IOmeT 6bITb pacnpOCTpaHCHO Tam-he Ha Bapua HII
CIIMOTII'IeCIWII XOpp,bl II 3IIrOl\IaRcu:r:rHpHoro yrJIa ropII30HTaJILHOn npoiPu:rn-
pOBI\II JIII a.
IToKa3aHIIH no Op6UTHOMY YKa3aTeJIlO OT p,aKpUOHa, BblpamalOID,eMy OT-
HOCIITe:lbHYIO BbICOTY Op6IIT, pa3rpaHU'IIIBalOT xaI\accmre rpynnbl BIJOJIHe
onpep,eJIeHHbIM 06pa30l\I. Ra'IIIH bl II Kon6aJIbl C6JIIIllialOTCH C npep,CTaBIITe-
.JIHMU IOmHOCII6IIpCKoro TIIIIa, 6eJIbTbIpbI - HaooopOT, ypa:rbCIwro. OpOIITHbIn
YI\a3aTeJIb B MymcKoH cepIIII caral'lIl;eB He OTJIII'IaeTCH no CBoell BeJIII'IIIHe
()T aHaJIOrIT'IHOrO COOTHomeHIIH Ha 'Iepenax I\a3aXOB II mIprII30B, Torp,a KaK
meHCI\aR caraiicKaH cepIIH IIOnaiJ;aeT B rpaHII bl BaplIRD,I1ii ypaJIbCIWro TIIna.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, nOJIOmeHue' carall eB no STOMY npII3HaRY, nO-BIIp,IIMO:UY,
MomeT C'IIITa TbCH HeihpaJIbHbIM.
ITo 06r::qe1VIY yrJIy npoiPlIJIH :UI a Bce xaKaccmle rpynnbI, RpmIe caran-
u;eB, He OTJIU'IaIOTCH IIJIII MaJIO OT.1.II'IaIOTCH OT IOmHOCIIOUPCKIIX rpynn. Mym-
CI\aH cepIIH 'IepenOB caran eB OKa3bIBaeTCH B npe;JeJIax I13MeH'IIIBOCTII ypaJIJ>-
CRoro TIrrra. Op,HaKO meHCKIIe 'Iepena caran eB TaI\me COJlIlmalOTCH c 'Iepe-
naMII Ka3aXOB II I\IIpI'II30B. ITpII 06meM BnOJIHe onpe;t:\eJIeHHOM nOJIOmeHlln
xaKaCCKIIX rpynn BHYTpn IOmnOCUOIIpCKoro TlIna caran bI, CJIep,OBaTeJIbHO,
]If no aToMy npII3HaKY, TaK llie KaK II no OPOIITHOMY YKa3aTeJIIO, 3aHII?>IaIOT
HellTpaJIbHOe MeCTO. To me caMoe ?>lOmeT ObITb nOBTopeHo II npo BapIIa nn
yrJIa cpep,Hen 'IaCTII JIII a, C TOll ']HIillb pa3HII en, 'ITO cpep,Hee Memp,y p,BYMH
TIrrraMII nOJIOmeHlre no aTOMY nplI3naI\Y xapaKTepHO He TOJIbIW ;t:\JIH car an-
u;eB, HO II p,JIH I\a'IIIH eB. ITo YKa3aTeJIlO BbICTynaHlIH JIII a I\a'IIIH bl MeHH-
IOTCH MeCTaMII C cara aMII cpaBHIITeJIbHO C IIX B3alIMHbUI nOJIOllieHueM no
06r::qeMY yrJIY npoiPIIJIH JIII a. Caran bI BMeCTe C J.l,pyrIIMII rpynnaMu C6JlII-
malOTCH C npe;t:\cTaBIITeJIHl\III lOilmOCIIoupG-lwro TIIna, B TO BpeMH KaK nOJIO-
1KeHIIe I\a'IIIHD,eB OCTaeTCH npmIeihYTO'IHbIM.
1
I
;;
394
TaoJIBI'\a 35
COnOCTaBJIeHHe xaKaCCKIiX rpynn Memp;y coooii: no ROJIH'IeCTBY npll3HaKoB ypaJIbCKOl'O
II romHocHoHpcKoro THnOB
Ka'lHHI1bI Koii6a;IbI CaraiiI1bI BeJIbTblpbI
'" '" '" '" '" c:J c:J '"
i'i i'i i'i i'i i'i i'i i'i IS:
IIPH3HaII :<:", :<:'" 2 :<:o:! 8 :<:'" :<:", :<:'"
'-' ,-,,, ,-,,, ,-,,, '-'" '-'''
:eOJ
0!:c:J :S:c:J ::::C!) ""'Co) :S:c:J :e", :s:'"
;.o. C,) ;.o. 2 ;.o. c:J ;.o. c:J1'Oo-
:;sg; "- Q;; :;s c:J :;sg; ;E :;s:;:: :;::
t::;::r ::"
8. IIonepe'IHbIll p;IIaMeTp X X + + X X + X
20. BbICOTHbIll p;IIaMeTp X - X - X - + X
OT IIOpIIOHa
8: 1. llepelIHoll YRa3aTeJIb + + + + - X X x:
45. CRYJIOBaH IIIIIpIIHa - X + X - X + X'
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa - - - - - - + -
JIII:L\a
55. BbICOTa Roca - - - - - - + +
5. ,D;JIIIHa OCROBaHIIH X - - - + X + X
'Iepena
9. lIaIIMenbIllaH IIIHPII- X + X + + + + +
na JI6a
SC. CIIMOTH'leCRaH xopp;a + + X + + + + X
72. YrOJI IIPOlPHJIH JIH:L\a - - - X + - - -
o6m;HH
73. YroJI cpep;Hell 'IaCTII X X - X + - - -
;;J:u:L\a
Lzm'. 3IIrOMaRCBJIJIHpHbIH X + - + + + X +
-
yrOJI
40: 45. YRasaTeJIb BbIcTyrra- X X - X X - - -
lIHH JIH:L\a
52 : 51a. Op6IITRbIll: yRa3aTeJIb - - X - - + + +
OT d (JIeB.)
PiOJIII'leCTBO npB3Ha- 2 4 3 5 6 4 9 4
ROB ypaJIbCRoro TIIrra
PiOJIII'leCTBO HeHT- 7 4 4 4 3 4 2 6
paJIbHbIX npB3HaROB
KOJI1!'IeCTBO IIpI13Ha- 5 6 7 5 5 6 3 4
ROB IOlliHOCB6IIpCRoro
THrra
CYMMapnoe ROJII1- 3 4 5 6,5
'IeCTBO rrpB3HaROB
ypa;'lbCROrO TlIna
CYMMapHoe ROJIII- 5,5 4 3,5 4
'IeCTBO HeHTpaJIbHbIX
npII3HaROB
CYl'.IMapHOe ROJIB- 5,5 6 5,5 3,5
'leCTBO npII3HaROB
IO'ImocII6IIpcRoro
TIIna
395
,t
<I
.
TaRIIM 00pa30M, rrpII3HaKII, Onpep,eJIHIOr::qIIe BepTIIRaJIbHYIO npoiPIIJIIIpOB-
RY JIII eBOro CI\eJIeTa, B OOJIbmen CTeneHII OO'.bep,IIHHIOT xaKaCOB C Ka3axa-
MIl II RIlprII3aMII, 'IeM C npep,CTaBIITeJIHMII ypaJIbCROrO T.una.
M3.;romeHHoe nOKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO OTHeceHIIe xaI\aCOB K ypaJIbcROMY IIJIII
.lOmHOCII6IIPCKOMY TIIrry no I\paHIIOJIOrII'leCKIIM p,aHHbIM cTaJIKIIBaeTCH C
06.;rhmIIMU 3aTpyp,HeHIIHMII, 'IelVI aHaJIOrII'IHaH nOnbITI\a, OCHOBaHHaH Ha CO-
IIOCTaBJIeHIIIl COMaTOJIOrII'IeCKIIX Ha6JIIOp,eHIIn. IToaTOMY eJIeC006pa3HbIMII
npep,CTaBJIHIOTCH CYMMapHaH o eHKa Bcex nepe'IIICJIeHHblX 14 nplI3HaKOB II
nO,l:{C'IeT 06r::qero ROJIII'IeCTBa npII3HaIWB, no IWTOPOlVIY Kamp,aH II3 XaI\aCCI\lIX
.rpynrr norrap,aeT B rpaHII bl II3MeH'lIIBOcTII ypaJIbCROrO II IOmHocII6IIpCKDrO I
'TunOB. Pe3y:rbTaTbl TaKDrO nOp,C'IeTa npep,CTaBJIeHbl B Ta6JI. 35. 3HalwM CJIO-
.areHIIH B Hen 0603Ha'IeHO ,!,HrOTeHlle Kamp,on xaI\aCCIwn rpynrrbl K ypaJIbCKO- " .;' ..
.MY nIIIY IIO p,aHHOMY npII3HaI\Y, 3HaKOM BbI'IIITaHIIH - THrOTeHIle 1\ IOmHO-
,cIl6npCROMY nmy, 3HaIWM ycvmomeHIIH - :aeihpaJIbHoe IIOJIOmeHIIe.
, HaI\ II c.:rep,OBaJIO omIIp,aTb, 60.;rbmIIHcTBo npII3HaKoB COJIIImalOT Ka'IIIH-
.:u,eB C rrpep,cTaBIITeJIHIVUi IOmHocII6npcKoro TlIna. BeJIbTblpbl 3aHIIMalOT IIpO-
"TIIBOnOJIOambIn nOJIIOC II c6:lIImalOTCH C ypaJIbCI\IIMII rpynnaMlI. ITpoMemy-
'TO'IHOe nOJIOmeHIIe caran eB II IWM6aJIOB XOpOIIIO corJIacyeTcH C xapaRTep-
HbIM p,JIH HIIX M03aII'IHblM CO'IeTaHIIeM rrpII3HaRoB 060IIX TIInOB.
TaI\IIM 06pa30M, I\paHIIOJIOrlI'IecI\IIe p,aHHble He TOJIbIW nop,TBepmp,aIOT
06r::qylO TeH.a:eH IIIO, HaMeTIIBmYIOCH npII paCCMOTpeHJIlI COMaTOJIOrII'IeCKlIX
naOJIIOp,eHIIM, HO II II03BOJIHIOT YTO'IHIITb aTO npep,CTaBJIeHIIe, II B 'IaCTJIoc.TH
Y'IeCTh CTerreHb BJIIlHHIIH IOmHOCIl61IpCIwro TIIrra Ha iPopMIIpoBaHIle aHTpono-
.JIOTII'IeCKOrO OOJIIII\a I\amp,on Il3 xaKaCCKIIX rpynn.
HOMrrJIeI\C npn3HaIWB, xapaKTepHbIII p,JIH IOmHocnoupCKoro TIma, B HalI-
60JIee nOJIHOM BIIp,e rrpe CTaBJIeH B aHTpOrrOJIOrII'leCKOM TIIrre Ra'IIIH eB.
B CBH3II C BapIIa IIHMII UX KpaHIIOJIOrII'IeCIWrO T1llIa CJIep,yeT OTMeTIITb, 'ITO
no MHorUM COMaTOJIOrII'IeCIUIIVI rrpU3HaKaM Ra'IIIH bI XOTH II rrorrap,alOT B IIpe-
.p,eJIbl BaplIa IIn ypaJIbCKOrO Tlma. HO 3aHIIMalOT TaM I\panHee rrOJIOmeHIIe.
Mx aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IecKIIn 06JIIII\, c.;re,'WBaTeJIbHO, MOllieT paccMaTpIIBaTLcH KaR
pe3YJIJ?TaT CMemeHlIH ypaJIbCIWrO II IOmHocu6npclwro TImOB C npe06JIa-
aHIIeM ocooeHHocTen nOCJIep,Hero.
TaKIuf 00pa30M, XOTH A. II. JIpxo II IICXOp,IIJI II3 oTBeprHYTbIX B npo ecce
,p,aJIbHeMlliero HaKOrrJIeHIIH MaTepUaJIOB I\plITepIIeB ,l:{.;rR Bblp,eJIeHIIH 10m&{)- ,
cII6IIpclwro nma, Cp,eJIaHHbIn 11M IWHKpeTHbIii BbIBOp, 0 npIIlIap,JIemHOCTll
R HeMy Ka'IIIH eB coxpaHHeT CBoe 3Ha'IeHue II B HaCTOHr::qee BpeMH.
06CTOHTeJIbHOe paCCMOTpeHIIe He TOJIbIW KpaIIIIOJIOrlI'IeCKIIX, HO II COMa-
TOJIOrII'leCKIIX p,aHHbIX II03BOJIHeT BIIeCTII HeKOTopbIe KOppeI\TIIBbl B 3aKJIIO- j
'IeHIIe 00 aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOM TUlle caralI eB II Kon6aJIOB, Cp,eJIaHHOe B rrpe]:\-
BapIITeJILHOM cooor::qeHIIII 0 pe3YJIbTaTaX Il3Y'IeHIIH KpaHIIOJIOrIIII xaKaCCKIIX
rpyurr B 1957 r. Torp,a H IIIICaJI, 'lTO, IICKJIlO'IaH Ka'I1IHD,eB, «BJIIIHHUe IIpII- .
1\Iecn eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCKoro TIIIIa B naU60JILmen CTelIeHII 3aCVIeTHO y Iwii.oaJIOB
II caraiiD,eB» 46. ITo Bcen BepoHTHoCTII. IUIeeTCH 60JIbme oCHoBaHIIM rOBopIITb
o ROCBeIlHOM BJIIIHHIIII ueHTpaJIbHOa3I1aTCIWrO TIma Ha iPOp IIIpOBaHue aHTpo-
rrOJIOrII'leCKOrO 06JIIII\a earanueB II Koii6aJIOB. HBJIHIOr::qerocR c.rre;\CTBlIOJlf 3Ha-
'IIITeJIbHOrO y'IacTIIH B aTOM rrpo[ eCce rrpep,CTaBIITeJIen ma\HOCIIOIlpCKoro TIIna.
OAHaKo ocooeHHOCTU ypaJIbCKOrO TlIlla B OOOIlX CJIY'IaHX Oc:raKnC'I npeoo.rra-
]J,ammInIlI.
ITpII aHaJIl!f3e COMaTOJIOrII'IeCI\lIX rrpII3HaKOB MbI I1pIlmJIH R 3aKJIIO'IeHIIIO.
'ITO eBporreOUJJ;Hbln KOMnOHeHT, Bome.a:mun B COCTaB XaI\aCOB, xapaKTepH30-
BaJ!CH TeMHon IIIIrMeHTa IIen rJIa3. HaJIII'lIIe rrpIIMeCII IOfltHOCIIOIlpCKoro TIIn3
B aHTpOIlOJIQrII'IeCKOM COCTaBe xaKaCOB rOBopIIT 0 TOM, 'ITO mIIpOKOJIII eCTb
TaKme HBJIH:IaCb OTJIll'IIITeJIbHbIlVf rrpU3HaIWM eBporreOIIp,HbIX IIpe KOB COBpe-
396
I
MeHHblX xaKaCOB, no BCH1WM CJIY'Iae Tex 113 HIIX, KOTopble lIpIIIIHJIII Y'IaCTIIe
B iPOpMIIpOBaHIIII Ka'IIIH eB II 'IaCTII'IHO Iwn6aJIOB II caraIID,en.
TaI\IIM 06pa30M, CJIeP,yeT npep,nOJIaraTb, 'ITO eBponeOII;cJ,HbIC TIIlIbI, lIpII-
IIIIMaBmIIe Y'IaCTIIe B iPopMIIpOBaHIlII aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCIWrO COCTaBa COBpeMeH-
.HblX xaKaCCKIIX rpynn II IWaCCII'IeCI\IIX npep,CTaBIITeJIen ypaJIbCI\OII paCbl,
pa3JIll'laJIIICb MelliL\Y C060H He TOJIbIW nIIrMeHTa Ilen r:Ia3, KaK STO MbI
nblTaJIIICb nOKa3aTb paHbme, HO II pa3MepaMII JIII eBOro CKeJIeTa.
,.
HEKOTOPbIE IIAJIEOAHTPOIIOJIOr:n:qECKME COOEP AiKEHlUI
.oor::qIIn 0630p naJIeOaHTpOIlOJIOrIIII MIIHycIIHcKon KOTJIOBlIHbI, I1alIIICaIIHbIn
'Ha OCHOBe MaTepIIaJIOB, II3MepeHIIbIx C nOMor::qLIO MeTOp,II'IeCKIIX npIleMoB,
.IICnOJIb3yeMblx II B HacToHr::qee Bpe IH, nOHBIlJICH 60JIee P,BYX p,eCHTIIJIeTIIn
Ha3ap, 7. Ec:rrr He C'IIITaTb p,OBOJIbHO 3IIa'IIITeJIbHOrO 'IIICJIa MeJIKIlX CTaTeH,
.c Tex nop 6bIJIII ony6JIlIKOBaHbI p,Be I\pynHbIe pa60Tbl - KHIlra A. r. K031IH-
IJ;eBa 110 KpaHlIOJIOrIIIl HaC8JIeHIIH TarapCIWH Ky.'lLTYPbl 8 II peay.TJ:LTaTbI
peBII3IIII naJIeOaHTpOnOJI0rllII I\apaCYI\CKOn KYJIbTypbl r. B. PbIKymluIOH, 113-
p,aHHble lIOI\a, K ComaJIeHIIIO, B ype3aHHOM BIIp,e 9. He Bp,aBaHCb B p,eTaJIlI,
MomHO OTMeTIITL, 'ITO OHII B 060IIX CJIY'IaHX Ha ropa3p,0 oOJIee I10JIHOM iPaI\-
'TII'IeCIWM IVIaTepIlaJIe nop,TBepmp,aIOT npep,mecTBylOr::qne Haomop,eHlUI - iPaKT
MopcpOJIOrII'IeCKOrO Cxop,CTBa TarapcKoro HaCeJIeHIIH C aiPanacbeBCI\IIM II ero
npllHap,JIemHOCTb 1\ enpOIleOIIp,Hon pace, a TaKme iPaKT I1pIIHap,JIemHOCTII
:KapatYKCKoro HaCeJIeHIIH K I\pyry 6paXIIKpaHHbIX eBponeOIIp,HbIX iPOPM,
.IIMeBIIIIlX no OTHomeHlUO K MlIHYClIHCKOii KOTJIOBIIHe lIe BOCTO'lIIOe, a rrpe-
MMyr::qeCTBeHIIO 3anap,Hoe npOIlCXOJ-I\:p,eIIIIe.
KpOMe SToro, ObIJIII nOCMepTHO II3p,aHbl II3MepeHIIH r. cD. )J;eoe a, npOII3-
>Bep,eHHble 11M Ha cepIIII 'IepenOB OKYHeBCIwn KYJIbTYPbI 5o . PaHee apxeOJIO-
rII'IeCKaH pa60Ta n03BOJIIIJIa IICIWIO'IIITb oKYHencKIIe lIorpe6eHIIH II npoIIcxo-
,p,HlI\Hn 113 HIlX I1aJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCKIIn IVIaTepIlaJI H3 'IIIC.'la aiPaHaCbeB-
.CKIIX 51. Bce aTO BbUIBIIJIO B lIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIlH MIIHycIIHcKon KOT JIOBIIHbI
HOBbln aHTpOlIOJIOrII'IeCKIIH IWMnOHeHT, KOTOpbllI C MopiPOJIOrII'IeCKOH TO'IKII
3peHIIH BameH p,JIH nOHIlMaHIIH reHe3IIca KapacyKcKorO IWl\mJIeKCa rrpIl3Ha-
ROB, HO npOIIcxomp,eHIIe KOToporo caMO no ceoe OCTaeTCH er::qe p,aJIeKO He
:HCHbIM.
no OTHomeHIIIO KO BceM neplIop,aM IICTOPII'IeCIWn p,llHaMIU\II HaCeJIerHUI
IIHYCIIHCKOH KOTJIOBIlHbI HapIICOBaHHaH paHee KapTIIHa BapHa IIn KpaHIIO-
JIOrII'IeCKIIX IWMnJIeKCOB BO BpeMeHII OCTaeTCH npemHen. )J;JIH Hamen TeMbI
BamHa o eHKa cepIIII alIOXII cpep,HeBeKOBbH B CBeTe Tex me RpIITepIIeB, KO-
'TOpbIe 6bIJIII IICnOJIb30BaHbI BbIme p,JIH OD,eHKII COMaTOJIOrII'IeCKIIX II 6JIl<I3KIIX
'It COBpeMeHHOCTII KpaHIIOJIOrII'leCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB.
B STO BpeMH Ha TeppIITOpIIII MIIHYCIIHCIWII KOTJIOBlIHbI npOIICXOp,IIJIII oyp-
HbIe IICTOpII'JeCKlIe C06bITIIH. K COmaJIeHIIIO, naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIH MaTe-
pIIaJI, no KOTopmIY l\IOJImO ObIJIO ObI Cyp,IITb 00 II3MeHeHIIII iPII3II'IeCIwro
'TIIna B STY anoxy, IWJIII'JeCTBeHHO HeneJIIlI\ II nJIOXO p,aTIIponaH. IToCJIe no-
:HBJIeHIIH B ne'IaTII npep,BapIITeJIblIOrO co06r::qeHIIH 06 IICCJIep,OBaHlUl cepIIII
n03)J,HeII lIOpbI meJIe3HOrO Ber\a 52 JI. P. KbI3JIaCOB OTMeTIIJI, 'ITO OHa cop,ep-
-milT HII MaJIO HII MHoro, I\aK HeCKOJIbKO 'IepelIOB, p,aTIIpYIOr::qIlXCH BTOpOH:
nOJIOBIIHOn II TbICH'IeJIeTIIH H. a. 53 TeM He MeHee OHa nce me MOJIWT 6bITb
'JICnOJIb30BaHa p,JIH nepBOIIa'IaJIbIIOII opIleHTa InI 3a HeIIMeHIleM JIY'Illlero
:MaTepIIaJIa II nOCKOJIbI\Y 'Iepena, p,aTIIpYlOmIIeCH OJIII3IUIM K COBpeMeHHOCTll
BpeMeHeM, COCTaBJIHIOT BHen MeHbmIIIICTBO.
BCH cepIIH xapaKTepII3yeTcH pe3KIIM II3 reHeHlIeM TIIlIa no cpaBlIeHIIIO
'C TaUlTblI\CKOH anOXOH, B 'IaCTHOCTII 3aMeTHblM YCIIJIeHIIeM MOHrOJIOIIp,ll bIX
I
I
397
'-.
Ta6mII'\a 36
KOJIu'lecTBo upHSHaROB ypaJILCRoro n JOmHocH6npCKoro TDnOB B cepnH
«eHHceiicRHx RbIprLISOB»)
IIpH:3HaH
me 11HbI
, Mym IIHb]
8. IIOnepe"IHbIlI AHaMeTp
20. BbICOTHl>IH AHaMeTp OT IIOpHOHa
8 : 1. qepenHoll YRa3aTeJIb
45. CRYJIOBaH IIIHpHHa
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa JIII:L\a
55. BbIcoTa JIII:L\a
5. j..(JIUHa OCHOBaHHH "Iepena
9. HaHMeHbIllaH IIIHpHHa JIoa
SC. CHMOTII'leCRaH xOPAa
72. 'YroJI IIPOIfJIIJIH JIII:L\a 06m;Hll
73. 'YroJI Cpe)"lHell 'laCTII JIH:L\a
Lzm'. 3HrOMaRCHJIJIHPHbIll yrOJI
40: 5. 'YRa3aTeJIb BblcTynaHHH JIH:L\a
52: 51a. Op6lITHbIlI YRa3aTeJIb OT d (JIeB.)
PiOJII1"IeCTBO npII3HaROB ypaJIbCROrO THHa
PiOJIII"IeCTBO HellTpaJIbHbIX IIpII3naROB
ROJIII"IeCTBO npII3HaROB JOlliHOCII6IIpcRoro TIIna
CYMMapHoe ROJIII'leCTBO IIpnSHaROB ypaJIb-
CRoro rnna
CYMMapHoe ROJIH'leCTBO HeiiTpaJIbHbIX IIpIIS-
HaIWB
CYMMapHoe KOJIII'IeCTBO IIpII3HaROB JOmHO-
cII6IIpCRoro THIIa
x
'X
X
X
+
X
X
+
+
+
X
X
+
2
6
6
+
+
+
6
2
6
-'
4
4
6
oco6eHHOCTen. JIII O CTaHOBIITCH MHOrO Bblme II TIlIIpe, 'IeM Ha TamTbIRcKIIX
'Iepenax. B ::JTOM OTHOmeHIIII HaCeJIeHIIe MIIHYCIIHcKon KOTJIOBIIHbI B ::Jnoxy
n03p,HerO meJIe3a He YCTynaJIO KJIaCCII'IeCI\IIM npe,a;CTaBIITeJIHM MOHrOJIOII.n;-
Hon paCbI. Op,HOBpeMeHHO C ::JTIIl\1 pe3KO B03paCTaeT Be:rIl'IIIHa 'IepelIHOro
YI\a3aTeJIH. Bce pa3MepbI, onpep,eJIHIOr::qIIe CTeneHb BblcTynaHIIH Hoca, Hao60-
pOT, YMeHbmaIOTCH.
TaKIIM 06pa30M, p,IIHaMIIRa nplI3HaROB npII TIepeXop,e OT paHHen nopbI:
meJIe3HOro BeI\a R n03p,Hen IIp,eT B TOM me HanpaBJIeHIIII, B KaKOM TamTbIR-
CRaH cepIIH OTJIII'IaeTCH OT 'IepenHbIX cepIIn COBpeMeHHblX CII6IIpCI\IIX MOH-
rOJIOII,l:{OB, II B 'IaCTHOCTII OT npep,CTaBIITeJIen eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTCI\Oro Tlrna.
3TO cBIIp,eTeJIbCTByeT 0 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOM YBeJIII'IeHIIII p,OJIII MOHrOJIOIIp,HOro
KOMnOHeHTa eHTpaJIbHOa3IIaTcKoro npoIIcxomp,eHIIH II 0 npe06JIap,alOr::qeii:
pOJIII, KOTOPYID OH CTaJI IIrpaTb Ha py6eme I II II TbICH'IeJIeTIIn H. ::J.
ITOCROJIbI\Y onpep,eJIeHIIe MeCTa cepIIII n03p,Hero meJIe3HOro Ber\a B CIICTe-
MaTIIKe pac BToporo nopHp,Ka HBJIHeTCH 3ap,a'Ien nepBocTerreHHon Ba1KHOcTII
BBIIp,y B03MomHon npeeMCTBeHHOCTII Memp,y cpe,a;HeBeROBbL'lI II COBpeMeHHblM
HaCeJIeHIIeM XaKacIIII, npep,nplIHHTa nOnbITI\a Cp,eJIaTb ::JTO, conOCTaBJIHH ee'
C ceplIHMII ypaJIbcROro II IOmHOCII6IIpCKOrO TIInOB TO'IHO Tal\ me, RaK ::JTO
6bIJIO npOII3Bep,eHO no OTHomeHHIO R MaTeplIaJIaM no KpaHIIOJIOrIIII COBpel\1eH-
HbIX xaKaCCKIIX rpynn. Pe3YJIbTaTbI conOcTaBJIeHIIH npep,cTaBJIeHlJ B Ta6JI.36..
398
ITO,l].C'IeT ROJIIIqeCTBa npII3HaROB nOI\a3bIBaeT, 'ITO CpeIJ:HeBeKOBOe HaCeJIe-
.IIlle Xal\ac.IIII, eCJIII Cyp,IITb 0 ero aHTpOnOJIOI'II'IeCKOM TillIe 1I0 TOIl cepIIII,
<l\OTOpaH Haxop,IITCH B HameM pacnopmKeHIIII, Xapal\Tepu30BaJIOCL TeM me CO-
<)THomeHIIeM npII3HaKOB ypaJIbCKOrO II IOmHOCII6IIpCKoro THIIOB, 'ITO II IWII6a-
JIb!. HaJIII o, CJIe;:J:OBaTeJIbHO, onpep,eJIeHIlOe npeBaJIUpOBaIIlIe BJIlIHIUlJI IOmHO-
'CII6IIpCIwro TIIna, XOTH oc06eHHOCTII ypaJIbCROrO TIIIIa BblpameHbI B IICCJIen;O-
'BaHHOn cepIIII TaKme p,OCTaTO'IHO OT'IeTJIIIBO. BeCLMa BepOHTHO, 'ITO
lIcKJIlO'IeHIIe 1I3 Hee 3aBep,0r.IO n03p,HIIX 'IepenOB yMeHbmu:ro 6bI IWJIII'IeCTBO
npu3HaKOB ypaJIbCKOrO TIIna. TaK IIJIII IIHa'Ie, aIITpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIM TIIII Ka-
IIH eB II B KaKon-TO Mepe Iwn6aJIOB II caran eB MOllieT BOCXOp,IITb 1\ aHTpo-
nOJIOrlI'IecI\IIM ocooeHHOCTHM HaCeJIeHIIH ::JnOXII cpep,HeBeKOBbH, Torp,a I\aK 1I0
OTHomeHIIIO 1\ 6e.JbTbIpaM p,onyr::qeHIIe TalWn B03MomHOCTII He cor.;racyeTcH
.c IIMeror::qIIMIICH iPaI\TaMII.
3AKJIIOqEHlIE
C. B. KIICeJIeB BbICKa3aJI rIIIIoTe3Y I1pOIICXOmp,eHIIH cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH
XaKaccRon aBTouoMHon 06JIaCTII OT «eHIIceMcKIIx KbIprbI30B» 54. AHTpOnOJIO-
'rlI'IeCKIIe p,aHHbIe He p,alOT B03lVIOmHOCTII TpaRTOBRTb HaJIII'IIIe npHIVIOii CBH3ll
.Memp,y cpep,HeBeKOBbDI II COBpeMeHHblM HaCeJIeHUeM Xal\aCUII c;;rIlmKOM pac-
.IITIIpUTeJIbHO, ItaK STO 6b!JIO Cp,eJIaHO C. B. KUCeJIeBbIM. OHa BepOHTIIa p,JIH
Ra'IllHD,eB, B03l\IOlliHa p,JIH Kon6a;;rOB U caraM eB II Ma:IOBepOHTHa n;.'IFi 6e.'IbTbI-
pOB II KbI3blJIb eB. ITo OTHomeHIIIO 1\ Ka'IIIHD,aM II CaraMD,aM HaJIII'IUe TaKon
CBH311 1I0p,TBeplli;J:aeTCH npHMbIIVIII p,aHHbIMU no pO;J:OBOIVIY COCTaBY STIIX
rpynn, a IIMeHHO IIaJIUqIleM B IlX COCTaBe ceOIWB KbIprbI3CKoro I1pOIICXOfK;Je-
HIIH ". Pe3YJIbTRTOl\I Y'IaCTIIH «eIIuceIICKIIX KbIprbI30B) B STHoreHe3e xaKa-
COB HBJIHeTCH, nO-BIIp,IIMOMY, HaJIII'IIIe B aHTpOnOJIOrIl'IeCKOIVI COCTaBe llOCJIep,-
BIIX MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX ::JJIeMeHTOB eHTpaJIbHOa3UaTCIWro npOIICXOlliD:eHIIH.
JJ;pyron MOHTOJIOU;J:HbIn IWMnOHeHT, pOp,HHr::qIIM xaI\aCOB C caMoep,o- II yrpo-
"H3bI'IHbIMII HapO;J;aMII, BOCXOp,IIT, nO-BIlp,IlMOMy, 1\ TaIIITbII\CKOMY BpeMeHU II
lIMeeT Ha TeppUTopIIU MIIIIYCIIHCIwn IWTJIOBIIHbI ceBeplIoe lIpOIICXOfKp,eHIIe.
TaKIIM 06pa30 I, HaCIWJIbIW STO l\IOfRHO KOHCTaTIlpOBaTL C I10IVIO LIO
aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKoro aHaJIII3a, Xal\aCCKIIn Hapop, IIMeeT CJIOmHYro ::JTHII'IeCKYro
'iICTOpIIro, B IWTopon npIIHHJIII y'IaCTIle Kal\ TropKcKIIe Hapop,bI rofRHOrO npo-
ncxomp,eHIIH, TaK n yrpoH3bl'IHble II caMoep,OH3blQHble rpynIIbI, HBJIHBmlIecH,
nO-BIU\IIMOMY, Ha TeppIITopIIII MIIHYCIIHCIwn ROTJIOBIIHbI 60JIee p,peBHUMII.
llpep,JIOmeHHaH JI. P. Hbl3JIaCOBbIM KOH eIlD,IIH ::JTHoreHe3a xaKaCOB, PUCYIO-
'iD,aH IIpII6JIII3IITeJIbHO aHaJIOrII'IHYIO KapTIIHY COOTHomeHIIH CaMoe,l].O-1i yrpo-
H3bl'IHbIX nJIaCTOB, C op,Hon CTOpOlIbl, II TlOpI\CKoro - C p,pyroII, nOJIY'Iae'i'
P;OlIOJIHIlTeJI HOe nop,TBepmp,eHIIe 56.
EBponeOIIp,HaH npUMeCb B COCTaBe Xal\aCOB. no Bceii BepoHTIIoCTII, Bep,eT
-CBoe npoIIcxomp,eHIle OT HaCeJIeHIIH TarapCKOi1: snoxJI. OTMe'IeuHoe
A. II. Hpxo HOCB'€TJIeHIIe nIIrMeHTa IIII rJIa3 y xaKaCCKUX rpYIIll HpOHBJIileT-
CH TOJIbRO B conOCTaBJIeHIIII C KJIaCCII'IeCKIIMU npep,cTaBUTeJIHMII MOHrOJIOIIp,-
ROn 60JIbmOn pacbI. IIo cpaBHeHIIIO C npep,cTaBIITeJIHIVIII MeCTHbIX TIIIIOB-
'ypaJIbCIWrO II IOn\HOCII6upCKoro - xaKaCbl xapaKTepu3YIOTCH, 'ITO Yllie 6bIJIO
'OTMe'IeHO, KaK pa3 TeMHblM BeTOl\l rJIa3. 8TO n03BOJIUJIO BbICKa3aTL npep,-
nOJIOmeHIIe 0 TeMHOrJIa30CTU eBponeoIIp,Horo KOlVIlIoHeHTa, Bome/.l,mero B CO-
'CTaB cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH XaKaccIWM aBTOHOl\IHOM oo.rraCTII. IIHlolMII
-CJIOBaMII, ::JTO 03Ha'iReT, 'ITO TarapcKoe HaCeJIeHIIe MIIHYCIIHCKon KOTJIOBllHbI
MaJIO OTJIWlaJIOCb B D,BeTe rJIa3 OT cOBpeMeHHblx npep,CTaBIITeJIeii IOrr\HoM BeT-
'ElI eBponeOIIp,Hon 60JIbmOn pacbl. Tal\IIM oopa30M, npII COlIOCTaBJIeHIIII
aJIeOaHTpOn0JIOl'IIqeCKIIX II COMaTOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p,aHHblx 1I01IblTKa B03pOp,IITb
399
rlllIOTe3Y f. E. fpYMM-fpmIIManJIO II paCCMaTpllBaTb Tarap eB B Ra'IeCTBe
npep,CTaBIITeJIen CBeTJIOnllrMeHTIIpOBaHHOrO Tllna, IIpep,npIIHHTaH . H. fy-
MIIJIeBbIM 57, He Haxop,IIT iPaKTll'IeCIWrO lIop,TBepmp,eHIIH.
- j
Epxo A. n. IIpe)"lBapI1TeJIbHoe coo6m;eHIIe 0 noe3p;Re B MI1HycHHCRIIlI Rpaii H CeBep-
Hblii A,ITaii JIeTOM 1925 r. II CeB. A3HH. 1926. .N2 2; OH :!ICe. IIHrl'.IeHTaI'\IIH BOJIOC, rJIaa
H ROIKI1 Y Hapop;HocTeii AJITae-CaHHCRoro HaropbH II Pyc. aHTpOnOJI. lKypH. 1929.
T. 17, BbIII. 3/4; OH :!ICe. AJITae-caJIHcRlIe TIOpRH. A6aRarr, 1947; Hpxo A. n., Ee" -
KUHa B. n. 1lJI13H'IeCROe pa3BIITHe HaCeJIeHI1H XaRaccRoro oRpyra II CeB. A3HH. 1928.
oN> 5/6.
2 rpY.M.M-rp:!ICu.Mau. o r. E. 3anap;HaH MOHrOJIHH 11 'YpHHxalIcRHii RpaiI. JI., 1926. T. 2.
3 JIeeuH M. r. Pi Bonpocy 0 lOlliHocn6IIpCROM aHTpOnOJIOrII'leCROM THIIe II RpaT. co06m;.
HH-Ta 9THorpa<pHH AH CCCP. 1954. BbIll. 21.
/f.e6elf r. W. AHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCIDIe I1CCJIe)"lOBaHIIH B RaM'IaTCROii 06JIacTH II Tp. HH-Ta
9THorpalfJIIlI All CCCP. H. C. T. 17. M., 1951. C. 68-69.
5 Epxo A. n. AJITae-caHHCRI1e TlOpRH; OH :!ICe. TypR:UeHbI Xope3Ma H CeBepHoro RaB-
Ra3a II AHTporroJI. lliypH. 1933. oN> 1, 2; OH :!ICe. raH)"IIKHiicRHe TlOpIDI II TaM llie. 1932.
oN> 2.
6 OH :!ICe. AJITae-caHHcRHe TIOpRH. C. 79.
7 A.lteKCeee B. I1. XaRaCl>I, eHHCelICRIIe RblprbI3l>I, RHprH3bI: (CpaBHIIT.-RpaHI10JI. O'IepR) /I
Tp. PiIIpr. apXeOJI.-9THorp. 9Rcne;W:L\HH. M., 1956. T. 1; OH :!ICe. RpaHIIOJIOrHH xaKaCOB
B CBH3II C BorrpocaMII !IX npOIICXOlli)"leHIIH: (IIpep;B. co06m;.) II PipaT. coo6m;. HH-Ta
9THorpalfJIIII All CCCP. 1957. BbIll. 28; OH :!ICe. PipaHIIOJIOrI1H xaRaCOB B CBH3H C
BorrpocaMII HX rrpoIIcxOmAeHI1H II Tp. RI1pr. apXeOJI.-9THorp. 9RCrre;IIII'\IIH. M., 1960.
T.4.
8 I1oranoe JI. I1. 8THorpalfJII'IeCRaH noesp;Ra Ha lOr XaRacHII B 1946 r.II'YTJ.eH. san.
XaRac. I1H-Ta H3bIKa, JIHTepaTypbI II HCTOpIIH. A6aRaH, 1947. Bl>In. 1; OH :!ICe. ::h-
HII'leCRlIii COCTaB CaralI:L\eB II COB. 9THorpa1fJIIH. 1947. 3.
9 Epxo A. n. AJITae-CaHHcKIIe TlOpRI1.
10 /f.e6elf r. W. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRI1e HccJIeAOBaHHH B RaM'laTCROii o6JIacTI1. C. 68-69.
1! CM., Harrp.: BYHaK B. B., HecTPYx M. W., PoeUHCKuu E. E. AHTponoJIorHH. M., 1941;
/f.e6elf r. w. IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorIIH CCCP. M.; JI., 1948. (Tp. HH-Ta 9THorpalfJnH AH
CCCP. II. C.; T. 4); P02UHCKUU E. E., JIeeuH M. r. OCHOBbI aHTpOIIOJIOrHH. M., 1955.
;2 A68yzue.ltuzueu.ltu M. r. MaTepHaJIbI R RpaHIIOJIOrIIH RaBRa3a II Tp. HH-Ta sKclIepHM.
MOp<pOJIOrIm AH rccp. T6IIJII1CII, 1955. T. 5; OH :!ICe. AHTponoJIorI1H ApeBHero H
COBpe IeHHOrO HaCeJIeHIIH rpY3IIII. T6IIJIHCI1, 1964; A.lteKCeee B. I1. IIpOHCXOm)"leHIIe
HapO)"lOB RaBRa3a: (RpaHIIOJI. HCCJIep;oB.). M., 1974.
t, Morant G. M. A preliminary classification of european races based on cranial
measurements II Biometrica. 1928. Vol. XX.
H. Woo T. Z., Morant G. M. A biometric study of the dlatnees>} of the facial sceleton
in man II Biomctrica. 1934. Vol. XXVI; /f.e6elf r. W. AHTponoJIorII'lecIDIe I1ccJIep;o-
BaHIIH B RaM'la TCKOM 06JIaCTII.
t5 BYHaJ> B. B. qeperra H3 CRJIenOB ropHoro RaBRa3a B cpaBHHTeJIbHO-aHTpOnOJIOrH'Ie-
CROM OCBem;eHIIH II C6. MY3eH aIlTporrOJIOrIIII II 9THorpa1fJIIII. M.; JI., 1953. T. 14.
te Schreiner A. Certain projective depth and bredth measurements of the facial skele-
ton in man II Biometrica. Vol. XXXI. London, 1940.
t7 EKu"uoe B. I1. lIa'IaJIbHbIe 3TanbI 3aCeJIeHIIH BOCTO'IHOM IIpII6aJITIIRI1 II EaJITHMCIDIM
9THorpa<pII'IeCRHii c60pHIIR. M., 1956. (Tp. HH-Ta sTHorpa<pI11I AH CCCP. H. C.;
T. 32); OH :!ICe. 0 )"IpeBHeii «MOHrOJIOH)"IHOCTH» B EBpone II PipaT. co06m;. HH-Ta ST-
HorpalfJHH AH CCCP. 1957. BbIIT. 28.
t8 BUToe M. B., MapK K. /0., TJe6oJ>capoe H. H. 8THII'IeCRaH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIH BOCTO'lHOa
IIpI16aJITI1RII II Tp. IIpII6aJIT. 9RcrreAI1:L\HH. M., 1959. T. 2.
t9 /f.e6elf r. W. MaTepIIaJIbI rro naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIII CCCP: HIIIKHee IIoBoJIlKbe II AHTpo-
nOJI. lliypH. 1936. .N2 1; OH :!ICe. IIaJIeoaHTponoJIornH CCCP.
20 HaTuzueu.ltu A. N., A6iJyzue.ltUZU6U.ltu M. n., A68yzue.ltuzu6u.ltU M. r. MaTepHaJIbI
9Rcne)"lH:L\IIII 1950 rOAa IIO aHTpOnOJIOrHII cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHHH rpY3HHCROll:
CCP II Tp. HH-Ta 9RclIepHM. MOplfJOJIOrIIlI All rccp. T6HJIHCH, 1953. T. 4; HaTuzueu-
.ltu A. 11., A68yzue.ltuzueu.ltu M. r. IIpep;BapHTeJIbHbIe AaHHbIe 06 aHTpOnOJIOrI1'IeCRHX
HCCJIeAOBaHHHx rpY3ImCRoro Hapop;a II RpaT. coo6m;. HH-Ta sTHorpalfJHH All CCCP.
1955. Bl>In. 22. A68yzue.ltuzueu.ltu M. r. OCeTI1HbI: (AHTponoJI. O'IepR) II Tp. HH-Ta
9RcnepHM. MOplfJOJIOrIIH AH rccp. T6I1JII1cI1, 1957. T. 6.
2t Morant G. M. A preliminary classification of europEan races based on cranial measure-
ments.
22 /f.e6elf r. W. AHTpOnOJIOrII'IeClme HCCJIe)"lOBaHHll B RaM'IaTCROlI o6JIacTH.
"
400
<:,
r
r
23 e6elf r. l/J. AHTporroJIOrII'leCRITe ITCCJIep;OBaHITH B RaM'laTCKOii 06JIaCTIT. OTTyp;a me
B3HTl>I IT )"IaHHbIe no cep:!IIT TYBI1H:L\eB.
2 A.lteKCeee B. I1. IIpoI1cxomp;eHHe HapO)"lOB BOCTO'lHOii EBporrbI: (RpaHHOJI. ITCCJIep;.)
M., 1969.
25 KacuMoea P. AHTporrOJIOrH'leCROe HCCJIegOBaHIIe 'leperrOB II3 MHHre'laypa. BaRY, 1959.
:l6 CepITH COCTaBHJIaCb 113 'lepeIIOB, xpaHHm;IIXCH Ha RalfJep;pax HOpMaJIbHOii aHaTOMHH
Op;eCCRoro Mep;IIHCTIITYTa IT BoeHHO-Mep;II:L\HHCIWH aRap;eMHII B JIeHIIHrpap;e. RaK B
9TOM, TaR II B rrpegbqym;Hx CJIY'laHX B3HTbI p;aHHble rro MYlliCRIIM 'IeperraM. CM.:
A.I!eKCeee B. I1. PipaHIIOJIOrH'leCRIIe MaTepIIaJIbI R 3THoreHe3Y TypRMeHCRoro Hapo-
Aa II IIp06JIeMbI 9THoreHe3a TypRMeHCRoro HapO)"la. AIIIXa6a)"l, 1960.
21 CM.: e6elf r. l/J. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'leCRIIe IICCJIe)"loBaHIIH B RaM'laTCROlI 06JIaCTII.
2R rUH36ype B. B., e6elf r. l/J.. JleeuH 111. r., TJ e60Kcapoe H. H. Q-qepIDI IIO aHTporro-
JIOrHII Pia3axcTaHa II PipaT. COoom;. IIH-Ta 9THorpalfJIIII All CCCP. 1952. BbIIT. 16;
MUK.ltaZUeecKaJ/, H. H. CmIaTOJIOrH'leCRIIe IICCJ.wp;OBaHIIH B PiIIprII3IIII II Tp. RHpr.
apXeOJI.-9THorp. m{crrep;I1:L\I1II. M., 1956. T. 1 (3p;ecb llie CM. IICTOpIIIO B3rJIHp;OB Ha MeCTO
RIIprII30B B paCOBolI CIICTeMaTIIRe); OHa :JICe. RpaHIIOJIOrIIH RIIprII30B II Tp. KHpr.
apXeOJI.-9THorp. 9Kcrrep;I1:L\I1Ir. M., 1959. T 2.
!1 rUH36ype B. B., e6eLJ' r. l/J., JleeuH M. r., TJe6oKcapoe H. H. O'lepRn...
30 JIeeuH ill. r. R Bonpocy 0 IOiRHOCII6IIpCROM aHTpOrrOJIOrI1'leCROxI TIIrre.
31 OH :JICe. RpaHIIOJIOrlI'leCRIrII THrr xaHTbI II MaHCII II RpaT. co06m;. IIH-Ta H IY3eH aHTpo-
IIOJIOrI1II 3a 1938-1939 rr. M., 1941; TpoifJUMoea T. A., TJe6oKcapoe H. H. CeBepo-
ypaJIbCRaH 9Rcnep;II:L\I1H MY3eH aHTpOrrOJIorI1II II TaM me; OHU :JICe. AHTponoJIorH'lecRoe
II3Y'leHIIe MaHCI1 II PipaT. co06m;. IIH-Ta IICTOpIIII MaTepIIaJIbHOll: RYJIbTypbI. 1941.
BbIIT. 9; TpofPuMoea T. A. TOOOJIbCRlIe II oapa6IIHcRIIe TaTapbI II Tp. IIH-Ta 3THOrpa-
IfJI1II All CCCP. II. C. M.; JI., 1947. T. 1; e6elf r. l/J. CeJIbRyrrbI: (AHTporroJI. O'iepR) /I
Tp. IIH-Ta 9THorpalfJIIII AH CCCP. H. C. M.; JI., 1947. T. 2; OH :JICe. IIaJIeoaHTporro-
JIOrIIH CCCP; OH :JICe. AHTponoJIorI1'lecRHe IICCJIep;OBaHIIH B RaM'laTcRolI 06JIaCTH;.
TJ e6oKcapoe H. H. OCHOBHbIe npIIH:L\IIITbI aHTpOrrOJIOrH'leCKIIX RJIaCCIIIfJHRa:L\IIlI II IIpo-
I1CXOffip;eHIIe 'leJIOBeKa II p;peBHee paCCeJIeHI1e 'leJIOBe'leCTBa. M., 1951. (Tp. IIH-Ta
9THorpa<pHII All CCCP. II. C.; T. 14).
32 BYHaK B. B. qeJIOBe'leCRIIe paCl>I II nYTII I1X 06pa30BaHIIH II COB. 9THorpa1fJIrH. 1956.
.NH.
33 e6eLJ r. l/J. 0 reHeaJIorn'lecRolI RJIaCcIIIfJIIRaWIII 'leJIOBe'leCRIIX pac II COB. 9THorpa--
IfJI1H. 1956. 1'& 4.
34 e6elf r. l/J. CeJIbRyrrbI.
35 Hpxo A. 11. Ra3aXII PYCCRoro AJITaH II CeB. A3IIH. 1930. 1'& 1, 2; OH :JICe. AJITae-caHH-
CRIIe TIOpKII; OH :JICe. PilIprII3bI 113a I1HP;YCTpIIaJII13a:L\IIIO COBeTcRoro BocToRa. M.._
1934.'
36 rUH36ype B. fl., e6elf r. l/J., JIeeuH M. r., 'C/e6oKcapoe H. H. O'iepRI1.
37 e6elf r. l/J. AHTpOnOJIOrII'leCKIIe IICCJIenOBaHIIH B PiaM'laTCROii 06JIac'fI1; JIeeuH M. r.
3THII'leCRaH aHTpOnOJIOrIIH II np06JIexlbI 9THoreHe3a HapOAOB )J;aJIbHerO BOCTORa II
Tp. IIH-Ta 9THorpalfJHI1 AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 36. M., 1958.
38 e6elf r. l/J. AHTporroJIorII'lecRIIe IICCJIeAOBaHIIH B RaM'laTCROii 06JIaCTI1.
39 Kbl3.1tacoe JI. P. TaIIITbIRCRaH 3rroxa. M., 1960.
40 O.lt3UX B. O. 06PHP;OBbIe coopymeHIIH HraHacaHOB II 9H:L\eB II RpaT. COoom;. IIH-Ta
9THorpalfJIIII All CCCP. 1951. BbIIT. 13; Bacu.lteeu'l. r. M., JIeeuH M. r. TIInbI OJIe-
HeBop;CTBa II IIX npoIIcxollip;eHIIe II COB. 9THorpa1fJIIH. 1951. 1'& 1; MO.ltbHap a. IIp06JIe-
MbI 9THoreHe3a II p;peBHeii IICTOpIII1 BeHrepcRoro Hapop;a II Studia Historica. Budapest,
1955. N 13. .
It I1poKofPbee r. H. 3THoroHIIH Hapop;HocTeii 06b-EHI1ceIIcRoro 6accelmallCoB. 3THO-
rpalfJI1H. JI., 1940. T. 3.
u e6elf r. l/J. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'leCRIIe HCCJIep;OBaHIIH B PiaxI'laTCROlI 06JIaCTI1.
'3 P030e H. C. MaTepIIaJIbI rro RpaHIIO"JIOnlII 'lYJIbUI:L\eB II CeJIbRyrroB II AHTpOnOJIOrH-
'leCRIIii C60PHIIR, I. M., 1956. (Tp. IIH-Ta 9THorpalfJIIII All CCCP. H. C.; T. 33; On :JICe.
AHTpOrrOJIOnI'leCRIIlI COCTaB p;peBHero HaCeJIeHIIH cpep;Heii 06II (ceJIbRynoB) II Y'leH.
3alI. TOM. YH-Ta. 1958. T. 32.
u rUH36ype B. B., 3a. KuHf} H. r. MaTepIIaJIbI R KpaHI10JIOrIm Ra3aXOB (B CBH3I1 C
BonpocaxIII 9THoreHe3a) II C6. MY3eH aHTpOrrOJIOrIII1 II 9THorpa1fJIIII. M.: JI., 1955. T. 16;
llcMaey.we O. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'leCRaH xapaKTepIIcTHRa cOBpeMeHHblx Ra3aXOB IIO AaH-
HbIM RpaHIIOJIOrIIII IITp. IlH-Ta 9THorpalfJIIII All CCCP. H. C. M., 1963. T. 83.
U MUK.ltaZUeecKaJ/, H. H. PipaHIIOJIOrIIH RHprn30B.
46 A.lte1l:ceee B. I1. RpaHlIOJIOrIIH xaRaCOB B CBH3II C BonpocaMH I1X npOIICXO)l\J(eHIIH.
41 A.lteKCeee B. I1. I1a.:IeOaHTpOnOJIOrIm AJITae-CaHHcKoro HaropbH B anOXII HeOJIIITa
II 6POH3bI II AHTponOJIorII'IeCRIIlI C60PHIIR, III. M., 1961 (Tp. IIH-Ta 9THorpalfJIII1 AH
CCCP. H. C. T. 71); OH :JICe. IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorIIH XaRaCIII1 9rrOXH meJIe3a II C6. MY3ea
aHTponOJIOrHII IT 9THorpalfJIII1 All CCCP. M.; JI., 1961. T. 20.
I
o.
401
I
'8 H08UHlfee A. r. AHTpOrrOJIOrI1'leCRIIll COCTaB II rrpOHCXOiI\)\eHIIe HaCeJIeHIIH TarapCRoii J. "
RYJIbTypbI. JI., 1977.
Pb£KywuHa r. B. HaCeJIeHI1e Cpe,J;Hero EHIIceH B RapacYRcRyro 9noxy: (PipaHIIOJI.
O'lepK) II IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIH CIIOlIpII. HOBOCIIOIIpCR, 1980.
5r /l,e6e!f r. l/J. IIaJIeoaHTponoJIorIUI oKYHeBcKoll RYJIbTypbI II IIaJIeOaHTpOnO.:IOrIIH CI1-
6I1pII.
'51 Mm;CUMeHKoe r. A. BrrYCRHbIe MOrI1JIbI oKyneBcRoro 9Tarra B alfJaHacbeBCKIIX Rypra-
Hax Ii COB. apXeOJIOnIH. 1965. M 4; IfeaHoea /1. A. 0 IIpOIICXOiR):\eIII1II opaxlmpaHHoro
ROMnOHeHTa B COCTaBe HaCeJIeHIIH alfJaHacbeBcRolI RYJIbTypbI II COB. 9THorpa1fJIIH.
1966. N2 3.
52 A.aeKceee B. I1. XaRaCbI, eHIICell:CRIIe KblprbI3bI, RIIpnI3bI: (CpaBHIIT.-RpaHIIOJI. O'iepR) II . ::'
Tp. PiI1pr. apXeOJI.-9THorp. 3Kcrre,J;IIUIIII. M., 1956. T. 1.
53 Kb£8.1tacoe JI. P. 0 CBH3HX RIIprrr30B EHlIceH II THHb-IIIaHH: (Pi Bonpocy 0 npOI1C-
XOJKp;eHIIII KIIpnmCKoro HapO,J;a) II Tp. PiI1pr. apXeOJI.-9THorp. 9Rcrrep;II:L\IIII. IlJpYH3e,
1959. T. 3.
M Huce..lee C. B. )J;peBHHH IICTOpIIH IOmHoii CII6.upI1. .i '
55 CM.: TOKapee C. A. IIepeiRIITKII pOP;OBbIX OTHOIlleHIIll y xaRaCOB B XIX B. II CI16IIp-
CRIIH 9TIIorpalfJ.u'leCRI1ii c60pHlIK, 1. M., 1952. (Tp. I1H-Ta 9THorpalfJIIH AH CCCP.
H. C. T. 18); I1oTanoe JI. I1. PipaTRlIe O'iepIUI IICTOpIIII 11 9TIIorpalfJI1II xaKaCOB
(XVII-XIX BB.). A6aRaH, 1952; OH :!ICe. IIpoIIcxomp;eHIIe II 1fJ0p II1pOBaHIIe XaRaCCROH
HapOp;HOCTlI. A6aRaH, 1957. .
5.; Kb£8JlUcoe JI. P. Pi Borrpocy 06 9THoreHe3e xaRaCOB II ¥'leH. 3an. XaRac. HaY'l.-IlCCJIep;.
IIH-Ta H3bIKa, JIIITepaTypbI II IICTOpUII. AoaRaH, 1959. BbIII. 7.
57 rYMu.ltee JI. H. )J;IIHJIIIHCRaH rrpOOJIeMa (rrepeCMOTp nIIIOTe3bI r. E. rpYMM-rpJKIIMaii-
HO B 'HOW BOO"'" n,,"pn"" n 'pXOO"O 'OH= "'WP","OB) /lIl'B D,"", . .
l'eorp. O-Ba. M.; JI., 1959. T. 91, BbIIT. 1.
AHTPOITOJIOfMqECKMB KOMMEHTAPMB
R fMITOTE3E QIIPKYMITOJIHPHOB KYJIbTYPbI
:npep,CTaBJIeHIIe 0 IIpI\YMnOmlpHOll I\YJIbType, paCIIpOcTpaHeHHon Bp,OJIb
ApKTII'IeCIWrO lIo6epellibH EBpa3IIH II AMepIIKII, B03HIIKJIO Bc.rreJJ:CTBIIe
'HeocnopIIMoro Cxop,CTBa MHorIIX KYJIbTypHbIX HBJIeHIIII B 3anap,HbIX II BOCTO'I-
HbIX panOHax API\TIIKII. B npo ecce IICCJIep,OBamIH :=noro Cxop,CTBa npep,JIa-
raJIIICb pa3HbIe rrrrrOTe3bI p:JIH ero 06'bHCHeHIIH, OObI'IJIO IICnOJIb3yel\IbIe npII
HHTepllpeTa IIII cxop,Hon KYJIbTY1JHOll: TIInOJIOrIIII B pa3Hblx panoHax: 06 ero
'cy6cTpaTa, aTHII'IeCKIIX MlIrpa IIn, I\YJIbTypHOll: p,IIiPiPY3IIII II ap,anTIIBHon KOH-
BepreHwm 1 . IIoCKOJIbKY OKOH'IaTeJIbHblii BbI60p MelliJJ:Y HIIMII He ocyr::qeCTBJIen
II cen'Iac, eCTL CMblCJI npIIBJIe'Ib K 06cymp,eHIIIO IIMelOr::qYIOCH aHTpOnOJIOrH-
'''leCI\YIO IIHiPopMa IIIO.
COMATOJIOrHqECKOECOIIOCTABJIEHHE
BeT aHTpOnOJIOrrl'IeCI\IIX pa60T, KOTopbIe OXBaTbIBamI 6bI Hapop,bl apKT.Il'Ie-
CKon 30Hbl B eJIOM. IToCJIe,'J;Hee 6blJIO Obi oc06eHHO BamIIO IIpIl l\WPtPO.:ro-
TH'IeCKOll: XapaI\TepIICTlIKe COBpe:\IeIIHoro HaCeJIeHIIH, TaK KaK n03BOJIIlJIO 6bI
1I36emaTb pa3JIII'IIIll: B MeTOD,IIKe onpeJJ,eJIeHIIH npII3HaKOB. C aTon eJIbIO
Ha'iHeM C COIIOCTaBJIeHIIH 'IVK'Ieii II HeH eB.
HeH bl IIcc.rreD,OBamICb' 3IIMOII 1969 r. B IIOC. TapKO-CaJIe ITYPOBCKOro
-panoHa TIOMeHCKOll: 06JIaCTII II' IIpep,CTaBJIHIOT OC06yIO rpynny Tal\ Ha3bIBae-
MbIX JIeCHbIX HeII eB. B aIITpOIlOJIOrIl'IeCKOM OTHOmeHITIl I10CJIep,IIlIe OTJIII-
'IalOTCH HaII6oJIbmell: cpep,II HeH eB KOH eHTpa IIen MOHrOJIOIIp,HbIX rrpII3Ha-
'ROB, 'ITO IIOKaaano B crie IIaJIbnoii pa60Te 2. qYK'IlI IICCJIe,'],OBaHbl B nOCeJIKaX
YaJIeH II JIOpIIHO qYIWTCKoro panOHa Marap,aIICRoii OOJIaCTIl JIeTOM 1970 r.
Pa3pbIB Mem:w P,BYMH aKcne,'J;II IIHIVIlI OIWJIO nOJIYTopa JIeT, 'J'TO B npIIHD,HIIe
402
I
Ta6JIH:L\a 37
CpaBHeHI1e JIeCHbIX HeH:L\eB II 'lYK'leii. Mym'lHHbI
IIpII3HaH
POCT 60PO)IbI (c 25 JIeT) , cpeJ];HIIH 6aJIJI
POCT 6pOBeH, )})}
lI;BeT BOJIOC, % M 27
lI;BeT rJIa3, cpeJ];HI1H 6aJIJI
8IIIIRaHTYc, % HaJIH'lIIH
CRJIaJ];Ra BeRa p, cpep;HIIlI 6aJIJI
CRJIaJ];Ra BeRa m, cpep;HIIii oaJIJI
CRJIaJ];Ra BeRa d, cpe)J:HI1ll: oaJIJl
Bl>ICOTa IIepeHOCbH, cpep;HIIii 6aJIJI
IIOlIepe'lHl>IH IIPOIfJI1JIb CIIHHRI1 Hoca, cpeJ];HIIR 6aJIJI
06m;IIH IIPOlfJlIJIb CIIIIHRII Hoca, % BOrHYTblx
IIoJIomeHI1e ROH'lIIRa Hoca, cpeJ];HHH 6aJIJI
rOplI30HTaJIbHblH IIPOIfJI1JIb JIl1I'\a, cpeJ];HIIH 6aJIJI
Bl>ICTyrraHI1e CRYJI, cpeJ];HIIH 6aJIJI
Bl>ICOTa BepxHeH ryObI, cpeJ];HHH 6aJIJI
BbICTYIIaHlIe BepxHeii ry6bI, cpeJ];HI1H 6aJIJI
«TOJIm;I1Ha)} BepxHeH ry6bI, cpeJ];HIIH 6aJIJI
«TOJIm;IIHa» HI1mHeH ryobI, cpeJ];HIlH 6aJIJI
HeHI1bI
(n-28)
1,52
1.64
4,0
1,20
42,8
2,21
2,50
2,50
1,50
1,57
53,5
1,21
1,46
2,25
1,93
1,30
1.43
1,82
I 'IYHqII In - 891
1,13
1,60
88,9
1,94
77,5
2,03
2,11
2,10
1,70
1,60
34,5
1,46
1,40
2,30
2,19
1,61
2,36
3,16
I
-
Mor;rrO ObI npIIBeCTII R cp,BIIry B lVIaCmTa6e Onpep,eJIeHIIJI OnIICaTeJIbHblX npII-
3HaROB. Ho B npOlV1emYTKe, JIeTOM 1969 r., aBTOp pa60TaJI Ha AJITae, rp,e
IICCJIep,OBaJI 'IeTblpe rpynnbl - aJITaII-KflmII, TeJIeHrIITOB, RYlVIaH,l];IIH eB II TY-
OaJIapOB.
ITOJIY'IeHHbIe p,aHHbIe npep,CTaBJIeHbl B TaOJI. 37. B Hell iPIIrypIIPYIOT
JIIImb onIICaTeJIbHble npII3HaRII, TaK KaR II3MepIlTeJIbHble npII3HaRII ,l];ame B
ROM6IIHa IIII "!aCTO COBnap,aIOT y npep,CTaBIlTeJIeII pa3HblX rpynn.
ITpIIHap,JIemHOCTb II 'IYR"IeII, II JIeCHhlX HeH eB R MOHrOJIOIIp,IIOII pace
HeCOlVIHeHHa, 'ITO 6bIJIO JlCHO II 3apaHee. B TO llie BpeMH p,OCTaTO'IHO p,eMOH-
CTpaTIIBHbI pa3JIIl'IIIH Memp,y HIIMII B pOCTe 60POp,bl, BeTe BOJIOC II rJIa3
BblpameHHOCTII ::JIlIIRaHTyca, pa3BIITIIII BepXHero BeRa, 06r::qeM IIpoiPIIJIe CIIIIH-
RII Hoca, IIOJIOmeHIlII ROH'IIIKa Hoca, BblCOTe BepXHeII ry6bI II «To:rr::qIIHe» ry6.
lfx 06'heKTIIBHbln xapaRTep TeM 60JIee He BhI3hIBaeT COIVIH, eHIln 'ITO rpYIlIIbI
npaKTII'IeCKII op,IIHaKOBhI IIO B03paCTHOMY COCTaBY: cpep,HIln B03paCT IICCJIe-
,l];OBaHHbIX JIeCHblX HeH eB - 41,3 rop,a, cpep,HIlII B03paCT 'IYK'IeII - 40,2 rop,a.
YpoBelIb CTaTIlCTII'IeCKOn 3Ha'IIIMOCTII pa3JIIl'IIIIl nOKa3aH Ha pIlC. 33, Ha RO-
TOpOM aMnJIIITyp,a pa3HII no Kam,l];OlVIY II3 06HapymIIBalOr::qIIx IIX npU3HaROB
BbipameHa B npO eIITaX omII6RII npo eHTHoro paCIIpep,eJIeHIIH. ECTecTBeHHo,
B rpaiPIIK nOnaJIII mlmh Te npII3HaRII, KOTopble oxapaRTepII30BaHbl npOn;eH-
TOlVI HaJIII'IIIH npe06JIa.J;arorn;ero IIJIII BaJ!moro BaplIaHTa.
MacmTao pa3:rII'IIlII Memp,y Il3Y'IeHHbllVIII Op,HIIM pa60TIIIIKOlVI HeH aMII U
'IYK'IaMII IIO npII3HaKaM, BamHblM p,JIH pacoBoII p,IIarHOCTIIKII, TaKOB, 'ITO OH
OnpaB)J,blBaeT OTHeceHne IIX R pa3HbllVI paCOBhIlVI rpYIlnalVI B I1pep,eJIax MOH-
rOJIOIID;OB. OnpaBp,aHHo pa3HbllVI C'IIITaeTCH II IIX IIpOIlCXOmp,eHIIe. HeH bl,
RaR II3BeCTHO, npep,CTaBIITeJIII ypaJIbcROII paCbI, op,Horo 113 OTBeTBJIeHIIn ROH-
TIIHeHTaJIbHbIX MOHrOJIOIIp,OB, BepOHTHO BKJIIO'IIIBmerO B CBon COCTaB eBpo-
neOII,l];Hyro npIIlVIeCb 3. 'llyR'III me BlVIeCTe C ::JCRIIl\lOCaMII II, nO-BII,l];IIMOMY,
403
t----------
----------1
'PI1C. 33. Pa3HH:L\a Melli,o;y HeH-
:L\aMH 11 'lYK'laMH IIO HeKoTopbIM
orrHCaTeJIbHbIM IIpI13HaKaM, BbI-
pallieHHaH B )J;OJIHX orrm6ID1
cpep;Hero rrpO:L\eHTHoro pacnpe-
)J;CJIeHI1H
1 - I1BeT BOJIOe (% 27);
2 - % HaJIWlHH 3mIRaHTyea;
3 - % BorHYTbIx 4>OPM OOll\ero npo-
4>HJUI eIlHHKH Hoea
I
J
"
,
1
Z
1---- ----4
J
f-- --I
1JIUU/KU Cj1l'fJ/ff.'Zfl /Tj1fll;elf/7lffflZfl j1I1C/TjJf'ilt'l1elfU/l
---- flI1JlfUl;U lI1eJfCJlp lfeHl/tlll1U Ii I/pM'tl/ll1i
.
,
JIeYTaIVIII OTHOCHTCH K apKTII'IeCKOIl pace II 06'be,lJ,IIHHIOTCH BlVIeCTe C romHbI-
.MII II BOCTO'IHbllVIII 1VI0HrOJIOIIp,aMII B TIIXOOKeaHCKYIO BeTBl, 4.
.D;pyraH B03MomHOCTl, conOCTaBJIeHIIH Hapop:OB B npep,eJIax apKTII'IeCKOii
30Hbl - II3Y'IeHHbIe r. <D. .D;e6eD,OM HeHD,hI, 'IYK'IH II ::JCKIIIVIOChI 5. HeH bI
6b1JIII IICCJIep,OBaHhI IIlVI B YCTl,e Ta3a, aCKIIIVIOChI II 'IYK'IH - KaK BO BHYTpeH-
'HIlX paiiOHax qYKOTCKoro I10JIYOCTpOBa, TaK II I10 n06epeml,lO. B Ta6JI. 38
.qJIIrYPIIPyeT 6eperoBaH rpynna, KaK 60Jlee IVIHDrO'IHCJIeHHaH. Cpep,HIIn B03-
paCT 06CJIep,OBaHHbIX HeH eB - 34,5 rop,a, ::JCKIIMOCOB - 34,7 rop,a, 'IYK'Ien-
36,5 rop,a. COBnap,eHIIe D,IIiPP cpep,Hero B03paCTa p,aeT B03lVIOmHOCTl, npOll3-
BeCTII I1pHIVIOe cpaBlleIIlle rpYllTI, He BBOAfl HIIKaKIIX p,OnOJIHIITeJIhHbIX norrpa-
mOK. HeH bl, KaK II rro MOIIM p,aIlIIbIM, ropa3p,0 60JIee CBeTJIOBOJIOCl,I II
.CBeTJIOrJIa3bl, IIlVIelOT npoiPIIJIIIpOBaHHoe JIII O, 60JIee nO,lJ,HHTbln KOH'IIIK Hioca,
MaJIOe nop,HOCOBoe paCCTOHHIIe, 60JIee opTOXelIJIll'IHbl II TOHKory6bI. ITpII
'cpaBHeHllII C 'IYK'IaMII OHII OTJIII'IaIOTCH 66JIl,mIIlVI pOCTOM 60POp,bl, lVIeHhmllM
IIpo eHTOM JIIID, C anllKaIITYCOM, MeHee pa3BIITon CKJIap,KOn BeKa.
RCTaTII CKa3aTl" rrpIIBJIeKalOT BHIIMaHIIe II ne 06CYllip,aBmIIeCH paHbme
'pa3JIII'IIIH lVIemp'Y 6eperOBhIl\Ul 'IYK'IaMII II aCKIIMocalVIII. .D;JIH nOCJIep,HIIX xa-
paRTepHbl 50.'Iee 06IIJIhHaH paCTIITe.'Il,HOCTb Ha JIIID,e, rro).!,aBJIHIOr::qee rrpeo6JIa-
)J,aHIIe IICCIIHH-<IepHhIX BOJIOC, lVIeHl,mee pa3BIITIIe arumaHTyca II CKJIap,KII
BeKa, nOp,aBJIHlOmee I1pe06JIap,aHIIe npHlVIl,IX II BblrryK.:rl,IX iPOpM 06r::qero rrpo-
'cpIIJIH cnIIHKll Hoca, O'IeHl, 60JIl,IHaH BhICOTa KomHoii 'IaCTII BepXHen rYObI.
TaKon KOIVIll.TJ:eKC OTJIII'IIIll 06'bHCHHeTCH, BIIp,IIIVIO, TeM, 'ITO crre IIiPII'IecRaH
p,JIH OJIeHHblX 'IYK'Ien KOM6IIHaD,l'lH rrpll;maKOB npOHBJIfleTCH qaCTII'IHO II Y 6e-
'perOBblX. r. <D. .D;e6e Heyp,a'IHo Ha3Ba.'I ee KaM'IaTCKOII. lI,eJIeC006pa3Hee
ObIJIO ObI Ha3hIBaTb ee B COOTBeTCTBllII C reorpaiPII'IeCKOn JIOKaJuI3aD,ueii
BHYTpII'IYKOTCKon. OHa, 6eccnopHo. Haxo.a:llT ce6e MeCTO B COCTaBe apKTII'Je-
-CRon paCbl, KaK II c06CTBeHHO oepIIHrmIOpCKIIn BapllaHT, xapaKTepHbIn p,JIH
::JCKIIMOCOB, HO p,JIH Hamen TeMbI BamHO, 'ITO KOlVIrrJIeKCHble pa3:rLI'IIIH rrpOJIB-
JIHIOTCH p,ame MeiI{P,Y Teppl'ITOpIIaJIhHO 6JIII3KIIlVUl II IICTOpII'IeCKII KaK 6yp,TO
pOp,C'FBeHHbIMII rrOrrYJIH:l(IIflMII.
B03Bpar::qaHCh K HeH alVI, CJIe;:J:yeT nOp,'IepKIIYTh llX oc060e nOJIOmeHIIe
II IIpIIHap,JIen,HOCTb K IIHOlVIY paCOBOMY apeaJIY no cpaBHeHIIIO C HaCeJIeHIIeM
EOCTO'IHon Cy6apKTIIKII. STOT BbIBOp, oc06eHHO IIHTepeceH, nOTOMY 'ITO OH
nOJIY'IeH npII corrOCTaBJIeHUII C aCKl1lVIOCa:lIII II 'IYK'IaIVUl TeIleph YShe lIe JIec-
IIbIX, a TYHiJ:POBbIX HeHl(eB.
ITOBTOpl1M onepa IIIO cpaBHeHIIH TeppIITOpIIaJIbHO p,aJIeKIIX apKTII'IeCKIIX
rpynn, BocrrO.'IL30BaBIHIICL :\IaTepUaJIalVIl1 If. M. 30JIOTapeBOll 6 . EID 06cJIe;J;0-
BaHbl HraHacaHbl Ha TanMhIpe, IOKarl1phI no HIImHeMY Te'IeHIIIO IfIIp,nrIIp,IUI
II ROJIbIlVIbI II 'IYK'III no HIIShHe:\IY Te'IeHlllO HOJIhDlhI. H COmaJIeHlllO, OHa He
npOBop,IIT B03paCTHoro pacrrpe eJIeHIIH i\IaTepnaJIa, 'ITO 3RTpyp,HHeT npHMoe
}
404
r
I
Ta6.1III:L\a 38
CpaBHeHHe HeH:L\eB, TIYKTIeii II aCRlI:\IOCOB no anHhIM r. 11>. )J;e6en:a. MymTIIIHhI
nplISHaR
HeH bI I 'IYR'1H l aCIIHMOChI
In - 52) (n - 190) (n - 191)
POCT 60POJJ;bI (c 25 JIeT), cpeJJ;HIIll: 6aml
I1,BeT BOJIOC, % M 27
I1,BeT rJIa3, cpeJ.\HIIll: 6aJIJI
3mmaHTYc, % HamI'lIIJI
CRJIaJJ;Ra BeRa p, Cpep;HHll: 6am]
C]map;Ka BeRa m, cpe,o;HHll: 6a.JIJI
CR.JIaJJ;Ra BeRa d, Cpep;HI1II 6aJIJI
BblcoTa IIepeHocbH. cpeJJ;HI1ll: 6am]
Done pe'lHbIll: IIPOq)lIJIb CIII1HRlI noca, cpeJJ;HlIll: 6aJIJI
06lI'\Hll: IIPOIfJHJIb cnHHIDI Boca, % BorHYTbIX
IIoJIoJI\eHI1e KOH'lllRa Hoca, cpeJJ;nI1ll: 6aJIJI
rOpII30HTaJIbHbIll: rrpolfJI1.JIb JIl1I'\a, cpeJJ;HHll: 6aJIJI
BblcoTa BepxHeH ry6bI, cpeJJ;HHll: 6aJIJI
BblcTynaBHe BepXHell: ry6l>I, cpeJJ;HIIll: 6aJIJI
(ITO.JIm;I1Ha» BepXHell: ry6bI, cpeJJ;HI1H 6aJIJI
«TOJIII a» BI1mHeH ry6bI, cpeJJ;HI1ll: 6a.iIJI
1,61
8,2
1,42
37,4
1,32
1,63
1,63
1,44
2,00
21,2
1,58
1,31
2,02
1,37
1,84
2,02
1,28
49,7
1,94
58,5
1.75
1,81
1,76
1,44
1,84
27,0
1,75
1,04
2,28
1,22
2,30
2,69
t,52
73,8
1,95
33,9
1,39
1,49
1,45
1,60
2,08
10,6
1,78
1,07
2,40
1,27
2,19
2,60
Ta6JIII:L\a 39
CpaBHeHHe HraHacaH, IOKarlIpOB H TIYKTIeii no aHHIdM H. M. 30JIOTapeBoii. MymTIHHIJI
I Rrana- I IOlIarHpbI I TIYR''111
(n 2) In - 39) In - 34)
POCT 60pOJJ;bI (c 25 JIeT), cpeJJ;BI1II 6aJIJI 1,11 1,05 1,10
POCT 6pIJBeii, cpeJJ;HlIlI 6aJIJI 1,54 1,27 1,56
BeT BOJIOC, % M 27 43,5 44,4 44,8
I1,BeT rJIa3, cpeJJ;HIIH 6aJIJI 1.84 1,75 1,78
mmaHTYC, % naJIII'lHH 43,4 50.1 58,3
CRJIaJJ;Ka BeKa p, cpeJJ;HHii 6aJIJI 1,88 2,48 2,53
CKJIaJJ;Ra BeRa m, cpeJJ;HIIH 6aJIJI 2,72 2,86 2,78
KJIaJJ;Ka BeRa d, cpeJJ;IDIll: 6a.JIJI 2,70 2,86 2,69
BblcO'Ta IIepeHOCbH, cpeJJ;HI1ll: 6aJIJI 1,20 1,09 1.25
IIOrrepeTIHbIll: IIPOq)IIJIb CIIIIHRI1 Boca, Cpep;HI1ll: 6aJIJI 2,11 1,98 2,03
06m;I1ll: IIPOIfJI1JIb CIII1HRI1 Hoca, % BorHYTbIX 30,6 34,1 33,4
IIoJIomeHHe ROBTIHKa Hoca, cpeJJ;HI1ll: 6aJIJI 1,44 1,48 1,36
rOpII30HTaJIbBbIll: rrpoq)HJIb .JIII:L\a, cpeJJ;HIIll: 6aJIJI 1,29 1,11 1,64
BblcTYlIaHlIe CRYJI, cpeJJ;HI1ll: 6aJIJI 2.16 2,32 1,97
BblcoTa BepXIIell: ry6bI, Cpep;HI1ll: 6aJIJI 2,46 2,76 2,65
BblcTyrraHIIe BepXHell: ry6l>I, cpeJJ;HIIll: 6aJIJI 1,28 1,05 1,15
«TOJIlI'\HHa» BepXHell: ry6bI, cpeJJ;HHii 6a.iIJI 1,31 1,59 1,97
«TOJIII(IdHa» mmmelI ryObI, cpeJJ;HIIII 6aJIJI 1,64 2,34 2,41
npllSHa:!I:
II,
3
C
405
lU
---
-:-- - c--
---
1/
.71//
Itr
lf1
.,
i
I
z
/
<:
1
.
-4
J
J
If
.7
P
7
/I
5
"
-
--
/2
/J
JlI
1
,
;
1.5
jff
11
...
"-
"-
....
- IIUltltbll' u#muflu
- - - /lUltltbfe r f/1. /lelieuu
- /luliltble II.M JDPDI/lUfleEuii
Puc. 34. B3aIIMHoe IIOJlOmeHI1e cOIIOCTaBJIHeMbIX rpYlI1I IIO MaTepnaJIaM pa3HbIX aBTopOB
H - HeHn;bI, q - 'lYR'HI, :3 - 3CRIIMOCbI, Hr - HraHacaHbI, 10 - IORarUpbI. HIDRHeROJIbIMCRIIe
-qYRqII (jJnrypIIPYIOT TOJIbRO no npII3HaFaM, Bapllan;IIII ROTOpbIX OTJIIIqaIOTCH 3aMeTHblM oopa30M
OT aHaJIOrWIHbIX BapIIan;IIfi APyrIIx rpynn
1 - pOCT OOpO,lJ,bl (3,1J,eCb II ,lJ,aJIbIUe B CROORax npUHHTaH aMnJIUTY,IJ,a MemrpynnoBbIx ROJIeOaHIIfi
1,00-4,00); 2-l(BeT BOJIOC (0-100%); 3-uBeT rJIa3 (0-2,00); 4-HaJIIIqIIe anIIRaHTyca
(0-100%); 5 - CRJIa,lJ,lia BeRa p (0-3,00); 6 - ClmaARa BeRa m (0-3,00); 7 - CRJIa,lJ,Ra BeRa d
(0-3,00); 8 - BbICOTa nepeHOCbH (1,00-3,00); 9 - nOnepeqHbIfi .UP04>IIJIb cnIIHRII Hoca (1,00-
3,00); 10 - HaJIIIqIIe BOrHYTbIX (jJOPM B OOll\eM npo(jJIIJIe crrIIHRII Hoca (0-80%); 11- nOJIome-
HIIe ROHqIIRa Hoca (1,00-2,50); 12 - ropII30HTaJIbHbIfi npo4>UJIb JIIIn;a (1,00-3,00); 13 - BbICTY-
ilIllme CRYJI (1,00-3,00); 14 - BbICOTa BepxHeti rYObl (1,00-3,00); 15 - BbIcTynaHIIe BepxHefi
ryobI (1,00-2,50); 16 - TOJIll\uHa BepxHeii ryobI (1,00-3,50); 17 - TOJIll\IIHa HIImHefi ryoId
(1,00-3,50)
cpaBHeHIIe II, BO BCHKOM CJIY'Iae, p,eJIaeT ero lVIeHee TO'IHbLU (Ta6JI. 39).
ECJIII YCJIOEHO ;:wnYCTIITb, 'ITO Bce TPH cpaBHIIBaeMbIe rpynnbI 0p,I10EOapaCT-
RbI, TO Or::qYTII:\Ible pa3JIH'fHH BbIHBJIHIOTCH B OTHOCIITeJIbHOII p,OJIe JIH C Bbl-
pameHHblM snHKaHTYCO:\f, B BblcTynaHIIII CKYJI II ropII30HTaJIbHOM npoiPIL'Ie
JIII a, B BblCOTe II BblcTynaHIIII RomHOH 'JaCTII BepXHeJI ry6bl, «TOJIr::qIIHe>}
ry6. Pa3JIII'<II1H B eJIOM MeHbrne, 'IelVI npII cpaBHeHIIII HeH eB II 'JyR'Ien no
MOIIIVI Ha6JIIOp,eHIIHM II Ha6JIIOp,eHIIHM r. <D. AeoeD,a. B npIIH IIne ::JTO JIerKO
06'bHCHIITb OOJIbmen 6JIII30CTblO IICCJIep,OBaHHbIX 11. M. 30JIOTapeBOH rpynn
p,pyr K p,pyry. Ha OCHOBaHIIII II3Y'IeHIIH ep,IIHII'IHbIX 'IepeIlOB HraHacaH H Bbl-
CKa3blBaJICH B nOJIb3Y OTHeceHIIH IIX R OanKaJIbCKOM rpynne nonYJIH IIn,
T. e. K TOll caMOH rpyrrne, K KOTOpOl1 npIIHap,JIemaT II IOKanlpbl 7. OT II'IIIH
JIerKO OO'bHCHHIOTCH HaJIH'IHelVI y HraHacaH CJIep,OB eBponeOIIJ.J:Hon npIllVIeCII.
'{:lTo KacaeTCH I1IImHeKOJIbIMCKIIX 'IYK'Ien, TO OHII npH nOCTOHHHOM KOIITaKTe
C IOKarIIpalVIH TaKllie MOrJIII B06paTb B ce6H 3Ha'IHTeJIbHYlO p,0:r1O C Tpyp,OM
406
«pIIKcnpye",wIl rrCTOpII'IeCIUI IImI ::J'rHorpaiPWIeCKII, HO peaJILHOn BrrYTpIIKOHTII-
HeHTaJIbHOII npIDIeCII.
ITpII BcelVI ::JTOM 'IYK'III II IOKarnpbl. 'IYK'III II lIranacaHbl OTJIII'IaIOTCJI
APyr OT iJ:Pyra rro rrepe'lIICJIeHHbIM npllaIIaKaM BrrOJIUe OT'IeTJIIIBO, er::qe paa
p,eIVIOrrCTpIIpYH, 'I TO apKTII'IeCI l1e II KOHTIIHeHTaJIbHble 1VI0Hro.;rOIIp,bl coxpa-
IIHIOT CB010 cne IIq)IIKY .a:ame npII p,JIIITe.'IbHOIVI COBlVIeCTHOM npO,KIIBaHIIII II
ueccnopHOII npOHII aeIVIOCTII 06paaye"'lOro pa3JIII'IHOII ::JTHII'IeCKon npIIHaA-
JIemHOCTbIO II pa3HbIM Jl3bIKmI reHeTIf'IeCKoro 6apbepa.
H3 npep,mecTByror::qIIX cpaBHeHIIll BbIIIaJIII JIonapu. r. <D. JJ:e6eD, II
H. M. 30JIOTapeBa He 6bIJIII Y JIorrapen, H pa60TaJI cpep,II JIOrrapell HOJIbCKorO
nOJIyocTpoBa, HO He 3aIlIIlVIaJICH aHTporrOMeTpIIen, nOIVIHH 0 TOM. 'ITO anaJIO-
rII'IHYIO pa60TY Yllie npoBemI JJ:. A. 30JIOTapeB 8 II M. B. BUTOB, MaTepIIaJI
ROToporo, K CO lli a.. emllO , nOKa He oIly6JIIIKOBaH. HO 6bIJI iJ:OcTyrreH MHe B
PYKonIICII. Heop,HOKpaTiIO IICCJIep,OBaJIlICb I1 cKaHp,IIHaBcKIIe JIOnapII 9. 06r::qe-
1I3BeCTHoe II HaY'IHO rrOp,KpenJIeHHOe cBoe06pa3IIe IIX 1VI0piPOJIOrIl'IecKoro TIIna
TaKOBO, 'ITO HII 0 KaKOM CXO;:J;CTBe C HapOiJ3MII 3anap,nocII6IIpC1wn TYH.a:pbl
II TelVI 60JIee BOCTO'IIIOll Cy6aplnIIKIf He npIIxop,IITCH rOBopIITb.
rpaiPII'IeCKOe lI306pameHIIe paaJIII'IIIn Hapop,OB apKTII'IeCKon 30HbI npeA-
CTaBJIenO Ha pIlC. 34. Pa3JIII'IIIH 1VI8TI;:iJY HeH alVIlI 1I HraHacaHa"'III, C op,Hon
CTOpOHbI, 'IyK'IaIVIIl - C .a;pyroII, BbIpallieHbl B npo eHTax MemrpYIlnoBoiii
3,MnJIIITyp,bl no 3elVIHOlVIY mapy JJ:JIH Kamp,oro npII3HaKa. Ha pIICYHKe BII.a:I1bI
3Ha'IIITeJIbHOCTb paaJIlI'UIII II OTHOCIITeJIbHOe YMeHbmeHIIe IIX B CJIY'Iae cpaB-
ReHIIH nraHacaH II HIImHeKOJIbIIVICKIlX 'Iywlen.
KP AHIiJo.TIOr:n:qECIHI:A: MATEPIIAJI
HpaHIIOJIorIIH apKTII'IeCKIIX rpyml, HeCMOTpH Ha Bce Tpyp,nOCTII p,06bIBaHIIH
RpaHIIOJIOnl'IeCKOrO Ma TepIIaJIa B yCJIOBIIHX TYHP,PbI, II3Y'IeHa p,OBOJIbHO Xopo-
mo. .n;JIH eJIen ::JTOll pa60TbI HeT ClVIbICJIa, op,HaKO, paCCMaTpIIBaTb ee CKOJIb-
RO-HII6yp,b no;:t:p06HO, p,OCTaTO'IHO orpaHII'IIITbCH cpaBHeHIIel\I p,aJIeKIIX I1ony-
JIHIJ;lIn, CKameM .'Ionapen II HapO;J;OB qYKOTCKoro nOJIYOCTpOBa. JJ:.:rfl I10JIHOTbI
MomHO BKJIlO'IUTb B ::JTO cpaBlIeHIIe npOlVIemYTO'IHYIO no lVIeCTOHaxomp,eHIIIO
I'pynny - HeHD,eB.
06'bep,IIHeHHaH JIOnapCKaH cepIIH nOJIy'reHa IIpU HeB3BemenHOM CYMMIIPO-
BaHIIII p,aHHbIX no JIOnapHM HopBenm 10, <DIIHJIHHp,IIII 11 II . CCCP 12
(Ta6JI. 40). B cKooKax YKa3aHO CYMMapHoe ROJlWIeCTBO 1I3l\IepeHHbIX 'Iepe-
nOB. CepIIH HeHeD,KIIX 'IepenOB IIOCIIT C60PHbIR XapaKTep II rrpOIIcxop,IIT co
Bcell TeppIITopIIII paCCeJIeHIIH HeHUeB. HaKoHeD" no HaCeJIeHIIIO qYKOTCKorO
DOJIYOCTpOBa CYMIVIIIpOBaHbl no JIOKaJIbHbDI rpynIlalVI II 6e3 Y'IeTa 'IIICJIeH-
HOCTII 'Iepena 'IYK'IeII II ::JCKHI\IOCOB, onIIcaHHbIe r. <D. .n;e6e oM 13. HCKJIIO-
'IeHIIe COCTaBJIHeT HaYKaHCKaH rpyurra, BKJlIO'IeHHafl B nOp,C'IeT Ha OCIIOBe
AOnOJIHeHHblX n;aHHbIX a. B rpaiPe {('IIICJIO na6JIIOp,eHIIll», TaK ,Ke KaK II B
CJIY'Iae C JIOnapHI\III, YKa3aHO CYMMapHoe 'IIICJIO 'IepenOB no BcelVI JIOKaJIb-
HbllVI rpynrraM.
TaK KaK KpaHlIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe p,alIHbIe B OTJIII'IIIe OT CO"'IaTOJIOrII'IeCKIIX
He Bbl3bIBalOT COI\IlIeHIIii B CBoell nOJIHoll cpaBHIIIVIOcTII, K HIIIVl rrpIIJIOmIIMbI
JIlO6bIe npIIeMbl cYMlVIapHoro cpaBHeHIIH no MHorIIM rrpII3HaKal\I. pa3pa60TaH-
Hblle B 6IIOMeTpII'IeCKOII CTaTIICTIIKe. ITpIIMeHeHIIe pa3HbIx npIIeMoB p,aeT p,o-
BOJIbHO cTporo KOppeJIIIpOBaHHbIe peay:rbTaTbI, nO::JToMY BOCnOJIb3yeMcH Op,HIIM
II3 npocTellmIIx IIpIleIVIOB, BbIpaa.;aH paaHIID,y no Kamp,oMY npII3IIaI,y 'Iepea
cTaHp,apTHoe KBan;paTII'lHoe YKJIOHeHIIe, 3aTeM CY1IMIIPYH pa3HIID,bI II p,eJIH IIX
Ha KOJIII'IeCTBO npII3HaKoB. IhoroBoe 'IIIC:rO, c.TJ:enOBaTeJIbHO, cpep,HHH paaHII-
n;a Memp,y conOCTaBJIHeMblMII rpYlInaMII, BblpameHHaH B eiJ:IIHII aX cTaHp,apT-
407
j
Ta6JIH:L\a 40
,CpaBHemIe TIeperrOB JIonapeii, HeHn;eB, TIYKTIeii H 9CKJlMOCOB. MymcKHe 'mpelIa
IIpII3HaR
I JIonaPH I HeHI1b1 I qYRqll II
(n - 313) (n - 38) 3CRHMOCbI
(n - 165)
1
i
1. IIPOJ];OJIbRbIll: J];naMeTp 178,6 179,2 183.2
8. IIOrrepe'lHbIll: J];llaMeTp 146,8 146,6 141,9
8: 1. qepenHOll: YRa3aTeJIb 82,0 81,9 77,5
17. BbICOTHbIll: J];I1aMeTp OT 6a3HoHa 129,8 129,0 135,8
5. )J;JIIffia OCHOBamm TIepelIa 100,1 98,2 103,1
9. HanMeRbIIIaH IIII1pHIIa JI6a 98,7 !J4,2 95,9
40. )J;JIHHa OCHOBaHIIH JII1:L\a 97,1 99,7 103,3
40: 5. YKa3aTeJIb BblcTyrraHI1H JIH:L\a 97,0 100,8 100,4
45. CRYJIOBaH IIInpHIIa 136,1 139,1 139,9
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa JII1:L\a 67,2 73,9 78,4
48: 45. BepxHHH JIH:L\eBOll: YRa3aTeJIb 49,2 53,1 56,0
48: 17. BepTIIRaJIbHbIII RpaHHolfJa:L\I1aJIbBbIII YRa3aTeJIb 52,0 57,4 57,8
51. IlII1pI1Ha Op6HTbI OT mf (JIeB.) 42,8 42,7 43,9
52. BblcoTa Op6HTbI (JIeB.) 33,3 34,4 36,4
52 : 51. Op6I1THl>Ill: YKa3aTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 77,8 80,5 83,1
54. IIInpHHa Boca 24,9 25,0 24,4
55. BblcoTa Hoca 50.7 53.0 55,6
54: 55. HOCOBOll YKa3aTeJIb 49,3 47,2 44,2
32. YroJi JI6a 82,9 81,8 78,8
72. YroJI 06m;ero IIPOqJHJIH JIH:L\a 85,8 86,1 83,6
75(1). YroJi HOCOBbIX ROCTell: K JIHHHH IIPOIfJHJIH 29,7 23,3 22,9
77. Ha3mmJIHpHbIll: yrOJI 141,3 146,4 146,9
Lzm'. 3HrOMaRCHJlJIHPHbIll: yrOJI 128,1 135,8 136,9
i
-:}
-
.
Horo BHYTpIIrpyrrrroBoro KBap,paTII'IHoro yRJIOHeHIIH II rrpIIBe/.l,eHHaH R Op,HOMY
rrpII3HaKY. ITo p,aHHbIM MHDrIIX IICCJIep,OBaHIIn, cYMMapnaH KOppeJIH IIH Mem-
P,Y rrpII3HaKa 1II He rrpeBblmaH 0,2-0,3, cp,BIIraeT IITorOBbIe pe3YJIbTaTbl B
Op,HOIVI HarrpaBJIeHIIII, elO MomHO rrpeHe6pe'Ib. ITpIIelVI YJJIe 6bIJI npliMeHeH B
pa60Te 0 KpaHlIOJIorIIII CaJITOBCKOro IVIOrIIJIbHIIKa, B KOTOpOM rrpIIBep,eHbI
rrepe'mHb BI-:.'IIO'IeHHbIX B corrOCTaB:reHIIe rrpII3HaKOB II Be.'III'IIIHbI rrpIIHHTblX
3a cTaH,l];apTHbIe RBap,paTII'IHbIX YHJIOHeHIIn 15. ITepe'IeHb npII3rraKOB p,onOJI-
HeH p,BYIVIH - Ha30lVIaJIHpHblM II 3IIrOMaKCIIJIJIHpHblM yrJIaMU. 3a CTaHp,apTHbIe
BeJIII'IIIHbI KBap,paTII'IHbIX YKJIOHeHlIn ::JTIIX yrJIOB rrpIIHHTbI COOTBeTCTBYIOI::qne
BeJIII'IIIHbl B CepIlII 'IeperrOB PYCCKnx eHTpaJIbHblX panOHOB 16.
Bbl'IIICJIeHHble pa3HII bl KaK IIO OTp,eJIbHbIM rrpII3HaKaM, TaK II rro IIX
ROMIIJIeKCY rrpIIBeAeHbl B Ta6JI. 41. OHII p,OCTaTO'IHO KpacHope'IIIBbI caMII
no ce6e: ,l];ame Mem;:J;Y 6JIIIlliaMmliMII cepIIHMII Cpep,HJlH pa3HII a rrpeBblIIlaeT
p,Be TpeTII KBap,paTII'IHoro YKJIOHeHIIH, YBeJIII'IIIBaHCb rrO'ITII BABoe rrpII cpaB-
HeHIIII 'IYR'Iei'i II ::JCKIIIVIOCOB C JIOrrapHIVIU. Ho oc06eHHO Bblpa3IITeJIbHblMII
rrOJIY'IeHHble pa3JIII'IIIH p,eJIaIOTCJI rrpII OD,eHKe IIX B rpYIIrrOBO I lVIacmTa6e,
T. e. rrpII cpaBHeHIIII IIX C aHaJIOrII'IHbIMII pa3JIII'IIIHMII Memp,y p,pyrIIMII
rpyrrIIaMII, IIOJIY'IeHHblMII C rrplllVIeHeHIIeM Toro me rrplieMa. MelliiJ:Y 6JIII3KII-
MII rronYJIHD,IIHIVIII (capMaTbl ¥KpaIIHbl II IToBOJImbH, HaCeJIeHIIe P,BYX rrlJCJIe-
,l];OBaTeJIbHbIX cTa;:J;IIM TarapCROJI RYJIbTYPbl) Cpep,HlIe pa3HII bl He npeBbl-
malOT 0,2-0.3 CTaHp,apTHoro YKJIOHeHIIH, II p,ame MeiKP,Y rrpep,CTaBIITeJIHMII
3aBep,OMO pa3HblX OOJIbmIIX pac - JIIOp,bMII, OCTaBIIBmIIMII CaJITOBCKIIn MO-
408
lizzuj1 Z
1---1 T: Z [J fill
1/
./lD17UflU
l'D17mDIJCJ:UU
IWDZU17bl4l'l;(
JlD17flfl U
J ;}.':7ffZ IJ 17 /JI
n
J-
./J
l'fljl.1fU171bJ
!/KjlIlUf/b/
/li'H If/JI
'--- tfl.!M /Zm/JI
. ..., f7Pif,'7I7J/t:/JJ!
I lffjPllf /I
JCKUIf/!7Ctl
I I/CHI4/J1
iff/Killi if
I J2'KuA-/!7cb/
PIlC. 35. TaKCOHmIH'IeCROe paCCTOHHHe MeiR):\Y pa3-
HbIMI1 IIOnYJIH:L\HHMI1 no CYMMe RpaHI10.rrorIl'leCRIlX
npI13HaKOB
II
- mKCDf/!7A-/lf!ll'CKUl' jl11CC171U/lflU/l
- - - - ICUZj1Uf/1UIIl'CK!7l' flllCC171U/lflU£
PIlC. 36. MacIIITaoHoe cpaBHeHI1e reorpalfJn'leCRI1X paccToHHnii Me1KP;Y conOCTaBJIHe-
MbIMH rpYlInaMH 11 TaRCOHmlH'IeCRHX paccToHHHlI MemP;Y HIIMH
YCJIOBHbIe 0603Ha'IemHI Te me, 'ITO H Ha pHC. 34; JI - JIOrrapH
rIIJIbHIIK Ha Y KpmUIe, II MOHrOJlaMII - OHa lVIeHbme, 'leM Memp'Y 'IYK'IaMH
'II ::JCKIIIVIOcaMII II JIOIIapfll\nr (pIlC. 35).
CJIep,yeT CIIeD,lIaJIbHO OTMeTIITb xopomee COBIIap,erUIe B ;::J:aHHO:l-I cJiY'Iae
TaKCOHOl\nr'IeCKllX paccToHHIIII C reorpaeJ)lIQeCKHIVI IIOJIOlKeHIIe:l-I cpaBHIIBae-
MblX rpYIIIl. 8CKIIlVIOCbl II 'IYK'III IlO'ITII Bp,Boe p,aJIbme OTCTOHT OT JIOIlapen
no cyMMe IlpII3HaKOB, 'leM OT HeH eB, IlOCJIep,HIIe 3aHIIMaIOT CTporo IIpOlVIe-
'mYTO'IHoe IlOJIOffieHIIe (pIIC. 36). COBIlap,eHHe TaKOBO, KaK ec:m 6bl TaKCO-
HOIVIII'IeCKaH cIITya IIH eJIrrKOIVI llJIII IlO'ITlI eJIIIKOIVI OIlpeiJ:e.:rHJIaCb IlpO-
.cTpaHcTBelIHol1 p,IliPiPepeHD,IIa lIeli. 8TO, KOHe'IHO, He TaR. ITpep,meCTBYIOr::qIIe
IICCJIep,OBaHIIH CBIIp,eTeJILCTBYIOT, 'I TO aIITpOIlOJIOrII'IeCKIIe KOMIIJIeKCbl BO Bcex
'Tpex CJIY'laHX IIlVIelOT 3aBep,01VIO pa3I10e npOlICXOIKp,eHIIe, HO TaKoe COBIlap,e-
Hue IIHTepeCHO B I\IeTOp,II'IeCKOIVI OTHomeHIIII II IlO::JTOMY 3aCJIymuBaeT BHII-
MaHIIH.
ITOp,BOp,H UTor KpaHUOJIorII'IeCKIIM cpaBHeHIIHIVI, HYIKHO Ilop,qepKHYTb IIX
xopornee COBIlap,eHIIe C BbIBOp,OIVI, IlOJIY'IeHHbIIVI I1a COMaTOJIOrII'IeCKOIVI lVIaTe-
puaJIe: ::JTHll'IeCKue rpYIIIlbl, npOlliIIBalOr::qIIe B 3aIlap,Hon II BOCTO'IHoii Cy6-
.apKTIIKe, pe3KO MopiPOJIOrII'IeCKll pa3JIII'IaIOTCH lVIelKP,Y c060n.
H30CEPO.TIOnm
R HaCTOHr::qeIVIY BpelVIeIlll HaKOIllIJIOCb p,OBOJIbHO 60JIbmOe 'IIICJIO Ha6JIIOp,eHIIn
'Hap, IlOlIYJIHD,llOHIIbIIVI paCIlpep,eJIeHlleM rpYIIIIOBbIX iPaKTopoB KpOBII Y apKTII-
'JeCIUIX HapOJ:OB. HO orpaHll'IeHHblx B OCHOBHOM CIICTelVIalVIII ABO, M
:II pe3YC. He paCCMaTpllBaH Bce rpYIIIlbI, IIpOBep,elVI, KaK II B Ilpep,blP,yr::qIIX
-eJIY'IaHX, COIlOCTaBJIeHlle JIOIlapen, HeHD,eB II Hapop,OB lIYKoTcKoro IIOJIYOCT-
pOBa. JJ:aHHbIe IlO JIOIlapHIVI 'IaCTU'lHO CYl\Il\IIlpOBaHbI B pa60Te A. B. Xa3aHO-
BOIl II H. IT. llIaMJIHH, rp,e npllBep,eHbl TaKIKe pe3YJIbTaTbl c06CTBeHIIblX
lICCJIe.a:OBaHIIn KOJIbCKllX JIOnapelI l7 , IIHiPopMaWIH 0 HeH ax B3HTa II3 pa6o-
TbI M. M. 30JIOTapeBoII 18 , IIHiPoplVIa IIH 0 'IYK'IaX II ::JCKIlIVIOcax - II3 pa60TbI
M. r. JIeBIIHa 19. HeH bl Ilpep,CTaBJIeHbJ rpYIlIlon, mIIByr::qeii B HII30BbHX
EHIlceH, 'IYK'III - KaK IlpII6peIKHbIMII, TaK II BHYTpIIlVIaTepIIKOBblMll IlOnyJIH-
IIHMII. M. r. JIeBllH He IICCJIep,OBaJl CIICTelVIY pe3YC, II B Ta6JI. 42 iPIIryplI-
PYIDT Hamil Heorry6JIIIKOBaHHble MaTepIIaJIbl. .
409
Ta6mII a 41
Cpe;n:HHe pasHB:L\bI Memp;y CepBJIlIIB 'leperrOB JIorrapeii, oe0:L\eB, 'lYRTIeii B 3CRBMOCO'G.
MymcRHe TIeperra
IIpn3HaR
I JIonapH _ I :IonapH - I HeH I1 b1 -
HeHI1bI 'lYE'lH H 'lYE'ln H
aCRIDlOCbI aCRHMOCbI
1. IIpop;oJIbHDIM p;IIaMeTp 0,10 0,80 0,70
8. IIolIepe'IHDIll p;IIaMeTp 0,13 1,03 0,99
8: 1. qepenHolI YRa3aTeJIb 0,04 1,68 1,64
17. BbICOTHbllI p;lIaMeTp OT oa3IIoHa 0,16 1,19 1.35
5. )J;JII1Ha OCIIOBaHI1H 'lepena 0,48 0,76 1,23
9. HaI1MenbIIIaH IIIlIpnHa JIoa 1,11 0,69 0,42
40. )J;JIIIHa OCHOBaHIIH JIH:L\a 0,54 1,28 0,74
40: 5. YKa3aTe.:Ib BbICTYlIaHHH JII1:L\a 1.13 1.01 0,12
45. CKY.:IOBaH IIIlIpIIHa 0,66 0,83 0,18
48. BepxHHH BblCOTa JIlI:L\a 0,61 2,70 1,08
48 : 45. BepXHI1II JIII:L\eBOll: YRa3aTeJIb 1,25 2,18 0,93
48 : 17. BepTIIRaJIbHDIll: RpaHIIOwa:L\I1aJIbHbIlI YRa3aTeJIb 1,76 1.89 0,13
51. IlIlIpI1Ha Op6HTbI OT mf (JIeB.) 0,05 0,60 0,65
52. BblcoTa Op6I1Tl>I (JIeB.) 0,58 1,65 1,06
52: 51. OPOI1TIlbIM YRa3aTeJIb OT mf (JIeB.) 0,58 1,14 0,56
54. IlIIIpHHa 1I0ca 0,06 0,28 0,34
55. BbICOTa Hoca 0,79 1,68 0,89
54 : 55. HOCOBOll: YRa3aTeJIb 0,55 1,34 0,79
32. YroJI JI6a 0,28 1,06 0,78
72. YrOJI 06m;ero npolfJHJIH JlH:L\a 0,09 0,68 0,77
75 (1). Y rOJI HOCOBbIX RocTeM R JII1HHI1 npOWHJIH 1,16 1,24 0,07
77. Ha30l'.IaJIHpHbIll: yrOJI 1,21 1.33 0,12
Lzm'. 3IIrOMaECI1JIJIHpHblii yrOJI 1,46 1,66 0,21
Cpep;HHH pa3HII:L\a 0,72 1.25 I 0,68
'"
P,,;
-'ij
,
j
:1
.
"i
1
i'
I'pynna
o
A
BlAB I !VI I
N
!VIN
Rh+
..
....
j
-1
j
t
1
Ta6;IIII a 42
rpyrrrrbI RpOBH JIorrapen, HeHQeB, TIYRTIeii II 3CRBMOCOB. WeHoTllIIbI
JIonapH, n 24 73 20 6 60 8 56 122
% 19.5 59,3 16,3 4,9 48,4 6,4 45,2 98,4
HeH:L\DI, n 96 69 54 16 14 109 112 192
% 40,8 29,4 23,0 6,8 6,0 46,4 47,6 100.0
qYRTIII, n 121 94 32 9 68 56 132 310
% 47,3 36,7 12,5 3,5 26,6 21,8 51,6 100,0
8CRI1MOCbI, n 82 60 55 8 69 38 97 20
% 40,0 29,3 26,8 3.9 33,8 18,6 47,6 100,0
reHHble 'IaCTOTbl rrpep,CTaBJIeHbI
OHII BbI'IIICJIeHbl aBTopoM, TaK KaK
Bep,eHbl cooTBeTcTBYIOr::qIIe paC'IeTbI.
CTeMbl ABO KoppeKTIIpoBaHbl C
Y. XeJI1VI60JIp,01VI II O. ITpoKorroM 20,
B Ta6JI. 43. ):(JIH 'IYK'Ieii II SCRIIMOCOB
B rry6JIIIKa IIII M. r. JIeBIIHa I1e nplI-
PaC'IeTb] 11. M. 30JIOTapeBOn p,JIH . CII-
rrOIVIOr::qblO rrorrpaBOR, npep,JIOmeHHblX
p,JIH CIICTelVIbI MN B ee rry6JIIIKaIJ;IIH
410
l
TaOJIH:L\a 43
reHHhIe TIaCTOThI rpYllrr KpOBH CI1CTellI ABO, MN If pesyc y JIorrapeii, HeHl eB, qyKTIeii
H aCRlIl\IOCOB
rpynna
r
p
q
m
n
d
JIollapH 0.474 0.411 0,114 0,709 0,290 0,126
HeH:L\bI 0,637 0,201 0,162 0,282 0,718 0,000
tIYR'II1 0,690 0,227 0.083 0,525 0,476 0,000
:1CRHMOCbI 0,648 0,184 0,168 0,575 0,425 0,000
Bo06r::qe nplIBe eHbl omlI60'IHble D,lIiPPbI. ITplI o eHKe I\O:reoaHlIn reHHbIX
TfaCTOT p,allie Ha rJIa3 BIIp,HO, 'ITO no CIICTeMe ABO JIOnapII 3Ha'IIITeJIbHO OT-
JIII'IalOTCH OT p,pyrIIx rpynn, a no CIICTelVIe MN cBoe06pa3Hoe COOTHomeHIIe
TeHHbIX 'IaCTOT IIlVIelOT I1e TOJIbKO JIOnaplI, no II HeIID,bI.
.[t;JIH OI:(eHRII KOJIII'IeCTBeHHoII lVIepbl SToro cBoeOOpa3IIH npep,JIOmeHO He-
{;KOJIbKO lVIeTop,OB, 113 KOTOpblX MbI BOCIIo.ib3ye:\ICH npOCTelIlIIlIlVI - o eHKon
C nOMor::qblO «XII-KBap,paT». Pa3pa60TaBmIIIT IlplIlVIeIleHlIe SToro lVIeTop,a 'K
'O eHRe TaKCOHOllIII'IeCIwrO paCCTOHHIIH no reHHblM 'IaCTOT8M JI. CaHrBII IIC-
nOJIb30BaJI ero B RBaJJ;pIIpOBaHHOJI iPoplVIe 21. H nplIcoep,IIHHIOCb K co06pame-
HIIHM P. KHycClIiaI-IHa 0 TOM, 'ITO TaKCOHOIVIII'IeCKlIe paCCTOHHIIH D,eJIeco06-
pa3Hee BblpamaTb B JIIIHeMUblX BeJlII'IIIHax 22, II rrOSTOMY KOHe'IHble pe3YJIb-
TaTbI npep,CTaB:reHbI He B BIIp,e cy1\1MapHbIX BeJIII'IIIH «, XII-KBap,paT)} a B BIIp,e
RBap,paTIIbIX RopHen II3 HIIX. EOJIee CJIOlliHble cnoc06bI CYMlVIapHoro cpaBHe-
HIIH rpynn no. .a:IICKpeTHbIM npII3HaKaM, R 'IIICJIY KOTOpblX OTHOCHTCH II reH-
HbIe 'IaCTOTbl, 06cymp,aIOTcH T. HYP'lIIHCRIIM, nOKa3aBmIIM, 'ITO OHII 06Ha-
pymIIBalOT BblCOKYIO KOppeJIH 1I1O C «XII-KBaApaT», 'IeM II onpaBAaHO nOJI-
EOCTblO ero npIIMeHeHIIe 23. .
IhoroBble pa3HII bl Memp,y COnOCTaBJIHelVIbIlVIII rpymralVIII CJIeiJ:YIOr::qIIe:
JIolIapll - HeH:L\bI 0,318 HeH:L\bI - 'lYK'lH 0,138
JIolIapH - 'IYli.'l1l 0,247 HeHI(bI - aCRIIMOCbI 0,158
JIorrapn - aCRIIMOCbI 0,253 qYRTIn - aCRIIMOCbI 0,035
Memp,y "IyK'IaMII II SCKIIlIIOcaMII paccToHHIIe, KaK II CJIep,OBaJIO omlIp,aTb,
MIIIIIIMaJIbHOe, Ha 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOM paccToHHIIII OT HIIX Haxop,HTcH HeH bI,
II COBceM OC06HHIWM CTOHT JlOnapII, o)J:IIHaKoBo p,aJIeKIIe II OT HeHI:(eB, II OT
Hapop,oB qYKoTCRoro nOJIyocTpoBa (ClVI. pIIC. 37). ITpaBp,a, nplIMeHennbIM
nplIelVI He p,aeT a6COJIlOTHOM Mepbl TaKCOHOMII'IeCKOrO paCCTOHHIIH IIJIII, Bep-
Hee CKa3aTb, B03MOJI{HOCTII o eHIITb ero, He IIlVIeH KaKorO-TO MellirpynlloBoro
MaCIIITa6a, HO C STIIIVI IIPIIXOJJ;IITCH MIIpIITbCH. TaK KaK STO' o6rn:ee CBonCTBO
:Bcex MeTop,OB CYMlIIapHOii OI:(eHKII.
):(EPMATOCKOIlHH
HaKOnJIeHHble R HaCTOHI::qeMY BpeMeHII 06mIIpHble CBeiJ:eHlIH 0 BaplIaI:(IDIX
JIap,OHHOro If naJIbD,eBoro peJIbeiPa B pa3HbIX nonYJIH IIHX 3eMHDrO mapa CBIl-
eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 3Ha'lIITeJIbHbIX pa3:III'IIIHX HaCeJIeHIIH p,alI{e OJIII3KIIX pano-
HOB 110 STon CIICTelVIe 2 . He paCIIOJIaraH p,aHIIbIlVIli no JIOllapHM, npIIXO;J;IITCH
OrpaHlI'IlIBaTbCH cpaBlleHlIeM JJ;epMaTOCKOnII'IeCKOrO KOIVIIIJIeKCa HeH eB
11 'IYK'Ien. TaRoe cpaBHeHlIe ocyr::qeCTBJIeHO T. .[t;. rJIap,KOBOn II r. JI. XIITb
B cop,epmaTeJIbHOII pa60Te, nocBHrn:eHHon p,eplVIaTOCKOllIIII HeCKOJIbKIIX Hapo-
OB CII6IIpII - H€HD,eB, SH eB, xaHTbI, IVIaHCII, HKYTOB II 'IYK'Ieii: 25. HeH bI
411
"1
T
npep,CTaBJIeHbl '<IeTblpbMH TeppIITOplIaJIbHbllVIli rpynnalVIlI - eBpOnenCKOn, ce-
BepOHlVIaJIbCKOM, IOJRHOHI\IaJIbCKOM II npIIeHIICenCKOn. )..t;JIH O eHKII COBoKyn-
HOCTII pa3JIII'Ilill MelKAY HeHeD,KIIIVIIf rpynnaMII n 'IYK'IalVfn OTCbIJIalO R p,BYM
rpaiPIIKaM, 3aKJIIO'IaIOr::qIIIVI CTaTblO T. )..t;. r:rap,KOBOn II r. .-:1. XIITb, lIa KOTO-
pblX npep,CTaBJIeHbI CYMMapHble pa3HnU;bl BCeX IICCJIep,OBaHHbIX Bbl60pOK
C HKYTCKOn. qYK'III pe3RO npOTIIBOCTOHT HeHD,aM npn CpaBHeHIIII Ha6JIIOp,e-
HIII-i: KaK no meJICKIIM, TaK II no MymcKIIM rpynnalVI. AHa.:rorII'IHYIO paaHII y
06HapYIKIIBaeT C '1YK'IaMII p,pyraH :3THII'IeCKaH rpynna, npOffiIIBaIOr::qaH B
TYHP,pe, - SH bI.
-
3THOrEHETHQECKHE BbIBO)J;bI
HaROBO ap,eKBaTHoe IICTOJIKOBaHIIe npIIBep,eHHbIX iPaRTOB? JICHO, 'ITO OHII
CBIIp,eTeJIbCTByIOT 0 pa3HOlVI rrpOIlCXOlli,'J,eHIIII Bcex paCCIVIOTpeHHbIX Hapop,OB,
o rJIy60KIIX reHeTII'IeCKIIX pa3JIII'IIIHX, p,IIiPiPepeHD,IIpYIOr::qIIX lIaCeJIeHlIe 3a-
nap,HblX II BOCTO'IHbIX panOHOB eBpa3IInCKOll CyoapKTIIKII. CalVI no ceoe STOT
BbIBO.a; HBJIHeTCH TpnBIIaJIbHbIM, TaR RaK HII y Koro He 6bIJIO COIVIHeHIIH
B CBoeoopa3IIII :3THOreHe3a JIonapen, C op,Hon CTOpOHbl, :3CKliIVIOCOB II 'lYK-i
'Jen - C p,pyron. Op,HaRo p,JIH Hamen TelV1bI OH BaR,eH, TaK KaK p,aeT B03Mom-
HOCTb o eHIITb 6mI30CTb K p,eIICTBIITe:rbHocTII IICTOPIIKO-KY,-TIbTYPHbIX rIIIIO-
Te3, TpaKTYIOr::qIIX CXOp,CTBO RYJIbTYPHblX 3.;rexIeHTOB npKYlV1nOJIHpHbIX Hapo-
p,OB. B CBeTe npIIBe.a;eHHblX aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIX p,aHHbIX STa 6mI30CTb
Haxop,IIT ceoe 06'bHCHeHIIe KaK ROHBepreHTHoe pa3BIITlie B YC:rOBIIHX ap,anTa-
nII K apKTII'IeCKOn TYHp,pe, a He KaK peay.:rbTaT 06 HOCTII npOIICXOIKp,erUIH.
03Ha'IaeT JIII STO, 'ITO aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIe Ha6JIIOp,eHIIH n03BOJIHlOT OT-
BeprHYTb He TOJIbKO rrpH.I\'IOe reHeTII'IeCKOe POp,CTBO lVIelKp,y HaCeJIeHIIeM OT-
AeJIbHblX panOHOB TYHP,PbI, 110 II rIInOTe3Y oo ero cyoCTpaTa, no-pa3HOMY
npOHBJIHIOr::qero ceoH Ha 3anap,e n Ha BOCTOKe? B npIIH I1ne - p,a, 03Ha'IaeT,
TaK RaK 3aBep,OMO II3BeCTHO, 'ITO npep,CTaBIITeJIII TaK Ha3bIBaelVIoro apKTII'Ie-
CKorO KOMnJIeKCa - :3CKliIVIOCbl II 'IYK'III ciPopMIIpOBaJIliCb rp,e-TO K lOry OT
TeppliTopIIII CBoero TerrepemHero pacce:reHIIH, npep,CTaBIITeJIli TaK Ha3bIBae-
Moro JIarrOHOIIp,Horo KOlVInJIeKCa - JIonapn - rp,e-TO K BOCTOKY OT Hero,
110 Memp,y paMOHalVIII IICxop,Hon npapop,IIHbI Tex II p,pyrIIx rrpOJIerJIII TblCH'IU
KUJIOMeTpOB pa3Hopop,HOII B JIaHp,maiPTIIoM OTHomeHIIII TeppliTopliU. qYK'Ili
II SCKIIIVIOCbl - TIIrrII'IHble HOCIITeJIli MOHrOJIOIIp,HOII KOIVI6IIHa IIU IIpII3HaKOB.
JIorrapn CKopee eBponeOII.a;bl C HeOOJIbmOn MOHrOJIOIlp,HOM rrplixIeCLIO. IToCJIep,-
HHH, KCTaTII CKa3aTb, p,ame eCJIli OCTaBRTbCH B palVIKax MopiPOJIOnnr, rp,e
OHa npOHBJIHeTCH 'IeT'Ie Bcero,- npep,MeT p,IICKYCCIIII. ITo COOTHomeHIIIO
rpynnoBblX iPaKTopoB KpOBII JIonapn C6JIIIJRalOTCH C p,pynunr eBponenCKIIlVIli
Hapop,aIVIU, nO'IeMY, CKameM, TOT me H. RYIl C'IIITaJI [IX Hep,IIiPiPepen IIpo-
BaHHOM nonYJIH IIen, a Y. Eonp, OTHOCIIJI K eBponeoIIp,HoII pace 26. BIle 3a-
BIICIIMOCTII OT pemeHIIH :3TOrO cnopHoro Bonpoca OTMeTliM OCHOBHoe: JIOrrapli
Haxop,HTCH C 'IYK'IaIVIU II :3CKliMOCaIVIU Ha npOTIIBOnOJIOmHbIX KOH ax eBpa3IIn-
CKOM aHTpOIlOJIOrII'IecKon II1KaJIbI.
MomeT 6blTb, He60JIbmylO MOHrOJIOIIP,HYIO npliMeCb B COCTaBe- JIorrapeii
npII BceM ee HeOT'IeTJIliBOCTII CJIeAyeT TpaKTOBaTb KaK Hac.:re).UIe p,peBHen-
IIIero cy6cTpaTa? TaK OHO, nO-BIIp,nIVIOMY, II eCTb, ocooeHIIO eCJIII Y'IeCTb
caMop,IIIICKIIM cyocTpaT, BbIHBJIHeMbIn B npOTocaalVICKOIVI H3bIKe 27. Ho STOT
CYOCTpaT He YBo.a;nT Hac p,aJIbme YpaJIa II He rrepeKIIp,bIBaeT xIOCT OT JIOIIapeM
K HaCeJIeHlIIO BOCTO'IHOII Cy6apKTIIKII.
OCTaeTCH, Op,IlaKO, rpynrra iPaKToB, RaK 6yp,TO rrpOTIIBOpe'lar::qIlX II3JIOIKeH-
HbiM BbIBop,aM II3 aHTpOnOJIorII'IecKliX Ha6JIIOp,eHIIn. Pe'lb np,eT 0 CaMO,1lIIM-
CKO-IOKarIIpCKlix H3bIKOBbIX CBH3HX 28 II 0 CneD,IIiPII'IeCKOIVI Cxop, TBe' OTp,eJIh-
1
I
1
.
.
j
412
[.
u 29
IIblX ::JJIeMeHTOB KYJIbTypbI, HarrpIIMep nOKpOH Op,emp,bl Y HeHD,eB n qYKqeu ..
ITpII pe3KIIX MOPiPOiPII3IIOJIOrnqeCKIIX pa3J1II'HIHX. paCCIVIOTpeHHbIX Bblme,
II IIX 6eccrropHO HaCJIep,CTBeHHOM xapaKTepe H BIImy TOJIbIW Op,IIH nYTb
COBMer::qeHIIH IIX C ::JTIIIVIll H3bIKOBbIMII II :3THOrpaiPIPIeCKIIIVIIl HaGJIIOp,eHIIHMII -
C'IIITaTb OTMeqeHHbIe COBIIap,eHIIH B H3bIKe II KYJIbType c:rep,CTBIIeM MHoro-
BeKOBblX Ky:rbTYPHbIX KOHTaKTOB II IIIIiPiPY3IIII KYJILTYPHbIX :3JIeMeHTOB.
t
J,
1 06aop TeoplIii, 6II6.;nIOrpaIfJIIIO II paCCMOTpeHHe rrpOOJIel'.IbJ CYOCTpaTa CM.: TJ epHe-
!foe B. H. Pi Bonpocy 06 9THII'leCROM cyocTpaTe B :L\HpKYMnOJIHpHOii RYJIbType /I
VII MelliP;YHapOp;Hl>IlI ROHrpecc aHTpOnOJIOrI1'leCKIIX II 9THorpaIfJI1'leCKlIX HayR. M.,
1964.
2 A.lteKCeee B. ll. JIecHbIe HeHI bI. COMaTOJIOrH'leCRIIe Ha6JIIOp;eHHH II Bonp. aHTpOrrOJIO-
rmI. 1971. BbIll. 39.
3 0630p nIIIGTe3 rrpOIICXOII>p;eHIIH II aprYl'.IeHTaUIIIO B rro:J:b3Y eBporreoIIp;HolI npHMecu
CM.: A,'leKceee B. I1. 0 nIemaHHmI rrpOIICXOiRp;eHHlI ypaJIbcRolI pacbI II BorrpOCbl apxeo-
JIOrIIII 'YpaJIa. CBepp;JIOBCK, 1961. BblTI. 1.
TJ e6oKcapoe H. H. CeBepHbIe KIITaiiI bl II IIX cocep;II II PipaT. coo6m;. MH-Ta 9THorpaqm:u"
AH CCCP. 1949. Bbill. 5. IIpIIHa}J,JleiRHOCTb aJIeYToB R apKTII'leCRIIIII 1II0HrOJIOHp;aM
aprYMeHTIIpoBaHa Ha RpaHIIOJIOrI1'leCKmI IaTepIIaJIe. CM.: pe6e!f r. l/J. AHTporroJIo-
rII'IeCmIe IICCJIep;OBaHHH B PiaM'laTCROlI OOJIaCTI1. M., 1951. (Tp. MH-Ta 3THorpalfJIIII
AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 17).
HpoMe YKa3aHHoli pa60Tbl CM.: lJe6e!f r. l/J. CeJIbRyrrbl: (AHTporroJI. o'lepR). M.; JI.,
1947 IITp. MH-Ta 9THorpatPIIII AH CCCP. H. C. T. 2.
6 30.ltOTapeea If. JJI. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOe IIcc.;rep;oBaHIIe HraHacaH II COB. 9THorpa1fJHH.
1962. .N2 6; Glia :JICe. IOKanIpbl: (AHTporroJI. O'iepR) IIIIp06JIeMbI aHTpOnOJIOrHII' H'
HCTOpI1'leCROlI 9THorpalfJIIII A3IIII. M., 1968.
7 A.lteJ>ceee B. I1. Pi RpaHIIOJIOrIIH HraHacaHOB II PipaT. cooom;. MH-Ta 9THorpalfJIIH AH'
CCCP. 1955. BbIII. 24.
ft 30.ltOTapee p. A. PiO.lJbCRIIe JIOrrapII. JI., 1928. MapmpYTbI 9Rcrrep;II:L\I1II OIIIIcaHbl: 30-
.ltorapee p. A. JIorrapcKaH 9Rcrrep;IIIIHH (11.I-11.V 1927 rop;a). JI., 1927.
p 0630p pe3YJIbTaTOB H 6II6mIOrpa1fJIIH: Coon C. The races of Europe. N. Y. 1939;
Levin Th. (ed.). Introduction to the biological characteristics of the Skolt Lapps II
Proceedings of the Finnish dental society. Vol. 67. Supplement I. 1971.
10 Schreiner K. Zur Osteologie der Lappen. Bd. I, II Oslo. 1932, 1935; Idem. Further
note on the craniology of the Lapps. Oslo. 1945.
t1 Pe3YJIbTaTbI II3MepeHIIll r. <D. J],e6e:L\a B l'.IY3eHX <DHHJIHHP;IIII, JIIOOe3HO rrpe}J,ocTaB-
JIeHHble aBTopy }J,JIH 03HaROMJIeHIIH II rry6JIIIRa:L\IIII. CM.: A.lteJ>ceee B. I1. PipaHlIOJIO-
rII'IeCRaH xapaKTepIICTIIKa HaCeJIeHlUI BOCTO'lHOlI <DeHHocRaHp;IIII II PacOreHenI'IeCIDIe
rrp0:L\eCCbI B 9THII'leCROH HCTOpHH. M., 1974.
12 A.lteJ>ceee B. I1. IIpolIcxomAeHHe Hapop;OB BOCTO'lHOH EBporrbl: (HpaHlIOJI. HCCJIeA.).
M., 1969.
13 pe6e!f r. l/J. AHTporroJIorII'lecRIIe IICCJIep;OBaHIIH B PiaM'laTCKOH 06JIaCTII.
'" A.lteKCeee B. I1. Pi RpaHlIOJIOrIIII 83IIaTCKIIX 9CRIIl'.IOCOB: (MaTepIIaJIbI R 9THoreHe3Y) II'
3arrHcRII 1JYRoTcRoro RpaeBep;'leCRoro MY3eH. Mara}J,aH, 1967.
15 A.lteKCeee B. I1. AHTpOrrOJIoriH CaJITiBbcRoro MOrlIJIbHIIRa II MaTepHiaJIll 3 aHTpono'
JIorii 'YRpalHH. llirIB. 1962. BIIrr. 2.
18 A.lteKCeee B. I1. IIpOIICXOiR}J,eIIIIe Hapop;OB BOCTO'lHOii EBpOITbl.
17 XaaaHoea A. B., maM.qRH H. I1. Pi aHTpOrrOJIOrHH II rrorrYJIH:L\IIOHITOlI reHeTIIRe JIona-
peH PiOJIbCKOro no.rryocTpoBa II Bonp. aHTpOrrO;IOrHII. 1970. BbIII. 34.
18 30.ltOTapeea If. M. Pacrrpep;eJIeHIIe rpyrrrr KpOBII Y Hapop;OB CeBepHOlI CH6IIpH It
VII Memp;YHapop;HblH ROHrpecc aHTpOrrOJIOrII'leCKIIX II 9THorpaIfJII'leCRIIX HayR. M...
1964. He IICrrOJIb30BaHbI MaTepIIaJIbl, orrYOJIIIKOBaHHbIe IO. r. PbI'IROBbnI (Bonp.
aHTpOrrOJIOrHII. 1965. BbIII. 21), TaK RaR B HIIX cO}J,epiRaTCH CBe}J,eHIIHTOJIbRO 0 CIICTe-
Me ABO H op;Ha II3 P;BYX orry6JIHlWBaHHbIX IIM BbiOOpOR 06pa30BaHa HBHO B Hapy-
meHIIe rronYJIH:L\IIOHHOii CTPYKTYPbI (EOJIbIIIe3eMe.rrbCKaH TYHp;pa, Ha}J,IIHCKaH TYHP;-
pa, p. IIyp, p. Ta3, r. CaJIexap}J,). J],aHHble, c06paHHble 3RCrrep;II:L\IIeII IIHCTHTYTa
aHTpOrrOJIOrHH Mr'Y rrop; PYROBOP;CTBOM T. M. AJIeKceeBoH, orryomIROBaHbI Yllie rrOCJIe.
HaITllCaHlIH 9TOlI paOOTbl II rr09TOMY He Y'ITeHbI.
19 JIeeuH lYI. r. rpyrrnbI KpOBII Y '1Yh"Ieii H 9CKIDIOCOB II COB. 9THorpalfJuH, 1958. M 5;.
OH :JICe. HOBbIe IaTepIIaJIbl no rpyrrrraM RpOBII Y 3CRIHIOCOB II JIal'.IYTOB II COB. 9THO-
rpalfJIIH. 1959, .N2 3.
7 Helmbold W.. ProkDP G. Die Bestimmung der ABO-Gen frequenzen mittels der
Maximum-Likelihood-Methode und andere Verfahren an Hand forensisher Blutgrup-
penbestimmungen in Berlin II Blut. Bd. 4. 1958.
r
f
!
t
413
I
21 $anghvi K. Comparison of genetical and morphological methods for a study of bio-
logical differences II American journal of physical anthropology (new series). Vol. II,
1953. N 3.
22 Knussmann R. Moderne Statistische Verfahren in der Rassenkunde II Die neue
Rassenkunde. Hrsg yon I. Schwidetzky. Stuttgart. 1962.
23 Kurcynski T. Generalized distance and discrete variables II Biometrics. Vol. 26, 1970.
N 3.
24 CBOAIDI o6m;ero xapaRTepa, IIORBHBIIIHeCR B IIOCJIeAHHe rO:Il>I, nepe'lHCJIeHbI: Po-
euncJ>uu H. H. HeROTOpbIe BOlIpOCbI CilCTmIaTIIRH H paCCe.:IeHH11 'leJIOBe'leCRIIX pac
IIO AaHHbIM Aepl'.IaTorJIlHlnIRII II Bonp. aHTpOnOJIOnm. 1970. BbIll. 34.
25 r .ltaf}J>oea T. II-. XUTb r. JI. MaTeplIaJIl>I no Aepl'.IaTorJImIJIIRe HeROTOpl>IX HapOAOB
CH6HpH II IIpOOJIeMbI aHTpOnOJIOrHH II IICTOplI'leCROll: 9THorpalfJIIlI A3IIH. M., 1968.
25 Boyd W. Achievements of the genetical method in physical anthropology II Ameri-
can anthropologist. Vol. 65, 1963. N 2.
27 HOBelrIIIHR 0030p rrp06JIeMbI H JIHTepaTYPy CM.: KepT r. M. Caal'.ICRIIH H3bIR. JI., 1971.
..28 Oco6eHHo rrOJIHO OHl! pacCMOTpeHbI: Kpeulioeu'l E. A. IORarHpcRHH H3bIR. M.; JI., 1958.
29 I1pb£TJ>oea H. l/J. Op;emAa HapoAoB Cal'.IOAIIHCROii rpyrrrrl>I RaR I1CTOpH'leCRIIlr HCTO'l-
HHR II Op;eiRAa Hapop;oB CH6IIplI. JI., 1970.
.'i
. i
i
o XAPARTEPE
8THOfEHETMqECRMX ITPOQECCOB
HA TEPPIITOPMM CMEMPM
B CBETE AHTPOITOJIOfMqECRMX ,l];AHHbIX
rlmOTE3A HEOJIIITIIQECKOrO B03PACTA
COBPEMEHHhlX HAPO)J;OB
-I
.t
iHeCMOTpH Ha 3Ha'IIITeJIbHOe pa3BIITIIe KOHKpeTHbIx :3THOreHeTII'IeCKIIX IICCJIe-
p,oBaHlIn, TeOpeTII'IeCKaH JIIITepaTypa no :3T1IOreHe3Y OCTaeTCH ,lW lIaCToHr::qero
BpeMeHII p,OBOJIbHO Gep,Hon, II B Hen HeT CKOJIbKO-HU6yp,b yp,OBJIeTBOpIITeJIb-
HblX nOnbITOK oxapaKTeplI30BaTb Bce cyr::qeCTBeHHbIe acneKTbl :3Torb npo
ec-
ca. ITo cyr::qeCTBY COBepmeHHO npaBIIJIbHbIe YKa3aHIIH Ha HeoGxop,IIMOCTb
ROMnJIeKCHOro nop,xop,a K np06JIeMaM :3THOreHe3a HOCHT p,OCTaTO'UlO oor::qlIn
xapaKTep II He npOHCHHIOT B p,OCTaTO'IHOn CTeneHII nYTen IICnOJIb30BaUIIH II'
KOMGIIHlIpoBaHIIH OTp,eJIbHblX IICTOpII'IeCKIIX IICTO'IHIIKOB B :3THOreHeTII'IeCKIIX
"IWJIHX. He COCTaBJIHeT IICKJIIO'IeHIIH II a.HTpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKIIn MaTepIIaJI: MHoro
nIICaJIOCb 0 HeCOBnap,eHIIII rpaHII
pacnpOCTpaHeHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKIIX II
JIIIUrBIICTII'IeCKIIX, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIX II IICTOpIIKO-Ky.'II,TYPHbIX oGr::qHocTen \
HO iPOpMbI IIX B3aIIMop,encTBIIH Ha pa3HblX :3TanaX IICTOpIIII qeJIOBe'IeCTBa
'er::qe npe.a:CTOIIT IICCJIep,OBaTb. .
Meffi.a:y TeM KaK HII CJIOmlIa xapaKTepIICTIIKa :3TIIOreHeTII'IeCKOrO npoD,ec-
.ca B
eJIOM II OTp,eJIbHbIX BpeMeHHbIX II TeppIITOpIIaJIbHbIX iPOpM ero npOHB-
JIeHIIH, OHa pacnap,aeTCH Ha pHp, COCTaBJIHIOr::qIIX, Kalli;J;aH II3 KOTOpbIX p,omK-
Ha ObITb paCCMOTpeHa II IICCJIe.a:OBaHa OTp,eJIbHO. H 'Inc.:ry :3TIIX COCTaBJIHIO-
ID,IIX MomHO orneCTII MHorOKOMnOHeHTHOCTb JIIOGoro :3THOreHe3a, xapaKTep
'conpmKeHHOCTII BO BpeMeHII iPopMIIpoBaHIIH aHTponO.JorII'IeCKIIX, JIIIHrBIICTII
'IeCKIIX II IICTOpIIKO-KyJIbTYPHbIX ocoGeHHocTeii CK:ra;J;bIBaIOr::qerOCH HOBoro
Hapop,a, COOTHomeHIIe :3THOreHe3a C :3KOJIOrn'IeCKOn cpe;J;on, nOHIIMaH nop,
nOCJIep,Hen II CO
IIaJIbHbIe II nplIpop,HbIe ee acneKTbI. HaKoHe
, He nOCJIep,Hen
no BamHOCTII COCTaBJIHIOr::qell xa paKTepIICTIIKII :3THOreHeTII'IeCIWrO npoD,eCca
npIIMeHIITe.TJ:bHO K CTaHOBJIeHIIIO OT/.I,eJIbHbIX Hapop,oB HBJIHeTCH p,JIIITeJIbHOCTb
:3Toro CTaHOBJIeHIIH II XpOHOJIOrII'IeCKaH npIIypO'IeHHOCTb K TOll IIJIII IIHon
.8noxe IICTOpIIII 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa. PaCCMOTpeIIIIe JII060ro 113 :3TIIX BonpOCOB Tpe-
414
r
oyeT Cnen;UaJIbHOII paOOTbI, Aame ec.:m pe'Ib U;J,eT He 0 rJIOOaJIbHOM OXBaTe
AaHHbIX, a JIIIIlIb 0 KRKon-TO orpalUI'IeHHOll TeppUTOpUU. B ;J:aIIHOM pa3AeJIe
nOIIAeT pe'lb 0 BpeMelUI CTaIIOBJIelUUI COBpe:'\feHHbIX Hapop;OB CUOllpU.
II3BeCTHaH CTaTLH A. D. OKJIap;IUIIWBa 0 HeOJIUTU'leCKUX apXeOJIOrII'leCKIIX
RYJIbTYpax Cuoupu onUpaJIaCb Ha O'leHb HeOOJIbiliOn U BbIObpo'lHBIn MaTe.
pnaJI, cop;epmaJIa MHoro TeppIITOpUaJIbIIbIX 3KCTpanOJIHn;Un 2, HO AaBaJIa B TO
me BpeMH 'leTKYIO TIIIIOJIOrnqecKyIO xapaKTepIICTIlKy KyJIbTYP U KapTY HX
apeaJIOB. 8KCTpanoaHn;UH BbIOOpO'lHbIX MaTepUaJIOB Ha AOCTaTO'lHO OOIlIHpHLIe
TeppUTOpUIT, HcnOCTb TITnOJIOrU'leCKUX xapaKTepUCTIIK U 'leTKOCTb apeaJIOB
OTp;eJIbHbIX KYJIbTYP npOII3BeJIII OOJIbiliOe Bne'laTJIenUe Ha cnen;IiaJIHCTOB-ap-
xeoaorOB U Ha MHorue rop;hI OOeCIIe'lIIJIU ':nOII CTaTbe iIUI3Hb B Ka'leCTBe OC-
HOBHoro IICTO'lHlIKa CBep;eHITij 0 neOJIIITU'leCKUX KYJIbTypax CUOUpu. Ho em;e
OOJIbille ObIJI pe30RaHC 3TOM CTaTbU npu U3Y'leIUIH BonpOCOB 3THoreHe3a:
npO'lUTaHHaH Jl.0 rrYOJIUKan;lIlI KaK p;OKJIap; Ha COBem;aHUU 110 3THoreHe3Y Ha-
pOAOB CIIOIIPU, ORa B 3HaqJITeJIhHOn CTeneIIU OIIpep;eJIIIJIa XpOfIOJIOrlIqeCKHe
paMKU, B KOTOpbIe CTaJIU BMem;aTbCH 3THoreHeTIIqeCKUe npOn;eCCbI, npHBeA-
IlIIIe K CJIOmPHUIO COBpeMeHHhIX HapO;J;OB CUOUplI. 8TO nepnop; 01' HaqaJIa
3nOXH HeOJIIITa p;o HaqaJIa 3rroxu 6POH3bI, T. e. BeCb 3Tan HeOJIUTa U 3Tan
paHIIen OpOH3bI. DOUCK HeOJIUTII'leCKIIX UCTUKOB 3TIIOreHe3a cOBpeMeHHbIx
CIIOUPCKUX Hapop;oB CTiUI OP;HIIM 1I3 MarUCTpaJIbHbIX nYTen u3yqeHHH ux npo-
ncxomp;eHHH He TOJIbRO B apxeOJIOrUqeCROII, HO U B IICTOPURO-3THOJIOrUqeCKOM:
IT aHTponOJIOrIIqeCKOII JIIITepaType.
HaRanJIIIBaBIlIIIeCH Bce aUJIee OOIlIlIpHbIe U IWHRpeTHbIe p;aHHbIe no p;n-
Hal\IIlKe UCTOPIIRu-3THoreHenlqeCRUX IIpOn;eCCOB Ha OTp;eJIbHbIX TeppUTopHHX
He Bcerp;a yRJIa,lIblBaJIIICb B 31'11 meCTKue paMKII. II C. B. KUCeJIeB, U BCJIe
aa HUM JI. P. RbI3JIaCOB AOCTaTOqHO yoep;UTeJIbHO nOKa3aJIU, qTO HH 0 RaKIIX
HeOJIUTIlqeCRIIX UCTORax 3THoreHe3a xaKaCCRoro Hapop;a He npuxop;IITCH ro-
BOpUTb U qTO HaUOOJIee IIHTeHCIIIHIbIii npon;ecc CJIOIKeIlIIH xaRaCOB UMeJI Me-
CTO B I TbICHqeJIeTIIH H. 3. 3 <DopMupoBarrIIe IIX OTJIIPIIITeJIbHbIX aHTpOnOJIO-
I'IPIeCKIIX ocooeulloCTeII npIJl\IepHO B 3TO me BpCMH llJIU p;ame rr03JKe ObIJIO
npoAeMoHCTpUpOnaJTo H naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrrrqeCRItlIHI MaTeprraJIaMlI 4. DpOII3-
BeAeHHoe E. II. J];epeBHHKO IIcc.TIeJl.OBaHIIe MOX3CCRIIX ApeBHOCTen Ha cpep;-
HeM AMype npIIHeCJIO He MeHee UHTepeCHbIe pe3YJIbTaTbI B 3TOM OTHOilieHUII:
MOX3CCRue IIJIeMeHa He npep;KU Toro IIJIU UHoro COBpeMeHHorOTyHrYCOH3b1q-
Horo Hapop;a, HO OHlI, OqeBlIp;nU, npUHHJIU Y'laCTUe B CPOpMupOBaHUII II Ha-
Hann;eB, U YJIbqen, H, B03Mom1I0, yp;3renn;eB, 3THH'IeCKaH caMOCTOHTeJIbHOCTb.
ROTOpbIX eIl e He ObIJIa, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, BbIpameHa BO BTopOM nOJIOBHHe'
I TbICHqeJIeTHH H. 3. II ROTopbIe 3THU'leCKU C,TIOmIIJIIICb B OOJIee n03AHee.
BpeMH 5.
TIOP;OOHbIe KpaCIIOpeqIIBbIe npUMepbI MomHU ObIJIO ObI YMHomaTb H
AaJIbme, no OHU He MeHHIOT CJIOn lIBillenCH Tpap;U InI, U OHa OCTaeTCH npem-
HeM: II 3THorpacpbI, U apXeOJIOrU, U 8HTpOnOJIOru, paccMaTpImaIOm;ue npooJIe-
MbI 3TIIOreHe3a cOBpeMeHHbIx Hapop;oB CUOllpU, O'leHb qaCTO oopam;aIOTCH R
apXeOJIOrIlqeCKoMY U naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrUqeClwMY l\IaTepIIaJIY. rrbITaHCb HanTH"
B lIeM nop;TBepmp;eHue HeOJIIITllqeCKOrO B03pacTa Toro IIJIU UHoro HapoAa.
HanoMHIO B :3ToM CBR3n cTapyIO nOJIeMuKy Memffi' A. D. ORJIaAHIIKOBbIM Ii"
M. r. JIeBIIHbIM 06 3THUqeCKOn npIIHa,lIJIemHOCTU HCOJIUTUqeCIWrO HaCeJIeHHH
ITpuoaIlKaJIbH. Cnop, KaK U3BeCTHO, IlIeJI 0 TOM, rrpeJ ROB RaRoro U3 COBpe-
MeHHbIX Hapop;OB BU.'J,eTb B HeOJIIITIIqeCKIIX rrorrYJIHn;IUIX ITpu6aMKaJIbR:
A. IT. OIma!..l;IIIIKOB OTCTaIIBaJI UX TYHrYCOfI3bIqHOCTb 6, M. r. JIeBuH BHAeJI'
B IIUX IIpep;KOB IOKarupUB 7. OilHaKO npII pa3HUn;e B KOHKpeTHOM nOAxoAe R
On;eHKe 3THUqeCROrO JIUn;a IIpUoaIlKaJIbCKoro HaCeJIeHITR ca:i\-Ia OCHOBa nOAxo-
)];a OCTRi'JaJIaCb op;IIHaKOBOII: HeOJIUTUqeCKUe UCTORII 3THoreHe3a II 3BeHrWB Hi
J
415
I
:IORarlipOB He BbI3bIBaJIII y nO. T IeMII3IIpOBaBIlIIIX CTOpOH HII MaJIeHllierO COM-
HeHIIH.
PaeCMOTpeHHaH TO'lRa speIIIIH nOJIy',mJIa XOllin;eHIIe II B naJIeOaHTpOnOJIO-
,rn'leCRoII JIIITepaType, npaBp;a B OCOOOM npeJIo!\omemw:: MOP<POJIorII'leCRIIe'
oco6eHHoCTH HeOJIHTH'leCRoro HaCeJIeHIIH ITpHoaIIKaJIbH HCTOJIROBbIBaJIIICb He
RaR OCHOBa <pOpMIIpOBaHIIH aUTpOIIUJIOrII'leCRoro COCTaBa Toro IIJIH IIHoro
Hapop;a, a RaR ocnOBa <pOpMIIpOBaHIiH aHTpOnOJIOrII'leCRoro COCTaBa CIIOllp-
<CRIIX Hapop;OB B D;eJIOM 8. B Ra'leCTBe p;ORaSaTeJIbCTBa <PIIryplipOBaJIO MOP<P O -
JIOrn'leCRoe CXOP;CTBO BooopalliaeMOH KpaHIIOJIOrIl'leeROII eepIIII, nOJIY'leHHOH
Ha OCHOBe ycpep;HeHIIH p;aHUbIX no RpaUIIOJIOrII'leCKIIM eepIIHM, OTHoeHllJ,lIMeH
R OTp;eJIbHbIM COBpeMeHHbIM Hapop;aM CIIOlipII, II cepIIII npnOaHRaJIbeROrO Heo-
JInTa. Gp;HaRO, ITOMllMO eaMOll YCJIOBHOeTII nop;OOfwro conOeTaBJIeHHH, npH
3TOM OCTaBJIeIIbI oes p;OCTaTOqHOrO BHIIMaHIIH Miwro'lIICJIeHHbIe sa<pIIReIIpo-
.BaHHbIe naJIeOaHTpUnOJIOrH'leeRII <paRTbI OOIlIHpHbIX p;peBHHx MlirpaD;IIll,
B xop;e ROTOpbIX Ha TepplITUpllII CIIOIIpII nOHBJIHJIIIeb OO:IbIllIre !\oweCbI HOBO-
ro nHopop;Horo no IIpOlleXOllip;eHIlIO HaeeJIeIIIIH. IT03TOMY BSrJIHp; Ha HeOJIIITII-
'lecKyIO OCHOBY 3THoreHesa COBpeMeHHbIX eIIOIIpCKIIX Hapop;OB II C aHTpono-
JIOrn'leeROM TO'lKII speHIIH He l\fQllieT c'liiTaTbCH oeeeIIopUbIM.
BPEMH tOOPMHPOBAHHH HAPOf};OB 3AIIAf};HO:O: CHEHPH
qTO AaeT HaM aUTpOnOJIOrIl'leCRIIII MaTeplIaJI B OTHOllIeHIIn nponCXOllin;eHIIH
yropCKIIX n caMop;IIHCKIIX HapOAOB 3ana;:J:HOH CIIOIIpn? GHII AOCTaTO'lHO pes-
Ru OTJIII'laIOTCH p;pyr OT p;pyra B BbIpaa,eHHOCTn !\oWHTOJIOIIAHbIX oeooeHHO-
CTell. ECJIII cpep;II npIIypaJIbCKnX MaHcn rrpeOOJIap;aeT eBponeOIlp;HaH KOMOII-
HaD;IIH rrpIISHaROB 9, TO CeJIbKynbI, HraHacaHbI, 3HD;bI, JIeCHbIe HeHD;bI - oec-
crropHLIe HOCnTeJIn MOHrOJIOIIp;HOro KOMnJIeKCa npliSHaKOB 10. I1cCJIeAOBaB-
lIme npnypaJIbCRIIX MaHCII T. A. TpO<pUlVIOBa II H. H. qeooKeapOB He oe3
OCHOBaHIIH paCCMaTpnBaJIII IIX RaR nOTOMROB IIJIeMeH aHp;pOHOBCKOH KyJIbTY-
pLI - RJIaCeII'leCROH KYJIbTYPbI 3nOXli OpOHSbI. ITolliaJIYH, 3TO HaHOOJIee p;peB-
HHH aHaJIOrIoIH TOMY Mop<pOJIOrn'leCKOi\IY Tllny, KOTOpbIH rrpep;eTaBJIeH B CO-
BpeMeHHOM HaeeJIeHIIII, HO II OHa, C OP;HOH CTOpOHbI, Ha Op;Ho-ABa TbICH'leJIeTnH
IIOSllie 3rroxn HeOJIIITa, a C APyroii,- eTporo rOBopH, BbIxop;nT sa paMKn CII-
"6npCIWll TeppnTopnn. K HaCTOHllJ,eMY BpeMeHII nsY'leHbI MHorO'lneJIeHHbIe II
paSHooopaSHbIe naJIeOaHTpOnOJlOnI'leCKIIe l\IaTepIIaJIbI ns MonmbHbIX naMHT-
IInlWB IOlliHOH 'laeTn 3arraf.l:IIOH Cnonpn, CBIIp;eTeJILCTBYIOllJ,ne 0 sHa'lIITeJIb-
HOM rrpeOOJIap;amUI TaM eBponeonp;noro TIIna y nJIeMeU 3noxn OPOHSbI II
"IaCTII'lHO paHHero il{eJIe3a 11. B ceBepHOll, TaellinOH 'laCTII 3arra)J:HOll CIIOII-
pII MOHrOJIOIIAHbIH KOMnOHeHT, BOSMOlliIIO, II npeOOJIa.uaJI. HO 3TO npeAnOJIO-
meHIIe ne onIIpaeTCH HII Ha KaRYIO naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrn'leCKYIO 1IH<popMa1J;nIO
11 OCTaeTCH 'IIIeTO YMospIITeJIhHbIM. BOJIbllIIIe MaCCbI eBponeOII)J:Horo HaCeJIe-
HUH B CTerrHOII n JIeCOCTerrHOH 30Hax 3anaAHOH CuonpII He MOrJIIi He OKa-
saTh cyllJ,eCTBeHHoe BJInHHlle Ha 3THoreHeTlI'IeeKUe rrpOD;eeCbI K ceBepy OT IlX
apeaJIa. IT03TOMY Aallie npn nmIHOM OTCYTCTBIHr rrpHMbIX rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrn-
'leCKnX p;OKaSaTeJIbCTB MOil,no C p;OCTaTO'IHOH YBepeHIIOCTbIO YTBeplli)J:aTb, 'ITO
cpopMnpOBaHlIe aHTpOnOJIOrnqeeKOrO coeTaBa RopeHIlbIX Hapop;OB 3anaAHOll
CIIOIIpn npOIISOIlIJIO He paIIbllle 'IeM B I TLICH'IeJIeHlIII H. 3., a 'IaCTn'IHO p;allie
nOSllie.
416
j
XPOHOJlOrJUI THOrEHETHqECRHX IIPO ECCOB
B I02RHO:O: CHBHPII
I1epeXO}];11 K TeppUTOpUU IOmHoH Cu6upn, CJIe):Q'eT cpasy me OTMeTHTb, 'ITO
:3THOreIIeTU'IeCKUe rrpo eCCbl B paSHblX ee 06JIaCTHX IIMeJIII paSJIH'IHYIO XPO-
HOJIGrU'IeCRYIO rrpuypO'IeHHOCTb. EBporreoup;Hoe rro CBOIIM Mop<pOJIOrU'IeCKHM
rrpUSlIaKaM HaCeJIeHlIe COCTaBJ1H.iIO 1I0p;aBJIHIOIIJ,YIO Maccy B CTerrHX AJITae-Ca-
HHCRoro HaropbH B 3rroxy 3HeOJIUTa U 6pOHSbl, 'IaCTII'IHO H B 31I0XY palmero
meJIesa. MOHrOJIOIlp;HaH rrpUl\IeCb <pUKcupyeTcH B aTO BpeMH JIIIllIb B ep;IIHH'I-
HblX CJIY'IaHX, HO 1I0CTelIerrHO YCIIJIUBaeTCH, Ha'IIIHaH C 3rrOXII paHHero meJIe-
sa, U p;OCTuraeT rrOJJHoro rrpeOOJIap;aHIIH B COBpeMeIIHYIO 3rroxy. TaKIIM 06pa-
SOM. OCIIOBHaH TeHp;eH IIH p;IIHaMIIKU aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKOrO COCTaBa aJITae-
caHHCKUX Hapop;OB COCTOHJIa B ,o:OCTaTO'IHO orrpe,o:eJIeHHO HarrpaBJIeHHOM sa-
Me:rn:eHUII eBporreoup;Horo ROMrrOHeHTa MOHrOJIOH,o:HbIM. Op;HaKO npOIJ,eCC saMe-
IIJ;eHIIH He ObIJI, 6YP;Y'III Cj.I,UHOnarrpaBJIellHbIM, paBHOMepHbIM, a rr03TOMY
KOHKpeTHbIe <pOpMhJ IT xpOnOJIOrlI'IeCKUe paMKU CMellIeHHH Mem,o:y eBporreOH,o:-
HbJMII II MOHrOJIOIIp;HbIMU rrorryJIHIJ,IIHMII HeJIbSH C'IlITaTb op;IIHaKOBbIMU B rrpe-
,o:eJIax paSHLlx ropHblX CUCTeM U pas,o:eJIHIOIIJ;UX UX ).I;OJIIIH B AJITae-CaHHCROM
Haropbe. I103TOMY BpeMH c.TIOmemIH Tpex KpyrrueiillIIIX Hapop;OB AJITae-CaHH-
CKoro HaropbH - xaKaCCKoro, aJITallCKOro U TYBUHCKoro Momuo C'IUTaTb
paSHbJM, U aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKUe p;aHHhIe ).I;eMOHCTpUpyroT TeppIITOpUaJIhHbIe
paSJJJI'IIIH B XpOHOJIOrIIII 3THoreH8TU'IeCKIIX rrpOIJ,eCCOB C IJOJIHOH onpep;eJIeH-
HOCTbIO.
XaKaCIIH B JIaH).I;llIa<pTHOM OTH01lI8HIIII npOTIlBorrOCTaBJIHeTCH B IISBeCTJIOH
CTeneHII AJITaIO II TYBe, npe;'.l,CTaBJIHH COOOH B OCHOBHOM paBHHHHYIO II rrpe,o:-
ropHYIO CTpaIlY B npOTIIBOBec rrO).l;HHTIIHM AJITae-CaHHCKOH ropHOH CUCTeMbl.
3aBIICIIl\lOCTL IIHTeHCIIBHOCTII 3THoreHesa OT xapaKTepa JIaHp;llIa<p Ta em;e He
rro,o:BepraJIaCb, yBbl, cepbeSHOMY ROHKpeTHO-UCTOpU'IeCROMY II TeOpeTU'IeCKO-
MY aHaJIII3Y, HO B 06IIJ,eH <popMe MOa\HO rrpep;IIOJIaraTb, 'ITO paBHIIHlIocTb
TepplIToplIII II OTCYTcTBue B ee IIpe,o:eJIax cepbeSHbJX reorpa<pIl'IeCKIIX py6e-
iReH 06JIer'IaIOT npn rrpo'Iux paBHblx yCJIOBUHX MIIrpaU;IIoHHble rroToRII, T. e.
rrOHBJIeHUe HOBbIX, 'Iymepo,o:HhlX rpynIl HaCeJIeHIlH, a C HIlMIl IlOHBJIeHlIe HO-
BbJX KOM6uHaIJ,UH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIQeCKUX rrpIIsHaRoB. ConpeMeHHaH TeppuTopHH
XaEacuII, T. e. MIIHYCIIHcKaH KOTJIOBIIHa, HBJIHeTCH IIp;eaJIbHbJM npuMepoM B
nOJILsy Ilo,!.l;06HOrO rrpe).l;rrOJIOmel-nIH. BhlllIe yme rOBOpIIJIOCb, 'ITO Hau60JIee
IIHTeHCHBHbJH npou;ecc <pOpMIIpoBaHIIH xaKaCCKoro Hapop;a nap;aeT Ha I TbJ-
CH'IeJIeTIIe H. 3., CKopee p;aiRe Ha ero BTOPYIO IlO.TIOmmy, a saBepllIeHIIe 3TorO
rrpoIJ,eCca MomlIO ,o:aTIlpOBaTb n em;e 60JIee rrOS).I;HIIM BpeMeHeM - Ha'IaJIOM
Halliero TbICH'IeJIeTIIH, 'ITO COrJIaCHO ).I;eMOHCTpUPY€TCH II IICTOpIIKO-3THorpa-
tPU'IeCKUMU, H apxeOJIOrU'IeCKIIMII, II aHTpOrrOJIOrIl'IeCIDIMU ,o:aHHbIMII. C06CT-
BeHHO rOBopH, eCJJJI He urHopupOBaTb IICTOPURO-3THorpa<pU'IeCKUX ,o:aHHhIX, TO
OKOH'IaHHe npou;ecca 3THoreHesa xaKaCCKoro Hapop;a HHKaK HeJIbSH OTHeCTII
K rrepIIO):Q' paHbllIe XVII B., TaK KaK UMeHHO B 3TO BpeMH eIIJ,e cym;ecTBo-
BaJIIl B Memp;ype'Ibe A6aKaHa U EHIlceH caMoe,o:oHShl'IHble 3THIl'IeCKIIe rpyn-
ilbI, BOllIep;llIHe B COCTaB xaKaCOB 12.
KOHKpeTHble <pOpMhl CMellIeHHH MOHrOJIOlI,o:OB II eBpOIleOHp;OB Ha AJITae
HOCIIJIII HeCKOJIbKO IIHOH xapaKTep. Cy,o:H rro naJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIM MaTe-
plIaJIaM, 3TO CMellieHIle SaKOH'IIIJIOCh Ha py6eme I II II TbICH'IeJIeTIIH H. 3.,
II K 3TOMY me BpeMeHU 06paSOBaJIUCb OTJIU'IIITeJIhHble oc06eHHOCTII HeKoTO-
pbIX rrJIeM8HHbJX rpynn, BOllIeJ(llIHX B COCTaB aJITaHu;eB, HanplIMep KYMaH-
,o:HHu;eB 13. Ha'IaJIo IIHTeHCIIBHoro CMellIeHHH naJ(aeT Ha CKII<PCKYIO 3noxy,
'II, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, CJIOmeHIIe aHTpOrrOJIOrlI'IeCKOrO COCTaBa aJITaHCKOro Hapo-
,o:a OXBaTHJIO rrepHOp; B rrOJITOphl TbICH'III JIeT. 3TIIMII XpOHOJIOrU'IeCKIIMII paM-
!
.
14 B. n. AJIeI<ceeB
417
RaMH AaTHpYIOTCH H OCHOBHbIe KYJIbTypHbIe aHaJIOI'HH, q,HKcHPyeMhIe 3THO-
I'paq,HqeCKH II apxeOJIOI'IIqeCKIl, a TIOpKHSa:I(IIH MeCTHOI'O HaCeJIeHIIH COBna-,
AaeT, nO-Bllp;IIMOMY, C noc.lIep;Heii TpeTbIO nOJIYTopaTbICHqHOI'O OTpeSKa
BpeMeHll. He TO B TYBe: HeOOJIbliiaH MOHI'OJIOIlp;naH nplIl\oIeCb q,IIKCHpyeTcH
TaM yllie B 3noxy OpOHSbI a, no npeOOJIa):\aHlIe eBponeOIIAOB OqeBIIAHO AO>
:mOXll npeAMOHI'OJIbCKOI'O BpeMeHH. Em.e B XII B. ImaCCllqeCKlle eBponeOIIAhI
npOllilIBaJIll B OTAeJIbHbIX paIlOHax 15. TaKIIM oopaSOM, CTaHOBJIeHHe aHTpo-
rrOJIOrlIqeCKHX ocooeHIfOCTeii TYBIIHD;eB P;OJIlliHO ObITb p;aTllpOBaHO nOCJIeMOH-
I'OJIbCKIIM BpeMeHeM, Ha IWTopoe naAaeT II OKOHqaHHe llX 3THOI'eHesa. IIOA-
BOP;H IITOI' paCCMOTpeHHIO rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOI'IlH AJITae-CaHHCKOI'O HaI'OpbH,
CJIep;yeT B CBHSH C OCHOBHOll TeMOH paSAeJIa nOp;qepKHYTb, qTO HH 0 KaRlIX
BeOJIHTHqeCKHX llCTOKax 3THoreHesa aJITae-CaHHCKHX HapOAOB He rrplIxop;HTCH
I'OBOpIITb.
BblIIIe Yllie ynoMIIHaJIOCb 00 HSBecTHoIl cnopHocTH rlInoTesbI, COI'JIaCHO'
ROTopoIl HeO;nITllqeC:HOe nace.lIeHlle IIpHoaImaJIbH OD;eHIIBaJIOCb KaK OCHORHOH
KOl\olIIOHeHT 3THOI'eHeSa Bcex COBpeMeHHblx CIIOlIpCKIIX Hapop;OB. B p;OnOJIHe-
Bile K CKasaHHOMY 00 aHTpOnOJIOI'IIqeCKIlX apI'YMeHTax B HOJIbSY :3TOll l'IlnO-
TeShI HeJIb3H He npUIIHTb BO BHIH1aHlIe II AeMOI'paq,IPleCKII8 c060pallieHIIH:
nonYJIHD;IlH OXOTHIIKOB H phIOOJIOBOB He rrpOllSBOP;HT HSOMTOqHOI'O p;eMOI'pa-
q,IIqeCKOI'O .o;aBJIeHIIH II BpHA JIll l\olOI'JIH ObI sa nHTb TbICHq JIeT K rrplIxoP;Y
PYCCIOlX paspaCTIICI> P;O paSMepOB oom.ecnOHpCKOll nonYJIHD;IIII. ,l];IICKYCCHH
00 anTpOnOJIOrnqeCIWM COCTaBe HeOJIHTlIqeCKHX norrYJIHIJ;IIll npo,n:OJIlliaeTCH
yllie HeCKOJIbKO AeCHTHJIeTllll, OCHOBHoe ee COAeplliaHHe COCTaBJIHeT, KaK IlS-
BeCTHO, OOCYlliAeHII8 Bonpoca 0 HaJIHqIIll II OTCYTCTBIIIf eBponeOHAHOll npll-
MeCH II ee MaCIIITaoax. B CBHsn C paCCMaTpllBael\olOll HaMil TeMOll BhIOOp Melli-
AY ABYMH aJIbTepmlTIIBaMII - HaJIllqlIeM eBponeOII,n:nOll nplIMeCll B COCTaBe
HeOJIHTllqeCKOI'O HaCeJIeHIIH IIplIOallKaJIbH n MOp OJIOrlIqeCKOll HellTpaJIbHO-
CTbIO 3TOI'O HaCeJIenlIH - OOJIee llJIII MeHee oeSpaSJIllqeH, TaK KaK B OOOIIX
C-JIyqaHX peqb HAeT 0 oesorOBOpOqnOM II CnpaBegJIlmOM nplISHaHlI1I neCOM-
HeHHbIX OTJIllqHM HeOJIIITlIqeCIWrO HaCeJIeIUIH OT COBpeMenHbIX CHOIIPCKHX
MOHrOJIOllp;OB. BHOBb OIUlcaHHbIH naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCKIIM MaTepHaJI HS
<l>oq,aHOBCKoro MOI'IIJIbHIIKa B 3aOaHKaJIbe nplIHec cym.eCTBeHHoe gOKaSaTeJIb-
CTBO B nOJIbSY rIInOTeSbI eBpOneOJIJJ:HOH npHMeCII, TaK KaK qepena lIS $oq,a-,
HOBCKoro MOrllJIbHIIKa OKasa.lIHCb SHaqlITeJIbHO OOJIee MOHI'OJIOIIP;HbIl\oIIl, qeM
npllOaMKaJIbCKlIe, MOHrOJIOIlAHble qepTbI Ha HIIX BbIpallieHbI He CJIaoee, qeM
y COBpeMeHHbIX KOpOHHbIX Hapop;OB CnOllplI 16. Ho nOBTopHIO, AJIH Hac BbIOOp'
TOM nJIll llHOH rlInOTeSbI IIl\oWeT BTopocTerreHHoe SHaqeHHe: II TYHryco-MaHb-'
"IlliypcKHe Hapo,n:bI, 0 KO'fOpbIX, HaK MbI nOMHIIM, nHCaJI A. II. OKJIap;HHKOB
B CBHSII C HeOJIHTGM IIpllOaiiHaJIbH, II IOKaI'HpbI, 0 KOTOphIX mlCaJI IVL r. JIe-
BHH,- KJIaCClIqeCKlIe npep;cTaBIITeJIII CIIOllpCKIIX MOHrOJIOIlAOB, II n03ToMY HX
aHTpOnOJIOl'Il"IeC:HIIM COCTaB He MOiKeT BOCXOP;IITb no npHMOll JIllHlllI K Heo-,
JIHTII"IeCKllM nonymID;IlHM IIpn6aMKaJIbH. To llie MOlliHO nOBToplITb II npo
OYPHT, HaCeJIHIOm.nx B HaCTOHm.ee BpeMH MHOI'HO paHoHhI IIpIIOaHItaJIbH.
OTplID;aHlIe HeOJIHTllqeCKIIX IICTOKOB 3TIlOI'eHeSa TeM oOJIee onpaBp;aHIlO B
AaHHOM CJIyqae, qTO OTAeJIbHbIe eBponeOHp;HbIe I'pynnbI npOlliImaJIII sAecb,
KaK II B TYBe. II B 3noxy cpep;HeBeKOBbH 17. XOTH' OHII IIMeJIH HeMeCTIloe
npOIICXOllip;eHlIe, OHII, eCTeCTBeHHO, P;OJIlliHbI OblJIH IIOBJIllfITb Ha CJIOllieHlle
aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOrO COCTaBa II KYJIbTYPHbIX ocooeHHOCTeM MeCTHoro HaCeJIe-
HllH. II 3TO OOCTOHTeJIbCTBO CBIIAeTeJIbCTByeT npOTllB Toro, "ITOObI 3THoreHe-
TlIqeCKne npOD;eCCbI B IIplIOaHKaJIbe saMbmaTb TOJIbKO Heo.lIHTlIqeCKOH 3no-
XOM. B 3aoaMHa.lIbe npeeMCTBeHHOCTh MOHrOJIOll,lIHoro KOMHJIeKCa npllSHaKOB,
.o;eHCTBHTeJIbHO npoc.lIellilIBaeTCH C anOXH HeOJIIITa AO COBpeMeHHOCTll, II KOM-
nJIeKC 3TOT He COAepllilIT HImaKoro CJIeAa eBponeollAHoIl nplIMecll. Ho OblJIo-
1
.
I
-
j
1
418
t
-
II
ObI RpaHHe OlipOMeT'IIIBO rrpOBOp;HTb rrpHMYIO JIHHHIO rrpeeMCTBeHHOCTII Mellip;y
neOJIIITII'IeCROH rrOrrYJIHD;neH, OCTamIBIIIeH $O<paHOBCRIIH MOrIIJIbHHR, II SaOaH-
RaJIbCRIIMH OYPHTaMII. RpaHIIOJIOrH'IeCIDIe rrpIISHaRII CRJIap;bmaIOTCH B OOOIIX
CJIY'IaHX B paSHble CO'IeTaHIIH, II CO'IeTaHIIe, XapaRTepHOe P;JIH SaOaHRaJIbCRHX
0YPHT, He OOHapYlliIIBaeT GOJIee paHIUIX aHaJIOrIIH, 'IeM ROMOIIHaD;IIH RpaHHO-
JIOrII'IeCRHX rrpIISHaROB, rrpep;CTaBJIennaH Y cpep;HeBeKOBbIX RO'IeBHIIROB 3a-
OaHRaJIbH 18. II B 3aOaHRaJIbe, CJIep;OBaTeJIbHO, MbI He HaXO;IJ;HM p;ORasa-
TeJIbCTB He TO.:n,RO HeOJIIITH'IeCROrO, HO II OOJIee rrosp;Hero, B 3rroxy 6pOHSbI
II paHHero meJIesa, reHeSIIca COBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH.
Yoep;HBJlIIICb, '11'0 HeOJIIITII'IeCROe HaCeJIeHIIe IIpIIOaIIRaJIbH He MOrJIO ObITb
OCHOBOII 3THoreHesa TYHrYCO-l\mHb'IlliypCIDIX Hapop;OB II IOKarnpOB, M.bI He
nCRJIIO'IaJIII, paSYMeeTCH, HeOJIIITII'IeCRHe rronYJIJI:L\IIH P;PyrHx TeppIITopHH.
qeperr HS IIIIIJIRIIHCROH rrem;epbI rJIaSROBCRoro BpeMeHII ObIJI p;IIarHOCTHpO-
BaH RaR rrpIIHap;JIelliam;IIii rrpep;CTaBHTeJIIO OaHRaJIbCROH paCbI l9 , H CeH'IaC
xapaRTepHOH JJ;JIH TYHrYCO-MaIlb'ImypOB H IORarHpOB. AHaJIOrII'IHYIO xapaR-
TepIICTIIRy rrOJIY'IHJI II 'Ieperr IIS rrem;epbI qOPTOBbI BopOTa B IIpIIMopbe 20.
B nepBOM CJIY'Iae pe'Ib IIp;eT 0 Haxop;Re 3rrOXH paHHeH OpOHS.bI, HO H TaRaH
p;peBHOCTb P;JIH 3THoreHeaa rrepe'IIICJIeHHbIX Hapop;OB BbITJIHP;IIT COMHHTeJIbHOH.
IIsY'IeHHe KpaHnOJIOrH'IeCRHX MaTepHaJIOB lIS MOX3CCRoro MOrIIJIbHHRa Y
C. TpOHD;Roro - rrepBbIX MaCCOBbIX rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRHX MaTepHaJIOB HS
TIpIIaMYPbH - nORaSaJIO, '11'0 p;allie 3TII rrosp;HHe rrJIeMeHa HeJIbSH paCCMaT-
pIIBaTb RaR OCHOBY CJIOllieHHH Toro IIJIH HHom lIS RopeHHbIX Hapop;OB AMYpa:
CBOHCTBeHHaH MOX3 ROM6HHaD;HH npHSHaROB HBJIHeTCH B TOH IIJIH HHOH CTe-
rreHH IICXOP;HOH P;JIH OpMllpOBaHIIH aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCROrO COCTaBa Bcex TYH-
rYCO-MaHb'IlliypCRIIX Hapop;OB oacceHHa AMypa 21. TaIDIM oopaSOM, OTJIH'IH-
TeJIbHbIe Mop<pOJIOrH'IeCRHe npHSHaRH Rallip;oro Hapop;a oopaSOBaJIHCb B OOJIee
rrosp;HOO BpeMH, T. e. B ROIID;e 1- Ha'IaJIe II TbICH'IeJIeTHH H. 3.
II
ii;
I[l
I;'
II:
BPEMH ROHKPETHLIX 3THOrEHE30B
HA CEBEPO-BOCTORE A3HII
M. r. JIemHI yoe,!J;IITeJIbHO p;OlmSaJI, '11'0 norrYJIHD;HH, OCTaBHBIIIIIe Y3JIeH-
CRIIH II 3RBeHCRIIH MOrIIJIbHIIRH, paCnOJIOllieHHbIe Ha TeppHTopIIII paCCeJIeHHH
'IYR'IeH II 3CRIIMOCOB, IIlIiIeJIII TOT me ROMrrJIeRC aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCRHX npHSHa-
ROB, '11'0 H COBpeMeHHoe HaCeJIeHHe qYROTCRoro rrOJIYOCTpOBa 22. Ha 3TOM
OCHOBaHIIII ObIJI Cp;eJIaH BliOJIHe crrpaBep;JIHBbIH BbIBOP; 0 TOM, '11'0 OpMHpO-
BaHIIe aHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCROrO COCTaBa 'IYR'IeH H 3CRIIMOCOB yllie SaROH'IIIJIOCb
R Pyoemy HOBOH 3pbI, ROTOpbIM p;aTIIPYIOTCH 3TH MOrHJIbHIIRH. IIocJIep;yIOm;He
HCCJIep;OBaHIIH nOp;TBep)IHJIH 31'01' BbIBOp; 23. Ho ep;HHH'IHbre Haxop;RH HeOJIH-
TII'IeCROro BpelliIeHII C 3TOH TeppIITopIIII yllie He 06HapYlliHBaIOT rrop;OOHOH
ROMOIIHaD;HH npIISHaROB, OrJIH'IaHCb RaRIIMH-TO rrpOTOMOp<pHbIMH OCOOeHHD-
CTHMH 2 . II B p;aHHOM CJIY'Iae MbI CTaJIRHBaeMCH, CJIep;OBareJIbHO, He C Heo-
JIIITII'IeCRHM liO BpeMeHH, a C OOJIee rrosp;HHM OpMIIpOBaHHeM OCHOBHbIX aHT-
pOrrOJIOrH'IeCRIIX rrpHSHaROB COBpeMeHHbIX Hapop;OB.
f
'
[
t
OB E 3ARJIIOTffiHIIE
B.bIIIIe He paCCMaTpIIBaJICH reHeSHC aHTpOnOJIOrH'IeCROrO THrra ReTOB, rIIJIH-
ROB, Hapop;OB RalliPJaTKII. Bce 3TH CJIY'IaII TpeOYIOT crreD;IIaJIbHOrO aHaJIHSa,
a rrpH nOJIHOM OTCYTcrBHII naJIeOaHrpOnOJIOrH'IeClmX p;aHHbIX peTpocrreRTHB-
HaH peROHCTpYRD;IIH He MomeT ObITb p;OCTarO'IHO y6ep;HreJIbHOH. Ho OOm;HH
BbIBOP; HS Bcero CRasaHHoro O'IeBIIp;eH: 0 HeOJIHTH'IeCROM rrepHop;e <pOpMHpO-
"BaHIIH aHTpOrrOJIOrH'IeCROrO COCTaBa rrOp;aBJIHIOm;erO 'IHCJIa RopeHHbIX Hapop;OB
419
14*
Cll6npll He npllXO ITcn rOBopllTb, ero OpMllpOBaHlle npllXO llTCH Ha ROHe
I TbICfPIeJIeTIUI o H. 3. - I II naqaJIO II TbICHqeJIeTHH H. 3. ECTb Bce OCHO-
BaHllH YMaTb, qTO 3THoreHes COBpeJ\oIeHHbIX HapO OB Cn6npll aTIIpyeTcH
rrpeIIJ\olym;ecTBeHHO TeM me OTpeSROM BpeMeHII.
t l1.e6elf r. (jj., JIeeun M. r., TporfiuMoea T. A. AHTpolloJIorIIqecKHii: MaTepHaJI RaK'
IICTOqHIIR II3yqeHHH BOllpOCOB 3THoreHe3a I I COB. 9THorpaqHIH. 1952. M 1.
2 OK.liaOnUlWe A. n. HeOJIHTllqeCKlIe naMHTHllKH KaR llCTOqHHKll 110 9THorOHHll CHOHpH
H ,l],aJII,HerO BocToKa II KpaT. COOom. MH-Ta HCTOpHH J'>IaTepllaJIbHOii KYJIbTYPbI. 1941.
BLm.9.
3 Ruce.we C. B. ,l],peBHJUI HCTOpHH IOlliHOll CHOHpll. M., 1951; RblB.liacoe JI. P. TalII-
TbIKCKaH 9110xa B UCTOpllH XaKaccKo-MHHYCllHCKOll KOTJIOBHHbI. M., 1960.
l1.e6elf r. (jj. IIaJIeoaHTpolloJIorHH CCCP. M.; JI., 1948. (Tp. IIH-Ta 9THorpa4>IlH AH
CCCP. H. C.; T. 4); A.lieKCeee B. n. IIaJIeoaHTpolloJIorHH XaKacHH 9110XII llie.TIe3a.
M.; JI., 1960. II C6. MY3eH aHTpOIlOJIOrHll .II 9THorpa4>IIII AH CCCP; T. 20.
5 l1.epeeRnKO E. H. IIJIeMeHa IIpHaMYPbH I TbICHqeJIeTIIH Hamell 9pbI: (OqepRH 9TH II-
qecKoii HCTOpHH II KYJIbTYPbI). HOBocHoHpcK, 1981; CM. TaKllie: A.lieKCeee B. n.
MaTepIIaJIbI 110 KpaHIIOJIOrIIll MOX9 II l1aJIeOaHTpOIlOJIOrHH CHOHpII. M., 1980.
6 OK.liaOnUKOe A. n. K H3Y'IeHHIO HaqaJIbHbIX 9TanOB 4>opMHpoBaHHH HapOi.\OB CllOHpII:
(HaceJIeHlIe IIpHoaiiKaJIbH n HeOJIHTe II paHHeJ'>I OpoH30BmI BeRe) II COB. 9THorpa-
4>IIH. 1950. M 2; On :HCe. HeOJIllT II 6pOH30Bblif HeR IIpllOaiiKaJIbH. M.; JI., 1950-
1955. 1.[. 1-3. (MaTepHaJibI II llCCJIe));OBaHHH 110 apXeOJIOrHH CCCP; M 18, 43).
7 JIeeun M. r. 8THHqeCKaH aHTpOnOJIOrHJI H npOOJIeMbI 9THoreHe3a HapO));OB ,l],aJIbHen»
BocToKa. M., 1958. II Tp. MH-Ta 9THorpa4>Hll AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 36.
8 PW-lKOe 10. r. HeKOTopble nOIlYJIHl\HOHHO-reHeTHqeCKlle 1I0p,XOp,bI K aHTpOIlOJIOrllH CH-
OIIPH II BOllp. aHTpOnOJIOrHll. 1969. BbIII. 33; Pbl'IKOe 10. r., MoececRn A. A. reHe-
THKo-aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKHii aHaJIH3 paCllpe));eJIeHIIH aHOJ'>IaJIllii qepena Y MOHrOJIOH));OB-
CHOllpll B CBH311 C npooJIeMoii HX IIpOHCXOllip,eHHH 111.[eJIoBeK. 8BOJIIOl\IIH H BHYTPH-
BHp,OBaH ),w4>4>epeHl\Hal\HH. M., 1972.
9 Tporfiu.Moea T. A., TJe6oKcapoe H. H. CeBepoypaJIbCKaH 9KCne));Hl\HH MY3eH aHTpOIlO-
JIOrHH II KpaT. cooom. MH-Ta II MY3eH aHTpOIlOJIOrHH IIPH Mr¥ 3a 1938-1939 rr.
M., 1941.
to l1.e6elf r. (jj. CeJIbKynbI: (AHTpolloJi. OqepK). M.; JI., 1947. (Tp. HH-Ta 9THorpa4>IlH
AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 2); A.lieKCeee B. n. JIecHble HeHl\bI (coMaTOJIorJI'IeCKHe HaOJlIO-
));eHHH) II Bonp. aHTpOIlOJIOrHH. 1971. BbIII. 39; 3o.liorapeea H. M. AHTpOIlOJIOrllH He-
KOTOpblX HapO));OB CeBepHoii CHOllpH II IOKarHpbI: (MCT.-9THorp. OqepK). HOBOCllOIIpCK,
1975.
11 l1.peMoe B. A. AHTpolloJIorHH BepxHero IIpHoobH B 9110XH HeOJIHTa II. OpOH3bI. M.
1981.
12 00 9TOM CM.: noranoe JI. n. KpaTKIIe OqepKII HCTOpHH II 9THorpa4>IlH xaKaCOB
(XVII-XIX BB.). AoaKaH, 1952; On :HCe. IIpoHcxolli));eHHe H 4>opMHpoBaHHe xaKac-
CROll HapO));HOCTH. AoaKaH, 1957.
t;. A.lieKCeee B. n. II03p;HHe KOqeBHHKH KY3Hel\KOll KOTJIOBHHbI 110 p;aHHbIM lIaJIeOaHTpo-
1I0JIOrHH II KpaT. cooom. MH-Ta 9THorpa4>HH AH CCCP. 1960. Bbill. 35; On :HCe.
K Cpe));HeBeROBoll naJIeOaHTpOIlOJIOrHII KY3Hel\KOll KOTJIOBllHbI II M3B. JIa6. apxeOJI.
HCCJIep;. KeMepoBo, 1974. Bbill. 5.
H rox.Man H. H. IIpOllcxolli):\eHHe l\eHTpaJIbHOa3HaTcKoll paCbI B CBeTe HOBbIX lIaJIeOaH-
TpOIIOJIOrIIqeCI{HX J'>IaTepHaJIOB II MCCJIep;OBaHHH 110 lIaJIeOaHTpOIIO.1orllH H KPaHllOJIOr.IIII.
CCCP. JI., 1980. (Co. MY3eH aHTpOIlOJIOrHll II 9THorpa4>H.II AH CCCP; BbIII. 36).
t3 A.lieKCeee B. n. 1.[epena H3 MYCYJIbMaHCKHX norpeoeHHll B TYBe II ¥qeH. 3an. TYBHH.
Hayq.-HCCJIe));. HH-Ta H3blKa, JIHTepaTypbI II HCTOpllll. KbI3bIJI, 1960. Bbill. 8.
16 repacu.Moea M. M. KpaHHOJIOrHqeCKIIll MaTepHaJi H3 MOrHJIbHHKa lIlYMHJIHxa (lIpe));-
BapHTeJIbHble p;aHHbIe) II EpOH30Bblii BeK IIpHaHrapbH: MorIIJIbHHK lIlYMllJIHxa. I1.p-
KYTCK, 1981.
n rOXMan If. H. Cpe));Hea3IIaTcKaH KOJIOHHH B IIpllOaiiKaJIbe II IIpOOJIeMbi aHTpOIlOJIO-
rHH H .IICTopn:qecKoll 9THorpa4>IlH A3HH. M., 1968,
18 MaMonoea H. H. KOqeBHllKII 3aoai'maJIbH IX-XIII BB. 110 ));aHHbIM lIaJIeOaHTpOIlOJIO-
rHH/I AHTponoJIorHqecKHll COOpHHK, III. M., 1961. (Tp. I1.H-Ta 9THorpa4>HH AH
CCCP. H. C.; T. 21).
19 JIeeun M. r. ,l],peBHHii qepell C peKH lIlHJIKH II KpaT. COOom. JiIH-Ta 9THorpa4>HH AH
CCCP. 1953. BbIII. 18.
2') Ba.liyeea T. C. KpaHHOJIOrn:qecKHii MaTepHaJI HeOJIHTHqeCKOrO CJIOH lIemepbI «1.[op-
TOBbi BopoTa>} (IIpHMopbe) II Bonp. aHTpOnOJIOrHH. 1978. Bbill. 58.
21 A.lieKCeee B. n. MaTepHaJIbl no KpaHHOJIOrHH MOX9.
1
1
'.j
.1
j
,
420
f ' , '"
,',
,
2" JIeeuH M. r. 06 aHTpOIIOJIOfI-lqeCROM TI-Ille peBHIIx 3CRI-I'lfOCOB II COBpeMeHHaH aHTpo-
IIOJIOfI-lH. M., 1964. (Tp. MocK. O-Ba I-IcrrblraTe.rreii rrpI-lpoJ(bI; T. 24).
23 l1.e6elf r. $. IIaJIeoaHTporrOJIOfI-lqeCKI-Ie ?IaTepI-laJIbI H3 peBHe6epIIIlfm!OpCRHX 10-
rI-lJIbHI-IKOB Y3JIeH I-I 8Kll3H II Ap YT/OHOe C, A., Cepeeee l1.. A IIp06JIe1\lbI 3THH'IeCROH
I-ICTOpI-lI-l EepI-lHfOMOpbH: (8K,J3eHCRIIH ;\IOfHiIbHIIR). M., 1975.
2 roxJ.t.an H. H. ,l],peBHI-III qepen C qYKOTKH II 3arr. qYKOT. KpaeBe));. 1\IY3en. Mafa aH,
1961. BbIlI. 2; JIe6eouncKaR r. B. IIpol.\ecc BOCCTaHOBJIeHI-IH rOJIOBbI no qeperry I-I3
YCTb-Ec.:IbCKOfO MOfI-lJIbHIfRa/lTallI n:w; rOXJnan Ii. 11" TOM7'OCOea JI, $, 0 BpellIeHI-I
4>opMI-IpOBaHI-IH apKTHqeCKOH pacbI II RpaTKoe cop,epmaHI-Ie l\ORJIap,OB HayqHOH cec-
CHI-I, rrOCBHJI:\eHHOH OCHOBHbIM HTOfa1\l pa60TbI B p,ecHToH IIHTI-IJIeTKe. JI., 1983.
--
f,.
r
l
M3YQEHME MOp O OrMQECRMX OCOEEHHOCTEfi
AMEPMRAHCRMX MH EnQEB
M TIPOEJIEMA 3ACEJIEHMJI AMEPMRM
.
HCTOPHqECRAH PETPOCIIERTHBA
"
Cpe)J,II lIUIOrO"lIICJIeHIIbIX nIl10T8S SaCeJIeHIIH AMepIII\II )1,0 CIIX IIOp H811IaJIOe
MeCTO SaHIIlIIaIOT TeopIIII IIOHBJIeHIIH SIIa"lIITeJIbHbIX Macc JIIO)J,eM lIS EBpUIIhI
H OKeaHIIII. ABTOp He 6Y)J,8T B )J,aJIbHeMllieM IIS.rrOi1\eHIIII KacaTbCH 3TIIX rII-
nOTes, TaK KaK C"lIITaeT aHTpOnOJIOrII"lecKyIO aprYMeHTaII;IIIO B [IX nOJIbSY
HBHO He)J,OCTaTO"lHOM. :ho He OSHa"la8T, "lTO Bce 6es IICKJIIO"leHHH rpY:IIJlbJ
JIIOJWM npOHIIKaJlII B AMeplIKY "lepes 06JIaCTb BeplIHroBa UpOJIIIBa, HO nuq e
anII30)J,II"leCKHe npOHIIKHOBeHIIH He OCTdBIIJIII OIII;YTIIMoro CJIe)J,a B )J,OCTYIIHbIX
HaM )J,aHHbIX II n03TOMY He MorYT 06CYlli)J,aTbCH HaY"lHO. 3aCeJIeHIIe AMepII
RaHCKoro KOHTIIHeHTa lIS CeBepHOM ASHII - e)J,IIHCl'BeHHaH rImOTeSa, Haxo-
p;HIII;aH peaJIbIIOe <paKTII"leCKOe nO)J,TBeplli)J,eHIIe, II OHa COCTaBJIHeT OCHOBY
HallIlIX BSrJIH)J,OB Ha np06.rreMY npOIICXOllip;eHIIH aMeplIKaHCKoro 'leJIOBeKa.
-y IICTOKOB COBp8MeHHbIX npe)J,CTaBJIeHIIM 0 sace.TIeHIIII AMepIIKII 'leJIOR&-
KOM II reHeSHce aHTpOnOJIOrII"leCKIIX oc06eHHOCTeM KopeHHoro HaCeJI8HIUl
AMeplIKaHCKoro MaTeplIKa CIOHT TPII BbI)J,aIOIII;IIXCH IICCJIe)J,OBaTeJIH, BHeCIUIIe
HeOII;eHHMbIM BKJIa)J, B HaKOIIJIeHIIe COOTBeTCTBYIOIII;nx <paKTII'leCKIIX )J,aHIIbIK
H HK IIHTepnpeTaII;IIIO. o'D;1HI lIS HIIX, pa60TaBlllIIII HeCKOJIbKO paI-ree )J,PyrlIx,-
A. Xp)1,JIII'lKa B npoII;ecce MHOrOJIeTHeII O'leHb aKTIIBHoiI 3KCIIe)J,IIII;HOHHOM p;eR-
TeJIbHOCTII c06paJI orpOMHbIll aHTponOMeTplI'leCKIIM lIIaTepHaJI, a TaKllie IISY,..
'I.lIIJI 60raTbIe KpaHIIOJIOrII'l8CKIIe c06paHIIH MyseeB CIIIA, B KOTOpliIX npe -
CTaBJIeHbI KOJIJIeKII;IIII 'lepeIIOn lwpCHHoro HdCeJIeHIIH. Ero IISBeCTHhfe
RaTaJIOrH RpaHIIOJIOrlI'leCI\HX KOJIJIeKII;HM pasHbIx MyseeB CIIIA )J,O CHX IIOp
CJIylliaT HeOII;eHIIMbIM IICTO"lIUnWM IIHwopMaII;HII 0 KpaHlIOJIOrH'leCKIIX HapHat-
U;IIHX a60pIIreHHblx IIHp;eiicKIIx nonYJIHII;rriI 1. -:t
JJ:pyroM - COBeTCKIIM IICCJIep;OBaTeJIb r. «1>. JJ:e6eII; 6liIJI mIOHepOM B IIS-
Y'leIUIH COMaTOJIOrHII 'lYK'leM II aSHaTCKIIX 3CKIIMOCOB II. nO)J,06Ho TOMY KaR
A. Xp)1,JIII'lKa OIIHca.TI KpaHIIO.rrorII'leCKIIe oc06eHIIocTII HH)J,eMII;eB H 3CKIIMOCOB
AJIHCKII, BBeJI B HaY'lHbIM 060POT 06UIIIpHbIe p;aHHble no KpaHIIOJIOrHII a6o-
pIIreHHbIx rronymIII;IIM CH6npII ".
TpeTIIM, TOllie cOBeTcKIIM IICCJIe)J,oBaT8.JIb, - M. r. JIeBIIH BIrepBbIe 1'l8
ypoBHe MeTo)J,JI'leCKHX Tpe60naHIIM conpellIeIllroii aHTpOrrOJIOrlI'leCKOM HaYKD
OnIICaJI 'leperra "lYK"leM II aanaTCKHX 3CKIIMOCOB \ rJIy60KHMII TeOpeTII'leCKH-
Mil paspa60TKaMII II c06paHIlbIMII IIM caMIIM opnrlIHaJIbHbIMII )J,aHHbIMII 060-
raTIIJI Haum npe)J,CTaBJIeHIIH 06 3THoreHese HapO)J,OB JJ:aJIbHerO BocToKa \
nepBbIM c06paJI p;aHHbIe 0 rpyrrnax KpOBII y KopeHIIbIX Hapop;OB ceBepo-Bo-
CTOKa ASIIII 5 II 6bIJI SaMe'laTeJIbHbIM IIHTepnpeTaTopOM HCTOpHKO-3THOJIOrH'le
CKOM IIH<popMaU;HH 0 npOllIJIOM 3TIIX Hapop;OB.
421
-
KaKIIe np06.rreMbI CTaBIIJUlCb II pelliaJIIICb B Tpy;-WX aTIIX BbIp;aIOID;IIXCH
IICCJIen;OBaTeJIen, qTO BbIAepllia.JO npoBepKy BpeMeHeJ\I II BOlliJIO B q,OHP; CO-
BpeMeHHoII HayKII, a qTO YCTapeJIO II HYllip;aeTCH B KoppeKTIIBax? A. Xp.a;-
JIIIqKa BIIp;eJI B aMepIIKaHCKIIX IIHp;en ax TOJIbKO MOHrOJIOIIp;OB, He rrpIIAaBaH
60JIblliOrO SHaqeHIIH IIX l\lOpq,OJIOrIPIeCKIIM OTJIIIqIIHl\l OT aSIIaTCKIIX l\lOIITO-
lIOIIP;HbIX nonYJIH IIn, a 'faK KaK HaII60JIee KJIaCCIIqeCKIIe npep;CTaBIITeJIII
MOHrOJIOIIAHOn paCbI HaCeJIHIOT CeBepHYIO ASIIIO, TO, no ero MHeHIlIO, TeppII-
TOpIIH AMepHKII 6bwa SaCeJIeHa qeJIOBeKOl\l IIMeHHO lIS CeBepHon ASIIII 6.
e aTon eJIbIO A. Xp.a;JIIIqKa nOCJIe npe6bIBaHIUJ B COBeTCKOM COIOse rrepe)];
BeJIIIKOn OTeqeCTBeHHon BO:ri:HOM II o6pa6oTKII KpaHIIOJIOrIIqeCI\IIX MaTepIIa
JIOB no p;peBnel\ly HaCeJIeHIlIO CII6IIpII CneTwaJIbHO aprYl\leHTIIpOBaJI l\lOpq,OJIO-
rII'IeCKOe CXOP;CTBO l\lelliP;y HIIl\l II ceBepOal\lepIIKaHCKIIl\III IIH,!J;eIICKIIl\lII nony-
JIH IIHMII 7. 3Ta rIInOTesa 0 CXOACTBe al\lepIIKaHOII,!J;OB II ,!J;peBIIIIX aSIIRTCKIIX
MOHrOJIOIIp;OB II SaCeJIeHIIII AMepIIKH lIS CII6IIpII npIIo6peJIa 60JIbillYIO nony-
JIHpHOCTb B JIIITepaType II AO CIIX nop IIMeeT CTOpOHHIIKOB. Ee aKTIIBHbIM
saID;HTHIIKOM 6bW nOKoMHbIM aRap;el\lIIK A. IT. Olmap;HIIKOB 8, CeIlqaC ee sa-
JJ:{HID;aeT IISBeCTHbIM al\lepImaHCKIIII aHTpOnOJIOr II apxeoJIor, SHaTOK KYJIbTypLI
II npOillJIOrO aJIeYToB Y. JIaq,JIHH. O,!J;IIa lIS ero CTaTen TaK II HaqIIHaeTCH:
«llepBbIMII JKIITeJIHMII Al\lepHRII 6bIJIII CII6IIpHRII» 9.
Op;HaKO, KaK nOKaSaJIH p;aJIbHeMlliIIe IICCJIep;OBamm, nOAo6HIJIii BapIIaHT
I'IDIOTeSbI aSIIaTCKoro rrpoIIcxolliAeHIIH KopeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH AMepIIRII 6bIJI He
muneH CJIa60cTen. ITporpaMMa IIsMepelmn, KOTOpyIO IICnOJIbSOBaJI A. XPA-
JIlI'lRa B CBOIIX pa6oTax, 6bIJIa OqeHb KpaTKoii: II OCTaBJIHJIa 6es BHITl\IaHIIH
MHorIIe BalliHble npHsHaRII, AIIq,q,epeHI{IIpYIOID;IIe aMepIIRaHoIIAoB II aSlfaT-
CRIIX MOHrOJIOHp;oB. B rrepBYIO Oqepep;b peqb ,!J;OJIlliHa IIJJ;TII B :3TOM CBHSII 0
BbICTynaHIIII Hoca II ynJIOID;eHHOcTII JIII a B ropIISOHTaJIbHOII nJIOCKOCTII:
aMepIIKaHcKIIe IIHp;eII bI, KaR II eBponeoII,!J;bI, OTJIIIqaIOTCH BblcTynaIOID;IIl\l HO-
COM IT KaK 6YATO p;OBOJIbnO CHJIbHO npoq,HJIIIpOBaHHbIl\l JIII OM, cH6IIpCKIIe
MOHrOJIOIIAbI - npOTHBOrrOJIOlliHhIl\l COqeTaHIIeM npIISHaKOB. B KaRon-TO Mepe
onIIpaHCb Ha BIIsyaJIbI-ryIO 0l.\errKY aTIIX OC06eHI-IOCTeM, A. XPAJIIlqRa rrpIIilleJI
R IIAec l\IOpq,OJIOrIIqeCKOrO CXOP;CTBil ApeBHero IWCeJIeHHH IOlliHon CII6IIpII II
COBpeMeHHhIX aMepIIKaHCKHX IIHAeM eB, B qel\l OH BIIAeJI aprYMeHT B nOJIbSY
IIX reneTIIqeCROI'O pO,lICTBa. 3Ta aHaJIOrIIH BbISBaJIa nOJIeMIIRy, II r. <1>. l1,-e-
6eI{ BblcTynIIJI CO Cne HaJIbHOn CTaTbeM 10, B KOTOpOM Ha OCHOBe IISl\lepeHIIn
ropIISOHTaJIhHOrO JIH eBOro npoq,IIJIH AOKaSaJI npIIHap;JIerKHOCTb ApeBHIIX no-
nyJIJII{Hn IOlliHOM CII6IIPII K eBponeOIIAHon, a He R MOHroJIOIIAHOM pace II,
CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, OTCYTCTBIIe reHeTIIqeCKOII npeeMCTBeHHOCTII l\lellip;y HIIMII II
aMepllRaHCKHMII IIHJJ;eM aMII. Ho TOqnaH l\leTpIIqeCKaH xapaKTepHCTIIKa JIII e-
BOl'O npoq,IIJIH nOCJIep;HHX He MOrJIa HanTII MeCTa B ero pa60Te lIs-sa OTCYT-
CTBIIH cooTBeTCTBYIOID;IIX KOJIJIeK IIn B COBeTCKIIX MyseHx.
KpoMe aTIIX OqeHb o6ID;IIX cpaBHeHIIM q,IISIIqeCKIIX ocooeIIHocTen aMepII-
RaHCKIIX IIHAen eB II npeACTaBHTeJIeM APyrIIx pac, aHTpOnOJIOrII'IeCKIIIT Ma-
TepIIaJI nOSBOJIIIJI KOCHYTbCH II 60JIee qaCTHbIX aTHoreHeTIIqeCKIIX BonpocoB,
B qaCTHOCTH pOJ(cTBa IIHp;en eB II aCKIIMOCOB. I1sBecTHbIM aMepIIRaHCKIIH
aTHOJIOr <1>. Boac II pa60TaBlliHe C HIIl\l IICCJIep;OBaTeJIII BbIP;BIIHYJIII, RaR IIS-
BeCTHO. B HaqaJIe BeRa ITp;eIO TaK HaSbIBaeMoro aCKIIMOCCKoro KJIIIHa, CorJIac-
HO KOTopon aCKIIl\lOCbI KaR ObI paCCeKJIII en;IIHbln B npOlliJIOl\l apeaJI KopeHHbIX
Hapop;oB CII6IIPII II al\lepIIKaHcKIIx IIHp;en eB, BABIII-ryBlliIICb B cepe.a;IIHY aToro
apeaJIa c ceBepa. JII06onbITHo OTl\leTHTb OP;HO MeTOp;IIqeCROe 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO,
cblrpaBlliee HB nepBblx nopax SHaqIITeJIbI-ryIO pOJIb B YTBepllip;eHIIII aTon IIp;eII.
AMepIIKaHCKIIe aTHOJIOrII pa60TaJIII cpep;II aCKIIMOCOB, IIl\leH B KaqeCTBe Mac-
illTa6a o eH1{II IIX KYJIbTyphI II q,IISIIqeCKIIX oco6eHHOCTen KYJIbTYPY II q,II3II-
qeCKIIM TIm IIHp;eM eB: HCHO, qTO aCRIIMOCbI C IIX q,IISIIqeCKlIM II KYJIbTYPHbIM
.
,1
j
"
422
f
,J
(
CBDeDopasueM )J,OJImHbI ObIJIU KaSaTbCH CDBepIIIeHHD IUlOpD)J,HbIM TeJIDM Ha
TeppUTo.pUU CeBepHDH AMepUKU. PYCCKIIe UCCJIe.a;DBaTeJIII UlIiIeJIII IIpU BSrJIH-
}J;e Ha 3CKUMDCDB IIHDH MaCIIITao Du;eHKU - <pII3IIqeCKIIe DCDoeHHDCTU II KYJIb-
TyPY KDpeHHbIX HapD)J,DB CHOUPU; U B 3TOM CJIyrrae 8CKUMDCbI RaSaJIIICb
qym)J,bIM BRJIKPIeHUeM B CpaBlIJITeJIbHD D)J,HDpD)J,HbIii 3THurreCRUH U aHTpUIID-
JIOrIIqeCKIIH lIiIaCCUB. TaKIU\I D6paSDM, IICXD)J,H US paSHbIX Ou;eHDqHbIX MepDR,
II aMepURaHCRIIe U pyccRue UCCJIe)J,DBaTeJIH nDCTYJIITpDBaJIU UCRJIIDqUTeJIbHDe
CBDeDopaSIIe 3CKUMDCDB, qTD II DOeCneqIIJID rIInDT€Se 3CKIIMDCCRDrD RJIUH3
nDnyJIHpHDCTb Ha npDTHmeHIIH HeCRDJIbRUX }J;eCHTIIJIeTIIH.
I1CTDPUKD-KYJIbTYPHliIe - apXeDJIDrUqeCRIIe U 3TIIDJIDrUqeCKIIe DCHDBaHUH
'3TDR rIIIIDTeSbl ObIJIIT paSDopaHbl A. M. 3DJIDTapeBbIM 11, yoe)J,UTeJIbIID nDRa-
saBIIIIIM, qTD CBDeDopaSIIe RYJIbTypliI 3CInIMDCOB u;eJIHIi:DM D6'bHCHHeTCH aRTIIB-
IIbIM npUCnDCDOJIeHneM R CYPDBbIM YCJIOBUHM B a3IIaTCRDH II aMepImanCKOH
ApRTIme, r)J,e CYIII;eCTBDBaHue lIeIlDSMDmHD oes DXUTbI Ha MDpCRorD SBepH-
RUTDB U MDpmeH, a OXDTa 3Ta TpeODBaJIa KyJIbTYPIIbIX HaBbmDB U ITSOOpeTe-
IIIIH, HeSHaRDMbIX }J;PYrIIM HapD)J,aM. qTD me RacaeTCH CBDeDopaSUH aHTponD-
JIDrIIqeCRDrD OOJIURa 3CRUMDCDB, 'I'D DHD BuepBbIe ObIJIU DO'beKTUBHO pacnWT-
peHD B CDDTHeceHUII C rImUTe;30H 8CKIIMDCCRDrD RJIUHa M. r. JIemIHbIM lIa
DCHDBe RpaHIIDJIDrIIqeCRDrD cpaBHeHIIH C CUOUPCRUMU MDHTDJIOII}J;aMII 12.
RpaHUDJIDrUqeCRDe CDIIDCTaBJIeHIIe B DTJIIIqUe 0.'1' CTpoeHIIH MHrRIIX TRaHeH
JIIIu;a Y HbIHe mIIByIIJ.UX HapD)J,DB, }J;JIH Du;eUKII RDTDpDrD nDRa He paspaODTa-
HD IIDJIHDCTbID CBDOD)J,HbIX 0.'1' CYO'beRTIIBHDCTII lIiIeTD}J;DB, )J,DnYCRaeT TDqIIyID
RDJIIIqeCTBeIIHYID Du;eIIKy Ha6JIIO}J;aeMbIX pasJIIPIITii, a CHell BMeCTe IT }J;DCTa-
TDqHO nDJIIIYIO DO'beRTIIBHDCTb BbIBD)J,DB. M. r. JIemIH yoe}J;UTeJIbHD UPD-
}J;eMDHCTpIIpDBaJI SHaqUTeJIbHDe MDP<PDJIDrIIqeCRDe CXDL(CTBD 3CRUMDCDB C
RDpeHHbIMII CUOUPCRIIMIT HapD}J;aMII BD MHDrux BamHbIX npUSHaRax II, CJIe}J;D-
BaTeJIbHD, HeCOCTOHTeJIbHOCTL runDTeSIiI 3CRUMDCCRDrD R.:IIIUa, eCJIII lIiIOif',HO
TaR BbIpaSUTbCH, nD)J, asuaTCKIIM yrJIDM speHIIH. HDsme 8'1'0. ObIJID nD}J;TBepm-
}J;eHD Ha DCHDBe OOJIee nDJIHbIX L(aHHbIX r. «1>. Aeoen;DM 13. OHII me DIIIICaJIH
II nepBbIH RpaHIIOJIDrUqeCRUH MaTepUaJI us )J,peBHUX 3CRUMDCCRITX MDrIIJIbHU-
RDB pyoema HDBOH 8PbI, rrDSBD.TIUBIIHIII YTBepm}J;aTL, qTD xapaKTepHbIe OCD-
OeHHDCTII <pIISUqeCRDrD TIma 3CRUMDCDB yme nDJIHDCTbID C<pDpMupDBaJIUCb
}J;Ba TbICHqeJIeTIUI nasa}J; 14.
I1TaR, mIITeJleH caMbIX ceBepHbIX paIIOHDB AMepURaHCRDrD RDHTUlIeH-
Ta - 3CRUMDCDB MDmHD, oeccnOpIID, CqUTaTb HapD)J,DM aSlIaTCRDrD npDITCXDiI-\-
}J;eHIIH, II saCeJIUJIH UX npe,,-\RII TeppIITDpHIO CBDerD HbIHeIIIHerD DOUTaHIIH He
c ceBepa, RaR CqUTaJIU CTDPDHUIIKU TIIIIDTeSbI 8CRUJ\lOCCRDrD KJIIIHa ( DTRY)J,a
C ceBepa - DCT3B3JIDCb ueHCHbIM, TaR RaR Ha ceBep 0.'1' qYRDTRU, AJIHCRH II
DCTpDBDB R3Ha}J;1iI paCIIDJI3raIOTCH JIIIIIIb JIe)J,HHbIe TDpDCbI II DTRpbITbIe BDJ(bI
CeBepHDrD JIe)J,UIIIITDrD ORemm), a C IOra, B)J,O,lIb TnXDOReaHCRDrD IIDoepembH
ASHII. 00 3TDM I'DBDPHT MHDrDqlICJIeHHbIe KYJIbTYPHbIe aHaJIDrIlU, DO 3TDM me
rDBDpHT II HeRDTDpbIe aHTpDIIDJIDrUqeCRIIe DCDoeHUDCTII, HaIIpUMep DTHDCII-
TeJIbHaH TeMHORDmeCTb, KDTopaH He MOrJIa C<PDpMIIpDBaTbCH B YCJIDBIIHX
ApRTITRII H CBUL(eTeJIbCTByeT DO USUaqaJIbHbIX )J,peBHHX RDHTaRTax C ODJIee
IDmHbIlIiHI HapD)J,aMII. Ho asuaTCRue, B qaCTHDCTU H ceBepDa3uaTcRue, arraJID-
rIIII B KYJIbType IT <pHsurrecKux Dco6eHHocTHX aMepITRaHCRITX I1H)J,eHu;eB 1'0.-
pas]J;D MeHee )J,eMoHcTpaTIIIJHbI, qeM y 3CIUIMDCDB. II IIDaTDMY rIlIIDTesa I1X
33ITaTCRDrD npOIICXDm)J,eHIIH B TpaRTDBRe A. XP]J;JIIIqRII, RaR MbI IIDMHUM III'[-
caBIIIero 0. IIpHMDM pD]J;CTBe aODpureHDB CUOUPH II IIH]J;eiiu;eB AMepUKII, He
MDmeT OIiITb CeHqaC IIDJIHDCTbID IIpIIIUITa.
t,
t
j,
r
,
I
423
,
[,
COMA TOJIOrHqECKOE COIIOCT ABJIEHHE
3CKHMOCOB H AMEPHKAHCKHX HH)),EIIn;EB
fipM cpparlliIeHTapHOCTIl naJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrII"leCKIIX MaTepIIaJIOB M3 1I0CTO"lIIbIX
imHoHoB CeBepHoH A3IIII, lJ,eHTpaJIbHOH M BOCTO"lHOH A3IIII, ooeIIx AMepMK,
npIIroAHblx JIMIllb' AJIH O"leIIb OOru;MX 3aIWIO"leHIIH, HaIIoo bIllee 3IIa"leHMe B
paccMoTpeHIIII MHTepecyroru;eH Hac TeMbI IIpMoopeTaeT COIIOCTaBJIeHIIe aHTpo-
.IIOJIOnl"leCKIlX xapaKTepIICTIm COBpeMeHHbIX IIorryJIHD;IIH. TpII rpYIIIIbI AaHHbIX
MoryT 6bITb MOOUJIII30BaHbI AJIH STOH D;eJIIl: MopcpOJIOrII"leCKIIe AaHHbIe no
COBpelliIeHHbIM rpYIInaM (IIlIiIeIOTCH B BIlAY B nepBYIO O'Iepe.D:b BapIIaD;IIII MHr-
KIIX TKaHeH JIIlD;a), KpaHIIOMeTpp:lJeCKIIe BapIIaD;IIII M HaOJIIO.D:enHH HaA reo-
rpacpII"leCKIIM pacupe.D:eJIeHIIeM reHHbIX lJaCTOT B cOBpeMeHHblx IIOIIYJIHD;HHX.
E nepBoM cJIY"lae pe'Ib IIrreT 0 conOCTaBJIeHIIII npII3HaKoB, KaK yiKe rOBO-
j)HJIOCb, B lIiIeTO.D:II"leCROM OTHOIlleHHII cpImcIIpyeMblx He.D:OCTaTO"lHO OO'beKTHB-
EO II nOSTOMY nJIOXO cpaBIIIIMbIX, ocooeHHO B CJIY"lae paCCMOTpeHHH aMepH-
KaHCKIIX II COBeTCKIlX .D:aIIIIbIX, B OOOIIX .D:PyrIIx CJIY"laHX MeT0.D:II"leCIUIe pa3-
JIIIlJIUI OTCYTCTByIOT IIJIIl 'TeTKO orOBopeHbI, nosToMy pe3YJIbTaTbI HOCHT OOJIee
% pOrIIH xapaKTep.
I13 BHeIllHIIX OC06eHHQCTeH, pa3JIH"laIOru;IIX a3HaTCKIIX MOHrOJIOIl.D:OB H
RMepIIKaHCKHX IIH.D:eHD;eB, HaIIOOJIbIllee BHIlMaHIIe B CTapOH JIInepaType ObIJIO
YAe eHO D;Bery KOiKII: a3IIaTCKIIe MOHrOJIOIl.D:bI Ha3bIBaJIHCb iKeJITOKOiKIIMII,
,HHAeHD;bI - KpaCHOKOiKIIMII. HImaKIlMH TO"lHbIMII HaOJIIO.D:eHHHMH STO pa3JIII-
'IRe He IIOgTBepJI\.D:aeTCH H OCTaeTCH Ha COBeCTIl nYTeIlleCTBeHHImOBII pOMa-
HHCTOB. Be3YCJIOBHO COOTBeTcTByeT peaJILHOH geHCTBIITeJIbHOCTII gpyroe
MopcpOJIOnl'IeCKOe pa3JIII"lIIe - CTeneHb BbIpaiKeHHOCTH ::mIIKaHTyca, CTOJIb
xapaHTepHoro gJIH a3IIaTCKHx MOHrOJIOIlgOB. IIIIIpOKO pacnpOCTpaHeHHoe,
oc06eHHO B IIonYJIHpHOii STHorpacpII"leCKOIl JIHTeparype, YTBepiKAeHIle 00 01'-
f;YTCTBIIH SIIIIKaHTyca y aMepIIKaHCKIIX IIHgeIlD;eB, CTporo rOBopH, HeBepHO-
OH npnCYTCTByeT, HO B O'leHb HeOOJIbIIIOM npOD;eHTe CJIY'laeB. ITpeACTaBJIeHIIe
o .D:0cTynHblx gaIIHbIX .D:aeT rreOOJIbIllaH cpaBHHTeJIbHaH TaOJIIID;a (TaOJI. 44),
YMMIIpyIOru;aH Ha6JIIOAeHHH aMepIIKaHCKIIX II COBeTCRIIX aBTopOB. HCHo, '11'0
Ta6mm;a 44
npoqeHT HaJIH'IHH 3DHIuIIITyca y 3CKHMOCOB II al\l:epHKaHCKHX HH)1;eiin;eB DO ODpe)1;eJIeHIIHM
paSHbIX RBTOpOB
j
J
1
J
j
-1
.
Mym'lMHbI iKeHII\MHbI
ABTOD
3CKM-IATarraCKM I IIH):\eHI1bI SCKM-IATarraCKM I HH):\etiI1bI
'. MOCbI Hy6bI MOCbI Ry6bI
Orrpe)1;eJIeHI<IH ]1,. ]1,meHHeca 89,0 3,0 - 95,0 12,0 I -
Orrpe)1;eJIeHIIH B. II. AJIeKceeBa 66,7 - 3,4 72,0 - 7,6
KpHTepHH oIIpeAeJIeHIIH SToro IIpII3HaKa y HHX pa3JIII'lHbI. Ho HCHO II APyrOe:
VTJIIl'lIIH Rl\IepImaHCKHx HHAeIlD;eB 01' a3IIaTCKIIX MOHrOJIOIlAOB He BbIMblillJIe-
HbI, a COBepIlleHHO peaJIbHbI. BbICKa3aHIIOe B JIHTeparype npegIIOJIOmeHHe 0
B03MomHOM J!KOObI OTKpbITIlII B oygyru;eM KaHHX-TO rpynn HHAeiiD;eB C CIIJIb-
HbUl pa3BHTIIeM snImaHTyca HII"leM nORa He nOATBepmgeHO 15.
KPAHHOJIOrHqECKHE OCOBEHHOCTH AMEPHKAHCKHX HH)),E:on;EB
RpaHIIOJIOrII'leCHOe cBoeoopa3IIe aMepImaHcKHx IIHgeiID;eB, BblpamaIOru;eecH
B CHJIbHOM BbIcTYIIaHIIIl HOCOBbIX HocTeIl II OCTpOM ropII30HTaJIbHOM npocpIIJIe,
He ObIJIO nOATBepiKgeHO KpaHIIOMeTpH'leCKH H3-3a OrpaHH'leHHOCTII nporpaM-
424
i,
,.
MbI MHOrMX O'leHb OCHOBaTeJIbHbIX RpaHMOMeTpM'leCRMX paOOT, BbllIOJIHeHHLIX
aMeplIRaHCRMMM MCCJIep;OBaTeJIHMM. IIporpaMMa ;}Ta He BRJIIO'laJIa HM M3Me-
peHIIH BbIcTyrraHIIH HOCOBbIX ROCTeM, HM II3MepeHMH yrrJIOlI\eHHOCTH JIIIn;eBOro
CReJIeTa. I1cRJIIO'leUHe COCTaBJIHJIO JIHllIb OOJIbllIOe cpaBHMTeJIbHOe MCCJIep;OBa-
HMe 'Y. XaY::JJI3a 16, HO MHp;eMCRMe nonYJIHn;MM rrpeiJ,CTaBJIeHbI B HeM JIIIIIIL
P;BYMfl CepMfll\HI, TaR IWR OCHOBHaH 3aiJ,a'la aBTopa COCTOHJIa B MIIpOBOM OXBa-
Te RpaHIIOMeTplI'leCRIIX BapMan;IIM M CTaTIICTM'leCROM On;eHRe RpaHMOMeTpu-
'leCROH ,[(M<p<pepeHI"(Man;MII B n;eJIOM.
IIepBbIe ,[(aHHbIe no yrJIaM ropM30nTaJIbHOrO npO<plI.'IH ObIJIM onYOJIMROBa-
HbI r. <D. ,lJ,eoen;OM, M3MepMBllIMM HeCROJIbRO ROJIJIeRn;MH B MY3€HX CIIIA U
MaJIO'IMCJI8fIHYIO IWJIJIeI,n;MIO MymcRMx 'IepenOB TJIMHRMTOB, xpaHHII\MXCH B
MY3eHX CCCP 17. II03me CYMMapHbIe p;aHHbIe no IIH,[(eMn;aM Ry6bI, CeBepHOM
AprenTIIHbI, IIepy, a TaRme no He60JIbIIIOM cepIIM MH.n;elln;eB ny::J6JIO ony6JIII-
ROBaJI B. B. rMH30ypr 18. 3a ny6JIMRan;HeH B. B. rMH30ypra XpOHOJIOrM'le-
CRM rrOCJIe,[(OBaJIa ynOMHHyTaH RHMra Y. XaY::JJI3a. AHaJIOrM'lHbIe ,[(aHHbIe no
iJ,BYM cepMflM ceBepOaMepIII\anCRMX MIIiJ,eMn;eB 6bIJIM onYOJIMROBaHbI aBTopOM
::JTMX CTpOR B pe3YJIbTaTe pa60TbI B MY3ee <DMJI.n;a B qMRaro B 1977 r. 19
. BOJIee OOIIIMpHbIM MaTepMaJI ObIJI MCCJIe,[(OBaH aBTopOM OC€HbIO 1980 r..
Ror,[(a II3Y'IeHMIO ObIJIM nop;BeprHYTbI <pOH,[(bI pH,[(a MY3een CIIIA, B TOM 'lIICJIe
II RpynHeMIIIMX XpaHMJIMII\ AMepHRaHCRoro My3eH eCTeCTBeHHOM IICTopmr B
HbIo-:tropRe, CMIITCOHOBCRoro MY3eH eCTecTBeHHoll IICTOpMII B BaIIIMHrTOHe
M MY3eH IIMoop;M B rapBap,[(e. MHorMe M3 ::JTHX ROJIJIeRI\HM ObIJIM OIIMcaHId
A. XPiJ,JIII'lROM M ,[(pyrMMII IICCJIe.n;OBaTeJIHMM no RpaTRoll nporpaMMe, HeRO-
TopbIe 6bIJIII II3y'leHbI BnepBbIe. .H CTaBIIJI n;eJIbIO CEoero cpaBHMTeJIbHO RpaT-
Roro IIpe6bIBaHIIfl B CIIIA He M3Yl.J.eHIIe RaRorO-TO ROJIII'IeCTBa HOBbIX MaTe-
pMaJIOB, 'lTO npM OOMJIMII RpaHIIOJIOrIPIeCKIIX :IaHIIbIX no aMepHRaHCRIIM
MHp;eMn;aM He OoelI\aJIO 3Ha'lMTeJIbHOrO YBeJIII'leHIIH MH<popMan;MM. a coop p;aH-
HbIX, IWTOpbIe cepbe3HO paCIIIMplIJIII ObI HaIIIM 3HaHMH 0 BaplIan;IIHX roplI30H-'
TaJIbHOrO npo<pIIJIH JIMn;eBOro CReJIeTa II pa3BIITIIII HOCOBOM OOJIaCTII. OrpOM
Hoe ROJIM'leCTBOKpaHMOJIOrM'leCRMX MaTepIIaJIOB B MY3eHX CIIIA TO'lHO p;o-
KYMeHTMpoBaHo B OTHOIIIeHMM CBoero reorpa<pII'leCROrO npoIIcxom.n;eHMH,
1I0 He p;ORYMeHTMpOBaHO B OTHOIIIeHMM ::JTHM'leCROM npYIHap;JIemHOCTII. ITCh
nbITKa r. <D. ,lJ,eoen;a CBH3aTb ::JTII MaTepMaJIbI C onpeiJ:eJIeIIHbIMII 3THM'leCIDI-'
MIl rpynnaMM B COCTaBe aMepMRaHCKMX MH,[(eMn;eB, omIpaHCb Ha reorpa<pM'Ie-
CRyIO JIOIWJIII3an;MIO COOTBeTCTBYIOII\MX MOrMJIbHMKOB, HOCMT cyryoo YCJIOBHLm
xapaKTep, TaR RaR MHorMe nJIeMeHa MH,[(eMn;eB ObIJIM paCCeJIeHbI 'IepecnOJI
HO, 3aHMMaH OP;HM M Te me paMonbI. RpaUMOJIOrM'IeCRMe cepIIM C .n;OCTaTO'IHO
onpe.n;eJIeHHOM ::JTHM'leCKOM npMHa,[(JIemHOCTbIO COCTaBJIHIOT MeHbIIIMHCTBO,
xpaHHTCH B MY3eHX OTp;eJIbHO M ObIJIM nop;BeprHYTbI M3MepeHMIO B nepByIO
O'Iepe.n;b.
RaK M3ReCTHO, RopeHHoe HaCeJIeHMe CeBepHOM AMepMRM rOBopIIJIO lI8
MHorO'IMCJIeHHbIX H3bII\3X, OO'beiJ,MHHeMbIX B COBpeMeHHbIX JIIIHrBMCTM'leCKm(
KJIaCCII<pIIRan;IIHX B HeCKOJIbRO orpOMHbIX H3bIKOBbIX ceMeM: aJIrOHKMHCRyJO.
MJIM aJIrOHRMHO-BaxaIIIcRyIO, HaiJ:eHe, XORa-CMY, neHYTII II pH,[( OOJIee MeJI-
RMX. B HaIIIeM pacnopHlReHHIl eCTb Tenepb II3MeplITeJIbHafl xapaRTepMCTMRa
IIHTepecyrolI\lIX Hac Mop<pOJIOrIPIeCRIIX ocooenHocTell B MH,[(eMcRlIx rpynrrax,
OTHOCHII\MXCH RO BceM 'leTbIpeM nepe'lIICJIeHHbIM BbIllIe H3bIKOBbIM CeMbHM.
'YnoMHHYTbIe BblllIe .n;aHHbIe B. B. rMH36ypra OTHOCHTCH R RapMoaM Mapa-
BaRaM. MOll acnMpaHT ROJIYMoMeI( X. Pop;pMrec. 3lIMOH 1982 r. paooT3H B
MY3eHX ROJIYM6MII, coopaJI cooTBeTcTByIOII\Me p;aHHbIe no HeCROJIbRIIM rpyn":'
HaM IIHp;eMn;eB ROJIYMOMM. B pe3yJIbTaTe MbI pacnOJIaraeM Tenepb MH«pOpMa-
I1;MeM, B HeCROJIbRO pa3 npeBblllIaIOlI\eM paHee M3BeCTHbIe BbIOOpO'lHlde
p;.aHHbIe, OXBaTbIBaIOlI\eM IIHp;eHn;eB 06eMX AMepMR II n03BOJIHIOII\ell ocym;ecT-'.
r'
425
,
BnTI. IIInpOROe COITOCTaBJIeIUre ROpeHHOrO HaCeJIeHIIH AMepIIRII C a3IIaTCRIIMII
MOHrOJIOnp:aMII II )".\pyrIIMn paCOBI.IMII TIIIIaMII 3eMJIII.
3p,eCI. YMeCTHO ynoMHHYTI. 0 TOM, 'lTO ITO ynJIOIIJ;eHHOCTII JIIIn;a H Hoca
a3lIaTCRne MOHrOJIOIIp,I.I, II cpe)".\II HIIX ocooeHHO CII6IIpCRlIe MOHrOJIOII,[(I.I, 3a-
HIIMalOT RpallHee MeCTO cpep,II p:pyrlIx 'leJIOBe'leCRIIX pac. B COOTBeTCTBIIH e
paHHIIMII rrpep:CTaBJIeHIIHMII 0 pa3BIITIIII 3TIIX npII3HaROB y 3MepURaHOIIp,OB
OHII, RaR MbI nOMHIIM, OTJIII'laIOTCH HROOI.I COOTHOIIIeHIIeM 3TIIX npII3HaROB,
C6JIUiRalOIIJ;IIM UX e eBponeOIIp,aMII,- OCTpI.IM JIIIn;eBI.IM npoqJlIJIeM II CIIJII.-
HblM BI.IcTynaHIIeM Hoca. B RaROll Mepe 3TII npeiRHIIe npep:CTaBJIeHIIH p:ell-
CTBIITe:rI.HO nop:TBepiRp:aIOTCH ROHRpeTHblMII 3MnIIplPIeCRIIMII naOJIIO,[(eHIIHMII?
HymHo cpa3y iRe nop:'lepRHYTI., 'lTO nop:TBepiRp:aIOTCH OHII JIIIIIII. 'laCTU'lHO.
UpII paCCMOTpeHlI1I BaplIaI(lIll npII3HaROB B aMepIIRaHOIIp:HI.IX rpynnax 06pa-
IIJ;aeT Ha ce6JI BHIIMaHIIe IIX IIeRJIIO'llITeJII.HI.Ill nOJIIIMopq,II3M, pe3RO 6pocalO-
IIJ;IIllCH B rJIa3a Ha q,oHe OTHOCHTeJIbHOH Mopq,OJIOrH'leeROH rOMoreHHOCTII
p:pyrIIx paCOBI.IX THTIOB. II pII 3TOM XOTH CO'leTaHIIe npII3HaROB B OTp:eJII.HI.IX
3THII'leCRIIX rpynnax IIH,[(elln;eB II cBoeoopa3Ho, HO OHO n03BOJIHeT Bce iRe p,IIq,-
q,epenn;IIpOBaTI. IIX OTIpep:eJIeHHbIM 06pa30M II YBIIp:eTI. B MOpq,OJIOrII'leCRIIX
ROMTIJIeRCaX CJIep:I.I pa3HbIx reHeTII'IOCRIIX IICTOROB Mopq,OJIOrII'leCRIIX ocooeH-
HOCTell ROpeHTIOrO HaCeJIeHIIH AMepIIKII.
Upep:BapIITeJII.HI.Ie pe3YJII.TaTI.I II3MepeHIIll BMeCTe e paHee OTIy6JIIIROBaH-
HI.IMII p,aIlHI.IMII CYMMIIpOBaHI.I B TaOJI. 45. He Bp:aBaHCI. B p:eTaJII.HI.Ill aHaJIII3
3TOll Ta6JIIIn;I.I, OTMeTIIM JIIIIIII. OCHOBHI.Ie MOMeHTI.I. IIpaRTII'lecRII rrO'lTII Bee
rpymII.I aMepIIRaHCRIIX IIHp:elln;eB IIMelOT OCTpI.Ill JIIIn;eBOll npoq,IIJII. II p:OBOJII.-
HO CII.ilhnO BI.IcTynalOIIJ;IIe HOCOBbIe ROCTII. BblcTynaHIIe Hoca B J eJI()M 3Ha-
'lIITeJII.HO CIIJII.Hee. 'leM y a3IIaTCRHX MOHrOJIOup:HI.IX q,OpM, HO Bce iRe MeHI.-
IIIe, 'leM y eBponeOIIp:OB. MeiRrpynnoBaH cpep:HHH yrJIa nplIMepHO paBHa
TOMY, 'lTO MI.I IIMeeM y cy6ypaJII.CRUX MOHrOJIOIIp:OB - RopeHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH
IIoBOJIiRbJI II IIplIypaJII.H. 8TO B op:IIHaRoBoll CTeneHII CBOllCTBeHHO RopeHHO-
MY HaCeJIeHIIIO II CeBepHOll II IOiRHOll AMepIIRII. OTp:eJII.HbIe rpynnbI (no-
TOMRII IIHp:elln;eB RYObI, rypoHbI 113 rpynnbI IIpORe30B, BXOp:HIIJ;UX B H3I.IROBYlO
ceMI.IO XORa-CIIY B CeBepHOll AMepIIRe, pHp: 3THII'leCRIIX rpynn B IOiRHOll
AMepIIRe) OTJIII'laIOTCH eIIJ;e MeHee CIIJII.HO pa3BIITOll HOCOBOll OOJIaCTI.IO,
HO ropII30HTaJII.HI.Ill npoq,IIJII. JIIIn;eBOro CRe:reTa y HIIX OCTaeTCH OCTpI.IM,
XOTH II no HeMY HHp:elln;I.I AMeplIRII 3aHIIMalOT eRopee npOMeiRYTO'lHOe no-
JIOJKeHIIe MeiRp:y COOTBeTCTBYIOIIJ;IIMII xapaRTepIICTIIRaMII eBponeOIIp:HI.IX II
MOHrOJIOIIp:HI.IX cepIIll.
TaRIIM 06pa30M, no eO'leTaHIIIO paCCMaTpIIBaeMI.IX q,YHp:aMeHTaJII.HI.IX
oeo6eHHOCTell nop:aBJIHIOIIJ;aH 'laCTI. ROpeIlHOrO HaCeJIeHIIH AMepIIRII OJIIIiRe
CRopee R eBponeOIIp:aM, 'leM R MOHrOJIOIIp:aM. B TO me BpeMH pacnpOCTpa-
HeHHoe B 3THorpaq,II'leCROll, p:a II B aHTpOnOJIOrII'leCROll JIIITepaType MHeHIIe,
'lTO IIHp:elln;I.I AMepIIRII He OTJIII'laIOTCH B 3TOM OTHOIIIeHIIII OT HaCeJIeHIIH
EBponI.I, He BnOJIHe TO'lHO: OHM OT.lIII'IaIOTCH OT a3IIaTCRIIX MOHrOJIOIIp:OB II
COJIHiRalOTCH C eBponeOIIp:aMH, HO He p:OCTIlraIOT MaRCIIMaJII.HI.IX BeJIII'lHH,
TIInH'lHI.IX p:JIH eBponeOIIp:OB. B COeTaBe eBponeOIIp:OB HeT rpynn C TaRIIM
CJIaObIM BI.IcTynaHIIeM Hoca, RaR rypOHI.I !IJIII IIHp:elln;I.I Ry6bI, HO B eOCTaBe
CMeIIIanHI.IX no paCOBOMY COCTaBY eBponeOII,[(HO-MOHrOJIOHp:HbIX MeTIICOB OHII
COCTaBJIHlOT npeOOJIap:aIOIIJ;ee 60JILIIIIIHCTBO.
06paIIJ;aeT Ha ce6H BHIIMaHIIe HCRJIIO'lHTeJII.HO CIIJII.HaH BapIIaOeJII.HOeTb
CTpoeHliH JIIIn;eBOro npoq,IIJIH II yrJIa HOCOBI.IX ROCTell BHYTPII aMepIIRanOII-
p:OB, C03,[(aIOIIJ;aH Bne'laTJIeHHe (oc06eHHO Ha q,OHe OTHOCIITeJII.Horo ep:IIHeTBa
3TIIX BapIIan;lIll BHYTPH a3IIaTCRHX MOHrOJIOIIp:OB) IIX reTeporeHHoro npOIIC-
XOiRp:eHIIH. 8TO q,YHp:aMeHTaJII.HI.Ill Bonpoc paCOBoro reHe3IIca aMepIIRaHOII-'
P;OB; BI.ITeRaIOIIJ;IIll 1I3 paeCMOTpeRHH IIHTepecylOIIJ;IIX Hae ocooeHHOCTeii.
1
.
1
426
,
'1
Ta6mlI\a 45
YrJlbl rOpH30HT8J1bHOrO npOcfIHJlH H BblcTynaHHH HOCOBMX KocTeii y 8MepHKaHcKHx
HH)1;euI\eB
MymCIllle 'leperra meHCRlle 'leperra
rpyrrrra I I I I
75(1) 77 Lzm' 75(1) 77 Lzm'
T JIHHKIITbI 23,1(9) 143,2 (9) 135.4 (9) - - -
Xaii}.J;a 24,0(69) 143,2(70) 131,1 (70) 21,0(26) 145,2 (30) 131,4(30.)
"LfepHoHorIIe B I\eJIOM 27,6(14) 139,1 (18) 128,2'(17) 25,6 (23) 138,8(27) 127,3(27)
DIIraHbI 29,2(5) 138,9 (10) 127,4(8) 22,6 (9) 140,90(13) 131,6(12)
Arra"lII 22,3(15) 143,6(16) 135,0 (15) 20,6 (5) 145.9 (8) 135.0 (7)
CIIY 28,4(54) 138,7(58) 129,6 (56) 25,3(39) 137,6(44) 127,1 (44)
DOHKa 30,2(11) 139,9(11) 127,9(11) 24,2 (10) 138,8(10) 127,5(10}
rYPOHbI 23,1 (8) 138,6 (14) 124,6(8) 21,3(7) 138,5 (10) 118,3 (8)
lIIeiieHbI 29,2(18) 139,7 (1!J) 129,2 (18) 27,0(5) 140,2 (5) 130,3(4)
"LfIIHYKlI 21.7 (38) 142,4(40) 127,6(40) 18,5 (22) 143,7 (26) 129,0(25)
IIys6JIO 20,8(13) 143,1 (14) 128,7 (12) 14,7(9) 143,9 (9) 129,5 (8)
A pima pbI - 140,0 (33) 126,9(33) - 138,2 (30) 128,3(30)
MH}.J;eiiU;bI IDJIOPII)1;bI - 138,2(54) 126,5(54) - 139,2 (30) 129,0(30)
MHgeiiU;bJ KaJIH!J!opmUf - 141,8(39) 127,3(39) - 144,6(23) 129,1(23)
CIIOOHCIJ (Kyoa) 18,0(12) 142,6(17) 126,5(12) 17,3(10) 143,9 (9) 126,8 (9)
']'aIfHO (Kyoa) 21,2 (20) 143,0 (22) 127,0 (20) 17,5 (13) 141,5 (13) 127,0(11)
MH}.J;eIIU;hI CeBepHoii 24,9(12) 144,5(12) 130,8(12) 23,7 (9) 146,3 (12) 130,0(11)
ApreHTI1HbI
MH}.J;eiiU;hI IIepy 24,2(22) 143,0(24) 126,5(24) 20,9 (8) 142,0(12) 124,2(10)
MYHCKII (KOJIYM6HH) 22,4 (7) 145,5 (32) 128,7 (32) 19,7 (27) 144,4 (27) 129,1 (27)
B aTOM OTHOIlIeHMH O'IeHJ-' BbJ)J,eJlHIOTCH B CeBepHOH AMepr.:R9 !WCHTeJIB
ynoMMHaBIlIMXCH BbIIlIe H3bIROB Hap;eHe - He TOJlbRO aTaIIaCRM, HO M MH,[(eH-
n;bI xaH,[(a. B lOiRHOH AMepHRe R HJIM IIpMMbIRaIOT OT,[(eJlbHbIe aTHM'IeClUIe
rpynIIbI, BXO,[(Hru;Me B O'IeHb 06IlIMPHYIO ceMbIO RapH6cRHX H3:bIROB. IIpo Bce
aTH napO,[(bI HMRaR HeJlb3H CRa3aTb, 'ITO OHM no BapMan;JIHM paCCMaTpMBae-
MbIX nplI3HaROB 6JlMiRe R eBpOIIeOMp,aM, a He R MOHrOJIOMp;aM: Bce OHH MMeIOT
p;OCTaTO'IHO nJlOCROe JlMn;O H xapaRTepJI3YIOTCH ynJloru;eHHbIMH HOCOBbHOI
ROCTHMM, 'lTO B n;eJlOM M C03p;aeT ROMIIJIeRC npM3HaROB, ;;IIIIlIb He3Ha'IHTeJIL-
HO OTJIIf'laIOru;MHCH OT TaROBoro y MOHrOJIOMp;OB. R COiRaJIeHHIO, B HameM pac-
IIOpHiReHMM HeT p;aHHbIX, ROTOpbIe CBIIp;eTeJIbCTBOBaJIII 6bI 0 TOM, 'ITO Y aTa-
IIaCROB M OCTaJIbHbIX nJIeMeH Hap;eHe aIIMRaIITYC BbIpaiReH CMJIbHee, 'IeM Y
p;pyrMx nJIeMeH aMepHRaHcRHX HH.o;eHn;eB. J];eCHTRM JIORaJIbHbIX BapMan;nii He
OXBa'IeHbJ aMIIlIpM'IeCRMMM Ha6JIIO.n:eHMHMM, n MbI MMeeM B pe3YJIbTaTe, Rail:
COBepIlIeHHO CIIpaBe.n:JIIIBO OTMeTHJIJI E. C'IaCMapII II H. OcceH6epr, RpaHHHii
Hep;ocTaToR MHq,opMan;IIII 0 JIORaJIbHbIX rpynnax ceBepOal\IepIIRaHCRMx H TeM
60JIee IOiRHOaMepMRaHcRMx MHp;eHn;eB. XOpOIlIIIX <poTonopTpeToB HHp;eHn;eB
TaRllie HeMHoro, 'IT06bI no HIIM CYP;IITb 06 OTJlJI'IMHX, cyru;eCTBYIOru;nx MemAY
MH.n:eHn;aMH ceMbH Ha.n:eHe - aTanaCRaMM, xaHp;a H p;p. - H OCTaJIbHbIMH ceBepo-
aMepHRaHCRMMM IIJIeM8HaMM. Ho pa3JIII'IJIH MeiR Y HIIMII B CTpoeHHH ropH-
30HTaJIbHOrO npo<pMJIH M BbIcTynaHMH Hoca, nOBTopHIO, HaCTOJIbRO p;eMOHCTpa-
TIIBHbI, 'ITO BbIp;eJIHIOT IIHp;eHn;eB Ha,[(eHe H3 OCTaJIbHOH MaCCbI HHp;eHcRlIx
nJIeMeH H C6JIMiRaIOT MX C MOHrOJIOH.n:aMH, Tor.n:a RaR B OCTaJIbHbIX CJIyq:anx,
.n:eHcTBHTeJIbHO, 60JIbilie oCHoBaHnii rOBopMTb 0 Mopq,OJIOrM'IeCROM CXOP;CTBe
C eBpoIIeoMp;aMH.
t c
f
427
AMEPHRAHOH]J;IJI - IIPOTOMOPcJ}HblE MOHrOJIOH]:t;bI?
n.:W 'OO'bHCHemUI :HOrO CXO;J:CTBa fl. fl. POrlIHCKIIH npeAJIOmlIJI rlInoTeay
aM.epIIKaHOIIAHOCTII ApeBHerO HaCeJIeHIIH CeBepHOH II BOCTO'IHOH AaIIH,
T. e. COXpaHeHlW B AMeplIKe npoToMopqJHOrO KOMnJIeKCa npHaHaROB, rIa oaae
ROToporo CgJOpMlIpOBaJICH B A3HIl RJIaCCH'IeCRHH MOHrOJIOHAHbIH KOMnJIeKC 20.
COrJIaCHO :JTOH rlInOTeae, ApeBHeHIlIee rraCeJIeHlIe STOH orpOMHOH OUJIaCTII He
IIMeJIO 'lBTKO BbIpameHIIbIX MOHrOJIOIIArrbIX IIpII3HaKOB, KOTOpbIe Boooru;e IIpeA-
CTaBJIHIOT COUOH O'IeHb II03AHIOIO CTaAIIIO pacooopaaOBaHIIH, II YIIJIoru;eIIIIoe
JIIIn;O II IIJIOCRIIH HOC CgJOpMlIpOBaJIIICb B A3IIII TorAa, RorAa AMepIIRa ObIJIa
ya;e aaceJIerra 'IeJIOBeKOM II 'TaCTb ApeBHeHIlIIIX a3IIaTCKIIX IIOIIYJIHmril YlliJIa
lIa A3I1I1 'Iepea pailOH BeplIIIrOBa IIpOJII'lBa B AMepIIRY. fHIIOTeaa 3Ta ObIJIa
BbIClmaaHa eru;e TorAa, RorAa MHorlIe HaIlIII IIpeiJ,CTaBJIellIIH 00 STaIIax pacore-
Iteaa 1I0CIIJIII iJ,OCTaTO'IHO CXeMaTlI'IHbIJI xapaRTep II IIO'ITII IIOJIHOCTbIO OT-
CYTCTBOBaJI xopomo lIaY'IeHHbIH IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrlI'IeCI{IIH MaTeplIaJI 1I3
B9CTO'IHOH II IJ;eHTpaJIbHOH AalIlI. CeH'IaC STOT MaTeplIaJI IIOHBHJICH, II, XOTH
B ,lleM MHoro IIpOOeJIOB, 011 IIOaBOJIHeT CAeJIaTb HeROTOpbIe AOnOJIHIITeJII.HI.Ie
BI.IBOiJ,bI.
IIpemiJ,e Bcero HeCKOJIhKO CJIOB OTIIOCIITeJIbHO caMI.IX paHHIIX IIaXOiJ,OK.
HeKOTopaH ynJIoru;eHHOCTb B'epXHero OTII,eJIa JIIIn;eBOro CKeJIeTa II JIOIIaTOOO-
paaHI.Ie pean;bI Y CIIHaHTpona, O'IerrI. CIIJIbHaH YIIJIoru;eHHOCTb JIIIn;a Y JIaHb-
T!I1IICROrO rOMIIHIIAa - conepIlIeHHO O'IeBIIiJ,HO CKJIaiJ,I.IBaIOru;IIHCH MOHrOJIOIIp,-
IIbIH ROMnJIeKC nplIaHaKOB, He iJ,OCTlIrIlIIIH eru;e CBoero nOJIHOrO paaBIITIIH 21.
::ho HaOJIIOiJ,eHlIe KaK UYiJ,TO nOATBepmiJ,aeT TlInoTeay npoToMopgJIIOCTII p;peB-
Hero naCeJIeHIIH AalIlI.
BepXllenaJIeOJIIITlI'IeCKlIe IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlPIeCKlIe HaxOAKII C coxpaHIIB-
WIIMCH JIIIn;eBI.IM CKeJIeTOM npOIICXOiJ,flT, RaK 1I3BeCTHO, lIa ABYX MeCTOHaxom-
p,eHIIH - BepXHeJI neru;epI.I qmOYROYiJ,HHb 22 II MeCTOHaxomiJ,eIIIIH .D:ynb-
].I;HHhHH 2", npIl'IeM nepBI.Ie HaXOiJ,KII OTHOCHTCH K aaRJIIO'IIITeJIbllOMY sTarry
l;!epXHero IIaJIeOJIIITa. II 'Iepen IIa .D:YHbiJ,HHbHHa, II ooa meHCKIIX 'Iepena Ha
BepxneH rreru;epbI IIMelOT ynJIoru;euIII.IH JIIIn;eBOH CReJIeT II MaJIO BblcTYIIaIO-
IIe HOCOBI.le KOCTII 24. llepeHocbe Y gJparMeHTa CO CTOHHKII AgJoHToBa
p,pa, B IOmHoH CIIOIIplI TaRme ObIJIO CIIJIbHO ymIOru;eHO 25. IIpaRTII'IeCKH
e,!j;HHCTBeHIIoe, 'ITO OCTaeTCH P;JIH p:ORa3aTeJIbCTBa npOTOMOpgJHOCTH ApeBHeH-
1p rQ HaCeJIeHHH BOCTO'IHOH AaIIII,- MymcKoH 'Iepen Ha BepXHeH neru;epI.I,
;i-if3TBIITeJIbHO OTJIII'IaIOru;IIHCH OT COBpeMeHHbIX MOHrOJIOIIp;HbIX cepIIll H 00-
JI,l,Je rrpOgJlIJIIIpOBaHHbIM JIHn;OM, M OOJIee BbIcTynaIOru;MMM HOCOBbIMM KOCTHMH.
.D:oCTaTO'lHbIH JIM STO aprYYleIIT? CTporo rOBopH, HeT, ocooeHHO eCJIM MI.I IIPH-
M J\I BO BHMMaHHe ep;MHlPIHOCTb HaXO}J.KM.
IIpOTMB rMnOTeabI HeBblpameHHOCTM ocooeHHocTeH MOllrOJIOHp;HOH paCbI Y
ApeBHero HaCeJIeHMH BOCTO'IHOH AaMII CBMp;eTeJIbCTByeT H oOJIee noap;HHH
J,laJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrM'IeCKHII MaTepIIaJI SIIOXII HeOJIMTa. lIa oacceHHa XyaHxs
O McaHO HeCKOJIbRO cepMH paaHoro BpeMeHM M paaJIII'IHOH RYJIbTYPHOH IIPH-
H-aAJIemHOCTM - Bce OHM OTJIII'IaIOTCH tIe TKO BbIpameHHI.IM MOHrOJIOMAHbIM
IWMnJIeKCOM npIIaHaKOB 26. IIpaBp;a, no OTHOIlIeHlUO K OP;HOH Ma ceplIH ObIJIO
BbICRaaaHO MHeHlIe 0 HaJIII'IIIII B OCTaBMBIlIeH ee nonyJIHn;IIM eBponeOMp;HOM
npnMeCM 2" HO OHO nOJIY'IMJIO O'IeHb HeyoeIl,MTeJIbHOe MOpgJOJIOrII'IeCKOe OOOC-
nOBaHHe. CTeneHh BblparKeHHOCTII MOHrOJIOMp;IIbIX IIpMaHaKOB B n;eJIOM He-
Ha: 1HOrO MeHbme y BOCTO'IHOaaIlaTCKMX MOIIrOJIOM}J.OB, 'IeM y CMUMPCKMX,
'II OHII RpaHMOJIOrM'IeCRM OJIMaKM K HeOJIMTlPIeCKMM JIIOAHM oacceHHa XyaHXS.
ECJIM Ha npOTHmeHHM IIOCJIep;HIIX nHTM TbICH'I JIeT B OIIpep;eJIeHHOM reorpa-
gJM'IeCROM paHOHe HaOJIIO;J:aeTCH TaKaH cTa6MJIbHOCTb aHTpOIIOJIOrlPIeCKOrO
,1WMIIJIeKCa, TO TPYAHO HaaBaTb gJYHAaMeHTaJIbHyIO IIPM'IMHY, ROTopaH MOrJIa
,..:;;
..
"
j
'4
,
j
428
i
ObI npMBeCTM R ero ObICTPOMY M3MeHeHMIO Ha npOTHiReHMM npep;meCTBYIOJ:IJ;MX
TbICH'IeJIeTlin.
Hamil 3HaIIMH B OOJIaCTli IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrMli CIIOlipli 28 M HrrOHCRIIX
OCT po BOB 29 B nOCJIep;HMe p:eCHTIIJIeTliH TaRiRe B03pOCJIM B HeCROJIbRO pa3.
HeOJIMTIIqeCROe HaCeJIeHMe aTliX 06JIaCTen OTJIIIqaJIOCb He MeHbmen BbIpaiReH-
HOCTblO MOHrOJIOM}J,HbIX ocooeHHOCTen, qeM: COBpeMeHHoe. IImJToMY rMnOTe3a
neiiTpaJIbHOrO MeHee Cnen;IIaJIII3IIpOBaHHoro aHTpOIIOJIOrIIqeCROrO TMna }J,peB-
HIIX a3IIaTCRIIX MOHrOJIOIIII,OB BbIrJIH}.(IIT He OqeUb y6e}J,IITeJIbHO, TaR RaR OHa
OCTaBJIHeT 6e3 06'bHCHeHMH MHoro BonpOCOB, II cenqac ona BpH}J, Jill MOiReT
ObITb nO}J,}J,epiRaHa naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIF!3CRIIMli aprYMeHTaMII II HYiR}J,aeTCH
JIII60 B 3aMeHe ee RaRon-TO }J,PyroH rImOTe30n (eCJIM CqIITaTb HenTpaJIbHOCTb-
npOTOMOHrOJIOM}J,HOro KOMnJIeKCa 4>lmn;IIen), JIIIOO B CYJ:IJ;eCTBeHHbIX }J,orrOJI-
HeHMHX.
MeiRIIY TeM onpe}J,eJIeHHbIn pHP; rraJIeOaHTpOrrOJIorlIqeCKIIX 4>aKTOB, BbIHB-
JIeHrrbIX 3a nOCJIe}J,HIIe 20 JIeT, 6pocaeT HOBbIn CBeT Ha rrpOOJIeMY B n;eJIOM.
Bo MHorMX panoHax IJ;eHTpaJIbHOn A3IIM - B TYBe 30, B 3arrap:HbIX panoHax
MOHrOJIIIIr 31 - npO/I-,IrBaJIlI B arroxy aHeOJIIITa, 6pOH3bI 11 paHHero meJIe3a
rronYJIHn;IIII C eBpOneOJI}J,HbIMli oc06eHHOCTHMH. Peqb H}J,eT He 06 OT}J,eJIbHbIX
BRJIlOqeHIIHX, a 0 }J,OCTaTot.IHO mHpoRoM pacnpocTpaneHMII eBponeOM}J,OB Ii
I eHTpaJILHon A3MM B anoxy aHeOJInTa M 6pOH3bI. Ha BOCTOKe eBponeoMAHbIn
apeaJI D,OXO}J,JIJf }J,O n;eHTpaJIbHbIX panoHoB HbIHemHeH TeppMTopMM MOHrOJIL-
CRon HapO}J,Hon Pecny6JIMRM,- aTO MMeeT npHMbIe naJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrlIqeCKMe
}J,oRa3aTeJIbCTBa, Ha OCHOBaHMII KOCBeHHbIX COOOpaiReHMn MOiRHO npe}J,nOJIa-
raTb, qTO ero BOCTOqHaH rpaHMn;a yxo}J,MJIa eJ:IJ;e }J,aJILme Ha BOCTOK II. npoJIe-
raJIa r}J,e-TO BO BHYTpeIIHen MOHrOJIMM MJIM p;aiRe eJ:IJ;e BOCTOqHee.
tIaxop:RH OOJIee paHHero BpeMeHM M3 aTMX panOHOB - C TeppMTopIIM TYBbI,
MOHroJIlIM II BHYTpeHHen MOHrOJIMM nOKa OTCYTCTBYIOT, HO aprYMeHTMpye-
MaH apXeOJIOrHqeCRII RYJIbTypHaH npeeMCTBeIIHOCTb B03BO}J,IIT 3}J,eCb reHe3HC
HaCeJIeIIIIH anox IIeOJIMTa M 6pOH3bI R 60JIee paHHeMY BpeMeHII. A apxeOJIO-
rM'IeCRaH xapaKTepMcTMRa naMHTHMKOB naJIeOJIIITIIqeCKOrO speMeHM oOHapy-
iRMBaeT B HIIX MHorIIe aJIeMeHTbI 3ana}J,Horo npOIIcxom}J,eHIIH 32.
BeCbMa BepOHTHO, qTO CTenHaH qaCTb n;eHTpaJIbHbIX OOJIaCTen 1l3HaqaJIbHO
BXO}J,MJIa B apeaJI 4>opMIIpOBaHIIH eBporreOII}J,OB II HbIHemHHH TeppMTopMH
AJITaH, XaRaCIIII II TYBbI, 3ana}J,HbIx panOHOB MOHrOJIIIII, MOiReT ObITb }J,aiRe
BCH MOHroJIMH }J,O BHYTpeHHen MOHromm:, npe}J,CTaBJIHJIa cooon 30HY pa3HbIX
OqarOB eBponeOM}J,Horo pacooopa30BaHIIH. TaKMM oopa30M, orpOMHbIn no
apeaJIY II MHOrOqIICJIeHHbIn MaCCMB eBponeOII}J,OB B IJ;eUTpaJIbHOn A3IIII
Ha paHHIIX aTanax pacooopa30BaHIIH npOCTIIpaBIllMII CBoe BJIIIHHIIe }J,aJIeRO Ha
BOCTOR,- peaJILHbIn 4>aKT, C KOTOpbIM HeJIb3H cent.rac He CqMTaTbCH npM pe-
IWIICTpYRn;IIII pacoreHeTMqeCKOrO npon;ecca Ha BOCTORe II ceBepe A3IIII II no-
pOiR}J,eHHbIX IIM IIMnYJIbCOB, pacnpOCTpaHMBmIIXCH B pa3HbIe CTOpOHbI, B TOM
t.IHCJIe II B AMepMKY.
rlInOTe3a 0 HaJIIIqlIII eBponeOM}J,Hon npIIMeCM Y Hapop:OB BOCTOqHOn A3MII
BbICKa3bIBaJIaCb B 30-40-x rOiJax PH}J,OM 3ana}J,HoeBponenCRIIX aHTpOrrOJIO-
rOB 3\ M OHa nO}J,BeprJIaCb Tor}J,a iRe OCTpon II B n;eJIOM crrpaBe}J,JIMBOn RPII-
TliKe CO CTOpOHbI COBeTCKIIX Cnen;IIaJIMCTOB, nOTOMY qTO 4>aKTMqeCRaH oa3a
ee ObIJIa OqeHb YH3BMMa (M300paiReHMH HR06bI CIIJIbHO oopO}J,aTbIX JIIO}J,en B
p;peBHeRMTanCKMX xpOHMKax), a TeopeTIIt.IeCRII OHa COnpOBOiR}J,aJIaCb KYJIbTYP-
TperepCRMMM TeH}J,eHn;IIHMM II CTpeMJIeHMeM npIInIIcaTb MeCTHbIe KYJIbTypHbIe
}J,OCTlIrKeHMH eBponeOII}J,HbIM npMmeJIbn;aM 3 . TaRon npMMIITIIBHbIn RYJIbTYP-
TperepcKMn eBpOn;eHTpII3M AaBHo OCTaBJIeH cOBpeMeHHon HaYRon, HO mIIpo-
Kiln KOHTaKT eBponeOM}J,OB C MOHrOJIOII}J,aMM Ha TeppIITopMM IJ;eHTpaJIbHOn M
'raCTMqHO BOCTOqHOn A3MM B anoxy paHHIIX aTanOB pacooopa30BaHIIH, RaK
429
MbI y6ep;HJIHCb, p;ORYMeHTHpyeTcH MHOrHMH 6eCCrrOpHbIMH «paIiTaMlI, COMHe-
HHH He BbI3bIBaeT H 3aCTaBJIHeT rrepeCTpOHTL Hame OTHomeHHe K Tpap;Hn;HOH-
HbIM cxeMaM 3aCeJIeHHH AMepHRH H HCXOP;HbIX paCOBbIX ROMrrJIeRCOB, HOCH-
TeJIH ROTOpbIX rrpHHHJIH yqaCTHe B aTOM rrpon;ecce.
KaRoe OTHomeHHe BCH aTa HOBaH HH«popMan;IIH HMeeT K paCCMOTpeHHOH
BbIme rIIrrOTe3e HeHTpaJIbHOrO 06JIIIRa P;peBHIIX MOHrOJIOIIp;OB? -MbI OTRa3a-
JIIICb OT :=ITOH rIIrrOTe3bI H3-3a OTCYTCTBIIH B ee rrOJIb3Y cepbe3HbIX MOp«p OJIO -
rIPIeCRIIX p;ORa3aTeJIbCTB, HO reIIe3IIC MOP«POJIOrJPIeCKHX ocooeHHOCTeH, KO-
TopbIe xapaRTepHbI P;JIH aMepIIRaHOIIp;OB, rrpOHCHHeTCH C rrOMO bIO Tex rra-
JIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCRHX MaTepHaJIOB, ROTOpbIe 6bIJIII IIepeqIICJIeHbI BbIlIIe. ECJIH,
RaR 6bIJIO yCTaIIOBJIeHO, apeaJI eBporreOIIp;OB Ha paHllIIX aTarrax paco-
06pa30BaHIIR 6bIJI ropa3p;o mllpe H OXBaTbIBaJI, XOTH 6bI qaCTIIqHO, IJ;eHTpaJIb-
HYIO A3IIIO, TO ROHTaRT IIX C rrpOTOMOHrOJIOHp;aMII p;OJImeH ObIJI 6bITb OqeHb
3HaqIITeJIbHbIM IIMeHHO B Tex paHOHax IJ;eHTpaJIbHOH, BOCTOqHOH II CeBepHOH
A3IIII, oTRyp;a BepOHTeH IICXOP; IIpep;ROB aMepIIRaHOIIp;OB B HOBbIH CBeT qepe3
p;peBHIOIO BepIIHreHCRYIO cymy.
YQACTHE PEBHEIlmHX EBPOIIEOH OB B OOPMHPOBAHHH
MOPcI>OJIOrlJlIECRHX OCOEEHHOCTEIl AMEPHRAHOH OB
B03Bpa aHCb R aHTpOrrOJIOrIIqeCRIIM oco6eHIIOCTHM KopeHHoro HaCeJIeHHH
06eIIX AMepIIR, MbI IIOJIyqaeM Terrepb ropa3p;o 6o:ree OCHOBaTeJIbHYIO <p aRTII -
qeCRYIO 6a3Y P;JIH IIX reHeTIIqeCROH IIHTeprrpeTan;IIII, 'IeM Ta, ROTopaH Haxo-
p;IIJIaCb B HameM paCIIopHmeHIIII paHbme. TaRIIe oco6eHHocTII, RaR P;OBOJIbHO
OCTpbIH JIIIn;eBOH IIPO<pIIJIb H CIIJIhHOe BbIcTyrraHIIe Hoca, JIerRO HaXOp;JIT ce6e
o6 HcHeHIIe RaR reHeTHqeCROe CJIep;CTBIIe 3HaqIITeJIbHOH eBporreoII HoH
rrpIIMeCH B COCTaBe Tex a3IIaTCRIIX rrorrYJIHn;IIH, ROTOpbIe p;aJIII HaqaJIO rrepBbIM
HaCeJIbHIIRaM AMepIIRaHcRoro ROHTIIHeHTa. B n;eJIOM Mop«pOJIOrIIqeCRIIH OOJIHK
aMepIIRaHOIIp;OB BrrOJIHe COOTBeTcTByeT TOH ROM6IIHan;IIII rrpII3HaROB, ROTopaH
MOrJIa oopa30BaTbcH rrpii mIIpOROM II IIpOp;OJImaBmeMCH MHoro IIOROJIeHIIH
CMemeHIIII C eBporreOIIp;aMII. CBoeoOpa3HbIe oco6eHHOCTII MOP«POJIOrIIII aMepH-
RaHCRIIX HHp;eHn;eB BIIOJIHe 06 HCHIIMbI IIX TbICHqeJIeTHeH II30JIHn;IIeH B IIpe-
p;eJIax o6eIIx AMepIIR.
Op;HaRo COOTHomeHHe eBpOIIeOHp;Horo H MOHrOJIOIIp;HOro KOMIIOHeHTOB y
aTIIX IIOIIYJIHn;IIH He 6bIJIO op;IIHaROBbIM - eBpOIIeOIIp;HaH rrpIIMeCb 6bIJIa IIpep;-
CTaBJIeHa B 60JIbmen IIJIII MeHbmeH CTerreHII. 8TO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO rrOMoraeT
IIOHHTb, IIOqeMY OTp;eJIbHbIe IIJIeMeHa ceBepoaMepIIKaHcRIIx IIH,o:eHn;eB pa3JIII- '1
qaIOTCH Memp;y C060H no Mop<pOJIOrIIII JIIIn;eBOro CReJIeTa: IIO-BIIP;III\IOMY,
B aTIIX pa3JIIIqIIHX npOHBJIHeTCH IIX pa3Hoe IIpoIIcxomp;eHIIe, BOcxop;H ee e e
R a3IIaTcRoH npapop;IIHe. K COmaJIeHIIIO, P;OBOJIbHO CJIa6aH II3yqeIIHOCTb rra-
JIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIII p;peBHeHmero Hace:reHIIH AMepIIRII 35 II HeII3yqeHHOCTb Ba-
pIIan;IIH IIHTepeCYIO IIX Hac IIpII3HaROB CTpoeHIIH JIIIn;eBOro npo<pIIJIH II pa3-
BIITIIH IIOCOBOH OOJIaCTII p;ame y II3BeCTIIbIX Haxop;OR JIIImaIOT B03MomHOCTH
HaHTII IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCRIIX IIpep;ROB OTp;eJIbHbIX RpyrrHbIx 06 HOCTeH
B COCTaBe IIHp;eHn;eB II npOCJIep;IITb p;IIRa:l-IIIRy IIX paCCeJIeHIIH ITO TepPIITOPIIII- .,, '
AMepIIRaHCRoro ROHTIIIIeHTa B xop;e BpeMeHII.
¥CTaHOBJIeHHOe OTJIIIqIIe IIHp;eHn;eB Hap;eHe OT p;pyrHX IIHp;eHCRIIX rpyrrn,
oco6eHHO p;eMOHCTpaTIIBHO IIpOHBJIHIO eeCH y TaRIIX xapaRTepHbIX IIpep;CTa-
BHTeJIeH aTOH rpyrrnbI, RaR aTaIIaCRII, OqeBIIp;HO, Tpe6yeT oco6oro 06 HCHe- 1
HHH. CeHqaC e e HeT rrOJIHOH reHeTIIqeCROH RJIaCcH«pIIRan;IIII aMepIIRaHCRIIX
H3bIROB, B npeD,eJIax ROTOpOH MomHO 6bIJIO 6bI p;OCTaTOqHO TO'IRO <pIIRcIIpoBaTb
BpeMH HX «pOpMIIpOBaHIIH, He pa3pa6OTaHO II 06 enpIIHHTOH IICTOPIIRO-RYJIb-
TYPHOH RJIaCCII«pIIRan;IIII OTp;eJIbHbIX IIHp;eHCRIIX rpYIIn, KOTopaH II03BOJIHJIa 6bI
430 ,I
j
,
OCTaTOqHO TOqHO q,HRCHpOBaTb BpeMH CJIOmeHHH XapaRTepHbIX JIH HHX
RYJIbTypHbIX OCOOeHHOCTeM. BOJIbllIOM OO'beM apXeOJIOrHqeCIWM paOOTbI H ee
pe3YJIbTaTbI aroT B03MOmHOCTb HaMeTHTb RaRHe-TO BeXH, HO MHOrOe 3 eCL
eII(e OCTaeTCfl HeHCHbIM. IToaTOMY XpOHOJIOrHqeCRaH nOCJIe OBaTeJIbHOCTb no-
HBJIeHlUI npe ROB OT eJIbHbIX RpynHbIx nop;pa3geJIeHHll HHp;eMI(eB H3 A3HH
OCTaeTCH HeYCTaHOBJIeHHOM, HO no OTHOllIeHMIO R HHgeMI(aM Hap;eHe aHTpono-
JIOrIPIeCRHe HaOJIIogeHHH n03BOJIHIOT BbICRa3aTb HeROTOpbIe cooopameHIDI,
He6e3pa3JIHqHbIe gJIH onpegeJIeHMH BpeMeHH nOHBJIeHHH HX npegRoB B AMe-
pHRe.
ITo ynJIOII(eHHOCTH JIIII(a H Hoca HHgeMI(bI HageHe OJIH3RM R CMOHpCRMM
MOHrOJIOHgaM - TeM H3 HHX, ROTopbIe HaCeJIHIOT 3anap;HYIO M IOmHYIO CH-
OMpb, a TaRme qaCTHqHO I(eHTpaJIbHbIe paMOHbI BOCTOqHOM CHOHpM. BepxHeii
XpOHOJIOrHqeCROII rparmI(eM BpeMeHH IIX nepeCeJIeHHH B AMepHRY HBJIHeTCH,
OqeBHgHo, I TbICH'IeJIeTHe go H. a., Rorga q,OpMIIpOBaJIaCb IIJIH yme cq,op-
MUpOBaJIaCb ,o:peBlIeaCRMMOccRaH RYJIbTypa II npegl\II aCRIIMOCOB yme npomMBa-
JIM B paMOHax BepMHrOMopbH, «3anepeB» aTOT Y3RMM npoxog gJIH gBMmeHIIH
.gpyrIIx HapogoB 36. HMmHHH rpaHIII(a - BpeMH q,OpMIIpOBaHIIH TMnHqHOrO
gJIIr CII6IIPCRIIX MOHrOJIOIIgoB ROMnJIeRCa npII3HaROB, ROTopoe naJIeOaHTpOHO-
JIOrIIqeCRH q,MRcIIpyeTcH anoxoN HeOJIIITa, T. e. pyoemoM IV-III TbICHqeJIe-
TMM ]];0 H. a., HO MomeT BOCXOgMTb II R oOJIee paHHeMY BpeMeHH 37. TaRIIM
o6pa30M, HaIIOOJIee BepOHTHaH gaTa nOHBJIeHMH npep;ROB HHgeMI(eB HageHe Ha
AMepMRaHCKOM KOHTMHeHTe - IV-II TbICHqeJIeTIIH go H. a., II OHM npeg-
CTaBJIHJIII nOCJIep;HIOIO naJIeOMHgeNcRylO BOJIHY' B 3aCeJIeHIIII AMepIIRII, IIpeg-
rneCTBYIOII(YIO 3CKIIMOCCROM.
ITaJIeoreorpaqmH gpeBHeM BepIIHreMCRON CYIlIU peROHCTpYMpyeTcH Ha OC-
HOBe MlIorux reOJIOrIIqeCRIIX, reorpaq,UqeCRIIX II OMOJIOrU'IeCRIIX HCCJIegoBa-
HMM 38. 20000-14000 JIeT Ha3ag IIORpOBHoe OJIep;eHeHMe oopa30BbIBaJIO Be-
pIIHreMcRylO cYIIIy, TIORpbITYro orpOMIIbIMII MaccaMII JIbga, IIO ROTOPOMY B
AMepIIRY nepexogUJIU II3 A3IIII He TOJIbRO JIlOgII, HO II cTaga MJIeRoniiTalO-
II(UX 9. OCJIaOJIeHIIe JIegoBoro pemUMa Ha npOTHmeHIIII 14000-10000 JIeT
Ha3ag npIIBeJIO R oopa30BaHIIIO CHaqaJIa OqelIb HeOOJIbllIOrO npOJIIIBa, ROTO-
pbIM, nOCTeneHHO paCIlIMpHHCb (B 3TOM, nO-BIIp;IIMOMy, IIrpaJIO pO Jib He TOJIbRO
nOBbIllIeHIIe ypOBHH BOgbI BCJIegcTBIIe TaHHIIH JIegHIIRa, HO II qaCTUqHOe IIO-
HHmeHIIe CYIlIII B pe3yJIbTaTe IIHTeHCIIBHbIX TeRTOHIIqeCRIIX gBIImeHIIM) O,
HeCROJIbRO TbICHq JIeT Ha3ag gocTIIr COBpeMeHHOM IlIIIpIIHbI. TaRIIM oopa30M,
HaII60JIee OJIarOnpUHTHoe CYXOIIYTHoe nepegBIImeHIIe H3 A3UII B AMepURY no
RpOllIKe CYIlIII C IOra OT JIegHHRa 6bIJIO ocyru;eCTBJIeHO, Hago gYMaTb, B anoxy
XVIII - XII TbICWf8JIeTMM go H. a., XOTH oTgeJIbHbIe P;OBOJIbHO MHOrOqHCJIeH-
HbIe rpYlInbI JIlOgell npOHUKaJIU B AMepuKY, RaK MbI yoegIIJIIICb, H MHoro
n03me.
B onpeD,eJIeHUH BpeMeHU nOHBJIeHIIH nepBoro qeJIOBeKa B AMepIIRe MbI
n;eJIHKOM 3aBIICUM OT pa3paooToK reOJIOrOB II reoq,II3IIKOB, a OHU P;OBOJIbHO
npOTIIBOpeqMBbI. 30-40 JIeT Ha3ag BpeMH 3aCeJIeHUH AMepIIKM qeJIOBeKOM C
onopoN Ha RJIaCCIIqeCKIIe reOJIOrH'IeCKHe II reoMopq,OJIOrnqeCKIIe HaOJIlOge:mIH
nOCTYJIUpOBaJIOCb B 10000-12000 JIeT Ha3ag H. C IIOHBJIeHMeM pagMoyrJIe-
pogHoro MeToga Bce gaTIIpoBKH nOnOJI3JIII BrJIy6b II BpeMH 3aCeJIeHMH OTO-
gBIIHYJIOCb Ha 25 000-30 000 H game Ha 40 000 JIeT OT COBpeMeHHOCTH.
B nOCJIe).l,Hee BpeMH HaMeTHJIaCb OTqeTJIIIBaH npoTMBOnOJIOlliHaH TeHgeHI(MH,
oOH3aHHaH, OqeBIIgHo, CBOHM B03HIIKHOBeHHeM OOJIee KpIITIIqeeKoMy OTOOPy
06pa3I(OB gJIH gaTIIpoBKII H TeXHIIqeCKOM pa3paooTKe caMOM npOI(egypbI ga-
TIIpOBaHIIH: TOqHO gOKYMeHTHpOBaHHbIe gaTbI gJIH naMHTIUmOB e qeTRO:H
eTpaTurpaq,HeN He YXOgHT rJIyome 20000 JIeT, T. e. npaKTMqeCKII He npeBbI-
rnalOT BpeMeHH oopa30BaHIIH BepHHreMCKOM eYIlIII. To, qTO gJIH cuoupeRoro
431
naJIeOJIJua nOJIY'leHbI 60JIee paHHHe p;aTbI 42, He p;omRHO Hac cMynWTb H He
P;OJIiRHO 3aCTaBJIHTb, RaR aTO p;eJIaroT HeROTopbIe HCCJIep;OBaTeJIH, aBTOMaTH-
'leCRH 3aBbIIIIaTb B03paCT p;peBHeMIIIHX CTOHHOR B AMepHRe: p;JIHTeJIbHbIM OT-
pe30R BpeMeHH, lIeCOMHeHHO, 6bIJI Heo6xop;HM, 'lTo6bI npeOp;OJIeTb BepHHreM-
CRyIO cyrrry, p;a H caM nOHCR nYTH 'Iepe3 Hee Tpe60BaJI YCHJIHM MHorHX no-
ROJIeHHM. HeJIb3H ynycRaTb H3 BHP;y H Toro COBepIlIeHHO O'leBHp;Horo
06CTOHTeJIbCTBa, qTO p;peBHeMiliHe naMHTHHRH B npep;eJIax BepHlIrellCROM
CYiliH MDrJIH YMTH nop; BOP;y H Hep;ocTynHu COBpeMeHHOMY HCCJIep;OBaTeJIIO.
l!TaR, B CBeTe Bcero CRa3aHHoro MOiRHO npep;nOJIaraTb, 'ITO BOCTO'lHO-
a3HaTCRHe H p;aJIbHeBOCTO'lHbIe nonYJIHIJ;HH arrOXH BepXHero naJIeOJII'lTa, BnlI-
TaBInlIe B ce6H 3Ha'lHTeJIbHYro eBponeOHp;HYro npHMeCb, p;BHraHCb BP;OJIb TH-
XOOReaHCRoro IIo6epeiRbH C rora Ha ceBep, BCTynHJIH Ha BepHHreHCRIIH cyxo-
nYTHbIH MOCT H, nO-BHp;MMOMY, BP;OJIb ero roiRHOH RpOMRII OROJIO 20000 JIeT
Ha3a.D; Ha'laJIH npOHIIRaTb B AMepIIRY. AHTpOnOJIOrH'IecRoe pa3Hoo6pa3He HH-
p;eHn;eB pa3IIbIX paHoHoB AMepHRII rOBopMT 0 TOM, 'ITO aTO npOHHRHOBeHMe
I1IJIO HeCROJIbRHMH reHeTH'leCRH OTHOCHTeJIbHO lIe3aBHCIIMbIMH BOJIHaMH II 3a-
Mep;JIMJIOCb MJIM IIpepBaJIOCb C 06pa30BaHMeM BepMHrOBa npOJIMBa, T. e.
10000-12000 JIeT Ha3ap; npM nepexop;e R anoxe Me30JIMTa.
CJIep;yroID;MH aTan rrpOHMRHOBeHMH JIrop;eM B AMepMRY M3 CM6MpM OTHO-
CMTCH, RaR Mbl npep;nOJIaraeM, R ropa3p;o 60JIee IIo3p;HeMy BpeMeHM -
IV - II TbICH'IeJIeTMHM p;o H. a. II CBH3aH C nepeCeJIeHlIeM npep;ROB MHp;elIn;eB
Hap;eHe, P;JIH ROTOpUX xapaRTepHbl YiRe He TMXOOReaHCRMe, a BHYTPMCM6Mp-
CRMe reHeTM'leCRMe CBH3M. OCHOBaTeJIb rJIOTTOXpOHOJIOrMM M JIeRCMROCTaTM-
CTMRM M. CBop;eIlI BblcTynlIJI ,[wa p:eCHTMJIeTMH Ha3ap; C rMnOTe30H relleTM'le-
CRoro pop;CTBa H3bIROB Hap;eHe M 3anap;HOCM6MpCRMX, ROTopaH B Te rop;bI Ra-
3aJIaCb COBepilieHno q,aHTaCTM'lHOM. Op;HaRO, RaR MbI y6ep;MJIMCb, OHa HaXO.D;MT
nOp;TBepiRp;enMe B aHTpOnOJIOrM'leCRHX p;aHHbIX M p;OJIiRHa noaTOMY CHOBa
npMBJIe'lb BHIIMaHIIe JIIIHrBMCTOB Ha npep;MeT nOJIOiReHHbIX B ee OCHOBY H3bI-
ROBbIX peaJIMM. HaROHen;, TpeTMM aTan 3aCeJIeHMH AMepIIRII - npOHHRHOBe-
HMe npep;ROB aCRIIMOCOB, Rorp;a CHOBa Ha nepBbIM nJIaH BbIp;BnTaeTCH TMXO-
OReaHCRMM nyTb 3aCeJIeHHH, TaR RaR p;peBIleaCRIIMOCCRaH RYJIbTypa o6Hapy-
iRMBaeT p:eMoHcTpaTIIBHbIe apXeOJIOrII'IeCRMe aHaJIOrIIM C RYJIbTYPOM RaM'IaTRM
II. n06epeiRbH OxoTcRoro MOpH 43.
TaRoBa RapTMHa 3aCeJIeHIIH AMepMRll 'IeJIOBeROM, RaR OHa peROHCTpYII-
pyeTcH Het OCHOBe Mopq,OJIOrM'IeCRoro M3Y'IeHMH COBpe:MeHHbIX M p;peBHHX
nonYJIHn;MM.
HEROTOPbIE rEHOrEOrPAq,HqECRHE COOBPMKEHIIH
R peIlIeIHnO np06JIeMbI pop;cTBa aMepMRaHcRMx IIHp:eMn;eB C a3MaTCRMMM no-
nyJIHn;MHMII, nOMMMO Mopq,OJIOrM'IeCRIIX Ha6JIrop;eHMH, MorYT 6UTb npHBJIe'le-
HbI M reHeTM'leCRMe p;aHUbIe. B nepBYro O'lepep;b pe'lb Mp;eT 0 reHeTII'leCRMX
MapRepax - rpynnoBbIx q,aRTopax RpOBII, IICCJIep;OBaHHbIx y Bcex CROJIbRO-
HM6YP;b RpynHbIx aTHM'leCRMX 06ID;HOCTell B A3MM M AMepMRe. Ho reUeTM'le-
CRaH MHTepnpeTan;MH pa3BMBaeTCfl B HaCTOHID;ee BpeMH M B MOpq,OJIDrMII:
OTp;eJIbHbIe p;MCRpeTIIO BapbMpyroID;Me npM3HaRM Ha qepene paCCMaTpMBaroTcH
RaR npM3HaRM CO cpaBHMTeJIbHO npocToll HaCJIep;CTBeHHocTbro, T. e. p;eTepMM-
HMpyeMbIe B cBoeH HacJIep;cTBeHHoll nepep:a'Ie OP;HMM IIJIM .D;BYMH reHaMM.
B aTOM OTHOilieHIIM OHM MorYT YCJIOBHO npMpaBHMBaTbCH R rpynnaM RpOBM.
Ha aTOM II OCHOBaHbI p;OCTMiReHMH q,eHoreHeTIIRII, ycneiliHo pa3BMBaeMOH B
CCCP yCMJIMHMII H. B. TMMoq,eeBa-PecoBcRoro M A. B. H6JIOROBa ..,- HayJI:M
o peROHcTpyRn;MM reHeTM'leCROrO COCTaBa cOBpeMeHHblx M p;peBHMX IIony-
JIHn;MH Ha OCHOBaHMM BapMan;Mll npM3HaRoB C p;McRpeTHbIM npOHBJIeHMeM. Ha-
-"'"
,
432.
.'
:
'lImaH C nIIOIlepCKOII pa60TbI A. II P. EappII 5 npII3HaKII C p:IICKpeTIIbIM npo-
HB eHIIeM 3aHH II 60 bIIlOe MeCTO II B II3Y'leHIIII KpaHIIO OrIIII 'le OBe'leCKIIX
nOIIY Hn;IIH 6. Bce TaKIIe IIpH3HaKII paCCMaTpIIBaIOTCH KaK paBHOn;eHHbIe,
paBHOn;eHHbIMII B reHeTII'IeCKOM OTHOIIleIIIII1 C'lIITaIOTCH II rpYIIIIbI KpOBI1,
C IIOMOIIJ;bIO CTaHp:apTHOH CTaTIICTII'leCKOH IIpOn;eP:YPbI BbI'lIICmIeTCH CYMMap-
HbIH IIOKa3aTe b pa3 II'lIIH Memp:y CpaBHIIBaeMbIMII rpYIIIIaMI1, OH 11 HB H-
eTCH MepII.TIOM reHeTI1'leCKOH 6 1130CTII II II yp:a eHHOCTII rpYIIII p:pyr OT p:pyra.
haHaJJ:CKl1e aHTpOIIo orII II reHeTIIKII E. C'IaCl\IapII 11 H. OcceHGepr,
Ha pa60TY KOTOpbIX BbIIIIe CJJ:e aHa CCbmKa, ocy:rn;eCTBII II nop:oGHbIH nop:C'leT,
OXBaTIIB IIM nOIIY Hn;IIII KopeHHbIX Hapop:OB CII6IIPII, aCKI1MOCOB II aMepIIKaH-
CKIIX IIHp:eHn;8B. Pe3Y bTaT aToro nop:C'leTa OKa3a CH BIIO He OIIpep:e eHHbIM:
II no ,lII1CKpeTHO BapbIIpYIOIIJ;IIM npII3HaKaM Ha 'lepene, II no reHeTII'le-
CKIIM MapKepaM aCKIIMOCbI OKa3a IICb 6 IIme K ceBepoaMepIIKaHCKIIM IIHp:eHn;aM,
'leM K CII6IIpCKIIM MOHrO OIIp:aM, cII6IIpCKI1e MOHrO OIIp:bI n ceBepoaMepIIKaH-
CKIIe IIHp:eHn;bI OTCTOHT p:pyr OT p:pyra p:OCTaTO'lHO p:a eKO. CTaTbH, ony6 II-
KOBaHHaH B «Current anthropology» II B COOTBeTCTBIIII C npaKTI1KOH, npIIHH-
TOH B aTOM mYPHaJIe, oGcymp:aBIIIaHCH Ha ero CTpaHIIn;ax cnen;IIa IICTaMII 113
pa3HbIX CTpaH, BbI3Ba a Oml1B eHnbIH 06MeH MneHIIHMII II pHp: KpIITII'leCKHX
3aMe'laHIIII. CaMbuI BamHbIM p: H HaIIleH TeMbI 6bmo TO, 'ITO A. r. h03IIIIIWB
II P. MaKrlI BbIHBII II HeKOTopbIe MOMeHTbI B CTaTIICTIl'leCKllX npon;ep:ypax,
KOTOpbIe n03BO HIOT IIHTepnpeTIIpOBaTb pe3Y bTaTbI nop:C'IeTOB He TaK, KaK
IIX IIHTepnpeTIIpOBa II E. C'IaCMapII n H. OcceH6epr, II nOKa3aTb, 'ITO aMe-
pMKaHcKIIe aCKIIMOCbI OTCTOHT OT CIIGIIpCKIIx MOHrOJIOIIp:OB npaKTIIqeCKM He-
p:a bIIle, 'IeM OT aMepMKaHCKIIX IIHp:eHn;eB 7. haHap:CKIIe aBTopbI BbIHymJJ:eHbI
6bmII B CBoeM OTBeTe Ha KPMTIIKY cor aCIITbCH C aTMM BbIBOp:OM M p:ame npo-
M IOCTpMpOBa II ero cnen;IIa bHOH )J,IIarpaMMOH.
ABTOp, npIIHHB Yt.IaCTMe B P:MCKYCCIIII 8, nbITa CH npop:eMOHCTpIIpOBaTI.
B npOTIIBOBec cpaBHeHMIO rpynn no CYMMe npII3HaKOB 3HaqeHIIe p:IIcpcpepeH-
n;IIpOBaHHoro nop:xop:a K On;eHKe OTp:e bIIbIX IIpII3IIaKOB. TaKOH 1I0P:XOP: n03BO-
HeT paCCMaTpIIBaTb CTpoeHMe ropII30HTa bHoro IIpOcpII H IIn;eBoro CKe eTa
II pa3BIITIIe HOCOBOH 06 aCTII KaK npM3HaKII, MMeIOIIIne (I)YHp:aMeHTa bHoe
3HaqeHIIe p: H OTp:e eHIIH aMepIIKaHCKMX IIHp:eHn;eB OT KopeHHbIX napop:OB
CIIGIIpII, KO b CKOpO, KaK yme rOBopM OCb, 06e rpYIIIIbI Hapop:OB IIpOTIIRO-
CTOHTJJ:pyr p:pyry B BapIIan;IIHX aTMX Mopcpo orII'reCKMX oc06eHHOCTeiI. HMeH
IIOqTM IIC'lepnbIBaIOIIJ;Me )I;aHHbIe no CII6IIpCKMM Hapop:aM, H CMor IIpMBeeTK
Torp:a IillIb OrpaHII'IeHHYIO IIHcpopMan;IIIO 06 aMepIIKaHCKMX IIHp:eiIn;ax, KOTO-
PYIO MomHO 3Ha'IIITe bHO pacIIIIIpIITb ceifqac. COIIocTaB eHIIe no BceM aTIIM
npII3HaKaM' a3MaTCKMX aCI{IIMOCOB, no KOTOpbIM eCTb COOTBeTCTBYIOIIJ;IIe p:aH-
HbIe 9, C KopeHHbIMII Hapop:aMII CII6IIpII H CeBepHoiI AMepIIKII npMBop:IIT K
0p:H03IIa'lHoMy BbIBOJJ:Y: aCKIIMOCbI Ma o OTmpIaIOTCR OT cII6IIpCKI1:\: Hapop:OB
M BMeCTe e HIIMII IIpOTIIBOIIO('TaB HIOTCH aMepMKaHeKMM HHp:eiin;aM. E. C'la-
CMapn II H. OcceH6epr, ocnapIIBaH aTOT BbIBOp:, cIIpaBep: IIBo OTMeTII M, 'ITO
OH oIIMpa cH HIIIb Ha BbI60pO'IHbIe p:aHHbIe IIO MHp:enn;aM AMepnKII, He II3Y-
'IeHIIbIe B 3TOM OTIIOIIleHIIII rpYIIIIbI IIHp:eiIn;eB MorYT IIMeTb IIHbIe BapIIan;IIM.
Ho Bce IIpep:II1eCTBYIOIIJ;ee M3 omeHMe c ymIIT, KaK KameTCH aBTOpy, IIOP;-
TBepmp:eIIMeM 3aK IO'leHIIR, cp:e aHHoro B 1979 r.
Bo06IIJ;e, rOBopH 0 reIloreorpacpII'leCKMX p;aHHbIX, He b3H He OTMeTIITb MX
Heop:H03Ha'lHOCTb IIpM BbI60pe Memp;y pa3HbIMM reHeTII'leCKMMM rIInoTeaaMM.
CTapbIe nonbITKII nOKaaaTb, 'lTO AMepIIKa 6bma 3ace eHa HeGo bIIlon rpyn-
non IOp:ell 50 - HOCIITe eH reHa r, 'IeM II 06'bHCHReTCH nO'lTH nOJJ:aB RIOIIJ;ee
pacnpOCTpaHeHIIe cpep:M KopeHHoro HaCe eHI1H AMepMKII rpynIIbI 0, C IIIII-
KOM RBHO npOTIIBOpe'laT Bcen HaKon eHHoiI MHcpopMan;IIM M l\IOpcpO OrM'leCKO-
TO II MCTopIIKo-aTHO OrII'leCKOrO xapaKTepa, B TOM 'lIIe e n paCCMOTpeHHOM
:
433
BbIllie. OTp;eJIbHbIe OCTpOBRil BbICOROM ROHD;eHTpan;IIII reHa r B CeBepHOM A3I1I1
He 06H3aTeJIbHO P;OJIiRHbI MMeTb OTHOllieHile R aHaJIOrIl'IHbIM BapMaD;I1HM B
npep;eJIax AMepIlRaHCRoro MaTepMRa 51 - Bep;b p;peM<p reHOB I1p;eT aBTOMaTII-
'leCKH B pa3HbIX IIonYJIHD;I1HX He60JIbllIOrO 06'beMa. B npep;llIeCTBYIOII(IIX pa3-
p;eJIax aBTOp nbITaJICH nORa3aTb, 'ITO reHeTII'leCROe cBoe06pa3I1e aMepMRaH-
CRMX MHp;eMn;eB no reHY r npOMCTeRaeT 3a C'IeT p;eMCTBIIH npaBIIJIa H. I1. Ba-
BIIJIOBa, a I1MeHIIO BbIII(enJIeHMH pen;eCCMBHblX reHOB B YCJIOBIDIX M30JIH-
D;IIM Ha ORpaMne BMp;OBoro apeaJIa 52. TaR MJIM IIHa'Ie, cOBepllIeHHo O'ieBIIp;Ho:
reHeTM'IeCROe cBoe06pa3IIe aMepMRaHcRIIx MHp;eMn;eB TaRoBo, 'lTO OHO CBIIp;e-
TeJIbCTByeT 06 MX MHorOBeROBOM M30JIHn;MM II caMOCTOHTeJIbHOM pa3BIITnn:
paCOreHeTII'IeCRMX npOn;eCCOB Ha AMepIIRaHCROM MaTepIIRe 6e3 3Ha'IMTeJIbHbIX
nOCTopOHHIIX BJIMHHMM. HCXOP;HbIe paCOBbIe ROMnOHeHTbI a3MaTCRoro npoIlC-
XOiRp;eHMH, CJIOiRMBllIMeCH B npon;ecce CMeIIIeHMH eBponeOIlp;OB M MOHrOJIOIl-
P;OB, II p:OJIiRHbI 6bIJIM npeTepneTb B xOIl,e SToro caMOCTOHTeJIbHOro pa3BMTMH,
RaR yiRe rOBOpMJIOCb, cepbe3Hble Mop<p0JIOrM'IeCRIIe II reHeTM'IeCRMe M3MeHe-
HIIH, CTOJIb CMJIbHO 3aTpyp;HHIOII(Me IIOMCRM npHMbIX aHaJIOrMII aHTpOnOJIOrIl-
"IeCRIUI oco6eIIHucTHM aMepMRaHcRMx IIHp;errn;eB B CTapoM CBeTe.
, Hrdlicka A. Catalogue of human crania in the United States national museum col-
lections II Proceedings of United States national museum. Washington. 1924, 1927,
1928, 1930, 1940, 1942, 1944.
2 /l,e6elf r. (/J. AHTpOIIOJIOrIIqeCKlIe IICCJIegoBaHIIJI B KaMqaTCIWH OOJIaCTH. M., 1951 II
Tp. lIH-Ta 3THorpa!J!1I1I AH CCCP. H. C. T. 17.
" Jleeun M. r. KpaHIIOJIOrlIqeCKlIe TIIIIbI qYK'ICii II 3CKII1\1OCOB II Co. MY3eJl aHTpoIIo-
JIorlIlI II 3THorpa!J!IIII AH CCCP. M.; JI., 1949. T. 10.
i, 3THHqeCKaJl aHTpOIIOJIOrlIH II npOOJIeMbI 3THoreHe3a HapO)1;OB }J;aJIbHerO BocToKa. M.,
1958 (Tp. IIH-Ta 3THorpa!J!IIII AH CCCP. H. C.; T. 36).
fpYIInbI KpOBH y qYKqeH II 3CKHl\IOCOB II COB. 3THorpa!J!IIJI. 1958. M 5; On 3/Ce. HOBbIe
l\IaTepIIaJIbI no rpynnaM KpOBIi y 3CKIIl\IOCOB II JIaMYToB II TaM me. 1959. M 3.
.;; Hrdlicka A. The origin and antiquity of the American Indians. Washington, 194 .
7 Hrdliika A. Crania of Siberia II Amer. journal of phys. anthropology. Vol. 29, 1942.
N 4.
8 OK,wonuKoe A. n., Bacu.nbeeCKUii P. C. IIo AmICKe H AJIeYTcKIiM oCTpOBal\I. HOBo-
cH6HPCK, 1976.
1) Laughlin W. Problems in the physical antropology of North American Indians, Eski-
mos and Aleuts II Arctic anthropology. Vol. XVI, 1979. N 1. S. 165.
10 /l,e6elf r. (/J. 0 gpeBHeH rpaHH1.\C eBponeOII)1;OB II aMepIIKaHOII)1;OB B IDmHOH CIIOI1-
pH II COB. 3THOrpa!J!Hfl. 1947. M 1.
11 30.wrapee A. M. K nonpocy 0 IIpoIIcxom;:J;eHIIlI 3CKH11OCOB II AHTpon. mypH, 1937.
M1. '
12 Jleeun M. r. KpamwJIorlIqecmlC TIIIIbI qYKqeH l'f 3CKIIMOCOB.
i3 /l,e6elf r. W. AHTponoJIDrHqecKHe l'fCCJIep;OBaHIIfl B KaMqaTCKOii 06JIaCTl'f.
H Jleeun M. r. 06 aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOl\1 TIIIIe p;peBHIIX 3CKl'fMOCOB II COBpel\IeHHaJl aHTpo-
nO.:wnm. M., 1964; /l,e6elf r. W. IIaJWOaHTpOIIOJIDrIIqeCKlIii MaTepIIaJI II3 gpeBHe6e-
pl'fHr011OpCmiX l\!OrIIJIbHHKOB }T3JleH II 3KBeH II ApYTIOHOB C. A., CepreeB }J;. A. IIpoo-
JIeMbI 3THIIqeCKOii IICTOpIIII EeplIHrmIOpbfl: MOl'IIJIbHIIfi 3KBeH. M., 1975.
t" Szathmary E., Ossenberg N. Are the biological differences between North American
Indians and Eskimos truly profound? II Current anthropology. Vol. 19, 1978. N 4.
,I Howells W. W. Cranial variation in man. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1973.
17 /l,efielf r. W. AHTpOIlOJIDrIIqeCKIIe IICCJIe)1;OBaHIIJI B KaMqaTCKOII OOJIaCTII; On JlCe.
OIlbIT rpa!J!IIqeCKoro l'f306pameHIIJI reHeaJIOrIIqeCKOH KJIaCCII!J!IIKaUIIH qeJIOBeqeCKHX
pac I I COB. 3THorpa!J!IIfl. 1958. M 4.
's rUll36ype B. B. AHTpOIIOJIOrIIqeCKaJl xapaKTepIIcTIIKa gpeBHIIX aooplireHoB Ky6bI II
Co, I\IY3eJl aHTpOnOJIOrlIII II 3THorpa!J!IIII AH CCCP. M., 1967. T. 24.
'" .fllexeev V. P. On Eskimo origins II Current anthropology. Vol. 20, 1979. N 1.
z.) PoeuncKuu H. H. IIp06JIeMa IIpoIIcxomgeHIIJI MOHrOJIbCKOrO paCOBoro TIIIIa II AHTpoII.
mypH. 1937. M 2.
2, A.neKceee B. n. IIaJIeOaHTpOnOJIDrIIJI 3eMHoro mapa II !J!Opl\lIIpOBaHIIe qeJIOBeqeCKIiX
pac. M., 1978.
22 Weidenreich F. On the earliest representatives of modern mankind recovered on
the soil of East Asia II Peking natural history bulletin. Vol. 13, 1939. N 3.
j
-
j
434
I
3
i
"
,
23 WOO Ju-kand. Human fossil Found in Liukiang, Kwangsi, China II Vertebrata pala-
siatica. Vol. III, 1959. N 3.
24 MeTpH'IecKYIO XapaKTepllcTHKY CM.: AJWKCeee B. II. IIaJIeoaHTporrOJrorHH 3eMHoro
mapa H 1J>0pMHpoBaHHe 'IeJIOBe'IeCKllX pac.
25 /{e6elf F. W. <l>parMeHT JI06HOII KOCTH'IeJIOBeKa H3 KYJIbTypHOro CJIOH CTOHHKH «A!J>oH-
TOBa ropa II» rrop; RpacHoHpcROM /I BIOJI. ROMHC. rro H3yq. 'IeTBepTH'I. rrepHop;a. 1946.
;M 8.
26 Black D. A study of Kansu and Honan aeneolothic skulls and specimens from later
Kansu prehistoric sites in comparison with North China and other recent crania /I
Paleontologia Sinica, series D. Vol. VI. F t 1. Peking, 1928; Jen /in. Report on th
skeletal remains from the neolithic site at Bao Ji, Shensi II Paleovertebrata et pa-
leoanthropologia. 1960. N 3; Idem. Investigations of the neolithic human skeletons
unearthed at Pan Po, Sian II Kaogu (Archaeology). 1960. N 9; Idem. Neolithic human
skeletons unearthed at Hua-Asien, Shensi II Kaogu suebao. 1962. N 2.
27 KplOKoe M. B., CoifJponoe M. B., fJe6oKcapoe H. H. )];peBHHe KHTaiiI.(bI: rrpOOJIe IbI
<JTHOreHe3a. M., 1978; fJe6oKcapoe H. H. 3THH'IeCKaH aHTpOrrOJIOl'lIH RHTaH (pacoBaH
MoplJ>OJIOrllH cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHHH). M., 1982.
28 CBop;Ka gaHHbIX: AAeKceee B. II., FoxJotan 11. 11. AHTporroJIorHH a3HaTCRorr 'IaCTH
CCCP. M., 1984.
29 Suzuki H. Microevolutional changes in the Japanese population from the prehistoric'
age to the present day II Journal of the Faculty of science, University of Tokyo, sec-
tion V. Anthropology. Vol. III, 1969. N 4.
3. FOXMan 11. 11. IIpoHcxollip;eHHe n;eHTpaJIbHOa3HaTcKOM pacbI B CBeTe HOBbIX rraJIeOaH-
TpOrrOJIOI'H'IeCKHX MaTepHaJIOB II C6. MY3eH aHTpOrrOJIOmH 11 <JTHorpalJ>HH AH CCCP.
II., 1980. T. 36.
31 AAeKceee B. II. HOBbIe gaHHbIC 0 eBporreoHp;HoM pace B IJ;eHTpaJIbHOII A3Hll II BpoH-
30BbIM II llieJIe3HbIM BeK Cll6HpH. HOBocHollpcK, 1974; MaMonoea H. H. AHTporroJIo-
rH'IeCKHM Tllrr p;peBHero HaCeJIeHHH 3arragHoH MOHrOJIllH rro p;aHHbIM rraJIeOaHTporro-
JIOI'HH /I C6. MY3eH aHTpOrrOJIOI'HH H <JTHorpalJ>llll AH CCCP. II., 1980. T. 36.
32 OKAaonUKoe A. II. IIaJIeoJIHT IJ;eHTpaJIbHOM A3HH. HOBocll6HpcK, 1981.
33 Montandon G. La race, les races, mise au point d'ethnologie somatique. Paris, 1933;'
Eickstedt E. Ra5senkunde und Rassengeschichte del' Menschheit. Stuttgart, 1934; Idem_
Rassendynamik von Ostasien. China und Japan. Thai und Khmer von der Urzeit big
heute. Berlin, 1944.
34 CM., oarrp.: C{ e60Kcapoe H. H. K Borrpocy 0 rrpoHcxollip;eHHH KHTalIn;eB I I COB. <JTHO-
rpalJ>HH. 1947. ;M 1.
35 Smith F. H. The skeletal remahlS of the earliest Americans: a survey II Tenesse
anthropologist. Vol. 1. 1976.
3(; /{UKoe H. H. ApxeoJIorH'IeCKlle rraMHTHHKH KaI\I'IaTKH, qYKOTKH II BepXHeII KOJIbII\IbI.
M., 1977; On 3/Ce. )];peBHlIe KYJIbTypbI CeBepo-BocTo'IHOH A3HH. M., 1979.
87 AAeKceee B. II., FOXMan IJ. IJ. AHTpOrrOJIOrlIH a3HaTcKoIl 'IaCTH CCCP.
8B BepHHI'HH B KaHH030e. BJIagHBocToK, 1976; Hopkins D. M. (ed.). The Bering land
bridge. Stanford, California, 1967.
39 mep A. B. MJIeKorrHTaIOII.(lIe H cTpaTHrpalJ>HH rrJIeMCTOn;eHa KpaMHero ceBepo-BocToKa
CCCP H CeBepHoM AMepHRII. M., 1971.
4J JIuno6epz F. J'. qeTBepTH'IHbIII rrepHOp; B CBeTe olIOI'eorpalJ>lI'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX. M.; II.,
1955; Ou 3/Ce. KpyrrHbIe KOJIeOaHIIH ypOBHH OKeaHa B 'IeTBepTII'IHbIM rrepHO.a;. II., 1972.
41 Wormington H. Ancient man in .\iorth America. Denver, Colorado, 1957.
42 MO'lanoe EO. A. )];peBHeMmHe <JTarrbI 3aCeJIeHHH 'IeJIOBeKOM CeBepo-BocTo'IHOH A3HH.
HOBocH6HpcK, 1977.
43 CI\I. rrpIIMe'I. 36.
4' TUMoifJeee-PecoecKUU H. B., 96Ao1we A. B. <l>eHbI, lJ>eHeTHKa H <JBOJIIOn;IIOHHaH 6110-
JIOI'HH II IIpHpo.a;a. 1973. ;M 5; 96,o701we A. B. CDeHeTIIHa. M., 1980.
45 Berry A. C. and R. I. Epigenetic variation in human cranium II Journal of anatomy.,
Vol. 101, 1967. N 2.
H CM., Harrp.: K o8uulfee A. r. )];IIcKpeTHbIe rrpH3HaKH Ha 'Iepen<lx <JrrOXH OpOH3bI H3
IOlliHorr CHonpII II C6. MY3eH aHTpOrrOJIOrIIII II 3THorpalJ>IIH AH CCCP. II., 1980. T. 36.,
41 McGhee R. Comments II Current anthropology. Vol. 19, 1978. N 4; Kozintsev A.
On Eskimo origins II Current anthropology. Vol. 20, 1979. N 1.
48 Alexeev V. On Eskimo origin II Current anthropology. 1979. Vol. 20, N 1.
43 /{e6elf r. W. AHTpOrrOJIOrII'IeCKIIe HCCJIep;OBaHIIH B KaI\I'IaTCKOII 06JIaCTH; A"wKce-
ee B. II., BaAyeea T. C. MaTepIIaJIbI rro KpaHIIOJIOrIIH a3IIaTCKIIX <JCKHI\IOCOB II COB.
<JTHorpaIJ>HH. 1976. ;M 1; Alexeev V. The craniology of the Arctic Eskimo II Arctic
anthropology. Vol. 2, 1964. N 2.
50 Wormington H. Origins II Program of the history of America, Indigenous period, I.,
Vol. 1. Mexico, 1953; /{e6elf r. W. AHTporroJIorHH CH6HpH H rrp06JIel\Ia 3aCeJIeHHH
4
:
,
1
"
f-
'
435
;.
A!\1epHKIiI II HayqHaH KOH4>epeHI.\HH no IiICTOpIIII CH61i1pH II ,l];a.m.Hero B6cToKa. CeK-
IiIH apxeOJronnr. 3THorpaqmlil. aHTpOnOJIOrHH H HCTopmr CIiI61i1plil iii ,l];aJIbHerO BocToKa
,!\00KTH6pbCKoro neplilop,a: Tea. p,OKJI. iii co06m;. I1PKYTCK, 1960.
" PbPuwe 10. r. Oc06eHHocTIiI cepoJIOrUqeCKOll p,ll(p«pepeHIlHa uH Hapop,oB CU6UpH II
Bonp. aHTpOnOJIoruH. 1965. BbIn. 21.
".2 A.qeKCeee B. II. reorpaqmH qeJIOBeqeCKHX pac. M., 1974.
3AKJIIOlIEHI1E
'CpaBHIITeJIbHO npocTaH 3ap;aqa - nOIJ:BeCTII IITor cop;epmaHIIIO OqepKOB, 00-
pa3YlOIII,IIx TpeTblO qaCTb <noH KHurII. Mx D,eJIblO 3hIJIO nOKa3aTb, ITO aHTpo-
rrOJIOrIIqeCKIIe gaHHbIe B IIIIIpOIWlII CMbICJIe CJIOBa, T. e. BKJIlOqaH II naJIeo-
aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCI{IIe, C ycnexoM MOryT ObITb IICnOJIb30BaHbI Ha pa3HbIx CIIH-
XpOITITbIX cpe3ax B peI{oHcTpYI{ IIII qpe3BbIqaHHO pa3HbIx no cBoeMY xapaK-
'Tepy 3THOreHeTlIqeCKIIX cIITyaD,IIH - npIIypwleHHocTII K pa3HbIM 3noxaM,
J(OcTctTOqnO ROHI{POTIlbIM B JIanp;IIIaqJTnO-KJIIIMaTIIqeCKOM OTHomeHIIII pa3JIIIq-
HbIi\1 reorpaqmqeCKIIM 06JIaCTHM, HerroBTopIIMO CBoeoopa3HbIM X03HHCTBeHHbIM,
COD,IIaJILHbIM II p;er.lOrpaqmqeCIHIM yCJIOBIIHM. ITpoBegeIlHaH peKoIIcTpYKD,IIH
npn 3TOM nOCTOHHHO COOTHOCIIJIaCb C pe3yJIbTaTaMII IICTOPIIIW-3THOJIOrII-
qeCI{IIX IICCJIep;OBaHIIH, HO II OHII KoppeKTIIpOBaJIIICb C ee nOMoIIl,blO. IIoJIyqeH-
HbI!!: CIIHTe3 OqepqIIBaeT rpaHIID,bI y1Ke p;ocTIIrHYTbIx B03MomHocTeH II HaMe-
qaeT KOHTYPbI p;aJIbHeHIIIeH pa3pa6oTKII HpOOJIeMbI COHOCTaBJIenIIH aHTpoHo-
,JIOrIIqeCKIIX lIaHHbIX co BceMII p;pyrIIMII BIIlIaMn nCTOpnqeCKIIX HCTOqHHIWB.
qTO BbITeI{aeT H3 Bcex paccMoTpeHHbIx XpOHOJIOrHqeCI{II pa3HoBpeMeHHbIx
II JIOKaJIbHO pa3Hooopa3HbIx MaTepHaJIOB? AHTpOnOJIOr:wlecKHH MaTepnaJI no-
3BO.JIHJI YJIOBHTb OCHOBHbIe TeHp;eHD,HH pa3BnTIIH Ji( rJIaBHbIe HaHpaBJIeHIIH
MnrpaD,HH rrprr CJIOmeHIIH HaCeJIeHIIH D,eJIoro MaTepHI{a, a HMeHHO Ar.mpHKII.
IIpn paccMoTpeHHH <popr.mpoBaHHH oTgeJIbHbIX HapogoB Ha R'aBI{a3e, B Cpep;-
Eell A3IIII II IOmHolI CHOHpII aHTpOHOJIOrHqeCIme p;aHHbIe gaJIH B03MomHOCTb
RaK peKoHcTpYHpoBaTb p;peBHeHIIIIIe HCTOKII Tex IWMHoHeHToB, IWTopbIe Hpep;-
CTi:lBJIenbI B COCTaBe cOBpeMeHHoro HaCeJIeHHH, TaK H qJIIKCHpOBaTb COObITIIH
rr03J HHX 3TaHOB ero IICTOpHII. ECJIII rOBopIITb 0 rJIyoHHHbIX peKoHcTpYKD,IIHX
3TIIoreHe3a, TO OHH OTqeTJIHBO IWHD,eHTpIIpYIOTCH BOKpyr II3yqeHIIH npOD,ec-
COB aHTpOrrOJIOrHqeCI{OrO H IICTOPHKO-KYJIbTypHoro pa3BHTIIfl B yCJIOBIIHX
II30JIHD,IIH, npep;onpegeJIJIer.IOH B nepBYIO Oqepegb 3KCTper.IaJIbHOH reorpa<p II -
qeCHOH cHTyaD,HeH - npomHBaHHeM. CHameM, B BbICOKoropHbIX paHOHax.
B TO me BpeMH BJIHHHHe reorpaqmqeCIWll cpep;bI HeJIb3H rrpeYBeJIIIqHBaTb,
p;ame eCJIII OHa H CTaBIIT TpygHbIe Hp06JIeMbI nepeg qeJIOBeqeCKHMII KOJIJIeK-
TImaMH. HpI{HH npIIMep B 3TOM OTHOIIIeIIIIII HpegcTaBJIHIOT COOOH H30JIHpOBaH-
nHe rronYJIHD,IIll ,l],arecTaHa, pHg II3 I{OTOPbIX rOBopflT Ha ogHoaYJIbHbIX H3bI-
Kax, He nMelOIII,HX BHeIIIHHX aHaJIOnIll. Ha npOTflllieHIIII II,eCHTIIJIeTIIH CqIITa-
,JIOCb OqeBIIp;HbIM, T£TO B03HIII{HOBeHHe H30JIUpOBaHHbIX H3bIKOB B ,l],arecTaHe
HMeeT cBoelI npIIqHHOH TpygHogOCTYHHbIe nepeBaJIbI n npomHBaHHe B oTgeJIb-
IIbTX 3aMI{HYTbIX gOJIIIHaX, T. e. reorpaqmqeCKHe yc.rrOBIIH B IIIIIpor{OM CMbICJIe
.CJIOBa. MemI:{y TeM II B 3TOM CJIyqae, nO-BHgHMOMY, HMeJIa MeCTO HepeOD,eHHi:I
po.mI reorpdqJIPleCKHX OOCTOHTeJILCTB. JI. M. JIaBpoB HpHBeJI y6eI:{IITeJIbHbIe
<paRTbI H coo6pameHHH B HOJIb3Y Toro, qTO MHoroo6pa3IIe H3bIKOB B Aare-
':Tarre II HaJIIIqHe H30JIHpOBaHHbIX H3bIHOB OOH3aHbI CBOHM rrOHBJIeHIIeM BHYT-
::HICeJIeHHOH 3HI:{OraMIIII \ T. e. <PaHTOPY COD,naJIbHOMY.
. qTO I{aCaeTCH car.lOro 3THoreHeTII IeCI{OrO rrpOD,eCca, TO, nOmaJIYH, MomHO
IWHCTaTIIpOBaTb gBa MOMeHTa, BbITeHalOIII,IIe H3 aIITpOrrOJIOrHqeCKIIX CO no-
.CTaBJIeHIIH. R'oMrroHeHTbI aHTpOrrOJIOrHqeCHOH CTPYHTypbI, Te IIJIII HHbIe JIO-
-,';
.
"
'
436
i
..KaJlhHble BapHaHTbI, BXOp,HIl\Me B COCTaB COBpe IeHHbIX HapOJ OB, M IeIOT, RaR
npaBMJIO, p,peBHee npOMCXOmp,eHMe H npOCJIemMBaIOTCH C Onpep,eJIeHHbIMM MO-
.p,M<pIIKan;MHMH p,0 3nOXM 6pOH3bI M HeOJIMTa. B 3TOM, RaR yme neOp,HOI{paTHO
rOBOpMJIOCh Bblille, M COCTOMT CMJIa aHTpOnOJIOrM'IeCRMX p,aHHbIX RaR MaTepHa-
..ITa p,JIH 3THoreHeTMqeCRMX na6JIIOp,eHHH. Ho anTpOnOJIOrHqeCRMH comaB JII060-
ro HapO)J,a, KaR OH <PHRcHpyeTcH B COBpeMeHHYIO :moxy, CRJIap,bIBaeTCH B
CBoeM OROHqaTeJIhHOM BMp,e B nOp,aBJIHIOIl\eM 60JIhillHHCTBe CJIyqaeB cpaBnH-
TeJIbHO n03p,HO - B 3noxy cpep,neBeKOBbH MJIM qYTh paHhille, B Ronn;e I TbICHqe-
JIeTMH p,o H. 3.- Ha IaJIe H. 3. ITonbITRe aprYMeHTHpOBaTh 3TO nOJIOmenMe no
OTHOIlleHMIO R napop,aM CH6MpM 6bIJIa nOCBHIl\eHa Cnen;MaJIhHaH CTaThH 2,
HO OHO RameTCH cnpaBep,JIMBbIM M B n;eJIOM, OTpamaH KaRHe-TO cnen;H<pHqe-
.CRMe epTbI npOn;eCCOB 3THo06pa30BaHMH M 3THoreHe3a.
Pa3YMeeTCH, nop,06HbIH BbIBOp, He MMeeT a6COJIIOTHOrO 3HaqeHMH - Bblille
npMBop,MJIMCh npMMepbI cTa6MJIhHOCTH aIITpOnOJIOrMqeCI{MX npM3HaROB Ha npo-
THmenMlJ TbICHqeJIeTMH. Ho B OOIl\eM rrepMOp, OT TbICHqeJIeTMH p,o P,BYX rrpII-
MepHO COOTBeTcTByeT cTa6MJIhHOH <pa3e pacoreHe3a, Ha rrpOTHmeHMH 60JIee
p,mITeJIhHOrO cpOKa yme HMeIOT MeCTO aHTpOrrOJIOrMqeCRMe M3MeHeHHH. Ta-
RMM 06pa30M, rrepexop, OT C06bITMH pacoreneTMqeCKOH HCTOpHH R C06bITMHM
.3THoreHeTHqeCKOH IICTOpHH OCYIl\eCTBJIHeTCfl TOJIbRO B pa lRax Ha3BaHHoro
npoMemyTRa BpeMeHH, 60JIee p,eTaJIhHaH peROHCTpYRn;Hfl 3THoreHe3a ua OC-
HOBe aHTpOrrOJIOrHqeCI{HX p,aHHbIX B03MomHa JIHillh B MCRJIIOqHTeJIbHbIX CJIY-
-:qaHX.
1 JIaepoe JI. 11. 0 IIpH'IHHaX MHOrOH3bl'IIIH B AareCTaHe II COB. 3THorpaWIIH. 1951. 2.
Z A..zeKceee B. II. 0 xapaKTepe 3THoreHeTII'IeCKIIX npoIJ;eccoB Ha TeppHTopIIU CU6IIpH
B CBeTe aHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCKHX p;aHHhIX 111I3B. CH6HpCKoro OTp;eJIeHHH AH CCCP. Cep.
MCTOpIIH, WHJIOnOrHH H WHJIOCOWHH. 1984, 9. BhIII. 2.
;
.
437
I1pep;IlCJIOBHe .
CO ,1J;EPlliAHI1E
3
qacTb IIepBaH
AHTPOIlo orHH: ROHTYPLI HAYRH
TeopeTH'IeCKoe HaCJIep;He 3HreJIbCa 11 aHTpOIIOJIOrH'IeCKaJl HaYKa 5
AHTpoIIoJIorHJI: HeKUTOpbIe HTorH H IIepcIIeKTHBbI HCCJIe));OBaHHD 14
PacIDHpeHHe rpaHIIn; HaYKH 14
reHeTH'IeCKJ2IH IIOP;XOp; . . . . . . . . . . . 17
I1onyJIHn;HOHHIiIH IIO));XO)); . . . . . . . . . . 18
ECTecTBeHHLIH oT60p 11 COn;HaJILHhIe 3aKoHoMepHocTH 19
8THoreHeTH'IeCKJ2IH acrreKT 21
OT aHTpOIIOJIOrHH K 3K30aHTpOrrOJIOrHH . 23
rOpHSOHTbI aHTpoIIOJIOrHH . 24
AHTpoIIoJIorHH - MOpWOJIOrII'IeCKaH HaYKa 24
HOBIiIe BeHHHH 24
CTPYKTypHIiIe ypOBHH 1ICCJIep;OBaHHH . 26
I1porH03 . . 30
AHTpoIIoJIorHJI H MOp OJIOrHH (B CBJl3H C Y'Ie6HOD KHHroii: IIO MOp OJIOrHH
'IeJIOBeKa) 35
reHeTH'IeCKHe acrreKTbl aHTpoIIOJIOrHH 40
qeJIOBeK KaK IIpep; IeT reHeTH'IeCKOrO H3Y'IeHHH 41
3Ha'IeHlle aHTpOIIOJIOrll'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX P;JIH reHeTH'IeCKHX HCCJIep;OBaHHH 42
AHTpOIIOJIOrIIH II [eUeTlIKa B ux B3aII lOCBH3II 46
3Ha'IeHHe reHeTII'IeCKIIX p;aHHbIX B aHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKHX HCCJIep;OBaHIIHX 49
AHTpoIIOJIOrIIH H reHeTIIKa B HX BJIIIHHHH Ha 06ID;ecTBo . 52
reHeTHKa H aHTpOIIOJIOrHJI . . . . . . 58
feHoreOrpaWll'IeCKlle rrpaBllJIa, YCTaHOBJIeHIIbIe H. 11. BaBIIJIOBIiIM 58
reHoreorpaWHH H WOpMHpOBaHHe eBpoIIeoHp;oB . 62
3Ha'IeHHe TPY));OB H. H. BaBIIJIoBa P;JIJI TeOpeTH'IeCKOD aHTponOJIOrHH 67
8KcIIep;Hn;IIlI 68
IJ;eHTpbI rrpOllCXOJRp;eHHH KYJIbTypHOH WJIOpIiI . . . . 76
OTTecHeHlle pen;eCCHBOB Ha oKpaHHY apeaJIa . 83
fOMOJIOrH'IeCKIIe pHIIIiI B HaCJIep;CTBeHHoH H3MeH'IHBOCTH 93
3KOJIOrHH 'IeJIOBelm (B3rJIH));bl aHTpOIlOJIOroB) 99
IIorrYJIJlD;HOHHaJl CTPYKTypa 'IeJIOBe'IeCTBa H HCTOpII'IeCKaJl aHTpOrrOJIOrHJI 107
PaMKII llCTOpII'IeCKOH aHTpOIIOJIOrHH 107
I1p06JIeMbI IICTOpH'IeCKOH aHTpOIIOJIOrHH 109
I1onYJIHn;IIH . . . . . . . . . . 112
IIaJIeoaHTpoIIoJIorH'IecKaH IIOIIYJIHl{1IH 115
BbIBOP;bI . . . . . . . 1'18
438
IIcTOpH'IeCKaH aHTpOrrOJIOrHH: rrp06JIeMLI H rrepcrreKTHBbI .
MeCTo HCTOpIl'IeCKOll aHTpOrrOJIOrHH B CHCTeMe aHTponOJromH
<DYH)];aMeHTaJIbHble rrp06JreMbI HCTOpHqeCKOll aHTpOrrOJIOrHH
3nOJJlOqHoHHLIe acrreIiTLI aHTpOrrOJIOrml )1;peBHero HaCeJIeHHH
IIocTaHoBKa Borrpoca . . . . .
Pa3Max BH)];OBOii: H3MeHqHBOCTH .
CTerreHb MOPWOJIOrHqeCKOII crreqHWHqHOCTH rrorrYJIHqHii:
XapaKTep Bll)];OBOll H3MeHqHBOCTH
I1arrpaBJIeHHLIe H3MeHeHllH IIpH3HaKOB BO BpeMeHH
3aKJIIO'IeHHe
qacTb BTopaH
TEOPETlIqECKIIE IIPOEJIEMbl
3THorEHETIIQECKIIX PEI{OHCTPYInJ;1I1l
ElI.:\e pas 0 IlOCTaHOBKe IIp06JIeM 3THoreHesa .
ROMllJIeKC HaYK H O)];Ha HaYKa
IIcTOpHqeCKHe paMKII 3THoreHeTHQeCKOrO HCCJIC)];OBaHHH
HSbIR KaK 9TIIHQeCKHii onpe)];eJIHTeJIb . . . .
, hHOrpaWHQeCKHe )];aHHbIe 11 9THoreHe3
POJIb apXeOJIOrHH B 9THoreHeTHQeCKOM HCCJIe)];OBaHHH
J\HTpOllOJIOrHQeCKHll MaTepHaJI RaK HCTOpHQeCKHll HCTOQHHK
l{oMllJIeKCHOCTb )];aHHLIX H lIX COIIO)];QHHeHHe .
o paSJIHQHH CHHxpOHHoro H )1;HaXpOHHoro cpaBHeHHH 3THorpacpH1JeCKHX HB-
ReHHn . . . . . . .
IIOCTaHOBKa np06JIeMLI
CHHxpOHHoe cpaBHeHHe
J(HaXpOHHoe cpaBHeHHe
BJIIIHHHe reOrpaWHQeCKOll Cpe)];bI Ha 9THOrpaWH1JeCKHe HBJIeHHH
CKOpOCTb H3MeHeHlIH 9THOrpaWH1JeCKIIX HBJIeHHii:
o llepeXO)];e OT CHHxpOHHoro cpaBHeHlIH K )];HaXpOHHOMY . .
o rpaHHqax )];HaXpOHHoro cpaBHeHlIH B WOJIbKJIOpHCTHRe
3THoreHeTH1JeCKHe IIpe)1;aHHh, JIHHrnHCTH1JeCKHIIJ ):IaHHbie, aHTpOrrOJIOrH1Je-
CKHll IaTepHaJI
OGocHoBaHHe xapaKTepa corrOCTaBJIeHllll . .
ITpocTpaHCTBO 9THoreHeTH1JeCKHX cHTyaqHH
IIaJIeoaHTporrOJIorHH H HCTOpHH
IIaJIeOaHTpOrrOJIOrH1JeCKHII MaTepHaJI KaK HCTOpIIQeCKHll HCT01JHHK
PeKOHCTpYKqHH 01JarOB aBTOXTOHHoro pa3BHTIIH
PeKOHCTpYKI.:\IIH )1;peBHHX MHrpaqHii:
AHTpOnOJIOI'II1JCCKaH )];HWWY3HH
YCTaHOBJIeHHe BpeMeHII KOHKpeTHbIX 9THoreHe30B
3aKJIIO'IeHHe . . . . . . . .
qacTb TpeTbH
IICTOPIIIW-AHTPOIIOJIOrIIQECIWE 1I3YtIEHHE
KOImPETHblX 3THorEHE30B
K HCTOpIl'leCIWii IIHTepnpeTan;I1H peSYJIbTaTOB HSY1JeHHH I1aJIeOaHTpOrrOJIO-
mH CTerren EBpasHH n CKH«pCKoe npeMH . . . . . 206
BBe)];eHIIe . . . . . . . . 206
MOrHJIbHIIKII, )];aBIIIHe p;OCTaT01JHO npe)];CTaBIITeJIbHLIii: rraJIeOaHTpOnOJIOrII-
'ICCKHll MllTepHaJI _ _, . ,. . 209
439
121
121
123
131
131
131
134
136
138
141
144
144 ..
145
146
148
150
152
153
155
155
157
160
162
163
166
167
171
171
174
190
190
193
196
198
200
204
l'eorpalJ>ll'ICCKaH HSMeU'IHBOCTL . . .
PacoreHeTH'IeCKOe HCTOMKOBaHne
::hHoreHeTH'IeCKHe HTorH . . . . . . .
IIaMeop;eMorpaIJ>H'lecKHe Ha6mop;eHHH . .
YpOBeHL mHSHH H 06eCIIe'IeHHOCTL IIHII:\eH
3aKMIO'leHHe
HeKOTOpbIe np06MeMLI IIpOHCXOm)1;eHHJI 6ammpqeB H Kapa'laeBqeB B CBeTe
)1;aHHbIX aHTponOMorHH
BBop;HbIe SaMe'laHHH . . . . . .
COMaTOMOrIf1IeCKHe gaHHbIe . . .
IIaMeoaHTponoMorH'lecKHe gaHHbIe
06cymgeHHe CYII:\eCTBYIOII:\HX rHIIOTes
BbIBO)1;bI
AHTponoJIorH'IecKHe )1;aHHbIe H npOHCXOm)1;eHHe OCeTHHCKOrO uapO)1;a
MCTOpHII HSY'IeHHH . . . . .
COMaTOMorHH II THnOMOrH'leCKaH xapaKTepHCTHKa
l{paHHOJlOrII'leCKHe BapHaIlHH .
rHIIOTesa ceBepHbIX aHaMorHlI .
IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOMOrH'leCKHe co06pameHHH
8THoreHeTII'leCKHe co06pameHHH
HeKOTopLIe IIepcneKTHBLI gaMbHeHmHX HCCJIegoBaHHH
B saII:\IITY IIcnOMbSOBaHlUI aHTpOIIOMOrII'leCKHX gaHHblx B <JTHoreHeTII'leCKOM
HccMegoBaHHII oceTHH . . . .. ....
AHTponoJIorH'IecIDIe )1;aHHble K np06JIelUe npOHcxom)1;eHHH HaCeJIeHnJl qeHT-
paJIbHbIX npegropHii l{aBKascKoro xpe6Ta
COCTOHHHe MaTepHaMOB . . . . . . . . .
I'HnoTesbl IIpOHcxomp;eHHH KaBKaCHOHCKoro THna
cDaKTLI, KOTOpbIe cMegyeT Y'lHTbIBaTb npH 06cymgeHIIH rHIIOTeSLI M. r. A6-
gymeJIIIIIIBHJIII
cDaKTbl, KOTOpbIe cMegyeT yq:IITbIBaTb npH 06cymgeHHH rIInOTeSbI 1'. cD. ,JJ;e6en;a
rHIIOTesa HSOMHn;HII
B.>IBOgbl
,JJ;peBHeiimee eBpOneOH)1;Hoe HaceMeHHe CpegHeii ASHH Hero IIOTOMIDI
06sop rIInOTes npOIICXOFKJJ:eHIIH naMHpo-lJ>cpraHcKoH pacbl .
MoplJ>oMOrII'leCKIIe OTMH'lIIH naMHpCKHX HapogoB OT ys6eKoB H TagmHKoB
IIaMeoaHTpOIIOJIOrII'IeCKIIe conOCTaBMeHHH
BLIBOgLI
OnblT aHTpOnOJIOrH'leCKOii oqeHKH cKYJIbnTYP XaM'laJIHa H aJIbBepSHHa
AHTpoIIOMOrII'IeCKIIe acneKTbl Hsyq:eHHJI )1;peBHeii CKYJIbIITYPbI
MSY'leHHe CKYJIbnTYP ,JJ;aMbBepsHHa H XaM'laHHa C IIOMombIO COMaTOJIOrIf1Ie-
cKolI MeTogIIKII
PacoBaH gIIarnocTIIKa H reHeSIIC HaceMeHHH CeBepHOll BaKTpIIH
AHTponOJlOrII'leCIDIe acneKTLI IIH)1;onpaHcKoii np06MeMbI
COMaTOJIOrIP1eCKIIe gaHHble . . .
ITaMeoaHTpOnOJIOrII'leCKaH peTpocIIeKTIIBa
R aHTpOIIoMorHII BOCTO'lHOeBpOIleiicKHX KapaHMoB
o npoHCxo3\)1;eHHII )1;peBHeiimero eBpOIIeOH)1;HOro HaCeJIelllIJI MHHyCIIHCKOii
KOTJIOBIIHLI . . . . . . .
R npoHcxomp;eHHIO TamTLIKcKoro HaCeJIeHHJI IOmHoD Cn6HpH
ITaMeoaHTpOIIOJIOrIIH TalliTbIKcKOll KYJIbTYPbl
06 <JTHH'IeCKOll IIpIIHagMemHocTH HaCeJIeHHH TamTbIKcKoH KYJIbTYpLI
440
21:}
230
232
234
236
237
241
241
242
246
249
253
255
255
258
263
268
271
273
274
276,
280
280,
283
285"
292
306
310
318
318
319
322
325
326
326
329
334
338
338
343
346
350'
355
355
362
IIpOlICXoa')1;eHHe xaKaCClwro HapO)1;a B CBeTe )1;auHbIX aHTpOnOJIOrHH . " 366
Pe3YJIbTaTbI aHTpOnOJIOrIIqeCKOI'O IICCJIe,[(oBaHIIR cOBpellmHHoro HaCeJIeHIIH 366
KpaHIIOJIOI'If'IeCKHii TIm COBpeMeHHbIX xaKaCOB 375
PaCOBble KOMnOHelITbI BToporo nopH,[(Ka . . . 381
HeKoTopbIe IIaJIeOaHTpOIIOJIOrIIqeCKHe coo6paiKeHHH 397
3aI{JIIOqeHHe 399
AIITponOJIOrHqeCKHii KOMlIICIITapHii K rHnOTese n;IIpKYMnOJIHpHOii KYJIbTypbI 402
COMaTOJIOrnqeCKOe COIIOCTaBJIeHHe 402
KpaHllOJIOrIIqeCKIIH MaTepHaJI 407
113ocepoJIol'IIH . . 409
,l];epMaTocKonIIH 411
8THol'eHeTnqeCKIIe BbIBO,[(bI 412
o xapaKTepe <JTlIoreHeTHqeCKlIX npon;eccoB Ha TeppHToplIH CH6HpH B CBeTe
HHTpOIIOJIOrHqeCKHX )1;aHI-IbIX 414
rIIIIoTe3a HeOJIlITIIqeCKOI'O B03pacTa cOBpeMeHHbIx Hapo,[(oB . . 414
BpeMH wopllmpoBaHIIH HapO)1;OB 3ana,[(HoE CII6IIpII . . . . . 416
XpOHOJIOrIIH <JTHOl'eHeTIIqeCKIIX npon;eccoB B lOiKHoM CII6IIpH 417
Bpe1IH KOHKpeTHbIx <JTHOl'eHe30B Ha ceBepo-BocToKe A3HH . 419
06Il!ee 3aKJIIOqeHlle . . . . . . 419
HsyqeHlIe 1I1OPWOJIOrIIqeCKlIX oc06eHHocTeii aMepHKaHcKHx HH)1;eiin;eB H
np06JIeMa S3CeJIeHIIH Al\IepHKH . . . . . 421
HCTOpIIQeCKaH peTpocneKTIIBa . . . . . . 421
COlYIaTOJIOI'IlQeCKOe conOCTaBJIeHIIe <JCKII1IOCOB II aMepIIKaHcKIIx nH,[(eiin;eB 424
KpaHIIOJIOI'HQeCKIIe oco6eHHocTH all1CpIIKaHcKHx IIH)1;errn;eB . . 424
A:l-lepHKaHoH,[(bI - npoToll1OPWHbIe MOHrOJIOII,[(bI? 428
Y'IaCTIIe ,[(peBHeiimlix eBponeoII,[(oB B WOp1\lIIpOBaHFIH MOPWOJIOI'HQeCKIlX oco-
6eHHocTelj all1CpHKaHoIl,[(oB . . 430
HeKoTopble reHoreOrpaWIlQeCKIIe co06paiKeHIIH 432
3aKJIIOQeHHe . . _ . . . . . 436
441
CONTENTS
1ntroduction
. . .. .. . . .. ..
. . . . . .. . . .. ..
Part 1
PHYSICAL ANTHROPOLOGY: THE CONTOURS OF SCIENCE
Theoretical heritage of Engels and physical anthropology . . .
Physical anthropology: some results and perspectives of studies
Expansion of the scopes of science .. .........
Genetic approach . . . . . . . . .
Population approach . . . . . . .
Natural selection and social regularities
Ethnogenetical aspects . . . . . .
From physical anthropology to physical exoanthropology
The horizons of physical anthropology' . . . .
Physical anthropology is a morphological science
New trends of development . .
Structural levels of investigations .. .
Perspectives of investigations . . . .
Physical antropology and morphology .
Genetic aspects of physical anthropology
Human being as a subject of genetic study
Importance of physical anthropological data for genetic studies
Physical anthropology and genetics in their relationships . .
Importance of genetic data for physical anthropological studies
Physical anthropology and genetics in their influence on the society
Genetics and physical anthropology . . . . .
Genogeographical rules of N. Vavilov . . . . .
Genogeography and the formation of Europeoids .
Significance of N. Vavilov's works for theoretical physical anthropology
Vavilov's expeditions . . . . . . . . . .
Centres of the origin of cultivated plants . .
Distribution of recessives in marginal areas . ".
Homologous series in inherited variation . .
Human ecology (physical anthropological points of view)
Population structure of mankind and historical anthropology
Framework of historical anthropology
Problems of historical anthropology
Population . . . . . . . . .
Palaeoanthropological population
Some results . . . . . . . .
442
3
5
14
14
17
18
19
21
23
24
24
24
26
30
35
40
41
42
46
49
52
58
58
62
67
68
76
83
93
99
107
107
109
112
115
118
Historical anthropology: problems and perspectives . . . . . . . . .
Place of historical anthropology in the system of physical anthropology
Fundamental problems of historical anthropology . . . . . . .
Evolutionary aspects of physical anthropology of ancient population . . .
Introductory remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Range of species variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Level of morphological peculiarities of populations . . . . . . . . .
Character of species variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Trait trends in time
Concluding remarks . . . . _ . . . . . . .
Part 2
THEORETICAL PROBLEMS
OF ETHNOGENETICAL RECONSTRUCTIONS
Once more on ethnogenetical problems . . . . . .
Complex of sciences and a single science . . . . .
Historical framework of ethnogenetical investigations
Language as an ethnical determinant . . . . . . .
Ethnographical data and ethnogenesis . . . . . .
Significance of archaeology in ethnogenetical investigations
Anthropological material as a source of historical information
Complex of data and their iererchy .. ..... .
On the difference between synchronous and diachronic comparisons of
ethnographic phenomena . . . . . .
Introductory remarks . . . . . .
Synchronous comparison . . . . . . .
Diachronic comparison . . . . . . .
Environmental influence on ethnographic phenomena
Rate of change of ethnographic phenomena . . .
Transition from synchronous comparison to diachronic one
On limitation of diachronic comparison in folkloristics
Ethnogenetical tales, lingvistic data and anthropological material
Some remarks on the character of comparisons
Space of etlmogenetical situations . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Paiaeoanthropology and history . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Palaeoanthropological material as a source of historical information
Reconstruction of the centres of autochthonous development
Reconstruction of ancient migrations . . . . . . . . . . .
Anthropological diffusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Definition of the Beginning of concrete ethnogenetical processes
Concluding remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Part 3
HISTORICAL ANTHROPOLOGICAL STUDY
OF CONCRETE ETHNOGENETICAL SITUATIONS
On historical interpretation of the palaeoanthropological study of Eurasian
steppes in Skythian times . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ., 206
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206
Cemeteries with enough numerous palaeoanthropological material 209
443
\
\
121
121
123
131
131
131
134
136
138
141
144
144
145
146
148
150
152
153
155
155
157
160
162
163
166
167
171
171
174
190
190
193
196
200
204
204
Geographical variation 215
Racial interpretation - 230
Etlmogenetical results . . . . 232
Palaeodemographical observations 234
Level of life and nutrition . . 236.
Conclusions . . . . . _ . . . 237
Some problems of the origin of Balkar and Karachaj peoples in the light
of anthropological data 241
Introductory remarks . . 241
Somatological data . . . 242
Palaeoanthropological data 246
Discussion on existing hypotheses 249.
Results ...... 253
Anthropological data and the origin of Oset people 255,
History of study . . . . . . 255.
Somatology and typological characteristics 258
Craniological variations . . . . . 263
Hypothesis of northern analogies . . 268.
Palaeo anthropological considerations 271
Ethnogenetical considerations . 273.
Some perspectives of further investigations 273
In defence of the use of anthropological data in ethnogenetical investiga-
tions of Osets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 276
Anthropological data to the origin of the population of central Caucasus 280
State of anthropological materials. ..... . . . . 280
Hyp.otheses of the origin of Caucasionian race . . . . . . 283
Some facts, which should be taken into account in the discussion on
M. Abdushelishvili's hypothesis .. .... . . . . . . 285.
Some facts which should be taken into account in the discussion on
G. Debetz's hypothesis . . . 292
Hypothesis of isolation . . . . . . . 306
Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 309-
The most ancient Europeoid populations of Soviet Central Asia and their
offsprings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . " 318
Short account of the hypotheses of the origin of Pamiro-Ferganian race . . 318.
Morphological peculiarities of Pamirian peoples in comparison with Uzbeks
and Tajiks 319
Palaeoanthropological comparisons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 322
Results .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 325.
Anthropological evaluation of the skulptures from Halchayan and Dalversin 326
Anthropological aspects of the study of ancient skulpture . . . . . .. 326.
Study of the skulptures from Dalversin and Halchayan with the help of
somatological methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 329.
Racial diagnosis and genesis of the populations of Northern Bactria 334
Anthropological aspects of the study of indoiranian problem 338
Somatological data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 338
Palaeoanthropological retrospectives . . . . . . . . . . 343
On physical anthropology of Eastern European Karaims . . 346
On the origin of the most ancient Europeoid populations of Minusa Basin 350,
On the origin of Tashtik populations of Southern Siberia 355.
Palaeoanthropology of Tashtik culture . . . . . . . 35::;
On ethnic affiliation of the populations of Tashtik culture 31:2
444
Origin of the Khakasy in the light of anthropological data . . 366
Some results of the anthropological study of modern population 366
Craniological features of modern Khakasy 375
Secondary racial components . . . . . 381
Some palaeoanthropological considerations 397
Conclusions . . . . . . . 399
Anthropological commentaries to the hypothesis of circumpolar culture 402
Somatological comparisons . . 402
Craniological material 407
Serology . . . . . 409
Dermatogliphics . . . . 411
Ethnogenetical results . . 412
On the character of ethnogenetical process on the territory of Siberia in the
light of anthropological data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 414
Hypothesis of neolithic age of modern peoples . . . . 414
Period of the formation of Western Siberian peoples . . . 416
Chronology of ethnogenetical process in Southern Siberia . . 417
Age of formation of modern peoples in Northern-Eastern Asia 419
General conclusions . . . . . . . . . . 419
Morphological features of American Indians and the problem of first peop-
ling of America . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 421
Historical retrospective . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 421
Somatological comparison of Eskimos and American Indians 424
Craniological features of American Indians . . . . . 424
Are Americanoids protomorfic Mongoloids? . . . . . 428
Participation of ancient Europeoids in the formation of morphological com-
position of Americanoids . 430
Some genogeographical considerations . 432
Concluding remarks 436